hennepin county brookdale regional center - high performance building case study
TRANSCRIPT
Brookdale Daylighting
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
A High Performance BuildingCase Study
The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
By Loren E Abraham AIA, LEED AP
abraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center1
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
The "Whole Building" Design ApproachGoal: to create a successful high-performance building.
Strategy: Apply an integrated design approach during the planning and programming phases, e.g Involve all stakeholders in the design processThe ownerDesign TeamBuilding occupantsConstruction ManagerOperation & maintenance personnelGovernment agenciesCommunity Groups
Act on the premise that all building systems are interdependent e.g., modeling the building using all available simulation tools
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
2The "Whole Building" Design Approach The goal of 'Whole Building' Design is to create a successful high-performance building. To achieve that goal, we must apply the integrated design approach to the project during the planning and programming phases. It is necessary for the people involved in the building design to interact closely throughout the design process. The owner, building occupants, and operation and maintenance personnel should be involved to capture their understanding of how the building and its systems will work for them once they occupy it. The fundamental challenge of 'whole buildings' design is to understand that all building systems are interdependent.
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
The Basic ConceptRecognizing that buildings: are complex consume vast amounts of energy and material resources over their life time
The 'whole buildings' design approach is: a collaborative effort a comprehensive evaluation and modeling of materials, systems and assemblies for: costquality-of-lifefuture flexibilityEfficiencyoverall environmental impactproductivity and creativity how the occupants will be enlivened
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
3The Basic ConceptBuildings are deceptively complex. At their best, they connect us with our past and represent our greatest legacy for the future. They provide shelter, encourage productivity and embody our culture. But they also consume an extraordinary share of America's energy and material resources. In the past, we have addressed this issue by analyzing the individual components and subsystems of each building and optimizing them separately.The 'whole buildings' design approach asks the members of the planning, design and construction team to look at the materials, systems and assemblies from many different perspectives. The design is evaluated for cost, quality-of-life, future flexibility, efficiency; overall environmental impact; productivity and creativity and how the occupants will be enlivened.
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Celebration of lightHennepin County Brookdale Regional CenterBrooklyn Center, Minnesota
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center4
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Brookdale Regional Center What is sustainable?Sustainable Building Overview Minnesota Sustainable Building Guide and Comparison to LEEDs Rating System Environmental Quality Daylighting Design and VerificationEnergy & Atmosphere Excel Energy Assets Program Brookdale Life-cycle Cost Analysis Avoided Pollution (Externalities)Material & Resource StrategiesBuilding SystemsValue Engineering Value AnalysisImportance of Post Occupancy Evaluation
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
5Design Considerations Sustainable Building Overview Minnesota Sustainable Building Guide and Comparison to LEEDs Rating System Environmental Quality Daylighting Design, Verification and ImplementationEnergy & Atmosphere Excel Energy Assets Program Brookdale Life-cycle Cost Analysis Avoided Pollution (Externalities)Material & Resource StrategiesBuilding SystemsBuilding CommissioningPost Occupancy Evaluation?
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Brookdale Key StrategiesReuse/Reduce/RecycleSite & Water StrategiesEnvironmental Quality StrategiesDaylightingIndoor Air QualityThermal ComfortHuman FactorsEnergy Strategies (Energy Assets)Value Engineering/Value AnalysisBuilding Commissioning
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
6
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Minnesota State GuidelinesB3
(Formerly: Minnesota Sustainable Buildings Guidelines)Similar in scope to LEED
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center7
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
LEED Vs. MSBGWhat is LEED?The LEED Green Building Rating System, developed by the USGBC, is the only nationally recognized green building rating system. LEED evaluates the performance of buildings from a whole building perspective, over the course of a buildings lifecycle, which provides a definitive standard for what constitutes a green building. LEED Credit Categories and point systemSustainable Sites 14 ptsWater Efficiency 5p ptsEnergy & Atmosphere 17 ptsMaterials & resources 13ptsIndoor Environmental Quality 15 ptsInnovation & Design Process 5 pts
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center8
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Optimize Resource Utilization Maximize Reuse of Existing Structure
Before
After
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center9
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center10
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Optimize Site PotentialSite Access, Circulation and parkingAccess to Public TransportationEncourage Use of Bicycles, Motorcycles and car poolsLocation of Buildings & Landscaping responds to climate & solar orientationSite Lighting contained to siteSecurity not an afterthoughtLID, stormwater Management Practices, Habitat, Ecosystems
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center11
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Sustainable BuildingSustainable architecture is foremost about reimagining the relationship between human beings and living systems. The most powerful expression of this is our built environment. Today, architects must work with systems; they must design new ways of living and working in which buildings play a key role. __Paul Hawken from the preface to Sustainable Architecture White Papers
Thermal envelope optimizedwith R25 walls and an R40.Landscape bufferat park boundary.
