ibm - motion for contingent stay
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 IBM - Motion for Contingent Stay
1/10
]IBVMF ZVKVMZ FBZVPBJV JC]PV
ZC]VDMPIFBZVPBJV CG GACPBFK
[ZOB! BIJ)!
Xakbivbgg!
w)
B@E OAC@KA GBIKIJBIO kif
BIVMPIKVBCIKA @]ZBIMZZ
EKJDBIMZ JCPXCPKVBCI!
Fmgmifkivz)
Jkzm Ic) 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP
B@EZECVBCIGCP K JCIVBIOMIV ZVKRCG VDM FMKFABIM GCPGBABIO MTXMPVFBZJACZ]PMZ KIFPM@]VVKAPMXCPVZ
Fmgmifkivz Bivmpikvbcika @}zbimzz Ekjdbimz Jcpxcpkvbci kif B@E Oac`ka
Gbikijbio $jcaamjvbwmar! Fmgmifkivz cp B@E"! x}pz}kiv vc P}am ;7$`"$6" cg vdm
Gmfmpka P}amz cg Jbwba Xpcjmf}pm! dmpm`r ecwm vdbz Jc}pv gcp k jcivbiomiv zvkr cg vdm N}ar
;0! 08;0 fmkfabim gcp B@E vc zmpwm bvz pm`}vvka mtxmpv pmxcpvz kif kzzcjbkvmf fbzjacz}pmz)
B@E zmmlz vdbz zvkr `mjk}zm Xakbivbgg [ZOB! Bij) $[ZOB" dkz icv zmpwmf
bvz xpbijbxka mtxmpv pmxcpvz kif kzzcjbkvmf fbzjacz}pmz! dbjd mpm f}m ci N}im ;0! 08;0)
[ZOB ecwmf vdm Jc}pv gcp ki mtvmizbci cg vdbz N}im ;0 fmkfabim $kz maa kz! mggmjvbwmar!
vdm mivbpm zjdmf}am" $Mtvmizbci Ecvbci") B@E cxxczmf vdbz ecvbci ci vdm opc}if vdkv
[ZOBz zcam `kzbz gcp zmmlbio ki mtvmizbci bz bvz gkba}pm vc xpczmj}vm bvz jkzm! dbjd bz icv
occf jk}zm) $Zmm Fmgmifkivz Cxxczbvbci vc Xakbivbggz Ecvbci gcp ki Mtvmizbci cg Vbem
vc Gbam Mtxmpv _bvimzz Fbzjacz}pmz $N}im 08! 08;0! MJG Ic) 24")" [ZOBz Mtvmizbci
Ecvbci bz j}ppmivar xmifbio `mgcpm vdm Jc}pv)
B@E dkz fbabomivar xpmxkpmf bvz fmgmizm kif bz xpmxkpmf vc zmpwm bvz mtxmpv
pmxcpvz ci N}ar ;0! jcizbzvmiv bvd vdm mtvkiv zjdmf}am) Bg! dcmwmp! vdm Jc}pv dkz icv
fmjbfmf [ZOBz Mtvmizbci Ecvbci `r N}ar ;0! B@E jc}af `m pm{}bpmf vc zmpwm pm`}vvka
Jkzm 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP Fcj}emiv ;8; Mivmpmf ci GAZF Fcjlmv 8?#80#08;0 Xkom ; cg =
-
7/31/2019 IBM - Motion for Contingent Stay
2/100
pmxcpvz xpbcp vc pmjmbwbio [ZOBz xpbijbxka pmxcpvz) Vdkv c}af `m baacobjka kif
bijcizbzvmiv bvd vdm zjdmf}amz zm{}mijbio cg pm`}vvka pmxcpvz vc gcaac xpbijbxka pmxcpvz)
Bv c}af kazc jk}zm kzvmf mggcpv! kz maa kz xpmn}fbjm vc B@Ez kif bvz mtxmpvz
xpmxkpkvbci bi vdbz jkzm)
Kjjcpfbioar! B@E kzlz vdm Jc}pv vc zvkr vdm N}ar ;0 fmkfabim gcp B@Ez
