hamilton v scott

8/11/2019 Hamilton v Scott

1/25

!!""!#$

$!

&'()*(+ ,-./012 31451-66057 .82109::;4?9;+ /@0. A4-6/ 629BB06C. /@9/ /@2 :0D2. 4B -5E465

1@0:?625 962 864/21/2? E; ':9E9C9F. G6457B-:H?29/@ ./9/-/2+

62796?:2.. 4B D09E0:0/;= I G60/2 .28969/2:; /4 2J8:905 G@; /@2

K-862C2 A4-6/F. ?210.045 05 (42 D= L9?2+ M!" N=K= !!O 3!#PO


2/25

!!""!#$

$$

0/. D09E0:0/; ./95?96? 0. 54/ 826.-9.0D2+ I 1451:-?2 /@9/+ 9/

:29./ G0/@ 62796? /4 /@2 :9G 4B G6457B-: ?29/@+ (42F. D09E0:0/;

./95?96? .@4-:? E2 -50D26.9::; 9E95?452?=

I= >@2 -5126/905 ./9/-. 4B /@2 D09E0:0/; ./95?96? 05 /46/ 95?

160C059: :9G .0512 (42=

K0512 !#PO+ G@25 (42 G9. ?210?2?+ :9G. 62796?057 86259/9:

05S-6;+ G6457B-: ?29/@+ 95? B2/9: @4C010?2 @9D2 051629.057:;

9E95?452? /@2 D09E0:0/; ./95?96? 2J862..2? 05 (42= I5

86259/9:H05S-6; :9G+ T2D26; S-60.?01/045 826C0/. 6214D26; B46

86259/9: 05S-602. 0B 9 1@0:? 0. E465 9:0D2= === >@0. 725269::;

@4:?. /6-2 62796?:2.. G@2/@26 /@2 05S-6; 411-662? 20/@26 E2B462

46 9B/26 /@2 8405/ 4B D09E0:0/;= === >@2 C9S460/; 4B

S-60.?01/045. 9:.4 6214750Q2 9 19-.2 4B 91/045 B46 /@2 G6457B-:

?29/@ 4B 9 ./0::E465+ D09E:2 B2/-.=T A64.E; D= U:9..141V

>6-1V057 A4=+ OM" K=A= W$W+ WOM+ XO$ K=*=$? YXW+ YW" 3$"""49:+ ,=+ ?0..25/057< 3B44/54/2. 4C0//2?< 310/057 Z96:2; D=

K96/05+ !#X L=[9= WP!+ MWW K=*=$? X$$ 3!##X


3/25

!!""!#$

$O

354/057 /@9/ O$ S-60.?01/045. 826C0//2? /@2 6214D26; 4B ?9C972.

B46 /@2 G6457B-: ?29/@ 4B 9 D09E:2 -5E465 1@0:?


4/25

!!""!#$

$M

>@2 C4./ .0750B0195/ .@0B/ 9G9; B64C /@2 D09E0:0/;

./95?96?+ @4G2D26+ @9. E225 05 /@2 :9G 4B B2/9: @4C010?2= '/

:29./ OY ./9/2. @9D2 2591/2? B2/9:H@4C010?2 ./9/-/2.+ 95? $Y 4B

/@4.2 ./9/-/2. 864/21/ :0B2 B64C 145128/045= K22 K/9/2 D=

[email protected]+ $#W A455= W$$+ WY# 5= MW+ ##Y '=$? !+ X" 5=MW 3$"!"@-.+ -5:2.. 9 ./9/2F.

:9G 145B:01/. G0/@ 9 G4C95F. T607@/T /4 95 9E46/045+ /@2 ./9/2

:9G ?42. 54/ 145B:01/ G0/@ (42= K22 9:.4 U45Q9:2. D= A96@96/+

XX" N=K= !$M+ !XY 3$""P< 354/057 /@9/ T/@2 K/9/2+ B64C /@2

05128/045 4B /@2 86275951;+T @9. 95 05/262./ T05 864/21/057 /@2

:0B2T 4B /@2 -5E465 1@0:?


11/25

!!""!#$

O!