Locally quarriedlimestone colonade.Structural systems optimized to reduce embodied energy by making frame lighter.Pond landscapedwith native wetland plant materials.Building demolition waste materials were ground up and reused on site as base for parking lot.Permeable pavingat plaza.Deciduous trees control solar rays based on seasonal requirements.Advanced selective low-e glazing optimizes daylight and solar gains with an R4 insulating value.Clerestory windows toharvest Daylight.Existing building and infrastructure were reused.
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center12Landscape bufferat park boundary.
Existing building and infrastructure were reused.
Structural systems optimized to reduce embodied energy by making frame lighter.
Thermal envelope optimizedwith R25 walls and an R40
Clerestory windows toharvest daylight.
Locally quarriedlimestone colonade.
Pond landscapedwith native wetland plant materials.
Advanced selective low-e glazing optimizes daylight and solar gains with an R4 insulating value.
Building demolition waste materials were ground up and reused on site as base for parking lot.
Permeable pavingat plaza.
Deciduous trees control solar rays based on seasonal requirements.
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Protect and Conserve WaterEcological Stormwater Management Pro-active watershed wide planning approachDraintiles adjusted and removed to let as much rain as possible soak into the ground where it fallsMinimize impervious surface areaDeep-Rooted Plant Communities in Pervious AreasDirect Runoff from Impervious Surfaces to Pervious SurfacesSwales with checkdams carry runoff to stormwater wetlandsRunoff detained and cleansed in stormwater wetlandsBio-swale schematic Courtesy Pierce County, WA/WSU Extension
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center13
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Protect and Conserve Water
Rainwater GardensWetland RestorationBio-filtration Pond takes runoff from parking lot
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center14
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center15
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center16
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Optimize Resource UtilizationReuse/Reduce/RecycleRenovate and Reuse Existing BuildingSalvage/Recycle Demolition MaterialsSeparate/Recycle Construction WastesUse Recycled MaterialsUse Recyclable MaterialsReduce Embodied EnergyDesign for Reuse/DisassemblyReduce Life-cycle Operation & Maintenance
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center17
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Celebrating light
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center18
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Design & VerificationDaylighting PrinciplesDaylighting GoalsDaylighting StrategiesDaylighting Assessment
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center19
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Design & VerificationDaylighting PrinciplesBring Light in HighControl and diffuse itBounce and redirect it
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center20
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Design & VerificationGoalsOptimize ambient levels in both perimeter and core zonesReduce glare, increase visual acuity and comfortMaintain minimum ambient levels in key areas e.g., 20 fc at floor in stack areasControl direct light more in task areas, less in non-task areas
Daylighting Strategies
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center21
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Strategies Implemented
Figure A: Schematic Section showing the daylighting strategies employed.Figure C: Small punched openings positioned high along mainstreet allow direct sunlight into non-critical task areas and the resulting light and shadow create movement and interest. The openings are beveled to optimize light and minimize uncomfortable contrasts between window and wall.Figure D: The condition at the new and existing building interface presents an opportunity to create clerestrories at the high-low roof intersection. The clerestory on the left faces north and brings in soft diffuse light while the clerestory on the right faces west. Figure E: Existing clerestories in the renovated portion of the regional center were retained and re-glazed with new higher performance glazing for improved daylighting performance. They allow daylight in the areas of the building core that would otherwise be windowless.Figure B: Prismatic glass redirects intense rays of light coming from the West up onto the plaster scoop.
