getting off on the right foot- subjective value versus economic value in predicting longitudinal job...

37
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=973825 !"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''.' ' ,/%%$%&'0"123''!45567!'(--'(7'504',6!05'-((5' ' ' !"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#3' 8/9:";#$<"'=1>/"'<"?@/@'4;*%*A$;'=1>/"'$%'' B?"2$;#$%&'C*%&$#/2$%1>'D*9'(/#;*A"@')?*A'D*9'())"?'7"&*#$1#$*%@' ' '  !"#$%&'()#*"+ ,"--".*)-$//-0+-/1/)/$234$.*+25267 8155"#79+6$#:53$+;$1+ <"=1+  !'>15%)33 ?+1=$#-1/723("5132#+1"@A$#B$5$7 0+C#$--@  !"#$%&' "(   )**'+,-./012"'"30 '  !"#$%&'()#*"+@D52"+D.*22523,"+"6$E$+/@,"--".*)-$//-0+-/1/)/$234$.*+25267' 8155"#79+6$#:53$+;$1+"+%<"=1+  !'>15%)33@F#6"+1G"/12+"5A$*"=12#"+%0+%)-/#1"5&$5"/12+-@ 8""-D.*22523A)-1+$--@?+1=$#-1/723("5132#+1"@A$#B$5$7'8155"#79+6$#:53$+;$1+1-+2H"/ /*$F51+D.*22523A)-1+$--@I"-*1+6/2+?+1=$#-1/71+D/'J2)1-'K#$C"#"/12+23/*1-"#/1.5$H"- -)CC2#/$%  ;7L"/12+"5D.1$+.$M2)+%"/12+9H"#%NOPNPNQ*$5%  ;7/*$31#-/")/*2#'4*$-$.2+% "+%/*1#%")/*2#-.2+/#1;)/$%$R)"557"+%"CC$"#"5C*";$/1."557' I$/*"+B,"SA"G$#E"+@ D$"+A#2H+@057-$(2%7@D)$>51+$@K")5F-/$#E"+@T1%"D."#C$552@"+%  !".R)$51+$I15;)#32# /*$1#"--1-/"+.$H1/*/*1-#$-$"#.*'(2##$-C2+%$+.$.2+.$#+1+6/*1-"#/1.5$-*2)5%  ;$"%%#$--$% /2  !"#$%&'()#*"+@,04D52"+D.*22523,"+"6$E$+/@UN,$E2#1"5 V#1=$@&22E:UPUUW@ ("E;#1%6$@,9NPXWPXYWQ@2#=1"/*$0+/$#+$//2.)#*"+ZC2-/'*"#="#%'$%)'

Upload: larry-lyon

Post on 09-Apr-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 1/37Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=973825

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''.'

'

,/%%$%&'0"123''!45567!'(--'(7'504',6!05'-((5'

'

'

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#3'

8/9:";#$<"'=1>/"'<"?@/@'4;*%*A$;'=1>/"'$%''

B?"2$;#$%&'C*%&$#/2$%1>'D*9'(/#;*A"@')?*A'D*9'())"?'7"&*#$1#$*%@'

'

'

 !"#$%&'

()#*"+

,"--".*)-$//-0+-/1/)/$234$.*+25267

8155"#79+6$#:53$+;$1+

<"=1+ !'>15%)33

?+1=$#-1/723("5132#+1"@A$#B$5$7

0+C#$--@ !"#$%&'"(  )**'+,-./012"'"30'

 !"#$%&'()#*"+@D52"+D.*22523,"+"6$E$+/@,"--".*)-$//-0+-/1/)/$234$.*+25267'

8155"#79+6$#:53$+;$1+"+%<"=1+ !'>15%)33@F#6"+1G"/12+"5A$*"=12#"+%0+%)-/#1"5&$5"/12+-@

8""-D.*22523A)-1+$--@?+1=$#-1/723("5132#+1"@A$#B$5$7'8155"#79+6$#:53$+;$1+1-+2H"/

/*$F51+D.*22523A)-1+$--@I"-*1+6/2+?+1=$#-1/71+D/'J2)1-'K#$C"#"/12+23/*1-"#/1.5$H"-

-)CC2#/$% ;7L"/12+"5D.1$+.$M2)+%"/12+9H"#%NOPNPNQ*$5% ;7/*$31#-/")/*2#'4*$-$.2+%

"+%

/*1#%

")/*2#-

.2+/#1;)/$%

$R)"557

"+%

"CC$"#

"5C*";$/1."557'

I$

/*"+B

,"S

A"G$#E"+@

D$"+A#2H+@057-$(2%7@D)$>51+$@K")5F-/$#E"+@T1%"D."#C$552@"+% !".R)$51+$I15;)#32#

/*$1#"--1-/"+.$H1/*/*1-#$-$"#.*'(2##$-C2+%$+.$.2+.$#+1+6/*1-"#/1.5$-*2)5% ;$"%%#$--$%

/2 !"#$%&'()#*"+@,04D52"+D.*22523,"+"6$E$+/@UN,$E2#1"5V#1=$@&22E:UPUUW@

("E;#1%6$@,9NPXWPXYWQ@2#=1"/*$0+/$#+$//2.)#*"+ZC2-/'*"#="#%'$%)'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 2/37Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=973825

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''E'

'

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#3'

8/9:";#$<"'=1>/"'<"?@/@'4;*%*A$;'=1>/"'$%''

B?"2$;#$%&'C*%&$#/2$%1>'D*9'(/#;*A"@')?*A'D*9'())"?'7"&*#$1#$*%@'

'

F9@#?1;#'

F>#+*/&+'%"&*#$1#$*%'"GH"?$"%;"@';1%'1))";#'1'%"&*#$1#*?I@'"%@/$%&'1##$#/2"@'1%2'9"+1<$*?J'>$##>"'

$@'K%*L%'19*/#'#+"$?'>*%&M#"?A';*%@"N/"%;"@O'P@$%&'1'>*%&$#/2$%1>'@/?<"Q'2"@$&%J'L"'#"@#'#+"'

2"&?""'#*'L+$;+'";*%*A$;'1%2'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'1;+$"<"2'$%':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@'H?"2$;#@'

"AH>*Q""@I'@/9@"N/"%#':*9'1##$#/2"@'1%2'$%#"%#$*%@'#*'#/?%*<"?O'',"@/>#@'$%2$;1#"'#+1#'@/9:";#$<"'

<1>/"'H?"2$;#@'&?"1#"?';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%'1%2':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'1%2'>*L"?'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%'

A"1@/?"2'*%"'Q"1?'>1#"?O''8/?H?$@$%&>QJ'#+"'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@'#+1#'%"&*#$1#*?@'1;+$"<"2'+12'%*'

1HH1?"%#'"))";#@'*%'#+"@"')1;#*?@O''6AH>$;1#$*%@J'>$A$#1#$*%@J'1%2')/#/?"'2$?";#$*%@'1?"'2$@;/@@"2O'

'

'  !"#$%&'()''"AH>*QA"%#'%"&*#$1#$*%J'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"J'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@J':*9'

@1#$@)1;#$*%J';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'#/?%*<"?'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 3/37Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=973825

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''R'

'

0$&+'@#1K"@'%"&*#$1#$*%';1%'9"'1'A"A*?19>"'"GH"?$"%;"'L$#+'>1@#$%&';*%@"N/"%;"@O''5*'

21#"J'+*L"<"?J'?"@"1?;+"?@'+1<"')*;/@"2'*%'#+"'$AA"2$1#"'*/#;*A"@'*)'%"&*#$1#$*%@'L+$>"'

>1?&">Q'$&%*?$%&'#+"$?'>*%&M#"?A'$AH>$;1#$*%@O''6%'#+$@'H1H"?J'L"'1##"AH#'#*')$>>'#+$@'<*$2'9Q'

"G1A$%$%&'#+"'"))";#@'*)'?"1>ML*?>2':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@'*%'"AH>*Q""@I'@/9@"N/"%#'>"<">@'*)'

@1#$@)1;#$*%'1%2'$%#"%#$*%@'#*'?"A1$%'L$#+$%'#+"$?'*?&1%$S1#$*%@O''-/?#+"?J'L"';*AH1?"'#+"'?">1#$<"'

 H?"2$;#$<"'H*L"?'*)'#L*'2$))"?"%#'#QH"@'*)'%"&*#$1#$*%'*/#;*A"@T"AH>*Q""@I'@/9:";#$<"'

"<1>/1#$*%@'*)'#+"$?':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@'<"?@/@'#+"$?'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@'1;+$"<"2O'

5*'@/HH>"A"%#'#+"'%"&*#$1#$*%')$">2I@'>*%&@#1%2$%&'?1#$*%1>$@#'H"?@H";#$<"J'?"@"1?;+"?@'

?";"%#>Q'+1<"'9";*A"'$%;?"1@$%&>Q'$%#"?"@#"2'$%'@*;$1>'H@Q;+*>*&$;1>')1;#*?@'$%'%"&*#$1#$*%'U)*?'1'

?"<$"LJ'@""'V1S"?A1%J'W/?+1%J'X'Y**?"J'EZZ.[O''5+"'H?"@"%#'@#/2Q')*;/@"@'*%'%"&*#$1#*?@I'

)"">$%&@'*)'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'L+$;+';1%'9"'$%)>/"%;"2'9Q'1'?1%&"'*)')1;#*?@J'$%;>/2$%&'1@H$?1#$*%'>"<">@'

U!1>$%@KQJ'Y/@@L"$>"?J'X'Y"2<";J'EZZE[J'#+"'#$A$%&'*)';*%;"@@$*%@'U\L*%'X']"$%&1?#J'EZZ^[J'

1%2'#+"'%/A9"?'*)'%"&*#$1#$*%'$@@/"@'U71N/$%J'EZZR[O''V";1/@"'A1%Q')1;#*?@'*#+"?'#+1%'#+"'

*9:";#$<"'#"?A@'*)'#+"'2"1>';1%'$%)>/"%;"'%"&*#$1#*?'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'%"&*#$1#*?'@1#$@)1;#$*%';1%'

 9";*A"'2$@;*%%";#"2')?*A'#+"'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'*)'@"##>"A"%#@'U!1>$%@KQJ'Y/@@L"$>"?J'X'Y"2<";J'

EZZE[O''-*?'$%@#1%;"J'%"&*#$1#*?@'L+*'?";"$<"2')1>@"')""291;K'$%2$;1#$%&'#+1#'#+"$?';*/%#"?H1?#'

L1@'+1HHQ')">#'>"@@'@/;;"@@)/>'#+1%'#+*@"'#*>2'#+1#'#+"$?';*/%#"?H1?#'L1@'2$@1HH*$%#"2J'"<"%'

#+*/&+'#+"?"'L1@'%*'2$))"?"%;"'$%'#+"'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@'1;?*@@'#+"@"';*%2$#$*%@'U5+*AH@*%J'

=1>>"QJ'X'\?1A"?J'.__`[O''6%')1;#J'$%';"?#1$%'@$#/1#$*%@J'";*%*A$;'<1>/"';1%'9"'%"&1#$<">Q'

;*??">1#"2'L$#+'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"O''7*#19>QJ'%"&*#$1#*?@'L+*'L"?"'$%2/;"2'#*'@"#'+$&+'1@H$?1#$*%'

>"<">@'1;+$"<"2'&?"1#"?'";*%*A$;'&1$%@'9/#')">#'>"@@'@1#$@)$"2'L$#+'#+"$?'*/#;*A"@J'&$<"%'#+"'

&?"1#"?'2$))$;/>#Q'$%'1;+$"<$%&'#+"@"'A*?"'1A9$#$*/@'&*1>@'U!1>$%@KQ'"#'1>OJ'EZZE[O'

6%'1%'"))*?#'#*'$%#"&?1#"'#+"'&?*L$%&'9*2Q'*)'?"@"1?;+'*%'%"&*#$1#*?'@1#$@)1;#$*%'1%2'*#+"?'

@*;$1>'H@Q;+*>*&$;1>'*/#;*A"@'@/;+'1@'#?/@#'1%2'@">)M$A1&"J'W/?+1%J'4>)"%9"$%J'1%2'a/'UEZZb['

?";"%#>Q'$%#?*2/;"2'#+"'/A9?">>1';*%@#?/;#'*)'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'U8=[J'L+$;+'"%;*AH1@@"@'#+"'

@*;$1>'H@Q;+*>*&$;1>';*%@"N/"%;"@'*)'1'%"&*#$1#$*%T$O"OJ')"">$%&@J'H"?;"H#$*%@J'1%2'"A*#$*%@O''

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 4/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''^'

8H";$)$;1>>QJ'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"';*%@$@#@'*)')*/?'$%#"??">1#"2'2$A"%@$*%@3'U1[')"">$%&@'19*/#'#+"'

*+(,&-."+,/0 '*/#;*A"'U$O"OJ'#+"'#"?A@'*)'#+"'2"1>[J'$%;>/2$%&'@/9:";#$<"'H"?;"H#$*%@'19*/#'L+"#+"?'

#+"'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"'L1@'2"@$?19>"J'91>1%;"2J'1%2';*%@$@#"%#'L$#+'H?$%;$H>"@'*)'>"&$#$A1;Q'1%2'

 H?";"2"%#c'U9[')"">$%&@'19*/#'#+"' ("012'$%;>/2$%&'>*@$%&')1;"'<"?@/@')"">$%&';*AH"#"%#'1%2'@1#$@)$"2'

#+1#'*%"'+1@'9"+1<"2'1HH?*H?$1#">Qc'U;[')"">$%&@'19*/#'#+"'%"&*#$1#$*%' 3&%4"((J'$%;>/2$%&'#+"'

 H"?;"H#$*%'#+1#'*%"'+1@'9""%'+"1?2'1%2'9""%'#?"1#"2')1$?>Qc'1%2'U2[')"">$%&@'19*/#'#+"'&"0/,*%+(5*3'

1A*%&'#+"'%"&*#$1#*?@J'$%;>/2$%&'H*@$#$<"'$AH?"@@$*%@J'#?/@#J'1%2'1'@*>$2')*/%21#$*%')*?'L*?K$%&'

#*&"#+"?'$%'#+"')/#/?"O''F>#+*/&+'?">1#"2'#*'#+"';*%;"H#'*)':/@#$;"TL+$;+'+1@'9""%'2")$%"2'1@'

dH"?;"$<"2')1$?%"@@e'U!?""%9"?&'X'W*>N/$##J'EZZ`J'HO'G$[T8='"%;*AH1@@"@'122$#$*%1>')1;#*?@'

#+1#'1?"'*/#@$2"'#+"'9*/%2@'*)'#+"':/@#$;"';*%@#?/;#J'@/;+'1@'#$A"'"))$;$"%;Q'1%2'@">)M"@#""AO''

-/?#+"?J'/%>$K"':/@#$;"J'8='?")"?@'@H";$)$;1>>Q'#*'#+"'2$@H/#"'?"@*>/#$*%';*%#"G#O'

' W/?+1%'"#'1>O'UEZZb['1?&/"2'#+1#'8='$@'$AH*?#1%#')*?'@"<"?1>'?"1@*%@O''-$?@#J'@/9:";#$<"'

<1>/"'A1Q'9"'1'&**2'$%'$#@">)c'#+1#'$@J'%"&*#$1#*?@'A1Q'<1>/"')"">$%&@'*)'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'H?$2"J'1%2'

;*%%";#$*%'@"H1?1#"')?*A'1%Q'1@@*;$1#"2'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@'UY$>>"?J'.___c'Y$>>@J'._^Z[O''

8";*%2J'%"&*#$1#*?@'A1Q'/@"'#+"$?')"">$%&@'19*/#'1'%"&*#$1#$*%'1@'$%#/$#$*%'19*/#'#+"$?'

 H"?)*?A1%;"'$%'#+"'%"&*#$1#$*%O''6%'A*@#'?"1>M>$)"'%"&*#$1#$*%'@"##$%&@'#+"?"'$@'%*'";*%*A$;'

A"1@/?"'*)'H"?)*?A1%;"'?"12$>Q'1<1$>19>"O''-*?'"G1AH>"J'"<1>/1#$%&'#+"'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"'*)'

 9/Q$%&'1'/@"2';1?'L*/>2'?"N/$?"';*AH>"#"'$%)*?A1#$*%'19*/#'#+"'2"1>"?I@'$%#"?"@#@'1%2'

1>#"?%1#$<"@J'#+"'2"1>@'?"1;+"2'9Q'*#+"?@'A1K$%&'@$A$>1?'H/?;+1@"@J'1%2'"<"%'#+"'#?/"'<1>/"'*)'#+"'

;1?T$%;>/2$%&'$%)*?A1#$*%'19*/#'N/1>$#Q'1%2'?">$19$>$#Q'#+1#'A1Q'9"'/%K%*L19>"'1#'#+"'#$A"O''5*'

@/HH>"A"%#'#+"$?'$AH"?)";#'$%)*?A1#$*%'$%'"<1>/1#$%&'#+"$?'H"?)*?A1%;"J'%"&*#$1#*?@'*)#"%'2?1L'

/H*%'#+"$?'*L%'@/9:";#$<"'$%#/$#$*%@O''5+$@'$AH"?)";#'1%1>Q@$@J'$%'#/?%J';1%'+1<"'$AH*?#1%#'

$AH>$;1#$*%@')*?')/#/?"'9"+1<$*?J'@/;+'1@'L+"#+"?'#*'%"&*#$1#"'1&1$%'L$#+'#+"'@1A"';*/%#"?H1?#'

U(>$<"?'"#'1>OJ'.__^[O''-$%1>>QJ'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'A1Q'@"?<"'1@'1'H?"2$;#*?'*)')/#/?"'";*%*A$;'<1>/"O''

-"">$%&@'19*/#'#+"'%"&*#$1#$*%'A1Q'$%)>/"%;"'@/9@"N/"%#'9"+1<$*?@'#+1#J'$%'#/?%J'$%)>/"%;"'

 H"?)*?A1%;"O''-*?'$%@#1%;"J'f?*>"#'1%2'Y*??$@'UEZZZ[')*/%2'#+1#'&?"1#"?'?1HH*?#'2"<">*H"2'$%'*%"'

%"&*#$1#$*%'>"2'#*'&?"1#"?'$%)*?A1#$*%'@+1?$%&'$%'1'@";*%2'%"&*#$1#$*%J'L+$;+'?"@/>#"2'$%'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 5/37

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 6/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''b'

)?*A'l.JZZZ'#*'lmJZZZ'H"?'Q"1?'U: 'n'l.Jmj`[O''!$<"%'#+1#'@#1?#$%&';*AH"%@1#$*%'>"<">'@"#@'1'

?")"?"%;"'H*$%#')*?')/#/?"'Q"1?@J'"<"%'A*2"?1#"'$%$#$1>'$%;?"1@"@'$%'@1>1?Q';1%'122'/H'#*'#"%@'*?'

