in the high court of south africa - saflii.org file1a m makua vs mec for health prefd no file...
TRANSCRIPT
/
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
GAUTENG DIVISION, PRETORIA
PRETORIA THIS 17TH
DAY OF MARCH 2016
THURSDAY
CRIMINAL TRIALS
IN COURT GA AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JORDAAN
IN COURT 4E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE POTTERILL Case Name: State v Langstone Nexon Gumbi and 5 others
Case Number: CC49/2008 IN COURT GC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAUMELA
URGENT COURT
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KOLLAPEN IN COURT 2D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE J W LOUW
Page 2 of 16
CRIMINAL APPEALS
IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSEN BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SKOSANA
Name of Advocate for the state: Mahomed
No. Case no. Name of appellant Jail/Bail
1. A411/14 G M Mokhari jail
2. A491/15 F D Moyo + 1 jail
3. A477/15 P Jobe jail
4. A441/15 A M Manzana jail
CIVIL APPEALS
IN COURT 4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEUWENHUIZEN BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE CANCA AJ
NETCARE HOSPITALS (PTY) LTD VS HEALTH PROFESSIONS COUNCIL A480/14/71745/14
REVIEW JUDGEMENT
IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSEN BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SKOSANA
1. The State vs Jaime Horacio Maheme A161/16
Page 3 of 16 ADMISSIONS
IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSEN BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SKOSANA
1. ANRI MARE ADV 6172/16
2. MAX-WILHELM ROSSLE ATT 4558/16
3. MNWEBA PHEZILE GOBODO ATT 1817/16
4. VARANA CHUTTERPAUL ATT 2236/16
5. BOSHONIG DOMINIQUE TANJA ATT 2279/16
6. DARREN BRENT STEVENS NOT 2280/16
IN COURT4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEWENHUIZEN BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE CANCA AJ
1. GLORIA MUKONDELENI MALOBA ADV 1819/16
2. MBALI KHUMALO ATT 4509/16
3. LEHLOGONOLO TANYA MASHAPHU ATT 96858/15
4. KIRSTIN LEIGH SMITH ATT 411/16
5. WICHT MELISSA SOPHIA ATT 2005/16
6. HEATHER MANDY HEPBURN NOT 4510/16
UNOPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT 2A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKGOKA IN COURT 2B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANCHOD IN COURT 2C AT 10:00
Page 4 of 16 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE
OPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT 6B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAVUNDLA IN COURT 4B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTHLE IN COURT8G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAGARDIE IN COURT 4D AT 9:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOSEAMO : THE BREAD BREAKFAST Café (PTY)LTD vs YNWA 15 (PTY)+ 1
CASE NUMBER : 190/2016
Regards,
JUDGMENTS
IN COURT 6A AT 9;30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE ISMAIL L T MKHONSI VS RAF FIRST RAND BANK A789/14 IN COURT 2B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANCHOD
Kruger
Vs
Minister of Safety and Security
Case no: A702/14
IN COURT A AT 10:00 PALACE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOLMAY CASE NAME: J J M KORTEKAAS v NEDBANK
Page 5 of 16 CASE NO: 25147/14
IN COURT 4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEUWENHUIZEN
Case Number: A105/2015
In the matter between:
SIPHO MOSES RADEBE Appellant
and
THE STATE Respondent
SPECIAL CIVIL TRIALS
IN COURT 6D AT 10:00 18/03/16 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN IN COURT C AT 10:00 PALACE 11/-03/16 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOLMAY IN COURT 6C AT 10:00 UNTILL18/03 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KUBUSHI
3RD
COURT MOTIONS
