google viacom youtube memorandum

8/9/2019 Google Viacom Youtube Memorandum

1/108

!"#!$% &'()"*+(,"-$

)"$+* .(*+/ 0+-$

.(",+* 0,-,+0 *"0,/"&, &'./,

0'.,!+/( *"0,/"&, ') (+1 %'/2

!"#$%& "'()* "'$+, -( #*+,

./01231445,

6+

7%8(89-, "'$+, -( #*+,

:;4;2 $05;

$161/ '?+ @AB$!BCD@E F**G=

(H- >%%(9#** #GG%$"#("%'

.I-&"-I *-#J8- *"&"(-:, -( #*+,

?2 K;L0/4 ?4 3L;M5;/6;5 02< 0// ?3L;N551M1/0N/O 513P03;


2/108

,-7$+ ') &'(,+(,0

489:

1

"'(I%:8$("%' +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ D

>#$(8#* #': *-J#* 9#$SJI%8': ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ [

#+ 7?P(PK; +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ [

D+ H?\ 7?P(PK; V?NU5 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ [

C+ (L; _P02313O #2< :16;N513O %4 !1- H#I9%I .I%(-$(G 7%8(89- #J#"'G( *"#9"*"(7

>%I #** %> .*#"'(">>G) $*#"&G ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ CD

#+ 7?P(PK; &;;35 (L; (LN;5L?/< _P0/141T031?25 >?N G04;BH0NK?N

.N?3;T31?2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ CD

D+ 7?P(PK; "5 # aG;N61T; .N?61


3/108

!"#$%&'(&)!%)!*!"#$%&$'()*

+,-.

11

$+ 7?P(PK; :1< '?3 H06; S2?\/;


4/108

!"#$%&'(&)!%)!*!"#$%&$'()*

+,-.

111

C+ *;Y0/ #2< .N0T31T0/ $?2511202T10/ 9;2;413 :1N;T3/O

#33N1KP30K/; (? (L; #//;Y;< "24N12Y12Y #T31613O++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ AD

D+ (L; :&$# .N?3;T35 *;Y131M03; G;N61T;5 (L03 :;N16; (L;1N

!0/P; >N?M G?PNT;5 %3L;N (L02 "24N12Y;M;23+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ AC

C+ 7?P(PK; H05 # *;Y131M03; 9P512;55 &?


5/108

!"#$%&'(&)!%)!*!"#$%&$'()*

+,-.

16

""+ 7%8(89- "G -'("(*-: (% G8&I7 ^8:J&-'( %' .*#"'(">>G)"':8$-&-'( $*#"&G ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ AR

#+ #5 # :&$#B$?M]/1023 G;N61T; .N?61


6/108

!"#$%&'"/!0&12!2%*+,-.345

6

&-0+0

!506&%& 17(0/8 9%/: ;: -#%' 17(0/ + GP]]+ C< R[ FG+:+'+7+ C@@E= +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ QE

!$0(", >&/#$+( ??@ ;: A(&%&":/#28 9%/:,

XEE >+ GP]]+ C< DC[ FG+:+'+7+ C@@Z= +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ RC

B066 3$,C,2 !$/C0;&( ;: *#$60%D E0%+&$(6&' ?"++,

[[R >+E< X@Q FC< $1N+ C@@X=++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ QE

@0"0F&%( A%0"&+ ;: G&+&$,6 + GP]]+ C< [Q@ FG+:+'+7+ C@@C= +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ QC

J&%+$0/4(#% ;: &B,'8 9%/+,

DXQ >+ GP]]+ C< D@RC F$+:+ $0/+ C@@D=+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ DA, CC, ED, QZ

9# 3$#7.8 9%/: ;: KC I&"L#$48 9%/:8

QRX >+ GP]]+ C< DDEC F'+:+ $0/+ C@@R= +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++.,((02

M,(.&$ ;: -#%' 17(0/ + GP]]+ C< EE[ FG+:+'+7+ C@@Q= +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ QC

EB? @#$.: ;: !$%#7"(,

X[X >+ GP]]+ C< EEQ FG+:+'+7+ C@@Z= +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ AZ

?&05#;0)"F ;: H,$,2#7%" H0/"7$&( @#$.+,

Z[R >+ GP]]+ DCD[ FG+:+'+7+ DZZX= ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ QE


7/108

!"#$%&'"/!0&12!2%*!"#$%&$'()*

+,-.345

61

1,N"#%&O3$,C,2 ;: B7$"/C,&66,R@E >+C< DCQE FC< $1N+ DZRX= ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ QE

