indonesian journal accreditation

8/8/2019 Indonesian Journal Accreditation

1/31

Ferry I. Sadikin

([email protected] or [email protected]

)

Panitia Penilai Majalah Berkala Ilmiah

(P2MBI)


2/31

(1) Who are we?(1) Who are we?

(2) Where are we now?(2) Where are we now?

What have we done?What have we done?(3) Where are we going?(3) Where are we going?

How will we get there?How will we get there?

What support do weWhat support do weneed?need?


3/31

(1) WHO(1) WHOARE WE?ARE WE?

Panitia

Penilai

Majalah

Berkala

Ilmiah

P2P2

MBIMBI


4/31

P2MBI tasks and functions are stipulated in

Menpans Decree128/ KEP/ M.PAN/ 9/ 2004 concerningFunctional Researchers and Their Credit

Points Joint Decrees between LIPI Chairman3719/ D/ 2004 and BKN Chairman60/ 2004 concerning Guidelines for theImplementation of Functional

Researchers and Their Credit Points LIPI Chairmans Decree 01/ E/ 2005concerning Guidelines for ScientificJournal Accredition


5/31

Scientific Journala periodical publication intendedto disseminate and to further the

progress of science, usually by

reporting new research

Types of Articles

Letters

Research NotesArticlesSupplemental ArticlesReview Articles


6/31

Types of Articles expected

to be acrredited by P2MBI

Articles*

Usually 5 to 20 pages; Complete descriptions ofcurrent original research findings

Review ArticlesNot cover original research but rather accumulatethe results of many different articles* on aparticular topic into a coherent narrative aboutthe state of the art in that field

Panitia

Penilai

Majalah

BerkalaIlmiah

P2P2MBIMBI


7/31


8/31

Implementation of Journal Accreditation

2006: Journal accreditation processwas initiated

2006-2009: Transition phase

(development process to integrate hi-quality Indonesian scientific journals)

28 Aug 2009: 165 journals have beenaccredited

22 Oct 2009: ISJD (IndonesianScientific Journal Database) waslaunched


9/31

Evaluation Criteria

# CRITERIA Weight

1. Name of Journal 52. Publishers Institution 13

3. Board of Editors 124. Steadiness of Appearance 95. Writing Style 116. Substance (Scientific Content) 28

7. Periodical Aspects 108. Journal Distribution 59. Other Aspects 7

TOTAL 100


10/31

# INSTITUTION %

1 M in ist ry of Agricul tu reMinistry of Agriculture 2323 13.913.9

2 Indonesian Inst itute o f SciencesIndonesian Institute of Sciences 2323 13.913.9

3 M inistry of I ndustryMinistry of Industry 1111 6.76.7

4 Nat iona l Nuclear Energy AgencyNational Nuclear Energy Agency 1010 6.16.1

5 M inistry of ForestryMinistry of Forestry 1010 6.16.1

6 Minist ry of Energy and Minera l ResourcesMinistry of Energy and M ineral Resources 1010 6.16.1

7 Minist ry of Mar ine Af fa irs and Fisher iesMinistry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries 1010 6.16.1

8 Agency for Assessment and Application of TechnologyAgency for Assessment and Application of Technology 88 4.84.8

9 Minist ry of Communicat ions and InformaticsM inistry of Communications and Informatics 88 4.84.8

10 Ministry of Culture and Tour ismMinistry of Culture and Tourism 77 4.24.2

11 OthersOthers 4545 27.327.3

TOTAL 165 100.0

Accr edi ted J our nals (I nst i tu ti ons)Accr edi ted J our nals (I nst i tu ti ons)


11/31

Accredited Journals (Scientific Fields)

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Count 40 37 22 8 7 7 7 37

Agricult,

Vet Sc.,

Enviro

Engineer

and

Techno

Earth

Sciences

Political

Science

and Policy

Economics Humanity

Medical

Sc. and

Health

Other

24.2%

22.4%

13.3%

4.8% 4.2% 4.2% 4.2%

22.4%


12/31

Accredited Journals (Cities)

60

41

24

11 74

13

5

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

Jk t Bgr Bdg Tgr Yog M dn M k s Oth

36.4%

24.8%

14.5%

6.7%

4.2% 3.0% 2.4%

7.9%


13/31

Accredited Journals (Predicate)

8350.3%

2917.6%

5332.1%

B C

A


14/31

Accredited Journals (Language)

127.3%

15392.7%

Indonesian


15/31

Panitia

Penilai

MajalahBerkala

Ilmiah

P2P2MBIMBI

Panitia

Penilai

MajalahBerkala

Ilmiah

P2P2MBIMBI

Panitia

Penilai

MajalahBerkala

Ilmiah

P2P2MBIMBI

Panitia

Penilai

MajalahBerkala

Ilmiah

P2P2MBIMBI

(3) Where are we going?(3) Where are we going?

How w ill we get there?How w ill we get there?

What support do we need?What support do we need?


