ii-ie oofd 2ivmdvi d vi4d the - nber...1".atflsvs rluoilt1a ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu...

45
!qqM © UOCC 12 AGU O iJJC 2OflLCC cxcccq jnn JxrwL&bp urnA pc drrnfcq itrporij cxbjicrj bctmiaarou bLoAIqcq jjrn ij cLcqu © JÔÔX P' 11SIA E!CPGUELGGU miq LG4GL J,GUJIU l'Jj LIJJ2 LcacLAcq apoc 2CC4OU2 OjtGxe IJOt W flflG&R 01.E00U0m!G KC2CCW yioucwA yuA obiu oua cxbLcaacq w° oijpc SflWoi2 uq uo oIjJJc J4&pou&j JJ112 LLCL LU14 OJ,J4BEJc,2 LC2C9LCJJ bLoJrnn2 TU W© DCACIOLWGU{ opc yuJcLTc9u pcououA &uq .lmJG Toa, swpuqc qy osn T 020 j&aacprracua VACUJIG MVIIOI4VF BflKEVfl OL ECOI4O1AIIC JEEVI{GH ftOLJC!U MJDCL QØQØ LGCL LGIH!IJ WIIA E!CPGULCCU GJFVL II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVID VI4D tHE J4BEK /AOK}C1140 WEEK 2E11E2

Upload: others

Post on 28-Nov-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

!qqM © UOCC 12 AGU O iJJC 2OflLCCcxcccq jnn JxrwL&bp urnA pc drrnfcq itrporij cxbjicrj bctmiaarou bLoAIqcq jjrn ij cLcqu© JÔÔX P' 11SIA E!CPGUELGGU miq LG4GL J,GUJIU l'Jj LIJJ2 LcacLAcq apoc 2CC4OU2 OjtGxe IJOt W

flflG&R 01.E00U0m!G KC2CCWyioucwA yuA obiu oua cxbLcaacq w° oijpc SflWoi2 uq uo oIjJJc J4&pou&j

JJ112 LLCL LU14 OJ,J4BEJc,2 LC2C9LCJJ bLoJrnn2 TU W© DCACIOLWGU{ opc yuJcLTc9u pcououA &uq

.lmJG Toa,swpuqc qy osn

T020 j&aacprracuaVACUJIG

MVIIOI4VF BflKEVfl OL ECOI4O1AIIC J�EEVI{GH

ftOLJC!U MJDCL QØQØ

LGCL LGIH!IJ

WIIA E!CPGULCCU

GJ�FVLII-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI�D VI4D tHE

J4BEK /AOK}C1140 WEEK 2E1�1E2

Page 2: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

cicpcuLccowpcI.JccJcAtqn bituJuuqccqnMBEK 14BEK

cv ôfl02 &upqqc yjy Ø3J3503 miibcto 3C1.L& Jt{&22CJJfl2CU2 JU2!WfC 1PJJOfl

UI flCJNATOL&J 3CTCUCG2 KOOW E3-380VCUfcL OL qA9Uccq IiqX cbqmcuf OLECOIJOUJTC28g)E!CPcULccU Bc1

jJG /Aoqq !U0 mc Of DCbLC22!0U

uq IJuEqjA qcjpjcq pA urnaa boprica pn oujA rjc pG Jufcwcpou u[, uuouj boJrc!ca jmq CJL&MJJ

ccouowA if tta CXBLcaacq 9lJq LcUT,oLCcq pA iJJC qiaconac SUJOU W jc&qcta if M92 obboacq

w we wcujujiç) opc ojq awuqtq ma bcu&aiAc &ucj coubcjjiu iO WC jc&qCLa OjjjJC!u{tLt/

qocnwcutcq cjacmpcte pn ou c LC2OIJ2 ityX LojicA UJ&ICCL2 opoac mc bopcica ipeA q!T ffiC

uOj IOCf12 ou flJG GIj,cCt2 oI. c ojq at&uqm:q '' tp DebLcaa!ou tAJJ!CJJ AC miq OfJJCL2 JflAC

ccuinj psujca.a coupuneg w sqpctc io w ojq JqgT.cj gajpc Q'. DCbLa!OU !'u"!uq ffiG qo

1P! b&bcLa mAl gGU buuisujA J9L pTa{ousua agcmbf a o cxhjrnu MJJA boppc9 jc&qcta uq

vIaLIcvc1

&uq vioucinA E00U0w!caDGAGJ0bUJCTU OJfJJG VUJGUCU pCOUOUJA

'inuc JooxT4BEJ� //O4CUJ bbcL J40 QOQO

ETcpcJJLccU uq bCi jcuJ!ujpc qq wuqq q w QLGS{ lJcbtcaa!ou

Page 3: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

noiaaoiqoU iseiD silt bus bisbnsta bloD silT

bsvloanu tssi silt Io sno an aOEQl sib lo noiaasqsb silt issil ol sun nos anshotaill

ti isrll nina d aiqot silt no Aood all anoqo ItfitinO niloL .'çwtno3 illO sill 1o asFista'm

bstnlsi tud stnmqsa lo isdmun stinilni tin to bsaoqmoo nonsmorisrlq sbiwbhow n

lo lnsmqolsvsb sib lb atosqas 'nsm bnntaisbnu ot minis ataimonoos rluoilt1A 1".atflsVs

tssi{I) sib iol noiiRnslqxs lnsisdoo n sbivcnq ot siulinl isrlt aoirnonoos 'çitioqmstnoo

aidT .aulnmqqs inutqsonoo risill lb anoiistimi! sill a'(niisd wsiv aiib ot nibrooon noiaasiqsCJ

silt iol noilnnniqxs tnstaianoo £ no ssrn ot noiaasloiq asimonoos silt lb 'ctilidnni sldianstao

sill lb asibuta inoholaiil lo eros silt In qs n asvnsl asmil nisbom lo istanaib otmonoos lnnia

sirnonoos lb atnsmintani sib lb noilu!ovs silt Insm'oIqmsnu aanm lb asonsupsanoo Isiooa

.taoW sib ni anansanos oi1oq inwlaoq sill lb sonogisms sib bus tnsmsgnnnm

bus aoimonoos iii qiilatsiorloa lo sinla silt lo anibnntaisbnuairn s a'nitsd wsiv alIT

atailniosqa nos auansanoo lo ssisb sidnthnmsi n alinvsiq won sisilT .'iotairl oiinonoos

nblhta ni betluasi anti qititinloilsa tnsos$I noiaasiqsCl tssrD silt lb asauno silt tuocln

nivsil as bs&mnasi sd nso swinish! rnsbom silt ;aiaho sib rol anoansi sib no tnsmssn

blo silt no asausol swtnishii tnrlT .noiaasiqsU Insif) silt lb slbbh sib bsvloa 'cllnitnntaclua

tnsiD silt otni rriutnwob aasniaud 'çinnibio tin bsrnut Izilt mainsrlosm sib an binbnnte

'(silt as ashtnuoo ninhamsd msta'(a bxnbnsta-blo silt lo atmntanoo silT £.noiaasiqsu

ot Issb tssig £ bsbbn Ion svsil atisqxs rnsbom" lnib ssq Ixon silt no bsbbn '(tnnn[) .E- .qq ô8Qi InnnD ".boohaisbnu ais'nsado [vjis-ioqmshnos} Isriw

.S2Q1 •nssignsrloiH ;Q8QI •nimsT ;aXQJ arlona bus nsoinsiloiH

I

Page 4: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

'oIoobi oil) bnA .yrnonooo bliow orb iii aonEr1z) ot aO$Q1 orb gnimb tqabs ot boIui1a

'1no tsr!) ano Os oAst ot aio!sm oi!oq ho! bisbnsla b1o orb lo oiiolorh hiss &tilfiJfIom

bhow orb Aobl ol bounilnos aio!nsd !sflnoD .eOEQ I orb ni aasi)aib Dimon000 bolrnJtn033s

.220fl2U0132i103 1201 Ii htnu nwob 25W ti oliriw 'rnonooo

ot isilimsl anoitsvorIrii Isoio1oborbom atoollsi 2u2fIOanOO won anD lath 51011 ougis oW

aosiasr!qmo noiaasiqeU isoiC) otft no omlsistil nisbom edT .alxotnoo isrbo mofi ansnolair!

naom ow 1ithtnom yd .otsta noilan orb lo oaqiloo orb baa ,aoiflloq aasni oawoaaib àfl1s)nom

-b!o OHT .oldiaaoq silt lo anobon iiorb boqarla iloidw ealo!sm 'i1oq 10 lea bnirn Isiooa edt

o!clsiiaob hiss oldiasol lo anoiiqoonoa aoiisioqmotnoo boqsda 11uhowoq tiIstnom bithnsta

'd bonislaisa bns bolsixo isno! on )srb bhow s rbiw oqoo oi beqolovoU .aoi3iIOq oirrlon030

tarnlanoa Isuloollolni air!) 1necnnobnsds ali bogsiuooaib lath) aemaaoiq Isanuloq bns !siooa

.orlqoiiastso oiirnon000 iol eldianoqasi 1htooiib 513W doxdw asanoqaoi '(oxIoq bsnwsqa

lo 'ti1ida orb botimil borsoqqua Ii anoitiflitani baa anoitos orb hiss 'ti1stnom air!T

110111 obsin lath aoioi!oq bodhoaoiq baa ttiaiovbs ot bnoqaoi ot alnscl Iwitnoo hiss atnorritnovog

blog hiss atiollob atnem'sq lo eons!sd ot oanoqaoi nI .iotlod lo bsstarii 0210W noitthnoo

lo Isog orb rhiw tibolo gnitoiilaoi monooo orb otaflob 1no bluoo atnomniovo aoaao!

sitU ol !soitnD .boiotaoi 25W oonslsd !snoxtsmolni litnu alaoo bins aeonq odsomob gniouboi

msdnofl .D3 aA .ataoo ni Inornolo Isogmi orb aogaw eouboi ol tiollo orb asw aeoooiq

I €21 ni gnibnalatobriu Isnoilnovnoo orb bosiwnrnua

!snoitsniotni rnolasi nso xior1t oisi ?lnsd iorhgirl orb io blog lo aaol silT"

as lnshoqrni isom orb oaodt 10 .aoonq Isrnotni gnioubsi 1(d 1no rnuiidiliupo .booubrn od 'sm modsi mail aomoOni iorbo bns aogsW .iuodal lo ooiiq or!)

hliw aior!to bins aiornso-ogsw bnsr! ono oril nO .toello olduob a ovsrh 111W air!T

aiaoo briar! ionic on!) nO .

atioqrni gnibuloni gnidtiovs no bnioqa oJ ass! avail

Page 5: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

od Iliw thoqml .2ontwbni tioqxs nibuloni oh1aubni Its ni booubo od Iliw E oormlsd oom oono 2wofl owl orb !ilriu bolsiumila atioqxo him bsloorlo

lo alo*mm ocisl bosi3ililoq him bomlomnia 'Iw1ias51oni or!) ni lull asw moldoiq omiT

ioclsl lo 1ibiufl silT .bsaaoaaoq oono 'oth ')ilidixofl oil) bstsl aosw bohoq mwiolni sri)

bus 2)0)1mm todsl Ismolni lo iIlwotg or!) inainoinu lo bsoiqa oil) 'd bolimil 2BW a)aoo

qinlanoilslot oil) ilhiw noi)sqiiooooiq lstons s bns ao)s)2 bolinU oil) Ni a)nomlrnqob Ionnonoq

bisbns)a-blo lsnoihnovnoo 3111 (102501 ahb oI .arotow iorl)o lo hull 0) osw asno lo

.oiolod as bo)sioqo tono1 on mainsnloom lnom)au[bs

lo Iiormnul orb ovloaoi 01 booillua ovsrl Ion )mlim '(fihidixofl lo alovol iswoiq novo mR

moflsq orb Hi aflida lsothst no boaoqmhoqua asw QQI ni Iooila 'isnoilsflob oilT .aOEQI oil)

Isnisixe tol a)aoo bns aooriq Ni aoRnsn!o oviansixo flnwpst alnomol)loa lsnioilsmolni lo

lo aaonauoioanoo orb ohsnonoq Jon bib arnoldotq sasH) oaso yns nI .boiolaox od oh eonslsd

lo 'Oilidaaivbs oil) noi)aoup at bsauIoi oilw liktnom btsbnsla-b!oR oil) o) noblorlod oaoill

.o)uoi 'xanoi)sI1ob oil) niuaiuq

bIos sill lo onolorb orb bns olsdob '(oiloq lo onolorfi oil) nsom ow oaiuooaib '1d

.)i1s1nom bisbns1a-bIo or!) nislaua bus rrriol o) boqisil saiuooaib ainiT .is!uoihisq ni bmbnsla

915W mainanloqomaoo bus 1ilids1a .'Cilidsiloi 11itn!1 lo aoithiv nsibtswbd bus nsiio)oiV omiT

him bslqioniiq Isiom anw blot) .ms)a'a 'osloniom orb lo ao)udhlls as llsu1ii boAovnii

orb bus rioiisflob 'd bovtoaotq asw tomiol omIT .oliaoqqo oil) tonom bosnsm ;bosilivio

oiio)oub airll .bosisaib "ato)sluooqa" '(mO .asgsw luo ol asw noimsiteb lo oitoloth

.'()ilidiltovnoo bIos 10 athom oil) noi)aoup bomb oilw oaoul) 10 a)nomugm sri) bosimi)iao!ob

.I-O.qq EQ1 rrmnlnisR

Page 6: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

orb him '(oiloq oxlduq iothsm Irnonsnil no iosqmi orb ot iooi eoitiloq aanM

.aoiilo !soiiiloq orb rmrb torbo aiolon lo oonouflrn him aobuiifls enobos orb lo iloaJi noiaaotqoCI

Jsrb is1uoitmq iii oaas1a niAiow orb him eV51302 lo atriornoa iorllo oaorb ni asw II

lsoii) orb oioha .aOEQ! orb iii ioVo boliod aoi3iloq him 'o1oobi bmhrmta-bIo 01 rioiliaoqqo

viol fisH 2oiE1 lasisirli beaist aAnsd 15111103 norfw tnocn'(olqmonu boiollua oily atotow orb mW

asw rnainoirw obsiT .bolirniI asw oairlontil silT .iIol anoilooldo tioth niAgm lo a'sw

wibhow oriT .oim1ni tiorb iii stew aoinzq todsi him iailsiooa .aobsil wol s ol boloitaot

.oup aulsia isionsriil orb ono11zrlo ol flosqto tsoinloq orb botsi aoaask)

niHoqrni {noiissinoinu niiuoorio 'ccl noilsulia airli borrnolanslt iW isoif) oriT

todsl him tai[siooa orb lo alooqaoiq Irnoloolo orb nivoiqmi him oairlOriSul sill lo aIIOIaiIOIXO

lsxooa orb bonovdua aoas1o nirnso him gnulaovni orb lo arioitiaoq orb ni Iuirla airiT .aoinsq

rorboriw ornil lath orb tol boks arobsol Isoiii!oq .aoioiloq bithrmla-b1o tswoiq lo aiasd

.'Vhuooa Isobiloq iiorb oriirmobnu ir1im oViJooTloa 'mnoi1nflob bmbnsla orb uo aoaob hoisoqth

orb nisiIids1aob 'ononuo orb grlisiliclElaob bsorxuoq to±mm orb ebolstia&ii 'oth oonO

rbiw brsbnsta b!o orb bnolob ol boon silT .'(rnonoos orb griisi!idsiaob him o3n onsnloxo

.3niaaotq olom orb us ornsood aoviisilini 'mnoiisllob

rithootd 'ccl noiaaoiqoU orb bolsvsrgz tsrb siuaasiq aas!o-nthow omsa orb lull

tol boon orb riiris1rlgiorl him oatuoo orb 's1a ol aaonrii1Iiw 'a1nomrnovo luods alduob

blog orb ol bobbow alsioillo norlW .oqsoao lo ansom orb hobivotq oals noilos 'mnobsllob

atorbo lo iovth 11 ooitIo lo mo moth bornul aiolov 4r1iI orb soa 03 boadtot 'oIoobi hrithnsla

orb rluonbls brsbns1a blo orb bonobnsds atobso! won oaorlT oup aulsia orb ol bobbow aaol

oitoiorb won orb sostdmo ot mnsioulsi bonismot tow 01 hsrl 'orb morlw rbiw. aioAnisd IstInso

