gildenhard-zissos - procne - 2007

Upload: florencia-cattan

Post on 14-Apr-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    1/25

    Barbarian variations:Tereus, Procne and Philomela in Ovid(Met. 6.412-674) and Beyond

    Ingo GildenhardUniversity of [email protected]

    and Andrew ZissosUniversity of California, [email protected]

    Introduction: OvidsEschaton?At t p f Ctp Rmy The Last World - a novel with

    an Ovidian repertoryMxmu Mu Ctt, f t fOv x pty , t v, ty fc, yt t Bck S. A um c Rm tt N v t u Tm, Ctt tm t f ut t bcm f f. At t m tm, v by t p f

    Rmy Die letzte Welt. Mit einem Ovidischen Repertoire (N 988) ft

    pp t Die Andere Bibliothek, t by H Mu Ezb; ct fm tE tt f J. E. W (N Yk 990). T t pubc p t t v t, cy ttu pc: , .., t ctbut Lj (2003).

    Dictynna- 4 - 2007

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    2/25

    2 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    f mucpt f tMetamorphoses. F Ov, t v t, ucc V f, ct t pubc cpy f pc mtpc ft f pqu t Auutu bf t x.

    If, The Last World, Rm t p f mc tyt p v ymu ty ffct tt buuccy,t ppv f t cpt f t t t m tm-p Tm. Lct t m f , t t f, ft y f btt f t . T v ccCtt vtu t ty m f m cc cy. Atft Rmy ptt t z tt t pcu v-

    mt f Tm t fmt f Ov ty mt v cmt f m ft t t t pp ffct.2 Tu fft tv t m uu Ov ppc, Ctt bcm vuty cct t mytc tv f t pm puu.T qut f Ov pc by uc utv tm Pyt, N fm vt, t t- Ec, t -p-p pkp Fm bcm cy fz ut Ctt f b by t puv f cm-m . Oy cpt fft, t t f t bk, c Rmyvt t pcu k f cty, t tumup Ctt vtu ct t t m f Ov myt.3

    T ctyt f t mmt f vt c cut tt bbtv p f Ov t. Jut t pu Ctt bt p f v t mutc puzz p by t vu cdramatis personae, ccty t t ff f t tbutc Tu yfuct u, cy m tTu, Pc Pm p fMet. 6. I Rmy k- f t uy t mt um t f Ov pc, cctbcm ptcpt-bv m quc vv p, mut-

    t, ftc, cbm. Bf Ov t tub mt- b cpcuy by Attc Rm pyt;4

    2 Sm f t cct Ctt cut tzt f Ov myt (Lyc,t f, Ac, t f-mut v); t ttxtu yb uc D: Rmy f t mt fm Gmy, t u t Pu C ut pty

    Auctz ymptmtc f t v pv tv t.3 S Fum (994), t pxc vct f t fu t t f Ct

    ty (Dt, Jumt, Hv, H) t tt f k f umtt m.4 T bc mt f t Ov v pp t v b pt y H

    (f. 32 MW) pp v Hm (Od. 9.58-23, , v, t u mbuu:t Sct c. mt m ctc ut cct ftc). But t myt v-ty cv t cc p-Ov tcut t Spc Tereus, ty tt uvv ubtt fmt (ufuy yz by Ftzptck [200]). T myt ppu tRm tt : Accu Tereus(pbby m t m tt f t Spc py)m t v b t fvt f t t pubc (Ot [966], 377; cf. Cc.Att. 6.2.3 6.5.). S Cm (977) Ecl. 6.78 m y Czz (950-).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    3/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 3

    Ctt ct t t , pppty, mmt f ucty. T ftct ck m ut f u, pmpt c f tm- ()cu c u t pcb anagnorisis. Cttb t ut tt t f t pm t f t uvct, tt t ty cm f t txt k t cv fct cum tfct t v f bb m t. Wtct ty vt t mut my, Ctt z tt t yy t mt t pt t t pm, ccpt t ty c b tcpt t cp pt f tMetamorphoses cv tt c t qu cp tt

    Rmy Tm.5 I t y cft umt, Ctt tump t ymb f t ct f , ct by ut f c t t tty mpp ut by t txt.

    A Rmy cumt tu t t Metamorphoses, Cttcqut f mtty ff u t Ov pt, c v t ut pt tu t vtcpt f pm, fm f mmtty pct cut mm tmv txt.6 Yt t f The LastWorld tc t t ubty f mtptc ptct.

    W t ttxtu pas de deux t t tumpt sphragisf tMetamorphosesmy b ttcy ctt, t ct mtfy- ubtxt. Uk Ov pu, c tu t v (Met.5.875-6 super astra ferar), Rmy p t ct uttt ky but t t. Of t Ov myt ttmt v t Ctt t t ty, Rmy ptf t f uy tqu vy. T cc ut tt, Rmy v, t mt pfu ut f Ov k v fm c cut t t mt ffv f t-

    y ft. I The Last World, t v f xpcb butttu ut t b ty cttc tt t t t Ctt tt t bk f ty f ty; but t fct tt pc tm ctt up t vcu xpc f cptc vcpuc tub cu f pv k (t p-tt f) bbty.

    5 S t vy fThe Last World: O t Ctt t t mut ty cpt t yt cv ... H u t u b m b ft , tc y t yb. W tpp t ctc bt, t t ty u tv ck, Ctt mtm fu t yb t t t, , Here!t c f ut cm bck t m. F t vbt fm t bk fm m.

    6 Ov ccu k ftf :Met. 5.878-9 ore legar populi, perqueomnia saecula fama / (siquid habent veri vatum praesagia) vivam. F pcptv cu f Ovpu t mtty Hktz (998), 88-90.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    4/25

    4 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    Gv t v b ty , t ptmy mk. Aft , Rmy t mut t t f tMetamorphoses t bk pt f Ov Tristia Epistulae ex Ponto. T f- ccttc f t discors machinatt ut fm t fu fOv pc t x pty btt t, p buty tuctv p, -pv f m mmpmbty t p uff qut pt fm t fqutcc t tt v cmc bckp t t um pt.Sm , t, tt Rmy u tu t um menage trois f Tu t t ut f P t t ky t

    ut Ov ty mt. H pcyptc v cc tu t ppc f Tu vctm, tycttut cumt mmt f The Last World.

    It m ffcut t vk t k f fuct umt txp t pc f uc tub mt t Metamorphosestf. T pc pty t t ccttcy Ov qu-t f tt t, y, fu um tt Rmy ytmtcy xpu fm Ov pty. Ev t pf Tu, Pc Pm, mt m t -mtc

    t t c ubjct mtt, tytc pt f t c.7

    I ttt f Wt ttu, y Amy Rc pp, [Ov]fuc b t, yt v ftm ctc fu ptytub bcu f t y pp t t ufuy ccum-tc.8 Wt Sc Qut, Ov t ttyctc, ft u m ut t um t ptymy ff t t t f ttc ppty m ubjct f bt. Yt f f ctt fm b -mk f Ov ptc, tt t t v m ctt t cpt f txt.