+/%2?"2@'*)'#+*/@1%2@'*)'2*>>1?@'*<"?'#+"';*/?@"'*)'1';1?""?'U!"?+1?#'X',Q%"@J'.__.[O'''

9-;<"4,*="7>/0-"7/+'79-;("?-"+,7@,,*,-'"(7

F'#?12$#$*%'L$#+$%'#+"')$">2'+1@'9""%'#*';*%@#?/"'%"&*#$1#$*%'1@'1'2";$@$*%MA1K$%&'

 H?*;"@@TL$#+'?1#$*%1>$#Q'1%2'*H#$A1>$#Q'1@'#+"'&*>2'@#1%21?2@'*)'H"?)*?A1%;"'UV1S"?A1%J'"#'1>OJ'

EZZ.c'7"1>"'X'V1S"?A1%J'.__.[O''W*%@"N/"%#>QJ'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'+1@'9""%'@""%'1@'%*'A*?"'#+1%'

1'H"?;"H#/1>'9$1@J'1')>""#$%&')*;/@'*)'1##"%#$*%'#+1#';1%'2$@#?1;#'/@')?*A'#+"'*9:";#$<"'%"&*#$1#$*%'

#1@K'1#'+1%2O''6%2""2J'1;#$%&'L$#+'#+"'&*1>'*)'A1G$A$S$%&'*%"I@'@/9:";#$<"'"GH"?$"%;"'d2*"@'%*#'

A""#'#+"'@#1%21?2@'*)'A*@#'?1#$*%1>';+*$;"'A*2">@g9";1/@"'h)"">$%&'&**2i'$@'*)'%*'A1#"?$1>'

;*%@"N/"%;"e'UY$>>"?J'.___J'.Z`RM.Z`^[O'

VQ';*%#?1@#J'L"'2?1L')?*A'H@Q;+*>*&$;1>'#+"*?$"@'*%'#+"'$%)*?A1#$*%'<1>/"'*)'1))";#'#*'

1?&/"'#+1#'8=';1%'H?*<$2"'%"&*#$1#*?@'L$#+'1'?*9/@#'1%2'>*%&'>1@#$%&'o&/#';+";KI'19*/#'#+"$?'

"GH"?$"%;"O''8;+L1?#S'1%2'W>*?"I@'U._jR['A**2M1@M$%)*?A1#$*%'#+"*?Q'A1$%#1$%@'#+1#'*/?'

1))";#$<"'@#1#"@'H?*<$2"'/@'L$#+'$%)*?A1#$*%'19*/#'#+"'L*?>2'1?*/%2'/@T@/;+'1@'L+"#+"?'#+"?"'$@'

@1)"#Q')*?'"GH>*?1#$*%'*?'1'H?*9>"A'#*'9"'@*><"2O''W>*?"'"#'1>O'U.__^['1?&/"2'#+1#'1))";#'#"%2@'#*'9"'

1'H1?#$;/>1?>Q'$%)>/"%#$1>'@*/?;"'*)'$%)*?A1#$*%')*?':/2&A"%#@'#+1#';*%;"?%'H?")"?"%;"@'1%2'>$K$%&J'

1%2'$%'2*A1$%@')*?'L+$;+'#+"')"">$%&@'@""A'A*@#'?">"<1%#O''F;;*?2$%&>QJ'1))";#'H?"2$;#@':*9'

@1#$@)1;#$*%'1%2'*#+"?':*9'1##$#/2"@'@/;+'1@'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%@'UV?$")'X']"$@@J'EZZEc'5+*?"@"%J'

\1H>1%J'V1?@KQJ']1??"%J'X'2"'W+"?A*%#J'EZZR[O''6%2""2J']"$@@'1%2'W?*H1%S1%*I@'U.__b['

F))";#$<"'4<"%#@'5+"*?Q'1?&/"@'#+1#':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'?"@/>#@')?*A'#+?""'2$@#$%;#')1;#*?@3'U1['

1))";#$<"'"GH"?$"%;"@J'U9['"<1>/1#$<"':/2&A"%#@J'1%2'U;['9">$")@'19*/#'*%"I@':*9O'']"'1?&/"'#+1#'

 :*9M*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%T1@'1'+$&+>Q'@1>$"%#J'A"A*?19>"J'1%2'"A*#$*%1>>Q';+1?&"2'"GH"?$"%;"T$@'

>$K">Q'#*'9"'1%'1))";#$<"'"<"%#'#+1#'@+1H"@')/#/?"':*9'1##$#/2"@O''-/?#+"?J'&$<"%'#+1#'1##$#/2"@'

2"?$<"2')?*A'1))";#'1HH"1?'#*'9"'A*?"'@#?*%&>Q'+">2'#+1%'#+*@"'2"?$<"2')?*A':/2&A"%#@'1%2'

 9">$")@'UV?$")'X']"$@@J'EZZE[J'L"'1?&/"'#+1#'#+$@'$%)>/"%;"'*)'8='L$>>';1@#'1'@+12*L'*<"?'#$A"O''

5+/@J'L"'1?&/"'8='$@'A*?"'#+1%'1')>""#$%&'9$1@'1%2J'$%2""2J'#+1#'8='$@'>$K">Q'#*'9"'?*9/@#3'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 7/37

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 8/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''j'

 E%;7(/,*(1/4,*%+D77!"%"?1>':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'$@'1%*#+"?':*9'1##$#/2"'>$K">Q'#*'9"'$%)>/"%;"2'9Q'

#+"':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%'"GH"?$"%;"O''D*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'+1@'9""%'2")$%"2'1@'d*%"I@'1))";#$<"'

1##1;+A"%#'#*'#+"':*9e'U5"##'X'Y"Q"?J'.__R['1%2J'1@'1%'1))";#$<"':/2&A"%#J'$@'>$K">Q'#*'9"'

 H1?#$;/>1?>Q'$%)>/"%;"2'9Q'#+"'@/9:";#$<"')"">$%&@';*A$%&'*/#'*)'1'%"&*#$1#$*%O''F'@/9:";#$<">Q'

 H*@$#$<"'%"&*#$1#$*%'"GH"?$"%;"'&"%"?1>>Q'"%&"%2"?@'H*@$#$<"'$AH?"@@$*%@'*)'*%"I@';*/%#"?H1?#'1@'

1'H"?@*%'1@'L">>'1@'#+"'H1$?I@'?">1#$*%@+$HJ'L+"?"1@'1'%"&1#$<"'%"&*#$1#$*%'"GH"?$"%;"'+1@'#+"'

*HH*@$#"'"))";#O''-*?'"G1AH>"J'C1L>"?'X'q**%'U.__R['?"H*?#"2'#+1#'?"H"1#"2'1&?""A"%#@'9"#L""%'

%"&*#$1#*?@'>"12'#*'H*@$#$<"'"A*#$*%@'@/??*/%2$%&'#+"$?'?">1#$*%@+$HJ'L+$;+'$%'#/?%'>"12'#*'+$&+"?'

>"<">@'*)'1))";#$<"';*AA$#A"%#O''F#'#+"'*#+"?'"G#?"A"J';*"?;$<"'#1;#$;@'>"12'%"&*#$1#*?@'#*'?"H*?#'

#+1#'#+"$?'?">1#$*%@+$H@'+1<"'9""%'21A1&"2'U!?""%+1>&+'X'W+1HA1%J'.__j[O'']"'1?&/"'#+1#'#+"'

1##$#/2"@')*?A"2'*%'#+"'91@$@'*)'*%"'*?'A*?"'%"&*#$1#$*%';*/%#"?H1?#@'$%'1%'"AH>*QA"%#'

%"&*#$1#$*%'@H?"12J'$%'#/?%J'#*'@1#$@)1;#$*%'L$#+'*%"I@':*9'1@'1'L+*>"O''B?"<$*/@'?"@"1?;+'+1@'

2"A*%@#?1#"2'#+1#':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%';1%'?"@/>#')?*A'#+"'N/1>$#Q'*)'"AH>*Q""@I'?">1#$*%@+$H@'L$#+'

K"Q'$%2$<$2/1>@'@/;+'1@'@/H"?<$@*?@'U8"##**%J'V"%%"##J'X'C$2"%J'.__bc'q/K>J'._j_['*?';>*@"'

)?$"%2@'1#'L*?K'U]$%@#"12J'f"?>"&1J'Y*%#&*A"?QJ'X'B$>K$%&#*%J'.__`[O'']"'1?&/"'#+1#'$%;*A$%&'

"AH>*Q""@'@""'#+"$?'%"&*#$1#$*%';*/%#"?H1?#@'1@'?"H?"@"%#1#$<"@'*)'#+"$?'"AH>*Q$%&'*?&1%$S1#$*%@'

1%2'>$K">Q'&"%"?1>$S"')?*A'#+"'?">1#$*%@+$H'#+1#'#+"Q'2"<">*H"2'2/?$%&'#+"'%"&*#$1#$*%O'

6-&+%="&7*+,"+,*%+O''6%'122$#$*%'#*'1))";#$%&'#+"'N/1>$#Q'*)'@/9@"N/"%#'?">1#$*%@'9"#L""%'

%"&*#$1#*?@J'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'$%'%"&*#$1#$*%@'A1Q'$%)>/"%;"'#+"'"G#"%#'#*'L+$;+'%"&*#$1#*?@'L1%#'

#*'A1$%#1$%'1%Q'?">1#$*%@+$H'1#'1>>O'',"@"1?;+'"G1A$%$%&'%"&*#$1#*?@I'2"@$?"')*?')/#/?"'$%#"?1;#$*%'

L$#+'"1;+'*#+"?'@/HH*?#@'#+"'$2"1'#+1#'8=';*/>2'9"'1%'$AH*?#1%#'2"#"?A$%1%#O''(>$<"?J'

V1>1K?$@+%1%J'1%2'V1??Q'U.__^[')*/%2'#+1#'+$&+'@1#$@)1;#$*%'L$#+'%"&*#$1#$*%'*/#;*A"@J'

$%2"H"%2"%#'*)'1;#/1>'*/#;*A"@J'H?"2$;#"2'&?"1#"?'2"@$?"'#*'%"&*#$1#"'L$#+'#+"'@1A"';*/%#"?H1?#'

$%'#+"')/#/?"O''8$A$>1?>QJ'H*@$#$<"'H"?;"H#$*%@'*)'#"1A'H"?)*?A1%;"'1A*%&'%"&*#$1#*?@'L*?K$%&'

#*&"#+"?'H?"2$;#"2'#+"$?'$%#"%#$*%@'#*'?"A1$%'H1?#'*)'#+"'#"1AJ'1%2'#+$@'"))";#'L1@'%*#'A"2$1#"2'9Q'

1;#/1>'H"?)*?A1%;"'UV1Q1S$#'X'Y1%%$GJ'EZZR[O''F#'#+"'>"<">'*)'$%2$<$2/1>'2$))"?"%;"@J'%"&*#$1#*?@'

L+*'1?"'"@H";$1>>Q'@"%@$#$<"'19*/#'#+"$?'@"%@"'*)'@">)T$%'#+"')*?A'*)';+?*%$;'@"%@$#$<$#Q'#*'$@@/"@'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 9/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''_'

*)')1;"'@1<$%&'1%2')1;"'#+?"1#T1?"'A*?"'>$K">Q'#+1%'#+"$?'>"@@'@"%@$#$<"'H""?@'#*'?"1;+'$AH1@@"@'

1@':*9';1%2$21#"@'$%'@$A/>1#"2'"AH>*QA"%#'%"&*#$1#$*%@'U]+$#"J'5Q%1%J'!1>$%@KQJ'X'5+*AH@*%J'

EZZ^[O''F>#+*/&+'*?&1%$S1#$*%1>'"AH>*Q""@'+1<"'&?"1#"?'#?1%@1;#$*%';*@#@'$%';+1%&$%&'

?">1#$*%@+$H'H1?#%"?@'#+1%'2*'#+*@"'$%'@$A/>1#"2'"AH>*QA"%#'%"&*#$1#$*%@J'#+"Q'2*'+1<"'#+"'

*H#$*%'*)'H/?@/$%&'1>#"?%1#$<"@'#*'#+"$?';/??"%#'"AH>*Q"?O'']"'1?&/"'#+1#'#+"'@1A"')1;#*?@'A1Q'

>"12'?"1>':*9';1%2$21#"@'L+*'"GH"?$"%;"'>*L'8='#*'L$#+2?1L'"))*?#')?*A'#+"$?'L*?K$%&'

?">1#$*%@+$H'1%2J'#+/@J'#*';*%@$2"?'#"?A$%1#$%&'"AH>*QA"%#'L$#+'#+"'*?&1%$S1#$*%'L+*@"'

?"H?"@"%#1#$<"'$%<*K"2'#+1#'H**?'"GH"?$"%;"O''-/?#+"?J'H1@#'L*?K'@+*L@'#+1#'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%@'

1HH"1?'#*'9"'$%)>/"%;"2'>"@@'9Q'*<"?1>>';*AH"%@1#$*%'>"<">@'#+1%'9Q';+1%&"@'#*';*AH"%@1#$*%T 

"O&OJ'>/AHM@/A'9*%/@"@'U8#/?A1%'X'8+*?#J'EZZZ[TL+$;+'@/&&"@#@'#+1#'#+"';*%;"@@$*%@'1%2'

"GH"?$"%;"')?*A'1':*9'%"&*#$1#$*%'A1Q'9"'$%)>/"%#$1>'1@'L">>O'

 A#3%,5"(*(7F3'0$&+'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'$%':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@'H?"2$;#@'A*?"'H*@$#$<"')/#/?"'

 :*9'1##$#/2"@O'

5*'#+"'"G#"%#'#+1#'%"&*#$1#*?@'+1<"'>$A$#"2'1;;"@@'#*'#+"$?'*L%'";*%*A$;'H"?)*?A1%;"J'

8='$@'>$K">Q'#*'9"'1'9"##"?'H?"2$;#*?'*)')/#/?"'9"+1<$*?'#+1%'";*%*A$;'<1>/"O''-*?'"G1AH>"J'

W/?+1%'"#'1>O'UEZZb[')*/%2'#+1#'+$&+'8='?"H*?#"2'$AA"2$1#">Q')*>>*L$%&'1'%"&*#$1#$*%'H?"2$;#"2'

L+"#+"?'%"&*#$1#*?@';+*@"'1')*?A"?';*/%#"?H1?#'1@'1'#"1AA1#"'*%'1%'"G"?;$@"')*?'L+$;+';*/?@"'

&?12"@'L"?"'1#'@#1K"J'L+"?"1@'*9:";#$<"'@;*?"@'+12'%*'@/;+'H?"2$;#$<"'H*L"?'U1>@*'@""'W/?+1%J'

4>)"%9"$%J'X'4$@"%K?1)#J'$%'H?"@@[O''!$<"%'#+1#':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@')*;/@'*@#"%@$9>Q'*%'

;*AH"%@1#$*%J'L"'A$&+#'1>@*'"GH";#'#+1#'#+"'#1%&$9>"'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@'1;+$"<"2'9Q'$%;*A$%&'

"AH>*Q""@'L$>>'H?"2$;#'#+"$?')/#/?"';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%O''W*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'$%'

#/?%J';1%')""2'$%#*'&"%"?1>':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'1%2'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%@'Uf?"+"?'"#'1>OJ'._jjc']$>>$1A@'

"#'1>OJ'EZZb[O''0*L"<"?J'8='1%2'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'#"%2'#*'9"'*%>Q'L"1K>Q';*??">1#"2'U"O&OJ'W/?+1%'

"#'1>OJ'EZZbc'!1>$%@KQ'"#'1>OJ'EZZE[J'1%2'#+"?"'1?"'#+"*?"#$;1>'1?&/A"%#@'1%2'"AH$?$;1>'21#1'

@/&&"@#$%&'#+1#'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'$@'1'9"##"?'H?"2$;#*?'#+1%'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'*)'1##$#/2"@'1%2'

 9"+1<$*?1>'$%#"%#$*%@'U"O&OJ'W/?+1%'"#'1>OJ'EZZb[O''-/?#+"?J'*9:";#$<"'H1Q'>"<">@'2*'%*#'1>L1Q@'

;*??">1#"'L$#+'H1Q'@1#$@)1;#$*%'UW/??1>>'"#'1>OJ'EZZ`[J'L+$;+'@/HH*?#@'#+"'$2"1'#+1#'@/9:";#$<"'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 10/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''.Z'

 H"?;"H#$*%@';1%'9"'A*?"'H?*G$A1>'#*'&"%"?1>$S"2':*9'1##$#/2"@'#+1%'";*%*A$;';+1?1;#"?$@#$;@O'

 A#3%,5"(*(7G3'5+"'1@@*;$1#$*%'9"#L""%'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'1%2')/#/?"':*9'1##$#/2"@'L$>>'9"'

@#?*%&"?'#+1%'#+"'1@@*;$1#$*%'9"#L""%'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'*)';*%;"@@$*%@'1%2')/#/?"':*9'1##$#/2"@O''

Y"#+*2'

 8/&,*4*3/+,(7

Y"A9"?@'*)'#+"'&?12/1#$%&';>1@@'*)'EZZ`'1#'1%'">$#"'Y1@#"?I@'*)'V/@$%"@@'F2A$%$@#?1#$*%'

UYVF['H?*&?1A'$%'#+"'P%$#"2'8#1#"@';*AH>"#"2'#L*'@/?<"Q@'<$1'#+"'6%#"?%"#T$%'Y1?;+'EZZ`J'

 H?$*?'#*'&?12/1#$*%J'1%2'$%'Y1Q'EZZbJ'1'Q"1?'1)#"?'&?12/1#$*%O''5+"Q'L"?"'1@@/?"2'*)'

;*%)$2"%#$1>$#Q'1%2'#+1#'21#1'L*/>2'9"'H?*<$2"2'#*'/@'9Q'/%$<"?@$#Q'*))$;$1>@'L+*'L*/>2'A1#;+'

#+"'@/?<"Q@'1%2'2">"#"'?"@H*%2"%#@I'%1A"@O''()'#+"'^.E'&?12/1#$%&'@#/2"%#@J'Rjm';*AH>"#"2'#+"'

)$?@#'@/?<"Q'U#+"' H.30%#."+,79-&="#['1%2J'*)'#+"@"J'._.';*AH>"#"2'#+"'@";*%2'@/?<"Q'U#+"' @0-.+*7

9-&="#[J')*?'1'#*#1>'?"@H*%@"'?1#"'*)'^bO^kO''F%1>Q@"@'*)'1'?1%&"'*)'2"A*&?1H+$;'1%2';*%#?*>'

<1?$19>"@'$%2$;1#"2'A$%$A1>';*%;"?%@'*)'?"@H*%@"'9$1@O.''5*'122?"@@'*/?'?"@"1?;+'N/"@#$*%@J'L"'

;?"1#"2'1'@/9M@1AH>"'*)'1>>'H1?#$;$H1%#@'L+*'$%2$;1#"2'#+1#'#+"Q'+12'%"&*#$1#"2'1%2'1;;"H#"2'1'

 :*9'*))"?'1@'*)'Y1?;+'EZZ`'1%2'L+*';*AH>"#"2'#+"'1>/A%$'@/?<"Q'$%'Y1Q'EZZbOE''5+"@"'mZ'

 H1?#$;$H1%#@'1;;"H#"2':*9@'1#'`b'2$))"?"%#';*AH1%$"@'1;?*@@'ER'2$))"?"%#'$%2/@#?$"@J'L$#+'1'A"2$1%'

1&"'*)'RZOE'Q"1?@O'-*/?'H1?#$;$H1%#@'L$#+'A$@@$%&'21#1'*%';*%#?*>'<1?$19>"@'L"?"'?"#1$%"2'$%'#+"'

@1AH>"J'L$#+'#+"'A"1%'<1>/"'@/9@#$#/#"2'$%'1%1>Q@"@O'R

'

:"/(-&"(7

9-;<"4,*="7/+'7H4%+%.*47>/0-"7IH.30%#."+,79-&="#J7

7 9-;<"4,*="7>/0-"7K+="+,%&#7U'n'O_R[O'(%'9*#+'@/?<"Q@J'H1?#$;$H1%#@'L+*'+12'%"&*#$1#"2'

 :*9'*))"?@';*AH>"#"2'1'.RM$#"A'<"?@$*%'*)'#+"'8/9:";#$<"'=1>/"'6%<"%#*?Q'U8=6c'W/?+1%'"#'1>OJ'

EZZb['A"1@/?"'*)'#+"')*/?M)1;#*?'A*2">'*)'8='U@""'FHH"%2$G[O''6%'>$&+#'*)'#+"'>$A$#"2'#$A"'

1<1$>19>"J'#+"'H1?#$;$H1%#'*?&1%$S1#$*%'1@K"2'#+1#'L"'?"2/;"'#+"'*?$&$%1>'.bM$#"A'@/?<"Q'#*'#+"'

"G#"%#'H*@@$9>"O''-*?'#+"'#+?""'8=6'@/9@;1>"@'L$#+'#+"'+$&+"@#'?">$19$>$#QJ'L"'?"A*<"2'#+"'$#"A'

L$#+'#+"'>*L"@#'?"H*?#"2')1;#*?'>*12$%&'1@'?"H*?#"2'$%'W/?+1%'"#'1>O'UEZZb[O'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 11/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''..'

