heading 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · web viewcombined session notes from eorganic visioning....

27
COMBINED SESSION NOTES FROM EORGANIC VISIONING FEBRUARY 26-28, 2007 MONDAY, FEBRUARY 26 TH Introduction to eXtension Powerpoint Presentation by Carla Craycraft, Craig Wood of eXtension. Debra Pankow discussed lessons learned in the development of the Personal Finance eXtension site. TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 27 TH eOrganic Overview Powerpoint presentation by Jim Riddle on behalf of Alex Stone, followed by brief introductions from each eOrganic Team Leader: Jim Riddle, Certification; Heather Darby, Dairy; Michelle Wander and Mary Barbercheck, Diversified Vegetable Cropping. General Comments and Questions Audience: Website audience also includes processors and retailers Are youth a target audience? Delivery methods: everything should also be available in a print version for those who don’t have access to the internet. Content: Strength of eXtension is that there may be people who have expertise that is not organic, but relevant to organic that can contribute. Conservative groups of researchers do not feel farmer anecdotal information is credible. However, this may be resolved if their content comes in the form of Case Studies, or are clearly identified as farmer experiences. Information needs to go through careful review. Bad information can put a farmer out for 3 years. 1

Upload: others

Post on 18-Oct-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

COMBINED SESSION NOTES FROM EORGANIC VISIONINGFEBRUARY 26-28, 2007

MONDAY, FEBRUARY 26TH

Introduction to eXtension

Powerpoint Presentation by Carla Craycraft, Craig Wood of eXtension. Debra Pankow discussed lessons learned in the development of the Personal Finance eXtension site.

TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 27TH

eOrganic Overview

Powerpoint presentation by Jim Riddle on behalf of Alex Stone, followed by brief introductions from each eOrganic Team Leader: Jim Riddle, Certification; Heather Darby, Dairy; Michelle Wander and Mary Barbercheck, Diversified Vegetable Cropping.

General Comments and Questions – Audience:

Website audience also includes processors and retailers Are youth a target audience?

– Delivery methods: everything should also be available in a print version for those who don’t have access to the internet.

– Content: Strength of eXtension is that there may be people who have expertise that is

not organic, but relevant to organic that can contribute. Conservative groups of researchers do not feel farmer anecdotal information

is credible. However, this may be resolved if their content comes in the form of Case Studies, or are clearly identified as farmer experiences.

Information needs to go through careful review. Bad information can put a farmer out for 3 years.

Can there be a space for creative writing for people to contribute, such as Blog?

– Logistics: Short Term goals are under the timeline with November launch date Communication between the resource teams: Team leaders are liaisons

between teams and have scheduled times throughout the year for meetings.

CERT (Certification Extension Resource Team):– Need glossary, search engines, table of contents. – Could NOSB meeting information be included on the site. Yes, through linking to

their site, and with information.

1

Page 2: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

– People interested in organic products are another audience. Want to know how organics become certified.

– Need to know why even certify– For farms who don’t have to certify, have information specifically for them.

DERT (Dairy Extension Resource Team):– If goal is the best organic dairy website on the planet, what other countries are

doing should be a consideration. There are cross compliance issues because standards in Europe are different. Possibilities for content are lists of differences between standards.

[Facilitator’s note: we did not have any specific comments on VERT’s presentation]

eOrganic Vision Statement Development

Carri Munn and Desiree Rajee, facilitators from Decisions Decisions, asked each participant to write down three wishes for eOrganics’ future. Cards were collected for review by the Vision Team.

eOrganic Concept Map

Jeff Birkby, ATTRA; Dan Sullivan, Rodale Institute/New Farm; and Jonathan Landeck, OFRF/Organic Ag Info briefly presented what their organization’s role in online organic information provision. Carri Munn presented a summary of eOrganic’s audience, content sources, and delivery methods described in the OREI proposal and facilitated a discussion around the question of what unique services or information eOrganic will offer that adds value.

