gb? < ikboh:g:eba - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/pdf/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h...

379
6,*081’)5(8’ AB=FMG>NJ?C> <<?>?GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA Q:KLVI?J<:Y E_dpbb Ba^Zgb_ih^]hlh\be 0=YJHR?<KDBC FHKD<: 'G:MD:K?JBY'DE:KKBDB G:MDBHkgh\ZgZ ZdZ^_fbdhf K B <Z\beh\uf IH>K?JBY 'I:FYLGBDBBKLHJBBG:MDBJ?>:DPBHGG:YDHEE?=BY : : ;Z_\ ij_^k_^Zl_ev B ? >ayehrbgkdbc : XBrebgkdbc K I DZibpZ B E Dgmgygp : G Dhefh]hjh\ K J Fbdmebgkdbc > < Hagh[brbgmq_guc k_dj_lZjv E K Iheyd Y : Kfhjh^bgkdbc :KKibjbg BL Njheh\aZf_klbl_ev ij_^k_^Zl_ey : G RZfbg:E Ygrbg I_j_\h^k g_f_pdh]h=<;Zjurgbdh\hc Ebl_jZlmjgZyj_^Zdpby??Khdheh\hcbL<Jh^bhgh\hc Hl\_lkl\_ggu_j_^ZdlhjuBLNjheh\F=Yjhr_\kdbc HRB;HQGU?>?CKL<BY >- Nj_c^ N <\_^_gb_ \ ikbohZgZeba E_dpbb :\lhju hq_jdZ h Nj_c^_ N < ;Zkkbg bF = Yjhr_\kdbcFGZmdZVkK_jby'DeZkkbdbgZmdb“,6%1 BaeZ]Zxlky hkgh\gu_ iheh‘_gby b ijbgpbiu ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc l_hjbb ebqghklb ij_^eh‘_gghc b jZajZ[hlZgghc \k_fbjgh ba\_klguf ikbobZljhf b ikboheh]hf Ab]fmg^hf Nj_c^hf >eyikboheh]h\nbehkhnh\khpbheh]h\f_^bdh\

Upload: others

Post on 18-Sep-2019

25 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

6,*081'�)5(8'AB=FMG>�NJ?C><<?>?GB? < IKBOH:G:EBAQ:KLV�I?J<:YE_dpbbBa^Zgb_�ih^]hlh\be0��=��YJHR?<KDBCFHKD<: ©G:MD:ª�����K?JBY� ©DE:KKBDB� G:MDBª� Hkgh\ZgZ� ZdZ^_fbdhf� K�� B�� <Z\beh\uf� IH>K?JBY©I:FYLGBDB�BKLHJBB�G:MDBªJ?>:DPBHGG:Y�DHEE?=BY�:��: ;Z_\ �ij_^k_^Zl_ev���B�� ?��>ayehrbgkdbc��:��X�Brebgkdbc�� K��I�� DZibpZ��B��E�Dgmgygp��:��G��Dhefh]hjh\��K��J��Fbdmebgkdbc��>��<��Hagh[brbg� �mq_guc�k_dj_lZjv���E��K�Iheyd�� Y�� :�� Kfhjh^bgkdbc�� :�K�Kibjbg�� B L� Njheh\� �aZf_klbl_ev� ij_^k_^Zl_ey��� :�� G�RZfbg��:��E YgrbgI_j_\h^�k g_f_pdh]h�=�<�;Zjurgbdh\hcEbl_jZlmjgZy�j_^Zdpby�?��?��Khdheh\hc�b L��<��Jh^bhgh\hcHl\_lkl\_ggu_�j_^Zdlhju�B L��Njheh\��F��=��Yjhr_\kdbcHRB;HQGU?�>?CKL<BY������>����-��Nj_c^ ��N��� � �<\_^_gb_�\ ikbohZgZeba��E_dpbb ��:\lhju�hq_jdZ�h Nj_c^_�N��<��;Zkkbg�b F��=�Yjhr_\kdbc���F���GZmdZ�����������V k���K_jby©DeZkkbdb�gZmdbª��,6%1��������������BaeZ]Zxlky� hkgh\gu_� iheh`_gby� b ijbgpbiu� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_hjbb� ebqghklb�ij_^eh`_gghc� b jZajZ[hlZgghc� \k_fbjgh� ba\_klguf� ikbobZljhf� b ikboheh]hf� Ab]fmg^hfNj_c^hf�>ey�ikboheh]h\��nbehkhnh\��khpbheh]h\��f_^bdh\�

Page 2: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Ij_^bkeh\b_Ij_^eZ]Z_fh_�\gbfZgbx�qblZl_ey�©<\_^_gb_�\ ikbohZgZebaª�gb \�dh_c�f_j_�g_�ij_l_g^m_lgZ�khi_jgbq_kl\h�k m`_�bf_xsbfbky�khqbg_gbyfb�\ wlhc�h[eZklb�gZmdb �+LWVFKPDQQ�� )UHXGV1HXURVHQOHKUH����$XI/��������3ILVWHU��'LH�SV\FKRDQDO\WLVFKH�0HWKRGH��������/HR�.DSODQ��*UXQG]XJHGHU�3V\FKRDQDO\VH��������5HJLV�HW�+HVQDUG��/D�SV\FKRDQDO\VH�GHV�QHYURVHV�HW�GHV�SV\FKRVHV��3DULV�������$GROI�)��0HLMHU��'H�%HKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�=HQXZ]LH�NHQ�GRRU�3V\FKR$QDO\VH��$PVWHUGDP��������Wlh�lhqgh_�baeh`_gb_�e_dpbc��dhlhju_�y qblZe�\ l_q_gb_�^\mo�abfgbo�k_f_kljh\���������]��b��������]��\jZqZf�b g_ki_pbZebklZf�h[h_]h�iheZ�<k_� k\h_h[jZab_� wlh]h� ljm^Z�� gZ� dhlhjh_� h[jZlbl� \gbfZgb_� qblZl_ev�� h[tykgy_lkymkeh\byfb�_]h�\hagbdgh\_gby��< e_dpbb�g_l�\hafh`ghklb�khojZgblv�[_kkljZklghklv�gZmqgh]hljZdlZlZ��;he__� lh]h��i_j_^�e_dlhjhf� klhbl� aZ^ZqZ�m^_j`Zlv� \gbfZgb_� kemrZl_e_c� \ l_q_gb_ihqlb�^\mo�qZkh\��G_h[oh^bfhklv�\ua\Zlv�g_f_^e_ggmx�j_Zdpbx�ijb\_eZ�d lhfm��qlh�h^bg�blhl� `_� ij_^f_l� h[km`^Zeky� g_h^ghdjZlgh�� gZijbf_j� \ i_j\uc� jZa� \ k\yab� k lhedh\Zgb_fkgh\b^_gbc�� Z aZl_f� \ k\yab� k ijh[e_fZfb� g_\jhah\�� <ke_^kl\b_� lZdhc� ih^Zqb� fZl_jbZeZg_dhlhju_� \Z`gu_� l_fu�� dZd�� gZijbf_j�� [_kkhagZl_evgh_�� g_evay� [ueh� bkq_jiu\Zxs_ij_^klZ\blv�\ dZdhf�lh�h^ghf�f_kl_��d gbf�ijboh^behkv�g_h^ghdjZlgh�\ha\jZsZlvky�b kgh\Z�bohklZ\eylv�� ihdZ� g_� ij_^klZ\eyeZkv� gh\Zy� \hafh`ghklv� qlh�lh� ijb[Z\blv� d m`_� bf_xsbfkyagZgbyf�h gbo�Lhl��dlh�agZdhf�k ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc�ebl_jZlmjhc��gZc^_l�\ wlhf� ©<\_^_gbbª�g_fgh]h_ba� lh]h�� qlh� [ueh� [u� _fm� g_ba\_klgh� ba� ^jm]bo�� [he__� ih^jh[guo� im[ebdZpbc�� H^gZdhihlj_[ghklv� ^Zlv� fZl_jbZe� \ p_ehklghf�� aZ\_jr_gghf� \b^_� \ugm^beZ� Z\lhjZ� ijb\e_qv� \hl^_evguo�jZa^_eZo� �h[�wlbheh]bb�kljZoZ��bkl_jbq_kdbo�nZglZabyo��jZg__�g_�bkihevah\Zggu_^Zggu_�<_gZ��\_kgZ������]���������������� Nj_c^I?J<:Y�E?DPBY<\_^_gb_M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��Fg_�g_ba\_klgh��gZkdhevdh�dZ`^uc�ba�\Zk�ba�ebl_jZlmju�bebihgZkeurd_� agZdhf� k ikbohZgZebahf��H^gZdh� kZfh�gZa\Zgb_�fhbo� e_dpbc ²�©We_f_glZjgh_\\_^_gb_�\ ikbohZgZebaª�²�ij_^iheZ]Z_l��qlh�\u�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_l_�h[�wlhf�b ]hlh\u�ihemqblvhl� f_gy� i_j\u_� k\_^_gby�� Kf_x� \k_� `_� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� \Zf� ba\_klgh� ke_^mxs__�ikbohZgZeba�y\ey_lky�h^gbf�ba�f_lh^h\�e_q_gby�g_j\gh[hevguo��b lml�y kjZam�fh]m�ijb\_klb\Zf�ijbf_j��ihdZau\Zxsbc��qlh�\ wlhc�h[eZklb�dh_�qlh�^_eZ_lky�ih�bghfm�beb�^Z`_�gZh[hjhl�q_f�ijbgylh�\ f_^bpbg_��H[uqgh��dh]^Z�[hevgh]h�gZqbgZxl�e_qblv�gh\uf�^ey�g_]h�f_lh^hf�_fm�klZjZxlky�\gmrblv��qlh�hiZkghklv�g_�lZd�\_ebdZ��b m\_jblv�_]h�\ mki_o_�e_q_gby��Y ^mfZx�wlh�kh\_jr_ggh�hijZ\^Zggh��lZd�dZd�l_f�kZfuf�fu�ih\urZ_f�rZgku�gZ�mki_o��Dh]^Z�`_�fugZqbgZ_f� e_qblv� g_\jhlbdZ�f_lh^hf� ikbohZgZebaZ��fu� ^_ckl\m_f� bgZq_��Fu� ]h\hjbf� _fm� hljm^ghklyo� e_q_gby�� _]h� ijh^he`bl_evghklb�� mkbebyo� b `_jl\Zo�� k\yaZgguo� k gbf�� Qlh� `_dZkZ_lky� mki_oZ�� lh� fu� ]h\hjbf�� qlh� g_� fh`_f� _]h� ]ZjZglbjh\Zlv�� ihkdhevdm� hg� aZ\bkbl� hl

Page 3: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ih\_^_gby� [hevgh]h�� _]h� ihgyleb\hklb�� k]h\hjqb\hklb� b \u^_j`db�� ?kl_kl\_ggh�� m gZk� _klv\_kdb_� hkgh\Zgby� ^ey� lZdh]h� DZd� [m^lh� [u� g_ijZ\bevgh]h� ih^oh^Z� d [hevghfm�� \ q_f� \u�\b^bfh��iha^g__�kfh`_l_�m[_^blvky�kZfb�G_� k_j^bl_kv�� _keb� y gZ� i_j\uo� ihjZo� [m^m� h[jZsZlvky� k \Zfb� lZd� `_�� dZd� k wlbfbg_j\gh[hevgufb�� Kh[kl\_ggh� ]h\hjy�� y kh\_lmx� \Zf� hldZaZlvky� hl� fukeb� ijbclb� kx^Z� \h\lhjhc�jZa��>ey�wlh]h�kjZam�`_�ohqm�ihdZaZlv�\Zf��dZdb_�g_kh\_jr_gkl\Z�g_ba[_`gh�ijbkmsbh[mq_gbx� ikbohZgZebam� b dZdb_� ljm^ghklb� \hagbdZxl� \ ijhp_kk_� \ujZ[hldb� kh[kl\_ggh]hkm`^_gby�h g_f��Y ihdZ`m�\Zf��dZd�\ky�gZijZ\e_gghklv�\Zr_]h�ij_^u^ms_]h�h[jZah\Zgby�b \k_ijb\uqgh_�\Zr_�fure_gb_�[m^ml�g_ba[_`gh�^_eZlv�\Zk�ijhlb\gbdZfb�ikbohZgZebaZ�b kdhevdhgm`gh�[m^_l�\Zf�ij_h^he_lv��qlh[u�kh\eZ^Zlv�k wlbf�bgklbgdlb\guf�khijhlb\e_gb_f��Qlh�\uihcf_l_� \ ikbohZgZeba_� ba� fhbo� e_dpbc�� aZjZg__� kdZaZlv�� _kl_kl\_ggh�� ljm^gh�� h^gZdh� fh]ml\_j^h� h[_sZlv�� qlh�� ijhkemrZ\� bo�� \u� g_� gZmqbl_kv� ijh\h^blv� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh_bkke_^h\Zgb_� b e_q_gb_�� ?keb�`_� kj_^b� \Zk� gZc^_lky� dlh�lh�� dlh� g_� m^h\e_l\hjblky� [_]eufagZdhfkl\hf�k ikbohZgZebahf��Z aZohq_l�ijhqgh�k\yaZlv�k_[y�k gbf��y g_�lhevdh�g_�ihkh\_lmxwlh�k^_eZlv��gh�\kyq_kdb�klZgm�_]h�ij_^hkl_j_]Zlv�hl�wlh]h�rZ]Z��H[klhyl_evkl\Z�lZdh\u��qlhih^h[guc� \u[hj� ijhn_kkbb� bkdexqZ_l� ^ey� g_]h� \kydmx� \hafh`ghklv� ijh^\b`_gby� \mgb\_jkbl_l_�� ?keb� `_� lZdhc� \jZq� aZcf_lky� ijZdlbdhc�� lh� hdZ`_lky� \ h[s_kl\_�� g_ihgbfZxs_f� _]h� mklj_fe_gbc�� hlghkys_fky� d g_fm� k g_^h\_jb_f� b \jZ`^_[ghklvx� bhiheqb\r_f� ijhlb\� g_]h� \k_� kdjulu_� l_fgu_� kbeu�� <hafh`gh�� dh_�dZdb_� fhf_glu�khimlkl\mxsb_�\hcg_��k\bj_ikl\mxs_c�gug_�\ ?\jhi_��^Z^ml�\Zf�g_dhlhjh_�ij_^klZ\e_gb_�hlhf��qlh�kbe�wlbo�²�e_]bhgu�IjZ\^Z�� \k_]^Z� gZc^mlky� ex^b�� ^ey� dhlhjuo� gh\h_� \ ihagZgbb� bf__l� k\hxijb\e_dZl_evghklv��g_kfhljy�gZ�\k_�k\yaZggu_�k wlbf�g_m^h[kl\Z��>Z�_keb�dlh�lh�ba�\Zk�ba�boqbkeZ�b��g_kfhljy�gZ�fhb�ij_^hkl_j_`_gby��ijb^_l�kx^Z�kgh\Z��y [m^m�jZ^�ijb\_lkl\h\Zlv�_]h�H^gZdh�\u�\k_�\ijZ\_�agZlv��dZdb_�ljm^ghklb�k\yaZgu�k ikbohZgZebahf�<h�i_j\uo��ke_^m_l�mdZaZlv�gZ�keh`ghklv�ij_ih^Z\Zgby�ikbohZgZebaZ�b h[mq_gby�_fm��GZaZgylbyo�ih�f_^bpbg_�\u�ijb\udeb�d gZ]ey^ghklb��<u�\b^bl_�ZgZlhfbq_kdbc�ij_iZjZl��hkZ^hdijb� obfbq_kdhc� j_Zdpbb�� khdjZs_gb_� furpu� ijb� jZa^jZ`_gbb� g_j\h\�� Iha^g__� \ZfihdZau\Zxl�[hevgh]h��kbfilhfu�_]h�g_^m]Z��ihke_^kl\by�[he_ag_ggh]h�ijhp_kkZ��Z \h�fgh]bokemqZyo� b \ha[m^bl_e_c� [he_agb� \ qbklhf� \b^_�� BamqZy� objmj]bx�� \u� ijbkmlkl\m_l_� ijbobjmj]bq_kdbo� \f_rZl_evkl\Zo� ^ey� hdZaZgby� ihfhsb� [hevghfm� b fh`_l_� kZfb� ijh\_klbhi_jZpbx�� < lhc� `_� ikbobZljbb� hkfhlj� [hevgh]h� ^Z_l� \Zf� fgh`_kl\h� nZdlh\�k\b^_l_evkl\mxsbo�h[�baf_g_gbyo�\ fbfbd_��h oZjZdl_j_�j_qb�b ih\_^_gbb��dhlhju_�\_kvfZ\i_qZleyxl�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� ij_ih^Z\Zl_ev� \ f_^bpbg_� b]jZ_l� jhev� ]b^Z�wdkdmjkh\h^Z�khijh\h`^Zxs_]h�\Zk�ih�fma_x��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�\u�kZfb�\klmiZ_l_�\ g_ihkj_^kl\_gguc�dhglZdlk h[t_dlZfb�b [eZ]h^Zjy� kh[kl\_gghfm�\hkijbylbx�m[_`^Z_l_kv�\ kms_kl\h\Zgbb�gh\uo�^eygZk�y\e_gbc�< ikbohZgZeba_�� d kh`Ze_gbx�� \k_� h[klhbl� kh\k_f� ih�^jm]hfm�� Ijb� ZgZeblbq_kdhfe_q_gbb�g_� ijhbkoh^bl� gbq_]h�� djhf_� h[f_gZ� keh\Zfb�f_`^m� iZpb_glhf� b \jZqhf��IZpb_gl]h\hjbl�� jZkkdZau\Z_l� h ijhreuo� i_j_`b\Zgbyo� b gug_rgbo� \i_qZle_gbyo�� `Zem_lky�ijbagZ_lky�\ k\hbo�`_eZgbyo�b qm\kl\Zo��<jZq�`_�kemrZ_l��klZjZykv�mijZ\eylv�oh^hf�fuke_c

Page 4: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[hevgh]h��dh_�h q_f�gZihfbgZ_l�_fm��m^_j`b\Z_l�_]h�\gbfZgb_�\ hij_^_e_gghf�gZijZ\e_gbb�^Z_l�h[tykg_gby�b gZ[ex^Z_l�aZ�j_Zdpbyfb�ijbylby�beb�g_ijbylby��dhlhju_�hg�lZdbf�h[jZahf\uau\Z_l� m [hevgh]h�� G_h[jZah\Zggu_� jh^kl\_ggbdb� gZrbo� [hevguo�� dhlhjuf� bfihgbjm_lebrv� y\gh_� b hsmlbfh_�� Z [hevr_� \k_]h� ^_ckl\by�� dZdb_� fh`gh� m\b^_lv� jZa\_� qlh� \dbg_fZlh]jZn_��gbdh]^Z�g_�mimklyl�kemqZy�mkhfgblvky�©DZd� wlh� fh`gh� \ue_qblv� [he_agv� h^gbfb� jZa]h\hjZfb"ª�� Wlh�� dhg_qgh�� klhev� `_g_^Zevgh\b^gh�� kdhev�b g_ihke_^h\Zl_evgh��<_^v� l_�`_� kZfu_� ex^b� m[_`^_gu�� qlh� [hevgu_©lhevdh� \u^mfu\Zxlª� k\hb� kbfilhfu��Dh]^Z�lh� keh\Z�[ueb� dhe^h\kl\hf�� keh\h�b l_i_jv� \hfgh]hf� khojZgbeh� k\hx� ij_`gxx� qm^h^_ckl\_ggmx� kbem�� Keh\Zfb� h^bg� q_eh\_d� fh`_lhkqZkleb\blv�^jm]h]h�beb�ih\_j]gmlv� _]h� \ hlqZygb_�� keh\Zfb� mqbl_ev�i_j_^Z_l� k\hb� agZgbymq_gbdZf�� keh\Zfb� hjZlhj� m\e_dZ_l� kemrZl_e_c�b kihkh[kl\m_l� hij_^_e_gbx� bo� km`^_gbc�bj_r_gbc�� Keh\Z� \uau\Zxl� Znn_dlu� b y\eyxlky� h[s_ijbagZgguf� kj_^kl\hf� \ha^_ckl\byex^_c�^jm]�gZ�^jm]Z��G_�[m^_f�`_�g_^hhp_gb\Zlv�bkihevah\Zgb_�keh\Z�\ ikbohl_jZibb�b [m^_f^h\hevgu��_keb�kfh`_f�mkeurZlv�keh\Z��dhlhjufb�h[f_gb\Zxlky�ZgZeblbd�b _]h�iZpb_gl�Gh� ^Z`_� b wlh]h� gZf� g_� ^Zgh�� ;_k_^Z�� \ dhlhjhc� b aZdexqZ_lky� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh_e_q_gb_�� g_� ^himkdZ_l� ijbkmlkl\by� ihklhjhggbo�� __� g_evay� ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv�� Fh`gh�dhg_qgh�� gZ� e_dpbb� ih� ikbobZljbb ihdZaZlv� mqZsbfky� g_\jZkl_gbdZ� beb� bkl_jbdZ�� Lhl�ih`Zemc�� jZkkdZ`_l� h k\hbo� `Zeh[Zo� b kbfilhfZo�� gh� g_� [hevr_� lh]h�� K\_^_gby�� gm`gu_ikbohZgZeblbdm��hg�fh`_l�^Zlv�ebrv�ijb�mkeh\bb�hkh[h]h�jZkiheh`_gby�d \jZqm��h^gZdh�hglml�`_�aZfheqbl��dZd�lhevdh�aZf_lbl�ohlv�h^gh]h�k\b^_l_ey��bg^bnn_j_glgh]h�d g_fm��<_^v�wlbk\_^_gby�bf_xl�hlghr_gb_�d kZfhfm�bglbfghfm�\ _]h�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��dh�\k_fm�lhfm��qlh�hg�dZd�ebph�khpbZevgh�kZfhklhyl_evgh_��\ugm`^_g�kdju\Zlv�hl�^jm]bo��Z lZd`_�d lhfm��\ q_f�hgdZd�p_evgZy�ebqghklv�g_�ohq_l�ijbagZlvky�^Z`_�kZfhfm�k_[_�LZdbf� h[jZahf�� [_k_^m� \jZqZ�� e_qZs_]h� f_lh^hf� ikbohZgZebaZ�� g_evay� mkeurZlvg_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�� <u� fh`_l_� lhevdh� magZlv� h g_c� b ihagZdhfbl_kv� k ikbohZgZebahf� \[md\Zevghf� kfuke_� keh\Z� ebrv� ihgZkeurd_�� D kh[kl\_gghfm� \a]ey^m� gZ� ikbohZgZeba� \Zfijb^_lky�ijbclb� \ g_h[uqguo� mkeh\byo�� ihkdhevdm� k\_^_gby� h g_f� \u� ihemqZ_l_� dZd� [u� ba\lhjuo�jmd��<h�fgh]hf�wlh�aZ\bkbl�hl�lh]h�^h\_jby��k dhlhjuf�\u�hlghkbl_kv�d ihkj_^gbdm�Ij_^klZ\vl_�k_[_�l_i_jv��qlh�\u�ijbkmlkl\m_l_�gZ�e_dpbb�g_�ih�ikbobZljbb��Z ih�bklhjbb�b e_dlhj�jZkkdZau\Z_l�\Zf�h `bagb�b \h_gguo�ih^\b]Zo�:e_dkZg^jZ�FZd_^hgkdh]h��GZ�dZdhfhkgh\Zgbb�\u�\_jbl_�\ ^hklh\_jghklv�_]h�khh[s_gbc"�KgZqZeZ�dZ`_lky��qlh�a^_kv�_s_�keh`g__�q_f�\ ikbohZgZeba_��\_^v�ijhn_kkhj�bklhjbb�g_�[ue�mqZklgbdhf�ihoh^h\�:e_dkZg^jZ�lZd�`_�dZd�b \u��ikbohZgZeblbd��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��khh[sZ_l�\Zf�h lhf��\ q_f�hg�kZf�b]jZe�dZdmx�lhjhev��Gh�lml�gZklmiZ_l�q_j_^�lhfm��qlh�aZklZ\ey_l�gZk�ih\_jblv�bklhjbdm��Hg�fh`_l�khkeZlvkygZ�k\b^_l_evkl\Z�^j_\gbo�ibkZl_e_c��dhlhju_�beb�kZfb�[ueb�kh\j_f_ggbdZfb�:e_dkZg^jZ��bebih�\j_f_gb�`beb�[eb`_�d wlbf�kh[ulbyf��l��_��gZ�dgb]b�>bh^hjZ��IemlZjoZ��:jjbZgZ�b ^j���hgihdZ`_l� \Zf� bah[jZ`_gby� khojZgb\rboky� fhg_l� b klZlmc� pZjy�� nhlh]jZnbx� ihfi_ckdhcfhaZbdb�[bl\u�ijb�Bkk_��H^gZdh��kljh]h�]h\hjy��\k_�wlb�^hdmf_glu�^hdZau\Zxl�lhevdh�lh��qlhm`_�[he__�jZggb_�ihdhe_gby�\_jbeb�\ kms_kl\h\Zgb_�:e_dkZg^jZ�b \�j_Zevghklv�_]h�ih^\b]h\�b \hl�k wlh]h�b fh]eZ�[u�gZqZlvky�\ZrZ�djblbdZ��Lh]^Z�\u�h[gZjm`bl_��qlh�g_�\k_�k\_^_gby�h[:e_dkZg^j_� ^hklh\_jgu� g_� \k_� ih^jh[ghklb� fh`gh� ijh\_jblv�� gh� y g_� fh]m� ij_^iheh`blv�

Page 5: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

qlh[u� \u� ihdbgmeb� e_dpbhgguc� aZe�� khfg_\Zykv� \ j_Zevghklb� ebqghklb� :e_dkZg^jZFZd_^hgkdh]h��<ZrZ�ihabpby�hij_^_eblky�]eZ\guf�h[jZahf�^\mfy�khh[jZ`_gbyfb��\h�i_j\uo�\jy^�eb�m e_dlhjZ�_klv�dZdb_�lh�fukebfu_�fhlb\u��ih[m^b\rb_�\u^Z\Zlv�aZ�j_Zevgh_�lh��qlh�hgkZf� g_� kqblZ_l� lZdh\uf�� b�� \h�\lhjuo�� \k_� ^hklmigu_� bklhjbq_kdb_� dgb]b� jbkmxl� kh[ulbyijbf_jgh�h^bgZdh\h��?keb�\u�aZl_f�h[jZlbl_kv�d bamq_gbx�^j_\gbo�bklhqgbdh\��\u�h[jZlbl_\gbfZgb_� gZ� l_� `_� h[klhyl_evkl\Z�� gZ� \hafh`gu_� ih[m^bl_evgu_� fhlb\u� ihkj_^gbdh\� gZkoh^kl\h� jZaebqguo� k\b^_l_evkl\�� J_amevlZlu� \Zr_]h� bkke_^h\Zgby� gZ\_jgydZ� mkihdhyl� \ZkgZkq_l�:e_dkZg^jZ��h^gZdh�hgb��\_jhylgh��[m^ml�^jm]bfb��_keb�j_qv�aZc^_l�h lZdbo�ebqghklyo�dZd�Fhbk_c� beb� Gbfjh^ �� H lhf�� dZdb_� khfg_gby� fh]ml� \hagbdgmlv� m \Zk� hlghkbl_evgh^h\_jby�d e_dlhjm�ikbohZgZeblbdm��\u�magZ_l_�iha`_� �Gbfjh^�beb�G_f\jh^ ��ih [b[e_ckdhc�e_]_g^_��hkgh\Zl_ev�<Z\behgkdh]h�pZjkl\Z�²�Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�L_i_jv� \u� \ijZ\_� aZ^Zlv� \hijhk�� _keb� m ikbohZgZebaZ� g_l� gbdZdbo� h[t_dlb\guoih^l\_j`^_gbc� b g_l� \hafh`ghklb� _]h� ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv�� lh� dZd� `_� _]h� \hh[s_� fh`ghbamqblv� b m[_^blvky� \ ijZ\hl_� _]h� iheh`_gbc"�>_ckl\bl_evgh�� bamq_gb_� ikbohZgZebaZ� ^_ehg_e_]dh_�� b ebrv� g_fgh]b_� ih�gZklhys_fm� h\eZ^_\Zxl� bf�� h^gZdh� ijb_fe_fuc� imlv�_kl_kl\_ggh�� kms_kl\m_l�� IkbohZgZebahf� h\eZ^_\Zxl� ij_`^_� \k_]h� gZ� kZfhf� k_[_�� ijbbamq_gbb�k\h_c�ebqghklb��Wlh�g_�kh\k_f� lh��qlh�gZau\Z_lky�kZfhgZ[ex^_gb_f��gh�\ djZcg_fkemqZ_� ikbohZgZeba� fh`gh� jZkkfZljb\Zlv� dZd� h^bg� ba� _]h� \b^h\�� ?klv� p_euc� jy^jZkijhkljZg_gguo�b h[s_ba\_klguo�ikbobq_kdbo�y\e_gbc��dhlhju_�ijb�g_dhlhjhf�h\eZ^_gbbl_ogbdhc� bamq_gby� kZfh]h� k_[y� fh]ml� klZlv� ij_^f_lZfb� ZgZebaZ�� Wlh� ^Z_l� \hafh`ghklvm[_^blvky� \ j_Zevghklb� ijhp_kkh\�� hibku\Z_fuo� \ ikbohZgZeba_�� b \� ijZ\bevghklb� boihgbfZgby�� IjZ\^Z�� mki_rghklv� ijh^\b`_gby� ih� wlhfm� imlb� bf__l� k\hb� ij_^_eu�� =hjZa^h[hevr_]h�fh`gh�^hklbqv��_keb�l_[y�h[ke_^m_l�hiulguc�ikbohZgZeblbd��_keb�gZ�kh[kl\_gghf�Ybkiulu\Z_rv� ^_ckl\b_� ZgZebaZ� b fh`_rv� hl� ^jm]h]h� i_j_gylv� lhgqZcrmx� l_ogbdm� wlh]hf_lh^Z��Dhg_qgh��wlhl�ij_djZkguc�imlv�^hklmi_g�ebrv�dZ`^hfm�hl^_evgh��Z g_�\k_f�kjZam�>jm]h_�aZljm^g_gb_�\ ihgbfZgbb�ikbohZgZebaZ�e_`bl�g_�\ g_f��Z \�\Zk�kZfbo��ihkdhevdm\u� ^h� kbo�ihj� aZgbfZebkv�bamq_gb_f�f_^bpbgu��Klbev� \Zr_]h�fure_gby�� knhjfbjh\Zggucij_^r_kl\mxsbf� h[jZah\Zgb_f�� ^Ze_d� hl� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h��<u� ijb\udeb� h[hkgh\u\Zlvnmgdpbb� hj]ZgbafZ� b bo� gZjmr_gby� ZgZlhfbq_kdb�� h[tykgylv� bo� obfbq_kdb� b nbabq_kdb� bihgbfZlv� [bheh]bq_kdb�� gh� gbdh]^Z� \Zrb� bgl_j_ku� g_� h[jZsZebkv� d ikbobq_kdhc� `bagb�dhlhjZy� dZd� jZa� b y\ey_lky� \_gphf� gZr_]h� m^b\bl_evgh� keh`gh]h� hj]ZgbafZ�� : ihk_fmikboheh]bq_kdbc�ih^oh^�\Zf�qm`^��b \u�ijb\udeb�hlghkblvky�d g_fm�k g_^h\_jb_f��hldZau\Zy_fm� \ gZmqghklb� b hl^Z\Zy� _]h� gZ� hldmi� g_ijhn_kkbhgZeZf�� ibkZl_eyf�� gZlmjnbehkhnZf� bfbklbdZf�� LZdZy� h]jZgbq_gghklv�� [_amkeh\gh�� lhevdh� \j_^bl� \Zr_c� \jZq_[ghc� ^_yl_evghklb�lZd� dZd� [hevghc� ij_^klZ_l� i_j_^� \Zfb� ij_`^_� \k_]h� k\h_c� ^mr_\ghc� klhjhghc�� dZd� wlh� bijhbkoh^bl�\h�\k_o�q_eh\_q_kdbo�hlghr_gbyo��b y�[hxkv��qlh�\ gZdZaZgb_�aZ�lh�\Zf�ijb^_lkyih^_eblvky� l_jZi_\lbq_kdhc� ihfhsvx�� dhlhjmx� \u� klj_fbl_kv� hdZaZlv�� k kZfhmqdZfb�agZoZjyfb�b fbklbdZfb��klhev�ij_abjZ_fufb�\Zfb�Fg_� ykgh�� q_f� hijZ\^u\Z_lky� wlhl� g_^hklZlhd� \ \Zr_f� h[jZah\Zgbb�� <Zf� g_� o\ZlZ_lnbehkhnkdbo� agZgbc�� dhlhjufb� \u�fh]eb� [u�ihevah\Zlvky� \ \Zr_c� \jZq_[ghc�ijZdlbd_��Gbki_dmeylb\gZy�nbehkhnby��gb�hibkZl_evgZy�ikboheh]by��gb�lZd�gZau\Z_fZy�wdki_jbf_glZevgZy

Page 6: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ikboheh]by��kf_`gZy�k nbabheh]b_c�qm\kl\��dZd�hgb�ij_ih^ghkylky�\ mq_[guo�aZ\_^_gbyo��g_�\khklhygbb�kdZaZlv�\Zf�qlh�gb[m^v�\jZamfbl_evgh_�h[�hlghr_gbb�f_`^m�l_ehf�b ^mrhc��^Zlvdexq�d ihgbfZgbx�\hafh`gh]h�gZjmr_gby�ikbobq_kdbo�nmgdpbc ��IjZ\^Z��\ jZfdZo�f_^bpbguhibkZgb_f� gZ[ex^Z_fuo� ikbobq_kdbo� jZkkljhckl\� b khklZ\e_gb_f� debgbq_kdhc� dZjlbgu[he_ag_c�aZgbfZ_lky�ikbobZljby��gh�\_^v�\ qZku�hldjh\_gghklb ikbobZlju�kZfb�\ukdZau\Zxlkhfg_gby�\ lhf�� aZkem`b\Zxl�eb�bo�hibkZgby�gZa\Zgby�gZmdb��Kbfilhfu��khklZ\eyxsb_� wlbdZjlbgu�[he_ag_c��g_�jZkihagZgu�ih�k\h_fm�ijhbkoh`^_gbx��f_oZgbafm�b \aZbfghc�k\yab� bfkhhl\_lkl\mxl� eb[h� g_hij_^_e_ggu_� baf_g_gby� ZgZlhfbq_kdh]h� hj]ZgZ� ^mrb�� eb[h� lZdb_baf_g_gby�� dhlhju_� gbq_]h� g_� h[tykgyxl�� L_jZi_\lbq_kdhfm� \ha^_ckl\bx� wlb� ikbobq_kdb_jZkkljhckl\Z�^hklmigu�lhevdh�lh]^Z��dh]^Z�bo�fh`gh�h[gZjm`blv�ih�ih[hqguf�ijhy\e_gbyfdZdh]h�lh�bgh]h�hj]Zgbq_kdh]h�baf_g_gby�IkbohZgZeba� dZd� jZa� b klj_fblky� \hkihegblv� wlhl� ijh[_e�� Hg� ij_^eZ]Z_l� ikbobZljbbg_^hklZxsmx�_c�ikboheh]bq_kdmx�hkgh\m��gZ^_ykv�gZclb� lm�h[smx�[Zam��[eZ]h^Zjy�dhlhjhcklZgh\blky� ihgylguf� khq_lZgb_� khfZlbq_kdh]h� gZjmr_gby� k ikbobq_kdbf�� >ey� wlh]hikbohZgZeba� ^he`_g�ba[_]Zlv� ex[hc� qm`^hc� _fm�ihkuedb� ZgZlhfbq_kdh]h�� obfbq_kdh]h� bebnbabheh]bq_kdh]h� oZjZdl_jZ� b ihevah\Zlvky� qbklh� ikboheh]bq_kdbfb� \kihfh]Zl_evgufbihgylbyfb�²�\hl�ihq_fm�y hiZkZxkv��qlh�hg�ihdZ`_lky�\Zf�kgZqZeZ�klhev�g_h[uqguf�< ke_^mxs_f� aZljm^g_gbb� y g_� ohqm� h[\bgylv� gb \Zk�� gb \Zr_� h[jZah\Zgb_�� gb� \ZrmmklZgh\dm�� >\mfy� k\hbfb� iheh`_gbyfb� ZgZeba� hkdhj[ey_l� \_kv� fbj� b \uau\Z_l� d k_[_� _]hg_ijbyagv�� h^gh� ba� gbo� gZlZedb\Z_lky� gZ� bgl_ee_dlmZevgu_�� ^jm]h_� ²� gZ� fhjZevgh�wkl_lbq_kdb_�ij_^jZkkm^db�G_� ke_^m_l�� h^gZdh�� g_^hhp_gb\Zlv� wlb� ij_^jZkkm^db�� wlh� \eZklgu_� kbeu�� ih[hqgucijh^mdl� ihe_aguo� b ^Z`_� g_h[oh^bfuo� baf_g_gbc� \ oh^_� jZa\blby� q_eh\_q_kl\Z�� Hgbih^^_j`b\Zxlky�gZrbfb�Znn_dlb\gufb�kbeZfb��b [hjhlvky�k gbfb�ljm^gh�Kh]eZkgh�i_j\hfm� dhjh[ys_fm� ml\_j`^_gbx� ikbohZgZebaZ�� ikbobq_kdb_� ijhp_kku� kZfbih� k_[_� [_kkhagZl_evgu�� khagZl_evgu� ebrv� hl^_evgu_� Zdlu� b klhjhgu� ^mr_\ghc� `bagb�<kihfgbl_�� qlh� fu�� gZh[hjhl�� ijb\udeb� b^_glbnbpbjh\Zlv� ikbobq_kdh_� b khagZl_evgh_�Bf_ggh�khagZgb_�kqblZ_lky�m gZk�hkgh\ghc�oZjZdl_jghc�q_jlhc�ikbobq_kdh]h��Z ikboheh]by�²gZmdhc� h kh^_j`Zgbb� khagZgby�� >Z�� wlh� lh`^_kl\h� dZ`_lky� gZklhevdh� kZfh� kh[hcjZamf_xsbfky��qlh� \hajZ`_gb_�ijhlb\�g_]h�ij_^klZ\ey_lky�gZf� hq_\b^ghc�[_kkfukebp_c��b\k_�`_�ikbohZgZeba�g_�fh`_l�g_�\hajZ`Zlv��hg�g_�fh`_l�ijbagZlv�b^_glbqghklv�khagZl_evgh]hb ikbobq_kdh]h� ��� Kh]eZkgh� _]h� hij_^_e_gbx�� ikbobq_kdh_� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� ijhp_kkuqm\kl\h\Zgby�� fure_gby�� `_eZgby�� b wlh� hij_^_e_gb_� ^himkdZ_l� kms_kl\h\Zgb_[_kkhagZl_evgh]h� fure_gby� b [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� `_eZgby�� Gh� ^Zggh_� ml\_j`^_gb_� kjZam� `_jhgy_l� _]h� \ ]eZaZo� \k_o� ijb\_j`_gp_\� lj_a\hc� gZmqghklb� b aZklZ\ey_l� ih^haj_\Zlv�� qlhikbohZgZeba�²�nZglZklbq_kdh_�lZcgh_�mq_gb_��dhlhjh_�[jh^bl�\ ihl_fdZo��`_eZy�eh\blv�ju[m\ fmlghc� \h^_��<Zf�`_�� m\Z`Z_fu_� kemrZl_eb�� ihdZ� _s_� g_ihgylgh�� ih� dZdhfm� ijZ\m� klhevZ[kljZdlgh_� iheh`_gb_�� dZd� ©ikbobq_kdh_� _klv� khagZl_evgh_ª�� y kqblZx� ij_^jZkkm^dhf�� \u�fh`_l�[ulv��lZd`_�g_�^h]Z^u\Z_l_kv��qlh�fh]eh�ijb\_klb�d hljbpZgbx�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��_keblZdh\h_� kms_kl\m_l�� b dZdb_� ij_bfms_kl\Z� ^Z\Zeh� lZdh_� hljbpZgb_�� <hijhk� h lhf�lh`^_kl\_ggh� eb� ikbobq_kdh_� khagZl_evghfm� beb� `_� hgh� ]hjZa^h� rbj_�� fh`_l� ihdZaZlvky

Page 7: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

imklhc� b]jhc� keh\�� gh� kf_x� \Zk� aZ\_jblv�� qlh ijbagZgb_� kms_kl\h\Zgby� [_kkhagZl_evguoikbobq_kdbo�ijhp_kkh\�\_^_l�d kh\_jr_ggh�gh\hc�hjb_glZpbb�\ fbj_�b gZmd_�<u� ^Z`_� g_� ih^haj_\Z_l_�� dZdZy� l_kgZy� k\yav� kms_kl\m_l� f_`^m� wlbf� i_j\uf� kf_eufml\_j`^_gb_f�ikbohZgZebaZ�b \lhjuf�� h dhlhjhf� j_qv� ihc^_l� gb`_��Wlh� \lhjh_� iheh`_gb_�dhlhjh_�ikbohZgZeba�kqblZ_l�h^gbf�ba�k\hbo�^hklb`_gbc��ml\_j`^Z_l��qlh�\e_q_gby��dhlhju_fh`gh�gZa\Zlv�k_dkmZevgufb�\ madhf�b rbjhdhf�kfukeZo�keh\Z��b]jZxl�g_\_jhylgh�[hevrmx�b^h� kbo�ihj�g_ijbagZggmx� jhev� \ \hagbdgh\_gbb�g_j\guo�b ikbobq_kdbo� aZ[he_\Zgbc��;he__lh]h��wlb�`_�k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby�mqZkl\mxl�\ kha^Zgbb�\ukrbo�dmevlmjguo��om^h`_kl\_gguob khpbZevguo�p_gghkl_c�q_eh\_q_kdh]h�^moZ��b bo�\deZ^�g_evay�g_^hhp_gb\Zlv�Ih� kh[kl\_gghfm� hiulm� agZx�� qlh� g_ijbylb_� wlh]h� j_amevlZlZ� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]hbkke_^h\Zgby� y\ey_lky� ]eZ\guf� bklhqgbdhf� khijhlb\e_gby�� k dhlhjuf� hgh� klZedb\Z_lky�Ohlbl_� agZlv�� dZd� fu� wlh� k_[_� h[tykgy_f"� Fu� kqblZ_f�� qlh� dmevlmjZ� [ueZ� kha^ZgZ� ih^\ebygb_f�`bag_gghc�g_h[oh^bfhklb�aZ�kq_l�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�\e_q_gbc��b hgZ�ih�[hevr_c�qZklbihklhyggh� \hkkha^Z_lky� [eZ]h^Zjy� lhfm�� qlh� hl^_evgZy� ebqghklv�� \klmiZy� \ q_eh\_q_kdh_h[s_kl\h�� kgh\Z�`_jl\m_l� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f� k\hbo� \e_q_gbc� \ ihevam� h[s_kl\Z�� Kj_^b� wlbo\e_q_gbc� agZqbl_evgmx� jhev� b]jZxl� k_dkmZevgu_�� ijb� wlhf� hgb� km[ebfbjmxlky�� l�� _�hldehgyxlky�hl�k\hbo�k_dkmZevguo�p_e_c�b gZijZ\eyxlky�gZ�p_eb��khpbZevgh�[he__�\ukhdb_�m`_� g_� k_dkmZevgu_�� WlZ� dhgkljmdpby�� h^gZdh�� \_kvfZ� g_mklhcqb\Z�� k_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gbyih^Z\eyxlky� k ljm^hf�� b dZ`^hfm�� dhfm� ij_^klhbl� \dexqblvky� \ kha^Zgbb� dmevlmjguop_gghkl_c��]jhabl�hiZkghklv��qlh�_]h�k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby�g_�^himklyl�lZdh]h�bo�ijbf_g_gby�H[s_kl\h� g_� agZ_l� [he__� kljZrghc� m]jhau� ^ey� k\h_c� dmevlmju�� q_f� \uk\h[h`^_gb_k_dkmZevguo� \e_q_gbc� b bo� \ha\jZl� d bagZqZevguf� p_eyf�� BlZd�� h[s_kl\h� g_� ex[blgZihfbgZgbc�h[�wlhf�keZ[hf�f_kl_�\ _]h�hkgh\Zgbb��hgh�g_�aZbgl_j_kh\Zgh�\ ijbagZgbb�kbeuk_dkmZevguo�\e_q_gbc�b \�\uykg_gbb�agZq_gby�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�^ey�dZ`^h]h��[hevr_�lh]h�ba� \hkiblZl_evguo� khh[jZ`_gbc� hgh� klZjZ_lky� hl\e_qv� \gbfZgb_� hl� \k_c� wlhc� h[eZklb�Ihwlhfm� hgh� klhev�g_l_jibfh� d \ur_mihfygmlhfm� j_amevlZlm�bkke_^h\Zgbc�ikbohZgZebaZ�bhohlg__� \k_]h� klj_fblky� ij_^klZ\blv� _]h� hl\jZlbl_evguf� k wkl_lbq_kdhc� lhqdb� aj_gby� bg_ijbklhcguf� beb� ^Z`_� hiZkguf� k lhqdb� aj_gby� fhjZeb�� Gh� lZdbfb� \uiZ^Zfb� g_evayhijh\_j]gmlv�h[t_dlb\gu_�j_amevlZlu�gZmqghc�jZ[hlu��?keb�m`�\u^\b]Zlv�\hajZ`_gby��lh�hgb^he`gu�[ulv�h[hkgh\Zgu�bgl_ee_dlmZevgh��<_^v�q_eh\_dm�k\hckl\_ggh�kqblZlv�g_ijZ\bevguflh��qlh�_fm�g_�gjZ\blky��b lh]^Z�e_]dh�gZoh^ylky�Zj]mf_glu�^ey�\hajZ`_gbc��BlZd��h[s_kl\h\u^Z_l� g_`_eZl_evgh_� aZ� g_ijZ\bevgh_�� hkiZjb\Zy� bklbgghklv� ikbohZgZebaZ� eh]bq_kdbfb� bnZdlbq_kdbfb� Zj]mf_glZfb�� ih^kdZaZggufb�� h^gZdh�� Znn_dlZfb�� b ^_j`blky� aZ� wlb\hajZ`_gby�ij_^jZkkm^db��g_kfhljy�gZ�\k_�ihiuldb�bo�hijh\_j]gmlv�Kf_x�\Zk�aZ\_jblv��m\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��qlh��\u^\b]Zy�wlh�kihjgh_�iheh`_gb_��fu\hh[s_�g_�klj_fbebkv�d l_g^_gpbhaghklb��Fu�ohl_eb�ebrv�ihdZaZlv�nZdlbq_kdh_�iheh`_gb_\_s_c��dhlhjh_��gZ^__fky��fu�ihagZeb�\ ijhp_kk_�mihjghc�jZ[hlu��Fu�b l_i_jv�kqblZ_f�k_[y\ijZ\_�hldehgblv�\kydh_�\lhj`_gb_�ih^h[guo�ijZdlbq_kdbo� khh[jZ`_gbc�\ gZmqgmx� jZ[hlm�ohly�fu�_s_�g_�mki_eb�m[_^blvky�\ h[hkgh\Zgghklb�l_o�hiZk_gbc��dhlhju_�bf_xl�ke_^kl\b_fwlb�khh[jZ`_gby�LZdh\u� ebrv� g_dhlhju_� ba� l_o� aZljm^g_gbc�� k dhlhjufb� \Zf� ij_^klhbl� klhedgmlvky� \

Page 8: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijhp_kk_�aZgylbc�ikbohZgZebahf��>ey�gZqZeZ��ih`Zemc��[he__�q_f�^hklZlhqgh��?keb�\u�kmf__l_ij_h^he_lv�g_]Zlb\gh_�\i_qZle_gb_�hl�gbo��fu�ijh^he`bf�gZrb�[_k_^u�<LHJ:Y�E?DPBYHrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\byM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Fu� gZqg_f� g_� k ij_^iheh`_gbc�� Z k� bkke_^h\Zgby�� ?]hh[t_dlhf�[m^ml�\_kvfZ�ba\_klgu_��qZklh�\klj_qZxsb_ky�b fZeh�ijb\e_dZ\rb_�d k_[_�\gbfZgb_y\e_gby�� dhlhju_�� g_� bf_y� gbq_]h� h[s_]h� k [he_agvx�� gZ[ex^Zxlky� m ex[h]h� a^hjh\h]hq_eh\_dZ�� Wlh� lZd� gZau\Z_fu_� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by� �)HKOOHLVWXQJHQ�� q_eh\_dZ�� h]h\hjdb�9HUVSUHFKHQ��²�dh]^Z��`_eZy�qlh�eb[h�kdZaZlv��dlh�lh�\f_klh�h^gh]h�keh\Z�mihlj_[ey_l�^jm]h_�hibkdb�²�dh]^Z�lh�`_�kZfh_�ijhbkoh^bl�ijb�ibkvf_��qlh�fh`_l�[ulv� aZf_q_gh�beb�hklZlvkyg_aZf_q_gguf�� hqbldb� �9HUOHVHQ�� ²� dh]^Z� qblZxl� g_� lh�� qlh� gZi_qZlZgh� beb� gZibkZgh�hkeurdb� �9HUKRUHQ�� ²� dh]^Z� q_eh\_d� keurbl� g_� lh�� qlh� _fm� ]h\hjyl�� gZjmr_gby� kemoZ� ihhj]Zgbq_kdbf�ijbqbgZf�kx^Z��dhg_qgh��g_�hlghkylky��< hkgh\_�^jm]hc�]jmiiu�lZdbo�y\e_gbce_`bl� aZ[u\Zgb_� �9HUJHVVHQ��� gh� g_� ^ebl_evgh_�� Z \j_f_ggh_�� dh]^Z� q_eh\_d� g_� fh`_l\kihfgblv��gZijbf_j��bf_gb� �1DPH���dhlhjh_�hg�gZ\_jgydZ�agZ_l�b h[uqgh�aZl_f�\kihfbgZ_l�beb�aZ[u\Z_l�\uihegblv�gZf_j_gb_��9RUVDW]���h dhlhjhf�iha^g__�\kihfbgZ_l��Z aZ[u\Z_l�ebrvgZ�hij_^_e_gguc�fhf_gl��< lj_lv_c� ]jmii_�y\e_gbc� wlhl�\j_f_gghc�Zki_dl�hlkmlkl\m_l��dZd�gZijbf_j��ijb�aZijylu\Zgbb� �9HUOHJHQ���dh]^Z�dZdhc�eb[h�ij_^f_l�dm^Z�lh�m[bjZ_rv��lZd�qlhg_�fh`_rv�_]h�[hevr_�gZclb��beb�ijb�kh\_jr_ggh�ZgZeh]bqghf�aZl_jb\Zgbb��9HUOLHUHQ���A^_kvi_j_^� gZfb� aZ[u\Zgb_�� d dhlhjhfm� hlghkbrvky� bgZq_�� q_f� d aZ[u\Zgbx� ^jm]h]h� jh^Z�� hgh\uau\Z_l� m^b\e_gb_�beb�^hkZ^m�� \f_klh� lh]h� qlh[u�fu� kqblZeb� _]h� _kl_kl\_gguf��Kx^Z�`_hlghkylky� hij_^_e_ggu_� hrb[db�aZ[em`^_gby� �,UUWXPHU�� �� dhlhju_� lZd`_� bf_xl� \j_f_gghcZki_dl�� dh]^Z� gZ� dZdh_�lh� \j_fy� \_jbrv� q_fm�lh�� h q_f� ^h� b ihke_� agZ_rv�� qlh� wlh� g_khhl\_lkl\m_l� ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�� b p_euc� jy^� ih^h[guo� y\e_gbc�� bf_xsbo� jZaebqgu_gZa\Zgby�<gmlj_gg__�koh^kl\h�\k_o�wlbo�kemqZ_\�\ujZ`Z_lky�ijbklZ\dhc�©h�ª�beb�©aZ�ª��YHU���\ bogZa\Zgbyo��Ihqlb�\k_�hgb�\_kvfZ�g_kms_kl\_ggu��\ [hevrbgkl\_�k\h_f�kdhjhij_oh^ysb�b g_b]jZxl�\Z`ghc�jheb�\ `bagb

� Keh\h ©,UUWXPª� i_j_\h^blky� [md\Zevgh� dZd� ©hrb[dZª�� ©aZ[em`^_gb_ª�� < gZklhys_f� ba^Zgbb� hgh� \aZ\bkbfhklb�hl�dhgl_dklZ�i_j_\h^blky�eb[h�dZd�©hrb[dZª��eb[h�dZd�©hrb[dZ�aZ[em`^_gb_ª�²�Ijbf_q��j_^�i_j_\h^Z�q_eh\_dZ�� Lhevdh� baj_^dZ� dZdhc�gb[m^v� ba� gbo�� gZijbf_j� aZl_jb\Zgb_� ij_^f_lh\�ijbh[j_lZ_l� ba\_klgmx� ijZdlbq_kdmx� agZqbfhklv�� Bf_ggh� ihwlhfm� gZ� gbo� g_� h[jZsZxlhkh[h]h�\gbfZgby��\uau\Zxl�hgb�ebrv�keZ[u_�wfhpbb�b l�^�Bf_ggh� d wlbf� y\e_gbyf� y b� ohqm� ijb\e_qv� l_i_jv� \Zr_� \gbfZgb_��Gh� \u� g_^h\hevgh\hajZabl_� fg_�� ©< fbj_�� dZd� b \� ^mr_\ghc�`bagb�� [he__� qZklghc� _]h� h[eZklb�� _klv� klhevdh\_ebdbo�lZcg��\ h[eZklb�ikbobq_kdbo�jZkkljhckl\�lZd�fgh]h�m^b\bl_evgh]h��dhlhjh_�gm`^Z_lky\ h[tykg_gbb�b aZkem`b\Z_l�_]h��qlh��ijZ\h��`Zev�ljZlblv�\j_fy�gZ�lZdb_�f_ehqb��?keb�[u�\u

Page 9: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fh]eb� h[tykgblv� gZf�� dZdbf� h[jZahf� q_eh\_d� k ohjhrbf� aj_gb_f� b kemohf� kj_^b� [_eZ� ^gyfh`_l�m\b^_lv�b mkeurZlv�lh��q_]h�g_l��Z ^jm]hc�\^jm]�kqblZ_l��qlh�_]h�ij_ke_^mxl�bf_ggh�l_�dh]h� hg�^h� kbo�ihj�[hevr_� \k_o� ex[be��beb� kZfuf�hkljhmfguf�h[jZahf� aZsbsZ_l� obf_ju�dhlhju_� ex[hfm� j_[_gdm� ihdZ`mlky� [_kkfukebp_c�� fu� _s_� dZd�gb[m^v� ijbagZeb� [uikbohZgZeba��Gh�_keb�hg�ij_^eZ]Z_l�gZf�ebrv�jZa[bjZlvky�\ lhf��ihq_fm�hjZlhj�\f_klh�h^gh]hkeh\Z� ]h\hjbl�^jm]h_�beb�ihq_fm�^hfhohaycdZ� dm^Z�lh� aZijylZeZ� k\hb� dexqb�� ^Z�b \� ^jm]boih^h[guo�imklydZo��lh�fu�kmf__f�gZclb�emqr__�ijbf_g_gb_�k\h_fm�\j_f_gb�b bgl_j_kZfª��Y[u� \Zf� hl\_lbe�� ©L_ji_gb_�� m\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�ª�Y kqblZx�� qlh� \ZrZ� djblbdZ� [v_lfbfh�p_eb��>_ckl\bl_evgh��ikbohZgZeba�g_�fh`_l�iho\ZklZlvky�l_f��qlh�gbdh]^Z�g_�aZgbfZekyf_ehqZfb��GZijhlb\��fZl_jbZehf�^ey�_]h�gZ[ex^_gbc�dZd�jZa�b kem`Zl�l_�g_aZf_lgu_�y\e_gby�dhlhju_� \ ^jm]bo� gZmdZo� hl\_j]Zxlky� dZd� g_^hklhcgu_� \gbfZgby�� kqblZxlky�� lZd� kdZaZlv�hl[jhkZfb�fbjZ� y\e_gbc��Gh� g_� ih^f_gy_l_� eb� \u� \ \Zr_c� djblbd_� agZqbfhklv� ijh[e_f� bo\g_rg_c�yjdhklvx"�JZa\_�g_l�\_kvfZ�kms_kl\_gguo�y\e_gbc��dhlhju_�fh]ml�ijb�hij_^_e_gguoh[klhyl_evkl\Zo�b \�hij_^_e_ggh_�\j_fy�\u^Zlv�k_[y�kZfufb�g_agZqbl_evgufb�ijbagZdZfb"�Yk e_]dhklvx�fh]m�ijb\_klb�fgh]h�ijbf_jh\�lZdbo�kblmZpbc��Ih�dZdbf�gbqlh`guf�ijbagZdZf\u��kb^ysb_�a^_kv�fheh^u_�ex^b��aZf_qZ_l_��qlh�aZ\h_\Zeb�[eZ]hkdehgghklv�^Zfu"�JZa\_�^eywlh]h�\u�`^_l_�h[tykg_gbc�\ ex[\b��iuedbo�h[tylbc��Z g_^hklZlhqgh�eb�\Zf�_^\Z� aZf_lgh]h\a]ey^Z�� [_]eh]h� ^\b`_gby�� qmlv� aZlygm\r_]hky� jmdhih`Zlby"� B _keb� \u�� [m^mqbdjbfbgZebklhf��mqZkl\m_l_�\ jZkke_^h\Zgbb�m[bckl\Z��jZa\_�jZkkqblu\Z_l_�\u�\ kZfhf�^_e_�qlh�m[bcpZ�hklZ\be�\Zf�gZ�f_kl_�ij_klmie_gby�k\hx�nhlh]jZnbx�k Z^j_khf��b g_�\ugm`^_gueb� \u� ^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky� [he__� keZ[ufb� b g_� klhev� y\gufb� ke_^Zfb� ijbkmlkl\by� ebqghklb�dhlhjmx�bs_l_"�LZd�qlh�g_�[m^_f�g_^hhp_gb\Zlv�g_agZqbl_evgu_�ijbagZdb��fh`_l�[ulv��hgbgZ\_^ml�gZk�gZ�ke_^�q_]h�gb[m^v�[he__�\Z`gh]h��: \ijhq_f��y��dZd�b \u��iheZ]Zx��qlh�\_ebdb_ijh[e_fu�fbjZ�b gZmdb�^he`gu�bgl_j_kh\Zlv�gZk�ij_`^_�\k_]h��Gh�h[uqgh�hq_gv�fZeh�ihevauhl�lh]h��qlh�dlh�lh�\h�\k_mkeurZgb_�aZy\be�h gZf_j_gbb�kjZam�`_�ijbklmiblv�d bkke_^h\Zgbxlhc�beb�bghc� \_ebdhc�ijh[e_fu��QZklh� \ lZdbo� kemqZyo�g_� agZxl�� k q_]h�gZqZlv��< gZmqghcjZ[hl_�i_jki_dlb\g__�h[jZlblvky�d bamq_gbx�lh]h��qlh�l_[y�hdjm`Z_l�b qlh�[he__�^hklmigh�^eybkke_^h\Zgby�� ?keb� wlh� ^_eZlv� ^hklZlhqgh� hkgh\Zl_evgh�� g_ij_^\aylh� b l_ji_eb\h�� lh�� _kebihkqZkleb\blky��^Z`_� lZdZy�\_kvfZ�g_ijblyaZl_evgZy�jZ[hlZ�fh`_l�hldjulv�imlv�d bamq_gbx\_ebdbo�ijh[e_f��ihkdhevdm��dZd�\k_�k\yaZgh�kh�\k_f��lZd�b fZeh_�kh_^bgy_lky�k \_ebdbf�<hl� lZd� [u� y jZkkm`^Ze�� qlh[u� ijh[m^blv� \Zr� bgl_j_k� d ZgZebam� dZ`msboky� lZdbfbgbqlh`gufb� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc� a^hjh\uo� ex^_c��: l_i_jv� ih]h\hjbf� k d_f�gb[m^v�� dlhkh\k_f�g_�agZdhf�k ikbohZgZebahf��b kijhkbf��dZd�hg�h[tykgy_l�ijhbkoh`^_gb_�wlbo�y\e_gbc�Ij_`^_� \k_]h� hg�� \b^bfh�� hl\_lbl�� ©H�� wlh� g_� aZkem`b\Z_l� dZdbo�eb[h� h[tykg_gbc�� wlhijhklh� fZe_gvdb_� kemqZcghklbª�� Qlh� `_� hg� ohq_l� wlbf� kdZaZlv"� <uoh^bl�� kms_kl\mxlgZklhevdh�gbqlh`gu_� kh[ulby�� \uiZ^Zxsb_�ba�p_ib�fbjh\uo� kh[ulbc�� dhlhju_� k lZdbf�`_mki_ohf� fh]ml� dZd� ijhbahclb�� lZd� b g_� ijhbahclb"� ?keb� dlh�lh� gZjmrbl�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�_kl_kl\_gguc�^_l_jfbgbaf�\ h^ghf�_^bgkl\_ighf�f_kl_��lh�jmog_l�\k_�gZmqgh_�fbjh\haaj_gb_�Lh]^Z�fh`gh�ihklZ\blv� _fm� \ mij_d��qlh� j_eb]bhagh_�fbjh\haaj_gb_� dm^Z�ihke_^h\Zl_evg__�dh]^Z�gZklhcqb\h�aZ\_jy_l��qlh�gb h^bg�\hehk�g_�miZ^_l�k ]heh\u�[_a�[h`v_c�\heb� >[md\���gbh^bg� \hjh[_c� g_� miZ^_l� k djurb� [_a� [h`v_c� \heb@�� >mfZx�� qlh� gZr� ^jm]� g_� [m^_l� ^_eZlv\u\h^u�ba�k\h_]h�i_j\h]h�hl\_lZ��hg�\g_k_l�ihijZ\dm�b kdZ`_l��qlh�_keb�wlb�y\e_gby�bamqZlv�

Page 10: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

lh�� _kl_kl\_ggh�� gZc^mlky� b ^ey� gbo� h[tykg_gby�� Hgb� fh]ml� [ulv� \ua\Zgu� g_[hevrbfbhldehg_gbyfb� nmgdpbc�� g_lhqghklyfb� \ ikbobq_kdhc� ^_yl_evghklb� ijb� hij_^_e_gguomkeh\byo��Q_eh\_d��dhlhjuc�h[uqgh�]h\hjbl�ijZ\bevgh��fh`_l�h]h\hjblvky���� _keb� _fm�g_a^hjh\blky�b hg� mklZe�� ��� _keb� hg� \a\hegh\Zg�� ��� _keb� hg� kebrdhf� aZgyl^jm]bfb� \_sZfb�� Wlb� ij_^iheh`_gby� e_]dh� ih^l\_j^blv�� >_ckl\bl_evgh�� h]h\hjdb\klj_qZxlky� hkh[_ggh� qZklh�� dh]^Z� q_eh\_d� mklZe�� _keb� m g_]h� [hebl� ]heh\Z� beb� gZqbgZ_lkyfb]j_gv��< wlbo�`_�mkeh\byo�e_]dh�ijhbkoh^bl�aZ[u\Zgb_�bf_g�kh[kl\_gguo��>ey�g_dhlhjuoebp� lZdh_� aZ[u\Zgb_� bf_g� kh[kl\_gguo� y\ey_lky� ijbagZdhf� ijb[eb`Zxs_cky� fb]j_gb�� <\heg_gbb�lZd`_�qZklh�imlZ_rv�keh\Z��aZo\Zlu\Z_rv ��ih�hrb[d_ª�g_�l_�ij_^f_lu��aZ[u\Z_rvh gZf_j_gbyo��^Z�b ijhba\h^brv�fZkkm�^jm]bo�g_ij_^\b^_gguo�^_ckl\bc�ih�jZkk_ygghklb��l��_�_keb�\gbfZgb_�kdhgp_gljbjh\Zgh�gZ�q_f�lh�^jm]hf��Ba\_klguf�ijbf_jhf�lZdhc�jZkk_ygghklbfh`_l�kem`blv�ijhn_kkhj�ba�)OLHJHQGH�%ORWWHU��dhlhjuc�aZ[u\Z_l�ahgl�b gZ^_\Z_l�qm`mx�reyim�ihlhfm�qlh�^mfZ_l�h ijh[e_fZo�k\h_c�[m^ms_c�dgb]b��Ih�kh[kl\_gghfm�hiulm�\k_�fu�agZ_f�hgZf_j_gbyo� b h[_sZgbyo�� aZ[uluo� ba�aZ� lh]h�� qlh� gZk� kebrdhf� aZo\Zlbeh� dZdh_�lh� ^jm]h_i_j_`b\Zgb_�Wlh�lZd�ihgylgh��qlh��ih�\b^bfhfm��g_�fh`_l�\ua\Zlv�\hajZ`_gbc��IjZ\^Z��fh`_l�[ulv��bg_�lZd�bgl_j_kgh��dZd�fu�h`b^Zeb��Ihkfhljbf�`_�gZ�wlb�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�ih\gbfZl_evg__�Mkeh\by�� dhlhju_�� �ih� ij_^iheh`_gbx�� g_h[oh^bfu� ^ey� \hagbdgh\_gby� wlbo� n_ghf_gh\�jZaebqgu��G_^hfh]Zgb_�b gZjmr_gb_�djh\hh[jZs_gby�y\eyxlky�nbabheh]bq_kdbfb�ijbqbgZfbgZjmr_gbc�ghjfZevghc�^_yl_evghklb��\heg_gb_��mklZehklv��jZkk_ygghklv�²�ijbqbgu�^jm]h]hoZjZdl_jZ�� dhlhju_� fh`gh� gZa\Zlv� ikbohnbabheh]bq_kdbfb�� L_hj_lbq_kdb� bo� e_]dh� fh`ghh[tykgblv�� Ijb� mklZehklb�� dZd� b ijb� jZkk_ygghklb� b ^Z`_� ijb� h[s_f� \heg_gbb� \gbfZgb_jZkij_^_ey_lky�lZdbf�h[jZahf��qlh�^ey�khhl\_lkl\mxs_]h�^_ckl\by�_]h�hklZ_lky�kebrdhf�fZeh�Lh]^Z� wlh�^_ckl\b_�\uihegy_lky�g_ijZ\bevgh�beb�g_lhqgh��E_]dh_�g_^hfh]Zgb_�b baf_g_gbyijblhdZ� djh\b� d ]heh\ghfm� fha]m� fh]ml� \ua\Zlv� lZdhc� `_� wnn_dl�� l�� _�� ih\ebylv� gZjZkij_^_e_gb_� \gbfZgby�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� \h� \k_o� kemqZyo� ^_eh� k\h^blky� d j_amevlZlZfjZkkljhckl\Z�\gbfZgby�hj]Zgbq_kdhc�beb�ikbobq_kdhc�wlbheh]bb�Ba� \k_]h� wlh]h�^ey�ikbohZgZebaZ�dZd�[m^lh�g_fgh]h�fh`gh�ba\e_qv��M gZk�fh`_l� hiylv\hagbdgmlv�bkdmr_gb_�hklZ\blv�wlm�l_fm��Gh�ijb�[eb`Zcr_f�jZkkfhlj_gbb�hdZau\Z_lky��qlhg_�\k_�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�fh`gh�h[tykgblv�^Zgghc�l_hjb_c�\gbfZgby�beb��\h�\kydhf�kemqZ_�hgb� h[tykgyxlky� g_� lhevdh� _x�� Hiul� ihdZau\Z_l�� qlh� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by� b aZ[u\Zgb_ijhy\eyxlky�b m�ebp��dhlhju_�g_�mklZeb��g_�jZkk_ygu�b g_�\a\hegh\Zgu��jZa\_�qlh�bf�ijbibrmlwlh�\heg_gb_�ihke_� k^_eZggh]h�hrb[hqgh]h�^_ckl\by��gh� kZfb�hgb� _]h�g_�bkiulu\Zeb��>Z�b\jy^� eb� fh`gh� k\_klb� \k_� d ijhklhfm� h[tykg_gbx�� qlh� mkbe_gb_� \gbfZgby� h[_ki_qb\Z_lijZ\bevghklv� ^_ckl\by�� hkeZ[e_gb_� `_� gZjmrZ_l� _]h� \uiheg_gb_�� Kms_kl\m_l� [hevrh_dhebq_kl\h� ^_ckl\bc�� qbklh� Z\lhfZlbq_kdbo� b lj_[mxsbo�fbgbfZevgh]h� \gbfZgby�� dhlhju_\uihegyxlky� ijb� wlhf� Z[khexlgh� m\_j_ggh�� GZ� ijh]med_� qZklh� g_� ^mfZ_rv�� dm^Z� b^_rv�h^gZdh�g_�k[b\Z_rvky�k imlb�b ijboh^brv��dm^Z�ohl_e��<h�\kydhf�kemqZ_��h[uqgh�[u\Z_l�lZd�Ohjhrbc� ibZgbkl� g_� ^mfZ_l� h lhf�� dZdb_� deZ\brb� _fm� gZ`bfZlv�� Hg�� dhg_qgh�� fh`_lhrb[blvky�� gh� _keb� [u� Z\lhfZlbq_kdZy� b]jZ� kihkh[kl\h\ZeZ� m\_ebq_gbx� qbkeZ� hrb[hd�� lhbf_ggh� \bjlmhau�� b]jZ� dhlhjuo� kh\_jr_ggh� Z\lhfZlbabjh\ZgZ� [eZ]h^Zjy� mijZ`g_gbyf�

Page 11: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hrb[Zebkv�[u�qZs_�\k_o��Fu�\b^bf�dZd�jZa�h[jZlgh_��fgh]b_�^_ckl\by�kh\_jrZxlky�hkh[_gghm\_j_ggh��_keb�gZ�gbo�g_�h[jZsZlv�\gbfZgby��Z hrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\b_�\hagbdZ_l�bf_ggh�lh]^Z�dh]^Z�ijZ\bevghklb�_]h�\uiheg_gby�ijb^Z_lky�hkh[h_�agZq_gb_�b hl\e_q_gb_�\gbfZgby�gbdZdg_� ij_^iheZ]Z_lky��Fh`gh� hlg_klb� wlh� gZ� kq_l� ©\heg_gbyª�� gh� g_ihgylgh�� ihq_fm� hgh� g_mkbeb\Z_l�\gbfZgby�d lhfm��qlh�lZd�ohq_lky�\uihegblv��Dh]^Z�\ \Z`ghc�j_qb�beb�\ jZa]h\hj_ba�aZ� h]h\hjdb� \ukdZau\Z_rv� ijhlb\hiheh`gh_� lhfm�� qlh� ohl_e� kdZaZlv�� \jy^� eb� wlh�fh`ghh[tykgblv�ikbohnbabheh]bq_kdhc�l_hjb_c�beb�l_hjb_c�\gbfZgby�< hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\byo�_klv�lZd`_�fgh]h�g_agZqbl_evguo�ih[hqguo�y\e_gbc��dhlhju_�g_ihgylu� b g_� h[tykg_gu� ^h� kbo� ihj� kms_kl\mxsbfb� l_hjbyfb�� GZijbf_j�� dh]^Z� gZ� \j_fyaZ[m^_lky�keh\h��lh�qm\kl\m_rv�^hkZ^m��ohq_rv�\h�qlh�[u�lh�gb�klZeh�\kihfgblv�_]h�b gbdZd�g_fh`_rv� hl^_eZlvky� hl� wlh]h� `_eZgby�� Ihq_fm� `_� jZkk_j^b\r_fmky� g_� m^Z_lky�� dZd� hg� gbklZjZ_lky��gZijZ\blv�\gbfZgb_�gZ�keh\h��dhlhjh_��dZd�hg�ml\_j`^Z_l��©\_jlblky�gZ�yaud_ª��ghwlh� keh\h� lml�`_� \kihfbgZ_lky�� _keb� _]h� kdZ`_l� dlh�lh� ^jm]hc"�Beb� [u\Zxl� kemqZb�� dh]^Zhrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�fgh`Zlky��i_j_ie_lZxlky�^jm]�k ^jm]hf��aZf_gyxl�^jm]�^jm]Z��< i_j\ucjZa�aZ[u\Z_rv�h k\b^Zgbb��^jm]hc�jZa�k l\_j^uf�gZf_j_gb_f�g_�aZ[ulv�h g_f�hdZau\Z_lky��qlhi_j_imlZe� qZk�� Ohq_rv� hdhevguf� iml_f� \kihfgblv� aZ[ulh_� keh\h�� \ j_amevlZl_� aZ[u\Z_rv\lhjh_�� dhlhjh_� ^he`gh� [ueh� ihfhqv� \kihfgblv� i_j\h_�� KlZjZ_rvky� ijbihfgblv� l_i_jv\lhjh_�� mkdhevaZ_l� lj_lv_� b l�� ^�� Lh�`_� kZfh_� ijhbkoh^bl� b k� hi_qZldZfb�� dhlhju_� ke_^m_lihgbfZlv�dZd�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�gZ[hjsbdZ��=h\hjyl��lZdZy�mklhcqb\Zy�hi_qZldZ�ijh[jZeZkvdZd�lh� \ h^gm� khpbZe�^_fhdjZlbq_kdmx� ]Za_lm��< khh[s_gbb� h[� h^ghf� ba\_klghf� lhj`_kl\_fh`gh� [ueh� ijhq_klv�� ©Kj_^b� ijbkmlkl\mxsbo� [ue� _]h� \_ebq_kl\h� dhjgijbgpª�� GZke_^mxsbc� ^_gv� ihy\behkv� hijh\_j`_gb_�� ©Dhg_qgh�� ke_^m_l� qblZlv� dghjijbgpª�� < lZdbokemqZyo�ex[yl�]h\hjblv�h g_qbklhc�kbe_��aehf�^mo_�gZ[hjgh]h�ysbdZ�b lhfm�ih^h[guo�\_sZo�\uoh^ysbo�aZ�jZfdb�ikbohnbabheh]bq_kdhc�l_hjbb�hi_qZldb�Y g_� agZx�� ba\_klgh� eb� \Zf�� qlh� h]h\hjdm� fh`gh� kijh\hpbjh\Zlv�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� \ua\Zlv\gmr_gb_f��Ih�wlhfm�ih\h^m�jZkkdZau\Zxl�Zg_d^hl�dZd�lh� gh\bqdm� ihjmqbeb� \Z`gmx� jhev� gZ� kp_g_�� \ Hje_Zgkdhc� ^_\_� hg� ^he`_g� [ue^heh`blv� dhjhex�� qlh� dhgg_lZ[ev� hlkueZ_l� k\hc� f_q �GHU� &RQQHWDEOH� VFKLFNW� VHLQ� 6FKZHUW]XULLFN��� B]jZ\rbc� ]eZ\gmx� jhev� ih^rmlbe� gZ^� jh[dbf� gh\bqdhf� b \h� \j_fy� j_i_lbpbbg_kdhevdh� jZa� ih^kdZaZe� _fm� \f_klh� gm`guo� keh\�� dhfnhjlZ[ev� hlkueZ_l� k\hx� ehrZ^v� �GHU.RP��RUWDEHO� VFKLFNW� VHLQ� 3IHUG� ]XULLFN�� b ^h[beky� k\h_]h�� GZ� ij_^klZ\e_gbb� g_kqZklguc^_[xlZgl�h]h\hjbeky��ohly� _]h�ij_^mij_`^Zeb� h[� wlhf�� Z fh`_l�[ulv��bf_ggh�ihlhfm� lZd�bkemqbehkv�<k_� wlb� fZe_gvdb_� hkh[_gghklb� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc� g_evay� h[tykgblv� lhevdh� l_hjb_chl\e_q_gby�\gbfZgby��Gh�wlh�_s_�g_�agZqbl��qlh�wlZ�l_hjby�g_ijZ\bevgZ��?c��ih`Zemc��q_]h�lhg_� o\ZlZ_l�� dZdh]h�lh� ^hihegbl_evgh]h� ml\_j`^_gby� ^ey� lh]h�� qlh[u� hgZ� iheghklvx� gZkm^h\e_l\hjyeZ�� Gh� g_dhlhju_� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by� fh`gh� jZkkfhlj_lv� lZd`_� b k� ^jm]hcklhjhgu�GZqg_f�k h]h\hjdb��hgZ�[hevr_�\k_]h�ih^oh^bl�gZf�ba�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��Ohly�k lZdbf`_�mki_ohf�fu�fh]eb�[u�\u[jZlv�hibkdm�beb�hqbldm��KjZam�`_�ke_^m_l�kdZaZlv��qlh�^h�kbo�ihjfu�kijZrb\Zeb�lhevdh�h lhf��dh]^Z��ijb�dZdbo�mkeh\byo�ijhbkoh^bl�h]h\hjdZ��b lhevdh�gZ�wlhl

Page 12: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\hijhk�fu�b ihemqZeb�hl\_l��Gh�fh`gh�lZd`_�aZbgl_j_kh\Zlvky�^jm]bf�b ihiulZlvky�magZlv�ihq_fm� q_eh\_d� h]h\hjbeky� bf_ggh� lZd�� Z g_� bgZq_�� ke_^m_l� h[jZlblv� \gbfZgb_� gZ� lh�� qlhijhbkoh^bl�ijb�h]h\hjd_��<u�ihgbfZ_l_��qlh��ihdZ�fu�g_�hl\_lbf�gZ�wlhl�\hijhk��ihdZ�fu�g_h[tykgbf� j_amevlZl� h]h\hjdb� k ikboheh]bq_kdhc� lhqdb� aj_gby�� wlh� y\e_gb_� hklZg_lkykemqZcghklvx��ohly�nbabheh]bq_kdh_�h[tykg_gb_�_fm�b fh`gh�[m^_l�gZclb��?keb�fg_�kemqblkyh]h\hjblvky��y fh]m�wlh�k^_eZlv�\ [_kdhg_qgh�fgh]bo�\ZjbZglZo��\f_klh�gm`gh]h�keh\Z�fh`ghkdZaZlv� lukyqm� ^jm]bo�� gm`gh_� keh\h� fh`_l� ihemqblv� [_kqbke_ggh_� fgh`_kl\h� bkdZ`_gbc�Kms_kl\m_l�eb�qlh�lh��qlh�aZklZ\ey_l�f_gy�ba�\k_o�\hafh`guo�h]h\hjhd�k^_eZlv�bf_ggh�lZdmx�beb� wlh� kemqZcghklv�� ijhba\he� b lh]^Z��fh`_l� [ulv�� gZ� wlhl� \hijhk� g_evay� hl\_lblv� gbq_]hjZamfgh]h">\Z�Z\lhjZ��F_jbg]_j�b FZc_j��h^bg²nbeheh]��^jm]hc²ikbobZlj���ihiulZebkv�\ �����]�bf_ggh�k wlhc�klhjhgu�ih^hclb�d \hijhkm�h[�h]h\hjdZo��Hgb�kh[jZeb�fgh]h�ijbf_jh\�b ijhklhhibkZeb� bo��Wlh�� dhg_qgh�� _s_� g_� ^Z_l� gbdZdh]h� h[tykg_gby� h]h\hjdZf�� gh� iha\hey_l� gZclbimlv� d g_fm�� :\lhju� jZaebqZxl� ke_^mxsb_� bkdZ`_gby�� \hagbdZxsb_� ba�aZ� h]h\hjhd�i_j_f_s_gby� �9HUWDXVFKXQJHQ���ij_^\hkobs_gby� �9RUNODQJH���hla\mdb� �1DFKNODQJH���kf_r_gby�beb� dhglZfbgZpbb� �9HUPHQJXQJHQ�� RGHU� .RQWDPLQDWLRQHQ��� b aZf_s_gby�� beb� km[klblmpbb�(UVHW]XQJHQ�� RGHU� 6XEVWLWXWLRQHQ���Y ijb\_^m� \Zf� ijbf_ju�� ij_^eh`_ggu_� Z\lhjZfb� ^ey� wlbohkgh\guo� ]jmii�� KemqZc� i_j_f_s_gby�� 'LH� 0LOR� YRQ� 9HQXV� \f_klh� GLH� 9HQXV� YRQ� 0LOR>i_j_f_s_gb_� \ ihke_^h\Zl_evghklb� keh\� ²�Fbeh_� ba� <_g_ju� \f_klh� <_g_ju� ba�FbehkZ@�ij_^\hkobs_gb_��(V�ZDU�PLU�DXI�GHU�6FKZHVW����DXI�GHU�%UXVW�VR�VFKZHU�>Fg_�[ueh�gZ�^mr_��^h_e��\ ]jm^b�� lZd� ly`_eh�� gh� \gZqZe_� \f_klh� keh\Z� ©%UXVWª� ²� ]jm^v� ²� [ueZ� k^_eZgZ� h]h\hjdZ©6FKZHVWª�� \ dhlhjhc� hljZabehkv� ij_^\hkobsZ_fh_� keh\h� ©VFKZHUª� ²� ly`_eh@�� Ijbf_jhfhla\mdZ�fh`_l�kem`blv�g_m^Zqguc�lhkl�,FK�IRUGHUH�6LH�DXI��DXI�GDV�:RKO�XQVHUHV�&KHIV�DXI]XVWR%HQ�>Ij_^eZ]Zx�<Zf�\uiblv� �^h_e��qhdgmlvky��aZ�a^hjh\v_�gZr_]h�r_nZ��gh�\f_klh�Zi�VWRILHQ�²�qhdgmlvky�²�kdZaZgh��DXIVWR%HQ�²hlju]gmlv@��Wlb�ljb�\b^Z�h]h\hjhd�^h\hevgh�j_^db��QZs_�\klj_qZxlky�h]h\hjdb�ba�aZ�kly`_gbybeb�kf_r_gby��gZijbf_j��dh]^Z�fheh^hc�q_eh\_d�aZ]h\Zjb\Z_l�k ^Zfhc�:HQQ� 6LH� JHVWDWWHQ� QLHLQ� )UDXOHLQ�� PRFKWH� LFK� 6LH� JHUQH� EHJOHLW�GLJHQ� >?keb�<u� jZaj_rbl_�[Zjurgy�� y <Zk� ijh\h`m�� gh� \ keh\h� ©EHJOHLWHQª� ²� ijh\h^blv²\klZ\e_gu� _s_� ljb� [md\u©GLJª@��< keh\_� EHJOHLW�GLJHQ�djh_lky��djhf_� keh\Z� EHJOHLWHQ� >ijh\h^blv@��hq_\b^gh�� _s_� keh\hEHOHLGLJHQ� >hkdhj[blv@�� �Fheh^hc� q_eh\_d�� \b^bfh�� g_� bf_e� [hevrh]h� mki_oZ� m ^Zfu��� GZaZf_s_gb_�Z\lhju�ijb\h^yl�ijbf_j�� ,FK�JHEH�GLH�3UDSDUDWH� LQ�GHQ�>]]_�NDVWHQ�DQVWDWW� NDVWHQ� >YklZ\ex�ij_iZjZlu�\ ihqlh\uc�ysbd�\f_klh�l_jfhklZlZ@�H[tykg_gb_�� dhlhjh_� h[Z� Z\lhjZ� iulZxlky� \u\_klb� ba� k\h_]h� kh[jZgby� ijbf_jh\�kh\_jr_ggh� g_^hklZlhqgh�� Hgb� kqblZxl�� qlh� a\mdb� b keh]b� \ keh\_� bf_xl� jZaebqgmxagZqbfhklv�b bgg_j\Zpby�[he__� agZqbfh]h� we_f_glZ�\eby_l�gZ�bgg_j\Zpbx�f_g__� agZqbfh]h�Ijb� wlhf� Z\lhju� kkueZxlky� gZ� j_^db_� kemqZb� ij_^\hkobs_gby� b hla\mdZ�� \ kemqZyo� `_h]h\hjhd�^jm]h]h� lbiZ� wlb� a\mdh\u_�ij_^ihql_gby�� _keb�hgb� \hh[s_� kms_kl\mxl��g_�b]jZxlgbdZdhc� jheb�� QZs_� \k_]h� ijb� h]h\hjd_� mihlj_[eyxl� ihoh`__� ih� a\mqZgbx� keh\h�� wlbfkoh^kl\hf�b h[tykgyxl�h]h\hjdm��GZijbf_j��\ k\h_c�\klmibl_evghc�j_qb�ijhn_kkhj�aZy\ey_l�,FK�ELQ�QLFKW�JHQHLJW��JHHLJQHW���GLH�9HUGLHQVWH�PHLQHV�VHKU�JHVFKDW]WHQ�9RUJDQJHUV�]X�ZLLUGLJHQ�>Y

Page 13: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_� kdehg_g� �\f_klh� g_kihkh[_g�� hp_gblv� aZkem]b� k\h_]h� m\Z`Z_fh]h� ij_^r_kl\_ggbdZ@��Beb^jm]hc� ijhn_kkhj�� %HLP� ZHLEOLFKHQ� *HQLWDOH� KDW� PDQ� WURW]� YLHOHU� 9HUVXFKXQJHQ���� 3DUGRQ�9HUVXFKH����>< `_gkdbo�]_gblZebyo��g_kfhljy�gZ�fgh]h�bkdmr_gbc��ijhklbl_��ihiulhd���@�Gh� kZfhc� h[uqghc� b \� lh�`_� \j_fy� kZfhc� ihjZabl_evghc� h]h\hjdhc� y\ey_lky� lZ�� dh]^Zijhbaghkblky� dZd� jZa�ijhlb\hiheh`gh_� lhfm�� qlh� kh[bjZeky� kdZaZlv��Ijb� wlhf� khhlghr_gb_a\mdh\�b \ebygb_�koh^kl\Z��dhg_qgh��g_�bf_xl� agZq_gby��Z aZf_gm�fh`gh�h[tykgblv� l_f��qlhijhlb\hiheh`ghklb� bf_xl� ihgylbcgh_� jh^kl\h� b \� ikboheh]bq_kdhc� ZkkhpbZpbb� hkh[_gghk[eb`Zxlky��Fh`gh� ijb\_klb� bklhjbq_kdb_� ijbf_ju� lZdh]h� jh^Z�� ij_ab^_gl� gZr_c� iZeZlu^_imlZlh\� hldjue� dZd�lh� aZk_^Zgb_� ke_^mxsbfb� keh\Zfb�� ©=hkih^Z�� y ijbagZx� qbkehijbkmlkl\mxsbo� ^hklZlhqguf� b h[ty\eyx� aZk_^Zgb_� aZdjulufª�� LZd� `_� ij_^Zl_evkdb�� dZdkhhlghr_gb_� ijhlb\hiheh`ghkl_c�� fh]ml� ih^\_klb� ^jm]b_� ijb\uqgu_� ZkkhpbZpbb�� dhlhju_bgh]^Z� \hagbdZxl� kh\k_f� g_dklZlb�� LZd�� gZijbf_j�� jZkkdZau\Zxl�� qlh� gZ� lhj`_kl\_gghf[jZdhkhq_lZgbb�^_l_c�=��=_evf]hevpZ�b agZf_gblh]h�bah[j_lZl_ey�b djmigh]h�ijhfure_ggbdZ<��Kbf_gkZ�ba\_klguc�nbabheh]�>x[mZ�J_cfhg�ijhbag_k�ijb\_lkl\_ggmx�j_qv��Hg� aZdhgqbek\hc�\iheg_�[e_klysbc� lhkl�keh\Zfb�� ©BlZd��^Z� a^jZ\kl\m_l�gh\Zy�nbjfZ�Kbf_gk�b =Zekd_ª�Wlh�[ueh��_kl_kl\_ggh��gZa\Zgb_�klZjhc�nbjfu��Khq_lZgb_�wlbo�^\mo�bf_g�lZd�`_�h[uqgh�^ey`bl_ey�;_jebgZ��dZd�©Jb^_ev�b ;hcl_evª�^ey�`bl_ey�<_gu�LZdbf� h[jZahf��fu� ^he`gu� d khhlghr_gbx� a\mdh\� b koh^kl\m� keh\� ijb[Z\blv� \ebygb_keh\_kguo�ZkkhpbZpbc��Gh�b wlh]h�_s_�g_^hklZlhqgh��< p_ehf�jy^_�kemqZ_\�h]h\hjdm�_^\Z�ebfh`gh�h[tykgblv�[_a�mq_lZ�lh]h��qlh�[ueh�kdZaZgh�\ ij_^r_kl\mxs_f�ij_^eh`_gbb�beb�`_�qlhij_^iheZ]Zehkv�kdZaZlv��BlZd��fh`gh�kqblZlv��qlh�wlh�hiylv�kemqZc�hla\mdZ��dZd�ih�F_jbg]_jm�gh� lhevdh� [he__� hl^Ze_ggh� k\yaZgguc� ih� kfukem�� >he`_g� ijbagZlvky�� qlh� ihke_� \k_o� wlboh[tykg_gbc� fh`_l� keh`blvky� \i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� fu� l_i_jv� _s_� [he__� ^Ze_db� hl� ihgbfZgbyh]h\hjhd��q_f�dh]^Z�eb[h�Gh� gZ^_xkv�� qlh� g_� hrb[mkv�� \ukdZaZ\� ij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh� \h� \j_fy� ijh\_^_ggh]hbkke_^h\Zgby�m \k_o�m gZk�\hagbdeh�bgh_�\i_qZle_gb_�hl�ijbf_jh\�h]h\hjhd��dhlhjh_�klhbeh�[uijhZgZebabjh\Zlv�� Fu� bkke_^h\Zeb� mkeh\by�� ijb� dhlhjuo� h]h\hjdb� \hh[s_� \hagbdZxl�hij_^_ebeb��qlh�\eby_l�gZ�hkh[_gghklb�bkdZ`_gbc�ijb�h]h\hjdZo��gh� kh\k_f�g_�jZkkfhlj_ebwnn_dlZ�h]h\hjdb�kZfh]h�ih�k_[_��[_ahlghkbl_evgh�d __�\hagbdgh\_gbx��?keb�fu�j_rbfky�iZwlh��lh�g_h[oh^bfZ�ba\_klgZy�kf_ehklv��qlh[u�kdZaZlv��^Z��\ g_dhlhjuo�kemqZyo�h]h\hjdZ�bf__lkfuke��6LQQ���Qlh�agZqbl�©bf__l�kfukeª"�Wlh�agZqbl��qlh�h]h\hjdm��\hafh`gh��ke_^m_l�kqblZlviheghp_gguf� ikbobq_kdbf� Zdlhf�� bf_xsbf� k\hx� p_ev�� hij_^_e_ggmx� nhjfm� \ujZ`_gby� bagZq_gb_��>h�kbo�ihj�fu�\k_�\j_fy�]h\hjbeb�h[�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\byo��Z l_i_jv�hdZau\Z_lky�qlh�bgh]^Z�hrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\b_�y\ey_lky�kh\_jr_ggh�ijZ\bevguf��lhevdh�hgh�\hagbdeh�\f_klh^jm]h]h�h`b^Z_fh]h�beb�ij_^iheZ]Z_fh]h�^_ckl\by�Wlhl� ^_ckl\bl_evguc� kfuke� hrb[hqgh]h� ^_ckl\by� \ hl^_evguo� kemqZyo� kh\_jr_gghhq_\b^_g� b g_khfg_g_g�� ?keb� ij_^k_^Zl_ev� iZeZlu� ^_imlZlh\� \ i_j\uo� `_� k\hbo� keh\ZoaZdju\Z_l� aZk_^Zgb_� \f_klh� lh]h�� qlh[u� _]h� hldjulv�� lh�� agZy� h[klhyl_evkl\Z�� \ dhlhjuoijhbahreZ�h]h\hjdZ��fu�kdehggu�kqblZlv�wlh�hrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\b_�g_�ebr_gguf�kfukeZ��Hg�g_h`b^Z_l�hl�aZk_^Zgby�gbq_]h�ohjhr_]h�b jZ^�[ue�[u�kjZam�_]h�aZdjulv��IhdZaZlv�wlhl�kfuke��l�_��bklhedh\Zlv�wlm�h]h\hjdm��g_�khklZ\ey_l�gbdZdh]h�ljm^Z��Beb�_keb�h^gZ�^ZfZ�k dZ`msbfky

Page 14: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

h^h[j_gb_f� ]h\hjbl� ^jm]hc�� 'LHVHQ� UHL]HQGHQ� QHXHQ� +XW� KDEHQ� 6LH� VLFK� ZRKO� VHOEVW� DXIJHSDW]">Wlm�ij_e_klgmx�gh\mx�reyim�<u��\_jhylgh��kZfb�h[^_eZeb"�²�\f_klh�DXIJHSXW]W�²hl^_eZeb@�lh�gbdZdZy�gZmqghklv�\ fbj_�g_�ihf_rZ_l�gZf�mkeurZlv�\ wlhc�h]h\hjd_�\ujZ`_gb_��'LHVHU�+XWLVW�HLQH�3DW]HUHL� >WlZ�reyiZ�[_agZ^_`gh�bkihjq_gZ@��Beb�_keb�ba\_klgZy�k\h_c�wg_j]bqghklvx^ZfZ� jZkkdZau\Z_l�� ©Fhc� fm`� kijhkbe� ^hdlhjZ�� dZdhc� ^b_lu� _fm� ijb^_j`b\Zlvky�� gZ� wlh^hdlhj�hl\_lbe�²�_fm�g_�gm`gZ�gbdZdZy�^b_lZ��h\]�fh`_l�_klv�b iblv�\k_��qlh�y ohqmª��lh�\_^vaZ�wlhc�h]h\hjdhc�klhbl�ykgh�\ujZ`_ggZy�ihke_^h\Zl_evgZy�ijh]jZffZ�ih\_^_gby�M\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� _keb� \uykgbehkv�� qlh� g_� lhevdh� g_dhlhju_� h]h\hjdb� bhrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�bf_xl�kfuke��gh�b bo� agZqbl_evgh_�[hevrbgkl\h��lh��g_khfg_ggh��wlhlkfuke�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��h dhlhjhf�^h�kbo�ihj�gbdlh�g_�]h\hjbe��b klZg_l�^ey�gZk�gZb[he__bgl_j_kguf�� Z \k_� hklZevgu_� lhqdb� aj_gby� ih� ijZ\m� hlhc^ml� gZ� aZ^gbc� ieZg�� Fu� fh`_fhklZ\blv� nbabheh]bq_kdb_� b ikbohnbabheh]bq_kdb_� ijhp_kku� b ihk\ylblv� k_[y� qbklhikboheh]bq_kdbf�bkke_^h\Zgbyf�h kfuke_��l��_��agZq_gbb�b gZf_j_gbyo�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc�B \�k\yab�k wlbf�fu�g_�mimklbf�\hafh`ghklb�ijb\e_qv�[he__�rbjhdbc�fZl_jbZe�^ey�ijh\_jdbwlbo�ij_^iheh`_gbc�Gh� ij_`^_� q_f�fu� \uihegbf� wlh� gZf_j_gb_�� y ijhkbe� [u� \Zk� ihke_^h\Zlv� ih� ^jm]hfmimlb��QZklh�kemqZ_lky��qlh�ihwl�ihevam_lky�h]h\hjdhc�beb�^jm]bf�hrb[hqguf�^_ckl\b_f�dZd\ujZabl_evguf� kj_^kl\hf�� Wlhl� nZdl� kZf� ih� k_[_� ^he`_g� gZf� ^hdZaZlv�� qlh� hg� kqblZ_lhrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\b_��gZijbf_j�h]h\hjdm��q_f�lh�hkfuke_gguf��ihlhfm�qlh�\_^v�hg�^_eZ_l�__gZf_j_ggh�� Dhg_qgh�� wlh� ijhbkoh^bl� g_� lZd�� qlh� k\hx� kemqZcgh� k^_eZggmx� hibkdm� ihwlhklZ\ey_l� aZl_f� k\h_fm� i_jkhgZ`m� \ dZq_kl\_� h]h\hjdb�� Hg� ohq_l� gZf� qlh�lh� h[tykgblvh]h\hjdhc��b fu�^he`gu�ihjZafukeblv��qlh�wlh�fh`_l�hagZqZlv��ohq_l�eb�hg�gZf_dgmlv��[m^lhba\_klgh_� ebph� jZkk_yggh� beb� mklZeh�� beb� _]h� `^_l� ijbklmi� fb]j_gb�� Dhg_qgh�� g_� ke_^m_lij_m\_ebqb\Zlv� lh]h�� qlh� ihwl� \k_]^Z� mihlj_[ey_l� h]h\hjdm� dZd� bf_xsmx� hij_^_e_gguckfuke�� < ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� hgZ� fh]eZ� [ulv� [_kkfuke_gghc� ikbobq_kdhc� kemqZcghklvx� blhevdh� \ djZcg_� j_^dbo� kemqZyo� bf_lv� kfuke�� gh� ihwl� \ijZ\_� ijb^Zlv� _c� kfuke�� qlh[ubkihevah\Zlv�_]h�^ey�k\hbo�p_e_c��B ihwlhfm�gZk�[u�g_�m^b\beh��_keb�[u�hl�ihwlZ�fu�magZeb�h[h]h\hjd_�[hevr_��q_f�hl�nbeheh]Z�b ikbobZljZ�Ijbf_j�h]h\hjdb�fu�gZoh^bf�\ <Zee_grl_cg_��Ibddhehfbgb����c Zdl����_ y\e_gb_���FZdkIbddhehfbgb�\ ij_^u^ms_c�kp_g_�kljZklgh�\uklmiZ_l�gZ�klhjhg_�]_jph]Z�b f_qlZ_l�h [eZ]ZofbjZ��jZkdju\rboky�i_j_^�gbf��dh]^Z�hg�khijh\h`^Ze�^hqv�<Zee_grl_cgZ�\ eZ]_jv��?]h�hl_p�bihkeZggbd� ^\hjZ� D\_kl_g[_j]� \ iheghf� g_^hmf_gbb�� : ^Zevr_� \ ��f y\e_gbb� ijhbkoh^blke_^mxs__�D\_kl_g[_j]<hl�^h�q_]h�^hreh��GZklhcqb\h�b g_l_ji_eb\h��: fu�_fm�\ ih^h[ghf�hke_ie_gv_Iha\hebeb�mclb��fhc�^jm]�,,�g_�ah\_f�_]h�lhlqZk�h[jZlgh�²

Page 15: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Hldjulv�_fm�]eZaZ"H d�l Z�\ b�h�hihfgb\rbkv� ihke_� ]em[hdh]h� jZa^mfvy�� Fg_� kZfhfm� Hldjue� ]eZaZ� hg� rbj_�� q_fohl_ehkv�D\_kl_g[_j]Qlh�k \Zfb��^jm]"H d�lZ�\ b�hIjhdeylZy�ih_a^dZ�D\_kl_g[_j]�DZd"�Qlh�lZdh_"HdlZ\bh�Ihkdhj_c��Fg_�gZ^h<a]eygmlv�gZ�wlhl�aehihemqguc�ke_^�B kZfhfm�m\b^_lv�\k_��Ihc^_fl_��Ohq_l�_]h�m\_klb��D\�_kl_g[_j]�AZq_f"�Dm^Z�\u"HdlZ\bh�\k_�_s_�lhjhibl�_]h�D g_c�D\_kl_g[_j]D dhfm"HdlZ\bh�kiho\Zlu\Zykv�>Z�d ]_jph]m��Ihc^_f���I_j_\h^�G��KeZ\ylbgkdh]h�HdlZ\bh�ohl_e�kdZaZlv�©d g_fmª��]_jph]m��gh�h]h\hjbeky�b \u^Ze�keh\Zfb�©b g_cª�ijbqbgm�ihq_fm�fheh^hc�]_jhc�f_qlZ_l�h fbj_�H��JZgd������Z���mdZaZe�gZ�_s_�[he__�ihjZabl_evguc�ijbf_j�m R_dkibjZ�\ <_g_pbZgkdhfdmip_�� \ agZf_gblhc� kp_g_� \u[hjZ� kqZkleb\uf� \haex[e_gguf� h^gh]h� ba� lj_o� eZjph\�� y�ih`Zemc��emqr_�ijhpblbjmx�kZfh]h�JZgdZ�©Qj_a\uqZcgh� lhgdh� om^h`_kl\_ggh� fhlb\bjh\ZggZy� b l_ogbq_kdb� [e_klys_bkihevah\ZggZy�h]h\hjdZ��dhlhjmx�ijb\h^bl�Nj_c^�ba�<Zee_grl_cgZ��^hdZau\Z_l��qlh�ihwluohjhrh� agZxl� f_oZgbaf� b kfuke� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc� b ij_^iheZ]Zxl� bo� ihgbfZgb_� b mkemrZl_ey��< <_g_pbZgkdhf�dmip_�R_dkibjZ� ���c Zdl����y kp_gZ��fu�gZoh^bf�lhfm�_s_�h^bgijbf_j��Ihjpby��dhlhjZy�ih�\he_�k\h_]h�hlpZ�fh`_l�\uclb�aZfm`�lhevdh�aZ�lh]h��dlh�\ulyg_lkqZkleb\uc� `j_[bc�� ebrv� [eZ]h^Zjy� kqZkleb\hc� kemqZcghklb� ba[Z\ey_lky� hl� g_fbeuo� _c`_gboh\�� Gh� dh]^Z� hgZ� gZoh^bl� gZdhg_p� ;ZkkZgbh�� ^hklhcgh]h� ij_l_g^_glZ�� dhlhjuc� _cgjZ\blky��hgZ�[hblky��dZd�[u�b hg�g_�\ulygme�g_kqZkleb\uc�`j_[bc��?c�ohq_lky�_fm�kdZaZlv�qlh�b \�wlhf�kemqZ_�hg�fh`_l�[ulv�m\_j_g�\ __�ex[\b��gh�hgZ�k\yaZgZ�^Zgghc�hlpm�deyl\hc��<

Page 16: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

wlhc�\gmlj_gg_c�^\hckl\_gghklb�hgZ�]h\hjbl�`_eZgghfm�`_gbom�Ihf_^ebl_��^_gv�^\Z�ohlv�ih^h`^bl_�<u�jbkdh\Zlv��\_^v�_keb�hrb[_l_kv��Y ihl_jyx�<Zk�lZd�ihl_jibl_��Fg_�qlh�lh�]h\hjbl��ohlv�g_�ex[h\v���Qlh�g_�ohqm�l_jylv�<Zk��<Zf�`_�ykgh��Qlhg_gZ\bklv� g_� ^Zkl� ih^h[ghc� fukeb�� Gh�� _keb� <Zf� g_� \k_� _s_� ihgylgh� �Ohlv� ^_\mrd_ijbklhcg_c�fukev��q_f�keh\h���Y [�f_kyp�^\Z�ohl_eZ� aZ^_j`Zlv�<Zk��IhdZ�jbkdg_l_��Y [�<ZkgZmqbeZ��DZd�\u[jZlv����Gh�lh]^Z�gZjmrm�deyl\m��G_l��gb aZ�qlh��BlZd��\hafh`_g�ijhfZo��Lh]^Z`Ze_lv� y [m^m�� qlh� ]j_oZ� G_� kh\_jrbeZ�� H�� ijhdeylv_� \ahjZf�� F_gy� hdhe^h\Z\rbf�jZa^_eb\rbf�>\_� iheh\bgu� m f_gy�� h^gZ� <ky� <Zf� ijbgZ^e_`bl�� ^jm]Zy� ²� <Zf����Fg_� ²� y kdZaZlvohl_eZ��agZqbl��<Zf�`_�²�LZd�<Zr_�\k_����I_j_\h^�L��S_idbghc�Dmi_jgbd�Ihwl� k m^b\bl_evguf� ikboheh]bq_kdbf� ijhgbdgh\_gb_f� aZklZ\ey_l�Ihjpbx� \ h]h\hjd_kdZaZlv� lh�� gZ� qlh� hgZ� ohl_eZ� lhevdh� gZf_dgmlv�� lZd� dZd� hgZ� ^he`gZ� [ueZ� kdju\Zlv�� qlh� ^hbkoh^Z�\u[hjZ�hgZ�\ky�_]h�b _]h�ex[bl��b wlbf�bkdmkguf�ijb_fhf�ihwl�\u\h^bl�ex[ys_]h��lZd`_�dZd�b khqm\kl\mxs_]h�_fm� ajbl_ey��ba� khklhygby�fmqbl_evghc�g_ba\_klghklb��mkihdZb\ZygZkq_l�bkoh^Z�\u[hjZª�H[jZlbl_� \gbfZgb_� gZ� lh�� dZd� eh\dh� Ihjpby� \uoh^bl� ba� kha^Z\r_]hky� \ke_^kl\b_� __h]h\hjdb�ijhlb\hj_qby��ih^l\_j`^Zy�\ dhgp_�dhgph\�ijZ\bevghklv�h]h\hjdb�Fg_�²�y kdZaZlv�ohl_eZ��agZqbl��<Zf�`_�²�LZd�<Zr_�\k_���LZd� fukebl_ev�� ^Ze_dbc� hl� f_^bpbgu�� bgh]^Z� fh`_l� jZkdjulv� kfuke� hrb[hqgh]h^_ckl\by� h^gbf� k\hbf� aZf_qZgb_f�� ba[Z\b\� gZk� hl� \ukemrb\Zgby� jZatykg_gbc�� <u� \k_�dhg_qgh��agZ_l_�hkljhmfgh]h�kZlbjbdZ�Eio�l_g[_j]Z������²�������h dhlhjhf�=zl_�kdZaZe��©LZf�]^_� m g_]h� rmldZ�� fh`_l� kdju\Zlvky� ijh[e_fZ�� Gh� \_^v� [eZ]h^Zjy� rmld_� bgh]^Z� j_rZ_lkyijh[e_fZª��< k\hbo�hkljhmfguo�kZlbjbq_kdbo�aZf_ldZo� �������Ebol_g[_j]�ibr_l��©Hg�\k_]^ZqblZe� $JDPHPQRQ� >:]Zf_fghg@� \f_klh� DQJHQRPPHQ� >ijbgylh@�� gZklhevdh� hg� aZqblu\Zeky=hf_jhfª��<hl�gZklhysZy�l_hjby�hqbldb�< ke_^mxsbc�jZa�fu�h[km^bf��gZkdhevdh�fu�fh`_f�kh]eZkblvky�k lhqdhc�aj_gby�ihwlh\�gZhrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�LJ?LVY�E?DPBYHrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�ijh^he`_gb_�M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��< ijhreuc�jZa�gZf�ijbreZ�\ ]heh\m�fukev�jZkkfZljb\Zlvhrb[hqgh_� ^_ckl\b_� kZfh� ih� k_[_�� [_ahlghkbl_evgh� d gZjmr_gghfm� bf� ^_ckl\bx�� dhlhjh_ij_^iheZ]Zeb�kh\_jrblv��m gZk�keh`behkv�\i_qZle_gb_��[m^lh�\ hl^_evguo�kemqZyo�hgh�\u^Z_lk\hc�kh[kl\_gguc�kfuke��b _keb�[u�wlh�ih^l\_j^behkv�_s_�\ [hevr_f�qbke_�kemqZ_\��lh�wlhlkfuke� [ue� [u� ^ey� gZk� bgl_j_kg__�� q_f� bkke_^h\Zgb_� mkeh\bc�� ijb� dhlhjuo� \hagbdZ_l

Page 17: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\b_�>h]h\hjbfky� _s_� jZa� h lhf�� qlh� fu� ihgbfZ_f� ih^� ©kfukehfª� �6LQQ�� dZdh]h�lhikbobq_kdh]h�ijhp_kkZ�g_�qlh�bgh_��dZd�gZf_j_gb_��dhlhjhfm�hg� kem`bl��b _]h�f_klh�\ jy^m^jm]bo� ikbobq_kdbo� ijhy\e_gbb�� < [hevrbgkl\_� gZrbo� bkke_^h\Zgbc� keh\h� ©kfukeª� fufh`_f�aZf_gblv�keh\hf ©gZf_j_gb_ª��$EVLFKW���©l_g^_gpbyª��7HQGHQ]���H^gZdh�g_�y\ey_lky�ebkZfhh[fZghf�beb�ihwlbq_kdhc�\hevghklvx�k gZr_c�klhjhgu��qlh�fu�mkfZljb\Z_f�\ hrb[hqghf^_ckl\bb�gZf_j_gb_";m^_f� `_� ih�ij_`g_fm� aZgbfZlvky� h]h\hjdZfb� b jZkkfhljbf� [hevr__� dhebq_kl\hgZ[ex^_gbc��Fu� m\b^bf��qlh� \ p_ehf� jy^_� kemqZ_\�gZf_j_gb_�� kfuke� h]h\hjdb� kh\_jr_gghhq_\b^_g�� Wlh� ij_`^_� \k_]h� l_� kemqZb�� dh]^Z� ]h\hjblky� ijhlb\hiheh`gh_� lhfm�� qlhgZf_j_\Zebkv�kdZaZlv��Ij_ab^_gl�\ j_qb�gZ�hldjulbb�aZk_^Zgby�]h\hjbl��©H[ty\eyx�aZk_^Zgb_aZdjulufª�� Kfuke� b gZf_j_gb_� _]h� hrb[db� \ lhf�� qlh� hg� ohq_l� aZdjulv� aZk_^Zgb_�� LZd� bohq_lky�ijhpblbjh\Zlv��©>Z�\_^v�hg�kZf�h[�wlhf�]h\hjblª�hklZ_lky� lhevdh� ihcfZlv� _]h� gZ� keh\_�� G_� \hajZ`Zcl_� fg_�� qlh� wlh� g_\hafh`gh�� \_^vij_^k_^Zl_ev��dZd�fu�agZ_f��ohl_e�g_�aZdjulv��Z hldjulv�aZk_^Zgb_��b hg�kZf�ih^l\_j^bl�wlh��Z_]h�fg_gb_�y\ey_lky�^ey�gZk�\ukr_c�bgklZgpb_c��Ijb�wlhf�\u�aZ[u\Z_l_��qlh�fu�mkeh\bebkvjZkkfZljb\Zlv�hrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\b_�kZfh�ih�k_[_��h _]h�hlghr_gbb�d gZf_j_gbx��dhlhjh_�ba�aZg_]h�gZjmrZ_lky��fu�[m^_f�]h\hjblv�iha`_��BgZq_�\u�^himklbl_�eh]bq_kdmx�hrb[dm�b ijhklhmkljZgbl_�ijh[e_fm��lh��qlh�\ Zg]ebckdhf�yaud_�gZau\Z_lky EHJJLQJ�WKH�TXHVWLRQ �< ^jm]bo� kemqZyo�� dh]^Z� ijb� h]h\hjd_� ijyfh� g_� \ukdZau\Z_lky� ijhlb\hiheh`gh_ml\_j`^_gb_�� \ g_c� \k_� `_� \ujZ`Z_lky� ijhlb\hiheh`guc� kfuke�� ©Y g_� kdehg_g� �\f_klhg_kihkh[_g�� hp_gblv� aZkem]b� k\h_]h� m\Z`Z_fh]h� ij_^r_kl\_ggbdZª�� ©*HQHLJWª� �kdehg_g�� g_y\ey_lky�ijhlb\hiheh`guf�©JHHLJQHWª��kihkh[_g���h^gZdh�wlh�y\gh_�ijbagZgb_�ijhlb\hj_qbl��kblmZpbb��h dhlhjhc�]h\hjbl�hjZlhj�<klj_qZxlky� kemqZb�� dh]^Z� h]h\hjdZ� ijhklh� ijb[Z\ey_l� d kfukem� gZf_j_gby� dZdhc�lh\lhjhc� kfuke�� Lh]^Z� ij_^eh`_gb_� a\mqbl� lZd�� dZd� [m^lh� hgh� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� kly`_gb_�khdjZs_gb_��k]ms_gb_�g_kdhevdbo�ij_^eh`_gbc��LZdh\h�aZy\e_gb_�wg_j]bqghc�^Zfu��hg��fm`�fh`_l�_klv�b iblv�\k_��qlh�y aZohqm��<_^v�hgZ�l_f�kZfuf�dZd�[u�]h\hjbl��hg�fh`_l�_klv�b iblv�qlh� hg� ohq_l�� gh� jZa\_� hg� kf__l� ohl_lv"� <f_klh� g_]h� y ohqm�� H]h\hjdb� qZklh� ijhba\h^yl\i_qZle_gb_� lZdbo� khdjZs_gbc�� GZijbf_j�� ijhn_kkhj� ZgZlhfbb� ihke_� e_dpbb� h ghkh\hcihehklb� kijZrb\Z_l�� \k_� eb� [ueh� ihgylgh� kemrZl_eyf�� b�� ihemqb\� ml\_j^bl_evguc� hl\_l�ijh^he`Z_l�� ©Khfg_\Zxkv�� ihlhfm� qlh� ^Z`_� \ ]hjh^_� k fbeebhgguf� gZk_e_gb_f� ex^_c�ihgbfZxsbo� ZgZlhfbx� ghkh\hc� ihehklb�� fh`gh� khkqblZlv� ih� h^ghfm� iZevpm�� ijhklbl_�� ihiZevpZf�h^ghc�jmdbª��Wlh�khdjZs_gb_�bf__l�k\hc�kfuke��_klv�lhevdh�h^bg�q_eh\_d��dhlhjucwlh�ihgbfZ_l�>Zgghc� ]jmii_�kemqZ_\��\ dhlhjuo�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�kZfb�mdZau\Zxl�gZ�k\hc�kfuke�ijhlb\hklhyl� ^jm]b_�� \ dhlhjuo� h]h\hjdb� g_� bf_xl� y\gh]h� kfukeZ� b dZd� [u� ijhlb\hj_qZlgZrbf�ij_^iheh`_gbyf��?keb�dlh�lh�ijb�h]h\hjd_�dh\_jdZ_l�bfy�kh[kl\_ggh_�beb�ijhbaghkblg_mihlj_[bl_evguc�gZ[hj�a\mdh\��lh�m`_�ba�aZ�lZdbo�qZklh�\klj_qZxsboky�kemqZ_\�\hijhk�h[hkfuke_gghklb�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc�dZd�[m^lh�fh`_l�[ulv�j_r_g�hljbpZl_evgh��B ebrv�ijb

Page 18: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[eb`Zcr_f�jZkkfhlj_gbb�wlbo�ijbf_jh\�h[gZjm`b\Z_lky��qlh�\ wlbo�kemqZyo�lh`_�\hafh`ghihgbfZgb_�bkdZ� �K\_klb�\hijhk�gZ�g_l �Zg]e����Ijbf_q��i_j�`_gbc��Z jZagbpZ�f_`^m�wlbfb�g_ykgufb�b \ur_hibkZggufb�hq_\b^gufb�kemqZyfb�g_�lZdm`�\_ebdZ�H^gh]h�]hkih^bgZ�kijhkbeb�h khklhygbb�a^hjh\vy�_]h�ehrZ^b��hg�hl\_lbe�� -D��GDV�GUDXW���'DV�GDXHUW�YLHOOHLFKW�QRFK�HLQHQ�0RQDW�>>Z��wlh�ijh^eblky��\_jhylgh��_s_�f_kyp��gh�\f_klh�keh\Z©ijh^eblkyª�²�GDXHUW�²�\gZqZe_�[ueh�kdZaZgh��kljZggh_�©GUDXWª@��GZ�\hijhk��qlh�hg�wlbf�ohl_ekdZaZlv�� hg�� ih^mfZ\�� hl\_lbe�� 'DV� LVW� HLQH� WUDXULJH� *HVFKLFKWH� >Wlh� i_qZevgZy� bklhjby@�� Baklhedgh\_gby� keh\� ©GDXHUWª� >^Zm_jl@� b ©WUDXULJHª� >ljZmjb]_@� ihemqbehkv� ©^jZmlª� �0HULQJHU�0D\HU��������>jm]hc�jZkkdZau\Z_l�h ijhbkr_kl\byo��dhlhju_�hg�hkm`^Z_l��b ijh^he`Z_l��'DQQ�DEHU�VLQGGLH� 7DWVDFKHQ� ]XP� 9RUVFKZHLQ� >nhjr\Zcg@� JHNRPPHQ���� >B lh]^Z� h[gZjm`bebkv� nZdlu�� gh� \keh\h� 9RUVFKHLQ� ²� we_f_gl� \ujZ`_gby� ©h[gZjm`bebkvª� ²\klZ\e_gZ� ebrgyy� [md\Z� Z@�� GZjZkkijhku�jZkkdZaqbd�hl\_lbe��qlh�hg�kqblZ_l�wlb�nZdlu�k\bgkl\hf�²�6FKZHLQHUHL��>\Z�keh\Z²�9RUVFKHLQ�>nhjrZcg@�b 6FKZHLQHUHL�>r\Zcg_�jZc@�²�\f_kl_�h[jZah\Zeb�kljZggh_�©nhjr\Zcgª�F_jbg]_j��FZc_j��� <kihfgbf� kemqZc�� dh]^Z� fheh^hc� q_eh\_d� ohl_e� EHJOHLWGLJHQ� ^Zfm��Fubf_eb� kf_ehklv� jZa^_eblv� wlm� keh\_kgmx� dhgkljmdpbx� gZ� EHJOHLWHQ� >ijh\h^blv@� b EHOHLGLJHQ>hkdhj[blv@�b [ueb�m\_j_gu�\ lZdhf� lhedh\Zgbb��g_� lj_[my� lhfm�ih^l\_j`^_gby��Ba�^Zgguoijbf_jh\�\Zf�ihgylgh��qlh�b lZdb_�g_ykgu_�kemqZb�h]h\hjhd�fh`gh�h[tykgblv�klhedgh\_gb_f�bgl_jn_j_gpb_c�^\mo�jZaebqguo�gZf_j_gby��JZagbpZ�khklhbl�\ lhf��qlh�\ i_j\hf�kemqZ_�h^ghgZf_j_gb_� iheghklvx� aZf_sZ_lky� �km[klblmijm_lky�� ^jm]bf�� b lh]^Z� \hagbdZxl� h]h\hjdb� kijhlb\hiheh`guf� kfukehf��� \ ^jm]hf� kemqZ_� gZf_j_gb_� lhevdh� bkdZ`Z_lky� bebfh^bnbpbjm_lky�� lZd� qlh� h[jZamxlky� dhf[bgZpbb�� dhlhju_� dZ`mlky� [he__� beb� f_g__hkfuke_ggufb�L_i_jv� fu�� dZ`_lky�� h[tykgbeb� agZqbl_evgh_� qbkeh� h]h\hjhd�� ?keb� fu� [m^_f� l\_j^hijb^_j`b\Zlvky�gZr_]h�ih^oh^Z��lh�kfh`_f�ihgylv�b ^jm]b_�[u\rb_�^h�kbo�ghj�aZ]Z^hqgufbh]h\hjdb�� GZijbf_j�� \jy^� eb� fh`gh� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� ijb� bkdZ`_gbb� bf_g� \k_]^Z� bf__lf_klh�dhgdmj_gpby�f_`^m�^\mfy�ihoh`bfb��gh�jZagufb�bf_gZfb��G_ljm^gh��\ijhq_f��m]Z^Zlvb ^jm]mx� l_g^_gpbx��<_^v� bkdZ`_gb_� bf_gb� qZklh� ijhbkoh^bl� g_� lhevdh� \ h]h\hjdZo�� bfyiulZxlky� ijhbag_klb� g_[eZ]ha\mqgh� b \g_klb� \ g_]h� qlh�lh� mgbabl_evgh_� ²� wlh� y\ey_lkyk\h_]h�jh^Z�hkdhj[e_gb_f��dhlhjh]h�dmevlmjguc�q_eh\_d��ohly�b g_�\k_]^Z�hohlgh�� klZjZ_lkyba[_]Zlv��Hg�_s_�qZklh�iha\hey_l�wlh�k_[_�\ dZq_kl\_�©rmldbª��ijZ\^Zª�g_\ukhdh]h�k\hckl\Z��<dZq_kl\_� ijbf_jZ� ijb\_^m� hl\jZlbl_evgh_� bkdZ`_gb_� bf_gb� ij_ab^_glZ� NjZgpmakdhcj_kim[ebdb� ImZgdZj_�� dhlhjh_� \ gZklhys__� \j_fy� i_j_^_eZeb� \ ©R\ZcgdZj_ª�� G_ljm^ghij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� b ijb� h]h\hjd_� fh`_l� ijhy\blvky� gZf_j_gb_� hkdhj[blv�� dZd� b ijbbkdZ`_gbb� bf_gb�� Ih^h[gu_� h[tykg_gby�� ih^l\_j`^Zxsb_� gZrb� ij_^klZ\e_gby�gZijZrb\Zxlky� b \� kemqZ_� h]h\hjhd� k dhfbq_kdbf� b Z[kmj^guf� wnn_dlhf�� ©Y ijhrm� <Zkhlju]gmlv� �\f_klh�qhdgmlvky�� aZ� a^hjh\v_�gZr_]h�r_nZª��IjZa^gbqguc�gZkljhc�g_h`b^ZgghgZjmrZ_lky� keh\hf�� \uau\Zxsbf� g_ijbylgh_� ij_^klZ\e_gb_�� b ih� ijbf_jm� [jZgguo� b

Page 19: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gZkf_reb\uo�j_q_c�g_ljm^gh�ij_^iheh`blv��qlh�bf_ggh�lZdbf�h[jZahf�\ujZabehkv�gZf_j_gb_�ijhlb\hj_qZs__� ij_m\_ebq_gghfm� ihql_gbx�� qlh� ohl_eb� kdZaZlv� ijbf_jgh� ke_^mxs__�� ©G_\_jvl_�wlhfm��\k_�wlh�g_k_jv_agh��ie_\Zlv�fg_�gZ�wlh]h�fZeh]h�b l��i�ª�Lh�`_�kZfh_�hlghkblky�dl_f� h]h\hjdZf�� \ dhlhjuo� [_ah[b^gu_� keh\Z� ij_\jZsZxlky� \ g_ijbebqgu_�� dZd� gZijbf_jDSRSRV� >ih� aZ^m@� \f_klh� DSURSRV� >dklZlb@� beb� (LVFKHLSZHLEFKHQ� >]gmkgZy� [Z[_gdZ@� \f_klh(LZHL�6VFKHLEFKHQ�>[_edh\Zy�ieZklbgdZ@��F_jbg]_j��FZc_j���Fu�agZ_f�fgh]bo�ex^_c��dhlhju_jZ^b�m^h\hevkl\by�gZf_j_ggh�bkdZ`Zxl�[_ah[b^gu_�keh\Z��ij_\jZsZy�bo�\ g_ijbebqgu_�wlh�kqblZ_lky�hkljhmfguf��b \�^_ckl\bl_evghklb�qZklh�ijboh^blky�kijZrb\Zlv�q_eh\_dZ�hl�dhlhjh]h�keurbrv�ih^h[gh_��ihrmlbe�eb�hg�gZf_j_ggh�beb�h]h\hjbeky�Gm��\hl�fu�[_a�hkh[h]h�ljm^Z�b j_rbeb� aZ]Z^dm�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��Hgb�g_�y\eyxlkykemqZcghklyfb��Z ij_^klZ\eyxl�kh[hc�k_jv_agu_�ikbobq_kdb_�Zdlu��bf_xsb_�k\hc�kfuke��hgb\hagbdZxl� [eZ]h^Zjy� \aZbfh^_ckl\bx�� Z emqr_� kdZaZlv�� ijhlb\h^_ckl\bx� ^\mo� jZaebqguogZf_j_gbc��: l_i_jv�fh]m� k_[_� ij_^klZ\blv�� dZdhc� ]jZ^� \hijhkh\� b khfg_gbc� \u� ]hlh\u� gZf_gy� h[jmrblv� b y� ^he`_g� hl\_lblv� gZ� gbo� b jZaj_rblv� \Zrb� khfg_gby�� ij_`^_� q_f� fuihjZ^m_fky� i_j\hfm� j_amevlZlm� gZr_c� jZ[hlu�� Y�� dhg_qgh�� g_� ohqm� ih^lZedb\Zlv� \Zk� dihki_rguf�\u\h^Zf��>Z\Zcl_�`_�ih^\_j]g_f�[_kijbkljZklghfm�ZgZebam�\k_�ih�ihjy^dm��h^ghaZ�^jm]bf�H q_f�\u�ohl_eb�[u�f_gy�kijhkblv"�KqblZx�eb�y��qlh�wlh�h[tykgy_l�\k_�kemqZb�h]h\hjhdbeb�lhevdh�hij_^_e_ggh_�bo�qbkeh"�Fh`gh�eb�lZdh_�h[tykg_gb_�i_j_g_klb�b gZ�fgh]b_�^jm]b_\b^u�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��gZ�hqbldb��hibkdb�� aZ[u\Zgb_�� aZo\Zlu\Zgb_�\_s_c� ©ih�hrb[d_ª�9HUJUHLIFQ�� ��bo�aZl_jb\Zgb_�b l��^�"�Bf_xl�eb�dZdh_�lh�agZq_gb_�^ey�ikbobq_kdhc�ijbjh^uhrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc�nZdlhju� mklZehklb�� \ha[m`^_gby�� jZkk_ygghklb�� gZjmr_gby� \gbfZgby"Fh`gh�� ^Ze__�� aZf_lblv�� qlh� ba� ^\mo� dhgdmjbjmxsbo� gZf_j_gbc� h^gh� \k_]^Z� ijhy\ey_lky� \hrb[hqghf�^_ckl\bb��^jm]h_�`_�g_�\k_]^Z�hq_\b^gh��Qlh�`_�g_h[oh^bfh�k^_eZlv��qlh[u�magZlvwlh� kdjulh_� gZf_j_gb_�� b�� _keb� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� fu� ^h]Z^Zebkv� h g_f�� dZdb_� _klv^hdZaZl_evkl\Z��qlh�gZrZ�^h]Z^dZ�g_�lhevdh�\_jhylgZ��gh�_^bgkl\_ggh�\_jgZ"�Fh`_l�[ulv��m \Zk_klv� _s_� \hijhku"� ?keb� g_l�� lh� y ijh^he`m�� GZihfgx� \Zf�� qlh� kZfb� ih� k_[_� hrb[hqgu_^_ckl\by� bgl_j_kmxl� gZk� ebrv� ihklhevdm�� ihkdhevdm� hgb� ^Zxl� p_gguc� fZl_jbZe�� dhlhjucbamqZ_lky� ikbohZgZebahf�� Hlkx^Z� \hagbdZ_l� \hijhk�� qlh� wlh� aZ� gZf_j_gby� beb� l_g^_gpbb�dhlhju_�f_rZxl�ijhy\blvky�^jm]bf��b dZdh\u�\aZbfhhlghr_gby�f_`^m�gbfb"�Fu�ijh^he`bfgZrm�jZ[hlm�lhevdh�ihke_�j_r_gby�wlhc�ijh[e_fu�BlZd��ih^oh^bl�eb�gZr_�h[tykg_gb_�^ey�\k_o� kemqZ_\�h]h\hjhd"�Y hq_gv� kdehg_g� wlhfm\_jblv�b bf_ggh�ihlhfm��qlh��dh]^Z�jZa[bjZ_rv �I_j_\h^�wlh]h�keh\Z�gZ�jmkkdbc�yaud�ij_^klZ\ey_l�agZqbl_evgu_�ljm^ghklb��9HUJUHLIHQ�hagZqZ_l�[md\Zevgh©hrb[dZª�� ©hrb[hqguc� aZo\Zlª� dZdh]h�eb[h� ij_^f_lZ�� Lhqguc� i_j_\h^� keh\Z� aZ\bkbl� hl� dhgl_dklZ�Ihwlhfm�\ h^ghf�kemqZ_�fu�i_j_\h^bf�wlh�keh\h�dZd�©aZo\Zlu\Zgb_ ���ih hrb[d_��ª��\ ^jm]hf�²�dZd�©^_ckl\b_ih hrb[d_ª� �g_� imlZlv� k ©hrb[hqguf� ^_ckl\b_fª� �� )HKOOHLVWXQJ�� dhlhjh_� y\ey_lky� jh^h\uf� ihgylb_f� d9HUJUHLIHQ���\ lj_lv_f²ijhklh�dZd� ©hrb[dZª� �g_�imlZlv�kh�keh\hf� ©,UUWXUQª��dhlhjh_�lZd`_�i_j_\h^blkydZd�©hrb[dZª��²�Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�dZ`^uc�kemqZc�h]h\hjdb��lZdh_�h[tykg_gb_�gZoh^blky��Gh�wlh�_s_�g_�^hdZau\Z_l��qlh�g_lh]h\hjhd� ^jm]h]h� oZjZdl_jZ�� Imklv� [m^_l� lZd�� ^ey� gZr_c� l_hjbb� wlh� [_ajZaebqgh�� lZd� dZd

Page 20: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\u\h^u��dhlhju_�fu�ohlbf�k^_eZlv�^ey�\\_^_gby�\ ikbohZgZeba��hklZgmlky�\ kbe_�^Z`_�\ lhfkemqZ_���_keb�[u�gZr_fm�h[tykg_gbx�ih^^Z\Zehkv�ebrv�g_[hevrh_�dhebq_kl\h�h]h\hjhd��qlh�\ijhq_f�� g_� lZd�� GZ� ke_^mxsbc� \hijhk� ²� fh`gh� eb� ihemq_ggu_� ^Zggu_� h[� h]h\hjdZojZkijhkljZgblv� gZ� ^jm]b_� \b^u� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc"� ²� y ohl_e� [u� aZjZg__� hl\_lblviheh`bl_evgh�� <u� kZfb� m[_^bl_kv� \ wlhf�� dh]^Z� fu� i_j_c^_f� d jZkkfhlj_gbx� ijbf_jh\hibkhd�� aZo\Zlu\Zgby� ©ih� hrb[d_ª� ij_^f_lh\� b l�� ^��Gh� ih� f_lh^bq_kdbf� khh[jZ`_gbyf� yij_^eZ]Zx�hleh`blv�wlm�jZ[hlm��ihdZ�fu�hkgh\Zl_evg__�g_�jZa[_j_fky�k h]h\hjdZfb�<hijhk�h lhf��bf_xl�eb�^ey�gZk�agZq_gb_�\u^\b]Z_fu_�^jm]bfb�Z\lhjZfb�gZ�i_j\uc�ieZgnZdlhju� gZjmr_gby� djh\hh[jZs_gby�� mlhfe_gby�� \ha[m`^_gby�� jZkk_ygghklb� b l_hjbyjZkkljhckl\Z� \gbfZgby�� aZkem`b\Z_l� [he__� \gbfZl_evgh]h� jZkkfhlj_gby�� _keb� fu� ijbagZ_fhibkZgguc�\ur_�ikbobq_kdbc�f_oZgbaf�h]h\hjdb��AZf_lvl_��fu�g_�hkiZjb\Z_f�wlbo�fhf_glh\�IkbohZgZeba�\hh[s_�j_^dh�hkiZjb\Z_l�lh��qlh�ml\_j`^Zxl�^jm]b_�dZd�ijZ\beh�� hg� ^h[Z\ey_l� qlh�lh�gh\h_��ijZ\^Z�� qZklh�ihemqZ_lky� lZd�� qlh� wlh� jZg__�g_aZf_q_ggh_� b \gh\v� ^h[Z\e_ggh_� b y\ey_lky� dZd� jZa� kms_kl\_gguf�� GZfb� [_ah]h\hjhqghijbagZ_lky�\ebygb_�gZ�\hagbdgh\_gb_�h]h\hjdb�nbabheh]bq_kdbo�mkeh\bc�e_]dh]h�g_a^hjh\vy�gZjmr_gbc�djh\hh[jZs_gby��khklhygby�bklhs_gby��h[�wlhf�k\b^_l_evkl\m_l�gZr�ih\k_^g_\gucebqguc�hiul��Gh�dZd�fZeh�wlbf�h[tykgy_lky��Ij_`^_�\k_]h��wlh�g_�h[yaZl_evgu_�mkeh\by�^eyhrb[hqgh]h� ^_ckl\by�� H]h\hjdZ� \hafh`gZ� ijb� Z[khexlghf� a^hjh\v_� b \� ghjfZevghfkhklhygbb�� Wlb� khfZlbq_kdb_� mkeh\by� fh]ml� lhevdh� h[e_]qblv� b mkdhjblv� ijhy\e_gb_k\h_h[jZagh]h�ikbobq_kdh]h�f_oZgbafZ�h]h\hjdb��>ey�h[tykg_gby�wlh]h�hlghr_gby�y ijb\h^bedh]^Z�lh�kjZ\g_gb_��dhlhjh_�k_cqZk�ih\lhjx�aZ�g_bf_gb_f�emqr_]h��Ij_^iheh`bf��qlh�y b^ml_fghc�ghqvx�ih�[_aex^ghfm�f_klm��gZ�f_gy�gZiZ^Z_l� ]jZ[bl_ev��hlgbfZ_l�qZku�b dhr_e_d�LZd� dZd� y g_� jZa]ey^_e� ebpZ� ]jZ[bl_ey�� lh� \ [eb`Zcr_f� ihebp_ckdhf� mqZkld_� y aZy\eyx�©;_aex^gh_�f_klh� b l_fghlZ� lhevdh� qlh� hlgyeb� m f_gy� p_ggu_� \_sbª��GZ� qlh� ihebp_ckdbcdhfbkkZj� fg_� fh`_l� kdZaZlv�� ©<u� gZijZkgh� ijb^_j`b\Z_l_kv� qbklh� f_oZgbklbq_kdhc� lhqdbaj_gby�� Ij_^klZ\bf� k_[_� ^_eh� emqr_� lZd�� ih^� aZsblhc� l_fghlu� \ [_aex^ghf� f_kl_g_ba\_klguc�]jZ[bl_ev�hlgye�m <Zk�p_ggu_�\_sb��KZfuf�\Z`guf�\ <Zr_f�kemqZ_�y\ey_lky��dZdfg_� dZ`_lky�� lh��qlh[u�fu�gZreb� ]jZ[bl_ey��Lh]^Z��fh`_l�[ulv��fu� kfh`_f� aZ[jZlv� m g_]hihobs_ggh_ª�LZdb_� ikbohnbabheh]bq_kdb_� mkeh\by�� dZd� \ha[m`^_gb_�� jZkk_ygghklv�� gZjmr_gb_\gbfZgby�^Zxl�hq_gv�fZeh�^ey�h[tykg_gby�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��Wlh�lhevdh�njZau��rbjfu��aZdhlhju_�fu�g_�^he`gu�[hylvky�aZ]eygmlv��Emqr_�kijhkbf��q_f�\ua\Zgh�wlh�\heg_gb_��hkh[h_hl\e_q_gb_� \gbfZgby�� <ebygb_� kha\mqbc�� koh^kl\� keh\� b mihlj_[bl_evguo� keh\_kguoZkkhpbZpbc� lh`_� ke_^m_l� ijbagZlv� \Z`gufb�� Hgb� lh`_� h[e_]qZxl� ihy\e_gb_� h]h\hjdb�mdZau\Zy� _c�imlb��ih� dhlhjuf�hgZ�fh`_l�ihclb��Gh� _keb�i_j_^h�fghc� e_`bl� dZdhc�lh�imlv�ij_^j_r_gh�eb��qlh�y ihc^m�bf_ggh�ih�g_fm"�G_h[oh^bf�_s_�dZdhc�lh�fhlb\��qlh[u�y j_rbekygZ�g_]h��b��djhf_�lh]h��kbeZ��dhlhjZy�[u�f_gy�ijh^\b]ZeZ�ih�wlhfm�imlb��LZdbf�h[jZahf��dZdkhhlghr_gb_� a\mdh\� b keh\�� lZd� b khfZlbq_kdb_� mkeh\by� lhevdh� kihkh[kl\mxl� ihy\e_gbxh]h\hjdb�b g_�fh]ml� __ h[tykgblv��Ih^mfZcl_��h^gZdh��h lhf�h]jhfghf�qbke_� kemqZ_\��dh]^Zj_qv� g_� gZjmrZ_lky� ba�aZ� koh`_klb� a\mqZgby� mihlj_[e_ggh]h� keh\Z� k ^jm]bf�� ba�aZijhlb\hiheh`ghklb�bo�agZq_gbc�beb�mihlj_[bl_evghklb�keh\_kguo�ZkkhpbZpbc��Fu�fh]eb�[u

Page 21: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kh]eZkblvky� k nbehkhnhf� <mg^lhf� \ lhf�� qlh� h]h\hjdZ� ihy\ey_lky�� dh]^Z� \ke_^kl\b_nbabq_kdh]h� bklhs_gby� ZkkhpbZlb\gu_� gZdehgghklb� gZqbgZxl� ij_h[eZ^Zlv� gZ^� ^jm]bfbih[m`^_gbyfb�\ j_qb��K wlbf�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�e_]dh�kh]eZkblvky��_keb�[u�wlh�g_�ijhlb\hj_qbehnZdlZf� \hagbdgh\_gby� h]h\hjdb� \ kemqZyo�� dh]^Z� hlkmlkl\mxl� eb[h� nbabq_kdb_�� eb[hZkkhpbZlb\gu_�mkeh\by�^ey�__ ihy\e_gby ��Gh�hkh[_ggh�bgl_j_kguf�dZ`_lky�fg_�\Zr� ke_^mxsbc� \hijhk�²�dZdbf�h[jZahf�fh`ghm[_^blvky�\ kms_kl\h\Zgbb�^\mo�khi_jgbqZxsbo�gZf_j_gbc"�<u�b g_�ih^haj_\Z_l_��d dZdbfk_jv_aguf�\u\h^Zf�\_^_l�gZk� wlhl�\hijhk��G_�ijZ\^Z�eb��h^gh�ba�^\mo�gZf_j_gbc�� Z bf_gghgZjmr_ggh_� �JHVWRUWH��� h[uqgh� g_� \uau\Z_l� khfg_gbc�� q_eh\_d�� kh\_jrb\rbc� hrb[hqgh_^_ckl\b_��agZ_l�h g_f�b ijbagZ_l�_]h��Khfg_gby�b jZafure_gby�\uau\Z_l�\lhjh_��gZjmrZxs__�VWRUHQGH�� gZf_j_gb_��Fu� m`_� keurZeb�� Z \u�� dhg_qgh�� g_� aZ[ueb�� qlh� \ jy^_� kemqZ_\� wlhgZf_j_gb_� lh`_� ^hklZlhqgh� ykgh� \ujZ`_gh�� Hgh� h[gZjm`b\Z_lky� \ wnn_dl_� h]h\hjdb�� _keblhevdh� \aylv� gZ� k_[y� kf_ehklv� kqblZlv� wlhl� wnn_dl� ^hdZaZl_evkl\hf�� Ij_ab^_gl�� dhlhjuc^himkdZ_l�h]h\hjdm�k h[jZlguf�kfukehf��dhg_qgh��ohq_l�hldjulv�aZk_^Zgb_��gh�g_�f_g__�ykgh�qlh� hg� ohq_l� _]h� b aZdjulv�� Wlh� gZklhevdh� hq_\b^gh�� qlh� lml� b lhedh\Zlv� g_q_]h�� : dZd^h]Z^Zlvky� h gZjmrZxs_f� gZf_j_gbb� ih� bkdZ`_gbx� \ l_o� kemqZyo�� dh]^Z� gZjmrZxs__gZf_j_gb_�lhevdh�bkdZ`Z_l�i_j\hgZqZevgh_��g_�\ujZ`Zy�k_[y�iheghklvx"< i_j\hf�jy^_�kemqZ_\�wlh�lhqgh�lZd�`_�ijhklh�b ^_eZ_lky�lZdbf�`_�h[jZahf��dZd�b ijbhij_^_e_gbb� gZjmr_ggh]h� gZf_j_gby��H g_f� khh[sZ_l� kZf� ^himklb\rbc� h]h\hjdm�� hg� kjZamfh`_l� \hkklZgh\blv� lh�� qlh� gZf_j_\Zeky� kdZaZlv� i_j\hgZqZevgh�� ©'DV� GUDXW�� QHLQ�� GDV� GDXHUWYLHOOHLFKW�QRFK�HLQHQ�0RQDWª�>Wlh�^jZml��g_l��wlh�ijh^eblky��\_jhylgh��_s_�f_kyp@��BkdZ`Zxs__gZf_j_gb_�hg�lml�`_�\ujZabe��dh]^Z�_]h�kijhkbeb��qlh�hg�ohl_e�kdZaZlv�keh\hf�©^jZmlª��©'DV�LVWHLQH� WUDXULJH� *HVFKLFKWHª� >Wlh� i_qZevgZy� bklhjby@�� <h� \lhjhf� kemqZ_�� ijb� h]h\hjd_©9RUVFKZHLQª��hg�kjZam�`_�ih^l\_j`^Z_l��qlh�ohl_e�kgZqZeZ�kdZaZlv��©'DV�LVW�6FKZHLQH�UHLª�>Wlhk\bgkl\h@��gh�k^_j`Zeky�b \ujZabeky�ih�^jm]hfm��BkdZ`Zxs__�gZf_j_gb_�a^_kv�lZd�`_�e_]dhmklZgh\blv�� dZd� b bkdZ`_ggh_�� Y gZf_j_ggh� hklZgh\beky� a^_kv� gZ� lZdbo� ijbf_jZo�� dhlhju_ijb\h^be� b lhedh\Ze� g_� y ieb� dlh�gb[m^v� ba� fhbo� ihke_^h\Zl_e_c�� H^gZdh� \ h[hbo� wlboijbf_jZo� ^ey� j_r_gby� ijh[e_fu� gm`_g� [ue� h^bg� g_[hevrhc� ijb_f�� GZ^h� [ueh� kijhkblv]h\hjb\r_]h�� ihq_fm� hg� k^_eZe� bf_ggh� lZdmx� h]h\hjdm� b qlh� hg� fh`_l� h g_c� kdZaZlv�� <ijhlb\ghf�kemqZ_��g_�`_eZy�__ h[tykgylv��hg�ijhr_e�[u�fbfh�g__��GZ�ihklZ\e_gguc�`_�\hijhkhg�^Ze�i_j\h_�ijbr_^r__�_fm�\ ]heh\m�h[tykg_gb_��: l_i_jv�\u�\b^bl_��qlh�wlhl�ijb_f�b _]hj_amevlZl�b _klv�ikbohZgZeba�b h[jZa_p�ex[h]h�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�bkke_^h\Zgby��dhlhjuffu�aZcf_fky�\ihke_^kl\bb�G_� kebrdhf� eb� y g_^h\_jqb\�� iheZ]Zy�� qlh� \ lhl� kZfuc� fhf_gl�� dh]^Z� m \Zk� lhevdhkdeZ^u\Z_lky� ij_^klZ\e_gb_� h ikbohZgZeba_�� ijhlb\� g_]h� `_� ih^gbfZ_lky� b ijhl_kl"� G_\hagbdZ_l� eb� m \Zk� `_eZgby� \hajZablv� fg_�� qlh� k\_^_gby�� ihemq_ggu_� hl� q_eh\_dZ�^himklb\r_]h�h]h\hjdm��g_�\iheg_�^hdZaZl_evgu"�Hl\_qZy�gZ�\hijhku��hg��dhg_qgh��klZjZeky�iheZ]Z_l_� \u�� h[tykgblv� k\hx� h]h\hjdm�� \hl� b kdZaZe� i_j\h_�� qlh� ijbreh� _fm� \ ]heh\m� bihdZaZehkv�ohlv�kdhev�gb[m^v�ijb]h^guf�^ey�h[tykg_gby��Gh�wlh�_s_�g_�^hdZaZl_evkl\h�lh]h�qlh� h]h\hjdZ� \hagbdeZ� bf_ggh� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� Dhg_qgh�� fh]eh� [ulv� b lZd�� gh� k lZdbf� `_mki_ohf�b bgZq_��?fm� \ ]heh\m�fh]eh� ijbclb� b ^jm]h_� h[tykg_gb_�� lZdh_�`_� ih^oh^ys__�� Z

Page 22: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fh`_l�[ulv��^Z`_�emqr__�M^b\bl_evgh��dZd�fZeh�m \Zk��\ kmsghklb��m\Z`_gby�d ikbobq_kdhfm�nZdlm��Ij_^klZ\vl_k_[_��qlh�dlh�lh�ijhba\_e�obfbq_kdbc�ZgZeba�\_s_kl\Z�b h[gZjm`be�\ _]h�khklZ\_�^jm]h_��\_khf\ klhevdh�lh�fbeeb]jZffh\��>Zgguc�\_k�^Z_l�\hafh`ghklv� k^_eZlv�hij_^_e_ggu_� \u\h^u��:l_i_jv� ij_^klZ\vl_�� qlh� dZdhfm�lh� obfbdm� ijbreh� \ ]heh\m� mkhfgblvky� \ wlbo� \u\h^Zo�fhlb\bjmy�wlh�l_f��qlh�\u^_e_ggh_�\_s_kl\h�fh]eh�bf_lv�b ^jm]hc�\_k��DZ`^uc�kqblZ_lky�knZdlhf��qlh�\_k�bf_ggh� lZdhc�� Z g_�^jm]hc��b m\_j_ggh� kljhbl�gZ� wlhf�^Zevg_crb_� \u\h^u�?keb�`_�gZebph�ikbobq_kdbc�nZdl��dh]^Z�q_eh\_dm�ijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m�hij_^_e_ggZy�fukev��\u�kwlbf�ihq_fm�lh�g_�kqblZ_l_kv�b ]h\hjbl_��qlh�_fm�fh]eZ�ijbclb�\ ]heh\m�b ^jm]Zy�fukev��M \Zk_klv�beexaby�ebqghc�ikbobq_kdhc�k\h[h^u��b \u�g_�ohlbl_�hl�g__�hldZaZlvky��Fg_�hq_gv�`Zev�gh�\ wlhf�y kZfuf�k_jv_aguf�h[jZahf�jZkoh`mkv�k \Zfb�\h�fg_gbyo�L_i_jv�\u�g_�klZg_l_�[hevr_�\hajZ`Zlv��gh� lhevdh�^h� l_o�ihj��ihdZ�g_�gZc^_l_�^jm]h]hijhlb\hj_qby��<u�ijh^he`bl_��fu�ihgbfZ_f��qlh�hkh[_gghklv�l_ogbdb�ikbohZgZebaZ�khklhbl�\lhf��qlh[u�aZklZ\blv�q_eh\_dZ�kZfh]h�j_rblv�k\hb�ijh[e_fu��<havf_f�^jm]hc�ijbf_j��hjZlhjijb]eZrZ_l� kh[jZ\rboky� qhdgmlvky� �hlju]gmlv�� aZ� a^hjh\v_� r_nZ�� Ih� gZrbf� keh\ZfgZjmrZxs__�gZf_j_gb_�\ wlhf�kemqZ_�²�mgbablv��hgh�b g_�^Z_l�hjZlhjm�\ujZablv�ihql_gb_��Ghwlh�\k_]h�ebrv�gZr_�lhedh\Zgb_��hkgh\Zggh_�gZ�gZ[ex^_gbyo�aZ�ij_^_eZfb�h]h\hjdb��?keb�fu\ wlhf� kemqZ_� [m^_f� jZkkijZrb\Zlv� h]h\hjb\r_]hky�� hg� g_� ih^l\_j^bl�� qlh� gZf_j_\ZekygZg_klb�hkdhj[e_gb_��[he__�lh]h��hg�[m^_l�wg_j]bqgh�wlh�hljbpZlv��Ihq_fm�`_�fu�\k_�`_�g_hldZau\Z_fky�hl�gZr_]h�g_^hdZam_fh]h�lhedh\Zgby�b ihke_�lZdh]h�q_ldh]h�\hajZ`_gby">Z��gZ�wlhl�jZa�\u�gZreb�k_jv_aguc�Zj]mf_gl��Y ij_^klZ\eyx�k_[_�g_agZdhfh]h�hjZlhjZ�\hafh`gh�� Zkkbkl_glZ� lh]h� r_nZ�� Z \hafh`gh�� m`_� ijb\Zl�^hp_glZ�� fheh^h]h� q_eh\_dZ� k[e_klysbf� [m^msbf�� Y gZklhcqb\h� klZgm� _]h� \ukijZrb\Zlv�� g_� qm\kl\h\Ze� eb� hg� ijbq_kl\h\Zgbb� r_nZ� ijhlb\hiheh`gh]h� gZf_j_gby"� Gh� \hl� y b� ihiZeky�� L_ji_gb_� _]hbklhsZ_lky�� b hg� \^jm]� gZ[jZku\Z_lky� gZ� f_gy�� ©DhgqZcl_� <u� k\hb� jZkkijhku�� bgZq_� y g_ihjmqmkv� aZ� k_[y��K\hbfb�ih^haj_gbyfb�<u�ihjlbl_�fg_�\kx�dZjv_jm��Y ijhklh�h]h\hjbeky�kdZaZe� DR\VWRMLHQ� \f_klh� DQVWRSHQ�� ihlhfm� qlh� \ wlhf� ij_^eh`_gbb� m`_� ^\Z� jZaZ� mihlj_[be��ZfH��� M F_jbg]_jZ� lZdZy� h]h\hjdZ� gZau\Z_lky� hla\mdhf�� b g_q_]h� lml� lhedh\Zlv� \djb\v� b\dhkv�� <u� f_gy� ihgyeb"� O\Zlblª�� =f�� dZdZy� m^b\bl_evgZy� j_Zdpby�� \_kvfZ� wg_j]bqgh_hljbpZgb_��K fheh^uf�q_eh\_dhf�gbq_]h�g_�ih^_eZ_rv��gh�y ijh�k_[y�^mfZx��qlh�_]h�\u^Z_lkbevgZy� ebqgZy� aZbgl_j_kh\Zgghklv� \ lhf�� qlh[u� _]h� hrb[hqghfm� ^_ckl\bx� g_� ijb^Z\ZebkfukeZ��Fh`_l�[ulv��b \Zf�ihdZ`_lky��qlh�g_ijZ\bevgh�k _]h�klhjhgu�\_klb�k_[y�lZd�]jm[h�\h\j_fy�qbklh�l_hj_lbq_kdh]h�h[ke_^h\Zgby��gh��\ dhgp_�dhgph\��ih^mfZ_l_�\u��hg�kZf�^he`_gagZlv��qlh�hg�ohl_e�kdZaZlv��Z q_]h�g_l��>he`_g�eb"�Ih`Zemc��wlh�_s_�\hijhk�Gm�� l_i_jv� \u� lhqgh� kqblZ_l_�� qlh� y m� \Zk� \ jmdZo�� LZd� \hl� dZdh\Z� \ZrZ� l_ogbdZbkke_^h\Zgby�� y keurm�� ]h\hjbl_� \u�� ?keb� k^_eZ\rbc� h]h\hjdm� ]h\hjbl� h g_c� lh�� qlh� \Zfih^oh^bl��lh�\u�hklZ\ey_l_� aZ�gbf�ijZ\h�ihke_^g_c�j_rZxs_c�bgklZgpbb�� ©Hg�\_^v�kZf� wlhkdZaZe�ª� ?keb� `_� lh�� qlh� hg� ]h\hjbl�� \Zf� g_� ]h^blky�� \u� lml� `_� aZy\ey_l_�� g_q_]h� k gbfkqblZlvky��_fm�g_evay�\_jblv�<k_� wlh� lZd�� Y fh]m� ijb\_klb� \Zf� ZgZeh]bqguc� kemqZc�� ]^_� ^_eh� h[klhbl� klhev� `_g_\_jhylgh��?keb�h[\bgy_fuc�ijbagZ_lky�km^v_�\ k\h_f�ijhklmid_��km^vy�\_jbl�_]h�ijbagZgbx�

Page 23: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gh�_keb�h[\bgy_fuc�hljbpZ_l�k\hx�\bgm��km^vy�g_�\_jbl�hfm��?keb�[u�[ueh�ih�^jm]hfm��lh�g_[ueh� [u� ijZ\hkm^by�� Z \u� \_^v� ijbagZ_l_� wlm� kbkl_fm�� g_kfhljy� gZ� bf_xsb_ky� \ i_cg_^hklZldb�>Z�� gh� jZa\_� \u� km^vy�� Z k^_eZ\rbc� h]h\hjdm� ih^km^bfuc"� JZa\_� h]h\hjdZ� ²ij_klmie_gb_"Fh`_l�[ulv��b g_�ke_^m_l�hldZau\Zlvky�hl�wlh]h�kjZ\g_gby��Gh�ihkfhljbl_�lhevdh��d dZdbfk_jv_aguf�jZagh]eZkbyf�fu�ijbreb��m]em[b\rbkv�\ lZdmx��dZaZehkv�[u��g_\bggmx�ijh[e_fm�dZd�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by��IhdZ�fu�_s_�g_�\ khklhygbb�k]eZ^blv�\k_�wlb�ijhlb\hj_qby��Y \k_�lZdb�ij_^eZ]Zx�\j_f_ggh�khojZgblv�kjZ\g_gb_�k km^v_c�b ih^km^bfuf��Kh]eZkbl_kv��qlh�kfukehrb[hqgh]h�^_ckl\by�g_�\uau\Z_l�khfg_gby��_keb�ZgZebabjm_fuc�kZf�ijbagZ_l�_]h��AZlh�b y^he`_g� kh]eZkblvky� k \Zfb��qlh�g_evay�ij_^klZ\blv�ijyfh]h�^hdZaZl_evkl\Z�ij_^iheZ]Z_fh]hkfukeZ� hrb[hqgh]h� ^_ckl\by�� _keb� ZgZebabjm_fuc� hldZau\Z_lky� khh[sblv� dZdb_�eb[hk\_^_gby� beb�`_� hg� ijhklh� hlkmlkl\m_l��< lZdbo� kemqZyo� lZd�`_�� dZd� b \� km^hijhba\h^kl\_�ijb[_]Zxl� d dhk\_gguf� mebdZf�� dhlhju_� iha\heyxl� k^_eZlv� [he__� beb� f_g__� \_jhylgh_aZdexq_gb_��GZ�hkgh\Zgbb�dhk\_gguo�mebd�km^�bgh]^Z�ijbagZ_l�ih^km^bfh]h�\bgh\guf��M gZkg_l�lZdhc�g_h[oh^bfhklb��gh�b gZf�g_�ke_^m_l�hldZau\Zlvky�hl�bkihevah\Zgby�lZdbo�mebd��;ueh[u� hrb[dhc�ij_^iheZ]Zlv�� qlh� gZmdZ� khklhbl� lhevdh� ba� kljh]h� ^hdZaZgguo�iheh`_gbc�� ^Z� bg_ijZ\bevgh�hl�g__�wlh]h�lj_[h\Zlv��LZdb_�lj_[h\Zgby�d gZmd_�fh`_l�ij_^ty\eylv�lhevdh�lhl�dlh�bs_l�Z\lhjbl_lh\�b hsmsZ_l�ihlj_[ghklv�aZf_gblv�k\hc�j_eb]bhaguc�dZl_obabk�gZ�^jm]hc�ohly�[u�b gZmqguc��GZmdZ�gZkqblu\Z_l�\ k\h_f�dZl_obabk_�fZeh�Zih^bdlbq_kdbo�iheh`_gbc��\g_c�[hevr_�ml\_j`^_gbc��bf_xsbo�hij_^_e_ggmx�kl_i_gv�\_jhylghklb��IjbagZdhf�gZmqgh]hfure_gby�dZd�jZa�b y\ey_lky� kihkh[ghklv�^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky�ebrv�ijb[eb`_gb_f�d bklbg_�bijh^he`Zlv�l\hjq_kdmx�jZ[hlm��g_kfhljy�gZ�hlkmlkl\b_�hdhgqZl_evguo�ih^l\_j`^_gbc�GZ�qlh�`_�gZf�hi_j_lvky�\ k\h_f�lhedh\Zgbb��]^_�gZclb�dhk\_ggu_�mebdb��_keb�ihdZaZgbyZgZebabjm_fh]h�g_�jZkdju\Zxl�kfukeZ�hrb[hqgh]h�^_ckl\by"�< jZaguo�f_klZo��KgZqZeZ�[m^_fbkoh^blv�ba�ZgZeh]bb�k y\e_gbyfb��g_�k\yaZggufb�k hrb[hqgufb�^_ckl\byfb��gZijbf_j��dh]^Zfu�ml\_j`^Z_f��qlh�bkdZ`_gb_�bf_g�ijb�h]h\hjd_�bf__l�lhl�`_�mgb`Zxsbc�kfuke��dZd�b ijbgZf_j_gghf�dh\_jdZgbc�bf_gb��>Ze__�fu�[m^_f�bkoh^blv�ba�ikbobq_kdhc�kblmZpbb��\ dhlhjhckh\_jrZ_lky� hrb[hqgh_� ^_ckl\b_�� ba� agZgby� oZjZdl_jZ� q_eh\_dZ�� kh\_jrb\r_]h� hrb[hqgh_^_ckl\b_�� ba� l_o� \i_qZle_gbc�� dhlhju_� hg� ihemqbe� ^h� hrb[hqgh]h� ^_ckl\by�� \hafh`gh�� qlhbf_ggh�gZ�gbo�hg�b j_Z]bjh\Ze�wlbf�hrb[hqguf�^_ckl\b_f��H[uqgh�fu�lhedm_f�hrb[hqgh_^_ckl\b_�� bkoh^y� ba� h[sbo� khh[jZ`_gbc�� b \ukdZau\Z_f� kgZqZeZ� lhevdh� ij_^iheh`_gb_�]bihl_am� ^ey� lhedh\Zgby�� Z aZl_f�� bkke_^my� ikbobq_kdmx� kblmZpbx� ^himklb\r_]h� hrb[dm�gZoh^bf� _fm� ih^l\_j`^_gb_�� Bgh]^Z� ijboh^blky� `^Zlv� kh[ulbc�� dZd� [u� ij_^kdZaZgguohrb[hqguf�^_ckl\b_f��qlh[u�gZclb�ih^l\_j`^_gb_�gZr_fm�ij_^iheh`_gbx�?keb�y h]jZgbqmkv�h^ghc�lhevdh�h[eZklvx�h]h\hjhd��y _^\Z�eb�kmf_x�klhev�`_�e_]dh�gZclbgm`gu_� ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z�� ohly� b a^_kv� _klv� hl^_evgu_� \i_qZleyxsb_� ijbf_ju�� Fheh^hcq_eh\_d��dhlhjuc�ohl_e�[u�EHJ�OHLWGLJHQ�^Zfm��gZ\_jgydZ�jh[dbc��^Zfm��fm`�dhlhjhc�_kl�b iv_llh��qlh�hgZ� ohq_l�� y agZx� dZd�h^gm�ba� l_o� wg_j]bqguo�`_gsbg�� dhlhju_� mf_xl� dhfZg^h\Zlv\k_f�\ ^hf_��Beb�\havf_f�lZdhc�ijbf_j��gZ�h[s_f�kh[jZgbb�©Dhgdhj^bbª�fheh^hc�qe_g�wlh]hh[s_kl\Z�ijhbaghkbl�]hjyqmx�hiihabpbhggmx�j_qv��\h�\j_fy�dhlhjhc�hg�h[jZsZ_lky�d qe_gZf

Page 24: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijZ\e_gby�� gZau\Zy� bo� ©� 9RUVFKX�67DLWJOLHGHUª� >qe_gu� kkm^u@�� keh\hf�� dhlhjh_� fh`_lihemqblvky�ba�kebygby�keh\�)RUVWDQG�>ijZ\e_gb_@�b $XVVFKXIW�>dhfbkkby@��Fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f��qlhm g_]h�\hagbdeh�gZjmrZxs__�gZf_j_gb_��ijhlb\hj_qZs__�_]h�hiihabpbhgguf�\ukdZau\Zgbyfb dhlhjh_� fh]eh� [ulv� k\yaZgh� kh� kkm^hc�� >_ckl\bl_evgh�� \kdhj_� fu� magZ_f�� qlh� hjZlhjihklhyggh� gm`^Zeky� \ ^_gv]Zo� b g_aZ^he]h� ^h� lh]h� ih^Ze� ijhr_gb_� h kkm^_�� GZjmrZxs__gZf_j_gb_�^_ckl\bl_evgh�fh]eh�\ujZablvky�\ lZdhc�fukeb��k^_j`bkv�\ k\h_c�hiihabpbb��wlh\_^v�ex^b��dhlhju_�jZaj_rZl�l_[_�\u^Zqm�kkm^u�Y kfh]m�ijb\_klb�\Zf�p_euc�jy^�lZdbo�mebqZxsbo�^hdZaZl_evkl\��dh]^Z�i_j_c^m�d ^jm]bfhrb[hqguf�^_ckl\byf�?keb� dlh�lh� aZ[u\Z_l� ohjhrh� ba\_klgh_� _fm� bfy� b k� ljm^hf� _]h� aZihfbgZ_l�� lh�fh`ghij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� ijhlb\� ghkbl_ey� wlh]h� bf_gb� hg� qlh�lh� bf__l� b g_� ohq_l� h g_f� ^mfZlv�JZkkfhljbf�ikbobq_kdmx�kblmZpbx��\ dhlhjhc�ijhbkoh^bl�wlh�hrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\b_��©=hkih^bgM [ue� [_agZ^_`gh� \ex[e_g� \ ^Zfm�� dhlhjZy� \kdhj_� \uoh^bl� aZfm`� aZ� ]hkih^bgZ ;�� Ohly]hkih^bg <�^Z\gh�agZ_l�]hkih^bgZ�O b�^Z`_�bf__l�k gbf�^_eh\u_�k\yab��hg�\k_�\j_fy�aZ[u\Z_l_]h�nZfbebx� b \kydbc� jZa�� dh]^Z� ^he`_g� ibkZlv� _fm� ih� ^_em�� kijZ\ey_lky� h _]h�nZfbebb� m^jm]boª� ��Hq_\b^gh��]hkih^bg�<�g_�ohq_l�gbq_]h�agZlv�h kqZkleb\hf�khi_jgbd_��©B ^mfZlv�hg_f�g_�ohqmª� �Ih�D��=��Xg]m �����������Beb�^jm]hc�ijbf_j��^ZfZ�kijZ\ey_lky�m \jZqZ�h a^hjh\v_�h[s_c�agZdhfhc��gZau\Zy�__ ih^_\bqv_c� nZfbebb�� ?_� nZfbebx� ih� fm`m� hgZ� aZ[ueZ�� AZl_f� hgZ� ijbagZ_lky�� qlh� hq_gvg_^h\hevgZ�wlbf�aZfm`_kl\hf�b g_�\ughkbl�fm`Z�k\h_c�ih^jm]b� �Fu� _s_� \_jg_fky� d aZ[u\Zgbx� bf_g� b h[km^bf� wlh� k jZaguo� klhjhg�� k_cqZk� `_� gZkbgl_j_km_l�ij_bfms_kl\_ggh�ikbobq_kdZy�kblmZpby��\ dhlhjhc�ijhbkoh^bl�aZ[u\Zgb_�AZ[u\Zgb_�gZf_j_gbc� \ h[s_f�fh`gh�h[tykgblv�ihlhdhf�ijhlb\hiheh`guo�gZf_j_gbc�dhlhju_� g_� iha\heyxl� \uihegblv� i_j\hgZqZevgh_� gZf_j_gb_�� LZd� ^mfZ_f� g_� lhevdh� fu�aZgbfZxsb_ky�ikbohZgZebahf��wlb�h[s_ijbgylh_�fg_gb_�ex^_c��dhlhju_�ijb^_j`b\Zxlky�_]h\ `bagb��gh�ihq_fm�lh�hljbpZxl�\ l_hjbb��Ihdjh\bl_ev��ba\bgyxsbcky�i_j_^�ijhkbl_e_f�aZ�lh�qlh� aZ[ue� \uihegblv� _]h�ijhkv[m�� _^\Z� eb�[m^_l� hijZ\^Zg� \ _]h� ]eZaZo��Ijhkbl_ev� kjZam�`_ih^mfZ_l�� _fm� \_^v� kh\_jr_ggh� \k_� jZ\gh��ohly� hg� h[_sZe��hg�gbq_]h�g_� k^_eZe��B \�`bagbaZ[u\Zgb_� lh`_� kqblZ_lky� \ ba\_klghf� hlghr_gbb� ij_^hkm^bl_evguf�� jZaebqbc� f_`^m`bl_ckdhc� b ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� lhqdhc� aj_gby� gZ� wlb� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by�� ih�\b^bfhfm�g_l��Ij_^klZ\vl_�k_[_�ohaycdm��dhlhjZy�\klj_qZ_l�]hkly�keh\Zfb��©DZd��<u�ijbreb�k_]h^gy"�: yb aZ[ueZ�� qlh� ijb]eZkbeZ� <Zk� gZ� k_]h^gyª�� Beb� fheh^h]h� q_eh\_dZ�� dhlhjuc� ijbagZeky� [u\haex[e_gghc�� qlh� hg� aZ[ue� h gZagZq_gghf� k\b^Zgbb��Dhg_qgh�� hg� \ wlhf� g_� ijbagZ_lky�� Zkdhj__� ijb^mfZ_l� kZfu_� g_\_jhylgu_� h[klhyl_evkl\Z�� dhlhju_� g_� iha\hebeb� _fm� ijbclb� gZk\b^Zgb_�b ^Z`_�g_�^Zeb�\hafh`ghklb�ij_^mij_^blv�h[�wlhf��GZ�\h_gghc�kem`[_��dZd�\k_�agZxlb kqblZxl�kijZ\_^eb\uf��aZ[uqb\hklv�g_�y\ey_lky�hijZ\^Zgb_f�b g_�hk\h[h`^Z_l�hl�gZdZaZgby�A^_kv�ihq_fm�lh�\k_�kh]eZkgu��qlh�hij_^_e_ggh_�hrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\bb_�bf__l� kfuke��ijbq_f\k_� agZxl�dZdhc��Ihq_fm�`_�g_evay�[ulv�^h�dhgpZ�ihke_^h\Zl_evguf�b g_�ijbagZlv��qlh�b d^jm]bf� hrb[hqguf� ^_ckl\byf� ^he`gh� [ulv� lZdh_� `_� hlghr_gb_"� GZijZrb\Z_lky

Page 25: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

_kl_kl\_gguc�hl\_l�?keb�kfuke�wlh]h�aZ[u\Zgby�gZf_j_gbc�klhev�hq_\b^_g�^Z`_�^ey�g_ki_pbZebklZ��lh�\u�g_[m^_l_�m^b\eylvky�lhfm��qlh�b ibkZl_eb�bkihevamxl�wlh�hrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\b_�\ lhf�`_�kfuke_�Dlh�ba�\Zk�qblZe�beb�\b^_e�iv_km�;��Rhm�P_aZjv�b De_hiZljZ�� lhl�ihfgbl��qlh� \ ihke_^g_ckp_g_�i_j_^�hlt_a^hf�P_aZjy�ij_ke_^m_l�fukev��[m^lh�hg�gZf_j_\Zeky�qlh�lh� k^_eZlv�� h q_fl_i_jv� aZ[ue�� < dhgp_� dhgph\� hdZau\Z_lky�� qlh� hg� aZ[ue� ihijhsZlvky� k De_hiZljhc�� WlhcfZe_gvdhc�kp_ghc�ibkZl_ev�ohq_l�ijbibkZlv�\_ebdhfm�P_aZjx�ij_bfms_kl\h��dhlhjuf�hg�g_h[eZ^Ze�b d�dhlhjhfm�kh\k_f�g_�klj_fbeky��Ba�bklhjbq_kdbo�bklhqgbdh\�\u�fh`_l_�magZlv��qlhP_aZjv�aZklZ\be�De_hiZljm�ihke_^h\Zlv�aZ�gbf�\ Jbf��b hgZ�`beZ�lZf�k fZe_gvdbf�P_aZjbhghf�ihdZ�P_aZjv�g_�[ue�m[bl��ihke_�q_]h�_c�ijbrehkv�[_`Zlv�ba�]hjh^Z�KemqZb�aZ[u\Zgby�gZf_j_gbc�\ h[s_f�gZklhevdh�ykgu��qlh�fZeh�ih^oh^yl�^ey�gZr_c�p_ebihemqblv� dhk\_ggu_� mebdb� ^ey� h[tykg_gby� kfukeZ� hrb[hqgh]h� ^_ckl\by� ba� ikbobq_kdhckblmZpbb��Ihwlhfm�h[jZlbfky�d �Ih�:��:��;_jbeem�������������hkh[_ggh� fgh]hagZqguf� b fZehihgylguf� hrb[hqguf� ^_ckl\byf� ²� d aZl_jb\Zgbx� baZijylu\Zgbx�\_s_c��<Zf�� dhg_qgh��ihdZ`_lky�g_\_jhylguf��qlh� \ aZl_jb\Zgbb�� dhlhjh_�fuqZklh�\hkijbgbfZ_f�dZd�^hkZ^gmx�kemqZcghklv��mqZkl\m_l�dZdh_�lh�gZr_�gZf_j_gb_��Gh�fh`ghijb\_klb�fgh`_kl\h� gZ[ex^_gbc� \jh^_� ke_^mxs_]h��Fheh^hc� q_eh\_d� ihl_jye� ^hjh]hc� ^eyi_]h�dZjZg^Zr��AZ�^_gv�^h�wlh]h�hg�ihemqbe�ibkvfh�hl�rmjbgZ��dhlhjh_�aZdZgqb\Zehkv�keh\Zfb�©M f_gy�g_l�`_eZgby�ihl\hjkl\h\Zlv�l\h_fm�e_]dhfukebx�b e_gbª� ��DZjZg^Zr�[ue�ih^Zjdhfwlh]h�rmjbgZ��;_a�lZdh]h�kh\iZ^_gby�fu��dhg_qgh��g_�fh]eb�[u�ml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�\ aZl_jb\ZgbbdZjZg^ZrZ� mqZkl\m_l� gZf_j_gb_� ba[Z\blvky� hl� \_sb�� :gZeh]bqgu_� kemqZb� hq_gv� qZklu�AZl_jb\Zxlky�ij_^f_lu��dh]^Z�ihkkhjbrvky�k l_f��dlh�bo�^Ze�b h�dhf�g_ijbylgh�\kihfbgZlv�beb�dh]^Z�kZfb�\_sb�i_j_klZxl�gjZ\blvky�b bs_rv�ij_^eh]Z�aZf_gblv�bo�^jm]bfb��emqrbfb�Ijhy\e_gb_f�lZdh]h�`_�gZf_j_gby�ih�hlghr_gbx�d ij_^f_lm�\uklmiZ_l�b lh��qlh�_]h�jhgyxl�jZa[b\Zxl�� ehfZxl�� Fh`gh� eb� kqblZlv� kemqZcghklvx�� qlh� dZd� jZa� gZdZgmg_� k\h_]h� ^gyjh`^_gby�rdhevgbd�l_jy_l��ihjlbl��ehfZ_l�gm`gu_�_fm�\_sb��gZijbf_j�jZg_p�beb�dZjfZggu_qZku"Lhl��dlh�i_j_`be�fgh]h�g_ijbylgh]h�ba�aZ�lh]h��qlh�g_�fh]�gZclb�\_sv��dhlhjmx�kZf�`_dm^Z�lh� aZeh`be��\jy^�eb�ih\_jbl��qlh�hi� k^_eZe� wlh�gZf_j_ggh��B \k_�lZdb�g_j_^db� kemqZb�dh]^Z� h[klhyl_evkl\Z�� khijh\h`^Zxsb_� aZijylu\Zgb_�� k\b^_l_evkl\mxl� h gZf_j_gbbba[Z\blvky�hl�ij_^f_lZ�gZ�dhjhldh_�ieb�^he]h_�\j_fy��<hl�emqrbc�ijbf_j�lZdh]h�jh^Z�Fheh^hc� q_eh\_d� jZkkdZau\Z_l�fg_�� ©G_kdhevdh� e_l� lhfm� gZaZ^� m f_gy� [ueb� k_f_cgu_g_mjy^bpu�� y kqblZe� k\hx� `_gm� kebrdhf� oheh^ghc�� b�� ohly� y ijbagZ\Ze� __ ij_djZkgu_dZq_kl\Z��fu�`beb�[_a�g_`guo�qm\kl\�^jm]�d ^jm]m��H^gZ`^u�hgZ�ih^ZjbeZ�fg_�dgb]m��dhlhjmxdmibeZ� \h� \j_fy� ijh]medb� b kqblZeZ� bgl_j_kghc� ^ey� f_gy�� Y ih[eZ]h^Zjbe� aZ� wlhl� agZd��\gbfZgby��� h[_sZe�ijhq_klv� dgb]m�� kijylZe� __ b�g_�fh]�ihlhf�gZclb��LZd�ijhreb�f_kypu�bgh]^Z� y \kihfbgZe� h[� bkq_agm\r_c� dgb]_� b gZijZkgh� iulZeky� gZclb� __�� Ihe]h^Z� kimklyaZ[he_eZ�fhy�ex[bfZy�fZlv��dhlhjZy�`beZ�hl^_evgh�hl�gZk��Fhy�`_gZ�m_oZeZ��qlh[u�moZ`b\ZlvaZ�k\_djh\vx��Khklhygb_�[hevghc�[ueh�ly`_eh_��`_gZ�ihdZaZeZ�k_[y�k kZfhc�emqr_c�klhjhgu�

Page 26: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

H^gZ`^u�\_q_jhf��ho\Zq_gguc�[eZ]h^Zjgufb�qm\kl\Zfb�d `_g_��y \_jgmeky�^hfhc��hldjue�[_ahij_^_e_ggh]h�gZf_j_gby��gh�dZd�[u�k khfgZf[mebq_kdhc�m\_j_gghklvx�hij_^_e_gguc�ysbdibkvf_ggh]h�klheZ�b k\_jom�gZr_e�^Z\gh�bkq_agm\rmx�aZijylZggmx�dgb]mª��Bkq_aeZ�ijbqbgZ�b ijhiZ`Z�gZreZkv�M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��Y fh]�[u�ijh^he`blv�wlhl�jy^�ijbf_jh\��Gh�y g_�[m^m�wlh]h^_eZlv�� < fh_c� dgb]_� ©IkbohiZlheh]by� h[u^_gghc� `bagbª� �\i_j\u_� \ureZ� \ ����� ]��� \ugZc^_l_� [h]Zluc� fZl_jbZe� ^ey� bamq_gby� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc� �� <k_� wlb� ijbf_juk\b^_l_evkl\mxl� h[� h^ghf�� Z bf_ggh� h lhf�� qlh� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by� bf_xl� k\hc� kfuke�� bihdZau\Zxl��dZd�wlhl�kfuke�fh`gh�magZlv�beb�ih^l\_j^blv�ih�khiml� �Ih�;��>Zllg_jm� �LZd`_�\ khqbg_gbyo�:��F_^_jZ �������������:��:��;jbeeZ���������W��>`hgkZ���������B��Rl_jg_��������b ^j�kl\mxsbf�h[klhyl_evkl\Zf��K_]h^gy�y [m^m�djZlhd��ihkdhevdm�fu�^he`gu�ijb�bamq_gbbwlbo� y\e_gbc� ihemqblv� g_h[oh^bfu_� k\_^_gby� ^ey� ih^]hlh\db� d ikbohZgZebam�� Y gZf_j_ghklZgh\blvky� lhevdh� gZ� ^\mo� ]jmiiZo� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc�� ih\lhjyxsboky� bdhf[bgbjh\Zgguo��b gZ�ih^l\_j`^_gbb�gZr_]h�lhedh\Zgby�ihke_^mxsbfb�kh[ulbyfb�Ih\lhjyxsb_ky�b dhf[bgbjh\Zggu_�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�y\eyxlky�k\h_]h�jh^Z�\_jrbghcwlh]h� \b^Z� ^_ckl\bc�� ?keb� [u� gZf� ijbrehkv� ^hdZau\Zlv�� qlh� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by� bf_xlkfuke��fu�[u�bf_ggh�bfb�b h]jZgbqbebkv��lZd�dZd�bo�kfuke�hq_\b^_g�^Z`_�h]jZgbq_gghfm�mfmb kZfhfm� ijb^bjqb\hfm� djblbdm�� Ih\lhjy_fhklv� ijhy\e_gbc� h[gZjm`b\Z_l� mklhcqb\hklv�dhlhjmx� ihqlb� gbdh]^Z� g_evay� ijbibkZlv� kemqZcghklb�� gh� fh`gh� h[tykgblvij_^gZf_j_gghklvx�� GZdhg_p�� aZf_gZ� hl^_evguo� \b^h\� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc� ^jm]� ^jm]hfk\b^_l_evkl\m_l�h lhf��qlh�kZfuf�\Z`guf�b kms_kl\_gguf�\ hrb[hqghf�^_ckl\bb�y\ey_lky�g_nhjfZ�beb�kj_^kl\Z��dhlhjufb�hgh�ihevam_lky��Z gZf_j_gb_��dhlhjhfm�hgh�kem`bl�b dhlhjh_^he`gh� [ulv� j_Zebah\Zgh� kZfufb� jZaebqgufb� imlyfb�� Ohqm� ijb\_klb� \Zf� ijbf_jih\lhjyxs_]hky�aZ[u\Zgby��W��>`hgk� ������������jZkkdZau\Z_l��qlh�h^gZ`^u�ih�g_ba\_klgufijbqbgZf� \ l_q_gb_� g_kdhevdbo� ^g_c� hg� aZ[u\Ze� ibkvfh� gZ� ibkvf_gghf� klhe_�� GZdhg_p�j_rbeky� _]h� hlijZ\blv�� gh� ihemqbe� hl� ©'HDG� OHWWHU� RIILFHª� h[jZlgh�� lZd� dZd� aZ[ue� gZibkZlvZ^j_k��GZibkZ\�Z^j_k��hg�ijbg_k�ibkvfh�gZ�ihqlm��gh�hdZaZehkv��qlh�aZ[ue�gZde_blv�fZjdm��Lmlm`�hg�[ue�\ugm`^_g�ijbagZlv��qlh�\hh[s_�g_�ohl_e�hlijZ\eylv�wlh�ibkvfh�< ^jm]hf� kemqZ_� aZo\Zlu\Zgb_� \_s_c� ©ih� hrb[d_ª� �9HUJUHLIHQ�� dhf[bgbjm_lky� kaZijylu\Zgb_f��H^gZ�^ZfZ�kh\_jrZ_l�kh�k\hbf�rmjbghf��ba\_klguf�Zjlbklhf��iml_r_kl\b_�\Jbf�� ?fm� hdZau\Z_lky� kZfuc� lhj`_kl\_gguc� ijb_f� `b\msbfb� \ Jbf_� g_fpZfb�� b kj_^bijhq_]h�hg�ihemqZ_l�\ ih^Zjhd�ahehlmx�Zglbqgmx�f_^Zev��>ZfZ�[ueZ�aZ^_lZ�l_f��qlh�rmjbg�g_fh`_l� hp_gblv� ij_djZkgmx� \_sv� ih� ^hklhbgkl\m�� Ihke_� lh]h� dZd� __ kf_gbeZ� k_kljZ� b hgZ\_jgmeZkv�^hfhc��jZkiZdh\u\Zy�\_sb��hgZ�h[gZjm`beZ��qlh�\ayeZ�f_^Zev�k kh[hc��kZfZ�g_�agZydZd��HgZ�lml�`_�gZibkZeZ�h[�wlhf�rmjbgm�b aZ\_jbeZ�_]h��qlh�gZ�ke_^mxsbc�`_�^_gv�hlijZ\blg_qZyggh� ihiZ\rmx� d g_c� f_^Zev� \ Jbf�� Gh� gZ� ke_^mxsbc� ^_gv� f_^Zev� [ueZ� dm^Z�lh� lZdaZijylZgZ��qlh�__�g_evay�[ueh�gZclb�b hlijZ\blv��b lh]^Z�^ZfZ�gZqZeZ�^h]Z^u\Zlvky��qlh�agZqbl__ ©jZkk_ygghklvª�²�ijhklh�_c�ohl_ehkv�hklZ\blv�f_^Zev�m k_[y� �

Page 27: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Y m`_� ijb\h^be� \Zf� ijbf_j� dhf[bgZpbb� aZ[u\Zgby� k hrb[dhc� �,Q�WXUQ��� dh]^Z� dlh�lhkgZqZeZ� aZ[u\Z_l�h k\b^Zgbb�� Z ihlhf� k l\_j^uf�gZf_j_gb_f�g_� aZ[ulv�h g_f� y\ey_lky�g_� dmkeh\e_gghfm�qZkm��Z \�^jm]h_�\j_fy��Kh\_jr_ggh�ZgZeh]bqguc�kemqZc�ba�kh[kl\_gghc�`bagbjZkkdZau\Ze�fg_�fhc�^jm]��dhlhjuc�aZgbfZeky�g_�lhevdh�gZmdhc��gh�b ebl_jZlmjhc��©G_kdhevdhe_l�lhfm�gZaZ^�y kh]eZkbeky�\klmiblv�\ dhfbkkbx�h^gh]h�ebl_jZlmjgh]h�h[s_kl\Z��ij_^iheZ]Zy�qlh�hgh�ihfh`_l�fg_�ihklZ\blv�fhx�^jZfm��DZ`^mx�iylgbpm�y ihy\eyeky�gZ�aZk_^Zgbb��ohly�b[_a�hkh[h]h�bgl_j_kZ��G_kdhevdh�f_kyp_\�lhfm�gZaZ^�y ihemqbe�m\_� �Ih�J��J_cle_jm������^hfe_gb_� h ihklZgh\d_� fh_c� iv_ku� \ l_Zlj_� \ N��� b k� l_o� ihj� y ihklhyggh� aZ[u\Zx� haZk_^Zgbyo�wlh]h�h[s_kl\Z��Dh]^Z�y ijhqblZe�<Zrm�dgb]m�h[�wlbo�y\e_gbyo��fg_�klZeh�klu^ghfh_c�aZ[u\qb\hklb��y mij_dZe�k_[y��qlh�wlh�ih^ehklv�²�g_�y\eylvky�gZ�aZk_^Zgby�ihke_�lh]h�dZd�ex^b�i_j_klZeb�[ulv�gm`gu��b j_rbe�gb�\ dh_f�kemqZ_�g_�aZ[ulv�ijh�[eb`Zcrmx�iylgbpm�Y \k_�\j_fy�gZihfbgZe�k_[_�h[�wlhf�gZf_j_gbb��ihdZ��gZdhg_p��g_�\uihegbe�_]h�b g_�hqmlbekyi_j_^� ^\_jvx� aZeZ� aZk_^Zgbc��Gh�� d fh_fm� m^b\e_gbx�� hgZ� hdZaZeZkv� aZdjulhc�� Z aZk_^Zgb_aZ\_jr_gguf��ihlhfm�qlh�y hrb[ky�\ ^g_��[ueZ�m`_�km[[hlZ�ª<_kvfZ� kh[eZagbl_evgh� kh[bjZlv�ih^h[gu_�gZ[ex^_gby��gh�gm`gh�b^lb�^Zevr_��Y ohqmihdZaZlv�\Zf�ijbf_ju��\ dhlhjuo�gZr_�lhedh\Zgb_�ih^l\_j`^Z_lky�\ [m^ms_f�Hkgh\ghc�oZjZdl_jghc�hkh[_gghklvx�wlbo�kemqZ_\�y\ey_lky�lh��qlh�gZklhysZy�ikbobq_kdZykblmZpby�gZf�g_ba\_klgZ�beb�g_^hklmigZ�gZr_fm�ZgZebam��Lh]^Z�gZr_�lhedh\Zgb_�ijbh[j_lZ_loZjZdl_j�lhevdh�ij_^iheh`_gby��dhlhjhfm�fu�b kZfb�g_�ohlbf�ijb^Z\Zlv�[hevrh]h�agZq_gby�Gh� iha^g__� ijhbkoh^yl� kh[ulby�� ihdZau\Zxsb_�� gZkdhevdh� kijZ\_^eb\h� [ueh� gZr_i_j\hgZqZevgh_�lhedh\Zgb_��DZd�lh�jZa�y [ue�\ ]hklyo�m gh\h[jZqguo�b keurZe��dZd�fheh^Zy`_gZ�kh�kf_ohf�jZkkdZau\ZeZ�h g_^Z\gh�ijhbkr_^r_f�k g_c�kemqZ_��gZ�ke_^mxsbc�^_gv�ihke_\ha\jZs_gby� ba� k\Z^_[gh]h� iml_r_kl\by� hgZ� ijb]eZkbeZ� k\hx� g_aZfm`gxx� k_kljm�� qlh[uihclb�k g_c��dZd�b jZgvr_��aZ�ihdmidZfb��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�fm`�mr_e�ih�k\hbf�^_eZf��<^jm]�gZ^jm]hc� klhjhg_� mebpu� hgZ� aZf_qZ_l�fm`qbgm� b�� ih^lZedb\Zy� k_kljm�� ]h\hjbl�� ©Kfhljb�� \hgb^_l�]hkih^bg�E�ª��HgZ�aZ[ueZ��qlh�wlhl�]hkih^bg�m`_�g_kdhevdh�g_^_ev�[ue�__ fm`_f��Fg_klZeh�g_�ih�k_[_�hl�lZdh]h�jZkkdZaZ��gh�y g_�j_rbeky�k^_eZlv�^he`guc�\u\h^��Y \kihfgbe�wlhlfZe_gvdbc�wibah^�kimkly�]h^u��ihke_�lh]h�dZd�wlhl�[jZd�aZdhgqbeky�kZfuf�i_qZevguf�h[jZahf�:�� F_^_j� jZkkdZau\Z_l� h[� h^ghc� ^Zf_�� dhlhjZy� aZ� ^_gv� ^h� k\Z^v[u� aZ[ueZ� ihf_jblvk\Z^_[gh_�ieZlv_�b��d m`Zkm� k\h_c�fh^bkldb��\kihfgbeZ�h[� wlhf� lhevdh�iha^gh�\_q_jhf��Hgijb\h^bl�wlhl�ijbf_j�aZ[u\Zgby�\ k\yab�k l_f��qlh�\kdhj_�ihke_�wlh]h�hgZ�jZa\_eZkv�kh�k\hbffm`_f��Y agZx�h^gm�l_i_jv�m`_�jZa\_^_ggmx�^Zfm��dhlhjZy��mijZ\eyy�k\hbf�khklhygb_f��qZklhih^ibku\ZeZ� ^hdmf_glu� k\h_c� ^_\bqv_c� nZfbeb_c� aZ� g_kdhevdh� e_l� ^h� lh]h�� dZd� hgZ� __^_ckl\bl_evgh� ijbgyeZ�� Y agZx� ^jm]bo� `_gsbg�� ihl_jy\rbo� h[jmqZevgh_� dhevph� \h� \j_fyk\Z^_[gh]h�iml_r_kl\by��b agZx�lZd`_��qlh�bo�kmijm`_kdZy�`bagv�ijb^ZeZ�wlhc�kemqZcghklbk\hc�kfuke��: \hl�yjdbc�ijbf_j�k [he__�ijbylguf�bkoh^hf��H[�h^ghf�ba\_klghf�g_f_pdhfobfbd_�jZkkdZau\Zxl��qlh�_]h�[jZd�g_�khklhyeky�ihlhfm��qlh�hg�aZ[ue�h qZk_�\_gqZgby�b \f_klhp_jd\b�ihr_e�\ eZ[hjZlhjbx��Hg�[ue�lZd�mf_g��qlh�h]jZgbqbeky�wlhc�h^ghc�ihiuldhc�b mf_johehklydhf�\ ]em[hdhc�klZjhklb�

Page 28: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Fh`_l�[ulv��\Zf�lh`_�ijbreh�\ ]heh\m��qlh�\ wlbo�ijbf_jZo�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�b]jZxljhev�dZdh]h�lh�agZdZ�beb�ij_^agZf_gh\Zgby�^j_\gbo��B ^_ckl\bl_evgh��qZklv�wlbo�agZdh\�[ueZg_�q_f�bguf��dZd�hrb[hqguf�^_ckl\b_f��dh]^Z��gZijbf_j��dlh�lh�kihludZeky�beb�iZ^Ze��>jm]Zy`_� qZklv� ghkbeZ� oZjZdl_j� h[t_dlb\gh]h� kh[ulby�� Z g_� km[t_dlb\gh]h� ^_ygby�� Gh� \u� g_ih\_jbl_�� dZd� ljm^gh� bgh]^Z� \ dZ`^hf� dhgdj_lghf� kemqZ_� hij_^_eblv�� d dZdhc� ]jmii_� _]hhlg_klb��>_ygb_�lZd�qZklh�mf__l�fZkdbjh\Zlvky�ih^�iZkkb\gh_�i_j_`b\Zgb_�DZ`^uc�ba�gZk��h]ey^u\Zykv�gZ�^he]bc�`bag_gguc�imlv��fh`_l��\_jhylgh��kdZaZlv��qlh�hgba[_`Ze�[u�fgh]bo�jZahqZjh\Zgbc�b [he_ag_gguo�ihljyk_gbc��_keb�[u�gZr_e�\ k_[_�kf_ehklvlhedh\Zlv�f_edb_�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�\ h[s_gbb�k ex^vfb�dZd�ij_^agZf_gh\Zgb_�b hp_gb\Zlvbo� dZd� agZd� _s_� kdjuluo� gZf_j_gbc�� QZs_� \k_]h� gZ� wlh� g_� hl\Z`b\Zxlky�� \hagbdZ_l\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�kgh\Z�klZgh\brvky�km_\_jguf�²�l_i_jv�m`_�hdhevguf�iml_f��q_j_a�gZmdm��Gh\_^v� g_� \k_�ij_^agZf_gh\Zgby� k[u\Zxlky�� Z ba� gZr_c� l_hjbb� \u� ihcf_l_�� qlh� g_� \k_� hgb� b^he`gu�k[u\Zlvky�Q?L<?JL:Y�E?DPBYHrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�hdhgqZgb_�M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��< j_amevlZl_�gZrbo�ijhreuo�[_k_^�fu�ijbreb�d \u\h^m��qlhhrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by� bf_xl� kfuke� ²� wlh� fu� b \havf_f� aZ� hkgh\m� gZrbo� ^Zevg_crbobkke_^h\Zgbc��Ke_^m_l�_s_�jZa�ih^q_jdgmlv��qlh�fu�g_�ml\_j`^Z_f�²�^Z�b ^ey�gZrbo�p_e_cg_l�\ wlhf�gbdZdhc�g_h[oh^bfhklb�²�qlh�ex[h_�hrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\b_�bf__l�kfuke��ohly� wlhdZ`_lky� fg_� \_kvfZ� \_jhylguf�� GZf� ^hklZlhqgh� lh]h�� qlh� lZdhc� kfuke� h[gZjm`b\Z_lkyhlghkbl_evgh� qZklh� \ jZaebqguo� nhjfZo� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc�� < wlhf� hlghr_gbb� wlbjZaebqgu_�nhjfu�ij_^iheZ]Zxl�b jZaebqgu_�h[tykg_gby��ijb�h]h\hjd_��hibkd_�b l��^��fh]ml\klj_qZlvky� kemqZb� qbklh� nbabheh]bq_kdh]h� oZjZdl_jZ�� \ kemqZyo� `_� aZ[u\Zgby� bf_g�gZf_j_gbc�� aZijylu\Zgby� ij_^f_lh\� b l�� ^�� y _^\Z� eb� kh]eZrmkv� k lZdbf� h[tykg_gb_f�AZl_jb\Zgb_�� ih� \k_c� \_jhylghklb�� fh`_l� ijhbahclb� b g_qZyggh�� <klj_qZxsb_ky� \ `bagbhrb[db� �,UUWXPHU�� \hh[s_� lhevdh� hlqZklb� ih^e_`Zl� gZr_fm� jZkkfhlj_gbx�� <k_� wlh� ke_^m_lbf_lv�\ \b^m�lZd`_�b \�lhf�kemqZ_��dh]^Z�fu�bkoh^bf�ba�iheh`_gby��qlh�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\byy\eyxlky� ikbobq_kdbfb� ZdlZfb� b \hagbdZxl� \ke_^kl\b_� bgl_jn_j_gpbb� ^\mo� jZaebqguogZf_j_gbc�LZdh\� i_j\uc� j_amevlZl� ikbohZgZebaZ��H kms_kl\h\Zgbb� lZdbo� bgl_jn_j_gpbb� b h[� bo\hafh`guo� ke_^kl\byo�� hibkZgguo� \ur_�� ikboheh]by� ^h� kbo� ihj� g_� agZeZ��Fu� agZqbl_evghjZkrbjbeb� fbj� ikbobq_kdbo� y\e_gbc� b \dexqbeb� \ h[eZklv� jZkkfhlj_gby� ikboheh]bbn_ghf_gu��dhlhjufb�hgZ�jZgvr_�g_�aZgbfZeZkv�HklZgh\bfky� l_i_jv� djZldh� gZ� ml\_j`^_gbb�� qlh� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by� y\eyxlky©ikbobq_kdbfb�ZdlZfbª��Y\ey_lky�eb�hgh�[he__�kh^_j`Z�l_evguf��q_f�i_j\h_�gZr_�iheh`_gb_�qlh�hgb�bf_xl�kfuke"�Y ^mfZx��g_l��wlh�\lhjh_�iheh`_gb_�_s_�[he__�g_hij_^_e_ggh�b fh`_lijb\_klb�d g_^hjZamf_gbyf��Bgh]^Z�\k_��qlh�fh`gh�gZ[ex^Zlv�\ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb��gZau\Zxl

Page 29: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ikbobq_kdbf� n_ghf_ghf�� <Z`gh� \uykgblv�� \ua\Zgh� eb� hl^_evgh_� ikbobq_kdh_� y\e_gb_g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�nbabq_kdbfb��hj]Zgbq_kdbfb��fZl_jbZevgufb�\ha^_ckl\byfb��b lh]^Z�hgh�g_hlghkblky� d h[eZklb�ikboheh]bb��beb� hgh� h[mkeh\e_gh� ij_`^_� \k_]h� ^jm]bfb� ikbobq_kdbfbijhp_kkZfb��aZ�dhlhjufb�kdju\Z_lky��\ k\hx�hq_j_^v��jy^�hj]Zgbq_kdbo�ijbqbg��Bf_ggh�\ wlhfihke_^g_f� kfuke_� fu� b ihgbfZ_f� y\e_gb_�� gZau\Zy� _]h� ikbobq_kdbf� ijhp_kkhf�� ihwlhfmp_e_khh[jZag__�\ujZ`Zlvky�lZd��y\e_gb_�bf__l�kh^_j`Zgb_��kfuke��Ih^�kfukehf�fu�ihgbfZ_fagZq_gb_��gZf_j_gb_��l_g^_gpbx�b f_klh�\ jy^m�ikbobq_kdbo�k\ya_c�?klv�p_euc�jy^�^jm]bo�y\e_gbc��hq_gv�[ebadbo�d hrb[hqguf�^_ckl\byf��d dhlhjuf� wlhgZa\Zgb_�� h^gZdh�� m`_� g_� ih^oh^bl�� Fu� gZau\Z_f� bo� kemqZcgufb� b kbfilhfZlbq_kdbfb^_ckl\byfb� >=XIDOOV� XQG� 6\PSWRP� KDQGOXQJHQ@�� Hgb� lh`_� ghkyl� oZjZdl_j� g_� lhevdhg_fhlb\bjh\Zgguo�� g_aZf_lguo�b g_agZqbl_evguo��gh�b baebrgbo� ^_ckl\bc��Hl� hrb[hqguo^_ckl\bc� bo� hlebqZ_l� hlkmlkl\b_� \lhjh]h� gZf_j_gby�� k dhlhjuf� klZedb\Zehkv� [u� i_j\h_� b[eZ]h^Zjy� dhlhjhfm� hgh� [u� gZjmrZehkv��K ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� wlb� ^_ckl\by� e_]dh� i_j_oh^yl� \`_klu� b ^\b`_gby�� dhlhju_�� ih� gZr_fm� fg_gbx�� \ujZ`Zxl� wfhpbb�� D wlbf� kemqZcguf^_ckl\byf�hlghkylky�\k_�dZ`msb_ky�[_kp_evgufb��\uihegy_fu_�dZd�[u�b]jZy�fZgbimeypbb�kh^_`^hc�� qZklyfb� l_eZ�� ij_^f_lZfb�� dhlhju_� fu� lh� [_j_f�� lh� hklZ\ey_f�� Z lZd`_� f_eh^bb�dhlhju_�fu� gZi_\Z_f�ijh� k_[y��Y m[_`^_g�� qlh� \k_� wlb� y\e_gby� ihegu� kfukeZ� b bo�fh`ghlhedh\Zlv� lZd�`_�� dZd� b hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by�� qlh� hgb� y\eyxlky� g_dhlhjuf� agZdhf� ^jm]bo�[he__�\Z`guo�^mr_\guo�ijhp_kkh\�b kZfb�hlghkylky�d iheghp_gguf�ikbobq_kdbf�ZdlZf��Gh�yg_� kh[bjZxkv� hklZgZ\eb\Zlvky� gZ� wlhc� gh\hc� h[eZklb� ikbobq_kdbo� y\e_gbc�� Z \_jgmkv� dhrb[hqguf� ^_ckl\byf�� lZd� dZd� hgb� iha\heyxl� k [hevr_c� lhqghklvx� ihklZ\blv� \Z`gu_� ^eyikbohZgZebaZ�\hijhku�< h[eZklb�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc�kZfufb�bgl_j_kgufb�\hijhkZfb��dhlhju_�fu�ihklZ\beb�gh�ihdZ�hklZ\beb�[_a�hl\_lZ��y\eyxlky�ke_^mxsb_�fu� kdZaZeb�� qlh� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by� \hagbdZxl� \ j_amevlZl_� gZeh`_gby� ^jm]� gZ� ^jm]Z^\mo�jZaebqguo�gZf_j_gbc��ba�dhlhjuo�h^gh�fh`gh�gZa\Zlv�gZjmr_gguf� �JHVWRUWH��� Z ^jm]h_gZjmrZxsbf� �VWRUHQGH��� GZjmr_ggu_� gZf_j_gby� g_� ij_^klZ\eyxl� kh[hc� ijh[e_fm�� Z \hl� h^jm]hc�]jmii_�fu�ohl_eb�[u�agZlv��\h�i_j\uo��qlh�wlh�aZ�gZf_j_gby��\uklmiZxsb_�dZd�ihf_oZ^ey�^jm]hc�]jmiiu��b��\h�\lhjuo��dZdh\u�bo�hlghr_gby�^jm]�d ^jm]m�JZaj_rbl_� fg_� hiylv� \aylv� \ dZq_kl\_� ijbf_jZ� ^ey� \k_o� \b^h\� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bch]h\hjdm�b hl\_lblv�kgZqZeZ�gZ�\lhjhc�\hijhk��ij_`^_�q_f�y hl\_qm�gZ�i_j\uc�Ijb� h]h\hjd_� gZjmrZxs__� gZf_j_gb_� fh`_l� bf_lv� hlghr_gb_� d kh^_j`ZgbxgZjmr_ggh]h�gZf_j_gby��lh]^Z�h]h\hjdZ�kh^_j`bl�ijhlb\hj_qb_��ihijZ\dm�beb�^hiheg_gb_�dg_fm��< f_g__�`_�ykguo�b [he__�bgl_j_kguo�kemqZyo�gZjmrZxs__�gZf_j_gb_�ih�kh^_j`Zgbxg_�bf__l�k gZjmr_gguf�gbq_]h�h[s_]h�Ih^l\_j`^_gby� hlghr_gbyf� i_j\h]h� jh^Z� fu� [_a� ljm^Z� gZc^_f� \ m`_� agZdhfuo� b bfih^h[guo� ijbf_jZo�� Ihqlb� \h� \k_o� kemqZyo� h]h\hjhd� gZjmrZxs__� gZf_j_gb_� \ujZ`Z_lijhlb\hiheh`gh_� kh^_j`Zgb_� ih� hlghr_gbx� d gZjmr_gghfm�� hrb[hqgh_� ^_ckl\b_ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� dhgnebdl� f_`^m� ^\mfy� g_kh]eZkh\Zggufb� klj_fe_gbyfb�� Y h[ty\eyxaZk_^Zgb_� hldjuluf�� gh� ohl_e� [u� _]h� aZdjulv� ²� lZdh\� kfuke� h]h\hjdb� ij_ab^_glZ�

Page 30: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Iheblbq_kdZy�]Za_lZ��dhlhjmx�h[\bgyeb�\ ijh^Z`ghklb��aZsbsZ_lky�\ klZlv_��dhlhjZy�^he`gZaZdZgqb\Zlvky�keh\Zfb��©GZrb�qblZl_eb�fh]ml�aZk\b^_l_evkl\h\Zlv��dZd�fu�\k_]^Z�kh\_jr_ggh[_kdhjuklgh�\uklmiZeb�gZ�[eZ]h�h[s_kl\Zª��Gh�j_^Zdlhj��khklZ\ey\rbc�wlm�klZlvx��hrb[ky�bgZibkZe�©dhjuklghª��Hg��\b^bfh��^mfZe��ohly�y b�^he`_g�gZibkZlv�lZd��gh�y agZx��qlh�wlh�eh`v�GZjh^guc� ij_^klZ\bl_ev�� ijba\Zgguc� ]h\hjblv� dZca_jm� [_kihsZ^gmx� �UXFNKDOWORV�� ijZ\^m�ijbkemrZ\rbkv�d \gmlj_gg_fm�]hehkm��dhlhjuc�dZd�[u�]h\hjbl��Z g_�kebrdhf�eb�lu�kf_e"�²^_eZ_l�h]h\hjdm²keh\h� UXFNKDOWORV� >[_kihsZ^guc@�ij_\jZsZ_lky�\ UXFNJUDWORV� >[_koj_[_lguc@ � < m`_� ba\_klguo� \Zf� ijbf_jZo�� dh]^Z� h]h\hjdZ� ijhba\h^bl� \i_qZle_gb_� kly`_gby� bkhdjZs_gby�keh\��ihy\eyxlky�ihijZ\db��^hiheg_gby�b ijh^he`_gby�\ukdZau\Zgby��\ dhlhjuo�gZjy^m� k i_j\hc�� gZoh^bl� k\h_� ijhy\e_gb_� b \lhjZy� l_g^_gpby�� ©Lml� h[gZjm`bebkv� �]XP9RUVFKHLQ� NRP�PHQ�� nZdlu�� Z emqr_� m`� ijyfh� kdZaZlv�� k\bgkl\Z� �6FKZHLQHUHLHQ�� ª�²� blZd�\hagbdZ_l�h]h\hjdZ��HV�VLQG�'LQJR�]XP�9RUVFWUZHLQ�JHNRLQUQHQ��©Ex^_c��dhlhju_�wlh�ihgbfZxl�fh`gh� khkqblZlv�ih�iZevpZf�h^ghc�jmdbª��gh� \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� _klv� lhevdh�h^bg�q_eh\_d�dhlhjuc�wlh�ihgbfZ_l��\ j_amevlZl_�ihemqZ_lky��khkqblZlv�ih�h^ghfm�iZevpm��Beb� ©fhc�fm`fh`_l�_klv�b iblv��qlh�hg�ohq_lª��Gh�jZa\_�y ihl_jiex��qlh[u�hg�qlh�lh�ohl_e��\hl�b \uoh^bl�hg�fh`_l�_klv�b iblv�\k_��qlh�y ohqm�<h� \k_o� wlbo� kemqZyo� h]h\hjdZ� eb[h� \hagbdZ_l� ba� kh^_j`Zgby� gZjmr_ggh]h� gZf_j_gby�eb[h�hgZ�k\yaZgZ�k wlbf�kh^_j`Zgb_f�>jm]hc� \b^� hlghr_gby� f_`^m� ^\mfy� [hjxsbfbky� gZf_j_gbyfb� ijhba\h^bl� \_kvfZkljZggh_� \i_qZle_gb_��?keb�gZjmrZxs__�gZf_j_gb_�g_�bf__l�gbq_]h�h[s_]h� k kh^_j`Zgb_fgZjmr_ggh]h��lh�hldm^Z�`_�hgh�[_j_lky�b ihq_fm�ihy\ey_lky�\ hij_^_e_gghf�f_kl_�dZd�ihf_oZ"GZ[ex^_gby��dhlhju_� lhevdh�b fh]ml�^Zlv�gZ� wlh�hl\_l��ihdZau\Zxl��qlh�ihf_oZ�\uau\Z_lkyl_f�oh^hf�fuke_c��dhlhju_�g_aZ^he]h�^h�lh]h�aZgbfZeb�q_eh\_dZ�b ijhy\bebkv�l_i_jv�lZdbfh[jZahf� g_aZ\bkbfh� hl� lh]h�� \ujZabebkv� eb� hgb� \ j_qb� beb� g_l��Wlm� ihf_om� ^_ckl\bl_evghfh`gh� gZa\Zlv� hla\mdhf�� h^gZdh� g_� h[yaZl_evgh� hla\mdhf� ijhbag_k_gguo� keh\�� A^_kv� lh`_kms_kl\m_l� ZkkhpbZlb\gZy� k\yav�f_`^m� gZjmrZxsbf� b gZjmr_gguf� gZf_j_gb_f�� gh� hgZ� g_kdju\Z_lky�\ kh^_j`Zgbb��Z mklZgZ\eb\Z_lky�bkdmkkl\_ggh��qZklh�\_kvfZ�hdhevgufb�imlyfb�Ijb\_^m�ijhklhc�ijbf_j�ba�kh[kl\_gguo�gZ[ex^_gbc��H^gZ`^u�y \klj_lbeky�m gZk�\ ]hjZom ^hehfblh\uo�i_s_j�k ^\mfy�h^_lufb�ih�lmjbklkdb�^ZfZfb��Y ijhr_e�k gbfb�g_fgh]h��b fuih]h\hjbeb�h ij_� �< g_f_pdhf�j_coklZ]_��ghy[jv������]�e_klyo� b ljm^ghklyo� lmjbklkdh]h� h[jZaZ� `bagb�� H^gZ� ba� ^Zf� kh]eZkbeZkv�� qlh� lZdh_\j_fyij_ijh\h`^_gb_� bf__l� k\hb� g_m^h[kl\Z�� ©>_ckl\bl_evgh�²� ]h\hjbl� hgZ�²� hq_gvg_ijbylgh�p_euc� ^_gv�rZ]Zlv� ih� khegp_i_dm�� dh]^Z� dhnlZ� b jm[ZrdZ� kh\_jr_ggh�fhdju� hlihlZª��< wlhf�ij_^eh`_gbb�hgZ�^_eZ_l�fZe_gvdmx�aZfbgdm�b ijh^he`Z_l��©Dh]^Z�ijboh^brvQDFK�+RVH�>^hfhc��gh�\f_klh�+DXVH�mihlj_[e_gh�keh\h�+RVH�²�iZglZehgu@�b _klv�\hafh`ghklvi_j_h^_lvky���ª�Fu� wlm� h]h\hjdm� g_� ZgZebabjh\Zeb�� gh� y ^mfZx�� \u� __ e_]dh� ihcf_l_��>ZfZbf_eZ� gZf_j_gb_� ijh^he`blv� i_j_qbke_gb_� b kdZaZlv�� dhnlm�� jm[Zrdm� b iZglZehgu�� Bakhh[jZ`_gbc� [eZ]hijbklhcghklb� keh\h� iZglZehgu� g_� [ueh� mihlj_[e_gh�� gh� \ ke_^mxs_f

Page 31: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ij_^eh`_gbb��kh\_jr_ggh�g_aZ\bkbfhf�ih�kh^_j`Zgbx��g_ijhbag_k_ggh_�keh\h�ihy\ey_lky�\\b^_�bkdZ`_gby��koh^gh]h�ih�a\mqZgbx�kh�keh\hf�+DXVH�Gm��Z l_i_jv��gZdhg_p��fu�fh`_f�i_j_clb�d \hijhkm��dhlhjuc�\k_�hldeZ^u\Zeb��qlh�wlh�aZgZf_j_gby��dhlhju_�lZdbf�g_h[uqguf�h[jZahf�ijhy\eyxlky�\ dZq_kl\_�ihf_o"�JZamf__lky��hgb\_kvfZ� jZaebqgu�� gh� fu� gZc^_f� \ gbo� b h[s__�� Bamqb\� p_euc� jy^� ijbf_jh\�� fu� fh`_f\u^_eblv� ljb� ]jmiiu�� D i_j\hc� ]jmii_� hlghkylky� kemqZb�� \ dhlhjuo� ]h\hjys_fm� ba\_klghgZjmrZxs__�gZf_j_gb_��b hg�qm\kl\h\Ze�_]h�i_j_^�h]h\hjdhc��LZd��\ h]h\hjd_� ©9RUVFKZHLQª]h\hjysbc�g_�lhevdh�g_�hljbpZ_l�hkm`^_gby�hij_^_e_gguo�nZdlh\��gh�ijbagZ_lky�\ gZf_j_gbb�hl�dhlhjh]h�hg�ihlhf�hldZaZeky��ijhbag_klb�keh\h�©6FKZHLQHUHLHQª�>k\bgkl\Z@��<lhjmx�]jmiimkhklZ\eyxl�kemqZb��dh]^Z�]h\hjysbc�lh`_�ijbagZ_l�gZjmrZxs__�gZf_j_gb_��gh�g_�ih^haj_\Z_l�qlh� hgh� klZeh� Zdlb\guf� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh� i_j_^� h]h\hjdhc�� Hg� kh]eZrZ_lky� k gZrbflhedh\Zgb_f��gh�\ ba\_klghc�kl_i_gb�m^b\e_g�bf��Ijbf_ju�lZdh]h�jh^Z�e_]q_�gZclb�\ ^jm]bohrb[hqguo�^_ckl\byo��q_f�\ h]h\hjdZo��D lj_lv_c�]jmii_�hlghkylky�kemqZb��dh]^Z�k^_eZ\rbch]h\hjdm� wg_j]bqgh� hl\_j]Z_l� gZr_� lhedh\Zgb_� gZjmrZxs_]h� gZf_j_gby�� hg� g_� lhevdhhkiZjb\Z_l�lhl�nZdl��qlh�^Zggh_�gZf_j_gb_�ih[m^beh�_]h�d h]h\hjd_��gh�ml\_j`^Z_l��qlh�hgh_fm� kh\_jr_ggh� qm`^h��<kihfgbf� kemqZc� k ©DXIVWRHQª� �hlju]gmlv� \f_klh� qhdgmlvky��� b lhlijyfh�lZdb� g_\_`eb\uc� hlihj�� dhlhjuc� y ihemqbe� hl� hjZlhjZ�� dh]^Z� ohl_e� bklhedh\ZlvgZjmrZxs__�gZf_j_gb_��DZd�\u�ihfgbl_��fu�g_�ijbreb�d _^bghfm�fg_gbx�\ ihgbfZgbb�wlbokemqZ_\��Y [u� ijhimklbe� fbfh� mr_c� \hajZ`_gby� hjZlhjZ�� ijhbaghkb\r_]h� lhkl�� ijh^he`Zyijb^_j`b\Zlvky�k\h_]h�lhedh\Zgby��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�\u��iheZ]Zx��hklZ_l_kv�ih^�\i_qZle_gb_f�_]hhlih\_^b�b ih^mfZ_l_��g_� emqr_� eb� hldZaZlvky� hl� lZdh]h� lhedh\Zgby�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc�bkqblZlv� bo� qbklh� nbabheh]bq_kdbfb� ZdlZfb�� dZd� wlh� [ueh� ijbgylh� ^h� ikbohZgZebaZ��Fh]mihgylv�� qlh� \Zk� im]Z_l��Fh_� lhedh\Zgb_� ij_^iheZ]Z_l�� qlh� m ]h\hjys_]h� fh]ml� ijhy\blvkygZf_j_gby�� h dhlhjuo� hg� kZf� gbq_]h� g_� agZ_l�� gh� h dhlhjuo� y fh]m� magZlv� gZ� hkgh\Zgbbdhk\_gguo�mebd��<Zk�hklZgZ\eb\Z_l�gh\bagZ�b k_jv_aghklv�fh_]h�ij_^iheh`_gby��IhgbfZx�bijbagZx�ihdZ�\Zrm�ijZ\hlm��Gh�\hl�qlh�fu�fh`_f�mklZgh\blv��_keb�\u�ohlbl_�ihke_^h\Zl_evghijb^_j`b\Zlvky� hij_^_e_ggh]h� \haaj_gby� gZ� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by�� ijZ\bevghklv� dhlhjh]h^hdZaZgZ� lZdbf� [hevrbf� dhebq_kl\hf� ijbf_jh\�� lh� \Zf� ijb^_lky� kh]eZkblvky� b k� wlbfkljZgguf�ij_^iheh`_gb_f��?keb�`_�\u�g_�fh`_l_�j_rblvky�gZ�wlh��lh�\Zf�gm`gh�hldZaZlvky�hl\k_]h��qlh�\u�m`_�agZ_l_�h[�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\byo�Gh�hklZgh\bfky�ihdZ�gZ�lhf��qlh�h[t_^bgy_l�\k_�ljb�]jmiiu��qlh�h[s_]h�\ f_oZgbaf_�wlboh]h\hjhd�� D kqZklvx�� wlh� g_� \uau\Z_l� khfg_gbc�� < i_j\uo� ^\mo� ]jmiiZo� gZjmrZxs__gZf_j_gb_�ijbagZ_lky�kZfbf�]h\hjysbf��\ i_j\hf�kemqZ_�d wlhfm�ijb[Z\ey_lky�_s_�lh��qlh�wlhgZf_j_gb_�ijhy\ey_lky�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�i_j_^�h]h\hjdhc��Gh�\ h[hbo�kemqZyo�wlh�gZf_j_gb_hll_kgy_lky�� =h\hjysbc� j_rbe� g_� ^himklblv� _]h� \ujZ`_gby� \ j_qb�� b lh]^Z� ijhbahreZh]h\hjdZ�� l�� _�� hll_kg_ggh_� gZf_j_gb_� \k_�lZdb� ijhy\behkv� ijhlb\� _]h� \heb�� baf_gb\\ujZ`_gb_�^hims_ggh]h�bf�gZf_j_gby��kf_rZ\rbkv�k gbf�beb�^Z`_�iheghklvx�aZf_gb\�_]h�LZdh\�f_oZgbaf�h]h\hjdb�K wlhc� lhqdb� aj_gby� fg_� lZd� `_� g_ljm^gh� iheghklvx� kh]eZkh\Zlv� ijhp_kk� h]h\hjhd�hlghkysboky�d lj_lv_c� ]jmii_�� k \ur_hibkZgguf�f_oZgbafhf��>ey� wlh]h�fg_�gm`gh� lhevdhij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� wlb� ljb� ]jmiiu� hlebqZxlky� ^jm]� hl� ^jm]Z� jZaghc� kl_i_gvx� hll_kg_gby

Page 32: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gZjmrZxs_]h� gZf_j_gby�� < i_j\hc� ]jmii_� wlh� gZf_j_gb_� hq_\b^gh�� hgh� ^Z_l� h k_[_� agZlv]h\hjys_fm�_s_�^h�\ukdZau\Zgby��lhevdh�ihke_�lh]h��dZd�hgh�hl\_j]gmlh��hgh�\haf_sZ_l�k_[y�\h]h\hjd_�� <h� \lhjhc� ]jmii_� gZjmrZxs__� gZf_j_gb_� hll_kgy_lky� _s_� ^Zevr_�� i_j_^\ukdZau\Zgb_f� ]h\hjysbc�_]h�m`_�g_� aZf_qZ_l��M^b\bl_evgh� lh��qlh� wlh�gbdhbf�h[jZahf�g_f_rZ_l� _fm�[ulv�ijbqbghc� h]h\hjdb��Gh� l_f� e_]q_�gZf� h[tykgblv�ijhbkoh`^_gb_� h]h\hjhdlj_lv_c� ]jmiiu��Y [_jm� gZ� k_[y� kf_ehklv� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� \ hrb[hqghf� ^_ckl\bb� fh`_lijhy\blvky�_s_�h^gZ�l_g^_gpby��dhlhjZy�^Z\gh��fh`_l�[ulv��hq_gv�^Z\gh�hll_kg_gZ��]h\hjysbcg_� aZf_qZ_l� __ b� dZd� jZa� ihwlhfm� hljbpZ_l��Gh� hklZ\bf� ihdZ� wlm� ihke_^gxx� ijh[e_fm�� ba^jm]bo� kemqZ_\� \u� ^he`gu� k^_eZlv� \u\h^�� qlh� ih^Z\e_gb_� bf_xs_]hky� gZf_j_gby� qlh�eb[hkdZaZlv�y\ey_lky�g_ij_f_gguf�mkeh\b_f�\hagbdgh\_gby�h]h\hjdb�L_i_jv�fu�fh`_f� ml\_j`^Zlv�� qlh� ijh^\bgmebkv� _s_� ^Zevr_� \ ihgbfZgbb� hrb[hqguo^_ckl\bc��Fu� g_� lhevdh� agZ_f�� qlh� hgb� y\eyxlky� ikbobq_kdbfb� ZdlZfb�� \ dhlhjuo� fh`ghmkfhlj_lv� kfuke�b gZf_j_gb_�� qlh� hgb� \hagbdZxl� [eZ]h^Zjy�gZeh`_gbx� ^jm]�gZ� ^jm]Z� ^\mojZaebqguo�gZf_j_gbc��gh��djhf_�lh]h��qlh�h^gh�ba�wlbo�gZf_j_gbc�ih^\_j]Z_lky�hll_kg_gbx�_]h� \uiheg_gb_� g_� ^himkdZ_lky� b \� j_amevlZl_� hgh� ijhy\ey_lky� \ gZjmr_gbb� ^jm]h]hgZf_j_gby��Gm`gh� kgZqZeZ� ihf_rZlv� _fm� kZfhfm�� qlh[u� hgh� fh]eh� klZlv� ihf_ohc��Ihegh_h[tykg_gb_� n_ghf_gh\�� gZau\Z_fuo� hrb[hqgufb� ^_ckl\byfb�� wlbf�� dhg_qgh�� _s_� g_^hklb]Z_lky��KjZam�`_�\klZxl�^jm]b_�\hijhku��b \hh[s_�dZ`_lky��q_f�^Zevr_�fu�ijh^\b]Z_fky\ ihgbfZgbb� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc�� l_f� [hevr_� ih\h^h\� ^ey� gh\uo� \hijhkh\��Fu� fh`_f�gZijbf_j�� kijhkblv�� ihq_fm� \k_� wlh� g_� ijhbkoh^bl� gZfgh]h� ijhs_"� ?keb� _klv� l_g^_gpbyhll_kgblv� hij_^_e_ggh_� gZf_j_gb_� \f_klh� lh]h�� qlh[u� _]h� \uihegblv�� lh� wlh� hll_kg_gb_^he`gh�ijhbkoh^blv�lZdbf�h[jZahf��qlh[u�wlh�gZf_j_gb_�\hh[s_�g_�ihemqbeh�\ujZ`_gby�beb`_�hll_kg_gb_�fh]eh�[u�g_�m^Zklky�\h\k_�b hll_kg_ggh_�gZf_j_gb_�\ujZabehkv�[u�iheghklvx�Hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�� h^gZdh��ij_^klZ\eyxl� kh[hc� dhfijhfbkku�� hgb�hagZqZxl�ihemm^Zqm�bihemg_m^Zqm� ^ey� dZ`^h]h�ba� ^\mo� gZf_j_gbc�� ihklZ\e_ggh_� ih^� m]jham� gZf_j_gb_� g_�fh`_l[ulv�gb�iheghklvx�ih^Z\e_gh��gb�\k_p_eh�ijhy\e_gh��aZ�bkdexq_gb_f�hl^_evguo�kemqZ_\��Fufh`_f� ij_^iheZ]Zlv�� qlh� ^ey� hkms_kl\e_gby� lZdbo� bgl_jn_j_gpbb� beb� dhfijhfbkkh\g_h[oh^bfu�hkh[u_�mkeh\by��gh�fu�g_�fh`_f�^Z`_�ij_^klZ\blv�k_[_�bo�oZjZdl_j��Y lZd`_�g_^mfZx��qlh�fu�fh]eb�[u�h[gZjm`blv�wlb�g_ba\_klgu_�gZf�hlghr_gby�ijb�^Zevg_crbo�[he__]em[hdbo� bkke_^h\Zgbyo� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc�� =hjZa^h� [he__� g_h[oh^bfuf� fu� kqblZ_fbamq_gb_� ^jm]bo� l_fguo� h[eZkl_c� ^mr_\ghc� `bagb�� b lhevdh� ZgZeh]bb� k l_fb� y\e_gbyfb�dhlhju_�fu�gZc^_f�\ wlbo�bkke_^h\Zgbyo��iha\heyl�gZf� k^_eZlv� l_�ij_^iheh`_gby�� dhlhju_g_h[oh^bfu� ^ey� emqr_]h� ihgbfZgby� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc��B _s_� h^gh�� ?klv� hij_^_e_ggZyhiZkghklv� \ jZ[hl_� k fZehagZqbl_evgufb� ikbobq_kdbfb� ijhy\e_gbyfb�� dZdbfb� ijboh^blkyaZgbfZlvky� gZf�� Kms_kl\m_l� ^mr_\gh_� aZ[he_\Zgb_�� dhf[bgZlhjgZy� iZjZghcy�� ijb� dh� ]hjhc>[hevgu_@�[_kdhg_qgh�^he]h�fh]ml�aZgbfZlvky�hp_gdhc�lZdbo�fZehagZqbl_evguo�ijbagZdh\��ghy g_�ihjmqmkv��qlh�ijb�wlhf�>hgb@�^_eZxl�ijZ\bevgu_�\u\h^u��Hl�lZdhc�hiZkghklb�gZk�fh`_lm[_j_qv� lhevdh� rbjhdZy� [ZaZ� gZ[ex^_gbc�� ih\lhjy_fhklv� koh^guo� aZdexq_gbc� ba� kZfuojZaebqguo�h[eZkl_c�ikbobq_kdhc�`bagb�GZ� wlhf�fu� ij_j\_f� ZgZeba� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc��Gh� y ohl_e� [u� ij_^mij_^blv� \Zk� h[h^ghf�� aZihfgbl_�� ih`ZemcklZ�� f_lh^� ZgZebaZ� wlbo� n_ghf_gh\�� GZ� bo� ijbf_j_� \u� fh`_l_m\b^_lv��dZdh\u�p_eb�gZrbo�ikboheh]bq_kdbo�bkke_^h\Zgbc��Fu�ohlbf�g_�ijhklh�hibku\Zlv�b

Page 33: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

deZkkbnbpbjh\Zlv�y\e_gby��Z klj_fbfky�ihgylv�bo�dZd�ijhy\e_gb_�[hjv[u�^mr_\guo�kbe��dZd\ujZ`_gb_�p_e_gZijZ\e_gguo�l_g^_gpbc��dhlhju_�jZ[hlZxl�kh]eZkgh�^jm]�k ^jm]hf�beb�^jm]ijhlb\�^jm]Z��Fu�ijb^_j`b\Z_fky�^bgZfbq_kdh]h�ihgbfZgby�ikbobq_kdbo�y\e_gbc��K gZr_clhqdb� aj_gby�� \hkijbgbfZ_fu_� n_ghf_gu� ^he`gu� mklmiblv� f_klh� lhevdh� ij_^iheZ]Z_fufklj_fe_gbyf�BlZd��fu�[m^_f�m]em[eylvky�\ ijh[e_fm�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��gh�[jhkbf�[_]euc�\a]ey^�gZwlm�h[eZklv�\h�\k_c�__ rbjhl_�� a^_kv�fu�\klj_lbf�b m`_� agZdhfh_��b dh_�qlh�gh\h_��Fu�ih�ij_`g_fm�[m^_f�ijb^_j`b\Zlvky� m`_�ijbgylh]h� \gZqZe_�^_e_gby�gZ� ljb� ]jmiiu� h]h\hjhd�� ZlZd`_�hibkhd��hqblhd��hkeur_d��aZ[u\Zgby�k _]h�ih^\b^Zfb�\ aZ\bkbfhklb�hl�aZ[ulh]h�h[t_dlZ�bf_gb� kh[kl\_ggh]h�� qm`bo� keh\�� gZf_j_gbc�� \i_qZle_gbc�� b aZo\Zlu\Zgby� ©ih� hrb[d_ª�aZijylu\Zgby��aZl_jb\Zgby�\_s_c��Hrb[db�aZ[em`^_gby� �,UUWXPHU���gZkdhevdh�hgb�ihiZ^Zxl�\ihe_�gZr_]h�\gbfZgby��hlghkylky�qZklbqgh� d aZ[u\Zgbx��qZklbqgh� d ^_ckl\bx� ©ih� hrb[d_ª�9HUJUHLIHQ��H[�h]h\hjd_�fb�m`_�]h\hjbeb�^h\hevgh�ih^jh[gh��b \k_�lZdb�dh_�qlh�fh`gh�^h[Z\blv��Dh]h\hjd_�ijbkh_^bgyxlky�f_g__�agZqbl_evgu_�Znn_dlb\gu_�y\e_gby��dhlhju_�g_[_augl_j_kgu^ey� gZk�� Gbdlh� g_� ex[bl� h]h\Zjb\Zlvky�� qZklh� h]h\hjb\rbcky� g_� keurbl� kh[kl\_gghch]h\hjdb��gh�gbdh]^Z�g_�ijhimklbl�qm`hc��H]h\hjdb�^Z`_�\ ba\_klghf�kfuke_� aZjZabl_evgu�^h\hevgh�ljm^gh�h[km`^Zlv�h]h\hjdb�b g_�k^_eZlv�__ kZfhfm��KZfu_�g_agZqbl_evgu_�nhjfuh]h\hjhd��dhlhju_�g_�fh]ml�^Zlv�gbdZdh]h�hkh[h]h�h[tykg_gby�klhysbo�aZ�gbfb�ikbobq_kdboijhp_kkh\�� g_ljm^gh� jZa]Z^Zlv� \ hlghr_gbb� bo� fhlb\Zpbb�� ?keb� dlh�lh� ijhbaghkbl� djZldh^he]bc� ]eZkguc� \ke_^kl\b_� q_f�lh� fhlb\bjh\Zggh]h� gZjmr_gby�� ijhy\b\r_]hky� \ijhbaghr_gbb�^Zggh]h�keh\Z��lh�ke_^mxsmx�aZ�g_c�djZldmx�]eZkgmx�hg�ijhbaghkbl�^he]h�b^_eZ_l� gh\mx� h]h\hjdm�� dhfi_gkbjmy� wlbf� ij_^u^msmx�� Lh� `_� kZfh_� ijhbkoh^bl�� dh]^Zg_qbklh� b g_[j_`gh� ijhbaghkblky� ^bnlhg]�� gZijbf_j�� _c� beb� Rg dZd� _]h�� `_eZy� bkijZ\blvhrb[dm��q_eh\_d�f_gy_l�\ ke_^mxs_f�f_kl_� H_ gZ�_c�beb� Rg��Ijb� wlhf��ih�\b^bfhfm��bf__lagZq_gb_�fg_gb_�kh[_k_^gbdZ��dhlhjuc�g_�^he`_g�ih^mfZlv��qlh�]h\hjys_fm�[_ajZaebqgh��dZdhg�ihevam_lky�jh^guf�yaudhf��<lhjh_�dhfi_gkbjmxs__�bkdZ`_gb_�dZd�jZa�gZijZ\e_gh�gZ�lh�qlh[u�h[jZlblv�\gbfZgb_�kemrZl_ey�iZ�i_j\mx�hrb[dm�b ihdZaZlv�_fm��qlh�]h\hjb\rbc�kZf�__aZf_lbe�� KZfufb� qZklufb�� ijhklufb� b fZehagZqbl_evgufb� kemqZyfb� h]h\hjhd� y\eyxlkykly`_gby� b ij_^\hkobs_gby�� dhlhju_� ijhy\eyxlky� \ g_kms_kl\_gguo� qZklyo� j_qb�� < [he__^ebgghf� ij_^eh`_gbb� h]h\Zjb\Zxlky�� gZijbf_j�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� qlh� ihke_^g__� keh\hij_^iheZ]Z_fh]h� \ukdZau\Zgby� a\mqbl� jZgvr_� \j_f_gb�� Wlh� ijhba\h^bl� \i_qZle_gb_hij_^_e_ggh]h� g_l_ji_gby�� `_eZgby� ihkdhj__� aZdhgqblv� ij_^eh`_gb_� b k\b^_l_evkl\m_l� h[ba\_klghf�ijhlb\h[hjkl\mxs_f�klj_fe_gbb�ih�hlghr_gbx�d wlhfm�ij_^eh`_gbx�beb�ijhlb\\k_c� j_qb� \hh[s_�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� fu� ijb[eb`Z_fky� d ih]jZgbqguf� kemqZyf�� \ dhlhjuojZaebqby� f_`^m� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbf� b h[uqguf� nbabheh]bq_kdbf� ihgbfZgb_f� h]h\hjdbklbjZxlky��Fu� ij_^iheZ]Z_f�� qlh� \ wlbo� kemqZyo� bf__lky� gZjmrZxsZy� j_q_\h_� gZf_j_gb_l_g^_gpby��gh�hgZ�fh`_l� lhevdh�gZf_dgmlv�gZ� k\h_� kms_kl\h\Zgb_��g_�\ujZab\� kh[kl\_ggh]hgZf_j_gby�� GZjmr_gb_�� dhlhjh_� hgZ� \uau\Z_l�� y\ey_lky� ke_^kl\b_f� dZdbo�lh� a\mdh\uo� bebZkkhpbZlb\guo� \ebygbc�� dhlhju_� fh`gh� ihgbfZlv� dZd� hl\e_q_gb_� \gbfZgby� hl� j_q_\h]hgZf_j_gby��Gh�gb wlh�hl\e_q_gb_�\gbfZgby��gb�klZ\rb_�^_ckl\_ggufb�ZkkhpbZlb\gu_�\ebygbyg_� h[tykgyxl� kmsghklb� ijhp_kkZ�� Hgb� lhevdh� mdZau\Zxl� gZ� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� gZjmrZxs_c

Page 34: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

j_q_\h_�gZf_j_gb_�l_g^_gpbb��ijbjh^m�dhlhjhc��h^gZdh��g_evay�hij_^_eblv�ih�__ ijhy\e_gbyf�dZd�wlh�m^Z_lky�k^_eZlv�\h�\k_o�[he__�yjdh�\ujZ`_gguo�kemqZyo�h]h\hjdb�HibkdZ� �9HUVFKUHLEHQ���d dhlhjhc�y l_i_jv�i_j_oh`m��gZklhevdh�ZgZeh]bqgZ�h]h\hjd_��qlhgbq_]h� ijbgpbibZevgh� gh\h]h� hl� __ bamq_gby� `^Zlv� g_� ijboh^blky�� Ohly�� fh`_l� [ulv�g_dhlhju_� ^hiheg_gby� fu� b \g_k_f�� Klhev� jZkijhkljZg_ggu_� hibkdb�� kly`_gby�� ihy\e_gb_\i_j_^b� ^Zevr_� klhysbo�� hkh[_ggh� ihke_^gbo� keh\� k\b^_l_evkl\mxl� hiylv�lZdb� h[� h[s_fg_`_eZgbb� ibkZlv� b h� g_l_ji_gbb�� [he__� yjdh� \ujZ`_ggu_� kemqZb� hibkdb� iha\heyxlh[gZjm`blv� oZjZdl_j� b gZf_j_gb_� gZjmrZxs_c� l_g^_gpbb��Dh]^Z� \ ibkvf_� h[gZjm`b\Z_lkyhibkdZ��fh`gh�ijbagZlv��qlh�m ibrms_]h�g_�\k_�[ueh�\ ihjy^d_��gh�g_�\k_]^Z�hij_^_ebrv��qlhbf_ggh� _]h� \hegh\Zeh�� K^_eZ\rbc� hibkdm�� lZd� `_� dZd� b h]h\hjdm�� qZklh� g_� aZf_qZ_l� __�Ijbf_qZl_evgh� ke_^mxs__� gZ[ex^_gb_�� _klv� ex^b�� dhlhju_� h[uqgh� i_j_^� hlijZ\e_gb_fi_j_qblu\Zxl�gZibkZggh_�ibkvfh��M ^jm]bo�lZdhc�ijb\uqdb�g_l��gh�_keb�hgb��h^gZdh��k^_eZxlwlh�\ \b^_�bkdexq_gby��lh�\k_]^Z�ihemqZxl�\hafh`ghklv�gZclb�hibkdm�b bkijZ\blv�__��DZd�wlhh[tykgblv"� KdeZ^u\Z_lky� \i_qZle_gb_�� [m^lh� ex^b� \k_� `_� agZxl�� qlh� hgb� k^_eZeb� hibkdm�Fh`gh�eb�wlh�\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�ij_^iheh`blv"K ijZdlbq_kdbf� agZq_gb_f� hibkdb� k\yaZgZ� h^gZ�bgl_j_kgZy� ijh[e_fZ��<u��fh`_l� [ulv�agZ_l_� kemqZc� m[bcpu� ;��� dhlhjuc�� \u^Z\Zy� k_[y� aZ� [Zdl_jbheh]Z�� ^hklZ\Ze� ba� gZmqgh�bkke_^h\Zl_evkdh]h� bgklblmlZ� ih� jZa\_^_gbx� dmevlmj� qj_a\uqZcgh� hiZkguo� ^ey� `bagb\ha[m^bl_e_c� [he_ag_c� b mihlj_[eye� bo� ^ey� mkljZg_gby� lZdbf� ©kh\j_f_ggufª� kihkh[hf[ebadbo� ex^_c� kh� k\h_]h� imlb�� H^gZ`^u� hg� ih`Zeh\Zeky� jmdh\h^kl\m� h^gh]h� ba� lZdbobgklblmlh\� gZ� g_^_ckl\_gghklv� ijbkeZgguo� _fm� dmevlmj�� gh� ijb� wlhf� ^himklbe� hrb[dm� b\f_klh�keh\�©ijb�fhbo�hiulZo�k furZfb�beb�fhjkdbfb�k\bgdZfbª�gZibkZe�©ijb�fhbo�hiulZok ex^vfbª�� WlZ� hibkdZ� [jhkbeZkv� \ ]eZaZ� \jZqZf� bgklblmlZ�� gh� hgb�� gZkdhevdh� y agZx�� g_k^_eZeb�ba�wlh]h�gbdZdbo�\u\h^h\��Gm��Z dZd�\u�^mfZ_l_"�Fh]eb�[u�\jZqb�ijbagZlv�hibkdm�aZijbagZgb_�b \ha[m^blv�ke_^kl\b_��[eZ]h^Zjy�q_fm�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�k\h_\j_f_ggh�ij_^mij_^blvij_klmie_gb_"� G_� ihkem`beh� eb� \ ^Zgghf� kemqZ_� g_agZgb_� gZr_]h� lhedh\Zgby� hrb[hqguo^_ckl\bc� ijbqbghc� lZdh]h� ijZdlbq_kdb� \Z`gh]h� mims_gby"�IheZ]Zx�� h^gZdh�� qlh� dZdhc� [uih^hajbl_evghc� g_� ihdZaZeZkv� fg_� lZdZy� hibkdZ�� bkihevah\Zlv� __ \� dZq_kl\_� ijyfhc� mebdbf_rZ_l�h^gh�\Z`gh_�h[klhyl_evkl\h��<k_�\_^v�g_�lZd�lh�ijhklh��HibkdZ�²�wlh��dhg_qgh��mebdZ�gh�kZfhc�ih�k_[_�__ _s_�g_^hklZlhqgh�^ey�gZqZeZ�ke_^kl\by��HibkdZ�^_ckl\bl_evgh�mdZau\Z_lgZ�lh��qlh�q_eh\_dZ�fh]eZ�aZgbfZlv�fukev�h aZjZ`_gbb�ex^_c��gh�hgZ�g_�iha\hey_l�ml\_j`^Zlv�ghkbl� eb� wlZ� fukev� oZjZdl_j� y\gh]h� aeh]h� mfukeZ� beb� ijZdlbq_kdb� [_ah[b^ghc� nZglZabb�<iheg_� \hafh`gh�� qlh� q_eh\_d�� ^himklb\rbc� lZdmx� hibkdm�� [m^_l� hljbpZlv� wlm�nZglZabx� kiheguf� km[t_dlb\guf� ijZ\hf� b kqblZlv� __ kh\_jr_ggh� qm`^hc� ^ey� k_[y�� Dh]^Z� fu� \^Zevg_cr_f�[m^_f� jZa[bjZlv� jZaebqb_�f_`^m� ikbobq_kdhc� b fZl_jbZevghc� j_Zevghklvx�� \u_s_� emqr_� kfh`_l_� ihgylv� wlm� \hafh`ghklv�� < ^Zgghf� `_� kemqZ_� hrb[hqgh_� ^_ckl\b_ijbh[j_eh�\ihke_^kl\bb�g_ij_^\b^_ggh_�agZq_gb_�Ijb� hqbld_� fu� bf__f� ^_eh� k ikbobq_kdhc� kblmZpb_c�� y\gh� hlebqghc� hl� kblmZpbb�� \dhlhjhc�ijhbkoh^yl�h]h\hjdb�b hibkdb��H^gZ�ba�^\mo�dhgdmjbjmxsbo�l_g^_gpbc� aZf_gy_lkya^_kv� k_gkhjguf� \ha[m`^_gb_f� b�� \hafh`gh�� ihwlhfm� f_g__� mklhcqb\Z�� Lh�� qlh� ke_^m_lijhqblZlv�� \ hlebqb_� hl� lh]h�� qlh� gZf_j_\Z_rvky� gZibkZlv�� g_� y\ey_lky� \_^v� kh[kl\_gguf

Page 35: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijh^mdlhf� ikbobq_kdhc� `bagb� qblZxs_]h�� < [hevrbgkl\_� kemqZ_\� hqbldZ� aZdexqZ_lky� \iheghc� aZf_g_� h^gh]h� keh\Z� ^jm]bf�� Keh\h�� dhlhjh_� gm`gh� ijhq_klv�� aZf_gy_lky� ^jm]bf�ijbq_f� g_� lj_[m_lky�� qlh[u� l_dkl� [ue� k\yaZg� k j_amevlZlhf� hqbldb� ih� kh^_j`Zgbx�� dZdijZ\beh��aZf_gZ�ijhbkoh^bl�gZ�hkgh\_�keh\_kghc�ZgZeh]bb��Ijbf_j�Ebol_g[_j]Z�²�:]Zf_fghg\f_klh� DQJHQRPPHQ�²� kZfuc� emqrbc�ba� wlhc� ]jmiiu��?keb�fu� ohlbf� magZlv� gZjmrZxsmxl_g^_gpbx��\uau\Zxsmx�hqbldm��ke_^m_l�hklZ\blv�\ klhjhg_�g_ijZ\bevgh�ijhqblZgguc�l_dkl�Z ih^\_j]gmlv� ZgZeblbq_kdhfm� bkke_^h\Zgbx� ^\Z� fhf_glZ�� dZdZy� fukev� ijbreZ� \ ]heh\mqblZ\r_fm�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�i_j_^�hqbldhc�b \�dZdhc�kblmZpbb�hgZ�ijhbkoh^bl��Bgh]^Z�agZgbywlhc� kblmZpbb� ^hklZlhqgh� ^ey� h[tykg_gby� hqbldb��GZijbf_j�� g_dlh� [jh^bl� ih� g_agZdhfhfm]hjh^m��bkiulu\Zy� _kl_kl\_ggmx�gm`^m��b gZ� [hevrhc� \u\_kd_�i_j\h]h� wlZ`Z� qblZ_l� deha_l�.ORVHWWKDXV���G_�mki_\�m^b\blvky�lhfm��qlh�\u\_kdZ�\bkbl�kebrdhf�\ukhdh��hg�m[_`^Z_lky��qlhke_^m_l� qblZlv� dhjk_lu� �.RUVHWWKDXV���< ^jm]bo� kemqZyo� hqblhd�� g_aZ\bkbfuo� hl� kh^_j`Zgbyl_dklZ�� gZh[hjhl�� g_h[oh^bf� lsZl_evguc� ZgZeba�� dhlhjuc� g_evay� ijh\_klb�� g_� agZyl_ogbq_kdbo� ijb_fh\� ikbohZgZebaZ� b g_� ^h\_jyy� bf�� Gh� \ [hevrbgkl\_� kemqZ_\� h[tykgblvhqbldm�g_ljm^gh��Ih� aZf_g_gghfm� keh\m� \ ijbf_j_� k :]Zf_fghghf� yk_g� djm]�fuke_c�� ba�aZdhlhjuo� \hagbdeh� gZjmr_gb_�� <h� \j_fy� wlhc� \hcgu�� gZijbf_j�� gZa\Zgby� ]hjh^h\�� bf_gZihedh\h^p_\� b \h_ggu_� \ujZ`_gby� \_kvfZ� qZklh� \uqblu\Zxl� \_a^_�� ]^_� lhevdh� \klj_qZ_lkyohlv� dZdh_�gb[m^v� ihoh`__� keh\h�� Lh�� qlh� aZgbfZl_evgh� b bgl_j_kgh�� aZf_gy_l� qm`^h_� bg_bgl_j_kgh_��HklZldb�>ij_^r_kl\mxsbo@�fuke_c�aZljm^gyxl�gh\h_�\hkijbylb_�Ijb� hqbld_� ^hklZlhqgh� qZklh� \klj_qZxlky� kemqZb� ^jm]h]h� jh^Z�� \ dhlhjuo� kZf� l_dkl\uau\Z_l� gZjmrZxsmx� l_g^_gpbx�� ba�aZ� dhlhjhc� hg� aZl_f� b ij_\jZsZ_lky� \ k\hxijhlb\hiheh`ghklv�� Q_eh\_d� \ugm`^_g� qblZlv� qlh�lh� ^ey� g_]h� g_`_eZl_evgh_�� b ZgZebam[_`^Z_l�gZk��qlh�bgl_gkb\gh_�`_eZgb_�hl\_j]gmlv�qblZ_fh_�\uau\Z_l�_]h�baf_g_gb_�< jZg__�mihfygmluo�[he__�qZkluo�kemqZyo�hqblhd�hlkmlkl\mxl�^\Z�nZdlhjZ��dhlhju_��ihgZr_fm�fg_gbx��b]jZxl�\Z`gmx�jhev�\ f_oZgbaf_�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��g_l�dhgnebdlZ�^\mol_g^_gpbc�b hll_kg_gby�h^ghc�ba�gbo��dhlhjZy�\haf_sZ_l�k_[y�\ hrb[hqghf�^_ckl\bb��G_�lhqlh[u� ijb� hqbld_� h[gZjm`b\Zehkv� [u� qlh�lh� kh\_jr_ggh� ijhlb\hiheh`gh_�� ih� \Z`ghklvkh^_j`Zgby�fukeb��ijb\h^ys_]h�d hqbld_��gZfgh]h�hq_\b^g__��q_f�hll_kg_gb_��dhlhjhfm�hgh^h�lh]h�ih^\_j]ehkv��Bf_ggh�h[Z�wlbo�nZdlhjZ�gZ]ey^g__�\k_]h�\uklmiZxl�\ jZaebqguo�kemqZyohrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��\ujZ`Zxsboky�\ aZ[u\Zgbb�AZ[u\Zgb_� gZf_j_gbc� dZd� jZa� h^ghagZqgh�� _]h� lhedh\Zgb_�� dZd� fu� m`_� agZ_f�� g_hkiZjb\Z_lky�^Z`_�g_ki_pbZebklZfb��GZjmrZxsZy�gZf_j_gb_� l_g^_gpby�\kydbc�jZa�y\ey_lkyijhlb\hiheh`guf�gZf_j_gb_f��g_`_eZgb_f�\uihegblv�i_j\h_��b gZf�hklZ_lky�lhevdh�magZlv�ihq_fm� hgh� g_� \ujZ`Z_lky� ih�^jm]hfm� b f_g__� aZfZkdbjh\Zggh�� Gh� gZebqb_� wlhcijhlb\hiheh`ghc� \heb� g_khfg_ggh�� Bgh]^Z� ^Z`_� m^Z_lky� magZlv� dh_�qlh� h fhlb\Zo�\ugm`^Zxsbo�kdju\Zlvky�wlm�ijhlb\hiheh`gmx�\hex��b \kydbc�jZa�hgZ�^hklb]Z_l�k\h_c�p_eb\ hrb[hqghf�^_ckl\bb��hklZ\Zykv�kdjulhc��ihlhfm�qlh�[ueZ�[u�gZ\_jgydZ�hldehg_gZ��_keb�[u\uklmibeZ� \ \b^_� hldjulh]h� \hajZ`_gby�� ?keb� f_`^m� gZf_j_gb_f� b _]h� \uiheg_gb_fijhbkoh^bl� kms_kl\_ggh_� baf_g_gb_� ikbobq_kdhc� kblmZpbb�� \ke_^kl\b_� dhlhjh]h� h\uiheg_gbb�gZf_j_gby�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�b j_qb�� lh]^Z� aZ[u\Zgb_�gZf_j_gby�\uoh^bl� aZ�jZfdbhrb[hqgh]h� ^_ckl\by�� LZdh_� aZ[u\Zgb_� g_� m^b\ey_l�� ihgylgh�� qlh� [ueh� [u� baebrg_

Page 36: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\kihfbgZlv� h gZf_j_gbb�� hgh� \uiZeh� ba� iZfylb� gZ� [he__� beb� f_g__� ^ebl_evgh_� \j_fy�AZ[u\Zgb_� gZf_j_gby� lhevdh� lh]^Z� fh`gh� kqblZlv� hrb[hqguf� ^_ckl\b_f�� _keb� lZdh_gZjmr_gb_�bkdexq_gh�KemqZb� aZ[u\Zgby�gZf_j_gbc�\ h[s_f�gZklhevdh�h^ghh[jZagu�b ijhajZqgu��qlh�bf_gghihwlhfm� hgb� g_� ij_^klZ\eyxl� gbdZdh]h� bgl_j_kZ� ^ey� gZr_]h� bkke_^h\Zgby��H^gZdh� dh_�qlhgh\h_�\ ^\mo�hlghr_gbyo�fu�fh`_f�magZlv��bamqZy�b wlh�hrb[hqgh_�^_ckl\b_��Fu�hlf_lbeb�qlh� aZ[u\Zgb_�� l�� _�� g_\uiheg_gb_� gZf_j_gby�� mdZau\Z_l� gZ� ijhlb\hiheh`gmx� \hex�\jZ`^_[gmx�wlhfm�gZf_j_gbx��Wlh�iheh`_gb_�hklZ_lky�\ kbe_��gh�ijhlb\hiheh`gZy�\hey��dZdihdZau\Zxl�gZrb�bkke_^h\Zgby��fh`_l�[ulv�^\mo�\b^h\�²�ijyfZy�b hihkj_^h\ZggZy��Qlh�fuihgbfZ_f� ih^� ihke_^g_c�� emqr_� \k_]h� ihdZaZlv� gZ� g_dhlhjuo� ijbf_jZo��Dh]^Z� ihdjh\bl_evaZ[u\Z_l� aZfhe\blv� keh\_qdh� aZ� k\h_]h� ijhl_`_�� lh� wlh�fh`_l� ijhbahclb� ihlhfm�� qlh� hg� g_hq_gv�bgl_j_km_lky�k\hbf�ijhl_`_�b m�g_]h�g_l�[hevrhc�hohlu�ijhkblv�aZ�g_]h��Bf_ggh�\ wlhfkfuke_�ijhl_`_�b ihgbfZ_l� aZ[u\qb\hklv�ihdjh\bl_ey��Gh� kblmZpby�fh`_l�[ulv�b keh`g__�Ijhlb\hiheh`gZy� \uiheg_gbx� gZf_j_gby� \hey� fh`_l� ihy\blvky� m ihdjh\bl_ey� ih� ^jm]hcijbqbg_� b ijhy\blv� k\h_� ^_ckl\b_� kh\k_f� \ ^jm]hf� f_kl_�� HgZ� fh`_l� g_� bf_lv� d ijhl_`_gbdZdh]h� hlghr_gby�� Z [ulv� gZijZ\e_gZ� ijhlb\� lj_lv_]h� ebpZ�� dhlhjh_� gm`gh� ijhkblv�� <u\b^bl_� l_i_jv�� dZdb_� khfg_gby� \hagbdZxl� b a^_kv� \ k\yab� k ijZdlbq_kdbf� bkihevah\Zgb_fgZr_]h�lhedh\Zgby��G_kfhljy�gZ�ijZ\bevgh_�lhedh\Zgb_�aZ[u\Zgby��ijhl_`_�fh`_l�ijhy\blvbaebrgxx� g_^h\_jqb\hklv� b g_kijZ\_^eb\hklv� ih� hlghr_gbx� d k\h_fm� ihdjh\bl_ex�� Beb_keb�dlh�gb[m^v�aZ[u\Z_l�ijh�k\b^Zgb_��gZagZq_ggh_�^jm]hfm��ohly�kZf�b gZf_j_g�[ue�y\blvky�lh� qZs_� \k_]h� wlh� h[tykgy_lky�ijyfuf� hldZahf� hl� \klj_qb� k wlbf� ebphf��Gh�bgh]^Z� ZgZebafh`_l� h[gZjm`blv�� qlh� gZjmrZxsZy� l_g^_gpby� bf__l� hlghr_gb_� g_� d ^Zgghfm� ebpm�� ZgZijZ\e_gZ� ijhlb\� f_klZ�� ]^_� ^he`gh� khklhylvky� k\b^Zgb_�� b k\yaZgZ� k g_ijbylguf\hkihfbgZgb_f�� dhlhjh]h� aZ[u\rbc� ohq_l� ba[_`Zlv�� Beb� \ kemqZ_�� dh]^Z� dlh�lh� aZ[u\Z_lhlijZ\blv� ibkvfh�� ijhlb\hiheh`gZy� l_g^_gpby� fh`_l� [ulv� k\yaZgZ� k kh^_j`Zgb_f� kZfh]hibkvfZ�� gh� \_^v� kh\k_f� g_� bkdexq_gh�� qlh� kZfh� ih� k_[_� [_ah[b^gh_� ibkvfh� \uau\Z_lijhlb\hiheh`gmx�l_g^_gpbx�lhevdh�ihlhfm��qlh�hgh�gZihfbgZ_l�h ^jm]hf��jZg__�gZibkZgghfibkvf_�� dhlhjh_� y\behkv� ih\h^hf� ^ey� ijyfh]h� ijhy\e_gby� ijhlb\hiheh`ghc� \heb�� Lh]^Zfh`gh�kdZaZlv��qlh�ijhlb\hiheh`gZy�\hey�a^_kv�i_j_ghkblky�k lh]h�ij_`g_]h�ibkvfZ��]^_�hgZ[ueZ�hijZ\^ZggZ��gZ�^Zggh_��\ dhlhjhf�_c��kh[kl\_ggh��g_q_fm�ijhlb\hj_qblv��LZdbf�h[jZahf�\u� \b^bl_�� qlh�� ihevamykv� gZrbf� ohly� b ijZ\bevguf� lhedh\Zgb_f�� ke_^m_l� ijhy\eylvk^_j`Zgghklv�b hklhjh`ghklv��lh��qlh�ikboheh]bq_kdb�lh`^_kl\_ggh��fh`_l�[ulv�ijZdlbq_kdbhq_gv�^Z`_�fgh]hagZqgh�Ih^h[gu_�y\e_gby�fh]ml�ihdZaZlvky�\Zf�hq_gv�g_h[uqgufb��<hafh`gh��\u�kdehggu�^Z`_ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� wlZ� ©hihkj_^h\ZggZyª�ijhlb\hiheh`gZy� \hey� oZjZdl_jbam_l� m`_� dZdhc�lhiZlheh]bq_kdbc�ijhp_kk��Gh�kf_x�\Zk�aZ\_jblv��qlh�hgZ�ijhy\ey_lky�m ghjfZevguo�b a^hjh\uoex^_c��<ijhq_f��ijhrm�ihgylv�f_gy�ijZ\bevgh��Y kZf�gb \�dh_c�f_j_�g_�ohqm�ijbagZ\Zlv�gZrbZgZeblbq_kdb_� lhedh\Zgby� g_gZ^_`gufb�� <ur_mihfygmlZy� fgh]hagZqghklv� aZ[u\ZgbygZf_j_gby�kms_kl\m_l�lhevdh�^h�l_o�ihj��ihdZ�fu�g_�ih^\_j]eb�kemqZc�ZgZebam��Z lhedm_f�_]hlhevdh�gZ�hkgh\Zgbb�gZrbo�h[sbo�ij_^iheh`_gbc��?keb�`_�fu�ijh\_^_f�k khhl\_lkl\mxsbfebphf� ZgZeba�� lh� fu� magZ_f� k iheghc� hij_^_e_gghklvx�� [ueZ� eb� \ ^Zgghf� kemqZ_� ijyfZyijhlb\hiheh`gZy�\hey�beb�hldm^Z�hgZ�\hagbdeZ�

Page 37: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

<lhjhc�fhf_gl� aZdexqZ_lky�\ ke_^mxs_f�� _keb�fu�\ [hevrbgkl\_� kemqZ_\� m[_`^Z_fky�qlh�aZ[u\Zgb_�gZf_j_gbc�h[tykgy_lky�ijhlb\hiheh`ghc�\he_c��lh�ihijh[m_f�jZkijhkljZgblvwlh� iheh`_gb_� gZ� ^jm]hc� jy^� kemqZ_\�� dh]^Z� ZgZebabjm_fh_� ebph� g_� ijbagZ_l�� Z hljbpZ_lhldjulmx� gZfb� ijhlb\hiheh`gmx� \hex�� <havf_f� \ dZq_kl\_� ijbf_jh\� hq_gv� qZklh\klj_qZxsb_ky� kemqZb�� dh]^Z� aZ[u\Zxl� \_jgmlv� \aylu_� gZ� \j_fy� dgb]b�� hieZlblv� kq_lZ� beb^he]b��Fu�[m^_f�gZklhevdh�kf_eu��qlh�kdZ`_f� aZ[u\r_fm��dZd�[u�hg� wlh�gb�hljbpZe��qlh�mg_]h�[ueh�gZf_j_gb_�hklZ\blv�dgb]b�k_[_�b g_�hieZlblv�^he]b��bgZq_�_]h�ih\_^_gb_�h[tykgblvg_evay��hg�bf_e�gZf_j_gb_��gh�lhevdh�gbq_]h�g_�agZe�h g_f��gZf��h^gZdh��^hklZlhqgh�lh]h��qlh_]h�\u^Zeh�aZ[u\Zgb_��Hg�fh`_l��dhg_qgh��\hajZablv��qlh�wlh�[ueZ�\k_]h�ebrv�aZ[u\qb\hklv�L_i_jv� \u� magZ_l_� kblmZpbx�� \ dhlhjhc� fu� m`_� h^gZ`^u� hdZaZebkv�� ?keb� fu� ohlbfihke_^h\Zl_evgh�ijh\h^blv�gZrb�lhedh\Zgby�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��dhlhju_�hijZ\^Zeb�k_[y�gZjZaghh[jZaguo� ijbf_jZo�� lh� fu� g_ba[_`gh� ijb^_f� d ij_^iheh`_gbx�� qlh� m q_eh\_dZ� _klvgZf_j_gby�� dhlhju_� fh]ml� ^_ckl\h\Zlv� g_aZ\bkbfh� hl� lh]h�� agZ_l� hg� h gbo� beb� g_l�� Gh�ml\_j`^Zy� wlh�� fu� \klmiZ_f� \ ijhlb\hj_qb_� kh� \k_fb� ]hkih^kl\mxsbfb� b \� `bagb�� b \ikboheh]bb�\a]ey^Zfb�AZ[u\Zgb_�bf_g� kh[kl\_gguo�b bghkljZgguo�gZa\Zgbc�� Z lZd`_� bghkljZgguo� keh\� lh`_fh`gh� k\_klb� d ijhlb\hiheh`ghfm� gZf_j_gbx�� dhlhjh_� ijyfh� beb� dhk\_ggh� gZijZ\e_ghijhlb\� khhl\_lkl\mxs_]h� gZa\Zgby�� G_dhlhju_� ijbf_ju� lZdhc� ijyfhc� g_ijbyagb� y m`_ijb\h^be�jZg__��Gh�dhk\_ggu_�ijbqbgu�a^_kv�hkh[_ggh�qZklu�b lj_[mxl��dZd�ijZ\beh��^ey�bomklZgh\e_gby�lsZl_evgh]h�ZgZebaZ��LZd��gZijbf_j��k_cqZk��\h�\j_fy�\hcgu��dhlhjZy�\ugm^beZgZk�hldZaZlvky�hl�fgh]bo�ij_`gbo�kbfiZlbc��\ kbem�dZdbo�lh�hq_gv�kljZgguo�k\ya_c�ihkljZ^ZeZlZd`_� iZfylv� gZ� bf_gZ� kh[kl\_ggu_�� G_^Z\gh� kh� fghc� ijhbahr_e� kemqZc�� dh]^Z� y g_� fh]\kihfgblv�gZa\Zgb_�[_ah[b^gh]h�fhjZ\kdh]h� ]hjh^Z�;ba_gp��b ZgZeba�ihdZaZe��qlh�ijbqbghc[ueZ�g_�ijyfZy�\jZ`^_[ghklv��Z kha\mqb_�k gZa\Zgb_f�iZeZpph�;ba_gpb�\ Hj\b_lh��]^_�y jZgvr_g_h^ghdjZlgh� `be�� Fhlb\hf� l_g^_gpbb�� gZijZ\e_gghc� ijhlb\� \hkklZgh\e_gby� gZa\Zgby� \iZfylb��a^_kv�\i_j\u_�\uklmiZ_l�ijbgpbi��dhlhjuc�\ihke_^kl\bb�h[gZjm`bl�k\h_�qj_a\uqZcgh[hevrh_� agZq_gb_� ^ey� hij_^_e_gby� ijbqbg� g_\jhlbq_kdbo� kbfilhfh\�� hldZa� iZfylb\kihfbgZlv� lh�� qlh� k\yaZgh� k g_ijbylgufb� hsms_gbyfb�� b \gh\v� i_j_`b\Zlv� wlhg_m^h\hevkl\b_�ijb�\hkihfbgZgbb��GZf_j_gb_�ba[_`Zlv�g_m^h\hevkl\by��bklhqgbdhf�dhlhjh]hkem`Zl� iZfylv� beb� ^jm]b_� ikbobq_kdb_� Zdlu�� ikbobq_kdh_� [_]kl\h� hl� g_m^h\hevkl\by� fuijbagZ_f� dZd� dhg_qguc� fhlb\� g_� lhevdh� ^ey� aZ[u\Zgby� bf_g� b gZa\Zgbc�� gh� b ^ey� fgh]bo^jm]bo� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc�� lZdbo�� dZd� g_bkiheg_gb_� h[_sZggh]h�� hrb[db�aZ[em`^_gby�,UUWXPHU��b ^j�H^gZdh�aZ[u\Zgb_�bf_g��ih�\b^bfhfm��hkh[_ggh�e_]dh�h[tykgblv�ikbohnbabheh]bq_kdbfbijbqbgZfb�� b ihwlhfm� _klv� fgh]h� kemqZ_\�� \ dhlhjuo� fhlb\� g_ijbylgh]h� qm\kl\Z� g_ih^l\_j`^Z_lky�� ?keb� dlh�lh� [u\Z_l� kdehg_g� d aZ[u\Zgbx� bf_g�� lh� iml_f� ZgZeblbq_kdh]hbkke_^h\Zgby� fh`gh� mklZgh\blv�� qlh� hgb� \uiZ^Zxl� ba� iZfylb� g_� lhevdh� ihlhfm�� qlh� kZfb\uau\Zxl�g_ijbylgh_�qm\kl\h�beb�dZd�lh�gZihfbgZxl�h g_f��Z ihlhfm��qlh�hij_^_e_ggh_�bfyhlghkblky�d ^jm]hfm�ZkkhpbZlb\ghfm�djm]m��k dhlhjuf�aZ[u\Zxsbc�khklhbl�\ [he__�bglbfguohlghr_gbyo��Bfy�\ g_f�dZd�[u�aZ^_j`b\Z_lky�b g_�^himkdZ_l�^jm]bo�^_ckl\mxsbo�\ ^Zggucfhf_gl� ZkkhpbZpbc�� ?keb� \u� \kihfgbl_� bkdmkkl\_ggu_� ijb_fu� fg_fhl_ogbdb�� lh� km^b\e_gb_f� aZf_lbl_�� qlh� bf_gZ� aZ[u\Zxlky� \ke_^kl\b_� l_o� `_� k\ya_c�� dhlhju_� gZf_j_ggh

Page 38: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

mklZgZ\eb\Zxl�� qlh[u� ba[_`Zlv� aZ[u\Zgby�� KZfuf� yjdbf� ijbf_jhf� lhfm� y\eyxlky� bf_gZex^_c��dhlhju_�^ey�jZaguo�ebp�fh]ml�bf_lv�jZagh_�ikbobq_kdh_�agZq_gb_��<havf_f��gZijbf_j�bfy�L_h^hj��>ey�dh]h�lh�hgh�gbq_]h�hkh[_ggh]h�g_�agZqbl��^ey�^jm]h]h�`_�wlh�fh`_l�[ulv�bfyhlpZ��[jZlZ��^jm]Z�beb�_]h�kh[kl\_ggh_��Hiul�ZgZeblbq_kdbo�bkke_^h\Zgbc�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�\i_j\hf� kemqZ_� g_l� hkgh\Zgbc� aZ[u\Zlv� wlh� bfy�� _keb� hgh� ijbgZ^e_`bl� ihklhjhgg_fm� ebpm�lh]^Z�dZd�\h�\lhjhf�[m^_l�ihklhyggh�ijhy\eylvky�kdehgghklv�ebrblv�ihklhjhgg_]h�bf_gb��kdhlhjuf�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� Zkkhpbbjmxlky� bglbfgu_� hlghr_gby�� Ij_^iheh`bl_�� qlh� wlhZkkhpbZlb\gh_� lhjfh`_gb_� fh`_l� khq_lZlvky� k ^_ckl\b_f� ijbgpbiZ� g_m^h\hevkl\by�8QOXVWSULQ]LS��b��djhf_�lh]h��k f_oZgbafhf�dhk\_gghc�ijbqbgghklb��b \u�ihemqbl_�ijZ\bevgh_ij_^klZ\e_gb_� h lhf�� gZkdhevdh� keh`gu� ijbqbgu� \j_f_ggh]h� aZ[u\Zgby� bf_g�� Gh� lhevdhlsZl_evguc�ZgZeba�hdhgqZl_evgh�jZkdjh_l�i_j_^�\Zfb�\k_�keh`ghklb�< aZ[u\Zgbb� \i_qZle_gbc� b i_j_`b\Zgbc� _s_� hlq_leb\__� b kbevg__�� q_f� \ aZ[u\Zgbbbf_g�� h[gZjm`b\Z_lky� ^_ckl\b_� l_g^_gpbb� mkljZg_gby� g_ijbylgh]h� ba� \hkihfbgZgby�Iheghklvx�wlh�aZ[u\Zgb_��dhg_qgh��g_evay�hlg_klb�d hrb[hqguf�^_ckl\byf��hgh�hlghkblky�dgbf� lhevdh� \ lhc� f_j_�� \ dZdhc� wlh� aZ[u\Zgb_� \uoh^bl� aZ� jZfdb� h[uqgh]h� hiulZ�� l�� _��gZijbf_j�� dh]^Z� aZ[u\Zxlky� kebrdhf� k\_`b_� beb� kebrdhf� \Z`gu_� \i_qZle_gby� beb� lZdb_�aZ[u\Zgb_� dhlhjuo�ij_ju\Z_l� k\yav� kh[ulbc�� \ hklZevghf� ohjhrh� khojZgb\rboky� \ iZfylb�Ihq_fm�b dZd�fu� \hh[s_� aZ[u\Z_f�� \ lhf�qbke_�b l_� i_j_`b\Zgby�� dhlhju_� hklZ\beb� \ gZkg_khfg_ggh� ]em[hqZcrbc� ke_^�� lZdb_�� dZd� kh[ulbc� i_j\uo� ^_lkdbo� e_l�²� wlh� kh\_jr_ggh^jm]Zy�ijh[e_fZ��\ dhlhjhc� aZsblZ�hl�g_ijbylguo�hsms_gbc�b]jZ_l�hij_^_e_ggmx�jhev��ghh[tykgy_l� ^Ze_dh� g_� \k_�� Lh�� qlh� g_ijbylgu_� \i_qZle_gby� e_]dh� aZ[u\Zxlky�²� nZdl�� g_ih^e_`Zsbc�khfg_gbx��Wlh�aZf_lbeb�jZaebqgu_�ikboheh]b��Z gZ�\_ebdh]h�>Zj\bgZ�wlhl�nZdlijhba\_e� lZdh_� kbevgh_� \i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� hg� \\_e� ^ey� k_[y� ©ahehlh_� ijZ\behª� k hkh[hclsZl_evghklvx� aZibku\Zlv� gZ[ex^_gby�� dhlhju_� ijhlb\hj_qbeb� _]h� l_hjbb�� lZd� dZd� hgm[_^beky��qlh�bf_ggh�hgb�g_�m^_j`b\Zxlky�\ _]h�iZfylb�Lhl�� dlh� \i_j\u_� keurbl� h[� wlhf� ijbgpbi_� aZsblu� hl� g_`_eZl_evguo� \hkihfbgZgbciml_f�aZ[u\Zgby��g_�mimklbl�kemqZy�\hajZablv��ijbau\Zy�hiul��qlh�dZd�jZa�g_ijbylgh_�ljm^ghaZ[ulv�� bf_ggh� hgh� ijhlb\� gZr_c� \heb� \k_� \j_fy� \ha\jZsZ_lky�� qlh[u� gZk� fmqblv�� dZd�gZijbf_j��\hkihfbgZgby�h[�h[b^Zo�b mgb`_gbyo��>Z`_�_keb�wlhl�nZdl�\_j_g��hg�g_�]h^blky�\dZq_kl\_�Zj]mf_glZ�ijhlb\�gZr_]h�ml\_j`^_gby��<Z`gh�\h\j_fy�ihgylv�lh�h[klhyl_evkl\h��qlh^mr_\gZy� `bagv� ²� wlh� Zj_gZ� [hjv[u� ijhlb\hiheh`guo� l_g^_gpbc� b qlh�� \ujZ`Zykv� g_^bgZfbq_kdb�� hgZ� khklhbl� ba� ijhlb\hj_qbc� b ijhlb\hiheh`guo� iZj��GZebqb_� hij_^_e_gghcl_g^_gpbb�g_�bkdexqZ_l�b ijhlb\hiheh`ghc�_c�²�f_klZ�o\Zlbl�^ey�h[_bo��>_eh�lhevdh�\ lhf�dZd� wlb� ijhlb\hiheh`gu_� l_g^_gpbb� hlghkylky� ^jm]� d ^jm]m�� dZdb_� ^_ckl\by� \ul_dZxl� bah^ghc�b dZdb_�ba�^jm]hc�AZl_jb\Zgb_� b aZijylu\Zgb_� \_s_c� gZf� hkh[_ggh� bgl_j_kgu� k\h_c� fgh]hagZqghklvx�jZaghh[jZab_f� l_g^_gpbc�� \ke_^kl\b_� dhlhjuo� fh]ml� ijhbahclb� wlb� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by�H[sbf�^ey�\k_o�kemqZ_\�y\ey_lky�lh��qlh�dZdhc�lh�ij_^f_l�ohl_eb�ihl_jylv��gh�ijbqbgu�b p_ebwlh]h� ^_ckl\by� jZagu_�� <_sv� l_jyxl�� _keb� hgZ� bkihjlbeZkv�� _keb� gZf_j_gu� aZf_gblv� __emqr_c�� _keb� hgZ� jZahgjZ\beZkv�� _keb� gZihfbgZ_l� h q_eh\_d_�� k dhlhjuf� bkihjlbebkvhlghr_gby�� beb� _keb� hgZ� [ueZ� ijbh[j_l_gZ� ijb� h[klhyl_evkl\Zo�� h dhlhjuo� g_� ohq_lky

