iicfreport appendixa-d-final 10dec web

Upload: eddy-satriya

Post on 01-Jun-2018

224 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    1/84

    THE INDONESIA ICT CONSULTATIVE FORUM:

    2014 REVIEW AND 2015 PRIORITIES

    December 2014

    Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    2/84

    !"#$%#$&

    !"#$%&" &"(()*" +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ,

    )$-.%!#"/*"&".0( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1

    "2"$3045" (3&&)67 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 8

    9)$-*6%3./ %: 44$: ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    %9

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    3/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; 2/A E2/2A95A41/ 95A2B N1@2D29K 4/ A29:3

    1F G34/? ./F19:5A41/ 5/0 (1::G/4>5A41/ O2>6/1=1?8 P.(OQ F19 :192 E910G>A4D2

    2>1/1:4> 5>A4D4A423K ./01/2345 3A4== =5?3 1G/A9423 0G2 A1 =4:4A5A41/3 4/

    >1//2>A41/ 3E220 5/0 =1>5= >1/A2/AB

    ,3 ./01/2345 65EA29K A6292 592 A92:2/01G3 1EE19AG/4A423 A1 G32

    50D5/>23 4/ A2>6/1=1?8 A1 02D2=1E 5 ;/1@=20?2R1/1:8B O62 4:E5>A 925>623

    F59 6/1=1?8 >5/ 62=E 4:E91D2 ?1D29/:2/A 329D4>23K

    20G>5A41/K 5/0 625=A6>592B O1 925=4I2 A6232 94A4>5= A1 02D2=1E 5 911383A2: @6292 4//1D5A41/ 5/0 2/A92E92/2G9364E >5/ A694D2B (1==56 53 A62 ./01/2345 .(O (1/3G=A5A4D2 S19G: P..(SQ 2/55/ 02D2=1E E91?92334D2 .(O E1=4>423 A65A @4== 62=E ./01/2345

    ?91@B

    ./ "LMTK A62 ..(S F1>G320 1/ 5 045=1?G2 51/340295A41/3K 5/0 =583 1GA

    /2JA 3A2E3 F19 A62 ..(S 4/ "LM$B ./ A62 >1:4/? 8259K @2 =11; F19@590 A1 02=4D294/? E1=4>8

    923G=A3

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    4/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    5/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    6/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; DA $)7&0(8 EFG$A@HI? *+-+6 >7%J1'.

    C0K+(8 C&-07()- 3)- F1'+317(+-&', >'2+=(-8 4-);)(&)'. >'2)'0=&1 >':0=(;0'(D))-2&'1(&', L)1-2 ELM4FI? D%-&= N+66. $K07(-+; C&-07()-. G=&1 417&3&7. 9$FG? 1'2

    C1:&2 $&)J.

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    7/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    8/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    9/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    10/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    11/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; 62: 56 6A3 4/@54?

    238B/054? 507 84/E54 43;34 6/ 5@AB3;3 6A3 >A5237 8/54 /G @2356B08 5 I0/F437831E5>37

    3@/0/=: B0 ,07/03>B5C

    7&87.#(0# 9:1+8:1+; '&%1)1#/ 6A2/98A B079>62: @/0>94656B/0 B0 6A3 73;34/? 507

    43;3258B08 /0 3@6/2J> 3H3 507 B00/;56B/0 6/ /4;3 @A5443083> G5@37 B0 ,*+157/

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    12/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; DE 4+, F,G

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    13/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; ; 5?7 )C.E58(-' F(6?5?7(E; -'( A0& 0122.--(( 0'5.6 1@ B:>G0H &'(+122.--(( +12=6.3(3 I1/(6?2(?- 1@@.+.5C3 5- -'( 33.3-5?- 5?7 2(6.+5?

    0'528(6 1@ 0122(6+( J>20'52K A?71?(3.5L3 A& M &(C(+1??(+-./.-9 0122.--((;

    D>:&)N; 5?7 O>@@5.63; 53 S(CC 53 D.?.3-(63 @612 6(C(/5?- D.?.3-6.(3; -'61,I' -'( 0'5.625?

    1@ -'( :-((6.?I 0122.--((H

    -+./ 0&.#1,2

    &'( S16Q 3-6(523 56( 7.6(+-(7 89 -'( )*(+,-./( 0122.--(( 5?7 =61/.7( 5? 5/(?,( -1

    7.3+,33 .33,(3 .? 7(=-'H )5+' S16Q 3-6(52 .3 C(7 89 5 2(28(6 @612 B:>G0L3 A0&

    0122.--(( 5?7 S.CC =61/.7( 7(-5.C(7 .?=,-3 5?7 -.2(C9 ,=75-(3H V./(? -'5- -'.3 .3 5

    +1?3,C-5-./( @16,2; -'( 3+1=( 1@ (5+' S16Q 3-6(52 .3 1=(? 5?7 3,8W(+- -1 +'5?I(H A?

    #X"Y; -'( .7(?-.@.(7 S16Q 3-6(523 S(6(Z

    "#$%&'()*+ ,-./$0(.

    ?$+'$2)4 @((=.$A ,*)B(

    ,-1#-(/2/3/-$ 4)1'&/3'(/)-

    ?$+'$24 %&/$.

    56#*$/-$ 7/$/('& 8*#-9.

    ?$+'$2)4 C*B2()(>/A D-+.B(33

    )*52.?.?I C1+5C 5?7 IC185C

    6(I,C5-.1?3 5?7 8(3- =65+-.+(3

    -'5- 57/5?+( 3,3-5.?58C(; C1?I4

    -(62 I61S-' .? -'( A0& 3(+-16

    A7(?-.@9.?I 1==16-,?.-.(3 -1 I61S

    -'( C1+5C A0& .?7,3-69

    B=75-(3 1? IC185C .?7,3-69 -6(?73

    5?7 6(C(/5?+( -1 -'( A0&

    (+1393-(2 .? A?71?(3.5H

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    14/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; 80AJ ,89 6D4@?062/A 08?0 M6@@ 6/519?A9 089 52D *25?@6P?062/J ,89 /993 721 >2K91/D9/0 @9?391A86< 6/

    A06D4@?06/> 6/K9A0D9/0 6/0919A0O

    o &D91>6/> Q6>60?@ ,19/3AJ ,19/3A 6/ )/32/9A6?NA 36>60?@ @?/3A5?