pm`}vvka mtxmpv pmxcpvz kif kzzcjbkvmf fbzjacz}pmz! kz gcaacz> Zdc}af vdm Jc}pv opkiv ki
mtvmizbci cg [ZOBz vbem vc zmpwm bvz xpbijbxka mtxmpv pmxcpvz! B@E pm{}mzvz k zvkr cg bvz
N}ar ;0 fmkfabim }ivba :8 fkrz kgvmp vdm fmkfabim zmv `r vdm Jc}pv gcp [ZOB vc zmpwm bvz
xpbijbxka mtxmpv pmxcpvz kif fbzjacz}pmz);
Zdc}af vdm Jc}pv fmir [ZOBz pm{}mzv gcp ki
mtvmizbci! B@E zmmlz k zvkr cg bvz N}ar ;0 fmkfabim }ivba ;8 fkrz kgvmp vdm fkvm cg vdkv
fmibka)0 B@E dkz occf jk}zm vc pm{}mzv vdbz pmabmg! dbjd bz imjmzzkpr vc xpmzmpwm vdm
acobjka zm{}mijbio cg mtxmpv pmxcpvz kif vc xpcwbfm gcp cpfmpar mtxmpv fbzjcwmpr) Gmf) P)
Jbw) X) ;7$`"$6" $K zjdmf}am ekr `m ecfbgbmf ciar gcp occf jk}zm kif bvd vdm n}fomz
jcizmiv)"
JCIJA]ZBCI
Gcp vdm gcpmocbio pmkzciz! B@E pmzxmjvg}aar pm{}mzvz vdkv vdm Jc}pv opkiv
B@Ez ecvbci gcp k jcivbiomiv zvkr cg vdm N}ar ;0! 08;0 fmkfabim)
; Zvkrbio vdm fmkfabim gcp pm`}vvka pmxcpvz }ivba :8 fkrz kgvmp vdm fmkfabim gcp xpbijbxkapmxcpvz bz jcizbzvmiv bvd vdm j}ppmiv zjdmf}am! dbjd xpmzmivar xpcwbfmz gcp pm`}vvka pmxcpvz ci
N}ar ;0 $b)m)! :8 fkrz kgvmp vdm N}im ;0 fmkfabim gcp xpbijbxka pmxcpvz") Bg vdm Jc}pv opkivz [ZOB
ki mtvmizbci cg vbem vc zmpwm bvz mtxmpv pmxcpvz kif fbzjacz}pmz! B@E kazc pm{}mzvz vdkv mtvmizbciz
`m opkivmf gcp vdm z}jjmmfbio fkvmz bi vdm zjdmf}am! bija}fbio kaacbio z}ggbjbmiv vbem gcaacbio
vdm fmkfabim gcp pm`}vvka pmxcpvz gcp mtxmpv fmxczbvbciz kif fbzxczbvbwm ecvbciz)
0 B@E kvvmexvmf vc jcigmp bvd [ZOB `mgcpm gbabio vdbz ecvbci) B@E jkaamf kif
jcppmzxcifmf bvd [ZOB bi ki mggcpv vc pmkjd kopmmemiv ci vdbz zvpkbodvgcpkpf zjdmf}abio
ekvvmp! `}v [ZOB fbf icv pmzxcif! xpcexvbio vdbz ecvbci) N}ar 0! 08;0 Fmjakpkvbci cg @minkebi
D) Fbmzzma 0%6)
Jkzm 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP Fcj}emiv ;8; Mivmpmf ci GAZF Fcjlmv 8?#80#08;0 Xkom 0 cg =
-
7/31/2019 IBM - Motion for Contingent Stay
3/10:
X}pz}kiv vc Acjka P}am ?);$k"$:"$K"! B dmpm`r jmpvbgr vdkv jc}izma gcp vdm ecwkiv dkz
zc}odv vc jcigmp bvd kaa xkpvbmz cp icixkpvbmz dc ekr `m kggmjvmf `r vdm pmabmg zc}odv bivdbz ecvbci bi k occf%gkbvd mggcpv vc pmzcawm vdm bzz}mz `}v dkz `mmi }ik`am vc pmzcawm vdm
bzz}mz)
Fkvmf> N}ar 0! 08;0
Pmzxmjvg}aar z}`ebvvmf!