Page 39: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\kihfbgZlv��K wlhc�`_�p_evx� \_sb� jhgyxl��ihjlyl�b ehfZxl��< h[s_kl\_gghc�`bagb� [uebk^_eZgu�gZ[ex^_gby��qlh�g_`_eZggu_�b \g_[jZqgu_�^_lb�gZfgh]h�[he_ag_gg__��q_f�aZdhggu_�>ey� ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z� g_l� g_h[oh^bfhklb� kkueZlvky� gZ� ]jm[u_� ijb_fu� lZd� gZau\Z_fuo©ijhba\h^bl_evgbp�Zg]_eh\ª� ��\iheg_�^hklZlhqgh�mdZaZlv�gZ�ba\_klgmx�g_[j_`ghklv�\ moh^_aZ� ^_lvfb��< [_j_`ghf� hlghr_gbb� d \_sZf� ijhy\ey_lky� lh�`_� kZfh_�� qlh� b \� hlghr_gbb� d^_lyf�>Ze__��gZ�ihl_jx�fh]ml�[ulv�h[j_q_gu�\_sb��g_�mljZlb\rb_�k\h_c�p_gghklb��\ lhf�kemqZ_�_keb�bf__lky�gZf_j_gb_�qlh�lh�ih`_jl\h\Zlv�km^v[_��aZsblb\�k_[y�wlbf�hl�^jm]hc�\gmrZxs_ckljZo�ihl_jb��Ih^h[gu_�aZdebgZgby�km^v[u��ih�^Zgguf�ikbohZgZebaZ��_s_�hq_gv�qZklu��lZd�qlhgZrb� ihl_jb� y\eyxlky� ^h[jh\hevghc� `_jl\hc�� Ihl_jb� fh]ml� [ulv� lZd`_� ijhy\e_gb_fmijyfkl\Z�b gZdZaZgby�kZfh]h�k_[y��dhjhq_��[he__�hl^Ze_ggu_�fhlb\Zpbb�gZf_j_gby�ihl_jylv\_sv�g_h[hajbfu�>_ckl\by�©ih�hrb[d_ª��9HUJUHLIHQ���dZd�b ^jm]b_�hrb[db��,UUWXPHU��qZklh�bkihevamxl�^eylh]h��qlh[u�\uihegblv�`_eZgby��\ dhlhjuo�ke_^h\Zeh�[u�k_[_�hldZaZlv��GZf_j_gb_�fZkdbjm_lkyijb�wlhf�ih^�kqZkleb\mx�kemqZcghklv��LZd��gZijbf_j��k h^gbf�fhbf�^jm]hf�ijhbahr_e�lZdhckemqZc��hg�^he`_g�[ue�y\gh�ijhlb\�k\h_c�\heb�k^_eZlv�\babl�aZ�]hjh^�ih�`_e_aghc�^hjh]_��ijbi_j_kZ^d_�hg�ih�hrb[d_�k_e�\ ih_a^��dhlhjuc�^hklZ\be�_]h�h[jZlgh�\ ]hjh^��Beb�[u\Z_l�lZd��qlh\h� \j_fy� iml_r_kl\by� ohq_lky� aZ^_j`Zlvky� gZ� iheimlb�� gh� ba�aZ� hij_^_e_gguo� h[yaZl_evkl\g_evay�wlh]h�^_eZlv��b lh]^Z�ijhimkdZ_rv�gm`guc�ih_a^��lZd�qlh�\ugm`^_g�k^_eZlv�`_eZggmxhklZgh\dm�� Beb� dZd� kemqbehkv� k fhbf� iZpb_glhf�� dhlhjhfm� y aZij_lbe� a\hgblv� ex[bfhc`_gsbg_��gh�hg��`_eZy�iha\hgblv�fg_�� ©ih�hrb[d_ª�� ©\ aZ^mfqb\hklbª�gZa\Ze�g_ijZ\bevgucghf_j� b \k_�lZdb� [ue� kh_^bg_g� k g_c�� Ij_djZkguc� ijZdlbq_kdbc� ijbf_j� ijyfh]hg_ijZ\bevgh]h�^_ckl\by��k\yaZggh]h�k ih\j_`^_gb_f�ij_^f_lZ��ijb\h^bl�h^bg�bg`_g_j�©G_^Z\gh�y k�fhbfb�dhee_]Zfb�jZ[hlZe�\ eZ[hjZlhjbb�bgklblmlZ�gZ^ �(QJHOPDFKHULQQHQ� �w\n_fbaf��ijhba\h^bl_evgbpu�Zg]_eh\��²�gZjh^gh_�\ujZ`_gb_��h[hagZqZxs__�`_gsbg�lZd�iehoh�ijbkfZljb\Zxsbo�aZ�^Zggufb�bf�gZ�\hkiblZgb_�^_lvfb��qlh�l_�ba�aZ�g_^hklZldZ�iblZgby�\kdhj_mfbjZxl��l��_��©ij_`^_\j_f_ggh�klZgh\ylky�Zg]_eZfbª���Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�k_jb_c�keh`guo�wdki_jbf_glh\�ih�mijm]hklb��jZ[hlZ��aZ�dhlhjmx�fu�\ayebkv�^h[jh\hevgh�aZlygmeZkv��h^gZdh��^hevr_��q_f�fu�ij_^iheZ]Zeb��H^gZ`^u� y k� dhee_]hc�N��hiylv�ihreb� \eZ[hjZlhjbx��hg�`Zeh\Zeky��qlh�bf_ggh�k_]h^gy�_fm�g_�ohl_ehkv�[u�l_jylv�lZd�fgh]h�\j_f_gb�m g_]h�fgh]h�^_e�^hfZ��y fh]�lhevdh�kh]eZkblvky�k gbf�b \�rmldm�kdZaZe��\kihfgb\�kemqZc�gZijhrehc�g_^_e_�� Ä;m^_f�gZ^_ylvky��qlh�b k_]h^gy�fZrbgZ�hiylv�bkihjlblky��lZd�qlh�hklZ\bfjZ[hlm�b ihjZgvr_�mc^_f��<h� \j_fy� jZ[hlu� kemqbehkv� lZd�� qlh� dhee_]Z�N�� ^he`_g� [ue� mijZ\eylv� djZghf� ij_kkZ�hklhjh`gh� hldju\Zy� djZg� b f_^e_ggh� \imkdZy� `b^dhklv� ih^� ^Z\e_gb_f� ba� ZddmfmeylhjZ� \pbebg^j� ]b^jZ\ebq_kdh]h� ij_kkZ�� Jmdh\h^bl_ev� hiulZ� klhbl� m fZghf_ljZ� b�� dh]^Z� ^Z\e_gb_^hklb]Z_l�gm`gh]h�mjh\gy��djbqbl��ÄKlhi���GZ�wlm�dhfZg^m�N��kh�\k_c�kbehc�ih\hjZqb\Z_l�djZg\e_\h� �\k_� djZgu� [_a� bkdexq_gby� aZdju\Zxlky� ih\hjhlhf� \ijZ\h���� Ba�aZ� wlh]h� \ ij_kk_gZqbgZ_l� ^_ckl\h\Zlv� ihegh_� ^Z\e_gb_� ZddmfmeylhjZ�� ih^\h^ysZy� ljm[dZ� g_� \u^_j`b\Z_l� behiZ_lky�²�kh\k_f�g_\bggZy�ihehfdZ�fZrbgu��gh�fu�\ugm`^_gu�ij_j\Zlv�gZ�k_]h^gy�jZ[hlm�bihclb�^hfhc�

Page 40: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

OZjZdl_jgh�� \ijhq_f�� qlh� g_dhlhjh_� \j_fy� kimkly�� dh]^Z� fu� h[km`^Zeb� wlhl� kemqZc�ijbyl_ev�N��Z[khexlgh�g_�ihfgbe�fhbo�keh\�h ihehfd_�fZrbgu��dhlhju_�y ihfgx�kh\_jr_gghhlq_leb\hª�Wlhl� kemqZc� fh`_l� gZ\_klb� gZ� ij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh� g_� \k_]^Z� [_ah[b^gZy� kemqZcghklv^_eZ_l�jmdb�\Zr_c�ijbkem]b�lZdbfb�hiZkgufb�\jZ]Zfb�\Zr_]h�^hfZ��A^_kv�`_�\klZ_l�\hijhk�\k_]^Z�eb�kemqZcgh�gZghkbrv�k_[_�\j_^�b ih^\_j]Z_rv�hiZkghklb�kh[kl\_ggh_�kms_kl\h\Zgb_�<k_�wlh�iheh`_gby��agZqbfhklv�dhlhjuo�\u�ijb�kemqZ_�fh`_l_�ijh\_jblv�gZ�hkgh\Zgbb�ZgZebaZgZ[ex^_gbc�M\Z`Z_fu_� kemrZl_eb�� Wlh� ^Ze_dh� g_� \k_�� qlh� fh`gh� [ueh� [u� kdZaZlv� h[� hrb[hqguo^_ckl\byo��?klv�_s_�fgh]h�lZdh]h��qlh�gm`gh�bkke_^h\Zlv� �b h[km^blv��Gh�y ^h\he_g��_keb�\j_amevlZl_�gZrbo�[_k_^�\u�i_j_kfhlj_eb�ij_`gb_�\a]ey^u�b ]hlh\u�ijbgylv�gh\u_��<ijhq_f��yh]jZgbqmkv� l_f�� qlh� g_dhlhju_� klhjhgu� ^_eZ� hklZgmlky� g_\uykg_ggufb��BamqZy� hrb[hqgu_^_ckl\by��fu�fh`_f� ^hdZaZlv� ^Ze_dh� g_� \k_� gZrb� iheh`_gby�� gh� ^ey� bo� ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z�fu[m^_f�ijb\e_dZlv�g_� lhevdh� wlhl�fZl_jbZe��;hevrZy�p_gghklv� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc� ^ey� gZkkhklhbl�\ lhf��qlh�wlh�hq_gv�qZklh�\klj_qZxsb_ky�y\e_gby��dhlhju_�fh`gh�e_]dh�gZ[ex^Zlv�gZkZfhf�k_[_��b bo�ihy\e_gb_�kh\_jr_ggh�g_�k\yaZgh�k dZdbf�eb[h�[he_ag_gguf�khklhygb_f��<aZdexq_gb_�y ohl_e�[u�hklZgh\blvky�lhevdh�gZ�h^ghf�\hijhk_��gZ�dhlhjuc�_s_�g_�hl\_lbe��_kebex^b��dZd�fu�wlh�\b^_eb�\h�fgh]bo�ijbf_jZo��lZd�[ebadh�ih^oh^yl�d ihgbfZgbx�hrb[hqguo^_ckl\bc�b qZklh�\_^ml�k_[y�lZd��dZd�[m^lh�hgb�^h]Z^u\Zxlky�h[�bo�kfuke_��lh�dZd�`_�fh`ghkqblZlv� wlb� y\e_gby� kemqZcgufb�� ebr_ggufb� kfukeZ� b agZq_gby� b lZd� wg_j]bqghkhijhlb\eylvky�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhfm�bo�h[tykg_gbx"<u� ijZ\u� ²� wlh� m^b\bl_evgh� b lj_[m_l� k\h_]h� h[tykg_gby�� Gh� y \Zf� _]h� g_� ^Zf�� Zihkl_i_ggh�ih^\_^m�d ihgbfZgbx�\aZbfhk\ya_c��ba�dhlhjh]h�h[tykg_gb_�hldjh_lky�\Zf�kZfh�ihk_[_�[_a�fh_]h�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh]h�mqZklby�IYL:Y�E?DPBYLjm^ghklb�b i_j\u_�ihiuldb�ihgbfZgbyM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Dh]^Z�lh� [ueh� k^_eZgh� hldjulb_�� qlh� kbfilhfu� [he_agbg_dhlhjuo�g_j\gh[hevguo�bf_xl� kfuke� ��GZ� wlhf� [ue� hkgh\Zg�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbc�f_lh^e_q_gby�� <h� \j_fy� wlh]h� e_q_gby� h[gZjm`behkv�� qlh� \aZf_g� kbfilhfh\� m [hevguo� lZd`_ihy\eyebkv�kgh\b^_gby��LZd�\hagbdeh�ij_^iheh`_gb_��qlh�b wlb�kgh\b^_gby�bf_xl�kfuke�Gh�fu�g_�ihc^_f�wlbf�bklhjbq_kdbf�iml_f��Z kh\_jrbf�h[jZlguc�oh^��Fu�ohlbf�ihdZaZlvkfuke�kgh\b^_gbc�b lZdbf�h[jZahf�ih^hclb�d bamq_gbx�g_\jhah\�����Wlhl�oh^�hijZ\^Zg��lZddZd�bamq_gb_�kgh\b^_gbc�g_�lhevdh�emqrbc�kihkh[�ih^]hlh\db�d bkke_^h\Zgbx�g_\jhah\��kZfhkgh\b^_gb_�lh`_�g_\jhlbq_kdbc�kbfilhf��dhlhjuc�d lhfm�`_��qlh�bf__l�^ey�gZk�g_hp_gbfh_ij_bfms_kl\h��ijhy\ey_lky�m \k_o�a^hjh\uo��>Z`_�_keb�[u�\k_�ex^b�[ueb�a^hjh\u�b lhevdh\b^_eb� kgh\b^_gby��fu�fh]eb�[u�ih�bo� kgh\b^_gbyf� k^_eZlv�\k_� l_�\u\h^u��d dhlhjuf�gZkijb\_eh�bamq_gb_�g_\jhah\�BlZd��k^_eZ_f�kgh\b^_gb_�h[t_dlhf�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�bkke_^h\Zgby��<gh\v�h[uqguc�

Page 41: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_^hklZlhqgh� hp_g_gguc� n_ghf_g�� dZd� [m^lh� ebr_gguc� ijZdlbq_kdhc� agZqbfhklb�� dZd� bhrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by�� k dhlhjufb� hg� bf__l� lh� h[s__�� qlh� ijhy\ey_lky� b m� a^hjh\uo��Gh� \hklZevghf� mkeh\by� gZr_c� jZ[hlu� f_g__� [eZ]hijbylgu�� Hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by� \k_]h� ebrvg_^hhp_gb\Zebkv� gZmdhc�� bo� fZeh� bamqZeb�� gh�� \ dhgp_� dhgph\�� g_l� gbq_]h� ihklu^gh]haZgbfZlvky�bfb��IjZ\^Z��]h\hjbeb��qlh�_klv�\_sb�ih\Z`g__��gh�fh`gh�b ba�gbo�dh_�qlh�ba\e_qv�AZgbfZlvky�`_�kgh\b^_gbyfb�g_�lhevdh�g_ijZdlbqgh�b baebrg_��gh�ijhklh�klu^gh��wlh�\e_q_laZ� kh[hc� mij_db� \ g_gZmqghklb�� \uau\Z_l� ih^haj_gb_� \ ebqghc� kdehgghklb� d fbklbpbafm�Qlh[u�\jZq�aZgbfZeky�kgh\b^_gbyfb��dh]^Z�^Z`_�\ g_\jhiZlheh]bb�b ikbobZljbb�klhevdh�[he__k_jv_aguo�\_s_c��himoheb�\_ebqbghc�k y[ehdh��dhlhju_�^Z\yl�gZ�fha]��hj]Zg�^mr_\ghc�`bagb�djh\hbaebygby��ojhgbq_kdb_�\hkiZe_gby��ijb�dhlhjuo�baf_g_gby�ldZg_c�fh`gh�ihdZaZlv�ih^fbdjhkdhihf�� G_l�� kgh\b^_gb_� ²� wlh� kebrdhf� gbqlh`guc� b g_^hklhcguc� bkke_^h\Zgbyh[t_dl�B _s_�h^gZ�hkh[_gghklv��ijhlb\hj_qZsZy�\k_f�lj_[h\Zgbyf�lhqgh]h�bkke_^h\Zgby��<_^vijb� bkke_^h\Zgbb� kgh\b^_gby� g_l� m\_j_gghklb� ^Z`_� \ h[t_dl_�� ;j_^h\Zy� b^_y�� gZijbf_j�ijhy\ey_lky� ykgh� b hij_^_e_ggh�� ©Y²dblZckdbc� bfi_jZlhjª�²aZy\ey_l� [hevghc� \h\k_mkeurZgb_���: kgh\b^_gb_"�?]h�qZklh�\hh[s_�g_evay�jZkkdZaZlv��JZa\_�_klv�m jZk� Cha_n�;j_c_j�\ ����������]]��Kj��lZd`_�fhb�e_dpbb�©H ikbohZgZeba_ª������Z���ijhqblZggu_�b :f_jbd_��b ©Dbklhjbb�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�^\b`_gbyª������G��kdZaqbdZ� ]ZjZglby�� qlh� hg� i_j_^Z_l� kgh\b^_gb_� ijZ\bevgh�� Z g_� baf_gy_l� fgh]h_� \ijhp_kk_� i_j_kdZaZ�� qlh�lh� ijb^mfu\Z_l�� \ke_^kl\b_� g_hij_^_e_gghklb� \hkihfbgZgbc";hevrbgkl\h� kgh\b^_gbc� \hh[s_� g_evay� \kihfgblv�� hgb� aZ[u\Zxlky� p_ebdhf�� \iehlv� ^hf_evqZcrbo�njZ]f_glh\��B gZ� lhedh\Zgbb� wlh]h� fZl_jbZeZ� b ^he`gZ� hkgh\u\Zlvky� gZmqgZyikboheh]by�beb�f_lh^�e_q_gby�[hevguo"Hij_^_e_ggh_�ij_m\_ebq_gb_�\ wlhc�hp_gd_�fh`_l�gZk�gZklhjh`blv��<hajZ`_gby�ijhlb\kgh\b^_gby�dZd�h[t_dlZ�bkke_^h\Zgby��hq_\b^gh��aZoh^yl�kebrdhf�^Ze_dh��K ml\_j`^_gb_f�hg_agZqbl_evghklb�bamqZ_fh]h�h[t_dlZ�fu�m`_�bf_eb�^_eh��jZa[bjZy�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by��Fu]h\hjbeb� k_[_�� qlh� \_ebdh_� fh`_l� ijhy\eylvky� b \� fZehf�� Qlh� dZkZ_lky� g_hij_^_e_gghklbkgh\b^_gby��lh�bf_ggh�hgZ�y\ey_lky�oZjZdl_jghc�_]h�hkh[_gghklvx�gZjy^m�k ^jm]bfb��y\e_gbyfg_evay� ij_^ibku\Zlv� bo� k\hckl\Z�� : djhf_� lh]h�� _klv� \_^v� ykgu_� b \iheg_� hij_^_e_ggu_kgh\b^_gby�� < ikbobZljbb� kms_kl\mxl� b ^jm]b_� h[t_dlu�� dhlhju_� bf_xl� lhl� `_g_hij_^_e_gguc� oZjZdl_j�� gZijbf_j�� fgh]b_� kemqZb� gZ\yaqb\uo� ij_^klZ\e_gbc�� dhlhjufb�h^gZdh�� aZgbfZxlky� j_ki_dlZ[_evgu_�� ijbagZggu_� ikbobZlju��Fg_� \kihfbgZ_lky� kemqZc� bafh_c�\jZq_[ghc�ijZdlbdb��;hevgZy�h[jZlbeZkv�dh�fg_�kh�keh\Zfb��©M f_gy�lZdh_�qm\kl\h��dZd[m^lh� y ijbqbgbeZ� \j_^� beb� ohl_eZ� wlh� k^_eZlv�`b\hfm� kms_kl\m� ²� j_[_gdm"�²� beb� g_l�kdhj__� kh[Zd_�²� fh`_l� [ulv�� k[jhkbeZ� k fhklZ� beb� k^_eZeZ� qlh�lh� ^jm]h_ª�� Fu� fh`_fmkljZgblv� g_lhqghklv� \hkihfbgZgby� h kgh\b^_gbb�� _keb� [m^_f� kqblZlv� kgh\b^_gb_f� lh�� qlhjZkkdZau\Z_l�\b^_\rbc�khg��g_�h[jZsZy�\gbfZgby�gZ�lh��qlh�hg�fh]�aZ[ulv�beb�baf_gblv�ijb\hkihfbgZgbb�� < dhgp_� dhgph\�� g_evay� `_� lZd� [_ah]h\hjhqgh� ml\_j`^Zlv�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_y\ey_lky� q_f�lh� g_agZqbl_evguf�� GZf� ba\_klgh� ba� kh[kl\_ggh]h� hiulZ�� qlh� gZkljh_gb_�� kdhlhjuf�ijh[m`^Z_rvky�hl�kgZ��fh`_l�^eblvky�\_kv�^_gv��\jZqb�gZ[ex^Zxl�kemqZb��dh]^Z�khkgh\b^_gby� gZqbgZ_lky� ^mr_\gZy� [he_agv� b [j_^h\Zy� b^_y� [_j_lky� ba� wlh]h� kgh\b^_gby�

Page 42: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ba\_klgu�bklhjbq_kdb_�ebqghklb��dhlhjuo�ih[m^beb�d \Z`guf�^_eZf�kgh\b^_gby��Ihwlhfm�baZ^Z_rvky�\hijhkhf��hldm^Z��kh[kl\_ggh��\ gZmqguo�djm]Zo�\hagbdZ_l�ij_aj_gb_�d kgh\b^_gbx"Y ^mfZx��qlh�hgh�y\ey_lky�j_Zdpb_c�gZ�kebrdhf�\ukhdmx�hp_gdm�kgh\b^_gbc�\ ^j_\gb_\j_f_gZ��Ba\_klgh�� qlh� \hkklZgh\blv� ijhreh_� ²� ^_eh� g_e_]dh_�� gh� k m\_j_gghklvx� fh`ghij_^iheh`blv�²�iha\hevl_�fg_�wlm�rmldm�²�qlh�gZrb�ij_^db������e_l�lhfm�gZaZ^�b jZgvr_lhqgh� lZd�`_� \b^_eb� kgu�� dZd� b fu��GZkdhevdh� fu� agZ_f�� ^j_\gb_� gZjh^u� ijb^Z\Zeb� \k_fkgh\b^_gbyf�[hevrh_�agZq_gb_�b kqblZeb�bo�ijZdlbq_kdb�agZqbfufb��Hgb�\b^_eb�\ gbo�agZdb[m^ms_]h��bkdZeb�\ gbo�ij_^agZf_gh\Zgby��>ey�^j_\gbo�]j_dh\�b ^jm]bo�gZjh^h\�;eb`g_]h�bKj_^g_]h�<hklhdZ�\h_gguc�ihoh^�[_a�lhedh\Zl_ey�kgh\b^_gbc�[ue�ih^qZk�lZd�`_�g_\hafh`_g�dZd� k_]h^gy� [_a� \ha^mrghc� jZa\_^db�� Dh]^Z� :e_dkZg^j� FZd_^hgkdbc� ij_^ijbgbfZe� k\hcaZ\h_\Zl_evguc� ihoh^�� \ _]h� k\bl_� [ueb� kZfu_� agZf_gblu_� lhedh\Zl_eb� kgh\b^_gbc�� =hjh^Lbj��jZkiheh`_gguc�lh]^Z�_s_�gZ�hkljh\_��hdZaZe�pZjx�lZdh_�yjhklgh_�khijhlb\e_gb_��qlh�hgih^mfu\Ze�m`_�h[�hldZa_�hl�_]h�hkZ^u��Gh�\hl�h^gZ`^u�ghqvx�hg�m\b^_e�\h�kg_�lZgpmxsbo�\ljbmfn_�kZlbjh\�b��dh]^Z�jZkkdZaZe�wlh�kgh\b^_gb_�lhedh\Zl_ex��magZe��qlh�_fm�ij_^\_sZ_lkyih[_^Z� gZ^� ]hjh^hf�� Hg� ijbdZaZe� \hckdZf� gZklmiZlv� b \aye� Lbj�� Qlh[u� magZlv� [m^ms__�wljmkdb� b jbfeyg_� ihevah\Zebkv� ^jm]bfb� f_lh^Zfb�� gh� \ l_q_gb_� \k_]h� weebgkdh�jbfkdh]hi_jbh^Z� lhedh\Zgb_� kgh\b^_gbc� dmevlb\bjh\Zehkv� b \ukhdh� p_gbehkv�� Ba� ebl_jZlmju�aZgbfZ\r_cky�wlbfb�\hijhkZfb��^h�gZk�^hreh��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��]eZ\gh_�ijhba\_^_gb_��dgb]Z:jl_fb^hjZ� ba� >Ze^bkZ�� dhlhjh]h� hlghkyl� dh� \j_f_gb� bfi_jZlhjZ� :^jbZgZ�� DZd� ihlhfkemqbehkv�� qlh�bkdmkkl\h� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc�ijbreh� \ miZ^hd�b kgh\b^_gbx� i_j_klZeb^h\_jylv��y g_�fh]m�\Zf�kdZaZlv��Ijhk\_s_gb_�g_�fh]eh�ku]jZlv�lml�[hevrmx�jhev��\_^v�l_fgh_kj_^g_\_dh\v_� khojZgbeh� \ lhf� `_� \b^_� ]hjZa^h� [he__� Z[kmj^gu_� \_sb�� q_f� Zglbqgh_lhedh\Zgb_� kgh\b^_gbc�� HklZ_lky� dhgklZlbjh\Zlv�� qlh� bgl_j_k� d kgh\b^_gbx� ihkl_i_gghhimklbeky� ^h� km_\_jby� b fh]� hklZlvky� lhevdh� kj_^b� g_h[jZah\Zgguo� ex^_c�� Ihke_^g__aehmihlj_[e_gb_�lhedh\Zgb_f�kgh\b^_gbc�gZoh^bl�k_[y�\ gZrb�^gb�\ ihiuld_�magZlv�ba�kgh\qbkeZ��dhlhju_�ke_^m_l�\ulZsblv�ijb�b]j_�\ ehlh��GZijhlb\��kh\j_f_ggZy�lhqgZy�gZmdZ�kgh\Z\_jgmeZkv� d kgh\b^_gbyf�� gh� lhevdh� k gZf_j_gb_f� ijh\_jblv� gZ� gbo� k\hb�nbabheh]bq_kdb_l_hjbb�� M \jZq_c� kgh\b^_gb_�� dhg_qgh�� kqblZ_lky� g_� ikbobq_kdbf� Zdlhf�� Z ijhy\e_gb_f� \^mr_\ghc�`bagb�khfZlbq_kdbo�jZa^jZ`_gbb��;bgi�\ �����]��h[ty\b\�kgh\b^_gb_�©nbabq_kdbfijhp_kkhf��\h�\k_o�kemqZyo�[_kihe_aguf��\h�fgh]bo�`_�ijyfh�lZdb�[he_ag_gguf��hl�dhlhjh]hfbjh\Zy�^mrZ�b [_kkf_jlb_�hlklhyl�lZd�`_�^Ze_dh��dZd�]hem[hc�wnbj�hl� aZjhkr_c�khjgydZfbi_kqZghc� ih\_joghklb� \ kZfhc� ]em[hdhc� ^hebg_ª� �%LQ]�� ������ �����Fhjb� �0DXU\�� ������ ���kjZ\gb\Z_l� _]h� k [_kihjy^hqgufb� ih^_j]b\Zgbyfb� ieykdi� k\�� <bllZ� \ ijhlb\hiheh`ghklvdhhj^bgbjh\Zgguf� ^\b`_gbyf� ghjfZevgh]h� q_eh\_dZ�� klZjh_� kjZ\g_gb_� ijh\h^bl� iZjZee_evf_`^m� kh^_j`Zgb_f� kgh\b^_gby� b a\mdZfb�� dhlhju_� ijhba\_eb� [u� ©^_kylv� iZevp_\g_k\_^ms_]h�\ fmaud_�q_eh\_dZ��dZkZxs_]hky�bgkljmf_glZª��6WUXPSHOO������������Lhedh\Zlv� ²� agZqbl� gZclb� kdjuluc� kfuke�� ijb� lZdhc� `_� hp_gd_� kgh\b^_gby� h[� wlhf�dhg_qgh�� g_� fh`_l� [ulv� b j_qb�� Ihkfhljbl_� hibkZgb_� kgh\b^_gby� m <mg^lZ� �������� Ch^ey�������b ^jm]bo�[he__�iha^gbo�nbehkhnh\��k p_evx�ijbgbablv�kgh\b^_gb_�hgb�^h\hevkl\mxlkyi_j_qbke_gb_f� hldehg_gbc� ijhbkoh^ysbo� \h� kg_� ijhp_kkh\� hl� fure_gby� \ khklhygbb[h^jkl\h\Zgby�� hlf_qZxl� jZkiZ^� ZkkhpbZpbc�� hldZa� hl� djblbdb�� bkdexq_gb_� \k_]h� agZgby� b^jm]b_� ijbagZdb� ihgb`_gghc� jZ[hlhkihkh[ghklb� ikbobdb�� ?^bgkl\_ggh� p_ggu_� nZdlu� ^ey

Page 43: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ihgbfZgby� kgh\b^_gby�� dhlhjufb� fu� h[yaZgu� lhqghc� gZmd_�� ^Zeb� bkke_^h\Zgby� \ebygbynbabq_kdbo� jZa^jZ`_gbb�� ^_ckl\mxsbo� \h� \j_fy� kgZ�� gZ� kh^_j`Zgb_� kgh\b^_gby�� FujZkiheZ]Z_f� ^\mfy� lheklufb� lhfZfb� wdki_jbf_glZevguo� bkke_^h\Zgbc� kgh\b^_gbc� g_^Z\ghmf_jr_]h�ghj\_`kdh]h�Z\lhjZ��>`��Fhmjeb�<hev^Z��\ �����b �����]]��i_j_\_^_gu�gZ�g_f_pdbcyaud���\ dhlhjuo�baeZ]Zxlky�ihqlb�bkdexqbl_evgh�j_amevlZlu�bamq_gby�baf_g_gbc�iheh`_gbydhg_qghkl_c��Bo�gZf�jZko\Zeb\Zxl�dZd�h[jZa_p�bkke_^h\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc��Fh`_l_�k_[_�l_i_jvij_^klZ\blv��qlh�[u�kdZaZeb�ij_^klZ\bl_eb�lhqghc�eZmdb��_keb�[u�hgb�magZeb��qlh�fu�ohlbfihiulZlvky�gZclb�kfuke�kgh\b^_gbc"�<hafh`gh��hgb�m`_�wlh�b kdZaZeb��Gh�fu�g_�^Z^bf�k_[yaZim]Zlv��?keb�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�fh]ml�bf_lv�kfukl��lh�b kgh\b^_gby�lh`_��Z hrb[hqgu_^_ckl\by�\ hq_gv�fgh]bo�kemqZyo�bf_xl�kfuke��dhlhjuc�mkdhevaZ_l�hl�bkke_^h\Zgby�lhqgufbf_lh^Zfb��IjbagZ_f�`_�k_[y�lhevdh�klhjhggbdZfb�ij_^jZkkm^dh\�^j_\gbo�b ijhklh]h�gZjh^Z�bihc^_f�ih�klhiZf�Zglbqguo�lhedh\Zl_e_c�kgh\b^_gbc�>ey�j_r_gby�ijh[e_fu�fu�ij_`^_�\k_]h�^he`gu�khjb_glbjh\Zlvky��h[haj_lv�\ h[s_f�\kxh[eZklv� kgh\b^_gbc�� <_^v� qlh� lZdh_� kgh\b^_gb_� �7UDXP�"� ?]h� ljm^gh� hij_^_eblv� \ h^ghfij_^eh`_gbb�� Gh� fu� b g_� iulZ_fky� ^Z\Zlv� hij_^_e_gb_� lZf�� ]^_� ^hklZlhqgh� mdZaZgby� gZh[s_ba\_klguc�fZl_jbZe��H^gZdh�gZf�ke_^h\Zeh�[u�\u^_eblv�\ kgh\b^_gbb�kms_kl\_ggh_��=^_`_�_]h�fh`gh�gZclb"�< wlhc�h[eZklb�bf_xl�f_klh� lZdb_�g_\_jhylgu_�jZaebqby��jZaebqby�ih\k_f� ebgbyf�� Kms_kl\_gguf� [m^_l�� ih`Zemc�� lh�� qlh� fu� fh`_f� kqblZlv� h[sbf� ^ey� \k_okgh\b^_gbc�<h�\kydhf�kemqZ_��i_j\h_��qlh�h[t_^bgy_l�\k_�kgh\b^_gby�²�wlh�lh��qlh�fu�ijb�wlhf�kibf�Hq_\b^gh�� \b^_lv� kgh\b^_gby� �7UDXPH�� \h� \j_fy� kgZ� �6FKODI�� y\ey_lky� ^mr_\ghc� `bagvx�dhlhjZy� bf__l� ba\_klgu_� ZgZeh]bb� k lZdh\hc� \ khklhygbb� [h^jkl\h\Zgby� b \� lh� `_� \j_fyh[gZjm`b\Z_l�j_adb_�hlebqby�hl�g__��Wlh�hij_^_e_gb_�[ueh�m`_�^Zgh�:jbklhl_e_f��<hafh`gh�qlh� f_`^m� kgh\b^_gb_f� b kghf� kms_kl\mxl� _s_� [he__� [ebadb_� hlghr_gby��Hl� kgh\b^_gbyfh`gh� ijhkgmlvky�� hq_gv� qZklh� kgh\b^_gb_� \hagbdZ_l� ijb� kihglZgghf� ijh[m`^_gbb�� ijbgZkbevkl\_gghf� gZjmr_gbb� aZkuiZgby�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� kgh\b^_gb_�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� y\ey_lkyijhf_`mlhqguf� khklhygb_f�f_`^m� kghf�b [h^jkl\h\Zgb_f��< lZdhf� kemqZ_�gZf�ijboh^blkyh[jZlblvky�dh�kgm��Qlh�`_�lZdh_�khg"Wlh�nbabheh]bq_kdZy�b [bheh]bq_kdZy�ijh[e_fZ��\ dhlhjhc� _s_�fgh]h� kihjgh]h��Fu�g_fh`_f� a^_kv� gbq_]h� kdZaZlv� hdhgqZl_evgh�� gh� y iheZ]Zx�� fh`gh� ihiulZlvky� ^Zlvikboheh]bq_kdmx�oZjZdl_jbklbdm�kgZ��Khg�²�wlh�khklhygb_��\ dhlhjhf�y gbq_]h�g_�ohqm�agZlv�h\g_rg_f�fbj_��fhc�bgl_j_k� d g_fm� m]ZkZ_l��Y ih]jm`Zxkv� \ khg�� hloh^y� hl� \g_rg_]h�fbjZ�aZ^_j`b\Zy�_]h�jZa^jZ`_gby��Y aZkuiZx�lZd`_��_keb�y hl�g_]h�mklZe��AZkuiZy��y dZd�[u�]h\hjx\g_rg_fm�fbjm��©HklZ\v�f_gy�\ ihdh_��y ohqm�kiZlvª��J_[_ghd�aZy\ey_l�ijhlb\hiheh`gh_��©Yg_� ihc^m� kiZlv�� y _s_� g_� mklZe�� y ohqm� _s_� qlh�gb[m^v� i_j_`blvª�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�[bheh]bq_kdhc�p_evx� kgZ��ih�\b^bfhfm�� y\ey_lky�hl^uo�� _]h�ikboheh]bq_kdbf�ijbagZdhf�²ihl_jy�bgl_j_kZ�d fbjm��GZr_�hlghr_gb_�d fbjm��\ dhlhjuc�fu�lZd�g_hohlgh�ijbreb��dZ`_lky�g_k_l�k kh[hc�lh��qlh�fu�g_�fh`_f�_]h�\ughkblv�g_ij_ju\gh��Ihwlhfm�fu�\j_fy�hl�\j_f_gb\ha\jZsZ_fky�\ khklhygb_��\ dhlhjhf�gZoh^bebkv�^h�ihy\e_gby�gZ�k\_l��l��_��\h�\gmljbmljh[gh_kms_kl\h\Zgb_� ���Fu� kha^Z_f�� ih� djZcg_c�f_j_�� kh\_jr_ggh� ZgZeh]bqgu_� mkeh\by�� dhlhju_[ueb�lh]^Z��l_ieh��l_fgh�b gbqlh�g_�jZa^jZ`Z_l��G_dhlhju_�_s_�k\hjZqb\Zxlky�\ dem[hq_d�b

Page 44: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijbgbfZxl�\h�kg_�lZdh_�`_�iheh`_gb_�l_eZ��dZd�\ mljh[_�fZl_jb��Fu�\u]ey^bf�lZd��dZd�[m^lhhl� gZk�� \ajhkeuo�� \ fbj_� hklZ_lky� lhevdh� ^\_� lj_lb�� Z h^gZ� lj_lv� \hh[s_� _s_� g_� jh^beZkv�DZ`^h_�ijh[m`^_gb_�mljhf�y\ey_lky�dZd�[u�gh\uf�jh`^_gb_f��H khklhygbb�ihke_�kgZ�fu�^Z`_]h\hjbf��y dZd�[m^lh�\gh\v�jh^beky��ohly�ijb�wlhf�fu��\_jhylgh��^_eZ_f�\_kvfZ�g_ijZ\bevgh_ij_^iheh`_gb_�h[�h[s_f�kZfhqm\kl\bb�gh\hjh`^_ggh]h��?klv�hkgh\Zgby�ij_^iheZ]Zlv��qlh�hgqm\kl\m_l�k_[y��kdhj__�\k_]h��hq_gv�g_mxlgh��H jh`^_gbb�fu�lZd`_�]h\hjbf��m\b^_lv�k\_l�?keb� khg� ihgbfZlv� bf_ggh� lZd�� lh� kgh\b^_gb_� \hh[s_� g_� \oh^bl� \ _]h� ijh]jZffm�� ZdZ`_lky�kdhj__�dZdhc�lh�g_`_eZl_evghc�ijbf_kvx��Fu�^Z`_�kqblZ_f��qlh�khg�[_a�kgh\b^_gbc²� emqrbc� b _^bgkl\_ggh� ijZ\bevguc�� <h� kg_� g_� ^he`gh� [ulv� gbdZdhc� ^mr_\ghc^_yl_evghklb�� _keb�`_� hgZ� \k_�lZdb�ijhbkoh^bl�� lh�fu�g_� ^hklb]Z_f� khklhygby� Z[khexlgh]hihdhy��hl�hklZldh\�^mr_\ghc�^_yl_evghklb�g_evay�iheghklvx�hk\h[h^blvky��Wlb�hklZldb�b _klvkgh\b^_gby�� Gh� lh]^Z� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� dZ`_lky�� qlh� kgh\b^_gbx� g_� gm`_g� kfuke�� Ijbhrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\byo� ^_eh� h[klhyeh� bgZq_�� wlh� [ueb� \k_�lZdb� ^_ckl\by� \h� \j_fy[h^jkl\h\Zgby�� Gh� _keb� y kiex�� kh\k_f� hklZgh\be� ^mr_\gmx� ^_yl_evghklv� b lhevdhhij_^_e_ggu_�__ hklZldb�g_�kfh]�ih^Z\blv��wlh�_s_�g_�agZqbl��qlh�wlb�hklZldb�bf_xl�kfuke��>Zfg_� b g_� gm`_g� wlhl� kfuke�� lZd� dZd� \_^v� \k_� hklZevgh_� \ fh_c� ^mr_\ghc�`bagb� kibl�� Lml^_ckl\bl_evgh�j_qv�fh`_l�b^lb� lhevdh�h km^hjh`guo�j_Zdpbyo�� lhevdh�h lZdbo�ikbobq_kdbon_ghf_gZo�� dhlhju_� ijyfh� ke_^mxl� aZ� khfZlbq_kdbf� jZa^jZ`_gb_f�� BlZd�� kgh\b^_gby� dZd[m^lh�y\eyxlky�f_rZxsbfb�kgm�hklZldZfb�^mr_\ghc�`bagb�ijb�[h^jkl\h\Zgbb��b fu�fh`_f\gh\v�ijbclb�d aZdexq_gbx��qlh�ke_^m_l�hklZ\blv�wlm�g_ih^oh^ysmx�^ey�ikbohZgZebaZ�l_fm�B \�lh�`_�\j_fy��dZd�[u�kgh\b^_gb_�gb�dZaZehkv�baebrgbf��hgh�\k_�lZdb�kms_kl\m_l��b fufh`_f� ihiulZlvky� ihgylv� ijbqbgu� _]h� kms_kl\h\Zgby�� Ihq_fm� ^mr_\gZy� `bagv� g_ij_djZsZ_lky� kh\k_f"�<_jhylgh�� ihlhfm�� qlh� qlh�lh� g_� ^Z_l� ^mr_� ihdhy��GZ� g__� ^_ckl\mxljZa^jZ`bl_eb��b hgZ�gZ�gbo�j_Z]bjm_l��LZdbf�h[jZahf��kgh\b^_gb_�²�wlh�kihkh[�j_Z]bjh\Zgby^mrb� gZ� ^_ckl\mxsb_� \h� kg_� jZa^jZ`bl_eb�� L_i_jv� m gZk� _klv� hij_^_e_gguc� ih^oh^� dihgbfZgbx�kgh\b^_gby��JZkkfZljb\Zy�jZaebqgu_�kgh\b^_gby��fu�fh`_f�bkdZlv�wlb�f_rZxsb_kgm�jZa^jZ`bl_eb��gZ�dhlhju_�q_eh\_d�j_Z]bjm_l�kgh\b^_gb_f��<hl�fu�b hlf_lbeb�i_j\h_��qlhh[t_^bgy_l�\k_�kgh\b^_gby�?klv�eb�m gbo�_s_�qlh�gb[m^v�h[s__"�>Z��g_khfg_ggh��gh�_]h�ljm^g__�ihgylv�b hibkZlv�>mr_\gu_� ijhp_kku� \h� \j_fy� kgZ� ghkyl� kh\k_f� ^jm]hc� oZjZdl_j�� q_f� ijb� [h^jkl\h\Zgbb��<kgh\b^_gbb�fgh]h_�i_j_`b\Z_rv�b \�wlh�\_jbrv��ohly�gZ�kZfhf�^_e_�gbq_]h�g_�i_j_`b\Z_rv�djhf_�� ih`Zemc�� dZdh]h�lh� f_rZxs_]h� jZa^jZ`_gby�� Kgh\b^_gb_� i_j_`b\Z_lkyij_bfms_kl\_ggh�\ ajbl_evguo�h[jZaZo��ijb�wlhf�fh]ml�\hagbdZlv�b qm\kl\Z��b ^Z`_�fukeb�^jm]b_� hj]Zgu� qm\kl\� fh]ml� lh`_� qlh�lh� bkiulu\Zlv�� gh� ij_h[eZ^Zxl� \k_�lZdb� ajbl_evgu_h[jZau�� AZljm^g_gby� ijb� i_j_^Zq_� kgh\b^_gby� ijhbkoh^yl� hlqZklb� ihlhfm�� qlh� wlb� h[jZaugm`gh�i_j_\_klb�\ keh\Z��Y fh]�[u�wlh�gZjbkh\Zlv��qZklh�]h\hjbl�\b^_\rbc�khg��gh�y g_�agZx�dZd� wlh� \ujZablv� keh\Zfb�� Kh[kl\_ggh� ]h\hjy�� wlh� g_� y\ey_lky� kgb`_gb_f� ikbobq_kdhc^_yl_evghklb��dZd�m keZ[hmfguo�ih�kjZ\g_gbx�k ]_gbZevgufb�ex^vfb��wlh�qlh�lh�dZq_kl\_ggh^jm]h_��gh�ljm^gh�kdZaZlv��\ q_f�aZdexqZ_lky�jZaebqb_�=��L��N_og_j� \ \ukdZaZe� dZd�lh�ij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh�f_klh� �\ ^mr_��� ]^_� jZau]ju\Zxlkykgh\b^_gby�� bgh_�� q_f� f_klh� kms_kl\h\Zgby� ij_^klZ\e_gbc� ijb� [h^jkl\h\Zgbb��IjZ\^Z�� fu

Page 45: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

wlh]h�g_�ihgbfZ_f��g_�agZ_f��qlh�ih�wlhfm�ih\h^m�^mfZlv��gh�\i_qZle_gb_�qm`^hklb��dhlhjh_ijhba\h^yl�[hevrbgkl\h�kgh\b^_gbc��a^_kv�^_ckl\bl_evgh�i_j_^Z_lky��KjZ\g_gb_�^_yl_evghklbkgh\b^_gby� k ^_ckl\byfb� g_fmaudZevghc� jmdb� lZd`h� g_� ihfh]Z_l�� <_^v� ibZgbgh� \ ex[hfkemqZ_� hl\_lbl� l_fb� `_� a\mdZfb�� imklv� b g_� f_eh^byfb�� dZd� lhevdh� dlh�gb[m^v� kemqZcghdhkg_lky� _]h� deZ\br�� Wlm� \lhjmx� h[smx� q_jlm� \k_o� kgh\b^_gbc�� dZd� [u� hgZ� gb [ueZg_ihgylgZ��^Z\Zcl_�g_�[m^_f�mimkdZlv�ba�\b^m�?klv� eb� _s_� ^jm]b_� h[sb_� q_jlu"� Y g_� gZoh`m� [hevr_� gb� h^ghc�� \kx^m� \b`m� lhevdhjZaebqby��ijbq_f�\h�\k_o�hlghr_gbyo�²�dZd�\ hlghr_gbb�dZ`ms_cky�^ebl_evghklb��lZd�b lh]h�qlh� dZkZ_lky� q_ldhklb�� mqZklby� Znn_dlh\�� khojZg_gby� \ iZfylb� b l�� i�� <k_� ijhbkoh^bl�kh[kl\_ggh� ]h\hjy�� kb\__f� g_� lZd�� dZd� fv]� fh]eb� [u� h`b^Zlv� ijb� \ugm`^_gghf�� [_^ghf�dhg\mevkb\ghf�hljZ`_gbb�jZa^jZ`_gby��Qlh�dZkZ_lky�^ebl_evghklb�kgh\b^_gbc��lh�_klv�hq_gvdhjhldb_�� kh^_j`Zsb_�h^gm�beb�g_kdhevdh�dZjlbg��h^gm�fukev�beb�^Z`_� lhevdh�h^gh� keh\h�^jm]b_��g_\_jhylgh�[h]Zlu_�kh^_j`Zgb_f��ij_^klZ\eyxl�kh[hc�p_eu_�jhfZgu�b��ih�\b^bfhfm�^eylky�^he]h��?klv�kgh\b^_gby�hlq_leb\u_��dZd�i_j_`b\Zgby� >ijb�[h^jkl\h\Zgbb@��gZklhevdhhlq_leb\u_��qlh�fu�dZdh_�lh�\j_fy�ihke_�ijh[m`^_gby�g_�ijbagZ_f�bo�aZ�kgh\b^_gby��^jm]b_`_� g_\_jhylgh� keZ[u_�� jZkieu\qZlu_�� dZd� l_gb�� \ h^ghf� b lhf�`_� kgh\b^_gbb� hq_gv� yjdb_f_klZ�fh]ml� kf_gylvky�_^\Z�meh\bfufb�b g_ykgufb��Kgh\b^_gby�fh]ml�[ulv�hkfuke_ggufbbeb�ih� djZcg_c�f_j_� k\yagufb�� ^Z`_� hkljhmfgufb��nZglZklbq_kdb�ij_djZkgufb�� ^jm]b_�`_kimlZggufb��dZd�[u�keZ[hmfgufb��Z[kmj^gufb��qZklh�^Z`_�[_amfgufb��;u\Zxl�kgh\b^_gby�dhlhju_�hklZ\eyxl�gZk�jZ\gh^mrgufb��^jm]b_�ihegu�\kydbo�Znn_dlh\��[hevx�^h�ke_a��kljZohf\iehlv� ^h� ijh[m`^_gby�� m^b\e_gb_f�� \hklhj]hf� b l�� ^�� ;hevrbgkl\h� kgh\b^_gbc� ihke_ijh[m`^_gby�aZ[u\Z_lky��beb�`_�hgb�khojZgyxlky�p_euc�^_gv��gh�d \_q_jm�\kihfbgZxlky�\k_keZ[__�b k�ijh[_eZfb��^jm]b_��gZijbf_j�^_lkdb_��kgh\b^_gby��khojZgyxlky�gZklhevdh�ohjhrh�qlh� b kimkly� ��� e_l� _s_� k\_`b� \ rZfylb�� Kgh\b^_gby�� dZd� bg^b\b^u�� fh]ml� y\blvky� h^bg�_^bgkl\_gguc�jZa�b gbdh]^Z�[hevr_�g_�ihy\eylvky��beb�hgb�ih\lhjyxlky�m h^gh]h�b lh]h�`_ebpZ�[_a�baf_g_gbc�beb�k g_[hevrbfb�hlklmie_gbyfb��Dhjhq_�]h\hjy��wlZ�ghqgZy�^_yl_evghklv^mrb�bf__l�h]jhfguc�j_i_jlmZj��fh`_l��kh[kl\_ggh��ijh^_eZlv�\k_��qlh�^mrZ�l\hjbl�^g_f��ghwlh�\k_�lZdb�g_�lh�`_�kZfh_�Fh`gh�[ueh�[u�ihiulZlvky�h[tykgblv� wlh�fgh]hh[jZab_�kgh\b^_gbc��ij_^iheh`b\��qlhhgb� khhl\_lkl\mxl� jZaebqguf� ijhf_`mlhqguf� klZ^byf� f_`^m� kghf� b [h^jkl\h\Zgb_f�jZaebqguf� kl_i_gyf� g_]em[hdh]h� kgZ�� >Z�� gh� lh]^Z� \f_kl_� k ih\ur_gb_f� agZqbfhklb�kh^_j`Zl_evghklb�b hlq_leb\hklb� kgh\b^_gby�^he`gh�[ueh�[u� mkbeb\Zlvky�ihgbfZgb_� lh]h�qlh�wlh�²�kgh\b^_gb_��lZd�dZd�ijb�lZdbo�kgh\b^_gbyo�^mrZ�[ebadZ�d ijh[m`^_gbx��b g_�fh]eh[ulv� lZd�� qlh� \ke_^� aZ� ykghc� b jZamfghc� qZklvx� kgh\b^_gby� reZ� [u� [_kkfuke_ggZy� bebg_ykgZy��Z aZ�g_c�²�hiylv�ohjhrh�jZajZ[hlZggZy�qZklv��LZd�[ukljh�^mrZ�g_�fh]eZ�[u��dhg_qgh�baf_gylv�]em[bgm�kgZ��BlZd��wlh�h[tykg_gb_�gbq_]h�g_�^Z_l��\k_�g_�lZd�ijhklh�HldZ`_fky� ihdZ� hl� >ijh[e_fu@� ©kfukeZª� kgh\b^_gby� b ihiulZ_fky� emqr_� ihgylvkgh\b^_gby�� bkoh^y� ba� bo� h[sbo� q_jl�� Ba� hlghr_gby� kgh\b^_gbc� d khklhygbx� kgZ� fuaZdexqbeb�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lky� j_Zdpb_c� gZ� f_rZxs__� kgm� jZa^jZ`_gb_�� DZd� fu� m`_agZ_f��wlh�_^bgkl\_gguc�fhf_gl��]^_�gZf�gZ�ihfhsv�fh`_l�ijbclb�lhqgZy�wdki_jbf_glZevgZyikboheh]by��hgZ�ijb\h^bl�^hdZaZl_evkl\Z�lh]h��qlh�jZa^jZ`_gby��ijhba\_^_ggu_�\h�\j_fy�kgZ�

Page 46: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijhy\eyxlky� \ kgh\b^_gbb��Fgh]h� lZdbo� hiulh\� [ueh� ihklZ\e_gh� m`_� mihfygmluf�Fhmjeb<hev^hf�� dZ`^uc� ba� gZk� \ khklhygbb� ih^l\_j^blv� wlhl� j_amevlZl� gZ� hkgh\Zgbb� ebqgh]hgZ[ex^_gby�� >ey� khh[s_gby� y \u[_jm� g_dhlhju_� [he__� klZju_� wdki_jbf_glu��Fhjb� ������ijhba\h^be�lZdb_�hiulu�gZ^�kZfbf�kh[hc��?fm�^Z\Zeb�ihgxoZlv�\h�kg_�h^_dhehg��Hg�\b^_e�\hkg_�� qlh� hg� \ DZbj_� \ eZ\d_� Bh]ZggZ� FZjby� NZjbgZ�� b ^Ze__� ke_^h\Zeb� g_\_jhylgu_ijbdexq_gby�� Beb� _]h� msbigmeb� ke_]dZ� aZ� aZluehd�� _fm� kgblky� gZeh`_gguc� gZju\ghcieZklujv� b \jZq�� e_qb\rbc� _]h� \ ^_lkl\_�� Beb� _fm� gZebeb� gZ� eh[� dZiex� \h^u�� Lh]^Z� hghdZaZeky�\ BlZebb��kbevgh�ihl_e�b ibe�[_eh_�\bgh�Hj\b_lh�Lh�� qlh� gZf� [jhkZ_lky� \ ]eZaZ� \ wlbo� wdki_jbf_glZevgh� \ua\Zgguo� kgh\b^_gbyo�� [m^_l�fh`_l�[ulv��ykg__�ba�^jm]bo�ijbf_jh\�kgh\b^_gbc��\ua\Zgguo�\g_rgbf�jZa^jZ`bl_e_f��Wlhljb� kgh\b^_gby�� h dhlhjuo� khh[sbe� hkljhmfguc�gZ[ex^Zl_ev�=bev^_[jZg^l� �������� \k_� hgby\eyxlky�j_Zdpbyfb�gZ�a\hg�[m^bevgbdZ�©BlZd��\_k_ggbf�mljhf�y b^m�]meylv�b [j_^m�a_e_g_xsbfb�iheyfb�\ khk_^gxx�^_j_\gx�lZf� y \b`m� `bl_e_c� ^_j_\gb� \ ijZa^gbqguo� ieZlvyo� k fhebl\_ggbdZfb� \ jmdZo�� [hevrhclheihc�gZijZ\eyxsboky�\ p_jdh\v��Gm�^Z��\_^v�k_]h^gy�\hkdj_k_gv_��b kdhjh�gZqg_lky�jZggyyh[_^gy�� Y j_rZx� ijbgylv� \ g_c� mqZklb_�� gh� kgZqZeZ� hl^hogmlv� gZ� hdjm`Zxs_f� p_jdh\vdeZ^[bs_��lZd�dZd�y g_fgh]h�jZa]hjyq_g��QblZy�a^_kv�jZaebqgu_�gZ^]jh[gu_�gZ^ibkb��y keurm�dZd� a\hgZjv� ih^gbfZ_lky� gZ� dhehdhevgx� b \b`m� gZ\_jom� fZe_gvdbc� ^_j_\_gkdbc� dhehdhe�dhlhjuc� ^he`_g� \ha\_klblv� gZqZeh� [h]hkem`_gby�� G_dhlhjh_� \j_fy� hg� \bkbl� g_ih^\b`gh�aZl_f� gZqbgZ_l� dhe_[Zlvky� ²� b \^jm]� jZa^Zxlky� _]h� ]jhfdb_� ijhgabl_evgu_� a\mdb�� lZdb_]jhfdb_�b ijhgabl_evgu_��qlh�y ijhkuiZxkv��A\mdb��h^gZdh��bkoh^yl�hl�[m^bevgbdZª�©<lhjZy� dhf[bgZpby�� Ykguc� abfgbc� ^_gv�� gZ� mebpZo� km]jh[u�� Y kh]eZkbeky� ijbgylvmqZklb_�\ ijh]med_�gZ�kZgyo��gh�\ugm`^_g�^he]h�`^Zlv��ihdZ�fg_�khh[sZl��qlh�kZgb�m \hjhl�AZl_f� ke_^mxl�ijb]hlh\e_gby� d lhfm��qlh[u� mk_klvky�²�gZ^_\Z_lky�rm[Z�� ^hklZ_lky�gh`ghcf_rhd��gZdhg_p�y kb`m�gZ�k\h_f�f_kl_��Gh�hlt_a^�_s_�aZ^_j`b\Z_lky��ihdZ�\h``Zfb�g_�^Z_lkyagZd� g_l_ji_eb\uf� ehrZ^yf�� <hl� hgb� ljh]Zxlky� k f_klZ�� kbevgh� ljykmsb_ky� dhehdhevqbdbgZqbgZxl�k\hx�agZf_gblmx�yguqZjkdmx�fmaudm�k lZdhc�kbehc��qlh�iZmlbgZ�kgZ�fhf_glZevghj\_lky��Hiylv�wlh�g_�qlh�bgh_��dZd�j_adbc�a\hg�[m^bevgbdZª�©B lj_lbc� ijbf_j�� Y \b`m� km^hfhcdm�� ijhoh^ysmx� ih� dhjb^hjm� \ klheh\mx� kg_kdhevdbfb� ^x`bgZfb� lZj_ehd�� ihklZ\e_gguo� h^gZ� gZ� ^jm]mx��Fg_� dZ`_lky�� qlh� dhehggZnZjnhjZ�\ __�jmdZo�\hl�\hl�ihl_jy_l�jZ\gh\_kb_��Kfhljb��]h\hjx�y��\_kv�]jma�ihe_lbl�gZ�a_fex�JZamf__lky��ke_^m_l�g_ba[_`gh_�\hajZ`_gb_��y m`_�ijb\udeZ�d ih^h[ghfm�b l��^���f_`^m�l_f�y\k_� _s_� g_� kimkdZx� [_kihdhcgh]h� \a]ey^Z� k b^ms_c�� B \� kZfhf� ^_e_�� gZ� ihjh]_� hgZkihludZ_lky�� b ojmidZy� ihkm^Z� k lj_kdhf� b a\hghf� jZae_lZ_lky� ih� ihem��Gh� wlh� [_kdhg_qghijh^he`Zxsbcky�a\hg��dZd�y kdhjh�aZf_qZx��g_�lj_kd��Z gZklhysbc�a\hg��b \bgh\gbdhf�_]h��dZdm`_�ihgbfZ_l�ijhkuiZxsbcky��y\ey_lky�[m^bevgbdª�Wlb�kgh\b^_gby�^h\hevgh�\ujZabl_evgu��kh\_jr_ggh�hkfuke_ggu��\h\k_�g_�lZd�[_kk\yagu�dZd� wlh� h[uqgh� k\hckl\_ggh� kgh\b^_gbyf��Fu� g_� [m^_f� ihwlhfm� qlh�eb[h� \hajZ`Zlv� ih� boih\h^m��H[s__�\ gbo�lh��qlh�\k_�hgb�dhgqZxlky�rmfhf��dhlhjuc�ijb�ijh[m`^_gbb�hdZau\Z_lkya\hghf�[m^bevgbdZ��Fu�\b^bf�a^_kv��dZd�ijhba\h^blky�kgh\b^_gb_��gh�magZ_f�lZd`_�dh_�qlh^jm]h_�� Kgh\b^_gb_� g_� magZ_l� [m^bevgbdZ� ²� hg� b g_� ihy\ey_lky� \ kgh\b^_gbb�²� gh� hgh

Page 47: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

aZf_gy_l�a\hg�[m^bevgbdZ�^jm]bf��hgh�lhedm_l�jZa^jZ`_gb_��dhlhjh_�gZjmrZ_l�khg��gh�lhedm_l_]h�dZ`^uc�jZa�ih�jZaghfm��Ihq_fm�lZd"�GZ�wlhl�\hijhk�g_l�hl\_lZ��wlh�dZ`_lky�ijhba\hevguf�Gh� ihgylv� kgh\b^_gb_� hagZqZeh� [u� mdZaZlv�� ihq_fm� bf_ggh� wlhl�rmf�� Z g_� gbdZdhc� ^jm]hc\u[bjZ_lky�^ey� h[hagZq_gby� jZa^jZ`_gby� hl� [m^bevgbdZ��Kh\_jr_ggh� ZgZeh]bqguf� h[jZahffh`gh�\hajZablv�ijhlb\�wdki_jbf_glh\�Fhjb��ijhba\_^_ggh_�jZa^jZ`_gb_�ihy\ey_lky�\h�kg_�gh�ihq_fm�bf_ggh�\ wlhc�nhjf_��wlh]h�g_evay�magZlv�b wlh��ih�\b^bfhfm��kh\k_f�g_�\ul_dZ_l�baijbjh^u� gZjmrZxs_]h� khg� jZa^jZ`_gby�� D lhfm� `_� \ hiulZo�Fhjb� d g_ihkj_^kl\_gghfm^_ckl\bx� jZa^jZ`_gby� ijbkh_^bgy_lky� h]jhfgh_� dhebq_kl\h� ^jm]h]h� fZl_jbZeZ� kgh\b^_gby�gZijbf_j�[_amfgu_�ijbdexq_gby�\ kgh\b^_gbb�k h^_dhehghf��^ey�dhlhjuo�g_l�h[tykg_gby�Gh� ijbfbl_� \h� \gbfZgb_�� qlh� bamq_gb_� kgh\b^_gby� k ijh[m`^_gb_f� ^Zkl� gZbemqrb_rZgku� ^ey� mklZgh\e_gby� \ebygby� \g_rgbo� jZa^jZ`_gbb�� gZjmrZxsbo� khg�� < [hevrbgkl\_^jm]bo� kemqZ_\� wlh� ljm^g__��IjhkuiZxlky� g_� hl� \k_o� kgh\b^_gbc�� b _keb� mljhf� \kihfgblvghqgh_� kgh\b^_gb_�� lh� dZd� fh`gh� gZclb� lh� gZjmrZxs__� jZa^jZ`_gb_�� dhlhjh_� ^_ckl\h\Zehghqvx"�H^gZ`^u�fg_�m^Zehkv�iha`_�mklZgh\blv�lZdhc�jZa^jZ`Zxsbc�rmf��gh��dhg_qgh��lhevdh[eZ]h^Zjy�hkh[uf�h[klhyl_evkl\Zf��DZd�lh�mljhf�y ijhkgmeky�\ ]hjghf�lbjhevkdhf�f_kl_qd_�km\_j_gghklvx�� qlh� y \b^_e� \h� kg_�� [m^lh� mf_j� jbfkdbc� iZiZ�� Y g_� fh]� h[tykgblv� k_[_kgh\b^_gby��gh� aZl_f�fhy�`_gZ� kijhkbeZ�f_gy�� ©Lu� keurZe� k_]h^gy� [eb`_� d mljm� m`Zkgucdhehdhevguc�a\hg��jZa^Z\Z\rbcky�\h�\k_o�p_jd\Zo�b dZi_eeZo"ª�G_l��y gbq_]h�g_�keurZe��fhckhg�[ue�[he__�dj_idbf��gh�y ihgye�[eZ]h^Zjy� wlhfm� khh[s_gbx� k\h_� kgh\b^_gb_��DZd�qZklhlZdb_�jZa^jZ`_gby�fh]ml�\uau\Zlv�m kiys_]h�kgh\b^_gby��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�hg�h gbo�gbq_]h�g_agZ_l"�Fh`_l�[ulv� hq_gv�qZklh��fh`_l�[ulv�b g_l��?keb�g_l� \hafh`ghklb�^hdZaZlv�gZebqb_jZa^jZ`_gby�� lh� g_evay� b m[_^blvky� \ g_f�� Gh� \_^v� fu� b [_a� wlh]h� hldZaZebkv� hl� hp_gdbgZjmrZxsbo� khg� \g_rgbo� jZa^jZ`_gbb� k l_o�ihj�� dZd�fu� magZeb�� qlh� hgb�fh]ml� h[tykgblvlhevdh�qZklv�kgh\b^_gby��Z g_�\k_�_]h�p_ebdhf�Ihwlhfm�gZf�g_�ke_^m_l�kh\k_f�hldZau\Zlvky�hl�wlhc�l_hjbb��;he__�lh]h��hgZ�fh`_l�gZclbk\h_�^Zevg_cr__�jZa\blb_��Kh\_jr_ggh�[_ajZaebqgh��q_f�gZjmrZ_lky�khg��Z ^mrZ�ih[m`^Z_lkyd kgh\b^_gbx��G_�\k_]^Z�wlh�fh`_l�[ulv�qm\kl\_ggh_�jZa^jZ`_gb_��bkoh^ys__�ba\g_��bgh]^Zwlh�jZa^jZ`_gb_��bkoh^ys__�ba�\gmlj_ggbo�hj]Zgh\��lZd�gZau\Z_fh_�hj]Zgbq_kdh_�jZa^jZ`_gb_�Ihke_^g__� ij_^iheh`_gb_� gZijZrb\Z_lky� kZfh� kh[hc�� hgh� khhl\_lkl\m_l� lZd`_� kZfufjZkijhkljZg_gguf� \a]ey^Zf� gZ� \hagbdgh\_gb_� kgh\b^_gbc�� QZklh� ijboh^blky� keurZlv�� qlhkgh\b^_gby�\hagbdZxl�\ k\yab�k khklhygb_f�`_em^dZ��D kh`Ze_gbx��b \�wlhf�kemqZ_�ijboh^blkylhevdh� ij_^iheZ]Zlv�� [ueh� eb� ghqvx� dZdh_�eb[h� \gmlj_gg__� jZa^jZ`_gb_�� dhlhjh_� ihke_ijh[m`^_gby� g_\hafh`gh� hij_^_eblv�� b ihlhfm� ^_ckl\b_� lZdh]h� jZa^jZ`_gby� hklZ_lkyg_^hdZam_fuf�� Gh� g_� [m^_f� hklZ\eylv� [_a� \gbfZgby� lhl� nZdl�� qlh� fgh]b_� ^hklh\_jgu_gZ[ex^_gby�ih^l\_j`^Zxl�\hagbdgh\_gb_�kgh\b^_gbc�hl�jZa^jZ`_gbb�\gmlj_ggbo�hj]Zgh\��<h[s_f�� g_khfg_ggh�� qlh� khklhygb_� \gmlj_ggbo� hj]Zgh\� fh`_l� \ebylv� gZ� kgh\b^_gby�� K\yavf_`^m� g_dhlhjuf� kh^_j`Zgb_f� kgh\b^_gby� b i_j_iheg_gb_f� fhq_\h]h� imaujy� beb\ha[m`^_gguf�khklhygb_f�iheh\uo�hj]Zgh\�^h�lh]h�hq_\b^gZ��qlh�__ g_\hafh`gh�hljbpZlv��Hlwlbo�ykguo�kemqZ_\�fh`gh�i_j_clb�d ^jm]bf��\ dhlhjuo�kh^_j`Zgb_�kgh\b^_gby��ih�djZcg_cf_j_�� iha\hey_l� hij_^_e_ggh� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� lZdb_� jZa^jZ`_gby� \gmlj_ggbo� hj]Zgh\hdZaZeb� k\h_� ^_ckl\b_�� lZd� dZd� \ wlhf� kh^_j`Zgbb� _klv� qlh�lh�� qlh� fh`gh� ihgylv� dZdi_j_jZ[hldm��hlh[jZ`_gb_���lhedh\Zgj]_�wlbo�jZa^jZ`_gbb��Bkke_^h\Zl_ev�kgh\b^_gbc�R_jg_j

Page 48: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

�6FKHPHU��������hkh[_ggh�gZklhcqb\h�hlklZb\Ze�lhqdm�aj_gby�gZ�ijhbkoh`^_gb_�kgh\b^_gbc�hljZa^jZ`_gbb� \gmlj_ggbo� hj]Zgh\� b ijb\_e� lhfm� g_kdhevdh� ij_djZkguo� ijbf_jh\�� LZd�gZijbf_j�� \ kgh\b^_gbb� ©^\Z� jy^Z� djZkb\uo� fZevqbdh\� k [_ehdmjufb� \hehkZfb� b g_`gufp\_lhf� ebpZ� klhyl� ^jm]� ijhlb\� ^jm]Z� k `_eZgb_f� [hjhlvky�� [jhkZxlky� ^jm]� gZ� ^jm]Z�� h^gZklhjhgZ�gZiZ^Z_l�gZ�^jm]mx��h[_�klhjhgu�hiylv�jZkoh^ylky�� aZgbfZxl�ij_`g__�iheh`_gb_��b\k_� ih\lhjy_lky� kgZqZeZª�� hg� lhedm_l� wlb� jy^u� fZevqbdh\� dZd� am[u�� khhl\_lkl\mxsb_� ^jm]>jm]m��b hgh�gZoh^bl�ihegh_�ih^l\_j`^_gb_��dh]^Z�ihke_�wlhc�kp_gu�\b^ysbc�khg�©\uly]b\Z_lba�q_exklb�^ebgguc� am[ª��Lhedh\Zgb_�h ©^ebgguo��madbo��ba\bebkluo�oh^Zoª��ih�\b^bfhfm�lh`_�\_jgh�mdZau\Z_l�gZ�dbr_qgh_�jZa^jZ`_gb_�b ih^l\_j`^Z_l�iheh`_gb_�R_jg_jZ�h lhf��qlhkgh\b^_gb_�ij_`^_�\k_]h�klZjZ_lky�bah[jZablv�\uau\Zxsbc�jZa^jZ`_gb_�hj]Zg�ihoh`bfb�gZg_]h�ij_^f_lZfb�BlZd��fu��^he`gh�[ulv��]hlh\u�m`_�ijbagZlv��qlh�\gmlj_ggb_�jZa^jZ`_gby�fh]ml�b]jZlv�\kgh\b^_gbb� lZdmx� `_� jhev�� dZd� b \g_rgb_�� D kh`Ze_gbx�� bo� hp_gb\Zgb_� \uau\Z_l� l_� `_\hajZ`_gby��< [hevrhf�qbkeA�kemqZ_\�lhedh\Zgb_�jZa^jZ`_gby�\gmlj_ggbo�hj]Zgh\�g_gZ^_`ghbeb� [_a^hdZaZl_evgh�� g_� \k_� kgh\b^_gby�� gh� lhevdh� hij_^_e_ggZy� bo� qZklv� \hagbdZ_l� ijbmqZklbb�jZa^jZ`_gby�\gmlj_ggbo�hj]Zgh\��b gZdhg_p��jZa^jZ`_gb_�\gmlj_ggbo�hj]Zgh\��lZd�`_dZd�b \g_rg__�qm\kl\_ggh_�jZa^jZ`_gb_��\ khklhygbb�h[tykgblv�ba�kgh\b^_gby�g_�[hevr_��q_fg_ihkj_^kl\_ggmx� j_Zdpbx�� gZ� jZa^jZ`_gb_�� Hldm^Z� [_j_lky� hklZevgZy� qZklv� kgh\b^_gby�hklZ_lky�g_ykguf�Hlf_lbf�k_[_��h^gZdh��k\h_h[jZab_�`bagb�kgh\b^_gbc��dhlhjh_�\uy\ey_lky�ijb�bamq_gbbjZa^jZ`Zxsbo�\ha^_ckl\bc��Kgh\b^_gb_�g_�ijhklh�i_j_^Z_l�jZa^jZ`_gb_��hgh�i_j_jZ[Zlu\Z_l_]h�� gZf_dZ_l� gZ� g_]h�� klZ\bl� _]h� \ hij_^_e_ggmx� k\yav�� aZf_gy_l� q_f�lh� ^jm]bf�� Wlh� h^gZklhjhgZ� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby�� dhlhjZy� ^he`gZ�gZk� aZbgl_j_kh\Zlv�� ihlhfm� qlh� hgZ�� \hafh`gh�[eb`_�ih^\_^_l�gZk�d kmsghklb�kgh\b^_gby��_keb�dlh�lh�^_eZ_l�qlh�gb[m^v�ih�ih[m`^_gbx��lhwlbf�ih[m`^_gb_f�^_eh�g_�h]jZgbqb\Z_lky��>jZfZ�FZd[_l�R_dkibjZ��gZijbf_j��\hagbdeZ�dZdiv_kZ�ih�kemqZx�lh]h��qlh�gZ�ij_klhe�\ahr_e�dhjhev��\i_j\u_�h[t_^bgb\rbc�ljb�kljZgu�ih^k\h_c� dhjhghc�� Gh� jZa\_� wlhl� bklhjbq_kdbc� ih\h^� bkq_jiu\Z_l� \k_� kh^_j`Zgb_� ^jZfu�h[tykgy_l� gZf� __� \_ebqb_� b aZ]Z^db"� <hafh`gh�� ^_ckl\mxsb_� gZ� kiys_]h� \g_rgb_� b\gmlj_ggb_�jZa^jZ`_gby�lh`_�lhevdh�ih[m^bl_eb�kgh\b^_gby��gbq_]h�g_�]h\hjysb_�gZf�h _]hkmsghklb�>jm]h_� h[s__� kgh\b^_gbyf� dZq_kl\h�²� _]h�ikbobq_kdZy� hkh[_gghklv�� k h^ghc� klhjhgu�ljm^gh� meh\bfZ�� Z k� ^jm]hc� ²� g_� ^Z_l� hlijZ\ghc� lhqdb� ^ey� ^Zevg_cr_]h� bkke_^h\Zgby�� <kgh\b^_gbb� fu� \ [hevrbgkl\_� kemqZ_\� qlh�lh� i_j_`b\Z_f� \ \bamZevguo� nhjfZo��Fh]ml� ebjZa^jZ`_gby� ^Zlv� wlhfm� h[tykg_gb_"� >_ckl\bl_evgh� eb� wlh� lh� jZa^jZ`_gb_�� dhlhjh_� fui_j_`b\Z_f"� Ihq_fm� `_� lh]^Z� i_j_`b\Zgb_� \bamZevgh�� _keb� jZa^jZ`_gb_� ]eZa� ijhbkoh^bllhevdh�\ kZfuo�j_^dbo�kemqZyo"�Beb�ke_^m_l�^himklblv��qlh�dh]^Z�gZf�kgylky�j_qb��lh�\h�\j_fykgZ�fu� keurbf�jZa]h\hj�beb�ih^h[guc� _fm�rmf"�Wlm�\hafh`ghklv� y iha\hex� k_[_� kh� \k_cj_rbl_evghklvx�hl\_j]gmlv�?keb�bamq_gb_�h[sbo�q_jl�kgh\b^_gbc�g_�fh`_l�ihfhqv�gZf�\ ^Zevg_crbo�bkke_^h\Zgbyo�lh�� \hafh`gh�� klhbl� h[jZlblvky� d bamq_gbx� bo� jZaebqbc�� IjZ\^Z�� kgh\b^_gby� qZklh[_kkfuke_ggu�� aZimlZggu�� Z[kmj^gu��gh� _klv�b hkfuke_ggu_�� lj_a\u_� �PLFKWHUQH���jZamfgu_�

Page 49: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Ihkfhljbf�� g_� kfh]ml� eb� ihke_^gb_�� hkfuke_ggu_�� jZatykgblv� gZf� i_j\u_�� [_kkfuke_ggu_�Khh[sm�\Zf�jZamfgh_�kgh\b^_gb_��jZkkdZaZggh_�fg_�h^gbf�fheh^uf�q_eh\_dhf��©Y ]meye�ihD_jlg_jrljZkk_��\klj_lbe�]hkih^bgZ�;���d dhlhjhfm�ijbkh_^bgbeky�gZ�dZdh_�lh�\j_fy��ihlhfihr_e� \ j_klhjZg�� AZ� fhbf� klhebdhf� kb^_eb� ^\_� ^Zfu� b h^bg� ]hkih^bg�� Y kgZqZeZ� hq_gvjZkk_j^beky�gZ�wlh�b g_�ohl_e�gZ�gbo�kfhlj_lv��Ihlhf�\a]eygme�b gZr_e��qlh�hgb�\_kvfZ�fbeuª�<b^_\rbc� khg� aZf_qZ_l� ijb� wlhf�� qlh� \_q_jhf� i_j_^� kghf� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� ]meye� ihD_jlg_jrljZkk_��wlh�_]h�h[uqguc�imlv��b \klj_lbe�]hkih^bgZ�;��>jm]Zy�qZklv�kgh\b^_gby�g_y\ey_lky�ijyfuf�\hkihfbgZgb_f��gh�bf__l�hij_^_e_ggh_�koh^kl\h�k g_^Z\gbf�i_j_`b\Zgb_f�Beb�^jm]h_�©lj_a\h_ª�kgh\b^_gb_�h^ghc�^Zfu��©?_�fm`�kijZrb\Z_l��g_�gZkljhblv�eb�ibZgbgh"HgZ� hl\_qZ_l�� g_� klhbl�� ^ey� g_]h� \k_� jZ\gh� gm`gh� k^_eZlv� gh\uc� q_oheª�� Wlh� kgh\b^_gb_ih\lhjy_l�ihqlb�[_a�baf_g_gbc�jZa]h\hj��ijhbkr_^rbc�aZ�^_gv�^h�kgh\b^_gby�f_`^m�fm`_f�b_x��Q_fm�`_� mqZl� gZk� wlb� ^\Z� ©lj_a\uoª� kgh\b^_gby"�Lhevdh� lhfm�� qlh� \ gbo�fh`gh� gZclbih\lhj_gby�ba�^g_\ghc�`bagb�beb�ba�k\ya_c�k g_c��Wlh�[ueh�[u�agZqbfh��_keb�[u�hlghkbehkv�dh\k_f�kgh\b^_gbyf��Gh�h[�wlhf�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�b j_qb��wlh�hlghkblky�lhevdh�d g_[hevrhfm�qbkemkgh\b^_gbc��\ [hevrbgkl\_�`_�bo�g_evay�gZclb�k\ya_c�k ij_^u^msbf�^g_f��Z [_kkfuke_ggu_�bZ[kmj^gu_�kgh\b^_gby�wlbf�\hh[s_�gbdZd�g_�h[tykgyxlky��Fu�agZ_f�lhevdh��qlh�klZedb\Z_fkyk gh\ufb�ijh[e_fZfb��Fu�g_� lhevdh�ohlbf� agZlv��h q_f� ]h\hjbl� kgh\b^_gb_��gh�^Z`_�\ l_okemqZyo��dh]^Z�hgh��dZd�\ \ur_ijb\_^_gguo�ijbf_jZo��ykgh�\ujZ`_gh��fu�ohlbf�agZlv�lZd`_�ihq_fm�b aZq_f�ih\lhjy_lky�wlh�agZdhfh_��lhevdh�qlh�i_j_`blh_�Y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� \u�� dZd� b y�� lhevdh� mklZg_f�� ijh^he`Zy� ih^h[gu_� wdki_jbf_glu��Fu\b^bf��qlh�g_^hklZlhqgh�h^gh]h�bgl_j_kZ�d ijh[e_f_��_keb�g_�agZlv�imlb��dhlhjuc�ijb\_e�[u�d__ j_r_gbx��IhdZ�m gZk� wlh]h�imlb�g_l��Wdki_jbf_glZevgZy�ikboheh]by�g_�^ZeZ�gZf�gbq_]h�djhf_�g_dhlhjuo�hq_gv�p_gguo�^Zgguo�h agZq_gbb�jZa^jZ`_gbb�dZd�ih[m^bl_e_c�kgh\b^_gbc�Hl� nbehkhnbb� gZf� g_q_]h� `^Zlv�� djhf_� \ukhdhf_jguo� mij_dh\� \ bgl_ee_dlmZevghcfZehp_gghklb�gZr_]h�h[t_dlZ��m hddmevlguo�gZmd�fu�b kZfb�g_�ohlbf�gbq_]h�aZbfkl\h\Zlv��Bklhjby� b gZjh^gZy� fhe\Z� ]h\hjyl� gZf�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� ihegh� kfukeZ� b agZq_gby�� hghij_^\b^bl�[m^ms__��wlh��h^gZdh��ljm^gh�ij_^iheh`blv�b��dhg_qgh��g_\hafh`gh�^hdZaZlv��LZdbfh[jZahf��ijb�i_j\hc�`_�ihiuld_�fu�hdZaZebkv�iheghklvx�[_kihfhsgu�G_h`b^Zggh� ihfhsv� ijboh^bl� d gZf� hllm^Z�� hldm^Z� fu� b g_� ih^haj_\Zeb�� < gZr_fkeh\hmihlj_[e_gbb�� dhlhjh_�^Ze_dh�g_� kemqZcgh�� Z y\ey_lky� \ujZ`_gb_f�^j_\g_]h�ihagZgby�ohly�_]h�b gZ^h�hp_gb\Zlv�k hklhjh`ghklvx�²�\ gZr_f�yaud_�_klv�ijbf_qZl_evgh_�\ujZ`_gb_©kgu�gZy\mª��7DJWUDXPH���Kgu�gZy\m�y\eyxlky�nZglZabyfb� �ijh^mdlZfb�nZglZabb�� ��wlh�hq_gvjZkijhkljZg_ggu_�n_ghf_gu��gZ[ex^Z_fu_�dZd�m a^hjh\uo��lZd�b m�[hevguo�b e_]dh�^hklmigu_^ey� bamq_gby� gZ� k_[_��KZfh_� m^b\bl_evgh_� \ wlbo�nZglZklbq_kdbo� h[jZah\Zgbyo� lh�� qlh� hgbkhojZgbeb� gZa\Zgb_� ©kgh\� gZy\mª�� g_� bf_y� ^\mo� h[sbo� ^ey� \k_o� kgh\b^_gbc� q_jl�� M`_� bogZa\Zgb_�ijhlb\hj_qbl�hlghr_gbx�d khklhygbx�kgZ��Z qlh�dZkZ_lky�\lhjhc�h[s_c�q_jlu��lh�\gbo� gbq_]h� g_� i_j_`b\Z_lky�� g_� ]Zeexpbgbjm_lky�� Z qlh�lh� ij_^klZ\ey_lky�� khagZ_rv�� qlhnZglZabjm_rv�� g_� \b^brv�� gh� ^mfZ_rv�� Wlb� kgu� gZy\m� ihy\eyxlky� \ \hajZkl_�ij_^r_kl\mxs_f� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb�� qZklh� m`_� \ iha^g_f� ^_lkl\_�� khojZgyxlky� \ ]h^uaj_ehklb�� aZl_f� hl� gbo� eb[h� hldZau\Zxlky�� eb[h� hgb� hklZxlky� ^h� ij_klZj_eh]h� \hajZklZ�Kh^_j`Zgb_�wlbo�nZglZabc�h[mkeh\e_gh�\iheg_�ykghc�fhlb\Zpb_c��Wlh�kp_gu�b ijhbkr_kl\by�\ dhlhjuo� gZoh^yl� k\h_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� w]hbklbq_kdb_�� q_klhex[b\u_� b \eZklhex[b\u_

Page 50: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ihlj_[ghklb� beb� wjhlbq_kdb_� `_eZgby� ebqghklb�� M fheh^uo� fm`qbg� h[uqgh� ij_h[eZ^Zxlq_klhex[b\u_� nZglZabb�� m `_gsbg�� q_klhex[b_� dhlhjuo� h]jZgbqb\Z_lky� ex[h\gufbmki_oZfb�²� wjhlbq_kdb_�� Gh� ^h\hevgh� qZklh� b m� fm`qbg� h[gZjm`b\Z_lky� wjhlbq_kdZyih^deZ^dZ�� \k_� ]_jhckdb_� ihklmidb� b mki_ob� ^he`gu� kihkh[kl\h\Zlv� \hkobs_gbx� b[eZ]hkdehgghklb�`_gsbg����<ijhq_f�� kgu�gZy\m� hq_gv� jZaghh[jZagu��b io� km^v[Z�jZaebqgZ�DZ`^uc� ba� gbo� q_j_a� dhjhldh_� \j_fy� beb� h[ju\Z_lky� b aZf_gy_lky� gh\uf�� beb� hgbkhojZgyxlky�� kie_lZxlky� \ ^ebggu_� bklhjbb� b ijbkihkZ[eb\Zxlky� d baf_gyxsbfky`bag_gguf�h[klhyl_evkl\Zf��Hgb�b^ml�� lZd� kdZaZlv��\ gh]m� kh�\j_f_g_f�b ihemqZxl� ©i_qZlv\j_f_gbª�ih^�\ebygb_f�gh\hc�kblmZpbb��Hgb�y\eyxlky�kujuf�fZl_jbZehf�^ey�ihwlbq_kdh]hl\hjq_kl\Z�� ihlhfm� qlh� ba� kgh\� gZy\m� ihwl� kha^Z_l� iml_f� ij_h[jZah\Zgbc�� i_j_^_ehd� bbkdexq_gbc� kblmZpbb��dhlhju_�hg�bkihevam_l�\ k\hbo�gh\_eeZo��jhfZgZo��iv_kZo��Gh� ]_jh_fkgh\�gZy\m�\k_]^Z�y\ey_lky�kZfZ�nZglZabjmxsZy�ebqghklv�beb�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh��beb�\ dZdhc�eb[h�hq_\b^ghc�b^_glbnbdZpbb�k ^jm]bf�ebphf�Fh`_l�[ulv��kgu�gZy\m�ghkyl�wlh�gZa\Zgb_�ba�aZ�lZdh]h�`_�hlghr_gby�d ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�ih^q_jdb\Zy��qlh�bo�kh^_j`Zgb_�lZd�`_�fZeh�j_Zevgh��dZd�b kh^_j`Zgb_�kgh\b^_gbc��Gh�fh`_l[ulv�� wlZ� h[sghklv� gZa\Zgbc� h[mkeh\e_gZ� _s_� g_ba\_klguf� gZf� ikbobq_kdbf� oZjZdl_jhfkgh\b^_gby��l_f��dhlhjuc�fu�bs_f��<hafh`gh�lZd`_��qlh�fu�\hh[s_�g_�ijZ\u��dh]^Z�ijb^Z_fhij_^_e_ggh_�agZq_gb_�h[sghklb�gZa\Zgbc��Gh�wlh�\uykgblky�ebrv�iha^g__�R?KL:Y�E?DPBYIj_^iheh`_gby�b l_ogbdZ�lhedh\ZgbyM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��BlZd��gZf�gm`_g�gh\uc�ih^oh^��hij_^_e_gguc�f_lh^��qlh[uk^\bgmlvky�k f_klZ�\ bamq_gbb�kgh\b^_gby��K^_eZx�h^gh�ijhklh_�ij_^eh`_gb_��^Z\Zcl_�[m^_fijb^_j`b\Zlvky� \ ^Zevg_cr_f� ij_^iheh`_gby�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lky� g_� khfZlbq_kdbf�� Zikbobq_kdbf� n_ghf_ghf�� Qlh� wlh� hagZqZ_l�� \u� agZ_l_�� gh� qlh� ^Z_l� gZf� ijZ\h� gZ� wlhij_^iheh`_gb_"� Gbq_]h�� gh� gbqlh� g_� f_rZ_l� gZf� _]h� �k^_eZlv�� <hijhk� klZ\blky� lZd�� _kebkgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lky� khfZlbq_kdbf�n_ghf_ghf�� lh�gZf�g_l�^h�g_]h�^_eZ��hgh�bgl_j_km_l�gZklhevdh�ijb�mkeh\bb��qlh�y\ey_lky�ikbobq_kdbf�n_ghf_ghf��LZdbf�h[jZahf��fu�[m^_f�jZ[hlZlvijb�mkeh\bb��qlh�wlh�^_ckl\bl_evgh�lZd��qlh[u�ihkfhlj_lv��qlh�ba�wlh]h�ke_^m_l��J_amevlZlugZr_c�jZ[hlu�ihdZ`ml��hklZg_fky�eb�fu�ijb�wlhf�ij_^iheh`_gbb�b kfh`_f�eb�kqblZlv�_]h��\k\hx� hq_j_^v�� hij_^_e_gguf� j_amevlZlhf�� Q_]h� fu�� kh[kl\_ggh�� ohlbf� ^hklbqv�� ^ey� q_]hjZ[hlZ_f"�Fu� ohlbf� lh]h�� d q_fm� \hh[s_� klj_fylky� \ gZmd_�� l�� _�� ihgbfZgby� n_ghf_gh\�mklZgh\e_gby�k\ya_c�f_`^m�gbfb�b \�dhg_qghf�kq_l_�lZf��]^_�wlh�\hafh`gh��mkbe_gby�gZr_c\eZklb�gZ^�gbfb�BlZd��fu�ijh^he`Z_f�jZ[hlm��ij_^iheZ]Zy��qlh�kgh\b^_gb_�_klv�ikbobq_kdbc�n_ghf_g��<wlhf� kemqZ_� hgh� y\ey_lky� ijh^mdlhf� b ijhy\e_gb_f� \b^_\r_]h� khg�� dhlhjuc�� h^gZdh�� gZfgbq_]h�g_�]h\hjbl��dhlhjuc�fu�g_�ihgbfZ_f��Gh�qlh�\u�[m^_l_�^_eZlv�\ kemqZ_��_keb�y kdZ`m\Zf� qlh�lh� g_ihgylgh_"�Kijhkbl_�f_gy�� g_� lZd� eb"�Ihq_fm� gZf� g_� k^_eZlv� lh�`_� kZfh_�� g_jZkkijhkblv�\b^_\r_]h�khg��qlh�hagZqZ_l�_]h�kgh\b^_gb_A

Page 51: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

<kihfgbl_�� fu� m`_� [ueb� h^gZ`^u� \ ^Zgghc� kblmZpbb�� Wlh� [ueh� ijb� bkke_^h\Zgbbhrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��\ kemqZ_�h]h\hjdb��G_dlh�kdZaZe�'D� VLQG� 'LQJH� ]XP� 9RUVFKZHLQ� JHNRPPHQ�� b ih� wlhfm� ih\h^m� _]h� kijhkbeb� ²� g_l�� dkqZklvx�� g_� fu�� Z ^jm]b_�� kh\_jr_ggh� g_ijbqZklgu_� d ikbohZgZebam� ex^b�²� wlb� ^jm]b_kijhkbeb�� qlh� hg� ohl_e� kdZaZlv� ^Zggufb� g_ihgylgufb� keh\Zfb�� Kijhr_gguc� lhlqZk� `_hl\_lbe�� qlh� hg� bf_e� gZf_j_gb_� kdZaZlv�� GDV� ZDUHQ� 6FKZHLQHUHLHQ� �wlh� [ueb� k\bgkl\Z��� ghih^Z\be�wlh�gZf_j_gb_�^ey�^jm]h]h��\ujZ`_ggh]h�[he__�fy]dh��M`_�lh]^Z�y \Zf�aZy\be��qlh�wlhljZkkijhk� y\ey_lky� ijhh[jZahf� ex[h]h� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h� bkke_^h\Zgby�� b l_i_jv� \uihgbfZ_l_�� qlh� l_ogbdZ� ikbohZgZebaZ� aZdexqZ_lky� \ lhf�� qlh[u� ihemqblv� j_r_gb_� aZ]Z^hd�gZkdhevdh�wlh�\hafh`gh��hl�kZfh]h�h[ke_^m_fh]h��LZdbf�h[jZahf��\b^_\rbc�khg�kZf�^he`_ggZf�kdZaZlv��qlh�agZqbl�_]h�kgh\b^_gb_�Gh�� dZd� ba\_klgh�� ijb� kgh\b^_gbb� \k_� g_� lZd� ijhklh�� Ijb� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\byo� wlhm^Z\Zehkv� \ p_ehf� jy^_� kemqZ_\�� gh� [ueb� b kemqZb�� dh]^Z� kijZrb\Z_fuc� gbq_]h� g_� ohl_e]h\hjblv�b ^Z`_�\hafms_ggh�hldehgye�ij_^eh`_gguc�gZfb�\ZjbZgl�hl\_lZ��Ijb�kgh\b^_gbb�`_kemqZ_\� i_j\h]h� jh^Z� \hh[s_� g_l�� \b^_\rbc� khg� \k_]^Z� hl\_qZ_l�� qlh� hg� gbq_]h� g_� agZ_l�HljbpZlv� gZr_� lhedh\Zgb_� hg� g_�fh`_l�� ihlhfm� qlh�fu� _fm� gbq_]h� g_�fh`_f� ij_^eh`blv�Fh`_l�[ulv��gZf�\k_�`_�hldZaZlvky�hl�k\h_c�ihiuldb"�Gb�hg��gb fu�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_f��Z dlh�lhlj_lbc�m`�gZ\_jgydZ�gbq_]h�g_�fh`_l�agZlv��lZd�qlh�m gZk��ih`Zemc��g_l�gbdZdhc�gZ^_`^u�qlh�eb[h�magZlv��Lh]^Z��_keb�ohlbl_��hklZ\vl_�wlm�ihiuldm��?keb�g_l��fh`_l_�ke_^h\Zlv�aZ�fghc��YkdZ`m�\Zf��qlh�\_kvfZ�\hafh`gh�b ^Z`_�hq_gv�\_jhylgh��qlh�\b^_\rbc�khg�\k_�lZdb�agZ_l��qlhhagZqZ_l�_]h�kgh\b^_gb_��hg�lhevdh�g_�agZ_l�h k\h_f�agZgbb�b iheZ]Z_l�ihwlhfm��qlh�g_�agZ_lwlh]h�<u� fh`_l_� fg_� aZf_lblv�� qlh� y hiylv� \\h`m� gh\h_� ij_^iheh`_gb_�� m`_� \lhjh_� \ wlhfdhjhldhf�baeh`_gbb��b l_f�kZfuf�\ agZqbl_evghc�kl_i_gb�klZ\ex�ih^�khfg_gb_�^hklh\_jghklvk\h_]h� f_lh^Z�� BlZd�� i_j\h_� ij_^iheh`_gb_� aZdexqZ_lky� \ lhf�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� _klvikbobq_kdbc�n_ghf_g��\lhjh_�²�\ lhf��qlh�\ ^mr_�q_eh\_dZ�kms_kl\m_l�qlh�lh��h q_f�hg�agZ_l�g_� agZy�� qlh� hg� h g_f� agZ_l�� b l�� ^�� Klhbl� lhevdh� ijbgylv� \h� \gbfZgb_� \gmlj_ggxxg_ijZ\^hih^h[ghklv� dZ`^h]h� ba� wlbo� ^\mo� ij_^iheh`_gbc�� qlh[u� \hh[s_� mljZlblv� \kydbcbgl_j_k�d \ul_dZxsbf�ba�gbo�\u\h^Zf�Gh��m\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��y ijb]eZkbe�\Zk�kx^Z�g_�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�ih^mjZqblv�bebqlh�lh� kdju\Zlv�� Y�� ijZ\^Z�� aZy\be� h[� ©we_f_glZjghf� dmjk_� e_dpbc� ih� \\_^_gbx� \ikbohZgZebaª��gh�y g_�gZf_j_g�[ue�baeZ]Zlv�\Zf�fZl_jbZe� LQ� XVXP� GHOSKLQL� ��bah[jZ`Zy� \k_k]eZ`_gguf�� lsZl_evgh� kdju\Zy� hl� \Zk� \k_� ljm^ghklb�� aZihegyy� \k_� ijh[_eu�� aZlmr_\u\Zykhfg_gby��qlh[u� \u� k e_]dbf� k_j^p_f�fh]eb�ih^mfZlv�� qlh�gZmqbebkv� q_fm�lh�gh\hfm��G_l�bf_ggh� ihlhfm�� qlh� \u� gZqbgZxsb_�� y ohl_e� ihdZaZlv� \Zf� gZrm� gZmdm� dZd� hgZ� _klv�� k __r_jhoh\Zlhklyfb�b ljm^ghklyfb��ij_l_gabyfb�b khfg_gbyfb��Y agZx��qlh�gb \�h^ghc�gZmd_�g_fh`_l�[ulv�bgZq_��hkh[_ggh�\gZqZe_��Y agZx�lZd`_��qlh�ijb�ij_ih^Z\Zgbb�kgZqZeZ�klZjZxlkykdjulv�hl�mqZsboky�wlb�ljm^ghklb�b g_kh\_jr_gkl\Z��Gh�d ikbohZgZebam�wlh�g_�ih^oh^bl��Y^_ckl\bl_evgh� k^_eZe� ^\Z�ij_^iheh`_gby�� h^gh� \ ij_^_eZo� ^jm]h]h�� b dhfm� \k_� wlh� dZ`_lkykebrdhf�ljm^guf�b g_hij_^_e_gguf��dlh�ijb\ud�d [hevr_c�^hklh\_jghklb�b

Page 52: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

�,Q�XVXP�GHOSKLQL���©^ey�^hnbgZª��gZ^ibkv��k^_eZggZy�gZ�ba^Zgbb�deZkkbdh\��dhlhjh_�ih ijbdZam�Ex^h\bdZ ;,9[ueh�khklZ\e_gh�^ey�_]h�kugZ����Ijbf_q��g_f��ba^�bays_kl\m�\u\h^h\��lhfm�g_�ke_^m_l�b^lb�k gZfb�^Zevr_��Y lhevdh�^mfZx��qlh�_fm�\hh[s_ke_^h\Zeh�[u�hklZ\blv�ikboheh]bq_kdb_�ijh[e_fu��ihlhfm�qlh��[hxkv��lhqguo�b ^hklh\_jguoiml_c��dhlhjufb�hg�]hlh\�b^lb��a^_kv�hg��kdhj__�\k_]h��g_�gZc^_l��>Z�b kh\_jr_ggh�baebrg_�qlh[u�gZmdZ�� dhlhjZy�fh`_l� qlh�lh� ij_^eh`blv�� [_kihdhbeZkv� h lhf�� qlh[u� __ mkeurZeb�� b\_j[h\ZeZ�[u�k_[_�klhjhggbdh\��?_�j_amevlZlu�^he`gu�]h\hjblv�aZ�g__�kZfb��Z kZfZ�hgZ�fh`_lih^h`^Zlv��ihdZ�hgb�ijb\e_dml�\gbfZgb_�Gh� l_o� ba� \Zk�� dlh� ohq_l� ijh^he`Zlv� aZgylby�� y ^he`_g� ij_^mij_^blv�� qlh� h[Z� fhbij_^iheh`_gby�g_�jZ\ghp_ggu��I_j\h_�ij_^iheh`_gb_��qlh�kgh\b^_gb_�y\ey_lky�ikbobq_kdbfn_ghf_ghf�� fu� ohlbf� ^hdZaZlv� j_amevlZlZfb� gZr_c� jZ[hlu�� \lhjh_� m`_� ^hdZaZgh� \ ^jm]hch[eZklb�gZmdb��b y�lhevdh�[_jm�gZ�k_[y�kf_ehklv�ijbeh`blv�_]h�d j_r_gbx�gZrbo�ijh[e_f�LZd� ]^_� `_�� \ dZdhc� h[eZklb� gZmdb� [ueh� ^hdZaZgh�� qlh� _klv� lZdh_� agZgb_�� h dhlhjhfq_eh\_dm�gbq_]h�g_�ba\_klgh� �dZd� wlh�bf__l�f_klh��ih�gZr_fm�ij_^iheh`_gbx�� m \b^_\r_]hkhg�"� Wlh� [ue� [u� aZf_qZl_evguc�� ihjZabl_evguc� nZdl�� f_gyxsbc� gZr_� ij_^klZ\e_gb_� h^mr_\ghc�`bagb�� dhlhjuc�g_l� gZ^h[ghklb� kdju\Zlv��F_`^m� ijhqbf�� wlh�nZdl�� dhlhjuc� kZfhljbpZ_l�lh��qlh�ml\_j`^Z_l��b \k_�lZdb�y\ey_lky�q_f�lh�^_ckl\bl_evguf��FRQWUDGLFWLR�LQ�DGMHFWR ��LZd�hg�b g_�kdju\Z_lky��B g_�_]h�\bgZ��_keb�h g_f�gbq_]h�g_�agZxl�beb�g_^hklZlhqgh�\ g_]h\^mfu\Zxlky��Lhqgh�lZd�`_�g_�gZrZ�\bgZ��qlh�h[h�\k_o�wlbo�ikboheh]bq_kdbo�ijh[e_fZo�km^ylex^b��dhlhju_�^Ze_db�hl�\k_o�gZ[ex^_gbc�b hiulh\��bf_xsbo�\ ^Zgghf�\hijhk_�j_rZxs__agZq_gb_�>hdZaZl_evkl\h�[ueh�^Zgh�\ h[eZklb�]bighlbq_kdbo�y\e_gbc��Dh]^Z�y \������]��gZ[ex^Zeqj_a\uqZcgh� m[_^bl_evgu_� ^_fhgkljZpbb� Ev_[h� b ;_jg]_cfZ� \ GZgkb�� y [ue� k\b^_l_e_f� bke_^mxs_]h�wdki_jbf_glZ��Dh]^Z�q_eh\_dZ�ijb\_eb�\ khfgZf[mebq_kdh_�khklhygb_��aZklZ\beb�\wlhf� khklhygbb� ]ZeexpbgZlhjgh� i_j_`blv� \k_\hafh`gu_� kblmZpbb��� Z aZl_f� jZa[m^beb�� lhkgZqZeZ�_fm�dZaZehkv��qlh�hg�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_l�kª�ijhbkoh^b\r_f�\h�\j_fy�]bighlbq_kdh]h�kgZ�;_jg]_cf�ihlj_[h\Ze�jZkkdZaZlv��qlh�k gbf�ijhbkoh^beh�\h�\j_fy�]bighaZ��Q_eh\_d�ml\_j`^Ze�qlh� gbq_]h� g_�fh`_l� \kihfgblv��Gh� ;_j]_cf� gZklZb\Ze�� lj_[h\Ze�� m\_jye� _]h�� qlh� hg� agZ_l�^he`_g�\kihfgblv��b \hl�q_eh\_d�aZdhe_[Zeky��gZqZe�kh[bjZlvky�k fukeyfb��\kihfgbe�kgZqZeZkfmlgh� h^gh� ba� \gmr_gguo� _fm� i_j_`b\Zgbc�� aZl_f� ^jm]h_�� \hkihfbgZgb_� klZgh\behkv� \k_hlq_leb\_c��\k_�iheg__�b gZdhg_p�[ueh�\hkklZgh\e_gh�[_a�ijh[_eh\��Gh�lZd�dZd�hg�\k_�wlh�agZe�dZd�aZl_f�b hdZaZehkv��ohly�gbdlh�ihklhjhggbc�g_�fh]�_fm�gbq_]h�khh[sblv��lh�gZijZrb\Z_lky\u\h^��qlh�hg�agZe�h[�wlbo�i_j_`b\Zgbyo�jZg__��Lhevdh�hgb�[ueb�_fm�g_^hklmigu��hg�g_�agZe�qlh�©hgb�m g_]h�_klv��hg�iheZ]Ze��qlh�gbq_]h�h gbo�g_�agZ_l��BlZd��wlh�kh\_jr_ggh�lZ�`_�kZfZykblmZpby��\ dhlhjhc��dZd�fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f��gZoh^blky�\b^_\rbc�khg�GZ^_xkv��\Zk�ihjZabl�wlhl�nZdl��b \u�kijhkbl_�f_gy��ihq_fm�`_�\u�g_�khkeZebkv�gZ�wlh^hdZaZl_evkl\h� m`_� jZgvr_�� jZkkfZljb\Z\� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by�� dh]^Z� fu� ijbreb� daZdexq_gbx��qlh�ijbibku\Zeb�h]h\h� �Ijhlb\hj_qb_�\ hij_^_e_gbb��eZl���²Ijbf_q��i_j�jb\r_fmky�q_eh\_dm�gZf_j_gby��h dhlhjuo�hg�g_�agZe�b dhlhju_�hljbpZe"�?keb�dlh�gb[m^v

Page 53: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

^mfZ_l��qlh�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_l�h i_j_`b\Zgbyo��\hkihfbgZgby�h dhlhjuo�m g_]h�\k_�lZdb�_klv��lhl_f�[he__�\_jhylgh��qlh�hg�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_l�b h�^jm]bo�\gmlj_ggbo�^mr_\guo�ijhp_kkZo��Wlhl^h\h^�� dhg_qgh�� ijhba\_e� [u� \i_qZle_gb_� b ihfh]� [u� gZf� ihgylv� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by�JZamf__lky��y fh]�[u�khkeZlvky�gZ�g_]h�b lh]^Z��gh�y ijb[_j_]�_]h�^ey�^jm]h]h�kemqZy��]^_�hg[ue� [he__� g_h[oh^bf�� Hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by� qZklbqgh� jZatykgbebkv� kZfb� kh[hc�� k ^jm]hcklhjhgu�� hgb� gZihfgbeb� gZf�� qlh� \ke_^kl\b_� h[s_c� k\yab� y\e_gbc� \k_�lZdb� ke_^m_lij_^iheh`blv� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� lZdbo� ^mr_\guo� ijhp_kkh\�� h dhlhjuo� gbq_]h� g_� ba\_klgh�BamqZy�kgh\b^_gby��fu�\ugm`^_gu�ihevah\Zlvky�k\_^_gbyfb�ba�^jm]bo�h[eZkl_c�b��djhf_�lh]h�y mqblu\Zx� lhl�nZdl�� qlh� a^_kv� \u� kdhj__� kh]eZkbl_kv� gZ� ijb\e_q_gb_� k\_^_gbc� ba� h[eZklb]bighaZ��Khklhygb_��\ dhlhjhf�kh\_jrZxlky�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by��^he`gh�[ulv��dZ`_lky�\ZfghjfZevguf��hgh�g_�ihoh`_�gZ�]bighlbq_kdh_��GZijhlb\��f_`^m�]bighlbq_kdbf�khklhygb_f�bkghf�� ijb� dhlhjhf� \hagbdZxl� kgh\b^_gby�� bf__lky� agZqbl_evgh_� koh^kl\h�� <_^v� ]bighahfgZau\Z_lky�bkdmkkl\_gguc�khg��fu�]h\hjbf�ebpm��dhlhjh_�]bighlbabjm_f��kibl_��b \gmr_gby�dhlhju_� fu� _fm� ^_eZ_f�� fh`gh� kjZ\gblv� kh� kgh\b^_gbyfb� \h� \j_fy� _kl_kl\_ggh]h� kgZ�Ikbobq_kdb_�kblmZpbb�\ h[hbo�kemqZyo�^_ckl\bl_evgh�ZgZeh]bqgu��Ijb�_kl_kl\_gghf�kg_�fu]Zkbf� bgl_j_k� d \g_rg_fm� fbjm�� ijb� ]bighlbq_kdhf� ²� hiylv�lZdb� dh� \k_fm� fbjm�� aZbkdexq_gb_f�ebpZ��dhlhjh_�gZk�]bighlbabjm_l��k dhlhjuf�fu�hklZ_fky�\ k\yab��<ijhq_f��lZdgZau\Z_fuc�khg�dhjfbebpu��ijb�dhlhjhf�hgZ�bf__l�k\yav�k j_[_gdhf�b lhevdh�bf�fh`_l�[ulvjZa[m`_gZ�� y\ey_lky� ghjfZevghc� ZgZeh]b_c� ]bighlbq_kdh]h� kgZ�� I_j_g_k_gb_� hkh[_gghkl_c]bighaZ� gZ� _kl_kl\_gguc� khg� g_� dZ`_lky� ihwlhfm� lZdbf� m`� kf_euf�� Ij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh\b^_\rbc�khg�lZd`_�agZ_l�h k\h_f�kgh\b^_gbb��dhlhjh_�_fm�lhevdh�g_^hklmigh��lZd�qlh�hg�bkZf� wlhfm� g_� \_jbl�� g_� kh\k_f� [_kihq\_ggh�� DklZlb�� aZf_lbf� k_[_�� qlh� a^_kv� i_j_^� gZfbhldju\Z_lky� lj_lbc�imlv�d bamq_gbx� kgh\b^_gbc��hl�gZjmrZxsbo� khg�jZa^jZ`_gbb��hl� kgh\gZy\m��Z l_i_jv�_s_�hl�kgh\b^_gbc��\gmr_gguo�\ ]bighlbq_kdhf�khklhygbb�: l_i_jv�� dh]^Z� gZrZ� m\_j_gghklv� \ k_[_� \hajhkeZ�� \_jg_fky� d gZr_c� ijh[e_f_��BlZd�hq_gv�\_jhylgh��qlh�\b^_\rbc� khg� agZ_l�h k\h_f� kgh\b^_gbb��b aZ^ZqZ� khklhbl�\ lhf��qlh[u^Zlv�_fm�\hafh`ghklv�h[gZjm`blv�wlh�agZgb_�b khh[sblv�_]h�gZf��Fu�g_�lj_[m_f��qlh[u�hgkjZam� kdZaZe� h kfuke_� k\h_]h� kgh\b^_gby��gh� hg�fh`_l� hldjulv�ijhbkoh`^_gb_� kgh\b^_gby�djm]�fuke_c�b bgl_j_kh\��dhlhju_� _]h�hij_^_ebeb��<kihfgbl_� kemqZc�hrb[hqgh]h�^_ckl\by�dh]^Z�m dh]h�lh�kijhkbeb��hldm^Z�ijhbahreZ�h]h\hjdZ�©9RUVFKZHLQª��b i_j\h_��qlh�ijbreh�_fm\ ]heh\m��^Zeh�gZf�jZatykg_gb_��GZrZ�l_ogbdZ�bkke_^h\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc�hq_gv�ijhklZ��\_kvfZihoh`Z�gZ�lhevdh�qlh�mihfygmluc�ijb_f��Fu�\gh\v�kijhkbf�\b^_\r_]h�khg��hldm^Z�m g_]h�wlhkgh\b^_gb_��b i_j\h_� _]h� \ukdZau\Zgb_�[m^_f� kqblZlv� h[tykg_gb_f��Fu�g_�[m^_f� h[jZsZlv\gbfZgb_�gZ� lh��^mfZ_l�eb�hg��qlh�qlh�lh� agZ_l��beb�g_�^mfZ_l��b \�h[hbo� kemqZyo�ihklmibfh^bgZdh\h�WlZ�l_ogbdZ��dhg_qgh��hq_gv�ijhklZ��gh��[hxkv��hgZ�\uah\_l�m \Zk�kZfuc�j_adbc�hlihj��<ukdZ`_l_�� gh\h_� ij_^iheh`_gb_�� lj_lv_�� B kZfh_� g_\_jhylgh_� ba� \k_o�� ?keb� y kijhrm� m\b^_\r_]h�khg��qlh�_fm�ijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m�ih�ih\h^m�kgh\b^_gby��lh�i_j\h_�`_��qlh�_fm�ijb^_l\ ]heh\m�� �b ^he`gh�^Zlv�`_eZ_fh_�h[tykg_gb_"�Gh�_fm�\hh[s_�fh`_l�gbq_]h�g_�ijbclb�bebijb^_l�[h]�agZ_l�qlh��Fu�g_�ihgbfZ_f��gZ�qlh�lml�fh`gh�jZkkqblu\Zlv��<hl�m`��^_ckl\bl_evgh�qlh�agZqbl�ijhy\blv�kebrdhf�fgh]h�^h\_jby�lZf��]^_�mf_klg__�[ueh�[u�ih[hevr_�djblbdb��Dlhfm�`_�kgh\b^_gb_�khklhbl�\_^v�g_�ba�h^gh]h�g_ijZ\bevgh]h�keh\Z��Z ba�fgh]bo� we_f_glh\�

Page 54: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

DZdhc�`_�fukeb��kemqZcgh�ijbr_^r_c�\ ]heh\m��gm`gh�ijb^_j`b\Zlvky"<u� ijZ\u� \h� \k_f�� qlh� dZkZ_lky� \lhjhkl_i_ggh]h�� Kgh\b^_gb_� hlebqZ_lky� hl� h]h\hjdblZd`_�b [hevrbf�dhebq_kl\hf�we_f_glh\��K wlbf�mkeh\b_f�l_ogbd_�g_h[oh^bfh�kqblZlvky��Ghy ij_^eZ]Zx� \Zf� jZa[blv� kgh\b^_gb_� gZ� we_f_glu� b bkke_^h\Zlv� dZ`^uc� we_f_gl� \hl^_evghklb�� b lh]^Z� \gh\v� \hagbdg_l� ZgZeh]by� k h]h\hjdhc�� <u� ijZ\u� b \� lhf�� qlh� ihhlghr_gbx� d hl^_evguf� we_f_glZf� kijZrb\Z_fuc� fh`_l� hl\_lblv�� qlh� _fm� gbq_]h� g_ijboh^bl� \ ]heh\m��?klv� kemqZb�� \ dhlhjuo�fu� m^h\e_l\hjbfky� wlbf� hl\_lhf��b iha^g__� \umagZ_l_�� dZdh\u� hgb�� Ijbf_qZl_evgh�� qlh� wlh� lZdb_� kemqZb�� h dhlhjuo� fu� kZfb� fh`_fkhklZ\blv�hij_^_e_ggh_�km`^_gb_��Gh�\ h[s_f��_keb�\b^_\rbc�khg�[m^_l�ml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�_fmgbq_]h�g_�ijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m��fu�\hajZabf�_fm��[m^_f�gZklZb\Zlv�gZ� k\h_f��m\_jylv� _]h��qlhohlv�qlh�lh�^he`gh�_fm�ijbclb�\ ]heh\m��b hdZ`_fky�ijZ\u��DZdZy�gb[m^v�fukev�ijb^_l�_fm�\]heh\m�� gZf� [_ajZaebqgh� dZdZy�� Hkh[_ggh� e_]dh� _fm� [m^_l� ^Zlv� k\_^_gby�� dhlhju_� fh`ghgZa\Zlv� bklhjbq_kdbfb�� Hg� kdZ`_l�� \hl� wlh� kemqbehkv� \q_jZ� �dZd� \ h[hbo� ba\_klguo� gZf©lj_a\uoª�kgh\b^_gbyo��beb��wlh�gZihfbgZ_l�qlh�lh�g_^Z\gh�kemqb\r__ky��lZdbf�h[jZahf��fuaZf_qZ_f��qlh�k\yab�kgh\b^_gbc�k \i_qZle_gbyfb�ihke_^gbo�^g_c�\klj_qZxlky�gZfgh]h�qZs_�q_f�fu�kgZqZeZ�ij_^iheZ]Zeb��Bkoh^y�ba�kgh\b^_gby��\b^_\rbc�khg�ijbihfgbl��gZdhg_p��[he__hl^Ze_ggu_��\hafh`gh�^Z`_�kh\k_f�^Ze_db_�kh[ulby�Gh� \ ]eZ\ghf� \u�g_�ijZ\u��?keb� \u� kqblZ_l_� kebrdhf�ijhba\hevguf�ij_^iheh`_gb_� hlhf��qlh�i_j\Zy�`_�fukev�\b^_\r_]h�khg�dZd�jZa�b ^Zkl�bkdhfh_�beb�^he`gZ�ijb\_klb�d g_fm�_keb� \u� ^mfZ_l_�� qlh� wlZ� i_j\Zy� ijbr_^rZy� \ ]heh\m� fukev� fh`_l� [ulv�� kdhj__� \k_]h�kh\_jr_ggh� kemqZcghc�b g_� k\yaZgghc� k bkdhfuf��qlh� y ijhklh� ebrv� \_jx� \ lh��qlh�fh`ghh`b^Zlv� hl� g__� ^jm]h]h�� lh� \u� ]em[hdh� aZ[em`^Z_l_kv�� Y m`_� iha\hebe� k_[_� h^gZ`^uij_^mij_^blv�\Zk��qlh�\ \Zk�dhj_gblky�\_jZ�\ ikbobq_kdmx�k\h[h^m�b ijhba\hevghklv��gh�hgZkh\_jr_ggh� g_gZmqgZ� b ^he`gZ� mklmiblv� lj_[h\Zgbx� g_h[oh^bfh]h� ^_l_jfbgbafZ� b \^mr_\ghc�`bagb��Y ijhrm�\Zk�kqblZlvky�k nZdlhf��qlh�kijhr_gghfm�ijb^_l�\ ]heh\m�bf_gghwlh�b gbqlh�^jm]h_��Gh�y g_�ohqm�ijhlb\hihklZ\eylv�h^gm�\_jm�^jm]hc��Fh`gh�^hdZaZlv��qlhijbr_^rZy�\ ]heh\m� kijhr_gghfm�fukev�g_�ijhba\hevgZ�� Z \iheg_�hij_^_e_ggZ�b k\yaZgZ� kbkdhfuf�gZfb�����>Z��y g_^Z\gh�magZe��g_�ijb^Z\Zy��\ijhq_f��wlhfm�[hevrh]h�agZq_gby��qlh�bwdki_jbf_glZevgZy�ikboheh]by�jZkiheZ]Z_l�lZdbfb�^hdZaZl_evkl\Zfb�< k\yab� k \Z`ghklvx� h[km`^Z_fh]h� ij_^f_lZ� ijhrm� \Zr_]h� hkh[h]h� \gbfZgby�� ?keb� yijhrm� dh]h�lh� kdZaZlv�� qlh� _fm� ijbreh� \ ]heh\m� ih� ih\h^m� hij_^_e_ggh]h� we_f_glZkgh\b^_gby�� lh� y lj_[mx� hl� g_]h�� qlh[u� hg� hl^Zeky� k\h[h^ghc� ZkkhpbZpbb�� ijb^_j`b\Zykvbkoh^gh]h�ij_^klZ\e_gby��Wlh�lj_[m_l�hkh[hc�mklZgh\db�\gbfZgby��dhlhjZy�kh\_jr_ggh�bgZy�q_f� mklZgh\dZ� ijb� jZafure_gbb�� b bkdexqZ_l� ihke_^g__�� G_dhlhjuf� e_]dh� ^Z_lky� lZdZymklZgh\dZ��^jm]b_�h[gZjm`b\Zxl�ijb�lZdhf�hiul_�ihqlb�ihegmx�g_kihkh[ghklv��Kms_kl\m_l�b[he__� \ukhdZy� kl_i_gv� k\h[h^u� ZkkhpbZpbb�� dh]^Z� himkdZ_lky� lZd`_� b wlh� bkoh^gh_ij_^klZ\e_gb_�b hij_^_ey_lky�lhevdh�\b^�b jh^�\hagbdZxs_c�fukeb��gZijbf_j��hij_^_ey_lkyk\h[h^gh�\hagbdZxs__�bfy�kh[kl\_ggh_�beb�qbkeh��WlZ�\hagbdZxsZy�fukev�fh`_l�[ulv�_s_ijhba\hevg__�� _s_� [he__� g_ij_^\b^_gghc�� q_f� \hagbdZxsZy� ijb� bkihevah\Zgbb� gZr_cl_ogbdb�� Gh� fh`gh� ^hdZaZlv�� qlh� hgZ� dZ`^uc� jZa� kljh]h� ^_l_jfbgbjm_lky� \Z`gufb\gmlj_ggbfb�mklZgh\dZfb��g_ba\_klgufb�gZf�b fhf_gl�bo�^_ckl\by�b lZd�`_�fZeh�ba\_klgufb�

Page 55: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dZd� gZjmrZxsb_� l_g^_gpbb� ijb� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\byo� b l_g^_gpbb�� ijh\hpbjmxsb_kemqZcgu_�^_ckl\by�Y b�fgh]b_�^jm]b_�ihke_�f_gy�g_h^ghdjZlgh�ijh\h^beb�lZdb_�bkke_^h\Zgby�k bf_gZfb�bqbkeZfb�� kZfhijhba\hevgh� \hagbdZxsbfb� \ fukeyo�� g_dhlhju_� ba� gbo� [ueb� lZd`_him[ebdh\Zgu�� Ijb� wlhf� ihklmiZxl� ke_^mxsbf� h[jZahf�� d ijbr_^r_fm� \ ]heh\m� bf_gb\uau\Zxl�jy^�ZkkhpbZpbc��dhlhju_�m`_�g_�kh\k_f�k\h[h^gu��Z k\yaZgu��dZd�b fukeb�ih�ih\h^mwe_f_glh\� kgh\b^_gby�� b wlh� ijh^he`Zxl� ^h� l_o� ihj�� ihdZ� k\yav� g_� bkq_jiZ_lky�� Gh� aZl_f\uykgyebkv�b fhlb\bjh\dZ��b agZq_gb_�k\h[h^gh�\hagbdZxs_]h�bf_gb��J_amevlZlu�hiulh\�\k_\j_fy� ih\lhjyxlky�� khh[s_gb_� h gbo� qZklh� lj_[m_l� baeh`_gby� [hevrh]h� nZdlbq_kdh]hfZl_jbZeZ� b g_h[oh^bfuo� ih^jh[guo� jZatykg_gbc�� <hafh`gh�� kZfufb� ^hdZaZl_evgufby\eyxlky�ZkkhpbZpbb�k\h[h^gh�\hagbdZxsbo�qbk_e��hgb�ijhl_dZxl�lZd�[ukljh�b gZijZ\eyxlkyd kdjulhc�p_eb�k lZdhc�m\_j_gghklvx��qlh�ijhklh�hr_ehfeyxl��Y ohqm�ijb\_klb�\Zf� lhevdhh^bg�ijbf_j�k lZdbf�ZgZebahf�bf_gb��lZd�dZd�_]h��d kqZklvx��fh`gh�baeh`blv�djZldh�<h�\j_fy�e_q_gby�h^gh]h�fheh^h]h�q_eh\_dZ�y aZ]h\Zjb\Zx�k gbf�gZ�wlm�l_fm�b mihfbgZxiheh`_gb_�h lhf��qlh��g_kfhljy�gZ�dZ`msmxky�ijhba\hevghklv��g_�fh`_l�ijbclb�\ ]heh\m�bfy�dhlhjh_� g_� hdZaZehkv� [u� h[mkeh\e_gguf� [eb`Zcrbfb� hlghr_gbyfb�� hkh[_gghklyfbbkiulm_fh]h�b _]h�gZklhysbf�iheh`_gb_f��LZd�dZd�hg�khfg_\Z_lky�\ wlhf��y ij_^eZ]Zx�_fm��g_hldeZ^u\Zy�� kZfhfm� ijh\_klb� lZdhc� hiul��Y agZx�� qlh� m g_]h� hkh[_ggh�fgh]h� jZagh]h� jh^Zhlghr_gbc�k `_gsbgZfb�b ^_\mrdZfb�b iheZ]Zx�ihwlhfm��qlh�m g_]h�[m^_l�hkh[_ggh�[hevrhc\u[hj�� _keb� _fm�ij_^eh`blv�gZa\Zlv�i_j\h_�ihiZ\r__ky�`_gkdh_�bfy��Hg� kh]eZrZ_lky��Gk� dfh_fm�beb��\_jg__��d _]h�m^b\e_gbx��gZ�f_gy�g_�dZlblky�eZ\bgZ�`_gkdbo�bf_g��Z��ihfheqZ\��hgijbagZ_lky�� qlh� _fm� ijbreh� gZ� mf� \k_]h� ebrv� h^gh� bfy�� :ev[bgZ�� KljZggh�� qlh� `_� \uk\yau\Z_l_�k wlbf�bf_g_f"�Kdhevdh�:ev[bg�\u�agZ_l_"�IhjZabl_evgh��gh�hg�g_�agZ_l�gb�h^ghc:ev[bgu��b [hevr_�_fm�gbq_]h�g_�ijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m�ih�ih\h^m�wlh]h�bf_gb�BlZd��fh`gh�[uehij_^iheh`blv��qlh�ZgZeba�g_�m^Zeky��gh�g_l��hg�[ue�m`_�aZdhgq_g��b g_�ihlj_[h\Zehkv�gbdZdbo^jm]bo�fuke_c��M fheh^h]h�q_eh\_dZ�[ue�g_h[uqgh�k\_leuc�p\_l�\hehk��\h�\j_fy�[_k_^�ijbe_q_gbb� y qZklh� \ rmldm� gZau\Ze� _]h� :ev[bgZ�� fu� dZd� jZa� aZgbfZebkv� \uykg_gb_f� ^heb`_gkdh]h� gZqZeZ� \ _]h� dhgklblmpbb�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� hg� kZf� [ue� wlhc� :ev[bghc�� kZfhcbgl_j_kghc�^ey�g_]h�\ wlh�\j_fy�`_gsbghc�Lh� `_� kZfh_� hlghkblky� d g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh� \kieu\Zxsbf� f_eh^byf�� dhlhju_hij_^_e_gguf�h[jZahf�h[mkeh\e_gu�djm]hf�fuke_c�q_eh\_dZ��aZgbfZxsbfb�_]h��ohly�hg�wlh]hb g_� aZf_qZ_l�� E_]dh� ihdZaZlv�� qlh� hlghr_gb_� d f_eh^bb� k\yaZgh� k __� l_dklhf� bebijhbkoh`^_gb_f�� gh� ke_^m_l� [ulv� hklhjh`guf�� wlh� ml\_j`^_gb_� g_� jZkijhkljZgy_lky� gZ^_ckl\bl_evgh�fmaudZevguo�ex^_c��hlghkbl_evgh�dhlhjuo�m f_gy�ijhklh�g_l�^Zgguo��M lZdboex^_c� __ ihy\e_gb_� fh`_l� h[tykgylvky� fmaudZevguf� kh^_j`Zgb_f� f_eh^bb�� Gh� qZs_\klj_qZ_lky��dhg_qgh��i_j\uc�kemqZc��LZd��y agZx�h^gh]h�fheh^h]h�q_eh\_dZ��dhlhjh]h�^he]h_\j_fy�ij_ke_^h\ZeZ�ij_e_klgZy�i_kgy�IZjbkZ�ba�Ij_djZkghc�?e_gu�>Hnn_g[ZoZ@��ihdZ�ZgZebag_�h[jZlbe�_]h�\gbfZgby�gZ�dhgdmj_gpbx�©B^uª�b ©?e_guª��aZgbfZ\rmx�_]h�\ lh�\j_fy�BlZd�� _keb� kh\_jr_ggh� k\h[h^gh� \hagbdZxsb_� fukeb� h[mkeh\e_gu� lZdbf� h[jZahf� bih^qbg_gu�hij_^_e_gghc�k\yab��lh�l_f�[he__�fu�fh`_f�aZdexqblv��qlh�fukeb�k _^bgkl\_gghck\yavx�� k bkoh^guf� ij_^klZ\e_gb_f�� fh]ml� [ulv� g_� f_g__� h[mkeh\e_ggufb�� Bkke_^h\Zgb_

Page 56: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

^_ckl\bl_evgh�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh��djhf_�ij_^iheZ]Z_fhc�gZfb�k\yab�k bkoh^guf�ij_^klZ\e_gb_f�ke_^m_l� ijbagZlv� bo� \lhjmx� aZ\bkbfhklv� hl� [h]Zluo� Znn_dlZfb� fuke_c� b bgl_j_kh\�dhfie_dkh\��\ha^_ckl\b_�dhlhjuo�\ gZklhysbc�fhf_gl�g_ba\_klgh��l��_��[_kkhagZl_evgh�K\h[h^gh� \hagbdZxsb_� fukeb� k lZdhc� k\yavx� [ueb� ij_^f_lhf� hq_gv� ihmqbl_evguowdki_jbf_glZevguo� bkke_^h\Zgbc�� ku]jZ\rbo� \ bklhjbb� ikbohZgZebaZ� ^hklhcgmx� \gbfZgbyjhev��RdheZ�<mg^lZ� ij_^eh`beZ� lZd� gZau\Z_fuc� ZkkhpbZlb\guc� wdki_jbf_gl�� ijb� dhlhjhfbkiulm_fhfm� ij_^eZ]Zehkv� dZd� fh`gh� [uklj__� hl\_lblv� ex[hc� j_Zdpb_c� gZ� keh\h�jZa^jZ`bl_ev��AZl_f�bamqZebkv�bgl_j\Ze�f_`^m�jZa^jZ`_gb_f�b j_Zdpb_c��oZjZdl_j�hl\_lghcj_Zdpbb�� hrb[db� ijb� ih\lhj_gbb� lh]h�`_� wdki_jbf_glZ� b ih^h[gh_��PxjbokdZy�rdheZ� ih^jmdh\h^kl\hf� ;e_ce_jZ� b Xg]Z� ^ZeZ� h[tykg_gb_� ijhbkoh^ysbf� ijb� ZkkhpbZlb\ghfwdki_jbf_gl_� j_Zdpbyf�� ij_^eh`b\� bkiulm_fhfm� jZatykgylv� ihemq_ggu_� j_Zdpbb^hihegbl_evgufb� ZkkhpbZpbyfb�� _keb� hgb� kZfb� ih� k_[_� ijb\e_dZeb� \gbfZgb_� k\h_cg_h[uqghklvx��AZl_f�hdZaZehkv��qlh�wlb�g_h[uqgu_�j_Zdpbb�kZfuf�l_kguf�h[jZahf�k\yaZgu�kdhfie_dkZfb�bkiulm_fh]h��L_f�kZfuf�;e_ce_j�b Xg]�i_j_[jhkbeb�fhkl�hl�wdki_jbf_glZevghcikboheh]bb�d ikbohZgZebam�GZ� hkgh\Zgbb� wlbo� ^Zgguo� \u� fh`_l_� kdZaZlv�� ©L_i_jv� fu� ijbagZ_f�� qlh� k\h[h^gh\hagbdZxsb_� fukeb� ^_l_jfbgbjh\Zgu�� g_� ijhba\hevgu�� dZd� fu� iheZ]Zeb�� Lh�`_� kZfh_� fu^himkdZ_f�b ih�hlghr_gbx�d fukeyf��\hagbdZxsbf�ih�ih\h^m�we_f_glh\�kgh\b^_gby��Gh�\_^vwlh�g_� lh��qlh�gZf�gm`gh��<_^v�\u�ml\_j`^Z_l_��qlh�fukeb��ijbr_^rb_�ih�ih\h^m� we_f_glZkgh\b^_gby�� ^_l_jfbgbjh\Zgu� dZdhc�lh� g_ba\_klghc� ikbobq_kdhc� hkgh\hc� bf_ggh� wlh]hwe_f_glZ�� : gZf� wlh� g_� dZ`_lky� hq_\b^guf��Fu� m`_� ij_^iheZ]Z_f�� qlh� fukev� ih� ih\h^mwe_f_glZ� kgh\b^_gby� ij_^hij_^_e_gZ� dhfie_dkZfb� \b^_\r_]h� khg�� gh� dZdZy� gZf� hl� wlh]hihevaZ"� Wlh� ijb\_^_l� gZk� g_� d ihgbfZgbx� kgh\b^_gby�� gh� lhevdh� d agZgbx� wlbo� lZdgZau\Z_fuo�dhfie_dkh\��dZd�wlh�[ueh�\ ZkkhpbZlb\ghf�wdki_jbf_gl_��Gh�qlh�m gbo�h[s_]h�khkgh\b^_gb_f"ª<u� ijZ\u�� gh� mimkdZ_l_� h^bg� fhf_gl�� DklZlb�� bf_ggh� lhl�� ba�aZ� dhlhjh]h� y g_� ba[jZeZkkhpbZlb\guc� wdki_jbf_gl� bkoh^ghc� lhqdhc� wlh]h� bh�eh`_gby�� < wlhf� wdki_jbf_gl_� h^gZ^_l_jfbgZglZ�j_Zdpbb��Z bf_ggh�keh\h�jZa^jZ`bl_ev��\u[bjZ_lky�gZfb�ijhba\hevgh��J_Zdpbyy\ey_lky� ihkj_^gbdhf� f_`^m� wlbf� keh\hf�jZa^jZ`bl_e_f� b aZljhgmluf� bf� dhfie_dkhfbkiulm_fh]h�� Ijb� kgh\b^_gbb� keh\h�jZa^jZ`bl_ev� aZf_gy_lky� q_f�lh�� qlh� kZfh� bkoh^bl� ba^mr_\ghc�`bagb�\b^_\r_]h�khg��ba�g_ba\_klguo�_fm�bklhqgbdh\��l��_��ba�lh]h��qlh�kZfh�e_]dhfh]eh�[u�klZlv� ©ijhba\h^guf�hl�dhfie_dkZª��Ihwlhfm�gZijZrb\Z_lky�ij_^iheh`_gb_��qlh�bk\yaZggu_� k we_f_glZfb� kgh\b^_gby� ^Zevg_crb_� fukeb� [m^ml� hij_^_e_gu� g_� ^jm]bfdhfie_dkhf��Z bf_ggh�dhfie_dkhf�kZfh]h�we_f_glZ�b ijb\_^ml�lZd`_�d _]h�jZkdjulbx�Iha\hevl_� fg_� gZ� ^jm]hf� ijbf_j_� ihdZaZlv�� qlh� ^_eh� h[klhbl� bf_ggh� lZd�� dZd� fuij_^iheZ]Z_f� \ gZr_f� kemqZ_�� AZ[u\Zgb_� bf_g� kh[kl\_gguo� y\ey_lky�� kh[kl\_ggh� ]h\hjy�ij_djZkguf�ijbf_jhf�^ey�ZgZebaZ�kgh\b^_gby�� lhevdh� a^_kv�\ h^ghf�ebp_� keb\Z_lky� lh��qlhijb� lhedh\Zgbb� kgh\b^_gby� jZkij_^_ey_lky�f_`^m� ^\mfy��?keb� y \j_f_ggh� aZ[ue� bfy�� lh� mf_gy� _klv� m\_j_gghklv�� qlh� y wlh� bfy� agZx�� lZ� m\_j_gghklv�� dhlhjmx� fu� fh`_f� \gmrblv\b^_\r_fm�khg�lhevdh�h[oh^guf�iml_f�ijb�ihfhsb�wdki_jbf_glZ�;_jg]_cfZ��Gh�aZ[ulh_��ohlyb agZdhfh_�bfy�fg_�g_^hklmigh��<k_�mkbeby�\kihfgblv�_]h�gb d�q_fm�g_�ijb\h^yl��wlh�y agZx

Page 57: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ih�hiulm��Gh�\f_klh�aZ[ulh]h�bf_gb�y fh]m�ijb^mfZlv�h^gh�beb�g_kdhevdh�aZf_sZxsbo�bf_g�B _keb�lZdh_�bfy�aZf_klbl_ev��(UVDW]��ijb^_l�fg_�\ ]h�eh\m�kihglZggh��lhevdh�lh]^Z�kblmZpby[m^_l�ihoh`Z�gZ�ZgZeba�kgh\b^_gby��We_f_gl�kgh\b^_gby�\_^v�lh`_�g_�lh��qlh�gm`gh��lhevdhaZf_klbl_ev� lh]h�^jm]h]h��gm`gh]h�� q_]h� y g_� agZx�b qlh�gm`gh�gZclb�ijb�ihfhsb� ZgZebaZkgh\b^_gby�� JZaebqb_� hiylv�lZdb� lhevdh� \ lhf�� qlh� ijb� aZ[u\Zgbb� bf_g� y g_� ijbagZxaZf_klbl_ev�kh[kl\_gguf� >kh^_j`Zgb_f@� �(LJHQWOLFKH���Z ^ey�we_f_glZ�kgh\b^_gby�gZf�ljm^ghklZlv�gZ�wlm�lhqdm�aj_gby��Gh�b ijb�aZ[u\Zgbb�bf_g�_klv�imlv�hl�aZf_klbl_ey�d kh[kl\_gghfm[_kkhagZl_evghfm�>kh^_j`Zgbx@��d aZ[ulhfm�bf_gb��?keb�y gZijZ\ex�k\h_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�bf_gZ�aZf_klbl_eb�b [m^m�ke_^blv�aZ�ijboh^ysbfb�fg_�\ ]heh\m�fukeyfb�ih�bo�ih\h^m��lh�jZgh�bebiha^gh�y gZc^m�aZ[ulh_�bfy�b ijb�wlhf�h[gZjm`blky��qlh�bf_gZ�aZf_klbl_eb��dZd�b ijbr_^rb_fg_�\ ]heh\m��[ueb�k\yaZgu�k aZ[uluf��[ueb�^_l_jfbgbjh\Zgu�bf�Y ohqm�ijb\_klb�\Zf�ijbf_j�ZgZebaZ�lZdh]h�jh^Z��h^gZ`^u�y aZf_lbe��qlh�aZ[ue�gZa\Zgb_fZe_gvdhc�kljZgu�gZ�Jb\v_j_��]eZ\guc�]hjh^�dhlhjhc�Fhgl_�DZjeh��Wlh�[ueh�^hkZ^gh��gh�lZd�Y \kihfbgZx�\k_��qlh�agZx�h[�wlhc�kljZg_��^mfZx�h dgya_�:ev[_jl_�ba�^hfZ�Emabgvyg��h _]h[jZdZo��h _]h�ex[\b�d bkke_^h\Zgbx�fhjkdbo�]em[bg�b h[h�\k_f��qlh�fg_�\^Z_lky�\kihfgblv��ghgbq_]h� g_� ihfh]Z_l�� Ihwlhfm� y ij_djZsZx� jZafure_gb_� b klZjZxkv� aZf_gblv� aZ[ulh_gZa\Zgb_��>jm]b_� gZa\Zgby� [ukljh� \kieu\Zxl��KZfh�Fhgl_�DZjeh�� aZl_f�Iv_fhgl��:e[Zgby�Fhgl_\b^_h��Dhebdh�KgZqZeZ�\ wlhf�jy^m�fg_�[jhkZ_lky�\ ]eZaZ�:e[Zgby��hgZ�[ukljh� kf_gy_lky�Fhgl_g_]jh�\hafh`gh�� dZd� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv� [_eh]h� b q_jgh]h�� AZl_f� y aZf_qZx�� qlh� \ wlbo� q_luj_ogZa\Zgbyo�aZf_klbl_eyo�kh^_j`blky�keh]�fhg��\^jm]�y \kihfbgZx� aZ[ulh_�gZa\Zgb_�b ]jhfdhijhbaghrm�FhgZdh�� AZf_klbl_eb� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� bkoh^beb� ba� aZ[ulh]h�� i_j\u_� q_luj_� ba� i_j\h]hkeh]Z�� ihke_^g__� \hkijhba\h^bl� ihke_^h\Zl_evghklv� keh]h\� b \_kv� dhg_qguc� keh]�� F_`^mijhqbf��y fh]m�\hkklZgh\blv��ihq_fm�y gZ�\j_fy�aZ[ue�gZa\Zgb_��FhgZdh�bf__l�hlghr_gb_�dFxgo_gm��wlh�_]h�blZevygkdh_�gZa\Zgb_��gZa\Zgb_�wlh]h�]hjh^Z�b hdZaZeh�lhjfhays__�\ebygb_�Ijbf_j�� dhg_qgh�� ohjhr�� gh� kebrdhf� ijhkl��< ^jm]bo� kemqZyo� d i_j\uf� aZf_sZxsbfgZa\Zgbyf�ke_^h\Zeh�[u�ijb[Z\blv�[he__�^ebgguc�jy^�\hagbdZxsbo�fuke_c��lh]^Z�ZgZeh]by�kZgZebahf�kgh\b^_gby�[ueZ�[u�ykg__��M f_gy�b \�wlhf�_klv�hiul��Dh]^Z�h^gZ`^u�g_agZdhf_pijb]eZkbe�f_gy�\uiblv�blZevygkdh]h�\bgZ��\ j_klhjZg_�hdZaZehkv��qlh�hg�aZ[ue�gZa\Zgb_�\bgZ�dhlhjh_�ohl_e�aZdZaZlv��lhevdh�ihlhfm��qlh�h g_f�hklZebkv�emqrb_�\hkihfbgZgby��Ba�[hevrh]hqbkeZ�aZf_sZxsbo�gZa\Zgbc��dhlhju_�ijbreb�_fm�\ ]heh\m�\f_klh�aZ[ulh]h��y k^_eZe�\u\h^�qlh�gZa\Zgb_� aZ[ulh�ba�aZ� dZdhc�lh�=_^\b]b��b ^_ckl\bl_evgh�� hg�g_� lhevdh�ih^l\_j^be�� qlhijh[h\Ze�_]h�\ h[s_kl\_�h^ghc�=_^\b]b��gh�b \kihfgbe�[eZ]h^Zjy�wlhfm�_]h�gZa\Zgb_��D wlhfm\j_f_gb�hg�[ue�kqZkleb\h�`_gZl��Z lZ�=_^\b]Z�hlghkbeZkv�d [he__�jZgg_fm�\j_f_gb��h dhlhjhfhg�g_hohlgh�\kihfbgZe�Lh�� qlh� hdZaZehkv� \hafh`guf� ijb� aZ[u\Zgbb� bf_g�� ^he`gh� m^Zklvky� b ijb� lhedh\Zgbbkgh\b^_gbc�� b^y� hl� aZf_klbl_ey� q_j_a� k\yau\Zxsb_� ZkkhpbZpbb�� fh`gh� k^_eZlv� ^hklmigufkdjulh_� kh[kl\_ggh_� >kh^_j`Zgb_@�� Ih� ijbf_jm� aZ[u\Zgby� bf_g� fu� fh`_f� kdZaZlv� h[ZkkhpbZpbyo� k we_f_glhf� kgh\b^_gby�� qlh� hgb� ^_l_jfbgbjh\Zgu� dZd� kZfbf� we_f_glhfkgh\b^_gby�� lZd� b kh[kl\_gguf� [_kkhagZl_evguf� >kh^_j`Zgb_f@�� L_f� kZfuf� fu� ijb\_eb

Page 58: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_dhlhju_�^hdZaZl_evkl\Z�ijZ\hf_jghklb�gZr_c�l_ogbdb�K?>VF:Y�E?DPBYY\gh_�kh^_j`Zgb_�kgh\b^_gby�b kdjulu_�_]h�fukebM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� <u� \b^bl_�� qlh� fu� g_� [_a� ihevau� bamqZeb� hrb[hqgu_^_ckl\by��;eZ]h^Zjy�wlbf�mkbebyf�fu�²�bkoh^y�ba�ba\_klguo�\Zf�ij_^iheh`_gbc�²�mk\hbeb^\Z�fhf_glZ��ihgbfZgb_� we_f_glZ�kgh\b^_gby�b l_ogbdm� lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gby��IhgbfZgb_we_f_glZ� kgh\b^_gby� aZdexqZ_lky� \ lhf�� qlh� hg�g_� y\ey_lky� kh[kl\_gguf� �kh^_j`Zgb_f� @�� ZaZf_klbl_e_f�q_]h�lh�^jm]h]h��g_ba\_klgh]h�\b^_\r_fm�khg��ih^h[gh�gZf_j_gbx�hrb[hqgh]h^_ckl\by�� aZf_klbl_e_f� q_]h�lh�� h q_f� \b^_\rbc� khg� agZ_l�� gh� wlh� agZgb_� _fm� g_^hklmigh�GZ^__fky�� qlh� wlh�`_� ihgbfZgb_�fh`gh� jZkijhkljZgblv� b gZ� \k_� kgh\b^_gb_�� khklhys__� balZdbo� we_f_glh\�� GZrZ� l_ogbdZ� khklhbl� \ lhf�� qlh[u� [eZ]h^Zjy� k\h[h^guf� ZkkhpbZpbyf\ua\Zlv� d wlbf� we_f_glZf� ^jm]b_� aZf_sZxsb_� ij_^klZ\e_gby�� ba� dhlhjuo� fh`gh� magZlvkdjulh_�L_i_jv� y ij_^eZ]Zx� \Zf� \g_klb�baf_g_gby� \ l_jfbgheh]bx�� dhlhju_� ^he`gu� mijhklblvgZr_� baeh`_gb_�� <f_klh� ©kdjulh_�� g_^hklmigh_�� g_� kh[kl\_ggh_� � >kh^_j`Zgb_@ª� fu�\ujZ`Zykv� lhqg__�� kdZ`_f� ©g_^hklmigh_� khagZgbx� \b^_\r_]h� khg�� beb� [_kkhagZl_evgh_ª�XQEHZX%W���Ih^�wlbf�fu�ih^jZamf_\Z_f� �dZd�wlh�[ueh�b \�hlghr_gbb�d aZ[ulhfm�keh\m�bebgZjmrZxs_c� l_g^_gpbb� hrb[hqgh]h� ^_ckl\by�� g_� qlh� bgh_�� dZd� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� \ ^Zggucfhf_gl��< ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv�wlhfm�fu��dhg_qgh��fh`_f�gZa\Zlv�kZfb�we_f_glu�kgh\b^_gby�b\gh\v�ihemq_ggu_�[eZ]h^Zjy�ZkkhpbZpbyf�aZf_sZxsb_�ij_^klZ\e_gby�khagZl_evgufb��K wlbfgZa\Zgb_f� g_� k\yaZgZ� dZdZy�lh� gh\Zy� l_hj_lbq_kdZy� dhgkljmdpby�� Mihlj_[e_gb_� keh\Z©[_kkhagZl_evgh_ª��dZd�e_]dh�ihgylgh]h�b ih^oh^ys_]h��g_�fh`_l�\ua\Zlv�\hajZ`_gbc�?keb� fu� jZkijhkljZgbf� gZr_� ihgbfZgb_� hl^_evgh]h� we_f_glZ� gZ� \k_� kgh\b^_gb_�� lhihemqblky�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� dZd� p_eh_� y\ey_lky� bkdZ`_gguf� aZf_klbl_e_f� q_]h�lh� ^jm]h]h�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��b aZ^ZqZ�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gby�²�gZclb�wlh�[_kkhagZl_evgh_��Hlkx^Z�kjZam\u\h^ylky� ljb� \Z`guo� ijZ\beZ�� dhlhjuo� fu� ^he`gu� ijb^_j`b\Zlvky� \h� \j_fy� jZ[hlu� gZ^lhedh\Zgb_f�kgh\b^_gby�����g_�gm`gh�h[jZsZlv�\gbfZgb_�gZ�lh��qlh�y\ey_l�kh[hc�kgh\b^_gb_�[m^v�hgh�ihgylguf�beb�Z[kmj^guf��ykguf�beb� kimlZgguf�� lZd�dZd�hgh� \k_�jZ\gh�gb�\ dh_fkemqZ_� g_� y\ey_lky� bkdhfuf� [_kkhagZl_evguf� �_kl_kl\_ggh_� h]jZgbq_gb_� wlh]h� ijZ\beZgZijZrb\Z_lky� kZfh� kh[hc��� ��� jZ[hlm� h]jZgbqb\Zlv� l_f�� qlh� d dZ`^hfm� we_f_glm� \uau\ZlvaZf_sZxsb_� ij_^klZ\e_gby�� g_� aZ^mfu\Zykv� h gbo�� g_� ijh\_jyy�� kh^_j`Zl� eb� hgb� qlh�lhih^oh^ys__��g_� h[jZsZlv� \gbfZgby��gZkdhevdh� hgb� hldehgyxlky� hl� we_f_glZ� kgh\b^_gby�� ��gm`gh� \u`^Zlv�� ihdZ� kdjulh_�� bkdhfh_� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� \hagbdg_l� kZfh�� lhqgh� lZd� `_�� dZdaZ[ulh_�keh\h�FhgZdh�\ hibkZgghf�ijbf_j_L_i_jv�gZf�lZd`_�ihgylgh��gZkdhevdh�[_ajZaebqgh��ohjhrh�beb�iehoh��\_jgh�beb�g_\_jgh\hkklZgh\e_gh�\ iZfylb� kgh\b^_gb_��<_^v�\hkklZgh\e_ggh_�\ iZfylb� kgh\b^_gb_�g_� y\ey_lkykh[kl\_gguf�kh^_j`Zgb_f��gh�lhevdh�bkdZ`_gguf�aZf_klbl_e_f�lh]h��qlh�^he`gh�gZf�ihfhqviml_f� \uau\Zgby� ^jm]bo� aZf_sZxsbo� ij_^klZ\e_gbc� ijb[ebablvky� d kh[kl\_gghfmkh^_j`Zgbx�� k^_eZlv� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� khagZl_evguf��?keb� \hkihfbgZgb_� [ueh� g_lhqguf�� lh

Page 59: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijhklh� \ aZf_klbl_e_� ijhbahreh� ^Zevg_cr__� bkdZ`_gb_�� dhlhjh_�� h^gZdh�� g_� fh`_l� [ulvg_fhlb\bjh\Zgguf�JZ[hlm�lhedh\Zgby�fh`gh�ijh\_klb�dZd�gZ�kh[kl\_gguo�kgh\b^_gbyo��lZd�b gZ�kgh\b^_gbyo^jm]bo�� GZ� kh[kl\_gguo� ^Z`_� [hevr_fm� gZmqbrvky�� ijhp_kk� lhedh\Zgby� a^_kv� [he__m[_^bl_e_g��BlZd��_keb�ihiulZ_rvky�wlh�k^_eZlv��lh�aZf_qZ_rv��qlh�qlh�lh�ijhlb\blky�jZ[hl_�Fukeb� ohly� b \hagbdZxl�� gh� g_� \k_f� bf� ijb^Z_rv� agZq_gb_�� Ijhba\h^blky� ijh\_jdZ�� b^_eZ_lky�\u[hj��H[�h^ghc�fukeb�]h\hjbrv�k_[_��g_l��wlh�a^_kv�g_�ih^� �Ih�kfukem�^he`gh�[ulv�©kh[kl\_ggh_ª�²�Ijbf_q�j_^�i_j_\h^Zoh^bl��g_�hlghkblky� kx^Z��h ^jm]hc�²� wlh� kebrdhf�[_kkfuke_ggh��h lj_lv_c�²� wlh�m`kh\k_f�\lhjhkl_i_ggh��b \kdhj_�aZf_qZ_rv��qlh�ijb�lZdbo�\hajZ`_gbyo�fukeb�aZ^_j`b\Zxlkyij_`^_�� q_f� klZgml� kh\_jr_ggh� ykgufb�� b gZdhg_p� ijh]hgyxlky�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� k h^ghcklhjhgu�� kebrdhf� kbevgh� aZ\bkbrv� hl� bkoh^gh]h� ij_^klZ\e_gby�� hl� kZfh]h� we_f_glZkgh\b^_gby�� k ^jm]hc� ²� \u[hj� f_rZ_l� j_amevlZlm� k\h[h^ghc� ZkkhpbZpbb�� ?keb� lhedh\Zgb_kgh\b^_gby�ijh\h^brv�g_�gZ_^bg_��Z ijhkbrv�dh]h�gb[m^v�lhedh\Zlv�k\h_�kgh\b^_gb_��lh�ykghqm\kl\m_rv� _s_� h^bg� fhlb\�� dhlhjuf� hijZ\^u\Z_rv� lZdhc� g_^himklbfuc� \u[hj�� Lh]^Z]h\hjbrv�k_[_�ih�ih\h^m�hl^_evguo�fuke_c��g_l��wlZ�fukev�kebrdhf�g_ijbylgZ��y g_�ohqm�bebg_�fh]m�__ \ukdZaZlv�Wlb�\hajZ`_gby�y\gh�m]jh`Zxl�mki_rghklb�gZr_c�jZ[hlu��Ijhlb\�gbo�gm`gh�aZsblblvky�b ijb�ZgZeba_�kh[kl\_ggh]h�kgh\b^_gby�^_eZ_rv�wlh�k l\_j^uf�gZf_j_gb_f�g_�ih^^Z\Zlvky�bf�_keb�ZgZebabjm_rv�kgh\b^_gb_�^jm]h]h��lh�klZ\brv�_fm�dZd�g_ij_eh`gh_�mkeh\b_�g_�bkdexqZlvgb h^ghc� fukeb�� ^Z`_� _keb� ijhlb\� g__� \hagbdZ_l� h^gh� ba� q_luj_o� \hajZ`_gbc�� qlh� hgZkebrdhf�g_agZqbl_evgZ��kebrdhf�[_kkfuke_ggZ��g_�hlghkblky�d ^_em�beb�__ g_ijbylgh�kdZaZlv�Hg�h[_sZ_l�ke_^h\Zlv�wlhfm�ijZ\bem��gh�aZl_f�k h]hjq_gb_f�aZf_qZ_rv��dZd�iehoh�ih^qZk�hgk^_j`b\Z_l�wlh�h[_sZgb_��KgZqZeZ�h[tykgy_rv�wlh�l_f��qlh�hg�g_�mykgbe�k_[_�kfuke�k\h[h^ghcZkkhpbZpbb�� g_kfhljy� gZ� m[_^bl_evgh_� aZ\_j_gb_�� b ^mfZ_rv�� qlh�� fh`_l� [ulv�� ke_^m_lih^]hlh\blv� _]h� kgZqZeZ� l_hj_lbq_kdb�� ^Z\Zy� _fm� ebl_jZlmjm� beb� ihkeZ\� _]h� gZ� e_dpbb�[eZ]h^Zjy�q_fm�hg�fh]�[u�klZlv�klhjhggbdhf�gZrbo�\haaj_gbc�gZ�k\h[h^gmx�ZkkhpbZpbx��Ghhl� wlbo�ijb_fh\� \ha^_j`b\Z_rvky�� aZf_qZy�� qlh�b kZf��[m^mqb� l\_j^h� m\_j_g� \ kh[kl\_gguom[_`^_gbyo�� ih^\_j`_g� wlbf� `_� djblbq_kdbf� \hajZ`_gbyf� ijhlb\� hij_^_e_gguo� fuke_c�dhlhju_�\ihke_^kl\bb�mkljZgyxlky��\ ba\_klghc�f_j_��\h�\lhjhc�bgklZgpbb�<f_klh� lh]h�qlh[u� k_j^blvky�gZ�g_ihkemrZgb_� \b^_\r_]h� khg��ihijh[m_f� hp_gblv� wlhlhiul�� qlh[u� gZmqblvky� ba� g_]h� q_fm�lh� gh\hfm�� q_fm�lh�� qlh� fh`_l� [ulv� l_f� \Z`g__�� q_ff_gvr_�fu�d g_fm�ih^]hlh\e_gu��Ihgylgh��qlh�jZ[hlZ�ih�lhedh\Zgbx�kgh\b^_gby�ijhbkoh^bl\hij_db� khijhlb\e_gbx� �:LGHUVWDQG��� dhlhjh_� ih^gbfZ_lky� ijhlb\� g_]h� b \ujZ`_gb_fdhlhjh]h� y\eyxlky� l_� djblbq_kdb_� \hajZ`_gby�� Wlh� khijhlb\e_gb_� g_aZ\bkbfh� hll_hj_lbq_kdbo� m[_`^_gbc� \b^_\r_]h� khg�� ;hevr_� lh]h�� Hiul� ihdZau\Z_l�� qlh� lZdh_djblbq_kdh_�\hajZ`_gb_�gbdh]^Z�g_�[u\Z_l�ijZ\bevguf��GZijhlb\��fukeb��dhlhju_�ohl_ehkv[u�ih^Z\blv�lZdbf�h[jZahf��hdZau\Zxlky�\k_�[_a�bkdexq_gby�kZfufb�\Z`gufb��j_rZxsbfb^ey�jZkdjulby�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��?keb�fukev�khijh\h`^Z_lky� lZdbf�\hajZ`_gb_f�� lh� wlh�dZdjZa�hq_gv�ihdZaZl_evgh�

Page 60: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Wlh�khijhlb\e_gb_�y\ey_lky�dZdbf�lh�kh\_jr_ggh�gh\uf�n_ghf_ghf��dhlhjuc�fu�gZrebbkoh^y� ba� gZrbo� ij_^iheh`_gbc�� ohly� hg� dZd� [m^lh� b g_� kh^_j`blky� \ gbo��Wlhfm� gh\hfmnZdlhjm�fu�g_�lZd�m`�ijbylgh�m^b\e_gu��Fu�m`_�ij_^qm\kl\m_f��qlh�hg�g_�h[e_]qbl�gZr_cjZ[hlu�� Hg� fh]� [u� gZk� ijb\_klb� d lhfm�� qlh[u� \h\k_� hklZ\blv� gZrb� klZjZgby� ihgylvkgh\b^_gb_�� LZdh_� g_agZqbl_evgh_� y\e_gb_�� dZd� kgh\b^_gb_�� b lZdb_� ljm^ghklb� \f_klh[_amdhjbag_gghc� l_ogbdb�� Gh�� k ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� bf_e� gh� wlb� ljm^ghklb� aZklZ\eyxl� gZkij_^iheZ]Zlv��qlh�jZ[hlZ�klhbl�mkbebc��Fu�ihklhyggh�gZlZedb\Z_fky�gZ�khijhlb\e_gb_��dh]^Zohlbf� hl� aZf_klbl_ey�� y\eyxs_]hky� we_f_glhf� kgh\b^_gby�� ijhgbdgmlv� \ _]h� kdjulh_[_kkhagZl_evgh_�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� fu� fh`_f� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� aZ� aZf_klbl_e_f� kdju\Z_lkyqlh�lh�agZqbl_evgh_��BgZq_�d q_fm�\k_�ij_iylkl\by��klj_fysb_ky�khojZgblv�kdju\Z_fh_"�?kebj_[_ghd� g_� ohq_l� hldjulv� jmdm�� qlh[u� ihdZaZlv�� qlh� \ g_c�� agZqbl�� lZf� qlh�lh�� q_]h� _fm� g_jZaj_rZ_lky�bf_lv�K_cqZk�� dh]^Z� fu� \\h^bf� \ oh^� gZrbo� jZkkm`^_gbc� ^bgZfbq_kdh_� ij_^klZ\e_gb_khijhlb\e_gby�� fu� ^he`gu� ih^mfZlv� h lhf�� qlh� wlh� khijhlb\e_gb_� fh`_l� dhebq_kl\_gghbaf_gylvky��Hgh�fh`_l�[ulv�[hevrbf�b f_gvrbf��b fu�]hlh\u�d lhfm��qlh�^Zggu_�jZaebqby�bh[gZjm`Zlky� \h� \j_fy� gZr_c� jZ[hlu��Fh`_l� [ulv�� [eZ]h^Zjy� wlhfm� fu� ijbh[j_l_f� ^jm]hchiul��dhlhjuc�lh`_�ijb]h^blky�\ jZ[hl_�ih�lhedh\Zgbx�kgh\b^_gbc��Bgh]^Z�g_h[oh^bfZ�h^gZ�_^bgkl\_ggZy� beb� \k_]h� g_kdhevdh� fuke_c�� qlh[u� i_j_clb� hl� we_f_glZ� kgh\b^_gby� d _]h[_kkhagZl_evghfm�� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd� \ ^jm]bo� kemqZyo� ^ey� wlh]h� lj_[m_lky� ^ebggZy� p_ivZkkhpbZpbc�b ij_h^he_gb_�fgh]bo�djblbq_kdbo�\hajZ`_gbc�Fu� kdZ`_f� k_[_�� qlh� wlb� jZaebqby� k\yaZgu� k baf_g_gb_f� \_ebqbgu� khijhlb\e_gby�� b[m^_f��\_jhylgh��ijZ\u��?keb�khijhlb\e_gb_�g_agZqbl_evgh��lh�b aZf_klbl_ev�g_�klhev�hlebq_ghl� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� gh� [hevrh_� khijhlb\e_gb_� ijb\h^bl� d [hevrbf� bkdZ`_gbyf[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��Z k�gbfb�m^ebgy_lky�h[jZlguc�imlv�hl�aZf_klbl_ey�d [_kkhagZl_evghfm�L_i_jv�� fh`_l� [ulv�� gZklZeh� \j_fy� \aylv� dZdh_�gb[m^v� kgh\b^_gb_� b ihijh[h\Zlvijbf_gblv�d g_fm�gZrm�l_ogbdm��qlh[u�hijZ\^Zlv�k\yau\Z_fu_�k g_c�gZ^_`^u��>Z��gh�dZdh_^ey�wlh]h�\u[jZlv�kgh\b^_gb_"�<u�g_�ij_^klZ\ey_l_�k_[_��dZd�fg_�ljm^gh�k^_eZlv�\u[hj��b y^Z`_�g_�fh]m�\Zf�_s_�jZatykgblv��\ q_f�ljm^ghklv��Hq_\b^gh��bf_xlky�kgh\b^_gby��dhlhju_�\h[s_f�fZeh�bkdZ`_gu��b kZfh_�emqr__�[ueh�[u�gZqZlv�k gbo���Gh�dZdb_�kgh\b^_gby�f_gvr_\k_]h�bkdZ`_gu"�Ihgylgu_�b g_�kimlZggu_��^\Z�ijbf_jZ�d_lhjuo�y m`_�ijb\h^be"�Gh�lml�lh�\u]em[hdh� hrb[Z_l_kv��Bkke_^h\Zgb_� ihdZau\Z_l�� qlh� wlb� kgh\b^_gby� ij_l_ji_eb� qj_a\uqZcgh\ukhdmx�kl_i_gv�bkdZ`_gby��Gh�_keb�y��hldZaZ\rbkv�hl�dZdbo�eb[h�h]jZgbq_gbc��\havfm�i_j\h_ihiZ\r__ky�kgh\b^_gb_��\u��\_jhylgh��[m^_l_�hq_gv�jZahqZjh\Zgu��Fh`_l�kemqblvky��qlh�gZfgm`gh�[m^_l�\u^_eblv�b aZibkZlv�lZdh_�h[beb_�fuke_c�d hl^_evguf�we_f_glZf�kgh\b^_gby��qlhjZ[hlZ� klZg_l� kh\_jr_ggh�g_h[hajbfhc��?keb�fu� aZibr_f� kgh\b^_gb_�� Z gZijhlb\� khklZ\bfkibkhd�\k_o�ijbr_^rbo�ih�_]h�ih\h^m�fuke_c��lh�hg�fh`_l�[ulv�[hevr_�l_dklZ�kgh\b^_gby�KZfuf� p_e_khh[jZaguf� dZ`_lky�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� \u[jZlv� ^ey� ZgZebaZ� g_kdhevdh� dhjhldbokgh\b^_gbc��ba�dhlhjuo�dZ`^h_�kfh`_l�gZf�qlh�gb[m^v�kdZaZlv�beb�qlh�eb[h�ih^l\_j^blv��GZwlh� fu� b j_rbfky�� _keb� hiul� gZf� g_� ih^kdZ`_l�� ]^_� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� fh`gh� gZclb� fZehbkdZ`_ggu_�kgh\b^_gby�Djhf_� lh]h�� y agZx� _s_� ^jm]hc� imlv� ^ey� h[e_]q_gby� gZr_c� aZ^Zqb��<f_klh� lhedh\Zgby

Page 61: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

p_euo� kgh\b^_gbc� ^Z\Zcl_� h]jZgbqbfky� hl^_evgufb� we_f_glZfb� b gZ� jy^_� ijbf_jh\ijhke_^bf��dZd�bo�fh`gh�h[tykgblv��bkihevamy�gZrm�l_ogbdm�Z��H^gZ�^ZfZ�jZkkdZau\Z_l��qlh�j_[_gdhf�hq_gv�qZklh�\b^_eZ�khg��[m^lh�m [h]Z�gZ�]heh\_hkljhdhg_qguc�[mfZ`guc�dheiZd��DZd�\u�wlh�ihcf_l_��g_�ijb[_]gm\�d ihfhsb�\b^_\r_c�khg"<_^v� wlh� kh\_jr_ggh� [_kkfuke_ggh�� Gh� wlh� i_j_klZ_l� [ulv� [_kkfukebp_c�� dh]^Z� ^ZfZkhh[sZ_l��qlh�_c�j_[_gdhf� aZ�klhehf�bf_eb�h[udgh\_gb_�gZ^_\Zlv�lZdhc�dheiZd��ihlhfm�qlhhgZ�g_�fh]eZ�hl\udgmlv�hl�lh]h��qlh[u�g_�dhkblvky�\ lZj_edb�[jZlv_\�b k_kl_j�b g_�kfhlj_lv��g_ihemqbe�eb�dlh�gb[m^v�ba�gbo�[hevr_�g__��LZdbf�h[jZahf��dheiZd�^he`_g�[ue�^_ckl\h\Zlv��dZdrhju�� DklZlb�� bklhjbq_kdh_� khh[s_gb_� [ueh� ^Zgh� [_a� \kydhc� aZ^_j`db�� Lhedh\Zgb_� wlh]hwe_f_glZ��Z k�gbf�b \k_]h�dhjhldh]h�kgh\b^_gby�e_]dh�hkms_kl\ey_lky�[eZ]h^Zjy�ke_^mxs_cfukeb�\b^_\r_c�khg��©LZd�dZd�y keurZeZ��qlh�[h]�\k_\_^ms�b \k_�\b^bl�²�]h\hjbl�hgZ�²�lhkgh\b^_gb_� hagZqZ_l� lhevdh�� qlh� y \k_� agZx� b \k_� \b`m�� dZd� [h]�� ^Z`_� _keb� fg_� ohlylihf_rZlvª��Wlhl�ijbf_j��\hafh`gh��kebrdhf�ijhkl�[��H^gZ�kd_ilbq_kdb�gZkljh_ggZy�iZpb_gldZ�\b^bl�^ebgguc�khg��\ dhlhjhf�ba\_klgu_�ebpZjZkkdZau\Zxl� _c� h fh_c� dgb]_� ©Hkljhmfb_ª� �����k�� b hq_gv� __� o\Zeyl�� AZl_f� qlh�lhmihfbgZ_lky�h ©DZgZe_ª��\hafh`gh��h ^jm]hc�dgb]_��\ dhlhjhc�nb]mjbjm_l�dZgZe��beb��_s_�qlh�lh��k\yaZggh_�k dZgZehf����hgZ�g_�agZ_l����wlh�kh\_jr_ggh�g_ykgh�<u�kdehggu�[m^_l_�ij_^iheh`blv��qlh�we_f_gl�©dZgZeª�g_�ih^^Z_lky�lhedh\Zgbx��ihlhfmqlh� hg� kZf� lZd� g_hij_^_e_g_g�� <u� ijZ\u� hlghkbl_evgh� ij_^iheZ]Z_fh]h� aZljm^g_gby�� ghlhedh\Zgb_�ljm^gh�g_�ihlhfm��qlh�wlhl�we_f_gl�g_yk_g��gZh[hjhl��hg�g_yk_g�ih�lhc�`_�ijbqbg_�ih� dhlhjhc� aZljm^g_gh� lhedh\Zgb_�� \b^_\r_c� khg� g_� ijboh^bl� ih� ih\h^m� dZgZeZ� gbdZdbofuke_c�� y�� dhg_qgh�� lh`_� gbq_]h� g_� fh]m� kdZaZlv�� G_dhlhjh_� \j_fy� kimkly�� \_jg__�� gZke_^mxsbc�^_gv�hgZ�]h\hjbl��qlh�_c�ijbreh�\ ]heh\m��qlh��fh`_l�[ulv��hlghkblky�d ^_em��:bf_ggh�hkljhlZ��dhlhjmx�hgZ�keurZeZ��GZ�iZjhoh^_�f_`^m�>m\jhf�b DZe_�ba\_klguc�ibkZl_ev[_k_^m_l�k h^gbf�Zg]ebqZgbghf��dhlhjuc�\ hij_^_e_gghc�k\yab�pblbjm_l��'X�VXEOLPH�DX�ULGLFXOHLO�Q\�D�TXXQ�SDV�>Hl�\_ebdh]h�^h�kf_rgh]h�lhevdh�h^bg�>rZ]@��IbkZl_ev�hl\_qZ_l��4XL��OH�SDV�GH&DODLV�>>Z��IZ�^_�DZe_@���rZ]�ih�njZgpmakdb�©iZª�²�Ijbf_q��i_j���²wlbf�hg�ohq_l�kdZaZlv��qlhNjZgpby� \_ebdZy� kljZgZ�� Z :g]eby� ²� kf_rgZy��Gh� 3DV� GH� &DODLV� \_^v� dZgZe�� bf_ggh� jmdZ\dZgZeZ�� &DQDO� OD� PDQFKH�� +H� ^mfZx� eb� y�� qlh� wlZ� fukev� bf__l� hlghr_gb_� d kgh\b^_gbx"Dhg_qgh�� ]h\hjx� y�� hgZ� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� h[tykgy_l� aZ]Z^hqguc� we_f_gl� kgh\b^_gby�� Beb� \ukhfg_\Z_l_kv��qlh�wlZ�rmldZ�m`_�^h�kgh\b^_gby�[ueZ�[_kkhagZl_evguf�^ey�we_f_glZ�©dZgZeª��bij_^iheZ]Z_l_��qlh�hgZ�ihy\beZkv�iha^g__"�Ijbr_^rZy�_c�\ ]heh\m�fukev�k\b^_l_evkl\m_l�hkd_ikbk_��dhlhjuc�kdju\Z_lky�m g__�aZ�bkdmkkl\_gguf�\hkobs_gb_f��Z khijhlb\e_gb_�y\ey_lkyh[s_c�ijbqbghc�dZd� aZ^_j`db�fukeb�� lZd�b lh]h��qlh� khhl\_lkl\mxsbc� we_f_gl� kgh\b^_gby[ue�lZdbf�g_hij_^_e_gguf��<^mfZcl_kv�\ wlhf�kemqZ_�\ hlghr_gb_�we_f_glZ�kgh\b^_gby�d _]h[_kkhagZl_evghfm����Hg�dZd�[u�dmkhq_d�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��dZd�[u�gZf_d�gZ�g_]h��bahebjh\Z\�_]h�fu�[u�_]h�kh\_jr_ggh�g_�ihgyeb�\��H^bg�iZpb_gl�\b^bl�^ebgguc�khg��\hdjm]�klheZ�hkh[hc�nhjfu�kb^bl�g_kdhevdh�qe_gh\_]h�k_fvb�b l��^��Ih�ih\h^m�klheZ�_fm�ijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m�fukev��qlh�hg�\b^_e�lZdhc�klhe�ijbihk_s_gbb� hij_^_e_gghc� k_fvb�� AZl_f� _]h� fukev� jZa\b\Z_lky�� \ wlhc� k_fv_� [ueb� hkh[u_hlghr_gby�f_`^m�hlphf�b kughf��b hg�lml�`_�^h[Z\ey_l��qlh�lZdb_�`_�hlghr_gby�kms_kl\mxl

Page 62: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

f_`^m�gbf�b _]h�hlphf��LZdbf�h[jZahf��klhe�\ayl�\ kgh\b^_gb_��qlh[u�ihdZaZlv�wlm�iZjZee_ev�Wlhl�iZpb_gl�[ue�^Z\gh� agZdhf� k lj_[h\Zgbyfb� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby��>jm]hc��fh`_l[ulv��[ue�[u�ihjZ`_g��qlh�lZdZy�g_agZqbl_evgZy�^_lZev��dZd�nhjfZ�klheZ��y\ey_lky�h[t_dlhfbkke_^h\Zgby��Fu�kqblZ_f��qlh�\ kgh\b^_gbb�g_l�gbq_]h�kemqZcgh]h�beb�[_ajZaebqgh]h�b `^_fjZa]Z^db�bf_ggh�hl�h[tykg_gby�lZdbo�g_agZqbl_evguo��g_fhlb\bjh\Zgguo�^_lZe_c��<u��fh`_l[ulv��_s_�m^b\bl_kv��qlh�jZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby�\ujZabeZ�fukev�©m gZk�\k_�ijhbkoh^bl�lZd��dZd�mgboª�bf_ggh�\u[hjhf�klheZ��Gh�\k_�e_]dh�h[tykgblky�� _keb�\u�magZ_l_��qlh� wlZ� k_fvy�ghkblnZfbebx�Lbre_j�>7LVFK�²�klhi�²�Ijbf_q��i_j�@��MkZ`b\Zy�k\hbo�jh^guo�aZ�wlhl�klhe��hg�dZd[u�]h\hjbl��qlh�hgb�lh`_�Lbre_ju��AZf_lvl_��\ijhq_f��dZd�\ khh[s_gbyo�h lZdbo�lhedh\Zgbyokgh\b^_gbc� ihg_\he_� klZgh\brvky� g_kdjhfguf�� L_i_jv� b \u� m\b^_eb� mihfygmlu_� \ur_ljm^ghklb� \ \u[hj_� ijbf_jh\�� Wlhl� ijbf_j� y fh]� [u� e_]dh� aZf_gblv� ^jm]bf�� gh� lh]^Z�\_jhylgh��ba[_`Ze�[u�wlhc�g_kdjhfghklb�aZ�kq_l�dZdhc�lh�^jm]hc�Fg_� dZ`_lky�� qlh� l_i_jv� kZfh_� \j_fy� \\_klb� ^\Z� l_jfbgZ�� dhlhjufb�fu�fh]eb� [u� m`_^Z\gh� ihevah\Zlvky�� Fu� ohlbf� gZa\Zlv� lh�� qlh� jZkkdZau\Z_lky� \ kgh\b^_gbb�� y\gufkh^_j`Zgb_f�kgh\b^_gby��PDQLIHVWHU�7UDXPLQKDOW���Z kdjulh_��d dhlhjhfm�fu�ijboh^bf��ke_^myaZ�\hagbdZxsbfb�fukeyfb��kdjulufb�fukeyfb�kgh\b^_gby��ODWHQWH�7UDXPJHGDQNHQ���H[jZlbf\gbfZgb_� gZ� hlghr_gby�f_`^m� y\guf� kh^_j`Zgb_f� kgh\b^_gby� b kdjulufb� _]h�fukeyfb� \gZrbo�ijbf_jZo��Wlb� hlghr_gby�fh]ml�[ulv� \_kvfZ�jZaebqgufb��< ijbf_jZo� Z��b [�� y\gucwe_f_gl�y\ey_lky�khklZ\ghc�qZklvx�kdjuluo�fuke_c��gh�lhevdh�g_agZqbl_evghc�bo�qZklvx��Ba\k_c�[hevrhc�b keh`ghc�ikbobq_kdhc�kljmdlmju�[_kkhagZl_evguo�fuke_c�\ y\gh_�kgh\b^_gb_ijhgbdZ_l�ebrv�qZklbpZ�dZd�bo�njZ]f_gl�beb�\ ^jm]bo�kemqZyo�dZd�gZf_d�gZ�gbo��dZd�ehamg]beb� khdjZs_gb_�\ l_e_]jZnghf� klbe_��Lhedh\Zgb_�^he`gh�\hkklZgh\blv�p_eh_�ih� wlhc�qZklbbeb� gZf_dm�� dZd� wlh� ij_djZkgh� m^Zehkv� \ ijbf_j_� [���H^bg� ba� \b^h\� bkdZ`_gby�� \ dhlhjhfaZdexqZ_lky� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby�� _klv�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� aZf_s_gb_� h[ju\dhf� beb� gZf_dhf�� <ijbf_j_� \��� djhf_� lh]h�� fh`gh� ij_^iheh`blv� ^jm]h_� hlghr_gb_�� [he__� ykgh� \ujZ`_ggh_� \ke_^mxsbo�ijbf_jZo�]�� <b^_\rbc� khg� ba\e_dZ_l� �KHUYRU]LHKW�� �hij_^_e_ggmx�� agZdhfmx� _fm�� ^Zfm� ba�ih^djh\Zlb��Hg�kZf�hldju\Z_l�kfuke�wlh]h�we_f_glZ�kgh\b^_gby�i_j\hc�ijbr_^r_c�_fm�\ ]heh\mfukevx��Wlh�hagZqZ_l��hg�hl^Z_l�wlhc�^Zf_�ij_^ihql_gb_��9RU]XJ��^�� >jm]hfm� kgblky�� qlh� _]h� [jZl� aZkljye� \ ysbd_�� I_j\Zy� fukev� aZf_gy_l� keh\h� ysbdrdZnhf��6FKUDQN���Z \lhjZy�^Z_l�wlhfm�lhedh\Zgb_�[jZl�h]jZgbqb\Z_l�k_[y��VFKUDQNW�VLFK�HLQ��_��<b^_\rbc�khg�ih^gbfZ_lky�gZ� ]hjm��hldm^Z�hldju\Z_lky�g_h[udgh\_ggh�^Ze_dbc�\b^�Wlh� a\mqbl� kh\_jr_ggh�jZpbhgZevgh��b��fh`_l�[ulv�� lml�g_q_]h� lhedh\Zlv�� Z ke_^m_l� lhevdhmagZlv�� dZdb_� \hkihfbgZgby� aZljhgmlu� kgh\b^_gb_f� b q_f� hgh� fhlb\bjh\Zgh�� Gh� \uhrb[Z_l_kv�²� hdZau\Z_lky�� bf_ggh� wlh� kgh\b^_gb_� gm`^Z_lky� \ lhedh\Zgbb�� dZd� gbdZdh_^jm]h_�kimlZggh_�<b^_\r_fm� khg� \h\k_� g_� ijboh^yl� \ ]heh\m� kh[kl\_ggu_� \hkoh`^_gby� gZ� ]hju�� Z hg\kihfbgZ_l��qlh�h^bg�_]h�agZdhfuc�ba^Z_l�©H[haj_gb_ª� �5XQGVFKDX���\ dhlhjhf�h[km`^ZxlkygZrb� hlghr_gby� d ^Zevgbf� kljZgZf�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� kdjulZy� fukev� kgh\b^_gby� a^_kv� ²

Page 63: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hlh`^_kl\e_gb_�\b^_\r_]h�khg�k ba^Zl_e_f�©H[haj_gbyª�A^_kv�\u�\b^bl_�gh\uc�lbi�hlghr_gby�f_`^m�y\guf�b kdjuluf�we_f_glZfb�kgh\b^_gby�I_j\uc� y\ey_lky�g_� klhevdh�bkdZ`_gb_f�ihke_^g_]h�� kdhevdh� _]h�bah[jZ`_gb_f��gZ]ey^guf�dhgdj_lguf� \ujZ`_gb_f� \ h[jZa_�� dhlhjh_� bf__l� k\hbf� bklhqgbdhf� kha\mqb_� keh\��H^gZdh[eZ]h^Zjy� wlhfm� ihemqZ_lky� hiylv� bkdZ`_gb_�� ihlhfm� qlh� fu� ^Z\gh� aZ[ueb�� ba� dZdh]hdhgdj_lgh]h�h[jZaZ�\uoh^bl�keh\h��b g_�magZ_f�_]h�\ aZf_s_gbb�h[jZahf��?keb�\u�ih^mfZ_l_�hlhf��qlh�y\gh_�kgh\b^_gb_�khklhbl�ij_bfms_kl\_ggh�ba�ajbl_evguo�h[jZah\��j_`_�ba�fuke_c�bkeh\�� lh� fh`_l_� ^h]Z^Zlvky�� qlh� wlhfm� \b^m� hlghr_gby� ijbgZ^e_`bl� hkh[h_� agZq_gb_� \h[jZah\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gby��<u�\b^bl_�lZd`_��qlh�wlbf�iml_f�fh`gh�kha^Zlv�\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb^ey�p_eh]h�jy^Z�Z[kljZdlguo�fuke_c�aZf_sZxsb_�h[jZau��dhlhju_�kem`Zl�gZf_j_gbx�kdjulvbo��Wlh�lZ�`_�l_ogbdZ�j_[mkZ��Hldm^Z�lZdb_�bah[jZ`_gby�ijbh[j_lZxl�hkljhmfguc�oZjZdl_j�wlh�hkh[uc�\hijhk��dhlhjh]h�fu�a^_kv�fh`_f�g_�dZkZlvky�H q_l\_jlhf�\b^_�hlghr_gby�f_`^m�y\guf�b kdjuluf�we_f_glZfb�kgh\b^_gby�y mfheqm�ihdZ� gZrZ� l_ogbdZ� g_� hldjh_l� gZf� _]h� hkh[_gghklv�� Gh� b lh]^Z� y g_� ^Ze� [u� ihegh]hi_j_qbke_gby�wlbo�hlghr_gbc��^ey�gZrbo�`_�p_e_c�^hklZlhqgh�b wlh]h�?klv�m \Zk�l_i_jv�fm`_kl\h�j_rblvky�gZ�lhedh\Zgb_�p_eh]h�kgh\b^_gby"�K^_eZ_f�ihiuldmb ihkfhljbf��^hklZlhqgh�eb�fu�ih^]hlh\e_gu�^ey�j_r_gby�wlhc�aZ^Zqb��JZamf__lky��y \u[_jmg_� kZfh_� g_ihgylgh_� kgh\b^_gb_�� Z hklZgh\exkv� gZ� lZdhf�� dhlhjh_� ohjhrh� hljZ`Z_l� _]hk\hckl\Z�BlZd��fheh^Zy��gh�m`_�^Z\gh�\ur_^rZy�aZfm`�^ZfZ�\b^bl�khg��hgZ�kb^bl�k fm`_f�\ l_Zlj_�h^gZ�iheh\bgZ�iZjl_jZ�kh\_jr_ggh�imklZ��?_�fm`�jZkkdZau\Z_l�_c��qlh�WebaZ�E��b __�`_gbolh`_�ohl_eb�ihclb��gh�kfh]eb�^hklZlv�lhevdh�iehob_�f_klZ��ljb�aZ���ne�����dj� ��Z \_^v�lZdb_f_klZ�hgb�g_�fh]eb�\aylv��HgZ�kqblZ_l��qlh�wlh�g_�[_^Z�I_j\h_��qlh�khh[sZ_l�gZf�\b^_\rZy�khg�²�wlh�lh��qlh�ih\h^�d kgh\b^_gbx�mdZaZg�\ y\ghfkgh\b^_gbb��Fm`�^_ckl\bl_evgh�jZkkdZaZe� _c��qlh�WebaZ�E��� agZdhfZy��ijbf_jgh� l_o�`_�e_l�h[jmqbeZkv��Kgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lky�j_Zdpb_c�gZ� wlh� khh[s_gb_��Fu� m`_� agZ_f�� qlh�ih^h[gucih\h^�\ i_j_`b\Zgbyo�^gy�gZdZgmg_�kgh\b^_gby�g_ljm^gh�^hdZaZlv�\h�fgh]bo�kgh\b^_gbyo��b\b^_\rb_� khg�qZklh� [_a� aZljm^g_gbc� ^Zxl� lZdb_� mdZaZgby��LZdb_�`_� k\_^_gby� \b^_\rZy� khg^Z_l�b ih�ih\h^m�^jm]bo� we_f_glh\�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby��Hldm^Z�\ayeZkv�^_lZev��qlh�iheh\bgZiZjl_jZ� g_� aZgylZ"� Wlh� gZf_d� gZ� j_Zevgh_� kh[ulb_� ijhrehc� g_^_eb��HgZ� j_rbeZ� ihclb� gZba\_klgh_� l_ZljZevgh_� ij_^klZ\e_gb_� b aZ[eZ]h\j_f_ggh� dmibeZ� [be_lu�� gh� lZd� jZgh�� qlh^he`gZ�[ueZ�^hieZlblv�aZ�wlh��dh]^Z�`_�hgb��nehjbg����dj_cp_jh\�²�Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�ijbreb� \ l_Zlj�� hdZaZehkv�� qlh� __ aZ[hlu� [ueb� gZijZkgu�� ihlhfm� qlh� h^gZ� iheh\bgZiZjl_jZ� [ueZ� ihqlb� imklZ�� HgZ� [u� g_� hiha^ZeZ�� _keb� [u� dmibeZ� [be_lu� ^Z`_� \ ^_gvij_^klZ\e_gby��?_�fm`�g_�ij_fbgme�ih^jZagblv�__ aZ�wlm�ihki_rghklv��Hldm^Z� ��ne�� ���dj�"Wlh�hlghkblky�d kh\k_f�^jm]hfm�b g_�bf__l�gbq_]h�h[s_]h�k ij_^u^msbf��gh�b lml�_klv�gZf_dgZ�ba\_klb_�ihke_^g_]h�^gy��?_�g_\_kldZ�ihemqbeZ�hl�k\h_]h�fm`Z�\ ih^Zjhd�����ne���b wlZ�^mjZg_�gZreZ�gbq_]h�emqr_]h��dZd�ih[_`Zlv�d x\_ebjm�b bkljZlblv�^_gv]b�gZ�mdjZr_gby��: hldm^Zljb"�H[�wlhf�hgZ�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_l��_keb�lhevdh�g_�kqblZlv�lhc�fukeb��qlh�g_\_klZ�WebaZ�E��\k_]h

Page 64: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ebrv�gZ�ljb�f_kypZ�fheh`_�g__��Z hgZ�ihqlb�^_kylv�e_l�aZfm`_f��: qlh�wlh�aZ�g_e_ihklv�[jZlvljb�[be_lZ��dh]^Z�b^_rv�\ l_Zlj�\^\h_f"�GZ�wlh�hgZ�gbq_]h�g_�hl\_qZ_l�b \hh[s_�hldZau\Z_lkyhl�^Zevg_crbo�h[tykg_gbc�Gh�wlb�ijbr_^rb_�_c�\ ]heh\m�fukeb�b lZd�^Zeb�gZf�^hklZlhqgh�fZl_jbZeZ��qlh[u�fh`gh[ueh�magZlv�kdjulu_�fukeb�kgh\b^_gby��H[jZsZ_l�gZ�k_[y�\gbfZgb_�lh��qlh�\ __�khh[s_gbyo�dkgh\b^_gbx� \ g_kdhevdbo� f_klZo� ih^q_jdb\Zxlky� jZagu_� kjhdb�� [eZ]h^Zjy� q_fm� f_`^mhl^_evgufb�qZklyfb�mklZgZ\eb\Z_lky�g_qlh�h[s__��hgZ�kebrdhf�jZgh�dmibeZ�[be_lu�\ l_Zlj�ihki_rbeZ�� lZd� qlh� ^he`gZ� [ueZ� i_j_ieZlblv�� g_\_kldZ� ih^h[guf� `_� h[jZahf� ihki_rbeZkg_klb�^_gv]b�x\_ebjm��qlh[u�dmiblv�mdjZr_gby��dZd�[m^lh�hgZ�fh]eZ�wlh�mimklblv��?keb�wlblZd�ih^q_jdgmlu_�©kebrdhf�jZghª��©ihki_rghª�khihklZ\blv�k ih\h^hf�kgh\b^_gby��ba\_klb_f�qlh� ijbyl_evgbpZ�� dhlhjZy� fheh`_� g__� \k_]h� gZ� ljb� f_kypZ�� l_i_jv� \k_�lZdb� gZreZ� k_[_ohjhr_]h�fm`Z��b k�djblbdhc��\ujZab\r_cky�\ hkm`^_gbb�g_\_kldb��g_e_ih�lZd�lhjhiblvky��lhkZfh� kh[hc� gZijZrb\Z_lky� ke_^mxsbc� oh^� kdjuluo� fuke_c� kgh\b^_gby�� bkdZ`_ggufaZf_klbl_e_f� dhlhjuo� y\ey_lky� y\gh_� kgh\b^_gb_�� ©G_e_ih� [ueh� k fh_c� klhjhgu� lZdlhjhiblvky� k aZfm`_kl\hf��GZ� ijbf_j_�Webau� y \b`m�� qlh� b iha`_�fh]eZ� [u� gZclb�fm`Zª��Ihki_rghklv�bah[jZ`_gZ� \ __�ih\_^_gbb�ijb�ihdmid_�[be_lh\�b \�ih\_^_gbb� g_\_kldb�ijbihdmid_�mdjZr_gbc��AZfm`_kl\h�aZf_s_gh�ihk_s_gb_f�l_ZljZ���Wlh�²�]eZ\gZy�fukev��fh`_l[ulv��fu�fh]eb�[u�ijh^he`Zlv��gh�k f_gvr_c�m\_j_gghklvx��ihlhfm�qlh�\ wlhf�f_kl_�ZgZebamg_aZq_f�[ueh�[u�hldZau\Zlvky�hl�aZy\e_gbc�\b^_\r_c�khg�©AZ�wlb�^_gv]b�y fh]eZ�[u�ijbh[j_klb�\ ����jZa�emqr__�ª������ne��\ ����jZa�[hevr_���ne����dj����?keb�[u�fu�fh]eb�^_gv]b�aZf_gblv�ijb^Zguf��lh�wlh�hagZqZeh�[u��qlh�fm`Z�ihdmiZxlaZ�ijb^Zgh_��fm`� aZf_g_g� mdjZr_gbyfb�b iehobfb�[be_lZfb��?s_� emqr_�[ueh�[u�� _keb�[uwe_f_gl� ©ljb� [be_lZª� bf_e� dZdh_�eb[h� hlghr_gb_� d fm`m��Gh� gZr_� ihgbfZgb_� g_� b^_l� lZd^Ze_dh��Fu� lhevdh�m]Z^Zeb��qlh�kgh\b^_gb_�\ujZ`Z_l�ij_g_[j_`_gb_�d fm`m�b kh`Ze_gb_�hkebrdhf�jZgg_f�aZfm`_kl\_�Ih�fh_fm�fg_gbx��j_amevlZl�wlh]h�i_j\h]h�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gby�gZk�[hevr_�ihjZ`Z_l�bkfmsZ_l��q_f�m^h\e_l\hjy_l��Kebrdhf�m`�fgh]h�gZ�gZk�kjZam�k\Zebehkv��[hevr_��k q_f�fu�\khklhygbb� kijZ\blvky��Fu�m`_� aZf_qZ_f��qlh�g_� kfh`_f�jZah[jZlvky�\ lhf��qlh�fh`_l�[ulvihmqbl_evgh]h� \ wlhf� lhedh\Zgbb� kgh\b^_gby�� Ihki_rbf� `_� ba\e_qv� lh�� qlh� fu� magZebg_khfg_ggh�gh\h]h�<h�i_j\uo�� aZf_qZl_evgh�� qlh� \ kdjuluo� fukeyo� ]eZ\guc� Zdp_gl� iZ^Z_l� gZ� we_f_glihki_rghklb�� \ y\ghf� kgh\b^_gbb�bf_ggh� h[� wlhf�gbq_]h�g_l��;_a� ZgZebaZ�fu�[u�g_�fh]ebij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� wlhl� fhf_gl� b]jZ_l� dZdmx�lh� jhev�� AgZqbl� \hafh`gh�� qlh� dZd� jZa� kZfh_]eZ\gh_��lh��qlh�y\ey_lky�p_gljhf�[_kkhagZl_evguo�fuke_c��\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb�hlkmlkl\m_l�;eZ]h^Zjy� wlhfm� kh\_jr_ggh� f_gy_lky� \i_qZle_gb_� hl� \k_]h� kgh\b^_gby�� <h�\lhjuo�� \kgh\b^_gbb� bf__lky� Z[kmj^gh_� khihklZ\e_gb_� ljb� aZ� ��ne�� ��� dj��� \ fukeyo� kgh\b^_gby�fum]Z^u\Z_f�njZam��g_e_ih�[ueh��lZd�jZgh�\uoh^blv�aZfm`���Fh`gh�eb�hljbpZlv��qlh�wlZ�fukev©g_e_ih� [uehª� \ujZ`_gZ� \ y\ghf� kgh\b^_gbb� bf_ggh� Z[kmj^guf� we_f_glhf"� <�lj_lvbo�kjZ\g_gb_�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�hlghr_gb_�f_`^m�y\gufb�b kdjulufb�we_f_glZfb�g_�ijhklh��hghkhklhbl�g_�\ lhf��qlh�h^bg�y\guc�we_f_gl�\k_]^Z�aZf_sZ_l�h^bg�kdjuluc��Wlh�kdhj__�]jmiih\h_hlghr_gb_� f_`^m� h[hbfb� eZ]_jyfb�� \gmljb� dhlhjh]h� h^bg� y\guc� we_f_gl� ij_^klZ\ey_lky

Page 65: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_kdhevdbfb�kdjulufb�beb�h^bg�kdjuluc�fh`_l�aZf_sZlvky�g_kdhevdbfb�y\gufb�Qlh� dZkZ_lky� kfukeZ� kgh\b^_gby�b hlghr_gby� d g_fm� \b^_\r_c� khg�� lh� h[� wlhf�fh`gh[ueh�[u�lh`_�kdZaZlv�fgh]h�m^b\bl_evgh]h��IjZ\^Z��hgZ�ijbagZ_l�lhedh\Zgb_��gh�ihjZ`Z_lky_fm��HgZ�g_�agZeZ��qlh�ij_g_[j_`bl_evgh�hlghkblky�d k\h_fm�fm`m��hgZ�lZd`_�g_�agZ_l��ihq_fmhgZ�d g_fm�lZd�hlghkblky��BlZd��\ wlhf�_s_�fgh]h�g_ihgylgh]h��Y ^_ckl\bl_evgh�^mfZx��qlh�fu_s_�g_�]hlh\u�d lhedh\Zgbx�kgh\b^_gbc�b gZf�gZ^h�kgZqZeZ�_s_�ihmqblvky�b ih^]hlh\blvky�<HKVF:Y�E?DPBY>_lkdb_�kgh\b^_gbyM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��M gZk�\hagbdeh�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�fu�kebrdhf�mreb�\i_j_^�<_jg_fky� g_fgh]h� gZaZ^�� Ij_`^_� q_f� fu� ij_^ijbgyeb� ihke_^gxx� ihiuldm� ij_h^he_lv� kihfhsvx�gZr_c�l_ogbdb�ljm^ghklb�bkdZ`_gby�kgh\b^_gby��fu�ihgyeb��qlh�emqr_�[ueh�[u�__h[hclb��\ay\�lZdb_�kgh\b^_gby��_keb�hgb�bf_xlky��\ dhlhjuo�bkdZ`_gb_�hlkmlkl\m_l�beb�hghhq_gv�g_agZqbl_evgh��Ijb�wlhf�fu�hiylv�hlhc^_f�hl�bklhjbb�jZa\blby�gZrbo�agZgbc��ihlhfmqlh�\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�gZ�kms_kl\h\Zgb_�lZdbo�k\h[h^guo�hl�bkdZ`_gby�kgh\b^_gbc�h[jZlbeb\gbfZgb_� lhevdh� ihke_� ihke_^h\Zl_evgh]h� ijbf_g_gby� l_ogbdb� lhedh\Zgby� b ijh\_^_gbyZgZebaZ�bkdZ`_gguo�kgh\b^_gbc�Kgh\b^_gby��dhlhju_�gZf�gm`gu��\klj_qZxlky�m ^_l_c��Hgb�djZldb��ykgu��g_�[_kk\yagu��g_^\mkfuke_ggu��bo�e_]dh�ihgylv��b \k_�lZdb�wlh�kgh\b^_gby��Gh�g_�^mfZcl_��qlh�\k_�kgh\b^_gby^_l_c�lZdh]h�jh^Z��B \�^_lkdhf�\hajZkl_�hq_gv�jZgh�gZklmiZ_l�bkdZ`_gb_�kgh\b^_gbc��aZibkZgukgh\b^_gby�iylb�²�\hkvfbe_lgbo�^_l_c��dhlhju_�bf_xl�\k_�ijbagZdb�[he__�iha^gbo��Gh�_keb\u� h]jZgbqbl_kv� \hajZklhf� k gZqZeZ� ba\_klghc� ^mr_\ghc� ^_yl_evghklb� ^h� q_l\_jlh]h� bebiylh]h� ]h^Z�� lh� \klj_lbl_kv� k jy^hf� kgh\b^_gbc�� dhlhju_� bf_xl� lZd� gZau\Z_fucbgnZglbevguc� oZjZdl_j�� Z aZl_f� hl^_evgu_� kgh\b^_gby� lZdh]h� jh^Z�fh`gh� gZclb� b \� [he__iha^gb_� ^_lkdb_� ]h^u�� >Z`_� m \ajhkeuo� ijb� hij_^_e_gguo� mkeh\byo� [u\Zxl� kgh\b^_gby�ihoh`b_�gZ�lbibqgh�bgnZglbevgu_�Bkihevamy� wlb� ^_lkdb_� kgh\b^_gby�� fu� k e_]dhklvx� b m\_j_gghklvx� k^_eZ_f� \u\h^u� hkmsghklb� kgh\b^_gby�� dhlhju_�� ohlbf�gZ^_ylvky��[m^ml� kms_kl\_ggufb�b h[sbfb� >^ey� \k_okgh\b^_gbc@�������>ey�ihgbfZgby�wlbo�kgh\b^_gbc�g_�lj_[m_lky�ZgZeba�b bkihevah\Zgb_�gZr_c�l_ogbdb�G_� gZ^h� b jZkkijZrb\Zlv� j_[_gdZ�� jZkkdZau\Zxs_]h� k\h_� kgh\b^_gb_�� >hklZlhqgh� g_fgh]h^hihegblv� kgh\b^_gb_� k\_^_gbyfb� ba� `bagb� j_[_gdZ�� <k_]^Z� bf__lky� dZdh_�gb[m^vi_j_`b\Zgb_�ij_^u^ms_]h�^gy��h[tykgyxs__�gZf�kgh\b^_gb_��Kgh\b^_gb_�y\ey_lky�j_Zdpb_c^mr_\ghc�`bagb�\h�kg_�gZ�wlh�\i_qZle_gb_�^gy�Fu�ohlbf�ij_^eh`blv�\Zf�g_kdhevdh�ijbf_jh\��qlh[u�k^_eZlv�_s_�g_dhlhju_�\u\h^u�Z�����f_kyqguc�fZevqbd�dZd�iha^jZ\bl_ev�^he`_g�ij_ih^g_klb�dhjabgm�\br_g��Hg�^_eZ_lwlh� k y\ghc� g_hohlhc�� ohly� _fm� h[_sZxl�� qlh� hg� kZf� ihemqbl� g_kdhevdh� \br_g�� Mljhf� hgjZkkdZau\Z_l�k\hc�khb�

Page 66: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

=_jfZg�kt_e�\k_�\brgb�[��>_\hqdZ� �� ����e_l�\i_j\u_�dZlZ_lky�gZ�eh^d_�ih�ha_jm��Dh]^Z�gZ^h�[ueh� \uoh^blv�baeh^db��hgZ�g_�ohl_eZ�wlh]h�k^_eZlv�b ]hjvdh�jZkieZdZeZkv��?c�ihdZaZehkv��qlh�\j_fy�ijh]medbijhreh�kebrdhf�[ukljh��GZ�ke_^mxs__�mljh�hgZ�kdZaZeZ��K_]h^gy�ghqvx�y dZlZeZkv�ih�ha_jm�Fu�fh]eb�[u�ijb[Z\blv��qlh�wlZ�ijh]medZ�^ebeZkv�^hevr_�\�� �� ����e_lg_]h�fZevqbdZ� \ayeb� k kh[hc�gZ�ijh]medm� \ Wr_jglZev�[eba�=ZeerlZllZ��HgkeurZe��qlh�=ZeerlZll�jZkiheh`_g�m ih^gh`by�>Zorl_cgZ��D wlhc�]hj_�hg�ijhy\eye�[hevrhcbgl_j_k��Ba�k\h_]h�^hfZ�\ :mka__�hg�fh]�ohjhrh�\b^_lv�>Zorl_cg��Z \�ih^ahjgmx�ljm[m�fh`gh[ueh�jZa]ey^_lv�gZ�g_f�Kbfhgb]xll_��J_[_ghd�g_�jZa�iulZeky�m\b^_lv�__ \�ih^ahjgmx�ljm[m�g_ba\_klgh�� k dZdbf� mki_ohf�� Ijh]medZ� gZqZeZkv� \ gZkljh_gbb� jZ^hklgh]h� h`b^Zgby�� DZdlhevdh�ihy\eyeZkv�dZdZy�gb[m^v�gh\Zy�]hjZ��fZevqbd�kijZrb\Ze��wlh�>Zorl_cg"�Q_f�qZs_�hgihemqZe�hljbpZl_evguc�hl\_l��l_f�[hevr_�jZkkljZb\Zeky��ihlhf�kh\k_f�aZfheqZe�b g_�aZohl_e^Z`_�g_fgh]h�ijhclb� d \h^hiZ^m��>mfZeb��qlh� hg� mklZe��gh�gZ� ke_^mxs__�mljh� hg�jZ^hklghjZkkdZaZe�� k_]h^gy� ghqvx� y \b^_e� \h� kg_�� qlh� fu� [ueb� gZ� Kbfhgb]xll_�� Hg� mqZkl\h\Ze� \ijh]med_�� h`b^Zy� wlh]h�fhf_glZ��H ih^jh[ghklyo� hg� lhevdh� kdZaZe��qlh� m`_� keurZe� jZgvl_�ih^gbfZxlky�r_klv�qZkh\�\\_jo�ih�klmi_gvdZf�Wlbo�lj_o�kgh\b^_gbc�^hklZlhqgh��qlh[u�ihemqblv�gm`gu_�gZf�k\_^_gby����Fu�\b^bf��qlh�wlb�^_lkdb_�kgh\b^_gby�g_�[_kkfuke_ggu��wlh�ihgylgu_��iheghp_ggu_^mr_\gu_� Zdlu�� <kihfgbl_�� qlh� y ]h\hjbe� \Zf� ih� ih\h^m� f_^bpbgkdh]h� km`^_gby� hkgh\b^_gbb�� wlh� lh�� qlh� ihemqZ_lky�� dh]^Z� g_� agZxsbc� fmaudb� [_kihjy^hqgh� i_j_[bjZ_ldeZ\brb�ibZgbgh��<u�g_�fh`_l_�g_�aZf_lblv��dZd�j_adh�wlb�^_lkdb_�kgh\b^_gby�ijhlb\hj_qZllZdhfm�ihgbfZgbx��Gh�g_� kebrdhf� eb� kljZggh��qlh�j_[_ghd� \ khklhygbb� \h� kg_�i_j_`b\Zlviheghp_ggu_� ^mr_\gu_� Zdlu�� lh]^Z� dZd� \ajhkeuc� ^h\hevkl\m_lky� \ lhf� `_� kemqZ_km^hjh`gufb�j_Zdpbyfb��M gZk�_klv�lZd`_�\k_�hkgh\Zgby�ij_^iheZ]Zlv��qlh�khg�j_[_gdZ�emqr_b ]em[`_����Wlb�kgh\b^_gby�ebr_gu�bkdZ`_gby��ihwlhfm�hgb�g_�gm`^Zxlky�\ lhedh\Zgbb��Y\gh_�bkdjulh_�kgh\b^_gb_�kh\iZ^Zxl��BlZd��bkdZ`_gb_�kgh\b^_gby�g_�_klv�ijhy\e_gb_�_]h�kmsghklb�Kf_x� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� m \Zk� ijb� wlhf� dZf_gv� k\Zebeky� k ^mrb�� Gh� qZklbpm� bkdZ`_gbykgh\b^_gby�� hij_^_e_ggh_� jZaebqb_�f_`^m� y\guf� kh^_j`Zgb_f� kgh\b^_gby� b _]h� kdjulufbfukeyfb�fu�ihke_�g_dhlhjh]h�jZafure_gby�ijbagZ_f�b aZ�wlbfb�kgh\b^_gbyfb���� >_lkdh_� kgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lky� j_Zdpb_c� gZ� i_j_`b\Zgb_� ^gy�� dhlhjh_� hklZ\behkh`Ze_gb_��lhkdm��g_bkiheg_ggh_�`_eZgb_��Kgh\b^_gb_�^Z_l�ijyfh_��g_ijbdjulh_�bkiheg_gb_wlh]h�`_eZgby��<kihfgbl_�l_i_jv�gZrb�jZkkm`^_gby�h jheb�nbabq_kdbo�jZa^jZ`_gbb��\g_rgbob \gmlj_ggbo�� dZd� gZjmrbl_e_c� kgZ� b ih[m^bl_e_c� kgh\b^_gbc�� Fu� magZeb� kh\_jr_ggh^hklh\_jgu_� nZdlu� ih� wlhfm� ih\h^m�� gh� lZdbf� h[jZahf� fh]eb� h[tykgblv� ebrv� g_[hevrh_qbkeh� kgh\b^_gbc��< wlbo� ^_lkdbo� kgh\b^_gbyo� gbqlh� g_� k\b^_l_evkl\m_l� h ^_ckl\bb� lZdbokhfZlbq_kdbo�jZa^jZ`_gbb��\ wlhf�fu�g_�fh`_f�hrb[blvky��lZd�dZd�kgh\b^_gby�kh\_jr_gghihgylgu� b \� gbo� ljm^gh� q_]h�gb[m^v� g_� aZf_lblv�� H^gZdh� wlh� g_� aZklZ\ey_l� gZk� hljbpZlvijhbkoh`^_gb_�kgh\b^_gbc�hl�jZa^jZ`_gbb��Fu�lhevdh�fh`_f�kijhkblv��ihq_fm�fu�k kZfh]hgZqZeZ�aZ[ueb��qlh��djhf_�nbabq_kdbo��_klv�_s_�b ^mr_\gu_�jZa^jZ`_gby��gZjmrZxsb_�khg"

Page 67: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Fu�\_^v�agZ_f��qlh�wlb�\heg_gby�[hevr_�\k_]h�\uau\Zxl�gZjmr_gb_�kgZ�m \ajhkeh]h�q_eh\_dZ�f_rZy� mklZgh\blv� ^mr_\gh_� khklhygb_� aZkuiZgby�� iZ^_gby� bgl_j_kZ� d fbjm�� Q_eh\_dm� g_ohq_lky�ij_ju\Zlv�`bagv��hg�ijh^he`Z_l�jZ[hlm�gZ^�aZgbfZxsbfb�_]h�\_sZfb�b ihwlhfm�g_kibl��>ey�j_[_gdZ�lZdbf�f_rZxsbf�kiZlv�jZa^jZ`_gb_f�y\ey_lky�g_bkiheg_ggh_�`_eZgb_��gZdhlhjh_�hg�j_Z]bjm_l�kgh\b^_gb_f���� Hlkx^Z� fu� djZlqZcrbf� iml_f� ijboh^bf� d h[tykg_gbx� nmgdpbb� kgh\b^_gby�Kgh\b^_gb_�� [m^mqb� j_Zdpb_c� gZ� ikbobq_kdh_� jZa^jZ`_gb_�� ^he`gh� [ulv� jZ\ghagZqghhk\h[h`^_gbx�hl�wlh]h�jZa^jZ`_gby��lZd�qlh�hgh�mkljZgy_lky��Z khg�fh`_l�ijh^he`Zlvky��DZd^bgZfbq_kdb�hkms_kl\ey_lky�wlh�hk\h[h`^_gb_�[eZ]h^Zjy�kgh\b^_gbx��fu�_s_�g_� �agZ_f��ghm`_� aZf_qZ_f�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lky� g_� gZjmrbl_e_f� kgZ�� dZd� wlh� _fm� ijbibku\Z_lky�� Zh[_j_]Z_l�_]h��mkljZgy_l�gZjmr_gby�kgZ��IjZ\^Z��gZf�dZ`_lky��qlh�fu�emqr_�kiZeb�[u��_keb�[ug_�[ueh�kgh\b^_gby��gh�fu�g_�ijZ\u��\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�[_a�ihfhsb�kgh\b^_gby�fu�\hh[s_[u�g_�kiZeb��?fm�fu�h[yaZgu��qlh�ijhkiZeb�ohly�[u�b lZd��Hih�g_�fh]eh�g_fgh]h�g_�ihf_rZlvgZf��ih^h[gh�ghqghfm�klhjh`m��dhlhjuc�g_�fh`_l�kh\k_f�g_�rmf_lv��ijh]hgyy�gZjmrbl_e_cihdhy��dhlhju_�ohlyl�jZa[m^blv�gZk�rmfhf����=eZ\ghc�oZjZdl_jghc�q_jlhc� kgh\b^_gby�y\ey_lky� lh��qlh�hgh�ih[m`^Z_lky�`_eZgb_f�bkiheg_gb_�wlh]h�`_eZgby�klZgh\blky�kh^_j`Zgb_f�kgh\b^_gby��>jm]hc�lZdhc�`_�ihklhygghcq_jlhc� y\ey_lky� lh�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� g_� ijhklh� \ujZ`Z_l� fukev�� Z ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc]ZeexpbgZlhjgh_� i_j_`b\Zgb_� bkiheg_gby�`_eZgby��Y `_eZeZ� [u� dZlZlvky� ih� ha_jm�� ]eZkbl`_eZgb_�� \uau\Zxs__� kgh\b^_gb_�� kh^_j`Zgb_� kgh\b^_gby�� y dZlZxkv� ih� ha_jm�� JZaebqb_f_`^m�kdjuluf�b y\guf�kgh\b^_gb_f��bkdZ`_gb_�kdjulhc�fukeb�kgh\b^_gby�hklZ_lky�b \�wlboijhkluo�^_lkdbo� kgh\b^_gbyo��b wlh�²�ij_\jZs_gb_�fukeb� \ i_j_`b\Zgb_�Ijb� lhedh\Zgbbkgh\b^_gby� gZ^h� ij_`^_� \k_]h� h[gZjm`blv� bf_ggh� wlh� qZklbqgh_� baf_g_gb_�� ?keb� [u� wlZoZjZdl_jgZy� q_jlZ� hdZaZeZkv� h[s_c� \k_f� kgh\b^_gbyf�� lh� ijb\_^_gguc� \ur_� njZ]f_glkgh\b^_gby�� y \b`m� k\h_]h� [jZlZ� \ ysbd_�²� gZ^h� [ueh� [u� ihgbfZlv� g_� dZd� ©fhc� [jZlh]jZgbqb\Z_lkyª�� Z dZd� ©y ohl_e� [u�� qlh[u� fhc� [jZl� h]jZgbqbeky�� fhc� [jZl� ^he`_gh]jZgbqblvkyª��Hq_\b^gh�� qlh� ba� ^\mo� ijb\_^_gguo� oZjZdl_jguo� q_jl� kgh\b^_gby� m \lhjhc[hevr_� rZgkh\� [ulv� ijbagZgghc� [_a� \hajZ`_gbc�� q_f� m i_j\hc�� Lhevdh� fgh]hqbke_ggu_bkke_^h\Zgby�fh]ml�mklZgh\blv��qlh�\ha[m^bl_e_f�kgh\b^_gby�^he`gh�[ulv�\k_]^Z�`_eZgb_��Zg_�hiZk_gb_��gZf_j_gb_�beb�mij_d��gh�^jm]Zy�oZjZdl_jgZy�q_jlZ��dhxjZy�aZdexqZ_lky�\ lhf��qlhkgh\b^_gb_�g_�ijhklh�i_j_^Z_l�wlh�jZa^jZ`_gb_��Z ij_djZsZ_l��mkljZgy_l��mgbqlh`Z_l�_]h�ijbihfhsb�hkh[h]h�jh^Z�i_j_`b\Zgby��hklZ_lky�g_ihdhe_[bfhc����Bkoh^y�ba�wlbo�oZjZdl_jguo�q_jl�kgh\b^_gby��fu�fh`_f�hiylv�\_jgmlvky�d kjZ\g_gbxkgh\b^_gby�k hrb[hqguf�^_ckl\b_f�< ihke_^g_f�fu�jZaebqZeb�gZjmrZxsmx�b gZjmr_ggmxl_g^_gpbx�� Z hrb[hqgh_� ^_ckl\b_� [ueh� dhfijhfbkkhf� f_`^m� h[_bfb�� LZ� `_� kZfZy� ko_fZih^oh^bl� b ^ey� kgh\b^_gby�� GZjmr_gghc� l_g^_gpb_c� \ g_c� fh`_l� [ulv� `_eZgb_� kiZlv�GZjmrZxsmx�l_g^_gpbx�fu�aZf_gy_f�ikbobq_kdbf�jZa^jZ`_gb_f��lh�_klv�`_eZgb_f��dhlhjh_klj_fblky� d k\h_fm� bkiheg_gbx�� lZd� dZd� ^h� kbo� ihj� fu� g_� \b^_eb� gbdZdh]h� ^jm]h]hikbobq_kdh]h� jZa^jZ`_gby�� gZjmrZxs_]h� khg�� B a^_kv� kgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lky� j_amevlZlhfdhfijhfbkkZ�� Kibrv�� gh� i_j_`b\Z_rv� mkljZg_gb_� `_eZgby�� m^h\e_l\hjy_rv� `_eZgb_� bijh^he`Z_rv�kiZlv��B lh��b ^jm]h_�hlqZklb�hkms_kl\ey_lky��hlqZklb�g_l�

Page 68: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

���<kihfgbl_��dZd�fu�iulZebkv�h^gZ`^u�gZclb�imlv�d ihgbfZgbx�kgh\b^_gbc�bkoh^y�bahq_gv� ihgylguo� h[jZah\Zgbc� nZglZabb�� lZd� gZau\Z_fuo� ©kgh\� gZy\mª�� Wlb� kgu� gZy\m^_ckl\bl_evgh� y\eyxlky� bkiheg_gb_f� `_eZgbc�� q_klhex[b\uo� b wjhlbq_kdbo�� dhlhju_� gZfohjhrh� ba\_klgu�� gh� hgb� fuke_ggu_�� b ohly� `b\h� ij_^klZ\eyxlky�� gh� gbdh]^Z� g_i_j_`b\Zxlky� ]ZeexpbgZlhjgh��LZdbf� h[jZahf�� ba� ^\mo� oZjZdl_jguo� q_jl� kgh\b^_gby� a^_kvhklZ_lky� f_g__� ^hklh\_jgZy�� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd� \lhjZy�� aZ\bkysZy� hl� khklhygby� kgZ� b g_j_Zebam_fZy� \ [h^jkl\h\Zgbb�� kh\_jr_ggh� hliZ^Z_l��B \� yaud_� _klv� lZd`_� gZf_d� gZ� lh�� qlhbkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby�y\ey_lky�hkgh\ghc�oZjZdl_jghc�q_jlhc�kgh\b^_gby��F_`^m�ijhqbf��_kebi_j_`b\Zgb_�\ kgh\b^_gbb�y\ey_lky�lhevdh�ij_\jZs_gguf�ij_^klZ\e_gb_f��l��_��©ghqguf�kghfgZy\mª��\hafh`guf�[eZ]h^Zjy�khklhygbx�kgZ��lh�fu�m`_�ihgbfZ_f��qlh�ijhp_kk�h[jZah\Zgbykgh\b^_gby�fh`_l� mkljZgblv� ghqih_� jZa^jZ`_gb_� b ijbg_klb� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�� ihlhfm� qlh� bkgu�iZy\m�y\eyxlky�^_yl_evghklvx��k\yaZgghc�k m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f��b \_^v�lhevdh�ba�aZ�wlh]h�bfb hl^Zxlky�G_� lhevdh� wlh�� gh� b ^jei]_� h[s_A� ihlj_[b� ]_evgu_� \ujZ`_gby� bf_xl� lhl� `_� kfukeIa\_kliuj�]h]h\hjdb�ml\_j`^Zxl��k\bgv_�kgblky�`_em^v��]mkx�²�dmdmjmaZ��beb�kijZrb\Zxl�qlh�\b^bl�\h�kg_�dmjbpZ"�Ijhkh��Ih]h\hjdZ�b^_l��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��^Zevr_��q_f�fu�²�hl�j_[_gdZd `b\hlghfm� ²� b ml\_j`^Z_l�� qlh� kh^_j`Zgb_� kgZ� y\ey_lky� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f� ihlj_[ghklb�Fgh]b_� \ujZ`_gby�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� ih^l\_j`^Zxl� wlh�� gZijbf_j�� ©ij_djZkgh�� dZd� \h� kg_ª�©wlh]h�b \h�kg_�g_�m\b^brvª��©y [u�g_�fh]�k_[_�wlh�ij_^klZ\blv�^Z`_�\ kZfhf�g_h[uqZcghfkg_ª��Mihlj_[e_gb_�\ yaud_�lZdbo�\ujZ`_gbc��hq_\b^gh��]h\hjbl�\ gZrm�ihevam��IjZ\^Z��_klvkljZrgu_� kgh\b^_gby� b kgh\b^_gby� k g_ijbylguf� beb� [_ajZaebqguf� kh^_j`Zgb_f�� gh� bokeh\hmihlj_[e_gb_�b g_�dhkgmehkv��Ohly�fu�b ]h\hjbf�h ©^mjguoª�kgZo��gh�^ey�gZr_]h�yaudZkgh\b^_gb_�\k_�jZ\gh�hklZ_lky�lhevdh�bkiheg_gb_f�`_eZgby��G_l�gb h^ghc�ih]h\hjdb��dhlhjZy[u�ml\_j`^ZeZ��qlh�k\bgvy�beb�]mkv�\b^_eb�\h�ki_��dZd�bo�aZdZeu\Zxl�Dhg_qgh�� g_fukebfh�� qlh[u� klhev� oZjZdl_jgZy� q_jlZ� kgh\b^_gby�� \ujZ`ZxsZyky� \bkiheg_gbb� `_eZgby�� g_� [ueZ� [u� aZf_q_gZ� Z\lhjZfb�� ibkZ\rbfb� h kgh\b^_gbyo�� Wlhijhbkoh^beh� hq_gv� qZklh�� gh� gb h^ghfm� ba� gbo� g_� ijbreh� \ ]heh\m� ijbagZlv� __ h[s_coZjZdl_jghc�q_jlhc�b kqblZlv�wlh�dexq_\uf�fhf_glhf�\ h[tykg_gbb�kgh\b^_gbc��Fu�fh`_fk_[_�ohjh�rh�ij_^klZ\blv��qlh�bo�fh]eh�hl�wlh]h�m^_j`b\Zlv��b _s_�dhkg_fky�wlh]h�\hijhkZ�Gh� ihkfhljbl_�� kdhevdh� k\_^_gbc� fu� ihemqbeb� ba� \ukhdh� hp_g_gguo� gZfb� ^_lkdbokgh\b^_gbc�b ihqlb�[_a�ljm^Z��Nmgdpby�kgh\b^_gby�dZd�kljZ`Z�kgZ��_]h�\hagbdgh\_gb_�ba�^\modhgdmjbjmxsbo� l_g^_gpbc�� ba� dhlhjuo� h^gZ� hklZ_lky� ihklhygghc�²�`_eZgb_� kgZ�� Z ^jm]Zyklj_fblky� m^h\e_l\hjblv�ikbobq_kdh_�jZa^jZ`_gb_��^hdZaZl_evkl\h��qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lkyhkfuke_gguf�ikbobq_kdbf�Zdlhf��h[_�_]h�oZjZdl_jgu_�q_jlu�bkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby�b ]ZeexpbgZlhjgh_�i_j_`b\Zgb_��B ijb�wlhf�fu�ihqlb�aZ[ueb��qlhaZgbfZ_fky�ikbohZgZebahf��Djhf_�k\yab�k hrb[hqgufb�^_ckl\byfb�\ gZr_c�jZ[hl_�g_�[uehgbq_]h� ki_pbnbq_kdh]h��Ex[hc�ikboheh]��gbq_]h�g_� agZxsbc� h[� bkoh^guo� ij_^iheh`_gbyoikbohZgZebaZ�� fh]� [u� ^Zlv� wlh� h[tykg_gb_� ^_lkdbo� kgh\b^_gbc��Ihq_fm� `_� gbdlh� wlh]h� g_k^_eZe"?keb�[u�\k_�kih\b^_gby�[ueb�lZdbfb�`_��dZd�^_lkdb_��lh�ijh[e_fZ�[ueZ�[u�j_r_gZ��gZrZaZ^ZqZ� \uiheg_gZ�� b g_� gm`gh� [ueh� [u� jZkkijZrb\Zlv� \b^_\r_]h� khg�� ijb\e_dZlv

Page 69: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[_kkhagZl_evgh_� b ihevah\Zlvky� k\h[h^ghc� ZkkhpbZpb_c��Gh� \ wlhf�lh�� hq_\b^gh�� b khklhblgZrZ� ^Zevg_crZy� aZ^ZqZ��GZr� hiul� m`_� g_� jZa� ihdZau\Ze�� qlh� oZjZdl_jgu_� q_jlu�� dhlhju_kqblZxlky�h[sbfb��ih^l\_j`^Zxlky�aZl_f�lhevdh�^ey�hij_^_e_ggh]h�\b^Z�b qbkeZ�kgh\b^_gbc�J_qv��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��b^_l�h lhf��hklZxlky�eb�\ kbe_�hldjulu_�[eZ]h^Zjy�^_lkdbf�kgh\b^_gbyfh[sb_� oZjZdl_jgu_� q_jlu�� ]h^ylky� eb� hgb� ^ey� l_o� g_ykguo� kgh\b^_gbc�� y\gh_� kh^_j`Zgb_dhlhjuo�g_�h[gZjm`b\Z_l�hlghr_gby�d dZdhfm�lh�hklZ\r_fmky�`_eZgbx��Fu�ijb^_j`b\Z_fkyfg_gby��qlh� wlb�^jm]b_� kgh\b^_gby�ij_l_ji_eb� ]em[hdh_�bkdZ`_gb_�b ihw�xfm� h gbo�g_evaykm^blv�kjZam��Fu�lZd`_�ij_^iheZ]Z_f��qlh�^ey�bo�h[tykg_gby�g_h[oh^bfZ�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdZyl_ogbdZ��dhlhjZy�g_�[ueZ�gZf�gm`gZ�^ey�ihgbfZgby�^_lkdbo�kgh\b^_gbc�Bf__lky��\ijhq_f��_s_�h^bg�deZkk�g_bkdZ`_gguo�kgh\b^_gbc��\ dhlhjuo��dZd�b \�^_lkdbo�e_]dh� magZlv� bkiheg_gb_� `_eZgby�� Wlh� l_�� dhlhju_� \uau\Zxlky� \ l_q_gb_� \k_c� `bagbbfi_jZlb\gufb� ihlj_hghklyfb� l_eZ�� ]heh^hf�� `Z`^hc�� k_dkmZevghc� ihlj_[ghklvx�� l�� _�y\eyxlky�bkiheg_gb_f�`_eZgbc�dZd�j_Zdpbb�gZ�\gmlj_ggb_�khfZlbq_kdb_�jZa^jZ`_gby��LZd��yaZibkZe�kgh\b^_gb_����f_kyqghc�^_\hqdb��dhlhjh_�khklhyeh�ba�f_gx�k ijb[Z\e_gb_f�__ bf_gb�:ggZ�N���a_feygbdZ��fZebgZ��ybqgbpZ��dZrZ���Kgh\b^_gb_�y\behkv�j_Zdpb_c�gZ�^_gv�]heh^h\dbba�aZ� jZkkljhckl\Z� ibs_\Zj_gby�� \ua\Zggh]h� dZd� jZa� ^\mfy� mihfygmlufb� y]h^Zfb�� < lh�`_\j_fy� b [Z[mrdZ�� \hajZkl� dhlhjhc� \f_kl_� k \hajZklhf� \gmqdb� khklZ\be� k_fv^_kyl� e_l�\ke_^kl\b_�[_kihdhckl\Z�ba�aZ�[em`^Zxs_c�ihqdb�^he`gZ�[ueZ�p_euc�^_gv�]heh^Zlv��b \�lm�`_ghqv� _c� kgbehkv�� qlh� __ ijreZkbeb� \ ]hklb� b m]hsZxl� kZfufb� emqrbfb� eZdhfkl\Zfb�GZ[ex^_gby�aZ�aZdexq_ggufb��dhlhjuo�aZklZ\eyxl�]heh^Zlv��b aZ�ebpZfb��l_jiysbfb�ebr_gby\ iml_r_kl\byo� b wdki_^bpbyo�� k\b^_l_evkl\mxl� h lhf�� qlh� \ wlbo� mkeh\byo� hgb� ihklhyggh\b^yl� \h� kg_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� wlbo� ihlj_[ghkl_c�� LZd� Hllh� Ghj^_gr_ev^� \ k\h_c� dgb]_:glZjdlbdZ��������khh[sZ_l�h abfh\Z\r_c�k gbf�dhfZg^_��l�����k������b _e���©H gZijZ\e_gghklb� gZrbo� khdjh\_gg_crbo� fuke_c� hq_gv� ykgh� ]h\hjbeb� gZrbkgh\b^_gby�� dhlhju_� gbdh]^Z� ij_`^_� g_� [ueb� klhev� yjdb� b fgh]hqbke_ggu�� >Z`_� l_� gZrblh\Zjbsb�� dhlhju_� \b^_eb� kgu� \ bkdexqbl_evguo� kemqZyo�� l_i_jv� ih� mljZf�� dh]^Z� fuh[f_gb\Zebkv� k\hbfb� i_j_`b\Zgbyfb� ba� wlh]h� nZglZklbq_kdh]h� fbjZ�� fh]eb� jZkkdZau\Zlv^ebggu_�bklhjbb��<h�\k_o�gbo�j_qv�reZ�h lhf�\g_rg_f�fbj_��dhlhjuc�[ue�l_i_jv�lZd�^Ze_d�hlgZk�� gh� qZklh� hgb� bf_eb� hlghr_gb_� b d� gZrbf� lh]^Zrgbf� mkeh\byf���� ?^Z� b iblv_� [uebp_gljhf�� \hdjm]� dhlhjh]h� qZs_� \k_]h� \jZsZebkv� gZrb� kgh\b^_gby�� H^bg� ba� gZk�� dhlhjuchkh[_ggh�qZklh�gZkeZ`^Zeky�]jZg^bhagufb�ghqgufb�ibjZfb��[ue�hl�^mrb�jZ^��_keb�mljhf�fh]khh[sblv��©qlh�kt_e�h[_^�ba�lj_o�[ex^ª��^jm]hc�\b^_e�\h�kg_�lZ[Zd��p_eu_�]hju�lZ[Zdm��lj_lvb²�dhjZ[ev��gZ�\k_o�iZjmkZo�ijb[eb`Zxsbcky�P�hldjulh]h�fhjy��AZkem`b\Z_l�mihfbgZgby�_s_h^gh�kgh\b^_gb_��y\ey_lky�ihqlZevhg�k ihqlhc�b ^ebggh�h[tykgy_l��ihq_fm� __ ijbrehkv� lZd^he]h�`^Zlv��hg�g_ijZ\bevgh�__ k^Ze�b _fm�k [hevrbf� ljm^hf�m^Zehkv�ihemqblv�__ h[jZlgh�Dhg_qgh�� \h� \j_fy� kgZ� gZk� aZgbfZeb� _s_� [he__� g_\hafh`gu_� \_sb�� gh� ihqlb� \h� \k_okgh\b^_gbyo��dhlhju_�\b^_e�y kZf�beb�h dhlhjuo�keurZe��ihjZ`Z_l�[_^ghklv�nZglZabb��?keb[u� \k_� wlb� kgh\b^_gby� [ueb� aZibkZgu�� wlh�� g_khfg_ggh�� ij_^klZ\beh� [u� [hevrhcikboheh]bq_kdbc�bgl_j_k��Gh�e_]dh�ihgylv��dZdbf�`_eZgguf�[ue�^ey�gZk�khg��ihlhfm�qlh�hgfh]�^Zlv�gZf�\k_��q_]h�dZ`^uc�[hevr_�\k_]h�`_eZeª��Pblbjmx�_s_�ih�>x�Gj_ex �����?������©Fmg]h�IZjd��ih]b[Z\rbc�hl�`Z`^u�\h�\j_fy�iml_r_kl\by�ih�:njbd_��[_kij_ju\gh�\b^_e�\hkg_�fgh]h\h^gu_�^hebgu�b em]Z�k\h_c�jh^bgu��LZd�b fmqbfuc�]heh^hf�Lj_gd�\b^_e�k_[y�\h

Page 70: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kg_�\ 6WHUQVFKDQ]H�\ FZ]^_[mj]_��hdjm`_gguf� jhkdhrgufb�h[_^Zfb�� Z =_hj]�;Zgd�� mqZklgbdi_j\hc� wdki_^bpbb� NjZgdebgZ��� dh]^Z� \ke_^kl\b_� g_\ughkbfuo� ebr_gbc� [ue� [ebahd� d]heh^ghc�kf_jlb��ihklhyggh�\b^_e�\h�kg_�h[bevgu_�h[_^uª�Lhfm��dlh�aZ�m`bghf�_kl�hkljmx�ibsm��\uau\Zxsmx�`Z`^m��e_]dh�fh`_l�ijbkgblvky��qlhhg� iv_l�� JZamf__lky�� g_\hafh`gh� m^h\e_l\hjblv� kbevgmx� ihlj_[ghklv� \ _^_� beb� iblv_� ijbihfhsb� kgh\b^_gby�� hl� lZdbo� kgh\b^_gbb� ijhkuiZ_rvky� k qm\kl\hf�`Z`^u� b gZib\Z_rvky\h^u�ih�gZklhys_fm��>hklb`_gb_�kgh\b^_gby�\ wlhf�kemqZ_�ijZdlbq_kdb�g_agZqbl_evgh��gh�g_f_g__� hq_\b^gh�� qlh� hgh� \hagbdeh� k p_evx� g_� ^himklblv� jZa^jZ`_gb_�� aZklZ\eyxs__ijhkgmlvky� b ^_ckl\h\Zlv�� Ijb� g_agZqbl_evghc� kbe_� wlbo� ihlj_[ghkl_c� kgu�� ijbghkysb_m^h\e_l\hj_gb_��qZklh�\iheg_�ihfh]Zxl�Lhqgh� lZd�`_� kgh\b^_gb_� ^Z_l� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� k_dkmZevguo� jZa^jZ`_gbb�� gh� hgh� bf__lhkh[_gghklb��h dhlhjuo�klhbl�mihfygmlv��<ke_^kl\b_�hkh[h]h�k\hckl\Z�k_dkmZevgh]h�\e_q_gby\ f_gvr_c�kl_i_gb�aZ\bk_lv�hl�h[t_dlZ��q_f�ijb�]heh^_�b `Z`^_��m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�\ kgh\b^_gbbk iheexpbyfb� fh`_l� [ulv� j_Zevguf�� Z ba�aZ� hij_^_e_gguo� ljm^ghkl_c� \ hlghr_gbyo� kh[t_dlhf��h q_f�fu�kdZ`_f�iha`_��hq_gv�qZklh�j_Zevgh_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�k\yaZgh�k g_ykguf�bebbkdZ`_gguf�kh^_j`Zgb_f�kgh\b^_gby��WlZ�hkh[_gghklv�kgh\b^_gby�k iheexpbyfb�^_eZ_l�bo�dZd� aZf_lbe� H�� JZgd� �����Z��� m^h[gufb� h[t_dlZfb� ^ey� bamq_gby� bkdZ`_gby� kgh\b^_gby�<ijhq_f�� \k_� kgh\b^_gby� \ajhkeuo�� k\yaZggu_� k m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f� ihlj_[ghklb�� djhf_m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� kh^_j`Zl�fgh]h_� ^jm]h_�� qlh� ijhbkoh^bl� ba� qbklh� ikbobq_kdbo� bklhqgbdh\jZa^jZ`_gby�b ^ey�k\h_]h�ihgbfZgby�gm`^Z_lky�\ lhedh\Zgbb�<ijhq_f��fu�g_�ohlbf�ml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�h[jZam_fu_�ih�lbim�^_lkdbo�kgh\b^_gby�\ajhkeuok bkiheg_gb_f� `_eZgby� y\eyxlky� lhevdh� j_Zdpbyfb� gZ� lZd� gZau\Z_fu_� bfi_jZlb\gu_ihlj_[ghklb��GZf�ba\_klgu�lZd`_�dhjhldb_�b ykgu_�kih\b^_gby�lZdh]h�lbiZ�ih^�\ha^_ckl\b_fhij_^_e_gguo� ^hfbgbjmxsbo� kblmZpbc�� bklhqgbdZfb� dhlhjuo� y\eyxlky�� g_khfg_ggh�ikbobq_kdb_� jZa^jZ`_gby�� LZdh\u�� gZijbf_j�� kgh\b^_gby�� >\ujZ`Zxsb_@� g_l_ji_gb_�� dh]^Zdlh�lh�]hlh\blky�d iml_r_kl\bx��\Z`ghc�^ey�g_]h�\uklZ\d_��^hdeZ^m��\bablm�b \b^bl�aZjZg__�\hkg_�bkiheg_gb_�h`b^Z_fh]h��l��_��ghqvx�_s_�^h�gZklhys_]h�kh[ulby�^hklb]Z_l�p_eb��\b^bl�k_[y\ l_Zlj_��[_k_^m_l�\ ]hklyo��Beb� lZd�gZau\Z_fu_� ©m^h[gu_ª�kgh\b^_gby��dh]^Z�dlh�lh��`_eZyijh^eblv� khg�� \b^bl��qlh� hg� m`_� \klZe�� mfu\Z_lky�beb�gZoh^blky� \ rdhe_�� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd� \^_ckl\bl_evghklb� ijh^he`Z_l� kiZlv�� l�� _�� ij_^ihqblZ_l� \klZ\Zlv� \h� kg_�� Z g_� \^_ckl\bl_evghklb��@_eZgb_� kiZlv�� ih� gZr_fm� fg_gbx�� ihklhyggh� ijbgbfZxs__� mqZklb_� \h[jZah\Zgbb� kgh\b^_gby�� y\gh� ijhy\ey_lky� \ wlbo� kgh\b^_gbyo� dZd� kms_kl\_gguc� nZdlhjh[jZah\Zgby�kgh\b^_gby��Ihlj_[ghklv�\h�kg_�k iheguf�ijZ\hf�aZgbfZ_l�f_klh�\ jy^m�^jm]bonbabq_kdbo�ihlj_[ghkl_c�GZ�ijbf_j_�j_ijh^mdpbb�dZjlbgu�R\bg^Z�ba�RZdd]Ze_j_b�\ Fxgo_g_�y ihdZ`m�\Zf��dZdijZ\bevgh� ihgye� om^h`gbd� \hagbdgh\_gb_� kgh\b^_gby� ih� ^hfbgbjmxs_c� kblmZpbb�� Wlh©Kgh\b^_gb_� magbdZª�� kh^_j`Zgb_� dhlhjh]h� g_� qlh� bgh_�� dZd� _]h� hk\h[h`^_gb_�Ijbf_qZl_evgh��qlh�hk\h[h`^_gb_�^he`gh�hkms_kl\blvky�q_j_a�hdgh��ihlhfm�qlh�q_j_a�hdghijhgbdZ_l� k\_lh\h_� jZa^jZ`_gb_�� hl� dhlhjh]h� magbd� ijhkuiZ_lky�� Klhysb_� ^jm]� aZ� ^jm]hf]ghfu�ij_^klZ\eyxl�_]h�kh[kl\_ggu_�ihke_^h\Zl_evgu_�iheh`_gby�ijb�ihiuld_�\ue_alb�\\_jod hdgm� b�� _keb� y g_� hrb[Zxkv� b g_� ijbibku\Zx� gZf_j_gbx� om^h`gbdZ� kebrdhf� fgh]h]h�

Page 71: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

klhysbc�\ur_�\k_o�]ghf��dhlhjuc�i_j_ibeb\Z_l�j_r_ldm��l��_��^_eZ_l�lh��qlh�ohl_e�[u�k^_eZlvkZf�magbd��bf__l�_]h�q_jlu�ebpZ�<h�\k_o�^jm]bo�kgh\b^_gbyo��djhf_�^_lkdbo�b mdZaZgguo��bgnZglbevguo�ih�k\h_fm�lbim�dZd�kdZaZgh��bkdZ`_gb_�\ha^\b]Z_l�gZ�gZr_f�imlb�ij_]jZ^u��Fu�ihdZ�_s_�g_�fh`_f�kdZaZlv�y\eyxlky�eb�b hgb�bkiheg_�gb_f�`_eZgby��dZd�fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f��ba�bo�y\gh]h�kh^_j`Zgby�fug_� agZ_f�� dZdhfm� ikbobq_kdhfm� jZa^jZ`_gbx� hgb� h[yaZgu� k\hbf� ijhbkoh`^_gb_f�� b fu� g_fh`_f�^hdZaZlv��qlh�hgb�lZd`_�klj_fylky�mkljZgblv�wlh�jZa^jZ`_gb_��Hgb��\_jhylgh��^he`gu[ulv�bklhedh\Zgu��l��_��i_j_\_^_gu��bo�bkdZ`_gb_�gZ^h�mkljZgblv��y\gh_�kh^_j`Zgb_�aZf_gblvkdjuluf�� ij_`^_� q_f� k^_eZlv� \u\h^�� qlh� hldjulh_� gZfb� \ ^_lkdbo� kgh\b^_gbyoih^l\_j`^Z_lky�^ey�\k_o�kgh\b^_gbc�>?<YL:Y�E?DPBYP_gamjZ�kgh\b^_gbyM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��Fu�ihagZdhfbebkv�k \hagbdgh\_gb_f��kmsghklvx�b nmgdpb_ckgh\b^_gby�� bamqZy� kgh\b^_gby� ^_l_c�� Kgh\b^_gby� y\eyxlky� mkljZg_gb_f� gZjmrZxsbo� khg�ikbobq_kdbo��jZa^jZ`_gbb�iml_f� ]ZeexpbgZlhjgh]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby��IjZ\^Z��ba�kgh\b^_gbc\ajhkeuo� fu� kfh]eb� h[tykgblv� lhevdh� h^gm� ]jmiim�� dhlhjmx� fu� gZa\Zeb� kgh\b^_gbyfbbgnZglbevgh]h�lbiZ��DZd�h[klhbl�^_eh�k ^jm]bfb�kgh\b^_gbyfb��fu�ihdZ�g_�agZ_f��fu�lZd`_�bg_� ihgbfZ_f� bo��IhdZ� fu� ihemqbeb� j_amevlZl�� agZq_gb_� dhlhjh]h� g_� ohlbf� g_^hhp_gb\Zlv�<kydbc� jZa�� dh]^Z� kgh\b^_gb_� gZf� Z[khexlgh� ihgylgh�� hgh� y\ey_lky� ]ZeexpbgZlhjgufbkiheg_gb_f�`_eZgby��LZdh_�kh\iZ^_gb_�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�kemqZcguf�b g_agZqbl_evguf�Bkoh^y�ba�g_dhlhjuo�khh[jZ`_gbc�b ih�ZgZeh]bb�k ihgbfZgb_f�hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc�fuij_^iheZ]Z_f�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� ^jm]h]h� jh^Z� y\ey_lky� bkdZ`_gguf� aZf_klbl_e_f� ^eyg_ba\_klgh]h� kh^_j`Zgby� b lhevdh� bf� ^he`gh� h[tykgylvky��Bkke_^h\Zgb_�� ihgbfZgb_� wlh]hbkdZ`_gby�kgh\b^_gby�b y\ey_lky�gZr_c�[eb`Zcr_c�aZ^Zq_c�BkdZ`_gb_� kgh\b^_gby�²� wlh� lh�� qlh� gZf� dZ`_lky� \ g_f� kljZgguf� b g_ihgylguf��Fuohlbf�fgh]h_�magZlv�h g_f��\h�i_j\uo��hldm^Z�hgh�[_j_lky��_]h�^bgZfbaf��\h�\lhjuo��qlh�hgh^_eZ_l�b��gZdhg_p��dZd�hgh�wlh�^_eZ_l��Fu�fh`_f�lZd`_�kdZaZlv��qlh�bkdZ`_gb_�kgh\b^_gby�²wlh� ijh^mdl� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby�� Fu� ohlbf� hibkZlv� jZ[hlm� kgh\b^_gby� b mdZaZlv� l]Z^_ckl\mxsb_�ijb�wlhf�kbeu�: l_i_jv�\ukemrZcl_�ijbf_j�kgh\b^_gby��?]h�aZibkZeZ�^ZfZ�gZr_]h�djm]Z� ��ih�__ keh\Zf�hgh� ijbgZ^e_`bl� h^ghc� ihql_gghc� \ukhdhh[jZah\Zgghc� ij_klZj_ehc� ^Zf_�� :gZeba� wlh]hkgh\b^_gby� g_� [ue� ijhba\_^_g��GZrZ� j_n_j_gldZ� aZf_qZ_l�� qlh� ^ey� ikbohZgZeblbdZ� hgh� g_gm`^Z_lky�\ lhedh\Zgbb��KZfZ�\b^_\rZy�khg�_]h�g_�lhedh\ZeZ��gh�hgZ�\ukdZaZeZ�h

�=hkih`Z�^�j nhg�=m]�=_eevfml��������g_f�k\h_�km`^_gb_��dZd�[m^lh�hgZ�kmf_eZ�[u�_]h�bklhedh\Zlv��<hl�dZd�hgZ�\ukdZaZeZkv�hg_f��b lZdZy�hl\jZlbl_evgZy� ]emihklv� kgblky�`_gsbg_� ���e_l��dhlhjZy�^_gv�b ghqv�g_�bf__l^jm]bo�fuke_c��djhf_�aZ[hlu�h k\h_f�j_[_gd_�

Page 72: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

: \hl�b kgh\b^_gb_�h ©ex[h\ghc�kem`[_ª��©�HgZ�hlijZ\ey_lky�\ ]Zjgbahgguc�]hkiblZev���� b ]h\hjbl� qZkh\hfm� m \hjhl�� qlh� _c� gm`gh� ih]h\hjblv� k ]eZ\guf� \jZqhf� �hgZ� gZau\Z_lg_agZdhfh_� _c� bfy��� lZd� dZd� hgZ� ohq_l� ihklmiblv� gZ� kem`[m� \ ]hkiblZev��Ijb� wlhf� hgZ� lZdih^q_jdb\Z_l� keh\h� Äkem`[Z��� qlh� mgl_j�hnbp_j� lhlqZk� ^h]Z^u\Z_lky�� qlh� j_qv� b^_l� hÄex[h\ghc� kem`[_��� LZd� dZd� hgZ� klZjZy� `_gsbgZ�� lh� hg� ijhimkdZ_l� __ ihke_� g_dhlhjh]hdhe_[Zgby��Gh�\f_klh�lh]h��qlh[u�ijhclb�d ]eZ\ghfm�\jZqm��hgZ�ihiZ^Z_l�\ [hevrmx�l_fgmxdhfgZlm�� ]^_� \hdjm]� ^ebggh]h� klheZ� kb^bl� b klhbl� fgh]h� hnbp_jh\� b \h_gguo� \jZq_c��HgZh[jZsZ_lky� kh� k\hbf� ij_^eh`_gb_f� d dZdhfm�lh� rlZ[ghfm� \jZqm�� dhlhjuc� ihgbfZ_l� __� kg_kdhevdbo�keh\��>hkeh\gh�__ j_qv�\h�kg_�ke_^mxsZy��ÄY b�fgh]b_�^jm]b_�`_gsbgu�b fheh^u_^_\mrdb� <_gu� ]hlh\u� khe^ZlZf�� jy^h\tr� b hnbp_jZf� [_a� jZaebqby����� A^_kv� \ kgh\b^_gbbke_^m_l�dZdh_�lh�[hjfhlZgb_��Gh�lh��qlh�__�ijZ\bevgh�ihgyeb��\b^gh�ih�hlqZklb�kfms_gghfm�hlqZklb� emdZ\hfm� \ujZ`_gbx� ebp� hnbp_jh\��>ZfZ� ijh^he`Z_l�� ÄY agZx�� qlh� gZr_� j_r_gb_g_kdhevdh� kljZggh�� gh� hgh� ^ey� gZk� qj_a\uqZcgh� k_jv_agh�� Khe^ZlZ� gZ� ihe_� [hy� lh`_� g_kijZrb\Zxl��ohq_l�hg�mfbjZlv�beb�g_l���Ke_^m_l�fbgmlgh_�fmqbl_evgh_�fheqZgb_��RlZ[ghc\jZq� h[gbfZ_l� __ aZ� lZebx� b ]h\hjbl�� ÄFbehklb\Zy� ]hkm^Zjugy�� ij_^klZ\vl_� k_[_�� qlh� ^_eh^_ckl\bl_evgh�^hreh� [u� ^h� ���� �[hjfhlZgb_����HgZ� hk\h[h`^Z_lky� hl� _]h� h[tylbc� k fukevx�Ä<k_�hgb�h^bgZdh\u��²�b \hajZ`Z_l��Ä=hkih^b��y klZjZy�`_gsbgZ�b��fh`_l�[ulv��g_�hdZ`mkv�\lZdhf� iheh`_gbb�� <ijhq_f�� h^gh� mkeh\b_� ^he`gh� [ulv� kh[ex^_gh�� mq_l� \hajZklZ�� qlh[ug_fheh^Zy�^ZfZ�kh\k_f�fheh^hfm�iZjgx�����[hjfhlZgb_���wlh�[ueh�[u�m`Zkgh���RlZ[ghc�\jZq�ÄY ij_djZkgh� ihgbfZx���G_dhlhju_� hnbp_ju�� b kj_^b� gbo� lhl�� dlh� k^_eZe� _c� \ fheh^hklbij_^eh`_gb_��]jhfdh�kf_xlky��b ^ZfZ�`_eZ_l��qlh[u�__�ijh\h^beb�d agZdhfhfm�]eZ\ghfm�\jZqm^ey�hdhgqZl_evgh]h�\uykg_gby��Ijb�wlhf��d \_ebdhfm�kfms_gbx��_c�ijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m��qlh�hgZg_� agZ_l� _]h�bf_gb��RlZ[ghc� \jZq� l_f� \j_f_g_f� hq_gv� \_`eb\h�ij_^eZ]Z_l� _c�ih^gylvky�gZ\_jogbc� wlZ`� ih� madhc� `_e_aghc� \bglh\hc� e_klgbp_�� dhlhjZy� \_^_l� ijyfh� ba� dhfgZlu� gZ\_jogb_� wlZ`b�� Ih^gbfZykv�� hgZ� keurbl�� dZd� h^bg� hnbp_j� ]h\hjbl�� ÄWlh� dhehkkZevgh_j_r_gb_�� [_ajZaebqgh��fheh^Zy� beb� klZjZy�� gm`gh� hl^Zlv� ^he`gh_���K qm\kl\hf�� qlh� ijhklh\uihegy_l�k\hc�^he]��hgZ�ih^gbfZ_lky�ih�[_kdhg_qghc�e_klgbp_ª�Wlh�kgh\b^_gb_�ih\lhjy_lky�gZ�ijhly`_gbb�g_kdhevdbo�g_^_ev�_s_�^\Z�jZaZ�k kh\_jr_gghg_agZqbl_evgufb�b ^h\hevgh�[_kkfuke_ggufb�baf_g_gbyfb��dZd�aZf_qZ_l�^ZfZ�< k\h_f� l_q_gbb� kgh\b^_gb_� khhl\_lkl\m_l� ^g_\ghc� nZglZabb�� \ g_f� fZeh� i_j_ju\h\�g_dhlhju_�qZklghklb�\ _]h�kh^_j`Zgbb�fh]eb�[u�[ulv�jZatykg_gu�jZkkijhkZfb��q_]h��dZd�\uagZ_l_�� g_� [ueh�� Gh� kZfh_� aZf_qZl_evgh_� b bgl_j_kgh_� ^ey� gZk� lh�� qlh� \ kgh\b^_gbb� _klvg_kdhevdh�ijhimkdh\��ijhimkdh\�g_�\ \hkihfbgZgbb��Z \�kh^_j`Zgbb��< lj_o�f_klZo�kh^_j`Zgb_dZd�[u�kl_jlh��j_qb��\ dhlhjuo�bf_xlky�ijhimkdb��ij_ju\Zxlky�[hjfhlZgb_f��LZd�dZd�fu�g_ijh\h^beb�ZgZebaZ��lh��kljh]h�]h\hjy��g_�bf__f�ijZ\Z�qlh�eb[h�]h\hjblv�h kfuke_�kgh\b^_gby�IjZ\^Z�� \ g_f� _klv� gZf_db�� ba� dhlhjuo� fh`gh� dh_�qlh� aZdexqblv�� gZijbf_j�� \ujZ`_gb_©ex[h\gZy� kem`[Zª��gh�qZklb�j_qb��g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�ij_^r_kl\mxsb_�[hjfhlZgbx�� lj_[mxlij_`^_� \k_]h� ^hiheg_gbc�� dhlhju_� fh]ml� bf_lv� h^bg� kfuke�� ?keb� fu� bo� bkihevam_f�� lhihemqblky�nZglZaby� lZdh]h� kh^_j`Zgby�� qlh� \b^_\rZy� khg� ]hlh\Z�� bkihegyy� iZljbhlbq_kdbc^he]��ij_^hklZ\blv�k_[y�^ey�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�ex[h\guo�ihlj_[ghkl_c�\h_gguo��dZd�hnbp_jh\�lZd� b jy^h\uo�� Wlh�� [_amkeh\gh�� kh\_jr_ggh� g_ijbebqgh�� h[jZa_p� ^_jadhc� eb[b^haghcnZglZabb��gh�\ kgh\b^_gbb� wlh]h�\h\k_�g_l��DZd�jZa� lZf�� ]^_�oh^�fuke_c�ijb\_e�[u�d wlhfm

Page 73: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijbagZgbx��\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb�g_ykgh_�[hjfhlZgb_��qlh�lh�mljZq_gh�beb�ih^Z\e_gh�<u� kh]eZkbl_kv�� gZ^_xkv�� qlh� bf_ggh� g_ijbebqb_� wlbo� f_kl� [ueh� fhlb\hf� ^ey� boih^Z\e_gby��=^_��h^gZdh��gZclb�ZgZeh]bx�wlhfm�kemqZx"�< gZrb�^gb�\Zf�g_�ijb^_lky�__ ^he]hbkdZlv��<havfbl_�dZdmx�gb[m^v��iheblbq_kdmx�]Za_lm��b \u�gZc^_l_��qlh�\ g_kdhevdbo�f_klZol_dkl�batyl��gZ�_]h�f_kl_�k\_lblky�[_eZy�[mfZ]Z��<u�agZ_l_��qlh�wlh�^_eh�]Za_lghc�p_gamju��GZwlbo�imkluo�f_klZo�[ueh�qlh�lh��qlh�g_�ihgjZ\behkv�\ukhdbf�p_gamjguf�\eZklyf�b ihwlhfm[ueh�m^Ze_gh��<u�^mfZ_l_��dZd�`Zev��wlh�[ueh��fh`_l�[ulv��kZfh_�bgl_j_kgh_��©kZfh_�emqr__f_klhª�< ^jm]bo�kemqZyo�p_gamjZ�hdZau\Z_l�k\h_�^_ckl\b_�g_�gZ�]hlh\uc�l_dkl��:\lhj�ij_^\b^_e�dZdb_� \ukdZau\Zgby� fh]ml� \ua\Zlv� \hajZ`_gby� p_gamju�� b ij_^mkfhljbl_evgh� kfy]qbe� bo�ke_]dZ� baf_gbe� beb� m^h\hevkl\h\Zeky� gZf_dZfb� b g_iheguf� baeh`_gb_f� lh]h�� qlh� ohl_ekdZaZlv��Lh]^Z�\ ]Za_l_�g_l�imkluo�f_kl��Z ih�g_dhlhjuf�gZf_dZf�b g_ykghklyf�\ujZ`_gby�\ufh`_l_�^h]Z^Zlvky��qlh�lj_[h\Zgby�p_gamju�m`_�aZjZg__�ijbgylu�\h�\gbfZgb_�;m^_f�ijb^_j`b\Zlvky� wlh]h� kjZ\g_gby��Fu� ml\_j`^Z_f�� qlh�ijhims_ggu_�� kdjulu_� aZ[hjfhlZgb_f� keh\Z� kgh\b^_gby� ijbg_k_gu� \ `_jl\m� p_gamj_��Fu� ijyfh� ]h\hjbf� h p_gamj_kgh\b^_gby��dhlhjhc�ke_^m_l�ijbibkZlv�ba\_klgh_�mqZklb_�\ bkdZ`_gbb�kgh\b^_gby��<_a^_��]^_\ y\ghf� kgh\b^_gbb� _klv� ijhimkdb�� \ gbo� \bgh\ZlZ� p_gamjZ� kgh\b^_gby��GZf� ke_^h\Zeh� [uihclb�_s_�^Zevr_�b kqblZlv��qlh�^_ckl\b_�p_gamju�kdZau\Z_lky�dZ`^uc�jZa�lZf��]^_�we_f_glkgh\b^_gby� \kihfbgZ_lky� hkh[_ggh� keZ[h�� g_hij_^_e_ggh� b k� khfg_gb_f� ih� kjZ\g_gbx� k^jm]bfb�� [he__� ykgufb� we_f_glZfb�� Gh� p_gamjZ� j_^dh� ijhy\ey_lky� lZd� hldjh\_ggh�� lZd�ohl_ehkv�[u�kdZaZlv��gZb\gh���dZd�\ ijbf_j_�kgh\b^_gby�h ©ex[h\ghc�kem`[_ª��=hjZa^h�qZs_p_gamjZ�ijhy\ey_lky�ih�\lhjhfm�lbim��ih^klZ\eyy�iZ�f_klh�lh]h��qlh�^he`gh�[ulv��kfy]q_ggh_�ijb[ebabl_evgh_��gZf_dZxs__�Lj_lbc�kihkh[�^_ckl\by�p_gamju�g_evay�kjZ\gblv�k ijb_fZfb�]Za_lghc�p_gamju��gh�y fh]mijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv� _]h� gZ� m`_� ijhZgZebabjh\Zgghf� ijbf_j_� kgh\b^_gby�� <kihfgbl_kgh\b^_gb_� k ©lj_fy� iehobfb� [be_lZfb� \ l_Zlj� aZ� �� ne�� ��� dj�ª��< kdjuluo� fukeyo� wlh]hkgh\b^_gby�gZ�i_j\hf�f_kl_�[ue�we_f_gl�©ihki_rgh��kebrdhf�jZghª��Wlh�hagZqZeh�g_e_ih� [ueh� lZd� jZgh� \uoh^blv� aZfm`�� lZd`_� [_kkfuke_ggh� [ueh� ihdmiZlv� lZd� jZgh[be_lu� \ l_Zlj�� kf_rgh� [ueh� kh� klhjhgu� g_\_kldb� lZd� ihki_rgh� bkljZlblv� ^_gv]b� gZmdjZr_gby�� Hl� wlh]h� p_gljZevgh]h� we_f_glZ� kgh\b^_gby� gbq_]h� g_� hklZehkv� \ y\ghfkgh\b^_gbb�� \ g_f� p_glj� ly`_klb� i_j_f_klbeky� gZ� ihk_s_gb_� l_ZljZ� b ihdmidm� [be_lh\�;eZ]h^Zjy� wlhfm� kf_s_gbx� Zdp_glZ�� wlhc� i_j_]jmiibjh\d_� we_f_glh\� kh^_j`Zgby� y\gh_kgh\b^_gb_� klZgh\blky� gZklhevdh� g_ihoh`bf� gZ� kdjulu_� fukeb� kgh\b^_gby�� qlh� fu� b g_ih^haj_\Z_f� h gZebqbb� wlbo�ihke_^gbo� aZ�i_j\uf��Wlh� kf_s_gb_� Zdp_glZ� y\ey_lky� ]eZ\gufkj_^kl\hf� bkdZ`_gby� kgh\b^_gby� b ijb^Z_l� kgh\b^_gbx� lm� kljZgghklv�� ba�aZ� dhlhjhc\b^_\rbc�khg�kZf�g_�ohl_e�[u�ijbagZlv�_]h�aZ�kh[kl\_gguc�ijh^mdl�Ijhimkd�� fh^bnbdZpby�� i_j_]jmiibjh\dZ� fZl_jbZeZ� ²� lZdh\u� ^_ckl\by� p_gamjukgh\b^_gby�b kj_^kl\Z�_]h�bkdZ`_gby��KZfZ�p_gamjZ�kgh\b^_gby�y\ey_lky�ijbqbghc�beb�h^ghcba�ijbqbg�bkdZ`_gby�kgh\b^_gby��bamq_gb_f�dhlhjh]h�fu�l_i_jv� aZcf_fky��Fh^bnbdZpbx�bi_j_]jmiibjh\dm�fu�ijb\udeb�gZau\Zlv�©kf_s_gb_fª��9HUVFKLHEXQJ��

Page 74: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Ihke_� wlbo� aZf_qZgbc� h ^_ckl\bb� p_gamju� kgh\b^_gby� h[jZlbfky� d \hijhkm� h __^bgZfbaf_�� GZ^_xkv�� \u� g_� \hkijbgbfZ_l_� \ujZ`_gb_� kebrdhf� Zgljhihfhjngh� b g_ij_^klZ\ey_l_� k_[_� p_gahjZ� kgh\b^_gby� fZe_gvdbf� kljh]bf� q_eh\_qdhf� beb� ^mohf�ihk_eb\rbfky� \ fha]h\hf� `_em^hqd_� b hllm^Z� mijZ\eyxsbf� ^_eZfb�� gh� g_� k\yau\Z_l_� _]hlZd`_� b k� ijhkljZgkl\_gguf� ij_^klZ\e_gb_f� h dZdhf�lh� ©fha]h\hf� p_glj_ª�� hdZau\Zxs_flZdh_�p_gamjbjmx]p__�\ebygb_��dhlhjh_�ij_djZlbehkv�[u�k gZjmr_gb_f�beb�m^Ze_gb_f�wlh]hp_gljZ�� IhdZ� wlh� g_� [he__� q_f� \_kvfZ� m^h[guc� l_jfbg� ^ey� h[hagZq_gby� ^bgZfbq_kdh]hhlghr_gby��Wlh� keh\h� g_�f_rZ_l� gZf� aZ^Zlv� \hijhk�� dZdb_� l_g^_gpbb� b gZ� dZdb_� we_f_glukgh\b^_gby�hdZau\Zxl�wlh�\ebygb_��fu�g_�m^b\bfky�lZd`_��magZ\��qlh�jZgvr_�m`_�klZedb\Zebkvk p_gamjhc�kgh\b^_gby��fh`_l�[ulv��g_�magZ\�__�: wlh� [ueh� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� lZd�� <kihfgbl_�� k dZdbf� ihjZabl_evguf� nZdlhf� fu\klj_lbebkv��dh]^Z�gZqZeb�ijbf_gylv�gZrm�l_ogbdm�k\h[h^ghc�ZkkhpbZpbb��Fu�ihqm\kl\h\Zeblh]^Z��qlh�gZrb�mkbeby�i_j_clb�hl�we_f_glZ�kgh\b^_gby�d _]h�[_kkhagZl_evghfm��aZf_klbl_e_fdhlhjh]h� hg� y\ey_lky��gZlhedgmebkv�gZ� khijhlb\e_gb_��Fu� ]h\hjbeb�� qlh� wlh� khijhlb\e_gb_jZaebqZ_lky� ih� k\h_c� \_ebqbg_�� \ h^gbo� kemqZyo� hgh� h]jhfgh�� \ ^jm]bo� g_agZqbl_evgh�� <ihke_^g_f� kemqZ_� ^ey� jZ[hlu� lhedh\Zgby� gm`gh� [ueh� lhevdh� g_kdhevdh� ijhf_`mlhqguoa\_gv_\�� gh� _keb� hgh� [ueh� \_ebdh�� lh]^Z�fu� ^he`gu� [ueb� ZgZebabjh\Zlv� ^ebggu_� p_ihqdbZkkhpbZpbc�hl�we_f_glZ��^Ze_dh�moh^beb�[u�hl�g_]h�b \ugm`^_gu�[ueb�[u�ij_h^he_\Zlv�fgh]hljm^ghkl_c�\ \b^_�djblbq_kdbo�\hajZ`_gbc�ijhlb\�wlbo�ZkkhpbZpbc��Lh��qlh�ijb�lhedh\Zgbbijhy\ey_lky� dZd� khijhlb\e_gb_�� l_i_jv� \ jZ[hl_� kgh\b^_gby� \uklmiZ_l� _]h� p_gamjhc�Khijhlb\e_gb_�lhedh\Zgbx�²�wlh�lhevdh�h[t_dlb\Zpby�p_gamju�kgh\b^_gby��Hgh�^hdZau\Z_lgZf��qlh�kbeZ�p_gamju�g_�bkq_jiu\Z_lky�\g_k_gb_f�\ kgh\b^_gb_�bkdZ`_gby�b ihke_�wlh]h�g_m]ZkZ_l�� gh� qlh� hgZ� dZd� ihklhyggh� ^_ckl\mxsZy� kbeZ� ijh^he`Z_l� kms_kl\h\Zlv�� klj_fykvkhojZgblv�bkdZ`_gb_��DklZlb��dZd�b khijhlb\e_gb_�ijb�lhedh\Zgbb�dZ`^h]h�we_f_glZ�f_gy_lkyih�k\h_c�kbe_��lZd�b \g_k_ggh_�p_gamjhc�bkdZ`_gb_�\ h^ghf�b lhf�`_�kgh\b^_gbc�jZaebqgh�^eydZ`^h]h�we_f_glZ��?keb�kjZ\gblv�y\gh_�b kdjulh_�kgh\b^_gby��lh�h[gZjm`blky��qlh�hl^_evgu_kdjulu_�we_f_glu�iheghklvx�hlkmlkl\mxl��^jm]b_�[he__�beb�f_g__�fh^bnbpbjh\Zgu��Z lj_lvbhklZebkv�[_a�baf_g_gbc�b ^Z`_��fh`_l�[ulv��mkbe_gu�\ y\ghf�kh^_j`Zgbb�kgh\b^_gby�Gh�fu�kh[bjZebkv�bkke_^h\Zlv��dZdb_�l_g^_gpbb�hkms_kl\eyxl�p_gamjm�b ijhlb\�q_]h�hgZgZijZ\e_gZ��GZ�wlhl�\hijhk��bf_xsbc�\Z`g_cr__�agZq_gb_�^ey�ihgbfZgby�kgh\b^_gby�b ^Z`_�fh`_l� [ulv�� \k_c� `bagb� q_eh\_dZ�� e_]dh� hl\_lblv�� _keb� ijhkfhlj_lv� jy^� bklhedh\Zgguokgh\b^_gbc��L_g^_gpbb��hkms_kl\eyxsb_�p_gamjm�²�l_��dhlhju_�ijbagZxlky�\b^_\rbf�khg�\[h^jkl\mxs_f�khklhygbb��k dhlhjufb�hg�kh]eZk_g��;m^vl_�m\_j_gu��qlh�_keb�\u�hldZau\Z_l_kvhl� \iheg_� ijZ\bevgh]h� lhedh\Zgby� kh[kl\_ggh]h� kgh\b^_gby�� lh� \u� ihklmiZ_l_� ih� l_f� `_fhlb\Zf�� ih� dhlhjuf� ^_ckl\h\ZeZ� p_gamjZ� kgh\b^_gby�� ijhbahreh� bkdZ`_gb_� b klZehg_h[oh^bfh�lhedh\Zgb_��<kihfgbl_�h kgh\b^_gbb�gZr_c����e_lg_c�^Zfu��;_a�lhedh\Zgby�hgZkqblZ_l�_]h�hl\jZlbl_evguf��[ueZ�[u�_s_�[hevr_�\hafms_gZ��_keb�[u�^�j nhg�=m]�=_eevfmlkhh[sZeZ� _c� qlh�lh� g_h[oh^bfh_� ^ey� lhedh\Zgby�� b bf_ggh� ba�aZ� wlh]h� hkm`^_gby� \ __kgh\b^_gbb�kZfu_�g_ijbebqgu_�f_klZ�aZf_g_gu�[hjfhlZgb_f�H^gZdh� l_g^_gpbb�� ijhlb\� dhlhjuo� gZijZ\e_gZ� p_gamjZ� kgh\b^_gbyª� ke_^mv]� kgZqZeZhibkZlv� ih� hlghr_gbx� d wlhc� ihke_^g_c�� Lh]^Z� fh`gh� lhevdh� kdZaZlv�� qlh� hgb� ih� k\h_c

