google-decisive-decade-report-1 · 4 ! 4f [email protected]$...

1

!"#$%&'(&')!*&+$&,$!"#$,-!-'#$$+./01203$4565$

!

!70$809:;:/0$809<=0$".>$?70$<990@03<?:.A$.B$:=0<;$>:@@$?3<A;B.31$?70$

>.3CD@<90$2E$4545$

!

2

%.A?0A?;$$6F ,.30>.3=$B3.1$G..H@0 ........................................................................................... 3

4F [email protected] ......................................................................................................... 4

JF #K09L?:/0$ML11<3E ................................................................................................ 5

NF !70$%.@@<2.3<?:/0$%.3D.3<?:.A ................................................................................ 7

NF6 !70$9.A?3:2L?:.A$9L@?L30 ............................................................................................................................. 7

NF4 %.@@<2.3<?0$?.$:AA./<?0 ............................................................................................................................ 11

NFJ [email protected]$?.$9.@@<2.3<?0 .................................................................................................................. 12

NFN !70$2<33:03;$?.$:AA./<?:.A ........................................................................................................................ 15

NFO )$B<:3$=<EP;$D<E ........................................................................................................................................ 16

NFQ *AA./<?:[email protected]<?:.A ............................................................................................................................ 19

OF !70$%.3D.3<?:.A$4F5 .............................................................................................. 21

OF6 R0A$S.A0;[email protected] .......................................................................................................................... 21

OF4 M<?.$U0:C.T$"L1<A$ME;?01;$8:309?.3$VD30/:.L;@E$"'$I<A<H03W ................................................................... 22

OFJ ,3<A9.:;$$8LB.L3T$*AA./<?:.A$(30;:=0A?$VB.3103@E$%*&W ............................................................................... 23

OFN S.2$3.@0;$.B$?70$BL?L30 .............................................................................................................................. 23

QF ML11<3E ............................................................................................................. 26

$$$$

3

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

4

!

4F [email protected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

T*D#B!+!.361*,!$5!*D;*,#-!+=,$--!#2*!59*8/-!$5!#*=2.$8$4)B!*6;8$)6*.#URSB!;$89=)B!$==3;+#9$.+8!;-)=2$8$4)!+./!+=+/*69+!0*,*!9.#*,?9*0*/!#$!4+9.!#2*9,!9.-942#!9.#$!#2*!0$,%;8+=*!$5!P(P(@!

I2*)!+,*V!!

• W,!<+,-#*.!NX,*.-*.!F!N*.9$,!Y*=#3,*,!9.!".5$,6+#9$.!N)-#*6-!+./!"..$?+#9$.B!Y$./$.!N=2$$8!$5!Z=$.$69=-!!

• N$369#,+!W3##+!F![,$5*--$,!$5!".5$,6+#9$.!N)-#*6-B!I2*!S$8+./!A*,4*,!<2+9,*/![,$5*--$,!9.!A3-9.*--!+./!I*=2.$8$4)B!"TNZOW!

• <2+,8*-FR*.,9!A*--*),*!W*-!R$,#-!F!O--$=9+#*![,$5*--$,!R*+/B!\+.+4*6*.#!+./!R36+.!S*-$3,=*-B!RZ<![+,9-B!G,+.=*!

• W*.9-!Z##942$55*,!F!G$3./*,!$5!#2*!I*=2.$;$89-!".-#9#3#*B!G,+.=*!• [,$5*--$,!O,9*!]!Y*09.!!C![,$5*--$,!$5!N$=9$8$4)B!I2*!G3Q3+!N=2$$8!$5!A3-9.*--B!W3%*!

L.9?*,-9#)B!LNO!• [*#*!A*=%6+.!F!W9,*=#$,B!Z8+1^"TNZOW_!O,4$..*!Y*+/*,-29;!<$6;3#9.4!G+=989#)B!LNO!• \,!N2$9=29!I*,+)+6+!C!Z/9#$,!9.!<29*5B!T9%%*9!A3-9.*--B!M+;+.!• [,$5*--$,!M9,$!:$%3,)$!C!W*+.!`![,$5*--$,B!:*9$!L.9?*,-9#)B!G+=38#)!$5![$89=)!

\+.+4*6*.#B!M+;+.!• W,!\+)369!R$,9!C![,$5*--$,B!R+%3$2!L.9?*,-9#)B!M+;+.!• \+,#9.!N;98%*,!C!W9,*=#$,!$5!<$,;$,+#*!<38#3,*!9.!+!78$1+89a*/!E$,8/B!A*,#*8-6+..!

N#95#3.4B!7*,6+.)!• W,!E982*86!A+3*,!F!\+.+49.4!W9,*=#$,!G,+3.2$5*,!"OH!+./!"OI!L.9?*,-9#)!$5!

N#3##4+,#B!7*,6+.)!• [,$5*--$,!W9*#6+,!R+,2$55!F!".-#9#3#*!5$,!"..$?+#9$.!S*-*+,=2B!I*=2.$8$4)!

\+.+4*6*.#!+./!Z.#,*;,*.*3,-29;B!7*,6+.)!!

E*!+,*!?*,)!4,+#*538!#$!#2*6!5$,!+88!#2*9,!3-*538!9.-942#-!+./!$;9.9$.-!$.!#29-!#$;9=@!

G9.+88)B!I2*!G3#3,*!G$3./+#9$.!9.#*,,$4+#*/!9#-!1+.%!$5!=$.-36*,!9.-942#-!+./!#,*./-!%.$08*/4*!#$!1398/!+!=8*+,!;9=#3,*!$5!#2*!0$,%;8+=*!9.!#2*!53#3,*@!!!

5

JF #K09L?:/0$ML11<3E$!I2*!5$88$09.4!%*)!59./9.4-!+,*!*D;8$,*/!9.!6$,*!/*;#2!#2,$342$3#!#2*!,*;$,#@!!

• I2*,*!9-!+.!*D#,*6*8)!=8$-*!bc&de!=$,,*8+#9$.!1*#0**.!9..$?+#9$.!+./!=$88+1$,+#9$.!C!$3,!"..$?+#9$.!"./*D!1*8$0!=8*+,8)!/*6$.-#,+#*-!#2+#!#2*!6$,*!0*!=$88+1$,+#*B!#2*!6$,*!=,*+#9?*!+./!9..$?+#9?*!0*!1*=$6*@!!!!

!• A3-9.*--*-!+.#9=9;+#*!#2*!4,$0#2!$5!4,+--,$$#-!9..$?+#9$.B!09#2!*6;8$)**-!$5!*?*,)!

8*?*8!*.=$3,+4*/!#$!;$$8!=,*+#9?*!,*-$3,=*-!09#29.!58+##*,!=$,;$,+#*!-#,3=#3,*-@!!

• Z6;8$)**-!?+83*!#2*!$;;$,#3.9#)!#$!9..$?+#*B!13#!$.8)!&'d!$5!#2*6!+,*!-+#9-59*/!09#2!#2*!;,$=*--*-!#2*9,!=$6;+.)!2+-!9.!;8+=*!#$!+88$0!#2*6!#$!/$!-$@!

!• I2*!6+J$,9#)!$5!*6;8$)**-!bfcde!1*89*?*!#2+#!9.!#2*!53#3,*B!=$,;$,+#9$.-!0988!2+?*!#$!

$55*,!#2*!?*,)!8+#*-#!9.!#*=2.$8$4)!+./!58*D918*!0$,%-;+=*-!#$!+##,+=#!+./!,*#+9.!#2*!1,942#*-#!0$,%5$,=*@!

!• H.8)!cd!$5!+88!,*-;$./*.#-!5**8!8*5#!1*29./!1)!#2*!;+=*!$5!#*=2.$8$49=+8!9..$?+#9$.B!

+./!02*.!13-9.*--*-!9.#,$/3=*!.*0!#*=2.$8$49*-!#$!#2*!0$,%;8+=*B!#2*,*!9-!+!4*.39.*!-*.-*!$5!*D=9#*6*.#!+./!*6;$0*,6*.#@!!!

!• R$0*?*,B!$.8)!&Pd!$5!*6;8$)**-!+,*!-+#9-59*/!09#2!#2*!#*=2.$8$4)!=3,,*.#8)!

+?+98+18*!#$!#2*6!+#!0$,%B!;,*5*,,9.4!#2*!6$,*!9.#39#9?*!#$$8-!#2*)!3-*!9.!#2*9,!;*,-$.+8!89?*-B!+./!.*+,8)!2+85!bgfde!/$!.$#!1*89*?*!#2*9,!*6;8$)*,!6+%*-!#2*!1*-#!3-*!$5!#*=2.$8$4)!#$!*.2+.=*!;,$/3=#9?9#)!+./!;*,5$,6+.=*@!

!!

!

"

#!

#"

$!

$"

%!

! #! $! %! &! "! '!

!""#$%&'#"()*#+,

-#..%/#+%&'#"( )*#+,

6

• O!%*)!1+,,9*,!#$!,*+89-9.4!#2*!9..$?+#9?*!;$#*.#9+8!$5!=$88+1$,+#9?*!#$$8-!9-!+!8+=%!$5!?9-9$.!5,$6!-*.9$,!6+.+4*6*.#!+./!8+=%!$5!9.?*-#6*.#!C!1$#2!.**/!#$!1*!,*-$8?*/!95!13-9.*--*-!0+.#!#$!/,9?*!9..$?+#9$.!9.!#2*!53#3,*@!

!• \+.+4*6*.#!-#,3=#3,*-!0988!2+?*!#$!=2+.4*!#$!+==$66$/+#*!=$88*=#9?*!=,*+#9?9#)@!!

I2*!1944*-#!9.=*.#9?*-!5$,!0$,%*,-!#$!=$6*!3;!09#2!=,*+#9?*!9/*+-!+,*!59.+.=9+8!,*0+,/!+./!,*=$4.9#9$.!5$,!#2*9,!+=29*?*6*.#-@!!A3#!+8#2$342!ggd!$5!*6;8$)**-!-+)!#2*9,!=$6;+.)!2+-!-)-#*6-!9.!;8+=*!#$!+88$0!#2*!=$.#,913#9$.!$5!9/*+-B!8*--!#2+.!#0$!9.!&(!b&hde!2+?*!1$.3-!-=2*6*-!#$!/9,*=#8)!,*0+,/!#2*!/*?*8$;6*.#!$5!9/*+-@!!O//,*--9.4!#29-!9--3*!0988!1*!%*)!#$!3.8$=%9.4!.*0!-$3,=*-!$5!9..$?+#9$.@!

!• T*0!13-9.*--!=$.#*D#3+8!-$=9+8!.*#0$,%9.4!#$$8-!0988!1*!/*?*8$;*/B!+./!,+#2*,!#2+.!

-**9.4!#2*6!+-!+!/9-#,+=#9$.B!=$6;+.9*-!0988!=+;9#+89-*!$.!#2*-*!.*0!+./!,9=2!13-9.*--!.*#0$,%-!1398#!+./!.3,#3,*/!1)!#2*9,!*6;8$)**-@!

!• O-!=$88+1$,+#9?*!#*=2.$8$49*-!1*=$6*!+!6+J$,!=+#+8)-#!$5!9..$?+#9$.!+./!13-9.*--!

-3==*--B!*8*6*.#-!$5!#2*!RS!+./!"I!53.=#9$.-!0988!9.#*4,+#*B!09#2!#2*!#0$!53.=#9$.-!9.=,*+-9.48)!0$,%9.4!2+./!9.!2+./@!!RS!0988!1*!6$,*!,*-;$.-918*!5$,!*.-3,9.4!#2+#!*6;8$)**-!+,*!6$#9?+#*/!#$!=$88+1$,+#*!+./!9..$?+#*B!0298*!"I!0988!;,$?9/*!#2*!9.5,+-#,3=#3,*!#$!*.+18*!9#@!

