icma 2014_panel 2_raul delgado wise
TRANSCRIPT
Migration and Development in
Latin America: the emergence of a
Southern perspective
Raúl Delgado Wise
Migration and Development in Latin America
The analytical point of departure: development theory and practice
Import Substitution Period: emphasis on internal migration and the dynamics of urbanization
Neoliberal and post-neoliberal Period: emphasis displaced from internal to international migration
Three alternative views: the perspective from the North, the Transnational framework and the perspective from the South
The Southern perspective
It does not entail the negation of the North, but rather the negation of the negation
Atempt to build an integral, inclusive, emancipatory and libertarian perspective
A view grounded on a Critical Development Studies standpoint
Key theoretical and methodological matters
Disentangle: a)The characteristics and main contradictions of neoliberal globalization (i.e. capitalism and imperialism today)
b)Main features of unequal development: the new international division of labour and the new dynamics of unequal exchange
c)The nature of contemporary human mobility: forced migration (the migration and labour question)
d)Analytical framework and alternative research agenda socially committed
Key analytical dimensions
Neolib
era
l G
lob
alizati
on
Neolib
era
l Glo
baliz
atio
n
TRANSITIMPACTS ON
ORIGEN
IMPACTS ON MIGRANTS AND THEIR FAMILIES
IMPACTS ON DESTINATION
ROOT CAUSES
Regional integration, development and migration
Messo level of analysis. Latin America divided:
Mexico, Central America and the Caribbean (Free Trade Agreements with the US). Hegemonic perspective
South America (UNASUR, South American Conference on Migration, alternative development projects—Vivir bien, Buen vivir, XXI Socialism, ECLAC manifesto): counter-hegemonic initiatives + Cuba
Internal, international, transit and return migration
Highly-skilled migration and restructuring of IS
Growing selectivity of migratory flows (fact and strategy)
Brain circulation and gain: Naïve, interested vision
Need of contextualizing the analysis: restructuring of innovation systems under the aegis of neoliberalism
The exportation of highly-skilled labour configures a new modality of dependency. The challenge: to promote alternative development strategies
US: Labour growth 2000-2010
Source: SIMDE, estimations based on CPS, March supplements 2000-2010
Str
ate
gic
ind
icato
rs
Contribution to US GDP Growth 2000-2010
Sources: SIMDE, estimation based on US Bureau of Economic Analysis, Gross Domestic Product by Industry Accounts, 2000 a 2010, and US Bureau of Census, CPS, March supplement, 2000 to 2010.
Str
ate
gic
ind
icato
rs
33%
Source: SIMDE, estimations based on CPS (1994-2008); CONEVAL , Línea de pobreza en México y Anuario de Estadísticas Educativas en México, 2008.
Emigration cost for Mexico vs. Remittances 1994-2008
Billion US dollars
Str
ate
gic
ind
icato
rs
The debate on public policies: migration management
National security doctrine (unilateral position contrary to international rights)
Principle: adjust supply to demand in destination countries (labour matching): corporate-driven public policies + temporary workers programmes
The remittances myth or mantra
The debate on migration policies: migration governance
Human security at the centre (this is not a premise contrary to national sovereignty, but coherent with the principles of equitable and sustainable human development)
Human rights at the centre (to defend a proactive and not only reactive and defensive attitude)
Tackle the root causes of the problematic and not only its consequences: reduce asymmetries and social inequalities, encourage free circulation regimes and promote decent work for everybody