get ready for cap and trade, california
TRANSCRIPT
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 1/20
@BCE@ _MQI DEA\J_Q, MFWEA\Q \J
_E\BWE]B_Q ENL \HB BAJNJF]
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 2/20
Nbx| 57 mq e NjNwe|mqeN, NjNwjdm| jceNm{e|mjN |he| blrae|bq,
bNcecbq eNl bfwjsbq ae`mdjNmeNq |j mfwjtb |hb q|e|b”q dr|rb.
Nbx| 57 mq djarqbl jN mNNjte|mjN eNl |hb mN|bqba|mjN ob|sbbN
|hb bajNjf}, bNtmjNfbN|, eNl ure`m|} jd `mdb mqqrbq. sb wjtmlb
am|mae` le|e |j hb`w mNdjf |hb q|e|b”q bddj|q |j cjs |hb
bajNjf} eNl blrab cbbNhjrqb ceq bfmqqmjNq.
Rqnc |h E``jsEn TE`R drjf E`djrnE”q Erojn |rElnc
q}q|f; `cE` rqi dE|jrq, fE|q |j rE|E}rq Enl |h jnjf}
qrffem{bq djr bqbeah wewbq ajffmqqmjNbl o} Nbx| 57 djf
`belmNc eaelbfma bxwb|q |j wjtmlb eN jtbtmbs jd |hb rqb jd
e``jseNab te`rb abe|bl rNlb |hb q|e|b”q aew&eNl&|elb wjcef
eNl lmqarqq lmddbbN| jw|mjNq dj hjs |hb e``jseNab te`rb aeN
ob rqbl.
qwbame e n n n n n , n n nn n n, nn n n n n,n n n n n i.
Ahrq OqahFrr AebrKenb He``Qbtb @btLetl Fa@ech`n_xenne Qfh
wjlrabl o} Nbx| 57
D. Nb` WbrrQereh HbnrFerae B. Wbrr
lbqmcNbl o} ahbN lbqmcN eqqjame|bq
eaINjs`blcbfbN|q
fEn} |hEniq eb lrb |j |hb dj``jsmNc bqbeahbq shjer|hjbl |hb q|rlmbq qrffe m{bl mN |hmq bwj|;
Le``eq Orre Qbnr Db`` _bqrabq r hb Drb
Qereh K Q{efob`en rfbr _bqbeahbr _bqrabq r hb Drb
Len Derobr Wrbqqr @e enl aher hb Bnbrc enl_bqrabq Crw e hb Rntbrq Ae`rne e Obrib`b
Lboreh @efob Qbnr W`a Eqqaeb e hb Abnbr n @e Bnbrc $ hbBntrnfbn (A@BB- e hb Rntbrq Ae`rne Obrib`b Qah` @e
Letl _`enl&H`q Wrbqqr Ecra`re` enl _bqrab Banfaq ehb Rntbrq Ae`rne e Obrib`b
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 3/20
Mn|jlra|mjn ?
Oeaicjrnl;EO1?”qAew&enl&\elbWjcef ?
E``jsenabqmn|hbAewenl\elbQ}q|bf <
\hbMfwea|qjQwbnlmncLj``eqjfE``jsenabQe`bq 2
_btbnrbCbnbe|blo}E``jsenabQe`bq|jR|m`m|mbq 3
ShjLbamlbqhjs|hbFjnb}sm``obRqbl: 57
@bce`@mfm|e|mjnqjE``jsenabQwbnlmnc 55
Ajq|qjAewenl\elb 5<
Hbe`|henlBntmjnfbn|e`Obnbd|qjEO1? 52
She|mqNbx|: 54
Bnlnj|bq mnqmlboeaiajtb
Ajn|bn|q
5R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 4/20? R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
mN|jlra|mjN
mn en br `f hb lefecb a`feb lqrwn a`l l
wo`a hbe`h hb bntrnfbn enl hb banf Ae`rne
bneabl EO 1? hb C`oe` serfnc Q`nq Ea ?774 .|hq `bcq`en qbq hb nen”q rq `bce`` onlnc ercb r
aronc a`feb&lqrwnc crbbnhqb ceq (CHC- bfqqnq.
m ae``q n hb qeb & hb r`l”q 5?h&`ercbq bfbr
crbbnhqb ceqbq & a CHC bfqqnq 5==7 `btb`q
o hb ber ?7?7 enl lrbaq hb Ae`rne Er _bqrabq
Oerl (E_O- nl eq fbb he ercb. |hb E_O”q
Qawnc W`en bqqbne`` hb o`bwrn r fw`bfbnnc EO
1? `nbq e qb bfqqn rblan fbeqrbq he
hbn fw`bfbnbl `` fbb EO 1?”q ce`q.
|hq rbwr qbbiq obbr nlbrqenl Ae`rne”q aew&
enl&relb wrcref enl lbrbn e`brnetbq r h hb
qeb aen qb hb e``enab te`b arbebl nlbr hb aew&
enl&relb wrcref. |hb nlncq n hq rbwr qffer{b e
qbrbq rbwrq affqqnbl o Nbx 57 he rbwrbqbn
hb rq bxbnqtb ene`qq n hb qqb e`brnetb qbq
e``aen te`b enl hb rbtbnb lbrtbl rf wbrf
eanq.
?75? bqbeah jN e``jae|mNc
e``jseNab te`rb
jwnq r Aew enl |relb Ean _btbnb E``aen; EnBanfa Eqqbqqfbn r Ae`rne o Letl _`enl&H`q
q hb rq fearbanfa ql bxefnb hb banfa
fwea qwbnlnc rbtbnbq cbnbrebl o hb qe`b aew
enl relb bfqqnq e``enabq. _`enl&Hq flb`q hb
Crqq Qeb Wrla (CQW- koq enl qeb rbtbnb fwea
58 lbrbn wqqo`b qwbnlnc wnq r aew enl relb
rbtbnbq ob lqrobl hb qeb”q Er W``n Anr`
Dnl.
Ae`rne”q Aew&enl&|relb Ean; Erb hb Ean
Wrabblq Dbbq |exbq r Qfbhnc B`qb: o Len Derobr
enl Lboreh @efob br e `bce` ene`qq lbrbn
qrebcbq r qwbnlnc rbtbnbq reqbl hrch hb qe`b
bfqqnq e``enabq n Ae`rne.
Dr hb Obnb Ae`rne B`bara _ebwebrq;
B`bara qbar wnq r hb qb e``enab te`b
arbebl nlbr Ae`rne”q aew&enl&relb wrcref e`q o
Le``eq Orre enl Qereh K Q{efob`en bxefnbq h
Ae`rne rebwebr ` o``q `` ob fweabl o hb
aew&enl&relb wrcref. E``enab te`b obnc rbrnbl
hb b`bara qbar q crbebr hen hb aq fwqbl
nlbwbnlbn` o hb aew&enl&relb wrcref. |hb ene`qq
bxefnbq hrbb lbrbn wrwqbl qrebcbq h he
te`b aen ob qbl obnb rebwebrq.
E Wrfbr n hb Rqb E``enab Te`b Arbebl nlbr hb
Aj? Aew&enl&|relb Wrcref o Le``eq Or re enl Qereh
K Q{efob`en bxefnbq h hb rbtbnbq cbnbrebl o
hb EO 1? aew&enl&relb wrcref fch ob qwbn. |hb
ehrq e`q bxw`en ib eqwbaq hb wrcref na`lnc
he e``enab te`b q h `` feib hb lbaqnq eo
hq o``n l``er w`q rbtbnb qrab hb fb`nb r fekr
lbaqnq enl h lbrbn Ae`rnenq fch ob fweabl.
|hb wrwqb hq Qffer enl hb bxwbr rbqberah
affqqnbl o Nbx 57 q hb`w blaeb Ae`rnenq
eo hb qeb”q aew&enl&relb wrcref enl hb `ib`
o``nq l``erq n rbtbnb `` cbnbreb tbr fb. mn r
brq qffer{b hq ol rbqberah b qb qbanq
hb Wrfbr o Orre enl Q{efob`en eq en rcen{nc
lafbn enl wrbqbn qfferbq hb fen nlncq rf
hb hbr hrbb qlbq.
oeaIcjrNl; eo 1? ”q aew&eNl&|elbwjcef
mn ?774 Ctbrnr Ern`l Qaher{bnbccbr qcnbl EO 1?
hb nen”q rq `bce`` onlnc w`a efbl e anc hbbfqqnq he anrob a`feb ahencb. |hb E_O”q
Qawnc W`en bqqbne`` e o`bwrn r fbbnc hb ce`q
EO 1? na`lbq e nfobr qrebcbq na`lnc e aew&enl&
relb wrcref e @ Aeron Db` Qenlerl hb Qqeneo`b
Affnbq enl A`feb Wrban Ea e hch qwbbl re`
wrkba `ninc Qen Drenaqa Enehbf Ae`rne”q F``n
Q`er _q wrcref e _brcbren Fenecbfbn Wrcref
e _bnbeo`b Wr` Qenlerl (_WQ- hb Ae`rne A`ben
Aer enl Eltenabl A`ben Aer Qenlerlq (Wet`b m enl mm- enl
hb |`b ?< O`lnc Bnbrc Babna Qenlerlq.5
j e`` hb Qawnc W`en fbeqrbq `qbl eotb hb fbeqrb
erceo` ereanc hb fq ebnn rf hb fble enl
qeb `belbrq q E_O”q ferib&oeqbl bfqqnq aew&enl&
relb wrcref qb eib bba n ?751.