!I2*!,*;$,#!9-!-#,3=#3,*/!9.#$!#0$!+,*+-V!!!

&@ !70$%.@@<2.3<?:/0$%.3D.3<?:.AV!=3,,*.#!+##9#3/*-!#$!0$,%!+./!#2*!;,$?9-9$.!$5!#$$8-!#$!=$88+1$,+#*!+./!9..$?+#*_!+./!#,*./-!-*#!#$!96;+=#!$.!13-9.*--*-!$?*,!#2*!.*D#!/*=+/*!

P@ !70$%.3D.3<?:.A$.B$?70$,L?L30V!02*,*!/$!0*!4$!5,$6!2*,*i!

7

!NF !70$%.@@<2.3<?:/0$%.3D.3<?:.A$

NF6 !70$9.A?3:2L?:.A$9L@?L30$

'

78+'-%9+'+&3+#+"'%&'+2)&):;')<'$"+%*.'=-+#+'3-+'2$#2>5%3$)&')<'?&)=5+"0+'%&"'3-+'

$&3+&*$<$2%3$)&')<'+@2-%&0+*'%#+'3-+')&5;'0>%#%&3++*'<)#'2#+%3$&0'9%5>+'<)#'A>*$&+**+*BC'D'

W*.9-!Z##942$55*,B!I*=2.$;$89-!".-#9#3#*!bG,+.=*e'!<$.-36*,-!+,*!+8,*+/)!3-9.4!#*=2.$8$4)!#$!0$,%!#$4*#2*,B!-2+,*!9/*+-!+./!;$$8!,*-$3,=*-@'I+%*!#2*!R+9#9+.!*+,#2Q3+%*!9.!M+.3+,)!P(&(!+-!+.!*D+6;8*!C!09#29.!2$3,-B!#2*!0*1!2+/!-03.4!9.#$!+=#9$.V!I09##*,!3-*,-!%*;#!#2*!0$,8/!9.5$,6*/!9.!,*+8!#96*_!$;*.!-$3,=*!#*=2.$8$4)!+88$0*/!=9#9a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`W!53.=#9$.-!=+6*!3;!09#2!9/*+-!#2+#!#2*!,*-#!$5!#2*!0$,%5$,=*!96;8*6*.#*/@!!I$/+)B!9#!9-!09/*8)!+4,**/!1)!$3,!*D;*,#-!+./!-3,?*)!,*-;$./*.#-!#2+#!9..$?+#9$.!0988!9.=,*+-9.48)!*6*,4*!5,$6!/955*,*.#!/9,*=#9$.-B!1$#2!9.-9/*!+./!$3#-9/*!#2*!$,4+.9-+#9$.B!+./!;+,#9=38+,8)!5,$6!+!4,+--,$$#-!8*?*8@!!!!!7E#%"$3$)&%55;.'$&&)9%3$)&'-%*'-%,,+&+"'=$3-$&')#0%&$*%3$)&*'=$3-$&'3-+'2)&3+@3')<'%'#+5%3$9+'

-$+#%#2-;B''F)',+),5+'*%3'%3'%'2+#3%$&',5%2+'$&'%&')#0%&$*%3$)&'%&"'3-+;'=+#+'&)3'%55)=+"'3)'

3%5?'3)',+),5+':)#+'3-%&')&+'5+9+5'%A)9+'3-+:BBB'E-+'*$:,5+'*)5>3$)&')<'2)>#*+'$*'3-%3';)>'

:%?+')#0%&$*%3$)&*':)#+'<5%3'%&"'+&%A5+',+),5+'3)'3%5?'3)',+),5+'3-+;'=)>5"'&)3')3-+#=$*+'

3%5?'3).'3-+&'3-+')#0%&$*%3$)&'%*'%'=-)5+'=)>5"'A+2):+':)#+'$&&)9%3$9+BC'C!W,!<+,-#*.!NX,*.-*.B!Y$./$.!N=2$$8!$5!Z=$.$69=-!'!!!

8

I2*,*!+,*!6+.)!*D+6;8*-!$5!$,4+.9-+#9$.-!3-9.4!#2*!09-/$6!$5!#2*!=,$0/B!,+#2*,!#2+.!J3-#!#2*!=2$-*.!5*0!-#,+#*49-#-!$,!=,*+#9?*-B!#$!4*.*,+#*!9/*+-!+./!-$8?*!;,$18*6-@!!*AA.%0A?:/0X!5$,!*D+6;8*B!#+%*-!,*-*+,=2!+./!/*?*8$;6*.#!;,$18*6-!9.!+!1,$+/!,+.4*!$5!/$6+9.-!-3=2!+-!*.49.**,9.4B!=$6;3#*,!-=9*.=*B!=2*69-#,)!+./!13-9.*--!+./!5,+6*-!#2*6!+-!j=2+88*.4*!;,$18*6-j!5$,!+.)$.*!#$!-$8?*B!49?9.4!=+-2!+0+,/-!5$,!#2*!1*-#!-$83#9$.-@!!<$6;3#*,!6+.35+=#3,*,!80@@P;$*=0<M?.31!=$88*=#9?*!49?*-!=$.-36*,-!#2*!=2+.=*!#$!#+%*!;+,#!9.!$.89.*!1,+9.-#$,6!-*--9$.-B!-2+,9.4!9/*+-!+./!=$88+1$,+#9.4!#$!9.583*.=*!S`W@!!<,$0/-$3,=9.4!-*,?9=*-!-3=2!+-!%@.L=%3.>=!+,*!+8-$!*6*,49.4B!;,$69-9.4!#$!k3-*!#2*!9.#*,.*#!#$!#+;!9.#$!;$$8-!$5!#+8*.#B!8+1$3,!+./!=,*+#9?9#)!#$!4*#!0$,%!/$.*l@!!I3,.9.4!#$!$3,!,*-*+,=2B!0*!-**!#2+#!6+.)!$,4+.9-+#9$.-!+,*!+8,*+/)!6+%9.4!-$6*!;,$?9-9$.!5$,!-#+55!#$!=$.#,913#*!9/*+-@[email protected];$<H300=$?7<?$?70:3$9.1D<AE$H:/0;$?701$?70$.DD.3?LA:?E$?.$9.10$LD$>:?7$:=0<;!+./!+!53,#2*,!f!9.!&(!2+?*!2+/!#2*!-+#9-5+=#9$.!$5!-**9.4!#2*6!96;8*6*.#*/@!!!Z6;8$)**-!9.!#2*!LN!bc&de!+./!L:!bc(de!+,*!6$-#!89%*8)!#$!1*!*.=$3,+4*/!#$!=$6*!3;!09#2!9/*+-!5$,!#2*9,!$,4+.9-+#9$.B!0298*!#2*,*!9-!-#988!0$,%!#$!1*!/$.*!9.!M+;+.!b'gde!+./!G,+.=*!bfKde@!!

!"#$%&'(&)"*&+,-%$./0%.,-&+01%0$*&.2&/*3.--.-3&%,&3#%"*$&4#+*&&

!!Z6;8$)**-!+,*!?*,)!63=2!1*29./!#29-!6$?*!#$!4,+--,$$#-!9/*+-F4*.*,+#9$.@!!H3,!,*-*+,=2!-2$0-!#2+#!&!9.!K!1*89*?*!#2*!.*D#!4*.*,+#9$.!$5!9..$?+#9$.!0988!=$6*!+-!+!,*-38#!$5!+88!-#+55!6*61*,-!1*9.4!*.=$3,+4*/!#$!=$6*!3;!09#2!9/*+-B!0298*!$.8)!&!9.!&(!#29.%!#2+#!.*0!9/*+-!0988!1*!/,9?*.!1)!-*.9$,!6+.+4*6*.#@!O!-94.959=+.#!69.$,9#)!bK&de!1*89*?*!9..$?+#9$.!0988!1*!/*89?*,*/!1)!5,**8+.=*!-3;;$,#!9.!#2*!5$,6!$5!*D#*,.+8!9/*+-!=$.-38#+.#-@!!!

9

!"#!9-!0$,#2!.$#9.4!#2+#!$.8)!fd!$5!*6;8$)**-!#29.%!#2+#!=$6;+.9*-!0988!6+9.#+9.!#2*!-#+#3-!Q3$!+./!.$#!=2+.4*!#2*!0+)!#2*)!+;;,$+=2!9..$?+#9$.. !

!"#$%&5(&611&2%#77&8.11&/*&*-+,0$#3*9&%,&+,:*&04&8.%"&.9*#2;.--,<#%.,-2&

[".>$=.$E.L$?7:AC$9.1D<A:0;$>:@@$<DD3.<97$?70$H0A03<?:.A$.B$A0>$:=0<;$<A=$:AA./<?:.A$:A$?70$A0K?$O$E0<3;\]'

'

!<,9#9=+8!#$!#2*!=$.#,913#9$.!=38#3,*!9-!#2*!1*89*5!+6$.4!6$,*!#2+.!+!Q3+,#*,!bPmde!$5!,*-;$./*.#-!#2+#!-#+55!0988!1*!,*0+,/*/!9.!89.*!09#2!#2*!9/*+-!#2*)!=$.#,913#*@!!".!5+=#B!1)!P(P(B!0*!0$38/!+,43*!#2+#!6$,*!?+83*!0988!1*!;8+=*/!$.!#2*!Q3+89#)!$5!9/*+-!4*.*,+#*/!#2+.!$.!+.)!$#2*,!;*,5$,6+.=*!6*#,9=@!!E*!*D;8$,*!#29-!53,#2*,!9.!#2*!G%$#'1%;H*'I%;!-*=#9$.!$5!#2*!,*;$,#@!!'

O./!)*#B!$?*,!+!Q3+,#*,!$5!;*$;8*!bPfde!!-+)!#2*9,!*6;8$)*,!/$*-!.$#!*.=$3,+4*!#2*6!#$!=$6*!3;!09#2!.*0!9/*+-B!-344*-#9.4!#2+#!6+.)!$,4+.9-+#9$.-!+,*!-#,34489.4!09#2!2$0!#$!6+.+4*!#2*!=$66*,=9+8!;$#*.#9+8!$5!4,+--,$$#-!9/*+-!4*.*,+#9$.@!!!!!!!!!!!

10

!"#$%&=(&>-+,0$#3*:*-%&%,&9*<*1,4&-*8&+$*#%.<*&.9*#2&

[[email protected]$=.0;$A.?$0A9.L3<H0$10$?.$9.10$LD$>:?7$A0>$:=0<;]!