Online Resources for Organic Information:– ATTRA– New Farm– Organic Ad Info– SARE mandated websites: some

states are required to have websites

– Certifiers– IFOAM– NODPA– MOSES– Organic Center– Organic Ecology Site– OFRF– State Departments of Agriculture– USDA: Organic data sheets– Soil help library: Classic organic

literature

– Natural Resources Conservation Service

– State Offices: creating organic section in website

– Organic E-prints: European research

– Cyberhelp for organic farmers of Canada

– NLP: Federal Organic Rule– Organic Valley– Ofarm.org– Organic Seed companies– Organic Trade Association

(consumer info)

2

Page 3: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

eOrganic’s Potential Target Audiences (Community of Interest)* indicates audience not previously identified in the OREI proposal

Farmers – Conventional and organic – In all US regions – Horticultural and agronomic crops – Livestock – Other agricultural products – Beginning Farmers*– Farmers looking to diversify*– Immigrant communities*

Agricultural professionals: – Crop advisors – Veterinarians – Researchers – Federal agencies (such as NRCS employees) – Processors (livestock and grain)– Certifying agencies – Land Grant University personnel – Extension educators and specialists – County Extension Agents*– Farm Managers and Rule Appraisers*– Intermediaries of Food Supply Chain*

Others:– Elementary through college students*– Consumers*– Tech Schools*– Lending Community*– Product developers*– Urban planners*– Medical and Public Health professionals*– Other CoPs in eXtension*

eOrganic Priorities:– Impact curriculum available for educators– Increase the supply of organic transition information– Inform Policy Makers of ecological and economic impacts

Important Content areas to be addressed:– Organic Standards– How standards/policy/regulation impact production– Organic markets of the future– Information of supply and demand of organic products

3

Page 4: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

– Climate change– Energy: alternative energy, conservation, use, technologies– Distribution systems– Agriculture equipment– Supply of feed– Land access – Incorporating Agriculture in urban areas– Local infrastructure for processing of organic sources– Methodology, how to do systems research? (long-term)– Efficacy of materials– Efficacy of cultural methods– Funding sources

Notes on Presentation of Content– Content needs to be easy to find from the Home Page

2-click rule to access what you’re searching- There will be usability study mid-year as part of evaluation

– Functional access and formatting Make documents available in print form (mail order or print on demand at

local Kinkos) Have html and PDF versions available for viewing content Make sure documents are easy to print (print-friendly layout) Ensure website meets ADA requirements. User-friendly for disabled people

(need compatible software systems) Documents in other languages (Spanish)

– Searching for information Provide users with access to the source of the information (order forms,

contact information). Identify who has contributed/authored information to maintain credibility Search summary results--need all relevant links related to that topic on the

same page. Provide “help” info on how to use search engines in partnership with content

– Explore creation of educational video Games– Allow users to drive content development

eXtension System & Support– eOrganic will use eXtension’s graphic format

Style sheet will be standard template up to launch Design elements (highlights, events) are fixed

– Content Development One-page instruction/tips sheet on guidelines to write content should be

developed Professional development offered by eXtension

– FAQ System Highly developed system that tracks editors and revisions over time

– Ask-the-Expert

4

Page 5: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

eXtension is currently working with Horticulture CoP to develop the ability to filter ask-the expert questions by region

Existing content/FAQs will appear to encourage user to read that information that may address their issue before submitting a question to the “expert”,

2-day response time-frame for questions A backlog report will be generated when questions have not received a

response in the 2-day time frame

How does eOrganic provide unique value?

Gateway to organic information online: It can be confusing for users when layouts of sites are so different from one another. As the information hub, eOrganic can provide a standard content layout and search engine for users to easily access content in multiple locations (e.g. eOrganic, ATTRA, Organic Ag Info).– eOrganic needs to be well-developed in the meta-language within the site, (after

performing a web search, meta-language is the brief content description which appears below a website link). Meta-language is the key tool for bridging content from multiple sources and websites and helping users find what they are looking for. Standards for meta-language will result in consistently formatted search results.