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    15/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    16/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; "'' % DC4,(A-*,-C(/- .55-22 /( @-.'/@5.,-E-*)5./?(

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    17/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; - 3 (3)35+- (-19--5 4313 &.21-+1*25 :-3,'.-, 354 18-

    4295,1.-3: -77-+1, 27 4313 )2+3)*@31*25 .-?'*.-:-51, 27 KCL= *5/-,1:-51,= 354

    9-)73.-; M8-.- 3),2 5--4, 12 (- 3 +)-3.-. )-B3) ,1354*5B 25 4313 +-51.-, *5

    E5425-,*3 354 :2.- +22.4*531*25 (-19--5 18- H*5*,1.6 27 N2::'5*+31*25 354

    E572.:31*25 M-+852)2B6 OHNEMP= 18- J*535+*3) G-./*+-, Q'182.*16 ORSTP= 354 218-.

    .-)31-4 B2/-.5:-51 *5,1*1'1*25,;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    18/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    19/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    20/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; 0)+6 3.)4+,- .>+ +5'+ )4 .0-,0 +. 1'&,:>'0-

    F4-.4,1)'I1 (6?,0 13'(,B +5, K*.?'* ;6?,01,(>0)+6 L:,4-' MF9CK;LN 4,,-1 +. ?,

    '--0,11,- /)+5)4 '** 3)**'01 )4 F4-.4,1)'G *,:'* &0'0'*

    (+>0,1B ('3'()+6 ?>)*-)4:B '4- )4+,04'+).4'* (..3,0'+).47

    L&+,0 +5, 0,30,1,4+'+)@, 15'0,- ,2)1+)4: :.@,04

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    21/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; (/.I +. 1'( >(;/./1/+.

    0.> 2(,0.1/*2 +; O*:=(< )0FP5

    .#/012/%& %13 4(+/#35(%& 6#%75(#7- B'/)( A.>+.(2/0 '02 >(E()+?(> 1(*'./*0) 0.>

    ?-

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    22/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    23/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    24/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    25/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; + V-8,)'-. G)D*6*'8 )E V)'4H-+3 KWVVFLA 6)5,.* 9-16*'8+ -/*

    -' ,'2/*-+,'0.1 E*-+,5.* 9-16*'8 9.-8E)/6 E)/ )'.,'* 0))(+ -'( +*/D,2*+: W,D*' 83*

    3,03 6)5,.* 93)'* 9*'*8/-8,)' /-8* ,' &'()'*+,- -'( /=/-. 9)9=.-8,)'+> .,6,8*(

    931+,2-. -22*++ 8) 5-'C+ -'( )83*/ E,'-'2,-. ,'+8,8=8,)'+A 83* 9/)D,+,)' )E 6)5,.*

    7-..*8+ 51 8*.*2)66=',2-8,)' )9*/-8)/+ *T8*'(+ *42)66*/2* -'( E,'-'2,-. +*/D,2*+ 8)

    9/*D,)=+.1 ='5-'C*( &'()'*+,-'+:

    " XG-+8*/H-/( ;22*.*/-8*+

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    26/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    27/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; 7-+,> &'?@5 8/ ) F828+)1E

    G0*>,*1,55E A0( H*,,/,* I0*1>J F,D,105 )/> K00159 :0*;5.0< =/ -011)60*)+80/ :8+. +., L'@LM C07/>)+80/ )/> ?8-*0504+E >,D,10 +:0 6)58- +*)8/8/2

    -07*5,5 40* 307/2 ,/+*,,D,10()/)2,(,/+B

    -.'/0)12 &'()*)()+, )1 !"#3

    ?2/.@ A,03-/*- E25-*7+0 0256-7+7+8-,-** 21 $"%$& "9%* /,E F-77-3 +,7-C3/7- 7B-5 +,72 3-C+2,/./,E C.2F/. 8/.)- 0B/+,* L'@LM N/18/, '?@ L-)>,(3J O*0D8>,5 '?@5 :8+. 4*,,E -,/+*)18P,>E 0/18/, )--,55 +0 *,1,D)/+

    )/> -07/+*3Q5 48/)/-, 8/40*()+80/B

    @QA0((,*-, 044,*5 ) 582/848-)/+ 0 7/8T7, -.)11,/2,5 8/ ,QA0((,*-, )>0E '?@5 /,,> 40* 6*0)>6)/> 5,*D8-,5 )*, /0+ )1:)35 5,*D,> 63

    +,1,-0((7/8-)+80/ 5,*D8-, ,*5B =/>05)+ 5.)*,> +.)+ 48R,> 5,*D8-,5 )*, 044,*,>

    +3>*,558/2 +., 48/,

    18/, 6,+:,,/ 5()11,* '?@5 )/> +., .82.Q,/> -0/57(,* ()*;,+B

    K.8*>E =/>0/,58)/ 6)/;59 *828> 5+)/>)*>5 8/ )*,)5 57-. )5 (,*-.)/+ 7/>,*:*8+8/2 18(8+5

    18/;)2,5 6,+:,,/ '?@ ,QA0((,*-, )-+8D8+8,5 )/> 6)/;5B K.85 85 ,R)-,*6)+,> 63 '?@5

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    28/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    29/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; 934/+0' /' .->./39 4+ -(39/?/0: /4' 5>99 :-+@4< =+4(04/39A

    B38/0: 3 2(8(9+=(2 =36,(04 /02>'4-6 /' 3 ;(6 (03C9(- 4+ ()*+,,(-.( :-+@4-(-' -(..4'A

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    30/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; *@+/*(&) /( +0(*' '-B.*@+/$ B2(@$))$)