!"#!9-!3.89%*8)!#2+#!#2*-*!.*0!0+)-!$5!0$,%9.4!0988!2+;;*.!$?*,.942#@!!A3#!#2*!6$,*!5$,0+,/!#29.%9.4!=$6;+.9*-!2+?*!+8,*+/)!-#+,#*/!#$!/9-=$?*,!#2+#!+3#$.$6)!/$*-!.$#!8*+/!#$!+.+,=2)!C!.+#3,+8!29*,+,=29*-!=+.!-;,9.4!3;!9.!;8+=*!$5!5$,6+8!$.*-B!+88$09.4!5$,!4,*+#*,!5,**/$6!09#29.!+4,**/!;+,+6*#*,-@!!O-![,$5*--$,!M9,$!:$%3,)$!$5!:*9$!L.9?*,-9#)B!M+;+.B!*D;8+9.-V!kJ')A*+#9+'3-%3'$&<)#:%5'5+%"+#*'3+&"'3)'+:+#0+'K$&',5%2+')<':)#+'<)#:%5'

-$+#%#2-$2%5'*3#>23>#+*LBBB<)#'+@%:,5+'$<';)>'5))?'%3'E=$33+#.'3-+#+'%#+'%'-%&"<>5')<',+),5+'

=-)'-%9+'3-)>*%&"*')<'<)55)=+#*BBB%5:)*3'%&'%5,-%'A5)00+#B''F)'3-+#+'#+:%$&*'%&'

$&<5>+&2+#M$&<5>+&2++'#+5%3$)&*-$,BC'

!*1D@:9<?:.A;$B.3$2L;:A0;;0;$:A$?70$=09:;:/0$=09<=0$

IL@?:><E$!3<BB:9$I<A<H010A?$

• E*!+,*!*.#*,9.4!+.!*,+!$5!638#90+)!9/*+-!#,+559=@!!"..$?+#9$.!0988!1*!4*.*,+#*/!5,$6!638#9;8*!-$3,=*-!C!1$#2!9.-9/*!+./!$3#-9/*!$5!#2*!$,4+.9-+#9$.!

• I2*!1+8+.=*!$5!;$0*,!9-!-295#9.4@!!G,$6!1,+./!#$!=$.-36*,B!*6;8$)*,!#$!*6;8$)**@!!O-!#29-!-295#!=$.#9.3*-!#$!4,$0!9.!96;$,#+.=*B!#2*!$;;$,#3.9#)!#$!=$88+1$,+#*!+./!=$.#,913#*!0988!1*=$6*!+!%*)!5+=#$,!9.!#2*!=2$9=*!$5!029=2!1,+./!#$!13)!+./!029=2!=$6;+.)!#$!0$,%!5$,!

• \+.+4*,-!0988!.**/!#$!;3#!;,$=*--*-!9.!;8+=*!#$!2+,.*--!#2*!9/*+-!+./!9..$?+#9$.!4*.*,+#*/!1)!#2*!=$.#,913#9$.!=38#3,*!!

• I2*!.*D#!=2+88*.4*!0988!1*!#$!*D;8$,*!+./!9/*.#95)!2$0!9/*+-!0988!1*!,*0+,/*/B!1$#2!9.-9/*!+./!$3#-9/*!#2*!$,4+.9-+#9$.!

!!!

!"

#!"

$!"

%!"

&!"

'!"

()*+, -. -/0 12+345 6527+38 9+:+3

0;255 0;255<=*2)3;,8

11

!

"

#!

#"

$!

$"

%!

! #! $! %! &! "! '!

!""#$%&'#"()*#+,

-#..%/#+%&'#"( )*#+,

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bmPd!=$6;+,*/!#$!Pcd!,*-;*=#9?*8)e@!!O!-9698+,!;9=#3,*!*6*,4*-!9.!#2*!L:B!09#2!fPd!$5!#2$-*!9.?9#*/!#$!=$88+1$,+#*!=$69.4!3;!09#2!9/*+-B!=$6;+,*/!#$!Kcd!02$!+,*!.$#_!+./!9.!M+;+.!bmPd!=$6;+,*/!#$!Pcde@!!I2*!=2+,#!1*8$0!-2$0-!#2*!-#,$.4!,*8+#9$.-29;!1*#0**.!=$88+1$,+#9$.!+./!9..$?+#9$.B!09#2!+.!c&d!+4,**6*.#!+6$.4!,*-;$./*.#-!#2+#!#2*!#0$!+,*!=8$-*8)!89.%*/@

!"#$%&?(&)"*&@--,<#%.,-&@-9*A&

E-+'$&"+@+*'<)#'2)55%A)#%3$)&'%&"'$&&)9%3$)&'2%52>5%3+'#+*,)&"+&3*H'%0#++:+&3'%2#)**'%'#%&0+')<'N>+*3$)&*'3)'

N>%&3$<;',)*$3$9+'),$&$)&*'3)=%#"*'2)55%A)#%3$)&'%&"'$&&)9%3$)&'#+*,+23$9+5;B''E-+'2)##+5%3$)&'A+3=++&'3-+'3=)'

$&"+@+*'"+:)&*3#%3+*'3-+'25)*+'#+5%3$)&*-$,'A+3=++&'3-+*+'*3%3+:+&3*B !!!!!!!!!!!!!

!I2*!96;89=+#9$.!5$,!13-9.*--*-!2*,*!9-!=8*+,!C!?0<1$0BB.3?;$BL0@;$:AA./<?:.AF$$E2+#!9-!6$,*B!*6;8$)**-!0+.#!#$!=$88+1$,+#*B!+./!*.J$)!0$,%9.4!+-!;+,#!$5!+!#*+6V!

• 'hd!$5!*6;8$)**-!+4,**!#2+#!#2*)!;,*5*,!0$,%9.4!+-!;+,#!$5!+!#*+6!• 'md!;,*5*,!#2*!-$=9+1989#)!$5!#2*!$559=*!+./!0988!+80+)-!0+.#!#$!-;*./!+#!8*+-#!-$6*!

$5!#2*9,!#96*!9.!#2*!=$6;+.)!$5!=$88*+43*-!• 'gd!4*#!#2*9,!1*-#!9/*+-!5,$6!/9-=3--9$.!09#2!=$88*+43*-!b,9-9.4!#$!f&d!9.!7*,6+.)e!

12

$*1D@:9<?:.A;$B.3$2L;:A0;;0;$:A$?70$=09:;:/0$=09<=0$

$(0.D@0$83:/0A$#9.A.1E$$

$'7!<3+#'"+2%"+*')<'"$0$3$*%3$)&.'A#$&0$&0'->:%&'A+$&0*'A%2?'3)'3-+'2+&3#+')<'$&<)#:%3$)&'

&+3=)#?*'K=$55'A+'?+;LBC'D!W*.9-!Z##942$55*,B!I*=2.$;$89-!".-#9#3#*!bG,+.=*e!

• E9#2!=$6;+.9*-!0$,%9.4!#$!8*--!29*,+,=29=+8!+./!6$,*!=$88+1$,+#9?*!!-#,3=#3,*-B!9#!0988!1*=$6*!9.=,*+-9.48)!96;$,#+.#!#$!5$=3-!$.!#2*!?+83*!$5!236+.!9.#*,+=#9$.!!

• I2*!6$?*!#$!+!6$,*!58*D918*!=38#3,*!0988!-**!#2*!R36+.!S*-$3,=*-!+./!".5$,6+#9$.!I*=2.$8$4)!/*;+,#6*.#-!#+-%*/!09#2!.3,#3,9.4!?9,#3+8!#*+6-B!6+.+49.4!#2*!=$88+1$,+#9$.!;,$=*--B!6$#9?+#9.4!-#+55!+./!*.-3,9.4!-*+68*--!/*89?*,)!-)-#*6-@!!Z8*6*.#-!$5!1$#2!53.=#9$.-!0988!.**/!#$!9.#*4,+#*!#$!+==$66$/+#*!#29-@!

• [,$5*--9$.+8-!+,*!+8,*+/)!+.#9=9;+#9.4!09/*-;,*+/!=2+.4*@!!O!#29,/!bK&de!$5!"I!6+.+4*,-!1*89*?*!#2*!<"H!0988!#+%*!$.!6$,*!,*-;$.-91989#)!5$,!9..$?+#9$.!9.!#2*!53#3,*B!0298*!Kgd!$5!RS!-#+55!+4,**!#2*)!0988!.**/!#$!8*+,.!.*0!-%988-!#$!5$-#*,!+!-*.-*!$5!=$,;$,+#*!=$663.9#)!

• I2*!,$8*!$5!RS!0988!9.=,*+-9.48)!5$=3-!$.!6+9.#+9.9.4!+!;$-9#9?*!1+8+.=*!02*.!.*0!#*=2.$8$4)!9-!9.#,$/3=*/B!;,$#*=#9.4!-#+55!5,$6!$?*,0$,%B!6+9.#+9.9.4!+!,*8+#9$.-29;!1+-*/!$.!#,3-#!+./!*.-3,9.4!#2+#!#2*)!;*,5$,6!+#!$;#9636!8*?*8-!

• 78+'-%9+'A)>&"%#$+*'=-$2-'>*+"'3)'A+'<$@+"'3-%3'%#+'&)='<%55$&0'")=&')9+#')>#'

-+%"*B''8+'>*+"'3)'-%9+'25+%#'"$*3$&23$)&*'A+3=++&'=-%3'=%*'-):+.'=-%3'=%*'=)#?B''

8-+3-+#'=+'=+#+',#$9%3+')#',>A5$2B''8+'>*+"'3)'3%?+'3-+*+'A)>&"%#$+*'<)#'0#%&3+"'

%&"'*)')&+')<'3-+'3-$&0*'%A)>3'OPOP'$*'3-%3'=$3-'%55')<'3-+*+'&+='*+#9$2+*'=+'#+%55;'

&++"'3)'3#;'%&"'>&"+#*3%&"'-)='3)'"+<$&+'&+='A)>&"%#$+*BC!W,!<+,-#*.!NX,*.-*.B!Y$./$.!N=2$$8!$5!Z=$.$69=-!!!

$NFJ [email protected]$?.$9.@@<2.3<?0$

7Q)#,)#%3+'JE'%#2-$3+23>#+'$*'A+-$&"'3-+'2>#9+BBB,+#*)&%5'2):,>3$&0'-%*':)9+"'%-+%"')<'

2)#,)#%3+'2):,>3$&0'%&"BBB3-%3H*'0)$&0'3)'2#+%3+'+&)#:)>*',#+**>#+*B''I+),5+'3)"%;'*%;'

R=+55.'J'2%&':%?+'%'=+A*$3+.'J'2%&'*-%#+',$23>#+*'%&"':)9$+*':>2-':)#+'+%*$5;'$&':;',+#*)&%5'

5$<+'3-%&'J'2%&'$&'3-+'=)#?'+&9$#)&:+&3H'%&"'3-%3'$*'&)3'*>*3%$&%A5+BC'F!N$369#,+!W3##+B!"TNZOW'!H3,!*D;*,#-!1*89*?*!#2+#!0$,%;8+=*!#*=2.$8$4)!9-!8+449.4!5+,!1*29./!#2*!#$$8-!0*!3-*!9.!$3,!;*,-$.+8!89?*-B!+./!#29-!9-!2+?9.4!+.!96;+=#!$.!#2*!9..$?+#9?*!=+;+1989#9*-!$5!$,4+.9-+#9$.-!+./!#2*!8*?*8!$5!*6;8$)**!-+#9-5+=#9$.@!!O./!02+#!*6*,4*-!=8*+,8)!5,$6!$3,!+.+8)-9-!9-!#2+#!6+.)!+,*!.$#!;3##9.4!#2*!#*=2.$8$4)!9.!;8+=*!#$!*.=$3,+4*!=$88+1$,+#9$.V!

13

• m(d!$5!*6;8$)**-!0*!-3,?*)*/!#29.%!.*0!#*=2.$8$49*-!+88$0!#2*6!#$!0$,%!1*##*,!09#2!=$88*+43*-B!13#!$.8)!&Pd!*D;,*--*/!-+#9-5+=#9$.!09#2!#2*!#*=2.$8$4)!+?+98+18*!#$!#2*6!+#!0$,%!

• ggd!-+)!#2*!#*=2.$8$4)!#2*)!3-*!9.!#2*9,!;*,-$.+8!89?*-!9-!1*##*,!#2+.!#2*)!2+?*!+#!0$,%!bJ36;9.4!#$!'Kd!9.!#2*!LNe!!