16/31

Continously improve the evaluation instrumentUrge editorial boards of accredited journals tobe more concerned with substances (scientificcontents) w ithout ignoring the importance ofboth journal management and appearance

Drive accredited journals to be more focused onspecific fields

Encourage the publication of on-line journals

Recommend hi-quality journals to be publishedin two versions (Indo & Eng)

Build and maintain ISJD (Indonesian Scientific

Journal Data Base) at www.jurnal.pdii.lipi.go.idEncourage journals to be registered atinternational index centers

(GO INTERNATIONAL)

Future Expectations:

Integrate

efforts

with

journals

editors

Build andlink

websites


17/31

OwnerOwner

ReaderReader

PeerPeerReviewerReviewer

AuthorAuthor

Editor

PromotingPromoting

IntegrityIntegrity

in Scientificin Scientific

JournalJournal

PublicationsPublications


18/31

Editor responsibili ties to authors (1)

Prov iding guidelines for preparing andsubmitting manuscripts.

Establishing and enforcing authorship criteria. Treating all authors with fairness, courtesy,

objectivity, and honesty.

Establishing and defining policies on conflicts ofinterest. Protecting the confidentiality of every authors work. Establishing a system for effective and rapid peer

review. Making editorial decisions w ith reasonable

speed and, when the manuscript is potentiallyappropriate for the journal, w ith input frompeer reviewers who have adequate expertiseto judge the manuscript, and communicatingthese decisions to authors in a constructiveand helpful manner.


19/31

Editor responsibili ties to authors (2)

Establishing clear guidelines for authors regardingacceptable practices for sharing information before andafter publication.

Establishing a procedure for reconsidering editorialdecisions.

Describing, implementing, and regularlyreview ing policies for handling ethical issuesand allegations or findings of misconduct byauthors.

Informing authors of solicited manuscriptsthat the submission w ill be evaluatedaccording to the journals usual procedures oroutlining the decision-mak ing process if it

differs from those procedures. Developing mechanisms to ensure timely publication ofaccepted manuscripts.

Clearly communicating all other editorial policies andstandards.


20/31

Editor responsibilities to reviewers (1)

Assigning papers for review appropriate to thereviewers areas of interest and expertise.

Establishing a process for reviewers to ensure thatthey treat the manuscript as a confidentialdocument and complete the review promptly.

Informing reviewers that they are not allowed tomake any use of the work described in themanuscript or take advantage of the knowledge theygained by reviewing it until it is published.

Providing reviewers w ith w ritten, explicitinstructions on the journals expectations for thescope, content, quality, and timeliness of theirreviews to promote thoughtful, fair, constructive,and informative critique of the submitted w ork.


21/31

Editor responsibilities to reviewers (2)

Requesting that reviewers identify any potentialconflicts of interest and asking that they recusethemselves if they cannot provide an unbiasedreview.

Allowing reviewers appropriate time to complete their

reviews. Requesting reviews at a frequency that does not

overtax any one reviewer.

Finding ways to recognize the contribution ofreviewers, for example by publicly thank ing

them in the journal, providing letters thatmight be used in applications for academicpromotion, offering professional educationcredits, or inviting them to serve on theeditorial board of the journal.


22/31

Editor responsibilities to readers (1)

Evaluating all manuscripts considered forpublication to make certain that eachmanuscript provides the evidence readersneed to evaluate the authors conclusions and

that authors conclusions reflect the evidenceprovided in the manuscript.

Prov iding literature references and authorcontact information so that interested readers

may pursue further discourse. Identifying individual and group authorship clearly

and developing processes to ensure that authorshipcriteria are met to the editors knowledge.


23/31


Requiring all authors to review and acceptresponsibility for the content of the final draftof each paper or for those areas to which theyhave contributed; this may involve signaturesof all authors or of only the correspondingauthor on behalf of all authors.

Maintaining the journals internal integrity(e.g., correcting errors; clearly identifying anddifferentiating types of content such as reports oforiginal data, opinion pieces such as editorials, lettersto the editor, corrections/errata, retractions,

supplemental data, and promotional material oradvertising; identifying published material withproper references).

Disclosing sources (e.g., authorship, journalownership, funding).


24/31


Creating mechanisms to determine whether thejournal is providing what readers need and want(e.g., reader surveys).

Disclosing all relevant potential conflicts of interest ofthose involved in considering a manuscript oraffirming that none exist.

Providing a mechanism for a further discussion onthe scientific merits of a paper, such as by publishingletters to the editor, inviting commentaries, orsoliciting other forms of public discourse.

Explicitly stating journal policies regardingethics, embargo, submission and publicationfees, and accessibility of content (w hat isfreely available vs what is under a subscriptionmodel).


25/31

Editor responsibilities to journal owners

Conducting peer review of submittedmanuscripts and complying w ith theguidelines and procedures of the ownerorganization, including any terms specified

in the contract w ith that organization. Making recommendations about improved

evaluation and dissemination of scientificmaterial.

