how to write a - utep · how to write a dissertation march 22, 2017 ... literature search ......

28
Dr. Irasema Coronado and Dr. Jacen Moore HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 9:30-11:30 A . M .

Upload: truongnga

Post on 03-Jul-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

Dr. Irasema

Coronado and

Dr. Jacen Moore

HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION

MARCH 22, 20179:30-11:30 A.M.

Page 2: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

Share who you are and something

about yourself…

INTRODUCTIONS

http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net

Page 3: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡ In general a dissertation:§Defines the problem§Explains the importance§Reviews what we already

know§Describes what’s missing§Describes method used for

study§Analyzes/discusses results§Draws conclusions

WHAT IS A DISSERTATION?

lmitalia.net

Page 4: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡Title & Signature Page¡Application to Graduate¡Acknowledgements¡Table of Contents¡Abstract §Offers an Overview of the Research, its issues and methods

“FRONT MATTER”

Page 5: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

•Styles may vary based on College and Department•General format:•Chapter I: Introduction•Chapter II: Literature Review Theory•Chapter III: Methodology and Results•Chapter IV: Summary and Discussion

DISSERTATION FORMATTING

Page 6: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡Bibliography¡Citation Style¡Appendices¡Tables and Charts ¡CV

PRIMARY COMPONENTS OF A DISSERTATION

http://learn.solent.ac.uk/pluginfile.php/3110/mod_book/chapter/1289/diss-references.jpghttps://pbs.twimg.com/media/C7G7VDsXQAAcrJ_.jpg

Page 7: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

§What is your dissertation topic?§What are your contributions?§What will be new or different?§Why is it significant? §Can you clearly explain your topic?§Human and Animal Subjects Protection

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR HOW TO BEGIN

Page 8: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡ What is a literature review?§ A description of the literature

relevant to your field or topic§ Identify key researchers and

arguments§ Identify key theories and

hypotheses in the field or topic

¡ See Chris Hart’s Book Doing your Masters Dissertation§ https://books.google.com/books/

about/Doing_Your_Masters_Dissertation.html?id=drmwc95ezaYC&source=kp_cover&hl=en

LITERATURE REVIEW

https://books.google.com

Page 9: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

THE LITERATURE REVIEW

§ Perform thorough literature search §all available databases

§ Identify and evaluate only those relevant to your topic

§ Summarize work and highlight missing points

http://www.literaturereviewwritingservices.com

Page 10: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡Benefits to subjects¡Informed consent¡Protection of participants¡Minimizing discomfort¡Privacy¡Community values¡Conservation of

resources

ISSUES REGARDING USE OF HUMAN AND ANIMAL SUBJECTS

http://www.lssu.edu/irb/

Page 11: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡ Insure the humane care and use of animals in experimental science

¡ Ensuring research is conducted by personnel according to protocol

¡ Animal species¡ Justification of using animal species

§Alternate methods (reduce numbers, lowest level of vertebrate, possible alternate methods such as in vitro or computer simulations)

¡ Procedures§Pain levels§Minimization of pain and distress

ISSUES REGARDING USE OF ANIMAL SUBJECTS

http://www.amrc.org.uk

Page 12: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡ All research involving the use of recombinant DNA or pathogenic microorganisms requires the approval of the Institutional Biosafety Committee (IBC) BEFORE you start the work

¡ Your thesis advisor is responsible for submitting the necessary documentation for this approval

¡ You are responsible for obtaining the necessary training and certifications required by the IBC to conduct such research

ISSUES REGARDING RECOMBINANT DNA AND PATHOGENIC ORGANISMS

https://www.ehs.ucla.edu/research/bio/ibc

Page 13: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡Large amounts of data/information/sources¡Adjust, expand and improve the database ¡Keywords, themes, categories¡Emphasize accessibility ¡Advantages: §Become better acquainted with your research§Can help you see major and minor trends §Statistical analysis of various sub-topics

COLLECTING DATA AND ORGANIZING A DATABASE

Page 14: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

Research ? Writing Dissertation

ORGANIZATION: FROM RESEARCH TO WRITING

You can spend months collecting data and resources but it does not mean you are ready to write. You need to process and

organize your research before the writing process can begin.

