human rights defenders handbook

Upload: kasamahumanrights

Post on 04-Apr-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    1/34

    Doing human rights work is like walking in a tightrope. HR defenders never know when

    to fall, and whether or not we fall hard, when it happens. Thus, in the course of this

    mission, defenders learned and continue to learn ways, skills, knowledge and creativity

    not just to survive but also to multiply. There are still plenty of things to learn and to

    experience however, as we continue to address the urgency of strengthening human

    rights work in the country particularly at the grassroots level. So this handbook aims to

    be a modest contribution to that process of helping human rights defenders weathersthe risks and dangers that the work entails.

    This is also a follow-up to the Know Your Rights pocket-guide that CTUHR published

    on January 2009.

    The practical content of the handbook is an accumulation of experiences of human

    rights defenders and families of victims of extrajudicial killings and other violations pri-marily in the labour sector that CTUHR worked with in its 25 years of existence.

    We could not have nished the handbook though, without the patience, openness,

    critiques and recommendations of nearly hundred HR defenders from various organi-

    zations and sectors nationwide who joined the Luzon, Visayas and Mindanao pretests.

    Specically, we thank the Pro-labour Legal Assistance (PLACE), Visayas Institute for

    Human Development Agency, Inc (VIHDA) and Nonoy Librado Development Founda-

    tion, Inc (NLDFI) for co-organizing the regional activities. To all of them, we owe our

    thanks.

    CTUHR also thanks the EPJUST Team for making the whole process of discussing and

    re-writing the draft an enjoyable educational experience.

    M E S S A G E

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    2/34

    M E S S A G E

    EP JUST EU-PHILIPPINES JUSTICE SUPPORT PROGRAMME

    Cooperation with CTUHR on this human rights defenders handbook has a special signi -

    cance for the European Union funded EPJUST program and myself: As early as 1870 trade-

    unions were formed in Europe, France and Germany in particular. Today, the largest union

    confederation in Europe is the German Confederation of Trade Unions representing 7 million

    people.

    In former times, there were severe penalties for attempting to organize unions, up to and

    including execution. Today we realize that trade unions are an essential part of any free

    society. There can be no democracy without free trade unions. Therefore, trade unions and

    trade unionists were and still remain the main targets of any dictatorship. Some examples

    of those, who refused to accept human rights: in Nazi-Germany trade unionists were killed by

    the thousands in concentration camps; after the military coup in Chile in 1973 the Pinochet-

    regime tortured and arrested so called leftist trade-unionists. Many were never seen again.Up to today, trade unionists are threatened and harassed in several countries, sometimes

    even in would-be democracies.

    Trade unionists are among the most active human rights defenders. This handbook is for

    them and other activists in the eld of human rights protection. It is meant to protect those,

    who are protecting others.

    Mr. Detlev Mehlis

    EPJUST Team Leader/ Senior Justice Expert

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    3/34

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    i. introducton......................................................................4

    ii. Your Human Rghts.........................................................5

    iii. Your Legal Rghts..........................................................11

    iV. Respondng to Rsks and Threats to Safety..................19

    V. important Contact Ponts................................................33

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    4/34

    INTRODUCTION

    Are you a poltcal actvst defendng the rghts to freedom of assembly and

    of expresson? Or a trade unonst? Or an actvst for housng rghts, land

    rghts, envronmental rghts, educaton rghts, ndgenous peoples rghts,

    women and chld rghts? Or someone actve n promotng or strvng forthe realaton of human rghts and fundamental freedoms at natonal and

    nternatonal level ndvdually or n assocaton wth others?

    if you are one of them, then you are called Human Rghts Defender (HRD)!

    The UN Declaratons on Human Rghts Defenders declares

    Everyone has the right, individually and in association with others,

    to promote and to strive for the protection and realization of human

    rights and fundamental freedoms at the national and internationallevels1

    Lke other persons wthn a jursdcton of a state, you have the rght to be

    protected by the State, both n laws and n practce. You have the rght

    to defend human rghts. The same Declaraton stresses that the prime

    responsibility and duty to promote and protect human rights and

    fundamental freedoms lie with the State.2

    Many human rghts organatons and human rghts defenders are notable to pursue ther actvtes freely, ncludng ther rght to freedom of

    assocaton, or rght of peaceful demonstraton, and are often subjected to

    harassment and ntmdaton.

    As human rghts defender, your work s mportant not only for the sectors

    or ssues you advocate, but to socety n general. But snce your work

    challenges persecuton and njustce, t can be rsky or lfe threatenng at

    tmes.

    So, ths handbook s for you, not as fool-proof safety guarantee (there s no

    such thng lke that!), but smple and helpful tps for basc protecton whle

    you perform your mportant msson.

    1 UN Declaration on the Right and Responsibility of Individuals, Groups and Organs of Society to Promote and Protect Universally

    Recognised Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms2 Ibid.

    4

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    5/34

    YOUR HUMAN RIGHTS

    Human rghts are unversal, ndvsble,

    nterdependent and nterrelated whether they

    are cvl, poltcal, economc, socal or cultural,

    and must be upheld wth equal determnatonn every country.3 They derve from the nherent dgnty of the human

    person Human rghts are recognsed and codfed n natonal laws and

    nternatonal treates. Ther enjoyment and fulflment cannot be suspended

    n any stuaton, even under martal law or a natonal state of emergency.

    The State (all branches of government) and ts agents have the duty to

    respect, protect and fulfl human rghts of all ndvduals. in realty, however,

    volatons of these rghts exst, even n democratc countres.