Operating the journal in a fiscallyresponsible manner.

Adhering to the agreed-on mission, publicationpractices, and schedule.


26/31

Editorial FreedomEditorial FreedomTo establish and maintain highTo establish and maintain high--quality journalquality journal

content (regardless of the scientific field), priorcontent (regardless of the scientific field), prior

to accepting a position, editors should:to accepting a position, editors should:

nn receive an explicit, written statementreceive an explicit, written statementfrom the journals owner that definesfrom the journals owner that defines

the editors responsibilities andthe editors responsibilities and

autonomy.autonomy.

nn be given full responsibility for editorialbe given full responsibility for editorial

decisions on individual manuscripts.decisions on individual manuscripts.


27/31

ISJDISJD(Indonesian Scientific Journal Database)(Indonesian Scientific Journal Database)

www.jurnal.pdii.lipi.go.idwww.jurnal.pdii.lipi.go.id


28/31

ET

K

A

S I

H

A

MI

R

THANX

Panitia

Penilai

Majalah

Berkala

Ilmiah

P2P2MBIMBI

www.jurnal.pdii.lipi.go.id


29/31

Journals of Medical Science and Health

# Name of Journal Publisher Pred.

1Buletin PenelitianSistem Kesehatan

R&D Center for Health System andPolicy, Ministry of Health

A

2

Media Penelitian danPengembangan

Kesehatan

Research & Development Agency forHealth, Ministry of Health

B

3Buletin PenelitianKesehatan

Research & Development Agency forHealth, Ministry of Health

B

4Indonesian Journal ofCancer

Dharmais Cancer Hospital, NationalCancer Center

B

5

Penelitian Gizi dan

Makanan

R&D Center for Nutrition and Food,

Min istry of Health B

6 Gizi IndonesiaAssociation of IndonesianNutritionists (PERSAGI )

B

7Jurnal EkologiKesehatan

R&D Center for Ecology and HealthStatus, Ministry of Health

C


30/31

Jurnal Hortikultura (J. Hort.) memuat artikel primer yang bersumber langsungpada hasil penelitian hortikultura yang belum pernah dipublikasikan. Jurnal

Hortikultura terbit empat nomor dalam setahun

Vol. 18 No. 2 ISSN 0853-7097 Juni 2008Terakreditasi dengan Predikat B Nomor: 050/ Akred-LIPI/ P2MBI/ 03/2008

Jurnal Hor t i k u l tur a(Jo ur n a l o f H or t i c ul t u r e)

Alamat (Address)Pusat Penelitian dan Pengemba ngan Hortikultura, Departemen Pertanian RI

Jl. Raya Ragunan 29 A, Pasar Minggu, Jakarta 11540Telp. (021) 7805768, 7890990, Faks. (021) 7805135

Email: [email protected], [email protected]: www.hortikultura.litbang.deptan.go.id

Penanggung jawabOfficially incharge

Kepala Pusat Penelitian dan Pengembangan Hortikultura(Director of R&D Center for Horticulture)

Dewan RedaksiEditorial board

Ir. Sabari, M.S. (Pascapanen/Postharvest)Prof. Dr. Ati Srie Duriat (Virologi/Virology)Dr. Witono Adiyoga, M.S. (Sosial Ekonomi/social economics)

Prof. Dr. Ir. Aziz Azirin Asandhi (Agronomi/Agronomy)Dr. Ir. Aan A. Daradjat, M.S. (Pemuliaan/Breeding)Dr. Budi Marwoto (Pemuliaan/Breeding)

Mitra BestariPeer Review er

Dr. Bambang SunarkoProf. Dr. Bamban g Subiyanto , M.Agr.Sc.Dr. Ir. Endang Tri Margaw ati, M.Agr.Sc.Dr. Gono SemiadiDr. Ir. M. Ahkam S ubroto, M.Appl.Sc.Prof. Dr. Ir. Roedhy Poerw anto, M.Sc.Prof. Dr. Subandriyo

Redaksi pelaksanaManaging editor Ria Riati Rahati, Sri Ita Bangun, Ofi Luthfiyah, Suarti Soetadi, M.Adnan Yasin, Sartono

Isi Jurnal Hortikultura dapat dikutip dengan menyebutkan sumbernya(Citation is permitted with acknowledgement of the source)


31/31

Berita Biologi is highly grateful to the following

Peer Reviewers (Referees) in this edition

Dr. Didik Widyatmoko

(Indonesian Institute of Sciences)

Prof. Dr. Bambang Satyo Purwoko

(Bogor Institute of Agriculture)

Prof. Dr. Adek Zamrud Adnan

(Andalas University)

Prof. Dr. Chair Rani

(Hasanuddin University)

Dr. Nyoto Santoso

(Assessment and Development Center for Mangrove)

Dr. Deasy Natalia(Bandung Institute of Technology)

Dr. Ocky Karna Radjasa

(University of Diponegoro)

Berita Biologi 9 (2) August 2008

indonesian journal accreditation

Documents