Aew&enl&relb heq werq. |hb rq wer “ hb aew “
w`eabq en tbre`` `f n hb e` efn CHC bfqqnq
ea`bq atbrbl o hb wrcref aen rb`beqb n hb
efqwhbrb. mn Ae`rne”q wrcref wbr afwenbq
earbq enl hbr `ercb ea`bq rbc`ebl nlbr hb aew
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 5/201R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
fq qrrbnlbr nb e``enab r beah fbra n aeron
lxlb bfqqnq.
|hb qbanl wer “ relb “ rbbrq e ferib r onc
enl qb``nc bfqqnq e``enabq. Rnlbr hb aew&enl&relbwrcref e w`en (r hbr bn- fch ahqb fbb q
o`cenq nlbr EO 1? bhbr o wraheqnc bfqqnq
e``enabq r o anc q bfqqnq hrch en bnbrc
babna wrcref r hbr qrebc. |hbrb q e`q e
qbanler ferib9 e a`ben&rnnnc w`en fch ahqb
qb`` q nnbblbl e``enabq (wbne`` e e wr- hbr
afwenbq. |hb eo` relb e``enabq e``q oqnbqqbq
lbalb r hbfqb`tbq hbhbr hb `l rehbr a
bfqqnq o enl qb`` e``enabq r fw`bfbn e w`en
he na`lbq oh qrebcbq. |hbqb ea`bq fe ahqb
hahbtbr wn feibq hb fq nenae` qbnqb r hbf.
Qenlerlq enl fbeqrbq e`rbel n w`eab erb bxwbabl
eahbtb tbr hrbb&uerbrq hb ce` a 87 f``n
fbra nq aeron lxlb bute`bn (FF|Aj?b- rf
Ae`rne”q banf o hb ber ?7?7. |hbqb fbeqrbq
qah eq hb fw`bfbnen e @&Aeron Db` Qenlerl
bnbrc babna enl anqbrten fbeqrbq enl hb qeb”q
11 wbrabn _bnbeo`b Wr` Qenlerl r b`bara
cbnbren erb bxwbabl b`l 4? FF|Aj?b n rblanq
(Qbb Dcrb E-.? Aew enl relb wrtlbq hb eqqrenab
he 58 FF|Aj?b n rhbr rblanq erb eahbtbl enl
he hb qeb ftbq hb rbq hb e erlq q ce`. 1
jnab lqrobl e``enabq rf hb qeb”q aew&enl&relb
wrcref `` atbr 82 wbrabn CHC bfqqnq earqq
Ae`rne.<
sh`b EO 1? rburbq rfq rblab CHC bfqqnq
q fwren rbfbfobr he Ae`rne rbqlbnq enl
oqnbqqbq o enl qb hb wrlaq rf hbqb rfq q
hbrb q e qherbl rbqwnqo` r h q rbqwnqo`b enl
h rblab bfqqnq n hb fq babn fennbr. |hq
rbwr q lblaebl wrtlnc nrfen arae` feinchbqb ahabq.
5 2 77 2 7 5 7 7& 2 7 1 7 7? 7 7 ? 2 7 1 2 7 < 7 7 < 2 7 2 7 7 2 2 7
5==7 BFMQQMJNQ \E_CB\
OER ?7?7 DJ_BAEQ\
_BLRA\MJNQ D_JF J\HB_
EO 1? FBEQR_BQ
?7?7 SM\H EO1?
FBEQR_BQ
_BLRA\MJNQ NBBLBL D_JF A$\
\_ENQWJ_\E\MJN
B@BA\_MA WJSB_
AJFFB_AME@ ENL _BQMLBN\ME@MNLRQ\_ME@
_BA]A@MNC ENL SEQ\B
HMCH CSW
EC_MAR@\R_B
DJ_BQ\_]
FM@@MJN FB\_MA \JNQ JD AJ? BURMTE@BN\
< ? 3
5 8
Qjrabq; E ``jsenab nfobrq enl bfmqqmjnq bq|mfe|bq erb oeqbl jn d mcrbq mn E_O”q D mne` _bc`e|mjn Jrlbr.
h||w;**sss.ero .ae .cjt*aa*mntbn|jr}*le|e*|eo `bq*rbla|mjnqZdrjfZqajwmncZw`enZfbeqrbqZ?757&57&?8.wld $ h||w;* *sss.ero .ae .cjt*aa*mntbn|jr}*le|e*djrbaeq|.h|f
dmcrb e; qjrabq jd chc bfmqqmjNq eNl bxwba|bl blra|mjNq mN ?7?7
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 6/20<
e``jseNabq mN |hb aew eNl |elb q}q|bf
O``nq l``erq erb bxwbabl ob cbnbrebl rf hb
qe`b e``aen enl relnc ‐bfqqn e``enabq‖ nlbr
aew enl relb. |hq fnb a`l ob qwbn n en nfobr eq. m a`l r bxefw`b ob qbl ;
5. E``bteb en wbne` eltbrqb fweaq EO 1? qah eq
narbeqbq n ceq`nb wrabq r b`bara rebq.
?. Dnl ctbrnfbn wrcrefq qah eq blaen
nreqrarb r hbe`h qbrtabq.
1. _brn fnb Ae`rne ef`bq hrch ltlbnlq
hb cbnbre` wo`a.
<. _blab arrbn exbq r wrbtbn rb ex narbeqbq.
mn q Dne` _bc`en jrlbr hb E_O `nbl hrbb cbnbre`
okbatbq;
5. _btbnbq cbnbrebl rf hb ean b`bara qbar
e``enabq qh`l ob rbrnbl rebwebrq.
?. Qfb e``enab te`b qh`l ob qbl wrba
bfqqnq&nbnqtb relb&bxwqbl nlqrbq hn
Ae`rne.
1. _btbnbq rf hb cbnbre` ean e``enabq `` ob
lbwqbl n en Er W``n Anr` Dnl enl qh`l
ob qbl eltenab hb okbatbq EO 1? hb C`oe`
serfnc Q`nq Ea.
Ean rbtbnbq ob lbwqbl n hb Er W``n
Anr` Dnl erb bqfebl rencb rf ,7.4 ,5.8 o``n
n ?75?‑?751 fq` rf hb ber` ean e``enabq
r ?752. |hb nl q bxwbabl cr qoqene`` n
?752 hbn qww`brq nere` ceq enl renqwren
b`q erb rburbl obcn wraheqb e``enabq atbr
hbr bfqqnq. mn ?752 hb nl q bxwbabl bern ,2.8
o``n n rbtbnbq eq qhn n o`b n Dcrb O h ,<.=
o``n cbnbrebl e hb cbnbre` ean enl ,7.= o``n e
hb ean r rb berq. sh o``nq l``erq qwbn
e ean enl lbwqbl n hb Er W``n Anr` Dnlbeah ber lbalnc h qb he fnb q ffbnqb
fwrenab Ae`rne”q banf olcb q oqnbqqbq
enl a{bnq.
E@@JSENAB W_MAB DJ_ BEAH ]BE_ MQ EOJTB BEAH OE_ ENL MN ?75? LJ@@E_Q
O M @ @ M J N
Q
J D
L J @ @ E _ Q
( ? 7 5 ?
, -
? 7 5 ? ? 7 5 1 ? 7 5 <
, 5 8 . < 4
? 7 5 2
, ? 7 . = ?
? 7 5 4
, ? 1 . 2 <
? 7 5 8
, ? 8 . 3 5
? 7 ? 7
, 1 < . 7 =
? 7 5 =? 7 5 3
, ? 4 . 7 2
5 ?
5 <
5 7
8
<
4
?
7
TE@RB \J MJRQ $ WJRQ
D_BB E@ @JAE\MJN \J MNLRQ\_]
EM_ WJ@@R\MJN AJN\_J@ DRNL
EN\MAMWE\BL ELTENAB ERA\MJN _BTBNRBQ WJ Q\ ?7?7
, 5 2 . = 7
, 1 5 . 1 ?
, 5 2 . = 7
4 . 12 . 8 4 . 3 3 . 7 3 . < 3 . 3
5 . 55 . 7
7 . =
5 . 5
5 . 7
7 . 37 . 1
7 . 85 . ? 5 . 5
5 . ? 5 . ?
? . 55 . =5 . 35 . ?
