in the supreme court of victoria at melbourne …

12
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE COMMON LAW DIVISION No of2010 IN THE MATTER of an application pursuant tci section 84 of the Property Law Act 1958 for the discharge of a restrictive covenant. THE APPLICATION of: MAUREEN CARMEL PROWSE Plaintiff AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT Date of document: Filed on behalf of: Prepared by: Lukaitis Partners Solicitors and Notary 123 Church Street HAWTHORN VIC 3122 Deponent: Sworn: 12 March 2010 The Plaintiff Michelle Cupples 12 March 2010 Solicitors Code: 9344 Telephone: (03) 9819 5515 Fax: (03) 9819 6078 Ref: JLL:MC:096185 I, MICHELLE CUPPLES of 123 Church Street Hawthorn in the State of Victoria, solicitor, MAKE 0 ATH AND SAY as follows: •\ 1 I am an employee solicitor in the finn ofLukaitis Partners Solicitors and Notary. I have the care, conduct and management of this proceeding for and on behalf of the Plaintiff. I am duly authorized by the Plaintiff to make this affidavit on her behalf and do so from my own personal knowledge, save where otherwise stated. 2 In or about October 2009 I was retained by the Plaintiff to make this application on her behalf relating to the property situated at and known as 191 - 193 1

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jan-2022

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

No of2010

IN THE MATTER of an application pursuant tci section 84 of the Property Law Act

1958 for the discharge of a restrictive covenant.

THE APPLICATION of:

MAUREEN CARMEL PROWSE Plaintiff

AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT

Date of document: Filed on behalf of: Prepared by: Lukaitis Partners Solicitors and Notary 123 Church Street HAWTHORN VIC 3122

Deponent:

Sworn:

12 March 2010 The Plaintiff

Michelle Cupples

12 March 2010

Solicitors Code: 9344 Telephone: (03) 9819 5515 Fax: (03) 9819 6078 Ref: JLL:MC:096185

I, MICHELLE CUPPLES of 123 Church Street Hawthorn in the State of Victoria,

solicitor, MAKE 0 ATH AND SAY as follows: •\

1 I am an employee solicitor in the finn ofLukaitis Partners Solicitors and Notary.

I have the care, conduct and management of this proceeding for and on behalf of

the Plaintiff. I am duly authorized by the Plaintiff to make this affidavit on her

behalf and do so from my own personal knowledge, save where otherwise stated.

2 In or about October 2009 I was retained by the Plaintiff to make this application

on her behalf relating to the property situated at and known as 191 - 193

1

Page 2: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

Wattletree Road Malvem, being the land descdbed in Cetiificate of Title

Volume 3607 Folio 399 ("the propetiy''). The Melway Map reference for the

property is page 59 grid reference D9.

3 I caused searches to be made by agents of Lukaitis Partners Solicitors and

Notmy of the records and dealings in Land Registry Victoria and the Probate

Office of the Supreme Comi of Victoria and depose to what is stated in this

affidavit from information obtained by me from such searches, all of which

information I believe to be true and correct.

4 The Plaintiff is the sole registered proprietor of the property. Now produced and

shown to me and marked "MC-1" is Land Registry Victoria's Register Search

Statement of the title to the propetiy.

5 An instrmnent of Transfer in respect of the property dated 11 May 1912 was

registered in Land Registry Victoda on 14 May 1912 and numbered 683810

("the transfer"). Now produced and shown to me and mm·ked "MC-2" is a hue

copy of the transfer.

6 The transfer included a restrictive covenant ("the covenant"). The covenant is

recorded as an encumbrance on the Certificate of Title to the property.

7 Under the terms of the covenant the transferee of the property covenanted for

himself and his successors in title with the transferors of the property and their

successors in title for the benefit of the transfero.rs successors in title and the ' registered proprietors for the time being of the untransferred part of the land in

Cetiificate of Title Volume 3442 Folio 352 ("the parent title"). Now produced

and shown to me and marked "MC-3" is a tme copy of the parent title.