– Allow multiple ways to access documents (e.g. under multiple subject or keyword headings)

– Multiple access points into the site – Different types of content will appear to targeted audiences

High-Quality Information – Credible: there is a system to review and filter information, this system provides

legitimacy to content, and is relevant to target audience– Useful: Draws from multiple sources and is relevant to many different cross-

sections– User-friendly: searchable, easy to navigate, intuitive from end-user perspective,

multiple forms of sharing information– Depth of information: amount of content– Breadth of information: links to more content– Relevant information: region-specific information, current issues– Accessible: printable, ADA, translations available

Content Development Methods: eOrganic will develop a collaborative model of content development to make the experiential information of farmers available in a credible format. By providing an information bridge between farmers with LGU faculty, eOrganic adds to the legitimacy of current organic practices, identifies research needs, supports integration of research and practice, and provides a platform for information sharing. – Collaborative Model for research and content development

5

Page 6: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

CoP within itself (Farmers and LGU faculty working together to develop research, farmer and LGU faculty member perform peer-review together)

CoP with CoI (mentoring, interactive website which draws on user input) CoI within itself (networking, information sharing between farmers)

Organic Farmer Mentors: supporting a Network of farmers: (future)

Comments:– Content should include credible Case Studies with experiential information of

Farmers.– A collaborative model will result in the development of information that would not

otherwise be available. – Researchers and farmers are able to fill-in the gaps for each other– Farmers get information from: Extension, neighbors, and Industry. eOrganic can

provide information from their fellow farmers and links to research. – Take information which is not available as on-farm research and systems

research to support collaborative work and make accessible to users – Allow farmers and extension faculty to connect and produce research together

(model in Holland)– Actively solicit farmer observations. – Peer-review process validity depends on target audience. – Bringing forward Farmer experiences should be an invigorating part of the site,

supported by research. – Social networking of CoI can occur within itself, and with CoP

Challenges in Content Development

Powerpoint Presentation by Raj Smith, content manager for Cornell University’s eXtension site Wildlife Damage Management.

eOrganic Guiding Principles

Facilitators conducted a brief brainstorming session to develop principles to guide eOrganics’s development process, content, relationships, and management. Notes were given to the Vision Team for refinement.

eOrganic’s relationship to other organic information providers

Partnership model: eOrganic will develop as one partner in a national, user-driven, evolving, web-based, organic agriculture information system that strives to:– Reflect equitable and complementary relationships – Prevent duplication

6

Page 7: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

– Maintain the quality of and audience for each entity’s work– Be cross-searchable

e-Organic’s role: Centralize access information by pulling together and indexing all other available sources information. – Database repository in partnership with AOI– Provide various levels of depth appropriate for different audiences– Link to external information of partnership entities

Important from time management perspective Partners maintain control over primary source content and responsibility for

updating– Establish a threshold of credibility through implementation of peer-review process

4 primary target audiences (Carmen)1) Extension educators, professionals, researchers, consultants looking for a peer accepted source to inform and educate themselves when speaking with their producer clients2) Farmer or well-experienced organic producer looking to advance their information on a specific area of work or practice3) Farmer wishing to transition to organic4) Non-farmer wanting to learn more about any number of aspects of organic production.

Content Development Priorities1) Get information from LGU system2) Use a peer-review process to validate information received outside of LGU

system3) Develop a methodology to bridge gap between practice and research

Comments and Issues– ATTRA vs. eOrganic: There is overlap. A way to pull LGU information out that has

not yet been released.– eOrganic can provide more credibility to ATTRA through partnership, because of

eOrganic’s LGU network. – With the FAQ function eOrganic could become very problem focused, an online

organic info hotline– Within LGU community, there are many resources available. There is

accountability built in.

– eOrganic’s Standards: Editorial Policy needs to be developed that identifies what is valid. Peer Review Replicated, randomized, complete experiments? Does eOrganic establish this

standard or does it present the information without these standards accepting it as is?

7

Page 8: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

Be honest about where the information came from. Embed reviews in the content to track changes Need consistency. Have separate, CLEARLY IDENTIFIED sections of

content.