IN COURT A AT 10:00 PALACE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RABIE IN COURT 6A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE ISMAIL
Page 6 of 16
CIVIL TRIALS DRAFT ORDERS ONLY
IN COURT 8E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA, DJP A NABO Z MAWENI VS RAF 61407/13 B ADV S CELLIERS VS RAF 67888/12 C L A MWEZO VS RAF 5070/14 D O N MODAU VS RAF 82824/14 E B M CACAMBILE VS RAF 69043/13 F N KWABABA VS RAF 78103/14
CIVIL TRIALS ALLOCATIONS ONLY
IN COURT 8E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA, DJP AA G PRETORIUS VS J P B HEAD 36428/14 BB J MOKOENA VS RAF 50917/13 CC DOUBELL VS RAF 44527/13
Page 7 of 16
CIVIL TRIALS
IN COURT8E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA, DJP 1A M MAKUA VS MEC FOR HEALTH PREFD NO FILE 68725/13 1B MY KHAN VS RAF PREFDATE 35964/13 1C S D KHAN VS RAF PREFDATE 59518/12 1D F E MONNANA VS RAF READINESS REMOVED 9234/14 1E T J NYEUFANE VS MIN OF POLICE PREF NO FILE 16432/04 1F M C SHEPPARD VS RAF PREFDATE NO FILE 54837/14
COURT ROLL 17 MARCH 2016
1 MARUKA P. VS PRASA 8905/14
2 SEOMANA M.G. VS PRASA 15229/12
3 SHELEMBE M.Z. VS PRASA 61087/12
4 ESSACK F.+1 VS CITY OF TSHWANE +2 52455/14
5 FIRSTRAND BANK VS VERSFELD W.J. 44716/11
6 MOROPA L.S. VS MIN SAFETY & SEC. NO FILE 54930/07
7 BOSCH A.J. VS ADONIS R.K. 72246/14
8 TENKE MINING VS SUMENTHERAN ARMOGAN 52161/13
9 SCRIBANTE CONCRETE VS OHLHORST AFRICAREMOVED8757/13
10 TIMBERNOLOGY CC VS KLINGENBERG O.J. 43949/14
11 BEUMER H.+1 VS SUPER GROUP VEHICLES 17615/08
Page 8 of 16 12 CHAPMAN A.J. VS CHAPMAN N.S. NO
FILE 64371/12
13 ENGIGYN CC VS J M RICHTER 43670/14
14 JORDAAN G. VS MIN.OF HOME AFFAIRS 82813/14
15 HENNING P.H. VS KOLBE J.C. 65863/11
16 VAN HEERDEN H. VS BOTHA T. NO FILE 56659/10
17 NORMANDIEN VS COPPER SUNSET TRADING 67739/13
18 MAJOLICA POTTERYVS SNYMAN & VENNOTE NO FILE 25792/93
19 KO PELE TRADING VS FARANANI SERVICES NO FILE
44367/13
20 NJANGU BRAIN VS RAF 3556/11
21 MABUZA S N VS RAF 21419/14
22 DALMAR PLANT HIREVS RMB STRUCTERED INS.
85202/14
23 STRYDOM G. VS LEGEND HOLDINGS REMOVED 41251/14
24 HAULERS B. VS NAICKER S. 69433/13
25 KHANGALE M.R. VS MEC HEALTH G.P.NO FILE 82576/14
26 DLAMINI S.Q. VS MEC HEALTH G.P. NO FILE 2645/14
27 LOUWRENS N.W. VS MIN OF POLICE NO FILE 63061/12
28 NTULI M.R. VS MIN OF POLICE +1 80181/14
29 MAHLARE T.M. VS MIN.OF POLICE 56227/12
30 BUSINESS PARTNERSVS PHELO-PELE HEALTH COMPLEX
35769/14
Page 9 of 16 31 L MBUNGELE VS RAF 45391/14
32 CELESTE NEL +2 VS KEYSTONE DEV. REMOVED41939/14
33 D MANQELE VS RAF 74461/15
34 MEDSHIELD SCHEMEVS STUART C.M. 46868/13
35 MEDSHIELD SCHEME VS PHALENG T. 47350/13
36 MEDSHIELD SCHEMEVS MABETA T.P. 46135/13
37 SWEETS F. VS MAKHUBU LOG. 11847/12
38 WACO AFRICA VS MARENTIA 230 CC +2 71768/12
39 MALEBO M.L. VS SEARLE PROKUREURS +2 69456/11
40 TEKS ALARMS CC VS RIANT INVESTMENTS REMOVED46772/14
41 MABATANE W.T. VS MIN.SAFETY& SEC. NO FILE 27754/13
42 N L MAKHAGA VS RAF 49848/13
43 BOTHA D.A. VS PETERSON L.W. 14339/14
44 JANSE V/RENSBURG+5 VS HARTKAMP J.W. 14130/05
45 ABSA BANK LTD VS HATTINGH P.W. 72267/13
46 BET SA CC VS SCHULER U.O. 36023/14
47 N M LEKABE VS RAF 80126/14
48 TRUTER J. VS GERMISHUYS P.J. 36048/14
49 NYLSTROOM WERKEVS MULDER R.A. NO FILE 6350/13
50 VAN HEERDEN P.S.+3 VS DANWET NO 131 65858/14
51 VAN DER BERG BFJ VS JOUBERT I.J. 73006/13
52 MM TOLO VS RAF 14026/14
Page 10 of 16 53 GNT SECURITY CC VS EHLANZENI FET 2787/13
54 ABSA BANK LTD VS YELLOW STAR TRADING 41003/13
55 SNYMAN J.P. VS MIN SAFETY & SEC.+3 NO FILE 47489/11
56 SNYMAN J.P. VS MIN SAFETY & SEC. +3 NO FILE 51658/11
57 HAMMAN F.C.+2 VS MIN.OF POLICE +3 37855/14
58 VILJOEN R. VS SA EXPLOSION PREV. 62527/14
59 MATSANA K.N. VS MIN.POLICE +1 37287/12
60 DPI PLASTICS VS ROUTE 7 TRADING 23195/13
61 RODRIGUES B. VS RODRIGUES N. 76013/12