 H4%+%.*47%-,4%."(DL7'B1?#$;$H1%#@'L+*'%"&*#$1#"2'#+"$?':*9'*))"?@'1>@*'H?*<$2"2'

A"1@/?"@'*)'#+"$?'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@O''-$?@#J'#+"Q'H?*<$2"2'#+"$?')$?@#MQ"1?';*AH"%@1#$*%'$%'

#"?A@'*)'#+"$?';/("7(/0/&#'U$O"OJ'H1$2';*%#$%/*/@>Q'*<"?'.E'A*%#+@['H>/@'#+"$?'%,5"&7M-/&/+,""'7

4%.3"+(/,*%+'U"O&OJ'9*%/@"@J'?">*;1#$*%'1>>*L1%;"@J'#/$#$*%'?"$A9/?@"A"%#J'1%2'*#+"?'

;*AA$#A"%#@[O'']"'1@@"@@"2'#*#1>'@1>1?Q'$%'>$&+#'*)'1'%/A9"?'*)'@#/2$"@'#+1#'$%2$;1#"'1'>$%K'

 9"#L""%'H1Q'1%2':*9'1##$#/2"@'U"O&OJ']$>>$1A@'"#'1>OJ'EZZb[O''8";*%2J'?"@H*%2"%#@'>$@#"2'$%')?""M

?"@H*%@"'1>>'*)'#+"';*%;"@@$*%@'#+1#'#+"Q'?";"$<"2'2/?$%&'#+"$?':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%O''5+"@"'L"?"'

;*2"2'$%#*'.`';1#"&*?$"@'9Q'#+"')$?@#'1%2'@";*%2'1/#+*?@J'9*#+'*)'L+*A'#"1;+'YVFM>"<">'

%"&*#$1#$*%@';*/?@"@'1%2';*1;+'&?12/1#$%&'@#/2"%#@'19*/#'#+"$?':*9'%"&*#$1#$*%@'U$%#"?M?1#"?'

1&?""A"%#'& nO__[O''B1?#$;$H1%#@'#+"%'L"?"'$%@#?/;#"2'#*'A*%"#$S"'#+"$?';*%;"@@$*%@'9Q'1%@L"?$%&'

#+"')*>>*L$%&'N/"@#$*%3'd6%'*?2"?'#*'1@@"@@'#+"'1HH?*G$A1#"'2*>>1?'<1>/"'*)'L+1#'Q*/'%"&*#$1#"2J'

 H>"1@"'"@#$A1#"'#+"'.*+*.-.'1A*/%#'*)'A*%"Q'Q*/'L*/>2'9"'L$>>$%&'#*'1;;"H#'U$%'2*>>1?@['$%'

"G;+1%&"')*?')*?)"$#$%&'1>>';*%;"@@$*%@'Q*/'?";"$<"2'$%'Q*/?'%"&*#$1#$*%Oe''!$<"%'#+1#'$#'$@'

;+1>>"%&$%&'#*'N/1%#$)Q'*9:";#$<">Q'#+"'<1>/"'*)'1'%"&*#$1#$*%'*/#@$2"'*)'>19*?1#*?Q'@"##$%&@J'#+$@'

A"1@/?"'H?*<$2"2'1'H?*GQ')*?'#+"'"4%+%.*47=/0-"'*)';*%;"@@$*%@J'1%2'"%@/?"2'#+1#'H1?#$;$H1%#@'

L"?"'1L1?"'*)'#+"$?'*L%'";*%*A$;'<1>/"O''F@'@/&&"@#$<"'"<$2"%;"'*)'#+"'<1>$2$#Q'*)'#+$@'A"1@/?"J'

#"@#p?"#"@#'?">$19$>$#Q'*%"'Q"1?'>1#"?'L1@')1$?>Q'?*9/@#J'& 'Ubj['n'OmEJ' 3rOZ.O''5+"';*??">1#$*%'

 9"#L""%'*/?'A"1@/?"@'*)'8='1%2'#+"'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'*)';*%;"@@$*%@'L1@'?">1#$<">Q'@A1>>'

U& 'n'OEZJ' 3'r'O.Z[J`'L+$;+'$@';*AH1?19>"'#*'W/?+1%'"#'1>OI@'UEZZb[';*??">1#$*%'*)'O.b'9"#L""%'#*#1>'

@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'1%2'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'*%'1'>19*?1#*?Q'#1@K'$%'L+$;+'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'L1@'

*9:";#$<">Q'<"?$)$19>"O''5+$@'$@'1>@*';*%@$@#"%#'L$#+'W/??1>>'"#'1>OI@'UEZZ`[')$%2$%&'#+1#'*9:";#$<"'

 H1Q'>"<">@'2$2'%*#';*??">1#"'L$#+'H1Q'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'1%2'f?"+"?J'F@+J'1%2'V?"#SI@'U._jj[')$%2$%&'*)'

1'?">1#$*%@+$H'9"#L""%')?$%&"'9"%")$#'>"<">@'1%2'@1#$@)1;#$*%'L$#+'#+"@"'9"%")$#@'*%>Q'1A*%&'

 H1?#$;$H1%#@'L+*'L"?"'K%*L>"2&"19>"'19*/#'+*L'#+"$?'9"%")$#'>"<">@';*AH1?"2'L$#+'*#+"?'

"AH>*Q"?@'$%'#+"'@1A"'$%2/@#?QO'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 12/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''.E'

5+"'2$@#?$9/#$*%')*?'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'L1@'+$&+>Q'@K"L"2'#*'#+"'?$&+#J'L$#+'@"<"?1>'A1:*?'

*/#>$"?@'U^ORk'*)'#+"'21#1'H*$%#@'L"?"'A*?"'#+1%'R'8f'19*<"'#+"'A"1%J'<@O'ZO.^k'$%'1'%*?A1>'

2$@#?$9/#$*%[O''6%'>$&+#'*)'&/$2">$%"@'#+1#'d#+"'@+1H"'*)'1'2$@#?$9/#$*%'*)';*%#$%/*/@'<1?$19>"@'$%'1'

A/>#$<1?$1#"'1%1>Q@$@'@+*/>2';*??"@H*%2'#*'1'U/%$<1?$1#"['%*?A1>'2$@#?$9/#$*%e'UY"Q"?@J'!1A@#J'X'

!/1?$%*'EZZbJ'HO'bm[TL$#+'#+"'?/>"'*)'#+/A9'#+1#'#+1#'#+"'@K"L%"@@'1%2'K/?#*@$@'@#1#$@#$;@'

@+*/>2'9"'L$#+$%'#+"'1;;"H#19>"'?1%&"'*)'M.'#*'.'U!"*?&"'X'Y1>>"?QJ'EZZR[TL"'#?1%@)*?A"2'

$%$#$1>'A"1@/?"@'*)'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'*)';*%;"@@$*%@'U@K"L%"@@'EO.bJ'K/?#*@$@'^OR_[J'91@"'@1>1?Q'

U@K"L%"@@'ZO^jJ'K/?#*@$@'.Ob`[J'1%2'8='U@K"L%"@@'p.OEmJ'K/?#*@$@'.Ojm[O''P@$%&'?"<"?@"'?1%K'

*?2"?$%&J'L$#+'d#$"@e'1L1?2"2'#+"'@1A"'?1%KJ'#+"';?$#"?$1')*?'%*?A1>$#Q'?"1;+"2'1;;"H#19>"'<1>/"@'

U";*%*A$;'<1>/"'@K"L%"@@'ZOERJ'K/?#*@$@'pZO__c'91@"'@1>1?Q'@K"L%"@@'pZOR^J'K/?#*@$@'pZObRc'8='

@K"L%"@@'MZORmJ'K/?#*@$@'pZO_`[Ob''5+$@'?1%K$%&'#?1%@)*?A1#$*%'A1$%#1$%"2'1'+$&+';*??">1#$*%'L$#+'

#+"'*?$&$%1>'A"1@/?"@'*)'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'*)';*%;"@@$*%@'U& 'n'Oj`[J'91@"'@1>1?Q'U& 'n'O_^[J'122$#$*%1>'

)$?@#MQ"1?';*AH"%@1#$*%'U& nO_`[J'1%2'8='U& 'n'O_`[O'

 E%;7@,,*,-'"(7I@0-.+*79-&="#J7

7 C%.3"+(/,*%+7(/,*(1/4,*%+7U'n'Obm[D775L*'$#"A@'L"?"'121H#"2')?*A'#+"'H1Q'@/9@;1>"'*)'

8H";#*?I@'U._j`['D*9'81#$@)1;#$*%'8/?<"Q3'd6')"">'6'1A'9"$%&';*AH"%@1#"2'1')1$?'1A*/%#')*?'#+"'

L*?K'6'2*e'1%2'd6')"">'@1#$@)$"2'L$#+'AQ';+1%;"@')*?'$%;?"1@"@'$%';*AH"%@1#$*%e'U@;1>"'

.nd (,&%+M0#7'*(/M&""N'#*'mnd (,&%+M0#7/M&""e[O'

7 E%;7(/,*(1/4,*%+'U'n'Oj^[D775+"')$?@#'$#"A'L1@'d6%'&"%"?1>J'6'1A'<"?Q'@1#$@)$"2'L$#+'AQ'

 :*9e'U@;1>"'.nd (,&%+M0#7'*(/M&""N'#*'mnd (,&%+M0#7/M&""ec'@""'8;1?H">>*'X'W1AH9">>J'._jRJ'*%'

#+"'9"%")$#@'*)'/@$%&'1'&>*91>'A"1@/?"'*)'*<"?1>>'D8[O''5+"'@";*%2'L1@'121H#"2')?*A'#+"'D*9M6%M

!"%"?1>'-1;"@'@;1>"'U\/%$%J'._``['1%2'1@K"2'H1?#$;$H1%#@'#*'@">";#'#+"')1;"'U*/#'*)')$<"')1;"@['

#+1#'d9"@#'"GH?"@@"@'+*L'Q*/')"">'19*/#'Q*/?':*9'$%'&"%"?1>eOm

''

7 6-&+%="&7*+,"+,*%+7U'n'Ojm[D''5L*'$#"A@'L"?"'121H#"2')?*A'H?$*?'@#/2$"@'*)'#/?%*<"?'

U\?1/#J'._m`c'71&QJ'EZZEc'8;+*>>J'._jR[3'd0*L'A/;+'L*/>2'Q*/'>$K"'#*'>"1<"'Q*/?':*9'L$#+$%'

#+"'%"G#'.E'A*%#+@se'1%2'd01<"'Q*/'#+*/&+#'@"?$*/@>Q'19*/#'>**K$%&')*?'1'%"L':*9'">@"L+"?"se'

U@;1>"'.n'd+%,7/,7/00N'#*'mnd="&#7.-45N[O'']"'"G1A$%"'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%@'?1#+"?'#+1%'1;#/1>'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 13/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''.R'

#/?%*<"?'9";1/@"')"L'A"A9"?@'*)'*/?'@1AH>"'+12'<*>/%#1?$>Q'>")#'#+"$?')$?@#'H*@$#$*%@'L$#+$%'#+"'

)$?@#'Q"1?'*)'"AH>*QA"%#'U+n^[J'1%2'9";1/@"'$#'$@';+1>>"%&$%&'Q"#'$AH*?#1%#'#+"*?"#$;1>>Q'#*'

@"H1?1#"'$%<*>/%#1?Q'#/?%*<"?'U"O&OJ')$?$%&@[')?*A'<*>/%#1?Q'#/?%*<"?'U5"##'X'Y"Q"?J'.__R[O''

5/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%J'+*L"<"?J'+1@'9""%'<1>$21#"2'1@'1'@#?*%&'H?"2$;#*?'*)'1;#/1>'<*>/%#1?Q'

#/?%*<"?'U5"##'X'Y"Q"?J'.__R[O'

C%+,&%07>/&*/;0"(7

7 9"OD77F;12"A$;'?";*?2@'H?*<$2"2'#+"'@"G'*)'"1;+'H1?#$;$H1%#O'']"';*%#?*>>"2')*?'@"G'

 9";1/@"'$#'$@'#+"'A*@#'L$2">Q'@#/2$"2'$%2$<$2/1>'2$))"?"%;"'$%'%"&*#$1#$*%O']*A"%'1HH"1?'#*'+1<"'

>*L"?'"GH";#1#$*%@'*)'A1#"?$1>'@/;;"@@'1%2'"GH"?$"%;"'>"@@';"?#1$%#Q'1%2';*A)*?#'L$#+'#+"'

%"&*#$1#$*%'#1@K'U\?1Q'X'5+*AH@*%J'EZZ`[J'L+$;+'>"12@'#+"A'#*'@"#'>*L"?'&*1>@'U8#"<"%@J'

V1<"##1J'X'!$@#J'.__R[O''8#/+>A1;+"?'1%2']1>#"?@I@'U.___['A"#1M1%1>Q@$@'@+*L"2'#+1#'A"%'#"%2'

#*'*/#H"?)*?A'L*A"%'$%';>1$A$%&'";*%*A$;'<1>/"O''-/?#+"?J'$%'#"?A@'*)'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"J'L*A"%'

A1Q'"<1>/1#"'#+"$?'*L%'H"?)*?A1%;"'>"@@')1<*?19>QJ'"<"%'$%'#+"'19@"%;"'*)'H"?)*?A1%;"'

2$))"?"%;"@'U\?1Q'X'5+*AH@*%J'EZZ`c']1#@*%'X'0*))A1%J'.__b[O'

7 P/("7(/0/&#7;"1%&"7&",-&+*+M7,%7(45%%07IH.30%#."+,79-&="#JD77B1?#$;$H1%#@'$%2$;1#"2'#+"'

 91@"'@1>1?Q'*)'#+"$?'H?"<$*/@':*9'#+1#'#+"Q'+">2'$AA"2$1#">Q'H?$*?'#*'9/@$%"@@'@;+**>O''5+$@'L1@'

$%;>/2"2'1@'1';*%#?*>'2/"'$#@'H*#"%#$1>'?*>"'1@'1'?")"?"%;"'H*$%#'1&1$%@#'L+$;+'"AH>*Q""@'A$&+#'

;*AH1?"'#+"$?';/??"%#'>"<">'*)';*AH"%@1#$*%O'

7 HO3"4,/,*%+(7%17Q-,-&"7K+,"&/4,*%+7IH.30%#."+,79-&="#JD''5*'1;;*/%#')*?'#+"'H*@@$9$>$#Q'

#+1#'%"&*#$1#$*%'"GH"?$"%;"@'1?"'A*?"')*?A1#$<"'L+"%'$%#"?1;#$%&'L$#+'1')/#/?"';*>>"1&/"J'

 H1?#$;$H1%#@'$%2$;1#"2'L+"#+"?'#+"Q'"GH";#"2')/#/?"'$%#"?1;#$*%'L$#+'#+"$?':*9'%"&*#$1#$*%'

;*/%#"?H1?#'Ud()'#+"'H"*H>"'L$#+'L+*A'Q*/'%"&*#$1#"2J'#*'L+1#'"G#"%#'Q*/'"GH";#'#*'$%#"?1;#'

1&1$%'L$#+'1%Q'*)'#+"A'*%;"'Q*/'9"&$%'#+"'H*@$#$*%seJ'@;1>"'.nd+%,7/,7/00 e'#*'mnd/7M&"/,7'"/0 e[O'

7 8%(*,*="7/+'7+"M/,*="7/11"4,7IH.30%#."+,79-&="#JD77B1?#$;$H1%#@'$%2$;1#"2'#+"$?'>"<">@'*)'

 H*@$#$<"'1%2'%"&1#$<"'1))";#'L$#+'@$%&>"'$#"A'A"1@/?"@'*%'mMH*$%#'@;1>"@3'd5*'L+1#'"G#"%#'2*'Q*/'

&"%"?1>>Q')"">'H*@$#$<"'"A*#$*%@'U"O&OJ'1;#$<"J'1>"?#J'1##"%#$<"J'2"#"?A$%"2J'"%#+/@$1@#$;J'"G;$#"2J'

$%@H$?"2J'$%#"?"@#"2J'H?*/2J'@#?*%&[se'1%2'd5*'L+1#'"G#"%#'2*'Q*/'&"%"?1>>Q')"">'%"&1#$<"'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 14/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''.^'

"A*#$*%@'U"O&OJ'1)?1$2J'1&$#1#"2J'1>1?A"2J'1%#1&*%$@#$;J'1HH?"+"%@$<"J'1@+1A"2J'&/$>#QJ'$??$#19>"J'

%"?<*/@J'*?'/H@"#[se''5+"'#L*'A"1@/?"@'L"?"'%*#'@$&%$)$;1%#>Q';*??">1#"2'L$#+'*%"'1%*#+"?'