Ix

Page 7: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

.noiisflsi to

thoitiloqoioo2 1o o3nshoqm! griiaseiorii silt naem ow eista noiin edt lo seqilos edt 'fl

txotnoo inS2elq orb nI .Isnoitsn edt risdt ierlto alevel ts gnitwisqo ziotosI OimOrlOasOiaOa bns

(n13M .mot' Isnoiismotrii silt lo noitsieqo silt no aiasdqme its iii noitoeflet abriil aidt

betinlJ orb ni atrieve ni noieetqeG edt lo aeauso edt trluoa evsd ataimonoce bits anthiotaid

edt betoe1en 'edt eausood 'iotos1ai1sa nsrlt 2251 nevotq sd doisee tiedT eetst2

nismob lznoitsmstni edt ni atneVe tsrlt tosl edt ai tsdt--qmula edt lo noianemib Isnoitsmetrii

otni bewol!cñ tsdt noiaaeoet 'cizriibio edt berinolanstt bits rnutnwob Q&Q1 edt icil e3sta edt tea

bits sJenom Isnoitsrnetni out lo griinoitornñ edt iii 'sl urieldmq edT t.noiaaeiqeb tseig s

ainemolitea Isrioitsrnetni lo rriettsq edt ni 2ensdo dtiw noitosietni ati ni bns mOta'(e Isionsilil

tostetiwoo ot bolith 2teAsm 'oi1oq sdw beiebnoq evsd anshotaill .1 isW bhoW cI tdgumw

trieoet ouT .ttiiovoa au betsvsis tosi ni loot 'orlt anoitos edt '(nw bns noiaaetqeU edt

betnoilnoo '(edt msta'(a Isnoitsirtetiti edt nsvi noitqo tedto on wsa edt tsdt awoda etutsief ii

.11 boweiv '(edt doidw duoirlt anol 1soio1oebi edt bits

.noiaaeiqeCl tsetD edt eouboiq ot tneioiThja asw enols. sebi eno tsdt Jteaas ton ob eW

'(nsm norns tnernele lsitneaae its ai bisbnsta b1o edt lo ui1stnem edt lsdt eum ow bsstariI

iii anoiludiitnoo auoivoiq iodteot aoit otoloiedt ewtstotil tnoo5l edT ziotosl nitudhtnoo

nsed noiaaeiqeU tseif) edt lo aiaiIsns inebom edT .'(tinu lsitneaae tiedt Isevet tsnlt asw

'(oiloq no betsxtneonoo '(edt aetst2 betinlJ edt tuods nithW ôyjfl3 bits nsmbohI dtiw

.EQQI iomo5I ;EQI !sflswnlo8 bits nsrnibehq

edt lo elm edt belovni aevleamedt EôQ1 •stiswdo2 bits nsrnbieR iots1 nislqxe ow aA .atneve oitaernob 1eiitne ito wool tnieisqqs iiedt etiqaeb bmbnsta blog

.EÔQI shswdoa bns nsmbeiiI

a

Page 8: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

.aoAsiairn as bosholonsrlo 'orll iloiriw mola'a onoao5l 1sioboI orb 'd riojlosm him arioos

ol nib-iooos aOEQl 'liso orb ni los ol bsunilnoo bs orb lull bolsovoi asH tow lnoooi moM

odhoaob 111w ow as earnsflsq sasilT sbsosb auoivmq orb ni borlai!dslao bsrl Ii arrisflsq sill

Ion )loslls laniss isllob orb lo oulsv blo orb nisinism bns bnolob ol bsniaob mow wo1od

.'clivilos oxmonooo oilaomob olomoiq ol

bhow orb aasqmoono 01 mulsoli1 oimonooo orb lo anool orb bobnsqxo iogiodothniA

lo' Jon nobnoJ isgnol oH :nomoorl niaeim orb lo olai sib bosiasrlqmo oH 8.noiaamqob

bsrl ii as bmbnsla blog orb sgsnsm ol asw II Thoboon nomsgsrl £ asw 'rlw niH .)hOY woT4

ono ai moloiodl Inomuam a'iowiodolbniA isW lsoii) orb oLot1od nobnoJ mad boaansm nood

.11 ol svilsmslls its Ion !morl bolnoaoxq woiv sill lo looqas

oauso omi-iq orb as aosw lo 'liIidixoflni bns !svsl orb no bosioa ovsrl aiothw lsiovo2

oAnsnioH ;'nsirnoD io1 woiv airli bouis ovsil aorrxs bns l&tsrlmofl .noiaamqoU Isoifi) orb lo

its asw ilirI ool oiow aosw Isill lnomugis orb wolod worla ow aA °'.t1lsiono moth

nirbiw rnoldoiq s mow aogw rIiH .omil orb lo oiioloth bisbnsla-b1o orb lo tmq lnsl-ioqmi

lnsttoqmi its as 'libih osw aolsloai noizanoath. inobom orb olirIW .insbnsla bIos orb

aislsm 'oiIoq 'tsioqmolnoo noiaasiqsU sill lo wsiv nsiasn'sA 'llsilnsaas ns ni lnonoqmoo

.islasath 01 bol lsrb oanoqaoi s -- aogsw nilluo cl noiaas'tqsCf orb JasTIs ot bohl

I

.IQQ! Moo1oorIW V

.EVQ I isgiodolbniA

iQQI nooinor1oiH

IQQI olnsmoH ;ô8Q1 aoms ; IQQI lInsrloioH °'

a

Page 9: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

nsibiswb,H 01 asw ii as mouoo bliow orb ol Aoorla s asw mW bhoW laiN oriT

ilol iloirlw nisthil Hi boom orb aoiuiqso ta \iinR '(Ol0tOi abioq xobbsM bio .1oiooa

".oviasvioq aaw bhow insasolquu isdwomoa bus won s lo oauoa orb lud 'lnooA Aoorla out

'1auoms1 aon'oA bisn'sM urlol aA .ouio Isriofismoini us riood bsrl bhow ouo-'d oriT

aO3rloUpoarioD oirnouoo&QdI ni sloiw

ni sal uimom airl guiqqia onodqo!ot '(ci iofrio bluoo riobnoJ lo tuslidsrlni ouT ill ooa idim or! as 'iiinsup rbua ni 41iso olodw orb b aiouboxq auoiisv orb bod

omsa orb is bluoo oil ;qoiaioob aid naqu iovilob '(lisa iiodi iaoqxa '(ldsnoasoi bus bus aoomoaox Igiuisu orb ni dihsow aid oiuinovbs ansom omsa orb '(ci bus Inomom

nova b uoihoxo tuoriliw oisr1a bus b1iow orb o iotisup '(us lo aoaiiqioluo won o!quo3 ol obioob bhio3 or! io ;aostusvbs bus aiunl avi ooqaoiq liorit ui olduofl

'(HE k o!qooqanwoi orb 1o rbisl boos orb rbiw aouunol aid lo '(ihuooa odi irlaim rioiisrrnolni 10 '(ormI isifi Inouiinoo 'ris ni \(lilsqioiuum lsiiusiadua oldstlolmo3 bus qssrlo li borlaiw or! Ii rbiwrItioI siuooa bluo3 oH .briornmoosi '(nlsrrrIo1 iorbo 10 tioqaasq iuorbiw olsruilo 10 '(11u1J03 '(05 ot liansit lo arisom

rbua iol lusd 5 lo 031110 unuodrIisn on ol iusviaa air! [ok] r!olsqaab bluoo booooiq noth bluoo bus 1uoinovnoo mooa irlim as alsiom auoi3oiq orb To 'Iqqua

10 osuusI rloii1oi iiorb lo obolwouA luorhiw aiorisup nioio1 ot bsoids 1soi iloamir! iobiauoo bluow bus rioaloq air! noqu rhlsow bouioo uhsod amoiauo

11s lo lrislioqmi iaom tuH .oouoiohoirn tasol orb Is bsai-iqiua rioum bus bsvsiis orb ni iqooxo tuousm1oq bris uistioo Ismion as aiis]is io otsia airb bobisoi or!

•iusnsds as ii mon noitsivob 'us bus iriamovrnqmi iorbiuI lo uoitosith LiolcisbiovE bris 1auolsbusoa

bovom -- uothlir!o lsuoiaaoioiq iiorb bus aiolusd uornaaouiaud -- olqooq boisoub

ot uilioR mon laso! Is b osoirlD ot wooaoM mail aailio Ishlaubui bus lsliqso noms '(liaso

isrb '(tilidsia oimouooo orb bolomoiq aoitio oaodi 3uimovog aoithorllus oriT ahoY woI4

oriT .bisbusia bloR orb ot niiorIbs '(ci moult noowiod ovorri ot oousuil bus auoaioq bowolls

iorbo ni bisbnsia b!o orb ot uiiorIbs -- oohq boxil s Is blog auilloa bus ui'(ud lo oiIoq

.8-4QI •b10q II

.V-O .q Q12J aonioA £

V

Page 10: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

.sgnsrloioini bosiIivi3 him 'ii1idsJa xmonooo rbod osinnsug ol boisoqqs -- afriow

bssiIodrn'a ii .anoasoi ocIockrna bus Lsi ibod ìñ iowoq air!) bsr! bisbnsla blog ouT

ot Eis3ni asw II aolilo oimonoos bns Isuloollolni o 3oubnoo lo airioflsq bns 'li1slnom Orb

boviooioq aisdmsm saorlw 'aas1o ni1asvni sr11 as ot bons1s asn'oA isfiw o sonogiomo orb

orb bus oixns-ioiiI or!) aoi1i1oq oil) aIsiom silT' .trl3iIob s bus 'iub s as aniiaovni bus gnivsa

bus boO .nivsa lo noitomrnq orb -id 'osiiqanoo bnsi £ UI boniot ogs orb lo noiiI&i

"b3Ii3nOo31 omw nornrnsM

onom lo liIidsla or!) 'd boswoono oow nilaovni him riivsa 1olrnonoo sioM

!sionsrnl £ o eulsv lss or!) lo isnsb on asw oor!1 sausood bothswor asw fibriT .aeijlsv

bonisiaoi bus asohq sldsia boaimcnq r!oidw btcbnsta blog silT sws botsflrii riiod loaas

b1o orb oausoofi .loilod air!) 1o io1ninsu orb asw ,alnorrnnovog k mobooiI Isiorisnil oil)

.obiwbFiow atos-Ufloo Ofl0ffl lo sulsv orb bosilidsia Ii ,ffisla\ca ianoilsn-iotui (Is 2.5w bisbnsla

ugioiol lo alovsl bo1ffoboooqrIu bsgsiuoorxo bobivoiq :1 '(Jilidsta olsi ousdaxs ouT

iorb lo biirb £ ot stisup s bolaovni oonsi1 bus nisthH oliI aoninuoo IsriT .lnorniasvni

rnonooo !snoitscrislni orb lo noiansqxo sill gniloifi €1Q1 bus 0881 noowlod bsoids agnivsa

ooolns ot bothow omil ornsa silt Is him hisbnsla bIos 0111 lo sououpoarioo s asw

•oorrq boxil £ Is blo anilisa bus gni'(ud lo oi1oq silt nistnisrn ot iobio iii

iii ioivsrlod bonilqioaib airiT abnuod uisfloo nidiliw nisils iiorb loubnoo ot bsr! atriommovo

.ô.q ,EQ1 asn'(oA

'ti1idsta oil) ni hilod lznoflnovrioo out! nood asrL.boiooi oa" 4iio bolnioq aon'(oX aA

wsaiovo oilw oaorb b.siiup5l aohlnuoo 'nsm ni 'nsI orb tsr!) "tonilnoo '(orlom s lo 'Oolsa bus .(V.q ,ESQI aoircoA) ebnod bobo-11i ni 'loviau!oxo taovni ot abrwl tarn)

bus (CEQI) otiilW ,(0EQ1) ai&1 osa bithnsta blo orb bus tnorniaovni naioioI nO .(2821) niolalsbH

8

Page 11: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

orb baA ô!blnbnsta bIos orb oi brnorllis tsrb aoFiinuoo ru '(tilidsia 31m0n033 botomrnq mW

silt k inotxo orb la io±usm £ as no)!st 25W oruilqioaib aid) nistruisrri at atnomrnovo la '(tilids

gniit iqol sqoiuH rristas3 bits sonernA nitsi lo asntrnjoo gni1iiita oriT .bhow bosilivio

£ 10 tsmllsil £ '31!O akil at oonoiorlbs riiAsm jnsbnsia b!o orb tqobs ot niIis1 bris

nsonomA bits rissqoiuH lo titho silt lo trio aoitoiooa nsohlA bits nsiaA .'(rriOrl030 boqolovob

.dulo airb rubE ot nails on obsrn itaiibrii

Iisbrisia bloa orb nhtozntanoo51 tsrlt I sW IthoW ioils bits riimb IsoiRol bomosa tI

-otq iii boos asw tsrlw iovoosi at thitnsaas 25W (atsw tasq 111 as mw ahb gnhub bobrioqaria)

bisbrtsta bLo orb oio1od as otriloads as od •ievon bluow rnailsnoitsrnstni ii novd .'Ooiooa 15W

orb timilob bits '(tilidsta oirnon000 otorrroiq bluoo tI .aruoitonul Isub an omuaoi liha bluoo

o'noao2 1s1obs *toY waIl orb Ia ioniovoD gnoit2 nirnsUuofl aA .'ctoiooa msbom Ia onsx

:bnsln lo irisH orb lo iorrIsvoD rusrrruoM ugstruoM at omom QI £ it! tnioq silt tuq innd

ovitsirIotts orb xsdt botsoibrui om 'd boisda aiR 3osI ni jloirlw ani1oo1 a'nsrrnoM .iM daithd orb '(ci noiaaolnoo s niod -— a3norrIsq blog lo noiiqmuaoi lo oiuuisl —

Ia boi-ioq gitol £ '(d bowollol 3d bluow omuaor ot o!diaaoqrru 25w ti isilt tnocnrnovoD inoloiv nsom bluow tI .oislqmotnoo ol '11soi auohoa oat anoitibnoo bobtoanu

lo aoulsv orb lo noitnohotob oviaaoigcnq '(Idsdotq ritiw aonsrloxo orb ni anoitsutouul saoth 1o ils at ovi noon! its obivoiq bluow ti ;isllob oil) aiv--aiv asioitfluo ngisioi

blog orb nsrb iorlto atnoiboqxo bits amintaon iol asobi lovon gruiorisvbs o'iow odw oisnobnu ot aomit is atnominovog ot ovitnooni bris ;aoisw iiorb hoe at bisbnsta

orb rib tluaoi boobni tr!irn ii ;noitsflni bris atnoiboqxo onom ioqsq Ia aoq't auohsv is tqrnoits omoa tofis ,tsr!t iooIlo orb ritiw blog 10 bhow orb gniriisib astst8 botinlJ

'tsionom lo bnb! ornoa aooFiq bits tiboto lo noitsiugot orb tol rnairusr!oorrt torbo ornoa tud noitiaoq toirnol ati at blog Ia noitstotaot otsinutlu tub tluaoi '(LIsrnI bluow aiaiw

hsoitiloq brus Isiooa ornoa '(ldiaaoq bus gruhs1lua bits qirlabusrl 10 bohsq s toils '(Irlo VI .tsbtoaib

ÔQQI 11oAoo5I bits obiofi

.14 .q Q8QI juimoT rub botoup RSQI JI 'isums1 erriubnstomoM gricrut2 VI

2

Page 12: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

silt asoibs bisbnsta blo silt niAsaio1 mail tluasl binow tsrlt alivs lo '(nEtil 2irlT

hen lo aiorronl svitsluinuo silt lo blot d3iclw aulsbssU nsilqsta nuo' ot bsilossiq norrnsa

lsnnsnil -- 203101 lo dssqa tI 81.iloiurlD oiloiltsj silt bsnobnsds onlw s2oilt '(ci bsiubns

'istsnom iswsiq 010t251 ot siuliäl silt '(ci beilaseinu oil bluow tsilt -- isIJioshletni bits

lo noitojyit2fIOo5I silt ai asoiol oii-istsa sasilt iol bssaivno noit8 'bomoi silT .atnsmonsuis

'(1155 silt iii atnsvs botsqioitns omsm aid tsrlt ai saiuo3 lo noii silT .bmbnsta bIos silt

