improved surface technology for protein arrays colin campbell · common abo blood types a 1 b o a 2...

25
Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell

Upload: others

Post on 30-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Impro

ved s

urf

ace t

echno

logy

for

pro

tein

arr

ays

Co

lin C

am

pbe

ll

Page 2: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Intr

od

uction

•R

ation

ale

•B

ackgro

un

d

•S

urf

ace c

hoic

e f

or

pro

tein

mic

roa

rray

•D

ete

ctio

n a

nd d

iscri

min

atio

n o

f div

ers

e s

urf

ace a

ntige

ns

•Lab

el-fr

ee d

ete

ction

•A

na

lysis

tools

Page 3: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Com

mon A

BO

blo

od types

A1

B

OA

2

The b

asic

unit o

f th

e A

BO

syste

m is t

he O

antigen:

fucose-t

erm

inate

d p

enta

sacchari

de

The A

and B

antigens a

re d

eri

vatives

In t

he c

ase o

f A

the s

ugar

is N

-acety

l ga

lacto

se

In t

he c

ase o

f B

it

is g

ala

cto

se.

A1B

Page 4: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Curr

ent m

eth

ods o

f blo

od typin

g

Oly

mp

us p

late

reader

Dia

me

dchro

mato

gra

ph

y “

card

Page 5: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

•D

efin

e su

rfac

e ch

emis

try:

Gla

ss s

lides

hav

e bee

n p

repar

ed a

nd c

oat

ed w

ith

1. P

oly

ion

2. F

unct

ional

sil

ane

layer

3. F

unct

ional

hyro

gel

layer

Pro

tein

arr

ay s

urf

ace c

hem

istr

y

H

Page 6: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

05

10

15

20

BR

AD

3JL

DM

3L

A2

LB

2

An

tib

od

y

S/Ngold

Hydro

gel I

Epoxy S

ilane

Hydro

gel II

Poly

-l-lysin

e

Com

parison o

f arr

ay s

urf

aces

Page 7: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Surf

ace e

nhanced flu

ore

scence

Effe

ct of m

eta

llic s

urf

ace

:F

luo

roph

ore

qu

ench

ing

0-5

nm

Incre

ased

ra

dia

tive

de

ca

y r

ate

/qu

an

tum

yie

ld 5

-20

nm

Page 8: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

B

0

50

10

0

15

0

20

0

25

0

30

0

BR

AD

3

NEA

T

DA

M1

NE

AT

ES

15

A(B

)

NE

AT

JLD

M3

NEA

T

LA

2 D

IL

1/8

LB

2 D

IL

1/2

Anti

bo

dy

S/N

A1

05

01

00

15

02

00

25

03

00

35

0

BR

AD

3

NE

AT

DA

M1

NE

AT

ES

15

A(B

)

NE

AT

JL

DM

3

NE

AT

LA

2 D

IL

1/8

LB

2 D

IL

1/2

An

tib

od

y

S/N

O

0

0.51

1.52

2.53

BR

AD

3

NEA

T

DA

M1

NEA

T

ES

15A

(B)

NEA

T

JLD

M3

NEA

T

LA

2 D

IL

1/8

LB

2 D

IL

1/2

Antibody

S/N

A2

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

BR

AD

3

NEA

T

DA

M1 N

EA

TES

15A

(B)

NEA

T

JL

DM

3

NEA

T

LA

2 D

IL 1

/8L

B2 D

IL 1

/2

An

tib

od

y

S/N

ab

cd

A1

B

A2

O

An

ti-R

hD

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

-ve

co

nt

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

An

ti-R

hD

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

/B-v

eco

nt

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

An

ti-R

hD

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

-ve

co

nt

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

An

ti-R

hD

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

-ve

co

nt

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

AB

O d

ete

ction

Page 9: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

A1B

+

0

50

100

150

200

BR

AD

3

NE

AT

DA

M1

NE

AT

ES

15A

(B)