• gfd!1*89*?*!#2*9,!*6;8$)*,!/$*-.>#!6+%*!#2*!1*-#!3-*!$5!#*=2.$8$4)!#$!*.2+.=*!;,$/3=#9?9#)!+./!;*,5$,6+.=*!b'cd!9.!M+;+.e!!

!O-!0*!=+.!-**!5,$6!#2*!=2+,#!1*8$0B!"I!6+.+4*,-!9.!6+.)!=$3.#,9*-!b09#2!#2*!*D=*;#9$.!$5!#2*!LNe!1*89*?*!#2*9,!$,4+.9-+#9$.!9-!-96;8)!.$#!#+%9.4!5388!+/?+.#+4*!$5!=$88+1$,+#9?*!#*=2.$8$4)@!

!"#$%&B(&!,:4#-.*2&#$*&-,%&#+".*<.-3&%"*.$&+,11#/,$#%.<*&4,%*-%.#1&8.%"&%*+"-,1,3C&

[!7:AC:AH$<2.L?$@0/0@;$.B$9.@@<2.3<?:.A$?7<?$9<A$A.>$20$<97:0/0=$:A$?70$>.3CD@<90$L;:[email protected]$<A=$>02^2<;0=$?..@;X$=.$E.L$?7:AC$E.L3$.3H<A:;<?:.A$:;$<97:0/:AH$:?;$D.?0A?:<@$:A$?7:;$<30<\]$V*!$1<A<H03;$.A@EW$

$

0.0%

10.0%

20.0%

30.0%

40.0%

50.0%

60.0%

70.0%

80.0%

90.0%

UK USA France Germany Japan

Yes

'

!I29-!9-!+!-2$,#F-942#*/!+;;,$+=2B!+./!#2*,*!9-!*?9/*.=*!#2+#!9#!/$*-!.$#!0$,%!F!,*-*+,=2!=+,,9*/!$3#!9.!#2*!L:&!-344*-#-!#2+#!3;!#$!hhd!$5!*6;8$)**-!+,*!=9,=36?*.#9.4!=$,;$,+#*!;$89=9*-!+./!3-9.4!+#!8*+-#!$.*!3.+3#2$,9-*/!E*1!P@(!#*=2.$8$4)!-3=2!+-!9.-#+.#!6*--*.4*,!$,!$.89.*!/$=36*.#!-2+,9.4!#$$8-!09#29.!#2*9,!0$,%;8+=*@!!"#!9-!=8*+,!#2+#!02*#2*,!$,4+.9-+#9$.-!89%*!9#!$,!.$#B!=$88+1$,+#9?*!#$$8-!+,*!2*,*!#$!-#+)@!!I2*!=2+88*.4*!9-!#$!59./!#2*!1*-#!0+)!#$!;,$?9/*!-#+55!09#2!13-9.*--!=$.#*D#3+8!?*,-9$.-!+./!3-*!#2*6!#$!*.2+.=*!;,$/3=#9?9#)!+./!1398/!;,$5*--9$.+8!+./!;*,-$.+8!.*#0$,%-@!!!

1 FaceTime Communications research, March 2010

14

Y$$%9.4!1+=%!+#!$3,!,*-*+,=2B!=$6;+.9*-!#2+#!2+?*!*61,+=*/!#*=2.$8$4)!+,*!+8,*+/)!-**9.4!#2*!1*.*59#-@!Z6;8$)**-!5,$6!*?*,)!=$3.#,)!.$#*/!#2+#!?70$:A?3.=L9?:.A$.B$A0>[email protected]:0;$7<;$@0=$?.$H30<?03$B@0K:2:@:?E$:A$?70$><E$D0.D@0$>.3CB!09#2!G,+.=*!9.!;+,#9=38+,!.$#9=9.4!+.!9.=,*+-*!9.!=$88+1$,+#9$.!+./!9..$?+#9$.@!!G,*.=2!bK(deB!A,9#9-2!bK(de!+./!O6*,9=+.!bg(de!0$,%*,-!1*89*?*!#2+#!.*0!#*=2.$8$49*-!0988!=$.#9.3*!#$!*.2+.=*!9..$?+#9$.B!0298*!9.!7*,6+.)B!-0**;9.4!=2+.4*-!#$!13-9.*--!6$/*8-!+,*!+.#9=9;+#*/!1)!+!Q3+,#*,!$5!*6;8$)**-!+-!+!/9,*=#!,*-38#!$5!#2*!+/$;#9$.!$5!#*=2.$8$4)@!!!".!+//9#9$.B!#2*!=2+,#!1*8$0!/*6$.-#,+#*-!#2+#!#2*!:A?3.=L9?:.A$.B$A0>[email protected]:0;$0AH0A=03;$<$B00@:AH$.B$0K9:?010A?$<A=$01D.>0310A?$:A$>.3C03;@!!I29-!*D=9#*6*.#!9-!;+,#9=38+,8)!;,*?+8*.#!9.!G,+.=*!bggde!+./!#2*!LN!bgKde@!!H.8)!cd!$5!+88!,*-;$./*.#-!5**8!8*5#!1*29./!1)!#2*!;+=*!$5!#*=2.$8$49=+8!9..$?+#9$.!F!#2*,*!9-!=8*+,8)!+!-#,$.4!+;;*#9#*!5$,!6$,*!-$;29-#9=+#*/!#*=2.$8$4)!09#29.!#2*!0$,%;8+=*@!

!"#$%&D(&E2.-3&-*8&%*+"-,1,3C&+$*#%*2&*A+.%*:*-%&#-9&*:4,8*$:*-%&

[".>$=.$E.L$L;L<@@E$B00@$<2.L?$A0>[email protected]:0;$>70A$?70E$<30$:A?3.=L90=$:A?.$E.L3$>.3CD@<90\]$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$7S+%"+#*-$,'*3;5+*'%&"'A)%#"T5+9+5'2)::>&$2%3$)&'=$55'-%9+'3)'%"%,3BBBQ6U*'&++"'3)':%?+'

:)#+'%&"'A+33+#'>*+')<'+:+#0$&0'2)::>&$2%3$)&'3+2-&)5)0$+*'=-$2-':)*3'-%9+'>33+#5;'

&+05+23+"BBBBE-+#+'$*'%'->0+'&++"'3)'+">2%3+'3-+:'D'=+'2%&&)3'=%$3'3-+'<>55'2%#++#'2;25+'3)'

*++'&+='3+2-&)5)0$+*'%##$9+'$&'3-+'A)%#"'#)):BC'C![,$5*--$,!W9*#6+,!R+,2$55B!".-#9#3#*!5$,!"..$?+#9$.!S*-*+,=2B!I*=2.$8$4)!\+.+4*6*.#!+./!Z.#,*;,*.*3,-29;!b7*,6+.)e''$

*1D@:9<?:.A;$B.3$2L;:A0;;0;$:A$?70$=09:;:/0$=09<=0\$$

M:1D@0$%.1D@0K:?E$

!" #!" $!" %!" &!" '!" (!" )!" *!" +!" #!!

"

,-./012134/56/16-5-/

7/.89:1-./1-8;/6121<./0/=6154>5?616@;/-.89A19/>1B@;89A1@C-159:1D1E89:18-

:8EE8BC4-1-@1F//31C3

G330/./968H/121I/>1-/B.9@4@A?1;5F/61;/19/0H@C6

,H/0>@0F/:121J/--89A1C31-@163//:1861KC6-159@-./01-.89A1-@15::1-@1;?1-@1:@1486-

L0C6-05-/:121D-1-5F/616@14@9A1-@1A/-1-@1F9@>1-./;MA/-1-./;1>@0F89A130@3/04?

N95EE/B-/:121-./1-/B.9@4@A?1D1C6/1861;?13/06@95414 8E/M@C-68:/1>@0F1861C6C544?

;@0/15:H59B/:1-.591>.5-1D1C6/15-1>@0F

D9H@4H/:121D1E//414/66186@45-/:159:1;@0/1350-1@E1-./1-/5;O1/H/918E1D1-05H/41@0

>@0F1E0@;1.@;/

D-1>@C4:1P/1/568/[email protected]/15-1>@0F1-./165;/1-/B.9@4@A?1D1C6/15-1.@;/

Q/48/H/:121-./?1./431;/1-@1;595A/1;?1>@0FM48E/1P5459B/1P/--/0

R9@>4/:A/5P4/121D1C6/14@-61@E1-/B.9@4@A?1@C-68:/1@E1-./1>@0F345B/

S;3@>/0/:121-.59F61-@19/>1-/B.9@4@A8/61D1B591:@1;@0/O1>@0F1E56-/0O1A/-

5B-8H/4?189H@4H/:1891;@0/130@K/B-6

STB8-/:121D14@H/1C689A19/>1-/B.9@4@A?

15

$• O-!=$.-36*,-!0*!+,*!/,+0.!#$!#$$8-!#2+#!6+%*!$3,!89?*-!6$,*!6+.+4*+18*!+./!

-#,+942#5$,0+,/!F!+./!13-9.*--*-!2+?*!63=2!#$!8*+,.!5,$6!#29-@!!T*+,8)!2+85!bgfde!$5!0$,%*,-!0*!-3,?*)*/!1*89*?*!#2*9,!*6;8$)*,!/$*-!.$#!6+%*!#2*!6$-#!$5!#*=2.$8$4)!#$!96;,$?*!;,$/3=#9?9#)!+./!;*,5$,6+.=*@!

• I2*!1*-#!*D+6;8*-!$5!#*=2.$8$4)!#2+#!+88$0!=,*+#9?9#)!+./!=$88+1$,+#9$.!9.!#2*!=$.-36*,!-;2*,*!+,*!1+-*/!$.!-96;8*!9.#*,5+=*-!C!MCED0P;!,+.4*!$5!29428)!53.=#9$.+8B!/*=*;#9?*8)!-96;8*!=$663.9=+#9$.!-*,?9=*-_!G..H@0$I<D;!+./!9#-!,9=28)!9.#39#9?*!9.#*,5+=*_!(7:@:D;P$M0A;0$_$M:1D@:9:?E!*#2$-B!+!#942#!9.#*,+=#9$.!$5!=$6;8*D!53.=#9$.+89#)!$?*,8+9/!09#2!-96;8*!/*-94.!

• "#!=+.!$.8)!1*!+!6+##*,!$5!#96*!1*5$,*!#2*!/*6+./!5$,!-96;8*!=$6;8*D9#)!598#*,-!9.#$!0$,%;8+=*!"I!+./!#29-!0988!2+?*!96;89=+#9$.-!5$,!#2*!RS!+./!"I!53.=#9$.-@!!I2*)!0988!.**/!#$!0$,%!=8$-*8)!#$!6+D969-*!;,$=*--*-!+./!1*##*,!3./*,-#+./!#2*!9.#*,;8+)!1*#0**.!#*=2.$8$4)!+./!236+.!=$..*=#*/.*--!