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center22Figure C:Small punched openings positioned high along mainstreet allow direct sunlight into non-critical task areas and the resulting light and shadow create movement and interest. The openings are beveled to optimize light and minimize uncomfortable contrasts between window and wall.
Figure E: Existing clerestories in the renovated portion of the regional center were retained and re-glazed with new higher performance glazing for improved daylighting performance. They allow daylight in the areas of the building core that would otherwise be windowless.
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Strategies Implemented
Figure 1: Shafts of daylight stream into West Rotunda Interior providing a feeling of well-being as well as valuable information.Figure 2: High clerestories in the library atMainstreet provide glare free abundant light to the room below without the problems of direct light. The vertical surfaces bounce and diffuse the lightFigure 3: Sloping the ceiling has the same effect as maintaining the higher level throughout the space with the added advantages of greater clearance above the ceiling for mechanical systems where it is needed and the ceiling is brighter than it would be if flat because it reflects incident horizontal light much better.Figure 4: A highly efficient reflective film called SOLF (short for solar optic lens film) made by 3M, optimizes the effectiveness of these light shelves in the Library which bounce light up onto the sloped ceiling providing more even illumination in the space. They also reduce glare near the windowsFigure 5: By providing a graduated frit pattern on the glass above the light shelf instead of using the solar shade, we ensure that there will always be illumination for the light shelf and the frit reduces heat gains similar to the shade system but with far less cost. Figure 6: The molded plaster light Scoop in the Courts waiting area effectively softens and distributes light not only to this space but the adjacent rooms as well.
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center23Figure 1: Shafts of daylight stream into West Rotunda Interior providing a feeling of well-being as well as valuable information. Figure 2: The molded plaster light Scoop in the Courts waiting area effectively softens and distributes light not only to this space but the adjacent rooms as well. Figure 3: A highly efficient reflective film called SOLF (short for solar optic lens film) made by 3M, optimizes the effectiveness of these light shelves in the Library which bounce light up onto the sloped ceiling providing more even illumination in the space. They also reduce glare near the windows. Figure 4: High clerestories in the library atMainstreet provide glare free abundant light to the room below without the problems of direct light. The vertical surfaces bounce and diffuse the light. Figure 5: Sloping the ceiling has the same effect as maintaining the higher level throughout the space with the added advantages of greater clearance above the ceiling for mechanical systems where it is needed and the ceiling is brighter than it would be if flat because it reflects incident horizontal light much better. Figure 6: By providing a graduated frit pattern on the glass above the light shelf instead of using the solar shade, we ensure that there will always be illumination for the light shelf and the frit reduces heat gains similar to the shade system but with far less cost.