2J8:9052? /@0. ?0./051/045 05 @0. ?0..25/ 05 U25/6; D= U0:C462+

W!O K4= $? !$M!+ !$MP 3':9= !##O


12/25

!!""!#$

O$

?2./6-1/045= I 1451:-?2 /@9/ /@2 :270.:9/-62 @9. 9607@/ /4 864/21/ 545D09E:2 B2/9: :0B2 G@25 0/.05/262./ 0. 14576-25/ G0/@ /@9/ 4B /@2 C4/@26=T

K1@4:96. @9D2 9:.4 6214750Q2? /@2 :0C0/9/045. 4B (42=!M Z46

/@2.2 629.45.+ (42 0. 54/ 145/64::057 9-/@460/; 05 /@0. 19.2=

III= (42F. D09E0:0/; ./95?96? 0. 54/ 826.-9.0D2=

_-C264-. .1@4:96. @9D2 160/010Q2? /@2 D09E0:0/; 6-:2 4B

(42=!X >4?9;+ T/@262 0. E649? 919?2C01 97622C25/ /@9/ (42

!MK22+ 2=7=+ A:96V2 \= Z46.;/@2+ ]4C010?2 4B /@2 N5E465 A@0:?j>@2 R465 ':0D2 (-:2 95? b/@26 a279: '[email protected].+ $! [9:= N= a=(2D= XWO+ W!M 3!#YP< 3Tc(42d ?42. 54/ 988:; /4 /@2 145/2J/ 4B545145.25.-9: /@06? 896/; 91/. 97905./ /@2 -5E465 1@0:?=T@2 ?210.045 05 (42 ?42. 54/ 8621:-?2 /@2 ./9/2B64C 864/21/057 862D09E:2 B2/9: :0B2 G@25 .-1@ 864/21/045 0.629.459E:2 95? 05B60572. -845 54 B-5?9C25/9: 46 4/@26 B2?269:46 ./9/2 607@/ ====T@2 a9G 4B >46/04-.

&6259/9: \29/@ K0512 (42 D= L9?2+ MX 4= a= (2D= WO#+ WXP 3!#Y"60C2./26 Z69C2G46V+ X! 'C= ,= a279: ]0./= X"X+ X!WH$W 3$"!!


13/25

!!""!#$

OO

B90:2? /4 864D0?2 95 9?2f-9/2 2J8:959/045 B46 /@2 D09E0:0/;

6-:2=T (95?; R21V+ U45Q9:2.+ A9.2;+ 95? /@2 [09E0:0/; (-:2+ !"O

_G= N= a= (2D= $M#+ $WYHW# 3$""#


14/25

!!""!#$

OM

1962B-: 2J9C059/045 2D25 G@25 (42 G9. G60//25=T ,4.28@

\2::982559+ \0.82::057 /@2 `;/@. 4B 'E46/045 ]0./46; !$W

3A964:059 '19?2C01 &62.. $""W


15/25

!!""!#$

OX

)9?96 54/2? 05 !#Y"+ T(07@/. 95? 864/21/045. :279::; 9BB46?2?

/@2 -5E465 1@0:? 962 4B 951025/ D05/972= I5 2f-0/;+ 864826/;+

160C2+ 95? /46/+ /@2 -5E465 @9. 62120D2? 95? 145/05-2. /4 62120D2

9 :279: 826.459:0/;=T \9D0? )9?96+ >@2 a9G 4B >46/04-. &6259/9:

\29/@ K0512 (42 D= L9?2+ MX 4= a= (2D= WO#+ WO# 3!#Y"< 3B44/54/2.

4C0//2?@2 A4-6/F. ?0.1-..045 05

(42 4B 86259/9:H?29/@ 6214D26; TG9. 826B-51/46;+ 95?

-5B46/-59/2:; :9672:; 05911-69/2+ 95? .@4-:? 54/ E2 62:02? -845

9. /@2 146621/ D02G 4B /@2 :9G 9/ /@2 /0C2 4B (42 D= L9?2=T MX

`4= a= (2D= 9/ WX$HXO= K22 9:.4 L0::09C (= ]48V05+ ,6=+ (42 D=

9E46/045 -5?26 /@2 14CC45 :9G G9. G2:: 2./9E:0.@2?=A4-6/. @9? 625?262? 1:296 @4:?057. /@9/ 9E46/045 G9.9 160C2+ 54 ?210.045 05?019/2? /@9/ 95; B46C 4B9E46/045 G9. :9GB-:+ 95? .2145?96; 9-/@460/02..0C0:96:; -50B46C:; .-8846/2? /@2 160C059:0/; 4B