8 The land in the parent title was subdivided into 63 lots by plan of subdivision

LP5320 ("the plan of subdivision"). Now produced and shown to me and

marked "MC-4" is a hue copy of the plan of subdivision.

9 The property comprises lots 7 and 8 on the plan of subdivision.

2

Page 3: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

10 My examination of the parent title discloses that at the time of registration of the

transfer and the issue of the Certificate of Title for the propetty on 14 May 1912

there were 39 lots then remaining untransferred in the parent title and which are

therefore entitled to the benetit of the covenant. They are set out in the table

below:

Transfer No. Date and Time Lot Number(s)

689278 10 July 1912 at 1.50pm 46

692264 10 August 1912 at 10.35am 31

683694 10 August 1912 at 10.35am 54

692263 10 August 1912 at 10.35am 51

694020 4 September 1912 at 2.32 pm 26

694722 9 September 1912 at 3.18pm 58

676748 15 May 1912 at 3.45 pm 13 & 14

730961 20 November 1913 at 2.48pm 16

731001 9 January 1914 at 10.33am 47 &48

731786 19 January 1914 at 11.35am 55

732121 3 December 1913 at 3.4 pm 56&57

735629 20 January 1914 at 2.34 pm 24

731965 2 December 1913 at 3.30pm 40

712362 25 Apri11913 at 3.2 pm 39

720331 29 July 1913 at 10.56am 17

721299 7 August 1913 at 3.18pm 49

721352 12 August 1913 12.3 pm 30

729703 8 November 1913 at 11.30am 44

765602 10 December 1914 at 3.26pm 19

772953 17 Apri\1915 at 10.32am 41 (recorded as 772853 on Plan of Subdivision 5320 see page 3)

774671 12 May 1915 at 12.34pm 42

775485 21 May 1915 at 2.16pm 43

3

Page 4: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

778538 24 June 1915 at 2.23pm Part of Lot 59

780847 10 July 1915 at 10.35am 52

736945 4 Febmary 1914 at 2.58pm 27

738586 23 Febmary 1914 at 2.24pm 12

748821 13 June 1914 at 10.16am 10

750144 13 June 1914 at 10.16am 25

749242 4 June 1914 at 3.llpm 11

765214 4 December 1914 at 2.48pm 15

796703 9 March 1916 at 11.00am 53

826129 18 May 1917 (time unknown) Part of Lot 59

834859 10 September 1917 (time unknown) 34

835439 17 September 1917 (time unknown) 33

2146543 Arthur Charles Langmore became the 23,36 & 37 surviving proprietor of the untransferred lots on 9 Apri11921 (time unknown)

11 According to the title searches carried out by the title searcher engaged by me, it

appears that all 63 lots have been transferred out of the parent title, but some

land stilt remains in the parent title. This consists of (a) the roads shown on the

plan of subdivision, and (b) one small triangular piece of land labeled R1

adjacent to the top left hand side of Lot 35 on the plan of subdivision. I am

informed by the title searcher engaged by me and believe that this small

triangular piece ofland is under the control of the local council.

12 For the assistance of this Honourable Court I have coloured a copy of the plan of

subdivision to show the lots having the benefit of the covenant. Now produced

and shown to me and marked "MC-5" is the coloured copy of the plan of

subdivision to which I refer. On the plan of subdivision, the subject lots of the

application are coloured red. The lots coloured green were transferred out of the

parent title before the subject lots. The lots coloured yellow were transferred out

of the parent title after the subject lots.

4

Page 5: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

13 "The Age" is a daily newspaper circulating generally in the area of the propetty

and "The Stonnington Leader" is a weekly newspaper circulating in the Malvern

area.

SWORN by MICHELLE CUPPLES

at Hawthorn in the State of Victoria

this 12 day ofMarch 2010

) ) ) )

~~c-L_ Before me ....................................................... .