'

$NFN !70$2<33:03;$?.$:AA./<?:.A$

E298*!#2*,*!+,*!6+.)!+,436*.#-!9.!5+?$3,!$5!1$$-#9.4!#2*!3;#+%*!$5!=$88+1$,+#9?*B!#*=2.$8$49*-!09#29.!#2*!0$,%;8+=*B!0*!/9-=$?*,*/!-$6*!-94.959=+.#!1+,,9*,-!09#29.!$,4+.9-+#9$.-!#2+#!.**/!#$!1*!+//,*--*/@!!E2*.!0*!+-%*/!"I!6+.+4*,-!02+#!#2*)!5*8#!0*,*!#2*!=$,*!1+,,9*,-!#$!+=29*?9.4!=$88+1$,+#9?*!;$#*.#9+8B!#2*!6$-#!;,*--9.4!*6+.+#*/!5,$6!-*.9$,!6+.+4*6*.#V!8+=%!$5!-*.9$,!?9-9$.!bgKde!+./!#2*!.**/!5$,!53./9.4U9.?*-#6*.#!bg&de!0*,*!=9#*/!+-!#2*!#$;!;,$18*6-B!J3-#!+2*+/!$5!-*=3,9#)!9--3*-@!!Z/3=+#9.4!-*.9$,!6+.+4*6*.#!+-!#$!#2*!;$#*.#9+8!=$66*,=9+8!1*.*59#-!$5!0*1F1+-*/!#$$8-!0988!1*!%*)!95!=$6;+.9*-!0+.#!#$!*61,+=*!9/*+-!+==*8*,+#9$.!+./!-#+)!+2*+/!$5!#2*9,!=$6;*#9#$,-@!!!"I!=$6*-!3./*,!;+,#9=38+,!-=,3#9.)!5,$6!-*.9$,!6+.+4*6*.#!+#!#96*!$5!*=$.$69=!/9559=38#)B!-+)-![*#*!A*=%6+.B!O,4$..*!T+#9$.+8!Y+1$,+#$,)!bLNOeV''7JE.'<)#'#+0>5%#'2):,%&$+*.'$*'%&'

)9+#-+%"B''J3'")+*&H3'*+55',#)">23*.'$3'")+*&H3'A#$&0'$&'#+9+&>+.'$3'")+*&H3'25)*+'%&;'"+%5*')#'

"+9+5),'%&;',#)">23*B''J3H*'%&'+&%A5$&0'3+2-&)5)0;'A>3BBB$<'=+'%""+"'VPW'3)'3-+'JE'A>"0+3.'

=)>5"'3-%3'$&2#+%*+')>#',#)<$3%A$5$3;'A;'3-+'*%:+'%:)>&3XBBB8-+&+9+#'3-+#+'$*'%'A>"0+3%#;'

2#>&2-.';)>'5))?'%3';)>#')9+#-+%"*BBB%&"'*):+3$:+*'JE'0+3*'5>:,+"'$&'3-+#+BC'

!O.$#2*,!%*)!1+,,9*,!#$!9..$?+#9$.!9-!#2+#!+8#2$342!6$,*!#2+.!-9D!9.!&(!*6;8$)**-!+4,**!=$88+1$,+#9?*!#*=2.$8$4)!2+-!=2+.4*/!#2*!0+)!#2*)!0$,%B!K&d!1*89*?*!+==*--!#$!-$=9+8!.*#0$,%9.4!#$$8-!-3=2!+-!G+=*1$$%!9.!#2*!0$,%;8+=*!6+%*-!-#+55!8*--!;,$/3=#9?*B!+./!gPd!#29.%!-3=2!#$$8-!+,*!/9-#,+=#9.4@!!!$

16

E*!1*89*?*!#2+#!#2*,*!9-!+!;?3.AH$9<;0$B.3$2L;:A0;;$9.A?0K?L<@$;.9:<@$A0?>.3C:AH$?..@;$$+./!#2+#!$.=*!-#+55!+;;,*=9+#*!#2*!1*.*59#-!#2*-*!=+.!1,9.4B!#2*)!0988!1*!*.#23-9+-#9=+88)!+/$;#*/@!!".!5+=#B!0*!0$./*,!02*#2*,!#2*,*!9-!;$#*.#9+8!5$,!I09##*,U!G+=*1$$%!#96*!#$!1*=$6*!9.!+!-*.-*!#2*!.*0!n=94+,*##*!1,*+%>!C!$.!#2*!-3,5+=*!;*,=*9?*/!+-!+!#96*F0+-#*,!13#!9.!,*+89#)!+!#96*!5$,!*6;8$)**-!#$!#+%*!+!1,*+%!#$!4*#!+!5,*-2!;*,-;*=#9?*B!*.2+.=*!#2*9,!;*,-$.+8!+./!;,$5*--9$.+8!.*#0$,%-B!1,+9.-#$,6!5,*-2!9/*+-!+./!59./!9.-;9,+#9$.@!!$

*1D@:9<?:.A;$B.3$2L;:A0;;0;$:A$?70$=09:;:/0$=09<=0\$$

+0?>.3C;$!

• A3-9.*--!=$.#*D#3+8!-$=9+8!.*#0$,%9.4!-2$38/!1*!/*?*8$;*/!,+#2*,!#2+.!;,$2919#*/!+-!#2*!=$,;$,+#9$.!$5!#2*!53#3,*!,*+=#-!#$!*6;8$)**!/*6+./!5$,!#2*-*!#$$8-!

• I29-!0988!2+?*!96;89=+#9$.-!5$,!;*,-$.+8!+./!;,$5*--9$.+8!.*#0$,%-@!!H.*!9.!59?*!*6;8$)**-!bPPde!1*89*?*!#2*!.*D#!4*.*,+#9$.!$5!9..$?+#9$.!0988!=$6*!5,$6!=$6;+.9*-!*D;+./9.4!#2*9,!1$,/*,-!#$!*.=$3,+4*!6$,*!=,$--F9./3-#,)!=$88+1$,+#9$.@!!".!#29-!=$.#*D#B!;*,-$.+8!+./!;,$5*--9$.+8!.*#0$,%-!0988!1*=$6*!*?*.!6$,*!96;$,#+.#!+./!9.5$,6+8!.*#0$,%-B!#*=2.9=+88)!9./*;*./*.#!$5!5$,6+8!6+.+4*6*.#!89.*-B!0988!5$,6!9.-9/*!=$6;+.9*-@!!!

• '7Q):,%&;'+:,5);++*'%#+'+@3+&"$&0'3-+$#'>*+')<'+T2)55%A)#%3$)&'&+3=)#?*'3)'"+9+5),'

3-+$#'#+5%3$)&*-$,*'%&"'+@2-%&0+*.'&)3')&5;'=$3-'2)55+%0>+*'A>3'%5*)'=$3-'3-+'

+:,5);++*')<'"$<<+#+&3'2):,%&$+*.',#)<+**$)&%5*'<#):':%&;'"$<<+#+&3'*+23)#*.'

+">2%3)#*'%&"'#+*+%#2-+#*BC'C!W*.9-!Z##942$55*,B!I*=2.$;$89-!".-#9#3#*!bG,+.=*e!• N+??)!=$6;+.9*-!0988!=$.#9.3*!#$!-**!#2*!?+83*!$5!*D;8$9#9.4!-#+55>-!89.%*/F3;!89?*-!

+./!.*#0$,%-B!1$#2!=$,;$,+#*!+./!;*,-$.+8!C!#2*-*!.*#0$,%-!0988!1*!?+83*/!+./!5$-#*,*/!

• I2*!Q3+89#)!$5!;*,-$.+8!.*#0$,%-!0988!1*=$6*!+.!+--*#B!09#2!*6;8$)*,-!96;,*--*/!1)!J3-#!2$0!6+.)!b+./!2$0!6+.)!96;$,#+.#e!;*$;8*!+.!+;;89=+.#!%.$0-B!1)!#2*!,9=2.*--!$5!#2*!9.#*,+=#9$.!09#2!#2*6@!N$=9+8!=+;9#+8!1*=$6*-!8+1$3,!6+,%*#!=+;9#+8@!!

• 7J&')#"+#'3)'<%2$5$3%3+'*)2$)T,#)<+**$)&%5'#%,,#)2-+:+&3*.'%<<$&$3;':+%*>#$&0'*)<3=%#+'

2%&':)&$3)#'3-+'2)&&+23$)&*'3-%3'%#+':%"+'A+3=++&',+),5+')&'3-+'=+AB''E-$*'3;,+')<'

*)<3=%#+'3-%3'3#%2+*'7->:%&'2-%$&*C'=$55'*))&'A+2):+'$&"$*,+&*%A5+'%*'%'3))5'<)#'

:%&%0$&0'#+5%3$)&*-$,*'A+3=++&'$&"$9$">%5*BCO'

'

$NFO )$B<:3$=<EP;$D<E$

H3,!59./9.4!#2+#!?70$2:HH0;?$:A90A?:/0;[email protected];$?.$9.10$LD$>:?7$930<?:/0$:=0<;$<30$B:A<A9:<@$30><3=$VNOZWX$<A=$309.HA:?:.A$B.3$?70:3$<97:0/010A?;$VJ`ZW$:;$<$93L9:<@$.A0$B.3$

2 Denis Ettighoffer, Technopolis Institute (France)

17

2L;:A0;;0;F!".!5+=#B!'cd!$5!*6;8$)**-!0*!-3,?*)*/!-+)!#2*)!0$38/!+8,*+/)!1*!=$69.4!3;!09#2!6$,*!=,*+#9?*!9/*+-!5$,!#2*9,!*6;8$)*,-!95!#2*)!#2$342#!#2*)!0$38/!1*!,*0+,/*/!5$,!#2*6!b;+,#9=38+,8)!9.!M+;+.!F!'gde@!!!!!

!"#$%&F(&G*8#$9&#-9&$*+,3-.%.,-&9$.<*&+$*#%.<.%C&

[a7:97$.B$?70$B.@@.>:AH$=.$E.L$?7:AC$>.L@=$1<C0$E.L$1.30$930<?:/0$<?$>.3C\]$

!!\$,*!#2+.!+!Q3+,#*,!$5!,*-;$./*.#-!bPmde!1*89*?*!#2+#!9.!53#3,*B!-#+55!0988!1*!,*0+,/*/!9.!89.*!09#2!#2*!9/*+-!#2*)!=$.#,913#*@!!R$0*?*,B!$3,!,*-*+,=2!,*?*+8-!+!-*,9$3-!/9-=,*;+.=)!*6*,49.4!1*#0**.!*D9-#9.4!-)-#*6-!5$,!+&2)>#%0$&0'9..$?+#9$.!+./!#+=%#"$&0'-#+55!+==$,/9.48)!C!ggd!-+)!#2*9,!=$6;+.)!2+-!-)-#*6-!9.!;8+=*!#$!+88$0!5$,!#2*!=$.#,913#9$.!$5!9/*+-!b,9-9.4!#$!''d!9.!#2*!LN!+./!'&d!9.!7*,6+.)e_!13#!8*--!#2+.!#0$!9.!&(!b&hde!2+?*!1$.3-!-=2*6*-!#$!/9,*=#8)!,*0+,/!#2*!/*?*8$;6*.#!$5!9/*+-!b/,$;;9.4!#$!&'d!9.!#2*!L:!+./!G,+.=*B!&fd!9.!M+;+.e@!!T+,,$09.4!#29-!/9-=,*;+.=)!0988!1*!%*)!#$!3.8$=%9.4!#2*!9..$?+#9$.!;$#*.#9+8!9.!#2*!=$,;$,+#9$.!$5!#2*!53#3,*@!!"#!9-!+8-$!.$#*0$,#2)!#2+#!0298*!$.8)!P(d!$5!0$,%*,-!-+)!#2*9,!*6;8$)*,!2+-!+!-)-#*6!9.!;8+=*!#$!,*0+,/!=$88+1$,+#9$.B!m&d!2+?*!=$.#,913#*/!+.!9/*+B!,9-9.4!#$!c(d!9.!#2*!L:!+./!c&d!9.!#2*!LN@!!Z?*.!02*.!#2*,*!9-!.$!,*0+,/!$,!5$,6+89-*/!-#,3=#3,*!#$!,*=$4.9-*!=$.#,913#9$.B!*6;8$)**-!+,*!-#988!/*?*8$;9.4!9/*+-B!-2$09.4!#2+#!#2*,*!9-!+.!+;;*#9#*!#$!9..$?+#*@!!!!N+??)!=$6;+.9*-!+,*!+8,*+/)!1*49..9.4!#$!5+=*!#29-!=2+88*.4*!+./!*D;8$,*!$;#9$.-!5$,!9.=*.#9?9-9.4!-#+55!9..$?+#9$.@!!R.330H.$M.@<3$ME;?01;!9.!<+895$,.9+!,*+89-*/!6+.)!$5!9#-!-#+55!0*,*!#$$!-2)!#$!=$6*!5$,0+,/!09#2!9/*+-B!-$!1*4+.!,3..9.4!=$6;*#9#9$.-!#$!*.=$3,+4*!

