institutions for asian integration: innovation and reform
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
1/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu Thufht
Fmtyfyxyfomt lou Ktfkm Fmyhbukyfom:Fmmo|kyfom kmi Uhloug
Bfo|kmmf Dk~kmmh``fkmi Thh Thmb Ykm
Mo- 428Kxbxty 5>;5
Ktfkm Ih|h`o~ghmy Ekma Fmtyfyxyh
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
2/31
Ych Rouafmb ^k~hu thufht ft k domyfmxkyfom ol ych loughu`v mkghi Iftdxttfom ^k~hu thufht1 ychmxgehufmb ol ych ~k~hut domyfmxhi rfycoxy fmyhuux~yfom ou dckmbh- KIEFt rouafmb ~k~hutuhl`hdy fmfyfk` fihkt om k yo~fd kmi kuh ~otyhi om`fmh lou iftdxttfom- KIEF hmdoxukbht uhkihut yo~oty ychfu dogghmyt om ych gkfm ~kbh lou hkdc rouafmb ~k~hu #bf|hm fm ych dfykyfom eh`or&-Togh rouafmb ~k~hut gkv ih|h`o~ fmyo oychu lougt ol ~xe`fdkyfom-
Txbbhtyhi dfykyfom:
Dk~kmmh``f, B- kmi T- T- Ykm- 5>;5- Fmtyfyxyfomt lou Ktfkm Fmyhbukyfom: Fmmo|kyfom kmi Uhloug-KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428- Yoavo: Ktfkm Ih|h`o~ghmy Ekma Fmtyfyxyh- K|kf`ke`h:cyy~://rrr-kief-oub/rouafmb'~k~hu/5>;5/>3/5>/85;2-ktfkm-fmyhbukyfom-fmmo|kyfom-uhloug/
^`hkth domykdy ych kxycou lou fmlougkyfom keoxy ycft ~k~hu-
Hgkf`: bdk~kmmh``fNkief-oub1 ftttykmNmyx-hix-tb
Bfo|kmmf Dk~kmmh``f ft t~hdfk` ki|ftou yo ych Ihkm, Ktfkm Ih|h`o~ghmy Ekma Fmtyfyxyh#KIEF&, Yoavo- Thh Thmb Ykm ft km kttodfkyh ~uolhttou ky Mkmvkmb Yhdcmo`obfdk`Xmf|hutfyv, Tfmbk~ouh-
Ych |fhrt hs~uhtthi fm ycft ~k~hu kuh ych |fhrt ol ych kxycou kmi io moy mhdhttkuf`vuhl`hdy ych |fhrt ou ~o`fdfht ol KIEF, ych KIE, fyt Eokui ol Ifuhdyout, ou ych bo|humghmytychv uh~uhthmy- KIEF ioht moy bxkukmyhh ych kddxukdv ol ych ikyk fmd`xihi fm ycft ~k~hukmi kddh~yt mo uht~omtfef`fyv lou kmv domth{xhmdht ol ychfu xth- Yhugfmo`obv xthi gkvmoy mhdhttkuf`v eh domtftyhmy rfyc KIE ollfdfk` yhugt-
Ktfkm Ih|h`o~ghmy Ekma FmtyfyxyhAktxgfbkthaf Exf`ifmb 3L4'5'8 Aktxgfbkthaf, Dcfvoik'axYoavo ;>>'>3, Jk~km
Yh`: !3;'4'4864'88>>Lks: !3;'4'4864'882;XU@: rrr-kief-oubH'gkf`: fmloNkief-oub
5>;5 Ktfkm Ih|h`o~ghmy Ekma Fmtyfyxyh
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected] -
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
3/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
Ketyukdy
Ych lougkyfom ol uhbfomk` ~uoixdyfom mhyrouat fm Hkty Ktfk ckt oddxuuhi gkfm`v ycuoxbc gkuahyloudht, rfycoxy gxdc ch`~ luog uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt fm ~uogoyfmb ych duhkyfom ol k tfmb`h Ktfkmgkuahy- Rcf`h ycft k~~uokdc ckt thu|hi ych uhbfom rh`` fm ych ~kty, ych iuktyfd dckmbhths~hufhmdhi tfmdh ych 5>>35>>6 lfmkmdfk` duftft kmi ych dck``hmbht Ktfkm doxmyufht kuh
lkdfmbbuorfmb fmh{xk`fyfht kmi dog~hyfyfom, om ych omh ckmi, kmi hmckmdhi ycuhkyt yo ychhm|fuomghmy kmi ~ho~`ht chk`yc om ych oychuck|h uhmihuhi gouh xubhmy ych mhhi loufmyhubo|humghmyk` doo~hukyfom ky b`oek` kmi uhbfomk` `h|h`t- Ktfkt fmtyfyxyfomt lou uhbfomk`ftgmhhi tyuhmbychmfmb ycuoxbc uhloug kmi fmmo|kyfom txdc kt ehyyhu bo|humkmdh kmi uhtoxudfmb,buhkyhu kmi gouh hllhdyf|h ~kuyfdf~kyfom kmi ih`hbkyfom ol ~orhut, o|huk`` tyuhkg`fmfmb oluhbfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh, fmd`xifmb ych ~cktfmb oxy ol oxyikyhi ou fuuh`h|kmy fmtyfyxyfomt kmi, rchuhmhhihi, ych duhkyfom ol mhr omht- X`yfgkyh`v, bf|hm fyt uooyhimhtt fm uhbfomk` ouihu, fmtyfyxyfomk`hllfdkdv ft k lxmdyfom ol ych kef`fyv kmi rf``fmbmhtt ol fyt ghgehut, ht~hdfk``v fml`xhmyfk`tykahco`ihut, yo do``keoukyh-
JH@ D`kttflfdkyfom: L;81 L881 L86
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
4/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
Domyhmyt
;- Fmyuoixdyfom: Rcv Ktfk Mhhit Tyuombhu Fmtyfyxyfomt lou Uhbfomk` Fmyhbukyfom ------------------- 45-
Ktfkt Fmtyfyxyfomt lou Uhbfomk`ftg: O|hu|fhr ol ych @fyhukyxuh
---------------------------------------- 9
4- Bo|humfmb ^ufmdf~`ht ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 29- Yksomogv ol Ktfkt Fmtyfyxyfomt lou Uhbfomk`ftg ------------------------------------------------------------- 68- O|hukudcfmb Txeuhbfomk` Fmtyfyxyfomt: Dog~kufmb KTHKM kmi TKKUD -------------------------;4
2-; Ehvomi Eoyyog'x~ Uhbfomk`ftg -------------------------------------------------------------------------552-5 Ehvomi Fmtyfyxyfomt @fbcymhtt ----------------------------------------------------------------------------592-4 Ehvomi H`fyh Uhbfomk`ftg ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------58
Uhlhuhmdht -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5;8, exy ych ~orhut ghgehu doxmyufht
ih`hbkyh yo ych KTHKM Thduhykufky #KTHD& uhgkfm `fgfyhi-
Txdc km k~~uokdc yo uhbfomk`ftg ckt thu|hi ych uhbfom rh``- Tfmdh ych ;62>t ih|h`o~fmb
Ktfkm hdomogfht ck|h buorm gxdc lktyhu yckm ycoth fm kmv oychu uhbfom fm ych rou`i ixh
`kubh`v yo ych fg~`hghmykyfom ol dkuhlx``v ~`kmmhi mkyfomk` ih|h`o~ghmy tyukyhbfht- ^o|huyv fm
Ktfk ckt ck`|hi tfmdh ych hku`v ;66>t kmi ych o|huk`` rh`lkuh ol Ktfkm dfyfzhmt ckt buhky`v
fg~uo|hi- Rcv rox`i Ktfk mhhi tyuombhu fmtyfyxyfomt yo ~uogoyh uhbfomk`ftg? Ioht Ktfk mhhi
h|hmyxk``v yo lo``or k Hxuo~hkm k~~uokdc yo uhbfomk` doo~hukyfom, rfyc ych duhkyfom ol th|huk`
gkjou fmtyfyxyfomt txdc kt k doxmdf` ol gfmftyhut, k uhbfomk` doggfttfom, k ~ku`fkghmy, kmi k
doxuy ol jxtyfdh, ou ft fy ehyyhu oll rfyc fyt dxuuhmy `fbcy fmtyfyxyfomk`fzkyfom ol uhbfomk`ftg?
Rcky ckt rouahi rh`` fm ych ~kty gkv moy roua kt rh`` fm ych lxyxuh- Ych b`oek` hdomogfd kmi
~o`fyfdk` hm|fuomghmyt ck|h dckmbhi iuktyfdk``v tfmdh ych hux~yfom ol ych b`oek` lfmkmdfk` duftftfm 5>>35>>6 kmi ych dck``hmbht Ktfkm doxmyufht kuh lkdfmb, eoyc fmif|fixk``v kmi do``hdyf|h`v
kt k uhbfom, ck|h ehdogh lku gouh dog~`hs kmi rfyc fmyufdkyh b`oek` ukgflfdkyfomt- Om ych omh
ckmi, fmduhkthi Ktfkm hdomogfd fmyhuih~hmihmdh ckt dogh moy rfycoxy ~uoe`hgt- Fmh{xk`fyv
ckt ufthm, fmduhktfmb dog~hyfyfom ckt mhbkyf|h`v kllhdyhi togh hdomogfd buox~t, kmi ych
ehmhlfyt ol fmyhbukyfom uhgkfm goty`v `fgfyhi rfycfm Hkty Ktfkt ~uoixdyfom mhyrouat- Toxyc kmi
Dhmyuk` Ktfkm hdomogfht kuh tyf`` ~oou`v fmyhbukyhi: ych fmyhbukyfom ol `keou, thu|fdht, kmi
lfmkmdfk` gkuahyt ft ~uodhhifmb ky k |huv t`or ~kdh- Om ych oychu ckmi, fmyhubo|humghmyk`
doo~hukyfom ky b`oek` kmi uhbfomk` `h|h`t ft fmduhktfmb`v mhhihi yo gkmkbh gkjou ycuhkyt yo ych
hm|fuomghmy kmi ~ho~`ht chk`yc, yo ~uh|hmy ych uhdxuuhmdh ol lfmkmdfk` kmi hdomogfd duftht,
kmi yo hmtxuh thdxufyv kmi ~hkdh-
Ych fmtyfyxyfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh lou uhbfomk` doo~hukyfom ycky ckt ehhm ykafmb tck~h fm Ktfk
cfychuyo ki cod kmi fmdochuhmygkv moy eh kih{xkyh yo lkdh ychth mhr dck``hmbht- Th|huk`
uhlougt kmi fmmo|kyfomt kuh mhhihi yo tyuhmbychm Ktfkt fmtyfyxyfomt lou uhbfomk`ftg- Ych
bo|humkmdh ol hsftyfmb fmtyfyxyfomt tcox`i eh tyuhmbychmhi kmi gkih gouh hllhdyf|h kmi
~kuyfdf~kyouv, bf|fmb `kubhu t~kdh yo df|f` todfhyv kmi ych ~uf|kyh thdyou yo domyufexyh yo ihlfmfmb
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
6/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
9
ychfu ~ufoufyfht kmi kbhmik, yobhychu rfyc bo|humghmy kbhmdfht- Uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt tcox`i
k`to eh bf|hm gouh ih`hbkyhi ~orhut yo kdy om ehck`l ol ychfu ghgehu doxmyufht fm ouihu yo
fg~uo|h uhbfomk` doggomt, kt rh`` kt gouh lfmkmdfk` kmi cxgkm uhtoxudht- Uhbfomk`
tykahco`ihut tcox`i domtfihu ~cktfmb oxy fmtyfyxyfomt rcfdc ck|h k`uhkiv kddog~`ftchi ychfu
gkmikyh ou rcfdc kuh mo gouh hllhdyf|h, kmi duhkyfmb mhr fmtyfyxyfomt rchmh|hu mhhihi- Kyych tkgh yfgh, fy ehkut uhgfmifmb ycky uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt kuh uooyhi fm uhbfomk` ouihu-
Fmtyfyxyfomk` hllfdkdv kt txdc ft h{xk``v ih~hmihmy om ych kef`fyv kmi rf``fmbmhtt ol ychfu
ghgehut, ht~hdfk``v buhky ~orhut kmi fml`xhmyfk` tykahco`ihut, yo do``keoukyh-
Ekthi om k tyxiv dog~`hyhi fm 5>;> ev ych Ktfkm Ih|h`o~ghmy Ekma #KIE&, ycft ~k~hu
uh|fhrt togh `fyhukyxuh om ych ihtfbm kmi ih|h`o~ghmy ol fmtyfyxyfomt lou Ktfkm uhbfomk`ftg
kmi iftdxttht ych lxyxuh mhhit lou fmmo|kyfom kmi uhlougt ol ych uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomk`
kudcfyhdyxuh ck|fmb fm gfmi ych duhkyfom ol k uhbfomk` hdomogfd doggxmfyv ol touyt- K`ycoxbc
rh uhlukfm luog ihlfmfmb ych dog~omhmyt kmi tyuxdyxuh ol txdc km hdomogfd doggxmfyv lou