131 -"7+0#(8 9%/: ;: 3$#4("&$8 ?"+:,

Q[Q 8+G+ ZDE FC@@Q= +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++.,((02

131 -"7+0#(8 9%/: ;: 3$#4("&$8 ?"+:,

[Q[ >+ GP]]+ C< ZXX F$+:+ $0/+ C@@X= Fa3$#4("&$ 99b= ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ RD, RQ, RZ

1#%#"'.& 92,D0%D8 9%/: ;: B0"("$&,28 9%/:,

EAX >+ GP]]+ C< RAA F'+:+ "//+ C@@Q= ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ R[

P% *,;0( ;: 3,.8 9%/+,C[X >+E< DQC FC< $1N+ C@@D=++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ QE

H&$)&/" QR8 9%/: ;: !2,F#%,

$!B@QB[AQE, 5/1] ?]+ F$+:+ $0/+ '?6+ [, C@@R=++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ED

H&$)&/" QR8 9%/: ;: @@B0668 ??@,

E[@ >+ GP]]+ C< D@AA F$+:+ $0/+ C@@[=+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ CE, AE

H&$)&/" QR8 9%/: ;: K0(, 9%"=6 -&$;: !((=%:,

[Z[ >+E< ARR FZ3L $1N+ C@@A= ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ RE

H&$)&/"QR8 9%/: ;: !2,F#%:/#28 9%/:,

Q@R >+E< DD[X FZ3L $1N+ C@@A= ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ DX, DZ

H&$)&/"QR8 9%/: ;: @@B066 ??@,

[RR >+E< DD@C FZ3L $1N+ C@@A= +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++.,((02

H#L&$&N @#$.: ;: >&60,%"


8/108

!"#$%&'"/!0&12!2%*!"#$%&$'()*

+,-.345

611

0,-,.,+0

>;


9/108

:;4;2


10/108

C

4N?M \0N c?2;5 02< 4N?M 1251


11/108

E

;44?N35 3? ]N?3;T3 T?]ON1YL3 \L1/; M012301212Y 02 ?];2 ;261N?2M;23 4?N TN;0316;,

]?/131T0/, 02< ];N5?20/ ;`]N;551?2, 15 ;`0T3/O 3L; U12< ?4 5;N61T; 3L03 G;T31?2 QDCFT=

\05 ;20T3;< 3? ]N?3;T3+ #3 3L; L;0N3 ?4 3L; 504; L0NK?N 15 0 2?31T;B02


12/108

[

]/01231445) 12


13/108

Q

3L;1N L?M; M?61;5 3? 3L; /0NY;53 M?61; 02< 3;/;6151?2 53P


14/108

X

53N;;35 ?4 (;LN02 05 3L; "N02102 Y?6;N2M;23 T/05L;< \13L 53P


15/108

A

5L0N;, ??< .N?YN0M P5; 7?P(PK; 3? ]PK/1T1c;

3L;1N T0P5;5, 12T/P


16/108

R

'9# 02< 'H*=k 0// ?4 3L; M0i?N N;T?N< /0K;/5 F8216;N50/ &P51T JN?P], G?2O &P51T,

V0N2;N &P51T JN?P], 02< -&"= 02< MP51T ]PK/15L;N5 L06; ;MKN0T;< 7?P(PK;)5

5;N61T; 3LN?PYL ]0N32;N5L1] 0YN;;M;235+ 9++ l Z+ 82


17/108

Z

E+ 7?P(PK;)5 ;`3;2516; ;44?N35 3? L;/] T?]ON1YL3 ?\2;N5

#/3L?PYL 7?P(PK; T022?3 T?23N?/ \L03 135 3;25 ?4 M1//1?25 ?4 P5;N5 ]?53 3?

3L; 5;N61T; ;0TL


18/108

D@

12


19/108

DD

$?]ON1YL3 L?/


20/108

DC

3;/;6151?2 ]N?YN0M5 02< M?61;5 3? 7?P(PK;+ -&& G;T31?2 "+$+E+K+11, 0%)$,+ !10T?M

L05 0/5? 1253NPT3;< 135 M?213?N12Y 0Y;235 3? /;06; P] ?2 7?P(PK; ;231N; T03;Y?N1;5

?4 P5;NB]?53;< 61


21/108

DE

30U;


