7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 1/26

Copyright © FPL and SEL 2015

Breaker Pole Scatter

and Its Effect on !adrilateral"ro!nd #istance Protection

James Ryan,Florida Power & Light Company 

 Arun Shrestha and Thanh-Xuan Nguyen,Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories, Inc.

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 2/26

$!tline

• Breaker pole scatter 

• Zone 1 challenges hen protect!ng

short l!nes

• "uadr!lateral d!stance element

• #ase study

• Solut!on and test results

• #onclus!on

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 3/26

Fa!lt Clearing %i&e

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 4/26

'or&al Breaker Pole Scatter 

B# $ault current!nterrupt!on

Normal load current

!nterrupt!on

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 5/26

(igh Breaker Pole Scatter 

%elayed &hase #current !nterrupt!on

'rare(

 AB $ault current

!nterrupt!on

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 6/26

Factors )ffecting Breaker Pole Scatter 

• Breaker operat!ng mechan!sm

• %!electr!c strength o$ arc !nterrupters

•)*ternal c!rcu!t parameters dur!ng $ault

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 7/26

Protection of Short Lines

• +ault res!stance can e s!gn!$!cantly h!gherthan l!ne !mpedance

• ho ground d!stance elements ha.e

l!m!ted $ault res!stance co.erage

• "uadr!lateral ground d!stance elements

are pre$erred

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 8/26

Fa!lt on Short %rans&ission Line

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 9/26

!adrilateral "ro!nd #istance Ele&ent

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 10/26

Factors %hat *ay )ffect !adrilateral

"ro!nd #istance Ele&ent

• /pen-pole cond!t!ons

• Breaker pole scatter 

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 11/26

Case St!dy

• Study e$$ect o$ B0 pole scatter on relay at B1

• Test cases 'B0(

♦ Normal $ault current !nterrupt!on

♦ nterrupt!on delayed y 234 cycles !n one pole

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 12/26

'or&al Fa!lt Interr!ptionB!s +

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 13/26

Interr!ption #elayed ,y 0-5 Cycles

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 14/26

Interr!ption #elayed ,y 0-5 CyclesB!s +

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 15/26

Interr!ption #elayed ,y 0-5 CyclesB!s .

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 16/26

+one 1 B" /eactance and

/esistance Calc!lation

5hen +SB asserts, relay !ssues tr!p command to reakers

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 17/26

FPL Syste&

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 18/26

Sit!ation Leading to

nintended $peration

• 6!gh reaker pole scatter o$

234 cycles 'rare(

• Strong sources at oth ends'SR 7 132(

• 8ery short l!nes

• 9arge res!st!.e co.erage $or :uadr!lateralground d!stance elements

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 19/26

FPL nintended $peration

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 20/26

+one 1 B" /eactance and

/esistance Calc!lation

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 21/26

Proposed Sol!tion

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 22/26

C$*%/)#E Play,ack %est

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 23/26

/%#S   %est /e&ote Fa!lt

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 24/26

/%#S %est +one 1 Fa!lt

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 25/26

Concl!sion

• 6!gh reaker pole scatter may occur asreakers ear and age

• Zone 0 element super.!s!on adds secur!ty

to :uadr!lateral d!stance elements dur!ngpole-scatter operat!ng cond!t!ons !thout

sacr!$!c!ng dependa!l!ty

7/23/2019 Ground Distance Protection

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ground-distance-protection 26/26

!estions3