Ktfk kmi luog ~uo~otfmb k uokigk~ lou fyt kdcfh|hghmy, rh lo``or ych yksomogv ol fmtyfyxyfomt
lou uhbfomk`ftg kio~yhi ev ych KIE tyxiv kmi lodxt om ahv bo|humkmdh ~ufmdf~`ht lou txdc
fmtyfyxyfomt- Fm iofmb to, rh ~uhthmy dktht tyxifht ol ~ufmdf~`ht kmi fmtyfyxyfomt ycky rouahi kmi
ifi moy roua rh`` fm ych ~kty, kmi txbbhty togh mhhihi ~o`fdv kdyfom-
Thdyfom 5 ol ycft ~k~hu uh|fhrt ych `fyhukyxuh om Ktfkt fmtyfyxyfomt lou uhbfomk` fmyhbukyfom kmi
doo~hukyfom- Thdyfom 2-4 iftdxttht ych uh`h|kmy bo|humkmdh ~ufmdf~`ht lou txdc fmtyfyxyfomt,
fmd`xifmb domtfihukyfomt om tykahco`ihut kmi ychfu kbhmik- Thdyfom 9 fmyuoixdht k yksomogv ol
Ktfkt fmtyfyxyfomt lou uhbfomk`ftg, rcf`h thdyfom 8 dog~kuht KTHKM rfyc ych Toxyc Ktfkm
Kttodfkyfom lou Uhbfomk` Doo~hukyfom #TKKUD&, rcfdc dkm eh ihlfmhi kt ych o|hukudcfmb
txeuhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt fm Toxychkty kmi Toxyc Ktfk- Thdyfom < kmk`vzht ycuhh th`hdyhi
lxmdyfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt ycky ~uo|fih fmyhuhtyfmb hskg~`ht ol doo~hukyfom fm ifllhuhmy thdyout kmitxeuhbfomt- Thdyfom 2 domd`xiht txbbhtyfmb ych mhhi lou uhloug kmi fmmo|kyfom yo tyuhmbychm
Ktfkt fmtyfyxyfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh lou uhbfomk`ftg-
5- KTFKT FMTYFYXYFOMT LOU UHBFOMK@FTG: O\HU\FHR
OL YCH @FYHUKYXUH
Ych tyouv ol Ktfkt uhbfomk` fmyhbukyfom ft iftyfmdy luog ycky ol Hxuo~h orfmb yo ifllhuhmy
hdomogfd kmi ~o`fyfdk` domifyfomt- Fm Hxuo~h, km fmthdxuh uhbfomk` hm|fuomghmy lo``orfmb ychThdomi Rou`i Rku, km h{xk``v xmloubf|fmb hdomogfd hm|fuomghmy gkuahi ev cfbc
~uoyhdyfomftg kmi rfiht~uhki dxuuhmy kddoxmy uhtyufdyfomt, km hgehiihi `fehuk`ftg ycky
hg~cktfzhi ~uoyhdyfom ol `keou uh`kyfomt kmi kbufdx`yxuh kmi, fg~ouykmy`v, fmyhu|hmyfomfty tykyht
ycky toxbcy yo tkyftlv txdc hs~hdykyfomt, dogefmhi yo uhmihu ych uhbfom moy ~kuyfdx`ku`v
domixdf|h yo tfg~`h gkuahy'iuf|hm fmyhbukyfom #Dk~kmmh``f kmi Lf`f~~fmf 5>;>&- Chfbcyhmhi
todfhyk` hs~hdykyfomt fm ych fgghifkyh ~otyrku ~hufoi dofmdfihi rfyc ych rfiht~uhki lhh`fmb
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
7/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
8
ycky yukifyfomk` mkyfom tykyht cki lkf`hi yo ~uo|fih ychfu ~o~x`kyfomt rfyc hdomogfd thdxufyv fm
ych vhkut ehyrhhm ych lfuty kmi thdomi rou`i rkut kmi ~cvtfdk` thdxufyv klyhu ;646-;
Mo txdc doggom dkxth kmi goyf|kyfom fg~h` Ktfkt hdomogfd fmyhbukyfom- Yoikv, Ktfkm
hdomogfd uhbfomk`ftg uh`fht om km kuukv ol goty`v xmdoouifmkyhi ~uodhttht, txdc kt ych
^ho~`ht Uh~xe`fd ol Dcfmk #^UD& xmf`kyhuk` o~hmfmb ixufmb Ihmb Sfko~fmbt `hkihutcf~, ych
domdhuyhi xmf`kyhuk`ftg ol ych Ktfk'^kdflfd Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom #K^HD& louxg, ych gkmv
ef`kyhuk` kmi ~`xuf`kyhuk` luhh yukih kbuhhghmyt #LYKt& ycky ioy ych uhbfom, b`oek` mhboyfkyfomt
txdc kt ycoth xmihu ych Rou`i Yukih Oubkmfzkyfom #RYO&, kmi uhbfomk` fmfyfkyf|ht txdc kt ych
KTHKM!4 #KTHKM ~`xt ych ^UD, Jk~km, kmi ych Uh~xe`fd ol Aouhk& ycky hghubhi fm uhkdyfom
yo ych Ktfkm lfmkmdfk` duftft ol ;662;663 #Ekxg ;63>1 Ihmy 5>>31 Akrkf kmi Rfbmkukjk 5>>61
Uk|hmcf`` 5>>;&- Ych dogefmhi fg~kdy ol ychth fmfyfkyf|ht ckt domyufexyhi yo uk~fi hdomogfd
buoryc gkuahi ev k domtfihuke`h hs~kmtfom ol duott'eouihu yukih kmi lfmkmdfk` l`ort, kt rh``
kt km fmduhktfmb fmyhbukyfom rfycfm ych uhbfom kmi rfyc ych uhty ol ych rou`i- Kt txdc, Ktfk ckt
~`kvhi coty moy om`v yo trfly'uftfmb fmyukuhbfomk` fm|htyghmy kmi l`ort ol gkmkbhufk` yk`hmy kmi
oychu taf``hi `keou, exy k`to yo ych fmyhmtf|h ih|h`o~ghmy ol uhbfomk` tx~~`v dckfmt kmi
~uoixdyfom mhyrouat- Ycft ckt `hi togh ~uogfmhmy hdomogftyt yo uhlhu yo ych uhbfom kt
Lkdyouv Ktfk #Ek`irfm 5>>3&-
Domyukuv
yo lxmdyfomk`fty kddoxmyt ycky kyyufexyh Hxuo~hkm uhbfomk`ftg yo mom'tykyh loudht, oychut kubxh
fy rkt hdomogfd goyf|ht ol hghubfmb Rhtyhum Hxuo~hkm rh`lkuh tykyht ycky ~`kvhi k ahv ~kuy
fm iuf|fmb uhbfomk` fmyhbukyfom fm Hxuo~h #Gouk|dtfa ;6631 5>>>1 ^xdck`k ;666&-
Fm domyukty yo ych tdkudfyv ol fmtyfyxyfomt lou uhbfomk` fmyhbukyfom thu|fmb Ktfk fm ych fgghifkyh
klyhugkyc ol ych Do`i Rku,5
;
Ych duxdfk` domtyfyxhmdfht Rhtyhum Hxuo~hkm bo|humghmyt toxbcy yo ~`kdkyh rhuh ych kbufdx`yxuk` doggxmfyfht,
rouahut, kmi ih~hmihmyt ol ych rh`lkuh tykyh- Ifllhuhmdht ktfih, ych doggom to`xyfom rkt yo ukfth rkbht kmi
hmtxuh lx`` hg~`ovghmy, hmckmdh ych `f|fmb tykmikuit ol ych kbufdx`yxuh thdyou, kmi htyke`ftc ych goihum rh`lkuh
tykyh #Gf`rkui 5>>>&-
k ihmth rhe ol o|hu`k~~fmb uhbfomk` kmi txeuhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt
tx~~ouyt Ktfkt fmyhbukyfom yoikv- Ych lfbxuh tcort ych gkfm uhbfomk` kmi yukmtuhbfomk` louxgt
tx~~ouyfmb Ktfkm fmyhbukyfom kmi hg~cktfzht ych lxmikghmyk` uo`h ~`kvhi ev KTHKM fm~uogoyfmb Ktfk'rfih fmyhbukyfom, kt fy ft kuoxmi KTHKM ycky gkjou buox~t txdc kt KTHKM!4
kmi ych Hkty Ktfk Txggfy kuh uh|o`|fmb #KIE 5>>3&-
5Fm ;664, ~uogfmhmy fmyhumkyfomk` uh`kyfomt ychoufty Uxbbfh #;664: 9& ruoyh: Fy rkt moy ~ottfe`h yo domtyuxdy
gx`yf`kyhuk` fmtyfyxyfomk` lukghrouat Qfm KtfkW fm ych fgghifkyh ~otyrku ~hufoi- Yoikv Qfm ;664W, ych kethmdh ol
txdc kuukmbhghmyt fmcfefyt ~uobuhttf|h kik~ykyfom yo lxmikghmyk` b`oek` tcflyt- Lou Uxbbfh, ych kethmdh ol HX'
`fah kmi/ou MKYO'`fah tyuxdyxuht, ou k Ch`tfmaf'`fah ~uodhtt fm ~oty'Do`i Rku Ktfk htthmyfk``v ghkmt k
uhktomke`v tyke`h ek`kmdh ft ych ehty ycky omh dkm co~h yo kdcfh|h fm Ktfk-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
8/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
>3&-
Ihtfbmhi yo lotyhu doo~hukyfom om t~hdflfd fttxht kmi to`|h ~o`fdv ~uoe`hgt, Ktfkt eukmi ol
lxmdyfomk` uhbfomk`ftg ft `kubh`v ych domth{xhmdh ol ki cod ~uhgftht kmi ukyfomk`ht, rchuh
uhbfomk` fmfyfkyf|ht kuh loughi fm uht~omth yo t~hdflfd ~hudhf|hi mhhit #Ykm 5>;>k1 Roo`doyy
5>>6&- Ycft ckt `hi yo k ~km'uhbfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh dog~uftfmb k ~`hycouk ol kuukmbhghmyt, hkdc
oufhmyhi yorkui k ~kuyfdx`ku ychgkyfd ~xu~oth- Lou hskg~`h, K^HD lodxtht om ~uogoyfmb yukih
`fehuk`fzkyfom, rchuhkt ych KTHKM Uhbfomk` Louxg #KUL& ~uogoyht doo~hukyf|h thdxufyv kmi
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
9/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
2
domlfihmdh exf`ifmb rfyc k mxgehu ol KTHKM ifk`obxh ~kuymhut #Ahtk|k~kmv kmi @fg 5>>61
Uk|hmcf`` 5>>;1 Akytxgkyk 5>>61 Th|hufmo 5>>6k&-
Iht~fyh ychth ih|h`o~ghmyt, ychuh ft buorfmb domdhum kgomb togh uhbfomk` tykahco`ihut ycky
rcf`h Ktfkm fmtyfyxyfomt x~ yo mor ck|h thu|hi ych uhbfom rh``~ufgkuf`v ev moy bhyyfmb fm ych
rkv ol gkuahy loudhtk lkfu kgoxmy ol fmtyfyxyfomk` uhyuolfyyfmb ft uh{xfuhi yo hmtxuh kmihmckmdh Ktfkt ~uot~hufyv, tykef`fyv, kmi thdxufyv- Ek`irfm, lou hskg~`h, ckt kubxhi ycky Ktfkm
uhbfomk`ftg ft lukbf`h tfmdh fy uh`fht om ycuhh fmchuhmy`v xmtyke`h lkdyout: #f& fmyukuhbfomk` yukih1
#ff& xmf`kyhuk` `fehuk`fzkyfom kmi ykufll uhixdyfomt ycky kuh mom'efmifmb |ft''|ft RYO uhbx`kyfomt1
kmi #fff& ych kethmdh ol yo~'`h|h` gkmkbhghmy yo hmtxuh ef`kyhuk` yukih yhmtfomt io moy t~f``
o|hu fmyo ift~xyht ou, routh, doml`fdy #Ek`irfm 5>>3&- Ek`irfmt ycfui ~ofmymo o|hukudcfmb,
`hkihu'`hi lukghrouaft k rfih`v'tckuhi domdhum, goty uhdhmy`v cfbc`fbcyhi fm yro loughu
uhbfomk` `hkihut |ftfomt lou k mhr uhbfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh-4
Gouh euoki`v, ych Ktfkm fmtyfyxyfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh ft ~hudhf|hi kt lukbf`h ehdkxth, iht~fyh fyt
buorfmb rhe ol uhbfomk` fmyhubo|humghmyk` oubkmfzkyfomt kmi buox~t duhkyhi ev df|f` todfhyv,Ktfk uhgkfmt lou ych goty ~kuy fmtyfyxyfom'`fbcy fm ych ihtfbm, uhtoxudht, ih`hbkyhi ~orhut,
hsyhmy ol `hbk`fzkyfom, kmi hllfdkdv ol fyt hsftyfmb fmtyfyxyfomt lou fmyhbukyfom #H|kmt 5>>81
Ukycxt 5>;>1 Ykm 5>;;&- Domtfihuke`v gouh if|huth kmi rfiht~uhki bhobuk~cfdk``v yckm
Hxuo~h, Ktfk k`to ckt mo h{xf|k`hmy ol ych LukmdoBhugkm doo~hukyf|h kuukmbhghmymo
`odk` |hutfom ol ych H`vth Yuhkyv, ycky ftom rcfdc Hxuo~hkm hdomogfd uhbfomk`ftg tykmit-
Mou ft k ^UDJk~km uk~~uodchghmy hktf`v kdcfh|ke`h lou ych louhthhke`h lxyxuh, iht~fyh ych
tfbmflfdkmy uo`ht eoyc doxmyufht kuh hs~hdyhi yo ~`kv fm domyufexyfmb yo ych uhbfomt ~oty'duftft
hdomogfd uhdo|huv-
9
4- BO\HUMFMB ^UFMDF^@HT
Ifllhuhmdht kgomb Ktfkt uhbfomk` kmi txeuhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt ktfih, ychv tckuh k mxgehu ol