18

=$.=*;#-!5$,!96;,$?9.4!#2*!13-9.*--@!!O-!0*88!+-!$55*,9.4!+!o'((!;,9a*!5$,!#2*!09..9.4!9/*+B!#2*!=$6;+.)!+8-$!*.-3,*-!#2*!1*-#!9/*+-!+,*!?9-918)!96;8*6*.#*/B!/*6$.-#,+#9.4!+!=$669#6*.#!#$!.3,#3,9.4!#+8*.#@!!G..H@0!$55*,-!9#-!*.49.**,-!kP(d!#96*lB!+!-=2*6*!02*,*1)!-#+55!/*?$#*!P(d!$5!#2*9,!,*-$3,=*-!#$!=,*+#9?*!;,$J*=#-!#2*)!5**8!;+--9$.+#*!+1$3#!- 9#-!29428)!-3==*--538!7$$48*!T*0-!5*+#3,*!0+-!5+6$3-8)!9.?*.#*/!1)!+!0$,%*,!/3,9.4!P(d!#96*@!!aFb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email protected]$<A=$/:3?L<@$>.3C;D<90;$?.$<??3<9?$?70$23:H7?0;?$>.3CB.390!C!5,$6!#29-B!0*!4*#!+!-*.-*!$5!J3-#!2$0!96;$,#+.#!.*0!#*=2.$8$49*-!+,*V!.$#!$.8)!/$!#2*)!+88$0!*6;8$)**-!#$!9..$?+#*!+./!=$6*!3;!09#2!#2*!1*-#!9/*+-_!#2*)!+8-$!*.+18*!=$,;$,+#9$.-!#$!+##,+=#!+./!%**;!#2*!1*-#!0$,%5$,=*@!

!"#$%&H(&)*+"-,1,3C&8.11&4$,<.9*&#&:#I,$&9$#8&7,$&2J.11*9&8,$J*$2&.-&%"*&70%0$*&

[*A$?70$BL?L30$9.1D<A:0;$>:@@$7</0$?.$.BB03$?70$@<?0;[email protected]$<A=$<$9.@@<2.3<?:/0$>.3C;D<90$:B$?70E$><A?$?.$<??3<9?$?70$20;?$<A=$23:H7?0;?$>.3CB.390]$$$

$$$$$$$$$$

!"

#!"

$!"

%!"

&!"

'!"

(!"

)!"

*!"

+!"

#!!"

,-./0 12 134 56/789 :96;/7< =/>/7

4?699 [email protected]?0<

19

!"

#!"

$!"

%!"

&!"

'!"

(!"

)!"

*!"

+!"

#!!"

,-./0 12 134 56/789 :96;/7< =/>/7

[email protected]@;-69@9;>0-<96D@EF00@-AA96@@A09GFH09@[email protected]@ AF.@[email protected]@>9->09LD@ 0FA9D.<09D ?@/;@;-69@9AAF8F97.@EK97@?@E-6I@69;-.90<

$$$$$$

*1D@:9<?:.A;$B.3$2L;:A0;;0;$:A$?70$=09:;:/0$=09<=0$!

• O-!#2*!=$.#,913#9$.!=38#3,*!4,$0-B!13-9.*--*-!0988!2+?*!#$!=$.-9/*,!,*0+,/!+./!,*63.*,+#9$.!6$/*8-!5$,!9/*+-!4*.*,+#9$.B!9.!$,/*,!#$!2+,.*--!#2*9,!9..$?+#9$.!;$#*.#9+8!!

• [,$?9/9.4!#2*!8+#*-#!#*=2.$8$4)!0988!1*=$6*!+.!96;$,#+.#!;+,#!$5!+##,+=#9.4!+./!,*#+9.9.4!+.!9..$?+#9?*!+./!9/*+-F/,9?*.!0$,%5$,=*!

• <$,;$,+#9$.-!0988!.**/!#$!59./!=,*+#9?*!0+)-!#$!4*.*,+#*!+./!*.=$3,+4*!9/*+-!5,$6!#2*9,!0$,%5$,=*'

$NFQ *AA./<?:[email protected]<?:.A$

I2*!234*!4,$0#2!9.!#*8*0$,%9.4!2+-!1**.!0*88F/$=36*.#*/!9.!,*=*.#!)*+,-!+./!+88!$5!$3,!*D;*,#-!$1-*,?*/!#2+#!02*,*!)$3!0$,%!2+-!1*=$6*!63=2!8*--!96;$,#+.#!#2+.!#2*!0$,%!)$3!/$@ 7BBB,-;*$2%5'5)2%3$)&'$*'$&2#+%*$&05;'$##+5+9%&3B''I+),5+'=)#?'+9+#;=-+#+BBBC'T'W,!M9,$!:$%3,)$B!:*9$!L.9?*,-9#)!bM+;+.e!'76:,5);+#*'=$55'-%9+'3)'%A%&")&'3-+'$"+%'3-%3',-;*$2%5',#+*+&2+')<'%&'+:,5);++'$*'$&"$2%3$9+'

)<'3-+$#',+#<)#:%&2+BC'C!\+,#9.!N;98%*,B!A*,#*8-6+..!N#95#3.4!b7*,6+.)e <3,,*.#8)!P(d!$5!*6;8$)**-!+4,**!#2+#!#2*9,!*6;8$)*,-!*.=$3,+4*!#2*6!#$!0$,%!,*6$#*8)B!,9-9.4!#$!+!Q3+,#*,!9.!#2*!L:!+./!+!#29,/!9.!#2*!LNO@!!R$0*?*,B!9.!G,+.=*B!7*,6+.)!+./!M+;+.!#2*!5943,*!,*6+9.-!+#!8*--!#2+.!&'d@!!]*#!+86$-#!m(d!$5!#2*!RS!6+.+4*,-!0*!-;$%*!#$!1*89*?*!#2+#!$55*,9.4!6$,*!58*D918*!2$3,-!0$38/!2+?*!+!;$-9#9?*!96;+=#!$.!-#+55!;,$/3=#9?9#)@!!!!Y$$%9.4!+2*+/B!$.8)!+!#29,/!$5!,*-;$./*.#-!5$,*-**!+!53#3,*!02*,*!$.8)!?*,)!5*0!0$,%*,-!+,*!$559=*F1+-*/!b2942*-#!9.!G,+.=*!+./!#2*!LNe@!!!!!

!"#$%&'K(&>:41,C**2&#-%.+.4#%*&#&71*A./1*&70%0$*&!!

20

!!!!!!!!E298*!0*!/$!.$#!1*89*?*!#2*,*!0988!*?*,!=$6*!+!#96*!02*.!4$9.4!#$!#2*!$559=*!1*=$6*-!$1-$8*#*B!#2*,*!+,*!9./9=+#9$.-!#2+#!02*,*!)$3!0$,%!0988!1*=$6*!+!63=2!6$,*!5839/!=$.=*;#B!8*--!=*.#,*/!+,$3./!$.*!$559=*!+./!6$,*!5$=3-*/!$.!5$-#*,9.4!;,$/3=#9?9#)!+./!;,$?9/9.4!+!1+8+.=*!5$,!-#+55@!! I29-!1+8+.=*!0988!=$6*!9.#$!-#+,%!5$=3-!+-!0*!+;;,$+=2!P(P(B!09#2!234*!96;$,#+.=*!;8+=*/!$.!#2*[email protected];$?.$D3./:=0$2.LA=<3:0;$<A=$@:1:?<?:.A;$?.$D3.?09?$;?<BB$B3.1$?70$c<@><E;$.AP$9L@?L30F!!gKd!$5!0$,%*,-!+8,*+/)!-+)!#2*)!0$,%!8$.4*,!2$3,-!02*.!0$,%9.4!,*6$#*8)!+./!+!53,#2*,!g(d!*D;*=#!#2*!1$3./+,9*-!1*#0**.!0$,%!+./!895*!#$!1*=$6*!6$,*!183,,*/@!!I29-!=38#3,*!0988!1*=$6*!3.-3-#+9.+18*!+./!6+.+49.4!9#!0988!1*=$6*!+!;,9$,9#)!5$,!$,4+.9-+#9$.-B!5$,!4$?*,.6*.#-!+./!5$,!9./9?9/3+8!*6;8$)**-@!!E*!+8-$!+.#9=9;+#*!#2*!9.#,$/3=#9$.!$5!6$,*!;*,-$.+89-*/B!=$.#*D#3+89-*/!;,9$,9#9-+#9$.!#$$8-!#$!2*8;!-#+55!6+.+4*!#2*9,!0$,%8$+/-!6$,*!*55*=#9?*8)@! I2*,*!0988!1*!+!.361*,!$5!5+=#$,-!+#!;8+)!9.!#2*!58*D918*!53#3,*!#2+#!$,4+.9-+#9$.-!0988!.**/!#$!1*!+0+,*!$5V!;$89#9=+88)B!=$6;+.9*-!0988!1*!9.=,*+-9.48)!*D;*=#*/!#$!$55*,!58*D918*!0$,%9.4!$;#9$.-!5$,!;+,*.#-_!#2*!#,3-#!#2+#!*6;8$)*,-!;3#!9.!#2*9,!-#+55!0988!1*=$6*!+!%*)!6$#9?+#$,!9.!+##,+=#9.4!+./!,*#+9.9.4!#2*!1,942#*-#B!1*-#!0$,%5$,=*_!+./!#*=2.$8$4)!0988!;8+)!+!234*!,$8*!9.!+88$09.4!58*D918*!0$,%9.4!$;#9$.-@!!I2*,*!+,*!+8-$!+!0*+8#2!$5!*D#*,.+8U!-$=9$F;$89#9=+8!5+=#$,-!#2+#!0988!#*-#!+!=$,;$,+#9$.>-!+1989#)!#$!6+9.#+9.!+!5388)!53.=#9$.9.4!0$,%5$,=*!9.!#2*!6$-#!#*-#9.4!=9,=36-#+.=*-!F!#,+.-;$,#!-#,9%*-B!*D#,*6*!0*+#2*,B!9.=,*+-9.4!=$.4*-#9$.!b+./!,*8+#*/!=2+,4*-e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

21

Y$$%9.4!+#!#2*!1944*,!;9=#3,*B!6+.)!$5!#2*!*D;*,#-!0*!-;$%*!#$!;,*/9=#!#2*!*6*,4*.=*!$5!*.#9,*8)!.*0!13-9.*--!6$/*8-!9.!#2*!53#3,*!F!6$/38+,9-*/B!/*=*.#,+89-*/!=$F*.#*,;,9-*-!029=2!2+?*!+1+./$.*/!#,+/9#9$.+8!$,4+.9-+#9$.+8!6*#2$/-!9.!5+?$3,!$5!8$$-*,B!8*--!5$,6+89-*/!13#!9.59.9#*8)!6$,*!58*D918*!-#,3=#3,*-@!!!![*#*!A*=%6+.B!O,4$..*!T+#9$.+8!Y+1$,+#$,)!bLNOe!*D;8$,*-!J3-#!$.*!-=*.+,9$V!78+'-%9+',+),5+'&)='=-)'-%9+'2-)*+&'3)'5$9+'

$&'/$&&+*)3%')#'Y+='/+@$2)'%&"'3+5+2)::>3+'A+2%>*+'3-%3H*'%'N>%5$3;')<'5$<+'$**>+B''E-+;'

")&H3'=%&3'3)'5$9+'&+2+**%#$5;'$&'3-+'A$0'2$3;BBB3-+;'=%&3'%'"$<<+#+&3'5$<+B''Y)3'%55'=)#?+#*'2%&'

")'3-%3BBB%'2#$3$2%5':%**'$*'&++"+"'$&'%'*$&05+',5%2+B''Z>3'$3'")+*':+%&'3-%3'%'3+%:')<'[TVP'

,+),5+'2)>5"'"+2$"+BBB3-%3'3-+;'=%&3'3)'5$9+'$&'/)&3%&%BC'

!*1D@:9<?:.A;$B.3$2L;:A0;;0;$:A$?70$=09:;:/0$=09<=0\$

$• I*=2.$8$4)!9-!+#!#2*!5$,*5,$.#!$5!#2*!/*6+--959=+#9$.!/,9?*!F!#2*!,+5#!$5!;*,-$.+8!