NEA

T

JLD

M3

NE

AT

LA

2 D

IL

1/8

LB

2 D

IL

1/2

Anti

bo

dy

S/N

A1+

0

50

10

015

0

20

0

25

0

30

0

BR

AD

3

NEA

T

DA

M1

NEA

T

ES

15A

(B)

NEA

T

JLD

M3

NE

AT

LA

2 D

IL

1/8

LB

2 D

IL

1/2

An

tibo

dy

S/N

Ax+

0

50

10

015

0

20

0

25

0

30

0

BR

AD

3

NEA

T

DA

M1

NE

AT

ES

15A

(B)

NEA

T

JLD

M3

NE

AT

LA

2 D

IL

1/8

LB

2 D

IL

1/2

Anti

bo

dy

S/N

B+

0

100

200

300

400

BR

AD

3

NE

AT

DA

M1

NE

AT

ES

15A

(B)

NE

AT

JL

DM

3

NE

AT

LA

2 D

IL

1/8

LB

2 D

IL

1/2

An

tib

od

y

S/N

O+

0

50

100

150

200

BR

AD

3

NE

AT

DA

M1

NE

AT

ES

15A

(B)

NEA

T

JLD

M3

NEA

T

LA

2 D

IL

1/8

LB

2 D

IL

1/2

Anti

bo

dy

S/N

A2B

+

0

50

100

150

200

250

BR

AD

3

NEA

T

DA

M1

NEA

T

ES

15

A(B

)

NEA

T

JLD

M3

NEA

T

LA

2 D

IL

1/8

LB

2 D

IL

1/2

Anti

bo

dy

S/N

ab

cd

ef

A1B

Rh

DA

2B

Rh

D

BR

hD

A1R

hD

AXR

hD

OR

hD

An

ti-R

hD

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

-ve

co

nt

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

An

ti-R

hD

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

-ve

co

nt

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

An

ti-R

hD

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

-ve

co

nt

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

An

ti-R

hD

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

-ve

co

nt

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

An

ti-R

hD

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

-ve

co

nt

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

An

ti-R

hD

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

-ve

co

nt

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

Page 10: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Rhesus a

ntigen

Most

com

mon R

hesus a

ntige

ns a

re D

, C

or

c a

nd E

or

e

Encode

d o

n t

wo s

tructu

rally

hom

olo

gous g

enes o

n t

he R

hlo

cus.

Both

are

417 a

am

ulti-pass inte

gra

l m

em

bra

ne p

rote

ins w

ith 6

expose

d p

ep

tide

loops o

n e

ryth

rocyte

surf

ace p

resentin

g d

iscre

te a

ntige

nic

epitopes.

Tw

o p

rote

ins d

iffe

r b

y 3

6 a

min

o a

cid

s a

nd t

he

antigen

ic r

egio

ns d

iffe

r b

y a

s little

as o

ne a

min

o a

cid

betw

een R

hD

an

d R

hC

E

Page 11: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

0.11

10

100

1000

LHM

76/5

8LH

M76

/59

LHM

50/2

BES

D1

LHM

76/5

5LH

M77

/64

LHM

70/4

5LH

M59

/19

LHM

169/

80B

RA

D3 LD

M1

LDM

77/6

4 ESD

1M

H48

DEM

1

An

tib

od

ies

log (S/N)

Rhesus d

iscrim

ination

R1R

1blo

od h

as D

antigen b

ut

neither

c n

or

E

r”r”

has c

and E

but

not

D

Page 12: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Label-fr

ee b

lood typin

g

•M

otivation

–R

em

ove

va

ria

bili

ty a

nd

tim

e b

y r

em

ovin

g

pro

ce

ss s

tep

s lik

e

•P

urificatio

n

•Lab

elli

ng

•C

am

e a

bout fr

om

effort

s to label th

e w

hole

blo

od p

rote

om

e

Page 13: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

05

10

15

20

25

DA

M1

ES

15

LA

2LB

2

An

tib

od

y

S/N

488/1

543/1

543/2

543/3

488/1

Repeat

Re

d C

ells

0.7

5

0.8

0.8

5

0.9

0.9

51

1.0

5

350

400

450

500

550

600

nm

Absorbance

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

Choic

e o

f scanner

settin

gs

585

543

Case 5

43/3

578

543

Case 5

43/2

570

543

Case 5

43/1

530

488

Case 4

88/1

Dete

ction

wa

vele

ngth

(n

m)