    >. 2'( RH@ 0++ 51*9;624 01( 1(/;+02(9 38 RH 9-1(62-B(4 ,'-6' 70.902( 2'02 *.6( 0

    51*9;62 3(01-./ 2'( JR 701G-./ -4 5+06(9 -. 2'( RH 701G(2@ 7(73(1 4202(4 4'0++

    51(4;7( 6*75+-0.6( ,-2' 2'( RH A-1(62-B(4 0.9 4'0++ .*2 51*'-3-2@ 1(421-62@ *1 -75(9(

    2'( 5+06(7(.2 *) 2'-4 51*9;62 *1 4(1B-6( -. 2'(-1 701G(2@ ;.+(44 2'(8 '0B( (B-9(.6( 2*

    2'( 6*.21018= >. 2'( H?@ 2(+(6*77;.-602-*. 51*9;624 ,-2' 0 A(6+0102-*. *) J*.)*17-28

    01( (:(752(9 )1*7 );12'(1 1(B-(, 38 2'( 1(/;+02*1=

    ?$)/

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    31/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    32/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; ?@#K LIM>NO34*.--3 5-+'0 %45* 57*D3' -7%- D73&2*9.43 -%B35 D3)3 )3'+,3'1 -73 57*)-6-3)2 4*55 .& 8*/3)&23&- )3/3&+35 D%5 P+.,Q40

    )3,*/3)3' .& -73 23'.+26-3)2 '+3 -* -73 8)*D-7 .& -73 -%B 9%53 RS.8+)3 $T:

    !"#$%& () *+","-. /0 12%3&- -/ %&4/5&% ,/6- -27 "8 .&2%6 0/,,/9"8# 28 2:;52,/%&1 -27 %&:$4-"/8

    !"##$%&'() +%$,-+,(- -./.0$#1.(& '( 2(-$(.3',

    U7.43 9)*%'9%&' .5 % Q30 3&%943) *C -73

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    33/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; 3)/?

    @2*4 A 0:('3*0'1 2) .)/0)(123 3)/ +23)/=2/*4 3B32+3>+(- ( 3++0;3*(/ 90' >'03/>3)/ *0 3;;03)/=2/*4F2)*()12B( 3::+2;3*20)1?

    .) .)/0)(123- *4( ;&''()* @2FG2 >3)/=2/*4 21 +22+2*,

    09 +3*(1* @2FG2 *(;4)0+0D2(1 *43* 1&::0'* >3)/=2/*41 09 H5 678 3)/ I5 678 3)/

    :'2B3*( &1('1J 3;;(11 *0 (K:3)/(/ 9'(L&();, >3)/1 09 $M$5F$"$5 678 3)/ $HN5 O $N#$

    678? .) 0'/(' 90' .)/0)(123) ;0)1&3)/ )(*=0'P1 3)/ 1('B2;(1 *43*

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    34/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    35/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567;

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    36/84

    "#$ %&'(&$)*+ %," ,(&)-./+/*0$ 1(2-34 5678 9$0*$: +&' 567; 2(3 5&' EF$@-/*0$ D$$/*&= G %%,1BK-&$ 58J 5678C

    $%%&'()* (

    D*&-/$) >2(3 L2' EF$@-/*0$ D$$/*&= G %%,1BM@/(A$2 5J 5678C

    $%%&'()* &

    N-II.$3$&/+2O D+/$2*+.)

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    37/84

    "##$%&'( "!"#$"" $"&'$()*& +," "-+'./)-,0"*+ 12

    3*(1*"-)' 345 41*-6/+'+)7" 81$60 93348: 5"'0

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    38/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    39/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    40/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    41/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    42/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    43/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    44/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    45/84

    "##$%&'( )"#$%&'( )*+, -(& ./'0%' "''$2 3 4456

    789*#: -; ?

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    46/84

    1st Executive Meeting Indonesia ICT Consultative ForumApril 1 st , 2014

    Welcoming Remarks

    Luky Eko Wuryanto, Deputy Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Planning,Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs (CMEA)

    ! Opened the forum, encouraging the sharing of perspectives, the involvement ofhigher officials and focused on outcomes that will result in concreteimprovements

    Alex Feldman, President, US-ASEAN Business Council (USABC)

    USABC looks forward to an ongoing and long-term programme. Indonesia is one of thetop five countries when it comes to tech use, including mobile technology, Facebook, andTwitter. The Indonesia ICT Consultative Forum aims to spur ICT in industry inIndonesia, as well as connect Indonesia to opportunities outside the country.

    2014 is a big year:! The Councils 30 th anniversary! Indonesias Parliamentary Elections! USABC is launching ASEAN Matters for America and American Matters

    for ASEAN! USABCs CEO Mission to Vietnam and the Philippines, where CEOs will

    meet with the President and members of cabinet and leaders of businesscommunity. This follows a CEO Mission in 2013 to Indonesia andMalaysia.

    Indonesia is half the population of SE Asia and more than half of its economicactivity. As economic activity continues, ICT will play a critical role in growthand Indo nesias success. Getting policies right is critical to ensuring people

    benefit and growth continues across the world. There are opportunities in theregion, as demonstrated through entrepreneurs in the region making headlinesthrough development of apps and games that are becoming some of the most

    popular in the world. Indonesia has a lot to gain in this sector, and there is greatexcitement for this new collaborative platform.

    Presentation on IICF Concept & Plan

    Eddy Satriya, Deputy Assistant for ICT and Utility, CMEA

    Purpose

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    47/84

    The Indonesia ICT Consultative Forum (IICF), an initiative started by the US-ASEANBusiness Councils ICT Committee and Coordinating Ministry of Economic Affairs aimsto create a collaborative platform between government and industry to supportIndonesias long -term policy of building a local ICT industry and toward fulfillment of ashared goal of creating an innovation and knowledge-based economy in Indonesia.Currently, every ministry has their own pilot projects involving ICT applications, thusthese experiences can be shared and learned from. The Forum will also serve to improvemutual understanding in the areas of innovation, investment and regulation and will assistin the development of future ICT policy in Indonesia.