    The right to life.1.Everyone has the rght to lfe4. Ths rght, however, can be volated n a

    varety of ways, ncludng:

    Kllngs by state agents, or persons actng n drect or ndrect complancewth the State, when the force used s not absolutely necessary andproportonate (extra judcal kllngs or extralegal kllngs);5

    Deaths n custody as a result of neglect, use of excessve force

    and torture, or lfe-threatenng condtons of detenton (summaryexecuton, salvagng);

    Delberate kllng by prvate groups or ndvduals or armed

    groups engagng war wth the State (the Geneva Conventons

    and protocols (Protocol ii) are mportant here partcularly n the

    context of non-nternatonal armed conflcts);6

    3 Ko Annan, UN Secretary General ` On Universality and Indivisibility of Human Rights, 24 April 2003, UN Commission on Human Rights,

    Geneva, Switzerland4 Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) Art. 3; 1987 Constitution Art. III Sec. 15 The international law denition of extrajudicial execution encompasses any killing by Government forces as well as killings by any other

    groups o individuals which the Government fails to investigate, prosecute and punish when it is in a position to do so, Prof Philip Alston, UN

    Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary or Arbitrary Executions, 15 October 2009. Extralegal killings are killings committed without

    due process of law, i.e. without legal safeguards or judicial proceedings. Rule on the Writ of Amparo: Annotation, p.48 and Case law: Sec

    of National Defense v. Manalo (GR 180906, 7 Oct 2008)6 The Geneva Conventions and their Additional Protocols are international treaties that contain the most important rules limiting the barbarity

    of war. They protect people who do not take part in the ghting (civilians, medics, aid workers) and those who can no longer ght (wounded,

    sick and shipwrecked troops, prisoners of war). Protocol II relates to the Protection of Victims of Non-International Armed Conicts, 8

    June 1977

    5

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    6/34

    Falure by the State to nvestgate, prosecute and judge volatons

    of the rght to lfe.

    The right to freedom from torture.2.

    Everyone has the rght tofreedom from torture and nhuman or defradng

    treatment or punshment.7

    in 2009, torture became a crme under Republc

    Act No.9745 or Ant-Torture Act of 2009. Ths

    rght can be volated through a varety of ways ;

    acts that consttute torture, nclude:

    the delberate nflcton of severe

    physcal or psychologcal pan on a

    person or group by State agents or

    wthn the consent or acquescence of

    a person n authorty or publc offcal or agent of a person n

    authorty or armed groups wth the ntenton of causng sufferng

    (e.g. systematc beatng, food deprvaton, cgarette burnng

    etc.), or obtanng nformaton, or a forced confesson for an

    alleged crme;

    e xpellng or returnng a person to a place n whch they face areal rsk of beng tortured or subjected to nhuman or degradng

    treatment or punshment;

    keepng persons n very poor condtons of detenton, even f

    there s no ntenton to nflct sufferng;

    corporal (physcal) punshment of chldren and batterng of

    spouses n the guse of dscplnary acton; and

    `secret detenton places, soltary confnement, ncommuncado

    and other smlar forms of detenton where torture may be carred

    out wth mpunty are also prohbted.

    7 The Principles on the Effective Investigation and Documentation of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or

    Punishment are annexed to General Assembly resolution 55/89 of 4 December 2000 and to Commission on Human Rights resolution

    2000/43 of 20 April 2000, both adopted without a vote.

    6

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    7/34

    To nvestgate or assess allegatons of torture, the UNs Istanbul Protocol8

    s useful. it provdes a set of nternatonal gudelnes for the assessment

    of persons who allege torture and ll treatment, for nvestgatng cases of

    alleged torture, and for reportng such fndngs to the judcary and any

    other nvestgatve body.

    The right not to be subjected to forced labour.3.

    No one shall be requred to perform forced or compulsory labour.9

    Compulsory labour shall mean all work or servce whch s exacted from

    any person under the menace of any penalty and for whch the sad

    person has not offered hmself voluntarly.10 Forced or compulsory labour

    wll requre a level of coercon or decepton between the employer and

    the vctm, beyond that whch mght be expected n normal employment

    arrangement.11

    There are seven (7) major categores of forced labour:

    slavery and abductons ;

    compulsory partcpaton n publc works projects;

    mandatory forced labour n remote areas;

    bonded labour or debt bondage - forcng another person to work

    n her/hs household as domestc or n hs famly or company as

    payment of debt;worker or farm labourer as payment for debt or contractual

    oblgaton;

    nvoluntary labour resultng from traffckng n persons ;

    domestc workers n nvoluntary labour stuatons;

    prson labour and rehabltaton through work unless t s a part

    of the punshment for the crme commtted

    The right to freedom of assembly and association.4.Everyone has the rght to freedom of assembly and of assocaton wth

    others ncludng the rght to form trade unons to protect ther nterests.12

    8 Slavery, Servitude and Forced or Compulsory Labour, Ministry of Justice, United Kingdom9 ICCPR Art. 8, Para 3 (a)10 ILO Conventions No. 29, Convention concerning Forced or Compulsory Labour.11 ICCPR Art 21; 1987 Constitution Art. III Sec. 412 ICCPR Art 22; ILO Conventions 87 and 98; 1987 Constitution Art. III Sec. 8

    7

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    8/34

    Ths rght, however, can be volated n a varety of ways, ncludng:

    preventng publc demonstratons;

    restrctng possbltes to jon voluntary assocatons

    (e.g. communty or peoples organaton); and

    denyng persons the rght to form and/or jon trade unons or

    workers assocatons13

    The right to freedom of opinion5.

    and expression

    Everyone shall have the rght to freedom

    of opnon and expresson; ths rght

    shall nclude freedom to seek, receve

    and mpart nformaton and deas of

    all knds, regardless of fronters, etherorally, n wrtng or n prnt, n the form

    of art, or through any other meda of hs

    choce.14

    Whle rght to freedom of opnon s

    absolute, rght to freedom of expresson

    s not.15

    Ths rght,however, can be volated n a varety of ways, ncludng by:

    lmtng the freedom of the press or placng undue restrctons on

    the press or passng a law that allows government nterference

    n meda affars (excludng reasonable lcensng restrctons, e.g.

    pror restrant on what can be publshed as news on prnt and

    broadcast meda);

    (prnt, broadcast ncludng new meda or nternet channels);

    nformal censorshp on journalsts through threats, ntmdatons

    and legal harassments;

    13 UDHR Art. 23; ILO Conventions 87 and 9814 ICCPR Art. 19; 1987 Constitution Art. III Sec. 415 Freedom ofExpression, a right (still) at risk UN Special Rapporteuron the Promotion and Protection of the Right to Freedom ofOpinion

    and Expression, Frank La Rue, UN Human Rights Council, 14th session, 06 July 2010.