Page 75: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijbjh^_�[_amkeh\gh�^hklhcgu�hkm`^_gby��g_ijbebqgu�\ wlbq_kdhf��wkl_lbq_kdhf��khpbZevghfhlghr_gbb��wlh�y\e_gby��h dhlhjuo�g_�kf_xl�^mfZlv�beb�^mfZxl�lhevdh�k hl\jZs_gb_f��Wlbhl\_j]gmlu_� p_gamjhc� b gZr_^rb_� \ kgh\b^_gbb� bkdZ`_ggh_� \ujZ`_gb_� `_eZgby� y\eyxlkyij_`^_� \k_]h� ijhy\e_gb_f� [_a]jZgbqgh]h� b [_kihsZ^gh]h� w]hbafZ�� B ^_ckl\bl_evgh�kh[kl\_ggh_�Y ihy\ey_lky� \ ex[hf� kgh\b^_gbb�b b]jZ_l� \ g_f� ]eZ\gmx� jhev��^Z`_� _keb� wlhmf_eh� kdjulh� \ y\ghf� kh^_j`Zgbb�� Wlhl� ©VDFUR� HJRLVPR� ª� kgh\b^_gby�� dhg_qgh�� k\yaZg� kmklZgh\dhc�gZ�khg��dhlhjZy�khklhbl�\ iZ^_gbb�bgl_j_kZ�dh�\k_fm�\g_rg_fm�fbjm�K\h[h^gh_� hl� \k_o� wlbq_kdbo� ma� Y b^_l� gZ\klj_qm� \k_f� ijblyaZgbyf� k_dkmZevgh]h\e_q_gby��\ lhf�qbke_�b lZdbf��dhlhju_�^Z\gh�hkm`^_gu�gZrbf�wkl_lbq_kdbf�\hkiblZgb_f�bijhlb\hj_qZl�\k_f�wlbq_kdbf�h]jZgbqbl_evguf�lj_[h\Zgbyf��Klj_fe_gb_�d m^h\hevkl\bx�²eb[b^h��/LELGR���dZd�fu�]h\hjbf�²�[_kij_iylkl\_ggh�\u[bjZ_l�k\hb�h[t_dlu�b hohlg__�\k_]hbf_ggh�aZij_lgu_��G_�lhevdh�`_gm�^jm]h]h��gh�ij_`^_�\k_]h�bg�p_klmhagu_��k\ylh�hojZgy_fu_q_eh\_q_kdbf�h[s_kl\hf�h[t_dlu��fZlv�b k_kljm�kh�klhjhgu�fm`qbgu��hlpZ�b [jZlZ�kh�klhjhgu`_gsbgu�� �Kgh\b^_gb_� gZr_c� ���e_lg_c� ^Zfu� lh`_� bgp_klmhagh�� __ eb[b^h�� g_khfg_ggh�gZijZ\e_gh� gZ� kugZ��� <h`^_e_gby�� dhlhju_� dZ`mlky� gZf� qm`^ufb� q_eh\_q_kdhc� ijbjh^_�hdZau\Zxlky�^hklZlhqgh�kbevgufb��qlh[u�\ua\Zlv�kgh\b^_gby��;_am^_j`gh�fh`_l�ijhy\eylvkylZd`_�g_gZ\bklv��@_eZgby�f_klb�b kf_jlb�kZfuf�[ebadbf�b ex[bfuf�\ `bagb�²�jh^bl_eyf�[jZlvyf�b k_kljZf��kmijm]m�beb�kmijm]_��kh[kl\_gguf�^_lyf�²�g_�y\eyxlky�gbq_f�g_h[uqguf�Wlb� hl\_j]gmlu_� p_gamjhc� `_eZgby� dZd� [m^lh� [u� ih^gbfZxlky� ba� gZklhys_]h� Z^Z�� \[h^jkl\mxs_f�khklhygbb�ihke_ �K\ys_gguc�w]hbaf�²�Ijbf_q��i_j�lhedh\Zgby�gbdZdZy�p_gamjZ�ijhlb\�gbo�g_�dZ`_lky�gZf�^hklZlhqgh�kljh]hc�Gh�g_�klZ\vl_�wlh�kljZrgh_�kh^_j`Zgb_�\ \bgm�kZfhfm�kgh\b^_gbx��G_�aZ[u\Zcl_��qlh�hghbf__l� [_ah[b^gmx�� ^Z`_� ihe_agmx� nmgdpbx� h]jZ^blv� khg� hl� gZjmr_gby�� LZdZy� gbahklv� g_bf__l�hlghr_gby�d kmsghklb�kgh\b^_gby��<u�\_^v�agZ_l_�lZd`_��qlh�_klv�kgh\b^_gby��dhlhju_�ke_^m_l�ijbagZlv��m^h\e_l\hjyxl�hijZ\^Zggu_�`_eZgby�b gZkmsgu_�nbabq_kdb_�ihlj_[ghklb�Gh�\ wlbo� kgh\b^_gbyo�g_l�bkdZ`_gby��hgb�\ g_f�g_�gm`^Zxlky��hgb�fh]ml�\uihegylv� k\hxnmgdpbx��g_�hkdhj[eyy�wlbq_kdbo�b wkl_lbq_kdbo�l_g^_gpbc Y��Ijbfbl_�lZd`_�\h�\gbfZgb_�qlh�bkdZ`_gb_�kgh\b^_gby�aZ\bkbl�hl�^\mo�nZdlhjh\��K h^ghc�klhjhgu��hgh�l_f�[hevr_��q_fom`_� hl\_j]Z_fh_� p_gamjhc� `_eZgb_�� gh� k ^jm]hc� ²� q_f� kljh`_� \ wlh� \j_fy� lj_[h\Zgbyp_gamju��Ihwlhfm�m fheh^hc��kljh]h�\hkiblZgghc��s_i_lbevghc�^_\mrdb�g_mfhebfZy�p_gamjZbkdZabl� ih[m`^_gby� kgh\b^_gby�� dhlhju_�� gZijbf_j�� fu�� \jZqb�� kqblZ_f� ^ha\he_ggufb�[_ah[b^gufb�eb[b^hagufb�`_eZgbyfb�b dhlhju_�hgZ�kZfZ�^_kylv�e_l�kimkly�khql_l�lZdbfb�`_�<ijhq_f�� fu� _s_� ^Ze_db� hl� lh]h�� qlh[u� \hafmsZlvky� wlbf� j_amevlZlhf� gZr_]hlhedh\Zgby��Y iheZ]Zx��qlh�fu�_]h�_s_�g_^hklZlhqgh�ohjhrh�ihgbfZ_f��gh�ij_`^_�\k_]h�i_j_^gZfb� klhbl� aZ^ZqZ� aZsblblv� _]h� hl� ba\_klguo� gZiZ^hd�� Kh\k_f� g_ljm^gh� gZclb� ^ey� wlh]haZp_idm�� GZrb� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc� ijhba\h^bebkv� k mq_lhf� h[ty\e_gguo� aZjZg__ij_^iheh`_gbc��qlh� kgh\b^_gb_�\hh[s_�bf__l� kfuke��qlh�[_kkhagZl_evgu_� \ dZdh_�lh� \j_fy^mr_\gu_�ijhp_kku�kms_kl\mxl�g_�lhevdh�ijb�]bighlbq_kdhf��gh�b ijb�ghjfZevghf�kg_�b qlh\k_�\hagbdZxsb_�ih�ih\h^m�kgh\b^_gby�fukeb�^_l_jfbgbjh\Zgu��?keb�[u�gZ�hkgh\Zgbb�wlbo

Page 76: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ij_^iheh`_gbc�fu�ijbreb� d ijb_fe_fuf� j_amevlZlZf� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc�� lh�ih�ijZ\mfh]eb� [u� aZdexqblv�� qlh� wlb� ij_^iheh`_gby� ijZ\bevgu��Gh� dZd� [ulv�� _keb� wlb� j_amevlZlu\u]ey^yl� lZd�� dZd� lhevdh� qlh� hibkZggu_"� Lh]^Z� fh`gh� [ueh� [u� kdZaZlv�� wlh� g_\hafh`gu_�[_kkfuke_ggu_� j_amevlZlu�� ih� f_gvr_c� f_j_�� hgb� \_kvfZ� g_\_jhylgu�� lZd� qlh� \ij_^iheh`_gbyo� [ueh� qlh�lh� g_ijZ\bevgh��Beb� kgh\b^_gb_� g_� ikbobq_kdbc�n_ghf_g�� beb� \ghjfZevghf�khklhygbb�g_l�gbq_]h�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��beb�gZrZ�l_ogbdZ�\ q_f�lh�g_kh\_jr_ggZ�G_�ijhs_�b g_�ijbylg__�eb�ij_^iheh`blv�wlh��q_f�ijbagZlv�\k_�l_�f_jahklb��dhlhju_�fu�[m^lh[u�hldjueb�gZ�hkgh\Zgbb�gZrbo�ij_^iheh`_gbc"B lh��b ^jm]h_��B ijhs_��b ijbylg__��gh�ba�aZ�wlh]h�g_�h[yaZl_evgh�ijZ\bevg__��G_�[m^_fki_rblv��\hijhk�_s_�g_�j_r_g��Ij_`^_�\k_]h��fu�fh`_f�mkbeblv�djblbdm�gZrbo�lhedh\Zgbckgh\b^_gbc��Lh��qlh�bo�j_amevlZlu�lZd�g_ijbylgu�b g_Zii_lblgu��fh`_l�[ulv��_s_�g_�kZfh_om^r__��;he__�kbevguf�Zj]mf_glhf�y\ey_lky�lh��qlh�\b^_\rb_�khg�j_rbl_evg_crbf�h[jZahf�bk iheguf� hkgh\Zgb_f� h�\_j]Zxl� `_eZgby�� dhlhju_� fu� bf� ijbibku\Z_f� [eZ]h^Zjy� gZr_fmlhedh\Zgbx�� ©Qlh"�²� ]h\hjbl�h^bg�²�Hkgh\u\Zykv�gZ� kgh\b^_gbb�� \u� ohlbl_�^hdZaZlv��qlhfg_�`Zev�^_g_]�gZ�ijb^Zgh_�k_klju�b \hkiblZgb_�[jZlZ"�Gh�\_^v�wlh]h�g_�fh`_l�[ulv��y lhevdh^ey�gbo�b jZ[hlZx��m f_gy�g_l�^jm]bo�bgl_j_kh\�\ `bagb��djhf_�\uiheg_gby�fh_]h�^he]Z�i_j_^gbfb�²�dZd�klZjrbc��y h[_sZe�wlh�ihdhcghc�fZl_jbª��Beb�^ZfZ��\b^_\rZy�khg�� ]h\hjbl�� ©Y`_eZx� kf_jlb� k\h_fm� fm`m�� >Z� \_^v� wlh� \hafmlbl_evgZy� g_e_ihklv�� <u� fg_�� \_jhylgh�� g_ih\_jbl_��qlh�m gZk�g_�lhevdh�kZfuc�kqZkleb\uc�[jZd��gh�_]h�kf_jlv�hlgyeZ�[u�m f_gy�\k_��qlh�ybf_x�\ `bagbª��Beb�lj_lbc�\hajZabl�gZf��©Y ^he`_g�bkiulu\Zlv�qm\kl\_ggu_�`_eZgby�d k\h_ck_klj_"�Wlh�kf_rgh��y gZ�g__�g_�h[jZsZx�gbdZdh]h�\gbfZgby��m gZk�iehob_�hlghr_gby�^jm]�k^jm]hf��b y�\ l_q_gb_�fgh]bo�e_l�g_�h[f_gyeky�k g_c�gb�keh\hfª��Fu�fh]eb�[u�k e_]dhklvxhlg_klbkv� d lhfm�� qlh� \b^_\rb_� khg� g_� ih^l\_j`^Zxl� beb� hljbpZxl� ijbibku\Z_fu_� bfgZf_j_gby��fu�fh]eb�[u�kdZaZlv��qlh�bf_ggh�h[� wlbo�\_sZo�hgb�b g_� agZxl��Gh� lh��qlh�hgbqm\kl\mxl� \ k_[_� dZd� jZa� ijhlb\hiheh`gh_� lhfm� `_eZgbx�� dhlhjh_� ijbibku\Z_l� bflhedh\Zgb_��b fh]ml�^hdZaZlv�gZf�ij_h[eZ^Zgb_�wlh]h�ijhlb\hiheh`gh]h�k\hbf�h[jZahf�`bagb�wlh�gZk�gZdhg_p�haZ^Zqb\Z_l��G_�[jhkblv�eb�l_i_jv�\kx�wlm�jZ[hlm�ih�lhedh\Zgbx�kgh\b^_gbc�ihkdhevdm�__ j_amevlZlu�\jh^_�[u�b ijb\_eb�d Z[kmj^m�G_l��\k_�_s_�g_l��B wlhl�[he__�kbevguc�Zj]mf_gl�hdZ`_lky�g_khklhyl_evguf��_keb�d g_fmih^hclb�djblbq_kdb��Ij_^iheh`_gb_��qlh�\ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb�_klv�[_kkhagZl_evgu_�l_g^_gpbb�_s_�g_�^hdZaZl_evkl\h��qlh�ijhlb\hiheh`gu_�bf�y\eyxlky�]hkih^kl\mxsbfb�\ khagZl_evghc`bagb��<hafh`gh�� qlh� \ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb� _klv� f_klh� ^ey� ijhlb\hiheh`guo� l_g^_gpbc�� ^eyijhlb\hj_qbc�� dhlhju_� kms_kl\mxl� jy^hf� ^jm]� k ^jm]hf�� \hafh`gh� ^Z`_�� qlh� dZd� jZaij_h[eZ^Zgb_� h^gh]h� ih[m`^_gby� y\ey_lky� mkeh\b_f� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� kms_kl\h\Zgby� _]hijhlb\hiheh`ghklb�� BlZd�� \u^\bgmlu_� \gZqZe_� \hajZ`_gby�� qlh� j_amevlZlu� lhedh\Zgbykgh\b^_gbc�g_�ijhklu�b hq_gv�g_ijbylgu��hklZxlky�\ kbe_��GZ�i_j\h_�fh`gh�\hajZablv��qlh�f_qlZy� h ijhklhl_�� \u� g_� kfh`_l_� j_rblv� gb h^ghc� ijh[e_fu� kgh\b^_gby�� \u� ^he`guijbfbjblvky�k ij_^iheZ]Z_fhc�keh`ghklvx�hlghr_gbc��: gZ�\lhjh_�²�qlh�\u�y\gh�g_�ijZ\u�bkihevamy� \ dZq_kl\_� h[hkgh\Zgby� ^ey� gZmqgh]h� km`^_gby� bkiulu\Z_fh_� \Zfb� qm\kl\hm^h\hevkl\by�beb�hl\jZs_gby��Qlh�gZf�aZ�^_eh�^h�lh]h��qlh�j_amevlZlu�lhedh\Zgby�dZ`mlky�\Zfg_ijbylgufb��^Z`_�ihahjgufb�b ijhlb\gufb"�KZ QHPSHFKH�SDV�GH[LVWHU� �²�keurZe�y \�lZdbokemqZyo� fheh^uf� \jZqhf� hl� k\h_]h� mqbl_ey� RZjdh�� Ijboh^blky� kfbjblvky� kh� k\hbfb

Page 77: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kbfiZlbyfb�b ZglbiZlbyfb��_keb�ohq_rv� agZlv��qlh�\ wlhf�fbj_�j_Zevgh��?keb�dZdhc�gb[m^vnbabd�^hdZ`_l�\Zf��qlh�\ kdhjhf�[m^ms_f�hj]Zgbq_kdZy�`bagv�gZ�a_fe_�ij_djZlblky��ihkf__l_eb�\u�_fm�\hajZablv��wlh]h�gZ�fh`_l�[ulv��wlZ�i_jki_dlb\Z�kebrdhf�g_ijbylgZ"�Y ^mfZx��qlh\u� ijhfheqbl_� beb� ih^h`^_l_�� ihdZ� y\blky� ^jm]hc� nbabd� b mdZ`_l� gZ� hrb[dm� \ _]hij_^iheh`_gbyo�beb�jZkq_lZo��?keb�\u�hlkljZgy_l_�hl�k_[y�lh��qlh�\Zf�g_ijbylgh��lh�\u��ihf_gvr_c�f_j_��^_ckl\m_l_��dZd�f_oZgbaf�h[jZah\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby��\f_klh� lh]h�qlh[u�ihgylv_]h�b h\eZ^_lv�bf�Fh`_l� [ulv�� \u� kh]eZkbl_kv� lh]^Z� g_� h[jZsZlv� \gbfZgby� gZ� hl\jZlbl_evguc� oZjZdl_jhl\_j]gmluo� p_gamjhc� `_eZgbc�� Z \u^\bg_l_� ^h\h^�� qlh� ijhklh� g_\_jhylgh�� qlh[u� \dhgklblmpbb� q_eh\_dZ� klhevdh� f_klZ� aZgbfZeh� aeh�� Gh� ^Z_l� eb� \Zf� \Zr� hiul� ijZ\h� lZd]h\hjblv"�Y g_�ohqm�]h� �Wlh�g_�f_rZ_l�lhfm��qlh[u�[ueh�lZd��njZgp�����Ijbf_q��i_j�\hjblv�h lhf��dZdbfb�\u�dZ`_l_kv�kZfb�k_[_��gh�fgh]h�eb�\u�gZreb�[eZ]hkdehgghklb�mk\h_]h�gZqZevkl\Z�b dhgdmj_glh\��fgh]h�eb�jupZjkl\Z�m k\hbo�\jZ]h\�b fZeh�eb�aZ\bklb�\ k\h_fh[s_kl\_�� qlh[u� qm\kl\h\Zlv� k_[y� h[yaZgguf� \uklmiZlv� ijhlb\� w]hbklbq_kdb� aeh]h� \q_eh\_q_kdhc�ijbjh^_"�JZa\_�\Zf�g_ba\_klgh��dZd�iehoh�\eZ^__l�kh[hc�b dZd�fZeh�aZkem`b\Z_l^h\_jby� kj_^gbc� q_eh\_d� \h� \k_o� h[eZklyo� k_dkmZevghc� `bagb"� Beb� \u� g_� agZ_l_�� qlh� \k_aehmihlj_[e_gby� b [_kqbgkl\Z�� dhlhju_� gZf� kgylky� ghqvx�� _`_^g_\gh� kh\_jrZxlky[h^jkl\mxsbfb� ex^vfb� dZd� ^_ckl\bl_evgu_� ij_klmie_gby"� < ^Zgghf� kemqZ_� ikbohZgZebalhevdh� ih^l\_j`^Z_l� klZjh_� baj_q_gb_� IeZlhgZ�� qlh� ^h[jufb� y\eyxlky� l_�� dhlhju_^h\hevkl\mxlky�kgh\b^_gbyfb�h lhf��qlh�aeu_�^_eZxl�\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�: l_i_jv� hl\e_dbl_kv� hl� bg^b\b^mZevgh]h� b i_j_g_kbl_� k\hc� \ahj� gZ� \_ebdmx� \hcgm�dhlhjZy� \k_� _s_� himklhrZ_l� ?\jhim�� ih^mfZcl_� h [_a]jZgbqghc� `_klhdhklb�� k\bj_ihklb� be`b\hklb�� dhlhju_� k_cqZk�rbjhdh� jZkijhkljZgbebkv� \ dmevlmjghf� fbj_�� <u� ^_ckl\bl_evgh^mfZ_l_��qlh�dmqd_�[_kkh\_klguo�dZjv_jbklh\�b kh[eZagbl_e_c�m^Zehkv�[u�k^_eZlv�klhevdh�aeZ�_keb�[u�fbeebhgu�b^msbo�aZ�\h`ZdZfb�g_�[ueb�khmqZklgbdZfb�ij_klmie_gby"�J_rbl_kv�eb�\ub ijb�wlbo�mkeh\byo�ehfZlv�dhivy�aZ�bkdexq_gb_�aeh]h�ba�^mr_\ghc�dhgklblmpbb�q_eh\_dZ"��<u�fg_�\hajZabl_��qlh�y h^ghklhjhgg_�km`m�h \hcg_��hgZ�h[gZjm`beZ�kZfh_�ij_djZkgh_�b[eZ]hjh^gh_�\ ex^yo��bo�]_jhckl\h��kZfhhl\_h�`_gghklv��khpbZevgh_�qm\kl\h��Dhg_qgh��gh�g_[m^vl_�klhev�`_�g_kijZ\_^eb\u�d ikbohZgZebam��dZd�l_��dlh�mij_dZ_l�_]h�\ lhf��qlh�hg�hljbpZ_lh^gh�� qlh[u� ml\_j`^Zlv� ^jm]h_�� Fu� g_� kh[bjZebkv� hljbpZlv� [eZ]hjh^gu_� klj_fe_gbyq_eh\_q_kdhc�ijbjh^u�b gbq_]h�gbdh]^Z�g_�^_eZeb��qlh[u�mfZeblv�bo�agZqbfhklv��GZijhlb\��yihdZau\Zx� \Zf� g_� lhevdh� hl\_j]gmlu_� p_gamjhc� aeu_� `_eZgby� kgh\b^_gby�� gh� b p_gamjm�dhlhjZy� bo� ih^Z\ey_l� b ^_eZ_l� g_magZ\Z_fufb�� Fu� ih^q_jdb\Z_f� aeh_� \ q_eh\_d_� lhevdhihlhfm��qlh�^jm]b_�hljbpZxl�_]h��hlq_]h�^mr_\gZy�`bagv�q_eh\_dZ�klZgh\blky�ohly�g_�emqr_�gh�g_ihgylg__��?keb�fu�hldZ`_fky�hl�h^ghklhjhgg_c� wlbq_kdhc�hp_gdb�� lh��dhg_qgh��fh`_fgZclb�[he__�ijZ\bevgmx�nhjfm�khhlghr_gby�aeh]h�b ^h[jh]h�\ q_eh\_q_kdhc�ijbjh^_�BlZd��\k_�hklZ_lky�ih�ij_`g_fm��GZf�g_�gm`gh�hldZau\Zlvky�hl�j_amevlZlh\�gZr_c�jZ[hluih�lhedh\Zgbx�kgh\b^_gbc��ohly�hgb�b dZ`mlky�gZf�kljZggufb��: ihdZ�aZihfgbf��bkdZ`_gb_kgh\b^_gby�y\ey_lky�ke_^kl\b_f�p_gamju��dhlhjZy�hkms_kl\ey_lky�ijbagZggufb�l_g^_gpbyfb

Page 78: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Y ijhlb\�g_ijbebqguo�ih[m`^_gbc��r_\_eysboky�\ gZk�ghqvx�\h�\j_fy�kgZ��IjZ\^Z��ihq_fmghqvx� b hldm^Z� [_jmlky� wlb� g_^hklhcgu_� `_eZgby�� \ wlhf� _s_� fgh]h� g_ihgylgh]h�� qlhij_^klhbl�bkke_^h\Zlv�Gh�k gZr_c�klhjhgu�[ueh�[u�g_kijZ\_^eb\h��_keb�[u�fu�g_�\u^_ �ebeb�\ ^hklZlhqghcf_j_�^jm]hc�j_amevlZl�wlbo�bkke_^h\Zgbc��@_eZgby�kgh\b^_gby��dhlhju_�gZjmrZxl�gZr�khg�gZf�g_ba\_klgu��fu�magZ_f�h gbo�lhevdh�ba�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc��bo�fh`gh�ihwlhfm�gZa\Zlv[_kkhagZl_evgufb�\ ^Zggh_�\j_fy�\ mdZaZgghf�\ur_�kfuke_��<b^_\rbc�khg�hl\_j]Z_l�bo��dZdfu�\b^_eb�\h�fgh]bo�kemqZyo��ihke_�lh]h�dZd�magZe�h gbo�[eZ]h^Zjy�lhedh\Zgbx��Ih\lhjy_lkykemqZc�� k dhlhjuf� fu� \klj_lbebkv� ijb� lhedh\Zgbb� h]h\hjdb� ©DXIVWRHQª�� dh]^Z� hjZlhj\hafms_ggh� m\_jye�� qlh� gb lh]^Z�� gb� dh]^Z�eb[h� jZgvr_� hg� g_� bkiulu\Ze� g_ihqlbl_evgh]hqm\kl\Z�d k\h_fm�r_nm��M`_�lh]^Z�fu�khfg_\Zebkv�\ lZdhf�aZ\_j_gbb�b \u^\bgmeb�\f_klh�g_]hij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh� hjZlhj� ^he]h� gbq_]h� g_� agZe� h[� bf_xs_fky� qm\kl\_�� L_i_jv� wlhih\lhjy_lky�ijb�\kydhf�lhedh\Zgbb�kbevgh�bkdZ`_ggh]h�kgh\b^_gby�b l_f�kZfuf�ijbh[j_lZ_l[hevrh_� agZq_gb_�^ey�ih^l\_j`^_gby�gZr_c� lhqdb� aj_gby��Fu� ]hlh\u� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� \^mr_\ghc�`bagb�_klv�ijhp_kku��l_g^_gpbb��h dhlhjuo�q_eh\_d�\hh[s_�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_l��hq_gv^Z\gh�gbq_]h�g_� agZ_l�� \hafh`gh�� gbdh]^Z� gbq_]h�g_� agZe��;eZ]h^Zjy� wlhfm� [_kkhagZl_evgh_ihemqZ_l� ^ey� gZk� gh\uc� kfuke�� ihgylb_� ©\ ^Zggh_� \j_fyª� beb� ©\j_f_gghª� bkq_aZ_l� ba� _]hkmsghklb�� hgh� fh`_l� lZd`_� hagZqZlv� ^ebl_evgh� [_kkhagZl_evgh_�� Z g_� lhevdh� ©kdjulh_� gZ^Zggh_�\j_fyª��H[�wlhf�gZf��dhg_qgh��lh`_�ijb^_lky�ih]h\hjblv�\ ^jm]hc�jZa�>?KYL:Y�E?DPBYKbf\hebdZ�kgh\b^_gbyM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b xkih^Z��Fu� m[_^bebkv��qlh�bkdZ`_gb_�� dhlhjh_�f_rZ_l�gZf�ihgylvkgh\b^_gb_��y\ey_lky�ke_^kl\b_f�^_yl_evghklb�p_gamju��gZijZ\e_gghc�ijhlb\�g_ijb_fe_fuo�[_kkhagZl_evguo�`_eZgbc��Gh�fu��dhg_qgh��g_�ml\_j`^Z_f��qlh�p_gamjZ�y\ey_lky�_^bgkl\_ggufnZdlhjhf�� \uau\Zxsbf� bkdZ`_gb_� kgh\b^_gby�� b \� ^Zevg_cr_f� fu� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� fh`©fmklZgh\blv��qlh�\ wlhf�bkdZ`_gbb�mqZkl\mxl�b ^jm]b_�fhf_glu��Wlbf�fu�ohlbf�kdZaZlv��qlh_keb�p_gamjm�kgh\b^_gby�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�bkdexqblv��fu�\k_�jZ\gh�[ueb�[u�g_�\ khklhygbbihgylv�kgh\b^_gby��y\gh_�kgh\b^_gb_�g_�[ueh�[u�b^_glbqgh�kdjuluf�_]h�fukeyf�Wlhl� ^jm]hc� fhf_gl�� aZl_fgyxsbc� kgh\b^_gb_�� wlhl� gh\uc� nZdlhj� _]h� bkdZ`_gby� fuhldjh_f�� _keb� h[jZlbf� \gbfZgb_� gZ� batyg� gZr_c� l_ogbdb� Y m`_� ijbagZ\Zeky� \Zf�� qlhZgZebabjm_fuf� bgh]^Z� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� gb� q_]h� g_� ijboh^bl� \ ]heh\m� ih� ih\h^m� hl^_evguowe_f_glh\�kgh\b^_gby�IjZ\^Z��wlh�ijhbkoh^bl�g_�lZd�qZklh��dZd�hgb�ml\_j`^Zxl��\ hq_gv�fgb]bo�kemqZyo�ijb�gZklhcqb\hklb�fukev�\k_�lZdb�fh`gh�aZklZ\blv�ihy\blvky��Gh�[u\Zxl��h^gZdh�kemqZb��\ dhlhjuo�ZkkhpbZpby�g_�ihemqZ_lky�beb��_keb�__ \ugm^blv��hgZ�g_�^Z_l�lh]h��qlh�fu�hlg__� h`b^Z_f�� ?keb� wlb� ijhbkoh^bl� \h� \j_fy� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h� e_q_gby�� lh� ijbh[j_lZ_lhkh[h_� agZq_gb_�� h q_f� fu� g_� [m^_f� a^_kv� ]h\hjblv�� Gh� wlh� kemqZ_lky� b ijb� lhedh\Zgbbkgh\b^_gbc�m ghjfZevguo�ex^_c�beb�ijb� lhedh\Zgbb�k\hbo�kh[kl\_gguo� kgh\b^_gbc��Dh]^Z\b^brv�� qlh� gbdZdZy� gZklhcqb\hklv� g_� ihfh]Z_l�� lh� \ dhgp_� dhgph\� m[_`^Z_rvky�� qlh

Page 79: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_`_eZl_evgZy�kemqZcghklv�j_]meyjgh�ih\lhjy_lky�ijb�hij_^_e_gguo�we_f_glZo�kgh\b^_gby��blh]^Z� gZqbgZ_rv� \b^_lv� gh\mx� aZdhghf_jghklv� lZf�� ]^_� kgZqZeZ� ij_^iheZ]Ze� lhevdhg_khklhyl_evghklv�l_ogbdb�< lZdbo� kemqZyo� \hagbdZ_l� kh[eZag� kZfhfm� bklhedh\Zlv� wlb� ©g_fu_ª� we_f_glukgh\b^_gby��ij_^ijbgbfZ_rv�bo�i_j_\h^ �2EHUVHW]XQJ��kh[kl\_ggufb�kj_^kl\Zfb��KZfh�kh[hcihemqZ_lky�� qlh� _keb� ^h\_jblvky� lZdhfm� aZf_s_gbx�� dZ`^uc� jZa� gZoh^brv� ^ey� kgh\b^_gby\iheg_�m^h\e_l\hjyx�sbc�kfuke��Z ^h�l_o�ihj��ihdZ�g_�j_rbrvky�gZ�wlhl�ijb_f��kgh\b^_gb_hklZ_lky� [_kkfuke_gguf� b _]h� k\yaghklv� gZjmrZ_lky�� Ih\lhj_gb_� fgh]b_� qj_a\uqZcghihoh`bo�kemqZ_\�ijb^Z_l�gZr_c�\gZqZe_�jh[dhc�ihiuld_�g_h[oh^bfmx�m\_j_gghklv�Y baeZ]Zx�\k_�g_kdhevdh�ko_fZlbqgh��gh�wlh�\iheg_�^himklbfh�\ ^b^Zdlbq_kdbo�p_eyo��bfh_�baeh`_gb_�g_�nZevkbnbdZpby��Z g_dhlhjh_�mijhs_gb_�LZdbf�h[jZahf�^ey�p_eh]h�jy^Z�we_f_glh\�kgh\b^_gbc�ihemqZ_rv�h^gb�b l_�`_�i_j_\h^u�ih^h[gh� l_f�� dZdb_� fh`gh� gZclb� \ gZrbo� ihimeyjguo� khggbdZo� ^ey� \k_\hafh`guoijbkgb\rboky�\_s_c��H^gZdh�g_�aZ[u\Zcl_��qlh�ijb�gZr_c�ZkkhpbZlb\ghc�l_ogbd_�ihklhyggu_aZf_s_gby�we_f_glh\�kgh\b^_gby�gbdh]^Z�g_�\klj_qZebkv�<u�kjZam�`_�\hajZabl_��qlh� wlhl�imlv� lhedh\Zgby�dZ`_lky�\Zf� _s_�[he__�g_gZ^_`guf�bkihjguf��q_f�ij_`gbc�ihkj_^kl\hf�k\h[h^guo�ZkkhpbZpbc��Gh�a^_kv�ke_^m_l�dh_�qlh�^h[Z\blv�Dh]^Z� [eZ]h^Zjy� hiulm� gZdZieb\Z_lky� ^hklZlhqgh� lZdbo� ihklhygguo� aZf_s_gbc�� gZqbgZ_rvihgbfZlv�� qlh� wlh� qZklbqgh_� lhedh\Zgb_� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� \hafh`gh� bkoh^y� ba� kh[kl\_gguoagZgbc��qlh�we_f_glu�kgh\b^_gby�^_ckl\bl_evgh�fh`gh�ihgylv�[_a�>bkihevah\Zgby@�ZkkhpbZpbb\b^_\r_]h� khg��DZdbf� h[jZahf�fh`gh� magZlv� bo� agZq_gb_�� h[� wlhf� [m^_l� kdZaZgh� \h� \lhjhcqZklb�gZr_]h�baeh`_gby�Wlh�ihklhyggh_�hlghr_gb_�f_`^m� we_f_glhf� kgh\b^_gby�b _]h�i_j_\h^hf�fu�gZau\Z_fkbf\hebq_kdbf� �V\PEROLVFKH��� kZf� we_f_gl� kgh\b^_gby� kbf\hehf� �6\PERO�� [_kkhagZl_evghcfukeb�kgh\b^_gby��<u�ihfgbl_��qlh�jZgvr_�ijb�bkke_^h\Zgbb�hlghr_gbc�f_`^m�we_f_glZfbkgh\b^_gby�b _]h�kh[kl\_gguf� >kh^_j`Zgb_f@�y \u^_ebe�ljb�\b^Z�lZdbo�hlghr_gbc��qZklb�hlp_eh]h��gZf_dZ�b h[jZagh]h�ij_^klZ\e_gby��H q_l\_jlhf� y lh]^Z�mihfygme��gh�g_�gZa\Ze� _]h�<\_^_ggh_�a^_kv�kbf\hebq_kdh_�hlghr_gb_�y\ey_lky�wlbf�q_l\_jluf��Ih�ih\h^m�g_]h�bf_xlkyhq_gv�bgl_j_kgu_�khh[jZ`_gby��d dhlhjuf�fu�h[jZlbfky��ij_`^_�q_f�ijbklmibf�d baeh`_gbxgZrbo� ki_pbZevguo� gZ[ex^_gbc� gZ^� kbf\hebdhc�� Kbf\hebdZ�� fh`_l� [ulv�� kZfZyijbf_qZl_evgZy�qZklv�\ l_hjbb�kgh\b^_gby�Ij_`^_� \k_]h�� \\b^m� lh]h� qlh� kbf\heu� bf_xl� mklhy\rb_ky� i_j_\h^u�� hgb� \ ba\_klghcf_j_�j_Zebamxl�b^_Ze�Zglbqgh]h�b ihimeyjgh]h�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc��hl�dhlhjh]h�fu�ijbgZr_c� l_ogbd_� lZd� ^Ze_dh� mreb� Hgb� iha\heyxl� gZf� bgh]^Z� lhedh\Zlv� kgh\b^_gby�� g_jZkkijZrb\Zy�\b^_\r_]h�khg��\_^v�hg�\k_�jZ\gh�gbq_]h�g_�kfh`_l�kdZaZlv�ih�ih\h^m�kbf\heZ�?keb� agZlv� ijbgylu_� kbf\heu� kgh\b^_gbc� b d� lhfm�`_� ebqghklv� \b^_\r_]h� khg�� mkeh\by�� \dhlhjuo�hg�`b\_l��b ihemq_ggu_�bf�^h�kgh\b^_gby�\i_qZle_gby�� lh�qZklh�fu�hdZau\Z_fky�\khklhygbb� [_a� aZljm^g_gbc� bklhedh\Zlv� kgh\b^_gb_�� i_j_\_klb� _]h� kjZam� `_�� LZdhc� nhdmkevklbl� lhedh\Zl_ex�b bfihgbjm_l� \b^_\r_fm� khg�� wlh� \u]h^gh� hlebqZ_lky� hl� mlhfbl_evghcjZ[hlu�ijb�jZkkijhkZo�\b^_\r_]h�khg��Gh�imklv�wlh�g_�\\_^_l�\Zk�\ aZ[em`^_gb_��Fu�g_�klZ\bf

Page 80: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

i_j_^� kh[hc� aZ^Zqm� ihdZau\Zlv� nhdmku�� Lhedh\Zgb_�� hkgh\Zggh_� gZ� agZgbb� kbf\heh\�� g_y\ey_lky� l_ogbdhc�� dhlhjZy� fh`_l� aZf_gblv� ZkkhpbZlb\gmx� beb� jZ\gylvky� k g_c�Kbf\hebq_kdh_�lhedh\Zgb_�y\ey_lky�lhevdh�^hiheg_gb_f�d g_c�b ^Z_l�p_ggu_�j_amevlZlu�ebrv\ khq_lZgbb�k ZkkhpbZlb\ghc�l_ogbdhc��: qlh�dZkZ_lky�agZgby�ikbobq_kdhc�kblmZpbb�\b^_\r_]hkhg��lh�ijhrm�ijbgylv�\h�\gbfZgb_��qlh�\Zf�ijb^_lky�lhedh\Zlv�kgh\b^_gby�g_�lhevdh�ohjhrhagZdhfuo�ex^_c��qlh�h[uqgh�\u�g_�[m^_l_�agZlv�kh[ulbc�^gy��dhlhju_�y\eyxlky�ih[m^bl_eyfbkgh\b^_gbc��b qlh�fukeb��ijboh^ysb_�\ ]heh\m� ZgZebabjm_fh]h��dZd�jZa�b ^Z^ml�\Zf� agZgb_lh]h��qlh�gZau\Z_lky�ikbobq_kdhc�kblmZpb_c�< k\yab�k h[klhyl_evkl\Zfb��h dhlhjuo�[m^_l�b^lb�j_qv�gb`_��^hklhcgh�hkh[h]h�\gbfZgbylh�� qlh� ijbagZgb_� kms_kl\h\Zgby� kbf\hebq_kdh]h� hlghr_gby� f_`^m� kgh\b^_gb_f� b[_kkhagZl_evguf�\uau\Zeh�hiylv�lZdb�kZfu_�wg_j]bqgu_�\hajZ`_gby��>Z`_�ex^b��h[eZ^Zxsb_kf_ehklvx�km`^_gby�b ihevamxsb_ky�ijbagZgb_f��ijhr_^rb_�k ikbohZgZebahf�agZqbl_evgucimlv�� hldZaZebkv� \ wlhf� ke_^h\Zlv� aZ�gbf��LZdh_� hlghr_gb_� l_f�[he__� m^b\bl_evgh��qlh�� \h�i_j\uo�� kbf\hebdZ� k\hckl\_ggZ� b oZjZdl_jgZ� g_� lhevdh� ^ey� kgh\b^_gby�� Z�� \h�\lhjuo�kbf\hebdm� \ kgh\b^_gbb�� dZd� gb [h]Zl� hg� hr_ehfeyxsbfb� hldjulbyfb�� hldjue� g_ikbohZgZeba��?keb�m`�\hh[s_�ijbibku\Zlv�hldjulb_� kbf\hebdb� kgh\b^_gby� kh\j_f_ggbdZf�lh�ke_^m_l�gZa\Zlv�nbehkhnZ�D��:��R_jg_jZ� �6FKHPHU���������IkbohZgZeba�lhevdh�ih^l\_j^behldjulby�R_jg_jZ��ohly�b hkgh\Zl_evgh�\b^hbaf_gbe�bo�L_i_jv� \Zf� ohq_lky� mkeurZlv� qlh�gb[m^v� h kmsghklb� kbf\hebdb� kgh\b^_gby� bihagZdhfblvky�k __�ijbf_jZfb��Y hohlgh�khh[sm�\Zf��qlh�agZx��gh�khagZxkv��qlh�gZrb�agZgbyg_�khhl\_lkl\mxl�lhfm��q_]h�[u�gZf�ohl_ehkv�Kmsghklvx� kbf\hebq_kdh]h� hlghr_gby� y\ey_lky� kjZ\g_gb_�� ohly� b g_� ex[h_�Ij_^iheZ]Z_lky��qlh�wlh�kjZ\g_gb_�hkh[uf�h[jZahf�h[mkeh\e_gh��ohly�wlZ�h[mkeh\e_gghklv�gZfg_�kh\k_f�ykgZ��G_�\k_�lh��k q_f�fu�fh`_f�kjZ\gblv�dZdhc�lh�ij_^f_l�beb�ijhp_kk��\uklmiZ_l�\kgh\b^_gbb�dZd�kbf\he��K ^jm]hc�klhjhgu��kgh\b^_gb_�\ujZ`Z_l�\ kbf\heZo�g_�\k_��Z lhevdhhij_^_e_ggu_� we_f_glu� kdjuluo� fuke_c� kgh\b^_gby�� BlZd�� h]jZgbq_gby� bf_xlky� k h[_boklhjhg��Ke_^m_l�lZd`_�kh]eZkblvky�k l_f��qlh�ihdZ�ihgylb_�kbf\heZ�g_evay�kljh]h�hij_^_eblv�hgh�keb\Z_lky�k aZf_s_gb_f��bah[jZ`_gb_f�b l��i���ijb[eb`Z_lky�d gZf_dm��E_`Zs__�\ hkgh\_kjZ\g_gby�\ jy^_�kbf\heh\�hkfuke_ggh��GZjy^m�k wlbfb�kbf\heZfb�_klv�^jm]b_��ijb�dhlhjuo\hagbdZ_l�\hijhk��]^_�bkdZlv�h[s__��7HUWLXP�khljZ]ZWLRQLV� �wlh]h�ij_^iheZ]Z_fh]h�kjZ\g_gby�Ijb� [eb`Zcr_f� jZkkfhlj_gbb� fu� eb[h� gZc^_f� _]h�� eb[h� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� hgh� hklZg_lkykdjuluf�hl�gZk��M^b\bl_evgh��^Ze__��lh��qlh�_keb�kbf\he�b y\ey_lky�kjZ\g_gb_f��lh�hgh � 7HUWLXP� FRPSDUDWLRQLV� �� ©lj_lv_� \ kjZ\g_gbbª�� l�� k�� h[s__� \ ^\mo� kjZ\gb\Z_fuo� f_`^m� kh[hc� y\e_gbyo�kem`Zs__�hkgh\Zgb_f�^ey�kjZ\g_gby���Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Zg_�h[gZjm`b\Z_lky�ijb�ihfhsb�ZkkhpbZpbb��qlh�\b^_\rbc�khg�lh`_�g_�agZ_l�kjZ\g_gby�ihevam_lky� bf�� g_� agZy� h g_f�� >Z`_� [hevr_� lh]h�� \b^_\rbc� khg� g_� `_eZ_l� ijbagZ\Zlv� wlhkjZ\g_gb_�� dh]^Z� _fm� gZ� g_]h� mdZau\Zxl�� BlZd�� \u� \b^bl_�� qlh� kbf\hebq_kdh_� hlghr_gb_y\ey_lky�kjZ\g_gb_f�kh\_jr_ggh�hkh[h]h�jh^Z��h[mkeh\e_gghklv�dhlhjh]h�gZf�_s_�g_�kh\k_fykgZ��Fh`_l�[ulv��mdZaZgby�^ey�_]h�\uykg_gby�h[gZjm`Zlky�\ ^Zevg_cr_f�Qbkeh� ij_^f_lh\�� bah[jZ`Z_fuo� \ kgh\b^_gbb� kbf\hebq_kdb�� g_\_ebdh�� Q_eh\_q_kdh_

Page 81: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

l_eh� \ p_ehf�� jh^bl_eb�� ^_lb�� [jZlvy� b k_klju�� jh`^_gb_�� kf_jlv�� gZ]hlZ� b _s_� g_fgh]h_�?^bgkl\_ggh� lbibqgh_�� l�� _�� ihklhyggh_� bah[jZ`_gb_� q_eh\_dZ� \ p_ehf�� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc^hf�� dZd� ijbagZe� R_jg_j�� dhlhjuc� ^Z`_� ohl_e� ijb^Zlv� wlhfm� kbf\hem� i_j\hkl_i_ggh_agZq_gb_��dhlhjh_�_fm�g_�k\hckl\_ggh��< kgh\b^_gbb�kemqZ_lky�kimkdZlvky�ih�nZkZ^m�^hfh\�lhk m^h\hevkl\b_f�� lh� kh� kljZohf��>hfZ� k kh\_jr_ggh� ]eZ^dbfb� kl_gZfb�bah[jZ`Zxl�fm`qbg�^hfZ�k \uklmiZfb�b [ZedhgZfb��aZ�dhlhju_�fh`gh�^_j`Zlvky�²�`_gsbg��Jh^bl_eb�ihy\eyxlky\h� kg_� \ \b^_�bfi_jZlhjZ�b bfi_jZljbpu�� dhjhey�b dhjhe_\u�beb� ^jm]bo� ij_^klZ\bl_evguoebp��ijb�wlhf�kgh\b^_gb_�ij_bkiheg_gh�qm\kl\Z�ihql_gby��F_g__�g_`gh�kgh\b^_gb_�hlghkblkyd ^_lyf�� [jZlvyf� b k_kljZf�� hgb� kbf\hebabjmxlky� fZe_gvdbfb� a\_j_gurZfb�� iZjZablZfb�Jh`^_gb_�ihqlb�\k_]^Z�bah[jZ`Z_lky�ihkj_^kl\hf�dZdh]h�eb[h�hlghr_gby�d \h^_��\ \h^m�beb[jhkZxlky�� beb� \uoh^yl� ba� g__�� ba� \h^u� dh]h�gb[m^v� kiZkZxl� beb� l_[y� kiZkZxl� ba� g__�� qlhhagZqZ_l� fZl_jbgkdh_� hlghr_gb_� d kiZkZ_fhfm�� MfbjZgb_� aZf_gy_lky� \h� kg_� hlt_a^hf�ih_a^dhc� ih� `_e_aghc� ^hjh]_�� kf_jlv� ²� jZaebqgufb� g_ykgufb�� dZd� [u� g_j_rbl_evgufbgZf_dZfb��gZ]hlZ�²�h^_`^hc�b nhjf_gghc�h^_`^hc��<u�\b^bl_��dZd� lml� klbjZxlky� ]jZgbpuf_`^m�kbf\hebq_kdbf�b gZf_dZxsbf�bah[jZ`_gb_f�;jhkZ_lky� \ ]eZaZ�� qlh� ih� kjZ\g_gbx� k i_j_qbke_ggvrb� h[t_dlZfb� h[t_dlu� ba� ^jm]hch[eZklb�ij_^klZ\e_gu�qj_a\uqZcgh�[h]Zlhc� kbf\hebdhc��LZdh\Z� h[eZklv� k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�]_gblZebc�� iheh\uo� ijhp_kkh\�� iheh\uo� kghr_gbc�� Qj_a\uqZcgh� [hevrh_� dhebq_kl\hkbf\heh\�\ kgh\b^_gbb�y\eyxlky�k_dkmZevgufb�kbf\heZfb��Ijb�wlhf�\uykgy_lky�m^b\bl_evgh_g_khhl\_lkl\b_�� H[hagZqZ_fuo� kh^_j`Zgbc� g_fgh]h�� kbf\heu� `_� ^ey� gbo� qj_a\uqZcghfgh]hqbke_ggu�� lZd�qlh�dZ`^h_�ba� wlbo� kh^_j`Zgbc�fh`_l�[ulv� \ujZ`_gh�[hevrbf�qbkehfihqlb� jZ\ghagZqguo� kbf\heh\�� Ijb� lhedh\Zgbb� ihemqZ_lky� dZjlbgZ�� \uau\ZxsZy� \k_h[s__\hafms_gb_�� Lhedh\Zgby� kbf\heh\� \ ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv� fgh]hh[jZabx� bah[jZ`_gbckgh\b^_gby� hq_gv� h^ghh[jZagu�� Wlh� g_� gjZ\blky� dZ`^hfm�� dlh� h[� wlhf� magZ_l�� gh� qlh� `_ih^_eZ_rv"LZd�dZd�\ wlhc�e_dpbb�fu�\i_j\u_� ]h\hjbf�h \hijhkZo�iheh\hc�`bagb�� y kqblZx� k\hbf^he]hf�khh[sblv�\Zf��dZd�y kh[bjZxkv�baeZ]Zlv�wlm�l_fm��IkbohZgZeba�g_�\b^bl�ijbqbg�^eykdju\Zgby� b gZf_dh\�� g_� kqblZ_l� gm`guf� klu^blvky� h[km`^_gby� wlh]h� \Z`gh]h� fZl_jbZeZ�iheZ]Z_l��qlh�dhjj_dlgh�b ijbklhcgh�\k_�gZau\Zlv�k\hbfb�gZklhysbfb� �bf_gZfb��b gZ^__lkylZdbf�h[jZahf�kdhj__�\k_]h�mkljZgblv�f_rZxsb_�ihklhjhggb_�fukeb��Lh�h[klhyl_evkl\h��qlhfg_�ijboh^blky�]h\hjblv�i_j_^�kf_rZgghc�Zm^blhjb_c��ij_^klZ\eyxs_c�h[Z�iheZ��gbq_]h�g_fh`_l�baf_gblv��DZd�g_l�gZmdb�LQ�XVDP�GHOSKLP� ��lZd�g_l�__ b�^ey�^_\hq_d�ih^jhkldh\��Z ^Zfuk\hbf� ihy\e_gb_f� \ wlhc� Zm^blhjbb� ^Zxl� ihgylv�� qlh� hgb� ohlyl� ihklZ\blv� k_[y� gZjZ\g_� kfm`qbgZfb�BlZd��kgh\b^_gb_�bah[jZ`Z_l�fm`kdb_�]_gblZebb�g_kdhevdbfb�kbf\heZfb��\ dhlhjuo�ih[hevr_c�qZklb�\iheg_�hq_\b^gh�h[s__�hkgh\Zgb_�^ey�kjZ\g_gby��Ij_`^_�\k_]h�^ey�fm`kdbo]_gblZebc�\ p_ehf�kbf\hebq_kdb�\Z`gh�k\ys_ggh_�qbkeh��Ijb\e_dZxsZy�[hevr__�\gbfZgb_�bbgl_j_kgZy� ^ey� h[hbo� iheh\� qZklv� ]_gblZebc�� fm`kdhc� qe_g�� kbf\hebq_kdb� aZf_gy_lky�� \h�i_j\uo�� ihoh`bfb� gZ� g_]h� ih� nhjf_�� lh� _klv� ^ebggufb� b lhjqZsbfb� \\_jo� ij_^f_lZfb�lZdbfb��gZijbf_j��dZd�iZedb�� ahglu��r_klu��^_j_\vy�b l��i��AZl_f�ij_^f_lZfb��bf_xsbfb� kh[hagZqZ_fuf� koh^kl\h� ijhgb]Zlv� \gmljv� b jZgblv�� l�� _�� \kydh]h� jh^Z� hkljuf� hjm`b_f�

Page 82: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gh`Zfb�� dbg`ZeZfb�� dhivyfb�� kZ[eyfb�� Z lZd`_� h]g_klj_evguf� hjm`b_f�� jm`vyfb�ibklhe_lZfb� b hq_gv� ihoh`bf� ih� k\h_c� nhjf_� j_\hev\_jhf�� < kljZrguo� kgZo� ^_\mr_d[hevrmx� jhev� b]jZ_l� ij_ke_^h\Zgb_� fm`qbgu� k gh`hf� beb� h]g_klj_evguf� hjm`b_f�� Wlh�fh`_l� [ulv�� kZfuc� qZkluc� kemqZc� kbf\hebdb� kgh\b^_gby�� dhlhjuc� \u� l_i_jv� e_]dh�fh`_l_ihgylv��LZd`_� \iheg_� ihgylgZ� aZf_gZ�fm`kdh]h� qe_gZ� ij_^f_lZfb�� ba� dhlhjuo� ev_lky� \h^Z�\h^hijh\h^gufb� djZgZfb�� e_cdZfb�� nhglZgZfb� b ^jm]bfb� ij_^f_lZfb�� h[eZ^Zxsbfbkihkh[ghklvx� \uly]b\Zlvky� \ ^ebgm�� gZijbf_j� \bkyqbfb� eZfiZfb�� \u^\b]ZxsbfbkydZjZg^ZrZfb�b l��^��<iheg_�ihgylgh_�ij_^klZ\e_gb_�h[�wlhf�hj]Zg_�h[mkeh\eb\Z_l�lhqgh�lZd`_� lh�� qlh� dZjZg^Zrb�� jmqdb��ibehqdb� ^ey�gh]l_c��fhehldb� b ^jm]b_�bgkljmf_glu� y\eyxlkyg_khfg_ggufb�fm`kdbfb�iheh\ufb�kbf\heZfb�;eZ]h^Zjy� ijbf_qZl_evghfm� k\hckl\m� qe_gZ� ih^gbfZlvky� \ gZijZ\e_gbb�ijhlb\hiheh`ghf� kbe_� ijbly`_gby� �h^gh� ba� ijhy\e_gbc� wj_dpbb��� hg� bah[jZ`Z_lkykbf\hebq_kdb� \ \b^_� \ha^mrgh]h�rZjZ�� ZwjhieZgh\�� Z \�ihke_^g__� \j_fy� \ \b^_� \ha^mrgh]hdhjZ[ey� p_ii_ebgZ�� Gh� kgh\b^_gb_� fh`_l� kbf\hebq_kdb� bah[jZablv� wj_dpbx� _s_� bguf�]hjZa^h�[he__� \ujZabl_evguf� kihkh[hf��Hgh�^_eZ_l�iheh\hc� hj]Zg� kZfhc� kmlvx� ebqghklb�baZklZ\ey_l�__ e_lZ]v��G_�h]hjqZcl_kv��qlh�qZklh�lZdb_�ij_djZkgu_�kgu�k ihe_lZfb��dhlhju_�fu\k_� agZ_f��^he`gu�[ulv�bklhedh\Zgu�dZd�kgh\b^_gby�h[s_]h�k_dkmZevgh]h�\ha[m`^_gby��dZdwj_dpbhggu_� kgh\b^_gby��Kj_^b� bkke_^h\Zl_e_c�ikbohZgZeblbdh\�I��N_^_jg� ������� ^hdZaZe�qlh� lZdh_� lhedh\Zgb_� g_� ih^e_`bl� gbdZdhfm� khfg_gbx�� gh� b ihqblZ_fuc� aZ� k\hxi_^Zglbqghklv� Fhmjeb� <hev^�� wdki_jbf_glbjh\Z\rbc� gZ^� kgh\b^_gbyfb�� ijb^Z\Zybkdmkkl\_ggh_�iheh`_gb_�jmdZf�b gh]Zf��b klhy\rbc�\ klhjhg_�hl�ikbohZgZebaZ��fh`_l�[ulv^Z`_�gbq_]h�g_�agZ\rbc�h g_f��ijbr_e�\ k\hbo�bkke_^h\Zgbyo�d lhfm�`_�\u\h^m������²�����l�����������G_�\hajZ`Zcl_��qlh�`_gsbgZf�lh`_�fh`_l�ijbkgblvky��qlh�hgb�e_lZxl��<kihfgbl_emqr_�� qlh� gZrb� kgh\b^_gby� ohlyl� bkihegblv� gZrb� `_eZgby� b qlh� hq_gv� qZklh� m `_gsbg[u\Z_l� khagZl_evgh_� beb� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� `_eZgb_� [ulv� fm`qbghc�� : \kydhfm� agZxs_fmZgZlhfbx�ihgylgh��qlh�b `_gsbgZ�fh`_l�j_Zebah\Zlv�wlh�`_eZgb_�l_fb�`_�hsms_gbyfb��qlh�bfm`qbgZ��< k\hbo�]_gblZebyo�`_gsbgZ�lh`_�bf__l�fZe_gvdbc�hj]Zg��ZgZeh]bqguc�fm`kdhfm��bwlhl�fZe_gvdbc�hj]Zg��deblhj��b]jZ_l�\ ^_lkdhf�\hajZkl_�b \�\hajZkl_�i_j_^�gZqZe_g�iheh\hc`bagb�lm�`_�jhev��qlh�b [hevrhc�fm`kdhc�iheh\hc�qe_g�D qbkem� f_g__� ihgylguo� fm`kdbo� k_dkmZevguo� kbf\heh\� hlghkylky� hij_^_e_ggu_ij_kfudZxsb_ky� b ju[u�� ij_`^_� \k_]h� ba\_klguc� kbf\he� af_b�� Ihq_fm� reyiZ� b iZetlhijbh[j_eb� lZdh_� `_� kbf\hebq_kdh_� agZq_gb_�� dhg_qgh�� g_e_]dh� magZlv�� gh� hgh� g_khfg_ggh�GZdhg_p��\hagbdZ_l�_s_�\hijhk��fh`gh�eb�kqblZlv�kbf\hebq_kdbf�aZf_s_gb_�fm`kdh]h�hj]ZgZdZdbf�gb[m^v� ^jm]bf�� gh]hc� beb� jmdhc�� Y ^mfZx�� qlh� h[sbc� oh^� kgh\b^_gby� bkhhl\_lkl\mxsb_�ZgZeh]bb�m `_gsbg�aZklZ\eyxl�gZk�wlh�k^_eZlv�@_gkdb_� iheh\u_� hj]Zgu� bah[jZ`Zxlky� kbf\hebq_kdb� ijb� ihfhsb� \k_?� ij_^f_lh\�h[eZ^Zxsbo� k\hckl\hf� h]jZgbqb\Zlv� iheh_� ijhkljZgkl\h�� qlh�lh� ijbgylv� \ k_[y�� L�� _�� ijbihfhsb�rZol��dhi_c�b i_s_j��ijb�ihfhsb�khkm^h\�b [mluehd��dhjh[hd��lZ[Zd_jhd��q_fh^Zgh\�[Zghd��ysbdh\��dZjfZgh\�b l��^��Km^gh�lh`_�hlghkblky�d bo�jZajy^m��Fgh]b_�kbf\heu�bf_xl[hevr_�hlghr_gby�d fZld_��q_f�d ]_gblZebyf�`_gsbgu��lZdh\u�rdZnu��i_qb�b ij_`^_�\k_]hdhfgZlZ�� Kbf\hebdZ� dhfgZlu� khijbdZkZ_lky� a^_kv� k kbf\hebdhc� ^hfZ�� ^\_jb� b \hjhlZ

Page 83: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

klZgh\ylky�kbf\heZfb�iheh\h]h�hl\_jklby��FZl_jbZeu�lh`_�fh]ml�[ulv�kbf\heZfb�`_gsbgu�^_j_\h�� [mfZ]Z� b ij_^f_lu�� k^_eZggu_� ba� wlbo� fZl_jbZeh\�� gZijbf_j�� klhe� b dgb]Z�� Ba`b\hlguo�g_khfg_ggufb�`_gkdbfb�kbf\heZfb�y\eyxlky�mebldZ�b jZdh\bgZ��ba�qZkl_c�l_eZ�jhldZd� h[jZa� iheh\h]h� hl\_jklby�� ba� kljh_gbc� p_jdh\v� b dZi_eeZ�� DZd� \b^bl_�� g_� \k_� kbf\heuh^bgZdh\h�ihgylgu�D ]_gblZebyf� ke_^m_l� hlg_klb� lZd`_� b ]jm^b�� dhlhju_�� dZd� b y]h^bpu� `_gkdh]h� l_eZ�bah[jZ`Zxlky� ijb� ihfhsb� y[ehd�� i_jkbdh\�� \hh[s_� njmdlh\�� <hehku� gZ� ]_gblZebyo� h[hboiheh\�kgh\b^_gb_�hibku\Z_l�dZd�e_k�b dmklZjgbd��Keh`ghklvx�lhih]jZnbb�`_gkdbo�iheh\uohj]Zgh\�h[tykgy_lky�lh��qlh�hgb�qZklh�bah[jZ`Zxlky�eZg^rZnlhf�kh�kdZeZfb��e_khf�b \h^hc�f_`^m�l_f�dZd�\gmrbl_evguc�f_oZgbaf�fm`kdh]h�iheh\h]h�ZiiZjZlZ�ijb\h^bl�d lhfm��qlh�_]hkbf\heZfb�klZgh\ylky�ljm^gh�ih^^Zxsb_ky�hibkZgbx�\ \b^_�keh`guo�fZrbg�DZd� kbf\he� `_gkdbo� ]_gblZebc� ke_^m_l� mihfygmlv� _s_� rdZlmedm� ^ey� mdjZr_gbc�^jZ]hp_gghklvx�b khdjh\bs_f�gZau\Zxlky�ex[bfu_�ebpZ�b \h�kg_��keZ^hklb�qZklh�bah[jZ`Zxliheh\h_�gZkeZ`^_gb_��KZfhm^h\e_l\hj_gb_�h[hagZqZ_lky�qZklh�dZd�\kydh]h�jh^Z�b]jZ�� lZd�`_dZd�b]jZ�gZ�nhjl_ibZgh��Lbibqguf�bah[jZ`_gb_f�hgZgbafZ�y\ey_lky�kdhev`_gb_�b kdZlu\Zgb_�Z lZd`_� kju\Zgb_� \_ldb�� Hkh[_ggh� ijbf_qZl_e_g� kbf\he� \uiZ^_gby� beb� \uju\Zgby� am[Z�Ij_`^_� \k_]h� hg� hagZqZ_l� dZkljZpbx� \ gZdZaZgb_� aZ� hgZgbaf�� Hkh[u_� kbf\heu� ^eybah[jZ`_gby�\ kgh\b^_gbb�iheh\h]h�ZdlZ�f_g__�fgh]hqbke_ggu��q_f�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�h`b^ZlvgZ� hkgh\Zgbb� \ur_baeh`_ggh]h�� A^_kv� ke_^m_l� mihfygmlv� jblfbq_kdmx� ^_yl_evghklv�gZijbf_j��lZgpu��\_joh\mx�_a^m��ih^t_fu��Z lZd`_�i_j_`b\Zgby��k\yaZggu_�k gZkbeb_f��dZd�gZijbf_j�� [ulv� aZ^Z\e_gguf�� Kx^Z� `_� hlghkylky� hij_^_e_ggu_� j_f_ke_ggu_� jZ[hlu� b�dhg_qgh��m]jhaZ�hjm`b_f�<u� g_� ^he`gu� ij_^klZ\eylv� k_[_� mihlj_[e_gb_� b i_j_\h^� wlbo� kbf\heh\� q_f�lh� hq_gvijhkluf��Iji� wlhf�\hafh`gu�\kydb_� kemqZcghklb���ijhlb\hj_qZsb_�gZrbf�h`b^Zgbyf��LZd�gZijbf_j��dZ`_lky�fZeh\_jhylguf��qlh�iheh\u_�jZaebqby�\ wlbo�kbf\hebq_kdbo�bah[jZ`_gbyoijhy\eyxlky�g_�j_adh��G_dhlhju_�kbf\heu�hagZqZxl�]_gblZebp�\hh[s_��[_ajZaebqgh��fm`kdb_beb� `_gkdb_�� gZijbf_j�� fZe_gvdbc� j_[_ghd�� fZe_gvdbc� kug� beb� fZe_gvdZy� ^hqv�� Bghc� jZaij_bfms_kl\_ggh�fm`kdhc�kbf\he�fh`_l�mihlj_[eylvky�^ey�`_gkdbo�]_gblZebc�beb�gZh[hjhl�Wlh� g_evay� ihgylv� [_a� [he__� [ebadh]h� agZdhfkl\Z� k jZa\blb_f� k_dkmZevguo� ij_^klZ\e_gbcq_eh\_dZ�� < g_dhlhjuo� kemqZyo� wlZ� ^\hckl\_gghklv� lhevdh� dZ`msZyky�� kZfu_� yjdb_� bakbf\heh\��lZdb_��dZd�hjm`b_��dZjfZg��ysbd��g_�fh]ml�mihlj_[eylvky�\ [bk_dkmZevghf�agZq_gbb�L_i_jv� y [m^m� bkoh^blv� g_� ba� bah[jZ`Z_fh]h�� Z ba� kbf\heZ�� jZkkfhljx� l_� h[eZklb�� badhlhjuo�ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�[_jmlky�k_dkmZevgu_�kbf\heu��b ijb[Z\ex�g_dhlhju_�^hiheg_gby�ijbgbfZy� \h� \gbfZgb_� kbf\heu�� \ dhlhjuo� g_ykgZ� h[sZy� hkgh\Z�� LZdbf� l_fguf� kbf\hehfy\ey_lky�reyiZ��fh`_l�[ulv��\hh[s_�]heh\ghc�m[hj�h[uqgh�k fm`kdbf�agZq_gb_f��gh�bgh]^Z�bk `_gkdbf��Lhqgh� lZd�`_�iZevlh� hagZqZ_l�fm`qbgm��gh�g_� \k_]^Z� \ iheh\hf� hlghr_gbb��<ufh`_l_� kdhevdh�m]h^gh� kijZrb\Zlv�ihq_fm��K\bkZxsbc� ]ZeZmd��dhlhjuc�`_gsbgZ�g_�ghkbl�y\ey_lky� y\gh� fm`kdbf� kbf\hehf�� ;_eh_� [_ev_�� \hh[s_� ihehlgh� kbf\hebabjm_l� `_gkdh_�ieZlv_��nhjf_ggZy�h^_`^Z��dZd�fu�m`_� agZ_f�� y\ey_lky� aZf_klbl_eyfb��gZ]hlu��nhjf� l_eZ�� Z[ZrfZd��lmney�²�`_gkdbo�]_gblZebc��klhe�b ^_j_\h�dZd�aZ]Z^hqgu_��gh�hij_^_e_ggh�`_gkdb_kbf\heu� m`_� mihfbgZebkv�� <kydh]h� jh^Z� e_klgbpu�� klj_fygdb� b ih^t_f� ih� gbf� ²

Page 84: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_khfg_gguc�kbf\he�iheh\h]h�ZdlZ��<^mfZ\rbkv��fu�h[jZlbf�\gbfZgb_�gZ�jblfbqghklv�wlh]hih^t_fZ�� dhlhjZy�� dZd� b�� \hafh`gh�� \hajZklZgb_� \ha[m`^_gby�� h^urdZ� ih� f_j_� ih^t_fZ�y\ey_lky�h[s_c�hkgh\hc�Fu� m`_� mihfbgZeb� h eZg^rZnl_� dZd�bah[jZ`_gbb�`_gkdbo� ]_gblZebc��=hjZ�b kdZeZ�²kbf\heu�fm`kdh]h�qe_gZ��kZ^�²�qZklh�\klj_qZxsbcky�kbf\he�`_gkdbo�]_gblZebc��Ieh^�bf__lagZq_gb_�g_�j_[_gdZ��Z ]jm^_c��>bdb_�a\_jb�hagZqZxl�qm\kl\_ggh�\ha[m`^_gguo�ex^_c��djhf_lh]h��^jm]b_�]jm[u_�`_eZgby��kljZklb��P\_l_gb_�b p\_lu�h[hagZqZxl�]_gblZebb�`_gsbg�beb��\[he__�ki_pbZevghf�kemqZ_�²^_\kl\_gghklv��G_�aZ[u\Zcl_��qlh�p\_lu�^_ckl\bl_evgh�y\eyxlky]_gblZebyfb�jZkl_gbc�DhfgZlZ�gZf�m`_�ba\_klgZ�dZd�kbf\he��A^_kv�fh`gh�ijh^he`blv�^_lZebaZpbx��hdgZ��\oh^ub \uoh^u�dhfgZlu�ihemqZxl�agZq_gb_�hl\_jklbc�l_eZ��D wlhc�kbf\hebd_�hlghkblky�lZd`_�b lh�hldjulZ� dhfgZlZ� beb� aZdjulZ�� Z dexq�� dhlhjuc� hldju\Z_l�� y\ey_lky� g_khfg_gguf�fm`kdbfkbf\hehf�LZdh\�fZl_jbZe�kbf\hebdb�kgh\b^_gbc��Hg�_s_�g_�ihehg�b _]h�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�m]em[blv�bjZkrbjblv��Gh�y ^mfZx��\Zf�b wlh]h�[he__�q_f�^hklZlhqgh��Z fh`_l�[ulv��m`_�b gZ^h_eh��<ukijhkbl_��g_m`_eb�y ^_ckl\bl_evgh�`b\m�kj_^b�k_dkmZevguo�kbf\heh\"�G_m`_eb�\k_�ij_^f_lu�dhlhju_� f_gy� hdjm`Zxl�� ieZlvy�� dhlhju_� y gZ^_\Zx�� \_sb�� dhlhju_� [_jm� \ jmdb�� \k_]^Zk_dkmZevgu_�kbf\heu�b gbqlh�^jm]h_"�Ih\h^�^ey�g_^hmf_gguo�\hijhkh\�^_ckl\bl_evgh�_klv��bi_j\uc� ba� gbo�� hldm^Z� gZf�� kh[kl\_ggh�� ba\_klgu� agZq_gby� wlbo� kbf\heh\� kgh\b^_gby�� hdhlhjuo�kZf�\b^_\rbc�khg�g_�]h\hjbl�gZf�gbq_]h�beb�khh[sZ_l�hq_gv�fZeh"Y hl\_qm�� ba� hq_gv� jZaebqguo� bklhqgbdh\�� ba� kdZahd� b fbnh\�� rmlhd� b hkljhl�� banhevdehjZ��l��_��ba�k\_^_gbc�h gjZ\Zo��h[uqZyo��ih]h\hjdZo�b gZjh^guo�i_kgyo��ba�ihwlbq_kdh]hb h[u^_ggh]h� yaudZ�� A^_kv� \kx^m� \klj_qZ_lky� lZ�`_� kbf\hebdZ�� b \� g_dhlhjuo� kemqZyo� fuihgbfZ_f�__ [_a�\kydbo�mdZaZgbc��?keb�fu�klZg_f�ih^jh[gh�bamqZlv�wlb�bklhqgbdb��lh�gZc^_fkbf\hebd_�kgh\b^_gbc�lZd�fgh]h�iZjZee_e_c��qlh�m\_jbfky�\ ijZ\bevghklb�gZrbo�lhedh\Zgbc�Q_eh\_q_kdh_� l_eh�� dZd� fu� kdZaZeb�� ih� R_jg_jm� qZklh� bah[jZ`Z_lky� \ kgh\b^_gbbkbf\hehf� ^hfZ�� Ijb� ^_lZevghf� jZkkfhlj_gbb� wlh]h� bah[jZ`_gby� hdgZ�� ^\_jb� b \hjhlZy\eyxlky�\oh^Zfb�\h�\gmlj_ggb_�ihehklb�l_eZ��nZkZ^u�[u\Zxl�]eZ^db_�beb�bf_xl�[Zedhgu�b\uklmiu�� qlh[u� ^_j`Zlvky�� Gh� lZdZy� `_� kbf\hebdZ� \klj_qZ_lky� \ gZr_c� j_qb�� dh]^Z� funZfbevyjgh�ijb\_lkl\m_f�ohjhrh�agZdhfh]h�©DOWHV�+DXVª�>klZjbgZ@��dh]^Z�]h\hjbf��qlh[u�^Zlvdhfm�gb[m^v�ohjhr_gvdh�DXIV�'DFKL�>ih�dmihem@�beb�h ^jm]hf��qlh�m g_]h�g_�\k_�\ ihjy^d_� LQ2EHUVWXEFKHQ�>q_j^Zd�g_�\ ihjy^d_@��< ZgZlhfbb�hl\_jklby�l_eZ�ijyfh�gZau\Zxlky�/HLEHVSIRUWHQ>\hjhlZ�l_eZ@�Lh��qlh�jh^bl_eb�\ kgh\b^_gbb�ihy\eyxlky�\ \b^_�bfi_jZlhjkdhc�beb�dhjhe_\kdhc�q_lu�kgZqZeZ�dZ`_lky�m^b\bl_evguf��Gh�wlh�gZoh^bl�k\hx�iZjZee_ev�\ kdZadZo��JZa\_�g_�\hagbdZ_l�mgZk�fukev��qlh�\ gZqZe_�fgh]bo�kdZahd�\f_klh��©`beb�[ueb�dhjhev�k dhjhe_\hcª�^he`gh�[ueh[u�[ulv��©`beb�[ueb�hl_p�k fZl_jvxª"�< k_fv_�^_l_c�\ rmldm�gZau\Zxl�ijbgpZfb��Z klZjr_]hgZke_^gbdhf� �.URQSULQ]���Dhjhev�kZf�gZau\Z_l�k_[y�hlphf�kljZgu� >/DQFOHVZDWHU��ih�jmkkdb�²pZjv�[ZlxrdZ@��FZe_gvdbo�^_l_c�\ rmldm�fu�gZau\Z_f�q_j\ydZfb� >ih�jmkkdb�²�dehiZfb@�bkhkljZ^Zl_evgh�]h\hjbf��[_^guc�q_j\yd�>GDV�DUPH�:XUP��ih�jmkkdb�²�[_^guc�dehi@�

Page 85: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

<_jg_fky� d kbf\hebd_� ^hfZ�� Dh]^Z� fu� \h� kg_� ihevam_fky� \uklmiZfb� ^hfh\�� qlh[umo\Zlblvky��g_�gZihfbgZ_l�eb�wlh�ba\_klgh_�gZjh^gh_�\ujZ`_gb_�^ey�kbevgh�jZa\blh]h�[xklZ��mwlhc�_klv�aZ�qlh�ih^_j`Zlvky"�GZjh^�\ujZ`Z_lky�\ lZdbo�kemqZyo�b bgZq_��hg�]h\hjbl��6LH�KDWYLHO� +RO]� YRU� GHP� +DXV� >m wlhc� fgh]h� ^jh\� i_j_^� ^hfhf@�� dZd� [m^lh� `_eZy� ijbclb� gZf� gZihfhsv�\ gZr_f�bklhedh\Zgbb�^_j_\Z�dZd�`_gkdh]h��fZl_jbgkdh]h�kbf\heZ�B _s_� h ^_j_\_�� GZf� g_ykgh�� dZd� wlhl� fZl_jbZe� klZe� kbf\hebq_kdb� ij_^klZ\eylvfZl_jbgkdh_��`_gkdh_��H[jZlbfky� aZ� ihfhsvx� d kjZ\gbl_evghc� nbeheh]bb��GZr_� g_f_pdh_keh\h�+RO]�>^_j_\h@�h^gh]h�dhjgy�k ]j_q_kdbf�XdL@��qlh�hagZqZ_l�©fZl_jbZeª��©kujv_ª��Lml�fubf__f� ^_eh� k ^h\hevgh� qZkluf� kemqZ_f�� dh]^Z� h[s__� gZa\Zgb_� fZl_jbZeZ� \ dhgp_� dhgph\khojZgbehkv�aZ�h^gbf�qZklguf��< hd_Zg_�_klv�hkljh\�ih^�gZa\Zgb_f�FZ^_cjZ��LZd�dZd�hg�\_kv[ue� ihdjul� e_khf�� ihjlm]Zevpu� ^Zeb� _fm� wlh� gZa\Zgb_�� dh]^Z� hldjueb� _]h�� 0DGHLUD� gZihjlm]Zevkdhf� yaud_� agZqbl� ©e_kª�� Gh� e_]dh� magZlv�� qlh� PDGHLUD� g_� qlh� bgh_�� dZd� ke_]dZbaf_g_ggh_� eZlbgkdh_� ke_\h� PDWHULD�� qlh� hiylv�lZdb� h[hagZqZ_l� fZl_jbx� \hh[s_�� $� PDWHULDijhbkoh^bl�hl�keh\Z�PDWHU�²�fZlv��FZl_jbZe��ba�dhlhjh]h�qlh�eb[h�khklhbl��y\ey_lky�dZd�[ufZl_jbgkdhc�qZklvx��LZdbf�h[jZahf�� wlh�^j_\g__�ihgbfZgb_� \ kbf\hebq_kdhf� mihlj_[e_gbbijh^he`Z_l�kms_kl\h\Zlv�Jh`^_gb_�\ kgh\b^_gbb�ihklhyggh�\ujZ`Z_lky�hlghr_gb_f�d \h^_��[jhkZlvky�\ \h^m�beb\uoh^blv� ba� g__� hagZqZ_l�� jh`^Zlv� beb� jh`^Zlvky�� G_� ke_^m_l� aZ[u\Zlv�� qlh� wlhl� kbf\he\^\hcg_� hijZ\^Zg� kkuedhc� gZ� bklhjbx� jZa\blby�� G_� lhevdh� l_f�� qlh� \k_� gZa_fgu_fe_dhiblZxsb_��\dexqZy�ij_^dh\�q_eh\_dZ��ijhbahreb�hl�\h^yguo�`b\hlguo�²� wlh� \_kvfZhl^Ze_ggZy� ZgZeh]by�²� gh� b l_f�� qlh� dZ`^h_� fe_dhiblZxs__�� dZ`^uc� q_eh\_d� ijhoh^bli_j\mx�nZam�k\h_]h�kms_kl\h\Zgby�\ \h^_��Z bf_ggh�dZd�wf[jbhg�\ hdhehieh^ghc�`b^dhklb�\qj_\_�fZl_jb��Z ijb�jh`^_gbb�\uoh^bl�ba�\h^u��Y g_�ohqm�ml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�\b^_\rbc�khg�agZ_lwlh��gZijhlb\��y kqblZx��qlh�_fm�b g_�gm`gh�wlh]h�agZlv��Hg��\_jhylgh��agZ_l�qlh�gb[m^v�^jm]h_�qlh�_fm�jZkkdZau\Zeb�\ ^_lkl\_��gh�b a^_kv�y [m^m�ml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�wlh�agZgb_�g_�kihkh[kl\h\Zehh[jZah\Zgbx� kbf\heZ�� < ^_lkdhc� _fm� ]h\hjbeb�� qlh� ^_l_c� ijbghkbl� Zbkl�� gh� hldm^Z� hg� bo[_j_l"�Ba�ijm^Z��ba�dheh^pZ��l��_��hiylv�lZdb�ba�\h^u��H^bg�ia�fhbo�iZpb_glh\��dhlhjhfm�wlhkdZaZeb��dh]^Z�hg�[ue�fZe_gvdbf��bkq_a�ihke_�wlh]h�gZ�\k_�ihke_h[_^_ggh_�\j_fy��GZdhg_p�_]hgZreb�gZ�[_j_]m�ijm^Z�m aZfdZ��hg�e_`Ze��ijbgbdgm\�ebqbdhf�d ih\_joghklb�\h^u�b mk_j^ghbkdZe�gZ�^g_�fZe_gvdbo�^_l_c�< fbnZo� h jh`^_gbb� ]_jhy�� ih^\_j]gmluo� kjZ\gbl_evghfm� bkke_^h\Zgbx� H�� JZgdhf�������� kZfuc� ^j_\gbc� ba� dhlhjuo� h pZj_� KZj]hg_� ba� :]Z^_�� hdheh� ����� e_l� ^h� J�� ;��ij_h[eZ^Zxsmx� jhev� b]jZ_l� [jhkZgb_� \ \h^m� b kiZkZgb_� ba� \h^u�� JZgd� hldjue�� qlh� wlh� ²bah[jZ`_gby� jh`^_gby�� ZgZeh]bqgu_� lZdbf�`_� \ kgh\b^_gbb�� ?keb� \h� kg_� kiZkZxl� ba� \h^udZdh_�gb[m^v�ebph��lh�kqblZxl�k_[y�_]h�fZl_jvx�beb�ijhklh�fZl_jvx��\ fbn_�ebph��kiZkZxs__j_[_gdZ�ba�\h^u��kqblZ_lky�_]h�gZklhys_c�fZl_jvx��< ba\_klghf�Zg_d^hl_�mfgh]h�_\j_ckdh]hfZevqbdZ�kijZrb\Zxl��dlh�[ue�fZl_jvx�Fhbk_y��Hg�g_�aZ^mfu\Zykv�hl\_qZ_l��ijbgp_kkZ��GhdZd� `_�� \hajZ`Zxl� _fm�� hgZ� \_^v� lhevdh� \ulZsbeZ� _]h� ba� \h^u�� LZd� ]h\hjbl� hgZ�� hl\_qZ_lfZevqbd��ihdZau\Zy��qlh�ijZ\bevgh�bklhedh\Ze�fbn�Hlt_a^� hagZqZ_l� \ kgh\b^_gbb� kf_jlv�� mfbjZgb_�� Ijbgylh� lZd� `_� hl\_qZlv� ^_lyf� gZ\hijhk��dm^Z�^_\Zehkv�mf_jr__�ebph��hlkmlkl\b_�dhlhjh]h�hgb�qm\kl\mxl��qlh�hgh�m_oZeh��Y

Page 86: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hiylv�ohl_e�[u�\hajZablv�l_f��dlh�kqblZ_l��qlh�kbf\he�kgh\b^_gby�ijhbkoh^bl�hl�wlh]h�kihkh[Zhl^_eZlvky�hl�j_[_gdZ��Ihwl�ihevam_lky�lZdhc�`_�kbf\hebdhc��]h\hjy�h aZ]jh[ghc�`bagb�dZd�hg_hldjulhc�kljZg_��hldm^Z�g_�\ha\jZsZeky�gi h^bg�imlgbd� �ih� WUDYHOOHU���< h[u^_gghc�`bagbfu�lh`_�qZklh�]h\hjbf�h ihke_^g_f�imlb��<kydbc�agZlhd�^j_\g_]h�jblmZeZ�agZ_l��dZd�k_jv_aghhlghkbebkv�d ij_^klZ\e_gbx�h iml_r_kl\bb�\ kljZgm�f_jl\uo��gZijbf_j��\ ^j_\g__]bi_lkdhcj_eb]bb�� >h� gZk� ^hreZ� \h� fgh]bo� wda_fieyjZo� Dgb]Z� f_jl\uo�� dhlhjhc�� dZd� [_^_d_jhf�kgZ[`Zeb� \ wlh� iml_r_kl\b_� fmfbx�� K l_o� ihj� dZd� deZ^[bsZ� [ueb� hl^_e_gu� hl� `bebs�ihke_^g__�iml_r_kl\b_�mf_jr_]h�klZeh�j_Zevghklvx�Kbf\hebdZ�]_gblZebc�lh`_�g_�y\ey_lky�q_f�lh�ijbkmsbf�lhevdh�kgh\b^_gbx��DZ`^hfm�ba\Zk�kemqZ_lky�[ulv�g_\_`eb\uf�b gZa\Zlv�`_gsbgm� ©DOWH� 6FKDFKWHOª� >klZjZy�dheh^Z@��g_� agZy�qlh�\u�ihevam_l_kv�ijb�wlhf�kbf\hehf�]_gblZebc��< Gh\hf�aZ\_l_�kdZaZgh��`_gsbgZ�²�khkm^kdm^_evguc��K\ys_ggh_�ibkZgb_�_\j__\��lZd�ijb[eb`Zxs__ky�ih�klbex�d ihwlbq_kdhfm��iheghk_dkmZevgh�kbf\hebq_kdbo�\ujZ`_gbc��dhlhju_�g_�\k_]^Z�ijZ\bevgh�ihgbfZebkv�b lhedh\Zgb_dhlhjuo�� gZijbf_j��I_kgb�I_kg_c�� ijb\_eh� d g_dhlhjuf� g_^hjZamf_gbyf�� < [he__� iha^g_c_\j_ckdhc� ebl_jZlmj_� hq_gv� jZkijhkljZg_gh� bah[jZ`_gb_�`_gsbgu� \ \b^_� ^hfZ�� \ dhlhjhf^\_jv� kqblZ_lky� iheh\uf� hl\_jklb_f�� Fm`� `Zem_lky�� gZijbf_j�� \ kemqZ_� hlkmlkl\by^_\kl\_gghklb��qlh�gZr_e�^\_jv�hldjulhc��Kbf\he�klheZ�^ey�`_gsbgu�lZd`_�ba\_kl_g�\ wlhcebl_jZlmj_��@_gsbgZ� ]h\hjbl�h k\h_f�fm`_�� y ijb]hlh\beZ� _fm� klhe��gh�hg� _]h�i_j_\_jgme�Ojhfu_�^_lb�ihy\eyxlky�ba�aZ�lh]h��qlh�fm`�i_j_\_jgme�klhe��Wlb�nZdlu�y [_jm�ba�klZlvb�E�E_\b�ba�;jxggZ��©K_dkmZevgZy�kbf\hebdZ�[b[ebb�b lZefm^Zª��������Lh�� qlh� b dhjZ[eb� \ kgh\b^_gbb� hagZqZxl� `_gsbg�� ihykgyxl� gZf� wlbfheh]b�� dhlhju_ml\_j`^Zxl��qlh�i_j\hgZqZevgh�dhjZ[e_f��6FKLII��gZau\Zeky�]ebgyguc�khkm^�b wlh�[ueh�lh�`_keh\h�� qlh� h\pZ� �6FKDII��� =j_q_kdh_� kdZaZgb_� h I_jbZg^j_� ba� DhjbgnZ� b _]h� `_g_�F_ebkk_ih^l\_j`^Z_l��qlh�i_qv�hagZqZ_l�`_gsbgm�b qj_\h�fZl_jb��Dh]^Z��ih�=_jh^hlm��lbjZg�\ua\Zel_gv�k\h_c�]hjyqh�ex[bfhc��gh�m[blhc�ba�j_\ghklb�kmijm]b��qlh[u�ihemqblv�hl�g__�g_dhlhju_k\_^_gby��mf_jrZy�m^hklh\_jbeZ�k_[y�gZihfbgZgb_f��qlh�hg��I_jbZg^j��ihklZ\be�k\hc�oe_[�\oheh^gmx�i_qv��gZf_dZy�gZ�kh[ulb_��h dhlhjhf�gbdlh�^jm]hc�g_�fh]�agZlv��< ba^Zgghc�N��K�DjZmkkhf�$QWKURSRSK\WHLD��g_aZf_gbfhf�bklhqgbd_�\k_]h��qlh�dZkZ_lky�iheh\hc�`bagb�gZjh^h\�fu�qblZ_f��qlh�\ h^ghc�g_f_pdhc�f_klghklb�h `_gsbg_��jZaj_rb\r_cky�hl�[j_f_gb��]h\hjyl�qlh�m g__�h[\ZebeZkv�i_qv��Ijb]hlh\e_gb_�h]gy��\k_��qlh�k gbf�k\yaZgh��^h�]em[bgu�ijhgbdgmlhk_dkmZevghc�kbf\hebdhc��IeZfy�\k_]^Z�y\ey_lky�fm`kdbfb�]_gblZebyfb��Z f_klh�h]gy��hqZ]�²`_gkdbf�ehghf�?keb��[ulv�fh`_l��\u�m^b\eyebkv�lhfm��dZd�qZklh�eZg^rZnlu�\ kgh\b^_gbb�bkihevamxlky^ey� bah[jZ`_gby�`_gkdbo� ]_gblZebc�� lh� hl�fbnheh]h\� \u�fh`_l_� magZlv�� dZdmx� jhev�fZlv�a_fey�b]jZeZ�\ ij_^klZ\e_gbyo�b dmevlZo�^j_\ghklb�b dZd�ihgbfZgb_�a_fe_^_eby�hij_^_eyehkvwlhc� kbf\hebdhc�� Lh�� qlh� \ kgh\b^_gbb� dhfgZlZ� �=LPPHU�� ij_^klZ\ey_l� `_gsbgm�)UDXHQ]LPPHU��� \u� kdehggu� [m^_l_� h[tykgblv� mihlj_[e_gb_f� \ gZr_f� yaud_� keh\Z)UDXHQ]LPQDHU�>[Z[Z@�\f_klh�)UDX��l��_��aZf_gu�q_eh\_q_kdhc�ebqghklb�ij_^gZagZq_gguf�^ey�g__ihf_s_gb_f��Ih^h[guf�`_�h[jZahf�fu�]h\hjbf�h <ukhdhc�Ihjl_�b ih^jZamf_\Z_f�ih^�wlbfkmelZgZ�b _]h�ijZ\bl_evkl\h��gZa\Zgb_�^j_\g__]bi_lkdh]h�\eZklbl_ey�nZjZhgZ�lZd`_�hagZqZehg_�qlh�bgh_��dZd�©[hevrhc�^\hjª���< >j_\g_f�<hklhdZ�^\hju�f_`^m�^\hcgufb�\hjhlZfb�]hjh^Z

Page 87: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

y\eyxlky�f_klhf�k[hjbsZ��dZd�jughqgu_�iehsZ^b�\ deZkkbq_kdhf�fbj_���Y��ijZ\^Z��^mfZx��qlhwlh� h[tykg_gb_� kebrdhf� ih\_joghklgh�� Fg_� dZ`_lky� [he__� \_jhylguf�� qlh� dhfgZlZ� dZdijhkljZgkl\h��\dexqZxs__�\ k_[y�q_eh\_dZ��klZeZ�kbf\hehf�`_gsbgu��Fu�m`_�\_^v�agZ_f��qlhkeh\h� ©^hfª� mihlj_[ey_lky� \ wlhf� agZq_gbb�� ba� fbnheh]bb� b ihwlbq_kdbo� \ujZ`_gbc� fufh`_f� ^h[Z\blv� \ dZq_kl\_� ^jm]bo� kbf\heh\�`_gsbgu� _s_� ]hjh^�� aZfhd�� ^\hj_p�� dj_ihklv�<hijhk� [ueh� [u� e_]q_� j_rblv�� bkihevamy� kgh\b^_gby� ebp�� g_� agZxsbo� b g_� ihgbfZxsbog_f_pdh]h� yaudZ�� < ihke_^gb_� ]h^u� y e_qbe� ij_bfms_kl\_ggh� bghkljZgp_\� b�� gZkdhevdhihfgx��\ bo�yaudZo�g_�[ueh�ZgZeh]bqgh]h� keh\hmihlj_[e_gby��?klv�b ^jm]b_�^hdZaZl_evkl\Zlhfm�� qlh� kbf\hebq_kdh_� hlghr_gb_� fh`_l� i_j_clb� yaudh\u_� ]jZgbpu�� qlh�� \ijhq_f�� m`hml\_j`^Ze� klZjuc� bkke_^h\Zl_ev� kgh\b^_gbc� Rm[_jl� �������� <ijhq_f�� gb h^bg� ba� fhboiZpb_glh\�g_�[ue�Z[khexlgh�g_agZdhf�k g_f_pdbf�yaudhf��lZd�qlh�y ij_^hklZ\eyx�j_rblv�wlhl\hijhk� l_f� ikbohZgZeblbdZf�� dhlhju_� fh]ml� kh[jZlv� hiul� \ ^jm]bo� kljZgZo�� bkke_^my� ebp�\eZ^_xsbo�h^gbf�yaudhf�Kj_^b�kbf\heh\��bah[jZ`Zxsbo�fm`kdb_�]_gblZebb��_^\Z�eb�gZc^_lky�ohlv�h^bg��dhlhjucg_� mihlj_[eyeky� [u� \ rmlhqguo�� ijhklhgZjh^guo� beb�ihwlbq_kdbo� \ujZ`_gbyo�� hkh[_ggh� mdeZkkbq_kdbo� ihwlh\� ^j_\ghklb�� D gbf� hlghkylky� g_� lhevdh� kbf\heu�� \klj_qZxsb_ky� \kgh\b^_gbyo��gh�e gh\u_��gZijbf_j��jZaebqgu_�bgkljmf_glu��\ i_j\mx�hq_j_^v�iem]��<ijhq_f�dZkZykv� kbf\hebq_kdh]h� bah[jZ`_gby� fm`kdh]h�� fu� aZljZ]b\Z_f� hq_gv� rbjhdmx� b ]hjyqhhkiZjb\Z_fmx� h[eZklv�� hl� m]em[e_gby� \ dhlhjmx� ba� khh[jZ`_gbc� wdhghfbb� fu� ohlbf\ha^_j`Zlvky�� Ebrv� ih� ih\h^m� h^gh]h�� dZd� [u� \uiZ^Zxs_]h� ba� jy^Z� kbf\heZ� ©ljbª� fg_ohl_ehkv� [u� k^_eZlv� g_kdhevdh� aZf_qZgbc��?s_� g_ykgh�� g_� h[mkeh\e_gZ� eb� hlqZklb� k\ylhklvwlh]h�qbkeZ�^Zgguf�kbf\hebq_kdbf�hlghr_gb_f��Gh�g_khfg_gguf�dZ`_lky�lh��qlh�\ke_^kl\b_lZdh]h� kbf\hebq_kdh]h� hlghr_gby� g_dhlhju_� \klj_qZxsb_ky� \ ijbjh^_� lj_oqZklgu_ij_^f_lu��gZijbf_j� ljbebklgbd��bkihevamxlky� \ dZq_kl\_� ]_j[h\� b wf[e_f��LZd� gZau\Z_fZynjZgpmakdZy�ebeby��lh`_�lj_oqZklgZy��b kljZgguc�]_j[�^\mo�lZd�^Ze_dh�jZkiheh`_gguo�^jm]�hl^jm]Z� hkljh\h\�� dZd�Kbpbeby�b hkljh\�F_g�� 7ULVNHOHV� �ljb�ihemkh]gmlu_�gh]b��bkoh^ysb_�bah^gh]h� p_gljZ��� ih�\b^bfhfm�� lhevdh� klbebaZpby� fm`kdbo� ]_gblZebc�� < ^j_\ghklb� ih^h[byfm`kdh]h� qe_gZ� kqblZebkv� kZfufb� kbevgufb� aZsblgufb� kj_^kl\Zfb� �$SRWURSDHD�� ijhlb\^mjguo� \ebygbc�� b k� wlbf� k\yaZgh� lh�� qlh� \ ijbghkysbo� kqZklv_� Zfme_lZo� gZr_]h� \j_f_gb\k_]^Z�e_]dh�magZlv�]_gilZevgu_�beb�k_dkmZevgu_�kbf\heu��JZkkfhljbf�lZdhc�gZ[hj��dhlhjucghkblky� \ \b^_� fZe_gvdbo� k_j_[jyguo� [j_ehdh\�� q_luj_oebklguc� de_\_j�� k\bgvy�� ]jb[�ih^dh\Z�� e_klgbpZ� b ljm[hqbkl�� Q_luj_oebklguc� de_\_j�� kh[kl\_ggh� ]h\hjy�� aZf_gy_llj_oebklguc��k\bgvy�²�^j_\gbc�kbf\he�ieh^hjh^by��]jb[�²�g_khfg_ggh��kbf\he�i_gbkZ��_klv]jb[u�� dhlhju_� ba�aZ� k\h_]h� g_khfg_ggh]h� koh^kl\Z� k fm`kdbf� qe_ghf� ihemqbeb� ijbdeZkkbnbdZpbb� gZa\Zgb_� 3KDOOXV� LPSXGLFXV�� ih^dh\Z� ih\lhjy_l� hq_jlZgb_�`_gkdh]h� iheh\h]hhl\_jklby�� Z ljm[hqbkl�� g_kmsbc� e_klgbpm�� bf__l� hlghr_gb_� d wlhc� dhfiZgbb� ihlhfm�� qlh^_eZ_l� lZdb_� ^\b`_gby�� k dhlhjufb� \ ijhklhgZjh^v_� kjZ\gb\Z_lky� iheh\hc� Zdl� �kf�$QWKURSRSK\WHLD���K _]h�e_klgbp_c�dZd�k_dkmZevguf�kbf\hehf�fu�ihagZdhfbebkv�\ kgh\b^_gbb�gZf� gZ� ihfhsv� ijboh^bl� mihlj_[e_gb_� \ g_f_pdhf� yaud_� keh\Z� ©VWHLJHQª� >ih^gbfZlvky@�ijbf_gy_fh]h�\ ki_pbnbq_kdb�k_dkmZevghf�kfuke_��=h\hjyl�©'HQ�)UDXHQ�QDFKVWHLJHQª�>ijbklZ\Zlv�d `_gsbgZf@�b ©HLQ�DOWHU�6WHLJHUª�>klZjuc�\hehdblZ@�Ih�njZgpmakdb� klmi_gvdZ� gZau\Z_lky� OD� PDUFKH�� fu� gZoh^bf� kh\_jr_ggh� ZgZeh]bqgh_

Page 88: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ujZ`_gb_�^ey�klZjh]h�[hg\b\ZgZ�ZQ� YLHX[�PDUFKHDUª��K wlbf��\_jhylgh��k\yaZgh� lh��qlh�ijbiheh\hf�Zdl_�fgh]bo�djmiguo�`b\hlguo�kZf_p�\a[bjZ_lky��ih^gbfZ_lky��VWHLJHQ��EHVWHLJHQ��gZkZfdm�Kju\Zgb_� \_ldb� dZd� kbf\hebq_kdh_� bah[jZ`_gb_� hgZgbafZ� g_� lhevdh� kh\iZ^Z_l� kijhklhgZjh^guf� bah[jZ`_gb_f� hgZgbklbq_kdh]h� ZdlZ�� gh� bf__l� b ^Ze_dh� b^msb_fbnheh]bq_kdb_� iZjZee_eb�� Gh� hkh[_ggh� aZf_qZl_evgh� bah[jZ`_gb_� hgZgbafZ� beb�� emqr_kdZaZlv��gZdZaZgby�aZ�g_]h��dZkljZpbb��ihkj_^kl\hf�\uiZ^_gby�b \uju\Zgby�am[h\��ihlhfm�qlhwlhfm� _klv� ZgZeh]by� \ nhevdehj_�� dhlhjZy�� ^he`gh� [ulv�� ba\_klgZ� hq_gv� g_fgh]bf� ebpZf�\b^ysbf�bo�\h�kg_��Fg_�dZ`_lky�g_khfg_gguf��qlh�jZkijhkljZg_ggh_�m klhev�fgh]bo�gZjh^h\h[j_aZgb_�y\ey_lky�wd\b\Ze_glhf�b aZf_ghc�dZkljZpbb��B \hl�gZf�khh[sZxl��qlh�\ :\kljZebbba\_klgu_� ijbfblb\gu_� ie_f_gZ� \\h^yl� h[j_aZgb_� \ dZq_kl\_� jblmZeZ� ijb� gZklmie_gbbiheh\hc�aj_ehklb� �\h�\j_fy�ijZa^g_kl\�ih�kemqZx�gZklmie_gby�kh\_jr_gghe_lby���\ lh�\j_fydZd�^jm]b_��`b\msb_�kh\k_f�jy^hf��\f_klh�wlh]h�ZdlZ�\urb[Zxl�h^bg�am[�Wlbfb�ijbf_jZfb�y aZdhgqm�k\h_�baeh`_gb_��Wlh�\k_]h�ebrv�ijbf_ju��fu�[hevr_�agZ_fh[�wlhf��Z \u�fh`_l_�k_[_�ij_^klZ\blv��gZkdhevdh�kh^_j`Zl_evg__�b bgl_j_kg__�ihemqbehkv�[uih^h[gh_� kh[jZgb_� ijbf_jh\�� _keb� [u� hgh� [ueh� khklZ\e_gh� g_� ^be_lZglZfb�� dZd� fu�� ZgZklhysbfb� ki_pbZebklZfb� \ h[eZklb� fbnheh]bb�� Zgljhiheh]bb�� yaudhagZgby�� nhevdehjZ�GZijZrb\Zxlky� g_dhlhju_� \u\h^u�� dhlhju_� g_�fh]ml� [ulv� bkq_jiu\Zxsbfb�� gh� ^Zxl� gZfibsm�^ey�jZafure_gbc�<h�i_j\uo��fu� ihklZ\e_gu� i_j_^�nZdlhf�� qlh� \ jZkihjy`_gbb� \b^ys_]h� khg� gZoh^blkykbf\hebq_kdbc�kihkh[�\ujZ`_gby��dhlhjh]h�hg�g_�agZ_l�b g_�magZ_l�\ khklhygbb�[h^jkl\h\Zgby�Wlh�gZklhevdh�`_�ihjZabl_evgh��dZd�_keb�[u�\u�k^_eZeb�hldjulb_��qlh�\ZrZ�ijbkem]Z�ihgbfZ_lkZgkdjbl��ohly�\u�agZ_l_��qlh�hgZ�jh^beZkv�\ [h]_fkdhc�^_j_\g_�b gbdh]^Z�_]h�g_�bamqZeZ��IjbgZrbo�ikboheh]bq_kdbo�\haaj_gbyo�g_e_]dh�h[tykgblv� wlhl�nZdl��Fu�fh`_f� lhevdh�kdZaZlv�qlh� agZgb_� kbf\hebdb� g_� hkhagZ_lky� \b^_\rbf� khg�� hgh� hlghkblky� d _]h� [_kkhagZl_evghc^moh\ghc� `bagb�� Gh� b wlbf� ij_^iheh`_gb_f� fu� gbq_]h� g_� ^hklb]Z_f�� >h� kbo� ihj� gZfg_h[oh^bfh� [ueh� ij_^iheZ]Zlv� lhevdh� [_kkhagZl_evgu_� klj_fe_gby�� lZdb_�� h dhlhjuo� gZf\j_f_ggh�beb�ihklhyggh�gbq_]h�g_�ba\_klgh��L_i_jv�`_�j_qv�b^_l�h [_kkhagZl_evguo�agZgbyo��heh]bq_kdbo� hlghr_gbyo�� hlghr_gbyo� kjZ\g_gby� f_`^m� jZaebqgufb� h[t_dlZfb�� \ke_^kl\b_dhlhjuo�h^gh�ihklhyggh�fh`_l�aZf_sZlvky�^jm]bf��Wlb�kjZ\g_gby�g_�\hagbdZxl�dZ`^uc�jZaaZgh\h��hgb�m`_�aZeh`_gu�]hlh\ufb��aZ\_jr_gu�jZa�b gZ\k_]^Z��wlh�\ul_dZ_l�ba�bo�koh^kl\Z�mjZaebqguo�ebp��koh^kl\Z�^Z`_��ih�\b^bfhfm��g_kfhljy�gZ�jZaebqb_�yaudh\�Hldm^Z�`_� [_j_lky� agZgb_� wlbo� kbf\hebq_kdbo� hlghr_gbc"�Lhevdh� g_[hevrZy� bo� qZklvh[tykgy_lky� keh\hmihlj_[e_gb_f�� JZaghh[jZagu_� iZjZee_eb� ba� ^jm]bo� h[eZkl_c� ih� [hevr_cqZklb�g_ba\_klgu�\b^_\r_fm�khg��^Z�b fu�ebrv�k ljm^hf�hlukdb\Zeb�bo�<h�\lhjuo�� wlb� kbf\hebq_kdb_� hlghr_gby� g_� y\eyxlky� q_f�lh� lZdbf�� qlh� [ueh� [uoZjZdl_jgh� lhevdh� ^ey� \b^_\r_]h� khg� beb� ^ey� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby�� [eZ]h^Zjy� dhlhjhc� hgb\ujZ`Zxlky�� <_^v� fu� magZeb�� qlh� lZdZy� `_� kbf\hebdZ� bkihevam_lky� \ fbnZo� b kdZadZo�� \gZjh^guo�ih]h\hjdZo�b i_kgyo��\ h[s_ijbgylhf�keh\hmihlj_[e_gbb�b ihwlbq_kdhc�nZglZabb�H[eZklv�kbf\hebdb�qj_a\uqZcgh�h[rbjgZ�� kbf\hebdZ� kgh\b^_gbc� y\ey_lky� __�fZehc�qZklvx�^Z`_�g_p_e_khh[jZagh�ijbklmiZlv�d jZkkfhlj_gbx�\k_c�wlhc�ijh[e_fu�bkoh^y�ba�kgh\b^_gby�

Page 89: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Fgh]b_� mihlj_[bl_evgu_� \ ^jm]bo� h[eZklyo� kbf\heu� \ kgh\b^_gbyo� g_� \klj_qZxlky� beb\klj_qZxlky� ebrv� hq_gv� j_^dh�� g_dhlhju_� ba� kbf\heh\� kgh\b^_gbc� \klj_qZxlky� g_� \h� \k_o^jm]bo� h[eZklyo�� Z lhevdh� \ lhc�beb�bghc��<hagbdZ_l� \i_qZle_gb_�� qlh�i_j_^�gZfb� dZdhc�lh^j_\gbc��gh�mljZq_gguc�kihkh[�\ujZ`_gby��hl�dhlhjh]h�\ jZaguo�h[eZklyo�khojZgbehkv�jZagh_�h^gh�lhevdh�a^_kv��^jm]h_�lhevdh�lZf��lj_lv_�\ ke_]dZ�baf_g_gghc�nhjf_�\ g_kdhevdbo�h[eZklyo�Y ohqm�\kihfgblv�a^_kv�nZglZabx�h^gh]h�bgl_j_kgh]h�^mr_\gh[hevgh]h��\hh[jZ`Z\r_]h�k_[_dZdhc�lh� ©hkgh\ghc� yaudª�� hl� dhlhjh]h� \h� \k_o� wlbo� kbf\hebq_kdbo� hlghr_gbyo� [m^lh� [ubf_ebkv�hklZldb�<�lj_lvbo�� \Zf� ^he`gh� [ueh� [jhkblvky� \ ]eZaZ�� qlh� kbf\hebdZ� \ ^jm]bo� mdZaZgguoh[eZklyo� g_� lhevdh� k_dkmZevgZy�� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd� \ kgh\b^_gbb� kbf\heu� bkihevamxlky� ihqlbbkdexqbl_evgh�^ey�\ujZ`_gby�k_dkmZevguo�h[t_dlh\�b hlghr_gbc��B wlh�g_e_]dh�h[tykgblv�G_�gZreb�eb�bkoh^gh�k_dkmZevgh�agZqbfu_�kbf\heu�iha^g__�^jm]h_�ijbf_g_gb_�b g_�k\yaZg�ebk wlbf�ba\_klguc�i_j_oh^�hl�kbf\hebq_kdh]h�bah[jZ`_gby�d ^jm]hfm�_]h�\b^m"�GZ�wlhl�\hijhk�hq_\b^gh�� g_evay� hl\_lblv�� _keb� bf_lv� ^_eh� lhevdh� k kbf\hebdhc� kgh\b^_gbc��Fh`gh� ebrvij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� kms_kl\m_l� hkh[_ggh� l_kgh_� hlghr_gb_� f_`^m� bklbggufb� kbf\heZfb� bk_dkmZevghklvx�Ih� wlhfm� ih\h^m� gZf� [ueh� ^Zgh� \ ihke_^gb_� ]h^u� h^gh� \Z`gh_� mdZaZgb_��Nbeheh]� =�Ri_j[_j� �MikZeZ��� jZ[hlZxsbc� g_aZ\bkbfh� hl�ikbohZgZebaZ�� \u^\bgme� ������� ml\_j`^_gb_�qlh�k_dkmZevgu_�ihlj_[ghklb�ijbgbfZeb�kZfh_�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh_�mqZklb_�\ \hagbdgh\_gbb�b^Zevg_cr_f� jZa\blbb� yaudZ�� GZqZevgu_� a\mdb� j_qb� kem`beb� khh[s_gbx� b ih^au\Zebk_dkmZevgh]h� iZjlg_jZ�� ^Zevg_cr__� jZa\blb_� dhjg_c� keh\� khijh\h`^Zeh� ljm^h\u_� hi_jZpbbi_j\h[ulgh]h� q_eh\_dZ�� Wlb� jZ[hlu� [ueb� kh\f_klgufb� b ijhoh^beb� \ khijh\h`^_gbbjblfbq_kdb�ih\lhjy_fuo�yaudh\uo�\ujZ`_gbc��Ijb�wlhf�k_dkmZevguc�bgl_j_k�i_j_ghkbeky�gZjZ[hlm��H^gh\j_f_ggh�i_j\h[ulguc�q_eh\_d�^_eZe�ljm^�ijbylguf�^ey�k_[y��ijbgbfZy�_]h� aZwd\b\Ze_gl�b aZf_gm�iheh\hc�^_yl_evghklb��LZdbf�h[jZahf��ijhbaghkbfh_�ijb�h[s_c�jZ[hl_keh\h�bf_eh�^\Z� agZq_gby��h[hagZqZy�dZd�iheh\hc�Zdl��lZd�b ijbjZ\g_ggmx�d g_fm� ljm^h\mx^_yl_evghklv��Kh�\j_f_g_f�keh\h�hk\h[h^behkv�hl�k_dkmZevgh]h�agZq_gby�b aZnbdkbjh\Zehkv�gZwlhc�jZ[hl_��Ke_^mxsb_�ihdhe_gby�ihklmiZeb� lhqgh� lZd�`_� k gh\uf� keh\hf�� dhlhjh_�bf_ehk_dkmZevgh_�agZq_gb_�b ijbf_gyehkv�d gh\hfm�\b^m�ljm^Z��LZdbf�h[jZahf�\hagbdZeh�dZdh_�lhqbkeh�dhjg_c�keh\��dhlhju_�\k_�[ueb�k_dkmZevgh]h�ijhbkoh`^_gby��Z aZl_f�ebrbebkv�k\h_]hk_dkmZevgh]h� agZq_gby�� ?keb� \ur_baeh`_ggZy� lhqdZ� aj_gby� ijZ\bevgZ�� lh� i_j_^� gZfi�� \h\kydhf� kemqZ_�� hldju\Z_lky� \hafh`ghklv� ihgbfZgby� kbf\hebdb� kgh\b^_gbc��Fu� fh]eb� [uihgylv�� ihq_fm� \ kgh\b^_gbb�� khojZgyxs_f� dh_�qlh� ba� wlbo� kZfuo� ^j_\gbo� hlghr_gbc�bf__lky� lZdh_� h]jhfgh_� fgh`_kl\h� kbf\heh\� ^ey� k_dkmZevgh]h�� ihq_fm� \ h[s_f� hjm`b_� bhjm^by� kbf\hebabjmxl� fm`kdh_�� fZl_jbZeu� b lh�� qlh� h[jZ[Zlu\Z_lky�²� `_gkdh_�Kbf\hebq_kdh_�hlghr_gb_�[ueh�[u�hklZldhf�^j_\g_c�ijbgZ^e_`ghklb� keh\Z��\_sb��dhlhju_dh]^Z�lh�gZau\Zebkv�lZd�`_��dZd�b ]_gblZebb��fh]eb�l_i_jv�\ kgh\b^_gbb�\uklmiblv�^ey�lh]h�`_\ dZq_kl\_�kbf\heh\�Gh� [eZ]h^Zjy� wlbf� iZjZee_eyf� d kbf\hebd_� kgh\b^_gbc� \u� fh`_l_� lZd`_� hp_gblvoZjZdl_jgmx� hkh[_gghklv� ikbohZgZebaZ�� [eZ]h^Zjy� dhlhjhc� hg� klZgh\blky� ij_^f_lhf\k_h[s_]h� bgl_j_kZ�� q_]h� g_� fh]ml� ^h[blvky� gb� ikboheh]by�� gb� ikbobZljby�� Ijb

Page 90: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� jZ[hl_� aZ\yau\Zxlky� hlghr_gby� k hq_gv� fgh]bfb� ^jm]bfb]mfZgblZjgufb� gZmdZfb�� k fbnheh]b_c�� Z lZd`_� k yaudhagZgb_f�� nhevdehjhf�� ikboheh]b_cgZjh^h\� b j_eb]bh\_^_gb_f�� bamq_gb_� dhlhjuo� h[_sZ_l� p_gg_crb_� j_amevlZlu�� <Zf� [m^_lihgylgh�� ihq_fm� gZ� ihq\_� ikbohZgZebaZ� \ujhk� `mjgZe� ,PDJR�� hkgh\Zgguc� \ ����� ]�� ih^j_^Zdpb_c�=ZgkZ�KZdkZ�b Hllh�JZgdZ��ihklZ\b\rbc�k_[_�bkdexqbl_evgmx�aZ^Zqm�ih^^_j`b\Zlvwlb� hlghr_gby�� <h� \k_o� wlbo� hlghr_gbyo� ikbohZgZeba� kgZqZeZ� [hevr_� ^Z\Ze�� q_f� ihemqZe�Ohly�b hg�ba\e_dZ_l�\u]h^m�ba�lh]h��qlh�_]h�k\h_h[jZagu_�j_amevlZlu�ih^l\_j`^Zxlky�\ ^jm]boh[eZklyo� b l_f� kZfuf� klZgh\ylky� [he__� ^hklh\_jgufb�� gh� \ p_ehf� bf_ggh� ikbohZgZebaij_^eh`be�l_�l_ogbq_kdb_�ijb_fu�b ih^oh^u��ijbf_g_gb_�dhlhjuo�hdZaZehkv�ieh^hl\hjguf�\wlbo� ^jm]bo� h[eZklyo���� >mr_\gZy� `bagv� hl^_evgh]h� q_eh\_q_kdh]h� kms_kl\Z� ^Z_l� ijbikbohZgZeblbq_kdhf�bkke_^h\Zgbb�k\_^_gby��k ihfhsvx�dhlhjuo�fu�fh`_f�jZaj_rblv�beb�ihdjZcg_c�f_j_�ijZ\bevgh�hk\_lblv�g_dhlhju_�lZcgu�ba�`bagb�q_eh\_q_kdbo�fZkk�<ijhq_f�� y \Zf� _s_� g_� kdZaZe�� ijb� dZdbo� h[klhyl_evkl\Zo� fu� fh`_f� ]em[`_� \k_]haZ]eygmlv�\ lhl�ij_^iheZ]Z_fuc�©hkgh\ghc�yaudª��ba�dZdhc�h[eZklb�magZlv�h g_f�[hevr_�\k_]h�IhdZ� \u� wlh]h� g_� agZ_l_�� \u� g_� fh`_l_� hp_gblv� \k_]h� agZq_gby� ij_^f_lZ�� H[eZklvx� wlhcy\ey_lky� g_\jhlbdZ�� fZl_jbZehf� ²� kbfilhfu� b ^jm]b_� g_\jhlbq_kdb_� ijhy\e_gby�� ^eyh[tykg_gby�b e_q_gby�dhlhjuo�b [ue�kha^Zg�ikbohZgZeba�JZkkfZljb\Zy� \hijhk� k q_l\_jlhc� lhqdb� aj_gby�� fu� hiylv� \ha\jZsZ_fky� d gZqZem� bgZijZ\ey_fky� ih� gZf_q_gghfm� imlb��Fu� kdZaZeb�� qlh� ^Z`_� _keb� [u� p_gamju� kgh\b^_gby� g_[ueh��gZf�\k_�jZ\gh�[ueh�[u�g_e_]dh�ihgylv� kgh\b^_gb_��ihlhfm�qlh�i_j_^�gZfb� \klZeZ�[uaZ^ZqZ�i_j_\_klb�yaud�kbf\heh\�gZ�yaud�gZr_]h�fure_gby�\ khklhygbb�[h^jkl\h\Zgby��LZdbfh[jZahf��kbf\hebdZ�y\ey_lky�\lhjuf�b g_aZ\bkbfuf�nZdlhjhf�bkdZ`_gby�kgh\b^_gby�gZjy^m�kp_gamjhc��GZijZrb\Z_lky�ij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh�p_gamj_� m^h[gh� ihevah\Zlvky� kbf\hebdhc�� lZddZd�hgZ�lh`_�klj_fblky�d lhc�`_�p_eb�²�k^_eZlv�kgh\b^_gb_�kljZgguf�b g_ihgylguf�Kdhjh�klZg_l�ykgh��g_�gZlhedg_fky�eb�fu�ijb�^Zevg_cr_f�bamq_gbb�kgh\b^_gby�gZ�gh\ucnZdlhj�� kihkh[kl\mxsbc� bkdZ`_gbx� kgh\b^_gby�� Y g_� ohl_e� [u� hklZ\eylv� l_fm� kbf\hebdbkgh\b^_gby��g_�dhkgm\rbkv�_s_�jZa�lh]h�aZ]Z^hqgh]h�h[klhyl_evkl\Z��qlh�hgZ�fh`_l�\klj_lblv\_kvfZ�wg_j]bqgh_�khijhlb\e_gb_�h[jZah\Zgguo�ex^_c��lh]^Z�dZd�jZkijhkljZg_gb_�kbf\hebdb\ fbnZo��j_eb]bb��bkdmkkl\_�b yaud_�kh\_jr_ggh�g_khfg_ggh��M`�g_�hij_^_ey_lky�eb�wlh�\gh\vhlghr_gb_f�d k_dkmZevghklb"H>BGG:>P:L:Y�E?DPBYJZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gbyM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� ?keb� \u� mk\hbeb� kmsghklv� p_gamju� kgh\b^_gby� bkbf\hebq_kdh]h� bah[jZ`_gby�� ohly� _s_� b g_� kh\k_f� jZaj_rbeb� \hijhk� h[� bkdZ`_gbbkgh\b^_gby�� \u� \k_�lZdb� \ khklhygbb�ihgylv� [hevrbgkl\h� kgh\b^_gbc��Ijb� wlhf� \u�fh`_l_ihevah\Zlvky� h[_bfb� ^hihegyxsbfb� ^jm]� ^jm]Z� l_ogbdZfb�� \uau\Zy� m \b^_\r_]h� khgZkkhpbZlb\gu_� fukeb� ^h� l_o� ihj�� ihdZ� g_� ijhgbdg_l_� hl� aZf_klbl_ey� d kh[kl\_gghfm>kh^_j`Zgbx@��ih^klZ\eyy�^ey�kbf\heh\�bo�agZq_gb_��bkoh^y�ba�k\hbo�kh[kl\_gguo�agZgbc��H[

Page 91: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hij_^_e_gguo�\hagbdZxsbo�ijb�wlhf�khfg_gbyo�j_qv�[m^_l�b^lb�gb`_�L_i_jv�fu�fh`_f�hiylv�\aylvky�aZ�jZ[hlm��dhlhjmx�\ k\h_�\j_fy�iulZebkv�k^_eZlv��g_�bf_y^ey�wlh]h�^hklZlhqgh�kj_^kl\��dh]^Z�fu�bamqZeb�hlghr_gby�f_`^m�we_f_glZfb�kgh\b^_gby�b_]h� kh[kl\_gguf� >kh^_j`Zgb_f@� b mklZgh\beb� ijb� wlhf� q_luj_� lZdbo� hkgh\guo� hlghr_gby�qZklb� d p_ehfm�� ijb[eb`_gby�� beb� gZf_dZ�� kbf\hebq_kdh]h� hlghr_gby� b gZ]ey^gh]hbah[jZ`_gby�keh\Z��Lh�`_�kZfh_�fu�ohlbf�ij_^ijbgylv�\ [hevr_f�fZkrlZ[_��kjZ\gb\Zy�y\gh_kh^_j`Zgb_�kgh\b^_gby�\ p_ehf�kh�kdjuluf�kgh\b^_gb_f��gZc^_gguf�iml_f�lhedh\Zgby�GZ^_xkv�� \u� gbdh]^Z� g_� i_j_imlZ_l_� bo� ^jm]� k ^jm]hf�� ?keb� \u� ^h[v_l_kv� wlh]h�� lh^hklb]g_l_� \ ihgbfZgbb� kgh\b^_gby� [hevr_]h�� q_f�� \_jhylgh�� [hevrbgkl\h� qblZl_e_c� fh_cdgb]b�Lhedh\Zgb_�kgh\b^_gbc��Iha\hevl_�_s_�jZa�gZihfgblv��qlh�lZ�jZ[hlZ��dhlhjZy�i_j_\h^blkdjulh_� kgh\b^_gb_� \ y\gh_�� gZau\Z_lky� jZ[hlhc� kgh\b^_gby� �7UDXPDUEHLW��� JZ[hlZ�ijh^_eu\Z_fZy�\ h[jZlghf�gZijZ\e_gbb��dhlhjZy�bf__l�p_evx�hl�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby�^h[jZlvky^h�kdjulh]h��y\ey_lky�gZr_c�jZ[hlhc�lhedh\Zgby��'HXWXQJVDUEHLW���JZ[hlZ�lhedh\Zgby�klj_fblkymkljZgblv� jZ[hlm� kgh\b^_gby�� IjbagZggu_� hq_\b^guf� bkiheg_gb_f� `_eZgby� kgh\b^_gby^_lkdh]h� lbiZ� \k_�lZdb� bkiulZeb� gZ� k_[_� qZklbqgmx� jZ[hlm� kgh\b^_gby�� Z bf_ggh� i_j_\h^`_eZgby�\ j_Zevghklv�b ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�lZd`_�i_j_\h^�fuke_c�\ \bamZevgu_�h[jZau��A^_kv�g_lj_[m_lky� gbdZdh]h� lhedh\Zgby�� lhevdh� h[jZlguc� oh^� wlbo� ^\mo� ij_\jZs_gbc�� Lh�� qlhijb[Z\ey_lky�d jZ[hl_�kgh\b^_gby�\ ^jm]bo�kgh\b^_gbyo��fu�gZau\Z_f�bkdZ`_gb_f�kgh\b^_gby�7UDXPHQWVWHOOXQJ���bf_ggh�_]h�b gm`gh�mkljZgblv�ihkj_^kl\hf�gZr_c�jZ[hlu�lhedh\Zgby�KjZ\gb\Zy� [hevrh_� dhebq_kl\h� lhedh\Zgbc� kgh\b^_gbc�� y \� khklhygbb� ihke_^h\Zl_evghihdZaZlv� \Zf�� qlh� ijh^_eu\Z_l� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby� k fZl_jbZehf� kdjuluo� _]h� fuke_c��Gh� yijhrm�\Zk�g_�lj_[h\Zlv�hl�wlh]h�kebrdhf�fgh]h]h��Wlh�\k_]h�ebrv�hibkZgb_��dhlhjh_�gm`gh\ukemrZlv�kh�kihdhcguf�\gbfZgb_f�I_j\uf�^hklb`_gb_f�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gby�y\ey_lky�k]ms_gb_� �9HUGLFKWXQJ���Ih^�wlbf�fuih^jZamf_\Z_f�lhl�nZdl��qlh�y\gh_�kgh\b^_gb_�kh^_j`bl�f_gvr_��q_f�kdjulh_��l��_��y\ey_lkyk\h_]h� jh^Z� khdjZs_gguf� i_j_\h^hf� ihke_^g_]h�� Bgh]^Z� k]ms_gb_� fh`_l� hlkmlkl\h\Zlv�h^gZdh�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� hgh� bf__lky� b hq_gv� qZklh� ^Z`_� qj_af_jgh_�� Gh� gbdh]^Z� g_� [u\Z_lh[jZlgh]h�� l�� _�� qlh[u� y\gh_� kgh\b^_gb_� [ueh� [hevr_� kdjulh]h� ih� h[t_fm� b kh^_j`Zgbx�K]ms_gb_�ijhbkoh^bl�[eZ]h^Zjy�lhfm��qlh����hij_^_e_ggu_�kdjulu_�we_f_glu�\hh[s_�himkdZxlky�����\ y\gh_�kgh\b^_gb_�i_j_oh^bllhevdh�qZklv�g_dhlhjuo�dhfie_dkh\�kdjulh]h�kgh\b^_gby�����kdjulu_�we_f_glu��bf_xsb_�qlh�lh�h[s__��\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb�kh_^bgyxlky��keb\Zxlky�\ h^gh�p_eh_�?keb� ohlbl_�� lh� fh`_l_� khojZgblv� gZa\Zgb_� ©k]ms_gb_ª� lhevdh� ^ey� wlh]h� ihke_^g_]hijhp_kkZ��?]h�j_amevlZlu�fh`gh�hkh[_ggh�e_]dh�ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv��Ba� k\hbo� kh[kl\_gguokgh\b^_gbc�\u�[_a�ljm^Z�\kihfgbl_�h k]ms_gbb�jZaebqguo�ebp�\ h^gh�LZdh_�kf_rZggh_�ebph\u]ey^bl�dZd�:��gh�h^_lh�dZd�;��kh\_jrZ_l�dZdh_�lh�^_ckl\b_��dZdh_��ihfgblky��^_eZe�<��Z ijbwlhf� agZ_rv�� qlh� wlh� ebph� ²� =�� Dhg_qgh�� [eZ]h^Zjy� lZdhfm� kf_rb\Zgbx� hkh[_gghih^q_jdb\Z_lky� qlh�lh� h[s__� ^ey� \k_o� q_luj_o� ebp�� LZd�`_� dZd� b ba� ebp�� fh`gh� khklZ\blvkf_kv�ba�ij_^f_lh\�beb�ba�f_klghkl_c��_keb�kh[ex^Z_lky�mkeh\b_��qlh�hl^_evgu_�ij_^f_lu�bf_klghklb�bf_xl� qlh�lh� h[s__�f_`^m� kh[hc�� \u^_ey_fh_� kdjuluf� kgh\b^_gb_f��Wlh� qlh�lh

Page 92: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\jh^_� h[jZah\Zgby�gh\h]h�b fbfhe_lgh]h�ihgylby� k wlbf� h[sbf� \ dZq_kl\_� y^jZ��;eZ]h^ZjygZdeZ^u\Zgbx�^jm]�gZ�^jm]Z� hl^_evguo� k]msZ_fuo� _^bgbp� \hagbdZ_l�� dZd�ijZ\beh��g_ykgZy�jZkieu\qZlZy�dZjlbgZ��ih^h[gh�lhc��dhlhjZy�ihemqZ_lky��_keb�gZ�h^ghc�nhlhieZklbgd_�k^_eZlvg_kdhevdh�kgbfdh\�>ey� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� h[jZah\Zgb_� lZdbo� kf_k_c� hq_gv� \Z`gh�� ihlhfm� qlh� fu� fh`_f^hdZaZlv��qlh�g_h[oh^bfu_�^ey�wlh]h�h[sb_�ijbagZdb�gZjhqgh�kha^Zxlky�lZf��]^_�bo�jZgvr_�g_[ueh�� gZijbf_j�� [eZ]h^Zjy� \u[hjm� keh\_kgh]h� \ujZ`_gby� dZdhc�eb[h� fukeb�� Fu� m`_ihagZdhfbebkv� k lZdbfb� k]ms_gbyfb� b kf_r_gbyfb�� hgb� b]jZeb� jhev� \ \hagbdgh\_gbbg_dhlhjuo�kemqZ_\�h]h\hjhd��<kihfgbl_�fheh^h]h�q_eh\_dZ��dhlhjuc�ohl_e�EVJOHLWGLJHQ�^Zfm�Djhf_� lh]h�� bf_xlky� hkljhlu�� f_oZgbaf� \hagbdgh\_gby� dhlhjuo� h[tykgy_lky� lZdbfk]ms_gb_f��H^gZdh�g_aZ\bkbfh�hl�wlh]h�fh`gh�ml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�^Zgguc�ijhp_kk�y\ey_lky�q_f�lh�g_h[uqguf�b kljZgguf��IjZ\^Z��h[jZah\Zgb_�kf_rZgguo�ebp�\ kgh\b^_gbb�bf__l�ZgZeh]bb\ g_dhlhjuo�l\hj_gbyo�gZr_c�nZglZabb��dhlhjZy�e_]dh�kh_^bgy_l�\ h^gh�p_eh_�khklZ\gu_�qZklb�\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�g_�k\yaZggu_�f_`^m�kh[hc�²�gZijbf_j��d_glZ\ju�b kdZahqgu_�`b\hlgu_�\^j_\g_c�fbnheh]bb�beb�gZ�dZjlbgZo�;_debgZ��<_^v� ©l\hjq_kdZy�nZglZabyª�\hh[s_�g_�fh`_lbah[j_klb�gbq_]h�gh\h]h��Z lhevdh�kh_^bgy_l�qm`^u_�^jm]�^jm]m�khklZ\gu_�qZklb��Gh�kljZgguf\ kihkh[_� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� y\ey_lky� ke_^mxs__�� fZl_jbZe�� dhlhjuf� jZkiheZ]Z_l� jZ[hlZkgh\b^_gby��khklhbl�\_^v�ba�fuke_c��fuke_c��g_dhlhju_�ba�dhlhjuo�fh]ml�[ulv�g_ijbebqgufbb g_ijb_fe_fufb�� h^gZdh� hgb� ijZ\bevgh� h[jZah\Zgu� b \ujZ`_gu�� Wlb� fukeb� i_j_\h^ylky[eZ]h^Zjy�jZ[hl_�kgh\b^_gby�\ ^jm]mx�nhjfm��b kljZggh�b g_ihgylgh��qlh�ijb�wlhf�i_j_\h^_�i_j_g_k_gbb�dZd�[u�gZ�^jm]hc�rjbnl�beb�yaud�gZoh^yl�k\h_�ijbf_g_gb_�kj_^kl\Z�kebygby�bdhf[bgZpbb�� <_^v� h[uqgh� i_j_\h^� klZjZ_lky� ijbgylv� \h� \gbfZgb_� bf_xsb_ky� \ l_dkl_jZaebqby��Z koh^kl\Z�g_�kf_rb\Zlv�f_`^m�kh[hc��JZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby�klj_fblky�d kh\_jr_gghijhlb\hiheh`ghfm��k]mklblv�^\_�jZaebqgu_�fukeb�lZdbf�h[jZahf��qlh[u�gZclb�fgh]hagZqgh_keh\h��\ dhlhjhf�h[_�fukeb�fh]ml�kh_^bgblvky��ih^h[gh�lhfm��dZd�wlh�^_eZ_lky�\ hkljhl_��Wlhli_j_oh^�g_evay�ihgylv�kjZam��gh�^ey�ihgbfZgby�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gby�hg�fh`_l�bf_lv�[hevrh_agZq_gb_�Ohly� k]ms_gb_� ^_eZ_l� kgh\b^_gb_� g_ihgylguf�� \k_�lZdb� g_� \hagbdZ_l� \i_qZle_gby�� qlhhgh� y\ey_lky� j_amevlZlhf� ^_ckl\by� p_gamju� kgh\b^_gby�� Kdhj__�� ohq_lky� h[tykgblv� _]hf_oZgbq_kdbfb� b wdhghfbq_kdbfb� nZdlhjZfb�� h^gZdh� ijboh^blky� ijbgbfZlv� \ jZkq_l� bp_gamjm�J_amevlZlu�k]ms_gby�fh]ml�[ulv�kh\_jr_ggh�bkdexqbl_evgufb��K _]h�ihfhsvx�bgh]^Z\hafh`gh�h[t_^bgblv�^\_�kh\_jr_ggh�jZaebqgu_�kdjulu_�fukeb�\ h^ghf�y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb�lZd�qlh�fh`gh�ihemqblv�h^gh�\jh^_�[u�m^h\e_l\hjyxs__�lhedh\Zgb_�kgh\b^_gby�b \k_�`_�ijbwlhf�mimklblv�\hafh`ghklv�^jm]h]h�Ke_^kl\b_f�k]ms_gby�y\ey_lky�lZd`_�hlghr_gb_�f_`^m�kdjuluf�b y\guf�kgh\b^_gb_f�aZdexqZxs__ky� \ lhf�� qlh� f_`^m� jZaebqgufb� we_f_glZfb� b g_� khojZgy_lky� ijhklh]hkhhl\_lkl\by�� H^bg� y\guc� we_f_gl� khhl\_lkl\m_l� h^gh\j_f_ggh� g_kdhevdbf� kdjuluf�� bgZh[hjhl�� h^bg� kdjuluc� we_f_gl� fh`_l� mqZkl\h\Zlv� \ g_kdhevdbo� y\guo� dZd� [u� \ \b^_i_j_dj_klZ�� Ijb� lhedh\Zgbb� kgh\b^_gby� hdZau\Z_lky� lZd`_�� qlh� >ZkkhpbZlb\gu_@� fukeb� dhl^_evghfm�y\ghfm�we_f_glm�g_�\k_]^Z�ijboh^yl�ih�ihjy^dm��QZklh�ijboh^blky�`^Zlv��ihdZ�\k_

Page 93: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kgh\b^_gb_�g_�[m^_l�bklhedh\Zgh�BlZd�� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby� kh\_jrZ_l� hq_gv� g_h[uqgmx� ih� nhjf_� ljZgkdjbipbx� fuke_ckgh\b^_gby�²�g_�i_j_\h^�keh\Z�aZ�keh\hf�beb�agZdZ�aZ�agZdhf�b g_�\u[hj�ih�hij_^_e_gghfmijZ\bem��dh]^Z�i_j_^Zxlky�lhevdh�kh]eZkgu_�dZdh]h�gb[m^v�keh\Z��Z ]eZkgu_�himkdZxlky��qlhfh`gh� [ueh� [u� gZa\Zlv� ij_^klZ\bl_evkl\hf�� l�� _�� h^bg� we_f_gl� \k_]^Z� ba\e_dZ_lky� \f_klhg_kdhevdbo�²�gh�wlh�g_qlh�^jm]h_�b ]hjZa^h�[he__�keh`gh_�<lhjuf� j_amevlZlhf� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� y\ey_lky� kf_s_gb_� �9HU�VFKLHEXQJ��� >ey� _]hihgbfZgby�fu��d kqZklvx��ijh\_eb�ih^]hlh\bl_evgmx�jZ[hlm��\_^v�fu�agZ_f��qlh�hgh�p_ebdhfy\ey_lky�^_ehf�p_gamju�kgh\b^_gby��Hgh�ijhy\ey_lky�^\hydbf�h[jZahf��\h�i_j\uo��\ lhf��qlhdZdhc�lh�kdjuluc�we_f_gl�aZf_sZ_lky�g_�kh[kl\_gghc�khklZ\ghc�qZklvx��Z q_f�lh�hl^Ze_gguf�l�� _�� gZf_dhf�� Z \h�\lhjuo�� \ lhf�� qlh� ikbobq_kdbc� Zdp_gl� kf_sZ_lky� k dZdh]h�lh� \Z`gh]hwe_f_glZ� gZ� ^jm]hc�� g_� \Z`guc�� lZd� qlh� \ kgh\b^_gbb� \hagbdZ_l� bghc� p_glj� b hgh� dZ`_lkykljZgguf�AZf_s_gb_�gZf_dhf�ba\_klgh�gZf�b ih� gZr_fm�fure_gbx� \ [h^jkl\mxs_f� khklhygbb�h^gZdh� a^_kv� _klv� jZaebqb_��Ijb�fure_gbb� \ [h^jkl\mxs_f� khklhygbb� gZf_d� ^he`_g� [ulve_]dh� ihgylguf�� Z aZf_klbl_ev� �bf_lv� kfukeh\h_� hlghr_gb_� d kh[kl\_gghfm� >kh^_j`Zgbx@�(LJHQWOLFKH��B hkljhlZ�qZklh�ihevam_lky�gZf_dhf��hgZ�hldZau\Z_lky� hl� ZkkhpbZpbb�ih� kh^_j`Zgbx�baZf_gy_l� __ g_h[uqgufb� \g_rgbfb� ZkkhpbZpbyfb�� lZdbfb�� dZd� kha\mqb_� b fgh]hagZqghklvkeh\Z�b ^j��Gh�hgZ�khojZgy_l�ihgylghklv��hkljhlZ�ebrbeZkv�[u�\k_]h�k\h_]h�^_ckl\by��_keb�[ug_evay� [ueh�[_a� ljm^Z�ijh^_eZlv� h[jZlguc� imlv� hl� gZf_dZ� d kh[kl\_gghfm� kh^_j`Zgbx��GhgZf_d� kf_s_gby� \ kgh\b^_gbb� k\h[h^_g� hl� h[hbo� h]jZgbq_gbc�� Hg� k\yaZg� k aZf_sZ_fufwe_f_glhf�kZfufb�\g_rgbfb�b hl^Ze_ggufb�hlghr_gbyfb�b ihwlhfm�g_ihgyl_g�� Z _keb� _]hjZatykgblv�� lh� lhedh\Zgb_� ijhba\h^bl� \i_qZle_gb_� g_m^Zqghc� hkljhlu� beb� gZkbevkl\_gghijblygmlhc� aZ� \hehku�� ijbgm`^_gghc� bgl_jij_lZpbb��P_gamjZ� lhevdh� lh]^Z� ^hklb]Z_l� k\h_cp_eb�� dh]^Z� _c� m^Z_lky� iheghklvx� aZl_fgblv� h[jZlguc� imlv� hl� gZf_dZ� d kh[kl\_gghfm>kh^_j`Zgbx@�Kf_s_gb_� Zdp_glZ� dZd� kj_^kl\h� \ujZ`_gby� fukeb� g_� \klj_qZ_lky�� Ijb� fure_gbb� \[h^jkl\mxs_f� khklhygbb� fu� bgh]^Z� ^himkdZ_f� _]h� ^ey� ^hklb`_gby� dhfbq_kdh]h� wnn_dlZ�<i_qZle_gb_�hrb[db��dhlhjh_�hgh�ijhba\h^bl��y fh]m�m \Zk�\ua\Zlv��gZihfgb\�h^bg�Zg_d^hl��\^_j_\g_� [ue� dmag_p�� dhlhjuc� kh\_jrbe� ij_klmie_gb_�� ^hklhcgh_� kf_jlghc� dZagb�� Km^ihklZgh\be��qlh�hg�^he`_g�ihg_klb�gZdZaZgb_�aZ�k\h_�ij_klmie_gb_��gh�lZd�dZd�\ ^_j_\g_�[uelhevdh�h^bg�dmag_p�b hg�[ue�g_h[oh^bf��ihjlguo�`_�\ ^_j_\g_�`beh�ljh_��lh�h^bg�ba�wlbo�lj_o[ue�ih\_r_g�\f_klh�g_]h�Lj_lbc� j_amevlZl� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� ikboheh]bq_kdb� kZfuc� bgl_j_kguc��Hg� khklhbl� \ij_\jZs_gbb� fuke_c� \ ajbl_evgu_� h[jZau�� AZihfgbf�� qlh� g_� \k_� \ fukeyo� kgh\b^_gbyih^e_`bl� wlhfm� ij_\jZs_gbx�� dh_�qlh� khojZgy_l� k\hx� nhjfm� b ihy\ey_lky� \ y\ghfkgh\b^_gbb� dZd� fukev� beb� agZgb_�� ajbl_evgu_� h[jZau� y\eyxlky� lZd`_� g_� _^bgkl\_gghcnhjfhc�� \ dhlhjmx� ij_\jZsZxlky� fukeb�� H^gZdh� hgb� \k_�lZdb� y\eyxlky� kms_kl\_ggufnZdlhjhf�\ h[jZah\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gby��wlZ�klhjhgZ�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gby��dZd�fu�agZ_f��y\ey_lky

Page 94: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\lhjhc� ihklhygghc� q_jlhc� kgh\b^_gby�� Z ^ey� \ujZ`_gby� hl^_evguo� we_f_glh\� kgh\b^_gbykms_kl\m_l��dZd�fu�\b^_eb��gZ]ey^gh_�bah[jZ`_gb_�keh\Z�Ykgh��qlh�wlh�g_e_]dZy�jZ[hlZ��Qlh[u�khklZ\blv�ihgylb_�h __�ljm^ghklyo��ij_^klZ\vl_�k_[_�qlh� \u� \ayeb� gZ� k_[y� aZ^Zqm� aZf_gblv� iheblbq_kdmx� i_j_^h\bpm� dZdhc�lh� ]Za_lu� jy^hfbeexkljZpbc��l��_��\_jgmlvky�hl�[md\_ggh]h�rjbnlZ�d ibkvfm�jbkmgdZfb��Lh��qlh�\ wlhc�klZlv_]h\hjblky� h ebpZo� b dhgdj_lguo� ij_^f_lZo�� \u� e_]dh� b�� fh`_l� [ulv�� m^Zqgh� aZf_gbl_beexkljZpbyfb�� gh� ijb� bah[jZ`_gbb� Z[kljZdlguo� keh\� b \k_o� qZkl_c� j_qb�� \ujZ`Zxsboeh]bq_kdb_� hlghr_gby�� lZdbo�� dZd� qZklbpu�� khxau� b l�� i��� \Zk� h`b^Zxl� ljm^ghklb�� Ijbbah[jZ`_gbb� Z[kljZdlguo� keh\� \u� kfh`_l_� k_[_� ihfhqv� \k_\hafh`gufb� bkdmkkl\_ggufbijb_fZfb��<u�ihiulZ_l_kv��gZijbf_j��i_j_^Zlv�l_dkl�klZlvb�^jm]bfb�keh\Zfb��dhlhju_�a\mqZl�fh`_l� [ulv�� g_h[uqgh�� gh� kh^_j`Zl� [hevr_� dhgdj_lguo� b ih^oh^ysbo� ^ey� bah[jZ`_gbyihgylbc�� AZl_f� \u� \kihfgbl_�� qlh� [hevrbgkl\h� Z[kljZdlguo� keh\� y\eyxlky� ihlmkdg_\rbfbdhgdj_lgufb� b ihwlhfm� ih� \hafh`ghklb� \hkihevam_l_kv� i_j\hgZqZevguf� dhgdj_lgufagZq_gb_f� wlbo� keh\�� BlZd�� \u� [m^_l_� jZ^u�� _keb� kfh`_l_� \hh[jZablv� h[eZ^Zgb_� �%HVLW]HQ�h[t_dlhf� dZd� ^_ckl\bl_evgh_�nbabq_kdh_� kb^_gb_� �'DUDXIVLW]HQ��� LZd�`_� ihklmiZ_l� b jZ[hlZkgh\b^_gby��Ijb� lZdbo�h[klhyl_evkl\Zo�\u�_^\Z�eb�[m^_l_�ij_^ty\eylv�[hevrb_�ij_l_gabb�dlhqghklb�bah[jZ`_gby��LZdbf�h[jZahf��b jZ[hl_�kgh\b^_gby�\u�ijhklbl_��qlh�hgZ��gZijbf_j�lZdhc� ljm^guc� ^ey� bah[jZ`_gby� we_f_gl�� dZd� gZjmr_gb_� [jZqghc� \_jghklb� �(KHEUXFK��aZf_gy_l� ^jm]bf� dZdbf�eb[h� jZaju\hf� �%UXFK��� i_j_ehf� gh]b� �%HLQEUXFK� �� GZ^_xkv�� \ukmf__l_� ^h� g_dhlhjhc� kl_i_gb� ijhklblv� [_kihfhsghklv� yaudZ� jbkmgdh\�� dh]^Z� hg� aZf_sZ_lkh[hc�[md\_gguc�>ey�bah[jZ`_gby�qZkl_c�j_qb��ihdZau\Zxsbo�eh]bq_kdb_�hlghr_gbyª�\jh^_�©ihlhfm�qlh�ihwlhfm��ghª�b l��^��g_l�ih^h[guo�\kihfh]Zl_evguo�kj_^kl\��lZdbf�h[jZahf��wlb�qZklb�l_dklZijhiZ^ml� ijb� i_j_\h^_� \ jbkmgdb�� Lhqgh� lZd� `_� [eZ]h^Zjy� jZ[hl_� kgh\b^_gby� kh^_j`Zgb_fuke_c� kgh\b^_gby� jZkl\hjy_lky� \ _]h� kujhf� fZl_jbZe_� h[t_dlh\� b ^_yl_evgh�kl_b�� B \ufh`_l_� [ulv� ^h\hevgu�� _keb� \Zf� ij_^hklZ\blky� \hafh`ghklv� dZdbf�lh� h[jZahf�gZf_dgmlv� \[he__� lhgdhf� h[jZaghf� \ujZ`_gbb� gZ� hij_^_e_ggu_� g_^hklmigu_� bah[jZ`_gbx� hlghr_gby�Lhqgh� lZd� `_� jZ[hl_� kgh\b^_gby� m^Z_lky� \ujZablv� qlh�lh� ba� kh^_j`Zgby� kdjuluo� fuke_ckgh\b^_gby�\ nhjfZevguo�hkh[_gghklyo�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby��\ _]h�ykghklb�beb�g_ykghklb��\ _]hjZa^_e_gbb�gZ�g_kdhevdh�njZ]f_glh\�b l�� i��Dhebq_kl\h� qZkl_c� kgh\b^_gby�� gZ� dhlhju_� hghjZkiZ^Z_lky�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� khq_lZ_lky� k qbkehf� hkgh\guo� l_f�� oh^hf� fuke_c� \ kdjulhfkgh\b^_gbb��dhjhldh_�\klmibl_evgh_�kgh\b^_gb_�qZklh�hlghkblky�d ihke_^mxs_fm�ih^jh[ghfmhkgh\ghfm�kgh\b^_gbx��dZd�\\_^_gb_�beb�fhlb� � Ijb� bkijZ\e_gbb� dhjj_dlmju� wlh]h� ebklZ� fg_� kemqZcgh� ihiZeZkv� ]Za_lgZy� aZf_ldZ�� dhlhjmx� y a^_kvijb\h`m�dZd�g_h`b^Zggh_�ihykg_gb_�\ur_baeh`_gguo�iheh`_gbc�©G:D:A:GB?�;H@B?� �i_j_ehf� jmdb� aZ�gZjmr_gb_� kmijm`_kdhc� \_jghklb`� �$UPEUXFKGXUFK�(KHEUXFK��:ggZ�F���kmijm]Z�h^gh]h�hiheq_gpZ��h[\bgbeZ�De_f_glbgm�D��k gZjmr_gbb�kmijm`_kdhc\_jghklb��< h[\bg_gbb�]h\hjblky��qlh�D��gZoh^blky�k DZjehf�F��\ ij_klmighc�k\yab��\ lh�\j_fydZd�__ kh[kl\_gguc�fm`�gZ�\hcg_��hldm^Z�hg�^Z`_�ijbkueZ_l�_c�_`_f_kyqgh�k_fv^_kyl�djhg��D�ihemqbeZ�hl�fm`Z�ihkljZ^Z\r_c�m`_�^h\hevgh�fgh]h�^_g_]��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�hgZ�kZfZ�k j_[_gdhf

Page 95: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ugm`^_gZ�`blv�\ gm`^_�b l_ji_lv�]heh^��Lh\Zjbsb�fm`Z�jZkkdZau\Zeb�_c��qlh�D��ihk_sZ_l�kF�� j_klhjZgu� b dmlbl� lZf� ^h� iha^g_c� ghqb�� H^gZ`^u� h[\bgy_fZy� ^Z`_� kijhkbeZ� fm`ZihkljZ^Z\r_c�\ ijbkmlkl\bb�fgh]bo�khe^Zl��kdhjh�eb�hg�jZa\_^_lky�kh�k\h_c�ÄklZjmohc���qlh[ui_j__oZlv� d g_c�� @_gZ� ijb\jZlgbdZ� ^hfZ�� ]^_� `b\_l� D��� lh`_� g_h^ghdjZlgh� \b^_eZ� fm`ZihkljZ^Z\r_c�\ iheghf�g_]eb`_�gZ�d\Zjlbj_�D�<q_jZ� i_j_^� km^hf� \ E_hihev^rlZll_� D�� hljbpZeZ�� qlh� agZ_l� F��� Z h[� bglbfguohlghr_gbyo� m`� g_�fh`_l� [ulv� b j_qb��H^gZdh� k\b^_l_evgbpZ�:ev[_jlbgZ�F�� ihdZaZeZ�� qlhg_h`b^Zggh�aZklZeZ�D���dh]^Z�hgZ�p_eh\ZeZ�fm`Z�ihkljZ^Z\r_c�>hijhr_gguc�ijb�i_j\hf�jZa[hj_�^_eZ�\ dZq_kl\_�k\b^_l_ey�F��hljbpZe�lh]^Z�bglbfgu_hlghr_gby� k h[\bgy_fhc�� <q_jZ� km^v_� [ueh� ij_^klZ\e_gh� ibkvfh�� \ dhlhjhf� k\b^_l_evhldZau\Z_lky� hl� k\h_]h� ihdZaZgby� gZ� i_j\hf� jZa[bjZl_evkl\_� ^_eZ� b khagZ_lky�� qlh� ^h� bxgyf_kypZ�ih^^_j`b\Ze�ex[h\gmx�k\yav�k D��Ijb�i_j\hf�jZa[hj_�hg�lhevdh�ihlhfm�hljbpZe�k\hbhlghr_gby�k h[\bgy_fhc��qlh�hgZ�i_j_^�jZa[hjhf�^_eZ�y\beZkv�d g_fm�b gZ�dhe_gyo�mfheyeZkiZklb� __ b� gbq_]h� g_� ]h\hjblv�� ÄL_i_jv�`_�²� ibr_l� k\b^_l_ev�²� y qm\kl\mx� ihlj_[ghklvhldjh\_ggh�khagZlvky�i_j_^�km^hf��lZd�dZd�y kehfZe�e_\mx�jmdm��b wlh�dZ`_lky�fg_�gZdZaZgb_f[h`vbf�aZ�fh_�ij_klmie_gb_��Km^vy�mklZgh\be��qlh�kjhd�ij_klmie_gby�ijhr_e��ihke_�q_]h�ihkljZ^Z\rZy�\ayeZ�`Zeh[mh[jZlgh��Z h[\bgy_fZy�[ueZ�hijZ\^ZgZª��������������������������������������������������\bjh\dZ��ijb^Zlhqgh_�ij_^eh`_gb_�\ fukeyo�kgh\b^_gby�aZf_sZ_lky�\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbbkf_ghc�\dexq_gguo�\ g_]h�kp_g�b��l��^��LZdbf�h[jZahf��nhjfZ�kgh\b^_gbc�gb�\ dh_f�kemqZ_�g_y\ey_lky�g_agZqbl_evghc��b kZfZ�lj_[m_l�lhedh\Zgby��G_kdhevdh�kgh\b^_gbc�h^gxc�ghqb�qZklhbf_xl� h^gh� b lh� `_� agZq_gb_� b mdZau\Zxl� gZ� mkbeby� dZd�gb[m^v� ihemqr_� kijZ\blvky� kgZjZklZxsbf� jZa^jZ`_gb_f�� >Z`_� \ h^gxf� kgh\b^_gbb� hkh[_ggh� ljm^guc� we_f_gl� fh`_l[ulv�bah[jZ`_g�©^m[e_lZfbª��g_kdhevdbfb�kbf\heZfb�Ijb�^Zevg_cr_f�kjZ\g_gbb�fuke_c�kgh\b^_gby�k aZf_sZxsbfb�bo�y\gufb�kgh\b^_gbyfbfu� magZ_f� lZdb_� \_sb�� d dhlhjuf� _s_� g_� ih^]hlh\e_gu�� gZijbf_j�� qlh� [_kkfukebpZ� bZ[kmj^ghklv�kgh\b^_gbc� lZd`_�bf_xl�k\h_� agZq_gb_��>Z��\ wlhf�imgdl_�ijhlb\hj_qb_�f_`^mf_^bpbgkdbf� b ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbf� ihgbfZgb_f� kgh\b^_gby� h[hkljy_lky� ^h� ihke_^g_ckl_i_gb�� K f_^bpbgkdhc� lhqdb�� aj_gby� kgh\b^_gb_� [_kkfuke_ggh�� ihlhfm� qlh� ^mr_\gZy^_yl_evghklv� kiys_]h� ebr_gZ� \kydhc� djblbdb�� k gZr_c� `_�� gZijhlb\�� kgh\b^_gb_[_kkfuke_ggh� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� kh^_j`ZsZyky� \ fukeyo� kgh\b^_gby� djblbdZ�� km`^_gb_� ©wlh[_kkfuke_gghª� ^he`gu� gZclb� k\h_� bah[jZ`_gb_�� Ba\_klgh_� \Zf� kgh\b^_gb_� k ihk_s_gb_fl_ZljZ� �ljb� [be_lZ� aZ� ��ne�� ��� dj��� ²� ohjhrbc� lhfm� ijbf_j��<ujZ`_ggh_� \ g_f� km`^_gb_hagZqZ_l��[_kkfuke_ggh�[ueh�lZd�jZgh�\uoh^blv�aZfm`�Lhqgh�lZd�`_�ijb�jZ[hl_�gZ^�lhedh\Zgb_f�fu�magZ_f�h qZklh�\ukdZau\Z_fuo�khfg_gbyo�bg_m\_j_gghklb� \b^_\r_]h� khg� ih� ih\h^m� lh]h�� \klj_qZeky� eb� \ kgh\b^_gbb� hij_^_e_ggucwe_f_gl�� [ue� eb� wlh� ^Zgguc� we_f_gl� beb� dZdhc�lh� ^jm]hc��DZd� ijZ\beh�� wlbf� khfg_gbyf� bg_m\_j_gghklb� gbq_]h� g_� khhl\_lkl\m_l� \ kdjuluo� fukeyo� k]]h\b^_gby�� hgb� \hagbdZxlbkdexqbl_evgh�ih^�^_ckl\b_f�p_gamju� kgh\b^_gby�b ^he`gu�[ulv�ijbjZ\g_gu� d g_� \iheg_

Page 96: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

m^Z\rbfky�ihiuldZf�mgbqlh`_gby�wlbo�we_f_glh\�D kZfuf�ihjZabl_evguf�hldjulbyf�hlghkblky�kihkh[��dZdbf�jZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby�jZaj_rZ_lijhlb\hj_qby� kdjulh]h� kgh\b^_gby�� Fu� m`_� agZ_f�� qlh� kh\iZ^_gby� \ kdjulhf� fZl_jbZe_aZf_sZxlky� k]ms_gbyfb� \ y\ghf� kgh\b^_gbb�� B \hl� k ijhlb\hiheh`ghklyfb� jZ[hlZkgh\b^_gby�ihklmiZ_l�lhqgh�lZd�`_��dZd�k kh\iZ^_gbyfb��\ujZ`Zy�bo�k hkh[uf�ij_^ihql_gb_fh^gbf�b l_f�`_�y\guf�we_f_glhf��H^bg�we_f_gl�\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb��dhlhjuc�kihkh[_g�[ulvijhlb\hiheh`ghklvx�� fh`_l�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� hagZqZlv� k_[y� kZfh]h�� Z lZd`_� k\hxijhlb\hiheh`ghklv�beb�bf_lv�h[Z�agZq_gby��lhevdh�ih�h[s_fm�kfukem�fh`gh�j_rblv��dZdhci_j_\h^�\u[jZlv��K wlbf�k\yaZg�lhl�nZdl��qlh�\ kgh\b^_gbb�g_evay�gZclb�bah[jZ`_gby�©g_lª��ihdjZcg_c�f_j_��g_^\mkfuke_ggh]h�Ijbf_j� `_eZgghc� ZgZeh]bb� wlhfm� kljZgghfm� ih\_^_gbx� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� ^Z_l� gZfjZa\blb_� yaudZ�� G_dhlhju_� ebg]\bklu� ml\_j`^Zxl�� qlh� \ kZfuo� ^j_\gbo� yaudZoijhlb\hiheh`ghklb��gZijbf_j�kbevguc�²�keZ[uc��k\_leuc�²�l_fguc��[hevrhc�²�fZe_gvdbc�\ujZ`Zebkv� h^gbf� b l_f�`_� dhjg_\uf� keh\hf�� �©Ijhlb\hiheh`guc� kfuke� i_j\hgZqZevguokeh\ª���LZd��gZ�^j_\g__]bi_lkdhf�yaud_�NHQ�i_j\hgZqZevgh�hagZqZeh�©kbevgucª�b ©keZ[ucª��<hba[_`Zgb_� g_^hjZamf_gbc� ijb� mihlj_[e_gbb� lZdbo� Zf[b\Ze_glguo� keh\� \ j_qbhjb_glbjh\Zebkv� gZ� bglhgZpbx� b khijh\h^bl_evguc� `_kl�� ijb� ibkvf_� ijb[Z\eyeb� lZdgZau\Z_fuc� ^_l_jfbgZlb\�� l�� _�� jbkmghd�� g_� ijhbaghkb\rbcky� ijb� ql_gbb�� .HQ� \ agZq_gbb©kbevgucª�ibkZehkv��lZdbf�h[jZahf��k ijb[Z\e_gb_f�ihke_�[md\_gguo� agZdh\�jbkmgdZ�ijyfhkb^ys_]h�q_eh\_qdZ��_keb�NHQ�hagZqZeh�©keZ[ucª��lh�ke_^h\Ze�jbkmghd�g_[j_`gh�kb^ys_]h�gZdhjlhqdZo� q_eh\_qdZ�� Lhevdh� iha`_� [eZ]h^Zjy� e_]dbf� baf_g_gbyf� h^bgZdh\h� a\mqZs_]hi_j\hgZqZevgh]h� keh\Z� ihemqbehkv� ^\Z� h[hagZq_gby� ^ey� kh^_j`Zsboky� \ g_fijhlb\hihklZ\e_gbc���LZd ba NHQ�²�©kbevguc�²�keZ[ucª� \hagbdeh�NHQ�²�©kbevgucª�b NDQ²�©keZ[ucª��G_�lhevdh�^j_\g_crb_�yaudb�\ k\h_f�iha^g_cr_f�jZa\blbb��gh�b ]hjZa^h�[he__fheh^u_�b ^Z`_�`b\u_�gug_�yaudb�khojZgbeb�\ [hevrhf�dhebq_kl\_�hklZldb�wlh]h�^j_\g_]hijhlb\hiheh`gh]h�kfukeZ��Ohqm�ijb\_klb�\Zf�\ wlhc�k\yab�g_kdhevdh�ijbf_jh\�ih�D��:[_ex�������< eZlbgkdhf�yaud_�lZdbfb�\k_�_s_�Zf[b\Ze_glgufb�keh\Zfb�y\eyxlky�� DOLDV� �\ukhdbc²gbadbc�� b VDFHU� �k\ylhc²g_q_klb\uc���< dZq_kl\_� ijbf_jh\�fh^bnbdZpbb� h^gh]h� b lh]h�`_dhjgy�y mihfygm��FODPDUH�²�djbqZlv��FODP�²�keZ[uc��lbobc�lZcguc��VLFFXV�²�kmohc��VXFFXV�²khd��Kx^Z�`_� ba� g_f_pdh]h� yaudZ� fh`gh� hlg_klb�� 6WLPPH�²� ]hehk�� VWXPP�²� g_fhc�� ?kebkjZ\gblv� jh^kl\_ggu_� yaudb�� lh� fh`gh� gZclb� fgh]h� ijbf_jh\�� Ih�Zg]ebckdb� ORFN� ²aZdju\Zlv��ih�g_f_pdb� /RFK�²� ^ujZ�� /LLFNH�²� exd��< Zg]ebckdhf� FOHDYH�²� jZkdZeu\Zlv�� \g_f_pdhf�NOHEHQ�²�de_blv�:g]ebckdh_� keh\h� ZLWKRXW�� hagZqZxs__�� kh[kl\_ggh�� ©k ²� [_aª�� l_i_jv� mihlj_[ey_lky� \agZq_gbb�©[_aª��lh��qlh�ZLWK��djhf_�ijb[Z\e_gby��bf__l�lZd`_�agZq_gb_�hlgbfZgby��ke_^m_l�bakeh`guo� keh\� ZLWKGUDZ�²� hl^_j]b\Zlv�� [jZlv� gZaZ^�� ZLWKKROG�²� hldZau\Zlv�� hklZgZ\eb\Zlv�Ih^h[gh_�`_�agZq_gb_�bf__l�g_f_pdh_�ZLHGHU�< jZa\blbb� yaudZ�gZoh^bl� k\hx�iZjZee_ev� _s_�h^gZ�hkh[_gghklv� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby��<^j_\g__]bi_lkdhf��dZd�b \�^jm]bo�[he__�iha^gbo�yaudZo��\klj_qZ_lky�h[jZlguc�ihjy^hd�a\mdh\\ keh\Zo�k h^gbf�agZq_gb_f��LZdbfb�ijbf_jZfb�\ Zg]ebckdhf�b g_f_pdhf�yaudZo�y\eyxlky�

Page 97: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

7RSL²SRW� >]hjrhd@�� ERDW²WXE� >eh^dZ@�� KXUU\� >ki_rblv@�²�5XKH� >ihdhc��g_ih^\b`ghklv@�%DONHQ�>[j_\gh��[jmk@�².OREHQ�>ihe_gh��qmj[Zg@�< eZlbgkdhf�b g_f_pdhf��kZj_]_�²�SDFNHQ�>o\ZlZlv@��UHQ�²�1LHUH�>ihqdZ@�LZdb_� bg\_jkbb�� dZdb_� a^_kv� ijhbkoh^yl� k hl^_evgufb� keh\Zfb�� kh\_jrZxlky� jZ[hlhckgh\b^_gby�jZaebqguf� kihkh[hf��I_j_\hjZqb\Zgb_� kfukeZ�� aZf_gm�ijhlb\hiheh`ghklvx�fum`_� agZ_f�� Djhf_� lh]h�� \ kgh\b^_gbyo� \klj_qZxlky� bg\_jkbb� kblmZpbb�� \aZbfhhlghr_gbyf_`^m� ^\mfy� ebpZfb�� dZd� \ ©i_j_\_jgmlhf� fbj_ª�� < kgh\b^_gbb� aZyp� g_j_^dh� klj_ey_l� \hohlgbdZ�� >Ze__�� \klj_qZxlky� baf_g_gby� \ ihjy^d_� ke_^h\Zgby� kh[ulbc�� lZd� qlh� lh�� qlhy\ey_lky� ij_^r_kl\mxs_c� ijbqbghc�� \ kgh\b^_gbb� klZ\blky� ihke_� \ul_dZxs_]h� ba� g__ke_^kl\by��<k_�ijhbkoh^bl��dZd�ijb�ihklZgh\d_�iv_ku�iehohc� ljmiihc��dh]^Z� kgZqZeZ�iZ^Z_l]_jhc�� Z ihlhf�ba�aZ� dmebk� jZa^Z_lky� \uklj_e�� dhlhjuc� _]h� m[b\Z_l��Beb� _klv� kgh\b^_gby�� \dhlhjuo�\_kv�ihjy^hd�we_f_glh\�h[jZlguc��lZd�qlh�ijb�lhedh\Zgbb��qlh[u�ihgylv�_]h�kfuke�ihke_^gbc�we_f_gl�gm`gh�ihklZ\blv�gZ�i_j\h_�f_klh��Z i_j\uc�²�gZ�ihke_^g__��<u�ihqgbl_lZd`_�ba�gZr_]h�bamq_gby�kbf\hebdb�kgh\b^_gby��qlh�\oh^blv�beb�iZ^Zlv�\ \h^m�hagZqZeh�lh`_� kZfh_��qlh�b \uoh^blv�ba� \h^u�� Z bf_ggh� jh`^Zlv�ieb� jh`^Zlvky��b qlh�ih^gbfZlvky�ihe_klgbp_� hagZqZ_l� lh� `_� kZfh_�� qlh� b kimkdZlvky� ih� g_c�� G_khfg_ggh�� qlh� bkdZ`_gb_kgh\b^_gby�fh`_l�ba\e_qv�ba�lZdhc�k\h[h^u�bah[jZ`_gby�hij_^_e_ggmx�\u]h^m�Wlb�q_jlu�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gby�fh`gh�gZa\Zlv�ZjoZbq_kdbfb��Hgb�ijbkmsb�lZd`_�^j_\gbfkbkl_fZf� \ujZ`_gby�� yaudZq�b ibkvf_gghklyf��b g_kml� k kh[hc� l_�`_� ljm^ghklb�� h dhlhjuoj_qv�[m^_l�gb`_�\ djblbq_kdhf�h[ahj_�: l_i_jv� _s_� h g_dhlhjuo� ^jm]bo� \a]ey^Zo�� Ijb� jZ[hl_� kgh\b^_gby� ^_eh�� hq_\b^gh�aZdexqZ_lky� \ lhf�� qlh[u� \ujZ`_ggu_� \ keh\Zo� kdjulu_� fukeb� i_j_\_klb� \ qm\kl\_ggu_h[jZau�ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�ajbl_evgh]h�oZjZdl_jZ��GZrb�fukeb�dZd�jZa�b ijhbahreb�ba�lZdboqm\kl\_gguo��h[jZah\��bo�i_j\uf�fZl_jbZehf�b ij_^\Zjbl_evgufb�wlZiZfb�[ueb�qm\kl�v_ggu_\i_qZle_gby�� ijZ\bevg__� kdZaZlv�� h[jZau� \hkihfbgZgby� h lZdh\uo�� Lhevdh� iha^g__� k gbfbk\yau\Zxlky� keh\Z�� Z aZl_f� b fukeb�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby� aZklZ\ey_l� fukebijhclb� j_]j_kkb\guc� imlv�� ebrZ_l� bo� ^hklb]gmlh]h� jZa\blby�� b ijb� wlhc� j_]j_kkbb� ^he`ghbkq_agmlv�\k_�lh��qlh�[ueh�ijbh[j_l_gh�\ oh^_�jZa\blby�hl�h[jZah\�\hkihfbgZgbc�d fukeyf�LZdh\Z� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby�� Ih� kjZ\g_gbx� k ijhp_kkZfb�� h dhlhjuo� fu� magZeb� ijb� __bamq_gbb��bgl_j_k�d y\ghfm�kgh\b^_gbx�^he`_g�hlhclb�gZ�aZ^gbc�ieZg��Gh�wlhfm�ihke_^g_fm�dhlhjh_�y\ey_lky�\k_�lZdb�_^bgkl\_gguf��qlh�gZf�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�ba\_klgh��y ohqm�ihk\ylblv_s_�g_kdhevdh�aZf_qZgbc�?kl_kl\_ggh�� qlh� y\gh_� kgh\b^_gb_� l_jy_l� ^ey� \Zk� k\hx� agZqbfhklv�� GZf� [_ajZaebqgh�ohjhrh�hgh�khklZ\e_gh�beb�jZkiZ^Z_lky�gZ�jy^�hl^_evguo�[_kk\yaguo�h[jZah\��>Z`_�_keb�hghbf__l�dZ`msmxky�hkfuke_gghc�\g_rgxx�klhjhgm��lh�fu�\k_�jZ\gh� agZ_f��qlh�hgZ�\hagbdeZ[eZ]h^Zjy�bkdZ`_gbx�kgh\b^_gby�b fh`_l�bf_lv�d \gmlj_gg_fm�_]h�kh^_j`Zgbx�lZd�`_�fZehhlghr_gby��dZd�nZkZ^�blZevygkdhc�p_jd\b�d __�dhgkljmdpbb�b kbemwlm��< g_dhlhjuo�kemqZyo�bwlhl�nZkZ^� kgh\b^_gby� bf__l� k\h_� agZq_gb_�� dh]^Z� hg� i_j_^Z_l� \ fZeh� beb� ^Z`_� kh\k_f� g_bkdZ`_gghf�\b^_�dZdmx�lh�\Z`gmx�khklZ\gmx�qZklv�kdjuluo�fuke_c� kgh\b^_gby��Gh�fu�g_fh`_f� magZlv� wlh]h�� g_� ih^\_j]gm\� kgh\b^_gb_� lhedh\Zgbx� b g_� khklZ\b\� [eZ]h^Zjy� g_fm

Page 98: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

km`^_gby�h lhf��\ dZdhc�f_j_�bf_eh�f_klh�bkdZ`_gb_��Ih^h[gh_�`_� khfg_gb_� \uau\Z_l� lhlkemqZc��dh]^Z�^\Z�we_f_glZ�kgh\b^_gby��ih�\b^bfhfm��gZoh^ylky�\ l_kghc�k\yab��< wlhf�fh`_lkh^_j`Zlvky� p_gguc� gZf_d� gZ� lh�� qlh� khhl\_lkl\mxsb_� wlbf� we_f_glZf� kdjulu_� fukebkgh\b^_gby�lh`_�^he`gu�[ulv�ijb\_^_gu�\ k\yav��gh�\ ^jm]bo�kemqZyo�m[_`^Z_rvky��qlh�lh�qlh�k\yaZgh�\ fukeyo��jZat_^bg_gh�\ kgh\b^_gbb�< h[s_f��ke_^m_l�ba[_]Zlv�lh]h��qlh[u�h[tykgylv�h^gm�qZklv�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby�^jm]hc�dZd�[m^lh�kgh\b^_gb_�k\yagh�khklZ\e_gh�b y\ey_lky�ijZ]fZlbq_kdbf�baeh`_gb_f��?]h��kdhj__�fh`gh� kjZ\gblv� k bkdmkkl\_gguf� fjZfhjhf� [j_dqb_c�� khklZ\e_gguf� ba� jZaebqguo� dmkdh\dZfgy�ijb�ihfhsb�p_f_glbjmxs_]h�kj_^kl\Z�lZd��qlh�ihemqZxsb_ky�mahju�g_�khhl\_lkl\mxli_j\hgZqZevguf� khklZ\guf�qZklyf��>_ckl\bl_evgh�� _klv�g_dZy�qZklv� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby�� lZdgZau\Z_fZy� \lhjbqgZy� h[jZ[hldZ� �VHNXQ�GDUH� %HDUEHLWXQJ��� dhlhjZy� klZjZ_lky� khklZ\blv� ba[eb`Zcrbo� j_amevlZlh\� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� [he__� beb� f_g__� ]Zjfhgbqgh_� p_eh_�� Ijb� wlhffZl_jbZe�jZkiheZ]Z_lky�aZqZklmx�kh\_jr_ggh�g_�\ khhl\_lkl\bb�kh�kfukehf��Z lZf��]^_�dZ`_lkyg_h[oh^bfuf��^_eZxlky�\klZ\db�K ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� g_evay� i_j_hp_gb\Zlv� jZ[hlm� kgh\b^_gby�� kebrdhf� _c� ^h\_jylv�� ?_^_yl_evghklv� bkq_jiu\Z_lky� i_j_qbke_ggufb� j_amevlZlZfb�� [hevr_�� q_f� k]mklblv�� kf_klblv�gZ]ey^gh�bah[jZablv�b ih^\_j]gmlv�p_eh_�\lhjbqghc�h[jZ[hld_��hgZ�g_�fh`_l�k^_eZlv��Lh��qlh�\kgh\b^_gbc� ihy\eyxlky� \ujZ`_gby� km`^_gbc�� djblbdb�� m^b\e_gby�� aZdexq_gby�²� wlh� g_j_amevlZlu� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� b lhevdh� hq_gv� j_^dh� wlh� ijhy\e_gby� jZafure_gby� hkgh\b^_gbb��gh� wlh�ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�²�njZ]f_glu�kdjuluo�fuke_c�kgh\b^_gby��[he__�bebf_g__�fh^bnbpbjh\Zgguo�b ijbkihkh[e_gguo�d dhgl_dklm��i_j_g_k_gguo�\ y\gh_�kgh\b^_gb_�JZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby� lZd`_� g_� fh`_l� kha^Z\Zlv� b j_q_c�� AZ� fZeufb� bkdexq_gbyfb� j_qb� \kgh\b^_gbb� y\eyxlky� ih^jZ`Zgbyfb� b khklZ\e_gu� ba� j_q_c�� dhlhju_� \b^_\rbc� khg� keurZebeb� kZf�ijhbaghkbe�\ lhl�^_gv��dh]^Z�\b^_e� khg��b dhlhju_�\dexq_gu�\ kdjulu_�fukeb�dZdfZl_jbZe� beb� dZd� ih[m^bl_eb� kgh\b^_gby�� Lhqgh� lZd� `_� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby� g_� fh`_lijhba\h^blv�\uqbke_gby��\k_�\uqbke_gby��dhlhju_�\klj_qZxlky�\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb�²�wlh�ih[hevr_c� qZklb� gZ[hj� qbk_e�� dZ`msb_ky� \uqbke_gby�� dZd� \uqbke_gby� hgb� kh\_jr_ggh[_kkfuke_ggu��b bklhdb�\uqbke_gbc�hiylv�lZdb�gZoh^ylky�\ kdjuluo�fukeyo�kgh\b^_gby��Ijbwlbo� hlghr_gbyo� g_m^b\bl_evgh� lZd`_�� qlh� bgl_j_k�� dhlhjuc� \uau\Z_l� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby�kdhjh�mklj_fey_lky�hl�g__�d kdjuluf�fukeyf�kgh\b^_gby��ijhy\eyxsbfky�[eZ]h^Zjy�y\ghfmkgh\b^_gbx� \ [he__� beb� f_g__� bkdZ`_gghf� \b^_�� Gh� g_evay� hijZ\^u\Zlv� lh�� qlh[u� wlhbaf_g_gb_�hlghr_gby�aZoh^beh�lZd�^Ze_dh��qlh�k l_hj_lbq_kdhc�lhqdb�aj_gby�kdjulu_�fukeb\hh[s_� klZ\ylky� gZ� f_klh� kZfh]h� kgh\b^_gby� b h� ihke_^g_f� \ukdZau\Z_lky� lh�� qlh� fh`_lhlghkblvky� lhevdh� d i_j\uf�� KljZggh�� qlh� ^ey� lZdh]h� kf_rb\Zgby� fh]eb� aehmihlj_[blvj_amevlZlZfb�ikbohZgZebaZ��©Kgh\b^_gb_fª�fh`gh�gZa\Zlv�g_�qlh�bgh_��dZd�j_amevlZl�jZ[hlukgh\b^_gby��l��_��nhjfm��\ dhlhjmx�kdjulu_�fukeb�i_j_\h^ylky�[eZ]h^Zjy�jZ[hl_�kgh\b^_gby�JZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby� ²� ijhp_kk� kh\_jr_ggh� k\h_h[jZagh]h� oZjZdl_jZ�� ^h� kbo� ihj� \^mr_\ghc�`bagb�g_�[ueh�ba\_klgh�gbq_]h�ih^h[gh]h��LZdb_�k]ms_gby��kf_s_gby��j_]j_kkb\gu_ij_\jZs_gby�fuke_c�\ h[jZau�y\eyxlky�gh\ufb�h[t_dlZfb��ihagZgb_�dhlhjuo�m`_�^hklZlhqgh\hagZ]jZ`^Z_l� mkbeby� ikbohZgZebaZ�� Ba� ijb\_^_gguo� iZjZee_e_c� d jZ[hl_� kgh\b^_gby� \ufh`_l_�lZd`_�ihgylv��dZdb_�k\yab�hldju\Zxlky�f_`^m�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbfb�bkke_^h\Zgbyfb�b

Page 99: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

^jm]bfb�h[eZklyfb��\ qZklghklb�f_`^m�jZa\blb_f�yaudZ�b fure_gby��H ^jm]hf�agZq_gbb�wlbo\a]ey^h\� \u� fh`_l_� ^h]Z^Zlvky� lhevdh� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� magZ_l_�� qlh� f_oZgbafu� h[jZah\Zgbykgh\b^_gbc�y\eyxlky�ijhlhlbihf�kihkh[Z�\hagbdgh\_gby�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�kbfilhfh\�Y agZx� lZd`_�� qlh�fu� _s_� g_�fh`_f� iheghklvx� ihgylv� agZq_gby� ^ey� ikboheh]bb� \k_ogh\uo�^Zgguo�� aZdexqZxsboky� \ wlbo� jZ[hlZo��Fu� ohlbf� mdZaZlv� ebrv� gZ� lh�� dZdb_� gh\u_^hdZaZl_evkl\Z� bf_xlky� ^ey� kms_kl\h\Zgby� [_kkhagZl_evguo� ^mr_\guo� Zdlh\� ²� Z \_^vkdjulu_� fukeb� y\eyxlky� bfb� ²� b dZdhc� g_h`b^Zggh� rbjhdbc� ^hklmi� d agZgbx[_kkhagZl_evghc�^mr_\ghc�`bagb�h[_sZ_l�gZf�lhedh\Zgb_�kgh\b^_gbc�Gm�� Z l_i_jv�� ih`Zemc�� kZfh_� \j_fy� ijb\_klb� \Zf� jZaebqgu_� ijbf_ju� hl^_evguokgh\b^_gbc��d wlhfm�\u�ih^]hlh\e_gu�\k_f�\ur_baeh`_gguf�><?G:>P:L:Y�E?DPBY:gZeba�hl^_evguo�kgh\b^_gbcM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��G_�jZahqZjh\u\Zcl_kv��_keb�y hiylv�ij_^eh`m�\Zf�njZ]f_glulhedh\Zgbc�kgh\b^_gbc��\f_klh�lh]h�qlh[u�ijb]eZkblv�\Zk�mqZkl\h\Zlv�\ lhedh\Zgbb�[hevrh]hohjhr_]h�kgh\b^_gby��<u�kdZ`_l_��qlh�bf__l_�gZ�wlh�ijZ\h�ihke_�klhevdbo�ijb]hlh\e_gbc��b\ukdZ`_l_� m[_`^_gb_�� qlh� ihke_� m^Zqgh]h� lhedh\Zgby� klhevdbo� lukyq� kgh\b^_gbc� ^Z\gh^he`gZ� [ueZ� [u� \hagbdgmlv� \hafh`ghklv� khklZ\blv� gZ[hj� hlebqguo� kgh\b^_gbc�� dhlhju_iha\heyeb�[u�ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv�\k_�gZrb�ml\_j`^_gby�h jZ[hl_�b fukeyo�kgh\b^_gby��>Z�gh�kms_kl\m_l�kebrdhf�fgh]h�ljm^ghkl_c��ij_iylkl\mxsbo�\uiheg_gbx�\Zr_]h�`_eZgby�Ij_`^_� \k_]h� ^he`_g� \Zf� ijbagZlvky�� qlh� g_l� gbdh]h�� dlh� aZgbfZeky� [u� lhedh\Zgb_fkgh\b^_gbc�\ dZq_kl\_�k\h_]h�hkgh\gh]h�aZgylby��<_^v�dZd�ijboh^yl�d lhedh\Zgbx�kgh\b^_gbc"KemqZcgh��[_a�hkh[h]h�gZf_j_gby�fh`gh�aZgylvky�kgh\b^_gbyfb�^jm]Z�beb�jZ[hlZlv�dZdh_�lh\j_fy�gZ^� k\hbfb� kh[kl\_ggufb� kgh\b^_gbyfb��qlh[u�ihmijZ`gylvky� \ ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhcjZ[hl_�� gh� ih� [hevr_c� qZklb� ijboh^blky� bf_lv� ^_eh� kh� kgh\b^_gbyfb� ebp�� kljZ^Zxsbog_\jhaZfb�� ih^\_j]Zxsboky� ZgZeblbq_kdhfm� e_q_gbx�� Kgh\b^_gby� wlbo� ihke_^gboij_^klZ\eyxl�kh[hc�hlebqguc�fZl_jbZe�b gbdhbf�h[jZahf�g_�mklmiZxl�kgh\b^_gbyf�a^hjh\uo�gh�l_ogbdZ�e_q_gby�\ugm`^Z_l�gZk�ih^qbgylv�lhedh\Zgb_�kgh\b^_gby�l_jZi_\lbq_kdbf�aZ^ZqZfb hklZ\eylv�[_a�\gbfZgby�[hevrh_�qbkeh�kgh\b^_gbc�ihke_�lh]h��dZd�ba�gbo�[ueh�\aylh�qlh�lhgm`gh_� ^ey� e_q_gby�� G_� dhlhju_� kgh\b^_gby�� \klj_qZxsb_ky� \h� \j_fy� e_q_gby�� \hh[s_g_^hklmigu�iheghfm�lhedh\Zgbx��LZd�dZd�hgb�\hagbdZxl�ba�\k_c�kh\hdmighklb�g_ba\_klgh]hgZf� ikbobq_kdh]h� fZl_jbZeZ�� lh� bo� ihgbfZgb_� \hafh`gh� lhevdh� ihke_� hdhgqZgby� e_q_gby�Khh[s_gb_�h lZdbo�kgh\b^_gbyo�k^_eZ�eh�[u�g_ba[_`guf�jZkdjulb_�\k_o�lZcg�g_\jhaZ��wlh�gZfg_�gm`gh��lZd�dZd�fu�\ayebkv�aZ�kgh\b^_gb_�k p_evx�ih^]hlh\blvky�d bamq_gbx�g_\jhah\�<u�hohlgh�hldZaZebkv�[u�hl�wlh]h�fZl_jbZeZ�b kdhj__�ij_^ihqeb�[u�mkeurZlv�lhedh\Zgbykgh\b^_gbc� a^hjh\v_� ex^_c� beb� k\hbo� kh[kl\_gguo�� Gh� ba�aZ� kh^_j`Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc� wlhg_^himklbfh��Gb�kZfh]h�k_[y��bb�^jm]h]h��qvbf�^h\_jb_f�ihevam_rvky��g_evay�lZd�[_kihsZ^ghh[gZ`Zlv��dZd�wlh]h�lj_[m_l�ih^jh[gh_�lhedh\Zgb_�_]h�kgh\b^_gbc��dhlhju_��dZd�\u�m`_�agZ_l_�bf_xl�hlghr_gb_�d kZfhfm�bglbfghfm�\ _]h�ebqghklb��Djhf_�wlh]h�aZljm^g_gby�\ ihemq_gbb

Page 100: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fZl_jbZeZ�� ^ey� khh[s_gby� ijbgbfZ_lky� \h� \gbfZgb_� b ^jm]h_�� <u� agZ_l_�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_dZ`_lky� kljZgguf�^Z`_� kZfhfm� \b^_\r_fm� khg��g_� ]h\hjy� m`_� h ^jm]hf�q_eh\_d_�� dhlhjhfmebqghklv� \b^_\r_]h� khg� g_agZdhfZ�� < gZr_c� ebl_jZlmj_� g_l� g_^hklZldZ� \ ohjhrbo� bih^jh[guo� ZgZebaZo� kgh\b^_gbc�� y kZf� him[ebdh\Ze� g_dhlhju_� ba� gbo� \ jZfdZo� bklhjbc[he_agb�� fh`_l� [ulv�� kZfuc� emqrbc� ijbf_j� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc� ij_^klZ\eyxl� kh[hchim[ebdh\Zggu_�H�� JZgdhf� �����V�� ^\Z� k\yaZgguo�f_`^m� kh[hc� kgh\b^_gby� h^ghc� fheh^hc^_\mrdb�� aZibkv�dhlhjuo� aZgbfZ_l�hdheh�^\mo�i_qZlguo� kljZgbp�� lh]^Z� dZd�bo� ZgZeba�²� ��kljZgbp��Fg_�ihgZ^h[beky�[u�ijbf_jgh�p_euc�k_f_klj��qlh[u�ihdZaZlv�\Zf�wlm�jZ[hlm��?keb[_j_rvky�aZ�dZdh_�gb[m^v�[he__�^ebggh_�b _s_�[he__�bkdZ`_ggh_�kgh\b^_gb_��lh�ijboh^blky^Z\Zlv�klhevdh�h[tykg_gbc��ijb\e_dZlv�lZdh_�h[beb_�ZkkhpbZlb\guo�fuke_c�b \hkihfbgZgbc�^_eZlv� lZd� fgh]h� hlklmie_gbc�� qlh� e_dpby� h g_f� hdZaZeZkv� [u� kh\_jr_ggh� aZimlZgghc� bg_m^h\e_l\hjbl_evghc�� Ihwlhfm� y ^he`_g� ijhkblv� \Zk� ^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky� l_f�� qlh� e_]q_ihemqblv�²�khh[s_gb_f�h g_[hevrbo�njZ]f_glZo�kgh\b^_gbc�ebp��kljZ^Zxsbo�g_\jhahf��ihdhlhjuf�ih�hl^_evghklb�fh`gh�magZlv�lh�beb�bgh_��E�_]q_�\k_]h�ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv�kbf\heukgh\b^_gby�� aZl_f� ²� hij_^_e_ggu_� hkh[_gghklb� j_]j_kkb\gh]h� bah[jZ`_gby� kgh\b^_gbc��HdZ`^hf�ba�gb`_�ke_^mxsbo�kgh\b^_gbc�y kdZ`m�\Zf��ihq_fm�y kq_e�gm`guf�khh[sblv�h g_f���� Kgh\b^_gb_� khklhbl� lhevdh� ba� ^\mo� ijhkluo� dZjlbg�� _]h� ^y^y� dmjbl� iZibjhkm�� ohlyk_]h^gy�km[[hlZ��dZdZy�lh�`_gsbgZ�]eZ^bl�b eZkdZ_l�_]h ^\b^_\r_]h�khg`��dZd�k\h_]h�j_[_gdZ�Ih� ih\h^m� i_j\hc� dZjlbgu� \b^_\rbc� khg� �_\j_c�� aZf_qZ_l�� qlh� _]h� ^y^y� ��� gZ[h`gucq_eh\_d�� dhlhjuc� gbdh]^Z� g_� kh\_jrZe� b g_� kh\_jrbe� [u� ih^h[gh]h� ]j_oZ�� Hlghkbl_evgh`_gsbgu�\h�\lhjhc�dZjlbg_�_fm�gbq_]h�g_�ijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m��djhf_�lh]h��qlh�wlh�_]h�fZlv�H[_� wlb� dZjlbgu� beb�fukeb�� hq_\b^gh�� ke_^m_l� ijb\_klb� \ khhl\_lkl\b_� ^jm]� k ^jm]hf��GhdZdbf�h[jZahf"�LZd�dZd�hg�j_rbl_evgh�hkiZjb\Z_l�^_ckl\b_�^y^b�� lh� _kl_kl\_ggh�ijb[Z\blv©_kebª�� ©?keb� fhc� ^y^y�� k\ylhc� q_eh\_d�� klZe� [u� dmjblv� \ km[[hlm� iZibjhkm�� lh� y fh]� [u^himklblv�eZkdb�fZl_jbª��Hq_\b^gh��qlh�eZkdZ�fZl_jb�²�lZdh_�`_�g_^himklbfh_�^_ckl\b_��dZddmj_gb_�\ km[[hlm�^ey�gZ[h`gh]h�_\j_y��<kihfgbl_��qlh�y ]h\hjbe�\Zf�h lhf��qlh�ijb�jZ[hl_kgh\b^_gby�hliZ^Zxl�\k_�hlghr_gby�f_`^m�fukeyfb�kgh\b^_gby��hgb�jZkl\hjyxlky�\ k\h_fkujhf�fZl_jbZe_��b aZ^Zq_c�lhedh\Zgby�y\ey_lky�\gh\v�\hkklZgh\blv�hims_ggu_�hlghr_gby����;eZ]h^Zjy�k\hbf�im[ebdZpbyf�h kgh\b^_gbb�y klZe�\ ba\_klghf�kfuke_�h[s_kl\_ggufdhgkmevlZglhf� ih� \hijhkZf� kgh\b^_gbc� b \� l_q_gb_� fgh]bo� e_l� ihemqZx� k kZfuo� jZaguoklhjhg� ibkvfZ�� \ dhlhjuo� fg_� khh[sZxlky� kgh\b^_gby� beb� ij_^eZ]Z_lky� b?� lhedh\Zgb_�� Y�dhg_qgh�� [eZ]h^Zj_g� \k_f� l_f�� dlh� ijb[Z\ey_l� d kgh\b^_gbx� ^hklZlhqgh� fZl_jbZeZ�� qlh[ulhedh\Zgb_�klZeh�\hafh`guf��beb�dlh�kZf�^Z_l�lZdh_�lhedh\Zgb_��D wlhc�dZl_]hjbb�hlghkblkyke_^mxs__�kgh\b^_gb_�h^gh]h�\jZqZ�ba�Fxgo_gZ��hlghkys__ky�d �����]��Y ijb\h`m�_]h��ihlhfmqlh� hgh� fh`_l� \Zf� ^hdZaZlv�� gZkdhevdh� kgh\b^_gb_� \ h[s_f� g_^hklmigh� ihgbfZgbx�� ihdZ\b^_\rbc� khg� g_� ^Zkl� gZf� ^hihegbl_evgh� k\hbo� k\_^_gbc�� Y \_^v� ij_^iheZ]Zx�� qlh� \u�� \kmsghklb�� kqblZ_l_� b^_Zevguf� lhedh\Zgb_� kgh\b^_gbc� k ihfhsvx� bkihevah\Zgby� agZq_gbykbf\heh\��ZkkhpbZlb\gmx�`_� l_ogbdm�ohl_eb�[u�mkljZgblv�� Z fg_�ohq_lky�hk\h[h^blv�\Zk�hlwlh]h�\j_^gh]h�aZ[em`^_gby�©���bxey� ����� ]��fg_� kgblky�� y _^m�gZ� \_ehkbi_^_� \gba�ih� mebp_�Lx[bg]_gZ�� dZd� \^jm]dhjbqg_\Zy� lZdkZ� imkdZ_lky� aZ� fghc� \ ih]hgx� b o\ZlZ_l� f_gy� aZ� iyldm�� Ijh_oZ\� g_fgh]h

Page 101: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

^Zevr_�� y ke_aZx� k \_ehkbi_^Z�� kZ`mkv� gZ� klmi_gvdm� b gZqbgZx� dhehlblv�`b\hlgh_�� dj_idhmp_ib\r__ky�am[Zfb� �hl�mdmkZ�b \k_c�kp_gu�m f_gy�ghl�g_ijbylguo�qm\kl\���GZijhlb\�kb^ylg_kdhevdh�ij_klZj_euo�^Zf��dhlhju_� kfhljyl�gZ�f_gy� meu[Zykv��AZl_f� y ijhkuiZxkv��b�� dZdm`_�qZklh�[u\Zeh�� \ wlhl�fhf_gl�i_j_oh^Z� d [h^jkl\h\Zgbx� \k_� kgh\b^_gb_� klZgh\blky�fg_ykgufª�Kbf\heZfb�a^_kv�fZeh�ihfh`_rv��Gh�\b^_\rbc�khg�khh[sZ_l�gZf�©< ihke_^g__�\j_fy�y [ue�\ex[e_g�\ h^gm�^_\mrdm��\b^_e�__ lhevdh�gZ�mebp_��gh�g_�bf_egbdZdhc�\hafh`ghklb�aZ\_klb�agZdhfkl\h��KZfuf�ijbylguf�^ey�f_gy�ih\h^hf�^ey�agZdhfkl\Zfh]eZ� [ulv� lZdkZ�� lZd� dZd� y [hevrhc� ex[bl_ev� `b\hlguo� b wlh� `_� dZq_kl\h� k kbfiZlb_caZf_lbe�m ^_\mrdbª��Hg�^h[Z\ey_l�lZd`_��qlh�g_h^ghdjZlgh�k [hevrhc�eh\dhklvx�b aZqZklmx�dm^b\e_gbx� ajbl_e_c�\f_rb\Zeky�\ [hjv[m� ]juamsboky�f_`^m�kh[hc�kh[Zd��BlZd��fu�magZ_f�qlh� ihgjZ\b\rZyky� _fm� ^_\mrdZ� ihklhyggh� ihy\eyeZkv� \ khijh\h`^_gbb� wlhc� hkh[_gghckh[Zdb��Gh�ba�y\gh�lh�kgh\b^_gby�wlZ�^_\mrdZ�mkljZg_gZ��hklZeZkv�lhevdh�Zkkhpbbjm_fZy�k g_ckh[ZdZ��Fh`_l�[ulv��ij_klZj_eu_�^Zfu��dhlhju_�_fm�meu[Zxlky��qZ�gyeb�f_klh�^_\mrdb��Lh]h�qlh�hg� _s_�khh[sZ_l��g_^hklZlhqgh�^ey�h[tykg_gby� wlh]h�fhf_glZ��Lh��qlh�\ kgh\b^_gbb�hg_^_l� gZ� \_ehkbi_^_�� y\ey_lky� ijyfuf� ih\lhj_gb_f� ijbihfbgZ_fhc� kblmZpbb�� Hg� \k_]^Z\klj_qZe�^_\mrdm�k kh[Zdhc�lhevdh�lh]^Z��dh]^Z�[ue�gZ�\_ehkbi_^_���� ?keb� dlh�gb[m^v� ihl_jye� k\h_]h� ^hjh]h]h� jh^kl\_ggbdZ�� lh� _fm� ^he]h_� \j_fy� ihke_wlh]h� kgylky� kgu� hkh[h]h� jh^Z�� \ dhlhjuo� agZgb_� h kf_jlb� aZdexqZ_l� kZfu_� kljZggu_dhfijhfbkku�k ihlj_[ghklvx�\hkdj_kblv�f_jl\h]h��Lh�mf_jrbc��[m^mqb�f_jl\uf��ijh^he`Z_l\k_�lZdb�`blv��ihlhfm�qlh�hg�g_�agZ_l��qlh�mf_j��b _keb�[u�hg�wlh�magZe��lh�ebrv�lh]^Z�mf_j�[uhdhgqZl_evgh��lh�hg�gZiheh\bgm�f_jl\��Z gZiheh\bgm�`b\��b dZ`^h_�ba�wlbo�khklhygbc�bf__lk\hb�hkh[u_�ijbagZdb��Wlb�kgh\b^_gby�g_evay�gZa\Zlv�[_kkfuke_ggufb��lZd�dZd�\hkdj_k_gb_^ey�kgh\b^_gby�g_�y\ey_lky�g_ijb_fe_fuf��dZd��gZijbf_j��b ^ey�kdZadb�� ]^_�wlh�kh\_jr_gghh[uqgh_� kh[ulb_�� GZkdhevdh� y kfh]� ijhZgZebabjh\Zlv� lZdb_� kgh\b^_gby�� hgb� kihkh[gu� gZjZamfgh_� j_r_gb_�� gh� ^hklhcgh_� m\Z`_gby� `_eZgb_� \ha\jZlblv� d `bagb� f_jl\h]h� mf__l^h[b\Zlvky� wlh]h� kZfufb� kljZggufb� kj_^kl\Zfb�� Y ij_^eZ]Zx� \Zf� a^_kv� lZdh_� kgh\b^_gb_�dhlhjh_�a\mqbl�^hklZlhqgh�kljZggh�b [_kkfuke_ggh�b ZgZeba�dhlhjh]h�ihdZ`_l�\Zf�fgh]h_�balh]h�� d q_fm� \u� ih^]hlh\e_gu� gZrbfb� l_hj_lbq_kdbfb� jZkkm`^_gbyfb�� Kgh\b^_gb_� h^gh]hfm`qbgu��dhlhjuc�g_kdhevdh�e_]�lhfm�gZaZ^�ihl_jye�hlpZ�Hl_p�mf_j��gh�[ue�\udhiZg�b iehoh�\u]ey^bl��K l_o�ihj�hg�`b\_l��b \b^_\rbc�khg�^_eZ_l\k_��qlh[u�hg�gbq_]h�g_�aZf_lbe���AZl_f�kgh\b^_gb_�i_j_oh^bl�gZ�^jm]b_�y\e_gby��g_�bf_xsb_k wlbf��ih�\b^bfhfm��gbq_]h�h[s_]h��Hl_p�mf_j��wlh�fu�agZ_f��Qlh�hg�[ue�\udhiZg��g_�khhl\_lkl\m_l�^_ckl\bl_evghklb��^Z�b \k_ihke_^mxs__�g_�ijbgbfZ_l�__ \h�\gbfZgb_��Gh�\b^_\rbc�khg�jZkkdZau\Z_l��dh]^Z�hg�\_jgmekyk ihohjhg�hlpZ��m g_]h�jZa[he_eky�am[��Hg�ohl_e�ihklmiblv�k gbf�ih�ij_^ibkZgbx�_\j_ckdh]hmq_gby�� _keb� l\hc� am[� l_[_� ^hkZ`^Z_l�� \uj\b� _]h�²� b hlijZ\beky� d am[ghfm� \jZqm��Gh� lhlkdZaZe�� am[� g_� ke_^m_l� \uju\Zlv�� gm`gh� ihl_ji_lv�� Y dh_�qlh� iheh`m�� qlh[u� _]h� m[blv�ijboh^bl_�q_j_a�ljb�^gy�hiylv��y wlh�\ugm�Wlh�©\ugbfZgb_ª��]h\hjbl�\^jm]�\b^_\rbc�khg��b _klv�wdk]mfZpby��G_m`_eb�\b^_\rbc�khg

Page 102: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijZ\"�G_�kh\k_f��ihlhfm�qlh�\_^v�\ugbfZeky�g_�kZf�am[��Z lhevdh�lh��qlh�\ g_f�hf_jl\_eh��Ghih^h[gu_�g_lhqghklb��km^y�ih�^jm]bf�ijbf_jZf��\iheg_�fh`gh�h`b^Zlv�hl�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gby�<b^_\rbc� khg� k]mklbe�� kebe� \ h^gh� mf_jr_]h� hlpZ� b f_jl\uc�� gh� khojZg_gguc� am[�G_m^b\bl_evgh��qlh�\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb�ihemqbehkv�qlh�lh�[_kkfuke_ggh_��ihlhfm�qlh�g_�\k_�qlh�fh`gh�kdZaZlv�h am[_��ih^oh^bl�d hlpm��=^_�`_�\hh[s_�7HUWLXP�FRPSDUDWLRQLV �f_`^m�am[hfb hlphf��qlh�k^_eZeh�\hafh`guf�wlh�k]ms_gb_"B \k_�lZdb� wlh�� ^he`gh� [ulv�� bf_ggh� lZd�� ihlhfm� qlh� \b^_\rbc� khg� ijh^he`Z_ljZkkdZau\Zlv�� qlh� _fm� ba\_klgh�� � _keb� m\b^brv \h� kg_� \uiZ\rbc� am[�� lh� wlh� agZqbl�� qlhihl_jy_rv�dh]h�gb[m^v�ba�qe_gh\�k_fvb�Fu�agZ_f��qlh�wlh�ihimeyjgh_�lhedh\Zgb_�g_\_jgh�beb�\_jgh��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��lhevdh�\rmlhqghf�kfuke_��L_f�[he__�gZk�ihjZ`Z_l�lh�h[klhyl_evkl\h��qlh�gZqZlmx�lZdbf�h[jZahf�l_fmfh`gh�ijhke_^blv�b \�^jm]bo�njZ]f_glZo�kh^_j`Zgby�kgh\b^_gby�;_a� ^Zevg_crbo� lj_[h\Zgbc� \b^_\rbc� khg� gZqbgZ_l� l_i_jv� jZkkdZau\Zlv� h [he_agb� bkf_jlb�hlpZ��b lZd`_�h k\h_f�hlghr_gbb�d g_fm��Hl_p�^he]h�[he_e��moh^�b e_q_gb_�klhbeb�_fm�kugm��fgh]h�^_g_]��B l_f�g_�f_g__�_fm�gbq_]h�g_�[ueh�`Zev��hg�gbdh]^Z�g_� l_jye� l_ji_gby�gbdh]^Z�g_�bkiulu\Ze�`_eZgby�� qlh[u� kdhj__�gZklmibe� dhg_p��Hg� o\ZklZ_l� qbklh� _\j_ckdhcihqlbl_evghklvx�d hlpm��kljh]bf�\uiheg_gb_f�_\j_ckdh]h� aZdhgZ��Gh�g_�[jhkZ_lky�eb�gZf�\]eZaZ�ijhlb\hj_qb_�\ hlghkysboky�d kgh\b^_gbx�fukeyo"�Hg�b^_glbnbpbjh\Ze� am[�k hlphf�Ih� hlghr_gbx� d am[m� hg� ohl_e�ihklmiblv�ih� _\j_ckdhfm� aZdhgm��ijb]h\hj� dhlhjh]h� ]eZkbe�\uj\Zlv�_]h��_keb�hg�ijbqbgy_l�[hev�b ^hkZ^m��B ih�hlghr_gbx�d hlpm�hg�ohl_e�ihklmiblv�ihij_^ibkZgbx�aZdhgZ��dhlhjuc�gZ�wlhl�jZa�hagZqZe��g_kfhljy�gZ�aZljZlu�b [_kihdhckl\h��\aylv\kx�ly`_klv�gZ�k_[y�b i_�^himkdZlv�gbdZdh]h�\jZ`^_[gh]h�gZf_j_gby�ijhlb\�ijbqbgyxs_]h]hj_�h[t_dlZ��JZa\_�koh^kl\h�g_�[ueh�[u�]hjZa^h�[he__�g_khfg_gguf� �Lj_lv_�\ kjZ\g_gbb�_keb�[u�hg�^_ckl\bl_evgh�ijhy\be�ih�hlghr_gbx�d [hevghfm�hlpm�l_�`_�qm\kl\Z��qlh�b d[hevghfm� am[m�� l�� _�� ih`_eZe� [u�� qlh[u� kdhjZy� kf_jlv� iheh`beZ� dhg_p� _]h� baebrg_fm�kljZ^Zevq_kdhfm�b ^hjh]hklhys_fm�kms_kl\h\Zgbx"Y g_�khfg_\Zxkv�\ lhf��qlh�lZdh\h�[ueh�_]h�^_ckl\bl_evgh_�hlghr_gb_�d hlpm�\h�\j_fy_]h�^ebl_evghc�[he_agb��Z o\Zkleb\u_�m\_j_gby�\ _]h�gZ[h`ghc�ihqlbl_evghklb�ij_^gZagZq_gu^ey� lh]h�� qlh[u� hl\e_qv� \gbfZgb_� hl� wlbo� \hkihfbgZgbc��Ijb� lZdbo� mkeh\byo� h[udgh\_ggh\hagbdZ_l� `_eZgb_� kf_jlb� lhfm�� dlh� ijbqbgy_l� [_kihdhckl\h�� b hg� kdju\Z_lky� ih^� fZkdhckhkljZ^Zgby��dh]^Z��gZijbf_j��^mfZxl��wlh�[ueh�[u�^ey�g_]h�lhevdh�ba[Z\e_gb_f��Gh�aZf_lvl_�qlh� \ ^Zgghf� kemqZ_� ^Z`_� \ kdjuluo� fukeyo� kgh\b^_gby� fu� i_j_rZ]gmeb� dZdmx�lh� q_jlm�I_j\Zy� bo� qZklv�� g_khfg_ggh�� lhevdh� \j_f_ggh�� l�� _�� \h� \j_fy� h[jZah\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby�[_kkhagZl_evgZ�� gh� \jZ`^_[gu_� qm\kl\Z� ijhlb\� hlpZ� fh]eb� [ulv� ^ebl_evgh_� \j_fy[_kkhagZl_evgufb�� fh`_l� [ulv�� \hagbdeb� _s_� \ ^_lkdb_� ]h^u�� Z \h� \j_fy� [he_agb� hlpZihkl_i_ggh�jh[dh�b aZfZkdbjh\Zggh�ijhkdZevau\Zeb�\ khagZgb_��K _s_�[hevr_c�m\_j_gghklvxfu� fh`_f� ml\_j`^Zlv� wlh� h ^jm]bo� kdjuluo� fukeyo�� dhlhju_�� [_a� khfg_gby�� [uebij_^klZ\e_gu�\ kh^_j`Zgbb�kgh\b^_gby��Ba�kZfh]h�kgh\b^_gby�h \jZ`^_[guo�qm\kl\Zo�d hlpmgbq_]h�g_evay�magZlv��Gh��bkke_^my�bklhdb�lZdhc�\jZ`^_[ghklb�d hlpm�\ ^_lkl\_��fu�\kihfgbf�

Page 103: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

qlh� kljZo� i_j_^� hlphf� kms_kl\m_l�� ihlhfm� qlh� m`_� \ kZfu_� jZggb_� ]h^u� hg� ijhlb\blkyk_dkmZevghc�^_yl_evghklb�fZevqbdZ��dZd�ijZ\beh��hg�ih\lhjy_l�wlh�ba�khpbZevguo�khh[jZ`_gbcb ihke_� ^hklb`_gby� bf� \hajZklZ� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb�� Wlh� hlghr_gb_� d hlpm� k\hckl\_ggh� bgZr_fm� \b^_\r_fm� khg� ebpm�� d _]h� ex[\b� d hlpm� [ueh� ijb[Z\e_gh� ^hklZlhqgh� m\Z`_gby� bkljZoZ��bf_\rbo�k\hbf�bklhqgbdhf�jZgg__�k_dkmZevgh_�aZim]b\Zgb_�>Zevg_crb_� ml\_j`^_gby� y\gh]h� kgh\b^_gby� h[tykgyxlky� dhfie_dkhf� hgZgbafZ�� ©�Hgiehoh�\u]ey^blª�ohly�b hlghkblky�d keh\Zf�am[gh]h�\jZqZ��qlh�[m^_l�g_djZkb\h��_keb�\uj\Zlvam[�gZ�wlhf�f_kl_��gh�h^gh\j_f_ggh�wlh�bf__l�hlghr_gb_�d g_\Z`ghfm�\b^m��dhlhjuf�fheh^hcq_eh\_d� \ i_jbh^� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb� \u^Z_l� beb� [hblky� \u^Zlv� k\hx� qj_af_jgmx� iheh\mx^_yl_evghklv��Lh��qlh�\b^_\rbc�khg�g_�[_a�h[e_]q_gby�i_j_g_k�\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb�g_\Z`guc\b^�k k_[y�gZ�hlpZ��_klv�h^gZ�ba�ba\_klguo�\Zf�bg\_jkbc�\ jZ[hl_�kgh\b^_gby��K l_o�ihj�hgijh^he`Z_l�`blv�ihdju\Z_lky�dZd�`_eZgb_f�\hkdj_kblv��lZd�b h[_sZgb_f�am[gh]h�\jZqZ��qlham[� khojZgblky��Gh� hkh[_ggh� obljhmfgh� ij_^eh`_gb_� ©\b^_\rbc� khg� ^_eZ_l� \k_�� qlh[u� hg�hl_p���wlh]h�g_�aZf_lbeª��gZijZ\e_ggh_�gZ�lh��qlh[u�kdehgblv�gZk�d ^hiheg_gbx��qlh�hg�mf_j�Gh�_^bgkl\_ggh�jZamfgh_�^hiheg_gb_�\ul_dZ_l�hiylv�lZdb�ba�dhfie_dkZ�hgZgbafZ��dh]^Z��kZfhkh[hc�jZamf__lky��fheh^hc�q_eh\_d�^_eZ_l�\k_��qlh[u�kdjulv�hl�hlpZ�k\hx�k_dkmZevgmx�`bagv�<kihfgbl_��gZdhg_p�� qlh� lZd�gZau\Z_fu_� kgh\b^_gby� k \uju\Zgb_f� am[Z�fu� ^he`gu� \k_]^Zlhedh\Zlv�dZd�hgZgbklbq_kdb_�b \ujZ`Zxsb_�kljZo�i_j_^�gZdZaZgb_f�aZ�hgZgbaf�L_i_jv� \u� \b^bl_�� dZd� khklZ\behkv� wlh� g_ihgylgh_� kgh\b^_gb_��Ijhbahreh� kljZggh_� b\\h^ys__�\ aZ[em`^_gb_�k]ms_gb_��\ dhlhjhf�\k_�fukeb�ijhbkoh^yl�ba�kj_^u�kdjuluo�fuke_cb \� dhlhjhf� ^ey� kZfuo� ]em[hdbo� b hl^Ze_gguo� ih� \j_f_gb� ba� wlbo� fuke_c� kha^Zxlky� __fgh]hagZqgu_�aZf_sZxsb_�h[jZah\Zgby����Fu� m`_� g_h^ghdjZlgh� iulZebkv� \aylvky� aZ� l_� ©lj_a\u_ª� b [ZgZevgu_� kgh\b^_gby�� \dhlhjuo�g_l�gbq_]h�[_kkfuke_ggh]h�beb�kljZggh]h��gh�ih�hlghr_gbx�d dhlhjuf�\klZ_l�\hijhk�aZq_f� \b^brv� \h� kg_� lZdmx� q_imom"� Y ohqm� ijb\_klb� _s_� h^bg� ijbf_j� lZdh]h� jh^Z�� ljbkhklZ\eyxsb_�h^gh�p_eh_�kgh\b^_gby��ijbkgb\rb_ky�\ h^gm�ghqv�fheh^hc�^Zf_�Z��HgZ�b^_l�q_j_a�aZem�k\h_]h�^hfZ�b jZa[b\Z_l�]heh\m�h gbadh�\bkysmx�exkljm�GbdZdbo�\hkihfbgZgbc��gbq_]h��qlh�^_ckl\bl_evgh�ijhbahreh�[u��?�dhff_glZjbb�\_^mlkh\k_f�ih�^jm]hfm�imlb��©<u�agZ_l_��dZd�kbevgh�m f_gy�\uiZ^Zxl�\hehku��>bly��kdZaZeZ�fg_\q_jZ�fZlv�� _keb� lZd� [m^_l� ijh^he`Zlvky�� lh� m l_[y� ]heh\Z� klZg_l� dZd� aZ^gyy� qZklv� �Jhjh�ª�BlZd�� ]heh\Z� \uklmiZ_l� a^_kv� \f_klh� ^jm]h]h� dhgpZ� l_eZ��Exkljm�fu� b kZfb�fh`_f� ihgylvkbf\hebq_kdb��\k_�ij_^f_lu��kihkh[gu_�\uly]b\Zlvky�\ ^ebgm��y\eyxlky�kbf\heZfb�fm`kdh]hqe_gZ��LZdbf�h[jZahf��j_qv�b^_l�h djh\hl_q_gbb�ba�gb`g_c�qZklb�l_eZ��dhlhjh_�\hagbdZ_l�hlklhedgh\_gby� k i_gbkhf�� Wlh� fh]eh� [u� bf_lv� _s_� g_kdhevdh� agZq_gbc�� __ ZkkhpbZlb\gu_fukeb� ihdZau\Zxl�� qlh� ^_eh� aZdexqZ_lky� \ ij_^iheh`_gbb�� [m^lh�f_gkljmZpby� \hagbdZ_l� \j_amevlZl_� iheh\h]h� ZdlZ� k fm`qbghc�²� qZklv� k_dkmZevghc� l_hjbb�� jZkijhkljZg_gghc� kj_^bfgh]bo�g_aj_eu_�^_\mr_d�[��HgZ� \b^bl� \ \bgh]jZ^gbd_� ]em[hdmx� yfm�� h dhlhjhc� hgZ� agZ_l�� qlh� lZ� h[jZah\ZeZkv[eZ]h^Zjy�\uj\Zgghfm�^_j_\m��HgZ�aZf_qZ_l�ijb�wlhfA�qlh�^_j_\Z�m g__�g_l��HgZ�bf__l�\ \b^m�qlh� g_� \b^_eZ� ^_j_\Z� \h� kg_�� gh� wlZ� njZaZ� kem`bl� \ujZ`_gb_f� ^jm]hc� fukeb�� dhlhjZy

Page 104: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

iheghklvx� ih^l\_j`^Z_l� kbf\hebq_kdh_� lhedh\Zgb_�� Kgh\b^_gb_� hlghkblky� d ^jm]hc� qZklb^_lkdbo� k_dkmZevguo� l_hjbc� ²� d m[_`^_gbx�� qlh� i_j\hgZqZevgh� ^_\hqdb� bf_eb� lZdb_� `_]_gblZebb�� dZd� b fZevqbdb�� b l_i_j_rgyy� bo� nhjfZ� h[jZah\ZeZkv� \ j_amevlZl_� dZkljZpbb�\uju\Zgby�^_j_\Z��\�� HgZ� klhbl� i_j_^� ysbdhf� k\h_]h� ibkvf_ggh]h� klheZ�� \ dhlhjhf� _c� \k_� lZd� ohjhrhagZdhfh��qlh�hgZ�kjZam�`_�magZ_l��_keb�dlh�gb[m^v�\ g_f�jueky��Ysbd�ibkvf_ggh]h�klheZ��dZd\kydbc� ysbd�� kmg^md�� dhjh[dZ� ²� `_gkdb_� ]_gblZebb��HgZ� agZ_l�� qlh� ih� ]_gblZebyf� fh`ghmagZlv� h[� bf_\r_f� f_klh� iheh\hf� kghr_gbb� �dZd� hgZ� ^mfZ_l�� b ijbdhkgh\_gbb��� b ^Z\gh[hblky� lZdh]h� jZah[eZq_gby�� Y ^mfZx�� qlh� \h� \k_o� wlbo� lj_o� kgh\b^_gbyo� Zdp_gl� ke_^m_lk^_eZlv� gZ� ihagZgbb�� HgZ� \kihfbgZ_l� \j_fy� k\h_]h� ^_lkdh]h� k_dkmZevgh]h� bkke_^h\Zgby�j_amevlZlZfb�dhlhjh]h�lh]^Z�hq_gv�]hj^beZkv����Hiylv�g_fgh]h� kbf\hebdb��Gh�gZ� wlhl� jZa� \ dhjhldhf�ij_^\Zjbl_evghf� khh[s_gbb� yaZjZg__�ij_^klZ\ex�ikbobq_kdmx�kblmZpbx��H^bg�]hkih^bg��dhlhjuc�ijh\_e�ex[h\gmx�ghqv�k`_gsbghc�� hibku\Z_l� k\hx� iZjlg_jrm� dZd� h^gm� ba� l_o� fZl_jbgkdbo� gZlmj�� m dhlhjuo� ijbiheh\uo�kghr_gbyo�k fm`qbghc�g_hl\jZlbfh�ihy\ey_lky�`_eZgb_�bf_lv�j_[_gdZ��Gh�mkeh\bylhc�\klj_qb�lj_[mxl�hklhjh`ghklb��ba�aZ�dhlhjhc�hieh^hl\hjyxs__�k_fyba\_j`_gb_�m^Zey_lkyba�`_gkdh]h�ehgZ��Ijhkgm\rbkv�ihke_�wlhc�ghqb��`_gsbgZ�jZkkdZau\Z_l�ke_^mxsbc�khg�GZ�mebp_�__ ij_ke_^m_l�hnbp_j�\ djZkghc�nmjZ`d_��HgZ�m[_]Z_l�hl�g_]h��[_`bl�\\_jo�ihe_klgbp_��hg�\k_�aZ�g_c��AZ^uoZykv��hgZ�^hklb]Z_l�k\h_c�d\Zjlbju�b aZoehiu\Z_l�aZ�kh[hc�^\_jv�Hg�hklZ_lky�kgZjm`b�b��dZd�hgZ�\b^bl�\ ]eZahd��kb^bl�kgZjm`b�b ieZq_l�< ij_ke_^h\Zgbb�hnbp_jZ�\ djZkghc�nmjZ`d_�b \�lhf��dZd�hgZ�aZ^uoZykv�ih^gbfZ_lky�ihe_klgbp_�� \u�� \b^bfh�� magZeb� bah[jZ`_gb_� iheh\h]h� ZdlZ�� Lh�� qlh� \b^_\rZy� khg� aZibjZ_lkyi_j_^� ij_ke_^h\Zl_e_f�� fh`_l� kem`blv� ijbf_jhf� lZd� qZklh� bkihevam_fuo� \ kgh\b^_gbbbg\_jkbc��ihlhfm�qlh�\_^v�\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�fm`qbgZ�\ha^_j`Zeky�hl�hdhgqZgby�ex[h\gh]hZdlZ��Lhqgh� lZd�`_�hgZ�i_j_g_keZ�k\hx� ]jmklv�gZ�iZjlg_jZ�� lZd�dZd�hg�ieZq_l�\ kgh\b^_gbb�h^gh\j_f_ggh�wlbf�^_eZ_lky�gZf_d�gZ�k_fyba\_j`_gb_�<u��dhg_qgh��dh]^Z�gb[m^v�keurZeb��[m^lh�ikbohZgZeba�ml\_j`^Z_l��qlh�\k_�kgh\b^_gbybf_xl�k_dkmZevgh_�agZq_gb_��L_i_jv�\u�kZfb�\ khklhygbb�km^blv�h dhjj_dlghklb�wlh]h�mij_dZ�<u� ihagZdhfbebkv� kh� kgh\b^_gbyfb�� \ujZ`Zxsbfb� `_eZgby�� \ dhlhjuo� j_qv� b^_l� h[m^h\e_l\hj_gbb� kZfuo� ykguo� ihlj_[ghkl_c�� ]heh^Z�� `Z`^uÄ� lhkdb� ih� k\h[h^_�� khkgh\b^_gbyfb�� \ujZ`Zxsbfb� m^h[kl\h� b g_l_ji_gb_�� Z lZd`_� qbklh� dhjuklhex[b\ufb� bw]hbklbq_kdbfb�� Gh� \h� \kydhf� kemqZ_� \u� ^he`gu� aZihfgblv� dZd� j_amevlZlikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�bkke_^h\Zgby��qlh�kbevgh�bkdZ`_ggu_�kgh\b^_gby�ij_bfms_kl\_ggh��ghhiylv�lZdb�g_�bkdexqbl_evgh��\ujZ`Zxl�k_dkmZevgu_�`_eZgby���� M f_gy� hkh[Zy� ijbqbgZ� ijb\_klb� ih[hevr_� ijbf_jh\� bkihevah\Zgby� kbf\heh\� \kgh\b^_gbb�� Ijb� gZr_c� i_j\hc� \klj_q_� y `Zeh\Zeky� gZ� lh�� dZd� ljm^gZ� ijb� ij_ih^Z\ZgbbikbohZgZebaZ�^_fhgkljZpby�b dZd�keh`gh�knhjfbjh\Zlv�lZdbf�iml_f�m[_`^_gby��b \u�kh�fghc�g_khfg_ggh��kh]eZkgu��H^gZdh�hl^_evgu_�ml\_j`^_gby�ikbohZgZebaZ�gZklhevdh�l_kgh�k\yaZguf_`^m�kh[hc��qlh�m[_`^_gb_�e_]dh�fh`_l�jZkijhkljZgblvky�k h^gh]h�imgdlZ�gZ�[hevrmx�qZklv\k_c�l_hjbb��H ikbohZgZeba_�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�kdZaZlv��dlh�^Z_l�_fm�iZe_p��lh]h�hg�^_j`bl�m`_�aZ

Page 105: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\kx� jmdm�� Dhfm� ykgh� h[tykg_gb_� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bb�� lhl�� ih� eh]bd_� \_s_c�� g_� fh`_l� g_ih\_jblv� \k_fm� hklZevghfm�� <lhjuf� lZdbf� `_� ^hklmiguf� fhf_glhf� y\ey_lky� kbf\hebdZkgh\b^_gbc��Khh[sm� \Zf� m`_� him[ebdh\Zggh_� kgh\b^_gb_�`_gsbgu� ba� ijhklhgZjh^vy��fm`dhlhjhc�ihebp_ckdbc�b dhlhjZy��dhg_qgh��gbdh]^Z�gbq_]h�g_�keurZeZ�h kbf\hebd_�kgh\b^_gbcb ikbohZgZeba_�� Km^bl_� kZfb�� fh`gh� eb� gZa\Zlv� ijhba\hevguf� b bkdmkkl\_gguf� _]hlhedh\Zgb_�k ihfhsvx�k_dkmZevguo�kbf\heh\�©���AZl_f�dlh�lh�\hj\Zeky�\ d\Zjlbjm��b hgZ�\ bkim]_�iha\ZeZ�ihebp_ckdh]h��Gh�lhl�k ^\mfyÄ[jh^y]Zfb��kihdhcgh�ihr_e�\ p_jdh\v��d dhlhjhc�\_eh�g_kdhevdh�klmi_g_c��AZ�p_jdh\vx�[ueZ]hjZ��Z gZ\_jom�]mklhc�e_k��GZ�ihebp_ckdhf�[ue�re_f��djm]euc�\hjhlgbd�b ieZs��m g_]h�[ueZl_fgZy�[hjh^Z��H[Z�[jh^y]b��dhlhju_�fbjgh�reb�\f_kl_�k ihebp_ckdbf��bf_eb�ih\yaZggu_�gZ[_^jZo�f_rdhh[jZagu_�i_j_^gbdb�Hl�p_jd\b�d ]hj_�\_eZ�^hjh]Z�HgZ�k h[_bo�klhjhg�ihjhkeZljZ\hc�b dmklZjgbdhf��dhlhjuc�klZgh\beky�\k_�]ms_��Z gZ�\_jrbg_�ij_\jZsZeky�\ gZklhysbce_kª�<u� [_a� ljm^Z� magZ_l_� bkihevah\Zggu_� kbf\heu��Fm`kdb_� ]_gblZebb� bah[jZ`_gu� lj_fyebpZfb�� `_gkdb_� ²� eZg^rZnlhf� k dZi_eehc�� ]hjhc� b e_khf�� <u� hiylv� \klj_qZ_l_kv� khklmi_gyfb� \ dZq_kl\_� kbf\heZ� iheh\h]h� ZdlZ�� Lh�� qlh� \ kgh\b^_gbb� gZau\Z_lky� ]hjhc�� b \ZgZlhfbb�bf__l�lh�`_�gZa\Zgb_��Z bf_ggh�0RQV�9HQHULV��[m]hj�<_g_ju����?s_�h^gh�kgh\b^_gb_��dhlhjh_�fh`gh�jZatykgblv�ijb�ihfhsb�kbf\heh\��aZf_qZl_evgh_b m[_^bl_evgh_�l_f��qlh�kZf�\b^_\rbc�khg�i_j_\_e�\k_�kbf\heu��ohly�m g_]h�g_�[ueh�gbdZdboij_^\Zjbl_evguo� l_hj_lbq_kdbo� agZgbc� ^ey� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc�� LZdhc� h[jZa� ^_ckl\bc\_kvfZ�g_h[uq_g��b mkeh\by�_]h�lhqgh�g_ba\_klgu�©Hg� ]mey_l� k hlphf�\ dZdhf� lh�f_kl_��gZ\_jgh_��gZ�EjZl_j_��ihlhfm�qlh� \b^gZ� jhlhg^Z�i_j_^�g_c�fZe_gvdZy�ijbkljhcdZ��d g_c�ijb\yaZg�\ha^mrguc�rZj��dhlhjuc�dZ`_lky�^h\hevghiehoh�gZ^mluf��Hl_p�kijZrb\Z_l�_]h��d q_fm�\k_�wlh��hg�m^b\ey_lky�wlhfm��gh�h[tykgy_l�_fm�AZl_f�hgb�ijboh^yl�gZ�^\hj��gZ�dhlhjhf�jZaeh`_g�[hevrhc�ebkl�`_klb��Hl_p�ohq_l�hlhj\Zlvk_[_�hl�g_]h�[hevrhc�dmkhd��gh�kgZqZeZ�h]ey^u\Z_lky��g_�fh`_l�eb�_]h�dlh�gb[m^v�aZf_lblv��Hg]h\hjbl� _fm��qlh�gm`gh� lhevdh� kdZaZlv� kfhljbl_ex��b lh]^Z� hg�fh`_l� \aylv� k_[_�[_a� \kydbodhe_[Zgbc��Ba�wlh]h�^\hjZ�\gba�\_^_l�e_klgbpZ�\ rZolm��kl_gu�dhlhjhc�h[blu�fy]dbf��\jh^_dZd� dh`Zgh_� dj_keh�� < dhgp_� wlhc� rZolu� ^ebggZy� ieZlnhjfZ�� Z ^Zevr_� gZqbgZ_lky� gh\ZyrZolZ���ªKZf�\b^_\rbc�khg�lhedm_l�_]h��jhlhg^Z�²�fhb� ]_gblZebb��\ha^mrguc�rZj�i_j_^�g_c²fhc�i_gbk��gZ�fy]dhklv�dhlhjh]h�y \ugm`^_g�`Zeh\Zlvky��Ke_^m_l�i_j_\_klb�[he__�^_lZevgh�jhlhg^Z� ²� aZ^gyy� qZklv�� ihklhyggh� ijbqbkey_fZy� j_[_gdhf� d ]_gblZebyf�� fZe_gvdZyijbkljhcdZ�²�fhrhgdZ��< kgh\b^_gbb�hl_p�_]h�kijZrb\Z_l��qlh�\k_�wlh�agZqbl��l��_��h p_qb�bnmgdpbb�]_gblZebc��<iheg_�_kl_kl\_ggh�h[_jgmlv�wlh�iheh`_gb_�\_s_c�lZd��qlh[u�kijZrb\Zehg��LZd�dZd�hg�gbdh]^Z�g_�kijZrb\Ze�hlpZ�h[� wlhf��fukev�kgh\b^_gby�ke_^m_l�ihgbfZlv�dZd`_eZgb_� ijbgylv� _]h� mkeh\gh� \jh^_�� ©_keb� [u� y ihijhkbe� hlpZ� jZatykgblv� k_dkmZevgh_ª�Ijh^he`_gb_�wlhc�fukeb�fu�kdhjh�gZc^_f�\ ^jm]hf�f_kl_�>\hj�� ]^_� jZaeh`_gZ� `_klv�� g_� ke_^m_l� kjZam� ihgbfZlv� kbf\hebq_kdb�� hg� ij_^klZ\ey_lkh[hc� lhj]h\h_� ihf_s_gb_� hlpZ�� Ih� ijbqbg_� kh[ex^_gby� lZcgu� y aZf_gbe� `_klvx� lhl

Page 106: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fZl_jbZe�� dhlhjuf� lhj]m_l� hl_p�� g_� baf_gb\� gb \� q_f� hklZevghf� ^hkeh\gmx� i_j_^Zqmkgh\b^_gby�� <b^_\rbc� khg� \klmibe� \ ^_eh� hlpZ� b [ue� qj_a\uqZcgh� ihjZ`_g� lhc� kdhj__g_dhjj_dlghc� ijZdlbdhc�� gZ� dhlhjhc� ih� [hevr_c� qZklb� hkgh\u\Z_lky� ihemq_� ib_� ijb[ueb�Ihwlhfm�ijh^he`_gb_�\ur_mihfygmlhc�fukeb�kgh\b^_gby�fh]eh�[u�]eZkblv��©�_keb�[u�y _]hkijhkbe��� hg� h[fZgme� [u� f_gy�� dZd� h[fZgu\Z_l� k\hbo� deb_glh\ª�� Ih� ih\h^m� ehfdb� `_klb�dhlhjZy� kem`bl� ^ey� bah[jZ`_gby� ^_eh\hc� g_q_klghklb�� \b^_\rbc� khg� kZf� ^Z_l� \lhjh_h[tykg_gb_��hgZ�hagZqZ_l�hgZgbaf��Wlh�gZf�g_�lhevdh�^Z\gh�agZdhfh��gh�lZd`_�hq_gv�ohjhrhkh]eZkm_lky� k l_f��qlh� lZcgZ� hgZgba�fZ� \ujZ`_gZ�ihkj_^kl\hf�ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb� �\_^v� wlhfh`gh� ^_eZlv� hldjulh��� >Z� e__�� dZd� b ke_^h\Zeh� h`b^Zlv�� hgZgbklbq_kdZy� ^_yl_evghklvijbibku\Z_lky�hiylv�lZdb�hlpm��dZd�b jZkkijhku�\ i_j\hc�kp_g_�kgh\b^_gby��RZolm�hg�kjZam`_�lhedm_l�dZd�\eZ]Zebs_��kkueZykv�gZ�fy]dmx�h[b\dm�kl_g��Lh��qlh�kimkdhf��dZd�b ih^t_fhf�h[uqgh�bah[jZ`Z_lky�iheh\hf�Zdl�\h�\eZ]Zebs_��y ^h[Z\ex�ih�kh[kl\_gghc�bgbpbZlb\_�L_�^_lZeb��qlh�aZ�i_j\hc�rZ?lhb�ke_^m_l�^ebggZy�ieZlnhjfZ��Z aZl_f�gh\Zy�rZolZ��hg�kZfh[tykgy_l�[bh]jZnbq_kdb��Hg�^he]h_� \j_fy� \_e�iheh\mx�`bagv�� aZl_f� hldZaZeky� hl�iheh\uokghr_gbc�\ke_^kl\b_�aZljm^g_gbc�b l_i_jv�gZ^__lky�hiylv�\hah[gh\blv�b?�k ihfhsvx�e_q_gby����H[Z�ke_^mxsbo�kgh\b^_gby�h^gh]h�bghkljZgpZ�k ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklvx�d iheb]Zfbb�yijb\_^m� \Zf� \ ^hdZaZl_evkl\h� ml\_j`^_gby�� qlh� kh[kl\_ggh_� Y ijhy\ey_lky� \ dZ`^hfkgh\b^_gbb�� ^Z`_� _keb� hgh� kdjulh� \ y\ghf� kh^_j`Zgbb�� Q_fh^Zgu� \ kgh\b^_gbb� y\eyxlky`_gkdbfb�kbf\heZfb�Z��Hg� m_a`Z_l�� _]h� [Z]Z`� ^hklZ\ey_lky� \ wdbiZ`_� gZ� \hdaZe�� fgh]h� q_fh^Zgh\� h^bg� gZ^jm]hf�� kj_^b� gbo� ^\Z� [hevrbo� q_jguo� ©h[jZaph\uoª� q_fh^ZgZ�� < ml_r_gb_� hg� dhfm�lh]h\hjbl��lZd�\_^v�wlb�_^ml�lhevdh�^h�\hdaZeZ�< ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� hg� iml_r_kl\m_l� k hq_gv� [hevrbf� [Z]Z`hf�� \h� \j_fy� e_q_gbyjZkkdZau\Z_l�lZd`_�hq_gv�fgh]h�bklhjbc�k `_gsbgZfb��>\Z�q_jguo�q_fh^ZgZ�khhl\_lkl\mxl^\mf�[jxg_ldZf��dhlhju_�\ gZklhys__�\j_fy�b]jZxl�\ _]h�`bagb�]eZ\gmx�jhev��H^gZ�ba�gboohl_eZ�ijb_oZlv�\ke_^�aZ�gbf�\ <_gm��gh�ih�fh_fm�kh\_lm�hg�hldZaZe�_c�ih�l_e_]jZnm�[�� Kp_gZ� \ lZfh`g_�� h^bg� iZkkZ`bj� hldju\Z_l� k\hc� q_fh^Zg� b ]h\hjbl�� jZ\gh^mrghaZdmjb\Zy�iZibjhkm��lml�gbq_]h�g_l��LZfh`_gguc�qbgh\gbd��dZ`_lky��\_jbl�_fm��gh�himkdZ_l_s_�jZa�jmdm�b gZoh^bl�qlh�lh�hkh[_ggh�aZij_s_ggh_��Lh]^Z�iZkkZ`bj�jZahqZjh\Zggh�]h\hjbl�lml�gbq_]h�g_�ih^_eZ_rv��Hg�kZf�²�iZkkZ`bj��y ²�lZfh`_gguc�qbgh\gbd��H[uqgh�hg�hq_gvbkdj_g_g� \ k\hbo� ijbagZgbyo�� gh� j_rbe� mlZblv� hl� f_gy� gh\mx� k\yav� k ^Zfhc�� ihlhfm� qlhijZ\bevgh� iheZ]Ze�� qlh� hgZ� fg_� g_[_aua\_klgZ��G_ijbylgh_� iheh`_gb_� [ulv� mebq_gguf� hgi_j_g_k�gZ�qm`h_�ebph��lZd�qlh�kZf�hg�dZd�[m^lh�g_�ihy\ey_lky�\ wlhf�kgh\b^_gbb����<hl�ijbf_j�bkihevah\Zgby�kbf\heZ��h dhlhjhf�y _s_�g_�mihfbgZe�Hg�\klj_qZ_l�k\hx�k_kljm�\ khijh\h`^_gbb�^\mo�ih^jm]��dhlhju_�kZfb�k_klju��Hg�ih^Z_ljmdm�h[_bf��Z k_kl_j�g_l�GbdZdhc�k\yab�k ^_ckl\bl_evgufb�kh[ulbyfb��?]h�fukeb�mghkylky�d lhfm�\j_f_gb��dh]^Zhg�jZafureye�gZ^�k\hbf�gZ[ex^_gb_f��qlh� ]jm^v�^_\hq_d�jZa\b\Z_lky� lZd�iha^gh��BlZd��h[_k_klju�²�wlh�]jm^b��hg�k m^h\hevkl\b_f�[u�bo�ihljh]Ze��gh�lhevdh�qlh[u�wlh�g_�[ueb�]jm^b_]h�k_klju�

Page 107: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

����: \hl�ijbf_j�kbf\hebdb�kf_jlb�\ kgh\b^_gbb�Hg�b^_l�ih�hq_gv�\ukhdhfm�djmlhfm�`_e_aghfm�fhklbdm�k ^\mfy�ebpZfb��bf_gZ�dhlhjuoagZ_l��gh�ijb�ijh[m`^_gbb�aZ[u\Z_l��<^jm]�l_�^\h_�bkq_aZxl��Z hg�\b^bl�q_eh\_dZ��ihoh`_]h�gZijb\b^_gb_��\ dheiZd_�b ihehlgyghf�dhklxf_��Hg�kijZrb\Z_l�m g_]h��g_�l_e_]jZnbkl�eb�hg���G_l��G_� ba\haqbd� eb"�G_l��Lh]^Z� hg� b^_l� ^Zevr_�� _s_� \h� kg_� bkiulu\Z_l� kbevguc� kljZo� b�ijhkgm\rbkv�� ijh^he`Z_l� kgh\b^_gb_� nZglZab_c�� qlh� `_e_aguc� fhkl� \^jm]� ehfZ_lky�� b hgiZ^Z_l�\ ijhiZklv�EbpZ��h dhlhjuo�ih^q_jdb\Z_lky��qlh�hgb�g_ba\_klgu��qlh�bo�bf_gZ�aZ[ulu��ih�[hevr_cqZklb� hq_gv� [ebadb_� ex^b�� <b^_\rbc� khg� bf__l� ^\mo� k_kl_j�� _keb� [u� hg� ohl_e� bf� h[_bfkf_jlb��lh�[ueh�[u�\iheg_�kijZ\_^eb\h��qlh�aZ�wlh�_]h�ihklb]�[u�kljZo�kf_jlb��H l_e_]jZnbkl_hg�aZf_qZ_l��qlh�lZdb_�ex^b�\k_]^Z�ijbghkyl�iehob_�\_klb��km^y�ih�nhjf_gghc�h^_`^_��wlh�fh][ulv� b nhgZjsbd�� dhlhjuc� lZd�`_� lmrbl� nhgZjb�� dZd� ]_gbc� kf_jlb� ]Zkbl� nZd_e� `bagb�� Kba\haqbdhf� hg� Zkkhpbbjm_l� klbohl\hj_gb_� MeZg^Z� h fhjkdhc� ih_a^d_� dhjhey� DZjeZ� b\kihfbgZ_l� hiZkgh_�fhjkdh_� iml_r_kl\b_� k ^\mfy� lh\ZjbsZfb�� \h� \j_fy� dhlhjh]h� hg� b]jZejhev� dhjhey� ba� klbohl\hj_gby�� Ih� ih\h^m� `_e_agh]h� fhklZ� _fm� ijboh^bl� \ ]heh\m� h^bgg_kqZklguc�kemqZc�ihke_^g_]h�\j_f_gb�b ]emih_�\ujZ`_gb_�©`bagv�_klv�fhkl�ba�p_i_cª�B��>jm]bf�ijbf_jhf�bah[jZ`_gby�kf_jlb�fh`_l�kem`blv�kgh\b^_gb_�G_ba\_klguc�]hkih^bg�ih^Z_l�aZ�g_]h�\bablgmx�dZjlhqdm�k q_jghc�dZcfhc����� <h� fgh]bo� hlghr_gbyo� \Zk� aZbgl_j_km_l� ke_^mxs__� kgh\b^_gb_�� d ij_^ihkuedZfdhlhjh]h��ijZ\^Z��hlghkblky�g_\jhlbq_kdh_�khklhygb_�Hg� _^_l�ih�`_e_aghc�^hjh]_��Ih_a^�hklZgZ\eb\Z_lky� \ hldjulhf�ihe_��Hg�iheZ]Z_l�� qlh]jhabl� dZlZkljhnZ�� b gZ^h� ih^mfZlv� h lhf�� qlh[u� kiZklbkv� [_]kl\hf�� ijhoh^bl� ih� \k_fhl^_e_gbyf�ih_a^Z�b m[b\Z_l�\k_o��dh]h�\klj_qZ_l��dhg^mdlhjh\��fZrbgbklZ�b l��^�Ih� wlhfm� ih\h^m� ²� \hkihfbgZgb_� h jZkkdZa_� ^jm]Z�� GZ� dZdhc�lh� ebgbb� \ BlZebb� \ihemdmi_� i_j_\habeb� ^mr_\gh[hevgh]h�� gh� ih� g_^hkfhljm� \imklbeb� d g_fm� iZkkZ`bjZ�>mr_\gh[hevghc� m[be� kimlgbdZ�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� hg� b^_glbnbpbjm_l� k_[y� k wlbf^mr_\gh[hevguf� b h[hkgh\u\Z_l� k\h_� ijZ\h� gZ\yaqb\uf� ij_^klZ\e_gb_f�� dhlhjh_� _]h\j_f_gZfb�fmqZ_l�� qlh� hg� ^he`_g� ©mkljZgblv� \k_o� khmqZklgbdh\ª��Gh� aZl_f� hg� kZf�gZoh^blemqrmx� fhlb\bjh\dm�� dhlhjZy� ^Z_l� ih\h^� ^ey� kgh\b^_gby�� <q_jZ� \ l_Zlj_� hg� kgh\Z� m\b^_e^_\mrdm��gZ�dhlhjhc�ohl_e�`_gblvkyª�gh�hklZ\be��lZd�dZd�hgZ�^ZeZ�_fm�hkgh\Zgb_�^ey�j_\ghklb�Ijb�lhc�bgl_gkb\ghklb��^h�dhlhjhc�m g_]h�^hoh^bl�j_\ghklv��hg�^_ckl\bl_evgh�khr_e�[u�k mfZ�_keb�[u�`_gbeky�gZ�g_c��Wlh� agZqbl��hg� kqblZ_l� _�gZklhevdh�g_gZ^_`ghc�� qlh�ba� j_\ghklb^he`_g� [ue� [u� m[b\Zlv� \k_o� ex^_c�� dhlhju_� ihiZ^Zebkv� _fm� gZ� imlb��Oh`^_gb_� q_j_a� jy^dhfgZl�� \ ^Zgghf� kemqZ_� hl^_e_gbc�� dZd� kbf\he� khklhygby� \ [jZd_� �9HUKHLUDWHW�VHLQ��ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv�_^bgh[jZqbx�²�(LQHKH��fu�m`_�agZ_f�H[�hklZgh\d_�ih_a^Z�\ hldjulhf�ihe_�b kljZo_�i_j_^�dZlZkljhnhc�hg�jZkkdZau\Z_l��dh]^Zh^gZ`^u� \h� \j_fy� ih_a^db� ih� `_e_aghc� ^hjh]_� ijhbahreZ� g_h`b^ZggZy� hklZgh\dZ� g_� gZklZgpbb�� h^gZ� _^msZy� \f_kl_� k gbf� fheh^Zy� ^ZfZ� aZy\beZ�� qlh�� \hafh`gh�� ij_^klhbl

Page 108: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

klhedgh\_gb_�b lh]^Z� kZfuf�p_e_khh[jZaguf� [ueh�[u� m[_`Zlv� >GLH� %HLQH� KRFK� ]X� KH�EHQ�²ih^gylv�\\_jo�gh]b@��Gh�wlh�©gh]b�\\_joª��GLH�%HLQH�KRFK��b]jZeh�lZd`_�k\hx�jhev�\h�fgh]boijh]medZo�g wdkdmjkbyo�gZ�ehgh�ijbjh^u��dhlhju_�hg�ij_^ijbgbfZe�k lhc�^_\mrdhc�\ i_j\h_kqZkleb\h_� \j_fy� ex[\b��Gh\uc� Zj]mf_gl� ^ey� lh]h�� qlh� hg� ^he`_g� [ue� khclb� k mfZ�� qlh[ul_i_jv� `_gblvky� gZ� g_c�� Y fh]� kqblZlv� g_khfg_gguf�� agZy� kblmZpbx�� qlh� m g_]h� \k_� _s_bf_ehkv�wlh�`_eZgb_�[ulv�lZdbf�kmfZkr_^rbf�LJBG:>P:L:Y�E?DPBY:joZbq_kdb_�q_jlu�b bgnZglbebaf�kgh\b^_gbyM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��Iha\hevl_�fg_�hiylv�gZqZlv�k ihemq_ggh]h�gZfb�j_amevlZlZ�qlh� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby� ih^� \ebygb_f� p_gamju� i_j_\h^bl� kdjulu_� fukeb� \ ^jm]mx� nhjfm\ujZ`_gby��Kdjulu_�fukeb�²�wlh�g_�qlh�bgh_��dZd�ba\_klgu_�gZf�khagZl_evgu_�fukeb�gZr_c`bagb� \ khklhygbb� [h^jkl\h\Zgby�� gh\uc� kihkh[� bo� \ujZ`_gby� g_ihgyl_g� gZf� ba�aZ� k\hbofgh]hh[jZaguo� q_jl�� Fu� kdZaZeb�� qlh� hg� \ha\jZsZ_lky� d l_f� khklhygbyf� gZr_]hbgl_ee_dlmZevgh]h� jZa\blby�� dhlhju_� fu� ^Z\gh� ij_h^he_eb�� d h[jZaghfm� yaudm�kbf\hebq_kdhfm�hlghr_gbx��fh`_l�[ulv��d hlghr_gbyf��kms_kl\h\Z\rbf�^h�jZa\blby�yaudZgZr_]h�fure_gby��Kihkh[� \ujZ`_gby� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby�fu� gZa\Zeb� ihwlhfm� ZjoZbq_kdbfbeb�j_]j_kkb\guf�Hlkx^Z� \u� fh`_l_� k^_eZlv� aZdexq_gb_�� qlh� [eZ]h^Zjy� m]em[e_gghfm� bamq_gbx� jZ[hlukgh\b^_gby� gZf�� ^he`gh� [ulv�� m^Zklky� ^h[ulv� p_ggu_� k\_^_gby� h fZehba\_klguo� gZqZeZogZr_]h� bgl_ee_dlmZevgh]h� jZa\blby��Y gZ^_xkv�� qlh� lZd� hgh� b [m^_l�� gh� ^h� kbo� ihj� d wlhcjZ[hl_� _s_� gbdlh� g_� ijbklmiZe�� >hbklhjbq_kdh_� \j_fy�� d dhlhjhfm� gZk� \ha\jZsZ_l� jZ[hlZkgh\b^_gby��^\hydh]h�jh^Z��\h�i_j\uo�� wlh�bg^b\b^mZevgh_�^hbklhjbq_kdh_�\j_fy��^_lkl\h��k^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� ihkdhevdm� dZ`^uc� bg^b\b^mmf� \ k\h_f� ^_lkl\_� dZdbf�lh� h[jZahf� \djZlp_ih\lhjy_l� \k_� jZa\blb_� q_eh\_q_kdh]h� \b^Z�� lh� wlh� ^hbklhjbq_kdh_� \j_fy� lZd`_nbeh]_g_lbq_kdh_�� <hafh`gh�� gZf� m^Zklky� jZaebqblv�� dZdZy� qZklv� kdjuluo� ^mr_\guoijhp_kkh\� ijhbkoh^bl� ba� bg^b\b^mZevghc�� Z dZdZy� ²� ba� nbeh]_g_lbq_kdhc� wihob�� LZd�gZijbf_j��fg_�dZ`_lky��qlh�kbf\hebq_kdh_�hlghr_gb_��dhlhjhfm�gbdh]^Z�g_�mqbeky�hl^_evgucq_eh\_d��bf__l�hkgh\Zgb_�kqblZlvky�nbeh]_g_lbq_kdbf�gZke_^b_f�H^gZdh� wlh�g_� _^bgkl\_ggZy� ZjoZbq_kdZy� q_jlZ� kgh\b^_gby��<u� \k_�� \_jhylgh�� agZ_l_�bakh[kl\_ggh]h� hiulZ� h kljZgghc� Zfg_abb� ^_lkl\Z��Y bf_x� \ \b^m� lhl�nZdl�� qlh� i_j\u_� ]h^u`bagb�^h�iylh]h��r_klh]h�beb�\hkvfh]h�]h^Z�g_�hklZ\eyxl�\ iZfylb�ke_^h\��dZd�[he__�iha^gb_i_j_`b\Zgby�� IjZ\^Z�� \klj_qZxlky� hl^_evgu_� ex^b�� dhlhju_� fh]ml� iho\ZklZlvkyg_ij_ju\gufb� \hkihfbgZgbyfb� hl� jZgg_]h� ^_lkl\Z� ^h� gZklhys_]h� \j_f_gb�� gh� ^jm]b_�� kijh\ZeZfb�iZfylb�²�g_kjZ\g_ggh�[he__�qZklh_�y\e_gb_��Y iheZ]Zx��qlh�wlhl�nZdl�g_�\uau\Zem^b\e_gby�� dhlhjh]h� hg� aZkem`b\Z_l��< ^\Z� ]h^Z� j_[_ghd�fh`_l� ohjhrh� ]h\hjblv�� kdhjh� hgh[gZjm`b\Z_l�� qlh� jZa[bjZ_lky� \ keh`guo� ^mr_\guo� kblmZpbyo�� b kZf� \ukdZau\Z_l� lZdb_km`^_gby�� dhlhju_�fgh]b_� ]h^u� kimkly� _fm�i_j_kdZau\Zxl�� lZd� dZd� kZf�hg�bo� aZ[ue��B ijbwlhf� iZfylv� \ jZggb_� ]h^u� [he__� ijh^mdlb\gZ�� ihlhfm� qlh� aZ]jm`_gZ� f_gvr_�� q_f� \ [he__

Page 109: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

iha^gb_� ]h^u��G_l� lZd`_� gbdZdh]h� hkgh\Zgby� kqblZlv�nmgdpbx� iZfylb� hkh[_ggh� \ukhdhc� bljm^ghc�^_yl_evghklvx�^mrb��gZijhlb\��ohjhrmx�iZfylv�fh`gh�\klj_lblv�m ebp��klhysbo�gZhq_gv�gbadhc�klmi_gb�bgl_ee_dlmZevgh]h�jZa\blby�< dZq_kl\_�\lhjhc�kljZgghc�hkh[_gghklb��dhlhjZy�^hihegy_l�i_j\mx��ke_^m_l�\u^_eblv�lh�qlh� ba� imklhlu� \hkihfbgZgbc�� ho\Zlu\Zxs_c� i_j\u_� ^_lkdb_� ]h^u�� \kieu\Zxl� hl^_evgu_ohjhrh� khojZgb\rb_ky�� ih� [hevr_c� qZklb� gZ]ey^gu_� \hkihfbgZgby�� khojZgylv� dhlhju_� g_lgbdZdbo� hkgh\Zgbc��K fZl_jbZehf� \i_qZle_gbc�� \klj_qZxsboky� gZf� \ ihke_^mxs_c�`bagb�iZfylv�jZkihjy`Z_lky�lZdbf�h[jZahf��qlh�^_eZ_l�ba�g_]h�\u[hj��HgZ�khojZgy_l�qlh�lh�\Z`gh_��Zhl�g_\Z`gh]h�hldZau\Z_lky��K khojZgb\rbfbky�^_lkdbfb�\hkihfbgZgbyfb�^_eh�h[klhbl�bgZq_�Hgb� khhl\_lkl\mxl� g_� kZfuf� \Z`guf� i_j_`b\Zgbyf� ^_lkdbo� e_l�� b ^Z`_� g_� l_f�� dhlhju_^he`gu�[u�dZaZlvky�\Z`gufb�k lhqdb�aj_gby�j_[_gdZ��QZklh�hgb�gZklhevdh�[ZgZevgu�b kZfb�ihk_[_�g_agZqbl_evgu��qlh�fu�lhevdh�m^b\ey_fky��ihq_fm�bf_ggh�wlZ�^_lZev�ba[_`ZeZ�aZ[\_gby�< k\h_� \j_fy� y iulZeky� k ihfhsvx� ZgZebaZ� bkke_^h\Zlv� aZ]Z^dm� ^_lkdhc� Zfg_abb� bijhju\Zxsbo�__ hklZldh\�\hkihfbgZgbc�b ijbr_e�d \u\h^m��qlh�\k_�lZdb�\ \hkihfbgZgbyo�mj_[_gdZ� hklZ_lky� lhevdh� \Z`gh_��Ebrv� [eZ]h^Zjy� m`_� agZdhfuf� \Zf� ijhp_kkZf� k]ms_gby� bhkh[_ggh�kf_s_gby�wlh�\Z`gh_�\ \hkihfbgZgbb�ij_^klZ\ey_lky�^jm]bf��qlh�dZ`_lky�g_\Z`guf�Wlb� ^_lkdb_� \hkihfbgZgby� y gZa\Ze� ihwlhfm� ihdju\Zxsbfb� \hkihfbgZgbyfb�'HFNHUULQHUXQJHQ���iml_f�hkgh\Zl_evgh]h�ZgZebaZ�ba�gbo�fh`gh�ba\e_qv�\k_�aZ[ulh_�Ijb� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhf� e_q_gbb� kh\_jr_ggh� aZdhghf_jgh� \hagbdZ_l� aZ^ZqZ� aZihegblvijh[_e�\ ^_lkdbo�\hkihfbgZgbyo��b ihkdhevdm�e_q_gb_�\hh[s_�\ dZdhc�lh�kl_i_gb�m^Z_lky��bwlh� kemqZ_lky� \_kvfZ� qZklh�� fu� \ khklhygbb� hiylv� \hkklZgh\blv� kh^_j`Zgb_� l_o� aZ[uluo^_lkdbo� e_l�� Wlb� \i_qZle_gby� gbdh]^Z� ih�gZklhys_fm� g_� aZ[u\Zxlky�� hgb� [ueb� lhevdhg_^hklmigufb��kdjulufb��ijbgZ^e_`Zeb�d [_kkhagZl_evghfm��Gh�kZfh�ih�k_[_�kemqZ_lky�b lZd�qlh� hgb� \kieu\Zxl� ba� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� b ijhbkoh^bl� wlh� \ k\yab� kh� kgh\b^_gbyfb�HdZau\Z_lky�� qlh� `bagv� \h� kg_� mf__l� gZoh^blv� ^hklmi� d wlbf� kdjuluf� bgnZglbevgufi_j_`b\Zgbyf��< ebl_jZlmj_�bf_xlky�ij_djZkgu_� lhfm�ijbf_ju��b y� kZf�bf_e� \hafh`ghklvhim[ebdh\Zlv� khh[s_gb_�h ih^h[ghf� kemqZ_��H^gZ`^u� y \b^_e�\h� kg_� \ hij_^_e_gghc� k\yabh^gh�ebph��dhlhjh_��ih�\k_c�\_jhylghklb��hdZaZeh�fg_�mkem]m�b dhlhjh_�y ykgh�m\b^_e�i_j_^kh[hc��Wlh� [ue� h^gh]eZauc�fm`qbgZ�fZe_gvdh]h� jhklZ�� lhekluc�� k ]em[hdh� kb^ys_c� f_`^mie_qZfb� ]heh\hc�� Ba� h[s_]h� dhgl_dklZ� y aZdexqbe�� qlh� hg� [ue� \jZq�� D kqZklvx�� y fh]jZkkijhkblv�k\hx� lh]^Z�[u\rmx�_s_�\ `b\uo�fZlv��dZd�\u]ey^_e�\jZq� lhc�f_klghklb�� ]^_� yjh^beky�b dhlhjmx� y ihdbgme�\ ljb� ]h^Z��b magZe�hl�g__��qlh� hg�[ue� h^gh]eZauc�� dhjhldbc�lhekluc��k ]em[hdh�kb^ys_c�f_`^m�ie_qZfb�]heh\hc��ihemqbe�lZd`_�k\_^_gby�h lhf��ijb�dZdhfaZ[ulhf� fghc� g_kqZklghf� kemqZ_� hg� hdZaZe� fg_� ihfhsv�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� wlZ� \hafh`ghklvjZkihjy`Zlvky� aZ[uluf� fZl_jbZehf� ^_lkdbo� e_l� y\ey_lky� ^jm]hc� ZjoZbq_kdhc� q_jlhckgh\b^_gby�Lh�`_�kZfh_�hlghkblky�b d�^jm]hc�ba�l_o�aZ]Z^hd��k dhlhjufb�fu�m`_�^h�wlh]h�klhedgmebkv�<u�ihfgbl_�� k dZdbf�m^b\e_gb_f�\u�\k_�ijbgyeb�j_amevlZlu�gZr_]h�bkke_^h\Zgby��dhlhju_ihdZaZeb�� qlh� ih[m^bl_eyfb� kgh\b^_gbc� y\eyxlky� aeh[gh�wg_j]bqgu_� b [_am^_j`gu_k_dkmZevgu_�`_eZgby��k^_eZ\rb_�g_h[oh^bfufb�p_gamjm�b bkdZ`_gb_�kgh\b^_gbc��Dh]^Z�fulhedh\Zeb� lZdh_� kgh\b^_gb_� \b^_\r_fm� khg�� hg� \ emqr_f� kemqZ_� g_� hkiZjb\Ze� kZfh

Page 110: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

lhedh\Zgb_��gh�\k_�lZdb�ihklhyggh�aZ^Z\Ze�\hijhk��hldm^Z�m g_]h�[_j_lky�lZdh_�`_eZgb_��lZd�dZdhg� \hkijbgbfZ_l� _]h� dZd� qm`^h_� b hkhagZ_l� ijhlb\hiheh`gh_� _fm�� GZf� g_q_]h� kl_kgylvkymdZaZgbc�gZ�bo�ijhbkoh`^_gb_��Wlb�aeh[gu_�`_eZgby�ijhbkoh^yl�ba�ijhreh]h��qZklh�ba�hq_gvg_^Ze_dh]h��Fh`gh�ihdZaZlv��qlh�dh]^Z�lh�hgb�[ueb�ba\_klgu�b hkhagZggu��ohly�l_i_jv�wlh]hm`_� g_l��@_gsbgZ�� kgh\b^_gb_� dhlhjhc� hagZqZ_l�� qlh� hgZ� ohl_eZ� [u� \b^_lv� f_jl\hc� k\hx_^bgkl\_ggmx� ���e_lgxx� ^hqv�� ih^� gZrbf� jmdh\h^kl\hf� ijbagZ_l�� qlh� hgZ� dh]^Z�lh� ihqlb`_eZeZ�wlhc�kf_jlb��J_[_ghd�y\ey_lky�ieh^hf�g_kqZklgh]h��\kdhj_�jZklhj]gmlh]h�[jZdZ��Dh]^ZhgZ�ghkbeZ�^hqv�_s_�\h�qj_\_��h^gZ`^u�ihke_�[mjghc�kp_gu�k fm`_f�\ ijbiZ^d_�yjhklb�hgZgZqZeZ� dhehlblv� dmeZdZfb� ih� `b\hlm�� qlh[u� m[blv� \ g_f� j_[_gdZ�� Kdhevdh� _klv� fZl_j_c�dhlhju_�\ gZklhys__�\j_fy�g_`gh��fh`_l�[ulv��q_j_kqmj�g_`gh�ex[yl�k\hbo�^_l_c��dhlhju_�h^gZdh�� g_hohlgh� \klj_lbeb� bo� ihy\e_gb_� gZ� k\_l� b dh]^Z�lh� `_eZeb�� qlh[u� `bagv� \ gboij_djZlbeZkv��^Z�hgb�b i_j_\h^beb�wlh�`_eZgb_�\ jZaebqgu_��d kqZklvx��[_a\j_^gu_�^_ckl\by�LZdh_� iha^g__� dZ`ms__ky� aZ]Z^hqguf� `_eZgb_� kf_jlb� ex[bfhfm� ebpm� ijhbkoh^bl�� lZdbfh[jZahf��ba�[he__�jZgg_]h�hlghr_gby�d g_fm�Hl_p�� kgh\b^_gb_� dhlhjh]h� ih^l\_j`^Z_l� lhedh\Zgb_�� qlh� hg� `_eZ_l� kf_jlb� k\h_fmex[bfhfm�klZjr_fm�j_[_gdm��lh`_�\ugm`^_g�\kihfgblv�h lhf��qlh�dh]^Z�lh�wlh�`_eZgb_�[ueh_fm�g_�qm`^h��Dh]^Z� wlhl�j_[_ghd�[ue� _s_� ]jm^guf�feZ^_gp_f��g_^h\hevguc� k\hbf�[jZdhffm`�qZklh�^mfZe��qlh�_keb�[u�fZe_gvdh_�kms_kl\h��gbq_]h�^ey�g_]h�g_� agZqZs__��mf_jeh��hghiylv�[ue�[u�k\h[h^_g�b emqr_�bkihevah\Ze�[u�wlm�k\h[h^m��Fh`gh�h[gZjm`blv��qlh�[hevrh_qbkeh� ih^h[guo� qm\kl\� g_gZ\bklb� bf_xl� lZdh_� `_� ijhbkoh`^_gb_�� hgb� y\eyxlkygZihfbgZgbyfb�h lhf��qlh�hlghkbehkv�d ijhrehfm��dh]^Z�lh�[ueh�khagZl_evguf�b b]jZeh�k\hxjhev� \ ^mr_\ghc� `bagb�� Hlkx^Z� \u� aZohlbl_� k^_eZlv� \u\h^�� qlh� lZdbo� `_eZgbc� b lZdbokgh\b^_gbc�g_�^he`gh�[ulv��dh]^Z�ih^h[gu_�i_j_f_gu�hlghr_gby�d dZdhfm�lh�ebpm�g_�bf_ebf_klZ��dh]^Z�wlh�hlghr_gb_�[ueh�jh\guf�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ��Y ]hlh\�kh]eZkblvky�k wlbf�\Zrbf\u\h^hf��ohqm� lhevdh�ij_^mij_^blv�\Zk�h lhf��qlh[u�\u�bf_eb� \ \b^m�g_�[md\Zevguc� l_dklkgh\b^_gby��Z _]h�kfuke�ihke_�lhedh\Zgby��Fh`_l�kemqblvky��qlh�y\gh_�kgh\b^_gb_�h kf_jlbex[bfh]h� ebpZ� lhevdh� gZ^_eh� kljZrgmx� fZkdm�� Z hagZqZ_l� hgh� kh\_jr_ggh� ^jm]h_�� bebex[bfh_�ebph�\uklmiZ_l�h[fZgqb\uf�aZf_klbl_e_f�^jm]h]h�ebpZ�Gh� l_� `_� nZdlu� \uah\ml� m \Zk� ^jm]hc�� [he__� k_jv_aguc� \hijhk�� <u� kdZ`_l_�� _keb� wlh`_eZgb_�kf_jlb�^Z`_�bf_ehkv�dh]^Z�lh�b ih^l\_j`^Z_lky�\hkihfbgZgb_f��lh�wlh�\k_�lZdb�_s_g_� h[tykg_gb_�� wlh� `_eZgb_� \_^v� ^Z\gh� ij_h^he_gh�� k_]h^gy� hgh� fh`_l� kms_kl\h\Zlv� \[_kkhagZl_evghf� lhevdh�dZd�ebr_ggh_�Znn_dlh\�\hkihfbgZgb_��Z g_�dZd� kbevgh_�ijhy\e_gb_qm\kl\Z�� < ihevam� ihke_^g_]h� \_^v� gbq_]h� g_� ]h\hjbl�� AZq_f� `_� kgh\b^_gb_� \hh[s_� h g_fgZihfbgZ_l"�Wlhl� \hijhk� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� hijZ\^Zg�� ihiuldZ� hl\_lblv� gZ� g_]h� aZ\_eZ� [u� gZkkebrdhf�^Ze_dh�b aZklZ\beZ�[u�hij_^_eblv�k\hb�ihabpbb�ih�hlghr_gbx�d h^ghfm�ba�kZfuoagZqbl_evguo� fhf_glh\� l_hjbb� kgh\b^_gbc�� Gh� y \ugm`^_g� hklZ\Zlvky� \ jZfdZo� gZr_]hjZa[hjZ� b \ha^_j`b\Zlvky� hl� ebir_]h�� Kfbjbl_kv� k wlbf� \j_f_gguf� hldZahf�� ;m^_f^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky�nZdlbq_kdbf�mdZaZgb_f�gZ�lh��qlh�wlh�ij_h^he_ggh_�`_eZgb_��dZd�^hdZaZgh�y\ey_lky�ih[m^bl_e_f�kgh\b^_gby��b ijh^he`bf�bkke_^h\Zgb_�hlghkbl_evgh�lh]h��g_�\u\h^ylkyeb�b ^jm]b_�aeh[gu_�`_eZgby�ba�ijhreh]h�HklZgh\bfky� gZ� `_eZgbyo� mkljZg_gby�� dhlhju_� fu� \ [hevrbgkl\_� kemqZ_\� fh`_f

Page 111: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

h[tykgblv�g_h]jZgbq_gguf�w]hbafhf�\b^_\r_]h�khg��Fh`gh�^hdZaZlv��qlh�lZdh_�`_eZgb_�hq_gvqZklh�y\ey_lky�ijbqbghc�h[jZah\Zgby�kgh\b^_gby��<kydbc�jZa��dh]^Z�dlh�gb[m^v�\klZ_l�m gZk�gZimlb�²� Z dZd� qZklh� wlh� kemqZ_lky� \ keh`guo�`bag_gguo� hlghr_gbyo�²� kgh\b^_gb_� lml�`_]hlh\h�_]h�m[blv��[m^v�lh�hl_p��fZlv��dlh�lh�ba�[jZlv_\�b k_kl_j��iZjlg_j�ih�[jZdm�b l��i��Fum`_�^hklZlhqgh�m^b\eyebkv�wlhc�bkihjq_gghklb�q_eh\_q_kdhc�gZlmju�b��dhg_qgh��g_�kdehggu[_ah]h\hjhqgh� kqblZlv� ijZ\bevguf� wlhl� j_amevlZl� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc�� Gh� _keb� gZfmdZau\Zxl�gZ�lh��qlh�bklhdb�lZdbo�`_eZgbc�gZ^h�bkdZlv�\ ijhrehf��lh�\kdhj_�fu�hldju\Z_fi_jbh^�bg^b\b^mZevgh]h�ijhreh]h�� dh]^Z� lZdhc� w]hbaf�b lZdb_�`_eZgby�^Z`_�ijhlb\� kZfuo[ebadbo� kh\k_f� g_� m^b\bl_evgu��Bf_ggh� lZdh\� j_[_ghd� \ l_� i_j\u_� ]h^u�� dhlhju_� iha^g__hdmlu\Zxlky�Zfg_ab_c��hg�qZklh�h[gZjm`b\Z_l�wlb�j_adb_�ijhy\e_gby�w]hbafZ��ihklhyggh�^Z_lihqm\kl\h\Zlv� y\gmx�ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklv�d g_fm�beb�� \_jg__�� _]h�hklZldb��J_[_ghd�ij_`^_\k_]h�ex[bl�kZfh]h�k_[y�b lhevdh�iha^g__�mqblky�ex[blv�^jm]bo��`_jl\h\Zlv�qZklbp_c�k\h_]h�YjZ^b�^jm]bo��>Z`_�ebp��dhlhjuo�hg��dZ`_lky��ex[bl�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ��hg�ex[bl�lhevdh�ihlhfm�qlh�gm`^Z_lky�\ gbo��g_�fh`_l�[_a�gbo�h[hclbkv��lZd�qlh�hiylv�lZdb�ba�w]hbklbq_kdbo�fhlb\h\�Lhevdh� iha^g__� qm\kl\h� ex[\b� ^_eZ_lky� g_aZ\bkbfuf� hl� wlh]h� w]hbafZ�� Hg� nZdlbq_kdb� gZw]hbaf_�gZmqbeky�ex[\b�< wlhc� k\yab� [m^_l� ihmqbl_evgh� kjZ\gblv� mklZgh\dm� j_[_gdZ� d _]h� [jZlvyf� b k_kljZf� kmklZgh\dhc�d _]h�jh^bl_eyf��K\hbo�[jZlv_\�b k_kl_j�fZe_gvdbc�j_[_ghd�g_�\k_]^Z�ex[bl��qZklh`_�y\gh�g_�ex[bl��G_khfg_ggh��qlh�hg�g_gZ\b^bl�\ gbo�dhgdmj_glh\��b ba\_klgh��dZd�qZklh�wlZmklZgh\dZ�kms_kl\m_l�g_ij_ju\gh�\ l_q_gb_�^he]bo�e_l�\iehlv�^h�\j_f_gb�aj_ehklb��^Z`_�_s_^hevr_�� IjZ\^Z�� hgZ� ^hklZlhqgh� qZklh� kf_gy_lky� beb�� emqr_� kdZaZlv�� ihdju\Z_lky� [he__g_`ghc��gh�\jZ`^_[gZy��ih�\b^bfhfm�\iheg_�aZdhghf_jgh��ihy\ey_lky�jZgvr_��E_]q_�\k_]h�__gZ[ex^Zlv� m j_[_gdZ� hl� ���� ^h� �� b �� e_l�� _keb� ihy\ey_lky� gh\uc� [jZlbd� beb� k_klj_gdZ�� <[hevrbgkl\_�kemqZ_\�wlh�\klj_qZ_l�hq_gv�g_^jm`_ex[guc�ijb_f��<ujZ`_gby�\jh^_��©Y _]h�g_ex[ex�� imklv� Zbkl� hiylv� \havf_l� _]h� k kh[hcª� \_kvfZ� h[uqgu�� <ihke_^kl\bb� bkihevam_lkyex[Zy�\hafh`ghklv�mgbablv�ijbr_evpZ�b ^Z`_�ihiuldb�bkdZe_qblv�_]h��ijyfu_�ihdmr_gby�gZg_]h�g_�y\eyxlky�g_keuoZggufb�ijhbkr_kl\byfb��?keb�jZagbpZ�e_l�f_g__�agZqbl_evgZ��lh�ijbijh[m`^_gbb�[he__�bgl_gkb\ghc�^mr_\ghc�^_yl_evghklb�j_[_ghd�gZoh^bl�dhgdmj_glZ�m`_�gZf_kl_�b ijbkihkZ[eb\Z_lky�d g_fm��?keb�jZagbpZ�[hevr_�� lh�gh\uc�j_[_ghd� k kZfh]h�gZqZeZfh`_l�\ua\Zlv�hij_^_e_ggu_�kbfiZlbb�dZd�bgl_j_kguc�h[t_dl��dZd�`b\Zy�dmdeZ��Z ijb�jZagbp_\ \hk_fv� e_l� b [he__�� hkh[_ggh� m ^_\hq_d�� m`_� fh]ml� ijhy\blvky� aZ[hleb\u_�� fZl_jbgkdb_qm\kl\Z��Gh��hldjh\_ggh� ]h\hjy��_keb� aZ�kgh\b^_gb_f�hldju\Z_rv�`_eZgb_�kf_jlb�[jZlvyf�bk_kljZf�� g_� gm`gh� kqblZlv� _]h� g_h[tykgbfuf�� _]h� ijhlhlbi� [_a� ljm^Z� gZoh^brv� \ jZgg_f^_lkdhf�\hajZkl_��^h\hevgh�qZklh�²�lZd`_�b \�[he__�iha^gb_�]h^u�kh\f_klghc�`bagb�<_jhylgh�� g_l� gb� h^ghc� ^_lkdhc� [_a� h`_klhq_ggu_� dhgnebdlh\� f_`^m� __ h[blZl_eyfbFhlb\Zfb� y\eyxlky� [hjv[Z� aZ� ex[h\v� jh^bl_e_c�� aZ� h[eZ^Zgb_� h[sbfb� \_sZfb�� aZ�f_klh� \dhfgZl_��<jZ`^_[gu_� qm\kl\Z� gZijZ\eyxlky� dZd� ijhlb\� [he__� klZjrbo�� lZd� b ijhlb\� [he__feZ^rbo� [jZlv_\� b k_kl_j��DZ`_lky�� ;_jgZj^�Rhm� \ukdZaZe�fukev�� ©?keb� _klv� dlh�lh�� dh]hfheh^Zy�Zg]ebckdZy�^ZfZ�g_gZ\b^bl�[hevr_��q_f�k\hx�fZlv��lh�wlh�__ klZjrZy�k_kljZª��Gh�\wlhf�baj_q_gbb�_klv�g_qlh�m^b\bl_evgh_�^ey�gZk��G_gZ\bklv�[jZlv_\�b k_kl_j�b khi_jgbq_kl\hfu�fh`_f�\ djZcg_f�kemqZ_�ihgylv��gh�dZd�fh`_l�\hagbdgmlv�g_gZ\bklv�\ hlghr_gbyo�f_`^m^hq_jvx�b fZl_jvx��jh^bl_eyfb�b ^_lvfb"