.motas(a 'çrstsnom aidt -- Ia insnnmobnsds tori -- ot aorraisdbs icl batstiqi3slq '(IISIJt3B aO€Q1

nooci aswls bsnl slsilT .'(tiiiupnffht bsistflo tesq silt ;siutul silt ni asw tsilt hid

silt gnhub alsAlsm lsionsnfl silt bslioi bsil ansohsmA silT .saiuoo lo anoxtsutaufl oimonoos

1iotrio ton Ilsila noY" bstaiani nsvjd aninns1 insilliW nsilw ôQ8l lo ngisqmso noitosis

sunitnoo bluow aststa bstinlJ silt Ii boisbnow aiotasvni bits "blo lo 22013 5 noqu bnblnsm

asisi lasietni tnea oinsq nitiuasi silT .sohq bsxil ati is bio lisa at noitsgildo au ionoil ot

ti ;bsvii-tioila azw Dinsq aiilt lud .enoitosansil isionsnil isnoitsinstni bstqrneib bns nhsda

astst2 botjnlj silT .isW tssii) silt lo rltsrrnetls silt ni abnim 'nsm lo tnoñsiol silt ni ton asw

snsisb ton bib tud bschuiaib aoitiloq oitasmob ati ; anoitslsi lsnistxs ni triisitasi nwoila bsil

.'(ff1011033 Isnoitarnotni silt

gnhs a silt :bisbnsta blog isw-siq silt lo alarlo isiltons asw ni1ssvsi bits biviv sioM

auobnsmsit s bims bssiuoone need bsil bnsl nsansmA iltuo2 ni noitsluoeq2 .0Q8 I lo aiaFc

bnuol 'Itnuoo tsilt Ia insmnisvo silt '(llsutnsv3 .tdsb tnemmevog nsonitnsiA Ia noiansqxs

silt ni trluso asw annsH Ia mill nobnoJ silT Jdsb bstslumiioas silt soivisa ot sldsnu Iloati

SSQI 03'(0l 8!

ethhfiOl5D ' 01

Page 13: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

booteishnu OQ8! iii bns1nH lo Ansd silt lo iomsvoD s1sbisbbiJ msilliW .slosdsb gniuens

iisilt tud bstnsw '(orb tsilw oh bhioo enEsnitnsglA silT .'<rnonoos bhow silt ni sloi eiil

usd1 ml null ilaithil bslon s Bnivlovni 'H .bushnsta blo silt nslsrnilt ot Jon susw asaassxs

.nobnoj ni oinsq sisisns bluo3 amsldoiq uisilt sisrlw anortthmoo bstssio 'silt agni1ssb

3nigsmooaib asnsesi stshurnnoos ot bar! oisbusbbij oinsq Isionanil s biôvs oT

Jrlim isift ansol ml Ilso Jon aiotibsio ssuuoons bits floila curt trlgini Ansa silt lath atduoth

tnsrncrisvog orb ot abnod ni11sa '(d bsrlailqmooos asw !so tauil silT .atstsm silt si1idstasb

bsstnsisu arthuosa bits sontfl lo kisS silt mon ablir!oarlto$I duourlt niwouiod 4aauM lo

its nirfossi '(ci bsvsiilos asw bnoosa silT .aAnsd )l3Ota-tnioi nobnoJ mofi ansol lo aisilo

gnionsrnl aus)loud hid ol sham bail 'silt anso! stsbiupil ot ton aMnad silt illiw nibnstaushnu

bsrrnolni slsbuobbii aao!orlJsnon aitsol ni Ilso ot nssd Ansd sno itorlW .sbsit nsohsmA sift

kisS silt is tnuooos a5lnsd silt seolo bluow sit ansoI ml has ot bsuniinoo ti Ii taut ussnsm all

ot mon ma ussnsm silt svsg sH .ausqsq gninsvs silt ni noitos tacIt sonuonna bits bns!nH lo

nloum oa ton asw sisbisbbij .noitsusqo lulaasooua bits bsbnscl-n!inI ainlt nI t.sbiosb.

silt gnilssvsu as hushnata blo sift nistnisrn ot bns!nd lo kisS silt lo uswoq sift nitidinIzs

ilofle tnioi £ it! noitnsqooo oitasmob bits Isnoitanisini ultod uol bssni

bits aiahD gniusfl silt macIt '(unonoos bhow silt ot !oorla isgml a awn iaW tasif) silT

lo lnsH sifT .sonsiusqxs Isoiiotairl lo sgnsi uisilt bno'(scl as ausMam 'oi1oq ot bsissqqs

gniusS silt nhub bnsmsb iii sassioni bsvil-tion!a silt n!tiw Isth ot abnul saist hi uoo bnsinH

nwo ati no bswouuod tnsmnnsvo silT .anssm nbua '(if isw silt sonsitil ton bluoo Ii tinci aiahD

mofi aAnsd nobnoJ ssiuooath ot noiasua [atom lo aiswoq all beau bnslan lo kisS silt bits

.VS .q lQI llswoq °

ii

Page 14: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

mslaa Isionsnil iswsiq sill lo noiaivoiq sA A .Islsrn auonsiq iii anoilosansil gnblsnsbnu

alaoo sinitisw iJiil sill 'd bsliinil sw noiloFilasi niorlliw blog tioqxs bits l-ioqmi ol lilh sill

sisi snsrloxs bnuoq-isllob sill lo noilssilidsla Ansd-lstnsD .niqqiila nssoo lo abisssrl bits

.2121 ni 'lno bslidirloiq 515W atioqxs bloD .awoll blog 101 bsluiiledua asw

asw 'iolaid lo noaasl silT .rioilqinaib '(lsioqmsl £ sw 15W sill aiai1D gniisfl sill sliJ

lo abssri sill slsbomcnooos ol '(Ito asw bisbrisla blog sill lo noilsthlibom '(isioqmsT .isslo

Aosd o bluoda nisliiH '(sw1sbnu 85W noll3inlanoosl snO .noil3lrtlanoosl iswlaoq bits isw

niH .isihss '(mlriso s nosloqsfrl ni1ss1sb isils snob bsrl Ii as bisbnsla bIos Isnoilibni sill ° lnssm noilsllni lnslluasi an bits isW issiD sill lo noilsoolaib sill noaas1 sill isslo isvswoil

onnonoos iswlaoq lo msldoiq silT .biswiobrIisila sd Ion bluow noilqinuasi lsrll

aiH lo isnoiaaicnmoD abioJ silT .nislFiH ni mw sill rihub bssinRoosm 85W noilssinsmo

tsd 1-ioqsi bits noilasup sill isbianoa ol ssnirninoD slliInuD sill bslnioqqs 'çiuassiT a'(lasisM

.8121 iii oa bib II .lriscnmsvo sill dl

lo 'iolairl aimon035 sill wobsilasiol Ii ol noibssi sill bits ssllimmoo aull lo tioqsm silT

asw 'li1idslarii oimonoos laniss sonslsb lasd sill isrIl sugis noqsi silT .nss' isvnslrii sill

rioilulilani sinsa sill Isill loibsiq ol iasq sill lo '(lilidsla sill bsAovni Ii bits bisbnsla b1o sill

sill isw sill isils Isrll svilrisqmi 81 Ii rioiniqo itio nI" :siulul sill iii '(lilidsla slsisnsa bluow

bsiolasi sd bluoda bisbnsla blog sviloslls its lo sonsnslnisin sill ol asaasosn anoilibnoo

sisa bits sasrloiuq ssil sill asw sslliinrrxoo sill cl bsEsaivns rioilsmolasi silT '2'.sIsb luoilliw

sbwnsq bluow Miislnsm bisbnsla-blo sill lo anoiaeamqxs rlou2 .asiiimsq iswsiq Is b1o lo

.aOQ1 sill iii anoiaauoaib

. .q 8121 nislhH lssiD 12

£1

Page 15: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

inoupoadua afl bus lQl ni brwoq orb iol tzoqqua ns3nomA to bno oth Jufi

as nous11ob oiiuprn bluow fforlsbnomm000l a'ooflimmoD sdl ni2qobs lsrli insorn noisiosiqth

niouboi lo aiaoo orb oaoqmi ol lnsioulo2 .a-isW ornooloqs%4 orb ial1s aoxoiloq mlimia bsd

ovil tol ouixiv lo nodqmuaot orb bonoqlaoq inornmovog orb ai3ib1oa ninm151 otto aogs

airiT .lo' aliup ton hid boD torn ovsa :wsa blo orb ni mrxnia orb lo 'xo orb gsw II .ama'

boisqiolios anoitibnoo us ni bits earn us Is btsbnsta b1o orb lo aaoriluloau orb luods iduob

molt WOt tsrb aoioiloq orb onimiobnu ot aOQl orb lo oawoo orb ni noqoob bluow Isth atduob

.àtilzinorn tnsriirnob orb

.!stI bits oonzll ni aoioiloq lsionsrnl botoolls tdguoth lo coborn Isnoilibsti omsa oriT

'iiisq mwotq orb ototeot 01 iabto ni oisflob bits nisthH otslurno ot haiti arisilsil orb oliriw tuH

ooubsi ot iobio iii mo1aia 1soail Isiriotni iS3 srnotot ot oldsnu siaw rlorioS orb Mill orb lo

otoleoi 01 enoinsqot nsrrnoD no botnuoo aioitnoi rlonot9 .aoiutibnoqxo inornrnovo novo

ovieasq nsrntoD ot hal trlu$I orb lo noitsquooo nariw nov3 .'iiioqaoiq Isnoilthsit tiSt

cii rlawpnilsi ot boauloi tnornsthsq donoR orb anoiisisqoi boasotoni usd1 iothst oonoleieot

iii onsil orb xii ol doidw is orilsv orb tuods anoiaauoeib nI iiioqaoiq iswoiq lo cohomorn

lo oulsv blo orb nisinism" bluoo 'odi tsth boqori 1(sflaouQ etnsqioiIisq orli lo ono ôQl

silT ".'i1nuoo io oh! orb otsti!iosh auth bits aoohq bFiow wolod eooiiq donoll

o noxtsiurnuoos ovicesm £ botsisrio8 aisox wol s ioi tasol is Isoa aith ho Inorndailqrnooos

.iolsl axso woh £ btsbnsta blog orb ho aicho orb ot botudiiinoo bris oonnl iii b1o

.(Jimq tswotq daildsiaooi ol niisI1ob ho olqrnsxo rlaithfl edt bowollol ansilsil silT

oWl C1O)uJHOa

.q lQ2! •atuoM ni botoup OSQI '(snaou9

El

Page 16: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

N

J'3 Eo.tpa Too? Ui

J90L SCt!A12uJ ic qounuq ot coj wcciq cmboQ1 OO2t !U Th5-st qnuu tpc

EUJJ!u MUG2 mow uotq moat bLowuoutjA zu tpG coj jou potpcq oj

o &qq b&Awcuta ut tpc bw-MsL bUui2 /A&2 rpwtcuiu to wqncc LGUJ MUca

tpo m91 cLjOT.r tpcA mcto r.odrnwq pccUnac ipo Loqifetlon coata tcdrnwq tOL tpo LoatoLspou

unjA &jjomucor jpoao wqicj bLoboj mLo joitiwsT;q pA tpo MO4cGL coutupnpou o

bLo&ffw O aOC!UJ!2UJ 110/A4 1AP!CP LUG&IJt ! bLUc(icc U UJJIJUJJIIW MUG U1J tUtO-bLOAiq€q

!11 !t COIU!11OUWJ 110!PP0L2 VU° tPO FUP0 B914A qIPUt0q !' ThS't !f Uqobtoq U

0bbo2ipou to qojtiou /AU2 oIJqounc !' BL!W!L? UJtjJ0flp U M&2 jt mOLt OLqOLJA qnn

oxhoucuco oi pAbcuutj9uow32

bUutA yqpctcuco to IJJG ojq awuqstq &uq !ta WcutUptç MU? !!U01120 !u (JGUJJUIJA U1:tGL tile

ffiOU atUp!J!tA MU? L€2tOLO !u TÔSt tPLOP t D" bJUu tpc UJULJ( toanucq U2 bL€MUL

OXbGLIO1JCO m coua!qcLcq out oj tpo op)cct jeaaoua hLoAm fib flJflO o tpc oq at&uqLq'

1P QOUJJUU? 1cJJ !'U' U bopcA o LJ1JU1JCW oxccaa ouqitJ U' pAbouurjtiow JJJbR

MU? erbroitru qowcaxc e(L81u2 ace qeq to UCjJIGA€ Cf 112 Lcarqr34

t!1M fJUI LO2tOLUt!0U 01: tIlt ojq atUuqULq MU? LCA!A!U tJ3 U0 01: cUbItUl !Uto JtUJA tJ1l220j!Ui

WU?? bstpca,4 jcq to U2CUJ LQtLCUCJJUJQIJt tUt U' tIILIJI jcq to ti't JAJSLCP 011 jçoiiit• Vt tilt 2UUJG

buoutA to U11ff11cU'I UUq 1JJOIJGtUQ atffp!1!SUt!OU flUB to cflJtAUt!1J tilt boptlcUj aflbbOLt 01: tIlt

uattntcq qcrJfft!ouULA IJJCU2IILt2 yccoLqiu to jOL2At? O!oI!tt!,2 U2a1UUJO1Jt OL .,P!PGL

ItUl!U0 0AOUJUfGut OJJJCIUJ2 Uuq CGIJtLUj U1JJCtL2 MGI.€ JO?? LtabOUa!At to tpc bnppc MIll UB

jpcA aonpt to LOUIU!1J MItPUJ tilt Ol-2tUUUL cjnp M!tP UJJ tJt ROUctit? UttLpfIttq to !t

Page 17: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

isill niiub 1nsma5IE nfl bsilassi lftsma%snsm bus noinu silT .irlu$I sill 0 noi SkJ33O d3nsll

131111103 sill tb noiluloesi sill ma .sgSW inuminim z bss1nsmu 55W eisAiow tdoisclw smil

lnsinssigs sill bits thoo cleijhfi iol bnnrnob sill ni 51111351) bswsnsi £ 01 bsl lnsnilnoo sill no

sth issq5r 03 anoiisi3osn bswsnsi silt olni lduoid asw isleiniM smFi'l silT .bseqnlloo

ni aiioiloisbsi slnl ol lo svsd '(lintios cull lo ais*iow sill Its :bisbnslc bIos sill lo nilrinm

bSti15 cli no 'cilaubni Iuq qlsrl ol esgsw

'(sw 'Ino sill ci i iua .lsstb cli no 'ilaubni niJJnq Ia sw sno 3a4 ci aawo lo culT

.sldieaimbs Ion sin asohq isdid 8nivlovni asyilnirislln sonic bizbnn1a b!o sill isbnu nsqo

mail awollol liso cull seunosd bisbusle bIos sill lo sanioscib sill ci csgsw Iswo! iol gnillsD

iiscll sulnvsb ionnno Insbnstc bIos sill no csiilnuoD .ms1ee vjsisnom sth Io eoxnMssm sill

lonnso '(silT .sth sgnsrloxs usd1 snicrnslsb 01 anoqxs ol bnsmsb sill wolln bus CsiOflsTiiJO

esoriq qu deuq bluow oc niob idi bnsmsb oilasmob slnlurnila ol '(lqqlm snom sill bnnqxs

soubsi ol 'nw '(Ino sill insilj 10q .sts sgnsdoxs sill nsAnsw bus attoqxs LIoa s4ovoiq

isvswoil bib II .iodnl 21 cleoo sasill lo lasin1 sill bus noiioubcnq lo alaoo soubs-i o1 ci esohq

.gmbulis asw slainiM smiil sill iloiilw ol alaoo nm-node seoqmi

Ion bib '(silT .enoansi lo '(lsnv n iol eiaoo sasill issd ol Insloulsi sis'n anoirnj silT

shsil ol iluons siuosa Ion smw 'silT .eisAnsd lnilnso sill lo noiaiv oilq'(lssoqn sill s-isila

won bus tiolls mw sill ni bslnqioinsq bnil '(silT cnin siulul bsfloqiuq mol esoilii3se InsTuJo

bsmolesi sill bsmsbnsi anoiloubsi sgsw 01 ssigs 01 sonsloulsi iiailT .sensqcnoosm bslosqxs

sill mon ii bsrmolaflni bun sldixsflni bus s!igsil emsy isvnslni sill lo bisbnnla blog

