how digital autoradiography technique can be useful for d ...€¦ · how digital autoradiography...

29
Titre du document ~ February 2016 ~ 1 How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D & D projects? Pascal Fichet, Raphaël Haudebourg, CEA Saclay, DPC/SEARS/LASE, France 17th February 2016

Upload: others

Post on 10-Jun-2020

10 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

Titre du document ~ February 2016 ~ 1

How Digital Autoradiography technique

can be useful for D & D projects?

Pascal Fichet, Raphaël Haudebourg, CEA Saclay,

DPC/SEARS/LASE, France

17th February 2016

Page 2: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 2

Outline

• LASE laboratory: Analytical Support to Facilities Laboratory

• Digital Autoradiography Technique

• Digital Autoradiography for Radionuclides Mapping

• Digital Autoradiography in support of sampling processes

• Conclusions

Page 3: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 3

Outline

• LASE laboratory: Analytical Support to Facilities Laboratory

• Digital Autoradiography Technique

• Digital Autoradiography for Radionuclides Mapping

• Digital Autoradiography in support of sampling processes

• Conclusions

Page 4: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 4

LASE Laboratory

Different characterization

techniques for low and intermediate

level wastes.

Destructive analysis (sample = 1 g)

Radiochemistry

Alpha, Gamma, LSC

Elemental analysis

In situ technique: Autoradiography

Page 5: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 5

LASE Laboratory

Lots of Radwastes must be characterized

Innovations are required for in situ

techniques, for techniques allowing a

better sampling process

Destructive techniques need less than 1

g of sample for digestion process

Page 6: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 6

Outline

• LASE laboratory: Analytical Support to Facilities Laboratory

• Digital Autoradiography Technique

• Digital Autoradiography for Radionuclides Mapping

• Digital Autoradiography in support of sampling processes

• Conclusions

Page 7: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 7

DA Technique

Radiography

Autoradiography

Interests: H, C, S, … radionuclides difficult to measure

Source Detector

Detector

Page 8: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 8

DA Technique

Sensitive side Plastic side

« Image » of radioactivity

Page 9: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 9

DA Technique

Screens can be reused hundreds of time

(1) Screen initialization (2) Screen Deposit (3) Exposure

Time

(4) Screen withdrawn (6) Calculations (5) Screen scan

Page 10: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 10

DA Technique

• Semi quantitative values are achievable.

• Repeatability corresponds only to few percents

Same H-3

analysis

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Page 11: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 11

Outline

• LASE laboratory: Analytical Support to Facilities Laboratory

• Digital Autoradiography Technique

• Digital Autoradiography for Radionuclides Mapping

• Digital Autoradiography in support of sampling processes

• Conclusions

Page 12: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 12

Radionuclides mapping

H-3 mapping requirement

High radioactivity Laboratories in

Facility 459 CEA, Saclay

3 laboratories (250

m2 each) must be

destroyed. After

historical study

characterization is

required.

Page 13: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 13

Radionuclides mapping

1) Shutdown after the

period of research 2) Cleanup

5) Dismantling

3) Researches on the history of the facility

4) R&D required for initial state characterizations.

Page 14: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 14

Radionuclides mapping

Ceiling Wall Floor

Page 15: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 15

Radionuclides mapping

A grid corresponding to 70 screens

Radioactivity

image, here

C-14

Page 16: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16

Radionuclides mapping

100 % measurements is very difficult and not efficient when

considering geostatistical approach

35 zones were drawn

on concrete surface 1000 screens were

deposited on the floor

and located precisely

by using a telemeter.

Page 17: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 17

Radionuclides mapping

All Autoradiography images are processed by a homemade software

Here image resolution corresponds to small square of 5 mm * 5 mm

X1, Y1, DLU1 X2, Y2, DLU2 X3, Y3, DLU3 ……

Page 18: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 18

Radionuclides mapping

For the characterization: approximately

20 000 values processed

Variogram calculated

Page 19: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 19

Radionuclides mapping

Kriging calculation Uncertainties

Tritium traces Only 20% investigated by

autoradiography

Page 20: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 20

Outline

• LASE laboratory: Analytical Support to Facilities Laboratory

• Digital Autoradiography Technique

• Digital Autoradiography for Radionuclides Mapping

• Digital Autoradiography in support of sampling processes

• Conclusions

Page 21: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 21

Sampling process

www.vwr.com

Classical sampling

process

by wipe tests =

problems for non

labile radioactivity

In Situ Samplings

Alpha spectrometers

Liquid Scintillation

Counting

Laboratory

measurements

In situ measurements by

Autoradiography

Page 22: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 22

Sampling process

Sampling process for tritiated wastes

Destructive measurement of H-3 is done by pyrolysis followed by

Liquid Scintillation Counting (LSC)

Sample = 1 g

Page 23: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 23

Sampling process

Rapid investigation of wipes containing Uranium traces

Only 3 wipes among 7 contained Uranium.

After studies with a destructive method: wipe digestion followed by alpha spectrometry and/or ICP-MS, detection limit was determined at 0.2 Bq/wipe for Uranium.

Page 24: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 24

Sampling process

Core made of concrete

containing C-14

Activity on surface

Activity

in depth

Interesting

sampling

Page 25: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 25

Sampling process

Graphite cores containing

C-14

4 small cores on the same screen

Calculations Homogeneity of the

contamination at a very low scale

Page 26: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 26

Sampling process

Study of a resin located inside a

plastic tube containing I-129

Plastic

deposited on a

film for 15

minutes

Efficient

solution

for

sampling

process

Page 27: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 27

Outline

• LASE laboratory: Analytical Support to Facilities Laboratory

• Digital Autoradiography Technique

• Digital Autoradiography for Radionuclides Mapping

• Digital Autoradiography in support of sampling processes

• Conclusions

Page 28: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 28

Conclusions

• Autoradiography technique has been used for characterization of

Radwastes.

• The technique is efficient for radionuclides difficult to measure :

alpha and beta emitters

• Autoradiography is very sensitive to alpha > beta > gamma

• It allows characterizations to provide radionuclides mapping and

better sampling process.

• Semi quantitative values can be obtained.

• Researches are going on to improve the Autoradiography technique:

« Preliminary identification of α and β contaminations through Digital

Autoradiography » R Haudebourg, P Fichet

Page 29: How Digital Autoradiography technique can be useful for D ...€¦ · How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 16 Radionuclides mapping

How Digital Autoradiography Technique can be useful for D&D projects? ~ February 2016 ~ 29

Conclusions