Page 15: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡Get Organized from Day #1 ¡Digital sources, data sets, search terms, etc.¡Multiple levels of accessing your material §A) secondary source material by topic §B) research (how can you organize your

material in such a way that you can locate data quickly?

§Suggestion: organize your research based on the argument you are making in each chapter

ORGANIZATION IS THE KEY

Page 16: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡General outline of the dissertation§How many chapters?§What aspect of your argument is covered in each chapter? §Organization of chapters matters greatly!

¡Outline each chapter before writing§Primary sources? Secondary sources?§Literature review?

DISSERTATION STRUCTURE

Page 17: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡Introduction§Places the project in its proper context§Describes contributions to the field§Discusses the sources / texts used§Outlines chapters, major argument(s)§You might address methodology here or discuss this chapter by chapter, per various methodologies

THE DISSERTATION INTRODUCTION

Page 18: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

§Dissertation Chapters§Should advance a new argument and material§You will still have to revisit and expand

discussion of relevant works and theories that you briefly discussed in the introduction.

§Write, write, write §Writing will save effort and time later§ Ensure each chapter has a smooth transition

THE DISSERTATION CHAPTERS

Page 19: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡ Conclusion§ Summarize the main arguments of each

chapter§ Contribution, implications, significance. § Answer the “why should academics outside

your immediate specialty care about your findings?”

¡ Detailed and precise citations¡ Excellent citations are invaluable when turning

the dissertation into chapters, manuscript or book.

CONCLUDING THE DISSERTATION

Page 20: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡Self-discipline ¡Schedule writing time (ex: MWF 10 to 3pm) ¡No other commitments!!!¡Do not access email or Facebook during your writing time. Treat them as a reward.

TIME MANAGEMENT: MAKING WRITING A PRIORITY

Page 21: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡Set writing goals and take them seriously. ¡Enlist the aid of your advisor.¡Commit to a conference and present a

paper based on a chapter.¡The pros and cons of dissertation writing

groups§Imposes another kind of writing deadline§Time consuming and not always helpful

ACHIEVING WRITING GOALS

Page 22: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡Possible defense dates§Allot time before graduation§Paperwork, signatures§Submit a draft 3-4 weeks before defense

¡Communicate with committee§Does the timeline work for them?

¡Revisions can take a long time§Conceptual, organizational, grammatical

¡The best dissertation is a finished dissertation

TIMELINES AND DEADLINES

Page 23: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡ CHS PhD program: RA funded full-time student• Spring 2011: Started PhD program• 1st year: Developed area of interest• Spring 2012: Wrote a literature review publication• Summer 2012: Developed research question• Summer 2013: Proposed (chapters 1-3) • Collected data Fall 2013 & Spring 2014• May 2014: Conference presented prelim. findings• August 2014: Defended dissertation

SAMPLE COMPLETION TIMELINE

Page 24: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

¡ Read many dissertations first¡ Talk with advanced students¡ Develop professional habits¡ Be consistent and focused¡ Be positive¡ Be reasonable with expectations

CONCLUDING ADVICE

Page 25: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

DISSERTATION TIPS

§Routinely meet with advisor and committee members

§ Completed dissertation=Job!§Dissertation is a publication§Seek out publication venues

§Do not get behind!§Write something every day§Slow and steady wins the race

https://desmos-lesson-uploads.s3.amazonaws.com/activitybuilder/19539c075399938c20e94cc8baabc1a2

Page 26: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

DISSERTATION TIPS

• Network • Peer Review• Elevator Speech• How do you want for your

dissertation to be cited in a literature review?• Do not be afraid to ask

questions and seek out advice from other experts

https://atmanco.com

Page 27: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

DISSERTATION TIPS

• Finish the dissertation before it finishes you!• As you enter job market- time

to completion is a good indication of success as a scholar• Gracefully transition to other

advisor if not making progress• Chair of your dissertation

must write a positive letter of recommendation for job

krejcovstvi-mustek.cz

Page 28: HOW TO WRITE A - UTEP · HOW TO WRITE A DISSERTATION MARCH 22, 2017 ... literature search ... •Elevator Speech •How do you want for your

DISSERTATION TIPS

•Go forth and write, write, write!

http://images.8tracks.com