8/15/2019 G.R. Nos. 221697 & 221698-700

1/3

Sirs/Mesdames:Please take notice that the Court en banc issued a Resolution datedAPRIL 5, 2016, which reads as follows:"G.R. No. 221697 (Mary Grace Natividad S. Poe-Llamanzares vs.Commission on Elections and Estrella C. Elamparo) and G.R. Nos.

221698-700 (Mary Grace Natividad S. Poe-Llamanzares vs.Commission on Elections !rancisco S. "atad #ntonio P. Contreras and#mado $. %aldez).- #ctin& on t'e olloin& motions or reconsideration(o t'e $ecision dated Marc' * +,) t'e Cort 0esolved 1y t'esame vote o 2- to DENY WITH FINALITY t'e said motions orreconsideration as t'e 1asic isses raised t'erein 'ave 1een passedpon 1y t'is Cort and no s1stantial ar&ments ere presented toarrant t'e reversal o t'e 3estioned $ecision:(a) 4r&ent Plea or 0econsideration dated Marc' * +, 5led 1yprivate respondents Estrella C. Elamparo #ntonio P. Contreras #mado

$. %aldez and consel or private respondent !rancisco S. "atad6(1) Motion or 0econsideration (it' 4r&ent Prayer to #pply Section +0le + o t'e 7nternal 0les o t'e Spreme Cort) dated Marc' +++, 5led 1y Commissioner #rt'r $. Lim as consel or t'eCommission on Elections6 and(c) Motion or 0econsideration dated Marc' +2 +, 5led 1y conselor respondent #mado $. %aldez.

 "'e Cort rt'er 0esolved to(a) NOTE t'e 4r&ent Maniestation and S1mission dated Marc' +

+, 5led 1y private respondents Estrella C. Elamparo !rancisco S. "atad #ntonio P. Contreras and #mado $. %aldez represented 1y #tty.Estrella C. Elamparo statin& it' apolo&y t'at pa&e 89 o t'eir4r&ent Plea or 0econsideration as inadvertently not inclded6 andres1mittin& a ll copy o t'e said 4r&ent Plea or 0econsideration6and(1) DENY  or lac o merit t'e Motion or Leave o Cort and to #dmit0e3est or ;dicial Notice dated #pril +, 5led 1y consel orprivate respondent !rancisco S. "atad.No rt'er pleadin&s or motions ill 1e entertained.Let entry o erna1e ;. ono?cial leave 1t let 'er vote in t'is case and maintained 'er dissent.(adv*@)%ery trly yors!EL7P# >. #N#M#Cler o Cort(Please see attached:

8/15/2019 G.R. Nos. 221697 & 221698-700

2/3

- Concurring Opinion of Chief Justice Maria Lourdes P. A. ereno-!issenting Opinion of enior Associate Justice Antonio " Carpio-eparate !issenting Opinion of Associate Justice "eresita J. Leonardo-!e Castro- !issenting Opinion of Associate Justice Arturo !. #rion-eparate Concurring Opinion of Associate Justice !iosdado M. Peralta-

eparate Concurring Opinion of Associate Justice Jose C. Mendo$a-!issenting Opinion of Associate Justice #ien%enido L. Re&es-Concurring Opinion of Associate Justice Mar%ic M.'.(. Leonen#""A. GEB0GE E07N M.G#0C7# (D)Consel or PetitionerG.E. Garcia La B?ceGrond !lr. L#7B >ildin&Ca1ildo St. 7ntramrosManila

#""AS. #LEF#N$E0 ;.PB>L#$B0$7NB %7%ENC7B #.#. "#M#AB

 ;4S"7N C07S"BPE0 C.MEN$BH##N$ S#N$0# M#E ".M#G#L#NG (D)Consel or PetitionerPo1lador >atista I 0eyes

@ t' !ir. SE$$CB >ildin&+, 0ada corner Le&aspiStreetsLe&aspi %illa&e Maati City#""A. ES"0ELL# C. EL#MP#0B(D)Private 0espondent8 t ' !ir. Paci5c Star >ildin&Sen. Gil Pyat #vene cornerMaati #vene Maati CityP4>L7C 7N!B0M#"7BN B!!7CE(D)

 ;4$7C7#L 0ECB0$S B!!7CE(D)

 ;4$GMEN" $7%7S7 BN (D)Spreme Cort Manila

 "E SBL7C7"B0 GENE0#L (D)89 #morsolo St. Le&aspi%illa&eMaati City

 "E BN. C#70M#N (D)Commission on ElectionsPalacio del Go1ernador

7ntramros Manila#""A. M#N4EL7"B 0. L4N#(D)Consel or Private0espondent!rancisco "atad0oom 9+ !EM7J >ildin&(#nneD)#. Soriano ;r. #vene

7ntramros Manila$0. #N"BN7B P.CBN"E0#0#S (D)Private 0espondentPolitical Science $epartment$e la Salle 4niversity K

 "at #vene Manila#""AS. #M#$B $. %#L$EHMEL47#$ESM#0C4S N. %#L$EH 77$BNN# S. #GBNC7LLBM#0 #N$0E M.S#N"7#GB #N$ LB0ENHE#NGELB G.$7BN7S7B (D)Consel or Private0espondent

8/15/2019 G.R. Nos. 221697 & 221698-700

3/3

#mado $. %aldez# %ernida-7 +, #morsoloSt.Le&aspi %illa&e Maati City

mm ,9,@ (adv*@) 9/*/