JOSEPH LEO LUKAITIS NOTARY PUBLIC

123 Church Street, Hawthorn Victoria Australia

5

Page 6: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

No of2010

IN THE MATTER of an application pursuant to section 84 of the Property Lmv Act

1958 for the discharge of a restrictive covenant.

THE APPLICATION of:

MAUREEN CARMEL PROWSE Plaintiff

CERTIFICATE IDENTIFYING EXHIBIT

Date of document: 12 March 2010

Filed on behalf of: The Plaintiff

Prepared by:

Lulmitis Partners

Solicitors and Notmy

123 Church Street

HAWTHORN VIC 3122

Solicitor's Code: 9344

DX: Not Applicable

Tel: (03) 9819 5515

Fax: (03) 9819 6078

Ref: JLL:MC:096185

This is the exhibit marked "MC-1" now produced and shown to MICHELLE CUPPLES at the time of swearing her affidavit on \ '2.. ~ W') ~ )...0 1",

~h..~~ Signature of person tal.<ing affidavit

JOSEPH LEO LUKAITIS NOTARY PUBLIC

123 Church Street, Hawthorn Victoria Australia

MC-1

Register Search Statement

6

Page 7: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

VIC L TO AL TS Title Search

Copyright State of Victoria. This publication is copyright. No part may be reproduced by any process except in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright Act or pursuant to a written agreement. The information is only valid at the time and in the form obtained from the LANDATA REGD Trot System. The State of Victoria accepts no responsibility ~or any subsequent release, publication or reproduction of the information.

REGISTER SEARCH STATEMENT (Title Search) Transfer of Land Act 1958

Title: 3607 399

VOLUME 03607 FOLIO 399 Security no : 12403137482SH Produced 06/10/2009 03,29 pm

LAND DESCRIPTioN

Lots 7 and 8 on Plan of Subdivision 005320. PARENT TITLE Volume 03442 Folio 352 Created by instrument 0683810 14/05/1912

REGISTERED PROPRIETOR

Estate Fee Simple Sole Proprietor

MAUREEN CARMEL PROWSE of 191 WATTLETREE RD MALVERN 3144 W212787Q 10/08/1999

ENCUMBRANCES 1 CAVEATS AND NOTICES

MORTGAGE AF862697F 23/05/2008 !SOBEL BELL ALLAN DAVID BULLER ALLAN DIBBLES·NOMINEES PTY LTD PICCHI BROTHERS FOUNDATION INC VARIATION OF MORTGAGE AG547903F 05/06/2009

COVENANT 0683810

Any encumbrances created by Section 98 Transfer of Land Act 1958 or Section 24 Subdivision Act 1988 and any other encumbrances shown or entered on the plan or imaged folio set out under DIAGRAM LOCATION below.

DIAGRAM LOCATION

SEE LP005320 FOR FURTHER DETAILS AND BOUNDARIES

ACTIVITY IN THE LAST 125 DAYS

NUMBER AG547903F

DOCUMENT END

VARIATION OF MORTGAGE

Printed by Espreon 06/10/2009 15:29 PM AEST

STATUS Registered

DATE 05/06/2009

For: JEL Ref: PROWSE COVEN Page 1/1

Page 8: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

No of2010

IN THE MATTER of an application pursuant to section 84 of the Property Law Act

1958 for the discharge of a restrictive covenant.

THE APPLICATION of:

MAUREEN CARMEL PROWSE Plaintiff

CERTIFICATE IDENTIFYING EXHIBIT

Date of document: 12 March 2010

Filed on behalf of: The Plaintiff

Prepared by:

Lulmitis Partners

Solicitors and Notmy

123 Church Street

HAWTHORN VIC 3122

Solicitor's Code: 9344

DX: Not Applicable

Tel: (03) 9819 5515

Fax: (03) 9819 6078

Ref: JLL:MC:096185

This is the exhibit marked "MC-2" now produced and shown to MICHELLE CUPPLES at the time of swearing her affidavit on 12-'"VVI~ J...j)to,

Signature of person taking affidavit

JOSEPH LEO LUKAITIS NOTARY PUBLIC

1 23 Church Street, Hawthorn Victoria Australia MC-2

Transfer No. 683810

7

Page 9: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

......... _-..,_,

··~ ··lit~:~~:l·i<)hD: .-~·-··""""·'' r .u," -. .. - '·""."-" .....