    He welcomes comments on the draft decree and proposes that the forum name IICF canstill change.

    Implementation

    Several objectives of the work streams include reducing coordination issues and providing timely information before policies are made. In addition, they can be used to promote local ICT industries.

    Structure

    The forum will be comprised of a "#$%&' ())%*%+, -&..%//## %$*,01%$2 '#3'#4#$/+/%5#4)'&. /6# 7&5#'$.#$/ &) 8$1&$#4%+9 +4 :#,, +4 /6# ;"#6&,1#'4?@6# "#$%&' ())%*%+, -&..%//## :%,, '#3&'/ )%$1%$24 /& /6# '#,#5+$/ A%$%4/#'4 &$*0''#$/ 8-@ %440#4 +4 %1#$/%)%#1 BC /6# DE#*0/%5# -&..%//##? ;$1#' /6# "#$%&'

    ())%*%+, -&..%//## %4 /6# DE#*0/%5# -&..%//## :6%*6 :%,, B# ,#1 BC *&F*6+%'4 )'&.;"

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    48/84

    Key purpose of the IICF is to ensure greater predictability , so that companies cansee where the government is coming from and how the business community canhelp meet the common objective of a vibrant ICT sector in Indonesia.

    Shared objectives Government and companies want the same thing a vibrantICT sector. IICF envisions working toward shared objectives, not as individualcompanies or ministries, but as thought leaders toward development of aninnovative, knowledge based community with local ICT industry development asan enabler to achieving this goal.

    Workstreams Workstreams are tools to discuss relevant issues in depth andserve as a starting pointing. Given that this is a consultative forum, the scope isopen and subject to change. Identified work streams are:

    ! Emerging Digital Trends The transformational nature of ICT is anenabler for economic growth. This includes new areas like: cloudcomputing and analytics, as well as others new styles of IT. These newtrends need to be understood and regulatory frameworks need to bealigned with the new trends, thus providing an environment to expand

    business and create a knowledge base. To be led by Microsoft andQualcomm.

    ! Incentivizing Localization This workstream looks at how to increaseinvestment interest. There is a need to level playing field and remove

    barriers, but also incentives need to be in place encourage investments. Inturn, greater ICT investment leads to job creation. To be led by Intel.

    ! Regulatory Insights Initially, regulatory framework changes triggeredthe need for forum. IICF wants to understand challenges and lookingforward to share best practices from other countries who are also creatinga domestic ICT industry. This information exchange helps addressIndonesia s needs and allows companies to be more effective. To be led

    by Google.

    Outcomes - Today is an outcome. At a minimum, the outcome IICF hopes toachieve are regular dialogues to minimize surprise. Such that if newregulations come up, there is a chance for consultation to allow companies to

    prepare operations to remain in compliance of the new policies. Beyondsharing of information, there can be a sharing of best practices anddevelopment of a roadmap toward the vision to create a knowledge base.

    "#$%&'$# ()&* +,,- ./0)1-/2 3#%40- 5$$1$0/'0 (&) 678 /', 901:10-2 7;+5

    Last September during USABCs ICT Business Mission to Indonesia this Forum was)%'4/ *&$*#%5#1 %$ &'1#' /& *'#+/# + '&B04/ 8-@ #*&4C4/#.?

    Predictability A win -win can be established using the input of governmentlocal incentives, timely regulation and using the expertise of companies.

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    49/84

    Outcomes: In addition to reporting our findings from the work streams, weshould consider other measures of success including other metrics or mediainvolvement.

    Participation : Attendees ideas and interaction are welcome. Questions toconsider: Which workstream is of most value? What topics would you like tohear from experts about?

    Work stream leaders presentation on objectives & plan s

    Emerging Digital Trends - Ruben Hattari (Microsoft) and Nies Purwati (Qualcomm) Purpose: Provide updates to stakeholders on global industry trends;

    international best practices; case studies; government policies for long termgrowth in the ICT sector.

    Cloud technology: how it can help government and businesses, like SMEs.! Used in healthcare, politics and education to improve the sectors! Important for SMEs in Indonesia given their desire for flexibility,

    collaboration, mobility and low costs. Also, considering around 90%of industries in Indonesia are SME, this amounts to a large number ofcompanies.

    ! Broadband connectivity is difficult given Indonesias large anddispersed geography/size, particularly in Eastern Indonesia whereconnectivity is needed.

    Concerns: cyber security, online privacy Potential technology, such as smart cities and smart phones, will be discussed

    in this workstream, as well as policy challenges that new technology creates.

    Incentivizing Localization, Deva Rachman (Intel) Local demand - The education sector has the biggest need for ICT industry Local government needs to add input but also the upcoming new government

    [national election coming up] requires leadership in this area as localizationneeds to be in line with Medium Term National Plan 2019.

    Regulatory Insights, Shinto Nugroho (Google) Regulatory insight Government needs to be in dialogue with private sector

    as another source of information on how to make regulations that willcontinue to create jobs and opportunities. Companies can share their good and

    bad experiences in regards to the impact regulations had on the ICT sector. Timeliness Government needs robust regulations to help Indonesia build

    human resources to increase competitiveness.

    Q & A

    Suggestion that high-level meetings be moved forward to allowrecommendations for ICT industry to be put forward for the incominggovernment and ask for chance to present to the new leadership.

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    50/84

    Presentation: Cloud Computing and Its Impact on Our LivesSpeaker: Tony Seno Hartono, National Technology Officer, Microsoft

    Key points

    Cloud computing touches all aspects of our life social, economic, political,healthcare

    Cloud technology provides choices Private, Public, Hybrid (Public/Private)and Community clouds exist. Each option provides a different level of

    privacy.! Clouds allow for automization, massive scalability and connectivity,

    which is relevant given Indone sias size/population/ dispersed islands.Therefore, the Indonesia government should create positive policies forcloud computing given these important benefits.

    ! Allow software developers to use the online market to download and getrevenue, or regional governments with no infrastructure to manageinfrastructure using eservices.