.noices-iqsU Issifi) sill lo isllimensil sill olni '(lilidnle 10 iolnflInu

.22S .q Q1 awoM

Page 18: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

bo5I rio anoienot boaao boith1o or! biadua sib baa noxtnevia1ni alolairliM omilq edT

lol oiuom 'cnsm bobnsmmoasi noieaimmoj (loumnEa) Lato2 silT .QI IE that ithiiq

flock orb ni boiowol od ot had sgw tacit bolai2ni Jud .nhq2 niwo1to1 sib \çltaubni !so3 orb

hIo edt lo orioteth orb wiiau aaW noiaaimmoD Ioums2 silt C1&I2IrIIM hq sib o1iJ .nm

orb no 2noitsitoaon lnsupoadua orb ni 10110 110(11 boad aionwo onim ouT .bisbaata

2SW tifiesI odT .amor! iono! bus aosw iowol no botaiani baa noitabnomcnoooi e'noiaairnmoD

ni oels tud iodsI lo ts&lob orb ni bobi-is oAiila OuT .oAhl2 1siono tud oAiita Isoa £ tub Jon

orb clod noAsow bluow tacit blsbnsJ2 b1o sib lo atnisitanos orb ot noitiaoqqo lo noitaoilibiloa

iii bsnobnsds) 'iilidiflovnoo ot tnornflrnmoo anisthE bns (QQ! iii botsolob) tnornrriovo tioT

.(IEQI

Jbiscloio8 .IIow s eohtnuoa dfto ni onO mW bhoW ions oldixofl aaol oiow aosW

.oaqslloo aimonoso a'ynsrmoO lo sanso orb Slow aOQ I orb ni aoaw nsrrnoD r!3i11 tacit bouis

ai suaai silt bris bo3ao1noo nood aarl aOSW 10 Ion! orb tuods riothoaas e'tbmrfolod

nsrrno[) tub aoaoqquaoiq iloali tnomugis silT .010(1 onaai orb Ion ai tsib tna VS.bovIoaomu

Void! lo trio riood ovsrl yoclt bluoo won oa1w1odtO .oldixs[lni SlOW asgaw

.olciixsfl aaol omoood had aogaw nsrrnofl) tacit '(booiibni iolni ol boon ton oh ow tuE

silt ni aogaw rmrnioD lo itilidixoll ocit botimi! arioitutilarii iotham-iodsl flu aagflBrlO iswtao

8201 atositnoo ovitoollos td bsisvoo 810)110w lo iodmuri edT 8.aOSQI orb to Msr! bnoooa

alositnoo sasdt lo noitosil s '(mo riguorbis asuinowt -burn orb baa €1 Q I nsawtod '(Iwomlorbo

.OQQI WRII2ISA ;OI qsrlJ .IQQIthisdoioa vs

.ô821 aomst ;QSQ1 1IonA ose

a'

Page 19: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

•iol ballue-Ili asw ninisgmd 3vi1331103 lo awiou-lIa ba1namañ airlT .3qo3a iii lsnoilsn 313W

cJ b38a313nJd asw II .aAoode OiiflOflO330flBifl him 23n3m1211[bs sbiw-tmonooo nh3snib1oo3

ni E2Q I lo bus 3111 is bscnjbottnirn Jud smiflsw iii bsaubotni Jaifi noiJsiJidm poaliiqmoo

aismillo iodsJ lo 'uainiM .noiith1nhoq'cl 3rD td belioni lasinu iods! orb ol sanoqast

.anoiloubrn osw 1uodi 3u2s1auil1n3 nsdll 2231 313W aioiwilidis 323rD nilnioqqs tcñ oldianoqast

moil srnso anasifi ;boii3q sill lo al3iainim lodE! au 313W IlaaaiW IlobuM him anuEiH rIofrnsFI

Jainoinu abEt) s aaw LIoaiW olidw aogsw 3au[ 10 aorisfloqmi sill gniaastla noilibEil oilorlizD £

noilsilidis '1oa1uqrno3 him Rnrn1smd evi 331103 mainoiftJJ lo bnsiqa aiD e2UhjT .II3amu!

aldilnqmoo svilarnsJls Insiarlos s nhJ3flano3 luorlliw alo±sm todsl basiisilnaaob b3lnsIqqua

.lnamJauLbfi bmbnsla-b1o lo a3vIlrn3qmi aill illiw

ahhl lo noi siaqo sill r1uoirh1 b3lsbomm033s 3d ol bsrl 3Ed1 aaonsdnnaxb sill jovoatoM

lo noiiiaoq sill bansthsw hail I mW bItoW .oqooa iii balnsbsosiqnu lud Its 313W mainsrlooiii

nssqoiud anoilsn 131110 lo Isifi bsnsrllgnstla him alo)hsm lsnoilamslni ni aiooiiboiq nssqotuH

bsrlaildslas alsoubolq .2.U mw sill nitub bslqirriaini n3sd 8nivscl s3nsmA rnlsJ 03 aJioqx3

noillirn IsE a33s1lno3 iloisSI d b3lavo3 315w 213)110W noillhn KI 8QI 'xzuns 1o aA Iaval-Jnslq 10 -nsqmoa td isdmun iogisl Ilila £ bus a1r13ms313s 1sno131 10 ioiilaih \(d

.213E11n03

3vsfl Js±mm iodsl b3silshInaosb '1r1icl bns hosilsilnas tIrlirI tail) alasua 'çiosilT iawol 10 oari LISa ars)hsm bssitsilnsasb s1diH .aAooda slEbommosas ol liasqsa Jaals3i sill

3rD bns 11ua31 111w lnomyolqm3nu r1irl ooi sis aasw II noililaqmoo Ilauolrll 23EW od 1163 arnooluo omsa sill aJoAmm b3siIshln3a nI .nWob mar11 bid Iliw adot 101 noilil3qmoo

aia±ism n3rlW sans am3ldolq .assw 121311)5 ol nojarnob bosilsilnso slania s r1uotrll b3vsirlos em ninismd sv!1331!oa 'd bsisvoa aquolt) .bssiisnn3aab ton bssilntlnaa 'cIr1iil iorlnon 316

31diiIg3n 3d ol olorlw £ 25 33)1mm iodsl 3111 flO aJnoms3igs liodI 10 Josqmi orb tol otsl ool 250103 smii silt nsrlw .JnuoDas olni alosqmi oaoilJ 3)151 ol ovilnaani sill svsrl ol hlsma ool md

332 .Jatfl ovom oJ ni1!iw 3d Iliw noinu Ishlaubni 10 lsnoisi on anoi2233no3 sgsw 101

iisrrnof) 3111 lo noissnslastsrla IqE 115 3d oJ ff1332 hluow airll .VRQI jIiThiU him aioImIsD .aOSQl sill ni noilEulia

VI

Page 20: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

Iluasi amna silT .sbo1aib ol lluoillib bsvrnq bus sisdl a)howlsn noiludiilaib him gnils*rsm

n bsrlailcfnlas aisoubolq sasnnqst him bsiqinaib STOW sibnl ot afloqxs ckitha nsrlw b.swolkñ

bsaoqmiisqua asw ascii anoilsisqsi bus aldsb mw lo nobiud lsnoilibbn silT .sisth bnsilrlsssd

bnsl ol baunilnoG aslnl2 bsiinU sill an gnol o2 .noiliaoq svililsqmoo asqomud ni flick aicil no

sill SOBO mEl .bs'n1sb sd bluo3 lnsmlauibn sqomud ol Aond aiqisosi alnsmnq-1o-sonnIsd au

bslinliuo aslni lasislni oiuasrnob isilgirl binbnnla blog sill lo snioibsm damn sill bsilqqn b&I

.laooi ol smod sinmo ans)loiilo sill ban awoflluo lnliqno .8.IJ

Io tisH sill lo iocnsvofl) nnmioM ugslnolvl aios1 sldnrxolmoonu sasnil clliw bsonl

.bsinlsm 515W anoxflbnoo oilasrnob ban binbnnla blog sill Inch bsinsb '1qmia (bnnlgnd

bluoo blog ol niulsi a'ninlhfi Inch ?SQI 'hns ni cnisonoo aid bsaasiqxo 'llsmosa IliiloiuclD

bins vjlaubrii sbnt ot. . .

IosrIo auoiisa iisv C gniiaoqmi saii 01 sisi Ansfl siwpsi

01 lo luo slqosq 2 saunosd lnnlioqrni ai 'snom qnsclD" :bsbnoqasi nncrnoM ".lnsnnr'olqrns

ai saiuoo lo aiclT C.anoans1 Inlnsmnbnul iol nmnlu ,1soigolon1oaq mol siom :oa mull

Ii b1og lo wollluo nm

lsallo 01 sin AnnH bsaisi bnnlgn3 o AnnH sill nsnlW .sanmsanon

.ae'nsasi ngisiol bslonlms Ii an '1sma an laul lnsm'o1qms bus lnsmlasvni oi asnnob bsqnnnb

auoiinv sill ni oaln nssa sd nsa frmnbnnla blog bsiolasi sill to 'li1nup auoinocnilonna silT

gnuoY him aswnU silT .'çnonoos incnisW sill qisnl 01 aslnl8 bslinu sill d Insa anoiaaim

bnn githolasi iii linq misnll mol belsidsiso nssd svnnl CQ21 bun 4Q! ni anoiaaimmoD

alnsnnmq noilsinqs51 iol lnionsD-lnsgA silT .inmisW ni lilidsia gnoloiq ol gnilqmslln

noiaairrz ismhq aid rnnli issla asw flsd1iD isAisq .8 noiaaimmoD aswnU sill ishnu bslnioqqn

sil anN aswnU sill 101 noilnvilonni sill bsninlqxs sri aA .binbnsla blog sill svmsasiq ol anW

t xibnsqqA SV2 I sbhoM 31

Page 21: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

01 bobnolni asw rloiilw molaya boI3oIoIq s bsdaildslao audi nnI atioqx3 silT' boioIainimbs

anouffIsqol oviaaooxo rluou1I 'lilidsJani lo ioansb orb Janisga onsdoxo nsrnloD sill frisuo1sa

s noowlod )1nil orb lioaas null oom ob 01 bnim a'tiodliD iii boon on asw abuT £Zccnansn

.'cmonooo oldsla s bns onsil3xs o!dsia

bsd bobiovs nood ovsrl Iulim au 323111 lo 3ffl02 Isill aiaogua '(rlqsioho1aid boilmo nA

bodgiul tacIt a1aoua ovitooqwioq airlT .aoi1haq 311211551 olom Is b1o ol boniulrn aafWoo

tusH .aOQ1 suit iii alnorniauibs vjisnoilsflob iol boon orb bolimil ovsrl lu1im aoitiisq bns aoohq

floa 5 10 aooq burn aosw lo uioilouboi Isoibsi £ iol boon silt bovomou ovsul ton bluow toub

..Aouita noiaaoiqoU Isoif) out oouio iovilsb 01 oldiaaoqirn ii bnuol ats±ism bosioiti!oq lath

)looda s asw noiaaoiqoU IssiE) silt li oiolsd isW Isoif) sill bns aiahD nhsH suit a)1iJ

as ad bluow Ii lull tnsisqqs '!olsibommi Ion asw Ii jaW tsoii) suit sIiJ .bFiow '(qqsul aid ot

as mo bonsia noiaaoiqoU Isoif) suiT o!dslivoni Ii asw ioM bib Ii as no! as las! bns oiovta

IssuE) orb olni botovnoo asw noiaaoooi aiulT .Ii oiolod 320111 3)!!! noilosilnoo simon000 its

isrllo ni aoioi1oq ojunoutooR .aooiol 'isnoilsl1sb orb bonuutnsoos larD aaioiloq '(d noiaaoiqoU

.li '(hanolni ol betas 'oult ;aOEQl 'clmo ouil rn noiaaoiqocl orb olsivolls ol los Ion bib abiow

Ion &isbnsma b1o oull ovmaoiq ol bsniaob siow 'cod oausood oaisvioq stow aoioiloq

Isiluiso lnom'{olqma siolasi omil iii bluow bisbnsla blo orb lo oonsnolrnsM .IuIom'o!qmo

lo oaqsl!oo oulT hal bluow 'c!tooiib Insnr(o!quno sassiouli ol alqmotls o!iulw ,lrluoull nsAnsd

orb isrlw 'cIoaiosiq sisw atoob usd1 boao!o aIrrscJ as asuivsa lo aaol orb bus aoohq bus luqJuo

SVI .q CVQ1 Jiod1iD

.OVQJ omuH olqrnsxo iol 03g

21

Page 22: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

11noupoano3 anoiislooqxo rhiw aomooluo nu1!3f103o5I .lnovoiq ot baaimo-iq bithnsla bIos

asw aiaho orb oorIW .rrnot lsnoliqo3xonu ni ainovo Isnoitqooxe oaacli n oqiolrn boiiupoi

.ji!sJnom bmbns1a-b1o sift oondmo ol siulisl 'aoithothus orb no bial asw omsid o1ovoa laom

lo owl orb ol bodmuooua bsrl mluothsq ni bns1nH lo !nsa orb has ovioaoM Isiob&:I eriT

bsrl 'or11 oms bishnsta-b1o orb 10 aolin orb d s1q ot bewlrn nivsH .'onom bosnsm

moth ni1nevoiq awofl blog Isnoilamsini bosilhola bsrl ocIT "iiboio lo eoauds" beflirnrnoo

aoonq botnovoiq airiT .anoitibnos liboio no sononilni gnisilidsla Ismion iioth niiioxo moil

.nitaibs moil alaoo has

mdi bouis €QI bns *EQ1 €Q1 ni sonsnil lo ioiainim donoR nitisM-nisrrrxoD aiuoj

bmbns1a-b1o lo noilsloiv ni aoohq oislisqmnsm ol 'oi1oq '(ismonom oats ol lqmolia orb

•moocl oldsnislatmnu as boloul bsrl Jiboio qsocfl .nokaoiqob orb no 1r1uoid bsrl aow13hla

laiR aohsriD ioaivbs aiH .noiaaoiqob bns aaoilaib lBiOrthniI rlatio oldslivoni orli ni niisnim1uo

.mood niboooiq oil lo liIsioiins orb moil 'Ilooiib nil1uaoi as qmula orb wsa

loyal osnq orb ni oniloob lnonoa s bo1ovoiq ovsrl bluow noilouhcnq boasoio[I] noilqmuanoo olsiumila ol aobia us moil obsm nood Ion bsrl atiollo 11 ioihso

lsoi ol nibnoqaoixoo lsth ol ioiioqua lovol s Is Ii nisinism ol has llsioi1ifls 1o niBbo oxliooqa orb Aooa ol '<isaaooon ai Ii Isdi WOIV mo ni oioth ai ii .omooni

".aiaho mnoaoiq orb

riliw anoilosansil Isnoilsniolni bns oilaomob niwoig elionoooi ol lisi ol bsr! alaoo has aoonq

b1o oil 10 olsothoiq nsholoiV oianhlni mill CIIFUIT .blo 'çislonom lo 'Iqqua oilasloni ns

ol golsi lasiolni olsluqinsm Ion bib aAnsd Isimnso ii luods airb gnhd bluow bisbnsIa

.l-O.qq ,4€QI ninsM-nisrrnoD t .E€ .q lQQ1 &iuoM ii bolD

Page 23: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

.noilqmnanos olsiumile '(IlElulEfinu bns nivse o1uo3aib

silt lo alnEd ovisasi Isnoissi sill ni bits .Dfl nolgnidasW ni bsllsvsiq wsiv omsa airiT

sill lo 'csllsT .q nn'J trmwqu bsllsiiqa insrno1qmsnu as nava .msla'? svises5l Lsisba9

air! mill bs woW sill lo noaFnsH sgioof) slrnw aslIsU lo AnsH svisao5l lsisb&I

ilguoidll abnsil airnonoos illiw sonsistislrn ibum sonsnslnuoo om bsnilonit Ion stow a'iolosiib