– Need an approach to bring the farmer experience in. This is paramount to the credibility of the content. Validation is crucial. Template: Harvard Case Study approach or NAS Alternative Agriculture

Study (potential collaborator) Case study has risk of outdated information. Anecdotal information timeframe

may be limited to result in firm results A lot of farmers are turned off by extension Farmers don’t want a one-stop shop

– Where is the balance between scientific and experiential information? From POV of evaluation its important to track the I don’t knows. Extension’s reputation: are they willing to stand behind what is put on the

website? Research extension system was developed as a risk management tool

Vision Team Work Session 2

The Vision Team discussed and refined the ideas expressed by the full group regarding eOrganic’s concept, value, and relationship to other information providers.

eOrganic as the search engine that produces results as links to other websites– Acknowledgment of source site and authors– What is useful:

Quick links, Quick access to information Lots of different access points to content Producers are looking to see what others have tried

– If it’s not just the link it becomes more complicated Case-by-case licensing agreement Once you take it off the home site, it becomes orphan content

– Overlap is helpful because there is wider distribution of the information.

Creating a cultural shift within Extension: We need to change the paradigm to encourage faculty to utilize the experiential information and push the envelope on the validity of this information. – Tell the extension agent stories, the researcher stories, in addition to farmers’

stories. – Use the Case Study method also with researchers and extension faculty. – Peer-to-Peer forums “virtural coffee shop” (agent-to-agent, farmer-to-farmer,

8

Page 9: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

researcher-to-researcher, and cross-sectional). How much time does it take to moderate interactive content?

– Create a safe environment for discussions to happen.– Partner with Journal of Extension– County extension agents tell their stories through video.

Complementary relationships among information providers

eOrganic Partner OrganizationWould decide what information to access from OAI and publish on eOrganicCoP would also be responsible to submit material to OAI with material. eOrganic provides peer review process for OAI.

OAI-provides the grey area informationOAI provides infrastructure for repository of informationWell categorized archive information. OAI works with farmers to get their information submitted

Can link to articles.Provides more exposureProvide forums for extension agents

New FarmMechanism for reprint permissionReach a broader audienceMore exposure=more effectiveness=more fundingJournalistic backgroundProvide forums for farmers

Take farmer research information SARE has reports that can help with fundingVideos of american farmer experienceOffers scholarships to eXtension

eOrganic will disseminate information and validate ATTRA. Maybe eOrganic could be 4th entity of USDA funded site

ATTRACredentialization of eOrganic. Many people do not value the information. Seeking the association with eXtension.

The Troutdale Manifesto: A Consortium of Organic Information Providers– Organize community of organic websites more formally.

Establish an MOU between entities or an umbrella organization Honor the fact in the culture and visually that this is a collaborative effort Would make sense to have all sites (OAI and eOrganic newly included) be a

part of the USDA funded sites.

9

Page 10: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

– Is there a way to fund a consortium? Collaborate rather than compete for funding, be supportive of each other We need a clear division of labor Commodity check off: choose to put them in organic.

– Benefits Consortium would be able to impact the policy makers in DC. Working together there is a lot of synergy. Information becomes more robust

because there are broader sources of input.

Ongoing Communication– Can information gatherers come together regularly? Quarterly?

Discuss who’s asking what questions Identify where information is coming from

– How do we communicate after this meeting? Using the wiki tool Team leaders meeting Leadership needs to provide clear direction and focus. USDA websites touch base on a monthly basis. Cross-fertilization.

David G’s proposed tagline: g-Oogling for Organic

10

Page 11: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 28TH

Funding: Who can we approach?

Carri Munn and Alex Stone explained the current state of eXtension’s funding model. Carri facilitated a brainstorming session to identify potential funders and eOrganic CoP members with connections to the prospects.

Notes on eXtension’s role:– eXtension’s governing committee is developing policy for sponsorship that should

address use of logos on the website.– As eOrganic fundraises, need to keep Betty Johnson, eXtension development

director, in the loop. She is coordinating efforts to work with the institutions and will be soliticing funds for multiple CoPs.

– eXtension receives a 25% share of all funds raised to support site maintenance and future development.