#z# Ak}pk @mzwbibjl
Ak}pk @mzwbibjl
Gacpbfk @kp Ic) :2;;=4
DCOKI ACWMAAZ ]Z AAX
088 Zc}vd @bzjkrim @awf)
Z}bvm 688
Ebkeb! GA ::;:;Vmamxdcim> :8=%6=2%7=88
Gkjzbebam> :8=%6=2%7==8
ak}pk)`mzwbibjlHDcokiAcwmaaz)jce
Mwki P) Jdmzamp.
Pbjdkpf N) Zvkpl.
Vmmik%Kii W) Zkilccpblka.
JPKWKVD! Z_KBIM ' ECCPM AAX_cpafbfm Xak~k40= Mbodvd Kwmi}m
Im Rcpl! IR ;88;2Vmamxdcim> 0;0%6?6%;888
Gkjzbebam> 0;0%6?6%:?88
mjdmzampHjpkwkvd)jce
pzvkplHjpkwkvd)jce
vzkilccpblkaHjpkwkvd)jce
Vr Jc``.
Mpbj N) Zvcjl.DCOKI ACWMAAZ ]Z AAX
Jca}e`bk Z{}kpm
=== Vdbpvmmivd Zvpmmv! I__kzdbiovci! FJ 08886
Vmamxdcim> 080%7:?%=788
Gkjzbebam> 080%7:?%=2;8
Vr)Jc``HDcokiAcwmaaz)jce
Mpbj)ZvcjlHDcokiAcwmaaz)jce
.Kfebvvmf Xpc Dkj Wbjm
Jc}izma gcp Fmgmifkivz B@E Oac`ka
Gbikijbio kif Bivmpikvbcika @}zbimzz
Ekjdbimz Jcpxcpkvbci
Jkzm 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP Fcj}emiv ;8; Mivmpmf ci GAZF Fcjlmv 8?#80#08;0 Xkom : cg =
-
7/31/2019 IBM - Motion for Contingent Stay
4/106
JMPVBGBJKVM CG ZMPWBJM
B DMPM@R JMPVBGR vdkv! ci vdbz 0if fkr cg N}ar 08;0! B mamjvpcibjkaar gbamf
vdm gcpmocbio fcj}emiv bvd vdm Jampl cg vdm Jc}pv }zbio JE#MJG) B kazc jmpvbgr
vdkv vdm gcpmocbio fcj}emiv bz `mbio zmpwmf vdbz fkr ci kaa jc}izma cg pmjcpf cp xpc zm
xkpvbmz bfmivbgbmf ci vdm kvvkjdmf Zmpwbjm Abzv bi vdm ekiimp zxmjbgbmf! mbvdmp wbk
vpkizebzzbci cg Icvbjmz cg Mamjvpcibj Gbabio omimpkvmf `r JE#MJG cp bi zcem cvdmp
k}vdcpb~mf ekiimp gcp vdczm jc}izma cp xkpvbmz dc kpm icv k}vdcpb~mf vc pmjmbwm
mamjvpcibjkaar Icvbjmz cg Mamjvpcibj Gbabio)
#z# Ak}pk @mzwbibjl
Jkzm 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP Fcj}emiv ;8; Mivmpmf ci GAZF Fcjlmv 8?#80#08;0 Xkom 6 cg =
-