    It t t tt ctc t t pbm, tv ft ctv pbt. TheLast World but f um-u ct t t f ty mt t tp tt cu Ct Ty Philomena et Progne, CucLegend of Good Women, G Confessio Amantis, Gc TheComplainte of Phylomene.9 Pyt ptcu v mbc tpt f tMetamorphoses my tb uc f pt.A t fct mut f c t Wt t k bck tt b f t u f Tu. Ov t pt, f t tfons

    7 S G Z (999), 64-70.8 Rc (992), 58; cf. S (994).9 Cuc: LGW7.58-64; G: Confessio Amantis5.555-6074. Ot y ctbu-

    t t t ptc tt cu Dt Purg. 9.3-5 Ptc pm Solo e pensoso.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    5/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 5

    et origo, t t cuc tbuty t ttc tt tt cctf, ft bv t, t t pfmc f um tc-t.0 Skp bv , but Sc, G C, mcty, Tmbk Wtbk S K (m t) vk Ov v f t Tu myt. Fm t pt f vf cpt, t pt f t Metamorphoses cqu ctypttu, mt f t Wt t t b f At mt t tm f vt t.2

    T pv tt t ty f cpt cc t Ov Tu,Pc Pm cc t t pc pc t ty t tv cmy f tMetamorphoses. It tt Ov cyxp t ty tmtc z f pm, f ut ,tub pbt t v f ptc tpy. T p- mk ft fm t m f (v) myt, c ct cb t t Oymp dramatis personae, t t f umptc, by fft ct, tt, cutu t t f ccy.3 T tt f c pcpt:T ft fm ty f t t ty f um py pc , t Gk mt my. It u cmpx ft c v cmpt y m p t mfct.4 T t tu mk, ptt ctc vc cumt c ut, pcfc t t vut f t cm ( Ov txtu uv) t pt tRm. I t fc fu f At cutu Tc bbty, t ctbut t t by uftt t f Gk cvz-t tt b tmtc cc f t Metamorphoses.5

    I t f, fcu fu tt ftu f Ov txttt v ttct t ttt f ubqut tt, but v yt t f

    fu ckmt ppct t scholarlyttu:6 ()

    0 T cc tuy Atu (938); m cty C (990) t ct-but Rm (99).

    Skp, Titus Andronicus, t Bt (993) (995); Sc, Thyestes, tSc (2003); C, Procne (427); Wtbk, The Love of the Nightingale (989); K,Cleansed(998).

    2 W t t xp t ty f cpt m t ubqut tc.3 T p p utvy t t v f Attc by upcf f

    my (6.422-3, cu fut b, . 8), t ft cct ttmt f um f t pm.

    4 Hub (ftcm). S fut Cy (989); F (992) (997); Gz Hub (2005).

    5 S G Z (2004).6 F t mtc pcp J (97), xv ( Vt Scftt

    [tt] uf tfft Dutu Ub), t uptcuz fc tKt Hmbu, mt ky Hmbu (965); my Mt (993).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    6/25

    6 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    fu f t; (2) ptc f pv; (3) ttc fvc; (4) tpy f cutu.

    1. Hell on earth

    T ft f fMet. 6 ctu t mt tm f t pv-u bk: putv ct tk by Oymp t t ybtcum. Mv tfm Ac (6.-45), Ap Dbv ptfy Nb (6.46-32), Lt tu t Lyc p-t t f (6.33-8); Ap k My (6.382-400).7 Aft

    mu tu ftu bf ccut f Pp (6.40-), t -tv um t Tu At, cty v yb tt. T tt pt f Bk 2 cyc fktisis, t cptc bt f Mv tpty t Acp tt pm cmptt t P fv pt f t cty. But t p tmytc , Ov mv f tm: pt-tctu, Tu t v v t cty fm bb v-.8 T fc t um ptc cc t ft tuptu m f Ov tv. Tu my tc bck t M, but t p t Oymp t , f t fttm tMetamorphoses, m cpcuu by t bc.9

    Ot v fc tk t pc. W t pt fcu um b tct t c t, Ov cu bt xpct mpct fc t t Fu t tv ttc, vt u ttpt t t f Tu, Pc, Pm fu f t. T ft ppc ptcu, c ccu t cyupcu cpt f t bt Tu Pc, pmmtc fc:

    non pub Iu,non Hymu t, non Gt ct;Eumenidestu fc fu pt,Eumenidestv tum, tctqu pfucubut bub tmqu cum t.hac avecuct Pc Tuqu, pthac aveut fct. tt t cct

    7 Sptct ttmt f t tv ttc cu Fy (993), 90-4 Ac; F Jm (2004) My.

    8 T vct f cfct bt utf bb my fm c t cuu; Ap. 3.4.8 mk At t Lbcu, k f Tb, t cc ft c t Tu.

    9 Ev Ov t f Tu v ptty tMet. 6.427 et genus a magno ducentemforte Gradivo mt m quvc t, .., Hy. Fab. 45.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    7/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 7

    Tc, qu p t mqu,quaquet t c P t tyquaquet tu Ity, ftm u vc:uqu tt utt! ...(Met. 6.428-38)

    T p, t t qu-tpc (cv by t pfEumenides, hac ave quaque, t pt by c, tccu m usque adeo latet utilitas!mk ff t pu fmt ctu t) c t p f ym.20 I ffct, Ov ct t pc tv fmt vct f t Eum,fu v f Hymu Ju pronuba.2 Rtt t tt, t t Fu v v cp, pv t cbt t bt f Ity.22 T tyzquc tu ff c vtmt f t um tu ttv pty tk: fm t vy b, t t ttc f t but t.

    I t t t Eum, t pc f t bubo ut tt but t bk Ov tv. T u f t t ptt c t t pvu bk, Pp

    tfm Acpu t bubo c ( y ) ttf t cumpt f t pmt. T fmut profanam avem(5.543-4) c t 6.43-2 profanus bubo (ctu byhac ave,hac ave 433-4); t ccu f t p pfu tb t Tu p:foedaque fit volucris, venturi nuntia luctus,/ ignavus bubo, dirum mortalibus omen (5.549-50). T bubo, b ttcm t b , , t t t t ct, c-ct t v um uff.23

    20 S N (93), 43-76.2 CttMet. 4.758-9 taedas Hymenaeus Amorque/praecutiunt(Pu Am)

    2.25 ecce canunt Hymenaeon (Ptu Hppm) tu bt vvt vc bf c tfcty ccu. T y utub u v c t xpcty p tMetamorphoses tt bt Ip (tu t m jut tm) It (9.796-7) c, v, t t ty f Opu Euyc, u ttHymu ub t b (0.-8).

