8/9/2019 Guillang vs de Silva

1/3

ALHAMBRA, RAYMOND PATRICK P.

SOFIA M. GUILLANG, represented by SUSAN GUILLANG CABATBAT,R!YNALDO, G!RARDO, BI!N"!NIDO, DA#NA, $nd N!LLI!, $%% s&rn$'edGUILLANG, G!NARO GUILLANG, (OS! DIGNADIC!, $nd AL"IN LLANILLO ).

RODOLFO B!DANIA AND RODOLFO D! SIL"AG.R. N*. + - /0, M$y -+, -11

CARPIO, (.2

3&$s4 de%45t2. Art45%e -+0 *6 t7e C4)4% C*de pr*)4des t7$t 87*e)er by $5t *r*'4ss4*n 5$&ses d$'$9e t* $n*t7er, t7ere be4n9 6$&%t *r ne9%49en5e, 4s*b%49ed t* p$y 6*r t7e d$'$9e d*ne. S&57 6$&%t *r ne9%49en5e, 46 t7ere 4s n*pre e:4st4n9 5*ntr$5t&$% re%$t4*ns bet8een t7e p$rt4es 4s 5$%%ed $ quasi-delict.

e:e'p%$ry d$'$9es2 4n 3&$s4 de%45ts, e:e'p%$ry d$'$9es '$y be 9r$nted 46 t7e de6end$nt $5ted 84t7 9r*ss ne9%49en5e.

pr*:4'$te 5$&se2 pr*:4'$te 5$&se 4s t7$t 87457, 4n t7e n$t&r$% $nd5*nt4n&*&s se3&en5e, &nbr*;en by $ny e

On -? O5t*ber + @, $t $b*&t ?>@? 4n t7e $6tern**n, Gen$r* M. G&4%%$n9

8$s dr4)4n9 74s br$nd ne8 T*y*t$ C*r*%%$ GLI sed$n $%*n9 !'4%4* A9&4n$%d*H4978$y 4n C$)4te. Anter*, Fe%4pe, D49n$d45e, $nd L%$n4%%* 7$d $%% =&st %e6t6r*' G*%den C4ty, D$s'$r4 $s, C$)4te, $nd 8ere *n t7e4r 8$y t* M$n4%$. Att7e *t7er s4de *6 t7e 74978$y, resp*ndent Bed$n4$ 8$s dr4)4n9 $ ten 87ee%erIs& & 5$r9* tr&5; t*8$rds T$9$yt$y C4ty , t7e tr&5; 8$s *8ned by resp*ndentR*d*%6* de S4%)$. A%*n9 t7e 74978$y $nd t7e r*$d %e$d4n9 t* t7e Or57$rd G*%6 C*&rse, Bed$n4$ ne9*t4$ted $ U t&rn, 87en t7e tr&5; entered 4nt* t7e*pp*s4te %$ne *6 t7e 74978$y, Gen$r* s 5$r 74t t7e r497t p*rt4*n *6 t7e tr&5;.

T7e tr&5; dr$99ed Gen$r* s 5$r s*'e )e 'eters t* t7e r497t *6 t7e r*$d.

A%% t7e p$ssen9ers *6 t7e 5$r 8ere r&s7ed t* De L$ S$%%e Un4)ers4ty Med45$%

Center 4n D$s'$r4 $s, C$)4te 6*r tre$t'ent, $s t7e 5*nse3&en5e *6 t7e5*%%4s4*n. Anter*, $'*n9 *t7ers re5e4)ed se)ere 4n=&r4es, $nd %$ter *n d4edd&e t* t7*se 4n=&r4es.

Gen$r*, L%$n4%%*, D49n$d45e, $nd t7e 7e4rs *6 Anter* 4nst4t&ted $ 5*'p%$4nt 6*rd$'$9es b$sed *n 3&$s4 de%45t $9$4nst resp*ndent Bed$n4$ $nd de S4%)$ *nApr4% -@, + ?.

8/9/2019 Guillang vs de Silva

2/3

T7e tr4$% 5*&rt 6*&nd Bed$n4$ 9r*ss%y ne9%49ent 6*r re5;%ess%y '$ne&)er4n9t7e tr&5; by '$;4n9 $ s&dden U t&rn 4n t7e 74978$y 84t7*&t d&e re9$rd t*tr$

D*se t7e Appe%%$te 5*&rt erred 4n d4s'4ss4n9 t7e 5$seE

#$s t7ere 9r*ss ne9%49en5e *n t7e p$rt *6 Bed$n4$ *n '$;4n9 $ U t&rn 4n t7e74978$y 84t7*&t d&e re9$rd t* tr$

8/9/2019 Guillang vs de Silva

3/3

F&rt7er'*re, U t&rns $re 9ener$%%y n*t $d)4s$b%e p$rt45&%$r%y *n '$=*rstreets 4t 4s n*t n*r'$% 6*r $ tr&5; t* '$;e $ U t&rn *n $ 74978$y. 7e s7*&%dsee; $n 4nterse5t4*n 87ere 4t 4s s$6er t* '$ne&)er t7e tr&5;. Bed$n4$ s7*&%d7$)e $%s* t&rned *n 74s s49n$% %497ts $nd '$de s&re t7$t t7e 74978$y 8$s5%e$r *6 )e745%es 6r*' t7e *pp*s4te d4re5t4*n be6*re e:e5&t4n9 t7e U t&rn.

Under Art45%e -+/? *6 t7e C4)4% C*de, &n%ess t7ere 4s pr**6 t* t7e 5*ntr$ry, $pers*n dr4)4n9 $ )e745%e 4s pres&'ed ne9%49ent 46 $t t7e t4'e *6 t7e '4s7$p,7e 8$s )4*%$t4n9 $ny tr$