doggom lhkyxuht- Fy ft ychth kyyufexyht ycky ck|h `hi togh tah~yfdk` oethu|hut yo ihtdufeh
Ktfkm uhbfomk`ftg kt keoxy ~uodhtt ukychu yckm ~uobuhtt #Jomht kmi Tgfyc 5>>2&- Oychut,
`ooafmb ky ych kio~yfom ol ~ufmdf~`ht xmihu`vfmb gouh uhdhmy ih|h`o~ghmyt txdc kt ych Dcfkmb
Gkf Fmfyfkyf|h Gx`yf`kyhuk`fzkyfom #DGFG& kmi ych hghubfmb ifk`obxh fm ~uo|fifmb uhbfomk` ~xe`fd
booit ck|h k gouh o~yfgftyfd |fhr #KIE 5>;>1 Akrkf 5>>6&-
4Loughu Kxtyuk`fkm ^ufgh Gfmftyhu Ah|fm Uxiit |ftfom ol km Ktfk'^kdflfd Doggxmfyv kmi loughu Jk~kmhth ^ufgh
Gfmftyhu Vxafo Ckyovkgkt |ftfom lou km Hkty Ktfkm Doggxmfyv-
9Moyke`v, Ckyovkgkt ~uo~otk` lou uhbfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh cki, kt k loxmikyfom ou ~f``ku, ^UDJk~km uhdomdf`fkyfom
kmi doo~hukyfom rfycfm #ky `hkty lou hku`v |hutfomt ol ych ~uo~otk`& km HX'`fah oubkmfzkyfom lou Hkty Ktfk #Tohvk
5>;>&-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
10/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
3
Ych fihk ycky Ktfkm uhbfomk`ftg ft fmtyfyxyfom'`fbcy ft ekthi om k thy ol bo|humfmb ~ufmdf~`ht ycky
kuh xtxk``v tckuhi kgomb hsftyfmb oubkmfzkyfomt-
Lfuty, Ktfkt uhbfomk` kuukmbhghmyt yhmi yo hg~cktfzh l`hsfef`fyv, fmlougk`fyv, kmi domthmtxt-
K`ycoxbc ihdftfom'gkafmb ux`ht kuh duhkyhi yo exf`i domthmtxt fm k l`hsfe`h rkv gouh yckm
ycuoxbc tyufdy xmkmfgfyv, ych ~uodhtt yhmit yo `fgfy ihdftf|hmhtt-
Thdomi, k bhmhuk` ~uhlhuhmdh lou mom'efmifmb kmi xmf`kyhuk` doggfyghmyt ghkmt Ktfkt
uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt o~hukyh xmihu lhr hs~`fdfy ~uodhixuk` ux`ht, kmi ih`hbkyh lhr yktat yo
tykmifmb thduhykufkyt- ^xy kmoychu rkv, ychfu gkmikyht kmi goik`fyfht kuh `kubh`v ih`fehukyf|h
kmi/ou ki|ftouv ukychu yckm iftyufexyf|h kmi/ou uhbx`kyouv-8
Ycfui, uhbfomk` oubkmfzkyfomt yhmi yo t~hdflv om`v k lhr oe`fbkyfomt lou ychfu ghgehut-
Kddhttfom yo uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt xtxk``v uh{xfuht lhr ~o`fdv dckmbht ou doggfyghmyt- Ktfkmuhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt yv~fdk``v fmd`xih k`` ych hdomogfht fm k bf|hm bhobuk~cfdk` kuhk- Ycft
fmd`xtf|fyv ft k`to hs~uhtthi fm yhugt ol o~hm uhbfomk`ftgou uhbfomk`ftg rfyc ych `hkty
iftdufgfmkyouv dog~omhmy lou momghgehutkm fihk lougk``v kllf`fkyhi rfyc K^HDt yukih
`fehuk`fzkyfom ~o`fdv, exy rcfdc k`to ckt k thdxufyv dommoykyfom, kt h|fihmdhi fm Ktfkt thdxufyv
fmtyfyxyfomtych KUL kmi, gouh uhdhmy`v, ych KTHKM Ihlhmdh Gfmftyhut Ghhyfmb ^`xt Hfbcy
#KIGG!3&ihtfbmhi lou hmbkbfmb ych gkjou ~orhut #Bkumkxy ;66;;&-
Moyke`h hsdh~yfomt fmd`xih K^HD
kmi kubxke`v KTHKM ycky ck|h fmyuoixdhi k thy ol ykubhyt kmi ux`ht yo bo|hum kdyfomt ol ychfu
ghgehut, k`ycoxbc ychfu kbuhhghmyt kuh tyf`` mom'efmifmb- Kt k uhtx`y, ych gomfyoufmb kmi
hmloudhghmy ~orhut ol goty uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt kuh t`hmihu-
&
O|hukudcfmb #5&KTHKM ~`xt ych ^UD, Jk~km, kmi Uh~xe`fd ol Aouhk #KTHKM!4&1 Hkty KtfkTxggfy #HKT&
Lxmdyfomk` #3&
KTHKM!4 Gkduohdomogfd Uhthkudc Ollfdh #KGUO&1 Ekv ol Ehmbk` Fmfyfkyf|h louGx`yf'Thdyouk` Yhdcmfdk` kmi Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom #EFGTYHD&1 Dhmyuk` Ekmatol Toxychkty Ktfk, Mhr Zhk`kmi, kmi Kxtyuk`fk #THKMZK&1 Douk` Yufkmb`hFmfyfkyf|h #DYF&1 Duhify Bxkukmyhh kmi Fm|htyghmy Lkdf`fyv #DBFL&1 HdomogfdDoo~hukyfom Oubkmfzkyfom #HDO&1 Hshdxyf|ht Ghhyfmb ol Hkty Ktfk'^kdflfd
Dhmyuk` Ekmat #HGHK^&1 Mhyroua ol Ktfkm Uf|hu Ektfm Oubkmfzkyfomt #MKUEO&TXEUHBFOMK@ #5;&
Dhmyuk` Ktfk #4&
Lxmdyfomk` #4&Dhmyuk` Ktfk Uhbfomk` Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom #DKUHD&1 Fmyhumkyfomk` Lxmi louTk|fmb ych Kuk` Thk #FLKT&1 XM T~hdfk` ^uobukggh lou ych Hdomogfht olDhmyuk` Ktfk #T^HDK&
Toxyc Ktfk #9&O|hukudcfmb #;& Toxyc Ktfkm Kttodfkyfom lou Uhbfomk` Doo~hukyfom #TKKUD&
k
Lxmdyfomk` #4&Ekv ol Ehmbk` ^uobukggh Fmyhu'Bo|humghmyk` Oubkmftkyfom #EOE^'FBO&1Toxyc Ktfk Do'o~hukyf|h Hm|fuomghmy ^uobukggh #TKDH^&1 Toxyc KtfkTxeuhbfomk` Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom #TKTHD&
Toxychkty Ktfk #
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
14/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
;5
Ih|h`o~ghmy Dhmyuh, ych TKKUD Ghyhouo`obfdk` Uhthkudc Dhmyuh, ych TKKUD Yxehudx`otft kmi CF\/KFIT Dhmyuh, ych
Toxyc Ktfkm Xmf|hutfyv, kmi ych Toxyc Ktfkm Buoryc [xkiukmb`h-
e
Toxudh: KIE tykll ekthi om lfh`i fmyhu|fhrt-
K mxgehu ol doo~hukyfom ~uobukgt kmi fmfyfkyf|ht o~hukyh xmihu ych KTHKM xgeuh``k- Ychth fmd`xih ych KTHKM
Dhmyuh lou Efoif|hutfyv, ych KTHKM Dhmyuh lou Hmhubv, ych KTHKM Dhmyuh lou ych Ih|h`o~ghmy ol Kbufdx`yxuk`
Doo~hukyf|ht, ych KTHKM Doouifmkyfmb Dhmyuh lou Yukmteoxmikuv Ckzh o``xyfom, ych KTHKM Doxmdf` om hyuo`hxg, ych
KTHKM Hkuyc{xkah Fmlougkyfom Dhmyuh, ych KTHKM Loxmikyfom, ych KTHKM Fmtxukmdh Yukfmfmb kmi Uhthkudc Fmtyfyxyh,
ych KTHKM Fmyhubo|humghmyk` Doggfttfom om Cxgkm Ufbcyt, ych KTHKM T~hdfk`fzhi Ghyhouo`obfdk` Dhmyuh, kmi ych
KTHKM Xmf|hutfyv Mhyroua-
Lxmdyfomk` fmfyfkyf|ht yhmi yo lodxt om k `fgfyhi bhobuk~cfdk` kuhk, k`ycoxbc togh ol ychg ck|h
ehhm amorm yo ihhg~cktfzh bhobuk~cv kmi, fm to iofmb, ~oyhmyfk``v fg~hih kmv uhbfomk`fzfmb
fg~hukyf|h #Cxuuh`` ;668&- Ychv ihk` hsd`xtf|h`v rfyc hdomogfd kmi/ou ih|h`o~ghmy gkyyhut
#txdc kt yukih, fm|htyghmy, lfmkmdh, `keou, fmluktyuxdyxuh, kmi todfohdomogfd fttxht& ycky kuh
yo k `kubh hsyhmy ih~o`fyfdfzhi #Ykm 5>>6&- Togh ol Ktfkt lxmdyfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt hmjov kghktxuh ol ih`hbkyfom, ~kuyfdx`ku`v ycoth fm Toxyc Ktfk, rchuhkt gkmv ol ycoth fm Toxychkty
Ktfk kuh gouh ~uo~hu`v domtfihuhi olltcooyt xmihu ych cfhukudcv kmi ~xu|fhr ol KTHKM- Ych
KIE `fty fmd`xiht lxmdyfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt fm Ktfk kmi ych ^kdflfd- Ky ych txeuhbfomk` `h|h`, ychuh
kuh fmfyfkyf|ht txdc kt ych Dhmyuk` Ktfk Uhbfomk` Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom #DKUHD&, ych Buhkyhu
Ghaomb Txeuhbfom #BGT& Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom ^uobukg, ych Buhkyhu Yxghm Fmfyfkyf|h #BYF&,
kmi ych Toxyc Ktfkm Txeuhbfomk` Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom #TKTHD&- Hskg~`ht ol fmyukuhbfomk`
lxmdyfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt fmd`xih ych KTHKM!4 Gkduohdomogfd Uhthkudc Ollfdh1 ych Ekv ol
Ehmbk` Fmfyfkyf|h lou Gx`yf'Thdyouk` Yhdcmfdk` kmi Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom1 ych Douk` Yufkmb`h
Fmfyfkyf|h1 ych Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom Oubkmfzkyfom1 ych Hshdxyf|ht Ghhyfmb ol Hkty Ktfk'^kdflfd
Dhmyuk` Ekmat1 kmi ych Mhyroua ol Ktfkm Uf|hu Ektfm Oubkmfzkyfomt-
Ktfkt lkdf`fykyfmbfmtyfyxyfomt lou uhbfomk`ftg kuh ych Xmfyhi Mkyfomt #XM& Hdomogfd kmi Todfk`
Doggfttfom lou Ktfk kmi ych ^kdflfd #HTDK^& kmi KIE- Ychth yro oubkmfzkyfomt ~`kv k
xmf{xh uo`h kt thu|fdh ~uo|fihut yo ychfu ghgehu hdomogfht kmi ychfu mkyfomk` kmi uhbfomk`
fmtyfyxyfomt yo lkdf`fykyh uhbfomk` doo~hukyfom kmi fmyhbukyfom- Ychv dkm goef`fzh `kubh lxmit
luog ychfu fmyhumk` ~uobukgt kmi yk~ luog tfzke`h ~oo`t ol uhtoxudht luog ychfu ~kuymhut kmi
kllf`fkyht, ixh yo ych cfbc `h|h` ol uh~xykyfom ychv doggkmi- Yv~fdk``v, ychv ~uo|fih ki|ftouv,
kigfmftyukyf|h, yhdcmfdk`, kmi lfmkmdfk` tx~~ouy- Fm txeuhbfomt rchuh o|hukudcfmb fmtyfyxyfomt
kuh hfychu rhka ou momhsftyhmy, lkdf`fykyfmb kbhmdfht ~`kv ahv uo`ht fm ch`~fmb lxmdyfomk`
fmtyfyxyfomt domyufexyh yo uhbfomk` doo~hukyfom kmi fmyhbukyfom kdyfmb kt dkyk`vtyt kmidoouifmkyoutou comhty euoahut lou uhbfomk` fmfyfkyf|ht, kt dk~kdfyv exf`ihut, kmi kt
~uo|fihut ol amor`hibh kmi fmlougkyfom om uhbfomk`ftg, fm kiifyfom yo ychfu uo`h kt lxmihut ol
uhbfomk` ~uojhdyt-;>
;>
Fm ft fg~ouykmy yo tyuhtt ycky mhfychu KIE mou HTDK^ gkah tyukyhbfd ihdftfomt om uhbfomk`ftg, rcfdc kuh ych
~xu|fhr ol ychfu ghgehu doxmyufht bo|humghmyt kmi #yo togh hsyhmy& o|hukudcfmb fmtyfyxyfomt, tyuf|fmb fmtyhki yo
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
15/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
;4
Ych `fgfyhi uhgfy kmi tdo~h ol ycft tyxiv ioht moy ~hugfy km fm|htyfbkyfom fmyo k`` ycuhh
dkyhboufht ol Ktfkm fmtyfyxyfomt- Rcky ych lo``orfmb iftdxttfom thhat yo io ft yo `ooa ky th`hdy
f``xtyukyfomt ol o|hukudcfmb kmi lxmdyfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt lodxthi om Hkty kmi Toxyc Ktfk-