9E46/045= >@2 45:; ?0BB262512 9C457 /@2.29-/@460/02. @9? E225 /@2 .2D260/; 4B /@2 160C23C0.?2C29546 46 B2:45;


16/25

!!""!#$

OW

L9?2 95? /@2 >69?0/0459: a279: K/95?96?. A451265057 &6275951;+

MP >2C8= a=n= P!X+ P$O 3!#PM< 3TcId/ C-./ 62.821/B-::; E2 8405/2?

4-/ /@9/ ,-./012 R:91VC-5 @9. -5?26./9/2? /@2 2J/25/ /4 G@01@

/@2 :9G 864/21/. /@2 -5E465 1@0:?=T


17/25

!!""!#$

OP

0C8:02? /@9/ .-1@ 9 19-.2 4B 91/045 G4-:? E2 6214750Q2? 45:; 0B

/@2 -5E465 1@0:? @9? 6291@2? D09E0:0/;= WX Z= K-88= 9/ !M"=

[09E0:0/; G9. 050/09::; 9?48/2? E; 14-6/. 05

86259/9:H05S-6; :9G+ E-/ 0/. 05B:-2512 G9. G95057 E; !#W!= K22

\9:2; D= `2026+ OO I::= '88= $? $!Y+ !PY _=*=$? W#! 3!#W!@2 A4-6/F. 62.845.2 @262 0. .0C8:; 54/ 9?2f-9/2= I/97622.+ 05?22? 0/ @4:?.+ /@9/ 9B/26 /@2 8405/ 4BD09E0:0/; 39 145128/ 0/ B90:. /4 54/2 G0:: E214C2 2D25:2.. 1:296 /@95 0/ 0. 54G 9. /@2 /21@54:47; 4B E06/@145/05-2. /4 ?2D2:48< /@2 05/262./ 05 864/21/057 /@2B2/-. 0. 14C82::057= *J91/:; G@; /@9/ 0. /@2 C9701C4C25/ 0. 54/ C9?2 1:296j [09E0:0/;+ 9. /@2 A4-6/?2B052. 0/+ 0. 91@02D2? .4C2 .0J /4 /G2:D2 G22V. 9B/26f-01V25057= 3n-01V25057 0. /@2 8405/ 9/ G@01@ /@2B2/-. E2705. ?0.12650E:; /4 C4D2 05?2825?25/:; 4B /@2C4/@26 95? /@2 8405/ /@9/ @9. @0./46019::; E225 ?22C2?16-109: HH /4 /@2 2J/25/ 95; 8405/ E2/G225 145128/04595? E06/@ @9. E225 B41-.2? 45=< R-/ 54+ 0/ 0.D09E0:0/; /@9/ 0. 145./0/-/0459::; 160/019:j /@2


21/25

!!""!#$

M!

A4-6/F. ?2B25.2 .22C. /4 C0./9V2 9 ?2B050/045 B46 9.;::470.C=

TFL0/@ 62.821/ /4 /@2 K/9/2F. 0C846/95/ 95?:270/0C9/2 05/262./ 05 84/25/09: :0B2+ /@2F14C82::057F 8405/ 0. 9/ D09E0:0/;= >@0. 0..4 E219-.2 /@2 B2/-. /@25 862.-C9E:; @9. /@21989E0:0/; 4B C295057B-: :0B2 4-/.0?2 /@2C4/@26F. G4CE=F

TL0/@ 62796? /4 G@; /@2 ./9/2 19554/ 145.0?26 /@0.

F0C846/95/ 95? :270/0C9/2 05/262./F 86046 /4

D09E0:0/;+ /@2 4805045 0. 2D25 :2.. .9/0.B91/46;=T

,4@5 ]96/ *:;+ >@2 L972. 4B A6;057 L4:Bj ' A4CC25/ 45 (42 D= L9?2+

Y$ e9:2 a=,= #$"+ #$MH$X 3!#PO< 3f-4/057 (42+ M!" N=K= 9/ !WO269/4:47; Y 3$? 2?= !##W

hamilton v scott

Documents