grips ms10 public sector innovation

8/13/2019 GRIPS MS10 Public Sector Innovation

1/51

Global Review of Innovation Intelligence and

Policy Studies

Mini Study 10

Innovation in the public sector

(Hugo Thenint, LL&A)

February 2010


2/51

Contents

..................................................................................................................... 3

1. ................................................ 5

1.1 T ......................................... 5

1.2 T ........................................................................................... 8

1.3 M ............................................................................... 10

1.4 A ........................................................................ 14

2. ................................................... 18

2.1 E ........................................................................................................................... 18

2.2 I ......................................................................................... 202.3 P ...................................................... 23

2.4 N ....................................................................... 27

3. ................................................................................................................ 30

3.1 T C T (UK), ............................................ 30

3.2 T L 27 R ................................................................................. 32

3.3 K B F A B B ................................................................ 34

4. ................................... 36

4.1 S ........................................................................................................................... 364.2 E E ....................................................................................................... 38

4.3 S EU ...................................................................................................... 41

...................................................................................................................... 45

.......................................................................................................... 48

T , , ,

. T E C.

T E C ,

, . T

.


3/51

3

Introduction

E ,

. P

, .

P E

. E' 40% 55% GDP 32%

U S, 26% J, 16% C 17% I. P

EU ,

( ) 15% EU.

P , ,

, ,

. H, E

, . W

, , ,

EU .

S

. A GDP

,

. M

. H, (

, ) . A ,

,

.

C , (

) , EU

E .

F, . T

. T ( ). I

( ),

( ).

T .

I , ( )

. T , , (

, , , ). T

, ;

, . T

, (.. )


4/51

4

. I , ,

.

T ? W

, . (S , ,

!) V

:

( ) (P D20, 2005)

B . W

(, , .),

:

D .. , ( ), (G, H &

M, 2002).

S , ,

,

(A & M, 2003)

T . F,

(,

). I

/ / . (T

, .) I ,

( )

. R (

). H, ;

,

I U .


5/51

5

1. Grasping the specifics of innovation in the public sector

T, . B

? R,

.

1.1 The main differences between public and private sector innovations

F,

( ). E

;

. T

.

G

(, , .). O

. A,

,

. I

.

I , ( )

. N,

. W

.

R (, , .)

. I ,

.

A , .

P ( )

. B

. N

(M, 2001).

T . E

. H,


6/51

6

, , ,

1.

T . A

,

. I ,

. I

, .

H,

. E ( , ,

.) . A ,

, . Q ,

,

.

I . I ,

,

. N

,

( ). S

.

O . I

( )

( ) . I

. T

( )

.

1S

( ) .


7/51

7

T 1: M

/

C I

P

P

S

M ()

P

P

/

M (, , ) C

S

P

P

J (

)

I

/

T ,

I

P (

)

M

P

/

P

P (

)

P

M

G ( )

P

( & , 2005)

A

. C,

,

. H,

;

,

( 2.3).

T

. T

.

B ,

. C

, , , NGO,

(, , , ICT

, .).


8/51

8

1.2 Typology of public sector innovations

T ,

( )

, (O M,

C I S). H,

( ) . H

( )

.

I , :

A ( )

P ( )

A ( ,

)

S ( ,

)

C ( ;

, )

R (

)

T . T

:

I / ( ,

, )

T / (

,

, ,

)

N (

,

)

(T PUBLIN D9 , T H,

J H, I M R R, 2005, O STEP) : ://..//.

I ,

( , , .)

. T

; () .


9/51

9

S B (2001 & 2006), USA C

( 300 )

:

S

T

/ . I

, . T

:

, ( ,

, .), ,

( / ).

T T , ICT,

. S

, & , . I

.

P

T

, , / . P

. I ,

.

E ,

E . T

,

/ . P

. E ()

.

U

T ( )

NGO , PPP,

, .

N

E .