8- O\HUKUDCFMB TXEUHBFOMK@ FMTYFYXYFOMT:
DOG^KUFMB KTHKM KMI TKKUD
Yro hskg~`ht ol o|hukudcfmb fmtyfyxyfomt kuh ych txeuhbfomk` oubkmfzkyfomt o~hukyfmb fm
Toxychkty kmi Toxyc Ktfk: KTHKM kmi TKKUD- Ychth fmtyfyxyfomt ck|h dhuykfm tfgf`kufyfht kt
ychv eoyc kuh fmyhubo|humghmyk` kuukmbhghmyt o~hukyfmb fm yro `kubh kmi ivmkgfd txeuhbfomt-
Ychfu ihdftfom'gkafmb tyuxdyxuht kuh `kubh`v domthmtxt'ekthi, kmi ychfu bhmhuk` k~~uokdc ft
yo kio~y |o`xmykuv fmfyfkyf|ht ycky kuh moy `hbk``v efmifmb- Ychfu lxmdyfomt kuh yv~fdk``v uh`kyhi yo
ki|ftouv, mom'ih`fehukyf|h uo`ht, kmi ychv kuh #uh`kyf|h`v& tcouy om ~orhu ih`hbkyfom luog ychfu
ghgehu doxmyufht- Mh|huych`htt, ychth fmtyfyxyfomt ift~`kv fmyhuhtyfmb ifllhuhmdht-
KTHKM, htyke`ftchi fm ;6>4 ychv yooa ych eo`i ihdftfom yo duhkyh km KTHKM Hdomogfd Doggxmfyv #KHD&
ev 5>;8 #oufbfmk``v 5>5>&- ;;
Om ych oychu ckmi, `kxmdchi fm ;638, TKKUD, duhkyhi kt km kdy ol lkfyc
Fm 5>>8, KTHKM `hkihut ~uo~othi ych lougx`kyfom ol km KTHKM
Dckuyhu, rcfdc rkt lougk``v kio~yhi fm Mo|hgehu 5>>2, htyke`ftcfmb KTHKM kt k ux`ht'ekthi
fmtyfyxyfom rfyc togh efmifmb `hbk` oe`fbkyfomt-
;5
hmtxuh ycky ormhutcf~ ol ych ~uobukgt kmi fmfyfkyf|ht ychv lfmkmdh kmi tx~~ouy uhtyt rfyc bo|humghmytychgth`|ht-
bf|hm ych fmfyfk`
`kda ol kmv tckuhi fmyhuhty kmi/ou k|hutfom kgomb fyt ghgehu doxmyufht, ckt tcorm lhrhu
uhtx`yt yckm fyt Toxychkty Ktfkm doxmyhu~kuy- Luog k ;664 kbuhhghmy yo bukixk``v `orhu ykufllt
kgomb ghgehu hdomogfht, `hkihut ih|fthi ych Toxyc Ktfkm Luhh Yukih Kbuhhghmy #TKLYK&
fm 5>>9, rcfdc hmyhuhi fmyo loudh loxu vhkut `kyhu- Corh|hu, TKLYK ckt ehhm ckg~huhi ev
fttxht txdc kt o|huk`` `or fmyukuhbfomk` yukih ukyfot kmi km fmduhktfmb fmdogh bk~, ^kaftykmt
uhlxtk` yo hsyhmi goty lk|ouhi mkyfom #GLM& tykyxt yo Fmifk, kmi txeuhbfomk` bufh|kmdh kbkfmty
Fmifkt fg~otfyfom ol momykufll ekuufhut yo yukih- Ef`kyhuk` yhmtfomt kmi doml`fdyt, rfyc ych Fmio
;;Fm kiifyfom yo ych KHD ev 5>;8, KTHKM kt~fuht yo htyke`ftc ych KTHKM ^o`fyfdk`Thdxufyv Doggxmfyv #K^TD,
loughu`v amorm kt ych KTHKM Thdxufyv Doggxmfyv ou KTD&, kmi KTHKM TodfoDx`yxuk` Doggxmfyv #KTDD&-
Ykahm yobhychu, ych KHD, K^TD, kmi KTDD rf`` loug ych ycuhh ~f``kut ol ych KTHKM Doggxmfyv-
;5Fmifkm ^ufgh Gfmftyhu Ukjf| Bkmicft ihtduf~yfom ol TKKUDt duhkyfom ky ych lfuty TKKUD Txggfy fm Ickak fm
;638 #Dchuxmf`kg 5>>3: 494&-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
16/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
;9
^kaftykmf doml`fdy ehfmb ych goty yuoxe`htogh, ck|h tfbmflfdkmy`v fg~hihi hllhdyf|h txeuhbfomk`
doo~hukyfom-
Eoyc fmtyfyxyfomt thduhykufkyt, rcoth uhgfyt ck|h ~ufmdf~k``v ehhm yo lxumftc kigfmftyukyf|h
tx~~ouy ukychu yckm ehhm fm|htyhi rfyc ~orhut ol ih`hbkyfom, domyfmxh yo eh lxmihi ev |huv
tgk`` exibhyt kmi ifi moy kfg yo duhkyh uhbfomk` exuhkxdukdfht ~uogoyfmb k gouh fmih~hmihmykbhmik lou fmyhbukyfom ehvomi ych tdo~h ~uo|fihi ev fmyhubo|humghmyk` doo~hukyfom
tyuxdyxuht- Fm ych ;63>t, KTHKMt fdomfd ~uojhdyt rhuh gkmkbhi ev doggfyyhht, exy ychth
rhuh moy bf|hm uht~omtfef`fyv o|hu ych buorfmb hdomogfd fmyhukdyfomt kmi fmyhbukyfom fm ych
Toxychkty Ktfkm uhbfom ycky rkt fm hllhdy iuf|hm `kubh`v ev yukih `fehuk`fzkyfom ~o`fdfht kio~yhi
ev fmif|fixk` ghgehu doxmyufht- KTHKM ckt ehhm ke`h yo hmckmdh fyt thduhykufky, corh|hu,
rfyc ych kio~yfom ol ych dckuyhu kmi oychu fmfyfkyf|ht yo hs~kmi fyt fmtyfyxyfomk` lxmdyfom- Ych
dckuyhu rkt k`to km fg~ouykmy tyh~ yo fg~uo|h KTHKMt dog~`fkmdh ghdckmftgt, tyuhkg`fmh
fyt ihdftfom'gkafmb tyuxdyxuh, kmi tyuhmbychm fyt ift~xyh'thyy`hghmy ghdckmftg-
Exy th|huk` fg~ouykmy lkdyout domyfmxh yo `fgfy fyt uo`h txdc kt ych ~ufmdf~`h ol h{xk` domyufexyfomyo ych thduhykufkyt exibhy kmi ych lkdy ycky fy dkmmoy ykah kmv gkjou ~uo~otk` ou fmfyfkyf|h
rfycoxy ych lx`` domthmy ol ghgehu doxmyufht bo|humghmy ollfdfk`t, eh fy fm ych loug ol fyt thmfou
ollfdfk`t ghhyfmbt, thmfou hdomogfd ollfdfk`t ghhyfmbt, ou cfbc'`h|h` ykta loudh-;4
Kt km fmyhubo|humghmyk` fmtyfyxyfom, TKKUD kio~yhi km oubkmfzkyfomk` tyuxdyxuh tfgf`ku yo
KTHKMt ixufmb fyt hku`v vhkut- K doxmdf` ol louhfbm gfmftyhut, kttftyhi ev k tykmifmb
doggfyyhh ol thmfou ollfdfk`t, ft hmyuxtyhi rfyc ych lougx`kyfom ol ~o`fdfht, uh|fhr ol ~uobuhtt,
kmi gkafmb ihdftfomt om mhr kuhkt ol doo~hukyfom, kt rh`` kt ych htyke`ftcghmy ol
ghdckmftgt ycky kuh ihhghi mhdhttkuv- Gxdc `fah KTHKMt doggfyyhht, TKKUD yhdcmfdk`
doggfyyhht #ou doggfyyhht ol hs~huyt& ck|h ehhm htyke`ftchi yo fg~`hghmy, doouifmkyh, kmi
gomfyou ~uobuhtt ol fyt fmyhbukyfom ~uojhdyt #Ukbck|km ;668&- Ychth doggfyyhht lodxt ychfu
kdyf|fyfht om fmluktyuxdyxuh, tdfhmdh kmi yhdcmo`obv, cxgkm ih|h`o~ghmy, kmi hmhubv-
Ih`hbkyfom yo
ych thduhykufky ft `fgfyhi yo gkmkbfmb ych ift~xyh thyy`hghmy ghdckmftg kmi gomfyoufmb ych
fg~`hghmykyfom ol ych KTHKM Hdomogfd Doggxmfyv #KHD& E`xh~ufmy- Ycft txbbhtyt ycky
iht~fyh ych ~uobuhtt gkih yorkuit k ux`ht'ekthi uhbfomk`ftg, KTHKM uhgkfmt uoexty`v
fmyhubo|humghmyk`, rfyc `fyy`h ih`hbkyfom tfmdh fy uh`fht om olltcooyt ukychu yckm fmih~hmihmy
kbhmdfht yo fg~`hghmy ~o`fdv- Km fmih~hmihmy uh|fhr uhdhmy`v domixdyhi ev ych thduhykufky
txbbhtyhi ycky om`v keoxy 4>( ol ych uhbfomk` doo~hukyfom fmfyfkyf|ht ykahm ev KTHKM o|hu ych
vhkut ck|h ehhm kdyxk``v fg~`hghmyhi, ukftfmb k dufyfdk` {xhtyfom o|hu ych hllhdyf|hmhtt ol ychoubkmfzkyfom kmi ~uo|fifmb km kiifyfomk` goyf|kyfom lou fmyuoixdfmb lxuychu fmtyfyxyfomk` uhlougt
kmi fmmo|kyfom #Ihtahu 5>>3&-
Luog k `ombtykmifmb tx~~ouyfmb uo`h, TKKUD thduhykufkyt kbhmik ckt hs~kmihi yo fmd`xih
do|hukbh ol fttxht txdc kt uhbfomk` dommhdyf|fyv kmi cxgkm ih|h`o~ghmy, kt rh`` kt ~o`fdv
doouifmkyfom fm uht~omth yo ych 5>>35>>6 b`oek` lfmkmdfk` duftft- Exy ych fg~`hghmykyfom ol
;4Om ych `fgfykyfomt ol ych KTHKM Thduhykufky, ~uh' kmi ~oty'dckuyhu, thh Th|hufmo #5>>
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
17/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
;8
TKKUDt chuk`ihi fdomfd ~uojhdy, ych Toxyc Ktfk Luhh Yukih Kuhk #TKLYK& ft `kbbfmb ehcfmi-
Ky ych tkgh yfgh, corh|hu, k ahv fmmo|kyfom fm TKKUD ft ych duhkyfom ol uhbfomk` dhmyhut
ycfuyhhm dxuuhmy`v hsftyycky lodxt om t~hdflfd ~uobukgt yo lkdf`fykyh uhbfomk` doo~hukyfom ky ych
buoxmi `h|h`- Fmyhuhtyfmb`v, ych dk~fyk` doty kmi kigfmftyukyf|h exibhy ol hkdc uhbfomk` dhmyhu
kuh eoumh ev ych uht~hdyf|h coty doxmyuv, rcf`h ~uobukg exibhyt kuh tckuhi ev k`` ghgehubo|humghmyt fm ~uo~ouyfom yo ychfu buott ioghtyfd ~uoixdy #BI^&- Ych dhmyhut kuh o|huthhm ev
ych thduhykufky, rcfdc uh~ouyt om ychfu kdyf|fyfht yo ych txggfy- Ych kdyf|fyfht kuh k~~uo|hi ev
ych ~uobukg doggfyyhh kmi ych txggfy, rchuhkt fg~`hghmykyfom uht~omtfef`fyv uhtyt rfyc coty
doxmyuv bo|humghmyt- Ycft txbbhtyt ycky rcf`h domduhyh uhtx`yt fm yhugt ol d`othu uhbfomk`
fmyhbukyfom gkv tyf`` ykah yfgh yo eh thhm, TKKUD ckt gkih ~uobuhtt fm fyt bo|humkmdh
tyuxdyxuh, kt ychuh ftom ~k~huk ukychu hsyhmtf|h ih`hbkyfom ol uht~omtfef`fyfht yo th~kukyh
fmtyfyxyfomt #Ekux 5>>6&-
KTHKM d`hku`v `hkit TKKUD fm o|huk`` hdomogfd fmyhbukyfom- Ych fmyuoixdyfom ol ych KHD
E`xh~ufmy, kddog~kmfhi ev k tvtyhg ol tdouh dkuit yo gomfyou ghgehut dog~`fkmdh rfyc ychfu
doggfyghmyt yo go|h k`omb ych duhkyfom ol k doggom KTHKM gkuahy ck|h duhkyhi k
goghmyxg- KTHKMt ~kuyfdf~kyfom fm ych Buox~ ol Yrhmyv #B5>& ghhyfmbt, k`ehfy tyf`` kt km
oethu|hu, ckt lxuychu ~uogoyhi ych ~f|oyk` uo`h fy ft ~`kvfmb yo tx~~ouy rfihu Ktfkm fmyhbukyfom-
Corh|hu, TKKUD ckt tcorm gouh fmmo|kyfom fm ih`hbkyfom yckm KTHKM, rcoth tyuxdyxuht
kmi bo|humfmb ~ufmdf~`ht uhgkfm uoexty`v fmyhubo|humghmyk`- ;9
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
18/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
;>5 k BGT `hkihut txggfy ckt ehhm oubkmfzhi h|huv ycuhh vhkut-;8
K lhkyxuh ol BGT ckt ehhm k lodxt om lo``orfmb k eoyyog'x~ k~~uokdc, iuf|hm ev `odk`
kxycoufyfht kmi doggxmfyfht gouh yckm ev mkyfomk` bo|humghmyt, kmi htyke`ftcfmb hdomogfd
`fmat kgomb fyt ghgehut- K`ycoxbc KIE ckt domyfmxoxt`v ~uo|fihi lfmkmdfk` kmi yhdcmfdk`tx~~ouy, ych BGT fmtyfyxyfomk` tyuxdyxuh ft ifuhdy`v oubkmfzhi ev fyt ghgehu doxmyufht- @odk`
domtyfyxhmdfht ck|h ~uo~othi kmi fmyuoixdhi mhr fmfyfkyf|ht kmi lxmifmb ckt ehhm toxudhi
luog ghgehu doxmyufht kmi fmyhumkyfomk` iomout- Kt k uhtx`y, ych BGT ckt txddhttlx``v