Iflsbjasiq bsaivbs 'lauoholon nolisM wstbnA 'çtslsios2 'çiuassiT " .aboillsm Isioilitis

sisbwpil" ol asw niIoO1 sldsnisleua £ ol tiiionooe sill siola5i ol 'Ew 'lno sill lull isvooH

lo iuo aasnnsiioi sill sgzuq. .olsIas lssi sisbiupil aisrrns1 sill sisbiupil aAaola sisbiupi! iodsl

siom £ svil [bits] ,isbisr! how Iliw slqosq' !bsilnutnoo nollsM iliiasi s aA "...mslaya sill

sb sift ynso 01 bsnnuino3 smob binbnsla-b1o lo Ixunla Isoiriniiiuq silT '.sliI Istom

'nA " .slurrnol bstosa n lo rioila slllil" as bisbnsla blo sill bsbisRsi Ilsamiil tsvooH

Isloog bits oimonoos tol Iscisi niosidms-11s ns "maiviloaIloo' as bsaaimaib srI noilthvsb

audI sosidms '1bsbnim-slgnia ol alnsd IstInso bits alnsmrnsvog lo siulisi sill bnA .'sosb

botnioqqs f won sift 4sioIvI tnsmslD aA .saiow aflidl sbsjn '1no srnBob lainoiisbiupil

€QI 'cmunst iii a-isblorlsisrla aid idol sonsR lo AnsH sill lo iomovo

ol 'çisaasosn nssd s'tsil bluow Ii noiau1onoo ali ol noiaasiqsb sill nhd ol isbto cii

bns noilssio sill 03 'lsin1 02 bsiuditlnoo svsil lull Iths-jo lo asauds sill qola lnsioñlua s btswol lnsmsvom on nssd asil sisill los1 iii aiarn sill lo bsrnqa

ol 'cIq oini Jiluoid ahollo silt sisw !uhswoq oa atibs-io nb1nncJ lo noiiosiinoo lo thiqa sill '(snom iaso bits qSsiIo lo '(oiloq Isis iiths its 'd 4aoo tns Is nislnism

01 bsvisa ylbslduobnu asil sonsbnsl audi' .noilsluosqa iol stasl sill bns saiiqislns 8E'u .olsilim ol bsbnslni asw mi aisbioaib sill sassioni

.SVE.q stiswrlo2 bus nsmbsuil ni bslio ,OEQ! 1 'Iu1 islls1 noaFrisll ol sIlsT ÔE

.08S .q ,QeQI •nsnsW

.X€ .q SiuoM ni bsliD

Page 24: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

bns!nH lo AnnH orb orrnood woiv airb ml 2iano Dimon030 orb ol 1ooEdu aw nisthH

11)1w aitho oldsbirrnol orb lo oairno 1s51 oriT" .noitsloqo a'bmbnsta blo3 orb bottnwrb b&I

ml oicxiw 'nno onoboil )aiIsrriuoi Isionsnil rlonoil orb "ni1tnte el bhow orb doi11w

rloirlw yoiloq intonom rjoAstairn orb risrb iorbo orion ci" J€21 'munst ml noiisrinolnl'J

as" 41 tuq llou$I coupoEt ougsolloo airl cA "...aiso not tasq orb iol bowollol asH bns!gnH

,atcoo notlotjboiq bolnovoiq bir1 2oesrloIuq lobsm noqo bris 0th Ansfl wol '(Ilsiotlitis

run tnorntaubs to! at asw won rioitqo '(mo ouT ",nwob booo1 niod mon !aogsw nibu!oni

'1no bluow atqoooiq !xisbnse-blog lo noitsloiv ml '(lqqua onom orb ithrisqxH .oa-iuoo all

oom riovo as burn rlasio iorbons ot nibso1 aoaeooxo oviisluooqa -iorltiuI ogsiuoorio

oonsniq aotsno2 r1onoI orb lo nsrrnisrlo !soths5l xus1!isD rlqoaot .noiaaoiqob oirlqoflestso

ol noitsflob 1d bemq od at bsrl aoahqiotno tow isilt grilugis ni nolloM boorloo oonimmoD

Jsnoirnrnojni orb olsilfidob at niunitnoo moil aOSQ I orb lo aoaaooxo Isioasuiil orb tirrrioq

.mota'e

ot bodiioas csw oninoI boos club nivths ni ots! csw noiaao'iqoU orb oiorlW

orb boisqe '(Ilsitini asw oorirnI isriT .aoisioib a'blsh4isla b1o orb lo oonstqooos boitlilsupriu

Ia tzsa orb ,onsil oil) Ia '(tllidsia bns dJnaita odi 03 baludhfls asw qmule orb lo e)ooTflo thaw

'1nirnooa all bns btsbnsla blog orb lo coisloib orb rbiw '(!qmoo ol noiisnirrnotob a'o3nST

oil) ml inobivo bIo2 Ia aoufliv oil) Ia noiioivrioo oilIsD .o'noaoi b1o o!ds!oivni

atilnuoo orb '(d booio]iiiox asw ,tai2 bus loioM nihsM-nisrrnoD rinat Ia atnomoonuonoiq

tIsrl aiiI orb ml noiisflni oviaivib-llsiooc £ boxo11ua bsil oomn3 .oiolod obsoob £ oonohoqxo

Ioitnoo Ia tuo run bsrl tobud odT .oons'ods ml asw '(tiliditiovnoo blog noriw aoi)nowt orb lo

£QI xusIIisD

Page 25: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

ernso aioisinommoD .onilqioaib bisbns3a-b1o ol bo3ooidua c1i13B asw 3nommovo odi litnu

oimonooo aoeaoDxo [sionsnil ol be! 1rnbnnta bIo2 odi iol bisgeieib 1s113 bo3rlivnoo '(SwE

dgid boioIIua bsd Isdi aehinuoc iedto iii belisvoiq aweiv inlimia .!iomiut Isiooa bus aosr1o

odi ni Ii tuq 1StifIifn 031151111 nsrrnoD emil-ono bus ielnsd 4oneiIIIeH lisA aA .noilsflni

S '(enom oAscn bluow !isbnsta b!o edt ninobnsds ,yenoM oiaaslo aid lo noitibo dtxia

".atasielni !stirid noowlod noiinotrlo3 lo enod"

ni b1uow tr1uI aidt bus bonieonoo ataeiotni 3113 noowtod Iluasi bluow 3dfl [A]' bus noasoi d Jon oansvbs ni bebicob oct j10fl03i13 sviiao1do 1113 IC) o3noads out odw saorlt Its ovsd bluorla ow obia ono orb nO .'Ino ooiol otuid d tud oziJaui

taegrnl edt io1 bus onom lo oisaai eldiaaoq teetsoig edt iol gnitrlgil enom owo ovsrl blijod a ew ebia iodto out no bus er1om lo eutsv edt ni noiiunimth eldiaaoq

odw aegEW bus abnobivib aons1sa boxil lo tqioosi ni eaodi Its bus aiotiboio

.'onom lo oulsv edt ni oaseiorn edt bus noiisvioaeiq edt ni bolarnetni oct bluow

ns nsrlt oiom bluow 'enom lo oulsv out bnuoi begsw od bluow d3idw trigil ouT orb 03 bsol Ihsaaeoen ,ataoietni auohsv neewted toillnoa oimonoe iodio

°".o1i1 isiooa lo bus oimonooe lo noiisailnomob

.e!sq out bno'(od asw blog gnitoooi ni eu Irlgirn noiaaoiqeU edt ot noiluloa edt tsrlT

no griitioqei ,(ooltimmoD nsllimosM orb) 'olaubnl bus sonsnS no oettimmoD rlaitiia edT

Ill-mt s lo aoior1 odi nislietne 03 boisqorq asw , I EQ,I lo iemmua edt ni amoldcnq Isionsnil

mist ot 'bsoi 510W aiobsol daithfl .bonobnzds 3d btsbnsta blog suit tsrlt gnibnornunoooi oiolod

.autsta bowollsd a'gnihoJe nixibwqoo eioIed obnt eon lo w3noo s 'hson no alosd itorli

jthst £ -- gnirli'{us vjrt 03 gnilliw asw" tdgi1 Isutoolletni gnibsol a'eotiirnrnoa odt aencoA

gnidnns -- anoitoiitaei gnibnol ngieiol (atnei bus atiIoiq ,aegsw no 'Osoit lsnoitsn S ,astoup

"'.ets1qmotnoo 03 aitasib oot asw rbirlw ,bmbnsta blog orb gnibnoqaua tqo3xo

Iô .q VSQI 4oheiuIleH °

.EQ.q ,V821 oo'ofl '

Page 26: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

au bun !rloiJsflob asw oriolorh alT .benobnsdn ton asw 'bnoupeanoo fnnbnnia b!o ouT

aoinsq Inionnriil brinlariuiw 01 'bnot booua oiolaiorlt aAnfid IsiunoD .noiionni lo asw àlilnlnom

ovioao5l Iniobo1 silT .unorn'oLqme o noniboiq o'noaoiq 01 ion tud aithD gnhnfl orb o111

ic1ia ui 2SW Dinnq on inrb aonoaoi !nsd aaooxo bnz aoini uaoioirii wol mon bonolni moiay8

orb 1EQT ni b1o ol inomtirrrnioo 2TJ orb ot tnoirb n anw 5IorIl noriW .rioiionni bollsanuoo bn

.noiaaoqob otni toqoob '-itnuoo orb nivhb bun Ipnr1a aoini taoxolni niainx '(d bobnoqaoi bo1

A .inllndiD lo AooR orb an gnoiua an ion anw iovoworl binbnste blog out .1(11 tioqqu8

oonia iooiia ninwoU boiquooo bnr! ,bnn1nd lo AnnH orb Ia bnohl on jelainim orniiq odn!

iovool-1 ,eauoH oiidW orb ni bobiaoi IIiia nnoilduqo5l n olidW .QSQI 10 iommue orb

ovnrf Iliw tnorn'oIqrnonu no rIani3 orb lo atoollo iaiow orb" Isrit OCQI rlomM ni boonuonnz

ton bib beqor! oH doiriw o1 'cxovooe sub bnn "nb 'Jxia Ixon orb gnhub boaanq noed

bnz1n3 lo AnnH orb rbofl .tI!noiismnib bsnorItno1 noiioolooi aid no abbo orif .osi1nhoim

ton anw '(rnonotus iiorli lud noitos Ia oonobnoqsbni bo'oLno evioao$I isisboq orb bnn

.boo1nnmu

lo oth orb lud bxnbrinla b1o orb nobnndn 01 inntiaoil, nood ovsrl 'nm aoithorbun odT

iobud orb nionsisR ii buolob 1auooiv at Innioulsi 'L1nupo merit boobnoi tnorn'(olqrnsnu

idt troqqua trio io asxsi oaiai at Jrrniiaod now aflrsmmovo 2nd ,

bomrn Lunoitnovnoo £ aaw

ninso1-tIoJ .aastiaib oimonooo inoaoiq orb nevig bo'(olqmsnu orb bnn a-ionoianoq arrniotov

oaln orow 'orIt hid atuo rloua 'Iqqn ot bornqorq tanol otow a'ninthd oAiI atnommovo

orb lo oanolob riot!) 11 obuuiloor li3oail iiorb lo alo*rom orb oonwnoa ot boi!do '(hs!uoitlnq

orb bun Aonutn bluow auoAmrn orb !aoxnu oainr at bolini torb IT .booooua ot anw bmbnsua bIo

II .noitnn orb Ia anoiinbnuol !nionnnil orb bnolob at bolini nivnH rol 11th idgim 1nomniovo

IC

Page 27: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

3103 cii lo eiaoioini orb boolob ol gnilisl 101 bomsld od 1r1im or1i aoxsi acisi bib 'or1i

qilirN aA inc 'EW on bsrl aisloillo lnrb wsa aiobsil tononuD .'sw'ns 11th bns 'oriouiiianO3

i1qsioidoins air! ni aieiio anillola orb bonislqxo tIioniooua ioIIoonsrD -inodsJ sill nobwon2

bsoids noiaesiqmi orb nevi bsd alsaoqoiq loRbuH orb ci nti inodsJ orb lo rioiiiaoqqo OIIT"

£tflIb1inu ion aw tiinuoo orb isili

orb bns'Iob oi boiiupoi as aoisi lasiolni acisi ci boisqsiq aAnsd Isiinso 010W ioM

s 'd bolnoilnoo bns1gn3 lo !nsfl oil .'(IIIL ni nobnoJ )Ioinle aicio nihoie orli noriW .moiata

oil rtiiior1inoI Io isol iol aim innooath all sam ci bsisiiaod oisi inosrro1qmsrnJ moo ioq O

ci bolisi sessioni iaiil orb nodW .slsi Ansfl oais-i ol cAoow owl 'hson boiisw II .aonoup ebb

noicrioqana orb lilnu onsrIo Isnfl orb ant chit niH .nisgs boaisi ant oisi orb aoeaoI blog lIsri

'iov tbsoi!s aconiand ilhiW' annA oh gnibioooA .diQI iodmoiqs2 no 'chiliditiovnoo lo

ni1Liw 013W jnomsihsq ni aoviisinaaeiqo-i iiorb ion inodsi ion lnomosnsm iorllion boaaoiqob

".iosxs bluow otsi AnsH riRiri s done rloidw oonq out ssq ci

Imbnsle bloz odi aslsi ocisi oi bolsiiaorl '(orli II .boianioo oiow aoiihorlius oriT

ooillo moil bsoiol ad irIim 1orb aohsi saisi bib '(oil II .aoiuaaoiq lotism oh dmnooua idgirn

oil o1dsnisiauann '(Ilsoiiilcq 25W oth sisi orb hnrb gniisqioiinA .eoiuaasiq lsoiiiloq '(d

Isdi noiissilsoi orb '(il bodaselnu oncm hoc! lo airlgifl oinsq .'(sw'(ns Aosiis irigim abo±Isin

bits aiioilsb obsil orb botxswb nooa smrno1ib airb rnoil oqsoas on bar! nisliiH dii aaiiinuoo

dnsd lsiln&) .aornil ierbo is ainorn'(sq lo oonslsd orb baisnirnob lull ooi'rioa idob Isinoixo

Ic inovo orb ni aoaaol lsiiqso biovs oi aoiiFwooa ngieiol nwo tiorli niisbiupi1 sil orli bonioj

.tEQI nobwona £i

.1x81 .q V8Q1 snuA

Page 28: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

oboIwonAos ci booio'x OIOW isvooH nothoH s411 novoilod owl nova .noiisulsvob nioio1 £

".bhow orb lo A3ob orb no rionima oaools' omo3od bsrl awofl Isionsitil bits bIos isrb

wsib 01 qirlabnoiil ioth boan aoiflrnioo Isi-iianbni nisiri orb lo ato!nsd lsnnoo ofiT

'lisb ni asw bns1nH lo AnsH orb lo nsrrnol4 .isoIIs qirla orb qooA 01 lqrnotis its ni iorliogoi

'sa at IEQI 8 ylnl no boilso oil .svioaoM Isisbol 2 .TJ orb o noainsH rbiw noiisoinnmmoa

ono '(11 ol nio asw isrIinJ isdi Arisdar1oioM orb lo bsorl jorlinJ mon bison bsrl oH isifi

rbiw iorbooi iovoU ol Iovsii nod inon1 its id '(sb Ixon orb nobnoJ ot eonslqcnos won orb

olidw oonsiI lo AnsH orb b ioioM rbiw ilnanoo ci ahs ol o bluow iorliuj .nsrnnioM

iiofli oeoqmi ot briuois bolovsfl nom lo qurng lisma emiT .o1asfl oi no bouniinoo nsrrnoM

Lsnoaioq orb lo omws '(Ibisri bns anojajoob '(sb-oi-'(sb ijofli ni bovlovni ion bliow s no noiaiv

21o)1rIsd isiirioo orb b rIOis3irlUmmOO insiarioo bns anoisloi

.rrorisftsb iol orrigno itn omsood bwbrzsia bIos orb insrnrioiivno oldsiemi airli 'ii

Isiinoo lo ao'noaoi ognsrloxo nioioI bits blo orb oi boAnil 510w flb5io bits onom lo aoilqqna

a)1risd lsiinoo asionoTrno '(5)1 lo '(Illidsie orb inods boirtuom '(imstisorln as iufl .alnsd

lo omila odT .aovioaoi blog iiorb qu blind ol aoonslsd ensrIoxo nRioiol iiorb boisbinpil

nwob , I EQI lo bno orb d moo ioq II ol Ilel eo'noaoi vjisisriom Isdoig ni ognsrlaxo ngioioI