=$663.9=+#9$.!#*=2.$8$49*-!-3=2!+-!A8+=%1*,,9*-!+./![WO-!9-!$.8)!+!-6+88!;+,#!$5!#29-!-#$,)@!!Z.#9,*!.*#0$,%-!=+.!1*!6+/*!+?+98+18*!#$!0$,%*,-!#2+.%-!#$!#2*!4,$0#2!$5!=8$3/!=$6;3#9.4!#*=2.$8$49*-@!![2)-9=+8!$559=*-!=+.!49?*!0+)!#$!-+#*889#*!231-!$,!*?*.!?9,#3+8!0$,%!-;+=*-@!![,$J*=#-!=+.!1*!-;89#!1*#0**.!?+,9$3-!-;*=9+89-*/!#*+6-!9.!/955*,*.#!;+,#-!$5!#2*!0$,8/!

• ZD;*=#!#$!-**!#2*!4,$0#2!$5!*.#9,*8)!.*0!6+.+4*6*.#!,$8*-!/*/9=+#*/!#$!2+./89.4!#2*!6$?*!#$!,*6$#*!0$,%9.4!+./!$?*,-**9.4!?9,#3+8!0$,%5$,=*-!

• E298*!#2*,*!0988!1*!-;+=*!5$,!*.2+.=*/!58*D91989#)!9.!#2*!53#3,*B!0*!/$!.$#!+.#9=9;+#*!#2*!/*+#2!$5!#2*!#,+/9#9$.+8!$559=*!-#,3=#3,*@!!O-!W,!<+,-#*.!NX,*.-*.!-+)-V!kI5%2+'*3$55':%33+#*B''Y)':%33+#'-)=':>2-'3+2-&)5)0;';)>'-%9+BBB$3'*3$55':%33+#*'=-+#+';)>'%#+BC!

'

$

OF !70$%.3D.3<?:.A$4F5$".!#29-!-*=#9$.!$5!#2*!,*;$,#B!0*!;+9.#!+!;9=#3,*!$5!#2*!=$,;$,+#9$.!9.!P(P(_!=,*+#*!;*.!;$,#,+9#-!5$,!+!/+)!9.!#2*!895*!$5!#2*!*6;8$)**B!<"HB!RS!/9,*=#$,_!+./!#+%*!+!8$$%!+#!-$6*!53#3,*!J$1!#9#8*-!#2+#!6+)!0*88!5$,6!#2*!1+=%1$.*!$5!#2*!*.#*,;,9-*!9.!#2*!.*D#!/*=+/*@!

$)$8<E$:A$?70$b:B0T$!L0;=<E$44$I<397X$4545$$

OF6 R0A$S.A0;[email protected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

22

$5!-#+55!1+-*/!9.!/955*,*.#!#96*!a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f@((!2*!;9=%-!3;!#2*!%9/-!5,$6!-=2$$8B!-;*./-!+!=$3;8*!$5!2$3,-!09#2!#2*6!+./!8$4-!1+=%!$.!#$!#2*!.*#0$,%!5,$6!2$6*!5$,!+!6**#9.4!09#2!LN!=$88*+43*-!#$!1,+9.-#$,6!9/*+-!5$,!+!.*0!-*,?9=*!#2*!=$6;+.)!9-!;8+..9.4@!!I2*9,!Z/9#$,!8$4-!9.!#$!0+#=2!#2*!58$0!$5!9/*+-B!#+%*!.$#*-!+./!+--*--!#2*!1$.3-!5$,!#2*!9/*+-!#2*)!4*.*,+#*@!!O#!PK@((B!A*.!2+-!+.!$.89.*!9.-#+.#!=$.?*,-+#9$.!09#2!+!N*=$./+,)!<+,**,!S*=,39#*,!#$!*D;8$,*!$;#9$.-!5$,!+!=+,**,!2*!9-!=$.-9/*,9.4!9.!6*/9+B!#2*.!2*+/-!$55!#$!1*/@!

$OF4 M<?.$U0:C.T$"L1<A$ME;?01;$8:309?.3$VD30/:.L;@E$"'$I<A<H03W$$

:*9%$!0+-!+--*--*/!5$,!#2*!,$8*!6$-#!-39#*/!#$!2*,!-%988-!+#!#2*!+4*!$5!&f!1)!#2*!0*+8#2!6+.+4*6*.#!=$.-38#+.=)!-2*!0$,%-!5$,!+./!$55*,*/!+!,$8*!1*5$,*!-2*!8*5#!-=2$$8@!!R*,!3.9?*,-9#)!/*4,**!0+-!#+98$,*/!#$!6**#!#2*!,*Q39,*6*.#-!$5!2*,!,$8*B!+./!-9.=*!2*,!+,,9?+8!9.!P(&f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m+6!09#2!+!?9,#3+8!6**#9.4!5$,!+.!$3#-$3,=9.4!;,$J*=#!-2*>-!0$,%9.4!$.!09#2!+!5,**8+.=*!#*+6!9.!"./9+B!=$./3=#*/!$.!2*,!6$198*!;2$.*!$.!2*,!0+)!#$!#2*!$559=*@!!I2*)!Q39=%8)!+4,**!$1J*=#9?*-!+./!:*9%$!+,,+.4*-!5$,!2*,!#*=2.$8$4)!#*+6!#$!+,,+.4*!+88!#2*!+;;,$;,9+#*!?9,#3+8!,*-$3,=*-!#$!1*49.!#2*!;,$J*=#@!

23

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

$OFJ ,3<A9.:;$$8LB.L3T$*AA./<?:.A$(30;:=0A?$VB.3103@E$%*&W$

Z942#!)*+,-!+4$!02*.!2*!,*+=2*/!#2*!+4*!$5!g'B!G,+.=$9-!/*=9/*/!#$!,*8$$%!+#!29-!<"H!J$1!#9#8*B!029=2!2*!5*8#!;94*$.F2$8*/!296!+-!+!#*=2.$8$49-#!+./!.$#!63=2!*8-*@!!N$!2*!/*?9-*/!#2*!,$8*!$5!"..$?+#9$.![,*-9/*.#!029=2!2*!5**8-!=+;#3,*-!63=2!6$,*!$5!#2*!-;9,9#!$5!02+#!2*!/$*-!+./!+8-$!-*./-!+!=8*+,!6*--+4*!#$!#2*!,*-#!$5!#2*!-#+55!C!9..$?+#9$.!9-!+!=,3=9+8!;+,#!$5!02+#!#29-!=$6;+.)!/$*-@!!!I96*-!2+?*!=2+.4*/!-9.=*!2*!-#+,#*/!+#!#2*!6*/9+!+4*.=)!9.!&hh(@!!A+=%!#2*.B!2*!0+-!=$.-#+.#8)!2+?9.4!#$!-$,#!$3#!9--3*-!09#2!#2*!=83.%)B!,*-#,9=#9?*!+./!.+,,$08)!5$=3-*/!#*=2.$8$4)!+?+98+18*@!!A3#!#2*!)*+,!P(&&!;,$?*/!#$!1*!+!#3,.9.4!;$9.#!C!.*0!-*,?9=*-!1*4+.!#$!+88$0!5$,!63=2!1,$+/*,!13-9.*--!-=$;*!+./!2*!0+-!+18*!#$!#3,.!29-!5$=3-!#$!+!63=2!09/*,!,+.4*!$5!,*-;$.-91989#9*-@!!!!R*!1*49.-!#2*!/+)!+#!(h@((!b$8/!2+19#-!/9*!2+,/e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m@((!09#2!#2*!".5$,6+#9$.!+./!"..$?+#9$.!#*+6-B!02$!2+?*!1**.!+--*--9.4!#2*!8+#*-#!4+/4*#-!+./!/*?9=*-!$.!#2*!6+,%*#!#$!*D;8$,*!02*#2*,!#2*)!0$38/!1*!-39#+18*!5$,!29-!=$6;+.)@!$

OFN S.2$3.@0;$.B$?70$BL?L30$

24

E298*!#2*!6+J$,9#)!$5!J$1!#9#8*-!0988!,*6+9.!#2*!-+6*B!0*!5$,*-**!+!0*+8#2!$5!$;;$,#3.9#)!5$,!.*0!,$8*-!+./!#9#8*-!#$!-;,9.4!3;!9.!#2*!=$,;$,+#9$.!$5!#2*!53#3,*@!!R*,*!+,*!-$6*!$5!#2*6V!!!70$%30<?:/:?E$_$*=0<;$I<A<H010A?$80D<3?10A?$$

!*!b#$ '#M(&+M*R*b*!d$<29*5!"/*+-!H559=*,$ S*-;$.-918*!5$,!5$-#*,9.4!+./!*.=$3,+49.4!.*0!9/*+-@!!O-!9#!

9-!#2*-*!9/*+-!#2+#!%**;!#2*!=$6;+.)!5,*-2B!*D=9#9.4!+./!=$6;*#9#9?*B!#29-!9-!+!%*)!,$8*!9.!#2*!=$,;$,+#9$.!$5!#2*!53#3,*!+./!0988!1*!29428)!-$342#!+5#*,!1)!=,*+#9?*!#);*-@!

"/*+-!Z/9#$,$ \+.+4*6*.#!,$8*!#$!*/9#!+./!,*438+#*!#2*!58$0!$5!9/*+-!5,$6!+=,$--!#2*!=$6;+.)B!5,$6!+!4,+--,$$#-!8*?*8!3;@!![,*?9$3-8)!<,*+#9?*!W9,*=#$,!$,!-3=2B!#29-!,$8*!.$0!+=%.$08*/4*-!#2*!6$?*!#$!4,+--,$$#-!9..$?+#9$.!+./!#+%*-!,*-;$.-91989#)!5$,!*/9#9.4B!,+#2*,!#2+.!4*.*,+#9.4!9/*+-@!