U& 'n'O.`J'+([O''B?"<$*/@'?"@"1?;+'/@$%&'@$%&>"M$#"A'1))";#'@;1>"@'+1@'2"A*%@#?1#"2'1;;"H#19>"'

 H@Q;+*A"#?$;'H?*H"?#$"@O'',/@@">>J']"$@@J'1%2'Y"%2">@*+%'U._j_[')*/%2'1';*??">1#$*%'9"#L""%'

#+"$?'@$%&>"M$#"A'@;1>"')*?'H>"1@1%#%"@@M/%H>"1@1%#%"@@'*)'ORm'L$#+'H*@$#$<"'1))";#'1%2'MO^`'L$#+'

%"&1#$<"'1))";#O''F92">M\+1>"K'UEZZb[')*/%2'1'*%"ML""K'#"@#M?"#"@#'?">$19$>$#Q'*)'Ojb')*?'1'@$%&>"M

$#"A'A"1@/?"'*)'+1HH$%"@@O'']"')/?#+"?'<1>$21#"2'*/?'@$%&>"M$#"A'@;1>"@'9Q'"G1A$%$%&'#+"$?'

;*%<"?&"%;"'L$#+'#+"')/>>M>"%&#+'B*@$#$<"'1%2'7"&1#$<"'F))";#'8;1>"'UBF7F8c']1#@*%J'W>1?KJ'X'

5">>"&"%J'._jj[J'L+$;+'19*/#'+1>)'*)'#+"'H1?#$;$H1%#@'+12';*AH>"#"2'2/?$%&'#+"$?'%"&*#$1#$*%@'

;*/?@"'$%'D1%/1?Q'*)'EZZ`O''V1@"2'*%' R nR_J';*%<"?&"%#'<1>$2$#Q';*"))$;$"%#@'L"?"'OER')*?'H*@$#$<"'

1))";#'1%2'O`b')*?'%"&1#$<"'1))";#J'L+$;+'$%2$;1#"2'1;;"H#19>"'H?*H"?#$"@')*?'#+"@"'@$%&>"M$#"A'

A"1@/?"@O''

5+"'$%;>/@$*%'*)'#+"@"'A"1@/?"@'1>>*L@'/@'#*';*%#?*>')*?';*AA*%'A"#+*2'9$1@J'&$<"%'#+1#'

 9*#+'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'1%2':*9'1##$#/2"@'L"?"'@">)M?"H*?#'A"1@/?"@'/@$%&'mMH*$%#'?1#$%&'@;1>"@O''

B*2@1K*))J'Y1;\"%S$"J'C""J'1%2'B*2@1K*))'UEZZR['1?&/"2'#+1#';*%#?*>>$%&')*?'A"1@/?"@'#+1#'

@+1?"'#+"';*AA*%'A"#+*2T$%'122$#$*%'#*'/@$%&'>*%&$#/2$%1>'2"@$&%@'@*'#+1#'A"1@/?"@'1?"'

;*>>";#"2'2/?$%&'2$@#$%;#'@"@@$*%@T1?"'1A*%&'#+"'?";*AA"%2"2'H?1;#$;"@'#*'1<*$2'#+"'H?*9>"A@'

*)';*AA*%'A"#+*2'9$1@O''-/?#+"?J'$%;>/2$%&'H*@$#$<"'1%2'%"&1#$<"'1))";#'1>>*L"2'/@'#*';*%#?*>'

)*?'1%Q'H*#"%#$1>>Q'@H/?$*/@'?">1#$*%@+$H@'#+1#'A$&+#'1HH"1?'9"#L""%'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'1%2':*9'

1##$#/2"@'1@'1'?"@/>#'*)'/%2"?>Q$%&'#?1$#'>"<">@'*)'2$@H*@$#$*%1>'1))";#'U8#1L'"#'1>OJ'._jb[O''

7 E%;7K+'-(,&*"(7/+'7Q-+4,*%+(7IH.30%#."+,79-&="#JD'F@'1';*%#?*>')*?':*9';+1?1;#"?$@#$;@J'

 H1?#$;$H1%#@'$%2$;1#"2'#+"':*9'$%2/@#?Qj'1%2':*9')/%;#$*%_')*?'#+"'H*@$#$*%@'#+"Q'1;;"H#"2O'6%'*?2"?'

#*'>$A$#'#+"'H?*>$)"?1#$*%'*)';*%#?*>'<1?$19>"@J'L"';*%2/;#"2'1%1>Q@"@'*)'<1?$1%;"'#*'2"#"?A$%"'

L+"#+"?'#+"?"'L"?"'2$))"?"%;"@'$%':*9'1##$#/2"@'1;?*@@'#+"@"';1#"&*?$"@')*?'L+$;+'+7'RJ'@"H1?1#">Q'

)*?':*9'$%2/@#?$"@'1%2')/%;#$*%@O''!$<"%'#+1#'W*%@/>#$%&t8#?1#"&$;'B>1%%$%&'L1@'1@@*;$1#"2'L$#+'

$%;?"1@"2';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'1%2'-$%1%;"'L1@'1@@*;$1#"2'L$#+'2";?"1@"2'$%#"%#$*%'#*'

#/?%*<"?J'#+"@"'#L*'<1?$19>"@'1?"';*%#?*>@'$%'1>>'+QH*#+"@$@'#"@#$%&O''

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 15/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''.`'

,"@/>#@'

519>"'.'?"H*?#@'#+"'A"1%@'1%2'@#1%21?2'2"<$1#$*%@'*)'#+"'@#/2Q'A"1@/?"@J'1%2'519>"'E'

;*%#1$%@'9$<1?$1#"';*??">1#$*%@'1A*%&'#+"@"'<1?$19>"@O''519>"'R'>$@#@'#+"'#QH"@'*)';*%;"@@$*%@'

?"H*?#"2'9Q'#+*@"' R nR_'$%2$<$2/1>@'L+*';*AH>"#"2'#+"')?""M?"@H*%@"'A"1@/?"O''5+$@';*??"@H*%2@'

#*'1%'"))";#$<"'?"@H*%@"'?1#"'*)'bZk'1A*%&'#+"'+nb`'$%2$<$2/1>@'L+*'+12'?"H*?#"2'1'%*%MS"?*'

%/A"?$;1>'2*>>1?'<1>/"')*?';*%;"@@$*%@O''F>#+*/&+'$#'L*/>2'9"'<1>/19>"'#*'1%1>QS"'@"H1?1#">Q'1@'1'

;*%#?*>'<1?$19>"'#+"'1A*/%#'*)'91@"'@1>1?Q'%"&*#$1#"2T1%2'*/?'21#1'@"#'2*"@'%*#'1>>*L'/@'#*'2*'

@*T$#'$@'%*#"L*?#+Q'#+1#'*%>Q'RRk'*)'H1?#$;$H1%#@'%"&*#$1#"2'#+"$?'91@"'@1>1?Q'1%2J'*)'#+"@"J'91@"'

 H1Q'L1@'#QH$;1>>Q'*%"'*)'#L*'$@@/"@'*%'L+$;+'#+"Q'?";"$<"2';*%;"@@$*%@O'

6%'@/HH*?#'*)'0QH*#+"@$@'.J'8='+12'+$&+';*%@$@#"%;Q'1;?*@@'#+"'#L*'@/?<"Q@'U& 'n'Om^[J'

$%2$;1#$%&'#+1#'?";*>>";#$*%@'*)'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'1?"'?*9/@#'*<"?'#$A"O'6%'@/HH*?#'*)'0QH*#+"@$@'EJ'

519>"'^';*%#1$%@'#+"'?"@/>#@'*)'?"&?"@@$*%'A*2">@'H?"2$;#$%&':*9'1##$#/2"@J'$%'L+$;+'&?"1#"?'8='

?"H*?#"2'@+*?#>Q'1)#"?'1':*9'%"&*#$1#$*%'H?"2$;#@'&?"1#"?';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'&?"1#"?':*9'

@1#$@)1;#$*%J'1%2'>*L"?'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%'1'Q"1?'>1#"?O''6%'@/HH*?#'*)'0QH*#+"@$@'RJ'9Q';*%#?1@#'

L$#+'8=J';*"))$;$"%#@')*?'#+"'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'*)';*%;"@@$*%@'?"H*?#"2'@+*?#>Q'1)#"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@'

L"?"'%"&>$&$9>"'1%2'%*%M@$&%$)$;1%#'$%'H?"2$;#$%&'>1#"?'1##$#/2"@O'']1>2'#"@#@'$%2$;1#"'#+1#'#+"@"'

?"&?"@@$*%';*"))$;$"%#@')*?'8='1%2';*%;"@@$*%'<1>/"@'2$))"?"2'@$&%$)$;1%#>Q')*?';*AH"%@1#$*%'

@1#$@)1;#$*%J' Q U.J'`j['n'mObjJ' 3'r'OZ.J'9/#'%*#')*?'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%J' Q U.J'`j['n'EOm`J' 3 O.Z'*?':*9'

@1#$@)1;#$*%J' QI .J'`j['n'EOZjJ' 3nO.bJ'1>>'<1>/"@'#L*M#1$>"2O''

6%'*?2"?'#*'?/>"'*/#'1'H*#"%#$1>';*%)*/%2$%&')1;#*?'9Q'#"@#$%&'L+"#+"?'#+"@"'?"@/>#@'1?"'

?*9/@#'#*'L+"#+"?'H1?#$;$H1%#@'A1Q'+1<"'%"&*#$1#"2'L$#+'#+"$?')/#/?"'@/H"?<$@*?J'122$#$*%1>'

A*2">@'$%;>/2"2'1%'$%#"?1;#$*%'#"?A'*)'8='1%2'#+"$?'"GH";#1#$*%@'*)')/#/?"'$%#"?1;#$*%O''5+"@"'

#"?A@'L"?"'%"&>$&$9>"'1%2'%*%M@$&%$)$;1%#')*?';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%'U;nMOZ^[J':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'

U;nOZR[J'1%2'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%'U;nOZE[J'1%2'#+"$?'$%;>/@$*%';+1%&"2'#+"';*"))$;$"%#@')*?'8='9Q'

OZ.'*?'>"@@O'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 16/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''.b'

' !$<"%'?"@"1?;+'@/&&"@#$%&'#+1#'1##$#/2"@'#*L1?2@';*AH"%@1#$*%'1?"'1A*%&'#+"'A*@#'

)*?A1#$<"'*%'*<"?1>>':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'1%2'*#+"?'1##$#/2"@'Uf?"+"?'"#'1>OJ'._jjc']$>>$1A@'"#'1>OJ'

EZZb[J'L"';*%2/;#"2'1')/?#+"?'1%1>Q@$@'#*'"G1A$%"'L+"#+"?';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%'A"2$1#"@'

#+"'?">1#$*%@+$H@'9"#L""%'8='1%2':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'*?'9"#L""%'8='1%2'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%J'/@$%&'

#+"')*/?'&/$2">$%"@')*?'#"@#$%&'A"2$1#$*%'*/#>$%"2'9Q'V1?*%'1%2'\"%%Q'U._jb[O''-*?':*9'

@1#$@)1;#$*%J'U.['1@'?"H*?#"2'$%'Y*2">'b'$%'519>"'^J'8='H?"2$;#@';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%'U;'n'

O^.J', 'n'RO`R[c'UE['$%'A*2">@'L$#+'#+"'@1A"';*%#?*>@J';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%'H?"2$;#@'&?"1#"?'

 :*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'U;7n'O`.J', 'n'ROmRJ'H'r'OZ.[c'UR[';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%'H?"2$;#@':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'

L+"%'122"2'#*'Y*2">'b'U;'n'O^`J', nEO_RJ' 3'r'OZ.['L+$>"'?"2/;$%&'#+"'@$S"'*)'#+"';*"))$;$"%#')*?'

8='U;'nO.bJ7, 'n'.OZjJ'+([J'1%2'U^['#+$@'2";?"1@"'$@'@$&%$)$;1%#'1;;*?2$%&'#*'1'8*9">'#"@#'U, 'n'EOE`J' 3'

r'OZ`[O''-*?'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%@J'U.['1@'?"H*?#"2'$%'Y*2">'_$%'519>"'^J'8='H?"2$;#@'#/?%*<"?'

$%#"%#$*%'U;'n'MORmJ', 'n'MEOj_J' 3rOZ.[c'UE['$%'A*2">@'L$#+'#+"'@1A"';*%#?*>@J';*AH"%@1#$*%'

@1#$@)1;#$*%'H?"2$;#@'>*L"?'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%'U;'n'MOE_J7,7n'MEO.bJ' 3rOZ`[c'UR[';*AH"%@1#$*%'

@1#$@)1;#$*%'2*"@'%*#'H?"2$;#'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%'L+"%'122"2'#*'Y*2">'_'U;'n'MO.bJ', nM.O..J'%@['

L+"?"1@'8='$@'@#$>>'1'@$&%$)$;1%#'H?"2$;#*?'U;'nMOR.J7,7n'MEO.bJ73rOZ`[J'1%2'U^['#+"'2";?"1@"')*?'#+"'

;*"))$;$"%#'*)'8='$@'%*#'@$&%$)$;1%#'1;;*?2$%&'#*'1'8*9">'#"@#'U,7n'.OZbJ'+([O''5+"@"'#"@#@'$%2$;1#"'

#+1#';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%'A"2$1#"@'#+"'?">1#$*%@+$H'9"#L""%'8='1%2':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'9/#'%*#'

#+"'?">1#$*%@+$H'9"#L""%'8='1%2'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%O'

f$@;/@@$*%'

' 5+"@"')$%2$%&@'#">>'1'H?*<*;1#$<"'@#*?Q'19*/#'#+"'H*#"%#$1>'H*L"?'*)'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'$%'

%"&*#$1#$*%'#*'H?"2$;#'@/9@"N/"%#'1##$#/2"@'1%2'9"+1<$*?1>'$%#"%#$*%@O''5+"'8='#+1#'$%;*A$%&'

"AH>*Q""@'1;+$"<"2'2/?$%&'#+"$?':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@'@$&%$)$;1%#>Q'H?"2$;#"2';*AH"%@1#$*%'

@1#$@)1;#$*%J':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'1%2'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%'A"1@/?"2'*<"?'*%"')/>>'Q"1?'1)#"?'#+"'

%"&*#$1#$*%@'+12'#1K"%'H>1;"O''f/?$%&'#+$@'#$A"J'H1?#$;$H1%#@'H?"@/A19>Q'L"?"'"GH*@"2'#*'1'L$2"'

?1%&"'*)'*#+"?'$%#"?<"%$%&')1;#*?@'#+1#';*/>2'+1<"'1))";#"2'#+"$?':*9'1##$#/2"@J'@/;+'1@'#+"'

;+1?1;#"?$@#$;@'*)'#+"$?':*9@J'#+"$?'$%#"?1;#$*%@'L$#+'@/H"?<$@*?@'1%2';*ML*?K"?@J'1%2'#+"'@/;;"@@'

*)'#+"';*AH1%QO''(/?'?"@/>#@'2"A*%@#?1#"'%*#'*%>Q'#+"'?*9/@#%"@@'*)'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"J'9/#'1>@*'$#@'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 17/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''.m'

$AH*?#1%#'H*#"%#$1>';*%@"N/"%;"@O''VQ';*%#?1@#J'#+"'1;#/1>'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'1;+$"<"2'$%'#+"@"'

%"&*#$1#$*%@'+12'%*'1@@*;$1#$*%'L$#+':*9'1##$#/2"@'*?'$%#"%#$*%@'#*'>"1<"T1'H1?#$;/>1?>Q'@#?$K$%&'

)$%2$%&'&$<"%'#+"'+$&+'";*%*A$;'@#1K"@'*)'#+"':*9'%"&*#$1#$*%O''

' (/?'@#/2Q'$@'1A*%&'#+"')"L')$">2'@#/2$"@'*)'?"1>'L*?>2'%"&*#$1#$*%@O''!$<"%'#+1#'

1?&/A"%#@')*?'#+"'<1>/"'*)'8='"AH+1@$S"'#+"'@+12*L'#+1#'$#';1%';1@#'*%'#+"')/#/?"J'L"'"G1A$%"2'

$#@';*%@"N/"%;"@'$%'1'>*%&M#"?A'@"##$%&'L$#+'+$&+M@#1K"@O''5+"'@+""?'%/A9"?'*)'$@@/"@'>$@#"2'$%'

519>"'R'@/&&"@#@'#+1#'#+$@'L1@'1';*AH>"G'%"&*#$1#$*%T?1#+"?'#+1%'1'@$AH>"'#/&M*)ML1?'*<"?'91@"'

@1>1?QTL+$;+'A1Q'H?*<$2"'1AH>"'?**A')*?'";*%*A$;'1%2'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'#*'9";*A"'2";*/H>"2'

)?*A'"1;+'*#+"?O''-/?#+"?J'*/?')$">2'@#/2Q';*%#"G#'"%19>"2'/@'#*'A"1@/?"';*%@"N/"%;"@'*)'8=T 

;*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%J':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'1%2'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%@T#+1#'+1<"'H*#"%#$1>>Q')1?M

?"1;+$%&'$AH>$;1#$*%@')*?'9*#+'"AH>*Q""@'1%2'#+"'*?&1%$S1#$*%@'#+1#'+$?"'#+"A'UV1#"A1%'X'

(?&1%J'._jRc'W/??1>>'"#'1>OJ'EZZ`c'(@#"?A1%J'._jmc']$>>$1A@J'Y;f1%$">J'X'7&/Q"%J'EZZb[O''5+$@'

&$<"@'#+"'H?"@"%#'@#/2Q'9?*12'?">"<1%;"'9"Q*%2'#+"')$">2'*)'%"&*#$1#$*%@'?"@"1?;+O'

 S*.*,/,*%+(7/+'7Q-,-&"7T"("/&457

F>#+*/&+'#+"'?"@/>#@'*)'#+$@'@#/2Q'1?"'$%#?$&/$%&J'*/?';*%;>/@$*%@'1?"'#"AH"?"2'9Q'1'

%/A9"?'*)'$AH*?#1%#'@+*?#;*A$%&@'#+1#'1?"'L*?#+'122?"@@$%&'$%')/#/?"'L*?KO''-$?@#J'1>>'?"H*?#"2'