Page 112: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Wlh� hlghr_gb_� b ^_lvfb� hp_gb\Z_lky� g_khfg_ggh� dZd� [he__� [eZ]hijbylgh_�� Hghkhhl\_lkl\m_l� lZd`_� gZrbf� h`b^Zgbyf�� fu� kqblZ_f� agZqbl_evgh� [he__� ij_^hkm^bl_evguf�_keb�g_�o\ZlZ_l�ex[\b�f_`^m�jh^bl_eyfb�b ^_lvfb��q_f�f_`^m�[jZlvyfb�b k_kljZfb��< i_j\hfkemqZ_� fu�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� kqblZ_f� k\yluf� lh�� qlh� \ ^jm]hf� y\ey_lky� h[uqguf�� H^gZdhih\k_^g_\gh_� gZ[ex^_gb_� ihdZau\Z_l�� dZd� qZklh� qm\kl\Z� f_`^m� jh^bl_eyfb� b \ajhkeufb^_lvfb� g_� khhl\_lkl\mxl� ihklZ\e_gghfm� h[s_kl\hf� b^_Zem�� kdhevdh� \ gbo� gZdhibehkv\jZ`^_[ghklb�� ]hlh\hc� ijhj\Zlvky�� _keb� [u� __� g_� k^_j`b\Zeh� g_fgh]h� ihqlbl_evghklb� bg_`guo�qm\kl\��Fhlb\u�wlh]h�h[s_ba\_klgu�b h[gZjm`b\Zxl�l_g^_gpbx�hl^_eblv�ebp�lh]h�`_iheZ��^hqv�hl�fZl_jb��hlpZ�hl�kugZ��>hqv�gZoh^bl�\ fZl_jb�kbem��dhlhjZy�h]jZgbqb\Z_l�__�\hexb gZ�dhlhjmx�\haeh`_gZ�fbkkby�ijh\_klb�\ `bagv�lj_[m_fuc�h[s_kl\hf�hldZa�hl�k_dkmZevghck\h[h^u�� \ hl^_evguo� kemqZyo� _s_� b dhgdmj_gldm�� dhlhjZy� ijhlb\blky� \ul_kg_gbx�� Lh� `_kZfh_�� gh� \ _s_� [he__� j_adhc� nhjf_� ih\lhjy_lky� f_`^m� hlphf� b kughf�� >ey� kugZ� \ hlp_\hiehsZ_lky� ex[h_� gZkbevkl\_ggh_� khpbZevgh_� ijbgm`^_gb_�� hl_p� aZdju\Z_l� _fm� ^hklmi� dijhy\e_gbx� kh[kl\_gghc� \heb�� d ij_`^_\j_f_gghfm� k_dkmZevghfm� gZkeZ`^_gbx� b dihevah\Zgbx�h[s_k_f_cguf�^hklhygb_f�lZf��]^_�hgh�bf__lky��M ij_klhehgZke_^gbdZ�`_eZgb_kf_jlb�hlpZ�\ujZklZ_l�^h�jZaf_jh\�� ]jZgbqZsbo�k ljZ]_^b_c��F_g__�hiZkguf�ij_^klZ\ey_lkyhlghr_gb_� f_`^m� hlphf� b ^hq_jvx�� fZl_jvx� b kughf��Ihke_^g__� ^Z_l� qbkl_crb_� h[jZapug_gZjmr_gghc�gbdZdbfb�w]hbklbq_kdbfb�khh[jZ`_gbyfb�g_baf_gghc�g_`ghklb���>ey� q_]h� y ]h\hjx� h[� wlbo� [ZgZevguo� b h[s_ba\_klguo� \_sZo"� Ihlhfm� qlh� bf__lkyhq_\b^gh_� klj_fe_gb_� hljbpZlv� bo� agZq_gb_� \ `bagb� b \u^Z\Zlv� khpbZevgh� h[mkeh\e_ggucb^_Ze�aZ�hkms_kl\e_gguc�]hjZa^h�qZs_��q_f�hg�\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�hkms_kl\ey_lky��Gh�emqr_�_keb�ijZ\^m�kdZ`_l�ikboheh]��q_f�pbgbd��<h�\kydhf�kemqZ_��wlh�hljbpZgb_�hlghkblky�lhevdh�dj_Zevghc� `bagb�� Gh� ebl_jZlmj_� b ^jZfZlbq_kdhc� ihwabb� ij_^hklZ\ey_lky� k\h[h^ghihevah\Zlvky�fhlb\Zfb��\ul_dZxsbfb�ba�gZjmr_gby�wlh]h�b^_ZeZ�BlZd�� gZf� g_� ke_^m_l� m^b\eylvky� lhfm�� qlh� m [hevrh]h� qbkeZ� ex^_c� kgh\b^_gb_h[gZjm`b\Z_l�`_eZgb_�mkljZgblv�jh^bl_e_c��Z bf_ggh�lh]h�ba�gbo��dlh�h^gh]h�iheZ�k \b^_\rbfkhg��Kf__f�ij_^iheh`blv��qlh�wlh�`_eZgb_�bf__lky�\ khklhygbb�[h^jkl\h\Zgby�b ^Z`_�bgh]^ZhkhagZ_lky��_keb�hgh�fh`_l� aZfZkdbjh\Zlvky�ih^�^jm]hc�fhlb\��gZijbf_j��ih^�khkljZ^Zgb_�dg_gm`guf� fmq_gbyf� hlpZ�� dZd� wlh� [ueh� m \b^_\r_]h� khg� \ ijbf_j_� ��� J_^dh� h^gZ� lhevdh\jZ`^_[ghklv� hij_^_ey_l� hlghr_gb_�� ]hjZa^h� qZs_� aZ� g_c� \uklmiZxl� [he__� g_`gu_ih[m`^_gby��dhlhjufb�hgZ�ih^Z\ey_lky�b ^he`gZ�\u`b^Zlv�^h�l_o�ihj��ihdZ�kgh\b^_gb_�__ dZd[u� bahebjm_l�� Lh�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� k ihfhsvx� lZdhc� baheypbb� bah[jZ`Z_l� ij_m\_ebq_gguf�aZl_f� hiylv� mf_gvrZ_lky�� dh]^Z� ihke_� gZr_]h� lhedh\Zgby� \dexqZ_lky� \ h[smx� `bag_ggmxk\yav� �6DFKV��������������Gh�fu�gZoh^bf�wlh�`_eZgb_�kgh\b^_gby�^Z`_�lZf��]^_�hgh�g_�bf__lk\yab� k `bagvx�b ]^_� \ajhkeuc�gbdh]^Z�g_�ijbagZeky�[u� \ g_f� \ [h^jkl\mxs_f� khklhygbb�IjbqbgZ�wlh]h�\ lhf��qlh�kZfuc�]em[hdbc�b ihklhygguc�fhlb\�hlqm`^_gby��hkh[_ggh�f_`^mebpZfb�h^gh]h�iheZ��ihy\ey_lky�m`_�\ jZgg_f�^_lkdhf�\hajZkl_�Y bf_x� \ \b^m� khi_jgbq_kl\h� \ ex[\b� y\gh� iheh\h]h� oZjZdl_jZ�� Kug� m`_� fZe_gvdbfj_[_gdhf� gZqbgZ_l� bkiulu\Zlv� hkh[mx� g_`ghklv� d fZl_jb�� dhlhjmx� hg� kqblZ_l� k\h_ckh[kl\_gghklvx�� Z hlpZ� \hkijbgbfZ_l� dZd� dhgdmj_glZ�� dhlhjuc� hkiZjb\Z_l� m g_]h� wlhbkdexqbl_evgh_�h[eZ^Zgb_��b lhqgh�lZd�`_�fZe_gvdZy�^hqv�\b^bl�\ fZl_jb�ebph��f_rZxs__�__

Page 113: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_`ghfm�hlghr_gbx�d hlpm�b aZgbfZxs__�f_klh��dhlhjh_�hgZ�kZfZ�k m^h\hevkl\b_f�[u�aZgyeZ�Ba�gZ[ex^_gbc�ke_^m_l�magZlv��^h�dZdh]h�jZgg_]h�\hajZklZ�^hoh^bl�wlZ�mklZgh\dZ��dhlhjmx�fugZau\Z_f�W^bih\uf�dhfie_dkhf��ihlhfm�qlh�\ e_]_g^_�h[�W^bi_�j_Zebamxlky� k kh\_jr_gghg_agZqbl_evguf�hkeZ[e_gb_f�h[Z�djZcgbo�`_eZgby��\ul_dZxsb_�ba�iheh`_gby�kugZ�²�m[blvhlpZ�b \aylv�\ `_gu�fZlv��Y g_�ohqm�ml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�W^bih\�dhfie_dk�bkq_jiu\Z_l�hlghr_gb_^_l_c� d jh^bl_eyf�� hgh� fh`_l� [ulv� gZfgh]h� keh`g__�� W^bih\� dhfie_dk� fh`_l� [ulv� lZd`_[he__�beb�f_g__�kbevgh�\ujZ`_g��fh`_l�kZf�ij_l_ji_lv�ijhlb\hiheh`gh_�\ujZ`_gb_��gh�hgihklhygguc� b hq_gv� agZqbl_evguc�nZdlhj� ^mr_\ghc�`bagb� j_[_gdZ�� b \hagbdZ_l� hiZkghklvkdhj__�g_^hhp_gblv�_]h�\ebygb_�b h[mkeh\e_ggh_�bf�jZa\blb_��q_f�i_j_hp_gblv�_]h��<h�\kydhfkemqZ_��^_lb�qZklh� j_Z]bjmxl� w^bih\hc� mklZgh\dhc�iZ� qm\kl\h� jh^bl_e_c�� dhlhju_�^h\hevghqZklh� jmdh\h^kl\mxlky� iheh\uf� jZaebqb_f� \ k\h_f� ex[h\ghf� \u[hj_�� lZd� qlh� hl_pij_^ihqblZ_l�^hqv��fZlv�²�kugZ��Z \�kemqZ_�hoeZ`^_gby�\ [jZd_�aZf_gyxl�bfb�h[_kp_g_gguch[t_dl�ex[\b�G_evay�kdZaZlv��qlh[u�fbj�[ue�hq_gv�[eZ]h^Zj_g�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhfm�bkke_^h\Zgbx� aZhldjulb_� W^bih\Z� dhfie_dkZ��GZh[hjhl�� hgh� \ua\Zeh� kZfuc� yjhklguc� ijhl_kl� \ajhkeuo�� bebpZ��dhlhju_�mimklbeb�\hafh`ghklv�ijbgylv� mqZklb_� \ hljbpZgbb� wlh]h�ij_^hkm^bl_evgh]hbeb� aZij_lgh]h�qm\kl\_ggh]h�hlghr_gby��bkijZ\beb�\ihke_^kl\bb�k\hx�hrb[dm�ihkj_^kl\hfikj_lhedh\Zgbc��ebrb\�dhfie_dk�_]h�agZq_gby��Ih�fh_fm�l\_j^hfm�m[_`^_gbx��a^_kv�g_q_]hhljbpZlv�b g_q_]h�ijbmdjZrb\Zlv��Ke_^m_l� ijbfbjblvky� k nZdlhf�� dhlhjuc� ^Z`_� ]j_q_kdbfkdZaZgb_f� ijbagZ_lky� dZd� g_mfhebfuc� jhd��Bgl_j_kgh�� qlh� bkdexq_gguc� ba�`bagb� W^bih\dhfie_dk� ij_^hklZ\ey_lky� ihwabb�� dZd� [u� i_j_^Z_lky� \ __� ihegh_� jZkihjy`_gb_��H�� JZgd� \lsZl_evgh� ijh\_^_gghf� bkke_^h\Zgbb� �����\�� ihdZaZe�� qlh� bf_ggh� W^bih\� dhfie_dk� ^Ze^jZfZlbq_kdhc� ihwabb� [h]Zlu_� fhlb\u� \ [_kdhg_qguo� baf_g_gguo�� kfy]q_gguo� baZfZkdbjh\Zgguo� nhjfZo�� l�� _�� \ lZdbo� bkdZ`_gbyo�� \ dZdbo� fu� magZ_f� j_amevlZl� ^_ckl\byp_gamju�� Wlhl� W^bih\� dhfie_dk� fu� fh`_f�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� ijbibkZlv� lZd`_� l_f� ebpZf�dhlhjuf�ihkqZkleb\behkv�ba[_`Zlv�\ ^Zevg_cr_c�`bagb�dhgnebdlh\�k jh^bl_eyfb��b \�l_kghck\yab�k gbf�fu�gZoh^bf�lh��qlh�gZau\Z_f�dhfie_dkhf�dZkljZpbb��j_Zdpbx�gZ�ijbibku\Z_fh_hlpm�k_dkmZevgh_�aZim]b\Zgb_�beb�ih^Z\e_gb_�jZgg_c�^_lkdhc�k_dkmZevghc�^_yl_evghklb�KkueZykv�gZ� m`_� ijh\_^_ggu_� bkke_^h\Zgby� ^_lkdhc� ^mr_\ghc�`bagb��fu� kf__f� lZd`_gZ^_ylvky��qlh�ih^h[guf�`_�h[jZahf�[m^_l�gZc^_gh�h[tykg_gb_�ijhbkoh`^_gby�^jm]hc�qZklbaZij_lguo� `_eZgbc� kgh\b^_gbc�� qj_af_jguo� k_dkmZevguo� qm\kl\�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� m gZk\hagbdZ_l�klj_fe_gb_�bamqZlv�jZa\blb_�^_lkdhc�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb��b fu�magZ_f�ijb�wlhf�bafgh]hqbke_gguo� bklhqgbdh\� ke_^mxs__�� g_^himklbfhc� hrb[dhc� y\ey_lky�� ij_`^_� \k_]h�hljbpZgb_� m j_[_gdZ� k_dkmZevghc� `bagb� b ij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh� k_dkmZevghklv� gZqbgZ_lkylhevdh�dh�\j_f_gb�iheh\h]h�khaj_\Zgby�\f_kl_�k khaj_\Zgb_f�]_gblZebc��GZijhlb\��m j_[_gdZ�kkZfh]h� gZqZeZ� bf__lky� [h]ZlZy� k_dkmZevgZy� `bagv�� dhlhjZy� \h� fgh]hf� hlebqZ_lky� hl� lhc�dhlhjmx� iha^g__� ijbgylh� kqblZlv� ghjfZevghc�� Lh�� qlh� \ `bagb� \ajhkeuo� fu� gZau\Z_f©ba\jZs_gb_fª�� hlebqZ_lky� hl� ghjfu� ke_^mxsbfb� k\hckl\Zfb�� \h�i_j\uo�� \uoh^hf� aZij_^_eu� \b^Z� �ijhiZklv� f_`^m� `b\hlguf� b q_eh\_dhf��� \h�\lhjuo�� \uoh^hf� aZ� ]jZgbpuhl\jZs_gby�� \�lj_lvbo�� \uoh^hf� aZ� ij_^_eu� bgp_klZ� �aZij_l� k_dkmZevgh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby� k[ebadbfb�ih�djh\b�jh^kl\_ggbdZfb���\�q_l\_jluo��]hfhk_dkmZevgufb�hlghr_gbyfb�b��\�iyluo�i_j_g_k_gb_f�nmgdpbc� ]_gblZebc�gZ� ^jm]b_� hj]Zgu�b mqZkldb� l_eZ��<k_� wlb� h]jZgbq_gby� g_

Page 114: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kms_kl\mxl� k kZfh]h� gZqZeZ�� Z kha^Zxlky� ebrv� ihkl_i_ggh� \ oh^_� jZa\blby� b \hkiblZgby�FZe_gvdbc�j_[_ghd�k\h[h^_g�hl�gbo��Hg�_s_�g_�agZ_l�kljZrghc�ijhiZklb�f_`^m�q_eh\_dhf�b`b\hlguf��\ukhdhf_jb_��hlebqZxs__�q_eh\_dZ�hl�`b\hlgh]h��\hagbdZ_l�m g_]h�ebrv�iha^g__�KgZqZeZ�m g_]h�g_l� hl\jZs_gby� d wdkdj_f_glZf�� hg� magZ_l� h g_f�ihkl_i_ggh�ih^� ^Z\e_gb_f\hkiblZgby�� hg� g_� ijb^Z_l� hkh[h]h� agZq_gby� jZaebqbx� iheh\�� kdhj__�� ij_^iheZ]Z_l� m h[hboh^bgZdh\mx� nhjfm� ]_gblZebc�� hg� gZijZ\ey_l� k\hb� i_j\u_� k_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gby� b k\h_ex[hiulkl\h� gZ� kZfuo� [ebadbo� b ih� jZaguf� ijbqbgZf� kZfuo� ex[bfuo� ebp� ²� jh^bl_e_c�[jZlv_\�b k_kl_j��moZ`b\Zxsbo�aZ�gbf�ex^_c�b��gZdhg_p��m g_]h�h[gZjm`b\Z_lky�lh��qlh�\gh\vijhju\Z_lky�iha`_�ijb�gZb[hevr_c�kbe_�ex[h\gh]h�hlghr_gby��Z bf_ggh�lh��qlh�hg�ihemqZ_lm^h\hevkl\b_�g_�lhevdh�hl�iheh\uo�hj]Zgh\��gh�qlh�fgh]b_�^jm]b_�mqZkldb�l_eZ�h[eZ^Zxl�lhc`_� qm\kl\bl_evghklvx�� ^hklZ\eyxl� ZgZeh]bqgu_� hsms_gby� gZkeZ`^_gby� b fh]ml�� lZdbfh[jZahf�� b]jZlv� jhev� ]_gblZebc�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� j_[_ghd� fh`_l� [ulv� gZa\Zg� ©ihebfhjnghba\jZs_ggufª��b _keb�m g_]h�ijhy\eyxlky�ebrv�ke_^u�\k_o�wlbo�qm\kl\��lh�wlh�ijhbkoh^bl��kh^ghc�klhjhgu��ba�aZ�g_agZqbl_evghc�bo�bgl_gkb\ghklb�ih�kjZ\g_gbx�k [he__�iha^gbfb�]h^Zfb`bagb�� k ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� ba�aZ� lh]h�� qlh� \hkiblZgb_� kjZam� `_� wg_j]bqgh� ih^Z\ey_l� \k_k_dkmZevgu_� ijhy\e_gby� j_[_gdZ�� Wlh� ih^Z\e_gb_� i_j_oh^bl�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� \ l_hjbx�� dh]^Z\ajhkeu_� klZjZxlky� g_� aZf_qZlv� dZdmx�lh� qZklv� ^_lkdbo� k_dkmZevguo� ijhy\e_gbc� b ebrblvk_dkmZevghc� ijbjh^u� iml_f� i_j_lhedh\Zgby� ^jm]mx� __ qZklv�� ihdZ� hgb� aZl_f� g_� gZqbgZxlhljbpZlv�\k_��QZklh�wlh�l_�`_�ex^b��dhlhju_�lhevdh�\ ^_lkdhc�g_]h^mxl�ba�aZ�\k_o�k_dkmZevguo^mjguo�ijb\uq_d�^_l_c��Z aZl_f�aZ�ibkvf_gguf�klhehf�aZsbsZxl�k_dkmZevgmx�qbklhlm�l_o�`_^_l_c��LZf��]^_�^_lb�ij_^hklZ\e_gu�kZfbf�k_[_�beb�[ueb�kh[eZag_gu��hgb�qZklh�h[gZjm`b\Zxl^h\hevgh�agZqbl_evgu_�ba\jZs_gby��JZamf__lky��\ajhkeu_�ijZ\u��hlghkykv�d wlhfm�g_k_jv_aghdZd�d ©j_[yq_kl\mª�b ©aZ[Z\Zfª��ihlhfm�qlh�j_[_gdZ�g_evay�km^blv�gb km^hf�gjZ\kl\_gghklb��gbih� aZdhgm�� gh� \_^v� wlb� \_sb� kms_kl\mxl�� hgb� bf_xl� agZq_gb_� dZd� ijbagZdb� \jh`^_gghcdhgklblmpbb�� Z lZd`_� dZd� [eZ]hijbylkl\mxsb_� ijbqbgu� ^Zevg_cr_]h� jZa\blby�� hgb� fgh]h_gZf�hldju\Zxl�\ ^_lkdhc�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb��Z \f_kl_�k l_f�b \�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�q_eh\_dZ\hh[s_�� BlZd�� dh]^Z� aZ� k\hbfb� bkdZ`_ggufb� kgh\b^_gbyfb� fu� hiylv� gZoh^bf� \k_� wlbba\jZs_ggu_�`_eZgby��lh�wlh�lhevdh�hagZqZ_l��qlh�kgh\b^_gb_�b \�wlhc�h[eZklb�k^_eZeh�rZ]gZaZ^�d bgnZglbevghfm�khklhygbx�Kj_^b�wlbo�aZij_lguo�`_eZgbc�hkh[h]h�mihfbgZgby�aZkem`b\Zxl�_s_�bgp_klmhagu_��l��_�gZijZ\e_ggu_�gZ�iheh\hc�Zdl�k jh^bl_eyfb��[jZlvyfb�b k_kljZfb��<u�agZ_l_��dZdh_�hl\jZs_gb_qm\kl\m_l�beb��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��ijhy\ey_l�q_eh\_q_kdh_�h[s_kl\h�ijhlb\�iheh\uo�hlghr_gbclZdh]h�jh^Z�b dZdh_�\gbfZgb_�h[jZsZ_lky�gZ�aZij_lu��gZijZ\e_ggu_�ijhlb\�wlh]h��IjbeZ]ZebkvkZfu_�g_\_jhylgu_�mkbeby��qlh[u�h[tykgblv�wlhl�kljZo�i_j_^�bgp_klhf��H^gb�ij_^iheZ]Zeb�qlh�wlh�khh[jZ`_gby�memqr_gby�\b^Z�\ ijbjh^_��ikbobq_kdb�ij_^klZ\e_ggu_�\ wlhf� aZij_l_�ihlhfm�qlh�bgpmol�mom^rbe�[u�oZjZdl_jgu_�ijbagZdb�jZk��^jm]b_�ml\_j`^Zeb��qlh�[eZ]h^Zjykh\f_klghc�`bagb�k jZgg_]h�^_lkl\Z�k_dkmZevgh_�\h`^_e_gb_�d mdZaZgguf�ebpZf�hkeZ[_\Z_l��<h[hbo�kemqZyo��\ijhq_f��ba[_]Zgb_�bgp_klZ�[ueh�[u�h[_ki_q_gh�Z\lhfZlbq_kdb��b g_ihgylgh�aZq_f� gm`gu� kljh]b_� aZij_lu�� dhlhju_� k\b^_l_evkl\mxl� kdhj__� h gZebqbb� kbevgh]h\h`^_e_gby��IkbohZgZeblbq_kdb_�bkke_^h\Zgby�g_^\mkfuke_ggh�ihdZaZeb��qlh�bgp_klmhaguc\u[hj�h[t_dlZ�ex[\b�y\ey_lky��gZijhlb\��i_j\uf�b h[uqguf��b lhevdh�\ihke_^kl\bb�ijhlb\g_]h� \hagbdZ_l� khijhlb\e_gb_�� ijhbkoh`^_gb_� dhlhjh]h� ba� bg^b\b^mZevghc� ikboheh]bb

Page 115: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ke_^m_l��\b^bfh��hljbpZlv�KhihklZ\bf� l_i_jv�� qlh� `_� gZf� ^Zeh� m]em[e_gb_� \ bamq_gb_� ^_lkdhc� ikboheh]bb� ^eyihgbfZgby�kgh\b^_gby��Fu�h[gZjm`beb�g_�lhevdh�lh��qlh�^ey�kgh\b^_gby�^hklmi_g�fZl_jbZeaZ[uluo�^_lkdbo�i_j_`b\Zgbc��ih�m\b^_eb�lZd`_��qlh�^mr_\gZy�`bagv�^_l_c�kh�\k_fb�k\hbfbhkh[_gghklyfb�� w]hbafhf�� bgp_klmhaguf� \u[hjhf� h[t_dlZ� ex[\b� b l�� ^�� _s_� ijh^he`Z_lkms_kl\h\Zlv� ^ey� kgh\b^_gby�� l�� _�� \ [_kkhagZl_evghf�� b qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� dZ`^mx� ghqv\ha\jZsZ_l� gZk� gZ� wlm� bgnZglbevgmx� klmi_gv�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� ih^l\_j`^Z_lky�� qlh[_kkhagZl_evgh_�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��_klv�bgnZglbevgh_��KljZggh�g_ijbylgh_�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�\q_eh\_d_�lZd�fgh]h� aeh]h��gZqbgZ_l�hkeZ[_\Zlv��Wlh�kljZrgh� aeh_�²�ijhklh�i_j\hgZqZevgh_�ijbfblb\gh_� bgnZglbevgh_� \ ^mr_\ghc� `bagb�� hldjulh_� ijhy\e_gb_� dhlhjh]h� fu� fh`_fgZclb�m j_[_gdZ��gh�q_]h�fu�hlqZklb�g_� aZf_qZ_f�ba�aZ�_]h�g_agZqbl_evghklb��ihlhfm�qlh�g_lj_[m_f�hl�j_[_gdZ�wlbq_kdh]h�kh\_jr_gkl\Z��Kgh\b^_gb_��kimklb\rbkv�gZ�wlm�klmi_gv��kha^Z_l\i_qZle_gb_��[m^lh�hgh�jZkdju\Z_l�\ gZk�wlh�aeh_��Gh�wlh�\k_]h�ebrv�aZ[em`^_gb_��dhlhjh_�gZklZd�im]Zeh��Fu�g_�lZd�m`�aeu��dZd�fh`gh�[ueh�ij_^iheh`blv�ihke_�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc�?keb�wlb�aeu_�ijhy\e_gby�\ kgh\b^_gbyo�\k_]h�ebrv�bgnZglbebafu��\ha\jZsZxsb_�gZk�dbklhdZf�gZr_]h�wlbq_kdh]h�jZa\blby��^_eZxsb_�gZk�\h�kg_�hiylv�ijhklh�^_lvfb�ih�fukeyf�bqm\kl\Zf�� lh� [eZ]hjZamfgh� [ueh� [u� g_� klu^blvky� wlbo� aeuo� kgh\b^_gbc�� Gh� [eZ]hjZamfb_y\ey_lky�lhevdh�qZklvx�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��djhf_�lh]h�\ ^mr_�ijhbkoh^bl�_s_�fgh]h�lZdh]h��qlhg_�jZamfgh��b ihwlhfm�kemqZ_lky�lZd��qlh�fu�g_[eZ]hjZamfgh�klu^bfky�lZdbo�kgh\b^_gbc��Fuih^\_j]Z_f�bo�p_gamj_��klu^bfky�b k_j^bfky��_keb�\ bkdexqbl_evguo�kemqZyo�h^ghfm�ba�wlbo`_eZgbc�m^Z_lky�ijhgbdgmlv�\ khagZgb_�\ gZklhevdh�g_bkdZ`_gghc�nhjf_��qlh�gZf�ijboh^blky_]h� magZlv�� ijZ\^Z�� bkdZ`_gguo� kgh\b^_gbc� fu� lhqgh� lZd� `_� klu^bfky�� dZd� [m^lh� fu� boihgbfZ_f�� <kihfgbl_� ohly� [u� g_]h^h\Zgb_� lhc� keZ\ghc� klZjhc� ^Zfu� ih� ih\h^m� __g_bklhedh\Zggh]h� kgh\b^_gby� h ©ex[h\guo� mkem]Zoª�� LZd� qlh� ijh[e_fZ� _s_� g_� j_r_gZ�� b\hafh`gh��qlh�ijb�^Zevg_cr_f�bamq_gbb�aeh]h�\ kgh\b^_gbb�fu�ijb^_f�d ^jm]hfm�km`^_gbx�bd ^jm]hc�hp_gd_�q_eh\_q_kdhc�ijbjh^u�< j_amevlZl_�bkke_^h\Zgby�fu�ijboh^bf�d ^\mf�iheh`_gbyf��dhlhju_��h^gZdh��\_^ml� aZkh[hc� ebrv� gh\u_� aZ]Z^db�� gh\u_� khfg_gby�� <h�i_j\uo�� j_]j_kkby� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� g_lhevdh� nhjfZevgZ�� gh� b fZl_jbZevgZ�� HgZ� g_� lhevdh� i_j_\h^bl� \ ijbfblb\gmx� nhjfm\ujZ`_gby� gZrb� fukeb�� gh� b \gh\v� h`b\ey_l� \k_� oZjZdl_jgu_� q_jlu� gZr_c� ijbfblb\ghc^mr_\ghc�`bagb��ij_`g__�\k_fh]ms_kl\h�Y��i_j\hgZqZevguc�ijhy\e_gby�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�^Z`_�^j_\g__�^hklhygb_�gZr_]h�bgl_ee_dlZ��_keb�kbf\hebq_kdh_�hlghr_gb_�fh`gh�ijbagZlv�aZlZdh\h_�� B \h�\lhjuo�� \k_� wlh� ^Z\g__� bgnZglbevgh_�� qlh� dh]^Z�lh� kZfh^_j`Z\gh]hkih^kl\h\Zeh��fu�^he`gu�l_i_jv�ijbqbkeblv�d [_kkhagZl_evghfm��ij_^klZ\e_gby�h dhlhjhfl_i_jv� f_gyxlky� b jZkrbjyxlky�� ;_kkhagZl_evgh_� ²� wlh� g_� lhevdh� gZa\Zgb_� \j_f_gghkdjulh]h�� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� ²� wlh� hkh[Zy� ^mr_\gZy� h[eZklv� kh� k\hbfb� kh[kl\_ggufb`_eZgbyfb��kh[kl\_gguf�kihkh[hf�\ujZ`_gby�b k\hckl\_ggufb�_fm�^mr_\gufb�f_oZgbafZfb�dhlhju_�bgZq_�g_�^_ckl\mxl��Gh�kdjulu_�fukeb��h dhlhjuo�fu�magZeb�[eZ]h^Zjy�lhedh\Zgbxkgh\b^_gbc�� \k_�lZdb� g_� ba� wlhc� h[eZklb�� hgb�� kdhj__�� lZdb_�� dZdbfb� fh]eb� [u� [ulv� b \khklhygbb�[h^jkl\h\Zgby��B \k_�`_� hgb� [_kkhagZl_evgu�� dZd� jZaj_rZ_lky� wlh�ijhlb\hj_qb_"Fu�gZqbgZ_f�ih^haj_\Zlv��qlh�a^_kv�ke_^m_l�ijhba\_klb�ih^jZa^_e_gb_��G_qlh��qlh�ijhbkoh^bl

Page 116: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ba� gZr_c� khagZl_evghc�`bagb� b bf__l� __ ijbagZdb�²�fu� gZau\Z_f� wlh� hklZldZfb� ^g_\guo\i_qZle_gbc�²� kh_^bgy_lky� ^ey� h[jZah\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby� k q_f�lh� ^jm]bf� ba� h[eZklb[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��F_`^m�wlbfb�^\mfy�qZklyfb�b jZa\_jlu\Z_lky�jZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby��<ebygb_hklZldh\�^g_\guo�\i_qZle_gbc�[eZ]h^Zjy�ijbkh_^bgyxs_fmky�[_kkhagZl_evghfm�y\ey_lky��ih�\b^bfhfm�� mkeh\b_f� j_]j_kkbb�� < wlhf� aZdexqZ_lky� kZfh_� ]em[hdh_� ihgbfZgb_� kmsghklbkgh\b^_gby��dhlhjh]h�fu�fh`_f�^hklbqv��ij_`^_�q_f�bamqbf�^jm]b_�h[eZklb�^mr_\ghc�`bagb�Gh�kdhjh�gZklZg_l�\j_fy�^Zlv�[_kkhagZl_evghfm�oZjZdl_jm�kdjuluo�fuke_c�kgh\b^_gby�^jm]h_gZa\Zgb_�k p_evx�hlebqblv�bo�hl�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�ba�h[eZklb�bgnZglbevgh]h�Fu�� _kl_kl\_ggh�� fh`_f� lZd`_� ihklZ\blv� \hijhk�� qlh� \ugm`^Z_l� ikbobq_kdmx^_yl_evghklv�\h�\j_fy�kgZ�gZ�lZdmx�j_]j_kkbx"�Ihq_fm�hgZ�g_�kijZ\ey_lky�k gZjmrZxsbfbkhg� ikbobq_kdbfb� jZa^jZ`_gbyfb� [_a� ihke_^g_c"� B _keb� ba�aZ� p_gamju� kgh\b^_gby� hgZ\ugm`^_gZ�ihevah\Zlvky�^ey�fZkdbjh\db�ZjoZbqghc��l_i_jv�g_ihgylghc�nhjfhc�\ujZ`_gby��lh^ey�q_]h�_c�kem`bl�\hajh`^_gb_�^Z\gbo��l_i_jv�ij_h^he_gguo�^mr_\guo�^\b`_gbc��`_eZgbc�boZjZdxjguo� q_jl�� l�� _�� fZl_jbZevgZy� j_]j_kkby�� dhlhjZy� ijbkh_^bgy_lky� d nhjfZevghc"?^bgkl\_gguc� m^h\e_l\hjyxsbc� gZk� hl\_l� aZdexqZeky� [u� \ lhf�� qlh� lhevdh� lZdbf� h[jZahffh`_l�h[jZah\Zlvky�kgh\b^_gb_��qlh�bgZq_�g_\hafh`gh�^bgZfbq_kdb�kgylv�jZa^jZ`_gb_�\h�kg_�Gh�ihdZ�fu�g_�\ijZ\_�^Z\Zlv�lZdhc�hl\_l�Q?LUJG:>P:L:Y�E?DPBYBkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby�M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��G_�klhbl�eb�fg_�_s_�jZa�ihdZaZlv�\Zf�ijhc^_gguc�gZfb�imlv"DZd� fu�� ijbf_gyy� gZrm� l_ogbdm�� gZlhedgmebkv� gZ� bkdZ`_gb_� kgh\b^_gby�� jZa^mfu\ZebkgZqZeZ�� dZd� [u� _]h� h[hclb�� b ihemqbeb� \Z`g_crb_� k\_^_gby� h kmsghklb� kgh\b^_gby� babgnZglbevguo� kgh\b^_gbc"� DZd� fu� aZl_f�� \hhjm`_ggu_� j_amevlZlZfb� wlh]h� bkke_^h\Zgby�aZgyebkv�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�bkdZ`_gb_f�kgh\b^_gby�b��gZ^_xkv��rZ]�aZ�rZ]hf�ij_h^he_eb�_]h"Gh�l_i_jv�fu�^he`gu�ijbagZlv��qlh�gZc^_ggh_�l_f�b ^jm]bf�iml_f�g_�kh\k_f�kh\iZ^Z_l��I_j_^gZfb�\klZ_l�aZ^ZqZ�khihklZ\blv�h[Z�j_amevlZlZ�b khhlg_klb�bo�f_`^m�kh[hc�K h[_bo� klhjhg� fu� ijbreb� d \u\h^m�� qlh� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby�� \ kmsghklb�� khklhbl� \i_j_\h^_� fuke_c� \ dZdh_�lh� ]ZeexpbgZlhjgh_� i_j_`b\Zgb_�� DZd� wlh� ijhbkoh^bl�ij_^klZ\ey_lky�\_kvfZ�aZ]Z^hqguf��gh�wlh�y\ey_lky�ijh[e_fhc�h[s_c�ikboheh]bb��dhlhjZy�g_^he`gZ� gZk� a^_kv� aZgbfZlv�� Ba� ^_lkdbo� kgh\b^_gbc� fu� magZeb�� qlh� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gbyklj_fblky�d mkljZg_gbx�gZjmrZxs_]h� khg�^mr_\gh]h� jZa^jZ`_gby�ijb�ihfhsb�bkiheg_gby`_eZgby�� H[� bkdZ`_gguo� kgh\b^_gbyo� fu� g_� fh]eb� kdZaZlv� gbq_]h� ih^h[gh]h�� ihdZ� g_gZmqbebkv� bo� lhedh\Zlv��Gh� k kZfh]h� gZqZeZ� fu� ij_^iheh`beb�� qlh� kfh`_f� jZkkfZljb\ZlvbkdZ`_ggu_�kgh\b^_gby�k l_o�`_�ihabpbc��qlh�b bgnZglbevgu_��I_j\uf�`_�ih^l\_j`^_gb_fwlh]h�ij_^iheh`_gby�klZeh�k^_eZggh_�gZfb�hldjulb_��qlh��kh[kl\_ggh�]h\hjy��\k_�kgh\b^_gbyy\eyxlky� ^_lkdbfb� kgh\b^_gbyfb�� jZ[hlZxl� k ^_lkdbf� fZl_jbZehf�� k ^_lkdbfb� ^mr_\gufb^\b`_gbyfb� b ijb� ihfhsb� ^_lkdbo�f_oZgbafh\��KqblZy� bkdZ`_gb_� kgh\b^_gby� kgyluf��fu^he`gu� ijbklmiblv� d bkke_^h\Zgbx� lh]h�� fh`_l� eb� [ulv� jZkijhkljZg_gh� iheh`_gb_� h[

Page 117: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

bkiheg_gbb�`_eZgby�gZ�bkdZ`_ggu_�kgh\b^_gby�G_^Z\gh� fu� ih^\_j]eb� lhedh\Zgbx� jy^� kgh\b^_gbc�� gh� kh\k_f� mimklbeb� ba� \b^mbkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby��M[_`^_g��qlh�ijb�wlhf�m \Zk�g_h^ghdjZlgh�gZijZrb\Zeky�\hijhk��dm^Z�`_^_ehkv�bkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby��dhlhjh_��\b^bfh��y\ey_lky�p_evx�kgh\b^_gby"�Wlh�\Z`guc�\hijhk�bf_ggh� _]h� b klZeb� aZ^Z\Zlv� gZrb� ^hfhjhs_ggu_� djblbdb�� DZd� \u� agZ_l_�� q_eh\_q_kl\hh[eZ^Z_l� bgklbgdlb\ghc� h[hjhgbl_evghc� j_Zdpb_c� gZ� bgl_ee_dlmZevgu_� gh\r_kl\Z���� HgZ\ujZ`Z_lky� \ lhf�� qlh� lZdh_� gh\r_kl\h� kjZam� `_� gba\h^blky� ^h� kZfhc� g_agZqbl_evghc\_ebqbgu��ih�\hafh`ghklb�k\h^blky�d ehamg]m��Wlbf�ehamg]hf�^ey�gh\hc�l_hjbb�kgh\b^_gbyklZeh� bkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby��>be_lZgl� aZ^Z_l� \hijhk�� ]^_�`_� bkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby"� KjZam�`_ihke_�lh]h��dZd�hg�mkeurZe��qlh�kgh\b^_gb_�^he`gh�[ulv�bkiheg_gb_f�`_eZgby��hg�� aZ^Z\Zywlhl�\hijhk��hl\_qZ_l�gZ�g_]h�hljbpZl_evgh��?fm�kjZam�`_�ijboh^yl�\ ]heh\m�fgh]hqbke_ggu_kh[kl\_ggu_�kgh\b^_gby��k dhlhjufb�[ueh� k\yaZgh�g_ijbylgh_�qm\kl\h�\iehlv�^h� ]g_lms_]hkljZoZ�� lZd� qlh� ^Zggh_� ml\_j`^_gb_� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_hjbb� kgh\b^_gby� dZ`_lky� _ ^mkh\_jr_ggh� g_\_jhylguf�� GZf� g_ljm^gh� hl\_lblv� _fm�� qlh� ijb� bkdZ`_gguo� kgh\b^_gbyobkiheg_gb_� `_eZgby� g_� fh`_l� [ulv� hq_\b^guf�� Z _]h� g_h[oh^bfh� ihbkdZlv�� lZd� qlh� [_alhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gby�mdZaZlv�gZ�g_]h�g_evay��Fu�lZd`_�agZ_f��qlh�`_eZgby�wlbo�bkdZ`_gguokgh\b^_gbc�²�aZij_s_ggu_��hl\_j]gmlu_�p_gamjhc�`_eZgby��kms_kl\h\Zgb_�dhlhjuo�dZd�jZa�bklZeh� ijbqbghc� bkdZ`_gby�� fhlb\hf� ^ey� \f_rZl_evkl\Z� p_gamju�� Gh� djblbdm�^be_lZglmljm^gh�^hdZaZlv��qlh�^h�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gby�g_evay�kijZrb\Zlv�h[�bkiheg_gbb�_]h�`_eZgby�H^gZdh�hg�h[� wlhf�ihklhyggh� aZ[u\Z_l��?]h� hljbpZl_evgZy�ihabpby�ih�hlghr_gbx� d l_hjbbbkiheg_gby�`_eZgby�y\ey_lky��kh[kl\_ggh��g_�q_f�bguf��dZd�ke_^kl\b_f�p_gamju�kgh\b^_gby�aZf_s_gb_f�b j_amevlZlhf�hljbpZgby�wlbo�ijhr_^rbo�p_gamjm�`_eZgbc�kgh\b^_gby�JZamf__lky�� b m� gZk� \hagbdZ_l� ihlj_[ghklv� gZclb� h[tykg_gb_� lhfm�� qlh� _klv� fgh]hfmqbl_evguo� b�� \ qZklghklb�� kljZrguo� kgh\b^_gbc�� Ijb� wlhf� fu� \i_j\u_� klZedb\Z_fky� kijh[e_fhc� Znn_dlh\� \ kgh\b^_gbb�� dhlhjZy� aZkem`b\Z_l� bamq_gby� kZfZ� ih� k_[_�� gh� dkh`Ze_gbxª�fu�g_�fh`_f�_x�aZgylvky��?keb�kgh\b^_gb_�y\ey_lky�bkiheg_gb_f�`_eZgby��lh�\hkg_�g_\hafh`gu�fmqbl_evgu_�hsms_gby��\ wlhf�djblbdb�^be_lZglu��ih�\b^bfhfm��ijZ\u��Ghgm`gh�ijbgylv�\h�\gbfZgb_�ljb��\b^Z�hkeh`g_gbc��h dhlhjuo�hgb�g_�ih^mfZeb�<h�i_j\uo�� fh`_l� [ulv�� qlh� jZ[hl_� kgh\b^_gby� g_� \iheg_� m^Zehkv� hkms_kl\blvbkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby��lZd�qlh�qZklv�fmqbl_evgh]h�Znn_dlZ�fuke_c�kgh\b^_gby�hklZ_lky�\ y\ghfkgh\b^_gbb�� Lh]^Z� ZgZeba� ^he`_g� [ue� [u� ihdZaZlv�� qlh� wlb� fukeb� [ueb� _s_� [he__fmqbl_evgufb�� q_f� ihemqb\r__ky� ba� gbo� kgh\b^_gb_�� DZ`^uc� jZa� wlh� b m^Z_lky� ^hdZaZlv�Lh]^Z�fu�kh]eZrZ_fky��qlh�jZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby�g_�^hklb]eZ�k\h_c�p_eb��lZd�`_�dZd�kgh\b^_gb_��\dhlhjhf�iv_rv�ih^� \ebygb_f�`Z`^u��fZeh� ^hklb]Z_l�p_eb� mlheblv�`Z`^m��?_� ijh^he`Z_rvbkiulu\Zlv��b gm`gh�ijhkgmlvky��qlh[u�ihiblv��B \k_�lZdb�wlh�[ueh�gZklhys__�kgh\b^_gb_��\_]h� kmsghklb� gbq_]h�g_� baf_gbehkv��Fu� ^he`gu� kdZaZlv�� 8W� GHVLQW� YLUHV�� WDPHQ� HVW� ODXGDQGDYROXQWDV ��Ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��aZkem`b\Z_l�ih�o\Zeu�ykgh�\ujZ`_ggh_�gZf_j_gb_��LZdb_�kemqZbg_m^Zqb�g_j_^db�Wlhfm� kh^_ckl\m_l� lh�� qlh� jZ[hl_� kgh\b^_gby� gZfgh]h� ljm^g__� baf_gblv� \gm`ghf� kfuke_� Znn_dlu�� q_f� kh^_j`Zgb_�� Znn_dlu� bgh]^Z� hq_gv� mklhcqb\u�� <hl� bihemqZ_lky��qlh�jZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby�ij_\jZlbeZ�fmqbl_evgh_�kh^_j`Zgb_�fuke_c�kgh\b^_gby�\bkiheg_gb_� dZdh]h�lh� `_eZgby�� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd� fmqbl_evguc� Znn_dl� ijhju\Z_lky� \ _s_

Page 118: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_baf_g_gghf�\b^_��< lZdbo�kgh\b^_gbyo�Znn_dl�kh\_jr_ggh�g_�khhl\_lkl\m_l�kh^_j`Zgbx��bgZrb�djblbdb�fh]ml�kdZaZlv��qlh�kgh\b^_gb_�gZklhevdh�^Ze_dh�hl�bkiheg_gby�`_eZgby��qlh�\g_f� ^Z`_� [_ah[b^gh_� kh^_j`Zgb_� fh`_l� hsmsZlvky� dZd� fmqbl_evgh_�� GZ� wlh� g_jZamfgh_aZf_qZgb_� fu� hl\_lbf�� qlh� bf_ggh� \ lZdbo� kgh\b^_gbyo� klj_fe_gb_� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gbybkihegblv� `_eZgb_� \ke_^kl\b_� _]h� >klj_fe_gby@� bahebjh\Zgghklb� ijhy\ey_lky� ykg__� \k_]h�Hrb[dZ� ijhbkoh^bl� hl� lh]h�� qlh� lhl�� dlh� g_� agZ_l� g_\jhah\�� ij_^klZ\ey_l� k_[_� k\yav�f_`^mkh^_j`Zgb_f�b Znn_dlhf�kebrdhf�l_kghc�b ihwlhfm�g_�fh`_l�ihgylv��qlh�kh^_j`Zgb_�fh`_lf_gylvky��g_�baf_gyy�hlghkys__ky�d g_fm�Znn_dlb\gh_�ijhy\e_gb_�<lhjhc�� ]hjZa^h� [he__� \Z`guc� b ]em[hdbc� fhf_gl�� dhlhjuc� lZd`_� g_^hhp_gb\Z_lky^be_lZglhf�� ke_^mxsbc�� Bkiheg_gb_� `_eZgby�� dhg_qgh�� ^he`gh� [ueh� [u� ^hklZ\blvgZkeZ`^_gb_��gh�� kijZrb\Z_lky��dhfm"�JZamf__lky�� lhfm�� dlh�bf__l�`_eZgb_��Gh� h \b^_\r_fkhg� gZf� ba\_klgh�� qlh� hg� hlghkblky� d k\hbf�`_eZgbyf� kh\_jr_ggh� hkh[h��Hg� hl\_j]Z_l� bo�ih^\_j]Z_l� p_gamj_�� h^gbf� keh\hf�� g_� l_jibl� bo�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� bo� bkiheg_gb_� fh`_l^hklZ\blv�_fm�g_�gZkeZ`^_gb_��Z lhevdh�ijhlb\hiheh`gh_�qm\kl\h��>Ze__�hiul�ihdZau\Z_l��qlhwlh� ijhlb\hiheh`gh_� qm\kl\h�� dhlhjh_� ke_^m_l� _s_� h[tykgblv�� \uklmiZ_l� \ nhjf_� kljZoZ�<b^_\r_]h� khg� \ hlghr_gbb� d _]h� `_eZgbyf� \h� kg_� fh`gh� kjZ\gblv� lhevdh� k kms_kl\hf�khklhysbf� ba� ^\mo� ebp�� hq_gv� l_kgh� k\yaZgguo�� h^gZdh�� f_`^m� kh[hc�� <aZf_g� ^Zevg_crbojZkkm`^_gbc� ij_^eZ]Zx� \Zf� ihkemrZlv� ba\_klgmx� kdZadm�� \ dhlhjhc� \u� gZc^_l_� l_� `_hlghr_gby�� >h[jZy� n_y� h[_sZ_l� [_^ghc� kmijm`_kdhc� iZj_�� fm`m� b `_g_�� bkiheg_gb_� boi_j\uo�lj_o�`_eZgbc��Hgb�kqZkleb\u�b kh[bjZxlky� ]sZl_evgh�\u[jZlv� wlb� ljb�`_eZgby��Gh`_gZ� kh[eZagy_lky� aZiZohf� `Zj_guo� khkbkhd� ba� khk_^g_c� ob`bgu� b `_eZ_l� ihemqblv� iZjmlZdbo� khkbkhd��Q_j_a� f]gh\_gb_� hgb� m`_� a^_kv� ²� b i_j\h_�`_eZgb_� bkiheg_gh�� Lh]^Z� fm`k_j^blky� b \� ]hjvdhc� h[b^_� `_eZ_l�� qlh[u� khkbkdb� ih\bkeb� m `_gu� gZ� ghkm�� Wlh� lh`_bkihegy_lky��b khkbkdb�g_evay� m^Zeblv� k bo�gh\h]h�f_klZ�ij_[u\Zgby�²� \hl�bkihegbehkv�b\lhjh_�`_eZgb_��gh�m`_�`_eZgb_�fm`Z��`_g_�bkiheg_gb_�wlh]h�`_eZgby�hq_gv�g_ijbylgh�<uagZ_l_��qlh�ijhbkoh^bl�^Zevr_�\ kdZad_��LZd�dZd�h[Z��\ kmsghklb��khklZ\eyxl �Imklv�g_^hklZeh�kbe��iho\Zeu�^hklhcgh�mk_j^b_��Im[ebc�H\b^bc�GZahg��±�Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�\k_�lZdb�h^gh��fm`Z�b `_gm��lh�lj_lv_�`_eZgb_�aZdexqZ_lky�\ lhf��qlh[u�khkbkdb�hklZ\bebghk�`_gu��Fu�fh`_f�bkihevah\Zlv�wlm�kdZadm�_s_�fgh]h�jZa�\ ^jm]hc�k\yab��a^_kv�hgZ�kem`bllhevdh�beexkljZpb_c�lh]h��qlh�bkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby�h^gh]h�fh`_l�\ua\Zlv�g_ijbylgh_�qm\kl\hm ^jm]h]h��_keb�h[Z�g_�kh]eZkgu�f_`^m�kh[hc�L_i_jv� gZf� [m^_l� g_ljm^gh� _s_� emqr_� ihgylv� kljZrgu_� kgh\b^_gby�� Fu� lhevdhijb\e_q_f� _s_� h^gh� gZ[ex^_gb_� b lh]^Z� j_rbfky� \ukdZaZlv� ij_^iheh`_gb_�� \ aZsblmdhlhjh]h�fh`gh�ijb\_klb�fgh]h�^h\h^h\��GZ[ex^_gb_�khklhbl�\ lhf��qlh�kljZrgu_�kgh\b^_gbyqZklh� bf_xl� kh^_j`Zgb_�� kh\_jr_ggh� k\h[h^gh_� hl� bkdZ`_gby�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� ba[_`Z\r__p_gamju�� KljZrgh_� kgh\b^_gb_� qZklh� y\ey_lky� g_ijbdjv�luf� bkiheg_gb_f� `_eZgby�_kl_kl\_ggh��g_�ijbylgh]h��Z hl\_j]Z_fh]h�`_eZgby��<f_klh�p_gamju�ihy\ey_lky�kljZo��?keb�h^_lkdhf�kgh\b^_gbb�fh`gh�kdZaZlv��qlh�hgh�y\ey_lky�bkiheg_gb_f�^ha\he_ggh]h�`_eZgby��h[h[udgh\_gghf�bkdZ`_gghf�kgh\b^_gbb�²�qlh�hgh�aZfZkdbjh\Zggh_�bkiheg_gb_�\ul_kg_ggh]h`_eZgby��lh�^ey�kljZrgh]h�kgh\b^_gby�ih^oh^bl�lhevdh�nhjfmeZ��qlh�hgh�ij_^klZ\ey_l�kh[hcg_ijbdjulh_� bkiheg_gb_� \ul_kg_ggh]h� `_eZgby�� KljZo� y\ey_lky� ijbagZdhf� lh]h�� qlh

Page 119: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ul_kg_ggh_�`_eZgb_�hdZaZehkv�kbevg__�p_gamju��qlh��g_kfhljy�gZ�g__��hgh�\k_�lZdb�ijh[behkvd bkiheg_gbx� beb� [ueh� ]hlh\h� ijh[blvky�� Fu� ihgbfZ_f�� qlh� lh�� qlh� ^ey� g_]h� y\ey_lkybkiheg_gb_f� `_eZgby�� ^ey� gZk�� ihkdhevdm� fu� gZoh^bfky� gZ� klhjhg_� p_gamju� kgh\b^_gby�fh`_l�[ulv�lhevdh�ih\h^hf�^ey�fmqbl_evguo�hsms_gbc�b hlihjZ��Ihy\eyxsbcky�ijb�wlhf�\kgh\b^_gbb�kljZo��_keb�ohlbl_��_klv�kljZo�i_j_^�kbehc� wlbo�h[uqgh�k^_j`b\Z_fuo�`_eZgbc�Ihq_fm� wlhl� hlihj� ijhy\ey_lky� \ nhjf_� kljZoZ�� g_evay� ihgylv�� bamqZy� lhevdh� kgh\b^_gby�hq_\b^gh��gm`gh�bamqZlv�kljZo�ih�^jm]bf�bklhqgbdZf�<k_��qlh�kijZ\_^eb\h�^ey�g_bkdZ`_gguo�kljZrguo�kgh\b^_gbc��fu�fh`_f�ij_^iheh`blvlZd`_� ^ey� lZdbo� kgh\b^_gbc�� dhlhju_� ij_l_ji_eb� qZklbqgh_� bkdZ`_gb_�� b ^ey� ijhqbog_ijbylguo� kgh\b^_gbc�� fmqbl_evgu_� hsms_gby� dhlhjuo�� \_jhylgh�� [ebadb� d kljZom�KljZrgh_�kgh\b^_gb_�h[uqgh�\_^_l�d ijh[m`^_gbx��fu�bf__f�h[udgh\_gb_�ij_ju\Zlv� khg�ij_`^_� q_f� \ul_kg_ggh_� `_eZgb_� kgh\b^_gby� ijh[v_lky� q_j_a� p_gamjm� d k\h_fm� iheghfmbkiheg_gbx��< wlhf�kemqZ_�j_amevlZl�kgh\b^_gby�hdZau\Z_lky�g_]Zlb\guf��gh�_]h�kmsghklv�hlwlh]h� g_� f_gy_lky��Fu� kjZ\gb\Zeb� kgh\b^_gb_� k ghqguf� klhjh`_f�� hojZgyxsbf� gZr� khg�qlh[u�_fm�g_�ihf_rZeb��B ghqghc�klhjh`�ihiZ^Z_l�\ lZdh_�iheh`_gb_��dh]^Z�hg�[m^bl�kiysbo�Z bf_ggh�lh]^Z��dh]^Z�qm\kl\m_l�k_[y�kebrdhf�keZ[uf��qlh[u�mkljZgblv�ihf_om�beb�hiZkghklv�B \k_�lZdb�gZf�bgh]^Z�m^Z_lky�ijh^he`Zlv�kiZlv��^Z`_�_keb�kgh\b^_gb_�klZgh\blky�lj_\h`gufb gZqbgZ_l�aZjh`^Zlvky�kljZo��Fu�]h\hjbf�k_[_�\h�kg_��\_^v�wlh�lhevdh�khg�²�b ijh^he`Z_fkiZlv�Dh]^Z� `_� kemqZ_lky� lZd�� qlh� `_eZgb_� kgh\b^_gby� hdZau\Z_lky� \ khklhygbb� ij_h^he_lvp_gamjm"�Mkeh\b_�^ey�wlh]h�fh`_l�\hagbdgmlv�dZd�kh�klhjhgu�`_eZgby�kgh\b^_gby��lZd�b khklhjhgu�p_gamju��Ih�g_ihgylguf�ijbqbgZf�`_eZgb_�fh`_l�klZlv�bghc�jZa�q_j_kqmj�kbevguf�gh�m gZk�kdeZ^u\Z_lky�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�qZs_�\bgZ�aZ�wlh�kf_s_gb_�khhlghr_gby�^_ckl\mxsbokbe�e_`bl�gZ�p_gamj_�kgh\b^_gby��Fu�m`_� agZ_f��qlh�p_gamjZ�jZ[hlZ_l�\ dZ`^hf�hl^_evghfkemqZ_�k jZaghc�bgl_gkb\ghklvx��d dZ`^hfm�we_f_glm�hlghkblky�k jZaghc�kl_i_gvx�kljh]hklb�a^_kv�gZf�ohl_ehkv�[u�\ukdZaZlv�_s_�h^gh�ij_^iheh`_gb_��qlh�hgZ�\hh[s_�\_kvfZ�\ZjbZ[_evgZb g_�\k_]^Z�h^bgZdh\h�kljh]Z�d h^ghfm�b lhfm�`_�g_ijbebqghfm�we_f_glm��?keb�kemqblky�lZd�qlh� hgZ� gZ� dZdhc�lh� fhf_gl� ihqm\kl\m_l� k_[y� [_kkbevghc� i_j_^� dZdbf�eb[h� `_eZgb_fkgh\b^_gby�� m]jh`Zxsbf� aZo\Zlblv� __ \jZkieho�� lh� \f_klh� bkdZ`_gby� hgZ� ijb[_]Z_l� dihke_^g_fm� hklZ\r_fmky� _c� kj_^kl\m� ²� hldZaZlvky� hl� khklhygby� kgZ� ih^� \ebygb_fgZjZklZxs_]h�kljZoZ�Ijb� wlhf� gZf� [jhkZ_lky� \ ]eZaZ�� qlh� fu� \_^v� \hh[s_� g_� agZ_f�� ihq_fm� wlb� kd\_jgu_�hl\_j]gmlu_�`_eZgby� ^Zxl� h k_[_� agZlv� bf_ggh� \ ghqgh_� \j_fy�� qlh[u� gZjmrblv� gZr� khg�Hl\_l�fh`_l�^Zlv�lhevdh�ij_^iheh`_gb_��mqblu\Zxs__�ijbjh^m�khklhygby�kgZ��>g_f�gZ� wlb`_eZgby�ly`_eh�^Z\bl�p_gamjZ��g_�^ZxsZy�bf��dZd�ijZ\beh��\hafh`ghklb�ijhy\blvky�\ dZdhf�lh^_ckl\bb��< ghqgh_� \j_fy� wlZ�p_gamjZ�� \_jhylgh�� dZd� \k_� ^jm]b_� bgl_j_ku� ^mr_\ghc�`bagb�k\h^blky�d _^bgkl\_gghfm�`_eZgbx�kiZlv�beb�`_��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��kbevgh�hkeZ[ey_lky��WlhfmhkeZ[e_gbx� p_gamju� \ ghqgh_� \j_fy� aZij_lgu_� `_eZgby� b h[yaZgu� l_f�� qlh� fh]ml� kgh\Zh`b\Zlv�� ?klv� g_j\gu_� [hevgu_�� kljZ^Zxsb_� [_kkhggbp_c�� dhlhju_� ijbagZ\Zebkv� gZf�� qlhkgZqZeZ�hgb�kZfb�ohl_eb�k\h_c�[_kkhggbpu��Hgb�g_�j_rZebkv�mkgmlv��ihlhfm�qlh�[hyebkv�k\hbokgh\b^_gbc��l��_��ihke_^kl\bc�wlh]h�hkeZ[e_gby�p_gamju��<u��ijZ\^Z��e_]dh�aZf_lbl_��qlh�wlm

Page 120: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijbhklZgh\dm� ^_yl_evghklb� p_gamju� \k_� `_� g_� ke_^m_l� hp_gb\Zlv� dZd� [hevrmxg_hklhjh`ghklv��Khklhygb_� kgZ�ebrZ_l�gZk� kihkh[ghklb�^\b]Zlvky��gZrb�^mjgu_�gZf_j_gby�_keb� hgb� b gZqbgZxl�r_\_eblvky�� g_� fh]ml� ijb\_klb� gb d� q_fm� bghfm�� dZd� d ijZdlbq_kdb[_a\j_^ghfm� kgh\b^_gbx�� b gZ� wlh� mkihdhbl_evgh_� khklhygb_� mdZau\Z_l� \ \ukr_c� kl_i_gb[eZ]hjZamfgh_�aZf_qZgb_�kiys_]h��hlghkys__ky��ijZ\^Z��d ghqb��gh�g_�d `bagb�\h�kg_��\_^v�wlhlhevdh�khg��ihwlhfm�ij_^hklZ\bf�_fm�k\h[h^m�^_ckl\by�b [m^_f�ijh^he`Zlv�kiZlv�?keb��\�lj_lvbo��\u�\kihfgbl_�h lhf��qlh�fu�ij_^klZ\beb�\b^_\r_]h�khg�[hjxsbfky�khk\hbfb�`_eZgbyfb��khklhysbf�ba�^\mo�hl^_evguo��gh�dZdbf�lh�h[jZahf�hq_gv�l_kgh�k\yaZgguoebp�� lh� ijbagZ_l_� b ^jm]mx� \hafh`ghklv�� dZd� [eZ]h^Zjy� bkiheg_gbx� `_eZgby� fh`_lhkms_kl\blvky� lh��qlh� \ \ukr_c� kl_i_gb�g_ijbylgh�²� Z bf_ggh�gZdZaZgb_�� A^_kv�gZf� hiylvfh`_l�ihfhqv�kdZadZ�h lj_o�`_eZgbyo��`Zj_gu_�khkbkdb�gZ�lZj_ed_�[ueb�ijyfuf�bkiheg_gb_f`_eZgby� i_j\h]h� ebpZ��`_gu�� khkbkdb� gZ� __ ghkm� [ueb� bkiheg_gb_f�`_eZgby� \lhjh]h� ebpZ�fm`Z��gh�h^gh\j_f_ggh�b gZdZaZgb_f�aZ�]emih_�`_eZgb_�`_gu��Ijb�g_\jhaZo�fu�gZoh^bf�aZl_ffhlb\Zpbx� lj_lv_]h� `_eZgby�� dhlhjh_� _s_� hklZehkv� \ kdZad_�� < ^mr_\ghc� `bagb� q_eh\_dZfgh]h�lZdbo�gZdZam_fuo�l_g^_gpbc��hgb�hq_gv�kbevgu��b bo�fh`gh�kqblZlv�hl\_lkl\_ggufb�aZg_dhlhjmx� qZklv� fmqbl_evguo� kgh\b^_gbc�� L_i_jv� \u�� fh`_l� [ulv�� kdZ`_l_�� qlh� ijb� wlbomkeh\byo� hl� o\Ze_gh]h� bkiheg_gby� `_eZgby� hklZ_lky� g_fgh]h_�� Gh� ijb� [he__� ijbklZevghfjZkkfhlj_gbb� ijb^_l_� d aZdexq_gbx�� qlh� g_� ijZ\u�� Ih� kjZ\g_gbx� k [he__� iha^gbfbmdZaZgbyfb� gZ� fgh]hh[jZab_� lh]h�� q_f� fh]eh� [u� [ulv� kgh\b^_gb_�²� Z ih� fg_gbx� fgh]boZ\lhjh\�� q_f� hgh� b y\ey_lky� gZ� kZfhf� ^_e_�²� ij_^klZ\e_gb_� h kgh\b^_gbb� dZd� bkiheg_gbb`_eZgby� ²� i_j_`b\Zgbb� kljZoZ� ²� bkiheg_gbb� gZdZaZgby� ²� hdZau\Z_lky� \k_�lZdb� \_kvfZh]jZgbq_gguf�� D wlhfm� gm`gh� ijb[Z\blv� lh�� qlh� kljZo� _klv� ijyfZy� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv`_eZgby�� qlh� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb� \ ZkkhpbZpbb� hkh[_ggh� [ebadb� ^jm]� ^jm]m�� Z \[_kkhagZl_evghf�� dZd� fu� magZeb�� kh\iZ^Zxl�� ^Ze__� lh�� qlh� gZdZaZgb_� lh`_� y\ey_lkybkiheg_gb_f�`_eZgby��gh�^jm]h]h�²�p_gamjbjmxs_]h�ebpZ�BlZd�� y \� h[s_f� g_� k^_eZe� gbdZdbo� mklmihd� \Zr_fm� \hajZ`_gbx� ijhlb\� l_hjbbbkiheg_gby� `_eZgby�� Gh� fu� h[yaZgu� ^hdZaZlv� bkiheg_gb_� `_eZgby� \ ex[hf� bkdZ`_gghfkgh\b^_gbb� b�� dhg_qgh�� g_� kh[bjZ_fky� hldZau\Zlvky� hl� wlhc� aZ^Zqb�� <_jg_fky� d m`_bklhedh\Zgghfm� kgh\b^_gbx� h lj_o� iehobo� l_ZljZevguo� [be_lZo� aZ� �� ]mev^_g� ��� dj��� gZijbf_j_� dhlhjh]h� fu� m`_� fgh]hfm� gZmqbebkv�� GZ^_xkv�� \u� _]h� _s_� ihfgbl_�� >ZfZ�� fm`dhlhjhc� khh[sbe� _c� ^g_f�� qlh� __ ih^jm]Z� WebaZ�� dhlhjZy� fheh`_� g__� gZ� ljb� f_kypZ�h[jmqbeZkv��\b^bl�\h�kg_��qlh�hgZ�kb^bl�\ l_Zlj_�kh�k\hbf�fm`_f��H^gZ�klhjhgZ�iZjl_jZ�ihqlbimklZ��?_�fm`�]h\hjbl�_c��qlh�WebaZ�k `_gbohf�lh`_�ohl_eb�ihclb�\ l_Zlj��gh�g_�kfh]eb��lZddZd�^hklZeb�lhevdh�iehob_�f_klZ��ljb�aZ�h^bg�]mev^_g�iylv^_kyl��HgZ�iheZ]Z_l��qlh�g wlhf�g_lgbdZdh]h� g_kqZklvy�� Fu� ^h]Z^Zebkv�� qlh� fukeb� kgh\b^_gby� \ujZ`Zeb� ^hkZ^m� gZ� jZgg__aZfm`_kl\h� b g_^h\hevkl\h� k\hbf� fm`_f�� Ex[hiulgh�� dZd� wlb� fjZqgu_� fukeb� [uebi_j_jZ[hlZgu� \ bkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby� b ]^_� djh_lky� _]h� ke_^� \ y\ghf� kgh\b^_gbb��Fvª� m`_agZ_f��qlh�we_f_gl�©kebrdhf�jZgh��ihki_rghª�mkljZg_g�ba�kgh\b^_gby�p_gamjhc��GZf_dhf�gZg_]h� y\ey_lky�imklhc�iZjl_j��AZ]Z^hqgh_� ©ljb� aZ� h^bg� ]mev^_g�iylv^_kylª� klZgh\blky� l_i_jv[he__�ihgylguf�k ihfhsvx�kbf\hebdb��k dhlhjhc�fu�aZ�wlh�\j_fy�ihagZdhfbebkv��WlZ�ljhcdZ�\^_ckl\bl_evghklb� hagZqZ_l� fm`qbgm�� b y\guc� we_f_gl� e_]dh� fh`gh� i_j_\_klb�� dmiblv� k_[_fm`Z� aZ� ijb^Zgh_� �©aZ� fh_� ijb^Zgh_� y fh]eZ� [u� k_[_� dmiblv� \ ^_kylv� jZa� emqr_]hª��

Page 121: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

AZfm`_kl\h�y\gh� aZf_s_gh�ihk_s_gb_f�l_ZljZ� �� ©Kebrdhf�jZggyy�ihdmidZ�[be_lh\ª�ijyfhaZf_sZ_l�kebrdhf�jZgg__�aZfm`_kl\h��Gh�wlh�aZf_s_gb_�y\ey_lky�^_ehf�bkiheg_gby�`_eZgby�GZrZ�^ZfZ�g_�\k_]^Z�[ueZ�lZd�g_^h\hevgZ�k\hbf�jZggbf�aZfm`_kl\hf��dZd�\ lhl�^_gv��dh]^Z�hgZihemqbeZ�ba\_klb_�h ihfhe\d_� k\h_c�ih^jm]b��< k\h_�\j_fy�hgZ� ]hj^beZkv�bf�b qm\kl\h\ZeZk\h_� ij_\hkoh^kl\h� i_j_^� ih^jm]hc�� GZb\gu_� ^_\mrdb� qZklh� ihke_� ihfhe\db� \ujZ`ZxljZ^hklv��qlh�l_i_jv�kdhjh�ihc^ml�\ l_Zlj�gZ�\k_�^h�kbo�ihj�aZij_s_ggu_�iv_ku�b \k_�m\b^yl�>hey� kljZklb� d ih^]ey^u\Zgbx� beb� ex[hiulkl\Z�� dhlhjZy� a^_kv� ijhy\ey_lky�� [ueZ� kgZqZeZhij_^_e_ggh� k_dkmZevghc� kljZklvx� d ih^]ey^u\Zgbx�� gZijZ\e_gghc� gZ� iheh\mx� `bagv�hkh[_ggh� jh^bl_e_c�� b aZl_f� klZeZ� kbevguf� fhlb\hf�� ih[m`^Z\rbf� ^_\mrdm� d jZgg_fmaZfm`_kl\m�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� ihk_s_gb_� l_ZljZ� klZgh\blky� ihgylguf� gZf_dZxsbfaZf_klbl_e_f�^ey�aZfm`_kl\Z��LZd�qlh�\ k\h_c�l_i_j_rg_c�^hkZ^_�gZ�k\h_�jZgg__�aZfm� � H ^jm]hf� gZijZrb\Zxs_fky� lhedh\Zgbb� wlhc� ljhcdb� m [_a^_lghc� `_gsbgu� y g_�mihfbgZx�� lZd� dZdgZklhysbc�ZgZeba�g_�^Ze�wlh]h�fZl_jbZeZ�`_kl\h�hgZ�\ha\jZsZ_lky�d lhfm�\j_f_gb��dh]^Z�hgh�[ueh�bkiheg_gb_f�`_eZgby��ihlhfmqlh� m^h\e_l\hjyeh� kljZklv� d ih^]ey^u\Zgbx�� Z ih^� \ebygb_f� wlh]h� ij_`g_]h� `_eZgbyaZfm`_kl\h�aZf_sZ_lky�ihk_s_gb_f�l_ZljZ�Fu�fh`_f�kdZaZlv��qlh�\u[jZeb�g_�kZfuc�m^Zqguc�ijbf_j�^ey�^hdZaZl_evkl\Z�bkiheg_gbykdjulh]h� `_eZgby�� :gZeh]bqguf� h[jZahf� fu� ^he`gu� [ueb� [u� ihklmiblv� b k� ^jm]bfbbkdZ`_ggufb�kgh\b^_gbyfb��Y g_�fh]m�wlh]h�k^_eZqv�b ohqm�lhevdh�\ujZablv�m[_`^_gb_��qlhwlh� \kx^m� m^Zklky��Gh�gZ� wlhf�fhf_gl_� l_hjbb�fg_� ohq_lky� _s_� aZ^_j`Zlvky��Hiul�ihdZaZefg_��qlh�\h�\k_c�l_hjbb�kgh\b^_gby�wlhl�fhf_gl�kZfuc�mya\bfuc�b qlh�fgh]b_�\hajZ`_gby�bg_^hjZamf_gby�k\yaZgu�k gbf��Djhf_�lh]h��m \Zk��fh`_l�[ulv��keh`blky�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�y m`_hlqZklb� hldZaZeky� hl� k\h_]h� ml\_j`^_gby�� kdZaZ\�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lky� \uiheg_gguf`_eZgb_f� beb� _]h� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklvx� ²� hkms_kl\e_gguf� kljZohf� beb� gZdZaZgb_f�� bih^mfZ_l_��qlh�wlh�m^h[guc�kemqZc�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�\ugm^blv�f_gy�gZ�^Zevg_crb_�mklmidb��YkeurZe�lZd`_�mij_d�\ lhf��qlh�baeZ]Zx�\_sb��dZ`msb_ky�fg_�hq_\b^gufb��kebrdhf�k`Zlh�bihlhfm�g_^hklZlhqgh�m[_^bl_evgh�?keb�dlh�gb[m^v�ke_^h\Ze�aZ�gZfb�\ lhedh\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gbc�^h�wlh]h�f_klZ�b ijbgye�\k_�qlh� hgh� gZf� ^h� kbo� ihj� ^Zeh�� lh� g_j_^dh� i_j_^� \hijhkhf� h[� bkiheg_gbb� `_eZgby� hghklZgZ\eb\Z_lky�b kijZrb\Z_l�^himklbf��qlh�dZ`^h_�kgh\b^_gb_�bf__l�kfuke��b wlhl�kfuke�fh`gh�\kdjulv�ijb�ihfhsbikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc�l_ogbdb��ihq_fm�`_�wlhl�kfuke��\hij_db�\kydhc�hq_\b^ghklb��h[yaZl_evgh^he`_g�[ulv�\lbkgml�\ nhjfmem�bkiheg_gby�`_eZgby"�Ihq_fm�kfuke�wlh]h�ghqgh]h�fure_gbyg_�fh`_l�[ulv�gZklhevdh�`_�jZaghh[jZaguf��dZd�b kfuke�^g_\gh]h�fure_gby��l��_��kgh\b^_gb_fh`_l� khhl\_lkl\h\Zlv� h^bg� jZa� h^ghfm� bkiheg_gghfm�`_eZgbx�� \ ^jm]hc� jZa�� dZd� \u� kZfb]h\hjbl_��_]h�ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb��dZdhfm�lh�^_ckl\bl_evghfm�hiZk_gbx��Z aZl_f�\ujZ`Zlv�bdZdh_�lh� gZf_j_gb_�� ij_^hkl_j_`_gb_�� jZkkm`^_gb_� aZ� b ijhlb\� beb� mij_d�� mdhj� kh\_klb�ihiuldm�ih^]hlh\blvky�d ij_^klhys_fm�^_ckl\bx�b l��^�"�Ihq_fm�`_�\k_]^Z�h^gh�`_eZgb_�beb\ emqr_f�kemqZ_�_s_�_]h�ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv"Fh`gh� [ueh� [u�ih^mfZlv�� qlh� jZagh]eZkb_� \ wlhf� \hijhk_� g_� lZd� \Z`gh�� _keb� \h� \k_f

Page 122: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hklZevghf�k gZfb�kh]eZkgu��>hklZlhqgh�lh]h��qlh�fu�gZreb�kfuke�kgh\b^_gby�b imlb��qlh[u_]h�magZlv��\ kjZ\g_gbb�k wlbf�g_�bf__l�[hevrh]h�agZq_gby�lh��qlh�fu�\ugm`^_gu�h]jZgbqblvwlhl� kfuke�� h^gZdh� wlh�g_� lZd��G_^hjZamf_gb_� \ wlhf�imgdl_� aZljZ]b\Z_l� kZfmx� kmlv�gZrboij_^klZ\e_gbc�h kgh\b^_gbb�b klZ\bl�ih^�khfg_gb_�bo�agZq_gb_�^ey�ihgbfZgby�g_\jhaZ��Djhª�_lh]h�� lZ� mklmiqb\hklv�� dhlhjZy� \ dhff_jq_kdhf� fbj_� p_gblky� dZd� ©ij_^mij_^bl_evghklvª�� \gZmd_�g_mf_klgZ�b��kdhj__�\k_]h��\j_^gZ�Fhc� i_j\uc� hl\_l� gZ� \hijhk�� ihq_fm� kgh\b^_gb_� g_� ^he`gh� [ulv� \ mdZaZgghf� kfuke_fgh]hagZqguf��]eZkbl��dZd�h[uqgh�\ lZdbo�kemqZyo��y g_�agZx��ihq_fm�lZd�g_�^he`gh�[ulv��Y[u� g_� bf_e� gbq_]h� ijhlb\��Imklv� [m^_l� lZd�� Ebrv� h^gZ� f_ehqv� ijhlb\hj_qbl� wlhfm� [he__rbjhdhfm�b [he__�m^h[ghfm�ihgbfZgbx�kgh\b^_gby��Z bf_ggh�lh��qlh�\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�wlhg_� lZd�� <lhjhc� fhc� hl\_l� ih^q_jdb\Z_l�� qlh� fg_� kZfhfm� g_� qm`^h� ij_^iheh`_gb_� hkhhl\_lkl\bb�kgh\b^_gby�fgh]hh[jZaguf�nhjfZf�fure_gby�b bgl_ee_dlmZevguo�hi_jZpbc��YdZd�lh�khh[sZe�\ h^ghc�bklhjbb�[he_agb�h kgh\b^_gbb��y\ey\r_fky�ljb�ghqb�ih^jy^�b [hevr_g_�ih\lhjy\r_fky��b h[tykgbe� wlhl� kemqZc� l_f��qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� khhl\_lkl\h\Zeh�gZf_j_gbx�dhlhjhfm� g_aZq_f� [ueh� ih\lhjylvky� ihke_� lh]h�� dZd� hgh� [ueh� \uiheg_gh�� Iha^g__� yhim[ebdh\Ze� ijbf_j� h^gh]h� kgh\b^_gby�� khhl\_lkl\h\Z\r_]h� ijbagZgbx�� DZd�`_� y \k_�lZdbfh]m�ml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�kgh\b^_gb_�ij_^klZ\ey_l�kh[hc�\k_]^Z�lhevdh�bkiheg_ggh_�`_eZgb_"Y ^_eZx�wlh�ihlhfm��qlh�g_�ohqm�^himkdZlv�]emih]h�g_^hjZamf_gby��dhlhjh_�fh`_l�ebrblvgZk� j_amevlZlh\� \k_o� gZrbo� mkbebc� \ ZgZeba_� kgh\b^_gbc�� g_^hjZamf_gby�� ijb� dhlhjhfkgh\b^_gb_�imlZxl�kh�kdjulufb�_]h�fukeyfb�b \ukdZau\Zxl�h g_f�lh��qlh�hlghkblky�d wlbfihke_^gbf�b lhevdh�d gbf��:[khexlgh�ijZ\bevgh��qlh�kgh\b^_gb_�fh`_l�ij_^klZ\eylv�\k_�wlhb [ulv�aZf_g_gh�l_f��qlh�fu�m`_�i_j_qbkebeb��gZf_j_gb_f��ij_^hkl_j_`_gb_f��jZkkm`^_gb_f�ijb]hlh\e_gb_f�� ihiuldhc� j_r_gby� dZdhc�lh� aZ^Zqb� b l�� ^�� Gh� _keb� \u� ijbkfhljbl_kv�� lhm\b^bl_�� qlh� \k_� wlh� hlghkblky� lhevdh� d kdjuluf� fukeyf� kgh\b^_gby�� ij_\jZlb\rbfky� \kgh\b^_gb_�� Ba� lhedh\Zgbc� kgh\b^_gbc� \u� agZ_l_�� qlh� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� fure_gb_� ex^_caZgylh� lZdbfb� gZf_j_gbyfb�� ijb]hlh\e_gbyfb�� jZafure_gbyfb� b l�� ^��� ba� dhlhjuo� aZl_fjZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby� ^_eZ_l� kgh\b^_gby�� ?keb� \Zk� ihdZ� g_� bgl_j_km_l� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby�� ghhq_gv�bgl_j_km_l�[_kkhagZl_evgZy�jZ[hlZ�fure_gby�q_eh\_dZ��lh�bkdexqbl_�jZ[hlm�kgh\b^_gbyb kdZ`bl_�h kgh\b^_gbb�ijZ\bevgh��qlh�hgh�khhl\_lkl\m_l�ij_^hkl_j_`_gbx��gZf_j_gbx�b l��b�< ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc�^_yl_evghklb�wlh�qZklh�\klj_qZ_lky��ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�klj_fylky�lhevdhd lhfm��qlh[u� \gh\v� jZajmrblv�nhjfm� kgh\b^_gby�b \f_klh�g_]h� \hkklZgh\blv� h[smx� k\yavkdjuluo�fuke_c��ba�dhlhjuo�hgh�khklZ\e_gh�LZd��kh\_jr_ggh�f_`^m�ijhqbf�fu�magZ_f�ba�hp_gdb�kdjuluo�fuke_c�kgh\b^_gby��qlh�\k_wlb�gZa\Zggu_�qj_a\uqZcgh�keh`gu_�^mr_\gu_�ijhp_kku�fh]ml�ijhoh^blv�[_kkhagZl_evgh�²klhev�`_�]jZg^bhaguc��kdhev�b hr_ehfeyxsbc�j_amevlZl�Gh�\_jg_fky�gZaZ^��<u�[m^_l_�ijZ\u��_keb�mykgbl_�k_[_��qlh�ihevah\Zebkv�khdjZs_ggufb\ujZ`_gbyfb�� b _keb� g_� [m^_l_� ^mfZlv�� qlh� ^he`gu� hlg_klb� mihfygmlh_� jZaghh[jZab_� dkmsghklb�kgh\b^_gby��?keb�\u�]h\hjbl_�h kgh\b^_gbb��lh�\u�^he`gu�bf_lv�\ \b^m�beb�y\gh_kgh\b^_gb_��l��_��ijh^mdl�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gby��beb�\ emqr_f�kemqZ_�kZfm�jZ[hlm�kgh\b^_gby��l�_�� lhl�ikbobq_kdbc�ijhp_kk��dhlhjuc�h[jZam_l� y\gh_� kgh\b^_gb_�ba� kdjuluo�fuke_c��Ex[h_^jm]h_�mihlj_[e_gb_�keh\Z�[m^_l�imlZgbp_c�\ ihgylbyo��dhlhjZy�fh`_l�[ulv�lhevdh�ijbqbghc

Page 123: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_^hjZamf_gby�� ?keb� \ k\hbo� ml\_j`^_gbyo� \u� bf__l_� \ \b^m� kdjulu_� fukeb�� klhysb_� aZkgh\b^_gb_f�� lh� kdZ`bl_� h[� wlhf� ijyfh� b g_� h[e_dZcl_� ijh[e_fm� kgh\b^_gby� \ g_ykgu_\ujZ`_gby�� dhlhjufb� \u� ihevam_l_kv�� Kdjulu_� fukeb� ²� wlh� fZl_jbZe�� dhlhjuc� jZ[hlZkgh\b^_gby� ij_h[jZam_l� \ y\gh_� kgh\b^_gb_�� Ihq_fm� `_� \u� g_ij_f_ggh� ohlbl_� kf_rb\ZlvfZl_jbZe� k jZ[hlhc�� dhlhjZy� _]h� nhjfhh[jZam_l"� DZdb_� `_� m \Zk� lh]^Z� ij_bfms_kl\Z� ihkjZ\g_gbx�k l_fb��dlh�\b^bl�lhevdh�ijh^mdl�b g_�fh`_l�h[tykgblv��hldm^Z�hg�ijhbkoh^bl�b dZdhg�k^_eZg"?^bgkl\_ggh� kms_kl\_gguf� \ kgh\b^_gbb� y\ey_lky� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby�� dhlhjZy\ha^_ckl\m_l�gZ�fZl_jbZe�fuke_c��Fu�g_�bf__f�ijZ\Z�b]ghjbjh\Zlv�__ \�l_hjbb��_keb�b fh`_fk_[_� iha\heblv� ij_g_[j_qv� _x� \ hij_^_e_gguo� ijZdlbq_kdbo� kblmZpbyo�� Djhf_� lh]h�ZgZeblbq_kdh_�gZ[ex^_gb_�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�jZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby�gbdh]^Z�g_�h]jZgbqb\Z_lky�l_f�qlh[u�i_j_\_klb�wlb�fukeb�\ ba\_klgmx�\Zf�ZjoZbq_kdmx�beb�j_]j_kkb\gmx�nhjfm�\ujZ`_gby�Gh�hgZ�ihklhyggh�ijb[Z\ey_l�dh_�qlh��g_�bf_xs__�hlghr_gby� d ^g_\guf� kdjuluf�fukeyf�y\eyxs__ky�� kh[kl\_ggh� ]h\hjy�� ^\b`ms_c� kbehc� h[jZah\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby�� Wlh� g_ba[_`gh_^h[Z\e_gb_� b _klv� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� `_eZgb_�� ^ey� bkiheg_gby� dhlhjh]h� ij_h[jZam_lkykh^_j`Zgb_� kgh\b^_gby�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� kgh\b^_gb_� fh`_l� [ulv� q_f� m]h^gh� ²ij_^hkl_j_`_gb_f��gZf_j_gb_f��ijb]hlh\e_gb_f�b l��^���_keb�\u�[m^_l_�ijbgbfZlv�\h�\gbfZgb_lhevdh� ij_^klZ\e_ggu_� bf� fukeb�� hgh� \k_]^Z� [m^_l� lZd`_� bkiheg_gb_f� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h`_eZgby� b lhevdh� bf�� _keb� \u� [m^_l_� jZkkfZljb\Zlv� _]h� dZd� j_amevlZl� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby�Kgh\b^_gb_��lZdbf�h[jZahf��gbdh]^Z�g_�[m^_]�ijhklh�gZf_j_gb_f��ij_^mij_`^_gb_f��Z \k_]^ZgZf_j_gb_f�b l��i����i_j_\_^_gguf�k ihfhsvx�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�`_eZgby�\ ZjoZbq_kdmx�nhjfm\ujZ`_gby� b ij_h[jZah\Zgguf� ^ey� bkiheg_gby� wlbo�`_eZgbc��H^bg� ijbagZd�²� bkiheg_gb_`_eZgby� ²� ihklhyg_g�� ^jm]hc� fh`_l� baf_gylvky�� hg� fh`_l�� \ k\hx� hq_j_^v�� lh`_� [ulv`_eZgb_f�� lZd� qlh� ^g_\gh_� kdjulh_� `_eZgb_� kgh\b^_gb_� ij_^klZ\ey_l� bkiheg_gguf� kihfhsvx�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�`_eZgby�Y \k_�wlh�hq_gv�ohjhrh�ihgbfZx��gh�g_�agZx��m^Zehkv�eb�fg_�k^_eZlv�wlh�ihgylguf�^ey\Zk��AZljm^gyxkv�lZd`_�^hdZaZlv�\Zf�wlh��K h^ghc�klhjhgu��wlh�g_\hafh`gh�[_a�lsZl_evgh]hZgZebaZ�fgh]bo�kgh\b^_gbc��Z k�^jm]hc��g_evay�m[_^bl_evgh�baeh`blv�wlhl�kZfuc�s_dhleb\ucb kZfuc�agZqbl_evguc�imgdl�gZr_]h�ihgbfZgby�kgh\b^_gby��g_�ijb\h^y�_]h�\ k\yav�k l_f��hq_f�[m^_l�j_qv�gb`_��Fh`_l_�eb�\u�\hh[s_�ij_^klZ\blv�k_[_��qlh�ijb�l_kghc�k\yab�\k_o�\_s_cfh`gh�]em[hdh�ijhgbdgmlv�\ ijbjh^m�h^ghc��g_�\f_rZ\rbkv�\ ^jm]b_��koh^ghc�k g_c�ijbjh^u"LZd� dZd�fu� _s_� gbq_]h�g_� agZ_f� h [eb`Zcrbo� jh^kl\_ggbdZo� kgh\b^_gby�� h g_\jhlbq_kdbokbfilhfZo�� lh�b a^_kv�fu� \ugm`^_gu�h]jZgbqblvky�^hklb]gmluf��Y lhevdh� ohqm� jZatykgblv\Zf�_s_�h^bg�ijbf_j�b ijb\_klb�gh\u_�khh[jZ`_gby�<havf_f� hiylv� lh� kZfh_� kgh\b^_gb_� h lj_o� l_ZljZevguo� [be_lZo� aZ� �� ]mev^_g� ��� dj��� ddhlhjhfm�fu�g_h^ghdjZlgh�\ha\jZsZebkv��Fh]m�\Zk�aZ\_jblv��qlh�kgZqZeZ�y \aye�_]h�\ dZq_kl\_ijbf_jZ� [_a� hkh[uo� gZf_j_gbc�� Kdjulu_� fukeb� kgh\b^_gby� \u� agZ_l_�� >hkZ^Z�� qlh� ^ZfZihki_rbeZ� k aZfm`_kl\hf��ihke_� lh]h� dZd� magZeZ�� qlh� __ ih^jm]Z� lhevdh� l_i_jv� h[jmqbeZkv�ij_g_[j_`_gb_� d k\h_fm� fm`m�� fukev�� qlh� hgZ� fh]eZ� [u� bf_lv� emqr_]h�� _keb� [u� lhevdhih^h`^ZeZ��@_eZgb_��kha^Z\r__�kgh\b^_gb_�ba�wlbo�fuke_c��\u�lh`_�agZ_l_�²�wlh�kljZklv�dih^]ey^u\Zgbx��\hafh`ghklv�oh^blv�\ l_Zlj��ijhbkoh^ysZy��ih�\k_c�\_jhylghklb��ba�ij_`g_]h

Page 124: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ex[hiulkl\Z�magZlv�gZdhg_p��qlh�`_�ijhbkoh^bl�� dh]^Z� \uoh^brv� aZfm`��Wlh� ex[hiulkl\h�dZd� ba\_klgh�� m ^_l_c� ihklhyggh� gZijZ\e_gh� gZ� k_dkmZevgmx� `bagv� jh^bl_e_c�� lZd� qlh� hghbgnZglbevgh�� Z ihkdhevdm�ijbkmlkl\m_l�b ^Zevr_�� y\ey_lky�\e_q_gb_f�� moh^ysbf� dhjgyfb� \bgnZglbevgh_��Gh�^ey�ijh[m`^_gby�wlhc�kljZklb�d ih^]ey^u\Zgbx�^g_\gh_�ba\_klb_�g_�[uehih\h^hf��Z \ua\Zeh�lhevdh�^hkZ^m�b kh`Ze_gb_��KgZqZeZ�wlh�`_eZgb_�g_�hlghkbehkv�d kdjuluffukeyf� kgh\b^_gby�� b fu� fh]eb� \dexqblv� j_amevlZl� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby� \ ZgZeba�� g_h[jZsZy�gZ�g_]h�\gbfZgby��>hkZ^Z�kZfZ�ih�k_[_�g_�kihkh[gZ�\ua\Zlv�kgh\b^_gb_��ba�fuke_c©[_kkfuke_ggh�[ueh�lZd�jZgh�\uoh^blv�aZfm`ª�kgh\b^_gb_�g_�fh]eh�h[jZah\Zlvky�jZg__��q_fhgb�ijh[m^beb�ij_`g__�`_eZgb_� magZlv�gZdhg_p��qlh�ijhbkoh^bl�ijb� aZfm`_kl\_��AZl_f� wlh`_eZgb_�h[jZah\Zeh�kh^_j`Zgb_�kgh\b^_gby��aZf_gb\�aZfm`_kl\h�ihk_s_gb_f�l_ZljZ�b ijb^Z\_fm�nhjfm�bkiheg_gby�ij_`g_]h�`_eZgby��\hl��y fh]m�b^lb�\ l_Zlj�b kfhlj_lv�\k_�aZij_s_ggh_�Z lu� g_� fh`_rv�� y aZfm`_f�� Z lu� ^he`gZ� `^Zlv�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� gZklhysZy� kblmZpbyij_\jZlbeZkv� \ k\hx� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv�� ij_`gbc� ljbmfn� [ue� ihklZ\e_g� gZ� f_klh� gh\h]hihjZ`_gby�� F_`^m� ijhqbf�� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� kljZklb� d ih^]ey^u\Zgbx� keb\Z_lky� kw]hbklbq_kdbf� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f� hl� ih[_^u� \ dhgdmj_gpbb�� Wlh� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� hij_^_ey_ly\gh_� kh^_j`Zgb_� kgh\b^_gby�� \ dhlhjhf� hgZ� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� kb^bl� \ l_Zlj_�� Z ih^jm]Z� g_kfh]eZ� ihiZklv�� D wlhc� kblmZpbb� m^h\e_l\hj_gby� \ \b^_� g_ih^oh^ys_c� b g_ihgylghcfh^bnbdZpbb� ijb[Z\e_gu� l_� we_f_glu� kh^_j`Zgby� kgh\b^_gby�� aZ� dhlhjufb� _s_� kijylZgukdjulu_�fukeb�kgh\b^_gby��Ijb�lhedh\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gby�g_�gm`gh�h[jZsZlv�\gbfZgby�gZ�\k_�qlh� kem`bl� bah[jZ`_gbx� bkiheg_gby�`_eZgby�� Z \hkklZgh\blv�fmqbl_evgu_� kdjulu_�fukebkgh\b^_gby����H^gh�khh[jZ`_gb_��dhlhjh_�y ohqm�ijb\_klb��^he`gh�h[jZlblv�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�\klZ\rb_l_i_jv� gZ� i_j\uc� ieZg� kdjulu_� fukeb�� Ijhrm� \Zk� g_� aZ[u\Zlv�� qlh�� \h�i_j\uo�� hgb[_kkhagZl_evgu�� ^ey� \b^_\r_]h� khg�� \h�\lhjuo�� kh\_jr_ggh� jZamfgu� b k\yagu�� lZd� qlh� bo\iheg_�fh`gh�ijbgylv� aZ�ihgylgu_� j_Zdpbb�gZ�ih\h^� kgh\b^_gby�� \�lj_lvbo�� qlh� hgb�fh]mlbf_lv�agZqbfhklv�ex[h]h�^mr_\gh]h�^\b`_gby�beb�bgl_ee_dlmZevghc�hi_jZpbb��Wlb�fukeb�ygZah\m�l_i_jv�kljh`_��q_f�^h�kbo�ihj��©�hklZldZfb�^g_\guo�\i_qZle_gbcª�g_aZ\bkbfh�hl�lh]h�ijbagZ_lky�\ gbo�\b^_\rbc�khg�beb�g_l��L_i_jv�y jZa^_eyx�hklZldb�^g_\guo�\i_qZle_gbc�bkdjulu_� fukeb� kgh\b^_gby�� gZau\Zy� kdjulufb� fukeyfb� \ khhl\_lkl\bb� k gZrbf� ij_`gbfmihlj_[e_gb_f� \k_� lh�� qlh� fu� magZ_f� ba� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby�� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd� hklZldb^g_\guo� \i_qZle_gbc� ²� wlh� lhevdh� qZklv� kdjuluo� fuke_c� kgh\b^_gby�� >Ze__�� kh]eZkghgZr_fm� ihgbfZgbx�� d hklZldZf� ^g_\guo� \i_qZle_gbc� qlh�lh� ijb[Z\ey_lky�� qlh�lhhlghkb\r__ky� lZd`_� d [_kkhagZl_evghfm�� kbevgh_�� gh� \ul_kg_ggh_� `_eZgb_�� b lhevdh� hgh^_eZ_l� \hafh`guf� h[jZah\Zgb_� kgh\b^_gby�� <ebygb_� wlh]h� `_eZgby� gZ� hklZldb� ^g_\guo\i_qZle_gbc�\uau\Z_l�^jm]mx�qZklv�kdjuluo�fuke_c�kgh\b^_gby��lm��dhlhjZy�m`_�g_�dZ`_lkyjZpbhgZevghc�b ihgylghc�ba�`bagb�\ [h^jkl\h\Zgbb�>ey� hlghr_gby� hklZldh\� ^g_\guo� \i_qZle_gbc� d [_kkhagZl_evghfm� `_eZgbx� y\hkihevah\Zeky� kjZ\g_gb_f�� dhlhjh_� fh]m� a^_kv� lhevdh� ih\lhjblv�� <h� \kydhf� ij_^ijbylbbgm`_g�dZiblZebkl��[_jmsbc�gZ�k_[y�jZkoh^u��b ij_^ijbgbfZl_ev��dhlhjuc�bf__l�b^_x�b mf__l__ hkms_kl\blv��< h[jZah\Zgbb� kgh\b^_gby� jhev� dZiblZebklZ� \k_]^Z� b]jZ_l� [_kkhagZl_evgh_`_eZgb_��hgh�hl^Z_l�ikbobq_kdmx�wg_j]bx�^ey�h[jZah\Zgby�kgh\b^_gby��ij_^ijbgbfZl_ev�²hklZlhd�^g_\guo� \i_qZle_gbc�� dhlhjuc� jZkihjy`Z_lky� wlbfb� jZkoh^Zfb��IjZ\^Z�� dZiblZebkl

Page 125: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kZf�fh`_l�bf_lv�b^_x��Z ij_^ijbgbfZl_ev�dZiblZe��Wlh�mijhsZ_l�ijZdlbq_kdmx�kblmZpbx��ghaZljm^gy_l� __ l_hj_lbq_kdh_� ihgbfZgb_�� < gZjh^ghf� ohayckl\_� wlh� h^gh� ebph� \k_]^Z� [m^ml^_eblv�gZ�^\Z�²�dZiblZebklZ�b ij_^ijbgbfZl_ey�²�b \hkklZgh\yl�lm�hkgh\gmx�ihabpbx��badhlhjhc�ijhbahreh�gZr_� kjZ\g_gb_��Ijb� h[jZah\Zgbb� kgh\b^_gby� lh`_� kemqZxlky� lZdb_�`_\ZjbZpbb��ijhke_^blv�dhlhju_�y ij_^hklZ\eyx�\Zf�>Zevr_�fu�k \Zfb�g_�fh`_f�ihclb��ihlhfm�qlh�\u��\_jhylgh��m`_�^Z\gh�aZgylu�\hijhkhf�dhlhjuc� aZkem`b\Z_l� \gbfZgby�� <u� kijZrb\Z_l_�� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� eb� hklZldb� ^g_\guo\i_qZle_gbc� [_kkhagZl_evgu� \ lhf� `_� kfuke_�� qlh� b [_kkhagZl_evgh_� `_eZgb_�� dhlhjh_ijb[Z\ey_lky�� qlh[u� k^_eZlv� bo� kihkh[gufb� kha^Zlv� kgh\b^_gb_"� <Zr_� ij_^iheh`_gb_ijZ\bevgh��A^_kv�kdju\Z_lky�kZfZy�kmlv�\k_]h�^_eZ��Hgb�g_�[_kkhagZl_evgu�\ lhf�`_�kfuke_�@_eZgb_�kgh\b^_gby�hlghkblky�d ^jm]hfm�[_kkhagZl_evghfm��d lhfm��dhlhjh_�fu�ijbagZ_f�aZbgnZglbevgh_�b gZ^_ey_f�hkh[ufb�f_oZgbafZfb��;ueh�[u�\iheg_�mf_klgh�jZa^_eblv�wlb�^\Z\b^Z� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� ^Z\� bf� jZagu_� gZa\Zgby�� Gh� k wlbf� emqr_� ih^h`^Zlv�� ihdZ� fu� g_ihagZdhfbfky� k h[eZklvx� g_\jhah\�� ?keb� m`� aZ� h^gh� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� gZk� mij_dZxl� \nZglZklbqghklb�� lh� qlh�`_� kdZ`ml�gZ�gZr_�ijbagZgb_�� qlh�gZf�g_h[oh^bfu� _s_� b ^\Z� \b^Z[_kkhagZl_evgh]h">Z\Zcl_�a^_kv�hklZgh\bfky��Hiylv�\u�mkeurZeb�lhevdh�h q_f�lh�g_aZdhgq_gghf��gh�jZa\_g_�\gmrZ_l�gZ^_`^m�fukev��qlh�wlb� agZgby�ijb\_^ml�d gh\uf��dhlhju_�ijbh[j_l_f�fu�kZfbbeb�^jm]b_�ihke_�gZk"�: fu�kZfb�jZa\_�g_�magZeb�^hklZlhqgh�gh\h]h�b ihjZabl_evgh]h"IYLG:>P:L:Y�E?DPBYKhfg_gby�b djblbdZM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��Fu�g_�fh`_f�hklZ\blv�h[eZklv�kgh\b^_gby��g_�mihfygm\�hkZfuo�h[uqguo�khfg_gbyo�b dhe_[Zgbyo��\hagbdZxsbo�\ k\yab�k gZrbfb�gh\ufb�\a]ey^Zfb�KZfu_�\gbfZl_evgu_�kemrZl_eb�ba�\Zk�kZfb�kh[jZeb�dh_�dZdhc�fZl_jbZe�ih�wlhfm�ih\h^m����<hafh`gh��m \Zk�keh`behkv�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�j_amevlZlu�gZr_c�jZ[hlu�ih�lhedh\Zgbxkgh\b^_gbc��g_kfhljy�gZ�lsZl_evghklv�l_ogbdb��^himkdZxl�lZd�fgh]h�g_hij_^_e_gghkl_c��qlhk^_eZlv�lhqguc�i_j_\h^�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby�gZ�>yaud@�kdjuluo�_]h�fuke_c�\k_�lZdb�g_�m^Z_lky�< aZsblm�wlh]h�\u�kdZ`_l_��qlh�\h�i_j\uo��gbdh]^Z�g_�ba\_klgh��ke_^m_l�eb�hij_^_e_ggucwe_f_gl� ihgbfZlv� \ _]h� kh[kl\_gghf� kfuke_� beb� kbf\hebq_kdb�� ihlhfm� qlh� \_sb�bkihevah\Zggu_�\ dZq_kl\_�kbf\heh\��ba�aZ�wlh]h�\k_�`_�g_�i_j_klZxl�[ulv�kZfbfb�kh[hc��Gh_keb� g_l� h[t_dlb\gh]h� hkgh\Zgby� ^ey� jZaj_r_gby� ^Zgghc� ijh[e_fu�� lh� \ wlhf� kemqZ_lhedh\Zgb_� aZ\bkbl� hl� ijhba\heZ� lhedh\Zl_ey�� >Ze__�� \ke_^kl\b_� kh\iZ^_gbyijhlb\hiheh`ghkl_c� ijb� jZ[hl_� kgh\b^_gby� dZ`^uc� jZa� hklZ_lky� g_ykguf�� ke_^m_l� ebihgbfZlv�dZdhc�lh�hij_^_e_gguc�we_f_gl�kgh\b^_gby�\ iheh`bl_evghf�beb�hljbpZl_evghf��\ijyfhf� beb� ijhlb\hiheh`ghf� kfuke_�� : wlh� gh\uc� ih\h^� ^ey� ijhy\e_gby� ijhba\heZlhedh\Zl_ey�� <�lj_lvbo�� \ke_^kl\b_� klhev� baex[e_gguo� \ kgh\b^_gbb� bg\_jkbc� lhedh\Zl_ev\he_g�\ ex[hf�f_kl_�kgh\b^_gby�ij_^ijbgylv�lZdmx�bg\_jkbx��GZdhg_p��\u�khre_l_kv�gZ�fhbkeh\Z�� qlh� j_^dh� fh`gh� [ulv� m\_j_gguf� \ lhf�� qlh� gZc^_ggh_� lhedh\Zgb_� _^bgkl\_ggh

Page 126: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\hafh`gh_��<k_]^Z�_klv�hiZkghklv�ijh]ey^_lv�dZdh_�gb[m^v�\iheg_�^himklbfh_�i_j_lhedh\Zgb_lh]h� `_� kgh\b^_gby�� Ijb� lZdbo� h[klhyl_evkl\Zo�� aZdexqbl_� \u�� ijhba\hem� lhedh\Zl_eyhldju\Z_lky� lZdh_� ihe_� ^_yl_evghklb�� rbjhlZ� dhlhjh]h�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� g_kh\f_klbfZ� kh[t_dlb\ghc�gZ^_`ghklvx�j_amevlZlh\��Beb�`_�\u�fh`_l_�ij_^iheh`blv��qlh�^_eh�\h\k_�g_�\kgh\b^_gbb�� gh� qlh� g_^hklZldb� gZr_]h� lhedh\Zgby� h[tykgyxlky� g_ijZ\bevghklvx� gZrbo\a]ey^h\�b bkoh^guo�ij_^ihkuehd�<_kv�\Zr�fZl_jbZe��[_amkeh\gh��ohjhr��gh�y iheZ]Zx��qlh�hg�g_�hijZ\^u\Z_l�^\mo�\ZrboaZdexq_gbc�� h lhf�� qlh� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc�� dZd� fu� bo� ijh\h^bf�� ij_^hklZ\e_guijhba\hem�� b h� lhf�� qlh� batygu� ihemq_gguo� j_amevlZlh\� klZ\yl� ih^� \hijhk� ijZ\hf_jghklvgZr_]h� f_lh^Z�� ?keb� ih^� ijhba\hehf� lhedh\Zl_ey� \u� [m^_l_� ihgbfZlv� _]h� eh\dhklv�� hiul�ihgyleb\hklv�� lh� y k� \Zfb� kh]eZrmkv�� hl� lZdbo� ebqguo� hkh[_gghkl_c� fu� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� g_fh`_f�hldZaZlvky��l_f�[he__�ijb�j_r_gbb�ljm^ghc�aZ^Zqb�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc��Gh�\_^v�b \^jm]bo� h[eZklyo� gZmdb� g_� bgZq_��G_l� kj_^kl\Z� ihf_rZlv� lhfm�� qlh[u� h^bg� \eZ^_e� dZdhc�lhhij_^_e_gghc� l_ogbdhc� g_� om`_� ^jm]h]h� beb� g_� fh]� emqr_� __ bkihevah\Zlv�� HklZevgh_�ijhba\h^ys__� \i_qZle_gb_�ijhba\heZ��gZijbf_j��ijb� lhedh\Zgbb� kbf\heh\�� mkljZgy_lky� l_f�qlh�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� k\yav� fuke_c� kgh\b^_gby� f_`^m� kh[hc�� k\yav� kgh\b^_gby� k `bagvx\b^_\r_]h� khg� b \ky� ikbobq_kdZy� kblmZpby�� \ dhlhjhc� kgh\b^_gb_� ijhbkoh^bl�� aZklZ\eyxl\u[jZlv�ba�^Zgguo�\hafh`guo� lhedh\Zgbc�h^gh��Z hklZevgu_�hldehgblv�dZd�g_ijb]h^gu_��:aZdexq_gb_� h g_ijZ\bevghklb� gZr_c� mklZgh\db�� hkgh\Zggh_� gZ� g_dhlhjuo� g_kh\_jr_gkl\Zolhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc��hijh\_j]Z_lky�aZf_qZgb_f��qlh�fgh]hagZqghklv�beb�g_hij_^_e_gghklvkgh\b^_gby�y\ey_lky�_]h�g_h[oh^bfuf�k\hckl\hf��\iheg_�hl\_qZxsbf�gZrbf�h`b^Zgbyf�<kihfgbf�h gZr_f�ml\_j`^_gbb��qlh�jZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby�i_j_\h^bl�fukeb�kgh\b^_gby�\ijbfblb\gmx� nhjfm� \ujZ`_gby�� ZgZeh]bqgmx� ibkvfm� ijb� ihfhsb� jbkmgdh\�� Gh� \k_� wlbijbfblb\gu_� kbkl_fu� \ujZ`_gby� klhev�`_�g_hij_^_e_ggu�b ^\mkfuke_ggu�� ohly� m gZk� g_lgbdZdh]h� khfg_gby� \ bo� ijb]h^ghklb� d ^Zgghfm� mihlj_[e_gbx�� <u� agZ_l_�� qlh� kh\iZ^_gb_ijhlb\hiheh`ghkl_c�ijb�jZ[hl_�kgh\b^_gby�ZgZeh]bqgh�lZd�gZau\Z_fhfm�©ijhlb\hiheh`ghfmkfukem�i_j\hgZqZevguo�keh\ª�\ ^j_\g_crbo�yaudZo��Ebg]\bkl�D��:[_ev� ��������dhlhjhfm�fuh[yaZgu� wlbf� ij_^klZ\e_gb_f�� ij_^mij_`^Z_l� gZk�� qlh[u� fu� g_� ^mfZeb�� qlh� khh[s_gb_�k^_eZggh_� ijb� ihfhsb� lZdbo� Zf[b\Ze_glguo� keh\�� [ueh� ^\mkfuke_g� guf�� Lhg� j_qb� bkhijh\h`^Zxsbc� __ `_kl� ^he`gu� [ueb� ykgh� ihdZaZlv�� dZdh_� ba� ^\mo� ijhlb\hiheh`guoagZq_gbc� ]h\hjysbc� bf_e� \ \b^m�� GZ� ibkvf_�� ]^_� `_kl� hlkmlkl\m_l�� hgb� aZf_gyebkv^hihegbl_evguf�� g_h[yaZl_evguf� ^ey� ijhbaghr_gby� jbkmgdhf�agZdhf�� gZijbf_jbah[jZ`_gb_f� [_kkbevgh� himklb\r_]hky� gZ� dhjlhqdb� beb� ijyfh� kb^ys_]h� q_eh\_qdZ� \aZ\bkbfhklb�hl�lh]h��hagZqZ_l�eb�^\mkfuke_ggh_�NHQ�b_jh]ebnbq_kdh]h�ibkvfZ�©keZ[ucª�beb©kbevgucª�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� g_kfhljy� gZ� fgh]hagZqghklv� a\mdh\� b agZdh\�� g_^hjZamf_gb_mkljZgyehkv�>j_vjb_� kbkl_fu� \ujZ`_gby�� gZijbf_j� ibkvf_gghklv� ^j_\g_crbo� yaudh\�� ^Zxl� gZfij_^klZ\e_gb_� h g_dhlhjuo� g_hij_^_e_gghklyo�� dhlhjuo� fu� g_� ihl_ji_eb� [u� \ gZr_ckh\j_f_gghc� ibkvf_gghklb�� LZd�� \ g_dhlhjuo� k_fblkdbo� yaudZo� gZ� ibkvf_� h[hagZqZxlkylhevdh�kh]eZkgu_�keh\��Ijhims_ggu_�]eZkgu_�qblZxsbc�^he`_g�\klZ\eylv�khh[jZagh�k\h_fmagZgbx� b ih� dhgl_dklm�� G_� kh\k_f� lZd�� gh� hq_gv� ihoh`_� ijhbkoh^bl� \ b_jh]ebnbq_kdhc

Page 127: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ibkvf_gghklb�� ihwlhfm� ijhbaghr_gb_� _]bi_lkdh]h� yaudZ� hklZehkv� gZf� g_ba\_klguf�K\ys_ggh_�ibkvfh�_]bilyg�bf__l�_s_�b ^jm]mx�g_hij_^_e_gghklv��LZd��gZijbf_j��ibrmsbcfh`_l� ijhba\hevgh� jZkiheZ]Zlv� jbkmgdb� kijZ\Z� gZe_\h� beb� ke_\Z� gZijZ\h�� Qlh[u� qblZlv�gm`gh�kh[ex^Zlv�ijZ\beh�ql_gby�\ lm�klhjhgm��dm^Z�h[jZs_gu�kbemwlu�nb]mj��ilbp�b l��i��Ghibrmsbc�fh]�jZkiheZ]Zlv�jbkmgdb�b ih�\_jlbdZeb��Z ijb�gZ^ibkyo�iZ�g_[hevrbo�h[t_dlZo�hgiha\heye� k_[_� baf_gblv� ihke_^h\Zl_evghklv� agZdh\� ih� wkl_lbq_kdbf� khh[jZ`_gbyf� b ^eyaZiheg_gby� ijhkljZgkl\Z��Gh� [he__� \k_]h� V� b_jh]ebnbq_kdhf� ibkvf_� aZljm^gy_l� hlkmlkl\b_jZa^_e_gby�keh\��Jbkmgdb�jZkiheh`_gu�\ kljhd_�gZ�h^bgZdh\hf�jZkklhygbb�^jm]�hl�^jm]Z��b \h[s_f�g_evay�magZlv��hlghkblky�eb�agZd�d ij_^u^ms_fm�keh\m�beb�y\ey_lky�gZqZehf�gh\h]h��<i_jkb^kdhc�debghibkb��gZijhlb\��dhkhc�debg�kem`bl�jZa^_ebl_e_f�keh\�;_amkeh\gh�^j_\gb_��gh�mihlj_[ey_fu_�b k_]h^gy�����fbeebhgZfb�yaud�b ibkvf_gghklv�²dblZckdb_��G_�^mfZcl_��qlh�y bo�agZx��y lhevdh�hk\_^hfbeky�h gbo��gZ^_ykv�gZclb�ZgZeh]bb�kg_hij_^_e_gghklyfb� kgh\b^_gby��B fh_� h`b^Zgb_�f_gy�g_�h[fZgmeh��DblZckdbc� yaud�ihehglZdbo� g_hij_^_e_gghkl_c�� qlh� hgb� fh]ml� \gmrblv� gZf� m`Zk�� DZd� ba\_klgh�� hg� khklhbl� badZdh]h�lh� qbkeZ� keh]h\uo� a\mdh\�� dhlhju_� ijhbaghkylky� hl^_evgh� beb� \ khq_lZgbb� ba� ^\mo�H^bg�ba�hkgh\guo�^bZe_dlh\�kh^_j`bl�hdheh�����lZdbo�a\mdh\��LZd�dZd�keh\Zjv�wlh]h�^bZe_dlZgZkqblu\Z_l� ijbf_jgh� ����� keh\�� ihemqZ_lky�� qlh� dZ`^uc� a\md� \ kj_^g_f� bf__l� ^_kylvjZaebqguo� agZq_gbc�� g_dhlhju_� ba� gbo�f_gvr_�� gh� ^jm]b_� aZlh� _s_� [hevr_��>Ze__� bf__lkyp_euc� jy^� kj_^kl\�� qlh[u� ba[_`Zlv� fgh]hagZqghklb�� lZd� dZd� lhevdh� ih� dhgl_dklm� g_evay^h]Z^Zlvky��dZdh_�ba�^_kylb�agZq_gbc�keh]h\h]h�a\mdZ�]h\hjysbc�ij_^eZ]Z_l�kemrZl_ex��Kj_^bgbo�²� kh_^bg_gb_�^\mo� a\mdh\� \ h^gh� khklZ\gh_� keh\h�b bkihevah\Zgb_� q_luj_o� jZaebqguo©lhih\ª��\ khijh\h`^_gbb�dhlhjuo�wlb�keh]b�ijhbaghkylky��>ey�gZr_]h�kjZ\g_gby�bgl_j_kgh_s_�lh�h[klhyl_evkl\h��qlh�\ wlhf�yaud_�ihqlb�g_l�]jZffZlbdb��Gb�h[�h^ghf�ba�h^ghkeh`guokeh\�g_evay�kdZaZlv��kms_kl\bl_evgh_�eb�wlh��]eZ]he��ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_��b g_l�gbdZdbo�baf_g_gbckeh\��ih�dhlhjuf�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�magZlv�jh^��qbkeh��hdhgqZgb_��\j_fy�beb�gZdehg_gb_��LZdbfh[jZahf��yaud�khklhbl��lZd�kdZaZlv��lhevdh�ba�kujh]h�fZl_jbZeZ��ih^h[gh�lhfm��dZd�gZr�yaudfuke_c�jZaeZ]Z_lky�[eZ]h^Zjy�jZ[hl_�kgh\b^_gby��mkljZgyxs_c�\ujZ`_gb_�hlghr_gbc��gZ�_]hkujhc� fZl_jbZe�� < dblZckdhf� yaud_� \h� \k_o� lZdbo� g_hij_^_e_gguo� kemqZyo� j_r_gb_ij_^hklZ\ey_lky� kemrZl_ex�� dhlhjuc� jmdh\h^kl\m_lky� ijb� wlhf� h[sbf� kfukehf��Y aZibkZek_[_�ijbf_j�h^ghc�dblZckdhc�ih]h\hjdb��dhlhjZy�\ ^hkeh\ghf�i_j_\h^_�]eZkbl�FZeh�qlh�\b^_lv��fgh]h�qlh�m^b\bl_evgh�?_� g_ljm^gh� ihgylv�� HgZ� fh`_l� hagZqZlv�� q_f� f_gvr_� dlh�lh� \b^_e�� l_f� [hevr_� hggZoh^bl� m^b\bl_evgh]h�beb�fgh]h� _klv� q_fm�ih^b\blvky�^ey� lh]h�� dlh�fZeh� \b^_e��JZaebqb_f_`^m� wlbfb� lhevdh� ]jZffZlbq_kdb� jZagufb� i_j_\h^Zfb�� jZamf__lky�� g_� ijbgbfZ_lky� \h\gbfZgb_�� G_kfhljy� gZ� wlb� g_hij_^_e_gghklb�� dblZckdbc� yaud�� dZd� gZk� m\_jyxl�� y\ey_lkyij_djZkguf� kj_^kl\hf� \ujZ`_gby� fuke_c�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� g_hij_^_e_gghklv� g_h[yaZl_evgh^he`gZ�\_klb�d fgh]hagZqghklb�H^gZdh�fu�^he`gu�ijbagZlvky��qlh�\ kbkl_f_�\ujZ`_gby�kgh\b^_gbc�\k_� ]hjZa^h�f_g__[eZ]hijbylgh�� q_f� \h� \k_o� wlbo� ^j_\gbo� yaudZo� b ibkvf_gghklyo��Ihlhfm� qlh� ihke_^gb_� \hkgh\_� k\h_c� \k_�lZdb� ij_^gZagZq_gu� ^ey� khh[s_gby�� l�� _�� jZkkqblZgu� gZ� lh�� qlh[u� [ulvihgylufb� dZdbfb� m]h^gh� imlyfb� b k� bkihevah\Zgb_f� ex[uo� \kihfh]Zl_evguo� kj_^kl\�� Gh

Page 128: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

bf_ggh�wlZ�q_jlZ�m kgh\b^_gby�hlkmlkl\m_l��Kgh\b^_gb_�gbdhfm�gbq_]h�g_�ohq_l�]h\hjblv��hghg_�y\ey_lky�kj_^kl\hf�khh[s_gby��gZh[hjhl��hgh�jZkkqblZgh�gZ�lh��qlh[u�hklZlvky�g_ihgyluf�Ihwlhfm�fu�g_�^he`gu�[ueb�[u�m^b\eylvky�b kfmsZlvky��_keb�hdZaZehkv��qlh�dZdh_�lh�qbkehfgh]hagZqghkl_c�b g_hij_^_e_gghkl_c� kgh\b^_gby� g_� ih^^Z_lky� jZatykg_gbx��G_khfg_ggufj_amevlZlhf�gZr_]h�kjZ\g_gby�hklZg_lky�lhevdh�lh�m[_`^_gb_��qlh�lZdb_�g_hij_^_e_gghklb��ba�aZ� dhlhjuo� ohl_eb� ihklZ\blv� ih^� khfg_gb_� hkgh\Zl_evghklv� gZrbo� lhedh\Zgbc� kgh\b^_gbc�y\eyxlky�ihklhyggufb�oZjZdl_jgufb�q_jlZfb�\k_o�ijbfblb\guo�kbkl_f�\ujZ`_gby�Lhevdh� hiul� b ijZdlbdZ� fh]ml� mklZgh\blv�� gZkdhevdh� ]em[hdbf� fh`_l� [ulv� \^_ckl\bl_evghklb� ihgbfZgb_� kgh\b^_gby�� Y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� hq_gv� ]em[hdbf�� b kjZ\g_gb_j_amevlZlh\�� dhlhju_� ihemqZxl� ijZ\bevgh� h[mq_g� gu_� ZgZeblbdb�� ih^l\_j`^Z_l� fhx� lhqdmaj_gby��RbjhdZy�im[ebdZ�^be_lZglh\��^Z`_�gZmqguo��gZoh^bl�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�\ lhf��qlh�i_j_^ebphf�ljm^ghkl_c�b g_m\_j_gghklb�\ gZmqghc�jZ[hl_�o\ZklZ_l�\ukhdhf_jguf�kd_ilbpbafhf��Y^mfZx��qlh� hgb�g_�ijZ\u��Fh`_l�[ulv��g_� \k_f� \Zf�ba\_klgh��qlh�ih^h[gZy� kblmZpby�bf_eZf_klh�\ bklhjbb�jZkrdnjh\db�Zkkbjh�\Z\behgkdbo�gZ^ibk_c��;ueh�\j_fy��dh]^Z�h[s_kl\_ggh_fg_gb_� aZoh^beh� lZd� ^Ze_dh�� qlh� kqblZeh� jZkrbnjh\sbdh\� debghibkb� nZglZa_jZfb�� Zbkke_^h\Zgb_� h[ty\e_gh� ©rZjeZlZgkl\hfª�� Gh� \ ����� ]�� Dhjhe_\� kdh_� ZabZlkdh_� h[s_kl\hijhba\_eh� j_rZxsmx� ijh\_jdm�� Hgh� ij_^eh`b� eh� q_luj_f� kZfuf� \b^guf� bkke_^h\Zl_eyfdebghibkb� ²� Jhmebgkhgm�� Obgdkm�� LZev[hlm� b Hii_jlm� ²� \ukeZlv� _fm� \ aZi_qZlZgghfdhg\_jl_� g_aZ\bkbfu_� i_j_\h^u� \gh\v� gZc^_gguo� gZ^ibk_c� b ihke_� kjZ\g_gby� q_luj_oi_j_\h^h\�kfh]eh�h[ty\blv��qlh�bo�koh^kl\h�^hklZlhqgh�\_ebdh��qlh�hgh�hijZ\^u\Z_l�^h\_jb_�dm`_� ^hklb]gmlhfm� b ^Z_l� m\_j_gghklv� \ ^Zevg_crbo� mki_oZo�� GZkf_rdb� mq_guo�g_ki_pbZebklh\� aZl_f� ihkl_i_ggh� ij_djZlbebkv�� Z m\_j_gghklv� ijb� ql_gbb� debghibkguo^hdmf_glh\�k l_o�ihj�qj_a\uqZcgh�\hajhkeZ����<lhjhc�jy^�khfg_gbc�l_kgh�k\yaZg�k \i_qZle_gb_f��hl�dhlhjh]h��fh`_l�[ulv��g_�\iheg_k\h[h^gu� b \u�� qlh� qZklv� \ZjbZglh\� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc�� dhlhju_� fu� \ugm`^_guij_^eh`blv�� dZ`mlky� gZlygmlufb�� bkdmkkl\_ggufb�� ijblygmlufb� aZ� \hehku�� l�� _�gZkbevkl\_ggufb� beb� ^Z`_� kf_rgufb� b ihoh`bfb� gZ� g_m^Zqgmx� hkljhlm�� LZdb_� aZy\e_gbygZklhevdh� qZklu�� qlh� y \havfm� gZm]Z^� ihke_^g__�� ba\_klgh_�fg_��BlZd�� kemrZcl_�� g_^Z\gh� \k\h[h^ghc� R\_cpZjbb� h^bg� ^bj_dlhj� k_fbgZjbb� [ue� ebr_g� k\h_]h� f_klZ� ba�aZ� lh]h�� qlhaZgbfZeky� ikb?hZgZebahf�� Hg� \ujZ� abe� ijhl_kl�� b h^gZ� [_jgkdZy� ]Za_lZ� him[ebdh\ZeZoZjZdl_jbklbdm� rdhevguo� \eZkl_c� h g_f�� Ba� wlh]h� ^hdmf_glZ� y ijb\h`m� g_kdhevdhij_^eh`_gbc�� hlghkysboky� d ikbohZgZebam�� ©^Ze__� ihjZ`Z_l� ij_l_gpbhaghklv� bbkdmkkl\_gghklv�\h�fgh]bo�ijbf_jZo��dhlhju_�bf_xlky�\ ijb\_^_gghc�dgb]_�^�jZ�Inbkl_jZ�baPxjboZ����IhjZ`Z_l��kh[kl\_ggh��lh��qlh�^bj_dlhj� k_fbgZjbb�[_a�djblbdb�ijbgbfZ_l�\k_� wlbml\_j`^_gby� b ik_\^h^hdZaZl_evkl\Zª�� Wlb� njZau� \u^Zxlky� aZ� j_r_gb_� ©[_kijbkljZklgh]hkm^vbª�� Y ^mfZx�� qlh� ©bkdmkkl\_gghª� kdhj__� wlh� [_kijbkljZklb_�� Ijbf_f� wlb� aZy\e_gby� kfukevx�� qlh� ^Z`_� ijb� [_kijbkljZklghf� km`^_gbb� g_� f_rZ_l� ih^mfZlv� b [ulv� g_fgh]hagZdhfuf�k ^_ehf�>_ckl\bl_evgh�� ijbylgh� \b^_lv�� dZd� [ukljh� b [_ahrb[hqgh� dlh�lh�fh`_l� jZah[jZlvky� \lZdhf� aZimlZgghf� \hijhk_� ]em[bgghc� ikboheh]bb�� bkoh^y� ba� k\hbo� i_j\uo� \i_qZle_gbc�Lhedh\Zgby� dZ`mlky� _fm� gZ^mfZg� gufb� b gZ\yaZggufb�� hgb� _fm� g_� gjZ\ylky�� agZqbl�� hgb

Page 129: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_ijZ\bevgu��gbdm^Z�g_�]h^ylky��b _fm�^Z`_�kemqZcgh�g_�ijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m�fukev�h ^jm]hc\hafh`ghklb��h lhf��qlh�wlb�lhedh\Zgby�bf_xl�\_kdb_�hkgh\Zgby��\ k\yab�k q_f�\hagbdZ_l�m`_ke_^mxsbc�\hijhk��dZdh\u�`_�wlb�\_kdb_�hkgh\Zgby�H[km`^Z_fuc�nZdl��\ kmsghklb��bf__l�hlghr_gb_�d j_amevlZlZf�kf_s_gby��dhlhjh_�\Zfba\_klgh� dZd� kZfh_� kbevgh_� kj_^kl\h� p_gamju� kgh\b^_gby�� K ihfhsvx� kf_s_gby� p_gamjZkgh\b^_gby�kha^Z_l�aZf_klbl_e_c��dhlhju_�fu�gZa\Zeb�gZf_dZfb��Gh�wlh�gZf_db��dhlhju_�kZfbih�k_[_�g_�lZd�lh�e_]dh�magZxlky��h[jZlguc�imlv�hl�gbo�d kh[kl\_gghfm�kh^_j`Zgbx�g_e_]dhgZclb��b hgb�k\yaZgu�k wlbf�ihke_^gbf�kZfufb�kljZggufb��ijZdlbq_kdb�g_�\klj_qZxsbfbky\g_rgbfb�ZkkhpbZpbyfb��Gh�\h�\k_o� wlbo�kemqZyo�j_qv�b^_l�h \_sZo��dhlhju_�^he`gu�[ulvkdjulufb��^he`gu�hklZ\Zlvky�\ lZcg_��\_^v�d wlhfm�klj_fblky�p_gamjZ�kgh\b^_gby��G_evay�`_h`b^Zlv�� qlh� kijylZggh_� gZc^_lky� \ f_kl_�� ]^_� _fm� h[uqgh� b iheZ]Z_lky� gZoh^blvky�>_ckl\mxsb_� k_]h^gy� ih]jZgbqgu_� dhfbkkbb� \ wlhf� hlghr_gbb� oblj__�� q_f� r\_cpZjkdb_rdhevgu_� \eZklb�� < ihbkdZo� ^hdmf_glh\� b aZibk_c� hgb� g_� ^h\hevkl\mxlky� ijhkfhljhfihjln_e_c� b dZjfZgh\�� gh� kqblZxlky� k \hafh`ghklvx�� qlh� ribhgu� b i_j_[_`qbdb� fh]mlghkblv�lZdb_�aZij_s_ggu_�\_sb�\ kZfuo�ihlZcguo�f_klZo�k\h_c�h^_`^u��]^_�bf��[_amkeh\gh�g_�f_klh��gZijbf_j��f_`^m�^\hcgufb�ih^hr\Zfb�kZih]��?keb�kdjulu_�\_sb�gZc^_gu�lZf��lhbo��\h�\kydhf�kemqZ_��g_�lhevdh�wg_j]bqgh�bkdZeb��gh�lZd`_�b gZreb�?keb� fu� ijbagZ_f� \hafh`ghklv� kZfuo� hl^Ze_gguo�� kZfuo� kljZgguo�� dZ`msboky� lhkf_rgufb�� lh� hkljhmfgufb� k\ya_c� f_`^m� dZdbf�lh� kdjuluf� we_f_glhf� kgh\b^_gby� b _]hy\guf�aZf_klbl_e_f��lh�hibjZ_fky�ijb�wlhf�gZ�[h]Zluc�hiul�ijbf_jh\��jZatykg_gb_�dhlhjuofu��dZd�ijZ\beh��ihemqbeb�g_�kZfb��QZklh�ijhklh�g_\hafh`gh�^Z\Zlv�lZdb_�lhedh\Zgby�kZfhfm�gb h^bg� jZamfguc� q_eh\_d� g_� fh]� [u� ^h]Z^Zlvky� h[� bf_xs_cky� k\yab�� I_j_\h^� ^Z_l� gZf\b^_\rbc� khg� eb[h� kjZam�[eZ]h^Zjy�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�ijbr_^r_c� _fm� \ ]heh\m�fukeb�²� hg\_^v�fh`_l�wlh�k^_eZlv��ihlhfm�qlh�m g_]h�b \hagbd�wlhl�aZf_klbl_ev�²�eb[h�hg�ij_^hklZ\ey_lgZf� klhevdh�fZl_jbZeZ�� qlh� lhedh\Zgb_� m`_�g_� lj_[m_l� hkh[h]h� hkljhmfby�� Z gZijZrb\Z_lkykZfh� kh[hc�� ?keb� `_� \b^_\rbc� khg� g_� ihfh]Z_l� gZf� wlbfb� ^\mfy� kihkh[Zfb�� lhkhhl\_lkl\mxsbc� y\vuc� we_f_gl� lZd� b hklZ_lky� gZ\k_]^Z� g_ihgylguf� ^ey� gZk�� Iha\hevl_jZkkdZaZlv� \Zf� _s_� h^bg� lZdhc� ijbf_j�� dhlhjuc� fg_� g_^Z\gh� \klj_lbeky�� H^gZ� ba� fhboiZpb_glhd� \h� \j_fy� e_q_gby� ihl_jyeZ� hlpZ�� K l_o� ihj� hgZ� bkihevam_l� ex[hc� ih\h^�� qlh[u\hkdj_kblv�_]h�\h�kg_��< h^ghf�ba�__�kgh\b^_gbc�hl_p�ihy\ey_lky�\ hij_^_e_gghc��g_�bf_xs_chkh[h]h�agZq_gby�k\yab�b ]h\hjbl��l_i_jv�q_l\_jlv�^\_gZ^pZlh]h��iheh\bgZ�^\_gZ^pZlh]h��ljbq_l\_jlb�^\_gZ^pZlh]h��Ijb�lhedh\Zgbb�wlhc�kljZgghklb�_c�ijbreZ�\ ]heh\m�lhevdh�lZ�fukev�qlh� hl_p� [u\Ze� ^h\he_g�� dh]^Z� \ajhkeu_� ^_lb� ZddmjZlgh� y\eyebkv� d h[s_fm� klhem�� Wlh�dhg_qgh��[ueh�k\yaZgh�k we_f_glhf�kgh\b^_gby��gh�g_�iha\heyeh�k^_eZlv�gbdZdh]h�aZdexq_gbyh _]h�ijhbkoh`^_gbb��;ueh�ih^haj_gb_�� h[mkeh\e_ggh_� lh]^Zrg_c� kblmZpb_c� e_q_gby�� qlh� \wlhf� kgh\b^_gbb� ijbgbfZeh� mqZklb_� lsZl_evgh� ih^Z\ey_fh_� djblbq_kdh_� khijhlb\e_gb_ex[bfhfm�b ihqblZ_fhfm�hlpm��H ihke_^mxs_f�oh^_�\hagbdZxsbo�m g__�fuke_c��dZd�[m^lh�[ukh\k_f�hl^Zeb\rboky�hl�kgh\b^_gby��\b^_\rZy�khg�jZkkdZau\Z_l��qlh�\q_jZ�\ __�ijbkmlkl\bbfgh]h� ]h\hjbehkv� h ikboheh]bb�� b h^bg� jh^kl\_ggbd� \ukdZaZe� aZf_qZgb_�� \h� \k_o� gZkijh^he`Z_l� `blv� i_j\h[ulguc� q_eh\_d� �8UPHQVFK��� L_i_jv� gZf� \k_� ihgylgh�� Wlh� ^Zeh� _cij_djZkguc�ih\h^� _s_� jZa� \hkdj_kblv� mf_jr_]h� hlpZ��< kgh\b^_gbb� hgZ� k^_eZeZ� _]h�� lZdbfh[jZahf�� q_eh\_dhf��`b\msbf� ih� qZkZf� �8KUPHQVFK`�� aZklZ\b\� _]h� h[ty\eylv� q_l\_jlb� qZkZ

Page 130: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ihihem^gb�< wlhf� ijbf_j_� \u� g_� fh`_l_� g_� aZf_lblv� koh^kl\Z� k hkljhlhc�� b ^_ckl\bl_evgh^hklZlhqgh� qZklh� kemqZ_lky� lZd�� qlh� hkljhlm� \b^_\r_]h� khg� ijbgbfZxl� aZ� hkljhmfb_lhedh\Zl_ey��?klv�b ^jm]b_�ijbf_ju��dh]^Z�kh\k_f�g_�e_]dh�j_rblv��bf__rv�eb�^_eh�k hkljhlhcbeb�kh�kgh\b^_gb_f��Gh�\u�ihfgbl_��qlh�bf_ggh�lZdh_�khfg_gb_�ihy\behkv�m gZk�ijb�ZgZeba_g_dhlhjuo�h]h\hjhd��H^bg�fm`qbgZ�jZkkdZau\Z_l��qlh�_fm�kgbehkv��[m^lh�_]h�^y^y�ihp_eh\Ze_]h�� dh]^Z� hgb� kb^_eb� \ _]h� Z\lh�fh[be_�� �$XWR��� Hg� kjZam� `_� ijb[Z\ey_l� lhedh\Zgb_�� WlhagZqbl�Zmlhwjhlbaf��$XWRHURWLVPXV���l_jfbg�ba�l_hjbb�eb[b^h��hagZqZxsbc�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�[_aihklhjhgg_]h� h[t_dlZ��� G_� iha\hebe� eb� k_[_� wlhl� q_eh\_d� k gZfb� rmldm� b g_� \u^Ze� ebihgjZ\b\rmxky�_fm�hkljhlm�aZ�kgh\b^_gb_"�Y ^mfZx��qlh�g_l��hg�^_ckl\bl_evgh�m\b^_e�lZdhckhg�� Gh� hldm^Z� [_j_lky� wlh� ihjZabl_evgh_� koh^kl\h"� < k\h_� \j_fy� wlhl� \hijhk� m\_e� f_gyg_fgh]h� \ klhjhgm� hl� fh_]h� imlb�� ihklZ\b\� i_j_^� g_h[oh^bfhklvx� bkke_^h\Zlv� kZfhhkljhmfb_��Ijb� wlhf� h[gZjm`behkv�� qlh� ^ey� \hagbdgh\_gby� hkljhlu� ij_^�khagZl_evguc� oh^fuke_c�ih^\_j]Z_lky�[_kkhagZl_evghc�h[jZ[hld_��ihke_�dhlhjhc�hg�ihy\ey_lky�\ \b^_�hkljhlu�Ih^� \ebygb_f� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� wlb� fukeb� ih^\_j]Zxlky� \ha^_ckl\bx� ]hkih^kl\mxsbo� lZff_oZgbafh\� k]ms_gby� b kf_s_gby�� l�� _�� l_o� `_� ijhp_kkh\�� dhlhju_�� dZd� fu� h[gZjm`beb�mqZkl\mxl� \ jZ[hl_� kgh\b^_gby�� b \� wlhc� h[sghklb� ke_^m_l� bkdZlv� bklhqgbd� koh^kl\Zhkljhmfby� b kgh\b^_gby� lZf�� ]^_� hgh� bf__l� f_klh�� Gh� g_ij_^gZf_j_ggh_� ©hkljhmfb_kgh\b^_gbyª� g_� ^hklZ\ey_l� gZf� gbdZdh]h� m^h\hevkl\by�� Ihq_fm�� \u� fh`_l_� magZlv�m]em[b\rbkv� \ bamq_gb_� hkljhmfby�� ©Hkljhmfb_� kgh\b^_gbyª� dZ`_lky� gZf� g_m^Zqgufhkljhmfb_f��hgh�g_�\uau\Z_l�kf_oZ��hklZ\ey_l�gZk�jZ\gh^mrgufb�Ijb�wlhf�fu�b^_f�ih�klhiZf�Zglbqgh]h�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc��hklZ\b\r_]h�gZf�gZjy^mkh� fgh]bf� [_kihe_aguf� g_dhlhju_� ohjhrb_� ijbf_ju� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc�� K_cqZk� yjZkkdZ`m�\Zf�bklhjbq_kdb�\Z`gh_�kgh\b^_gb_�:e_dkZg^jZ�FZd_^hgkdh]h��h dhlhjhf�khh[sZxlk g_dhlhjufb�baf_g_gbyfb�IemlZjo� b :jl_fb^hj�ba�>Ze^bkZ��Dh]^Z� pZjv� [vi� aZgyl� hkZ^hchlqZyggh� aZsbsZ\r_]hky� ]hjh^Z�LbjZ� �����]��^h�J��;����hg�m\b^_e�dZd�lh�\h�kg_� lZgpmxs_]hkZlbjZ�� Lhedh\Zl_ev� kgh\b^_gbc� :jbklZg^j�� gZoh^b\rbcky� ijb� \hckd_�� bklhedh\Ze� wlhkgh\b^_gb_�� jZaeh`b\� keh\h� kZlbj� gZ� ZZ 7XSRJ� >l\hc� Lbj@� b ihwlhfm� h[_sZe� :e_dkZg^jmih[_^m�gZ^�]hjh^hf��Ih^�\ebygb_f�lhedh\Zgby�:e_dkZg^j�ijh^he`be�hkZ^m�b \�dhgp_�dhgph\\aye� Lbj�� Lhedh\Zgb_�� dhlhjh_� \u]ey^bl� ^hklZlhqgh� bkdmkkl\_gguf�� [ueh�� g_khfg_ggh�ijZ\bevguf����Fh]m� k_[_� ij_^klZ\blv�� dZdh_� hkh[h_� \i_qZle_gb_� ijhba\_^_l� gZ� \Zk� khh[s_gb_�� qlhijhlb\�gZr_]h�ihgbfZgby�kgh\b^_gby�\hajZ`Zeb�b l_�ebpZ��dhlhju_�kZfb�dZd�ikbohZgZeblbdb^he]h_�\j_fy�aZgbfZebkv�lhedh\Zgb_f�kgh\b^_gbc��;ueh�[u�kebrdhf�g_h[udgh\_gguf��_keb[u� lZdhc� ih\h^� d gh\uf� aZ[em`^_gbyf� hklZeky� g_bkihevah\Zgguf�� lZd� qlh� ba�aZ� imlZgbpuihgylbc�b g_hijZ\^Zgguo�h[h[s_gbc�\hagbdeb�[u�ml\_j`^_gby��dhlhju_�ih�g_ijZ\bevghklbg_gZfgh]h� mklmiZeb� ihgbfZgbx� kgh\b^_gbc� \ f_^bpbg_�� H^gh� ba� gbo� \u� m`_� agZ_l_�� HghaZy\ey_l��qlh�kgh\b^_gb_�iulZ_lky�ijbkihkh[blvky�d gZklhys_fm�b j_rblv�aZ^Zqb�[m^ms_]h��l�_�� ij_ke_^m_l� ©ijhki_dlb\gmx� l_g^_gpbxª� �0DHGHU�� ������� Fu� m`_� mdZaZeb�� qlh� wlhml\_j`^_gb_�hkgh\Zgh�gZ�ih^f_g_�kgh\b^_gby�_]h�kdjulufb�fukeyfb��l��_��iZ�b]ghjbjh\ZgbbjZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby�< dZq_kl\_� oZjZdl_jbklbdb� [_kkhagZl_evghc� mfkl\_gghc� ^_yl_evghklb�� d

Page 131: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dhlhjhc�ijbgZ^e_`Zl�kdjulu_�fukeb�kgh\b^_gby��wlh�ml\_j`^_gb_��k h^ghc�klhjhgu��g_�gh\h�k ^jm]hc�� hgh� g_� y\ey_lky� bkq_jiu\Zxsbf�� ihlhfm� qlh� [_kkhagZl_evgZy� mfkl\_ggZy^_yl_evghklv�gZjy^m�k ih^]hlh\dhc�[m^ms_]h�gZijZ\e_gZ�gZ�fgh]h_�^jm]h_��?s_�[he__�]jm[Zyhrb[dZ� aZdexq_gZ� \ ml\_j`^_gbb�� qlh� aZ� dZ`^uf� kgh\b^_gb_f� klhbl� ©deZmameZ� � kf_jlbª�7RGHVNODQVHO���6WFNHO�������������Y g_�agZx��qlh�hagZqZ_l �Xjb^bq_kdbc�l_jfbg��hagZqZxsbc�h]h\Zjb\Z_fh_�mkeh\b_��\ ^h]h\hj_��²�Ijbf_q�j_^��i_j_\h^Z�wlZ�nhjfmeZ��gh�ij_^iheZ]Zx��qlh�aZ�g_c�kdju\Z_lky�ih^f_gZ�kgh\b^_gby�\k_c�ebqghklvx\b^_\r_]h�khg�G_hijZ\^Zggh_� h[h[s_gb_� g_fgh]bo� ohjhrbo� ijbf_jh\� kh^_j`blky� \ iheh`_gbb�� qlhdZ`^h_� kgh\b^_gb_� ^himkdZ_l� ^\Z� lhedh\Zgby� ²� h^gh�� ihdZaZggh_� gZfb�� lZd� gZau\Z_fh_ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh_�� ^jm]h_� ²� lZd� gZau\Z_fh_� ZgZeh]bq_kdh_�� dhlhjh_� hldZau\Z_lky� hl\e_q_gbc� b gZijZ\e_gh� gZ� bah[jZ`_gb_� \ukrbo� ^mr_\guo� ijhp_kkh\� �6LOEHUHU�� ������� LZdb_kgh\b^_gby�bf_xlky��gh�\u�gZijZkgh�[m^_l_�iulZlvky�jZkijhkljZgblv�wlm�lhqdm�aj_gby�ohly�[ugZ� [hevrbgkl\h� kgh\b^_gbc�� Ihke_� \k_]h�� qlh� \u� keurZeb�� \Zf� ihdZ`_lky� kh\_jr_gghg_ihgylguf�b ml\_j`^_gb_��qlh�\k_�kgh\b^_gby�ke_^m_l�lhedh\Zlv�[bk_dkmZevgh��dZd�kebygb_ihlhdh\��dhlhju_�ke_^m_l�gZau\Zlv�fm`kdbf�b `_gkdbf� �:^e_j���������Dhg_qgh��_klv�b lZdb_hl^_evgu_� kgh\b^_gby�� b iha^g__� \u� magZ_l_�� qlh� hgb� bf_xl� lh� `_� kljh_gb_�� qlh� bhij_^_e_ggu_� bkl_jbq_kdb_� kbfilhfu��Y mihfbgZx� h[h� \k_o� wlbo� hldjulbyo� gh\uo� h[sboq_jl�kgh\b^_gby��qlh[u�ij_^hkl_j_qv�\Zk�hl�gbo�beb��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��qlh[u�g_�hklZ\blv�m \Zkkhfg_gby�ih�ih\h^m�lh]h��qlh�y h[�wlhf�^mfZx����H^gZ`^u�h[t_dlb\gZy�agZqbfhklv�bamq_gby�kgh\b^_gbc�[ueZ�ihklZ\e_gZ�ih^�\hijhk�ba�aZ� gZ[ex^_gby�� qlh� iZpb_glu�� e_qZsb_ky� ZgZebahf�� ijbkihkZ[eb\Zxl� kh^_j`Zgb_� k\hbokgh\b^_gbc� d ex[bfuf� l_hjbyf� k\hbo� \jZq_c�� h^gbf� kgylky� ij_bfms_kl\_ggh� k_dkmZevgu_\e_q_gby�� ^jm]bf� ²� klj_fe_gb_� d \eZklb�� lj_lvbf� ²� ^Z`_� gh\h_� jh`^_gb_� �Rl_dd_ev��P_gghklv�wlh]h�gZ[ex^_gby�ihgb`Z_lky��_keb�ijbgylv�\h�\gbfZgb_�lh��qlh�ex^b�\b^_eb�kgum`_� ^h� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h� e_q_gby�� dhlhjh_� fh]eh� [u� \ebylv� gZ� bo� kgh\b^_gby�� b qlhl_i_j_rgb_�iZpb_glu�lZd`_�bf_eb�h[udgh\_gb_�\b^_lv�kgu�b ^h�e_q_gby��NZdlbq_kdZy�klhjhgZwlh]h�hldjulby�kdhjh�ijbagZ_lky�kZfh�kh[hc�jZamf_xs_cky�b g_�bf_xs_c�gbdZdh]h�agZq_gby^ey� l_hjbb� kgh\b^_gby�� HklZldb� ^g_\guo� \i_qZle_gbc�� ih[m`^Zxsb_� d h[jZah\Zgbxkgh\b^_gby�� bf_xl� k\hbf� bklhqgbdhf� mklhcqb\u_�`bag_ggu_� bgl_j_ku� ijb� [h^jkl\h\Zgbb�?keb�[_k_^u�\jZqZ�b ^Zggu_�bf�mdZaZgby�ijbh[j_eb�^ey�ZgZebabjm_fh]h�[hevrh_�agZq_gb_��lhhgb� \oh^yl� \ djm]� hklZldh\� ^g_\guo� \i_qZle_gbc�� fh]ml� klZlv� ikbobq_kdbfb� ih[m^bl_eyfbkgh\b^_gby�� dZd� ^jm]b_� wfhpbhgZevgh� hdjZr_ggu_� g_m^h\e_l\hj_ggu_� bgl_j_ku� ^gy�� b^_ckl\h\Zlv�ih^h[gh�khfZlbq_kdbf�jZa^jZ`bl_eyf��hdZau\Zxsbf�\ha^_ckl\b_�gZ�kiys_]h�\h\j_fy� kgZ�� Ih^h[gh� wlbf� ^jm]bf� ih[m^bl_eyf� kgh\b^_gby� \ua\Zggu_� \jZqhf� fukeb� fh]ml\hagbdgmlv�\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb�beb�h[gZjm`blvky�\ kdjulhf��Fu�m`_�agZ_f��qlh�kgh\b^_gbyfh`gh� \ua\Zlv� wdki_jbf_glZevgh� beb�� ijZ\bevg__� kdZaZlv�� \\_klb� \ kgh\b^_gb_� qZklv� _]hfZl_jbZeZ��LZdbf�h[jZahf��[eZ]h^Zjy�wlhfm�\ebygbx�gZ�k\h_]h�iZpb_glZ�ZgZeblbd�b]jZ_l�jhevwdki_jbf_glZlhjZ�� dhlhjuc�� dZd�Fhmjeb�<hev^�� ijb^Z_l� qe_gZf� bkiulm_fh]h� hij_^_e_ggu_iheh`_gby�

Page 132: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

QZklh�fh`gh� \gmrblv� kiys_fm�� h q_f� ^he`gh� [ulv� _]h� kgh\b^_gb_�� gh� gbdh]^Z� g_evayih\ebylv� gZ� lh�� qlh� hg� m\b^bl� \h� kg_��F_oZgbaf� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� b _]h� [_kkhagZl_evgh_`_eZgb_� g_� ih^^Zxlky� gbdZdhfm� qm`hfm� \ha^_ckl\bx�� Ijb� hp_gd_� kgh\b^_gbc�� \ua\ZgguokhfZlbq_kdbfb�jZa^jZ`bl_eyfb��\u�m`_�magZeb��qlh�k\h_h[jZab_�b kZfhklhyl_evghklv�`bagb�\hkg_�ijhy\ey_lky� \ j_Zdpbb�� dhlhjhc� kgh\b^_gb_� hl\_qZ_l�gZ� \eby\rb_�gZ�g_]h� khfZlbq_kdb_beb� ikbobq_kdb_� jZa^jZ`bl_eb��BlZd�� \ hkgh\_� h[km`^Z\r_]hky� a^_kv� ml\_j`^_gby�� dhlhjh_ihklZ\beh�ih^�khfg_gb_�h[t_dlb\ghklv�bamq_gby�kgh\b^_gbc��hiylv�e_`bl�ih^f_gZ�kgh\b^_gby_]h�fZl_jbZehf�<hl�b \k_��m\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��qlh�y ohl_e�\Zf�kdZaZlv�h ijh[e_fZo�kgh\b^_gby��<u^h]Z^u\Z_l_kv��qlh�fgh]h_�y mimklbe��b agZ_l_�kZfb��qlh�ihqlb�ih�\k_f�\hijhkZf�y \ukdZaZekyg_ihegh�� Gh� ijbqbghc� wlh]h� y\ey_lky� \aZbfhk\yav� n_ghf_gh\� kgh\b^_gby� b g_\jhlbq_kdboy\e_gbc��Fu�bamqZeb�kgh\b^_gb_�dZd�\\_^_gb_�\ l_hjbx�g_\jhah\��b wlh��dhg_qgh��ijZ\bevg__�q_f�_keb�[u�fu�ihklmibeb�gZh[hjhl��Gh�dZd�kgh\b^_gb_�ih^]hlZ\eb\Z_l�ihgbfZgb_�g_\jhah\�lZd�� k ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� ijZ\bevgmx� hp_gdm� kgh\b^_gby� fh`gh� ijbh[j_klb� lhevdh� ihke_agZdhfkl\Z�k g_\jhlbq_kdbfb�y\e_gbyfb�G_� agZx�� dZd� ^mfZ_l_� \u��gh� y ^he`_g� \Zk� aZ\_jblv�� qlh�g_�`Ze_x� h lhf�� qlh� ihk\ylbeijh[e_fZf� kgh\b^_gby� lZd�fgh]h� ij_^hklZ\e_ggh]h� gZf� \j_f_gb� b lZd� ^he]h� aZgbfZe� \Zr_\gbfZgb_�� Gb� gZ� dZdhf� ^jm]hf� h[t_dl_� g_evay� lZd� [ukljh� m[_^blvky� \ ijZ\bevghklbml\_j`^_gbc�� gZ� dhlhjuo� ab`^_lky� ikbohZgZeba�� Gm`gZ� gZijy`_ggZy� jZ[hlZ� \ l_q_gb_g_kdhevdbo� f_kyp_\� b ^Z`_� e_l�� qlh[u� ihdZaZlv�� qlh� kbfilhfu� dZdh]h�lh� kemqZyg_\jhlbq_kdh]h�aZ[he_\Zgby�bf_xl�k\hc�kfuke��kem`Zl�dZdhfm�lh�gZf_j_gbx�b h[mkeh\e_guh[klhyl_evkl\Zfb�`bagb�[hevgh]h��GZijhlb\��\ l_q_gb_�g_kdhevdbo�qZkh\�m^Z_lky��fh`_l�[ulv�^hdZaZlv� lh�`_� kZfh_�hlghkbl_evgh� kgZqZeZ� aZimlZggh]h� kgh\b^_gby�b ih^l\_j^blv� wlbf� \k_iheh`_gby�ikbohZgZebaZ�²�h [_kkhagZl_evghklb�^mr_\guo�ijhp_kkh\��h[�hkh[uo�f_oZgbafZo�dhlhjuf� hgb� ih^qbgyxlky�� b ^\b`msbo� kbeZo�� dhlhju_� \ gbo� ijhy\eyxlky�� : _keb� fukhihklZ\bf� ihegmx� ZgZeh]bx� \ ihkljh_gbb� kgh\b^_gby� b g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� kbfilhfZ� k[ukljhlhc� ij_\jZs_gby� kiys_]h� q_eh\_dZ� \ [h^jkl\mxs_]h� b jZamfgh]h�� lh� m gZk� ihy\blkym\_j_gghklv��qlh�b g_\jha�hkgh\Zg�lhevdh�gZ�baf_g_gghf�\aZbfh^_ckl\bb�kbe�^mr_\ghc�`bagb�R?KLG:>P:L:Y�E?DPBYIkbohZgZeba�b ikbobZljbyM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Y jZ^� kgh\Z� \b^_lv� \Zk� ihke_� ]h^bqgh]h� i_j_ju\Z� bijh^he`blv� gZrb� [_k_^u�� < ijhrehf� ]h^m� y baeh`be� \Zf� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdmx� jZajZ[hldmijh[e_f� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc� b kgh\b^_gbc�� l_i_jv� y ohl_e� [u� \\_klb� \Zk� \ ihgbfZgb_g_\jhlbq_kdbo�y\e_gbc��dhlhju_��dZd�\u�kdhjh�magZ_l_��bf_xl�fgh]h�h[s_]h�dZd�k l_fb��lZd�b k^jm]bfb��Gh�kdZ`m� aZjZg__��qlh�gZ�wlhl�jZa�y g_�fh]m�ij_^hklZ\blv�\Zf�lh�`_�iheh`_gb_�ihhlghr_gbx�d k_[_��qlh�\ ijhrehf�]h^m��Lh]^Z�hgh�h[tykgyehkv�l_f��qlh�y g_�fh]�k^_eZlv�gbh^gh]h�rZ]Z��g_�kh]eZkh\Z\�_]h�k \Zrbf�km`^_gb_f��y fgh]h�^bkdmlbjh\Ze�k \Zfb��kqblZeky�k\Zrbfb� \hajZ`_gbyfb�� ijbagZ\Ze�� kh[kl\_ggh�� \Zk� b \Zr� ©a^jZ\uc� kfukeª� aZ� \ukrmx

Page 133: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

bgklZgpbx�� >Zevr_� lZd� ijh^he`Zlvky� g_� fh`_l�� ijbq_f� ih� hq_gv� ijhklhc� ijbqbg_�Hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�b kgh\b^_gby�dZd�n_ghf_gu�g_�[ueb�\Zf�g_agZdhfu��fh`gh�kdZaZlv��qlhm \Zk�[ueh�klhevdh�`_�hiulZ��kdhevdh�b m�f_gy��beb�\u�e_]dh�fh]eb�ijbh[j_klb�lZdhc�`_�hiul�Gh�h[eZklv�g_\jhah\�\Zf�qm`^Z��ihkdhevdm�\u�kZfb�g_�\jZqb��m \Zk�g_l�d g_c�gbdZdh]h�bgh]h^hklmiZ��djhf_�fhbo�khh[s_gbc��Z qlh�agZqbl�kZfh_�emqr__�km`^_gb_��_keb�g_l�agZdhfkl\Z�kfZl_jbZehf��ih^e_`Zsbf�h[km`^_gbx�H^gZdh� g_� ihcfbl_� fh_]h� aZy\e_gby� \ lhf� kfuke_�� qlh� y kh[bjZxkv� qblZlv� \Zf^h]fZlbq_kdb_� e_dpbb� b ^h[b\Zxkv� lh]h�� qlh[u� \u� g_ij_f_ggh� ijbgyeb� bo� gZ� \_jm�� LZdh_g_^hjZamf_gb_� [ueh� [u� [hevrhc� g_kijZ\_^eb\hklvx� ih� hlghr_gbx� dh� fg_�� Y g_� ohqmgZ\yau\Zlv� gbdZdbo� m[_`^_gbc� ²� y gZf_j_g� ijh[m^blv� \Zrm� fukev� b ihdhe_[Zlvij_^m[_`^_gby��?keb�ba�aZ�nZdlbq_kdh]h�g_agZgby�\u�g_�\ khklhygbb�bf_lv�km`^_gby��lh�\Zfg_�ke_^m_l�gb \_jblv��gb�hljbpZlv��<u�^he`gu�kemrZlv�b g_�ijhlb\blvky�\ha^_ckl\bx�lh]h��hq_f�y \Zf�jZkkdZ`m��M[_`^_gby�ijbh[j_lZxlky�g_�lZd�e_]dh��Z _keb�d gbf�ijboh^yl�[_a�ljm^Z�lh�hgb�kdhjh�l_jyxl�k\hx�agZqbfhklv�b hdZau\Zxlky�g_�kihkh[gufb�d khijhlb\e_gbx��IjZ\hgZ� m[_`^_gb_�bf__l� lhevdh� lhl�� dlh�ih^h[gh�fg_�fgh]b_� ]h^u� jZ[hlZe�gZ^� h^gbf� b l_f�`_fZl_jbZehf� b kZf� ijbh[j_e� ijb� wlhf� lhl�`_� gh\uc� m^b\bl_evguc� hiul�� D q_fm� \hh[s_� \bgl_ee_dlmZevghc�h[eZklb�wlb�kdhjhki_eu_�m[_`^_gby��fhegb_ghkgh_�h[jZs_gb_�\ bgmx�\_jm�fhf_glZevguc� hldZa� hl�g__"�JZa\_� \u�g_� aZf_qZ_l_�� qlh� ©FRXS� GH� IRXGUHª�� ex[h\v� k i_j\h]h\a]ey^Z��ijhbkoh^bl�kh\k_f�ba�^jm]hc�²�Znn_dlb\ghc�²�h[eZklb"�>Z`_�hl�gZrbo�iZpb_glh\fu�g_�lj_[m_f��qlh[u�hgb�ijboh^beb�d gZf�k m[_`^_gb_f�beb�]hlh\ghklvx�klZlv�klhjhggbdZfbikbohZgZebaZ��QZklh� wlh�^Z`_�\uau\Z_l�ih^haj_gby��;eZ]h`_eZl_evguc�kd_ikbk�²�\hl� kZfZy`_eZl_evgZy� ^ey� gZk� bo� mklZgh\dZ�� LZd� qlh� b \u� ihiulZcl_kv� ijhgbdgmlvkyikbohZgZeblbq_kdbfb� \a]ey^Zfb� gZjy^m� k h[s_ijbgylufb� beb� ikbobZljbq_kdbfb�� ihdZ� g_ij_^klZ\blky� kemqZc�� dh]^Z� hgb� ih\ebyxl� ^jm]� gZ� ^jm]Z�� khh[jZamxlky� ^jm]� k ^jm]hf� bh[t_^bgylky�\ h^gh�hdhgqZl_evgh_�m[_`^_gb_�Gh� k ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� \u� gb� fbgmlu� g_� ^he`gu� iheZ]Zlv�� qlh� baeZ]Z_fu_� fghxikbohZgZeblbq_kdb_�\a]ey^u�y\eyxlky�ki_dmeylb\ghc�kbkl_fhc��Wlh��gZijhlb\��hiul�²�eb[hg_ihkj_^kl\_ggh_�\i_qZle_gb_�hl�gZ[ex^_gby��eb[h�j_amevlZl�_]h�i_j_jZ[hldb��Y\ey_lky�eb�wlZi_j_jZ[hldZ�^hklZlhqghc�b hijZ\^Zgghc��\uykgblky�\ oh^_�^Zevg_cr_]h�jZa\blby�gZmdb��Z ihijhr_kl\bb�ihqlb�^\mo�k iheh\bghc�^_kylbe_lbc��^hklb]gm\�^h\hevgh�ij_klZj_eh]h�\hajZklZ��y[_a� o\Zklh\kl\Z� kf_x� kdZaZlv�� qlh� jZ[hlZ�� ^Z\rZy� wlb� gZ[ex^_gby�� [ueZ� hkh[_ggh� ly`_ehc�bgl_gkb\ghc�b m]em[e_gghc��M f_gy�qZklh� kha^Z\Zehkv�\i_qZle_gb_��[m^lh�gZrb�ijhlb\gbdbkh\_jr_ggh� g_� ohlyl� ijbgbfZlv� \h� \gbfZgb_� wlh� ijhbkoh`^_gb_� gZrbo� ml\_j`^_gbc�� dZd[m^lh�hgb�iheZ]Zxl��qlh�^_eh� b^_l�\k_]h�ebrv�h km[t_dlb\guo�b^_yo��dhlhjuf�^jm]hc�fh`_lijhlb\hihklZ\blv� k\h_� kh[kl\_ggh_� fg_gb_�� Wlh� ih\_^_gb_� ijhlb\gbdh\� fg_� g_� kh\k_fihgylgh�� Fh`_l� [ulv�� wlh� ijhbkoh^bl� hl� lh]h�� qlh� \jZqb� h[uqgh� lZd� [_amqZklgu� dg_j\gh[hevguf�� lZd� g_\gbfZl_evgh� \ukemrb\Zxl�� qlh� hgb� ohlyl� kdZaZlv�� qlh� bf� dZ`_lkykljZgghc� \hafh`ghklv� ihemqblv� ba� bo� khh[s_gbc� qlh�lh� p_ggh_�� l�� _�� ijh\h^blv� gZ^� gbfbk_jv_agu_� gZ[ex^_gby�� < wlhc� k\yab� y h[_sZx� \Zf�� qlh�� qblZy� wlb� e_dpbb�� y [m^m� fZehihe_fbabjh\Zlv�� hkh[_ggh� k hl^_evgufb� ebpZfb�� Y g_� kfh]� m[_^blvky� \ ijZ\bevghklbiheh`_gby��qlh�kihj�²�hl_p�\k_o�\_s_c��Y ^mfZx��hgh�ijhbkoh^bl�ba�]j_q_kdhc�khnbklbdb�bkljZ^Z_l��dZd�b hgZ��i_j_hp_gdhc�^bZe_dlbdb��Fg_�`_��gZijhlb\��dZaZehkv��qlh�lZd�gZau\Z_fZy

Page 134: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gZmqgZy� ihe_fbdZ� \ h[s_f� ^h\hevgh� [_kieh^gZ��g_� ]h\hjy� m`_� h lhf�� qlh� hgZ�ihqlb� \k_]^Z\_^_lky� djZcg_� ebqgh�� G_kdhevdh� e_l� gZaZ^� b y� fh]� iho\Zeblvky�� qlh� dh]^Z�lh� \klmibe� \gZklhysbc�gZmqguc�kihj�k h^gbf�_^bgkl\_gguf�bkke_^h\Zl_e_f��Ez\_gn_ev^hf�ba�Fxgo_gZ��>_eh�dhgqbehkv� l_f��qlh�fu�klZeb�^jmavyfb�b hklZ_fky�bfb�^h�k_]h^gyrg_]h�^gy��H^gZdh�y^Z\gh�g_�ih\lhjye�wlhl�hiul��lZd�dZd�g_�[ue�m\_j_g�\ ih^h[ghf�bkoh^_�<u��ih`Zemc��ih^mfZ_l_��qlh�lZdhc�hldZa�hl�ebl_jZlmjghc�^bkdmkkbb�k\b^_l_evkl\m_l�h[hkh[_ggh�[hevrhc�g_l_jibfhklb�d \hajZ`_gbyf��h kZfhfg_gbb�beb��dZd�ex[_agh�\ujZ`Zxlky�\gZmd_�� h ©ihf_rZl_evkl\_ª�� GZ� wlh� y ohl_e� [u� \Zf� hl\_lblv�� qlh� _keb� \u� dh]^Z�gb[m^vijbh[j_l_l_�dZdh_�lh�m[_`^_gb_�[eZ]h^Zjy�lZdhfm�ly`_ehfm�ljm^m��m \Zk�lh`_�[m^_l�ba\_klgh_ijZ\h� ijb^_j`b\Zlvky� wlh]h� m[_`^_gby� k g_dhlhjuf� mihjkl\hf�� >Ze__� y fh]m� ijb\_klb� \dZq_kl\_�^h\h^Z�b lh��qlh�\h�\j_fy�k\h_c�jZ[hlu�y fh^bnbpbjh\Ze�k\hb�\a]ey^u�ih�g_dhlhjuf\Z`guf�\hijhkZf��f_gye�bo��aZf_gye�gh\ufb��h q_f��jZamf__lky��dZ`^uc�jZa�^_eZe�im[ebqgu_khh[s_gby��: dZdh\�j_amevlZl�wlhc�hldjh\_gghklb"�H^gb�\hh[s_�g_�magZeb�h \g_k_gguo�fghxkZfbf�ihijZ\dZo�b _s_�k_]h^gy�djblbdmxl�f_gy� aZ�iheh`_gby��dhlhju_�^Z\gh�g_�bf_xl�^eyf_gy�ij_`g_]h�agZq_gby��>jm]b_�mij_dZxl�f_gy�bf_ggh�\ wlbo�i_j_f_gZo�b kqblZxl�ihwlhfmg_gZ^_`guf�� G_� ijZ\^Z� eb�� dlh� g_kdhevdh� jZa� ihf_gye� k\hb� \a]ey^u�� lhl� \hh[s_� g_aZkem`b\Z_l�^h\_jby��ihlhfm�qlh�e_]dh�^himklblv��qlh�b \�k\hbo�ihke_^gbo�ml\_j`^_gbyo�hgfh]� hrb[blvky"� Gh� lh]h�� dlh� g_mdehggh� ijb^_j`b\Z_lky� h^gZ`^u� \ukdZaZggh]h�� kqblZxlmijyfuf� b gZau\Zxl� ihf_rZgguf�� Qlh� `_� ^_eZlv� i_j_^� ebphf� wlbo� ijhlb\hj_qb\uoaZdexq_gbc� djblbdb�� dZd� g_� hklZ\Zlvky� kZfbf� kh[hc� b \_klb� k_[y� lZd�� dZd� ih^kdZau\Z_lkh[kl\_ggh_�fg_gb_"�GZ� wlh� y b� j_rbeky� b g_� ^Zf� m^_j`Zlv� k_[y� hl� \g_k_gby� baf_g_gbc� bihijZ\hd� \h� \k_� fhb� l_hjbb�� dhlhjuo� lj_[m_l� fhc� jZklmsbc� hiul�� < hkgh\hiheZ]Zxsbo\a]ey^Zo�y ^h�kbo�ihj�g_�gZr_e�gbq_]h��qlh�[ueh�[u�g_h[oh^bfh�baf_gblv��b gZ^_xkv��qlh�lZd[m^_l�b ^Zevr_�BlZd�� y gZf_j_g� baeh`blv� \Zf� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh_� ihgbfZgb_� g_\jhlbq_kdbo� y\e_gbc�Ijb�wlhf�_kl_kl\_ggh�khhlg_klb�bo�k m`_�bamq_ggufb�n_ghf_gZfb�dZd�\ke_^kl\b_�bo�ZgZeh]bb�lZd�b dhgljZklZ��GZqgm�k kbfilhfZlbq_kdh]h�^_ckl\by��dhlhjh_�y gZ[ex^Zx�m fgh]bo�ebp�\h\j_fy�ijb_fZ��K l_fb��dlh�ijboh^bl�d gZf�\ ijb_fgu_�qZku��qlh[u�aZ�q_l\_jlv�qZkZ�jZkkdZaZlvh g_\a]h^Zo� k\h_c�^he]hc�`bagb�� ZgZeblbd� k^_eZ_l�g_�fgh]h_��?]h�[he__� ]em[hdh_� agZgb_�g_iha\hey_l�_fm�\ukdZaZlv�aZdexq_gb_��dZd�wlh�k^_eZe�[u�^jm]hc�\jZq��©<u�a^hjh\uª�²�b ^Zlvkh\_l��ijh^_eZcl_�g_[hevrhc�dmjk�\h^he_q_gby��H^bg�gZr�dhee_]Z�gZ�\hijhk��qlh�hg�^_eZ_l�khk\hbfb�iZpb_glZfb�\h�\j_fy�ijb_fZ��hl\_lbe��ih`bfZy�ie_qZfb��hg�gZeZ]Z_l�gZ�gbo�rljZn�\klhevdh�lh�djhg�aZ�bo�rZehklb��LZd�qlh�\u�g_�m^b\eycl_kv��mkeurZ\��qlh�^Z`_�m kZfuo�aZgyluoikbohZgZeblbdh\�\h�\j_fy�ijb_fZ�[u\Z_l�g_�hq_gv�lh�h`b\e_ggh��Y mkljhbe�f_`^m�ijb_fghc�bk\hbf�dZ[bg_lhf�^\hcgmx�^\_jv�b ijbdZaZe�h[blv�__ \hcehdhf��GZagZq_gb_�wlh]h�fZe_gvdh]hijbkihkh[e_gby�g_�\uau\Z_l�khfg_gby��B \hl�ihklhyggh�kemqZ_lky��qlh�iZpb_glu��dhlhjuo�y\imkdZx� ba� ijb_fghc�� aZ[u\Zxl� aZdjulv� aZ� kh[hc� ^\_jb� b ihwlhfm� ihqlb� \k_]^Z� h[_� ^\_jbhklZxlky� hldjulufb�� AZf_lb\� wlh�� y ^h\hevgh� g_ex[_aguf� lhghf� gZklZb\Zx� gZ� lhf�� qlh[u\hr_^rbc�beb�\hr_^rZy�²�[m^v�lh�we_]Zglguc� ]hkih^bg�beb�hq_gv�jZknjZgq_ggZy�^ZfZ�²\_jgmeky�b bkijZ\be�k\hx�hrb[dm��Wlh�ijhba\h^bl�\i_qZle_gb_�g_mf_klghc�i_^Zglbqghklb��KlZdbf�lj_[h\Zgb_f�fg_�kemqZehkv�ihiZ^Zlv�b \ijhkZd��dh]^Z�^_eh�dZkZehkv�ebp��dhlhju_�kZfbg_�fh]ml�ijbdZkZlvky�d ^\_jghc�jmqd_�b jZ^u��_keb�khijh\h`^Zxsb_�bo�ebpZ�hk\h[h`^Zxl�bo

Page 135: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hl�wlh]h�ijbdhkgh\_gby��Gh�\ [hevrbgkl\_�kemqZ_\�y [u\Ze�ijZ\��ihlhfm�qlh�lhl��dlh�hklZ\ey_lhldjulhc� ^\_jv� ba� ijb_fghc� \ dZ[bg_l� \jZqZ�� ijbgZ^e_`bl� d ^mjgh� \hkiblZgguf� ex^yf� baZkem`b\Z_l� kZfh]h�g_ijb\_leb\h]h�ijb_fZ��G_�\klZ\Zcl_� kjZam�gZ�bo� klhjhgm��g_� \ukemrZ\\k_]h��WlZ�g_[j_`ghklv�iZpb_glZ�bf__l�f_klh� lhevdh�\ lhf� kemqZ_�� _keb�hg�[ue�\ ijb_fghch^bg�b hklZ\ey_l�aZ�kh[hc�imklmx�dhfgZlm��gh�wlh]h�gbdh]^Z�g_�kemqZ_lky��_keb�k gbf�\f_kl_h`b^Zxl� ^jm]b_�� ihklhjhggb_�� < wlhf� ihke_^g_f� kemqZ_� hg� ij_djZkgh� ihgbfZ_l�� qlh� \ _]hbgl_j_kZo��qlh[u� _]h�g_�ih^kemrb\Zeb�� dh]^Z� hg� ]h\hjbl� k \jZqhf��b hg�gbdh]^Z�g_� aZ[m^_llsZl_evgh�aZdjulv�h[_�^\_jb�>_l_jfbgbjh\Zggh_� lZdbf� h[jZahf� mims_gb_� iZpb_glZ� g_� y\ey_lky� gb kemqZcguf�� gb[_kkfuke_gguf�� gb� ^Z`_� g_agZqbl_evguf�� ihlhfm� qlh�� dZd� fu� m\b^bf�� hgh� hij_^_ey_lhlghr_gb_�iZpb_glZ�d \jZqm��IZpb_gl�ijbgZ^e_`bl�d [hevrhfm�qbkem�l_o��dlh�lj_[m_l�hl�\jZqZih^ebgghc�\eZklb��ohq_l�[ulv�hke_ie_gguf��aZim]Zgguf��Fh`_l�[ulv��kijZrb\Zy�ih�l_e_nhgm�\ dZdh_�\j_fy�_fm�emqr_�\k_]h�ijbclb��hg�jZkkqblu\Ze�m\b^_lv�lheim�`Z`^msbo�ihfhsb��dZdi_j_^�nbebZehf�>nbjfu@�XebmkZ�F_cgey ��B \hl�hg�\oh^bl�\ imklmx��d lhfm�`_�qj_a\uqZcghkdjhfgh�h[klZ\e_ggmx�ijb_fgmx��b wlh�_]h�ihljykZ_l��Hg�^he`_g�aZklZ\blv�\jZqZ�ihieZlblvkyaZ� lh�� qlh� kh[bjZeky� hlg_klbkv� d g_fm� kh� kebrdhf� [hevrbf� ihql_gb_f�� b \hl� hg� aZ[u\Z_laZdjulv�^\_jv�f_`^m�ijb_fghc�b dZ[bg_lhf�\jZqZ��Wlbf�hg�ohq_l�kdZaZlv�\jZqm��Zo��\_^v�a^_kvgbdh]h�g_l��b��\_jhylgh��gbdlh�g_�ijb^_l��ihdZ�y [m^m�a^_kv��B \h�\j_fy�[_k_^u�hg�\_e�[u�k_[yg_[eZ]h\hkiblZggh� b g_m\Z`bl_evgh�� _keb� [u� _]h� aZghkqb\hklv� k kZfh]h� gZqZeZ� g_� hkZ^bebj_adbf�aZf_qZgb_f�< ZgZeba_� wlh]h� g_agZqbl_evgh]h� kbfilhfZlbq_kdh]h� ^_ckl\by� \u� g_� gZc^_l_� gbq_]hlZdh]h��qlh�g_�[ueh�[u�\Zf�m`_�agZdhfh��Z bf_ggh�ml\_j`^_gb_��qlh�hgh�g_�kemqZcgh��Z bf__ldZdhc�lh� fhlb\�� kfuke� b gZf_j_gb_�� qlh� hgh� \oh^bl� \ dZdmx�lh� ^mr_\gmx� k\yav� bk\b^_l_evkl\m_l�dZd�g_agZqbl_evguc�ijbagZd�h dZdhf�lh�[he__�\Z`ghf�^mr_\ghf�ijhp_kk_��Ghij_`^_�\k_]h� wlhl�ijhy\b\rbcky� lZdbf�h[jZahf�ijhp_kk�g_�ba\_kl_g� khagZgbx� lh]h�� dlh� _]hkh\_jrZ_l��ihlhfm�qlh�gb h^bg�ba�iZpb_glh\��hklZ\ey\rbo�hldjulufb�h[_�^\_jb��g_�ijbagZeky[u��qlh�wlbf�mims_gb_f�hg�ohl_e�\ujZablv�fg_�k\h_�g_ihql_gb_��Bghc��ih`Zemc��b ijbihfgblqm\kl\h� jZahqZjh\Zgby�ijb� \oh^_� \ imklmx�ijb_fgmx��gh� k\yav�f_`^m� wlbf� \i_qZle_gb_f�bke_^mxsbf�aZ�gbf�kbfilhfZlbq_kdbf�^_ckl\b_f�gZ\_jgydZ�hklZeZkv�g_\_^hfhc�_]h�khagZgbx�: l_i_jv� d wlhfm� g_[hevrhfm� ZgZebam� kbfilhfZlbq_kdh]h� ^_ckl\by� ^Z\Zcl_� ijb\e_q_fgZ[ex^_gb_�aZ�h^ghc�[hevghc��Y \u[bjZx�lZdhc�kemqZc��dhlhjuc�k\_`�m f_gy�\ iZfylb��lZd`_b ihlhfm�� qlh� _]h�fh`gh� hlghkbl_evgh� djZldh�baeh`blv��< ex[hf� lZdhf� khh[s_gbb� ijhklhg_\hafh`gh�ba[_`Zlv�g_dhlhjuo�ih^jh[ghkl_c�Fheh^hc� hnbp_j�� g_gZ^he]h� \_jgm\rbcky� \ hlimkd�� ijhkbl� f_gy� ihe_qblv� _]h� l_sm�dhlhjZy��g_kfhljy�gZ� kZfu_�[eZ]hijbylgu_�mkeh\by�� hljZ\ey_l�`bagv� k_[_�b k\hbf�[ebadbf�h^_j`bfZy� [_kkfuke_gghc� b^__c�� Y agZdhfexkv� k ���e_lg_c� ohjhrh� khojZgb\r_cky� ^Zfhcex[_agh]h�b ijhklh]h�oZjZdl_jZ��dhlhjZy�[_a�khijhlb\e_gby�jZkkdZau\Z_l�fg_�ke_^mxs__��HgZ`b\_l� aZ� ]hjh^hf� \ kZfhf� kqZkleb\hf� [jZd_� kh� k\hbf� fm`_f�� mijZ\eyxsbf� [hevrhcnZ[jbdhc��HgZ�g_�fh`_l�gZo\Zeblvky�ex[_aghc�aZ[hleb\hklvx�k\h_]h�fm`Z�����e_l�lhfm�gZaZ^hgZ�\ureZ�aZfm`�ih�ex[\b��k l_o�ihj�gbdh]^Z�g_�[ueh�gb�h^gh]h�g_^hjZamf_gby��jZagh]eZkbybeb�ih\h^Z�^ey�j_\ghklb��>\h_�__�^_l_c�kqZkleb\u�\ [jZd_��fm`�ba�qm\kl\Z�^he]Z�g_�ohq_l�b^lb

Page 136: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gZ� ihdhc�� =h^� lhfm� gZaZ^� kemqbehkv� g_qlh� g_\_jhylgh_�� g_ihgylgh_� _c� kZfhc�� hgZ� kjZamih\_jbeZ� Zghgbfghfm�ibkvfm�� \ dhlhjhf� __ ij_djZkguc�fm`� h[\bgyeky� \ ex[h\ghc� k\yab� kfheh^hc�^_\mrdhc��b k�l_o�ihj�__ kqZklv_�jZa[blh��< ih^jh[ghklyo�^_eh�aZdexqZehkv�ijbf_jgh\ ke_^mxs_f��m g__�[ueZ�]hjgbqgZy��k dhlhjhc�hgZ��ih`Zemc��kebrdhf�qZklh�\_eZ�bglbfgu_jZa]h\hju��WlZ�^_\mrdZ�ij_ke_^h\ZeZ�^jm]mx�ijyfh�lZdb�kh�aeh[ghc�\jZ`^_[ghklvx��ihlhfmqlh�lZ�]hjZa^h�[hevr_�ij_mki_eZ�\ `bagb��ohly�[ueZ�ebrv�qmlv�emqr_]h � Ijh^h\hevkl\_ggu_� fZ]Zabgu� nbjfu�� i_j_^� dhlhjufb� \ \h_ggh_� \j_fy� klhyeb� hq_j_^b� ihdmiZl_e_c��Ijbf_q��g_f��ba^�ijhbkoh`^_gby�� <f_klh� lh]h� qlh[u� ihklmiblv� gZ� kem`[m�� hgZ� ihemqbeZ� dhff_jq_kdh_h[jZah\Zgb_�� ihklmibeZ� gZ� nZ[jbdm� b \ke_^kl\b_� g_^hklZldZ� i_jkhgZeZ� ba�aZ� ijbau\Zkem`Zsbo� gZ� \h_ggmx� kem`[m� \u^\bgmeZkv� gZ� ohjhr__� f_klh�� L_i_jv� hgZ� `beZ� gZ� kZfhcnZ[jbd_�� \jZsZeZkv� kj_^b� ]hkih^� b ^Z`_� gZau\ZeZkv� [Zjurg_c�� HlklZ\rZy� gZ� `bag_gghfihijbs_��_kl_kl\_ggh��[ueZ�]hlh\Z�gZ]h\hjblv�gZ�[u\rmx�rdhevgmx�ih^jm]m�\k_\hafh`guo]Z^hkl_c�� H^gZ`^u� gZrZ� ^ZfZ� [_k_^h\ZeZ� k ]hjgbqghc� h[� h^ghf� ]hklb\r_f� m gbo� klZjhf]hkih^bg_��h dhlhjhf�agZeb��qlh�hg�g_�`b�l kh�k\h_c�`_ghc��Z bf_e�k\yav�k ^jm]hc��HgZ�g_�agZ_l�dZd�wlh�\ureh��qlh�hgZ�\^jm]�kdZaZe��©>ey�f_gy�[ueh�[u�kZfuf�m`Zkguf��_keb�[u�y magZeZ��qlhfhc�^h[juc�fm`� lh`_�bf__l� k\yavª��GZ� ke_^mxsbc� ^_gv� hgZ�ihemqbeZ�ih�ihql_� Zghgbfgh_ibkvfh��\ dhlhjhf�baf_g_gguf�ihq_jdhf�khh[sZehkv�wlh�dZd�[u�gZdebdZggh_�_x�ba\_klb_��HgZj_rbeZ�²�b \_jhylgh��ijZ\bevgh�²qlh�ibkvfh²^_eh�jmd�__ haeh[e_gghc�]hjgbqghc��ihlhfmqlh� \haex[e_gghc�fm`Z� [ueZ� gZa\ZgZ� bf_ggh� lZ� [Zjurgy�� dhlhjmx� kem`ZgdZ� ij_ke_^h\ZeZk\h_c�g_gZ\bklvx��Gh�ohly�hgZ� lhlqZk�gZkd\hav�m\b^_eZ�\kx�bgljb]m�b agZeZ�\ k\h_c�hdjm]_^hklZlhqgh� ijbf_jh\�� k\b^_l_evkl\mxsbo� h lhf�� dZd� fZeh� ^h\_jby� aZkem`b\Zxl� lZdb_ljmkeb\u_� ^hghku�� kemqbehkv� lZd�� qlh� wlh� ibkvfh� __ kjZam� kjZabeh�� ?_� ho\Zlbeh� kljZrgh_\ha[m`^_gb_��b hgZ�lhlqZk�ihkeZeZ�aZ�fm`_f��qlh[u�\ujZablv�_fm�kZfu_�`_klhdb_�mij_db��Fm`kh� kf_ohf� hljbpZe� h[\bg_gb_� b k^_eZe� kZfh_� emqr__�� qlh� [ueh� \hafh`gh�� Hg� iha\Ze^hfZrg_]h� b nZ[jbqgh]h� \jZqZ�� dhlhjuc� ihklZjZeky� mkihdhblv� g_kqZklgmx� `_gsbgm�>Zevg_crb_� ^_ckl\by� h[hbo� [ueb� lh`_� \iheg_� [eZ]hjZamfgu�� =hjgbqghc� [ueh� hldZaZgh�h^gZdh�fgbfZy�khi_jgbpZ�hklZeZkv��K l_o�ihj�[hevgZy�g_h^ghdjZlgh�mkihdZb\ZeZkv�gZklhevdh�qlh� [hevr_� g_� \_jbeZ� kh^_j`Zgbx� Zghgbfgh]h� ibkvfZ�� gh� wlh� mkihdh_gb_� gbdh]^Z� g_� [uehiheguf�j ijh^he`bl_evguf��>hklZqhqgh�[ueh�mkeurZlv�bfy�lhc�[Zjurgb�beb�\klj_lblv�__ gZmebp_��qlh[u�\ua\Zlv�m g__�gh\uc�\kie_kd�g_^h\_jby��[heb�b mij_dh\�<hl�bklhjby�[he_agb�wlhc�keZ\ghc�`_gsbgu��G_�gm`_g�[hevrhc�ikbobZljbq_kdbc�hiul�qlh[u�ihgylv��qlh�\ ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv�^jm]bf�g_j\gh[hevguf�hgZ�bah[jZabeZ�k\hx�[he_agvkdhj__�kebrdhf�fy]ch��dZd�fu�]h\hjbf��^bkkbfmebjh\ZeZ��b qlh��\ kmsghklb��hgZ�gbdh]^Z�g_l_jyeZ�\_ju�\ h[\bg_gby�Zghgbfgh]h�ibkvfZ�DZdmx� ihabpbx� aZcf_l� ikbobZlj� \ wlhf� kemqZ_� [he_agb"�DZd� hg� ih\_^_l� k_[y� \ kemqZ_kbfilhfZlbq_kdh]h�^_ckl\by�iZpb_glZ��g_�aZdju\Zxs_]h�^\_jb�\ ijb_fgmx��fu�m`_�agZ_f��Hgh[ty\ey_l�_]h�ebr_gghc�ikboheh]bq_kdh]h�bgl_j_kZ�kemqZcghklvx��dhlhjZy�_]h�gbkdhevdh�g_dZkZ_lky�� Gh� d kemqZx� [he_agb� j_\gb\hc� `_gsbgu� lZdh]h� hlghr_gby� [ulv� g_� fh`_l�KbfilhfZlbq_kdh_� ^_ckl\b_� dZ`_lky� q_f�lh� [_ajZaebqguf�� gh� \ kbfilhf_� [he_agb� \b^blkyg_qlh� agZqbl_evgh_�� Hg� k\yaZg� k bgl_gA� kb\guf� km[t_dlb\guf� kljZ^Zgb_f�� hg� h[t_dlb\gh

Page 137: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

m]jh`Z_l� kh\f_klghc� `bagb� k_fvb�� lZd� qlh� y\ey_lky� ij_^f_lhf� g_ba[_`gh]h� bgl_j_kZ� ^eyikbobZljZ�� KgZqZeZ� ikbobZlj� iulZ_lky� oZjZdl_jbah\Zlv� kbfilhf� ih� _]h� kms_kl\_gghfmk\hckl\m��KZfm�ih�k_[_�b^_x��dhlhjhc�fmqZ_lky�wlZ�`_gsbgZ��g_evay�gZa\Zlv�[_kkfuke_gghc�\_^v�[u\Z_l��qlh�g_fheh^u_�fm`vy�aZ\yau\Zxl�ex[h\gu_�hlghr_gby�k fheh^ufb�^_\mrdZfb�Gh� qlh�lh� ^jm]h_� \ wlhf� [_kkfuke_ggh� b g_ihgylgh�� M iZpb_gldb� g_l� gbdZdh]h� ^jm]h]hhkgh\Zgby��djhf_�ml\_j`^_gby�Zghgbfgh]h�ibkvfZ��\_jblv�\ lh��qlh�__ g_`guc�b \_jguc�kmijm]hlghkblky� d wlhc� kh\k_f� g_j_^dhc� dZl_]hjbb� fm`_c�� HgZ� agZ_l�� qlh� wlh� ibkvfh� g_� bf__lgbdZdhc� ^hdZaZl_evghc� kbeu�� hgZ� \ khklhygbb� m^h\e_l\hjbl_evgh� h[tykgblv� _]hijhbkoh`^_gb_��hgZ�^he`gZ�[ueZ�[u�k_[y�m\_jblv��qlh�m g__�g_l�gbdZdbo�ih\h^h\�^ey�j_\ghklb�hgZ�b ]h\hjbl�wlh�k_[_�b l_f�g_�f_g__�kljZ^Z_l�lZd�`_��dZd�_keb�[u�hgZ�ijbagZ\ZeZ�wlm�j_\ghklvkh\_jr_ggh� hijZ\^Zgghc�� B^_b� lZdh]h� jh^Z�� g_ih^\eZklgu_� eh]bq_kdbf� b b^msbf� hlj_Zevghklb� Zj]mf_glZf�� ijbgylh� gZau\Zlv� [j_^h\ufb� b^_yfb��FbeZy� ^ZfZ� kljZ^Z_l�� lZdbfh[jZahf��[j_^hf�j_\ghklb��LZdh\Z��ih`Zemc��kZfZy�kms_kl\_ggZy�oZjZdl_jbklbdZ�wlh]h�kemqZy[he_agb�Ihke_� wlhc�i_j\hc�dhgklZlZpbb�gZr�ikbobZljbq_kdbc�bgl_j_k�\hajZklZ_l�dZd�[m^lh� _s_[hevr_��?keb�k [j_^h\hc�b^__c�g_evay�ihdhgqblv�kkuedhc�gZ�j_Zevghklv��lh��ih`Zemc��hgZ�b g_bf__l�dhjg_c�\ j_Zevghklb��Hldm^Z�`_�hgZ�lh]^Z�ijhbkoh^bl"�;j_^h\u_�b^_b�[u\Zxl�kZfh]hjZaghh[jZagh]h� kh^_j`Zgby�� ihq_fm� \ gZr_f� kemqZ_� kh^_j`Zgb_f� [j_^Z� y\ey_lky� bf_gghj_\ghklv"�M dh]h�h[jZamxlky�[j_^h\u_�b^_b�b��\ qZklghklb��[j_^h\u_�b^_b�j_\ghklb"�Lml�gZf[u� ohl_ehkv� ihkemrZlv� ikbobZljZ�� gh� a^_kv�lh� hg� gZk� b ih^\_^_l�� Hg� \hh[s_� hklZgh\blkylhevdh� gZ� h^ghf�_^igkl\_gghf� ba� gZrbo� \hijhkh\�� Hg� [m^_l� bamqZlv� bklhjbx� k_fvb� wlhc`_gsbgu�b��fh`_l�[vit�� hl\_lbl�gZf��[j_^h\u_�b^_b�[u\Zxl� m lZdbo� ebp�� \ k_fv_�dhlhjuog_h^ghdjZlgh� \klj_qZebkv� ih^h[gu_� beb� ^jm]b_� ikbobq_kdb_� gZjmr_gby��>jm]bfb� keh\Zfb�_keb� m wlhc� `_gsbgu� jZa\beZkv� [j_^h\Zy� b^_y�� lh� m g__� [ueh� d wlhfm� gZke_^kl\_ggh_ij_^jZkiheh`_gb_�� Wlh�� dhg_qgh�� dh_�qlh�� gh� jZa\_� \k_�� qlh� fu� ohlbf� agZlv"� <k_�� qlhihkem`beh� ijbqbghc� [he_agb"�Ke_^m_l� eb� gZf� ^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky� ij_^iheh`_gb_f�� qlh� _keb\f_klh� dZdh]h�gb[m^v� ^jm]h]h� jZa\beky� [j_^� j_\ghklb�� wlh� g_� bf__l� agZq_gby�� kemqZcgh� bg_h[tykgbfh"� B ke_^m_l� eb� gZf� ihgylv� iheh`_gb_�� aZy\eyxs__� h ij_h[eZ^ZgbbgZke_^kl\_ggh]h� \ebygby�� b \� hljbpZl_evghf� kfuke_�� [_ajZaebqgh�� dZdb_� i_j_`b\Zgbyihljykeb� wlm� ^mrm�� jZa� _c� [ueh� ij_^hij_^_e_gh� dh]^Z�lh� aZ[he_lv� ihf_rZl_evkl\hf"� <uaZohlbl_� magZlv�� ihq_fm� gZmqgZy� ikbobZljby� g_� `_eZ_l� ^Zlv� gZf� gbdZdbo� ^Zevg_crboh[tykg_gbc��Gh�y \Zf�hl\_qm��ieml�lhl��dlh�^Z_l�[hevr_��q_f�bf__l��<_^v�ikbobZlj�dZd�jZa�b g_agZ_l� imlb�� \_^ms_�x d� ^Zevg_cr_fm� ihgbfZgbx� lZdh]h� kemqZy�� Hg� \ugm`^_g^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky�^bZ]ghahf�b g_m\_j_gguf�ijh]ghahf�^Zevg_cr_]h�l_q_gby�[he_agb��g_kfhljygZ�[h]Zluc�hiul�Gh�fh`_l�eb�ikbohZgZeba�^hklbqv�\ wlhf�kemqZ_�[hevr_]h"�G_khfg_ggh��gZ^_xkv�ihdZaZlv\Zf��qlh�^Z`_�\ klhev�ljm^ghf�kemqZ_�hg�kihkh[_g�hldjulv�g_qlh�lZdh_��qlh�^Z_]�\hafh`ghklvkZfh]h�]em[hdh]h�ijhgbdgh\_gby�\ kmlv�^_eZ��<h�i_j\uo��ijhrm�h[jZlblv�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�lmg_agZqbl_evgmx�^_lZev��qlh�iZpb_gldZ�ijyfh�kijh\hpbjh\ZeZ�Zghgbfgh_�ibkvfh��gZ�dhlhjhfhkgh\ZgZ� __ [j_^h\Zy� b^_y�� \ukdZaZ\� gZdZgmg_� bgljb]Zgd_� fukev�� qlh� ^ey� g__� [ueh� [u\_ebqZcrbf�g_kqZklv_f��_keb�[u�__ fm`�bf_e�ex[h\gmx�k\yav�k fheh^hc�^_\mrdhc��Wlbf�hgZgZ\_eZ�kem`Zgdm�gZ�fukev�ihkeZlv�_c�Zghgbfgh_�ibkvfh��LZd�qlh�[j_^h\Zy�b^_y�ijbh[j_lZ_l

Page 138: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ba\_klgmx�g_aZ\bkbfhklv�hl�Zghgbfgh]h�ibkvfZ��hgZ�m`_�^h�g_]h�bf_eZkv�m [hevghc�\ nhjf_hiZk_gby� ²� beb� `_eZgby�� Ijb[Z\vl_� d wlhfm� _s_� lh�� qlh� ^Zeb� ^\Z� qZkZ� ZgZebaZ� ^jm]bog_agZqbl_evguo�gZf_dh\��IjZ\^Z��iZpb_gldZ�hlg_keZkv�hq_gv�hljbpZl_evgh�d lj_[h\Zgbx�ihke_jZkkdZaZ�k\h_c�bklhjbb�khh[sblv�^Zevg_crb_�jZafure_gby��ijboh^ysb_�_c�\ ]heh\m�fukeb�b\hkihfbgZgby��HgZ�ml\_j`^ZeZ��qlh�_c�gbq_]h�g_�ijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m��qlh�hgZ�m`_�\k_�kdZaZeZ��bq_j_a�^\Z�qZkZ�ihiuldZ�^Zevg_cr_c�[_k_^u�k g_c�^_ckl\bl_evgh�\ugm`^_gZ�[ueZ�ij_djZlblvky�lZd�dZd�hgZ�aZy\beZ��qlh�qm\kl\m_l�k_[y�m`_�a^hjh\hc�b m\_j_gZ��qlh�[he_ag_ggZy�b^_y�[hevr_g_�ihy\blky��HgZ�kdZaZeZ�wlh��dhg_qgh��lhevdh�ba�khijhlb\e_gby�b kljZoZ�i_j_^�ijh^he`_gb_fZgZebaZ��Gh� aZ� wlb�^\Z�qZkZ�hgZ�\k_�lZdb�h[jhgbeZ�g_kdhevdh� aZf_qZgbc��dhlhju_�^himkdZxlhij_^_e_ggh_� lhedh\Zgb_�� ^Z`_� ^_eZxl� _]h� g_ba[_`guf�� b wlh� lhedh\Zgb_� ijheb\Z_l� yjdbck\_l� gZ� ijhbkoh`^_gb_� __� [j_^Z� j_\ghklb�� HgZ� kZfZ� [ueZ� kbevgh� \ex[e_gZ� \ fheh^h]hq_eh\_dZ��lh]h�kZfh]h�ayly��ih�gZklhygbx�dhlhjh]h�h[jZlbeZkv�dh�fg_�dZd�iZpb_gldZ��H[�wlhc\ex[e_gghklb�hgZ�gbq_]h�g_� agZeZ�beb��fh`_l�[ulv�� agZeZ�hq_gv�fZeh��ijb� kms_kl\h\Z\rbojh^kl\_gguo� hlghr_gbyo� wlZ� \ex[e_gghklv� fh]eZ� e_]dh� fZkdbjh\Zlvky� ih^� [_ah[b^gmxg_`ghklv��Ijb�\k_f�gZr_f�hiul_�gZf�g_ljm^gh�ijhgbdgmlv�\ ^mr_\gmx�`bagv�wlhc����e_lg_cihjy^hqghc� `_gsbgu� b ohjhr_c� fZl_jb�� LZdZy� \ex[e_gghklv�� dZd� g_qlh� qm^h\bsgh_�g_\hafh`gh_�� g_� fh]eZ� klZlv� khagZl_evghc�� h^gZdh� hgZ� hklZ\ZeZkv� b dZd� [_kkhagZl_evgZye_`ZeZ� ly`_euf� ]jmahf��Qlh�lh�^he`gh� [ueh� k g_c�ijhbahclb�� dZdhc� lh� \uoh^� ^he`_g� [ue[ulv�gZc^_g��b kZfh_�ijhklh_�h[e_]q_gb_�ij_^hklZ\be�f_oZgbaf�kf_s_gby��dhlhjuc�lZd�qZklhmqZkl\m_l�\ \hagbdgh\_gbb�[j_^h\hc�j_\ghklb��?keb�g_�lhevdh�hgZ��klZjZy�`_gsbgZ��\ex[e_gZ\ fheh^h]h�fm`qbgm��gh�b __�klZjuc�fm`�ih^^_j`b\Z_]�ex[h\gmx�k\yav�k fheh^hc�^_\mrdhc�lh�hgZ�hk\h[h`^ZeZkv�[u�hl�mij_dh\� kh\_klb�ba�aZ�g_\_jghklb��NZglZaby�h g_\_jghklb�fm`Z[ueZ��lZdbf�h[jZahf��hoeZ`^Zxsbf�dhfij_kkhf�gZ�__ `]mqmx�jZgm��?_�kh[kl\_ggZy�ex[h\v�g_hkhagZ\ZeZkv�_x��gh�__ hljZ`_gb_��^Z\Z\r__�_c�lZdb_�ij_bfms_kl\Z��gZ\yaqb\h�hkhagZ\Zehkv�\\b^_�[j_^Z��<k_�^h\h^u�ijhlb\�g_]h��jZamf__lky��g_�^hklb]Zeb�p_eb��ihlhfm�qlh�gZijZ\eyebkvebrv�ijhlb\�hljZ`_gby��Z g_�ijhlb\�i_j\hgZqZevgh]h�h[jZaZ��dhlhjhfm�hgh�[ueh�h[yaZgh�k\h_ckbehc�b dhlhjuc�g_ijbdhkgh\_ggh�hklZ\Zeky�kdjuluf�\ [_kkhagZl_evghf�: l_i_jv� khihklZ\bf�� qlh� gZf� ^Ze� ^ey� ihgbfZgby� wlh]h� kemqZy� [he_agb� dhjhldbc�� ghaZljm^g_gguc�ikbohZgZeba��JZamf__lky��ijb�mkeh\bb��qlh�gZrb�k\_^_gby�ihemq_gu�ijZ\bevgh�q_]h�y k�\Zfb�g_�fh]m�a^_kv�h[km`^Zlv��<h�i_j\uo��[j_^h\Zy�b^_y�g_�y\ey_lky�[hevr_�q_f�lh[_kkfuke_gguf� beb� g_ihgylguf�� hgZ� hkfuke_ggZ�� ohjhrh� fhlb\bjh\ZgZ�� k\yaZgZ� kZnn_dlb\guf� i_j_`b\Zgb_f� [hevghc�� <h�\lhjuo�� hgZ� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� g_h[oh^bfmxj_Zdpbx�gZ�[_kkhagZl_evguc�^mr_\guc�ijhp_kk��m]Z^u\Z_fuc�ih�^jm]bf�ijbagZdZf��b h[yaZgZk\hbf� [j_^h\uf� oZjZdl_jhf� bf_ggh� wlhfm� hlghr_gbx�� _]h� mklhcqb\hklb� i_j_^� gZlbkdhfeh]bdb�b j_Zevghklb��HgZ�kZfZ�_klv�qlh�lh�`_eZggh_��k\h_]h�jh^Z�ml_r_gb_�<�lj_lvbo�� i_j_`b\Zgb_f�� g_aZ\bkbfh� hl� aZ[he_\Zgby�� g_^\mkfuke_ggh� hij_^_ey_lkyihy\e_gb_�bf_ggh�[j_^h\hc�b^_b�j_\ghklb��Z g_�dZdhc�gb[m^v�^jm]hc��<u�\_^v�ihfgbl_��qlhhgZ�gZdZgmg_�\ukdZaZeZ�bgljb]Zgd_�fukev��qlh�^ey�g__�[ueh�[u�kZfuf�m`Zkguf��_keb�[u�__fm`� hdZaZeky� g_\_jguf� _c�� G_� hklZ\eycl_� [_a� \gbfZgby� lZd`_� h[_� ZgZeh]bb� kijhZgZebabjh\Zgguf� gZfb� kbfilhfZlbq_kdbf� ^_ckl\b_f�� bf_xsb_� \Z`gh_� agZq_gb_� ^eyh[tykg_gby�kfukeZ�beb�gZf_j_gby�b hij_^_e_gby�hlghr_gby�d bf_xs_fmky�\ wlhc�kblmZpbb[_kkhagZl_evghfm�

Page 139: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

JZamf__lky�� l_f�kZfuf�g_�^Z_lky�hl\_lZ�gZ�\k_�\hijhku��dhlhju_�fu�fh]eb�ihklZ\blv�\k\yab�k wlbf�kemqZ_f��;hevr_�lh]h��wlh"�kemqZc�[he_agb�ihehg�^jm]bo�ijh[e_f��lZdbo��dhlhju_ihdZ� \hh[s_�g_jZaj_rbfu��b ^jm]bo�� dhlhju_�g_�fh]ml� [ulv� j_r_gu� \ke_^kl\b_� g_dhlhjuog_[eZ]hijbylguo� mkeh\bc�� GZijbf_j�� ihq_fm� wlZ� kqZkleb\Zy� \ [jZd_� `_gsbgZ� ih^^Z_lky\ex[e_gghklb�\ k\h_]h�ayly��b ihq_fm�h[e_]q_gb_��dhlhjh_�fh]eh�[u�[ulv�^hklb]gmlh�b ^jm]bfkihkh[hf��hkms_kl\ey_lky�\ nhjf_�lZdh]h�hljZ`_gby��ijh_dpbb�k\h_]h�kh[kl\_ggh]h�khklhygbygZ�fm`Z"�Gh�g_�^mfZcl_��qlh�klZ\blv�lZdb_�\hijhku�fh`gh�lhevdh�ba�ijZa^gh]h�ex[hiulkl\Z�< gZr_f�jZkihjy`_gbb�m`_�_klv�g_dhlhjuc�fZl_jbZe�^ey�\hafh`gh]h�hl\_lZ�gZ�gbo��IZpb_gldZgZoh^blky� \ lhf� djblbq_kdhf� \hajZkl_�� dh]^Z� k_dkmZevgZy� ihlj_[ghklv� m `_gsbg� \^jm]g_`_eZl_evgh�\hajZklZ_l��wlh]h�h^gh]h�m`_�^hklZlhqgh��Beb�d wlhfm�fh]eh�ijbkh_^bgblvky�lh�qlh� __ ^h[juc� b \_jguc� kmijm]� m`_� \ l_q_gb_� g_kdhevdbo� e_l� g_� h[eZ^Z_l� lhc� k_dkmZevghckihkh[ghklvx�� \ dhlhjhc� gm`^ZeZkv� ohjhrh� khojZgb\rZyky� `_gsbgZ� ^ey� k\h_]hm^h\e_l\hj_gby��Hiul� h[jZlbe� gZr_� \gbfZgb_� gZ� lh�� qlh� bf_ggh� lZdb_� fm`qbgu�� \_jghklvdhlhjuo�\iheg_�_kl_kl\_ggZ��hlebqZxlky�hkh[hc�g_`ghklvx�\ h[jZs_gbb�kh�k\hbfb�`_gZfb�bg_h[udgh\_gghc� l_jibfhklvx� d bo� g_j\guf� g_^m]Zf�� >Ze__�� g_[_ajZaebqgh�� qlh� bf_gghfheh^hc� fm`� ^hq_jb� klZe� h[t_dlhf� wlhc� iZlh]_gghc� \ex[e_gghklb�� KbevgZy� wjhlbq_kdZyijb\yaZgghklv� d ^hq_jb�� h[mkeh\e_ggZy� \ dhg_qghf� kq_l_� k_dkmZevghc� dhgklblmpb_c�fZl_jb�qZklh�gZoh^bl�k\h_�ijh^he`_gb_�\ lZdhf�ij_\jZs_gbb��Kf_x�\Zf�gZihfgblv�\ wlhc�k\yab��qlhhlghr_gby�f_`^m�l_s_c�b ayl_f�k ^Z\gbo�ihj�kqblZebkv�m ex^_c�hkh[_ggh�s_dhleb\ufb�b mi_j\h[ulguo� gZjh^h\� ^Zeb� ih\h^� ^ey� hq_gv� kljh]bo� ij_^ibkZgbc� lZ[m� b ©ba[_]Zgbyª� ^jm]^jm]Z �� Wlb� hlghr_gby� qZklh� i_j_oh^yl� `_eZl_evgmx� dmevlmjgmx� ]jZgbpm� dZd� \iheh`bl_evgmx�� lZd� b \� hljbpZl_evgmx� klhjhgm��DZdhc� ba� wlbo� lj_o�fhf_glh\� ijhy\beky� \gZr_f�kemqZ_��^\Z�eb�ba�gbo��\k_�eb�hgb�kh_^bgbebkv��wlh]h�y \Zf��ijZ\^Z��kdZaZlv�g_�fh]m��ghlhevdh�ihlhfm��qlh�m f_gy�g_�[ueh�\hafh`ghklb�ijh^he`blv� ZgZeba�^Zggh]h� kemqZy�[hevr_^\mo�qZkh\�L_i_jv� y aZf_qZx�� m\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� qlh� \k_� \j_fy� ]h\hjbe� h \_sZo�� dihgbfZgbx� dhlhjuo� \u� _s_� g_� ih^]hlh\e_gu�� Y k^_eZe� wlh� ^ey� lh]h�� qlh[u� kjZ\gblvikbobZljbx� k ikbohZgZebahf��: l_i_jv� y ohqm� kijhkblv� \Zk� h[� h^ghf�� aZf_lbeb� \u� dZdh_�gb[m^v� ijhlb\hj_qb_� f_`^m� gbfb"� IkbobZljby� g_� ihevam_lky� l_ogbq_kdbfb� f_lh^ZfbikbohZgZebaZ��hgZ�g_�ijh[m_l�k\yau\Zlv�qlh�lh�k kh^_j`Zgb_f�[j_^h\hc�b^_b�b��mdZau\Zy�gZgZke_^kl\_gghklv��^Z_l�gZf�hq_gv�h[smx�b hl^Ze_ggmx�wlbheh]bx��\f_klh�lh]h�qlh[u�ihdZaZlv[he__�qZklgu_�b [ebadb_�ijbqbgu��Gh�jZa\_�\ wlhf�djh_lky�ijhlb\hj_qb_��ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv"G_� y\ey_lky� eb� wlh� kdhj__� mkh\_jr_gkl\h\Zgb_f"� JZa\_� ijbagZgb_� gZke_^kl\_ggh]h�nZdlhjZmfZey_l�jhev�i_j_`b\Zgby��g_�h[t_^bgyxlky�eb�h[Z�nZdlhjZ�kZfuf�^_ckl\_gguf�h[jZahf"�<ukh]eZkbl_kv� kh�fghc�� qlh��ih� kms_kl\m�� \ ikbobZljbq_kdhc� jZ[hl_� g_l�gbq_]h�� qlh�fh]eh� [uijhlb\hj_qblv� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhfm� bkke_^h\Zgbx�� LZd� qlh� ikbobZlju� ijhlb\ylkyikbohZgZebam�� Z g_� ikbobZljby�� IkbohZgZeba� hlghkblky� d ikbobZljbb� ijb[ebabl_evgh� dZd]bklheh]by�d ZgZlhfbb��h^gZ�bamqZ_l�\g_rgb_�nhjfu�hj]Zgh\��^jm]Zy�²�bo�kljh_gb_�ba�ldZg_cb we_f_glZjguo�qZklbq_d��Ijhlb\hj_qb_�f_`^m�wlbfb�^\mfy�\b^Zfb�bamq_gby��h^gh�ba�dhlhjuoijh^he`Z_l�^jm]h_��ijhklh�ljm^gh�k_[_�ij_^klZ\blv��<u�agZ_l_��qlh�k_]h^y�ZgZlhfby�kqblZ_lkyhkgh\hc� gZmqghc� f_^bpbgu�� gh� [ueh� \j_fy�� dh]^Z� \kdju\Zlv� q_eh\_q_kdb_� ljmiu� ^ey� lh]h�qlh[u� ihagZdhfblvky� k \gmlj_ggbf� kljh_gb_f� l_eZ�� [ueh� lZd� `_� aZij_s_gh�� dZd� k_]h^gy

Page 140: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dZ`_lky�ij_^hkm^bl_evguf�aZgbfZlvky�ikbohZgZebahf��qlh[u�magZlv�h \gmlj_gg_f�f_oZgbaf_^mr_\ghc� `bagb�� B fh`_l� [ulv�� \ g_^Ze_dhf� [m^ms_f� fu� ihcf_f�� qlh� ]em[hdh� gZmqgZyikbobZljby�g_\hafh`gZ�[_a�ohjhr_]h�agZgby�]em[hdh�e_`Zsbo��[_kkhagZl_evguo�ijhp_kkh\�\^mr_\ghc�`bagb�<hafh`gh��kj_^b�\Zk�gZc^mlky�b klhjhggbdb�klhev�g_gZ\b^bfh]h�ikbohZgZebaZ��dhlhjuf[m^_l�ijbylgh��_keb�hg�kfh`_l�hijZ\^Zlvky�k >jm]hc��l_jZi_\lbq_kdhc�klhjhgu��<u�agZ_l_��qlhgZrZ�k_]h^gyrgyy�ikbobZljbq_kdZy�l_jZiby�g_�\ khklhygbb�\ha^_ckl\h\Zlv�gZ�[j_^h\u_�b^_b�Fh`_l� [ulv�� ikbohZgZeba� [eZ]h^Zjy� k\hbf� \a]ey^Zf� gZ� f_oZgbaf� >h[jZah\Zgby@� kbfilhfh\kihkh[_g�gZ�wlh"�G_l��]hkih^Z��hg�g_�fh`_l�wlh]h��hg�lZd�`_�[_kkbe_g�ijhlb\�wlh]h�g_^m]Z��dZdb ex[Zy� ^jm]Zy� l_jZiby�� ih� djZcg_c� f_j_�� ihdZ�� Ohly� fu� fh`_f� ihgylv�� qlh� ijhbahreh� k[hevguf��m gZk�g_l��h^gZdh��gbdZdh]h�kj_^kl\Z�k^_eZlv�wlh�ihgylguf�^ey�kZfbo�[hevguo��<ukeurZeb��qlh�fg_�m^Zehkv�lhevdh�gZqZlv�ZgZeba� wlhc�[j_^h\hc�b^_b��KlZg_l_�eb�\u�ihwlhfmml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�ZgZeba�lZdbo�kemqZ_\�g_�gm`_g��ihlhfm�qlh�[_kieh^_g"�Y ^mfZx��qlh�\k_�lZdbg_l�� Fu� bf__f� ijZ\h�� ^Z`_� h[yaZgghklv� ijh\h^blv� bkke_^h\Zgb_�� g_� kqblZykv� kg_ihkj_^kl\_gguf� ihe_aguf� wnn_dlhf�� < dhgp_� dhgph\� fu� g_� agZ_f�� ]^_� b dh]^Z� dZ`^ZyqZklbpZ�agZgby�ij_\jZlblky�\ mf_gb_��\ lhf�qbke_�b l_jZi_\lbq_kdh_��?keb�[u�ikbohZgZeba�[ue[u�lZdbf�`_�[_amki_rguf�\h�\k_o�^jm]bo�nhjfZo�g_j\guo�b ikbobq_kdbo�aZ[he_\Zgbc��dZd�\h[eZklb� [j_^h\uo� b^_c�� hg� \k_� jZ\gh� hklZeky� [u� iheghklvx� hijZ\^Zgguf� dZd� g_aZf_gbfh_kj_^kl\h�gZmqgh]h�bkke_^h\Zgby��Ohly�lh]^Z�fu�hdZaZebkv�[u�g_�\ khklhygbb�ijbf_gblv�_]h�ex^b�� gZ� dhlhjuo� fu� ohlbf� mqblvky��`b\u_� ex^b� kh� k\h_c� kh[kl\_gghc� \he_c� b ih� k\hbffhlb\Zf� mqZkl\mxsb_� \ jZ[hl_�� hldZaZeb� [u� gZf� \ wlhf�� JZaj_rbl_� fg_� ihwlhfm� k_]h^gyaZdhgqblv�khh[s_gb_f��qlh�_klv�[hevrb_�]jmiiu�g_j\guo�jZkkljhckl\��]^_�fu�^_ckl\bl_evghkfh]eb�\hiehlblv�gZrb� agZgby�\ l_jZi_\lbq_kdh_�mf_gb_��b qlh�ijb�ba\_klguo�mkeh\byo�fu^hklb]Z_f� \ kemqZyo� wlbo� aZ[he_\Zgbc�� h[uqgh� ljm^gh� ih^^Zxsboky� e_q_gbx�� mki_oh\�� g_mklmiZxsbo�gbdZdbf�^jm]bf�\ h[eZklb�\gmlj_gg_c�l_jZibb�K?FG:>P:L:Y�E?DPBYKfuke�kbfilhfh\M\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� GZ� ijhrehc� e_dpbb� y ]h\hjbe� \Zf�� qlh� debgbq_kdZyikbobZljby�h[jZsZ_l�fZeh�\gbfZgby�gZ�nhjfm�ijhy\e_gby�b kh^_j`Zgb_�hl^_evgh]h�kbfilhfZ�Z ikbohZgZeba� bf_ggh� k wlh]h� gZqbgZe� b mklZgh\be� ij_`^_� \k_]h�� qlh� kbfilhf� hkfuke_g� bk\yaZg� k i_j_`b\Zgb_f� [hevgh]h�� Kfuke� g_\jhlbq_kdbo� kbfilhfh\� [ue� hldjul� kgZqZeZ� B�;j_c_jhf�[eZ]h^Zjy�bamq_gbx�b mki_rghfm�bae_q_gbx�h^gh]h�kemqZy�bkl_jbb��klZ\r_]h�k l_oihj�agZf_gbluf������²�������<_jgh��qlh�Iv_j�@Zg_�g_aZ\bkbfh�>hl�g_]h@�^hdZaZe�lh�`_�kZfh_�njZgpmakdhfm�bkke_^h\Zl_ex�ijbgZ^e_`bl�^Z`_�ebl_jZlmjguc�ijbhjbl_l��ihlhfm�qlh�;j_c_jhim[ebdh\Ze� k\h_� gZ[ex^_gb_� ebrv� [he__� ^_kylb� e_l� kimkly� �����²������� khljm^gbqZy� khfghc�� <ijhq_f�� gZf� ^he`gh� [ulv� [_ajZaebqgh�� d_f� k^_eZgh� wlh� hldjulb_�� ihlhfm� qlh� \uagZ_l_��qlh�ex[h_�hldjulb_�^_eZ_lky�[hevr_��q_f�h^bg�jZa��b gb�h^gh�g_�^_eZ_lky�kjZam��Z mki_o\k_� jZ\gh� g_� khimlkl\m_l� aZkem]Zf�� :f_jbdZ� g_� ghkbl� bfy� Dhemf[Z�� >h� ;j_c_jZ� b @Zg_djmiguc�ikbobZlj�E_j_�\ukdZaZe�fg_gb_��qlh�^Z`_�[j_^u�^mr_\gh[hevguo�^he`gu�[ueb�[u

Page 141: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[ulv�ijbagZgu�hkfuke_ggufb��_keb�[u�fu�lhevdh�mf_eb�bo�i_j_\h^blv��IjbagZxkv��y ^he]h_\j_fy�hq_gv�\ukhdh�hp_gb\Ze�aZkem]m�I��@Zg_�\ h[tykg_gbb�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�kbfilhfh\��lZd�dZdhg�ihgbfZe�bo�dZd�\ujZ`_gb_�LGHHV�LQFRQVFLHQWHV ��\eZ^_xsbo�[hevgufb��Gh�ihke_�lh]h�@Zg_�kqj_a\uqZcghc� k^_j`Zgghklvx� \ukdZau\Zeky� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� dZd� [m^lh� ohl_e�ijbagZlvky�� qlh[_kkhagZl_evgh_� [ueh� ^ey� g_]h� g_� q_f� bguf�� dZd� kihkh[hf� \ujZ`_gby�� \kihfh]Zl_evgufkj_^kl\hf��beb� LDTRQ�GH�SDUOHU ��ih^�wlbf�hg�g_�ih^jZamf_\Ze�gbq_]h�j_Zevgh]h��K l_o�ihj�y[hevr_�g_�ihgbfZx�jZkkm`^_gbc�@Zg_��gh�iheZ]Zx��qlh�hg�kh\_jr_ggh�gZijZkgh�ebrbe�k_[yfgh]bo�aZkem]�BlZd�� g_\jhlbq_kdb_� kbfilhfu�� dZd� hrb[hqgu_� ^_ckl\by�� dZd� kgh\b^_gby�� bf_xl� k\hckfuke�b lZd�`_��dZd�hgb��ih�k\h_fm� k\yaZgu� k `bagvx�ebp��m dhlhjuo�hgb�h[gZjm`b\Zxlky�Wlhl�\Z`guc�j_amevlZl�bkke_^h\Zgby�fg_�ohl_ehkv�[u�ihykgblv�\Zf�g_kdhevdbfb�ijbf_jZfb�Fh`gh�lhevdh�ml\_j`^Zlv��gh�g_�^hdZaZlv��qlh�lZd�[u\Z_l�\k_]^Z�b \h�\k_o�kemqZyo��Lhl��dlhihiulZ_lky� ijbh[j_klb� k\hc� kh[kl\_gguc� hiul�� m[_^blky� \ wlhf�� Gh� ih� ba\_klgufkhh[jZ`_gbyf� y \havfm� wlb� ijbf_ju� g_� ba� h[eZklb� bkl_jbb�� Z ba� h[eZklb� ^jm]h]h�� \_kvfZkljZggh]h��\ ijbgpbi_�hq_gv�[ebadh]h�_c�g_\jhaZ��h dhlhjhf�y ^he`_g�\Zf�kdZaZlv�g_kdhevdh�\\h^guo�keh\��Wlhl�lZd�gZau\Z_fuc�g_\jha�gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc�g_�klhev�ihimeyj_g��dZd�\k_fba\_klgZy�bkl_jby�� hg�� _keb�fh`gh� lZd� \ujZablvky��g_� klhev� \uau\Zxs_�rmfeb\�� \uklmiZ_lkdhj__�qZklguf�^_ehf�[hevgh]h��ihqlb�iheghklvx�hldZau\Z_lky�hl�khfZlbq_kdbo�ijhy\e_gbc�b\k_�k\hb�kbfilhfu�kha^Z_l�\ ^mr_\ghc�h[eZklb��G_\jha�gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc�b �;_kkhagZl_evguo�b^_c��njZgp�����Ijbf_q�i_j� �J_q_\uf�h[hjhlhf��njZgp����Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�bkl_jby�²�wlh�l_�nhjfu�g_\jhlbq_kdh]h�aZ[he_\Zgby��gZ�bamq_gbb�dhlhjuo�ij_`^_�\k_]h�b[ue�ihkljh_g�ikbohZgZeba��\ e_q_gbb�dhlhjuo�gZrZ�l_jZiby�lZd`_�^hklb]Z_l�k\h_]h�ljbmfnZ�Gh� g_\jha� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc�� dhlhjuc� h[oh^bl� lhl� aZ]Z^hqguc� kdZqhd� ba� ^mr_\gh]h� \khfZlbq_kdh_�� [eZ]h^Zjy� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhfm� bkke_^h\Zgbx� klZe� gZf�� kh[kl\_ggh� ]h\hjy�[he__�ykguf�b agZdhfuf��q_f�bkl_jby��b fu�magZeb��qlh�hij_^_e_ggu_�djZcgb_�oZjZdl_jgu_g_\jhlbq_kdb_�q_jlu�\ g_f�ijhy\eyxlky�gZfgh]h�j_aq_�G_\jha�gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc�\ujZ`Z_lky�\ lhf��qlh�[hevgu_�aZgylu�fukeyfb��dhlhjufbhgb��kh[kl\_ggh��g_�bgl_j_kmxlky��qm\kl\mxl�\ k_[_�bfimevku��dZ`msb_ky�bf�\_kvfZ�qm`^ufb�b ih[m`^_gby� d ^_ckl\byf�� \uiheg_gb_� dhlhjuo� ohly� b g_� ^hklZ\ey_l� bf� gbdZdh]hm^h\hevkl\by��gh�hldZaZlvky�hl�g_]h�hgb�gbdZd�g_�fh]ml��Fukeb� �gZ\yaqb\u_�ij_^klZ\e_gby�kZfb� ih� k_[_�fh]ml� [ulv� [_kkfuke_ggufb� beb�`_� lhevdh� [_ajZaebqgufb� ^ey� bg^b\b^mmfZ�qZklh� hgb� kh\_jr_ggh� g_e_iu�� \h� \kydhf� kemqZ_�� hgb� y\eyxlky� j_amevlZlhf� gZijy`_gghc�bagmjbl_evghc�^ey�[hevgh]h�fukebl_evghc�^_yl_evghklb��dhlhjhc�hg�hq_gv�g_hohlgh�hl^Z_lky�Ijhlb\�k\h_c�\heb�hg�^he`_g�aZgbfZlvky�kZfhdhiZgb_f�b jZa^mfu\Zlv��dZd�[m^lh�^_eh�b^_l�h_]h� kZfuo� \Z`guo�`bag_gguo� aZ^ZqZo��Bfimevku�� dhlhju_� [hevghc� qm\kl\m_l� \ k_[_��fh]mlijhba\h^blv� lZd`_�\i_qZle_gb_�g_e_ih]h�j_[yq_kl\Z��gh�ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�hgb�bf_xl� kZfh_kljZrgh_�kh^_j`Zgb_��lbiZ�ihiulhd�d kh\_jr_gbx�ly`dbo�ij_klmie_gbc��lZd�qlh�[hevghc�g_lhevdh� hljbpZ_l� bo� dZd� qm`^u_�� gh� \ m`Zk_� [_`bl� hl� gbo� b aZsbsZ_lky� hl� bo� bkiheg_gbyaZij_lZfb�� hldZaZfb� b h]jZgbq_gbyfb� k\h_c� k\h[h^u�� Ijb� wlhf� \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� hgb

Page 142: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gbdh]^Z��gb�jZam�g_�^hoh^yl�^h�bkiheg_gby��\ j_amevlZl_�ih[_`^Zxl�[_]kl\h�b hklhjh`ghklv�Lh�� qlh� [hevghc� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� bkihegy_l� dZd� lZd� gZau\Z_fu_� gZ\yaqb\u_� ^_ckl\by�²[_ah[b^gu_�� g_khfg_ggh� g_agZqbl_evgu_� ^_ckl\by�� ih� [hevr_c� qZklb� ih\lhj_gby�p_j_fhgbZevgu_� mdjZr_gby� ^_yl_evghkl_c� h[u^_gghc� `bagb�� ba�aZ� q_]h� wlb� g_h[oh^bfu_hlijZ\e_gby�`bag_gguo�ihlj_[ghkl_c��hloh^�dh�kgm��mfu\Zgb_��lmZe_l��ijh]medZ�²�klZgh\ylky\ \ukr_c� kl_i_gb� ijh^he`bl_evgufb� b ij_\jZsZxlky� \ ihqlb� g_jZaj_rbfu_� ijh[e_fu�;he_ag_ggu_� ij_^klZ\e_gby�� bfimevku� b ^_ckl\by� \ hl^_evguo� nhjfZo� b kemqZyo� g_\jhaZgZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc� khq_lZxlky� ^Ze_dh� g_� \ jZ\guo� qZklyo�� kms_kl\m_l� kdhj__� ijZ\behij_h[eZ^Zgby� \ >h[s_c@� dZjlbg_� h^gh]h� beb� ^jm]h]h� ba� wlbo� fhf_glh\�� qlh� b ^Z_l� [he_agbgZa\Zgb_��h^gZdh�h[sb_�q_jlu�\k_o�wlbo�nhjf�^hklZlhqgh�hq_\b^gu�Wlh�� dhg_qgh�� qm^h\bsgh_� kljZ^Zgb_�� Y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� kZfhc� g_h[ma^ZgghcikbobZljbq_kdhc�nZglZabb�g_�m^Zehkv�[u�ijb^mfZlv�gbq_]h�ih^h[gh]h��b _keb�[u�wlh]h�g_evay[ueh�\b^_lv�_`_^g_\gh��gbdlh�[u�g_�j_rbeky�wlhfm�ih\_jblv��Gh�g_�ih^mfZcl_��qlh�\u�hdZ`_l_[hevghfm� mkem]m�� _keb� [m^_l_� _]h� m]h\Zjb\Zlv� hl\e_qvky�� g_� aZgbfZlvky� �wlbfb� ]emiufbfukeyfb�� Z k^_eZlv� qlh�gb[m^v� jZamfgh_� \f_klh� k\hbo� imklydh\���Hg� b kZf� [u� wlh]h� ohl_e�ihlhfm�qlh� _]h� khagZgb_� kh\_jr_ggh� ykgh��hg�jZa^_ey_l� \Zr_� km`^_gb_� h k\hbo�gZ\yaqb\uokbfilhfZo��^Z�hg�kZf�\Zf�h[�wlhf�jZkkdZau\Z_l��Hg�lhevdh�g_�fh`_l�bgZq_��lh��qlh�\ g_\jha_gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc� ijhju\Z_lky� d ^_ckl\bx�� ^_eZ_lky� k lZdhc� wg_j]b_c�� ^ey� dhlhjhc�\_jhylgh�� g_l� gbdZdh]h� kjZ\g_gby� \ ghjfZevghc� ^mr_\ghc� `bagb�� Hg� fh`_l� ebrv� h^gh�kf_klblv�� aZf_gblv�� mihlj_[blv� \f_klh� h^ghc� ]emihc� b^_b� ^jm]mx�� g_kdhevdh� hkeZ[e_ggmx�i_j_clb� hl� h^ghc� ij_^hklhjh`ghklb� beb� aZij_lZ� d ^jm]hfm�� \uihegblv� \f_klh� h^gh]hp_j_fhgbZeZ� ^jm]hc�� Hg� fh`_l� kf_klblv� gZ\yaqb\h_� khklhygb_�� gh� g_� mkljZgblv� _]h�Kihkh[ghklv�\k_o� kbfilhfh\� k^\b]Zlvky�ih^Zevr_�hl� k\h_c�i_j\hgZqZevghc�nhjfu� y\ey_lky]eZ\ghc�oZjZdl_jghc�q_jlhc�_]h�[he_agb��djhf_�lh]h��[jhkZ_lky�\ ]eZaZ��qlh�ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb�iheyjghklb���dhlhjufb�ihegZ�^mr_\gZy�`bagv��\ _]h�khklhygbb�ijhy\eyxlky�hkh[_ggh�j_adhjZa^_e_ggufb�� GZjy^m� k gZ\yaqb\uf� khklhygb_f� iheh`bl_evgh]h� beb� hljbpZl_evgh]hkh^_j`Zgby�\ bgl_ee_dlmZevghc�h[eZklb�\hagbdZ_l�khfg_gb_��ihkl_i_ggh�ih^lZqb\Zxs__�^Z`_kZfh_� gZ^_`gh_� \ h[uqguo� mkeh\byo�� <k_� \f_kl_� ijb\h^bl� dh� \k_� \hajZklZxs_cg_j_rbl_evghklb�� hlkmlkl\bx� wg_j]bb�� h]jZgbq_gbx� k\h[h^u�� Ijb� wlhf� kljZ^ZxsbcgZ\yaqb\uf� khklhygb_f� g_\jhlbd� bkoh^gh� bf__l� \_kvfZ� wg_j]bqguc� oZjZdl_j�� qZklhqj_a\uqZcgh�mijyf��dZd�ijZ\beh��bgl_ee_dlmZevgh�h^Zj_g�\ur_�kj_^g_]h�mjh\gy��Ih�[hevr_cqZklb� hg� ^hklb]Z_l� \ukhdhc� kl_i_gb� wlbq_kdh]h� jZa\blby�� hlebqZ_lky� qj_af_jghckh\_kleb\hklvx�� dhjj_dl_g� [hevr_� h[udgh\_ggh]h��Fh`_l_� k_[_� ij_^klZ\blv�� dZdbo� ljm^h\klhbl�ohlv�kdhevdh�gb[m^v�jZah[jZlvky�\ wlhf�ijhlb\hj_qb\hf�khq_lZgbb�k\hckl\�oZjZdl_jZ�bkbfilhfh\�[he_agb��IhdZ�fu�b g_�klj_fbfky�gb�d q_fm�^jm]hfm��dZd�d ihgbfZgbx�g_dhlhjuokbfilhfh\�wlhc�[he_agb��d >ijbh[j_l_gbx@�\hafh`ghklb�bo�lhedh\Zgby�;ulv�fh`_l��bf_y�\ \b^m�gZr_�h[km`^_gb_��\u� aZohlbl_�ij_`^_�magZlv��dZd�hlghkblky�dijh[e_fZf�g_\jhaZ�gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc�kh\j_f_ggZy�ikbobZljby��Gh�wlh�[_kihe_agh_�^_eh�IkbobZljby�^Z_l�jZaebqguf�gZ\yaqb\uf�khklhygbyf�gZa\Zgby��gh�[hevr_�gbq_]h�g_�]h\hjbl�hgbo�� AZlh� hgZ� ih^q_jdb\Z_l�� qlh� ghkbl_eb� wlbo� kbfilhfh\� ©^_]_g_jZluª�� Wlh� fZehm^h\e_l\hjy_l��wlh��kh[kl\_ggh��hp_gdZ��km`^_gb_�\f_klh�h[tykg_gby��GZf�ke_^m_l� agZlv��qlhbf_ggh�m ex^_c� lZdh]h� kdeZ^Z�b \klj_qZxlky�\k_\hafh`gu_� kljZgghklb��Fu�^Z`_�iheZ]Z_f�

Page 143: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

qlh�ebpZ��m dhlhjuo�jZa\b\Zxlky�lZdb_�kbfilhfu��^he`gu�[ulv�hl�ijbjh^u�bgufb��q_f�^jm]b_ex^b�� Gh� ohl_ehkv� [u� kijhkblv�� y\eyxlky� eb� hgb� [he__� ©^_]_gZjZ�lZfbª�� q_f� ^jm]b_g_j\gh[hevgu_��gZijbf_j��bkl_jbdb�beb�[hevgu_�ikbohaZfb"�OZjZdl_jbklbdZ��hq_\b^gh��hiylvkebrdhf� h[sZy�� B fh`gh� ^Z`_� aZkhfg_\Zlvky� \ __� ijZ\bevghklb�� _keb� magZ_rv�� qlh� lZdb_kbfilhfu�\klj_qZxlky�m aZf_qZl_evguo�ex^_c�k hkh[_ggh�\ukhdhc�b ihe_aghc�^ey�h[s_kl\ZjZ[hlhkihkh[ghklvx��H[uqgh�fu� agZ_f�fZeh� bglbfgh]h� h gZrbo� h[jZaph\h� \_ebdbo� ex^yo[eZ]h^Zjy�bo�kh[kl\_gghc�kdjulghklb�b e`b\hklb�bo�[bh]jZnh\��gh�bgh]^Z�[u\Z_l��qlh�dlh�lhy\ey_lky� lZdbf� nZgZlbdhf� ijZ\^u�� dZd� Wfbev� Ahey�� b lh]^Z� fu� magZ_f�� kdhev� fgh]bfbkljZggufb�gZ\yaqb\ufb�ijb\uqdZfb�hg�kljZ^Ze�\kx�k\hx�`bagv� �Lh]^Z� ikbobZljby� gZreZ� \uoh^�� ]h\hjy� h 'HJHQHUHV� VXSHULHDUV� �� Ij_djZkgh� ²� gh[eZ]h^Zjy�ikbohZgZebam�fu�magZeb��qlh�wlb�kljZggu_�gZ� Lmema�W��Wfbev�Ahey��f_^bdh�ikboheh]bq_kdh_�bkke_^h\Zgb_��IZjb`�������� �<ukrbo�^_]_g_jZlZo��njZgp���²Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�\yaqb\u_�kbfilhfu��dZd�^jm]b_�g_^m]b�b m�^jm]bo�ex^_c��g_^_]_g_jZlh\��fh`gh�gZ^he]hmkljZgblv��Fg_�kZfhfm�wlh�g_h^ghdjZlgh�m^Z\Zehkv�Ohqm�ijb\_klb�\Zf�ebrv�^\Z�ijbf_jZ�ZgZebaZ�gZ\yaqb\h]h�kbfilhfZ��h^bg�ba�^Z\gbrg_]hgZ[ex^_gby�� dhlhjuc� y g_�fh]m� aZf_gblv� emqrbf��b ^jm]hc�� \klj_lb\rbcky�fg_�g_^Z\gh��Yh]jZgbqmkv� wlbf� g_agZqbl_evguf� qbkehf� ijbf_jh\�� ihlhfm� qlh� ijb� lZdhf� khh[s_gbbijboh^blky�[ulv�hq_gv�h[klhyl_evguf��\oh^blv�\h�\k_�ih^jh[ghklb�H^gZ� ihqlb� ���e_lgyy� ^ZfZ�� kljZ^Z\rZy� kZfufb� ly`_eufb� gZ\yaqb\ufb� y\e_gbyfb�dhlhjhc�y��ih`Zemc��ihfh]�[u��_keb�[u�dh\Zjguc�kemqZc�g_�khj\Ze�fh_c�jZ[hlu�²�fh`_l�[ulv�y _s_�jZkkdZ`m�\Zf�h[�wlhf�²�g_kdhevdh�jZa�\ ^_gv�ijh^_eu\ZeZ�f_`^m�ijhqbf�ke_^mxs__kljZggh_�gZ\yaqb\h_�^_ckl\b_��HgZ�\u[_]ZeZ�ba�k\h_c�dhfgZlu�\ khk_^gxx��klZgh\beZkv�lZf�gZhij_^_e_ggh_�f_klh�m klhy\r_]h�ihk_j_^bg_�klheZ��a\hgbeZ�]hjgbqghc��^Z\ZeZ�_c�dZdh_�gb[m^vg_agZqbl_evgh_�ihjmq_gb_�beb�hlimkdZeZ�gb k�q_f�b aZl_f�m[_]ZeZ�h[jZlgh��Wlh��dhg_qgh�g_ly`_euc�[he_ag_gguc�kbfilhf��gh�hg�fh]�\k_�lZdb�\ua\Zlv�ex[hiulkl\h��H[tykg_gb_�y\behkvkZfuf� _kl_kl\_gguf�� g_� ^himkdZxsbf� \hajZ`_gbc� h[jZahf�� bkdexqZxsbf� \kydh_\f_rZl_evkl\h�kh�klhjhgu�\jZqZ��Y kh\_jr_ggh�g_�ij_^klZ\eyx�k_[_��dZd�[u�y fh]�ijbclb�ddZdhfm�eb[h� ij_^iheh`_gbx� h kfuke_� wlh]h� gZ\yaqb\h]h� ^_ckl\by�� d dZdhfm�eb[hij_^iheh`_gbx�hlghkbl_evgh�_]h�lhedh\Zgby��Kdhevdh�y gb�kijZrb\Ze�[hevgmx�©Ihq_fm� \u� wlh� ^_eZ_l_�� dZdhc� wlh� bf__l� kfuke"ª� ²� hgZ� hl\_qZeZ�� ©Y g_� agZxª�� Ghh^gZ`^u��ihke_�lh]h��dZd�fg_�m^Zehkv�ih[hjhlv�__ \Z`gh_�ijbgpbibZevgh_�khfg_gb_��hgZ�\^jm]hkhagZeZ�b jZkkdZaZeZ� \k_�� qlh�bf_eh� hlghr_gb_� d gZ\yaqb\hfm� ^_ckl\bx�� ;he__� ^_kylb� e_llhfm�gZaZ^�hgZ�\ureZ�aZfm`�aZ�q_eh\_dZ�gZfgh]h�klZjr_�g__��dhlhjuc�hdZaZeky�bfihl_glhf�\i_j\mx�[jZqgmx�ghqv��;_kqbke_ggh_�fgh`_kl\h�jZa�\[_]Ze�hg�ba� k\h_c�dhfgZlu�\ __��qlh[uih\lhjblv� ihiuldm�� gh� dZ`^uc� jZa� [_amki_rgh��Mljhf� hg� k ^hkZ^hc� kdZaZe�� ©<_^v� klu^ghi_j_^�]hjgbqghc��dh]^Z�hgZ�[m^_l�m[bjZlv�ihkl_evª��ko\Zlbe�[mluedm�djZkguo�q_jgbe��dhlhjZykemqZcgh�hdZaZeZkv�\ dhfgZl_��b \uebe�__ kh^_j`bfh_�gZ�ijhklugx��gh�g_�gZ�lh�f_klh��dhlhjh_fh]eh� [u� bf_lv� ijZ\h� gZ� lZdh_� iylgh�� KgZqZeZ� y g_� ihgye�� qlh� h[s_]h� f_`^m� wlbf\hkihfbgZgb_f� b h[km`^Z_fuf� gZ\yaqb\uf� ^_ckl\b_f�� lZd� dZd� gZoh^be� koh^kl\h� lhevdh� \

Page 144: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ih\lhjyxs_fky�\u[_]Zgbc�b \[_]Zgbb�\ dhfgZlm�b dh_�qlh�_s_�\ ihy\e_gbb�]hjgbqghc��Lh]^ZiZpb_gldZ�ih^\_eZ�f_gy�d klhem�\h�\lhjhc�dhfgZl_�b ihdZaZeZ�[hevrh_�iylgh�gZ�kdZl_jlb��HgZh[tykgbeZ� lZd`_�� qlh� klZgh\blky� m klheZ� lZd�� qlh[u� \ua\ZggZy� _x� ^_\mrdZ� g_� fh]eZ� g_aZf_lblv�iylgZ��L_i_jv�g_evay� [ueh� khfg_\Zlvky� \ bglbfghc� k\yab�f_`^m� lhc� kp_ghc�ihke_[jZqghc�ghqb�b __�l_i_j_rgbf�gZ\yaqb\uf�^_ckl\b_f��gZ� wlhf�ijbf_j_��h^gZdh��fh`gh�_s_fgh]hfm�ihmqblvky�Ij_`^_�\k_]h��ykgh��qlh�iZpb_gldZ�b^_glbnbpbjm_l�k_[y�kh�k\hbf�fm`_f��hgZ�b]jZ_l�_]hjhev��ih^jZ`Zy�_]h�[_]hlg_�ba�h^ghc�dhfgZlu�\ ^jm]mx��Ijb^_j`b\Zykv�wlh]h�kjZ\g_gby��fu^he`gu� kh]eZkblvky� ^Ze__�� qlh� djh\Zlv� b ijhklugx� hgZ� aZf_sZ_l� klhehf� b kdZl_jvx�� WlhihdZaZehkv�[u�ijhba\hevguf��gh�fu�g_�ajy�bamqZeb�kbf\hebdm�kgh\b^_gbc��< kgh\b^_gbb�dZdjZa�hq_gv�qZklh�\b^yl� klhe��dhlhjuc� ke_^m_l� lhedh\Zlv��h^gZdh��dZd�djh\Zlv��Klhe�b djh\Zlv\f_kl_�khklZ\eyxl�[jZd��ihwlhfm�h^gh�e_ldh�klZ\blky�\f_klh�^jm]h]h�Lh��qlh�gZ\yaqb\h_�^_ckl\b_�bf__l�kfuke��dZd�[m^lh�m`_�^hdZaZgh�hgh�dZ`_lky�bah[jZ`_gb_f��ih\lhj_gb_f�lhc�agZqbfhc�kp_gu��Gh�gZk�gbdlh�g_�aZklZ\ey_lh]jZgbqb\Zlvky� wlbf� \g_rgbf� koh^kl\hf�� _keb� fu� bkke_^m_f� hlghr_gb_� f_`^m� h[hbfbih^jh[g__�� lh�� \_jhylgh�� gZf� hldjh_lky� g_qlh� [he__� ]em[hdh_� ²� gZf_j_gb_� gZ\yaqb\h]h^_ckl\by�� ?]h� y^jhf�� hq_\b^gh�� y\ey_lky� \uah\� ]hjgbqghc�� dhlhjhc� hgZ� ihdZau\Z_l� iylgh� \ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv� aZf_qZgbx� k\h_]h�fm`Z�� klu^gh�i_j_^�^_\mrdhc��Hg��jhev�dhlhjh]h�hgZb]jZ_l��lZdbf�h[jZahf��g_�klu^blky�^_\mrdb��iylgh��km^y�ih�wlhfm��gZ�ijZ\bevghf�f_kl_��BlZd�fu� \b^bf�� qlh� hgZ� g_� ijhklh� ih\lhjbeZ� kp_gm�� Z ijh^he`beZ� __ b� bkijZ\beZ�� ij_\jZlb\� \ijZ\bevgmx�� Gh� wlbf� hgZ� bkijZ\ey_l� b ^jm]h_�� qlh� [ueh� lZd� fmqbl_evgh� \ lm� ghqv� bihlj_[h\Zeh�^ey�\uoh^Z�ba�iheh`_gby�djZkguo�q_jgbe�²�bfihl_gpbx��GZ\yaqb\h_�^�_ckl\b_]h\hjbl�� g_l�� wlh� g_\_jgh�� _fm� g_q_]h� klu^blvky� ]hjgbqghc�� hg� b_� [ue� bfihl_glhf�� hghbah[jZ`Z_l��dZd�\ kgh\b^_gbb��wlh�`_eZgb_�\uiheg_gguf�\ gZklhys_f�^_ckl\bb��hgh�kem`blgZf_j_gbx�\ha\ukblv�fm`Z�gZ^�lh]^Zrg_c�g_m^Zq_c�Kx^Z�ijb[Z\ey_lky�\k_�lh��qlh�y fh]�[u�jZkkdZaZlv�\Zf�h[�wlhc�`_gsbg_��\_jg__�]h\hjy�\k_�� qlh� fu� h g_c� _s_� agZ_f�� mdZau\Z_l� gZf� imlv� d wlhfm� lhedh\Zgbx� kZfh]h� ih� k_[_g_ihgylgh]h�gZ\yaqb\h]h�^_ckl\by��M`_�fgh]h�e_l�`_gsbgZ�`b\_l�hl^_evgh�hl�k\h_]h�fm`Z�b[hj_lky�k gZf_j_gb_f�jZklhj]gmlv�k\hc�[jZd�ih�km^m��Gh�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�b j_qb�h lhf��qlh[uhgZ�hk\h[h^beZkv�hl�g_]h�� hgZ� \ugm`^_gZ� hklZ\Zlvky� _fm� \_jghc�� hl^Zey_lky� hl� \k_]h� k\_lZ�qlh[u�g_�\iZklv�\ bkdmr_gb_��\ k\h_c�nZglZabb�hgZ�ba\bgy_l�b \ha\_ebqb\Z_l�_]h��>Z��kZfZy]em[hdZy� lZcgZ� __ [he_agb� \ lhf�� qlh� [eZ]h^Zjy� _c� hgZ� hojZgy_l� fm`Z� hl� aeuo� kie_l_g�hijZ\^u\Z_l�k\h_�hl^Ze_gb_�hl�g_]h�b ^Z_l�_fm�\hafh`ghklv�\_klb�ihdhcgmx�hl^_evgmx�`bagv�LZd� ZgZeba� [_ah[b^gh]h�gZ\yaqb\h]h� ^_ckl\by� \u\h^bl� gZ�ijyfhc�imlv� d kZfhfm� ]em[hdhfmy^jm�aZ[he_\Zgby��gh�\ lh�`_�\j_fy�\u^Z_l�gZf�agZqbl_evgmx�^hex�lZcgu�g_\jhaZ�gZ\yaqb\uokhklhygbc�\hh[s_��Y hohlgh� aZ^_j`b\Zx�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�wlhf�ijbf_j_��ihlhfm�qlh�\ g_fkh_^bgyxlky� mkeh\by�� dhlhjuo� ih� kijZ\_^eb\hklb� g_evay� lj_[h\Zlv� hl� \k_o� kemqZ_\�� A^_kv[hevgZy� kjZam�gZreZ� lhedh\Zgb_� kbfilhfZ� [_a� jmdh\h^kl\Z� beb� \f_rZl_evkl\Z� ZgZeblbdZ�� bhgh� hkms_kl\behkv� [eZ]h^Zjy� k\yab� k i_j_`b\Zgb_f�� hlghkysbfky� g_� d aZ[ulhfm� ^_lkdhfmi_jbh^m�� dZd� wlh� h[uqgh� [u\Z_l�� Z kemqb\rbfky� \ aj_ehc� `bagb� [hevghc� b hklZ\b\rbfg_ba]eZ^bfuc� ke_^� \ __� iZfylb�� <k_� \hajZ`_gby�� dhlhju_� djblbdZ� bf__l� h[udgh\_gb_

Page 145: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijb\h^blv� ijhlb\� gZrbo� lhedh\Zgbc� kbfilhfh\�� \ wlhf� hl^_evghf� kemqZ_� kgbfZxlky�JZamf__lky��^_eh�m gZk�h[klhbl�r_�\k_]^Z�klhev�ohjhrh�B _s_�h^gh��G_�[jhkbehkv�eb�\Zf�\ ]eZaZ��dZd�wlh�g_aZf_lgh_�gZ\yaqb\h_�^_ckl\b_�\\_ehgZk� \ bglbfgmx� `bagv� iZpb_gldb"�@_gsbgZ� \jy^� eb� fh`�_l� jZkkdZaZlv� qlh�gb[m^v� [he__bglbfgh_��q_f�bklhjbx�k\h_c�i_j\hc�[jZqghc�ghqb��b jZa\_�kemqZcgh�b g_agZqbl_evgh�lh��qlhfu� ijbreb� bf_ggh� d bglbfghklyf� iheh\hc�`bagb"�IjZ\^Z�� wlh�fh]eh� [u� [ulv� ke_^kl\b_fk^_eZggh]h� fghx� gZ� wlhl� jZa� \u[hjZ�� G_� [m^_f� lhjhiblvky� k km`^_gb_f� b h[jZlbfky� dh\lhjhfm��kh\_jr_ggh�bghfm�ijbf_jm�qZklh�\klj_qZxs_]hky�^_ckl\by��Z bf_ggh�d p_j_fhgbZemmdeZ^u\Zgby�kiZlv�>_\ylgZ^pZlbe_lgyy� p\_lmsZy� h^Zj_ggZy� ^_\mrdZ�� _^bgkl\_gguc� j_[_ghd� k\hbojh^bl_e_c�� dhlhjuo� hgZ� ij_\hkoh^bl� ih� h[jZah\Zgbx� b bgl_ee_dlmZevghc� Zdlb\ghklb�� [uyZg_m]hfhgguf� b rZeh\eb\uf� j_[_gdhf�� Z \� l_q_gb_� ihke_^gbo� e_l� [_a� \b^bfuo� \g_rgboijbqbg�ij_\jZlbeZkv�\ g_j\gh[hevgmx��HgZ�hq_gv�jZa^jZ`bl_evgZ��hkh[_ggh�ijhlb\�fZl_jb�\k_]^Z�g_^h\hevgZ��m^jmq_gZ��kdehggZ�d g_j_rbl_evghklb�b khfg_gbx�b��GZdhg_p��ijbagZ_lky�qlh�g_�\ khklhygbb�[hevr_�h^gZ�oh^blv�ih�iehsZ^yf�b [hevrbf�mebpZf��Fu�g_�[m^_f�fgh]haZgbfZlvky� __ keh`guf� [he_ag_gguf� khklhygb_f�� lj_[mxsbf� ih� f_gvr_c� f_j_� ^\mo^bZ]ghah\�� Z]hjZnh[bb�b g_\jhaZ�gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc�� Z hklZgh\bfky� lhevdh�gZ� lhf��qlh� mwlhc� ^_\mrdb� jZa\beky� lZd`_� p_j_fhgbZe� mdeZ^u\Zgby� kiZlv�� hl� dhlhjh]h� hgZ� aZklZ\ey_lkljZ^Zlv�k\hbo�jh^bl_e_c��Fh`gh�kdZaZlv��qlh�\ ba\_klghf�kfuke_�ex[hc�ghjfZevguc�q_eh\_dbf__l� k\hc� p_j_fhgbZe� mdeZ^u\Zgby� kiZlv� beb� lj_[m_l� kh[ex^_gby� hij_^_e_gguo� mkeh\bc�g_\uiheg_gb_�dhlhjuo�f_rZ_l�_fm�aZkgmlv��hg�h[e_d�i_j_oh^�hl�khklhygby�[h^jkl\h\Zgby�dhkgm�\ hij_^_e_ggu_�nhjfu��dhlhju_�hg�h^bgZdh\uf�h[jZahf�ih\lhjy_l�dZ`^uc�\_q_j��Gh�\k_�qlh� lj_[m_l� a^hjh\uc� hl� mkeh\bc� ^ey� kgZ�� fh`gh� jZpbhgZevgh� ihgylv�� b _keb� \g_rgb_h[klhyl_evkl\Z� \uau\Zxl� g_h[oh^bfu_� baf_g_gby�� lh� hg� e_]dh� ih^qbgy_lky�� GhiZlheh]bq_kdbc� p_j_fhgbZe� g_mklmiqb\�� hg� mf__l� ^h[blvky� k\h_]h� p_ghc� kZfuo� [hevrbo`_jl\�� b hg� lhqgh� lZd�`_� ijbdju\Z_lky� jZpbhgZevguf� h[hkgh\Zgb_f� b ijb� ih\_joghklghfjZkkfhlj_gbb� dZ`_lky� hlebqZxsbfky� hl� ghjfZevgh]h� ebrv� g_dhlhjhc� ij_m\_ebq_gghclsZl_evghklvx�� Gh� _keb� ijbkfhlj_lvky� ih[eb`_�� lh� fh`gh� aZf_lblv�� qlh� ihdju\ZehjZpbhgZevghklb�kebrdhf�dhjhldh��qlh�p_j_fhgbZe�\dexqZ_l�lj_[h\Zgby��^Ze_dh�\uoh^ysb_�aZjZpbhgZevgh_�h[hkgh\Zgb_��b ^jm]b_��ijyfh�ijhlb\hj_qZsb_�_fm��GZrZ�iZpb_gldZ�\ dZq_kl\_fhlb\Z� k\hbo� ghqguo� ij_^hklhjh`ghkl_c� ijb\h^bl� lh�� qlh� ^ey� kgZ� _c� gm`_g� ihdhc� b hgZ^he`gZ� mkljZgblv� \k_� bklhqgbdb� rmfZ�� K wlhc� p_evx� hgZ� ihklmiZ_l� ^\hydbf� h[jZahf�hklZgZ\eb\Z_l�[hevrb_�qZku�\ k\h_c�dhfgZl_��\k_�^jm]b_�qZku�ba�dhfgZlu�m^Zeyxlky��hgZ�g_l_jibl�^Z`_�ijbkmlkl\by�\ ghqghc� lmf[hqd_�k\hbo�djhohlguo�qZkh\�gZ�[jZke_l_��P\_lhqgu_]hjrdb� b \Zau� khklZ\eyxlky� gZ� ibkvf_gghf� klhe_� lZd�� qlh[u� hgb� ghqvx� g_� fh]eb� miZklv�jZa[blvky�b ihlj_\h`blv�__ \h�kg_��HgZ�agZ_l��qlh�\k_�wlb�f_ju�fh]ml�bf_lv�lhevdh�dZ`ms__kyhijZ\^Zgb_�^ey�lj_[h\Zgby�ihdhy��lbdZgb_�fZe_gvdbo�qZkh\�g_evay�mkeurZlv��^Z`_�_keb�[u�hgbhklZ\Zebkv�gZ�lmf[hqd_��b \k_�fu�agZ_f�ih�hiulm��qlh�jZ\ghf_jgh_�lbdZgb_�qZkh\�k fZylgbdhfgbdh]^Z� g_�f_rZ_l� kgm�� Z kdhj__� ^_ckl\m_l� mkuieyxs_��HgZ� ijbagZ_l� lZd`_�� qlh� hiZk_gb_�[m^lh� p\_lhqgu_� ]hjrdb� b \Zau�� hklZ\e_ggu_� gZ� k\h_f� f_kl_�� ghqvx� fh]ml� kZfb� miZklv� bjZa[blvky�� ebr_gh� \kydhc� \_jhylghklb�� >ey� ^jm]bo� lj_[h\Zgbc� p_j_fhgbZeZ� hgZ� m`_� g_kkueZ_lky� gZ� g_h[oh^bfhklv� ihdhy�� >_ckl\bl_evgh�� lj_[h\Zgb_�� qlh[u� ^\_jv� f_`^m� __

Page 146: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dhfgZlhc�b kiZevg_c�jh^bl_e_c�hklZ\ZeZkv�ihemhldjulhc��bkiheg_gby�dhlhjh]h�hgZ�^h[b\Z_lkyl_f��qlh�\klZ\ey_l�\ ijbhldjulmx�^\_jv�jZaebqgu_�ij_^f_lu��dZ`_lky��gZijhlb\��fh`_l�klZlvbklhqgbdhf�gZjmrZxsbo�lbrbgm�rmfh\�Gh�kZfu_�\Z`gu_�lj_[h\Zgby�hlghkylky�d kZfhc�djh\Zlb��Ih^mrdZ�m ba]heh\vy�djh\Zlb�g_^he`gZ�dZkZlvky�^_j_\ygghc�kibgdb�djh\Zlb��FZe_gvdZy�ih^mr_qdZ�^ey�]heh\u�fh`_l�e_`ZlvgZ�[hevrhc�ih^mrd_�g_�bgZq_�dZd�h[jZamy�jhf[�� ]heh\m� lh]^Z�hgZ� deZ^_l� lhqgh�ih�^ebgghc^bZ]hgZeb�jhf[Z��I_jbgZ��©'XFKHQWª��dZd�]h\hjbf�fu�\ :\kljbb���i_j_^�l_f�dZd�_c�mdjulvky�^he`gZ�[ulv�\a[blZ� lZd��qlh[u�__ djZc�m gh]� klZe� kh\k_f� lhekluf��gh� aZl_f� hgZ�g_� mimklblkgh\Z�jZa]eZ^blv�wlh�kdhie_gb_�i_jv_\�Iha\hevl_�fg_�h[hclb�^jm]b_��qZklh�hq_gv�f_edb_�ih^jh[ghklb�wlh]h�p_j_fhgbZeZ��hgb�g_gZmqbeb�[u�gZk�gbq_fm�gh\hfm�b kebrdhf�^Ze_dh� m\_eb� [u� hl�gZrbo�p_e_c��G_� mimkdZcl_�h^gZdh��ba�\b^m��qlh�\k_�wlh�ijhbkoh^bl�g_�lZd�m`�]eZ^dh��Ijb�wlhf�__ g_�hklZ\ey_l�hiZk_gb_�qlh�g_�\k_�k^_eZgh��dZd�ke_^m_l��\k_�^he`gh�[ulv�ijh\_j_gh��ih\lhj_gh��khfg_gb_�\hagbdZ_l�lhih�ih\h^m�h^ghc��lh�ih�ih\h^m�^jm]hc�ij_^hklhjh`ghklb��b \�j_amevlZl_�ijhoh^bl�hdheh�^\moqZkh\�� \ l_q_gb_� dhlhjuo� ^_\mrdZ� kZfZ� g_� fh`_l� kiZlv� b g_� ^Z_l� mkgmlv� bkim]Zggufjh^bl_eyf�:gZeba� wlbo�fmq_gbc�ijhl_dZe�g_� lZd�ijhklh��dZd�\ kemqZ_�gZ\yaqb\h]h�^_ckl\by�gZr_ci_j\hc� iZpb_gldb�� Y \ugm`^_g� [ue� ^_eZlv� ^_\mrd_� gZ\h^ysb_� gZf_db� b ij_^eZ]Zlvlhedh\Zgby�� dhlhju_� hgZ� dZ`^uc� jZa� hldehgyeZ� j_rbl_evguf� ©g_lª� beb� ijbgbfZeZ� kij_ajbl_evguf� khfg_gb_f�� Gh� aZ� wlhc� i_j\hc� hljbpZl_evghc� j_Zdpb_c� ihke_^h\Ze� i_jbh^�dh]^Z� hgZ� kZfZ� aZgbfZeZkv� ij_^eh`_ggufb� _c� \hafh`gufb� lhedh\Zgbyfb�� ih^[bjZeZih^oh^ysb_�d gbf�fukeb��\hkijhba\h^beZ�\hkihfbgZgby��mklZgZ\eb\ZeZ�k\yab��ihdZ��bkoh^y�bakh[kl\_gghc�jZ[hlu��g_�ijbgyeZ�\k_� wlb� lhedh\Zgby��Ih�f_j_� lh]h�dZd� wlh�ijhbkoh^beh��hgZlZd`_� \k_� [hevr_� mklmiZeZ� \ bkiheg_gbb� gZ\yaqb\uo� f_j� ij_^hklhjh`ghklb� b _s_� ^hhdhgqZgby� e_q_gby� hldZaZeZkv� hl� \k_]h� p_j_fhgbZeZ�� <u� ^he`gu� lZd`_� agZlv�� qlhZgZeblbq_kdZy�jZ[hlZ��dZd�fu�__ l_i_jv�\_^_f��ijyfh�bkdexqZ_l�ihke_^h\Zl_evgmx�h[jZ[hldmhl^_evgh]h� kbfilhfZ� ^h� hdhgqZl_evgh]h� _]h� \uykg_gby�� ;hevr_� lh]h�� [u\Z_rv� \ugm`^_gihklhyggh�hklZ\eylv�h^gm�dZdmx�lh�l_fm�\ iheghc�m\_j_gghklb��qlh�\_jg_rvky�d g_c�kgh\Z�\^jm]hc� k\yab��Lhedh\Zgb_� kbfilhfZ�� dhlhjh_� y \Zf� k_cqZk� khh[sm�� y\ey_lky�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�kbgl_ahf� j_amevlZlh\�� ^h[u\Zgb_� dhlhjuo�� ij_ju\Z_fh_� ^jm]hc� jZ[hlhc�� ^eblky� i_^_eb� bf_kypu�GZrZ�iZpb_gldZ�gZqbgZ_l�ihkl_i_ggh�ihgbfZlv��qlh�\h�\j_fy�k\hbo�ijb]hlh\e_gbc�dh�kgmhgZ�mkljZgyeZ�qZku�dZd�kbf\he�`_gkdbo� ]_gblZebc��QZku��dhlhju_�fh]ml�[ulv�kbf\hebq_kdbbklhedh\Zgu� b ih�^jm]hfm�� ijbh[j_lZxl� wlm� ]_gblZevgmx� jhev� \ k\yab� k i_jbh^bqghklvxijhp_kkh\�b ijZ\bevgufb�bgl_j\ZeZfb��@_gsbgZ�fh`_l�iho\Zeblvky��qlh�m g__�f_gkljmZpbbgZklmiZxl� k ijZ\bevghklvx� qZkh\h]h�f_oZgbafZ��Gh� hkh[_ggh� gZrZ� iZpb_gldZ� [hyeZkv�� qlhlbdZgb_� qZkh\� ihf_rZ_l� kgm�� LbdZgb_� qZkh\� fh`gh� kjZ\gblv� k imevkZpb_c� deblhjZ� ijbiheh\hf�\ha[m`^_gbb��Ba�aZ�wlh]h�g_ijbylgh]h�_c�hsms_gby�hgZ�^_ckl\bl_evgh�g_h^ghdjZlghijhkuiZeZkv��Z l_i_jv�wlhl�kljZo�i_j_^�wj_dpb_c�\ujZabeky�\ lj_[h\Zgbb�m^Zeblv�hl�k_[y�gZghqv� b^msb_� qZku�� P\_lhqgu_� ]hjrdb� b \Zau�� dZd� \k_� khkm^u�� lh`_� `_gkdb_� kbf\heu�Ij_^hklhjh`ghklv��qlh[u�hgb�g_�miZeb�b g_�jZa[bebkv��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��g_�ebr_gZ�kfukeZ��GZf

Page 147: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ba\_kl_g�rbjhdh�jZkijhkljZg_gguc�h[uqZc�jZa[b\Zlv�\h�\j_fy�ihfhe\db�khkm^�beb�lZj_edm�DZ`^uc� ba� ijbkmlkl\mxsbo� [_j_l� k_[_� hkdhehd�� qlh� fu� ^he`gu� ihgbfZlv� dZd� hldZa� hlijblyaZgbc�gZ�g_\_klm�k lhqdb�aj_gby�[jZqgh]h�h[uqZy�^h�fhgh]Zfbb��Hlghkbl_evgh�wlhc�qZklbp_j_fhgbZeZ�m ^_\mrdb�ihy\behkv�h^gh�\hkihfbgZgb_�b g_kdhevdh�fuke_c��H^gZ`^u�j_[_gdhfhgZ�miZeZ�kh�kl_deygguf�beb�]ebgyguf�khkm^hf��ihj_aZeZ�iZevpu��b kbevgh�reZ�djh\v��Dh]^ZhgZ�\ujhkeZ�b magZeZ�nZdlu�ba�iheh\hc�`bagb��m g__�\hagbdeZ�im]ZxsZy�fukev��qlh�\ i_j\mx[jZqgmx�ghqv�m g__�g_�ihc^_l�djh\v�b hgZ�hdZ`_lky�g_�^_\kl\_ggbp_c��?_�ij_^hklhjh`ghklbijhlb\�lh]h��qlh[u�\Zau�g_�jZa[bebkv��hagZqZxl��lZdbf�h[jZahf��hljbpZgb_�\k_]h�dhfie_dkZ�k\yaZggh]h� k ^_\kl\_gghklvx�b djh\hl_q_gb_f�ijb�i_j\hf�iheh\hf� Zdl_�� Z lZd`_� hljbpZgb_kljZoZ� i_j_^� djh\hl_q_gb_f� b ijhlb\hiheh`gh]h� >_fm� kljZoZ@�²� g_� bf_lv� djh\hl_q_gby��Dij_^mij_`^_gbx� rmfZ�� jZ^b� dhlhjh]h� hgZ� ij_^ijbgbfZeZ� wlb� f_ju�� hgb� bf_eb� ebrvhl^Ze_ggh_�hlghr_gb_�=eZ\guc� kfuke� k\h_]h� p_j_fhgbZeZ� hgZ� m]Z^ZeZ� \ h^bg� ij_djZkguc� ^_gv�� dh]^Z� \^jm]ihgyeZ�ij_^ibkZgb_��qlh[u�ih^mrdZ�g_�dZkZeZkv�kibgdb�djh\Zlb��Ih^mrdZ�^ey�g__�\k_]^Z�[ueZ`_gsbghc��]h\hjbeZ�hgZ��Z \_jlbdZevgZy�^_j_\yggZy�kibgdZ�²�fm`qbghc��LZdbf�h[jZahf��hgZohl_eZ²� fZ]bq_kdbf� kihkh[hf�� kf__f� ^h[Z\blv� ²� jZa^_eblv� fm`qbgm� b `_gsbgm�� l _�jZaemqblv� jh^bl_e_c�� g_� ^himklblv� bo� ^h� kmijm`_kdh]h� ZdlZ�� Wlhc� `_� p_eb� hgZ� iulZeZkv^h[blvky�jZgvr_��^h�\\_^_gby�p_j_fhgbZeZ��[he__�ijyfuf�kihkh[hf��HgZ�kbfmebjh\ZeZ�kljZobeb�ihevah\ZeZkv�bf_\r_cky�kdehgghklvx�d kljZom�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�g_�^Z\Zlv�aZdju\Zlv�^\_jvf_`^m� kiZevg_c� jh^bl_e_c� b ^_lkdhc�� Wlh� lj_[h\Zgb_� _s_� hklZehkv� \ __� gZklhys_fp_j_fhgbZe_��LZdbf�h[jZahf�hgZ�kha^ZeZ�k_[_�\hafh`ghklv�ih^kemrb\Zlv�aZ�jh^bl_eyfb��gh�bkihevamy� wlm� \hafh`� ghklv�� hgZ� h^gZ`^u� ijbh[j_eZ� [_kkhggbpm�� ^eb\rmxky� f_kypu�� G_\iheg_� ^h\hevgZy� \hafh`ghklvx�f_rZlv� jh^bl_eyf� lZdbf� kihkh[hf�� hgZ� bgh]^Z� ^h[b\ZeZkvlh]h�� qlh� kZfZ� kiZeZ� \ kmijm`_kdhc� ihkl_eb� f_`^m� hlphf� b fZl_jvx�� Lh]^Z� ©ih^mrdZª� b©kibgdZ�djh\Zlbª�^_ckl\bl_evgh�g_�fh]eb�kh_^bgblvky��GZdhg_p��dh]^Z�hgZ�m`_�[ueZ�gZklhevdh[hevrhc�� qlh� g_� fh]eZ� m^h[gh� ihf_sZlvky� \ djh\Zlb� f_`^m� jh^bl_eyfb�� khagZl_evghckbfmeypb_c� kljZoZ�hgZ�^h[b\ZeZkv� lh]h��qlh�fZlv�f_gyeZkv�k g_c�djh\Zlyfb�b mklmiZeZ� k\h_f_klh� \hae_� hlpZ�� WlZ� kblmZpby� hij_^_e_ggh� klZeZ� gZqZehf� nZglZabc�� ihke_^kl\b_� dhlhjuoqm\kl\m_lky�\ p_j_fhgbZe_�?keb� ih^mrdZ� [ueZ� `_gsbghc�� lh� b \a[b\Zgb_� i_jbgu� ^h� l_o� ihj�� ihdZ� \k_� i_jvy� g_hdZau\Zebkv� \gbam� b g_� h[jZah\u\Zeb� lZf� mlhes_gb_�� bf_eh� kfuke�� Wlh� hagZqZeh� ^_eZlv`_gsbgm�[_j_f_gghc��h^gZdh�hgZ�g_�aZ[u\ZeZ�k]eZ^blv�wlm�[_j_f_gghklv��ihlhfm�qlh�\ l_q_gb_fgh]bo� e_l� hgZ� gZoh^beZkv� ih^� kljZohf�� qlh� iheh\u_� kghr_gby� jh^bl_e_c� ijb\_^ml� dihy\e_gbx�\lhjh]h�j_[_gdZ�b��lZdbf�h[jZahf��ij_ih^g_kml�_c�dhgdmj_glZ��K ^jm]hc�klhjhgu�_keb� [hevrZy� ih^mrdZ� [ueZ� `_gsbghc�� fZl_jvx�� lh� fZe_gvdZy� ]heh\gZy� ih^mr_qdZ� fh]eZij_^klZ\eylv�kh[hc�lhevdh�^hqv��Ihq_fm�wlZ�ih^mrdZ�^he`gZ�[ueZ�[ulv�iheh`_gZ�jhf[hf��Z __]heh\Z� lhqgh�ih� _]h� hk_\hc� ebgbb"�Fg_� [_a� ljm^Z� m^Zehkv� gZihfgblv� _c�� qlh� jhf[� gZ� \k_ogZkl_gguo� jhkibkyo� y\ey_lky� jmgbq_kdbf� agZdhf� hldjuluo� `_gkdbo� ]_gblZebc�� HgZ� kZfZb]jZeZ� \ lZdhf� kemqZ_� jhev� fm`qbgu�� hlpZ�� b aZf_gyeZ� ]heh\hc� fm`kdhc� qe_g� �kj�kbf\hebq_kdh_�bah[jZ`_gb_�dZkljZpbb�dZd�h[_a]eZ\eb\Zgb_��DZdZy�^bqv��kdZ`_l_�\u��aZihegy_l�]heh\m�g_ihjhqghc�^_\mrdb��Kh]eZk_g��gh�g_�aZ[u\Zcl_�

Page 148: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

y wlb� \_sb� g_� khqbgye�� Z lhevdh� bklhedh\Ze�� LZdhc� p_j_fhgbZe� mdeZ^u\Zgby� kiZlv� lZd`_y\ey_lky�q_f�lh�kljZgguf��b \u�g_�fh`_l_�g_�ijbagZlv�khhl\_lkl\by�f_`^m�p_j_fhgbZehf�bnZglZabyfb��dhlhju_�hldju\Z_l�gZf�lhedh\Zgb_��Gh�^ey�f_gy�\Z`g__�h[jZlblv�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_gZ� lh��qlh� \ p_j_fhgbZe_�hljZabeZkv�g_� h^gZ�nZglZaby�� Z g_kdhevdh�� dhlhju_� ]^_�lh��h^gZdh�bf_xl�k\hc�p_glj��: lZd`_�gZ�lh��qlh�ij_^ibkZgby�p_j_fhgbZeZ�i_j_^Zxl�k_dkmZevgu_�`_eZgbylh�iheh`bl_evgh��lh�hljbpZl_evgh��qZklbqgh�ij_^klZ\eyy��Z qZklbqgh�hl\_j]Zy�bo�Ba�ZgZebaZ�wlh]h�p_j_fhgbZeZ�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�ihemqblv�_s_�[hevr_��_keb�k\yaZlv�_]h�k^jm]bfb�kbfilhfZfb�[hevghc��Gh�fu�g_�ihc^_f�ih�wlhfm�imlb��M^h\e_l\hjbl_kv�mdZaZgb_f�gZlh��qlh� wlZ�^_\mrdZ�gZoh^blky� \h� \eZklb� wjhlbq_kdhc�ijb\yaZgghklb� d hlpm��gZqZeh� dhlhjhckdju\Z_lky�\ jZggbo�^_lkdbo�]h^Zo��<hafh`gh��ihwlhfm�hgZ�lZd�g_^jm`_ex[gh�\_^_l�k_[y�ihhlghr_gbx�d fZl_jb��Fu�g_�fh`_f�lZd`_�g_�aZf_lblv��qlh�ZgZeba�wlh]h�kbfilhfZ�hiylv�ijb\_egZk� d k_dkmZevghc� `bagb� [hevghc�� Q_f� qZs_� fu� [m^_f� ihgbfZlv� kfuke� b gZf_j_gb_g_\jhlbq_kdh]h�kbfilhfZ��l_f��fh`_l�[ulv��f_gvr_�fu�[m^_f�m^b\eylvky�wlhfm�BlZd��gZ�^\mo�ijb\_^_gguo�ijbf_jZo�y \Zf�ihdZaZe��qlh�g_\jhlbq_kdb_�kbfilhfu��lZd�`_dZd� hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�b kgh\b^_gby��bf_xl� kfuke�b gZoh^ylky� \ bglbfghf� hlghr_gbb� di_j_`b\Zgbyf�iZpb_glh\��Fh]m�eb�y jZkkqblu\Zlv��qlh�\u�ih\_jbl_�fg_�\ wlhf�qj_a\uqZcgh\Z`ghf�iheh`_gbb�gZ�hkgh\Zgbb�^\mo�ijbf_jh\"�G_l��Gh�fh`_l_� eb� \u� lj_[h\Zlv�� qlh[u� yijb\h^be� \Zf� \k_� gh\u_� b gh\u_� ijbf_ju�� ihdZ� \u� g_� aZy\bl_�� qlh� m[_^bebkv"� Lh`_� g_l�ihlhfm�q]h�ijb�lhc�h[klhyl_evghklb��k dhlhjhc�y jZkkfZljb\Zx�hl^_evguc�kemqZc��y ^he`_g[ue�[u�ihk\ylblv�^ey�jZkkfhlj_gby�wlh]h�h^gh]h�imgdlZ�l_hjbb�g_\jhah\�iylbqZkh\mx�e_dpbx�LZd� qlh� y h]jZgbqmkv� l_f�� qlh� ihdZaZe� \Zf� ijbf_j� ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z� fh_]h� ml\_j`^_gby�� Z \hklZevghf�hlhrex�\Zk�d khh[s_gbyf�\ ebl_jZlmj_��d deZkkbq_kdbf�lhedh\Zgbyf�kbfilhfh\��\i_j\mx� hq_j_^v�� ;j_c_jZ� �bkl_jby��� d aZo\Zlu\Zxsbf� jZatykg_gbyf� kh\_jr_ggh� l_fguokbfilhfh\� lZd� gZau\Z_fhc� 'HPHQWLD� SUDHFR[� � D�� =�� Xg]hf� �������� hlghkysbfky� d lhfm\j_f_gb��dh]^Z�wlhl�bkke_^h\Zl_ev�[ue�lhevdh�ikbohZgZeblbdhf�b _s_�g_�ohl_e�[ulv�ijhjhdhf�b dh�\k_f�jZ[hlZf��dhlhju_�aZihehgbeb�k l_o�ihj�gZrb�`mjgZeu��Bf_ggh�\ wlbo�bkke_^h\Zgbyom gZk� g_l� g_^hklZldZ�� :gZeba�� lhedh\Zgb_�� i_j_\h^� g_\jhlbq_kdbo� kbfilhfh\� lZd� aZo\ZlbeikbohZgZeblbdh\��qlh�\ i_j\h_�\j_fy�hgb�aZ[jhkbeb�^jm]b_�ijh[e_fu�g_\jhlbdb�Dlh�ba�\Zk�\havf_l�gZ�k_[y�lZdhc�ljm^��ihemqbl�g_khfg_ggh�kbevgh_�\i_qZle_gb_�hl�h[beby^hdZaZl_evkl\��Gh�hg�klhedg_lky�b k�h^ghc�ljm^�JZgg__�keZ[hmfb_��eZ]��h^gh�ba�gZa\Zgbc�rbahnj_gbb�±�Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�ghklvx��Kfuke�kbfilhfZ��dZd�fu�magZeb��djh_lky�\ _]h�k\yab�k i_j_`b\Zgb_f�[hevgh]h�Q_f�bg^b\b^mZevgh_� \ujZ`_g� kbfilhf�� l_f� kdhj__�fu�fh`_f� h`b^Zlv� \hkklZgh\e_gby� wlhck\yab��AZl_f�\hagbdZ_l�ijyfZy�aZ^ZqZ�gZclb�^ey�[_kkfuke_gghc�b^_b�b [_kp_evgh]h�^_ckl\bylZdmx�kblmZpbx�\ ijhrehf��\ dhlhjhc� wlZ�b^_y�[ueZ�hijZ\^ZggZ��Z ^_ckl\b_�p_e_khh[jZagh�GZ\yaqb\h_�^_ckl\b_�gZr_c�iZpb_gldb��ih^[_]Z\r_c�d klhem�b a\hgb\r_c�]hjgbqghc��y\ey_lkydZd� jZa� ijbf_jhf� wlh]h� jh^Z� kbfilhfh\��Gh� \klj_qZxlky�� b dZd� jZa� hq_gv� qZklh�� kbfilhfukh\k_f�^jm]h]h�oZjZdl_jZ��Bo�gm`gh�gZa\Zlv�©lbibqgufbª�kbfilhfZfb�[he_agb��hgb�ijbf_jghh^bgZdh\u�\h�\k_o�kemqZyo��bg^b\b^mZevgu_�jZaebqby�m gbo�hlkmlkl\mxl�beb��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_�gZklhevdh� mf_gvrZxlky�� qlh� bo� ljm^gh� ijb\_klb� \ k\yav� k bg^b\b^mZevguf� i_j_`b\Zgb_f

Page 149: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[hevguo�b hlg_klb�d hl^_evguf�i_j_`bluf�kblmZpbyf��H[jZlbfky�hiylv�d g_\jham�gZ\yaqb\uokhklhygbc��M`_�p_j_fhgbZe�mdeZ^u\Zgby�kiZlv�gZr_c�\lhjhc�iZpb_gldb�bf__l�\ k_[_�fgh]hlbibqgh]h��ijb�wlhf��h^gZdh��^hklZlhqgh�bg^b\b^mZevguo�q_jl��qlh[u�k^_eZlv�\hafh`guf��lZdkdZaZlv��bklhjbq_kdh_�lhedh\Zgb_��Gh�\k_�wlb�[hevgu_�k gZ\yaqb\ufb�khklhygbyfb�kdehggu�dih\lhj_gbyf�� jblfbaZpbb� ijb� bkiheg_gbb� ^_ckl\bc� b bo� bahebjh\Zgbx� hl� ^jm]bo�;hevrbgkl\h�ba�gbo�kebrdhf�fgh]h�fh_lky��;hevgu_��kljZ^Zxsb_�Z]hjZnh[b_c� �lhihnh[b_c�[hyagvx� ijhkljZgkl\Z��� dhlhjmx�fu� [hevr_� g_� hlghkbf� d g_\jham� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc�� Zhij_^_ey_f�dZd�bkl_jbx� kljZoZ� �$QJVWK\VWHULH���ih\lhjyxl� \ k\hbo� dZjlbgZo�[he_agb�qZklh� kmlhfbl_evguf�h^ghh[jZab_f�h^gb�b l_�`_�q_jlu��Hgb�[hylky�aZdjuluo�ijhkljZgkl\��[hevrbohldjuluo�iehsZ^_c��^Ze_dh�lygmsboky�mebp�b Zee_c��Hgb�qm\kl\mxl�k_[y�\ [_ahiZkghklb��_kebbo�khijh\h`^Zxl�agZdhfu_�beb�_keb�aZ�gbfb�_^_l�wdbiZ`�b l��^��GZ�wlm�h[smx�hkgh\m��h^gZdh�hl^_evgu_�[hevgu_�gZdeZ^u\Zxl�k\hb�bg^b\b^mZevgu_�mkeh\by��dZijbau��ohl_ehkv�[u�kdZaZlv�\ hl^_evguo� kemqZyo� ijyfh� ijhlb\hiheh`gu_� ^jm]� ^jm]m��H^bg� [hblky� lhevdh� madbo� mebp�^jm]hc�²�lhevdh�rbjhdbo��h^bg�fh`_l�b^lb�lhevdh�lh]^Z��dh]^Z�gZ�mebp_�fZeh�ex^_c��^jm]hc²� dh]^Z� fgh]h�� Lhqgh� lZd�`_� b bkl_jby� ijb� \k_f� [h]Zlkl\_� bg^b\b^mZevguo� q_jl� bf__l� \ba[uld_� h[sb_� lbibqgu_� kbfilhfu�� dhlhju_�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� g_� ih^^Zxlky� ijhklhfmbklhjbq_kdhfm�h[tykg_gbx��G_�aZ[m^_f��qlh�wlh�\_^v�l_�lbibqgu_�kbfilhfu��ih�dhlhjuf�fuhjb_glbjm_fky�ijb�ihklZgh\d_�^bZ]ghaZ��?keb�fu�\ h^ghf�kemqZ_�bkl_jbb�^_ckl\bl_evgh�k\_eblbibqguc� kbfilhf� d h^ghfm� i_j_`b\Zgbx� beb� d p_ib� ih^h[guo� i_j_`b\Zgbc�� gZijbf_j�bkl_jbq_kdmx�j\hlm�d ihke_^kl\byf�\i_qZle_gbc�hl\jZs_gby��lh�fu�l_jy_f�m\_j_gghklv��dh]^ZZgZeba�j\hlu�\ dZdhf�lh�^jm]hf�kemqZ_�\kdjh_l�kh\_jr_ggh�^jm]hc�jy^�\b^bfh�^_ckl\mxsboi_j_`b\Zgbc�� Lh]^Z� wlh� \u]ey^bl� lZd�� dZd� [m^lh� m bkl_jbqguo� j\hlZ� ijhy\ey_lky� ihg_ba\_klguf� ijbqbgZf�� Z ^h[ulu_� ZgZebahf� bklhjbq_kdb_� ih\h^u� y\eyxlky� lhevdhij_^eh]Zfb�� bkihevam_fufb� wlhc� \gmlj_gg_c� g_h[oh^bfhklvx�� dh]^Z� hgb� kemqZcghhdZau\Zxlky�LZdbf� h[jZahf�� fu� kdhjh� ijboh^bf� d i_qZevghfm� \u\h^m�� qlh� ohly� fu� fh`_fm^h\e_l\hjbl_evgh� h[tykgblv� kfuke� bg^b\b^mZevguo� g_\jhlbq_kdbo� kbfilhfh\� [eZ]h^Zjyk\yab�k i_j_`b\Zgb_f��gZr_�bkdmkkl\h��h^gZdh��baf_gy_l�gZf�\ ]hjZa^h�[he__�qZkluo�kemqZyolbibqguo� kbfilhfh\��D wlhfm� ke_^m_l� ^h[Z\blv� _s_� lh�� qlh� y ihagZdhfbe� \Zk� ^Ze_dh�g_� kh\k_fb� ljm^ghklyfb�� \hagbdZxsbfb� ijb� ihke_^h\Zl_evghf� ijh\_^_gbb� bklhjbq_kdh]hlhedh\Zgby� kbfilhfh\�� Y b� g_� ohqm� wlh]h� ^_eZlv�� ihlhfm� qlh� ohly� y gZf_j_g� gbq_]h� g_ijbmdjZrb\Zlv�beb�qlh�lh�kdju\Zlv�hl�\Zk��gh�y b�g_�fh]m�^himklblv��qlh[u�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZgZrbo� kh\f_klguo� bkke_^h\Zgbc� \u� [ueb� [_kihfhsgu� b h[_kdmjZ`_gu�� <_jgh�� qlh� fuiheh`beb� ebrv� gZqZeh� ihgbfZgbx� agZq_gby� kbfilhfh\�� gh� fu� [m^_f� ijb^_j`b\Zlvkyijbh[j_l_gguo�agZgbc�b rZ]�aZ�rZ]hf�ijh^\b]Zlvky�\ h[tykg_gbb�_s_�g_�ihgylh]h��Ihijh[mxml_rblv� \Zk� khh[jZ`_gb_f�� qlh� \k_�lZdb� \jy^� eb� fh`gh� ij_^iheZ]Zlv� nmg^Zf_glZevgh_jZaebqb_� f_`^m� h^gbf� b ^jm]bf� \b^hf� kbfilhfh\�� ?keb� bg^b\b^mZevgu_� kbfilhfu� lZdhq_\b^gh�aZ\bkyl�hl�i_j_`b\Zgby�[hevgh]h��lh�^ey�lbibqguo�kbfilhfh\�hklZ_lky�\hafh`ghklv�qlh� hgb� \_^ml� d i_j_`b\Zgbx�� dhlhjh_� kZfh� lbibqgh�� h[s_� \k_f� ex^yf��>jm]b_� ihklhygghih\lhjyxsb_ky� q_jlu� fh]ml� [ulv� h[sbfb� j_Zdpbyfb�� gZ\yaZggufb� [hevghfm� ijbjh^hc[he_ag_ggh]h� baf_g_gby�� gZijbf_j�� ih\lhj_gb_� beb� khfg_gb_� ijb� g_\jha_� gZ\yaqb\uokhklhygbc��Dhjhq_�]h\hjy��m gZk�g_l�gbdZdh]h�hkgh\Zgby�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�aZjZg__�iZ^Zlv�^mohf�

Page 150: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ihkfhljbf��qlh�[m^_l�^Zevr_�K kh\_jr_ggh� ZgZeh]bqguf� aZljm^g_gb_f� fu� klZedb\Z_fky� b \� l_hjbb� kgh\b^_gby�� <gZrbo�ij_`gbo�[_k_^Zo�h kgh\b^_gbb� y g_�fh]� dhkgmlvky� __��Y\gh_� kh^_j`Zgb_� kgh\b^_gbc[u\Z_l�qj_a\uqZcgh�jZaghh[jZaguf�b bg^b\b^mZevgh�baf_gqb\uf��b fu�ih^jh[gh�ihdZaZeb�qlh�fh`gh�ihemqZlv�ba� wlh]h� kh^_j`Zgby� [eZ]h^Zjy� ZgZebam��Gh� gZjy^m� k wlbf� \klj_qZxlkykgh\b^_gby��dhlhju_�lh`_�gZau\Zxlky�©lbibqgufbª�²�h^bgZdh\u_�m \k_o�ex^_c�kgh\b^_gbyh^ghh[jZagh]h�kh^_j`Zgby��dhlhju_�klZ\yl�ZgZeba�i_j_^�l_fb�`_�ljm^ghklyfb��Wlh�kgh\b^_gbyh iZ^_gbb��e_lZgbb��iZj_gbb��ieZ\Zgbb��khklhygbb�kl_kg_gghklb��h gZ]hl_�b ^jm]b_�ba\_klgu_kljZrgu_�kgh\b^_gby��dhlhjuf�m hl^_evguo�ebp�^Z_lky�lh�h^gh��lh�^jm]h_�lhedh\Zgb_��ijbq_fgb fhghlhgghklv�� gb lbibqghklv� __ ijhy\e_gby� g_� gZoh^yl� k\h_]h� h[tykg_gby��Gh� b \� wlbokgh\b^_gbyo� fu� gZ[ex^Z_f�� qlh� h[sZy� hkgh\Z� h`b\ey_lky� bg^b\b^mZevgh� baf_gqb\ufbijb[Z\e_gbyfb�b��\_jhylgh��ijb�m]em[e_gbb�gZrbo�ij_^klZ\e_gbb�hgb�lh`_�[_a�gZly`db�fh]ml[ulv� h[tykg_gu� l_fb� hkh[_gghklyfb�`bagb� kgh\b^_gbc�� dhlhju_�fu� hldjueb� gZ�fZl_jbZe_^jm]bo�kgh\b^_gbc�<HK?FG:>P:L:Y�E?DPBYNbdkZpby�gZ�ljZ\f_��[_kkhagZl_evgh_M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��< ijhreuc�jZa�y kdZaZe��qlh�fu�gZf_j_gu�ijh^he`Zlv�gZrmjZ[hlm�� g_� h]ey^u\Zykv� gZ� gZrb� khfg_gby�� Z bkoh^y� ba� gZrbo� hldjulbc�� H ^\mo� kZfuobgl_j_kguo�ke_^kl\byo��\ul_dZxsbo�ba�ZgZebah\�h[hbo�ijbf_jh\��fu�\hh[s_�_s_�g_�kdZaZeb�I_j\h_��h[_�iZpb_gldb�ijhba\h^yl�\i_qZle_gb_��dZd�[m^lh�hgb�nbdkbjh\Zgu�gZ�dZdhf�lhhij_^_e_gghf�hlj_ad_�k\h_]h�ijhreh]h��g_�fh]ml�hk\h[h^blvky�hl�g_]h�b ihwlhfm�gZklhys__�b[m^ms__�hklZxlky�bf�qm`^ufb��Hgb�ijyqmlky�\ k\h_c�[he_agb��dZd�jZgvr_�bf_eb�h[udgh\_gb_m^Zeylvky� \ fhgZklujv�� qlh[u� ^h`b\Zlv� lZf� k\hc� \_d�� >ey� gZr_c� i_j\hc� iZpb_gldb� lZdmxmqZklv�m]hlh\be�jZklhj]gmluc�\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�[jZd�k __�fm`_f��K\hbfb�kbfilhfZfb�hgZijh^he`Z_l�h[s_gb_�kh�k\hbf�fm`_f��fu�gZmqbebkv�ihgbfZlv�l_�]hehkZ��dhlhju_�\uklmiZxlaZ� g_]h�� ba\bgyxl� b \ha\urZxl� _]h�� hieZdb\Zxl� _]h� ihl_jx��Ohly� hgZ� fheh^Z� b fh]eZ� [uihgjZ\blvky�^jm]bf�fm`qbgZf��hgZ�ij_^ijbgyeZ�\k_�j_Zevgu_�b \hh[jZ`Z_fu_� �fZ]bq_kdb_�ij_^hklhjh`ghklb�� qlh[u� khojZgblv� _fm� \_jghklv�� HgZ� g_� ihdZau\Z_lky� m ihklhjhggbo�� g_ke_^bl�aZ�k\h_c�\g_rghklvx��gh�hgZ�lZd`_�g_�\ khklhygbb�[ukljh�\klZlv�k dj_keZ��gZ�dhlhjhfkb^_eZ�� b hldZau\Z_lky� ih^ibku\Zlv� k\hx� nZfbebx�� g_� fh`_l� gbdhfm� k^_eZlv� ih^ZjdZ�fhlb\bjmy�wlh�l_f��qlh�gbdlh��g_�^he`_g�gbq_]h�bf_lv�hl�g__�M gZr_c� \lhjhc� iZpb_gldb�� fheh^hc� ^_\mrdb�� wjhlbq_kdZy� ijb\yaZgghklv� d hlpm�\hagbdrZy�^h�iheh\hc�aj_ehklb��k^_eZeZ�\ __�`bagb�lh�`_�kZfh_��HgZ�lh`_�ijbreZ�d \u\h^m�qlh�g_�fh`_l�\uclb�aZfm`��ihdZ�hgZ�lZd�[hevgZ��Kf__f�ij_^iheh`blv��qlh�hgZ�lZd�aZ[he_eZ�qlh[u�g_�\uoh^blv�aZfm`�b hklZlvky�k hlphf�Fu� g_�fh`_f� h[hclb� \hijhkZ� h lhf�� dZd�� dZdbf� iml_f� b \� kbem� dZdbo� fhlb\h\� fh`_l\hagbdgmlv� lZdZy� kljZggZy� b g_\u]h^gZy� `bag_ggZy� mklZgh\dZ�� >himklbf�� qlh� ^Zggh_ih\_^_gb_�y\ey_lky�h[sbf�ijbagZdhf�g_\jhaZ��Z g_�hkh[uf�k\hckl\hf�wlbo�^\mo�[hevguo��Wlh

Page 151: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ kZfhf�^_e_�h[sZy��ijZdlbq_kdb�hq_gv�agZqbfZy�q_jlZ�\kydh]h�g_\jhaZ��I_j\Zy�bkl_jbq_kdZyiZpb_gldZ� ;j_c_jZ� [ueZ� ih^h[guf� `_� h[jZahf� nbdkbjh\ZgZ� gZ� lhf� \j_f_gb�� dh]^Z� hgZmoZ`b\ZeZ�aZ�k\hbf�ly`_eh�aZ[he_\rbf�hlphf��G_kfhljy�gZ�k\h_�\ua^hjh\e_gb_��hgZ�k l_o�ihj\ ba\_klghf� kfuke_� ihdhgqbeZ� k `bagvx�� ohly� hklZeZkv� a^hjh\hc� b ljm^hkihkh[ghc�� ghhldZaZeZkv�hl�_kl_kl\_ggh]h�ij_^gZagZq_gby�`_gsbgu��;eZ]h^Zjy�ZgZebam�fu�fh`_f�m dZ`^h]hba�gZrbo�[hevguo�h[gZjm`blv��qlh�hg�\ k\hbo�kbfilhfZo�[he_agb�b bo�ihke_^kl\byo�i_j_g_kky\ hij_^_e_gguc�i_jbh^�k\h_]h�ijhreh]h��< [hevrbgkl\_�kemqZ_\�hg�\u[bjZe�^ey�wlh]h�hq_gvjZggxx�nZam�`bagb��\j_fy�k\h_]h�^_lkl\Z��b ^Z`_��dZd�gb�kf_rgh�wlh�a\mqbl��feZ^_gq_kl\h�< [ebadhc� ZgZeh]bb� k wlbf� ih\_^_gb_f� gZrbo� g_j\gh[hevguo� gZoh^ylky� aZ[he_\Zgby�hkh[_ggh� qZklh� \hagbdZxsb_� bf_ggh� l_i_jv�� \h� \j_fy� \hcgu�²� lZd� gZau\Z_fu_ljZ\fZlbq_kdb_� �WUDXPDWLVFKH�� g_\jhau�� LZdb_� kemqZb�� dhg_qgh�� [u\Zeb� b ^h� \hcgu� ihke_`_e_agh^hjh`guo� djmr_gbc� b ^jm]bo� kljZrguo� `bag_gguo� dZlZkljhn�� < k\h_c� hkgh\_ljZ\fZlbq_kdb_� g_\jhau� g_� lh� `_� kZfh_�� qlh� kihglZggu_� g_\jhau�� dhlhju_� fu� h[uqghZgZeblbq_kdb� bkke_^m_f� b e_qbf�� gZf� lZd`_� _s_� g_� m^Zehkv� jZkkfhlj_lv� bo� k gZr_c� lhqdbaj_gby��b y�gZ^_xkv�dZd�gb[m^v�h[tykgblv�\Zf��\ q_f�aZdexqZ_lky�wlh�h]jZgbq_gb_��Gh�\ wlhfh^ghf� imgdl_� fu� fh`_f� ih^q_jdgmlv� bo� ihegh_� koh^kl\h�� LjZ\fZlbq_kdb_� g_\jhau� ghkyly\gu_�ijbagZdb�lh]h��qlh�\ bo�hkgh\_�e_`bl�nbdkZpby�gZ�fhf_gl_�ljZ\fu��< k\hbo�kgh\b^_gbyowlb� [hevgu_� ihklhyggh� ih\lhjyxl� ljZ\fZlbq_kdmx� kblmZpbx�� lZf�� ]^_� \klj_qZxlkybkl_jhih^h[gu_� ijbiZ^db�� ^himkdZxsb_� ZgZeba�� magZ_rv�� qlh� ijbiZ^hd� khhl\_lkl\m_liheghfm�i_j_g_k_gbx�\ wlm�kblmZpbx��IhemqZ_lky�lZd��dZd�[m^lh�wlb�[hevgu_�g_�ihdhgqbeb�kwlhc�ljZ\fZlbq_kdhc�kblmZpb_c��dZd�[m^lh�hgZ�klhbl�i_j_^�gbfb�dZd�g_jZaj_r_ggZy�ZdlmZevgZyijh[e_fZ��b fu�\iheg_�k_jv_agh�kh]eZrZ_fky�k wlbf�ihgbfZgb_f��hgh�ihdZau\Z_l�gZf�imlv�dwdhghfbq_kdhfm�� dZd� fu� gZau\Z_f�� jZkkfhlj_gbx� ^mr_\guo� ijhp_kkh\�� >Z�� \ujZ`_gb_©ljZ\fZlbq_kdbcª�bf__l�lhevdh�lZdhc� wdhghfbq_kdbc�kfuke��LZd�fu�gZau\Z_f�i_j_`b\Zgb_�dhlhjh_� \ l_q_gb_� dhjhldh]h� \j_f_gb� ijb\h^bl� \ ^mr_\ghc� `bagb� d lZdhfm� kbevghfmm\_ebq_gbx� jZa^jZ`_gby�� qlh� hk\h[h`^_gb_� hl� g_]h� beb� _]h� ghjfZevgZy� i_j_jZ[hldZ� g_m^Z_lky��\ j_amevlZl_�q_]h�fh]ml�gZklmiblv�^ebl_evgu_�gZjmr_gby�\ jZkoh^h\Zgbb�wg_j]bb�WlZ� ZgZeh]by�gZ\h^bl�gZk�gZ�fukev�gZa\Zlv� ljZ\fZlbq_kdbfb� lZd`_� l_�i_j_`b\Zgby��gZdhlhjuo�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� nbdkbjh\Zgu� gZrb� g_j\gh[hevgu_�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� ^ey� h[tykg_gby\hagbdgh\_gby� g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� aZ[he_\Zgby� dZd� [u� gZijZrb\Z_lky� h^gh� ijhklh_� mkeh\b_�G_\jha�ke_^h\Zeh�[u�mih^h[blv�ljZ\fZlbq_kdhfm�aZ[he_\Zgbx��Z _]h�\hagbdgh\_gb_�h[tykgblvg_kihkh[ghklvx� kijZ\blvky� kh� kebrdhf� kbevguf� Znn_dlb\guf� i_j_`b\Zgb_f�� LZdh\Z� \^_ckl\bl_evghklb�b [ueZ�i_j\Zy�nhjfmebjh\dZ��dhlhjhc�;j_c_j�b y�\ ����²�����]]��ih^\_ebl_hj_lbq_kdbc�blh]�gZrbf�gZ[ex^_gbyf��KemqZc�gZr_c�i_j\hc�iZpb_gldb��fheh^hc�`_gsbgu�jZaemq_gghc� k fm`_f�� hq_gv� ohjhrh� \ibku\Z_lky� \ wlb� \a]ey^u�� HgZ� g_� \ug_keZg_hkms_kl\bfhklb� k\h_]h� [jZdZ� b aZkljyeZ� gZ� wlhc� ljZ\f_�� Gh� m`_� gZr� \lhjhc� kemqZcnbdkbjh\Zgghc�gZ�k\h_f�hlp_�^_\mrdb�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�nhjfmebjh\dZ�g_^hklZlhqgh�rbjhdZ��Kh^ghc��klhjhgu��lZdZy�\ex[e_gghklv�fZe_gvdhc�^_\hqdb�\ hlpZ�qlh�lh�gZklhevdh�h[uqgh_�b lZdqZklh� ij_h^he_\Z_fh_�� qlh� gZa\Zgb_� ©ljZ\fZlbq_kdbcª� kh\_jr_ggh� ihl_jyeh� [u� k\h_kh^_j`Zgb_��k ^jm]hc� klhjhgu��bklhjby�[hevghc�gZf�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh� wlZ�i_j\Zy� wjhlbq_kdZynbdkZpby�kgZqZeZ�dZd�[m^lh�[u�ijhreZ�[_a�\kydh]h�\j_^Z�b lhevdh�g_kdhevdh�e_l�kimkly�hiylvijhy\beZkv�\ kbfilhfZo�g_\jhaZ�gZ\yaqb\h]h�khklhygby��BlZd��fu�ij_^\b^bf�lml�hkeh`g_gby�

Page 152: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[hevr__� jZaghh[jZab_� mkeh\bc� aZ[he_\Zgby�� gh� fu� ij_^qm\kl\m_f� lZd`_�� qlh� hl©ljZ\fZlbq_kdhcª�lhqdb�aj_gby�g_evay�hldZaZlvky�dZd�hl�hrb[hqghc��hgZ�ijb]h^blky�\ ^jm]hff_kl_�b ijb�^jm]bo�mkeh\byo�A^_kv�fu�hiylv�hklZ\bf�imlv��ih�dhlhjhfm�reb��IhdZ�hg�g_�\_^_l�gZk�^Zevr_��Z gZf�gm`ghmagZlv�_s_�fgh]h_�^jm]h_��ij_`^_�q_f�fu�kfh`_f�gZclb�_]h�bklbggh_�ijh^he`_gb_��AZf_lbf_s_�ih�ih\h^m�nbdkZpbb�gZ�hij_^_e_gghc�nZa_�ijhreh]h��qlh�lZdh_�y\e_gb_�\uoh^bl�aZ�jZfdbg_\jhaZ�� <kydbc� g_\jha� g_k_l� \ k_[_� lZdmx� nbdkZpbx�� gh� g_� \kydZy� nbdkZpby� ijb\_^_l� dg_\jham��kh\iZ^_l�k gbf�beb�\klZg_l�gZ�_]h�imlb��Ijbf_jhf�Znn_dlb\ghc�nbdkZpbb�gZ�q_f�lhijhrehf�y\ey_lky�i_qZev��dhlhjZy�ijb\h^bl�d iheghfm�hloh^m�hl�gZklhys_]h�b [m^ms_]h��Gh^Z`_�^ey�g_ki_pbZebklZ�i_qZev�j_adh�hlebqZ_lky�hl�g_\jhaZ��AZlh�_klv�g_\jhau��dhlhju_�fh`ghgZa\Zlv�iZlheh]bq_kdhc�nhjfhc�i_qZeb�KemqZ_lky�lZd`_��qlh�ljZ\fZlbq_kdh_�kh[ulb_��ihljykZxs__�\k_�hkgh\u�ij_`g_c�`bagb�hklZgZ\eb\Z_l�ex^_c�gZklhevdh��qlh�hgb�l_jyxl�\kydbc�bgl_j_k�d gZklhys_fm�b [m^ms_fm�b \^mr_� ihklhyggh� hklZxlky� \ ijhrehf�� gh� wlb� g_kqZklgu_� g_� h[yaZl_evgh� ^he`gu� klZlvg_j\gh[hevgufb��Fu�g_�ohlbf�i_j_hp_gb\Zlv�^ey�oZjZdl_jbklbdb�g_\jhaZ�wlm�h^gm�q_jlm��dZd[u�ihklhyggZ�b agZqbl_evgZ�hgZ�gb [ueZ�: l_i_jv� i_j_c^_f� d ^jm]hfm� j_amevlZlm� gZr_]h� ZgZebaZ�� h g_\u]h^ghf� h]jZgbq_gbbdhlhjh]h� gZf� g_q_]h� [_kihdhblvky�� H gZr_c� i_j\hc� iZpb_gld_� fu� khh[sbeb�� dZdh_[_kkfuke_ggh_�gZ\yaqb\h_�^_ckl\b_�hgZ�bkihegyeZ�b dZdh_�bglbfgh_�`bag_ggh_�\hkihfbgZgb_\ k\yab�k wlbf�hgZ�jZkkdZaZeZ��aZl_f�fu�bkke_^h\Zeb�hlghr_gb_�f_`^m�h[hbfb�b ba�wlhc�k\yab^h]Z^Zebkv� h p_eb� gZ\yaqb\h]h� ^_ckl\by��Gh� fu� hklZ\beb� \ klhjhg_� h^bg� fhf_gl�� dhlhjucaZkem`b\Z_l�gZr_]h�ijbklZevgh]h�\gbfZgby��IhdZ�iZpb_gldZ�ih\lhjyeZ�gZ\yaqb\h_�^_ckl\b_�hgZ�gbq_]h�g_�agZeZ�h lhf��qlh�hgh�k\yaZgh�k l_f�i_j_`b\Zgb_f��K\yav�f_`^m�gbfb�[ueZ�^eyg__� kdjulZ�� ih� ijZ\^_� ]h\hjy�� hgZ� ^he`gZ� [ueZ� hl\_lblv�� qlh� g_� agZ_l�� \ kbem� dZdboih[m`^_gbc�hgZ�wlh�^_eZ_l��AZl_f�ih^�\ebygb_f�e_q_gby�\^jm]�kemqbehkv�lZd��qlh�hgZ�gZreZwlm�k\yav�b fh]eZ�h g_c�khh[sblv��Gh�hgZ�\k_�_s_�g_�agZeZ�h p_eb��dhlhjhc�kem`beh�gZ\yaqb\h_^_ckl\b_�� h p_eb� bkijZ\blv�fmqbl_evguc� hlj_ahd� ijhreh]h� b ihklZ\blv� ex[bfh]h�fm`Z� gZ[he__� \ukhdbc� mjh\_gv�� Wlh� ^ebehkv� ^h\hevgh� ^he]h� b klhbeh� fgh]bo� ljm^h\�� ihdZ� hgZ� g_ihgyeZ� b g_� ijbagZeZkv� fg_�� qlh� lZdhc� fhlb\� fh]� [ulv� _^bgkl\_gghc� ^\b`ms_c� kbehcgZ\yaqb\h]h�^_ckl\by�K\yav� kh� kp_ghc� ihke_� g_m^Zqghc� [jZqghc� ghqb� b fhl_\� g_`ghklb� [hevghc� \f_kl_khklZ\eyxl� lh�� qlh� fu� gZa\Zeb� ©kfukehfª� gZ\yaqb\h]h� ^_ckl\by�� Gh� wlhl� kfuke� \ h[hbogZijZ\e_gbyo�� ©hldm^Zª� b ©aZq_fª�� [ue� _c� g_ba\_kl_g�� dh]^Z� hgZ� \uihegyeZ� gZ\yaqb\h_^_ckl\b_��LZdbf�h[jZahf��\ g_c�^_ckl\h\Zeb�^mr_\gu_�ijhp_kku��Z gZ\yaqb\h_�^_ckl\b_�[uehbf_ggh�j_amevlZlhf�bo�\ebygby��\ ghjfZevghf�khklhygbb�hgZ�qm\kl\h\ZeZ�wlh�\ebygb_��gh�^h�__khagZgby�g_�^hoh^beh�gbq_]h�ba�^mr_\guo�ij_^ihkuehd�wlh]h�\ebygby��HgZ�\_eZ�k_[y�lhqgh�lZd`_�� dZd� aZ]bighlbabjh\Zgguc�� dhlhjhfm� ;_jg]_cf� \gmrbe� q_j_a� iylv� fbgml� ihke_ijh[m`^_gby� hldjulv� \ iZeZl_� ahglbd�� b dhlhjuc� \uihegbe� wlh� \gmr_gb_� \ [h^jkl\mxs_fkhklhygbb�� g_� mf_y� h[tykgblv� fhlb\Z� k\h_]h� ihklmidZ��Bf_ggh� lZdh_� iheh`_gb_� \_s_c� fubf__f� \ \b^m�� dh]^Z� ]h\hjbf� h kms_kl\h\Zgbb� [_kkhagZl_evguo� ^mr_\guo� ijhp_kkh\��Fu[jhkZ_f�\uah\�\k_fm�fbjm��ij_^eZ]Zy�[he__�kljh]bf�gZmqguf�h[jZahf�ij_^klZ\blv�wlb�nZdlu�

Page 153: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

b lh]^Z�fu� hohlgh� hldZ`_fky� hl� ij_^iheh`_gby� kms_kl\h\Zgby� [_kkhagZl_evguo� ^mr_\guoijhp_kkh\��: ^h�lh]h�fu�[m^_f�ijb^_j`b\Zlvky�wlh]h�ij_^iheh`_gby�b��g_^hmf_ggh�ih`bfZyie_qZfb�� [m^_f� hl\_j]Zlv� dZd� g_ihgylgh_� lh� \hajZ`_gb_�� qlh� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� g_� y\ey_lky� \^Zgghf�kemqZ_�gbq_f�j_Zevguf�\ gZmqghf�kfuke_��Z lhevdh�\kihfh]Zl_evguf�kj_^kl\hf��bebIDFRQV� GH� SDUOHU �� DZdh_� `_� wlh� g_j_Zevgh_�� hl� dhlhjh]h� bkoh^yl� lZdb_� j_Zevgh� hsmlbfu_ihke_^kl\by��dZd�gZ\yaqb\h_�^_ckl\b_�< kmsghklb�� lh� `_� kZfh_� fu� gZoh^bf� b m� gZr_c� \lhjhc� iZpb_gldb�� M g__� \hagbdehlj_[h\Zgb_�� qlh[u� ih^mrdZ� g_� dZkZeZkv� kibgdb� djh\Zlb�� b hgZ� ^he`gZ� \uihegylv� wlhlj_[h\Zgb_�� gh� hgZ� g_� agZ_l�� hldm^Z� hgh� ijhbahreh�� qlh� hagZqZ_l� b dZdbf�fhlb\Zf� h[yaZghk\h_c�kbehc��>ey�_]h �J_q_\uf�h[hjhlhf��njZgp���\uiheg_gby� [_ajZaebqgh�� hlghkblky� eb� hgZ� d g_fm�bg^bnn_j_glgh�beb�ijhlb\blky� _fm�\hafmsZ_lky�� kh[bjZ_lky� _]h� gZjmrblv�� Hgh� ^he`gh� [ulv� \uiheg_gh�� b hgZ� gZijZkghkijZrb\Z_l�k_[y�ihq_fm��Ke_^m_l��h^gZdh��ijbagZlv��qlh�\ wlbo�kbfilhfZo�g_\jhaZ�gZ\yaqb\h]hkhklhygby�� \ wlbo� ij_^klZ\e_gbyo� b bfimevkZo�� ihy\eyxsboky� g_ba\_klgh� hldm^Z�� lZdbomklhcqb\uo�ijhlb\�\k_o�\ebygbc�\ hklZevghf�ghjfZevghc�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��ijhba\h^ysbo�gZkZfh]h�[hevgh]h�\i_qZle_gb_��dZd�[m^lh�hgb�k\_jokbevgu_�]hklb�ba�qm`h]h�fbjZ��[_kkf_jlgu_�\f_rZ\rb_ky� \ kmlhehdm� kf_jlguo�� aZdexqZ_lky� kZfh_� ykgh_� mdZaZgb_� gZ� dZdmx�lh� hkh[mx�bahebjh\Zggmx� hl� hklZevgh]h� h[eZklv� ^mr_\ghc� `bagb�� Hl� gbo� \_^_l� g_ba[_`guc� imlv� dijbagZgbx� kms_kl\h\Zgby� \ ^mr_� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� b bf_ggh� ihwlhfm� debgbq_kdZyikbobZljby�� ijbagZxsZy� lhevdh� ikboheh]bx� khagZgby�� g_� fh`_l� k gbfb� k^_eZlv� gbq_]h^jm]h]h�� dZd� \u^Zlv� aZ� ijbagZdb� hkh[h]h� jh^Z� ^_]_g_jZpbb�� JZamf__lky�� kZfb� gZ\yaqb\u_ij_^klZ\e_gby� b gZ\yaqb\u_� bfimevku� g_� [_kkhagZl_evgu�� b lZd� `_� fZeh� \uiheg_gb_gZ\yaqb\h]h�^_ckl\by�mkdhevaZ_l�hl�khagZl_evgh]h�\hkijbylby��Hgb�g_�[ueb�[u�kbfilhfZfb�_keb�[u�g_�ijhgbdeb�\ khagZgb_��Gh�ikbobq_kdb_�ij_^ihkuedb��jZkdjulu_�ZgZebahf��k\yab��\dhlhju_�fu�bo�\\h^bf�[eZ]h^Zjy�lhedh\Zgbx��y\eyxlky�[_kkhagZl_evgufb�ih�djZcg_c�f_j_�^hl_o�ihj��ihdZ�fu�g_�k^_eZ_f�bo�khagZl_evgufb�^ey�[hevgh]h�iml_f�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�jZ[hlu�: l_i_jv�ijbfbl_� \h� \gbfZgb_��qlh� wlh�iheh`_gb_� \_s_c�� mklZgh\e_ggh_�gZfb� \ h[hbogZrbo�kemqZyo��ih^l\_j`^Z_lky�\h�\k_o�kbfilhfZo�\k_o�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�y\e_gbc��qlh�\k_]^Z�b\_a^_�kfuke�kbfilhfh\�g_ba\_kl_g�[hevghfm��qlh�ZgZeba�ihklhyggh�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�kbfilhfu²� ijhba\h^gh_� [_kkhagZl_evguo� ijhp_kkh\�� dhlhju_�� h^gZdh�� ijb� jZaguo� [eZ]hijbylguomkeh\byo� fh`gh� k^_eZlv� khagZl_evgufb�� b \u� ihcf_l_�� qlh� \ ikbohZgZeba_� fu� g_� fh`_fh[hclbkv�[_a�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�\ ikbobd_�b ijb\udeb�hi_jbjh\Zlv�bf�dZd�q_f�lh�qm\kl\_gghhkyaZ_fuf��Gh�\u��fh`_l�[ulv��lZd`_�ihcf_l_��dZd�fZeh�kihkh[gu�d km`^_gbx�\ wlhf�\hijhk_\k_� ^jm]b_�� dlh� kqblZ_l� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� lhevdh� ihgylb_f�� dlh� gbdh]^Z� g_� ZgZebabjh\Ze�gbdh]^Z�g_� lhedh\Ze�kgh\b^_gbc�b g_�bkdZe�\ g_\jhlbq_kdbo�kbfilhfZo�kfuke�b gZf_j_gb_�>ey� gZrbo� p_e_c� ih\lhjx� _s_� jZa�� \hafh`ghklv� ijb^Zlv� kfuke� g_\jhlbq_kdbf� kbfilhfZf[eZ]h^Zjy� ZgZeblbq_kdhfm� lhedh\Zgbx� y\ey_lky� g_hijh\_j`bfuf� ^hdZaZl_evkl\hfkms_kl\h\Zgby�²� beb�� _keb� \Zf� m]h^gh�� g_h[oh^bfhklb� ij_^iheh`_gby�²� [_kkhagZl_evguo^mr_\guo�ijhp_kkh\�

Page 154: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Gh�wlh�_s_�g_�\k_��;eZ]h^Zjy�\lhjhfm�hldjulbx�;j_c_jZ��dhlhjh_�fg_�dZ`_lky�^Z`_�[he__kh^_j`Zl_evguf� b dhlhjh_� g_� gZreh� klhjhggbdh\�� fu� _s_� [hevr_� magZ_f� h k\yab� f_`^m[_kkhagZl_evguf�b g_\jhlbq_kdbfb�kbfilhfZfb��B g_�lhevdh�lh��qlh�kfuke�kbfilhfh\�\k_]^Z[_kkhagZl_e_g�� f_`^m� wlhc� [_kkhagZl_evghklvx� b \hafh`ghklvx� kms_kl\h\Zgby� kbfilhfh\kms_kl\m_l� lZd`_�hlghr_gb_� aZf_klbl_evkl\Z��<u�f_gy�kdhjh�ihcf_l_��<f_kl_�k ;j_c_jhf� yml\_j`^Zx� ke_^mxs__�� dZ`^uc� jZa�� klZedb\Zykv� k kbfilhfhf�� fu� fh`_f� aZdexqblv�� qlh� m[hevgh]h� bf_xlky� hij_^_e_ggu_� [_kkhagZl_evgu_� ijhp_kku�� \ dhlhjuo� kh^_j`blky� kfukekbfilhfZ�� Gh� ^ey� lh]h�� qlh[u� h[jZah\Zeky� kbfilhf�� g_h[oh^bfh� lZd`_�� qlh[u� kfuke� [ue[_kkhagZl_evguf�� Ba� khagZl_evguo� ijhp_kkh\� kbfilhfu� g_� h[jZamxlky�� dZd� lhevdhkhhl\_lkl\mxsb_� [_kkhagZl_evgu_� ijhp_kku� k^_eZxlky� khagZl_evgufb�� kbfilhf� ^he`_gbkq_agmlv��<u�kjZam�`_�ij_^m]Z^u\Z_l_�a^_kv�imlv�d l_jZibb��imlv�d mgbqlh`_gbx�kbfilhfh\�Wlbf�iml_f�;j_c_j�^_ckl\bl_evgh�\ue_qbe�k\hx�bkl_jbq_kdmx�iZpb_gldm��l��_��hk\h[h^be�__ hlkbfilhfh\�� hg� gZr_e� l_ogbdm� ^h\_^_gby� ^h� __ khagZgby� [_kkhagZl_evguo� ijhp_kkh\�kh^_j`Z\rbo�kfuke�kbfilhfZ��b kbfilhfu�bkq_aeb�Wlh� hldjulb_� ;j_c_jZ� [ueh� j_amevlZlhf� g_� mfhaj_gby�� Z kqZkleb\h]h� gZ[ex^_gby�klZ\r_]h� \hafh`guf� [eZ]h^Zjy� lhfm�� qlh� [hevgZy� ihreZ� _fm� gZ\klj_qm��Gh� \Zf� l_i_jv� g_ke_^m_l�klj_fblvky�h[tykgblv� _]h�g_ij_f_ggh�ba�q_]h�lh�^jm]h]h��m`_� agZdhfh]h��h^gZdh�\u^he`gu�ijbagZlv�\ g_f�gh\uc�nmg^Zf_glZevguc�nZdl��k ihfhsvx�dhlhjh]h�fh`gh�ijhykgblvfgh]h_�^jm]h_��JZaj_rbl_�fg_�ihwlhfm�ih\lhjblv�lh�`_�kZfh_�\ ^jm]bo�\ujZ`_gbyo�H[jZah\Zgb_� kbfilhfZ� ²� wlh� aZf_s_gb_� �(UVDW]�� q_]h�lh� ^jm]h]h�� qlh� g_� fh]ehijhy\blvky�� Hij_^_e_ggu_� ^mr_\gu_� ijhp_kku� ghjfZevguf� h[jZahf� ^he`gu� [ueb� [ujZa\blvky� gZklhevdh�� qlh[u� hgb� klZeb� ba\_klgu� khagZgbx�� Wlh]h� g_� kemqbehkv�� gh� aZlh� baij_j\Zgguo�� dZdbf�lh� h[jZahf� gZjmr_gguo� ijhp_kkh\�� dhlhju_� ^he`gu� [ueb� hklZlvky[_kkhagZl_evgufb�� \hagbd� kbfilhf�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� ihemqbehkv� qlh�lh� \jh^_� ih^klZgh\db�_keb�\ha\jZlblvky�d bkoh^ghfm�iheh`_gbx��lh�l_jZi_\lbq_kdh_�\ha^_ckl\b_�gZ�g_\jhlbq_kdb_kbfilhfu�^hklb]g_l�k\h_c�p_eb�Hldjulb_� ;j_c_jZ� _s_� ^h� kbo� ihj� y\ey_lky�nmg^Zf_glhf� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_jZibb�Iheh`_gb_�h lhf��qlh� kbfilhfu�bkq_aZxl�� _keb�bo�[_kkhagZl_evgu_�ij_^ihkuedb� k^_eZebkvkhagZl_evgufb�� ih^l\_j^behkv� \k_fb� ^Zevg_crbfb� bkke_^h\Zgbyfb�� ohly� ijb� ihiuld_� _]hijZdlbq_kdh]h� ijbf_g_gby� klZedb\Z_rvky� k kZfufb� kljZggufb� b kZfufb� g_h`b^Zggufbhkeh`g_gbyfb�� GZrZ� l_jZiby� ^_ckl\m_l� [eZ]h^Zjy� lhfm�� qlh� ij_\jZsZ_l� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� \khagZl_evgh_��b ebrv�ihklhevdm��ihkdhevdm�hgZ�\ khklhygbb�hkms_kl\blv�wlh�ij_\jZs_gb_�Ihki_rbf� l_i_jv� k^_eZlv� fZe_gvdh_� hlklmie_gb_�� qlh[u� m \Zk� g_� \hagbdeh� bkdmr_gbyij_^klZ\blv� k_[_� wlm� l_jZi_\lbq_kdmx� jZ[hlm� dZd� g_qlh� kebrdhf� e_]dh_�� Km^y� ih� gZrbfij_^u^msbf� jZkkm`^_gbyf�� g_\jha� y\ey_lky� ke_^kl\b_f� k\h_]h� jh^Z� g_agZgby�� g_\_^_gby� h^mr_\guo� ijhp_kkZo�� h dhlhjuo� ke_^h\Zeh� [u� agZlv�� Wlh� hq_gv� ihoh^beh� [u� gZ� ba\_klgmxl_hjbx�KhdjZlZ��kh]eZkgh�dhlhjhc�^Z`_�ihjhdb�hkgh\Zgu�gZ�g_agZgbb��Gh�hiulghfm�\ ZgZeba_\jZqm��dZd�ijZ\beh��hq_gv�e_]dh�^h]Z^Zlvky��dZdb_�^mr_\gu_�^\b`_gby�lh]h�beb�bgh]h�[hevgh]hhklZebkv�[_kkhagZl_evgufb��?fm�g_ljm^gh�[ueh�[u�ihwlhfm�\ue_qblv�[hevgh]h��hk\h[h^b\�hlkh[kl\_ggh]h� _]h�g_agZgby� khh[s_gb_f� lh]h�� qlh� hg� agZ_l��Ih� djZcg_c�f_j_�� lZdbf� h[jZahfe_]dh� \kdjulv� qZklv� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� kfukeZ� kbfilhfh\�� h ^jm]hc� `_� qZklb�� h k\yab

Page 155: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kbfilhfh\�k i_j_`b\Zgbyfb�[hevgh]h�\jZq��ijZ\^Z��fh`_l�kdZaZlv�g_fgh]h_��ihlhfm�qlh�hg�g_agZ_l�wlbo�i_j_`b\Zgbc��hg�^he`_g�`^Zlv��ihdZ�[hevghc�bo�\kihfgbl�b jZkkdZ`_l�_fm��H[�wlboi_j_`b\Zgbyo�fh`gh�kijZ\blvky�m jh^kl\_ggbdh\�[hevgh]h��b hgb�qZklh�[u\Zxl�\ khklhygbbhij_^_eblv� kj_^b�gbo� l_�� dhlhju_� hdZaZeb� ljZ\fZlbq_kdh_� ^_ckl\b_�� khh[sblv��fh`_l� [ulv�^Z`_� lZdb_�i_j_`b\Zgby�� h dhlhjuo�[hevghc�g_� agZ_l��ihlhfm� qlh� hgb�bf_eb�f_klh� \ hq_gvjZggb_�]h^u�_]h�`bagb��Kh_^bgb\�wlb�^\Z�ijb_fZ��fh`gh�[ueh�[u�gZ^_ylvky�aZ�dhjhldh_�\j_fyb fZeufb�mkbebyfb�ebd\b^bjh\Zlv�iZlh]_ggh_�g_agZgb_�[hevgh]h�Gh� _keb� [u� wlh� [ueh� lZd�� A^_kv� fu� ijbh[j_eb� hiul�� d dhlhjhfm� kgZqZeZ� g_� [uebih^]hlh\e_gu�� AgZgb_� agZgbx� jhagv�� _klv� jZagu_� \b^u� agZgby�� kh\_jr_ggh� g_jZ\ghp_ggu_ikboheh]bq_kdb�� ,,� m D� MDJRWV� HW� IDJRWV� �� ]h\hjblky� ]^_�lh� m Fhev_jZ��AgZgb_� \jZqZ�g_� lh�`_kZfh_��qlh�agZgb_�[hevgh]h��b hgh�g_�fh`_l�hdZaZlv�lh�`_�^_ckl\b_��?keb�\jZq�i_j_^Z_l�k\h_agZgb_�[hevghfm�iml_f�khh[s_gby��wlh�g_�bf__l�gbdZdh]h�mki_oZ��<ijhq_f��[ueh�[u�g_\_jghlZd�]h\hjblv��Mki_o�a^_kv�aZdexqZ_lky�g_�\ ij_h^he_gbb�kbfilhfh\��Z \�lhf��qlh�l_f�kZfufgZqbgZ_lky�ZgZeba��i_j\ufb�\_klgbdZfb�dhlhjh]h�y\eyxlky�ijhy\e_gby�khijhlb\e_gby��Lh]^Z[hevghc�agZ_l�qlh�lh��q_]h�^h�kbo�ihj�g_�agZe��l��_��kfuke�k\h_]h�kbfilhfZ��b \k_�`_�hg�lZd�`_fZeh�agZ_l�h g_f��dZd�b jZgvr_��LZd�fu�magZ_f��qlh�_klv�[he__��q_f�h^bg��\b^�g_agZgby��Qlh[uihdZaZlv��\ q_f�jZaebqby��g_h[oh^bfh�ba\_klgh_�m]em[e_gb_�gZrbo�ikboheh]bq_kdbo� agZgbc�Gh� gZr_� iheh`_gb_�� qlh� ijb� agZgbb� bo� kfukeZ� kbfilhfu� bkq_aZxl�� hklZ_lky� \k_�lZdbijZ\bevguf��>_eh�lhevdh�\ lhf��qlh�agZgb_�^he`gh�[ulv�hkgh\Zgh�gZ�\gmlj_gg_f�baf_g_gbb[hevgh]h�� dhlhjh_� fh`_l� [ulv� \ua\Zgh� ebrv� ikbobq_kdhc� jZ[hlhc� k hij_^_e_gghc� p_evx�A^_kv� fu� klhbf� i_j_^� ijh[e_fZfb�� dhlhju_� kdhjh� h[t_^bgylky� \ ^bgZfbdm� h[jZah\Zgbykbfilhfh\�M\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� L_i_jv� y ^he`_g� ihklZ\blv� \hijhk�� g_� dZ`_lky� eb� \Zf� lh�� qlh� y]h\hjx��kebrdhf�l_fguf�b keh`guf"�G_�aZimlu\Zx�eb�y \Zk�l_f��qlh�lZd�qZklh�hldZau\Zxkv�hljZg__�kdZaZggh]h�b h]jZgbqb\Zx�_]h��gZqbgZx�jZa\b\Zlv�fukev�b aZl_f�hklZ\eyx�__"�Fg_�[ueh[u�`Zev��_keb�[u�wlh�[ueh�lZd��Gh�m f_gy�kbevgh_�hl\jZs_gb_�d mijhs_gbyf�\ ms_j[�bklbg_��yg_� bf_x� gbq_]h� ijhlb\�� qlh[u� \u� ihemqbeb� ihegh_� ij_^klZ\e_gb_� h fgh]hklhjhgghklb� bfgh]hk\yaghklr�ij_^f_lZ��b ^mfZx��qlh�g_l�\j_^Z�\ lhf��_keb�ih�dZ`^hfm�\hijhkm�y ]h\hjx\Zf� [hevr_�� q_f� \u� fh`_l_� bkihevah\Zlv� \ gZklhysbc� fhf_gl�� Y \_^v� agZx�� qlh� ex[hckemrZl_ev�b qblZl_ev�fuke_ggh�\u\_jy_l��khdjZsZ_l��mijhsZ_l�b ba\e_dZ_l�ba�ij_^eh`_ggh]h_fm�lh��qlh�hg�ohl_e�[u�aZihfgblv��>h�ba\_klghc�kl_i_gb�\_jgh�lh��qlh��q_f�kh^_j`Zl_evg__[ue�ij_^eh`_gguc�fZl_jbZe��l_f�[hevr_�hl�g_]h�hklZ_lky��Iha\hevl_�fg_�gZ^_ylvky��qlh�kmlvfhbo�khh[s_gbc�h kfuke_�kbfilhfh\��h [_kkhagZl_evghf�b k\yab�f_`^m�gbfb�\u�ykgh�ihgyeb�g_kfhljy�gZ�\k_�\lhjhkl_i_ggu_�fhf_glu��<u��\b^bfh��lZd`_�ihgyeb��qlh�\ ^Zevg_cr_f�gZrbmkbeby� [m^ml� kdhgp_gljbjh\Zgu� gZ� ^hklb`_gbb� ^\mo� p_e_c�� magZlv�� \h�i_j\uo�� dZd� ex^baZ[he_\Zxl�� ijbh[j_lZxl� g_\jhlbq_kdmx� `bag_ggmx� mklZgh\dm�� qlh� y\ey_lky� debgbq_kdhcijh[e_fhc�� b�� \h�\lhjuo�� dZd� ba� mkeh\bc� g_\jhaZ� jZa\b\Zxlky� [he_ag_ggu_� kbfilhfu�� qlhhklZ_lky�ijh[e_fhc�^mr_\ghc�^bgZfbdb��B h[_�ijh[e_fu�]^_�lh�^he`gu�\klj_lblvky� �<_sv�\_sb�jhagv��njZgp���²�Ijbf_q��i_j�K_]h^gy�y lh`_�g_�ohqm�b^lb�^Zevr_��gh�lZd�dZd�gZr_�\j_fy�_s_�g_�bkl_deh��y gZf_j_gh[jZlblv�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�^jm]mx�hkh[_gghklv�^\mo�gZrbo�ZgZebah\��\k_� agZq_gb_�dhlhjhc

Page 156: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hiylv�lZdb�[m^_l�hp_g_gh�ebrv�iha`_��Z bf_ggh�gZ�ijh[_eu�\ \hkihfbgZgbyo��beb�Zfg_abb��<ukeurZeb�� qlh� aZ^Zqm�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h� e_q_gby�fh`gh� knhjfmebjh\Zlv� dZd� ij_\jZs_gb_\k_]h� iZlh]_ggh]h� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� \ khagZl_evgh_��L_i_jv� \u�� \hafh`gh�� m^b\bl_kv�� magZ\�qlh� wlm� nhjfmebjh\dm� fh`gh� aZf_gblv� ^jm]hc�� aZihegblv� \k_� ijh[_eu� \ \hkihfbgZgbyo[hevgh]h�� mkljZgblv� _]h� Zfg_abb�� Wlh� k\_ehkv� [u� d lhfm� `_�� :fg_abyf� g_\jhlbdZijbibku\Z_lky�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� \Z`gZy� k\yav� k \hagbdgh\_gb_f� _]h� kbfilhfh\��Gh� _keb� \uijbf_l_� \h� \gbfZgb_� ZgZeba� gZr_]h� i_j\h]h� kemqZy�� \u� gZc^_l_� wlm� hp_gdm� Zfg_abbg_hijZ\^Zgghc��;hevgZy�g_�aZ[ueZ�kp_gm��k dhlhjhc�k\yaZgh�__ gZ\yaqb\h_�^_ckl\b_��gZh[hjhl�`b\h�ojZgbl�__ \�iZfylb��b gbqlh�^jm]h_�ba�aZ[ulh]h�lh`_�g_�mqZkl\m_l�\ \hagbdgh\_gbb�wlh]hkbfilhfZ��F_g__�hlq_leb\h��gh�\ h[s_f�ZgZeh]bqgh�h[klhbl�^_eh�m gZr_c�\lhjhc�iZpb_gldb�^_\mrdb�k gZ\yaqb\uf�p_j_fhgbZehf��B hgZ��kh[kl\_ggh��g_�aZ[ueZ�k\h_]h�ih\_^_gby�\ jZggb_]h^u��l_o�nZdlh\��qlh�hgZ�gZklZb\ZeZ�gZ�hldju\Zgbb�^\_j_c�f_`^m�kiZevg_c�jh^bl_e_c�b k\h_cb ijh]hgyeZ�fZlv�k __�f_klZ�\ kmijm`_kdhc�ihkl_eb��hgZ�\kihfbgZ_l�wlh�kh\_jr_ggh�ykgh��ohlyb k� g_j_rbl_evghklvx� b g_hohlgh�� KljZgguf� fu� fh`_f� kqblZlv� lhevdh� lh�� qlh� i_j\ZyiZpb_gldZ�� bkihegyy� [_kqbke_ggh_� fgh`_kl\h� jZa� k\h_� gZ\yaqb\h_� ^_ckl\b_�� gb jZam� g_aZf_lbeZ� _]h� koh^kl\Z� k i_j_`b\Zgb_f� ihke_� i_j\hc� [jZqghc� ghqb�� b wlh� \hkihfbgZgb_� g_\hagbdeh� m g__�� dh]^Z� _c� aZ^Z\Zebkv�ijyfu_� \hijhku� ^ey� \uykg_gby�fhlb\Zpbb�gZ\yaqb\h]h^_ckl\by��Lh�`_� kZfh_� hlghkblky� d ^_\mrd_�� m dhlhjhc� p_j_fhgbZe� b _]h� ih\h^u� k\yaZgu� kh^ghc�b lhc�`_��dZ`^uc�\_q_j�ih\lhjy\r_cky�kblmZpb_c��< h[hbo�kemqZyo��kh[kl\_ggh�]h\hjy�g_l�gbdZdhc�Zfg_abb��gbdZdh]h�\uiZ^_gby�\hkihfbgZgbc��gh�ij_j\ZgZ�k\yav��dhlhjZy�^he`gZ[ueZ� [u� \ua\Zlv� \hkijhba\_^_gb_�� gh\h_� ihy\e_gb_� \hkihfbgZgby�� Ih^h[gh]h� gZjmr_gbyiZfylb� ^hklZlhqgh� ^ey� g_\jhaZ� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc�� ijb� bkl_jbb� ijhbkoh^bl� bgZq_��Wlhlihke_^gbc�g_\jha�hlebqZ_lky�\ [hevrbgkl\_�kemqZ_\�hq_gv�[hevrbfb�Zfg_abyfb��DZd�ijZ\beh�ijb� ZgZeba_� dZ`^h]h� hl^_evgh]h� kbfilhfZ� bkl_jbb� gZoh^brv� p_emx� p_iv� `bag_gguo\i_qZle_gbc��dhlhju_�ijb�bo�\ha\jZs_gbb�\ iZfylv�hij_^_eyxlky�[hevgufb�dZd�y\gh�aZ[ulu_�K h^ghc�klhjhgu��wlZ�p_iv�^hoh^bl�^h�kZfuo�jZggbo�e_l�`bagb��lZd�qlh�bkl_jbq_kdmx�Zfg_abxfh`gh�kqblZlv�g_ihkj_^kl\_gguf�ijh^he`_gb_f�^_lkdhc�Zfg_abb��dhlhjZy�m gZk��ghjfZevguoex^_c��hdmlu\Z_l�gZqZeh�gZr_c�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��K ^jm]hc�klhjhgu��fu�k m^b\e_gb_f�magZ_f�qlh�b kZfu_�ihke_^gb_�i_j_`b\Zgby�[hevguo�fh]ml�aZ[u\Zlvky�b \�hkh[_gghklb�ih^\_j]ZxlkyZfg_abb�� _keb� g_� kh\k_f� ih]ehsZxlky� _c�� ih\h^u�� ijb� dhlhjuo� \hagbdeZ� beb� mkbebeZkv[he_agv��Ba�h[s_c�dZjlbgu�lZdh]h�g_^Z\g_]h�\hkihfbgZgby�ihklhyggh�bkq_aZxl�\Z`gu_�^_lZebieb�aZf_gyxlky�eh`gufb�\hkihfbgZgbyfb��Ihqlb�\k_]^Z�[u\Z_l�lZd��qlh�ebrv�g_aZ^he]h�^hhdhgqZgby�ZgZebaZ�\kieu\Zxl�hij_^_e_ggu_�\hkihfbgZgby�h g_^Z\gh�i_j_`blhf��dhlhju_�lZd^he]h�fh]eb�aZ^_j`b\Zlvky�b hklZ\eyeb�\ k\yab�qm\kl\_ggu_�ijh[_eu�LZdb_�gZjmr_gby�kihkh[ghklb�\kihfbgZlv��dZd�[ueh�kdZaZgh��oZjZdl_jgu�^ey�bkl_jbb��ijbdhlhjhc� ^Z`_� \ dZq_kl\_� kbfilhfh\� gZklmiZxl� khklhygby� �bkl_jbq_kdb_� ijbiZ^db��� g_hklZ\eyxsb_� \ \hkihfbgZgbb� gbdZdh]h� ke_^Z�� ?keb� ijb� g_\jha_� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbcijhbkoh^bl�bgZq_��lh�ba�wlh]h�\u�fh`_l_�aZdexqblv��qlh�ijb�wlbo�Zfg_abyo�j_qv�b^_l�\hh[s_�hikboheh]bq_kdhf�oZjZdl_j_�bkl_jbq_kdh]h�baf_g_gby��Z g_�h[�h[s_c�q_jl_�g_\jhah\��AgZq_gb_wlh]h� jZaebqby� h]jZgbqb\Z_lky� ke_^mxsbf� khh[jZ`_gb_f�� Ih^� ©kfukehfª� kbfilhfZ� fuihgbfZ_f� h^gh\j_f_ggh� ^\Z� fhf_glZ�� hldm^Z� hg� [_j_lky� b dm^Z� beb� d q_fm� \_^_l�� l�� _�\i_qZle_gby�b i_j_`b\Zgby��hl�dhlhjuo�hg�bkoh^bl��b p_eb��dhlhjuf�kem`bl�

Page 157: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

LZdbf� h[jZahf�� gZ� \hijhk�� hldm^Z� [_j_lky� kbfilhf�� hl\_qZxl� \i_qZle_gby�� dhlhju_ijboh^yl� ba\g_�� [ueb� dh]^Z�lh� \ kbem� g_h[oh^bfhklb� khagZl_evgufb� b k� l_o� ihj� [eZ]h^ZjyaZ[u\Zgbx�fh]ml�klZlv�[_kkhagZl_evgufb��Gh�p_ev�kbfilhfZ��_]h�l_g^_gpby�²�wlh�dZ`^uc�jZawg�^hikbobq_kdbc�ijhp_kk��dhlhjuc��\hafh`gh��kgZqZeZ�[ue�khagZ\Z_f��gh�g_�f_g__�\_jhylgh�qlh� hg� gbdh]^Z� g_� [ue� \ khagZgbb� b ^Z\gh� hklZ\Zeky� \ [_kkhagZl_evghf�� LZd� qlh� g_� hq_gv\Z`gh�� aZo\ZlbeZ� eb� Zfg_aby� lZd`_� b bkoh^gu_� i_j_`b\Zgby�� gZ� dhlhjuo� hkgh\u\Z_lkykbfilhf��dZd�wlh�ijhbkoh^bl�ijb�bkl_jbb��p_ev��l_g^_gpby�kbfilhfZ��dhlhjZy�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZfh`_l�[ulv�[_kkhagZl_evgZ��hkgh\ZgZ�gZ�_]h�aZ\bkbfhklb�hl�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��b ijb�g_\jha_gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc�g_�f_g__�l_kghc��q_f�ijb�bkl_jbb�Gh�wlbf�\u^\b`_gb_f�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�gZ�i_j\uc�ieZg�\ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb�fu�\ua\ZebkZfuo� aeuo�^moh\�djblbdb�ikbohZgZebaZ��G_�m^b\eycl_kv� wlhfm�b g_�\_jvl_� lZd`_� lhfm��qlhkhijhlb\e_gb_�ijhlb\�gZk� aZdexqZ_lky�ebrv�\ ljm^ghklb�ihgbfZgby�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�beb�\hlghkbl_evghc�g_^hklmighklb�hiulguo�^Zgguo��dhlhju_�_]h�^hdZau\Zxl��Y iheZ]Zx��hgh�bf__l[he__�]em[hdb_�ijbqbgu��< l_q_gb_�\_dh\�gZb\gh_�kZfhex[b_�q_eh\_q_kl\Z�\ugm`^_gh�[uehij_l_ji_lv�hl�gZmdb�^\Z�\_ebdbo�hkdhj[e_gby��I_j\h_��dh]^Z�hgh� magZeh��qlh�gZrZ� a_fey�g_p_glj�\k_e_gghc��Z djhr_qgZy�qZklbqdZ�fbjh\hc�kbkl_fu��\_ebqbgm�dhlhjhc�_^\Z�fh`gh�k_[_ij_^klZ\blv�� Hgh� k\yaZgh� ^ey� gZk� k bf_g_f� Dhi_jgbdZ�� ohly� ih^h[gh_� ijh\ha]eZrZeZ� m`_Ze_dkZg^jbckdZy� gZmdZ�� AZl_f� \lhjh_�� dh]^Z� [bheh]bq_kdh_� bkke_^h\Zgb_� mgbqlh`behijb\be_]bx� khl\hj_gby� q_eh\_dZ�� mdZaZ\� _fm� gZ� ijhbkoh`^_gb_� ba� `b\hlgh]h� fbjZ� bg_bkdhj_gbfhklv�_]h�`b\hlghc�ijbjh^u��WlZ�i_j_hp_gdZ�ijhbahreZ�\ gZrb�^gb�ih^�\ebygb_fQ�� >Zj\bgZ�� Mhee_kZ� b bo� ij_^r_kl\_ggbdh\� g_� [_a� h`_klhq_gg_cr_]h� khijhlb\e_gbykh\j_f_ggbdh\��Gh�lj_lbc��kZfuc�qm\kl\bl_evguc�m^Zj�ih�q_eh\_q_kdhc�fZgbb�\_ebqby�[uehkm`^_gh�gZg_klb� kh\j_f_gghfm� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhfm� bkke_^h\Zgbx�� dhlhjh_� mdZaZeh�Y�� qlhhgh� g_� y\ey_lky� ^Z`_� ohaybghf� \ k\h_f� ^hf_�� Z \ugm`^_gh� ^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky� `Zedbfbk\_^_gbyfb�h lhf��qlh�ijhbkoh^bl�\ _]h�^mr_\ghc�`bagb�[_kkhagZl_evgh��Gh�b wlhl�ijbau\�dkdjhfghklb�bkoh^bl�g_� \i_j\u_�b g_� lhevdh� hl�gZk��ikbohZgZeblbdh\�� h^gZdh��ih�\b^bfhfm�gZf� km`^_gh�hlklZb\Zlv� _]h� kZfuf� wg_j]bqguf�h[jZahf�b ih^l\_j^blv�nZdlZfb��ihgylgufbdZ`^hfm�� Hlkx^Z� \k_h[sbc� ijhl_kl� ijhlb\� gZr_c� gZmdb�� hldZa� hl� \kydhc� ZdZ^_fbq_kdhc\_`eb\hklb�b hk\h[h`^_gb_�hiihabpbb�hl�\kydh]h�k^_j`b\Zgby�g_iZjlbcghc�eh]bdb��b d�wlhfm_s_�ijb[Z\ey_lky�lh��qlh�fu��dZd�\u�kdhjh�magZ_l_��gZjmrbf�ihdhc�wlh]h�fbjZ�_s_�b ^jm]bfh[jZahf�>?<YLG:>P:L:Y�E?DPBYKhijhlb\e_gb_�b \ul_kg_gb_M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��>ey�lh]h�qlh[u�ijh^\bgmlvky�^Zevr_�\ ihgbfZgbb�g_\jhah\�gZf�gm`gu�gh\u_�hiulgu_�^Zggu_��b fu�jZkkfhljbf�^\_�ba�gbo��H[_�\_kvfZ�ijbf_qZl_evgu�b\ k\h_�\j_fy�ihjZ`Zeb��<u�d gZf�ih^]hlh\e_gu�gZrbfb�ijhreh]h^gbfb�[_k_^Zfb�<h�i_j\uo�� _keb� fu� klj_fbfky� \ue_qblv� [hevgh]h�� hk\h[h^bl_� _]h� hl� [he_ag_gguokbfilhfh\��lh�hg�hdZau\Z_l�gZf�h`_klhq_ggh_��mihjgh_�khijhlb\e_gb_��:LGHUVWDQG���^eys__ky

Page 158: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ l_q_gb_�\k_]h�e_q_gby��Wlh�gZklhevdh�kljZgguc�nZdl��qlh�fu�^Z`_�g_�h`b^Z_f��qlh[u�_fmih\_jbeb��Jh^kl\_ggbdZf�[hevgh]h�emqr_�\k_]h�gbq_]h�g_� ]h\hjblv�h[�wlhf��ihlhfm�qlh�hgbgbdh]^Z� g_� ih^mfZxl� gbq_]h� ^jm]h]h�� djhf_� dZd� ijbgylv� wlh� aZ� hl]h\hjdm�� ba\bgyxsmx^ebl_evghklv�beb�g_mki_rghklv�gZr_]h�e_q_gby��;hevghc�lh`_�^_fhgkljbjm_l�\k_�ijhy\e_gbywlh]h�khijhlb\e_gby���g_�khagZ\Zy�_]h��b m`_�[hevrh_�^hklb`_gb_��_keb�gZf�m^Z_lky�^h\_klb[hevgh]h� ^h� ihgbfZgby� wlh]h� khijhlb\e_gby� b g_h[oh^bfhklb� kqblZlvky� k gbf��Ih^mfZcl_lhevdh�� [hevghc�� dhlhjuc� lZd� kljZ^Z_l� hl� k\hbo� kbfilhfh\� b aZklZ\ey_l� kljZ^Zlv� k\hbo[ebadbo��dhlhjuc�]hlh\�ih`_jl\h\Zlv�klhevdh�\j_f_gb��^_g_]��kbe�b ij_h^he_\Zlv�k_[y��qlh[uhk\h[h^blvky�hl�gbo��wlhl�[hevghc�hdZau\Z_l�khijhlb\e_gb_�\jZqm�\ bgl_j_kZo�k\h_c�[he_agb�DZdbf�g_\_jhylguf�^he`gh�dZaZlvky�lZdh_�ml\_j`^_gb_��B l_f�g_�f_g__�wlh�lZd��b dh]^Z�gZfmdZau\Zxl�gZ�g_\_jhylghklv� wlh]h�nZdlZ��gZf� hklZ_lky� lhevdh�hl\_lblv��qlh� wlhfm� _klv� k\hbZgZeh]b�� b ex[hc�� dlh� ijb]eZkbe� am[gh]h� \jZqZ� ijb� g_kl_jibfhc� am[ghc� [heb�� [m^_lhllZedb\Zlv�_]h�jmdm��dh]^Z�hg�aZohq_l�ijb[ebablvky�d [hevghfm�am[m�k sbipZfb�Khijhlb\e_gb_�[hevguo�qj_a\uqZcgh� jZaghh[jZagh�� \ \ukr_c� kl_i_gb� mlhgq_ggh��qZklhljm^gh�jZkihagZ_lky��ihklhyggh�f_gy_l�nhjfm�k\h_]h�ijhy\e_gby��>ey�\jZqZ�wlh�agZqbl�g_�[ulv^h\_jqb\uf�b hklZ\Zlvky�ih�hlghr_gbx�d g_fm�gZklhjh`_��< ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc�l_jZibb�fubkihevam_f� l_ogbdm�� dhlhjZy� agZdhfZ� \Zf� ih� lhedh\Zgbx� kgh\b^_gbc��Fu� ijhkbf� [hevgh]hijbclb�\ khklhygb_�kihdhcgh]h�kZfhgZ[ex^_gby��g_�m]em[eyykv�\ jZa^mfvy��b khh[sZlv�\k_��qlhhg�fh`_l�hij_^_eblv�ijb�wlhf�ih�\gmlj_ggbf�hsms_gbyf��qm\kl\Z��fukeb��\hkihfbgZgby� �\lhc�ihke_^h\Zl_evghklb��\ dhlhjhc�hgb�\hagbdZxl��Ijb� wlhf�fu�gZklhcqb\h�ij_^hkl_j_]Z_f_]h� g_� ih^^Z\Zlvky� dZdhfm�gb[m^v� fhlb\m�� `_eZxs_fm� \u[jZlv� beb� mkljZgblv� qlh�eb[h� baijbr_^rbo�_fm�\ ]heh\m�fuke_c��ohly�[u�hgb�dZaZebkv�kebrdhf�g_ijbylgufb�beb�kebrdhfg_kdjhfgufb��qlh[u�bo \ukdZau\Zlv��beb�kebrdhf�g_\Z`gufb��g_�hlghkysbfbky�d ^_em��beb[_kkfuke_ggufb��lZd�qlh�g_aZq_f�h gbo�b ]h\hjblv��Fu�\gmrZ_f�_fm�ihklhyggh�ke_^blv�ebrvaZ� ih\_joghklvx� khagZgby�� hldZau\Zlvky� hl� ihklhyggh� \hagbdZxs_c� djblbdb� lh]h�� qlh� hggZoh^bl��b m\_jy_f�_]h��qlh�mki_o�e_q_gby��Z ij_`^_�\k_]h�_]h�ijh^he`bl_evghklv��aZ\bkyl�hl^h[jhkh\_klghklb�� k dhlhjhc� hi� [m^_l� ke_^h\Zlv� wlhfm� hkgh\ghfm� l_ogbq_kdhfm� ijZ\bemZgZebaZ�� Ba� l_ogbdb� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc� fu� agZ_f�� qlh� bf_ggh� lZdb_� fukeb�� ijhlb\dhlhjuo� \hagbdZxl� i_j_qbke_ggu_� khfg_gby� b \hajZ`_gby�� h[uqgh� kh^_j`Zl� fZl_jbZe�\_^msbc�d jZkdjulbx�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�<u^\b]Zy� wlh� hkgh\gh_� l_ogbq_kdh_� ijZ\beh�� fu� ^h[b\Z_fky� kgZqZeZ� �lh]h�� qlh� \k_khijhlb\e_gb_�gZijZ\ey_lky�gZ�g_]h��;hevghc�\kyq_kdb�iulZ_lky�ba[_`Zlv�_]h�ij_^ibkZgbc��Lhhg�ml\_j`^Z_l��qlh�_fm�gbq_]h�g_�ijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m��lh��qlh�gZijZrb\Z_lky�lZd�fgh]h��qlh�hggbq_]h�g_�fh`_l�ihgylv��>Ze__�fu�k g_ijbylguf�m^b\e_gb_f� aZf_qZ_f��qlh�hg�ih^^Z_lky� lhh^ghfm�� lh� ^jm]hfm� djblbq_kdhfm� \hajZ`_gbx�� hg� \u^Z_l� k_[y� ^ebggufb� iZmaZfb�� dhlhju_^himkdZ_l� \ k\hbo� \ukdZau\Zgbyo�� Lh]^Z� hg� ijbagZ_lky�� qlh� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� g_� fh`_l� wlh]hkdZaZlv�� klu^blky� b kqblZ_lky� k wlbf�fhlb\hf�� g_kfhljy� gZ� k\h_� h[_sZgb_��Beb� _fm� qlh�lhijboh^bl�\ ]heh\m��gh�wlh�dZkZ_lky�^jm]h]h�ebpZ��Z g_�_]h�kZfh]h��b ihwlhfm�hg�bkdexqbe�wlh�bakhh[s_gby��Beb�qlh�l_i_jv�_fm�ijbreh�\ ]heh\m�^_ckl\bl_evgh�kebrdhf�g_\Z`gh_��kebrdhf]emih_�b kebrdhf�[_kkfuke_ggh_��\_^v�g_�fh]�`_�hg�ih^mfZlv��qlh�^he`_g�hklZgZ\eb\Zlvky�gZlZdbo�fukeyo��b lZd�ijh^he`Z_lky�\ [_kqbke_gguo� \ZjbZpbyo��gZ�qlh�ijboh^blky� \hajZ`Zlv�qlh�]h\hjblv�\k_�²�agZqbl�^_ckl\bl_evgh�]h\hjblv�\k_�

Page 159: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

?^\Z�eb�\klj_lbrv�[hevgh]h��dhlhjuc�g_�iulZeky�[u�khojZgblv�dZdmx�lh�h[eZklv��qlh[uij_]jZ^blv� d g_c� ^hklmi� ^ey� e_q_gby�� LZd�� h^bg�� dhlhjh]h� y ijbqbkeye� d \ukr_c� kl_i_gbbgl_eeb]_glguf��g_^_eyfb�mfZeqb\Ze�h[�bglbfghc�ex[h\ghc�k\yab�b��dh]^Z�y ihlj_[h\Ze�hlg_]h�h[tykg_gbc�aZ�gZjmr_gb_�k\ylh]h�ijZ\beZ��\u^\bgme�\ aZsblm�Zj]mf_gl��hg�^mfZe��qlh�wlZbklhjby�²�_]h�ebqgh_�^_eh��JZamf__lky��ZgZeblbq_kdh_�e_q_gb_��g_�^himkdZ_l�lZdh]h�ijZ\Z�gZm[_`bs_��Ihijh[mcl_�dZ�\ lZdhf�]hjh^_��dZd�<jgZ��^himklblv�bkdexq_gb_�^ey�dZdh]h�lh�f_klZ�\jh^_�<ukhdh]h�jugdZ�b P_jd\b�k\��Kl_nZgZ��h[ty\b\��qlh�lZf�g_evay�ijhba\h^blv�Zj_klu��bihklZjZcl_kv�aZl_f�ihcfZlv�dZdh]h�gb[m^v�ba\_klgh]h�ij_klmigbdZ��?]h�g_evay�[m^_l�gZclb�gb\ dZdhf�bghf�f_kl_��dZd�lhevdh�\ wlhf�m[_`bs_��H^gZ`^u�y j_rbeky�ij_^hklZ\blv�q_eh\_dm�ljm^hkihkh[ghklv�dhlhjh]h�[ueZ�h[t_dlb\gh�hq_gv�\Z`gZ��lZdh_�ijZ\h�gZ�bkdexq_gb_��ihlhfmqlh�hg�gZoh^beky�ih^�kem`_[ghc�ijbky]hc��aZij_sZxs_c�_fm�khh[sZlv�^jm]hfm�hij_^_e_ggu_\_sb��Hg��ijZ\^Z��[ue�^h\he_g� mki_ohf� e_q_gby��gh� y g_l��b y� j_rbe� \ij_^v�ijb�ih^h[guomkeh\byo�g_�ih\lhjylv�hiulZ�KljZ^Zxsb_� g_\jhahf� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc� ij_djZkgh� mf_xl� k^_eZlv� ihqlbg_ijb]h^guf� l_ogbq_kdh_� ijZ\beh� l_f�� qlh� hlghkylky� d g_fm� k qm\kl\hf� ih\ur_ggh���kh\_kleb\hklb� b khfg_gby�� Bkl_jbdb�� kljZ^Zxsb_� kljZohf�� \uihegyxl� _]h�� ^h\h^y� DGDEVXUGXP ��lZd�dZd�hgb�\hkijhba\h^yl�lhevdh�l_�fukeb��dhlhju_�gZklhevdh�^Ze_db�hl�bkdhfh]h�qlh� gbq_]h� g_� ^Zxl� ^ey� ZgZebaZ�� Gh� y g_� gZf_j_g� \\h^blv� \Zk� \ jZa[hj� wlbo� l_ogbq_kdboljm^ghkl_c��>hklZlhqgh� lh]h��qlh� \ dhgp_�dhgph\�[eZ]h^Zjy� j_rbl_evghklb�b gZklhcqb\hklbm^Z_lky� hl\h_\Zlv� m khijhlb\e_gby� ba\_klgmx� ^hex� ih^qbg_gby� hkgh\ghfm� l_ogbq_kdhfmijZ\bem�� b lh]^Z� hgh� i_j_ghkblky� gZ� ^jm]mx� h[eZklv��Hgh� \uklmiZ_l� dZd� bgl_ee_dlmZevgh_khijhlb\e_gb_�� [hj_lky� ijb� ihfhsb� Zj]mf_glh\�� ihevam_lky� ljm^ghklyfb� bg_ijZ\^hih^h[gufb� iheh`_gbyfb�� dhlhju_� ghjfZevgh_�� gh� g_� hk\_^hfe_ggh_� fure_gb_gZoh^bl�\ ZgZeblbq_kdbo�l_hjbyo��Lh]^Z�gZf�kheh�ijboh^blky�\ukemrb\Zlv�\k_�\hajZ`_gby�bdjblbdm��dhlhju_�ohjhf�jZa^Zxlky�\ gZmqghc�ebl_jZlmj_��LZd�qx�^ey�gZk�g_l�gbq_]h�gh\h]h�\lhf���qlh�gZf�djbqZl�ba\g_��Wlh�gZklhysZy�[mjy�\ klZdZg_�\h^u��H^gZdh�k iZpb_glhf�fh`ghih]h\hjblv�� hg� ijhkbl� gZk� hk\_^hfeylv� _]h�� ihmqZlv�� hijh\_j]Zlv�� mdZaZlv� _fm� ebl_jZlmjm�bamqb\� dhlhjmx�� hg� fh]� [u� ijbh[j_klb� gh\u_� agZgby��Hg� hohlgh� ]hlh\� klZlv� klhjhggbdhfikbohZgZebaZ� ijb� mkeh\bb�� qlh[u� ZgZeba� ihsZ^be� [u� _]h� ebqgh�� Gh� fu� magZ_f� \ wlhcex[hagZl_evghklb� khijhlb\e_gb_��mdehg_gb_�hl�gZrbo�ki_pbZevguo� aZ^Zq�b hl\_j]Z_f� __��Mg_\jhlbdZ�k gZ\yaqb\uf�khklhygb_f�fu�^he`gu�h`b^Zlv�hkh[hc� lZdlbdb� khijhlb\e_gby��HgqZklh� [_kij_iylkl\_ggh� iha\hey_l� b^lb� ZgZebam� k\hbf� oh^hf�� lZd� qlh� \ aZ]Z^dZo� _]h� kemqZyaZ[he_\Zgby�ijbh[j_lZ_lky�\k_�[hevr_�ykghklb��gh�\ dhgp_�dhgph\�fu�gZqbgZ_f�m^b\eylvky�qlh� wlhfm� jZatykg_gbx� g_� khhl\_lkl\m_l� gbdZdhc� ijZdlbq_kdbc� mki_o�� g_l� gbdZdh]hbkq_agh\_gby� kbfilhfh\�� Lh]^Z� fu� fh`_f� h[gZjm`blv�� qlh� khijhlb\e_gb_� hlklmibeh� aZkhfg_gb_�� k\hckl\_ggh_�g_\jham�gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc��b k� wlhc� ihabpbb� mki_rgh� ^Z_l� gZfhlihj�� ;hevghc� kdZaZe� k_[_� ijb[ebabl_evgh� ke_^mxs__�� \k_� wlh� ij_djZkgh� b bgl_j_kgh�� Yhohlgh�ihkfhljx��qlh�[m^_l�^Zevr_��Wlh�hq_gv�baf_gbeh�[u�fhx�[he_agv��_keb�[u�[ueh�\_jgh�Gh�\_^v�y kh\_jr_ggh�g_�\_jx��qlh�wlh�ijZ\bevgh��Z ihdZ�y wlhfm�g_�\_jx��fh_c�[he_agb�gbq_]hg_�dZkZ_lky��LZd�fh`_l�^he]h�ijh^he`Zlvky��ihdZ�kZf�g_�^hc^_rv�^h�wlh]h�ihlZcgh]h�f_klZ��blh]^Z�gZqbgZ_lky�j_rbl_evgZy�[hjv[Z�Bgl_ee_dlmZevgu_� khijhlb\e_gby� g_� kZfu_� om^rb_�� gZ^� gbfb� \k_]^Z� h^_j`b\Z_rv

Page 160: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ih[_^m��Gh�iZpb_gl��hklZ\Zykv�\ jZfdZo�ZgZebaZ��mf__l�lZd`_�kha^Z\Zlv�lZdb_�khijhlb\e_gby�ij_h^he_gb_� dhlhjuo� hlghkblky� d kZfuf� ljm^guf� l_ogbq_kdbf� aZ^ZqZf��<f_klh� lh]h� qlh[u\kihfbgZlv��hg�\hkijhba\h^bl�ba�k\h_c�`bagb�lZdb_�mklZgh\db�b qm\kl\Z��dhlhju_�ihkj_^kl\hflZd�gZau\Z_fh]h�©i_j_g_k_gbyª��8EHUWUDJXQJ��fh`gh�bkihevah\Zlv�^ey�khijhlb\e_gby�\jZqm�be_q_gbx��?keb�iZpb_gl�²�fm`qbgZ��hg�[_j_l�wlhl�fZl_jbZe��dZd�ijZ\beh��ba�k\h_]h�hlghr_gbyd hlpm��gZ�f_klh�dhlhjh]h�hg�klZ\bl�\jZqZ��b lZdbf�h[jZahf�kha^Z_l�khijhlb\e_gb_�ba�k\h_]hklj_fe_gby� d ebqghc�b bgl_ee_dlmZevghc� kZfhklhyl_evghklb��ba� k\h_]h� q_klhex[by�� dhlhjh_\b^_eh�k\hx�i_j\mx�p_ev�\ lhf��qlh[u�ih^jZ`Zlv�hlpm�beb�ij_\ahclb�_]h��ba�_]h�g_`_eZgby\lhjhc�jZa�\ `bagb�\aylv�gZ�k_[y�[j_fy�[eZ]h^Zjghklb��Ihjhc�\hagbdZ_l�\i_qZle_gb_� �>h�Z[kmj^Z��eZl���²�Ijbf_q��i_j�[m^lh�m [hevgh]h�_klv�gZf_j_gb_�ihdZaZlv��qlh�\jZq�g_�ijZ\��^Zlv�_fm�ihqm\kl\h\Zlv�k\h_[_kkbeb_��h^_j`Zlv�gZ^�gbf�\_jo��dhlhjh_�iheghklvx�aZf_gy_l�emqr__�gZf_j_gb_�ihdhgqblv�k[he_agvx�� @_gsbgu� ^ey� p_e_c� khijhlb\e_gby� mf_xl� fZkl_jkdb� bkihevah\Zlv� g_`gh_�wjhlbq_kdb�ih^q_jdgmlh_�i_j_g_k_gb_�gZ�\jZqZ��Ijb�ba\_klghc�kbe_�wlhc�kdehgghklb�ijhiZ^Z_l\kydbc�bgl_j_k�d ^_ckl\bl_evghc�kblmZpbb�e_q_gby��g_�bkihegy_lky�gb h^ghc�ba�h[yaZl_evkl\�\ayluo� gZ� k_[y� \ gZqZe_� _]h�� Z gbdh]^Z� g_� ij_djZsZxsZyky� j_\ghklv�� Z lZd`_� ]hj_qv� ba�aZg_ba[_`gh]h��ohly�b hklhjh`gh]h�hldZaZ�\ hl\_lghf�qm\kl\_�^he`gu�kh^_ckl\h\Zlv�mom^r_gbxebqgh]h�hlghr_gby�d \jZqm�b��lZdbf�h[jZahf��bkdexqblv�h^gm�ba�kZfuo�fh]mqbo�^_ckl\mxsbokbe�ZgZebaZ�G_evay� h^ghklhjhgg_� hkm`^Zlv� khijhlb\e_gby� wlh]h� jh^Z�� Hgb� kh^_j`Zl� fgh]h\Z`g_cr_]h�fZl_jbZeZ�ba�ijhreh]h�[hevgh]h��\hkijhba\h^yl�_]h�\ lZdhc�m[_^bl_evghc�nhjf_�qlh� klZgh\ylky� gZbemqr_c� hihjhc� ZgZebaZ�� _keb� bo�� mfZeh� bkihevamy� l_ogbdm�� gZijZ\blv� \gm`gh_� jmkeh�� AZf_qZl_evgh� lhevdh� lh�� qlh� kgZqZeZ� wlhl�fZl_jbZe� kem`bl� khijhlb\e_gbx� b\uklmiZ_l� k\h_c� \jZ`^_[ghc� e_q_gbx� klhjhghc��Fh`gh� lZd`_� kdZaZlv�� qlh� wlh� oZjZdl_jgu_k\hckl\Z�� mklZgh\db�Y�� dhlhju_�imkdZxlky� \ oh^� ^ey� [hjv[u� k baf_g_gbyfb�� d dhlhjuf�fuklj_fbfky��Ijb�wlhf�magZ_rv��dZd�h[jZah\Zebkv�wlb�oZjZdl_jgu_�k\hckl\Z�\ k\yab�k mkeh\byfb>\hagbdgh\_gby@� g_\jhaZ� \ \b^_� j_Zdpbb� ijhlb\� bo� lj_[h\Zgbc� b magZ_rv� wlb� oZjZdl_jgu_hkh[_gghklb�� dhlhju_� bgZq_� fh]ml� g_� ijhy\blvky� beb� ijhy\blvky� g_� \ lhc� f_j_� b dhlhju_fh`gh�gZa\Zlv�eZl_glgufb��M \Zk�g_�^he`gh�lZd`_�kdeZ^u\Zlvky�\i_qZle_gby��qlh�\ ihy\e_gbbwlbo�khijhlb\e_gbc�fu�mkfZljb\Z_f�g_ij_^\b^_ggmx�hiZkghklv�^ey�ZgZeblbq_kdh]h�\ebygby�G_l��fu�agZ_f��qlh�wlb�khijhlb\e_gby�^he`gu�ihy\blvky��fu�lhevdh�[u\Z_f�g_^h\hevgu��_keb\uau\Z_f�bo�g_^hklZlhqgh�ykgh�b g_�fh`_f�h[tykgblv�bo�[hevrhfm��GZdhg_p��fu�ihgbfZ_f�qlh�ij_h^he_gb_�wlbo�khijhlb\e_gbc�y\ey_lky�kms_kl\_gguf�^hklb`_gb_f�ZgZebaZ�b lhc�qZklbjZ[hlu��dhlhjZy�lhevdh�b ^Z_l�gZf�m\_j_gghklv��qlh�fu�q_]h�lh�^h[bebkv�m [hevgh]h�Ijb[Z\vl_� d wlhfm�� qlh� [hevghc� ihevam_lky� \k_fb� \klj_qZxsbfbky� \h� \j_fy� e_q_gbykemqZcghklyfb�� qlh[u� ihf_rZlv� _fm�� ex[uf� hl\e_dZxsbf� hl� g_]h� kh[ulb_f�� ex[uf\jZ`^_[guf� \uiZ^hf� \ Z^j_k� ZgZebaZ� kh� klhjhgu� Z\lhjbl_lgh]h� \ _]h� djm]m� q_eh\_dZ�kemqZcguf� beb� khijy`_gguf� k g_\jhahf� hj]Zgbq_kdbf� aZ[he_\Zgb_f�� qlh� ^Z`_� ex[h_memqr_gb_� k\h_]h� khklhygby�hg�bkihevam_l� dZd�ih\h^�^ey� hkeZ[e_gby� k\h_]h� klZjZgby��b \uihemqbl_� ijb[ebabl_evgmx� b \k_� _s_� g_� ihegmx� dZjlbgm�nhjf� b kj_^kl\� khijhlb\e_gby�� \[hjv[_�k dhlhjuf�gjh?h^bl�ex[hc�ZgZeba��Y lZd�ih^jh[gh�hklZgh\beky�gZ�wlhf�imgdl_��ihlhfm

Page 161: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

qlh� ^he`_g� \Zf� kdZaZlv�� qlh� wlb� gZrb� ^Zggu_� h khijhlb\e_gbb� g_\jhlbdh\� mkljZg_gbx� bokbfilhfh\�e_]eb�\ hkgh\m�gZr_]h�^bgZfbq_kdh]h�\a]ey^Z�gZ�g_\jha��;j_c_j�b y� kZf� kgZqZeZaZgbfZebkv� ikbohl_jZib_c� ijb� ihfhsb� ]bighaZ�� i_j\mx� iZpb_gldm� ;j_c_j� \k_]^Z� e_qbe� \khklhygbb� ]bighlbq_kdh]h� \gmr_gby�� \ wlhf� y \gZqZe_� ke_^h\Ze� _fm�� KhagZxkv�� qlh� lh]^ZjZ[hlZ�reZ�e_]q_�b ijbylg__�� Z lZd`_�gZfgh]h�[uklj__��Gh�j_amevlZlu�[ueb�g_ihklhyggu�bkhojZgyebkv�\ l_q_gb_�g_ijh^he`bl_evgh]h� ]j_f_gi��ihwlhfm� y \�dhgp_�dhgph\�hldZaZeky�hl]bighaZ��B lh]^Z�y ihgye��qlh�ijb�bkihevah\Zgbb�]bighaZ�g_\hafh`gh�[ueh�ihgylv�^bgZfbdmwlbo� ihjZ`_gbc�� Wlh� khklhygb_� dZd� jZa� b g_� iha\heyeh� \jZqm� aZf_lblv� kms_kl\h\Zgb_khijhlb\e_gby��Hgh� hlh^\b]Zeh� khijhlb\e_gb_� gZ� aZ^gbc� ieZg�� hk\h[h`^Zeh� hij_^_e_ggmxh[eZklv�^ey�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�jZ[hlu�b khkj_^hlhqb\Zeh�_]h�gZ�]jZgbpZo�wlhc�h[eZklb�lZd��qlh�hghklZgh\behkv� g_ij_h^hebfuf�� ih^h[gh� khfg_gbx�� \hagbdZxs_fm� ijb� g_\jha_� gZ\yaqb\uokhklhygbc��Ihwlhfm� y bf_x� ijZ\h� kdZaZlv�� qlh� ih^ebgguc� ikbohZgZebZ� gZqZeky� k hldZaZ� hlihfhsb�]bighaZ�Gh�_keb�\hijhk�h khijhlb\e_gbb�lZd�agZqbf��lh�g_�ke_^m_l�eb�gZf�\ujZablv�hklhjh`gh_khfg_gb_��g_�kebrdhf�eb�fgh]h_�fu�h[tykgy_f�khijhlb\e_gb_f"�Fh`_l�[ulv��^_ckl\bl_evgh_klv�kemqZb�g_\jhah\��ijb�dhlhjuo�ZkkhpbZpbb�g_�\hagbdZxl�ih�^jm]bf�ijbqbgZf��fh`_l�[ulv�^h\h^u�ijhlb\�gZrbo�ij_^ihkuehd�^_ckl\bl_evgh�aZkem`b\Zxl�kh^_j`Zl_evgh]h�h[km`^_gby�b fu� ihklmiZ_f� g_kijZ\_^eb\h�� lZd� jZ\gh^mrgh� hlh^\b]Zy� \ klhjhgm� bgl_ee_dlmZevgmxdjblbdm�ZgZebabjm_fh]h�dZd�khijhlb\e_gb_��>Z��m\Z`Z_fu_�]hkih^Z��gh�fu�g_e_]dh�ijbreb�dlZdhfm� \u\h^m��Fu� bf__f� \hafh`ghklv� gZ[ex^Zlv� dZ`^h]h� lZdh]h� djblbdmxs_]h� iZpb_glZijb� ihy\e_gbb� b ihke_� bkq_agh\_gby� khijhlb\e_gby�� < ijhp_kk_� e_q_gby� khijhlb\e_gb_ihklhyggh�f_gy_l�k\hx�bgl_gkb\ghklv��hgh�\k_]^Z�jZkl_l��dh]^Z�ijb[eb`Z_rvky�d gh\hc�l_f_�^hklb]Z_l�gZb[hevr_c�kbeu�gZ�\ukhl_�__ jZajZ[hldb�b kgh\Z�kgb`Z_lky��dh]^Z�l_fZ�bkq_jiZgZ�?keb� g_� ^himklblv� hkh[uo� l_ogbq_kdbo� hrb[hd�� lh�fh`gh� gbdh]^Z� g_� bf_lv� ^_eZ� k iheghcf_jhc�khijhlb\e_gby��gZ�dhlhjh_�kihkh[_g�iZpb_gl��LZdbf�h[jZahf��fu�fh]eb�m[_^blvky��qlhh^bg�b lhl�`_�q_eh\_d�\ ijh^he`_gb_�ZgZebaZ�[_kqbke_ggh_�fgh`_kl\h�jZa�lh�hklZ\ey_l�k\hxdjblbq_kdmx� mklZgh\dm�� lh� kgh\Z� ijbgbfZ_l� __�� ?keb� gZf� ij_^klhbl� i_j_\_klb� \ khagZgb_gh\mx� b hkh[_ggh� fmqbl_evgmx� ^ey� g_]h� qZklv� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� lh� hg� klZgh\blky� ^hdjZcghklb�djblbqguf��_keb�hg�jZgvr_�fgh]h_�ihgbfZe�b ijbgbfZe��lh�l_i_jv�wlb�aZ\h_\ZgbydZd� [m^lh� [u� bkq_aeb�� \ k\h_f� klj_fe_gbb� d hiihabpbb� \h� qlh� [u� lh� gb klZeh� hg� fh`_lijhba\h^blv� ihegh_� \i_qZle_gb_� Znn_dlb\gh� keZ[hmfgh]h�� ?keb� m^Zehkv� ihfhqv� _fm� \ij_h^he_gbb�wlh]h�gh\h]h�khijhlb\e_gby��lh�hg�kgh\Z�h[j_lZ_l�[eZ]hjZamfb_�b ihgbfZgb_��?]hdjblbdZ�� ke_^h\Zl_evgh�� g_� y\ey_lky� kZfhklhyl_evghc�� \gmrZxs_c� m\Z`_gb_� nmgdpb_c�� hgZgZoh^blky�\ ih^qbg_gbb�Znn_dlb\guo�mklZgh\hd�b mijZ\ey_lky�_]h�khijhlb\e_gb_f��?keb�_fmqlh�lh� g_� ijZ\blky�� hg� fh`_l� hq_gv� hkljhmfgh� aZsbsZlvky� hl� wlh]h� b hdZaZlvky� hq_gvdjblbqguf��gh� _keb� _fm� qlh�lh� \u]h^gh�� lh� hg�fh`_l�� gZijhlb\�� [ulv� \_kvfZ� e_]dh\_jguf�Fh`_l�[ulv��fu�\k_�g_gZfgh]h�emqr_��ZgZebabjm_fuc�lhevdh�ihlhfm�lZd�ykgh�h[gZjm`b\Z_lwlm�aZ\bkbfhklv�bgl_ee_dlZ�hl�Znn_dlb\ghc�`bagb��qlh�fu�\h�\j_fy�ZgZebaZ�^hklZ\ey_f�_fmlZd�fgh]h�h]hjq_gbc�DZdbf� h[jZahf� fu� kqblZ_fky� k l_f� nZdlhf�� qlh� [hevghc�� lZd� wg_j]bqgh� ijhlb\blkymkljZg_gbx� k\hbo� kbfilhfh\� b \hkklZgh\e_gbx� ghjfZevgh]h� l_q_gby� _]h� ^mr_\guoijhp_kkh\"� Fu� ]h\hjbf� k_[_�� qlh� ihqm\kl\h\Zeb� a^_kv� [hevrb_� kbeu�� hdZau\Zxsb_

Page 162: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

khijhlb\e_gb_� baf_g_gbx� khklhygby�� wlh�� ^he`gh� [ulv�� l_� `_� kbeu�� dhlhju_� \ k\h_� \j_fyijbgm^bl_etgh� \ua\Zeb� wlh� khklhygb_�� Ijb� h[jZah\Zgbb� kbfilhfh\� ijhbkoh^beh�� ^he`gh[ulv��qlh�lh�lZdh_��qlh�fu��jZa]Z^u\Zy�kbfilhfu��fh`_f�j_dhgkljmbjh\Zlv�ih�gZr_fm�hiulm�Ba� gZ[ex^_gby� ;j_c_jZ� fu� m`_� agZ_f�� qlh� ij_^ihkuedhc� ^ey� kms_kl\h\Zgby� kbfilhfZy\ey_lky�lh��qlh�dZdhc�lh�^mr_\guc�ijhp_kk�g_�ijhbahr_e�^h�dhgpZ�ghjfZevguf�h[jZahf��lZdqlh� hg� g_� fh]� klZlv�� khagZl_evguf�� Kbfilhf� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� aZf_klbl_ev� lh]h�� q]h� g_hkms_kl\behkv��L_i_jv�fu� agZ_f��d dZdhc� lhqd_�ijbeZ]Z_lky�^_ckl\b_�ij_^iheZ]Z_fhc� kbeu�Kbevgh_�khijhlb\e_gb_�^he`gh�[ueh�gZijZ\blvky�ijhlb\�lh]h��qlh[u�mihfygmluc�^mr_\gucijhp_kk� ejhgbd� \ khagZgb_�� ihwlhfm� hg� hklZeky� [_kkhagZl_evguf�� DZd� [_kkhagZl_evguc�� hgh[eZ^Z_l� kihkh[ghklvx� h[jZah\Zlv� kbfilhf�� Lh� `_� kZfh_� khijhlb\e_gb_� \h� \j_fyZgZeblbq_kdh]h� e_q_gby� \gh\v� ijhlb\h^_ckl\m_l� klj_fe_gbx� i_j_\_klb� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� \khagZgb_��Wlh�fu�hsmsZ_f�dZd� khijhlb\e_gb_��IZlh]_gguc�ijhp_kk��ijhy\eyxsbcky�\ \b^_khijhlb\e_gby��aZkem`b\Z_l�gZa\Zgby�\ul_kg_gby��9HUGUDQJXQJ��H[� wlhf� ijhp_kk_� \ul_kg_gby� fu� ^he`gu� khklZ\blv� k_[_� [he__� hij_^_e_ggh_ij_^klZ\e_gb_��Hgh�y\ey_lky�ij_^ihkuedhc�h[jZah\Zgby�kbfilhfh\��gh�hgh� \uklmiZ_l� lZd`_dZd�lh��q_fm�fu�g_�agZ_f�ZgZeh]h\��?keb�fu�\havf_f��d ijbf_jm��bfimevk��^mr_\guc�ijhp_kk�klj_fysbcky�ij_\jZlblvky� \ ^_ckl\b_�� lh�fu� agZ_f�� qlh� hg�fh`_l� [ulv� hldehg_g�� b wlh�fugZau\Z_f� hldZahf� beb� hkm`^_gb_f�� Ijb� wlhf� m g_]h� hlgbfZ_lky� wg_j]by�� dhlhjhc� hgjZkiheZ]Z_l��hg�klZgh\blky�[_kkbevguf��ih�fh`_l�khojZgblvky�dZd�\hkihfbgZgb_��<_kv�ijhp_kkijbgylby�j_r_gby�h g_f�ijhoh^bl�ih^�dhgljhe_f�Y��Kh\k_f�bgh_�^_eh��_keb�fu� �ij_^klZ\bfk_[_��qlh�wlhl�`_�bfimevk�ih^e_`bl�\ul_kg_gbx��Lh]^Z�hg�khojZgbe�[u�k\hx�wg_j]bx��b h�g_fg_�hklZehkv�[u�gbdZdh]h�\hkihfbgZgby��Z ijhp_kk�\ul_kg_gby�kh\_jrbeky�[u�lZd`_�g_aZf_lgh^ey�Y��LZdbf�h[jZahf��wlh�kjZ\g_gb_�g_�ijb[eb`Z_l�gZk�d ihgbfZgbx�kmsghklb�\ul_kg_gby�Y ohqm� khh[sblv� \Zf�� dZdb_� l_hj_lbq_kdb_� ij_^klZ\e_gby� hdZaZebkv� _^bgkl\_gghijb_fe_fufb�� qlh[u�ijb^Zlv� ihgylbx� \ul_kg_gby� [hevrmx� hij_^_e_gghklv��Ij_`^_� \k_]h�gZf� g_h[oh^bfh� i_j_clb� hl� qbklh� hibkZl_evgh]h� kfukeZ� keh\Z� ©[_kkhagZl_evgh_ª� dkbkl_fZlbq_kdhfm�� l�� _�� fu� j_rZ_fky� kdZaZlv�� qlh� khagZl_evghklv� beb� [_kkhagZl_evghklvikbobq_kdh]h� ijhp_kkZ� y\ey_lky� ebrv� h^gbf� ba� _]h� k\hckl\�� dhlhjh_� fh`_l� [ulvg_h^ghagZqguf�� ?keb� lZdhc� ijhp_kk� hklZeky� [_kkhagZl_evguf�� lh� wlh� hlkmlkl\b_� khagZgby�[ulv�fh`_l��lhevdh�agZd�ihklb]r_c�_]h�km^v[u��gh�g_�kZfZ�km^v[Z��>ey�lh]h�qlh[u�gZ]ey^ghij_^klZ\blv� wlm� km^v[m�� ij_^iheh`bf�� qlh� \kydbc� ^mr_\guc� ijhp_kk�²� a^_kv� ^he`gh� [ulv^hims_gh� bkdexq_gb_�� h dhlhjhf� [m^_l� mihfygmlh� gb`_�²� kgZqZeZ� kms_kl\m_l� \[_kkhagZl_evghc�klZ^bb�beb�nZa_�b lhevdh�ba�g__�i_j_oh^bl�\ khagZl_evgmx�nZam��ijbf_jgh�dZdnhlh]jZnbq_kdh_� bah[jZ`_gb_� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� kgZqZeZ� g_]Zlb\� b aZl_f� [eZ]h^Zjyihablb\ghfm� ijhp_kkm� klZgh\blky� bah[jZ`_gb_f�� Gh� g_� ba� \kydh]h� g_]Zlb\Z� ihemqZ_lkyihablb\�� b lZd� `_� g_� h[yaZl_evgh�� qlh[u� \kydbc� [_kkhagZl_evguc� ^mr_\guc� ijhp_kkij_\jZsZeky� \ khagZl_evguc�� Bgufb� keh\Zfb�� hl^_evguc� ijhp_kk� \oh^bl� kgZqZeZ� \ikbobq_kdmx� kbkl_fm� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� b fh`_l� aZl_f� ijb� ba\_klguo� mkeh\byo� i_j_clb� \kbkl_fm�khagZl_evgh]h�KZfh_� ]jm[h_� b kZfh_� m^h[gh_� ^ey� gZk� ij_^klZ\e_gb_� h[� wlbo� kbkl_fZo²wlhijhkljZgkl\_ggh_��Fu� kjZ\gb\Z_f� kbkl_fm�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h� k [hevrhc�i_j_^g_c�� \ dhlhjhc

Page 163: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dhihrZlky��ih^h[gh�hl^_evguf�kms_kl\Zf��^mr_\gu_�^\b`_gby��D wlhc�i_j_^g_c�ijbfudZ_l^jm]Zy� dhfgZlZ�� [he__� madZy�� \jh^_� ]hklbghc�� \ dhlhjhc� lZd`_� ij_[u\Z_l� b khagZgb_��Gh� gZihjh]_� f_`^m� h[_bfb� dhfgZlZfb� klhbl� gZ� ihklm� kljZ`�� dhlhjuc� jZkkfZljb\Z_l� dZ`^h_^mr_\gh_�^\b`_gb_�\ hl^_evghklb��ih^\_j]Z_l�p_gamj_�b g_�imkdZ_l�\ ]hklbgmx��_keb�hgh�_fmg_� gjZ\blky�� <u� kjZam� ihgbfZ_l_�� qlh� g_[hevrZy� jZagbpZ� ²� hl]hgy_l� eb� kljZ`� dZdh_�lh^\b`_gb_� m`_� k ihjh]Z� beb� ijh]hgy_l� _]h� hiylv� aZ� ihjh]� ihke_� lh]h�� dZd� hgh� ijhgbdeh� \]hklbgmx��>_eh� ebrv� \ _]h� [^bl_evghklb� b k\h_\j_f_gghf� jZk� ihagZ\Zgbb��Ijb^_j`b\Zykvwlh]h� h[jZagh]h� kjZ\g_gby�� fu� fh`_f� jZajZ� [hlZlv� ^Zevr_� gZrm� ghf_gdeZlmjm�� >mr_\gu_^\b`_gby� \ i_j_^g_c� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� g_^hklmigu� \ahjm� khagZgby�� gZoh^ys_]hky� \ ^jm]hcdhfgZl_�� hgb� kgZqZeZ� ^he`gu� hklZ\Zlvky� [_kkhagZl_evgufb�� ?keb� hgb� m`_� ^h[jZebkv� ^hihjh]Z�� b kljZ`� bo� hl\_j]�� lh� hgb� g_� kihkh[gu� ijhgbdgmlv� \ khagZgb_�� fu� gZau\Z_f� bo\ul_kg_ggufb��Gh�b l_�^mr_\gu_�^\b`_gby��dhlhju_�kljZ`�ijhimklbe�q_j_a�ihjh]��\ke_^kl\b_wlh]h� g_� h[yaZl_evgh� klZgh\ylky� khagZl_evgufb�� xgb� fh]ml� klZlv� lZdh\ufb� lhevdh� \ lhfkemqZ_�� _keb� bf� m^Zklky� ijb\e_qv� d k_[_� \ahju� khagZgby�� Ihwlhfm� k iheguf� ijZ\hf� fugZau\Z_f�wlm�\lhjmx�dhfgZlm�kbkl_fhc�ij_^khZgZl_etgh]h��9RUEHZX%WH���>ihgylb_@�hkhagZgbykhojZgy_l� lh]^Z� k\hc� qbklh� ^_kdjbilb\guc� kfuke�� Gh� km^v[Z� \ul_kg_gby� ^ey� hl^_evgh]h^mr_\gh]h� ^\b`_gby� khklhbl� \ lhf�� qlh� hgh� g_� ^himkdZ_lky� kljZ`_f� ba�� kbkl_fu[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�\ kbkl_fm�ij_^hhagZl_evgh]h��Wlh�lhl�`_�kljZ`��dhlhjuc�\uklmiZ_l�^ey�gZkdZd� khijhlb\e_gb_�� dh]^Z� fu� iulZ_fky� k ihfhsvx� ZgZeblbq_kdh]h� e_q_gby� mkljZgblv\ul_kg_gb_�Gh� y agZx�� \u� kdZ`_l_�� qlh� wlb� ij_^klZ\e_gby� klhev� `_� ]jm[u��� kdhev� nZglZklbqgu� bkh\_jr_ggh�g_^himklbfu�\ gZmqghf�baeh`_gbb��Y agZx��qlh�hgb�]jm[u��[he__�lh]h��fu�agZ_flZd`_�� qlh� hgb� g_ijZ\bevgu�� b _keb� fu� g_� hq_gv� hrb[Z_fky�� lh� m gZk� m`_� ]hlh\Z� emqrZyaZf_gZ��G_�agZx��ihdZ`mlky�eb�hgb�\Zf�klhev�`_�nZglZklbqgufb��IhdZ�wlh�\kihfh]Zl_evgu_ij_^klZ\e_gby�\jh^_�q_eh\_qdZ�:fi_jZ��ieZ\Zxs_]h�\ we_dljbq_kdhf�lhd_��b bfb�g_�ke_^m_lij_g_[j_]Zlv��ihkdhevdm�hgb�ihfh]Zxl�ihgylv�gZ[ex^Z_fu_�nZdlu��Fh]m�\Zk�m\_jblv��qlh�wlb]jm[u_� ij_^iheh`_gby� h ^\mo� dhfgZlZo�� h kljZ`_� gZ� ihjh]_�f_`^m� gbfb� b h� khagZgbb� dZdgZ[ex^Zl_e_�\ dhgp_�\lhjh]h�aZeZ�\k_�lZdb�hq_gv�[ebadb�d ^_ckl\bl_evghfm�iheh`_gbx�\_s_c�Fg_� ohl_ehkv� [u� lZd`_� mkeurZlv� hl� \Zk� ijbagZgb_�� qlh� gZrb� gZa\Zgby� hlghr_gbc� ²[_kkhagZl_evgh_��ij_^khagZl_evgh_�� khagZl_evgh_�²�f_g__� kihkh[gu�\\_klb�\ aZ[em`^_gb_�b[he__� hijZ\^Zggu�� q_f� ^jm]b_� ij_^eZ]Z_fu_� b mihlj_[ey_fu_�� dZd�lh�� ih^khagZl_evgh_�XQWHUEH?YX-%W���hdhehkhagZl_evgh_��QHEHQEH�ZX%W���\gmljbkhagZl_evgh_��ELQQHQEHZX%�W��b l��i�Ihwlhfm�_s_�[he__�agZqbfuf�^ey�f_gy�[m^_l��_keb�\u�fg_�mdZ`_l_��qlh�lZdh_�mkljhckl\h^mr_\gh]h�ZiiZjZlZ��dhlhjh_�y ij_^iheh`be��h[tykgyy�g_\jhlbq_kdb_�kbfilhfu��^he`gh�[ueh[u�bf_lv�h[s__�agZq_gb_�b��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��hljZ`Zlv�lZd`_�b ghjfZevgh_�nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgb_��<wlhf�\u��dhg_qgh��ijZ\u��K_cqZk�fu�g_�fh`_f�\gbdZlv�\ kmlv�wlh]h�\u\h^Z��gh�gZr�bgl_j_k�dikboheh]bb� h[jZah\Zgby� kbfilhfh\� qj_a\uqZcgh� \hajZklZ_l�� _keb� [eZ]h^Zjy� bamq_gbxiZlheh]bq_kdbo� hlghr_gbc� \hagbdg_l� i_jki_dlb\Z� jZah[jZlvky� \ klhev� ]em[hdh� kdjuluoghjfZevguo�^mr_\guo�ijhp_kkZo�<ijhq_f��jZa\_�\u�g_�magZ_l_��gZ�q_f�hkgh\u\Z_lky�gZr_�ij_^iheh`_gb_�h ^\mo�kbkl_fZo�hlghr_gbb�f_`^m�gbfb�b d�khagZgbx��<_^v�kljZ`�f_`^m�[_kkhagZl_evguf�b ij_^khagZl_evguf

Page 164: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

²� g_� qlh� bgh_�� dZd� p_gamjZ�� dhlhjhc�� dZd� fu� agZ_f�� ih^\_j]Z_lky� h[jZah\Zgb_� y\gh]hkgh\b^_gby�� HklZldb� ^g_\guo� \i_qZle_gbc�� \ dhlhjuo� fu� magZ_f� ih[m^bl_e_c� kgh\b^_gby�[ueb� ij_^khagZl_evguf� fZl_jbZehf�� bkiulZ\rbf� ghqvx� \ khklhygbb� kgZ� \ebygb_[_kkhagZl_evguo�b \ul_kg_gguo�`_eZgbc�b [eZ]h^Zjy�bo�wg_j]bb�kmf_\rbf�h[jZah\Zlv�\f_kl_k gbfb�kdjulh_�kgh\b^_gb_��Ih^�^Z\e_gb_f�[_kkhagZl_evghc�kbkl_fu�wlhl�fZl_jbZe�ih^\_j]kyi_j_jZ[hld_� ²� k]ms_gbx� b kf_s_gbx�� dhlhju_� \ ghjfZevghc� ^mr_\ghc� `bagb�� l�� _�� \ij_^khagZlaevghf��g_ba\_klgu�b ^himklbfu�ebrv�\ \b^_�bkdexq_gby��Wlh�jZaebqb_�\ kihkh[_jZ[hlu� klZeh� ^ey� gZk� oZjZdl_jbklbdhc� h[_bo� kbkl_f�� hlghr_gb_� d khagZgbx�� dhlhjh_kh_^bg_gh� k ij_^khagZl_evguf�� fu� kqblZeb� lhevdh� ijbagZdhf� ijbgZ^e_`ghklb� d lhc� beb^jm]hc�kbkl_f_��<_^v�kgh\b^_gb_�m`_�g_�iZlheh]bq_kdbc�n_ghf_g��hgh�fh`_l�ihy\blvky�m \k_oa^hjh\uo� \ mkeh\byo� khklhygby� kgZ��LZdh_� ij_^iheh`_gb_� h kljmdlmj_� ^mr_\gh]h� ZiiZjZlZ�dhlhjh_� iha\hey_l� gZf� ihgylv� dZd� \hagbdgh\_gb_� kgh\b^_gby�� lZd� b \hagbdgh\_gb_g_\jhlbq_kdbo�kbfilhfh\��bf__l�g_hkihjbfh_�ijZ\h�gZ�lh��qlh[u�[ulv�ijbgyluf�\h�\gbfZgb_b ijb�ghjfZevghc�^mr_\ghc�`bagb�<hl� \k_�� qlh� fu� `_eZ_f� kdZaZlv� k_cqZk� h \ul_kg_gbb�� Gh� hgh� ebrv� ij_^ihkuedZ� ^eyh[jZah\Zgby�kbfilhfh\��Fu� agZ_f��qlh� kbfilhf�²� wlh� aZf_klbl_ev�q_]h�lh��q_fm�ihf_rZeh\ul_kg_gb_��Gh� hl� \ul_kg_gby� ^h� ihgbfZgby� h[jZah\Zgby� wlh]h� aZf_klbl_ey� _s_� ^Ze_dh�� <k\yab�k \uy\e_gb_f�\ul_kg_gby�\hagbdZxl�\hijhku�b k�^jm]hc�klhjhgu��dZdh]h�jh^Z�^mr_\gu_^\b`_gby�ih^e_`Zl�\ul_kg_gbx��dZdbfb�kbeZfb�hgh�hkms_kl\ey_lky��ih�dZdbf�fhlb\Zf"�Ihwlhfm� ih\h^m� gZf� ^h� kbo� ihj� ba\_klgh� lhevdh� h^gh�� Ijb� bkke_^h\Zgbb� khijhlb\e_gby� fumagZeb��qlh�hgh�bkoh^bl�ba�kbe�Y��ba�ba\_klguo�b kdjuluo�k\hckl\�oZjZdl_jZ��Ke_^h\Zl_evgh�hgb�b ihaZ[hlbebkv�h \ul_kg_gbb�beb��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��mqZkl\h\Zeb�\ g_f�����<k_�hklZevgh_gZf�ihdZ�g_ba\_klgh�Lml�gZf�gZ�ihfhsv�ijboh^bl�\lhjhc�nZdl��h dhlhjhf�y ]h\hjbe��Ba�ZgZebaZ�fu�\ kZfuoh[sbo�q_jlZo�fh`_f�mdZaZlv��qlh�y\ey_lky�p_evx�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�kbfilhfh\��B \�wlhf�^ey�\Zkg_l�gbq_]h�gh\h]h��Y \Zf�m`_�ihdZaZe�wlh�gZ�^\mo�ijbf_jZo�g_\jhah\��IjZ\^Z��qlh�agZqZl�^\Zijbf_jZ"� <u� \ijZ\_� ihlj_[h\Zlv�� qlh[u� wlh� ^_fhgkljbjh\Zehkv� \Zf� ^\_klb�� [_kqbke_ggh_fgh`_kl\h� jZa��;_^Z� lhevdh� \ lhf��qlh� y g_�fh]m� wlh]h� k^_eZlv��Hkgh\gmx� jhev� a^_kv� \gh\vb]jZxl�kh[kl\_gguc�hiul�beb�\_jZ��dhlhjZy�fh`_l�hi_j_lvky�\ wlhf�imgdl_�gZ�_^bgh^mrgu_mdZaZgby�\k_o�ikbohZgZeblbdh\�<u� ihfgbl_�� qlh� \ ^\mo� kemqZyo�� kbfilhfu� dhlhjuo� fu� ih^\_j]eb� lsZl_evghfmbkke_^h\Zgbx�� ZgZeba� ihk\ylbe� gZk� \ kZfmx� bglbfgmx� h[eZklv� k_dkmZevghc� `bagb� wlbo[hevguo�� < i_j\hf� kemqZ_�� djhf_� lh]h�� fu� hkh[_ggh� ykgh� ihgyeb� p_ev� beb� l_g^_gpbxbkke_^h\Zggh]h�kbfilhfZ��fh`_l�[ulv��\h�\lhjhf�kemqZ_�hgZ�g_kdhevdh�aZl_fgy_lky�nZdlhjhf�h dhlhjhf�j_qv�[m^_l�gb`_��Lh��qlh�fu�\b^_eb�\ wlbo�h[hbo�kemqZyo��gZf�ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zeb[u�b ^jm]b_�ih^\_j]gmlu_�ZgZebam�kemqZb��:gZeba�\kydbc�jZa�ijb\h^be�[u�gZk�d k_dkmZevgufi_j_`b\Zgbyf�b `_eZgbyf�[hevgh]h��b \kydbc�jZa�fu�^he`gu�[ueb�[u�mklZgZ\eb\Zlv��qlh�bokbfilhfu� kem`Zl� h^ghc� b lhc� `_� p_eb�� WlZ� p_ev� hldju\Z_lky� gZf� \ m^h\e_l\hj_gbbk_dkmZevguo�`_eZgbc��kbfilhfu�kem`Zl�k_dkmZevghfm�m^h\e_l\hj_gbx�[hevguo��hgb�y\eyxlkyaZf_klbl_eyfb�lZdh]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby��dhlhjh]h�hgb�ebr_gu�\ `bagb�Ijbihfgbl_� gZ\yaqb\h_� ^_ckl\b_� gZr_c� i_j\hc� iZpb_gldb��@_gsbgZ� ebrZ_lky� k\h_]h

Page 165: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

]hjyqh� ex[bfh]h� fm`Z�� k dhlhjuf� hgZ� g_� fh`_l� jZa^_eylv� `bagv� ba�aZ� _]h� g_^hklZldh\� bkeZ[hkl_c�� HgZ� ^he`gZ� hklZ\Zlvky� \_jghc� _fm�� hgZ� g_� fh`_l� aZf_gblv� _]h� ^jm]bf�� ?_gZ\yaqb\uc�kbfilhf�^Z_l�_c�lh��q_]h�hgZ�`Z`^_l�²�\ha\urZ_l�__ fm`Z��hljbpZ_l��bkijZ\ey_l_]h�keZ[hklb��ij_`^_�\k_]h�_]h�bfihl_gpbx��< kmsghklb��wlhl�kbfilhf�y\ey_lky�bkiheg_gb_f`_eZgby� lhqgh� lZd�`_�� dZd� kgh\b^_gb_�� Z bf_ggh�� q_f� kgh\b^_gb_� [u\Z_l� ^Ze_dh� g_� \k_]^Z�bkiheg_gb_f� wjhlbq_kdh]h�`_eZgby��< kemqZ_�gZr_c�\lhjhc�iZpb_gldb�\u��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_�fh]eb� ihgylv�� qlh� __ p_j_fhgbZe� klj_fblky� ihf_rZlv� iheh\uf� kghr_gbyf� jh^bl_e_c� bebhlkjhqblv�bo��qlh[u�\ j_amevlZl_�g_�ihy\beky�gh\uc�j_[_ghd��<u��\_jhylgh��^h]Z^Zebkv��qlh��\kmsghklb��hgZ�klj_fblky�d lhfm��qlh[u�ihklZ\blv�k_[y�gZ�f_klh�fZl_jb��Ke_^h\Zl_evgh��hiylvmkljZg_gb_� ihf_o� \ k_dkmZevghf� m^h\e_l\hj_gbb� b bkiheg_gbb� kh[kl\_gguo� k_dkmZevguo`_eZgbc��H g_dhlhjhf�gZf_lb\r_fky�a^_kv�hkeh`g_gbb�j_qv�[m^_l�gb`_�M\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z��Y ohl_e�[u�ba[_`Zlv� lh]h��qlh[u�\ihke_^kl\bb�^_eZlv�hlklmie_gbyhlghkbl_evgh�h[s_]h�oZjZdl_jZ�fhbo�ml\_j`^_gbc��b ihwlhfm�h[jZsZx�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�lh�qlh� \k_�� qlh� y a^_kv� ]h\hjx� h \ul_kg_gbb�� h[jZah\Zgbb� kbfilhfh\� b bo� agZq_gbb�� [ueh\uykg_gh�gZ�fZl_jbZe_�lj_o�nhjf�g_\jhah\��bkl_jbb�kljZoZ��dhg\_jkbhgghc�bkl_jbb�b g_\jhaZgZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc�²�b kgZqZeZ�hlghkbehkv� lhevdh�d wlbf�nhjfZf��Wlb� ljb� aZ[he_\Zgby�dhlhju_� fu� ijb\udeb� h[t_^bgylv� \ h^gm� ]jmiim� ©g_\jhah\� i_j_g_k_gbyª�8EHUWUDJXQJVQHXURVHQ���h]jZgbqb\Zxl�lZd`_�h[eZklv�ijbeh`_gby�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc�l_jZibb�>jm]b_�g_\jhau�bamq_gu�ikbohZgZebahf�\ ]hjZa^h�f_gvr_c�kl_i_gb��h^gm�]jmiim�g_\jhah\�fuh[hreb� ih� ijbqbg_� g_\hafh`ghklb� l_jZi_\lbq_kdh]h� \ebygby�� G_� aZ[u\Zcl_� lZd`_�� qlhikbohZgZeba�_s_�hq_gv�fheh^Zy�gZmdZ��qlh�hg�lj_[m_l�fgh]h�ljm^Z�b \j_f_gb�^ey�ih^]hlh\db�bqlh�^h�g_^Z\g_]h�\j_f_gb�hg�jZajZ[Zlu\Zeky�h^gbf�q_eh\_dZf��Gh�fu� ]hlh\u�m]em[blvky�\h\k_klhjhgg__� ihagZgb_� wlbo� ^jm]bo� aZ[he_\Zgbc�� i_� hlghkysboky� d g_\jhaZf� i_j_g_k_gby�GZ^_xkv�� y kfh]m� _s_� ihdZaZlv� \Zf�� gZkdhevdh� jZkrbjyxlky� gZrb� ij_^iheh`_gby� bj_amevlZlu��ijbkihkZ[eb\Zykv�d wlhfm�gh\hfm�fZl_jbZem��b qlh�wlb�^Zevg_crb_�bkke_^h\Zgbyijb\_eb�g_�d ijhlb\hj_qbyf��Z d�mklZgh\e_gbx�_^bgkl\Z�gZ�[he__�\ukhdhf�mjh\g_��BlZd��_keb\k_�kdZaZggh_�a^_kv�bf__l�hlghr_gb_�d lj_f�g_\jhaZf�i_j_g_k_gby��lh�iha\hevl_�fg_�kgZqZeZih\ukblv� >\ \Zrbo� ]eZaZo@� agZqbfhklv� kbfilhfh\� gh\uf� khh[s_gb_f�� KjZ\gbl_evgh_bkke_^h\Zgb_� ih\h^h\� aZ[he_\Zgbc� ^Z_l� j_amevlZl�� dhlhjuc� fh`gh� knhjfmebjh\Zlvke_^mxsbf� h[jZahf�� wlb� ebpZ� aZ[he_\Zxl� \ke_^kl\b_� \ugm`^_ggh]h� hldZaZ� �9HUVDJXQJ�� hlq_]h�lh��dh]^Z�j_Zevghklv�g_�^Z_l�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�bo�k_dkmZevguf�`_eZgbyf��<u�aZf_qZ_l_��dZdij_djZkgh�h[Z�wlb�j_amevlZlZ�khhl\_lkl\mxl�^jm]�^jm]m��< lZdhf�kemqZ_�kbfilhfu�l_f�[he__ke_^m_l�ihgbfZlv�dZd�aZf_klbl_eb�g_^hklZxs_]h�\ `bagb�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�JZamf__lky�� \hafh`gu� _s_� fgh]b_� \hajZ`_gby� ijhlb\� iheh`_gby�� qlh� g_\jhlbq_kdb_kbfilhfu� y\eyxlky� aZf_klbl_eyfb� k_dkmZevgh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� GZ� ^\mo� ba� gbo� y ohqmk_]h^gy�hklZgh\blvky��?keb�\u�kZfb�ZgZeblbq_kdb�h[ke_^h\Zeb�[hevrh_�qbkeh�g_\jhlbdh\��lh�\hafh`gh��kdZ`_l_��dZqZy�]heh\hc��\ jy^_�kemqZ_\�wlh�\_^v�kh\_jr_ggh�g_�ih^oh^bl��kbfilhfu�dZd�dZ`_lky��kh^_j`Zl�kh\_jr_ggh�ijhlb\hiheh`gmx�p_ev��bkdexqblv�iheh\h_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_beb� hldZaZlvky� hl� g_]h�� Y g_� [m^m� hkiZjb\Zlv� ijZ\bevghklv� \Zr_]h� lhedh\Zgby�� KikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc�lhqdb�aj_gby�qZklh�\k_�a^_kv�g_kdhevdh�keh`g__��q_f�gZf�ohq_lky��?keb�[u^_eh� h[klhyeh� lZd� ijhklh�� lh�� \hafh`gh�� g_� lj_[h\Zehkv� [u� ikbohZgZebaZ�� qlh[u� \k_� wlh\kdjulv�� >_ckl\bl_evgh�� m`_� g_dhlhju_� q_jlu� p_j_fhgbZeZ� gZr_c� \lhjhc� iZpb_gldb

Page 166: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

h[gZjm`b\Zxl� _]h� Zkd_lbq_kdbc�� \jZ`^_[guc� k_dkmZevghfm� m^h\e_l\hj_gbx� oZjZdl_j�gZijbf_j��dh]^Z�hgZ�mkljZgy_l�qZku��qlh�bf__l�fZ]bq_kdbc�kfuke�ba[_`Zlv�ghqguo�wj_dpbc�beb� dh]^Z� hgZ� ohq_l� ij_^mij_^blv� iZ^_gb_� b ehfdm� khkm^h\�� qlh� jZ\ghkbevgh� aZsbl_� __^_\kl\_gghklb�� < ^jm]bo� kemqZyo�� dhlhju_� y bf_e� \hafh`ghklv� ZgZebabjh\Zlv�� wlhlhljbpZl_evguc�oZjZdl_j�ihkl_evgh]h�p_j_fhgbZeZ�[ue�\ujZ`_g�]hjZa^h�yjq_��p_j_fhgbZe�fh]kiehrv�khklhylv�ba�aZsblguo�f_j�ijhlb\�k_dkmZevguo�\hkihfbgZgbc�b bkdmr_gbc��H^gZdh�\ikbohZgZeba_� fu� m`_� lZd� qZklh� m[_`^Zebkv�� qlh� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb� g_� hagZqZxlijhlb\hj_qby��Fu�fh]eb�[u�jZa\blv�gZr_� ml\_j`^_gb_� \ lhf� kfuke_��qlh� kbfilhfu�bf_xlp_evx�beb� k_dkmZevgh_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_��beb� aZsblm�hl�g_]h�� Z bf_ggh�ijb�bkl_jbb�\ h[s_fqZs_� \klj_qZ_lky� iheh`bl_evguc�� bkihegyxsbc�`_eZgby� oZjZdl_j� >kbfilhfZ@�� ijb� g_\jha_gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbb²hljbpZl_evguc�� Zkd_lbq_kdbc�� ?keb� kbfilhfu� fh]ml� kem`blv� dZdk_dkmZevghfm� m^h\e_l\hj_gbx�� lZd� b _]h� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb�� lh� wlZ� ^\mklhjhgghklv�� bebiheyjghklv�� hlq_leb\h� hij_^_ey_lky� hkh[_gghklvx� bo� f_oZgbafZ�� h dhlhjhc� fu� _s_� g_mihfbgZeb��DZd�fu�magZ_f��hgb�y\eyxlky�j_amevlZlZfb�dhfijhfbkkZ��ijhbkr_^r_]h�ba�[hjv[u^\mo� ijhlb\hiheh`guo� klj_fe_gbc�� b ij_^klZ\eyxl� dZd� \ul_kg_ggh_�� lZd� b \ul_kgyxs__�mqZkl\h\Z\r__�\ bo�h[jZah\Zgbb��Ijb�wlhf�\ [hevr_c�kl_i_gb�fh`_l�[ulv�ij_^klZ\e_gZ�h^gZbeb� ^jm]Zy� klhjhgZ�� gh� lhevdh� \ j_^dbo� kemqZyo� \ebygb_� bkq_aZ_l� iheghklvx��Ijb� bkl_jbbijhbkoh^bl� kh\iZ^_gb_� h[_bo� p_e_c��Ijb� g_\jha_� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc� h[_� qZklb� g_j_^dhjZkiZ^Zxlky��kbfilhf�bf__l�lh]^Z�^\Z�i_jbh^Z��khklhbl�ba�^\mo�^_ckl\bc��kh\_jrZ_fuo�h^ghaZ�^jm]bf�b mkljZgyxsbo�^jm]�^jm]Z�G_� lZd�lh� e_]dh� mkljZgblv� \lhjh_� khfg_gb_�� ?keb� \u� ijhkfhljbl_� [hevrh_� dhebq_kl\hlhedh\Zgbc�kbfilhfh\��lh�kgZqZeZ�m \Zk��\_jhylgh��keh`blky�fg_gb_��qlh�ihgylb_�k_dkmZevgh]hm^h\e_l\hj_gby�djZcg_�rbjhdh��<u�g_�ij_fbg_l_�ih^q_jdgmlv��qlh�wlb�kbfilhfu�g_�^Zxl�^eym^h\e_l\hj_gby� gbq_]h� j_Zevgh]h�� qlh� ^hklZlhqgh� qZklh� hgb� h]jZgbqb\Zxlky� h`b\e_gb_fdZdh]h�lh�hsms_gby�beb�bah[jZ`_gb_f�dZdhc�lh�nZglZabb�ba�k_dkmZevgh]h�dhfie_dkZ��>Ze__�lh�� qlh� fu� gZ[u\Z_f� k_dkmZevguf� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f�� lZd� qZklh� h[gZjm`b\Z_l� ^_lkdbc� bg_ijbklhcguc� oZjZdl_j�� ijb[eb`Z_lky� d hgZgbklbq_kdhfm� Zdlm� beb� gZihfbgZ_lg_qbklhiehlgu_�ijb\uqdb��dhlhju_�aZij_sZxl�m`_�^_lyf�b hlmqZxl�hl�gbo��B djhf_�lh]h��\u\ujZabl_� k\h_� m^b\e_gb_�� qlh� aZ�iheh\h_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� ohlyl� \u^Zlv� lh�� qlh� ^he`gh� [ulvhibkZgh� dZd� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� `_klhdbo� beb� hl\jZlbl_evguo�� ^Z`_� aZkem`b\Zxsbo� gZa\Zgbyijhlb\h_kl_kl\_gguo�� kljZkl_c�� < wlhf� ihke_^g_f� imgdl_�� m\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� fu� g_^hklb]g_f� ihgbfZgby�� ihdZ� g_� ih^\_j]g_f� hkgh\Zl_evghfm� bamq_gbx� k_dkmZevgmx� `bagvq_eh\_dZ�b g_�mklZgh\bf�ijb�wlhf��qlh�bf__l�ijZ\h�gZau\Zlvky�k_dkmZevguf�><:>P:L:Y�E?DPBYK_dkmZevgZy�`bagv�q_eh\_dZM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z��Fh`_l� ihdZaZlvky�� qlh� g_l� gbdZdbo� khfg_gbc� \ lhf�� qlhke_^m_l�ihgbfZlv�ih^�©k_dkmZevgufª��K_dkmZevgh_�ij_`^_�\k_]h�²�wlh�g_ijbebqgh_��lh��h q_fg_evay� ]h\hjblv��Fg_� jZkkdZau\Zeb�� qlh� mq_gbdb� h^gh]h� agZf_gblh]h� ikbobZljZ� ihiulZebkvdZd�lh�m[_^blv�k\h_]h�mqbl_ey�\ lhf��qlh�kbfilhfu�bkl_jbdh\�qZklh�bah[jZ`Zxl�k_dkmZevgu_

Page 167: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

i_j_`b\Zgby��K wlhc�p_evx�hgb�ih^\_eb�_]h�d djh\Zlb�h^ghc�bkl_jbqghc�[hevghc��ijbiZ^dbdhlhjhc�g_khfg_ggh�bah[jZ`Zeb�ijhp_kk�jh^h\��Gh�hg�mdehgqb\h�hl\_lbe��lZd�\_^v�jh^u�\h\k_g_�k_dkmZevgh_��JZamf__lky��g_�\h�\k_o�kemqZyo�jh^u�²�wlh�qlh�lh�g_ijbebqgh_�Y aZf_qZx��\Zf�g_�gjZ\blky��qlh�y rmqm�h lZdbo�k_jv_aguo�\_sZo��Gh�wlh�g_�kh\k_f�rmldZ�=h\hjy� k_jv_agh�� g_� lZd�lh� e_]dh� hij_^_eblv�� qlh� khklZ\ey_l� kh^_j`Zgb_� ihgylby©k_dkmZevgh_ª�� Fh`_l� [ulv�� _^bgkl\_ggh� \_jguf� [ueh� [u� kdZaZlv� ²� \k_�� qlh� k\yaZgh� kjZaebqb_f�^\mo�iheh\��gh�\u�gZc^_l_�wx�[_kp\_lguf�b kebrdhf�h[sbf��?keb�\u�ihklZ\bl_�\p_glj� nZdl� iheh\h]h� ZdlZ� lh�� fh`_l� [ulv�� kdZ`_l_�� k_dkmZevgh_� ²� wlh� \k_� lh�� qlhijh^_eu\Z_lky� k l_ehf�� \ qZklghklb� k iheh\ufb� hj]ZgZfb� ^jm]h]h� iheZ�� k p_evx� ihemq_gbygZkeZ`^_gby�b \�dhg_qghf�blh]_�gZijZ\e_gh�gZ�kh_^bg_gb_�]_gblZebb�b bkiheg_gb_�iheh\h]hZdlZ��Gh� lh]^Z�\u�\ kZfhf�^_e_�g_^Ze_db�hl�ijbjZ\gb\Zgby�k_dkmZevgh]h�d g_ijbebqghfm��bjh^u�^_ckl\bl_evgh�g_�hlghkylky�d k_dkmZevghfm��Gh�_keb�kmlvx�k_dkmZevghklb�\u�ihkqblZ_l_ijh^he`_gb_�jh^Z��lh�jbkdm_l_�bkdexqblv�p_euc�jy^�\_s_c��dhlhju_�g_�kem`Zl�ijh^he`_gbxjh^Z�b \k_�lZdb�hij_^_e_ggh�k_dkmZevgu��dZd��gZijbf_j��fZklmj[Zpby�b ^Z`_�ihp_emc��Gh�fu\_^v�m`_�m[_^bebkv��qlh�ihiuldb�^Z\Zlv�hij_^_e_gby�\k_]^Z�\uau\Zxl�aZljm^g_gby��g_�[m^_f^mfZlv��qlh�bf_ggh�\ wlhf�kemqZ_�^_eh�h[klhbl�ih�^jm]hfm��Fu�ih^haj_\Z_f��qlh�\ jZa\blbbihgylby� ©k_dkmZevgh_ª�ijhbahreh�g_qlh� lZdh_�� qlh��ih� m^Zqghfm� \ujZ`_gbx�=�� Abev[_j_jZ�ih\e_deh�aZ�kh[hc�©hrb[dm�gZeh`_gbyª��©8EHUGHFNXQJV�IHKOHUª���Gh�\ p_ehf�\_^v�fu�g_�kh\k_fm`�g_�jZa[bjZ_fky�\ lhf��qlh�ex^b�gZau\Zxl�k_dkmZevguf�Wlh� lh�� qlh� kdeZ^u\Z_lky� ba� mq_lZ� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb� iheh\�� ihemq_gby� gZkeZ`^_gby�ijh^he`_gby� jh^Z� b oZjZdl_jZ� kdju\Z_fh]h� g_ijbebqgh]h�²� lZdh]h� hij_^_e_gby� [m^_l^hklZlhqgh�^ey�\k_o�ijZdlbq_kdbo�lj_[h\Zgbc�`bagb��Gh�_]h�g_^hklZlhqgh�^ey�gZmdb��Ihlhfmqlh�[eZ]h^Zjy� lsZl_evguf�bkke_^h\Zgbyf�� klZ\rbf�\hafh`gufb� lhevdh�[eZ]h^Zjy� ]hlh\hfmgZ�`_jl\u�kZfhij_h^he_gbx��fu�ihagZdhfbebkv�k ]jmiiZfb�bg^b\b^h\��©k_dkmZevgZy�`bagvªdhlhjuo� kZfuf� j_adbf� h[jZahf� hldehgy_lky� hl� h[uqgh]h� kj_^g_]h� ij_^klZ\e_gby��H^gb� bawlbo� ©ba\jZs_gguoª� bkdexqbeb�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� ba� k\h_c� ijh]jZffu� jZaebqb_� iheh\�� Lhevdhex^b�h^gh]h�k gbfb�iheZ�fh]ml�\ha[m^blv�bo�k_dkmZevgu_�`_eZgby��^jm]hc�ihe��hkh[_ggh�_]hiheh\u_� hj]Zgu�� \hh[s_� g_� y\ey_lky� ^ey� gbo� iheh\uf� h[t_dlhf�� \ djZcgbo� kemqZyo� ^Z`_\uau\Z_l� hl\jZs_gb_�� L_f� kZfuf� hgb�� _kl_kl\_ggh�� hldZaZebkv� hl� \kydh]h� mqZklby� \ijh^he`_gbb�jh^Z��LZdbo�ebp�fu�gZau\Z_f� ]hfhk_dkmZebklZfb��beb�bg\_jlbjh\Zggufb��Wlhfm`qbgu� b `_gsbgu�� ^h\hevgh� qZklh� ²� gh� g_� \k_]^Z� ²� [_amkeh\gh� h[jZah\Zggu_�bgl_ee_dlmZevgh� jZa\blu_� b \ukhdhgjZ\kl\_ggu_�� hly]q_ggu_� ebrv� wlbf� h^gbf� jhdh\ufhldehg_gb_f��MklZfb� k\hbm�gZmqguo� aZsblgbdh\� hgb� \u^Zxl� k_[y� aZ� hkh[mx� jZagh\b^ghklvq_eh\_q_kdh]h� lbiZ�� aZ� ©lj_lbc� iheª�� jZ\ghijZ\gh� kms_kl\mxsbc� gZjy^m� k ^\mfy� ^jm]bfb�;ulv�fh`_l��gZf�ij_^klZ\blky�kemqZc�djblbq_kdb�ijhZgZebabjh\Zlv�bo�ijblyaZgby��JZamf__lky�hgb� g_� y\eyxlky� ©weblhcª� q_eh\_q_kl\Z�� dZd� hgb� ex[yl� ]h\hjblv�� Z kj_^b� gbo� bf__lky� ihf_gvr_c� f_j_� klhebdh� `_� g_iheghp_gguo� b gbdq_fguo� bg^b\b^h\�� kdhevdh� b m� bguo� \k_dkmZevghf�hlghr_gbb�ex^_c�Wlb�ba\jZs_ggu_��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��ihklmiZxl�kh�k\hbf�k_dkmZevguf�h[t_dlhf�ijbf_jghlZd�`_��dZd�ghjfZevgu_�kh�k\hbf��Gh�bf__lky�[hevrh_�qbkeh�lZdbo�g_ghjfZevguo��k_dkmZevgZy^_yl_evghklv� dhlhjuo� \k_� [hevr_� m^Zey_lky� hl� lh]h�� qlh� dZ`_lky� `_eZgguf� jZamfghfm

Page 168: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

q_eh\_dm��Ih� jZaghh[jZabx� b kljZgghklb� bo�fh`gh� kjZ\gblv� ebrv� k ]jhl_kdgufb� mjh^Zfb�dhlhjuo� I�� ;j_c]_ev� bah[jZabe� bkdmrZxsbfb� k\ylh]h� :glhgby�� beb� k ^Z\gbfb� [h]Zfb� b\_jmxsbfb��dhlhjuo�=��Neh[_j�aZklZ\ey_l�ijhghkblvky�\ ^ebgghc�ijhp_kkbb�i_j_^�gZ[h`gufdZxsbfky� ]j_rgbdhf�� Bo� gZ^h� dZd�lh� deZkkbnbpbjh\Zlv�� qlh[u� gZf� g_� aZimlZlvky�� FujZa^_ey_f�bo�gZ�lZdbo��m dhlhjuo��dZd�m ]hfhk_dkmZebklh\��baf_gbeky�k_dkmZevguc�h[t_dl��b gZ^jm]bo��m dhlhjuo�ij_`^_�\k_]h�baf_gbeZkv�k_dkmZevgZy�p_ev��D i_j\hc�]jmii_�hlghkylky�l_�dlh�hldZaZeky�hl�kh_^bg_gby�]_gblZebc�b ijb�iheh\hf�Zdl_�aZf_gy_l�]_gblZebb�iZjlg_jZ�^jm]hcqZklvx� beb� h[eZklvx� l_eZ�� ijb� wlhf� hgb� g_� kqblZxlky� k g_^hklZldZfb� hj]Zgbq_kdh]hmkljhckl\Z�b i_j_klmiZxl�]jZgbpu�hl\jZs_gby� �jhl��aZ^gbc�ijhoh^�\f_klh�\eZ]ZebsZ���Kx^Zhlghkylky� b ^jm]b_�� m dhlhjuo� ohly� b khojZgbeky� bgl_j_k� d ]_gblZebyf�� gh� g_� ba�aZk_dkmZevguo��Z ba�aZ�^jm]bo�nmgdpbc��\ dhlhjuo�hgb�mqZkl\mxl�ih�ZgZlhfbq_kdbf�ijbqbgZf�b\ke_^kl\b_� khk_^kl\Z��Ih� gbf�fu� magZ_f�� qlh�nmgdpbb� \u^_e_gby�� dhlhju_� ijb� \hkiblZgbbj_[_gdZ� hlh^\b]Zxlky� gZAaZ^gbc� ieZg� dZd� g_ijbebqgu_�� fh]ml� \k_p_eh� ijb\e_qv� d k_[_k_dkmZevguc�bgl_j_k��>Ze__�b^ml�^jm]b_��dhlhju_�\hh[s_�hldZaZebkv�hl�]_gblZebc�dZd�h[t_dlZb ihklZ\beb�gZ�bo�f_klh�dZd�`_eZgguc�h[t_dl�^jm]mx�qZklv�l_eZ�²�`_gkdmx�]jm^v��gh]m��dhkm�AZl_f�ke_^mxl�l_��^ey�dhlhjuo�gbq_]h�g_�agZqbl�b qZklv�l_eZ��gh�\k_�`_eZgby�\uihegy_l�dZdhc�eb[h�ij_^f_l�h^_`^u��h[m\v��qlh�eb[h�ba�gb`g_]h�[_evy�²�n_lbrbklu��Ke_^mxs__�f_klh�\wlhf� jy^m� aZgbfZxl� ebpZ�� dhlhju_� ohly� b `_eZxl� \_kv� h[t_dl�� gh� ij_^ty\eyxl� d g_fmkh\_jr_ggh�hij_^_e_ggu_�kljZggu_�beb�hl\jZlbl_evgu_�lj_[h\Zgby��^Z`_�lZdb_��qlh[u�h[t_dlklZe� [_aaZsblguf� ljmihf�� b ^_eZxl� _]h� lZdh\uf� \ k\h_f� ij_klmighf� gZkbebb�� qlh[ugZkeZ`^Zlvky�bf��Gh�^h\hevgh�m`Zkh\�ba�wlhc�h[eZklb�>jm]mx� ]jmiim� \ha]eZ\eyxl� ba\jZs_ggu_�� ihklZ\b\rb_� p_evx� k\hbo� k_dkmZevguo`_eZgbc�lh��qlh�\ ghjfZevguo�mkeh\byo�y\ey_lky�lhevdh�\klmibl_evguf�b ih^]hlh\bl_evguf^_ckl\b_f��Z bf_ggh�jZa]ey^u\Zgb_�b hsmiu\Zgb_�^jm]h]h�ebpZ�beb�ih^]ey^u\Zgb_�aZ�gbf�ijbbkiheg_gbb�bglbfguo� hlijZ\e_gbc�beb� h[gZ`_gb_� k\hbo� kh[kl\_gguo� qZkl_c� l_eZ�� dhlhju_^he`gu�[ulv�Kdjulu��\ kfmlghc�gZ^_`^_��qlh�hgb�[m^ml�\hagZ]jZ`^_gu�lZdbf�`_�hl\_lguf^_ckl\b_f��AZl_f�ke_^mxl�aZ]Z^hqgu_�kZ^bklu��g_`gh_�klj_fe_gb_�dhlhjuo�g_�agZ_l�gbdZdhcbghc� p_eb�� dZd� ijbqbgblv� k\h_fm� h[t_dlm� [hev� beb� fmq_gb_�� gZqbgZy� k e_]dh]h� mgb`_gby\iehlv� ^h� ly`_euo� l_e_kguo� ih\j_`^_gbc�� b�� dZd� [u� ^ey� jZ\gh\_kby�� bo� Zglbih^u� ²fZahobklu��_^bgkl\_ggh_�m^h\hevkl\b_�dhlhjuo�khklhbl�\ lhf��qlh[u�bkiulZlv�hl�ex[bfh]hh[t_dlZ�\k_�mgb`_gby�b fmq_gby�\ kbf\hebq_kdhc�b \�j_Zevghc �nhjf_��Bf_xlky�_s_�b ^jm]b_�m dhlhjuo�khq_lZ_lky�b i_j_ie_lZ_lky�g_kdhevdh�lZdbo�g_ghjfZevghkl_c��b��gZdhg_p��fu�_s_magZ_f�� qlh� dZ`^Zy� ba� wlbo� ]jmii� kms_kl\m_l� \ ^\mo� \b^Zo�� qlh� gZjy^m� k l_fb�� dlh� bs_lk_dkmZevgh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby� \ j_Zevghklb�� _klv� _s_� ^jm]b_�� dhlhju_� ^h\hevkl\mxlky� l_f�qlh[u� lhevdh� ij_^klZ\blv� k_[_� lZdh_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�� dhlhjuf� \hh[s_� g_� gm`_g� gbdZdhcj_Zevguc�h[t_dl��lZd�dZd�hgb�fh]ml�aZf_gblv�_]h�k_[_�nZglZab_c�Ijb� wlhf� g_� ih^e_`bl� gb�fZe_cr_fm� khfg_gbx�� qlh� \ wlbo� [_amfkl\Zo�� kljZgghklyo� bf_jahklyo� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� ijhy\ey_lky� k_dkmZevgZy� ^_yl_evghklv� wlbo� ex^_c�� G_� lhevdh� hgbkZfb�lZd�ihgbfZxl�b qm\kl\mxl�aZf_sZxs__�hlghr_gb_��gh�b fu�^he`gu�kdZaZlv��qlh�\k_�wlhb]jZ_l�\ bo�`bagb�lm�`_�jhev��qlh�b ghjfZevgh_�k_dkmZevgh_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�\ gZr_c��aZ�wlhhgb�ijbghkyl�l_�`_��qZklh�]jhfZ^gu_�`_jl\u��b \�h[s_f��b \�qZklghf�fh`gh�ijhke_^blv��]^_wlb� g_ghjfZevghklb� ]jZgbqZl� k ghjfhc�� Z ]^_� hldehgyxlky� hl� g__�� <u� lZd`_� g_� fh`_l_� g_

Page 169: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

aZf_lblv�� qlh� oZjZdl_j� g_ijbebqgh]h�� ijbkmsbc� k_dkmZevghc� ^_yl_evghklb�� bf__l� f_klh� ba^_kv��gh�ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�hg�mkbeb\Z_lky�^h�ihahjgh]h�DZd�`_��m\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��fu�hlghkbfky�d wlbf�g_h[uqguf�\b^Zf�k_dkmZevgh]hm^h\e_l\hj_gby"�<hafms_gb_f��\ujZ`_gb_f�gZr_]h�ebqgh]h�hl\jZs_gby�b aZ\_j_gb_f��qlh�fug_� jZa^_ey_f� wlb� ijbohlb�� hq_\b^gh�� gbq_]h� g_� k^_eZ_rv�� >Z� gZk� h[� wlhf� gbdlh� b g_kijZrb\Z_l�� < dhgp_� dhgph\�� wlh� lZdZy� `_� h[eZklv� y\e_gbc�� dZd� b ^jm]Zy�� HljbpZl_evgmxhl]h\hjdm��qlh� wlh�\_^v� lhevdh�j_^db_�b dmjv_agu_� kemqZb��g_ljm^gh�[ueh�[u� hijh\_j]gmlv�GZh[hjhl��j_qv�b^_l�h[�hq_gv� qZkluo��rbjhdh� jZkijhkljZg_gguo� y\e_gbyo��Gh� _keb�[u� dlh�gb[m^v� aZohl_e� gZf� kdZaZlv�� qlh� hgb� g_� ^he`gu� k[b\Zlv� gZk� k lhedm� \ gZrbo� \a]ey^Zo� gZk_dkmZevgmx� `bagv�� ihlhfm� qlh� hgb� \k_� [_a� bkdexq_gby� y\eyxlky� aZ[em`^_gbyfb� bgZjmr_gbyfb�k_dkmZevgh]h�\e_q_gby��lh�[ue�[u�mf_kl_g�k_jv_aguc�hl\_l��?keb�fu�g_�kmf__fihgylv�wlb�[he_ag_ggu_�nhjfu�k_dkmZevghklb�b k\yaZlv�bo�k ghjfZevghc�k_dkmZevghc�`bagvx�lh�fu�g_�ihcf_f�b ghjfZevghc�k_dkmZevghklb��H^gbf�keh\hf��i_j_^�gZfb�klhbl�g_ba[_`gZyaZ^ZqZ�^Zlv�l_hj_lbq_kdh_�h[tykg_gb_�\hafh`ghklb� >\hagbdgh\_gby@�gZa\Zgguo�ba\jZs_gbc�bbo�k\yab�k lZd�gZau\Z_fhc�ghjfZevghc�k_dkmZevghklvx�< wlhf�gZf�ihfh]ml�bf_xs__ky�\haaj_gb_�b ^\Z�gh\uo�nZdlZ��I_j\uf�fu�h[yaZgu�B\Zgm;ehom� �����²�������hg�baf_gbe�fg_gb_��qlh�\k_�wlb�ba\jZs_gby�²�©ijbagZdb�^_]_g_jZpbbª�mdZaZgb_f� gZ� lh�� qlh� lZdb_� hldehg_gby� hl� k_dkmZevghc� p_eb�� lZdh_� hkeZ[e_gb_� hlghr_gby� dk_dkmZevghfm�h[t_dlm�\klj_qZebkv�k ^Z\gbo�ihj��\h�\k_�ba\_klgu_�gZf�\j_f_gZ��m \k_o�gZjh^h\�dZd� kZfuo� ijbfblb\guo�� lZd� b kZfuo� \ukhdh�pb\bebah\Zgguo�� kqblZebkv� ^himklbfufb� bgZoh^beb�\k_h[s__�ijbagZgb_��H[Z�nZdlZ�[ueb�ihemq_gu�\ ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhf�bkke_^h\Zgbbg_\jhlbdh\�� hgb� ^he`gu� j_rbl_evguf� h[jZahf� baf_gblv� gZr_� ihgbfZgb_� k_dkmZevguoba\jZs_gbc�Fu� kdZaZeb�� qlh� g_\jhlbq_kdb_� kbfilhfu� y\eyxlky� aZf_s_gb_f� k_dkmZevgh]hm^h\e_l\hj_gby��b y�mdZaZe�\Zf��qlh�ih^l\_j`^_gb_�wlh]h�iheh`_gby�iml_f�ZgZebaZ�kbfilhfh\gZlhedg_lky�gZ�g_dhlhju_�ljm^ghklb��Hgh�hijZ\^u\Z_lky�lhevdh�\ lhf�kemqZ_��_keb�\ ihgylb_©k_dkmZevgh_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_ª� fu� \dexqbf� lZd� gZau\Z_fu_� ba\jZs_ggu_� k_dkmZevgu_ihlj_[ghklb�� ihlhfm� qlh� lZdh_� lhedh\Zgb_� kbfilhfh\� gZijZrb\Z_lky� ihjZabl_evgh� qZklh�IjblyaZgby� ]hfhk_dkmZebklh\�� beb� bg\_jlbjh\Zgguo�� gZ� bkdexqbl_evghklv� kjZam�`_� l_jyxlk\hc� kfuke�� dh]^Z�fu� magZ_f��qlh� m^Z_lky�^hdZaZlv�gZebqb_� ]hfhk_dkmZevguo�ih[m`^_gbc� mdZ`^h]h�g_\jhlbdZ�b qlh�agZqbl_evgh_�qbkeh�kbfilhfh\�\ujZ`Z_l�wlh�kdjulh_�ba\jZs_gb_��L_�dlh� kZfb� k_[y� gZau\Zxl� ]hfhk_dkmZebklZfb�� ij_^klZ\eyxl� kh[hc� khagZl_evgh� b hldjulhbg\_jlbjh\Zgguo�� aZl_jygguo� kj_^b� [hevrh]h� qbkeZ� kdjuluo� ]hfhk_dkmZebklh\�� Gh� fu\ugm`^_gu�jZkkfZljb\Zlv�\u[hj�h[t_dlZ�ba�k\h_]h�iheZ�bf_ggh�dZd�aZdhghf_jgh_�hl\_l\e_gb_ex[h\ghc� `bagb� b ijbmq_gu� kqblZlv� _]h� gZb[he__� agZqbfuf�� JZamf__lky�� l_f� kZfuf� g_mgbqlh`Zxlky� jZaebqby�f_`^m� hldjulhc� ]hfhk_dkmZevghklvx�b ghjfZevguf�ih\_^_gb_f�� __ijZdlbq_kdh_�agZq_gb_�hklZ_lky��gh�l_hj_lbq_kdZy�__ p_gghklv�qj_a\uqZcgh�mf_gvrZ_lky��Fu^Z`_� ij_^iheZ]Z_f�� qlh� h^gh� aZ[he_\Zgb_�� dhlhjh_� fu� g_� kqblZ_f� [he__� \hafh`gufijbqbkeylv� d g_\jhaZf� i_j_g_k_gby�� iZjZghcy�� aZdhghf_jgh� gZklmiZ_l� \ke_^kl\b_� ihiuldbkhijhlb\e_gby� kebrdhf� kbevguf� ]hfhk_dkmZevguf� ih[m`^_gbyf�� Fh`_l� [ulv�� \u� _s_ihfgbl_��qlh�h^gZ�ba�gZrbo�iZpb_glhd� \ k\h_f�gZ\yaqb\hf�^_ckl\bb�b]jZeZ� jhev�fm`qbgu�

Page 170: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

k\h_]h�kh[kl\_ggh]h��hklZ\e_ggh]h�_x�fm`Z�lZdh_�ijhy\e_gb_�kbfilhfh\�hl�ebpZ�fm`qbgu�\_kvfZ�h[uqgh�m g_\jhlbq_kdbo�`_gsbg�?keb�_]h�b g_evay�ijbqbkeblv�d kZfhc�]hfhk_dkmZevghklb��lh�hgh�\k_�lZdb�bf__l�l_kgmx�k\yav�k__ ij_^ihkuedZfb�DZd�\Zf��\_jhylgh��ba\_klgh��kbfilhfu�bkl_jbq_kdh]h�g_\jhaZ�fh]ml�\hagbdgmlv�\h�\k_okbkl_fZo� hj]Zgh\� b l_f� kZfuf� gZjmrblv� \k_� nmgdpbb�� :gZeba� ihdZau\Z_l�� qlh� ijb� wlhfijhy\eyxlky� \k_� gZa\Zggu_� ba\jZs_ggu_� ih[m`^_gby�� klj_fysb_ky� aZf_gblv� ]_gblZebb^jm]bfb� hj]ZgZfb�� Wlb� hj]Zgu� \_^ml� k_[y� ijb� wlhf� dZd� aZf_klbl_eb� ]_gblZebc�� Bf_ggh[eZ]h^Zjy� kbfilhfZlbd_� bkl_jbb� m gZk� \hagbdeh� fg_gb_�� qlh� hj]Zgu� l_eZ�� djhf_� bonmgdpbhgZevghc�jheb��bf_xl�lZd`_�k_dkmZevgh_�²�wjh]_ggh_�²�agZq_gb_�b bkiheg_gb_�wlhcnmgdpbhgZevghc�aZ^Zqb�gZjmrZ_lky��_keb�k_dkmZevgZy�kebrdhf�h\eZ^_\Z_l�bfb��;_kqbke_ggu_hsms_gby�b bgg_j\Zpbb��\uklmiZxsb_�dZd�kbfilhfu�bkl_jbb��\ hj]ZgZo��dhlhju_��dZ`_lky��g_bf_xl�k k_dkmZevghklvx�gbq_]h�h[s_]h��jZkdju\Zxl�i_j_^�gZfb��lZdbf�h[jZahf��k\hx�ijbjh^m\ nhjf_�bkiheg_gby�ba\jZs_gguo�k_dkmZevguo�ih[m`^_gbc��ijb�dhlhjuo�gZagZq_gb_�iheh\uobf_xl�l_i_jv�^jm]b_��hj]Zgu��>Ze__��fu�\b^bf�lZd`_��\ dZdhc�[hevrhc�f_jv�bf_ggh�hj]ZguiblZgby�b \u^_e_gby�fh]ml�klZlv�ghkbl_eyfb�k_dkmZevghx�\ha[m`^_gby��Wlh��ke_^h\Zl_evgh�lh� `_� kZfh_�� qlh� gZf� ihdZaZeb� ba\jZs_gby�� lhevdh� \ gbo� wlh� [ueh� \b^gh� [_a� ljm^Z� b g_ih^e_`Zeh� khfg_gbx�� Z ijb� bkl_jbb� fu� ^he`gu� [ueb� ijh^_eZlv� h[oh^ghc� imlv� q_j_alhedh\Zgb_� kbfilhfh\�b ijbibkZlv� khhl\_lkl\mxsb_�ba\jZs_ggu_� k_dkmZevgu_�ih[m`^_gbyg_�khagZgbx�bg^b\b^h\��Z bo�[_kkhagZl_evghfm�KZfu_�\Z`gu_�ba�fgh]hqbke_gguo� khq_lZgbc� kbfilhfh\��\ dhlhjuo�ijhy\ey_lky�g_\jhagZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc��hdZau\Z_lky��\hagbdZxl�ih^�^Z\e_gb_f�hq_gv�kbevguo�kZ^bklkdbo��l��_�ba\jZs_gguo�ih�k\h_c�p_eb��k_dkmZevguo�ih[m`^_gbc��b \�khhl\_lkl\bb�kh�kljmdlmjhc�g_\jhaZgZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc� kbfilhfu� kem`Zl�ij_bfms_kl\_ggh�ijhlb\h^_ckl\bx� wlbf�`_eZgbyfbeb� \ujZ`Zxl� [hjv[m� f_`^m� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f� b ijhlb\h^_ckl\b_f� _fm�� Gh� b kZfhm^h\e_l\hj_gb_�g_�hdZau\Z_lky�ijb�wlhf�ms_fe_gguf��hgh�mf__l�^h[blvky�k\h_]h�\ ih\_^_gbb[hevguo�h[oh^gufb�imlyfb�b gZijZ\ey_lky�]eZ\guf�h[jZahf�ijhlb\�bo�kh[kl\_gghc�ebqghklb�ij_\jZsZy� bo� \ kZfhbklyaZl_e_c�� >jm]b_� nhjfu� g_\jhah\�� khijh\h`^Zxsb_ky� ^he]bfbjZa^mfvyfb�[hevguo��khhl\_lkl\mxl�qj_af_jghc�k_dkmZebaZpbb�Zdlh\��dhlhju_�h[uqgh�kem`Zlih^]hlh\dhc�d ghjfZevghfm�iheh\hfm�m^h\e_l\hj_gbx��l��_��`_eZgbx�jZkkfZljb\Zlv��ljh]Zlv�bbkke_^h\Zlv��Hkh[Zy� agZqbfhklv� [hyagb� ijbdhkgh\_gby� b gZ\yaqb\h]h� fulvy� jmd� gZoh^bl� \wlhf� k\h_� h[tykg_gb_�� M^b\bl_evgh� [hevrZy� qZklv� gZ\yaqb\uo� ^_ckl\bc� \ \b^_� kdjulh]hih\lhj_gby� b fh^bnbdZpbb� \hkoh^bl� d fZklmj[Zpbb�� dhlhjZy�� dZd� ba\_klgh�� wlbf_^bgkl\_gguf�� koh^guf� ih� nhjf_� ^_ckl\b_f� khijh\h`^Z_l� kZfu_� jZaghh[jZagu_� nhjfuk_dkmZevgh]h�nZglZabjh\Zgby�Fg_� g_� klhbeh� [u� [hevrh]h� ljm^Z� ihdZaZlv� \Zf� _s_� [he__� l_kgu_� hlghr_gby� f_`^mba\jZs_gb_f�b g_\jhahf��gh�y ^mfZx��qlh�kdZaZggh]h�[m^_l�^ey�gZr_c�p_eb�^hklZlhqgh��H^gZdhihke_�wlbo�h[tykg_gbc�agZq_gby�kbfilhfh\�gZf�gZ^h�hiZkZlvky�ij_m\_ebq_gby�qZklhlu�b kbeuba\jZs_gguo�kdehgghkl_c�ex^_c��<u�keurZeb��qlh�ba�aZ�hldZaZ�hl�ghjfZevgh]h�k_dkmZevgh]hm^h\e_l\hj_gby�fh`gh�aZ[he_lv�g_\jhahf��Gh�ijb�wlhf�j_Zevghf�hldZa_�ihlj_[ghklv�klj_fblkyd g_ghjfZevguf�imlyf�k_dkmZevgh]h�\ha[m`^_gby��Iha^g__�\u�m\b^bl_��dZd�wlh�ijhbkoh^bl��<h

Page 171: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\kydhf� kemqZ_�� \u� ihgbfZ_l_�� qlh� \ke_^kl\b_� lZdh]h� ©dheeZl_jZevgh]hª� aZklhy� ba\jZs_ggu_ih[m`^_gby� ^he`gu� [ulv� kbevg__�� q_f� hgb� [ueb� [u�� _keb� [u� ghjfZevgh_� k_dkmZevgh_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�g_�\klj_lbeh�[u�j_Zevguo�ij_iylkl\bc��<ijhq_f��ih^h[gh_�\ebygb_�ke_^m_lijbagZlv� b \� hldjuluo� ba\jZs_gbyo�� < g_dhlhjuo� kemqZyo� hgb� ijh\hpbjmxlky� bebZdlb\bjmxlky� l_f�� qlh� ^ey� ghjfZevgh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby� k_dkmZevgh]h� \e_q_gby� \hagbdZxlkebrdhf�[hevrb_�ij_iylkl\by�\ kbem�\j_f_gguo�h[klhyl_evkl\�beb�ihklhygguo�khpbZevguoghjf��< ^jm]bo�kemqZyo�ba\jZs_ggu_�gZdehgghklb�dZd�[m^lh�kh\_jr_ggh�g_�aZ\bkyl�hl�lZdbo[eZ]hijbylkl\mxsbo� bf� fhf_glh\�� hgb� y\eyxlky� ^ey� ^Zggh]h� bg^b\b^Z�� lZd� kdZaZlv�ghjfZevghc�nhjfhc�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�Fh`_l�[ulv��\ gZklhysmx�fbgmlm�m \Zk�kha^Z_lky�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�fu�kdhj__� aZimlZeb�q_f�\uykgbeb�hlghr_gb_�f_`^m�ghjfZevghc�b ba\jZs_gghc�k_dkmZevghklvx��Gh�ijbfbl_�\h\gbfZgb_� ke_^mxs__� khh[jZ`_gb_�� _keb� \_jgh� lh�� qlh� j_Zevgh_� aZljm^g_gb_� beb� ebr_gb_ghjfZevgh]h� k_dkmZevgh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby� fh`_l� \ua\Zlv� m g_dhlhjuo� ebp� ba\jZs_ggu_gZdehgghklb��dhlhju_�\ ^jm]bo�mkeh\byo�g_�ihy\bebkv�[u��lh�m wlbo�ebp�ke_^m_l�ij_^iheh`blvg_qlh�lZdh_��qlh�b^_l�gZ\klj_qm�ba\jZs_gbyf��beb��_keb�ohlbl_��hgb�bf_xlky�m gbo�\ eZl_glghcnhjf_�� Gh� l_f� kZfuf� fu� ijboh^bf� dh� \lhjhfm� gh\hfm� nZdlm�� h dhlhjhf� y \Zf� aZy\be�IkbohZgZeblbq_kdh_� bkke_^h\Zgb_� [ueh� \ugm`^_gh� aZgylvky� lZd`_� k_dkmZevghc� `bagvxj_[_gdZ�� Z bf_ggh� ihlhfm�� qlh� \hkihfbgZgby� b fukeb�� ijboh^ysb_� \ ]heh\m� ijb� ZgZeba_kbfilhfh\� �\ajhkeuo��� ihklhyggh� \_^ml� dh� \j_f_gb� jZgg_]h� ^_lkl\Z�� Lh�� qlh� fu� ijb� wlhfhldjueb�� Aih^l\_j^behkv� aZl_f�rZ]� aZ�rZ]hf� [eZ]h^Zjy� g_ihkj_^kl\_gguf� gZ[ex^_gbyf� aZ^_lvfb�� B lh]^Z� hdZaZehkv�� qlh� \ ^_lkl\_� fh`gh� gZclb� dhjgb� \k_o� ba\jZs_gbc�� qlh� ^_lbij_^jZkiheh`_gu�d gbf�b hl^Zxlky�bf�\ khhl\_lkl\bb�kh�k\hbf�g_aj_euf�\hajZklhf��dhjhq_]h\hjy��qlh�ba\jZs_ggZy�k_dkmZevghklv�_klv�g_�qlh�bgh_��dZd�\hajhkrZy��jZks_ie_ggZy�gZ�k\hbhl^_evgu_�ih[m`^_gby�bgnZglbevgZy�k_dkmZevghklv�L_i_jv�\u��\h�\kydhf�kemqZ_��m\b^bl_�ba\jZs_gby�\ ^jm]hf�k\_l_�b g_�kfh`_l_�g_�ijbagZlvbo� k\yab� k k_dkmZevghc�`bagvx� q_eh\_dZ��gh�p_ghx� dZdbo� g_ijbylguo� ^ey� \Zk� kxjijbah\� bfmqbl_evguo�^ey��\Zr_]h�qm\kl\Z�jZkkh]eZkh\Zgbc��JZamf__lky��\u�[m^_l_�kdehggu�kgZqZeZ�\k_hkiZjb\Zlv�� b lhl�nZdl�� qlh� m ^_l_c� _klv� qlh�lh�� qlh�fh`gh� gZa\Zlv� k_dkmZevghc�`bagvx�� b\_jghklv�gZrbo�gZ[ex^_gbc��b hkgh\Zgby�^ey�hlukdZgby�\ ih\_^_gbb�^_l_c�jh^kl\_ggh]h�lhfm�qlh� \ihke_^kl\bb� hkm`^Z_lky� dZd� ba\jZs_gb_�� Ihwlhfm� jZaj_rbl_� fg_� kgZqZeZ� h[tykgblvfhlb\u�\Zr_]h�khijhlb\e_gby��Z aZl_f�ih^\_klb�blh]�gZrbf�gZ[ex^_gbyf��Lh��qlh�m ^_l_c�g_lgbdZdhc�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�²�k_dkmZevgh]h�\ha[m`^_gby��k_dkmZevguo�ihlj_[ghkl_c�b k\h_]hjh^Z�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�²�ih�\k_�wlh�\^jm]�\hagbdZ_l�m gbo�f_`^m� ���b ���]h^Zfb��[ueh�[u�²g_aZ\bkbfh� hl� \k_o� gZ[ex^_gbc� ²� k [bheh]bq_kdhc� lhqdb� aj_gby� lZd�`_� g_\_jhylgh�� ^Z`_g_e_ih��dZd�_keb�[u�hgb�ihy\eyebkv�bZ�k\_l�[_a�]_gblZebc��b hgb�\ujZklZeb�[u�m gbo�lhevdh�dh\j_f_gb�iheh\hc� aj_ehklb��Lh��qlh�ijh[m`^Z_lky�m gbo�d wlhfm�\j_f_gb��y\ey_lky�nmgdpb_cijh^he`_gby� jh^Z�� dhlhjZy� ihevam_lky� ^ey� k\hbo� p_e_c� m`_� bf_xsbfky� nbabq_kdbf� b^mr_\guf�fZl_jbZehf��<u�kh\_jrZ_l_�hrb[dm��kf_rb\Zy�k_dkmZevghklv�k ijh^he`_gb_f�jh^Z�b aZdju\Z_l_� k_[_� wlbf� imlv� d ihgbfZgbx� k_dkmZevghklb�� ba\jZs_gbc� b g_\jhah\�� Gh� wlZhrb[dZ�l_g^_gpbhagZ��?_�bklhqgbdhf��dZd�gb�kljZggh��y\ey_lky�lh��qlh�\u�kZfb�[ueb�^_lvfb�bbkiulZeb� gZ� k_[_� \ebygb_� \hkiblZgby�� D qbkem� k\hbo� kZfuo� \Z`guo� aZ^Zq� \hkiblZgbyh[s_kl\h�^he`gh�hlg_klb�mdjhs_gb_��h]jZgbq_gb_��ih^qbg_gb_�k_dkmZevgh]h�\e_q_gby��dh]^Z

Page 172: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hgh� \g_aZigh� ihy\ey_lky� \ \b^_� klj_fe_gby� d ijh^he`_gbx� jh^Z�� bg^b\b^mZevghc� \he_�b^_glbqghc� khpbZevghfm� lj_[h\Zgbx�� H[s_kl\h� aZbgl_j_kh\Zgh� lZd`_� \ lhf�� qlh[uhlh^\bgmlv�_]h�ihegh_�jZa\blb_�^h�l_o�ihj��ihdZ�j_[_ghd�g_�^hklb]g_l�hij_^_e_gghc�klmi_gbbgl_ee_dlmZevghc� aj_ehklb�� ihlhfm� qlh� k iheguf� ijhju\hf� k_dkmZevgh]h� \e_q_gbyijZdlbq_kdb�ijboh^bl�dhg_p�\ebygbx�\hkiblZgby��< ijhlb\ghf�kemqZ_�\e_q_gb_�ijhj\Zeh�[u\k_� ij_]jZ^u� b kf_eh� [u� \ha\_^_ggh_� k lZdbf� ljm^hf� a^Zgb_� dmevlmju�� : _]h� mdjhs_gb_gbdh]^Z� g_� [m^_l� e_]dbf�� hgh� m^Z_lky� lh� kebrdhf� iehoh�� lh� kebrdhf� ohjhrh�� Fhlb\q_eh\_q_kdh]h� h[s_kl\Z� hdZau\Z_lky� \ dhg_qghf� kq_l_� wdhghfbq_kdbf�� lZd� dZd� m g_]h� g_l^hklZlhqgh�`bag_gguo� kj_^kl\�� qlh[u� kh^_j`Zlv� k\hbo� qe_gh\�[_a�bo� ljm^Z�� lh� hgh� ^he`ghh]jZgbqb\Zlv� qbkeh� k\hbo� qe_gh\�� Z bo� wg_j]bx� hl\e_dZlv� hl� k_dkmZevghc� ^_yl_evghklb� bgZijZ\eylv� gZ� ljm^�� <_qgZy�� bkdhggZy�� kms_kl\mxsZy� ^h� gZklhys_]h� \j_f_gb� `bag_ggZyg_h[oh^bfhklv�Hiul��^he`gh�[ulv��ihdZaZe�\hkiblZl_eyf��qlh�aZ^ZqZ�k^_eZlv�k_dkmZevgmx�\hex�gh\h]hihdhe_gby�ihkemrghc�jZaj_rbfZ� lhevdh�\ lhf�kemqZ_��_keb�gZ�g__�gZqbgZxl�\ha^_ckl\h\ZlvaZ[eZ]h\j_f_ggh��g_�^h`b^Zykv�[mjb�iheh\hc�aj_ehklb��Z \f_rb\Zykv�m`_�\ k_dkmZevgmx�`bagv^_l_c��dhlhjZy�__ ih^]hlZ\eb\Z_l��K wlhc�p_evx�j_[_gdm�aZij_sZxl�b hl[b\Zxl�m g_]h�hohlm�dh\k_f�bgnZglbevguf�k_dkmZevguf�ijhy\e_gbyf��klZ\blky�b^_ZevgZy�p_ev�k^_eZlv�`bagv�j_[_gdZZk_dkmZevghc�� kh� \j_f_g_f� ^hoh^yl� gZdhg_p� ^h� lh]h�� qlh� kqblZxl� __� ^_ckl\bl_evghZk_dkmZevghc��b gZmdZ�aZl_f�ijh\ha]eZrZ_l�wlh�k\h_c�l_hjb_c��Qlh[u�g_�\iZklv�\ ijhlb\hj_qb_kh�k\h_c�\_jhc�b k\hbfb�gZf_j_gbyfb��k_dkmZevgmx�^_yl_evghklv�j_[_gdZ�g_�aZf_qZxl�²�Z wlhg_fZeuc� ljm^� ²� beb� ^h\hevkl\mxlky� \ gZmd_� l_f�� qlh� jZkkfZljb\Zxl� __ bgZq_�� J_[_ghdkqblZ_lky� qbkluf�� g_\bgguf�� Z dlh� hibku\Z_l� _]h� ih�^jm]hfm�� lhl�� dZd� ]gmkguc� aeh^_c�h[\bgy_lky�\ hkdhj[e_gbb�g_`guo�b k\yluo�qm\kl\�q_eh\_q_kl\Z�>_lb²_^bgkl\_ggu_��dlh�g_�ijbagZ_l�wlbo�mkeh\ghkl_c�²kh�\k_c�gZb\ghklvx�ihevamxlkyk\hbfb� `b\hlgufb� ijZ\Zfb� b ihklhyggh� ^hdZau\Zxl�� qlh� bf� _s_� gm`gh� klZlv� qbklufb�<_kvfZ� ijbf_qZl_evgh�� qlh� hljbpZxsb_� ^_lkdmx� k_dkmZevghklv� g_� ^_eZxl� \ \hkiblZgbbgbdZdbo�mklmihd��Z kh�\k_c�kljh]hklvx�ij_ke_^mxl�bf_ggh�ijhy\e_gby�hljbpZ_fh]h�bfb�ih^gZa\Zgb_f� ©^_lkdb_� ^mjgu_�ijb\uqdbª��;hevrhc� l_hj_lbq_kdbc� bgl_j_k� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hclZd`_� lh�� qlh� i_jbh^� `bagb�� gZoh^ysbcky� \ kZfhf� j_adhf� ijhlb\hj_qbb� k ij_^jZkkm^dhfZk_dkmZevghklb�^_lkl\Z�� Z bf_ggh�^_lkdb_� ]h^u�^h�iylb�beb�r_klb� e_l�� hdmlu\Z_lky� aZl_f� m[hevrbgkl\Z� ex^_c� Zfg_klbq_kdbf� ihdju\Zehf�� jZahj\Zlv� dhlhjh_� ih�gZklhys_fm� fh`_llhevdh� ZgZeblbq_kdh_� bkke_^h\Zgb_�� gh� dhlhjh_� m`_� ^h� wlh]h� ijhgbpZ_fh� ^ey� hl^_evguokljmdlmj�kgh\b^_gbc�: l_i_jv�y ohqm�baeh`blv�\Zf�lh��qlh�ykg__�\k_]h�iha\hey_l�km^blv�h k_dkmZevghc�`bagbj_[_gdZ�� A^_kv� p_e_khh[jZagh� lZd`_� \\_klb� ihgylb_� eb[b^h� �/LELGR��� Eb[b^h�� kh\_jr_gghZgZeh]bqgh� ]heh^m�� gZau\Z_lky� kbeZ�� \ dhlhjhc� \ujZ`Z_lky� \e_q_gb_�� \ ^Zgghf� kemqZ_k_dkmZevgh_��dZd�\ ]heh^_�\ujZ`Z_lky�\e_q_gb_�d ibs_��>jm]b_�ihgylby��lZdb_��dZd�k_dkmZevgh_\ha[m`^_gb_�b m^h\e_l\hj_gb_��g_�gm`^Zxlky�\ h[tykg_gbb��<u�kZfb�e_]dh�ihcf_l_��qlh�ijbk_dkmZevguo� ijhy\e_gbyo� ]jm^gh]h� feZ^_gpZ� [hevr_� \k_]h� ijboh^blky� aZgbfZlvkylhedh\Zgb_f��b \u��\_jhylgh��[m^_l_�kqblZlv�wlh�\hajZ`_gb_f��Wlb� lhedh\Zgby�\hagbdZxl�gZhkgh\_� ZgZeblbq_kdbo� bkke_^h\Zgbc�� _keb� b^lb� h[jZlguf� iml_f�� hl� kbfilhfZ�� I_j\u_

Page 173: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

k_dkmZevgu_� ih[m`^_gby� m ]jm^gh]h� feZ^_gpZ� ijhy\eyxlky� \ k\yab� k ^jm]bfb� `bag_ggh\Z`gufb�nmgdpbyfb��?]h�]eZ\guc�bgl_j_k��dZd�\u�agZ_l_��gZijZ\e_g�gZ�ijb_f�ibsb��dh]^Z�hg�gZkulb\rbkv�� aZkuiZ_l� m ]jm^b�� m g_]h� ihy\ey_lky� \ujZ`_gb_� [eZ`_ggh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�dhlhjh_�iha^g__�ih\lhjblky�ihke_�i_j_`b\Zgby�iheh\h]h�hj]ZafZ��Gh�wlh]h��ih`Zemc��kebrdhffZeh�� qlh[u� kljhblv� gZ� g_f� aZdexq_gb_�� H^gZdh� fu� gZ[ex^Z_f�� qlh� feZ^_g_p� `_eZ_lih\lhjylv�Zdl�ijb_fZ�ibsb��g_�lj_[my�gh\hc�ibsb��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��ijb�wlhf�hg�g_�gZoh^blky�\h\eZklb� ]heh^Z�� Fu� ]h\hjbf�� hg� khk_l�� b lh�� qlh� ijb� wlhf� ^_ckl\bb� hg� hiylv� aZkuiZ_l� k[eZ`_gguf� \ujZ`_gb_f�� ihdZau\Z_l� gZf�� qlh� Zdl� khkZgby� kZf� ih� k_[_� ^hklZ\be� _fmm^h\e_l\hj_gb_��DZd�ba\_klgh��kdhjh�hg�m`_�g_�aZkuiZ_l��g_�ihkhkZ\��GZ�k_dkmZevghc�ijbjh^_wlh]h� ^_ckl\by� gZqZe� gZklZb\Zlv� klZjuc� \jZq� \ ;m^Zi_rl_� ^�j Ebg^g_j� �������� EbpZ�moZ`b\Zxsb_�aZ�j_[_gdhf��g_�ij_l_g^my�gZ�l_hj_lbq_kdb_�\u\h^u��ih�\b^bfhfm��ZgZeh]bqghhp_gb\Zxl�khkZgb_��Hgb�g_�khfg_\Zxlky�\ lhf��qlh�hgh�kem`bl�j_[_gdm�lhevdh�^ey�ihemq_gbym^h\hevkl\by�� hlghkyl� _]h� d ^mjguf�ijb\uqdZf� b ijbgm`^Zxl� j_[_gdZ� hldZaZlvky� hl� wlh]h�ijbf_gyy�g_ijbylgu_�\ha^_ckl\by��_keb�hg�kZf�g_�`_eZ_l�hklZ\blv�^mjgmx�ijb\uqdm��LZdbfh[jZahf�� fu� magZ_f�� qlh� ]jm^ghc� feZ^_g_p� \uihegy_l� ^_ckl\by�� g_� bf_xsb_� ^jm]hc� p_eb�djhf_�ihemq_gby�m^h\hevkl\by��Fu�iheZ]Z_f��qlh�kgZqZeZ�hg�i_j_`b\Z_l�wlh�m^h\hevkl\b_�ijbijb_f_�ibsb��gh�kdhjh�gZmqZ_lky�hl^_eylv�_]h�hl�wlh]h�mkeh\by��Fu�fh`_f�hlg_klb�ihemq_gb_wlh]h�m^h\hevkl\by�lhevdh�d \ha[m`^_gbx�ahgu�jlZ�b ]m[��gZau\Z_f�wlb�qZklb�l_eZ�wjh]_ggufbahgZfb�� Z ihemq_ggh_� ijb� khkZgbb� m^h\hevkl\b_� k_dkmZevguf�� H ijZ\hf_jghklb� lZdh]hgZa\Zgby�gZf��dhg_qgh��ijb^_lky�_s_�^bkdmlbjh\Zlv�?keb�[u�feZ^_g_p�fh]�h[tykgylvky��hg�g_khfg_ggh�ijbagZe�[u�Zdl�khkZgby�fZl_jbgkdhc]jm^b�kZfuf�\Z`guf�\ `bagb��Ih�hlghr_gbx�d k_[_�hg�g_�lZd�m`�g_�ijZ\��ihlhfm�qlh�wlbfZdlhf� kjZam� m^h\e_l\hjy_l� ^\_� \Z`gu_� ihlj_[ghklb��G_� [_a� m^b\e_gby� fu� magZ_f� aZl_f� baikbohZgZebaZ��dZdh_�[hevrh_�ikbobq_kdh_�agZq_gb_�khojZgy_l�wlhl�Zdl�gZ�\kx�`bagv��KhkZgb_fZl_jbgkdhc� ]jm^b� klZgh\blky� bkoh^guf� imgdlhf� \k_c� k_dkmZevghc� `bagb�� g_^hklb`bfufijhh[jZahf� ex[h]h� [he__� iha^g_]h� k_dkmZevgh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� d dhlhjhfm� \ ly`_eu_\j_f_gZ� qZklh� \ha\jZsZ_lky�nZglZaby��Hgh� \dexqZ_l�fZl_jbgkdmx� ]jm^v� dZd� i_j\uc� h[t_dlk_dkmZevgh]h�\e_q_gby��y g_�\ khklhygbb�^Zlv�\Zf�ij_^klZ\e_gb_�h lhf��gZkdhevdh�agZqbl_e_gwlhl� i_j\uc� h[t_dl� ^ey� \u[hjZ� \ [m^ms_f� ex[h]h� ^jm]h]h� h[t_dlZ�� dZdb_� \ha^_ckl\byhdZau\Z_l�hg�kh�\k_fb�k\hbfb�ij_\jZs_gbyfb�b aZf_s_gbyfb�gZ�kZfu_�hl^Ze_ggu_�h[eZklbgZr_c�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��Gh�kgZqZeZ�feZ^_g_p�hldZau\Z_lky�hl�g_]h�\ Zdl_�khkZgby�b aZf_gy_lqZklvx�kh[kl\_ggh]h�l_eZ��J_[_ghd�khk_l�[hevrhc�iZe_p��kh[kl\_gguc�yaud��;eZ]h^Zjy�wlhfmhg�ihemqZ_l�g_aZ\bkbfhklv�\ ihemq_gbb�m^h\hevkl\by�hl�h^h[j_gby�\g_rg_]h�fbjZ� Z�� djhf_lh]h�� ^ey� _]h� mkbe_gby� bkihevam_l� \ha[m`^_gb_� ^jm]hc� ahgu� l_eZ�� Wjh]_ggu_� ahgu� g_h^bgZdh\h� wnn_dlb\gu�� ihwlhfm� dh]^Z� feZ^_g_p�� dZd� khh[sZ_l�Ebg^g_j�� ijb� h[ke_^h\Zgbbkh[kl\_ggh]h� l_eZ� hldju\Z_l� hkh[_ggh� \ha[m^bfu_� qZklb� k\hbo� ]_gblZebc� b i_j_oh^bl� hlkhkZgby�d hgZgbafm��wlh�klZgh\blky�\Z`guf�i_j_`b\Zgb_f�;eZ]h^Zjy� >\uykg_gbx@� agZqbfhklb� khkZgby� fu� ihagZdhfbebkv� k ^\mfy� hkgh\gufbhkh[_gghklyfb� ^_lkdhc� k_dkmZevghklb�� HgZ� \hagbdZ_l� \ k\yab� k m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f� \Z`guohj]Zgbq_kdbo�ihlj_[ghkl_c�b ijhy\ey_lky�Zmlhwjhlbq_kdb��l��_��bs_l�b gZoh^bl�k\hb�h[t_dlugZ�kh[kl\_gghf�l_e_��Lh��qlh�ykg__�\k_]h�h[gZjm`behkv�ijb�ijb_f_�ibsb��hlqZklb�ih\lhjy_lkyijb� \u^_e_gbyo�� Fu� aZdexqZ_f�� qlh� feZ^_g_p� bkiulu\Z_l� hsms_gb_� m^h\hevkl\by� ijb

Page 174: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fhq_bkimkdZgbb�b bkijZ`g_gbb�b kdhjh�gZqbgZ_l�klZjZlvky�kh\_jrZlv�wlb�Zdlu�lZd��qlh[u�hgb^hklZ\eyeb�_fm�\hafh`gh�[hevr__�m^h\hevkl\b_�hl�\ha[m`^_gby�khhl\_lkl\mxsbo�wjh]_gguoahg� kebabklhc� h[hehqdb�� < wlhf� hlghr_gbb�� dZd� lhgdh� aZf_lbeZ� Em� :g^j_Z�KZehf_� �������\g_rgbc�fbj�\uklmiZ_l�ijhlb\�g_]h�ij_`^_�\k_]h�dZd�f_rZxsZy��\jZ`^_[gZy�_]h�klj_fe_gbxd m^h\hevkl\bx� kbeZ� b aZklZ\ey_l� _]h� ij_^qm\kl\h\Zlv� [m^msmx� \g_rgxx� b \gmlj_ggxx[hjv[m�� Hl� k\hbo� wdkdj_lh\� hg� \ugm`^_g� hk\h[h`^Zlvky� g_� \ ex[hc� fhf_gl�� Z dh]^Z� wlhhij_^_eyxl�^jm]b_�ebpZ��Qlh[u�aZklZ\blv�_]h�hldZaZlvky�hl�wlbo�bklhqgbdh\�m^h\hevkl\by��\k_�qlh�dZkZ_lky�wlbo�nmgdpbc��h[ty\ey_lky�g_ijbebqguf�b ^he`gh�kdju\Zlvky�hl�^jm]bo��A^_kv�hg\ugm`^_g�ij_`^_�\k_]h�h[f_gylv�m^h\hevkl\b_�gZ�khpbZevgh_�^hklhbgkl\h��?]h�hlghr_gb_�dkZfbf� wdkdj_lZf� kgZqZeZ� kh\_jr_ggh� bgh_�� Hg� g_� bkiulu\Z_l� hl\jZs_gby� d k\h_fm� dZem�hp_gb\Z_l� _]h� dZd� qZklv� k\h_]h� l_eZ�� k dhlhjhc� _fm� g_e_]dh� jZkklZlvky�� b bkihevam_l� _]h� \dZq_kl\_�i_j\h]h�©ih^ZjdZª��qlh[u�gZ]jZ^blv�ebp��dhlhjuo�hg�hkh[_ggh�p_gbl��B ^Z`_�ihke_lh]h��dZd�\hkiblZl_eyf�m^Zehkv�hlmqblv�_]h�hl�wlbo�gZdehgghkl_c��hg�i_j_ghkbl�hp_gdm�dZeZ�gZ©ih^Zjhdª� b gZ� ©^_gv]bª�� K\hb� mki_ob� \ fhq_bkimkdZgbb�� hg�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� gZijhlb\�jZkkfZljb\Z_l�k hkh[hc�]hj^hklvx���Y agZx��qlh�\Zf�^Z\gh�ohq_lky�f_gy�ij_j\Zlv�b djbdgmlv��^h\hevgh�]Z^hkl_c��>_n_dZpby²� bklhqgbd� k_dkmZevgh]h� m^h\hevkl\by�� dhlhjh_� bkiulu\Z_l� m`_� feZ^_g_p�� DZe� ²� p_ggZykm[klZgpby�� aZ^gbc� ijhoh^� ²� k\h_]h� jh^Z� ]_gblZebb��Fu� g_� \_jbf� wlhfm�� gh� l_i_jv� fuihgbfZ_f�� ihq_fm� i_^bZlju� b i_^Z]h]b� hl\_j]eb� ikbohZgZeba� b _]h� j_amevlZlu�� G_l�m\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� <u� lhevdh� aZ[ueb�� qlh� y ohl_e� \Zf� baeh`blv� nZdlu� bgnZglbevghck_dkmZevghc�`bagb�\ k\yab�k k_dkmZevgufb�ba\jZs_gbyfb��Ihq_fm�[u�\Zf�g_�agZlv��qlh�aZ^gbcijhoh^� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� [_j_l� gZ� k_[y� jhev� \eZ]ZebsZ� ijb� iheh\hf� Zdl_� m [hevrh]h� qbkeZ\ajhkeuo�� ]hfhk_dkmZevguo� b ]_l_jhk_dkmZevguo"�B qlh� _klv� fgh]h� ex^_c�� bkiulu\ZxsbokeZ^hkljZklgh_�hsms_gb_�ijb�^_n_dZpbb�\kx�k\hx�`bagv�b hibku\Zxsbo�_]h�dZd�^h\hevghkbevgh_"�Qlh� dZkZ_lky�bgl_j_kZ� d Zdlm�^_n_dZpbb�b m^h\hevkl\by� hl�gZ[ex^_gby� ^_n_dZpbb^jm]h]h�� lh� \Zf� ih^l\_j^yl� wlh� kZfb� ^_lb�� dh]^Z� klZgml� gZ� g_kdhevdh� e_l� klZjr_� b kfh]mlkhh[sblv�h[� wlhf��JZamf__lky��\u�g_�^he`gu�i_j_^� wlbf�ihklhyggh� aZim]b\Zlv�^_l_c��bgZq_hgb�hlebqgh�ihcfml��qlh�^he`gu�fheqZlv�h[�wlhf��Qlh�dZkZ_lky�^jm]bo�\_s_c��dhlhjuf�\u�g_ohlbl_� \_jblv�� y hlkueZx� \Zk� d j_amevlZlZf� ZgZebaZ� b g_ihkj_^kl\_gghfm� gZ[ex^_gbx� aZ^_lvfb�b ^he`_g�kdZaZlv��qlh�wlh�ijyfh�lZdb�bkdmkkl\h�g_�\b^_lv�\k_]h�wlh]h�beb�\b^_lv�dZd�lhbgZq_��Y lZd`_�g_�bf_x�gbq_]h�ijhlb\�lh]h��qlh[u�\Zf�j_adh�[jhkbehkv�\ ]eZaZ�jh^kl\h�^_lkdhck_dkmZevghklb�k k_dkmZevgufb�ba\jZs_gbyfb��Wlh��kh[kl\_ggh��kZfh�kh[hc�jZamf__lky��_keb�mj_[_gdZ�\hh[s_�_klv�k_dkmZevgZy�`bagv��lh�hgZ�^he`gZ�[ulv�ba\jZs_ggh]h�oZjZdl_jZ��ihlhfmqlh�� djhf_� �g_dhlhjuo� l_fguo� gZf_dh\�� m j_[_gdZ� g_l� gbq_]h�� qlh� ^_eZ_l� k_dkmZevghklvnmgdpb_c�ijh^he`_gby�jh^Z��K ^jm]hc�klhjhgu��h[sZy�hkh[_gghklv�\k_o�ba\jZs_gbc�khklhbl�\lhf��qlh�hgb�g_�ij_ke_^mxl�p_ev�ijh^he`_gby�jh^Z��Fu�gZau\Z_f�k_dkmZevgmx�^_yl_evghklvba\jZs_gghc� bf_ggh� \ lhf� kemqZ_�� _keb� hgZ� hldZau\Z_lky� hl� p_eb� ijh^he`_gby� jh^Z� bklj_fblky� d ihemq_gbx� m^h\hevkl\by� dZd� d g_aZ\bkbfhc� hl� g_]h� p_eb�� <u� ihcf_l_�� lZdbfh[jZahf��qlh�i_j_ehf�b ih\hjhlguc�imgdl�\ jZa\blbb�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�khklhbl�\ ih^qbg_gbb__ p_eyf�ijh^he`_gby�jh^Z��<k_��qlh�ijhbkoh^bl�^h�wlh]h�ih\hjhlZ��lZd�`_�dZd�b \k_��qlh�_]hba[_`Zeh��qlh� kem`bl� lhevdh�ihemq_gbx�m^h\hevkl\by��ijbh[j_lZ_l�fZehihql_ggh_�gZa\Zgb_©ba\jZs_ggh]hª�b ij_abjZ_lky�dZd�lZdh\h_�

Page 175: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Iha\hevl_� fg_� ihwlhfm� ijh^he`blv� djZldh_� baeh`_gb_� >nZdlh\@� bgnZglbevghck_dkmZevghklb�� Lh�� qlh� y khh[sbe� h ^\mo� hj]Zgbq_kdbo� kbkl_fZo� �ibs_\Zjbl_evghc� b\u^_ebl_evghc��� y fh]� [u� ^hihegblv� k mq_lhf� ^jm]bo� kbkl_f�� K_dkmZevgZy� `bagv� j_[_gdZbkq_jiu\Z_lky�bf_ggh�ijhy\e_gb_f�jy^Z�qZklguo�\e_q_gbc��3DUWLDOWULHEH���dhlhju_�g_aZ\bkbfh^jm]�hl�^jm]Z�iulZxlky�ihemqblv�m^h\hevkl\b_�qZklbqgh�hl�kh[kl\_ggh]h�l_eZ��qZklbqgh�m`_�hl\g_rg_]h� h[t_dlZ�� Hq_gv� kdhjh� kj_^b� wlbo� hj]Zgh\� \u^_eyxlky� ]_gblZebb�� _klv� ex^b�� mdhlhjuo� ihemq_gb_� m^h\hevkl\by� hl� kh[kl\_gguo� ]_gblZebc� [_a� ihfhsb� ]_gblZebc� ^jm]h]hq_eh\_dZ�beb�h[t_dlZ�ijh^he`Z_lky�[_a�i_j_ju\Z�hl�feZ^_gq_kdh]h�hgZgbafZ�^h�\ugm`^_ggh]hhgZgbafZ�\ ]h^u�iheh\hc�aj_ehklb�b kms_kl\m_l�aZl_f�g_hij_^_e_ggh�^he]h�b \�^Zevg_cr_f�<ijhq_f�� k l_fhc� hgZgbafZ� fu� g_� lZd�lh� kdhjh� ihdhgqbf�� wlh� fZl_jbZe�� lj_[mxsbcfgh]hklhjhgg_]h� jZkkfhlj_gby�� <k_�lZdb� ^he`_g� \Zf� kdZaZlv� dh_�qlh� h k_dkmZevghfbkke_^h\Zgbb� �6H[XDOIRUVFKXQJ�� ^_l_c�� Hgh� kebrdhf� lbibqgh� ^ey� ^_lkdhc� k_dkmZevghklb� bdjZcg_� agZqbfh� ^ey� kbfilhfZlbdb� g_\jhah\�� >_lkdh_� k_dkmZevgh_� bkke_^h\Zgb_� gZqbgZ_lkyhq_gv�jZgh��bgh]^Z�_s_�^h�lj_oe_lg_]h�\hajZklZ��Hgh�k\yaZgh�g_�k jZaebqb_f�iheh\��gbq_]h�g_]h\hjysbf�j_[_gdm��lZd�dZd�hg�²�ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��fZevqbd�²�ijbibku\Z_l�h[hbf�iheZf�l_�`_fm`kdb_� ]_gblZebb�� ?keb� fZevqbd� aZl_f� h[gZjm`b\Z_l� \eZ]Zebs_� m fZe_gvdhc� k_klju� bebih^jm]b�ih�b]jZf�� lh�kgZqZeZ�hg�iulZ_lky�hljbpZlv� wlh�k\b^_l_evkl\h�k\hbo�hj]Zgh\�qm\kl\�ihlhfm�qlh�g_�fh`_l�ij_^klZ\blv�ih^h[gh_�k_[_�q_eh\_q_kdh_�kms_kl\h�[_a�klhev�p_gghc�^eyg_]h� qZklb�� Iha^g__� hg� im]Z_lky� wlh]h� hldjulby�� b lh]^Z� ij_`gb_� m]jhau� aZ� kebrdhfbgl_gkb\gh_�aZgylb_�k\hbf�fZe_gvdbf�qe_ghf�hdZau\Zxl�k\h_�^_ckl\b_��Hg�ihiZ^Z_l�\h�\eZklvdZkljZpbhggh]h�dhfie_dkZ��h[jZah\Zgb_�dhlhjh]h�bf__l�[hevrh_�agZq_gby�^ey�nhjfbjh\Zgby_]h� oZjZdl_jZ�� _keb� hg� hklZ_lky� a^hjh\uf�� ^ey� _]h� g_\jhaZ�� _keb� hg� aZ[he_\Z_l�� b ^ey� _]hkhijhlb\e_gbc��_keb�hg�ih^\_j]Z_lky�ZgZeblbq_kdhfm�e_q_gbx��H fZe_gvdhc�^_\hqd_�fu�agZ_f�qlh� hgZ� kqblZ_l� k_[y� ]em[hdh� ms_fe_gghc� ba�aZ� hlkmlkl\by� [hevrh]h� \b^bfh]h� i_gbkZ�aZ\b^m_l� \ wlhf� fZevqbdm� b \� hkgh\ghf� ih� wlhc� ijbqbg_� m g__� \hagbdZ_l� `_eZgb_� [ulvfm`qbghc��`_eZgb_��kgh\Z�ihy\eyxs__ky�iha^g__�ijb�g_\jha_��dhlhjuc�gZklmiZ_l�\ke_^kl\b___ g_m^Zqb�\ `_gkdhc�jheb��<ijhq_f��deblhj�^_\hqdb�\ ^_lkdhf�\hajZkl_�\iheg_�b]jZ_l�jhevi_gbkZ��hg�y\ey_lky�ghkbl_e_f�hkh[hc�\ha[m^bfhklb��f_klhf��\ dhlhjhf�^hklb]Z_lky�Zmlhwjhlb�q_kdh_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�� Ij_\jZs_gb_� fZe_gvdhc� ^_\hqdb� \ `_gsbgm� \h� fgh]hf� aZ\bkbl� hllh]h�� i_j_ghkblky� eb� wlZ� qm\kl\bl_evghklv� deblhjZ� k\h_\j_f_ggh� b iheghklvx� gZ� \oh^� \h\eZ]Zebs_�� < kemqZyo� lZd� gZau\Z_fhc� k_dkmZevghc� Zg_kl_abb� m `_gsbg� deblhj� mihjghkhojZgy_l�k\hx�qm\kl\bl_evghklv�K_dkmZevguc�bgl_j_k�j_[_gdZ�kdhj__�h[jZsZ_lky�kgZqZeZ�d ijh[e_f_��hldm^Z�[_jmlky�^_lb�d lhc� kZfhc�� dhlhjZy� e_`bl� \ hkgh\_� \hijhkZ�nb\Zgkdh]h� knbgdkZ��b ijh[m`^Z_lky�[hevr_cqZklvx�w]hbklbq_kdbfb�hiZk_gbyfb�ijb�ihy\e_gbb�gh\h]h�j_[_gdZ��Hl\_l��^Z\Z_fuc�\ ^_lkdhc�qlh�^_l_c�ijbghkbl�Zbkl��\uau\Z_l�g_^h\_jb_�^Z`_�m fZe_gvdbo�^_l_c� ]hjZa^h�qZs_��q_f�fu^mfZ_f��Hsms_gb_��qlh�\ajhkeu_�_]h�h[fZgu\Zxl��kdju\Zy�bklbgm��kihkh[kl\m_l�hlqm`^_gbxj_[_gdZ�b jZa\blbx� _]h� kZfhklhyl_evghklb��Gh� j_[_ghd�g_� \ khklhygbb� jZaj_rblv�ijh[e_fmkh[kl\_ggufb�kj_^kl\Zfb��?]h�_s_�g_jZa\blZy�k_dkmZevgZy�dhgklblmpby�klZ\bl�hij_^_e_ggu_]jZgbpu�^ey�_]h�ihagZ\Zl_evghc�kihkh[ghklb��KgZqZeZ�hg�ij_^iheZ]Z_l��qlh�^_lb�ijhbkoh^ylhl�lh]h��qlh�k ibs_c�kt_^Zxl�qlh�lh�hkh[h_��b gbq_]h�g_� agZ_l�h lhf��qlh�^_l_c�fh]ml�bf_lvlhevdh�`_gsbgu��Iha`_�hg�magZ_l�h[�wlhf�h]jZgbq_gbb�b hldZau\Z_lky�hl�fukeb��qlh�j_[_ghd

Page 176: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijhbkoh^bl�hl�_^u��wlZ�fukev�hklZ_lky�lhevdh�\ kdZad_��Ih^jZklZxsbc�j_[_ghd�kdhjh�aZf_qZ_l�qlh�hl_p�^he`_g�b]jZlv�dZdmx�lh�jhev�\ ihy\e_gbb�j_[_gdZ��gh�g_�fh`_l�m]Z^Zlv��dZdmx��?kebhg�kemqZcgh�klZgh\blky�k\b^_l_e_f�iheh\h]h� ZdlZ�� lh�\b^bl�\ g_f�ihiuldm�gZkbeby��[hjv[m�kZ^bklkdb�bklhedh\u\Z_l�dhblmk��Gh�kgZqZeZ�hg�g_�k\yau\Z_l�wlhl�Zdl�k ihy\e_gb_f�j_[_gdZ�Dh]^Z�hg�h[gZjm`b\Z_l�ke_^u�djh\b�\ ihkl_eb�b gZ�[_ev_�fZl_jb��hg� lh`_�ijbgbfZ_l� wlh� aZ^hdZaZl_evkl\h�gZg_k_ggh]h�hlphf�jZg_gby��< [he__�iha^gb_�]h^u�hg��\b^bfh��ij_^qm\kl\m_l�qlh�iheh\hc�hj]Zg�fm`qbgu�ijbgbfZ_l�kms_kl\_ggh_�mqZklb_�\ ihy\e_gbb�^_l_c��gh�g_�fh`_lijbibkZlv�wlhc�qZklb�l_eZ�gbdZdhc�^jm]hc�nmgdpbb��djhf_�fhq_bkimkdZl_evghc�K kZfh]h�gZqZeZ�^_lb�_^bgh^mrgu�\ lhf��qlh�jh`^_gb_�j_[_gdZ�^he`gh�hkms_kl\eylvkyq_j_a� dbr_qgbd�� qlh� j_[_ghd� ihy\ey_lky�� ke_^h\Zl_evgh�� dZd� dhf� dZeZ�� Lhevdh� ihke_h[_kp_gb\Zgby�\k_o�ZgZevguo�bgl_j_kh\�wlZ�l_hjby�hklZ\ey_lky�b aZf_gy_lky�ij_^iheh`_gb_f�qlh�hldju\Z_lky�imihd�beb�qlh�f_klhf�jh`^_gby�y\ey_lky�h[eZklv�f_`^m�`_gkdbfb�]jm^yfb�LZdbf�h[jZahf�iuleb\uc�j_[_ghd�ijb[eb`Z_lky�d agZgbx�k_dkmZevguo�nZdlh\�beb�ijhoh^blfbfh� gbo�� k[bluc� k lhedm� k\hbf� g_agZgb_f�� ihdZ� \ ij_im[_jlZlghf� \hajZkl_� g_� ihemqblh[uqgh� hkdhj[bl_evgh]h� b g_ihegh]h� h[tykg_gby�� g_j_^dh� hdZau\Zxs_]h� ljZ\fZlbq_kdh_^_ckl\b_�<u�� dhg_qgh�� keurZeb�� m\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� qlh� ihgylb_� k_dkmZevgh]h� \ ikbohZgZeba_ij_l_ji_eh�g_hijZ\^Zggh_�jZkrbj_gb_�k p_evx�khojZgblv�iheh`_gby�h k_dkmZevghc�ijbqbg_g_\jhah\�b k_dkmZevghf�agZq_gbb�kbfilhfh\��L_i_jv�\u�fh`_l_�kZfb�km^blv��y\ey_lky�eb�wlhjZkrbj_gb_� g_hijZ\^Zgguf��Fu� jZkrbjbeb� ihgylb_� k_dkmZevghklb� ebrv� gZklhevdh�� qlh[uhgh�fh]eh�\dexqblv�k_dkmZevgmx�`bagv�ba\jZs_gguo�b ^_l_c��Wlh�agZqbl��qlh�fu�\ha\jZlbeb_fm� _]h� ijZ\bevguc� h[t_f�� Lh�� qlh� gZau\Zxl� k_dkmZevghklvx� \g_� ikbohZgZebaZ�� hlghkblkylhevdh� d h]jZgbq_gghc� k_dkmZevghc� `bagb�� kem`Zs_c� ijh^he`_gbx� jh^Z� b gZau\Z_fhcghjfZevghc�><:>P:LV�I?J<:Y�E?DPBYJZa\blb_�eb[b^h�b k_dkmZevgZy�hj]ZgbaZpbyM\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� Y gZoh`mkv� ih^� \i_qZle_gb_f�� qlh� fg_� g_� \iheg_� m^Zehkvm[_^bl_evgh�jZatykgblv�\Zf�agZq_gb_�ba\jZs_gbc�^ey�gZr_]h�ij_^klZ\e_gby�h k_dkmZevghklb�Ihwlhfm�y ohl_e�[u��gZkdhevdh�fh]m��gZijZ\blv�b ^hihegblv�baeh`_ggh_�>_eh�h[klhbl�\h\k_�g_�lZd��dZd�[m^lh�lhevdh�ba\jZs_gby�\ugm^beb�gZk�d lhfm�baf_g_gbxihgylby� k_dkmZevghklb�� dhlhjh_� \ua\Zeh� klhev� j_adbc� ijhl_kl�� ?s_� [hevr_� kihkh[kl\h\Zehwlhfm�bamq_gb_�^_lkdhc�k_dkmZevghklb��Z kh\iZ^_gb_�h[hbo�y\e_gbc�klZeh�^ey�gZk�j_rZxsbf�Gh�ijhy\e_gby�^_lkdhc�k_dkmZevghklb��dZd�[u�hgb�gb�[ueb�hq_\b^gu�\ [he__�iha^g_f�^_lkl\_�dZ`_lky��bkq_aZxl�\ g_hij_^_e_gghklb�ih�f_j_�ijb[eb`_gby�d bo�gZqZevguf�klZ^byf��Lhl��dlhg_�ohq_l�h[jZsZlv�\gbfZgby�gZ�bklhjbx�jZa\blby�b ZgZeblbq_kdmx�k\yav��[m^_l�hkiZjb\Zlv�bok_dkmZevguc� b ijbagZ\Zlv� \f_klh� g_]h� dZdhc�gb[m^v� g_^bnn_j_gpbjh\Zgguc� oZjZdl_j�� G_aZ[u\Zcl_�� qlh� \ gZklhys__� \j_fy� fu� _s_� g_� bf__f� h[s_ijbgylh]h� ijbagZdZ� k_dkmZevghcijbjh^u�dZdh]h�lh�ijhp_kkZ��djhf_�hiylv�lZdb�ijbgZ^e_`ghklb�d nmgdpbb�ijh^he`_gby�jh^Z�

Page 177: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gh�_]h�fu�kqblZ_f�kebrdhf�madbf��;bheh]bq_kdb_�djbl_jbb��\jh^_�ij_^eh`_gguo�<��Nebkkhf������� i_jbh^h\� \ ��� b ��� ^g_c�� _s_� hq_gv� kihjgu�� obfbq_kdb_� hkh[_gghklb� k_dkmZevguoijhp_kkh\�� dhlhju_� fu� fh`_f� ebrv� ij_^iheZ]Zlv�� _s_� lhevdh� `^ml� k\h_]h� hldjulby�K_dkmZevgu_� ba\jZs_gby� \ajhkeuo�� gZijhlb\�� y\eyxlky� q_f�lh� hsmlbfuf� bg_^\mkfuke_gguf�� DZd� ihdZau\Z_l� m`_� bo� h[s_ijbagZggh_� gZa\Zgb_�� hgb�� g_khfg_ggh�hlghkylky�d k_dkmZevghfm��Imklv�bo�gZau\Zxl�ijbagZdhf�^_]_g_jZpbb�ieb�dZd�m]h^gh�bgZq_�_s_�gbdlh�g_�gZoh^be�\ k_[_�j_rbfhklb�hlg_klb�bo�d q_fm�gb[m^v�^jm]hfm��Z g_�d n_ghf_gZfk_dkmZevghc�`bagb��Lhevdh�hgb�^Zxl�gZf�ijZ\h�ml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�k_dkmZevghklv�b ijh^he`_gb_jh^Z�g_�kh\iZ^Zxl��ihlhfm�qlh�hq_\b^gh��qlh�\k_�hgb�hldZau\Zxlky�hl�p_eb�ijh^he`_gby�jh^Z�Y \b`m� a^_kv� h^gm� g_[_augl_j_kgmx� iZjZee_ev�� < lh� \j_fy� dZd� ^ey� [hevrbgkl\Z©khagZl_evgh_ª�b ©ikbobq_kdh_ª�[ueh�l_f�`_�kZfuf��fu�[ueb�\ugm`^_gu�jZkrbjblv�ihgylb_©ikbobq_kdh_ª� b ijbagZlv� ikbobq_kdh_�� dhlhjh_� g_� khagZl_evgh�� B kh\_jr_ggh� ZgZeh]bqgh^jm]b_�h[ty\eyxl�b^_glbqguf� ©k_dkmZevgh_ª�b ©hlghkys__ky� d ijh^he`_gbx� jh^Zª�²�beb�_keb� ohlbl_� \ujZablvky� dhjhq_�� ©]_gblZevgh_ª�²� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd�fu� g_�fh`_f� g_� ijbagZlv©k_dkmZevgh]hª��dhlhjh_�g_�©]_gblZevghª��b g_�bf__l�gbq_]h�h[s_]h�k ijh^he`_gb_f�jh^Z��Wlhlhevdh�nhjfZevgh_�koh^kl\h��h^gZdh�hgh�bf__l�[he__�]em[hdh_�hkgh\Zgb_�Gh� _keb� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� k_dkmZevguo� ba\jZs_gbc� y\ey_lky� \ wlhf� \hijhk_� lZdbfm[_^bl_evguf�^hdZaZl_evkl\hf��ihq_fm�hgh�jZgvr_�g_�hdZaZeh� k\h_]h�^_ckl\by�b g_� j_rbehwlhl� \hijhk"� Y�� ijZ\h�� g_� fh]m� kdZaZlv�� Fg_� dZ`_lky�� ^_eh� \ lhf�� qlh� d k_dkmZevgufba\jZs_gbyf�bf__lky� kh\_jr_ggh�hkh[h_�hlghr_gb_�� dhlhjh_�jZkijhkljZgy_lky�gZ� l_hjbx�blZd`_�f_rZ_l�bo�gZmqghc�hp_gd_��DZd�[m^lh�gbdlh�g_�fh`_l�aZ[ulv��qlh�hgb�g_�lhevdh�qlh�lhhl\jZlbl_evgh_�� gh� b qm^h\bsgh_�� hiZkgh_�� dZd� [m^lh� bo� kqblZxl� kh[eZagbl_evgufb� b \]em[bg_�^mrb�\ugm`^_gu�ih[hjhlv�lZcgmx�aZ\bklv�d l_f��dlh�bfb�gZkeZ`^Z_lky��ih^h[gh�lhfmdZd�\ ba\_klghc�iZjh^bb�gZ�LZg]_ca_jZ�dZjZxsbc�eZg^]jZn�khagZ_lky����< ]jhl_� <_g_ju� aZ[ue� hg� q_klv� b ^he]�� ²� KljZggh�� qlh� k gZrbf� [jZlhf� wlh]h� g_kemqZ_lky�< ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� `_� ba\jZs_ggu_� kdhj__� `Zedb_� kms_kl\Z�� hq_gv� ^hjh]hjZkieZqb\Zxsb_ky�aZ�k\h_�ljm^gh�^hklb`bfh_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�Lh�h[klhyl_evkl\h��qlh�Zdl�ba\jZs_ggh]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�\ [hevrbgkl\_�kemqZ_\�\k_�`_aZdZgqb\Z_lky� iheguf� hj]Zafhf� b \u^_e_gb_f� iheh\uo� ijh^mdlh\�� ^_eZ_l� ba\jZs_ggmx^_yl_evghklv�g_khfg_ggh�k_dkmZevghc��g_kfhljy�gZ�\kx�kljZgghklv�h[t_dlZ�b p_e_c��Gh� wlh�jZamf__lky�� lhevdh� ke_^kl\b_� lh]h�� qlh� wlb� ebpZ� ²� \ajhkeu_�� m j_[_gdZ� hj]Zaf� b iheh\u_\u^_e_gby� g_\hafh`gu�� hgb� aZf_gyxlky� gZf_dZfb�� dhlhju_� hiylv�lZdb� g_� ijbagZxlkyg_khfg_ggh�k_dkmZevgufb��Qlh[u�^hihegblv�hp_gdm�k_dkmZevguo�ba\jZs_gbc��y ^he`_g�dh_�qlh� ^h[Z\blv�� DZd� hgb� gb hihjhq_gu�� dZd� j_adh� gb� ijhlb\hihklZ\eyxlky� ghjfZevghck_dkmZevghc�^_yl_evghklb��ijhklh_�gZ[ex^_gb_�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�lZ�beb�bgZy�ba\jZs_ggZy�q_jlZihqlb�\k_]^Z�bf__lky�\ k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�ghjfZevguo�ex^_c��>Z`_�ihp_emc�fh`_l�ih�ijZ\mgZau\Zlvky�ba\jZs_gguf�Zdlhf��ihlhfm�qlh�hg�khklhbl�\ kh_^bg_gbb�^\mo�wjh]_gguo�ahg�jlZ\f_klh� ^\mo� ]_gblZebc��Gh� gbdlh� g_� hldZau\Z_lky� hl� g_]h� dZd� hl� ba\jZs_gby�� gZijhlb\�� gZkp_g_�hg�^himkdZ_lky�dZd�kfy]q_gguc�gZf_d�gZ�iheh\hc�Zdl��Gh�dZd�jZa�ihp_emc�fh`_l�klZlv�biheguf� ba\jZs_gb_f�� Z bf_ggh� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� hg� lZd� bgl_gkb\_g�� qlh� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh

Page 178: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

khijh\h`^Z_lky�\u^_e_gb_f�ba�]_gblZebc�b hj]Zafhf��qlh�[u\Z_l�g_�lZd�m`�j_^dh��<ijhq_f�fh`gh� gZ[ex^Zlv�� qlh� ^ey� h^gh]h� g_ij_f_ggufb� mkeh\byfb� k_dkmZevgh]h� gZkeZ`^_gbyy\eyxlky�hsmiu\Zgb_�b jZa]ey^u\Zgb_�h[t_dlZ��Z ^jm]hc�\ ihju\_�k_dkmZevgh]h�\ha[m`^_gbysbiZ_l� beb� dmkZ_l�� qlh� kZfh_� [hevrh_� \ha[m`^_gb_� m ex[ys_]h� g_� \k_]^Z� \uau\Zxl]_gblZebb��Z dZdZy�gb[m^v�^jm]Zy�qZklv�l_eZ�h[t_dlZ�b lhfm�ih^h[gh_�\ [hevrhf�jZaghh[jZabb�G_�bf__l�gbdZdh]h�kfukeZ�\u^_eylv�ebp�k g_dhlhjufb�lZdbfb�q_jlZfb�ba�jy^Z�ghjfZevguo�bijbqbkeylv�bo�d ba\jZs_gguf��[hevr_�lh]h��\k_�ykg__�ihgbfZ_rv��qlh�kmsghklv�ba\jZs_gbckhklhbl� g_� \ hlklmie_gbb� hl� k_dkmZevghc� p_eb�� g_� \ aZf_g_� ]_gblZebc�� ^Z`_� g_� \k_]^Z� \baf_g_gbb�h[t_dlZ��Z lhevdh�\ bkdexqbl_evghklb��k dhlhjhc�kh\_jrZxlky�wlb�hlklmie_gby��ba�aZ� dhlhjuo� hlklZ\ey_lky� kZf� iheh\hc� Zdl�� kem`Zsbc� ijh^he`_gbx� jh^Z�� Ihkdhevdmba\jZs_ggu_� ^_ckl\by� \dexqZxlky� \ kh\_jr_gb_� ghjfZevgh]h� iheh\h]h� ZdlZ� dZdih^]hlh\bl_evgu_� beb� mkbeb\Zxsb_� _]h�� hgb�� kh[kl\_ggh�� i_j_klZxl� [ulv� ba\jZs_ggufb�Dhg_qgh�� [eZ]h^Zjy� nZdlZf� lZdh]h� jh^Z� ijhiZklv� f_`^m� ghjfZevghc� b ba\jZs_gghck_dkmZevghklvx� kbevgh� mf_gvrZ_lky�� GZijZrb\Z_lky� _kl_kl\_gguc� \u\h^�� qlh� ghjfZevgZyk_dkmZevghklv� ijhbkoh^bl� ba� q_]h�lh�� qlh� kms_kl\h\Zeh� ^h� g__�� bkdexqZy� dZd� g_ijb]h^gu_h^gb�klj_fe_gby�b h[t_^bgyy�^jm]b_�k l_f��qlh[u�ih^qbgblv�bo�gh\hc�p_eb�ijh^he`_gby�jh^Z�Ij_`^_�q_f�fu�\hkihevam_fky�gZrbfb�agZgbyfb�h[�ba\jZs_gbyo�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�kgh\Zm]em[blvky�\ bamq_gb_�^_lkdhc�k_dkmZevghklb��bkoh^y�ba�mlhqg_gguo�ij_^iheh`_gbc��y ^he`_gh[jZlblv� \Zr_� \gbfZgb_� gZ� \Z`gh_� jZaebqb_� f_`^m� gbfb��Ba\jZs_ggZy� k_dkmZevghklv�� dZdijZ\beh��\_ebdhe_igh�p_gljbjh\ZgZ��\k_�^_ckl\by�klj_fylky�d h^ghc��\ [hevrbgkl\_�kemqZ_\�²_^bgkl\_gghc�p_eb��qZklgh_�\e_q_gb_�h^_j`b\Z_l�\_jo��b eb[h�lhevdh�hgh�b h[gZjm`b\Z_lky�eb[h�\k_�^jm]b_�ih^qbg_gu�_]h�p_eyf��< wlhf�hlghr_gbb�f_`^m�ba\jZs_gghc�b ghjfZevghck_dkmZevghklvx� g_l� ^jm]h]h� jZaebqby�� djhf_� lh]h�� qlh� ]hkih^kl\mxsb_� qZklgu_� \e_q_gby� bkhhl\_lkl\mxsb_�bf� k_dkmZevgu_�p_eb� m gbo� jZagu_��B a^_kv��b lZf� ^_ckl\m_l�� lZd� kdZaZlv�ohjhrh�hj]Zgbah\ZggZy� lbjZgby�� lhevdh� a^_kv� \eZklv� aZo\ZlbeZ�h^gZ� k_fvy�� Z lZf�²� ^jm]Zy�BgnZglbevgZy�k_dkmZevghklv��gZijhlb\��g_�bf__l�\ h[s_f�lZdhc�p_gljZpbb�b hj]ZgbaZpbb��__hl^_evgu_�qZklgu_�\e_q_gby�jZ\ghijZ\gu��dZ`^h_�gZ�k\hc�kljZo�b jbkd�klj_fblky�d ihemq_gbxm^h\hevkl\by��Hlkmlkl\b_�� dZd� b gZebqb_� p_gljZpbb�� jZamf__lky�� ohjhrh� kh]eZkmxlky� k l_fnZdlhf�� qlh� h[Z� \b^Z� k_dkmZevghklb� ²� ba\jZs_ggZy� b ghjfZevgZy� ²� ijhbahreb� babgnZglbevghc��<ijhq_f�� _klv� kemqZb� ba\jZs_gghc� k_dkmZevghklb�� bf_xsb_� ]hjZa^h� [hevr_koh^kl\Z�k bgnZglbevghc��dh]^Z�fgh]hqbke_ggu_�qZklgu_�\e_q_gby�g_aZ\bkbfh�^jm]�hl�^jm]Zhkms_kl\beb�beb��emqr_�kdZaZlv��khojZgbeb�k\hb�p_eb��< lZdbo�kemqZyo�ijZ\bevg__�]h\hjblv�h[bgnZglbebaf_�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb��q_f�h[�ba\jZs_gbb�<hhjm`_ggu_� wlbfb� agZgbyfb�� fu� fh`_f� ijbklmiblv� d h[km`^_gbx� ij_^eh`_gby�dhlhjh]h� gZf� gZ\_jgydZ� g_� ba[_`Zlv�� GZf� kdZ`ml�� ihq_fm� \u� gZklZb\Z_l_� gZ� lhf�� qlh[ugZau\Zlv� k_dkmZevgufb� m`_� l_�� ih� \Zr_fm� kh[kl\_gghfm� k\b^_l_evkl\m�� g_hij_^_e_ggu_^_lkdb_� ijhy\e_gby�� ba� dhlhjuo� iha^g__� jZa\b\Z_lky� k_dkmZevghklv"� Ihq_fm� \u� g_� ohlbl_emqr_� ^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky� nbabheh]bq_kdbf� hibkZgb_f� b ijhklh� kdZaZlv�� qlh� m feZ^_gpZgZ[ex^Zxlky� lZdb_� \b^u� ^_yl_evghklb�� dZd� khkZgb_� beb� aZ^_j`b\Zgb_� wdkdj_f_glh\�ihdZau\Zxsb_�gZf��qlh�hg�klj_fblky�d ihemq_gbx�m^h\hevkl\by�hl�nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby�hj]Zgh\�2UJDQOXVW�"�Wlbf�\u�[u�ba[_`Zeb�hkdhj[eyxs_]h�\kydh_�qm\kl\h�ij_^i]�lh`_gby�h gZebqbbk_dkmZevghc�`bagb�m j_[_gdZ��>Z��m\Z`Z_fu_�]hkih^Z��y g_�bf_x�gbq_]h�ijhlb\�m^h\hevkl\by

Page 179: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hl�nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby�hj]Zgh\��y agZx��qlh�\ukrbf�gZkeZ`^_gb_f�ijb�kh\hdmie_gbb�y\ey_lkym^h\hevkl\b_�hl�nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby�hj]Zgh\��k\yaZggh_�k ^_yl_evghklvx�]_gblZebc��Gh�fh`_l_eb� \u� fg_� kdZaZlv�� dh]^Z� wlh� i_j\hgZqZevgh� bg^bnn_j_glgh_� m^h\hevkl\b_� hlnmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby� hj]Zgh\� ijbh[j_lZ_l� k_dkmZevguc� oZjZdl_j�� dhlhjuf� hgh� g_khfg_gghh[eZ^Z_l�gZ�[he__�iha^gbo�nZaZo�jZa\blby"�AgZ_f�eb�fu�h[�m^h\hevkl\bb�hl�nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgbyhj]Zgh\�[hevr_��q_f�h k_dkmZevghklb"�<u�hl\_lbl_��qlh�k_dkmZevguc�oZjZdl_j�ijbkh_^bgy_lkybf_ggh� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� ]_gblZebb� gZqbgZxl� b]jZlv� k\hx� jhev�� k_dkmZevgh_� kh\iZ^Z_l� k]_gblZevguf��<u�hl\_j]g_l_�^Z`_�\hajZ`_gb_�hlghkbl_evgh�ba\jZs_gbc��mdZaZ\�fg_�gZ�lh��qlhp_evx� [hevrbgkl\Z� ba\jZs_gbc� \k_�lZdb� y\ey_lky� ]_gblZevguc� hj]Zaf�� ohly� b ^hklb]Z_fuc^jm]bf�iml_f��Z g_�kh_^bg_gb_f�]_gblZebc��<u�aZcf_l_�^_ckl\bl_evgh�]hjZa^h�[he__�\u]h^gmxihabpbx�� _keb� bkdexqbl_� ba� oZjZdl_jbklbdb� k_dkmZevgh]h� hlghr_gb_� d ijh^he`_gbx� jh^Z�hdZaZ\r__ky�g_khklhyl_evguf�\ke_^kl\b_�kms_kl\h\Zgby�ba\jZs_gbc��b \f_klh�g_]h�\u^\bg_l_gZ�i_j\uc�ieZg�^_yl_evghklv�]_gblZebc��Gh�lh]^Z�fu�hdZ`_fky�g_^Ze_dh�^jm]�hl�^jm]Z�iheh\u_�hj]Zgu�ijhklh�ijhlb\hihklZ\eyxlky�^jm]bf�hj]ZgZf��: qlh�\u�\hajZabl_�ijhlb\fgh]hqbke_gguo� nZdlh\�� ihdZau\Zxsbo�� qlh� ^ey� ^hklb`_gby� gZkeZ`^_gby� ]_gblZebb� fh]mlaZf_gylvky� ^jm]bfb� hj]ZgZfb�� dZd� ijb� ghjfZevghf� ihp_em_�� \ ijZdlbd_� ba\jZs_gbc�� \kbfilhfZlbd_� bkl_jbb"� Ijb� ihke_^g_f� g_\jha_� kh\_jr_ggh� h[uqgh_� ^_eh�� qlh� y\e_gby\ha[m`^_gby�� hsms_gby� b bgg_j\Zpbb�� ^Z`_� ijhp_kku� wj_dpbb�� ijbkmsb_� ]_gblZebyf�i_j_ghkylky� gZ� ^jm]b_�� hl^Ze_ggu_� h[eZklb� l_eZ� �gZijbf_j�� \\_jo� gZ� ]heh\m� b ebph��Mebq_ggu_� lZdbf� h[jZahf� \ lhf�� qlh� m \Zk� gbq_]h� g_� hklZ_lky� ^ey� oZjZdl_jbklbdbk_dkmZevgh]h�� \u�� \b^bfh�� ^he`gu� [m^_l_� j_rblvky� ihke_^h\Zlv� fh_fm� ijbf_jm� bjZkijhkljZgblv� gZa\Zgb_� ©k_dkmZevgh_ª� lZd`_� gZ� ^_ckl\by�� gZijZ\e_ggu_� gZ� ihemq_gb_m^h\hevkl\by�hl�nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby�hj]Zgh\�\ jZgg_f�^_lkl\_�: l_i_jv�\ukemrZcl_�\ hijZ\^Zgb_�fh_c� lhqdb� aj_gby�^\Z�^jm]bo� khh[jZ`_gby��DZd� \uagZ_l_��khfgbl_evgu_�b g_hij_^_e_ggu_�^_ckl\by�^ey�ihemq_gby�m^h\hevkl\by�\ kZfhf�jZgg_f^_lkl\_� fu� gZau\Z_f� k_dkmZevgufb�� ihlhfm� qlh� \uoh^bf� gZ� gbo� iml_f� ZgZebaZ� kbfilhfh\q_j_a� [_kkihjgh� k_dkmZevguc� fZl_jbZe�� Wlh� _s_� g_� agZqbl�� qlh� hgb� kZfb� ^he`gu� [ulvk_dkmZevgufb�� kh]eZk_g��Gh� \havfbl_� ZgZeh]bqguc� kemqZc��Ij_^klZ\vl_� k_[_�� qlh� m gZk� g_l\hafh`ghklb�gZ[ex^Zlv�jZa\blb_�^\mo�^\m^hevguo�jZkl_gbc��y[ehgb�b nZkheb��ba�bo�k_fyg��gh\ h[hbo� kemqZyo� fh`gh� ijhke_^blv� bo� jZa\blb_� \ h[jZlghf� gZijZ\e_gbb� hl� iheghklvxknhjfbjh\Z\r_]hky� jZkl_gby� ^h� i_j\h]h� jhkldZ� k ^\mfy� aZjh^ur_\ufb� ebkldZfb�� H[ZaZjh^ur_\uo�ebkldZ�\u]ey^yl�bg^bnn_j_glgh��\ h[hbo�kemqZyo�hgb� kh\_jr_ggh�h^ghjh^gu�Ij_^iheh`m�eb�y ihwlhfm��qlh�hgb�^_ckl\bl_evgh�h^ghjh^gu�b qlh�ki_pbnbq_kdh_�jZaebqb_f_`^m�y[ehg_c�b nZkhevx�gZklmibl�ebrv�iha^g__��ijb�\_]_lZpbb"�Beb�k [bheh]bq_kdhc�lhqdbaj_gby� ijZ\bevg__� iheZ]Zlv�� qlh� wlh� jZaebqb_� bf__lky� m`_� \ jhkld_�� ohly� ih� aZjh^ur_\ufebkldZf�_]h�g_evay�m\b^_lv��Gh�\_^v�fu�^_eZ_f�lh�`_�kZfh_��gZau\Zy�k_dkmZevguf�gZkeZ`^_gb_ijb� ^_ckl\byo� feZ^_gpZ�� Ex[h_� eb� m^h\hevkl\b_� hl� nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby� hj]Zgh\� fh`_lgZau\Zlvky� k_dkmZevguf� beb� gZjy^m� k k_dkmZevguf� _klv� ^jm]h_�� g_� aZkem`b\Zxs__� wlh]hgZa\Zgby�� y a^_kv� ZgZebabjh\Zlv� g_� fh]m�� Y kebrdhf� fZeh� agZx� h[� m^h\hevkl\bb� hlnmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby�hj]Zgh\�b h�_]h�mkeh\byo��Z ijb�j_]j_kkbjmxs_f�oZjZdl_j_�ZgZebaZ�\hh[s_g_� m^b\exkv�� _keb� \ dhgp_� dhgph\� ^hc^m� ^h� fhf_glh\�� g_� ih^^Zxsboky� hij_^_e_gbx� \gZklhys__�\j_fy�

Page 180: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

B _s_�h^gh��< k\h_f�ml\_j`^_gbb�h k_dkmZevghc�qbklhl_�j_[_gdZ�\u�\ h[s_f�hq_gv�fZeh\ub]jZeb�[u��^Z`_� _keb�[u� kfh]eb�m[_^blv�f_gy�\ lhf��qlh�^_ckl\by�feZ^_gpZ�emqr_�\k_]hhp_gblv�dZd�g_�k_dkmZevgu_��Ihlhfm�qlh�m`_�k lj_oe_lg_]h�\hajZklZ�k_dkmZevgZy�`bagv�j_[_gdZg_�ih^e_`bl�gbdZdbf�khfg_gbyf��\ wlh�\j_fy�gZqbgZxl�ijhy\eylv�k_[y�]_gblZebb��fh`_l�[ulv�aZdhghf_jgh�gZklmiZ_l�i_jbh^�bgnZglbevgh_�fZklmj[Zpbb��l��_��]_gblZevgh]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�M`_� [hevr_� g_l� gZ^h[ghklb� g_� aZf_qZlv� ^mr_\gu_� b khpbZevgu_� ijhy\e_gby� k_dkmZevghc`bagb��\u[hj�h[t_dlZ��g_`gh_�ij_^ihql_gb_�hl^_evguo�ebp��^Z`_�j_r_gb_�\ ihevam�h^gh]h�baiheh\��j_\ghklv�mklZgh\e_gu�[_kijbkljZklgufb�gZ[ex^_gbyfb�g_aZ\bkbfh�hl�ikbohZgZebaZ�b^h�_]h�ihy\e_gby�b fh]ml�[ulv�ih^l\_j`^_gu�ex[uf�gZ[ex^Zl_e_f��`_eZxsbf�wlh�\b^_lv��<u\hajZabl_��qlh�khfg_\Zebkv�g_�\ jZgg_f�ijh[m`^_gbb�g_`ghklb��Z lhevdh�\ lhf��qlh�g_`ghklvwlZ�ghkbl�k_dkmZevguc�oZjZdl_j��Ohly�^_lb�hl�lj_o�^h�\hkvfb�e_l�m`_�gZmqbebkv�_]h�kdju\Zlv�gh� _keb� \u� [m^_l_� \gbfZl_evgu�� lh� kfh`_l_Ak_�lZdb� kh[jZlv� ^hklZlhqgh� ^hdZaZl_evkl\©qm\kl\_gguoª� p_e_c� wlhc� g_`ghklb�� Z q_]h� \Zf� [m^_l� g_^hklZ\Zlv�� \ [hevrhf� dhebq_kl\_^Z^ml�ZgZeblbq_kdb_�bkke_^h\Zgby��K_dkmZevgu_�p_eb�wlh]h�i_jbh^Z�`bagb�gZoh^ylky�\ kZfhcl_kghc� k\yab� k h^gh\j_f_gguf� k_dkmZevguf� bkke_^h\Zgb_f� kZfh]h� j_[_gdZ�� g_dhlhju_ijbf_ju�dhlhjh]h�y \Zf�ijb\h^be��Ba\jZs_gguc�oZjZdl_j�g_dhlhjuo�ba�wlbo�p_e_c� aZ\bkbl�dhg_qgh�� hl� dhgklblmpbhgZevghc� g_aj_ehklb� j_[_gdZ�� dhlhjuc� _s_� g_� hldjue� p_eb� ZdlZkh\hdmie_gby�Ijbf_jgh�k r_klh]h�^h�\hkvfh]h�]h^Z�`bagb�gZ[ex^Z_lky�aZlbrv_�b kiZ^�\ k_dkmZevghfjZa\blbb�� dhlhjuc� \ kZfuo� [eZ]hijbylguo� \ dmevlmjghf� hlghr_gbb� kemqZyo� aZkem`b\Z_lgZa\Zgby� eZl_glgh]h�i_jbh^Z� �/DWHQ]]HLW���EZl_glgh]h�i_jbh^Z�fh`_l�b g_� [ulv�� hg� \h\k_�g_h[yaZl_evgh�ij_ju\Z_l�gZ�\j_fy�k_dkmZevgmx�^_yl_evghklv�b ]Zkbl�k_dkmZevgu_�bgl_j_ku�ih\k_c�ebgbb��;hevrbgkl\h�i_j_`b\Zgbc�b ^mr_\guo�^\b`_gbc�i_j_^�gZklmie_gb_f�eZl_glgh]hi_jbh^Z� ih^\_j]Z_lky� aZl_f� bgnZglbevghc� Zfg_abb�� m`_� h[km`^Z\r_fmky� jZg__� aZ[\_gbx�dhlhjh_� hdmlu\Z_l� gZrb� i_j\u_� ]h^u� b hlqm`^Z_l� bo� hl� gZk�� Ijb� dZ`^hf� ikbohZgZeba_klZ\blky�aZ^ZqZ�\hkklZgh\blv�\ iZfylb�wlhl�aZ[uluc�i_jbh^�`bagb��g_\hafh`gh�hl^_eZlvky�hlfukeb��qlh�fhlb\hf�wlh]h�aZ[\_gby�hdZaZebkv�kh^_j`Zsb_ky�\ g_f�bklhdb�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�l��_��qlh�wlh�aZ[\_gb_�y\ey_lky�j_amevlZlhf�\ul_kg_gby�K lj_oe_lg_]h�\hajZklZ�k_dkmZevgZy�`bagv�j_[_gdZ�\h�fgh]hf�khhl\_lkl\m_l�k_dkmZevghc`bagb� \ajhkeh]h�� hgZ� hlebqZ_lky� hl� ihke_^g_c�� dZd� m`_� ba\_klgh�� hlkmlkl\b_f� l\_j^hchj]ZgbaZpbb�k ijbfZlhf�]_gblZebc��g_ba[_`gufb�q_jlZf\�ba\jZs_gby�b��jZamf__lky��]hjZa^hf_gvr_c�bgl_gkb\ghklvx�\k_]h�\e_q_gby��Gh�kZfu_�bgl_j_kgu_�^ey�l_hjbb�nZau�k_dkmZevgh]hjZa\blby��beb��dZd�fu�ij_^ihqblZ_f�]h\hjblv��jZa\blb_�eb[b^h��b^ml�\ke_^�aZ�wlbf�fhf_glhf�Wlh�jZa\blb_�ijhl_dZ_l�lZd�[ukljh��qlh�g_ihkj_^kl\_gghfm�gZ[ex^_gbx�gbdh]^Z�g_�m^Zehkv�[uaZ^_j`Zlv� _]h�fbfhe_lgu_� dZjlbgu��Lhevdh�ijb�ihfhsb�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�bkke_^h\Zgbyg_\jhah\�fh`gh� [ueh� ^h]Z^Zlvky� h _s_� [he__� jZggbo�nZaZo� jZa\blby� eb[b^h��Wlh�� dhg_qgh�\k_]h� ebrv� dhgkljmdpbb�� gh� _keb� \u� aZcf_l_kv� ZgZebahf� ijZdlbq_kdb�� lh� gZc^_l_� wlbdhgkljmdpbb�g_h[oh^bfufb�b ihe_agufb��<u�kdhjh�ihcf_l_��dZd�ijhbkoh^bl��qlh�iZlheh]byfh`_l�gZf�jZkdjulv�a^_kv�hlghr_gby��dhlhju_�g_evay�aZf_lblv�\ ghjfZevghf�h[t_dl_�BlZd��fu�fh`_f� l_i_jv� ihdZaZlv�� dZd� kdeZ^u\Z_lky� k_dkmZevgZy�`bagv� j_[_gdZ�� ij_`^_q_f�mklZgh\blky�ijbfZl�]_gblZebc��dhlhjuc�ih^]hlZ\eb\Z_lky�\ i_j\mx�bgnZglbevgmx�wihom

Page 181: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

^h� eZl_glgh]h� i_jbh^Z� b g_ij_ju\gh� hj]Zgbam_lky� \ i_jbh^� iheh\h]h� khaj_\Zgby�� < wlhljZggbc� i_jbh^� kms_kl\m_l� hkh[h]h� jh^Z� g_mklhcqb\Zy� hj]ZgbaZpby�� dhlhjmx� fu� gZau\Z_fij_]_gblZetghc��Gh�gZ�i_j\hf�ieZg_�\ wlhc�nZa_�\uklmiZxl�g_�]_gblZevgu_�qZklgu_�\e_q_gby�Z kZ^bklkdb_�b ZgZevgu_��Ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv�fm`kdh]h�b `_gkdh]h� a^_kv�g_�b]jZ_l�gbdZdhcjheb��__�f_klh�aZgbfZ_l�ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv�Zdlb\gh]h�b iZkkb\gh]h��dhlhjmx�fh`gh�gZa\Zlvij_^r_kl\_ggbp_c� k_dkmZevghc� iheyjghklb�� k dhlhjhc� hgZ� iha^g__� b keb\Z_lky�� Lh�� qlh� \ijhy\e_gbyo� wlhc� nZau� gZf� dZ`_lky� fm`kdbf�� jZkkfhlj_ggh_� k lhqdb� aj_gby� ]_gblZevghcnZau�� hdZau\Z_lky� \ujZ`_gb_f� klj_fe_gby� d h\eZ^_gbx�� e_]dh� i_j_oh^ys_]h� \ `_klhdhklv�Klj_fe_gby�� bf_xsb_� iZkkb\gmx� p_ev�� k\yau\Zxlky� k hq_gv� agZqbfufb� ^ey� wlh]h� \j_f_gbwjh]_ggufb� ahgZfb� m \uoh^Z� dbr_qgbdZ�� Kbevgh� ijhy\ey_lky� \e_q_gb_� d jZa]ey^u\Zgbx� bihagZgbx��]_gblZebb�ijbgbfZxl�mqZklb_�\ k_dkmZevghc�`bagb��kh[kl\_ggh��ebrv�\ jheb�hj]ZgZ\u^_e_gby�fhqb��M qZklguo�\e_q_gbc�wlhc�nZau�g_l�g_^hklZldZ�\ h[t_dlZo��gh�\k_�wlb�h[t_dlug_� h[yaZl_evgh� kh_^bg_gu� \ h^ghf� h[t_dl_�� KZ^bklkdh�ZgZevgZy� hj]ZgbaZpby� y\ey_lky[eb`Zcr_c�klmi_gvx�d nZa_�]_gblZevgh]h�]hkih^kl\Z��;he__�ih^jh[gh_�bamq_gb_�ihdZau\Z_l�kdhevdh�hl�wlhc�hj]ZgbaZpbb�khojZgy_lky�\ [he__�iha^g_c�hdhgqZl_evghc�nhjf_�k_dkmZevghklbb dZdbfb� imlyfb� __ qZklgu_� \e_q_gby� \ugm`^_gu� \dexqZlvky� \ gh\mx� ]_gb�lZevgmxhj]ZgbaZpbx�� AZ� kZ^bklkdh�ZgZevghc� nZahc� jZa\blby� eb[b^h� gZf� hldju\Z_lky� _s_� [he__jZggyy��_s_�[he__�ijbfblb\gZy�klmi_gv�hj]ZgbaZpbb��\ dhlhjhc�]eZ\gmx�jhev�b]jZ_l�wjh]_ggZyahgZ� jlZ�� <u� fh`_l_� ^h]Z^Zlvky�� qlh� d g_c� hlghkblky� k_dkmZevgZy� ^_yl_evghklv� khkZgby�� b\hkobsZlvky�ihgbfZgb_f�^j_\gbo�_]bilyg��\ bkdmkkl\_�dhlhjuo�j_[_ghd��^Z`_�[h`_kl\_ggucOhjmk�bah[jZ`Z_lky�k iZevp_f�\h�jlm��Lhevdh�g_^Z\gh��������:[jZoZf�k^_eZe�khh[s_gb_�h lhf�dZdb_�ke_^u�hklZ\ey_l�wlZ�ijbfblb\gZy�hjZevgZy�nZaZ�\ k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�[he__�iha^gbo�e_l�M\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� Fh]m� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� ihke_^gb_� khh[s_gby� h k_dkmZevguohj]ZgbaZpbyo�kdhj__�h[j_f_gbeb�\Zk��q_f�\jZamfbeb��Fh`_l�[ulv��y hiylv�kebrdhf�m]em[beky\ ih^jh[ghklb��Gh�bf_cl_�l_ji_gb_��lh��qlh�\u�l_i_jv�keurZeb��klZg_l�[he__�p_gguf�^ey�\Zkijb�ihke_^mxs_f�bkihevah\Zgbb��: ihdZ�khojZgbl_�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�k_dkmZevgZy�`bagv²�dZdfu�]h\hjbf��nmgdpby�eb[b^h�²�ihy\ey_lky�g_�dZd�g_qlh�]hlh\h_�b g_�h[gZjm`b\Z_l�ijhklh]hjhklZ��Z ijhoh^bl�jy^�ke_^mxsbo�^jm]�aZ�^jm]hf�nZa��g_�ihoh`bo�^jm]�gZ�^jm]Z��y\eyykv��lZdbfh[jZahf�� g_h^ghdjZlgh� ih\lhjyxsbfky� jZa\blb_f�� dZd�� gZijbf_j�� jZa\blb_� hl� ]mk_gbpu� ^h[Z[hqdb�� Ih\hjhlguf� imgdlhf� jZa\blby� klZgh\blky� ih^qbg_gb_� \k_o� k_dkmZevguo� qZklguo\e_q_gbc�ijbfZlm�]_gblZebc�b \f_kl_�k wlbf�ih^qbg_gb_�k_dkmZevghklb�nmgdpbb�ijh^he`_gbyjh^Z�� >h� wlh]h� kms_kl\m_l�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� jZkk_yggZy� k_dkmZevgZy� `bagv�� kZfhklhyl_evgh_ijhy\e_gb_� hl^_evguo� qZklguo� \e_q_gbc�� klj_fysboky� d ihemq_gbx� m^h\hevkl\by� hlnmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby�hj]Zgh\��WlZ�ZgZjoby�kfy]qZ_lky�[eZ]h^Zjy�i_j_oh^m�d ©ij_]_gblZevgufªhj]ZgbaZpbyf�� kgZqZeZ� kZ^bklkdh�ZgZevghc� nZau�� ^h� g__� ²� hjZevghc�� \hafh`gh�� kZfhcijbfblb\ghc�� D wlhfm� ijbkh_^bgyxlky� jZaebqgu_� _s_� iehoh� bamq_ggu_� ijhp_kku� kf_guh^ghc�nZau�^jm]hc��DZdh_�agZq_gb_�^ey�ihgbfZgby�g_\jhah\�bf__l�lh��qlh�eb[b^h�ijh^_eu\Z_llZdhc�^ebgguc�b fgh]hklmi_gqZluc�imlv��\u�magZ_l_�\ ke_^mxsbc�jZa�K_]h^gy�fu�ijhke_^bf� _s_�h^gm� klhjhgm� wlh]h� jZa\blby�� Z bf_ggh� hlghr_gb_� qZklguok_dkmZevguo�\e_q_gbc�d h[t_dlm��<_jg__��fu�k^_eZ_f�[_]euc�h[ahj�wlh]h�jZa\blby�k l_f��qlh[uih^hevr_� hklZgh\blvky� gZ� h^ghf� ^h\hevgh� iha^g_f� _]h� j_amevlZl_�� BlZd�� g_dhlhju_� badhfihg_glh\�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ�bf_xl�h[t_dl�b khojZgyxl�_]h��dZd��gZijbf_j�

Page 182: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

klj_fe_gb_� d h\eZ^_gbx� �kZ^baf��� klj_fe_gb_� d jZa]ey^u\Zgbx� b ihagZgbx�� >jm]b_�� [he__y\gh�k\yaZggu_�k hij_^_e_ggufb�wjh]_ggufb� ahgZfb��bf_xl�h[t_dl�ebrv�\gZqZe_��ihdZ�hgb\uihegyxl� g_k_dkmZevgu_� nmgdpbb�� b hldZau\Zxlky� hl� g_]h�� dh]^Z� hk\h[h`^Zxlky� hl� wlbonmgdpbc�� LZd�� i_j\uf� h[t_dlhf� hjZevgh]h� dhfihg_glZ� k_dkmZevgh]h� \e_q_gby� y\ey_lkyfZl_jbgkdZy� ]jm^v�� m^h\e_l\hjyxsZy� ihlj_[ghklv� feZ^_gpZ� \ ibs_�� < Zdl_� khkZgbywjhlbq_kdbc� dhfihg_gl�� ihemqZ\rbc� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� ijb� dhjfe_gbb� ]jm^vx�� klZgh\blkykZfhklhyl_evguf��hldZau\Zykv�hl�ihklhjhgg_]h�h[t_dlZ�b aZf_sZy�_]h�dZdbf�gb[m^v�hj]Zghfkh[kl\_ggh]h� l_eZ�� HjZevgh_� \e_q_gb_� klZgh\blky� Zmlhwjhlbq_kdbf�� dZdh\ufb� ZgZevgu_� b^jm]b_� wjh]_ggu_� \e_q_gby� y\eyxlky� k kZfh]h� gZqZeZ��>Zevg_cr__� jZa\blb_� bf__l�� dhjhldh]h\hjy��^\_�p_eb��\h�i_j\uo��hldZaZlvky�hl�ZmlhwjhlbafZ��kgh\Z�aZf_gblv�h[t_dl�kh[kl\_ggh]hl_eZ� gZ� ihklhjhggbc� b�� \h�\lhjuo�� h[t_^bgblv� jZaebqgu_� h[t_dlu� hl^_evguo� \e_q_gbc�aZf_gb\� bo� h^gbf� h[t_dlhf�� JZamf__lky�� wlh� m^Z_lky� lhevdh� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� wlhl� h^bg� h[t_dlij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� p_eh_�� ihoh`__� gZ� kh[kl\_ggh_� l_eh�� Ijb� wlhf� dZdh_�lh� qbkehZmlhwjhlbq_kdbo�\e_q_gbc�dZd�g_ijb]h^gu_�fh`_l�[ulv�lZd`_�hklZ\e_gh�Ijhp_kku�gZoh`^_gby�h[t_dlZ�^h\hevgh�aZimlZggu�b ^h�kbo�ihj�g_�[ueb�ykbh�baeh`_gu�Ih^q_jdg_f�^ey�gZr_c�p_eb��qlh�dh]^Z�\ ^_lkdb_�]h^u�^h�eZl_glgh]h�i_jbh^Z�ijhp_kk�^hklb]hij_^_e_ggh]h� aZ\_jr_gby�� gZc^_gguc� h[t_dl� hdZau\Z_lky� ihqlb� b^_glbqguf� i_j\hfm[eZ]h^Zjy� ijbkh_^bg_gbx� d g_fm� hjZevgh]h� klj_fe_gby� d m^h\hevkl\bx�� ?keb� wlh� b g_fZl_jbgkdZy�]jm^v��lh�\k_�lZdb�fZlv��Fu�gZau\Z_f�fZlv�i_j\uf�h[t_dlhf�ex[\b��Fu�]h\hjbfbf_ggh�h ex[\b��dh]^Z�\u^\b]Z_f�gZ�i_j\uc�ieZg�^mr_\gmx�klhjhgm�k_dkmZevguo�klj_fe_gbcb hlh^\b]Z_f�gZaZ^�beb�ohlbf�gZ�dZdhc�lh�fhf_gl�aZ[ulv�e_`Zsb_�\ hkgh\_�nbabq_kdb_��beb©qm\kl\_ggu_ª��lj_[h\Zgby�\e_q_gbc��D lhfm�\j_f_gb��dh]^Z�fZlv�klZgh\blky�h[t_dlhf�ex[\b�m j_[_gdZ� m`_� gZqZeZkv� lZd`_� ikbobq_kdZy� jZ[hlZ� \ul_kg_gby�� dhlhjZy� ebrZ_l� _]h� agZgbydZdhc�lh� qZklb� k\hbo� k_dkmZevguo� p_e_c�� D wlhfm� \u[hjm� fZl_jb� h[t_dlhf� ex[\bijbkh_^bgy_lky� \k_� lhª�� qlh� ih^� gZa\Zgb_f� W^bih\Z� dhfie_dkZ� ijbh[j_eh� lZdh_� [hevrh_agZq_gb_�� \ ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhf� h[tykg_gbb� g_\jhah\� b�� fh`_l� [ulv�� ku]jZeh� g_� f_gvrmxjhev�\ khijhlb\e_gbb�ikbohZgZebam�IhkemrZcl_� g_[hevrmx� bklhjbx�� dhlhjZy� ijhbahreZ� \h� \j_fy� wlhc� \hcgu�� h^bg� bakf_euo�ihke_^h\Zl_e_c�ikbohZgZebaZ�gZoh^blky�\ dZq_kl\_�\jZqZ�gZ�g_f_pdhf�njhgl_�]^_�lh�\Ihevr_� b ijb\e_dZ_l� d k_[_� \gbfZgb_� dhee_]� l_f�� qlh� h^gZ`^u� _fm� m^Z_lky� hdZaZlvg_h`b^Zggh_� \ha^_ckl\b_� gZ� [hevgh]h�� < hl\_l� gZ� jZkkijhku� hg� ijbagZ_lky�� qlh� jZ[hlZ_lf_lh^hf� ikbohZgZebaZ� b kh]eZk_g� ih^_eblvky� k\hbfb� agZgbyfb� k lh\ZjbsZfb��B \hl� \jZqbdhjimkZ�� dhee_]b�b gZqZevgbdb�� kh[bjZxlky� dZ`^uc� \_q_j�� qlh[u� ihkemrZlv� lZcgu_� mq_gbyZgZebaZ�� DZdh_�lh� \j_fy� \k_� b^_l� ohjhrh�� �gh� ihke_� lh]h�� dZd� hg� jZkkdZaZe� kemrZl_eyf� h[W^bih\hf�dhfie_dk_��\klZ_l�h^bg�gZqZevgbd�b aZy\ey_l��qlh�wlhfm�hg�g_�\_jbl��qlh�]gmkgh�khklhjhgu� ^hdeZ^qbdZ� jZkkdZau\Zlv� lZdb_� \_sb� bf�� [jZ\uf� fm`qbgZf�� [hjxsbfky� aZ� k\h_hl_q_kl\h��b hlpZf�k_f_ckl\Z��b qlh�hg�aZij_sZ_l�ijh^he`_gb_�e_dpbc��Wlbf�^_eh�b dhgqbehkv�:gZeblbd� ijhkbe� i_j_\_klb� _]h� gZ� ^jm]hc� mqZklhd� njhglZ�� Gh� y ^mfZx�� iehoh� ^_eh�� _kebg_f_pdZy�ih[_^Z�gm`^Z_lky�\ lZdhc� ©hj]ZgbaZpbbª�gZmdb��b g_f_pdZy�gZmdZ�iehoh�i_j_ghkblwlm�hj]ZgbaZpbx���: l_i_jv�\u�k g_l_ji_gb_f�ohlbl_�magZlv��qlh�`_�lZdh_�wlhl�kljZrguc�W^bih\�dhfie_dk�

Page 183: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

KZfh� bfy� \Zf� ]h\hjbl� h[� wlhf�� <u� \k_� agZ_l_� ]j_q_kdh_� kdZaZgb_� h pZj_� W^bi_�� dhlhjhfmkm^v[hc� [ueh� ij_^hij_^_e_gh� m[blv� k\h_]h� hlpZ� b \aylv� \ `_gu� fZlv�� dhlhjuc� ^_eZ_l� \k_�qlh[u�ba[_`Zlv�bkrheg_gby�ij_^kdZaZgbc�hjZdmeZ��b ihke_�lh]h��dZd�magZ_l��qlh�ih�g_agZgbx\k_�lZdb�kh\_jrbe�h[Z�wlbo�ij_klmie_gby��\ gZdZaZgb_�\udZeu\Z_l�k_[_�]eZaZ��GZ^_xkv��fgh]b_ba� \Zk� kZfb� i_j_`beb� ihljykZxs__� ^_ckl\b_� ljZ]_^bb�� \ dhlhjhc� Khnhde� ij_^klZ\be� wlhlfZl_jbZe��Ijhba\_^_gb_�Zllbq_kdh]h�ihwlZ�bah[jZ`Z_l��dZd�[eZ]h^Zjy�bkdmkgh�aZ^_j`b\Z_fhfmb hiylv� \ha[m`^Z_fhfm� \k_�gh\ufb� mebdZfb� jZkke_^h\Zgbx�ihkl_i_ggh� jZkdju\Z_lky� ^Z\ghkh\_jr_ggh_�ij_klmie_gb_�W^biZ��\ wlhf�hlghr_gbb�hgh�bf__l�hij_^_e_ggh_�koh^kl\h�k oh^hfikbohZgZebaZ�� < ijhp_kk_� ^bZeh]Z� hdZau\Z_lky�� qlh� hke_ie_ggZy� fZlv�kmijm]Z� BhdZklZijhlb\blky�ejh^he`_gbx�jZkke_^h\Zgby��HgZ�kkueZ_lky�gZ�lh��qlh�fgh]bf�ex^yf�ijboh^blky\b^_lv�\h�kg_��[m^lh�hgb�bf_xl�kghr_gby�k fZl_jvx��ih�gZ�kgu�g_�klhbl�h[jZsZlv�\gbfZgby�Fu� g_� kqblZ_f� kgh\b^_gby� fZeh\Z`gvrb�� b f_gvr_� \k_]h� lbibqgu_� kgh\b^_gby�� lZdb_�dhlhju_�kgylky�fgh]bf�ex^yf��b g_�khfg_\Z_fky��qlh�mihfygmlh_�BhdZklhc�kgh\b^_gb_�l_kghk\yaZgh�kh�kljZgguf�b kljZrguf�kh^_j`Zgb_f�kdZaZgby�M^b\bl_evgh�� qlh� ljZ]_^by� KhnhdeZ� g_� \uau\Z_l� m kemrZl_ey� ih� f_gvr_c� f_j_\hafms_ggh]h�ijhl_klZ�� koh^ghc�b ]hjZa^h�[he__� hijZ\^Zgghc� j_Zdpbb�� q_f� j_Zdpby�gZr_]hijhklh\Zlh]h�\h_ggh]h�\jZqZ��Ihlhfm�qlh��\ kmsghklb��wlZ�ljZ]_^by�²�[_agjZ\kl\_ggZy�iv_kZ�hgZ� kgbfZ_l� k q_eh\_dZ� gjZ\kl\_ggmx� hl\_lkl\_gghklv�� ihdZau\Z_l� [h`_kl\_ggu_� kbeu� dZdhj]ZgbaZlhjh\� ij_klmie_gby� b [_kkbeb_� gjZ\kl\_gguo� ih[m`^_gbc� q_eh\_dZ�khijhlb\eyxsboky� ij_klmie_gbx�� Fh`gh� [ueh� [u� e_]dh� ij_^klZ\blv� k_[_�� qlh� fZl_jbZekdZaZgby�bf__l�p_evx�h[\bgblv�[h]h\�b km^v[m��b \�jmdZo�djblbqgh]h�W\jbib^Z��dhlhjuc�[ue�k[h]Zfb�g_�\ eZ^Zo��wlh��\_jhylgh��b klZeh�[u�lZdbf�h[\bg_gb_f��Gh�m \_jmxs_]h�KhnhdeZ�hlZdhf� bkihevah\Zgbb� kdZaZgby� g_� fh`_l� [ulv� b j_qb�� ij_h^he_lv� aZljm^g_gby� ihfh]Z_l[h]h[hyag_ggZy�ba\hjhleb\hklv��ih^qbgyxsZy�\ukrmx�gjZ\kl\_gghklv�\he_�[h]h\��^Z`_�_kebhgZ� ij_^ibku\Z_l� ij_klmie_gb_�� Y g_� fh]m� kqblZlv�� qlh� wlZ� fhjZev� hlghkblky� d kbevgufklhjhgZf� iv_ku�� gh� hgZ� g_� bf__l� agZq_gby� ^ey� ijhba\h^bfh]h� _x� \i_qZle_gby�� KemrZl_evj_Z]bjm_l�g_�gZ�g__��Z gZ�lZcguc�kfuke�b kh^_j`Zgb_�kdZaZgby��Hg�j_Z]bjm_l�lZd��dZd�[m^lhiml_f�kZfhZgZebaZ�h[gZjm`be�\ k_[_�W^bih\�dhfie_dk�b jZah[eZqbe�\hex�[h]h\�b hjZdmeZ�dZdaZfZkdbjh\Zggh_� ih^� \ha\ur_ggh_� kh[kl\_ggh_� [_kkhagZl_evgh_�� Hg� dZd� [m^lh� \kihfbgZ_l`_eZgby�mkljZgblv�hlpZ�b \aylv�\f_klh�g_]h� \ `_gu�fZlv�b m`ZkZ_lky�bf��B ]hehk�ihwlZ� hgihgbfZ_l� lZd�� dZd� [m^lh� lhl� ohl_e� _fm� kdZaZlv�� gZijZkgh� lu� ijhlb\brvky� k\h_chl\_lkl\_gghklb� b m\_jy_rv�� qlh� [hjheky� ijhlb\� wlbo� ij_klmiguo� gZf_j_gbc�� Lu� \k_�lZdb\bgh\Zl��ihlhfm�qlh�g_�kfh]�bo�mgbqlh`blv��hgb�kms_kl\mxl�\ l_[_�[_kkhagZl_evgh��B \�wlhfaZdexqZ_lky�ikboheh]bq_kdZy�ijZ\^Z��>Z`_�_keb�q_eh\_d�\ul_kgbe�k\hb�^mjgu_�ih[m`^_gby�\[_kkhagZl_evgh_�b ohl_e�[u�m[_^blv�k_[y��qlh�hg�aZ�gbo�g_�hl\_lkl\_g��hg�\k_�lZdb�\ugm`^_gqm\kl\h\Zlv�wlm�hl\_lkl\_gghklv�dZd�qm\kl\h�\bgu�hl�g_ba\_klghc�_fm�ijbqbgu�Kh\_jr_ggh�g_khfg_ggh��qlh�\ W^bih\hf�dhfie_dk_�fh`gh�\b^_lv�h^bg�ba�kZfuo�\Z`guobklhqgbdh\� khagZgby� \bgu�� dhlhjh_� lZd� qZklh� fmqZ_l� g_\jhlbdh\�� >Z`_� [he__� lh]h�� \bkke_^h\Zgbb� h ijhbkoh`^_gbb� q_eh\_q_kdhc� j_eb]bb� b gjZ\kl\_gghklb�� dhlhjh_� yhim[ebdh\Ze�\ �����]��ih^�gZa\Zgb_f�Lhl_f�b lZ[m��y \ukdZaZe�ij_^iheh`_gb_��qlh��\hafh`gh�q_eh\_q_kl\h� \ p_ehf�ijbh[j_eh� k\h_� khagZgb_� \bgu��bklhqgbd�j_eb]bb�b gjZ\kl\_gghklb�� \gZqZe_�k\h_c�bklhjbb�ba�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ����Y hohlgh�kdZaZe�[u�[hevr_�h[�wlhf��gh�emqr_