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting StudiesIlluminance Study ResultsBenefits of ClerestoriesExcess Light at CurtainwallLight Shelves EffectiveSkylights Beneficial at Low Ceiling Areas
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center24
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center25
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting StudiesIlluminance Study ResultsBenefits of ClerestoriesExcess Light at CurtainwallLight Shelves Effective
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center26
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Studies curtainwall & lightshelves
No light shelvesLight shelves
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center27
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting StudiesIlluminance Study ResultsBenefits of ClerestoriesExcess Light at CurtainwallLight Shelves Effective
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center28
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting StudiesIlluminance Study ResultsBenefits of ClerestoriesExcess Light at CurtainwallLight Shelves EffectiveSkylights Beneficial at Low Ceiling Areas
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center29
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center30
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Studies
No Skylights at Low Ceiling
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center31
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Studies
Skylights at Low Ceiling
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center32
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting StudiesIrradiance StudiesPurpose: To Determine Times and Source of Undesirable Direct Ray penetration into interior
WSolsticeWSolsticeSSolsticeEquinox
SSolsticeEquinoxWSolsticeSSolsticeEquinox
WSolsticeSSolsticeEquinox
DBEA
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center33
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting StudiesExterior Shading Studies
EquinoxSSolsticeEquinox
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center34
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Study AnalysisConclusions & Corrective MeasuresSolar Shading System needed at Curtainwall below light shelfGraduated frit preferred for solar control above light shelfLight shelf helps to create a more uniform illuminance level across area South of Main StreetWindow Blinds will be needed at all perimeter windows
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center35
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Study Analysis
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center36
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Study AnalysisConclusions & Corrective Measures
Prismatic Glazing preferred for solar control at West facing clerestoryRotundas will not present a visual disability problem to adjacent task areasBlack out shades needed at Storytime
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center37
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Shafts of daylight stream into Rotunda Interiors providing a feeling of well-being as well as valuable subliminal information.
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center38
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Clerestories in the library atMainstreet provide glare free abundant light to the spaces below without the problems of direct light. The vertical surfaces bounce and diffuse the light.
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center39
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Sloping the ceiling has the same effect as maintaining the higher level throughout the space with the added advantages of greater clearance above the ceiling for mechanical systems here it is needed and the ceiling is brighter than it would be if flat because it reflects incident horizontal light much better.
Sloped Ceiling
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center40
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Light Shelves
Light Shelves: A highly efficient reflective film called SOLF (short for solar optic lens film) made by 3M, optimizes the effectiveness of these light shelves in the Library which bounce light up onto the sloped ceiling providing more even illumination in the space. They also reduce glare near the windows
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center41
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
By providing a graduated frit pattern on the glass above the light shelf instead of using the solar shade, we ensure that there will always be illumination for the light shelf and the frit reduces heat gains similar to the shade system but with far less cost.
Fritted Glass
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center42
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Plaster light scoopThe molded plaster light Scoop in the Courts waiting area effectively softens and distributes light not only to this space but the adjacent rooms as well.
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center43
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Hardware Strategies
order to harvest the energy savings made possible from harvesting the natural daylight, photosensors detect natural light levels and send a message to the light fixture ballast (shown at right) dimming the light proportionately between 25-100% of the total lamp output.Electronic dimming ballasts are used in all light fixtures serving designated Daylight Zones and allow photosensor controlled dimmingA highly efficient reflective film called SOLF (short for solar optic lens film) made by 3M, optimizes the effectiveness of these light shelves in the Library which bounce light up onto the sloped ceiling providing more even illumination in the space. They also reduce glare near the windowsCharcoal Gray Eco-veil 5% open shade cloth is used. Darker colors appear transparent to occupants, whereas lighter colors diffuse light and add glare.
Solar Trac II Automated sun tracking shade control system.
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center44
Figure 7: In order to harvest the energy savings made possible from harvesting the natural daylight, photosensors detect natural light levels and send a message to the light fixture ballast (shown at right) dimming the light proportionately between 25-100% of the total lamp output.
Figure 8: Electronic dimming ballasts are used in all light fixtures serving designated Daylight Zones and allow photosensor controlled dimming. Figure 9: Mechoshades Solar Tracking Electroshade system provides control for each window zone independently without any operator involvement .for a bright glare-free environment. Figure 10: The condition at the new and existing building interface presents an opportunity to create clerestrories at the high-low roof intersection. The clerestory on the left faces north and brings in soft diffuse light while the clerestory on the right faces west.