10/51

10

1.3 Main innovation trends in the public sector

A

A , ,

. T ,

E (UK, F, G, .). P

. H,

(R 1981, M 1984, E

A 1987, .).

D , , E US,

. T

,

:

, , , ,

, . T

, . I

,

( , , .). T

; ,

E,

. T ,

.

I ,

. D

. A, OECD, 1995,

:

, , ,

, .

H, , ,

. A

/ .

I

, ,

. D

. R

, .


11/51

11

A , P V T

,

. I , (C &

P, 2008), :

W ?

T ?

H ?

D , . F,

. B

() ()

. S

(.. )

. T , , .

T ICT. I

I T. A, ICT

(D A R P A & US N S F

I; M F D

T

UK P O). H,

F

.T,

. IT . T ,

. I 20 30

30 60

(G, 2007). E

, , / / ,

, (H, 1999).

B , IT

. IT (

) ,

,

N

, . L ,

G (GC)

( ).

C , G

, ,

. A,

( IT ,


12/51

12

, .), , (

).

R,

( ), .

T ,

. A

27 R ( 3).

T

. T

,

.

T 2: D

S

C,

C

S,

E

C,

H

M (,

)

N

P P P

L, O

I

L

M ,

T

(. )

C C L &

& E

C C

H (2005)

R

. B ,

, , , , , .


13/51

13

T T (2009)

:

S ;

P , ; S , & ;

C ; ;

H , , , , ;

I ;

I ;

P ;

N ;

S : , , ;

E : , , , ,

, .

R 40 , T

( ):

1. A G. T

, ICT,

, , . C

: A, B, D, G, G, I, L,

N, P, S, S, B, C, E, H, L, L,M, R, L, N B;

2. A (

/ ). T

. C

: B, G, G, F, F, P, C R,

H, L, M, P, R, S, S, C I;

3. P : ( ,

, ). E B,

F, C, M, P R;

4. D: A

( ). E B (A),

UK, C (A), B (A), N T;

5. P / : S

. E

I, H, J, T USA;


14/51

14

6. F, /

( , , , .

). E D, N,

UK, L ( ), S, .

W (UK, D, N,

F, .) ICT ,

. S

. A

EU M S,

.

I

. I D, B I

,

(S, I G). E

G B ( E) F, . R

F

( ). I F,

R C ( )

.

A

. T

. T

,

. P

. H,

.

1.4 Attempts at measuring public sector innovation

A

.

S O

. T

,

.


15/51

15

S ,

DI / EA I2 3

D M S, T I. T

N . E,

C M

.

T ( )

.

/

E , ;

E ;

R ( ; R&D ; % ,

.);

S (% , );

O

( , , , .);

D :

(.. , ,

);

R ( , ,

& , M);

A (ICT) (, ,

.);

N ;

N , , ;

N / ;

N ;

P, , ;

M

(, , , .);

S ;

A;

O ;

2://.../

3://../


16/51

16

C ;

Q ;

C (% , %

, .);

S ( , , , .);

P ( /

).

A . T

. T

,

, . I

.

I . T

. I

;

. V ,

. A

, : ,

.

O D

E ,

, .

T :

C

(, )

( )

T

T

T , . F

S

. O S E (

) AS (

). A

, ( G C

R I A ).

P .

S

.


17/51

17

T 3: P

BE

DK

DE

GR

ES

FR

IE

IT

LU

NL

AT

PT

FI

SE

UK

CZ

HUPL

SK

2,0

2,5

3,0

3,5

4,0

4,5

5,0

5,5

6,0

6,5

7,0

3,0 3,5 4,0 4,5 5,0 5,5 6,0 6,5 7,0

trust

performance

O

UK

SE

FI

PT

ATNL

LU

IT

IE

FRES

GR

DE

DK

BE

SK

PL

HU

CZ

US

CAAU

3,0

3,5

4,0

4,5

5,0

5,5

6,0

6,5

7,0

30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65

Corrected government expenditure (% GDP)

Performance score

C

: C & D I, 2004


18/51

18

2. How to foster public sector innovation and diffusion

2.1 Existing barriers

T T 300

U.S. C . P (

), , ,

.