    8

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    9/34

    restrctng access to poltcal, artstc or commercal nformaton

    and deas (e.g. denyng ndvduals and organatons access to

    varous poltcal groups or correct nformaton and servces on

    sexual and reproductve health);and

    arrest of people for wearng advocacy t-shrts or usng alternatve

    meda that can be crtcal of certan polces or authortes.

    6. The right to liberty and security.

    Everyone has the rght to lberty and securty. No one shall be subjected

    to arbtrary arrest or detenton, deprved of hs lberty except on such

    grounds and n accordance wth such procedure as are establshed by

    law.16 Deprvaton of lberty means any form of detenton or mprsonment

    or the placement of a person n a publc or prvate custodal settng

    whch that person s not permtted to leave at wll by order of any judcal,

    admnstratve or other authorty.17

    Ths rght,however, can be volated n a varety of ways, ncludng by:

    unlawful or arbtrary detenton (where there s no legal bass for

    the deprvaton of lberty), for example when a person s kept n

    detenton after a mandatory perod wthout a charge n court, or

    completon of ther prson sentence, or despte an amnesty law

    whch apples to them;

    threat s, survellances or harassments that lmt the free

    movement of an ndvdual from one place to another;

    detenton of persons because they have exercsed the rghts

    and freedoms guaranteed by natonal and nternatonal laws and

    mechansms;

    detenton on false charges because you perform your role and

    functons as a human rghts defender;

    detenton after a tral whch dd not comply wth nternatonal

    standards for a far tral (see the right to a fair trial).

    16 ICCPR Art 9; 1987 Constitution Art. III Sec. 117 Optional Protocol on Convention Against Torture (OP-CAT) Art 4. Para 2

    9

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    10/34

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    11/34

    YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS

    Human rghts defenders work s legal. Human rghts defenders are legal

    and legtmated by natonal and nternatonal communtes. Human rghts

    defenders often rsk ther lves and well-beng n the pursut of truth and

    justce. Ths secton provdes some useful tps n lessenng rsks forhuman rghts defenders n crtcal stuatons of arrests and detentons,

    and searches and seures.

    Arrests and DetentionsA.

    Everyone has the rght not to be subjected to

    arbtrary arrest or detenton. Everyone has the

    rght not to be deprved of hs lberty except on

    such grounds and n accordance wth such procedureas are establshed by law.20

    You can only be legally arrested on two grounds: 1) f there s a

    case fled aganst you n court and an arrest warrant had been ssued

    aganst you; and, 2) f you are arrested n any of the crcumstances where

    warrantless arrests are legal under Rule 113 Secton 5 of the Rules of

    Court.

    The polce has the judcal authorty to serve a warrant and effect an

    arrest.

    1. If you have been arrested and/or under investigation, RA 743821

    provides for your rights, as follows:

    You have the rght to be nformed of the reason of arrest

    and the charges aganst you;

    You have the rght to reman slent and not to be compelled

    to testfy aganst yourself;

    20 ICCPR Art 9; 1987 Constitution Art. III Sec. 2, 12 (2)21 See Section 2. Rights of Persons Arrested, Detained or Under Custodial Investigation.

    11

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    12/34

    You have the rght to have a counsel of your choce to

    assst you at all tmes n any custodal nvestgaton or

    nterrogaton22;

    You have the rght to be presented to a judge as soon

    as possble but not later than:a) 12 hours after the arrest for a lght offense

    (e.g. vandalism)

    b) 18 hours after the arrest for less grave offense

    (e.g. illegal assembly)

    c) 36 hours after arrest for a grave offense

    (e.g. murder, rebellion)

    Remember: if the arrestng person faled to comply wth the above, your

    arrest and detenton become llegal and you shold fle a complant to

    consttutonal authortes at the frst opportunty to do so. 23

    When you are presented to a judge,

    You have the rght to make a formal complant f you feel

    you have been dened counsel, pushed around, forced to

    confess, tortured or ntmdated;

    You have the rght to ask to be released on reasonable

    bal, unless you are charged wth a crme punshable by

    reclusion perpetua or lfe sentence and the evdence of

    your gult s strong;

    You have the rght to be vsted by a famly member,

    relatve, frend and lawyers.

    22 RA 7438 Sec. 4. provides a penalty clause for (a) Any arresting public ofcer or employee, or any investigating ofcer, who fails to inform

    any person arrested, detained or under custodial investigation of his right to remain silent and to have competent and independent counsel

    preferably of his own choice, shall suffer a ne of Six thousand pesos (P6,000.00) or a penalty of imprisonment of not less than eight (8)

    years but not more than ten (10) years, or both. The penalty of perpetual absolute disqualication shall also be imposed upon the investigat-

    ing ofcer who has been previously convicted of a similar offense.23 Revised Penal Code of the Philippines (RPC) Art. 125

    12

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    13/34

    2. If you continue to be detained while your case is being heard:

    You have the rght to be treated wth humanty and wth

    respect for the nherent dgnty of the human person.24

    You have the rght to a speedy and mpartal procedure;

    You have the rght to receve adequate food, and you

    may decde to procure food from outsde through the

    admnstraton of the detenton center or through famly

    and frends;

    You have the rght to practce your relgon;

    You have the rght to a healthful accommodaton wth

    suffcent lght and ventlaton and adequate santary and

    bathng facltes;

    You have the rght to be furnshed wth and to procure

    readng and wrtng materals;

    You have the rght to be separated from sentenced

    convcts;

    You have the rght to have at least an hour of outdoorexercse; and

    You have the rght not to be compelled to work unless you

    wsh to.