,,

i"both' ·of ·wnttlEJ 'l';,iJt:f .. t,iQ.~ .Mf\).~i.n:•i:t. ~·1ng 1:-agi~ te-r(f!i, .a a· ~Oint ; . . . . . . . ~ .

i\i>>'_ojir_~~tor" or. '"' o·s bate· :Ui·i~~-- id"JliS ·in -th~ lnfl'+ Uopi;>-in,ar~ec _

1

,

~d~acrlt.ed subJoet to :tna ~~~~):li'an~e.;;,Jbit'i;e(l :~ar;~unie"' in oonoido ~ . . .

.J::·

, ;HA~ELT!:f01lll <Jf OpoilU Qi'<~aiont: ~n\v9t>n '\erri~or, of line J;ogiol<itho · ·".

r.;{';j'"; Collnoil 4nd ,in oons'l.Q.Ar,.tion o~ tho a\lln of $•von nundrsct ~nd twi>ntr

\'1t i Polll'Xlo prdrl to £1,i, , s<l'id ,BY-ecl•M.~k fh<<;~:iv;orn by i~i:~;l;1ML D[J'M'"'\·r·"~"-P'r f i ur P"rk Hmm~ k~l~"fb ~':..Ji-<_;;j. oo HEimst TRAl'iS1!7.R t.o t;Uo

; t "h ot_· .'l!wO ·h~.ed·.a.P .. d, ·:e~t.¥ .ppmxl __ . ~ p.!i._;J,.d t.~:·ufl:· hy _ll!U?PJ.~Rrct-: 'To· ·\- .. 1;) otw.. . . . .

;· .·. . ; ... : ' ~~WlLiirori O).lrl.)~_·-!-.an1:f:e, i\t; -~~-!) triqu~ofi ~<1. by· ~;L.t'~o-tion pr t~ht"t an.~li: lFr~<>~I<;~ ~ajie;l thoi?it, tqni;tfiqd b~ h~<';o.fgn~t,!X'<l h~reto . All- ot)x. ~s tP,toi, t' . . . . .. • . . ·.·. . ' ·.·.. . ....... · J,;j,,~!'~~') ·, .. ~~~_tntee>~a~ '~--~!·£, til~:<r· P,i~o~ ;~r i.Mc! ?-·~~~"'~"a:<~'Jd;~?~i?.\'!')t\ ;•~ .·.~'-''"''·'·'·"'""" jblue .1:>:n 'tbo plan \lr&mi· hi>~•oo)l".)ie'ing L<it0 sevon and eigljt on. I' lap ot:. · 1

• ~ . ;·;,',·i !s<ir,ct'ir.iisio>i.ilo, s;::~~ '!;Qi!g~(l, in:~$9l't'!-~• 9f ~itloa _ .. IJ.t0: iain~ ~;.;:~·oi'l "'l :.,- ,,., ( ., ]Jro,;; Fortion !•;ii,~~;J,Yir~e. at "Gi<i'Mh~ P.trl.\lb, of' i>r..h~~n Qo,;l:lt:i of, ;i

~ \'~:,\''. ;;Uo\~,(,; uni! )\sing !ian of pie iand plirt~~pltirll< !l~~l>flb~d in. i: t '' Jc;ertAf,~<>~to or TiUe mit~;_;;,.,t'in\b~ R~~i~~~ Bo~~ Vqlu,;, ;£,..;:,Folio li. l "~"'±:·/.~ ~~883oii_~f,'Itf~ to the ~<ilii Jan~ Lanl9;:9;.~ ·~. _'\~thu~ dh.ulos . '