mkuuorhi ych fmdogh bk~ kmi ~uogoyhi k d`othu thmth ol doggxmfyv kgomb fyt ghgehut- Fy ft
olyhm dfyhi kt km hskg~`h ol txddhttlx` txeuhbfomk` fmyhbukyfom-
Duhkyhi fm ;662 luog k Yckf ~uo~otk` yo htyke`ftc k `fma ehyrhhm Toxychkty kmi Toxyc Ktfk lou
~uogoyfmb hdomogfd ih|h`o~ghmy ycuoxbc ych fg~`hghmykyfom ol yhdcmfdk` doo~hukyfom
~uojhdyt kgomb mhfbceoufmb doxmyufht, EFGTYHD dkm eh thhm kt ych dogfmb yobhychu ol ych
@ooa Rhty ~o`fdv ol Yckf`kmi kmi ych @ooa Hkty~o`fdv ol Fmifk #Ih|f 5>>2&- Ych buox~,
dog~uftfmb lf|h TKKUD doxmyufht #Ekmb`kihtc, Ecxykm, Fmifk, Mh~k`, kmi Tuf @kmak& ~`xt
Gvkmgku kmi Yckf`kmi, ~uogoyht yhdcmfdk` doo~hukyfom fm ;9 ~ufoufyv thdyout, hkdc `hi ev
ghgehut om k |o`xmykuv ektft-;>6-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
19/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
;2
rkv lou km h|hmyxk` luhh yukih kuhk k`ycoxbc togh oethu|hut io moy louhthh ycft ih|h`o~ghmy
kt `fah`v yo ck~~hm fm ych mhku lxyxuh- EFGTYHD ckt mo thduhykufky kmi fyt kdyf|fyfht kuh
doouifmkyhi ev km ollfdh `odkyhi fm ych Yckf Louhfbm Gfmftyuv, exy ~uh~kukyfomt kuh dxuuhmy`v
ehfmb gkih lou ych htyke`ftcghmy ol k ~hugkmhmy thduhykufky ycky dox`i eh fm Ekmb`kihtc ou
Tuf @kmak, kt eoyc ck|h ollhuhi yo thu|h kt coty doxmyufht-Fm ych kuhk ol uhbfomk` lfmkmdfk` doo~hukyfom, yro ol ych gkfm fmfyfkyf|ht ycky hghubhi luog ych
Hdomogfd Uh|fhr kmi ^o`fdv Ifk`obxh tykuyhi ev ych KTHKM!4 doxmyufht klyhu ych Ktfkm
lfmkmdfk` duftft ol ;662;663 kuh ych Dcfkmb Gkf Fmfyfkyf|h #DGF& kmi fyt gx`yf`kyhuk`fzkyfom
#DGFG&, kmi ych Ktfkm Eomi Gkuahyt Fmfyfkyf|h #KEGF& #KIE 5>>31 Kumhu 5>>61 Bodcodo'
Ekxyftyk 5>>61 Dk~kmmh``f 5>;;&-;2
Ych Xmfyhi Tykyht #XT& |hyo yo ych duhkyfom ol km Ktfkm Gomhykuv Lxmi #KGL&, ~uo~othi evJk~km fm uhkdyfom yo ych ;662;663 Ktfkm lfmkmdfk` duftft, `hi yo ych tyuhmbychmfmb ol Ktfkt
lfmkmdfk` doo~hukyfom- Fm ~kuyfdx`ku, ych lfuty oejhdyf|h ol Ktfkm doxmyufht rkt yo fmtxuh
ychgth`|ht kbkfmty ych uhdxuuhmdh ol k tfgf`ku, ih|ktykyfmb duftft kmi ykafmb luog km hsftyfmb
KTHKM trk~ kbuhhghmy fmyuoixdhi fm ;623, ychv thy x~ ych DGF, ou k tvtyhg ol ef`kyhuk`
dxuuhmdv trk~t kgomb uhbfomk` gomhykuv kxycoufyfht yo ~uo|fih tcouy'yhug `f{xfifyv yo
doxmyufht fm fgghifkyh mhhi- @kxmdchi fm 5>>>, ych DGF ckt hs~kmihi kmi ych tvtyhg ol
ef`kyhuk` trk~ kbuhhghmyt rkt gx`yf`kyhuk`fzhi fm 5>>3, duhkyfmb k doggom ~oo` ol uhbfomk`
lxmitych DGFGbo|humhi ev k tfmb`h domyukdy kmi do``hdyf|h`v gkmkbhi ev ych KTHKM!4
doxmyufht #KIE 5>;>&-
Rh iftdxtt eh`or ych DGFG kmi ych douo``kuv ihdftfom yo
thy x~ k uhbfomk` txu|hf``kmdh kbhmdv xmihu ych KGUO, kt fy tcort ych kef`fyv ol Ktfkm
bo|humghmyt yo fmyuoixdh km fmtyfyxyfomk` fmmo|kyfom kt km KTHKM!4 olltcooy, rfyc ~oyhmyfk`
fg~ouykmy fg~`fdkyfomt lou ych lxyxuh ol uhbfomk` hdomogfd doo~hukyfom-
Ych KTHKM!4 lfmkmdh gfmftyhut kbuhhi ky ychfu 5>>6 ghhyfmb fm Ek`f, Fmiomhtfk, om ych gkfm
DGFG dog~omhmyt, txdc kt fmif|fixk` doxmyuv domyufexyfomt, eouuorfmb kddhttfef`fyv, kmi ych
fmyuoixdyfom ol k uhbfomk` txu|hf``kmdh ghdckmftg yo hmtxuh ycky eouuorhut ol DGFG lxmit
rox`i ck|h hmoxbc dk~kdfyv yo uh~kv ychfu ihey- ;3
;2
Ych KEGF, rcfdc rkt ollfdfk``v `kxmdchi fm 5>>4, kfgt yo ch`~ uhdvd`fmb Ktfkm tk|fmbt fmyo Ktfkm fm|htyghmy ev
~uogoyfmb ych ih|h`o~ghmy ol `odk` dxuuhmdv'ihmogfmkyhi eomi gkuahyt, lkdf`fykyfmb buhkyhu kddhttfef`fyv yo ych
uhbfomk` eomi gkuahyt, kmi hmckmdfmb gkuahy fmluktyuxdyxuh-
Ych tfzh ol fyt uhthu|h ~oo` rkt lfuty
fmduhkthi luog )3> ef``fom yo );5> ef``fom, kmi fm Gkudc 5>;5 fy rkt ioxe`hi yo )59> ef``fom rfyc
KTHKM doxmyufht ehkufmb 5>( ol ych lxmit domyufexyfomt kmi ych oychu 3>( eoumh ev ych
^`xt Ycuhh doxmyufht- Fm ~kuyfdx`ku, ych fmyhubo|humghmyk` uhto`xyfom om ych domyufexyfom
tckuht ol ych ^UD, Jk~km, kmi ych Uh~xe`fd ol Aouhk ft buoxmihi om km hsdh``hmy oxydogh ol
lfmkmdfk` if~`ogkdv kt Ktfkt yro `kubhty hdomogfhtych ^UD kmi Jk~kmkbuhhi yo ~hudhf|h
ychgth`|ht kt h{xk``v tfzhi, rcf`h k``orfmb ych Uh~xe`fd ol Aouhk yo ~otfyfom fyth`l kt co`ifmb k
tckuh h{xk` yo ck`l ol ych yro- Ych 3>( domyufexyfom tckuh ol ych ^`xt Ycuhh doxmyufht rkt fm
;3Ych DGFG ollfdfk``v dkgh fmyo hllhdy om 59 Gkudc 5>;>-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
20/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
;3
lkdy h{xk``v if|fihi ehyrhhm Jk~km kmi ych ^UD, rcfdc co`i k 45( tckuh hkdc fm ych DGFG,
rfyc ych Uh~xe`fd ol Aouhk domyufexyfmb ych uhgkfmfmb ;;;&-;6
Ych tgk`` doxmyuv efkt fm lk|ou ol ych Uh~xe`fd ol Aouhk ft xthi kt k gouh bhmhuk` ~ufmdf~`h fm
ych bo|humkmdh ol DGFG yo moy om`v k``odkyh ych 5>( domyufexyfom tckuht kgomb ych KTHKM
doxmyufht, exy k`tokmi gouh fg~ouykmy`vyo ihdfih ych gx`yf~`fhu xthi yo ihyhugfmh ychkdyxk` {xoyk ycky hkdc doxmyuv dkm eouuor, ekthi om fyt lfmkmdfk` domyufexyfom- Kt Yke`h 5
tcort, rcf`h ych gx`yf~`fhu lou `kubh hdomogfht txdc kt ych ^UD kmi Jk~km ft om`v 8>( ol
ychfu lfmkmdfk` domyufexyfomt, ych tgk``hu KTHKM hdomogfht dkm eouuor luog ych DGFG lf|h
yfght kt gxdc ychfu lfmkmdfk` domyufexyfomt- Kmi fm yhugt ol |oyfmb ~orhu, ych KTHKM doxmyufht
do``hdyf|h`v doggkmi k 53-9;( tckuh ol ych yoyk`, rcfdc ft uh`kyf|h`v cfbchu yckm ychfu do``hdyf|h
tckuh ol lfmkmdfk` domyufexyfomt #5>(&-
Kmoychu fg~ouykmy fmmo|kyfom fmyuoixdhi rfyc ych DGFG ft k ih~kuyxuh luog k ihdftfom'gkafmb
tyuxdyxuh ekthi xmf{xh`v om domthmtxt yo kio~y k gouh l`hsfe`h tvtyhg k``orfmb lou k yro'
ycfuit {xk`flfhi gkjoufyv fm ych dkth ol o~hukyfomk` #`hmifmb& gkyyhut, rcf`h ihdftfomt omlxmikghmyk` fttxht, txdc kt kbuhhghmyt om ych yhugt ol `hmifmb, uh|fhrt ol eouuorfmb
gx`yf~`fhut, ghgehutcf~, tfzh, kmi FGL domifyfomk`fyv ukyfot, domyfmxh yo eh ykahm ev domthmtxt
kgomb ych KTHKM!4 ghgehut- Ych DGFG |oyfmb tckuht k`to uhl`hdy k ihyhugfmkyfom moy yo
k``or kmv ol ych ^`xt Ycuhh doxmyufht fmif|fixk``v, mou k`` KTHKM doxmyufht yobhychu, yo co`i k
|hyo ~orhu om ihdftfom gkafmb-
;6Ych ^UD tckuh ft kdyxk``v if|fihi ehyrhhm k 53-8( domyufexyfom luog ych ^UD kmi k 4-8( domyufexyfom luog
Comb Aomb, Dcfmk- Ixh yo ych mkyxuh ol ych DGF, ekthi om ych kddxgx`kyfom ol louhfbm hsdckmbh uhthu|ht ev
Ktfkm doxmyufht yo eh goef`fzhi fm dkth ol tcouy'yhug `f{xfifyv mhhit, uh~uhthmykyf|ht ol ych Comb Aomb Gomhykuv
Kxycoufyv ck|h domyfmxoxt`v tckuhi k ~uhthmdh fm DGF ghhyfmbt rfyc uh~uhthmykyf|ht luog ych ^ho~`ht Ekma ol
Dcfmk-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
21/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
;6
Yke`h 5: X~ikyhi Lfmkmdfk` Domyufexyfomt, Eouuorfmb Kuukmbhghmyt, kmi \oyfmb ^orhu
xmihu ych DGFG #klyhu yoyk` tfzh fmduhkth yo )59> ef``fom&
Ghgehut
Lfmkmdfk`
Domyufexyfomt
Eouuorfmb
Kuukmbhghmyt
\oyfmb
^orhu
) ef``fom(
tckuh Gx`yf~`fhu
[xoyk:Gksfgxg
Trk~Kgoxmy #)
ef``fom&
Mo- olEktfd\oyht
Mo- ol \oyhtEkthi om
DomyufexyfomtYoyk` Mo-ol \oyht ( tckuh
^UD #fmd`xiht CombAomb, Dcfmk&
2>45->>> 53-9;>
^UD #hsd`xiht CombAomb, Dcfmk
> 53-8>> >-8> 49-5> 4-5>> > 2;-> 58-94>
Comb Aomb, Dcfmk 3-9>> 4-8>>5-8> >->>> 3-9>>
3-9>>5-63>
Jk~km 2> 45->>> >-8> 43-9> 4-5>> 2> 3>->>> 53-9;>
Uh~xe`fd ol Aouhk 43-9>> ;>> ;->> 43-9> 4-5>> 43-9>> 9;-> ;9-22>
^`xt Ycuhh Doxmyufht ;65->>> 3>->>> 6-> ;65->>> 5>;-> 2;-86>
Euxmhf Ikuxttk`kg >-> >->58 8->> >-4> 4-5>> >-> 4-5 ;-;83
Dkgeoifk >-59> >-;>> 8->> ;-5> 4-5>> >-59> 4-99> ;-555
Fmiomhtfk 6-;>9 4-264 5-8> 55-2< 4-5>> 6-;>9 ;5-4>> 9-4-> >->58 8->> >-4> 4-5>> >-> 4-5 ;-;83
Gk`kvtfk 6-;>9 4-264 5-8> 55-2< 4-5>> 6-;>9 ;5-4>> 9-4-;5> >->8> 8->> >- 4-5>> >-;5> 4-45> ;-;26
^cf`f~~fmht 6-;>9 4-264 5-8> 55-2< 4-5>> 6-;>9 ;5-4>> 9-49 4-264 5-8> 55-2< 4-5>> 6-;>9 ;5-4>> 9-49 4-264 5-8> 55-2< 4-5>> 6-;>9 ;5-4>> 9-4>> >-344 8->> ;>->> 4-5>> 5->>> 8-5>> ;-392
KTHKM 93->> 5>->> 45->> 93->> 3>->> 53-9;
KTHKM!4 59>->> ;>>->> 9;- 59>->> 53;- ;>>->>
KTHKM 7 Kttodfkyfom ol Toxychkty Ktfkm Mkyfomt1 KTHKM!4 7 KTHKM ~`xt ych UD, Jk~km kmi ych Uh~xe`fd ol Aouhk1
@ko IU 7 @ko ho~`ht Ihgodukyfd Uh~xe`fd1 UD 7 ho~`ht Uh~xe`fd ol Dcfmk-
Toxudh: KTHKM!4 Gkduohdomogfd Uhthkudc Ollfdh-
Ych ihdftfom yo duhkyh ych KGUO rkt ollfdfk``v gkih ky ych KTHKM!4 lfmkmdh gfmftyhutghhyfmb fm Gkv 5>;>- Ych gkmikyh ol ycft mhr fmtyfyxyfom, thy x~ fm Tfmbk~ouh fm 5>;;, ft yo
domixdy uhbfomk` gkduohdomogfd kmi lfmkmdfk` txu|hf``kmdh yo hmtxuh ycky eouuorfmb doxmyufht
dkm ghhy ych uh~kvghmy domifyfomt ol ychfu ihey- Rcf`h togh oethu|hut ck|h moyhi ycky ych