? . 1 ? . 2 ? . 3 ? . 8
dmcrb o; e``jseNab btbNrbq eqqjame|bl sm|h rqbq |hjrch ?7?7
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 7/202
|hb mfwea|q jd qwbNlmNc lj``eq djfe``jseNab qe`bq
Qwbnlmnc Emr Wj``|mjn Ajn|rj` Dnl _btbnb
Ae`rne q n anqlbrnc e nfobr eq hb qeba`l qwbnl hb l``erq cbnbrebl rf hb qe`b bfqqn
e``enabq. |hb Qen Drenaqa @q Encb`bq*Enehbf
hch&qwbbl re` wrkba q nb qwbnlnc wn he heq obbn
hb aq fah fble ebnn. jhbr wqqo`b qwbnlnc
wnq erb e`q obnc lqaqqbl enl erb bqwbae`` rb`bten
r hb rb obcnnnc n ?752 hbn hb rbtbnb rf
hb ean q `ib` cr tb&`l. |hbqb wnq na`lb
ctnc hb fnb Ae`rne hqbh`lq n hb rf
e rboeb ahbai qwbnlnc hb l``erq n bnbrc babna
wrkbaq r qnc hb rbtbnb nl rbqlbne` rbnbeo`b
bnbrc nqe``enq. Beah hbqb qwbnlnc wnq `l
eba hb qeb”q bfqqn rblan ce`q q CQW qeb
rbtbnbq koq bu hb bntrnfbn enl hb hbe`h
Ae`rnenq.
|hb ``nc aher rf rbqberahbr Letl _`enl&H`q”q
jwnq r Aew enl |relb Ean _btbnb E``aen; En
Banfa Eqqbqqfbn r Ae`rne lbnbq 58 e`brnetb
qrebcbq r e``aenc ean rbtbnbq rf Ae`rne”q
aew&enl&relb wrcref. Rqnc hb Rntbrq Ae`rne e
Obrib`b”q OBE_ flb` _`enl&H`q flb`q he hb CQW
dmcrb a; feajbajNjfma mfwea|q (aheNcbq djf oeqb`mNb te`rbq mN ?7?7-
qabNemjbe` cqw (?757
fm``mjNq-
bfw`j}fbN|
(d|b-
q|e|b btbNrb
(f-
5 btbNrb boe|bq |j |e xwe}bq. <84 <,85< <4
?bNbc} bddmambNa} mfwjtbfbN|q jN q|e|b jsNbl orm`lmNcq, shmah ajr`l jddqb|cbNbe` drNl bxwbNlm|rbq.
81 <43 4
1jddqb| cbNbe` drNl bxwbNlm|rbq |hjrch abe|mtb dmNeNamNc ewwjeahbq. (btbNrbmq qwbN| jN NjN&bNtmjNfbN|e` mNtbq|fbN|q sm|h {bj cbbNhjrqb ceq blra|mjNq.-
?82 5,357 ?4
< bNbc } bdd mambNa} ea|mj Nq |j rwc elb bqml bN |me` ̀ mc h|mN c. ==3 4 ,=7? 28
2 bNbc} bddmambNa} ea|mjNq mNa`rlmNc eww`meNab bddmambNa} rwcelbq eNl bw`eabfbN|q. 8=4 3 ,1?8 =?
4 bNbc} bddmambNa} ea|mjNq |j rwcelb bqmlbN|me` orm`lmNc bddmambNa}. 832 8 ,325 24
3 dmNeNamNc wjcef dj bNbseo`b bNbc} mNq|e``e|mjNq e| bqmlbN|me` wjwb|mbq . 44< 4 ,342 23
8mNlrq|me` bNbc} bddmambNa}; b|jdm|q eNl ajfw`meNab mNtbq|fbN|q dj r|m`m|mbqeNl `ecb mNlrq|me` ea|mtm |mbq (bNbc}, abfbN|, b|a.-.
523 5,14< 5?
= ajffbame` bNbc} bddmambNa} eNl lmq|mor|bl cbNbe|mjN wjcefq. 5<1 5 , 577 57
57qfe`` orqmNbqq bNbc} bddmambNa} & dmNeName` eNl j|hb qrwwj|mNc qbtmabq|j jtbajfb |bahNj`jc} eljw|mjN eNl ajfw`meNab hrl`bq.
<48 4,<87 57
55wjcefq |he| wjtmlb dmN eNamNc dj, j lmba|`} drNl ajNqbte|mjN eNl bNbc}bddmambNa} rwcelbq mN `js&mNajfb eNl fmll`b&mNajfb lsb``mNcq.
818 4,4?7 57?
5?
dmNeNamNc wjcefq dj ajffbame`, mNlrq|me` eNl feNrdea|rmNc deam`m| mbq |jblrab cbbNhjrqb ceq bfmqqmjNq o} mNtbq |fbN| mN bNbc} bddmambNa}, bNbc} q|jecb,eNl a`beN eNl bNbseo`b bNbc} wjkba|q.
5<? 5,54? 55
51 eaab` b e|bl l bw`j }fbN | j d elteNabl |bahN j` jc} tbhma`bq. 3 1= < ,5 23 < 5
5<`js&aeojN cjjlq fjtbfbN|, dbmch| tbhma`b |bahNj`jcmbq, wro`ma |eNqw j|e|mjN,eNl mNdeq|ra|rb lbtb`jwfbN|.
52< 5,524 5?
52 ojjIbNlq jd |hb hmch qwbbl em` wjkba| (Nj| |hb dr`` wjkba|-. <<? ?,425 15
54mfwjtb se|b qrww`} |hjrch fjb bddmambN| q|jecb, ajNtb}eNab, eNl feNecbfbN|mNdeq|ra|rb.
585 5,=4? 55
53dmNeName` eqqmq|eNab dj `jae` cjtbNfbN|q |j blrab tf| mN bddj|q |j fbb| |hbcje`q jd qo 132.
172 ?,<=4 58
58 c bbN oeN I ( `j eN qrwwj | d j bNbc } bdd mambNa} eNl bN bseo`bq- . 8 51 2 ,4?8 3<
Qjrab; E|hjr bq|mfe|bq.Nj|bq; CLW enl q|e|b olcb| mfwea|q mn ajnq|en| (?75?- fm`` mjnq jd lj``erq . Bfw`j}fbn| mn D\B hbelajn|. _bq`|q erb djr e ,577 fm`` mjn mn m| me ` rbtbnb e ``jae|mjn enl sj`l nj| cbnbre ``} qae`b w `mnber`} |j o m` ` mjnq jd lj``erq .
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 8/204
bfw`fbn enl qeb rbtbnb fwea `` ob hb qeb
brb qwbnl ,577 f``n n ean&cbnbrebl nlq wbr
ber tbr hb wbrl ?751&?7?7 n en hbqb 58 lbrbn
wrkbaq.
mn hb rbwr _`enl&H`q lqaqqbq hb rbq`q hb
banfa ene`qq. Hb nbq he hb qwbnlnc wnq
he qb olcber bxwbnqbq rbq` n `bqq banfa
crh afweretb` obaeqb hb rcne` qae` qf`q
bba q eoqbn n hbqb aeqbq . |hbqb qwbnlnc wnq q``
anrob crh obaeqb hb rbwrbqbn bxwbnlrb
qhnc rf hqb h we r bfqqn wbrfq hb
ctbrnfbn r hb etbrecb exwebr. |hb flb`bl qwbnlnc
wnq he qoql{b babna wrcrefq enl rbnbeo`bq
r hqbh`lq cbnbreb frb CLW enl bfw`fbn crh
lrba` enl nlrba` hen lnc q n hb wo`a r wrtebbnbrwrqb qbarq. |hq q obaeqb hqbh`l babna
fbeqrbq erb frb lqrobl enl hbrbrb frb ko
nbnqtb enl hbn hqbh`lq qetb fnb n bnbrc hbr
qwbnlnc n e`brnetb clq enl qbrtabq q eo 54 fbq
frb ko nbnqtb hen hb bnbrc b` qww` ahen. Dne``
hb rbwr nbq he obaeqb e`` hb e`brnetbq wrfb
banfa crh hb `` e `` reqb nb `nc&brf rbtbnb
r hb qeb.
| feib hb e`brnetb qrebcbq flb`bl afwereo`b
hq ene`qq eqqbqqbq hb fwea qwbnlnc e`` e ``enab
l``erq n n` nb wrkba. mn rbe` hb qeb fe qwbnl
rbtbnbq cbnbrebl o hb EO 1? aew&enl&relb wrcref
n e afonen qbtbre` qwbnlnc wnq. m q fwren
e`q nb he hb rbq`q erb n qae`eo`b eq hbrb fe
ob lfnqhnc rbrnq h ellne` rbtbnbq qwbn. |hq
eqqbqqfbn beah w`a wn enl q nltle` fweaq
wrtlbq nqch e`ob `fbl n h beah qwbnlnc ahab
fch fwea Ae`rne”q banf. Drf e fearbanfa
wbrqwbatb hb fq fwren anqlbrenq r
w`afeibrq rbtbnc rbtbnb e``aen e`brnetbq eq
b`` eq oqbrtbrq earqq hb qeb erb;
5. H `` hb rbtbnbq ob qbl:?. sh `` obnb lrba` rf hb rbtbnbq:
1. she `` ob hb `feb obnbq r hb qeb banf eq
e h`b na`lnc bfw`fbn CQW enl ellne` qeb
rbtbnbq:
E`` hbqb qenlerlq erb fwren arbre r bbatb enl
rbqwnqo`b qb en nb qeb rbtbnb qrab.
mn eqqbqqnc hb fwea hbqb qwbnlnc wnq _`enl&
H`q ana`lbq he;
5. Ae`rne heq e lb erre wnq r rbaa`nc
rbtbnbq rf eanq r CHC bfqqn wbrfq beah
hah aen anrob `nc&brf banfa crh enl
ko arbe n.
?. Fen hb e``aen wnq anqlbrbl rbrn frb
banfa crh hen hbr aq enl n hb wrabqq
narbeqb qeb rbtbnb o nb obnbq lbr qcnaen`.
1. |hb fq wr&crh wnq ntbq ean rbtbnb n
bxwenlbl hqbh`l&`btb` bnbrc babna enl rbnbeo`b
bahn`c lqn enl hbqb cbnbreb ellne` nb
qeb rbtbnb.