-isilob bns -gnilioma cli bloc oonsi1 bo Ansfl ouT .oiobod aiso'( oorirb moo ioq VE won

iol boI orb bits bnslgnd lo )1nsa orb is abooooiq out bomnoaoiq bits abnod boisnirnoriob

1iboio bolobmasi '(oniT .abmonl blog iiorb bitolob oi aAnsd Inirioo seoHi gnioiol noieiovn03

.Vô .q E .lov Q1 jovooH

.tsQI .q VôQi o±tsID

.A xibnoqqA (MQI) oaAiuVl

Page 29: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

tnsfl .lriorn'oIqmo bus noilouboiq eoohq niaaoiqob bus dnsd lsioommo3 nisi!idElaob

luo ol tomio1 sill nioio1 acrni1 bus ablocloenorl 01 iiboio lo rioiivoiq orb bslqimib smaolo

lo asbiud sill boilingam noilslloG VtnoiJ3ubo.1q ltariijo ol isflsl sill (noilqmu2noo iisill

nijthiism ol tiollo sill iii iorltitñ Ilila nibnoqa iisrll listnn ol aioldob nioio1 4dob anibnslaluo

swq lo bnbl sill olni Iosd hoaqiilloo bwbnsia onsxbzo-b1o sill aA 8'.aaoniiltiow lib5io iiorll

as boxilidslaeb oiow alotam 'vi1idsla Isionsriil illiw bolsiaoaas loloM Mill mola'a boasd-bIo

.oiolod mvon

lanl sill lo emil orb is 0281 iii bosinsio olsbiobbii isril tioqqua nicno1 10 bniA silT

Ilusilith siom asw floqqua iloua lud sanoqaoi auoivdo sill asw aiaho Isiorisnfl omiloossq lsoi

iioth lo 3ili2 lao! srnor1 is zrnoldoiq cJ bsiquooooiq aioAnsd IsilnoD .!EQ1 ni oldmsaas ol

ol nusd '(bsoils bail alo*ism bsloonriooislni lo bliow s nood boil IsriW .oonobrioqob Isulum

nibsil lo noilquiaib silT .oaqslloo ojinonoos sill lo siuaaoiq sill iobriu slsislniaib

aslffla ioaasooua bovisla-sunsvsi sill 1d beiqobs ailhsl won sill eT isW blioW 'd aqirlarioilsloi

nsonomA riilsj bobriim-noilzsilshiaubrii 'cd bus siiqm3 nshsnuH-oilauA sill ol

sill 'cJ boislasvob oisw aoiilaubni oilasmob oaoilw eohlnuoo iii 25)11(1 llhsl bus alnomrnovo

arioilsisqo-i bus aldeb 15W lo signal silT .mola'& Isnoilsmslni sill lo oridsi sill lnsi ift ,qmuia

.noilsisq003 iol aiosqaoiq sill boiuoa isrlnul ylssiT aollisaioV sill '(d bsullssuped 111w ff1 baa

lilguoa snlauA bus I €21 Ia 'sM ni snnoiV Aoinla aIarIO llslanA-libsiD sill noilW

laiil shlauA lull babnsmsb jsvsJ onoN oilaithnoilsn sill '(d ho! rlonsi1 sill qlorl ngiotol

bus toY woM rluodllA .nsrxnsO illiw noinu amolaijo £ aninriol lo noiliisliu ils sofliiOiisi

.E8QI o,1risn-isH al mainsrloom airll lo luomsisla inoosi Isiflzouflrii iaom silT

.EEQ1 elerlaN gni'nI 10 noiaas-iqsU sill lo wsiv noilsflsb-ldsb auornsl sill ai airlT

vs

Page 30: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

aiaFio sill noriW •aFizq rhiw bobia orno5l bns alsaazna oarIs3aiaas smoa bobivrnq nobnoJ

Isril bobrrnrrisb tstoM bis rxgioio'c boiiailoa lnsmnisvo nsrrnoO ortt bris niFzaa ol hsszqa

orIi usc! bns anoiisiloon anoiisisqoi noqosi 01 iaoupoi air! wsibilhiw laiil aninthH iolloonsrC)

sill ol oiudiflnoo ol bosigs boI woW sill 'lo rioaFrisll .aqidaohisd lsAooq k noilotriuanoo

aonslaiaas Jscfj niisbnoi g)!nsd oils ol 3ib513 au bolirnil Ansdadois5l sill i '!rio naol riRmioD

-blog orb lo brinla anal aoam anT .mola'a Isiorisrift nsmisF1) sill nthoqqua io1 aasloau

.bslnnom aiana sib as onofla wsi 1ithunom bmbnsla

Isiunso bus alnomrjmvo orb lo aoaivbs oimonoao sill 03 bobnoixo àuiialnom airlT

lxEQ1 ui bouwts ssluimmoD usllimosM orb b iodmom 3asnuo'( oil) aniddo5I Ionoij .aio)!nscI

ad alaoa us Is laum aolsi aosw usd1 woiv orb 1o oans!svoiq sill iol nood Jon bsd ii II'

sill k oanoloiv orb iomuanoa sill k iowoq niasrIamq sill nisinism ol io&Io ui bonislnisrni

bluow Ii boinsqmooos asnl rloirlw lnonrr'(olqmonu sill lo abinirism sill bus noiaaoiqob irIoa5lq

asgsw iowol ,bisbnsla blog sill lo snousib sill ui asw1s aA 0t0.aaof yjdsiobianoa nood svscl

.mo1a'a oslsnorn orb 'd boiiupai rioilsflab sill bowolls svsil bluow

md uloJ sill no noilsligs laul Ion asw Ilsinwob amoJa'a usc!) ol bs! usilw bno sill nI

bns oimonoao lo losi orb moil 'go1oobi bisbrisla-blog lo nomsgsil sill ol ognollsilo sill

€asioiloq bmbnsla-b!og ol aevisainorll bsusoiboboi alrismnnovog siom silT .aaoilaib Isionisnil

olnoiiolob 01 bsunilnoo noilibnoo a'Inoilsq orb aA .omsood anoilibnoo oirnonooo oeiow orb

sonsi1 as gnol o2 .aoibsrnsi lsnoilnovrioornj iobianoo ol nsgscl aisvsilod srnl nova

bluos toil noiaasiqsU sill lo aIooe laiow orb bsuaiasi aoiilnuoo zulonoEl orb bns bnslissuiwa

.SOQ1 nonrisH

.ô81 .q 4CQ1 aniddo5I °

Page 31: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

.'xobor1tio 1nsbnsta-b1o 03 ovsolo ol oiulist tioril ol aiodrIion -norb lo 1c1i1q orb odiioas

orb bo1svstgs '1no oninflo'çila o aoeob bolsoqot bns boloolrri 010W aoimoriooo nwo iiorb 03fl0

.smooa asw asniltoob oimonooo Io Ionsaoiosa Thom orb non Jon noinbnoo

C

.uIJRnslia bolorbsg 'o1oobi auth ol noilieoqqo bonoqoob uioiaaolqoU orb aA

orb boauoqao odw atobsol Isoiiiloq bns atoirind lstlrioo orb joy .'11soii1oq bns 'llsoimoriooo

orb non bns JiIsrn oimonoos ]o oos orb iii rliis'x tioth oJ JoJstoqaob nu1o frisbnsia bIos

.Moali btsbnsTh b1o o113 k noilsigsiriiaib

jnomflhnmoo tioth bonobnsds srnmo1ib Ismaib all 1o anIon orb no lr1uso 4aithd orIT

a'Inormnovo ouT .IEQ! Ia Ilsi oil ni olsi boxil s Is blog tol '(OflOilnO rlaitha orisrIoxo ol

to tnsbiastq ab1on'(s5I .3 noaAosl to1 .nhsIJsrIa rlhso asw OiIiditiovnoo bnoqaua 01 noiaiosb

jioanilol moT R...b1tow orb lo bno orb oAiI' asy, Ji MaY woI4 lo InsH IsnoiisM iatiI orb

borriis1oxo '(Iauomtl jsoE svq btoJ bns bnsbooa tol '(islotooa 'isJriomsihsq iorntoI

'1lqs Ii oausosd '(!oa!oolq bolsidolso ai inocnmoo aiH lisrb ob blijoo ow an bloi bodoM'

.Inomrkmoia6 lo oansa gmlisvotq sill aosnsrnrniia

sill gnmrnlau2 .nooaotoI nosd svsrl bluorla bns auth mill ougis nao ono 4rfithnirf thiW

(l3nsaaooni atovoilod out sib as onioibom nlatsrl tol rlosmola £ boiiupoi btsbnsla b!o

ovsil 1r1311T1 33110 iBftt noiithoG .Iio lotas3 airli Jaoni 01 3ns13u151 atw todsJ .boisoqoi

aasm bus aodotsm iorwr1 bolovoiq won ato)how orb mon oonslqooos olum bolioilo

?lool bo'(olqmonu orb to oollimrrioD uloioil bs!-jairiummoD orb nismtoD iii .anoilsijanomob

asw (OEQI rlotsM) sU 1nomo1qmsriU Isnoilsinsinl .QSQ! tsdrnooou ni alasila sub ol

.E1I.q j'BQ! snuA ni bolD

Page 32: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

ouT .oDi1oq orb rbiw 2or12513 2uoh02 bum nnod1sg ogmi d aolsi2 botinlJ orb ni boAisrn

olfloiq-rlirl 'to ohsa s bogsl2 inornovorn 'iotoW bo'o1qrnorilJ lsnoiisM rlaitha

him 2oitiloq bosinsgio mon noitsnoils ot ho! bsrl notlo itsqaob bus ionuH .2noitsltanornob

aids ioflod 0I0W Won tio±ow boi'taimaaib lud aothsq isoin!oq bosinngxo rbiw tiiorntfisflorioaib

'to bsoiqa orb him aoitisq 10dB! bus t2ilsi3o2 lo 0211 orb ol sub 2noitoo,co ibiD ooiov ot

ot bottimmoo t!Isutooiiotni flnornmovo ov!ts'no2rIoo nova .os'i't'tua olnrn iseiovinu

.rlasblosd lsoili!oq s 3nitboni 'to 'mo't io't oeiuoo orb 'sta ot botstiasrl eomsom 'çmnoiisllob

botsiaoas nood but nobtsl'tob 01011w nisthd ni usd1 tno-mqqs oiorn 2irll 213W oiorlwol4

visIonoMjjQ_tonTrlT sAil 2noitBoiIduq ni aon'(oA .obsoob 5 101 tnonr(o!qrnonu r1irl 1111w

torriJ 3)111 alobsol iodsl botsoubo oot1irnrnoD nslhrnonM silt ot oonobivo otsvhq bus rrnp'toSI

asw nsrrnoM norlW .tnom'oiqmonu bus otsi irisH rioowtod anoiloonnoo orb tuods nivoH

him aonoA mofi Aostts bolloiisd-olduob s torn oil 00IThmm03 suit oiolod vlitaet ol bo!!so

moiI b1sbnBta b1o silt iol bnno't od bluorla tnomoos!qoi s lull bobubno3 nooa nivoH .nivoH

lo anoitibnoo orb 'to noilsloiiolob orlT]" ".nis ot bqoia aoazslo loitnol orb !no' rioniw

oonsnolnisrn orb iol 'sq ot oobiq s rliil ool asw" botnornsi or! "aioAiow 'to anoillim

nslIim3sM orb 'to 1-loqol mull orb bonia nivofi oliriW ta.flObflOJ ui gnbtnsd isnoiisrriotni...'to

.bonobnncfs oil bluorla rnole 0111 tsdl niugis tnoaaib s bolisib oafs oil ooflimrnoD

bluoa bns!n3 'to AnsH sill toAosj-tista airit rnoi't 'rnonoos orb niooñ ohriw nays tufi

iot'ts aolsi taoiotni oDubol 01 botnliaorl tI .1i!stnorn hisbnsta-b1o orb mad 1!oati son Ion

bFiow silt nifloa içisrzoilsftsb laom sift ru !noiisflrii .noijsImni bios's ot -zsbio iii noiisulsvob

.ô8I \tsT1ED £t

.o-eQ!.qq 1QI !noemnhlliW €a

OE

Page 33: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

s inso)sq 01 tuods ni1ls1 sisw asrilnuos Isitaubni Its iii asoriq nsilw jiwonA isvs asil

as aiM aA t'.booI1 a'rlsoM ni sii9 siFT (13 ot" •abiow tnsilan5lt ais'rtaado as iii esw

ot bsllaqmoo tIsi hue bonsH 'toM bns shoaM asmsl eieimono3o obhdmsD silt EQ1 snul

silt bus astn tasialni b nOi3IJbs1 silt nits3ovbs asiniT silT ol ions! isluoiio s fis-ib

tasisini 1113 03 bststiasil bnsln3 :10 AnsH silt 11113 .(sassnni on mssl Is io) asxst lo noiaaimsi

silt €l lo Itsil bnoosa silt ni !t11su1nsv .'(lsv035i io1 aulumila smoa sbivoiq bns estsi

laomls bloil ot bsunilno3 'tilsinsm blog blo sill" nsilt nsvs tufi .trlgil sill wse AnsH

tsivsnibns3a bns sMqmH en 1o ansq nistiid isa-if) ni iqs3xa "'(swa lswIsvinu

silt noi sulsvsb ilahui8 sill iol sgsa silt isa tu11 aicilo gnblnsd silt lo tluasi s cA

ton bib ismisW rlgrioili nsvH .snsiloxs ngisio1 ni eno osanst bstohtesi tnsminsvog nnmis[)

bithnsla blog sill lo hsmhlsil silt asw tsrli 'on5tiuo lo sine bus sasilomq s511 silt su1svsb

moil llsamirl san Ion bluoo bns1gnd lo AnsH silt sAil gninth8 tsY .bswolls -isgnoi on esw

silT .'nsmisD IsmisW iii ensioililoq sillo bluos oM bisbnsla blog silt 10 ètiistnsm silt

esw silt sausosd bisbasta blog sill no gnisd as 'nsmisD k Assqa ot bsunitnoo

silt to 'tivitos lstnamsbnul silt bstsloiv aloitnos 'onsriuo ilguoilt nsvs tiisq tn bsnistnism

silt sbsrn bns--sisilwsals bns noiaaiinmoD sllilnuD silt iii bston as -- bisbnste blog

lo asi-iomam 'd bstnusH tisttsm svitsitainimbs '1smq s ,'tiisq lo sonsnstrnsm

ol bsngiasb esioiloq suamq 01 bsunitnoo gninUifi elnow a'iloFisuulsH 'd bns noi1sflnhsqil

cuomsl aiH .bisbnsla blog sill lo onotsth '(1snoitsllsb silt bsilossiq bus gnibnsqa aesiqatos

F1 .q 8EQ1 e(51t'115H R

IV q EQ1 :tb5A35 aa

.t8Q1 1bisrloioH

IE

Page 34: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

'unrrnoD ro1'tn arilnorn xia 1EQ1 ,isdmoooU ni bouaai asw aooiiq tin gniotiboi ooiosb

.biog bonobunds hail 'ioviloo1'to

'toilod iiodl iii d3nasla ninismoi ,riiiEt orb Jqoi iovooH bus notioM nEooo orb eeoioA

bnuois boaqnhloD 'mono3o risoiiornA orb an novo bmbasla bloa orb 'to aiewoq ovilsino orb ru

iii '(oiloq t'isnoiionulnoo culT .1 EQI iodo1oO iii fpsr1a o1ni taoislni boaini b&I oriT .modi

noilossi Annd-hsilnoo oucanlo oil 25W ii ;'lqoru' ion enw oridoob oimonoos biqsi 'to labim orb

bIos sill 'to iowoq oil boboIwornbs xflswdoE bus nsmbohl .aiaixo bmbnsie-bJo s ol

:rioilostnoo nsonomA oil 'to inuooos iiorb 'to OelUoo orb ni noilos curb ru bmbnnia

es juinib isnioixo orb ol '(iiqmrnq bus 'ieuoiogiv bolosot rnoie' o'noaoM isiob&I oriT woW 'to svtoeo5l orb Q todoioO nO .nistb isrnoirui woivoiq orb oi ion hail ii