    ISO 31,000 Risk Management framework can help make decisions about public/private cloud and when to use each. Some require services on premise,others off-premise or some in-between.

    Need to have back-up/baskets depending on expected service level agreement(SLA) and solutions need to be designed accordingly.

    Digital trends in Indonesia

    Young demographic in Indonesia - 54 million students = cloud computingopportunity.

    Population growth will increase internet use, particularly the 12-34 year oldsusers who are often with a higher education.

    Growth is primarily in mobile phones High social media use. Opportunities for cloud computing in education, healthcare, and politics Shared responsibility - Government and citizens working together provide

    highest ROI thus internet access should be shared responsibility betweengovernment and citizens.

    Challenge of internet connectivity! TV Band White Spaces Use unused frequency spectrum of TV for

    data ! Potential to provide all citizens with free internet access to equalize

    access The power of cloud computing to transform government services such as

    healthcare and education. Thus, we should maximize benefits of cloudcomputing.

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    51/84

    Open Discussion

    "#/: ,#*/',

    A%$%4/'C &) 8$104/'C H&*04#4 &$ 4/+'/F03 *&.3+$%#4 %$ 8-@ Asks how to collaborate between the government and private sector on ICT

    issues. Proposes for next meetings:

    ! Look at how ICT has increased investment in Indonesia! Look at how to grow the local ICT industry. The benefits of cloud

    computing are known but the ministry struggles with how to support ICTgrowth and grab the local market.

    ! Proposes looking at practices to grow local ICT industry in other countries looking at bad practices and also incentives needed to support ICT.

    Workstream on incentivizing localization will address the creation of localdemand and will bring best practices, case studies . (i.e. Vietnam). These casestudies will be from closer to Indonesia and other emerging economies.

    .#>4)10-

    Concerns expressed regarding data security with cloud computing. Point of viewthat certain data may be considered strategic thus making data security and

    protection very important.

    Security and privacy are important issues that must be addressed. However, this isa period of transitioning from data in a physical way to where data is on the cloud.There are different levels of data security and privacy such that government datais different and private. Today, d ata doesnt have boundaries such that data is anew form of currency. We need to think that data is accessible globally by banks

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    52/84

    or enterprises and need to maximize this digital economy, particularly to the benefit of SMEs to facilitate turning them into global players.

    Financing / SMEs

    Local industry needs to be supported, especially in ICT because it is hard forstart-ups to get funding from banking institutions. Start-ups usually get fundingfrom venture capital firms and telcos.

    Investment is needed but also there are lots of SMEs who need coordination underMinistry of Industry and Communication. In this context, the ministry isconcerned about security but cannot avoid new technologies so instead requireassistance for training and education . Ministry is challenged by all the newconcerns and balancing the need for technology with the need to comply tolegislative measures because this is the way forward.

    Financial services

    Bank of Indonesia Recommends inviting Indonesia Financial Authority (OJK) to joinIICF

    Regulates non-banks and banks. Given cross-over with financial services, Financial Services Committee should

    also be included.

    Infrastructure requirements

    KOMINFO There is a need for a responsive regulatory environment and askswhat this new environment would look like. But also raises concern on whatinfrastructure is needed and the funding required ; what infrastructure is needed toensure is internet free and once it is built how to maintain good qualityinfrastructure and continuity of infrastructure operators .

    Need to collaborate with other systems like transport and logistics. However, itsalso important to consider the soft infrastructure i.e. human capital. Hard andsoft infrastructure are both needed. There is currently US government support forentrepreneurship support in Indonesia such that companies can help withtraining, entrepreneurship, and promotion of hackathons in tech space.

    Discussion of IICF Next Steps

    Workstream leaders will make respective work plans. Companies are encouragedto sign u p, if they havent already . Also, there is a need to reach each out todifferent agencies so these meetings can be taking place on a regular workinglevel.

    There is a need for case studies, experts and guest speakers to share moreinformation on this ICT transition in Indonesia.

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    53/84

    Appendix

    Resources

    Presentation: IICF Concept & Plan

    Draft decree

    Presentation: Cloud Computing and its Impact on Economy

    ASEAN Matters for America report

    Partners in Prosperity: US Investment in Indonesia

    Attendees

    GOI

    Luky Eko Wuryanto, Deputy Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Planning,CMEA

    Eddy Satriya, Deputy Assistant for ICT and Utility, CMEA Coordinating Ministry for Politics, Law and Security Ministry of Industry Ministry of Trade Fiscal Policy Agency, Ministry of Finance Ministry of Communication and Informatics Bank of Indonesia BKPM Ministry of Tourism and Creative Economy

    Partners

    Didie Soewondho, Vice Chairman of Telecommunication, InformationTechnology and Broadcasting, KADIN

    Eddy Thoyib, Executive Director, MASTEL Andrew White, Managing Director, AmCham Indonesia

    Sri Lakkundi, ICT Committee Co-Chair, AmCham Indonesia Jim Caruso, Economic Counselor, US Embassy Phil Nervig, Economic Officer, US Embassy

    USABC Members

    Nazrya Octora, Associate Consultant, APCO Worldwide Seow Hiong Goh, Executive Director, Global Policy & Government Affairs,

    Cisco Systems

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    54/84

    Satria Gunayoman, Consultant, Cisco Systems - HD Asia Advisory Shinto Nugroho, Head of Public Policy and Government Relations, Google

    Indonesia Agung Yudhawiranata, Analyst - Public Policy & Government Relations, Google

    Indonesia Suren Velappu , Director of Corporate Affairs, South East Asia, Hewlett-Packard Elizabeth Hernandez, Vice President of Corporate Affairs, Asia Pacific Japan,

    Hewlett-Packard Ananta Gondomono, Governmental Programs Lead Indonesia, IBM Darryn Lim, Director, Trade and Innovation Policy, Microsoft Nies Purwati, Director of Government Affairs Indonesia, QUALCOMM Claudia Chan, Head of Government Relations, Asia Pacific and Japan, Seagate