Excitation

wa

vele

ngth

(nm

)

An

ti-A

(B)

Page 14: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Gro

up

B

0.1110100

1000

DA

M1

Ne

at

ES

15 N

ea

tL

A2

Ne

at

LB

2 1:

4

An

tib

od

y

log S/N Ratio

Lab

elle

d R

ed C

ells

Wh

ole

Blo

od

- N

eat

Wh

ole

Blo

od

1/5

Dilu

tion

Wh

ole

Blo

od

1/1

0 D

ilutio

n

Gro

up

A1

0.1110100

1000

DA

M1

ES

15

LA

2 L

B2

An

tib

od

y

log S/N Ratio

La

be

lled

Red

Ce

lls

Wh

ole

Blo

od

- N

ea

t

Wh

ole

Blo

od

1/5

Dilu

tio

n

Wh

ole

Blo

od

1/1

0 D

iluti

on

Typ

e O

0123456789

10

DA

M1 N

ea

tE

S15 N

ea

tL

A2 N

ea

tL

B2 1

:2

An

tib

od

y

log S/N Ratio

La

be

lle

d R

ed

Ce

lls

Wh

ole

Blo

od

- N

ea

t

Wh

ole

Blo

od

1/5

Dilu

tio

n

Wh

ole

Blo

od

1/1

0 D

ilu

tio

n

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

An

ti-A

An

ti-A

(B)

An

ti-A

An

ti-B

Ch

oic

e o

f sa

mp

le

pre

-tre

atm

en

t

Sho

ws la

bel-fr

ee A

BO

dis

cri

min

atio

n

Page 15: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Conclu

sio

n

•A

rray b

ased m

eth

od c

an d

iscrim

inate

com

mon e

ryth

rocyte

s

•A

uto

fluore

scence

can b

e u

sed a

s a

read-

out m

odalit

y

Page 16: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Evalu

ation o

f a P

rote

in M

icro

chip

Meth

od f

or

Typin

g W

hole

Blo

od

Ste

w –

Lab T

alk

20

thN

ovem

ber

2006

Page 17: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Aim

•T

ake

67

blo

od

sam

ple

s a

nd

eva

lua

te the

arr

ay m

eth

od

of A

BO

p

he

noty

pin

g.

•A

rra

ys w

ere

pri

nte

d w

ith

mu

ltip

le s

potte

d r

ep

lica

tes o

f a

ntib

od

ies

sp

ecific

for

eith

er

A (

LA

2)

or

B (

LB

2)

blo

od

typ

e a

ntige

ns, a

lon

g w

ith

P

BS

an

d Ig

G o

nly

sp

ots

as n

eg

ative

co

ntr

ols

•In

to

tal 3

2 s

ep

ara

te s

ub

-arr

ays w

ere

prin

ted

per

slid

e, w

ith

each

su

b-a

rra

y c

onta

inin

g 5

re

plic

ate

s o

f L

A2

an

tib

od

y, 7 r

ep

lica

tes o

f L

B2

, 2

re

plic

ate

s o

f Ig

G a

nd

7 r

ep

lica

tes o

f P

BS

•T

he

refo

re e

ach

arr

ay c

onta

ine

d the

fo

llow

ing

num

bers

of re

plic

ate

sp

ots

: L

A2

(n =

16

0),

LB

2 (

n =

224

), IgG

(n

= 6

4)

an

d P

BS

(n

= 2

24)