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center45
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center46
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center47
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center48
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center49
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Indoor Environmental QualityIndoor Air Quality (IAQ)Thermal ComfortLighting Quality and Visual AcuityHuman Factors
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center50
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Indoor Air Quality Factors affecting Indoor Air QualityVentilationSource Control & Material SelectionCleansing and Maintenance
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center51
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Human Factors
User adjustable work surfaces and seatingFacilities designed for accessibilityAppropriate selection of hardwareLogically laid out spaces with intuitive way-finding circulation designEasily seen and understood signage
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center52
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Energy and AtmosphereSignificance of Energy Consumption in Buildings
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center53
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Energy and Atmosphere Excel Energy AssetsThermal LoadsOptimization and DesignEnergy Use Reduction Peak Demand Load ReductionUtility Cost ReductionComputer Simulation (DOE 2)Life Cycle Cost Benefit AnalysisBuilding CommissioningEnergy Strategy Verification and Utility Rebate ($50,000)
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center54
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Energy Efficiency Strategies Employed High Performance Lighting Systems:Daylight Harvesting Continuous Dimming Controls High Performance AzurliteTM Glazing (high transmittance-VT /low shading coef.)Occupancy Sensor Lighting Controls Wherever feasible, e.g., Private Offices, Conference Rooms, Storage Rooms, etc.Programmable Multi-purpose Lighting Systems in Meeting and Training RoomsTimer Control of lighting wherever feasible by BASImprove Lighting Quality & Reduce FC LevelsT8 lamps w/Electronic BallstsCompact Fluorescents used in lieu of Incandescent and HID
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center55
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Energy Efficiency Strategies EmployedHigh Performance HVAC Systems:Reduced Thermal Loads (reduce equipment size) through high performance Glazing, solar controls & landscaping - Result: 20% (100 ton) reduction in cooling loadsVFDs on pumps and AHU fansHigh Efficiency Chiller (modular screw type)Building Automation SystemAll Direct Digital Temperature Controls (in lieu of Pneumatic)Occupancy Sensor Control of VAV Boxes where appropriate
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center56
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Other Energy Strategies EmployedHi-reflectance Ceilings (improved lighting efficacy)Increased Thermal Insulation R-Values (R25 avg. walls & R40 Roof)Commissioning ProcessExpanded Daylighting StrategyIncrease VAV boxes (greater degree of individual user control)
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center57
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Energy Simulation Results
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center58
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center59
Importance of CommissioningEstablish Design goals that are optimal and comprehensiveEnsure that construction details and specifications are installed as designedProvide for optimal calibration of Daylighting Controls and Occupancy SensorsProvide for Proper Programming of Temperature Controls and Building Automation SystemsEvaluate effectiveness of design and possible need for modifications
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
60