    22 T pttpronubaf Ju yy t Metamorphoses, cu y c(9.762), Tpu, ck but t mmt m-x m f c-ut Ip, y. Gratiay ccu . F t t f m y Ov. Her. 2.7 pronuba Tisiphonet Kx (995), 33 tc t bck t

    Ju cu A t Lv, ct V.Aen. 7.39 Bellona manet te pronuba. F tpv f Gk ty, Sf (987); f t mptt t Rm pc vAct puut ftty f v, H (993), 90. Fut mt cct by F (2003),3-2 [S.] Oct. 23-4: illa, illa meis tristis Erinys/ thalamis Stygios praetulit ignes.

    23 S t ppc funereus bubo t 0.452-3 (jut bf My ct) Stygius bubo t 5.79 (C t); cf. V. Aen. 4.462 solaque culminibus feralicarmine bubo (t Sv. c.: solact u put ... f vm); Ibis223-4 sedit in

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    8/25

    8 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    Aft t xpct vct, t Fu ctu t t ub-mt fm. Tu tuut Tu ty At, m f f,b bu mt t tv.24 A f t m v,tuy, t ffty t t mtc f f v: Cup t tt vctm f; yt ty fu t t m f H.Tc ptcu t ccttc ccutmt f t Fu,25jut t mpcptb ftt f t m t fy p- t tctv mu p. A ttxtu cct tV Aeneid f Ov fmmty p v ubttt fc t k. Fm 6.465-6 (et nihil estquod non effreno captus amore / ausit, nec capiunt inclusas pectora flam-mas) t pp tt Am tk ct f Tu. But t p k bck t Amt cut t Act Aeneid7, tLt qu y uccumb t t Fuy t p: necdum animustoto percepit pectore flammam, y V t pt t -utpc (Aen. 7.356). By c t y t V ttxt,Ov ppp tc m t ut, mk ctt t vt fc t Tu bt b t t pf Am t U.

    T ptt f f ctmt vt t typcu f vc t Tu. If At t Fu ut pc u v f tc furor, Tc ty tk cvb Dyc vy. Pc t ut t cu t u t f Bccc ftvt:26

    Tmpu t qu c t ttc BccSt cb uu: nox conscia sacris.noctet Rp ttbu cut;

    nocteu t m qutbu tutufurialiaque accipit arma...cct p v tub cmtt uumterribilisPcfuriisque agitata doloris,Bcc, tu simulat...(Met. 6.587-96)

    adverso nocturnus culmine bubo, / funereoque graves edidit ore sonos: t m cu.24 Met. 6.455-7, 460, 466, 480, 490-3 t Kuf (997), 67.25 Met. 4.48-2 Tisiphone ... sumit ... facem; 508-9 tum face iactata per eundem saepius

    orbem / consequitur motis velociter ignibus ignes.26 T Bccc t Pc Bccc u pp t v ftu Accu v

    (Acc. f. 647 W t Dbv [993], 206), cu utmty v fm Spc. If , tOv ccptuzt f t mt ( pp tt f t tvfuct) u b t t v p f.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    9/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 9

    T Dy mu uqutby ptt tu m txtu cu f t u f ubu fm vc.I, Eup Bacchaeupp pt tc pm f t t uf, bv t tuz mu mmbmt f by mt.27 But t u Av f cy fm t yp-c-cu Pc. A m ptt mtc pcu Eup Medea, pymu t Pc t bt cc fftc vc t pbt pu t pctcc tt fctt ffc.28 Mv, tu Pc

    up m t c, Ov mk c tt Bccccty f, v, c, t v f pt, my cc tt , t v f ptc, ct t pc f fft tv fc: t Fu. T ctu tt utv tf, t mt nocte noctec t tp p tt t cpt.29 But t c uv tu t tf ctxt fAeneid7 tt v t pt m:

    H ub ququm ct xpt Ltumct t vt, ptuqu vc pum

    serpentis furiale malum ttmqu pt,tum v fxingentibus excita monstrismmm mfuritlymphatap ubm...qu tm v simulato numine Bacchimu t f mmqu fumvt, t tm f mtbu bt,qu tmum pt Tuc tqu mtueuhoe Bacchefm ...

    tm t v, t t fumm Act stimulis agit undique Bacchi.(Aen. 7.373-7, 385-9, 404-5)

    27 Cuy (997) ut tt Ov pv vb mcc f Eu. Bacch.8-20 Ity mt cymater! mater!t 6.640.

    28 S Nm (994), 37-8.29 T Fu t ffp f Nt (Met. 4.45-2 sorores / Nocte ... genitas, grave et

    implacabile numen; cf. Ac. Eum. 034 o; i [i, t F [968]) tcy quf t p v pt f mut tt u um b tk f cmp. Apppty, Ov, t t cuc juctu, f t cctbt tt f m. Cmmt Tu tfu pfmc c m ct tP Pm, t pt xcm:pro superi, quantum mortalia pectora caecae / noctis habent!(6.472-3) - c fc t t Hv t p t k tv cmfm H. A t t f t p, Tu c f y t , Ov yybv tantaque nox animi est(6.652).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    10/25

    0 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    W t v vk t Dyc fzy f t tc tt ct ty tu t tc cpt,30 t t fuy Act ct t Bccc utc ctvt. S tmut Amtt ct ut t f m. T mut f Dyc bvv m f bt I Atm tc u Met. 4 Pc tcky Met. 6.3 H kfuy Ov Pc tt Bccc u my b fm Bm cuf Pc furialia arma (6.59). T ftb Ov cm-mtt t tt p t Ov furialis u y fc tt Fu, tt t pt p v ppty uqu

    tfc t tfuror bacchantium.32 But t ttxtu mtt V Amt c ct m cmpx tt f ff. BtV Ov ( Ov v V) tk up pfu Attc ty, my t cft f Bccc fu, cmft tf uc fmut Bcct fm H, qut but t f cm p. T cft t tccu t pc cptc vc, uc ftc, ttu mu f c, t-mt ut, cbm, by v t t mt f t f c Dyu

    pp t tk pbty.33 T uvv tc cpt tt xpt cfut mt tty Eup Hecuba, py t c-cty t Tc.34

    A t tv p, Pc Pm bcm c-y mt t Fu. Oc ut, ty fm ut ttm t v cm cmmtt t t fmy y p-

    30 S .. Pc. 422-3 R2Flexanima tamquam lymphata aut Bacchi sacris / commota, cp Ctuu cpt f m t 64.254-5 (Quae tum alacres passim lymphata mente fure-bant / Euhoe bacchantes, euhoe capita inflectentes.) uy V m .

