icadv—09-10domestic violence homicide: social impact and community costs the impact of domestic...

42
ICADV—09-10 Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Upload: sydney-erik-garrison

Post on 16-Jan-2016

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

ICADV—09-10 Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs

The Impact of Domestic Violence

Homicide,October 2010

Page 2: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

On October 1, 2010, ICADV Released Its

Domestic Violence Homicide Report: June 2009 – May 2010

Page 3: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

ICADV examined the circumstances surrounding 76 domestic violence homicides in a recent, one year period and shows that when domestic violence homicide occurs, it is men who kill their partners and former partners, as well as their children.

Page 4: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Why Should

YOU Care?

Page 5: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

WHO IS AFFECTED BY DOMESTIC VIOLENCE?

EVERYONE

Page 6: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE HOMICIDE

A TRUE STORY

Page 7: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

1975

THE STORY BEGINS

Page 8: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Police did not arrest even if assaults were serious.

No Order of Protection was available for Police to enforce.

Page 9: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

The murderer’s sister & family (4).

Page 10: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Dead wife’s brother & his family (5).

Page 11: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

One (1) wife murdered.

1978

Page 12: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

The dead wife’s two (2) parents.

Page 13: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

One (1) 11-year-old son witnessed

murderof mother.

Page 14: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Students at son’s school (50).

Page 15: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Neighbors at four different residences

(30).

Page 16: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Church friends (30).

Page 17: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Other community members (5).

Page 18: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Friends (5).

Page 19: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Police/Fire/Health Professionals (30)

Page 20: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

This woman’s death effected 163 people throughout

the community.

Page 21: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Cost Associated with Investigating, Trying, and Incarcerating

Perpetrator of 1 DV Murder Clean-up of murder site: $2,400 Casket/funeral: $7,445 Autopsy: $2,500 Law enforcement costs: $5,600 Trial costs: $45,000 5 years in prison: $111,000 Total: $173,945*

*Figures based on data presented in The Cost of Murder, The Tennessean. http://tennessean.com/apps/pbcs.dll/section?Category=NEWS1302, retrieved 7/18/06.

Page 22: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Murdered victim’s lost income for her family was $900,000.

30 years lost income at $30k a year.

*The figures are based on data presented in The Cost of Murder, The Tennessean. http://tennessean.com/apps/pbcs.dll/section?Category=NEWS1302, retrieved 7/18/06.

Page 23: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

In MAY 2002, the same man killed his 14

year old daughter in her maternal grandparent’s home, and then set it on

fire.

Page 24: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

This same man killed his second wife’s sister (4).

Page 25: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Second wife’s parents and family (12).

Page 26: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Second wife (1).

Page 27: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

•Police/Fire/Health Professionals (40).•High school freshmen(130).•Church friends (30). •Friends (10).•Other community members (5).

Page 28: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Domestic violence program staff (10).

Page 29: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

These two deaths impacted 243

people.

Page 30: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Sister’s lost income(30 years @ $30k/yr):

$900,000+

Daughter’s lost income(40 years @$30k/yr):

$1,200,000(DHHS, CDC, 2003 Costs of Intimate Partner Violence Against

Women in the United States)

Page 31: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Cost Associated with Investigating, these 2 DV Murders and 1 Suicide

Clean-up of murder site: $7,200 Casket/funeral: $22,335 Autopsy: $7,500 Law enforcement costs: $16,800 Total:

$53,835*

*Figures based on data presented in The Cost of Murder, The Tennessean. http://tennessean.com/apps/pbcs.dll/section?Category=NEWS1302, retrieved 7/18/06.

Page 32: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

1975-2002

1 perpetrator shoots and kills 3 family members.

Page 33: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

406 people affected

6 communities

$3 million lost income

$227,780 cost to taxpayers

Page 34: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Taxpayer costs higher

Trial $90,000 20 years in prison $888,000 Wounded-Hospital

$48,000 Total $1,026,000

Page 35: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Is Domestic Violence a private matter?

Could these murders have been prevented?

1978 - NO2002 - YES

Page 36: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Sheriff did not fully understand domestic violence dynamics or IDVA.

Deputies were not adequately trained.

Deputies did not follow up.

Page 37: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Lack of coordinated response between jurisdictions.

Access to guns and no consequences.

Page 38: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Unfortunately, this story is all too common.

Page 39: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Your Town, IL:

# murders in # years for an average of #

people affected

Page 40: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

Cost Associated with Investigating, Trying, and Incarcerating Perpetrators of # DV Murders

Clean-up of murder site: $ Casket/funeral: $ Autopsy: $ Law enforcement costs: $ Trial costs: $ 5 years in prison: $ Total: $*

*Figures based on data presented in The Cost of Murder, The Tennessean. http://tennessean.com/apps/pbcs.dll/section?Category=NEWS1302, retrieved 7/18/06.

Page 41: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

WHO IS AFFECTED BY DOMESTIC VIOLENCE?

EVERYONE

Page 42: ICADV—09-10Domestic Violence Homicide: Social Impact and Community Costs The Impact of Domestic Violence Homicide, October 2010

To read the full report on Illinois domestic violence homicides, go to

http://www.ilcadv.org/dkdkdkdk