Page 18: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Exp

ecte

d R

esu

lts

•T

hre

e b

loo

d typ

es w

ere

ana

lyse

d: A

, B

an

d O

•T

wo

an

tib

od

ies w

ere

use

d to

dete

ct th

ese

diffe

ren

t b

loo

d typ

es:

–LA

2 =

anti-A

blo

od t

ype a

ntig

en

–LB

2 =

anti-B

blo

od t

ype a

ntig

en

•T

yp

e A

blo

od s

hou

ld r

eact w

ith

th

e L

A2

an

tib

od

y

•T

yp

e B

blo

od s

hou

ld r

eact w

ith

th

e L

B2

an

tib

od

y

•T

yp

e O

blo

od s

hou

ld n

ot re

act w

ith e

ith

er

an

tib

od

y (

neg

ative

respo

nse)

Page 19: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

RO

C C

urv

es

•R

OC

curv

es w

ere

in

itia

lly d

eve

lop

ed

in

th

e 1

94

0s in

ord

er

to m

ake

se

nse

of ra

dio

sig

na

ls c

on

tam

ina

ted

by n

ois

e

•R

OC

’sare

a g

rap

hic

al p

lot o

f se

nsitiv

ity v

s (

1-s

pe

cific

ity)

or

true

p

ositiv

es v

s fa

lse

po

sitiv

es

•T

he

op

tim

um

pre

dic

tive

ou

tco

me

is th

ere

fore

a c

urv

e in

th

e u

ppe

rle

ft c

orn

er

of th

e g

raph

i.e

10

0%

se

nsitiv

ity (

all

true

positiv

es fo

un

d)

an

d 1

00

% s

pe

cific

ity (

no

fals

e p

ositiv

es fo

un

d)

•In

co

ntr

ast a c

om

ple

tely

ran

do

m p

red

icto

r w

ou

ld g

ive a

str

aig

ht lin

e

at 4

5 d

egre

es fro

m th

e h

orizo

nta

l, fro

m b

otto

m le

ft to

to

p r

igh

t

Page 20: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Use

of R

OC

s to

se

t th

resh

old

s

•A

n In

de

x S

core

wa

s o

bta

ine

d for

ea

ch

arr

ay w

here

the

med

ian

sig

na

l-b

ackg

rou

nd

va

lue for

the

LA

2 a

ntib

od

y w

as d

ivid

ed

by th

e

me

dia

n for

the

LB

2, g

ivin

g a

ra

tio

va

lue

fo

r th

e tw

o a

ntib

od

y

resp

on

se

s

•R

OC

curv

es (

se

nsitiv

ity v

s. (1

-sp

ecific

ity))

were

th

en

plo

tte

d to

o

bta

in thre

sho

ld v

alu

es w

ith

in w

hic

h it co

uld

be

con

fid

en

tly s

aid

tha

t a

giv

en

sa

mple

wa

s o

f a

pa

rtic

ula

r b

lood

typ

e

Page 21: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

De

fin

ing

a th

resh

old

•R

OC

curv

es w

ere

constr

ucte

d t

o o

bta

in t

hre

shold

va

lues f

or

each o

f th

e b

lood

types,

the R

OC

curv

e f

or

the A

blo

od t

ype is s

ho

wn b

elo

w

•T

he R

OC

curv

e is a

gra

ph

ical plo

t of

sensitiv

ity v

s.

(1-s

pecific

ity).

•F

or

the R

OC

analy

sis

the A

blo

od t

ype s

am

ple

inde

x s

core

s w

ere

use

d t

o

repre

se

nt

the t

rue p

ositiv

e s

am

ple

s,

whils

t th

e ind

ex s

core

s o

f th

e B

blo

od t

ype

sam

ple

s w

ere

used a

s t

he f

als

e p

ositiv

es

Are

a u

nd

er c

urv

e =

0.9

95

Page 22: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

De

fin

ing

a th

resh

old

•T

he

RO

C c

urv

e d

em

on

str

ate

d a

go

od

ab

ility

to

se

pa

rate

th

e A

an

d B

blo

od

typ

es a

s t

he

are

a u

nd

er

the

cu

rve

(0

.99

5)

wa

s c

lose

to

th

e m

axim

um

are

a o

f 1

,in

dic

atin

g a

to

tal

se

pa

ratio

n o

f th

e s

am

ple

se

ts.