••

7

fi">- 1. jLan!l'i,;,.e -ol' the t'efiio_te,-oo "i>r'qp~tet6i· OP ~~o?~:t.~to.r.i f:o~ the t:L)¥~ ,.• 1 \ /i._./,,,...._,,~ .. ,.; < ." '. ' " " " "" ", ",, " " " " " "" " . " ; " f "

;;;~,.,.£"""'-64, ;,b•l:ng or t.ot l!th~t~o" ;;, :oo;id':Pta:n i>r slip;-~"ii>.l¢~ ~~::ig~t.~L~':•i.'.',~e;~j·

.{·' .. : i .

' ' . \ . '

• _

1 /~ .• ('t,{. ~.·.)::• rs,Qeo~ary. ilfpli;ne,a. ~:~ ~~~:-.:~R~·.~_;t. ;·:;~·Qn;··.:, :~·~.: .. ~. i _rl _t:~{rb. ugh <JY~>~ anJ nl~~· . t.ho l , ·. . 1· .. · f);: ".'li:l l".nii _<><>:tor!iol blue i'ol' We t>tJi'J:Joao 9f :Oo(!~t'duotJ.hg ehln~J>~ !!.. or•) · ·

. :j} ~."':P '>~•;:nll<b>ing t\ dr•~il, up?n 't~Q 1\•ii;lJ:n·~j,,??lQ':e<i: J?i:u~ _ w_ioh ful)), d i \ ' ' ::'ira:. right: t,md i)\ .• ,~y or in;#,~~if ~it.~~· ~'n<l t~e\:ee~, t>l .tJy.onil) ove~;> l ": ·; :;·,,··'i"i<

along the.~ai.d lnY;{oO.J,c>r&<J; ii~ue·_:r:or· t,1i~ p\ii;Fo.;;; ~t'qr.;~,;t,('"or-"t-<n: t · . . .. ·.:. ·.' .. · . ·. ·.·.-: ·.\··.':· ·; ,• .. ·.:· · .. ·. ·~· .. - :.; .. . ·.:.-:_.·· . . : ~·=··~·':: ,,~n<' "·j>lll?lo••t> or .. ln~]~C-~:!:~ir ·.t>avri·h~_\bg.·.·.!.ll."t9ri_llg· 0).' Q.1er.m~tnB =.the .. a~Jp. .,, I ', . ' -c:.·.

. . .. . . . . ' . . . . .. . .... . ~ ., .. ·,:,_:

,·, ....• ,,;;,•.

Page 10: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

.. ,,." . .:· .. . \ ...

~ ... ~ il

~ . , jl

' ;; ~

;! '

~-·: \ j ,.

1 ~ 6 ' l! l 1

. ~ t;

' 'f -~

:i ~

;,.

~~ ;: il ~

.;

'

16:26 20f4

_. .· ·-' · .. ''-":····;f. ···. -~,

:~·

fJ?3·rJ(o ..... ,, ........... : (. ·•.•

~ 1-_J:s.ln nn:l t'Qr- .al;L o·l~ .iU1Y.. 9~' t;q_o:i,:_piuw.<>.a~·a · ~'t'"o:r:·enuid to break up

·:,·+_ei;~n·.·;at.i) rtn·d. !'~tO:(e. a.ii rw any :~urt o:t t.tlo. !J~rl'ace ol' t.h!l l.·Hiid .land~ c· ·.·~·.·. _. . -.... ,. ·: lp,olOr"l<l i1lUfJ A N. f) thf} flt:\id -Wii.J.if,Ull", Durhum Ls13l i~ cloth hat'oby