22/108

D[

(\? ?4 3L; ]P30316; T/055 ]/01231445 0N; 5]?N35 055?T1031?25+ (L; >??3K0// #55?T1031?2

.N;M1;N *;0YP; *1M13;< Fa.N;M1;N *;0YP;b= 0//;Y;5 124N12Y;M;23 ?4 N1YL35 12 0PN;2TL %];2 3;2215 3?PN20M;23, M0U;5 T/01M5 K05;< ?2

KN?0N;2TL %];2 K;3\;;2 C@@E 02+ GP]]+ C< D@Z@, D@ZR FV+:+ V05L+ C@@[=+ 9O a/1M1312Y 3L; /10K1/13O ?4 5;N61T;

]N?61


26/108

DR

\L? ]?53;< 3L; M03;N10/ 5PKi;T3 3? 0 30U;


27/108

DZ

5PTL 0T31613O+b f QDCFT=FD=F9=+ #5 3L; 3;`3 02< 53NPT3PN; ?4 3L;5; ]N?6151?25 M0U;

T/;0N, 0 412


28/108

C@

3L?5; T/1]5 ;`];


29/108

CD

12


30/108

CC

7?P(PK; L05 0/5? 1M]/;M;23;< 0 ]?/1TO 4?N 3;NM120312Y 0TT?P235 ?4 N;];03

124N12Y;N5 02<


31/108

CE

E+ 7?P(PK; H05 #


32/108

C[


33/108

CQ

7?P(PK; L05 K?3L a0 \?NU12Y 2?3141T031?2 5O53;Mb 02< a0 ]N?T;


34/108

CX

]N;6;235 P5;N5 \L?5; 0TT?P235 L06; K;;2 3;NM1203;< 4N?M TN;0312Y 2;\ 0TT?P235 KO

N;T?N


35/108

CA

7; 4F8@HD@IIG5 &F8@BG "HE


36/108

CR

?4 P5;N5+ 9++ l C+ #5 \; 2?\ 0T1/1303; 85;N #TT;55 (? G3?N;< &03;N10/+

$?PN35 0]]/O12Y G;T31?2 QDCFT= L06; P214?NM/O L;/< 3L03 3L; 504; L0NK?N 15

2?3 /1M13;< 3? M;N; 53?N0Y; ?4 M03;N10/, KP3 0/5? ]N?3;T35 ?2/12; 5;N61T;5 3L03 M0U;

P5;NBP]/?0


37/108

CZ

M?N; 3L02 02 ?2/12; 61


38/108

E@

aP2


39/108

ED

D+ ./01231445 H06; (L; 9PN


40/108

EC

]/0123144 0//;Y;5+ (L; 3;`3 02< 53NPT3PN; ?4 3L; 5303P3; M0U; 3L03 T/;0N+ # 5;N61T;

]N?61


41/108

EE

E+ (L;N; #N; '? >0T35 %N $1NTPM5302T;5 S2?\2 (? 7?P(PK; >N?M

VL1TL (L; #//;Y;< "24N12Y;M;235 V;N; a#]]0N;23+b

#5 02 0/3;N20316; 3? 0T3P0/ U2?\/;


42/108

E[

DA 8+G+$+ f QDCFM=+ (L03 N;dP1N;M;23 15 1M]?N3023 L;N; K;T0P5; 7?P(PK;

;M]/?O;;5 L06; 2;6;N ;6;2 5;;2 3L; ?6;N\L;/M12Y M0i?N13O ?4 3L; M?N; 3L02 Q@@

M1//1?2 61


43/108

EQ

K+ H6,0%"0))(= /60.( 0% (70" /,%%#" 5& W$&+ )6,D(:X

-6;2 14 ]/01231445 T?P/< ]?123 3? ;61


44/108

EX

$?2YN;55 3LP5 M0


45/108

EA

\05 02 ?K61?P5 124N12Y;M;23 ?4 ]/01231445) T?]ON1YL35+ #3 0 M121MPM, 02O T/1] 3L03

FD= /;06;5


46/108

ER

\?NU5 /1U; 3L;5; 3L03 3L;O M150]]N?]N103;< ]/01231445) T?]ON1YL3;< T?23;23+ @#$50(,

EQD >+ GP]]+ C< 03 DD@R+DE

-6;2 14 ?2; T?P/<


47/108

EZ

F11= !10T?M)5 ;`3;2516; 02< 60N1;< P5; ?4 7?P(PK; 4?N

M0NU;312Y 2;Y03;5 02O 0NYPM;23 3L03 3L; 0]];0N02T; ?4

!10T?M T?23;23 12


48/108

[@

VC& Y,66 -"$&&" M#7$%,6j aO?P 0/M?53 T02)3 412< 0 K;33;N ]/0T; 3L02 7?P(PK; 3?