Who will support eOrganic? (Short-term and long-term funding. Default ask amount, if not specified, is $10,000)

Prospective Funder Amount Contact for AskGeneral Mills $10K David G., Jim R.Departments of Agriculture -Donate time/Partner on Grants (Minn&Mich)Stonyfield $10K HeatherSafeway Hy-VeeWhole Foods $10K Amy’s Organic $10K AlexOrganic Trade Association $10K Jim R.Tom’s of Maine Dr. Bronners $5K HarrietNational Organic Program $5K HarrietHorizon $10K Jim R.Hood $10k HeatherBen and Jerry’s $10k HeatherKellogg Kellogg Foundation Nancy CreamerBullet Foundation (Seattle) Jim R., Brian?Clarence E. Heller (Partnership with OFRF)(SF)Lowe’s eXtensionTarget eXtensionNewman’s Own $10K Jim R.Honest Tea Leslie

11

Page 12: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

SARE DeborahJohn Deere DeborahDow eXtensionCertifiers: QAI $50-100(k?)Oregon Tilth AlexGerber eXtensionSilk soy milk Haine Celestial AlexHeinz Mars/Seeds of Change JoelWalden Family Foundation (may need to find a K-12 education hook, DERT Program)

Michelle

Walmart Corporate Funding Farm Aid (will probably need to go to an organization(nonprofit?))

Mark

SARE training funds that go to LGUs-

Deborah and Geoff

Regionalized IPM centers, (Regional Grants)

Geoff (Southern Regional Center)

EPA (Pesticide Reduction Program, Regional Grants)NFIPME Pesticide Environmental Steward (Grants)

$25-30K limit

Risk Management Agency DeborahFederal State Marketing Improvement Program (Grant)Consumers Union BrianSierra Club Shore Bank Nature ConservancyWorld Wildlife FundWorking AssetsCo-Op AmericaOrganic Farm Supply StoresPeaceful ValleySmith and HawkinBEJOGaiamSeed SuppliersHollywood Money (e.g. Meryl Streep, Susan Sarandon)Gates FoundationAllen FoundationMoore Foundation

12

Page 13: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

Heinz FoundationWallace Genetic FundRodale Inc. DanPew Charitable TrustNW Area FoundationLottery FundsPrince CharlesBransonPaul McCartney (Michelle)Lyle LovettDave MatthewsFord Foundation Kevin Kline Alex’s BrotherFrontier GrillSlow Food InternationalDairy Processors (Strauss, Humboldtz)Organic Valley (Challenge Grant) Jim Pierce

Fundraising Committee– Jim Riddle– Jim Pierce– Alex Stone– Heather Darby– Deborah Cavanaugh-Grant– Harriet Behar

Marketing eOrganic

Alex Stone led a brainstorm on how best to market the site when it goes live.

Have website available at trade association shows and other venues

Have CoP give presentation on eOrganic all around the country – Propose to conferences as a workshop session – There is some money budgeted for booths and conferences in OREI– Professional Society and conference meetings should also be tapped. – Identify a speaker’s list/bureau among the CoP and find out what the other areas

of expertise are so they can present eOrganic. – Team approach can help stimulate interest at these events.

Have a public launch celebration to announce it in November (or after) – Should have an event in each region for launch. – Start planning this soon

13

Page 14: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

Have one extension contact in each state who is interested in technology– Have an annual meeting. – If there is a liaison they can help spread the word. (In Florida, this is funded, so it

wouldn’t have to be budgeted.)

Promotional opportunities through extension offices.

eXtension’s role in Promotion– There are more marketing people available to help us with this process. – eXtension will be presented at some conferences--coordinate

Evaluation Plan

Powerpoint presentation of OREI proposal’s evaluation component by Mary Staben, Oregon State University.

Vision Team Work Session 3

The Vision Team discussed how to prioritize future content development following DERT, VERT, and CERT.

Goal: Target content development in areas where eOrganic can provide unique information and add to the conversation

Soils: eOrganic can be the soil info hub for the whole LGU system. – Soil is unique. Even conventional farmers don’t think LGU has a handle on this.

Create both new material, and find the links to existing info and material from LGUs.

Gather grey publications and convene people. There is no existing information on nitrogen in organic systems in practitioner

language. Soil data is not there. – Biology related to function is where there can be a lot of value added.