    Ruben Hattari, Director of Corporate Affairs-Indonesia, Microsoft Tony Seno, National Technology Officer, Microsoft Deva Rachman, Corporate Affairs Director, Intel Indonesia Corporation Arnold Djiwatampu, Motorola Solutions Alexander Feldman, President, US-ASEAN Business Council Kathy Santillo, Regional Managing Director, US-ASEAN Business Council Desi Indrimayutri, Senior Country Representative, US-ASEAN Business Council Shay Wester, Manager, US-ASEAN Business Council Caroline Tanjaya, Country Representative, US-ASEAN Business Council

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    55/84

    "##$%&'( )"#$%&'( )*+, -$. /0'1%' "''$3 4 5567

    89%$' -:; -

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    56/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    57/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    58/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    59/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    60/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    61/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    62/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    63/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    64/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    65/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    66/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    67/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    68/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    69/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    70/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    71/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    72/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    73/84

    "##$%&'( &"#$%&'( )*+, -*. /0'1%' "''$3 4 5567

    891&+:'* ;< ;=>?@

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    74/84

    !"#$% '(%)(*+#, '-! -)(+./0,0#1* 2)$.3 4''-25 6#(.0*+"#$%&'()* +,-./0% 1* 123456 7(%%8.--* 56 700-89: ;09-0% 0? 1@

    -)7-",#$*% 89: A'') B(-%8)(* C0D$-) E&&8&-(9- F.% G;" (9' H-8?8-)* ;7AE B$%%09'%09 I0?(DD$* C8%0,-.% .F ;.%D.%(-0 EFF(8%& F.% EBAEJ* KL 0%9N09-R

    */,??. 4@A5 "#0 GG;Q 8& (9 8ND.%-(9- D?(-F.%N F.% :.>0%9N09- (9' 89'$&-%) -. '0>0?.D ( N$-$(? $9'0%&-(9'89:

    89 -#0 (%0(& .F 899.>(-8.9* 89>0&-N09-* (9' %0:$?(-8.9V T#8,# 8& ,%8-8,(? 89 (,#80>89: -#0 (%0'./W0,-8>0 .F /$8?'89: (9 899.>(-8>0* P9.T?0':0S/(&0' 0,.9.N) 89 G9'.90&8(R

    "#8& 8& -#0 -#8%' .$- .F F.$% F.%$N& -. /0 #0?' -#8& )0(%R "#0 D%0>8.$& &0&&8.9& #(>0 /009 >(?$(/?0-. .$% G;" ,.NN8--00 N0N/0%&* (9' T0 /0?80>0* F.% -#0 X.>0%9N09- .F G9'.90&8( (& T0??R 60 ?..PF.%T(%' -. ,.N89: /(,P 89 C0,0N/0% F.% -#0 F89(? F.%$N F.% -#8& )0(%R

    Our last session addressed the governments cyber security concerns and several private sector0UD0%-& (%0' 0U8&-89: &.?$-8.9& F.% '(-( D%.-0,-8.9* ,?.$' &0,$%8-)* &0,$%89: .9?890 /(9P89:-%(9&(,-8.9&* (9' F%($' D%0>09-8.9R "#0 :.> ernment officials sharing of regulatory measuresintended to safeguard cyber security furthered private sectors understanding of certain%0:$?(-8.9&R

    In todays third IICF meeting, we hope to continue this constructive discussion about the'0>0?.DN09- .F F$-$%0 G;" D.?8,) 89 G9'.90&8(* D(%-8,$?(%?) 89 (%0(& .F 0S,.NN0%,0 (9' D%.N.-89:-%('0 (9' 89>0&-N09-R

    In todays forum, we hope to accomplish the following outcomes:8@ B#(%89: .F /0&- D%(,-8,0& (9' 8'09-8F)89: ,$%%09- /(%%80%& (9' .DD.%-$98-80& -. D%.N.-0

    G;" '0>0?.DN09-88@ G'09-8F) .DD.%-$98-80& F.% D$/?8,SD%8>(-0 D(%-90%D& -. (''%0&& :(D& (9' ,#(??09:0& 89

    -#0 89'$&-%)888@ C0-0%N890 F$-$%0 (%0(& .F T.%P (9' %0&0(%,# -#(- T8?? /0 $&0F$? 89 '0>0?.D89: D.?8,)

    89D$-& F.% -#0 89,.N89: 90T ('N898&-%(-8.9

    I8&8.9 of Indonesias ICT Ecosystem ! #$ /539(1&3* :2;5+ ,09 /) -0,#9.?.:)* -#0 G;" (%09( 8& ')9(N8, (9' ,#(9:0& %(D8'?)R "#8& 90,0&&8-(-0& ,.9&-(9-'8(?.:$0 /0-T009 :.>0%9N09- &-(P0#.?'0%& (9' D%8>(-0 &0,-.% %0D%0&09-(-8>0&V (9' N.%0 D?(-F.%N&F.% '8&,$&&8.9* &$,# (& -#0 GG;Q* (%0 900'0'R

    E %./$&- G;" A,.&)&-0N ,.ND%8&0& .F -#%00 P0) D8??(%&Y

    8@ G9F%(&-%$,-$%0

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    75/84

    "#$%&'%(& )* % +,- ,(%'.,# $/ 01, 234 )(&5*0#-6 35##,(0.-7 2(&$(,*)% $(.- 1%* 89:;< $/*=,>0#5? %..$>%0,& /$# @)#,.,** '#$%&'%(&6 A)01 B $=,#%0$#* )( 2(&$(,*)% %(& .)?)0,&'%(&@)&01 %C%).%'.,7 ?$#, *=,>0#5? (,,&* 0$ ', %..$>%0,& /$# '#$%&'%(& 0$%>>$??$&%0, 01, /$#,>%*0,& )(>#,%*, )( &,?%(&6