]N?M?3; O?PN M?61;+b GTL0]1N? -`+ CE 03 Ek (&& ,6(# 0+: -`+ C[ FA@jDXBADjC[=k IPK12

:;T/+ -`+ E, -`+ Z FJ%%@@DB@DRQQRRX= Fa\;)N; P512Y 7?P(PK; 4?N 0// ?4 ?PN ?2/12;

61


49/108

[D

!10T?M N;YP/0N/O P5;5 5?BT0//;< a53;0/3L M0NU;312Yb 3? Y;3 135 T?23;23 ?23? 7?P(PK;+

(L; Y?0/ 15 3? TN;03; 3L; 0]];0N02T; ?4 0P3L;231T YN055BN??35 123;N;53 12 3L; T?23;23

K;12Y ]N?M?3;025T0]; F0+:=k (?30/ #550P/3 F0+:=k >1/3;N

$N;0316; JN?P] F0+:=k $0N03 F0+: -`+ [C=k (E F0+:=k 9Pcc>;;< F0+:=k #:: &0NU;312Y F0+:

-`+ [E=k (!1N0/ F0+: -`+ [[=k :;;] >?TP5 F0+: -`+ [Q FCRjA=k I;< "23;N0T316; F0+: FCRjXB

A=k 02< .0/150


50/108

[C

-`+ [Xk (&& ,6(# IPK12 -`+ CC F61


51/108

[E

3L;5; ]N?M?31?20/ 61


52/108

[[

7?P(PK; .I


53/108

[Q

F111= !10T?M)5 a/;06; P]b ]N0T31T;5 4PN3L;N P2


54/108

[X

12T/P


55/108

[A

P] ?N a]055 ?2b 3L; N;M01212Y EDQ+ 9++ -`+ XC F9#7(G. @@D@ZEQDR=, -`+ DD FDE[jDZB

DEXjD@, DERjCQBDEZjD[=+

!10T?M)5 T?241


56/108

[R

!10T?M ]PK/1T/O 5303;< 3L03 13 \05 TL??512Y 3? 0//?\ 5?M; ?4 135 M03;N10/ 3?

N;M012 ?2 7?P(PK;+ GTL0]1N? -`+ AA F


57/108

[Z

F16= (L; 0NN0O ?4 0P3L?N1c;< P5;5 ?4 02< T?M]/;` ?\2;N5L1]

155P;5 5PNN?P2


58/108

Q@

T?M]021;5 \L? /1T;25;< ];N4?NM02T; N1YL35 3? IWH)5 \?NU5 3? ]?53 T/1]5 ?4 3L;1N

]N?


59/108

QD

7?P(PK; ?3L;N T?23;23 3L03 3L;O ?\2 ?N 0P3L?N1c;< ?3L;N5 3?


60/108

QC

12


61/108

QE

F6= >01N P5; 02< +& 20%020( P5; 4PN3L;N 2;Y03; ]/01231445)

0K1/13O 3? 5L?\ U2?\/;


62/108

Q[

&02O ?4 3L; T/1]5 12 5P13 0N; ]/0P51K/; F12


63/108

QQ

\05 ?2 3L; 5;N61T;, T?23012;< ]/01231445) T?]ON1YL3;< T?23;23, 02< \05 ]?53;+ GP]]+ C< 03 DDD@+ 7?P(PK; 3LP5


69/108

XD

124N12Y12Y, 7?P(PK;)5 T?23N?/ ?6;N 135 60N1?P5 5O53;M5 12 2? \0O a;dP03;g5h 3? 3L;

N1YL3 02< 0K1/13O 3? T?23N?/ 124N12Y12Y 0T31613O+b 9++

C+ *;Y0/ #2< .N0T31T0/ $?251


70/108

XC

4?N 3L; QDCFT= 504; L0NK?N+b A13 99, XXQ >+ GP]]+ C< 03 DDDE+ (L; T?23N?/ 12dP1NO


71/108

XE

0NYPM;23 3L03 a!;?L 5L?P/< L06; TL02Y;< 135 KP512;55 ?];N031?25 3? ]N;6;23

124N12Y12Y 0T31613O 4N?M ?TTPNN12Y ?2 135 513;+b QRX >+ GP]]+ C< 03 DDQ[+ a:;T/1212Y

3? TL02Y; KP512;55 ?];N031?25 15 2?3 3L; 50M; 05


72/108

X[

F1= ./01231445 L06; L0< ];N5153;23


73/108

XQ

"2 02 ;44?N3 3? ]N;6;23 3L; N;M?60/ ?4 61


74/108

XX

135 0Y;235 N?P312;/O M0


75/108

XA


76/108

XR

(L;5; 5;N10/ M151


77/108

XZ

O?PN \;K513; P231/ 4PN3L;N T/0N141T031?2 ?4 ?\2;N5L1] ?N /1T;2512Y N1YL35 T02 K;