)$%2$%&@'1?"'*9@"?<1#$*%1>J'1%2'1@'@/;+J'L"';1%%*#';*%)$?A';1/@1>'$%)"?"%;"@O''P%A"1@/?"2'

<1?$19>"@'A1Q'+1<"'$%)>/"%;"2'9*#+'H?"2$;#*?'1%2'2"H"%2"%#'A"1@/?"@O''-*?'$%@#1%;"J';"?#1$%'

"AH>*Q"?@'A1Q'9"'A*?"'"))";#$<"'1#'A1K$%&'9*#+'#+"$?':*9';1%2$21#"@'1%2'"AH>*Q""@')"">'&**2J'

L+"?"1@'*#+"?'"AH>*Q"?@'A1Q'#?"1#'9*#+'H?*@H";#$<"'1%2';/??"%#'"AH>*Q""@'H**?>QO''

F>#"?%1#$<">QJ';"?#1$%'$%2$<$2/1>@'A1Q'#"%2'#*'">$;$#'&**2'#?"1#A"%#')?*A'*#+"?@'1%2J'1@'1'?"@/>#J'

#+*@"'$%2$<$2/1>@'A$&+#'9"'#?"1#"2'L">>'9*#+'2/?$%&'#+"$?':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@'1%2'*%'1'21$>Q'

 91@$@'1#'L*?KO''0*L"<"?J'"<"%'$)'#+"@"'1>#"?%1#$<"'"GH>1%1#$*%@'L"?"'#?/"J'#+"'H?"@"%#'@#/2Q'@#$>>'

"@#19>$@+"@':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%'8='1@'1%'"1?>Q'$%2$;1#*?'*)')/#/?"':*9M?">1#"2'1##$#/2"@TL+$;+'$@'

@#?$K$%&'$%'#+1#':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@'?"H?"@"%#'*%>Q'1')$?@#'9?$")'"GH"?$"%;"'L$#+'*%"I@'"AH>*Q"?J'

$%';*%#?1@#'#*'#+"'"%#$?"')$?@#'Q"1?'*)'"AH>*QA"%#O'''

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 18/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''.j'

F>*%&'#+"@"'>$%"@J'*%"'A$&+#'@H";/>1#"'#+1#'8='$%)>/"%;"@')/#/?"':*9'1##$#/2"@'A"?">Q'

 9";1/@"'$#'?")>";#@'"AH>*Q""@I'12<1%;"'9">$")@'19*/#'+*L'L">>'#+"Q'L$>>'9"'#?"1#"2'*%'1':*9O''6%'

*?2"?'#*'122?"@@'#+$@'H*@@$9$>$#QJ'L"';*>>";#"2'122$#$*%1>'"AH>*QA"%#'@/?<"Q'21#1'L$#+'#+"'YVF'

;>1@@'*)'EZZm'U R n.._.Z

[J'/@$%&'#+"';/??"%#'A"1@/?"@'1%2'1%'122$#$*%1>'$#"A'd6%'&"%"?1>J'+*L'

@1#$@)$"2'2*'Q*/'"GH";#'Q*/'L$>>'9"'L+$>"'L*?K$%&'1#'Q*/?'%"L':*9e'UmMH*$%#'@;1>"')?*A' (,&%+M0#7

'*(/M&""'#*' (,&%+M0#7/M&""[O''F>#+*/&+'L"';*/>2'%*#';*>>";#'122$#$*%1>'1>/A%$'@/?<"Q'21#1'#*'/@"'

#+$@'A"1@/?"'1@'1';*<1?$1#"'$%'+QH*#+"@$@'#"@#$%&J'L"';*/>2'2"A*%@#?1#"'#+1#'$#'$@';*%;"H#/1>>Q'

2$@#$%;#')?*A'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"O''-$?@#J'"GH";#"2'@1#$@)1;#$*%'1%2'8=';*??">1#"2'1#'& nORZJ' 3rOZ.J'

L+$;+'$@'A*2"?1#"'9/#'L">>'9">*L'*%"J'1%2'L">>'9">*L'#+"'#"@#M?"#"@#'?">$19$>$#Q'*)'8='*)'Om^T 

$%2$;1#$%&'#+1#'#+"@"'1?"'*<"?>1HH$%&'Q"#'2$@#$%;#';*%@#?/;#@O''f$@1##"%/1#$%&')*?'A"1@/?"A"%#'

"??*?T)*?'8='/@$%&'#+"'1>H+1'*)'O_RJ'1%2')*?'#+"'@$%&>"M$#"A'"GH";#"2'@1#$@)1;#$*%'@;1>"'$%)"??$%&'

#+"'>$K">Q'A"1@/?"A"%#'"??*?'91@"2'*%'#+"'$%#"?M$#"A';*??">1#$*%'*)'& nOmE')?*A'#+"'#L*M$#"A':*9'

@1#$@)1;#$*%'@;1>"'$%'#+"'1>/A%$'@/?<"QTQ$">2@'1%'"@#$A1#"2'#?/"';*??">1#$*%'*)'O^`J'1&1$%'L">>'

 9">*L'*%"O''8";*%2J''#+"'1<"?1&"'9$<1?$1#"';*??">1#$*%'1A*%&'#+"'.R'$#"A@'*)'#+"'8=6'$@'&7n'O^_J'

L+"?"1@'#+"'1<"?1&"';*??">1#$*%'9"#L""%'#+"'$%2$<$2/1>'8=6'N/"@#$*%@'1%2'"GH";#"2'@1#$@)1;#$*%'

$@'A/;+'>*L"?'1#'& nOERT1&1$%J'@/&&"@#$%&'#+1#'8=';1H#/?"@'1';*%@#?/;#'#+1#'$@'2$@#$%;#')?*A'

"AH>*Q""@I'H?$*?'9">$")@'19*/#'+*L'L">>'#+"Q'L$>>'9"'#?"1#"2O'''

5+1#'@1$2J'"AH>*Q""@I'"GH";#1#$*%@'*)'1':*9'1?"'>$K">Q'#*'9"'$%)>/"%;"2'9Q'#+"$?'

"GH"?$"%;"@'L$#+'?"H?"@"%#1#$<"@'*)'#+1#'*?&1%$S1#$*%J'1%2'@/;+'"GH";#1#$*%@'L*/>2'9"'

L*?#+L+$>"'#*'$%;>/2"'1@'H*#"%#$1>'A"2$1#$%&'<1?$19>"@'$%')/#/?"'L*?KO''!$<"%'#+1#'#+"';*??">1#$*%'

 9"#L""%'8='1%2'@/;+'"GH";#1#$*%@'$@'>*L"?'#+1%'#+"'@#1%21?2$S"2'"))";#'@$S"@'$%'#+"'H?"@"%#'

@#/2QJ'L"'"GH";#'#+1#'$#';*/>2'@"?<"'1@'1'H1?#$1>'9/#'%*#';*AH>"#"'A"2$1#*?O''-/?#+"?'?"@"1?;+'

@+*/>2'122?"@@'$%'&?"1#"?'2"H#+'1'?1%&"'*)'H*#"%#$1>'A"2$1#$%&')1;#*?@'9"#L""%'8='1%2':*9'

1##$#/2"@O''5+"'?"@/>#@'*)'*/?'A"2$1#$*%'1%1>Q@"@'$AH>Q'#+1#':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%'"GH"?$"%;"'

$%$#$1>>Q';*>*?@'H"?;"H#$*%@'*)';*AH"%@1#$*%'L+$;+J'$%'#/?%J'@H?"12@'#*'@1#$@)1;#$*%'L$#+'#+"':*9'$%'

&"%"?1>O''0*L"<"?J'#+$@'L1@'%*#'#+"';1@"')*?'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%@O'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 19/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''._'

F'@";*%2'A1:*?'>$A$#1#$*%'$@'#+"'@$S"'1%2'%1#/?"'*)'#+"'@1AH>"J'1>*%&'L$#+'#+"'H1?#$;/>1?'

;*%#"G#')?*A'L+$;+'#+"'H1?#$;$H1%#@'L"?"'2?1L%O..'F'>1?&"?'@1AH>"'@$S"'?">1#$<"'#*'#+"'%/A9"?'*)'

<1?$19>"@'@#/2$"2'L*/>2'H?*<$2"'A*?"'H?";$@"'"))";#'@$S"'"@#$A1#"@O''5+"'@1AH>"'@$S"'1>@*'>$A$#"2'

*/?'19$>$#Q'#*'2$@#$%&/$@+')$%2$%&@'1;?*@@'#+"')*/?';*AH*%"%#@'*)'8=J'L+$;+'1?"'1&&?"&1#"2'

#*&"#+"?'$%'#+"'H?"@"%#'1%1>Q@"@O''-/?#+"?J'#+"'&"%"?1>$#Q'*)'#+"@"')$%2$%&@'A1Q'9"'>$A$#"2'9Q'#+"'

$2$*@Q%;?1#$;'%1#/?"'*)'#+"'@1AH>"J'$%'L+$;+'YVF'@#/2"%#@')?*A'1%'">$#"'/%$<"?@$#Q'%"&*#$1#"2'

*<"?'"%#?QM>"<">'H*@$#$*%@'L$#+'A1%1&"?$1>'H*#"%#$1>O''5+"@"'@#/2"%#@'L"?"'1>>'"GH*@"2'#*'#+"'

)/%21A"%#1>';*%;"H#@'*)'%"&*#$1#$*%@'$%'#+"$?'?"N/$?"2';*/?@"L*?KJ'1%2'A1%Q'?";"$<"2')/?#+"?'

$%@#?/;#$*%'#+?*/&+'H*H/>1?'">";#$<"';*/?@"@O'

F'#+$?2'>$A$#1#$*%'*)'*/?'@#/2Q'$@'#+1#'#+"'2"H"%2"%#'A"1@/?"@'L"?"'1##$#/2$%1>'1@'*HH*@"2'

#*'9"+1<$*?1>O''F>#+*/&+'H?$*?'?"@"1?;+'+1@'>$%K"2';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%J':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'

1%2'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%'#*'1'?1%&"'*)'$AH*?#1%#'9"+1<$*?1>'*/#;*A"@J'L"'L"?"'%*#'19>"'#*'A"1@/?"'

@/;+'9"+1<$*?@'$%'#+"'H?"@"%#'@#/2QO'

-*/?#+J'*/?'A"1@/?"@'L"?"'1>>'@">)M?"H*?#"2'9Q'H1?#$;$H1%#@O''8/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'1%2':*9'

1##$#/2"@'1?"'%*#'?"12$>Q'1A"%19>"'#*'%*%M@">)'?"H*?#"2'A"#+*2@J'1%2'B*2@1K*))'"#'1>OI@'UEZZR['

 9"@#'H?1;#$;"@'1@@/1&"2';*%;"?%@'19*/#';*AA*%'A"#+*2'9$1@'#*'#+"'"G#"%#'H*@@$9>"O''(/?'

A"1@/?"'*)'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'L1@'%*#'%";"@@1?$>Q'1%'*9:";#$<"'1@@"@@A"%#J'$%'#+1#'A1%Q'

;*%;"@@$*%@'?";"$<"2'9Q'H1?#$;$H1%#@'1?"'A*?"'@/9:";#'#*'$%#"?H?"#1#$*%'#+1%'*#+"?@'$%'#"?A@'*)'

N/1%#$)$;1#$*%'$%'2*>>1?'#"?A@'U"O&OJ':*9'#$#>"'<@O'@#1?#$%&'9*%/@[O''-"L'@#/2$"@'*)'%"&*#$1#$*%'+1<"'

#1K"%'H>1;"'*/#@$2"'*)'#+"'>19*?1#*?Q'$%'H1?#'9";1/@"'$#'$@';+1>>"%&$%&'#*')$%2'H1?#$;$H1%#@'L+*'

"%&1&"'$%'@$A$>1?'%"&*#$1#$*%@'1%2'L+*@"'*/#;*A"@';1%'9"'A"1@/?"2'/@$%&'1';*%@$@#"%#'A"#?$;O''

6%'#+"'H?"@"%#'@#/2QJ'L"'1##"AH#"2'#*'122?"@@'#+$@';*%;"?%'9Q'1@K$%&'H1?#$;$H1%#@'#*'H?*<$2"'1'

A*%"#1?Q'"N/$<1>"%#'*)'#+"$?'%"&*#$1#"2';*%;"@@$*%@O''0$&+'#"@#M?"#"@#';*%@$@#"%;Q'@H"1K@'#*'#+"'

<1>$2$#Q'*)'#+$@'A"#+*2O''-/?#+"?J'+$&+';*??">1#$*%@'9"#L""%'91@"'@1>1?Q'1%2'+$&+';*AH"%@1#$*%'

@1#$@)1;#$*%J'+$&+':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'1%2'>*L'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%'@/&&"@#'#+1#'H1?#$;$H1%#@'2$2'

?">$19>Q'@">)M?"H*?#'*#+"?')$%1%;$1>'21#1O''4<"%'@*J'$)'8='+12';*%#1A$%1#"2'H1?#$;$H1%#@I'?"H*?#$%&'

*)'";*%*A$;'<1>/"J'#+"%'#+"'$%)>/"%;"'*)'8='*%')/#/?"':*9'1##$#/2"@'L*/>2'+1<"';?"1#"2'1%'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 20/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''EZ'

$>>/@*?Q';*??">1#$*%'9"#L""%'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@'1%2':*9'1##$#/2"@J'L+$;+'L"'2$2'%*#'@""'$%'#+"@"'

21#1O''5+$@'@/&&"@#@'#+1#'*/?'1%1>Q@"@'?"H?"@"%#'1';*%@"?<1#$<"'#"@#'*)'#+"'$%)>/"%;"'*)'";*%*A$;'

;*%;"@@$*%@'*%':*9'1##$#/2"@O''5+1#'@1$2J'1'#?/>Q'*9:";#$<"'A"1@/?"'*)'";*%*A$;'<1>/"J'$%'122$#$*%'

#*'A"1@/?"@'*)'1;#/1>':*9'9"+1<$*?J'L*/>2'9"'2"@$?19>"O'''

5+"')$%2$%&@'H?"@"%#"2'+"?"'H*$%#'#*'1'%/A9"?'*)'122$#$*%1>')/#/?"'2$?";#$*%@')*?'?"@"1?;+'

*%'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'1%2'%"&*#$1#$*%O''-$?@#J'#+"'H?"@"%#'@#/2Q')*;/@"@'*%'#+"'8='*)':*9';1%2$21#"@J'

 9/#'2*"@'%*#';*%@$2"?'#+"'8='*)'?";?/$#"?@O''f/?$%&'#+"$?':*9'*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@J'$%;*A$%&'

"AH>*Q""@';*/>2'A1K"'1'>1@#$%&'$AH?"@@$*%'*%'#+"$?'"AH>*Q"?@J'1%2'$#'L*/>2'9"'$%#"?"@#$%&'#*'

#?1;K'#+"';*%@"N/"%;"@'*)'?";?/$#"?@I'8=O''8";*%2J'1%2'A*?"'9?*12>QJ'#+"'H?"@"%#'@#/2Q'#?"1#@'8='

1@'1'H?"2$;#*?'9/#'>"1<"@'*H"%'#+"'N/"@#$*%'*)'+*L'$#'$@')*@#"?"2O''6%'*?2"?')*?'+/A1%'?"@*/?;"@'

2"H1?#A"%#@'*?'*#+"?'%"&*#$1#*?@'#*';1H$#1>$S"'*%'#+"'1HH1?"%#'9"%")$;$1>'"))";#@'*)'$%<*K$%&'+$&+'

8='$%'#+"$?';*/%#"?H1?#@J'#+"'@H";$)$;'2"#"?A$%1%#@'*)'8='L*/>2'%""2'#*'9"'$2"%#$)$"2O'''

C%+40-(*%+7

]"'9">$"<"'#+1#'*/?')$%2$%&@'+1<"'$AH*?#1%#'$AH>$;1#$*%@')*?'?"@"1?;+'1%2'H?1;#$;"O''-*?'

?"@"1?;+"?@J'*/?')$%2$%&@'@/&&"@#'#+1#'A"1@/?$%&'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@'1>*%"'A1Q'>$A$#'#+"'

&"%"?1>$#Q'*)';*%;>/@$*%@'?"1;+"2'$%'@#/2$"@'*)'%"&*#$1#$*%O''4<"%'$%'#+"'+$&+M@#1K"@'L*?>2'*)':*9'

*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@J'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@'+12'%*'@$&%$)$;1%#'"))";#'*%'#+"'@/9@"N/"%#':*9'1##$#/2"@'

*)'"AH>*Q""@T9Q';*%#?1@#'L$#+'8=O''-/#/?"'@#/2$"@'L*/>2'2*'L">>'#*'A"1@/?"'@/9:";#$<"'

*/#;*A"@'$%'122$#$*%'#*'*9:";#$<"'*?'";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@O'

-*?'H?1;#$#$*%"?@J'+$?$%&'*?&1%$S1#$*%@'A$&+#'9"%")$#'9Q'H1Q$%&';>*@"'1##"%#$*%'#*'#+"$?':*9'

*))"?'%"&*#$1#$*%@O'']+1#'#?1%@H$?"@'$%'#+"@"'%"&*#$1#$*%@'A1Q'+1<"'>1@#$%&'$AH>$;1#$*%@')*?'#+"'

)/#/?"'"AH>*Q""p"AH>*Q"?'?">1#$*%@+$HO''!$<"%'#+"'1HH1?"%#'2$@;*%%";#'9"#L""%'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'

1%2'>*%&M#"?A'1##$#/2"@J'"AH>*Q"?@'@+*/>2'?"1>$S"'#+1#';*%;"2$%&'*%'*9:";#$<"'$@@/"@'A1Q'+1<"'1'

>$A$#"2'"))";#'*%'"<*K$%&'&**2L$>>')?*A'#+"$?'"AH>*Q""@T"G;"H#'#*'#+"'"G#"%#'#+1#'2*$%&'@*'

$%)>/"%;"@'#+"'"AH>*Q""@I'$AA"2$1#"'8=O''5+$@'@/&&"@#@'#+1#'"AH>*Q"?@'%""2'#*'A1K"'#+"'<1>/"'

*)';*%;"@@$*%@';>"1?'#*'"AH>*Q""@'#*'9"')/>>Q'1HH?";$1#"2O''W*%<"?@">QJ'"%&"%2"?$%&'+$&+'8='$%'

"AH>*Q""@'A1Q'%*#'9"'*9:";#$<">Q'"GH"%@$<"')*?'"AH>*Q"?@O''6%2""2J'@K$>>"2'%"&*#$1#*?@'A1Q'9"'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 21/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''E.'

19>"'#*'1;+$"<"'+$&+'";*%*A$;'<1>/"')*?'#+"A@"><"@'L+$>"'@$A/>#1%"*/@>Q'H?*<$2$%&'+$&+'8=')*?'