T 4: B

: B 2006

T P (2005) I (2006)

, .. ,

. T

UK, I N

. T :

1. . T

, ,

. A , ,

( ). T


19/51

19

( , ). A

, ,

.

2. A . T

. R ,

,

,

.

3. . I , ,

. T, ,

, . T

. H,

(.. ,

).

4. . M

, . T

. T,

.

5. . T ,

. T

, . W

, .

6. . T (

, , .)

. I ,

,

. C,

. T

, . T

.

7. . T .

T , ,

. O

,


20/51

20

( ).

8. A . T

. R : F ,

,

.

2.2 Identification of drivers and enablers

T 5: T

.

.

.

A

++ +++ ++ ++

++ +++ + +

+ + + ++

++ + ++ +

++ +++ +++ + ++

(

)

+++ ++ ++ ++ +

+++

++ + +

A ++ +

+ +++

+ +

+

+ +

: B 2006

T 5 U.S.

C . T .

T , ,

, . T ,

,

, .


21/51

21

O,

, .

H,

. R

( 1.3). A ,

.

W ,

. T

, 1980. I ,

, . B, , (M, 2007). N

. A,

.

A , ,

. B (1999)

, ,

, ,

, . M,

. S

,

, (H & M, 1991, P &

W, 2003).

I ,

. P

.

S

(A . 1996, G, 1999 & 2001). L .

L , .

L . T

.

T , , . T


22/51

22

,

, . I (M, 2007)

( ). A

,

.

T . G,

. G

()

. I

. I , NGO .

I , . A,

.

S E . A ,

, .

T , ,

( ), , (

). T

,

. S

E U4 NESTA UK, ML D 27 F

( ).

C

. F ,

NGO. L

ICT ( ).

I ,

. F ,

. S

. I

. H ,

( ) ( /

) .

4F , IGRIPS : ://.

.///880//


23/51

23

I

. T

.

Q

. R .

T

. A

.

2.3 Patterns for the development of citizen-driven innovations

P

. T , :

T ,

A ,

T

,

C ,

P .

T OECD O I

G. I

. T

. M ,

, ,

, . T

.

B . B

,

(B, 2008).

I 2000, C

. L ;

; ;

; . L

,

. A ,

.


24/51

24

,

W E ( ),

. C

. P , ,

. S

(G, 2005).

T

. T

, .

T . T .

G

. M

(

, .). O ,

. I , ,

, .

A

. T

,

. I ,

.

T . F ,

,

, . C

, , .

B . W

. P "" /

.

F ,

. A,

. A ,


25/51

25

, , (N,

2008).

T ICT

. T

:

P I,

C ,

,

C ,

I ( , , , ,

).

O . T ,

/ /

. I ,

. E

.

T W 2.0

. G 2.0

W 2.0

. T

. F ,

W 2.0 . I

, , , ,

P, C .

G,

W

E. A

, , . T

, , . A

/ ICT

, . T L L5. I

( ). T

()

ICT.

5F : ://../

://..//AMI%40WC


26/51

26

:

L L :

A A

I :

, ICT

, ICT '

(.. , )

A ICT

,

. T

, .

T

.

,

N ,

. I

. W

,

. I ,

N T UK.

A,

,

. E ( )

(P, 2005).


27/51

27

2.4 New perspectives for public-private cooperation

P (PPP)

. P

.

I , PPP . I,

( UK )

. A ,

PPP EU M S.

T 6: PPP E

A S , PPP 4% . A

, PPP ,

. I ,

. S

(H, 2008). C F UK

M

.

C ,

( ) . O

, . I


28/51

28

(),

. I

, .

A T 7, PPP

. H,

,

, , . P

, PPP

(K,

2006). N

.

T 7: S D: W

?