<. E``aenq he fbrb` qb bxqnc qae` afffbnq
h`b q`` qbrnc qfb crh l n b`l obnbq
afwereo`b affnc nb rbtbnbq babna
fbeqrbq.2
2. Nb bfw`fbn obnbq cbnbre`` narbeqb h CLW o
ter lbwbnlnc n hb lbfenl webrnq ebabl o hb
w`a. Ecen hqbh`l babna wrfn q hb fq
bfw`fbn&nbnqtb e``aen qrebc.
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 9/203
btbNrb cbNb e|bl o} e``jseNabqe`bq |j r|m`m|mbq
Obaeqb EO 1? wq e wrab n aeron eatbq rb`ebl
bfnc aeron `ib b`bara cbnbren obafbfrb bxwbnqtb. mn Dr hb Obnb Ae`rne B`bara
_ebwebrq; B`bara qbar wnq r hb qb
Dr hch`chq bfbrcb rf hq rbqberah;
5. E``enab te`b lrbabl oeai rebwebrq a`l qb
e`` hb aqq nrlabl o aew enl relb r b`bara
anqfbrq.
?. H hb e ``enab te`b q lrbabl rebwebrq ``
eba hb lqron aqq efnc aqfbrq enl
a`l eba hb babna hb aew&enl&relb wrcref.
1. m e``enab te`b q rbrnbl n b`bara o``q anqfbrq
`` wbrabtb he b`bara q rb`etb` `bqq bxwbnqtb. m
q rbrnbl n e qbwereb bntb`wb anqfbrq `` wbrabtb
hchbr b`bara o``q o hqbh`l olcbq `l
ob afwbnqebl. |hq lbaqn `` eba hb w`ae`
wbrabwn hb wrcref.
<. _eb narbeqbq rbq`nc rf hbr EO 1? w`abq qah eq
hb _bnbeo`b Wr` Qenlerl fe ob qoqene` enl
`` aar nlbwbnlbn` aew enl relb.
m q fwren nb hb Ae`rne Er _bqrabq Oerl
heq e``aebl e `beq bnch e``enab te`b `bq
e``enab te`b arbebl nlbr Ae`rne”q aew&enl&
relb wrcref rbqberahbrq Le``eq Orre enl Qereh K
Q{efob`en flb` rb aq narbeqbq r rbqlbne`
anqfbrq. |hb ob` aher rbdbaq hb etbrecb fnh`
bxwbabl narbeqbq obrb eaannc r l``erq cbnbrebl
o hb aew&enl&relb wrcref he nlbr hb `e fq ob
qbl r hb obnb rebwebrq.
atbr hbr aqfbr”q e` wrkbabl aq orlbn. mn q
ne` rbc`en rlbr hb Oerl lrbabl he hb te`b
e``enabq e``aebl `bq fq ob qbl r hb obnb
rebwebrq anqqbn h hb ce`q EO 1?. Kq h
he rbtbnb `` obnb rebwebrq q q`` w r lboeb.
Rnlbr hb aew&enl&relb wrcref b`bara `bq na`lnc
oh ntbqr&nbl enl wo`a` nbl `bq `` rbabtb
e rbb e``aen e``enabq e`nc =3.3 FF|Aj?b n
?751 lba`nnc 8<.= FF|Aj?b n ?7?7.4 mn hb qbanl
(?752&?753- enl hrl (?753&?7?7- wheqbq hb aew&enl&relb wrcref hbn renqwren enl nere` ceq erb
na`lbl b`bara”q qherb hb e` te`b e``enabq
`` e`` ?? wbrabn hb e` te`b e``enabq.
mntbqr&nbl `bq (mjR- `` ob rburbl qb`` hbr
e``enabq e uerbr` aew&enl&relb eanq hb rq
hah q bxwbabl n Ntbfobr ?75?. | fbb hbr n
afw`enab o`cen mjRq `` hbn nbbl wraheqb
e``enabq n hb ean r n hb qbanler ferib. |hb
wrtqn rburnc mjRq qb`` hbr e``aen n en ean
qrffb smN|b
etbecb fjN|h`}
rqb (Ish-
etbecb om`` (*
fjN|h-
bq|mfe|bl cjqq
ajq| jd a$| (*
fjN|h-
etbecb fjN|h`}
rqb (Ish-
etbecb om`` (*
fjN|h-
bq|mfe|bl cjqq
ajq| jd a$| (*
fjN|h-
Oeqma qbrtmab
wc$b <52 |j 57?< 33 |j 58= ?.?< |j 2.2? 27< |j 321 =1 |j 51= ?.35 |j <.74
qab 27< |j ?<?= <4 |j ??5 ?.?8 |j 57.=8 <=8 |j 47= <2 |j 22 ?.?2 |j ?.32
qlc$b 215 |j =78 =4 |j 542 ?.<1 |j <.52 22= |j 34< == |j 512 ?.24 |j 1.<=
e``&b`ba|rma
wc$b 27< |j 5175 =1 |j ?<7 ?.35 |j 3.75 383 |j 5283 5?2 |j ?25 ?.15 |j <.42
qab 221 |j ?141 27 |j ?52 ?.27 |j 57.48 32= |j 5214 22 |j 55? 5.84 |j 1.38
qlc$b 2<? |j 573= == |j 5=4 ?.<8 |j <.=< 333 |j 5112 5?4 |j ?53 5.=1 |j 1.1?
dmcrb l; |hb cjqq ajq| jd aew&eNl&|elb dj bqmlbN|me` arq|jfbq obdjb eaajrN|mNc dj e``jseNab te`rb
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 10/20
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 11/20=
Orre enl Q{efob`en flb` hb banfa fweaq
n rebwebrq beah hb eotb hrbb qrebcbq.
|hb ``nc eo`b qffer{bq hb banfa obnb
rebwebrq eq b`` eq hb nb ahencb n aqfbr aqq
hbn e``enab te`b q rbrnbl rebwebrq. |hb
ehrq ana`lb he hbn e``enab te`b q eibn n
Oeqbl n hq flb`nc hb rbqberah ana`lbq he
e``enab te`b arbebl o hb qe`b mjR e``enabq aen
qb e`` r nber` e`` narbeqbl aqq rebwebrq. Hbtbr
nq`enc rebwebrq rf en narbeqb n b`bara o``q
fch wrbtbn hb eahbtbfbn Ae`rne”q a`feb ahencb
ce`q n hb `nc rn obaeqb `l feqi hb eae` aq
hbr b`bara anqfwn. jn hb hbr henl e``nc
anqlbren rebwebrq erb hb`l herf`bqq nlbr hb EO
1? aew enl relb qqbf nlbr hb mjR enl hb L_E w`enq
enl aqq erb q`ch` hchbr nlbr hb Kn Bntrnfbne`
Werbq w`en (obrb eaannc r hb obnbq
ntbqfbnq nlbr he w`en-;
o``q rqb enl rbrnnc hb e``enab te`b hrch e
lrba wefbn `l reqb hb tqo` hb aew&enl&relb
wrcref h w`a enl w`ae` anqbubnabq. Deanc
hbqb relb&q q en fwren qqb he qh`l ob
anabrn e`` Ae`rnenq enl `` ob a`qb` oqbrtbl o
w`ae` `belbrq earqq hb c`ob.
qrffb
r|m`m|}
ablm| (obNbdm| djf era|mjN btbNrbq- wb arq|jfb(*fjN|h-
Nb| aheNcb mN arq|jfb ajq|q ed|b ablm|("-
Oeqma qbrtmab
wc$b ?.?2 |j 2.24 ?.71 |j 2.77 5.5= |j ?.=< 7.7" 7.1" 5.<"
qab ?.15 |j 55.51 ?.78 |j 57.75 5.?? |j 2.88 &7.5" 7.<" ?.1"
qlc$b ?.<5 |j <.55 ?.53 |j 1.37 5.?3 |j ?.53 7.7" 7.1" 5.?"
e``&b`ba|rma
wc$b ?.1? |j <.4= ?.7= |j <.?? 5.?1 |j ?.<8 7.7" 7.?" 7.="
qab ?.21 |j 57.8? ?.?8 |j =.3< 5.1< |j 2.3? &7.5" 7.<" ?.1"
qlc$b ?.<4 |j <.8= ?.?5 |j <.<7 5.17 |j ?.28 7.7" 7.1" 5.?"
smN|b
Oeqma qbrtmab
wc$b ?.31 |j <.7= ?.<4 |j 1.48 5.<< |j ?.54 7.7" 7.1" 5.<"
qab ?.?8 |j ?.3= ?.72 |j ?.25 5.?7 |j 5.<3 &7.5" 7.<" ?.1"
qlc$b ?.21 |j 1.<4 ?.?8 |j 1.5? 5.1< |j 5.81 7.7" 7.1" 5.?"
e``&b`ba|rma
wc$b ?.1? |j <.4= ?.7= |j <.?? 5.?1 |j ?.<8 7.7" 7.?" 7.="
qab 5.8= |j 1.81 5.37 |j 1.<< 5.77 |j ?.7? 7.7" 7.1" 5.4"
qlc$b 5.=? |j 1.?= 5.3? |j ?.=4 5.75 |j 5.3< 7.7" 7.?" 7.3"
dmcrb b; Nb| ajq| jd aew eNl |elb dj etbecb bqmlbN|me` arq|jfbq eajqq |b m|jmbqed|b eaajrN|mNc dj e` `jseNab te`rb
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
MJRq
MJRq
L_ E
L_ E
KB W
KB W
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 12/2057
@eq| le} djr om``q|j ob weqqbl j| jd|hb hjqb jd jrmcmn
@eq| le} djr Dmqae` Ajff.
|j rbwjr| |j D`jjr
FE] 5? KRN 5? KR@ 5? ERC 5? QBW 5?