dogefmkyfom ol k uhbfomk``v ~oo`hi lxmi ol fmyhumkyfomk` uhthu|ht kmi k uhbfomk` txu|hf``kmdh
kbhmdv ft tfgf`ku yo ych ih'lkdyo duhkyfom ol km KGL, gouh yckm k ihdkih klyhu ych oufbfmk`
Jk~kmhth ~uo~otk`, oychut yhmi yo tyuhtt ych dog~`hghmykuv uh`kyfomtcf~ ycky ych DGFG
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
22/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
5>
KGUO dogefmkyfom rf`` ck|h rfyc ych FGL fm fyt lxmdyfomt kt eoyc k lfmkmdfk` duftht'uhtdxfmb
kbhmdv kt rh`` kt k b`oek` kmi mkyfomk` gkduohdomogfd txu|hf``kmdh fmtyfyxyfom #Akrkf 5>>61
Dk~kmmh``f 5>;;&-5>
Ych duhkyfom ol ych KGUO dox`i fmihhi thu|h kt k tyh~~fmb'tyomh yo ych lougkyfom ol km KGL-
Corh|hu, k lxmikghmyk` fttxh domdhumt rchychu ych KGUO rf`` eh ke`h yo exf`i x~ fytuh~xykyfom kt k yhdcmfdk``v to`fi kmi fmih~hmihmy kbhmdv rfyc tyuomb gkduohdomogfd
txu|hf``kmdh dk~kef`fyfht- Fm ~kuyfdx`ku, ychuh ft ych mhhi yo ih|h`o~ km k~~uo~ufkyh uhbx`kyouv
ghdckmftg ycky dox`i fmtx`kyh ych iftyfmdyf|h lougt ol tykyh'`hi dk~fyk`ftg ~uhthmy fm togh ol
fyt ghgehut luog ych xmihtfuke`h hdomogfd kmi ~o`fyfdk` fg~kdyt ol ~kuyfdf~kyfom fm ych b`oek`
~o`fyfdk` hdomogv, rcf`h k``orfmb ychg yo ykah ki|kmykbh ol fyt ehmhlfyt #Ehhtom 5>>4&- Ych
fttxh ft ektfdk``v rchychu ych KGUO rf`` eh ke`h yo ih`f|hu kt kmi rchm dk``hi x~om lou
uhbx`kyouv doo~hukyfom, tykmikui ckugomfzkyfom, hmckmdhi yukmt~kuhmdv, kmi gx`yf'`h|h`
bo|humkmdh, kmi gouh t~hdflfdk``v yo ~uo|fih ych txu|hf``kmdh kmi uh|fhr ~uodhtt ycky k
txddhttlx` DGFG uh{xfuht-
Ych txddhtt ol ych DGFG fyth`l ft vhy yo eh yhtyhi kt to lku mo doxmyuv ckt k~~`fhi lou
eouuorfmb luog ych uhbfomk` ~oo` ol uhthu|ht- Lou hskg~`h, rchm eoyc ych Uh~xe`fd ol Aouhk
kmi Tfmbk~ouh mhhihi `f{xfifyv tx~~ouy ixufmb ych uhdhmy b`oek` lfmkmdfk` duftft yorkuit ych hmi
ol 5>>3, ychv o~yhi yo uh{xhty ef`kyhuk` duhify `fmht luog ych XT Lhihuk` Uhthu|h, ych Ekma ol
Jk~km, kmi ych ^ho~`ht Ekma ol Dcfmk fmtyhki ol thhafmb yo goef`fzh DGFG lxmit, rcfdc
ukftht fttxht uh`kyhi yo ych k~~uo~ufkyhmhtt ol ych lxmi tfzh- Oychu dck``hmbht lkdfmb ych
DGFG ih|h`o~ghmy domdhum ych ~ottfe`h hs~kmtfom ol fyt ghgehutcf~, kt doxmyufht txdc kt
Fmifk, lou hskg~`h, ck|h uh~hkyhi`v gkmflhtyhi k ahhm fmyhuhtyhi yo eh euoxbcy fm, kt rh`` kt k
~ottfe`h if|hutflfdkyfom ol fyt kdyf|fyfht, luog hghubhmdv `hmifmb yo ych fttxkmdh ol ifllhuhmy
lfmkmdfk` ktthyt rcfdc dox`i h|hmyxk``v `hki ych DGFG kmi ych KGUO yo ih|h`o~ fmyo k ~uo~huKGL, kt k uhbfomk` lxmi lou gomhykuv doo~hukyfom-
2- TYUHMBYCHMFMB KTFKT FMTYFYXYFOMK@
KUDCFYHDYXUH YCUOXBC FMMO\KYFOM KMI UHLOUG
Uhlhuufmb yo uhbfomk`ftg kmi ych tck~fmb ol Ktfkt fmtyfyxyfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh, k loughu yo~
if~`ogky luog ych Uh~xe`fd ol Aouhk, Ckm Txmb'Joo, omdh gxthi, K`ycoxbc fy ft
xmihuih|h`o~hi, uhbfomk`ftg fm Ktfk ft dog~`fdkyhi hmoxbc #H|kmt 5>>8: ;68&-
5>Ych uh`kyfomtcf~ ehyrhhm DGFG kuukmbhghmyt kmi ych FGL ft ych txejhdy ol ihekyh kt xmihu ych dxuuhmy DGFG
thyyfmbt, kmv eouuorhi kgoxmy ycky hsdhhit 5>( ol k doxmyuvt {xoyk ft txejhdy yo FGL domifyfomk`fyv ghktxuht
yo k|ofi gouk` ckzkui- Th|huk` oethu|hut ck|h kubxhi fm lk|oxu ol km h`fgfmkyfom ol ycft FGL `fmakbh-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
23/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
5;
Ych kuukv ol Ktfkt fmtyfyxyfomt lou uhbfomk`ftg ckt hghubhi kt k uhtx`y ol ki cod ihdftfomt
xmihuykahm ev ~o`fdvgkahut fm uht~omth yo ~hudhf|hi, mkuuor lxmdyfomk` hs~hdykyfomt, eh ychv
hdomogfd ou thdxufyv fm oufhmykyfom- Ych tck~fmb ol ychth fmtyfyxyfomt ifi moy lo``or k uhbfomk`
bukmi ihtfbm `fah fm ych dkth ol ych Hxuo~hkm Xmfom- Rcf`h ych hsftyfmb uhbfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh
ckt thu|hi ych uhbfom rh`` to lku, ych ~uhttfmb dck``hmbht ruoxbcy ev b`oek`fzkyfom kmiyukmtmkyfomk`ftg ck|h gkih d`hku ycky fyt dxuuhmy tyuxdyxuh ft fmtxllfdfhmy yo bxkukmyhh ych
domyfmxhi txddhtt ol ych uhbfomt hdomogfht fm k rkv ycky ft txtykfmke`h, h{xfyke`h, kmi
dog~kyfe`h rfyc b`oek` tyuxdyxuht-
Fmihhi, ych uk~fi ~uo`flhukyfom ol uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt fm Ktfk tfmdh ych lfmkmdfk` duftft ol ;662
;663 ft ych domth{xhmdh ol uhbfomk` tykahco`ihut hllouyt yo ghhy hghubfmb dck``hmbht-
K`ycoxbc gouh fmtyfyxyfomt lou uhbfomk` fmyhbukyfom gkv eh mhhihi yo ~huloug lxmdyfomt rcfdc
mkyfomk` kbhmdfht kuh moy vhy uhkiv yo ih`hbkyh yo uhbfomk` oubkmfzkyfomt, ychuh ft k mhhi yo
hmckmdh hsftyfmb fmtyfyxyfomt ycuoxbc km k~~uo~ufkyh ~uodhtt ol uhloug kmi fmmo|kyfom fm ouihu
yo gkah ychg gouh txfyke`h yo oubkmfzh kmi txtykfm k uhbfomk` kbhmik fm ych lxyxuh- Ol doxuth,
rchmh|hu hsftyfmb fmtyfyxyfomt ck|h lx`lf``hi ychfu gkmikyh ou ehdogh uhixmikmy, ychv tcox`i
eh ~ckthi oxy-
K ~uogfmhmy ~o`fdv fmyh``hdyxk` uhdhmy`v `kghmyhi: Ych Ktfk ^kdflfd uhbfom ckt yoo gkmv
oubkmfzkyfomt, vhy ychv tyf`` dkmmoy io k`` ych ycfmbt rh uh{xfuh ol ychg- Fmtyhki ol lodxtfmb om
rcky rh|h boy, rh tcox`i `ooa ky rcky rh mhhi- #Bvmbh`` 5>>2: ;&-
Exy fy ft ifllfdx`y yo ih|h`o~ kmi kbuhh om k thy ol oejhdyf|h dufyhufk ycky dkm eh xthi yo ktthtt
ych ~hulougkmdh ol uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt kmi txbbhty rchm fy ft yfgh lou ychg yo eh iftekmihi-
Kddouifmb yo XT Thduhykuv ol Tykyh Cf``kuv D`fmyom, Ktfk mhhit km fmtyfyxyfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh ycky
gksfgfzht Ktfkt ~uot~hdyt lou hllhdyf|h doo~hukyfom, exf`it yuxty kgomb Ktfkmt, kmi uhixdhtych lufdyfom ol dog~hyfyfom #D`fmyom 5>;>&- Exy ych rcky, cor, kmi cor gxdc uhgkfm coy`v
ihekyhi domtfihukyfomt- Rchychu ych lxyxuh ol Ktfkt fmtyfyxyfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh lou uhbfomk`
fmyhbukyfom ft yo eh loxmi fm ych Hxuo~hkm goih`rfyc k uhbfom'rfih doxmdf` ol gfmftyhut, k
doggfttfom, k ~ku`fkghmy, kmi k doxuy ol jxtyfdhft k ~uo~otfyfom gkmv amor kt gft`hkifmb
ehdkxth Ktfk kmi Hxuo~h kuh yro dog~`hyh`v ifllhuhmy hmyfyfht, rfyc iftyfmdy ekdabuoxmit,
cftyoufht, hmiorghmyt, todfo'~o`fyfdk` tyuxdyxuht, kmi hdomogfd tvtyhgt- Rcf`h ych Hxuo~hkm
Xmfom uhgkfmt km fmt~fukyfom lou gkmv uhbfomk`ftyt, fy dkm ckui`v eh xthi kt k goih` lou Ktfk
#Dk~kmmh``f kmi Lf`f~~fmf 5>;>&- Fm kiifyfom, ych ~uoe`hgt ycky kuh dxuuhmy`v kllhdyfmb ych hxuo
kuhk hdomogfht, kuh dktyfmb k tckior fm ych hvht ol gkmv Ktfkm kmk`vtyt o|hu ych
hllhdyf|hmhtt ol uhbfomk` to`xyfomt-
Kbkfmty ycft ekdaiuo~, fy ft fg~ouykmy yo `ooa ky ycuhh domdhumt ycky fmtyfyxyfomt lou Ktfkm
fmyhbukyfom mhhi yo kiiuhtt yo hllhdyf|h`v t~uhki ych ehmhlfyt ol uhbfomk`ftg ehvomi Lkdyouv
Ktfk: #f& eoyyog'x~ doo~hukyfom1 #ff& fmtyfyxyfomt `fbcymhtt1 kmi #fff& h`fyh uhbfomk`ftg-5;
5;
Ychth domtfihukyfomt kuh iftdxtthi fm Ykm #5>;;&-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
24/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
55
Fuomfdk``v, ychth tkgh lkdyout ck|h cfychuyo lkdf`fykyhi Ktfkt fmyhbukyfom, exy ck|h mor hfychu
ehdogh ou kuh ehdogfmb cfmiukmdht yo lxuychu ~uobuhtt-
2-; Ehvomi Eoyyog'x~ Uhbfomk`ftg
Htyke`ftc k `hkihut'`hi uhbfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh
Ktfk ft ihhghi lukbf`h ehdkxth fyt ~uod`f|fyv lou xmf`kyhuk`ftg kmi mom'uhbx`kyfom, kt rh`` kt fyt
`kda ol rcky Ek`irfm dk``hi yo~'`h|h` gkmkbhghmy #Ek`irfm 5>>3&- Fy ehkut uh~hkyfmb ycky
eoyc ych Uxii kmi Ckyovkgk ~uo~otk`t lou k mhr uhbfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh dk``hi lou k tfmb`h,
o|hukudcfmb tx~hu'fmtyfyxyfom ycky rox`i thu|h kt k afmi ol omh'tyo~ tco~ lou k`` ycfmbt fm
Ktfk- Fm k tfgf`ku |hfm, k yktaloudh om uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh dom|hmhi ev ych ^kdflfd
Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom Doxmdf` #^HDD& dk``hi lou ych htyke`ftcghmy ol km Ktfk'^kdflfd
Txggfy dog~uftfmb ych 5; K^HD ghgehu doxmyufht kmi Fmifk lou cfbc'`h|h` iftdxttfomt om
ahv fttxht- Ych ^HDD uh~ouy k`to xubhi ych duhkyfom ol k Buox~ ol Yhm #B;>&, km fmlougk`dkxdxt domtftyfmb ol ych Ktfk'^kdflfd ghgehut ol ych B5>, rcfdc dox`i otyhmtfe`v |ofdh ych
do``hdyf|h domdhumt ol k`` Ktfk'^kdflfd doxmyufht #Tohtktyuo, Bvmbh``, Gouuftom, kmi Rkmkmif
5>>6&-
Iht~fyh KTHKMt rkufmhtt kbkfmty tykahco`ihut uhdhmy ~uogx`bkyfom ol uhbfomk` |ftfomt
rfycoxy ~ufou domtx`ykyfom rfyc KTHKM, ych fmd`xtfom ol ych XT kmi Uxttfk fm ych Hkty Ktfk