    3. If you are facing trial:

    You have the rght to be nformed of what you are charged

    wth and what acts you are accused of havng commtted;

    You have the rght to be asssted by a counsel of your own

    choce;

    You have the rght to be presumed nnocent untl you have

    proven gulty beyond reasonable doubt;

    24 ICCPR Art. 10, para 1

    13

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    14/34

    You have the rght not to be compelled to be a wtness

    aganst yourself;

    You have the rght to confront the wtness(es) aganst

    you;

    You have the rght to have compulsory process to produce

    evdence favourable to you;

    You have the rght to present your defense;

    You have the rght not to be placed twce n jeopardy for the

    same offense;

    You have the rght not to be sentenced to pay an excessve

    fne nor to suffer cruel or unusual punshment; and

    You have the rght to a speedy, mpartal and publc tral.

    Warrantless ArrestB.

    As a general rule, you can only be legally arrested when there s a warrant

    of arrest ssued by the court aganst you. There are crcumstances

    determned by law where warrantless arrest s vald and legal. Rule 113

    Secton 5 of the Rules of Court provdes for nstances of vald warrantless

    arrests as follows:

    Section 5.Arrest without warrant; when lawful. A peace offcer or a

    prvate person may, wthout a warrant, arrest a person:

    (a) When, n hs presence, the person to be arrested has

    commtted, s actually commttng, or s attemptng to

    commt an offense;

    (b) When an offense has just been commtted, and he has

    probable cause to beleve based on personal knowledge

    of facts or crcumstances that the person to be arrested

    has commtted t; and

    14

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    15/34

    (c) When the person to be arrested s a prsoner who has

    escaped from a penal establshment or place where he s

    servng fnal judgment or s temporarly confned whle hs

    case s pendng, or has escaped whle beng transferred

    from one confnement to another.

    in cases fallng under paragraph (a) and (b) above, the person arrested

    wthout a warrant shall be forthwth delvered to the nearest polce staton

    or jal and shall be proceeded aganst n accordance wth secton 7 of

    Rule 112. (5a)

    if you are arrested outsde any of the above-wrtten crcumstances, the

    arrest s llegal and you should be mmedately released. However, under

    the ilagan Doctrne25 of the Supreme Court, an llegal arrest can be curedand can be legaled f a corrected nformaton s fled at the prosecutors

    offce or the court ssued a warrant of arrest on the accused. The use of

    ths doctrne s stll beng legally contested.

    C. Searches and Seizures

    You have a rght not to have your house or offce searched, your papers

    and belongngs seed by State agents wthout a vald search warrant

    ssued by a Judge, and not to have anythng seed whch s not specfedn the presented search warrant. A search warrant s not a lcense

    to ransack your house or your offce. if you are legally arrested, your

    person and surroundngs may be searched for dangerous weapons and

    any evdence found on your person and mmedate vcnty (person and

    immediate vicinity only) whch may have been used to commt the crme

    you are charged of may be seed.

    iF YOUR HOUSE OR OFFiCE iS TARGETTED FOR A SEARCH ANDSUPPOSED WARRANT iS iSSUED:

    1. Check f the search warrant s vald. A search warrant s vald f:

    t s sgned by the judge who has jursdcton over the place to be

    searched;

    25 Ilagan vs. Enrile, 139 SCRA 3491985

    15

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    16/34

    t specfes one offense only;

    t descrbes wth partcularty the exact locaton and/or address of

    the place to be searched, and lst down exactly what thngs are to

    be seed. A search warrant can be ssued only for objects that

    are the subject of the crme allegedly commtted (e.g. unlcensed

    frearms) or fruts of the crme (stolen money);

    t s executed wthn 10 days after ts ssuance;

    t s not a photocopy search warrant.

    2. if the search warrant s vald, only then should you allow the

    search to be conducted. Before lettng the search party to enter

    your house or offce, ask ther names, rank, offce, command or

    unts they belong and get name and rank of the commandng

    offcer. if t s a lawful search, the search party should normallygve ther names.

    3. Durng the search, accompany the group conductng the search

    at all tmes, do not leave them alone and always be alert, to

    prevent plantng of documents, weapons or any other materals

    n your home or offce that can be used aganst you later.

    4. if you have doubts about the authentcty

    of the search warrant, ask for a copy of thewarrant from the court that ssued t even f

    the search had been consummated. Ths s

    useful especally f you want to contest the

    search n court.

    Remember: the search party s allowed to conduct the search only

    n the presence of the lawful occupant or any member of the famly. if

    NO occupant or member of the famly s present, the search must beconducted n the presence of two wtnesses resdng from the same

    localty, or a barangay captan.26

    26 RPC Art. 130

    16

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    17/34

    5. if anythng s taken from your house or offce, the offcer seng

    the property must gve a detaled recept. Ask the offcer of the

    group conductng the search and a member of your communty

    to sgn the recept mmedately below the last wrtten lne of ts

    page.

    6. You may ask to sgn an affdavt of orderly search. if n your opnon

    the search wasnt orderly at all, do not sgn the affdavt. if you are

    forced to sgn, add n your sgnature, the phrase under protest

    or under duress. in ths way, you can regster your objecton.

    7. if the WARRANT iS iNVALiD, the search and seure s unlawful.

    Any evdence obtaned as a result of an unlawful search and

    seure cannot be used as evdence n any proceedng. You may

    resst, wthout lablty to an unlawful search and seure. Youmay also fle crmnal, cvl or dscplnary acton cases aganst

    the offcer servng an unlawful warrant.

    8. Where there s no search warrant, do not voluntarly submt

    yourself to a search. Object mmedately and demand for ther

    dentty, names, rank, offce or command they come from. Do not

    agree to be searched and regster your opposton. A warrantless

    search wthout your expressed consent s iLLEGAL.