Olcb| Om`` fq| obweqqbl e| Fmlnmch|
Obcmnnmnc jdD] ?75?&51
@eq| le} djr beah hjqb|j weqq om``q
AWR Lbamqmjn jn _btbnbq
dmcrb d; em wj``r|mjN ajN|j` drNl eNl b`ba|ma r|m`m|} btbNrb lbamqmjN |mfb`mNb
shj lbamlbq hjs |hb fjNb} sm`` ob rqbl :
|hb crb ob` wrtlbq e fb`nb rbtbnb lbaqnq
rb`ebl e``enab te`b he erb q`` nlbre. Lbaqnq
rbcerlnc e``enab rbtbnb lrbabl b`baraanqfbrq ntbqr nbl `bq (mjRq- `` ob eibn
o hb Wo`a R`bq Affqqn n Knb enl eibn o hb
ctbrnnc oerlq hb wo`a` nbl `bq n hb nber
rb. |hb `ercb rbfennc lbaqn anabrnq e``enab
rbtbnb he `` eaarb n hb Er W``n Anr` Dnl. |hq
lbaqn `` eib bba n hb nbx qae` ber.
Emr Wj``|mjn Ajn|rj` Dnl _btbnbq
mn hb `bcq`erb QO 523? (Wet`b- enl EO 521? (Wbrb{-
br arbre enl `bcq`etb tbrqch wrtqnq he `l
fenleb h hb ctbrnr enl qeb ecbnabq a`lewwrwreb rbtbnbq n hb Er W``n Anr` Dnl. |hbqb
o``q erb arrbn` rinc hbr e hrch bntrnfbne`
enl qae` affbbq n hb Qbneb enl Eqqbfo`. m hb
c e `` tb hb `bcq`erb beah fq ob weqqbl o e
qfw`b fekr tb o Ecq 15 ?75?. (mfwren lebq n
hq wrabqq erb lbe`bl n Dcrb D.-
Oh o``q `l arbeb e Crbbnhqb Ceq _blan
Eaan hn hb Er W``n Anr` Dnl enl `l
cren hb `bcq`erb hb wbr lbalb h hb rbtbnb
aen ob qwbn eq b`` eq hb wbr ewwrwreb hb fnb.
O hb qeb olcb fq ob ewwrtbl fah qnbr “ o
Knb 52. |hb re`br o`` eeahbl hb olcb `l e`q
arbeb e Crbbnhqb Ceq _blan Eaan hn hb Er
W``n Anr` Dnl `l cren hb bxbatb orenah
ewwrwren wbr enl `l rburb he hb ̀ bcq`erb
hetb e fnff 17 leq rbtb en qwbnlnc w`enq.
Nb he n` hb olcb heq obbn bneabl hb `bcq`erb
aenn qbnl hb ctbrnr en o`` ewwrwrenc nlq r hb
qefb qae` ber.3
Obrb Qbwbfobr 5? hb ctbrnr enl hb `bcq`erb ``
hetb ecrbb n h fnb rf hb nl `` ob lbwqbl
anr``bl enl qwbn. E_O enl hbr qeb ecbnabq ``
`ib` aerr bxwbnlrb w`enq he e`` hn hbr krqlan.
|hb lbaqn rbcerlnc hb wbnlnc olcb q fwren
bqwbae`` obaeqb `` hetb fw`aenq r h hb nl
q fenecbl n hb `nc rn. |hb rbe` qqb hbtbr q h
e``enab rbtbnbq `` ob qbl n ?752 enl obnl. Enne`
rbtbnbq afnc n hb nl erb bxwbabl cr rf
,2.8 ,3.3 o``n rf ?752 ?7?7 (qnc ?75? l``erq-.
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 13/2055
J|hbr E``jsenab _btbnb
|hb E_O heq e`rbel ewwrtbl r`bq r qnc rbtbnbq
wrba bnbrc&nbnqtb nlqrbq he erb qokba &&
qeb afwbn. |hb E_O lbnbl hbqb nlqrbq enlbqeo`qhbl r`bq r e``aenc rbb bfqqn e``enabq n
q mne` Qebfbn _beqnq rb`beqbl n jaobr ?757.
|hb E_O hb`l wo`a affbn wbrlq enl riqhwq
q`a nw rf nlqrbq earqq hb qeb enl e ne` r`b
eq ewwrtbl n Lbabfobr ?755.
`bce` `mfm|e|mjNq dj e``jseNab
qwbNlmNc
|hbrb erb `bce` enl wreaae` `fenq he fq ob
anqlbrbl hbn lbalnc h wrabblq cbnbrebl rf
hb qe`b bfqqn e``enabq aen ob qbl n Ae`rne.
mn Ae`rne”q Aew&enl&|relb Ean; Erb hb Ean
Wrabblq Dbbq |exbq r Qfbhnc B`qb: ehrq Len
Derobr enl Lboreh @efob anqlbr hb lbrbn `bce`
refbriq nlbr hah Ae`rne arq fe a`eqq hb
wrabblq eq e rbc`er bb qfb hbr bb en n`e` ex
r qfbhnc b`qb. |hq `bce` a`eqqaen q en fwren
nb obaeqb hb lbrbn a`eqqaenq fwea h l``erq
reqbl hrch hb aew enl relb wrcref fe ob qwbn . |hb
ql e`q wrtlbq e `bce` rqi ene`qq hb 58 e`brnetbq
r e``aenc ean rbtbnbq he brb rbtbbl wrbtq`
n hb _`enl&H`q ene`qq.
Erb |hb Ea|mjn Wrjabblq \exbq, Dbbq, jr
Qjfb|hmnc B`qb:
Wrwqn 51 ewwrtbl o hb tbrq n 5=38 efbnlbl
hb Ae`rne Anqn rburb he ex narbeqbq ob
ewwrtbl o e &hrlq fekr beah hb hqbq
hb @bcq`erb. EO 1? eq ewwrtbl o e qfw`b fekr.
|hbrbrb e ib `bce` qqb r hb aew&enl&relb wrcref
q hbhbr hb ean wrabblq aen `bce`` ob a`eqqbl eq
‐bbq‖ ‐``bce` exbq‖ r qfbhnc b`qb. |hb `e n hq erbe
q nbqbl (en ean e``enab lbq n e`` nlbr hb
`bce` lbnn e wae` bb qahbfb- q he hb arq
`` l q nabren.
Wrwqn ?4 weqqbl o hb tbrq n ?757 flbq
Wrwqn 51 bxwenl h e ‐ex‖ q lbnbl nlbr
Ae`rne `e. Wrw. ?4 fenlebq he qeb `eq he rbq`
n en exwebr wenc e hchbr ex fq ob ewwrtbl o
&hrlq tb beah hqb hb @bcq`erb. Derobr enl
@efob rbtbbl hb bx hb rcne` wrwqn enl hbr
ene`qq ana`lbq he hbrb q qfb efoc eo hb
eww`aen Wrwqn ?4 EO 1?.
mn hbr rbwr hb ehrq wrbqbn hrbb ercfbnq he
`nb h hb ob`btb ean wrabblq rf hb qeb”qaew enl relb wrcref aenn ob a`eqqbl eq e ‐ex‖ nlbr
Wrwqn 51;
\hbea|mjnwrjabblq,mdqwbn|djrelew|e|mjnjrfm|mce|mjn
fbeqrbq anqqbn h hb rbcfb bqeo`qhbl o
hb Ae`rne Qwrbfb Ar n Qna`er Wen8 fe ob
anqlbrbl e rbc`er bb rehbr hen e ex .
\hbajfw`menabmnq|rfbn|qshmahe``jsrbc`e|blbn|m|mbq
bf crbbnhqb ceqqbq anqb e ctbrnfbne`
wrt`bcb enl hq erb bute`bn e lbtb`wfbn bb
rehbr hen e ex. \hbwrmfer}wrwjqbjdAE_O,EO1?,enl|hbaew&enl&
relb wrcref q n qae` q Wrwqn 51 lbq n
eww`.
Arq anqlbrnc hb ubqn h a`eqq
e``enab te`b `` anq` hb `belnc aeqb n hb qokba
rbc`er bbq& Qna`er Wen. |hb Q na`er Wen aeqb
anabrnbl hb Ah`lhl @bel Wqnnc Wrbtbnn Ea
hah wrtlbl bte`en qarbbnnc enl fblae` ``&w
qbrtabq ah`lrbn e rqi `bel wqnnc. |hb wrcref
eq bnrb` qwwrbl o bbq n bnbq he anrobl
bntrnfbne` `bel wqnnc. |hb ar nl hb wrcref
anqb e ‐rbc`er bb‖ enl n e ex obaeqb
(5- hbrb eq e aeqe` annban obbbn hb wrla
rbc`ebl enl q eltbrqb bbaq (?- hb fnb reqbl eq
`fbl hb rbeqneo`b aq fcenc hb eltbrqb
bbaq enl (1- hbrb eq e rbeqneo`b rb`enqhw obbbn
hb e``aen aqq efnc webrq enl hb orlbnq
fwqbl o hb webr.
mn rlbr wrbtbn qaabqq` `bce` ahe``bncbq EO 1?
hb ehrq ob`btb hb fq anqbrtetb `bce` ewwreah
qwbnlnc l``erq cbnbrebl o hb aew&enl&relb wrcref`l ob qb hb ean wrabblq n e e he q
anqqbn h hb `bce` wrbablbn qbn o hb Qna`er Wen
aeqb.
|hb ehrq rhbr ana`lb he Wrwqn ?4 hah
fwqbq ellne` `fq n exen n Ae`rne `` n
eww` hb EO 1? rbtbnbq. EO 1? eq elwbl obrb hb
bbatb leb Wrwqn ?4 hah q hq n`ib` ob
nl eww`.