7/31/2019 IBM - Motion for Contingent Stay
5/10=
[ZOB! BIJ) ZMPWBJM ABZV
N}ki Xk`ac @k}vk! BB
Gmppkpc Ak Gbpe6888 Xcijm fm Amci @awf
Z}bvm ?88
Ebkeb! GA ::;67Xdcim> :8=%:?=%8;;;
Gkt> :8=%:?2%7000
Emabzzk Fkebki Wbzjcivb
Gmppkpc Ak Gbpe
6888 Xcijm fm Amci @awf
Z}bvm ?88
Ebkeb! GA ::;67:8=%:?=%8;;;
Gkt> :8=%:?2%7000
Mekba> efwHgmppkpcak)jce
Jkzm 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP Fcj}emiv ;8; Mivmpmf ci GAZF Fcjlmv 8?#80#08;0 Xkom = cg =
-
7/31/2019 IBM - Motion for Contingent Stay
6/10
Jkzm 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP Fcj}emiv ;8;%; Mivmpmf ci GAZF Fcjlmv 8?#80#08;0 Xkom ; cg =
-
7/31/2019 IBM - Motion for Contingent Stay
7/10
Jkzm 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP Fcj}emiv ;8;%; Mivmpmf ci GAZF Fcjlmv 8?#80#08;0 Xkom 0 cg =
-
7/31/2019 IBM - Motion for Contingent Stay
8/10
MTDB@BV ;
Jkzm 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP Fcj}emiv ;8;%; Mivmpmf ci GAZF Fcjlmv 8?#80#08;0 Xkom : cg =
-
7/31/2019 IBM - Motion for Contingent Stay
9/10
vc> x`!kkl!efw!ij` 8?#80#08;0;;>;8KE
Jj>PbjdkpfZvkpl!Vmmik%KiiZkilccpblka!vr)jc` !ak}pk)`mzwbibjl!
mpbj)zvcjl
@jj> B@E=70
N}kikifKekifk>
Bn}zvjkaamfjcijmpibiovdm`mackifamgvemzzkomzgcpmkjdcgrc})_mc}afkxxpmjbkvmkpmzxcizmvcfkrcivdm`macbvmez)Bkekwkbak`ambivdmcggbjmvcfkrvcfbzj}zz)
@minkebiFbmzzmaJpkwkvd!Zkbim'EccpmAAX40=MbodvdKwmi}mImRcpl!IR;88;2$0;0"6?6%;;??$fbpmjv"$0;0"6?6%:?88$gkt"
@minkebiFbmzzma 87#02#08;08;>=:>0=XEN}ki>Bjkaamfmkpabmpvcfkrvcfbzj}zzzjdmf}abio)))
Gpce> @minkebiFbmzzma#IRJ#JpkwkvdVc> x`Hgmppkpcak)jce!kklHgmppkpcak)jce!efwHgmppkpcak)jce!ij`Hgmppkpcak)jceJj> PbjdkpfZvkpl#IRJ#JpkwkvdHJpkwkvd!Vmmik%KiiZkilccpblka#IRJ#JpkwkvdHJpkwkvd!