    3 Tp tvt Met. 4, c t t Bccc fzy f I Atm,ct tf m fm Ju: euhoe Bacche! sonat: Bacchi sub nomine Iuno / risit et hos usus

    praestet tibi dixit alumnus!(4.523-4). Imuc Ju pt m up t xmpf Dyu, t p tu ff ty f t cft f ty, pc, , tu- cfut tt ut muc Sv Lt pty. It t t fut mccf t I Atm p tt fc t mu f t Tu, Pc Pmt: 4.502 caecae oblivia mentis~ 6.472-3 quantum mortalia pectora caecae / noctis habent; 4.504aere cavo (t pt c Tp b pu t) ~ 6.645 cavis aenis(t pt c Pc b up Ity); 4.503 caedis amorem 506 furiale venenum ~ 6.657 sparsis furialecaede capillis; 4.57 bracchia tendentem (Lcu c ut t muu ft) ~ 6.639 ten-dentemque manus(Ity c ut t muu mt); 4.47 in facinus traherent Athamanta

    furores 52furibundus~ 6.480 ciboque furoris 595 furiisque agitata doloris.32 Bm (969-86) Met. 4.506.33 S Sc (988), pcy 24-5. Mm (995), 90 . 56. F t f t

    fu Gk ty, p. Acyu, Wt-Im (980), 206-9.34 Sc (988). I fct, Ov mf, cut t ft f Hcub bk 3,

    k Tu Pymt by u f t ptt Odrysius(6.490 3.554, t y tccuc t pm).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    11/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS

    czt f t Eum. T tfmt t Pmtumpt ppc bf t f Tu, tcy cfm mmz buty t t b f t p: sicut eratsparsis furiali caede capillis, / prosiluit(6.657-8). Tu vct f tky St (vipereasque ciet Stygia de valle sorores, 6.662) tfky c.35 Ov, cmpt m. Gv tt tt tuctu f tv ym ct t tptt vt vct ty ccu vct, t t pf Tu, Pc, Pm bcm mt k ymc c-bt f t p f t Eum.

    Fut vct f t bv, ft cmb t v ppt bt u vt t t tc tm f um mpv-c, fm t cutpt t t pvv fuc f t p minences grises. Tu, t t b f t t, t bttf Tc t z tt vt v b t mt tt ut upkb uff. I t c, ty cbt t f Tu Pc t bt f Ity t tkv tt . Lt , bt t pt (6.472-3) P (6.499) vkt p bv t fm cy cmmt t bt

    tt f m tt tt cct.36 But t mt tkpp b t Pm. Aft t p c f vc f ct cu tt mk t puttv cmc ct-t up Tu pumt:37

    tm c up cut, um vumut qu, put m mcum,qucumqu m p b

    v cu tb,mpb v t cc x mvb.

    35 I, cu u tt Tu my pt ct f vct pfm by Pm v tu, mumu t t k t (6.558 ipsa [sc. lingua]iacet terraeque tremens immurmurat atrae) ut vct f t m f t u.T mp fc by t u fater, tt pc fft t t tm: Bm (969-86) 3.63 t fut ttu. Lk, t ubqut m ttcmp t tu t t ttc t f bct k (Met. 6.559-60) tb cct t v f my. Sk t mt cvt ty ccutmt f tEy, Ov Fu ptcuy -: .. 4.454 deque suis atros pectebantcrinibus angues; 474-5 Tisiphone canos, ut erat, turbata capillos / movit et obstantes reiecit ab ore colu-bras; 49 nexaque vipereis distendens bracchia nodis; 495-6 inde duos mediis abrumpit crinibus angues /

    pestiferaque manu raptos immisit. S fut Rc (992), 64.36 S bv . 29.37 T futty f pp t t bv y ct t 6.525-6, Ov,

    t ytctc juct, Pm vb ptt u t p v t btvbut:frustra clamato saepe parente, / saepe sorore sua, magnis super omnia divis.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    12/25

    2 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    ut c t, t u uu t.

    (Met. 6.542-8)

    Wt Pm uff by t cp f tcy: tu t mpy t jutc f t , but t vy xtc. Fm pt f v, Tu ut tk pcyptc m: vy-t (omnia) t tk; but t v m t Tu pcbuty t c vctm. Pm tu bcm m uv f ; t vctm t jut f Tu, but f t uc cm c vy pc ft.38

    T bc f Oymp t tuut t p,but m tky t t t ccu. Ov cumtmtmp (6.667-73) u-tm t pct t tv cvt t t qut by y f t ptt, ttbut t pcfc uptu cy t bmytpc tt. I t ccut, t tfmt ttb-ut t pty t p t t py f P ut,f Tu muu t, v f t mtmp tv t mutu t (Sp. f. 58.9-0 Rt).39 Aptz,

    Pc t b t mt v Ity.40

    T uc c-c umt tc mpt Ov: deus ex machinapp t t u uc tt m pv. Tmtmp ft umtvt bt t v t umv, tu Pc fv mk by cm (6.669-70) v pty xpc ctt. Ay fc t t ft t, c ut (cu Spc) tpt Pc f , cpcuuy bt fm tv.4Ev b, Tu t t t cut ymc f p-

    ptu, um tty.

    42

    T fc t k tMetamorphoses38 A F (2003) [S.] Oct. 9-3 bv, t cy tt xt

    vu vtu typcy tc (pcy Eup) cmt, puc bycct uff bu jutc.

    39 Dv cmp ftu t Hy. Fab. 45; cf. Ap. 3.4.8.40 T pct Eup: cf. Mm (995), 20 ( t bc f deus ex

    machina t Hecuba): Eup t t t ty py; t mbtt, cfu , t f t ctty c tpy u vtuc, v m t m; t t f um cfu ubt, t y t mt t f v t k, t m f umt vyu t tt pt f t py.

    4 I fct Ov v pcfy c t bcm t t c t - ( mtt c t cfu t tt: Bm [969-86] c.).

    42 T tfmt c tt f Ac, k t -m t-mt ft u mtmp ty u-p (Met. 6.36 atque ita vivequidem, pende tamen, inproba dixit [sc. Minerva]; cf. 6.667-8 corpora Cecropidum pennis pendere

    putares: / pendebant pennis!).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    13/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 3

    v t c, but t utv mp f ut (neque adhuc de pectore caedis / excessere notae, signa-taque sanguine pluma est, 6.669-70) vc (prominet immodicumpraelonga cuspide rostrum, 6.673). T f cupt cmpt tfm xtmt by pt t pmtu t f t tckP:

    Hc t m qu xtm cttmp Tt P mt umb.

    (Met. 6.675-6)

    T btt f t t tk umt, ff cty ut f b vt v um ff.43I t t t uptu v f by t Fu, t tcmc by mp cuty f cm pumt tut tb pc f cc. T t f t U uc f tv y f pcu pty t VAct, uby t ft fu f pu v Rm ttu.44 Butt t Ov bt f t V t t f Tu,Pc Pm tt t ccpt f t mt cctt

    ut tcut.