Page 184: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ha^_j`mkv�� Ljm^gh� hklZ\blv� wlm� l_fm�� _keb� m`_� gZqZe�� gh� gZf� gm`gh� \_jgmlvky� dbg^b\b^mZevghc�ikboheh]bb�BlZd��qlh�`_�fh`gh�magZlv�h[�W^bih\hf�dhfie_dk_�ijb�g_ihkj_^kl\_gghf�gZ[ex^_gbb�aZj_[_gdhf�\ i_jbh^�\u[hjZ�h[t_dlZ�^h�gZklmie_gby�eZl_glgh]h�i_jbh^Z"�E_]dh� aZf_lblv��qlhfZe_gvdbc�fm`qbgZ�h^bg�ohq_l�h[eZ^Zlv�fZl_jvx��\hkijbgbfZ_l�ijbkmlkl\b_�hlpZ�dZd�ihf_om�\hafmsZ_lky�� dh]^Z� lhl� iha\hey_l� k_[_� g_`ghklb� ih� hlghr_gbx� d fZl_jb�� \ujZ`Z_l� k\h_m^h\hevkl\b_�� _keb� hl_p� m_a`Z_l�beb� hlkmlkl\m_l��QZklh� hg� \ujZ`Z_l� k\hb� qm\kl\Z� keh\Zfb�h[_sZy�fZl_jb�`_gblvky�gZ�g_c��KdZ`ml��qlh�wlh]h�fZeh�ih�kjZ\g_gbx�k ^_ygbyfb�W^biZ��gh�gZkZfhf�^_e_�^hklZlhqgh��\ aZjh^ur_�wlh�lh�`_�kZfh_��QZklh�^_eh�aZl_fgy_lky�l_f��qlh�lhl�`_j_[_ghd� h^gh\j_f_ggh� ijb� ^jm]bo� h[klhyl_evkl\Zo� ijhy\ey_l� [hevrmx� g_`ghklv� d hlpm�lhevdh� lZdb_� ijhlb\hiheh`gu_� ²� beb�� emqr_� kdZaZlv�� Zf[b\Ze_glgu_� ²� wfhpbhgZevgu_mklZgh\db�� dhlhju_� m \ajhkeh]h�ijb\_eb� [u� d dhgnebdlm�� m j_[_gdZ�ij_djZkgh� m`b\Zxlky� \l_q_gb_�^ebl_evgh]h�\j_f_gb��ih^h[gh�lhfm�dZd�iha^g__�hgb�ihklhyggh�gZoh^ylky�^jm]�\hae_^jm]Z�\ [_kkhagZl_evghf��KlZgml�\hajZ`Zlv�lZd`_��qlh�ih\_^_gb_�fZe_gvdh]h�fZevqbdZ�bf__lw]hbklbq_kdb_�fhlb\u�b g_�iha\hey_l�ij_^iheh`blv� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� wjhlbq_kdh]h�dhfie_dkZ�FZlv�aZ[hlblky�h \k_o�gm`^Zo�j_[_gdZ��b ihwlhfm�j_[_ghd�aZbgl_j_kh\Zg�\ lhf��qlh[u�hgZ�gb�hdhf� ^jm]hf� g_� [_kihdhbeZkv�� B wlh� \_jgh�� gh�� kdhjh� klZgh\blky� ykgh�� qlh� w]hbklbq_kdbcbgl_j_k�\ wlhc�b ih^h[ghc�kblmZpbyo�y\ey_lky�ebrv�ih\h^hf��dhlhjuf�ihevam_lky�wjhlbq_kdh_klj_fe_gb_�� Dh]^Z� fZeur� ijhy\ey_l� kZfh_� g_ijbdjulh_� k_dkmZevgh_� ex[hiulkl\h� ihhlghr_gbx� d fZl_jb�� lj_[my�� qlh[u� hgZ� [jZeZ� _]h� ghqvx� kiZlv� k kh[hc�� ijhkblkyijbkmlkl\h\Zlv�ijb�__ lmZe_l_�beb�^Z`_�ij_^ijbgbfZ_l�ihiuldb�kh[eZagblv�__��dZd�wlh�qZklhfh`_l�aZf_lblv�b kh�kf_ohf�jZkkdZaZlv�fZlv��lh�\ wlhf��\g_�\kydh]h�khfg_gby��h[gZjm`b\Z_lkywjhlbq_kdZy�ijbjh^Z�ijb\yaZgghklb�d fZl_jb��G_evay�lZd`_�aZ[u\Zlv��qlh�lZdmx�`_�aZ[hlm�fZlvijhy\ey_l�d k\h_c�fZe_gvdhc�^hq_jb��g_�^hklb]Zy� lh]h�`_�j_amevlZlZ��b qlh�hl_p�^hklZlhqghqZklh�khi_jgbqZ_l�k g_c�\ aZ[hl_�h fZevqbd_��gh�_fm�g_�m^Z_lky�klZlv�klhev�`_�agZqbfuf��dZdfZlv�� Dhjhq_� ]h\hjy�� gbdZdhc� djblbdhc� g_evay� bkdexqblv� ba� kblmZpbb� fhf_gl� iheh\h]hij_^ihql_gby��K lhqdb�aj_gby�w]hbklbq_kdh]h�bgl_j_kZ�kh�klhjhgu�fZe_gvdh]h�fm`qbgu��[ueh[u�ebrv�g_jZamfgh�g_�ih`_eZlv�bf_lv�d k\hbf�mkem]Zf�^\mo�ebp�\f_klh�h^gh]h�ba�gbo�DZd� \u� aZf_lbeb�� y hoZjZdl_jbah\Ze� lhevdh� hlghr_gb_� fZevqbdZ� d hlpm� b fZl_jb�� MfZe_gvdhc�^_\hqdb�hgh�kdeZ^u\Z_lky�k g_h[oh^bfufb�baf_g_gbyfb�kh\_jr_ggh� ZgZeh]bqgh�G_`gZy� ijb\yaZgghklv� d hlpm�� ihlj_[ghklv� mkljZgblv� fZlv� dZd� ebrgxx� b aZgylv� __ f_klh�dhd_lkl\h�� ihevamxs__ky� kj_^kl\Zfb� [he__� iha^g_]h� i_jbh^Z� `_gkl\_gghklb�� bf_ggh� mfZe_gvdhc�^_\hqdb�h[jZamxl�ij_e_klgmx�dZjlbgm��dhlhjZy�aZklZ\ey_l�aZ[u\Zlv�h k_jv_aghklb�b\hafh`guo� ly`_euo� ihke_^kl\byo�� klhysbo� aZ� wlhc� bgnZglbevghc� kblmZpb_c�� G_� aZ[m^_fijb[Z\blv��qlh�qZklh�kZfb�jh^bl_eb�hdZau\Zxl�j_rZxs__�\ebygb_�gZ�ijh[m`^_gb_�w^bih\hcmklZgh\db�m j_[_gdZ�� ke_^my�iheh\hfm�ijbly`_gbx��b lZf�� ]^_�g_kdhevdh�^_l_c�� hl_p� kZfufy\guf�h[jZahf�hl^Z_l�g_`gh_�ij_^ihql_gb_�^hq_jb��Z fZlv�kugm��Gh�b wlhl�fhf_gl�g_�fh`_lk_jv_agh� ihdhe_[Zlv� g_aZ\bkbfmx� ijbjh^m� ^_lkdh]h� W^bih\Z� dhfie_dkZ�� W^bih\� dhfie_dkjZajZklZ_lky� \ k_f_cguc� dhfie_dk�� dh]^Z� ihy\eyxlky� ^jm]b_� ^_lb�� <gh\v� hibjZykv� gZw]hbklbq_kdh_�qm\kl\h��hg�fhlb\bjm_l�hljbpZl_evgh_�hlghr_gb_�d ihy\e_gbx�[jZlv_\�b k_kl_jb `_eZgb_�g_ij_f_ggh�mkljZgblv�bo��H[�wlbo�qm\kl\Zo�g_gZ\bklb�^_lb�aZy\eyxl��dZd�ijZ\beh�^Z`_�]hjZa^h�qZs_��q_f�h qm\kl\Zo��bf_xsbo�k\hbf�bklhqgbdhf�jh^bl_evkdbc�dhfie_dk��?keb

Page 185: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

lZdh_�`_eZgb_�bkihegy_lky��b kf_jlv�[ukljh�mghkbl�g_`_eZl_evgh]h�gh\h]h�qe_gZ�k_fvb��lh�baZgZebaZ� \ [he__�iha^gb_� ]h^u�fh`gh� magZlv�� dZdbf� \Z`guf�i_j_`b\Zgb_f�[ue� ^ey� j_[_gdZwlhl�kemqZc�kf_jlb��ohly�hg�fh]�b g_�khojZgblvky�\ iZfylb��J_[_ghd��hlh^\bgmluc�jh`^_gb_fgh\h]h� j_[_gdZ� gZ� \lhjhc� ieZg�� i_j\h_� \j_fy� ihqlb� bahebjh\Zgguc� hl� fZl_jb�� k ljm^hfijhsZ_l�_c�wlh�k\h_�iheh`_gb_��m g_]h�ihy\eyxlky�qm\kl\Z��dhlhju_�m \ajhkeh]h�fh`gh�[ueh[u�gZa\Zlv�]em[hdbf�h`_klhq_gb_f��b qZklh�hgb�klZgh\ylky�ijbqbghc�^ebl_evgh]h�hlqm`^_gby�Fu� m`_� mihfbgZeb�� qlh� k_dkmZevgh_� bkke_^h\Zgb_� kh� \k_fb� _]h� ihke_^kl\byfb� h[uqghhibjZ_lky�gZ�wlhl�`bag_gguc�hiul�j_[_gdZ��K ih^jZklZgb_f�wlbo�[jZlv_\�b k_kl_j�mklZgh\dZ�dgbf�ij_l_ji_\Z_l� kZfu_� agZqbl_evgu_� baf_g_gby��FZevqbd�fh`_l� \u[jZlv� h[t_dlhf� ex[\bk_kljm�dZd�aZf_gm�g_\_jghc�fZl_jb��f_`^m�g_kdhevdbfb�[jZlvyfb��moZ`b\Zxsbfb�aZ�feZ^r_ck_klj_gdhc�� m`_� \ ^_lkdhc� \hagbdZxl� kblmZpbb� \jZ`^_[gh]h� khi_jgbq_kl\Z�� agZqbfu_� ^eyihke_^mxs_c� `bagb�� FZe_gvdZy� ^_\hqdZ� gZoh^bl� \ klZjr_f� [jZl_� aZf_gm� hlpm�� dhlhjuc[hevr_� g_� aZ[hlblky� h g_c� k g_`ghklvx�� dZd� \ kZfu_� jZggb_� ]h^u�� beb�`_�feZ^rZy� k_kljZaZf_gy_l�_c�j_[_gdZ��dhlhjh]h�hgZ�ls_lgh�`_eZeZ�bf_lv�hl�hlpZ�LZdb_�b ^jm]b_�ih^h[gh]h�`_�jh^Z�hlghr_gby�hldju\Zxl�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh_�gZ[ex^_gb_�aZ^_lvfb�b bamq_gb_�ohjhrh�khojZgb\rboky��g_�ih^\_j]gmluo�\ebygbx�ZgZebaZ�\hkihfbgZgbc^_lkdbo�e_l��Ba�wlh]h�\u��f_`^m�ijhqbf��k^_eZ_l_�\u\h^��qlh�\hajZklgh_�iheh`_gb_�j_[_gdZkj_^b�[jZlv_\�b k_kl_j�y\ey_lky�qj_a\uqZcgh�\Z`guf�fhf_glhf�^ey�_]h�ihke_^mxs_c�`bagb�dhlhjuc�gm`gh�ijbgbfZlv�\h�\gbfZgb_�\h�\kydhc�[bh]jZnbb��Gh��qlh�_s_�\Z`g__��[eZ]h^Zjywlbf�k\_^_gbyf��dhlhju_�g_ljm^gh�ihemqblv��\u�g_�[_a�meu[db�\kihfgbl_�\ukdZau\Zgby�gZmdbih�ih\h^m�ijbqbg�aZij_lZ�bgp_klZ��Q_]h�lml�lhevdh�g_�ijb^mfZeb��Qlh�\ke_^kl\b_�kh\f_klghc`bagb�\ ^_lkl\_�iheh\h_�\e_q_gb_�g_�^he`gh�gZijZ\eylvky�gZ�qe_gh\�k_fvb�^jm]h]h�iheZ�bebqlh� \h� ba[_`Zgb_� \ujh`^_gby� [bheh]bq_kdZy� l_g^_gpby� ^he`gZ� gZclb� k\h_� ikbobq_kdh_\ujZ`_gb_�\h�\jh`^_gghf�hl\jZs_gbb�d bgp_klm��Ijb�wlhf�kh\_jr_ggh�aZ[u\Zxl��qlh�\ lZdhfg_mfhebfhf� aZij_l_� aZdhghf� b h[uqZyfb� g_� [ueh� [u� g_h[oh^bfhklb�� _keb� [u� ijhlb\bgp_klmhagh]h� bkdmr_gby� kms_kl\h\Zeb� dZdb_�eb[h� gZ^_`gu_� _kl_kl\_ggu_� h]jZgbq_gby�BklbgZ�dZd�jZa�\ ijhlb\hiheh`ghf��I_j\uc�\u[hj�h[t_dlZ�m ex^_c�\k_]^Z�bgp_klmhaguc��mfm`qbgu�²�gZijZ\e_gguc�gZ�fZlv�b k_kljm��b lj_[mxlky�kZfu_�kljh]b_�aZij_lu��qlh[u�g_�^Zlvijhy\blvky� wlhc� ijh^he`Zxs_c� hdZau\Zlv� k\h_� ^_ckl\b_� ^_lkdhc� kdehgghklb�� MkhojZgb\rboky� ^h� kbo� ihj� ijbfblb\guo� ^bdbo� gZjh^h\� bgi_klmhagu_� aZij_lu� _s_� [he__kljh]b_��q_f�m gZk��b g_^Z\gh�L��J_cd�\ [e_klys_c�jZ[hl_� �����²������ihdZaZe��qlh�jblmZeu�k\yaZggu_� k >gZklmie_gb_f@� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb� ^bdZj_c�� bah[jZ`Zxsb_� \lhjh_� jh`^_gb_�bf_xl� kfuke� hk\h[h`^_gby� fZevqbdZ� hl� bgp_klmhaghc� ijb\yaZgghklb� d fZl_jb� b _]hijbfbj_gby�k hlphf�Fbnheh]by� ]h\hjbl� \Zf��qlh� ydh[u� klhev� hl\jZlbl_evguc�^ey� ex^_c�bgp_kl�[_a� \kydbohiZk_gbc�jZaj_rZ_lky�[h]Zf��Z ba�^j_\g_c�bklhjbb�\u�fh`_l_�magZlv��qlh�bgp_klmhaguc�[jZd�kk_kljhc� [ue� k\ys_gguf� ij_^ibkZgb_f� ^ey� \eZkl_ebgZ� �m ^j_\gbo�nZjZhgh\�� bgdh\� \ I_jm��J_qv�b^_l��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��h ij_bfms_kl\_��g_^hklmighf�ijhklhfm�gZjh^m�Djh\hkf_kbl_evkl\h� k fZl_jvx� ²� h^gh� ij_klmie_gb_� W^biZ�� m[bckl\h� hlpZ� ²� ^jm]h_�DklZlb�]h\hjy��wlh�lZd`_�l_�^\Z�\_ebdbo�ij_klmie_gby��dhlhju_�aZij_sZ_l�i_j\Zy�khpbZevgh�j_eb]bhagZy�hj]ZgbaZpby�ex^_c��lhl_fbaf��I_j_c^_f�l_i_jv�hl�g_ihkj_^kl\_gguo�gZ[ex^_gbc

Page 186: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

aZ� j_[_gdhf� d ZgZeblbq_kdhfm� bkke_^h\Zgbx� \ajhkeuo�� aZ[he_\rbo� g_\jhahf�� Qlh� `_� ^Z_lZgZeba�^ey�^Zevg_cr_]h�bamq_gby�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ"�Wlh�fh`gh�kdZaZlv�\ ^\mo�keh\Zo��HggZoh^bl�_]h�lZdbf�`_��dZdbf�hibku\Z_l�_]h�kdZaZgb_��hg�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�dZ`^uc�g_\jhlbd�kZfW^bi�beb��dZd�j_Zdpby�gZ�dhfie_dk��=Zfe_l��qlh�k\h^blky�d lhfm�`_��JZamf__lky��ZgZeblbq_kdh_bah[jZ`_gb_�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ�y\ey_lky�m\_ebq_gb_f�b h]jm[e_gb_f�lh]h��qlh�\ ^_lkl\_�[uehebrv�gZ[jhkdhf��G_gZ\bklv�d hlpm��`_eZgb_�_]h�kf_jlb�²�m`_�g_�jh[db_�gZf_db��\ g_`ghklb�dfZl_jb�kdju\Z_lky�p_ev�h[eZ^Zlv�_x�dZd�`_gsbghc��Fh`_f�eb�fu�^_ckl\bl_evgh�ij_^iheZ]Zlvkms_kl\h\Zgb_�klhev�j_adbo�b djZcgbo�ijhy\e_gbc�qm\kl\�\ g_`gu_�^_lkdb_�]h^u�beb�ZgZeba\\h^bl�gZk� \ aZ[em`^_gb_�ba�aZ� \f_rZl_evkl\Z� dZdh]h�lh�gh\h]h�nZdlhjZ"�LZdh\hc�g_ljm^ghgZclb�� <kydbc� jZa�� dh]^Z� q_eh\_d�� [m^v� lh� ^Z`_� bklhjbd�� jZkkdZau\Z_l� h ijhrehf�� gm`ghijbgbfZlv�\h�\gbfZgb_��qlh�bf_ggh�hg�g_\hevgh�qlh�lh�i_j_ghkbl�\ ijhreh_�ba�gZklhys_]hbeb� ba� ijhf_`mlhqguo� i_jbh^h\�� bkdZ`Zy� l_f� kZfuf� _]h� dZjlbgm�� ?keb� wlh� g_\jhlbd�� lh\hagbdZ_l� ^Z`_� \hijhk�� y\ey_lky� eb� lZdh_� i_j_g_k_gb_� g_ij_^gZf_j_gguf�� iha^g__� fuihagZdhfbfky�k _]h�fhlb\Zfb�b \hh[s_�^he`gu�[m^_f� kqblZlvky� k nZdlhf� ©nZglZabjh\ZgbygZaZ^ª�\ ^Ze_dh_�ijhreh_��Fu�e_]dh�h[gZjm`b\Z_f�lZd`_��qlh�g_gZ\bklv�d hlpm�mkbeb\Z_lkyjy^hf� fhlb\h\�� ijhbkoh^ysbo� ba� [he__� iha^gbo� i_jbh^h\� b hlghr_gbc�� qlh� k_dkmZevgu_`_eZgby� ih� hlghr_gbx� d fZl_jb� \ueb\Zxlky� \ nhjfu�� dhlhju_�� hq_\b^gh�� _s_� g_ba\_klguj_[_gdm�� Gh� gZijZkgh� [ueh� [u� klZjZlvky� h[tykgylv� \k_� \ W^bih\hf� dhfie_dk_©nZglZabjh\Zgb_f�gZaZ^ª�b hlghkblv�d [he__�iha^gbf�i_jbh^Zf��BgnZglbevgh_�y^jh��Z lZd`_[hevrZy� beb� f_gvrZy� qZklv� f_ehq_c� khojZgy_lky�� dZd� wlh� ih^l\_j`^Z_l� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh_gZ[ex^_gb_�aZ�j_[_gdhf�Debgbq_kdbc� nZdl�� \uklmiZxsbc� aZ� ZgZeblbq_kdb� mklZgh\e_gghc� nhjfhc� W^bih\Zdhfie_dkZ�� bf__l� h]jhfgh_� ijZdlbq_kdh_� agZq_gb_�� Fu� magZ_f�� qlh� dh� \j_f_gb� iheh\hcaj_ehklb�� dh]^Z� k_dkmZevgh_� \e_q_gb_� kgZqZeZ� k iheghc� kbehc� \u^\b]Z_l� k\hb� lj_[h\Zgby�kgh\Z� ijbgbfZxlky� ij_`gb_� k_f_cgu_� b bgp_klmhagu_� h[t_dlu� b hiylv� aZo\Zlu\Zxlky�EHVHW]W�� eb[b^h�� BgnZglbevguc� \u[hj� h[t_dlZ� [ue� ebrv� keZ[hc� ij_ex^b_c�� aZ^Z\r_cgZijZ\e_gb_� \u[hjZ� h[t_dlZ� \ i_jbh^� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb�� A^_kv� jZau]ju\Zxlky� hq_gvbgl_gkb\gu_�wfhpbhgZevgu_�ijhp_kku�\ gZijZ\e_gbb�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ�beb�j_Zdpbb�gZ�g_]h�dhlhju_��h^gZdh��ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�hklZxlky�\g_�khagZgby��lZd�dZd�mkeh\by�bo�hkms_kl\e_gbyklZeb�g_\ughkbfu��K wlh]h�\j_f_gb�bg^b\b^�^he`_g�ihk\ylblv�k_[y�\_ebdhc�aZ^Zq_�hloh^Z�hljh^bl_e_c�b lhevdh�ihke_�__ j_r_gby�hg�fh`_l�i_j_klZlv�[ulv�j_[_gdhf��qlh[u�klZlv�qe_ghfkhpbZevgh]h�p_eh]h��>ey�kugZ�aZ^ZqZ�khklhbl�\ lhf��qlh[u�hl^_eblv�k\hb�eb[b^hagu_�`_eZgbyhl�fZl_jb�b bkihevah\Zlv�bo�^ey�\u[hjZ�ihklhjhgg_]h�j_Zevgh]h�h[t_dlZ�ex[\b�b ijbfbjblvkyk hlphf��_keb�hg�hklZ\Zeky�k gbf�\h�\jZ`^_��beb�hk\h[h^blvky�hl�_]h�^Z\e_gby��_keb�hg�\ \b^_j_Zdpbb� gZ� ^_lkdbc� ijhl_kl� ihiZe� \ ih^qbg_gb_� d g_fm�� Wlb� aZ^Zqb� klhyl� i_j_^� dZ`^uf�m^b\bl_evgh�� dZd� j_^dh� m^Z_lky� bo� j_rblv� b^_Zevguf� h[jZahf�� l�� _�� ijZ\bevgh� \ikboheh]bq_kdhf�b khpbZevghf�hlghr_gbb��: g_\jhlbdZf�wlh�j_r_gb_�\hh[s_�g_�m^Z_lky��kug\kx�k\hx�`bagv�kdehgy_lky�i_j_^�Z\lhjbl_lhf�hlpZ�b g_�\ khklhygbb�i_j_g_klb�k\h_�eb[b^h�gZihklhjhggbc� k_dkmZevguc� h[t_dl�� Ijb� khhl\_lkl\mxs_f� baf_g_gbb� hlghr_gbc� lZdhc� `_fh`_l� [ulv� b mqZklv� ^hq_jb�� < wlhf� kfuke_� W^bih\� dhfie_dk� ih� ijZ\m� kqblZ_lky� y^jhfg_\jhah\�<u� ^h]Z^u\Z_l_kv�� m\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� dZd� djZldh� y hklZgZ\eb\Zxkv� gZ� [hevrhf� qbke_

Page 187: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijZdlbq_kdb�b l_hj_lbq_kdb�\Z`guo�hlghr_gbc��k\yaZgguo�k W^bih\vr�dhfie_dkhf��Y lZd`_g_�hklZgZ\eb\Zxkv�gZ�_]h�\ZjbZpbyo�b gZ�\hafh`guo�ij_\jZs_gbyo�\ ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv��H_]h� [he__� hl^Ze_gguo� k\yayo� fg_� ohq_lky� _s_� aZf_lblv� lhevdh� lh�� qlh� hg� hdZaZe� h]jhfgh_\ebygb_� gZ� ihwlbq_kdh_� l\hjq_kl\h�� Hllh� JZgd� \ aZkem`b\Zxs_c� \gbfZgby� dgb]_� �����\�ihdZaZe�� qlh� ^jZfZlmj]b� \k_o� \j_f_g� [jZeb� k\hb� kx`_lu� ba� W^bih\Z� b bgp_klmhagh]hdhfie_dkh\�� bo� \ZjbZpbc� b fZkdbjh\hd�� G_evay� g_� mihfygmlv� lZd`_�� qlh� h[Z� ij_klmiguo`_eZgby� W^bih\Z� dhfie_dkZ� aZ^he]h� ^h� ikbohZgZebaZ� [ueb� ijbagZgu� ih^ebggufbij_^klZ\bl_eyfb� [_am^_j`ghc�`bagb� \e_q_gbc��Kj_^b� khqbg_gbc� wgpbdehi_^bklZ�>b^jh� \ugZc^_l_�agZf_gbluc�^bZeh]�Ie_fyggbd�JZfh��i_j_\_^_gguc�gZ�g_f_pdbc�yaud�kZfbf�=_l_��LZf\u�fh`_l_�ijhq_klv� aZf_qZl_evgmx�njZam�� 6L� OH� SHWLW� VDXYDJH� HWDLW� DEDQGRQQH� D� OXL�PHPH�� TXLOFRQVHUYDW�WRDWH�VRQ�LPEHFLOOLWH�HW�TXLO�UHXQLW�DX�SHQ�GH�UDLVRQ�GH�,HQMDQW�DX�EHUFHDX�OD�YLROHQFH�GHVSDVVLRQV�GH�,KRPPH�GH�WUHQWH�DQV��LO�WRUGUDLW�OH�khb�D�VRQ�SHUH�HW�FRXFKHUDLW�DXHV�VD�PHUH�>?keb�[ufZe_gvdbc�^bdZjv�[ue�ij_^hklZ\e_g�kZfhfm�k_[_�lZd��qlh[u�hg�khojZgbe�\kx�k\hx�]emihklv�bijbkh_^bgbe�d gbqlh`ghfm�jZamfm�j_[_gdZ�\ Dheu[_eb�g_bklh\kl\h�kljZkl_c�ljb^pZlbe_lg_]hfm`qbgu��hg�k\_jgme�[u�r_x�hlpm�b me_]ky�[u�k fZl_jvx@�Gh�h dh_�q_f�^jm]hf�y g_�fh]m�g_�mihfygmlv��FZlv�kmijm]Z�W^biZ�g_^Zjhf�gZihfgbeZ�gZfh kgh\b^_gbb��Ihfgbl_� j_amevlZl� gZrbo� ZgZebah\� kgh\b^_gbc�� qlh� h[jZamxsb_� kgh\b^_gb_`_eZgby� lZd� qZklh� bf_xl� ba\jZs_gguc�� bgp_klmhaguc� oZjZdl_j� beb� \u^Zxl� g_h`b^Zggmx\jZ`^_[ghklv� d [ebadbf� b ex[bfuf� jh^guf"� Lh]^Z� fu� hklZ\beb� g_\uykg_gguf� \hijhk�hldm^Z� [_jmlky� wlb� aeh[gu_� qm\kl\Z�� L_i_jv� \u� kZfb� fh`_l_� gZ� g_]h� hl\_lblv�� Wlh� jZggb_^_lkdb_� jZkij_^_e_gby� eb[b^h� b ijb\yaZgghklb� d h[t_dlZf� �2EMHNWEHVHW]XQJ��� ^Z\ghhklZ\e_gguf� \ khagZl_evghc� `bagb�� dhlhju_� ghqvx� hdZau\Zxlky� _s_� kms_kl\mxsbfb� b \ba\_klghf�kfuke_�^__kihkh[gufb��: lZd�dZd�g_�lhevdh�g_\jhlbdb��gh�b \k_�ex^b�bf_xl�lZdb_ba\jZs_ggu_�� bgp_klmhagu_� b g_bklh\u_� kgh\b^_gby�� fu� fh`_f� k^_eZlv� \u\h^�� qlh� bghjfZevgu_� ex^b� ijh^_eZeb� imlv� jZa\blby� q_j_a� ba\jZs_gby� b ijb\yaZgghklb� >eb[b^h@� dh[t_dlZf�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ��qlh�wlh�imlv�ghjfZevgh]h�jZa\blby��qlh�g_\jhlbdb�ihdZau\ZxlgZf�lhevdh�\ ij_m\_ebq_gghf�b mkm]m[e_gghf�\b^_�lh��qlh�ZgZeba�kgh\b^_gbc�h[gZjm`b\Z_l�bm a^hjh\h]h��B wlZ�h^gZ�ba�ijbqbg��ihq_fm�bamq_gb_f� kgh\b^_gbc�fu� aZgyebkv� jZgvr_��q_fbkke_^h\Zgb_f�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�kbfilhfh\�><:>P:LV�<LHJ:Y�E?DPBYIj_^klZ\e_gb_�h jZa\blbb�b j_]j_kkbb��Wlbheh]by�M\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z��Fu� magZeb�� qlh� nmgdpby� eb[b^h� ijh^_eu\Z_l� ^ebl_evgh_jZa\blb_��ij_`^_�q_f�klZg_l�kem`blv�ijh^he`_gbx�jh^Z�kihkh[hf��gZau\Z_fuf�ghjfZevguf�L_i_jv�y ohl_e�[u�\Zf�ihdZaZlv��dZdh_�agZq_gb_�bf__l�wlh�h[klhyl_evkl\h�^ey�\hagbdgh\_gbyg_\jhah\�Y iheZ]Zx��qlh�\ khhl\_lkl\bb�k l_hjbyfb�h[s_c�iZlheh]bb�fu�fh`_f�ij_^iheh`blv��qlhlZdh_� jZa\blb_� g_k_l� \ k_[_� hiZkghklb� ^\mo� \b^h\�²� \h�i_j\uo�� hiZkghklv� aZ^_j`db�+HPPXQJ�� b�� \h�\lhjuo�²� j_]j_kkbb� �5HJUHVVLRQ��� Wlh� agZqbl�� qlh� ijb� h[s_c� kdehgghklb

Page 188: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[bheh]bq_kdbo� ijhp_kkh\� d \ZjbZlb\ghklb� ^he`gh� [m^_l� kemqblvky� lZd�� qlh� g_� \k_ih^]hlh\bl_evgu_�nZau�[m^ml�ijhc^_gu�h^bgZdh\h�mki_rgh�b ij_h^he_gu�iheghklvx��dZdb_�lh� dhfihg_glu� nmgdpbb� gZ^he]h� aZ^_j`Zlky� gZ� wlbo� jZggbo� klmi_gyo� b \� h[s_c� dZjlbg_jZa\blby�ihy\blky�g_dhlhjZy�^hey�aZ^_j`db�wlh]h�jZa\blby�Ihbs_f�ZgZeh]b�^Zgguf�ijhp_kkZf�\ ^jm]bo�h[eZklyo��?keb�p_euc�gZjh^�ihdb^Ze�f_klZk\h_]h� ihk_e_gby� \ ihbkdZo� gh\uo�� dZd� wlh� g_� jZa� [u\Zeh� \ jZggb_� i_jbh^u� bklhjbbq_eh\_q_kl\Z�� lh�� g_khfg_ggh�� hg� g_� ijboh^be� gZ� gh\h_� f_klh� \ k\h_f� iheghf� khklZ\_�G_aZ\bkbfh� hl� ^jm]bo� ihl_jv�� ihklhyggh� [u\Zeh� lZd�� qlh� g_[hevrb_� hljy^u� beb� ]jmiiudhq_\gbdh\�hklZgZ\eb\Zebkv�ih�^hjh]_�b k_ebebkv�gZ�wlbo�hklZgh\dZo��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�hkgh\gZyfZkkZ�hlijZ\eyeZkv�^Zevr_��Beb�\havf_f�[he__�[ebadh_�kjZ\g_gb_��<Zf�ba\_klgh��qlh�m \ukrbofe_dhiblZxsbo�fm`kdb_�aZjh^ur_\u_�`_e_au��i_j\hgZqZevgh�ihf_sZxsb_ky�]em[hdh�\gmljbihehklb�`b\hlZ��d hij_^_e_gghfm�\j_f_gb�\gmljbmljh[ghc�`bagb�f_gyxl�f_klh�b ihiZ^Zxlihqlb�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�ih^�dh`m�lZah\h]h�dhgpZ��<ke_^kl\b_�wlh]h�[em`^Zgby�m jy^Z�fm`kdbohkh[_c� h[gZjm`b\Z_lky�� qlh� h^bg� ba� iZjguo� hj]Zgh\� hklZeky� \ ihehklb� lZaZ� beb� ihklhygghgZoh^blky� \ lZd�gZau\Z_fhf�iZoh\hf� dZgZe_�� dhlhjuc� h[Z� >hj]ZgZ@� ijhoh^yl�gZ� k\h_f� imlb�beb�� ih� djZcg_c�f_j_�� lh�� qlh� wlhl� dZgZe� hklZeky� hldjuluf�� ohly� h[uqgh� ihke_� aZ\_jr_gbyi_j_f_s_gby�iheh\uo�`_e_a� hg� ^he`_g� aZjZklZlv��Dh]^Z� y xguf� klm^_glhf� \uihegye� k\hxi_j\mx� gZmqgmx� jZ[hlm� ih^� jmdh\h^kl\hf� ;jxdd_aw�� y aZgbfZeky� ijhbkoh`^_gb_f� aZ^gbog_j\guo�dhj_rdh\�\ kibgghf�fha]m�fZe_gvdhc��hq_gv�ZjoZbqghc�ih�k\h_fm�kljh_gbx�ju[u��YgZr_e��qlh�g_j\gu_�\hehdgZ�wlbo�dhj_rdh\�\uoh^yl�ba�[hevrbo�de_lhd�\ aZ^g_f�jh]_�k_jh]h\_s_kl\Z��q_]h�m`_�g_l�m ^jm]bo�`b\hlguo�kh�kibgguf�fha]hf��Gh�\kdhj_�y hldjue��qlh�wlbg_j\gu_�de_ldb�gZoh^ylky�\g_�k_jh]h�\_s_kl\Z�gZ�\k_f� >_]h@�ijhly`_gbb�^h�lZd�gZau\Z_fh]hkibgZevgh]h� ]Zg]eby� aZ^g_]h� dhj_rdZ�� ba� q_]h� y aZdexqbe�� qlh� de_ldb� wlbo� ]Zg]ebhaguokdhie_gbc�i_j_reb�ba�kibggh]h�fha]Z�\ dhj_rdh\mx�qZklv�g_j\h\��Wlh�ihdZau\Z_l�b bklhjbyjZa\blby��gh�m wlhc�fZe_gvdhc�ju[u�\_kv�imlv�baf_g_gbc�hlf_q_g�hklZ\rbfbky�de_ldZfb��Ijb[he__�ijbklZevghf�jZkkfhlj_gbb�\Zf�g_ljm^gh�[m^_l�hlukdZlv�keZ[u_�f_klZ�wlbo�kjZ\g_gbc�Fu� ohlbf� ihwlhfm� ijyfh� kdZaZlv�� qlh� ^ey� dZ`^h]h� hl^_evgh]h� k_dkmZevgh]h� klj_fe_gbykqblZ_f�\hafh`guf�lZdh_�jZa\blb_��ijb�dhlhjhf�hl^_evgu_�_]h�dhfihg_glu�hklZxlky�gZ�[he__jZggbo� klmi_gyo� jZa\blby�� lh]^Z� dZd� ^jm]bf� m^Z_lky� ^hklbqv� dhg_qghc� p_eb�� Ijb� Zlhf� \u\b^bl_�� qlh� dZ`^h_� lZdh_� klj_fe_gb_� fu� ij_^klZ\ey_f� k_[_� dZd� ijh^he`Zxsbcky� k gZqZeZ`bagb�ihlhd��\ ba\_klghc�f_j_�bkdmkkl\_ggh�jZaeZ]Z_fuc�gZfb�gZ�hl^_evgh�ke_^mxsb_�^jm]�aZ^jm]hf�qZklb��<Zr_�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�wlb�ij_^klZ\e_gby�gm`^Zxlky�\ ^Zevg_cr_f�jZatykg_gbb�ijZ\bevgh�� gh� ihiuldZ� k^_eZlv� wlh� aZ\_eZ� [u� gZk� kebrdhf� ^Ze_dh�� Iha\hevl_� gZf� _s_^h[Z\blv��qlh�lZdmx�hklZgh\dm�qZklgh]h�\e_q_gby�g�[he__�jZgg_c�klmi_gb�ke_^m_l�gZau\ZlvnbdkZpb_c��)L[LHUXQJ��>\e_q_gby@�<lhjZy� hiZkghklv� lZdh]h� klmi_gqZlh]h� jZa\blby� aZdexqZ_lky� \ lhf�� qlh� ^Z`_� l_dhfihg_glu�� dhlhju_� jZa\bebkv� ^Zevr_��fh]ml� e_]dh� \_jgmlvky� h[jZlguf� iml_f� gZ� h^gm� bawlbo�[he__�jZggbo�klmi_g_c��qlh�fu�gZau\Z_f�j_]j_kkb_c��Klj_fe_gb_�i_j_`b\Z_l�j_]j_kkbx�\lhf�kemqZ_��_keb�bkiheg_gb_�_]h�nmgdpbc��l��_��^hklb`_gb_�p_eb�_]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby��\ [he__iha^g_c�beb�[he__� \ukhdhjZa\blhc�nhjf_�gZlZedb\Z_lky�gZ� k_jv_agu_� \g_rgb_�ij_iylkl\by�GZijZrb\Z_lky�ij_^iheh`_gb_��qlh�nbdkZpby�b j_]j_kkby�g_�kh\k_f�g_aZ\bkbfu�^jm]�hl�^jm]Z�Q_f� ijhqg__� nbdkZpbb� gZ� imlb� jZa\blby�� l_f� kdhj__� nmgdpby� hlklmibl� i_j_^� \g_rgbfb

Page 189: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ljm^ghklyfb��j_]j_kkbjmy�^h�wlbo�nbdkZpbc��l��_��l_f�g_kihkh[g__�d khijhlb\e_gbx�\g_rgbfij_iylkl\byf�^ey�__ \uiheg_gby�hdZ`_lky� knhjfbjh\ZggZy�nmgdpby��Ij_^klZ\vl_� k_[_�� _kebdhq_\hc� gZjh^� hklZ\be� gZ� klhygdZo� gZ� k\h_f� imlb� kbevgu_� hljy^u�� lh� mr_^rbf� \i_j_^_kl_kl\_ggh� \_jgmlvky� d wlbf� klhygdZf�� _keb� hgb� [m^ml� jZa[blu� beb� \klj_lylky� kij_\hkoh^ysbf�bo�ih�kbe_�ijhlb\gbdhf��Gh�\f_kl_�k l_f�hgb�l_f�kdhj__�hdZ`mlky�\ hiZkghklbihl_ji_lv�ihjZ`_gb_��q_f�[hevr_�gZjh^m�ba�k\h_]h�qbkeZ�hgb�hklZ\beb�gZ�imlb�>ey�ihgbfZgby�g_\jhah\�\Zf�\Z`gh�g_�mimkdZlv�ba�\b^m�wlh�hlghr_gb_�f_`^m�nbdkZpb_cb j_]j_kkb_c��Lh]^Z�\u�ijbh[j_l_l_�l\_j^mx�hihjm�\ \hijhk_�h ijbqbgZo�g_\jhah\��\ \hijhk_h[�wlbheh]bb�g_\jhah\��d dhlhjuf�fu�kdhjh�ih^hc^_f�KgZqZeZ� ^Z\Zcl_� hklZgh\bfky� _s_� gZ� j_]j_kkbb��Ih� lhfm�� qlh� \Zf� ba\_klgh� h jZa\blbbnmgdpbb� eb[b^h�� \u� fh`_l_� ij_^iheh`blv� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� ^\mo� \b^h\� j_]j_kkbb�� \ha\jZl� di_j\uf� aZo\Zq_gguf� eb[b^h� h[t_dlZf�� dhlhju_�� dZd� ba\_klgh� bgp_klmhagh]h� oZjZdl_jZ�� b\ha\jZl�h[s_c�k_dkmZevghc�hj]ZgbaZpbb�gZ�[he__�jZggxx�klmi_gv��H[Z�\b^Z�\klj_qZxlky�ijbg_\jhaZo� i_j_g_k_gby� b b]jZxl� \ bo�f_oZgbaf_� [hevrmx� jhev��Hkh[_ggh� \ha\jZl� d i_j\ufbgp_klmhaiuf� h[t_dlZf� eb[b^h� y\ey_lky� q_jlhc��ih\lhjyxs_cky� m g_\jhlbdh\� k ijyfh�lZdbmlhfbl_evghc� j_]meyjghklvx�� =hjZa^h� [hevr_� fh`gh� kdZaZlv� h j_]j_kkbyo� eb[b^h�� _kebijb\e_qv� ^jm]mx� ]jmiim� g_\jhah\�� lZd� gZau\Z_fuo� gZjpbkklbq_kdbo�� q_]h� fu� g_� gZf_j_gu^_eZlv� \ gZklhys__� \j_fy�� Wlb� aZ[he_\Zgby� iha\heyxl� gZf� km^blv� h ^jm]bo�� _s_� g_mihfbgZ\rboky�ijhp_kkZo�jZa\blby�nmgdpbb�eb[b^h�b khhl\_lkl\_ggh�ihdZau\Zxl�gZf�gh\u_\b^u�j_]j_kkbb��Gh�y ^mfZx��qlh�k_cqZk�^he`_g�ij_`^_�\k_]h�ij_^hkl_j_qv�\Zk�hl�lh]h��qlh[u\u� g_� imlZeb� j_]j_kkbx� b \ul_kg_gb_�� b ihfhqv� \Zf� \uykgblv� hlghr_gby� f_`^m� h[hbfbijhp_kkZfb��<ul_kg_gb_��dZd�\u�ihfgbl_��wlh�lZdhc�ijhp_kk��[eZ]h^Zjy�dhlhjhfm�ikbobq_kdbcZdl�� kihkh[guc� [ulv� hkhagZgguf�� l�� _�� ijbgZ^e_`Zsbc� kbkl_f_� ij_^khagZl_evgh]h� �9EZ��^_eZ_lky�[_kkhagZl_evguf��l��_��i_j_f_sZ_lky�\ kbkl_fm�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h� �8EZ���B lhqgh�lZd`_�fu�]h\hjbf�h \ul_kg_gbb��dh]^Z�[_kkhagZl_evguc�ikbobq_kdbc�Zdl�\hh[s_�g_�^himkdZ_lky�\[eb`Zcrmx� ij_^khagZl_evgmx� kbkl_fm�� Z hl\_j]Z_lky� p_gamjhc� m`_� gZ� ihjh]_�� Ihgylb_\ul_kg_gby��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��g_�bf__l�gbdZdh]h�hlghr_gby�d k_dkmZevghklb��aZf_lvl_�k_[_�wlh�ih`ZemcklZ��Hgh�h[hagZqZ_l�qbklh�ikboheh]bq_kdbc�ijhp_kk��dhlhjuc�fu�fh`_f�_s_�emqr_hoZjZdl_jbah\Zlv�� gZa\Z\� lhibq_kdbf�� Wlbf� fu� ohlbf� kdZaZlv�� qlh� hgh� bf__l� ^_eh� kij_^iheZ]Z_fufb� ikbobq_kdbfb� ijhkljZgkl\_ggufb� _fdhklyfb�� beb�� _keb� hiylv� \\_klb� wlh]jm[h_� \kihfh]Zl_evgh_� ij_^klZ\e_gb_�� k ihkljh_gb_f� ^mr_\gh]h� ZiiZjZlZ� ba� hkh[uoikbobq_kdbo�kbkl_f�Lhevdh�ijh\_^y�wlh�kjZ\g_gb_��fu�aZf_lbf��qlh�^h�kbo�ihj�mihlj_[eyeb�keh\h�©j_]j_kkbyªg_� \ _]h� h[s_f�� Z \� kh\_jr_ggh� ki_pbZevghf� agZq_gbb�� ?keb� \u� ijb^Z^bl_� _fm� _]h� h[sbckfuke� ²� \ha\jZl� hl� [he__� \ukhdhc� klmi_gb� jZa\blby� d [he__� gbadhc�� lh� b \ul_kg_gb_ih^iZ^Z_l� ih^� j_]j_kkbx�� ihlhfm� qlh� hgh� lh`_� fh`_l� [ulv� hibkZgh� dZd� \ha\jZl� gZ� [he__jZggxx� b ]em[bggmx� �WLHIHUH�� klmi_gv� jZa\blby� ikbobq_kdh]h� ZdlZ�� Lhevdh� ijb� \ul_kg_gbbkmlv� aZdexqZ_lky� g_� \ wlhf� h[jZlghf� ^\b`_gbb�� ihlhfm� qlh� fu� gZau\Z_f� \ul_kg_gb_f� \^bgZfbq_kdhf� kfuke_� b lhl� kemqZc�� dh]^Z� ikbobq_kdbc� Zdl� aZ^_j`b\Z_lky� gZ� [he__� gbadhcklmi_gb�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��<ul_kg_gb_�bf_ggh�lhibq_kdb�^bgZfbq_kdh_�ihgylb_��j_]j_kkby�`_²�qbklh�hibkZl_evgh_��Gh�lh��qlh�fu�^h�kbo�ihj�gZau\Zeb�j_]j_kkb_c�b ijb\h^beb�\ k\yav�k

Page 190: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

nbdkZpb_c�� fu� ihgbfZeb� bkdexqbl_evgh� dZd� \ha\jZl� eb[b^h� gZ� [he__� jZggb_� klmi_gb� _]hjZa\blby�� l�� _�� dZd� g_qlh� kh\_jr_ggh� hlebqgh_�� ih� kms_kl\m�� hl� \ul_kg_gby� b kh\_jr_gghg_aZ\bkbfh_� hl� g_]h�� Fu� g_� fh`_f� lZd`_� gZa\Zlv� j_]j_kkbx� eb[b^h� qbklh� ikbobq_kdbfijhp_kkhf� b g_� agZ_f�� dZdmx� ehdZebaZpbx� mdZaZlv� _c� \ ^mr_\ghf� ZiiZjZl_�� ?keb� hgZ� bhdZau\Z_l� gZ� ^mr_\gmx�`bagv� kbevg_cr__� \ebygb_�� lh� \k_�lZdb� hj]Zgbq_kdbc�nZdlhj� \ g_cgZb[he__�agZqbl_e_g�JZatykg_gby�� ih^h[gu_� wlbf�� m\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� ^he`gu� dZaZlvky� g_kdhevdh� kmobfb�H[jZlbfky�d debgbd_��qlh[u�ihdZaZlv�ijbf_g_gb_�gZrbo�^Zgguo��dhlhjh_�ijhba\_^_l�[hevr__\i_qZle_gb_�� <u� agZ_l_�� qlh� bkl_jby� b g_\jha� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc� ²� ^\Z� hkgh\guoij_^klZ\bl_ey�]jmiiu�g_\jhah\�i_j_g_k_gby��Ohly�ijb�bkl_jbb�b \klj_qZ_lky�j_]j_kkby�eb[b^hd i_j\bqguf� bgp_klmhaguf� h[t_dlZf� b hgZ� aZdhghf_jgZ�� gh� j_]j_kkbb� gZ� [he__� jZggxxklmi_gv� k_dkmZevghc� hj]ZgbaZpbb� kh\_jr_ggh� g_� [u\Z_l�� AZlh� \ul_kg_gbx� \ f_oZgbaf_bkl_jbb� ijbgZ^e_`bl� ]eZ\gZy� jhev�� ?keb�fg_� iha\he_gh� [m^_l� ^hihegblv� gZrb� l_i_j_rgb_^hklh\_jgu_� k\_^_gby� h[� wlhf� g_\jha_� h^ghc� dhgkljmdpb_c�� y fh]m� hibkZlv� nZdlbq_kdh_iheh`_gb_� \_s_c� ke_^mxsbf� h[jZahf�� h[t_^bg_gb_� qZklguo� \e_q_gbc� ih^� ijbfZlhf]_gblZebc�aZ\_jrbehkv��gh�_]h�j_amevlZlu�gZlZedb\Zxlky�gZ�khijhlb\e_gb_�ij_^khagZl_evghckbkl_fu��k\yaZgghc�k khagZgb_f��=_gblZevgZy�hj]ZgbaZpby�agZqbfZ�^ey�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��gh�g_^ey� ij_^khagZl_evgh]h�� b wlh� hljbpZgb_� kh� klhjhgu� ij_^khagZl_evgh]h� kha^Z_l� dZjlbgm�bf_xsmx�hij_^_e_ggh_�koh^kl\h�k khklhygb_f�^h�]hkih^kl\Z�]_gblZebc��G�h \k_�`_�wlh�g_qlhkh\k_f� bgh_�� Ba� ^\mo� j_]j_kkbc� eb[b^h� ]hjZa^h� [he__� ijbf_qZl_evgZ� j_]j_kkby� gZ� [he__jZggxx� klmi_gv� k_dkmZevghc�hj]ZgbaZpbb��LZd�dZd�hgZ�ijb�bkl_jbb�hlkmlkl\m_l�� Z \k_�gZr_ihgbfZgb_� g_\jhah\� gZoh^blky� _s_� ih^� kbevguf� \ebygb_f� ij_^r_kl\h\Z\r_]h� ih� \j_f_gbbamq_gby� bkl_jbb�� lh� agZq_gb_� j_]j_kkbb� eb[b^h� klZg_l� gZf� ykgh� gZfgh]h� iha^g__�� q_fagZq_gb_� \ul_kg_gby�� Ijb]hlh\bfky� d lhfm�� qlh� gZrb� \a]ey^u� _s_� [he__� jZkrbjylky� bih^\_j]gmlky� i_j_hp_gd_�� dh]^Z� fu� ih^\_j]g_f� jZkkfhlj_gbx�� djhf_� bkl_jbb� b g_\jhaZgZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc��_s_�^jm]b_��gZjpbkklbq_kdb_�g_\jhau�Ijb� g_\jha_� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc�� gZijhlb\�� j_]j_kkby� eb[b^h� gZ� ij_^\Zjbl_evgmxklmi_gv�kZ^bklkdh�ZgZevghc�hj]ZgbaZpbb�y\ey_lky�kZfuf�aZf_qZl_evguf�b j_rZxsbf�nZdlhfkbfilhfZlbq_kdh]h� \ujZ`_gby�� Ex[h\guc� bfimevk� ^he`_g� lh]^Z� fZkdbjh\Zlvky� ih^kZ^bklkdbc�� GZ\yaqb\h_� ij_^klZ\e_gb_�� y ohl_e� [u� l_[y� m[blv�� \ kmsghklb�� hagZqZ_l�� _kebhk\h[h^blv�_]h�hl�hij_^_e_gguo��gh�g_�kemqZcguo��Z g_h[oh^bfuo�^h[Z\e_gbc��g_�qlh�bgh_�dZd�� y ohl_e� [u� gZkeZ^blvky� lh[hc� \ ex[\b��Ijb[Z\vl_� d wlhfm� _s_� lh�� qlh� h^gh\j_f_gghijhbahreZ� j_]j_kkby� h[t_dlh\�� lZd� qlh� wlb� bfimevku� hlghkylky� lhevdh� d kZfuf� [ebadbf� bkZfuf� ex[bfuf� ebpZf�� b \u� kfh`_l_� k_[_� ij_^klZ\blv� lhl� m`Zk�� dhlhjuc� \uau\Zxl� m[hevgh]h� wlb� gZ\yaqb\u_� ij_^klZ\e_gby�� b h^gh\j_f_ggh� lm� kljZgghklv�� k dhlhjhc� hgb\uklmiZxl�i_j_^�_]h�khagZl_evguf�\hkijbylb_f��Gh�b \ul_kg_gb_�ijbgbfZ_l�\ f_oZgbaf_�wlbog_\jhah\� [hev�sj_AmqZklb_�� dhlhjh_�� ijZ\^Z�� g_e_]dh� jZatykgblv� \ lZdhf� [_]ehf� \\h^ghfwdkdmjk_�� dZd� gZr�� J_]j_kkby� eb[b^h� [_a� \ul_kg_gby� gbdh]^Z� g_� ijb\_eZ� [u� d g_\jham�� Z\uebeZkv�[u� \ ba\jZs_gb_��Hlkx^Z� \u� \b^bl_��qlh� \ul_kg_gb_�²� wlh� lhl�ijhp_kk�� dhlhjucij_`^_� \k_]h� k\hckl\_g� g_\jham� b emqr_� \k_]h� _]h� oZjZdl_jbam_l��Gh�� fh`_l� [ulv�� m f_gydh]^Z�gb[m^v�[m^_l�kemqZc�ihdZaZlv�\Zf��qlh�fu� agZ_f�h f_oZgbaf_�ba\jZs_gbc��b lh]^Z�\um\b^bl_��qlh�b a^_kv�gbqlh�g_�ijhbkoh^bl�lZd�ijhklh��dZd�ohl_ehkv�[u�k_[_�ij_^klZ\blv�

Page 191: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

M\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� Y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� \u�� kdhj__� \k_]h�� ijbfbjbl_kv� k lhevdh� qlhmkeurZggufb� jZkkm`^_gbyfb� h nbdkZpbb� b j_]j_kkbb� eb[b^h�� _keb� [m^_l_� kqblZlv� bo� aZih^]hlh\dm�d bkke_^h\Zgbx�wlbheh]bb�g_\jhah\��H[�wlhf�y k^_eZe�lhevdh�h^gh�_^bgkl\_ggh_khh[s_gb_��Z bf_ggh�lh��qlh�ex^b�aZ[he_\Zxl�g_\jhahf��_keb�m gbo�hlgbfZ_lky�\hafh`ghklvm^h\e_l\hj_gby�eb[b^h��l��_��hl�©\ugm`^_ggh]h�hldZaZª��9HUVD�JXQJ���dZd�y \ujZ`Zxkv��b qlh�bokbfilhfu�y\eyxlky�aZf_klbl_eyfb�g_khklhy\r_]hky�m^h\e_l\hj_gby��JZamf__lky��wlh�hagZqZ_l\h\k_�g_�lh��qlh�ex[hc�hldZa�hl�eb[b^hagh]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�^_eZ_l�g_\jhlbdhf�dZ`^h]h��dh]hhg� dZkZ_lky�� Z ebrv� lh�� qlh� \h� \k_o� bkke_^h\Zgguo� kemqZyo� g_\jhaZ� [ue� h[gZjm`_g�nZdlhj\ugm`^_ggh]h� hldZaZ��Iheh`_gb_�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� g_h[jZlbfh��<u�� gZ\_jgh_�� lZd`_� ihgyeb�qlh�wlh�ml\_j`^_gb_�g_�jZkdju\Z_l�\k_o�lZcg�wlbheh]bb�g_\jhah\��Z \u^_ey_l�ebrv�\Z`gh_�bh[yaZl_evgh_�mkeh\b_�aZ[he_\Zgby�< gZklhys__�\j_fy�g_ba\_klgh��ke_^m_l�eb�ijb�^Zevg_cr_f�h[km`^_gbb�wlh]h�iheh`_gbyh[jZlblv�hkh[h_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�ijbjh^m�\ugm`^_ggh]h�hldZaZ�beb�gZ�k\h_h[jZab_�lh]h��dlh�_fmih^\_j`_g�� <ugm`^_gguc� hldZa� qj_a\uqZcgh� j_^dh� [u\Z_l� \k_klhjhggbf� b Z[khexlguf�qlh[u� klZlv� iZlh]_ggh� ^_ckl\mxsbf�� hg� ^he`_g� aZljhgmlv� lhl� kihkh[� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�dhlhjh]h� lhevdh� b lj_[m_l� ^Zggh_� ebph�� gZ� dhlhjuc� hgh� lhevdh� b kihkh[gh��< h[s_f�� _klvhq_gv� fgh]h� iml_c�� qlh[u� \ug_klb� ebr_gb_� eb[b^hagh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� g_� aZ[he_\� ba�aZg_]h��Ij_`^_� \k_]h� gZf� ba\_klgu� ex^b�� dhlhju_� \ khklhygbb� i_j_g_klb� lZdh_� ebr_gb_� [_a\j_^Z�hgb�g_�qm\kl\mxl�k_[y�lh]^Z�kqZkleb\ufb��kljZ^Zxl�hl�lhkdb��gh�g_�aZ[he_\Zxl��AZl_ffu�^he`gu�ijbgylv�\h�\gbfZgb_��qlh�bf_ggh�k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby�qj_a\uqZcgh�ieZklbqgu�_keb�fh`gh�lZd�\ujZablvky��Hgb�fh]ml�\uklmiZlv�h^gh�\f_klh�^jm]h]h��h^gh�fh`_l�ijbh[j_klbbgl_gkb\ghklv� ^jm]bo�� _keb� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� h^gh]h� hl\_j]Z_lky� j_Zevghklvx�� lhm^h\e_l\hj_gb_�^jm]h]h�fh`_l�ijb\_klb�d iheghc�dhfi_gkZpbb��Hgb�hlghkylky�^jm]�d ^jm]m�dZd�k_lv�khh[sZxsboky��gZiheg_gguo�`b^dhklvx�dZgZeh\��b wlh�²�g_kfhljy�gZ�bo�ih^qbg_gb_ijbfZlm�]_gblZebc��qlh�\h\k_�g_�lZd�e_]dh�h[t_^bgblv�\ h^ghf�ij_^klZ\e_gbb��>Ze__��qZklgu_k_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gby�� lZd� `_� dZd� khklZ\e_ggh_� ba� gbo� k_dkmZevgh_� klj_fe_gb_�� bf_xlkihkh[ghklv�f_gylv�k\hc�h[t_dl��aZf_sZlv�_]h�^jm]bf��\ lhf�qbke_�b [he__�e_]dh�^hklb`bfuf�wlZ� kihkh[ghklv� kf_sZlvky� b ]hlh\ghklv� ^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky� kmjjh]ZlZfb� ^he`gu� kbevghijhlb\h^_ckl\h\Zlv� iZlh]_gghfm� \ebygbx� \ugm`^_ggh]h� hldZaZ�� Kj_^b� wlbo� ijhp_kkh\�aZsbsZxsbo�hl� aZ[he_\Zgby�ba�aZ�ebr_gby��h^bg�ijbh[j_e�hkh[h_�dmevlmjgh_� agZq_gb_��Hgkhklhbl�\ lhf��qlh�k_dkmZevgh_�klj_fe_gb_�hldZau\Z_lky�hl�k\h_c�p_eb�qZklgh]h�m^h\hevkl\bybeb�m^h\hevkl\by�hl�ijh^he`_gby�jh^Z��b gZijZ\ey_lky�d ^jm]hc�>p_eb@��]_g_lbq_kdb�k\yaZgghck lhc��hl�dhlhjhc�hldZaZebkv��gh�kZfhc�ih�k_[_�m`_�g_�k_dkmZevghc��Z aZkem`b\Zxs_c�gZa\Zgb_khpbZevghc��Fu� gZau\Z_f� wlhl� ijhp_kk� ©km[ebfZpb_cª� �6XEOLPLHUXQJ��� ijbgbfZy� ijb� wlhfh[smx�hp_gdm��klZ\ysmx�khpbZevgu_�p_eb�\ur_�k_dkmZevguo��w]hbklbq_kdbo�\ k\h_c�hkgh\_�Km[ebfZpby�� \ijhq_f�� y\ey_lky� ebrv� ki_pbZevguf� kemqZ_f� ijbkh_^bg_gby� k_dkmZevguoklj_fe_gbc�d ^jm]bf��g_�k_dkmZevguf��Fu�[m^_f�]h\hjblv�h g_f�_s_�jZa�\ ^jm]hc�k\yab�L_i_jv� m \Zk� fh`_l� keh`blvky� \i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� [eZ]h^Zjy� \k_f� wlbf� kj_^kl\Zf�ihfh]Zxsbf� i_j_g_klb� ebr_gb_�� hgh� ihl_jyeh� k\h_� agZq_gb_��Gh� g_l�� hgh� khojZgy_l� k\hxiZlh]_ggmx� kbem�� < p_ehf� kj_^kl\Z� ijhlb\h^_ckl\by� hdZau\Zxlky� g_^hklZlhqgufb�Dhebq_kl\h� g_m^h\e_l\hj_ggh]h� eb[b^h�� dhlhjh_� \ kj_^g_f� fh]ml� i_j_g_klb� ex^b�h]jZgbq_ggh��IeZklbqghklv��beb�k\h[h^gZy�ih^\b`ghklv��eb[b^h�^Ze_dh�g_�m \k_o�khojZgy_lky

Page 192: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

iheghklvx�� b km[ebfZpby� fh`_l� hk\h[h^blv� \k_]^Z� lhevdh� hij_^_e_ggmx� qZklv� eb[b^h�� g_]h\hjy�m`_�h lhf��qlh�fgh]b_�ex^b�ebrv�\ g_agZqbl_evghc�kl_i_gb�h[eZ^Zxl�kihkh[ghklvx�dkm[ebfZpbb��KZfh_� \Z`gh_� kj_^b� wlbo� h]jZgbq_gbc�²� hq_\b^gh�� h]jZgbq_gb_� ih^\b`ghklbeb[b^h�� lZd� dZd� hgh� ^_eZ_l� aZ\bkbfuf� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� bg^b\b^Z� hl� hq_gv� g_agZqbl_evgh]hqbkeZ� p_e_c� b h[t_dlh\�� <kihfgbl_� lhevdh� h lhf�� qlh� g_kh\_jr_ggh_� jZa\blb_� eb[b^hhklZ\ey_l� \_kvfZ� fgh]hqbke_ggu_�� bgh]^Z� ^Z`_� fgh]hdjZlgu_� nbdkZpbb� eb[b^h� gZ� jZggbonZaZo� hj]ZgbaZpbb� b gZoh`^_gby� h[t_dlZ�� ih� [hevr_c� qZklb� g_� kihkh[gu_� ^Zlv� j_Zevgh_m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�� b \u� ijbagZ_l_� \ nbdkZpbb� eb[b^h� \lhjhc� fhsguc� nZdlhj�� \uklmiZxsbc\f_kl_� k \ugm`^_gguf� hldZahf� ijbqbghc� aZ[he_\Zgby�� Ko_fZlbq_kdb� djZldh� \u� fh`_l_kdZaZlv��qlh�\ wlbheh]bb�g_\jhah\�nbdkZpby�eb[b^h�ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc�ij_^jZkiheZ]Zxsbc�\gmlj_ggbc�nZdlhj��\ugm`^_gguc�`_�hldZa�²�kemqZcguc��\g_rgbc�A^_kv�y \hkihevamxkv�kemqZ_f�ij_^hkl_j_qv�\Zk��qlh[u�\u�g_�ijbgyeb�dZdmx�eb[h�klhjhgm\ kh\_jr_ggh�baebrg_f�kihj_��< gZmd_�\_kvfZ�ijbgylh�\uo\Zlu\Zlv�qZklv�bklbgu��klZ\blv�__gZ�f_klh�p_eh]h�b [hjhlvky�\ __�ihevam�kh�\k_f�hklZevguf��g_�f_g__�\_jguf��LZdbf�iml_f�hlikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h� ^\b`_gby� hldhehehkv� m`_� g_kdhevdh� gZijZ\e_gbc�� h^gh� ba� dhlhjuoijbagZ_l�lhevdh�w]hbklbq_kdb_�\e_q_gby��gh�hljbpZ_l�k_dkmZevgu_��^jm]h_�`_�hl^Z_l�^he`gh_lhevdh�\ebygbx�j_Zevguo�`bag_gguo�aZ^Zq��g_�aZf_qZy�bg^b\b^mZevgh]h�ijhreh]h�b l��i��B\hl� a^_kv� \hagbdZ_l� ih\h^� ^ey� ih^h[gh]h� ijhlb\hihklZ\e_gby� b ihklZgh\db� ijh[e_fu�y\eyxlky�eb�g_\jhau�wdah]_ggufb�beb�wg^h]_ggufb�aZ[he_\Zgbyfb��g_ba[_`guf�ke_^kl\b_fhij_^_e_gghc� dhgklblmpbb� beb� ijh^mdlhf� hij_^_e_gguo� \j_^guo� �ljZ\fZlbq_kdbo�`bag_gguo� \i_qZle_gbc�� \ qZklghklb�� \uau\Zxlky� eb� hgb� nbdkZpb_c� eb[b^h� �b ijhq_ck_dkmZevghc� dhgklblmpb_c�� beb� \hagbdZxl� ih^� ]g_lhf� \ugm`^_ggh]h� hldZaZ"� WlZ� ^be_ffZdZ`_lky� fg_� \ h[s_f� g_� [he__� ]em[hdhfuke_gghc�� q_f� ^jm]Zy�� dhlhjmx� y fh]� [u� \Zfij_^eh`blv��ihy\ey_lky�eb�j_[_ghd�\ j_amevlZl_�hieh^hl\hj_gby�hlphf�beb�\ke_^kl\b_�aZqZlbyfZl_jvx"�H[Z�mkeh\by�h^bgZdh\h�g_h[oh^bfu��kijZ\_^eb\h�hl\_lbl_�\u��< ijbqbgZo�g_\jhah\khhlghr_gb_�_keb�g_�kh\k_f�lZdh_��lh�hq_gv�ihoh`__��<k_�kemqZb�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�aZ[he_\Zgbcijb�jZkkfhlj_gbb�bo�ijbqbg�jZkiheZ]Zxlky�\ h^bg�jy^��\ ij_^_eZo�dhlhjh]h�h[Z�nZdlhjZ�²k_dkmZevgZy�dhgklblmpby�b i_j_`b\Zgby�beb�� _keb�ohlbl_��nbdkZpby�eb[b^h�b \ugm`^_gguchldZa�²�ij_^klZ\e_gu�lZd��qlh�h^gh�\hajZklZ_l��_keb�^jm]h_�mf_gvrZ_lky��GZ�h^ghf�dhgp_�jy^ZgZoh^ylky�djZcgb_�kemqZb��h dhlhjuo�\u�k m[_`^_gb_f�fh`_l_�kdZaZlv��wlb�ex^b�aZ[he_eb�[u�\ex[hf� kemqZ_� \ke_^kl\b_� k\h_]h�hkh[h]h� jZa\blby� eb[b^h�� qlh�[u� hgb�gb�i_j_`beb�� dZd�[uaZ[hleb\h�gb sZ^beZ�bo�`bagv��GZ�^jm]hf�dhgp_�jZkiheZ]Zxlky�kemqZb��h dhlhjuo�ke_^h\Zeh[u�km^blv�ijhlb\hiheh`guf�h[jZahf��>wlb�ex^b@�hij_^_e_ggh�ba[_`Zeb�[u�[he_agb��_keb�[u`bagv�g_�ihklZ\beZ�bo�\ lh�beb�bgh_�iheh`_gb_��< kemqZyo��gZoh^ysboky�\gmljb�jy^Z��[hevrZybeb� f_gvrZy� kl_i_gv� ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklb� k_dkmZevghc� dhgklblmpbb� gZdeZ^u\Z_lky� gZ[hevrmx� beb� f_gvrmx� kl_i_gv� \j_^ghklb� `bag_gguo� lj_[h\Zgbc�� Bo� k_dkmZevgZydhgklblmpby� g_� ijb\_eZ� [u� d g_\jham�� _keb� [u� m gbo� g_� [ueh� lZdbo� i_j_`b\Zgbc�� b wlbi_j_`b\Zgby� g_� ih^_ckl\h\Zeb� [u� gZ� gbo� ljZ\fZlbq_kdb�� _keb� [u� m gbo� [ueb� ^jm]b_hlghr_gby� eb[b^h�� Y�� ih`Zemc�� fh]� [u� ijbagZlv�� qlh� \ wlhf� jy^m� [hevrmx� jhev� b]jZxlij_^jZkiheZ]Zxsb_� fhf_glu�� gh� b wlh� aZ\bkbl� hl� lh]h�� dZd� ^Ze_dh� \u� jZklyg_l_� ]jZgbpug_\jZkl_gbb�M\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z��Ij_^eZ]Zx�gZa\Zlv�ih^h[gh]h�jh^Z�jy^u�^hihegbl_evgufb� jy^Zfb

Page 193: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

�(UJDQ]XQJVUHLKHQ��b ij_^mij_`^Zx�\Zk��qlh�m gZk�[m^_l�ih\h^�h[jZah\Zlv�b ^jm]b_�ih^h[gu_jy^u�Mihjkl\h�� k dhlhjuf� eb[b^h� ^_j`blky� aZ� hij_^_e_ggu_� gZijZ\e_gby� b h[t_dlu�� lZdkdZaZlv�� ijbebiqb\hklv� eb[b^h�� dZ`_lky� gZf� kZfhklhyl_evguf�� bg^b\b^mZevgh� baf_gqb\uf�kh\_jr_ggh� g_ba\_klgh� hl� q_]h� aZ\bkysbf� nZdlhjhf�� agZq_gb_� dhlhjh]h� ^ey� wlbheh]bbg_\jhah\�fu�� dhg_qgh��g_�[m^_f� [hevr_�g_^hhp_gb\Zlv��Gh�g_evay�b i_j_hp_gb\Zlv� ]em[bgmwlhc�k\yab��LZdZy�`_�©ijbebiqb\hklvª�eb[b^h�²�ih�g_ba\_klguf�ijbqbgZf�²�\klj_qZ_lky�ijbfgh]bo� mkeh\byo� m ghjfZevgh]h� q_eh\_dZ� b kqblZ_lky� hij_^_eyxsbf� nZdlhjhf� ^ey� ebp�dhlhju_�\ ba\_klghf�kfuke_�ijhlb\hiheh`gu�kljZ^Zxsbf�g_\jhahf�²�^ey�ba\jZs_gguo��?s_^h� ikbohZgZebaZ� �%LQHW�� ������ �� [ueh� ba\_klgh�� qlh� \ ZgZfg_a_� ba\jZs_gguo� \_kvfZ� qZklh\klj_qZ_lky� hq_gv� jZgg__� \i_qZle_gb_� g_ghjfZevghc� gZijZ\e_gghklb� \e_q_gby� beb� \u[hjZh[t_dlZ�� gZ� dhlhjhf� eb[b^h� wlh]h� ebpZ� aZkljyeh� gZ� \kx� `bagv�� QZklh� g_evay� kdZaZlv�� qlhk^_eZeh� wlh� \i_qZle_gb_� kihkh[guf� hdZaZlv� gZ� eb[b^h� klhev� bgl_gkb\gh_� ijbly]Zl_evgh_^_ckl\b_�� Y jZkkdZ`m� \Zf� kemqZc� lZdh]h� jh^Z� ba� kh[kl\_ggh]h� hiulZ� gZ[ex^_gbc�� H^bgfm`qbgZ��^ey�dhlhjh]h�]_gblZebb�b ^jm]b_�ij_e_klb�`_gsbgu�m`_�gbq_]h�g_�agZqbeb��dhlhjucfh]�ijbclb� \ g_ij_h^hebfh_� k_dkmZevgh_� \ha[m`^_gb_� lhevdh� hl� h[mlhc�gh]b� hij_^_e_gghcnhjfu�� \kihfbgZ_l� h^gh� i_j_`b\Zgb_� \ r_klbe_lg_f� \hajZkl_�� klZ\r__� j_rZxsbf� ^eynbdkZpbb� _]h� eb[b^h�� Hg� kb^_e� gZ� kdZf__qd_� \hae_� ]m\_jgZgldb�� m dhlhjhc� [jZe� mjhdbZg]ebckdh]h�yaudZ��M ]m\_jgZgldb��klZjhc��kmohc��g_djZkb\hc�^_\u�k \h^ygbklufb� ]hem[ufb]eZaZfb�b \a^_jgmluf�ghkhf�� \ lhl� ^_gv� [he_eZ� gh]Z��b ihwlhfm� hgZ� \ulygmeZ� __�� h[mlmx� \[ZjoZlgmx� lmnex��gZ�ih^mrd_��ijb� wlhf�\_jogyy�qZklv�gh]b�[ueZ� aZdjulZ� kZfuf� kdjhfgufh[jZahf�� LZdZy� om^Zy� `bebklZy� gh]Z�� dhlhjmx� hg� \b^_e� lh]^Z� m ]m\_jgZgldb�� ihke_� jh[dhcihiuldb�ghjfZevghc�iheh\hc�^_yl_evghklb�\ i_jbh^�iheh\hc�aj_ehklb�klZeZ�_]h�_^bgkl\_ggufk_dkmZevguf�h[t_dlhf��b hg�[ue�g_m^_j`bfh�m\e_q_g��_keb�d wlhc�gh]_�ijbkh_^bgyebkv�_s_�b^jm]b_� q_jlu�� gZihfbgZ\rb_� lbi� ]m\_jgZgldb�Zg]ebqZgdb�� Gh� \ke_^kl\b_� wlhc� nbdkZpbbk\h_]h�eb[b^h�wlhl�q_eh\_d�klZe�g_�g_\jhlbdhf��Z ba\jZs_gguf��dZd�fu�]h\hjbf��n_lbrbklhfgh]b� ��BlZd��\u�\b^bl_��ohly�qj_af_jgZy��d lhfm�`_�_s_�b ij_`^_\j_f_ggZy�nbdkZpby�eb[b^hy\ey_lky�g_ij_f_gghc�ijbqbghc�g_\jhah\��h^gZdh�djm]�__ ^_ckl\by�\uoh^bl�^Ze_dh�aZ�h[eZklvg_\jhah\�� KZfh� ih� k_[_� wlh� mkeh\b_� y\ey_lky� lZdbf� `_� fZeh� j_rZxsbf�� dZd� b jZg__mihfygmlh_�mkeh\b_�\ugm`^_ggh]h�hldZaZ�BlZd�� ijh[e_fZ� ijbqbg� g_\jhah\�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� mkeh`gy_lky�� < kZfhf� ^_e_�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh_�bkke_^h\Zgb_�agZdhfbl�gZk�k gh\uf�nZdlhjhf��g_�ijbgyluf�\h�\gbfZgb_�\gZr_f� wlbheh]bq_kdhf� jy^m�� dhlhjuc� emqr_� \k_]h� gZ[ex^Zlv� \ l_o� kemqZyo�� dh]^Z� ohjhr__kZfhqm\kl\b_� g_h`b^Zggh� gZjmrZ_lky� g_\jhlbq_kdbf� aZ[he_\Zgb_f�� M lZdbo� ebp� \k_]^ZgZoh^ylky�ijbagZdb�klhedgh\_gby�`_eZgbc�beb��dZd�fu�ijb\udeb�]h\hjblv��ikbob� �Kj��jZ[hlm�Nj_c^Z�©N_lbrbafª������_��q_kdh]h�dhgnebdlZ��QZklv�ebqghklb�hlklZb\Z_l�hij_^_e_ggu_�`_eZgby��^jm]Zy�ijhlb\blkywlhfm�b hldehgy_l�bo��;_a�lZdh]h�dhgnebdlZ�g_�[u\Z_l�g_\jhaZ��< wlhf��dZaZehkv�[u��g_l�gbq_]hhkh[_ggh]h�� <u� agZ_l_�� qlh� gZrZ� ^mr_\gZy� `bagv� [_kij_ju\gh� ihljykZ_lky� dhgnebdlZfb�dhlhju_� fu� ^he`gu� jZaj_rZlv�� Ke_^h\Zl_evgh�� ^ey� lh]h� qlh[u� lZdhc� dhgnebdl� klZeiZlh]_gguf�� ^he`gu� [ulv� \uiheg_gu� hkh[u_� mkeh\by�� Fu� fh`_f� kijhkblv�� dZdh\u� wlb

Page 194: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

mkeh\by��f_`^m�dZdbfb�^mr_\gufb�kbeZfb�jZau]ju\Zxlky�wlb�iZlh]_ggu_�dhgnebdlu��dZdh_hlghr_gb_�bf__l�dhgnebdl�d ^jm]bf�nZdlhjZf��y\eyxsbfky�ijbqbghc�[he_agb�GZ^_xkv�� y kfh]m� ^Zlv� \Zf� bkq_jiu\Zxsbc� hl\_l� gZ� wlb� \hijhku�� ohly� hg� b [m^_lko_fZlbqguf��Dhgnebdl� \uau\Z_lky�\ugm`^_gguf�hldZahf��dh]^Z� ebr_ggh_� m^h\e_l\hj_gbyeb[b^h�\ugm`^_gh�bkdZlv�^jm]b_�h[t_dlu�b imlb��Mkeh\b_f�dhgnebdlZ� y\ey_lky� lh��qlh� wlb^jm]b_�imlb�b h[t_dlu�\uau\Zxl�g_^h\hevkl\h� qZklb� ebqghklb�� lZd�qlh�gZdeZ^u\Z_lky� \_lh�^_eZxs__� kgZqZeZ� g_\hafh`guf� gh\uc� kihkh[� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� Hlkx^Z� b^_l� ^Ze__� imlv� dh[jZah\Zgbx�kbfilhfh\��dhlhjuc�fu�ijhke_^bf�iha^g__��Hl\_j]gmlu_�eb[b^hagu_�klj_fe_gbyhdZau\Zxlky� \ khklhygbb�^h[blvky�p_eb� hdhevgufb�imlyfb�� ohly�b mklmiZy�ijhl_klm� \ \b^_hij_^_e_gguo�bkdZ`_gbc� b kfy]q_gbc��H[oh^gu_� imlb� b _klv� imlb� h[jZah\Zgby� kbfilhfh\�kbfilhfu� ²� gh\h_� b aZf_sZxs__� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�� klZ\r__� g_h[oh^bfuf� [eZ]h^Zjy� nZdlm\ugm`^_ggh]h�hldZaZ�AgZq_gb_�ikbobq_kdh]h�dhgnebdlZ�fh`gh�\ujZablv�ih�^jm]hfm�d \g_rg_�\ugm`^_gghfm�hldZam��qlh[u�hg�klZe�iZlh]_gguf��^he`_g�ijbkh_^bgblvky�_s_\gmlj_gg_�\ugm`^_gguc�hldZa��JZamf__lky��\g_rg_�b \gmlj_gg_� ��\ugm`^_gguc�hldZa�bf_xlhlghr_gb_� d jZaguf� imlyf� b h[t_dlZf�� <g_rg_�\ugm`^_gguc� hldZa� hlgbfZ_l� h^gm\hafh`ghklv� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� \gmlj_gg_�\ugm`^_gguc� ohl_e� [u� bkdexqblv� ^jm]mx\hafh`ghklv�� \hdjm]� dhlhjhc� aZl_f� b jZau]ju\Z_lky� dhgnebdl�� Y ij_^ihqblZx� wlhl� kihkh[baeh`_gby�� ihlhfm� qlh� hg� bf__l� kdjulh_� kh^_j`Zgb_�� Hg� gZf_dZ_l� gZ� lh�� qlh� \gmlj_ggb_aZ^_j`db� ijhbahreb�� \_jhylgh�� \ ^j_\gb_� i_jbh^u� q_eh\_q_kdh]h� jZa\blby� ba�aZ� j_Zevguo\g_rgbo�ij_iylkl\bc�Gh� dZdh\u� l_� kbeu�� hl� dhlhjuo� bkoh^bl� ijhl_kl� ijhlb\� eb[b^hagh]h� klj_fe_gby�� qlhij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� ^jm]Zy� klhjhgZ� \ iZlh]_gghf� dhgnebdl_"� <hh[s_� ]h\hjy�� wlh� g_k_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gby�� Fu� h[t_^bgy_f� bo� \h� ©\e_q_gby� Yª� ��� ikbohZgZeba� g_\jhah\i_j_g_k_gby�g_� ^Z_l�gZf�ijyfh]h� ^hklmiZ� d bo� ^Zevg_cr_fm� jZaeh`_gbx��fu� agZdhfbfky� kgbfb� \ emqr_f� kemqZ_� ebrv� hlqZklb� [eZ]h^Zjy� khijhlb\e_gbyf�� hdZau\Z_fuf� ZgZebam�IZlh]_gguf� dhgnebdlhf�� ke_^h\Zl_evgh�� y\ey_lky� dhgnebdl� f_`^m� \e_q_gbyfb� Y bk_dkmZevgufb�\e_q_gbyfb��< p_ehf�jy^_�kemqZ_\�dZ`_lky��[m^lh�dhgnebdl�ijhbkoh^bl�f_`^mjZaebqgufb�qbklh�k_dkmZevgufb�klj_fe_gbyfb��gh��\ kmsghklb��wlh�lh�`_�kZfh_��ihlhfm�qlh�ba^\mo�gZoh^ysboky�\ dhgnebdl_�k_dkmZevguo�klj_fe_gbc�h^gh�\k_]^Z��lZd�kdZaZlv��ijZ\bevgh�klhqdb�aj_gby�Y��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�^jm]h_�\uau\Z_l�hlihj�Y��Ke_^h\Zl_evgh��dhgnebdl�\hagbdZ_lf_`^m�Y b�k_dkmZevghklvx�M\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� Hq_gv� qZklh�� dh]^Z� ikbohZgZeba� kqblZe� ^mr_\guc� ijhp_kkj_amevlZlhf�jZ[hlu�k_dkmZevguo�\e_q_gbc��_]h�k k_j^blhc�\jZ`^_[ghklvx�mij_dZeb�\ lhf��qlhq_eh\_d�khklhbl�g_�lhevdh�ba�k_dkmZevghklb��qlh�\ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb�_klv�_s_�^jm]b_�\e_q_gby�bbgl_j_ku��djhf_�k_dkmZevguo��g_evay�©\k_ª�k\h^blv�d k_dkmZevghklb�b l��i��Hq_gv�ijbylgh�bghcjZa�[ulv�h^gh]h�fg_gby�kh�k\hbfb�ijhlb\gbdZfb��IkbohZgZeba�gbdh]^Z�g_�aZ[u\Ze��qlh�_klv�bg_k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby��hg�hibjZ_lky�gZ�q_ldh_�jZa^_e_gb_�k_dkmZevguo�\e_q_gbc�b \e_q_gbcY b�_s_�^h�\kydbo�\hajZ`_gbc�ml\_j`^Ze�g_�lh��qlh�g_\jhau�ihy\eyxlky�ba�k_dkmZevghklb��Zqlh� hgb� h[yaZgu� k\hbf� ijhbkoh`^_gb_f� dhgnebdlm� f_`^m� Y b� k_dkmZevghklvx�� Dh]^Z� hgbamqZ_l�jhev�k_dkmZevguo�\e_q_gbc�\ [he_agb�b \�`bagb��m g_]h�lZd`_�g_l�gbdZdh]h�\hafh`gh]h

Page 195: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fhlb\Z� hkiZjb\Zlv� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� b agZq_gb_� \e_q_gbc�Y�� Lhevdh� _]h� km^v[Z� lZdh\Z�� qlh[uaZgbfZlvky� k_dkmZevgufb� \e_q_gbyfb� \ i_j\mx� hq_j_^v�� ihlhfm� qlh� [eZ]h^Zjy� g_\jhaZfi_j_g_k_gby� hgb� klZeb� kZfufb� ^hklmigufb� ^ey� jZkkfhlj_gby� b ihlhfm� qlh� _fm� ijbrehkvbamqZlv�lh��q_f�^jm]b_�ij_g_[j_]eb�G_\_jgh� lZd`_� b lh�� qlh� ikbohZgZeba� \h\k_� g_� bgl_j_kh\Zeky� g_k_dkmZevghc� qZklvxebqghklb��DZd�jZa�jZa^_e_gb_�Y b�k_dkmZevghklb�iha\hey_l�gZf�k hkh[hc�ykghklvx�ihgylv��qlh�b\e_q_gby�Y ijhoh^yl�agZqbl_evguc�imlv�jZa\blby��jZa\blby��dhlhjh_�g_�kh\k_f�g_aZ\bkbfh�hleb[b^h�b g_�ijhbkoh^bl�[_a�h[jZlgh]h�\ha^_ckl\by�gZ�g_]h��IjZ\^Z��fu�]hjZa^h�om`_�agZ_f�hjZa\blbb�Y�� q_f� h jZa\blbb� eb[b^h�� ihlhfm� qlh� lhevdh� bamq_gb_� gZjpbkklbq_kdbo� g_\jhah\h[_sZ_l�^Zlv�ihgbfZgb_�kljmdlmju�Y��H^gZdh�m`_�bf__lky�aZkem`b\ZxsZy�\gbfZgby�ihiuldZN_j_gpb����������l_hj_lbq_kdb�ihkljhblv�klmi_gb�jZa\blby�Y b�ih�djZcg_c�f_j_�\ ^\mo�f_klZofu�ihemqbeb�l\_j^u_�lhqdb�hihju�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�km^blv�h[�wlhf�jZa\blbb��Fu�g_�^mfZ_f�qlh�eb[b^hagu_�bgl_j_ku�ebqghklb�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ�gZoh^ylky�\ ijhlb\hj_qbb�d __�bgl_j_kZfkZfhkhojZg_gby�� kdhj__� Y [m^_l� klj_fblvky� gZ� dZ`^hc� klmi_gb� hklZ\Zlvky� \ kh]eZkbb� kkhhl\_lkl\mxs_c� k_dkmZevghc� hj]ZgbaZpb_c� b ih^qbgylv� __ k_[_�� Kf_gZ� hl^_evguo� nZa� \jZa\blbb�eb[b^h�ijhbkoh^bl��\_jhylgh��ih�ij_^ibkZgghc�ijh]jZff_��gh�g_evay�g_�kh]eZkblvky�qlh�gZ�wlhl�ijhp_kk�fh`_l�hdZau\Zlv�\ebygb_�Y b�h^gh\j_f_ggh��ih�\b^bfhfm��ij_^mkfhlj_gba\_klguc�iZjZee_ebaf��hij_^_e_ggh_� khhl\_lkl\b_�nZa� jZa\blby�Y b� eb[b^h��gZjmr_gb_�`_wlh]h�khhl\_lkl\by�fh]eh�[u�klZlv�iZlh]_gguf�nZdlhjhf��K gZr_c�lhqdb�aj_gby�\Z`gh��dZd�Yhlghkblky� d ijhqghc�nbdkZpbb� k\h_]h� eb[b^h�gZ� dZdhc�lh� klmi_gb� _]h� jZa\blby��Hgh�fh`_l^himklblv� __ b� klZg_l� lh]^Z� \ khhl\_lkl\mxs_c� f_j_� ba\jZs_gguf� beb�� qlh� lh� `_� kZfh_�bgnZglbevguf��Gh�hgh�fh`_l�hlg_klbkv�d wlhfm�aZdj_ie_gbx�eb[b^h�b hljbpZl_evgh��b lh]^ZY ijbh[j_l_l�©\ul_kg_gb_ª�lZf��]^_�m eb[b^h�bf__lky�©nbdkZpbyª�LZdbf� h[jZahf�� fu� ihemqZ_f�� qlh� lj_lbc� nZdlhj� wlbheh]bb� g_\jhah\�� kdehgghklv� ddhgnebdlZf��lhqgh�lZd�`_�aZ\bkbl�hl�jZa\blby�Y��dZd�b hl�jZa\blby�eb[b^h��GZr_�ihgbfZgb_ijbqbg� g_\jhah\�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� m]em[behkv�� KgZqZeZ�� dZd� kZfh_� h[s__� mkeh\b_� ²\ugm`^_gguc� hldZa�� aZl_f� ²� nbdkZpby� eb[b^h�� dhlhjZy� l_kgbl� _]h� \ hij_^_e_gguogZijZ\e_gbyo��b��\�lj_lvbo��kdehgghklv�d dhgnebdlZf�\ j_amevlZl_�jZa\blby�Y��hl\_j]Zxs_]hlZdb_�ijhy\e_gby�eb[b^h��Iheh`_gb_�\_s_c��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��g_�lZd�m`�aZimlZgh�b g_�lZd�ljm^gh\ g_f�jZah[jZlvky��dZd�\Zf��\_jhylgh��ihdZaZehkv�\ oh^_�fhbo�jZkkm`^_gbc��Ih`Zemc��h^gZdh�wlh�_s_�g_�\k_��Gm`gh�ijb[Z\blv�_s_�dh_�qlh�gh\h_�b ^_lZebabjh\Zlv�m`_�ba\_klgh_�>ey�lh]h�qlh[u�ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv�\Zf�\ebygb_�jZa\blby�Y gZ�h[jZah\Zgb_�dhgnebdlh\�b\f_kl_� k l_f� gZ� ijbqbgm� g_\jhah\�� y ohl_e� [u� ijb\_klb� ijbf_j�� ohly� b kh\_jr_ggh\ufure_gguc��gh�gb \�dh_c�f_j_�g_�ebr_gguc�\_jhylghklb��KkueZykv�gZ� aZ]eZ\b_�dhf_^bbG_kljhcy�� y ^Zf� ijbf_jm� oZjZdl_jgh_� gZa\Zgb_� ©< ih^\Ze_� b gZ� i_j\hf� wlZ`_ª�� < ih^\Ze_`b\_l�^\hjgbd��gZ�i_j\hf�wlZ`_�²�^hfh\eZ^_e_p��[h]Zluc�b agZlguc�q_eh\_d��M h[hbo�_klv^_lb��b ij_^iheh`bf��qlh�^hq_jb�^hfh\eZ^_evpZ�jZaj_rZ_lky�[_a�ijbkfhljZ�b]jZlv�k j_[_gdhfijhe_lZjby��E_]dh�fh`_l�kemqblvky��qlh�b]ju�^_l_c�ijbfml�g_ijbklhcguc��l��_��k_dkmZevguc�oZjZdl_j�� qlh� hgb� [m^ml� b]jZlv� ©\ iZim� b fZfmª�� jZa]ey^u\Zlv� ^jm]� ^jm]Z� ijb� bglbfguohlijZ\e_gbyo�b jZa^jZ`Zlv�]_gblZebb��>_\hqdZ�^\hjgbdZ��dhlhjZy��g_kfhljy�gZ�k\hb�iylv�bebr_klv� e_l��fh]eZ� gZ[ex^Zlv� dh_�qlh� ba� k_dkmZevghc�`bagb� \ajhkeuo�� ih`Zemc�� ku]jZ_l� ijb

Page 196: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

wlhf� jhev� kh[eZagbl_evgbpu�� Wlbo� i_j_`b\Zgbc�� ^Z`_� _keb� hgb� ijh^he`Zxlky� g_^he]h�^hklZlhqgh�� qlh[u� Zdlb\babjh\Zlv� m h[hbo� ^_l_c� hij_^_e_ggu_� k_dkmZevgu_� bfimevku�dhlhju_� ihke_� ij_djZs_gby� kh\f_klguo� b]j� \ l_q_gb_� g_kdhevdbo� e_l� [m^ml� \ujZ`Zlvky� \fZklmj[Zpbb�� LZdh\h� h[s__�� dhg_qguc�`_� j_amevlZl� m h[hbo� ^_l_c� [m^_l� hq_gv� jZaebqguf�>hqv�^\hjgbdZ�[m^_l�ijh^he`Zlv�fZklmj[Zpbx�^h�gZklmie_gby�f_gkljmZpbc��aZl_f�[_a��ljm^Zij_djZlbl�__��g_kdhevdh�e_l�kimkly�gZc^_l�k_[_�ex[h\gbdZ�b��\hafh`gh��jh^bl�j_[_gdZ��ihc^_lih� lhfm� beb� ^jm]hfm� `bag_gghfm� imlb�� dhlhjuc�� fh`_l� [ulv�� ijb\_^_l� __ d� iheh`_gbxihimeyjghc� Zdljbku�� b aZdhgqbl� `bagv� ZjbklhdjZldhc�� <iheg_� \hafh`gh�� qlh� __ km^v[ZhdZ`_lky�f_g__�[e_klys_c��gh�\h�\kydhf�kemqZ_�hgZ�\uihegbl�k\h_�ij_^gZagZq_gb_�\ `bagb��g_ihkljZ^Z\�hl�ij_`^_\j_f_ggh]h�ijhy\e_gby�k\h_c�k_dkmZevghklb��k\h[h^gZy�hl�g_\jhaZ��>jm]h_^_eh� ²� ^hqv� ^hfh\eZ^_evpZ�� HgZ� _s_� j_[_gdhf� gZqg_l� ih^haj_\Zlv�� qlh� k^_eZeZ� qlh�lhkd\_jgh_��kdhjh��gh��\hafh`gh��ebrv�ihke_�ly`_ehc�[hjv[u�hldZ`_lky�hl�fZklmj[Zpbhg�gh]hm^h\hevkl\by� b�� g_kfhljy� gZ� wlh�� \ g_c� khojZgblky� dZdZy�lh� m^jmq_gghklv��Dh]^Z� \ ^_\bqvb]h^u�hgZ�kfh`_l�dh_�qlh�magZlv�h iheh\uo�kghr_gbyo��lh�hl\_jg_lky�hl�wlh]h�k g_h[tykgbfufhl\jZs_gb_f� b ij_^ihql_l� hklZlvky� \ g_\_^_gbb�� <_jhylgh�� l_i_jv� hgZ� mklmibl� \gh\vho\Zlb\r_fm� __ g_ij_h^hebfhfm� klj_fe_gbx� d fZklmj[Zpbb�� h dhlhjhf� g_� j_rZ_lkyih`Zeh\Zlvky��< ]h^u��dh]^Z�hgZ�fh]eZ�[u�ihgjZ\blvky�fm`qbg_�dZd�`_gsbgZ��m g__�ijhj\_lkyg_\jha�� dhlhjuc� ebrbl� __ [jZdZ� b `bag_gghc� gZ^_`^u�� ?keb� ijb� ihfhsb� ZgZebaZ� m^Zklkyihgylv� wlhl� g_\jha�� lh� hdZ`_lky�� qlh� wlZ� ohjhrh� \hkiblZggZy�� bgl_eeb]_glgZy� ^_\mrdZ� k\ukhdbfb� klj_fe_gbyfb� kh\_jr_ggh� \ul_kgbeZ� k_dkmZevgu_� qm\kl\Z�� Z hgb�� [_kkhagZl_evgh^ey�g__��aZkljyeb�gZ�`Zedbo�i_j_`b\Zgbyo�k ih^jm]hc�^_lkl\Z�ª�JZaebqb_� ^\mo� km^_[�� g_kfhljy� gZ� h^bgZdh\u_� i_j_`b\Zgby�� ijhbkoh^yl� hl� lh]h�� qlh�Yh^ghc�^_\mrdb�ijh^_eZeh�jZa\blb_��g_�bf_\r__�f_klZ�m ^jm]hc��>hq_jb�^\hjgbdZ�k_dkmZevgZy^_yl_evghklv�dZaZeZkv�klhev�`_�_kl_kl\_gghc�b g_�\uau\Zxs_c�khfg_gby��dZd�\ ^_lkl\_��>hqv^hfh\eZ^_evpZ� bkiulZeZ� \ha^_ckl\b_� \hkiblZgby� b ijbgyeZ� _]h� lj_[h\Zgby�� ?_� Y baij_^hklZ\e_gguo� _fm� ih[m`^_gbc� kha^Zeh� k_[_� b^_Zeu�`_gkdhc� qbklhlu� b g_ihjhqghklb�� kdhlhjufb�g_kh\f_klbfZ� k_dkmZevgZy� ^_yl_evghklv�� __ bgl_ee_dlmZevgh_� jZa\blb_� kgbabeh� __bgl_j_k� d `_gkdhc� jheb�� ij_^gZagZq_gghc� ^ey� g__�� ;eZ]h^Zjy� wlhfm� [he__� \ukhdhfmfhjZevghfm�b bgl_ee_dlmZevghfm�jZa\blbx�k\h_]h�Y hgZ�ihiZeZ�\ dhgnebdl�k lj_[h\Zgbyfbk\h_c�k_dkmZevghklb�K_]h^gy�y ohqm�hklZgh\blvky�_s_�gZ�h^ghf�imgdl_�jZa\blby�Y��dZd�ba�aZ�ba\_klguo�^Ze_dboi_jki_dlb\�� lZd�b ihlhfm��qlh�bf_ggh� lh��h q_f�[m^_l�j_qv��hijZ\^u\Z_l�baex[e_ggh_�gZfb�j_adh_� b g_� kZfh� kh[hc� jZamf_xs__ky� hl^_e_gb_� \e_q_gbc� Y hl� k_dkmZevguo� \e_q_gbc�� <hp_gd_�h[hbo�jZa\blbb��Y b�eb[b^h��fu�^he`gu�\u^\bgmlv�gZ�i_j\uc�ieZg�lhqdm�aj_gby��gZdhlhjmx� ^h� kbo� ihj� g_� qZklh� h[jZsZeb� \gbfZgb_�� H[Z� hgb� ij_^klZ\eyxl� kh[hc� \ hkgh\_mgZke_^h\Zggu_�� khdjZs_ggu_� ih\lhj_gby� jZa\blby�� ijhc^_ggh]h� \k_f� q_eh\_q_kl\hf� \l_q_gb_�hq_gv� ^ebl_evgh]h� \j_f_gb��gZqbgZy� k i_j\h[ulguo� \j_f_g ��Fg_� dZ`_lky�� qlh� wlhnbeh]_g_lbq_kdh_�ijhbkoh`^_gb_�jZa\blby�eb[b^h�\iheg_�hq_\b^gh��Ij_^klZ\vl_�k_[_��qlh�mh^gh]h�deZkkZ�`b\hlguo�]_gblZevguc�ZiiZjZl�gZoh^blky�\ l_kg_cr_c�k\yab�k jlhf��m ^jm]h]hg_hl^_ebf� hl� ZiiZjZlZ� \u^_e_gby�� m lj_lv_]h� k\yaZg� k hj]ZgZfb� ^\b`_gby�� \k_� wlb� ^Zggu_ij_djZkgh�hibkZgu� \ p_gghc� dgb]_�<��;zevr_� �����²�������M `b\hlguo�fh`gh� \b^_lv�� lZdkdZaZlv�� aZklu\rbfb� \ k_dkmZevghc� hj]ZgbaZpbb� \k_� \b^u� ba\jZs_gbc�� Gh� m q_eh\_dZ

Page 197: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

nbeh]_g_lbq_kdh_�jZkkfhlj_gb_�hlqZklb�aZkehgy_lky�l_f�h[klhyl_evkl\hf��qlh�lh��qlh�y\ey_lky�ih� kms_kl\m�� mgZke_^h\Zgguf�� \gh\v� ijbh[j_lZ_lky� \ bg^b\b^mZevghf� jZa\blbb� b \_jhylghihlhfm�� qlh� l_� `_� kZfu_� h[klhyl_evkl\Z�� dhlhju_� \ k\h_� \j_fy� \ua\Zeb� g_h[oh^bfhklvijbh[j_l_gby� gh\uo� k\hckl\�� ijh^he`Zxl� kms_kl\h\Zlv� b ^_ckl\h\Zlv� gZ� dZ`^h]h� \hl^_evghklb�� Y [u� kdZaZe�� qlh� \ k\h_� \j_fy� hgb� hdZaZeb� l\hjq_kdh_� \ebygb_�� l_i_jv� `_\uau\Zxl�d `bagb�m`_�kha^Zggh_��Djhf_�lh]h��g_khfg_ggh��qlh�oh^�ij_^gZq_jlZggh]h�jZa\blbym dZ`^h]h� \ hl^_evghklb�fh`_l� [ulv� gZjmr_g� b baf_g_g� gh\ufb� \ebygbyfb� ba\g_��Gh� fuagZ_f�kbem��dhlhjZy�\ugm^beZ�q_eh\_q_kl\h�gZ�lZdh_�jZa\blb_�b k_]h^gy�ijh^he`Z_l�hdZau\Zlvk\h_�^Z\e_gb_�\ lhf�`_�gZijZ\e_gbb��wlh�hiylv�lZdb�\ugm`^_gguc�j_Zevghklvx�hldZa�beb��_kebgZau\Zlv� __ gZklhysbf� bf_g_f�� `bag_ggZy� g_h[oh^bfhklv� �$ZSW7@��� HgZ� [ueZ� kljh]hc\hkiblZl_evgbp_c� b fgh]h_� k^_eZeZ� ba� gZk��G_\jhlbdb� hlghkylky� d l_f� ^_lyf�� dhlhjuf� wlZkljh]hklv�ijbg_keZ�]hjvdb_�ieh^u��gh�lZdhc�jbkd�_klv�\ ex[hf�\hkiblZgbb��<ijhq_f��^ZggZyhp_gdZ� `bag_gghc� g_h[oh^bfhklb� dZd� ^\b]Zl_ey� jZa\blby� g_� ^he`gZ� \hkklZgZ\eb\Zlv� gZkijhlb\�agZq_gby�©\gmlj_ggbo�l_g^_gpbc�jZa\blbyª��_keb�lZdh\u_�fh`gh�^hdZaZlv�<_kvfZ�^hklhcgh�\gbfZgby�lh��qlh�k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby�b bgklbgdlu�kZfhkhojZg_gby�g_h^bgZdh\uf� h[jZahf� \_^ml� k_[y� ih� hlghr_gbx� d j_Zevghc� g_h[oh^bfhklb�� BgklbgdlukZfhkhojZg_gby�b \k_��qlh�k gbfb�k\yaZgh��e_]q_�ih^^Zxlky�\hkiblZgbx��hgb�jZgh�gZmqZxlkyih^qbgylvky�g_h[oh^bfhklb�b gZijZ\eylv�k\h_�jZa\blb_�ih�mdZaZgbyf�j_Zevghklb��Wlh�ihgylgh�ihlhfm�qlh�hgb�g_�fh]ml�ijbh[j_klb�k_[_�gm`gu_�h[t_dlu�gbdZdbf�^jm]bf�kihkh[hf��[_a�wlboh[t_dlh\�bg^b\b^mmf�^he`_g�ih]b[gmlv��K_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby�ljm^g__�\hkiblZlv��ihlhfm�qlh\gZqZe_�m gbo�g_l�g_h[oh^bfhklb�\ h[t_dl_��LZd�dZd�hgb�ijbkh_^bgyxlky�d ^jm]bf�nmgdpbyfl_eZ��dZd�[u�iZjZablbjmy��b Zmlhwjhlbq_kdb�m^h\e_l\hjyxlky�kh[kl\_gguf� l_ehf�� lh�kgZqZeZmkdhevaZxl�ba�ih^�\hkiblZl_evgh]h�\ebygby�j_Zevghc�g_h[oh^bfhklb�b m�[hevrbgkl\Z�ex^_cml\_j`^Zxl�wlhl�oZjZdl_j�k\h_\heby��g_^hklmighklb�\ebygbx�\hkiblZgby��lh��qlh�fu�gZau\Z_f©g_jZamfghklvxª�� \ dZdhf�lh� hlghr_gbb� \ l_q_gb_� \k_c� `bagb�� B ih^\_j`_gghklb\hkiblZlZl_evguf� \ha^_ckl\byf� fheh^hc� ebqghklb�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� ijboh^bl� dhg_p�� dh]^Z� __k_dkmZevgu_� ihlj_[ghklb� hdhgqZl_evgh� ijhkuiZxlky�� Wlh� ba\_klgh� \hkiblZl_eyf�� b hgb^_ckl\mxl� khh[jZagh� wlhfm�� gh�� fh`_l� [ulv�� [eZ]h^Zjy� j_amevlZlZf�� ihemq_gguf� \ikbohZgZeba_��bo�m^Zklky�kdehgblv�d lhfm��qlh[u�i_j_g_klb� ]eZ\guc�Zdp_gl�gZ�\hkiblZgb_�\i_j\u_� ^_lkdb_� ]h^u�� gZqbgZy� k feZ^_gq_kdh]h� \hajZklZ�� FZe_gvdbc� q_eh\_d� qZklh� m`_� dq_l\_jlhfm�beb�iylhfm�]h^m�[u\Z_l�aZdhgq_g�b lhevdh�ihkl_i_ggh�ijhy\ey_l�lh��qlh�\ g_f�m`_aZeh`_gh�Qlh[u� iheghklvx� hp_gblv� agZq_gb_� mdZaZggh]h� jZaebqby� f_`^m� h[_bfb� ]jmiiZfb\e_q_gbc�� fu� ^he`gu� gZqZlv� ba^Ze_dZ� b ijb\_klb� h^gh� ba� l_o� jZkkm`^_gbc�� dhlhjh_aZkem`b\Z_l�gZa\Zgby�wdhghfbq_kdh]h��L_f�kZfuf�fu�\klmiZ_f�\ h^gm�ba�kZfuo�\Z`guo��gh��dkh`Ze_gbx��b kZfuo� l_fguo� h[eZkl_c�ikbohZgZebaZ��Fu� klZ\bf� \hijhk��fh`gh� eb� \ jZ[hl_gZr_]h�^mr_\gh]h�ZiiZjZlZ�gZclb� ]eZ\gmx�p_ev��b hl\_qZ_f�gZ�g_]h�\ i_j\hf�ijb[eb`_gbb�qlh�wlZ�p_ev�khklhbl�\ ihemq_gbb�m^h\hevkl\by��DZ`_lky��qlh�\ky�gZrZ�^mr_\gZy�^_yl_evghklvgZijZ\e_gZ� gZ� lh�� qlh[u� ihemqZlv� m^h\hevkl\b_� b ba[_]Zlv� g_m^h\hevkl\by�� qlh� hgZZ\lhfZlbq_kdb�j_]mebjm_lky�ijbgpbihf�m^h\hevkl\by� �/XVWSULQ]LS���;hevr_�\k_]h�gZ�k\_l_�fuohl_eb� [u� agZlv�� dZdh\u� mkeh\by� \hagbdgh\_gby� m^h\hevkl\by� b g_m^h\hevkl\by�� gh� bf_gghwlh]h�lh� gZf� b g_� o\ZlZ_l�� K m\_j_gghklvx� fh`gh� ml\_j`^Zlv� lhevdh� lh�� qlh� m^h\hevkl\b_

Page 198: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dZdbf�lh�h[jZahf�k\yaZgh�k mf_gvr_gb_f��kgb`_gb_f�beb�m]ZkZgb_f�bf_xs_]hky�\ ^mr_\ghfZiiZjZl_� dhebq_kl\Z� jZa^jZ`_gby�� Z g_m^h\hevkl\b_� ²� k _]h� m\_ebq_gb_f�� Bkke_^h\Zgb_kZfh]h� bgl_gkb\gh]h� m^h\hevkl\by�� ^hklmigh]h� q_eh\_dm�²� gZkeZ`^_gby� ijb� kh\_jr_gbbiheh\h]h� ZdlZ� ²� g_� hklZ\ey_l� khfg_gby� \ wlhf� imgdl_�� LZd� dZd� ijb� lZdbo� ijhp_kkZom^h\hevkl\by� j_qv� b^_l� h km^v[_� dhebq_kl\Z� ^mr_\gh]h� \ha[m`^_gby�� beb� wg_j]bb�� lhjZkkm`^_gby� lZdh]h� jh^Z� fu� gZau\Z_f� wdhghfbq_kdbfb��Fu� aZf_qZ_f�� qlh� fh`_f� hibkZlvaZ^Zqm�b nmgdpbx�^mr_\gh]h� ZiiZjZlZ� lZd`_�bgZq_�b \�[he__�h[s_f� \b^_��q_f� \u^\b]Zy�gZi_j\uc�ieZg�ihemq_gb_�m^h\hevkl\by��Fu�fh`_f�kdZaZlv��qlh�^mr_\guc�ZiiZjZl�kem`bl�p_ebh^he_lv�ihklmiZxsb_�\ g_]h�ba\g_�b bagmljb�jZa^jZ`_gby�b \ha[m`^_gby�b hk\h[h^blvky�hlgbo��< k_dkmZevguo�\e_q_gbyo�kh\_jr_ggh�ykgh�ijh]ey^u\Z_l�lh��qlh�hgb�dZd�\ gZqZe_��lZd�b \dhgp_� k\h_]h� jZa\blby� klj_fylky� d ihemq_gbx� m^h\hevkl\by�� hgb� khojZgyxl� wlmi_j\hgZqZevgmx� nmgdpbx� [_a� baf_g_gby�� D lhfm� `_� kZfhfm� klj_fylky� kgZqZeZ� b ^jm]b_\e_q_gby� Y�� Gh� ih^� \ebygb_f� gZklZ\gbpu�g_h[oh^bfhklb� \e_q_gby� Y [ukljh� gZmqZxlkyaZf_gylv� ijbgpbi� m^h\hevkl\by� dZdhc�eb[h� fh^bnbdZpb_c�� AZ^ZqZ� ij_^hl\jZsZlvg_m^h\hevkl\b_�klZ\blky�^ey�gbo�ihqlb�gZjZ\g_�k aZ^Zq_c�ihemq_�^by�m^h\hevkl\by��Y magZ_l�qlh�g_ba[_`gh�ijb^_lky�hldZaZlvky�hl�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby��hleh`blv�ihemq_gb_m^h\hevkl\by��i_j_`blv�g_fgh]h�g_m^h\hevkl\by��Z hl�hij_^_e_gguo�bklhqgbdh\�gZkeZ`^_gby\hh[s_�hldZaZlvky��<hkiblZggh_�lZdbf�h[jZahf�Y klZeh�©jZamfgufª��hgh�g_�iha\hey_l�[hevr_ijbgpbim� m^h\hevkl\by� \eZ^_lv� kh[hc�� Z ke_^m_l� ijbgpbim� j_Zevghklb� �5HDOLWDWVSULQ]LS��dhlhjuc��\ kmsghklb��lh`_�ohq_l�ihemqblv�m^h\hevkl\b_��ohly�b hlkjhq_ggh_�b mf_gvr_ggh_�gh�aZlh�gZ^_`gh_�[eZ]h^Zjy�mq_lm�j_Zevghklb�I_j_oh^�hl�ijbgpbiZ�m^h\hevkl\by�d ijbgpbim�j_Zevghklb�y\ey_lky�h^gbf�ba�\Z`g_crbomki_oh\� \ jZa\blbb� Y�� Fu� m`_� agZ_f�� qlh� k_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gby� iha^gh� b ebrv� g_ohlyijhoh^yl�wlhl�wlZi�jZa\blby�Y��Z iha`_�fu�mkeurbf��dZdb_�ihke_^kl\by�bf__l�^ey�q_eh\_dZ�lh�qlh�_]h�k_dkmZevghklv�^h\hevkl\m_lky�lZdbf�g_ijhqgu_�hlghr_gb_f�d \g_rg_c�j_Zevghklb��B \aZdexq_gb_� ²� _s_� h^gh� hlghkys__ky� kx^Z� aZf_qZgb_�� ?keb� Y q_eh\_dZ� bf__l� bklhjbxjZa\blby��dZd�eb[b^h��lh�\u�g_�m^b\bl_kv��mkeurZ\��qlh�[u\Zxl�b ©j_]j_kkbb�Yª��b aZohlbl_magZlv�� dZdmx� jhev� wlhl� \ha\jZl� Y gZ� [he__� jZggb_� nZau� jZa\blby� fh`_l� b]jZlv� \g_\jhlbq_kdbo�aZ[he_\Zgbyo�><:>P:LV�LJ?LVY�E?DPBYImlb�h[jZah\Zgby�kbfilhfh\M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��>ey�g_ki_pbZebklZ�kmsghklv�[he_agb�khklZ\eyxl�kbfilhfu�\ua^hjh\e_gb_�� dZd� hg� kqblZ_l�²� mkljZg_gb_� kbfilhfh\�� <jZq� `_� ijbagZ_l� kms_kl\_ggufhlebqb_� kbfilhfh\� hl� [he_agb� b kqblZ_l�� qlh� mkljZg_gb_� kbfilhfh\� _s_� g_� y\ey_lkybae_q_gb_f�[he_agb��Gh�qlh�j_Zevgh]h�hklZ_lky�hl�[he_agb�ihke_�mkljZg_gby�kbfilhfh\�²�lhwlh� ebrv� kihkh[ghklv� h[jZah\u\Zlv� gh\u_��>Z\Zcl_� ihwlhfm� \klZg_f� ihdZ� gZ� lhqdm� aj_gbyg_ki_pbZebklZ� b [m^_f� kqblZlv�� qlh� ijhgbdgh\_gb_� \ kmlv� kbfilhfh\� hagZqZ_l� ihgbfZgb_[he_agb�

Page 199: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Kbfilhfu�²�fu�]h\hjbf�a^_kv��jZamf__lky��h ikbobq_kdbo��beb�ikboh]_gguo��kbfilhfZob ikbobq_kdhf�aZ[he_\Zgbb�²�ij_^klZ\eyxl�kh[hc�\j_^gu_�^ey�\k_c�`bagb�beb��ih�djZcg_cf_j_�� [_kihe_agu_� Zdlu�� gZ� dhlhju_� ebph�� kljZ^Zxs__� bfb�� qZklh� `Zem_lky� dZd� gZ\ugm`^_ggu_� b k\yaZggu_� ^ey� g_]h� k g_ijbylghklyfb� beb� kljZ^Zgbyfb�� Bo� ]eZ\guc� \j_^aZdexqZ_lky� \ ^mr_\guo� aZljZlZo�� dhlhjuo� klhyl� hgb� kZfb�� Z \� ^Zevg_cr_f� \ aZljZlZo�g_h[oh^bfuo� ^ey� bo� ij_h^he_gby��Ijb� bgl_gkb\ghf� h[jZah\Zgbb� kbfilhfh\� h[Z� \b^Z� wlboaZljZl�fh]ml�ijb\_klb�D qj_a\uqZcghfm�h[_^g_gbx�ebqghklb�\ hlghr_gbb�gZoh^ys_cky�\ __jZkihjy`_gbb�^mr_\ghc�wg_j]bb�b l_f�kZfuf�d __�[_kihfhsghklb�ijb�j_r_gbb�\k_o�\Z`guo`bag_gguo� aZ^Zq�� LZd� dZd� wlhl� j_amevlZl� aZ\bkbl� ]eZ\guf� h[jZahf� hl� dhebq_kl\ZaZlj_[h\Zgghc� lZdbf� h[jZahf� wg_j]bb�� lh� \u� e_]dh� ihcf_l_�� qlh� ©[ulv� [hevgufª� ²� \kmsghklb�� ijZdlbq_kdh_� ihgylb_��Gh� _keb� \u� \klZg_l_� gZ� l_hj_lbq_kdmx� lhqdm� aj_gby� b g_[m^_l_�h[jZsZlv�\gbfZgby�gZ�wlb�dhebq_kl\Z��lh�e_]dh�fh`_l_�kdZaZlv��qlh�\k_�fu�[hevgu��l��_�g_\jhlbqgu��lZd�dZd�mkeh\by�^ey�h[jZah\Zgby�kbfilhfh\�fh`gh�h[gZjm`blv�b m�ghjfZevguoex^_c�H g_\jhlbq_kdbo�kbfilhfZo�gZf�m`_�ba\_klgh��qlh�hgb�y\eyxlky�j_amevlZlhf�dhgnebdlZ�\hagbdZxs_]h�ba�aZ�gh\h]h�\b^Z�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�eb[b^h��H[_�jZahr_^rb_ky�[ueh�kbeu�kgh\Z\klj_qZxlky� \ kbfilhf_�� dZd� [m^lh� ijbfbjyxlky� [eZ]h^Zjy� dhfijhfbkkm� ²� h[jZah\Zgbxkbfilhfh\��Ihwlhfm� kbfilhf� lZd� mklhcqb\�²� hg� ih^^_j`b\Z_lky� k ^\mo� klhjhg��Fu� agZ_flZd`_�� qlh� h^ghc� ba� ^\mo� klhjhg� dhgnebdlZ� y\ey_lky� g_m^h\e_l\hj_ggh_�� hl\_j]gmlh_j_Zevghklvx� eb[b^h�� \ugm`^_ggh_� l_i_jv� bkdZlv� ^jm]bo� iml_c� ^ey� k\h_]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�?keb�j_Zevghklv�hklZ_lky�g_mfhebfhc��^Z`_�dh]^Z�eb[b^h�]hlh\h�kh]eZkblvky�gZ�^jm]hc�h[t_dl\f_klh�aZij_lgh]h��lh�hgh�\ugm`^_gh�\ dhgp_�dhgph\�\klZlv�gZ�imlv�j_]j_kkbb�b klj_fblvky�dm^h\e_l\hj_gbx�\ jZfdZo�h^ghc�ba�m`_�ij_h^he_gguo�hj]ZgbaZpbc�beb�[eZ]h^Zjy�h^ghfm�bajZg__�hklZ\e_gguo�h[t_dlh\��GZ�imklv�j_]j_kkbb�eb[b^h�m\e_dZ_l�nbdkZpby��dhlhjZy�hklZ\beZ_]h�gZ�wlbo�mqZkldZo�_]h�jZa\blby�Lml�imlb�� \_^msb_� d ba\jZs_gbx�b d�g_\jham�� j_adh� jZkoh^ylky��?keb� wlb� j_]j_kkbb�g_\uau\Zxl� \hajZ`_gbc� kh� klhjhgu�Y�� lh� ^_eh�b g_� ^hoh^bl� ^h�g_\jhaZ�� Z eb[b^h�^h[b\Z_lkydZdh]h�gb[m^v�j_Zevgh]h��ohly�m`_�b g_ghjfZevgh]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby��?keb�`_�Y��bf_xs__�\k\h_f�jZkihjy`_gbb�g_�lhevdh�khagZgb_��gh�b ^hklmi�d fhlhjghc�bgg_j\Zpbb�b l_f�kZfuf�dj_ZebaZpbb�^mr_\guo�klj_fe_gbc��g_� kh]eZkgh� k wlbfb�j_]j_kkbyfb�� lh� kha^Z_lky�dhgnebdl�Eb[b^h�dZd�[u�hlj_aZgh�b ^he`gh�ihiulZlvky�hlklmiblv�dm^Z�lh��]^_�gZc^_l�hllhd�^ey�k\h_cwg_j]bb�ih�lj_[h\Zgbx�ijbgpbiZ�m^h\hevkl\by��Hgh�^he`gh�\uclb�ba�ih^�\eZklb�Y��Gh�lZdh_hlklmie_gb_� _fm� ij_^hklZ\eyxl� nbdkZpbb� gZ� _]h� imlb� jZa\blby�� ijhoh^bfhf� l_i_jvj_]j_kkb\gh��ijhlb\�dhlhjuo�Y aZsbsZehkv�\ k\h_�\j_fy�\ul_kg_gbyfb��AZgbfZy�\ h[jZlghf^\b`_gbb� wlb� \ul_kg_ggu_� ihabpbb�� eb[b^h� \uoh^bl� ba�ih^� \eZklb� Y b� _]h� aZdhgh\�hldZau\Zykv� ijb� wlhf� lZd`_� hl� \k_]h� ihemq_ggh]h� ih^� \ebygb_f� Y \hkiblZgby�� Hgh� [uehihkemrgh�� ihdZ� gZ^_yehkv� gZ� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�� ih^� ^\hcguf� ]g_lhf� \gmlj_gg_� b \g_rg_\ugm`^_ggh]h� hldZaZ� hgh� klZgh\blky� g_ihdhjguf� b \kihfbgZ_l� ij_`gb_� emqrb_� \j_f_gZ�LZdh\� _]h�� ih� kmlb� g_baf_ggu_�� oZjZdl_j��Ij_^klZ\e_gby�� dhlhju_� eb[b^h� l_i_jv� aZihegy_lk\h_c� wg_j]b_c�� ijbgZ^e_`Zl� kbkl_f_� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� b ih^qbgyxlky� \hafh`guf� \ g_fijhp_kkZf�� \ qZklghklb� k]ms_gbx� b kf_s_gbx�� LZd� \hagbdZxl� mkeh\by�� kh\_jr_gghZgZeh]bqgu_� mkeh\byf� h[jZah\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc�� Ih^h[gh� lhfm� dZd� keh`b\r_fmky� \

Page 200: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[_kkhagZl_evghf�kh[kl\_gghfm��HLJHQWOL�FKH��kgh\b^_gbx��ij_^klZ\eyxs_fm�kh[hc�bkiheg_gb_[_kkhagZl_evghc�`_eZgghc�nZglZabb��ijboh^bl�gZ�ihfhsv�dZdZy�lh�qZklv��ij_^��khagZl_evghc^_yl_evghklb��hkms_kl\eyxsZy�p_gamjm�b ^himkdZxsZy�ihke_�m^h\e_l\hj_gby� __� lj_[h\Zgbch[jZah\Zgb_� y\gh]h� kgh\b^_gby� \ \b^_� dhfijhfbkkZ�� lZd� b ij_^klZ\bl_eb� eb[b^h� \[_kkhagZl_evghf� ^he`gu� kqblZlvky� k kbehc� ij_^khagZl_evgh]h�Y��<hajZ`_gb_�� ih^gy\r__kyijhlb\�eb[b^h�\ Y��ijbgbfZ_l�nhjfm�©ijhlb\h^_ckl\byª��*HJHQEHVHW]XQJ� ��\ugm`^Zy�\u[jZlvlZdh_� \ujZ`_gb_�� dhlhjh_� fh`_l� klZlv� h^gh\j_f_ggh� _]h� kh[kl\_gguf� \ujZ`_gb_f�� LZd\hagbdZ_l� kbfilhf��dZd�fgh]hdjZlgh�bkdZ`_ggh_�ijhba\h^gh_�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h� eb[b^hagh]hbkiheg_gby� `_eZgby�� bkdmkgh� \u[jZggZy� ^\mkfuke_gghklv� k ^\mfy� kh\_jr_gghijhlb\hj_qZsbfb� ^jm]� ^jm]m� agZq_gbyfb�� Lhevdh� \ wlhf� ihke_^g_f� imgdl_� fh`gh� m\b^_lvjZaebqb_� f_`^m� h[jZah\Zgb_f� kgh\b^_gby� b h[jZah\Zgb_f� kbfilhfZ�� ihlhfm� qlhij_^khagZl_evgZy�p_ev�ijb�h[jZah\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gby�aZdexqZ_lky�ebrv�\ lhf��qlh[u�khojZgblvkhg��g_� ijhimklblv� \ khagZgb_� gbq_]h�� qlh�fh]eh� [u� _]h� gZjmrblv�� b g_�gZklZb\Z_l�gZ� lhf�qlh[u� j_adh� hl\_lblv� [_kkhagZl_evghfm� `_eZgbx�� g_l�� gZijhlb\�� HgZ� fh`_l� [ulv� [he__lhe_jZglghc�� lZd� dZd� iheh`_gb_� kiys_]h� \gmrZ_l� f_gvr_� hiZk_gbc�� <uoh^� \ j_ZevghklvaZdjul�m`_�kZfbf�khklhygb_f�kgZ�<u� \b^bl_�� qlh� hlklmie_gb_� eb[b^h� \ mkeh\byo� dhgnebdlZ� klZeh� \hafh`guf� [eZ]h^ZjygZebqbx�nbdkZpbc��J_]j_kkb\gh_�aZiheg_gb_�wlbo�nbdkZpbc�eb[b^h�\_^_l�d h[oh^m�\ul_kg_gbyb \u\h^m� ²� beb� m^h\e_l\hj_gbx� ²� eb[b^h�� ijb� dhlhjhf� khojZgyxlky� dhfijhfbkkgu_mkeh\by��H[oh^guf�iml_f�q_j_a�[_kkhagZl_evgh_�b ij_`gb_�nbdkZpbb�eb[b^h�gZdhg_p�m^Z_lky^h[blvky� j_Zevgh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� ohly� b qj_a\uqZcgh� h]jZgbq_ggh]h� b _^\Z� aZf_lgh]h�Iha\hevl_�fg_� ^h[Z\blv� ih� ih\h^m� wlh]h� hdhgqZl_evgh]h� bkoh^Z� ^\Z� aZf_qZgby��<h�i_j\uo�h[jZlbl_�\gbfZgb_��dZd�l_kgh� a^_kv�hdZau\Zxlky�k\yaZgu�eb[b^h�b [_kkhagZl_evgh_��k h^ghcklhjhgu��b Y��khagZgb_�b j_Zevghklv�²�k ^jm]hc��ohly�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ�hgb�\h\k_�g_�khklZ\eyxlh^gh� p_eh_�� b ijbfbl_� d k\_^_gbx� ^Ze__� fh_� khh[s_gb_�� qlh� \k_� kdZaZggh_� a^_kv� bjZkkfZljb\Z_fh_�\ ^Zevg_cr_f�hlghkblky�lhevdh�d h[jZah\Zgbx�kbfilhfh\�ijb�bkl_jbq_kdhfg_\jha_�=^_�`_�eb[b^h�gZoh^bl�l_�nbdkZpbb��\ dhlhjuo�hgh�gm`^Z_lky�^ey�ijhju\Z�\ul_kg_ggh]h"< ijhy\e_gbyo� b i_j_`b\Zgbyo� bgnZglbevghc� k_dkmZevghklb�� \ hklZ\e_gguo� qZklguoklj_fe_gbyo� b \� h[t_dlZo� i_jbh^Z� ^_lkl\Z�� hl� dhlhjuo� hgh� hldZaZehkv�� D gbf�lh� eb[b^h� b\ha\jZsZ_lky�hiylv��AgZq_gb_�wlh]h�i_jbh^Z�^_lkl\Z�^\hydh_��k h^ghc�klhjhgu��\ g_f�kgZqZeZijhy\eyxlky� gZijZ\e_gghklb� \e_q_gbc�� dhlhju_� j_[_ghd� bf__l� \ k\hbo� \jh`^_gguoij_^jZkiheh`_gbyo�� Z \h�\lhjuo�� Zdlb\babjmxlky� ^jm]b_� _]h� \e_q_gby�� jZa[m`_ggu_\g_rgbfb�\ha^_ckl\byfb��kemqZcgufb�i_j_`b\Zgbyfb�Y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� fu�� g_khfg_ggh�� bf__f� ijZ\h� gZ� lZdh_� jZa^_e_gb_�� Ijhy\e_gb_\jh`^_gghc� ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklb� g_� ih^e_`bl� gbdZdhfm� djblbq_kdhfm� khfg_gbx�� ghZgZeblbq_kdbc� hiul� \ugm`^Z_l� gZk� ^himklblv�� qlh� qbklh� kemqZcgu_� i_j_`b\Zgby� ^_lkl\Z� \khklhygbb�hklZ\blv�nbdkZpbb�eb[b^h��B y�g_�\b`m�\ wlhf�gbdZdbo�l_hj_lbq_kdbo�aZljm^g_gbc�DhgklblmpbhgZevgu_� ij_^jZkiheh`_gby�� g_khfg_ggh�� y\eyxlky� ihke_^kl\byfb� i_j_`b\Zgbc^Ze_dbo�ij_^dh\��hgb�lh`_�[ueb�dh]^Z�lh�ijb� �;md\���©dhgljaZiheg_gbyª�>wg_j]b_c@��< Zg]ebckdhf�yaud_�wd\b\Ze_glhf�y\ey_lky�©ZglbdZl_dkbkª���Ijbf_q�

Page 201: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

j_^��i_j_\h^Z�h[j_l_gu��[_a�lZdh]h�ijbh[j_l_gby�g_�[ueh�[u�gZke_^kl\_gghklb��B jZa\_�fukebfh��qlhlZdh_� \_^ms__� d gZke_^h\Zgbx� ijbh[j_l_gb_� ij_djZlblky� bf_ggh� m jZkkfZljb\Z_fh]h� gZfbihdhe_gby"�Ihwlhfm�g_�ke_^m_l��dZd�wlh�qZklh�kemqZ_lky��iheghklvx�b]ghjbjh\Zlv�agZqbfhklvbgnZglbevguo� i_j_`b\Zgbc� ih� kjZ\g_gbx� kh� agZqbfhklvx� i_j_`b\Zgbc� ij_^dh\� bkh[kl\_gghc� aj_ehklb�� Z�� gZijhlb\�� ^Zlv� bf� hkh[mx� hp_gdm��Hgb� bf_xl� l_f� [he__� ly`_eu_ihke_^kl\by�� qlh� ihiZ^Zxl� gZ� \j_fy� g_aZ\_jr_ggh]h� jZa\blby� b [eZ]h^Zjy� bf_ggh� wlhfmh[klhyl_evkl\m� kihkh[gu� ^_ckl\h\Zlv� ljZ\fZlbq_kdb�� JZ[hlu� ih� f_oZgbd_� jZa\blby� Jm�� b^jm]bo�ihdZaZeb��qlh�mdhe�\ aZjh^ur_\mx�ldZgv��gZoh^ysmxky�\ klZ^bb�^_e_gby�de_lhd��bf__lke_^kl\b_f� ly`_eh_� gZjmr_gb_� jZa\blby�� LZdh_� `_� jZg_gb_�� ijbqbg_ggh_� ebqbgd_� bebjZa\b\r_fmky�`b\hlghfm��i_j_g_kehkv�[u�[_a�\j_^Z�NbdkZpby� eb[b^h� \ajhkeh]h�� \\_^_ggZy� gZfb� \ wlbheh]bq_kdh_� mjZ\g_gb_� g_\jhah\� \dZq_kl\_�ij_^klZ\bl_ey�dhgklblmpbhgZevgh]h�nZdlhjZ��jZkiZ^Z_lky��lZdbf�h[jZahf��^ey�gZk�gZ^\Z�dhfihg_glZ��gZ�mgZke_^h\Zggh_�ij_^jZkiheh`_gb_�b gZ�ij_^jZkiheh`_gb_��ijbh[j_l_ggh_\ jZgg_f�^_lkl\_��Fu�agZ_f��qlh�ko_fZ�gZ\_jgydZ�\uah\_l�kbfiZlbx�h[mqZxs_]hky��ihwlhfmij_^klZ\bf�wlb�hlghr_gby�\ ko_f_�IjbqbgZ�g_\jhaZ �Ij_^jZkiheh`_gb_�[eZ]h^Zjy �� � �KemqZcgh_�i_j_`b\Zgb_�nbdkZpbbeb[b^h �ljZ\fZlbq_kdh_��_�������� >\ajhkeh]h@BgnZglbevgh_�i_j_`b\Zgb_K_dkmZevgZy�dhgklblmpby��^hbklhjbq_kdh_�i_j_`b\Zgb_�GZke_^kl\_ggZy� k_dkmZevgZy� dhgklblmpby� ij_^hklZ\ey_l� gZf� [hevrh_� jZaghh[jZab_ij_^jZkiheh`_gbc� \ aZ\bkbfhklb� hl� lh]h�� dZdhc� aZeh`_gghc� kbehc� h[eZ^Z_l� lh� beb� bgh_qZklgh_�\e_q_gb_�kZfh�ih�k_[_�beb�\��khq_lZgbb�k ^jm]bfb��K nZdlhjhf�^_lkdh]h�i_j_`b\Zgbyk_dkmZevgZy�dhgklblmpby�h[jZam_l�hiylv�lZdb�©^hihegbl_evguc�jy^ª��ih^h[gh�m`_�ba\_klghfmjy^m� f_`^m� ij_^jZkiheh`_gb_f� b kemqZcguf� i_j_`b\Zgb_f� \ajhkeh]h�� A^_kv�� dZd� b lZf�\klj_qZxlky� lZdb_�`_�djZcgb_�kemqZb��b bo�ij_^klZ\eyxl� l_�`_�hlghr_gby��Lml� _kl_kl\_gghihklZ\blv�\hijhk��g_�h[mkeh\e_gZ�eb�kZfZy� aZf_qZl_evgZy�ba�j_]j_kkbc�eb[b^h��j_]j_kkby�gZ[he__� jZggb_� klmi_gb� k_dkmZevghc� hj]ZgbaZpbb�� ij_bfms_kl\_ggh� gZ�ke_^kl\_ggh�dhgklblmpbhgZevguf� nZdlhjhf�� gh� hl\_l� gZ� wlhl� \hijhk� emqr_� \k_]h� hleh`blv�� ihdZ� g_jZkkfhlj_gh�[hevr__�qbkeh�nhjf�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�aZ[he_\Zgbc�HklZgh\bfky� gZ� lhf� nZdl_�� qlh� ZgZeblbq_kdh_� bkke_^h\Zgb_� ihdZau\Z_l� k\yav� eb[b^hg_\jhlbdh\� k bo� bgnZglbevgufb� k_dkmZevgufb� i_j_`b\Zgbyfb�� Hgh� ijb^Z_l� bf�� lZdbfh[jZahf��\b^bfhklv�h]jhfghc�agZqbfhklb�^ey�`bagb�b aZ[he_\Zgby�q_eh\_dZ��WlZ�agZqbfhklvkhojZgy_lky� aZ� gbfb� \ iheghf� h[t_f_�� dh]^Z� j_qv� b^_l� h l_jZi_\lbq_kdhc� jZ[hl_��Gh� _kebhklZ\blv�\ klhjhg_�wlm�aZ^Zqm��lh�e_]dh�ijbagZlv��qlh�a^_kv�djh_lky�hiZkghklv�g_^hjZamf_gby�dhlhjh_�fh]eh�[u�\\_klb�gZk�\ aZ[em`^_gb_�hjb_glbjh\Zlvky�\ `bagb�ebrv�gZ�g_\jhlbq_kdmxkblmZpbx�� H^gZdh� agZqbfhklv� bgnZglbevguo� i_j_`b\Zgbc� mf_gvrZ_lky� l_f�� qlh� eb[b^h\ha\jZsZ_lky�d gbf�j_]j_kkb\gh��ihke_�lh]h�dZd�[ueh�ba]gZgh�kh�k\hbo�[he__�iha^gbo�ihabpbc�Gh� lh]^Z� gZijZrb\Z_lky� ijhlb\hiheh`guc� \u\h^�� qlh� eb[b^hagu_�i_j_`b\Zgby� g_� bf_eb� \k\h_� \j_fy� kh\_jr_ggh� gbdZdh]h� agZq_gby�� Z ijbh[j_eb� _]h� lhevdh� iml_f� j_]j_kkbb�

Page 202: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

<kihfgbl_�� qlh� fu� \ukdZaZeb� k\h_� fg_gb_� ih� hlghr_gbx� d lZdhc� Zevl_jgZlb\_� ijbh[km`^_gbb�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ�B gZ�wlhl�jZa�gZf�g_ljm^gh�[m^_l�ijbgylv�j_r_gb_��AZf_qZgb_��qlh�aZiheg_gghklv�eb[b^h²� b�� ke_^h\Zl_evgh�� iZlh]_ggh_� agZq_gb_� ²� bgnZglbevguo� i_j_`b\Zgbc� \ [hevrhc� f_j_mkbeb\Z_l_A� j_]j_kkb_c� eb[b^h�� g_khfg_ggh� ijZ\bevgh�� gh� hgh� ijb\_eh� [u� d aZ[em`^_gbx�_keb� _]h� kqblZlv� _^bgkl\_ggh� hij_^_eyxsbf�� G_h[oh^bfh� kqblZlvky� b k� ^jm]bfbkhh[jZ`_gbyfb��<h�i_j\uo��gZ[ex^_gb_��\g_�\kydh]h�khfg_gby��ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�bgnZglbevgu_i_j_`b\Zgby�bf_xl� k\h_� kh[kl\_ggh_� agZq_gb_� b ^hdZau\Zxl� _]h� m`_� \ ^_lkdb_� ]h^u��<_^v\klj_qZxlky�b ^_lkdb_�g_\jhau��ijb�dhlhjuo�nZdlhj�\j_f_ggh]h�k^\b]Z�gZaZ^�hq_gv�kgb`Z_lkybeb� kh\k_f� hliZ^Z_l�� dh]^Z� aZ[he_\Zgb_� \hagbdZ_l� dZd� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh_� ke_^kl\b_ljZ\fZlbq_kdbo� i_j_`b\Zgbc�� Bamq_gb_� wlbo� ^_lkdbo� g_\jhah\� ij_^mij_`^Z_l� g_dhlhjh_hiZkgh_�g_^hihgbfZgb_�g_\jhah\�\ajhkeuo��ih^h[gh�lhfm�dZd�kgh\b^_gby�^_l_c�^Zeb�gZf�dexqd ihgbfZgbx�kgh\b^_gbc�\ajhkeuo��G_\jhau�m ^_l_c�\klj_qZxlky�hq_gv�qZklh��]hjZa^h�qZs_�q_f� ^mfZxl�� Bo� g_j_^dh� g_� aZf_qZxl�� hp_gb\Zxl� dZd� ijbagZd� bkihjq_gghklb� bebg_\hkiblZgghklb�� qZklh� ih^Z\eyxl� Z\lhjbl_lhf� \hkiblZl_e_c� ©^_lkdhcª�� gh� bo� e_]dhjZkihagZlv�iha`_�j_ljhki_dlb\gh��< [hevrbgkl\_�kemqZ_\�hgb�ijhy\eyxlky�\ nhjf_�bkl_jbbkljZoZ��Qlh�wlh�agZqbl��fu�magZ_f�_s_�\ ^jm]hc�k\yab��?keb�\ [he__�iha^gb_�]h^u�m q_eh\_dZjZa\b\Z_lky� g_\jha�� lh� ijb� ihfhsb� ZgZebaZ� hg� jZkdju\Z_lky� dZd� ijyfh_� ijh^he`_gb_� lh]h�\hafh`gh�� g_ykgh]h�� ebrv� gZf_qZ\r_]hky� ^_lkdh]h� aZ[he_\Zgby�� Gh�� dZd� kdZaZgh�� [u\ZxlkemqZb�� dh]^Z� wlZ�^_lkdZy�g_j\haghklv�[_a� \kydh]h�i_j_ju\Z�i_j_oh^bl� \ [he_agv�� ^eysmxky\kx�`bagv��G_kdhevdh�ijbf_jh\� ^_lkdbo� g_\jhah\�fu� bf_eb� \hafh`ghklv� ZgZebabjh\Zlv� gZkZfhf�j_[_gd_�²�\ ZdlmZevghf�khklhygbb��gh�]hjZa^h�qZs_�gZf�ijboh^behkv�^h\hevkl\h\Zlvkyl_f��qlh�aZ[he_\rbc�\ aj_ehf�\hajZkl_�^Z\Ze�\hafh`ghklv�^hihegbl_evgh�ihagZdhfblvky�k _]h^_lkdbf� g_\jhahf�� ijb� wlhf� fu� g_� fh]eb� g_� mqblu\Zlv� hij_^_e_gguo� ihijZ\hd� bij_^hklhjh`ghkl_c�<h�\lhjuo�� gm`gh� kdZaZlv�� qlh� [ueh� [u� g_ihgylgh�� ihq_fm� eb[b^h� ihklhyggh\ha\jZsZ_lky�d \j_f_gZf�^_lkl\Z��_keb�lZf�gbq_]h�g_l��qlh�fh]eh�[u�_]h�ijb\e_dZlv��NbdkZpby�dhlhjmx� fu� ij_^iheZ]Z_f� \ hl^_evguo� lhqdZo� jZa\blby�� bf__l� kh^_j`Zgb_� lhevdh� \ lhfkemqZ_��_keb�fu�^himklbf��qlh�\ g__�\eh`_gh�hij_^_e_ggh_�dhebq_kl\h�eb[b^haghc� wg_j]bb�GZdhg_p�� y fh]m� \Zf� gZihfgblv�� qlh� a^_kv�f_`^m� bgl_gkb\ghklvx� b iZlh]_gguf� agZq_gb_fbgnZglbevguo�b [he__�iha^gbo�i_j_`b\Zgbc�bf__lky� koh^gh_� hlghr_gb_� ^hiheg_gby�� dZd� \m`_� jZg__� bamq_gguo� gZfb� jy^Zo�� ?klv� kemqZb�� \ dhlhjuo� ijbqbgZ� aZ[he_\Zgby� djh_lky]eZ\guf� h[jZahf� \ k_dkmZevguo� i_j_`b\Zgbyo� ^_lkl\Z�� dh]^Z� wlb� \i_qZle_gby� hdZau\Zxlg_khfg_ggh�ljZ\fZlbq_kdh_�^_ckl\b_�b g_�gm`^Zxlky�gb�\ dZdhc�^jm]hc�ih^^_j`d_��djhf_�lhc�dhlhjmx�bf�ij_^hklZ\ey_l�h[uqgZy�g_aZ\_jr_ggZy�dhgklblmpby��GZjy^m�k gbfb�[u\Zxl�^jm]b_kemqZb��\ dhlhjuo�\_kv�Zdp_gl�iZ^Z_l�gZ�[he__�iha^gb_�dhgnebdlu��Z \uklmie_gb_�\ ZgZeba_�gZi_j\uc� ieZg� ^_lkdbo� \i_qZle_gbc� dZ`_lky� bkdexqbl_evgh� j_amevlZlhf� j_]j_kkbb�ke_^h\Zl_evgh��\klj_qZxlky�djZcgb_�kemqZb�©aZ^_j`db�jZa\blbyª�b ©j_]j_kkbbª��Z f_`^m�gbfb²�ex[Zy�kl_i_gv�\aZbfh^_ckl\by�h[hbo�nZdlhjh\�Wlb�hlghr_gby�ij_^klZ\eyxl�hij_^_e_gguc�bgl_j_k�^ey�i_^Z]h]bdb��dhlhjZy�klZ\bl�k\h_caZ^Zq_c� ij_^mij_`^_gb_� g_\jhah\� [eZ]h^Zjy� k\h_\j_f_gghfm� \f_rZl_evkl\m� \ k_dkmZevgh_

Page 203: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

jZa\blb_� j_[_gdZ�� IhdZ� \gbfZgb_� gZijZ\e_gh� ij_bfms_kl\_ggh� gZ� ^_lkdb_� k_dkmZevgu_i_j_`b\Zgby�� kqblZ_lky�� qlh� ^ey� ijhnbeZdlbdb� g_j\guo� aZ[he_\Zgbc� \k_� k^_eZgh�� _kebihaZ[hlblvky� h lhf�� qlh[u� aZ^_j`Zlv� wlh� jZa\blb_� b ba[Z\blv� j_[_gdZ� hl� lZdh]h� jh^Zi_j_`b\Zgbc��Gh�fu�m`_�agZ_f��qlh�mkeh\by��y\eyxsb_ky�ijbqbghc�g_\jhah\��keh`gu�b gZ�gbog_evay� hdZaZlv� \k_klhjhgg_]h� \ebygby�� mqblu\Zy� h^bg�_^bgkl\_gguc�nZdlhj��Kljh]Zy� hojZgZ^_lkl\Z�l_jy_l�k\hx�p_gghklv��ihlhfm�qlh�hgZ�[_kkbevgZ�ijhlb\�dhgklblmpbhgZevgh]h�nZdlhjZ�djhf_�lh]h��__ ljm^g__�hkms_kl\blv��q_f�ij_^klZ\eyxl�k_[_�\hkiblZl_eb��b hgZ�\e_q_l�aZ�kh[hc^\_� hiZkghklb�� dhlhju_� g_evay� g_^hhp_gb\Zlv�� h^gZ� ^hklb]Z_l� kebrdhf� fgh]h]h�� Z bf_gghkha^Z_l� [eZ]hijbylgu_� mkeh\by� ^ey� \ihke_^kl\bb� \j_^gh]h� qj_af_jgh]h� k_dkmZevgh]h\ul_kg_gby�� b j_[_ghd� ihiZ^Z_l� \ `bagv� g_kihkh[guf� d khijhlb\e_gbx� h`b^Zxs_fm� _]hrlmjfm�k_dkmZevguo�lj_[h\Zgbc�\ i_jbh^�iheh\hc�aj_ehklb��LZd�qlh�hklZ_lky�\_kvfZ�b \_kvfZkhfgbl_evguf��gZkdhevdh�ihe_aghc�fh`_l�[ulv�ijhnbeZdlbdZ�^_lkl\Z��b g_�h[_sZ_l�eb�^jm]ZymklZgh\dZ� ih� hlghr_gbx� d ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� emqrbo� i_jki_dlb\� ^ey� ij_^mij_`^_gbyg_\jhah\�: l_i_jv� \_jg_fky� d kbfilhfZf�� BlZd�� hgb� kha^Zxl� aZf_s_gb_� g_khklhy\r_fmkym^h\e_l\hj_gbx� [eZ]h^Zjy� j_]j_kkbb� eb[b^h� d [he__� jZggbf� i_jbh^Zf�� k q_f� g_jZaju\ghk\yaZg�\ha\jZl�gZ�[he__�jZggb_�klmi_gb�jZa\blby�\u[hjZ�h[t_dlh\�beb�hj]ZgbaZpbb��Fu�m`_jZgvr_�keurZeb��qlh�g_\jhlbd�aZklj_\Z_l�]^_�lh�\ k\h_f�ijhrehf��l_i_jv�fu�agZ_f��qlh�wlhi_jbh^�ijhreh]h��dh]^Z�_]h�eb[b^h�g_�[ueh�ebr_gh�m^h\e_l\hj_gby��dh]^Z�hg�[ue�kqZkleb\�Hg� lZd� ^he]h� bkke_^m_l� bklhjbx� k\h_c�`bagb�� ihdZ� g_� gZoh^bl� lZdh_� \j_fy� ²� imklv� ^Z`_i_jbh^� k\h_]h� feZ^_gq_kl\Z� ²� dZdbf� hg� \kihfbgZ_l� beb� ij_^klZ\ey_l� _]h� k_[_� ih� [he__iha^gbf� ih[m`^_gbyf�� Kbfilhf� dZdbf�lh� h[jZahf� ih\lhjy_l� lhl� \b^� jZgg_]h� ^_lkdh]hm^h\e_l\hj_gby��bkdZ`_ggh]h�\ua\Zgghc�dhgnebdlhf�p_gamjhc��h[jZs_ggh]h��dZd�ijZ\beh��dhsms_gbx�kljZ^Zgby�b kf_rZggh]h�k we_f_glZfb��ihkem`b\rbfb�ih\h^hf�^ey� aZ[he_\Zgby�Lhl� \b^� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� dhlhjuc� ijbghkbl� kbfilhf�� bf__l� \ k_[_�fgh]h� kljZggh]h��Fu� g_h[jZsZ_f� \gbfZgby� gZ� lh�� qlh� hgh� hklZ_lky� g_ba\_klguf� ^ey� ebpZ�� dhlhjh_� hsmrZ_l� wlhfgbfh_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�kdhj__�dZd�kljZ^Zgb_�b `Zem_lky�gZ�g_]h��Wlh�ij_\jZs_gb_�hlghkblky�dikbobq_kdhfm� dhgnebdlm�� ih^� ^Z\e_gb_f� dhlhjh]h� b ^he`_g� h[jZah\Zlvky� kbfilhf�� Lh�� qlh[ueh� dh]^Z�lh� ^ey� bg^b\b^Z� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f�� k_]h^gy� ^he`gh� \uau\Zlv� _]h� khijhlb\e_gb_beb� hl\jZs_gb_�� GZf� ba\_kl_g� g_agZqbl_evguc� gh� ihmqbl_evguc� ijbf_j� lZdh]h� baf_g_gbyhsms_gbc�� Lhl� `_� j_[_ghd�� dhlhjuc� k `Z^ghklvx� khkZe� fhehdh� ba� fZl_jbgkdhc� ]jm^b�g_kdhevdh� e_l� kimkly� h[uqgh� \ujZ`Z_l� kbevgh_� hl\jZs_gb_� d fhehdm�� ij_h^he_lv� dhlhjh_\hkiblZl_eyf�^hklZlhqgh�ljm^gh��Hl\jZs_gb_�mkbeb\Z_lky��_keb�fhehdh�beb�kf_rZgguc�k gbfgZiblhd�ihdjul�i_gdhc��<b^bfh��g_evay�hljbpZlv�lh��qlh�i_gdZ�\uau\Z_l�\hkihfbgZgb_�h klhev`_eZgghc� g_dh]^Z� fZl_jbgkdhc� ]jm^b�� F_`^m� gbfb� e_`bl� i_j_`b\Zgb_� hlemq_gby�ih^_ckl\h\Z\r__�ljZ\fZlbq_kdb�?klv� _s_� dh_�qlh� ^jm]h_�� qlh� dZ`_lky� gZf� kljZgguf� b g_ihgylguf� \ kbfilhfZo� dZdkj_^kl\Zo�eb[b^hagh]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby��Hgb�g_�gZihfbgZxl�gZf�gbq_]h�lZdh]h��hl�q_]h�fu�\ghjfZevguo�mkeh\byo�h[uqgh�`^_f�m^h\e_l\hj_gby��Hgb�\ [hevrbgkl\_�kemqZ_\�b]ghjbjmxlh[t_dl� b hldZau\Zxlky� l_f� kZfuf� hl� k\yab� k \g_rg_c� j_Zevghklvx��Fu� ihgbfZ_f� wlh� dZdke_^kl\b_�hloh^Z�hl�ijbgpbiZ�j_Zevghklb�b \ha\jZl�d ijbgpbim� m^h\hevkl\by��Gh� wlh� lZd`_\ha\jZl�d g_dhlhjhfm�\b^m�jZkrbj_ggh]h� ZmlhwjhlbafZ��dhlhjuc�ij_^hklZ\eye� k_dkmZevghfm

Page 204: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\e_q_gbx�i_j\h_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_��Hgh� klZ\bl�gZ�f_klh�baf_g_gby�\g_rg_]h�fbjZ�baf_g_gb_l_eZ�� l�� _�� \gmlj_ggxx� Zdpbx� \f_klh� \g_rg_c�� ijbkihkh[e_gb_� \f_klh� ^_ckl\by�� qlh� hiylvkhhl\_lkl\m_l�qj_a\uqZcgh�\Z`ghc�\ nbeh]_g_lbq_kdhf�hlghr_gbb�j_]j_kkbb��Fu�ihcf_f�wlhlhevdh� \ k\yab� k gh\uf� y\e_gb_f�� dhlhjh_� gZf� _s_� ij_^klhbl� magZlv� ba� ZgZeblbq_kdbobkke_^h\Zgbc�h[jZah\Zgby�kbfilhfh\��>Ze__�fu�ijbihfgbf��qlh�ijb�h[jZah\Zgbb�kbfilhfh\^_ckl\h\Zeb�l_�`_�ijhp_kku�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��qlh�b ijb�h[jZah\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gbc�²�k]ms_gb_b kf_s_gb_��Kbfilhf��dZd�b kgh\b^_gb_��bah[jZ`Z_l�qlh�lh�bkiheg_gguf��^Z_l�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_ih� lbim� bgnZglbevgh]h�� gh� ba�aZ� ij_^_evgh]h� k]ms_gby� wlh� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� fh`_l� [ulvk\_^_gh� d h^ghfm�_^bgkl\_gghfm� hsms_gbx� beb� bgg_j\Zpbb�� h]jZgbqblvky� \ j_amevlZl_djZcg_]h� kf_s_gby� h^ghc�fZe_gvdhc� ^_lZevx� \k_]h� eb[b^hagh]h� dhfie_dkZ��G_m^b\bl_evgh�qlh�^Z`_�fu�g_j_^dh�bkiulu\Z_f�ljm^ghklb�ijb�jZkihagZgbb�ij_^iheZ]Z_fh]h�\ kbfilhf_�b\k_]^Z�ih^l\_j`^Zxs_]hky�eb[b^hagh]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�Y ij_^mij_`^Ze�\Zk��qlh�gZf�ij_^klhbl�magZlv�_s_�dh_�qlh�gh\h_�wlh� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� g_qlh� ihjZabl_evgh_� b kfmsZxs__�� <u� agZ_l_�� qlh� ihkj_^kl\hfZgZebaZ��hllZedb\Zykv�hl�kbfilhfh\��fu�ihagZdhfbebkv�k bgnZglbevgufb�i_j_`b\Zgbyfb��gZdhlhjuo�nbdkbjh\Zgh�eb[b^h�b ba�dhlhjuo�kha^Zxlky�kbfilhfu��B \hl�ihjZabl_evgh�lh��qlhwlb� bgnZglbevgu_� kp_gu� g_� \k_]^Z� \_jgu��>Z�^Z�� \ [hevrbgkl\_� kemqZ_\� hgb� g_� \_jgu�� Z \hl^_evguo�kemqZyo�gZoh^ylky�\ ijyfhc�ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb�d bklhjbq_kdhc�ijZ\^_��<u�\b^bl_�qlh� wlh� hldjulb_�� dZd�gbdZdh_�^jm]h_�� kihkh[gh�^bkdj_^blbjh\Zlv�beb� ZgZeba��ijb\_^rbc� dlZdhfm� j_amevlZlm�� beb� [hevguo�� gZ� \ukdZau\Zgbyo� dhlhjuo� ihkljh_g� ZgZeba�� dZd� b \k_ihgbfZgb_� g_\jhah\��: djhf_� lh]h�� _klv� _s_� g_qlh� \_kvfZ� kfmsZxs__�� ?keb� [u� \kdjulu_ZgZebahf�bgnZglbevgu_�i_j_`b\Zgby�[ueb�\k_]^Z�j_Zevgufb��m gZk�[ueh�[u�qm\kl\h��qlh�fuklhbf�gZ�l\_j^hc�ihq\_��_keb�[u�hgb�\k_]^Z�hdZau\Zebkv�ih^^_evgufb��jZah[eZqZebkv�[u�dZd\ufukeu��nZglZabb� [hevguo�� lh� gZf� gm`gh� [ueh� [u� ihdbgmlv� wlm� dhe_[exsmxky� ihq\m� bbkdZlv� kiZk_gby� gZ� ^jm]hc��Gh� gb� lh�� gb� ^jm]h_� g_� khhl\_lkl\m_l� bklbg_�� Z iheh`_gb_� ^_elZdh\h�� qlh� kdhgkljmbjh\Zggu_� beb� \hkklZgh\e_ggu_� \ \hkihfbgZgbyo� ijb� ZgZeba_� ^_lkdb_i_j_`b\Zgby� h^bg� jZa� [_kkihjgh� e`b\u�� ^jm]hc� jZa� klhev� `_� g_khfg_ggh� ijZ\bevgu�� Z \[hevrbgkl\_�kemqZ_\�ij_^klZ\eyxl�kh[hc�kf_kv�bklbgu�b e`b��LZd�qlh�kbfilhfu�bah[jZ`Zxllh� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� ijhbkoh^b\rb_� i_j_`b\Zgby�� dhlhjuf� fh`gh� ijbibkZlv� \ebygb_� gZnbdkZpbx� eb[b^h�� lh� nZglZabb� [hevgh]h�� dhlhjuf�� _kl_kl\_ggh�� wlZ� wlbheh]bq_kdZy� jhevkh\_jr_ggh� g_�ijbkmsZ��< wlhf� ljm^gh� jZah[jZlvky��I_j\mx� lhqdm� hihju�fu��fh`_l� [ulv�gZc^_f� \ koh^ghf� hldjulbb�� qlh� bf_ggh� hl^_evgu_� ^_lkdb_� \hkihfbgZgby�� dhlhju_� ex^bkhagZl_evgh�ojZgbeb�\ k_[_�ba^Z\gZ�^h�\kydh]h�ZgZebaZ��lh`_�fh]ml�[ulv�eh`gufb�beb��fh]mlih�djZcg_c�f_j_�� khq_lZlv�^hklZlhqgh�bklbgu�b e`b��>hdZaZl_evkl\h�g_ijZ\bevghklb� \ wlhfkemqZ_�j_^dh�\klj_qZ_l�ljm^ghklb��b fu�bf__f�ih�f_gvr_c�f_j_�ebrv�h^gh�ml_r_gb_��qlh�\wlhf�jZahqZjh\Zgbb�\bgh\Zl�g_�ZgZeba��Z dZdbf�lh�h[jZahf�[hevgu_�Ih�g_dhlhjuf�jZafure_gbyf�fu�e_]dh�ihcf_f��qlh�gZk�lZd�kfmsZ_l�\ wlhf�iheh`_gbb\_s_c�� Wlh� g_^hhp_gdZ� j_Zevghklb�� ij_g_[j_`_gb_� jZaebqb_f� f_`^m� g_c� _ nZglZab_c��Fu]hlh\u� m`_� hkdhj[blvky� l_f�� qlh� [hevghc� aZgbfZe� gZk� \ufure_ggufb� bklhjbyfb�>_ckl\bl_evghklv� dZ`_lky� gZf� q_f�lh� [_kdhg_qgh� hlebqguf� hl� \ufukeZ� b aZkem`b\Zxsbfkh\_jr_ggh� bghc� hp_gdb�� <ijhq_f�� lZdhc�`_� lhqdb� aj_gby� \ k\h_f� ghjfZevghf� fure_gbb

Page 205: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijb^_j`b\Z_lky� b [hevghc�� Dh]^Z� hg� ijb\h^bl� fZl_jbZe�� dhlhjuc� \_^_l� hl� kbfilhfh\� dkblmZpbyf� `_eZgby�� ihkljh_gguf� ih� h[jZapm� ^_lkdbo� i_j_`b\Zgbc�� fu� kgZqZeZ�� ijZ\^Z�khfg_\Z_fky�� b^_l� eb� j_qv� h ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� beb� h nZglZabb�� Iha^g__� gZ� hkgh\Zgbbhij_^_e_gguo�ijbagZdh\�fu�fh`_f�ijbgylv� j_r_gb_�ih� wlhfm�ih\h^m��b i_j_^�gZfb� \klZ_laZ^ZqZ�hagZdhfblv� k gbf�b [hevgh]h��Ijb� wlhf� ^_eh�gbdh]^Z�g_� h[oh^blky� [_a� aZljm^g_gbc�?keb� fu� k kZfh]h� gZqZeZ� hldju\Z_f� _fm�� qlh� l_i_jv� hg� kh[bjZ_lky� ihdZaZlv� nZglZabb�dhlhjufb� hdmlZe� k\hx� bklhjbx� ^_lkl\Z�� dZd� \kydbc� gZjh^� kdZaZgbyfb� k\hc� aZ[uluc^hbklhjbq_kdbc�i_jbh^��lh�fu�aZf_qZ_f��qlh�m g_]h�g_`_eZl_evguf�h[jZahf�\^jm]�ihgb`Z_lkybgl_j_k� d ijh^he`_gbx� l_fu�� Hg� lh`_� ohq_l� agZlv� ^_ckl\bl_evghklv� b ij_abjZ_l� \kydb_©nZglZabbª��?keb�`_�fu�^h�hdhgqZgby�wlhc�qZklb�jZ[hlu�ij_^hklZ\bf�_fm�\_jblv��qlh�aZgylubamq_gb_f� j_Zevguo� kh[ulbc� _]h� ^_lkdbo� e_l�� lh� jbkdm_f�� qlh� iha^g__� hg� mij_dg_l� gZk� \hrb[d_� b \ukf__l� aZ� gZr_� dZ`ms__ky� e_]dh\_jb_�� Hg� ^he]h� g_� fh`_l� ihgylv� gZr_ij_^eh`_gb_�ihklZ\blv�gZjZ\g_�nZglZabx�b ^_ckl\bl_evghklv�b g_�aZ[hlblvky�kgZqZeZ�h lhf�ij_^klZ\eyxl�eb�kh[hc�^_lkdb_�i_j_`b\Zgby��dhlhju_�gm`gh�\uykgblv��lh�beb�^jm]h_��B \k_�lZdb�wlh��hq_\b^gh��_^bgkl\_ggh�ijZ\bevgZy� lhqdZ� aj_gby�gZ� wlb�^mr_\gu_�ijh^mdlu��B hgbbf_xl�oZjZdl_j�j_Zevghklb��hklZ_lky�nZdl��qlh�[hevghc�kha^Ze�k_[_�lZdb_�nZglZabb��b wlhl�nZdlbf__l� ^ey� _]h� g_\jhaZ� \jy^� eb� f_gvr__� agZq_gb_�� q_f� _keb� [u� hg� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� i_j_`bekh^_j`Zgb_� wlbo� nZglZabc�� Wlb� nZglZabb� h[eZ^Zxl� ikbobq_kdhc� j_Zevghklvx� \ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv�fZl_jbZevghc��b fu�ihkl_i_ggh�gZmqZ_fky�ihgbfZlv��qlh�\ fbj_�g_\jhah\j_rZxs_c�y\ey_lky�ikbobq_kdZy�j_Zevghklv�Kj_^b� h[klhyl_evkl\�� \k_]^Z� ih\lhjyxsboky� \ xghr_kdhc� bklhjbb� g_\jhlbdh\� b�� ih�\b^bfhfm��ihqlb�\k_]^Z�bf_xsbo�f_klh��g_dhlhju_�ijbh[j_lZxl�hkh[mx�\Z`ghklv��b ihwlhfmy kqblZx��qlh�bo�ke_^m_l�hkh[h�\u^_eblv�ba�^jm]bo��< dZq_kl\_�ijbf_jh\�lZdh]h�jh^Z�y ijb\_^mke_^mxsb_�nZdlu��gZ[ex^_gb_�iheh\h]h�kghr_gby�jh^bl_e_c��kh\jZs_gb_�\ajhkeuf�ebphf�bm]jham� dZkljZpb_c�� ;ueh� [u� [hevrhc� hrb[dhc� iheZ]Zlv�� qlh� hgb� gbdh]^Z� g_� bf_xlfZl_jbZevghc� j_Zevghklb�� ?gZh[hjhl�� __ qZklh� fh`gh� k g_khfg_gghklvx� ^hdZaZlv� ijbjZkkijhkZo� klZjrbo� jh^kl\_ggbdh\��� LZd�� gZijbf_j�� \h\k_� g_� j_^dhklv�� qlh� fZe_gvdhfmfZevqbdm�� dhlhjuc� gZqbgZ_l�g_ijbebqgh� b]jZlv� kh� k\hbf� qe_ghf�b _s_� g_� agZ_l�� qlh� lZdh_aZgylb_� gm`gh� kdju\Zlv�� jh^bl_eb� beb� moZ`b\Zxsb_� aZ� ^_lvfb� ]jhayl� hlj_aZlv� qe_g� beb]j_rgmx�jmdm��Ijb�jZkkijhkZo�jh^bl_eb�qZklh�khagZxlky�\ wlhf��lZd�dZd�iheZ]Zxl��qlh�lZdbfaZim]b\Zgb_f� ^_eZeb� qlh�lh� p_e_khh[jZagh_�� m g_dhlhjuo� hklZ_lky� lhqgh_�� khagZl_evgh_\hkihfbgZgb_�h[�wlhc�m]jha_��hkh[_ggh�\ lhf�kemqZ_��_keb�hgZ�[ueZ�k^_eZgZ�\ [he__�iha^gb_]h^u��?keb� m]jham� \ukdZau\Z_l�fZlv� beb� ^jm]h_� ebph�`_gkdh]h� iheZ�� lh� __ bkiheg_gb_� hgbi_j_deZ^u\Zxl�gZ�hlpZ�beb�\jZqZ��< agZf_gblhf�Kl_id_�jZklj_id_�njZgdnmjlkdh]h�i_^bZljZ=hnfZgZ�� h[yaZggh]h� k\h_c� ihimeyjghklvx� bf_ggh� ihgbfZgbx� k_dkmZevguo� b ^jm]bo�dhfie_dkh\� ^_lkdh]h� \hajZklZ�� \u� gZc^_l_� dZkljZpbx� kfy]q_gghc�� aZf_g_gghc� hlj_aZgb_f[hevrh]h� iZevpZ� \ gZdZaZgb_� aZ� mijyfh_� khkZgb_��Gh� \ \ukr_c� kl_i_gb� g_\_jhylgh�� qlh[u^_lyf� lZd� qZklh� ]jhabeb� dZkljZpb_c�� dZd� wlh� h[gZjm`b\Z_lky� \ ZgZebaZo� g_\jhlbdh\�� GZf^hklZlhqgh� ihgbfZgby� lh]h�� qlh� lZdmx� m]jham� j_[_ghd� kh_^bgy_l� \ nZglZabb� gZ�� hkgh\ZgbbgZf_dh\�� k ihfhsvx� agZgby�� qlh� Zmlhwjhlbq_kdh_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� aZij_s_gh�� b ih^\i_qZle_gb_f� k\h_]h� hldjulby� `_gkdbo� ]_gblZebc�� Lhqgh� lZd� `_� gbdhbf� h[jZahf� g_bkdexq_gh��qlh�fZe_gvdbc�j_[_ghd��ihdZ�m g_]h�g_�^himkdZxl�ihgbfZgby�b iZfylb��b g_�lhevdh

Page 206: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ ijhe_lZjkdbo�k_fvyo��klZgh\blky�k\b^_l_e_f�iheh\h]h�ZdlZ�jh^bl_e_c�beb�^jm]bo�\ajhkeuo��bg_evay� hldZaZlvky� hl� fukeb�� qlh� \ihke_^kl\bb� j_[_ghd� fh`_l� ihgylv� wlh� \i_qZle_gb_� bj_Z]bjh\Zlv� gZ� g_]h�� ?keb� `_� wlh� kghr_gb_� hibku\Z_lky� k kZfufb� ih^jh[gufb� ^_lZeyfb�ij_^klZ\eyxsbfb� ljm^ghklb� ^ey� gZ[ex^_gby�� beb� _keb� hgh� hdZau\Z_lky� kghr_gb_f� kaZ^b�PRUH� IHUDUXP �� dZd� wlh�qZklh�[u\Z_l�� lh�g_�hklZ_lky�gbdZdh]h� khfg_gby� \ ijbqZklghklb� wlhcnZglZabb� d gZ[ex^_gbx� aZ� kghr_gb_f� `b\hlguo� �kh[Zd�� b \� fhlb\bjh\d_� __g_m^h\e_l\hj_gghc� kljZklvx� d ih^]ey^u\Zgbx� j_[_gdZ� \ ]h^u� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb�� <ukrbf^hklb`_gb_f�lZdh]h�jh^Z�y\ey_lky�nZglZaby�h gZ[ex^_gbb�iheh\h]h�ZdlZ�jh^bl_e_c�\h�\j_fyij_[u\Zgby� \ fZl_jbgkdhc� mljh[_� _s_� ^h� jh`^_gby�� Hkh[uc� bgl_j_k� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hcnZglZaby�h kh\jZs_gbb��ihlhfm�qlh�kebrdhf�qZklh�wlh�g_�nZglZaby��Z j_Zevgh_�\hkihfbgZgb_�Gh� d kqZklvx�� hgh� \k_� `_� g_� lZd� qZklh� j_Zevgh�� dZd� wlh� fh]eh� [u� kgZqZeZ� ihdZaZlvky� ihj_amevlZlZf�ZgZebaZ��Kh\jZs_gb_�klZjrbfb�^_lvfb�beb�^_lvfb�lh]h�`_�\hajZklZ�kemqZ_lky�\k__s_� qZs_�� q_f� \ajhkeufb�� b _keb� m ^_\mr_d�� jZkkdZau\Zxsbo� h lZdhf� kh[ulbb� \ bklhjbbk\h_]h�^_lkl\Z��kh[eZagbl_� �Ih^h[gh�`b\hlguf��eZl���²Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�e_f�^h\hevgh� qZklh� \uklmiZ_l�hl_p�� lh�gb�nZglZklbq_kdZy�ijbjh^Z� wlh]h� h[\bg_gby��gb\uau\Zxsbc� _]h� fhlb\� g_� ih^e_`Zl� gbdZdhfm� khfg_gbx�� NZglZab_c� kh\jZs_gby�� dh]^ZgbdZdh]h� kh\jZs_gby� g_� [ueh�� j_[_ghd�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� ijbdju\Z_l� Zmlhwjhlbq_kdbc� i_jbh^k\h_c� k_dkmZevghc� ^_yl_evghklb�� Hg� ba[Z\ey_l� k_[y� hl� klu^Z� aZ� fZklmj[Zpbx�� i_j_ghky� \nZglZabb� `_eZgguc� h[t_dl� gZ� wlb� kZfu_� jZggb_� \j_f_gZ�� G_� ^mfZcl_�� \ijhq_f�� qlhbkihevah\Zgb_�j_[_gdZ�dZd�k_dkmZevgh]h�h[t_dlZ�_]h�[eb`Zcrbfb�jh^kl\_ggbdZfb�fm`kdh]hiheZ�hlghkblky�g_ij_f_ggh�d h[eZklb�nZglZabb��Fgh]b_�ZgZeblbdb�e_qbeb�kemqZb��\ dhlhjuolZdb_�hlghr_gby�[ueb�j_Zevgu�b fh]eb�[ulv�k g_khfg_gghklvx�mklZgh\e_gu��lhevdh�b lh]^Zhgb�hlghkbebkv�d [he__�iha^gbf�^_lkdbf�]h^Zf��Z [ueb�i_j_g_k_gu�\ [he__�jZggb_�<hagbdZ_l� \i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� lZdb_� kh[ulby� \ ^_lkl\_� dZdbf�lh� h[jZahf� lj_[mxlky�� k`_e_aghc�g_h[oh^bfhklvx�\oh^yl�\ khklZ\�g_\jhaZ��Bf_xlky�hgb�\ j_Zevghklb�²�ohjhrh��_kebj_Zevghklv� hldZau\Z_l� \ gbo�� lh� hgb� khklZ\eyxlky� ba� gZf_dh\� b ^hihegyxlky� nZglZab_c�J_amevlZl� h^bg� b lhl� `_�� b ^h� gZklhys_]h� \j_f_gb� gZf� g_� m^Zehkv� ^hdZaZlv� jZaebqby� \ihke_^kl\byo� \ aZ\bkbfhklb� hl� lh]h�� ijbgbfZ_l� \ wlbo� ^_lkdbo� kh[ulbyo� [hevr__� mqZklb_nZglZaby� beb� j_Zevghklv�� A^_kv� hiylv�lZdb� bf__lky� h^gh� ba� lZd� qZklh� mihfbgZ\rboky^hihegbl_evguo�hlghr_gbc�wlh��ijZ\^Z��h^gh�ba�kZfuo�kljZgguo��ba\_klguo�gZf��Hldm^Z�[_j_lky�ihlj_[ghklv�\ wlbonZglZabyo� b fZl_jbZe� ^ey� gbo"� G_\hafh`gh� khfg_\Zlvky� \ bklhqgbdZo� \e_q_gbc�� ghg_h[oh^bfh�h[tykgblv�nZdl��qlh�dZ`^uc�jZa�kha^Zxlky�l_�`_�nZglZabb�k l_f�`_�kh^_j`Zgb_f�M f_gy� ]hlh\� hl\_l�� gh� y agZx�� qlh� hg� ihdZ`_lky� \Zf� jbkdh\Zgguf�� Y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� wlbijZnZglZabb�²�lZd�fg_�ohl_ehkv�[u�gZa\Zlv�bo�b��dhg_qgh��_s_�g_dhlhju_�^jm]b_�²�y\eyxlkynbeh]_g_lbq_kdbf�^hklhygb_f��Bg^b\b^�\uoh^bl�\ gbo�aZ�ij_^_eu�kh[kl\_ggh]h�i_j_`b\Zgby\ i_j_`b\Zgb_� ^hbklhjbq_kdh]h� \j_f_gb�� ]^_� _]h� kh[kl\_ggh_� i_j_`b\Zgb_� klZgh\blkykebrdhf� jm^bf_glZjguf�� Fg_� dZ`_lky� \iheg_� \hafh`guf�� qlh� \k_�� qlh� k_]h^gyjZkkdZau\Z_lky� ijb� ZgZeba_� dZd� nZglZaby�²� kh\jZs_gb_� ^_l_c�� \kiurdZ� k_dkmZevgh]h\ha[m`^_gby�ijb�gZ[ex^_gbb�iheh\h]h�kghr_gby�jh^bl_e_c��m]jhaZ�dZkljZpb_c�²�beb��\_jg__�

Page 207: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dZkljZpby�²�[ueh�j_Zevghklvx�\ i_j\h[ulghc�q_eh\_q_kdhc�k_fv_��b nZglZabjmxsbc�j_[_ghdijhklh� \hkihegbe� ^hbklhjbq_kdhc� ijZ\^hc� ijh[_eu� \ bg^b\b^mZevghc� ijZ\^_�� M gZkg_h^ghdjZlgh�\hagbdZeh�ih^haj_gb_��qlh�ikboheh]by�g_\jhah\�khojZgbeZ�^ey�gZk�ba�^j_\g_]hi_jbh^Z�q_eh\_q_kdh]h�jZa\blby�[hevr_��q_f�\k_�^jm]b_�bklhqgbdb�M\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z�� <ur_mihfygmlu_� h[klhyl_evkl\Z� \ugm`^Zxl� gZk� ih[eb`_jZkkfhlj_lv� \hagbdgh\_gb_� b agZq_gb_� lhc� ^mr_\ghc� ^_yl_evghklb�� dhlhjZy� gZau\Z_lkynZglZab_c�� DZd� \Zf� ba\_klgh�� hgZ� ihevam_lky� \k_h[s_c� \ukhdhc� hp_gdhc�� ohly� __ f_klh� \^mr_\ghc� `bagb� hklZ_lky� g_\uykg_gguf�� Y fh]m� \Zf� kdZaZlv� h[� wlhf� ke_^mxs__�� DZd� \uagZ_l_�� ih^� \ha^_ckl\b_f� \g_rg_c� g_h[oh^bfhklb� Y q_eh\_dZ� ihkl_i_ggh� ijbmqZ_lkyhp_gb\Zlv�j_Zevghklv�b ke_^h\Zlv�ijbgpbim�j_Zevghklb��hldZau\Zykv�ijb� wlhf�\j_f_ggh�bebgZ^he]h� hl� jZaebqguo� h[t_dlh\� b p_e_c� k\h_]h� klj_fe_gby� d m^h\hevkl\bx� ²� g_� lhevdhk_dkmZevghfm��Gh�hldZa�hl�m^h\hevkl\by�\k_]^Z�^Z\Zeky�q_eh\_dm�k ljm^hf��hg�kh\_jrZ_l�_]h�g_[_a� k\h_]h� jh^Z� \haf_s_gby�� Hg� khojZgbe� k_[_� aZ� wlh� ^mr_\gmx� ^_yl_evghklv�� \ dhlhjhc^himkdZ_lky� ^Zevg_cr__� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� \k_o� wlbo� hklZ\e_gguo� bklhqgbdh\� gZkeZ`^_gby� bihdbgmluo� iml_c� _]h� ihemq_gby�� nhjfZ� kms_kl\h\Zgby�� \ dhlhjhc� hgb� hk\h[h`^Zxlky� hlijblyaZgby� gZ� j_Zevghklv� b hl� lh]h�� qlh� fu� gZau\Z_f� ©bkiulZgb_f� j_Zevghklvxª�� Ex[h_klj_fe_gb_� kjZam� ^hklb]Z_l� nhjfu� ij_^klZ\e_gby� h _]h� bkiheg_gbb�� g_khfg_ggh�� qlhgZijZ\e_gb_�nZglZabb�gZ�bkiheg_gb_�`_eZgbc�^Z_l�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_��ohly�ijb�wlhf�kms_kl\m_lagZgb_�lh]h��qlh�j_qv�b^_l�g_�h j_Zevghklb��LZdbf�h[jZahf��\ ^_yl_evghklb�nZglZabb�q_eh\_dgZkeZ`^Z_lky� k\h[h^hc� hl� \g_rg_]h� ijbgm`^_gby�� hl� dhlhjhc� hg� ^Z\gh� hldZaZeky� \^_ckl\bl_evghklb�� ?fm� m^Z_lky� [ulv� _s_� ihi_j_f_ggh� lh� gZkeZ`^Zxsbfky� `b\hlguf�� lhhiylv� jZamfguf� kms_kl\hf��Hg� g_� ^h\hevkl\m_lky�`Zedbf� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f�� dhlhjh_�fh`_lhl\h_\Zlv�m ^_ckl\bl_evghklb��©H[hclbkv�[_a�\kihfh]Zl_evguo�dhgkljmdpbc�\hh[s_�g_evayª�²kdZaZe�h^gZ`^u�L��NhglZg_��Kha^Zgb_�^mr_\ghc�h[eZklb�nZglZabb�gZoh^bl�ihegmx�ZgZeh]bx�\hj]ZgbaZpbb� ©aZih\_^gbdh\ª�� ©gZpbhgZevguo� iZjdh\ª� lZf�� ]^_� lj_[h\Zgby� a_fe_^_eby�ljZgkihjlZ�b ijhfure_gghklb�m]jh`Zxl�[ukljh�baf_gblv�^h�g_magZ\Z_fhklb�i_j\hgZqZevguc\b^�a_feb��GZpbhgZevguc�iZjd�khojZgy_l�k\h_�ij_`g__�khklhygb_��dhlhjh_�ih\kx^m�\ ^jm]bof_klZo� ijbg_k_gh� \ `_jl\m� g_h[oh^bfhklb��LZf�fh`_l� jZklb� b jZajZklZlvky� \k_�� qlh� ohq_l�^Z`_� [_kihe_agh_�� ^Z`_� \j_^gh_�� LZdbf� ebr_gguf� ijbgpbiZ� j_Zevghklb� aZih\_^gbdhf� by\ey_lky�^mr_\gZy�h[eZklv�nZglZabb�KZfu_�ba\_klgu_�ijh^mdlu�nZglZabb�²� m`_� agZdhfu_�gZf� ©kgu� gZy\mª�� \hh[jZ`Z_fh_m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� q_klhex[b\uo�� \ujZ`Zxsbo� fZgbx� \_ebqby�� wjhlbq_kdbo� `_eZgbc�jZkp\_lZxsbo� l_f� iurg__�� q_f� [hevr_� ^_ckl\bl_evghklv� ijbau\Z_l� d kdjhfghklb� bebl_ji_gbx��< gbo�k hq_\b^ghklvx�h[gZjm`b\Z_lky�kmsghklv�kqZklvy�\ nZglZabb��\hkklZgh\e_gb_g_aZ\bkbfhklb�ihemq_gby�gZkeZ`^_gby�hl�h^h[j_gby�j_Zevghklb��GZf�ba\_klgh��qlh�lZdb_�kgugZy\m�y\eyxlky�y^jhf�b ijhh[jZaZfb�ghqguo�kgh\b^_gbc��Ghqgh_�kgh\b^_gb_��\ kmsghklb��g_qlh� bgh_�� dZd� khg� gZy\m�� bkihevah\Zgguc� ghqghc� k\h[h^hc� \e_q_gbc� b bkdZ`_gguc� ghqghcnhjfhc�^mr_\ghc�^_yl_evghklb��Fu�m`_�hk\hbebkv�k fukevx��qlh�b kgu�gZy\m�g_�h[yaZl_evghkhagZl_evgu��qlh�hgb�[u\Zxl�b [_kkhagZl_evgufb��LZdb_�[_kkhagZl_evgu_�kgu�gZy\m�y\eyxlkydZd�bklhqgbdhf�ghqguo�kgh\b^_gbc��lZd�b bklhqgbdhf�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�kbfilhfh\�AgZq_gb_� nZglZabb� ^ey� h[jZah\Zgby� kbfilhfh\� klZg_l� \Zf� ykgh� ba� ke_^mxs_]h�� Fu

Page 208: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kdZaZeb�� qlh� \ kemqZ_� \ugm`^_ggh]h� hldZaZ� eb[b^h� j_]j_kkb\gh� aZgbfZ_l� hklZ\e_ggu_� bfihabpbb�� gZ� dhlhjuo� hgh� aZkljyeh� \ g_dhlhjhf� dhebq_kl\_��Fu� g_� hldZau\Z_fky� hl� wlh]hml\_j`^_gby� b g_� bkijZ\ey_f� _]h�� gh� ^he`gu� \klZ\blv� ijhf_`mlhqgh_� a\_gh�� DZd� eb[b^hgZoh^bl�imlv� d wlbf�f_klZf�nbdkZpbb"�<k_� hklZ\e_ggu_� h[t_dlu� b gZijZ\e_gghklb� eb[b^hhklZ\e_gu�g_�\h�\k_o�kfukeZo��Hgb�beb�bo�ijhba\h^gu_�k hij_^_e_gghc�bgl_gkb\ghklvx�_s_khojZgyxlky�\ ij_^klZ\e_gbyo�nZglZabb��Eb[b^h�gm`gh�lhevdh�mclb�\ nZglZabb��qlh[u�gZclb�\gbo�hldjuluc�imlv�dh�\k_f�\ul_kg_gguf�nbdkZpbyf��Wlb�nZglZabb�^himkdZebkv�\ ba\_klghckl_i_gb��f_`^m�gbfb�b Y��dZd�gb�j_adb�ijhlb\hj_qby��g_�[ueh�dhgnebdlZ��ihdZ�kh[ex^Zehkvh^gh�hij_^_e_ggh_�mkeh\b_�Mkeh\b_� wlh�� dhebq_kl\_ggh_� ih� ijbjh^_�� gZjmrZ_lky� h[jZlguf� ijblhdhf� eb[b^h� dnZglZabyf��<ke_^kl\b_� wlh]h� ijb[Z\e_gby� aZjy`_gghklv�nZglZabc� wg_j]b_c� lZd� ih\urZ_lky�qlh�hgb�klZgh\ylky�hq_gv�lj_[h\Zl_evgufb��jZa\b\Zy�klj_fe_gb_�d j_ZebaZpbb��Gh�wlh�^_eZ_lg_ba[_`guf� dhgnebdl� f_`^m� gbfb� b Y�� G_aZ\bkbfh� hl� lh]h�� [ueb� eb� hgb� jZgvr_ij_^khagZl_evgufb� beb� khagZl_evgufb�� l_i_jv� hgb� ih^e_`Zl� \ul_kg_gbx� kh� klhjhgu� Y bij_^hklZ\eyxlky� ijbly`_gbx� kh� klhjhgu� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� Hl� [_kkhagZl_evguo� l_i_jvnZglZabc� eb[b^h� i_j_f_sZ_lky� d bo� bklhdZf� \ [_kkhagZl_evghf�� d f_klZf� bo� kh[kl\_gghcnbdkZpbb�<ha\jZl� eb[b^h� d nZglZabyf� y\ey_lky� i_j_oh^ghc� klmi_gvx� gZ� imlb� h[jZah\Zgbykbfilhfh\��aZkem`b\Zxs_c�hkh[h]h�h[hagZq_gby��D��=��Xg]�^Ze�_c�hq_gv�ih^oh^ys__�gZa\Zgb_bgljh\_jkbb��gh�g_p_e_khh[jZagh�ijb^Ze�_fm�_s_�^jm]h_�agZq_gb_����Fu�hklZg_fky�gZ�lhf��qlhbgljh\_jkby� h[hagZqZ_l� hloh^� eb[b^h� hl� \hafh`ghkl_c� j_Zevgh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby� b^hihegbl_evgh_� aZiheg_gb_�bf�[_ah[b^guo�^h� lh]h�nZglZabc��Bgljh\_j�lbjh\Zgguc�q_eh\_d_s_� g_� g_\jhlbd�� gh� hg� gZoh^blky� \ g_mklhcqb\hf� iheh`_gbb�� ijb� [eb`Zcr_f� baf_g_gbbkhhlghr_gby�kbe�m g_]h�^he`gu�jZa\blvky�kbfilhfu��_keb�hg�g_�gZc^_l�^jm]bo�\uoh^h\�^eygZdhib\r_]hky� m g_]h� eb[b^h�� G_j_Zevguc� oZjZdl_j� g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby� bij_g_[j_`_gb_� jZaebqb_f� f_`^m� nZglZab_c� b ^_ckl\bl_evghklvx� m`_� ij_^hij_^_e_guij_[u\Zgb_f�gZ�klmi_gb�bgljh\_jkbb�<u�� gZ\_jgh�� aZf_lbeb�� qlh� \ k\hbo� ihke_^gbo� jZkkm`^_gbyo� y \\_e� \ kljmdlmjmwlbheh]bq_kdhc�p_ib�gh\uc�nZdlhj��Z bf_ggh�dhebq_kl\h��\_ebqbgm�jZkkfZljb\Z_fuo�wg_j]bc�k wlbf� nZdlhjhf� gZf� _s_� \kx^m� ijb^_lky� kqblZlvky�� Qbklh� dZq_kl\_gguf� ZgZebahfwlbheh]bq_kdbo� mkeh\bc� fu� g_� h[hc^_fky�� Beb�� ^jm]bfb� keh\Zfb�� lhevdh� ^bgZfbq_kdh]hihgbfZgby� wlbo�^mr_\guo�ijhp_kkh\�g_^hklZlhqgh��gm`gZ� _s_� wdhghfbq_kdZy� lhqdZ� aj_gby�Fu� ^he`gu� k_[_� kdZaZlv�� qlh� dhgnebdl� f_`^m� ^\mfy� klj_fe_gbyfb� g_� \hagbdg_l�� ihdZ� g_[m^_l�^hklb]gmlZ�hij_^_e_ggZy�kl_i_gv�aZjy`_gghklb�wg_j]b_c��ohly�kh^_j`Zl_evgu_�mkeh\byfh]ml�^Z\gh�kms_kl\h\Zlv��Lhqgh�lZd�`_�iZlh]_ggh_� agZq_gb_�dhgklblmpbhgZevguo�nZdlhjh\aZ\bkbl� hl� lh]h�� gZkdhevdh� [hevr_� \ dhgklblmpbb� aZeh`_gh� h^gh]h� qZklgh]h� \e_q_gby�� q_f^jm]h]h��fh`gh�k_[_�^Z`_�ij_^klZ\blv��qlh�dZq_kl\_ggh�dhgklblmpbb�\k_o�ex^_c�h^bgZdh\u�bjZaebqZxlky� lhevdh� wlbfb� dhebq_kl\_ggufb� khhlghr_gbyfb��G_�f_g__� j_rZxsbf� y\ey_lkydhebq_kl\_gguc�nZdlhj�b ^ey�kihkh[ghklb�d khijhlb\e_gbx�g_\jhlbq_kdhfm�aZ[he_\Zgbx��Wlh[m^_l� aZ\bk_lv�hl� lh]h��dZdh_�dhebq_kl\h�g_bkihevah\Zggh]h�eb[b^h�q_eh\_d�fh`_l�hklZ\blvk\h[h^guf�b dZdmx� qZklv� k\h_]h� eb[b^h� hg� kihkh[_g� hllhj]gmlv� hl� k_dkmZevgh]h� ^ey�p_e_c

Page 209: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

km[ebfZpbb��Dhg_qgZy�p_ev�^mr_\ghc�^_yl_evghklb��dhlhjmx�dZq_kl\_ggh�fh`gh�hibkZlv�dZdklj_fe_gb_� d ihemq_gbx� m^h\hevkl\by� b ba[_]Zgb_� g_m^h\hevkl\by�� k wdhghfbq_kdhc� lhqdbaj_gby�ij_^klZ\ey_lky�aZ^Zq_c�kijZ\blvky�k ^_ckl\mxsbf�\ ^mr_\ghf�ZiiZjZl_�dhebq_kl\hf\ha[m`^_gby��fZkkhc�jZa^jZ`_gby��b g_�^himklblv�_]h�aZklhy��\uau\Zxs_]h�g_m^h\hevkl\b_�<hl� lh�� qlh� y ohl_e� \Zf� kdZaZlv� h[� h[jZah\Zgbb� kbfilhfh\� ijb� g_\jha_�� Gh� qlh[u� g_aZ[ulv��ih^q_jdgm�_s_�jZa�kh�\k_c�hij_^_e_gghklvx�\k_� a^_kv� kdZaZggh_� hlghkblky� lhevdh� d h[jZah\Zgbx� kbfilhfh\� ijb� bkl_jbb��M`_� ijbg_\jha_� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc� ²� ohly� hch\gh_� khojZgblky� ²� fgh]h_� [m^_l� ih�^jm]hfm�Ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb� ih� hlghr_gbx� d lj_[h\Zgbyf� \e_q_gbc�� h dhlhjuo� reZ� j_qv� b ijbbkl_jbb�� ijb� g_\jha_� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc� \uklmiZxl� gZ� i_j\uc� ieZg� b ij_h[eZ^Zxl� \debgbq_kdhc�dZjlbg_�[eZ]h^Zjy�lZd�gZau\Z_fuf�©j_Zdlb\guf�h[jZah\Zgbyfª��LZdb_�`_�b _s_^Zevr_� b^msb_� hlklmie_gby� fu� hldju\Z_f� ijb� ^jm]bo� g_\jhaZo�� ]^_� bkke_^h\Zgby� hf_oZgbafZo�h[jZah\Zgby�kbfilhfh\�gb \�dh_c�f_j_�g_�aZ\_jr_gu�Ij_`^_�q_f�hlimklblv�\Zk�k_]h^gy��y ohl_e�[u�gZ�fbgmlm�h[jZlblv�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�h^gmklhjhgm� `bagb� nZglZabb�� dhlhjZy� ^hklhcgZ� \k_h[s_]h� bgl_j_kZ�� ?klv� h[jZlguc� imlv� hlnZglZabb�d j_Zevghklb��wlh�²�bkdmkkl\h��< hkgh\_�k\h_c�om^h`gbd�lh`_�bgljh\_jlbjh\Zgguc�dhlhjhfm�g_^Ze_dh�^h�g_\jhaZ��< g_f�l_kgylky�k\_jokbevgu_�\e_q_gby��hg�ohl_e�[u�ihemqZlvihq_klb��\eZklv��[h]Zlkl\h��keZ\m�b ex[h\v�`_gsbg��gh�m g_]h�g_l�kj_^kl\��qlh[u�^h[blvky�bom^h\e_l\hj_gby�� : ihlhfm�� dZd� \kydbc� g_m^h\e_l\hj_gguc� q_eh\_d�� hg� hl\hjZqb\Z_lky� hl^_ckl\bl_evghklb� b i_j_ghkbl� \_kv� k\hc� bgl_j_k�� Z lZd`_� k\h_� eb[b^h� gZ�`_eZggu_� h[jZauk\h_c�nZglZabb��hldm^Z�fh]�[u�hldjulvky�imlv�d g_\jham��B fgh]h_�^he`gh�kh\iZklv��qlh[u�wlhg_�klZeh�iheguf�bkoh^hf�_]h�jZa\blby��\_^v�ba\_klgh��dZd�qZklh�bf_ggh�om^h`gbdb�kljZ^Zxlba�aZ�g_\jhah\�qZklbqghc�ihl_j_c�k\h_c�ljm^hkihkh[ghklb��<_jhylgh��bo�dhgklblmpby�h[eZ^Z_lkbevghc� kihkh[ghklvx� d km[ebfZpbb� b hij_^_e_gghc� keZ[hklvx� \ul_kg_gbb�� jZaj_rZxsbodhgnebdl��H[jZlguc�`_�imlv�d j_Zevghklb�om^h`gbd�gZoh^bl�ke_^mxsbf�h[jZahf��<_^v�hg�g__^bgkl\_gguc��dlh�`b\_l�`bagvx�nZglZabb��Ijhf_`mlhqgh_�pZjkl\h�nZglZabb�kms_kl\m_l�kh\k_h[s_]h�kh]eZkby�q_eh\_q_kl\Z��b \kydbc��bkiulu\Zxsbc�ebr_gby��`^_l�hl�g_]h�h[e_]q_gbyb ml_r_gby��Gh�^ey�g_om^h`gbdZ�\hafh`ghklv�ihemq_gby�gZkeZ`^_gby�ba�bklhqgbdh\�nZglZabbh]jZgbq_gZ�� G_mfhebfhklv� \ul_kg_gbb� \ugm`^Z_l� _]h� ^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky� kdm^gufb� ]j_aZfb�dhlhju_�fh]ml�_s_�hklZ\Zlvky�khagZl_evgufb��Gh�_keb�dlh�lh�²�bklbgguc�om^h`gbd��lh]^Z�hgbf__l�\ k\h_f�jZkihjy`_gbb�[hevr_��<h�i_j\uo��hg�mf__l�lZd�h[jZ[hlZlv�k\hb�]j_au��qlh�hgbl_jyxl� \k_� kebrdhf� ebqgh_�� hllZedb\Zxs__� ihklhjhgg_]h�� b klZgh\ylky� ^hklmigufb� ^eygZkeZ`^_gby� ^jm]bo��Hg� mf__l� lZd`_� gZklhevdh� kfy]qblv� bo�� qlh� g_e_]dh� ^h]Z^Zlvky� h[� boijhbkoh`^_gbb� ba� aZij_lguo� bklhqgbdh\�� >Ze__�� hg� h[eZ^Z_l� lZbgkl\_gghc� kihkh[ghklvxijb^Z\Zlv� hij_^_e_gghfm� fZl_jbZem� nhjfm�� ihdZ� lhl� g_� klZg_l� \_jguf� hlh[jZ`_gb_f� _]hnZglZklbq_kdh]h� ij_^klZ\e_gby�� b aZl_f� hg� mf__l� k\yaZlv� k wlbf� bah[jZ`_gb_f� k\h_c[_kkhagZl_evghc� nZglZabb� ihemq_gb_� lZdh]h� [hevrh]h� gZkeZ`^_gby�� qlh� [eZ]h^Zjy� wlhfm\ul_kg_gby��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_�\j_f_ggh��ij_h^he_\Zxlky�b mkljZgyxlky��?keb�hg�\k_�wlh�fh`_lkh\_jrblv��lh�^Z_l�b ^jm]bf�\hafh`ghklv�kgh\Z�q_jiZlv�ml_r_gb_�b h[e_]q_gb_�ba�bklhqgbdh\gZkeZ`^_gby� bo� kh[kl\_ggh]h� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� klZ\rbo� g_^hklmigufb�� ihemqZy� bo[eZ]h^Zjghklv�b \hkobs_gb_�b ^hklb]Zy�[eZ]h^Zjy�k\h_c�nZglZabb�lhª�qlh�kgZqZeZ�bf_e�lhevdh

Page 210: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ nZglZabb��ihq_klb��\eZklv�b ex[h\v�`_gsbg� �><:>P:LV�Q?L<?JL:Y�E?DPBYH[uqgZy�g_j\haghklvM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z��Ihke_� lh]h� dZd� \ ihke_^gbo� [_k_^Zo�fu� aZ\_jrbeb� lZdmxljm^gmx� qZklv� jZ[hlu�� y gZ� g_dhlhjh_� \j_fy� hklZ\eyx� wlhl� ij_^f_l� b h[jZsZxkv� d \Zf� khke_^mxsbf�Y agZx��qlh�\u�g_^h\hevgu��<u�ij_^klZ\eyeb�k_[_� ©<\_^_gb_�\ ikbohZgZebaª�bgZq_��<uij_^iheZ]Zeb�mkeurZlv�`bag_ggu_�ijbf_ju��Z g_�l_hjbb��<u�kdZ`_l_�fg_��qlh�_^bgkl\_ggucjZa��dh]^Z�y ij_^klZ\be�\Zf�iZjZee_ev� ©< ih^\Ze_�b gZ�i_j\hf� wlZ`_ª��\u�dh_�qlh�ihgyeb�hijbqbg_�g_\jhah\��lhevdh�emqr_�[u�wlh�[ueb�^_ckl\bl_evgu_�gZ[ex^_gby��Z g_�ijb^mfZggu_bklhjbb�� Beb� dh]^Z� y \gZqZe_� jZkkdZaZe� \Zf� h ^\mo� ²� \b^bfh�� lh`_� g_� \ufure_gguo� ²kbfilhfZo�b jZatykgbe�bo�hlghr_gb_�d `bagb�[hevgh]h��lh�\Zf�klZe�yk_g�©kfukeª�kbfilhfh\�\u�gZ^_yebkv��qlh�y [m^m�ijh^he`Zlv�\ lhf�`_�^mo_��<f_klh�wlh]h�y baeZ]Ze�\Zf�ijhkljZggu_�jZkieu\qZlu_�l_hjbb��dhlhju_�gbdh]^Z�g_�[ueb�ihegufb��d dhlhjuf�ihklhyggh�^h[Z\eyehkvqlh�lh� gh\h_�� ihevah\Zeky� ihgylbyfb�� dhlhjuo� _s_� g_� jZatykgbe� \Zf�� i_j_oh^be� hlhibkZl_evgh]h� baeh`_gby� d ^bgZfbq_kdhfm� ihgbfZgbx�� Z hl� g_]h� ²� d lZd� gZau\Z_fhfm©wdhghfbq_kdhfmª��f_rZy�\Zf�ihgylv��dZdb_�ba�bkihevam_fuo�l_jfbgh\�hagZqZxl�lh�`_�kZfh_b aZf_gyxl�^jm]�^jm]Z�lhevdh�ih�ijbqbg_�[eZ]ha\mqby���ij_^eZ]Ze�\Zf�lZdb_�rbjhdb_�ihgylby�dZd�ijbgpbiu�m^h\hevkl\by�b j_Zevghklb�b nbeh]_g_lbq_kdb�mgZke_^h\Zggh_��b��\f_klh� lh]hqlh[u� \\h^blv� \h� qlh�lh�� y jZa\_jlu\Ze� i_j_^� \Zrbf� \ahjhf� g_qlh� lZdh_�� qlh� \k_� [hevr_m^Zeyehkv�hl�\Zk�Ihq_fm�y g_�gZqZe�\\_^_gb_�\ l_hjbx�g_\jhah\�k lh]h��qlh�\u�kZfb�agZ_l_�h g_j\haghklb�bqlh� ^Z\gh� \uau\Z_l� \Zr� bgl_j_k"� Ihq_fm� g_� gZqZe� k hibkZgby� k\h_h[jZaghc� kmsghklbg_j\gh[hevguo�� bo� g_ihgylguo� j_Zdpbc� gZ� q_eh\_q_kdh_� h[s_gb_� b \g_rgb_� \ebygby�� bojZa^jZ`bl_evghklb��g_ij_^kdZam_fhklb�ih\_^_gby�b g_ijbkihkh[e_gghklb�d `bagb"�Ihq_fm�g_ih\_e� \Zk� rZ]� aZ� rZ]hf� hl� ihgbfZgby� [he__� ijhkluo� ih\k_^g_\guo� nhjf� d ijh[e_fZfaZ]Z^hqguo�djZcgbo�ijhy\e_gbc�g_j\haghklb">Z��m\Z`Z_fu_� ]hkih^Z��g_�fh]m�g_�ijbagZlv�\Zr_c�ijZ\hlu��Y g_�gZklhevdh�\ex[e_g�\kh[kl\_ggh_�bkdmkkl\h�baeh`_gby��qlh[u�\u^Z\Zlv�aZ�hkh[mx�ij_e_klv�dZ`^uc�_]h�g_^hklZlhd�Y kZf�^mfZx��qlh�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�k^_eZlv�bgZq_�b k�[hevr_c�\u]h^hc�^ey�\Zk��y wlh]h�b ohl_e�Gh�g_�\k_]^Z�fh`gh�\uihegblv� k\hb�[eZ]b_�gZf_j_gby��< kZfhf�fZl_jbZe_�qZklh� aZdexq_ghqlh�lh� lZdh_�� qlh� jmdh\h^bl� >\Zfb@� b m\h^bl� hl� i_j\hgZqZevguo� gZf_j_gbc�� >Z`_� lZdZyg_agZqbl_evgZy�jZ[hlZ��dZd�hj]ZgbaZpby�ohjhrh�agZdhfh]h�fZl_jbZeZ��g_�\iheg_�ih^qbgy_lky\he_� Z\lhjZ�� hgZ� b^_l�� dZd� ohq_l�� b lhevdh� iha`_�fh`gh� kijhkblv�� k_[y�� ihq_fm� hgZ� \ureZlZdhc��Z g_�^jm]hc�<_jhylgh��h^gZ�ba�ijbqbg�\ lhf��qlh�gZa\Zgb_�©<\_^_gb_�\ ikbohZgZebaª�m`_�g_�ih^oh^bld wlhc� qZklb�� ]^_� h[km`^Zxlky� g_\jhau�� <\_^_gb_� \ ikbohZgZeba� khklZ\ey_l� bamq_gb_hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc� b kgh\b^_gbc�� mq_gb_� h g_\jhaZo� ²� wlh� kZf� ikbohZgZeba��G_� ^mfZx�

Page 211: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

qlh[u� fg_� [u� m^Zehkv� aZ� lZdh_� dhjhldh_� \j_fy� ihagZdhfblv� \Zk� k kh^_j`Zgb_f� mq_gby� hg_\jhaZo� bgZq_�� q_f� \ lZdhc� kdhgp_gljbjh\Zgghc� nhjf_��>_eh� aZdexqZehkv� \ lhf�� qlh[u� \h[s_c� k\yab� ihdZaZlv� \Zf� kfuke� b agZq_gb_� kbfilhfh\�� \g_rgb_� b \gmlj_ggb_� mkeh\by� bf_oZgbaf�bo�h[jZah\Zgby��Y b�ihiulZeky�wlh�k^_eZlv��lZdh\Z�ijbf_jgh�kmlv�lh]h��q_fm�fh`_lgZmqblv�ikbohZgZeba�k_]h^gy��Ijb�wlhf�fgh]h�ijbrehkv�]h\hjblv�h eb[b^h�b _]h�jZa\blbb��dh_�qlh�b h� jZa\blbb�Y��;eZ]h^Zjy� \\_^_gbx� \u� m`_� [ueb�ih^]hlh\e_gu� d hkh[_gghklyf� gZr_cl_ogbdb��d hkgh\guf�\a]ey^Zf�gZ�[_kkhagZl_evgh_�b \ul_kg_gb_��khijhlb\e_gb_���GZ�h^ghc�ba[eb`Zcrbo�e_dpbc�\u�magZ_l_��\ q_f�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdZy�jZ[hlZ�gZoh^bl� k\h_�hj]Zgbq_kdh_ijh^he`_gb_��IhdZ�y g_�kdju\Ze�hl�\Zk��qlh�\k_�gZrb�k\_^_gby�hkgh\Zgu�gZ�bamq_gbb�lhevdhh^ghc�_^bgkl\_gghc� ]jmiiu�g_j\guo� aZ[he_\Zgbc��gZ� lZd�gZau\Z_fuo�g_\jhaZo�i_j_g_k_gby�F_oZgbaf�h[jZah\Zgby�kbfilhfh\�y ijhke_^be�\k_]h�ebrv�^ey�bkl_jbq_kdh]h�g_\jhaZ��?keb�\ub g_�ijbh[j_eb�kheb^guo�agZgbc�b g_�aZihfgbeb�dZ`^mx�^_lZev��lh�\k_�`_�y gZ^_xkv��qlh�m \Zkkeh`behkv�ij_^klZ\e_gb_�h lhf��dZdbfb�kj_^kl\Zfb�jZ[hlZ_l�ikbohZgZeba�� aZ�j_r_gb_�dZdbo\hijhkh\�[_j_lky�b dZdbo�j_amevlZlh\�hg�m`_�^hklb]�Y ijbibkZe� \Zf� ih`_eZgb_�� qlh[u� y gZqZe� baeh`_gb_� l_fu� g_\jhah\� k ih\_^_gbyg_j\gh[hevguo��k hibkZgby�lh]h��dZd�hgb�kljZ^Zxl�hl�k\hbo�g_\jhah\��dZd�[hjxlky�k gbfb�bijbkihkZ[eb\Zxlky� d gbf�� Wlh�� dhg_qgh�� bgl_j_kguc� b ^hklhcguc� ihagZgby� b g_� hq_gvljm^guc� ^ey� baeh`_gby� fZl_jbZe�� gh� khfgbl_evgh� gZqbgZlv� k g_]h�� Jbkdm_rv� g_� hldjulv[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� g_� m\b^_lv� ijb� wlhf� [hevrh]h� agZq_gby� eb[b^h� b km^blv� h[h� \k_ohlghr_gbyo�lZd��dZd�hgb�dZ`mlky�Y g_j\gh[hevgh]h��: lh��qlh�wlh�Y gb�\ dh_c�f_j_�g_�gZ^_`gZyb g_� [_kijbkljZklgZy� klhjhgZ�� kh\_jr_ggh� hq_\b^gh�� <_^v� Y²� wlh� kbeZ�� dhlhjZy� hljbpZ_l[_kkhagZl_evgh_�b k\h^bl�_]h�d \ul_kg_gghfm��dZd�`_�fh`gh�\_jblv�_fm�\ lhf��qlh�hgh�[m^_lkijZ\_^eb\h� d wlhfm� [_kkhagZl_evghfm"� Kj_^b� wlh]h� \ul_kg_ggh]h� gZ� i_j\hf� f_kl_� klhylhl\_j]gmlu_� lj_[h\Zgby� k_dkmZevghklb�� kZfh� kh[hc� jZamf__lky�� qlh� fu� gbdh]^Z� g_� kfh`_fmagZlv� h[� bo� h[t_f_� b agZq_gbb� ba� fg_gbc� Y�� K lh]h� fhf_glZ�� dh]^Z� ^ey� gZk� gZqbgZ_lijhykgylvky� ihabpby� \ul_kg_gby��fu� ^he`gu� lZd�`_� hkl_j_]Zlvky� lh]h�� qlh[u� g_� ihklZ\blvkm^v_c�\ wlhf�kihj_�h^gm�ba�kihjysbo�klhjhg��d lhfm�`_�_s_�b ih[_^b\rmx��Fu�ih^]hlh\e_gud lhfm��qlh�\ukdZau\Zgby�Y \\_^ml�gZk�\ aZ[em`^_gb_��?keb�\_jblv�Y��lh�hgh�gZ�\k_o�wlZiZo[ueh� Zdlb\guf�� kZfh� `_eZeh� k\hbo� kbfilhfh\� b kha^Zeh� bo�� Fu� agZ_f�� qlh� hgh� kqblZ_l\hafh`guf� [ulv� \ ba\_klghc� kl_i_gb� iZkkb\guf�� qlh� ohq_l� aZl_f� kdjulv� b ijbmdjZkblv�IjZ\^Z�� hgh� g_� \k_]^Z� j_rZ_lky� gZ� lZdmx� ihiuldm�� ijb� kbfilhfZo� g_\jhaZ� gZ\yaqb\uokhklhygbc� hgh� ^he`gh� ijbagZlv�� qlh� _fm� ijhlb\hihklZ\ey_lky� qlh�lh� qm`^h_�� hl� q_]h� hgh� kljm^hf�aZsbsZ_lky�Dh]h�g_�m^_j`b\Zxl�wlb�ij_^hkl_j_`_gby�ijbgbfZlv�aZ�qbklmx�fhg_lm�ih^^_edb�Y��lhfm�jZamf__lky�� e_]dh�`b\_lky�� b hg� ba[Z\e_g� hl� \k_]h� lh]h� khijhlb\e_gby�� dhlhjh_� ih^gbf_lkyijhlb\� \u^\b`_gby� \ ikbohZgZeba_� gZ� i_j\uc� ieZg� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� k_dkmZevghklb� biZkkb\ghklb� Y�� Lhl� fh`_l� ml\_j`^Zlv�� ih^h[gh� :evnj_^m� :^e_jm� �������� qlh� ©g_j\gucoZjZdl_jª�y\ey_lky�ijbqbghc�g_\jhaZ�\f_klh�_]h�ke_^kl\by��gh�hg�lZd`_�g_�[m^_l�\ khklhygbbh[tykgblv�gb h^ghc�^_lZeb�\ h[jZah\Zgbb�kbfilhfZ�b gb�h^gh]h�kgh\b^_gby�<u� kijhkbl_�� g_evay� eb� kijZ\_^eb\h� hp_gblv� mqZklb_� Y \� g_j\haghklb� b h[jZah\Zgbbkbfilhfh\�� y\gh� g_� ij_g_[j_]Zy� ijb� wlhf� hldjulufb� ikbohZgZebahf� nZdlhjZfb�� Y hl\_qm�

Page 212: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dhg_qgh��wlh�\hafh`gh�b dh]^Z�gb[m^v�ijhbahc^_l��gh�gZqbgZlv�bf_ggh�k wlh]h�g_�\ ljZ^bpbyoikbohZgZebaZ��IjZ\^Z��fh`gh�ij_^kdZaZlv��dh]^Z�wlZ�aZ^ZqZ�\klZg_l�i_j_^�ikbohZgZebahf��?klvg_\jhau��\ dhlhjuo�Y mqZkl\m_l�]hjZa^h�Zdlb\g__��q_f�\ bamq_gguo�^h�kbo�ihj��fu�gZau\Z_f�bo©gZjpbkklbq_kdbfb� g_\jhaZfbª�� :gZeblbq_kdZy� h[jZ[hldZ� wlbo� aZ[he_\Zgbc� ^Zkl� gZf\hafh`ghklv�[_kijbkljZklgh�b \_jgh�km^blv�h[�mqZklbb�Y \�g_\jhlbq_kdhf�aZ[he_\Zgbb�Gh�h^gh�ba�hlghr_gbc�Y d�k\h_fm�g_\jham�gZklhevdh�hq_\b^gh��qlh�_]h�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZfh`gh�ijbgylv�\h� \gbfZgb_��Hgh��ih�\b^bfhfm� \klj_qZ_lky� \h� \k_o� kemqZyo��gh� ykg__� \k_]hh[gZjm`b\Z_lky� ijb� aZ[he_\Zgbb�� dhlhjh_� fu� k_]h^gy� _s_� g_^hklZlhqgh� ihgbfZ_f�²� ijbljZ\fZlb�q_kd^f� g_\jha_��<u� ^he`gu� agZlv�� qlh� \ ijbqbg_� b \� f_oZgbaf_� \k_o� \hafh`guonhjf� g_\jhah\� \k_]^Z� ^_ckl\mxl� h^gb� b l_� `_� nZdlhju�� lhevdh� \ h^ghf� kemqZ_� ]eZ\gh_agZq_gb_�\ h[jZah\Zgbb� kbfilhfh\�ijbh[j_lZ_l�h^bg�ba� wlbo�nZdlhjh\��\ ^jm]hf�²�^jm]hc�Wlh�ih^h[gh�rlZlm�Zjlbklbq_kdhc�ljmiiu��\ dhlhjhf�dZ`^uc�bf__l�k\h_�hij_^_e_ggh_�ZfiemZ�]_jhc�� [ebadbc� ^jm]�� bgljb]Zg� b l�� ^��� gh� ^ey� k\h_]h� [_g_nbkZ� dZ`^uc� \u[_j_l� ^jm]mxiv_km��LZd��nZglZabb��ij_\jZsZxsb_ky�\ kbfilhfu��gb]^�g_�ijhy\eyxlky�[he__�y\gh��q_f�ijbbkl_jbb��ijhlb\hiheh`gu_��beb�j_Zdlb\gu_��h[jZah\Zgby�Y ]hkih^kl\mxl� \ dZjlbg_�g_\jhaZgZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc��lh��qlh�fu�gZa\Zeb�\lhjbqghc�h[jZ[hldhc�\ kgh\b^_gbb��\uklmiZ_l�gZi_j\h_�f_klh�\ \b^_�[j_^Z�ijb�iZjZghc_�b l��^�LZdbf�h[jZahf��ijb� ljZ\fZlbq_kdbo�g_\jhaZo��hkh[_ggh� lZdbo�� dhlhju_� \hagbdZxl�ba�aZm`Zkh\�\hcgu��^ey�gZk�g_khfg_g_g� w]hbklbq_kdbc�fhlb\�Y�� klj_fysbcky�d aZsbl_�b \u]h^_�dhlhjuc�\ h^bghqdm�_s_�g_�kha^Z_l�[he_agv��gh�kZgdpbhgbjm_l�__ b�ih^^_j`b\Z_l��_keb�hgZ�m`_gZqZeZkv��Wlhl�fhlb\�ohq_l�m[_j_qv�Y hl�hiZkghkl_c��m]jhaZ�dhlhjuo�b ihkem`beZ�ih\h^hf�^eyaZ[he_\Zgby�� b g_� ^himklbl� \ua^hjh\e_gby�� ij_`^_� q_f� g_� [m^_l� bkdexq_gZ� \hafh`ghklvih\lhj_gby� wlbo� hiZkghkl_c� beb� ebrv� ihke_� lh]h�� dZd� [m^_l� ihemq_gZ� dhfi_gkZpby� aZi_j_g_k_ggmx�hiZkghklv�Gh� b \h� \k_o� ^jm]bo� kemqZyo� Y ijhy\ey_l� ZgZeh]bqgmx� aZbgl_j_kh\Zgghklv� \\hagbdgh\_gbb� b ihke_^mxs_f� kms_kl\h\Zgbb� g_\jhaZ�� Fu� m`_� kdZaZeb�� qlh� kbfilhfih^^_j`b\Z_lky�lZd`_�b Y��ihlhfm�qlh�m g_]h�g_\jhau�h[gZjm`b\Zxl�g_khfg_ggh_�koh^kl\h�k[he_ag_ggufb� khklhygbyfb�� \hagbdZxsbfb� \ke_^kl\b_� ojhgbq_kdh]h� \ebygby� wdah]_gguoy^h\bluo�\_s_kl\�b hkljh]h�bo�ebr_gby��l��_��k bglhdkbdZpbyfb�b khklhygby�fb�Z[klbg_gibb�H[_�]jmiiu�aZ[he_\Zgbc�_s_�[hevr_�k[eb`Zxlky�^jm]�k ^jm]hf�[eZ]h^Zjy�lZdbf�khklhygbyf�dhlhju_�fu�gZmqbebkv�hlghkblv�lh`_�gZ�kq_l�^_ckl\by�y^h\bluo�\_s_kl\��gh�g_�\\_^_gguo�\hj]Zgbaf�� qm`^uo� _fm�� Z h[jZah\Zgguo� \ ijhp_kk_� kh[kl\_ggh]h� h[f_gZ� \_s_kl\�� dZd�gZijbf_j��ijb�[Za_^h\hc�[he_agb��Y iheZ]Zx��qlh�gZ�hkgh\Zgbb�wlbo�ZgZeh]bc�fu�g_�fh`_f�g_kqblZlv�g_\jhau�ke_^kl\b_f�gZjmr_gby�k_dkmZevgh]h�h[f_gZ�\_s_kl\��[m^v�hgh�ba�aZ�lh]h��qlhwlbo�k_dkmZevguo�lhdkbgh\�ijhba\h^blky�[hevr_��q_f�^Zggh_�ebph�fh`_l�mk\hblv��beb�ba�aZlh]h��qlh�\gmlj_ggb_�b ^Z`_�ikbobq_kdb_�mkeh\by�f_rZxl�ijZ\bevghfm�bkihevah\Zgbx� wlbo\_s_kl\��< gZjh^_�ba^Z\gZ�ijb^_j`b\Zebkv�lZdh]h�\a]ey^Z�gZ�ijbjh^m�k_dkmZevgh]h�`_eZgby�gZau\Zy� ex[h\v� ©hivyg_gb_fª� b kqblZy� \hagbdgh\_gb_� \ex[e_gghklb� ^_ckl\b_f� ex[h\gh]hgZibldZ��i_j_ghky�ijb�wlhf�^_ckl\mxs__�gZqZeh�\ ba\_klghf�kfuke_�gZ�\g_rgbc�fbj��>ey�gZkwlh� [ueh� [u� ih\h^hf� \kihfgblv� h[� wjh]_gguo� ahgZo� b h[� ml\_j`^_gbb�� qlh� k_dkmZevgh_\ha[m`^_gb_� fh`_l� \hagbdgmlv� \ kZfuo� jZaebqguo� hj]ZgZo�� <ijhq_f�� keh\Z� ©k_dkmZevguc

Page 213: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

h[f_g�\_s_kl\ª�beb�©obfbaf�k_dkmZevghklbª�^ey�gZk�g_�bf_xl�kh^_j`Zgby��fu�gbq_]h�h[�wlhfg_� agZ_f� b g_� fh`_f� ^Z`_� j_rblv�� ke_^m_l� eb� gZf� ij_^iheZ]Zlv� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� ^\mok_dkmZevguo�\_s_kl\��dhlhju_�gZau\Zebkv�[u�lh]^Z�©fm`kdbfª�b ©`_gkdbfª��beb�fu�fh`_fh]jZgbqblvky� h^gbf� k_dkmZevguf� lhdkbghf�� \ dhlhjhf� ke_^m_l� \b^_lv� ghkbl_ey� \k_ojZa^jZ`Zxsbo� \ha^_ckl\bc� eb[b^h�K�� Kha^Zggh_� gZfb� gZmqgh_� a^Zgb_� ikbohZgZebaZ� \^_ckl\bl_evghklb�y\ey_lky�gZ^kljhcdhc��dhlhjZy�^he`gZ�[ulv�dh]^Z�gb[m^v�ihklZ\e_gZ�gZ�k\hchj]Zgbq_kdbc�nmg^Zf_gl��gh�ihdZ�fu�_]h�_s_�g_�agZ_f�IkbohZgZeba�dZd�gZmdm�oZjZdl_jbam_l�g_�fZl_jbZe��dhlhjuf�hg�aZgbfZ_lky��Z l_ogbdZ��ijbihfhsb� dhlhjhc� hg� jZ[hlZ_l��;_a� hkh[uo� gZly`_d� ikbohZgZeba�fh`gh� ijbf_gylv� d bklhjbbdmevlmju��gZmd_�h j_eb]bb�b fbnheh]bb�lhqgh�lZd�`_��dZd�b d�mq_gbx�h g_\jhaZo����P_evx�_]hy\ey_lky� g_� qlh� bgh_�� dZd� jZkdjulb_� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� \ ^mr_\ghc� `bagb�� Ijh[e_fuZdlmZevguo� g_\jhah\�� kbfilhfu� dhlhjuo�� \_jhylgh�� \hagbdZxl� ba�aZ� \j_^gh]h� lhdkbq_kdh]h\ha^_ckl\by��g_�^Zxl�\hafh`ghklb�ijbf_gylv�ikbohZgZeba��hg�g_�fgh]h_�fh`_l�k^_eZlv�^ey�boh[tykg_gby�b ^he`_g�ij_^hklZ\blv� wlm� aZ^Zqm�[bheh]bq_kdhfm�f_^bpbgkdhfm�bkke_^h\Zgbx�L_i_jv� \u�� fh`_l� [ulv�� emqr_� ihcf_l_�� ihq_fm� y g_� jZkiheh`be� k\hc� fZl_jbZe� \ ^jm]hfihjy^d_��?keb�[u�y h[_sZe�\Zf�©<\_^_gb_�\ mq_gb_�h g_\jhaZoª��lh��g_khfg_ggh��ijZ\bevguf[ue� [u� imlv� hl� ijhkluo� nhjf� ZdlmZevguo� g_\jhah\� d [he__� keh`guf� ikbobq_kdbfaZ[he_\Zgbyf�\ke_^kl\b_�jZkkljhckl\�eb[b^h��Ijb�h[km`^_gbb�ZdlmZevguo�g_\jhah\�y ^he`_g[ue� [u� kh[jZlv� k jZaguo� klhjhg� \k_�� qlh� fu� magZeb� beb� iheZ]Zeb�� qlh� agZ_f�� Z ijbikbohg_\jhaZo�j_qv�aZreZ�[u�h ikbohZgZeba_�dZd�h \Z`g_cr_f�l_ogbq_kdhf�\kihfh]Zl_evghfkj_^kl\_�^ey�ijhykg_gby� wlbo� khklhygbc��Gh� y h[ty\be�b gZf_j_\Zeky�ijhq_klv� ©<\_^_gb_� \ikbohZgZebaª��^ey�f_gy�[ueh�\Z`g__��qlh[u�\u�ihemqbeb�ij_^klZ\e_gb_�h ikbohZgZeba_��Z g_hij_^_e_ggu_�agZgby�h g_\jhaZo��b ihwlhfm�y g_�fh]�\u^\bgmlv�gZ�i_j\uc�ieZg�[_kieh^gu_^ey�ikbohZgZebaZ�ZdlmZevgu_�g_\jhau��>mfZx�lZd`_��qlh�k^_eZe�^ey�\Zk�[he__�[eZ]hijbylguc\u[hj�� lZd� dZd� ikbohZgZeba� \ke_^kl\b_� k\hbo� ]em[hdbo� ij_^ihkuehd� b h[rbjguo� k\ya_caZkem`b\Z_l�lh]h��qlh[u�ijb\e_qv�bgl_j_k�ex[h]h�h[jZah\Zggh]h�q_eh\_dZ��Z mq_gb_�h g_\jhaZo²�lZdZy�`_�h[eZklv�f_^bpbgu��dZd�b ex[Zy�^jm]Zy�F_`^m�l_f�\u�h[hkgh\Zggh�gZ^__l_kv��qlh�fu�^he`gu�[m^_f�ijhy\blv�g_dhlhjuc�bgl_j_kb d� ZdlmZevguf� g_\jhaZf�� GZk� \ugm`^Z_l� d wlhfm� bo� bglbfgZy� debgbq_kdZy� k\yav� kikbohg_\jhaZfb�� Ihwlhfm� y ohqm� \Zf� khh[sblv�� qlh� fu� jZaebqZ_f� ljb� qbkluo� nhjfuZdlmZevguo� g_\jhah\�� g_\jZkl_gbx�� g_\jha� kljZoZ�� b bihohg^jbx��Gh� b wlh� jZa^_e_gb_� b_hklZehkv� [_a� \hajZ`_gbc�� GZa\Zgby�� ijZ\^Z�� \k_� mihlj_[eyxlky�� gh� bo� kh^_j`Zgb_g_hij_^_e_ggh� b g_mklhcqb\h�� ?klv� \jZqb�� dhlhju_� ijhlb\ylky� ex[hfm� ^_e_gbx� \ imlZghffbj_�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�y\e_gbc��ex[hfm�\u^_e_gbx�debgbq_kdbo�_^bgbp��hl^_evguo�[he_ag_c�bg_� ijbagZxl� ^Z`_� jZa^_e_gby� gZ� ZdlmZevgu_� g_\jhau� b ikbohg_\jhau�� Y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� hgbaZoh^yl� kebrdhf� ^Ze_dh� b ihreb� g_� ih� lhfm� imlb�� dhlhjuc� \_^_l� d ijh]j_kkm��GZa\Zggu_nhjfu�g_\jhaZ�bgh]^Z�\klj_qZxlky� \ qbklhf� \b^_��gh�qZs_� kf_rb\Zxlky�^jm]� k ^jm]hf�b kikbohg_\jhlbq_kdbf�aZ[he_\Zgb_f��Wlb�y\e_gby�g_�^he`gu�aZklZ\eylv�gZk�hldZau\Zlvky�hl�bo^_e_gby��<kihfgbl_�jZaebqb_�mq_gby�h fbg_jZeZo�b mq_gby�h dZfgyo�\ fbg_jZeh]bb��Fbg_jZeuhibku\Zxlky�dZd�hl^_evgu_�_^bgbpu��dhg_qgh��\ k\yab�k l_f��qlh�hgb�qZklh�\klj_qZxlky�\ \b^_djbklZeeh\��j_adh�hl]jZgbq_gguo�hl�hdjm`Zxs_c�kj_^u��DZfgb�khklhyl�ba�kf_kb�fbg_jZeh\�kh_^bgb\rboky�ih�\k_c�hij_^_e_gghklb�g_�kemqZcgh��Z \ke_^kl\b_�mkeh\bc�bo�\hagbdgh\_gby�

Page 214: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

< mq_gbb� h g_\jhaZo� fu� _s_� kebrdhf� fZeh� ihgbfZ_f� oh^� jZa\blby�� qlh[u� kha^Zlv� qlh�lhih^h[gh_�mq_gbx�h dZfgyo��Gh�fu��g_khfg_ggh�� �ihklmibf�ijZ\bevgh��_keb�kgZqZeZ�\u^_ebfba�h[s_c�fZkku�agZdhfu_�gZf�debgbq_kdb_�_^bgbpu��dhlhju_�fh`gh�kjZ\gblv�k fbg_jZeZfb�<_kvfZ� kms_kl\_ggZy� k\yav� f_`^m� kbfilhfZfb� ZdlmZevguo� g_\jhah\� b ikbohg_\jhah\ihfh]Z_l� gZf� magZlv� h[� h[jZah\Zgbb� kbfilhfh\� ihke_^�\bo�� kbfilhfu� ZdlmZevgh]h� g_\jhaZqZklh� y\eyxlky� y^jhf� b ij_^\Zjyxs_c� klZ^b_c� jZa\blby� ikbohg_\jhlbq_kdh]h� kbfilhfZ�Ykg__� \k_]h� lZdh_� hlghr_gb_� gZ[ex^Z_lky� f_`^m� g_\jZkl_gb_c� b g_\jhahf� i_j_g_k_gby�gZa\Zgguf� ©dhg\_jkbhgghc� bkl_jb_cª�� f_`^m� g_\jhahf� kljZoZ� b bkl_jb_c� kljZoZ�� Z lZd`_f_`^m� bihohg^jb_c� b nhjfZfb�� ^Ze__� mihfbgZ_fufb� dZd� iZjZnj_gby� �jZgg__� keZ[hmfb_� biZjZghcy��� <havf_f� ^ey� ijbf_jZ� kemqZc� bkl_jbq_kdhc� ]heh\ghc� [heb� beb� [heb� \ dj_klp_�:gZeba� ihdZau\Z_l� gZf�� qlh� \ j_amevlZl_� k]ms_gby� b kf_s_gby� hgZ� klZeZ� aZf_klbl_e_fm^h\e_l\hj_gby�^ey�p_eh]h�jy^Z�eb[b^haguo�nZglZabc�beb�\hkihfbgZgbc��Gh�dh]^Z�lh�wlZ�[hev[ueZ� j_Zevghc�� b lh]^Z� hgZ� [ueZ� g_ihkj_^kl\_gguf� k_dkmZevgh�lhdkbq_kdbf� kbfilhfhf�khfZlbq_kdbf� \ujZ`_gb_f� eb[b^hagh]h� \ha[m`^_gby��Fu� kh\_jr_ggh�g_� ohlbf� ml\_j`^Zlv�qlh� lZdh_� y^jh� bf_xl� \k_� bkl_jbq_kdb_� kbfilhfu�� gh� hklZ_lky� nZdlhf� lh�� qlh� lZd� [u\Z_lhkh[_ggh�qZklh�b qlh�\k_�²�ghjfZevgu_�b iZlheh]bq_kdb_�²�l_e_kgu_�\ha^_ckl\by�[eZ]h^Zjyeb[b^haghfm� \ha[m`^_gbx� kem`Zl� ij_bfms_kl\_ggh� bf_ggh� ^ey� h[jZah\Zgby� kbfilhfh\bkl_jbb��Hgb�b]jZxl�jhev�lhc�i_kqbgdb��dhlhjmx�fheexkd�h[\heZdb\Z_l�kehyfb�i_jeZfmljZ�LZdbf�`_�h[jZahf�ikbohg_\jha�bkihevam_l�ij_oh^ysb_�ijbagZdb� k_dkmZevgh]h� \ha[m`^_gby�khijh\h`^Zxsb_�iheh\hc� Zdl�� dZd� kZfuc� m^h[guc�b ih^oh^ysbc�fZl_jbZe� ^ey� h[jZah\Zgbykbfilhfh\�Ih^h[guc�ijhp_kk�\uau\Z_l�hkh[uc�^bZ]ghklbq_kdbc�b l_jZi_\lbq_kdbc�bgl_j_k��M ebp�ij_^jZkiheh`_gguo�d g_\jham��gh�g_�kljZ^Zxsbo�\ujZ`_gguf�g_\jhahf��g_j_^dh�[u\Z_l�lZd�qlh�[he_ag_ggh_�l_e_kgh_�baf_g_gb_�²�\hkiZe_gb_�b jZg_gb_A��\uau\Z_l�jZ[hlm�h[jZah\ZgbykbfilhfZ�� lZd� qlh� hgZ� g_f_^e_ggh� ^_eZ_l� ^Zgguc� _c� \ j_Zevghklb� kbfilhf� ij_^klZ\bl_e_f\k_o�l_o�[_kkhagZl_evguo�nZglZabc��dhlhju_�lhevdh�b `^Zeb�lh]h��qlh[u�h\eZ^_lv�kj_^kl\hf\ujZ`_gby��< lZdhf�kemqZ_�\jZq�ba[_j_l�lhl�beb�bghc�imlv�e_q_gby��hg�beb�aZohq_l�mkljZgblvhj]Zgbq_kdmx�hkgh\m��g_�aZ[hlykv�h __�[mcghc�g_\jhlbq_kdhc�i_j_jZ[hld_��beb�[m^_l�[hjhlvkykh� kemqZcgh� \hagbdrbf� g_\jhahf�� g_� h[jZsZy� \gbfZgby� gZ� _]h� hj]Zgbq_kdbc� ih\h^��Mki_oihdZ`_l�ijZ\bevghklv�beb�g_ijZ\bevghklv�lh]h�beb�bgh]h�\b^Z�mkbebc��^ey�lZdbo�kf_rZgguokemqZ_\�_^\Z�eb�fh`gh�^Zlv�h[sb_�ij_^ibkZgby�><:>P:LV�IYL:Y�E?DPBYKljZoM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Lh�� qlh� y kdZaZe� \Zf� gZ� ijhrehc� e_dpbb� h[� h[s_cg_j\haghklb�� \u� ihkqblZeb�� gZ\_jgh_�� kZfuf� g_iheguf� b kZfuf� g_^hklZlhqguf� ba� fhbokhh[s_gbc��Y wlh�agZx�b ^mfZx��qlh�gbqlh�g_�m^b\beh�\Zk�[hevr_��q_f�lh��qlh�\ g_c�gbq_]h�g_[ueh� kdZaZgh�h kljZo_��gZ�dhlhjuc�`Zem_lky�[hevrbgkl\h�g_j\gh[hevguo�� kqblZy�_]h�kZfufm`Zkguf� k\hbf� kljZ^Zgb_f�� b dhlhjuc� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� fh`_l� ^hklbqv� m gbo� ]jhfZ^ghc

Page 215: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

bgl_gkb\ghklb�b ijb\_klb�d kZfuf�[_amfguf�ihklmidZf��Gh��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��\ wlhf�\hijhk_�yg_�ohl_e�[ulv�djZldbf�gZijhlb\�� y j_rbe� hkh[_ggh� xkljh� ihklZ\blv� ijh[e_fm� kljZoZ� m g_j\gh[hevguo� bih^jh[gh�baeh`blv��__ \Zf�KZf� ih� k_[_� kljZo� fg_� g_� gm`gh� \Zf� ij_^klZ\eylv�� dZ`^uc� ba� gZk� dh]^Z�gb[m^v� gZkh[kl\_gghf�hiul_�magZe�wlh�hsms_gb_�beb��ijZ\bevg__� ]h\hjy��wlh�Znn_dlb\gh_�khklhygb_�Gh� y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� gbdlh� gbdh]^Z� ^hklZlhqgh� k_jv_agh� g_� kijZrb\Ze� k_[y�� ihq_fm� bf_gghg_j\gh[hevgu_�bkiulu\Zxl�kljZo�\ ]hjZa^h�[hevr_c� kl_i_gb��q_f�^jm]b_��Fh`_l�[ulvA� wlhkqblZeb� kZfh� kh[hc� jZamf_xsbfky�� \_^v� h[uqgh� keh\Z� ©g_j\gucª� b ©[hyaeb\ucª� mihlj_[eyxl�h^gh�\f_klh�^jm]h]h��dZd�[m^lh�[u�hgb�ha� �< g_f_pdhf�yaud_� ©[hyaeb\uc� �DQJVWOLFK�� ��ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_�hl�keh\Z� ©kljZoª� �$QJVW���<kh\j_f_gghc�ikboheh]bq_kdhc�ebl_jZlmj_� wlh� keh\h� aZqZklmx�i_j_\h^blky� dZd� ©lj_\h`gucª�Fu�khqeb�\hafh`guf�\ gZklhys_f�ba^Zgbb�i_j_\_klb�wlh�keh\h�dZd�©[hyaeb\ucª��l��d��Nj_c^mihlj_[ey_l�wlh�keh\h�\ [he__�h[s_f�agZ�iZqZxl�h^gh�b lh�`_��Gh�fu�g_�bf__f�gZ�wlh�gbdZdh]hijZ\Z�� _klv� [hyaeb\u_� ex^b�� gh� \h\k_� i_� g_j\gu_�� b _klv� g_j\gu_�� kljZ^Zxsb_� fgh]bfbkbfilhfZfb�� m dhlhjuo� g_l� kdehgghklb� d kljZom�� DZd� [u� lZf� gb� [ueh�� g_khfg_ggh�� qlhijh[e_fZ� kljZoZ� ²� maeh\hc� imgdl�� \ dhlhjhf� koh^ylky� kZfu_� jZaebqgu_� b kZfu_� \Z`gu_\hijhku��lZcgZ��j_r_gb_�dhlhjhc�^he`gh�ijheblv�yjdbc�k\_l�iZ�\kx�gZrm�^mr_\gmx�`bagv��G_klZgm� ml\_j`^Zlv�� qlh� fh]m� \Zf� ^Zlv� __ ihegh_� j_r_gb_�� gh� \u�� dhg_qgh�� h`b^Z_l_�� qlhikbohZgZeba�b d�wlhc�l_f_�ih^oh^bl�kh\_jr_ggh�bgZq_��q_f�rdhevgZy�f_^bpbgZ��LZf��dZ`_lky�bgl_j_kmxlky� ij_`^_� \k_]h� l_f�� dZdbfb� ZgZlhfbq_kdbfb� imlyfb� hkms_kl\ey_lky� khklhygb_kljZoZ��Wlh�agZqbl��qlh�jZa^jZ`Z_lky�0HGXOD REORQJDWD��b [hevghc�magZ_l��qlh�kljZ^Z_l�g_\jhahf[em`^Zxs_]h� g_j\Z�� 0HGXOD REORQJDWD ²� hq_gv� k_jv_aguc� b djZkb\uc� h[t_dl�� Y ohjhrhihfgx��kdhevdh�\j_f_gb�b ljm^Z�ihk\ylbe�_]h�bamq_gbx�fgh]h�e_l�lhfm�gZaZ^��Gh�k_]h^gy�y^he`_g�\Zf�kdZaZlv��qlh�g_�agZx�gbq_]h��qlh�[ueh�[u�^Zevr_�hl�ikboheh]bq_kdh]h�ihgbfZgbykljZoZ��q_f�agZgb_�g_j\gh]h�imlb��ih�dhlhjhfm�b^ml�_]h�bfimevku�H kljZo_� fh`gh� fgh]h� jZkkm`^Zlv�� \hh[s_� g_� mihfbgZy� g_j\haghklb�� <u� f_gy� kjZamihcf_l_��_keb�lZdhc�kljZo�y gZah\m�j_Zevguf�\ ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv�g_\jhlbq_kdhfm��J_ZevguckljZo� y\ey_lky�^ey�gZk�q_f�lh� \iheg_� jZpbhgZevguf�b ihgylguf��H g_f�fu� kdZ`_f�� qlh� hgij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� j_Zdpbx� gZ� \hkijbylb_� \g_rg_c� hiZkghklb�� l�� _�� h`b^Z_fh]h�ij_^iheZ]Z_fh]h� ih\j_`^_gby�� k\yaZg� k j_ne_dkhf� [_]kl\Z�� b _]h� fh`gh� jZkkfZljb\Zlv� dZd\ujZ`_gb_�bgklbgdlZ� kZfhkhojZg_gby��Ih� dZdhfm� ih\h^m�� l�� _�� i_j_^� dZdbfb� h[t_dlZfb� b \dZdbo�kblmZpbyo�ihy\ey_lky�kljZo��\ [hevrhc�f_j_��jZamf__lky��aZ\bkbl�hl�khklhygby�gZr_]hagZgby� b hl� hsms_gby� kh[kl\_gghc� kbeu� i_j_^� \g_rgbf� fbjhf��Fu� gZoh^bf� kh\_jr_gghihgylguf�� qlh�^bdZjv�[hblky�imrdb� b im]Z_lky� kheg_qgh]h� aZlf_gby�� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd� [_eucq_eh\_d��mf_xsbc�h[jZsZlvky�k wlbf�hjm^b_f�b ij_^kdZaZlv�^Zggh_�kh[ulb_��\ wlbo�mkeh\byok\h[h^_g�hl�kljZoZ��< ^jm]hc�jZa�bf_ggh�[hevr__�agZgb_�\uah\_l�kljZo��lZd�dZd�hgh�iha\hey_laZjZg__� agZlv� h[� hiZkghklb�� LZd�� ^bdZjv� bkim]Z_lky� ke_^h\� \ e_km�� gbq_]h� g_� ]h\hjysbog_hk\_^hfe_gghfm�� gh� mdZau\Zxsbo� ^bdZjx� gZ� [ebahklv� obsgh]h� a\_jy� ��� Z hiulgucfhj_ieZ\Zl_ev� [m^_l� k m`Zkhf� jZkkfZljb\Zlv� h[eZqdh� gZ� g_[_�� dZ`ms__ky� g_agZqbl_evgufiZkkZ`bjm�� ih� ij_^\_sZxs__� fhjydm� ijb[eb`_gb_� mjZ]ZgZ��Ijb� ^Zevg_cr_f� jZafure_gbb

Page 216: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ke_^m_l�ijbagZlv��qlh�fg_gb_�h j_Zevghf�kljZo_��[m^lh�hg�jZamf_g�b p_e_khh[jZa_g��gm`^Z_lky\ hkgh\Zl_evghc� ijh\_jd_�� ?^bgkl\_ggh� p_e_khh[jZaguf� ih\_^_gb_f� ijb� m]jh`Zxs_chiZkghklb� [ueZ� [u� kihdhcgZy� hp_gdZ� kh[kl\_gguo� kbe� ih� kjZ\g_gbx� k \_ebqbghc� m]jhau� baZl_f�j_r_gb_��qlh�h[_sZ_l�[hevrmx�gZ^_`^m�gZ�[eZ]hihemqguc�bkoh^��[_]kl\h�beb�aZsblZ��Zfh`_l�[ulv��^Z`_�gZiZ^_gb_�Gh�\ lZdhf�kemqZ_�^ey�kljZoZ�\hh[s_�g_�hklZ_lky�f_klZ��\k_��qlh�ijhbkoh^bl��ijhbahreh[u�lZd�`_�ohjhrh�b��\_jhylgh��_s_�emqr_��_keb�[u�kdehgguc�d kljZom�©\hh[s_ª��Z g_�lhevdh�d [_kij_^f_lghfm�kljZom��dZdbf�y\ey_lky�lj_\h]Z����Ijbf_q��j_^�i_j_\h^���Ijh^he]h\Zluc�fha]��eZl���²Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�^_eh�g_�^hreh�^h�jZa\blby�kljZoZ��<u�\b^bl_�lZd`_��qlh�_keb�kljZo�qj_af_jgh�kbe_g��lh�hgdjZcg_�g_p_e_khh[jZa_g��hg�iZjZebam_l�lh]^Z�ex[h_�^_ckl\b_��\ lhf�qbke_�b [_]kl\h��H[uqghj_Zdpby� gZ� hiZkghklv� khklhbl� ba� kf_kb� Znn_dlZ� kljZoZ� b aZsblgh]h� ^_ckl\by�� Bkim]Zggh_`b\hlgh_�[hblky�b [_`bl��gh�p_e_khh[jZaguf�ijb�wlhf�y\ey_lky�[_]kl\h��Z g_�[hyagv�BlZd��\hagbdZ_l�bkdmr_gb_�ml\_j`^Zlv��qlh�ijhy\e_gb_�kljZoZ�gbdh]^Z�g_�y\ey_lky�q_f�lhp_e_khh[jZaguf�� Fh`_l� [ulv�� emqr_fm� ihgbfZgbx� ihfh`_l� [he__� lsZl_evguc� ZgZeyakblmZpbb�kljZoZ��I_j\uf�\ g_c�y\ey_lky�]hlh\ghklv�d hiZkghklb��\ujZ`ZxsZyky�\ ih\ur_gghfk_gkhjghf� \gbfZgbb� b fhlhjghf� gZijy`_gbb�� Wlm� ]hlh\ghklv� h`b^Zgby� ke_^m_l�� g_aZ^mfu\Zykv��ijbagZlv�[hevrbf�ij_bfms_kl\hf��__ `_�hlkmlkl\b_�fh`_l�ijb\_klb�d k_jv_agufihke_^kl\byf��Ba�g__�bkoh^bl��k h^ghc�klhjhgu��fhlhjgh_�^_ckl\b_��kgZqZeZ�[_]kl\h��gZ�[he__\ukhdhc� klmi_gb� ^_yl_evgZy� aZsblZ�� k ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� lh�� qlh� fu� hsmsZ_f� dZd� khklhygb_kljZoZ��Q_f�[hevr_�jZa\blb_�kljZoZ�h]jZgbqb\Z_lky�lhevdh�ih^]hlh\dhc��lhevdh�kb]gZehf��l_f[_kij_iylkl\_gg_c�kh\_jrZ_lky�i_j_oh^� ]hlh\ghklb�d kljZom�\ ^_ckl\b_�� l_f�p_e_khh[jZag_cijhl_dZ_l� \_kv� ijhp_kk�� Ihwlhfm� \ lhf�� qlh� fu� gZau\Z_f� kljZohf�� ]hlh\ghklv� d kljZom�$QJVWEHUHLW�VFKDIW�� �dZ`_lky�fg_�p_e_khh[jZaghc��jZa\blb_�`_�kljZoZ�²�g_p_e_khh[jZaguf�Y ba[_]Zx� ih^oh^blv� [eb`_� d \hijhkm� h lhf�� bf_xl� eb� \ gZr_f� yaud_� keh\Z� ©kljZoª�©[hyagvª�� ©bkim]ª� h^bgZdh\h_� beb� jZagh_� agZq_gb_�� Y lhevdh� iheZ]Zx�� qlh� ©kljZoª� �$QJVW�hlghkblky�d khklhygbx�b g_�\ujZ`Z_l�\gbfZgby�d h[t_dlm��f_`^m� l_f� dZd� ©[hyagvª� �)XUFKW�mdZau\Z_l� dZd� jZa� gZ� h[t_dl��GZijhlb\�� ©bkim]ª� �6FKUHFN��� dZ`_lky�� bf__l� hkh[uc� kfuke�� Zbf_ggh�ih^q_jdb\Z_l�^_ckl\b_�hiZkghklb��dh]^Z�g_�[ueh�]hlh\ghklb�d kljZom��LZd�qlh�fh`gh[ueh�[u�kdZaZlv��qlh�hl�bkim]Z�q_eh\_d�aZsbsZ_lky�kljZohf�Ba\_klgZy� fgh]hagZqghklv� b g_hij_^_e_gghklv� mihlj_[e_gby� keh\Z� ©kljZoª� g_� fh`_lmkdhevagmlv� hl� \Zk�� Ih^� kljZohf� ih� [hevr_c� qZklb� ihgbfZxl� km[t_dlb\gh_� khklhygb_�� \dhlhjh_�ihiZ^Zxl�[eZ]h^Zjy� hsms_gbx� ©jZa\blby� kljZoZª�b gZau\Zxl� _]h� Znn_dlhf��: qlhlZdh_� Znn_dl�\ ^bgZfbq_kdhf� kfuke_"�<h�\kydhf� kemqZ_��g_qlh�hq_gv� keh`gh_��:nn_dl��\h�i_j\uo�� \dexqZ_l� hij_^_e_ggu_� fhlhjgu_� bgg_j\Zpbb� beb� hllhdb� wg_j]bb�� \h�\lhjuo�ba\_klgu_�hsms_gby��ijbq_f�^\hydh]h�jh^Z��\hkijbylby�khklhy\rboky�fhlhjguo�^_ckl\bc�bg_ihkj_^kl\_ggu_� hsms_gby� m^h\hevkl\by� b g_m^h\hevkl\by�� ijb^Zxsb_� Znn_dlm�� dZd]h\hjyl��hkgh\ghc�lhg��Gh�y g_�^mfZx��qlh[u�wlh�i_j_qbke_gb_�aZljZ]b\Zeh�[u�dZd�lh�kmsghklvZnn_dlZ��Ijb�g_dhlhjuo�Znn_dlZo��ih�\b^bfhfm��fh`gh�aZ]eygmlv�]em[`_�b magZlv��qlh�y^jhf�

Page 217: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

h[t_^bgyxsbf� gZa\Zgguc� ZgkZf[evA� y\ey_lky� ih\lhj_gb_� dZdh]h�lh� hij_^_e_ggh]hagZqbl_evgh]h� i_j_`b\Zgby�� Wlh� i_j_`b\Zgb_� fh]eh� [u� [ulv� ebrv� hq_gv� jZggbf\i_qZle_gb_f�\_kvfZ�h[s_]h�oZjZdl_jZ��dhlhjh_�gm`gh�hlg_klb�d ^hbklhjbq_kdhfm�i_� � < kh\j_f_gghc� ikboheh]bq_kdhc� ebl_jZlmj_� ^ey� h[hagZq_gby� wlh]h� ihgylby� mihlj_[eyxlky� l_jfbgu©lj_\h]Zª��©lj_\h`ghklvª���Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\�jbh^m�g_�bg^b\b^Z��Z \b^Z��>jm]bfb�keh\Zfb��Znn_dlb\gh_�khklhygb_�ihkljh_gh�lZd�`_�dZd� bkl_jbq_kdbc� ijbiZ^hd�� b�� dZd� b hg�� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� hkZ^hd� \hkihfbgZgby�Bkl_jbq_kdbc� ijbiZ^hd�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� fh`gh� kjZ\gblv� kh� \gh\v� h[jZah\Zggufbg^b\b^mZevguf� Znn_dlhf�� ghjfZevguc� Znn_dl� ²� k \ujZ`_gb_f� h[s_c� bkl_jbb�� klZ\r_cgZke_^kl\_gghc�G_�^mfZcl_��qlh�kdZaZggh_�a^_kv�h[�Znn_dlZo�y\ey_lky�ijbagZgguf�^hklhygb_f�h[uqghcikboheh]bb��GZijhlb\��wlh�\a]ey^u��\hagbdrb_�gZ�ihq\_�ikbohZgZebaZ�b ijbagZggu_�lhevdh�bf�Lh��qlh�\u�fh`_l_�magZlv�h[�Znn_dlZo�\ ikboheh]bb��gZijbf_j��l_hjbx�>`_fkZ²EZg]h��dZdjZa�^ey�gZk��ikbohZgZeblbdh\��g_ihgylgh�b g_�h[km`^Z_lky��Gh�b gZr_�agZgb_�h[�Znn_dlZo�fulh`_� g_� kqblZ_f� hq_gv� gZ^_`guf�� wlh� ebrv� i_j\Zy� ihiuldZ� hjb_glbjh\db� \ wlhc� l_fghch[eZklb��Gh�ijh^he`m��gZf�dZ`_lky��qlh�fu�agZ_f��dZdh_�jZgg__�\i_qZle_gb_�ih\lhjy_lky�ijbZnn_dl_�kljZoZ��Fu�iheZ]Z_f��qlh�wlh�\i_qZle_gb_�hl�ZdlZ�jh`^_gby��ijb�dhlhjhf�ijhbkoh^bllZdh_� h[t_^bg_gb_� g_ijbylguo� \i_qZle_gbc�� klj_fe_gbc� d jZajy^d_� >gZijy`_gby@� bkhfZlbq_kdbo� hsms_gbc�� dhlhjh_� klZeh� ijhh[jZahf� \ha^_ckl\by� kf_jl_evghc� hiZkghklb� b kl_o� ihj� ih\lhjy_lky� m gZk� dZd� khklhygb_� kljZoZ�� G_\_jhylgh_� ih\ur_gb_� \ha[m`^_gby\ke_^kl\b_� ij_djZs_gby� h[gh\e_gby� djh\b� �\gmlj_gg_]h� ^uoZgby�� [ueh� lh]^Z� ijbqbghci_j_`b\Zgby� kljZoZ�� lZd� qlh� i_j\uc� kljZo� [ue� lhdkbq_kdbf�� GZa\Zgb_� ©kljZoª� �$QJVW�� ²DQJXVWLDH��l_kghlZ��l_kgbgZ��(QJH��²�\u^_ey_l�ijbagZd�kl_kg_gby�^uoZgby��dhlhjh_�lh]^Z�[uehke_^kl\b_f� j_Zevghc� kblmZpbb� b l_i_jv� ihqlb� ihklhyggh� \hkijhba\h^blky� \ Znn_dl_�� FuijbagZ_f� lZd`_� \_kvfZ� agZqbl_evguf� lh�� qlh� i_j\h_� khklhygb_� kljZoZ� \hagbdeh� \ke_^kl\b_hl^_e_gby�hl�fZl_jb��JZamf__lky��fu�m[_`^_guª�qlh�ij_^jZkiheh`_gb_�d ih\lhj_gbx�i_j\h]hkhklhygby�kljZoZ�lZd�hkgh\Zl_evgh�\hreh�\ hj]Zgbaf�[eZ]h^Zjy�[_kdhg_qghfm�jy^m�ihdhe_gbc�qlh� hl^_evguc�bg^b\b^�g_�fh`_l�ba[_`Zlv� Znn_dlZ� kljZoZ�� ^Z`_� _keb� hg��� dZd� e_]_g^ZjgucFZd^mn�� ©[ue� \uj_aZg� ba� l_eZ�fZl_jbª�� l�� _�� g_� agZe� kZfh]h� ZdlZ� jh`^_gby��Fu� g_� fh`_fkdZaZlv�� qlh� y\ey_lky� ijhh[jZahf� kljZoZ� m ^jm]bo� fe_dhiblZxsbo�`b\hlguo��Fu� lZd`_� g_agZ_f��dZdhc�dhfie_dk�hsms_gbc�m wlbo�kha^Zgbc�wd\b\Ze_gl_g�gZr_fm�kljZom�Fh`_l�[ulv��\Zf�bgl_j_kgh�[m^_l�mkeurZlv��dZd�fh`gh�ijbclb�d fukeb��qlh�Zdl�jh`^_gbyy\ey_lky� bklhqgbdhf� b ijhh[jZahf� Znn_dlZ� kljZoZ�� Mfhaj_gb_� ijbgbfZeh� \ wlhf� kZfh_g_agZqbl_evgh_� mqZklb_�� kdhj__�� y ihaZbfkl\h\Ze� wlh� m gZb\gh]h� fure_gby� gZjh^Z�� Dh]^Zfgh]h� e_l� lhfm� gZaZ^� fu�� fheh^u_� [hevgbqgu_� \jZqb�� kb^_eb� aZ� h[_^_gguf� klhehf� \j_klhjZg_�� Zkkbkl_gl� Zdmr_jkdhc� debgbdb� jZkkdZaZe�� dZdZy� \_k_eZy� bklhjby� ijhbahreZ� gZihke_^g_f� wdaZf_g_� Zdmr_jhd�� H^gm� dZg^b^Zldm� kijhkbeb�� qlh� agZqbl�� dh]^Z� ijb� jh^Zo� \hloh^ys_c�`b^dhklb� h[gZjm`b\Z_lky� 0HNRQLXP� �i_j\hjh^guc� dZe�� wdkdj_f_glu��� b hgZ�� g_aZ^mfu\Zykv��hl\_lbeZ��qlh�j_[_ghd�bkiulu\Z_l�kljZo��?_�hkf_yeb�b kj_aZeb��Gh�y \� ]em[bg_^mrb� \klZe� gZ� __ klhjhgm� b gZqZe� ^h]Z^u\Zlvky�� qlh� g_kqZklgZy� `_gsbgZ� ba� gZjh^ZijZ\bevguf�qmlv_f�hldjueZ�\Z`gmx�k\yav�

Page 218: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

L_i_jv�i_j_c^_f�d g_\jhlbq_kdhfm�kljZom��dZdb_�nhjfu�ijhy\e_gby�b hlghr_gby�bf__lkljZo�m g_j\gh[hevguo"�Lml�fh`gh�fgh]h_�hibkZlv�<h�i_j\uo�� fu� gZoh^bf� h[smx� [hyaeb\hklv�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� k\h[h^guc� kljZo�� ]hlh\ucijb\yaZlvky� d ex[hfm� [he__� beb� f_g__� ih^oh^ys_fm� kh^_j`Zgbx� ij_^klZ\e_gby�hdZau\Zxsbc�\ebygb_�gZ�km`^_gb_��\u[bjZxsbc�h`b^Zgby��ih^kl_j_]Zy�ex[hc�kemqZc��qlh[ugZclb� k_[_� hijZ\^Zgb_��Fu� gZau\Z_f� wlh� khklhygb_� ©kljZohf� h`b^Zgbyª� beb� ©[hyaeb\ufh`b^Zgb_fª��EbpZ�� kljZ^Zxsb_�wlbf�kljZohf��\k_]^Z�ij_^\b^yl�ba�\k_o�\hafh`ghkl_c�kZfmxkljZrgmx�� kqblZxl� ex[mx� kemqZcghklv� ij_^\_klgbdhf� g_kqZklvy�� bkihevamxl� ex[mxg_m\_j_gghklv�\ ^mjghf�kfuke_��Kdehgghklv�d lZdhfm�h`b^Zgbx�g_kqZklvy�dZd�q_jlZ�oZjZdl_jZ\klj_qZ_lky� m fgh]bo� ex^_c�� dhlhjuo� g_evay� gZa\Zlv� [hevgufb�� bo� kqblZxl� kebrdhf[hyaeb\ufb� beb� i_kkbfbklbqgufb�� gh� g_h[uqgZy� kl_i_gv� kljZoZ� h`b^Zgby� \k_]^Z� bf__lhlghr_gb_� d g_j\ghfm� aZ[he_\Zgbx�� dhlhjh_� y gZa\Ze� ©g_\jhahf� kljZoZª� b ijbqbkeyx� dZdlmZevguf�g_\jhaZf�<lhjZy� nhjfZ� kljZoZ�� \ ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv� lhevdh� qlh� hibkZgghc�� ikbobq_kdb� [he__k\yaZgZ� b kh_^bg_gZ� k hij_^_e_ggufb� h[t_dlZfb� beb� kblmZpbyfb�� Wlh� kljZo� \ nhjf_qj_a\uqZcgh� fgh]hh[jZaguo� b qZklh� hq_gv� kljZgguo� ©nh[bcª�� Kl_geb� Ohee�� \b^gucZf_jbdZgkdbc� ikboheh]�� \aye� gZ� k_[y� ljm^� ij_^klZ\blv� gZf� \_kv� jy^� wlbo� nh[bc� ih^\_ebdhe_igufb� ]j_q_kdbfb� gZa\Zgbyfb�� Wlh� a\mqbl� dZd� i_j_qbke_gb_� ^_kylb� _]bi_lkdbodZag_c��gh�lhevdh�bo�qbkeh�agZqbl_evgh�ij_\urZ_l�^_kylv��IhkemrZcl_��qlh�lhevdh�g_�fh`_lklZlv�h[t_dlhf�beb�kh^_j`Zgb_f�nh[bb��l_fghlZ��k\h[h^gh_�ijhkljZgkl\h��hldjulu_�iehsZ^b�dhrdb�� iZmdb�� ]mk_gbpu�� af_b��furb�� ]jhaZ�� hklju_� ij_^f_lu�� djh\v�� aZdjulu_� ihf_s_gby�q_eh\_q_kdZy�lheiZ��h^bghq_kl\h��i_j_oh^�fhklh\��ih_a^dZ�ih�fhjx��ih�`_e_aghc�^hjh]_�b l��^�Ijb� i_j\hc� ihiuld_� khjb_glbjh\Zlvky� \ wlhf� kmf[mj_� fh`gh� jZaebqblv� ljb� ]jmiiu�G_dhlhju_�ba�h[t_dlh\�b kblmZpbc��\gmrZxsbo�kljZo��b ^ey�gZk��ghjfZevguo�ex^_c��y\eyxlkyq_f�lh�`mldbf��bf_xl�hlghr_gb_�d hiZkghklb��b ihwlhfm�wlb�nh[bb�dZ`mlky�gZf�ihgylgufb�ohly� b ij_m\_ebq_ggufb� ih� k\h_c� kbe_�� LZd�� [hevrbgkl\h� ba� gZk� bkiulu\Z_l� qm\kl\hhl\jZs_gby�ijb�\klj_q_�kh�af__c��Nh[by�af_c��fh`gh�kdZaZlv��h[s_q_eh\_q_kdZy��b Q��>Zj\bghq_gv�yjdh�hibkZe��dZd�hg�g_�fh]�ih[hjhlv�kljZo�i_j_^�ijb[eb`Zxs_cky�af__c��ohly�agZe��qlhaZsbs_g�hl�g__�lhekluf�kl_dehf��Dh�\lhjhc�]jmii_�fu�hlghkbf�kemqZb��bf_xsb_�hlghr_gb_�dhiZkghklb�� \ dhlhjuo��h^gZdh��fu�ijb\udeb�g_�ijb^Z\Zlv� _c� agZq_gby�b g_� \u^\b]Zlv� __�gZi_j\uc�ieZg��Kx^Z�hlghkblky�[hevrbgkl\h�kblmZlb\guo�nh[bc��Fu�agZ_f��qlh�ijb�ih_a^d_�ih`_e_aghc�^hjh]_�\hagbdZ_l�[hevr_�\hafh`ghkl_c�^ey�g_kqZkl�eh]h�kemqZy��q_f�^hfZ��Z bf_ggh\_jhylghklv�`_e_agh^hjh`gh]h�djmr_gby��fu�agZ_f�lZd`_��qlh�dhjZ[ev�fh`_l�ihclb�dh�^gm��bijb� wlhf�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� ex^b� lhgml�� gh� fu� g_� ^mfZ_f� h[� wlbo� hiZkghklyo� b [_a� kljZoZiml_r_kl\m_f�ih�`_e_aghc�^hjh]_�b ih�fhjx��G_evay�lZd`_�hljbpZlv�\hafh`ghklv�iZ^_gby�\j_dm��_keb�fhkl�jmog_l�\ lhl�fhf_gl��dh]^Z�_]h�i_j_oh^brv��gh�wlh�kemqZ_lky�lZd�j_^dh��qlh�g_ijbgbfZ_lky�\h�\gbfZgb_�dZd�hiZkghklv��B h^bghq_kl\h�bf__l�k\hb�hiZkghklb��b fu�ba[_]Z_f_]h�ijb�ba\_klguo�h[klhyl_evkl\Zo��gh�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�b j_qb�h lhf��qlh[u�fu�g_�fh]eb� _]h\ug_klb� ijb� dZdbo�lh� mkeh\byo� b \k_]h� ebrv� gZ� g_dhlhjh_� \j_fy��Lh�`_� kZfh_� hlghkblky� dq_eh\_q_kdhc� lhei_�� aZdjulhfm� ihf_s_gbx�� ]jha_� b l�� i�� Qlh� gZk� ihjZ`Z_l� \ wlbo� nh[byog_\jhlbdh\�²�lZd�wlh�\hh[s_�g_�klhevdh�bo�kh^_j`Zgb_��kdhevdh�bgl_gkb\ghklv��KljZo�nh[bcijyfh�g_hibkm_f��B bghc�jZa�m gZk�kdeZ^u\Z_lky�\i_qZle_gb_��[m^lh�g_\jhlbdb�[hylky�\h\k_�g_

Page 219: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

l_o�\_s_c�b kblmZpbc��dhlhju_�ijb�ba\_klguo�h[klhyl_evkl\Zo�b m�gZk�fh]ml�\ua\Zlv�kljZo��Zl_o��dhlhju_�hgb�gZau\Zxl�l_fb�`_�bf_gZfb�HklZ_lky� lj_lvy� ]jmiiZ� nh[bc�� dhlhju_� fu� \hh[s_� g_� fh`_f� ihgylv�� ?keb� dj_idbc\ajhkeuc� fm`qbgZ� g_� fh`_l� hl� kljZoZ� i_j_clb� mebpm� beb� iehsZ^v� ohjhrh� _fm� agZdhfh]hjh^gh]h� ]hjh^Z�� _keb� a^hjh\Zy�� ohjhrh� jZa\blZy�`_gsbgZ� \iZ^Z_l� \ [_kkhagZl_evguc� kljZo�ihlhfm�qlh�dhrdZ�dhkgmeZkv�djZy�__ ieZlvy�beb�q_j_a�dhfgZlm�ijhrfu]gmeZ�furv��lh�dZdmx`_�fu�fh`_f� a^_kv� mklZgh\blv� k\yav� k hiZkghklvx�� dhlhjZy��� hq_\b^gh�� \k_�lZdb� kms_kl\m_l^ey� kljZ^Zxsbo�nh[byfb"�< hlghkysboky� kx^Z� kemqZyo�nh[bb�`b\hlguo� g_�fh`_l� [ulv� bj_qb� h[� h[s_q_eh\_q_kdbo� ZglbiZlbyo�� ihlhfm� qlh�� dZd� [u� ^ey� ^_fhgkljZpbbijhlb\hiheh`gh]h�� \klj_qZ_lky� fgh`_kl\h� ex^_c�� dhlhju_� g_� fh]ml� ijhclb� fbfh� dhrdb�qlh[u�g_�ihfZgblv� __ b�g_�ih]eZ^blv��Furv�� dhlhjmx� lZd� [hylky�`_gsbgu�� \ lh�`_� \j_fykem`bl�emqrbf�eZkdZl_evguf�bf_g_f��bgZy�^_\mrdZ��k m^h\hevkl\b_f�kemrZy��dZd�__ gZau\Z_llZd�ex[bfuc��k m`Zkhf�\kdjbdb\Z_l��dh]^Z�\b^bl�fbeh_�fZe_gvdh_�kms_kl\h�k wlbf�bf_g_f��<hlghr_gbb�fm`qbgu��kljZ^Zxs_]h�kljZohf�mebp�beb�iehsZ^_c��fu�fh`_f�^Zlv�_^bgkl\_ggh_h[tykg_gb_�� qlh� hg� \_^_l� k_[y� dZd� fZe_gvdbc� j_[_ghd�� ;eZ]h^Zjy� \hkiblZgbx� j_[_gdZg_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�ijbmqZxl�ba[_]Zlv�lZdbo�hiZkguo�kblmZpbc��b gZr�Z]hjZnh[bd�^_ckl\bl_evghhk\h[h`^Z_lky�hl�kljZoZ��_keb�_]h�dlh�gb[m^v�khijh\h`^Z_l�ijb�i_j_oh^_�q_j_a�iehsZ^v�H[_� hibkZggu_� a^_kv� nhjfu� kljZoZ�� k\h[h^guc� kljZo� h`b^Zgby� b kljZo�� k\yaZgguc� knh[byfb��g_aZ\bkbfu�^jm]�hl�^jm]Z�H^bg� g_� y\ey_lky� [he__� \ukhdhc� klmi_gvx� jZa\blby� ^jm]h]h�� hgb� \klj_qZxlky� \f_kl_lhevdh� \ \b^_� bkdexq_gby� b lh� dZd� [u� kemqZcgh�� KZfZy� kbevgZy� h[sZy� [hyaeb\hklv� g_h[yaZl_evgh�ijhy\ey_lky�\ nh[byo�ebpZ�� \ky�`bagv� dhlhjuo� h]jZgbq_gZ� Z]hjZnh[b_c��fh]ml� [ulv� kh\_jr_ggh� k\h[h^gu� hli_kkbfbklbq_kdh]h�kljZoZ�h`b^Zgby��G_dhlhju_�nh[bb��gZijbf_j�kljZo�iehsZ^_c��kljZo�i_j_^`_e_aghc� ^hjh]hc�� ijbh[j_lZxlky�� [_kkihjgh�� ebrv� \ aj_eu_� ]h^u�� ^jm]b_�� dZd� kljZo� i_j_^l_fghlhc�� ]jhahc��`b\hlgufb�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� kms_kl\h\Zeb� k kZfh]h� gZqZeZ��KljZob� i_j\h]hjh^Z�ihoh`b�gZ�ly`_eu_�[he_agb��ihke_^gb_�dZ`mlky�kdhj__�kljZgghklyfb��dZijbaZfb��M lh]h�dlh� h[gZjm`b\Z_l� wlb�ihke_^gb_�� dZd�ijZ\beh��fh`gh� ij_^iheh`blv�b ^jm]b_�� ZgZeh]bqgu_�>he`_g�ijb[Z\blv��qlh�\k_�wlb�nh[bb�fu�hlghkbf�d bkl_jbb�kljZoZ��l��_��jZkkfZljb\Z_f�bo�dZdaZ[he_\Zgb_��jh^kl\_ggh_�ba\_klghc�dhg\_jkbhgghc�bkl_jbb�Lj_lvy�ba�nhjf�g_\jhlbq_kdh]h�kljZoZ�klZ\bl�gZk�i_j_^�lhc�aZ]Z^dhc��qlh�fu�iheghklvxl_jy_f� ba� \b^m� k\yav� f_`^m� kljZohf� b m]jh`Zxs_c� hiZkghklvx�� Wlhl� kljZo� ihy\ey_lky�gZijbf_j�� ijb� bkl_jbb�� khijh\h`^Zy� bkl_jbq_kdb_� kbfilhfu�� beb� \ ex[uo� mkeh\byo\ha[m`^_gby�� dh]^Z�fu��� ijZ\^Z��fh]eb� [u� h`b^Zlv� Znn_dlb\guo� ijhy\e_gbc�� gh� lhevdh� g_Znn_dlZ�kljZoZ��beb�\ \b^_�ijbklmiZ�k\h[h^gh]h�kljZoZ��g_aZ\bkbfh]h�hl�dZdbo�eb[h�mkeh\bc�bh^bgZdh\h� g_ihgylgh]h� dZd� ^ey� gZk�� lZd� b ^ey� [hevgh]h�� H dZdhc�lh� hiZkghklb� b dZdhf�lhih\h^_�� dhlhjuc�fh]�[u�[ulv� jZa^ml�^h�g__�ij_m\_ebq_gb_f�� \h\k_�g_�fh`_l�[ulv� j_qb��<h\j_fy� wlbo� kihglZgguo� ijbklmih\� fu� magZ_f�� qlh� dhfie_dk�� gZau\Z_fuc� gZfb� khklhygb_fkljZoZ�� kihkh[_g� jZkdhehlvky� gZ� qZklb�� <_kv� ijbiZ^hd� fh`_l� [ulv� ij_^klZ\e_g� hl^_evguf�bgl_gkb\gh� \ujZ`_gguf� kbfilhfhf� ²� ^jh`vx�� ]heh\hdjm`_gb_f�� k_j^p_[b_gb_f�h^urdhc�²� Z h[uqgh_� qm\kl\h�� ih� dhlhjhfm� fu� magZ_f� kljZo�²� hlkmlkl\h\Zlv� beb� [ulv