    ;%C)(D % #,D5.%0$#- =.%0/$#? 01%0 %..$@* 01, %>>,.,#%0)$( $/ 234 )(/#%*0#5>05#,&,C,.$=?,(0 )* ,**,(0)%.6

    ))E F%-?,(0 G-*0,?* F%-?,(0 *-*0,?* D$ ',-$(& ?$')., *,#C)>,* %(& ,C,( $//,# C$5>1,#*6 H( $=,#%0$# *5>1

    %* 2(&$*%0 1%* I897999 =%-?,(0 $50.,0* 01%0 =#$C)&, ,(0#- %(& ,J)0 =$)(0* /$# ?$(,-7015* ?%+)(D =,$=., ?$#, '%(+%'.,6

    2( 0,#?* $/ ?$')., ?$ ney, Indosats view is that it sho 5.& ', % 0#%(*)0)$( 0$ '%(+=%-?,(06 H .)?)0 $/ KGL 899 *1$5.& ', )?=$*,& $( ?$')., ?$(,-7 %(& ',-$(& 01%0 *5?7=,$=., (,,& 0$ C)*)0 % '%(+6 ;$@,C,#7 >1%..,(D,* #,?%)( )( ?%)(0%)()(D >$(0#$.6

    A)01 2(&$(,*)%(* %.#,%&- 50).)$??,#>, )(&5*0#-6 35##,(0.-7 01#,, .%#D, $=,#%0$#*

    1%C, ?$')., =#$&5>0* %(& @, &$ ($0 5(&,#*0%(& @1- @, *1$5.& ', >$?=,0)(D @)01'%(+* 01%0 1%C, $01,# *,#C)>, $//,#)(D*7 @1)>1 %#, %.*$ %@%#&,& @)01 ?$')., .)>,(*,*6

    )))E 3$(0,(0 %(& 2(C,*0?,(0 L,C,.$=,#* %#, % +,- %*=,>0 $/ 01, ,>$*-*0,? %(& 01,)# *+)..* %#, %.#,%&- ',)(D ,J=$#0,&

    '- 2(&$(,*)%6 2(C,*0?,(0 )* %.*$ >#5>)%. %(& 1%C)(D %(D,. )(C,*0$#* %(& )(>5'%0$#* %#, (,>,**%#- 0$

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

    2(&$*%0 %(& G$/0'%(+ 1%C, %.*$ >$..%'$#%0,& 0$ *,0 5= % /5(& 01%0 =#$C)&,* >$?=%(),*@)01 >%=)0%.6 ;$@,C,#7 @, /$5(& )0 &)//)>5.0 0$ /)(& *0%#05=* 01%0 %#, #,%&- /$# )(C,*0?,(06

    ! # $

    2(&$*0%0 1%* 0@$ .)(,* $/ *,#C)>,S >,..5.%# %(& /)J,&6 T)J,& *,#C)>,* %#, 5*5%..- $//,#,& 0$ >$#=$#%0,*%(& .%#D,# G:U*6 4$ ?- +($@.,&D,7 2(&$*%0 )* 01, $(.- $=,#%0$# 01%0 )* =5*1)(D /$# 01, G:U*,D?,(06 ;$@,C,#7 01,#, %#, >1%..,(D,* )( =#$C)&)(D *,#C)>,* 0$ *?%..,# G:U* &5, 0$ 01, /)(, .)(,',0@,,( 01,? %(& 01, 1)D1 ,(& >$(*5?,# ?%#+,06

    While Indonesias high smart phone p ,(,0#%0)$( VI8WE $//,#* $==$#05()0-7 )0 )* &)//)>5.0 0$&,?$(*0#%0, )0* C%.5, 0$ G:U*6 41, D$C,#(?,(0 %(& =#)C%0, *,>0$# *,, 01, $==$#05()0- /$# G:U*)( =#$C)&)(D 5*,/5. %==.)>%0)$(* *5>1 %* '%(+)(D *,#C)>,*6 UC,( 01$5D1 01, >5##,(0 #%0, $/ G:UD#$@01 )* ($0 )&,%. VXMRWE7 )0 )* *0).. 1)D1,# 01%( >$(*5?,# D#$@01 VYWE6 35##,(0.-7 01,#, %#, ?%(-%==.)>%0)$(* ',)(D $//,#,&7 1$@,C,# 01, ,&5>%0)$( =#$>,** )* 0)?,M>$(*5?)(D %(& @, (,,& 0$

    31%( Z$+ [$(D V)&UH\)F%-]]ES (, $/ 01, +,- )C,#* $/ ,M>$??,#>, D#$@01 )( HGUH_ >$5(0#),* %#,G:U*6 ;$@,C,#7 )( 2(&$(,*)%7 01,#, )* ($ /$#?%.)$?=%(),* .)+,H==., %(& N$$D.,7 @1)>1 =#$C)&, ,**,(0)%. *5==$#0 )( 0,#?* $/ )(/#%*0#5>05#, %(&0,.,>$??5()>%0)$(*6 ;$@ &$,* 2(&$*%0 .)(+ @)01 G:U* 0$ *5==$#0 01,?`

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    76/84

    "#$%&'& " #(%)%#"* +",,- ./ )$%, "(&"0 )$& 12'&(/+&/) "/3 4"/5, $"'& 4&&/ $&*6%/1 47 288&(%/1,+"**&( ,%9&3 *2"/,-

    :& )2)"**7 3%,"1(&& ;%)$ )$& governments 6(262,"* )2 .- :$&/ " 6$2/& %, 3&*%'&(&30)$&2(&)%#"**70 %) ,$2. /

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    77/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    78/84

    Discussion 1: Supporting Indonesias e !"#$$%&'% )*&+%, !"#$%#&'( *&+, -$.$& /0$'1#&2$&3 *+34+#',$5043#&$1#3 67( !8,+14 9:;&484 /