    2. A poetics of perversion

    I t 980 90, v p up cp tMetamorphoses, mt ctc mvmt tt mt b bt fmm vutz ccpt f Ov ty ttyby xp ptct f, bv , , u, tv tcqu.45 F t ft tm, t t ( u)bt cmpt c fc, Ov cmpx cmpv

    tk f u t Gk Lt ty pc, ct mut f t pc tv vc cv t tttty v.46 Nt vy p by t mp fm.I v f Stp H The Metamorphosis of Persephone, WmA tt tt t t puu t f-ccu Ov tty pmmtc pt, b t c u. Bcu ft mt ucc f t puut, pp u z tt c f Ov m uy t ctu Rm ,

    43 Ev Rmy The Last World, t tfmt f t t um b tb pv cc cu t t cptc vc.

    44 S m y Tm (993).45 F fmm G Z (999).46 Ey mptu f t ctc mvmt cm fm t m tu f Kx (986)

    H (987).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    14/25

    4 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    qut but Auut vu, xp t tc fu f v, vk u ympty t um f.47 Fm mtcpt f v, f cu, t t ppc t mutuy xcuv: p c b c t pmmtc, ttxtu, c -tu t ff mtt um xpc.48 T ttuvu f ctmy tt ut A utmty futptpc tvt pv t . Itty, tu, t fmt mvmt yt t pp t t Tu, Pc Pm p. Sc yz t tpy f cmpt cmt, ppc tt k f Ap Dp, D

    Pp, Pypmu Gt, v y t c ft pt f t pm.49 But , t, m fmt pb myp t puc Ov ttc tty.

    Omnia turbasti (6.537): Pm uccct ummt f tmc cquc f Tu butty cc t t pfm tmtc utk. I t y t f t umv tv, Ov py ptc f pv pxtt cp t cmpmt pcu tpy. TMetamorphoses , t b u, pm tt pty pb t- t puttv cvt f t pc . It tmk pt t tc cu ptt f tc pcmt ttt t but tty f c mt tv . But tTu, Pc, Pm p ff mt m c: tmfct f t c ytm ty u t mp ut ttv pc f tMetamorphoses, tv ctc c pc c mt tt pvt t.

    I t ft pt f t t, Ov t mpbby fu pty f mtf fm c pt.50 Up tt y Pm, Tu mtt t tc p; t cu f t

    ubqut tv t P, tut cuct cfmt vc t ft tArs Amatoria.5 H t mpu t bb

    47 A (989), 358.48 F fut cu f t pt, G Z (997).49 Ap Dp: Nc (980); D Pp: H (987); Pypmu

    Gt: F (992). A J Hub m u, t tpy f tc pc mtf (t t f x ctu pc p py by fft m) f cu Hm.

    50 Jcb (984) t tt t Tu Pc p tt mtf myfm tt f Ap Dp; f u y t cuc pt pt fm t ctxtu-zt f t mtf tv mu t mk c fft f t p, f c , .., G Z (2000).

    5 T c vy m tu cmp t Accu ccut f Tu t-tu bb v (f. 639-42 W): Tereus indomito more atque animo barbaro / conspexitin eam; amore vecors flammeo, / depositus, facinus pessimum ex dementia / confingit. T ffc ttmt t m fct tt Ov u pp t b pt Accu : Cu (98), 2725.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    15/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 5

    Pm u cmp52 tu, uk t py-pc-persona f t Ars Amatoria, ctmpt bby mvc.53 I cc tc b t m ct uf Pc ty tmt, Tu pt t pcb Ovm.54 A jut Ov pm (A.A. .609-0), t mttbb fm Tc x qut:facundum faciebat amor(6.469).Tu bt tc pfmc t t (addidit et lacrimas,6.47), c cc t Ov pcpt.55 A fy pju mf tc puut (6.506), Ov p utz-t f uc cuct m t v t .56 But t tt

    tc-c cu tt fm t pt f t tv cy ct by u xu vc.Up c Tc, Tu xuty xcm vicimus! (6.53),

    mbz mty mtp ft u tc ctxt.57 Tppct f mty my tmy t t ff f v cttutv ftu f Rm v y, ctbut, t tcmpmty ty mtp fservitium amoris, t t cm-px tc y.58 H, v, t ubqut tv mkc, Tu, f M, cctz t mtpc cu fmilitiaamoris, uc t ubt ctc f v pty t mptc(pc) butty. Gc c ctu t t m f t (6.56-8), c t ctyp t Iliad(22.306-

    52 Cf. Met. 6.46-3 impetus est illi comitum corrumpere curam / nutricisque fidem, nec noningentibus ipsam / sollicitare datis totumque inpendere regnum tA.A. .35-5 sed prius ancillam cap-tandae nosse puellae / cura sit: accessus molliet illa tuos ... hanc tu pollicitis, hanc tu corrumpe rogando .

    53 Cmp A.A. .399-42 Ov cu t t ty y fm pttv t, uc bty, fct xptu mt b c f, t Tu t t km (totum impendere regnum,Met. 6.463).

    54 Cf. A.A. .489-90 neve aliquis verbis odiosas offerat auris, / qua potes, ambiguis callidusabde notis.

    55 Cf.A. A. .659-60 et lacrimae prosunt; lacrimis adamanta movebis: / fac madidas videat,si potes, illa genas.

    56 Cf. A. A. .633-6 Iuppiter ex alto periuria ridet amantum / et iubet Aeolios inrita eferreNotos. / per Styga Iunoni falsum iurare solebat / Iuppiter: exemplo nunc favet ipse suo. Tt c c- tc ctxt uccptb pc . Wt Ac, t ctyp pc ,tk but uc tc f upcty t ctxt f mby, tt cy t Oyu,

    Ajx Px t mby-c f ct pc, Il. 9.32-3 (F tfu my y, v t t f H, tt m t m y t). S fut

    Ac. f. 609 Mtt, f t t fft p f t p, pv Tu ub tu bty f ttc u.

    57 S Bm (969-86) c. Vicimus xcmt f tc tump, uby t xuy v Smc mmt f tump t Hmptu tMet. 4.356,k bck t Pp. .8.28.

    58 Cf. Tm (964), 54: Tbuu Pptu ft v t tp t fu -fcc ty mtp tt t cct tm But t Ov yut t mtp pfct t, v t pyfu ctt vt t f tt mty t p t pt. O t cu f Rm vy, Ky (993).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    16/25

    6 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    ).59 T Hmc p tt t cmbt f Ac Hct;Ov pp t t Tu t v p vctm. Aft t p,Pm b qut t f m Tu t b-t pt (6.527-30).60 Pvck ty um up t mpt f tytm f my: Lk t pc t bttf, Tu ttPm my t b vcm.6

    A t t c pv ctu. W t butzPm tt t c Tu ut t t , cut ut tu:

    x mct utm u,p ct tqu tm mmumut t,utqu t mutt cu cub,pptt t m m vt qut.