?K3012;


78/108

A@

./01231445) ]N?K/;M5 12 dP1TU/O 02< N;/10K/O M0U12Y


79/108

AD

0]]0N03P5 ?4 T?PN5; 12T/P+ GP]]+

C< 03 DDQEBQ[+ #2


80/108

AC

/;Y131M03;, 02< 7?P(PK;


81/108

AE

]N?3;T31?2 4N?M /10K1/13O 3L02 3L;O \?P/< L06; ;2i?O;< P2


82/108

A[

QQD F.0N3 C=, 03 Q[+[@ .N?61


83/108

AQ

?\2;N5 12T/P


84/108

AX

5?M;\L03 05 3L; 5;N61T; L05 YN?\2 02< ;6?/6;


85/108

AA

3L03 L06; K;;2 ]?53;< ?N T/01M;< KO 0 T?23;23 ]0N32;N \L? L05 0441NM0316;/O

1253NPT3;< 7?P(PK; 3?


86/108

AR

'?3L12Y 12 3L; :&$# 51Y20/5 0 T?2YN;551?20/ 123;23 3? 5? P];2< 5302


87/108

AZ

1M]?N3023 53;]5 3?


88/108

R@

12


89/108

RD

3L03 3L;O T?2T;


90/108

RC

/1U;/O 3L03 G3N;0M$053 T?2


91/108

RE

12T/P


92/108

R[

TN;+ GP]]+ C< RAA, RRZ F'+:+ "//+ C@@Q= FYN02312Y

5PMM0NO iP


93/108

RQ

12


94/108

RX

U;O 3? ?PN 5PTT;55 15 ];N5?20/ 61


95/108

RA

! 7?P(PK;)5 4?P2


96/108

RR

0K?P3 3L; K051T5 ?4 T?]ON1YL3 /0\ 5? 3L03 3L;O P2


97/108

RZ

53N1U12Y/O


98/108

Z@

61


99/108

ZD

#2?3L;N ]?551K/; ]N?`O 4?N 3L; dP023PM ?4 ]?3;2310//O P20P3L?N1c;< 61


100/108

ZC

P5;N5) 124N12Y;M;23+b 9++[[ H;N;, 7?P(PK;


101/108

ZE

-&/#%+, 7?P(PK; L05 /?2Y 30U;2 M02O ?3L;N 53;]5 3?


102/108

Z[

3LN?PYL ]N?T;55 ?4 5;2


103/108

ZQ

S12Y :;T/+ l CD+[Q 7?P(PK;)5 T?MM13M;23 3?


104/108

ZX

[, DE+ #5 3L; 513; T?2312P;< 3? YN?\, 7?P(PK; N?//;< ?P3 02 12TN;0512Y/O

5?]L1531T03;< 5;N1;5 ?4 3;TL2?/?Y1T0/ 3??/5 3? L;/] T?]ON1YL3 L?/


105/108

ZA

'?3L12Y 0K?P3 5PTL 0 \;K513;)5


106/108

ZR

!10T?MBN;/03;< 61


107/108

ZZ

]PN]?5;4P/, TP/]0K/; 3L;43 ?4 123;//;T3P0/ ]N?];N3O+ (L; P2


108/108

CONCLUSIONFor the reasons above, YouTube is entit led to summary judgment (1) that it

qualifies for protection under Section 512(c) of the DMCA against all of plaintiffs'direct and secondary infringement claims; and (2) on plaintiffs' claims forcontributory liability under the theory of inducement.

Dated: March 11, 2010New York, NY Respectfully submitted,

Andrew H. SchapiroA. John P. ManciniMatthew D. IngberBrianM. WillenMAYER BROWN LLP1675 BroadwayNew York, New York 10019(212) 506-2500David H. KramerMaura L. ReesMichael H. RubinBart E. VolkmerWILSON SONSINI GOODRICH & ROSATI PC650 Page Mill RoadPalo Alto, California 94304

google viacom youtube memorandum

Documents