Rodale and Lampton have trials related to this. – There is a lot of information on physical and chemical properties—good place to

start with low hanging fruit – Soil content area will take several years to develop– Michelle Wander has expertise in this area

Transitioning to organic: TERT– Intro should include paradigm shift and what you have think about. – VERT is shaping their site on transitions.– Would be interesting to have information organized by Farm type (fruit, mixed,

dairy).– Includes basic information on marketing and rotations

14

Page 15: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

– Include processing? Could also be embedded in certification and other areas

– Rotations is a priority because it lends itself to regionality. Would be nice to show an interested farmer what works. Two primary audiences need to be approached differently: For the landowner respond to philosophical and economic issues For the operator address how to make organic happen.

– Counterpoint is that transition is market driven. Smart growers will first ask what the market wants, then grow it.

Marketing: identify organic market information and direct users to sources that will help them prioritize crop plantings and connect to local food distribution networks – LGUs are bad at marketing – information is propriety– eOrganic will not actively participate in business planning, but make the

information available. – Need to have a disclaimer that there are brokers that will take advantage of

people.

How does eOrganic get information for new topics?– Agenda Item for annual Leadership Team meeting– eOrganic FAQs: analyze failed searches to determine what information people

need and are not finding– Talk to Consortium members– Poll LGU faculty and extension agents for topics and common questions

How to Create an FAQ in the eXtension wiki

Powerpoint presentation by Carla Craycroft, eXtension.

VISION Team Presentation and Meeting Summary

Powerpoint presentation by David Granastein of Washington State University, and Carmen Fernholz of OFARM, on the work of the Vision Team. Content included mission statement, vision statement, guiding principles, establishing a consortium of organic information providers, eOrganic’s primary target audiences, seven content development priorities, and process for defining future content development priorities.

Comments on Mission, Vision, Values– Need to incorporate “tools to meet regulatory compliance” within the visioning

and values documents. eOrganic gives “compliant” information.

Comments on Consortium– Gaining legitimacy: “Legitimacy by Association”– Collaborative funding opportunities:

15

Page 16: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

Develop a business plan for Consortium and eOrganic. Sustainability needs to be considered; cost-recovery strategy eXtension calls for a fundraising strategy. Determine annual eOrganic maintenance costs

Comments on Target Audiences– Proposed Change: Bullet 1: “when speaking with their producer clients” to “when

communicating to diverse clients”– As we develop it will be important to track audience of website through

evaluation. Need to understand who they are to meet their needs Need to find out if the site is successful in directing people who were

searching for information that we don’t have. – Driving force behind the Organic market are people interested in the process.

Would be nice for Farmers interested in “learning about” or transitioning and Organic gardeners to be able to go eOrganic as a resource. What do we do?

Be friendly to Gardeners, but be mindful of our main target audience, and explain that site is geared to production and agriculture. Even though focus is not gardening, they can still find relevant information.

Establish a liaisonship between Horticulture CoP and eOrganic CoP. Encourage the development of an Organic Gardening CoP that is not us.

Comments on Content Development Priorities– Suggested content development priority: identify grey content and translate for

use by eOrganic primary audiences– Leadership team needs to create a Policy Committee to address urgent needs of

CERT, VERT, DERT teams. Acknowledgment and contribution Peer-review for each article

DERT Suggestion: Team of 3 (extension, producer, other; 2/3 will be available to read document)

Linking to Commercial Entities (suppliers) How to bring new partners in?

– Joel has non-proprietary research (photos too)– Need to consider ways in which eOrganic’s information will be used beyond

standard extension model. – Fundamentals content can initially address soils, pest management, transition

etc. – Organize content based on how people search

Crop specific, animal specific By general issues that are relevant to all

eXtension’s role – There has been talk of an online donation function. A decision will be made by

the governing committee.

16

Page 17: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

– How does eOrganic work with other CoPs so that the layout meets the users’ needs in a consistent and reliable manner of information delivery? eXtension will help target information to user groups and assist with

formatting. Information architect is contracted out from eXtension

– The FAQ systems tracks searches and can generate a report on all searches, successful and failed.