\i for h"lrr:selt hio ~"~XfO.Utors a.r..d · a:dt~iljio.t.r':\.ial-~L o~v.onn.nt with· tn.a atd~~ :: . ',.. :;''"·"' . . . . . ·. ·:··. . • . .... .-.',>:of!·<'

.. ;. ;.'/::.:.~:- t.:~~e ~~flfUore . .- _.~).r }~-~~~- 9~r.1 ~a· }~.u~9:c-e -~~i.~k-·q•r;gA-l·th<t~~---~~-;~--··· .. :t ~. · ·.· ·f~f~:.·.?e~~';~;:t}··~~;x·t~w ....... _. ... ,_,-.-(_ f..~-::"sA•!'-r.r:lw..7vfJ·~-, ... ~fi:.-r::ft;t:~-/·'j· r-"'$._, .. . / ~ -!•n' ....... , ..••• ~:- ·\::;-•.•

·'..-·:F· . i-. ·t~\o:-·r·.·· ;;;i'!!•A t fii•;,....: 'dlfd .w:i_.t!i'i.llf13 ~L'·a t,~!''1~ thfJ:'O,~. ,n~--~.{t~!-'1·-"· oa~fl ¥+ 1~ ~.a.»! .. b~_~iiQ ~T..i7UI':tu· h'tJ· :&xflo)li6l~s riJrlt:th·i:~t~fil.hf'il ··or. ·tr.'i~:at~rr-e: .. ls wtu 0 ·0 t f.\t. -fiX!y

--. ' :time or 1 imea he~Jt;~n.t'~f3l' qut~.rr-y on the said laUd or o6r-t or oa·z.r•)-l. -- · 4 . ' '!;-a_~tty ~y Oj.:.i:me S:t'a.va~ .. so;u or na.nd_<_:t!lil:f:~~·:rro~. o:f·:_zo'.~_e ~l1Y i:l'?O~V~t;lQnq:

-'ih&r!Ji:r~ e~oe~ ~ Such na ·.~:~-- bf.l n1~c~a;a;y tc0--t" laYing thp r(Jun~~:tifbh-·- 1 -R . - .- . . -- . .. . .

f br· roly bl!il..d} .. u$ on:- -tth~_ ·.a~td ').ntid l}lf.D- F~ftl;U:~m ·,t;hat- he o~ ·iiia¥ .-W-1.1~ .1 .[not e_~'f'Jct lliore tha.Q .. one· h¢~9~ ··on· eaCh ~1: t_he· enid Lois ru;ld t.Mt~: any ~ g . __ -. . . . .. - . ' .. . ·Lho4se oo ere.q-t:ed .shall bn ot· ot.one Ot' biiok or .brick ancl at._Ot'lf.l 'lfith ~ ;: . ·; ro.oi· o.r ul8.-t;.es :'?t' tilB_Q; ou_ ~.ho 'ala.;l.n _por-tion· thet~lci"6J· nt ::t cQ(d:. pf

,. t ·• ··1~... ·~t ~:un-1 r>er' nr.",...t~~ ·o.,.ch .,.x61-Uai\.•e .'Or ·at,abll3-.:'$ ..:....,.d~ :! n.o ; ... ':)G~ r. u•n ::>-'-:!.. .._, ~>..\ t ¥"".,..__.,_,._. ... 'J ......._.

:, .

~j ou.t.bit1Lti:qgs tmct. :~-ha.·t,_ -.1Ju4h o.uii.~~ti~. ·ar~~ll-:-~'=?·t L~ uaofl.fo(:~ni: trade L f;· ~~ ~1u~inano AJ<h Ptifi;f~ER .. t~t.·--thf:t:'··~t~1-~.: Wll,ilP.rti Dur~~ .~eali~: ~ia '~ ,)· e:iec).lt-Qhi ~dm.i:-d:.~t:PiVtora, -~:(._: t'r~~~·f-~V:rfj~~· ~i;;l.~~-6-t. :iubdtyJ.il'i!. ~.i·t~~~ ! . i1.o:r. t-~w ztd_d: L?~.$ ,1-nto_.nmal·;.t,f~r. ~-~,~o,~m~n.t.o._ ~~-~ ~cfduo~ t.!1e i'Mnt-agti