DAAD D , 2007

I K R OS (DEMOS, 2008)

,

. T ,

. T

, , , . F ,

, , ,

(NESTA & FORA, 2009).

T B DTI (2004)

. T

:

D ,

E ,


29/51

29

S /

,

A ,

I

,

E .

A ,

. S

.

F , ,

. S ,

, . T B P

6

:

D

H

M

I

G

H,

. D

. T , S D , S C, E, T,

P I., IDEO, ,

, , .

A D C (UK) ,

. P .

P

.

6://.../DC/1/W/O/P/


30/51

30

3. Case studies

T

/ .

3.1 The Carbon Trust (UK), public service through a private company

I 1998, C E E

. T

2001 C C L, ,

. T , ,

. T , A 2001, UK T C T

, . T T

C C P; D F, E R A (DEFRA) D B, E

R R, , S E,

W A, I N I. I ,

(FAO, 2007).

W C T , DEFRA , ,

,

(HC 157, 2008, .11). W

,

, (FAO, 2007, .5) T

() 2010 . T

,

. T T

(HC 157, 2008).

T C T UK . I

/ . I ,

, (

20,000) . M

. T T

: I,

; I, ; I,

; S, ; E,

. M , (HC 157, 2008).


31/51


32/51

32

C C T

.

V ...

, ,

.

AA C T,

. I

,

. T B D A G

,

.

AT C T L C B A

. I

C T

.

: C (2006) C . ( )

T C T

500,000 ,

36 (D, 2009). L , ,

; T C T, , ,

. I , C T

UK .

3.2 Territories in residence - La 27me Rgion

T R (T ) F 27

R

. L 27

R, ,

F R A (ARF), C D (F

), E C (EA ).

T T R , , . T

, , , , , , , , .

W , (

), , , .

D , : ,

, ,

.

S F . T

, L27

R. A ,


33/51

33

. T ,

.

&

T T R : . T . T

, . T

. T

.

T : , .

I ,

( ),

(, , )

A , . T

:

W 1: 3

W 2: ( + )

W 3: , .

S , .

E , , I F R A,

.

A

T R 15 . S ,

.

O CA ,

. T T R

? T

, , ,

: (

), ,

. L R

CA . A

, L 27 R :

.


34/51

34

A , A;

R C, ;

IT R (B).

T 27

R ,

, . T ,

(

).

H, :

(B, 2009). T

, .

3.3 Kafka Brigade - First Aid for Bureaucratic Breakdown

K B N

, .

I N, K B ,

. I ,

. T K B

. A ,

B .

T B

. T

, K B . A (

)

K B .

C

T , K B

. T

, .

P

I ,

: , , ,

. T K B

.

R ,


35/51

35

L, : . B

, ,

. T K B

, .

U

T K B ,

. T K B

, .

C :

C

. W , K B .

S 2005, K B

:

R

F

S NEET (J N E, E T)

C

I

G

C

V

R

R

R

B

D O

R

R

R

E

T K B I A7

. T

, A I

D G I H K S C

G S L U N.

7..


36/51

36

4. Exploring the rationale and possible European support actions

4.1 Scope for action

P EU

. T

E . A ,

EU :

A ( ) , ,

. , , .

, , . (COM(2007)725 F)

"G "

. T

(.. , ) S

(.. ) (..

).

I 8 , EU

EC T M S

, . T , EU ( ) .

S

(.. ).

I

(,

, , , .).

H, EU ,

. F,

EU . F ,

EU . A,

;

EU. C

EU

, , .

O , ,

O C M, .

8P U (

) , .


37/51

37

T / EU

. S :

T /

T E,

. I ,

, EU

(, , .)

. T M .

L

EU E , ,

( ). A

/ . T E

, , , ,

M S.

P

C ,

EU ( , , ,

, .)

. T

( )

.

I

T EU EU //

. T E U

. S

(

).

W ,

:

T :

, ,

. I (

,

).

B (

)

.


38/51

38

B

/ .