•T

his

in

dic

ate

s t

ha

t fo

r th

e c

ho

se

n t

hre

sh

old

cu

t-o

ff v

alu

e o

f 2

.71

fo

r th

e A

blo

od

typ

e

va

lues,

a s

en

sitiv

ity o

f 1

00

% a

nd

a s

pe

cific

ity o

f 9

6.2

% w

as o

bta

ine

d

•T

hre

sh

old

va

lue

s f

or

the

oth

er

blo

od

typ

es w

ere

ob

tain

ed

an

d a

rep

rese

nte

d b

elo

w,

ag

ain

th

e R

OC

cu

rve

s d

em

on

str

ate

d a

go

od

ab

ility

to

se

pa

rate

bo

th t

he

A a

nd

O,

an

d

the

B a

nd

O b

loo

d t

yp

es

100 (

at 0

.929

)

97 (

at 2

.7)

87.5

(at

0.9

29

)

92.3

(at

2.7

)

0.9

29 –

2.7

O

87.5

100

�0.6

4B

96.2

100

�2.7

1A

% S

pec

ific

ity a

t T

hres

hold

% S

ensi

tivit

y a

t T

hre

shold

Th

resh

old

Valu

e S

elec

ted

of

Ind

ex

Sco

re

fro

m R

OC

Cu

rve

Blo

od

Typ

e

Page 23: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Assig

nin

g b

lood

typ

es b

ase

d o

n th

e

se

lecte

d th

resh

old

s

Cla

ssif

ica

tion

A

B

O

Tota

l

Sam

ple

s

To

tal

Sam

ple

s 26

8

33

67

Corr

ect

ly P

red

icte

d

25

7

32

64

Inco

rrec

tly P

red

icte

d

1

1

1

3

% S

am

ple

s C

orr

ectl

y P

red

icte

d

96.2

87

.5

96.9

95.5

Carr

ied o

ut

a “

hold

-out”

valid

ation b

y u

sin

g 9

0%

of

the s

am

ple

s a

s “

train

ing

set”

and 1

0%

as a

“te

st

set”

Page 24: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Co

nclu

sio

ns

•S

ho

wn

tha

t w

e c

an

use

an

tib

od

y a

rra

y tech

no

log

y to

accu

rate

ly

ph

en

oty

pe

RB

Cs b

y d

ete

ctin

g c

om

ple

x m

ixtu

res o

f an

tig

ens o

n the

ce

ll surf

ace

•T

he

syste

m is la

be

l fr

ee a

nd

ca

n d

ete

ct b

loo

d typ

e a

ntig

ens in

who

le

blo

od

sa

mp

les thu

s a

ctin

g to

sig

nific

an

tly s

imp

lifyin

g th

e b

loo

dty

pin

g p

roce

du

re

•T

he

use

of R

OC

curv

es a

llow

s th

e d

efin

itio

n o

f cle

ar

thre

sho

lds

with

in w

hic

h a

n u

nkno

wn

sa

mp

le c

an

be

successfu

lly a

ssig

ne

d a

p

art

icu

lar

blo

od

typ

e

Page 25: Improved surface technology for protein arrays Colin Campbell · Common ABO blood types A 1 B O A 2 The basic unit of the ABO system is the O antigen: fucose-terminated pentasaccharide

Acknow

ledgem

ents

•D

PM

–P

ete

r G

hazal, J

ohn

Beatt

ie,

Ala

n R

oss,

Ste

wart

Burg

ess,

Thors

ten

Fors

ter

•S

NB

TS

–N

ick O

’loo

ney,

Janin

e

Ro

bb,

Marisa C

ho

ng-

Kw

an,

Jura

j P

etr

ik

•S

co

ttis

h E

nte

rpri

se