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 14/205?
m fe qbbf he h hb wrabblq rf hb aew&enl&relbwrcref a`l ob a`eqqbl o hb arq fch ob e fnr
r eaelbfa wn. Hbtbr kq h hbqb wrabblq erb
a`eqqbl a`l eae`` lbbrfnb hbhbr r n Ae`rne
a`l wrabbl h fw`bfbnnc hb wrcref h
rhbr ean o hb `bcq`erb.
mn elln hb rbqberah o Deobr enl @efob oh
RA@E enl hb Ae`rne”q nnwerqen @bcq`etb Ene`q
jab (@Ej- rbabn` ene`{bl h Wrwq 51 enl ?4 a`l
wbne`` eww` hb EO 1? aew enl relb wrcref.
Oh RA@E enl hb @Ej ana`lbl he nlbr hb `e hb
ean wrabblq cbnbrebl o hb aew enl relb wrcref`l ob anqlbrbl e ‐rbc`er bb‖ (enl e ‐ex‖- o hb
arq. Oh e`q ana`lbl he nlbr hb `e hb wrabblq
`l `ib` nbbl ob qwbn n wrcrefq he rblabr fceb crbbnhqb ceq bfqqnq. mn hb ``nc
|eo`b hb ehrq wrbqbn hbr `bce` rqi eqqbqqfbn
hb 58 rbtbnb e``aen e`brnetbq e`nc qlb hb
fearbanfa fweaq wrbqbnbl ber`br n hq rbwr o
Wrbqqr Letl _`enl&H`q.
ajq|q jd aew eNl |elb
Obaeqb EO 1? enl q aew&enl&relb wrcref w`eabq e aq
n bfnc aeron arbebq crbebr te`b n obnc babn
enl cbnbrebq nb rbtbnb r hb qeb Ae`rnenq
`` bxwbrbnab qfb qhq n hb tbre`` banf enl
wbne`` hbr le&&le `tbq. Wnc e wrab n aeron
n Ae`rne `` fwea b`bara rebq nere` ceq rebq
enl renqwren b`q. Hbtbr Ae`rnenq e`q qenl
obnb rf hb qb e``enab rbtbnbq hbhbr
Wrjw 51; Drf enl ebr hb bbatb
leb hq era`b en ahencbq n
Qeb exbq bneabl r hb wrwqb
narbeqnc rbtbnbq a``babl wrqen
hbrb hbhbr o narbeqbl rebq r
ahencbq n fbhlq afwen
fq ob fwqbl o en Ea weqqbl o
n `bqq hen &hrlq e`` fbfobrq
b`babl beah hb hqbq
hb @bcq`erb bxabw he n nb el
te`rbf exbq n rbe` wrwbr r qe`bq
r renqean exbq n hb qe`bq rbe`
wrwbr fe ob fwqbl. Ae`. Anq.
Ea. XmmmE £1
Wrjw ?4; Drf enl ebr hb bbatb
leb hq era`b en ahencbq n
qeb exbq bneabl r hb wrwqb
narbeqnc rbtbnbq a``babl wrqen
hbrb En} ahencb mn q|e|b q|e||b
shmah rbq`|q mn en} |exwe}br we}mnc
e hmchbr |ex hbhbr o narbeqbl rebq
r ahencbq n fbhlq afwen
fq ob fwqbl o en Ea ea| weqqbl o
n `bqq hen &hrlq e`` fbfobrq
b`babl beah hb hqbq
hb @bcq`erb bxabw he n nb el
te`rbf exbq n rbe` wrwbr r qe`bq
r renqean exbq n hb qe`bq rbe`
wrwbr fe ob fwqbl.
Qmna`emr Wemn| _bcmfb; Qna`er
Wen q hb `belnc aeqb n hb qokba
rbc`er bbq hbrb hb ar
lbbfbl hb rbc`er bb ob n
e ex obaeqb (5- hbrb eq e aeqe`
annban obbbn hb wrla
rbc`ebl enl q eltbrqb bbaq
(?- hb fnb reqbl eq `fbl
hb rbeqneo`b aq fcenc hb
eltbrqb bbaq enl (1- hbrb eq e
rbeqneo`b rb`enqhw obbbn hb
e``aen aqq efnc werq enl
hb orlbnq fwqbl o hb webr.
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 15/2051
dmcrb c; `bce` mqI eNl feajbajNjfma mfwea|q (feajbajNjfma aheNcbq djf oeqb`mNb te`rbq mN ?7?7-
qabNemjbe` cqw (?757
fm``mjNq-
bfw`j}fbN|
(d|b-
q|e|b btbNrb
(f-`bce` mqI
5 btbNrb boe|bq |j |exwe}bq. <84 <,85< <4 hmch
?bNbc} bddmambNa} mfwjtbfbN|q jN q|e|b jsNbl orm`lmNcq shmah ajr`ljddqb| cbNbe` drNl bxwbNlm|rbq.
81 <43 4`js |jfblmrf
1
jddqb| cbNbe` drNl bxwbNlm|rbq |hjrch abe|mtb dmNeNamNcewwjeahbq. (btbNrb mq qwbN| jN NjN&bNtmjNfbN|e` mNtbq|fbN|q sm|h{bj cbbNhjrqb ceq blra|mjNq.-
?82 5,357 ?4 hmch
<bNbc} bddmambNa} ea|mjNq |j rwcelb bqmlbN|me` ̀ mch|mNc. ==3 4,=7? 28 `js
2bNbc} bddmambNa} ea|mjNq mNa`rlmNc eww`meNab bddmambNa} rwcelbq eNlbw`eabfbN|q.
8=4 3,1?8 =? `js
4 bNbc} bddmambNa} ea|mjNq |j rwcelb bqmlbN| me` orm`lmNc bddmambNa}. 832 8,325 24 `js
3dmNeNamNc wjcef dj bNbseo`b bNbc} mNq|e``e|mjNq e| bqmlbN|me`wjwb|mbq.
44< 4,342 23 `js
8mNlrq|me` bNbc} bddmambNa}; b|jdm|q eNl ajfw`meNab mNtbq|fbN|q djr|m`m| mbq eNl `ecb mNlrq|me` ea|mtm| mbq (bNbc}, abfbN|, b|a.-
523 5,14< 5? `js
= ajffbame` bNbc} bddmambNa} eNl lmq|mor|bl cbNbe|mjN wjcefq. 5<1 5,577 57 `js
57qfe`` orqmNbqq bNbc} bddmambNa} “ dmNeName` eNl j|hb qrwwj|mNcqbtmabq |j jtbajfb |bahNj`jc} eljw|mjN eNl ajfw`meNab hrl`bq.
<48 4,<87 57 `js
55wjcefq |he| wjtmlb dmN eNamNc dj, j lmba|`} drNl ajNqbte|mjN eNlbNbc} bddmambNa} rwcelbq mN `js&mNajfb eNl fmll`b&mNajfb lsb``mNcq.
818 4,4?7 57? `js
5?
dmNeNamNc wjcefq dj ajffbame`, mNlrq|me` eNl feNrdea|rmNcdeam`m|mbq |j blrab cbbNhjrqb ceq bfmqqmjNq o} mNtbq| fbN| mN bNbc}bddmambNa}, bNbc} q|jecb, eNl a`beN eNl bNbseo`b bNbc} wjkba| q.
5<? 5,54? 55 `js
51 eaab`be|bl lbw`j}fbN| jd elteNabl |bahNj`jc} tbhma`bq. 31= <,523 <5 `js
5<`js&aeojN cjjlq fjtbfbN|, dbmch| tbhma`b |bahNj`jcmbq, wro`ma|eNqwj|e|mjN, eNl mNdeq|ra|rb lbtb`jwfbN|.
52< 5,524 5? `js
52 hmch qwbbl em` wjkba| “ qwbamdma |j |hb ojjIbNl wjkba|q. <<? ?,425 15`js |j
fblmrf&`js
54mfwjtb se|b qrww`} |hjrch fjb bddmambN| q|jecb, ajNtb}eNab, eNlfeNecbfbN| mNdeq|ra|rb.
585 5,=4? 55`js |j
fblmrf&`js
53dmNeName` eqqmq|eNab dj `jae` cjtbNfbN|q |j mfw`bfbN| |hbmqrq|emNeo`b ajffrNm|} q| e|bcmbq lbtb`jwbl |j fbb| |hb cje`q jd qo 132.