T

EU .

T 9: S EU

T I ( , )

C ( / / )

S ,

( )

F , , .

L C (, , ):

, & S

S S

P B ( EC )

S

S ( )

S /

B / EU

I EC ( )

R EU ,

( )

F EC :

C / : I P

S A S B (IPSASB) EUPAN

4.2 Existing European initiatives

A , EU

E , . T :

I :

I (ECTS , )

/ ,

S , .

D :

C / : ,

B , .


39/51

39

M EU

. F ,

. T EU

. T E C

.

T EU ( )

.

E: IDABC (I D E G S

A, B C) H

STESTA E C' , IP . STESTA

E . I E IP , I ,

.

L IDA

. I

,

. I , L

. T '

(, , , , ,

.).

ID PEGS (PE EG S). PE

G (PEGS)

E

.

. G

G E

(S : IDABC P C I, )

E I ( 2008) :

, BH, .

L

.

F P R T D: S

PUBLIN (FP5) SPPIN (FP7)

.


40/51

40

/ :

E

E C T S /

T

(DG E)

C (US, C, I,

I, .)

H

EU & EU

S C (C

P 20072013

PROGRESS

T

U I/II

N &

IDABC P C I: LISFLOOD A. O

L + E P G

S

C

PERICLES & H II

A / T

PROGRESS

F 2013

CIP E & I,

.

T URBACT (2006)

EU ,

, :

T

URBACT. T

, , . B

. A

,

. I ,

G ,

G EU . D

INTERREG 4.


41/51

41

D ,

URBAN.

A 1.2

EU .

T

. I

.

4.3 Suggestions for the EU policy

A EU ,

() . A

. T ,

EU , ,

E C T S E (

S S ). E

.

D , ,

E . B ,

. T E C

. A, EU

/ .

EU . D

,

EU C.

A 1 A , ,

O: ( : , ,

) .

I / (, , .). E

. C

, . I

EC

EU .


42/51

42

F . S ,

, EU . H,

E

.

I, , ( / ). T EU ( DI / EA I)

. F , EU ,

.

59 E

I , EU

E

. T

.

T

E

, . T , ,

:

? C , ? H

,

?

T ,

E . T

.

A 2 D

O: T ,

.

S . A , C

DG, /

( ). S

(

) (

).

9GRIPS W : E

, 2829 O 2009, B.


43/51

43

5 E ,

T

. T

(

) .

S

. T URBACT

.

D . S ,

. T

: . I

.

A 3 T &

E .

E . C / (

, , .). T

EC .

C, ,

. T / (, , )

. R ( ,

/ , , .)

I :

. EC

, T (

, ), S / , ;

I L

, () (T, 2009).


44/51

44

410

I

S

. I

(ML D L 27 R F). T

. T

.

S

: ( ),

, ,

, .

T EU

, ,

EU.

F : ICT . D

.

R: F EU F P

R & D,

.

O . T EU

. , ,

. I

E

. T EU

, EC.

A 4 S, ,

U

. F 2002 E I F PEGS

(P E EG S) IDABC .

E ISO 9001:2008

( 3). I 9001:2008 ,

, , , . I . (..)

P EU

. L (

, , .).

10 E, 1213 O 2009, C.


45/51

45

Conclusion

I ,

. T , ,

. H, , E

. I

. T

:

A ;

F ;

C ;

C ;

A ( ) ;

F .

T

, :

R ( / )

P ( ,

)

C

( , , )

L ,

L I (

)

A . T

:

P P

. W (

, , , .)

(, , , .),

. T

, ,

. P

, ,

.

E

H , ,

. S

.


46/51

46

H,

. C

. I

( ).

M T ,

. T

(

), (

). H,

, ,

. I ,

,

. S (

).

C D (, , ) .

D

, . T

(

). P

. L

,

. A ,

;

. E

. B ,

.,

.

S

A ,

. W ,

. R ,

, . I

, , (

), , . S

,

.