    (Met. 6.557-60)

    T v tu u b t m t Hmc bttf,62but utty pppt tc ctxt. I t f tArs Amatoriacmmuct bt v, ft mumu, t-

    pc up mutuy pub x. T tqu m ft ct tu, ttc py t u mumut t bck t (terraeque tremens immurmurat atrae) tu m pv ubttut f t tc .63 Rmcc f ctmy (dominae, vestigia) fc t pt.64 At t f tft mvmt, t, t pc c t t mutuy cm-pm cupt. T f mtf fm t Ars Amatoria k mpc tcktk f Ov fvu ty pt.A v t btuy put tv vc t ut

    Tu, ft t mutt, ctu t p vctm.65

    59 S Pvck (99), 47 . 0.60 T tm f cmp v pcu mt pc. Cmp, f xmp,

    Ac puut f Hct t Hm. Il. 22.39-42 ( fc t mut, ftt f ctu, p ty ft tmb v: f bf m, , by, t t t c, t b m z ) ubqut mk tt v mbv t f cc, but v-m ctuy t t t... (22.263-4).

    6 Pvck (99), 36, k Tu mppct fvirtus t Sxtu Tquuut Luct t Fasti.

    62 Cf. t cpt f Dm p v Pu tu t Il. 5.292-3, mby Fc (956), 23-4 t b typc Hmc tuc f Scmu.

    63 Cmp t p t cmx:A.A. 2.723-4 accedent questus, accedet amabilemurmur / et dulces gemitus aptaque verba ioco A.A. 3.795-6 nec blandae voces iucundaque murmuracessent/ nec taceant mediis improba verba iocis.

    64 Pvck (99), 40.65 Exp v t ut pt vix ausim credere(6.56).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    17/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 7

    3. An aesthetics of revenge(and metapoetics of literary emulation)

    Gc uptu vt t c f f t t, c tc c tt ptt t b up Ov ub-qut t f M.66 Lk M, Pc cut uytc mm, t v t m f (f) ub t mt tmt. Lk, v t butc Ity tmpy k by ck tut cc. But Pc t tc cc f t t ub,

    k up Pm, cm t t c, uc t pfu ut-p tt ctt mut t ptt ,cumt t pxc zt scelus est pietas in coniuge Terei(6.635).67 N cc c pc uty, muIty tu f tut v vt y (6.642).

    I t pt f t tv t c f v ct tmtcpccupt. I c t pcu ymc f t Tu t,t pfu t tu bt t fm f v: tt tt pcp ftalio ( y f y) ub pybck (t yf y, t ). T c f t ius talionis cv mp -cu t ttu v ty.68 Rt fuy ck- t fct tt, ct tut, t ymmty f qu pybckmy b bfc, muc mu ct tbu-t ff m f cfct ut tt ct t c mf v.69 T ppt v ct: t v t up p, tut tt b t ptt f futvc, c, f t ctu t f t pcp f ub pybck vtuy ut mu. A E F bv, D Pzp bbtu m Vtu-Et ft utmtc zu but-

    Kfkt, v Btt ct m tzut , v Dtt bt m.70

    C t t, t t f Tu, Pc Pmt ut f t uqu cmbt f pv ymmty tkct. Pc cm f vc vv ub tty tt

    66 Lmu (990), 3-4; N (997), 92-5.67 Sm px t 3.5facto pius et sceleratus eodem; 7.339 his ut quaequae pia est horta-

    tibus inpia prima est; 9.407-8 ultusque parente parentem / natus erit facto pius et sceleratus eodem.68 K (996) ff ufu vv.69 F (998), 05-6, ccu tt [] T t mc v m z-

    c Mckt, Vtu zuz, Gmcft ct fc.

    70 F (998), 07. H t t c vc f t ub pybck p-cp Gk f tut, fm H. Op. 709- t t cut pc f fut-ctuy

    At, t tpc pmt (08-).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    18/25

    8 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    cv k f ymbc pty t fmk f ct t-but. Bf cu Pc tv f ymmty, t b pfut mtt b pcp f pm tt ut tt p.7 Dv Lmu my b cvty qut :72

    T mt f t tut m vy c A Tuflagrat(460), Pc ardet (60). T k f Ity (furiali caede, 657)tky c Tu ttmt f Pm t : Pc Ity ff t mt pt f t u, k t t f, jut Tu tk Pm t cu pt, k f t mb t v; Pc t c cy f mater, mater(640),

    jut Tu p ttt t Pm p t ft tt ; Pc k t c t (ense ferit, 64) jut Tucut ut vctm tu ense fero (557). Pm t t Ity tt(643), ct c c Tu cm pu ut , Pm ff m tt, p f t (543-4).Fy, Pc xbt crudelia gaudia(653) t tump v Tu(mf cb crudelis).

    Wt t v qubum Pc cft t pbm f t mt ut ftt pumt t Tu f p mutt

    t. But t cm t xu vc, t fm f t pc t mt f vt, pcy Ov Metamorphoses: y f t ffty- p t pc pptt by m. I c- pt, Pc ty p t bvu pbt fctmy, b ctt (6.66-7, qut b). But futctmpt t tt m pt f v tt t t f pty. By ty ptt Tut cv futv p c, k t cm, t fm t t cfu, fmz

    tquy mpt tfu pu. Pc tu pintus habes, quem poscis(6.655) t Tu quy t t -but tmt tt fu y t py Tu bck k.T c b fmut m pcy: Tu t t ft p t p by ptt by ut fmy mmb.Ity tmbmt t by f pt t mt tfyy

    7 T p mft cpcuu ymmty tv tuctu. Aft t p-u, c mk ff tytcy fm t t f t ty, t bc tv mvmtf. T ft tt Tu butzt f Pm; t c, cy pt tm tt tmp mct t 6.57 signa deus bis sex acto lustraverat anno pv t cutpt c Pc xct tbut.

    72 Lmu (990), 33-4. It my b t pt ut t tt Ity ffct-t pt t Pc c Pm t ft t t b f t ty(6.624-8 475-9 pctvy). S G Z (999), 64-70 f fut fmymmt t ft c f f t t: Pc tt ty.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    19/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 9

    ymmtc vc tt t t cu v vt up t c-tuu pt. Acc t t mtc cmy tt v t p,Pc cv fttquid pro quo f t vt f t.A ffmt f ptc jutc tu cy t k Pc ct-mt f tbut, Tu btuy tcut Att t cu Tc mt v tt Pm ptyuct: omnia turbasti.

    At t m tm, t ymmty cy c t fvc (fm p t mu, c tm f utty ct vctm), fm Spc , t t b xmpfybfu ct, t t xu c f t talio pcp.Suc, , u pp t b t ccu bvt, pbbyutt by t deus ex machina, f Spc Tereus:73

    [o jio: i; jov [ivio hvvo ov.o{i ; j oii i; oio ovi h ovo o; vo,ijov ji oj jihv .(f. 589 Rt)

    H [c. Tu] m; but ty [c. Pc Pm] pu- m m my t tu vc. F y , by tub, mt my t t , ctuv .