    D. WARRANTLESS SEARCH

    As a general rule, you need a vald search warrant before any search can

    be conducted. However, accordng to law, a warrantless search s vald or

    legal on the followng crcumstances:

    search ncdental to a vald arrest- t s natural that you1.

    wll be searched for possble weapon, drugs or any llegal

    objects deemed by law

    movng vehcle2. 27

    smuggled goods or sometmes called as contraband3.

    27 Moving Vehicle/Probable Cause Doctrine--an automobile, truck, van, motorhome, boat, airplane or other movable object can be searched

    IF there is (a) probable cause (b) the vehicle is moving or about to be moved, and (c) a warrant cannot be readily obtained. Every part of the

    vehicle can be searched, including closed containers in the trunk, although special justication is needed for trunks.

    17

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    18/34

    seure of evdence n plan vew-4. plain view doctrine

    allows an offcer to see wthout a warrant, evdence

    and contraband found n plan vew durng a lawful

    observaton.

    waver5. or consented warrantless search- when consent

    s gven freely and voluntarly and not through the use of

    force or threat

    stop6. and frsk 28

    ponts7. of entry such as ports or arports

    prsoners8. of war

    admnstratve9. nspecton n commercal establshments

    checkponts10.

    28 Stop and Frisk doctrine originated in the US in a 1968 case of Terry vs. Ohio- Under the Terry ruling, a police ofcer may stop and detain

    a person based on reasonable suspicion. And, if the police reasonably suspect the person is armed and dangerous, they may also frisk

    him or her for weapons.

    18

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    19/34

    RESPONDING TO RISKS AND THREATS TO SAFETY

    Human rghts defenders often face a myrad of challenges, both n conflct

    or post-conflct stuatons. Stayng alve serves the cause of human rghts

    and justce further. Therefore, rsks have to be perodcally assessed and

    threats mtgated to ensure that personal and organatonal safety arenot compromsed.

    WHAT TO DO if You Beleve There is a Threat to your Personal Safety

    Do1. not go out alone and whenever possble, ask someone to

    accompany you to actvtes or meetngs you attend. The rsk

    of beng abducted or klled has ncreased because there are no

    wtnesses.

    if2. you have been vsted by suspcous men or women or armed

    groups several tmes n your house do not stay at home. Homes

    of human rghts defenders are no longer safe sanctuares. in

    recent experences, your house or offce becomes the most

    vulnerable place for survellances and more. in the last few

    years, ncdents of llegal arrest, abducton and even extrajudcal

    kllngs are commtted n the homes or n the vcnty of the

    vctms resdence.

    Move3. to another place but mantan communcaton lnes wth

    your trusted frends, colleagues and/or a member of your

    famly. Tell them about the threat or the possblty of your beng

    abducted and what to do n that case. Tell them specfcally, who

    to contact or run for help and how to get n touch wth them and

    where to search for you. You may also decde to nvolve the

    polce by flng a blotter, f you thnk t wll help you.

    Establsh4. a way or system of communcaton that only you andyour frends, or colleagues understand to alert them f you are

    n unsecured stuaton when normal communcaton cannot be

    used.

    Before5. gong out, tell your frends or colleagues where you are

    gong, whom you wll see and how long you expect to be out

    19

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    20/34

    and what to do f you fal to return on tme or fal to reach your

    destnaton or keep your appontment.

    When6. you go out, always carry an adequate dentfcaton and

    avod carryng thngs that can be construed as ncrmnatng.

    in7. case you are arrested, partcularly n publc places, see to

    t that people know that you are beng arrested by attractng

    attenton to your arrest, and when possble shout your name

    and person/s arrestng you or leave some sgn or anythng that

    can dentfy you.

    Avod8. establshng a pattern n your movements by avodng the

    same routne everyday.

    Do9. not stay outsde late at nght partcularly n places that are notfamlar to you or where no one knows you.

    if10. you have relable nformaton that there s a plan or lkelhood

    that you wll be abducted or klled, or f you feel that you are

    under survellance, mmedately report ths nformaton to your

    colleagues or frends, and do not mmedately go nto hdng.

    Whle takng extra precautonary measures, ask your frends or

    colleagues or lawyers to check on the exstence of a watch-lst

    (Order of Battle), or f there s an arrest warrant aganst you,

    of f there are cases fled aganst you and status of those cases.

    When cases are stll n prelmnary nvestgaton, ask your lawyer

    for advce.

    if11. n your assessment, together wth your organaton, an arrest

    or abducton can be deterred by publcng the threat, ask your

    colleagues to publce your case as wdely as possble and

    to ssue letters of concern on your case. There are numerous

    human rghts organatons that could ntervene and support on

    your behalf.

    Regularly12. update your frends on your whereabouts.

    Do13. not dscuss senstve nformaton on your cell phone, ether

    through call or SMS, as t may be montored.

    20

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    21/34

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    22/34

    WHAT TO DO if You Beleve There is A Threat to Your Communty or

    Communty-Based Organsatons

    Wth the Republc Act No. 855129 whch amended RA 6975 and Executve

    Order 546 (August 2006)30, the jont operatons of the AFP and the PNP

    n nternal securty, peace and order, has been legaled. As observed byPhlp Alston, the UN Specal Rapporteur on Extrajudcal, Summary or

    Arbtrary Executons31, the Phlppne governments approach to securty

    threats partcularly from communsts have turned from negotaton to

    counternsurgency. And the mltarys counternsurgency strategy aganst

    the CPP/NPA/NDF ncreasngly focused on dsmantlng cvl socety

    organatons that are purported to be alled wth communsts. Note that

    membershp n the Communst Party of the Phlppnes (CPP) s legal

    snce 1992 when Congress repealed the Ant-Subverson Act (RA 1700).As Alston reported to the UN Human Rghts Councl, the campagn of

    vlfcaton of, the enforced dsappearance of or kllng of actvsts or

    leaders of local organatons nstlled fear n the communtes, and such

    attacks led to some dsntegraton of organed cvl socety.