-41103 isq \1 C ol 41 iodoloO no bus moo ioq £\1 01 olin iruuoocihoi cli bsaiin thoY to oio'tod moiesa orb 'to vjomairl storiw orb ni bohoq £ loud oc nirbiw 3211 leoqisrlc orb

ni ovilooldo as an bolqooos anw btnbrrnla bios sill 'to oonsnsninm ouT sonic se 'ffsi ol 'bnoi 013W 2WOIV 'to onsx bsrnd £ 'to nom rloirlw 'to tioqque

looio-lnobic5Iq orb lailno oX ni'ol lqsA iovooH EQ1 'to noilooho orb niaoi iol'ts nov3

Jlovoaoo2 obirlo ol bolt iovooH ECQ1 ymindo en olal cA .bisbrznla bLo orb 'to ruoqquc ni

bssi binow rioilsuisvob msrb gniugis isI!ob sib 'to oohq biog or!) tioqqua ol mnomiimmoo s olrii

Is rboci noiioui1asb oioiqmoo ol absoi Ii lsrb Iiriisrroo orb ibiw isw oimon000 bliow £" 01

orb riliw holy Ji1oqcoiq nuioicoi 'to 1so silT .aovilom boxim bsrl octuoo 'to niruiha VC

oIsm ol mid boool bisbrisic bloR orb lsrb ougin bluoo giuinUiH .anoimsisqoi nibrio 'to mis ol 'li!idn a"aarrnoD lanisga oonobivo as oats bluoo norb or! amluaoi ocoriw anoilos 'çisnoimsl'tob

-bios orb 'to oonstioqmi orb dainimib ion ob anoiinoiiqmoo bobbs oaorb lufi .crioilnisqoi 'nq narrnoi) orb omnxtaoiq ol notriobnu svsrt Ion bluoo 3ninthd io1 .ii!smnom binbnsie

air! atooqana sno bnA .bisbnnia blo& sill 'to onomorli sib mail tioqqua muorbiw 'monooo oi i0B3 02 aaw oriw nohloM 'inmoioo2 'to oaoit nsrb boxim atom on ruood ovsul \csm aovilom

.E-E .qq O8Q1 csrnst ooE ir1ia ni nidtçovo olsbiupit

asnswilo2 bus risrnbioS ci 'iqoul" S8E CVIE .qq C021 stiswrJo8 bus nnmbioR .VO1 .q .bidI aoE .oi1oq bo9 'to noiissi-ioionnrlo

Page 35: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

'bscnds baa oritod

mom silt nova lsbrw tils1nsm lieu mofi bsqsoae svsd ot iseqqa slqooq sasdi lo snoW

as noL as iol asiailoq 'osnoiisflsb iiodt benistuism isvooH baa aninthfl .siuaasiq amsitxs

'(inswT .iawoq iaoI isili isfis nave macli noiqmsrb ol bsunitno '(alit bns 33it110 ill 313W '(3111

sill ninis3nism lo ioslIs silt null misI3 £EQ I aid '(lnivo1qqs bstsoqai isvooH !lsts! a•ma'(

lo istisidiD ano bsnistniam '(dslsdt svsrl oW" :aetsta betinU edt idi booa asw bisbnsla bloR

ad bisa ninitifl ô.aosdo 1o titamevom edt tens ot baiudiiinos bus J±ow silt iii '(iiIiclsia

lo '(13V0301 sib ion anoitsisqsi lo bno silt tnsam sH '.lso edt mail aiaJsm 001 nelisI bad

edt nithiw '(siB ol noed tsr! ailoq lsqoiq silt lailt tcluob on bslssvai oil tud tnem'(oIqmo

.lleati '(iiliditlsvnoo gninobnsda tafis nave fnsbnsta bfo sift lo thowamsil bus ohoteth

ii ansioiti!oq bns aisAnsd Isitrias no tils3nsm bisbnsta-b1o ath lo bloc! silt navif)

bits gninthd 10 3nstanoa !soio!oebi silT .'(oiloq sariads 01 qidaisbssl lo snsrla s Aoot

odw "aaslo gnitasvni" 'asn'{eA lo aiedmsm lo aslqmsxs anomal mom sift '(mo 515 isvooll

03 asaaslo nhods1 edt mon eiuaaq Aoot ii .aIsS nsa! '(fl5m nhiib tils1nam usd1 ot itiiIo

.etsloivni bevcnq ohototh lieu Ii aiebsel ninsda d a3i3iIoq oi!duq e2nsdo

lo atoells silT .anoitioqoiq 3i1112'(135t53 01 aeituidY '(1153 silt ni earn tnsin'(olqmsnU

riiiIsiomsb edt 01 '(!imsl s nibse1 lo qidahusil lsaia'(dq silt mail ,110i331 313W san audi

sw snO .tasloiq lo arrnol owl bawolls bluow iawlaoq silT ihow lo tuo niad lo 133113

tnsm'(olqmenu eviasvisq 3(13 hid ,anouasoao smoa no beFit 313W edT .anoitsutanomeb aasm

.EE21 usvooH

281 .q eE.v S2!1avooH Ob

2€ .q O82! ,asms

Page 36: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

.111w a'ioclsf lo noiaaoiqxo ns as ldhowoq bus oviiawifls aaol aoAhia obsrn

IsoiD orb 3101011 oaidonsfi orb lo noilsiimiJ .slov orb asw taoicriq lo rrriol bno3sa ouT

.onol1srlo Juoriliw olin bluioo bisbnsia blo orb lo 'oloobi orb rbirlw 111 '(SW ono asw isW

ounovs as aoftojooa Isiiiaubni cxi axohow nov12 bsd oeiilonnl OIII lo noiansixo thubsi2 orb fljfl

ooiov 01 r1uorio lud aqsrhoq boAil ovsrl 'sm '(0111 as noflo as loW .awoiv Modi aaoiqxo ol

.fIOiJ3sllnOa imoriooo lo tIsO'( 051113 10 OWl iolls bmbnsla bios orb ol noiliaoqqo norb

orb iofis nooa aoihsq isoiliioq isnoitibsil odi nobrisds ol usgod aioiov nsirnoO

rloirlw ninthH as Insbnsia blog edl ol boflimmoD as 510W aiailsiooa &!T .nsgod noiaasiqocl

nsrrnoO .aoioiloq vjsnoiansqxo OlOffi o1 tisq iiorb nirbiw ailso grnlooo1 '(11 boworla '(orb

OEQI orb ni gsiarloio$1 orb iii oorloaolq £ 01 '(tlsq oguifil £ rnoil aissM orb borrnolaumil aiotov

orb no noolqa iisrll bslnov noril aloiov silT VOl ol £ I mon alsoa usd1 griiasouoni '(ci uioiloolo

tori asri aia'1srm gniloV .alsoa OES now aissl4 orb noriw SEQ1 '(iuI. ni aoilusq lsnoilibnl

ai Ii lufi .anoilosls oaoub ni aolov issVl bnz lrlorri'(olqmonu noowlod noilslsrioo gnoula s bnuol

oimonooo orb lo lnobnoqsbni asw olov issM orb ni oah usluoslooqa orb isth ougis ol busH

noIst nsrll uodisi lasiouq lo oholorli orb riguouril bsiolIil siorI1 asw lriil ouT .rioilosulnoo

orb lo oriolorlu orb oislaim bluoo ono on 1l1la E%nom'(olqrnonu lo noilonul n as irigisula

.Iyisbnsla blog orb lo oiuolorh orb uol aisst4

SV-bI .qq 1ôQ1 .vlanul'(oW

uiorb boasouosb '(orb 1os1 ni .noiliaoq 'cubism s olni aissW orb olov Ion bib auoloV Jauft orb obsrri auoaaoooua a'nintha norlw StQl lo noiloolo bnoooe orb ni aissM orb uol Juoqqua oil bsolanl .busbnsla blog orb lo aoioiioq bns onolsuft orb gninobnsds buswol aqola ovilsinol

usrnioW orb giudnobnifl wolls 01 aissl4 orb no '1ilids1ooqaou riguono bouiolnoo auolov uovo oAsI 01 boboon aissW orb liz asw II .lriomnuovog orb olni aissM orb slivni ol inobiaoiq

noliimsH ooa .siqooq iorbo 'nsm bns nwo uiorb ol Ishg aaoibrio oauso brm 1oiooa nsrrnoO £821 auobludD ;S821

Page 37: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

jnobiaoiq boriismoi iovoofl as gaol o2 .iognol ñsw ot bsrl aoisiE botinU 3113 111

botov aio±ow orb CSEQI iodmovoM ni O3iorIo s noviD .'oiIoq boqsr!a aoaaslo gnitaovni orb

oriw onoomoa bisbrisia blog orb 1o anovsm uob orb oIil Its is ton bobnuoa oriw onoorrioa

tiorli bolIiIliEI i!ovoaoo5l .dll asaiiomA idI 0Th3 orb as ,noiisflob ion "noiisfloi" boblsiorl

norli bns EEQ! 431aM iii 031110 niAsJ toils 'Inoda htzbnsia blog orb gninobrisds d oisbnsrri

oi boIlsD .lu1 ru oorioiolnoD 3imorlooa bboW orli is muioi s oislqrriolnoo oi gniauI5I

iii saimrnq olin! bsrl oorio1noo orb bmbrista blog bomiist orb lo bsvsa od bluoo isriw sgsvlsa

ol gruillsngia !bonoqo non Ii otoled Ii belasid ilsvsaoo5l .EEQI lo anol ibrioo auobnotior! orb

orb lo ohoisrh out mail rnut qmr!a air! 22513 gn aovrn Isnoiismoini orb lo aiodmom iorbo orb

auoiooqa orb d bollul od gnol ion 111w bhow or!T" :ebiow ailovaaool ru .bisbnsia blog

orb no ogrlsrl3xo rugiouol ni 'oilidsia lsioilirxs ns 1dsdo1q bns 'çiffIoqmai £ gnivoirl3s lo sHs1

£ 2 noiisn £ lo noirnuiia olmonoos Ismoini bnuoa oriT ... Irio aohtrruoo ogtsl wol £ 10 nsq

tô!t\3noflhi3 an lo oohq orb nsrb gniod-llow an ni 101351 1015mg

blog orb lo Milsinem orb omrlw oonsiI iii gnimoo ni aiso' oslrli lliia asw ogrisrb airiT

bus ,ao'noaoi blog ogis! rbiw boisloqo oonsfI lo ArisE ouT .gncnia 'Fis1uoitxsq asw bisbrisia

orb is bisbrrsia biog silt lo rzoiisigoiaiaib out oi bsiudhiaoo bail bJo som iol stboqqs au

borusd rjonoiq silt 4nornmsvog ni aognsrlo auoruibuiiflum siiqaoU .aOEQl orb 10 gflinnigsd

bhow silt lo teom ioils ruovo uowoq molt ohoiorh fruabrusia-blog rbiw bosigsaib or!w ono'ns

gninismm orb bosinsgio 'orlT .iluaoi £ 25 '1ovoooi oirrionooo us nsgod bits blog bonobnsds

oorirnolrioD oimonooa bfuoW ovinocjz oili lo rlisrrnoils orb ni oold blog £ oinj aiovoilod oral

won isrb oa oaiuooaib bsioils bsrl noiaaoiqeCl orb 10 tsob,o ofiT .Qó.q QôQI noxiM oiow yxoborltio bisbrwia-blog molt anoiisivsb ,'flauoivoi ".Isioilitis" asw bisbnsia blog orb

.ailuem "Isioiitis" bisit oi bia

Page 38: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

oimonOoo boirnilnos lo sosi sill iii bmbnsl blog sill lo onoloth bsiil sift bslssqsi 'sill bns

.snilosb

bsisoovbs oilw sno'nn ioI lwol '(lao bsqolsvsb oup auJsta elift ol noiliaoqqo 31151q

bsrl lsth loilhno3 thnoiludiilaib sill gninsqorn lo bsauoos 2SW bisbnsta hog sill gni'1ibom

513W flOilBIJIsV3b '1o aslsoovbA .eOQ! sill lo lisil iwiiI sill iii oilduqs5l ilons3 sill bosisa

.noitsulsvsb larzxsgs "sbsaxno' £ bsrl3rnisl '(Jnsq sift lo nsbnsIsU "231151311" as bsornsonsb

oi iss!o asw bsudmi 515W bisbasla blog sill iii eisvsilsd sun doiilw ilhiw iov-isl auoigilsi silT

.ssa

S sisimujsJ lo iolibs ahoH asiosO .bsilqilhsm asils'isil sill '(Isuja lix! '(Iwola

idI Ilso oh mil 3111 gnorns asw ,asitxsq Isoililoq loism sill lo lnsbnsqsbni isqsqawsn 1IAssw

iii noilsulsvsb io'I bsugis ,snonslsq bnom's2 1ai1sniuo[ lnsbnsqsbni isrilonA .noilsulsvsb

atow oilduq '1o noilqobs sill gniflirnisq bus hivi1os otmonoos gnibomoiq '1o '(SW B as EQ1

silh sisilw bns1n3 slil ashlnuoo 'lo s!qmsxs sill '(ci bsonsullni asw silonslsq .asvilsihini

nzioihiloq mssxlanism laiil silT .'(monoos sill bsvivsx hsrl noilsufavsb Isill angia '(bEslis 515W

ism-tol s ,busn'(sM ,tEQ I iii noilsulsvsb o'1 bsllsa oilw ,busns5I ius anw dan iisilh fl!O 01

b ishoqque smil-guol bns nunlosqa lsoibiloq sill 'to lilgii slnsbom sill no sonsrnl 'to ishainim

siom aqsthsq ,bns qmula sift 'to sonstaiaisq silt '(4 bstrnvnoo asw b1sbrwha Mog sill

bisbnsla sill '(lqqs '(llulaasaoua oh ainsmmsvog donsfl 'to '(hilidsni sill '(d ,'(llnsflOqmi

.snioibsm 'isnoibnflsb

siom has siom gnimoosd" asw noiniqo ilonsfl Isill bisa sd bluos Ii EQ I-Mm 1H

OE

Page 39: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

won orb o3sldms ol oldiaaoqrrü ii bnuol iowoq a! oaodt luff tótt0jjjjJy0 ol bsIi3noosi

bo'(oi boiioq sill 10 alriomrnsvo 1E3!bf51 him lrnodiJ bsoi-odt-io-olbbim ouT .evilooqnoq

osibisqoo Ion bib oa gniob JErli Inoixo sill 01 '1no lud asyilsilini '(-lsnohsflsl lo <Ioi1sv s riliw

orb lrlauoid risiriw !noiloolo ÔEQ! orb AooI II .lnomflmmoo blsbnsia-b!oR oldsloivni orb

1OJXIU .3i1oq simonoso lo '(lilsinom bus FioIorh orb rrnolanst ol 13woq ol inoii is1uqo

iii as noi1snJsvob siow afloilqo '(mo ouT .luo boim asw noilsilob isritiLfi 3noi isIuqo orli

113111W lo noiiaoup on 25W oiorli o3ns1l i&I .'(nsrrnsD ni as a1o1Jno3 ognerlaxo 10 nisth8

bns laiSl oIiI bisbnsla bloa orb lo wiobnolob rlonusla nova .wolIoi ol olqmsxo Isnoilsn

213 bolailno bns sldslslsqnu as aoioiloq oI'(Ia-nsmloD lo noilqobs orb wna nitmM-nisrrnoD

.noilsutsvob lo 2lStlOqqlJ2 Jnsiouloi

olsi sill 10 mood no1 orb gnFiub boqolovob bsd bisbnsla b1o orb 10 àii!slnom ouT

olsa s boairnolq bus I 113W bhoW lo Aoorla orb bovinua ii .aonulnoo r1IO '(bso bus rIIQ!