A , E U ,

. B , EU

EU ,

.

H, ,

. T E


47/51

47

. B ,

E. I EU

, , ,

.

I , EU .T , (

& , )

(, .). V

. E ,

, , , . I

, ,

.

M EU ,

. A

EU , , .

T EU . L

M S .

I

. A ( , /

, , .) . T

, (

?) . I , EU

PPP.

A EU , ,

(, , ISO, .) (

E , EU , .

T , E . T

,

E.


48/51

48

Annex: References

A D. M G.J. (2003) I , C O, L.

A, T. M. C, R. C, H. L, J. & H, M. (1996) A

,A of Management Journal,Vol 39, pp1154-1184.B J. (2009) A ... S V L 27 R: P I L ,

IG 9.

B & A. (2009) : E

, W 2829 O 2009, B,

INNOGRIPS.

B, R. D. (1999). D ? I H. G. F J. M.

J (.), I. T, AL: U A

P.

B S. (2006) T C I G, I , IBM C

B G.

B S. (2001) P M I: T G P,A

A, S 2001

B J. (2008) C , IGDE

I , 25 D 2008.

C (2008) E : A , L C

O UK.

C T (2006) C . A :

://../

C J, G B, S P (2008) I , NESTA.

C D. P E. (2008) : , W

F.

C P., H J., K P & S N. (2006) I :

, P R N D24.

://..//.

D A S, T I (2008) I I C .


49/51

49

DTI (2004) C I, , UK .

D, J. (2009, 9 S) A : T

. G.

ECOTEC (2006) E BAC, .

EA G. (1987) . F ,

L R M R . A, N Y: M. E. S.

E C (2007) S ,

: E , C :A

21 E, COM(2007) 725 .

FORA, NESTA (2009) , OECD DSTI/IND.

K G., M G. M S. (2002) C A

,UK C O, L.

G E. D. (2005) A E, J, V 10(1), 2005.

G E. D. (2001) K , I J:

I J, V 6 (2), 2001.

G E. D. (1999) S I P S, I J:

D .

G . (2007) P, C F, I S D

P S, A , SO 2007.

G, L., H, J., M, I, 2002, S I: D S I

E U, A G R R D, E C

E P C

H D. (2008) E , P S I R U (PSIRU).

H T, H J, M I R R (2005)

PUBLIN P, D3, O: STEP; :

://..//.

H J. (2005), I G P : P P, &

, J 2005.

H C (2000) I D. O: M

P W G S. ISBN 066229243X


50/51

50

H R. (1999, .) G I A: I I

E , L : R .

H, G. A. & G, C. (2007). P : A .

A , 67(3), 545558.

H, B., M, P. (1991), M PA A: I

C, A O, J D J , E, , 7, 2452.

H C C P A (2008) T C T: A

(HC 157).

200708.

H C (2003) I : I ,

://...//200203///170/170.

IDEA (2005) I : ://...///1118552

J A. (2008) , BERR.

K P M (2006) I , NORDEN.

L E (2006)A C : C C E C

, CS P S.

M K. (2001) I , Q I

C, QUT/CSIRO Q U T.

M, R. 1984. C. C, W B

B.

M M. (2006) H , D I C.

M G. (2007) ? , NESTA.

NAO (2007, N), T : A . A

, HC 7 20072008.

N S. (2008) T G T C I, I ,

IBM C B G.

OECD (1995) G : ECD C. P.

P S. & P S. (., 2008) I:

, DEMOS.


51/51

P, C., W, D. (2003), T

, CMPO W P S, N. 03/073, C M P O,

U B, B, M, .

R P. (1981) C ', L S, P.

S C P O & D M I (2004) :A , , ,S C P O, T H.

T E (F 2008) T

://..//.?STORYID=10638105.

T H. (2009) L E, GI #4 , 1213 O

2009, C.

U N (2006) I G A: ,

UN D E S A.

grips ms10 public sector innovation

Documents