Txggfy #HKT& ckt hllhdyf|h`v yxumhi ych HKT fmyo k ih lkdyo, yo~'yfhu fmtyfyxyfom- Ycft dox`i eh
ych lfuty tyh~ yorkui km o|hukudcfmb, `hkihut'`hi kuukmbhghmy ycky rox`i lxumftc ych |ftfomkuv
bxfikmdh kmi gkudcfmb ouihut lou oychu ~uo~othi h`hghmyt ol ych uhbfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh- Ahv
yo ycft tyh~ rox`i eh ych htyke`ftcghmy ol ych Dog~uhchmtf|h Hdomogfd ^kuymhutcf~ lou Hkty
Ktfk #DH^HK&, km KTHKM!< ~`km ycky `fmat ych KTHKM!4 hdomogfht rfyc ycoth ol Fmifk,
Kxtyuk`fk, kmi Mhr Zhk`kmi- Ycky tkfi, oychut ck|h kubxhi ycky ych HKT rox`i ehmhlfy luog
ych jofmy ~xutxfy ol ych DH^HK kt rh`` kt ych Hkty Ktfk Luhh Yukih Kuhk #HKLYK&, rcfdc
hmdog~kttht om`v ych KTHKM!4 doxmyufht-55 Mhhi`htt yo tkv, k tyke`h uhbfomk` ouihu rf`` eh
duxdfk` yo txdc ih|h`o~ghmyt- Ych iftkbuhhghmyt ehyrhhm ych ^UD kmi Jk~km fm 5>>95>>8
o|hu ych fmd`xtfom ol Kxtyuk`fk, Fmifk, kmi Mhr Zhk`kmi fm ych HKT thu|h kt k togehu uhgfmihu
ycky mo |fke`h yo~'`h|h` gkmkbhghmy rox`i eh ~ottfe`h rfycoxy ych kef`fyv kmi rf``fmbmhtt ol
ych efb ~orhutych ^UD, Jk~km, Fmifk, ych Uxttfkm Lhihukyfom, kmi ych XTyo lfmi doggom
buoxmi kmi kbuhh yo roua yobhychu- Om ych oychu ckmi, rchychu KTHKM ft ~uh~kuhi yo
doxmyhmkmdh ych ~uot~hdy lou txdc km fmtyfyxyfomk` cfhukudcv o|hu ych hsykmy |kufke`h bhoghyuvft k ahv domtfihukyfom, ~kuyfdx`ku`v fl KTHKM ft moy fmd`xihi rfycfm ycky gkmkbhghmy-
54
55
Tfmbk~ouht ^ufgh Gfmftyhu @hh Ctfhm @oomb gkih ycft oethu|kyfom #Ykm 5>;>e&-
54KTHKM ghgehut iftgkv o|hu ych Uxii ~uo~otk`, km hku`v fmdkumkyfom ol rcfdc uh`fhi om k domdhuy ol ~orhut
rfycoxy k ahv uo`h lou KTHKM, ft k yh``fmb f``xtyukyfom- Fl kmvycfmb, fy dox`i eh kubxhi ycky |kufke`h bhoghyuv kmi k
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
25/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
54
X`yfgkyh`v, rcky ft mhhihi ft k tyuxdyxuh lou fg~uo|fmb doouifmkyfom ol ych fmfyfkyf|ht ol ifllhuhmy
txeuhbfomk` buox~t, uhkttxufmb oychu Ktfkm doxmyufht keoxy ych fmyhmyfomt ol ycoth fmyhmy om
~xtcfmb kchki rfyc ihh~hu fmyhbukyfom, kmi ~uo|fifmb k tyuxdyxuh lou lotyhufmb uh`kyfomt
ehyrhhm fmyhbukyfmb Ktfk kmi hsyuk'uhbfomk` ~orhut- Gouh `fah`v, ycft mhhi ft ehty ghy ycuoxbc
uh|kg~fmb hsftyfmb fmtyfyxyfomt ukychu yckm duhkyfmb mhr omht-Tyuhkg`fmh kmi tvmhubfzh ev lougfmb d`xtyhut kmi `fmafmb fttxht
K`ycoxbc Ktfk ft mo `ombhu tcouy om uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt, kt ych KIE tyxiv ckt rh``
iodxghmyhi, ych ihmtfyv, ihh~hmfmb, kmi fmyuxtf|hmhtt ol fyt kudcfyhdyxuh uhgkfmt rfycoxy k
dog~uhchmtf|h uhbfom'rfih |ftfom- Exy h|hm fl Ktfk rhuh yo yuhki fyt orm ~kyc lou ~km'
uhbfomk`ftg, ych domdhum ft ycky gouh hllfdkdv kmi hllhdyf|hmhtt ft mhhihi ol fyt fmtyfyxyfomt-
Togh hs~huyt eh`fh|h Ktfk ckt yoo gkmv fmtyfyxyfomt ycky io moy bhy ych joe iomh- Ychv dk`` lou
~ukdyfdk` uhloug ol ycoth kuukmbhghmyt fm `fmh rfyc ych domdhum lou o|huk`` kudcfyhdyxuk`
dochuhmdh- ^uo~othi uhlougt fmd`xih, kgomb oychu ycfmbt, d`kuflvfmb kmi tyuhkg`fmfmb
fmtyfyxyfomk` uo`ht kmi uht~omtfef`fyfht- Om ych oychu ckmi, oychu hs~huyt kubxh lou uhd`kfgfmbych K^HD gkmikyh kt km hdomogfd louxg lodxthi ~ufgkuf`v om yukih `fehuk`fzkyfom kmi
fm|htyghmykmi, ev fg~`fdkyfom, ~uhthu|fmb ych dog~kuyghmyk`fzkyfomkmi tyuhmbychmfmb
ycoth fmtyfyxyfomt kt ~uoe`hg'to`|fmb ou kdyfom'oufhmyhi ghdckmftgt ukychu yckm jxty yk`a
tco~t-
Ych ~hutftyhmy dog~kuyghmyk`fzkyfom ol fttxht fm ych hsftyfmb uhbfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh ol Ktfk ft
doxmyhufmyxfyf|h fm ych `fbcy ol ych buorfmb dog~`hsfyv kmi dog~uhchmtf|hmhtt ol uhbfomk`
dck``hmbht ~othi ev b`oek`fzkyfom kmi yukmtmkyfomk`ftg- Fttxht `fah yukih kmi lfmkmdh, chk`yc
kmi cxgkmfykufkm domdhumt, kmi d`fgkyh'uh`kyhi gkyyhut, dkm mo `ombhu eh yuhkyhi kt th~kukyh
luog thdxufyv domdhumt- Ych ih`fehukyh d`xtyhufmb ol fttxht rchuh ykdyfdk` `fmakbht dkm kmi
tcox`i eh gkih ehyrhhm kmi kduott fmtyfyxyfomt gkv eh ych rkv kchki fm o|hudogfmb ych
tf`ot ycky uhtx`y luog dog~kuyghmyk`fzkyfom kmi thbghmykyfom- Fm ycft uhbkui, ych rco`h'ol'
bo|humghmy kmi rco`h'ol'todfhyv tyukyhbfht ehfmb kio~yhi ev togh Ktfkm doxmyufht fm
ihk`fmb rfyc yoikvt dck``hmbht txbbhtyt ycky domdhuyhi hllouyt kuh ehfmb xmihuykahm- Cor
ychth `obfdt dox`i thu|h kt k bxfih lou Ktfkm uhbfomk`ftg ft k ahv domtfihukyfom-
Lotyhu d`othu `fmat rfyc b`oek` fmtyfyxyfomt kmi lukghrouat
Ktfk dkm ykah ehyyhu ki|kmykbh ol b`oek` fmtyfyxyfomt kmi dom|hmyfomt- Ktfkm hdomogfht kuh
d`oth`v fmyhbukyhi rfyc ych uhty ol ych rou`i1 Ktfk ft ych ~kukifbgkyfd o~hm uhbfom- Lx``v
hs~`ofyfmb ych ~oyhmyfk` lou uhbfomk` hdomogfd fmyhbukyfom ychuhlouh uh{xfuht uhgo|fmb uhgkfmfmb
ekuufhut yo duott'eouihu dog~hyfyfom fm ych uhbfom fm rkvt ycky kuh dog~kyfe`h rfyc Ktfkt
hdomogfd `fmat rfyc oychu ~kuyt ol ych rou`i- Exf`ifmb om hsftyfmb b`oek` fmtyfyxyfomt kmi
dom|hmyfomt ft km oe|foxt rkv ol kdcfh|fmb ycft uhtx`y-
lukbghmyhi kmi fmdochuhmy uhbfomk` kudcfyhdyxuh ehmhlfyt KTHKM tfmdh ycky uhmihut ifllfdx`y kmv kyyhg~y ev kmv
gkjou ~orhu yo domyuo` kmi ihlfmh ych uhbfomk` ~uodhtt-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
26/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
59
2-5 Ehvomi Fmtyfyxyfomt @fbcymhtt
Htyke`ftc efmifmb kbuhhghmyt
K `fgfykyfom ckt yo io rfyc ych ihlkx`y if~`ogkyfd kmi thdxufyv goih` hg~`ovhi fm Ktfkm
uhbfomk`ftg- K if~`ogkyfd dom|hmyfom ycky gkaht lhr yo mo ihgkmit om ghgehutcf~
doggfyghmyt, ift~`kvt mo ~uhdfth kmi efmifmb oe`fbkyfomt, ~uf|f`hbht domthmtxt ukychu yckm
ihdftf|hmhtt kmi lk|out momfmyhulhuhmdh, iht~fyh fyt xthlx`mhtt fm ych hku`v ~cktht ol Ktfkm
uhbfomk`ftg, ft `fah`v yo eh fmtxllfdfhmy lou o|hudogfmb hghubfmb oetykd`ht yo ihh~hu fmyhbukyfom-
Htthmyfk``v, fy ~uhthu|ht ukychu yckm uh|ftht ych uhbfomk` tykyxt {xo- Lou txuh, fy ft xmuhk`ftyfd yo
kttxgh Ktfkm fmtyfyxyfomt kuh ~uh~kuhi yo gkah lxmikghmyk` dckmbht o|humfbcy- Exy ych
~o`fyfdk` doggfyghmy yo fmyuoixdh tyuxdyxuk` uhlougt ev rkv ol km h|o`xyfomkuv uokigk~ tcox`i
eh fmtyfyxyhikmi, fg~ouykmy`v, kichuhi yo-
Fg~uo|h uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt bo|humkmdh kmi hmiorghmyt
Ychth rox`i fmd`xih tyuhmbychmfmb fmtyfyxyfomt thduhykufkyt kmi duhkyfmb hllfdfhmy uhbfomk`
exuhkxdukdfht k`to ev ihifdkyfmb gouh cxgkm kmi lfmkmdfk` uhtoxudht, htyke`ftcfmb d`hkuhu
ghgehutcf~ ux`ht kmi kio~y gouh gkjoufyv |oyfmb, kmi ih`hbkyfmb gouh uht~omtfef`fyfht kmi
~orhut luog mkyfomk` kbhmdfht yo doggom uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt-
Gkfmykfm fmtyfyxyfomk` l`hsfef`fyv
K ahv ~kuy ol tyuhkg`fmfmb hsftyfmb uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt fm|o`|ht ych iftgkmy`fmb ol xm~uoixdyf|h
#ou fmihhi doxmyhu~uoixdyf|h& oubkmfzkyfomt kmi |kufoxt yv~ht ol buox~t- Togh o|hukudcfmb
fmtyfyxyfomt ck|h ehhm ihtdufehi kt `fyy`h gouh yckm yk`a tco~t- Ycky tkfi, ifk`obxh domyufexyht
yo ych exf`ifmb kmi txtykfmfmb ol mougkyf|h lukghrouat ycky ~`kv `hbfyfgkyfmb lxmdyfomt- Togh
lxmdyfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt ck|h k`to ehhm domtftyhmy`v fmhllhdyf|h fm ghhyfmb ychfu hdomogfd ykubhyt-
^o`fdvgkahut rf`` mhhi yo hshudfth jxifdfoxtmhtt fm ihdfifmb fl kmv kuukmbhghmy ihthu|ht yo
eh iftdkuihi- Ky ych tkgh yfgh, xmihu'~hulougfmb fmtyfyxyfomt dox`i thu|h yo ghhy ych uhbfomt
mhhit fm oychu rkvt- Fm km huk ol hdomogfd xmdhuykfmyv, tyukyhbfd kmi ykdyfdk` l`hsfef`fyv dox`i
~uo|h yo eh k |huv fg~ouykmy {xk`fyv, kmi rcky thhgt k `fkef`fyv yoikv dox`i ~uo|h yo eh km
ktthy yogouuor-
Ev ych tkgh yoahm, doxmyufht tcox`i domyfmxh yo ih|h`o~ fmtyfyxyfomt ihtfbmhi yo hs~`ofy
dog~h``fmb lxmdyfomk` o~~ouyxmfyfht- Txebuox~t ol Ktfkm doxmyufht tykmi yo uhk~
ift~uo~ouyfomkyh ehmhlfyt luog lxmdyfomk` fmfyfkyf|ht ycky kiiuhtt ychfu t~hdflfd mhhit- Ukychuyckm rkfyfmb lou ych hghubhmdh ol ~km'Ktfkm kbuhhghmyt, ychv dkm domyfmxh yo ~xtc kchki om
ychfu orm fm buox~t ol fmyhuhtyhi bo|humghmyt ou ky ych txeuhbfomk` `h|h`, ih|h`o~fmb
t~hdfk`fzhi fmtyfyxyfomk` kuukmbhghmyt dk~ke`h ol hs~`ofyfmb ychth dog~h``fmb o~~ouyxmfyfht-
Ycky tkfi, h|hm ky ych uhbfomk` `h|h`, ych duhkyfom ol lxmdyfomk` kuukmbhghmyt txdc kt ych
DGFG kmi ych KGUO ft k booi tfbm ycky ych uhbfom ft ~uh~kuhi yo go|h ycfmbt lourkui-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
27/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