    When your organaton s faced wth a stuaton lke ths,

    if1. there s a sudden ncrease n the number and presence of

    armed groups n your communty n the absence of reasons that

    may warrant t (declaraton of state of emergency or martal law),

    stay alert and nqure quetly on the `reason of such presence.

    if2. communty organaton/s exst/s, convene the leaders of your

    organaton/s to assess the stuaton and to decde f acton

    should be taken. if you are not sure, on the detals of such

    sudden deployment, you can do the next step.

    29 RA 8551 Act Providing For The Reform And Reorganization Of The Philippine National Police And For Other Purposes ,establishes

    the role and function of the Police in support of AFPs principal role in the internal security of the country by suppressing insurgency and

    other threats to national security30 EO 546 signed by Mrs. Gloria Arroyo directs the PNP to undertake active support to the Armed Forces Of The Philippines in Internal

    Security Operations For The Suppression Of Insurgency And Other Serious Threats To National Security, it also authorized the PNP to

    deputize the barangay tanods as force multipliers in the implementation of the peace and order plan in the area.31 UN General Assembly Report of the Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary or Arbitrary Executions, Philip Alston. Addendum

    mission to (the) Philippines (A/HRC/8/3/Add.2 of 16 April 2008 and A/HRC/11/2/Add.8 of 29 April 2009)

    22

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    23/34

    inqure3. and/or ask for a dalogue wth your barangay charperson

    on the objectves of armed groups deployment or encampment

    n your barangay. You may rase your organatons concern

    durng the dalogue. Report to your membershp and ask them

    to gve feedbacks on the new stuaton.

    if4. elements of armed groups start conductng a house to

    house vst, or a census askng for the member/s of any

    communty, peoples or partylst organatons that members

    may feel ntmdated or threatened to rase ther concern even

    at the barangay level, seek the support of a lawyer or other

    organaton/s outsde your communty. A follow-up dalogue

    can agan be requested or conducted, wth the support of other

    human rghts organatons or ndvduals of stature such aschurch leaders or other sympathetc publc offcals.

    if5. ncdents of harassments, ntmdatons or others threat to

    personal safety of communty leaders have occurred, you can

    choose to do any of the followng or both: 1) fle a complant at

    the CHR and seek ther nterventon; 2) publce the ncdents

    through the help of networks of human rghts organatons to

    deter any possblty of commttng more volatons; 3) conduct a

    dalogue wth the LGUs concerned and ask for ther nterventonto stop any volatons; and 4) f perpetrators are dentfed, fle a

    case at the regular courts. Other natonal organatons whom

    you ask for support can also advse the local communty of any

    other possble actons.

    if6. armed group operatons (holdng forums or nterference n

    labour affars) are n the workplace, (plantaton, farms, factores

    etc), and the unon exsts, mmedately seek a dalogue wth youremployer and ask for explanaton. Tell the employer the effect

    of such operatons on your membershp and entre organaton

    and seek mmedate soluton.

    23

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    24/34

    Send7. a letter and request a dalogue wth the Department of

    Labor and Employment (DOLE) to report the ncdents and

    mpact on your organaton, or check f they have knowledge on

    such operatons. Smlar to the above, ask them for an mmedate

    soluton to your concerns.

    if8. n your assessment, publcty s a good opton as deterrent

    to human rghts volaton, and your organaton s not capable

    of dong that, seek the support of other organatons. There

    are many of them at the natonal or nternatonal level who are

    wllng to help and launch a campagn on your behalf.

    You9. can also decde other actons mentoned n paragraph 4.

    WHAT TO DO in Emergency Stuatons Or Deployment of QRTs (Quck

    Response Teams)

    in urban or town centres, ths stuaton often ncludes volent evctons of

    slum communtes or street vendors, dspersal or breakng up of protest

    ralles or demonstratons, labor strkes that results n njures, arrests and

    subsequent detenton. Other ncdents whch may happen both n rural

    and town centres nclude summary or extrajudcal kllngs, abductonand subsequent dsappearance, forced entry nto the homes or offces,

    serous threats such as stalkng or houndng of another HR defender or

    ther famly or ther organatonal members by suspcous ndvduals or

    groups on unmarked vehcles etc.

    When you or your organaton s called to respond to any of these

    ncdents, do the followng:

    Do1. not panc, ask the caller about the name of the vctm orlocaton and tme where the ncdent took place and report t to

    your organaton or offce.

    Verfy2. the nformaton, f you are n the area where the ncdent

    took place, establsh contact wth your colleagues n the area

    and tell them that you are close. Do not mmedately go to the

    area alone (especally n case of abducton and dsappearance)

    24

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    25/34

    and start askng queston. if you are not n the area where the

    ncdent happen, contact your pont persons or correspondent n

    the area, ask them f they are aware of such ncdent/ or contact

    the organaton where the vctm/s belong.

    if3. the report s verfed to be true, take your next steps.

    3.1 if the ncdent nvolves extrajudcal kllngs, abducton or

    possblty of subsequent dsappearance:

    . Get as many detals as possble from your contact

    person/s to help you n gettng meda attenton or

    organng a QRT (Quck Response Team of 3 or more

    persons and Fact-Fndng Msson). Before a QRT leaves,

    make sure that someone wll coordnate wth the meda,

    other lawyers and do other lason work wth dfferent

    nsttutons

    . For QRT dspatch, prepare all your logstcs

    (transporaton, money documentaton materals, etc) and

    people. Decde and clarfy specfc desgnaton of task

    to each team member and the structure or processes

    how the QRT/FFM wll be carred out. The objectve sto revew the crcumstances, ascertan facts surroundng

    the ncdent, detals of the ncdent ncludng the possble

    perpetrators, gather evdence and look after the securty

    and safety of vctms famly members

    . For alleged abductons, prepare yourself to vst mltary

    camps or polce statons f there are ndcatons or

    wtnesses that the perpetrators are from the state

    securty forces. immedately establsh contact wth thenearest CHR feld offce.

    v. When you arrve at the crme scene, ahead of the polce,

    do not touch, step or move anythng snce these are

    potental evdences whch maybe tampered wth your

    bare hands or footsteps. You may photograph or sketch

    25

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    26/34

    the place or scene as potental evdence. Do not pck up

    thngs and prevent others from dong so. Remember

    that you are not the ofcialcrime scene investigator,

    respect and secure the crime scene. Prevent others

    from spoiling the crime scene.

    v. Regularly update your man offce or organaton on the

    progress of your msson and document every event or

    progress or non-progress of your msson, the teams

    observatons and analyss.