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    79/84

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    80/84

    "#$$%&'()*+ ',%-% &,)#./ 0% 1)/#.%& 2)- "34 %/#56'()* )* %75)11%-5%8

    !"#$%& ()*+&"& ,-&&*./0 9)&&(0.% 5)..60)-6'()* )* "34 %/#56'()* )* %75)11%-5% :(', ',% "34 ;#&(*%&& "AGL 0(..()* )2 (*C%&'1%*' :%*' ') ',% @?D &%5')- )2 "AG8H'-(..()* 16-T%' )NN)-'#*('= 2-)1 ',% $-):(*$ 1(//.% 5.6&&8 D,%-% :(.. 0% MF 1(..()* 6//('()*6.5)*%-& (* EFHF8 @*/)*%&(6* 5)*%-& 6.&) ,6C% ',% ,($,%&' 5)*%- 5)*2(/%*5% (*/%U 61)*$

    ',% VEF 5)#*'-(%&8 @*/)*%&(6 (& ',% 1)&' N-)1(&(*$ 5)#*'-= 2)- )C%-&%6& 0#&(*%&& 655)-/(*$ ') ',%R6N6* ;6*T 2)- @*'%-*6'()*6. ?))N%-6'()* "#-C%= EFGH8

    9))- (*2-6&'-#5'#-% -%16(*& 6 5,6..%*$% 0#' ',%-% ,6& 0%%* N-)$-%&& ',-)#$, N-)$-61& .(T% [email protected] W(*$P %'58

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    81/84

    taxes or other taxes on connection, other special taxes, for example tax on mobile operators gross"#$#%'(

    )% *+,,- . '/&01 2% ,,, 34&%/"2#' '546#0 /5./ /5# 7"474"/24% 48 94/.: ;4'/ 48 6%#"'527?9;@ .334&%/#0 84" =1 /.A 5.0 2%3"#.'#0 to an average of 18.11% (Deloitte/GSMA 2011, GlobalMobile Tax Review). Handset costs act as a barrier to the benefits of mobile usage and taxes34%'/2/&/#0 *BC 48 /52' 34'/ 4% .$#".D#( )% #:#$#% 34&%/"2#'- /.A 34%'/2/&/#0 4$#" E+C 48 /5# 5.%0'#/34'/(

    I%04%#'2. 3&""#%/:1 5.' B,F G2::24% G4=2:# 34%%#3/24%'- *H(BC 48 65235 ."# G4=2:# ="4.0=.%0( I2/5/5# "2D5/ "#D&:./24%' 2% 7:.3#- 6# #A7#3/ G4=2:# ="4.0=.%0 /4 .334&%/ 84" F+(BC 48 . /4/.: 48 EBJG2::24% 34%%#3/24%' ?KL%3# . 7"40&3/ =#."2%D /5# ;] G."V2%D 2' 7:.3#0 2% /5# ]^G."V#/- G#G=#" '/./#' '5.:: %4/ 7"452=2/- "#'/"23/ 4" 2G7#0# /5# 7:.3#G#%/ 48 /52' 7"40&3/ 4" '#"$23#

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    82/84

    "# $%&"' ()'*&$ +' $&''"$+',- .'+/01$2 3&)'"#4 56 ()'* 1)##+$ 3& 2$+77&/ )$ 102$+(2 )#/ 1)# 8'&&9,$'):&9 "#$+ $%& 6; )#/ ()'*&$ 20':&"99)#1& )#/ ()'*&$ +'1&($ "2 $%&'&27+#2"3"9"$, +8 &)1% (&(3&' 2$)$&- ?)'*&$ @0':&"99)#1& A0$%+'"$"&2 /+ ')#/+( 1+(79")#1& 1%&1*2ABC6D 7'+/01$2 )'& )9'&)/, 79)1&/ +# $%& ()'*&$- C%"2 "2 +77+2"$& $+ ) $,7"1)9 )77'+:)9 '&4"(& )2

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    83/84

    "#$#% &'()*+ ,-./0 " #$%&'()&$( *+,,+-' (.& )/01&(2 3' ,+$4 /' / )/01&( 5/$ 6& 50&/(&7 8$ /$9 :/0( +* #$7+$&'8/;8$%&'()&$( -8,, 5+)&2 ' (+ ./%& 5+,,/6+0/(8+$-8(. 7+)&'(85 780&5( 8$%&'(+0' 8$ (.& &F5+))&05& 6?'8$&''2 3( (.& )+)&$( (.& 4+%&0$)&$( 8' '(8,,6?8,78$4 (.& 0&/78$&'' +* #$7+$&'8/$ &F5+))&05& 6?'8$&'' :,/9&0'2

    3$+(.&0 &G/):,& 8' (.& /$8)/(8+$ '&5(+02 #( 8' 5,+'&7 ?$(8, #$7+$&'8/ ./' (.& &G:&0(8'& /$7 (.& (/,&$('8$ /$8)/(8+$ (+ )/1& '?0& (./( ,+5/, :,/9&0' '(8,, ./%& (.& +::+0(?$8(9 (+ 7&%&,+: (.& '&5(+02

    2($34 5#%% ,67081 E,&/0,9 (.& 8):/5( +* 5,+'8$4 '&5(+0 ,81& &F5+))&05& 8$ (.& J&4/(8%& #$%&'()&$( K8'( 8' $&4/(8%&2

    34?$4 L?7./-80/$/(/ MN++4,& #$7+$&'8/"O HI# /0& *+5?'&7 8$ =/%/2 #' (.&0& /$9 :0+40/) +0 :,/$*0+) CBAD (+ .&,: ':0&/7 (.& HI#P

    A.8, J&0%84 MQ@ >)6/''9"O

  • 8/9/2019 IICFReport AppendixA-D-Final 10Dec Web

    84/84

    !"#"$ &'()*+ ,-./01 "#$% &' ()*+, -.+ /00,*&)1-&)2 %&)&'-,3 40, 560)07&6 8441&,'9 :.+,+ 1,+ &)-+,;7&)&'-+,&1< 7++-&)2'-0 *&'6('' =('&)+'' '+6-0,' -0 =+ 0>+)+* 0, 616-' -0 -.++60)073 04 @)*0)+'&19 :+,0-+6- 0(, >+0>1)&+' -.1- A1)- -0 -1D+ >1,- &) -.+ *&'6(''&0) 0) -.+ &7>>0,-1)- &' .1?&)2 1 '-1=