Importance of Post-Occupancy EvaluationDetermine whether Design functions as intendedEvaluate user satisfactionIdentify and resolve problemsVerify Predicted Energy savingsVerify Predicted performance of Renewable Energy Systems (e.g., photovoltaic, wind turbines, Ground source Heat Pumps, etc.)Verify stormwater management system performanceIdentify gains in Productivity and Absenteeism
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
61
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
OWNER TEAMHennepin County Property Services DepartmentMark Merrill, Project ManagerGreg, Karr, Design Construction ManagerTom Peters, Facilities ManagerRoy Earl, Engineering ManagerSusie Graber, Interiors ManagerTom Billings, Engineering ManagerDick Eisner, Industrial HygienistPhrashant Kharkar , Planning DirectorJon Gravender, PlannerMark Lee, Acting Security ManagerHennepin County LibrariesJanet Leick, Librarian Administrative DirectorCharles Brown, DirectorDavid Cramer, Administrative Service ManagerSharon Charles, Tech Server ManagerLarry Aamot, Purchasing ManagerBruce Wilda, FacilitiesBill Berg, Audio Visual SystemsRick Johnson, Audio Visual SystemsHenn. County Children, Family, Adult serviceDavid Sanders, DirectorJoan Smith, Deputy DirectorBruce Gottsche, Deputy DirectorTerri McGinley, Deputy DirectorJohn Sellen, Deputy DirectorRandy Stacy, Deputy DirectorKaren WahlundLea Bloomquist
County Economic AssistanceDeborah Huskins, DirectorDon HolmbergCathy LindbergGloria LundbergHennepin County Community CorrectionsFred LaFleur, DirectorJuli JonesLinda BergDonna GriffinLes PrattBob RoeglinElizabeth SandsHennepin County Sheriff's OfficePatrick McGowan, SheriffMike Hubred, SargeantBrian Kasbohm, DeputyDick Loose, CaptainThomas Merkel, InspectorHennepin County District CourtMark Thompson, AdministratorMichael Kelley, Assistant AdministratorMike HickeyWayne MinskeSandra PughHennepin County Taxpayer ServicesPat O'Conner, DirectorMark Oswald, ManagerBarb Ramaker, ITInformation Technology OperationsLeanne CombsGary KampBob LernerHennepin County CommunicationsDeb HolwegerGreg White
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
62Hennepin County Property Services DepartmentMark Merrill, Project ManagerGreg, Karr, Design Construction ManagerRoy Earl, Engineering ManagerSusie Graber, Interiors ManagerTom Billings, Engineering ManagerDick Eisner, Industrial HygienistPhrashant Kharkar , Planning DirectorJon Gravender, PlannerMark Lee, Acting Security ManagerHennepin County LibrariesJanet Leick, Librarian Administrative DirectorCharles Brown, DirectorDavid Cramer, Administrative Service ManagerSharon Charles, Tech Server ManagerLarry Aamot, Purchasing ManagerBruce Wilda, FacilitiesBill Berg, Audio Visual SystemsRick Johnson, Audio Visual SystemsHenn. County Children, Family, Adult serviceDavid Sanders, DirectorJoan Smith, Deputy DirectorBruce Gottsche, Deputy DirectorTerri McGinley, Deputy DirectorJohn Sellen, Deputy DirectorRandy Stacy, Deputy DirectorKaren WahlundLea BloomquistCounty Economic AssistanceDeborah Huskins, DirectorDon HolmbergCathy LindbergGloria LundbergHennepin County Community CorrectionsFred LaFleur, DirectorJuli JonesLinda BergDonna GriffinLes PrattBob RoeglinElizabeth SandsHennepin County Sheriff's OfficePatrick McGowan, SheriffMike Hubred, SargeantBrian Kasbohm, DeputyDick Loose, CaptainThomas Merkel, InspectorHennepin County District CourtMark Thompson, AdministratorMichael Kelley, Assistant AdministratorMike HickeyWayne MinskeSandra PughHennepin County Taxpayer ServicesPat O'Conner, DirectorMark Oswald, ManagerBarb Ramaker, ITInformation Technology OperationsLeanne CombsGary KampBob LernerHennepin County CommunicationsDeb HolwegerGreg WhiteUser Groups:Hennepin County Property Services User GroupKandice Barnes, Building ManagerJeff McGregor, Building EngineerBrookdale Library User GroupMichael McConnell, Head LibrarianJulaine Heit, Youth Service LibraryJackie Gillespie, Service ManagerJoe ManionGail Mauer, Adult Service LibraryMolly Schaaf, Youth Service LibraryJeanne Stevens, Adult Service LibraryBrookdale Regional Center Children, Family, Adult service User GroupLynn Malfeld, CFS SupervisorPam ReinkeHal Schippitz, AS SupervisorLaura Linn, AS SupervisorHennepin County Public Defender User GroupLeonardo CastroBarry Marchant, ITHennepin County District Court User GroupSheldon Spack, SupervisorHennepin County Sheriff's Office User GroupJune Johnson, SargeantBrian Kasbohm, DeputyBrookdale Service Center User GroupLyn Juntunen, ManagerMichael Hanson