    P ut m t qu t c: tu ftc t utpu t f by t pcpftalio. T upu Pc t bt, fty t pbty f xct vc cc t t lex

    talionis, but qucky jct t f m p tfct: t cm c qut um, f, qu b, qu vc fumpt. m f m, m, pv:ut , cum fcbu tct cmb,tfcm m mmttm T fmm,ut um tqu cu t qu tb mmb pumbtuut f pm, ut p vu mtm mm xpm. mum qucumqu pv;

    qu t, uc ubt. (Met. 6.6-9)

    73 T qut b vuy tf A, At Hm: Ftzptck (200), 99.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    20/25

    20 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    Pc vty k t ut- Tu. I Ov , Bk put t, t t bcm myt f cmpttv mutt.74 Att c f t p, t vc tt t p v m ut fct, t Tu but t k t t, t tbu f ct py-bck fz tu uttbut mtmp (cu bv).

    T ubt mtty m t Pc bc ctv-ty, pcp f ct ptt, tt pck up by my fOv ucc, fm Sc tu Skp t S K. FPc : lector cft by txt c, auctor, mut bt puc up. T txt tt t

    fc f cu t tpty, c pbby ftu t mbut . T u k pp t b t c f SpcTereus, Ftzptck u:75

    W ctty but t tu f Pm v mp-b, vt t t f umt pp t b fvu f txt. A pct ptt k t u pbty f cvyby Tu mf f y vt. O mt v k muc pc t Pm cu t pct f fcxpc, , ctt, txt y cu v f-

    ct .A t tu f tMetamorphosesv. Mv, Cuy

    pt ut, purpureas notas (6.577) btt ut t cpt t tm.76 I y c, Pc (legit) t carmenmiserabile(6.582): t t txt mut up. Pc ttcf v, t, up ttxtu pppt f t p-tt txt f mutt pv mb m f ubqutttxtu pppt f t Ov p. T ty f cp-t tct tcy f cct ttu tt ft

    Ov t mut t t, t m t b - ctmtf t xty f fuc, t ut ty t ut t pc- by ct t mut f pct cuty b.77 I ct f pt ptc, t c f ub pybck mt t f ty. T pt tmt f t ut

    74 Bk (986), 244.75 Ftzptck (200), 97-8, t t tt Skp Titus Andronicus,

    t m vy b Lv u tff t cb t u Stupum C Dmtu (4..77).

    76 Cuy (2003), 93-4 ucOLD.v. nota3-9 t tt t mcmtcmpct fpurpureas fv t txtu v t pct; cf. contraPvck (99), 42.

    77 S, .., S. Thy. 56-7 Thracium fiat nefas / maiore numero t Sc (2003), 70-8;Skp, Titus Andronicus2.3.4 A cft Tu, cu, t tu mt 5.2.94-5F t Pm yu u my ut, / A t P I b v tBt (993), 08-9.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    21/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 2

    f P t up t cm cuct f Tu v bv t Wt t.78 If v ttct t mtt bcu, byubmtt cct t c, t mtt f cu t t pfc, t ttct m bcu t v ut tt.79

    4. Cultural entropy

    If Pc Pm m upy uccfu v,ty uby f um , m pcfcy, At. A t

    p vp ty bcm pvy t fm t cutu , fm t p tt f tf t cvz fH. T ut f P t t bt f TcTu, , y t, tk f ttbut. T cpbmt f pptt vctm tu t ct f tbut pbm t tc f v tt b cuby K.80 F Ov t mt tpc pcfcy cutu mpct t t ytm f pm.

    T Metamorphoses ftu cmpx tcy, c t -t ctct. A t ttmt f umty, Ov cb c pctum f ccptu pbt. B tt t my,t m tu tt t tuy utu bv t pc, t mtvcu p, t mt cu ut, , t t quf xcptf C, t t t cbm, ccu t t mt m, um b ft t t vc ( tt f ff yumbt Bk ). I t pct, cuc ftu f t Tu,Pc Pm p t fmt , c

    ut ccmtt xp f um cy. F t ft tm, vctm f f tt, t um tt v pptt. A cquc, t tc f v bcm tubm u. N btt- , t cct

    78 S bv, . .79 K (996), 7. S Sc (2003), 85-98 t fu f Atu Sc

    Thyestes.80 S K (996), pcy ufu yp (6): Evty, t tuctu f v-

    c xct m t vc t. Etc xc mpct t mpt pt. I ttpm ct t p t, t ymmty f v pb fm mtc y ccmpct t m tut f t v. T y tk ffct f ut v;t t ty ppv f vc, t cmpct t. F B, ju by

    A, t A t A t m, mk mf mb t ppt bm, tfm my t t k f vctm c . F v ct Gc Gkty, .. Gk (987) Butt (998).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    22/25

    22 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    m u t t pptt f uct,tc vc.8

    T t qut f uc xpt f umty cpc-ty f ck ut ft t t pm . If , tE. A. Scmt, t f z tp tt Ov cut t p bk (Pmtu, t fu , t b f t tc.)t jut ccy, but yccy ttmpt, tt ,t mp ut pctum f um cpbt, fm my t t mc cmty f t f tMetamorphoses u uf utt f t pctum,

    t t Tu, Pc, Pm p (tt t f, buty f, t) c b ut xmp f t t ttum b cpb f, t fp , t , t t f pty uc Pm Buc.82

    But t mt m : Ov uvz t-py cm t pcfc cutu t. It t by cct tt pb t mt um cuct t ctxt f Atmyt. I t Gk mt, f cu, t uc Tc,t t f t k , t m vu f (Gk)

    cvzt t ppy. It f pp y f bbpctc, uc um cfc (pcy t cfc f f, pv f t Gk ttut fxenia), fm , cb-m, . I t fft ctuy, At pyt b t bk t by ppt tt ut uc cutu ctuct,fc up t t zt tt v uc f bu-b tut f P t uk v mpu tt t t cm-bt f ccumtc cu u. Av t vctmt t m tm, t t bcm mbm f t pu tfcbt bbty cvzt (At) cty. M y,ty t At t tcut t b tut tct vc t xt but t butt f t Gk m tty.83

    OvMetamorphosescfu t tmtc fm Rm ptf v. I ffc tc tct bt t vu ptt, ctu t tc t um cvt Hc

    8 E negativo, t t u pp t ut tt t Ov pc v mt f m fuct, v f t mty py cmpm.

    82 S Scmt (99).83 It t t tt t tc v f t ut f P ff fm tt

    ft fu t m f mytc ptt. Kck (2005) cu cuptu up fPc Ity t At Acp, vty ptv pct f t ftc. LkDmt, epitaphios f t f C (60.28), ct Pc Pm pty xmp f At tc t bb hubris.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    23/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 23

    cutu ctuct.84 But uk t At pyt, fm t , ppctv xt, pt f b tty fctuct ct f Gk cvzt ut t Rm c-cy.85

    Bibliography

    A, W. S. (989). Rv f H (987). Gnomon 6, 356-8.

    Atu, A. (938). Le Thtre et son Double. (P).

    Bk, L. (986). The Gods Made Flesh: Metamorphosis and the Pursuit of Paganism. (Y).