    3.2 if the ncdent nvolves volent evcton n slum communtes or n

    streets, resultng to njures and you are far from the area, advce

    your contact person to provde some frst ad treatment and when

    necessary brng the vctms to the hosptal. Whenever possble,brng them n publc hospotal and later ask for a medco-legal

    examnaton. When treatment s done, ask the doctor to gve you

    a copy of the medco-legal certfcate that wll detal the nature

    and extent of njures of the vctms.

    if the vctm has already rested, ntervew hm or her on the

    detals of the ncdent and advse them, record the ntervew and

    tell hm/her that t s best that a sworn statement s executed.Prepare a draft of the sworn statement and let the vctm read t

    before t gets fnaled and later notared to make sure that your

    understandng of the facts are accurate. Both the certfcate and

    the sworn statement have legal purpose, n case the vctm later

    decde to fle a case or reply to a case fled

    3.3 if the ncdent nvolves arrest and detenton, and there s

    no mmedately avalable lawyer to assst, you may act as a

    paralegal. Get the names of all the arrested persons from yourcontact persons. Wth the other QRT members, follow those

    arrested to the polce staton to make sure that no volaton of

    rghts of the arrested person/s wll happen and the polce are

    remnded about the rghts of the arrested and ther responsblty

    to the former:

    26

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    27/34

    Dvde. the team members nto dfferent tasks: a)

    as negotator wth the authorty, b) one who wll

    talk and attend to the needs of the arrested, and to

    nform of ther rghts, and later ntervew them; c)

    documentor;

    At. the polce staton, ntroduce yourself and

    organaton that you represent and ask for the

    staton chef or offcer-n-charge.

    Tell. them about your objectve: that you were

    called concernng the arrested person/s and ask

    f any charge has been fled. Ask the permsson

    of the offcer-n-charge before you or any other

    QRT member talk or ntervew the vctms. Take

    the statements, as detaled as possble from thearrested and nform them that t wll be used for ther

    affdavts; other team members may focus on the

    well-beng of the arrested, lke provson of water or

    food when necessary.

    ifv. no case has been fled, try to negotate

    dplomatcally to get the arrested released wthout

    charges, or f one of your team members s a lawyer

    or trusted or promnent ndvdual, ask them f

    custody of the arrested can be gven to them. Ths

    happens occasonally f you are able to explan to the

    polce or arrestng offcer the crcumstances why the

    arrested and other communty members ressted or

    protested and appeal for ther understandng. Avod

    beng antagonstc n talkng wth the authortes,

    often t does not help and n some cases, t speeds

    up the process of flng charges aganst the arrested.Remember that your objectve s negotatng the

    release wthout charges.

    ifv. the case has been fled, and a lawyer s requred

    durng the nquest procedure, call your lawyer.

    When the lawyer/s arrves, orent them on what

    transpred and consult wth them on the next steps.

    27

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    28/34

    Whle watng for the nquest to happen, convene

    your QRT team to assess the assgned tasks and

    prepare the affdavt/s of the arrested. Normally, n

    cases lke ths, the role of QRT team ends when the

    arrested are released ether on bal or for further

    nvestgaton.

    ifv. you dont know where the polce keeps the arrested

    person, call the nearby polce statons where the

    reported ncdent happened, and nqure f that

    person you are lookng for s under ther custody.

    if after callng all the statons, the whereabouts of

    the person arrested s stll unknown, try precnct or

    jal vstatons to personally dentfy the arrested or

    mssng person. Brng someone along who knowspersonally the sad person, preferably n coordnaton

    wth the Commsson on Human Rghts who has the

    authorty to conduct jal and detenton vsts. When

    you fnd who you are lookng for, then advce hm/

    her on the stuaton and hs/her legal rghts, as

    prevously dscussed.

    inv. all nstances, make sure you document or record

    the detals.

    3.4. Basc requstes for QRT members.

    Make. sure you are physcally ft, so that you wll not

    gve addtonal concern to the team and that you wll

    not be a subject of another QRT. it s not advsable that

    defenders who have some heart-related alments jon

    the QRT operatons partcularly n cases of EJK anddsappearances.

    You. have completed a basc paralegal tranng.

    28

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    29/34

    Be. creatve and flexble n handlng every stuaton

    even f you have mapped out a fantastc plan, be

    prepared to make an adjustment when the stuaton

    warrants t.

    Bev. cool, not aggressve but bold and vglant Although t s often dffcult to stay calm, try your best,

    and make sure that all your senses are n ther best.

    Be keen on every detal especally f you are n a new

    envronment.

    Actv. and dress respectably Stay away from your

    favourte worn-out jeans, shrt wth your favourte

    poltcal or socal statement and sneakers or your

    rally attre, when gong to polce statons or camps.in a socety where appearance matters to gan proper

    attenton or respect, whether t s rght or wrong, t

    s best to dress approprately. Shrts wth poltcal

    statements also nvte attenton when you dont need

    t.

    Bev. dscplned, relable and dependable Come on

    agreed tme, not too early and not late. Always value

    the team unty hghly. Do not make or execute any plan,no matter how excellent t s wthout consultaton wth

    the rest of the team members as ths may jeoparde

    the securty and safety of the QRT and the vctms you

    are respondng to. Always seek the opnon or dea of

    other team members when you need to decde on the

    spot and be quck to share yours. Abde by the rules

    you have prevously agreed. Be patent, untl the Team

    fnshes ts msson and youre all back home safely.