1or1ons all .asoa oimonoos bus Isoniioq jsiooa '(mloIa '(ci boloIIud olsia lo eqiria io'i navsrl

•lso!is aoimonooo orb niqooA nub ioHlaSI .aJ!oon iiorll bnuois onolallim s bovoiq jovoworl

.morb lnia ol boqiorl Ii

nilo5noo-i1oa Irihswoq rbiw bowobno ai oos aionoado leorri '(mono3o bhow ouT

oonuod ol Ii iol '(onthnoi £ obivoiq aniA-iow ionni ali nwob arnul liviIos nodW .aoionebnol

ii isril rbsq alit? Ito isi oa '(1n0n03o bhow orb avith aso aoioiloq bsd bonirJaua 1nO .Aosd

diol no AoinoM .M (111w woiviolnl us io oIoW ô! l\88lT ooiuiO biosoB oilduq diiha .OVE .q e2221 nsoinsdoi3 ni boli3 "&Ql 'sM

VE

Page 40: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

01 wiebse! oonivnoo uso 'oIoebi ornomeged s 'lno bnA Jevo35I ol 'liosqso all aoaol

.2$13110q evilouboiqiolnuoc rloua iii laiaioq

!io onolorb s 'c1 borioqqua 'goloebi ornomeorI £ doua Jeu bobivoiq bmbnsia blo edT

oioled aiso'( edt ni yoiloq oilduq lo noiaau3aib belsnimob 3rloierh all .ebunJ3sl brm '(li1sIom

boaoqmi '(sill as aisbsst lsoitiloq him aiolrisd lstnoo benislaua Ii him ,rioiaaoiqeG isoif) orb

ol lcisIaiaei bovoiq hisbnsla bloR edt lo li1slnom edT .olqooq '(isnibio no 21203 IOIsSI iOVO

"t1Id2It10425 a' IMW" .233fl5i2fflhJ3i13 oimOnOoo lo niaaoiq taom orb isbnu nova ognsilo

bloR orb boilno ax tsdw r!oidw bloc! '(isnihiositxs orb ai" EQl 111 be'neado lJeAosl8 liasfi

.a!nsfl IsitnoD a'bliow edt lo aoithorltus did orb noms '(Ilsi3Oqae benlstdo and '(lilsInem

cxi a)Insfl IsilrroD Ia abwoa srIJ 'Ia 311102 ioI noiiloi a omnooed asil bisbnsia blo ouT

us 'Io eldsqsoni moth aeARm doidw 'iuovxo'I Isnobome us dliw ni bevelled oqomd IsinonilnoG

'.aovi1srnolIs oldiaaoq lo noilsnimsxe evitooi o bus be3ibi4eiqnu

lo mitt qirlaiobsef won iobnu '(thoqarnq 5101251 01 o!inIa orif nsod (mo aOrrlffUoD

.aowl auoivoiq ni hisbnsla blog edt lo 3nolorh orb ol 'flsq need ton bsc! or!w a!subivibni

atadnoxoa blo norlw eoslq eAst noflo anoilulovsi ollitnsioa Isdi ogs nso' bougis ndu2 asmodT

nfl gnilsoovbs 20110 WOfi d bsoslqoi eis mgibsisq Mo us 01 boisrlbs l1asIbso1a 011w

ol aOEQI edt iii ioiaso bevoiq if .mgibsisq bisbnsla-blog orb diiw asw Ii o2 Só.ovbsmolls

mseitanism gnoms weiv lsnoilnovnoo edt b Inemeitla 1110351 iaoisolo sill aqsdie .aQQI oAriscrxeH ax 1noiaaeiqeU iseif) ecu ot beilqqs as atairn0nO3s

orb lo adtqeb orb Is nova .lnenitnoD odt no '(mo ton bnA .IV.q CQl 1teAosI8 aniddo5l .noiisllob iedtxul io'I llso bluoo aniddo5l (bioJ isis!) Ionoij oAil olqooq noiaae'iqeU

nsrb ierbo oh rmo atneve bhow lo io'noado Isitisqmi '(lissi on" Isrlt evoilod ol beunilnoo taii'I orli 'Io eriqoilasiso £ 25 nisthfl isoiD '(d bisbnsla blog odt lo lnomnobnsds edt bisgei

.Vl l.q €EQI aniddo5l ".obxflingsrn lo iefrio

.&Ql nduN

8E

Page 41: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

.modt tiovnoo ol nEil 'o1oobi aidi dtiw bsDlu3ni aiobsol ooslqoi

aw Ii doidw rhiw 'goIoobi binbns1a-b1o oil bus aasI3 Laoiflloq aid! '(IOiErfliilU

bus 2lainoiisftob boliod-bwd odT" .norJ3uruasb (iwo iS!) Io abosa oil) bonis)no3 houdini

iuq 'çisioqmoinoo ono as ttthnsd iiedi bo's1qiovo 1qmia sis aid! lo aiainoitsbiupi! bno-ioflid

Io inuoms edt ot bne on oi1duq oub 1o nsq or!) no oonsiubno lo timil on bosingooo-i '(silT" ii

bsd oil3 iollcn mssia s '(il iovo mix need bzrl ysdT...otl bluoo olqooq edt tsr!) inomdauriuq

msoia aid! tsd! betiw Ii mill Ilita '(silT .noiisupo nsmurl orb '(lomsn n!ffIO3 nosa tori

binbnsla blo orb o '(lilsinom orb siolod oohq dirl s bisq bFtow edT '.nols orriso iolloi

.'çxovoooi oimon030 ol aol3stado orb nivomoi islloi msola nscnuc! aid! 'd benolisfl asw

.V2S .q IE21 •oiba

Page 42: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

23311313132

'OiaiovinU olsY :novsH woW nsmxsftk 'nsvoooM ounonoo3riI !(QQ1) aomsl jiogriA .aaoil

SI :aIlrisT (bo) ogbhovod msiIliW ni 81 ialqsrb 'sbsiT lo oorzslsa oñT" .DYI jnsñnofl .OÔS-4$&qq EQ1 ansmnoJ :nobnoJ eboflurnsX3 OaSD

:ogbrxdrnsD) IEQI .2iaiO LB1311s11i1_SUQ vosrno!giQStkaa vcrnrrnoD .W Jrmwb 3ionnod .(ôQ1 '(lialovinU bisvmll

orli lo noiisgsqoll orb ni aiai-C) 15131151119 orb 1 alooTIJ 'QslorlomnoW (E8Q!) nofi oAnsrnoH .ÔVS-V?S.qq EV woivol 3imonood nsoimrnA "jioiaaoiqsfl IsoiD

ovisiaqmoD A :rioiaaoiqoU isoiD orb lo aoirrion030cuiosM orIT" tRI) nofi O)!flsniOfl .8-I.qq 2nb!nsHn& lihoiD .vsnoMj Isnmol "rbsoiqqA

riosiD ansmgrioJ :ncthnoj !bonicnsx3 oasDSI :fliisT jEQ!) .Is 10 rnsilliW ii8 ogbiiovoH .(rzoinba ishiqoq)

.oD bas oldzlanoD :nobnoJ yonoM bonnslq EQ1) •q hasH iiots1fl

iii nisthd isoiD bowohho9 ovsH trismioD bluorle bus blijoj" (I8Q1) ninA ibisr1aioH .VQ-IV1 .qq ,E1 yxoiaifl oimonooa nsociowdlo Isrrnjoll "clnthnsia MoD aiJi nivsoJ

voihoqbfIS vioiaiH simonoop nsmioD cnoboM aoviioogtio (1QQ1) tunA tthsdoioH .(aaofl tnaIovinU ogbhdmsD :obiicimsD)

gniqootauoll bootY s as bisbusi2 bloD silT" e(ÔQQI) IIoAsoSI uigull bus ,IosrIoiM obioH .8-Q8E .qq ,ô vioieiH oimonosd Isinuot "'1svoiqqA lo Isoa

:sbjiduuisD ,EQ1-QfQf .bscna2oiDjfils rnailstiosD daiiiifl ,(V8Q1) .U.W tiodo2 ,33'(OH

.aaoll liwiovinU obhcJmsD

iI.ha& asrlosoTjj rIoidW anoaoJSI :aiaiiD bhoWjrff ,(SCQ1) ihqoaot ,xusllisD .noaiobnsa-nobdoD :nobnoj po1s1iaaoooMiJ rIoidW sonoba oimonoo3lo ainorulautbA

bus aoimonoaH oil :haiM isvlia bus noilqmuao5l hssdnosiD" (4QQ1) aohiiuhD aiiimoIsD bus obiofi hosiloiM cit "OOQ1-b8! ,aolsl8 bolinU orb ni ognsrlD omigo2 'cisionoM 10 aoiii!oq

'liaiovinU ogbiidmsD :ogbiidmsD enOiii2nsiTjij aomioB 'nsionoM ,Cabo) oiqsD iaono2 •aaoiq

.vnsrrnoDjfl rnaioa&ljQ anoitsbnuo9 hsioot5l :ioioV issW4I 28Q!) asrnorlT ,aiobhiiD .ao1I sniloisD rinoM 10 '(liaiovinU :hlill IoqsrlD EEQ1-Q!Q!

o1

Page 43: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

ovis51 1Eisbs :*ioY woW 1E-lQI .noitsiogooD Ansfl lntnoD JVÔQI) .0 .V noilqol2 oths1D .AioY woW lo 1ns8

:±oY woW mei1siisgrnI r1ifl jj A.çfijij lnsmtasvnl anoaxov0 8QI) lsncIoiM 1nisialobJ .aiq '1ieioviciU rndmuloD

•agoiq yfigijjgjTJ sisY :novsH woW ,nsJIoU (ttQ1) .U.J oibJ

noiaasigoG iEsD.ith..ku bbnsia bloDidi :aio11o1 nobloD (SQQ1) 'orn nsonscIoid •a2Olq tlinovinU biolx0 :AitoY woW

iii 'çiovooo5l oimonoo3 him asisM onsdoxd' ,(t8QI) adosa 'offio1 him 'çnsfl noonor1oid .à1-Q .qq .violaill oimonooJjQ 1srnuo1 "aOEQI orb

.aaoiq '1iaiovinU hioIx0 :toY woW tobioaiU isoDçff JEQQI) bisioD nsffthI&1

.aaoiq 'tinovinU olsY :novsFl woW ioArisa a'bhoWdI :ogoiud !(OEQI) tiotholl aio4

J £Oi 10m01103d "{anoiaaoiqoG IsoiD lo woW noiislloU-idoU edT" j&Q!) niviI iedaM .VE-VEE.qq

.3111 inofl aehsdD bits tiodlA :toY woW a'obsisq (8$SQI) xobbsM bio bicR

'naiovinU abhdmsD :ohiidmsD 4jJ_IsiodiJ3_aiahDsdT e(EQQI) .1. as1uoU di'axoI .aaoiq

-Vô81 .aoiRl2 bolinlJ oSlo v-xolaifl vislsiioMA Stmwdoa I snnA him noiIiM nsrnbshI .(EôQ1 ea5I ylinovinU nojooniiq :noioonii) oöcfl

.rlowonsvol oonfl lnuoomll :tc,Y woW noiaaoipsG JsrnD..Qff (ô8Q1) .A cxr1o izrisO

•j0q :aiisq Vetupi ermod si ma auon-asmmo2 (4EQI) aiuoj nitisM-nisrrnoD

isdrno3oU 4nomvsq anoiisisgoMjth 1sioneD-1neAS.k txogo5l (\tQ 1) is)h5 2 nod1iD .01

nioio1.him vonoTIuD..gQ noiaaimmoD..dLk flogol mhoipl inN (8IQ1) nisthS isoiD .S81Q .bD j&.ith ioñA aonsdoxa

•eaoiq tiiaievinU noioonjiq :notsonii9 ViohiH beioV oriW (8Q 1) bisdoiM noi1irnsH

.nooiD ansmnoJ :nobnoj aa_Ansa3 'rwlnoDA (8EQ1) dqisSI soi1wsH

.(hloilnl aiuod .armii) riscjinoD irlqTobA edT :±oY woW yonoM (VrQ1) lisA dthoullsH

Page 44: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

bn fniai,crimo3 'EE?I ,EI vjfilnd&1 aaaibbA U rilooniJ" (EEQ1) .fl tiochsH 1nvooH .(EEQI 81 muid&I) 8E-ÔEII .qq ÔEI olornoifiD !fiiOf1EfJiI

.nsllirrnsM :*ioY woW aiiomoM (SQI) .H tiochofl iovooH

bloD silT (.bo) biB1Io onbi2 ni 'jioilslloU bas bisbnsl2 b!oi) silT" (OVQI) .1..! srrwH .qq nourIioM :nobnoj aisW..ji noowisH aoiaiIoq 3nornvolgmH.kua frisbnsi2

:biohO ôEQI-T&QI .oimonoo& aoiiilo'1 :gmul2 nsmioOdI Ø8Q!) b!oiall sm& •2aoiq nobnsislD

.doadouH .W 11 :toY woW igiflA srJi iismo (Q1) 2$ITIEt °'(0 bns blolnobioW :nobnod ?1is'T vosoornoU fmrrneO biU ydW :mmisW (OQQI) nsl wsilwwA

.noalooiVl

:nobnoj 0551iti0 230psupoanoD oirnonoof.iI (Q!Q1) hmn'zM nrlo eon'oN .iinllitnosM

.nsI1irnoM :nobnoJ crno1s5l ymionoM no_totiTA (E&Q1) bmnnM nrIol oirsN

,vonoM.jj 1oiotnI .tnsmvotgrnEIi 'nosilT IinsnoQjff (ôEQ1) bmn'sM nrIo1 aonsA .nBIhrnoslvI :nobnoj

o 'VkisvinU :ogzoirfD anoiiuIovo5{ oiThnoioEjQ sluJouhtpQfff (rô1) .2 aBU1OIIT ,IIEIIJA

•aaoiq osoiil3

mocriD :nobnoj IEQI iii bisbrmi2 MoO anisthUj sitifiH silT JV8QI) .H onsiU snuA .mIoH

o3bhdmsD :obhdmsD 1E4SQ1 .yoiIo1 v-intonoM rIi1hH VQ!) 2 .0 ogbhggoM •aasq iinovinU

him nibns1nobn1J oirnonooH :sworxioq oonnq aS ni&nnsM ,( I QQ I) dionno)1 èiijoM '(Ji1ovinU obijcIcnsD :oabhdmsD OEQI-8Q! .voiloCl vmtonoM ilonit1..qj lniinianoD Is3itiIo'T

.aa5fl

•eesq osoiilD lo '3ieiovinU :ogsoidD aisWjfi noowloff nisthd QI) .J asfistiD tzwoM

- LEQI '(lEunsi nis11A nioioqbns jlovoaoo$I.U ni1AnsiI (QOQI) .bo .fl 1Eba noxiW •eaoiq ytitiovinU brnvmfl :ogbiidrrmD j .IoV 4EQI 'inind&1

.1$QI arioiiM o ougsal :svonO !oononogxa vonorwD lsnoitnrnolnl (1EQ1mnM oe*iuM

Page 45: II-IE OOFD 2IVMDVI D VI4D tHE - NBER...1".atflsVs rluoilt1A ataimonoos minis ot bnntaisbnu 'nsm atosqas lb sib lnsmqolsvsb lo 'çitioqmstnoo aoirnonoos isrlt siulinl ot sbivcnq n lnsisdoo

.nobnoj 4otsM vonoM oclflo noinjlovH anT jIQ!) .T a1113

.nnllimosM :nobnoj noiaarngoU lsoiDaff (NQI) b'o1J aniddo5I

:11 IH IoqsdD goiuH.iij oxisnimob5lq rIan&13 DEI.jLff (ôVQ!) .A noriqeta aoAutha .aaotl £nulois3 rifloM lo 'cliaiovinU

.ftEQI noaisW baa noalocloil4 :nobnoj) vc1gnoido1nAjth qilicN jiobwona

•aaoiq TIM :obhcfm3 1noiao-igoU rnoiDçfi mofi anoaa&J (Q8QI) 10jq !nurnT

bioxO :toY W314 noiaaoigoO isoiD iovooH tiochaH ,(QtQ!) !noF'(EO einaH jwnsW .223q hemvin1J

yisionoM anoaai 1sib&I1o vano1a'no3flfi yois-u2 ouT (IQQI) .3 bivnU pbolo&IW •2251q 'JiaisvinU obiidrnsD :ogbhdmn3 .EE-4Q1 .voilpq

:.sM obiidms3 EII-O88I .inuoooA fsnoiisminJ rbnoftjf[ (EEQI) .U vrmfl aiidW •231q 'iinovinU bisvisfl

jfi .3uil0q daithd :lnomrnovoO IsnoitsMq eithD 1snoiiM .(IQQI) qiIirN !rloadnsiHiW •31q '(lialoviflU obhdmn3 :bhdmE3 EQ!-ôQI .axigrnH.hu& vmonooJ

.bmuasV :toY wJ4 pspaaq yrnioia j1ôQI) .2 .W '(knii'(oW

Et