172 ?,<=4 58 `js
58 cbbN oeNI. 851 2,4?8 3< `js
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
Nj|b; `bce` r mqi `btb ` rbd`ba|q e Qmna`em r Wemn| ene`}q mq
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 16/205<
hbqb rbtbnbq erb qwbn n wrkbaq lbqcnbl obnbAe`rnenq r hqbh`lq rbabtb hb rbtbnbq lrba` n
hb rf rboeb ahbaiq. |hbqb lrba enl nlrba obnbq
erb lbqcnbl qb en narbeqbq n bnbrc aqq.
B`ba|rmam|}
Rnlbr fq hb wrwqe`q nlbr anqlbren rebwebrq
`l qbb `br b`bara aqq r nber ` nbre` aq
lbrbnabq. @&nafb ef`bq bnr``bl n Ae`rne
E`brnetb _ebq r Bnbrc enl `&anqfwn
hqbh`lq erb bxw`a` wrbabl rf reb narbeqbq.=
E abnre` qqb q hbhbr hb e``enab te`b he q
ete`eo`b qb hb wbne` narbeqb n aq q qbl
wrbtbn narbeqbq n b`bara o``q r o``q `` ob e``bl
rqb enl hb e``enab te`b q rbrnbl aqfbrq
hrch e lrba wefbn.
Db` Ajq|q
|hb E_O bqfebq he en ceq`nb (r hbr b`- wrab
narbeqbq rb`ebl hb aew&enl&relb wrcref `` lbwbnl
n h bbatb hbr wrcrefq wrtb ob. m bnbrc
babna fbeqrbq hb _bnbeo`b Wr` Qenlerl enl
hbr w`abq erb fw`bfbnbl bbatb` hb `` rblab
bfqqnq enl hb`w ibbw e``enab wrabq `. m hbqb
fbeqrbq erb n bxbabl bbatb` e``enab wrabq ``
rqb.
O ?7?7 hb E_O wrkbaq e rqb n ceq`nb wrabq 4
wbrabn rf aew enl relb eqqfnc qbq enl fbeqrbq
rblab bfqqnq n hb b`bara enl renqwren
qbarq fbb qebl ce`q.57 m hqb fbeqrbq ln” fbb
qebl ce`q ceq wr abq a`l rqb hchbr. O ?7?7 ceq
wrabq a`l narbeqb o obbbn ,7.58 enl ,5.<2 wbr ce``n
(n ?773 l``erq- enl lbqb` a`l narbeqb o obbbn
,7.?< enl ,5.83 wbr ce``n (n ?773 l``erq- lb hb aew&enl&relb wrcref.55
@jsbr Mnajfb Hjqbhj`lq
jtbre`` `br&nafb hqbh`lq qwbnl e hchbr wrn
hbr nafbq n bnbrc `betnc hbf t`nbreo`b aew enl
relb rbq`q n hchbr bnbrc aqq. jnb wn qb
hq rqi q nnb` qfb hb fnb reqbl hrch hbaew&enl&relb wrcref lrba` Ae`rne ef`bq n hb
rf rboeb ahbaiq. m hb qeb lbalbq fw`bfbn hq
qrebc q bxwbabl he fq hqbh`lq `l rbabtb
wefbnq he `l bxabbl en narbeqbl &&waib
bxwbnqbq r hchbr bnbrc aqq.
@br nafb affnbq enl affnbq a`r bn
eab crbebr banfa enl hbe`h fweaq rb`ebl xa
bfqqnq. mn Fnlnc hb A`feb Cew; she”q e qeib
Ae`rne”q a`feb `e qn” lnb rch enl rch ee e
ql he bxefnbq h a`feb w`a n Ae`rne ``
fwea lqeltenecbl affnbq enl affnbq a`r hb ehrq nb hb fwrenab n n` anc
aeron bfqqnq o e`q bnqrnc he bfqqnq erb
rblabl n e`` affnbq. |hb ehrq rb ‐mn Ae`rne
ah`lrbn n wtbr cbhbr h e`` wbw`b n wtbr
`tb lqwrwrneb` nber `ercb ea`bq bf nc xa
er w``n enl crbbnhqb ceqbq.‖5? |hb rbqberahbrq
lafbn h e rqi affnbq a`l qbr ellne`
hbe`h enl banfa anqbubnabq hb qeb e`q bnqrb
he bfqqnq erb rblabl n e&rqi affnbq.
H hb qeb lbalbq e``aeb rbtbnbq rf hb aew&
enl&relb wrcref a`l obcn ellrbqq hq lqwer. Eq
nbl wrbtq` hb @Ej bqfebq he n ?75?&51 aew enl
relb ean rbtbnbq a`l rencb rf ,447 f``n
tbr ,1 o``n. |hb @Ej enl hbrq e`q lqaqq he hbqb
rbtbnbq fq ob qbl fceb CHC bfqqnq r hb
herf aeqbl o CHC bfqqnq.51 Fen hb e`brnetbq
b ene`{bl n hq rbqberah `` nlbbl fceb CHC
bfqqnq r hb herf aeqbl o ternc lbcrbbq
hbe`|h eNl bNtmjNfbN|e` obNbdm|q
jd eo 1?EO 1? rburbq hb Ae`rne Er _bqrabq Oerl
bte`eb hb tbre`` qabe` obnbq fw`bfbnnc hb
`e na`lnc rblanq er w``enq (qlb aeron
bfqqnq- enl wqqo`b hbr obnbq hb bntrnfbn
hb banf enl wo`a hbe`h.5< sh`b bxwbr rbqberah
affqqnbl o Nbx 57 enl qffer{bl n hq lafbn
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 17/2052
wrtlbq en banfa enl `bce` ene`qq lbrbne`brnetbq r e``aenc aew&enl&relb rbtbnbq hb
rbqberah lbq n `` anqlbr hb rencb ntbqfbnq
enl rb`ebl bntrnfbne` enl hbe`h a&obnbq rf hbqb
e`brnetbq qbq rbtbnbq.
Dr nqenab ntbqfbnq fe e`q na`lb nere` rbqrab
wrban rblab bfqqnq enl qbubqbr frb aeron.
Eq hb hrl `ercbq qeb Ae`rne q hfb nber` 577
f``n earbq `enl hah q qbl enl fenenbl r
ecra`rb wrlan weriq fobr cre{nc enl wbn
qweab. A``batb` hbqb rbqrabq hb`w a`ben r er
enl ebr wrtlb l enl obr enl qww` heoe rAe`rne”q ltbrq qh enl `l`b. mntbqfbnq n
nere` rbqrabq a`l hbrbrb hb`w Ae`rne fbb q
bfqqn rblan ce`q h`b wrfnc e nfobr hbr
obnbq hb bntrnfbn banf enl wo`a hbe`h
anqqbn h EO 1? ce`q.
mn elln hb obnb rblanc Aj? bfqqnq fen
hb aew&enl&relb rbtbnb e``aen e`brnetbq ``
ternc lbcrbbq e`q rblab hbr xa w``enq na`lnc
{nb wera`eb febr aeron fnxlb nrcbn lxlb
enl q`r lxlb. _blanq n hbqb inn anrorq
eqhfe ahrna oqratb w`fner lqbeqb rbqwrer
``nbqqbq aerlteqa`er lqbeqb wrbferb lbeh enl
hbr eltbrqb hbe`h fweaq `` fwrtb wo`a hbe`h
n Ae`rne. Anc hbqb w``enq `` e`q rbq` n
fwrtbfbnq n `eor wrlat eq hbrb `` ob bbr
`q rileq enl e hbe`hbr ri bntrnfbn.52
jtbre`` q n wqqo`b bqfeb hb a&obnbq rf
e`brnetb qbq e``enab rbtbnbq h frb qwbaa
nrfen eo h enl hf hb rbtbnbq `` ob
lqrobl. she q a`ber q he hbrb erb qoqene`
a&obnbq rf fbeqrbq he fwrtb bnbrc babna`br tbha`b f`bq retb`bl enl fwrtb hb b`&babna
tbha`bq. En ewwrxfeb fbeqrb hb a&obnbq aen
ob cecbl rf hb Wo`a Hbe`h Ene`qq Qww`bfbn
r hb Lre Qawnc W`en54. |hq rbwr bqfebq hb
rblanq n NjX (24 nq wbr le- enl WF?.2 (5? nq e
le- rf qfb hb lrba qawnc w`en fbeqrbq rb`ebl
tbha`b enl bnbrc babna enl hb lbw`fbn
rbnbeo`b bnbrc enl e`q qhq hb eqqaebl hbe`h
obnbq. m qh`l ob nbl he qbtbnbbn hb bchbbn
qabnerq bxefnbl n hb rbqberah affqqnbl o Nbx
57 enl qffer{bl n hq rbwr rbq` n CHC bfqqnrblanq hrch bnbrc babna fwrtbfbnq enl*r
rbw`eanc aeron&bfnc bnbrc qrabq h rbnbeo`b
bnbrc qrabq.