#+"$?';*/%#"?H1?#@O''6#'@+*/>2'%*#';*@#'"AH>*Q"?@'A*?"'#*'%"&*#$1#"'L$#+'#+"$?')/#/?"'"AH>*Q""@'$%'

1'A1%%"?'#+1#'"AH+1@$S"@'#+"'>*&$;'1%2'@#1%21?2@'9"+$%2'#+"':*9'*))"?J'#+1#'?"@H";#@';1%2$21#"@I'

 H"?@*%1>'2$&%$#QJ'#+1#'&$<"@';1%2$21#"@'<*$;"'1%2'*#+"?';*%#?*>'*<"?'#+"'H?*;"@@J'1%2'#+/@J'#+1#'

#?"1#@';1%2$21#"@'1@'<1>/"2'?">1#$*%@+$H'H1?#%"?@O''!$<"%'*/?'H?"@"%#')$%2$%&@J'#+"')1;#*?@'#+1#'

$%;?"1@"'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'A1Q'#?/>Q'1>>*L'"AH>*Q"?@'1%2'"AH>*Q""@'#*'&"#'*))'*%'#+"'?$&+#')**#O

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 22/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''EE'

,")"?"%;"@'

F92">M\+1>"KJ'FO'YO'UEZZb[O'Y"1@/?$%&'+1HH$%"@@'L$#+'1'@$%&>"M$#"A'@;1>"O''9%4*/07P"5/=*%&7/+'78"&(%+/0*,#27GL2'.R_M.`ZO'

V1>S"?J']O'\OJ'X'8/>@KQJ'CO'YO'U.__E[O'01>*'1%2'H"?)*?A1%;"'1HH?1$@1>'?"@"1?;+3'F';?$#$;1>'"G1A$%1#$*%O' E%-&+/07%17@330*"'78(#45%0%M#27UU2'_m`p_j`O'

V1?>"QJ'8O',O'U.__.[O''W*%#"G#/1>$S$%&';*%)>$;#3'7*#"@'*%'#+"'1%#+?*H*>*&Q'*)'2$@H/#"@'1%2'%"&*#$1#$*%@O''6%'YO'0O'V1S"?A1%J',O'DO'C"L$;K$J'X'VO'0O'8+"HH1?2'U42@O[J' T"("/&457%+7+"M%,*/,*%+7*+7%&M/+*V/,*%+('U=*>O'RJ'HHO'.b`p.__[O''!?""%L$;+J'W53'DF6'B?"@@O'

V1?*%J',O'YOJ'X'\"%%QJ'fO'FO'U._jb[O''5+"'A*2"?1#*?MA"2$1#*?'<1?$19>"'2$@#$%;#$*%'$%'@*;$1>' H@Q;+*>*&$;1>'?"@"1?;+3'W*%;"H#/1>J'@#?1#"&$;J'1%2'@#1#$@#$;1>';*%@$2"?1#$*%@O' E%-&+/07%17 8"&(%+/0*,#7/+'79%4*/078(#45%0%M#27WB2'..mRM..jEO'

V1#"A1%J'5O'8OJ'X'(?&1%J'fO']O'U._jR[O'D*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%'1%2'#+"'&**2'@*>2$"?3'5+"'?">1#$*%@+$H' 9"#L""%'1))";#'1%2'"AH>*Q""'d;$#$S"%@+$HOe' @4/'".#7%17:/+/M"."+,7E%-&+/027FX27`jmp`_`O'

V1Q1S$#J'YOJ'X'Y1%%$GJ'4O'UEZZR[O'8+*/>2'6'@#1Q'*?'@+*/>2'6'&*s'B?"2$;#$%&'#"1A'A"A9"?@I'$%#"%#'#*'?"A1$%'$%'#+"'#"1AO'9./007Y&%-37T"("/&4527GL2'E_ZpRE.O'

V1S"?A1%J'YO'0OJ'W/?+1%J'DO',OJ'X'Y**?"J'fO'FO'UEZZ.[O'5+"'2"1#+'1%2'?"9$?#+'*)'#+"'@*;$1>' H@Q;+*>*&Q'*)'%"&*#$1#$*%O'6%'!O'DO'(O'->"#;+"?'X'YO'8O'W>1?K'U42@O[J' P0/4Z$"0075/+';%%Z7%17 (%4*/073(#45%0%M#)7K+,"&3"&(%+/073&%4"(("(7 UHHO'._bpEEj[O'(G)*?2J'4%&>1%23'V>1;KL">>O'

V?$")J'FOJ'X']"$@@J'0O'UEZZE[O'(?&1%$S1#$*%1>'9"+1<$*?3'F))";#'$%'#+"'L*?KH>1;"O' @++-/07T"=*"$7

%178(#45%0%M#27WG27Em_MRZmO'

W*%%*>>QJ'DO'DOJ'X'=$@L"@<1?1%J'WO'UEZZZ[O'5+"'?*>"'*)'1))";#$<$#Q'$%':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%3'F'A"#1M1%1>Q@$@O' 8"&(%+/0*,#7/+'7K+'*=*'-/07[*11"&"+4"(27F\27Eb`pEj.O'

W/?+1%J'DO',OJ'4>)"%9"$%J'0O'FOJ'X'4$@"%K?1)#J'7O'U$%'H?"@@[O''5+"'*9:";#$<"'<1>/"'*)'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"3'F'A/>#$M?*/%2'%"&*#$1#$*%'"GH"?$A"%#O'' E%-&+/07%17@330*"'79%4*/078(#45%0%M#O'

W/?+1%J'DO',OJ'4>)"%9"$%J'0O'FOJ'X'a/J'0O'UEZZb[O']+1#'2*'H"*H>"'<1>/"'L+"%'#+"Q'%"&*#$1#"s'Y1HH$%&'#+"'2*A1$%'*)'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'$%'%"&*#$1#$*%O' E%-&+/07%178"&(%+/0*,#7/+'79%4*/07 8(#45%0%M#27\B2'^_Rp`.EO'

W/?+1%J'DO',OJ'7"1>"J'YO'FOJ',*@@J'COJ'X',*@"%;?1%SM4%&">A1%%J'DO'UEZZm[O'65"7]D7A"+&#7H11"4,)765"7K.3/4,7%17T"0/,*%+/07R%&.(7%+7R"M%,*/,*%+7]-,4%."(D'Y1%/@;?$H#'@/9A$##"2')*?'

 H/9>$;1#$*%O''F<1$>19>"')*?'2*L%>*12'<$1'88,73'+##H3tt@@?%O;*At19@#?1;#nRE.^^jO'

W/??1>>J'8O'WOJ'5*L>"?J'FO'DOJ'D/2&"J'5O'FOJ'X'\*+%J'CO'UEZZ`[O'B1Q'@1#$@)1;#$*%'1%2'*?&1%$S1#$*%1>'*/#;*A"@O'' 8"&(%++"078(#45%0%M#27W^27b.RMb^ZO'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 23/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''ER'

f?"+"?J'!O'-OJ'F@+J',O'FOJ'X'V?"#SJ',O'fO'U._jj[O'V"%")$#';*<"?1&"'1%2'"AH>*Q""';*@#3'W?$#$;1>')1;#*?@'$%'"GH>1$%$%&';*AH"%@1#$*%'@1#$@)1;#$*%O'' 8"&(%++"078(#45%0%M#27LB2'ERmME`^O'

f?*>"#J'FO'COJ'X'Y*??$@J'YO']O'UEZZZ[O',1HH*?#'$%';*%)>$;#'?"@*>/#$*%3'F;;*/%#$%&')*?'+*L')1;"M#*M)1;"';*%#1;#')*@#"?@'A/#/1>';**H"?1#$*%'$%'A$G"2MA*#$<"';*%)>$;#@O' E%-&+/07%17HO3"&*."+,/079%4*/078(#45%0%M#27GX2'Ebp`ZO'

-*>&"?J',O'U._mm[O'f$@#?$9/#$<"'1%2'H?*;"2/?1>':/@#$;"3'W*A9$%"2'$AH1;#'*)'d<*$;"e'1%2'$AH?*<"A"%#'*%'"GH"?$"%;"2'$%"N/$#QO' E%-&+/07%178"&(%+/0*,#7/+'79%4*/078(#45%0%M#27GW27.Zjp.._O'

-*>&"?J',OJ'X'\*%*<@KQJ'YO'FO'U._j_[O'4))";#@'*)'H?*;"2/?1>'1%2'2$@#?$9/#$<"':/@#$;"'*%'?"1;#$*%@'#*'H1Q'?1$@"'2";$@$*%@O' @4/'".#7%17:/+/M"."+,7E%-&+/027GF27..`p.RZO'

-*?&1@J'DO'U.__j[O'(%')"">$%&'&**2'1%2'&"##$%&'Q*/?'L1Q3'Y**2'"))";#@'*%'%"&*#$1#*?';*&%$#$*%'1%2'91?&1$%$%&'@#?1#"&$"@O' E%-&+/07%178"&(%+/0*,#7/+'79%4*/078(#45%0%M#27UL2'`b`p`mmO'

!1>$%@KQJ'FO'fOJ'Y/@@L"$>"?J'5OJ'X'Y"2<";J'=O'0O'UEZZE[O'f$@;*%%";#$%&'*/#;*A"@'1%2'"<1>/1#$*%@'$%'%"&*#$1#$*%@3'5+"'?*>"'*)'%"&*#$1#*?')*;/@O' E%-&+/07%178"&(%+/0*,#7/+'79%4*/07 8(#45%0%M#27^G27..R.p..^ZO'

!"*?&"J'fOJ'X'Y1>>"?QJ'BO'UEZZR[O'989971%&7_*+'%$(7(,"37;#7(,"3)7@7(*.30"7M-*'"7/+'7&"1"&"+4"7BBD`7-3'/,"7U^#+'"2O[O'V*@#*%3'F>>Q%'X'V1;*%O'

!"?+1?#J'VOJ'X',Q%"@J'8O'U.__.[O'f"#"?A$%1%#@'1%2';*%@"N/"%;"@'*)'@1>1?Q'%"&*#$1#$*%@'9Q'A1>"'1%2')"A1>"'YVF'&?12/1#"@O' E%-&+/07%17@330*"'78(#45%0%M#27UX2'E`bpEbEO'

!?""%9"?&J'DO'X'W*>N/$##J'DO'FO'UEZZ`[O'765"7A/+';%%Z7%17]&M/+*V/,*%+/07E-(,*4"O''Y1+L1+J'7"L'D"?@"Q3'4?>91/AO'

!?""%+1>&+J'COJ'X'W+1HA1%J'fO'6O'U.__j['7"&*#$1#*?'?">1#$*%@+$H@3'W*%@#?/;#'A"1@/?"A"%#J'1%2'2"A*%@#?1#$*%'*)'#+"$?'$AH1;#'*%'#+"'H?*;"@@'1%2'*/#;*A"@'*)'9/@$%"@@'#?1%@1;#$*%@O'Y&%-37 ["4*(*%+7/+'7R"M%,*/,*%+27U J'^b`M^j_O'

01;KA1%J'DO',OJ'X'(>2+1AJ'!O',O'U._mb[O'Y*#$<1#$*%'#+?*/&+'#+"'2"@$&%'*)'L*?K3'5"@#'*)'1'#+"*?QO']&M/+*V/,*%+/07P"5/=*%&7/+'7A-./+78"&1%&./+4"27BX27E`ZpEm_O'

6Q"%&1?J'8O'8OJ']">>@J',O'4OJ'X'8;+L1?#SJ'VO'UEZZb[O'f*$%&'9"##"?'9/#')"">$%&'L*?@"3'C**K$%&')*?'#+"'d9"@#e':*9'/%2"?A$%"@'@1#$@)1;#$*%O' 8(#45%0%M*4/0794*"+4"27BU27.^Rp.`ZO'

\?1/#J'FO'6O'U._m`[O'B?"2$;#$%&'#/?%*<"?'*)'"AH>*Q""@')*?'A"1@/?"2':*9'1##$#/2"@O'']&M/+*V/,*%+/07

 P"5/=*%&7/+'7A-./+7["4*(*%+78&%4"(("(27BG27FGG pE^RO'

\?1QJ'CO'DOJ'X'5+*AH@*%J'CO'UEZZ`[O'!"%2"?'@#"?"*#QH"@'1%2'%"&*#$1#$*%'H"?)*?A1%;"3'F%'"G1A$%1#$*%'*)'#+"*?Q'1%2'?"@"1?;+O7T"("/&457*+7]&M/+*V/,*%+/07P"5/=*%&27FX2'.ZRM.jEO'

\/%$%J'5O'U._``[O'5+"';*%@#?/;#$*%'*)'1'%"L'#QH"'*)'1##$#/2"'A"1@/?"O' 8"&(%++"078(#45%0%M#27^2'b`pmjO'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 24/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''E^'

\L*%J'8OJ'X']"$%&1?#J'CO',O'UEZZ^[O'P%$>1#"?1>';*%;"@@$*%@')?*A'#+"'*#+"?'H1?#Q3'W*%;"@@$*%' 9"+1<$*?J'1##?$9/#$*%@J'1%2'%"&*#$1#$*%':/2&A"%#@O' E%-&+/07%17@330*"'78(#45%0%M#27^\2'EbRp EmjO'

C1L>"?J'4O'DOJ'X'q**%J'DO'U.__R[O'B*L"?'1%2'#+"'"A"?&"%;"'*)';*AA$#A"%#'9"+1<$*?'$%'%"&*#$1#"2'"G;+1%&"O' @."&*4/+79%4*%0%M*4/07T"=*"$27W^2'^b`p^j.O'

C""J'WO'U.__`[O'B?*@*;$1>'*?&1%$S1#$*%1>'9"+1<$*?@3'5+"'?*>"@'*)'L*?KH>1;"':/@#$;"J'1;+$"<"A"%#'@#?$<$%&J'1%2'H1Q'@1#$@)1;#$*%O' E%-&+/07%17P-(*+"((78(#45%0%M#27B`27._mpEZbO'

C"<"@N/"J'YO'DOJ'X'\"%%QJ'fO'FO'U.__R[O'F;;/?1;Q'*)'9"+1<$*?1>'H?"2$;#$*%@'1#'S"?*'1;N/1$%#1%;"3'F'@*;$1>'?">1#$*%@'1%1>Q@$@O' E%-&+/07%178"&(%+/0*,#7/+'79%4*/078(#45%0%M#27XW27BBU^aBB^UD''

Y;7"">QJ'VO'COJ'X'Y"&>$%*J'VO'YO'U.__^[O'5+"'?*>"'*)'2$@H*@$#$*%1>'1%2'@$#/1#$*%1>'1%#";"2"%#@'$%'H?*@*;$1>'*?&1%$S1#$*%1>'9"+1<$*?3'F%'"G1A$%1#$*%'*)'#+"'$%#"%2"2'9"%")$;$1?$"@'*)'

 H?*@*;$1>'9"+1<$*?O' E%-&+/07%17@330*"'78(#45%0%M#27U\27jRbpj^^O'

Y"@#21&+J'8OJ'X'V/">"%@J'YO'UEZZR[O'65*+Z*+M7;/4Z7%+7$5"&"7$"b&"7M%*+M)7@7.",5%'%0%M*4/07/(("((."+,7%171*="7'"4/'"(7%17&"("/&457*+7+"M%,*/,*%+7;"5/=*%&D '.b#+'F%%/1>'6%#"?%1#$*%1>'F@@*;$1#$*%'*)'W*%)>$;#'Y1%1&"A"%#'W*%)"?"%;"J'Y">9*/?%"J'F/@#?1>$1O'

Y"Q"?@J'CO'8OJ'!1A@#J'!OJ'X'!/1?$%*J'FO'DO'UEZZb[O'' @330*"'7.-0,*=/&*/,"7&"("/&45)7["(*M+7/+'7*+,"&3&",/,*%+D75+*/@1%2'(1K@3'81&"'B/9>$;1#$*%@O'

Y$>>"?J'fO'5O'U.___[O''5+"'%*?A'*)'@">)M$%#"?"@#O'' @."&*4/+78(#45%0%M*(,27WLJ'.Z`RM.ZbZO'

Y$>>@J'WO']O'U._^Z[O'8$#/1#"2'1;#$*%@'1%2'<*;19/>1?$"@'*)'A*#$<"O' @."&*4/+79%4*%0%M*4/07T"=*"$27W2'_Z^p_.RO'

 71&QJ'YO'8O'UEZZE[O''P@$%&'1'@$%&>"M$#"A'1HH?*1;+'#*'A"1@/?"')1;"#':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%O'' E%-&+/07%17]44-3/,*%+/07/+'7]&M/+*V/,*%+/078(#45%0%M#27UWJ'mmpjbO'

 71N/$%J'WO'UEZZR[O'5+"'1&*%Q'*)'*HH*?#/%$#Q3'7/A9"?'*)'%"&*#$19>"'$@@/"@J';*/%#"?)1;#/1>'#+$%K$%&J'1%2')"">$%&@'*)'@1#$@)1;#$*%O']&M/+*V/,*%+/07P"5/=*%&7/+'7A-./+7["4*(*%+7 8&%4"(("(27\B27_mp.ZmO'

 7"1>"J'YO'FOJ'X'V1S"?A1%J'YO'0O'U.__.[O'C%M+*,*%+7/+'7&/,*%+/0*,#7*+7+"M%,*/,*%+O'7"L'q*?K3'5+"'-?""'B?"@@O'

(IW*%%*?J'\O'YOJ'X'F?%*>2J'DO'FO'UEZZ.[O'f$@#?$9/#$<"'@H$?1>@3'%"&*#$1#$*%'$AH1@@"@'1%2'#+"'

A*2"?1#$%&'?*>"'*)'2$@H/#1%#'@">)M"))$;1;QO']&M/+*V/,*%+/07P"5/=*%&7/+'7A-./+7["4*(*%+7 8&%4"(("(27^L27.^jp.mbO'

(IW*%%*?J'\O'YOJ'F?%*>2J'DO'FOJ'X'V/??$@J'4O',O'UEZZ`[O''7"&*#$1#*?@I'91?&1$%$%&'+$@#*?$"@'1%2'#+"$?'"))";#@'*%')/#/?"'%"&*#$1#$*%'H"?)*?A1%;"O'' E%-&+/07%17@330*"'78(#45%0%M#27\`27R`ZpRbEO'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 25/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''E`'

(>$<"?J',O'COJ'V1>1K?$@+%1%J'BO'=OJ'X'V1??QJ'VO'U.__^[O'(/#;*A"'@1#$@)1;#$*%'$%'%"&*#$1#$*%3'F'#"@#'*)'"GH";#1%;Q'2$@;*%)$?A1#$*%O']&M/+*V/,*%+/07P"5/=*%&7/+'7A-./+7["4*(*%+78&%4"(("(27X`27E`EpEm`O'