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
BROOKDALE USER GROUPSHennepin County Property Services User GroupKandice Barnes, Building ManagerJeff McGregor, Building Engineer
Brookdale Library User GroupMichael McConnell, Head LibrarianJulaine Heit, Youth Service LibraryJackie Gillespie, Service ManagerGail Mauer, Adult Service LibraryMolly Schaaf, Youth Service LibraryJeanne Stevens, Adult Service LibraryJoe ManionDiane Deutsch
Brookdale Regional Center Children, Family, Adult service User GroupLynn Malfeld, CFS SupervisorPam ReinkeHal Schippitz, AS SupervisorLaura Linn, AS Supervisor
Hennepin County Public Defender User GroupSheila FaulknerJames GrochalBarry Merchant
Hennepin County District Court User GroupSheldon Spack, Supervisor
Hennepin County Sheriff's Office User GroupJune Johnson, SargeantBrian Kasbohm, Deputy
Brookdale Service Center User GroupLyn Juntunen, ManagerMichael Hanson
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
63
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
PROJECT DESIGN TEAMOWNER REPRESENTATIVEHennepin County Property Services Mark Merrill, Project Manager
ARCHITECTSAbraham + Associates ArchitectsLoren E. Abraham, AIA, Lead Designer and Principal ArchitectGreg Ludwig, AIA, Project Manager
Buetow & Associates, Inc.Tom Dunwell, AIA, PrincipalMod Feders, AIA, Project ManagerDave Olds, AIA Project ArchitectJames Kampmann, Project Captain
INTERIOR DESIGNERNelson (E-Design)Debra Emert, ASID, PrincipalJennifer Gilligan, Senior Interior Designer
CIVIL & STRUCTURALClark Engineering CorporationENGINEERS Hadi Sajadi, P.E., Principal Structural EngineerBarry Wagner, P.E., Principal Civil Engineer
MECHANICAL & ELECTRICALGausman & MooreENGINEERS Robert Full, P.E., Principal Mechanical EngineerBill Kosanke, Mechanical EngineerLane Hersey, Principal Electrical EngineerSteve Schroeder, Electrical EngineerJim Keller, P.E., Consulting Engineer (Sustainable Design)DaJeff Westlund, P.E. Communications Engineer
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
64OWNER REPRESENTATIVEHennepin County Property Services Mark Merrill, Project ManagerARCHITECTSBuetow & Associates, Inc.Tom Dunwell, AIA, PrincipalMod Feders, AIA, Project ManagerDave Olds, AIA Project ArchitectJames Kampmann, Project CaptainAbraham + Associates ArchitectsLoren E. Abraham, AIA, Principal ArchitectINTERIOR DESIGNERNelson (E-Design)Debra Emert, ASID, PrincipalJennifer Gilligan, Senior Interior DesignerCIVIL & STRUCTURALClark Engineering CorporationENGINEERS Hadi Sajadi, P.E., Principal Structural EngineerBarry Wagner, P.E., Principal Civil EngineerMECHANICAL & ELECTRICALGausman & MooreENGINEERSRobert Full, P.E., Principal Mechanical EngineerBill Kosanke, Mechanical EngineerLane Hersey, Principal Electrical EngineerSteve Schroeder, Electrical EngineerJim Keller, P.E., Consulting Engineer (Sustainable Design)
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
PROJECT TEAM (Other Consultants)LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS Brodsho ConsultingDebbie Brodsho, Landscape Architect and Kestrel Design Group, Inc.Peter McDonagh, RLASean Jergens, Landscape designer
DAYLIGHTINGAbraham + Associates/Daybreak Technology, L.L.C.Loren Abraham, Principal Facilities: UofM Daylighting Lab
ENERGY ASSISTANCE The Weidt GroupJay Johnson, Project Manager
SUSTAINABLE DESIGN University of Minnesota Center for Sustainable Building ResearchJohn Carmody, Director
AUDIO VISUALElert & Associates Will Craig, CTS-D
SECURITY James L. Johnson Associates, Inc. James L. Johnson, Principal
CONTRACTOR Shaw-Lundquist Associates, Inc. Dave LaPree, Project ManagerSpencer Jurens, Job SuperintendantPaul Rosendale, Project Manager at large
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center
65
Loren E. Abraham, AIA, LEED APabraham + associates architects
Questions
Daylighting Case Study The Hennepin County Brookdale Regional Center66