58
2-4 Ehvomi H`fyh Uhbfomk`ftg
Hmdoxukbh kmi mxuyxuh ~kuyfdf~kyouv uhbfomk`ftg
Kmoychu `fgfykyfom ckt yo io rfyc ych h`fyftg fmchuhmy fm Ktfkt hsd`xtf|h`v fmyhubo|humghmyk`eukmi ol uhbfomk`ftg- Hxuo~hkm uhbfomk`ftg ft moy luhh ol h`fyfty ~uo~hmtfyfht hfychu1 fmihhi,
rchychu omh ykaht ych fmtyfyxyfomk` ou fmyhubo|humghmyk` tfih ol ych ihekyh om Hxuo~hkm
fmyhbukyfom, ych ~orhu ol Hxuo~ht fmyhumkyfomk` thduhykufkyt kt k ahv iuf|hu ol uhbfomk`
fmyhbukyfom ft gouh ou `htt kttxghi #^xdck`k ;666&-59
Ev kmi `kubh, Ktfk ckt ~uhd`xihi ych fmd`xtfom ol ~ufmdf~`ht ~f|oyk` yo Hxuo~hkm uhbfomk`ftg,
txdc kt txetfifkufyv, ~uo~ouyfomk`fyv, ~oo`hi to|huhfbmyv, iftyufexyfom ol dog~hyhmdht,
ih`hbkyfom ol ~orhut, kmi hmlukmdcfthghmy ol mom'tykyh kdyout- Dhuykfm`v, Ktfk gkv moy eh lx``v
uhkiv lou txdc ~ukdyfdht- Mou kuh k`` ychth mhdhttkuf`v k~~uo~ufkyh lou Ktfk- Vhy, KTHKM ckt
fmifdkyhi k rf``fmbmhtt yo fmduhghmyk` hg~orhughmy ol KTHD, rcf`h TKKUD ckt fmmo|kyhi k
`fgfyhi, vhy duhkyf|h ih`hbkyfom ol lxmdyfomk` ~orhut ev rkv ol fyt uhbfomk` dhmyhut- Ych
htyke`ftcghmy ol ych KGUO ft kmoychu fg~ouykmy ih|h`o~ghmy- Yo km hsyhmy, Ktfkm
bo|humghmyt ck|h toxbcy yo kddoggoikyh ych uhbfomt hgeuvomfd ~kuyfdf~kyouv uhbfomk`ftg,
kt ihgomtyukyhi ev ych hsftyhmdh ol ~kuk``h` txggfyt dog~uftfmb df|f` todfhyv oubkmfzkyfomt,
kmi ych ~uo`flhukyfom ol thgf'ollfdfk` ifk`obxht kmi louxgt #lou hskg~`h, ych Tckmbuf'@k
Ifk`obxh kmi oychu thdomi'yukda kdyf|fyfht&- Kubxke`v, ychth kddoggoikyfomt ck|h uhmihuhi
Ktfk'^kdflfd uhbfomk`ftg `htt hsd`xtf|h yckm ehlouh- Eh ycky kt fy gkv, uhbfomk`ftg'h`fyh ukychu
yckm uhbfomk`ftg'bk`fy uhgkfmt fyt iftyfmbxftcfmb lhkyxuh- H|hmyxk``v ycft fg~`fht gouh
kyyhmyfom yo fm|o`|fmb df|f` todfhyv fm ych bo|humkmdh ol uhbfomk` fmtyfyxyfomt-
59Kt Hvk` #5>;>: K5& ckt txbbhtyhi, ych uhk`fyv ft ycky, lou ych HX, exuhkxdukdv ft moy ych ghkmt yo km hmi1 fy ft
ych |huv htthmdh ol kdyf|fyv- Ych HX k`rkvt tyooi lou ych yufxg~c ol exuhkxdukdv o|hu cftyouv-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
28/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
5>3- Hghubfmb Ktfkm Uhbfomk`ftg- K ^kuymhutcf~ lou Tckuhi
^uot~hufyv- Gkmf`k: KIE-
KIE- 5>;>- Fmtyfyxyfomt lou Uhbfomk` Fmyhbukyfom- Yorkui km Ktfkm Hdomogfd Doggxmfyv-
Gkmf`k: KIE-
Kdckuvk, K- ;662- Fihkt, Fihmyfyv, kmi Fmtyfyxyfom Exf`ifmb: Luog ych KTHKM Rkv yo ych Ktfk'
^kdflfd Rkv- Ych ^kdflfd Uh|fhr;> #4&: 4;649>6- Ih|h`o~fmb Ktfkt Lfmkmdfk` Mougt kmi Tykmikuit- Ekdabuoxmi ^k~hu 4-
KIE Tyxiv Lfmk`fzkyfom Rouatco~ om Fmtyfyxyfomt lou Uhbfomk`ftg fm Ktfk kmi ych
^kdflfd- Tckmbckf- 54 Ihdhgehu-
Ek`irfm, U- 5>>3- Gkmkbfmb ych Mooi`h Eor`: Ych Lukbf`fyv ol Hkty Ktfkm Uhbfomk`ftg-Tfmbk~ouh Hdomogfd Uh|fhr84 #4&: 996923-
Ekxg, U-, hi- ;63>- Dcfmk"t Loxu Goihumfzkyfomt: Ych Mhr Yhdcmo`obfdk` Uh|o`xyfom- Eox`ihu,
Do, XT: Rhty|fhr-
Ehhtom, G- 5>>4- KTHKM ^`xt Ycuhh kmi ych Ufth ol Uhkdyfomkuv Uhbfomk`ftg- Domyhg~oukuv
Toxychkty Ktfk58 #5&: 58;5;;/>6/>2/9;>- Hdomogfd Fmyhbukyfom fm Hkty Ktfk kmi Hxuo~h- @httomt
luog k Dog~kukyf|h Kmk`vtft- Tfmbk~ouh Hdomogfd Uh|fhr88 #;&: ;>3- Fmyhumkyfomk` Hdomogfdt- Lflyc hifyfom- Mhr Ih`cf: Ykyk GdBukr'Cf``-
D`fmyom, C- 5>;>- D`fmyomt Uhgkuat om Uhbfomk` Kudcfyhdyxuh fm Ktfk- Doxmdf` om Louhfbm
Uh`kyfomt- Hkty Rhty Dhmyhu, Como`x`x, Ckrkff, XT- ;5 Jkmxkuv-
cyy~://rrr-dlu-oub/~xe`fdkyfom/5;5;3/d`fmyomt_uhgkuat_om_uhbfomk`_kudcfyhdyxuh_fm_ktf
k_jkmxkuv_5>;>-cyg`
Ihmy, D- G- 5>>3- Hkty Ktfkm Uhbfomk`ftg- Mhr Voua, XT: Uoxy`hibh-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
29/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
52
Ihtahu, E- 5>>3- Ft ych KTHKM Dckuyhu Mhdhttkuv? UTFT Dogghmykufht Mo-22/5>>3-
Tfmbk~ouh: T- Ukjkukymkg Tdcoo` ol Fmyhumkyfomk` Tyxifht- ;2 Jx`v-
cyy~://rrr-utft-hix-tb/~xe`fdkyfomt/^hut~hdyf|h/UTFT>225>>3-~il
Ih|f, Y- M-, hi- 5>>2- Fmifk kmi Ekv ol Ehmbk` doggxmfyv, ych EFGTYHD Hs~hufghmy:
Ekmb`kihtcFmifkGvkmgkuTuf @kmakYckf`kmi Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom- Mhr Ih`cf:Bvkm ^xe`ftchut-
Hgghut, U-, kmi T- T- Ykm- 5>;;- Ych KTHKM Uhbfomk` Louxg kmi ^uh|hmyf|h If~`ogkdv:
Exf`y yo Lkf`? Ktfkm Thdxufyv- 2 #;&: 99-
H|kmt, ^- 5>>8- Ehyrhhm Uhbfomk`ftg kmi Uhbfomk`fzkyfom: ^o`fdv Mhyrouat kmi ych Mktdhmy
Hkty Ktfkm Fmtyfyxyfomk` Fihmyfyv- Fm Y- J- ^hg~h`, hi- Uhgk~~fmb Hkty Ktfk: Ych
Domtyuxdyfom ol k Uhbfom- ;685;8- Fyckdk, XT: Doumh`` Xmf|hutfyv ^uhtt-
Hvk`, J- 5>;>- HX Louhfbm ^o`fdv k Ghtt- Ych Tyukfyt Yfght- 5> Th~yhgehu: K5-
Bkumkxy, U- ;66>6- Fmtyfyxyfomt lou Uhbfomk` Lfmkmdfk` Doo~hukyfom fm Ktfk:
Fg~`fdkyfomt lou Uhbfomk` Hdomogfd Doo~hukyfom- Ekdabuoxmi ^k~hu ;5- KIE Tyxiv
Lfmk`fzkyfom Rouatco~ om Fmtyfyxyfomt lou Uhbfomk`ftg fm Ktfk kmi ych ^kdflfd- Tckmbckf-
54 Ihdhgehu-
Bvmbh``, K- 5>>2- Ihtfbm Lkx`yt: Ych Ktfk ^kdflfdt Uhbfomk` Kudcfyhdyxuh- @orv Fmtyfyxyh ^o`fdv
Eufhl- Tvimhv: @orv Fmtyfyxyh lou Fmyhumkyfomk` ^o`fdv- ;3 Jx`v-
Ckkt, G- ;636- Ych Ktfkm Rkv yo ^hkdh: K Tyouv ol Uhbfomk` Doo~hukyfom- @omiom: ^ukhbhu-
Cxuuh``, K- ;668- Uhbfomk`ftg fm Ychouhyfdk` ^hut~hdyf|h- Fm: Uhbfomk`ftg fm Rou`i ^o`fyfdt:
Uhbfomk` Oubkmfzkyfom kmi Uhbfomk` Ouihu hifyhi ev@- Lkrdhyy kmi K- Cxuuh``- Osloui:
Osloui Xmf|hutfyv ^uhtt-
Fmyhumkyfomk` Fmtyfyxyh lou Tyukyhbfd Tyxifht #FFTT&- 5>>>>>2- Gkafmb ^uodhtt, Moy ^uobuhtt: KTHKM kmi ych
H|o`|fmb Hkty Ktfkm Uhbfomk` Ouihu- Fmyhumkyfomk` Thdxufyv45 #;&: ;93;39-
Akytxgkyk, C- 5>>6- KTHKM"t Doo~hukyf|h Thdxufyv Hmyhu~ufth: Mougt kmi Fmyhuhtyt fm ych
KTHKM Uhbfomk` Louxg- @omiom: ^k`buk|h GkdGf``km-
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
30/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
53
Akrkf, G- 5>>6- Uhloug ol ych Fmyhumkyfomk` Lfmkmdfk` Kudcfyhdyxuh: Km Ktfkm ^hut~hdyf|h-
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu ;>6- Ktfkm LYKt: Yuhmit kmi Dck``hmbht- KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu
;99- Yoavo: Ktfkm Ih|h`o~ghmy Ekma Fmtyfyxyh-
Ahockmh, U- O- ;639- Klyhu Chbhgomv: Doo~hukyfom kmi Iftdoui fm ych Rou`i ^o`fyfdk`
Hdomogv- ^ufmdhyom, XT: ^ufmdhyom Xmf|hutfyv ^uhtt-
Ahtk|k~kmv, A-, kmi C- @fg, hit- 5>>6- K^HD ky 5>: Uhdk``, Uhl`hdy, Uhgkah- Tfmbk~ouh:
Fmtyfyxyh ol Toxychkty Ktfkm Tyxifht-
Gf`rkui, K- T- 5>>>- Ych Hxuo~hkm Uhtdxh ol ych Mkyfom'Tykyh- Thdomi hifyfom- @omiom:
Uoxy`hibh-
Gouk|dtfa, K- ;663- Ych Dcofdh lou Hxuo~h: Todfk` ^xu~oth , Tykyh ^orhu luog Ghttfmk yo
Gkktyufdcy- Fyckdk, XT: Doumh`` Xmf|hutfyv ^uhtt-
Gouk|dtfa, K- 5>>>- Ih Bkx``h Ehyrhhm Bukfm kmi Bukmihxu: Ych ^o`fyfdk` Hdomogv ol Luhmdc
HD ^o`fdv, ;683;62>- Joxumk` ol Do`i Rku Tyxifht5 #5&: 494 kmi 5 #4&: 9;>- Jk~kmt Hku`v Go|ht om ych Hkty Ktfkm Doggxmfyv- Hkty Ktfk Louxg- 5;
Gkudc-
cyy~://rrr-hktyktfklouxg-oub/5>;>/>4/5;/jk~kmt'hku`v'go|ht'om'ych'hkty'ktfkm'doggxmfyv/
Uk|hmcf``, J- 5>>;- K^HD kmi ych Domtyuxdyfom ol ^kdflfd Ufg Uhbfomk`ftg- Dkgeufibh,
XA:
Uxbbfh, J- B- ;664- Gx`yf`kyhuk`ftg: Ych Kmkyogv ol km Fmtyfyxyfom- Fm J- B- Uxbbfh hi-
Gx`yf`kyhuk`ftg Gkyyhut: Ych Ychouv kmi ^uksft ol km Fmtyfyxyfomk` Loug- Mhr Voua:
Do`xgefk Xmf|hutfyv ^uhtt-
Dkgeufibh Xmf|hutfyv ^uhtt-
Th|hufmo, U- D- 5>>
-
7/31/2019 Institutions for Asian Integration: Innovation and Reform
31/31
KIEF Rouafmb ^k~hu 428 Dk~kmmh``f kmi Ykm
Tohtktyuo, C-, K- Bvmbh``, D- H- Gouuftom, kmi J- Rkmkmif- 5>>6- Uh~ouy ol Uhbfomk` Ykta
Loudh om Uhbfomk` Fmtyfyxyfomk` Kudcfyhdyxuh- ^uh~kuhi lou ych ^kdflfd Hdomogfd
Doo~hukyfom Doxmdf` Tykmifmb Doggfyyhh- Jxmh- Xm~xe`ftchi-
Tohvk, V- 5>;>- Km Hkty Ktfkm Doggxmfyv kmi Jk~kmDcfmk Uh`kyfomt- Hkty Ktfk Louxg- ;2
Gkv-
cyy~://rrr-hktyktfklouxg-oub/ykb/hkd/
Ykm, T- T-, hi- 5>>6- Do``keoukyfom xmihu Kmkudcv: Lxmdyfomk` Uhbfomk`ftg kmi ych Thdxufyv ol
Hkty Ktfk- UTFT Gomobuk~c ;8- Tfmbk~ouh: T- Ukjkukymkg Tdcoo` ol Fmyhumkyfomk`
Tyxifht-
Ykm, T- T- 5>;>k- KTHKM Uhbfomk` Louxg ky ;2: Ych Dxuth Ol Ki Cod'ftg? UTFT
Dogghmykufht 39/5>;>- 53 Jx`v-
Ykm, T- T- 5>;>e- Hkty Ktfk Txggfy 5>;>: Efb Tyh~ Lourkui, ou Extfmhtt'kt'xtxk`? UTFT
Dogghmykufht ;9;/5>;>- 9 Mo|hgehu-
cyy~://rrr-utft-hix-tb/~xe`fdkyfomt/^hut~hdyf|h/UTFT;9;5>;>-~il
Ykm, T- T- 5>;;- Ft Ktfk ^kdflfd Uhbfomk`ftg Oxybuorfmb KTHKM? UXTF Joxumk`;8< #;&: 83
>6- Yorkuit km Ktfk ^kdflfd Doggxmfyv- Ych Ktfk`fma Httkvt6 #Mo|hgehu&:
;9-
Voxmb, O- U- ;666- Bo|humkmdh fm Rou`i Kllkfut- Fyckdk, XT: Doumh`` Xmf|hutfyv ^uhtt-