(@#"?A1%J'BO'U._jm[O'5/?%*<"?J'"AH>*QA"%#'@";/?$#QJ'1%2'#+"'H"?)*?A1%;"'*)'#+"')$?AO'6%'YO'YO'\>"$%"?J',O'7O'V>*;KJ'YO',**AK$%J'X'8O']O'81>@9/?&'U42@O[J' A-./+7&"(%-&4"(7/+'7,5"7 3"&1%&./+4"7%17,5"71*&.7UHHO'Em`pR.m[O7]1@+$%&#*%J'fW3'V7F'B?"@@O'

B*2@1K*))J'BO'YOJ'Y1;\"%S$"J'8O'VOJ'C""J'DOJ'X'B*2@1K*))J'7O'BO'UEZZR[O'W*AA*%'A"#+*2'9$1@"@'$%'9"+1<$*?1>'?"@"1?;+3'F';?$#$;1>'?"<$"L'*)'#+"'>$#"?1#/?"'1%2'?";*AA"%2"2'?"A"2$"@O' E%-&+/07%17@330*"'78(#45%0%M#27^^2'jm_p_ZRO'

B?$;K"##J'5OJ'!121MD1$%J'7OJ'X'V"?%$"?$J'-O'DO'UEZZZJ'Y1Q[O'65"7*.3%&,/+4"7%171*&(,7*.3&"((*%+(7*+7/7<%;7*+,"&=*"$D7B1H"?'H?"@"%#"2'1#'#+"'1%%/1>'A""#$%&'*)'#+"'Y$2L"@#"?%'B@Q;+*>*&$;1>'F@@*;$1#$*%J'W+$;1&*J'6CO'

B?/$##J'fO'!OJ'X',/9$%J'DO'uO'U._jb[O'9%4*/074%+10*4,)7H(4/0/,*%+27(,/0"./,"27/+'7(",,0"."+,D7 7"L'

q*?K3'Y;!?1LM0$>>O'

,/@@">>J'DO'FOJ']"$@@J'FOJ'X'Y"%2">@*+%J'!O'FO'U._j_[O'F))";#'&?$23'F'@$%&>"M$#"A'@;1>"'*)' H>"1@/?"'1%2'1?*/@1>O'' E%-&+/07%178"&(%+/0*,#7/+'79%4*/078(#45%0%M#27WU2'^_RM`ZEO''

81;K@J'YO'FOJ',$";+1?#J'\O'8OJ'X'B?*))$##J']O'5OJ'D?O'U.___['V?*12"%$%&'#+"'"<1>/1#$*%'*)'2$@H/#"'?"@*>/#$*%3'W*%#"G#@'1%2'?">1#$*%@+$H@'*<"?'#$A"O' R"M%,*/,*%+7E%-&+/027BWJ'RR_M^bO'

8;1?H">>*J'=OJ'X'W1AH9">>J'DO'BO'U._jR[O'D*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%3'F?"'1>>'#+"'H1?#@'#+"?"s' 8"&(%++"07 8(#45%0%M#27GX27`mmpbZZO'

8;+*>>J',O']O'U._jR[O'W1?""?'>$%"@'1%2'"AH>*QA"%#'@#19$>$#QO' @4/'".#7%17:/+/M"."+,7E%-&+/027

FX2'jbp.ZRO'

8;+L1?#SJ'VOJ']1?2'FOJ'Y*%#"?*@@*J'DOJ'CQ/9*A$?@KQJ'8OJ']+$#"J'\OJ'X'C"+A1%J'fO',O'UEZZE[O'Y1G$A$S$%&'<"?@/@'@1#$@)$;$%&3'01HH$%"@@'$@'1'A1##"?'*)';+*$;"O' E%-&+/07%178"&(%+/0*,#7/+'79%4*/078(#45%0%M#27^GJ'..mjM.._mO'

8;+L1?SJ'7OJ'X'W>*?"J'!O'CO'U._jR[O'Y**2J'A$@1##?$9/#$*%'1%2':/2&A"%#@'*)'L">>M9"$%&3'6%)*?A1#$<"'1%2'2$?";#$<"')/%;#$*%@'*)'1))";#$<"'@#1#"@O' E%-&+/07%178"&(%+/0*,#7/+'79%4*/07 8(#45%0%M#27LW2'`.RM`ERO'

8"##**%J',O'BOJ'V"%%"##J'7OJ'X'C$2"%J',O'WO'U.__b[O'8*;$1>'"G;+1%&"'$%'*?&1%$S1#$*%@3'B"?;"$<"2'*?&1%$S1#$*%1>'@/HH*?#J'>"12"?MA"A9"?'"G;+1%&"J'1%2'"AH>*Q""'?";$H?*;$#QO' E%-&+/07%17

 @330*"'78(#45%0%M#27^B27E._pEEmO'

8H";#*?J'BO'4O'U._j`[O''Y"1@/?"A"%#'*)'+/A1%'@"?<$;"'@#1))'@1#$@)1;#$*%3'f"<">*HA"%#'*)'#+"'D*9'81#$@)1;#$*%'8/?<"QO'' @."&*4/+7E%-&+/07%17C%..-+*,#78(#45%0%M#27BGJ'b_Rpm.RO'

8#1LJ'VO'YOJ'V">>J'7O'4OJ'X'W>1/@"%J'DO'FO'U._jb[O'5+"'2$@H*@$#$*%1>'1HH?*1;+'#*':*9'1##$#/2"@3'F'>$)"#$A"'>*%&$#/2$%1>'#"@#O' @'.*+*(,&/,*="794*"+4"7c-/&,"&0#27GB27`bpmmO'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 26/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''Eb'

8#"<"%@J'WO'\OJ'V1<"##1J'FO'!OJ'X'!$@#J'YO'4O'U.__R[O'!"%2"?'2$))"?"%;"@'$%'#+"'1;N/$@$#$*%'*)'@1>1?Q'%"&*#$1#$*%'@K$>>@3'5+"'?*>"'*)'&*1>@J'@">)M"))$;1;QJ'1%2'H"?;"$<"2';*%#?*>O' E%-&+/07%17 @330*"'78(#45%0%M#27U^27mERMmR`O'

8#/+>A1;+"?J'FO'-OJ'X']1>#"?@J'FO'4O'U.___[O'!"%2"?'2$))"?"%;"@'$%'%"&*#$1#$*%'*/#;*A"3'F'A"#1M1%1>Q@$@O'' 8"&(%++"078(#45%0%M#27WF27b`RMbmmO'

8#/?A1%J'YO'WOJ'X'8+*?#J'DO'WO'UEZZZ[O'C/AHM@/A'9*%/@'@1#$@)1;#$*%3'5"@#$%&'#+"';*%@#?/;#'<1>$2$#Q'*)'1'%"L'H1Q'@1#$@)1;#$*%'A"1@/?"O'' 8"&(%++"078(#45%0%M#27WG27bmRMmZZO'

5"##J',O'BOJ'X'Y"Q"?J'DO'BO'U.__R[O'D*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%J'*?&1%$S1#$*%1>';*AA$#A"%#J'#/?%*<"?'$%#"%#$*%J'1%2'#/?%*<"?3'B1#+'1%1>Q@"@'91@"2'*%'A"#1M1%1>Q#$;')$%2$%&@O' 8"&(%++"078(#45%0%M#27LX27E`_pE_RO'

5+$91/#J'DOJ'X']1>K"?J'CO'U._m`[O' 8&%4"'-&/07<-(,*4")7@73(#45%0%M*4/07/+/0#(*(D'0$>>@21>"J'7D3'4?>91/AO'

5+*AH@*%J'CO'U.__Z[O'7"&*#$1#$*%'9"+1<$*?'1%2'*/#;*A"@3'4AH$?$;1>'"<$2"%;"'1%2'#+"*?"#$;1>'$@@/"@O' 8(#45%0%M*4/07P-00",*+27B`^2'`.`p`REO'

5+*AH@*%J'CO'U.__R[O'5+"'$AH1;#'*)'%"&*#$1#$*%'*%'$%#"?&?*/H'?">1#$*%@O' E%-&+/07%17 HO3"&*."+,/079%4*/078(#45%0%M#27F\27RZ^pRE`O'

5+*AH@*%J'CO'COJ'=1>>"QJ'\O'CO'X'\?1A"?J',O'YO'U.__`[O'5+"'9$##"?@L""#')"">$%&'*)'@/;;"@@3'F%'"G1A$%1#$*%'*)'@*;$1>'H"?;"H#$*%'$%'%"&*#$1#$*%O' E%-&+/07%17HO3"&*."+,/079%4*/078(#45%0%M#27GB2'^bmp^_EO'

5+*?"@"%J'WO'DOJ'\1H>1%J'8O'FOJ'V1?@KQJ'FO'BOJ']1??"%J'WO',OJ'X'2"'W+"?A*%#J'\O'UEZZR[O'5+"'1))";#$<"'/%2"?H$%%$%&@'*)':*9'H"?;"H#$*%@'1%2'1##$#/2"@3'F'A"#1M1%1>Q#$;'?"<$"L'1%2'$%#"&?1#$*%O'

 8(#45%0%M*4/07P-00",*+27BF\27\BLa\LWD'

5+*?%2$K"J'4O'CO'U._EZ[O'F';*%@#1%#'"??*?'$%'H@Q;+*>*&$;1>'?1#$%&@O' E%-&+/07%17@330*"'7 8(#45%0%M#27L27E`pE_O'

5$%@>"QJ'WO'0OJ'(IW*%%*?J'\O'YOJ'X'8/>>$<1%J'VO'FO'UEZZE[O'5*/&+'&/Q@')$%$@+'>1@#3'5+"'H"?$>@'*)'1'2$@#?$9/#$<"'?"H/#1#$*%O'']&M/+*V/,*%+/07P"5/=*%&7/+'7["4*(*%+78&%4"(("(27^^2 'bE.pb^EO'

]1#@*%J'fOJ'W>1?KJ'CO'FOJ'X'5">>"&"%J'FO'U._jj[O''f"<">*HA"%#'1%2'<1>$21#$*%'*)'9?$")'A"1@/?"@'*)'H*@$#$<"'1%2'%"&1#$<"'1))";#3'5+"'BF7F8'@;1>"@O' E%-&+/07%178"&(%+/0*,#7/+'79%4*/07 8(#45%0%M#27WL27.ZbRM.ZmZO'

]1#@*%J'WOJ'X'0*))A1%J'CO',O'U.__b[O'Y1%1&"?@'1@'%"&*#$1#*?@3'F'#"@#'*)'H*L"?'<"?@/@'&"%2"?'1@' H?"2$;#*?@'*)')"">$%&@J'9"+1<$*?J'1%2'*/#;*A"@O' S"/'"&(5*37c-/&,"&0#27U27bRpj`O'

]"9@#"?J'4O'WO'U._b^[O' ["4*(*%+a./Z*+M7*+7,5"7".30%#."+,7*+,"&=*"$D7Y*%#?"1>J'v/"9";J'W1%1213'Y;!$>>'P%$<"?@$#QJ'6%2/@#?$1>',">1#$*%@'W"%#?"O'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 27/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''Em'

]+$#"J'DO'VOJ'5Q%1%J',OJ'!1>$%@KQJ'FO'fOJ'X'5+*AH@*%J'CO'CO'UEZZ^[O'-1;"'#+?"1#'@"%@$#$<$#Q'$%'%"&*#$1#$*%3',*129>*;K'#*'1&?""A"%#'1%2':*$%#'&1$%O']&M/+*V/,*%+/07P"5/=*%&7/+'7A-./+7 ["4*(*%+78&%4"(("(27\LJ'.ZEM.E^O'

]$>>$1A@J'YO'COJ'Y;f1%$">J'YO'FOJ'X'7&/Q"%J'7O'5O'UEZZb[O'F'A"#1M1%1>Q@$@'*)'#+"'1%#";"2"%#@'1%2';*%@"N/"%;"@'*)'H1Q'>"<">'@1#$@)1;#$*%O' E%-&+/07%17@330*"'78(#45%0%M#27\B27R_Ep^.RO'

]$%@#"12J'VO'FOJ'f"?>"&1J'=O'DOJ'Y*%#&*A"?QJ'YO'DOJ'X'B$>K$%&#*%J'WO'U.__`['5+"'N/1>$#Q'*)')?$"%2@+$H@'1#'L*?K'1%2':*9'@1#$@)1;#$*%O' E%-&+/07%179%4*/07/+'78"&(%+/07T"0/,*%+(5*3(27BF27.__pE.`O'

]?$&+#J'5O'FOJ'X'8#1LJ'VO'YO'U.___[O''F))";#'1%2')1<*?19>"'L*?K'*/#;*A"@3'5L*'>*%&$#/2$%1>'#"@#@'*)'#+"'+1HHQMH?*2/;#$<"'L*?K"?'#+"@$@O'' E%-&+/07%17]&M/+*V/,*%+/07P"5/=*%&27F`2'.pERO'

q/K>J'!O'U._j_[O' S"/'"&(5*37*+7%&M/+*V/,*%+(7UE%2'"2O[O'B?"%#$;"M01>>3'4%&>"L**2'W>$))@J'7DO'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 28/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''Ej'

519>"'.' ["(4&*3,*="79,/,*(,*4(77'' '' ''

'' 9[D7

4;*%*A$;'=1>/"' EZJZ``OEZ E`JmRjOZZ'

8/9:";#$<"'=1>/"'U.Mm'@;1>"[' `OjR ZO_Z'

V1@"'@1>1?Q' .ZZJ^`ZOZZ E.JE`.O__'

5*#1>')$?@#'Q"1?';*AH"%@1#$*%'U%*#'$%;>/2$%&'@1>1?Q[' REJ_RbO_. E`JmZ^O`^'

MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM'

W*AH"%@1#$*%'81#$@)1;#$*%'U.Mm'@;1>"[' `OZ^ .O`Z'

D*9'81#$@)1;#$*%'U.Mm'@;1>"[' ^O_E .ObZ'

5/?%*<"?'6%#"%#$*%'U.Mm'@;1>"[' RO^Z .Omj'

MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM'

8"G'U-"A1>"n.[' ZOEm ZO^`'

B?$*?'91@"'@1>1?Q' mRJE.jOR^ E_J^`jObR'

4GH";#1#$*%@'*)')/#/?"'$%#"?1;#$*%'U.Mm'@;1>"[' `OjZ .O`b'

B*@$#$<"'1))";#'U.M`'@;1>"[' ROjb ZObm'

  7"&1#$<"'1))";#'U.M`'@;1>"[' EOZ_ ZO_Z'D*9'-/%;#$*%'MM'W*%@/>#$%&t8#?1#"&$;'B>1%%$%&' ZOEm ZO^`'

D*9'-/%;#$*%'MM'-$%1%;"' ZO.. ZORE'

'' '' ''

 7*#"3' R nmZO'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 29/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''E_'

519>"'E' P*=/&*/,"74%&&"0/,*%+(7/.%+M7(,-'#7."/(-&"(7IRdU`J7'

.O EO RO ^O `O bO mO jO _O .ZO ..O .EO .RO

.O' 4;*%*A$;'=1>/"

EO' 8/9:";#$<"'=1>/" ZOEZ w

RO' V1@"'@1>1?Q ZOE. w ZO.j

^O' (#+"?')$?@#'Q"1?';*AH"%@1#$*% ZOZZ MZOZ_ ZO.R

`O' W*AH"%@1#$*%'81#$@)1;#$*% ZO.b ZORZ x ZO^E xx ZOE. w

bO' D*9'81#$@)1;#$*% ZOZ_ ZOER w ZOZR ZOE. w ZO^m xx

mO' 5/?%*<"?'6%#"%#$*% MZO.^ MZOE` x MZOZ. MZOR_ xx MZOR` xx MZOb. xx

jO' 8"G'U-"A1>"n.[ MZOEZ ZO.Z MZO.m MZOR^ xx MZOEj x MZO.j ZOEZ

_O' B?$*?'91@"'@1>1?Q ZOZ` MZO.` ZOE^ x ZO.m xx MZO.j MZOE^ x ZOE` x MZOZ_

.ZO' 4GH";#1#$*%@'*)')/#/?"'$%#"?1;#$*% ZOR. xx ZO.^ ZO.b ZOZZ ZO.` ZO.Z MZOZ^ ZOZE ZO.R

..O' B*@$#$<"'1))";# ZOZ` ZO^. xx ZOZR MZO.b MZOZm MZO.Z ZO.` ZOER w MZOEE w MZOZm

.EO' 7"&1#$<"'1))";# ZOZ. MZOR_ xx MZO.^ MZO.m ZOZE MZOZ_ ZO.E MZOZb M ZOE. w MZOEE w MZO.`

.RO' D*9' -/%;#$*%'W*%@/>#$%&t8#? 1#"&$;'B >1%%$%& MZO Zj ZOZ_ ZO. ` MZOZ` ZOR. x ZOZ` ZOZZ Z OZb MZO. _ MZOZ` ZOZj ZOZ.

.^O' D*9'-/%;#$*%'-$%1%;" ZO.E MZOE^ x ZOZ^ ZO^Z xx ZO.Z ZOZ. MZO.m MZO.E ZOZR MZOZ^ MZOEb x ZO.E w MZOEE w

 yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy 

 7*#"3'7nmZO'

wH'r'O.Zc'xH'r'OZ`c'xxHrOZ.c'1>>'<1>/"@'#L*M#1$>"2O

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 30/37

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 31/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''R.'