_.r~~e~~ot t.f} a· illt!\l!e:r :~l,·O~tag_e thr.m ·wP~ar'a bt1 t~~a-· s~J,d F:l~ .. 0 f. ~:. -l~ Sf.ibd.iv.i'alD.s:l A N D .. ~he ua-id i'liilta:)~. DWlu~m .i~ali~·l:terreby r€\quosts ~

. f,. '

~Oyt.:mo:uts. l:li~y .nP?~~r--·an ·~ ~mctmib.t'a.nee on · r. h e ~

d~:t· Qr /~·u·y. on·o tQ:o\wu_nd nino . . . / .. ·

i ., ] ' :1 ' i

. I

i

'· .;,-,. • . .- •:.·,,. ,.;;.--·

Page 11: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

~. . ?·~·· . ' ,.

\ \ ' l '

"j

.(

l !

.·.~.; . ·,

:;

.. · .. :,-:

· .. _,., ·,...., • .,, .• ~~;.'-". ··'···"'·'c

' ~- ·, ..• ;·:.-··

~t0N;;:n c¥ t.ttliJ sa.~d iliU.!All

i..>iirfrhH'.. L"(tSLr;:; in t. h ·e,.

ftt·~t.lfH\!}0~ Ot' . ·'

; .. ',•

·:~. .J:; .·-./ ~--:~;:

.·;··

~--.

i

·!·

' i ·. I • '

.·.·.:..;

,, ......... .

·::' ·······

N i ·.t.

•' ' • •r ·-'' •·

',•

.. ,._. -·~. J'

· . .) ..

··~

.;;

,, j ·, il rr I J ...

·.·:

·:.,

:1. 1 '. ,. .-~~-~

.. , /" :,i :-1/f~

'

Page 12: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE …

;.· ~ .h •' " ~\ ;l

I .. , .. _

l

,,

·_,·.· ,; .. .,......·:..; ;·.'.:. .. ·'"'""'

<;J .' '

·. ·P: ... . ~ :: .

·:·~.·· ~~.

(:1

col6DR ccioi: Y::Y&I!ow Bfi=Browrt G..-::Gceen R.=fl~ BbBlue P:Purp!e: H=Halell9<1 CU::Cro.u. !1atche-d

:· .. ,·.

,. : (."

. . . 'Mt-:·.~::-::~~~U.c,. Of .. fN~T}.Hi .. t-.1.ci~~=r?: · ... ·· · ....

' !"1/l"·>(t£"·! ··'--6:' ., . '-'· <<,J t'dj~el?. c,,,:,,,-~·,,~''i/7d40~~~i .

.. ,.,..~_·._· .... _., __ J::":: .. :::'",.J ' . . . "f, · /}J1rr • .f/1

~~---.."-< 'ft " /,1}!.-f/u: e--... ·--- ~-- l g.;::.:' .. f <:·~f~Ht:. "H~f'·r \:: ::~::: ~- ~'"'"< • • .. _ ··: ,;; :~v .. ~ .;:;. ...

:,,~~',"·'·:~""''''''',~. -· -~t~~~;,~f::.~-~·~ -'.f~<l---" , . . , 1

't A~8HJTA~rf ~~ :, ......... c"'-·----·-··-, .. , ........... , .... -~ ..... _"': -~·- .. • ".. , ,

L.

• • ,.._, __ ,.:c ............... . :·~~:!J,j:j <·"?f -~~ ;··

. ;'

...

·• t :.·~. j:·i-".-3 • . . '" !!if : t I

• I . i.'

t t • • • ..

·.~ ··~ • .. t • ' •· l I 1'-! f.l~ J•·H l l<>" • . . . i ~: ~

. -·'· :.

;·.;