    29

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    30/34

    DOCUMENTATION: WHY IS IT NECESSARY AND HOW TO DO IT

    Document and montor your case, the ncdent you have responded to or

    followng up. Human rghts volatons can only be effectvely addressed

    f prompt, proper and accurate documentaton exst. Documentaton s

    essental for any future legal acton or remedy. it can help wn or defeata court case. Documentaton s also an effectve tool for advocacy. it can

    provde a stuaton analyss, detalng the context, pattern or trends n

    human rghts volatons, and reflectons on the weakness or strength of

    responses or exstng mechansms.

    As HRD, t s mperatve that you do documentaton. Do not worry,

    documentaton can be as easy as 1, 2, and 3 especally f you take t as

    part of your day-to-day work.

    You can document n varous formats:

    textual1. or the wrtten format, it can start from a fact sheet whch

    contans answers to basc questons:

    what. - the ncdent or case s all about,

    when. - date and tme t happened, f the case s contnung,

    provde a chronology of events.

    wh. o - vctms names, ages, gender, organatonal

    afflaton f any and perpetrator- names, gender command

    or staton they belong to, organatons

    wherev. - exact locaton where ncdent or case happened,

    street #, vllage or barangay, town or cty, provnce,

    regon)

    whyv. - motve, analyss of the possble reason why the

    ncdent occurred, and crcumstances surroundng thencdent

    howv. - manner by whch the volaton has been commtted;

    f there are gunshot or stab wounds for example, specfy

    how many gunshot / stab wounds and body parts ht

    backgroundv. - nformaton on the nature of work of the

    vctm, ssues she/he advocate and ncdents that could

    30

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    31/34

    be related to the present case.

    Actonsv. taken f there s any and the result/s of such

    acton, ncludng mpact on the vctm, hs/her famly

    members and communty

    Updatex. - development or progress of the case from the

    tme of your frst documentaton. Ths s very mportant n

    a contnung case.

    Datex. - do not forget to put a date when your document

    was wrtten and the person responsble for wrtng t.

    vsual2. take photo or vdeo or make a sketch when you have

    no other equpment. Agan, f you arrve n the place of ncdent,

    mmedately take photographs or vdeo footages or make

    sketches. in takng vdeo, ask your colleague to dentfy the placeand the vctm and the date whle you are takng the vdeo so

    everythng wll be put on record. Ask hm or her to state her name,

    organaton before spewng out the detals. The same, f you are

    ntervewng a wtness. Do not edt your vdeo footages. Edted

    vdeo footages are not admssble as evdence.

    if you are n a hgh rsk area, fnd a way to send or transmt your

    photos and vdeos to your organatons offce or create backupcopes, n case an untoward ncdent happens that may

    result to a loss of your recordngs.

    audo3. ths s useful when you are n stuaton

    that takng pctures s not possble or n recordng

    conversaton over the phone whch can cause you to

    feel harassed or threatened.

    Part of a contnung case documentaton, s gatherngevdence that may support the case: object, documentary

    or testmonal etc. Examples of documentary evdence

    are polce blotter or report, medco-legal certfcate,

    publcatons, court documents, and the lke, and

    affdavts (testmonal).

    31

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    32/34

    it s also necessary that you montor and record the progress or

    non progress of the case or ncdent you have frst documented.

    if the case s fled n court, get an update. Ths s partcularly

    mportant f you are dong advocacy n support of the case,

    because your network wll expect you to gve a regular update

    and advce for further acton, f necessary or untl the case sfnshed or settled.

    if you have some dffcultes n establshng a QRT, or performng

    as paralegals, or dong systematc documentaton, organe

    specfc tranng sessons on these concerns or does not have

    access to ths tranng, request assstance from other human

    rghts or servce organatons n your network or regon.

    32

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    33/34

    At the end of ths handbook, we have compled a lst of networks nvolvng the

    State and cvl socety whch may be useful n the dfferent aspects of work of

    a human rghts defender.

    IMPORTANT CONTACT POINTS

    NATiONAL iNSTiTUTiONS:1. Commsson on Human Rghts of the Phlppnes

    Commonwealth Avenue, Dlman, Queon CtyTelefax: (632) 929 0102Hotlne: (632) 377 2477

    Emal: [email protected]

    Contact person: Hon. Loretta Ann Etta P. Rosales, Charperson

    2. Phlppne Natonal PolceHuman Rghts Affars OffceCamp Crame, Queon Cty

    Telefax: (632) 723 0401 loc. 3668Emal:[email protected]

    NON-GOVERNMENT ORGANizATiONS

    1. Center for Trade Unon and Human Rghts, inc (CTUHR)702 Culmat Bldg, 127 E. Rodrgue AvenueQueon cty, 1112 PhlppnesTelefax No. 632.4110256; Hotlne: 0910.3801897Emal:ctuhr.manlagmal.com or [email protected]

    webste: www.ctuhr.org

    Contact person: Dasy Arago, Executve Drector2. Prolabor Legal Assstance Center (PLACE)

    33-B E. Rodrgue AvenueQueon ctyTelefax: 02.4134561

    Emal:[email protected]

    Contact person: Atty Remgo Saladero Jr, Charperson

    3. Vsayas insttute for Human Development Agency (ViHDA)Door 8, 3rd Floor, AJ Sol Bldg

    Junquera Street, Cebue ctyTelephone 032.2548760

    Contact person: Ms. Dvna Malcay, Executve Drector4. Nonoy Lbrado Development Foundaton, inc (NLDFi)

    O85 Garnet Street, Phse 1, Coutrysde Vllage,Bangkal, Davao CtyTelephone no. (082) 296 -0767Emal address: [email protected]

    Contact person: Ms. Emma Rcaforte, Executve Drector

    33

  • 7/29/2019 Human Rights Defenders Handbook

    34/34

    HUMANRiGH

    DEFENDERS

    HANDBOOK

    REGiONALPRETESTS