<,*+#9?*!O,=29?9-#$ I+-%*/!09#2!6+9.#+9.9.4!+!%.$08*/4*!1+.%!$5!9/*+-!4*.*,+#*/!+=,$--!#2*!=$6;+.)!5$,!53#3,*!3-*@!!<$88+1$,+#9?*!.*#0$,%-!=,*+#*!+!58$0!$5!9..$?+#9$.!-$!9#!9-!=,3=9+8!#$!-#$,*!+88!#2$-*!9/*+-!+./!+==*--!#2*6!#$!6**#!#2*!3.9Q3*!,*Q39,*6*.#-!$5!*+=2!;,$J*=#!

<$88+1$,+#9$.!H559=*,$ S*-;$.-918*!5$,!#2*!/*?*8$;6*.#!+./!6+9.#*.+.=*!$5!=$88+1$,+#9?*!.*#0$,%-@!!E$,%9.4!=8$-*8)!09#2!#2*!<29*5!"/*+-!H559=*,!+./!#2*!"I!#*+6B!#29-!,$8*!,*Q39,*-!+!-#,$.4!3./*,-#+./9.4!$5!2$0!9..$?+#9$.!9-!4*.*,+#*/!?9+!=$88+1$,+#9$.!+./!029=2!-)-#*6-!#$!96;8*6*.#!!

!70$"L1<A$ME;?01;$80D<3?10A?$V9.12:A0=$>:?7$?70$*AB.31<?:.A$<A=$*AA./<?:.A$80D<3?10A?W$

!*!b#$ '#M(&+M*R*b*!d$R36+.!N)-#*6-!W9,*=#$,$ N#,+//89.4!#2*!;,*?9$3-8)!#9#8*/!RS!+./!"I!/*;+,#6*.#-B!#2*!

RNW!9-!9.!=2+,4*!$5!-*+68*--8)!9.#*4,+#9.4!#2*!236+.F=$6;3#*,!9.#*,+=#9$.!;,$=*--@!!O.!3./*,-#+./9.4!$5!#2*!236+.!*8*6*.#!1*29./!#2*!#*=2.$8$4)!0988!1*!=,3=9+8!

E$,%F895*!A+8+.=*!\+.+4*,$ I+-%*/!09#2!*.-3,9.4!+!;$-9#9?*!0$,%F895*!1+8+.=*!5$,!+88!*6;8$)**-!b9.F2$3-*B!,*6$#*!0$,%9.4!+./!5,**8+.=*e@!!N2+,*-!,*-;$.-91989#)!09#2!*6;8$)**-!#$!*.-3,*!#2*)!6+9.#+9.!+!2*+8#2)!+##9#3/*!#$!0$,%!+./!-09#=2!$55!02*.!.$#!0$,%9.4!

9<38#3,9-#$ E9#2!0$,%*,-!-;,*+/!+=,$--!/955*,*.#!8$=+#9$.-B!=$,;$,+#*!=38#3,*!0988!*!6$,*!96;$,#+.#!#2+.!*?*,!C!#2*!9<38#3,9-#!9-!,*-;$.-918*!5$,!.*#0$,%9.4!+=,$--!*?*,)!*8*6*.#!$5!895*V!

25

6+9.#+9.9.4!0*881*9.4B!*.J$)6*.#!+./!4$$/!0988B!0298*!*.-3,9.4!-*+68*--!0$,%!+./!;*,-$.+8!.*#0$,%-!!

I+8*.#!\+.+4*6*.#!N#,+#*49-#$ N$3,=9.4!#2*!1*-#!;*$;8*!5$,!*+=2!;,$J*=#!0988!1*!%*)!#$!=$,;$,+#*!-3==*--!9.!#2*!53#3,*@!!E9#2!,*6$#*U?9,#3+8!#*+6-!+./!*F8+.=*,-!;9=%9.4!3;!*8*6*.#-!$5!;,$J*=#!0$,%B!#2*!I\N!0988!2+?*!59.*8)!2$.*/!-%988-!#$!;9=%!#2*!,942#!;*$;8*!5$,!#2*!,942#!J$1@!

$$$$!70$*AB.31<?:.A$<A=$*AA./<?:.A$80D<3?10A?$

!*!b#$ '#M(&+M*R*b*!d$<8$3/!N*=3,9#)!\+.+4*,$ E9#2!=$,;$,+#9$.-!6$?9.4!#2*9,!*.#9,*!0$,%8$+/!9.#$!#2*!

=8$3/B!-#+55!0988!1*!,*Q39,*/!#$!6+9.#+9.!-+5*#)!+./!-*=3,9#)!-)-#*6-@!!".!+//9#9$.B!#29-!,$8*!0988!1*!,*-;$.-918*!5$,!$?*,-**9.4!#2*!9.#,$/3=#9$.!$5!.*0!0*1F1+-*/!#$$8-@!S*;$,#-!9.#$!<8$3/!W9,*=#$,B!1$+,/!/9,*=#$,!,$8*!

".5$,6+#9$.!G8$0-!W9,*=#$,$ E$,%9.4!=8$-*8)!09#2!#2*!<,*+#9?9#)!`!"/*+-!+./!R36+.!N)-#*6-!W*;+,#6*.#-!B!#29-!,$8*!*.-3,*-!+!-#*+/)!58$0!$5!9.5$,6+#9$.!+./!9..$?+#9$.!1*#0**.!-#+55B!.*#0$,%-B!=$88+1$,+#$,-!+./!*6;8$)*,-!!

"..$?+#9$.![,*-9/*.#$ R*+/!$5!#2*!/*;+,#6*.#@!!I2*!+6*./*/!J$1!#9#8*!,*58*=#-!#2*!.**/!5$,!+!-#,$.4!3./*,-#+./9.4!$5!=,*+#9?9#)!09#29.!#2*!09/*,!59*8/!$5!#*=2.$8$4)B!+./!#2*!0+)-!9.!029=2!#*=2.$8$4)!-2$38/!*.+18*!4,*+#*,!9..$?+#9$.!+./!=$88+1$,+#9$.!

$&?703$A0>$3.@0;$;.L390=$B3.1$0KD03?;$<A=$30;D.A=0A?;$

!*!b#$ '#M(&+M*R*b*!d$p9,#3+8!\+,%*#**,-K!$ k\+,%*#9.4!0988!1*!=$6;8*#*8)!9.#*,.+#9$.+89-*/!+-!+!

-;*=9+89-*/!;,$5*--9$.@!!L;!3.#98!.$0!9.!M+;+.B!0*!2+?*!,*5*,,*/!#$!9#!+-!営業!b+$0;))@@@8*#>-!-+)!5$,!#2*!-+%*!$5!+,436*.#!#2+#!9#!0+-!1+-9=+88)!+!=+-*!$5!=,*+#9.4!+!5,+6*0$,%!#$!-*88!#29.4-!09#29.!)$3,!$0.!=$3.#,)@!A3#!#2*!Q3*-#9$.!$5!2$0!63=2!)$3!=+.!-*88!#29.4-!9.!#2*!0$,8/!$5!#2*!9.#*,.*#q!$5!=$3,-*!)$3!.**/!+!/*89?*,)!-)-#*6B!13#!

3 Ref: Mr Shoichi Terayama, Nikkei Business, Japan

26

)$3!=+.!+,,+.4*!+88!$5!#2+#!$.89.*@!N$!5$,!#2*!-;*=9+89a*/!;,$5*--9$.-B!;+,#9=38+,8)!#2*!0$,8/!$5!6+,%*#9.4B!#2*,*!0$38/!1*!.$!.**/!#$!2+?*!#2*-*!,*-$3,=*-!9.!M+;+.!$,!9.!#2*!LNr#2*)!=$38/!9.-#*+/!*D9-#!?9,#3+88)B!$.89.*@l!

I2*!\38#9F<$,;$,+#9$.!E$,%*,g$

kH.*!9./9?9/3+8!=+.!1*8$.4!#$!+./!0$,%!5$,!638#9;8*!$,4+.9-+#9$.-B!1,9.49.4!+1$3#!#2*!19,#2!$5!.*0!J$1!=+#*4$,9*-@l!

I*8*#*+=29.4'U![*,-$.+8!Y$.4FW9-#+.=*!I*+=2*,f$

Z/3=+#$,!+./!"I!-;*=9+89-#B!2*8;9.4!-#+55!+/?+.=*!#$!.*0!8*?*8-!$5!+=29*?*6*.#!?9+!?9,#3+8!.*#0$,%-!

".#*,5+=*!6+.+4*,m! [,$?9/*-!+.!9.#*,5+=*!1*#0**.!#2*!=$,*!$,4+.9-+#9$.!+./!;*,9;2*,+8!-#+55!

"I!,*6$#*!6+9.#*.+.=*!-;*=9+89-#$

Z.-3,9.4!,*6$#*!#*=2.$8$4)!9-!6+9.#+9.*/!9.!,*+8!#96*!

N$=9+8!T*#0$,%9.4!ZD*=3#9?*U!\+,%*#*,$

S*-;$.-918*!5$,!6+9.#+9.9.4!#2*!=$6;+.)>-!-$=9+8!6*/9+!5**/-B!18$4-!*#=!

p9,#3+8!O/69.!O--9-#+.#!$

O!,$8*!/*-94.*/!#$!#,+.-8+#*!6$/*-!$5!0$,%9.4!5,$6!#2*!j$8/j!0+)!$5!/$9.4!#29.4-!#$!#2*!j.*0j!0+)!

R$6*!<$.-38#9.4!W$=#$,$ W$=#$,-!#,+9.*/!#$!=$.-38#!;+#9*.#-!9.!#2*9,!2$6*-!?9+!#2*!.*#!+./!+-%!=$88*+43*-!5$,!+/?9=*U-*=$./!$;9.9$.!?9,#3+88)!+./!9.!,*+8!#96*!

!

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

44 Dr Mayumi Hori, Hakuoh University, Japan 5 Denis Ettighoffer, Technopolis Institute, France 6 Professor Dietmar Harhoff, Germany 7 Charles-Henri Besseyre des Horts, France

27

I2*!=$6;+.9*-!#2+#!=$6*!#$!/$69.+#*!#2*!.*D#!#*.!)*+,-!$5!9..$?+#9$.!0988!1*!#2$-*!#2+#!+,*!*+,8)!#$!*61,+=*!#2*-*!.*0!#$$8-!+./!.*0!0+)-!$5!#29.%9.4!C!+./!#2$-*!#2+#!9/*.#95)!2$0!#$!6$#9?+#*!+./!,*0+,/!*6;8$)**-!02$!=$.#,913#*!9/*+-@!!!E2+#!9-!=8*+,!9-!#2+#!94.$,9.4!#2*!9/*+-!,*?$83#9$.!9-!5$$82+,/)@!!<$.-36*,-!C!+./!1)!*D#*.-9$.!*6;8$)**-!C!+,*!+#!#2*!?*,)!2*+,#!$5!#2*!9..$?+#9$.!/,9?*!+./!#2*)!+,*!;$0*,538@!!".!#2*!0$,/-!$5!Z,9%!s3+86+.!F!k"#>-!+!D0.D@0$=3:/0A!*=$.$6)B!-#3;9/l8@!!O,*!)$3!,*+/)!5$,!#2*!/*=9-9?*!/*=+/*i!!!

8 “It's the economy, stupid" was a phrase coined by strategist James Carville during Bill Clinton's successful 1992 US presidential campaign. It was adapted by Erik Qualman, author of ‘Socialnomics: How Social Media has changed the way we live and do business’ to describe the consumer-driven revolution enabled by modern technology and Web 2.0

google-decisive-decade-report-1 · 4 ! 4f [email protected]$...

Documents