vr)jc``Hdcokiacwmaaz)jce!ak}pk)`mzwbibjlHdcokiacwmaaz)jce!mpbj)zvcjlHdcokiacwmaaz)jceFkvm> 87#02#08;08;>=:XEZ}`nmjv> [ZOBw)B@E%Gcaac]xpmFbzjcwmprkifZjdmf}abioBzz}mz
N}ki>
Bjkaamfmkpabmpvcfkrvcfbzj}zzzjdmf}abiokiffbzjcwmprbzz}mz)Bjc}aficvomvvdpc}odvcmbvdmprc}cp
Kekifk!zcBamgvrc}kwcbjmekba)Xamkzmobwmemkjkaa`kjldmirc}dkwmkjdkijmcppmzxcifvcvdbzmekba)
Gbpzv!kzpm{}mzvmfbierwcbjmekba!xamkzmkfwbzmdmvdmp[ZOBbivmifzvcxpcjmmfbvdFkiPkizfmaa/zfmxczbvbciciN}ar;0)[ZOBdkzrmvvcpmzxcifvcc}pN}im0;cpN}im07mekbazcivdbzz}`nmjv)Bgmfcicvdmkpgpce[ZOBjcijmpibiovdbzfmxczbvbci`rV}mzfkr!N}ar:!mbaapmamkzmvdbzfkvm)KzBzvkvmfbierN}im0;mekba!xpmzmivar!vdbzfkvmbzEp)Pkizfmaa/zciarkwkbak`babvrgcpfmxczbvbcibiN}ar$`}vmbaaamvrc}licbgvdbzjdkiomz")
Zmjcif!kzBzvkvmfbieremzzkom!B@Ezvbaadkzicvpmjmbwmf[ZOB/zbvimzzfbzjacz}pmz!dbjdmpmf}mkmmlkoc)_dmibaa[ZOB`mxpcwbfbiobvzbvimzzfbzjacz}pmz3
Vdbpf!kzrc}lic![ZOB/zfmkfabimvcxpcwbfmbvzmtxmpvpmxcpvzkifkzzcjbkvmffbzjacz}pmzkzN}im;0)CiN}im;0![ZOBecwmfgcpk:8%fkrmtvmizbcicgvdbzfmkfabim!dbjdB@Ecxxczmf)Vdkvecvbcibzj}ppmivarxmifbio`mgcpmvdmJc}pv)B@EbzxpmxkpmfvcxpcwbfmbvzmtxmpvpmxcpvzciN}ar;0!jcizbzvmivbvdvdmmtvkivzjdmf}am)Bg!dcmwmp!vdmJc}pvdkzicvfmjbfmf[ZOB/zmtvmizbciecvbci`rN}ar;0!xpcwbzbci`rB@Ecgbvzpmxcpvzcivdkvfkvmjc}afpmz}avbiB@Expcwbfbiopm`}vvkapmxcpvzvc[ZOBxpbcpvcB@Epmjmbwbioxpbijbxkapmxcpvzgpce[ZOB$kzz}ebiovdkvvdmJc}pvvdmpmkgvmpopkivz[ZOB/zmtvmizbciecvbci")Vdbzbzbijcizbzvmivbvdvdmzjdmf}am/zzm{}mijbiocgpm`}vvkapmxcpvzvcgcaacxpbijbxkapmxcpvz)Kjjcpfbioar!B@Ec}afablmvczvkrvdmN}ar;0fmkfabimgcpbvzmtxmpvpmxcpvz}ivba:8fkrzkgvmpvdmfkvmgcp[ZOB/zxpcwbzbcicgmtxmpvpmxcpvz!cp;8fkrzkgvmpvdmJc}pv/zfmibkacgvdmmtvmizbciecvbci!kzvdmjkzmekr`m)Xamkzmamv}zlicbg[ZOBbaakopmm)Bgmfcicvdmkpgpcerc}`rEcifkrkv6>88XE!B@Ebaagbamkecvbcizmmlbioz}jdpmabmg)
Jkzm 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP Fcj}emiv ;8;%; Mivmpmf ci GAZF Fcjlmv 8?#80#08;0 Xkom 6 cg =
-
7/31/2019 IBM - Motion for Contingent Stay
10/10
Gbikaar!xamkzmkfwbzmdmvdmp[ZOBbivmifzvcxpcjmmfbvdvdmfmxczbvbcizcgNcmakifNkebmCmizcivdmicvbjmffkvmcgN}ar;;!08;0)
@minkebiFbmzzmaJpkwkvd!Zkbim'EccpmAAX40=MbodvdKwmi}mImRcpl!IR;88;2$0;0"6?6%;;??$fbpmjv"$0;0"6?6%:?88$gkt"
Jkzm 2>;;%jw%48448%LAP Fcj}emiv ;8;%; Mivmpmf ci GAZF Fcjlmv 8?#80#08;0 Xkom = cg =