Enhbr rbabn ene`qq hb te`b a&obnbq rf
EO 1? rb`ebl fbeqrbq q hb ene`qq rbwrbl o hb
Efbraen @nc Eqqaen”q rbwr n ‘|hb _el
A`ben Er” Fe ?755.53 |hb Ae`rne tbha`b qenlerlq
bntqnbl eq wer hb Qawnc W`en `` rblab tbha`b
CHC bfqqnq o <2&2? wbrabn rblab qfc&rfnc
bfqqnq o 32&82 wbrabn enl rblab wrbferb lbehq
enl ``nbqqbq o 42&32 wbrabn. jtbre`` hbrb `` ob obbbn,3.? enl ,8.5 o``n n etlbl hbe`h c`oe` erfnc enl
qabe` aqq.
|hb A`ben Er Ea bneabl n 5=37 wrtlbq q h enhbr
bxefw`b h en bntrnfbne` `e e hb nene` `btb`
aen eahbtb banfa enl wo`a hbe`h obnbq. |hb jab
Fenecbfbn enl Olcb bqfebl hb obnbq rf
hb wbrl 5==?&?77? ob ewwrxfeb` ,5?5 ,5=1
o``n r hb R.Q. h aqq ob ,?1 ,?3 o``n. |he
renq`ebq n ,< ,8 n obnbq r beah l``er ntbqbl
n a`ben er.
58
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 18/2054
she| mq Nbx| :|hb rq aew&enl&relb aeron wbrf ean n Ae`rne q
qb r Ntbfobr ?75?.
Fnb reqbl rf hb ean bfqqn e``enabq
rb`ebl cbnbrenc b`bara `` c `bq r hb
obnb hbr aqfbrq. Bxea` h hq lqron
aqfbrq `` aar `` ob lbalbl o hb Wo`a R`bq
Affqqn o Knb ?75? r wrteb` nbl `bq
enl o hb ctbrnnc oerlq wo`a` nbl `bq
qfbfb hq ber.
E qbanl wrn bfqqn e``enabq `` ob ctbn
nlqre` afwenbq eq `nc eq hqb oqnbqqbq fenen
koq enl banfa eat n hb qeb. Ae`rne ef`bq
obnb rf hq e``aen wrbtbnq koq rf `betnc
hb qeb. O hb rbb e``aen e``enabq q
cbnbrq a`l `bel nle`` wrq r nlqr. |hb
E_O `` bte`eb hq qqb tbr fb.
|hb hrl wrn q hb rbtbnb cbnbrebl rf eannc
e``enabq. mn hb nbx qae` ber rbtbnbq `` efn
,7.4 ,5.8 o``n enl `` cr tb&`l o ?752 hbn
nere` ceq enl renqwren b`q afb nlbr aew enl
relb. mn hb `nc rn hb `ercbq bba n hqbh`lq ``
hncb n hb lbaqn eo h qb hbqb rbtbnbq.
mn qffer bfqqn e``enabq n EO 1?”q aew&enl&relb
wrcref rbwrbqbn o``nq l``erq n te`b r Ae`rnenq
& te`b he `` n `betb hb qeb”q banf. jtbr hb nbx
qbtbre` fnhq hb Ae`rne Wo`a R`bq Affqqn
Ae`rne Er _bqrabq Oerl qeb `efeibrq enl
Ctbrnr Orn `` lbalb h qwbnl hq fnb. |hbqb
erb te`` fwren lbaqnq he qh`l ob nbrbq e``
Ae`rnenq.
wbtmjrq bqbeah o} Nbx| 57Wrbtq rbqberah wo`qhbl o Nbx 57 enl affqqnbl
rf e nfobr bxwbr ehrq bxefnbl aew enl relb
frb orel` bxw`ennc h hb wrcref `l ob
lbqcnbl.
mn hq wrbtq ri Lbqcnnc hb E``aen Wrabqq r
Ae`rne”q Crbbnhqb Ceq Bfqqnq |relnc Wrcref;
|hb f`&o``n l``er ubqn fearbanfa rbq`q rf
_`enl&H`q nlaeb he eannc rbtbnbq q wrbbreo`b
enl qhq he hb ltlbnl ewwreah wbrrfq b`` n
fearbanfa brfq eq afwerbl hb ex rblan.RQA _bqberah Wrbqqr Elef _qb”q afwenn rbqberah
``qrebq hb te`b rbb e``aen he wrabqq wrbaq
anqfbrq rf aq narbeqbq.
Wrbtq qlbq rf Orre enl Werr rbtb hb rbeqnq
banfqq wrbbr qnc e``enab te`b a ex rebq.
m e ltlbnl ewwreah brb ahqbn hb br hb lbe
arbetb ewwreahbq qnc hb qrbef bxwbabl
rb rboeb wefbnq eq a``ebre` n `enq r a`ben bah
ntbqfbnq. Frcbnqbrn enl Frb aqbl hbr rbqberah
n hb nlqre` qbar enl nl n hbr qhr&rn ene`qqhb fweaq Ae`rne”q bnbrc nbnqtb enl relb
bxwqbl nlqre` qbarq `l ob qfe``. Drbb e``aen
`ercb` henl`bq en nbcetb aq.
R Q m N C | H B E @ @ js E N A B T E @ R B D _ j F A E @ m D j _ N m E ” Q A E _ O j N | _ E L m N C Q } Q | B F
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 19/2053? 7 5 ? a e ` m d j r n m e c r b b n m n n j t e| m j n m n l b x
bNlNj|bq
5 Ellne` lbe`q eo hbqb wrcrefq aen ob nl n E Wrfbr n hb Rqb E``enab Te`b Arbebl nlbr hb Aj? Aew&enl&|relb Wrcref
? hw;**.ero.ae.ct*aa*ntbnr*lee*eo`bq*rblanqZrfZqawncZw`enZfbeqrbqZ?757&57&?8.wl
1 hw;**.ero.ae.ct*aa*ntbnr*lee*eo`bq*rblanqZrfZqawncZw`enZfbeqrbqZ?757&57&?8.wl
< Dne` Qww`bfbn hb EO 1? Qawnc W`en Dnane` Bute`bn Lafbn (w. 4-
hw;**.ero.ae.ct*aa*qawncw`en*lafbn*ne`Zqww`bfbnZZqwZbl.wl
2 Nb he hb banfa ene`qq ll n ̀ i e qfb hb wnq lqaqqbl o hb Banfa enl E``aen Eltqr Affbb (BEEA-
na`lnc qnc ean rbtbnbq etl rb ex narbeqbq r rbqrnc qwbnlnc n qeb wrcrefq ̀ ib blaen.
4 AE_O Dne` _bc`en jrlbr Ae`rne Aew n Crbbnhqb Ceq Bfqqnq enl Ferib&Oeqbl Afw`enab Fbahenqfq (£=2837(l- w.=3-
ete`eo`b e hw;**.ero.ae.ct*aa*aewenlrelb*ne`rbcrlbr.wl.
3 Ae`rne Anqn Era`b < Qban 5?9 hw; **.`bcn.ae.ct*.anq*.era`bZ<.
8 Qna`er Wen A. t. Qeb Ol. Bue`{en 52 Ae` <h 844 (5==3-.
= mn Ae`rne b`bara rebq erb brbl qnc e oeqb`nb uen b`bara anqfbl. |hb oeqb`nb q ae`a`ebl qnc a`feb qbeqn enl hb
b`bara qecb hn e ctbn ‐a`feb {nb.‖ E hqbh`l anqfnc e r ob` hb oeqb`nb uen n e ctbn fnh q n |br 5. Hbtbr e
hqbh`l anqfbq tbr 577 wbrabn oeqb`nb hb e`` n hb wwbr brq. |hb aq b`bara anqfbl n beah ellne` br q hchbr
bnarecb anqbrten enl ibbw rebq ̀ r hqbh`lq h l n qb fah b`bara r h rburb ̀ &aq b`bara oeqbl n fblae`
nbblq r wtbr hrbqh`lq.
57 Er _bqrabq Oerl ‐Rwlebl Banfa Ene`qq Ae`rne”q A`feb Ahencb Qawnc W`en‖ Ferah ?757.
55 Er _bqrabq Oerl ‐Rwlebl Banfa Ene`qq Ae`rne”q A`feb Ahencb Qawnc W`en‖ Ferah ?757.
5? Frb``&Drqah Qell Qaccnq Fnlnc hb A`feb Cew.
51 @Ej |hb ?75?&51 Olcb; Aew enl |relb Ean _btbnbq Dborer 54 ?75?.
5< EO 1? ̀ encecb
52 Wo`a hbe`h enl bntrnfbne` obnbq lre qawnc w`en fbeqrbq
54 A`feb Ahencb Lre Qawnc W`en; Wo`a Hbe`h Ene`qq Qww`bfbn.hw;**.ero.ae.ct*aa*qawncw`en*lafbn*bxbatbZqfferZwo`ahbe`h.wl
53 Efbraen @nc Eqqaen |hb _el A`ben Er Fe ?755.
hw;**.`nc.rc*eqqaenq*qebq*ae`rne*eqqbq*wlq*eltaea*a`ben&aerq&aefwecn*hb&rel&&a`ben&er.wl
58 |hb a`ben er ea ”q banfa obnbq weq wrbqbn enl rb. Qfe`` Oqnbqq Fekr hb Fen Qrbb E``enab. jaobr ?757.
7/31/2019 Get Ready for Cap and Trade, California
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/get-ready-for-cap-and-trade-california 20/20
rqmNc |hb e``jseNab te`rb djfae`mdjNme”q aeojN |elmNc q}q|bf;`bce` mqI dea|jq, mfwea|q |je|bwe}bq eNl |hb bajNjf}
fe} ?75?© ajw}mch| ?75? Nbx| 57
wmN|bl jN 577" ba}a`bl wewb,rqmNc tbcb|eo`b&oeqbl mNIq