CERT Presentation

Presented orally by Jim Riddle. Session notes to be posted on Sharepoint.

Top three realistic development priorities for eOrganic’s launch: – General info about certification process: record keeping, developing cert plan,

proceedures, etc. Kathleen D. is the lead author. – Standards: NOP for dummies and also info on int’l standards, labeling, and

approved materials info. Brian Baker will be the lead.– Compliance and Enforcement: Miles McEvoy

Key Roles:– FAQ manager: Jim Riddle

Goal: well written and solid before quick publication– Photo leader: Heather will provide proper source info, etc.

Timeline:– March 15: base content sent to area leaders (content or links)– May 1st : first draft of articles– August 1: final drafts, Copy editor review,– Sept. 1: things ready for posting

Recruiting additional members:– Lyn Cody– Mark Bradley from the National Organic Program

Communication with other teams:– FAQs: we’re focused only on certification. We do need to coordinate overall. – Lost CERT team members in DERT and VERT (Nick and Harriet) are liaisons to

help with this process.

DERT Presentation

Presented orally by Heather Darby. Complete session notes to be posted on Sharepoint.

DERT Leadership Team: – Harriet & Jim Pierce certification and intro to Organic dairy

17

Page 18: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

– Heather Darby & Lisa McCrory- dairy cropping systems– Ann Wells - livestock– Geoff Bensen – marketing & economics– Mike Gamroth- other

Responsibilities: – Develop & contact COP for each content area– Modify, edit content area outline– Assingn developers, editors, etc.– Write FAQs…

COP Recruitment List (page)– Need people in grains, soils, or cropping systems or economics in the LGU

system working in these areas as they relate to dairy– Need farmers to work with in the south– Contacting CoPs

Develop contact list- Mike Letter/email to solicit participation requesting level of involvement Deadlines for mailing and responses

3 Tiered Information Format for Fundamentals of Organic Dairy: for use in all areas; includes a logo based tagging system (e.g. worms or leaves to identify levels one, two and three) (page)– Fundamentals: intro/overview level practical information– Anecdotal: user-friendly

Farmer testimony (case studies, what works and what didn’t) How To articles: cert General info: what is Organic dairy, what is a dairy farming system

– Science Based: complex information and resources Best Management Practices- preventative, 3 tier approach Research reports Learning modules (future)

Immediate content for launch– Fundamentals:

milk quality feeding & nutrition grazing

– Anecdotal Intro dairy farming systems What is o dairy Easy-access certification material

18

Page 19: HEADING 1 - eorganic.info€¦  · Web viewCombined Session Notes from EOrganic Visioning. February 26-28, 2007. Monday, February 26th. Introduction to eXtension. Powerpoint Presentation

Review Policy– All information reviewed by at least 3 reviewers, considering different types of

reviewers (producers, LGU, other, Cert, Extension)– Create checklist

Funding Year 1-3: raise money right away– $32k admin, – $30k contracting, – $10k to travel, – $10k supplies

Timeline– March 1-15: draft COP letter, send, expect response, fundraising– March 31st: develop content template and review process– April: collect content– May-July: review, edit– Sept-Nov: work with extension to launch site.

VERT Presentation

Presented electronically by Michelle Wander and Mary Barbercheck. Complete session notes to be posted on Sharepoint.

Additional Comments– Let VERT team know if you have contacts for them to add to the community of

practice/content– VERT would like to have the 3-tiered info model described by DERT

Issues to be worked out across teams– Work flow– Meta-data– Logic about the organization of the site – Policy on posting of sources into the Sharepoint so people can easily see what

content is there and not duplicate submissions for initial review.– All teams agreed that policies will be in a policy folder so that groups share

editorial policies and content templates.

Next Steps

Powerpoint presentation by Alex Stone and wiki/sharepoint details by Lane Selman.

Wiki/sharepoint training– Get accounts for all CoP members now (Lane will submit to Raj)– Lane will send all participants an info packet– Leadership team will make a decision about location of listserv functionality

eXtension can support this

19