62 REMOVED
63 ADV S SAYED VS RAF 36291/14
64 VAN ZYL D.W. VS VAN ZYL M. NO FILE 2681/14
65 KLEYNHANS A. VS KLEYNHANS W. NO FILE 26800/11
66 NGWENYA M.A. VS NGWENYA E.F. 52236/14
67 GROBLER A. VS GROBLER A. NO FILE
71281/12
68 BASSON J. VS BASSON E.J. NO FILE 6067/14
69 FOURIE P. VS FOURIE N. NO FILE 25399/14
70 SCHOEMAN W.J. VS SCHOEMAN E. 82317/14
71 PORTER J.H. VS RAF 39581/14
72 MASHIKE J. VS RAF 39956/14
73 MORWATSHEHLA M. VS RAF 62201/14
74 NGQALO M. VS RAF 78832/14
Page 11 of 16 75 MASEMOLA M.A. VS RAF
79671/14
76 SIMANGWA J.S. VS RAF 25639/13
77 JJ CLARKE VS RAF 54788/14
78 BOER K. VS RAF 55878/13
79 THOMPSON M.J. VS RAF 29845/14
80 VAN BREDA J.H. VS RAF 69929/14
81 MAKGAKE L.M. VS RAF 31416/14
82 MULAUDZI T.P. VS RAF 50410/14
83 SIBEKO N. VS RAF 75571/14
84 MADUMA N.C. VS RAF 64705/14
85 MAGASHANE M.L. VS RAF 33175/14
86 MEYER E.J. VS RAF 69866/14
87 MASINGI S.J. VS RAF 73588/13
88 SMIT A.L. VS RAF 62234/14
89 NEL K. VS RAF 71114/09
90 DIKGALE K.A. VS RAF 44395/14
91 MSUTHU N.D. VS RAF 72825/14
92 SIGCAU S. VS RAF 67558/14
93 DS MABULE VS RAF NO FILE 85295/15
94 NIRRAD M. VS RAF 25330/14
95 BONTIYA S.D. VS RAF 31212/14
96 MPOTULO N. VS RAF 23141/14
Page 12 of 16 97 MASOLA M. VS RAF
6977/14
98 THOKWANE P.P. VS RAF 70597/14
99 MOKOENA Q.S. VS RAF 45354/14
100 MITCHELL C. VS RAF 17743/14
101 MOHLALA M VS RAF 72800/14
102 VA NDWENI VS RAF READINESS 32967/14
103 M I MATHOTHO VS RA READDINESS 69955/14
104 E MTHOMBENI VS RAF NO FILE 34996/08
105 ADV B G MOGASWA VS RAF 46776/12
106 E N M MASELELA VS RAF NO FILE 36491/12
107 M J MOTSHWENI VS RAF NO FILE 52470/12
108 M MZUNGU VS RAF 22984/12
109 M MJOBO VS RAF 30972/12
Page 13 of 16
110 T MOROLONG VS RAF NO FILE 77105/14
111 IS BURGER VS RAF MERITS 2308/11
112 MSMOLOELE VS RAF 2905/13
113 V S MAGANGANE VS RAF READINESS 5517/12
114 N S MNGOMEZULU VS RAF READINESS 26876/13
115 S MALULEKA VS RAF READINESS 9455/11
116 LEGODI T L VS RAF READINESS 49492/14
117 K MAOTO VS RAF 27369/14
118 R C LECGAU VS RAF 27612/14
119 D L MOGOSHI VS RAF NO FILE 1092/14
120 MM MAVHAPO VS RAF 9855/11
121 RCSC BEHRENS VS RAF 56400/12
122 A SITHATHU VS RAF NO FILE 50328/14
123 V J NGALO VS RAF MER 20184/13
Page 14 of 16
124 M KHUMALO VS RAF 31999/13
125 E S MSWELI VS RAF 45773/13
126 E SHANGE VS RAF 62696/13
127 S SITHETHO VS RAF READINESS 68444/13
128 M F MAMLINDELWA VS RAF READINESS 61378/13
129 D Z ZWANE VS RAF READINESS 80177/14
130 N G RAHUBE VS RAF READINESS 86331/14
131 C NGOBENI VS RAF NO FILE 8502/15
132 C L ECCLES VS RAF READINES 37218/15
133 S S BUTHELEZI VS RAF 9461/14
134 W H DE BEER VS RAF NO FILE 70395/13
135 ADV S SAYED VS RAF NO FILE 35291/14
136 M J GEAYAYA VS RAF SERT 55888/12
Page 15 of 16 137 P C MOKALE VS RAF
37487/15
138 RABALI M J VS RAF 27492/12
139 J BASSON VS E J BASSON 6067/14
140 A MOCHIFEFE VS C DU PREEZ +1 41104/13
141 T C MTHIMUNYE VS RAF 72180/12
142 M T HENNING VS RAF 2833/13
143 NCHABELENG T J VS RAF 32418/15
144 MOTLOGELOA J R VS RAF 46576/15
145 PHASHA L LETWATWA VS RAF 45989/12
CIVIL TRIAL JUDGES
IN COURT 6F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEGODI IN COURT B AT 10:00 PALACE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PRETORIUS IN COURT 6G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MSIMEKI
Page 16 of 16 IN COURT 6E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE DE VOS IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAQWA IN COURT 8A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE D FOURIE IN COURT 8B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BASSON IN COURT 8C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALI IN COURT 8F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SIKHWARI AJ IN COURT GD AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MSIBI AJ
COURTS AVAILABLE