'519>"'R'6#3"(7%174%+4"((*%+(7&"4"*="'7;#7<%;7+"M%,*/,%&(7IRdG\J7

' '

5QH"'*)';*%;"@@$*%'B"?;"%#'?"H*?#$%&'

8$&%$%&'9*%/@' ^^k'

81>1?Q' RRk'

,">*;1#$*%'U"O&OJ'A*<$%&'"GH"%@"@J'+*/@$%&J';*@#M*)M>$<$%&'1@@$@#1%;"[' E.k'

8#1?#'21#"' .Rk'

B"?)*?A1%;"'9*%/@' .Zk'

8#*;K'*H#$*%@' jk'

=1;1#$*%'#$A"' jk'

V"%")$#@'U"O&OJ'+"1>#+'$%@/?1%;"[' `k'

f"9#'?")$%1%;$%&' `k'

F22$#$*%1>'#?1$%$%&' `k'

!"*&?1H+$;'>*;1#$*%' Rk'=$@1'1@@$@#1%;"' Rk'

W1>"%21?')*?';*%@$2"?$%&'H?*A*#$*%@' Rk'

5$A"'#*'2";$2"'*%'*))"?' Rk'

C"<">'*)'H*@$#$*%' Rk'

' '

' '

'

'

'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 32/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''RE'

519>"' '̂:-0,*=/&*/,"7&"M&"((*%+7.%'"0(73&"'*4,*+M74%.3"+(/,*%+7(/,*(1/4,*%+27<%;7(/,*(1/4,*%+27/+'7,-&+%="&7*+,"+,*%+'7

W*AH"%@1#$*%'81#$@)1;#$*% D*9'81#$@)1;#$*% 5/?%*<"?'6%#"%#$*%

C%+,&%07>/&*/;0"(

8"G'U-"A1>"n.[ MO.m MO.m MO._ w MO.Z MOZj MOZ_ OZ^ OZ. OZE

B?$*?'91@"'@1>1?Q MOEj x MOEj x MO.m MORm xx MORm xx MOEj x O^. xx O^. xx OR. x

4GH";#1#$*%@'*)')/#/?"'$%#"?1;#$*% O.b O.b O.b O.E OZ_ OZ_ MOZb MOZR MOZR

B*@$#$<"'1))";# MOZb MOZb MO.j MO.` MO.m MOEb w O.j OEZ ORZ x

  7"&1#$<"'1))";# OZE OZE O.` MO.E MO.R MOZE O.m O.m OZ`

D*9'-/%;#$*%'W*%@/>#$%&t8#?1#"&$;'B>1%%$%& O._ w O._ w O._ w MOZE MOZ. MOZ. OZR OZE OZE

D*9'-/%;#$*%'-$%1%;" OZR OZR OZm MO.Z MO.. MOZm OZZ OZ. MOZR

 H4%+%.*47/+'79-;<"4,*="7>/0-"

V1@"'@1>1?Q O^. xx O^. xx OR^ xx OZ` OZR MOZE OZ. OZE OZj

(#+"?')$?@#'Q"1?';*AH"%@1#$*% O.b O.b O._ w OEE OEE OE` w MO^Z xx MO^Z xx MO^E xx

4;*%*A$;'=1>/" MOZ. MOZ_ OZj OZZ MO.. MOZR

8/9:";#$<"'=1>/" O^. xx OR^ x MORm xx

:%'"07'*/M+%(,*4(

 Q7 #"@#'*)'A*2"> -U_J'bZ[ -U.ZJ'`_[ -U..J'`j[ -U_J'bZ[ -U.ZJ'`_[ -U..J'`j[ -U_J'bZ[ -U.ZJ'`_[ -U..J'`j[

=1>/"'*)' Q  ^Obj xx ^O.^ xx `ObR xx .O`^ .O^. .O_. w RO.E xx EOjm xx ROmZ xx

, E

O^. O^. O`E O._ O._ OEm ORE ORR O^.

W+1%&"'$%', E')?*A'W*%#?*>'Y*2"> M OZZ O.Z M OZ. OZj M OZ. OZ_

F2:/@#"2', E

ORE OR. O^E OZm OZb O.R OEE OE. ORZ

W+1%&"')?*A'W*%#?*>'Y*2"> -U.J'`_[ -UEJ'`j[ -U.J'`_[ -UEJ'`j[ -U.J'`_[ -UEJ'`j[

=1>/"'*)' Q  M OZZ bOEE xx M OR_ ROZm w M Omb ^Ob. x

 R%,"D 'F>>'#"?A@'*#+"?'#+1%'A*2">'2$1&%*@#$;@'1?"'@#1%21?2$S"2'?"&?"@@$*%';*"))$;$"%#@O' n'mZO

F>>'*9:";#$<"'1%2'@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'A"1@/?"@'+1<"'9""%'?1%KM#?1%@)*?A"2'1@'2"@;?$9"2'$%'#+"',"@/>#@'@";#$*%

wH'r'O.Zc'xH'r'OZ`c'xxHrOZ.c'1>>'<1>/"@'#L*M#1$>"2O

8/9:";#$<"'

=1>/"

Y*2">'.3 Y*2" >'E3 Y*2" >'R3 Y*2">'^3 Y*2" >'`3 Y*2">'b3 Y*2">'m3 Y*2">'j3 Y*2">'_3

4;*%*A$;'

=1>/"'*)'

W*%;"@@$*%@

8/9:";#$<"'

=1>/"

W*%#?*>'

=1?$19>"@

4;*%*A$;'

=1>/"'*)'

W*%;"@@$*%@

W*%#?*>'

=1?$19>"@

4;*%*A$;'

=1>/"'*)'

W*%;"@@$*%@

8/9:";#$<"'

=1>/"

W*%#?*>'

=1?$19>"@

'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 33/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''RR'

FHH"%2$G'''

65*&,""+aK,".79-;<"4,*="7>/0-"7K+="+,%&#7I9>KJ7@'/3,"'71%&7,5"7H.30%#."+,7R"M%,*/,*%+7

9",,*+M7

'

.O'0*L'@1#$@)$"2'1?"'Q*/'L$#+'Q*/?'*L%'*/#;*A"T$O"OJ'#+"'"G#"%#'#*'L+$;+'#+"'#"?A@'*)'Q*/?'1&?""A"%#'9"%")$#'Q*/s''U.'n'7*#'1#'1>>J'^'n'Y*2"?1#">QJ'm'n'B"?)";#>Qc'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

EO'f$2'Q*/')"">'>$K"'Q*/')*?)"$#"2'*?'d>*@#e'$%'#+$@'%"&*#$1#$*%s''U.'n'7*#'1#'1>>J'^'n'Y*2"?1#">QJ'm'n'F'&?"1#'2"1>c'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

RO'f*'Q*/'#+$%K'#+"'#"?A@'*)'Q*/?'1&?""A"%#'1?"';*%@$@#"%#'L$#+'H?$%;$H>"@'*)'>"&$#$A1;Q'

*?'*9:";#$<"';?$#"?$1'U"O&OJ';*AA*%'@#1%21?2@'*)')1$?%"@@J'H?";"2"%#J'$%2/@#?Q'H?1;#$;"J'>"&1>$#QJ'"#;O[s'U.'n'7*#'1#'1>>J'^'n'Y*2"?1#">QJ'm'n'B"?)";#>Qc'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

^O'f$2'Q*/'d>*@"')1;"e'U$O"OJ'21A1&"'Q*/?'@"%@"'*)'H?$2"['$%'#+"'%"&*#$1#$*%s'U.'n'7*#'1#'1>>J'^'n'Y*2"?1#">QJ'm'n'F'&?"1#'2"1>c'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

`O'f$2'#+$@'%"&*#$1#$*%'A1K"'Q*/')"">'A*?"'*?'>"@@';*AH"#"%#'1@'1'%"&*#$1#*?s'U.'n'6#'A12"'A"')"">'C488';*AH"#"%#J'^'n'6#'2$2'%*#'A1K"'A"')"">'A*?"'*?'>"@@'

;*AH"#"%#J'm'n'6#'A12"'A"')"">'Y(,4';*AH"#"%#c'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

bO'f$2'Q*/'9"+1<"'1;;*?2$%&'#*'Q*/?'*L%'H?$%;$H>"@'1%2'<1>/"@s'U.'n'7*#'1#'1>>J'^'n'Y*2"?1#">QJ'm'n'B"?)";#>Qc'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

mO'f$2'#+$@'%"&*#$1#$*%'H*@$#$<">Q'*?'%"&1#$<">Q'$AH1;#'Q*/?'@">)M$A1&"'*?'Q*/?'$AH?"@@$*%'*)'Q*/?@">)s'U.'n'6#'74!F56=4Cq'$AH1;#"2'AQ'@">)M$A1&"J'^'n'6#'2$2'%*#'H*@$#$<">Q'*?'%"&1#$<">Q'$AH1;#'AQ'@">)M$A1&"J'm'n'6#'B(8656=4Cq'$AH1;#"2'AQ'@">)M$A1&"c'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'

 7F[''

jO']*/>2'Q*/';+1?1;#"?$S"'#+"'%"&*#$1#$*%'H?*;"@@'1@')1$?s'U.'n'7*#'1#'1>>J'^'n'Y*2"?1#">QJ'm'n'B"?)";#>Qc'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 34/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''R^'

_O'0*L'@1#$@)$"2'1?"'Q*/'L$#+'#+"'"1@"'U*?'2$))$;/>#Q['*)'?"1;+$%&'1%'1&?""A"%#s'U.'n'7*#'1#'1>>'@1#$@)$"2J'^'n'Y*2"?1#">Q'@1#$@)$"2J'm'n'B"?)";#>Q'@1#$@)$"2c'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

.ZO'f$2'Q*/?';*/%#"?H1?#';*%@$2"?'Q*/?'L$@+"@J'*H$%$*%@J'*?'%""2@s'U.'n'7*#'1#'1>>J'^'n'Y*2"?1#">QJ'm'n'B"?)";#>Qc'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

..O']+1#'K$%2'*)'d*<"?1>>e'$AH?"@@$*%'2$2'Q*/?';*/%#"?H1?#'A1K"'*%'Q*/s'U.'n'4G#?"A">Q'74!F56=4J'^'n'7"$#+"?'%"&1#$<"'%*?'H*@$#$<"J'm'n'4G#?"A">Q'B(8656=4c'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

.EO'f$2'#+"'%"&*#$1#$*%'A1K"'Q*/'#?/@#'Q*/?';*/%#"?H1?#s'U.'n'7*#'1#'1>>J'^'n'Y*2"?1#">QJ'm'n'B"?)";#>Qc'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

.RO'f$2'#+"'%"&*#$1#$*%'9/$>2'1'&**2')*/%21#$*%')*?'1')/#/?"'?">1#$*%@+$H'L$#+'Q*/?';*/%#"?H1?#s'U.'n'7*#'1#'1>>J'^'n'Y*2"?1#">QJ'm'n'B"?)";#>Qc'$%;>/2"@'1%'*H#$*%'7F[''

 7*#"O''W*HQ?$&+#'EZZj'9Q'DO',O'W/?+1%'1%2'0O'FO'4>)"%9"$%O''B"?A$@@$*%'#*'/@"'#+"'8/9:";#$<"'=1>/"'6%<"%#*?Q'$@'&?1%#"2')?""'*)';+1?&"')*?'%*%;*AA"?;$1>'H/?H*@"@'*%>QO''8""'LLLO@/9:";#$<"<1>/"O;*A')*?'122$#$*%1>'$%)*?A1#$*%'*?')*?'H"?A$@@$*%'#*'?"H?*2/;"'#+"'8/9:";#$<"'=1>/"'6%<"%#*?QO'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 35/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''R`'

-**#%*#"@''

'.'8#/2"%#@'L+*'L"?"'?";"$<$%&'1%'122$#$*%1>'2"&?""'9"@$2"@'#+"'YVF'L"?"'

@>$&+#>Q'A*?"'>$K">Q'#*';*AH>"#"'9*#+'@/?<"Q@'U& 'n'O.EJ' 3'r'OZ`['1%2'#+"'1<"?1&"'!BF'*)'

@#/2"%#@';*AH>"#$%&'9*#+'@/?<"Q@'L1@'@>$&+#>Q'+$&+"?'#+1%'#+"'1<"?1&"'!BF'*)'@#/2"%#@'

L+*';*AH>"#"2'%"$#+"?'*?':/@#'*%"'*)'#+"'@/?<"Q@'U^ObR'<@O'^O``J' 3'r'OZ.[O''7*'*#+"?'

<1?$19>"@'@+*L"2'2$))"?"%;"@'9"#L""%'?"@H*%2"%#@'1%2'%*%M?"@H*%2"%#@O'

E']"'">$A$%1#"2'+n.m'9";1/@"'#+"Q'+12'%*#'1;;"H#"2'%"L'"AH>*QA"%#J'>1?&">Q'

2/"'#*';*AH1%Q'@H*%@*?@+$H'*?'"%#?"H?"%"/?$1>'<"%#/?"@c'+njR'9";1/@"'#+"Q'+12'%*#'

%"&*#$1#"2'#+"$?':*9'*))"?c'+n.`')*?'%*%M?"@H*%@"'#*'#+"'8=J'";*%*A$;'<1>/"J'*?':*9'

1##$#/2"@'N/"@#$*%@c'1%2'+nb'9";1/@"'#+"$?'?"@H*%@"@'#*'#+"'N/"@#$*%'*%'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'

2$))"?"2'&?"1#>Q'9"#L""%'#+"'4AH>*QA"%#'8/?<"Q'1%2'F>/A%$'8/?<"Q'U9Q'1')1;#*?'*)'j'

#$A"@'*?'A*?"[J'L+$;+'@/&&"@#@'1'#QH*&?1H+$;1>'"??*?'$%'1'K"Q'A"1@/?"O'''

()'#+"'.`'?"@H*%2"%#@'L$#+'A$@@$%&'21#1J'b'2$2'%*#'?"@H*%2'#*'#+"'N/"@#$*%@'19*/#'

@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'*%'*%"'*?'9*#+'@/?<"Q@'1%2'_'2$2'%*#'H?*<$2"'21#1'19*/#'#+"'";*%*A$;'

<1>/"'*)'#+"$?';*%;"@@$*%@O''F>>'H1?#$;$H1%#@'?"@H*%2"2'#*'#+"':*9'1##$#/2"'N/"@#$*%@O''

5+"@"'.`'2$2'%*#'2$))"?')?*A'#+"'mZ'L+*'L"?"'$%;>/2"2')*?'1%1>Q@$@'$%'#"?A@'*)'#+"'#+?""'

2"H"%2"%#'A"1@/?"@J', @'UjR[''ZO^_J' 3@''ObR[O'

R'4))";#'@$S"@'1%2'@$&%$)$;1%;"'>"<">@'L"?"'"@@"%#$1>>Q'/%;+1%&"2'9Q'2">"#$%&'#+"@"'

)*/?'?"@H*%2"%#@'L$#+'A$@@$%&'21#1O'

^']"'/@"'#+"'#"?A'd";*%*A$;'*/#;*A"@e'$%'K""H$%&'L$#+'5+*AH@*%'U.__Z['#*'

?")"?'#*'#+"'#"?A@'*)'1'2"1>O''4>@"L+"?"'UW/?+1%'"#'1>OJ'EZZbc'W/?+1%J'4>)"%9"$%J'X'

4$@"%K?1)#J'$%'H?"@@[J'L"'/@"'#+"'#"?A'd*9:";#$<"'<1>/"Je'9/#'%*#'$%'#+$@';1@"'2/"'#*'

'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 36/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''Rb'

';*%;"?%@'?1$@"2'9Q'1%'1%*%QA*/@'?"<$"L"?'#+1#'*/?'A"1@/?"'$@'@">)M?"H*?#"2'1%2'

$%#"?H?"#"2'9Q'H1?#$;$H1%#@O''5+/@J'$#'$@'%*#'"%#$?">Q'*9:";#$<"O''

`

'5+"';*??">1#$*%'9"#L""%'*9:";#$<"'<1>/"'1%2'#+"'$%@#?/A"%#1>'2$A"%@$*%'*)'

@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'L1@'1>@*'@A1>>'U& 'n'O.`J'+([O'

b'C*&1?$#+A$;'#?1%@)*?A1#$*%J'9Q';*%#?1@#J'2$2'%*#'9?$%&'#+"@"';?$#"?$1'$%#*'#+"'

1;;"H#19>"'?1%&"'U@/9:";#$<"'<1>/"'@K"L%"@@'M.O_mJ'K/?#*@$@'`O.Zc'";*%*A$;'<1>/"'hL$#+'1'

;*%@#1%#'*)'.'122"2'#*'1;;*/%#')*?'S"?*'<1>/"@i'@K"L%"@@'pEO^jJ'K/?#*@$@'bO.^c'91@"'@1>1?Q'

@K"L%"@@'MOmRJ'K/?#*@$@'EOjb[O'

m'-*?'1&&?"&1#$*%J'?"@H*%@"@'L"?"';*%<"?#"2'#*'1'mMH*$%#'@;1>"'9Q'@/9#?1;#$%&'.J'

A/>#$H>Q$%&'9Q'.O`J'1%2'122$%&'.O'

j'W1#"&*?$"@'L"?"3'F/#*A*#$<"tF"?*@H1;"J'W*AH/#"?@t4>";#?*%$;@J'W*%@/A"?'

B1;K1&"2'!**2@J'W*%@/>#$%&J'f$<"?@$)$"2'-$%1%;$1>'8"?<$;"@J'!*<"?%A"%#t7*%MB?*)$#J'

6%<"@#A"%#'V1%K$%&tV?*K"?1&"'6%<"@#A"%#J'Y1%1&"A"%#J'Y"2$1t4%#"?#1$%A"%#J'

($>t4%"?&QJ'B+1?A1;"/#$;1>t0"1>#+;1?"tV$*#";+%*>*&QJ',"1>'4@#1#"J',"#1$>'8*)#L1?"J'

5">";*AA/%$;1#$*%@J'5?1%@H*?#1#$*%t4N/$HA"%#tf")"%@"J'="%#/?"'W1H$#1>J'

Y1%/)1;#/?$%&J'1%2'8"?<$;"O'

_W1#"&*?$"@'L"?"3'V/@$%"@@'f"<">*HA"%#J'W*%@/>#$%&t8#?1#"&$;'B>1%%$%&J'-$%1%;"'

h6%<"@#A"%#'V1%K$%&J'81>"@'X'5?12$%&J'6%<"@#A"%#'Y1%1&"A"%#',"@"1?;+J'(#+"?iJ'

!"%"?1>'Y1%1&"A"%#tC"12"?@+$H'f"<">*HA"%#'B?*&?1AJ'6%)*?A1#$*%'5";+%*>*&QJ'

Y1?K"#$%&'t'81>"@J'(H"?1#$*%@'t'B?*:";#'Y1%1&"A"%#J'B?*2/;#'

Y1%1&"A"%#tf"<">*HA"%#J'(#+"?['

'

8/7/2019 Getting Off on the Right Foot- Subjective Value Versus Economic Value in Predicting Longitudinal Job Outcomes From…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/getting-off-on-the-right-foot-subjective-value-versus-economic-value-in-predicting 37/37

!"##$%&'())'*%'#+"',$&+#'-**#'''Rm'

'.Z'FA*%&'#+"';>1@@'*)'EZZmJ'#+"?"'L"?"'Rmb'@/?<"Q'?"@H*%2"%#@'1@'*)'D/>Q'EZZmJ'

*)'L+*A'EmE'+12'1;;"H#"2'1':*9'*))"?')*?')/>>M#$A"'"AH>*QA"%#J'.E_'?"H*?#"2'%"&*#$1#$%&'

#+$@':*9'*))"?J'1%2'.._'U_Ek['?"@H*%2"2'#*'#+"'@/?<"Q'$#"A@')*?'#+"'8=6'$#"A@'1%2'

"GH";#"2'@1#$@)1;#$*%O'

..']"'#+1%K'1%'1%*%QA*/@'?"<$"L"?')*?'?1$@$%&'#+$@'H*$%#O'