    Bt, J. (993). Shakespeare and Ovid. (Oxf).

    --- (.) (995) Titus Andronicus. The Arden Shakespeare. (L).

    Bm, F. (.) (969-86). P. Ovidius Naso: Metamorphosen, Kommentar.(Hb).

    Butt, A. P. (998). Revenge in Attic and later tragedy. (Bky, L A,L).

    Czz, I. (950-). La saga di Itis nella tradizione letteraria e mitografica

    Greco-Romana, 2 v. (V).Cy, J. S. (989). The politics of Olympus: form and meaning in the major Homeric

    hymns. (Pct).

    Cm, R. (.) (977). Vergil: Eclogues. (Cmb).

    C, J. V. (990). T vc f m: t f t ScPhaedra. Boundary2.7.3, 95-5.

    Cu, H. M. (98). Ov t Rm St. ANRW2.3.4, 270-42.

    Cuy, D. (997). Ov, Met. 6.640: A Du bt Mt S.CQ47, 320-2.

    --- (2003). Ov Tereus: tt mttt. 63-97 A. H. Smmt(.), Shards from Kolonos: Studies in Sophoclean Fragments. (B).

    Dbv, G. (993). T tc cmc Tu.AJP4, 89-234.

    F, J. (992). Du f G Ov Lv f Pypmu(Metamorphoses3.79-897).AJP3, 235-68.

    Fy, D. C. (993). The gods in epic: poets and critics of the classical tradition.(Oxf).

    F, D. (968). Nuktos paides apaides: A. Eum. 034 u tOxym T. Hermes96, 42-55.

    84 Cf. Lmu (990), 34: T mpct tt t bb/Gk tt f ubu vty. Pc Pm, fm At, t fft fm Tc Tuft .

    85 S G Z (2004) f t umt.

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    24/25

    24 INGO GILDENHARD AND ANDREW ZISSOS

    F, A. Jm, P. (2004). Mk t mt f My. Arethusa37,

    75-03.F, R. (2003). Octavia: a play attributed to Seneca. (Cmb).

    Ftzptck, D. (200). Spc Tereus. CQ5, 90-0.

    F, E. (998). Oedipus: tragischer Vatermord im klassischen Athen. (Muc).

    F, A. (992). Homer: the poetry of the past. (Itc).

    --- (997). Epc . 396-44 I. M B. P (.) A newcompanion to Homer. (L).

    Fc, W. H. (956). Verwundung und Tot in der Ilias. (Gtt).

    Fum, M. (994). Rv f Rmy (988) [bv, . ]. Arbitrium 7,250-4.

    Gk, H.-J. (987). D Gc u Rc: Vuc tcPyc. Saeculum 38, 2-49.

    G, I. Z, A. (997). Rv f W. A (.), OvidsMetamorphoses Books 1-5. BMCR997.9..

    --- (999). Smtc Ecm: Tc B Ptc D OvMetamorphoses. 62-8 P. H, A. Bc, S. H (.),Ovidian Transformations. Essays on Ovids Metamorphoses and its reception.

    (Cmb).--- (2000). Ipt Fct: Autbpy Gc Rfxvty

    Ov Pm. Greece & Rome47 (2000), 67-79.

    --- (2004). Ov Hc: Dctuct At tMetamorphoses.JRS94, 47-72.

    Gz, B. Hub, J. (2005). The resonance of epic. (L).

    Hmbu, K. (965). Von Sophokles zu Sartre. Griechische Dramenfiguren antikund modern. (Stuttt).

    H, P. H. (993). The Epic Successors of Virgil. (Cmb).

    Hub, J. (ftcm). At A: Htu 5.82-9.

    Hktz, D. (998). The madness of epic: reading insanity from Homer toStatius. (Oxf).

    H, S. (987). The Metamorphosis of Persephone. (Cmb).

    Jcb, G. A. (984). Ap Tu: P Mtf OvMetamorphoses. CJ80, 45-52.

    J, W. (.) (97). Die Bauformen der griechischen Tragdie. (Muc).

    Kuf, S. D. (997). Ov Tu: F, B t Rfct f

    Futv Lu. CP92, 66-7.Ky, D. (993). The Arts of Love: Five Studies in the Discourse of Roman Love

    Elegy. (Cmb).

    K, J. (996). Revenge tragedy: Aeschylus to Armageddon. (Oxf).

  • 7/29/2019 Gildenhard-Zissos - Procne - 2007

    25/25

    BARBARIAN VARIATIONS 25

    Kck, A. (2005). M Mtt. M, Pk u Mtv

    fuctb Rc m kc At. 247-64 G. Fc S.M (.), Die andere Seite der Klassik. Gewalt im 5. und 4. Jahrhundertv. Chr. (Stuttt).

    Kx, P. (986). Ovids Metamorphoses and the Traditions of Augustan Poetry.(Cmb).

    --- (.) (995). Ovid Heroides: Select Epistles. (Cmb).

    Lj, J. (.) (2003). Lectures croises de Christoph Ransmayr: Le dernier desmondes. (P).

    Lmu, D. H. J. (990). Tc Contaminatio Ov Metamorphoses:

    Pc M; Pm Ip (6.424-674); Scy P (8.9-5). ICS5, 3-4.

    Mt, C. (993). Redeeming the text: Latin poetry and the hermeneutics ofreception. (Cmb).

    Mm, J. (995). Wild Justice: a Study of Euripides Hecuba. (Oxf).

    N, C. (997). T Mtmp f Ov M. 78-208 J. J.Cu S. I. J (.),Medea. (Pct).

    Nm, J. (994). A Lt M Wm t Hm L T M:Pm, Fm Vc Skp The Rape of Lucrece.

    Shakespeare Quarterly45, 304-26.Nc, W. S. M. (980). Cup, Ap, Dp (Ov, Met. .452ff.).CQ30, 74-82.

    N, E. (93).Agnostos Theos. (Lpz B).

    Ot, B. (966). Ovid as an epic poet. (Cmb).

    Pvck, B. (99). T Tyt Buy Vt Ov TuEp. Helios8, 34-48

    Rm, J. (.) (99). Violence in drama. (Cmb).

    Rc, A. (992). R Ov Rp. 58-79 . (.), Pornography

    and Representation in Greece and Rome. (Oxf).Sc, A. (2003). The passions in play: Thyestes and the dynamics of Senecan

    drama. (Cmb).

    Sc, R. (988). D Bkc H: yc Apkt vEup Hkb.Metis3, -35.

    Scmt, E. A. (99). Ovids poetische Menschenwelt: die Metamorphosen alsMetapher und Symphonie. (Hb).

    Sf, R. (987). T Tc W.JHS07, 06-30.

    S, C. (994). Pm b t pu f t txt: v-

    c tMetamorphosesf Ov. 257-80 I.J.F. J P. Suv(.), Modern Critical Theory and Classical Literature. (L, N Yk,C).