Page 220: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_ykguf�� b \k_� `_� wlb� khklhygby�� hibkZggu_� gZfb� dZd� ©wd\b\Ze_glu� kljZoZª�� �\h� \k_odebgbq_kdbo�b wlbheh]bq_kdbo�hlghr_gbyo�fh`gh�ijbjZ\gylv�d kljZom�L_i_jv�\hagbdZxl�^\Z�\hijhkZ��Fh`gh�eb�g_\jhlbq_kdbc�kljZo��ijb�dhlhjhf�hiZkghklv�g_b]jZ_l� gbdZdhc� jheb� beb� b]jZ_l� klhev� g_agZqbl_evgmx� jhev�� ijb\_klb� \ k\yav� k j_ZevgufkljZohf��\k_]^Z�y\eyxsbfky�j_Zdpb_c�gZ�hiZkghklv"�B dZd�ke_^m_l�ihgbfZlv�g_\jhlbq_kdbckljZo"�IhdZ�fu�[m^_f�ijb^_j`b\Zlvky�ij_^iheh`_gby��lZf��]^_�_klv�kljZo��^he`gh�[ulv�lZd`_qlh�lh��q_]h�ex^b�[hylky�>ey� ihgbfZgby� g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� kljZoZ� debgbq_kdh_� gZ[ex^_gb_� ^Z_l� gZf� g_dhlhju_mdZaZgby��agZq_gby�dhlhjuo�y ohl_e�[u�\Zf�baeh`blv�Z��G_ljm^gh�mklZgh\blv��qlh�kljZo�h`b^Zgby��beb�h[sZy�[hyaeb\hklv��gZoh^blky�\ l_kghcaZ\bkbfhklb� hl� hij_^_e_gguo� ijhp_kkh\� \ k_dkmZevghc� `bagb�� kdZ`_f�� hl� hij_^_e_ggh]hbkihevah\Zgby� eb[b^h�� KZfuc� ijhklhc� b ihmqbl_evguc� ijbf_j� wlh]h� jh^Z� ^Zxl� gZf� ebpZ�ih^\_j]Zxsb_ky� lZd� gZau\Z_fhfm� g_iheghfm� \ha[m`^_gbx�� l�� _�� m dhlhjuo� kbevgu_k_dkmZevgu_� \ha[m`^_gby�g_�gZoh^yl� ^hklZlhqgh]h� \uoh^Z�� g_� ^hklb]Zxl� m^h\e_l\hjyxs_]hdhgpZ��LZd�[u\Z_l��gZijbf_j�� m fm`qbg� \h� \j_fy�`_gboh\kl\Z�b m�`_gsbg��fm`vy� dhlhjuog_^hklZlhqgh�ihl_glgu�beb�ba�hklhjh`ghklb�khdjZsZxl�beb�ij_ju\Zxl�iheh\hc�Zdl��< wlbomkeh\byo�eb[b^hagh_�\ha[m`^_gb_�bkq_aZ_l��Z \f_klh�g_]h�ihy\ey_lky�kljZo�dZd�\ nhjf_�kljZoZh`b^Zgby�� lZd� b \� nhjf_� ijbiZ^dh\� b bo� wd\b\Ze_glh\�� Ij_ju\Zgb_� iheh\h]h� ZdlZ� bahklhjh`ghklb�� klZ\� k_dkmZevguf� j_`bfhf�� lZd� qZklh� klZgh\blky� ijbqbghc� g_\jhaZ� kljZoZ� mfm`qbg��gh�hkh[_ggh�m `_gsbg��qlh�\h�\jZq_[ghc�ijZdlbd_�j_dhf_g^m_lky�\ lZdbo�kemqZyo�\i_j\mx� hq_j_^v� bkke_^h\Zlv� wlm� wlbheh]bx�� Ijb� wlhf� fh`gh� [_kqbke_ggh_� fgh`_kl\h� jZam[_^blvky��qlh��dh]^Z�ij_djZsZxlky�k_dkmZevgu_�hldehg_gby��g_\jha�kljZoZ�bkq_aZ_l�NZdl�ijbqbgghc�k\yab�f_`^m�k_dkmZevguf�\ha^_j`Zgb_f�b khklhy�\b_f�kljZoZ��gZkdhevdhfg_�ba\_klgh��[he__�g_�hkiZjb\Z_lky�^Z`_�\jZqZfb��dhlhju_�^Ze_db�hl�ikbohZgZebaZ��H^gZdhfh]m�k_[_�ohjhrh�ij_^klZ\blv��qlh�[m^_l�k^_eZgZ�ihiuldZ�i_j_\_jgmlv�hlghr_gb_�b aZsbsZlvfg_gb_��qlh�j_qv�b^_l�h ebpZo��bagZqZevgh�kdehgguo�d [hyaeb\hklb�b ihwlhfm�k^_j`Zgguo�\k_dkmZevghf�hlghr_gbb��Gh�ijhlb\�wlh]h�kh�\k_c�j_rbl_evghklvx�]h\hjbl�ih\_^_gb_�`_gsbg�k_dkmZevgu_� ijhy\e_gby� dhlhjuo�� \ kmsghklb�� iZkkb\gu� ih� ijbjh^_�� l�� _�� hij_^_eyxlkyh[jZs_gb_f� kh� klhjhgu� fm`qbgu�� Q_f� `_gsbgZ� l_fi_jZf_glg__�� q_f� [he__� kdehggZ� diheh\uf� kghr_gbyf�b [he__� kihkh[gZ� d m^h\e_l\hj_gbx�� l_f� kdhj__� hgZ� [m^_l� j_Z]bjh\ZlvkljZohf� gZ� bfihl_gpbx� fm`qbgu� beb� gZ� FRLWXV� LQWHUUXSWXV �� f_`^m� l_f� dZd� lh� `_� kZfh_� moheh^guo�\ iheh\hf�hlghr_gbb�b fZeheb[b^haguo�`_gsbg�b]jZ_l�]hjZa^h�f_gvrmx�jhev�Lh� `_� kZfh_� agZq_gb_� ^ey� \hagbdgh\_gby� khklhygbc� kljZoZ� bf__l� lZd� ]hjyqhj_dhf_g^m_fh_�\ gZklhys__�\j_fy�\jZqZfb�k_dkmZevgh_�\ha^_j`Zgb_��jZamf__lky��ebrv�\ l_okemqZyo�� dh]^Z� eb[b^h�� dhlhjhfm� hldZaZgh� \ m^h\e_l\hjyxs_f� \uoh^_�� \ khhl\_lkl\mxs_ckl_i_gb�kbevgh�b g_�i_j_jZ[hlZgh�ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�iml_f�km[ebfZpbb��J_rZxsbf�fhf_glhf^ey� >\hagbdgh\_gby@� aZ[he_\Zgby� \k_]^Z� y\eyxlky� dhebq_kl\_ggu_�nZdlhju��B lZf�� ]^_�^_ehdZkZ_lky�g_�[he_agb��Z ijhy\e_gby�oZjZdl_jZ��e_]dh�aZf_lblv��qlh�k_dkmZevgh_�h]jZgbq_gb_�b^_ljmdZ�h[�jmdm�k ba\_klghc�[hyaeb\hklvx�b hiZkeb\hklvx��f_`^m�l_f�dZd�[_kkljZrb_�b kf_eZyhl\Z]Z� ijb\h^bl� d k\h[h^_� ^_ckl\bc� ^ey� m^h\e_l\hj_gby� k_dkmZevghc� ihlj_[ghklb�� DZd� gbf_gyxlky�b gb�mkeh`gyxlky�wlb�hlghr_gby�[eZ]h^Zjy�fgh]hh[jZaguf�dmevlmjguf�\ebygbyf��\

Page 221: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kj_^g_f�hklZ_lky�nZdlhf�lh��qlh�kljZo�k\yaZg�k k_dkmZevguf�h]jZgbq_gb_f�Y khh[sbe� \Zf� ^Ze_dh�g_� \k_�gZ[ex^_gby��ih^l\_j`^Zxsb_� ]_g_lbq_kdmx� k\yav�f_`^meb[b^h� b kljZohf�� Kx^Z� _s_� hlghkblky�� gZijbf_j�� \ebygb_� gZ� \hagbdgh\_gb_� kljZoZhij_^_e_gguo� i_jbh^h\� `bagb�� dhlhjuf� fh`gh� ijbibkZlv� agZqbl_evgh_� ih\ur_gb_ijh^mdpbb� eb[b^h�� dZd�� gZijbf_j�� i_jbh^Z� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb� b f_ghiZmau�� < g_dhlhjuokhklhy�gbyo� \ha[m`^_gby�fh`gh� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh� gZ[ex^Zlv� kf_r_gb_� eb[b^h� b kljZoZ� b \dhgp_�dhgph\�aZf_s_gb_�eb[b^h�kljZohf��<i_qZle_gb_�hl�\k_o�wlbo�nZdlh\�^\hydh_��\h�i_j\uo�qlh� ^_eh�b^_l� h gZdhie_gbb� eb[b^h�� dhlhjh_� ebrZ_lky� k\h_]h� ghjfZevgh]h� ijbf_g_gby�� \h�\lhjuo��qlh�ijb� wlhf�gZoh^brvky�bkdexqbl_evgh�\ h[eZklb�khfZlbq_kdbo�ijhp_kkh\��DZd�baeb[b^h�\hagbdZ_l�kljZo��kgZqZeZ�g_ykgh��dhgklZlbjm_rv�lhevdh��qlh�eb[b^h�ijhiZ^Z_l��Z gZ�_]hf_kl_�ihy\ey_lky�kljZo�[�� <lhjh_� mdZaZgb_� fu� [_j_f� ba� ZgZebaZ� ikbohg_\jhah\�� \ qZklghklb� bkl_jbb�� FukeurZeb��qlh�ijb�wlhf�aZ[he_\Zgbb�g_j_^dh�gZklmiZ_l�kljZo�\ khijh\h`^_gbb�kbfilhfh\��ghlZd`_� b g_k\yaZgguc� kljZo�� ijhy\eyxsbcky� \ \b^_� ijbiZ^dZ� beb� ^ebl_evgh]h� khklhygby�;hevgu_�g_�fh]ml�kdZaZlv��q_]h�hgb�[hylky��b k\yau\Zxl�_]h�iml_f�y\ghc�\lhjbqghc�h[jZ[hldbk ih^oh^ysbfb� nh[byfb�� lbiZ� nh[bc� kf_jlb�� kmfZkr_kl\by�� m^ZjZ�� ?keb� fu� ih^\_j]g_fZgZebam�kblmZpbx��\uklmib\rmx�bklhqgbdhf�kljZoZ��beb�khijh\h`^Z_fu_�kljZohf�kbfilhfu�lh�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� fh`_f� mdZaZlv�� dZdhc� ghjfZevguc� ikbobq_kdbc� ijhp_kk� g_� khklhyeky� baZf_s_g�n_ghf_ghf� kljZoZ��<ujZabfky�bgZq_��fu� kljhbf� [_kkhagZl_evguc�ijhp_kk� lZd�� dZd[m^lh� hg� g_� ih^\_j]Zeky� \ul_kg_gbx� b [_kij_iylkl\_ggh� ijh^he`Zeky� \ khagZgbb�� Wlhlijhp_kk� lh`_� khijh\h`^Zeky� [u� hij_^_e_gguf� Znn_dlhf�� b lml� fu� magZ_f�� d k\h_fmm^b\e_gbx��qlh�wlhl�khijh\h`^Zxsbc�ghjfZevguc�ijhp_kk�Znn_dl�ihke_�\ul_kg_gby�\ ex[hfkemqZ_� aZf_sZ_lky� kljZohf� g_aZ\bkbfh� hl� k\h_]h� dZq_kl\Z�� Ke_^h\Zl_evgh� _keb� i_j_^� gZfbbkl_jbq_kdh_� khklhygb_� kljZoZ�� lh� _]h� [_kkhagZl_evguc� dhjj_eyl� fh`_l� [ulv� ijhy\e_gb_fkoh^gh]h�qm\kl\Z��l��_��kljZoZ� �Ij_j\Zgguc�iheh\hc�Zdl��eZl�����Ijbf_q�klu^Z�� kfms_gby�� gh� lhqgh� lZd� `_� iheh`bl_evguf� eb[b^haguf� \ha[m`^_gb_f� beb\jZ`^_[gh�Z]j_kkb\guf� \jh^_� yjhklb� b ^hkZ^u�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� kljZo� y\ey_lky� oh^dhcfhg_lhc��gZ�dhlhjmx�f_gyxlky�beb�fh]ml�h[f_gb\Zlvky�\k_� Znn_dlu�� _keb� khhl\_lkl\mxs__kh^_j`Zgb_�ij_^klZ\e_gby�ih^e_`bl�\ul_kg_gbx�\�� Lj_lbc� nZdl� fu� gZ[ex^Z_f� m [hevguo� k gZ\yaqb\ufb� ^_ckl\byfb�� dhlhjuo� kljZom^b\bl_evguf�h[jZahf�dZd�[m^lh�[u�ihsZ^be��Gh�_keb�fu�ihijh[m_f�ihf_RZlv�bf�bkihegblvbo�gZ\yaqb\h_�^_ckl\b_��bo�mfu\Zgb_��bo�p_j_fhgbZe�beb�_keb�hgb�kZfb�j_rZxlky�gZ�ihiuldmhldZaZlvky�hl�dZdhc�eb[h�ba�k\hbo�gZ\yaqb\hkl_c��lh�m`Zkguc�kljZo�aZklZ\ey_l�bo�ih^qbgblvkywlhc� gZ\yaqb\hklb�� Fu� ihgbfZ_f�� qlh� kljZo� [ue� ijbdjul� gZ\yaqb\uf� ^_ckl\b_f� b hgh\uihegyehkv�ebrv�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�ba[_`Zlv�kljZoZ��Ijb�g_\jha_�gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc�kljZo�dhlhjuc� ^he`_g� [ue� [u� \hagbdgmlv�� aZf_sZ_lky� h[jZah\Zgb_f� kbfilhfh\�� Z _keb� fuh[jZlbfky� d bkl_jbb�� lh� ijb� wlhf� g_\jha_� gZc^_f� ZgZeh]bqgh_� hlghr_gb_�� j_amevlZlhfijhp_kkZ�\ul_kg_gby�[m^_l�beb�jZa\blb_�qbklh]h�kljZoZ��beb�kljZoZ�k h[jZah\Zgb_f�kbfilhfh\�beb�[he__�kh\_jr_ggh_�h[jZah\Zgb_�kbfilhfh\�[_a�kljZoZ��LZd�qlh�\ hl\e_q_gghf�kfuke_��ih�

Page 222: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\b^bfhfm��ijZ\bevg__�kdZaZlv��qlh�kbfilhfu�\hh[s_�h[jZamxlky�ebrv�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�h[hclbg_ba[_`gh_�\ ijhlb\ghf�kemqZ_�jZa\blb_�kljZoZ��;eZ]h^Zjy� lZdhfm�ihgbfZgbx�kljZo�dZd�[uhdZau\Z_lky�\ p_glj_�gZr_]h�bgl_j_kZ�d ijh[e_fZf�g_\jhah\�Ba� gZ[ex^_gbc� aZ� g_\jhahf� kljZoZ� fu� aZdexqbeb�� qlh� hl\e_q_gb_� eb[b^h� hl� _]hghjfZevgh]h� ijbf_g_gby�� ba�aZ� q_]h� \hagbdZ_l� kljZo�� ijhbkoh^bl� gZ� ihq\_� khfZlbq_kdboijhp_kkh\��Ba�ZgZebah\�bkl_jbb�b g_\jhaZ�gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc�ke_^m_l�^h[Z\e_gb_��qlh�lZdh_`_�hl\e_q_gb_�k l_f�`_�j_amevlZlhf�fh`_l�\ua\Zlv�lZd`_�hldZa�ikbobq_kdbo�bgklZgpbc��<hl\k_�� qlh� fu� agZ_f� h \hagbdgh\_gbb� g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� kljZoZ�� wlh� a\mqbl� _s_� ^h\hevghg_hij_^_e_ggh��Gh�ihdZ�y g_�\b`m�imlb��dhlhjuc� \_e�[u�gZk�^Zevr_��<lhjmx�ihklZ\e_ggmxi_j_^� gZfb� aZ^Zqm� ²� mklZgh\blv� k\yav� f_`^m� g_\jhlbq_kdbf� kljZohf�� y\eyxsbfkyg_ghjfZevgh�bkihevah\Zgguf�eb[b^h��b j_Zevguf�kljZohf��dhlhjuc�khhl\_lkl\m_l�j_Zdpbb�gZhiZkghklv�� dZ`_lky�� _s_� ljm^g__� j_rblv��Ohl_ehkv� [u� ^mfZlv�� qlh� j_qv� b^_l� h kh\_jr_gghjZaguo�\_sZo��h^gZdh�m gZk�g_l�kj_^kl\Z�hlebqblv�ih�hsms_gbx�j_Zevguc�b g_\jhlbq_kdbckljZo�^jm]�hl�^jm]Z�BkdhfZy� k\yav� gZdhg_p� mklZgZ\eb\Z_lky�� _keb� fu� ij_^iheh`bf� gZebqb_� qZklhml\_j`^Z\r_cky� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb� f_`^m� Y b� eb[b^h�� DZd� fu� agZ_f�� jZa\blb_� kljZoZy\ey_lky� j_Zdpb_c� Y gZ� hiZkghklv� b kb]gZehf� ^ey� h[jZs_gby� \ [_]kl\h�� ihwlhfm� ^ey� gZk_kl_kl\_ggh� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� ijb� g_\jhlbq_kdhf� kljZo_�Y ij_^ijbgbfZ_l� lZdmx� ihiuldm[_]kl\Z�hl�lj_[h\Zgbc�k\h_]h�eb[b^h��hlghkykv�d wlhc�\gmlj_gg_c�hiZkghklb�lZd��dZd�_keb�[uhgZ�[ueZ� \g_rg_c��Wlbf� hijZ\^u\Z_lky�ij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh� lZf�� ]^_�ihy\ey_lky� kljZo�� _klvlZd`_�lh��q_]h�ex^b�[hylky��Gh�ZgZeh]bx�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�ijh\_klb�^Zevr_��Ih^h[gh�lhfm�dZdihiuldZ� [_]kl\Z� hl� \g_rg_c� hiZkghklb� kf_gy_lky� klhcdhklvx� b p_e_khh[jZagufb� f_jZfbaZsblu�� lZd� b jZa\blb_� g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� kljZoZ� mklmiZ_l� h[jZah\Zgbx� kbfilhfh\�� dhlhjh_kdh\u\Z_l�kljZo�L_i_jv�\ ijhp_kk_�ihgbfZgby�\hagbdZ_l�^jm]h_�aZljm^g_gb_��KljZo��hagZqZxsbc�[_]kl\h�Yhl�k\h_]h�eb[b^h��kZf��h^gZdh��ijhbkoh^bl�ba�wlh]h�eb[b^h��Wlh�g_ykgh�b gZihfbgZ_l�h lhf�qlh��\ kmsghklb��eb[b^h�dZdh]h�lh�ebpZ�ijbgZ^e_`bl�_fm�b g_�fh`_l�ijhlb\hihklZ\eylvky�dZdqlh�lh� \g_rg__�� Wlh� _s_� l_fgZy� ^ey� gZk� h[eZklv� lhibq_kdhc�^bgZfbdb� jZa\blby� kljZoZ�g_ba\_klgh��dZdb_�ijb�wlhf�jZkoh^mxlky�^mr_\gu_�wg_j]bb�b ba�dZdbo�ikbobq_kdbo�kbkl_f��Yg_�fh]m�h[_sZlv�\Zf�hl\_lblv�b gZ�wlb�\hijhku��gh�g_�[m^_f�mimkdZlv�\hafh`ghklv�ihclb�ih^\mf� ^jm]bf� imlyf� b \hkihevam_fky� ijb� wlhf� kgh\Z� g_ihkj_^kl\_gguf� gZ[ex^_gb_f� bZgZeblbq_kdbf� bkke_^h\Zgb_f�� qlh[u� ihfhqv� gZrbf� mfhajbl_evguf� \a]ey^Zf��H[jZlbfky� d\hagbdgh\_gbx� kljZoZ� m j_[_gdZ� b d� ijhbkoh`^_gbx� g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� kljZoZ�� k\yaZggh]h� knh[byfb�;hyaeb\hklv�^_l_c�y\ey_lky�q_f�lh�\_kvfZ�h[uqguf��b ^hklZlhqgh� ljm^gh��ih�\b^bfhfm�jZaebqblv�� g_\jhlbq_kdbc� wlh� kljZo� beb� j_Zevguc�� ;hevr_� lh]h�� p_gghklv� wlh]h� jZaebqbyklZ\blky�ih^�\hijhk�ih\_^_gb_f�^_l_c��Ihlhfm�qlh��k h^ghc�klhjhgu��fu�g_�m^b\ey_fky��_kebj_[_ghd�[hblky�\k_o�qm`bo�ebp��gh\uo�kblmZpbc�b ij_^f_lh\��b hq_gv�e_]dh�h[tykgy_f�k_[_�wlmj_Zdpbx� _]h� keZ[hklvx� b g_agZgb_f�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� fu� ijbibku\Z_f� j_[_gdm� kbevgmxkdehgghklv�d j_Zevghfm�kljZom�b kqblZeb�[u�\iheg_�p_e_khh[jZaguf��_keb�[u�hg�gZke_^h\Zewlm� [hyaeb\hklv�� < wlhf� hlghr_gbb� j_[_ghd� ebrv� ih\lhjye� [u� ih\_^_gb_� i_j\h[ulgh]h

Page 223: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

q_eh\_dZ�b kh\j_f_ggh]h�^bdZjy��dhlhjuc�\ke_^kl\b_�k\h_]h�g_agZgby�b [_kihfhsghklb�[hblky\k_]h�gh\h]h�b fgh]h]h�lh]h��qlh�\ gZklhys__�\j_fy�gZf�agZdhfh�b m`_�g_�\gmrZ_l�kljZoZ��BgZr_fm� h`b^Zgbx� \iheg_� khhl\_lkl\h\Zeh� [u�� _keb� [u� nh[bb� j_[_gdZ� ohly� [u� hlqZklbhdZau\Zebkv�l_fb�`_��dZdb_�fu�fh`_f�ij_^iheh`blv�\ l_�i_j\h[ulgu_�\j_f_gZ�q_eh\_q_kdh]hjZa\blby�K ^jm]hc�klhjhgu��g_evay�g_�aZf_lblv��qlh�g_�\k_�^_lb�[hyaeb\u�\ jZ\ghc�f_j_�b qlh�dZdjZa� l_� ^_lb�� dhlhju_� ijhy\eyxl� hkh[mx� im]eb\hklv� i_j_^� \k_\hafh`gufb� h[t_dlZfb� bkblmZpbyfb�� \ihke_^kl\bb� hdZau\Zxlky� g_j\gufb�� G_\jhlbq_kdZy� ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklvijhy\ey_lky�� lZdbf� h[jZahf��b \� y\ghc� kdehgghklb� d j_Zevghfm� kljZom��[hyaeb\hklv� dZ`_lkyq_f�lh� i_j\bqguf�� b ijboh^brv� d aZdexq_gbx�� qlh� j_[_ghd�� Z iha^g__� ih^jhklhd� [hblkybgl_gkb\ghklb� k\h_]h� eb[b^h� bf_ggh� ihlhfm�� qlh� \k_]h� [hblky�� <hagbdgh\_gb_� kljZoZ� baeb[b^h� l_f� kZfuf� dZd� [u� hljbpZ_lky�� Z _keb� ijhke_^blv� mkeh\by� \hagbdgh\_gby� j_Zevgh]hkljZoZ�� lh� ihke_^h\Zl_evgh� fh`gh� ijbclb� d fg_gbx�� qlh� khagZgb_� kh[kl\_gghc� keZ[hklb� b[_kihfhsghklb� ²� g_iheghp_gghklb�� ih� l_jfbgheh]bb� :�� :^e_jZ�²� y\ey_lky� dhg_qghcijbqbghc�g_\jhaZ��_keb�wlh�khagZgb_�i_j_oh^bl�ba�^_lkdh]h�i_jbh^Z�\ [he__�aj_euc�\hajZkl�Wlh� a\mqbl� lZd� ijhklh� b ih^dmiZxs_�� qlh� bf__l� ijZ\h� gZ� gZr_� \gbfZgb_��IjZ\^Z�� wlhi_j_g_keh� [u� jZaj_r_gb_� aZ]Z^db� g_j\haghklb� \ ^jm]mx� iehkdhklv�� KhojZg_gb_� qm\kl\Zg_iheghp_gghklb�²�Z k�gbf�b mkeh\by�>^ey�\hagbdgh\_gby@�kljZoZ�b h[jZah\Zgby�kbfilhfh\�²dZ`_lky�lZdbf�g_khfg_gguf��qlh�\ h[tykg_gbb�kdhj__�gm`^Z_lky�lh��dZdbf�h[jZahf��ohly�[u�\\b^_� bkdexq_gby�� fh`_l� bf_lv� f_klh� \k_� lh�� qlh� fu� gZau\Z_f� a^hjh\v_f�� : qlh� ^Z_l� gZflsZl_evgh_�gZ[ex^_gb_�[hyaeb\hklb�m ^_l_c"�FZe_gvdbc�j_[_ghd�[hblky�ij_`^_�\k_]h�qm`boex^_c�� kblmZpbb� ijbh[j_lZxl� agZqbfhklv� ebrv� [eZ]h^Zjy� mqZklbx� \ gbo� ebp�� Z ij_^f_lu\hh[s_�ijbgbfZxlky�\h�\gbfZgb_Abrv�iha^g__��Gh�wlbo�qm`bo�j_[_ghd�[hblky�g_�ihlhfm��qlhij_^iheZ]Z_l�m gbo�aeu_�gZf_j_gby�b kjZ\gb\Z_l�k\hx�keZ[hklv�k bo�kbehc��l��_��jZkp_gb\Z_l�bodZd�m]jham�^ey� k\h_]h�kms_kl\h\Zgby��[_ahiZkghklb�b hlkmlkl\by�[heb��LZdhc�g_^h\_jqb\uc�gZim]Zgguc�]hkih^kl\mxsbf�\ fbj_�\e_q_gb_f�d Z]j_kkbb�j_[_ghd�y\ey_lky�hq_gv�g_m^Zqghcl_hj_lbq_kdhc�dhgkljmdpb_c��J_[_ghd�`_�im]Z_lky�qm`h]h�h[jZaZ��ihlhfm�qlh�gZkljh_g�m\b^_lvagZdhfh_�b ex[bfh_�ebph��\ hkgh\ghf�fZl_jb��< kljZo�ij_\jZsZ_lky�_]h�jZahqZjh\Zgb_�b lhkdZ�l�� _�� g_� gZr_^r__� ijbf_g_gby� eb[b^h�� dhlhjh_� l_i_jv� g_�fh`_l� m^_j`b\Zlvky� \ k\h[h^ghfkhklhygbb�b i_j_\h^blky� \ kljZo��<jy^� eb�fh`_l�[ulv� kemqZcguf��qlh� \ wlhc� lbibqghc� ^ey^_lkdh]h� kljZoZ� kblmZpbb�ih\lhjy_lky� mkeh\b_� >\hagbdgh\_gby@� i_j\h]h� khklhygby� kljZoZ� \h\j_fy�ZdlZ�jh`^_gby��Z bf_ggh�hl^_e_gb_�hl�fZl_jb���I_j\u_�nh[bb� kblmZpbc� m ^_l_c� ²� wlh� kljZo� i_j_^� l_fghlhc� b h^bghq_kl\hf�� i_j\ucqZklh�khojZgy_lky�gZ�\kx�`bagv��\ h[hbo�kemqZyo�hlkmlkl\m_l�ex[bfh_�ebph��dhlhjh_�aZ�gbfmoZ`b\Z_l��l��_��fZlv��Y keurZe��dZd�j_[_ghd��[hy\rbcky�l_fghlu��djbqZe�\ khk_^gxx�dhfgZlm�©L_ly��ih]h\hjb�kh�fghc��fg_�kljZrghª�²�©Gh�qlh�l_[_�hl�wlh]h"�Lu�`_�f_gy�g_�\b^brvª�GZ� qlh� j_[_ghd� hl\_qZ_l�� ©Dh]^Z� dlh�lh� ]h\hjbl�� klZgh\blky� k\_le__ª�� LhkdZ� \ l_fghl_ij_h[jZam_lky�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� \ kljZo� i_j_^� l_fghlhc��Fu� ^Ze_db� hl� lh]h�� qlh[u� kqblZlvg_\jhlbq_kdbc� kljZo� ebrv� \lhjbqguf� b hkh[uf� kemqZ_f� j_Zevgh]h� kljZoZ�� kdhj__�� fum[_`^Z_fky��qlh�m fZe_gvdh]h�j_[_gdZ�\ \b^_�j_Zevgh]h�kljZoZ�ijhy\ey_lky�g_qlh� lZdh_��qlhbf__l� k g_\jhlbq_kdbf� kljZohf� kms_kl\_ggmx� h[smx� q_jlm� ²� \hagbdgh\_gb_� ba

Page 224: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_bkihevah\Zggh]h�eb[b^h��GZklhysbc�j_Zevguc�kljZo�j_[_ghd�dZd�[m^lh�fZeh�bkiulu\Z_l��<h\k_o� kblmZpbyo�� dhlhju_� iha^g__� fh]ml� klZlv� mkeh\byfb� >^ey� \hagbdgh\_gby@� nh[bc�²gZ\ukhl_��gZ�madhf�fhklbd_�gZ^�\h^hc��ijb�ih_a^d_�ih�`_e_aghc�^hjh]_�b ih�fhjx�²�j_[_ghd�g_ijhy\ey_l� kljZoZ�� b ijhy\ey_l� _]h� l_f� f_gvr_�� q_f� [he__� hg� g_k\_^ms�� ;ueh� [u� hq_gv`_eZl_evgh�� _keb� [u� hg� mgZke_^h\Ze� ih[hevr_� lZdbo� aZsbsZxsbo�`bagv� bgklbgdlh\�� wlbf[ueZ� [u� hq_gv� h[e_]q_gZ� aZ^ZqZ� gZ^ahjZ� >gZ^� gbf@�� dhlhjuc� ^he`_g� ij_iylkl\h\Zlv� lhfm�qlh[u� j_[_ghd� ih^\_j]Zeky� lh� h^ghc�� lh� ^jm]hc� hiZkghklb��Gh� \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� j_[_ghdkgZqZeZ�i_j_hp_gb\Z_l�k\hb�kbeu�b k\h[h^_g�hl� kljZoZ��ihlhfm�qlh�g_� agZ_l�hiZkghkl_c��Hg[m^_l�[_]Zlv�ih�djZx�\h^u��\e_aZlv�gZ�dZjgba�hdgZ��b]jZlv�k hkljufb�ij_^f_lZfb�b k�h]g_f�dhjhq_��^_eZlv�\k_��qlh�fh`_l� _fm�ih\j_^blv�b \ua\Zlv�[_kihdhckl\h�gyg_d��B _keb� \ dhgp_dhgph\� m g_]h� ijhkuiZ_lky� j_Zevguc� kljZo�� lh� wlh�� g_khfg_ggh�� ^_eh� \hkiblZgby�� lZd� dZdg_evay�iha\heylv��qlh[u�hg�gZmqbeky�\k_fm�gZ�kh[kl\_gghf�hiul_�?keb� \klj_qZxlky� ^_lb�� dhlhju_� b^ml� ^Zevr_� ih� imlb� wlh]h� \hkiblZgby� kljZoZ�� b kZfbaZl_f� gZoh^yl� hiZkghklb�� h dhlhjuo� bo� g_� ij_^mij_`^Zeb�� lh� \ hlghr_gbb� gbo� \iheg_^hklZlhqgh� h[tykg_gby�� qlh� \ bo� dhgklblmpbb� bf_ehkv� [hevr__� dhebq_kl\h� eb[b^haghcihlj_[ghklb�beb�qlh�hgb�ij_`^_\j_f_ggh�[ueb�ba[Zeh\Zgu�eb[b^haguf�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f�G_m^b\bl_evgh��qlh�kj_^b�wlbo�^_l_c�gZoh^ylky�b [m^msb_�g_j\gh[hevgu_��\_^v�fu�agZ_f�qlh�\hagbdgh\_gb_�g_\jhaZ�[hevr_�\k_]h�h[mkeh\eb\Z_lky�g_kihkh[ghklvx�^ebl_evgh_� \j_fy\ughkblv�agZqbl_evgh_�gZdhie_gb_�eb[b^h��<u�aZf_qZ_l_��qlh�b dhgklblmpbhgZevguc�fhf_glihemqZ_l� ijb� wlhf� k\hb� ijZ\Z�� ohly� \ gbo� _fm�� ijZ\^Z�� fu� gbdh]^Z� g_� hldZau\Zeb�� Fu\hajZ`Z_f�ebrv�ijhlb\�lh]h��qlh�ba�aZ�wlh]h�ijblyaZgby�ij_g_[j_]Zxl�\k_fb�^jm]bfb�b \\h^yldhgklblmpbhgZevguc�nZdlhj� ^Z`_� lZf�� ]^_� _fm�� kh]eZkgh� h[sbf� j_amevlZlZf� gZ[ex^_gby� bZgZebaZ��g_�f_klh�eb[h�hg�aZgbfZ_l�ih�agZqbfhklb�kZfh_�ihke_^g__�f_klh�Iha\hevl_� gZf� h[h[sblv� k\_^_gby� ba� gZ[ex^_gbc� h [hyaeb\hklb� ^_l_c�� bgnZglbevguckljZo� bf__l� hq_gv� fZeh� h[s_]h� k j_Zevguf� kljZohf� b�� gZh[hjhl�� hq_gv� [ebahd� dg_\jhlbq_kdhfm�kljZom�\ajhkeuo��DZd�b ihke_^gbc��hg�\hagbdZ_l�ba�g_bkihevah\Zggh]h�eb[b^hb aZf_sZ_l�g_^hklZxsbc�h[t_dl�ex[\b�\g_rgbf�ij_^f_lhf�beb�kblmZpb_c�L_i_jv�\u�k m^h\hevkl\b_f�mkeurbl_��qlh�ZgZeba�nh[bc�g_�fh`_l�^Zlv�fgh]h�gh\h]h��Ijbgbo��kh[kl\_ggh��ijhbkoh^bl� lh�`_�kZfh_��qlh�ijb�^_lkdhf�kljZo_��g_bkihevah\Zggh_�eb[b^h[_kij_ju\gh�ij_\jZsZ_lky�\ dZ`msbcky�j_Zevguf�kljZo��b lZdbf�h[jZahf�fZe_crZy�\g_rgyyhiZkghklv�aZf_sZ_l�lj_[h\Zgby�eb[b^h��< wlhf�khhl\_lkl\bb�g_l�gbq_]h�kljZggh]h��ihlhfm�qlh^_lkdb_�nh[bb�y\eyxlky�g_�lhevdh�ijhh[jZahf�[he__�iha^gbo��ijbqbkey_fuo�gZfb�d bkl_jbbkljZoZ�� gh� b g_ihkj_^kl\_gghc� bo� ij_^ihkuedhc� b ij_ex^b_c�� Ex[Zy� bkl_jbq_kdZy� nh[by\hkoh^bl� d ^_lkdhfm� kljZom� b ijh^he`Z_l� _]h�� ^Z`_� _keb� hgZ� bf__l� ^jm]h_� kh^_j`Zgb_� b�ke_^h\Zl_evgh�� ^he`gZ� [ulv� bgZq_� gZa\ZgZ�� JZaebqb_� h[hbo� aZ[he_\Zgbc� djh_lky� \ >bo@f_oZgbaf_��>ey�ij_\jZs_gby�eb[b^h�\ kljZo�m \ajhkeh]h�g_^hklZlhqgh�lh]h��qlh[u�eb[b^h�\nhjf_� lhkdb�hdZaZehkv�g_bkihevah\Zgguf�\ ^Zgguc�fhf_gl��Hg�^Z\gh�gZmqbeky�^_j`Zlv�_]hk\h[h^guf�b bkihevah\Zlv�ih�^jm]hfm��Gh�_keb�eb[b^h�hlghkblky�d ikbobq_kdhfm�bfimevkm�ih^\_j]r_fmky�\ul_kg_gbx��lh�kha^Zxlky�lZdb_�`_�mkeh\by��dZd�m j_[_gdZ��m dhlhjh]h�_s_�g_ljZa^_e_gby�gZ�khagZl_evgh_�b [_kkhagZl_evgh_��b [eZ]h^Zjy�j_]j_kkbb�gZ�bgnZglbevgmx�nh[bxdZd�[u�hldju\Z_lky�ijhoh^��ih�dhlhjhfm�e_]dh�hkms_kl\ey_lky�ij_\jZs_gb_�eb[b^h�\ kljZo�

Page 225: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

DZd� \u�ihfgbl_��fu�fgh]h� ]h\hjbeb� h \ul_kg_gbb��gh�ijb� wlhf� \k_]^Z�ijhke_`b\Zeb� ebrvkm^v[m�ih^e_`Zs_]h�\ul_kg_gbx�ij_^klZ\e_gby��jZamf__lky��ihlhfm��qlh�__ e_]q_�[ueh�magZlvb baeh`blv�� Lh�� qlh� ijhbkoh^bl� k Znn_dlhf�� dhlhjuc� [ue� k\yaZg� k \ul_kg_ggufij_^klZ\e_gb_f��fu�hklZ\eyeb�\ klhjhg_�b lhevdh�l_i_jv�magZeb��qlh�[eb`ZcrZy�mqZklv�wlh]hZnn_dlZ� khklhbl� \ ij_\jZs_gbb� \ kljZo�� \ nhjf_� dhlhjh]h� hg� \k_]^Z� ijhy\beky� [u� ijbghjfZevghf� l_q_gbb��Gh� wlh� ij_\jZs_gb_� Znn_dlZ�²� ]hjZa^h� [he__� \Z`gZy� qZklv� ijhp_kkZ\ul_kg_gby�� H[� wlhf� g_� lZd�lh� e_]dh� ]h\hjblv�� ihlhfm� qlh� fu� g_� fh`_f� ml\_j`^Zlv�� qlhkms_kl\mxl�[_kkhagZl_evgu_�Znn_dlu�\ lhf�`_�kfuke_��dZd�[_kkhagZl_evgu_�ij_^klZ\e_gby�Ij_^klZ\e_gb_�hklZ_lky�l_f�`_�g_aZ\bkbfh�hl�lh]h��khagZl_evgh�hgh�beb�[_kkhagZl_evgh��fufh`_f� mdZaZlv�� qlh� khhl\_lkl\m_l� [_kkhagZl_evghfm� ij_^klZ\e_gbx�� Gh� h[� Znn_dl_�y\eyxs_fky�ijhp_kkhf�jZajy^db� >gZijy`_gby@� �$EIXKUYRUJDQJ���ke_^m_l�km^blv�kh\k_f�bgZq_�q_f� h ij_^klZ\e_gbb��qlh� _fm� khhl\_lkl\m_l� \ [_kkhagZl_evghf��g_evay� kdZaZlv�[_a� ]em[hdbojZa^mfbc�b \uykg_gby�gZrbo�ij_^ihkuehd�h ikbobq_kdbo�ijhp_kkZo��Wlh]h�fu�a^_kv�g_�fh`_fij_^ijbgylv��Gh�^Z\Zcl_�khojZgbf�ihemq_ggh_�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�jZa\blb_�kljZoZ�l_kgh�k\yaZghk kbkl_fhc�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�Y kdZaZe��qlh�ij_\jZs_gb_�\ kljZo��beb��emqr_��jZajy^dZ��$EIXKU��\ nhjf_�kljZoZ��y\ey_lky[eb`Zcr_c� mqZklvx� ih^\_j]gmlh]h� \ul_kg_gbx� eb[b^h��>he`_g� ^h[Z\blv�� g_� _^bgkl\_gghcbeb� hdhgqZl_evghc��Ijb� g_\jhaZo� jZa\b\Zxlky� ijhp_kku�� klj_fysb_ky� k\yaZlv� wlh� jZa\blb_kljZoZ��b wlh�bf�m^Z_lky�jZaebqgufb�imlyfb��Ijb�nh[byo��gZijbf_j��fh`gh�ykgh�jZaebqblv�^\_nZau� g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� ijhp_kkZ��I_j\Zy� hkms_kl\ey_l� \ul_kg_gb_� b i_j_\h^� eb[b^h� \ kljZo�k\yaZgguc� k \g_rg_c� hiZkghklvx�� <lhjZy� aZdexqZ_lky� \ \u^\b`_gbb� \k_o� l_oij_^hklhjh`ghkl_c�b ij_^mij_`^_gbc��[eZ]h^Zjy�q_fm�ij_^hl\jZsZ_lky�klhedgh\_gb_�k wlhchiZkghklvx�� dhlhjZy� kqblZ_lky� \g_rg_c�� <ul_kg_gb_� khhl\_lkl\m_l� ihiuld_� [_]kl\Z� Y hleb[b^h�� \hkijbgbfZ_fh]h� dZd� hiZkghklv��Nh[bx�fh`gh� kjZ\gblv� k hdhihf� ijhlb\� \g_rg_chiZkghklb�� dhlhjmx� l_i_jv�ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� \gmrZxs__� kljZo� eb[b^h��KeZ[hklv� kbkl_fuaZsblu� ijb� nh[byo� aZdexqZ_lky�� dhg_qgh�� \ lhf�� qlh� dj_ihklv�� gZklhevdh� mdj_ie_ggZy� k\g_rg_c� klhjhgvl�� hklZ_lky� hldjulhc� ^ey� gZiZ^_gby� k \gmlj_gg_c�� Ijh_dpby� eb[b^haghchiZkghklb� \h\g_� gbdh]^Z� g_� fh`_l� m^Zklvky� \iheg_�� Ihwlhfm� ijb� ^jm]bo� g_\jhaZomihlj_[eyxlky� ^jm]b_� kbkl_fu� aZsblu� ijhlb\� \hafh`gh]h� jZa\blby� kljZoZ�� Wlh� hq_gvbgl_j_kgZy� h[eZklv� ikboheh]bb� g_\jhah\�� d kh`Ze_gbx�� hgZ� m\_^_l� gZk� kebrdhf� ^Ze_dh� bij_^iheZ]Z_l�[he__�hkgh\Zl_evgu_�ki_pbZevgu_�agZgby��Y ohqm�^h[Z\blv�_s_�lhevdh�h^gh��Ym`_� ]h\hjbe� \Zf� h ©ijhlb\h^_ckl\bbª �� d dhlhjhfm�Y ijb[_]Z_l� ijb� \ul_kg_gbb� b ^he`ghihklhyggh� _]h� ih^^_j`b\Zlv�� qlh[u� \ul_kg_gb_� hkms_kl\behkv�� GZ� wlh� ijhlb\h^_ckl\b_\haeZ]Z_lky�fbkkby�\hiehlblv�\ `bagv�jZaebqgu_�nhjfu�aZsblu�ijhlb\�jZa\blby�kljZoZ�ihke_\ul_kg_gby�<_jg_fky� d nh[byf�� L_i_jv�� ih`Zemc�� y fh]m� kdZaZlv�� \u� ihgbfZ_l_�� gZkdhevdhg_^hklZlhqgh�h[tykgylv�bo�lhevdh�kh^_j`Zgb_f��bgl_j_kmykv�ebrv�l_f��hldm^Z�ijhbkoh^bl�lh�qlh� lhl� beb� bghc� h[t_dl� beb� dZdZy�lh� kblmZpby� klZgh\blky� ij_^f_lhf� nh[bb�� Kh^_j`Zgb_nh[bb� bf__l� ^ey� g__� ijbf_jgh� lh� `_� agZq_gb_�� dZdh_� y\gZy� qZklv� kgh\b^_gby� ^ey� \k_]hkgh\b^_gby�� Kh[ex^Zy� g_h[oh^bfu_� h]jZgbq_gby�� ke_^m_l� ijbagZlv�� qlh� kj_^b� wlbokh^_j`Zgbc�nh[bc� gZoh^ylky� lZdb_�� dhlhju_�� dZd� ih^q_jdb\Z_l�Kl_geb�Ohee� ��� fh]ml� klZlvh[t_dlZfb�kljZoZ�[eZ]h^Zjy�nbeh]_g_lbq_kdhfm�mgZke_^h\Zgbx��K wlbf�kh]eZkm_lky�b lh��qlh

Page 226: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fgh]b_� ba� wlbo� \gmrZxsbo� kljZo� \_s_c� fh]ml� bf_lv� k hiZkghklvx� lhevdh� kbf\hebq_kdmxk\yav�LZd�fu�m[_^bebkv��dZdh_��fh`gh�kdZaZlv��p_gljZevgh_�f_klh�kj_^b�\hijhkh\�ikboheh]bbg_\jhah\� aZgbfZ_l� ijh[e_fZ� kljZoZ�� GZ� gZk� ijhba\_eh� kbevgh_� \i_qZle_gb_� lh�� gZkdhevdhjZa\blb_� kljZoZ� k\yaZgh� k km^v[Zfb� eb[b^h� b k� kbkl_fhc� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� Lhevdh� h^bgfhf_gl�fu�\hk�©DhgljaZiheg_gbyª�>wg_j]b_c@�ijbgbfZ_f�dZd�\uiZ^Zxsbc�ba�k\yab��dZd�ijh[_e�\ gZr_f�ihgbfZgbb�²�wlh�lhl�ljm^ghhkiZjb\Z_fuc�nZdl��qlh�j_Zevguc�kljZo�^he`_g�jZkkfZljb\Zlvky�dZd�ijhy\e_gb_�bgklbgdlh\kZfhkhojZg_gby�Y�

><:>P:LV�R?KL:Y�E?DPBYL_hjby�eb[b^h�b gZjpbkkbafM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Fu� g_h^ghdjZlgh� b ebrv� g_^Z\gh� \gh\v� bf_eb� ^_eh� kjZa^_e_gb_f�bgklbgdlh\�Y b�k_dkmZevguo�\e_q_gbc��KgZqZeZ�\ul_kg_gb_�gZf�ihdZaZeh��qlh�hgbfh]ml�\klmiblv�\ ijhlb\hj_qb_�^jm]�k ^jm]hf��qlh�aZl_f��nhjfZevgh�ih[_`^_ggu_��k_dkmZevgu_\e_q_gby� \ugm`^_gu� ihemqZlv� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� j_]j_kkb\gufb� h[oh^gufb� imlyfb�dhfi_gkbjmy�ijb�wlhf�k\h_�ihjZ`_gb_�k\h_c�g_ij_h^hebfhklvx��>Ze__�fu�magZeb��qlh�hgb�kkZfh]h�gZqZeZ�ih�jZaghfm�hlghkylky�d \hkiblZl_evgbp_�g_h[oh^bfhklb��lZd�qlh�ijh^_eu\Zxlg_h^bgZdh\h_�jZa\blb_�b bf_xl�g_h^bgZdh\h_�hlghr_gb_�d ijbgpbim�j_Zevghklb��GZdhg_p��fuiheZ]Z_f��qlh�k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby�k\yaZgu�k Znn_dlb\guf�khklhygb_f�kljZoZ�]hjZa^h�[he__l_kgufb� maZfb�� q_f�bgklbgdlu�Y��²� j_amevlZl�� dhlhjuc� dZ`_lky�g_iheguf� lhevdh� \ h^ghf\Z`ghf� imgdl_�� Ihwlhfm� ^ey� _]h� ^hihegbl_evgh]h� ih^l\_j`^_gby� fu� ohlbf� ijb\e_qv^hklhcguc�\gbfZgby�nZdl��qlh�g_m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�]heh^Z�b `Z`^u��^\mo�kZfuo�we_f_glZjguobgklbgdlh\� kZfhkhojZg_gby�� gbdh]^Z� g_� \_^_l� d \hagbdgh\_gbx� kljZoZ�� f_`^m� l_f� dZdij_\jZs_gb_�\ kljZo�g_m^h\e_l\hj_ggh]h�eb[b^h��dZd�fu�agZ_f��ijbgZ^e_`bl�d qbkem�kZfuoba\_klguo�b qZs_�\k_]h�gZ[ex^Z_fuo�n_ghf_gh\�Gh�g_evay�hlf_gblv�gZr_�ijZ\h�jZa^_eylv�bgklbgdlu�Y b�k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby��Hgh�^Zgh\f_kl_�k kms_kl\h\Zgb_f�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�dZd�hkh[hc�^_yl_evghklb�bg^b\b^Z��Fh`gh�ebrvkijhkblv��dZdh_�agZq_gb_�fu�ijb^Z_f�wlhfm�jZa^_e_gbx��gZkdhevdh�kms_kl\_gguf�kqblZ_f�_]h�Gh� hl\_l� gZ� wlhl� \hijhk� [m^_l� aZ\bk_lv� hl� hij_^_e_gby� lh]h�� gZkdhevdh� bgZq_� \_^ml� k_[yk_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gby� \ khfZlbq_kdbo� b ^mr_\guo� ijhy\e_gbyo� ih� kjZ\g_gbx� k ^jm]bfb�dhlhju_� fu� ijhlb\hihklZ\ey_f� bf�� b gZkdhevdh� agZqbl_evgu� ihke_^kl\by� wlbo� jZaebqbc�GZklZb\Zlv�gZ�kms_kl\_gghf��ohly�b g_�hq_gv�meh\bfhf�jZaebqbb�h[_bo�]jmii�\e_q_gbc��m gZk�jZamf__lky�� g_l� gbdZdbo� hkgh\Zgbc��H[_� ]jmiiu� \uklmiZxl� i_j_^� gZfb� ebrv� dZd� gZa\Zgbybklhqgbdh\�wg_j]bb�bg^b\b^Z��b ^bkdmkkby�h lhf��y\eyxlky�eb�hgb�\ hkgh\_�h^gbf�b l_f�`_�bebkms_kl\_ggh�jZaebqguf��b _keb�h^gbf��lh�]^_�hgb�hl^_ebebkv�^jm]�hl�^jm]Z"���^he`gZ�\_klbkvg_�h ihgylbyo��Z h�[bheh]bq_kdbo�nZdlZo��klhysbo�aZ�gbfb��H[�wlhf�fu�ihdZ�agZ_f�kebrdhf

Page 227: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fZeh�� Z _keb� [u� ^Z`_� agZeb� [hevr_�� lh� d gZr_c� ZgZeblbq_kdhc� aZ^Zq_� wlh� g_� bf_eh� [uhlghr_gby�Fu�� hq_\b^gh�� lZd`_� hq_gv� fZeh� \ub]jZ_f�� _keb� ih� ijbf_jm� Xg]Z� ih^q_jdg_fi_j\hgZqZevgh_�_^bgkl\h�\k_o�\e_q_gbc�b gZah\_f�©eb[b^hª�ijhy\eyxsmxky�\h�\k_f�wg_j]bx�LZdA� dZd� k_dkmZevgmx� nmgdpbx� g_evay� mkljZgblv� ba� ^mr_\ghc� `bagb� gbdZdbfbbkdmkkl\_ggufb� ijb_fZfb�� lh� fu� [ueb� [u� \ugm`^_gu� lh]^Z� ]h\hjblv� h k_dkmZevghf� bZk_dkmZevghf�eb[b^h��H^gZdh�^ey�^\b`msbo�kbe�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�khojZgbf�ih�ijZ\m��dZdfu�wlh�b ^_eZeb�^h�kbo�ihj��gZa\Zgb_�eb[b^h�Y ^mfZx�ihwlhfm��qlh� \hijhk�h lhf�� dZd�^Ze_dh� ke_^m_l� \_klb�g_khfg_ggh� hijZ\^Zggh_jZa^_e_gb_�gZ�k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby�b bgklbgdlu�kZfhkhojZg_gby��^ey�ikbohZgZebaZ�[hevrh]hagZq_gby� g_� bf__l�� ^Z� hg� b g_� dhfi_l_gl_g� \ wlhf�� Kh� klhjhgu� [bheh]bb�� jZamf__lky�� _klvjZaebqgu_� hkgh\Zgby� kqblZlv� wlh� jZa^_e_gb_� q_f�lh� \Z`guf�� <_^v� k_dkmZevghklv� ²_^bgkl\_ggZy�nmgdpby�`b\h]h�hj]ZgbafZ��\uoh^ysZy�aZ�ij_^_eu�bg^b\b^Z�b h[_ki_qb\ZxsZy_]h� k\yav� k \b^hf�� G_khfg_ggh�� qlh� __ \uiheg_gb_� g_� \k_]^Z� ijbghkbl� ihevam� hl^_evghfmkms_kl\m��dZd�_]h�^jm]b_�nmgdpbb��Z p_ghc�g_h[udgh\_ggh�\ukhdh]h�gZkeZ`^_gby�ih^\_j]Z_lhiZkghklyf��m]jh`Zxsbf�`bagb�b ^h\hevgh�qZklh�ebrZxsbf�__��<_jhylgh��g_h[oh^bfu�lZd`_kh\_jr_ggh�hkh[u_��hlebqgu_�hl�\k_o�^jm]bo�ijhp_kku�h[f_gZ�\_s_kl\��qlh[u�khojZgylv�^eyihlhfkl\Z� qZklv� bg^b\b^mZevghc� `bagb� \ \b^_� ij_^jZkiheh`_gbc�� B gZdhg_p�� hl^_evgh_kms_kl\h��dhlhjh_��dZd�^jm]b_��kqblZ_l�k_[y�kZfuf�]eZ\guf��Z k\hx�k_dkmZevghklv�kj_^kl\hfk\h_]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� k [bheh]bq_kdhc� lhqdb� aj_gby� ebrv� wibah^� \ jy^m� ihdhe_gbc�djZldh\j_f_gguc� ijb^Zlhd� aZjh^ur_\hc� ieZafu�� gZ^_e_gghc� \bjlmZevghc� [_kkf_jlghklvx�ih^h[gh�\j_f_gghfm�\eZ^_evpm�fZchjZlgh]h�bfms_kl\Z��dhlhjh_�_]h�i_j_`b\Z_l�H^gZdh� ^ey� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h� h[tykg_gby� g_\jhah\� g_� gm`gu� klhev� rbjhdb_h[h[s_gby��K ihfhsvx�bkke_^h\Zgby�\ hl^_evghklb�k_dkmZevguo�\e_q_gbc�b bgklbgdlh\�Y fugZreb�dexq�d ihgbfZgbx�]jmiiu�g_\jhah\�i_j_g_k_gby��Fu�kmf_eb�h[tykgblv�bo�hkgh\gufiheh`_gb_f�� qlh� k_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gby� \klmiZxl� \ [hjv[m� k bgklbgdlZfb� khojZg_gby� beb�\ujZ`Zykv� [bheh]bq_kdbf� yaudhf�� ohly� b f_g__� lhqgh�� qlh� h^gZ� ihabpby� Y dZdkZfhklhyl_evgh]h� hl^_evgh]h� kms_kl\Z� ijhlb\hj_qbl� ^jm]hc� _]h� ihabpbb� dZd� a\_gZ� \ p_ibihdhe_gbc��<hafh`gh��qlh�^h�lZdh]h�jZa^\h_gby�^_eh�^hoh^bl�lhevdh�m q_eh\_dZ��b ihwlhfm�\h[s_f� b p_ehf� g_\jha� y\ey_lky� _]h� ij_bfms_kl\hf� i_j_^� `b\hlgufb�� Kebrdhf� kbevgh_jZa\blb_� _]h� eb[b^h�b klZ\r__��ih�\b^bfhfm�� [eZ]h^Zjy� wlhfm� \hafh`guf�[h]Zlh_� jZa\blb_fgh]hh[jZaghc� ^mr_\ghc� `bagb�� dZd� dZ`_lky�� kha^Zeb� mkeh\by� ^ey� \hagbdgh\_gby� lZdh]hdhgnebdlZ�� Kh\_jr_ggh� hq_\b^gh�� qlh� \ wlhf� aZdexqZxlky� lZd`_� mkeh\by� _]h� [hevrbomki_oh\��dhlhju_�ihklZ\beb�q_eh\_dZ�gZ^�_]h�h[sghklvx�k `b\hlgufb��lZd�qlh�_]h�kihkh[ghklvd g_\jham� ²� wlh� lhevdh� h[jZlgZy� klhjhgZ� _]h� h^Zj_gghklb� \ hklZevghf�� Gh� b wlh� ebrvmfhaZdexq_gby��hl\e_dZxsb_�gZk�hl�gZr_c�aZ^Zqb�>h�kbo�ihj�ij_^ihkuedhc�gZr_c�jZ[hlu�\uklmiZeh� lh��qlh�fu�fh`_f�hlebqblv�^jm]�hl^jm]Z�klj_fe_gby�Y b�k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby�ih�bo�ijhy\e_gbyf��Ijb�g_\jhaZo�i_j_g_k_gby�wlhm^Z\Zehkv� [_a� ljm^Z�� Wg_j]bx�� gZijZ\ey_fmx� Y gZ� h[t_dlu� k_dkmZevguo� klj_fe_gbc�� fugZau\Zeb� ©eb[b^hª�� \k_� ^jm]b_� \b^u� wg_j]bb�� bkoh^ysb_� ba� bgklbgdlh\� kZfhkhojZg_gby�²©bgl_j_khfª��b fu�fh]eb�ihemqblv�i_j\h_�ij_^klZ\e_gb_�h f_oZgbaf_�^mr_\guo�kbe�[eZ]h^Zjy

Page 228: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gZ[ex^_gbx� aZ� ijb\yaZgghklyfb� eb[b^h�� bo� ij_\jZs_gbyfb� b hdhgqZl_evghc� km^v[hc�G_\jhau� i_j_g_k_gby� ij_^hklZ\beb� gZf� ^ey� wlh]h� kZfuc� ih^oh^ysbc� fZl_jbZe�� Gh� Y�� _]hkhklZ\� ba� jZaebqguo� kljmdlmj�� bo� hj]ZgbaZpby� b kihkh[� nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby� hklZ\Zebkvkdjulufb� hl� gZk�� b fu� fh]eb� ij_^iheZ]Zlv�� qlh� lhevdh� ZgZeba� ^jm]bo� g_\jhlbq_kdbogZjmr_gbc�ihfh]�[u�gZf�wlh�ihgylv�Fu�^Z\gh�gZqZeb�jZkijhkljZgylv�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdb_�\a]ey^u�gZ�ihgbfZgb_�wlbo�^jm]boaZ[he_\Zgbc��M`_�\ �����]��ihke_�h[f_gZ�fg_gbyfb�kh�fghc�D��:[jZoZf�\ukdZaZe�iheh`_gb_�qlh� ]eZ\ghc� q_jlhc� 'HPHQWLD� j]Z_kho� >ijbqbkey_fhc� d ikbohaZf@� y\ey_lky� lh�� qlh� ijb� g_chlkmlkl\m_l�ijb\yaZgghklv�eb[b^h��/LELGREHVHW]XQJ��d h[t_dlZf��©Ikbohk_dkmZevgu_�jZaebqbybkl_jbb� b 'HPHQWLD� j]Z_khoª��� Gh� lh]^Z� \hagbd� \hijhk�� qlh� `_� ijhbkoh^bl� k eb[b^hkeZ[hmfguo�� dhlhjh_� hl\_jgmehkv� hl� h[t_dlh\"� :[jZoZf� g_� aZf_^ebe� ^Zlv� hl\_l�� hghh[jZsZ_lky� gZ� Y�� b wlh� hljZ`_ggh_� h[jZs_gb_� y\ey_lky� bklhqgbdhf� [j_^Z� \_ebqby� ijb'HPHQWLD� j]Z_kho�� ;j_^� \_ebqby�� [_amkeh\gh�� fh`gh� kjZ\gblv� k ba\_klghc� \ �ghjfZevghc�ex[h\ghc�`bagb� k_dkmZevghc�i_j_hp_gdhc� h[t_dlZ� ex[\b��LZd� gZf� \i_j\u_� m^Zehkv� ihgylvdZdmx�lh�q_jlm�ikbohlbq_kdh]h�aZ[he_\Zgby�ih�k\yab�k ghjfZevghc�ex[h\ghc�`bagvx�KdZ`m� kjZam�� qlh� wlb� i_j\u_� \a]ey^u� :[jZoZfZ� khojZgbebkv� \ ikbohZgZeba_� b [uebiheh`_gu� \ hkgh\m� gZr_c� ihabpbb� ih� hlghr_gbx� d ikbohaZf�� Kh� \j_f_g_f� mdj_ibehkvij_^klZ\e_gb_�� qlh� eb[b^h�� dhlhjh_�fu� gZoh^bf� ijb\yaZgguf� d h[t_dlZf�� dhlhjh_� y\ey_lky\ujZ`_gb_f� klj_fe_gby� ihemqblv� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� hl� wlbo� h[t_dlh\�� fh`_l� hklZ\blv� wlbh[t_dlu�b ihklZ\blv�gZ�bo�f_klh�kh[kl\_ggh_�Y��ihkl_i_ggh�wlh�ij_^klZ\e_gb_�jZa\b\Zehkv�kh\k_�[hevr_c�ihke_^h\Zl_evghklvx��GZa\Zgb_�^ey�lZdh]h�jZaf_s_gby�eb[b^h�²�gZjpbkkbaf�²fu�aZbfkl\h\Zeb�ba�hibkZggh]h�I��G_dd_� �������ba\jZs_gby��ijb�dhlhjhf�\ajhkeuc�bg^b\b^^Zjbl� k\h_fm� kh[kl\_gghfm� l_em� \k_� g_`ghklb�� h[uqgh� ijhy\ey_fu_� d ihklhjhgg_fmk_dkmZevghfm�h[t_dlm�Gh�\kdhj_�]h\hjbrv�k_[_��qlh�_keb�kms_kl\m_l�lZdZy�nbdkZpby�eb[b^h�gZ�kh[kl\_gghf�l_e_b kh[kl\_gghc�ebqghklb�\f_klh�h[t_dlZ��lh�wlh�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�bkdexqbl_evguf�b fZeh\Z`gufy\e_gb_f��=hjZa^h�\_jhylg__��qlh� wlhl�gZjpbkkbaf�²�h[s__�b i_j\hgZqZevgh_� khklhygb_��badhlhjh]h�lhevdh�iha^g__�jZa\beZkv�ex[h\v�d h[t_dlm��ijbq_f�ba�aZ�wlh]h�gZjpbkkbaf�\h\k_�g_^he`_g� bkq_agmlv�� Ba� bklhjbb� jZa\blby� h[t_dl�eb[b^h� gm`gh� \kihfgblv�� qlh� fgh]b_k_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gby� kgZqZeZ� m^h\e_l\hjyxlky� gZ� kh[kl\_gghf� l_e_�� dZd� fu� ]h\hjbf�Zmlhwjhlbq_kdb�b qlh�wlZ�kihkh[ghklv�d Zmlhwjhlbafm�y\ey_lky�ijbqbghc�hlklZ\Zgby�jZa\blbyk_dkmZevghklb� ijb� \hkiblZgbb� ih� ijbgpbim� j_Zevghklb�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� Zmlhwjhlbaf� [uek_dkmZevguf�ijhy\e_gb_f�gZjpbklbq_kdhc�klZ^bb�jZaf_s_gby�eb[b^h�Dhjhq_� ]h\hjy�� fu� khklZ\beb� k_[_� ij_^klZ\e_gb_� h[� hlghr_gbb� Y�eb�[b^h� b h[t_dl�eb[b^h�� dhlhjh_� y fh]m� ihdZaZlv� \Zf� gZ]ey^gh� gZ� kjZ\g_gbb� ba� ahheh]bb�� <kihfgbl_� h l_oijhkl_crbo� `b\uo� kms_kl\Zo�� khklhysbo� ba� fZeh^bnn_j_gpbjh\Zggh]h� dhfhqdZijhlhieZafZlbq_kdhc� km[klZgpbb��Hgb� ijhly]b\Zxl� hljhkldb�� gZau\Z_fu_� ik_\^hih^byfb�� \dhlhju_� i_j_eb\Zxl� km[klZgpbx� k\h_]h� l_eZ�� <uly]b\Zgb_� hljhkldh\� fu� kjZ\gb\Z_f� kjZkijhkljZg_gb_f� es`^h� gZ� h[t_dlu�� f_`^m� l_f� dZd� hkgh\gh_� dhebq_kl\h� eb[b^h� fh`_lhklZ\Zlvky� \ Y��b fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f�� qlh� \ ghjfZevguo� mkeh\byo�Y�eb[b^h�[_kij_iylkl\_gghi_j_oh^bl�\ h[t_dl�eb[b^h��Z hgh�hiylv�fh`_l�\_jgmlvky�\ Y�

Page 229: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

K ihfhsvx� wlbo� ij_^klZ\e_gbc� fu� l_i_jv� fh`_f� h[tykgblv� p_euc� jy^� ^mr_\guokhklhygbc� beb�� \ujZ`Zykv� kdjhfg__�� hibkZlv� bo� gZ� yaud_� l_hjbb� eb[b^h�� wlh� khklhygby�dhlhju_�fu�^he`gu�ijbqbkeblv�d ghjfZevghc�`bagb��dZd��gZijbf_j��ikbobq_kdh_�ih\_^_gb_ijb� \ex[e_gghklb�� ijb� hj]Zgbq_kdhf� aZ[he_\Zgbb�� \h� kg_�� >ey� khklhygby� kgZ� fu� k^_eZebij_^iheh`_gb_��qlh�hgh�hkgh\Zgh�gZ�moh^_�hl�\g_rg_]h�fbjZ�b mklZgh\d_�gZ�`_eZgb_�kiZlv��Lh�qlh� ijhy\eyehkv� \h� kg_� dZd� ghqgZy� ^mr_\gZy� ^_yl_evghklv�� kem`bl�� dZd� fu� h[gZjm`bf�`_eZgbx� kiZlv� b�� djhf_� lh]h�� gZoh^blky� \h� \eZklb� bkdexqbl_evgh� w]hbklbq_kdbo� fhlb\h]�L_i_jv�\ khhl\_lkl\bb�k l_hjb_c�eb[b^h�fu�aZy\ey_f��qlh�khg�_klv�kb�klhygb_��\ dhlhjhf�\k_ijb\yaZgghklb�d h[t_dlZf��dZd�eb[b^hagu_��lZd�b w]hbklbq_kdb_��hklZ\eyxlky�b \ha\jZsZxlky\ Y��G_� ijheb\Z_lky� eb� wlbf� gh\uc� k\_l� gZ� hl^uo� \h� kg_� b gZ� ijbjh^m� mklZehklb� \hh[s_"<i_qZle_gb_�[eZ`_gghc�baheypbb�\h�\gmljbmljh[ghc�`bagb��dhlhjh_�\uau\Z_l�m gZk�kiysbcdZ`^mx�ghqv��\hkihegy_lky��lZdbf�h[jZahf��b kh�klhjhgu�ikbobdb��M kiys_]h�\hkklZgh\behkvi_j\h[ulgh_� khklhygb_� jZkij_^_e_gby� eb[b^h�� iheguc� gZjpbkkbaf�� ijb� dhlhjhf� eb[b^h� bbgl_j_k�Y `b\ml�_sz�\f_kl_�b g_jZa^_evgh�\ kZfhm^h\e_l\hjyxs_fky�Y�A^_kv�mf_klgu�^\Z�aZf_qZgby��<h�i_j\uo��q_f�hlebqZxlky�ihgylby�gZjpbkkbaf�b w]hbaf"Y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� gZjpbkkbaf� y\ey_lky� eb[b^haguf� ^hiheg_gb_f� w]hbafZ�� Dh]^Z� ]h\hjyl� h[w]hbaf_�� bf_xl� \ \b^m� lhevdh� ihevam� ^ey� bg^b\b^Z�� ]h\hjy� h gZjpbkkbaf_�� ijbgbfZxl� \h\gbfZgb_� b _]h� eb[b^hagh_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�� < dZq_kl\_� ijZdlbq_kdbo� fhlb\h\� bo� fh`ghijhke_^blv�ihjhagv�gZ�p_ehf�jy^_�y\e_gbc��Fh`gh�[ulv�Z[khexlgh� w]hbklbqguf�b \k_�lZdbbf_lv�kbevgu_�eb[b^hagu_�ijb\yaZgghklb�d h[t_dlZf��ihkdhevdm�eb[b^hagh_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_hl�h[t_dlZ�hlghkblky�d ihlj_[ghklyf�Y��W]hbaf�[m^_l�ke_^blv�lh]^Z�aZ�l_f��qlh[u�klj_fe_gb_�dh[t_dlm� g_� ijbqbgbeh� \j_^Z� Y�� Fh`gh� [ulv� w]hbklbqguf� b ijb� wlhf� lZd`_� hq_gvgZjpbkklbqguf��l��_��bf_lv�hq_gv�g_agZqbl_evgmx�ihlj_[ghklv�\ h[t_dl_��b wlh�hiylv�lZdb�beb\ ijyfhf�k_dkmZevghf�m^h\e_l\hj_gbb��beb� lZd`_�\ l_o�\ukhdbo��bkoh^ysbo�ba� k_dkmZevghcihlj_[ghklb� klj_fe_gbyo�� dhlhju_� fu� dZd� ©ex[h\vª� bgh]^Z� bf__f� h[udgh\_gb_ijhlb\hihklZ\eylv� ©qm\kl\_gghklbª�� <h� \k_o� wlbo� hlghr_gbyo� w]hbaf� y\ey_lky� kZfh� kh[hcjZamf_xsbfky��ihklhygguf��gZjpbkkbaf�`_�²�f_gyxsbfky� we_f_glhf��Ijhlb\hiheh`ghklvw]hbafZ�²�Zevljmbaf�²�dZd�ihgylb_�g_�kh\iZ^Z_l�k eb[b^haghc�ijb\yaZgghklvx�d h[t_dlZf��hghlebqZ_lky�hl�g__�hlkmlkl\b_f� klj_fe_gbc�d k_dkmZevghfm� m^h\e_l\hj_gbx��Gh�ijb� kbevghc\ex[e_gghklb� Zevljmbaf� kh\iZ^Z_l� k eb[b^haghc� ijb\yaZgghklvx� d h[t_dlZf��H[udgh\_gghk_dkmZevguc�h[t_dl�ijb\e_dZ_l�d k_[_�qZklv�gZjpbkkbafZ�Y��qlh�klZgh\blky�aZf_lguf�ih�lZdgZau\Z_fhc� ©k_dkmZevghc� i_j_hp_gd_ª� h[t_dlZ�� ?keb� d wlhfm� ijb[Z\ey_lky� _s_Zevljmbklbq_kdh_� i_j_g_k_gb_� hl� w]hbafZ� gZ� k_dkmZevguc� h[t_dl�� lh� k_dkmZevguc� h[t_dlklk�A�h\blky�fh]ms_kl\_gguf��hg�dZd�[u�ih]ehlbe�Y�Y ^mfZx��\u�khql_l_�aZ�hl^uo���_keb�ihke_�kmohc��\ kmsghklb��nZglZklbdb gZmdb� yijb\_^m \Zf�ihwlbq_kdh_�bah[jZ`_gb_�wdhghfbq_kdhc�ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb��gZjpbkkbafZ�b \ex[e_gghklb��Y aZbfkl\mx�_]h�ba�AZiZ^gh�\hklhqgh]h�^b\ZgZ�=_l_�Ame_cdZ� JZ[��gZjh^�b m]g_lZl_ev<_qgu�\ [_]_�gZrbo�^g_cKqZkleb\�fbjZ�h[blZl_ev

Page 230: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Lhevdh�ebqghklvx�k\h_c�@bagv�jZkoh^mc�dZd�kmf__rv�Gh�b^b�k\h_c�ljhihc�<k_f�ih`_jl\mc��qlh�bf__rv�Lhevdh�[m^v�kZfbf�kh[hc�OZ�l_f�>Z��y keurZe�wlh�fg_gv_�Gh�bgZq_�y kdZ`m�KqZklv_��jZ^hklv��ml_r_gv_�²�<k_�\ Ame_cd_�gZoh`m��Qmlv�hgZ�fg_�meu[g_lky��Fg_�k_[y�^hjh`_�g_l��Qmlv��gZofmjykv��hl\_jg_lky�²�Ihl_jye�k_[y�b ke_^��OZl_f�dhgqbeky�[ gZ�wlhf��D kqZklvx��hg�khh[jZabe�GZ^h�kjhqgh�klZlv�ihwlhfBev�^jm]bf��dlh�\k_�` _c�fbe��I_j_\h^�<��E_\bdZ�<lhjh_� aZf_qZgb_�y\ey_lky�^hiheg_gb_f�d l_hjbb� kgh\b^_gbc��Fu�g_�fh`_f�h[tykgblvk_[_� \hagbdgh\_gb_� kgh\b^_gby�� _keb� g_� ij_^iheh`bf�� qlh� \ul_kg_ggh_� [_kkhagZl_evgh_ihemqbeh� ba\_klgmx� g_aZ\bkbfhklv� hl� Y�� lZd� qlh� hgh� g_� ih^qbgy_lky� `_eZgbx� kiZlv� bkhojZgy_l� k\hb� ijb\yaZgghklb�� ^Z`_� _keb� \k_� aZ\bkysb_� hl� Y ijb\yaZgghklb� d h[t_dlZfhklZ\e_gu� jZ^b� kgZ�� Lhevdh� \ wlhf� kemqZ_� fh`gh� ihgylv�� qlh� wlh� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� bf__l\hafh`ghklv� \hkihevah\Zlvky� ghqguf� hlkmlkl\b_f� beb� mf_gvr_gb_f� p_gamju� b mf__lh\eZ^_lv� hklZldZfb� ^g_\guo� \i_qZle_gbcª� ^ey� lh]h� qlh[u� h[jZah\Zlv� ba� bo� fZl_jbZeZaZij_lgh_� `_eZgb_� kgh\b^_gby�� K ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� b hklZldb� ^g_\guo� \i_qZle_gbc� qZklvxk\h_]h� ijhlb\h^_ckl\by� ij_^ibkZgghfm� `_eZgb_f� kiZlv� hllhdm� eb[b^h� h[yaZgu� m`_kms_kl\mxs_c� k\yab� k wlbf� [_kkhagZl_evguf�� Wlm� ^bgZfbq_kdb� \Z`gmx� q_jlm� fu� ohlbf^hihegbl_evgh�\dexqblv�\ gZr_�ij_^klZ\e_gb_�h[�h[jZah\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gbc�Hj]Zgbq_kdh_� aZ[he_\Zgb_�� [he_ag_ggh_� jZa^jZ`_gb_�� \hkiZe_gb_� hj]Zgh\� kha^Zxlkhklhygb_��bf_xs__�ihke_^kl\b_f�y\gh_�hl^_e_gb_�eb[b^h�hl� _]h�h[t_dlh\��Hlgylh_�eb[b^hkgh\Z� gZoh^blky� \ Y� \ nhjf_� mkbeb\r_cky� ijb\yaZgghklb� d aZ[he_\r_c� qZklb� l_eZ��Fh`gh^Z`_�j_rblvky�gZ�ml\_j`^_gb_��qlh�\ wlbo�mkeh\byo�hloh^�eb[b^h�hl�k\hbo�h[t_dlh\�[jhkZ_lky\ ]eZaZ� [hevr_�� q_f� mljZlZ� w]hbklbq_kdh]h� bgl_j_kZ� d \g_rg_fm� fbjm�� Hlkx^Z� dZd� [m^lhhldju\Z_lky�imlv� d ihgbfZgbx�bihohg^jbb��ijb� dhlhjhc� dZdhc�lh� hj]Zg�ih^h[guf� h[jZahf

Page 231: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

aZgbfZ_l�Y��g_�[m^mqb�[hevguf�k gZr_c�lhqdb�aj_gby�Gh� y mklhx� i_j_^� bkdmr_gb_f� b^lb� ^Zevr_� beb� h[km`^Zlv� ^jm]b_� kblmZpbb�� dhlhju_klZgh\ylky� ihgylgufb� gZf� beb]e_]dh� ih^^Zxlky� hibkZgbx� [eZ]h^Zjy� ij_^iheh`_gbxi_j_oh^Z� h[t_dl�eb[b^h� \ Y�� ihlhfm� qlh� fg_� g_� l_jiblky� ^Zlv� hl\_l� gZ� ^\Z� \hajZ`_gby�dhlhju_��dZd�fg_�ba\_klgh��\Zk� l_i_jv� aZgbfZxl��<h�i_j\uo��\u�ohlbl_�ihlj_[h\Zlv�hl�f_gyh[tykg_gbc�� ihq_fm� y g_ij_f_ggh� ohqm� jZaebqZlv� \ kemqZyo� kgZ�� [he_agb� b lhfm� ih^h[guokblmZpbyo� eb[b^h� b bgl_j_k�� k_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gby� b bgklbgdlu� Y�� lh]^Z� dZd� gZ[ex^_gby\iheg_� iha\heyxl� h[hclbkv� ij_^iheh`_gb_f� >h kms_kl\h\Zgbb@� h^ghc� h^ghjh^ghc� wg_j]bb�dhlhjZy�� y\eyykv� ih^\b`ghc�� aZihegy_l� lh� h[t_dl�� lh� Y�� \uklmiZy� gZ� kem`[_� lh� h^gh]h�� lh^jm]h]h� \e_q_gby�� B \h�\lhjuo�� dZd� y fh]m� j_rblvky� jZkkfZljb\Zlv� hl^_e_gb_� eb[b^h� hlh[t_dlZ�\ dZq_kl\_�bklhqgbdZ�iZlheh]bq_kdh]h�khklhygby��_keb�lZdhc�i_j_oh^�h[t_dl�eb[b^h�\Y�eb[b^h�²�beb�� ]h\hjy�[he__�h[s_��\ wg_j]bx�Y ²�hlghkblky�d ghjfZevguf��_`_^g_\gh�b_`_ghsgh�ih\lhjyxsbfky�ijhp_kkZf�^mr_\ghc�^bgZfbdb�GZ� wlh�fh`gh�hl\_lblv��\Zr_�i_j\h_� \hajZ`_gb_� a\mqbl� ohjhrh��H[tykg_gb_� khklhygbckgZ��[he_agb��\ex[e_gghklb�kZfh�ih�k_[_��\_jhylgh��gbdh]^Z�g_�ijb\_eh�[u�gZk�d jZaebq_gbxY�eb[b^h� b h[t_dl�eb[b^h� beb� eb[b^h� b bgl_j_kZ�� Gh� ijb� wlhf� \u� ij_g_[j_]Z_l_bkke_^h\Zgbyfb�� ba� dhlhjuo� fu� bkoh^beb� b \� k\_l_� dhlhjuo� l_i_jv� jZkkfZljb\Z_fh[km`^Z_fu_� ^mr_\gu_� kblmZpbb�� JZaebq_gb_� f_`^m� eb[b^h� b bgl_j_khf�� l�� _�� f_`^mk_dkmZevgufb� \e_q_gbyfb� b bgklbgdlZfb� kZfhkhojZg_gby�� klZeh� g_h[oh^bfuf� [eZ]h^ZjyihgbfZgbx� dhgnebdlZ�� ba�aZ� dhlhjh]h� ijhbkoh^yl� g_\jhau� i_j_g_k_gby��Ihke_� wlh]h�fu� g_fh`_f�\gh\v�hldZaZlvky�hl�g_]h��Ij_^iheh`_gb_��qlh�h[t_dl�eb[b^h�fh`_l�ij_\jZlblvky�\ Y�eb[b^h�� lZd� qlh� k Y�eb[b^h� ijboh^blky� kqblZlvky�� dZaZehkv� gZf� _^bgkl\_ggh� kihkh[gufjZaj_rblv�aZ]Z^dm�lZd�gZau\Z_fuo�gZjpbkklbq_�kdbo�g_\jhah\��gZijbf_j�'HPHQWLD� SUDHFR[��bmykgblv�bo�koh^kl\Z�b jZaebqby�\ kjZ\g_gbb�k bkl_jb_c�b gZ\yaqb\ufb�khklhygbyfb��< kemqZyo[he_agb�� kgZ� b \ex[e_gghklb� fu� ijbf_gy_f� l_i_jv� lh�� qlh� gZreb� \iheg_� hijZ\^Zgguf� \^jm]hf�f_kl_��Fu�fh`_f�ijh^he`blv�wlh�ijbf_g_gb_�b ihkfhlj_lv���q_]h�fu�wlbf�^hklb]g_f�?^bgkl\_ggh_� ml\_j`^_gb_�� g_� y\eyxs__ky� ijyfuf� hljZ`_gb_f� gZr_]h� ZgZeblbq_kdh]hhiulZ��khklhbl�\ lhf��qlh�eb[b^h�hklZ_lky�eb[b^h��g_aZ\bkbfh�hl�lh]h��gZijZ\e_gh�eb�hgh�gZh[t_dlu�beb�gZ�kh[kl\_ggh_�Y��b hgh�gbdh]^Z�g_�ij_\jZsZ_lky�\ w]hbklbq_kdbc�bgl_j_k��dZd�g_[u\Z_l� b h[jZlgh]h�� Gh� wlh� ml\_j`^_gb_� jZ\ghp_ggh� jZa^_e_gbx� k_dkmZevguo� \e_q_gbc� bbgklbgdlh\� Y�� m`_� hp_g_gghfm� djblbq_kdb�� dhlhjh]h� fu� [m^_f� ijb^_j`b\Zlvky� baw\jbklbq_kdbo�fhlb\h\��ihdZ�hgh��[ulv�fh`_l��g_�hdZ`_lky�g_ijZ\bevguf�B \lhjh_� \Zr_� \hajZ`_gb_� kh^_j`bl� kijZ\_^eb\uc� \hijhk�� gh� b^_l� ih� eh`ghfm� imlb�JZamf__lky�� i_j_oh^� h[t_dl�eb[b^h� \ Y� g_� y\ey_lky� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh� iZlh]_gguf�� \_^v� fuagZ_f��qlh�hg�ij_^ijbgbfZ_lky�dZ`^uc�jZa�i_j_^�hloh^hf�dh�kgm��qlh[u�ijh^_eZlv�h[jZlgucimlv� ijb� ijh[m`^_gbb��F_evqZcr__� `b\hlgh_�� khklhys__� ba� ijhlhieZafu�� \ly]b\Z_l� k\hbhljhkldb�� qlh[u� kgh\Z� \uimklblv� bo� ijb� ke_^mxs_f� ih\h^_�� Gh� kh\k_f� ^jm]h_� ^_eh�� _kebdZdhc�lh�hij_^_e_gguc�hq_gv�wg_j]bqguc�ijhp_kk�\ugm`^Z_l�hlgylv�eb[b^h�m h[t_dlZ��Lh]^ZklZ\r__�gZjpbkklbq_kdbf�eb[b^h�fh`_l�g_�gZclb�h[jZlgh]h�imlb�d h[t_dlZf��b wlh�gZjmr_gb_ih^\b`ghklb� eb[b^h� klZgh\blky�� dhg_qgh�� iZlh]_gguf�� DZ`_lky�� qlh� kdhie_gb_gZjpbkklbq_kdh]h� eb[b^h� k\_jo� hij_^_e_gghc� f_ju� g_evay� \ug_klb��Fu� fh`_f� k_[_� lZd`_

Page 232: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ij_^klZ\blv��qlh�bf_ggh�ihwlhfm�^_eh�^hreh�^h�ijb\yaZgghklb�d h[t_dlZf��qlh�Y ^he`gh�[uehhl^Zlv� k\h_� eb[b^h�� qlh[u� g_� aZ[he_lv� hl� _]h� kdhie_gby�� ?keb� [u� \ gZrb� ieZgu� \oh^behih^jh[gh_�bamq_gb_�'HPHQWLD�SUDHFR[��y [u�\Zf�ihdZaZe��qlh�ijhp_kk��hl^_eyxsbc�eb[b^h�hlh[t_dlh\� b ij_]jZ`^Zxsbc� _fm� h[jZlguc� imlv�� [ebahd� d ijhp_kkm� \ul_kg_gby� b ^he`_gjZkkfZljb\Zlvky� dZd� ^hiheg_gb_� d g_fm�� Gh� ij_`^_� \k_]h� \u� ihqm\kl\h\Zeb� [u� agZdhfmxihq\m�ih^�gh]Zfb��magZ\��qlh�mkeh\by�wlh]h�ijhp_kkZ�ihqlb�b^_glbqgu�²�gZkdhevdh�fu�ihdZagZ_f�²�mkeh\byf�\ul_kg_gby��Dhgnebdl��ih�\b^bfhfm��lhl�`_�kZfuc�b jZau]ju\Z_lky�f_`^ml_fb� `_� kbeZfb��: _keb� bkoh^� bghc�� q_f�� gZijbf_j�� ijb� bkl_jbb�� lh� ijbqbgZ� fh`_l� [ulvlhevdh�\ jZaebqbb�ij_^jZkiheh`_gby��JZa\blb_�eb[b^h�m wlbo�[hevguo�bf__l�keZ[h_�f_klh�\^jm]hc� k\h_c� nZa_�� klhev� \Z`gZy� nbdkZpby�� dhlhjZy� ijheZ]Z_l�� dZd� \u� ihfgbl_�� imlv� dh[jZah\Zgbx�kbfilhfh\��gZoh^blky�]^_�lh�\ ^jm]hf�f_kl_��\_jhylgh��gZ�klZ^bb�ijbfblb\gh]hgZjpbkkbafZ�� d dhlhjhfm� \ k\h_f� dhg_qghf� blh]_� \ha\jZsZ_lky� 'HPHQWLD� SUDHFR[�� <_kvfZ^hklhcgh� \gbfZgby� lh�� qlh� ^ey� \k_o� gZjpbkklbq_kdbo� g_\jhah\� fu� ^he`gu� ij_^iheh`blvnbdkZpbx� eb[b^h�gZ� ]hjZa^h� [he__� jZggbo�nZaZo�� q_f� ijb�bkl_jbb� beb� g_\jha_� gZ\yaqb\uokhklhygbc�� Gh� \u� keurZeb�� qlh� ihgylby�� \ujZ[hlZggu_� gZfb� ijb� bamq_gbb� g_\jhah\i_j_g_k_gby�� hdZaZebkv� ^hklZlhqgufb� b ^ey� hjb_glZpbb� \ ]hjZa^h� [he__� ly`_euo� \ijZdlbq_kdhf�hlghr_gbb�gZjpbkklbq_kdbo�g_\jhaZo��Q_jlu�koh^kl\Z�b^ml�hq_gv�^Ze_dh�\ kmsghklb�� wlh� lZ� `_� h[eZklv� y\e_gbc��Gh� \u� fh`_l_� k_[_� lZd`_� ij_^klZ\blv�� dZdbf[_agZ^_`guf�dZ`_lky�h[tykg_gb_� wlbo� aZ[he_\Zgbc��hlghkysboky�m`_�d ikbobZljbb�� lhfm�� mdh]h� ^ey� j_r_gby� wlhc� aZ^Zqb� g_^hklZ_l� ZgZeblbq_kdh]h� ij_^klZ\e_gby� h g_\jhaZoi_j_g_k_gby�DZjlbgZ� kbfilhfh\� 'HPHQWLD� SUDHFR[�� \ijhq_f� hq_gv� baf_gqb\Zy�� hij_^_ey_lky� g_bkdexqbl_evgh�kbfilhfZfb��\hagbdZxsbfb�\ke_^kl\b_�hll_kg_gby�eb[b^h�hl�h[t_dlh\�b _]hkdhie_gby�\ \b^_�gZjpbkklbq_kdh]h�eb[b^h�\ Y��;hevrh_�f_klh� aZgbfZxl�^jm]b_�n_ghf_gu�dhlhju_� k\h^ylky� d klj_fe_gbx� eb[b^h� \gh\v� \_jgmlvky� d h[t_dlZf�� l�� _�� khhl\_lkl\mxlihiuld_�\hkklZgh\e_gby�beb�\ua^hjh\e_gby��Wlb�rmfeb\u_�kbfilhfu�^Z`_�[hevr_�[jhkZxlky\ ]eZaZ�� hgb� h[gZjm`b\Zxl� g_khfg_ggh_� koh^kl\h� k kbfilhfZfb� bkl_jbb� beb� ²� j_`_� ²g_\jhaZ�gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc��gh�hlebqZxlky�hl�gbo�\h�\k_o�hlghr_gbyo��DZ`_lky��qlh�eb[b^hijb�'HPHQWLD�SUDHFR[�\ k\h_f�klj_fe_gbb�kgh\Z�\_jgmlvky�d h[t_dlZf��l��_��d ij_^klZ\e_gbyfh[t_dlh\��^_ckl\bl_evgh�qlh�lh�meZ\eb\Z_l�hl�gbo��gh�dZd�[u�lhevdh�bo�l_gb��y bf_x�\ \b^mhlghkysb_ky� d gbf� keh\_kgu_�ij_^klZ\e_gby�� A^_kv� y [hevr_�g_�fh]m� ]h\hjblv� h[� wlhf�� ghiheZ]Zx�� qlh� lZdh_� ih\_^_gb_� klj_fys_]hky� h[jZlgh� eb[b^h� iha\hey_l� gZf� ihgylv�� qlh^_ckl\bl_evgh�khklZ\ey_l�jZaebqb_�f_`^m�khagZl_evguf�b [_kkhagZl_evguf�ij_^klZ\e_gb_f�Y \\_e�\Zk�\ h[eZklv��]^_�ke_^m_l�h`b^Zlv�gh\uo�mki_oh\�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�jZ[hlu��K l_o�ihjdZd� fu� j_rbebkv� ihevah\Zlvky� ihgylb_f� Y�eb[b^h�� gZf� klZeb� ^hklmigu� gZjpbkklbq_kdb_g_\jhau��\hagbdeZ� aZ^ZqZ�gZclb�^bgZfbq_kdh_�h[tykg_gb_� wlbo� aZ[he_\Zgbc�b h^gh\j_f_gghihihegblv� gZr_� agZgb_� ^mr_\ghc� `bagb� ihgbfZgb_f� Y�� Ikboheh]by� Y�� d dhlhjhc� fuklj_fbfky�� ^he`gZ� hkgh\u\Zlvky� g_� gZ� ^Zgguo� gZrbo� kZfhgZ[ex^_gbc�� Z�� dZd� b \� kemqZ_eb[b^h�� gZ� ZgZeba_� gZjmr_gbc� b jZkiZ^h\�Y��<_jhylgh�� dh]^Z� [m^_l� ijh^_eZgZ� wlZ� [hevrZyjZ[hlZ�� fu� [m^_f� g_\ukhdh]h� fg_gby� h gZr_f� gug_rg_f� agZgbb� h km^v[Zo� eb[b^h�ihq_jigmlhf� ba� bamq_gby� g_\jhah\� i_j_g_k_gby��Gh� \_^v� fu� _s_� b g_� ijh^\bgmebkv� \ g_c

Page 233: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

^Ze_dh�� GZjpbkklbq_kdb_� g_\jhau� _^\Z� eb� ijhgbpZ_fu� ^ey� lhc� l_ogbdb�� dhlhjhc� fuihevah\Zebkv�ijb�bamq_gbb�g_\jhah\�i_j_g_k_gby��<u�kdhjh�magZ_l_�ihq_fm��A^_kv�m gZk�\k_]^Zijhbkoh^bl� lZd�� qlh� ihke_� dhjhldh]h� ijh^\b`_gby� \i_j_^� fu� hdZau\Z_fky� i_j_^� kl_ghc�aZklZ\eyxs_c� gZk� hklZgh\blvky�� <Zf� ba\_klgh�� qlh� b ijb� g_\jhaZo� i_j_g_k_gby� fugZlZedb\Zebkv� gZ� ih^h[gu_� ij_iylkl\by�� gh� gZf� m^Z\Zehkv� mkljZgylv� bo� ih� qZklyf�� IjbgZjpbkklbq_kdbo� g_\jhaZo� khijhlb\e_gb_� g_ij_h^hebfh�� \ emqr_f� kemqZ_� fu� fh`_f� ebrv[jhkblv� ex[hiulguc� \a]ey^� aZ� kl_gm�� qlh[u� ih^]ey^_lv�� qlh� ijhbkoh^bl� ih� lm� __ klhjhgm�GZrb�l_ogbq_kdb_�f_lh^u�^he`gu�[ulv��lZdbf�h[jZahf��aZf_g_gu�^jm]bfb��fu�_s_�g_�agZ_f�m^Zklky�eb�gZf�lZdZy�aZf_gZ��Gh�b wlb�[hevgu_�^Zxl�^hklZlhqgh�fZl_jbZeZ�^ey�gZk��Hgb�fgh]h]h\hjyl� h k_[_�� ohly� b g_� hl\_qZxl� gZ� gZrb� \hijhku�� b ihdZ�fu� \ugm`^_gu� lhedh\Zlv� wlb\ukdZau\Zgby� k ihfhsvx� ij_^klZ\e_gbc�� ijbh[j_l_gguo� [eZ]h^Zjy� bamq_gbx� kbfilhfh\g_\jhah\�i_j_g_k_gby��Koh^kl\h�^hklZlhqgh� \_ebdh��qlh[u�h[_ki_qblv�gZf�gZqZevguc�mki_o�<hijhk��gZkdhevdh�^hklZlhqghc�[m^_l�wlZ�l_ogbdZ��hklZ_lky�hldjuluf�<hagbdZxl� b ^jm]b_� aZljm^g_gby�� f_rZxsb_� gZr_fm� ijh^\b`_gbx� \i_j_^�GZjpbkklbq_kdb_� aZ[he_\Zgby�b ijbfudZxsb_� d gbf� ikbohau�fh]ml� [ulv� jZa]Z^Zgu� lhevdhl_fb�gZ[ex^Zl_eyfb��dhlhju_�ijhreb�rdhem�ZgZeblbq_kdh]h�bamq_gby�g_\jhah\�i_j_g_k_gby�Gh�gZrb�ikbobZlju�g_�bamqZxl�ikbohZgZeba��Z fu��ikbohZgZeblbdb��kebrdhf�fZeh�gZ[ex^Z_fikbobZljbq_kdbo� kemqZ_\�� >he`gh� _s_� ih^jZklb� ihdhe_gb_� ikbobZljh\�� ijhr_^rbo� rdhemikbohZgZebaZ� dZd� ih^]hlh\bl_evghc� gZmdb�� GZqZeh� wlhfm� iheh`_gh� \ gZklhys__� \j_fy� \:f_jbd_�� ]^_� hq_gv� fgh]b_� \_^msb_� ikbobZlju� qblZxl� klm^_glZf� e_dpbb� hikbohZgZeblbq_kdhf�mq_gbb��Z \eZ^_evpu�e_q_[guo�mqj_`^_gbc�b ^bj_dlhjZ�ikbobZljbq_kdbo[hevgbp� klj_fylky� \_klb� gZ[ex^_gby� aZ� k\hbfb� [hevgufb� \ ^mo_� wlh]h� mq_gby�� >Z� b gZfm^Zehkv� a^_kv� g_kdhevdh� jZa� aZ]eygmlv� aZ� gZjibkklbq_kdmx� kl_gm�� b \� ^Zevg_cr_f� y ohqmjZkkdZaZlv�\Zf�dh_�qlh�ba�lh]h��qlh�gZf��dZ`_lky��m^Zehkv�ih^kfhlj_lv�NhjfZ� aZ[he_\Zgby�iZjZghc_c��ojhgbq_kdbf�kbkl_fZlbq_kdbf�mfhihf_rZl_evkl\hf��ijbihiuldZo�deZkkbnbdZpbb�\ kh\j_f_gghc�ikbobZljbb�i_�aZgbfZ_l�hij_^_e_ggh]h�f_klZ��F_`^ml_f� __ [ebadh_� koh^kl\h� k 'HPHQWLD� SUDHFR[� g_� ih^e_`bl� gbdZdhfm� khfg_gbx�� H^gZ`^u� yiha\hebe� k_[_� ij_^eh`blv� h[t_^bgblv� iZjZghcx� b 'HPHQWLD� SUDHFR[� ih^� h[sbf� gZa\Zgb_fiZjZnj_gby�� Ih� bo� kh^_j`Zgbx� nhjfu� iZjZghcb� hibku\Zxlky� dZd�� [j_^� \_ebqby�� [j_^ij_ke_^h\Zgby�� ex[h\guc� [j_^� �wjhlhfZgby��� [j_^� j_\ghklb� b l�� ^��Hl� ikbobZljbb� ihiulhdh[tykg_gby�fu�g_�`^_f�< dZq_kl\_� h[jZapZ� lZdh\hc�� ohly� b mklZj_\r_]h� b g_� kh\k_f� iheghp_ggh]h� ijbf_jZ�ijb\_^m� \Zf� ihiuldm� \u\_klb� h^bg� kbfilhf� ba� ^jm]h]h� ihkj_^kl\hf� bgl_ee_dlmZevghcjZpbhgZebaZpbb�� [hevghc�� dhlhjuc� ih� i_j\bqghc� kdehgghklb� kqblZ_l�� qlh� _]h� ij_ke_^mxl�^he`_g�^_eZlv�ba� wlh]h�ij_ke_^h\Zgby�\u\h^��qlh�hg�ij_^klZ\ey_l�ba� k_[y�hkh[_ggh�\Z`gmxebqghklv�b ihwlhfm�m g_]h�jZa\b\Z_lky�[j_^�\_ebqby��>ey�gZr_c�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�lhqdb�aj_gby[j_^� \_ebqby� y\ey_lky� g_ihkj_^kl\_gguf� ke_^kl\b_f� \ha\_ebqb\Zgby� Y ba�aZ� hlgylbyeb[b^haguo� ijb\yaZgghkl_c� m h[t_dlh\�� \lhjbqguf� gZjpbkkbafhf� dZd� \ha\jZs_gb_f� di_j\hgZqZevghfm� gZjpbkkbafm� jZgg_]h� ^_lkl\Z�� Gh� gZ� >fZl_jbZe_@� kemqZ_\� [j_^Zij_ke_^h\Zgby� fu� k^_eZeb� g_dhlhju_� gZ[ex^_gby�� dhlhju_� aZklZ\beb� gZk� ihclb� ihhij_^_e_gghfm� imlb�� KgZqZeZ� gZf� [jhkbehkv� \ ]eZaZ�� qlh� \ ij_h[eZ^Zxs_f� [hevrbgkl\_

Page 234: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kemqZ_\�ij_ke_^h\Zl_ev�[ue�lh]h�`_�iheZ��qlh�b ij_ke_^m_fuc��Wlhfm�_s_�fh`gh�[ueh�^Zlvg_\bggh_�h[tykg_gb_��gh�\ g_dhlhjuo�ohjhrh�bamq_gguo�kemqZyo�y\gh�h[gZjm`behkv��qlh�ebphlh]h� `_� iheZ�� gZb[he__� ex[bfh_� \ h[uqgh_� \j_fy�� k fhf_glZ� aZ[he_\Zgby� ij_\jZlbehkv� \ij_ke_^h\Zl_ey��>Zevg_cr__�jZa\blb_�\hafh`gh�[eZ]h^Zjy�lhfm��qlh�ex[bfh_�ebph�aZf_gy_lky^jm]bf�ih�ba\_klghfm� koh^kl\m��gZijbf_j��hl_p�mqbl_e_f��gZqZevgbdhf��Ba� lZdbo�ijbf_jh\�qbkeh� dhlhjuo� \k_� m\_ebqb\Z_lky�� fu� ijbreb� d \u\h^m�� qlh� 3DUDQRLD� SHUVHFXWRULD� � ²� wlhnhjfZ�� \ dhlhjhc� bg^b\b^� aZsbsZ_lky� hl� ]hfhk_dkmZevgh]h� qm\kl\Z�� klZ\r_]h� kebrdhfkbevguf��Ij_\jZs_gb_�g_`ghklb� \ g_gZ\bklv�� dhlhjZy�� dZd�ba\_klgh��fh`_l� klZlv� k_jv_aghcm]jhahc�^ey�`bagb�ex[bfh]h�b g_gZ\bklgh]h�h[t_dlZ��khhl\_lkl\m_l�ij_\jZs_gbx�eb[b^haguobfimevkh\�\ kljZo��y\eyxsbcky�ihklhygguf�j_amevlZlhf�ijhp_kkZ�\ul_kg_gby��<hl��gZijbf_j�ihke_^gbc�kemqZc�fhbo�gZ[ex^_gbc�lZdh]h�jh^Z��H^gh]h�fheh^h]h�\jZqZ�ijbrehkv�\ukeZlv�ba_]h�jh^gh]h�]hjh^Z��ihlhfm�qlh�hg�m]jh`Ze�`bagb�kugZ�ijhn_kkhjZ�ba�lh]h�`_�]hjh^Z��[u\r_]h^h� lh]h� _]h� emqrbf� ^jm]hf�� Wlhfm� ij_`g_fm� ^jm]m� hg� ijbibku\Ze� ihbklbg_� ^vy\hevkdb_gZf_j_gby� b ^_fhgbq_kdh_� fh]ms_kl\h�� Hg� [ue� \bgh\gbdhf� \k_o� g_kqZklbc�� ihklb]rbo� aZihke_^gb_�]h^u�k_fvx�[hevgh]h��\k_o�k_f_cguo�b khpbZevguo�g_m^Zq��Gh�fZeh�lh]h��aehc�^jm]b _]h�hl_p��ijhn_kkhj��\ua\Zeb�\hcgm�b ijb\_eb�\ kljZgm�jmkkdbo��AZ�wlh�hg�lukyqm�jZa�^he`_g[ue� [u� ihieZlblvky� `bagvx�� b gZr� [hevghc� [ue� m[_`^_g�� qlh� kh� kf_jlvx� ij_klmigbdZgZklmibe�[u�dhg_p�\k_f�g_kqZklvyf��B \k_�lZdb�_]h�ij_`gyy�g_`ghklv�d g_fm�[ueZ�gZklhevdhkbevgZ��qlh�iZjZebah\ZeZ�_]h�jmdm��dh]^Z�_fm�h^gZ`^u�ij_^klZ\beky�kemqZc�ih^klj_eblv�\jZ]ZgZ� kZfhf� [ebadhf� jZkklhygbb�� < dhjhldbo� [_k_^Zo�� dhlhju_� [ueb� m f_gy� k [hevguf�\uykgbehkv��qlh�^jm`_kdb_�hlghr_gby�f_`^m�h[hbfb�gZqZebkv�^Z\gh��\ ]bfgZabq_kdb_�]h^u�Ih�f_gvr_c�f_j_�h^bg�jZa�[ueb�i_j_c^_gu�]jZgbpu�^jm`[u��ijh\_^_ggZy�\f_kl_�ghqv�[ueZih\h^hf�^ey�ihegh]h�k_dkmZevgh]h�kghr_gby��D `_gsbgZf�gZr�iZpb_gl�gbdh]^Z�g_�bkiulu\Zel_o�qm\kl\��dhlhju_�khhl\_lkl\h\Zeb�_]h�\hajZklm�b _]h�ijb\e_dZl_evghklb��H^bg�jZa�hg�[ueh[jmq_g� k djZkb\hc� b agZlghc� ^_\mrdhc�� gh� lZ� jZkkljhbeZ� ihfhe\dm�� lZd� dZd� g_� \klj_lbeZg_`ghklb�kh�klhjhgu�k\h_]h �;j_^�ij_ke_^h\Zgby��eZl���²�Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�`_gboZ��=h^u�kimkly�_]h�[he_agv�jZajZabeZkv�dZd�jZa�\ lhl�fhf_gl��dh]^Z�_fm�\ i_j\uc�jZam^Zehkv� iheghklvx� m^h\e_l\hjblv� `_gsbgm�� Dh]^Z� wlZ� `_gsbgZ� k [eZ]h^Zjghklvx� b \kZfhaZ[\_gbb�h[gyeZ�_]h��hg�\^jm]�ihqm\kl\h\Ze�aZ]Z^hqgmx�[hev��dhlhjZy�ijhreZ�dZd�hkljucgZ^j_a�\hdjm]�djurdb�q_j_iZ��Iha^g__�hg�bklhedh\Ze� wlh�hsms_gb_� lZd��[m^lh� _fm� k^_eZebgZ^j_a��dhlhjuf�hldju\Zxl�fha]�ijb�\kdjulbb��Z lZd�dZd�_]h�^jm]�klZe�iZlheh]hZgZlhfhf��lhihkl_i_ggh�hg�hldjue��qlh�lhevdh�7270RU�ih^hkeZlv�_fm�wlm�`_gsbgm�^ey�bkdmr_gby��K l_oihj� m g_]h� hldjuebkv� ]eZaZ�b gZ�^jm]b_�ij_ke_^h\Zgby��`_jl\hc� dhlhjuo� hg� klZe� [eZ]h^Zjy^_ckl\byf�[u\r_]h�^jm]Z�Gh� dZd� `_� [ulv� \ l_o� kemqZyo�� dh]^Z� ij_ke_^h\Zl_ev� g_� h^gh]h� iheZ� k ij_ke_^m_fuf�dhlhju_�� dZ`_lky�� ijhlb\hj_qZl� gZr_fm� h[tykg_gbx� aZsblu� hl� ]hfhk_dkmZevgh]h� eb[b^h"G_^Z\gh�m f_gy�[ueZ�\hafh`ghklv�bkke_^h\Zlv�lZdhc�kemqZc��b \�dZ`ms_fky�ijhlb\hj_qbb�yfh]�h[gZjm`blv�ih^l\_j`^_gb_��Fheh^Zy�^_\mrdZ��kqblZ\rZy��qlh�__�ij_ke_^m_l�fm`qbgZ��kdhlhjuf�hgZ�bf_eZ�^\Z�g_`guo�k\b^Zgby��\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�kgZqZeZ�bf_eZ�[j_^h\mx�b^_x�ihhlghr_gbx� d `_gsbg_�� dhlhjmx� fh`gh� kqblZlv� aZf_klbl_evgbp_c� fZl_jb�� Lhevdh� ihke_

Page 235: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\lhjh]h� k\b^Zgby� hgZ� k^_eZeZ� rZ]� \i_j_^� b�� hl^_eb\� wlm� [j_^h\mx� b^_x� hl� `_gsbgu�i_j_g_keZ� __ gZ� fm`qbgm�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� mkeh\b_� gZebqby� lh]h� `_� iheZ� m ij_ke_^h\Zl_eyi_j\hgZqZevgh� [ueh� kh[ex^_gh� b \� wlhf� kemqZ_��< k\h_c�`Zeh[_� ^jm]m�gZklZ\gbdm� b \jZqmiZpb_gldZ� g_� mihfygmeZ� h[� wlhc� ij_^\Zjbl_evghc� klZ^bb� [j_^Z� b wlbf� kha^ZeZ� \b^bfhklvijhlb\hj_qby�gZr_fm�ihgbfZgbx�iZjZghcb�=hfhk_dkmZevguc� \u[hj� h[t_dlZ� i_j\hgZqZevgh� [eb`_� d gZjpbkkbafm�� q_f]_l_jhk_dkmZevguc��?keb�aZl_f�g_h[oh^bfh�hl\_j]gmlv�g_`_eZl_evgh�kbevgh_�]hfhk_dkmZevgh_qm\kl\h��lh�h[jZlguc�imlv�d gZjpbkkbafm�hkh[_ggh�e_]hd��>h�kbo�ihj�m f_gy�[ueh�hq_gv�fZehih\h^h\�]h\hjblv�k \Zfb�h[�hkgh\Zo�ex[h\ghc�`bagb��gZkdhevdh�fu�bo�magZeb��y b�l_i_jv�g_fh]m� wlh� \hkihegblv�� Ohqm� ebrv� ih^q_jdgmlv�� qlh� \u[hj� h[t_dlZ�� rZ]� \i_j_^� \ jZa\blbbeb[b^h�� dhlhjuc� ^_eZ_lky� ihke_� gZjpbkklbq_kdhc� klZ^bb�� fh`_l� hkms_kl\blvky� ih� ^\mfjZaebqguf�lbiZf��Beb�ih�gZjpbkklb�q_kdhfm�lbim��dh]^Z�gZ�f_klh�kh[kl\_ggh]h�Y \uklmiZ_l\hafh`gh�[he__�ihoh`bc�gZ�g_]h�h[t_dl��beb�ih� lbim�hihju��dh]^Z�ebpZ��klZ\rb_�^hjh]bfb[eZ]h^Zjy�m^h\e_l\hj_gbx�^jm]bo�`bag_gguo�ihlj_[ghkl_c��\u[bjZxlky�b h[t_dlZfb�eb[b^h�Kbevgmx�nbdkZpbx�eb[b^h�gZ�gZjibkklbq_�kdhf�lbi_�\u[hjZ�h[t_dlh\�fu�\dexqZ_f�lZd`_�\ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklv�d hldjulhc�]hfhk_dkmZevghklb�<u�ihfgbl_��qlh�\h�\j_fy�i_j\hc�gZr_c�\klj_qb�\ wlhf�k_f_klj_�y jZkkdZaZe�\Zf�kemqZc[j_^Z� j_\ghklb� m `_gsbgu�� L_i_jv�� dh]^Z� fu� lZd� [ebadb� d dhgpm�� \u�� dhg_qgh�� ohl_eb� [umkeurZlv��dZd�fu�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdb�h[tykgy_f�[j_^h\mx�b^_x��Gh�ih�wlhfm�ih\h^m�y fh]m\Zf� kdZaZlv� f_gvr_�� q_f� \u� h`b^Z_l_�� G_ijhgbpZ_fhklv� [j_^h\hc� b^_b� lZd� `_�� dZd� bgZ\yaqb\h]h�khklhygby�^ey�eh]bq_kdbo�Zj]mf_glh\�b j_Zevgh]h�hiulZ�h[tykgy_lky� hlghr_gb_fd [_kkhagZl_evghfm�� dhlhjh_� ij_^klZ\ey_lky� b ih^Z\ey_lky� [j_^h\hc� beb� gZ\yaqb\hc� b^__c�JZaebqb_�f_`^m�gbfb�hkgh\Zgh�gZ�jZaebqghc�lhibd_�b ^bgZfbd_�h[hbo�aZ[he_\Zgbc�DZd� ijb�iZjZghc_�� lZd� b ijb�f_eZgohebb�� dhlhjZy� ij_^klZ\e_gZ��f_`^m� ijhqbf�� \_kvfZjZaebqgufb� debgbq_kdbfb� nhjfZfb�� fu� gZreb� f_klh�� k dhlhjh]h� fh`gh� aZ]eygmlv� \h\gmlj_ggxx�kljmdlmjm�aZ[he_\Zgby��Fu�magZeb��qlh�kZfhmij_db��dhlhjufb�wlb�f_eZgohebdbfmqZxl� k_[y� kZfuf� [_kihsZ^guf� h[jZahf�� \ kmsghklb�� hlghkylky� d ^jm]hfm� ebpm�k_dkmZevghfm� h[t_dlm�� dhlhjuc� hgb� mljZlbeb� beb� dhlhjuc� ih� k\h_c� \bg_� ihl_jye� ^ey� gboagZqbfhklv��Hlkx^Z�fu�fh]eb�aZdexqblv��qlh�ohly�f_eZgohebd�b hl\_e�k\h_�eb[b^h�hl�h[t_dlZ�gh�[eZ]h^Zjy�ijhp_kkm��dhlhjuc� ke_^m_l�gZa\Zlv� ©gZjpbkklbq_kdhc�b^_glbnbdZpb_cª��h[t_dl\ha^\b]gml� \ kZfhf� Y�� dZd� [u� kijh_pbjh\Zg� gZ� Y�� A^_kv� y fh]m� \Zf� ^Zlv� ebrv� h[jZagmxoZjZdl_jbklbdm��Z g_�lhibdh�^bgZfbq_kdh_�hibkZgb_��Lh]^Z�k kh[kl\_gguf�Y h[jZsZxlky��dZd�khklZ\e_gguf�h[t_dlhf��b hgh�bkiulu\Z_l�gZ�k_[_�\k_�Z]j_kkbb�b ijhy\e_gby�fklbl_evghklb�ij_^gZagZqZ\rb_ky�h[t_dlm��B kdehgghklv�d kZfhm[bckl\m�f_eZgohebdh\�klZgh\blky�ihgylg__�_keb� ijbgylv� \h� \gbfZgb_�� qlh� h`_klhq_gb_� [hevgh]h� h^gbf� b l_f� `_� m^Zjhf� ihiZ^Z_l� \kh[kl\_ggh_� Y b� \ ex[bfh�g_gZ\bklguc� h[t_dl�� Ijb� f_eZgohebb�� lZd� `_� dZd� ijb� ^jm]bogZjpbkklbq_kdbo� aZ[he_\Zgbyo�� \ yjdh� \ujZ`_gghc� nhjf_� ijhy\ey_lky� q_jlZ� `bagb� qm\kl\�dhlhjmx�fu�ijb\udeb�\ke_^�aZ�;e_ce_jhf�gZau\Zlv�Zf[b\Ze_glghklvx��Fu�ih^jZamf_\Z_f�ih^wlbf�ijhy\e_gb_�ijhlb\hiheh`guo��g_`guo�b \jZ`^_[guo��qm\kl\�ih�hlghr_gbx�d h^ghfm�blhfm�`_� ebpm��<h� \j_fy� wlbo� e_dpbc� y�� d kh`Ze_gbx�� g_� bf_x� \hafh`ghklb� jZkkdZaZlv� \Zf[hevr_�h[�Zf[b\Ze_glghklb�qm\kl\�

Page 236: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Djhf_�gZjpbkklbq_kdhc�b^_glbnbdZpbb��[u\Z_l�bkl_jbq_kdZy��ba\_klgZy�gZf�hq_gv�^Z\gh�Y [u� kZf� ohl_e�� qlh[u� hdZaZehkv� \hafh`guf� h[tykgblv� bo� jZaebqb_� g_kdhevdbfb� ykgufbhij_^_e_gbyfb�� H i_jbh^bq_kdbo� b pbdebq_kdbo� nhjfZo� f_eZgohebb� y fh]m� \Zf� dh_�qlhjZkkdZaZlv��qlh�\u��gZ\_jgh_��hohlgh� \ukemrZ_l_��Ijb�[eZ]hijbylguo� mkeh\byo�� hdZau\Z_lky\hafh`guf�²�y ^\Z�jZaZ�ijh^_eu\Ze�wlhl�hiul�²�ij_^hl\jZlblv�ih\lhj_gb_�khklhygby�lZdh]h`_� beb� ijhlb\hiheh`gh]h� gZkljh_gby� [eZ]h^Zjy� ZgZeblbq_kdhfm� e_q_gbx� \ k\h[h^guc� hl[he_agb�ijhf_`mlhd�\j_f_gb��Ijb�wlhf�magZ_rv��qlh�b ijb�f_eZgohebb��b ijb�fZgbb�^_eh�b^_lh[� hkh[hf� kihkh[_� jZaj_r_gby� dhgnebdlZ�� ij_^ihkuedb� dhlhjh]h� iheghklvx� kh\iZ^Zxl� kij_^ihkuedZfb� ^jm]bo� g_\jhah\�� Fh`_l_� k_[_� ij_^klZ\blv�� kdhevdh� ikbohZgZebam� _s_ij_^klhbl�hldjulv�\ wlhc�h[eZklb�Y kdZaZe� \Zf� lZd`_�� qlh� [eZ]h^Zjy� ZgZebam� gZjpbkklbq_kdbo� aZ[he_\Zgbc� fu� gZ^__fkymagZlv�khklZ\�gZr_]h�Y b�_]h�ihkljh_gb_�ba�jZaebqguo�bgklZgpbc��< h^ghf�f_kl_�fu�iheh`bebwlhfm�gZqZeh��Ba� ZgZebaZ� [j_^Z�gZ[ex^_gby�fu� k^_eZeb� \u\h^�� qlh� \ Y� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� _klvbgklZgpby��dhlhjZy�[_kij_ju\gh�gZ[ex^Z_l��djblbdm_l�b kjZ\gb\Z_l��ijhlb\hihklZ\eyy� k_[y�lZdbf�h[jZahf��^jm]hc�qZklb�Y��Fu�iheZ]Z_f�ihwlhfm��qlh�[hevghc�\u^Z_l�gZf�_s_�g_�\iheg_hp_g_ggmx� ijZ\^m�� `Zemykv�� qlh� ex[hc� _]h� rZ]� \uke_`b\Z_lky� b gZ[ex^Z_lky�� ex[Zy� _]hfukev�^hdeZ^u\Z_lky�b djblbdm_lky��Hg�hrb[Z_lky�ebrv�\ lhf��qlh�i_j_ghkbl�wlm�g_ijbylgmxkbem�� dZd�g_qlh�ihklhjhgg__�� \h� \g_rgbc�fbj��Hg� qm\kl\m_l� \ k\h_f�Y ]hkih^kl\h� dZdhc�lhbgklZgpbb��dhlhjZy�kjZ\gb\Z_l�_]h�^_ckl\bl_evgh_�Y b�ex[mx�_]h�^_yl_evghklv�k Y�b^_Zehf�kha^Zgguf� bf� \ ijhp_kk_� k\h_]h� jZa\blby�� Fu� ^mfZ_f� lZd`_�� qlh� kha^Zgb_� wlh]h� b^_ZeZijhbahreh� k p_evx� \hkklZgh\e_gby� kZfh^h\hevkl\Z�� k\yaZggh]h� k i_j\bqguf�bgnZglbevgufgZjpbkkbafhf��gh�ij_l_ji_\r_]h�k l_o�ihj�lZd�fgh]h�g_ijbylghkl_c�b h[b^��GZ[ex^ZxsZy�aZkZfbf� kh[hc�bgklZgpby�ba\_klgZ�gZf�dZd�p_gahj�Y�� dZd� kh\_klv�� wlh� lZ�`_� kZfZy�bgklZgpby�dhlhjZy� ghqvx� hkms_kl\ey_l� p_gamjm� kgh\b^_gby�� hl� dhlhjhc� bkoh^yl� \ul_kg_gbyg_^himklbfuo�`_eZgbc��Dh]^Z�hgZ�ijb�[j_^_�gZ[ex^_gby�jZkiZ^Z_lky��lh�jZkdju\Z_l�gZf�k\h_ijhbkoh`^_gb_�ba�\ebygby�jh^bl_e_c��\hkiblZl_e_c�[L�khpbZevghc�kj_^u��ba�b^_glbnbdZpbb�khl^_evgufb�ba�wlbo�ebp��kem`Zsbo�b^_Zehf�LZdh\u� g_dhlhju_� j_amevlZlu�� ihemq_ggu_� gZfb� ^h� kbo� ihj� [eZ]h^Zjy� bkihevah\ZgbxikbohZgZebaZ� \ kemqZyo� gZjpbkklbq_kdbo� aZ[he_\Zgbc�� Hgb�� jZamf__lky�� _s_� kebrdhfg_agZqbl_evgu� b aZqZklmx� ebr_gu� lhc� ykghklb�� dhlhjZy� fh`_l� [ulv� ^hklb]gmlZ� \ gh\hch[eZklb�ebrv�[eZ]h^Zjy�hkgh\Zl_evghc�hk\_^hfe_gghklb��<k_f�bf�fu�h[yaZgu�bkihevah\Zgb_fihgylby�Y�eb[b^h��beb�gZjpbkklbq_kdh]h�eb[b^h��k ihfhsvx�dhlhjh]h�fu�jZkijhkljZgbeb�gZgZjpbkklbq_kdb_�g_\jhau�ij_^klZ\e_gby��ih^l\_j^b\rb_ky�gZ�g_\jhaZo�i_j_g_k_gby��Gh�l_i_jv\u� ihklZ\bl_� \hijhk�� \hafh`gh� eb�� qlh[u� gZf� m^Zehkv� h[tykgblv� l_hjb_c� eb[b^h� \k_gZjmr_gby� gZjpbkklbq_kdbo� g_\jhah\� b ikbohah\�� qlh[u� fu� \_a^_� ijbagZeb� \bgh\gbdhfaZ[he_\Zgby�eb[b^haguc�nZdlhj�^mr_\ghc�`bagb�b gbdh]^Z�g_�kqblZeb�hl\_lkl\_gguf�aZ�g_]hbaf_g_gb_�\ nmgdpbb�bgklbgdlh\�kZfhkhojZg_gby"�M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��fg_�dZ`_lky�qlh�g_�ke_^m_l�ki_rblv�k j_r_gb_f�wlh]h�\hijhkZ��dhlhjh_��ij_`^_�\k_]h��_s_�g_�khaj_eh��Fukihdhcgh�fh`_f�ij_^hklZ\blv�_]h�gZmqghfm�ijh]j_kkm��Y [u�g_�m^b\beky��_keb�[u�kihkh[ghklviZlh]_ggh]h� \ha^_ckl\by�^_ckl\bl_evgh� hdZaZeZkv�ij_bfms_kl\hf� eb[b^haguo� \e_q_gbc�� lZdqlh� l_hjby� eb[b^h� fh]eZ� [u� ijZa^gh\Zlv� k\hc� ljbmfn� ih� \k_c� ebgbb� hl� ijhkl_crboZdlmZevguo�g_\jhah\�^h�kZfh]h�ly`_eh]h�ikbohlbq_kdh]h�hlqm`^_gby�bg^b\b^Z��<_^v�fu�agZ_f

Page 237: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

oZjZdl_jgmx�q_jlm�eb[b^h�ijhlb\blvky�ih^qbg_gbx�j_Zevghklb�fbjZ��km^v[_��Gh�y kqblZx�\\ukr_c� kl_i_gb� \_jhylguf�� qlh� bgklbgdlu� Y \lhjbqgh� aZo\Zlu\Zxlky� iZlh]_ggufbbfimevkZfb�eb[b^h�b \ugm`^Zxlky�d gZjmr_gbx�nmgdpbb��B y�g_�fh]m�ijbagZlv�ihjZ`_gb_gZr_]h� gZijZ\e_gby� bkke_^h\Zgby�� _keb� gZf� ij_^klhbl� magZlv�� qlh� ijb� ly`_euo� ikbohaZobgklbgdlu�Y ^Z`_�i_j\bqgh�[u\Zxl�k[blu�k imlb��wlh�ihdZ`_l�[m^ms__��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��\Zf�: fg_�iha\hevl_�_s_�gZ�h^gh�f]gh\_gb_�\_jgmlvky�d kljZom��qlh[u�hk\_lblv�hklZ\r__kylZf� l_fgh_�f_klh��Fu� kdZaZeb��qlh�gZf�g_� ke_^m_l� kh]eZrZlvky� kh� klhev� ohjhrh�ba\_klgufhlghr_gb_f�f_`^m�kljZohf�b eb[b^h��[m^lh�j_Zevguc� kljZo�i_j_^�e^phf�hiZkghklb�^he`_g[ulv�ijhy\e_gb_f�bgklbgdlh\�kZfhkhojZg_gby��ohly�kZfh�ih�k_[_�wlh�_^\Z�eb�hkihjbfh��Gh�dZdh[klhyeh�[u�^_eh��_keb�[u�Znn_dl�kljZoZ�bkoh^be�g_�ba�w]hbklbq_kdbo�bgklbgdlh\�Y��Z ba�Y�eb[b^h"�<_^v�khklhygb_�kljZoZ�\h�\kydhf�kemqZ_�g_p_e_khh[jZagh��b _]h�g_p_e_khh[jZaghklvhq_\b^gZ��_keb�hg�^hklb]Z_l�[he__�\ukhdhc�kl_i_gb��Hg�f_rZ_l�^_ckl\bx��[m^v�lh�[_]kl\h�bebaZsblZ�� qlh� _^bgkl\_ggh�p_e_khh[jZagh�b kem`bl� kZfhkhojZg_gbx��LZdbf� h[jZahf�� _keb�fuijbibr_f�Znn_dlb\gmx�qZklv�j_Zevgh]h�kljZoZ�Y�eb[b^h��Z ^_ckl\b_�ijb�wlhf�²�bgklbgdlZfkZfhkhojZg_gby�� lh� mkljZgbf� \k_� l_hj_lbq_kdb_� ljm^ghklb�� <ijhq_f�� \u� \_^v� g_� ^mfZ_l_\k_jv_a�� qlh� q_eh\_d� m[_]Z_l�� ihlhfm� qlh� bkiulu\Z_l� kljZo"� G_l�� bkiulu\Zxl� kljZo� bh[jZsZxlky�\ [_]kl\h�ih�h[s_c�ijbqbg_��dhlhjZy�\hagbdZ_l��dh]^Z�aZf_qZxl�hiZkghklv��Ex^b�i_j_`b\rb_� [hevrb_� `bag_ggu_� hiZkghklb�� jZkkdZau\Zxl�� qlh� hgb� kh\k_f� g_� [hyebkv�� Zlhevdh� ^_ckl\h\Zeb�� gZijbf_j�� p_ebebkv� ba� jm`vy� \ obsgbdZ�� Z wlh� [ueh�� dhg_qgh�� kZfufp_e_khh[jZaguf�><:>P:LV�K?>VF:Y�E?DPBYI_j_g_k_gb_M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��LZd�dZd�l_i_jv�fu�ijb[eb`Z_fky�d dhgpm�gZrbo�[_k_^��lh�m\Zk�\hagbdZ_l�gZ^_`^Z��\ dhlhjhc�\u�g_�^he`gu�h[fZgmlvky��<u��\_jhylgh��^mfZ_l_��qlh�g_�^eylh]h�y \h^be�\Zk�ih�^_[jyf�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�fZl_jbZeZ��qlh[u�\ dhgp_�dhgph\�hlimklblv�g_� kdZaZ\� gb keh\Z� h l_jZibb�� gZ� dhlhjhc� hkgh\ZgZ� \hafh`ghklv� \hh[s_� aZgbfZlvkyikbohZgZebahf��>Z� y b� g_� fh]m� g_� dhkgmlvky� wlhc� l_fu�� ihlhfm� qlh� ijb� wlhf� \u� gZ]ey^ghihagZdhfbl_kv� k gh\uf� nZdlhf�� [_a� agZgby� dhlhjh]h� ihgbfZgb_� bamq_gguo� gZfb� [he_ag_chklZehkv�[u�kZfuf�hsmlbfuf�h[jZahf�g_iheguf�Y agZx�� qlh� \u� g_� `^_l_� hl� f_gy� jmdh\h^kl\Z� ih� l_ogbd_� ijh\_^_gby� ZgZebaZ� kl_jZi_\lbq_kdhc� p_evx�� <u� ohlbl_� ebrv� \ kZfuo� h[sbo� q_jlZo� agZlv�� dZdbf� h[jZahf\ha^_ckl\m_l� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdZy� l_jZiby� b q_]h� hgZ� ijbf_jgh� ^hklb]Z_l�� B magZlv� wlh� \ubf__l_� g_hkihjbfh_� ijZ\h��Gh� y g_� ohqm� \Zf� wlh� khh[sZlv�� Z gZklZb\Zx� gZ� lhf�� qlh[u� \u^h]Z^Zebkv�kZfb�Ih^mfZcl_��<u�ihagZdhfbebkv�k kZfufb�kms_kl\_ggufb�mkeh\byfb�aZ[he_\Zgby��Z lZd`_kh�\k_fb�nZdlhjZfb��^_ckl\mxsbfb�gZ� aZ[he_\r_]h��Qlh�`_�lml�ih^e_`bl�l_jZi_\lbq_kdhfm\ha^_ckl\bx"� Wlh�� ij_`^_� \k_]h�� gZke_^kl\_ggZy� ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklv�� gZf� g_� qZklhijboh^blky�h g_c�]h\hjblv��ihlhfm�qlh�hgZ�wg_j]bqgh�hlklZb\Z_lky�^jm]bfb��b fu�g_�fh`_f

Page 238: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kdZaZlv�h g_c�gbq_]h�gh\h]h��Gh�g_�^mfZcl_��qlh�fu�__�g_^hhp_gb\Z_f��bf_ggh�dZd�l_jZi_\lufu�^h\hevgh�ykgh�hsmsZ_f�__ kbem��<h�\kydhf�kemqZ_��fu�gbq_]h�g_�fh`_f�\ g_c�baf_gblv�hgZ�b ^ey�gZk�hklZ_lky�q_f�lh�^Zgguf��qlh�klZ\bl�ij_^_eu�gZrbf�mkbebyf��AZl_f�²�\ebygb_jZggbo�^_lkdbo�i_j_`b\Zgbc��dhlhju_�fu�ijb\udeb�\u^\b]Zlv�\ ZgZeba_�gZ�i_j\h_�f_klh��hgbhlghkylky� d ijhrehfm�� fu� g_� fh`_f� bo� mgbqlh`blv�� >Ze__�� \k_� lh�� qlh� fu� h[t_^bgbeb� \ihgylb_�©j_Zevguc�\ugm`^_gguc�hldZaª��g_m^Zqgh�keh`b\rZyky�`bagv��ke_^kl\b_f�dhlh�jhcy\ey_lky� g_^hklZlhd� ex[\b�� [_^ghklv�� k_f_cgu_� jZa^hju�� g_kqZkl� eb\v]Z� [jZd�g_[eZ]hijbylgu_� khpbZevgu_� mkeh\by� b kljh]hklv� gjZ\kl\_gguo� lj_[h\Zgbc�� ih^� ]g_lhfdhlhjuo�gZoh^blky�ebqghklv��Lml�dZd�[m^lh�^hklZlhqgh�\hafh`ghkl_c�^ey�hq_gv�^_ckl\_gghcl_jZibb�� gh� wlh� ^he`gZ� [ueZ� [u� [ulv� l_jZiby�� dhlhjmx� ijh\h^be�� ih� \_gkdhfm� gZjh^ghfmij_^Zgbx�� bfi_jZlhj� Bhkbn�� l�� _�� \f_rZl_evkl\h� fh]ms_kl\_ggh]h� [eZ]hl\hjbl_ey�� i_j_^\he_c� dhlhjh]h� kdehgyxlky� ex^b� b bkq_aZxl� ljm^ghklb�� : dlh� lZdb_� fu�� qlh[u� \dexqblvlZdmx� [eZ]hl\hjbl_evghklv� dZd� kj_^kl\h� \ gZrm� l_jZibx"� KZfb� [_^gu_� b [_kihfhsgu_� \h[s_kl\_gghf�hlghr_gbb��\ugm`^_ggu_�^h[u\Zlv�kj_^kl\Z�d kms_kl\h\Zgbx�k\h_c�\jZq_[ghc^_yl_evghklvx��fu�^Z`_�g_�\ khklhygbb�hl^Z\Zlv�k\hc�ljm^�lZdbf�`_�g_bfmsbf��dZd�wlh�fh]ml^jm]b_�\jZqb��e_qZsb_�^jm]bfb�f_lh^Zfb��>ey� wlh]h�gZrZ� l_jZiby� aZgbfZ_l�kebrdhf�fgh]h\j_f_gb� b ^eblky� kebrdh� ^he]h��Gh��fh`_l� [ulv�� \u� mo\Zlbl_kv� aZ� h^bg� ba� i_j_qbke_gguofhf_glh\� b ih^mfZ_l_�� qlh� lZf� gZc^_l_� lhqdm� ijbeh`_gby� ^ey� gZr_]h� \ha^_ckl\by�� ?kebgjZ\kl\_ggh_� h]jZgbq_gb_�� lj_[m_fh_� h[s_kl\hf�� ijbgbfZ_l� mqZklb_� \ bkiulu\Z_fhf[hevguf� ebr_gbb�� lh� \_^v� e_q_gb_�fh`_l� ijb^Zlv� _fm�fm`_kl\Z� beb� ^Zlv� ijyfh_� mdZaZgb_ij_klmiblv� wlb� ij_]jZ^u� b ^h[blvky� m^h\e_l\hj_gby� b \ua^hjh\e_gby�� hldZaZ\rbkv� hlhkms_kl\e_gby� \ukhdhp_gbfh]h� h[s_kl\hf�� gh� klhev� qZklh� hklZ\ey_fh]h� b^_ZeZ�� LZdbfh[jZahf�� fh`gh� \ua^hjh\_lv�� ©^Z\� \hexª� k\h_c� k_dkmZevghklb�� IjZ\^Z�� ijb� wlhfZgZeblbq_kdh_�e_q_gb_�fh`gh�mij_dgmlv�\ lhf��qlh�hgh�g_�kem`bl�h[s_kl\_gghc�fhjZeb��Lh�qlh�hgh�^Z_l�h^ghfm��hlgylh�m h[s_kl\Z�Gh��m\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��dlh�\Zk�lZd�g_ijZ\bevgh�bgnhjfbjh\Ze"�G_�fh`_l�[ulv�bj_qb� h lhf�� qlh[u� kh\_l� ^Zlv� \hex� k\h_c� k_dkmZevghklb� fh]� ku]jZlv� dZdmx�lh� jhev� \ZgZeblbq_kdhc�l_jZibb��M`_�ihlhfm�wlh�g_�lZd��qlh�fu�kZfb�h[ty\beb��qlh�m [hevgh]h�bf__lkymihjguc� dhgnebdl� f_`^m� eb[b^haguf� ih[m`^_gb_f� b k_dkmZevguf� \ul_kg_gb_f�� f_`^mqm\kl\_gghc�b Zkd_lbq_kdhc�gZijZ\e_gghklyfb��Wlhl�dhgnebdl�g_�mkljZgy_lky�k ihfhsvx�lh]h�qlh� h^ghc�ba�gZijZ\e_gghkl_c�ihfh]Z_l� h^_j`Zlv�ih[_^m�gZ^�ijhlb\hiheh`ghc��Fu� \b^bf�qlh� m g_j\gh[hevgh]h� Zkd_lbaf� h^_j`Ze� \_jo�� Ke_^kl\b_f� wlh]h� y\ey_lky� dZd� jZa� lh�� qlhih^Z\e_ggh_� k_dkmZevgh_� klj_fe_gb_� gZoh^bl� k_[_� \uoh^� \ kbfilhfZo�� ?keb� [u�fu� l_i_jv�gZh[hjhl��^h[bebkv�ih[_^u�qm\kl\_gghklb��lh�hlh^\bgmlh_�\ klhjhgm�k_dkmZevgh_�\ul_kg_gb_^he`gh� [ueh� [u� gZclb� k_[_� aZf_s_gb_� \ kbfilhfZo��Gb� h^gh� ba� h[hbo� j_r_gbc� g_�fh`_lmgbqlh`blv� \gmlj_ggbc� dhgnebdl�� \kydbc� jZa� dZdZy�eb[h� h^gZ� klhjhgZ� hklZ\ZeZkv� [ug_m^h\e_l\hj_gghc��Lhevdh�\ g_dhlhjuo�kemqZyo�dhgnebdl�[u\Z_l�lZd�g_mklhcqb\��qlh�lZdhcnZdlhj��dZd�khqm\kl\b_�\jZqZ�lhc�beb�bghc�klhjhg_��fh`_l�bf_lv�j_rZxs__�agZq_gb_��gh�wlbkemqZb��kh[kl\_ggh��b g_�gm`^Zxlky�\ ZgZeblbq_kdhf�e_q_gbb��EbpZ��gZ�dhlhjuo�\jZq�fh`_lhdZaZlv� lZdh_� \ebygb_�� gZreb� [u� wlhl� imlv� b [_a� \jZqZ��<u� agZ_l_�� qlh� _keb� \ha^_j`Zggucfheh^hc� q_eh\_d� j_rblky� gZ� \g_[jZqgmx� iheh\mx� k\yav� beb� g_m^h\e_l\hj_ggZy� `_gsbgZ\hagZ]jZ`^Z_l�k_[y�k ^jm]bf�fm`qbghc�� lh�h[uqgh�hgb�g_�`^ml�jZaj_r_gby�\jZqZ�beb�^Z`_

Page 239: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ZgZeblbdZ�< wlhc�kblmZpbb�h[uqgh�mimkdZxl�ba�\b^Z�h^bg�kms_kl\_gguc�fhf_gl��Z bf_ggh�lhl��qlhiZlh]_gguc� dhgnebdl� g_\jhlbdh\� g_evay� kf_rb\Zlv� k ghjfZevghc� [hjv[hc� ^mr_\guo^\b`_gbc�� \ujhkrbo� gZ� h^ghc� b lhc�`_� ikboheh]bq_kdhc� ihq\_�� Wlh� klhedgh\_gb_� kbe�� badhlhjuo�h^gZ�^hklb]eZ� klmi_gb�ij_^khagZl_evgh]h�b khagZl_evgh]h�� Z ^jm]Zy� aZ^_j`ZeZkv�gZklmi_gb�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��Ihwlhfm�dhgnebdl�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�jZaj_r_g��kihjysb_�lZd�`_�fZehih^oh^yl� ^jm]�>jm]m�� dZd� [_euc� f_^\_^v� b dbl� \ ba\_klghf� ijbf_j_�� J_r_gb_� fh`_l� [ulvijbgylh�lhevdh�lh]^Z��dh]^Z�hgb�\klj_lylky�gZ�h^ghc�b lhc�`_�ihq\_��Y iheZ]Zx��qlh�k^_eZlvwlh�\hafh`guf�b y\ey_lky�_^bgkl\_gghc�aZ^Zq_c�l_jZibb���: djhf_�lh]h��m\_jyx�\Zk��qlh�\u�g_\_jgh�hk\_^hfe_gu��_keb�ij_^iheZ]Z_l_��qlh�kh\_lu�bjmdh\h^kl\h� \ `bl_ckdbo� ^_eZo� y\eyxlky� khklZ\ghc� qZklvx� ZgZeblbq_kdh]h� \ha^_ckl\by�GZijhlb\��fu�ih�\hafh`ghklb�ba[_]Z_f�lZdhc�f_glhjkdhc�jheb�b [hevr_�\k_]h�`_eZ_f��qlh[u[hevghc�kZfhklhyl_evgh�ijbgbfZe�k\hb�j_r_gby��K wlhc�p_evx�fu�^Z`_� lj_[m_f��qlh[u�\k_`bag_ggh� \Z`gu_� j_r_gby²h \u[hj_� ijhn_kkbb�� ohayckl\_gguo� ij_^ijbylbyo�� aZdexq_gbb[jZdZ�beb�jZa\h^_�²�hg�hleh`be�gZ�\j_fy�e_q_gby�b ijb\_e�\ bkiheg_gb_� lhevdh�ihke_� _]hhdhgqZgby�� Kh]eZkbl_kv�� \k_� h[klhbl� bgZq_�� q_f� \u� k_[_� ij_^klZ\eyeb�� Lhevdh� khij_^_e_ggufb� hq_gv� fheh^ufb� beb� kh\_jr_ggh� [_kihfhsgufb� b g_mjZ\gh\_r_ggufb[hevgufb� fu� g_� fh`_f� hkms_kl\blv� wlh� `_eZl_evgh_� h]jZgbq_gb_�� >ey� gbo� fu� ^he`gukh\f_sZlv� ^_yl_evghklv� \jZqZ� b \hkiblZl_ey�� lh]^Z� fu� ij_djZkgh� khagZ_f� k\hxhl\_lkl\_gghklv�b \_^_f�k_[y�k g_h[oh^bfhc�hklhjh`ghklvx�Gh�ba�lh]h�j\_gby��k dhlhjuf�y aZsbsZxkv�ijhlb\�mij_dZ��qlh�g_j\gh[hevgh]h�\h�\j_fyZgZeblbq_kdh]h�e_q_gby�ih[m`^Zxl� ©^Zlv�k_[_�\hexª��\j�f g_�ke_^m_l�^_eZlv�\u\h^��qlh�fu\ha^_ckl\m_f�gZ�g_]h�\ ihevam�h[s_kl\_gghc�gjZ\kl\_gghklb��Wlh�gZf�ih�f_gvr_c�f_j_�klhev`_� qm`^h�� Ohly� fu� g_� j_nhjfZlhju�� Z ebrv� gZ[ex^Zl_eb�� gh� fu� g_� fh`_f� g_� kfhlj_lvdjblbq_kdbfb�]eZaZfb�b khqeb�g_\hafh`guf�\klZlv�gZ�klhjhgm�mkeh\ghc�k_dkmZevghc�fhjZeb�b\ukhdh� hp_gblv� lhl� kihkh[�� dZdbf� h[s_kl\h� iulZ_lky� ijZdlbq_kdb� meZ^blv� ijh[e_fuk_dkmZevghc� `bagb�� Fu� fh`_f� ijyfh� ih^kqblZlv�� qlh� lh�� qlh� h[s_kl\h� gZau\Z_l� k\h_cgjZ\kl\_gghklvx�� klhbl�[hevrbo�`_jl\�� q_f� aZkem`b\Z_l��b qlh� _]h�f_lh^u� g_� hkgh\Zgu� gZijZ\^b\hklb� b g_� k\b^_l_evkl\mxl� h[� mf_��Fu� g_� f_rZ_f� gZrbf� iZpb_glZf� kemrZlv� wlmdjblbdm��ijbmqZy�bo�d k\h[h^ghfm�hl�ij_^jZkkm^dh\�h[km`^_gbx�k_dkmZevguo�\hijhkh\��dZd�b\kydbo� ^jm]bo�� b _keb� hgb�� klZ\� kZfhklhyl_evgufb� ihke_� aZ\_jr_gby� e_q_gby�� j_rZxlky� ihkh[kl\_gghfm� jZamf_gbx� aZgylv� dZdmx�lh� kj_^gxx� ihabpbx� f_`^m� iheguf� gZkeZ`^_gb_f`bagvx�b h[yaZl_evguf�Zkd_lbafhf��fu�g_�qm\kl\m_f�m]jua_gbc�kh\_klb�gb� aZ�h^bg�ba�wlbo\uoh^h\��Fu� ]h\hjbf�k_[_��qlh�lhl��dlh�k mki_ohf�\ujZ[hlZe�bklbggh_�hlghr_gb_�d kZfhfmk_[_�� gZ\k_]^Z� aZsbs_g� hl� hiZkghklb� klZlv� [_agjZ\kl\_gguf�� _keb� ^Z`_� _]h� djbl_jbcgjZ\kl\_gghklb� dZdbf�lh� h[jZahf� b hlebqZ_lky� hl� ijbgylh]h� \ h[s_kl\_�� <ijhq_f�� fuhkl_j_]Z_fky� ij_m\_ebqblv� agZq_gb_� \hijhkZ� h \ha^_j`Zgbb� \ e_q_gbb� g_\jhah\�� Ebrv� \g_[hevrhf�qbke_�kemqZ_\�fh`gh�jZaj_rblv�iZlheh]bq_kdmx�kblmZpbx�\ugm`^_ggh]h�hldZaZ�kkhhl\_lkl\mxsbf�aZklh_f�eb[b^h�e_]dh�^hklb`bfuf�kihkh[hf�iheh\uo�kghr_gbc�LZdbf� h[jZahf�� \u g_� fh`_l_� h[tykgblv� l_jZi_\lbq_kdh_� \ha^_ckl\b_� ZgZebaZjZaj_r_gb_f� k_dkmZevguo� gZkeZ`^_gbc�� Ihbsbl_� ^jm]h_� h[tykg_gb_�� Fg_� dZ`_lky�� qlh�

Page 240: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hldehgyy� wlh� \Zr_�ij_^iheh`_gb_�� y h^gbf� aZf_qZgb_f�gZ\_e� \Zk�gZ�ijZ\bevguc�imlv��Fu�^he`gh� [ulv�� ijbghkbf� ihevam� l_f�� qlh� aZf_gy_f� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� khagZl_evguf�� i_j_\h^y[_kkhagZl_evgh_�\ khagZl_evgh_��>_ckl\bl_evgh��lZd�hgh�b _klv��Ijb[eb`Zy�[_kkhagZl_evgh_�dkhagZl_evghfm��fu� mgbqlh`Z_f� \ul_kg_gb_�� mkljZgy_f� mkeh\by� ^ey� h[jZah\Zgby� kbfilhfh\�ij_\jZsZ_f� iZlh]_gguc� dhgnebdl� \ ghjfZevguc�� dhlhjuc� dZdbf�lh� h[jZahf� ^he`_g� gZclbjZaj_r_gb_��Fu� \uau\Z_f� m [hevgh]h� g_� qlh� bgh_�� dZd� h^gh� wlh� ikbobq_kdh_� baf_g_gb_�gZkdhevdh�hgh�^hklb]gmlh��gZklhevdh�hdZaZgZ�ihfhsv��LZf��]^_�g_evay�mgbqlh`blv�\ul_kg_gb_beb�ZgZeh]bqguc�_fm�ijhp_kk��lZf�gZr_c�l_jZibb�^_eZlv�g_q_]h�P_ev�gZrbo�mkbebc�fu�fh`_f�knhjfmebjh\Zlv�ih�jZaghfm��hkhagZgb_�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�mgbqlh`_gb_�\ul_kg_gbb��\hkiheg_gb_�Zfg_klbq_kdbo�ijh[_eh\�²�\k_�wlh�h^gh�b lh�`_��Gh�\hafh`gh�� \Zk� g_� m^h\e_l\hjbl� wlh� ijbagZgb_�� <u� kh\k_f� bgZq_� ij_^klZ\eyeb� k_[_\ua^hjh\e_gb_�g_j\gh[hevgh]h��Z bf_ggh�lZd��qlh�hg�klZgh\blky�^jm]bf�q_eh\_dhf�ihke_�lh]h�dZd�ih^\_j]ky�mlhfbl_evghc�jZ[hl_�ikbohZgZebaZ��Z lml�\_kv�j_amevlZl�khklhbl�ebrv�\ lhf��qlhm g_]h� hdZau\Z_lky�g_fgh]h�f_gvr_�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h� b g_fgh]h� [hevr_� khagZl_evgh]h�� q_fjZgvr_�� Gh� \u�� \_jhylgh�� g_^hhp_gb\Z_l_� agZq_gb_� lZdh]h� \gmlj_gg_]h� baf_g_gby�<ue_q_gguc� g_j\gh[hevghc� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� klZe� ^jm]bf� q_eh\_dhf�� gh�� ih� kms_kl\m�� hg�jZamf__lky��hklZeky�l_f�`_�kZfuf��l��_��hg�klZe�lZdbf��dZdbf�fh]�[u�klZlv�\ emqr_f�kemqZ_�ijbkZfuo� [eZ]hijbylguo� mkeh\byo�� : wlh� hq_gv� fgh]h�� ?keb� \u� aZl_f� magZ_l_�� kdhevdh� \k_]hgm`gh�k^_eZlv�b dZdb_�g_h[oh^bfu�mkbeby��qlh[u�hkms_kl\blv�wlh�dZ`ms__ky�g_agZqbl_evgufbaf_g_gb_�\ _]h�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��lh�\Zf�ihdZ`_lky�\_kvfZ�ijZ\^hih^h[guf�agZqbfhklv�lZdh]hjZaebqby�\ ikbobq_kdhf�mjh\g_�Y hldehgxkv�gZ�fbgmlm�hl�l_fu��qlh[u�kijhkblv��agZ_l_�eb�\u��qlh�gZau\Z_lky�dZmaZevghcl_jZib_c"�LZd�gZau\Z_lky�ijb_f��gZijZ\e_gguc�g_�gZ�[he_ag_ggu_�y\e_gby��Z gZ�mkljZg_gb_ijbqbg�[he_agb��Y\ey_lky�eb�gZrZ�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdZy�l_jZiby�dZmaZevghc�beb�g_l"�Hl\_l�g_ijhkl��gh��fh`_l�[ulv��hg�^Zkl�ih\h^�m[_^blvky�\ fZehc�agZqbfhklb�lZdhc�ihklZgh\db�\hijhkZ�Ihkdhevdm�ZgZeblbq_kdZy�l_jZiby�g_�klZ\bl�k\h_c�[eb`Zcr_c�aZ^Zq_c�mkljZg_gb_�kbfilhfh\�hgZ�^_ckl\m_l�dZd�dZmaZevgZy��< ^jm]hc�k\yab�\u�fh`_l_�kdZaZlv��qlh�hgZ�g_�dZmaZevgZy��Fum`_� ^Z\gh� ijhke_^beb� ijbqbggmx� p_iv� hl� \ul_kg_gbb� ^h� \jh`^_gguo� \e_q_gbc�� bohlghkbl_evgmx� bgl_gkb\ghklv� \ dhgklblmpbb� b hldehg_gby� \ ijhp_kk_� bo� jZa\blby�Ij_^iheh`bl_� l_i_jv�� qlh� fu� fh]eb� [u� obfbq_kdbf� iml_f� \f_rZlvky� \ wlhl� f_oZgbaf�ih\urZy� beb� kgb`Zy� dhebq_kl\h� bf_xs_]hky� eb[b^h� beb� mkbeb\Zy� h^gh� \e_q_gb_� aZ� kq_l^jm]h]h��lh]^Z�wlh�[ueZ�[u�dZmaZevgZy�l_jZiby�\ ih^ebgghf�kfuke_��^ey�dhlhjhc�gZr�ZgZebaijh^_eu\Ze� [u� g_h[oh^bfmx� ij_^\Zjbl_evgmx� jZa\_^u\Zl_evgmx� jZ[hlm�� H lZdhf\ha^_ckl\bb�gZ�ijhp_kku�eb[b^h�\ gZklhys__�\j_fy��dZd�\u�agZ_l_��g_�fh`_l�[ulv�j_qb��gZrZikbohl_jZiby�hdZau\Z_l�k\h_�^_ckl\b_�gZ�^jm]h_�a\_gh�p_ib��g_�ijyfh�gZ�ba\_klgu_�gZf�bklhdby\e_gbc�� gh� \k_� `_� gZ� ^hklZlhqgh� ^Ze_dh_� hl� kbfilhfh\� a\_gh�� klZ\r__� gZf� ^hklmiguf[eZ]h^Zjy�aZf_qZl_evguf�h[klhyl_evkl\Zf�BlZd�� qlh� fu� ^he`gu� ^_eZlv�� qlh[u� aZf_gblv� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� m gZr_]h� iZpb_glZkhagZl_evguf"�Dh]^Z�lh� fu� iheZ]Zeb�� qlh� wlh� hq_gv� ijhklh�� gZf� gm`gh� lhevdh� m]Z^Zlv� wlh[_kkhagZl_evgh_�b ih^kdZaZlv�_]h�[hevghfm��Gh�l_i_jv�fu�agZ_f��qlh�wlh�[ueh�g_^Zevgh\b^gufaZ[em`^_gb_f��GZr_�agZgb_�h [_kkhagZl_evghf�g_jZ\ghp_ggh�agZgbx�h g_f�[hevgh]h��_keb�fu

Page 241: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

khh[sbf� _fm� gZr_� agZgb_�� lh� hg� [m^_l� h[eZ^Zlv� bf� g_� \f_klh k\h_]h� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� ZgZjy^m k gbf��b wlh�hq_gv�fZeh�qlh�f_gy_l��Fu�^he`gu�ij_^klZ\blv�k_[_�wlh�[_kkhagZl_evgh_kdhj__� lhibq_kdb�� gZclb� _]h� \ \hkihfbgZgbb� [hevgh]h� lZf�� ]^_� hgh� \hagbdeh� [eZ]h^Zjy\ul_kg_gbx�� Wlh� \ul_kg_gb_� gm`gh� mkljZgblv�� b lh]^Z� e_]dh� fh`_l� ijhbahclb� aZf_s_gb_[_kkhagZl_evgh]h� khagZl_evguf�� DZd� `_� mkljZgy_lky� lZdh_� \ul_kg_gb_"� A^_kv� gZrZ� aZ^ZqZi_j_oh^bl� \h� \lhjmx� klZ^bx� j_r_gby�� KgZqZeZ� ihbkdb� \ul_kg_gby�� aZl_f� ²� mkljZg_gb_khijhlb\e_gby��ih^^_j`b\Zxs_]h�wlh�\ul_kg_gb_�DZd�mkljZgblv�khijhlb\e_gb_"�Lhqgh�lZdbf�`_�h[jZahf��magZ\�_]h��jZatykgblv�iZpb_glm�<_^v� khijhlb\e_gb_� lh`_� ijhbkoh^bl� ba� \ul_kg_gby� ²� eb[h� ba� lh]h�� dhlhjh_� fu� ohlbfmgbqlh`blv��eb[h�ba�bf_\r_]h�f_klh�\ ijhrehf��Hgh�kha^Z_lky�ijhlb\h^_ckl\b_f��\hagbdrbf^ey�\ul_kg_gby�g_ijbebqgh]h�ih[m`^_gby��L_i_jv�fu�^_eZ_f�lh�`_�kZfh_��qlh�ohl_eb�k^_eZlvm`_�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ��m]Z^u\Z_f��gZoh^bf�lhedh\Zgb_�b khh[sZ_f�_]h��gh�l_i_jv�fu�^_eZ_f�wlhk\h_\j_f_ggh��Ijhlb\h^_ckl\b_��beb�khijhlb\e_gb_��ijbgZ^e_`bl�m`_�g_�[_kkhagZl_evghfm��ZY��dhlhjh_�y\ey_lky�gZrbf�khljm^gbdhf��b wlh�ijhbkoh^bl�^Z`_�lh]^Z��dh]^Z�hgh�g_hkhagZggh�Fu�agZ_f��qlh�a^_kv�j_qv�b^_l�h ^\hcghf�kfuke_�keh\Z�©[_kkhagZl_evgucª��k h^ghc�klhjhgu�dZd�n_ghf_gZ�� k ^jm]hc�²� dZd� kbkl_fu��Wlh� dZ`_lky� hq_gv� ljm^guf� b l_fguf��gh� \_^v� wlhlhevdh�ih\lhj_gb_��g_�ijZ\^Z�eb"�Fu�d wlhfm�^Z\gh�ih^]hlh\e_gu��Fu�h`b^Z_f��qlh�[hevghchldZ`_lky� hl� wlh]h� khijhlb\e_gby�� hklZ\bl� ijhlb\h^_ckl\b_�� _keb� fu� jZatykgbf� _]h� Y ijbihfhsb� lhedh\Zgby�� DZdb_� ^\b`msb_� kbeu� kh^_ckl\mxl� gZf� \ wlhf� kemqZ_"� <h�i_j\uo�klj_fe_gb_�iZpb_glZ�d \ua^hjh\e_gbx��ih[m^b\r__�_]h�ih^qbgblvky�gZr_c�k gbf�kh\f_klghcjZ[hl_��b��\h�\lhjuo��_]h�bgl_ee_dl��dhlhjhfm�fu�ihfh]Z_f�gZrbf�lhedh\Zgb_f��G_l�gbdZdh]hkhfg_gby� \ lhf�� qlh� bgl_ee_dlm� [hevgh]h� e_]q_� jZkihagZlv� khijhlb\e_gb_� b gZclbkhhl\_lkl\mxsbc� i_j_\h^� \ul_kg_gghfm�� _keb� fu� ^Zeb� _fm� ih^oh^ysb_� ^ey� wlh]hij_^iheh`bl_evgu_�ij_^klZ\e_gby��?keb�y \Zf�kdZ`m��ihkfhljbl_�gZ�g_[h��lZf�fh`gh�m\b^_lv\ha^mrguc�rZj��lh�\u�_]h�kdhj__�gZc^_l_��q_f�_keb�y ihijhrm�\Zk�lhevdh�ihkfhlj_lv�gZ\_jo�g_� h[gZjm`bl_� eb� \u� lZf� q_]h�gb[m^v�� LZd� b klm^_glm�� dhlhjuc� \ i_j\uc� jZa� kfhljbl� \fbdjhkdhi��ij_ih^Z\Zl_ev�khh[sZ_l��qlh�hg�^he`_g�m\b^_lv��\ ijhlb\ghf�kemqZ_�hg�\hh[s_�g_\b^bl�wlh]h��ohly�\k_�wlh�lZf�_klv�b _]h�fh`gh�m\b^_lv�: l_i_jv�nZdl��< p_ehf�jy^_�nhjf�g_j\gh]h�aZ[he_\Zgby��ijb�bkl_jbyo��khklhygbyo�kljZoZ�g_\jhaZo�gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc�gZr_�ij_^iheh`_gb_�hijZ\^u\Z_lky��;eZ]h^Zjy�lZdbf�ihbkdZf\ul_kg_gby�� jZkdjulbx� khijhlb\e_gbc�� lhedh\Zgbx� \ul_kg_ggh]h� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� m^Z_lkyj_rblv� aZ^Zqm�� l�� _�� ij_h^he_lv� khijhlb\e_gby�� mgbqlh`blv� \ul_kg_gb_� b ij_\jZlblv[_kkhagZl_evgh_�\ khagZl_evgh_��Ijb�wlhf�m gZk�kdeZ^u\Z_lky�kh\_jr_ggh�ykgh_�ij_^klZ\e_gb_h lhf�� dZd� \ ^mr_� iZpb_glZ� jZau]ju\Z_lky� h`_klhq_ggZy� [hjv[Z� aZ� ij_h^he_gb_� dZ`^h]hkhijhlb\e_gby��ghjfZevgZy�^mr_\gZy�[hjv[Z�gZ�h^ghc�b lhc�`_�ikboheh]bq_kdhc�ihq\_�f_`^mfhlb\Zfb��`_eZxsbfb� khojZgblv�ijhlb\h^_ckl\b_��b ijhlb\hiheh`gufb�� ]hlh\ufb� hl�g_]hhldZaZlvky�� I_j\u_� ²� wlh� klZju_� fhlb\u�� hkms_kl\b\rb_� \ k\h_� \j_fy� \ul_kg_gb_�� kj_^bihke_^gbo� gZoh^ylky� \gh\v� ihy\b\rb_ky�� dhlhju_�� [m^_f� gZ^_ylvky�� jZaj_rZl� dhgnebdl� \`_eZl_evghf� ^ey� gZk� kfuke_�� GZf� m^Zehkv� \gh\v� h`b\blv� klZjuc� dhgnebdl� \ul_kg_gby�ih^\_j]gm\� i_j_kfhljm� aZ\_jrb\rbcky� lh]^Z� ijhp_kk�� < dZq_kl\_� gh\h]h� fZl_jbZeZ� fuijb[Z\ey_f��\h�i_j\uo��ij_^mij_`^_gb_��qlh�ij_`g__�j_r_gb_�ijb\_eh�d [he_agb�b h[_sZgb_�qlh� ^jm]h_� j_r_gb_� hldjh_l� imlv� d \ua^hjh\e_gbx�� \h�\lhjuo�� ]jZg^bhagh_� baf_g_gb_� \k_o

Page 242: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

h[klhyl_evkl\�kh�\j_f_gb� lh]h�i_j\h]h�\ul_kg_gby��Lh]^Z�Y [ueh� keZ[uf��bgnZglbevguf�b�fh`_l�[ulv��bf_eh�hkgh\Zgb_�aZij_lblv�lj_[h\Zgb_�eb[b^h�dZd�hiZkgh_��L_i_jv�hgh�hdj_ieh�bijbh[j_eh�hiul��Z djhf_�lh]h��bf__l�ihfhsgbdZ�\ ebp_�\jZqZ��LZd�qlh�fu�fh`_f�gZ^_ylvky�qlh�ijb\_^_f�h[gh\e_gguc�dhgnebdl�d emqr_fm�bkoh^m��q_f�d \ul_kg_gbx��b��dZd�kdZaZgh��ijbbkl_jbyo��g_\jhaZo�kljZoZ�b gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbyo�mki_o�ijbgpbibZevgh�hijZ\^u\Z_l�gZk�H^gZdh� _klv� ^jm]b_� nhjfu� aZ[he_\Zgbc�� ijb� dhlhjuo�� g_kfhljy� gZ� koh^kl\h� mkeh\bc�gZrb�l_jZi_\lbq_kdb_�f_ju�gbdh]^Z�g_�ijbghkyl�mki_oZ��B \�gbo�^_eh�[ueh�\ i_j\hgZqZevghfdhgnebdl_� f_`^m� Y b� eb[b^h�� dhlhjuc� ijb\_e� d \ul_kg_gbx�� ohly� lhibq_kdb� _]h� fh`ghoZjZdl_jbah\Zlv� bgZq_�� b a^_kv� fh`gh� hlukdZlv� mqZkldb�� ]^_� \ `bagb� [hevgh]h� ijhbahreb\ul_kg_gby��>b a^_kv@�fu�ijbf_gy_f�l_�`_�f_lh^u��]hlh\u�^Zlv�l_�`_�h[_sZgby��hdZau\Z_f�lm`_�ihfhsv��khh[sZy�h`b^Z_fu_�ij_^klZ\e_gby��b \gh\v�jZagbpZ�\h�\j_f_gb�f_`^m�gZklhysbfb ijhreufb�\ul_kg_gbyfb�kihkh[kl\m_l�bghfm�bkoh^m�dhgnebdlZ��B \k_�lZdb�gZf�g_�m^Z_lkymgbqlh`blv�khijhlb\e_gb_�b mkljZgblv�\ul_kg_gb_��Wlb�iZpb_glu�²�iZjZghbdb��f_eZgohebdb�kljZ^Zxsb_ 'HPHQWLD� SUDHFR[� ²� hklZxlky� \ h[s_f� g_� aZljhgmlufb� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhcl_jZib_c�b g_\hkijbbfqb\ufb�d g_c��Ihq_fm� lZd�ihemqZ_lky"�G_�hl�g_^hklZldZ�bgl_ee_dlZ�ba\_klgZy� kl_i_gv� bgl_ee_dlmZevghc� jZ[hlhkihkh[ghklb�� dhg_qgh�� lj_[m_lky� hl� gZrboiZpb_glh\��gh�\ g_c�hij_^_e_ggh�g_l�g_^hklZldZ��gZijbf_j��m iZjZghbdh\��kihkh[guo�gZ�\_kvfZhkljhmfgu_� dhf[bgZpbb�� Bf_xlky� b ^jm]b_� kbeu�� kihkh[kl\mxsb_� \ua^hjh\e_gbx�f_eZgohebdb��gZijbf_j��\ hq_gv�\ukhdhc�kl_i_gb�hkhagZxl��qlh�[hevgu�b ihwlhfm�lZd�ly`_ehkljZ^Zxl��qlh�hlkmlkl\m_l�m iZjZghbdh\��gh�hl�wlh]h�hgb�g_�klZgh\ylky�^hklmig__��Fu�bf__fa^_kv� g_ihgylguc� nZdl�� \uau\Zxsbc� m gZk� ihwlhfm� khfg_gb_� \ lhf�� ihgbfZ_f� eb� fu� \^_ckl\bl_evghklb�\k_�mkeh\by�^hklb`_gby�mki_oZ�ijb�^jm]bo�g_\jhaZo�?keb�fu�hklZgh\bfky�gZ�gZrbo�aZgylbyo�k bkl_jbqgufb�b [hevgufb�g_\jhahf�gZ\yaqb\uokhklhygbc�� lh� \kdhj_� i_j_^� gZfb� \klZ_l� \lhjhc� nZdl�� d dhlhjhfm� fu� kh\_jr_ggh� g_ih^]hlh\e_gu�� Q_j_a� g_dhlhjh_� \j_fy� fu� aZf_qZ_f�� qlh� wlb� [hevgu_� \_^ml� k_[y� \_kvfZk\h_h[jZagh� ih� hlghr_gbx� d gZf�� Fu� iheZ]Zeb�� qlh� mqeb� \k_� kbeu�� dhlhju_� ijboh^blkyijbgbfZlv� \h� \gbfZgb_� ijb� e_q_gbb�� iheghklvx� ijh^mfZeb� kblmZpbx� f_`^m� gZfb� biZpb_glhf��lZd�qlh�\ g_c�\k_�ij_^klZeh�dZd�\ Zjbnf_lbq_kdhc�aZ^Zq_��Z aZl_f�hdZau\Z_lky��qlh�\g__� \djZehkv� qlh�lh�� g_� \oh^b\r__� \ jZkq_l�� Wlh� g_h`b^Zggh_� gh\h_� kZfh� ih� k_[_fgh]hh[jZagh��kgZqZeZ�y hibrm�[he__�qZklu_�b ihgylgu_�nhjfu�_]h�ijhy\e_gby�BlZd�� fu� aZf_qZ_f�� qlh� iZpb_gl�� dhlhjhfm� ke_^h\Zeh� [u� bkdZlv� \uoh^Z� ba� k\hbo[he_ag_gguo�dhgnebdlh\��ijhy\ey_l�hkh[uc�bgl_j_k�d ebqghklb�\jZqZ��<k_��qlh�k\yaZgh�k wlhcebqghklvx��dZ`_lky�_fm�agZqbl_evg__��q_f�_]h�kh[kl\_ggu_�^_eZ��b hl\e_dZ_l�_]h�hl�[he_agb�H[s_gb_�k gbf�klZgh\blky�gZ�dZdh_�lh�\j_fy�hq_gv�ijbylguf��hg�hkh[_ggh�ij_^mij_^bl_e_g�klZjZ_lky�� ]^_�fh`gh��ijhy\blv�[eZ]h^Zjghklv��h[gZjm`b\Z_l�mlhgq_gghklv�b iheh`bl_evgu_dZq_kl\Z�k\h_]h�kms_kl\Z��dhlhju_�fu��fh`_l�[ulv��b g_�klj_fbebkv�gZclb�m g_]h��<jZq�lh`_khklZ\ey_l� k_[_� [eZ]hijbylgh_� fg_gb_� h iZpb_gl_� b [eZ]h^Zjbl� kemqZc�� ^Z\rbc� _fm\hafh`ghklv� hdZaZlv� ihfhsv� hkh[h� agZqbfhc� ebqghklb�� ?keb� \jZqm� ij_^klZ\beky� kemqZcih[_k_^h\Zlv� k jh^kl\_ggbdZfb� iZpb_glZ�� lh� hg� k m^h\hevkl\b_f� keurbl�� qlh� wlZ� kbfiZlbb\aZbfgZ�� >hfZ� iZpb_gl� [_a� mklZeb� jZko\Zeb\Z_l� \jZqZ�� ij_\haghky� \ g_f� \k_� gh\u_iheh`bl_evgu_�dZq_kl\Z��©Hg�]j_abl�\Zfb��ke_ih�^h\_jy_l�\Zf��\k_��qlh�\u�]h\hjbl_��^ey�g_]h

Page 243: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hldjh\_gb_ª�²� jZkkdZau\Zxl� jh^kl\_ggbdb�� Bgh]^Z� dlh�gb[m^v� ba� wlh]h� �ªhjZ� \ujZ`Z_lkyj_aq_��©Ijhklh�gZ^h_eh��hg�[_kij_klZggh�]h\hjbl�lhevdh�h \Zkª�Ohlbf� gZ^_ylvky�� qlh� \jZq� ^hklZlhqgh� kdjhf_g�� qlh[u� h[tykgylv� wlm� hp_gdm� k\h_cebqghklb� iZpb_glhf� gZ^_`^Zfb�� dhlhju_� hg� _fm� fh`_l� ih^Zlv�� b jZkrbj_gb_f� _]hbgl_ee_dlmZevgh]h� ]hjbahglZ� [eZ]h^Zjy� ihjZabl_evguf� b jZkdj_ihsZxsbf� hldjulbyf�dhlhju_� g_k_l� k kh[hc� >_]h@� e_q_gb_�� Ijb� lZdbo� mkeh\byo� ZgZeba� oZjZdl_jbam_lkyaZf_qZl_evgufb� mki_oZfb�� iZpb_gl� ihgbfZ_l� gZf_db�� m]em[ey_lky� \ ihklZ\e_ggu_� e_q_gb_faZ^Zqb�� m g_]h� \ bah[bebb� \kieu\Z_l� fZl_jbZe� \hkihfbgZgbc� b fuke_c�� hg� ihjZ`Z_l� \jZqZm\_j_gghklvx�b f_ldhklvx�k\hbo�lhedh\Zgbc��b lhl�lhevdh�k m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f�dhgklZlbjm_l��kdZdhc� ]hlh\ghklvx� [hevghc� \hkijbgbfZ_l� \k_� l_� ikboheh]bq_kdb_� gh\r_kl\Z�� dhlhju_h[udgh\_ggh� \uau\Zxl� kZfh_� h`_klhq_ggh_� khijhlb\e_gb_� m a^hjh\uo�� Ohjhr_fm\aZbfhihgbfZgbx� \h� \j_fy� ZgZeblbq_kdhc� jZ[hlu� khhl\_lkl\m_l� b h[t_dlb\gh_�� \k_fbijbagZ\Z_fh_�memqr_gb_�khklhygby�[hevgh]h�Gh�g_�\k_�\j_fy�klhbl�lZdZy�ykgZy�ih]h^Z��H^gZ`^u�g_[hkdehg�aZ\heZdb\Z_lky�lmqZfb��<e_q_gbb� h[gZjm`b\Zxlky� aZljm^g_gby�� iZpb_gl� ml\_j`^Z_l�� qlh� _fm� gbq_]h� g_� ijboh^bl� \]heh\m��<hagbdZ_l�kh\_jr_ggh�ykgh_�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�hg�[hevr_�g_�bgl_j_km_lky�jZ[hlhc�b qlhhg� k e_]dbf� k_j^p_f� hldZaZeky� hl� ^Zggh]h� _fm� ij_^ibkZgby� ]h\hjblv� \k_�� qlh� ijb^_l� _fm� \]heh\m��g_�ih^^Z\Zykv�gbdZdbf�djblbq_kdbf�khh[jZ`_gbyf��Hg�gZoh^blky�dZd�[u�\g_�e_q_gby�dZd� [m^lh� m g_]h� k \jZqhf� g_� [ueh� gbdZdh]h� m]h\hjZ�� hg� y\gh� q_f�lh� m\e_q_g�� qlh� ohq_lkhojZgblv� ^ey� k_[y��Wlh� hiZkgZy� ^ey� e_q_gby� kblmZpby��G_khfg_ggh�� qlh� a^_kv� bf__l�f_klhkbevgh_�khijhlb\e_gb_��Gh�qlh�`_�ijhbahreh"?keb�lu�\ khklhygbb�kgh\Z�\uykgblv�kblmZpbx��lh�hldju\Z_rv�ijbqbgm�ihf_ob�\ lhf��qlhiZpb_gl�i_j_g_k�gZ�\jZqZ�bgl_gkb\gu_�g_`gu_�qm\kl\Z��g_�hijZ\^Zggu_�gb ih\_^_gb_f�\jZqZ�gb keh`b\rbfbky�\h�\j_fy�e_q_gby�hlghr_gbyfb��< dZdhc�nhjf_�\ujZ`Z_lky�wlZ�g_`ghklv�bdZdb_� p_eb� hgZ� ij_ke_^m_l�� dhg_qgh�� aZ\bkbl� hl� ebqguo� hlghr_gbc� h[hbo� mqZklgbdh\��?keb^_eh� dZkZ_lky� fheh^hc� ^_\mrdb� b fheh^h]h� q_eh\_dZ�� lh� m gZk� kha^Z_lky� \i_qZle_gb_ghjfZevghc�\ex[e_gghklb��fu�gZc^_f�\iheg_�ihgylguf��qlh�^_\mrdZ�\ex[ey_lky�\ fm`qbgm�k dhlhjuf� hgZ� fh`_l� ih^he]m� hklZ\Zlvky� gZ_^bg_� b h[km`^Zlv� bglbfgu_� ^_eZ� b dhlhjucaZgbfZ_l�ih�hlghr_gbx�d g_c�\u]h^gmx�ihabpbx�ij_\hkoh^ys_]h�__ ihfhsgbdZ��gh�lh]^Z�fu�\_jhylgh��mimklbf�ba�\b^m�lh��qlh�m g_\jhlbq_kdhc�^_\mrdb�kdhj__�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�h`b^ZlvgZjmr_gb_� kihkh[ghklb� ex[blv�� Q_f� f_gvr_� ebqgu_� hlghr_gby� \jZqZ� b iZpb_glZ� [m^mlihoh^blv�gZ�wlhl�ij_^iheZ]Z_fuc�\ZjbZgl��l_f�[he__�kljZgguf�ihdZ`_lky�gZf��qlh��g_kfhljygZ� wlh��fu�ihklhyggh�[m^_f�gZoh^blv� lh�`_� kZfh_�hlghr_gb_�\ h[eZklb�qm\kl\��Fh`gh� _s_^himklblv��_keb�fheh^Zy�g_kqZklgZy�\ [jZd_�`_gsbgZ�dZ`_lky�ho\Zq_gghc�k_jv_aghc�kljZklvxd k\h_fm�ihdZ�_s_�k\h[h^ghfm�\jZqm��_keb�hgZ�]hlh\Z�^h[blvky�jZa\h^Z��qlh[u�ijbgZ^e_`Zlv_fm��beb�\ kemqZ_�khpbZevguo�ij_iylkl\bc�g_�hklZgZ\eb\Z_lky�i_j_^�l_f��qlh[u�\klmiblv�k gbf\ lZcgmx�ex[h\gmx� k\yav��Ih^h[gh_� kemqZ_lky�b \g_�ikbohZgZebaZ��Gh�ijb� wlbo�mkeh\byo� km^b\e_gb_f�keurbrv�\ukdZau\Zgby�kh�klhjhgu�`_gsbg�b ^_\mr_d��mdZau\Zxsb_�gZ�\iheg_hij_^_e_ggh_� hlghr_gb_�d l_jZi_\lbq_kdhc�ijh[e_f_��hgb��fhe�� \k_]^Z� agZeb��qlh�bo�fh`_l\ue_qblv�lhevdh�ex[h\v��b k�kZfh]h�gZqZeZ�e_q_gby�h`b^Zeb��qlh�[eZ]h^Zjy�wlbf�hlghr_gbyfbf��gZdhg_p��[m^_l�ih^Zj_gh�lh��q_]h�`bagv�ebrZeZ�bo�^h�kbo�ihj��Lhevdh�ba�aZ�wlhc�gZ^_`^u

Page 244: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hgb�hl^Z\Zeb�lZd�fgh]h�kbe�e_q_gbx�b ij_h^he_\Zeb�aZljm^g_gby�ijb�jZa]h\hjZo�h k_[_��Fu�khk\h_c�klhjhgu�ijb[Z\bf��b lZd�e_]dh�ihgbfZeb� \k_��q_fm�h[udgh\_ggh� ljm^gh�ih\_jblv��GhlZdh_� ijbagZgb_� ihjZ`Z_l� gZk�� hgh� hijhdb^u\Z_l� \k_� gZrb� jZkq_lu��G_m`_eb�fu� mimklbebkZfh_�\Z`gh_"B \� kZfhf� ^_e_�� q_f� [hevr_� m gZk� hiulZ�� l_f�f_gvr_�fu� \ khklhygbb� khijhlb\eylvky\g_k_gbx�wlh]h�bkijZ\e_gby��ihahjys_]h�gZrm�mq_ghklv��< i_j\uc�jZa�fh`gh�[ueh�ih^mfZlv�qlh� ZgZeblbq_kdh_� e_q_gb_� gZldgmehkv� gZ� ihf_om� \ke_^kl\b_� kemqZcgh]h� kh[ulby�� l�� _�� g_\oh^b\r_]h�\ _]h�ieZgu�b g_�bf�\ua\Zggh]h��Gh�_keb�lZdZy�g_`gZy�ijb\yaZgghklv�iZpb_glZ�d\jZqm� ih\lhjy_lky� aZdhghf_jgh� \ dZ`^hf� gh\hf� kemqZ_�� _keb� hgZ� ijhy\ey_lky� ijb� kZfuog_[eZ]hijbylguo�mkeh\byo��k ijyfh�lZdb�]jhl_kdgufb�g_^hjZamf_gbyfb�b ^Z`_�m ij_klZj_euo`_gsbg�� ^Z`_� ih� hlghr_gbx� d k_^hfm� fm`qbg_�� ^Z`_� lZf�� ]^_�� ih� gZr_fm� fg_gbx�� g_lgbdZdh]h� kh[eZagZ�� lh�fu�^he`gu� hldZaZlvky� hl�fukeb� h kemqZcghc�ihf_o_�b ijbagZlv�� qlh^_eh�b^_l�h n_ghf_g_��l_kg_crbf�h[jZahf�k\yaZgghf�k kmsghklvx�[he_agb�Gh\uc�nZdl�� dhlhjuc�fu�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� g_ohly� ijbagZ_f��fu� gZau\Z_f� i_j_g_k_gb_f�8EHUWUDJXQJ�� Fu�bf__f�\ \b^m�i_j_g_k_gb_�qm\kl\�gZ�ebqghklv�\jZqZ��ihlhfm�qlh�g_�kqblZ_f�qlh�kblmZpby�e_q_gby�fh]eZ�hijZ\^Zlv�\hagbdgh\_gb_�lZdbo�qm\kl\��Kdhj__�fu�ij_^iheh`bf�qlh�\ky�]hlh\ghklv�bkiulu\Zlv�qm\kl\Z�ijhbkoh^bl�ba�q_]h�lh�^jm]h]h��gZaj_eZ�\ [hevghc�b ijbZgZeblbq_kdhf� e_q_gbb� i_j_ghkblky� gZ� ebqghklv� \jZqZ�� I_j_g_k_gb_� fh`_l� ijhy\blvky� \[mjghf�lj_[h\Zgbb�ex[\b�beb�\ [he__�mf_j_gguo�nhjfZo��\f_klh�`_eZgby�[ulv�\haex[e_gghcm fheh^hc� ^_\mrdb� fh`_l� \hagbdgmlv� `_eZgb_� klZlv� ex[bfhc� ^hq_jvx� klZjh]h� fm`qbgu�eb[b^hagh_� klj_fe_gb_� fh`_l� kfy]qblvky� ^h� ij_^eh`_gby� g_jZaju\ghc�� gh� b^_Zevghc�g_qm\kl\_gghc� ^jm`[u��G_dhlhju_�`_gsbgu� mf_xl� km[ebfbjh\Zlv� i_j_g_k_gb_� b baf_gylv_]h�� ihdZ� hgh� \_� ijbh[j_l_l� hij_^_e_ggmx�`bag_kihkh[ghklv�� ^jm]b_� \ugm`^_gu� ijhy\eylv_]h�\ ]jm[hf��i_j\bqghf��ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�g_\hafh`ghf�\b^_��Gh��\ kmsghklb��wlh�\k_]^Z�h^ghb lh�`_��ijbq_f�gbdh]^Z�g_evay�hrb[blvky�\ _]h�ijhbkoh`^_gbb�ba�lh]h�`_�kZfh]h�bklhqgbdZ�Ij_`^_�q_f�aZ^Z\Zlvky�\hijhkhf��dm^Z�gZf�hlg_klb�gh\uc�nZdl�i_j_g_k_gby��^hihegbf�_]hhibkZgb_��DZd�h[klhbl�^_eh� k iZpb_glZfb�fm`qbgZfb"�M`� lml�lh�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�gZ^_ylvkyba[_`Zlv�^hdmqeb\h]h�\f_rZl_evkl\Z�jZaebqby�iheh\�b \aZbfgh]h�bo�\e_q_gby��H^gZdh�hl\_l]eZkbl�� g_� gZfgh]h� bgZq_�� q_f� m iZpb_glh\�`_gsbg�� LZ� `_� ijb\yaZgghklv� d \jZqm�� lZ� `_i_j_hp_gdZ�_]h�dZq_kl\��lZ�`_�ih]ehs_gghklv�_]h�bgl_j_kZfb��lZ�`_�j_\ghklv�ih�hlghr_gbx�dh\k_f�� [ebadbf� _fm� \ `bagb�� Km[ebfbjh\Zggu_� nhjfu� i_j_g_k_gby� f_`^m� fm`qbghc� bfm`qbghc�\klj_qZxlky�ihklhevdm�qZs_��Z g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh_�k_dkmZevgh_�lj_[h\Zgb_�ihklhevdmj_`_�� ihkdhevdm� hldjulZy� ]hfhk_dkmZevghklv� hlklmiZ_l� i_j_^� ^jm]bfb� kihkh[Zfbbkihevah\Zgby�wlbo�dhfihg_glh\�\e_q_gby��M k\hbo�iZpb_glh\�fm`qbg�\jZq�lZd`_�qZs_��q_f�m`_gsbg�� gZ[ex^Z_l� nhjfm� i_j_g_k_gby�� dhlhjZy� gZ� i_j\uc� \a]ey^�� dZ`_lky�� ijhlb\hj_qbl\k_fm�\ur_hibkZgghfm�²�\jZ`^_[gh_�beb�g_]Zlb\gh_ i_j_g_k_gb_�Mykgbf�k_[_�ij_`^_�\k_]h��qlh�i_j_g_k_gb_�bf__lky�m [hevgh]h�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ�e_q_gby�bg_dhlhjh_� \j_fy� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� kZfmx� fhsgmx� kihkh[kl\mxsmx� jZ[hl_� kbem�� ?]hkh\_jr_ggh� g_� qm\kl\m_rv�� b h� g_f� g_q_]h� b [_kihdhblvky�� ihdZ� hgh� [eZ]hijbylgh\ha^_ckl\m_l�gZ�kh\f_klgh�ijh\h^bfuc�ZgZeba��Gh�dh]^Z�hgh�ij_\jZsZ_lky�\ khijhlb\e_gb_��gZg_]h�ke_^m_l�h[jZlblv�\gbfZgb_�b ijbagZlv��qlh�hgh�baf_gbeh�hlghr_gb_�d e_q_gbx�ijb�^\mo

Page 245: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

jZaebqguo� b ijhlb\hiheh`guo� mkeh\byo�� \h�i_j\uo�� _keb� hgh� \ \b^_� g_`ghc� kdehgghklbgZklhevdh�mkbebehkv��gZklhevdh�ykgh�\u^Z_l�ijbagZdb� k\h_]h�ijhbkoh`^_gby�ba�k_dkmZevghcihlj_[ghklb�� qlh� \ua\Zeh� ijhlb\� k_[y� \gmlj_gg__� khijhlb\e_gb_�� b�� \h�\lhjuo�� _keb� hghkhklhbl� ba� \jZ`^_[guo�� Z g_� ba� g_`guo� ih[m`^_gbc�� DZd� ijZ\beh�� \jZ`^_[gu_� qm\kl\Zijhy\eyxlky� iha`_�� q_f� g_`gu_�� b ihke_� gbo�� bo� h^gh\j_f_ggh_� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� ohjhrhhljZ`Z_l� � Zf[b\Ze_glghklv� qm\kl\�� ]hkih^kl\mxsmx� \ [hevrbgkl\_� gZrbo� bglbfguohlghr_gbc�d ^jm]bf�ex^yf��<jZ`^_[gu_�qm\kl\Z��lZd�`_�dZd�b g_`gu_��hagZqZxl�qm\kl\_ggmxijb\yaZgghklv��ih^h[gh� lhfm� dZd� mijyfkl\h� hagZqZ_l� lm�`_� aZ\bkbfhklv�� qlh�b ihkemrZgb_�ohly�b k�ijhlb\hiheh`guf� agZdhf��>ey�gZk�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�khfg_gby�\ lhf��qlh�\jZ`^_[gu_qm\kl\Z� d \jZqm� aZkem`b\Zxl� gZa\Zgby� ©i_j_g_k_gbyª�� ihlhfm� qlh� kblmZpby� e_q_gbyij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� kh\_jr_ggh� g_^hklZlhqguc� ih\h^� ^ey� bo� \hagbdgh\_gby�� g_h[oh^bfh_ihgbfZgb_� g_]Zlb\gh]h� i_j_g_k_gby� m[_`^Z_l� gZk�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� qlh� fu� g_� hrb[ebkv� \km`^_gbb�h iheh`bl_evghf�beb�g_`ghf�i_j_g_k_gbb�Hldm^Z�[_j_lky�i_j_g_k_gb_��dZdb_�ljm^ghklb�^hklZ\ey_l�gZf��dZd�fu�_]h�ij_h^he_\Z_f�bdZdmx� ihevam� ba� g_]h� \ dhgp_� dhgph\� ba\e_dZ_f�²� \k_� wlh� ih^jh[gh� h[km`^Z_lky� \l_ogbq_kdhf� jmdh\h^kl\_� ih� ZgZebam�� b k_]h^gy� fh`_l� [ulv� ebrv� ke_]dZ� aZljhgmlh� fghx�Bkdexq_gh��qlh[u�fu�ih^qbgbebkv�bkoh^ysbf�ba�i_j_g_k_gby�lj_[h\Zgbyf�iZpb_glZ��g_e_ih[ueh�[u�g_^jm`_ex[gh�beb�`_�\hafms_ggh�hldehgylv�bo�fu� ij_h^he_\Z_f� i_j_g_k_gb_�� mdZau\Zy� [hevghfm�� qlh� _]h� qm\kl\Z� bkoh^yl� g_� bagZklhys_c� kblmZpbb� b hlghkylky� g_� d ebqghklb� \jZqZ�� Z ih\lhjyxl� lh�� qlh� k gbf� m`_ijhbkoh^beh� jZgvr_�� LZdbf� h[jZahf� fu� \ugm`^Z_f� _]h� ij_\jZlblv� ih\lhj_gb_� \\hkihfbgZgb_�� Lh]^Z� i_j_g_k_gb_�� [_ajZaebqgh� g_`gh_� beb� \jZ`^_[gh_�� dhlhjh_� dZaZehkv� \ex[hf�kemqZ_�kZfhc�kbevghc�m]jhahc�e_q_gbx��klZgh\blky�emqrbf�_]h�hjm^b_f��k ihfhsvxdhlhjh]h�hldju\Zxlky�kZfu_�khdjh\_ggu_�lZcgbdb�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��Gh�y ohl_e�[u�kdZaZlv�\Zfg_kdhevdh� keh\�� qlh[u� jZkk_ylv� g_^hmf_gby� ih� ih\h^m� \hagbdgh\_gby� wlh]h� g_h`b^Zggh]hn_ghf_gZ��GZf�g_�ke_^m_l�aZ[u\Zlv��qlh�[he_agv�iZpb_glZ��ZgZeba�dhlhjh]h�fu�[_j_f�gZ�k_[y�g_� y\ey_lky� q_f�lh� aZdhgq_gguf�� aZklu\rbf�� Z ijh^he`Z_l� jZklb� b jZa\b\Zlvky�� dZd� `b\h_kms_kl\h�� GZqZeh� e_q_gby� g_� ij_djZsZ_l� wlh]h� jZa\blby�� gh� dZd� lhevdh� e_q_gb_� aZ\eZ^_eh[hevguf��hdZau\Z_lky��qlh�\ky�gh\Zy�^_yl_evghklv�[he_agb�gZijZ\ey_lky�gZ�h^gh��b bf_ggh�gZhlghr_gb_� d \jZqm�� I_j_g_k_gb_� fh`gh� kjZ\gblv�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� kh� keh_f� dZf[by� f_`^m^j_\_kbghc� b dhjhc� ^_j_\Z�� ba� dhlhjh]h� \hagbdZxl� gh\hh[jZah\Zgby� ldZgb� b jhkl� kl\heZ� \lhesbgm�� DZd� lhevdh� i_j_g_k_gb_� ijbh[j_lZ_l� wlh� agZq_gb_�� jZ[hlZ� gZ^� \hkihfbgZgbyfb[hevgh]h�hlklmiZ_l�gZ�aZ^gbc�ieZg��IjZ\bevgh�[ueh�[u�kdZaZlv��qlh�bf__rv�^_eh�g_�k ij_`g_c[he_agvx�iZpb_glZ��Z k�aZgh\h�kha^Zgguf�b i_j_^_eZgguf�g_\jhahf��aZf_gb\rbf�i_j\uc��AZwlbf�gh\uf�\ZjbZglhf�klZjhc�[he_agb�ke_^brv�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ��\b^brv�_]h�\hagbdgh\_gb_�bjZa\blb_�b hkh[_ggh�ohjhrh�\ g_f�jZa[bjZ_rvky��ihlhfm�qlh�kZf�gZoh^brvky�\ _]h�p_glj_�dZdh[t_dl��<k_�kbfilhfu�[hevgh]h�ebrbebkv�k\h_]h�i_j\hgZqZevgh]h�agZq_gby�b ijbkihkh[bebkvd gh\hfm�kfukem��bf_xs_fm�hlghr_gb_�d i_j_g_k_gbx��Beb�hklZebkv�lhevdh�lZdb_�kbfilhfu�dhlhjuf�m^ZeZkv�ih^h[gZy�i_j_jZ[hldZ��Gh�ij_h^he_gb_�wlh]h�gh\h]h�bkdmkkl\_ggh]h�g_\jhaZhagZqZ_l� b hk\h[h`^_gb_� hl� [he_agb�� dhlhjmx� fu� gZqZeb� e_qblv�� j_r_gb_� gZr_cl_jZi_\lbq_kdhc� aZ^Zqb�� Q_eh\_d�� klZ\rbc� ghjfZevguf� ih� hlghr_gbx� d \jZqm� bhk\h[h^b\rbcky�hl�^_ckl\by�\ul_kg_gguo�\e_q_gbc��hklZ_lky�lZdbf�b \�qZklghc�`bagb��dh]^Z

Page 246: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\jZq�hiylv�hlkljZgbe�k_[y�LZdh_�bkdexqbl_evgh_��p_gljZevgh_�agZq_gb_�i_j_g_k_gb_�bf__l�ijb�bkl_jbyo��bkl_jbyokljZoZ� b g_\jhaZo� gZ\yaqb\uo� khklhygbc�� h[t_^bgy_fuo� ihwlhfm� ih� ijZ\m� ih^� gZa\Zgb_fg_\jhah\�i_j_g_k_gby� Dlh�ihemqbe�ihegh_�\i_qZle_gb_�h nZdl_�i_j_g_k_gby�ba�ZgZeblbq_kdhcjZ[hlu�� lhl� [hevr_� g_� fh`_l� khfg_\Zlvky� \ lhf�� dZdh]h� oZjZdl_jZ� [ueb� ih^Z\e_ggu_ih[m`^_gby�� dhlhju_� gZreb� \ujZ`_gb_� \ kbfilhfZo� wlbo� g_\jhah\�� b g_� ihlj_[m_l� [he__\_kdh]h� ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z� bo� eb[b^haghc� ijbjh^u��Fu� fh`_f� kdZaZlv�� qlh� gZr_� m[_`^_gb_� hagZq_gbb�kbfilhfh\�dZd�aZf_klbl_e_c�eb[b^hagh]h�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�hdhgqZl_evgh�mdj_ibehkvebrv�[eZ]h^Zjy�\\_^_gbx�i_j_g_k_gby�L_i_jv� m gZk� _klv� \k_� hkgh\Zgby� bkijZ\blv� gZr_� ij_`g__� ^bgZfbq_kdh_� ihgbfZgb_ijhp_kkZ�\ua^hjh\e_gby�b kh]eZkh\Zlv�_]h�k gZrbfb�gh\ufb�\a]ey^Zfb��Dh]^Z�[hevghc�^he`_gij_h^he_lv�ghjfZevguc�dhgnebdl�k khijhlb\e_gbyfb��dhlhju_�fu�_fm�hldjueb�ijb�ZgZeba_�hg�gm`^Z_lky� \ fhsghf� klbfme_�� \_^ms_f� d \ua^hjh\e_gbx��< ijhlb\ghf� kemqZ_�fh]eh�[ukemqblvky��qlh�hg�\gh\v�j_rbeky�[u�gZ�ij_`gbc�bkoh^�b hiylv�\ul_kgbe�[u�lh��qlh�ih^gyehkv�\khagZgb_��J_rZxs__�agZq_gb_�\ wlhc�[hjv[_�bf__l�lh]^Z�g_�_]h�bgl_ee_dlmZevgh_�ihgbfZgb_²�^ey�lZdh]h�^_ckl\by�hgh�g_^hklZlhqgh�]em[hdh�b k\h[h^gh�²�Z _^bgkl\_ggh�_]h�hlghr_gb_�d\jZqm�� Ihkdhevdm� _]h� i_j_g_k_gb_� ghkbl� iheh`bl_evguc� oZjZdl_j�� hgh� gZ^_ey_l� \jZqZZ\lhjbl_lhf��\hiehsZ_lky�\ \_j_�_]h�khh[s_gbyf�b fg_gbyf��;_a�lZdh]h�i_j_g_k_gby�beb�_kebhgh�hljbpZl_evgh��hg�[u�b kemrZlv�g_�klZe�\jZqZ�b _]h�Zj]mf_glu��<_jZ�ijb�wlhf�ih\lhjy_lbklhjbx� k\h_]h� \hagbdgh\_gby�� hgZ� y\ey_lky� ijhba\h^ghc� ex[\b� b kgZqZeZ� g_� gm`^ZeZkv� \Zj]mf_glZo��Ebrv�iha^g__�hg�m^_ey_l�Zj]mf_glZf�klhevdh�f_klZ��qlh�ih^\_j]Z_l�bo�ijh\_jd_�^Z`_� _keb� hgb� ijb\h^ylky� _]h� ex[bfuf� ebphf��:j]mf_glu� [_a� lZdhc� ih^^_j`db� gbq_]h� g_agZqbeb� b gbdh]^Z� gbq_]h� g_� agZqZl� \ `bagb� [hevrbgkl\Z� ex^_c�� < h[s_f�� q_eh\_d� b kbgl_ee_dlmZevghc�klhjhgu�^hklmi_g�\ha^_ckl\bx�ebrv�ihklhevdm��ihkdhevdm�hg�kihkh[_g�gZeb[b^hagmx� ijb\yaZgghklv� d h[t_dlm�� b m� gZk� _klv� ihegh_� hkgh\Zgb_� \b^_lv� \ kl_i_gb� _]hgZjpbkkbafZ� ij_^_e� ^ey� \hafh`ghklb� \ebygby� gZ� g_]h� ^Z`_� ijb� ihfhsb� kZfhc� emqr_cZgZeblbq_kdhc�l_ogbdb�b hiZkZlvky�wlh]h�h]jZgbq_gby�Kihkh[ghklv� jZkijhkljZgylv� eb[b^hagmx� ijb\yaZgghklv� d h[t_dlZf� lZd`_� b gZ� ebp^he`gZ�[ulv�ijbagZgZ�m \k_o�ghjfZevguo�ex^_c��Kdehgghklv�d i_j_g_k_gbx�m \ur_gZa\Zgguog_\jhlbdh\� y\ey_lky� ebrv� qj_af_jguf� ij_m\_ebq_gb_f� wlh]h� ijbkms_]h� \k_f� dZq_kl\Z��Gh[ueh�[u�hq_gv�kljZggh��_keb�[u�lZdZy�jZkijhkljZg_ggZy�b agZqbl_evgZy�q_jlZ�oZjZdl_jZ�ex^_cgbdh]^Z� g_� [ueZ� [u� aZf_q_gZ� b bkihevah\ZgZ��B wlh� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� ijhbahreh�� ;_jg]_cf� kg_h[udgh\_gghc�ijhgbpZl_evghklvx�h[hkgh\Ze�mq_gb_�h ]bighlbq_kdbo�y\e_gbyo�iheh`_gb_f�qlh�\k_f�ex^yf�dZdbf�lh�h[jZahf�k\hckl\_ggZ�kihkh[ghklv�d \gmr_gbx��©\gmrZ_fhklvª��?]h\gmrZ_fhklv�g_�qlh�bgh_��dZd�kdehgghklv�d i_j_g_k_gbx��Gh�;_jg]_cf�gbdh]^Z�g_�fh]�kdZaZlv�qlh� lZdh_� kh[kl\_ggZ� \gmr_gb_� b dZd� hgh� hkms_kl\ey_lky�� Hgh� [ueh� ^ey� g_]hhkgh\hiheZ]Zxsbf�nZdlhf�� ijhbkoh`^_gb_� dhlhjh]h� hg� g_� fh]� ^hdZaZlv��Hg� g_� h[gZjm`beaZ\bkbfhklb VXJJHVWLELOLWH �hl�k_dkmZevghklb��hl�ijhy\e_gby�eb[b^h��B fu�^he`gu�aZf_lblv�qlh�\ gZr_c�l_ogbd_�fu�hldZaZebkv�hl�]bighaZ�lhevdh�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�kgh\Z�hldjulv�\gmr_gb_\ \b^_�i_j_g_k_gby� �<gmrZ_fhklb��njZgp���²Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�

Page 247: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

L_i_jv� y mfhedZx� b ij_^hklZ\eyx� keh\h� \Zf�� Y aZf_qZx�� qlh� m \Zk� lZd� kbevghgZijZrb\Z_lky�h^gh�\hajZ`_gb_��qlh�hgh�ebrbeh�[u�\Zk�kihkh[ghklb�kemrZlv��_keb�\Zf�g_�^Zlv\hafh`ghklb�_]h�\ukdZaZlv�©BlZd��\u�gZdhg_p�ijbagZebkv��qlh�jZ[hlZ_l_�k ihfhsvx�\gmr_gby��dZd�]bighlba_j��Fu^Z\gh� wlh� ij_^iheZ]Zeb��Gh� aZq_f�`_� lh]^Z� [ue� gm`_g� h[oh^ghc� imlv� q_j_a� \hkihfbgZgbyijhreh]h��hldjulb_�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� lhedh\Zgb_�b h[jZlguc�i_j_\h^�bkdZ`_gbc�� h]jhfgZyaZljZlZ� ljm^Z�� \j_f_gb� b ^_g_]�� _keb� _^bgkl\_ggh� ^_ckl\_gguf� y\ey_lky� ebrv� \gmr_gb_"Ihq_fm� \u� ijyfh� g_� \gmrZ_l_� [hjv[m� k kbfilhfZfb�� dZd� wlh� ^_eZxl� ^jm]b_�� q_klgu_]bighlba_ju"�B ^Ze__��_keb�\u�ohlbl_�hijZ\^Zlvky�l_f��qlh�gZ�ijhc^_gghf�h[oh^ghf�imlb�\uk^_eZeb� fgh]h� agZqbl_evguo� ikboheh]bq_kdbo� hldjulbc�� kdjuluo� ijb� bkihevah\Zgbbg_ihkj_^kl\_ggh]h�\gmr_gby��dlh�l_i_jv�ihjmqblky�aZ�\_jghklv�\Zrbo�hldjulbc"�G_�y\eyxlkyeb�b hgb�lh`_�j_amevlZlhf�\gmr_gby�b ijbq_f�g_ij_^gZf_j_ggh]h��g_�fh`_l_�eb�\u�gZ\yaZlv[hevghfm�b \�wlhc�h[eZklb�\k_��qlh�ohlbl_�b qlh�dZ`_lky�\Zf�ijZ\bevguf"ª<k_��qlh�\u�fg_�lml�\hajZ`Z_l_��g_\_jhylgh�bgl_j_kgh�b g_�^he`gh�hklZlvky�[_a�hl\_lZ��Ghk_]h^gy�y _]h�^Zlv�g_�fh]m�aZ�g_^hklZldhf�\j_f_gb��LZd�qlh�^h�ke_^mxs_]h�jZaZ��<u�m\b^bl_��y^Zf� h[tykg_gby��: k_]h^gy� y ^he`_g� aZdhgqblv� lh�� qlh�gZqZe��Y h[_sZe� ijb� ihfhsb�nZdlZi_j_g_k_gby� h[tykgblv� \Zf�� ihq_fm� gZrb� l_jZi_\lbq_kdb_� mkbeby� g_� bf_xl� mki_oZ� ijbgZjpbkklbq_kdbo�g_\jhaZo�Y fh]m�wlh�k^_eZlv�\ g_kdhevdbo�keh\Zo��b \u�m\b^bl_��dZd�ijhklh�j_rZ_lky�aZ]Z^dZ�b dZdohjhrh�\k_�kh]eZkm_lky��GZ[ex^_gb_�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh� aZ[he_\rb_�gZjpbkklbq_kdbf�g_\jhahfg_�bf_xl�kihkh[ghklb�d i_j_g_k_gbx�beb�h[eZ^Zxl�ebrv�__ g_^hklZlhqgufb�hklZldZfb��HgbhldZau\Zxlky�hl�\jZqZ�g_�ba�\jZ`^_[ghklb��Z ba�jZ\gh^mrby��Ihwlhfm�hgb�b g_�ih^^Zxlky�_]h\ebygbx�� lh�� qlh� hg� ]h\hjbl�� g_� ljh]Z_l� bo�� g_� ijhba\h^bl� gZ� gbo� gbdZdh]h� \i_qZle_gby�ihwlhfm� m gbo� g_�fh`_l� \hagbdgmlv� lhl�f_oZgbaf� \ua^hjh\e_gby�� dhlhjuc�fu� kha^Z_f� ijb^jm]bo� g_\jhaZo�²� h[gh\e_gby� iZlh]_ggh]h� dhgnebdlZ� b ij_h^he_gby� khijhlb\e_gby\ul_kg_gby��Hgb�hklZxlky�l_f��qlh�hgb�_klv��Hgb�m`_�g_�jZa�ij_^ijbgbfZeb�kZfhklhyl_evgu_ihiuldb� \ue_qblvky�� ijb\_^rb_� d iZlheh]bq_kdbf� j_amevlZlZf�� lml� fu� g_� \ kbeZo� gbq_]hbaf_gblv�GZ� hkgh\Zgbb� gZrbo� debgbq_kdbo� \i_qZle_gbc� hl� gZ[ex^_gby� aZ� wlbfb� [hevgufb� fuml\_j`^Zeb�� qlh� m gbo� ^he`gZ� hlkmlkl\h\Zlv� ijb\yaZgghklv� d h[t_dlZf�� b h[t_dl�eb[b^h^he`gh�ij_\jZlblvky�\ Y�eb�[b^h��<ke_^kl\b_�wlh]h�oZjZdl_jgh]h�ijbagZdZ�fu�hl^_ebeb�bo�hli_j\hc�]jmiiu�g_\jhlbdh\��bkl_jby��g_\jha�kljZoZ�b gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc����Bo�ih\_^_gb_�ijbl_jZi_\lbq_kdbo�ihiuldZo�ih^l\_j`^Z_l�gZr_�ij_^iheh`_gb_��Hgb�g_�ijhy\eyxl�i_j_g_k_gbyb ihwlhfm�g_^hklmigu�gZr_fm�\ha^_ckl\bx��g_�fh]ml�[ulv�\ue_q_gu�gZfb�><:>P:LV�<HKVF:Y�E?DPBY:gZeblbq_kdZy�l_jZibyM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��<u� agZ_l_��h q_f�m gZk� k_]h^gy�[m^_l�[_k_^Z��<u� kijhkbebf_gy�� ihq_fm� fu� g_� ihevam_fky� \ ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_jZibb� ijyfuf� \gmr_gb_f�� _keb

Page 248: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijbagZ_f��qlh�gZr_�\ebygb_�\ agZqbl_evghc�f_j_�hkgh\Zgh�gZ�i_j_g_k_gbb��l��_��gZ�\gmr_gbb��b\ k\yab�k wlbf�\ujZabeb�khfg_gb_��fh`_f�eb�fu�ijb�lZdhf�ij_h[eZ^Zgbb�\gmr_gby�jmqZlvky�aZh[t_dlb\ghklv�gZrbo�ikboheh]bq_kdbo�hldjulbc��Y h[_sZe�\Zf�ih^jh[guc�hl\_l�Ijyfh_�\gmr_gb_�²�wlh�\gmr_gb_��gZijZ\e_ggh_�ijhlb\�ijhy\e_gby�kbfilhfh\��[hjv[Zf_`^m�\Zrbf�Z\lhjbl_lhf�b fhlb\Zfb�[he_agb��Ijb�wlhf�\u�g_�[_kihdhbl_kv�h[�wlbo�fhlb\Zo�lj_[my�hl�[hevgh]h�lhevdh�lh]h��qlh[u�hg�ih^Z\eye�bo�\ujZ`_gb_�\ kbfilhfZo��Ih^\_j]Z_l_�eb\u�[hevgh]h� ]bigham�beb�g_l��ijbgpbibZevgh]h� jZaebqby�g_�bf__l��;_jg�]_cf� hiylv�lZdb� khk\hckl\_gghc�_fm�ijhgbpZl_evghklvx�ml\_j`^Ze��qlh�kZfh_�kms_kl\_ggh_�\ y\e_gbyo�]bighaZ²�wlh�\gmr_gb_��Z kZf�]bigha�y\ey_lky�m`_�j_amevlZlhf�\gmr_gby��\gmr_gguf�khklhygb_f��bhg�ij_^ihqblZe�ijh\h^blv�\gmr_gb_�\ khklhygbb�[h^jkl\h\Zgby�[hevgh]h��qlh�fh`_l�^Z\Zlv�l_`_�j_amevlZlu��qlh�b \gmr_gb_�ijb�]bigha_�LZd�qlh�`_�\u�ohlbl_�mkeurZlv�kgZqZeZ�\ hl\_l�gZ�wlhl�\hijhk��lh��h q_f�]h\hjbl�hiul��bebl_hj_lbq_kdb_�khh[jZ`_gby"GZqg_f� k i_j\h]h��Y [ue� mq_gbdhf�;_jg]_cfZ�� dhlhjh]h� y ihk_lbe� \ ����� ]�� \ GZgkb�bdgb]m�dhlhjh]h�h \gmr_gbb�i_j_\_e�gZ�g_f_pdbc�yaud��< l_q_gb_�fgh]bo�e_l�y e_qbe�]bighahf�kgZqZeZ�\gmr_gb_f�aZij_lZ��Z iha^g__�khq_lZy�_]h�k jZkkijhkZfb�iZpb_glZ�ih�;j_c_jm��LZd�qlhy fh]m� km^blv� h[� mki_oZo� ]bighlbq_kdhc� beb� km]]_klb\ghc� l_jZibb� gZ� hkgh\Zgbb� [hevrh]hhiulZ��?keb��kh]eZkgh�klZjbgghc�\jZq_[ghc�nhjfme_��b^_ZevgZy�l_jZiby�^he`gZ�[ulv�[ukljhc�gZ^_`ghc�b g_�\uau\Zlv�g_ijbyagb�m [hevgh]h��lh�f_lh^�;_jg]_cfZ�hl\_qZe��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_�^\mf� ba� wlbo� lj_[h\Zgbc��Hg� ijh\h^beky� gZfgh]h� [uklj__�� ^Z`_� g_kjZ\g_ggh� [uklj__�� q_fZgZeblbq_kdbc��b g_�^hklZ\eye�[hevghfm�gb oehihl��gb�aZljm^g_gbc��Kh�\j_f_g_f�^ey�\jZqZ�wlhklZgh\behkv� fhghlhgguf� aZgylb_f�� dZ`^uc� jZa� h^bgZdh\h�� ijb� ihfhsb� h^gbo� b l_o� `_ijb_fh\�aZij_sZlv�ijhy\eylvky�kZfuf�jZaebqguf�kbfilhfZf��g_�bf_y�\hafh`ghklb�ihgylv�bokfuke� b agZq_gb_�� Wlh� [ueZ� g_� gZmqgZy� ^_yl_evghklv�� Z jZ[hlZ� ih^fZkl_jvy�� dhlhjZygZihfbgZeZ�fZ]bx��aZdebgZgby�b nhdmku�h^gZdh� wlh�g_�ijbgbfZehkv�\h� \gbfZgb_� \ kjZ\g_gbb� k bgl_j_kZfb�[hevgh]h��Gh� lj_lv_lj_[h\Zgb_�g_� kh[ex^Zehkv�� wlhl�f_lh^�g_�[ue�gZ^_`guf�gb� \ dZdhf� hlghr_gbb��D h^ghfm[hevghfm� _]h�fh`gh� [ueh� ijbf_gylv�� d ^jm]hfm�²� g_l�� \ h^ghf� kemqZ_� m^Z\Zehkv� ^hklbqvfgh]h]h��\ ^jm]hf�²�hq_gv�fZeh]h��g_ba\_klgh�ihq_fm��?s_�om`_��q_f�wlZ�dZijbaghklv�f_lh^Z�[ueh� hlkmlkl\b_� ^ebl_evgh]h� mki_oZ��Q_j_a� g_dhlhjh_� \j_fy�� _keb� \gh\v� ijboh^behkv� hiylvkeurZlv�h [hevghf��hdZau\Zehkv��qlh�ij_`gbc�g_^m]�\_jgmeky�beb�aZf_gbeky�gh\uf��Fh`gh[ueh� kgh\Z� gZqbgZlv� e_q_gb_� ]bighahf�� : djhf_� lh]h�� hiulgu_� ex^b� ij_^hkl_j_]Zeb� g_ebrZlv� [hevgh]h� kZfhklhyl_evghklb� qZkluf� ih\lhj_gb_f� ]bighaZ� b g_� ijbmqZlv� _]h� d wlhcl_jZibb��dZd�d gZjdhlbdm��Kh]eZk_g��qlh�bghc�jZa�\k_�m^Z\Zehkv�dZd�g_evay�emqr_��g_[hevrbfbmkbebyfb�^hklb]Zeky�iheguc�b ^ebl_evguc�mki_o��Gh�mkeh\by�lZdh]h�[eZ]hijbylgh]h�bkoh^ZhklZ\Zebkv� g_ba\_klgufb�� H^gZ`^u� m f_gy� ijhbahr_e� kemqZc�� dh]^Z� ly`_eh_� khklhygb_�iheghklvx�mkljZg_ggh_�fghc�ijb�ihfhsb�g_ijh^he`bl_evgh]h�e_q_gby� ]bighahf��\_jgmehkvg_baf_g_gguf�ihke_� lh]h�� dZd� [hevgZy� jZkk_j^beZkv� gZ�f_gy� [_ah� \kydhc�fh_c� \bgu�� ihke_ijbfbj_gby�k g_c�y hiylv�b ]hjZa^h�hkgh\Zl_evg_c�mgbqlh`be�[he_ag_ggh_�khklhygb_��b \k_�lZdb�hgh�hiylv�ihy\behkv��dh]^Z�hgZ�\h�\lhjhc�jZa�hl^ZebeZkv�hl�f_gy��< ^jm]hc�jZa�y hdZaZeky\ kblmZpbb��dh]^Z�[hevgZy��dhlhjhc�y g_h^ghdjZlgh�ihfh]Ze�]bighahf�ba[Z\blvky�hl�g_j\guo

Page 249: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

khklhygbc��g_h`b^Zggh�\h�\j_fy�e_q_gby�hkh[_ggh�ljm^gh]h�kemqZy�h[\beZ�jmdZfb�fhx�r_x�Wlh� aZklZ\beh� [u� ex[h]h�� ohq_l� hg� lh]h� beb� g_l�� aZgylvky� \hijhkhf� h ijbjh^_� bijhbkoh`^_gbb�k\h_]h�Z\lhjbl_lZ�ijb�\gmr_gbb�LZdh\u�hiulgu_�^Zggu_��Hgb�ihdZau\Zxl��qlh��hldZaZ\rbkv�hl�ijyfh]h�\gmr_gby��fu�g_ihl_jyeb� gbq_]h� g_aZf_gbfh]h�� L_i_jv� jZaj_rbl_� gZf� ijb[Z\blv� d wlhfm� _s_� g_dhlhju_khh[jZ`_gby��Ijh\_^_gb_�]bighlbq_kdhc�l_jZibb�lj_[m_l�hl�iZpb_glZ�b hl�\jZqZ�ebrv�hq_gvg_agZqbl_evguo�mkbebc��WlZ�l_jZiby�ij_djZkgh�kh]eZkm_lky�k hp_gdhc�g_\jhah\��dhlhjhc�_s_ijb^_j`b\Z_lky� [hevrbgkl\h� \jZq_c�� <jZq� ]h\hjbl� kljZ^Zxs_fm� g_\jhahf�� ^Z� m \Zk� \_^vgbq_]h� g_l�� wlh� lhevdh� g_j\u�� Z ihlhfm� y g_kdhevdbfb� keh\Zfb� aZ� g_kdhevdh� fbgml� fh]mhk\h[h^blv� \Zk� hl� g_^m]Z�� Gh� lZdZy� kihkh[ghklv� i_j_^\b]Zlv� [hevrhc� ]jma�� ijbeZ]Zyg_ihkj_^kl\_ggh� g_agZqbl_evgu_� mkbeby�� g_� bkihevamy� ijb� wlhf� gbdZdbo� khhl\_lkl\mxsboijbkihkh[e_gbc�� ijhlb\hj_qbl� gZr_fm� wg_j]_lbq_kdhfm� h[jZam� fuke_c��Ihkdhevdm� mkeh\bykjZ\gbfu��hiul�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�ijb�g_\jhaZo�wlhl�nhdmk�g_�m^Z_lky��Gh�y agZx��qlh�wlhl�^h\h^g_�y\ey_lky�g_hijh\_j`bfuf��[u\Zxl�b ©m^Zqbª�< k\_l_� l_o� agZgbc��dhlhju_�fu�ijbh[j_eb�[eZ]h^Zjy�ikbohZgZebam��fu�fh`_f�hibkZlvjZaebqb_� f_`^m� ]bighlbq_kdbf� b ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbf� \gmr_gb_f� ke_^mxsbf� h[jZahf�]bighlbq_kdZy� l_jZiby� klZjZ_lky� qlh�lh� aZdjulv� b aZlmr_\Zlv� \ ^mr_\ghc� `bagb�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdZy�²�qlh�lh�jZkdjulv�b mkljZgblv��I_j\Zy�jZ[hlZ_l�dZd�dhkf_lbdZ��\lhjZy�²dZd� objmj]by�� I_j\Zy� ihevam_lky� \gmr_gb_f�� qlh[u� aZij_sZlv� kbfilhfu�� hgZ� mkbeb\Z_l\ul_kg_gb_�� hklZ\eyy� g_baf_g_ggufb� \k_� ijhp_kku�� dhlhju_� ijb\_eb� d h[jZah\Zgbxkbfilhfh\��:gZeblbq_kdZy� l_jZiby� ijhgbdZ_l� ^Zevr_� \ kmsghklv�� \ l_� dhgnebdlu�� dhlhju_ijb\_eb� d h[jZah\Zgbx� kbfilhfh\�� b ihevam_lky� \gmr_gb_f�� qlh[u� baf_gblv� bkoh^� wlbodhgnebdlh\�� =bighlbq_kdZy� l_jZiby� hklZ\ey_l� iZpb_glZ� [_a^_yl_evguf� b g_baf_g_gguf�� bihlhfm� klhev� `_� g_kihkh[guf� d khijhlb\e_gbx� ijb� \kydhf� gh\hf� ih\h^_� d aZ[he_\Zgbx�:gZeblbq_kdh_� e_q_gb_� lj_[m_l� hl� \jZqZ� b hl� [hevgh]h� ly`_eh]h� ljm^Z�� gZijZ\e_ggh]h� gZmkljZg_gb_�\gmlj_ggbo�khijhlb\e_gbc��;eZ]h^Zjy�ij_h^he_gbx�wlbo�khijhlb\e_gbc�^mr_\gZy`bagv� [hevgh]h� gZ^he]h� baf_gy_lky�� ih^gbfZ_lky� gZ� [he__� \ukhdmx� klmi_gv� jZa\blby� bhklZ_lky�aZsbs_gghc�hl�gh\uo�ih\h^h\�^ey�aZ[he_\Zgby�WlZ� jZ[hlZ� ih� ij_h^he_gbx� y\ey_lky� kms_kl\_gghc� qZklvx� ZgZeblbq_kdh]h� e_q_gby�[hevghc� ^he`_g� __ \uihegblv�� Z \jZq� ihfh]Z_l� _fm� \ wlhf� \gmr_gb_f�� ^_ckl\mxsbf� \\hkiblZl_evghf kfuke_�� Ihwlhfm� ijZ\bevgh� ]h\hjbehkv�� qlh� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh_� e_q_gb_y\ey_lky�q_f�lh�\jh^_�^h\hkiblZgby�GZ^_xkv�� qlh� l_i_jv� y jZatykgbe� \Zf�� q_f� hlebqZ_lky� gZr� kihkh[� l_jZi_\lbq_kdh]hijbf_g_gby� \gmr_gby� hl� _^bgkl\_ggh� \hafh`gh]h� kihkh[Z� ijb� ]bighlbq_kdhc� l_jZibb�� :k\_^y� \gmr_gb_� d i_j_g_k_gbx�� \u� ihcf_l_� \kx� dZijbaghklv� ]bighlbq_kdhc� l_jZibb�[jhkb\rmxky� gZf� \ ]eZaZ� ijb� __ bkihevah\Zgbb�� f_`^m� l_f� dZd� ZgZeblbq_kdZy� ^h� djZcgbok\hbo�ij_^_eh\�ih^^Z_lky�jZkq_lm��Bkihevamy�]bigha��fu�aZ\bkbf�hl�kihkh[ghklb�[hevgh]h�di_j_g_k_gbx�� g_� bf_y� \hafh`ghklb� kZfbf� \ebylv� gZ� g__�� I_j_g_k_gb_� ]bighlbabjm_fh]hfh`_l�[ulv�g_]Zlb\guf�beb��dZd�wlh�qZs_�\k_]h�[u\Z_l��Zf[b\Ze_glguf��hg�fh`_l�aZsbsZlvkyhl�k\h_]h�i_j_g_k_gby�hkh[ufb�mklZgh\dZfb��h[�wlhf�fu�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_f��< ikbohZgZeba_�fujZ[hlZ_f� gZ^� kZfbf� i_j_g_k_gb_f�� mkljZgyy� lh�� qlh� _fm� ijhlb\h^_ckl\m_l�� ]hlh\bf� k_[_

Page 250: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

bgkljmf_gl�� k ihfhsvx� dhlhjh]h� ohlbf� hdZau\Zlv� \ebygb_�� LZd� i_j_^� gZfb� hldju\Z_lky\hafh`ghklv� kh\k_f� bgZq_� bkihevah\Zlv� kbem� \gmr_gby�� fu� ihemqZ_f� \eZklv� gZ^� g_c�� g_[hevghc� \gmrZ_l� k_[_� lh�� qlh� _fm� ohq_lky�� Z fu� jmdh\h^bf� _]h� \gmr_gb_f�� gZkdhevdh� hg\hh[s_�ih^^Z_lky�_]h�\ebygbx�L_i_jv�\u�kdZ`_l_��qlh�gZah\_f�eb�fu�^\b`msmx�kbem�gZr_]h�ZgZebaZ�i_j_g_k_gb_f�beb\gmr_gb_f�� _klv� \k_�lZdb� hiZkghklv�� qlh� \ebygb_� gZ� iZpb_glZ� klZ\bl� ih^� khfg_gb_h[t_dlb\gmx� ^hklh\_jghklv� gZrbo� ^Zgguo�� Lh�� qlh� b^_l� gZ� ihevam� l_jZibb�� ijbghkbl� \j_^bkke_^h\Zgbx��Bf_ggh�wlh�\hajZ`_gb_�qZs_�\k_]h�\u^\b]Zehkv�ijhlb\�ikbohZgZebaZ��b gm`ghkhagZlvky��qlh�_keb�hgh�b hrb[hqgh��_]h�\k_�`_�g_evay�hl\_j]gmlv�dZd�g_jZamfgh_��Gh�_keb�[uhgh� hdZaZehkv� kijZ\_^eb\uf�� lh� ikbohZgZeba� klZe� [u� g_� q_f� bguf�� dZd� hkh[_ggh� ohjhrhaZfZkdbjh\Zgguf�� hkh[_ggh� ^_ckl\_gguf� \b^hf� km]]_klb\gh]h� e_q_gby�� b fu� fh]eb� [ug_k_jv_agh� hlghkblvky� dh� \k_f� _]h� ml\_j`^_gbyf� h `bag_gguo� mkeh\byo�� ikbobq_kdhc^bgZfbd_��[_kkhagZl_evghf��LZd�b iheZ]Zxl�gZrb�ijhlb\gbdb��hkh[_ggh�\k_�lh��qlh�dZkZ_lkyagZqbfhklb� k_dkmZevguo� i_j_`b\Zgbc�� _keb� b g_� kZfb� wlb� i_j_`b\Zgby�� fu�� ^he`gh� [ulv�©\gmrbebª� [hevghfm�� ihke_� lh]h� dZd� ih^h[gu_� dhf[bgZpbb� \hagbdeb� \ gZr_c� kh[kl\_gghcbkihjq_gghc� nZglZabb�� Wlb� gZiZ^db� e_]q_� hijh\_j]gmlv� kkuedhc� gZ� hiul�� q_f� k ihfhsvxl_hjbb��Lhl��dlh�kZf�ijh\h^be�ikbohZgZeba��fh]�[_kqbke_ggh_�fgh`_kl\h�jZa�m[_^blvky�\ lhf�qlh� g_evay� [hevghfm� qlh�eb[h� \gmrblv� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� JZamf__lky�� _]h� g_ljm^gh� k^_eZlvklhjhggbdhf� hij_^_e_gghc� l_hjbb� b l_f� kZfuf� aZklZ\blv� mqZkl\h\Zlv� \ \hafh`ghc� hrb[d_\jZqZ��Hg�\_^_l�k_[y�ijb�wlhf�dZd�\kydbc�^jm]hc��dZd�mq_gbd��gh�wlbf�iml_f�fh`gh�ih\ebylvlhevdh� gZ� _]h� bgl_ee_dl�� Z g_� gZ� [he_agv�� JZaj_rblv� _]h� dhgnebdlu� b ij_h^he_lv� _]hkhijhlb\e_gby� m^Z_lky� ebrv� \ lhf� kemqZ_�� _keb� _fm� ij_^eZ]Zxlky� lZdb_� \hafh`gu_ij_^klZ\e_gby�� dhlhju_� \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� m g_]h� bf_xlky�� G_khhl\_lkl\mxsb_ij_^iheh`_gby�\jZqZ�hliZ^Zxl�\ ijhp_kk_�ZgZebaZ��hl�gbo�ke_^m_l�hldZaZlvky�b aZf_gblv�[he__ijZ\bevgufb�� LsZl_evgZy� l_ogbdZ� ihfh]Z_l� ij_^mij_`^Zlv� ihy\e_gb_� ij_`^_\j_f_gguomki_oh\� \gmr_gby�� gh� g_l� hiZkghklb� b \� lhf�� _keb� lZdb_� mki_ob� bf_xl� f_klh�� ihlhfm� qlhi_j\uc�mki_o�gbdh]h�g_�m^h\e_l\hjbl��:gZeba�g_evay�kqblZlv�aZdhgq_gguf��ihdZ�g_�ihgylu�\k_g_ykghklb� ^Zggh]h� kemqZy�� g_� aZiheg_gu� ijh[_eu� \ \hkihfbgZgbyo�� g_� gZc^_gu� ih\h^u� d\ul_kg_gbyf�� < kebrdhf� [ukljuo� mki_oZo� \b^brv� kdhj__� ihf_om�� q_f� kh^_ckl\b_ZgZeblbq_kdhc� jZ[hl_�� b ihwlhfm� ebd\b^bjm_rv� ^hklb]gmlh_�� \gh\v� b \gh\v� mgbqlh`Zyi_j_g_k_gb_�� dhlhjh_� _]h� h[mkeh\beh�� < kmsghklb�� wlhc� ihke_^g_c� q_jlhc� ZgZeblbq_kdh_e_q_gb_�hlebqZ_lky�hl�qbklh�km]]_klb\gh]h��Z ZgZeblbq_kdb_�j_amevlZlu�g_�aZih^hajbrv�\ lhf�qlh� hgb� ihemq_gu� ijb� ihfhsb� \gmr_gby�� Ijb� ex[hf� ^jm]hf� km]]_klb\ghf� e_q_gbbi_j_g_k_gb_� lsZl_evgh�h[_j_]Z_lky�b g_� aZljZ]b\Z_lky��ijb� ZgZeblbq_kdhf�`_�hgh� kZfh� _klvh[t_dl� e_q_gby� b jZaeZ]Z_lky� gZ� \k_� nhjfu� k\h_]h� ijhy\e_gby�� D dhgpm� ZgZeblbq_kdh]he_q_gby� kZfh�i_j_g_k_gb_�^he`gh�[ulv�mkljZg_gh��b _keb� l_i_jv� \hagbdZ_l�beb� khojZgy_lkyiheh`bl_evguc� j_amevlZl�� lh� hg� h[mkeh\e_g� g_� \gmr_gb_f�� Z ^hklb]gmluf� k _]h� ihfhsvxij_h^he_gb_f�\gmlj_ggbo�khijhlb\e_gbc��gZ�ijhbkr_^r_f�\ [hevghf�\gmlj_gg_f�baf_g_gbb�<hagbdgh\_gbx� hl^_evguo� \gmr_gbc� ijhlb\h^_ckl\m_l� lh�� qlh� \h� \j_fy� e_q_gby� fu[_kij_ju\gh�^he`gu�[hjhlvky�k khijhlb\e_gbyfb��dhlhju_�fh]ml�ij_\jZsZlvky�\ g_]Zlb\gu_�\jZ`^_[gu_��i_j_g_k_gby��Fu�g_�mimklbf�kemqZy�khkeZlvky�lZd`_�gZ�lh��qlh�[hevrh_�qbkehqZklguo� j_amevlZlh\� ZgZebaZ�� dhlhju_� fh]eb� [u� [ulv� h[mkeh\e_gu� \gmr_gb_f�

Page 251: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ih^l\_j`^Zxlky�k ^jm]hc��g_�\uau\Zxs_c�khfg_gbc��klhjhgu��< gZrm�ihevam�\ ^Zgghf�kemqZ_]h\hjbl�ZgZeba�keZ[hmfguo�b iZjZghbdh\��m dhlhjuo��dhg_qgh��g_evay�aZih^hajblv�kihkh[ghklbih^iZklv� ih^� km]]_klb\gh_� \ebygb_�� Lh�� qlh� wlb� [hevgu_� jZkkdZau\Zxl� gZf� h i_j_\h^Zokbf\heh\� b nZglZabyo�� ijhgbdrbo� \ bo� khagZgb_�� lhqgh� kh\iZ^Z_l� k j_amevlZlZfb� gZrbobkke_^h\Zgbc�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�m kljZ^Zxsbo�g_\jhaZfb�i_j_g_k_gby�b ih^l\_j`^Z_l�� lZdbfh[jZahf�� h[t_dlb\gmx� ijZ\bevghklv� gZrbo� lhedh\Zgbc�� qZklh� ih^\_j]Zxsboky� khfg_gbx�IheZ]Zx��qlh�\u�g_�hrb[_l_kv��ih\_jb\�\ wlhf�imgdl_�ZgZebam�L_i_jv�fu�ohlbf�^hihegblv�gZr_�hibkZgb_�f_oZgbafZ�\ua^hjh\e_gby��ij_^klZ\b\�_]h�\nhjfmeZo� l_hjbb� eb[b^h�� G_\jhlbd� g_kihkh[_g� d gZkeZ`^_gbx�� ihlhfm� qlh� _]h� eb[b^h� g_gZijZ\e_gh�gZ�h[t_dl��b hg�g_jZ[hlhkihkh[_g��ihlhfm�qlh�hq_gv�fgh]h�k\h_c�wg_j]bb�^he`_gljZlblv�gZ�lh��qlh[u�khojZgylv�eb[b^h�\ khklhygbb�\ul_kg_gby�b aZsbsZlv�k_[y�hl�_]h�gZihjZ�Hg�klZe�[u�a^hjh\uf��_keb�[u�dhgnebdl�f_`^m�_]h�Y b�eb[b^h�ij_djZlbeky�b Y�hiylv�fh]eh�[ujZkihjy`Zlvky�eb[b^h��LZdbf�h[jZahf��aZ^ZqZ�l_jZibb�khklhbl�\ lhf��qlh[u�hk\h[h^blv�eb[b^hhl� _]h� \j_f_gguo�� hlgyluo� m Y�ijb\yaZgghkl_c�b ih^qbgblv� _]h� hiylv�Y��=^_�`_�gZoh^blkyeb[b^h�g_\jhlbdZ"�GZclb�g_ljm^gh��hgh�k\yaZgh�k kbfilhfZfb��\j_f_ggh�^hklZ\eyxsbfb�_fm_^bgkl\_ggh� \hafh`gh_� aZf_s_gb_� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� Gm`gh�� ke_^h\Zl_evgh�� h\eZ^_lvkbfilhfZfb��mgbqlh`blv�bo� k^_eZlv�dZd�jZa�lh��q_]h�lj_[m_l�hl�gZk�[hevghc��>ey�mgbqlh`_gbykbfilhfh\� g_h[oh^bfh� \_jgmlvky� d bo� \hagbdgh\_gbx�� h`b\blv� dhgnebdl�� ba� dhlhjh]h� hgbijhbahreb��b ih�^jm]hfm�jZaj_rblv�_]h�k ihfhsvx�lZdbo�^\b`msbo�kbe��dhlhjufb�[hevghc�\k\h_� \j_fy� g_� jZkiheZ]Ze�� WlZ� j_\baby� ijhp_kkZ� \ul_kg_gby� fh`_l� hkms_kl\blvky� ebrvhlqZklb� ih� ke_^Zf� \hkihfbgZgbc� h ijhp_kkZo�� dhlhju_� ijb\_eb� d \ul_kg_gbx�� J_rZxsZyqZklv� jZ[hlu� ijh^_eu\Z_lky�� dh]^Z� \ hlghr_gbb� d \jZqm�� \ i_j_g_k_gbb� kha^Zxlky� gh\u_\ZjbZglu�klZjuo�dhgnebdlh\��\ dhlhjuo�[hevghc�ohl_e�[u�\_klb�k_[y�lZd�`_��dZd�hg�\_e�k_[y�\k\h_�\j_fy��f_`^m�l_f�dZd��bkihevamy�\k_�gZoh^ysb_ky�\ jZkihjy`_gbb� >iZpb_glZ@�^mr_\gu_kbeu��_]h�\ugm`^Zxl�ijbgylv�^jm]h_�j_r_gb_��LZdbf�h[jZahf��i_j_g_k_gb_�klZgh\blky�ihe_f[bl\u��]^_�klZedb\Zxlky�\k_�[hjxsb_ky�f_`^m�kh[hc�kbeu�<k_�eb[b^h��dZd�b ijhlb\h^_ckl\b_�_fm��dhgp_gljbjm_lky�gZ�hlghr_gbb�d \jZqm��ijb�wlhfkbfilhfu� g_ba[_`gh� ebrZxlky� eb[b^h�� <f_klh� gZklhys_c� [he_agb� iZpb_glZ� \uklmiZ_lbkdmkkl\_ggh� kha^ZggZy� [he_agv� i_j_g_k_gby�� \f_klh� jZaghh[jZaguo� g_j_Zevguo� h[t_dlh\eb[b^h�²� hiylv�lZdb�nZglZklbq_kdbc� h[t_dl� ebqghklb� \jZqZ��Gh�gh\Zy�[hjv[Z� \hdjm]� wlh]hh[t_dlZ� k ihfhsv� \jZq_[gh]h� \gmr_gby� ih^gbfZ_lky�gZ� \ukrmx� ikbobq_kdmx� klmi_gv�� hgZijhl_dZ_l�dZd�ghjfZevguc�^mr_\guc�dhgnebdl��;eZ]h^Zjy�lhfm�qlh�m^Z_lky�ba[_`Zlv�gh\h]h\ul_kg_gby�� hlqm`^_gghklv�f_`^m�Y b� eb[b^h� ij_djZsZ_lky� b \hkklZgZ\eb\Z_lky� ^mr_\gh__^bgkl\h�ebqghklb��Dh]^Z�eb[b^h�kgh\Z�hl^_ey_lky�hl�\j_f_ggh]h�h[t_dlZ�ebqghklb�\jZqZ��hghg_�fh`_l�\_jgmlvky�d k\hbf�ij_`gbf�h[t_dlZf��b hklZ_lky�\ jZkihjy`_gbb�Y��KbeZfb��ijhlb\dhlhjuo� \_eZkv� [hjv[Z� \h� \j_fy� wlhc� l_jZi_\lbq_kdhc� jZ[hlu�� y\eyxlky�� k h^ghc� klhjhgu�ZglbiZlby� Y d� hij_^_e_gguf� gZijZ\e_gghklyf� eb[b^h�� \ujZab\rZyky� \ \b^_� kdehgghklb� d\ul_kg_gbx��Z k�^jm]hc�klhjhgu��ijb\yaqb\hklv�beb�ijbebiqb\hklv�eb[b^h��dhlhjh_�g_hohlghhklZ\ey_l�dh]^Z�lh�aZgylu_��EHVHW]WH� bf�h[t_dlu�L_jZi_\lbq_kdZy�jZ[hlZ��lZdbf�h[jZahf��jZkiZ^Z_lky�gZ�^\_�nZau�\ i_j\hc�nZa_�\k_�eb[b^h�hll_kgy_lky�hl�kbfilhfh\�\ i_j_g_k_gb_�b lZf�dhgp_gljbjm_lky�

Page 252: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\h�\lhjhc�nZa_�\_^_lky�[hjv[Z�\hdjm]�wlh]h�gh\h]h�h[t_dlZ��b eb[b^h�hk\h[h`^Z_lky�hl�g_]h�Ijb� wlhf� gh\hf� dhgnebdl_� j_rZxsbf� ^ey� [eZ]hijbylgh]h� bkoh^Z� baf_g_gb_f� y\ey_lkymkljZg_gb_�\ul_kg_gby��lZd�qlh�eb[b^h�g_�fh`_l�hiylv�mkdhevagmlv�hl�Y ijb�ihfhsb�[_]kl\Z�\[_kkhagZl_evgh_��Wlh�klZgh\blky�\hafh`guf�[eZ]h^Zjy�baf_g_gbx�Y��dhlhjh_�kh\_jrZ_lky�ih^\ebygb_f�\jZq_[gh]h�\gmr_gby��;eZ]h^Zjy�jZ[hl_�lhedh\Zgby��ij_\jZsZxs_c�[_kkhagZl_evgh_\ khagZl_evgh_��Y m\_ebqb\Z_lky� aZ� kq_l� wlh]h�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��[eZ]h^Zjy�jZatykg_gbx� hghfbjblky�k eb[b^h�b kdehgy_lky�^himklblv�^ey�g_]h�dZdh_�lh�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_��Z _]h�kljZo�i_j_^lj_[h\Zgbyfb� eb[b^h� mf_gvrZ_lky� [eZ]h^Zjy� \hafh`ghklb� hk\h[h^blvky� hl� _]h� qZklbihkj_^kl\hf� km[ebfZpbb�� Q_f� [hevr_� ijhp_kku� ijb� e_q_gbb� kh\iZ^Zxl� k wlbf� b^_ZevgufhibkZgb_f�� l_f� gZ^_`g__� [m^_l� mki_o� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_jZibb�� Ij_^_e� wlhfm� mki_omfh`_l� iheh`blv� g_^hklZlhqgZy� ih^\b`ghklv� eb[b^h�� ijhlb\ys_]hky� lhfm�� qlh[u� hklZ\blvk\hb� h[t_dlu�� b mihjkl\h� gZjpbkkbafZ�� g_� iha\heyxs_]h� i_j_g_k_gbx� \uclb� aZ� ba\_klgu_]jZgbpu�� Fh`_l� [ulv�� fu� ihcf_f� _s_� emqr_� ^bgZfbdm� ijh]j_kkZ� \ua^hjh\e_gby�� _kebaZf_lbf��qlh�fu�meZ\eb\Z_f�\k_�eb[b^h��mr_^r__�ba�ih^�\eZklb�Y��hl\e_dZy�_]h�qZklv�gZ�k_[y[eZ]h^Zjy�i_j_g_k_gbx�Mf_klgh� lZd`_� ij_^mij_^blv�� qlh� ba� jZkij_^_e_gbc� eb[b^h�� mklZgh\b\rboky� \h� \j_fye_q_gby�b [eZ]h^Zjy�_fm��g_evay�^_eZlv�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh_�aZdexq_gb_�h jZkij_^_e_gbb�eb[b^hvh�\j_fy�[he_agb��Ij_^iheh`bf��qlh�gZf�m^Zehkv�^h[blvky�[eZ]hijbylgh]h�bkoh^Z�dZdh]h�eb[hkemqZy� [eZ]h^Zjy� kha^Zgbx� b mkljZg_gbx� i_j_g_k_gby� kbevguo� qm\kl\� � hlpZ� gZ� \jZqZ�� gh[ueh� [u� g_ijZ\bevgh� aZdexqblv�� qlh� [hevghc� jZgvr_� kljZ^Ze� lZdhc� [_kkhagZl_evghcijb\yaZgghklvx� k\h_]h� eb[b^h� d hlpm�� I_j_g_k_gb_� k hlpZ� ²� wlh� lhevdh� ihe_� [bl\u�� gZdhlhjhf�fu�h^he_\Z_f�eb[b^h��eb[b^h�[hevgh]h�[ueh�gZijZ\e_gh�lm^Z�k ^jm]bo�ihabpbc��Wlhihe_� [bl\u� g_� \k_]^Z� jZkiheZ]Z_lky� \hae_� h^gh]h� ba� \Z`guo� mdj_ie_gbc� \jZ]Z�� AZsblZ\jZ`_kdhc� klhebpu� g_� ^he`gZ� g_ij_f_ggh� ijhbkoh^blv� m __� \hjhl�� Lhevdh� ihke_� lh]h�� dZdi_j_g_k_gb_� hiylv� mkljZg_gh�� fh`gh� fuke_ggh� j_dhgkljmbjh\Zlv� jZkij_^_e_gb_� eb[b^h�bf_\r__�f_klh�\h�\j_fy�[he_agb�K lhqdb�aj_gby�l_hjbb�eb[b^h�fu�fh`_f�kdZaZlv�ihke_^g__�keh\h�b ih�ih\h^m�kgh\b^_gby�Kgh\b^_gby�g_\jhlbdh\�� dZd�b bo�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by�b k\h[h^gh�ijboh^ysb_�bf� \ ]heh\mfukeb��ihfh]Zxl�gZf�m]Z^Zlv� kfuke� kbfilhfh\�b h[gZjm`blv�jZaf_s_gb_�eb[b^h��< nhjf_bkiheg_gby�`_eZgby�hgb�ihdZau\Zxl�gZf��dZdb_�`_eZgby�ih^\_j]ebkv�\ul_kg_gbx�b d�dZdbfh[t_dlZf�ijb\yaZehkv�eb[b^h��hlgylh_�m Y��Ihwlhfm�\ ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhf�e_q_gbb�lhedh\Zgb_kgh\b^_gbc� b]jZ_l� [hevrmx� jhev� b \� g_dhlhjuo� kemqZyo� ^ebl_evgh_� \j_fy� y\ey_lky� kZfuf\Z`guf� kj_^kl\hf� jZ[hlu��Fu� m`_� agZ_f�� qlh� kZfh� khklhygb_� kgZ� ijb\h^bl� d ba\_klghfmhkeZ[e_gbx� \ul_kg_gby�� ;eZ]h^Zjy� lZdhfm� mf_gvr_gbx� hdZau\Z_fh]h� gZ� g_]h� ^Z\e_gbyklZgh\blky�\hafh`guf�]hjZa^h�[he__�ykgh_�\ujZ`_gb_�\ul_kg_ggh]h�ih[m`^_gby�\h�kg_��q_f_fm� fh`_l� ij_^hklZ\blv� kbfilhf� \ l_q_gb_� ^gy�� Bamq_gb_� kgh\b^_gby� klZgh\blky� kZfufm^h[guf�iml_f�^ey�hagZdhfe_gby�k \ul_kg_gguf�[_kkhagZl_evguf��dhlhjhfm�ijbgZ^e_`bl�bhlgylh_�m Y�eb[b^h�Gh� kgh\b^_gby� g_\jhlbdh\�� ih� kms_kl\m�� g_� hlebqZxlky� hl� kgh\b^_gbc� ghjfZevguoex^_c�� bo�� fh`_l� [ulv�� \hh[s_� g_evay� hlebqblv� ^jm]� hl� ^jm]Z�� G_e_ih� [ueh� [u� kqblZlvkgh\b^_gby�g_j\gh[hevguo�g_�bf_xsbfb�hlghr_gby�d kgh\b^_gbyf�ghjfZevguo�ex^_c��Fu

Page 253: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

^he`gu�ihwlhfm�kdZaZlv��qlh�jZaebqb_�f_`^m�g_\jhahf�b a^hjh\v_f�kms_kl\m_l�lhevdh�^g_f�gh�g_�jZkijhkljZgy_lky�gZ�`bagv�\h�kg_��Fu�\ugm`^_gu�i_j_g_klb�b gZ�a^hjh\h]h�q_eh\_dZ�jy^ij_^iheh`_gbc�� dhlhju_� \ul_dZxl� ba� hlghr_gby� f_`^m� kgh\b^_gbyfb� b kbfilhfZfb� mg_\jhlbdZ��Fu�g_�fh`_f�hljbpZlv��qlh�b a^hjh\uc�q_eh\_d�bf__l�\ k\h_c�^mr_\ghc�`bagb�lh�qlh�lhevdh�b ^_eZ_l�\hafh`guf�dZd�h[jZah\Zgb_�kgh\b^_gbc��lZd�b h[jZah\Zgb_�kbfilhfh\��bfu� ^he`gu� k^_eZlv� \u\h^�� qlh� b hg� ijhba\_e� \ul_kg_gby� b mihlj_[ey_l� ba\_klgu_� mkbeby�qlh[u� khojZgblv� bo�� qlh� _]h� kbkl_fZ� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� kdju\Z_l� \ul_kg_ggu_�� gh� \k_� _s_h[eZ^Zxsb_�wg_j]b_c�ih[m`^_gby�b qlh�qZklv�_]h�eb[b^h�g_�gZoh^blky�\ jZkihjy`_gbb�_]h�Y�B a^hjh\uc�q_eh\_d��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��y\ey_lky�ihl_gpbZevguf�g_\jhlbdhf��gh�kgh\b^_gb_��ih�\b^bfhfm��_^bgkl\_gguc�kbfilhf��dhlhjuc�hg�kihkh[_g�h[jZah\Zlv��?keb�ih^\_j]gmlv�[he__kljh]hfm� ZgZebam� _]h� `bagv� \ [h^jkl\h\Zgbb�� lh� hldjh_lky� lh�� qlh� ijhlb\hj_qbl� wlhc\b^bfhklb��lh��qlh�wlZ�fgbfh�a^hjh\Zy�`bagv�ijhgbaZgZ�g_kf_lguf�dhebq_kl\hf�gbqlh`guo�ijZdlbq_kdb�g_agZqbl_evguo�kbfilhfh\�JZaebqb_� f_`^m� ^mr_\guf� a^hjh\v_f� b g_\jhahf� \u\h^blky� ba� ijZdlbq_kdbokhh[jZ`_gbc�b hij_^_ey_lky�ih�j_amevlZlm�²�hklZeZkv�eb�m ^Zggh]h�ebpZ�\ ^hklZlhqghc�f_j_kihkh[ghklv� gZkeZ`^Zlvky� b jZ[hlhkihkh[ghklv"� Hgh� k\h^blky�� \_jhylgh�� d j_eylb\ghfmhlghr_gbx�f_`^m�hklZ\rbfky�k\h[h^guf�b k\yaZgguf�\ul_kg_gb_f�dhebq_kl\Zfb�wg_j]bb�bbf__l� dhebq_kl\_gguc�� Z g_� dZq_kl\_gguc� oZjZdl_j��Fg_� g_aZq_f� \Zf� gZihfbgZlv�� qlh� wlhl\a]ey^�l_hj_lbq_kdb�h[hkgh\u\Z_l�ijbgpbibZevgmx�bae_qbfhklv�g_\jhah\��g_kfhljy�gZ�lh�qlh\ hkgh\_�bo�e_`bl�dhgklblm�pbhgZevgZy�ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklv�<hl� \k_�� qlh� fu� ^ey� oZjZdl_jbklbdb� a^hjh\vy� fh`_f� \u\_klb� ba� nZdlZ� b^_glbqghklbkgh\b^_gbc� m a^hjh\uo�b g_\jhlbdh\��Gh� >ijb� jZkkfhlj_gbb@� kZfh]h� kgh\b^_gby�fu�^_eZ_fbghc�\u\h^��fu�g_�^he`gu�hl^_eylv�_]h�hl�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�kbfilhfh\��g_�^he`gu�^mfZlv��qlh_]h� kmsghklv� aZdexqZ_lky� \ nhjfme_� i_j_\h^Z� fuke_c� \ ZjoZbq_kdmx� nhjfm� \ujZ`_gby�� Z^he`gu�^himklblv��qlh�hgh�ihdZau\Z_l�gZf�^_ckl\bl_evgh�bf_xsb_ky�jZaf_s_gby�eb[b^h�b_]h�ijb\yaZgghklb�d h[t_dlZf�Fu� kdhjh� ih^hc^_f� d dhgpm�� ;ulv� fh`_l�� \u� jZahqZjh\Zgu�� qlh� ih� l_f_ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_jZibb�y baeh`be� lhevdh� l_hj_lbq_kdb_�\a]ey^u�b gbq_]h�g_�kdZaZe�h[mkeh\byo��\ dhlhjuo�gZqbgZ_lky�e_q_gb_��b h[�mki_oZo��dhlhjuo�hgh�^hklb]Z_l��Gh�y himkdZx�blh��b ^jm]h_��I_j\h_�²�ihlhfm�qlh�y g_�kh[bjZxkv�^Z\Zlv�\Zf�ijZdlbq_kdh_�jmdh\h^kl\h�ihijh\_^_gbx�ikbohZgZebaZ��Z \lhjh_�²�ihlhfm�qlh�f_gy�m^_j`b\Zxl�hl�wlh]h�fgh]b_�fhlb\u��<gZqZe_� gZrbo� [_k_^� y ih^q_jdgme�� qlh� ijb� [eZ]hijbylguo� mkeh\byo� fu� ^h[b\Z_fky� lZdbomki_oh\�\ e_q_gbb��dhlhju_�g_�mklmiZxl�kZfuf�emqrbf�mki_oZf�\ h[eZklb�l_jZibb�\gmlj_ggbo[he_ag_c��b y�fh]m�_s_�^h[Z\blv��qlh�bo�g_evay�[ueh�[u�^hklbqv�gbdZdbf�^jm]bf�iml_f��KdZ`by [hevr_��f_gy�aZih^hajbeb�[u�\ lhf��qlh�y ohqm�j_deZfhc�aZ]emrblv�klZ\rb_�]jhfdbfb�]hehkZg_^h\hevkl\Z�� < Z^j_k� ikbohZgZeblbdh\� g_h^ghdjZlgh� ^Z`_� gZ� hnbpbZevguo� dhg]j_kkZo\ujZ`ZeZkv� m]jhaZ� kh� klhjhgu� \jZq_c�©dhee_]ª�� qlh� kh[jZgb_f� kemqZ_\� g_m^Zq� ZgZebaZ� bijbqbg_ggh]h�bf�\j_^Z�hgb�hldjhxl�]eZaZ�kljZ`^ms_c�im[ebd_�gZ�fZehp_gghklv�wlh]h�f_lh^Ze_q_gby��Gh�lZdh_�kh[jZgb_��g_aZ\bkbfh�hl�aeh[gh]h��^hghkh�ih^h[gh]h�oZjZdl_jZ�wlhc�f_ju�g_�kfh]eh�[u�ij_^hklZ\blv�\hafh`ghklv�\ujZ[hlZlv�ijZ\bevgh_�km`^_gb_�h l_jZi_\lbq_kdhc^_ckl\_gghklb�ZgZebaZ��:gZeblbq_kdZy�l_jZiby��dZd�\u�agZ_l_��fheh^Z�

Page 254: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gm`gh� [ueh� fgh]h� \j_f_gb�� qlh[u� \ujZ[hlZlv� khhl\_lkl\mxsmx� l_ogbdm�� b wlh� fh]ehijhbahclb� lhevdh� \h� \j_fy� jZ[hlu� b ih^� \ebygb_f� \hajZklZxs_]h� hiulZ�� <ke_^kl\b_ljm^ghkl_c� h[mq_gby� \jZq�� gZqbgZxsbc� aZgbfZlvky� ikbohZgZebahf�� \ [hevr_c� f_j_�� q_f^jm]hc�ki_pbZebkl��\ugm`^_g�kh\_jr_gkl\h\Zlvky�kZfhklhyl_evgh��b mki_ob�i_j\uo�_]h�jZ[hlgbdh]^Z�g_�iha\heyxl�km^blv�h ^_ckl\bl_evghc�wnn_dlb\ghklb�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�l_jZibb��������²Fgh]b_�ihiuldb�e_q_gby�g_�m^Zebkv�\ i_j\h_�\j_fy�bkihevah\Zgby�ZgZebaZ��ihlhfm�qlh�hgijbf_gyeky�\ kemqZyo��dhlhju_�\hh[s_�g_�ih^oh^yl�^ey� wlh]h�f_lh^Z�b dhlhju_� k_]h^gy�fubkdexqZ_f� [eZ]h^Zjy� gZrbf� \a]ey^Zf� gZ� _]h� gZagZq_gb_�� Gh� wlh� gZagZq_gb_� fh]eh� [ulvmklZgh\e_gh� lhevdh� gZ� hkgh\Zgbb� hiulZ�� < k\h_� \j_fy� g_� agZeb� aZjZg__�� qlh� iZjZghcy� b'HPHQWLD� SUDHFR[ \ yjdh� \ujZ`_gguo�nhjfZo� g_ih^\eZklgu� ZgZebam�� b iulZebkv� ijbf_gylvwlhl�f_lh^�ijb�\k_o�aZ[he_\Zgbyo��H^gZdh�[hevrbgkl\h�g_m^Zq�i_j\uo�e_l�ijhbahreh�g_�ih\bg_�\jZqZ�beb�\ke_^kl\b_�g_ih^oh^ys_]h�h[t_dlZ��Z ba�aZ�g_[eZ]hijbylguo�\g_rgbo�mkeh\bc�GZr_c� l_fhc� [ueb� lhevdh� \gmlj_ggb_� khijhlb\e_gby� iZpb_glZ�� dhlhju_� g_ba[_`gu� bij_h^hebfu��<g_rgb_� khijhlb\e_gby�� hdZau\Z_fu_� ZgZebam� mkeh\byfb�`bagb� [hevgh]h�� _]hhdjm`_gb_f�� bf_xl� g_agZqbl_evguc� l_hj_lbq_kdbc� bgl_j_k�� gh� h]jhfgh_� ijZdlbq_kdh_agZq_gb_��IkbohZgZeblbq_kdh_� e_q_gb_�fh`gh� kjZ\gblv� k objmj]bq_kdbf� \f_rZl_evkl\hf��bhgh� lh`_� lj_[m_l� kZfuo�[eZ]hijbylguo� mkeh\bc�^ey� m^Zqgh]h�ijh\_^_gby��<u� agZ_l_�� dZdb_f_ju� h[uqgh� ij_^ijbgbfZ_l� ijb� wlhf� objmj]�� khhl\_lkl\mxs__� ihf_s_gb_�� ohjhr__hk\_s_gb_��Zkkbkl_glu��hlkljZg_gb_�jh^kl\_ggbdh\�b l��^��: l_i_jv�kijhkbl_�k_[y��kdhevdh�bawlbo�hi_jZpbc�aZdhgqbehkv�[u�[eZ]hihemqgh��_keb�[u�hgb�^_eZebkv�\ ijbkmlkl\bb�\k_o�qe_gh\k_fvb��kmxsbo�k\hc�ghk�\ hi_jZpbhggh_�ihe_�b ]jhfdh�\kdjbdb\Zxsbo�ijb�dZ`^hf�jZaj_a_gh`Z��Ijb�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhf�e_q_gbb�\f_rZl_evkl\h�jh^kl\_ggbdh\�²�ijyfZy�hiZkghklv�bbf_ggh�lZdZy��d dhlhjhc�g_�agZ_rv��dZd�hlg_klbkv��Fu�]hlh\u�d \gmlj_ggbf�khijhlb\e_gbyfiZpb_glZ��dhlhju_�kqblZ_f�g_h[oh^bfufb��gh�dZd�aZsblblvky�hl�wlbo�\g_rgbo�khijhlb\e_gbc"K jh^kl\_ggbdZfb� iZpb_glZ� g_evay� kijZ\blvky� ijb� ihfhsb� dZdbo�eb[h� jZatykg_gbc�� bog_\hafh`gh�m[_^blv�^_j`Zlvky�\ klhjhg_�hl�\k_]h�^_eZ��b gbdh]^Z�g_evay�[ulv�k gbfb�aZh^gh�ihlhfm�qlh�jbkdm_rv�ihl_jylv�^h\_jb_�[hevgh]h��dhlhjuc� kijZ\_^eb\h� lj_[m_l��qlh[u�ebph�ihevamxs__ky�_]h�^h\_jb_f��[ueh�gZ�_]h�klhjhg_��Dlh�\hh[s_�agZ_l��dZdb_�jZagh]eZkby�qZklhjZa^bjZxl�k_fvx��lhl�b \�dZq_kl\_�ZgZeblbdZ�g_�[m^_l�m^b\e_g��magZ\��qlh�[ebadb_�[hevgh]hijhy\eyxl�ih^qZk�f_gvr_�bgl_j_kZ�d _]h�\ua^hjh\e_gbx��q_f�d lhfm��qlh[u�hg�hklZeky�lZdbf�dZdh\� hg� _klv�� LZf�� ]^_� g_\jha� k\yaZg� k dhgnebdlZfb� f_`^m� qe_gZfb� k_fvb�� dZd� wlh� qZklh[u\Z_l�� a^hjh\uc� ^he]h� g_� jZa^mfu\Z_l� gZ^� \u[hjhf� f_`^m� k\hbf� bgl_j_khf� b\ua^hjh\e_gb_f�[hevgh]h��G_q_]h�m^b\eylvky��qlh�fm`m�g_�gjZ\blky�e_q_gb_��ijb�dhlhjhf��dZdhg� bf__l� hkgh\Zgb_� ij_^iheZ]Zlv�� \kdju\Z_lky� jy^� _]h� ij_]j_r_gbc�� fu� g_� lhevdh� g_m^b\ey_fky�wlhfm��gh�b g_�fh`_f�mij_dZlv�k_[y��_keb�gZrb�mkbeby�hklZxlky�[_kieh^gufb�bebij_`^_\j_f_ggh�ij_djZsZxlky��ihlhfm�qlh�d khijhlb\e_gbx�[hevghc�`_gsbgu�ijb[Z\ey_lkykhijhlb\e_gb_�fm`Z��Fu� klj_fbfky� d q_fm�lh� lZdhfm�� qlh� \ kms_kl\mxsbo� mkeh\byo� [uehg_\uihegbfh�<f_klh�fgh]bo� kemqZ_\� y jZkkdZ`m� ebrv� h^bg�� dh]^Z� y ba� \jZq_[guo� khh[jZ`_gbc� [uehkm`^_g�gZ�jhev�ihkljZ^Z\r_]h��Fgh]h�e_l�lhfm�gZaZ^�y ijbklmibe�d ZgZeblbq_kdhfm�e_q_gbxfheh^hc� ^_\mrdb�� dhlhjZy� ba�aZ� kljZoZ� m`_� ^he]h_� \j_fy� g_� fh]eZ� \uoh^blv� gZ� mebpm� bhklZ\Zlvky�h^gZ�^hfZ��;hevgZy�ihkl_i_ggh�ijbagZeZkv��qlh�__ nZglZab_c�aZ\eZ^_eb�kemqZcgu_

Page 255: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

k\b^_l_evkl\Z�kms_kl\h\Zgby�g_`guo�hlghr_gbc�f_`^m�__ fZl_jvx�b khklhyl_evguf�^jm]hf^hfZ�� Gh� hgZ� [ueZ� lZdhc� g_eh\dhc� beb� lZdhc� obljhc�� qlh� gZf_dgmeZ� fZl_jb� gZ� lh�� qlhh[km`^Zehkv� gZ� ZgZeblbq_kdbo� k_ZgkZo�� ijbq_f�� baf_gb\� k\h_� ih\_^_gb_� ih� hlghr_gbx� dfZl_jb��hgZ�gZklZb\ZeZ�gZ�lhf��qlh[u�lhevdh�fZlv�ba[Z\eyeZ�[u�__ hl�kljZoZ�hklZ\Zlvky�h^ghcb�� dh]^Z� lZ� ohl_eZ� mclb� ba� ^hfZ�� ihegZy� kljZoZ�� ij_]jZ`^ZeZ� _c� ^hjh]m� d ^\_jb��FZlv� kZfZjZgvr_� [ueZ� hq_gv� g_j\ghc�� gh� g_kdhevdh� e_l� lhfm� gZaZ^� \ue_qbeZkv� \ ]b^jhiZlbq_kdhce_q_[gbp_��AZf_lbf�d wlhfm��qlh�\ lhc�e_q_[gbp_�hgZ�ihagZdhfbeZkv�k fm`qbghc��k dhlhjuffh]eZ� \klmiblv� \ kghr_gby�� m^h\e_l\hjb\rb_� __ \h� \k_o� hlghr_gbyo��IhjZ`_ggZy�[mjgufblj_[h\Zgbyfb�^_\mrdb��fZlv� \^jm] ihgyeZ��qlh�hagZqZe� kljZo� __ ^hq_jb��HgZ�iha\hebeZ� k_[_aZ[he_lv��qlh[u�k^_eZlv�fZlv�ie_ggbp_c�b ebrblv�__�k\h[h^u�i_j_^\b`_gby��g_h[oh^bfhc�^ey\klj_qb� k \haex[e_gguf�� ;ukljh� ijbgy\� j_r_gb_�� fZlv� ihdhgqbeZ� k \j_^guf� e_q_gb_f�>_\mrdZ� [ueZ� ^hklZ\e_gZ� \ e_q_[gbpm� ^ey� g_j\gh[hevguo� b \� l_q_gb_� fgh]bo� e_l� __^_fhgkljbjh\Zeb�dZd� ©g_kqZklgmx�`_jl\m�ikbohZgZebaZª��LZd�`_�^he]h�ba�aZ�hljbpZl_evgh]hj_amevlZlZ�e_q_gby�wlh]h�kemqZy�h[h�fg_�oh^beZ�^mjgZy�fhe\Z��Y ojZgbe�fheqZgb_��ihlhfm�qlhkqblZe� k_[y� k\yaZgguf� ^he]hf� \jZq_[ghc� lZcgu��Fgh]h� \j_f_gb� kimkly� y magZe� hl� k\h_]hdhee_]b��dhlhjuc�ihk_lbe� lm�e_q_[gbpm�b \b^_e� lZf�^_\mrdm�� kljZ^Z\rmx� Z]hjZnh[b_c��qlhhlghr_gby� f_`^m� __ fZl_jvx� b khklhyl_evguf� ^jm]hf� ^hfZ� ba\_klgu� \k_fm� ]hjh^m� bihevamxlky�h^h[j_gb_f�fm`Z�b hlpZ��BlZd��\ `_jl\m�wlhc�©lZcg_ª�[ueh�ijbg_k_gh�e_q_gb_�< ^h\h_ggu_�]h^u��dh]^Z�gZieu\�[hevguo�ba�fgh]bo�kljZg�k^_eZe�f_gy�g_aZ\bkbfuf�hlfbehkl_c�beb�g_fbehkl_c�jh^gh]h�]hjh^Z��y ke_^h\Ze�ijZ\bem�g_�[jZlvky�aZ�e_q_gb_�[hevgh]h�dhlhjuc� g_� [ue� [u VDL� MXULV � g_aZ\bkbfuf� hl� ^jm]bo� \ k\hbo� kms_kl\_gguo� `bag_gguohlghr_gbyo�� G_� \kydbc� ikbohZgZeblbd� fh`_l� k_[_� wlh� iha\heblv�� Fh`_l� [ulv�� ba� fhboij_^hkl_j_`_gbc� ijhlb\� jh^kl\_ggbdh\� \u� k^_eZ_l_� \u\h^�� qlh� \ bgl_j_kZo� ikbohZgZebaZ[hevguo�ke_^m_l�bahebjh\Zlv�hl�bo�k_f_c��l��_��h]jZgbqblv�wlm�l_jZibx�h[blZl_eyfb�e_q_[gbp^ey�g_j\gh[hevguo��H^gZdh�y g_�fh]m�k \Zfb�\ wlhf�kh]eZkblvky��]hjZa^h�emqr_��_keb�[hevgu_²�ihkdhevdm�hgb�g_�gZoh^ylky�\ khklhygbb�ly`_eh]h�bklhs_gby�²�hklZxlky�\h�\j_fy�e_q_gby\ l_o�mkeh\byo��\ dhlhjuo�bf�ij_^klhbl�ij_h^he_\Zlv�ihklZ\e_ggu_�i_j_^�gbfb�aZ^Zqb��Lhevdhjh^gu_�k\hbf�ih\_^_gb_f�g_�^he`gu�ebrZlv�bo�wlh]h�ij_bfms_kl\Z�b \hh[s_�g_�ijhlb\blvkyk \jZ`^_[ghklvx� mkbebyf� \jZqZ�� Gh� dZd� \u� aZklZ\bl_� ^_ckl\h\Zlv� \ wlhf� gZijZ\e_gbbg_^hklmigu_� gZf� nZdlhju�� <u�� dhg_qgh�� ^h]Z^u\Z_l_kv� lZd`_�� gZkdhevdh� rZgku� gZ� mki_oe_q_gby�hij_^_eyxlky�khpbZevghc�kj_^hc�b mjh\g_f�dmevlmju�k_fvb�G_� ijZ\^Z� eb�� wlh� gZf_qZ_l� \_kvfZ� i_qZevgmx� i_jki_dlb\m� mkbe_gby� ^_ckl\_gghklbikbohZgZebaZ� dZd� l_jZibb�� ^Z`_� _keb� ih^Z\eyxs__� [hevrbgkl\h� gZrbo� g_m^Zq� fu� fh`_fh[tykgblv�� mqblu\Zy�f_rZxsb_� \g_rgb_�nZdlhju�� Lh]^Z� klhjhggbdb� ZgZebaZ� ihkh\_lh\ZebgZf� hl\_lblv� gZ� kh[jZgb_� g_m^Zq� khklZ\e_gghc� gZfb� klZlbklbdhc� mki_oh\�� Y b� gZ� wlh� g_kh]eZkbeky��Y \u^\bgme�^h\h^��qlh�klZlbklbdZ�gbq_]h�g_�klhbl��_keb �KZfhklhyl_evguf��eZl���²Ijbf_q��i_j�\dexq_ggu_�\ g__�_^bgbpu�kebrdhf�g_h^ghjh^gu��Z kemqZb�g_\jhlbq_kdh]h�aZ[he_\Zgby�ih^\_j]gmlu_� e_q_gbx�� [ueb� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� g_jZ\ghp_ggu� \ kZfuo� jZaebqguo� hlghr_gbyo�Djhf_� lh]h�� jZkkfZljb\Z_fuc� i_jbh^� \j_f_gb� [ue� kebrdhf� dhjhlhd�� qlh[u� km^blv� h[hdhgqZl_evghf�bae_q_gbb��Z h�fgh]bo�kemqZyo�\hh[s_�g_evay�[ueh�khh[sZlv��Wlh�dZkZehkv�ebp�

Page 256: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dhlhju_�kdju\Zeb�k\hx�[he_agv��Z lZd`_�l_o��e_q_gb_�b \ua^hjh\e_gb_�dhlhjuo�lh`_�^he`gh[ueh�hklZ\Zlvky�lZcghc��Gh�kbevg__�\k_]h�m^_j`b\Zeh�khagZgb_�lh]h��qlh�\ ^_eZo�l_jZibb�ex^b\_^ml�k_[y�djZcg_�bjjZpbhgZevgh��lZd�qlh�g_l�gbdZdhc�gZ^_`^u�^h[blvky�hl�gbo�q_]h�gb[m^vjZamfgufb� kj_^kl\Zfb�� L_jZi_\lbq_kdh_� gh\r_kl\h� \klj_qZ_lky� eb[h� k hivygyxsbf\hklhj]hf�� gZijbf_j�� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� Dho� k^_eZe� ^hklhygb_f� h[s_kl\_gghklb� k\hc� i_j\uclm[_jdmebg�ijhlb\� lm[_jdme_aZ�� eb[h� k ]em[hdbf�g_^h\_jb_f�� dZd� wlh� [ueh� k ^_ckl\bl_evghihe_aghc�ijb\b\dhc�>`_gg_jZ��dhlhjZy�ih�k_c�^_gv�bf__l�k\hbo�g_ijbfbjbfuo�ijhlb\gbdh\�Ijhlb\�ikbohZgZebaZ�bf_ehkv�y\gh_�ij_^m[_`^_gb_��?keb�bae_qb\Zeky�ljm^guc�kemqZc��fh`gh[ueh� keurZlv�� wlh� g_� ^hdZaZl_evkl\h�� aZ� wlh� \j_fy� hg� b kZf� fh]� [u� \ua^hjh\_lv�� B _keb[hevgZy��dhlhjZy�ijhreZ�m`_�q_luj_�pbdeZ�m^jmq_gghklb�b fZgbb��ihiZeZ�dh�fg_�gZ�e_q_gb_�\h\j_fy�iZmau�ihke_�f_eZgohebb�b ljb�g_^_e�b kimkly�m g__�hiylv�gZqZeZkv�fZgby��lh�\k_�qe_guk_fvb�� Z lZd`_� \jZq� k [hevrbf� Z\lhjbl_lhf�� d dhlhjhfm� h[jZlbebkv� aZ� kh\_lhf�� [uebm[_`^_gu�� qlh� gh\uc� ijbklmi� fh`_l� [ulv� lhevdh� ke_^kl\b_f� k^_eZgghc� k g_c� ihiuldhcZgZebaZ�� Ijhlb\� ij_^m[_`^_gbc� gbq_]h� g_evay� k^_eZlv�� l_i_jv� \u� \b^bl_� wlh� gZij_^m[_`^_gbyo�� dhlhju_� h^gZ� ]jmiiZ� \hxxsbo� gZjh^h\� ijhy\beZ� ijhlb\� ^jm]hc�� KZfh_jZamfgh_�²�`^Zlv�b ij_^hklZ\blv�\j_f_gb�h[gZjm`blv�bo�khklhyl_evghklv��< h^bg�ij_djZkguc^_gv� l_�`_� kZfu_� ex^b� h l_o�`_� kZfuo� \_sZo� gZqbgZxl� ^mfZlv� kh\k_f� bgZq_�� q_f�ij_`^_�ihq_fm�hgb�jZgvr_�lZd�g_�^mfZeb��hklZ_lky�l_fghc�lZcghc�<hafh`gh��qlh�ij_^m[_`^_gb_�ijhlb\�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�l_jZibb�m`_�l_i_jv�ihreh�gZ�m[uev�< ihevam� wlh]h� dZd� [m^lh� k\b^_l_evkl\mxl� g_ij_ju\gh_� jZkijhkljZg_gb_� ZgZeblbq_kdbol_hjbc�� m\_ebq_gb_� \ g_dhlhjuo� kljZgZo� qbkeZ� \jZq_c�� e_qZsbo� ZgZebahf�� Dh]^Z� y [uefheh^uf�\jZqhf��lh�\klj_lbeky�k lZdhc�`_�[mj_c�\hafms_gby�\jZq_c�ijhlb\�]bighlbq_kdh]hkm]]_klb\gh]h�e_q_gby��dhlhjh_�©lj_a\u_�]heh\uª�l_i_jv�ijhlb\hihklZ\eyxl�ikbohZgZebam��Gh]bighlbaf� dZd� l_jZi_\lbq_kdh_� kj_^kl\h� g_� k^_eZe� lh]h�� qlh� h[_sZe� \gZqZe_�� fu�ikbohZgZeblbdb��fh`_f�kqblZlv�k_[y�_]h� aZdhggufb�gZke_^gbdZfb�b g_� aZ[u\Z_f��gZkdhevdhh[yaZgu� _fm� ih^^_j`dhc� b l_hj_lbq_kdbfb� jZatykg_gbyfb�� Ijbibku\� Z_fuc� ikb?hZgZ�ebam\j_^�h]jZgbqb\Z_lky�\ hkgh\ghf�ijhoh^ysbfb� y\e_gbyfb�\ke_^kl\b_�h[hklj_gby� dhgnebdlZ�_keb�ZgZeba�ijh\h^blky�g_mf_eh�beb�_keb�hg�h[ju\Z_lky�gZ�k_j_^bg_��<u�\_^v�keurZeb�hlq_l�hlhf��qlh�fu�^_eZ_f�k [hevgufb��b fh`_l_�kZfb�km^blv��kihkh[gu�eb�gZrb�^_ckl\by�gZg_klb^ebl_evguc� \j_^�� Aehmihlj_[e_gb_� ZgZebahf� \hafh`gh� \ jZaebqguo� nhjfZo�� hkh[_gghi_j_g_k_gb_� y\ey_lky� hiZkguf� kj_^kl\hf� \ jmdZo� g_^h[jhkh\_klgh]h� \jZqZ�� Gh� hlaehmihlj_[e_gby�g_�aZkljZoh\Zeb�gb�h^gh�f_^bpbgkdh_�kj_^kl\h�beb�f_lh^��_keb�gh`�g_�j_`_l�hg��lh`_�g_�fh`_l�kem`blv�\ua^hjh\e_gbx�<hl� y b� ih^hr_e� d dhgpm�� m\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z��B wlh� [hevr_�� q_f� ijb\uqgucj_q_\hc� h[hjhl�� _keb� y ijbagZx�� qlh� f_gy� kZfh]h� m^jmqZxl� fgh]hqbke_ggu_� g_^hklZldbe_dpbc��dhlhju_�y \Zf�ijhq_e��Ij_`^_�\k_]h�fg_�`Zev��qlh�y lZd�qZklh�h[_sZe�\Zf�\_jgmlvky�d_^\Z� aZljhgmlhc� l_f_� \ ^jm]hf� f_kl_�� Z aZl_f� h[sZy� k\yav� baeh`_gby� g_� ^Z\ZeZ� fg_\hafh`ghklb� k^_j`Zlv� k\h_� h[_sZgb_�� Y \ayeky� aZ� lh�� qlh[u� ihagZdhfblv� \Zk� k _s_� g_aZdhgq_gguf��gZoh^ysbfky�\ jZa\blbb�ij_^f_lhf��b fh_�khdjZs_ggh_�h[h[s_gb_�kZfh�\urehg_iheguf��< g_dhlhjuo�f_klZo�y ijb]hlh\be�fZl_jbZe�^ey�\u\h^Z��Z kZf�g_�k^_eZe�_]h��Gh�y bg_�jZkkqblu\Ze�gZ�lh��qlh[u�k^_eZlv�ba�\Zk�agZlhdh\��y ohl_e�ebrv�ijhk\_lblv�\Zk�b ijh[m^blv\Zr�bgl_j_k�

Page 257: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

IJH>HE@?GB?�E?DPBC�IH�<<?>?GBX�< IKBOH:G:EBA�������>������@�Ij_^bkeh\b_E_dpbb� ih� \\_^_gbx� \ ikbohZgZeba [ueb� ijhqblZgu� \ e_dpbhgghf� aZe_� <_gkdhcikbobZljbq_kdhc� debgbdb� \ l_q_gb_� ^\mo� abfgbo� k_f_kljh\� �������� ]�� b �������� ]�� ^eykf_rZgghc� Zm^blhjbb� kemrZl_e_c� \k_o� nZdmevl_lh\�� E_dpbb� i_j\hc� qZklb� \hagbdeb� dZdbfijh\baZpby�b [ueb�ihlhf�kjZam�`_�aZibkZgu��e_dpbb�\lhjhc�qZklb�[ueb�ih^]hlh\e_gu�e_lhf\h�\j_fy�ij_[u\Zgby�\ AZevp[mj]_�b [_a�baf_g_gbc�ke_^mxs_c�abfhc�ijhqblZgu�kemrZl_eyf�Lh]^Z�m f_gy�_s_�[ueZ�nhgh]jZnbq_kdZy�iZfylv�< hlebqb_�hl�ijhreuo�^Zggu_�gh\u_�e_dpbb�gbdh]^Z�ijhqblZgu�g_�[ueb��Ih�\hajZklm�yhk\h[h`^_g�^Z`_�hl�lZdh]h�g_agZqbl_evgh]h�mqZklby�\ ^_eZo�mgb\_jkbl_lZ��dZd�ql_gb_�e_dpbc�^Z�b objmj]bq_kdZy�hi_jZpby�g_�iha\hey_l�fg_�[hevr_�\uklmiZlv�\ dZq_kl\_�hjZlhjZ��Ihwlhfmebrv�kbehc�nZglZabb�y \gh\v�i_j_g_kmkv�\ Zm^blhjbx�^ey�baeh`_gby�ihke_^mxs_]h�fZl_jbZeZ��imklv�hgZ�ihfh`_l�fg_�g_�aZ[u\Zlv�h]ey^u\Zlvky�gZ�qblZl_ey�ijb�m]em[e_gbb�\ ij_^f_l�Wlb�gh\u_�e_dpbb�gb \�dh_c�f_j_�g_�aZf_gyxl�ij_^u^msb_��Hgb�\hh[s_�g_�y\eyxlky�q_f�lh� kZfhklhyl_evguf� b g_� jZkkqblZgu� gZ� k\hc� djm]� qblZl_e_c�� Z ijh^he`Zxl� b ^hihegyxljZggb_�e_dpbb�b ih�hlghr_gbx�d gbf�jZkiZ^Zxlky�gZ�ljb�]jmiiu��D i_j\hc�]jmii_�hlghkylkyl_��\ dhlhjuo�\gh\v�jZajZ[Zlu\Zxlky�l_fu��m`_�h[km`^Z\rb_ky�iylgZ^pZlv�e_l�lhfm�gZaZ^��ghlj_[mxsb_�k_]h^gy�^jm]h]h�baeh`_gby��l��_��djblbq_kdh]h�i_j_kfhljZ�ih�ijbqbg_�m]em[e_gbygZrbo� \a]ey^h\� b baf_g_gby� \haaj_gbc�� >\_� ^jm]b_� ]jmiiu� \dexqZxl�� kh[kl\_ggh�� [he__h[rbjguc�fZl_jbZe��]^_�jZkkfZljb\Zxlky�kemqZb��dhlhjuo�eb[h�\hh[s_�g_�kms_kl\h\Zeh�\ lh\j_fy�� dh]^Z� qblZebkv�i_j\u_� e_dpbb�ih� ikbohZgZebam�� eb[h� bo� [ueh� kebrdhf�fZeh�� qlh[u\u^_eblv�\ hkh[mx�]eZ\m��G_evay�ba[_`Zlv�lh]h��^Z�h[�wlhf�g_�klhbl�b kh`Ze_lv��qlh�g_dhlhju_ba�wlbo�gh\uo�e_dpbc�h[t_^bgyl�\ k_[_�q_jlu�lhc�b ^jm]hc�]jmiiu�AZ\bkbfhklv� wlbo� gh\uo� e_dpbc� hl� E_dpbc� ih� \\_^_gbx \ujZ`Z_lky� b \� lhf�� qlh� hgbijh^he`Zxl�bo�gmf_jZpbx��I_j\Zy�e_dpby�wlh]h�lhfZ�²����y��Ijhn_kkbhgZevghfm�ZgZeblbdmhgb�^Z^ml�hiylv�lZdb�fZeh�gh\h]h��Z h[jZsZxlky�d lhc�[hevrhc�]jmii_�h[jZah\Zgguo�ex^_c�dhlhju_� fh]eb� [u� ijhy\blv� [eZ]hkdehgguc�� ohly� b k^_j`Zgguc� bgl_j_k� d k\h_h[jZabx� b^hklb`_gbyf� fheh^hc� gZmdb�� B gZ� wlhl� jZa� fh_c� hkgh\ghc� p_evx� [ueh� g_� klj_fblvky� ddZ`ms_cky�ijhklhl_��iheghl_�b aZdhgq_gghklb��g_�kdju\Zlv�ijh[e_f��g_�hljbpZlv�ijh[_eh\�bkhfg_gbc��Gb� \ dZdhc�^jm]hc�h[eZklb�gZmqghc� jZ[hlu�g_�gm`gh�[ueh� [u� \udZau\Zlv� lZdhc]hlh\ghklb�d jZamfghfm�kZfhhlj_q_gbx��<kx^m�hgZ�kqblZ_lky�_kl_kl\_gghc��im[ebdZ�bgh]h�bg_�`^_l��Gb� h^bg� qblZxsbc� jZ[hlu� ih� Zkljhghfbb� g_� ihqm\kl\m_l� k_[y� jZahqZjh\Zgguf� bklhysbf� \ur_� gZmdb�� _keb� _fm� mdZ`ml� ]jZgbpu�� m dhlhjuo� gZrb� agZgby� h \k_e_gghcklZgh\ylky� \_kvfZ� lmfZggufb�� Lhevdh� \ ikboheh]bb� \k_� ih�^jm]hfm�� a^_kv� hj]Zgbq_kdZyg_ijb]h^ghklv� q_eh\_dZ� d gZmqghfm� bkke_^h\Zgbx� ijhy\ey_l� k_[y� \ iheghc� f_j_�� Hlikboheh]bb� dZd� [m^lh� lj_[mxl� g_� mki_oh\� \ ihagZgbb�� Z dZdbo�lh� ^jm]bo� ^hklb`_gbc�� __mij_dZxl� \ ex[hc� g_j_r_gghc� ijh[e_f_�� \ ex[hf� hldjh\_ggh� \ukdZaZgghf� khfg_gbb�� Dlh

Page 258: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ex[bl�gZmdm�h `bagb�^mrb��lhl�^he`_g�ijbfbjblvky�b k�wlhc�g_kijZ\_^eb\hklvx��<_gZ��e_lh�����]�><:>P:LV�>?<YL:Y�E?DPBYI_j_kfhlj�l_hjbb�kgh\b^_gbcM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Kh[jZ\� \Zk� ihke_� [he__� q_f� iylgZ^pZlbe_lg_]h� i_j_ju\Z�qlh[u�h[km^blv��qlh�gh\h]h��Z fh`_l�[ulv��b emqr_]h�\g_k_gh� aZ�wlh�\j_fy�\ ikbohZgZeba��ygZoh`m�\h�\k_o�hlghr_gbyo�hijZ\^Zgguf�b mf_klguf�h[jZlblv�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_�ij_`^_�\k_]h�gZkhklhygb_� l_hjbb�kgh\b^_gbc��< bklhjbb�ikbohZgZebaZ�hgZ� aZgbfZ_l�hkh[h_�f_klh�� agZf_gmykh[hc� ih\hjhlguc� imgdl�� [eZ]h^Zjy� _c� ikbohZgZeba� k^_eZe� rZ]� hl� ikbohl_jZi_\lbq_kdh]hf_lh^Z�d ]em[bgghc�ikboheh]bb��K l_o�ihj�l_hjby�kgh\b^_gbc�hklZ_lky�kZfuf�oZjZdl_jguf�bkZfuf�k\h_h[jZaguf�\ wlhc�fheh^hc�gZmd_��g_�bf_xsbf�ZgZeh]h\�\ gZrbo�ijhqbo�mq_gbyo�mqZkldhf� p_ebgu�� hl\h_\Zgguf� m km_\_jbc� b fbklbdb�� G_h[uqghklv� \u^\b]Z_fuo� _xml\_j`^_gbc� ij_\jZlbeZ� __ \ ijh[guc� dZf_gv�� k ihfhsvx� dhlhjh]h� hdhgqZl_evghhij_^_ebehkv��dlh�kfh]�klZlv�ijb\_j`_gp_f�ikbohZgZebaZ��Z ^ey�dh]h�hg�lZd�b hklZeky�gZ\k_]^Zg_ihklb`bfuf��>ey�f_gy�kZfh]h�hgZ�[ueZ�gZ^_`guf�hjb_glbjhf�\ l_�ljm^gu_�\j_f_gZ��dh]^Zg_ihgylgu_�y\e_gby�\ h[eZklb�g_\jhah\�ih^qZk�kfmsZeb�fh_�g_hdj_ir__�km`^_gb_��B dZd�[uqZklh�y gb�gZqbgZe�khfg_\Zlvky�\ ijZ\bevghklb�k\hbo�rZldbo�\u\h^h\��\kydbc�jZa��dh]^Z�fg_m^Z\Zehkv�ij_^klZ\blv�\b^_\r_fm�khb�[_kkfuke_ggh_��aZimlZggh_�kgh\b^_gb_�dZd�ijZ\bevgucb ihgylguc�^mr_\guc�ijhp_kk�� y kgh\Z�h[j_lZe�m\_j_gghklv�\ lhf��qlh�gZoh`mkv�gZ�\_jghfimlb�LZdbf� h[jZahf�� ^ey� gZk� ij_^klZ\ey_l� hkh[uc� bgl_j_k� bf_ggh� gZ� �ijbf_j_� l_hjbbkgh\b^_gbc� ijhke_^blv�� dZdb_� baf_g_gby� ijhbahreb� aZ� wlh� \j_fy�� k h^ghc� klhjhgu�� \ikbohZgZeba_�b��k ^jm]hc��dZdb_�mki_ob�[ueb�^hklb]gmlu�\ ihgbfZgbb�b hp_gd_�wlhc�l_hjbbhdjm`Zxsbfb��KjZam�`_�ij_^mij_`^Zx�\Zk��qlh�\ h[hbo�kemqZyo�\Zk�`^_l�jZahqZjh\Zgb_�>Z\Zcl_� \f_kl_� i_j_ebklZ_f� \uimkdb� F_`^mgZjh^gh]h� `mjgZeZ� ih� e_q_[ghfmikbohZgZebam� \ dhlhjuo�k �����]��kh[jZgu�\_^msb_�jZ[hlu�\ gZr_c�h[eZklb��< i_j\uo�lhfZo\u�gZc^_l_�ihklhyggmx�jm[jbdm�©H lhedh\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gbcª�k fgh]hqbke_ggufb�klZlvyfb�ihjZaebqguf� Zki_dlZf� l_hjbb� kgh\b^_gbc��Gh� q_f� ^Zevr_�� l_f� j_`_ [m^ml� ihiZ^Zlvky� lZdb_klZlvb��ihdZ�ihklhyggZy�jm[jbdZ�g_�bkq_ag_l�kh\k_f��:gZeblbdb�\_^ml�k_[y�lZd��dZd�[m^lh�bf[hevr_� g_q_]h� kdZaZlv� h kgh\b^_gbb�� dZd� [m^lh� jZajZ[hldZ� l_hjbb� kgh\b^_gbc� iheghklvxaZ\_jr_gZ�� Gh� _keb� \u� kijhkbl_�� qlh� ^mfZxl� h lhedh\Zgbb� kgh\b^_gbc� ebpZ�� klhysb_g_kdhevdh� \ klhjhg_�²� fgh]hqbke_ggu_� ikbobZlju� b ikbohl_jZi_\lu�� ]j_x�jpb_� jmdb� mgZr_]h� dhkljZ�� dklZlb� ^Z`_� g_� kqblZy� gm`guf� ih[eZ]h^Zjblv� aZ� ]hkl_ijbbfkl\h�� lZdgZau\Z_fu_�h[jZah\Zggu_�ex^b��dhlhju_�bf_xl�h[udgh\_gb_�ih^o\Zlu\Zlv�gZmqgu_�k_gkZpbb�ebl_jZlhju� b rbjhdZy� im[ebdZ�� lh� hl\_l� [m^_l� _s_� f_g__� ml_rbl_evguf�� G_dhlhju_iheh`_gby� klZeb�h[s_ba\_klgu�� kj_^b�gbo�b lZdb_�� dhlhjuo�fu�gbdh]^Z�g_� \u^\b]Zeb�� dZd�gZijbf_j�� l_abk� h lhf�� qlh� \k_� kgh\b^_gby� [m^lh� [u� ghkyl� k_dkmZevguc� oZjZdl_j�� Z lZdb_\Z`gu_� \_sb�� dZd� ijbgpbibZevgh_� jZaebqb_� f_`^m� y\guf� kh^_j`Zgb_f� kgh\b^_gby� b _]h

Page 259: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kdjulufb� fukeyfb�� beb� iheh`_gb_�� kh]eZkgh� dhlhjhfm� kgh\b^_gby�� khijh\h`^Zxsb_kykljZoZfb�� g_� ijhlb\hj_qZl� lZdhc� nmgdpbb� kgh\b^_gby�� dZd� bkiheg_gb_� `_eZgbc�� bebg_\hafh`ghklv� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby�� _keb� g_� jZkiheZ]Z_rv� hlghkysbfbky� d g_fmZkkhpbZpbyfb� \b^_\r_]h� khg�� b ij_`^_� \k_]h� \u\h^� h lhf�� qlh� kmlvx� kgh\b^_gby� y\ey_lkyijhp_kk� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby�²� \k_� wlh� hl� \k_h[s_]h� khagZgby�� ih�\b^bfhfmª� ihqlb� lZd� `_^Ze_dh��dZd�b ljb^pZlv�e_l� lhfm�gZaZ^��Y bf_x�ijZ\h� ]h\hjblv� lZd��ihlhfm�qlh� aZ� wlh�\j_fyihemqbe� [_kqbke_ggh_� fgh`_kl\h� ibk_f�� Z\lhju� dhlhjuo� ij_^eZ]Zxl� kgh\b^_gby� ^eylhedh\Zgby�beb� lj_[mxl� k\_^_gbc�h ijbjh^_� kgh\b^_gby�� ml\_j`^Zy�� qlh�ijhqeb�Lhedh\Zgb_kgh\b^_gbc �����Z���b \k_�lZdb�\u^Z\Zy�\ dZ`^hf�ij_^eh`_gbb�k\h_�ihegh_�g_ihgbfZgb_�gZr_cl_hjbb�kgh\b^_gbc��Wlh�ih[m`^Z_l�gZk�_s_�jZa�ihke_^h\Zl_evgh�baeh`blv�\k_��qlh�fu�agZ_f�hkgh\b^_gbyo��<u�ihfgbl_��qlh� \ ijhreuc�jZa�fu�ihk\ylbeb�p_euc�jy^� e_dpbc� lhfm��qlh[uihdZaZlv��dZd�fu�ijbreb�d ihgbfZgbx� wlh]h�^h� kbo�ihj� _s_�g_�h[tykg_ggh]h�ikbobq_kdh]hn_ghf_gZ�BlZd��_keb�gZf�dlh�lh��gZijbf_j�iZpb_gl��\h�\j_fy�ikbohZgZebaZ��jZkkdZau\Z_l�h dZdhf�lhk\h_f�kgh\b^_gbb��fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f��qlh�hg�^_eZ_l�gZf�h^gh�ba�l_o�khh[s_gbc��d dhlhjuf�_]hh[yau\Z_l� e_q_gb_� ZgZeblbq_kdbf�f_lh^hf��IjZ\^Z�� khh[s_gb_� g_ih^oh^ysbfb� kj_^kl\Zfb�\_^v�kZfh�ih�k_[_�kgh\b^_gb_�g_�y\ey_lky�khpbZevguf�ijhy\e_gb_f�beb�kj_^kl\hf�h[s_gby�Fu� \_^v� lh`_�g_�ihgbfZ_f�� qlh�gZf� ohl_e� kdZaZlv� \b^_\rbc� khg�� ^Z� b kZf� hg� agZ_l� wlh�g_emqr_�� A^_kv� gZf� g_h[oh^bfh� kjZam� `_� ijbgylv� j_r_gb_�� beb�� dZd� m\_jyxl� gZk� \jZqb�g_ikbohZgZeblbdb��kgh\b^_gb_�k\b^_l_evkl\m_l�h lhf��qlh�\b^_\rbc� khg�ijhklh�ieh�W� kiZe�qlh�g_�\k_�qZklb�_]h�fha]Z�h^bgZdh\h�hdZaZebkv�\ khklhygbb�ihdhy��qlh�hl^_evgu_�_]h�mqZkldbih^� \ebygb_f� g_ba\_klguo� jZa^jZ`bl_e_c� ijh^he`Zeb� jZ[hlZlv� b ^_eZeb� wlh� \_kvfZg_kh\_jr_gguf�h[jZahf��?keb�wlh�lZd��lh�fu�\ijZ\_�g_�aZgbfZlvky�[hevr_�wlbf�[_kihe_agufijh^mdlhf�ikbobdb��f_rZxsbf�ghqghfm�kgm��Qlh�ihe_agh]h�^ey�gZrbo�p_e_c�fh`gh�h`b^Zlvhl� _]h� bkke_^h\Zgby"� Beb� `_�� aZf_lbf� k_[_�� fu� aZjZg__� ijbgbfZ_f� ^jm]h_� j_r_gb_�� Fuij_^iheZ]Z_f��ihklmebjm_f�²�ijbagZxkv��^hklZlhqgh�ijhba\hevgh��qlh�^Z`_� wlh�g_ihgylgh_kgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lky� iheghijZ\guf�� hkfuke_gguf� b \_kvfZ� agZqbfuf� ikbobq_kdbf� Zdlhf�dhlhjuc�fu�fh`_f�bkihevah\Zlv�ijb�ZgZeba_�dZd�_s_�h^gh�khh[s_gb_�iZpb_glZ��IjZ\u�eb�fu�ihdZ`_l� lhevdh�mki_rghklv�bkke_^h\Zgby��?keb�gZf�m^Zklky�ij_\jZlblv� kgh\b^_gb_� \ lZdh_�agZqbfh_� \ukdZau\Zgb_�� lh� i_j_^� gZfb�� hq_\b^gh�� hldjh_lky� i_jki_dlb\Z� magZlv� gh\h_�ihemqblv�khh[s_gby�lZdh]h�oZjZdl_jZ��dhlhju_�bgZq_�hklZebkv�[u�^ey�gZk�g_^hklmigufb�Gm� Z l_i_jv� i_j_^� gZfb� \klZxl� \k_� ljm^ghklb� ihklZ\e_gghc� aZ^Zqb� a aZ]Z^dbjZkkfZljb\Z_fhc� ijh[e_fu�� DZdbf� `_� h[jZahf� ij_\jZlblv� kgh\b^_gb_� \ lZdh_� ghjfZevgh_khh[s_gb_�b dZd�h[tykgblv�lhl�nZdl��qlh�qZklv�\ukdZau\Zgbc�iZpb_glZ�ijbgbfZ_l�g_ihgylgmxdZd�^ey�g_]h��lZd�b ^ey�gZk�nhjfm"<u�\b^bl_��m\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��qlh�gZ� wlhl�jZa�y b^m�iml_f�g_� ]_g_lbq_kdh]h��Z^h]fZlbq_kdh]h� baeh`_gby�� I_j\uf� gZrbf� rZ]hf� [m^_l� gh\Zy� mklZgh\dZ� ih� hlghr_gbx� dijh[e_f_� kgh\b^_gby� [eZ]h^Zjy� \\_^_gbx� ^\mo� gh\uo� ihgylbc�� gZa\Zgbc��Lh�� qlh� gZau\Zxlkgh\b^_gb_f��fu�gZau\Z_f�l_dklhf�kgh\b^_gby��beb�y\guf kgh\b^_gb_f��Z lh��qlh�fu�bs_f�ij_^iheZ]Z_f�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� aZ� kgh\b^_gb_f�²� kdjulufb fukeyfb� kgh\b^_gby�� H[_� gZrbaZ^Zqb�fu�fh`_f� knhjfmebjh\Zlv�^Ze__� ke_^mxsbf�h[jZahf��fu�^he`gu�y\gh_� kgh\b^_gb_

Page 260: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ij_\jZlblv�\ kdjulh_�b ij_^klZ\blv�k_[_��dZdbf�h[jZahf�\ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb�\b^ys_]h�khg�wlhihke_^g__� klZgh\blky� i_j\uf��I_j\Zy� qZklv� jZ[hlu�²� ijZdlbq_kdZy�� wlh� aZ^ZqZ�lhedh\Zgbykgh\b^_gbc� lj_[mxsZy�hij_^_e_gghc�l_ogbdb��\lhjZy�²�l_hj_lbq_kdZy��hgZ�^he`gZ�h[tykgblvij_^iheZ]Z_fuc� ijhp_kk� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby b fh`_l� [ulv� lhevdh� l_hjb_c�� B l_ogbdmlhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc��b l_hjbx�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gby�ke_^m_l�kha^Zlv�aZgh\h�K q_]h�`_�fu�gZqg_f"�Y iheZ]Zx��k l_ogbdb�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc�wlh�[m^_l�gZ]ey^g__�b ijhba\_^_l�gZ�\Zk�[he__�`b\h_�\i_qZle_gb_�BlZd��iZpb_gl�jZkkdZaZe�kgh\b^_gb_��dhlhjh_�fu�^he`gu�bklhedh\Zlv�� Fu�_]h�kihdhcgh\ukemrZeb�� g_� imkdZykv� \ jZafure_gby�� Qlh� fu� ^_eZ_f� kgZqZeZ"�IhklZjZ_fky� f_g__� \k_]haZ[hlblvky� h lhf�� qlh� mkeurZeb�� l�� _�� h y\ghf kgh\b^_gbb�� Dhg_qgh�� wlh� y\gh_� kgh\b^_gb_h[eZ^Z_l�\k_\hafh`gufb�k\hckl\Zfb��dhlhju_�gZf�hlgx^v�g_�[_ajZaebqgu��Hgh�fh`_l�[ulvk\yaguf�� q_ldbf�ih� dhfihabpbb�� dZd�ihwlbq_kdh_�ijhba\_^_gb_��beb�g_ihgylgh� aZimlZgguf�ihqlb�dZd�[j_^��fh`_l�kh^_j`Zlv�we_f_glu�Z[kmj^gh]h�beb�hkljhlu�b dZ`msb_ky� ]em[hdbfbmfhaZdexq_gby�� hgh� fh`_l� [ulv� ^ey� \b^_\r_]h� khg� ykguf� b hlq_leb\uf� beb� kfmlguf� bjZkieu\qZluf��_]h�h[jZau�fh]ml�h[gZjm`blv�ihegmx�kbem�qm\kl\_gguo�\hkijbylbb�beb�[ulvdZd� l_gb�� dZd� g_ykgh_� ^mgh\_gb_�� \ h^ghf� kgh\b^_gbb� fh]ml� khclbkv� kZfu_� jZaebqgu_ijbagZdb�� ijbkmsb_� jZaguf� \_sZf�� gZdhg_p�� kgh\b^_gb_� fh`_l� [ulv� hdjZr_gh� \bg^bnn_j_glguc� wfhpbhgZevguc� lhg� beb� khijh\h`^Zlvky� kbevg_crbfb� jZ^hklgufb� bebg_ijbylgufb� wfhpbyfb� ²� g_� ^mfZcl_�� qlh� fu� g_� ijb^Z_f� gbdZdh]h� agZq_gby� wlhfm[_kdhg_qghfm�fgh]hh[jZabx�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby��iha^g__�fu�d g_fm�\_jg_fky�b gZc^_f�\ g_fhq_gv� fgh]h� p_ggh]h� ^ey� lhedh\Zgby�� gh� ihdZ� hklZ\bf� _]h� b ihc^_f� l_f� ]eZ\guf� iml_f�dhlhjuc�\_^_l�gZk�d lhedh\Zgbx�kgh\b^_gby��Wlh�agZqbl��qlh�fu�ihlj_[m_f�hl�\b^_\r_]h�khghk\h[h^blvky�hl�\i_qZle_gby�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby��gZijZ\b\�_]h�\gbfZgb_�hl�p_eh]h�d hl^_evgufnjZ]f_glZf�kh^_j`Zgby�kgh\b^_gby�b ij_^eh`b\�khh[sblv�gZf�ih�ihjy^dm��qlh�_fm�ijboh^bl\ �]heh\m�ih�ih\h^m�dZ`^h]h�ba�wlbo�njZ]f_glh\��dZdb_�m g_]h�\hagbdZxl�ZkkhpbZpbb��_keb�hgjZkkfhljbl�bo�\ hl^_evghklb�G_ijZ\^Z� eb� wlh� hkh[Zy� l_ogbdZ�� Z g_�ijb\uqguc� kihkh[� h[jZs_gby� k khh[s_gb_f� beb\ukdZau\Zgb_f"� <u� ^h]Z^u\Z_l_kv�� dhg_qgh�� qlhaZ� wlbf� ijb_fhf� djhxlky� ij_^ihkuedb�dhlhju_�_s_�g_�[ueb�\ukdZaZgu�Gh�ihc^_f�^Zevr_��< dZdhc�ihke_^h\Zl_evghklb�fu�ij_^eZ]Z_f�iZpb_glm�jZkkfZljb\ZlvnjZ]f_glu� _]h� kgh\b^_gby"� A^_kv� i_j_^� gZfb� hldju\Z_lky� g_kdhevdh� iml_c�� Fu� fh`_fijb^_j`b\Zlvky�ojhgheh]bq_kdh]h�ihjy^dZ��dhlhjuc�\ul_dZ_l�ba�jZkkdZaZ�kgh\b^_gby��Wlh��lZdkdZaZlv��kZfuc�kljh]bc��deZkkbq_kdbc�f_lh^��Beb�fu�fh`_f�ihijhkblv�\b^_\r_]h�khg�gZclbkgZqZeZ�\ kgh\b^_gbb�hklZldb�^g_\guo�\i_qZle_gbc� ihlhfm�qlh�hiul�mqbl�gZk��qlh�ihqlb�\dZ`^hf� kgh\b^_gbb� \kieu\Z_l� dZdhc�lh� njZ]f_gl� \hkihfbgZgby� beb� gZf_d� gZ� kh[ulb_ij_^r_kl\mxs_]h�kgh\b^_gbx�^gy��qZklh�gZ�g_kdhevdh�lZdbo�kh[ulbc��b _keb�fu�ihke_^m_f�aZwlbfb�k\yayfb��lh�qZklh�kjZam�`_�gZc^_f�i_j_oh^�hl�dZ`ms_]hky�^Ze_dbf�fbjZ�kgh\b^_gby�dj_Zevghc� `bagb� iZpb_glZ�� Beb� `_� fu� ij_^eh`bf� _fm� gZqZlv� k l_o� we_f_glh\� kh^_j`Zgbykgh\b^_gby��dhlhju_�_fm�aZihfgbebkv�\ke_^kl\b_�bo�hkh[hc�hlq_leb\hklb�b qm\kl\_gghc�kbeu�: gZf�ba\_klgh�� qlh� dZd� jZa�ijb�ihfhsb� wlbo� we_f_glh\� _fm� [m^_l� hkh[_ggh� e_]dh� \ua\ZlvZkkhpbZpbb��;_ajZaebqgh��dZdbf�bf_ggh�ba�wlbo�kihkh[h\�fu�ihemqbf�bkdhfu_�ZkkhpbZpbb�

Page 261: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

B \hl�fu�\ua\Zeb�wlb�ZkkhpbZpbb��Q_]h�\ gbo�lhevdh�g_l��\hkihfbgZgby�h \q_jZrg_f�^g_�h ^g_��ij_^r_kl\h\Z\r_f�kgh\b^_gbx��b h�^Z\gh�fbgm\rbo�\j_f_gZo��jZafure_gby��^bkdmkkbbkh�\k_fb� aZ�b ijhlb\��ijbagZgby�b \hijhku��G_dhlhju_�ba�gbo� lZd�b kuiexlky�ba�iZpb_glZ�i_j_^� ^jm]bfb� hg� gZ� dZdhc�lh� fhf_gl� hklZgZ\eb\Z_lky�� ;hevrbgkl\h� ba� gbo� h[gZjm`b\Z_lq_ldmx�k\yav�k dZdbf�eb[h�we_f_glhf�kgh\b^_gby��wlh�g_m^b\bl_evgh��\_^v�hgb�bkoh^yl�ba�wlbowe_f_glh\��gh�kemqZ_lky��qlh�iZpb_gl�ij_^\Zjy_l�bo�keh\Zfb��©DZ`_lky��wlh�g_�bf__l�gbdZdh]hhlghr_gby�d kgh\b^_gbx��y ]h\hjx�h[�wlhf�ihlhfm��qlh�wlh�ijbreh�fg_�\ ]heh\mª�<ukemrZ\� wlhl� ihlhd� \g_aZiguo� fuke_c�� \kdhj_� aZf_qZ_rv�� qlh� k kh^_j`Zgb_fkgh\b^_gby� hgb� [he__� l_kgh� k\yaZgu�� q_f� ijhklh� dZd� bkoh^gu_� fhf_glu�� Hgb� \^jm]\uk\_qb\Zxl� \k_� qZklb� kgh\b^_gby�� aZihegyxl� ijh[_eu�f_`^m� gbfb�� ^_eZxl� ihgylgufb� bokljZggu_� khq_lZgby�� GZdhg_p�� klZgh\blky� ykguf� khhlghr_gb_� f_`^m� gbfb� b kh^_j`Zgb_fkgh\b^_gby��Kgh\b^_gb_�y\ey_lky�djZldhc�\u`bfdhc�ba�ZkkhpbZpbb��dhlhjZy�[ueZ�k^_eZgZ�ihihdZ� _s_� g_ihgylguf� ijZ\beZf�� Z _]h� we_f_glu� \uklmiZxl� dZd� [u� ba[jZggufbij_^klZ\bl_eyfb�\k_]h�bo�fgh`_kl\Z��G_khfg_ggh��qlh�[eZ]h^Zjy�gZr_c�l_ogbd_�fu�ihemqbeblh��qlh�aZf_sZ_lky�kgh\b^_gb_f�b \�q_f�aZdexqZ_lky�ikbobq_kdZy�p_gghklv�kgh\b^_gby��gh�qlhm`_�[hevr_�g_�bf__l�kljZgguo�hkh[_gghkl_c�kgh\b^_gby��_]h�g_h[uqghklb�b aZimlZgghklb�Gh� ihcfbl_� f_gy� ijZ\bevgh�� :kkhpbZpbb� d kgh\b^_gbx� _s_� g_� y\eyxlky� kdjulufbfukeyfb� kgh\b^_gby��Ihke_^gb_� kh^_j`Zlky� \ ZkkhpbZpbyo�� dZd� \ fZlhqghf� jZkl\hj_��gh�g_p_ebdhf�� K h^ghc� klhjhgu�� ZkkhpbZpbb� ^Zxl� ]hjZa^h� [hevr_�� q_f� gZf� gm`gh� ^eynhjfmebjh\db� kdjuluo� fuke_c� kgh\b^_gby�� Z bf_ggh� \k_� jZkkm`^_gby�� i_j_oh^u�� k\yab�dhlhju_� bgl_ee_dl� iZpb_glZ� ^he`_g� ijhba\_klb� ^ey� ijb[eb`_gby� d fukeyf� kgh\b^_gby�� K^jm]hc�klhjhgu��ZkkhpbZpby�qZklh�hklZgZ\eb\Z_lky�dZd�jZa�i_j_^�fukeyfb�kgh\b^_gby��lhevdhijb[ebab\rbkv�d gbf�b _^\Z�dhkgm\rbkv�bo�gZf_dhf��Lh]^Z�fu�\f_rb\Z_fky�kZfb��^hihegyyebrv� ke_]dZ� h[hagZq_ggh_�� ^_eZ_f�g_hijh\_j`bfu_� \u\h^u�� \ukdZau\Z_f� lh�� qlh� iZpb_gl� \k\hbo�ZkkhpbZpbyo�ebrv�\kdhevav�mihfygme��<k_�lh]^Z�gZqbgZ_l�\u]ey^_lv�lZd��dZd�[m^lh�furmly�b \_kvfZ�ijhba\hevgh�b]jZ_f�k fZl_jbZehf��dhlhjuc�\b^_\rbc�khg�ij_^hklZ\be�\ gZr_jZkihjy`_gb_�� b aehmihlj_[ey_f� wlbf�� bklhedh\u\Zy� _]h� \ukdZau\Zgby� \ lZdhf� kfuke_�dhlhjuc� bf� g_� [ue� ijbkms�� h^gZdh� Z[kljZdlgufb� jZkkm`^_gbyfb� ihdZaZlv� ijZ\hf_jghklvgZr_]h�ih^oh^Z�g_e_]dh��Ihijh[mcl_�emqr_�kZfb�ijhZgZebabjh\Zlv�dZdh_�gb[m^v�kgh\b^_gb_beb� m]em[bl_kv� \ dZdhc�gb[m^v� ohjhrh� hibkZgguc� \ ebl_jZlmj_� ijbf_j�� b \u� m[_^bl_kv�gZkdhevdh�h[hkgh\ZggZ�lZdZy�ijZdlbdZ�lhedh\Zgby�?keb�ijb�lhedh\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gby�fu�aZ\bkbf�\hh[s_�b \�i_j\mx�hq_j_^v�hl�ZkkhpbZpbc\b^_\r_]h� khg�� lh� ih� hlghr_gbx� d hij_^_e_gguf� we_f_glZf� kh^_j`Zgby� kgh\b^_gby� fu^_ckl\m_f� \k_� `_� kh\_jr_ggh� kZfhklhyl_evgh� b ij_`^_� \k_]h� ihlhfm�� qlh� bgZq_� g_evay�ihkdhevdm�ZkkhpbZpbb�lml��dZd�ijZ\beh��g_�]h^ylky��Fu�aZjZg__�hlf_lbeb��qlh�wlh�hlghkblky�d\iheg_�hij_^_e_gguf�kh^_j`Zgbyf��bo�g_�lZd�fgh]h��b gZdhie_gguc�hiul�mqbl�gZk�lhfm��qlhbo�ke_^m_l�ihgbfZlv�b lhedh\Zlv�dZd�kbf\heu q_]h�lh�^jm]h]h��< hlebqb_�hl�^jm]bo�we_f_glh\kgh\b^_gby� bf� fh`gh� ijbibkZlv� ihklhyggh_� agZq_gb_�� dhlhjh_� g_h[yaZl_evgh� ^he`gh� [ulvh^gbf�b l_f�`_��_]h�h[t_f�hij_^_ey_lky�hkh[ufb��ijb\uqgufb�^ey�gZk�ijZ\beZfb��Ihkdhevdmfu�mf__f�i_j_\h^blv�wlb�kbf\heu��Z \b^_\rbc�khg�²�g_l��ohly�hg�kZf�bo�mihlj_[be��fh`_lkemqblvky�� qlh� kfuke� kgh\b^_gby� klZg_l� ^ey� gZk� kh\_jr_ggh� yk_g� _s_� ^h� ihiulhd� _]h

Page 262: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

lhedh\Zgby��dZd�lhevdh�fu�mkeurbf�l_dkl�kgh\b^_gby��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�kZf�\b^_\rbc�khg�_s_haZ^Zq_g��Gh�h kbf\hebd_��gZrbo�agZgbc�h g_c��h ijh[e_fZo��dhlhju_�hgZ�i_j_^�gZfb�klZ\bl��ym`_�lZd�fgh]h�]h\hjbe�\ ij_^u^msbo�e_dpbyo��qlh�k_]h^gy�g_l�gm`^u�ih\lhjylvky�LZdh\� gZr� f_lh^� lhedh\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc�� <hagbdZ_l� ke_^mxsbc�� \iheg_� hijZ\^Zgguc\hijhk��fh`gh�eb�k _]h�ihfhsvx�lhedh\Zlv�\k_�kgh\b^_gby"�B hl\_l�gZ�g_]h�lZdh\��g_l��g_�\k_�gh�klhev�fgh]b_��qlh�wlh�m[_`^Z_l�\ ijb]h^ghklb�b hijZ\^Zgghklb�f_lh^Z��Ihq_fm�`_��h^gZdh�g_� \k_"�Gb`_ke_^mxsbc� hl\_l� ^Zkl� gZf� g_qlh� \Z`gh_� ^ey� ihgbfZgby� ikbobq_kdbo� mkeh\bch[jZah\Zgby�kgh\b^_gby��ihlhfm�qlh�jZ[hlZ�ih�lhedh\Zgbx�kgh\b^_gbc�kh\_jrZ_lky�\hij_dbkhijhlb\e_gbx�� dhlhjh_� fh`_l� f_gylvky� hl� _^\Z� aZf_lguo� \_ebqbg� ^h� kl_i_gb� kh\_jr_gghg_ij_h^hebfhc�ij_]jZ^u��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��^ey�kj_^kl\�\ha^_ckl\by��dhlhjufb�fu�jZkiheZ]Z_f\ gZklhys__�\j_fy��Ijhy\e_gbc�wlh]h�khijhlb\e_gby�g_evay�g_�aZf_lblv�\ ijhp_kk_�jZ[hlu��<g_dhlhjuo�kemqZyo�ZkkhpbZpbb�\hagbdZxl�g_aZf_^ebl_evgh��b m`_�i_j\Zy�beb�\lhjZy�ba�gbo�\k_ijhykgy_l��< ^jm]bo�kemqZyo�iZpb_gl�kihludZ_lky�b f_^ebl��ij_`^_�q_f�\ukdZaZlv�dZdmx�lhZkkhpbZpbx�� b lh]^Z� aZqZklmx� ijboh^blky� \ukemrb\Zlv� ^ebggmx� p_iv� ijboh^ysbo� _fm� \]heh\m� fuke_c�� ihdZ� g_� ihemqbrv� g_�lh� ih^oh^ys__� ^ey� ihgbfZgby� kgh\b^_gby�� FukijZ\_^eb\h� kqblZ_f�� qlh�� q_f� ^ebgg__� b aZimlZgg__� ZkkhpbZlb\gZy� p_iv�� l_f� kbevg__khijhlb\e_gb_�� B \� aZ[u\Zgbb� kgh\b^_gbc� gZf� \b^blky� lh� `_� \ebygb_�� >h\hevgh� qZklhkemqZ_lky��qlh�iZpb_gl��g_kfhljy�gZ� \k_� mkbeby��g_�fh`_l� \kihfgblv� dZdh_�gb[m^v�ba� k\hbokgh\b^_gbc�� Gh� ihke_� lh]h�� dZd� fu� gZ� dZdhf�lh� wlZi_� ZgZeblbq_kdhc� jZ[hlu� mkljZgbfaZljm^g_gb_�� dhlhjh_� f_rZeh� ijZ\bevghfm� hlghr_gbx� iZpb_glZ� d ZgZebam�� aZ[ulh_kgh\b^_gb_� g_h`b^Zggh� \hkklZgZ\eb\Z_lky�� D wlhfm� bf_xl� hlghr_gb_� b ^\Z� ^jm]bogZ[ex^_gby��Hq_gv�qZklh�kemqZ_lky��qlh�ba�dZdh]h�lh�kgh\b^_gby�kgZqZeZ�\uiZ^Z_l�njZ]f_gl�dhlhjuc�aZl_f�ijb[Z\ey_lky�dZd�^hiheg_gb_��Wlh�ke_^m_l�ihgbfZlv�dZd�ihiuldm� aZ[ulv�wlhlnjZ]f_gl��Hiul�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�bf_ggh�wlhl�njZ]f_gl�bf__l�gZb[hevr__�agZq_gb_�fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f��qlh�_]h�khh[s_gbx�ij_iylkl\h\Zeh�[he__�kbevgh_�khijhlb\e_gb_��q_fkhh[s_gbx� ^jm]bo�� >Ze__�� fu� qZklh� aZf_qZ_f�� qlh� \b^_\rbc� khg� kZf� klZjZ_lkyijhlb\h^_ckl\h\Zlv� aZ[u\Zgbx� k\hbo� kgh\b^_gbc�� aZibku\Zy� bo� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh� ihke_ijh[m`^_gby��Fu�fh`_f�_fm�kdZaZlv��qlh�wlh�[_kihe_agh��lZd�dZd�khijhlb\e_gb_��m dhlhjh]h�hghl\h_\Ze�kh^_j`Zgb_�kgh\b^_gby��i_j_ghkblky�lh]^Z�gZ�ZkkhpbZpbx�b ^_eZ_l�y\gh_�kgh\b^_gb_g_^hklmiguf�^ey�lhedh\Zgby��Ijb�wlbo�mkeh\byo�g_�ijboh^blky�m^b\eylvky��_keb�^Zevg_cr__mkbe_gb_� khijhlb\e_gby� \hh[s_� ih^Z\ey_l� ZkkhpbZpbb�� ebrZy� l_f� kZfuf� \hafh`ghklblhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gby�Ba�\k_]h�wlh]h�fu�^_eZ_f�\u\h^��qlh�khijhlb\e_gb_��dhlhjh_�fu�aZf_qZ_f�ijb�jZ[hl_�gZ^lhedh\Zgb_f� kgh\b^_gby�� ^he`gh� mqZkl\h\Zlv� b \� \hagbdgh\_gbb� kgh\b^_gby�� JZaebqZxlkykgh\b^_gby�� dhlhju_� \hagbdZxl� ijb� gZebqbb� g_agZqbl_evgh]h� beb� [hevrh]h� ^Z\e_gbykhijhlb\e_gby�� Gh� b wlh� ^Z\e_gb_� g_h^bgZdh\h� gZ� ijhly`_gbb� h^gh]h� kgh\b^_gby�� hgh\bgh\Zlh� \ ijh[_eZo�� g_ykghklyo�� imlZgbp_�� dhlhju_� fh]ml� gZjmrblv� k\yaghklv� kZfh]hij_djZkgh]h�kgh\b^_gby�Gh�qlh�`_�kha^Z_l�wlh�khijhlb\e_gb_�b ijhlb\�q_]h�hgh"�Khijhlb\e_gb_�y\ey_lky�^ey�gZk\_jguf� ijbagZdhf� g_dh_]h� dhgnebdlZ�� <b^bfh�� _klv� dZdZy�lh� kbeZ�� dhlhjZy� ohq_l� qlh�lh\ujZablv��b _klv�^jm]Zy��dhlhjZy�klj_fblky�g_�^himklblv�wlh]h��Lh��qlh� aZl_f�ij_^klZ\ey_lky

Page 263: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

y\guf�kgh\b^_gb_f��h[t_^bgy_l�\ k_[_�\k_�j_r_gby��\ dhlhjuo�\hiehlbeZkv� wlZ�[hjv[Z�^\moklj_fe_gbc��< h^ghf�f_kl_��\b^bfh��h^ghc�kbe_�m^Zehkv�ijh[blvky�b kdZaZlv��qlh�_c�ohl_ehkv��\^jm]bo� f_klZo� ijhlb\h[hjkl\mxs_c� bgklZgpbb� ihkqZkleb\behkv� iheghklvx� ih]Zkblv]hlh\ys__ky�khh[s_gb_�beb�aZf_gblv�_]h�q_f�lh��qlh�g_�g_k_l�gZ�k_[_�gbdZdh]h�_]h�ke_^Z��QZs_\k_]h� \klj_qZxlky� b gZb[he__� oZjZdl_jgu� ^ey� \hagbdgh\_gby� kgh\b^_gby� kemqZb�� \ dhlhjuodhgnebdl� \ueb\Z_lky� \ dhfijhfbkk�� lZd� qlh� khh[sZxsZy� bgklZgpby� fh`_l� kdZaZlv�� qlh� _cohl_ehkv�� gh� g_� lZd�� dZd� _c� ohl_ehkv�� Z ebrv� kfy]q_ggh�� bkdZ`_ggh� b g_\gylgh��BlZd�� _kebkgh\b^_gb_� i_j_^Z_l� fukeb� kgh\b^_gby� g_lhqgh�� _keb� hgh� gm`^Z_lky� \ lhedh\Zgbb�� qlh[ui_j_[jhkblv�fhkl�q_j_a�ijhiZklv�f_`^m�gbfb��lh�wlh�aZkem]Z�khijhlb\eyxs_cky��lhjfhays_c�bh]jZgbqb\Zxs_c� bgklZgpbb�� dhlhjmx� fu� h[gZjm`beb� [eZ]h^Zjy� khijhlb\e_gbx� ijblhedh\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gby��IhdZ�fu�bamqZeb�kgh\b^_gb_�dZd�bahebjh\Zgguc�n_ghf_g��g_aZ\bkbfhhl� jh^kl\_gguo� _fm� ikbobq_kdbo� h[jZah\Zgbc�� fu� gZau\Zeb� wlm� bgklZgpbx� p_gahjhfkgh\b^_gby�<u�^Z\gh�agZ_l_��qlh�wlZ�p_gamjZ�g_�y\ey_lky�q_f�lh�hkh[_gguf�\ `bagb�kgh\b^_gbc��qlhdhgnebdl� ^\mo� ikbobq_kdbo� bgklZgpbc�� dhlhju_� fu� g_lhqgh� gZau\Z_f� [_kkhagZl_evguf\ul_kg_gguf� b khagZl_evguf�� \hh[s_� mijZ\ey_l� gZr_c� ikbobq_kdhc� `bagvx� b qlhkhijhlb\e_gb_�lhedh\Zgbx�kgh\b^_gby��dZd�ijbagZd�p_gamju�kgh\b^_gby��_klv�g_�qlh�bgh_��dZdkhijhlb\e_gb_� \ul_kg_gby �9HUGUDQJXQJVZLGHUVWDQG��� [eZ]h^Zjy� dhlhjhfm� wlb� h[_� bgklZgpbbhl^_eyxlky�^jm]�hl�^jm]Z��<u�agZ_l_�lZd`_��qlh�ba�bo�dhgnebdlZ�ijb�hij_^_e_gguo�mkeh\byo\hagbdZxl� ^jm]b_� ikbobq_kdb_� kljmdlmju�� dhlhju_� lZd� `_�� dZd� b kgh\b^_gb_ª� y\eyxlkyj_amevlZlhf� dhfijhfbkkh\�� b g_� [m^_l_� gZklZb\Zlv�� qlh[u� y ih\lhjye� \Zf� a^_kv� \k_�� qlhkh^_j`blky�\h�\\_^_gbb�\ l_hjbx�g_\jhah\ª�^Z[u�ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv�lh��qlh�gZf�ba\_klgh�h[mkeh\byo� h[jZah\Zgby� lZdbo� dhfijhfbkkh\�� <u� ihgyeb�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� y\ey_lkyiZlheh]bq_kdbf� ijh^mdlhf�� i_j\uf� a\_ghf� p_ib�� dhlhjZy� \dexqZ_l� bkl_jbq_kdbc� kbfilhf�gZ\yaqb\h_� ij_^klZ\e_gb_�� [j_^h\mx� b^_x�� gh� hlebqZ_lky� hl� gbo� ij_oh^ysbf� oZjZdl_jhf� bl_f�� qlh� hg� \hagbdZ_l� \ mkeh\byo�� k\hckl\_gguo� ghjfZevghc� `bagb�� LZd� qlh� [m^_fijb^_j`b\Zlvky�fg_gby�� qlh�`bagv� kgh\b^_gby²� dZd� kdZaZe� _s_�:jbklhl_ev� ²� wlh� kihkh[jZ[hlu�gZr_c�^mrb� \ khklhygbb� kgZ��Khklhygb_� kgZ�ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� hloh^� hl� j_Zevgh]h\g_rg_]h�fbjZ��b wlbf� kha^Z_lky�mkeh\b_�^ey�jZa\blby�ikbohaZ��KZfh_� lsZl_evgh_�bamq_gb_ly`_euo�ikbohah\�g_�^Zkl�gZf�ijbagZdZ��[he__�oZjZdl_jgh]h�^ey�wlh]h�[he_ag_ggh]h�khklhygby�Gh� ijb� ikboha_� hloh^� hl� j_Zevghklb� \hagbdZ_l� ^\hydbf� h[jZahf�� beb� dh]^Z� \ul_kg_ggh_[_kkhagZl_evgh_� klZgh\blky� k\_jokbevguf� gZklhevdh�� qlh� [_j_l� \_jo� gZ^� aZ\bkysbf� hlj_Zevghklb�khagZl_evguf��beb�dh]^Z�j_Zevghklv�g_k_l�\ k_[_�klhevdh�g_\ughkbfh]h�kljZ^Zgby�qlh�ih^\_j]gmlh_�m]jha_�Y \�hlqZygghf�ijhl_kl_�[jhkZ_lky�\ jmdb�[_kkhagZl_evguo�\e_q_gbc�;_ah[b^guc� ikboha� kgh\b^_gby� y\ey_lky� ke_^kl\b_f� khagZl_evgh� `_eZ_fh]h� b ebrv\j_f_ggh]h� hloh^Z� hl� \g_rg_]h� fbjZ�� b hg� bkq_aZ_l� ijb� \hah[gh\e_gbb� hlghr_gbc� k wlbffbjhf��Ijb�baheypbb�kiys_]h�baf_gy_lky�lZd`_�jZkij_^_e_gb_�_]h�ikbobq_kdhc�wg_j]bb��qZklvwg_j]bb� \ul_kg_gby�� dhlhjZy� h[uqgh� bkihevam_lky� ^ey� mkfbj_gby� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� fh`_l[ulv� kwdhghfe_gZ�� ihlhfm� qlh� ^Z`_� _keb� hgh� >[_kkhagZl_evgh_@� bkihevah\Zeh� [u� __hlghkbl_evgh_� \uk\h[h`^_gb_� ^ey� k\h_c� Zdlb\ghklb�� lh� h[gZjm`beh� [u�� h^gZdh�� qlh� imlv� d^\b]Zl_evghc� kn_j_� aZdjul�� Z hldjul� ebrv� imlv� d [_ah[b^ghfm� ]ZeexpbgZlhjghfmm^h\e_l\hj_gbx��<hl�lml�lh�b fh`_l�\hagbdgmlv�kgh\b^_gb_��gh�nZdl�kms_kl\h\Zgby�p_gamju

Page 264: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kgh\b^_gby�ihdZau\Z_l�� qlh�b \h� \j_fy� kgZ� khojZgy_lky� \k_� _s_� ^hklZlhqgh_� khijhlb\e_gb_\ul_kg_gby�A^_kv�gZf�hldju\Z_lky�imlv�^ey�hl\_lZ�gZ�\hijhk��\uihegy_l�eb�kgh\b^_gb_�lh`_�dZdmx�lhnmgdpbx�� ^h\_j_gZ� eb� _fm� dZdZy�lh� ihe_agZy� jZ[hlZ��Ebr_gguc� \kydbo� jZa^jZ`_gbb� ihdhc�dhlhjuc� ohl_eh� [u� kha^Zlv� khklhygb_� kgZ�� ih^\_j`_g� hiZkghklyf� k lj_o� klhjhg�� [he__kemqZcguf�h[jZahf�kh�klhjhgu�\g_rgbo�jZa^jZ`bl_e_c�\h�\j_fy� kgZ�b kh�klhjhgu�^g_\guobgl_j_kh\�� dhlhju_� g_� bkq_aZxl�� b g_ba[_`gh� kh� klhjhgu� g_m^h\e_l\hj_gguo� \ul_kg_gguo\e_q_gbc��dhlhju_�lZd�b `^ml�\hafh`ghklb�ijhy\blvky��<ke_^kl\b_�hkeZ[e_gby�\ul_kg_gbb�\ghqgh_�\j_fy�bf_eZkv�[u�hiZkghklv�gZjmr_gby�kgZ�dZ`^uc�jZa��dh]^Z�\g_rg__�b \gmlj_gg__\ha[m`^_gb_� fh]eh� [u� \klmiblv� \ k\yav� k h^gbf� ba� bklhqgbdh\� [_kkhagZl_evguo� \e_q_gbc�Ijhp_kk� kgh\b^_gby� iha\hey_l� ij_\jZlblv� ijh^mdl� lZdh]h� \aZbfh^_ckl\by� \ [_a\j_^gh_]ZeexpbgZlhjgh_� i_j_`b\Zgb_�� h[_ki_qb\Zy� lZdbf� h[jZahf� ijh^he`_gb_� kgZ�� <uiheg_gbxwlhc�nmgdpbb�gb� \ dh_c�f_j_�g_�ijhlb\hj_qbl�b lhl�nZdl��qlh�bgh]^Z� kljZrgh_� kgh\b^_gb_[m^bl�kiys_]h��wlh��kdhj__��kb]gZe�lh]h��qlh�ghqghc�kljZ`�kqblZ_l�kblmZpbx�kebrdhf�hiZkghcb g_�\_jbl�m`_�\ \hafh`ghklv� kijZ\blvky� k g_c��G_j_^dh� _s_�\h� kg_�fu� keurbf�ml_r_gb_�ijba\Zggh_�ij_^hl\jZlblv�ijh[m`^_gb_��^Z�\_^v�wlh�`_�lhevdh�khg�<hl�b \k_��qlh�y ohl_e�kdZaZlv�\Zf��m\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��h lhedh\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gbc�aZ^ZqZ� dhlhjh]h�²� ijbclb� hl� y\gh]h� kgh\b^_gby� d kdjuluf� _]h�fukeyf��Bo� ihemq_gb_f� bbkq_jiu\Z_lky� qZs_� \k_]h� bgl_j_k� ijZdlbq_kdh]h� ZgZebaZ� d kgh\b^_gbx�� Khh[s_gb_�ihemq_ggh_� \ nhjf_� kgh\b^_gby�� ijb[Z\ey_lky� d ^jm]bf�� b ZgZeba� ijh^he`Z_lky�� GZf� `_bgl_j_kgh�_s_�g_fgh]h�aZ^_j`Zlvky�gZ�l_f_�kgh\b^_gby��gZk�ijb\e_dZ_l�\hafh`ghklv�bamqblvijhp_kk� ij_\jZs_gby� kdjuluo� fuke_c� kgh\b^_gby� \ y\gh_� kgh\b^_gb_�� Fu� gZau\Z_f� _]hjZ[hlhc�kgh\b^_gby��<u�ihfgbl_��y jZa[bjZe�_]h�ih^jh[gh�\ ij_^u^msbo�e_dpbyo��lZd�qlh�\k_]h^gyrg_f�h[ahj_�y fh]m�h]jZgbqblvky�kZfufb�djZldbfb�\u\h^Zfb�BlZd�� ijhp_kk� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� y\ey_lky� q_f�lh� kh\_jr_ggh� gh\uf� b g_ijb\uqguf�gbq_]h� ih^h[gh]h� jZgvr_� ba\_klgh� g_� [ueh��Hg� ^Ze� gZf� \hafh`ghklv� \i_j\u_� aZ]eygmlv� \ijhp_kku��ijhbkoh^ysb_�\ kbkl_f_�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��ihdZaZ\��qlh�hgb�kh\_jr_ggh�bgu_��q_flh�� qlh� fu� agZ_f� h gZr_f� khagZl_evghf� fure_gbb�� dhlhjhfm� hgb�� ^he`gh� [ulv�� dZ`mlkyg_keuoZggufb�b hrb[hqgufb��AgZq_gb_� wlbo� hldjulbc� \hajhkeh� _s_�[hevr_�� dh]^Z� magZeb�qlh�ijb�h[jZah\Zgbb�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�kbfilhfh\�^_ckl\mxl�l_�`_�f_oZgbafu� �fu�g_�j_rZ_fkykdZaZlv��fukebl_evgu_� ijhp_kku��� dhlhju_� ij_\jZsZxl� kdjulu_�fukeb� kgh\b^_gby� \ y\gh_kgh\b^_gb_�Ijb�^Zevg_cr_f�baeh`_gbb�g_\hafh`gh�ba[_`Zlv�ko_fZlbqghklb��Ij_^iheh`bf��qlh�fubkke_^m_f� \ hij_^_e_gghf� kemqZ_� \k_� l_� kdjulu_�� [he__�beb�f_g__� Znn_dlb\gh� aZjy`_ggu_fukeb��dhlhju_�ihke_�lhedh\Zgby�\uklmibeb�\f_klh�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby��GZf�[jhkZ_lky�\ ]eZaZjZaebqb_� f_`^m� gbfb�� b wlh� jZaebqb_� ^Ze_dh� m\_^_l� gZk��Ihqlb� \k_� wlb� fukeb� kgh\b^_gbymagZxlky�beb�ijbagZxlky�\b^_\rbf�khg��hg�khagZ_lky��qlh�^mfZe�lZd�\ wlhl�beb�\ ^jm]hc�jZa�beb� hg� fh]� [u� lZd� ^mfZlv�� Lhevdh� ijhlb\� ij_^iheh`_gby� h^ghc�_^bgkl\_gghc� fukeb� hgwg_j]bqgh� \hajZ`Z_l�� wlZ�fukev� _fm� qm`^Z��fh`_l� [ulv�� ^Z`_� hl\jZlbl_evgZ�� \hafh`gh�� hghlf_l_l�__�\ kljZklghf�\ha[m`^_gbb��B lh]^Z�gZf�klZgh\blky�ykgh��qlh�^jm]b_�fukeb�²� wlhnjZ]f_glu�khagZl_evgh]h��\_jg__�]h\hjy��ij_^khagZl_evgh]h�fure_gby��hgb�fh]eb�ihy\blvky�b

Page 265: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ [h^jkl\mxs_f� khklhygbb�� \_jhylgh� lZd`_�� qlh� hgb� \hagbdeb� \ l_q_gb_� ^gy�� Gh� wlZ_^bgkl\_ggZy� hl\_j]Z_fZy� fukev� beb�� lhqg__�� wlh� _^bgkl\_ggh_� ih[m`^_gb_� ²� ihjh`^_gb_ghqb�� hgh� hlghkblky� d h[eZklb� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� \b^_\r_]h� khg�� ihwlhfm� b hl\_j]Z_lky�hl[jZku\Z_lky� bf�� Hgh� dZd� [u� ^h`b^Zehkv� hkeZ[e_gby� \ul_kg_gby� ghqvx�� qlh[u� dZdbf�lhh[jZahf�ijhy\blvky��Wlh�ijhy\e_gb_�\k_]^Z�kfy]q_gh��bkdZ`_gh��aZfZkdbjh\Zgh��[_a�jZ[hlu�gZ^lhedh\Zgb_f� kgh\b^_gby� fu� [u� _]h� g_� gZreb�� ;eZ]h^Zjy� k\yab� k ^jm]bfb� [_amij_qgufbfukeyfb� kgh\b^_gby� wlh� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� \e_q_gb_� \ aZfZkdbjh\Zgghf� \b^_� ijhkdZevau\Z_lq_j_a�h]jZgbq_gb_�p_gamju��k ^jm]hc�klhjhgu��ij_^khagZl_evgu_�fukeb�kgh\b^_gby�[eZ]h^Zjywlhc�`_� k\yab� h[eZ^Zxl� \hafh`ghklvx� aZgbfZlv� ^mr_\gmx�`bagv� b \h� \j_fy� kgZ��B[h� fugbkdhevdh� g_� khfg_\Z_fky�� qlh� wlh� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� \e_q_gb_� b _klv�� kh[kl\_ggh�� kha^Zl_evkgh\b^_gby�� ^ey� _]h� h[jZah\Zgby� _fm� lj_[m_lky� ikbobq_kdZy� wg_j]by�� DZd� b ex[h_� ^jm]h_\e_q_gb_��hgh�klj_fblky�gb d�q_fm�bghfm��dZd�d k\h_fm�kh[kl\_gghfm�m^h\e_l\hj_gbx��b gZrhiul�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc�lh`_�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�wlh�b y\ey_lky�kfukehf�\k_]h�kgh\b^_gby��<ex[hf�kgh\b^_gbb�\e_q_gb_�^he`gh�ij_^klZlv�dZd�hkms_kl\e_ggh_��GhqgZy�bahebjh\Zgghklv^mr_\ghc�`bagb�hl�j_Zevghklb�b klZ\rZy�\hafh`ghc�[eZ]h^Zjy�_c�j_]j_kkby�d ijbfblb\guff_oZgbafZf� ijb\h^yl� d lhfm�� qlh� wlh� `_eZ_fh_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� \e_q_gby� i_j_`b\Z_lky]ZeexpbgZlhjgh� dZd� j_Zevgh_�� <ke_^kl\b_� wlhc� `_� j_]j_kkbb� ij_^klZ\e_gby� \ kgh\b^_gbbi_j_\h^ylky� \ ajbl_evgu_� h[jZau�� l�� _�� kdjulu_� fukeb� kgh\b^_gby� ^jZfZlbabjmxlky� bbeexkljbjmxlky�Ba� wlh]h� wlZiZ�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gby�fu�magZ_f�h g_dhlhjuo�gZb[he__�yjdbo�b hkh[_gguoq_jlZo� kgh\b^_gby�� Y _s_� jZa� kdZ`m� h ihjy^d_� \hagbdgh\_gby� kgh\b^_gby�� Bkoh^gh_khklhygb_�� `_eZgb_� kiZlv�� gZf_j_gguc� hldZa� hl� \g_rg_]h� fbjZ�� >\Z� _]h� ke_^kl\by� ^ey^mr_\gh]h�ZiiZjZlZ��\h�i_j\uo��\hafh`ghklv�ijhy\e_gby�\ g_f�[he__�^j_\gbo�b ijbfblb\guokihkh[h\�jZ[hlu�²�j_]j_kkbb��\h�\lhjuo��hkeZ[e_gb_�khijhlb\e_gby�\ul_kg_gby��ly]hl_xs_]hgZ^� [_kkhagZl_evguf�� DZd� ke_^kl\b_� wlh]h� ihke_^g_]h� fhf_glZ� \hagbdZ_l� \hafh`ghklvh[jZah\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby�� dhlhjmx�b bkihevamxl� ih\h^u�²� h`b\rb_� \gmlj_ggb_� b \g_rgb_jZa^jZ`bl_eb��Kgh\b^_gb_��\hagbdr__�lZdbf�h[jZahf��ij_^klZ\ey_l�kh[hc�m`_�dhfijhfbkkgh_h[jZah\Zgb_��hgh�\uihegy_l�^\hydmx�nmgdpbx��k h^ghc�klhjhgu��hgh�m^h\e_l\hjy_l�Y��dh]^Zkem`bl� `_eZgbx� kiZlv� iml_f� hk\h[h`^_gby� hl� gZjmrZxsbo� khg� jZa^jZ`_gbb�� k ^jm]hcklhjhgu��hgh�iha\hey_l�\ul_kg_gghfm�\e_q_gbx�\hafh`gh_�\ wlbo�mkeh\byo�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�\nhjf_� ]ZeexpbgZlhjgh]h� bkiheg_gby� `_eZgby�� Gh� \_kv� ^himkdZ_fuc� kiysbf� Y ijhp_kkh[jZah\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby� ijhoh^bl� \ mkeh\byo� p_gamju�� dhlhjZy� hkms_kl\ey_lky� hklZldhfkhojZgb\r_]hky�\ul_kg_gby��Ijhs_�baeh`blv�wlhl�ijhp_kk�y g_�fh]m��hg�b g_�ijhs_��H^gZdhl_i_jv�y fh]m�ijh^he`blv�hibkZgb_�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gby�<_jg_fky�_s_�jZa�d kdjuluf�fukeyf�kgh\b^_gby��KZfuf�kbevguf�bo�we_f_glhf�y\ey_lky\ul_kg_ggh_�\e_q_gb_��dhlhjh_��hibjZykv�gZ�kemqZcgu_�jZa^jZ`bl_eb�b i_j_ghkykv�gZ�hklZldb^g_\guo�\i_qZle_gbc��gZreh�\ gbo�k\h_�\ujZ`_gb_��imklv�kfy]q_ggh_�b aZ\mZebjh\Zggh_��DZdb ex[h_� \e_q_gb_�� hgh� klj_fblky� d m^h\e_l\hj_gbx� ijb� ihfhsb� ^_ckl\by�� gh� imlv� \^\b]Zl_evgmx� kn_jm� aZdjul� ^ey� g_]h� nbabheh]bq_kdbfb� f_oZgbafZfb� khklhygby� kgZ�� hgh\ugm`^_gh� ijh[b\Zlvky� \ h[jZlghf� gZijZ\e_gbb� d \hkijbylbx� b ^h\hevkl\h\Zlvky]ZeexpbgZlhjguf�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f��LZdbf�h[jZahf��kdjulu_�fukeb�kgh\b^_gby�i_j_\h^ylky�\kh\hdmighklv�qm\kl\_gguo�h[jZah\�b ajbl_evguo�kp_g��GZ�wlhf�imlb�k gbfb�ijhbkoh^bl�lh��qlh

Page 266: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dZ`_lky�gZf�klhev�gh\uf�b kljZgguf�<k_� l_� yaudh\u_� kj_^kl\Z�� dhlhjufb� \ujZ`Zxlky� [he__� lhgdb_� fukebl_evgu_hlghr_gby�²� khxau��ij_^eh]b�� kdehg_gby�b kijy`_gby�²� hliZ^Zxl��ihkdhevdm�^ey�gbo�g_lbah[jZabl_evguo�kj_^kl\��dZd�b \�ijbfblb\ghf�yaud_�[_a�]jZffZlbdb��a^_kv�ij_^klZ\e_g�ebrvkujhc�fZl_jbZe�fure_gby��Z Z[kljZdlgh_�k\h^blky�d e_`Zs_fm�\ _]h�hkgh\_�dhgdj_lghfm��Lh�qlh� \ j_amevlZl_� wlh]h� hklZ_lky�� e_]dh�fh`_l� ihdZaZlvky� [_kk\yaguf��Hgh� khhl\_lkl\m_l� dZdZjoZbq_kdhc� j_]j_kkbb� \ ^mr_\ghf� ZiiZjZl_�� lZd� b lj_[h\Zgbyf� p_gamju�� dh]^Z� ^eybah[jZ`_gby� hij_^_e_gguo� h[t_dlh\� b ijhp_kkh\� \ [hevrhc� f_j_� bkihevamxlky� kbf\heu�klZ\rb_� qm`^ufb� khagZl_evghfm� fure_gbx�� Gh� _s_� ^Zevr_� aZoh^yl� ^jm]b_� baf_g_gby�ij_l_ji_\Z_fu_�we_f_glZfb�fuke_c�kgh\b^_gby��L_�ba�gbo��dhlhju_�fh]ml�gZclb�ohlv�dZdmx�gb[m^v�lhqdm�khijbdhkgh\_gby��k]msZxlky \ gh\u_�_^bgbpu��Ijb�i_j_\h^_�fuke_c�\ h[jZauhl^Z_lky� g_khfg_ggh_� ij_^ihql_gb_� l_f� ba� gbo�� dhlhju_� ih^^Zxlky� lZdhfm� kh_^bg_gbx�k]ms_gbx�� ^_ckl\m_l� dZd� [u� dZdZy�lh� kbeZ�� ih^\_j]ZxsZy� fZl_jbZe� kij_kkh\Zgbx�� k`Zlbx�AZl_f� \ke_^kl\b_� k]ms_gby� dZdhc�lh� we_f_gl� \ y\ghf� kgh\b^_gbb� fh`_l� khhl\_lkl\h\Zlvfgh`_kl\m� we_f_glh\� \ kdjuluo� fukeyo� kgh\b^_gby�� gh� b gZh[hjhl�� dZdhc�gb[m^v� we_f_glfuke_c�kgh\b^_gby�fh`_l�[ulv�ij_^klZ\e_g�g_kdhevdbfb�h[jZaZfb�\ kgh\b^_gbb�?s_� ijbf_qZl_evg__� ^jm]hc� ijhp_kk� kf_s_gby beb� i_j_g_k_gby� Zdp_glZ�� dhlhjuc� \khagZl_evghf� fure_gbb� jZkp_gb\Z_lky� lhevdh� dZd� hrb[dZ� fure_gby� beb� dZd� kj_^kl\hhkljhmfby��>_eh�\ lhf��qlh�hl^_evgu_�ij_^klZ\e_gby�fuke_c�kgh\b^_gby�g_�jZ\ghp_ggu��hgbg_kml� gZ� k_[_� jZaebqgu_� ih� \_ebqbg_� Znn_dlb\gu_� gZ]jmadb� b \� khhl\_lkl\bb� k wlbfhp_gb\Zxlky�dZd�[he__�beb�f_g__�\Z`gu_��^hklhcgu_�\gbfZgby��<h�\j_fy�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gbywlb�ij_^klZ\e_gby�hl^_eyxlky�hl�]hkih^kl\mxsbo�gZ^�gbfb�Znn_dlh\��Znn_dlu�jZa\b\ZxlkykZfb�ih�k_[_��hgb�fh]ml�kf_klblvky�gZ�qlh�lh�^jm]h_��khojZgblvky�\ lhf�`_�\b^_��ij_l_ji_lvbaf_g_gby�� \hh[s_� g_� ihy\blvky� \ kgh\b^_gbb�� <Z`ghklv� hk\h[h`^_gguo� hl� Znn_dlZij_^klZ\e_gbc� \ kgh\b^_gbb� \ujZ`Z_lky� qm\kl\_gghc� kbehc� h[jZah\� kgh\b^_gby�� gh� fuaZf_qZ_f��qlh�wlhl�Zdp_gl�i_j_f_klbeky�kh� agZqbl_evguo� we_f_glh\�gZ�bg^bnn_j_glgu_�� lZdqlh� \ kgh\b^_gbb� \ dZq_kl\_� ]eZ\gh]h� gZ� i_j_^g_f� ieZg_� hdZau\Z_lky� lh�� qlh� \ fukeyokgh\b^_gb_� b]jZ_l� ebrv� ih[hqgmx� jhev�� b�� gZh[hjhl�� kZfh_� kms_kl\_ggh_� ba� fuke_ckgh\b^_gby�gZoh^bl�\ kgh\b^_gbb�lhevdh�ih\_joghklgh_��g_ykgh_�hljZ`_gb_��GbdZdhc�^jm]hcnZdlhj�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gby�g_�kihkh[kl\m_l�klhev�kbevgh�lhfm��qlh[u�k^_eZlv�kgh\b^_gb_�^ey\b^_\r_]h� khg� qm`^uf� b g_ihgylguf�� Kf_s_gb_� y\ey_lky� ]eZ\guf� kj_^kl\hf� bkdZ`_gbykgh\b^_gby� dhlhjhfm�ih^\_j]Zxlky�fukeb�kgh\b^_gby�ih^�\ebygb_f�p_gamju�Ihke_� wlbo� \ha^_ckl\bc� gZ� fukeb� kgh\b^_gby� hgh� ihqlb� ]hlh\h�� Ihke_� lh]h� dZdkgh\b^_gb_� \kieu\Z_l� i_j_^� khagZgb_f� dZd� h[t_dl� \hkijbylby�� ke_^m_l� _s_� h^bg� \_kvfZg_ihklhygguc�fhf_gl�� lZd�gZau\Z_fZy�\lhjbqgZy�h[jZ[hldZ��Lh]^Z�fu�ih^oh^bf�d g_fm� lZd�dZd�fu�\hh[s_�ijb\udeb�ih^oh^blv�d kh^_j`Zgbyf�gZr_]h�\hkijbylby�²�iulZ_fky�aZihegblvijh[_eu��mklZgh\blv�k\yab��^_eZy�ijb� wlhf�^h\hevgh�qZklh� ]jm[u_�hrb[db��Gh� wlZ�\jh^_�[ujZpbhgZebabjmxsZy� ^_yl_evghklv�� ijb^ZxsZy� kgh\b^_gbx� \ emqr_f� kemqZ_� ijb]eZ`_gguc\b^��imklv�b g_�khhl\_lkl\mxsbc�^_ckl\bl_evghfm�_]h�kh^_j`Zgbx��fh`_l�b hlkmlkl\h\Zlv�beb`_�ijhy\blvky� \ hq_gv� kdjhfguo� jZaf_jZo�� ^Z\Zy� kgh\b^_gbx� hldjulh� h[gZjm`blv� \k_� k\hbjZaju\u�b lj_sbgu��K ^jm]hc�klhjhgu��g_�ke_^m_l� aZ[u\Zlv�lZd`_��qlh�b jZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby

Page 267: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijhbkoh^bl� g_� \k_]^Z� h^bgZdh\h� wg_j]bqgh�� ^h\hevgh� qZklh� hgZ� h]jZgbqb\Z_lky� ebrvhij_^_e_ggufb�njZ]f_glZfb�fuke_c�kgh\b^_gby��hklZevgu_�`_�ijhy\eyxlky�\ kgh\b^_gbb�\g_baf_g_gghf� \b^_�� Lh]^Z� kdeZ^u\Z_lky� \i_qZle_gb_�� [m^lh� \ kgh\b^_gbb� dlh�lh� ijh\h^bllhgqZcrb_� b keh`g_crb_� bgl_ee_dlmZevgu_� hi_jZpbb�� jZafurey_l�� rmlbl�� ijbgbfZ_lj_r_gby�� j_rZ_l�ijh[e_fu�� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd� \k_� wlh� y\ey_lky�j_amevlZlhf�gZr_c�ghjfZevghcmfkl\_gghc� ^_yl_evghklb�� dhlhjZy� fh]eZ� ijhbkoh^blv� dZd� ^g_f� gZdZgmg_� kgh\b^_gby�� lZd� bghqvx� b dhlhjZy� g_� bf__l� k jZ[hlhc� kgh\b^_gby� gbq_]h� h[s_]h� b g_� h[gZjm`b\Z_l� gbq_]hoZjZdl_jgh]h�^ey�kgh\b^_gby��G_ebrg_�lZd`_�_s_�jZa�\u^_eblv�ijhlb\hj_qb_��kh^_j`Zs__ky�\kZfbo� fukeyo� kgh\b^_gby�� f_`^m� [_kkhagZl_evguf� \e_q_gb_f� b hklZldZfb� ^g_\guo\i_qZle_gbc�� < lh� \j_fy� dZd� ihke_^gb_� ij_^klZ\eyxl� \k_� fgh]hh[jZab_� gZrbo� ^mr_\guo^\b`_gbc�� i_j\h_�� klZgh\ykv� kh[kl\_ggh� ^\b`ms_c� kbehc� h[jZah\Zgby� kgh\b^_gby�� h[uqghaZ\_jrZ_lky�bkiheg_gb_f�`_eZgby�<k_� wlh� y fh]� [u� kdZaZlv� \Zf� _s_� iylgZ^pZlv� e_l� lhfm� gZaZ^�� b ^mfZx�� qlh� wlh� y^_ckl\bl_evgh� ]h\hjbe��: l_i_jv� ^Z\Zcl_�ih^ulh`bf�� dZdb_�`_� baf_g_gby� b gh\u_� \a]ey^uihy\bebkv�aZ�wlhl�ijhf_`mlhd�\j_f_gb�DZd�y m`_�\Zf�]h\hjbe��y hiZkZeky��dZd�[u�\u�g_�khqeb��qlh�wlh]h�kebrdhf�fZeh��b qlh�\Zf[m^_l�g_ihgylgh��ihq_fm�y aZklZ\be�\Zk�\ukemrZlv�h^gh�b lh�`_�^\Z`^u��Z k_[y�kgh\Z�]h\hjblvh[� wlhf��Gh� \_^v�ijhreh�iylgZ^pZlv� e_l��b y�gZ^_xkv�� qlh� lZdbf� kihkh[hf�fg_� e_]q_� \k_]h[m^_l� \hkklZgh\blv� k \Zfb� dhglZdl�� D lhfm� `_� wlb� lZdb_� we_f_glZjgu_� \_sb� bf_xl� klhevj_rZxs__�agZq_gb_�^ey�ihgbfZgby�ikbohZgZebaZ��qlh�bo�g_iehoh�ihkemrZlv�b \h�\lhjhc�jZa��Zlh�� qlh� hgb� b iylgZ^pZlv� e_l� kimkly� hklZebkv� kh\_jr_ggh� l_fb�`_�� kZfh� ih� k_[_� ^hklhcgh\gbfZgby�< ebl_jZlmj_� wlh]h� \j_f_gb� \u�� _kl_kl\_ggh�� gZc^_l_� fgh`_kl\h� ih^l\_j`^_gbc� b^_lZevguo� baeh`_gbc�� ba� dhlhjuo� y ohqm� ijb\_klb� \Zf� ebrv� g_dhlhju_��Ijb� wlhf� y kfh]mlZd`_�mihfygmlv�dh_�qlh��qlh�m`_�[ueh�ba\_klgh�jZg__��< hkgh\ghf� wlh�dZkZ_lky� kbf\hebdbkgh\b^_gbc�b ijhqbo�bah[jZabl_evguo�kj_^kl\�kgh\b^_gby��<hl�ihkemrZcl_�kh\k_f� g_^Z\gh� f_^bdb� h^gh]h� Zf_jbdZgkdh]h� mgb\_jkbl_lZ� hldZaZeb� ikbohZgZebam� \gZmqghklb�� h[hkgh\u\Zy� wlh� l_f�� qlh� hg�^_� g_� jZkiheZ]Z_l� wdki_jbf_glZevgufb^hdZaZl_evkl\Zfb�� Ih^h[guc� mij_d� hgb� fh]eb� [u� k^_eZlv� b \� Z^j_k� Zkljhghfbb�� \_^vwdki_jbf_glbjh\Zlv� k g_[_kgufb� l_eZfb� hkh[_ggh� aZljm^gbl_evgh�� A^_kv� \k_� hkgh\Zgh� gZgZ[ex^_gbb��B \k_�`_�bf_ggh�\_gkdb_�bkke_^h\Zl_eb�iheh`beb�gZqZeh� wdki_jbf_glZevghfmh[hkgh\Zgbx�kbf\hebdb�gZrbo�kgh\b^_gbc��G_dlh�^�j Rjzll_j�_s_�\ �����]��h[gZjm`be��qlh_keb�ebpZf��gZoh^ysbfky�ih^�]em[hdbf�]bighahf��^Z_lky�aZ^Zgb_�m\b^_lv�\h�kg_�k_dkmZevgu_ijhp_kku�� lh� \ kijh\hpbjh\Zgghf� lZdbf� h[jZahf� kgh\b^_gbb� k_dkmZevguc� fZl_jbZeaZf_sZ_lky�ba\_klgufb�gZf�kbf\heZfb��Ijbf_j��h^ghc�`_gsbg_�[ueh�^Zgh�aZ^Zgb_�m\b^_lv�\hkg_�iheh\u_�kghr_gby�k ih^jm]hc��< __�kgh\b^_gbb�ih^jm]Z�y\beZkv�k ^hjh`ghc�kmfdhc� gZdhlhjhc� [ueZ� ijbde__gZ� aZibkdZ�� ©Lhevdh� ^ey� ^Zfª�� ?s_� [hevr__� \i_qZle_gb_� ijhba\h^ylbkke_^h\Zgby� ;_lev]_cfZ� b =ZjlfZgZ� �������� dhlhju_� gZ[ex^Zeb� aZ� [hevgufb� k lZdgZau\Z_fuf� kbg^jhfhf� DhjkZdh\Z�� Hgb� jZkkdZau\Zeb� bf� bklhjbb� ]jm[h� k_dkmZevgh]hkh^_j`Zgby� b gZ[ex^Zeb� aZ� l_fb� bkdZ`_gbyfb�� dhlhju_� \hagbdZeb� \ hl\_l� gZ� ijhkv[m\hkijhba\_klb�jZkkdZaZggh_��Ijb�wlhf�hiylv�lZdb�ihy\eyebkv�agZdhfu_�gZf�kbf\heu�iheh\uo

Page 268: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hj]Zgh\� b iheh\uo� kghr_gbc�� kj_^b� ijhqbo� kbf\he� e_klgbpu�� ih� ih\h^m� dhlhjh]h� Z\lhjukijZ\_^eb\h�aZf_qZxl��qlh�khagZl_evghfm�`_eZgbx�bkdZ`_gby�hg�[ue�[u�g_^hklmi_g�=�� Abev[_j_j� \ h^ghc� hq_gv� bgl_j_kghc� k_jbb� hiulh\� ������� ������ ihdZaZe�� qlh� jZ[hlZkgh\b^_gby� fh`_l� ijhklh� hr_ehfblv� l_f�� k dZdhc� hq_\b^ghklvx� Z[kljZdlgu_� fukebi_j_\h^ylky�_x�\ ajbl_evgu_�h[jZau��Dh]^Z�hg�\ khklhygbb�mklZehklb�b khgeb\hklb�iulZekyijbgm^blv�k_[y�d mfkl\_gghc�jZ[hl_��fukev�qZklh�mkdhevaZeZ�hl�g_]h��Z \f_klh�g__�ihy\eyehkv\b^_gb_��dhlhjh_�y\gh�[ueh�__�aZf_klbl_e_f�Ijhklhc�ijbf_j��©Y ^mfZx�h lhf�²�]h\hjbl�Abev[_j_j��qlh�fg_�g_h[oh^bfh�bkijZ\blv�\h^ghf�khqbg_gbb�g_m^Z\r__ky�f_klhª��<b^_gb_�©Y \b`m�k_[y�kljh]Zxsbf�dmkhd�^_j_\Zª��< wlbo�bkke_^h\Zgbyo�qZklh�kemqZehkv�lZd��qlhkh^_j`Zgb_f� \b^_gby� klZgh\beZkv� g_� fukev�� gm`^ZxsZyky� \ h[jZ[hld_�� Z _]h� kh[kl\_ggh_km[t_dlb\gh_� khklhygb_� \h� \j_fy� mkbeby�� l�� _�� khklhygb_� \f_klh� ij_^f_lghklb�*HJHQVWDQGOLFKH��� qlh� Abev[_j_j� gZau\Z_l� ©nmgdpbhgZevguf� n_ghf_ghfª��Ijbf_j� kjZam� `_h[tykgbl�\Zf��qlh�bf__lky�\ \b^m��:\lhj�iulZ_lky�kjZ\gblv�lhqdb�aj_gby�^\mo�nbehkhnh\�gZhij_^_e_ggmx�ijh[e_fm��Gh�\ ^j_fhl_�h^gZ�ba�wlbo�lhq_d�aj_gby�\k_�\j_fy�mkdhevaZ_l�hl�g_]h�b gZdhg_p�� \hagbdZ_l� \b^_gb_�� [m^lh� hg� lj_[m_l� hl\_lZ� hl� dZdh]h�lh� m]jxfh]h� k_dj_lZjy�dhlhjuc�� kdehgb\rbkv�gZ^�ibkvf_gguf�klhehf��kgZqZeZ�_]h�g_� aZf_qZ_l��Z aZl_f� kfhljbl�gZg_]h� g_^h\hevgh� b dZd� [u� `_eZy� hl^_eZlvky�� <_jhylgh�� kZfbfb� mkeh\byfb� wdki_jbf_glZh[tykgy_lky� lh� h[klhyl_evkl\h�� qlh� \ua\Zggh_� lZdbf� h[jZahf� \b^_gb_� klhev� qZklh� y\ey_lkyj_amevlZlhf�kZfhgZ[ex^_gby�HklZgh\bfky� _s_� jZa� gZ� kbf\heZo�� ;ueb� kj_^b� gbo� lZdb_�� dhlhju_� fu�� dZaZehkv�jZkihagZeb��gh�\ dhlhjuo�gZk�\k_�lZdb�kfmsZeh�lh��qlh�fu�g_�fh]eb�h[tykgblv��dZdbf�h[jZahfwlhl kbf\he� ijbh[j_e� wlh� agZq_gb_��< ih^h[guo� kemqZyo� hkh[_ggh�`_eZl_evgufb� ^ey� gZk[ueb�ih^l\_j`^_gby�ba�^jm]bo�bklhqgbdh\��ba�yaudhagZgby��nhevdehjZ��fbnheh]bb��jblmZeh\�Ijbf_jhf� lZdh]h�jh^Z�[ue� kbf\he�iZevlh��Fu� ]h\hjbeb��qlh�\ kgh\b^_gbb�h^ghc�`_gsbguiZevlh�hagZqZeh�fm`qbgm��GZ^_xkv��gZ�\Zk�ijhba\_^_l�\i_qZle_gb_��_keb�y kdZ`m��qlh�L��J_cd�\�����]��ibkZe��©< h^ghc�hq_gv�^j_\g_c�[jZqghc�p_j_fhgbb�[_^mbgh\�`_gbo�gZdju\Z_l�g_\_klmhkh[uf�ieZshf��gZau\Z_fuf�ÄZ[Z���b ijhbaghkbl�ijb�wlhf�jblmZevgu_�keh\Z��ÄHlgug_�gbdlhg_� ^he`_g� ihdju\Zlv� L_[y�� djhf_� f_gy�ª� �pbl�� ih� Jh[_jlm� Wcke_jm�� Fbjh\hc� ihdjh\� bg_[_kguc�dmihe�>����@���Fu�gZreb�_s_�g_kdhevdh�gh\uo�kbf\heh\��b y�ohqm�khh[sblv�\Zf��ihdjZcg_c�f_j_��h ^\mo�ba�gbo��Ih�:[jZoZfm� ��������ijyedZ�\ kgh\b^_gbb�²�kbf\he�fZl_jb��ghnZeebq_kdhc� fZl_jb�� dhlhjhc� [hbrvky�� lZd� qlh� kljZo� i_j_^� ijyedhc� \ujZ`Z_l� m`Zk� i_j_^bgp_klhf�ih�hlghr_gbx�d fZl_jb�b hl\jZs_gb_�d `_gkdhfm�iheh\hfm�hj]Zgm��<u��\hafh`gh�agZ_l_�� qlh�fbnheh]bq_kdbc� h[jZa� ]heh\u�F_^mau� \hkoh^bl� d lhfm�`_�fhlb\m� kljZoZ� i_j_^dZkljZpb_c��>jm]hc�kbf\he��h dhlhjhf�fg_�ohl_ehkv�[u�\Zf�kdZaZlv��wlh�kbf\he�fhklZ��N_j_gpbb h[tykgbe�_]h�\ ����²�����l]��I_j\hgZqZevgh�hg�hagZqZe�fm`kdhc�qe_g��dhlhjuc�kh_^bgy_ljh^bl_e_c�ijb�iheh\uo�kghr_gbyo��gh�aZl_f�hg�ijbgye�b ^jm]b_�agZq_gby��dhlhju_�\u\h^ylkyba� i_j\h]h��Ihkdhevdm� fm`kdhfm� qe_gm� fu� h[yaZgu� l_f�� qlh� \hh[s_� ihy\bebkv� gZ� k\_l� bajh^h\hc�`b^dhklb��lh�fhkl�y\ey_lky�i_j_oh^hf�ba�ihlmklhjhgg_]h�fbjZ��ba�[ulby�^h�jh`^_gby�fZl_jbgkdh]h� ehgZ�� \ wlhl� fbj� �`bagv��� Z lZd� dZd� q_eh\_dm� b kf_jlv� ij_^klZ\ey_lky� dZd\ha\jZs_gb_�\ fZl_jbgkdh_�ehgh��\h^m���lh�fhkl�ijbh[j_lZ_l�agZq_gb_�ijb[eb`_gby�d kf_jlb�

Page 269: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

b gZdhg_p�� ijb� _s_� [hevr_f� hl^Ze_gbb� hl� i_j\hgZqZevgh]h� kfukeZ�� hg� hagZqZ_l� i_j_oh^�baf_g_gb_�khklhygby�\hh[s_��Ihwlhfm�ihgylgh��qlh�`_gsbgZ��g_�ij_h^he_\rZy�`_eZgby�[ulvfm`qbghc��qZklh�\b^bl�\h�kg_�fhklu��kebrdhf�dhjhldb_��qlh[u�^hklbqv�^jm]h]h�[_j_]Z�< y\ghf� kh^_j`Zgbb� kgh\b^_gbc� ^h\hevgh� qZklh� \klj_qZxlky� h[jZau� b kblmZpbb�gZihfbgZxsb_� ba\_klgu_� fhlb\u� kdZahd�� e_]_g^� b fbnh\�� Lhedh\Zgb_� lZdbo� kgh\b^_gbcijheb\Z_l� k\_l� gZ� i_j\hgZqZevgu_� bgl_j_ku�� kha^Z\rb_� wlb� fhlb\u�� ohly� fu�� dhg_qgh�� g_^he`gu�aZ[u\Zlv�h[�baf_g_gbb�agZq_gbc��dhlhjh_�wlhl�fZl_jbZe�ij_l_ji_e�kh�\j_f_g_f��GZrZjZ[hlZ�ih�lhedh\Zgbx�kgh\b^_gbc�hldju\Z_l��lZd�kdZaZlv��bkoh^gh_�kujv_��dhlhjh_�^h\hevghqZklh�fh`gh�gZa\Zlv�k_dkmZevguf�\ kZfhf�rbjhdhf�kfuke_�keh\Z��gh�dhlhjh_�ijb�^Zevg_cr_ch[jZ[hld_�gZoh^bl�kZfh_�jZaghh[jZagh_�bkihevah\Zgb_��Ih^h[gu_�\ha\jZs_gby�gZaZ^�h[uqghgZ\e_dZxl�gZ�gZk�]g_\�\k_o�g_�ZgZeblbq_kdb�gZkljh_gguo�bkke_^h\Zl_e_c��dZd�[m^lh�\k_��qlhgZ^kljZb\Z_lky�\ oh^_�^Zevg_cr_]h�jZa\blby��fu�hljbpZ_f�beb�g_^hhp_gb\Z_f��L_f�g_�f_g__lZdb_� \a]ey^u� ihmqbl_evgu� b bgl_j_kgu�� Wlh� `_� hlghkblky� d ijhbkoh`^_gbx� g_dhlhjuofhlb\h\�bah[jZabl_evgh]h�bkdmkkl\Z��GZijbf_j��>`��Wcke_j���������jZa[bjZy�kgh\b^_gby�k\hboiZpb_glh\�� lZd� ZgZeblbq_kdb�bklhedh\Ze�xghrm��b]jZxs_]h� k fZevqbdhf�� dZd� wlh�bah[jZabeIjZdkbl_ev�\ k\h_f�=_jf_k_��B _s_�h^gh�lhevdh�keh\h��y ijhklh�g_�fh]m�g_�mihfygmlv�h lhf�dZd� qZklh�bf_ggh�fbnheh]bq_kdb_� l_fu� gZoh^yl� k\h_� h[tykg_gb_� \ lhedh\Zgbb� kgh\b^_gbc�LZd�� gZijbf_j�� \ e_]_g^_� h eZ[bjbgl_� jZkihagZ_lky� bah[jZ`_gb_� ZgZevgh]h� jh`^_gby�aZimlZggu_�oh^u�²�wlh�dbrdb��gblv�:jbZ^gu�²�imih\bgZ�Kihkh[u�bah[jZ`_gby�ijb�jZ[hl_�kgh\b^_gby��ijb\e_dZl_evguc�b ihqlb�g_bkq_jiZ_fucfZl_jbZe��[eZ]h^Zjy�ih^jh[ghfm�bamq_gbx� klZgh\blky�gZf� \k_��ª�ihgylg__�� y ohqm�ijb\_klb\Zf� g_dhlhju_� ijbf_ju� ba� wlhc� h[eZklb�� LZd�� gZijbf_j�� qZklhlgh_� hlghr_gb_� kgh\b^_gb_bah[jZ`Z_l� q_j_a� fgh`_kl\_gghklv� h^ghjh^gh]h�� IhkemrZcl_� kljZggh_� kgh\b^_gb_� h^ghcfheh^hc�^_\mrdb��hgZ�\oh^bl�\ [hevrhc� aZe�b \b^bl�\ g_f�dZdh]h�lh�q_eh\_dZ�� kb^ys_]h�gZklme_�� h[jZa� ih\lhjy_lky�r_klv�� \hk_fv� b [he__� jZa�� gh� dZ`^uc� jZa� wlh� __ hl_p�� <k_� e_]dhh[tykgy_lky�� dh]^Z� ba� ih[hqguo� h[klhyl_evkl\� lhedh\Zgby� fu� magZ_f�� qlh� wlh� ihf_s_gb_bah[jZ`Z_l�fZl_jbgkdh_�ehgh��Lh]^Z�kgh\b^_gb_�klZgh\blky�jZ\ghagZqguf�ohjhrh�ba\_klghcgZf�nZglZabb�^_\mrdb��dhlhjhc�dZ`_lky��qlh�m`_�\h�\gmljbmljh[ghc�`bagb�hgZ�\klj_qZeZkv�khlphf��dh]^Z�hg�\h�\j_fy�[_j_f_gghklb�ihy\eyeky�\ fZl_jbgkdhf�ehg_��Lh��qlh�\ kgh\b^_gbbdh_�qlh� gZh[hjhl� ²� ihy\e_gb_� hlpZ� i_j_g_k_gh� gZ� kh[kl\_ggmx� i_jkhgm�²� g_� ^he`gh� \Zk\\h^blv� \ aZ[em`^_gb_�� wlh� bf__l�� \ijhq_f�� _s_� k\h_� hkh[h_� agZq_gb_�� Fgh`_kl\_gghklvi_jkhgu� hlpZ� fh`_l� \ujZ`Zlv� lhevdh� lh�� qlh� khhl\_lkl\mxsbc� ijhp_kk� g_h^ghdjZlghih\lhjyeky�� Kh[kl\_ggh�� fu� ^he`gu� lZd`_� ijbagZlv�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_� g_� lZd� m`� kbevgh\hevgbqZ_l�� \ujZ`Zy� qZklhlm �+DXILJNHLW� q_j_a� gZ]jhfh`^_gb_� �+DXIXQJ�� < g_f� lhevdhbkihevam_lky�i_j\hgZqZevgh_�agZq_gb_�keh\Z��dhlhjh_�k_]h^gy�h[hagZqZ_l�^ey�gZk�ih\lhj_gb_\h�\j_f_gb��gh�ijhbkoh^bl�hl�gZdhie_gby�\ ijhkljZgkl\_��H^gZdh�jZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby�\hh[s_i_j_\h^bl�� ]^_� wlh� \hafh`gh�� \j_f_ggu_� hlghr_gby� \ ijhkljZgkl\_ggu_� b bah[jZ`Z_l� bo� \\b^_� lZdh\uo�� >himklbf�� \b^_gb_� \ kgh\b^_gbb� kp_gu� f_`^m� ebpZfb�� dZ`msbfbky� hq_gvfZe_gvdbfb�b m^Ze_ggufb��dZd�_keb�[u�kfhlj_e�\ i_j_\_jgmluc�[bghdev��FZehklv�lZd�`_��dZdb ijhkljZgkl\_ggZy� m^Ze_gghklv�� hagZqZxl� a^_kv� h^gh� b lh� `_�� Z bf_ggh�hl^Ze_gghklv� \h\j_f_gb��wlh�ke_^m_l�ihgbfZlv�dZd�kp_gm�ba�^Z\gh�fbgm\r_]h�ijhreh]h��>Ze__��fh`_l�[ulv��\uihfgbl_��qlh�y m`_�]h\hjbe�

Page 270: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\Zf�\ ij_^u^msbo�e_dpbyo�b ihdZau\Ze�gZ�ijbf_jZo��dZd�fu�gZmqbebkv�bkihevah\Zlv�^eylhedh\Zgby�b qbklh�nhjfZevgu_�q_jlu�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby��l��_��i_j_\h^blv�\ kh^_j`Zgb_�dh_�qlh� ba� kdjuluo� fuke_c� kgh\b^_gby�� L_i_jv� \u� agZ_l_�� qlh� \k_� kgh\b^_gby� h^ghc� ghqbgZoh^ylky�\ h^ghc�b lhc�`_�k\yab��Gh�^Ze_dh�g_�[_ajZaebqgh��y\eyxlky�eb�wlb�kgh\b^_gby�^ey\b^ys_]h�khg�_^bguf�p_euf��beb�hg�jZkqe_gy_l�bo�gZ�g_kdhevdh�hlju\dh\��b _keb�^Z�� lh�gZkdhevdh�� QZklh� qbkeh� wlbo� hlju\dh\� khhl\_lkl\m_l� lZdhfm� `_� dhebq_kl\m� h[hkh[e_gguop_gljh\� h[jZah\Zgby� fuke_c� \ kdjuluo� fukeyo� kgh\b^_gby� beb� [hjxsboky� f_`^m� kh[hcihlhdh\�\ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb�\b^ys_]h� khg��ba�dhlhjuo� dZ`^uc�gZoh^bl� k\h_�ij_h[eZ^Zxs__�ohly� b g_� _^bgkl\_ggh_� \ujZ`_gb_� \ dZdhf�lh� hkh[hf� hlju\d_� kgh\b^_gby�� Dhjhldh_ij_^kgh\b^_gb_�b ^ebl_evgh_�hkgh\gh_�kgh\b^_gb_�qZklh�gZoh^ylky�^jm]�d ^jm]m�\ hlghr_gbbmkeh\by� b bkiheg_gby�� q_fm� \u� fh`_l_� gZclb� \_kvfZ� ykguc� ijbf_j� \ ij_`gbo� e_dpbyo�Kgh\b^_gb_��dhlhjh_�\b^_\rbc�khg�bah[jZ`Z_l�dZd�[u�\klZ\dhc��^_ckl\bl_evgh�khhl\_lkl\m_l\lhjhkl_i_gghfm� \ fukeyo� kgh\b^_gby�� NjZgp� :e_dkZg^_j� ������� \ h^ghf� bkke_^h\ZgbbiZjguo�kgh\b^_gbc�ihdZaZe��qlh�kgh\b^_gby�h^ghc�ghqb�g_j_^dh�jZa^_eyxl�\uiheg_gb_�aZ^Zqbkgh\b^_gby�lZdbf�h[jZahf��qlh��\f_kl_�\aylu_��hgb�hkms_kl\eyxl�bkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby�\ ^\ZwlZiZ�� q_]h� g_� fh`_l� k^_eZlv� dZ`^h_�kgh\b^_gb_� \ hl^_evghklb�� ?keb� `_eZgb_� kgh\b^_gbykh^_j`bl�aZij_lgh_�^_ckl\b_�ih�hlghr_gbx�d hij_^_e_gghfm�ebpm��lh�wlh�ebph�ihy\ey_lky�\i_j\hf� kgh\b^_gbb� hldjulh�� ^_ckl\b_�`_� ^Z_lky� ebrv� jh[dbf� gZf_dhf��<lhjh_� kgh\b^_gb_^_eZ_l� aZl_f� bgZq_�� >_ckl\b_� gZau\Z_lky� \ g_f� hldjulh�� h^gZdh� ebph� baf_g_gh� ^hg_magZ\Z_fhklb�beb� aZf_g_gh�bg^bnn_j_glguf��>_ckl\bl_evgh�� wlh� ijhba\h^bl� \i_qZle_gb_obljhklb��<lhjh_�ih^h[gh_�`_�hlghr_gb_�f_`^m�h[_bfb�qZklyfb�iZjgh]h�kgh\b^_gby�lZdh\h�qlh� h^gZ� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� gZdZaZgb_�� Z ^jm]Zy� ²� bkiheg_gb_� ihjhqgh]h� `_eZgby�IhemqZ_lky�dZd�[u�ke_^mxs__��_keb�ijbgbfZ_lky�gZdZaZgb_��lh�aZij_s_ggh_�iha\hey_lky�G_� fh]m� [hevr_� aZ^_j`b\Zlv� \Zk� gZ� ih^h[guo� fZe_gvdbo� hldjulbyo�� jZ\gh� dZd� b gZ^bkdmkkbyo��hlghkysboky�d bkihevah\Zgbx�lhedh\Zgby�kgh\b^_gbc�\ ZgZeblbq_kdhc�ijZdlbd_�>mfZx��qlh�\Zf�g_�l_jiblky�mkeurZlv��dZdb_�`_�baf_g_gby�ijhbahreb�\ hkgh\guo�\a]ey^Zo�gZkmsghklv�b agZq_gb_�kgh\b^_gby��<u�m`_�ih^]hlh\e_gu�d lhfm��qlh�bf_ggh�h[�wlhf�fZeh�qlhfh`gh� khh[sblv�� <_^v� kZfuf� kihjguf� fhf_glhf� \k_c� l_hjbb� [ueh� ml\_j`^_gb_�� qlh� \k_kgh\b^_gby�y\eyxlky�hkms_kl\e_gb_f�`_eZgby��K g_ba[_`guf��\gh\v�b \gh\v�ih\lhjyxsbfky\hajZ`_gb_f� g_ijhn_kkbhgZeh\�� qlh� \_^v� lZd� fgh]h� kljZrguo� kgh\b^_gbc�� fu�� gZ^_xkv�ihdhgqbeb� \ ij_^u^msbo� e_dpbyo�� K jZa^_e_gb_f� bo� gZ� kgh\b^_gby� `_eZgby�� kljZrgu_kgh\b^_gby�b kgh\b^_gby�gZdZaZgby�fu�©hojZgbeb�gZrm�l_hjbx�\ kbe_�Kgh\b^_gby� gZdZaZgby� lh`_� y\eyxlky� bkiheg_gb_f� `_eZgbc�� gh� g_� \e_q_gbc�� Zdjblbdmxs_c��p_gamjbjmxs_c�b gZdZamxs_c�bgklZgpbb� \ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb��?keb�fu�bf__f^_eh�k qbkluf�kgh\b^_gb_f�gZdZaZgby��lh�gZf�\iheg_�^hklmigZ�ijhklZy�fukebl_evgZy�hi_jZpbyih� \hkklZgh\e_gbx� kgh\b^_gby� `_eZgby�� ih� hlghr_gbx� d dhlhjhfm� kgh\b^_gb_� gZdZaZgbyy\ey_lky�bklbgguf�\hajZ`_gb_f��b dhlhjh_�wlbf�hldZahf�b�[ueh�aZf_s_gh�\ y\ghf�kgh\b^_gbb��<u�agZ_l_��m\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��qlh�bamq_gb_kgh\b^_gbc� kgZqZeZ� ihfh]eh� gZf� ihgylv� g_\jhau�� <u� gZc^_l_� lZd`_� ihgylguf�� qlh� gZrbagZgby�h g_\jhaZo�\ihke_^kl\bb�kfh]eb�hdZaZlv�\ebygb_�gZ�gZr_�ij_^klZ\e_gb_�h kgh\b^_gbb�DZd�\u�magZ_l_��fu�\ugm`^_gu�[ueb�ij_^iheh`blv�kms_kl\h\Zgb_�\ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb�hkh[hc

Page 271: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

djblbdmxs_c� b aZij_sZxs_c� bgklZgpbb�� dhlhjmx� fu� gZau\Z_f� K\_jo�Y��IjbagZ\� p_gamjmkgh\b^_gby� lZd`_� j_amevlZlhf� jZ[hlu� wlhc� bgklZgpbb�� fu� l_f� kZfuf� \ugm`^_gu� [he__lsZl_evgh�jZkkfhlj_lv�mqZklb_�K\_jo�Y \�h[jZah\Zgbb�kgh\b^_gby�Ijhlb\� l_hjbb� bkiheg_gby� `_eZgby� \ kgh\b^_gbb� \hagbdeh� ebrv� ^\Z� k_jv_aguo\hajZ`_gby�� jZkkfhlj_gb_� dhlhjuo� m\h^bl� kebrdhf� ^Ze_dh�� g_� ^Z\Zy�� \ijhq_f�� \iheg_m^h\e_l\hjbl_evgh]h�hl\_lZ��I_j\h_�\hajZ`_gb_�hibjZ_lky�gZ�nZdl��kh]eZkgh�dhlhjhfm�ebpZ�i_j_`b\rb_� rhd�� ly`_emx� ikbobq_kdmx� ljZ\fm�� qZklh� kemqZ\rb_ky� \h� \j_fy� \hcgu� be_`Z\rb_� \ hkgh\_� ljZ\fZlbq_kdhc� bkl_jbb�� \ kgh\b^_gbyo� ihklhyggh� \ha\jZsZxlky� \ljZ\fZlbq_kdmx�kblmZpbx��Kh]eZkgh�`_�gZrbf�ij_^iheh`_gbyf�h nmgdpbb�kgh\b^_gby�wlh]h[ulv� g_� ^he`gh�� DZdh_� \i_qZle_gb_� fh]eh� [u� m^h\e_l\hjblvky� wlbf� \ha\jZlhf� d \ukr_ckl_i_gb�g_ijbylghfm�ljZ\fZlbq_kdhfm�i_j_`b\Zgbx"�>h]Z^Zlvky�ljm^gh��Kh�\lhjuf�nZdlhffu� ihqlb� _`_^g_\gh� klZedb\Z_fky� \ ZgZeblbq_kdhc� jZ[hl_�� hg� lh`_� g_� y\ey_lky� lZdbf� m`\_khfuf� \hajZ`_gb_f�� dZd� b i_j\uc��<u� agZ_l_�� qlh� h^ghc� ba� aZ^Zq� ikbohZgZebaZ� y\ey_lkyijhgbdgh\_gb_� \ lZcgm� Zfg_abb�� dhlhjhc� ihdjulu� i_j\u_� ^_lkdb_� ]h^u�� b ^h\_^_gb_� ^hkhagZl_evgh]h� \hkihfbgZgby� kh^_j`Zsboky� \ gbo� ijhy\e_gbc� jZgg_c� ^_lkdhc� k_dkmZevghc`bagb��Wlb�i_j\u_�k_dkmZevgu_�i_j_`b\Zgby�j_[_gdZ�k\yaZgu�k fmqbl_evgufb�\i_qZle_gbyfbkljZoZ��aZij_lZ��jZahqZjh\Zgby�b gZdZaZgby��ihgylgh��qlh�hgb�\ul_kg_gu��gh�lh]^Z�g_ihgylghlh��qlh�hgb�bf_xl� lZdhc�rbjhdbc�^hklmi� d `bagb� kgh\b^_gbc�� qlh� hgb�^Zxl�h[jZapu� klhevfgh]bf�nZglZabyf�kgh\b^_gby��qlh�kgh\b^_gby�ihegu�j_ijh^mdpbc�wlbo�bgnZglbevguo�kp_g�bgZf_dh\� gZ� gbo�� H^gZdh� bo� g_`_eZl_evguc� oZjZdl_j� b l_g^_gpby� jZ[hlu� kgh\b^_gby� dbkiheg_gbx� `_eZgbc�� \b^bfh�� iehoh� khq_lZxlky� ^jm]� k ^jm]hf�� Gh� \hafh`gh�� fuij_m\_ebqb\Z_f�\ wlhf�kemqZ_�ljm^ghklb��GZ�l_�`_�^_lkdb_�i_j_`b\Zgby�gZkeZb\Zxlky�\_^v�\k_ihklhyggu_�� g_bkiheg_ggu_�`_eZgby�� dhlhju_� ^Zxl� wg_j]bx� ^ey� h[jZah\Zgby� kgh\b^_gbc� \l_q_gb_�\k_c�`bagb�b hl�dhlhjuo�fh`gh�h`b^Zlv��qlh�k\hbf�fh]mqbf�ihju\hf�hgb�kihkh[gu\ug_klb�gZ�ih\_joghklv�b h[klhyl_evkl\Z��\hkijbgbfZ\rb_ky�kh�klu^hf��: k�^jm]hc�klhjhgu��\kihkh[_�j_ijh^mdpbb�wlh]h�fZl_jbZeZ�g_khfg_ggh�\ujZ`Z_lky�klj_fe_gb_�jZ[hlu�kgh\b^_gbyaZfZkdbjh\Zlv� g_m^h\hevkl\b_� bkdZ`_gb_f�� ij_\jZlblv� jZahqZjh\Zgb_� \ bkiheg_gb_�� IjbljZ\fZlbq_kdbo� g_\jhaZo� \k_� h[klhbl� ih�^jm]hfm�� a^_kv� kgh\b^_gby� ihklhyggh� ijb\h^yl� dkljZom��Y iheZ]Zx��qlh�fu�g_�^he`gu�[hylvky�ijbagZlv��qlh�\ wlhf�kemqZ_�nmgdpby�kgh\b^_gbyg_� kjZ[Zlu\Z_l�� Y g_� ohqm� kkueZlvky� gZ� lh�� qlh� bkdexq_gb_� ih^l\_j`^Z_l� ijZ\beh�� wlZfm^jhklv�dZ`_lky�fg_�\_kvfZ�khfgbl_evghc��H^gZdh�bkdexq_gb_�b g_�hlf_gy_l�ijZ\beZ��?keblZdmx�hl^_evgmx�ikbobq_kdmx�^_yl_evghklv��dZd�\b^_gb_�kgh\��\ p_eyo�bamq_gby�\u^_eblv�bah[s_]h�f_oZgbafZ��lh��\hafh`gh��wlh�b iha\hebl�\kdjulv�ijbkmsb_�_c� aZdhghf_jghklb��_keb`_�__ hiylv�\dexqblv�\ h[smx�kljmdlmjm��lh�gm`gh�[ulv�]hlh\uf�d lhfm���qlh�wlb�j_amevlZlu�klZedb\Zykv�k ^jm]bfb�kbeZfb��aZlmrmxlky�beb�klZgml�f_g__�agZqbl_evgufb��Fu�]h\hjbf��qlhkgh\b^_gb_�_klv�bkiheg_gb_�`_eZgby��_keb�ijbgylv�\h�\gbfZgb_�ihke_^gb_�\hajZ`_gby��lh�\k_�lZdb�ke_^m_l�kdZaZlv��qlh�kgh\b^_gb_�y\ey_lky�ihiuldhc bkiheg_gby�`_eZgby��Gb�^ey�dh]h��dlhfh`_l�m]em[blvky�\ ikbobq_kdmx�^bgZfbdm��\u�g_�kdZ`_l_�gbq_]h�^jm]h]h��Ijb�hij_^_e_gguoh[klhyl_evkl\Zo� kgh\b^_gb_�fh`_l� hkms_kl\blv� k\h_� gZf_j_gb_� eb[h� hq_gv� g_kh\_jr_ggufh[jZahf�� eb[h�hgh�^he`gh� \hh[s_� hl�g_]h�hldZaZlvky�� \b^bfh��[_kkhagZl_evgZy�nbdkZpby�gZljZ\f_� ijb� wlbo� kju\Zo� \uiheg_gby�nmgdpbb� kgh\b^_gby� h^_j`b\Z_l� \_jo��< lh� \j_fy� dZdkiysbc� ^he`_g� \b^_lv� khg�� ihlhfm� qlh� ghqgh_� hkeZ[e_gb_� \ul_kg_gby� iha\hey_l

Page 272: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Zdlb\babjh\Zlvky� klj_fe_gbx� d ljZ\fZlbq_kdhc� nbdkZpbb�� _]h� jZ[hlZ� kgh\b^_gby�� dhlhjZy`_eZeZ�[u�ij_\jZlblv�ke_^u�\hkihfbgZgbc�h ljZ\fZlbq_kdhc�kblmZpbb�\ bkiheg_gb_�dZdh]h�gb[m^v�`_eZgby��hklZ_lky�[_aj_amevlZlghc��< lZdbo�kemqZyo�fh`_l�gZklmiblv�[_kkhggbpZ��ba�aZkljZoZ� i_j_^� g_m^Zq_c� ^_ckl\by� kgh\b^_gby� q_eh\_d� hldZau\Z_lky� hl� kgZ�� LjZ\fZlbq_kdbcg_\jha�^_fhgkljbjm_l�gZf�a^_kv�djZcgbc�kemqZc��gh�ljZ\fZlbq_kdbc�oZjZdl_j�ke_^m_l�ijbagZlvb aZ� ^_lkdbfb� i_j_`b\Zgbyfb�� lZd� qlh� g_� ke_^m_l� m^b\eylvky�� _keb� f_g__� agZqbl_evgu_gZjmr_gby�nmgdpbb�kgh\b^_gby�ijhy\eyxlky�b \�^jm]bo�mkeh\byo�LJB>P:L:Y�E?DPBYKgh\b^_gb_�b hddmevlbafM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��K_]h^gy�fu�\klmiZ_f�gZ�madmx�ljhim���gh�hgZ�fh`_l�hldjulvi_j_^�gZfb�rbjhdmx�i_jki_dlb\m�AZy\e_gb_�h lhf��qlh�y [m^m�]h\hjblv�h[�hlghr_gbb�kgh\b^_gby�d hddmevlbafm��\jy^�eb�\Zkm^b\bl��<_^v� kgh\b^_gb_�� qZklh� jZkkfZljb\Z\r__ky� dZd� \hjhlZ� \ fbj� fbklbdb�� _s_� k_]h^gyfgh]bfb� ijbgbfZ_lky� aZ� hddmevlguc� n_ghf_g�� B fu�� k^_eZ\� _]h� h[t_dlhf� gZmqgh]hbkke_^h\Zgby��g_�hkiZjb\Z_f��qlh�h^gZ�beb�g_kdhevdh�gbl_c�k\yau\Zxl�_]h�k wlbfb�l_fgufb\_sZfb��FbklbdZ�� hddmevlbaf� ²� qlh� ih^jZamf_\Z_lky� ih^� wlbfb� gZa\Zgbyfb"�G_�`^bl_� hlf_gy�ihiuldb�^Zlv� hij_^_e_gby� wlbf� h[eZklyf��ij_^_eu� dhlhjuo� mklZgh\e_gu�g_lhqgh��Fu\k_�� \ h[s_f�� ijbf_jgh� agZ_f�� qlh� ih^jZamf_\Z_lky� ih^� wlbf��Wlh�²� k\h_]h� jh^Z� h[jZlgZyklhjhgZ�k\_leh]h��mijZ\ey_fh]h�g_mfhebfufb�aZdhgZfb�fbjZª�dhlhjuc�kha^ZeZ�^ey�gZk�gZmdZ�Hddmevlbaf� ml\_j`^Z_l� j_Zevgh_� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� l_o� ©\_s_c� f_`� g_[hf� b a_fe_c�� hdhlhjuo� gZrZ� rdhevgZy� ij_fm^jhklv� g_� kf__l� b ihfukeblvª�� Gh� fu� g_� ohlbf� rdhevghch]jZgbq_gghklb�� fu� ]hlh\u� ih\_jblv� lhfm�� qlh� ^hklhcgh� \_ju��Fu� gZf_j_gu� ihklmiblv� kwlbfb�\_sZfb�lZd�`_��dZd�k ex[uf�^jm]bf�fZl_jbZehf�gZmdb��mklZgh\blv�kgZqZeZ��y\eyxlky�eblZdb_� ijhp_kku� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� ^hdZam_fufb�� Z lh]^Z� b lhevdh� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� bo� hq_\b^ghklv[m^_l�g_khfg_ggZ��ihiulZ_fky�bo�h[tykgblv��Gh�g_�ke_^m_l�hljbpZlv��qlh�b wlh�j_r_gb_�gZfljm^gh� ijbgylv� ih� khh[jZ`_gbyf� bgl_ee_dlmZevgh]h�� ikboheh]bq_kdh]h� b bklhjbq_kdh]hihjy^dZ��Wlhl�kemqZc�lj_[m_l�kh\_jr_ggh�bgh]h�ih^oh^Z��g_`_eb�^jm]b_�bkke_^h\Zgby�KgZqZeZ� ljm^ghklb� bgl_ee_dlmZevgu_�� JZaj_rbl_� ^Zlv� kZfu_� h[sb_� jZatykg_gby�Ij_^iheh`bf��qlh�j_qv�b^_l�h khklZ\_�g_^j�a_feb��DZd�ba\_klgh��fu�g_�agZ_f�h[�wlhf�gbq_]hhij_^_e_ggh]h�� Fu� ij_^iheZ]Z_f�� qlh� lZf� gZoh^ylky� ly`_eu_� f_lZeeu� \ jZkdZe_gghfkhklhygbb��>himklbf�� qlh� dlh�lh� \u^\b]Z_l� ml\_j`^_gb_�� qlh�g_^jZ� a_feb� aZiheg_gu� \h^hc�gZkus_gghc�m]e_dbkehlhc��lbiZ�kh^h\hc��Fu��dhg_qgh��kdZ`_f��qlh�wlh�\_kvfZ�fZeh\_jhylgh�ijhlb\hj_qbl� \k_f� gZrbf� h`b^Zgbyf�� g_� mqblu\Z_l� hlijZ\guo� lhq_d� gZr_]h� ihagZgby�dhlhju_� ijb\_eb� gZk� d \u^\b`_gbx� ]bihl_au� f_lZeeh\�� H^gZdh� hgh� \k_�lZdb� g_� y\ey_lkyg_fukebfuf��_keb�dlh�lh�mdZ`_l�gZf�imlv�d ijh\_jd_�]bihl_au�kh^h\hc�\h^u��fu�ihke_^m_f_fm�[_a�\hajZ`_gbc��Gh�\hl�ihy\ey_lky�^jm]hc�b \k_jv_a�ml\_j`^Z_l��qlh�y^jh�a_feb�khklhbl�bafZjf_eZ^Z��D wlhfm�fu�hlg_k_fky�kh\k_f�bgZq_��Fu�kdZ`_f�k_[_��qlh�fZjf_eZ^�\ ijbjh^_�g_\klj_qZ_lky�� hg� y\ey_lky� ijh^mdlhf� q_eh\_q_kdhc� dmogb�� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� wlh]h� ij_^f_lZ

Page 273: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ij_^iheZ]Z_l��djhf_�lh]h��gZebqb_�njmdlh\uo�^_j_\v_\�b bo�ieh^h\��Z fu�g_�agZ_f��fh`gh�ebnehjm� b ih\Zjkdh_� bkdmkkl\h� q_eh\_dZ� i_j_g_klb� \ g_^jZ� a_feb�� \ j_amevlZl_� wlbobgl_ee_dlmZevguo�\hajZ`_gbc�gZr�bgl_j_k�[m^_l�gZijZ\e_g�\ ^jm]mx�klhjhgm��b \f_klh�lh]h�qlh[u� ijbklmiblv� d bkke_^h\Zgbx�� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� eb� y^jh� a_feb� khklhbl� ba�fZjf_eZ^Z�� fukijhkbf�k_[y��Z qlh�wlh�aZ�q_eh\_d��dhlhjuc�fh]�ijbclb�d lZdhc�b^__��beb��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_�kijhkbf� _]h�� hldm^Z� hg� wlh� agZ_l�� G_kqZklguc� Z\lhj� fZjf_eZ^ghc� l_hjbb� [m^_l� ]em[hdhhkdhj[e_g� b h[\bgbl� gZk� \ lhf�� qlh� fu� hldZau\Z_f� _fm� \ h[t_dlb\ghf� ijbagZgbb� _]hml\_j`^_gby� \ke_^kl\b_� ydh[u� gZmqgh]h� ij_^m[_`^_gby�� Gh� wlh� _fm� gbq_]h� g_� ^Zkl�� Fuqm\kl\m_f�� qlh� ij_^m[_`^_gby� g_� \k_]^Z� ij_^hkm^bl_evgu�� qlh� bgh]^Z� hgb� hijZ\^Zggu� bp_e_khh[jZagu�� lZd� dZd� ba[Z\eyxl� gZk� hl� [_kihe_aghc� ljZlu� kbe�� <_^v� hgb� \k_]h� ebrvaZdexq_gby��ZgZeh]bqgu_�^jm]bf��ohjhrh�h[hkgh\Zgguf�km`^_gbyf�P_euc�jy^�hddmevlguo�ml\_j`^_gbc�^_ckl\m_l�gZ�gZk�ih^h[gh�fZjf_eZ^ghc�]bihl_a_��lZdqlh�fu� kqblZ_f� k_[y� \ijZ\_� hl\_j]gmlv� bo� kjZam�`_�� g_� ih^\_j]Zy� ijh\_jd_��Gh� \k_� g_� lZdijhklh��KjZ\g_gb_�� ih^h[gh_� lhfm�� dhlhjh_� y \u[jZe�� gbq_]h� g_� ^hdZau\Z_l� beb� ^hdZau\Z_lkebrdhf� fZeh�� dZd� b \hh[s_� \k_� kjZ\g_gby�� <_^v� hklZ_lky� kihjguf�� ih^oh^bl� eb� hgh�� bihgbfZ_rv�� qlh� mklZgh\dZ� gZ� ij_g_[j_`bl_evgh_� hl\_j`_gb_� m`_� hij_^_ebeZ� _]h� \u[hj�Ij_^m[_`^_gby�bgh]^Z�p_e_khh[jZagu�b hijZ\^Zggu��bgh]^Z�`_�hrb[hqgu�b \j_^gu��b gbdh]^Zg_�agZ_rv��dh]^Z�hgb�y\eyxlky�i_j\ufb��Z dh]^Z�\lhjufb��KZfZ�bklhjby�gZmd�k ba[uldhf�ihegZkemqZ_\��dhlhju_�fh]ml�ij_^hkl_j_qv�hl�ihki_rgh]h�hkm`^_gby��LZd��^he]h_�\j_fy�kqblZehkv[_kkfuke_gguf� ij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh� dZfgb�� dhlhju_� fu� k_]h^gy� gZau\Z_f� f_l_hjblZfb�ihiZeb�gZ�a_fex�k g_[Z�beb�qlh�]hjgZy�ihjh^Z��\dexqZxsZy�hklZldb�jZdmr_d��dh]^Z�lh�[ueZ^ghf� fhjy��F_`^m� ijhqbf�� b gZr_fm� ikbohZgZebam� ijbrehkv� g_gZfgh]h� emqr_�� dh]^Z� hg\uklmibe� k jZajZ[hldhc� ijh[e_f� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� LZd� qlh� m gZk�� ZgZeblbdh\�� _klv� hkh[ZyijbqbgZ� [ulv� hklhjh`gufb� ijb� bkihevah\Zgbb� bgl_ee_dlmZevgh]h� fhlb\Z� ^ey� ml\_j`^_gbygh\uo� ij_^iheh`_gbc�� qlh�� ijbagZlvky�� g_� ihfh]Z_l� gZf� ba[_`Zlv� hljbpZgby�� khfg_gbc� bg_^h\_jby�<lhjuf�fhf_glhf�y gZa\Ze�ikboheh]bq_kdbc��Ijb�wlhf�y bf_x�\ \b^m�h[smx�kdehgghklvex^_c�d e_]dh\_jbx�b \_j_�\ qm^_kZ��K kZfh]h�gZqZeZ��dh]^Z�`bagv�[_j_l�gZk�ih^�k\hc�kljh]bcgZ^ahj��\ gZk�ih^gbfZ_lky�ijhl_kl�ijhlb\�g_ij_eh`ghklb�b fhghlhgghklb�aZdhgh\�fure_gby�bijhlb\�lj_[h\Zgbc�ijh\_jdb�j_Zevghklvx��JZkkm^hd�klZgh\blky�\jZ]hf��hlgbfZxsbf�m gZk�lZdfgh]h�\hafh`ghkl_c�^ey�gZkeZ`^_gbc��Hldju\Z_rv��dZdh_�m^h\hevkl\b_�²�ohly�[u�g_gZ^he]h²� ba[Z\blvky� hl� g_]h� b ij_^Zlvky� kh[eZagZf� [_kkfukebpu�� Rdhevgbd� jZa\e_dZ_lkybkdZ`_gb_f� keh\�� ijhn_kkbhgZevguc� mq_guc� ih^rmqb\Z_l� gZ^� k\h_c� ^_yl_evghklvx� ihke_gZmqgh]h�dhg]j_kkZ��^Z`_�k_jv_aguc�q_eh\_d�gZkeZ`^Z_lky�b]jhc�hkljhmfby��;he__�k_jv_agZy\jZ`^_[ghklv� d ©jZkkm^dm� b gZmd_�� kZfhc� emqr_c� kbe_� q_eh\_dZª� `^_l� k\h_]h� kemqZy�� hgZki_rbl�hl^Zlv�ij_^ihql_gb_�qm^h�^hdlhjm�beb�bkdmkghfm�agZoZjx�i_j_^�©h[mq_ggufª�\jZqhf�hgZ�b^_l�gZ\klj_qm�ml\_j`^_gbyf�hddmevlbafZ��ihdZ�_]h�fgbfu_�nZdlu�\hkijbgbfZxlky�dZdgZjmr_gb_� aZdhgZ� b ijZ\be�� hgZ� mkuiey_l� djblbdm�� ba\jZsZ_l� \hkijbylby�� ^h[b\Z_lkyijbagZgbc� b h^h[j_gbc�� dhlhju_� g_� fh]ml� [ulv� hijZ\^Zgu�� Dlh� ijbf_l� \h� \gbfZgb_� wlmkdehgghklv� ex^_c�� bf__l� \k_� hkgh\Zgby� ^ey� h[_kp_gb\Zgby� fgh]bo� khh[s_gbc� hddmevlghcebl_jZlmju�

Page 274: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Lj_lvbf�khh[jZ`_gb_f�y gZa\Ze�bklhjbq_kdh_��`_eZy�h[jZlblv�\gbfZgb_�gZ�lh��qlh�\ fbj_hddmevlbafZ�g_�ijhbkoh^bl��kh[kl\_ggh�]h\hjy��gbq_]h�gh\h]h��gh�\ g_f�\gh\v�\hagbdZxl�\k_�l_agZf_gby��qm^_kZ��ijhjhq_kl\Z�b y\e_gby�^moh\�� h dhlhjuo�fu� agZ_f� k ^j_\gbo� \j_f_g�b ba^j_\gbo� dgb]� b dhlhju_� fu� ^Z\gh� khqeb� ihjh`^_gb_f� g_h[ma^Zgghc� nZglZabb� bebl_g^_gpbhaguf� gZ^m\Zl_evkl\hf�� ijh^mdlhf� lh]h� \j_f_gb�� dh]^Z� g_\_`_kl\_gghklvq_eh\_q_kl\Z�[ueZ�hq_gv�\_ebdZ��Z gZmqguc�jZamf�gZoh^beky�_s_�\ i_e_gdZo��?keb�fu�ijbf_faZ�bklbgm�lh��qlh�ijhbkoh^bl�_s_�b k_]h^gy��ih�khh[s_gbyf�hddmevlbklh\��lh�fu�^he`gu�[m^_fijbagZlv�^hklh\_jgufb�b l_�k\_^_gby�ba�kj_^g_\_dh\vy��: l_i_jv�\kihfgbf��qlh� ljZ^bpbb�bk\ys_ggu_� dgb]b� gZjh^h\� i_j_iheg_gu� lZdbfb� bklhjbyfb� h qm^_kZo� b qlh� j_eb]bb� \ k\hboijblyaZgbyo�gZ�^hklh\_jghklv�hibjZxlky�dZd�jZa�gZ�lZdb_�qj_a\uqZcgu_�b qm^_kgu_�kh[ulby�q_jiZy� \ gbo� ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z� ^_ckl\by� k\_joq_eh\_q_kdbo� kbe�� B lh]^Z� ljm^gh� ba[_`Zlvih^haj_gby��qlh�hddmevlguc�bgl_j_k�y\ey_lky��kh[kl\_ggh��j_eb]bhaguf��qlh�d lZcguf�fhlb\Zfhddmevlgh]h� ^\b`_gby� hlghkblky� klj_fe_gb_� ihfhqv� j_eb]bb�� dhlhjhc� m]jh`Z_l� ijh]j_kkgZmqgh]h�fure_gby��: k�ijbagZgb_f�lZdh]h�fhlb\Z�^he`gh�\hajZklb�gZr_�g_^h\_jb_�b gZr_g_`_eZgb_�imkdZlvky�\ bkke_^h\Zgb_�lZd�gZau\Z_fuo�hddmevlguo�n_ghf_gh\�Gh� \ dhgp_� dhgph\� wlm� ZglbiZlbx� ijb^_lky� \k_�lZdb� ij_h^he_lv�� J_qv� b^_l� h \hijhk_^_ckl\bl_evghklb�� l�� _�� bklbggh� beb� g_l� lh�� h q_f� khh[sZxl� hddmevlbklu�� Wlh� \_^v� fh`ghj_rblv� iml_f� gZ[ex^_gby�� < ijbgpbi_� fu� ^he`gu� [ulv� [eZ]h^Zjgu� hddmevlbklZf�Khh[s_gby� h qm^_kZo� ^j_\gbo� \j_f_g�fu� g_�fh`_f� ih^\_j]gmlv� ijh\_jd_��IheZ]Zy�� qlh� bog_evay� ^hdZaZlv�� fu� ^he`gu� \k_� `_� ijbagZlv�� qlh� bo� g_evay� kh� \k_c� kljh]hklvx� bhijh\_j]gmlv\��� Gh� h lhf�� qlh� ijhbkoh^bl� \ gZklhys__� \j_fy�� q_fm� fu� fh`_f� [ulvk\b^_l_eyfb�²� h[� wlhf�fu� ^he`gu� bf_lv� l\_j^h_� km`^_gb_��?keb�fu� m[_^bfky�� qlh� lZdboqm^_k� k_]h^gy� g_� [u\Z_l�� lh�fu� g_� bkim]Z_fky� b \hajZ`_gby�� qlh� \ ^j_\ghklb� hgb� \k_�lZdbfh]eb�kemqZlvky��>jm]b_�h[tykg_gby�hdZ`mlky�lh]^Z�_s_�ihgylg__��BlZd��fu�hklZ\ey_l�gZrbkhfg_gby�b ]hlh\u�ijbklmiblv�d gZ[ex^_gbx�hddmevlguo�n_ghf_gh\�D g_kqZklvx��lml�fu�\klj_qZ_fky�k h[klhyl_evkl\Zfb��qj_a\uqZcgh�g_[eZ]hijbylgufb�^eygZr_]h� [eZ]h]h� gZf_j_gby�� GZ[ex^_gby�� hl� dhlhjuo� ^he`gh� aZ\bk_lv� gZr_� km`^_gb_�ijhbkoh^yl� \ mkeh\byo�� ^_eZxsbo� gZrb� qm\kl\_ggu_� \hkijbylby� g_gZ^_`gufb�ijblmieyxsbo�gZr_�\gbfZgb_��\ l_fghl_�beb�ijb�kdm^ghf�djZkghf�k\_l_��ihke_�^ebl_evgh]hgZijZkgh]h� h`b^Zgby��GZf� ]h\hjyl�� qlh� kZfZ� ih� k_[_� gZrZ� kd_ilbq_kdZy�� l�� _�� djblbq_kdZy�mklZgh\dZ� fh`_l� ihf_rZlv� ihy\e_gbx� h`b^Z_fuo� n_ghf_gh\�� Kha^Z\rZyky� lZdbf� h[jZahfkblmZpby�y\ey_lky�ijhklh�dZjbdZlmjhc�gZ�mkeh\by��\ dhlhjuo�fu�ijb\udeb�h[uqgh�ijh\h^blvgZmqgu_� bkke_^h\Zgby�� GZ[ex^_gby� ijh\h^ylky� gZ^� lZd� gZau\Z_fufb� f_^bmfZfb�� ebpZfb�dhlhjuf�ijbibku\Zxlky� hkh[u_� ©k_gablb\gu_ª� kihkh[ghklb��gh� dhlhju_�gb� \ dh_c�f_j_�g_hlebqZxlky� \u^Zxsbfbky� dZq_kl\Zfb� mfZ� beb� oZjZdl_jZ�� g_� y\eyxlky� ghkbl_eyfb� dZdhc�lh[hevrhc� b^_b� beb� k_jv_agh]h� aZfukeZ�� dZd� ^j_\gb_� qm^hl\hjpu��GZijhlb\�� ^Z`_� m l_o�� dlh\_jbl�\ bo� lZcgu_�kbeu��hgb� keu\ml�hkh[_ggh�g_gZ^_`gufb��[hevrbgkl\h�ba�gbo�m`_�[uebjZah[eZq_gu� dZd� h[fZgsbdb�� ke_^m_l� h`b^Zlv�� qlh�b hklZevguf�ij_^klhbl� lh�`_� kZfh_��Lh�q_]h�hgb�^hklb]Zxl��ijhba\h^bl�\i_qZle_gb_�^_lkdh]h�hahjkl\Z�beb�nhdmkh\��?s_�gb jZam�gZk_ZgkZo�k wlbfb�f_^bmfZfb�g_�ijhbahreh�gbq_]h��^hklhcgh]h�\gbfZgby��\jh^_�ijbh[s_gby�dgh\hfm�bklhqgbdm�kbeu��IjZ\^Z��b hl�ljxdZ�nhdmkgbdZ��qm^_kguf�h[jZahf�\uimkdZxs_]h�baimklh]h�pbebg^jZ�]hem[_c��g_�ijboh^blky�`^Zlv�jZa\blby�]hem[_\h^kl\Z��E_]dh�fh]m�ihklZ\blv

Page 275: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

k_[y� \ iheh`_gb_�q_eh\_dZ�� dhlhjuc��`_eZy� kh[exklb� lj_[h\Zgb_� h[t_dlb\ghklb��ijbgbfZ_lmqZklb_�\ k_ZgkZo�hddmevlbklh\��gh�q_j_a�g_dhlhjh_�\j_fy�mklZ_l�b k�hl\jZs_gb_f�hldZau\Z_lkyhl�ihklZ\e_gguo�lj_[h\Zgbc�b��lZd�gbq_fm�b g_�gZmqb\rbkv��\ha\jZsZ_lky�d k\hbf�ij_`gbfij_^m[_`^_gbyf�� LZdh]h� q_eh\_dZ� fh`gh� mij_dgmlv� \ g_ijZ\bevghf� ih\_^_gbb�� ihkdhevdmn_ghf_gZf��dhlhju_�hg�ohq_l�bamqblv��g_evay�ij_^ibku\Zlv�aZjZg__��dZdbfb�hgb�^he`gu�[ulvb ijb� dZdbo� mkeh\byo� hgb� ^he`gu� ihy\eylvky�� [he__� lh]h�� ke_^m_l� ijhy\blv� \u^_j`dm� bkh[ex^Zlv�f_ju�ij_^hklhjh`ghklb�b dhgljhey��dhlhjufb�_s_�g_^Z\gh�iulZebkv�aZsblblvky�hlg_gZ^_`ghklb�f_^bmfh\��D kh`Ze_gbx�� wlZ� kh\j_f_ggZy� l_ogbdZ� [_ahiZkghklb� deZ^_l� dhg_pe_]dhc�^hklmighklb�hddmevlguo�gZ[ex^_gbc��Bamq_gb_�hddmevlbafZ�klZgh\blky�hkh[h�ljm^ghcijhn_kkb_c��^_yl_evghklvx��dhlhjhc�g_evay�ij_^Z\Zlvky�gZjy^m�k ijhqbfb�k\hbfb�bgl_j_kZfb�B ihdZ� aZgbfZxsb_ky� wlbf� bkke_^h\Zl_eb� ijb^ml� d dZdbf�lh� \u\h^Zf�� \Zf� hklZ_lky� ebrvkhfg_\Zlvky�b [ulv�ij_^hklZ\e_ggufb�k\hbf�kh[kl\_gguf�ij_^iheh`_gbyf�Kj_^b�wlbo�ij_^iheh`_gbc�gZb[he__�\_jhylguf�y\ey_lky��ih`Zemc��lh��qlh�\ hddmevlbaf_j_qv� b^_l� h dZdhf�lh� j_Zevghf� y^j_ ILQH g_� ihagZgguo� nZdlh\�� dhlhjh_� h[fZg� b nZglZabyhdmlZeb�ljm^gh�ij_h^hebfhc�h[hehqdhc��Gh�dZd�fu�fh`_f�ohly�[u�ijb[ebablvky�d wlhfm�y^jm�k dZdhc� klhjhgu�ih^hclb� d ijh[e_f_"�A^_kv�� y iheZ]Zx��gZf�gZ�ihfhsv�ijb^_l� kgh\b^_gb_�ih^Z\�gZf�kh\_l�\u^_eblv�ba�\k_]h�wlh]h�oZhkZ�l_fm�l_e_iZlbb�<u� agZ_l_�� qlh� l_e_iZlb_c� fu� gZau\Z_f� ij_^iheZ]Z_fuc� nZdl�� dh]^Z� kh[ulb_�ijhbkoh^ys__� \ hij_^_e_ggh_� \j_fy�� ijbf_jgh� \ lh� `_� \j_fy� hkhagZ_lky� hl^Ze_gguf� \ijhkljZgkl\_�ebphf��ijb�wlhf�ba\_klgu_�gZf�kihkh[u�khh[s_gby�g_evay�ijbgbfZlv�\ jZkq_l�FheqZeb\hc�ij_^ihkuedhc� wlh]h�y\ey_lky� lh��qlh�^Zggh_�kh[ulb_�dZkZ_lky�ebpZ��d dhlhjhfm^jm]h_�ebph��ijbgbfZxs__�ba\_klb_��bf__l�kbevguc�wfhpbhgZevguc�bgl_j_k��LZd��gZijbf_j��kebphf�: ijhbkoh^bl�g_kqZklv_�beb�hgh�mfbjZ_l��Z ebph�;��[ebadh�k\yaZggh_�k gbf�²�fZlv��^hqvbeb� \haex[e_ggZy� ²� magZ_l� h[� wlhf� ijbf_jgh� \ lh� `_� \j_fy� [eZ]h^Zjy� ajbl_evghfm� bebkemoh\hfm� \hkijbylbx�� ihke_^gbc� kemqZc�� ijb� dhlhjhf� _c� h[� wlhf� [m^lh� [u� khh[sbeb� ihl_e_nhgm�� q_]h� gZ� kZfhf� ^_e_� g_� [ueh�� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� \ ba\_klghc� f_j_� ikbobq_kdh_ih^h[b_� [_kijh\hehqgh]h� l_e_]jZnZ�� G_l� g_h[oh^bfhklb� ]h\hjblv� h lhf�� gZkdhevdhg_\_jhylgu� lZdb_� y\e_gby�� b [hevrbgkl\h� wlbo� khh[s_gbc� fh`gh� k iheguf� hkgh\Zgb_fhl\_j]gmlv�� l_�`_�� dhlhju_� hldehgblv� g_� lZd�lh� ijhklh�� hklZxlky�� JZaj_rbl_� fg_� ^ey� lh]h�qlh[u�khh[sblv�\Zf�lh��qlh�y gZf_lbe��\ ^Zevg_cr_f�himkdZlv�hklhjh`gh_�keh\_qdh�©ydh[uª�bijh^he`Zlv�lZd��keh\gh�y \_jx�\ h[t_dlb\gmx�j_Zevghklv�l_e_iZlbq_kdh]h�n_ghf_gZ��H^gZdh[m^vl_�m\_j_gu��qlh�wlh�g_�lZd��qlh�y hkgh\u\Zxkv�g_�gZ�m[_`^_gbb�Y fh]m� khh[sblv� \Zf�� kh[kl\_ggh�� g_fgh]h�� \k_]h� ebrv� g_agZqbl_evguc� nZdl�� Y ohqmlZd`_� kjZam�`_� _s_� [hevr_� mf_jblv� \Zrb� h`b^Zgby�� kdZaZ\�� qlh� kgh\b^_gb_�� ih� kms_kl\m�bf__l� fZeh� h[s_]h� k l_e_iZlb_c�� DZd� l_e_iZlby� g_� ijheb\Z_l� gh\uc� k\_l� gZ� kmsghklvkgh\b^_gby�� lZd� b kgh\b^_gb_� g_� y\ey_lky� ijyfuf� k\b^_l_evkl\hf� j_Zevghklb� l_e_iZlbb�L_e_iZlbq_kdbc�n_ghf_g� lZd`_� kh\k_f� g_� k\yaZg� kh� kgh\b^_gb_f�� hg�fh`_l� \hagbdgmlv� b \khklhygbb�[h^jkl\h\Zgby��?^bgkl\_gghc�ijbqbghc�^ey�h[km`^_gby�k\yab�f_`^m�kgh\b^_gb_f�bl_e_iZlb_c� y\ey_lky� lh�� qlh� khklhygb_� kgZ� dZ`_lky� hkh[_ggh� ih^oh^ysbf� ^ey� ijb_fZl_e_iZlbq_kdh]h�ihkeZgby��B \hl�dlh�lh�\b^bl�lZd�gZau\Z_fuc�l_e_iZlbq_kdbc�khg��Z ijb�_]hZgZeba_� m[_`^Z_lky�� qlh� l_e_iZlbq_kdh_� ba\_klb_� ku]jZeh� lm� `_� jhev�� qlh� b ex[hc� ^jm]hc

Page 276: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hklZlhd�^g_\guo�\i_qZle_gbc��b��dZd�lZdh\hc��hgh�hdZaZehkv�baf_g_gguf�\ j_amevlZl_�jZ[hlukgh\b^_gby��ih^qbgb\rbkv�__ l_g^_gpbb�Ijb� ZgZeba_� lZdh]h� l_e_iZlbq_kdh]h� kgh\b^_gby� ijhbkoh^bl� g_qlh�� ihdZaZ\r__ky� fg_^hklZlhqgh� bgl_j_kguf�� qlh[u�� g_kfhljy� gZ� \kx� _]h� g_agZqbl_evghklv�� ijbgylv� _]h� aZbkoh^guc�imgdl�wlhc�e_dpbb��Dh]^Z�\ �����]��y ^_eZe�i_j\h_�khh[s_gb_�h[�wlhf�ij_^f_l_��\fh_f�jZkihjy`_gbb�[ueh�lhevdh�h^gh�gZ[ex^_gb_��K l_o�ihj�y ihemqbe�b ^jm]b_��ZgZeh]bqgu_�gh�y hklZgh\exkv�gZ�i_j\hf�ijbf_j_��ihkdhevdm�_]h�e_]q_�\k_]h�baeh`blv��b kjZam�`_�\\_^m�\ZkLQ�PHGLDV�UHV �H^bg�y\gh�bgl_eeb]_glguc�q_eh\_d��ih�_]h�ml\_j`^_gbx��©[_a�fZe_crbo�hddmevlbklkdbogZdehgghkl_cª�� ibr_l� fg_� h[� h^ghf� kgh\b^_gbb�� dhlhjh_� ihdZaZehkv� _fm� kljZgguf�� >eygZqZeZ� hg� jZkkdZau\Z_l�� qlh� _]h� aZfm`gyy� ^hqv�� ijh`b\ZxsZy� ^Ze_dh� hl� g_]h�� h`b^Z_l� \k_j_^bg_�^_dZ[jy�jh`^_gby�k\h_]h�i_j\_gpZ��WlZ�^hqv�_fm�hq_gv�[ebadZ��hg�lZd`_�agZ_l��qlh�bhgZ�hq_gv�bkdj_gg_�d g_fm�ijb\yaZgZ��< ghqv�k ���]h�gZ����_ ghy[jy�_fm�kgblky�khg��qlh�_]h`_gZ� jh^beZ� [ebag_ph\�� AZl_f� ke_^h\Zeb� g_dhlhju_� ih^jh[ghklb�� dhlhju_� y fh]m� a^_kvhimklblv��^Z�b g_�\k_�bo�m^Zehkv�h[tykgblv��@_gsbgZ��dhlhjZy�\ kgh\b^_gbb� klZeZ�fZl_jvx[ebag_ph\�²�_]h�\lhjZy�`_gZ��fZq_oZ�_]h�^hq_jb��Hg�g_�ohq_l�bf_lv�^_l_c�hl�wlhc�`_gsbgu�hldZau\Zy� _c� \ kihkh[ghklb� jZamfgh� \hkiblu\Zlv� ^_l_c�� Dh� \j_f_gb� kgh\b^_gby� hg� ^Z\ghij_djZlbe� k g_c� iheh\u_� kghr_gby�� GZibkZlv� fg_� ih[m^beh� _]h� g_� khfg_gb_� \ l_hjbbkgh\b^_gby��d q_fm��dZaZehkv�[u��^Z\Zeh�hkgh\Zgb_�y\gh_�kh^_j`Zgb_�kgh\b^_gby��b[h�ihq_fmkgh\b^_gb_�aZklZ\beh�wlm�`_gsbgm�jh`Zlv�^_l_c�\hij_db�_]h�`_eZgbx"�Ih�_]h�k\b^_l_evkl\m�g_�[ue�lZd`_�gbdZdbo�ijbqbg�^ey�hiZk_gby��qlh�wlh�g_`_eZl_evgh_�kh[ulb_�fh`_l�ijhbahclb�H[klhyl_evkl\hf��ih[m^b\rbf�_]h�khh[sblv�fg_�h kgh\b^_� �< kmlv�^_eZ��eZl���²�Ijbf_q��i_j�gbb��[ueh�lh��qlh����]h�ghy[jy�jZgh�mljhf�hg�ihemqbe�l_e_]jZffm�h lhf��qlh�m _]h�^hq_jbjh^bebkv�[ebag_pu��L_e_]jZffZ�[ueZ�hlijZ\e_gZ�aZ�^_gv�^h�wlh]h��jh^u�ihke_^h\Zeb�\ ghqv�k���]h� gZ� ���_�� ijbf_jgh� \ lhl� `_� qZk�� dh]^Z� _fm� kgbeky� khg� h lhf�� qlh� `_gZ� jh^beZ� _fm[ebag_ph\��<b^_\rbc�khg�kijZrb\Z_l�f_gy��kqblZx�eb�y kemqZcghklvx�kh\iZ^_gb_�kgh\b^_gbyb kh[ulby�� Hg� g_� j_rZ_lky� gZa\Zlv� kgh\b^_gb_� l_e_iZlbq_kdbf�� lZd� dZd� jZaebqb_� f_`^mkh^_j`Zgb_f�kgh\b^_gby�b kh[ulb_f�dZkZ_lky�dZd�jZa�lh]h��qlh�dZ`_lky�_fm�kms_kl\_gguf��Zbf_ggh�i_jkhgu�jh`_gbpu��Gh�h^gh�ba�_]h�aZf_qZgbc�iha\hey_l�aZdexqblv��qlh�hg�g_�m^b\beky[u� b gZklhys_fm� l_e_iZlbq_kdhfm� kgh\b^_gbx��>hqv�� dZd� hg� iheZ]Z_l�� \ k\hc� ljm^guc� qZkgZ\_jgydZ�©^mfZeZ�hkh[_ggh�h g_fª�>Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Y m\_j_g�� qlh� \u� kZfb� m`_� fh`_l_� h[tykgblv� wlh� kgh\b^_gb_� bihgbfZ_l_��ihq_fm�y _]h�\Zf�jZkkdZaZe��Wlhl�q_eh\_d�g_^h\he_g�k\h_c�\lhjhc�`_ghc��hg�ohl_e[u��qlh[u�_]h�`_gZ�[ueZ�lZdhc�`_��dZd�_]h�^hqv�hl�i_j\h]h�[jZdZ��>ey�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h� wlh©dZdª��dhg_qgh��g_kms_kl\_ggh��B \hl�ghqvx�_fm�ijboh^bl�l_e_iZlbq_kdh_�ihkeZgb_��qlh�^hqvjh^beZ�[ebag_ph\��JZ[hlZ�kgh\b^_gby�aZ\eZ^_\Z_l�wlbf�ba\_klb_f��iha\hey_l�[_kkhagZl_evghfm`_eZgbx�� klj_fys_fmky� ihklZ\blv� gZ�f_klh�`_gu� ^hqv�� ih^_ckl\h\Zlv� gZ�g_]h�� b \hagbdZ_lkljZggh_� y\gh_� kgh\b^_gb_�� dhlhjh_� fZkdbjm_l� `_eZgb_� b bkdZ`Z_l� ihkeZgb_�� IjbagZlvky�ebrv� lhedh\Zgb_� kgh\b^_gby�ihdZaZeh�gZf��qlh� wlh� kgh\b^_gb_� l_e_iZlbq_kdh_��ikbohZgZeba

Page 277: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\kdjue�l_e_iZlbq_kdb_�nZdlu��dhlhju_�fu�bgZq_�g_�kfh]eb�[u�magZlv�Gh� g_� iha\heycl_� \k_�lZdb� \\_klb� k_[y� \ aZ[em`^_gb_�� G_kfhljy� gZ� wlh� lhedh\Zgb_kgh\b^_gby��gbqlh�g_�khh[sbeh�h[�h[t_dlb\ghc�bklbg_� l_e_iZlbq_kdh]h�nZdlZ��Fh`_l�[ulv�wlh�\b^bfhklv��^himkdZxsZy�b ^jm]h_�h[tykg_gb_��<hafh`gh��qlh�kdjulu_�fukeb�kgh\b^_gbyq_eh\_dZ�[ueb�lZdh\u��©K_]h^gy�^_gv��dh]^Z�^he`gu�[ueb�[u�ijhbahclb�jh^u��_keb�^hqv��dZdy��kh[kl\_ggh��kqblZx��hrb[ZeZkv�gZ�f_kyp��B \u]ey^_eZ�hgZ��dh]^Z�y \b^_e�__ \�ihke_^gbc�jZa�lZd��keh\gh�m g__�[m^_l�^\hcgy��: fhy�ihdhcgZy�`_gZ�lZd�ex[beZ�^_l_c��dZd�hgZ�h[jZ^h\ZeZkv[u�[ebag_pZf�ª� �Ihke_^gbc�fhf_gl� y \u\h`m�ba� _s_�g_� mihfygmluo� ZkkhpbZpbc� \b^_\r_]hkhg���< wlhf�kemqZ_�ih[m^bl_e_f�kgh\b^_gby�[ueb�[u�ohjhrh�h[hkgh\Zggu_�ij_^iheh`_gby\b^_\r_]h�khg��Z g_�l_e_iZlbq_kdh_�ihkeZgb_��gh�j_amevlZl�hklZeky�[u�l_f�`_��<u�\b^bl_��qlh�bwlh�lhedh\Zgb_�kgh\b^_gby�gbq_]h�g_�^Z_l�^ey�hl\_lZ�gZ�\hijhk��ke_^m_l�eb�l_e_iZlbx�ijbagZlvh[t_dlb\ghc�j_Zevghklvx��Wlh�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�j_rblv�lhevdh�iml_f�ih^jh[gh]h�bkke_^h\Zgby\k_o� h[klhyl_evkl\� ^Zggh]h� kemqZy�� qlh�� d kh`Ze_gbx�� \ wlhf� ijbf_j_� [ueh� lZd� `_� fZeh\hafh`gh�� dZd�b \�^jm]bo�ijbf_jZo�ba�fh_]h�hiulZ��>himklbf�� qlh� ]bihl_aZ� l_e_iZlbb� ^Z_lkZfh_� ijhklh_� h[tykg_gb_�� gh� wlbf� \ub]ju\Z_lky� g_fgh]h_�� KZfh_� ijhklh_� h[tykg_gb_� g_\k_]^Z� ijZ\bevgh�� bklbgZ� hq_gv� qZklh� g_� ijhklZ�� b ij_`^_� q_f� j_rblvky� gZ� lZdh_� \Z`gh_ij_^iheh`_gb_��ohq_lky�kh[exklb�\k_�f_ju�ij_^hklhjh`ghklb�L_fm�kgh\b^_gby�b l_e_iZlbb�fu�fh`_f�l_i_jv�hklZ\blv��fg_�g_q_]h�\Zf�[hevr_�kdZaZlvh[� wlhf��Gh� aZf_lvl_� k_[_�� qlh� \_^v�g_� kgh\b^_gb_� ^Zeh�gZf� dZdh_�lh� agZgb_� h l_e_iZlbb�� Zlhedh\Zgb_� kgh\b^_gby�� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdZy� h[jZ[hldZ�� LZd� qlh� \ ^Zevg_cr_f� fu� fh`_fkh\k_f�hklZ\blv�kgh\b^_gby��ij_^iheh`b\��qlh�ijbf_g_gb_�ikbohZgZebaZ�ijhev_l�g_dhlhjuck\_l� gZ� ^jm]b_� nZdlu�� gZau\Z_fu_� hddmevlgufb�� LZd�� gZijbf_j�� n_ghf_g� bg^mdpbb�� bebi_j_^Zqb�fuke_c��\_kvfZ�[ebadbc�d l_e_iZlbb��kh[kl\_ggh�]h\hjy��[_a�hkh[hc�gZly`db�fh`_l[ulv�k \_c�h[t_^bg_g��Hg�hagZqZ_l��qlh�^mr_\gu_�ijhp_kku�h^gh]h�ebpZ��_]h�ij_^klZ\e_gby�khklhygby� \ha[m`^_gby�� \he_\u_� ih[m`^_gby� fh]ml� i_j_^Z\Zlvky� kd\hav� k\h[h^gh_ijhkljZgkl\h� ^jm]hfm� ebpm� [_a� bkihevah\Zgby� ba\_klguo� kihkh[h\� khh[s_gby� keh\Zfb� bagZdZfb��<u�ihgbfZ_l_�� dZd�[ueh�[u� aZf_qZl_evgh�� Z fh`_l� [ulv�� ^Z`_�ijZdlbq_kdb� \Z`gh�_keb� [u�ih^h[gh_�^_ckl\bl_evgh� kemqZehkv��KdZ`m�ihimlgh�� qlh�� dZd� gb� kljZggh�� \ ^j_\gbohibkZgbyo�qm^_k�bf_ggh�h[�wlhf�n_ghf_g_�]h\hjblky�f_gvr_�\k_]h�Ijb�e_q_gbb�iZpb_glh\�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbf�f_lh^hf�m f_gy�keh`behkv�\i_qZle_gb_��qlhaZgylby�ijhn_kkbhgZevguo�ij_^kdZaZl_e_c�lZyl�\ k_[_�[eZ]hijbylgmx�\hafh`ghklv�hkh[_ggh[_amij_qgh]h�gZ[ex^_gby�aZ�i_j_^Zq_c�fuke_c��Wlh�g_agZqbl_evgu_�beb�^Z`_�g_iheghp_ggu_ex^b��ihk\ylb\rb_�k_[y�dZdhfm�gb[m^v�aZgylbx�²�]Z^Zgbx�gZ�dZjlZo��bamq_gbx�ihq_jdh\�bebgbc�jmd��Zkljheh]bq_kdbf�\uqbke_gbyf�²�b ij_^kdZau\Zxsb_�ijb�wlhf�k\hbf�ihk_lbl_eyf[m^ms__��ihke_� lh]h� dZd� hgb�ihdZ`ml� k_[y�ihk\ys_ggufb� \ bo�ijhreh_�beb�gZklhys__��Bodeb_glu� ih� [hevr_c� qZklb� \iheg_� ^h\hevkl\mxlky� wlbf� b g_� k_lmxl�� _keb� \ihke_^kl\bbijhjhq_kl\Z� g_� k[u\Zxlky��Y agZx�fgh`_kl\h� lZdbo� kemqZ_\�� bf_e� \hafh`ghklv� bamqblv� boZgZeblbq_kdb�b k_cqZk�jZkkdZ`m� \Zf� kZfuc� aZf_qZl_evguc�ba� wlbo�ijbf_jh\��D kh`Ze_gbx�^hdZaZl_evghklv�wlbo�khh[s_gbc�mfZey_lky�l_f��qlh�y \ugm`^_g�h fgh]hf�mfZeqb\Zlv��lZd�dZdd wlhfm�f_gy�h[yau\Z_l�\jZq_[gZy� wlbdZ��Gh� y kh�\k_c� kljh]hklvx�ba[_]Ze�bkdZ`_gbc��BlZd�ihkemrZcl_� bklhjbx� h^ghc� ba� fhbo� iZpb_glhd�� m dhlhjhc� [ue� lZdhc� kemqZc� k h^gbf

Page 278: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ij_^kdZaZl_e_f�HgZ� [ueZ� klZjr_c� kj_^b� [jZlv_\� b k_kl_j�� \ujhkeZ� \ mkeh\byo� qj_a\uqZcgh� kbevghcijb\yaZgghklb�d hlpm��jZgh�\ureZ� aZfm`��\ kmijm`_kl\_�gZreZ�ihegh_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_��>eyihegh]h�kqZklvy�_c�g_�o\ZlZeh�ebrv�h^gh]h�²�hgZ�hklZ\ZeZkv�[_a^_lghc��lZd�qlh�__�ex[bfucfm`� g_� fh]� iheghklvx� aZgylv� f_klh� hlpZ�� Dh]^Z� `_� ihke_� ^he]bo� e_l� jZahqZjh\Zgby� hgZj_rbeZkv� gZ� ]bg_dheh]bq_kdmx� hi_jZpbx�� fm`� ijbagZeky� _c�� qlh� \bgZ� e_`bl� gZ� g_f�� ba�aZ[he_agb�^h�`_gblv[u�hg�klZe�g_kihkh[_g�d aZqZlbx��Wlh�jZahqZjh\Zgb_�hgZ�i_j_g_keZ�k ljm^hf�klZeZ�g_�\jhlbqghc��y\gh�kljZ^Zy� kljZoZfb� kh[eZagZ��Qlh[u�jZa\e_qv��fm`�\aye� __ k� kh[hc�\^_eh\mx�ih_a^dm�\ IZjb`��H^gZ`^u�hgb�kb^_eb�lZf�\ ohee_�hl_ey��dh]^Z�_c�[jhkbehkv�\ ]eZaZdZdh_�lh�h`b\e_gb_�kj_^b�ijbkem]b��HgZ�kijhkbeZ��\ q_f�^_eh��b magZeZ��qlh�ijb[ue 0RQVLHXUOH� SURIHV�VHXU� dhlhjuc� ^Z_l� dhgkmevlZpbb� \ lZdhf�lh� dZ[bg_l_�� HgZ� aZohl_eZ� lh`_ijhdhgkmevlbjh\Zlvky��Fm`�_c�g_�kh\_lh\Ze��gh�hgZ�memqbeZ�fhf_gl��ijhkdhevagmeZ�\ dZ[bg_l^ey�dhgkmevlZpbc�b ij_^klZeZ�i_j_^�ij_^kdZaZl_e_f��?c�[ueh����e_l��gh�\u]ey^_eZ�hgZ�gZfgh]hfheh`_�� h[jmqZevgh_� dhevph� hgZ� kgyeZ� 0RQVLHXU� OH� SURIHVVHXU ihijhkbe� __� himklblv� jmdm� \qZrm�� gZiheg_ggmx� ahehc�� lsZl_evgh� bamqb\� hli_qZlhd�� hg� jZkkdZaZe� _c� aZl_f� h ly`_ehc[hjv[_��dhlhjZy�_c�ij_^klhbl��b aZdhgqbe�ml_rbl_evguf�aZ\_j_gb_f��qlh�hgZ�\k_�lZdb�\uc^_l_s_�aZfm`�b d����]h^Zf�[m^_l�bf_lv�^\hbo�^_l_c��Dh]^Z�hgZ�jZkkdZau\ZeZ�fg_�wlm�bklhjbx��_c[ueh� ��� ]h^Z�� ly`_eh�[hevgZy��hgZ�g_�bf_eZ�gbdZdhc�gZ^_`^u�jh^blv�dh]^Z�gb[m^v�j_[_gdZ�LZdbf� h[jZahf�� ijhjhq_kl\h� g_� bkihegbehkv�� gh� ]h\hjbeZ� hgZ� h g_f� [_a� \kydhc� ]hj_qb�� Z ky\guf� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f�� keh\gh� \kihfbgZeZ� jZ^hklgh_� i_j_`b\Zgb_�� G_ljm^gh� [uehmklZgh\blv�� qlh� hgZ� g_� bf_eZ� gb� fZe_cr_]h� ij_^klZ\e_gby�� qlh� fh]eb� hagZqZlv� h[Z� qbkeZijhjhq_kl\Z����b ����b agZqbeb�eb�hgb�\hh[s_�qlh�gb[m^v�<u�kdZ`_l_��dZdZy�]emiZy�b g_ihgylgZy�bklhjby��b kijhkbl_��^ey�q_]h�y __�\Zf�jZkkdZaZe�>Z��y [ue�[u�k \Zfb�kh\_jr_ggh�kh]eZk_g��_keb�[u�²�b lml�j_rZxsbc�fhf_gl�²�g_�ZgZeba�iha\heb\rbc�gZf�bklhedh\Zlv�lh�ijhjhq_kl\h��dhlhjh_�dZd�jZa�[eZ]h^Zjy�h[tykg_gbx�^_lZe_cijhba\h^bl�m[_^bl_evgh_�\i_qZle_gb_��>_eh�\ lhf��qlh�h[Z�qbkeZ�b]jZeb�jhev�\ `bagb�fZl_jbfh_c�iZpb_gldb��LZ�iha^gh�\ureZ�aZfm`��ihke_�ljb^pZlb��b \�k_fv_�qZklh�]h\hjbeb�h lhf��dZdm^Zqgh�hgZ�ihki_rbeZ�gZ\_jklZlv�mims_ggh_��H[Z�i_j\uo�j_[_gdZ�� kgZqZeZ�gZrZ�iZpb_gldZ�jh^bebkv� k kZfuf� \hafh`gh� dhjhldbf� ijhf_`mldhf� \j_f_gb� \ h^ghf� dZe_g^Zjghf� ]h^m�� b^_ckl\bl_evgh� \ ��� ]h^Z� m g__� m`_� [ueh� ^\h_� ^_l_c�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� lh�� qlh 0RQVLHXU� OHSURIHVVHXU kdZaZe�fh_c�iZpb_gld_��hagZqZeh��ml_rvl_kv��\u�_s_�lZd�fheh^u��M \Zk�[m^_l�lZdZy`_�km^v[Z��dZd�m \Zr_c�fZl_jb��dhlhjhc�lh`_�ijbrehkv�^he]h�`^Zlv�^_l_c��m \Zk�lh`_�[m^_l^\h_�^_l_c�d ���]h^Zf��Gh�bf_lv�lZdmx�`_�km^v[m��dZd�b fZlv��ihklZ\blv�k_[y�gZ�__ f_klh��aZgylv__ f_klh� ijb� hlp_²� \_^v� wlh� b [ueh� kZfh_� kbevgh_� `_eZgb_� __ xghklb�� `_eZgb_�� ba�aZg_\uiheg_gby� dhlhjh]h� gZqZeZkv� l_i_jv� __ [he_agv�� Ijhjhq_kl\h� h[_sZeh� _c�� qlh� _]hbkiheg_gb_� \k_� _s_� \hafh`gh�� qlh� `_�� djhf_� ijbagZl_evghklb�� hgZ� fh]eZ� qm\kl\h\Zlv� dij_^kdZaZl_ex"� Gh� kqblZ_l_� eb� \u� \hafh`guf�� qlh[u 0RQVLHXU� OH� SURIHVVHXU agZe� nZdlubglbfghc�`bagb�k_fvb�k\h_c�kemqZcghc�deb_gldb"�Wlh�g_\hafh`gh��Hldm^Z�`_�ijbreh�d g_fmagZgb_��dhlhjh_�ihfh]eh�_fm�\dexqblv�\ ijhjhq_kl\h�h[Z�qbkeZ�b \ujZablv�kZfh_�kbevgh_�bkZfh_�lZcgh_�`_eZgb_�iZpb_gldb"�Y \b`m�lhevdh�^\Z�\hafh`guo�h[tykg_gby��Beb�wlZ�bklhjby\ lhf�\b^_��\ dZdhf�hgZ�hueZ�fg_�jZkkdZaZgZ��g_ijZ\^hih^h[gZ�b ijhbkoh^beZ�ih�^jm]hfm��bebke_^m_l� ijbagZlv�� qli� i_j_^ZqZ� fuke_c� y\ey_lky� j_Zevguf� n_ghf_ghf�� IjZ\^Z�� fh`gh

Page 279: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ij_^iheh`blv�b lh��qlh�ih�ijhr_kl\bb� ��� e_l�iZpb_gldZ� kZfZ� \klZ\beZ� \ \hkihfbgZgb_�h[ZqbkeZ��h dhlhjuo�b^_l�j_qv��\ay\�bo�ba�k\h_]h�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��M f_gy�g_l�gbdZdh]h�hkgh\Zgby^ey�wlh]h�ij_^iheh`_gby��gh�bkdexqblv�_]h�y g_�fh]m�b kqblZx��qlh�\u�kdhj__�ih\_jbl_�\ lZdh_h[tykg_gb_��g_`_eb�\ j_Zevghklv�i_j_^Zqb�fuke_c��?keb�`_�\u�j_rbl_kv�gZ�ihke_^g__��lh�g_aZ[u\Zcl_� h lhf�� qlh� ebrv� ZgZeba� \uy\be� hddmevlgu_�nZdlu�� \kdju\� bo� lZf�� ]^_� hgb� [uebbkdZ`_gu�^h�g_magZ\Z_fhklb�������������� _?keb�[u�j_qv�reZ� lhevdh�h[�h^ghf lZdhf� kemqZ_��dZd� k fh_c�iZpb_gldhc�� lh�fbfh�g_]hfh`gh� [ueh� [u� ijhclb�� ih`Z\� ie_qZfb��Gbdhfm� g_� ijbreh� [u� \ ]heh\m� hkgh\u\Zlv� \_jm�hagZqZxsmx�klhev�j_rbl_evguc�ih\hjhl��gZ�h^ghf�_^bgkl\_gghf�gZ[ex^_gbb��Gh�ih\_jvl_�wlh�g_�_^bgkl\_gguc�kemqZc�\ fh_f�hiul_��Y kh[jZe�p_euc�jy^�lZdbo�ijhjhq_kl\�b ba�\k_o�gbo\ug_k� \i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� ij_^kdZaZl_ev� \ujZabe� lhevdh� fukeb� h[jZlb\rboky� d g_fm� ebp� bhkh[_ggh� bo� lZcgu_� `_eZgby�� lZd� qlh� kijZ\_^eb\h� [ueh� [u� ijhZgZebabjh\Zlv� lZdb_ijhjhq_kl\Z�� dZd� _keb� [u� hgb� y\eyebkv� km[t_dlb\gufb� ijh^mdlZfb�� nZglZabyfb� bebkgh\b^_gbyfb�wlbo�ebp��Dhg_qgh��g_�\k_�kemqZb�h^bgZdh\h�^hdZaZl_evgu�b g_�^ey�\k_o�kjZamfh`gh�gZclb�[he__�jZpbhgZevgh_�h[tykg_gb_��gh�\k_�lZdb�\ p_ehf�hq_gv�\_ebdZ�\_jhylghklv^_ckl\bl_evghc�i_j_^Zqb�fuke_c��Ba�aZ�\Z`ghklb�ij_^f_lZ�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�ijb\_klb�\Zf�\k_fhb� kemqZb�� gh� wlh� g_\hafh`gh� \ke_^kl\b_� ijhkljZgghklb� bo� hibkZgby� b g_ba[_`gh]hgZjmr_gby�ijb� wlhf�\jZq_[ghc� wlbdb��IhiulZxkv�mkihdhblv�k\hx�kh\_klv��ijb\_^y�\Zf� _s_g_kdhevdh�ijbf_jh\�H^gZ`^u� f_gy� ihk_lbe� \_kvfZ� bgl_eeb]_glguc� fheh^hc� q_eh\_d�� klm^_gl� i_j_^� k\hbfihke_^gbf�wdaZf_ghf�gZ�kl_i_gv�^hdlhjZ��dhlhjuc�hg�g_�\ khklhygbb�[ue�k^Zlv��ihlhfm�qlh�dZd� hg� `Zeh\Zeky�� hg� mljZlbe� \k_� bgl_j_ku�� kihkh[ghklv� dhgp_gljZpbb�� ^Z`_� \hafh`ghklvmihjy^hq_ggh]h� \hkihfbgZgby�� Ij_^uklhjby� wlh]h� ih^h[gh]h� iZjZebqm� khklhygby� kdhjhjZkdjueZkv��hg�aZ[he_e�\ j_amevlZl_�h]jhfgh]h�kZfhij_h^he_gby��M g_]h�_klv�k_kljZ��d dhlhjhchg�hlghkbeky�k bgl_gkb\ghc��gh�ihklhyggh�k^_j`b\Z_fhc�ex[h\vx��dZd�b hgZ�d g_fm��DZd�`Zev�qlh�fu�g_�fh`_f�ih`_gblvky��g_j_^dh� ]h\hjbeb�hgb�f_`^m�kh[hc��H^bg�^hklhcguc�q_eh\_d\ex[beky�\ wlm�k_kljm��hgZ�hl\_lbeZ�_fm�[eZ]hkdehgghklvx��gh�jh^bl_eb�kh]eZkby�gZ�[jZd�g_^Zeb��< wlhf�[_^kl\_gghf�iheh`_gbb�fheh^Zy�iZjZ�h[jZlbeZkv�d [jZlm��b hg�g_�hldZaZe�bf�\ihfhsb��Hg� [ue� ihkj_^gbdhf� \ bo� i_j_ibkd_�� ih^� _]h� \ebygb_f� m^Zehkv� gZdhg_p� ^h[blvkykh]eZkby� jh^bl_e_c� gZ� [jZd�� IjZ\^Z�� aZ� \j_fy� ihfhe\db� ijhbahr_e� h^bg� kemqZc�� agZq_gb_dhlhjh]h� e_]dh� jZa]Z^Zlv��Hg�ij_^ijbgye� ljm^gh_�iml_r_kl\b_� \ ]hju� k [m^msbf� ayl_f� [_aijh\h^gbdZ�� hgb� k[bebkv� k imlb�� b bf� ]jhabeZ� hiZkghklv� g_� \_jgmlvky� gZaZ^� p_eufb� bg_\j_^bfufb�� <kdhj_� ihke_� aZfm`_kl\Z� k_klju� hg� \iZe� \ wlh� khklhygb_� ikbobq_kdh]hbklhs_gby�KlZ\� ih^� \ebygb_f� ikbohZgZebaZ� \gh\v� jZ[hlhkihkh[guf�� hg�ihdbgmlv�f_gy�� kh[bjZykvk^Z\Zlv� k\hb� wdaZf_gu�� gh� ihke_� m^Zqghc� bo� k^Zqb� hk_gvx� lh]h�`_� ]h^Z� gZ� dhjhldh_� \j_fykgh\Z� \_jgmeky� dh�fg_��Hg� jZkkdZaZe� h kljZgghf�i_j_`b\Zgbb�� dhlhjh_� hg�bkiulZe� \ dZgmge_lZ�� < bo� mgb\_jkbl_lkdhf� ]hjh^d_� [ueZ� h^gZ� ij_^kdZaZl_evgbpZ�� dhlhjZy� ihevah\ZeZkv[hevrbf� mki_ohf�� >Z`_� ijbgpu� ^bgZklbb� bf_eb� h[udgh\_gb_� i_j_^� \Z`gufb� ^_eZfbj_]meyjgh� dhgkmevlbjh\Zlvky� k g_c��Kihkh[�� ijb� ihfhsb� dhlhjh]h� hgZ� jZ[hlZeZ�� [ue� hq_gvijhkl��HgZ�ijhkbeZ�khh[sblv�_c�^Zlm�jh`^_gby�hij_^_e_ggh]h�ebpZ��g_�lj_[my�gbdZdbo�^jm]bo

Page 280: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

k\_^_gbc�� ^Z`_� bf_gb�� aZl_f� kijZ\eyeZkv� \ Zkljheh]bq_kdbo� dgb]Zo�� ijhba\h^beZ� ^he]b_\uqbke_gby� b gZdhg_p� \u^Z\ZeZ� ijhjhq_kl\h� h khhl\_lkl\mxs_f� ebp_��Fhc� iZpb_gl� j_rbe\hkihevah\Zlvky�__ lZbgkl\_gguf�bkdmkkl\hf�\ hlghr_gbb�k\h_]h�ayly��Hg�ihk_lbe�__��gZa\Z\lj_[m_fmx�^Zlm�jh`^_gby�ayly��Ihke_�lh]h�dZd�hgZ�ijhba\_eZ�k\hb�\uqbke_gby��hgZ�khh[sbeZijhjhq_kl\h�� wlh�ebph�mfj_l�hl�hljZ\e_gby�jZdZfb�beb�mkljbpZfb�\ bxe_�beb� Z\]mkl_� wlh]h]h^Z��Fhc�iZpb_gl�aZdhgqbe�k\hc�jZkkdZa�keh\Zfb��©Wlh�[ueh�ijhklh�\_ebdhe_igh�ªY k� kZfh]h� gZqZeZ� kemrZe� g_hohlgh��Ihke_� wlh]h� \hkdebpZgby� y iha\hebe� k_[_� \hijhk�©Qlh�`_ \_ebdhe_igh]h�\u�gZoh^bl_�\ wlhf�ijhjhq_kl\_"�K_cqZk�iha^gyy�hk_gv��\Zr�aylv�g_mf_j��wlh�[u�\u�khh[sbeb�fg_�kjZam��BlZd��ijhjhq_kl\h�g_�k[uehkvª��©Qlh�\_jgh��lh�\_jgh�²aZy\be� hg�²� gh� aZf_qZl_evgh� ke_^mxs__�� Fhc� aylv�� kljZklguc� ex[bl_ev� jZdh\� b mkljbp�ijhreuf� e_lhf�� l�� _�� ^h ihk_s_gby� ij_^kdZaZl_evgbpu�� i_j_g_k� hljZ\e_gb_� mkljbpZfb�� hldhlhjh]h� qmlv� g_� mf_jª�� Qlh� y fh]� kdZaZlv� gZ� wlh"� Y fh]� lhevdh� ih^hkZ^h\Zlv�� qlh\ukhdhh[jZah\Zgguc� q_eh\_d�� dhlhjuc�� djhf_� lh]h�� mki_rgh� ijhr_e� dmjk� ZgZebaZ�� g_� kfh]emqr_� jZa]ey^_lv� \aZbfhk\yab�� Y�� kh� k\h_c� klhjhgu�� ij_`^_� q_f� ih\_jblv� lhfm�� qlh� ihZkljheh]bq_kdbf� dgb]Zf� fh`gh� \uqbkeblv� hljZ\e_gb_� jZdZfb� beb� mkljbpZfb�� hohlg__ij_^iheh`be� [u�� qlh�fhc� iZpb_gl� \k_� _s_� g_� ij_h^he_e� g_gZ\bklb� d k\h_fm� khi_jgbdm�� hl\ul_kg_gby�dhlhjhc�hg�\ k\h_�\j_fy� aZ[he_e��b qlh�ij_^kdZaZl_evgbpZ�ijhklh� \ukdZaZeZ� _]hkh[kl\_ggmx�gZ^_`^m��hl�lZdbo�ijbkljZklbc�g_�hldZau\Zxlky��b dh]^Z�gb[m^v�hg�\k_�lZdb�hlwlh]h�ih]b[g_l��Y ml\_j`^Zx��qlh�^ey� wlh]h� kemqZy� y g_� agZx�gbdZdh]h�^jm]h]h�h[tykg_gby�djhf_��fh`_l�[ulv��lh]h��qlh�fhc�iZpb_gl�iha\hebe�k_[_�kh�fghc�ihrmlblv��Gh�hg�g_�ih^Z\Zegb lh]^Z��gb iha`_�hkgh\Zgby�^ey� lZdh]h�ih^haj_gby�b��dZaZehkv��qlh�\k_��h q_f�hg� ]h\hjbe�[ueh�k_jv_agh�>jm]hc�kemqZc��H^bg�fheh^hc�q_eh\_d��aZgbfZxsbc�\b^gh_�iheh`_gb_��khklhbl�\ k\yab�kg_dh_c� k\_lkdhc� ^Zfhc�� ijhy\eyy� ijb� wlhf� kljZggh_� gZkbeb_��<j_fy� hl� \j_f_gb� hg� ^he`_gijbqbgylv� k\h_c� \haex[e_gghc� [hev� gZkf_rdZfb� b ba^_\dZfb�� ihdZ� lZ� g_� \iZ^_l� \ ihegh_hlqZygb_��>h\_^y�__ ^h�lZdh]h�khklhygby��hg�qm\kl\m_l�h[e_]q_gb_��fbjblky�k g_c�b h^Zjb\Z_lih^ZjdZfb��Gh�l_i_jv�hg�ohl_e�[u�hk\h[h^blvky�hl�g__��gZkbeb_�_fm�g_ijbylgh��hg�aZf_qZ_l�qlh� _]h� kh[kl\_ggZy� j_imlZpby� kljZ^Z_l� hl� wlhc� k\yab�� hg� ohq_l�bf_lv�`_gm�� aZ\_klb� k_fvx�Ihkdhevdm� hg� g_� fh`_l� kh[kl\_ggufb� kbeZfb� hk\h[h^blvky� hl� wlhc� ^Zfu�� hg� ijb[_]Z_l� dihfhsb�ZgZebaZ��Ihke_�h^ghc�lZdhc�hkdhj[bl_evghc�kp_gu��m`_�\h�\j_fy�ZgZebaZ��hg�ijhkbl�__gZibkZlv�_fm�hldjulhqdm��dhlhjmx�ij_^eZ]Z_l�]jZnheh]m��AZdexq_gb_��ihemq_ggh_�bf��]eZkbl�wlh� ihq_jd� q_eh\_dZ�� gZoh^ys_]hky� \ \ukr_c� kl_i_gb� hlqZygby�� dhlhjuc� g_ij_f_ggh� \[eb`Zcrb_�^gb�ihdhgqbl� k kh[hc��IjZ\^Z�� wlh]h� g_�ijhbkoh^bl�� ^ZfZ� hklZ_lky� \ `b\uo�� ghiml_f� ZgZebaZ�m^Z_lky�hkeZ[blv� _]h� hdh\u��hg� hklZ\ey_l�^Zfm�b ^Zjbl� k\h_� \gbfZgb_� h^ghcfheh^hc�^_\mrd_��hl�dhlhjhc�`^_l��qlh�hgZ�[m^_l�^ey�g_]h�ohjhr_c�`_ghc��<kdhj_�ihke_�wlh]h_fm� kgblky� khg�� dhlhjuc� fh`gh� bklhedh\Zlv� lhevdh� dZd� gZqbgZxs__ky� khfg_gb_� \^hklhbgkl\Zo�wlhc�^_\mrdb��Hg�b m�g__�[_j_l�h[jZa_p�ihq_jdZ��ij_^eh`b\�_]h�aZl_f�lhfm�`_Z\lhjbl_lm�� b � magZ_l� km`^_gb_� h __� ihq_jd_�� ih^l\_j`^Zxs__� _]h� khfg_gby�� Lh]^Z� hghldZau\Z_lky�hl�gZf_j_gby�k^_eZlv�__ k\h_c�`_ghc�Qlh[u� hp_gblv� lhedh\Zgby� ]jZnheh]Z�� hkh[_ggh� i_j\h_�� gm`gh� dh_�qlh� agZlv� ba� lZcghcbklhjbb�gZr_]h�fheh^h]h�q_eh\_dZ��< jZgg_f�xghr_kdhf�\hajZkl_�hg�[ue�^h�[_amfby�\ex[e_g

Page 281: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ khhl\_lkl\bb�kh�k\h_c�kljZklghc�gZlmjhc�\ h^gm�fheh^mx�`_gsbgm��dhlhjZy�[ueZ��h^gZdh�klZjr_� _]h�� Ihemqb\� hl� g__� hldZa�� hg� kh\_jrbe� ihiuldm� kZfhm[bckl\Z�� k_jv_aghklv� _]hgZf_j_gby�g_�\uau\Z_l�khfg_gby��Lhevdh�[eZ]h^Zjy�kemqZcghklb�hg�ba[_`Ze�kf_jlb��b ebrvihke_� ^ebl_evgh]h� moh^Z� kbeu� _]h� \hkklZgh\bebkv�� Gh� _]h� ^bdbc� ihklmihd� ijhba\_e� gZex[bfmx� `_gsbgm� ]em[hdh_� \i_qZle_gb_�� hgZ� ih^ZjbeZ� _fm� [eZ]hkdehgghklv�� hg� klZe� __\haex[e_gguf��k l_o�ihj�[ue�k g_c�\ lZcghc�k\yab�b kem`be�_c��dZd�gZklhysbc�jupZjv��Kimkly[he__� ^\mo� ^_kylbe_lbc�� dh]^Z� h[Z� ihklZj_eb��`_gsbgZ�� _kl_kl\_ggh�� [hevr_�� q_f� hg�� \ g_fijhkgmeZkv� ihlj_[ghklv� hl^_eZlvky� hl� g__�� klZlv� k\h[h^guf�� \_klb� kZfhklhyl_evgmx�`bagv�aZ\_klb� k\hc�^hf�b k_fvx��B h^gh\j_f_ggh� k wlhc�ij_kus_gghklvx� m g_]h�ihy\beZkv�^he]hih^Z\ey_fZy� ihlj_[ghklv� f_klb� k\h_c� \haex[e_gghc�� ?keb� dh]^Z�lh� hg� ohl_e� ihdhgqblv� kkh[hc��ihlhfm�qlh�hgZ�ij_g_[j_]eZ�bf��lh�l_i_jv�_fm�aZohl_ehkv�gZclb�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�\ lhf�qlh� hgZ� [m^_l� bkdZlv� kf_jlb�� ihlhfm� qlh� hg� hklZ\bl� __��Gh� _]h� ex[h\v� [ueZ� _s_� kebrdhfkbevghc�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�wlh�`_eZgb_�fh]eh�klZlv�hkhagZgguf��hg�[ue� lZd`_�g_�\ khklhygbbijbqbgblv�_c�^hklZlhqgh�aeZ��qlh[u�^h\_klb�__ ^h�kf_jlb��< lZdhf�khklhygbb�^moZ�hg�k^_eZek\_lkdmx�^Zfm�\ ba\_klghc�kl_i_gb�fZevqbdhf�^ey�[blvy��qlh[u LQ�FRUSRUH�YLOL m^h\e_l\hjblvk\hx�`Z`^m�f_klb��ijbqbgyy�_c�\kydb_�fmq_gby��h`b^Zy�hl�gbo�lh]h�bkoh^Z��dhlhjh]h�hg�`_eZeih�hlghr_gbx�d ex[bfhc�`_gsbg_��Lh��qlh�f_klv�hlghkbeZkv��kh[kl\_ggh��d wlhc�ihke_^g_c�\u^Z_l�ebrv�lh�h[klhyl_evkl\h��qlh�hg�ihk\ylbe�__ \�k\hx�ex[h\gmx�k\yav��k^_eZ\�__ k\h_ckh\_lqbp_c��\f_klh�lh]h�qlh[u�kdjulv�hl�g__�k\h_�iZ^_gb_��G_kqZklgZy�^Z\gh��\b^bfh��kljZ^ZeZhl�_]h�nZfbevyjghklb�[hevr_��q_f�k\_lkdZy�^ZfZ�hl�_]h�`_klhdhklb��GZkbeb_��gZ�dhlhjh_�hg`Zeh\Zeky�ih�hlghr_gbx�d ih^klZ\ghfm�ebpm�b dhlhjh_�ijb\_eh�_]h�d ZgZebam��[ueh��dhg_qgh�i_j_g_k_gh� kh� klZjhc� \haex[e_gghc� gZ� g__�� wlZ� ihke_^gyy� [ueZ� lhc�� hl� dhlhjhc� hg� ohl_ehk\h[h^blvky�b g_�fh]��Y g_�]jZnheh]�b g_�\ukhdh]h�fg_gby�h[�bkdmkkl\_�m]Z^u\Zlv�oZjZdl_jih� ihq_jdm�� _s_� f_gvr_� y \_jx� \ \hafh`ghklv� ij_^kdZau\Zlv� lZdbf� h[jZahf� [m^ms__ibkZ\r_]h��Gh�\u�\b^bl_��dZd�gb jZa^mfu\Zc�h p_gghklb�]jZnheh]bb��g_khfg_ggh��qlh�wdki_jl�h[_sZy�� qlh� gZibkZ\rbc� ij_^eh`_ggmx� _fm� ijh[m� \ [eb`Zcr__� \j_fy� ihdhgqbl� k kh[hc�\uy\ey_l� hiylv�lZdb� lhevdh� kbevgh_� lZcgh_� `_eZgb_� h[jZlb\r_]hky� d g_fm� ebpZ�� G_qlhih^h[gh_�ijhbahreh�b ijb�\lhjhf�lhedh\Zgbb��jZa\_�qlh�a^_kv�j_qv�reZ�g_�h [_kkhagZl_evghf`_eZgbb��Z h�lhf��qlh�aZjh`^Z\rb_ky�khfg_gby�b haZ[hq_gghklv�kijZrb\Zxs_]h�gZreb�k\h_ykgh_� \ujZ`_gb_� \ mklZo� ]jZnheh]Z��<ijhq_f��fh_fm� iZpb_glm� m^Zehkv� k ihfhsvx� ZgZebaZk^_eZlv�\u[hj�\haex[e_gghc�aZ�ij_^_eZfb�aZdhe^h\Zggh]h�djm]Z��\ dhlhjuc�hg�ihiZe�>Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��<hl�\u�\ukemrZeb��qlh� lhedh\Zgb_� kgh\b^_gbc�b ikbohZgZeba� \hh[s_k^_eZeb�^ey�hddmevlbafZ��GZ�ijbf_jZo�\u�\b^_eb��qlh�[eZ]h^Zjy�bo�bkihevah\Zgbx�hddmevlgu_nZdlu��dhlhju_�hklZebkv �GZ�fZehp_gghf�h[t_dl_��eZl��²�Ijbf_q�j_^��i_j_\h^Z[u� g_ijhgbpZ_fufb�� ijhykgbebkv�� GZ� \hijhk�� dhlhjuc�� g_khfg_ggh�� bgl_j_km_l� \Zk[hevr_�\k_]h�²�fh`gh�eb�\_jblv�\ h[t_dlb\gmx�j_Zevghklv�wlbo�nZdlh\"�²�ikbohZgZeba�g_fh`_l�hl\_lblv�ijyfh��h^gZdh�\uy\e_gguc�k _]h�ihfhsvx�fZl_jbZe�ijhba\h^bl�ih�f_gvr_cf_j_� [eZ]hijbylgh_� \i_qZle_gb_� ^ey� ml\_j^bl_evgh]h� hl\_lZ�� GZ� wlhf� \Zr� bgl_j_k� g_bkq_jiu\Z_lky��<u�aZohlbl_�magZlv��ijZ\h�gZ�dZdb_�\u\h^u�^Z_l�lhl�g_kjZ\g_ggh�[he__�[h]ZlucfZl_jbZe��d dhlhjhfm�ikbohZgZeba�g_ijbqZkl_g��Gh�\ wlhf�y g_�fh]m�\Zf�ihfhqv��wlh�m`_�g_

Page 282: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fhy� h[eZklv��?^bgkl\_ggh_�� qlh� y fh]m� _s_� k^_eZlv�� wlh� jZkkdZaZlv� h gZ[ex^_gbyo�� dhlhju_bf_xl�d ZgZebam�ohlv�dZdh_�lh�hlghr_gb_��hgb�[ueb�k^_eZgu�\h�\j_fy�ZgZeblbq_kdh]h�e_q_gby�fh`_l�[ulv��^Z`_�klZeb�\hafh`gu�[eZ]h^Zjy�_]h�\ebygbx��Y ijb\_^m�\Zf�h^bg�lZdhc�ijbf_j�lhl�� dhlhjuc� ijhba\_e� gZ� f_gy� kZfh_� kbevgh_� \i_qZle_gb_�� k^_eZx� wlh� hq_gv� ih^jh[gh�aZ^_j`m�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�h[bebb�qZklghkl_c��b \k_�lZdb�ijb�wlhf�ijb^_lky�himklblv�fgh]h_�qlh� hq_gv� ih\ukbeh� [u� m[_^bl_evghklv� gZ[ex^_gby�� Wlh� ijbf_j�� \ dhlhjhf� nZdlu� ykghijhklmiZxl� b bo� g_� gm`gh� jZkimlu\Zlv� ijb� ihfhsb� ZgZebaZ��H^gZdh�� h[km`^Zy� bo�� fu� g_kfh`_f�h[hclbkv�[_a�g__��Gh�y aZjZg__�ij_^mij_`^Zx�\Zk��qlh�^Z`_�wlhl�ijbf_j�dZ`ms_ckyi_j_^Zqb� fuke_c� gZ� jZkklhygbb� \ ZgZeblbq_kdhc� kblmZpbb� g_� aZkljZoh\Zg� hl� \kyq_kdbokhfg_gbc�b g_�iha\hey_l�[_amkeh\gh�ijbgylv�aZ�j_Zevghklv�hddmevlguc�n_ghf_g�BlZd�� ihkemrZcl_��H^gZ`^u� hk_gvx� ����� ]�� ijbf_jgh� [_a� q_l\_jlb� ��� mljZ� lhevdh� qlhijb[u\rbc�ba�Ehg^hgZ� ^�j >w\b^�NhjkZcl�ih^Ze�fg_� \bablgmx� dZjlhqdm� \ lh� \j_fy�� dZd� yaZgbfZeky�h^gbf�iZpb_glhf���Fhc�m\Z`Z_fuc�dhee_]Z�ba�Ehg^hgkdh]h�mgb\_jkbl_lZ��dhg_qgh�g_�khql_l� aZ� [_klZdlghklv�� _keb� y hldjhx�� qlh� \ l_q_gb_� g_kdhevdbo� f_kyp_\� \\h^be� _]h� \bkdmkkl\h� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_ogbdb���M f_gy� [ueh� \j_fy� lhevdh� ihijb\_lkl\h\Zlv� _]h� bijb]eZkblv�gZ�[he__�iha^gbc�qZk��M f_gy�^�j NhjkZcl�\uau\Ze�hkh[uc�bgl_j_k��hg�[ue�i_j\ufbghkljZgp_f�� dhlhjuc� ijb[ue� dh� fg_� ihke_� baheypbb� \h_gguo� e_l�� agZf_gmy� k\hbfihy\e_gb_f�gZklmie_gb_�emqrbo�\j_f_g��<kdhj_�ihke_�wlh]h��\ ���qZkh\��ijbr_e�h^bg�ba�fhboiZpb_glh\��]hkih^bg�I���hkljhmfguc�b ex[_aguc�q_eh\_d�\ \hajZkl_�f_`^m����b ����dhlhjuc�\k\h_� \j_fy� h[jZlbeky� dh� fg_� ba�aZ� ljm^ghkl_c� k `_gsbgZfb�� ?]h� kemqZc� g_� ij_^\_sZel_jZi_\lbq_kdh]h� mki_oZ�� y ^Z\gh� ij_^eZ]Ze� _fm� ij_djZlblv� e_q_gb_�� gh� hg� ohl_e� _]hijh^he`_gby��hq_\b^gh��ihlhfm�qlh�ijbylgh�hsmsZe�k_[y�\ >khklhygbb@�i_j_g_k_gby�qm\kl\ZgZ�f_gy�dZd�gZ�hlpZ��>_gv]b�\ l_�\j_f_gZ�g_�b]jZeb�gbdZdhc�jheb��lZd�dZd�bo�[ueh�kebrdhffZeh��qZku��dhlhju_�y ijh\h^be�k gbf��[ueb�b ^ey�f_gy�ijbylguf�\ha[m`^_gb_f�b hl^uohf��blZdbf� h[jZahf�� \hij_db� kljh]bf� ijZ\beZf� \jZq_[ghc� ijZdlbdb�� ZgZeblbq_kdb_� aZgylbyijh^he`Zebkv�^h�gZf_q_ggh]h�kjhdZ�< wlhl�^_gv�I��\_jgmeky�d k\hbf�ihiuldZf�mklZgh\blv�k `_gsbgZfb�ex[h\gu_�hlghr_gbyb hiylv�mihfygme�h djZkb\hc�ibdZglghc�[_^ghc�^_\mrd_��m dhlhjhc�hg�fh]�[u�bf_lv�mki_o�_keb�[u�hl�ex[h]h�k_jv_agh]h�rZ]Z�_]h�g_�hlim]gme�nZdl�__ ^_\kl\_gghklb��Hg�b jZgvr_�qZklh]h\hjbe� h g_c�� k_]h^gy�`_� \ i_j\uc� jZa� jZkkdZaZe�� qlh� hgZ�� dhg_qgh� g_� bf_y� gb�fZe_cr_]hij_^klZ\e_gby� h ^_ckl\bl_evguo� ijbqbgZo� _]h� aZljm^g_gby�� h[uqgh� gZau\Z_l� _]h� ©]hkih^bg9RUVLFKWª >nhjabol�²�hklhjh`ghklv@��Wlh�khh[s_gb_�ihjZabeh�f_gy��dZjlhqdZ�^�jZ�NhjkZclZ[ueZ�m f_gy�ih^�jmdhc��y ihdZaZe�__ _fm�LZdh\u�nZdlu��Ij_^iheZ]Zx��qlh�hgb�ihdZaZebkv�\Zf�kdm^gufb��gh�\u�lhevdh�ihkemrZcl_^Zevr_��aZ�wlbf�djh_lky�[hevr__�G_kdhevdh� e_l� k\h_c� xghklb� I�� ijh`be� \ :g]ebb� b k� l_o� ihj� khojZgbe� ihklhyggucbgl_j_k� d Zg]ebckdhc� ebl_jZlmj_�� M g_]h� [ueZ� [h]ZlZy� Zg]ebckdZy� [b[ebhl_dZ�� hg� bf_eh[udgh\_gb_�ijbghkblv�fg_� �ba�g__�dgb]b��b _fm�y h[yaZg�agZdhfkl\m�k lZdbfb�Z\lhjZfb��dZd;Agg_l� b =hekmhjkb�� dhlhjuo� y ^h� wlh]h� fZeh� qblZe��H^gZ`^u� hg� ^Ze� fg_� ihqblZlv� jhfZg=hekmhjkb� ih^� gZa\Zgb_f� Q_eh\_d�kh[kl\_ggbd� dhlhjuc� jZau]ju\Z_lky� \ ijb^mfZgghcibkZl_e_f�k_fv_�NhjkZcl �)RUV\WH���Hq_\b^gh��=hekmhjkb�kZf�ie_gbeky�wlhc�\u^mfdhc��ihlhfm

Page 283: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

qlh� b \� [he__�iha^gbo� jZkkdZaZo� hg�g_h^ghdjZlgh� \ha\jZsZ_lky� d i_jkhgZ`Zf� wlhc� k_fvb� bgZdhg_p�kh[bjZ_l�\k_�dZkZxsb_ky�bo�khqbg_gby�ih^�gZa\Zgb_f�KZ]Z�h NhjkZclZo� <k_]h�ebrvaZ�g_kdhevdh�^g_c�^h�hibku\Z_fh]h�kemqZy�I��ijbg_k�fg_�gh\uc�lhf�ba�wlhc�k_jbb��NZfbebyNhjkZcl� b \k_� lbibqgh_�� qlh� ohl_e� \hiehlblv� \ g_c� ibkZl_ev�� b]jZeZ� jhev� lZd`_� b \� fhbo[_k_^Zo� k I��� klZ\� qZklvx� lZcgh]h� yaudZ�� lZd� qZklh� \hagbdZxs_]h�f_`^m� ^\mfy� ebpZfb� ijbihklhygghf�h[s_gbb��IjZ\^Z��nZfbeby�NhjkZcl �)RUV\WH� \ l_o�jhfZgZo�g_fgh]h�hlebqZ_lky�hlnZfbebb� fh_]h� ihk_lbl_ey� NhjkZclZ �)RUV\WK�� ^ey� g_f_pdh]h� ijhbaghr_gby� wlh� _^\ZjZaebqbfh�� Z kfukeh\h_� Zg]ebckdh_� keh\h�� ijhbaghkbfh_� gZfb� lZd`_� IRUHVLJKW O nhjkZcl@�i_j_\h^blky�� ij_^\b^_gb_� beb� hklhjh`ghklv�� BlZd�� I�� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� ba� k\hbo� ebqguo\aZbfhk\ya_c�ba\e_d�lm�`_�kZfmx�nZfbebx��dhlhjZy�\ wlh�`_�\j_fy�\ke_^kl\b_�g_ba\_klgh]h_fm�kh[ulby�aZgbfZeZ�f_gy�G_� ijZ\^Z� eb�� wlh� \u]ey^bl� m`_� emqr_��Gh� y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� fu� ihemqbf� [he__� kbevgh_\i_qZle_gb_� hl� wlh]h� kljZggh]h� n_ghf_gZ� b ^Z`_� dZd� [u� ijhgbdg_f� \ mkeh\by� _]h\hagbdgh\_gby��_keb�ZgZeblbq_kdb�hk\_lbf�^\_�^jm]b_�ZkkhpbZpbb��dhlhju_�ijb\_e�I��bf_ggh�\lhl�qZk�<h�i_j\uo��\ h^bg�ba�^g_c�gZ�ijhrehc�g_^_e_�y gZijZkgh�ijh`^Ze�]hkih^bgZ�I��\ ���qZkh\b aZl_f�mr_e�gZ\_klblv�^�jZ�:glhgZ�nhg�Nj_cg^Z�\ _]h�iZgkbhg_��Y [ue�ihjZ`_g��magZ\��qlh]hkih^bg�I��`be� gZ� ^jm]hf� wlZ`_� ^hfZ�� ]^_� ihf_sZeky� iZgkbhg��< k\yab� k wlbf� y iha^g__jZkkdZaZe�I���qlh�y _]h��fh`gh�kdZaZlv��ihk_lbe�\ _x�^hf_��gh�y gZ\_jgydZ�agZx��qlh�y g_�gZa\ZenZfbebb�ebpZ��dhlhjh]h�y ihk_lbe�\ iZgkbhg_��B \hl�\kdhj_�ihke_�mihfbgZgby�]hkih^bgZ�nhgNhjabol� �9RUVLFKW� hg�kijZrb\Z_l�f_gy�� ©G_� y\ey_lky�eb�Nj_c^�Hllhj_]h� dhlhjZy�qblZ_l�\gZjh^ghf�mgb\_jkbl_l_�dmjk�Zg]ebckdh]h�yaudZ��<Zr_c�^hq_jvx"ª�B \i_j\u_�aZ�^he]h_�\j_fyh[s_gby�hg�^himkdZ_l�bkdZ`_gb_�fh_c�nZfbebb��d dhlhjhfm�f_gy��ijZ\^Z��ijbmqbeb�\eZklb�qbgh\gbdb�/�gZ[hjsbdb��hg�kdZaZe�\f_klh�Nj_c^�²�Nj_cg^�<h�\lhjuo�� \ dhgp_� lh]h� `_� qZkZ� hg� jZkkdZaZe� khg�� hl� dhlhjh]h� \ kljZo_� ijhkgmeky�gZklhysbc��ih�_]h�keh\Zf��dhrfZj��Hg�^h[Z\be��qlh�g_^Z\gh�aZ[ue��dZd�wlh�[m^_l�ih�Zg]ebckdbb kdZaZe�kijZrb\Zxs_fm��qlh�ih�Zg]ebckdb�dhrfZjguc�khg�gZau\Z_lky� ©^ PDUHV� QHVWª� Wlh�dhg_qgh��[_kkfukebpZ� D�PDUHV�QHVW hagZqZ_l�g_\_jhylgmx�bklhjbx��g_[uebpm��dhrfZjguc�khg`_�i_j_\h^blky�dZd ©QLJKW�PDUHª� Wlhl�kemqZc��dZ`_lky��g_�bf__l�k ij_^u^msbf�gbq_]h�h[s_]h�djhf_� h^gh]h� we_f_glZ�²� Zg]ebckdh]h� yaudZ�� gh�fg_� hg� gZihfgbe� h^bg�fZe_gvdbc� wibah^�ijhbkr_^rbc�ijbf_jgh�gZ�f_kyp�jZgvr_��I��kb^_e�m f_gy�\ dhfgZl_��dh]^Z�g_h`b^Zggh�ihke_^he]hc�jZaemdb� dh�fg_� \hr_e�^jm]hc�ijbylguc�fg_� ]hklv�ba�Ehg^hgZ��^�j Wjg_kl�>`hgk��Yih^Ze�_fm�agZd�ijhclb�\ ^jm]mx�dhfgZlm��ihdZ�y ^h]h\hjxkv�k I��Gh�lhl�kjZam�magZe�_]h�ih\bkys_c�\ ijb_fghc�nhlh]jZnbb�b ^Z`_�\ujZabe�`_eZgb_�[ulv�_fm�ij_^klZ\e_gguf��: >`hgky\ey_lky�Z\lhjhf�fhgh]jZnbb�h dhrfZjghf�kg_�² QLJKW�PDUH ��������y g_�agZe��ba\_klgZ�eb�hgZ[ueZ�I��Lhl�ba[_]Ze�qblZlv�ZgZeblbq_kdb_�dgb]b�KgZqZeZ�y ohl_e�[u�ihdZaZlv�\Zf��dZd�fh`gh�ZgZeblbq_kdb�ihgylv�k\yav�nZglZabc�I��b bofhlb\bjh\db��< hlghr_gbb�nZfbebb )RUV\WH�beb )RUV\WK I��bf_e�lm�`_�mklZgh\dm��qlh�b y��hgZhagZqZeZ� ^ey� g_]h� lh� `_� kZfh_�� y \hh[s_� h[yaZg� _fm� agZdhfkl\hf� k wlhc� nZfbeb_c�Ijbf_qZl_evguf�[ue�nZdl��qlh�hg�\g_k�wlm�nZfbebx�g_h`b^Zggh�\ ZgZeba�\kdhj_�ihke_�lh]h�dZd� \ j_amevlZl_� gh\h]h� kh[ulby�� ijb[ulby� ehg^hgkdh]h� \jZqZ�� hgZ� ijbh[j_eZ� ^ey� f_gy

Page 284: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

agZq_gb_� \ ^jm]hf� kfuke_�� Gh� fh`_l� [ulv�� g_� f_g__� bgl_j_kguf�� q_f� kZf� nZdl�� y\ey_lkykihkh[� ihy\e_gby� nZfbebb� \ gZr_c� ZgZeblbq_kdhc� [_k_^_�� Hg� ^Z`_� g_� kdZaZe�� k_cqZk� fg_ijbreZ� \ ]heh\m� nZfbeby )RUV\WH ba� ba\_klguo� \Zf� jhfZgh\�� gh� kmf_e� \ie_klb� __� \ k\hbi_j_`b\Zgby�[_ah�\kydh]h�hkhagZggh]h�hlghr_gby�d wlhfm�bklhqgbdm�b ba\e_d�__ hllm^Z�gZ�k\_l[h`bc��qlh�fh]eh�[u�ijhbahclb�^Z\gh��gh�^h�kbo�ihj�g_�ijhbkoh^beh��: aZl_f�hg�kdZaZe�y lh`_� NhjkZcl�� \_^v� ^_\mrdZ� f_gy� lZd� gZau\Z_l�� Ljm^gh� g_� jZkihagZlv� kf_r_gbyj_\gb\h]h�ijblyaZgby� b ]hjvdh]h� kZfhmgbqb`_gby�� dhlhju_� gZoh^yl� k\h_� \ujZ`_gb_� \ wlhf\ukdZau\Zgbb��Fu�g_�hrb[_fky�� _keb�^hihegbf� _]h�ijbf_jgh� lZd��f_gy�h[b`Z_l��qlh�<Zrbfukeb�p_ebdhf�aZgylu�ijb[u\rbf��<_jgbl_kv�\k_�lZdb�dh�fg_��y \_^v�lh`_�NhjkZcl��)RUV\WK�²ijZ\^Z��\k_]h�ebrv�]hkih^bg�nhg�Nhjabol� >hklhjh`ghklv@��dZd�]h\hjbl�^_\mrdZ��B \hl�oh^_]h� fuke_c� \ha\jZsZ_lky� ih� ZkkhpbZlb\ghc� gblb� we_f_glZ� ©Zg]ebckdbcª� d ^\mf� ij_`gbfh[klhyl_evkl\Zf�� dhlhju_� fh]eb� \ua\Zlv� lm� `_� j_\ghklv�� ©G_kdhevdh� ^g_c� lhfm� gZaZ^� <ugZg_keb�\babl�\ fhc�^hf��gh��d kh`Ze_gbx��g_�fg_��Z dZdhfm�lh�]hkih^bgm�nhg�Nj_cg^mª� WlZfukev� aZklZ\ey_l� _]h� baf_gblv� nZfbebx� Nj_c^� gZ� Nj_cg^�� NZfbeby� Nj_c^�Hllhj_]h \e_dpbhgghc� ijh]jZff_� ^he`gZ� [ueZ� [ulv� ijb\e_q_gZ� ihlhfm�� qlh� hgZ�� dZd� ijbgZ^e_`ZsZyij_ih^Z\Zl_evgbp_� Zg]ebckdh]h� yaudZ�� kihkh[kl\h\ZeZ� y\ghc� ZkkhpbZpbb�� : aZl_fijbkh_^bgy_lky�\hkihfbgZgb_�h ^jm]hf�ihk_lbl_e_��ijb[u\r_f�aZ�g_kdhevdh�g_^_ev�^h�lh]h�ih�hlghr_gbx�d dhlhjhfm�hg��dhg_qgh��lh`_�bkiulu\Ze�qm\kl\h�j_\ghklb��gh�\ lh�`_�\j_fyihgbfZe�� qlh� g_� fh`_l� k gbf� khi_jgbqZlv�� lZd� dZd� ^�j >`hgk� kmf_e� gZibkZlv� jZ[hlm� hdhrfZjghf� kg_�� Z hg� wlb� kgu� \ emqr_f� kemqZ_� \b^_e� kZf��B mihfbgZgb_� h k\h_c� hrb[d_� \agZq_gbb ©D� PDUHV� QHVWª hlghkblky� d wlhc� `_� k\yab�� wlbf� _fm� ohl_ehkv� kdZaZlv� ebrvke_^mxs__�� y \_^v� \k_�lZdb� g_� gZklhysbc� Zg]ebqZgbg�� lZd�`_� dZd� b g_� gZklhysbc�NhjkZcl�)RUV\WK��?]h�j_\gb\u_�ih[m`^_gby�y g_�fh]m�gZa\Zlv�gb g_mf_klgufb��gb g_ihgylgufb��Hg�[ueih^]hlh\e_g�d lhfm��qlh�_]h�aZgylby�ZgZebahf��Z k�gbfb�b gZr_�h[s_gb_�aZdhgqZlky��dZd�lhevdh\ <_gm� ijb[m^ml� bghkljZggu_� mq_gbdb� b iZpb_glu�� b lZd� hgh� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� \kdhj_� bijhbahreh�� Gh� lh�� q_]h� fu� ^h� kbo� ihj� ^hklb]eb�� [ueh� qZklvx� ZgZeblbq_kdhc� jZ[hlu�h[tykgb\r_c�ljb�nZglZabb��ijhbkr_^rb_�\ h^bg�b lhl�`_�qZk��ijh^bdlh\Zggu_�h^gbf�b l_f�`_fhlb\hf��Z wlh�bf__l�g_fgh]h�h[s_]h�k ^jm]bf�\hijhkhf��fh]ml�eb�wlb�nZglZabb�\hagbdgmlv[_a�i_j_^Zqb�fuke_c�beb�g_l"�Ihke_^g__�bf__l�hlghr_gb_�d dZ`^hc�ba�lj_o�nZglZabc�b��lZdbfh[jZahf��jZkiZ^Z_lky�gZ�ljb�hl^_evguo�\hijhkZ��fh]�eb�I��agZlv��qlh�^�j NhjkZcl�lhevdh�qlhgZg_k�fg_�k\hc�i_j\uc�\babl"�Fh]�eb�hg�agZlv�nZfbebx�ebpZ��dhlhjh_�y ihk_lbe�\ _]h�^hf_"AgZe�eb�hg��qlh�^�j >`hgk�gZibkZe�jZ[hlm�h dhrfZjghf�kg_"�Beb�wlh�[ueh�lhevdh�fh_�agZgb_h[� wlbo� \_sZo�� dhlhjh_� ijhy\behkv� \ _]h� nZglZabyo"� Hl� hl\_lZ� gZ� wlb� ljb� \hijhkZ� [m^_laZ\bk_lv��iha\hebl�eb�fh_�gZ[ex^_gb_�k^_eZlv�\u\h^�\ ihevam�i_j_g_k_gby�fuke_c��HklZ\bf�gZg_dhlhjh_�\j_fy�i_j\uc�\hijhk��\ ^\mo�^jm]bo�e_]q_�jZah[jZlvky��KemqZc�k \bablhf�\ iZgkbhgijhba\h^bl�gZ�i_j\uc�\a]ey^�hkh[_ggh�h[gZ^_`b\Zxs__�\i_qZle_gb_��Y m\_j_gA�qlh�\ k\h_fdhjhldhf�rmleb\hf�mihfbgZgbb�h \babl_�\ _]h�^hf_�y g_�gZa\Ze�gbdZdhc�nZfbebb��b kqblZx\_kvfZ�fZeh\_jhylguf��qlh�I��kijZ\eyeky�\ iZgkbhg_�h nZfbebb�ebpZ��h dhlhjhf�b^_l�j_qv�kdhj__� y ij_^iheh`m�� qlh� h _]h� kms_kl\h\Zgbb� lhfm� [ueh� kh\_jr_ggh� g_ba\_klgh�� Gh^hdZaZl_evghklv�wlh]h�kemqZy�ih^\_j]Z_lky�hkgh\Zl_evghfm�khfg_gbx�ba�aZ�h^ghc�kemqZcghklb�Q_eh\_d��dhlhjh]h�y gZ\_klbe�\ iZgkbhg_��g_�lhevdh�ghkbe�nZfbebx�Nj_cg^ �)UHXQG�� gh�hg�[ue

Page 285: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

^ey� gZk� \k_o� gZklhysbf� ^jm]hf� �� Wlh� [ue� ^�j :glhg� Nj_cg^�� [eZ]h^Zjy� ih`_jl\h\Zgbxdhlhjh]h�[ueh�hkgh\Zgh�gZr_�ba^Zl_evkl\h��?]h�[_a\j_f_ggZy�dhgqbgZ��dZd�b kf_jlv�gZr_]hDZjeZ� :[jZoZfZ� g_kdhevdh� e_l� kimkly�� [ueb� kZfufb� ly`_eufb� mljZlZfb�� ihklb]rbfbikbohZgZeba��BlZd�� y fh]� [u� lh]^Z� kdZaZlv� ]hkih^bgm�I��� ©Y ihk_lbe� \ \Zr_f� ^hf_� h^gh]h^jm]Zª� b k�wlhc�\hafh`ghklvx�hddmevlguc�bgl_j_k�d _]h�\lhjhc�ZkkhpbZpbb�bkq_aZ_l�<i_qZle_gb_�hl�lj_lv_c�nZglZabb�lh`_�[ukljh�jZkk_b\Z_lky��Fh]�eb�I��agZlv��qlh�>`hgkhim[ebdh\Ze�jZ[hlm�h dhrfZjghf�kg_��_keb�hg�gbdh]^Z�g_�qblZe�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�ebl_jZlmju">Z��hg�fh]�wlh�agZlv��M g_]h�[ueb�dgb]b�gZr_]h�ba^Zl_evkl\Z��b hg�fh]�\b^_lv�ZgghlZpbb�gh\uoim[ebdZpbc�gZ�h[eh`dZo��Wlh�g_evay�^hdZaZlv��gh�g_evay�b hijh\_j]gmlv��BlZd��wlbf�iml_f�fug_�ijb^_f�gb d�dZdhfm�j_r_gbx��D kh`Ze_gbx��fh_�gZ[ex^_gb_�kljZ^Z_l�l_f�`_�g_^hklZldhf�dZd�b fgh]b_�_fm�ih^h[gu_��Hgh�[ueh� kebrdhf�iha^gh� aZibkZgh�b h[km`^Zehkv�\ lh�\j_fy�dh]^Z�y [hevr_�g_�\b^_eky�k ]hkih^bghf�I��b g_�fh]�jZkkijhkblv�_]h�h ih^jh[ghklyo�Gh� \_jg_fky� d i_j\hfm� kemqZx�� dhlhjuc�� ^Z`_� \ayluc� \ hl^_evghklbª� dZd� [m^lh� [ukhojZgy_l�\b^bfhklv�nZdlZ�i_j_^Zqb�fuke_c��Fh]�I� �Ih�g_f_pdb )UHXQG�² ^jm]�²�Ijbf_q��i_j�agZlv��qlh�^hdlhj�NhjkZcl�[ue�m f_gy�aZ�q_l\_jlv�qZkZ�^h�g_]h"�Fh]�eb�hg�\hh[s_�agZlv�h_]h�kms_kl\h\Zgbb�beb�h _]h�ijb_a^_�\ <_gm"�G_evay�ih^^Z\Zlvky�bkdmr_gbx�\k_p_eh�hljbpZlvh[Z�ij_^iheh`_gby��Fg_�\b^blky�\k_�`_�imlv��dhlhjuc� \_^_l� d qZklbqghfm� ml\_j`^_gbx��Y\_^v� fh]� [u� khh[sblv� ]hkih^bgm� I��� qlh� `^m� \jZqZ� ba� :g]ebb� ^ey� h[mq_gby� ZgZebam�� dZdi_j\h]h�]hem[y�ihke_�\k_fbjgh]h�ihlhiZ��Wlh�fh]eh�[ulv�e_lhf������]���aZ�g_kdhevdh�f_kyp_\^h�k\h_]h�ijb[ulby�^�j NhjkZcl�^h]h\Zjb\Zeky�kh�fghc�h[�wlhf�\ ibkvfZo��Y ^Z`_�fh]�gZa\Zlv_]h�nZfbebx��ohly�wlh�dZ`_lky�fg_�\_kvfZ�fZeh�\_jhylguf��>ey�\uykg_gby�^jm]h]h�agZq_gbywlhc�nZfbebb�^ey�gZk�h[hbo�ke_^h\Zeh�[u�\kihfgblv�[_k_^m�k mihfbgZgb_f�wlhc�nZfbebb��hldhlhjhc�m f_gy�^he`gh�[ueh�[u�dh_�qlh�hklZlvky�\ iZfylb��<k_�`_�wlh�fh]eh�[ulv��Z y�ihlhf�h[wlhf� fh]� hkgh\Zl_evgh� aZ[ulv�� lZd� qlh� ©]hkih^bg� nhg� Nhjabolª� fh]� ijhba\_klb� gZ� f_gy\i_qZle_gb_� qm^Z� \h� \j_fy� ZgZeblbq_kdhc� [_k_^u�� ?keb� kqblZlv� k_[y� kd_ilbdhf�� lh� \_kvfZihke_^h\Zl_evgh�khfg_\Zlvky�\j_fy�hl�\j_f_gb�b \�k\h_f�kd_ikbk_��Fh`_l�[ulv��b m�f_gy�_klvlZcgZy�kdehgghklv�d qm^_kghfm��dhlhjZy�lZd�kihkh[kl\m_l�kha^Zgbx�hddmevlguo�nZdlh\�?keb�b wlhl�qm^_kguc�kemqZc�m[jZlv�k imlb��lh�gZk�`^_l�_s_�^jm]hc��kZfuc�ljm^guc�ba\k_o��Ij_^iheh`bf��qlh� ]hkih^bg�I�� agZe�h kms_kl\h\Zgbb�g_dh_]h�^�jZ�NhjkZclZ��dhlhjh]hh`b^Zxl�\ <_g_�hk_gvx��dh]^Z�dZd�h[tykgblv��qlh�hg�lZd�\hkijbbfqb\�d g_fm�dZd�jZa�\ ^_gv�_]hijb[ulby�b g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�ihke_�_]h�i_j\h]h�\bablZ"�Fh`gh�kdZaZlv��qlh�wlh�kemqZcghklv��l�_��hklZ\blv�g_h[tykg_gguf��gh�y ih^jh[gh�h[km^be�l_�^\_�nZglZabb�I��bf_ggh�^ey�lh]h��qlh[ubkdexqblv� kemqZcghklv�� qlh[u� ihdZaZlv� \Zf�� qlh� hg� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� [ue� aZgyl� j_\gb\ufbfukeyfb� h ex^yo�� dhlhju_� ihk_sZxl� f_gy� b dhlhjuo� y ihk_sZx�� beb� fh`gh� ihiulZlvkyij_^iheh`blv�� qlh[u�g_� mimklblv� kZfmx� djZcgxx� \hafh`ghklv�� qlh�I�� aZf_lbe�fh_� hkh[h_\heg_gb_��h dhlhjhf�y��ijZ\^Z��gbq_]h�g_�agZe��k^_eZ\�ba�g_]h�k\h_�aZdexq_gb_��Beb�]hkih^bgI���dhlhjuc�ijbr_e�\_^v�\k_]h�ebrv�q_l\_jlv�qZkZ�kimkly�ihke_�Zg]ebqZgbgZ��\klj_lbe�_]h�]^_�lh�gZ�h[s_f�imlb��magZe�ih� lbibqgh�Zg]ebckdhc� \g_rghklb�b��bf_y�ihklhyggh�mklZgh\dm�gZk\h_� j_\gb\h_� h`b^Zgb_�� ih^mfZe�� ©<hl� wlh� ²� ^�j NhjkZcl�� k ijb[ulb_f� dhlhjh]h� fhbf

Page 286: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

aZgylbyf�ZgZebahf�gZklmibl�dhg_p��B \_jhylgh��hg�k_cqZk�dZd�jZa�b^_l�hl�ijhn_kkhjZª��Ihclb^Zevr_� wlbo�jZpbhgZebklbq_kdbo�ij_^iheh`_gbc�y g_�fh]m��Hiylv�ihi OLTXHW ��gh� y ^he`_gijbagZlv��qlh��ih�fh_fm��qZrZ�\_kh\�b a^_kv�kdehgy_lky�\ ihevam�i_j_^Zqb�fuke_c��<ijhq_f�[_amkeh\gh� y g_� _^bgkl\_gguc�� dhfm� ^h\h^behkv� i_j_`b\Zlv� lZdb_� ©hddmevlgu_ª� kemqZb� \ZgZeblbq_kdhc�kblmZpbb��?e_gZ�>_cq�\ �����]��him[ebdh\ZeZ�ih^h[gu_�gZ[ex^_gby�b bamqZeZbo�h[mkeh\e_gghklv�hlghr_gbyfb�i_j_g_k_gby�f_`A�^m�iZpb_glhf�b ZgZeblbdhf�Y m[_`^_g��qlh�\u�g_�hkh[_ggh�^h\hevgu�fh_c�mklZgh\dhc�gZ�wlm�ijh[e_fm��m[_`^_g�g_�^hdhgpZ�b \k_�`_�d m[_`^_gbx�]hlh\��<hafh`gh� �©G_�ykghª�²�keh\Z��k dhlhjufb�^j_\g_jbfkdbc�km^vy�\ha^_j`b\Zeky�hl�km`^_gby�²�Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\h^Z�\u� kdZ`_l_� k_[_�� wlh� hiylv� lhl� kemqZc�� dh]^Z� q_eh\_d�� \kx� k\hx� `bagv� q_klghijhjZ[hlZ\rbc�\ dZq_kl\_�_kl_kl\hbkiulZl_ey��k \hajZklhf�klZgh\blky�keZ[hmfguf��gZ[h`gufb e_]dh\_jguf�� Y agZx� g_kdhevdh� \_ebdbo� bf_g�� ijbgZ^e_`Zsbo� d bo� qbkem�� gh� f_gy� g_ke_^m_l�ijbqbkeylv�d gbf��GZ[h`guf�y��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��g_�klZe��gZ^_xkv��qlh�b e_]dh\_jguflh`_��Lhevdh� _keb�q_eh\_d� \kx� k\hx�`bagv� k]b[Zeky�^ey� lh]h��qlh[u�ba[_]Zlv�[he_ag_ggh]hklhedgh\_gby�k nZdlZfb��lh�b \�klZjhklb�_]h�kibgZ�hklZg_lky�kh]gmlhc��k]b[Zykv�ih^�gh\ufbnZdlZfb�� <Zf� [ueh� [u�� dhg_qgh�� ijbylg__�� _keb� [u� y ijb^_j`b\Zeky� mf_j_ggh]h� l_bafZ� bihdZaZe� k_[y� g_ijbfbjbfuf�� hldehgyy� \k_� hddmevlgh_�� Gh� y g_� kihkh[_g� ^h[b\Zlvky[eZ]hkdehgghklb�� y ij_^eZ]Zx�\Zf�hlg_klbkv�[he__�^jm`_ex[gh�d h[t_dlb\ghc� \hafh`ghklbi_j_^Zqb�fuke_c��Z \f_kl_�k l_f�b l_e_iZlbb�G_�aZ[u\Zcl_��qlh�y h[km`^Ze�wlb�ijh[e_fu�a^_kv�ebrv�ihklhevdm��ihkdhevdm�d gbf�fh`ghijb[ebablvky�kh�klhjhgu�ikbohZgZebaZ��Dh]^Z�[he__�^_kylb�e_l�lhfm�gZaZ^�hgb�\i_j\u_�\hreb\ ihe_�fh_]h� aj_gby�� y lh`_�bkiulZe� kljZo�i_j_^� m]jhahc�gZr_fm�gZmqghfm�fbjh\haaj_gbxdhlhjh_� \ kemqZ_� ih^l\_j`^_gby� we_f_glh\� hddmevlbafZ� ^he`gh� [ueh� [u� mklmiblv� f_klhkibjblbafm� b fbklbd_��K_]h^gy� y ^mfZx� ih�^jm]hfm�� y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� h [hevrhf� ^h\_jbb� dgZmd_�hlgx^v�g_�k\b^_l_evkl\m_l�g_\_jb_�\ lh��qlh�hgZ�fh`_l�\hkijbgylv�b i_j_jZ[hlZlv�lh�qlh� hdZ`_lky� ^_ckl\bl_evguf� \ hddmevlguo� ml\_j`^_gbyo�� Qlh� `_� dZkZ_lky�� \ qZklghklb�i_j_^Zqb�fuke_c��lh�hgZ�lh��dZ`_lky��dZd�jZa�b [eZ]hijbylkl\m_l�jZkijhkljZg_gbx�gZmqgh]h�²ijhlb\gbdb� kdZ`ml�� f_oZgbklbq_kdh]h� ²� h[jZaZ� fure_gby� gZ� klhev� ljm^gh� ihklb`bfmx^moh\gmx�h[eZklv��<_^v�l_e_iZlbq_kdbc�ijhp_kk��^he`gh�[ulv��\ lhf�b aZdexqZ_lky��qlh�dZdhc�lh�ikbobq_kdbc�Zdl�h^gh]h�ebpZ�\ha[m`^Z_l�lh`^_kl\_gguc�ikbobq_kdbc�Zdl�m ^jm]h]h�ebpZ�Lh��qlh�e_`bl�f_`^m�h[hbfb�ikbobq_kdbfb�ZdlZfb��e_]dh�fh`_l�[ulv�nbabq_kdbf�ijhp_kkhf��\dhlhjuc�k h^gh]h�dhgpZ�i_j_oh^bl�ikbobq_kdh_�b dhlhjuc�gZ�^jm]hf�dhgp_�hiylv�i_j_\h^blky\ lZdh_� `_� ikbobq_kdh_�� :gZeh]by� k ^jm]bfb� i_j_oh^Zfb�� dZd�� gZijbf_j�� ijb� jZa]h\hj_� bkemrZgbb� ih� l_e_nhgm�� [ueZ� [u� lh]^Z� g_khfg_gghc�� : ij_^klZ\vl_�� _keb� [u� fh`gh� [uehh\eZ^_lv� wlbf� nbabq_kdbf� wd\b\Ze_glhf� ikbobq_kdh]h� ZdlZ�� Ohqm� kdZaZlv�� qlh�� \dexqb\[_kkhagZl_evgh_� f_`^m� nbabq_kdbf� b l_f�� qlh� ^h� kbo� ihj� gZau\Zehkv� ©ikbobq_kdbfª�ikbohZgZeba�ih^]hlh\be�ihq\m�^ey�ij_^iheh`_gby�lZdbo�ijhp_kkh\��dZd�l_e_iZlby��Ijb\udgbfu�d ij_^klZ\e_gbx�h l_e_iZlbb��k __�ihfhsvx�fu�kfh`_f�k^_eZlv�fgh]h��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_�\\hh[jZ`_gbb�� <_^v�� dZd� ba\_klgh�� g_l� k\_^_gbc� h lhf�� dZd� hkms_kl\ey_lky� h[sZy� \hey� \[hevrbo�dhehgbyo�gZk_dhfuo��<hafh`gh��wlh�ijhbkoh^bl�iml_f�ih^h[ghc�ijyfhc�ikbobq_kdhci_j_^Zqb�� <hagbdZ_l� ij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh� wlh� i_j\hgZqZevguc�� ZjoZbq_kdbc� imlv

Page 287: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dhffmgbdZpbb� f_`^m� hl^_evgufb� kms_kl\Zfb�� dhlhjuc� \ ijhp_kk_� nbeh]_g_lbq_kdh]hjZa\blby� \ul_kgy_lky� emqrbf� kj_^kl\hf� khh[s_gby� ijb� ihfhsb� agZdh\�� \hkijbgbfZ_fuohj]ZgZfb� qm\kl\��Gh� [he__�^j_\g__� kj_^kl\h�fh`_l� khojZgblvky�� hklZ\Zykv�gZ� aZ^g_f�ieZg_�\uklmiZy� gZ� i_j\uc� ieZg� ijb� hij_^_e_gguo� mkeh\byo�� gZijbf_j� \ kljZklgh� \ha[m`^_gguofZkkZo��<k_�wlh�_s_�g_hij_^_e_ggh�b ihegh�g_j_r_gguo�aZ]Z^hd��gh�im]Zlvky�wlh]h�g_l�ijbqbg�?keb� l_e_iZlby� kms_kl\m_l� dZd� j_Zevguc� ijhp_kk�� lh�� g_kfhljy� gZ� __� ljm^gmx^hdZam_fhklv��fh`gh�ij_^iheh`blv��qlh�hgZ�y\ey_lky�^h\hevgh�jZkijhkljZg_gguf�n_ghf_ghf�GZrbf� h`b^Zgbyf� khhl\_lkl\h\Zeh� [u�� _keb� [u� fu� h[gZjm`beb� __� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh� \^mr_\ghc� `bagb� j_[_gdZ�� Lml�lh� b \kihfgbrv� h qZklh� \klj_qZxsboky� kljZoZo� ^_l_c�� qlhjh^bl_eb�agZxl�\k_�bo�fukeb��ohly�hgb�bo�bf�b g_�khh[sZeb�²�ihegZy�ZgZeh]by�b��[ulv�fh`_l�bklhqgbd�\_ju�\ajhkeuo�\h�\k_\_^_gb_�[h]Z��G_^Z\gh�h^gZ�\gmrZxsZy�^h\_jb_�^ZfZ��>hjhlb;_jebg]_f��khh[sbeZ�\ k\h_c�jZ[hl_�©:gZeba�j_[_gdZ�b fZlvª��������h gZ[ex^_gbyo��dhlhju_�_keb� hgb� ih^l\_j^ylky�� ^he`gu� iheh`blv� dhg_p� hklZldZf� khfg_gbc� \ j_Zevghklb� i_j_^Zqbfuke_c��Bkihevah\Z\�g_j_^dmx�l_i_jv�kblmZpbx��dh]^Z�fZlv�b j_[_ghd�h^gh\j_f_ggh�ijhoh^ylZgZeblbq_kdb_� aZgylby�� hgZ� jZkkdZaZeZ� h[� h^ghf� ba� kljZgguo� kemqZ_\�� ijhbkr_^rbo� k g_c�h^gZ`^u�gZ�ZgZeblbq_kdhf�aZgylbb�fZlv�jZkkdZaZeZ�h ahehlhc�\_sbp_��b]jZ\r_c�hij_^_e_ggmxjhev�\ h^ghc�ba�__ ^_lkdbo�kp_g��KjZam�ihke_�wlh]h��dh]^Z�hgZ�\_jgmeZkv�^hfhc��__ fZe_gvdbc�hdheh� ��� e_l��fZevqbd�ijbr_e� d g_c� \ dhfgZlm� b ijbg_k� __ ahehlmx� \_sbpm�� dhlhjmx� hgZojZgbeZ�^ey�g_]h��HgZ�kijhkbeZ�_]h�m^b\e_ggh��hldm^Z�hg�__ \aye��Hg�ihemqbe�__ \�ih^Zjhd�dh^gx� jh`^_gby�� gh� ^_gv� jh`^_gby� [ue� g_kdhevdh� f_kyp_\� lhfm� gZaZ^�� b g_� [ueh� gbdZdboijbqbg�lh]h��qlh[u�bf_ggh�k_cqZk�j_[_ghd�\kihfgbe�h[�wlhc�ahehlhc�\_sbp_��FZlv�jZkkdZaZeZh kemqb\r_fky�`_gsbg_�ZgZeblbdm�b ihijhkbeZ�__ magZlv�h ijbqbg_�_]h�^_ckl\by��Gh�ZgZeba�ijh\_^_gguc�k j_[_gdhf��g_�^Ze�gbdZdh]h�jZatykg_gby��\ lhl�^_gv�^_ckl\b_�\hj\Zehkv�\ `bagvj_[_gdZ� dZd� bghjh^gh_� l_eh�� G_kdhevdh� g_^_ev� kimkly� fZlv� kb^_eZ� aZ� ibkvf_gguf� klhehf�aZibku\Zy�jZkkdZaZggh_�i_j_`b\Zgb_��h q_f�__ ihijhkbeb��Lml�ihy\beky�fZevqbd�b ihijhkbeahehlmx� \_sbpm� h[jZlgh�� qlh[u� \aylv� __ k� kh[hc�gZ� ZgZeblbq_kdmx� [_k_^m� b ihdZaZlv� �lZf�:gZeba�hiylv�g_�^Ze�gbdZdh]h�h[tykg_gby�wlhfm�`_eZgbx�<hl�fu�b \_jgmebkv�kgh\Z�d ikbohZgZebam��k dhlhjh]h�gZqZeb�LJB>P:LV�I?J<:Y�E?DPBYJZa^_e_gb_�ikbobq_kdhc�ebqghklbM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��Y agZx��qlh�\ k\hbo�\aZbfhhlghr_gbyo�k ebpZfb�beb�\_sZfb\u� kZfb� hij_^_ey_l_�� qlh� y\ey_lky� bkoh^guf� imgdlhf�� LZd� [ueh� b k� ikbohZgZebahf�� ^eyjZa\blby��dhlhjh_�hg�ihemqbe��^ey�A�hldebdZ��dhlhjuc�hg�gZr_e��[ueh�g_[_ajZaebqgh��qlh�gZqZehg� k jZ[hlu� gZ^� kbfilhfhf�� kZfuf� qm`^uf� ^ey� Y we_f_glhf�� dhlhjuc� bf__lky� \ ^mr_�Kbfilhf�ijhbkoh^bl�hl�\ul_kg_ggh]h��y\eyykv�h^gh\j_f_ggh�_]h�ij_^klZ\bl_e_f�i_j_^�Y��gh\ul_kg_ggh_� ^ey� Y ²� wlh� qm`Zy� kljZgZ�� \gmlj_ggyy� aZ]jZgbpZ�� lZd� `_� dZd� n_Zevghklv� ²jZaj_rbl_� lZdh_� g_h[uqgh_� \ujZ`_gb_� ²� aZ]jZgbpZ� \g_rgyy�� Hl� kbfilhfZ� imlv� e_`Ze� d[_kkhagZl_evghfm�� d `bagb� \e_q_gbc�� d k_dkmZevghklb�� b wlh� [ueh� \j_fy�� dh]^Z� ijhlb\

Page 288: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ikbohZgZebaZ�\u^\b]Zebkv�]em[hdhfuke_ggu_�\hajZ`_gby��qlh�q_eh\_d�²�kms_kl\h�g_�lhevdhk_dkmZevgh_��hg�agZdhf�b k�[he__�[eZ]hjh^gufb�b [he__�\ukhdbfb�ihju\Zfb��Fh`gh�[ueh�[u^h[Z\blv�� qlh�� \^hogh\e_gguc� khagZgb_f� wlbo� \ukhdbo� ihju\h\�� hg� g_j_^dh� iha\hey_l� k_[_g_kmjZagu_�fukeb�b b]ghjbjh\Zgb_�nZdlh\�<Zf� emqr_� agZlv�� qlh� k kZfh]h� gZqZeZ� m gZk� kqblZehkv�� q_eh\_d� kljZ^Z_l� hl� dhgnebdlZf_`^m� lj_[h\Zgbyfb�`bagb� \e_q_gbc�b khijhlb\e_gb_f�� dhlhjh_�ih^gbfZ_lky� \ g_f�ijhlb\gbo�� b fu� gb� gZ� fb]� g_� aZ[u\Zeb� h[� wlhc� khijhlb\eyxs_cky�� hldehgyxs_c�� \ul_kgyxs_cbgklZgpbb�� dhlhjZy�� dZd�fu�iheZ]Zeb�� h[eZ^Z_l� k\hbfb� hkh[ufb� kbeZfb�� klj_fe_gbyfb�Y��bdhlhjZy�kh\iZ^Z_l�k Y�ihimeyjghc�ikboheh]bb��Lhevdh�\_^v�ijb�\k_o�ljm^guo�mki_oZo�gZmqghcjZ[hlu� b ikbohZgZebam� g_� ih^� kbem� [ueh� h^gh\j_f_ggh� bamqZlv� \k_� h[eZklb� b \ukdZau\Zlvkm`^_gb_�kjZam�ih�\k_f�ijh[e_fZf��GZdhg_p��^_eh�^hreh�^h� lh]h��qlh�fu� kfh]eb�gZijZ\blvk\h_�\gbfZgb_�k \ul_kg_ggh]h�gZ�\ul_kgyxs__�b \klZeb�i_j_^�wlbf�Y��dZaZ\rbfky�lZdbf�kZfhkh[hc�jZamf_xsbfky��\ l\_j^hc�m\_j_gghklb�b a^_kv�\klj_lblv�\_sb��d dhlhjuf�fu�fh]eb�[ulvg_�ih^]hlh\e_gu��h^gZdh�[ueh�g_e_]dh�gZclb�i_j\uc�ih^oh^��<hl�h[�wlhf�lh�y b�ohqm�k \Zfbk_]h^gy�ih[_k_^h\Zlv�Ij_^iheZ]Zx��h^gZdh��qlh�wlh�fh_�baeh`_gb_�ikboheh]bb�Y ih^_ckl\m_l�gZ�\Zk�bgZq_��q_f\\_^_gb_� \ ikbobq_kdmx� ij_bkih^gxx�� dhlhjh_� _fm� ij_^r_kl\h\Zeh�� Ihq_fm� wlh� lZd�� klhqghklvx�kdZaZlv�g_�fh]m��DZd�dZaZehkv�fg_�kgZqZeZ��\u�ih^mfZ_l_��qlh�jZg__�y khh[sZe�\ZfnZdlu�� imklv� ^Z`_� g_ijb\uqgu_� b k\h_h[jZagu_�� lh]^Z� dZd� l_i_jv� \u� mkeurbl_ij_bfms_kl\_ggh� fg_gby�� l�� _�� mfhajbl_evgu_� jZkkm`^_gby�� Gh� wlh� g_� lZd�� ihemqr_� \k_\a\_kb\��y ^he`_g�kdZaZlv��qlh�m^_evguc�\_k�fukebl_evghc�h[jZ[hldb�nZdlbq_kdh]h�fZl_jbZeZ\ gZr_c� ikboheh]bb�Y g_gZfgh]h� [hevr_�� q_f� \ ikboheh]bb� g_\jhah\��>jm]b_� h[hkgh\Zgbyk\h_]h�ij_^iheh`_gby�y lh`_�\ugm`^_g�[ue�hl[jhkblv��l_i_jv�y kqblZx��qlh�dZdbf�lh�h[jZahfwlh�djh_lky�\ oZjZdl_j_�kZfh]h�fZl_jbZeZ�b \�g_ijb\uqghklb�gZr_]h�h[jZs_gby�k gbf��<k_�`_y g_�m^b\exkv��_keb�\ k\h_f�km`^_gbb�\u�ijhy\bl_�_s_�[hevr_�k^_j`Zgghklb�b hklhjh`ghklb�q_f�^h�kbo�ihj�KblmZpby��\ dhlhjhc�fu�gZoh^bfky�\ gZqZe_�gZr_]h�bkke_^h\Zgby�� kZfZ�^he`gZ�mdZaZlvgZf�imlv��Fu�ohlbf�k^_eZlv�ij_^f_lhf�wlh]h�bkke_^h\Zgby�Y��gZr_�gZbkh[kl\_gg_cr__�Y��Gh\hafh`gh� eb� wlh"� <_^v� Y y\ey_lky� kZfuf� ih^ebgguf� km[t_dlhf�� dZd� `_� hgh� fh`_l� klZlvh[t_dlhf"� B \k_�lZdb�� g_khfg_ggh�� wlh� \hafh`gh�� Y fh`_l� \aylv� k_[y� \ dZq_kl\_� h[t_dlZ�h[jZsZlvky�k kh[hc��dZd�k ijhqbfb�h[t_dlZfb��gZ[ex^Zlv�k_[y��djblbdh\Zlv�b [h]�agZ_l�qlh�_s_k kZfbf�kh[hc�^_eZlv��Ijb�wlhf�h^gZ�qZklv�Y ijhlb\hihklZ\ey_l�k_[y�hklZevghfm�Y��BlZd��YjZkqe_gbfh��hgh�jZkqe_gy_lky�\ g_dhlhjuo�k\hbo�nmgdpbyo��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��gZ�\j_fy��QZklbfh]ml�aZl_f�kgh\Z�h[t_^bgblvky��KZfh�ih�k_[_�wlh�g_�gh\h��\hafh`gh��g_ijb\uqguc�\a]ey^�gZh[s_ba\_klgu_� \_sb�� K ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� gZf� agZdhfZ� lhqdZ� aj_gby�� qlh� iZlheh]by� k\hbfbij_m\_ebq_gbyfb�b h]jm[e_gbyfb�fh`_l�h[jZlblv�gZr_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�ghjfZevgu_�hlghr_gby�dhlhju_� [_a� wlh]h� mkdhevagmeb� [u� hl� gZk�� LZf�� ]^_� hgZ� h[gZjm`b\Z_l� kehf� b kju\�� \ghjfZevghf�khklhygbb�fh`_l�bf_lv�f_klh�jZkqe_g_gb_��?keb�fu�[jhkbf�djbklZee�gZ�a_fex��hgjZah[v_lky��gh�g_�ijhba\hevgh�� Z jZkiZ^_lky�ih�gZijZ\e_gbyf� k\hbo� lj_sbg�gZ� dmkdb�� ]jZgbdhlhjuo�� ohly� b g_\b^bfh�� \k_�lZdb� ij_^hij_^_e_gu� kljmdlmjhc� djbklZeeZ�� LZdbfbjZklj_kdZ\rbfbky�b jZkdheh\rbfbky�kljmdlmjZfb�y\eyxlky�^mr_\gh[hevgu_��B fu�g_�fh`_f

Page 289: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

bf�hldZaZlv�\ q_f�lh�\jh^_�ihqlbl_evgh]h�kljZoZ��dhlhjuc�bkiulu\Zeb�^j_\gb_�gZjh^u�i_j_^kmfZkr_^rbfb�� Hgb� hl\_jgmebkv� hl� \g_rg_c� j_Zevghklb�� gh� bf_ggh� ihwlhfm� hgb� [hevr_agZxl� h \gmlj_gg_c��ikbobq_kdhc�j_Zevghklb�b fh]ml�gZf� dh_�qlh� \u^Zlv�� qlh�[ueh� [u�gZfbgZq_� g_^hklmigh�� H[� h^ghc� ]jmii_� lZdbo� [hevguo� fu� ]h\hjbf�� qlh� hgb� kljZ^Zxl� [j_^hfgZ[ex^_gby �%HREDFKWXQJVZDKQ� �� Hgb� `Zemxlky� gZf�� qlh� ihklhyggh� b \iehlv� ^h� kZfuobglbfguo�hlijZ\e_gbc�gZoh^ylky�ih^�m^jmqZxsbf�gZ[ex^_gb_f�g_ba\_klguo� kbe�� \_jhylgh\k_�lZdb� ebp�� b \� ]ZeexpbgZpbyo� keurZl�� dZd� wlb� ebpZ� h[ty\eyxl� h j_amevlZlZo� k\hbogZ[ex^_gbc�� ©K_cqZk� hg� ohq_l� kdZaZlv� wlh�� \hl� hg� h^_\Z_lky�� qlh[u� \uclb�� b l�� ^�ª� WlhgZ[ex^_gb_�²�_s_�g_�lh�`_�kZfh_��qlh�ij_ke_^h\Zgb_��gh�[ebadh�d g_fm��hgh�ij_^iheZ]Z_l��qlh[hevghfm� g_� ^h\_jyxl��`^ml�� dZd� [u� aZklZlv� _]h� aZ� aZij_lgufb� ^_ckl\byfb�� aZ� dhlhju_� _]h^he`gu�gZdZaZlv��Qlh�[ueh�[u��_keb�[u�wlb�kmfZkr_^rb_�[ueb�ijZ\u��_keb�[u�m gZk�m \k_o[ueZ�lZdZy�gZ[ex^ZxsZy�b m]jh`ZxsZy�gZdZaZgb_f�bgklZgpby�\ Y��dhlhjZy�m gbo�ebrv�j_adhhl^_e_gZ�hl�Y b�ih�hrb[d_�kf_s_gZ�\h�\g_rgxx�j_Zevghklv"G_� agZx�� ijhbahc^_l� eb� k \Zfb� lh�`_�� qlh� b kh� fghc��Gh� k l_o� ihj�� dZd� ih^� kbevguf\i_qZle_gb_f� wlhc� dZjlbgu� [he_agb� fghx� h\eZ^_eZ� b^_y�� qlh� hl^_e_gb_� gZ[ex^Zxs_cbgklZgpbb� hl� hklZevgh]h� Y fh`_l� [ulv� \ kljmdlmj_� Y aZdhghf_jghc� q_jlhc�� hgZ� f_gy� g_hklZ\ey_l�� b y� \ugm`^_g� [ue� aZgylvky� bamq_gb_f� b ^jm]bo� oZjZdl_jguo� hkh[_gghkl_c� bhlghr_gbc� wlhc� hl^_e_gghc� lZdbf� h[jZahf� bgklZgpbb��<kdhj_� [ue� k^_eZg� ke_^mxsbc�rZ]�M`_�kh^_j`Zgb_�[j_^Z�gZ[ex^_gby�gZf_dZ_l�gZ�lh��qlh�gZ[ex^_gb_�y\ey_lky�ebrv�ih^]hlh\dhcd km^m�b gZdZaZgbx��b��lZdbf�h[jZahf��fu�magZ_f��qlh�m wlhc�bgklZgpbb�_klv�^jm]Zy�nmgdpby�dhlhjmx�fu�gZau\Z_f�k\h_c�kh\_klvx��<jy^�eb�\ gZk�gZc^_lky�qlh�eb[h�^jm]h_��qlh�fu�[u�lZdihklhyggh�hl^_eyeb�hl�k\h_]h�Y b�lZd�e_]dh�ijhlb\hihklZ\eyeb�_fm��dZd�kh\_klv��Y qm\kl\mxkdehgghklv� qlh�lh� k^_eZlv�� qlh� h[_sZ_l� fg_� gZkeZ`^_gb_�� gh� hldZau\Zxkv� hl� wlh]h� gZhkgh\Zgbb�lh]h��qlh�kh\_klv�fg_�wlh]h�g_�iha\hey_l��Beb��ih^^Z\rbkv�qj_af_jghfm�`_eZgbxgZkeZ`^_gby��y ^_eZx�qlh�lh��ijhlb\�q_]h�ih^gbfZ_lky�]hehk�kh\_klb��b ihke_�ijhklmidZ�fhykh\_klv�gZdZau\Z_l�f_gy� mij_dZfb� klu^Z�� aZklZ\ey_l� jZkdZb\Zlvky� aZ�g_]h��Y fh]� [u� kdZaZlvijhklh��qlh�hkh[Zy�bgklZgpby��dhlhjmx�y gZqbgZx�jZaebqZlv�\ Y��y\ey_lky�kh\_klvx��gh�[he__hklhjh`guf� [ueh� [u� kqblZlv� wlm� bgklZgpbx� kZfhklhyl_evghc� b ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� kh\_klvy\ey_lky� h^ghc� ba� __ nmgdpbc�� Z kZfhgZ[ex^_gb_�� g_h[oh^bfh_� dZd� ij_^ihkuedZ� km^_[ghc^_yl_evghklb�kh\_klb��y\ey_lky �< kh\_lkdhc�ikbobZljbq_kdhc�ebl_jZlmj_�jZkkfZljb\Z_lky�dZd�h^bg�ba� \ZjbZglh\�[j_^Z�ij_ke_^h\Zgby��Ijbf_q��j_^��i_j_\�^jm]hc� __� nmgdpb_c�� : lZd� dZd�� ijbagZ\Zy� kZfhklhyl_evgh_� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� dZdhc�eb[h\_sb��gm`gh�^Zlv�_c�bfy��y [m^m�hlgug_�gZau\Zlv�wlm�bgklZgpbx�\ Y�©K\_jo�Yª�: l_i_jv�`^m�hl�\Zk�bjhgbq_kdh]h�\hijhkZ��g_�k\h^blky�eb�wlZ�\ZrZ�ikboheh]by�Y \hh[s_d lhfm��qlh[u�[md\Zevgh�ihgbfZlv�h[s_mihlj_[bl_evgu_�Z[kljZdpbb��ij_\jZsZy�bo�ba�ihgylbc\ ij_^f_lu�� fgh]h]h� g_� \ub]ju\Zy� wlbf"� Hl\_qm�� \ ikboheh]bb� Y ljm^gh� [m^_l� ba[_`Zlvh[s_ba\_klgh]h��a^_kv�j_qv�[m^_l�b^lb��kdhj__��h gh\uo�lhqdZo�aj_gby�b kbkl_fZlbaZpbyo��q_f�hgh\uo��hldjulbyo��LZd�qlh�hklZ\Zcl_kv�ihdZ�ijb�k\h_f�mgbqlh`Zxs_f�djblbq_kdhf�fg_gbb�bih^h`^bl_� ^Zevg_crbo� jZkkm`^_gbc�� NZdlu� iZlheh]bb� ^Zxl� gZrbf� bkke_^h\Zgbyf� nhg�dhlhjuc� \u� gZijZkgh� bkdZeb� [u� \ ihimeyjghc� ikboheh]bb��>Ze__�� ?^\Z� fu� ijbfbjbebkv� k

Page 290: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

b^__c� lZdh]h� K\_jo�Y�� dhlhjh_� ihevam_lky� ba\_klghc� kZfhklhyl_evghklvx�� ij_ke_^m_lkh[kl\_ggu_� gZf_j_gby� b \� k\h_f� h[eZ^Zgbb� wg_j]b_c� g_aZ\bkbfh� hl� Y�� dZd� i_j_^� gZfbg_ba[_`gh�\klZ_l�dZjlbgZ�[he_agb��\ dhlhjhc�kh�\k_c�ykghklvx�h[gZjm`b\Z_lky�kljh]hklv��^Z`_`_klhdhklv�wlhc�bgklZgpbb�b baf_g_gby�__�hlghr_gby�Y��Y bf_x�\ \b^m�khklhygb_�f_eZgohebb�\_jg__��ijbklmiZ�f_eZgohebb��h dhlhjhf�b \u�lh`_�^hklZlhqgh�fgh]h�keurZeb��^Z`_�_keb�\ug_�ikbobZlju��Ijb�wlhf�g_^m]_��h ijbqbgZo�b f_oZgbafZo�dhlhjh]h�fu�kebrdhf�fZeh�agZ_f�gZb[he__� yjdhc� q_jlhc� y\ey_lky� kihkh[� h[jZs_gby�K\_jo�Y ²� ijh� k_[y� \u�fh`_l_� kdZaZlv�kh\_klb�²�k Y��< lh�\j_fy�dZd�f_eZgohebd�\ a^hjh\hf�khklhygbb�fh`_l�[ulv�[he__�beb�f_g__kljh]� d k_[_�� dZd� ex[hc� ^jm]hc�� \ ijbklmi_� f_eZgohebb� K\_jo�Y klZgh\blky� k\_jokljh]bf�jm]Z_l��mgb`Z_l��bklyaZ_l�[_^gh_�Y��aZklZ\ey_l�_]h�h`b^Zlv�kZfuo�kljh]bo�gZdZaZgbc��mij_dZ_l_]h� aZ� ^Z\gh� kh^_yggh_�� dhlhjh_� \ k\h_� \j_fy� \hkijbgbfZehkv� e_]dh�� dZd� [m^lh� hgh� \k_� wlh\j_fy� kh[bjZeh� h[\bg_gby� b lhevdh� \u`b^Zeh� k\h_]h� l_i_j_rg_]h� ijbeb\Z� kbe�� qlh[u\uklmiblv� k gbfb� b \ug_klb� ijb]h\hj� gZ� hkgh\Zgbb� wlbo� h[\bg_gbc�� K\_jo�Y ij_^ty\ey_lkZfu_�kljh]b_�fhjZevgu_�lj_[h\Zgby�d hl^Zgghfm�\ _]h�jZkihjy`_gb_�[_kihfhsghfm�Y��hgh\hh[s_� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� lj_[h\Zgby� fhjZeb�� b fu� kjZam� ihgbfZ_f�� qlh� gZr_� fhjZevgh_qm\kl\h� \bgu� _klv� \ujZ`_gb_�gZijy`_gby�f_`^m�Y b�K\_jo�Y��Wlh� \_kvfZ�ijbf_qZl_evgucj_amevlZl�gZ[ex^_gby��fhjZev��^ZggZy�gZf�ydh[u�hl�[h]Z�b imklb\rZy�klhev�]em[hdb_�dhjgb�\uklmiZ_l� >m lZdbo� iZpb_glh\@� dZd� i_jbh^bq_kdh_� y\e_gb_��Ihlhfm� qlh� q_j_a� hij_^_e_ggh_dhebq_kl\h� f_kyp_\� \k_� fhjZevgh_� gZ\Z`^_gb_� ijhoh^bl�� djblbdZ� K\_jo�Y mfhedZ_l�� Yj_Z[beblbjm_lky� b \gh\v� ihevam_lky� \k_fb� q_eh\_q_kdbfb� ijZ\Zfb� \iehlv� ^h� ke_^mxs_]hijbklmiZ�� IjZ\^Z�� ijb� g_dhlhjuo� nhjfZo� aZ[he_\Zgby� \ ijhf_`mldZo� ijhbkoh^bl� g_qlhijhlb\hiheh`gh_��Y gZoh^blky�\ khklhygbb�[eZ`_ggh]h�hivyg_gby��hgh�lhj`_kl\m_l��dZd�[m^lhK\_jo�Y mljZlbeh� \kydmx� kbem� b kebehkv� k Y�� b wlh� klZ\r__� k\h[h^guf�� fZgbZdZevgh_� Yiha\hey_l� k_[_� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� [_am^_j`gh_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� \k_o� k\hbo� ijbohl_c��Ijhp_kku�ihegu_�g_j_r_gguo�aZ]Z^hd�<u�`^_l_��dhg_qgh��[hevr_��q_f�ijhklhc�beexkljZpbb��mkeurZ\�hl�f_gy��qlh�fu�dh_�qlhagZ_f� h[� h[jZah\Zgbb� K\_jo�Y�� l�� _�� h \hagbdgh\_gbb� kh\_klb�� Hkgh\u\Zykv� gZ� ba\_klghf\ukdZau\Zgbb�DZglZ��kjZ\gb\r_]h�gZrm�kh\_klv�kh�a\_a^guf�g_[hf��gZ[h`guc�q_eh\_d�fh]�[u�ih`Zemc��ihqm\kl\h\Zlv�bkdmr_gb_�ihq_klv�h[Z�bo�aZ�ij_djZkgu_�kha^Zgby�l\hjpZ��G_[_kgu_l_eZ��dhg_qgh��\_ebdhe_igu��gh�qlh�dZkZ_lky�kh\_klb��lh�a^_kv�[h]�ihjZ[hlZe�g_�klhev�fgh]h�bg_[j_`gh�� ihlhfm� qlh� ih^Z\eyxs__� [hevrbgkl\h� ex^_c� ihemqbeh� __ ebrv� \ kdjhfguojZaf_jZo�beb�\ klhev�fZehc�kl_i_gb��qlh�h[�wlhf�g_�klhbl�b ]h\hjblv��Fu�gb \�dh_c�f_j_�g_hljbpZ_f�lm�qZklv�ikboheh]bq_kdhc�bklbgu��dhlhjZy�kh^_j`blky�\ ml\_j`^_gbb��qlh�kh\_klv�²[h`_kl\_ggh]h� ijhbkoh`^_gby�� gh� wlh� iheh`_gb_� lj_[m_l� jZatykg_gby�� ?keb� kh\_klv� lh`_y\ey_lky� q_f�lh� ©\ gZkª�� lh� wlh� \_^v� g_� bagZqZevgh�� Wlh� ²� ihegZy� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklvk_dkmZevghc�`bagb��dhlhjZy�^_ckl\bl_evgh�[ueZ�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ�`bagb��Z g_�^h[Z\beZkv�ebrv\ihke_^kl\bb��Gh�fZe_gvdbc�j_[_ghd��dZd�ba\_klgh��ZfhjZe_g��m g_]h�g_l�\gmlj_ggbo�lhjfhah\ijhlb\�klj_fe_gbc�d m^h\hevkl\bx��Jhev��dhlhjmx�iha^g__�[_j_l�gZ�k_[y�K\_jo�Y��bkihegy_lkykgZqZeZ�\g_rg_c�kbehc��jh^bl_evkdbf�Z\lhjbl_lhf��Jh^bl_evkdh_�\ebygb_�gZ�j_[_gdZ�hkgh\ZghgZ� ijhy\e_gbyo� agZdh\� ex[\b� b m]jhaZo� gZdZaZgbyfb�� dhlhju_� ^hdZau\Zxl� j_[_gdm� mljZlmex[\b� b kZfb� ih� k_[_� ^he`gu� \uau\Zlv� kljZo�� Wlhl� j_Zevguc� kljZo� y\ey_lkyij_^r_kl\_ggbdhf�[he__�iha^g_]h�kljZoZ�kh\_klb��ihdZ�hg�pZjbl��g_l�gm`^u�]h\hjblv�h K\_jo�

Page 291: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Y b� h kh\_klb�� Lhevdh� \ihke_^kl\bb� h[jZam_lky� \lhjbqgZy� kblmZpby�� dhlhjmx� fu� kebrdhfhohlgh� ijbgbfZ_f� aZ� ghjfZevgmx�� dh]^Z� \g_rg__� k^_j`b\Zgb_� moh^bl� \h\gmljv�� dh]^Z� gZf_klh� jh^bl_evkdhc� bgklZgpbb� ihy\ey_lky� K\_jo�Y�� dhlhjh_� lhqgh� lZd� `_� gZ[ex^Z_l� aZ� Y�jmdh\h^bl�bf�b m]jh`Z_l�_fm��dZd�jZgvr_�wlh�^_eZeb�jh^bl_eb�\ hlghr_gbb�j_[_gdZ�K\_jo�Y�� dhlhjh_�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� [_j_l� gZ� k_[y� \eZklv�� jZ[hlm� b ^Z`_� f_lh^ujh^bl_evkdhc� bgklZgpbb�� y\ey_lky� g_� lhevdh� __ ij__fgbdhf�� gh� b ^_ckl\bl_evgh� aZdhggufijyfuf� gZke_^gbdhf�� Hgh� b \uoh^bl� ijyfh� ba� g__�� b fu� kdhjh� magZ_f�� dZdbf� iml_f�� GhkgZqZeZ� hklZgh\bfky� gZ� jZkkh]eZkh\Zgbb� f_`^m� gbfb�� DZ`_lky�� qlh� K\_jo�Y h^ghklhjhgg_i_j_gbfZ_l� ebrv� l\_j^hklv� b kljh]hklv� jh^bl_e_c�� bo� aZij_sZxsmx� b gZdZau\Zxsmxnmgdpbx��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�bo�bkiheg_ggZy�ex[\b�aZ[hlZ�g_�gZoh^bl�f_klZ�b ijh^he`_gby��?kebjh^bl_eb�^_ckl\bl_evgh�ijb^_j`b\Zebkv� kljh]h]h� \hkiblZgby�� lh� dZ`_lky� \iheg_�ihgylguf�_keb�b m�j_[_gdZ�jZa\b\Z_lky�kljh]h_�K\_jo�Y��h^gZdh�ijhlb\�h`b^Zgby�hiul�ihdZau\Z_l��qlhK\_jo�Y fh`_l� [ulv� lZdbf� `_� g_mfhebfh� kljh]bf�� ^Z`_� _keb� \hkiblZgb_� [ueh� fy]dbf� b^h[juf�� _keb� m]jha� b gZdZaZgbc� ih� \hafh`ghklb� ba[_]Zeb�� Iha^g__� fu� \_jg_fky� d wlhfmijhlb\hj_qbx��dh]^Z�[m^_f�]h\hjblv�h ij_\jZs_gbyo�\e_q_gbc�ijb�h[jZah\Zgbb�K\_jo�Y�H ij_\jZs_gbb� jh^bl_evkdh]h� hlghr_gby� \ K\_jo�Y y� g_� fh]m� kdZaZlv� \Zf� lZd�� dZdohl_ehkv�[u��hlqZklb�ihlhfm��qlh�wlhl�ijhp_kk�lZd�aZimlZg��qlh�_]h�baeh`_gb_�g_�mf_klblky�\jZfdb�\\_^_gby��dhlhjh_�y ohqm�\Zf�^Zlv��Z k�^jm]hc�klhjhgu��ihlhfm��qlh�fu�kZfb�g_�m\_j_gu�qlh� iheghklvx� _]h� ihgyeb��Ihwlhfm� ^h\hevkl\mcl_kv� ke_^mxsbfb� jZatykg_gbyfb��Hkgh\hcwlh]h�ijhp_kkZ�y\ey_lky�lZd�gZau\Z_fZy�b^_glbnbdZpby �,GHQ�WLIL]LHUXQJ�� l��_��mih^h[e_gb_�Yqm`hfm� Y�� \ke_^kl\b_� q_]h� i_j\h_� Y \� hij_^_e_gguo� hlghr_gbyo� \_^_l� k_[y� dZd� ^jm]h_�ih^jZ`Z_l� _fm�� ijbgbfZ_l� _]h� \ ba\_klghc� kl_i_gb� \ k_[y�� B^_glbnbdZpbx� g_� [_a� mki_oZfh`gh� kjZ\gblv� k hjZevguf�� dZggb[Zebklbq_kdbf� ih]ehs_gb_f� qm`hc� ebqghklb�B^_glbnbdZpby�²�hq_gv�\Z`gZy�nhjfZ�k\yab�k ^jm]bf�ebphf��\_jhylgh��kZfZy�i_j\hgZqZevgZy�gh�g_�lh�`_�kZfh_��qlh�\u[hj�h[t_dlZ��JZaebqb_�fh`gh�\ujZablv�ijbf_jgh�lZd��_keb�fZevqbdb^_glbnbpbjm_l�k_[y�k hlphf��lh�hg�ohq_l�[ulv� dZd�hl_p��_keb�hg�^_eZ_l�_]h�h[t_dlhf�k\h_]h\u[hjZ��lh�hg�ohq_l�h[eZ^Zlv� \eZ^_lv�bf��\ i_j\hf�kemqZ_�_]h�Y f_gy_lky�ih�h[jZam�hlpZ��\h\lhjhf�wlh�g_�g_h[oh^bfh��B^_glbnbdZpby�b \u[hj�h[t_dlZ�\ rbjhdhf�kfuke_ �g_aZ\bkbfu^jm]� hl� ^jm]Z�� gh� fh`gh� b^_glbnbpbjh\Zlv� k_[y� bf_ggh� k wlbf� ebphf�� baf_gylv� Y \khhl\_lkl\bb� k gbf�� \u[jZ\� _]h�� gZijbf_j�� \ dZq_kl\_� k_dkmZevgh]h� h[t_dlZ�� =h\hjyl�� qlh\ebygb_� k_dkmZevgh]h� h[t_dlZ� gZ�Y hkh[_ggh� qZklh� ijhbkoh^bl� m `_gsbg�b oZjZdl_jgh� ^ey`_gkl\_gghklb�� H gZb[he__� ihmqbl_evghf� hlghr_gbb� f_`^m� b^_glbnbdZpb_c� b \u[hjhfh[t_dlZ�y m`_�dZd�lh�]h\hjbe�\Zf�\ ij_^u^msbo�e_dpbyo��?]h�e_]dh�gZ[ex^Zlv�dZd�m ^_l_c��lZdb m� \ajhkeuo�� dZd� m ghjfZevguo�� lZd� b m� [hevguo� ex^_c��?keb� h[t_dl� mljZq_g� beb� hl� g_]h\ugm`^_gu�hldZaZlvky��lh�^hklZlhqgh�qZklh�ihl_jx�\haf_sZxl�l_f��qlh�b^_glbnbpbjmxl�k_[yk gbf�� \hkklZgZ\eb\Zy� \ k\h_f� Y�� lZd�� qlh� a^_kv� \u[hj� h[t_dlZ� dZd� [u� j_]j_kkbjm_l� db^_glbnbdZpbb�Wlbfb� jZkkm`^_gbyfb� h[� b^_glbnbdZpbb� y kZf� g_� \iheg_� m^h\e_l\hj_g�� gh� fg_� [m^_l^hklZlhqgh��_keb�\u�kfh`_l_�ijbagZlv��qlh�\\_^_gb_�\ ^_ckl\b_�K\_jo�Y fh`_l�[ulv�hibkZghdZd�m^Zqguc�kemqZc�b^_glbnbdZpbb�k jh^bl_evkdhc�bgklZgpb_c��J_rZxsbf�nZdlhf�^ey�wlhclhqdb��aj_gby�y\ey_lky�lh��qlh�wlh�gh\hh[jZah\Zgb_�ij_\hkoh^ys_c�bgklZgpbb��Y l_kg_crbf

Page 292: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

h[jZahf�k\yaZgh�k km^v[hc�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ��lZd�qlh�K\_jo�Y y\ey_lky�gZke_^b_f�wlhc�klhevagZqbfhc� ^ey� ^_lkl\Z� wfhpbhgZevghc� k\yab�� Fu� ihgbfZ_f�� qlh� k mkljZg_gb_f� W^bih\Zdhfie_dkZ� j_[_ghd� ^he`_g� hldZaZlvky� hl� bgl_gkb\ghc� ijb\yaZgghklb� d h[t_dlZf�� dhlhjufb[ueb� _]h� jh^bl_eb�� Z ^ey� dhfi_gkZpbb� wlhc� mljZlu� h[t_dlh\� \ _]h� Y hq_gv� mkbeb\Zxlky\_jhylgh�^Z\gh�bf_\rb_ky�b^_glbnbdZpbb�k jh^bl_eyfb��LZdb_�b^_glbnbdZpbb��dZd�ke_^kl\byhldZaZ�hl�ijb\yaZgghklb�d h[t_dlZf��iha^g__�^hklZlhqgh�qZklh�ih\lhjyxlky�\ `bagb�j_[_gdZ�gh�wfhpbhgZevghc�p_gghklb�wlh]h�i_j\h]h�kemqZy�lZdhc�aZf_gu�\iheg_�khhl\_lkl\m_l�lh��qlh�\j_amevlZl_� wlh]h� \ Y� kha^Z_lky� hkh[h_�iheh`_gb_��LsZl_evgh_�bkke_^h\Zgb_�ihdZau\Z_l�gZflZd`_�� qlh� K\_jo�Y l_jy_l� \ kbe_� b aZ\_jr_gghklb� jZa\blby�� _keb� ij_h^he_gb_� W^bih\Zdhfie_dkZ� m^Z_lky� ebrv� hlqZklb�� < ijhp_kk_� jZa\blby� gZ� K\_jo�Y \ebyxl� lZd`_� l_� ebpZ�dhlhju_�aZf_klbeb�jh^bl_e_c��l��_��\hkiblZl_eb��mqbl_ey��b^_Zevgu_�ijbf_ju��H[uqgh�hgh�\k_[hevr_�hl^Zey_lky� hl�i_j\hgZqZevguo�bg^b\b^mZevghkl_c� jh^bl_e_c�� klZgh\ykv�� lZd� kdZaZlv�\k_�[he__�[_aebqghklguf��Gh�g_evay�lZd`_�aZ[u\Zlv��qlh�j_[_ghd�ih�jZaghfm�hp_gb\Z_l�k\hbojh^bl_e_c�gZ�jZaguo� wlZiZo�`bagb��D lhfm� \j_f_gb�� dh]^Z�W^bih\� dhfie_dk� mklmiZ_l�f_klhK\_jo�Y�� hgb� y\eyxl� kh[hc� g_qlh� kh\_jr_ggh� aZf_qZl_evgh_�� mljZqb\Zy� hq_gv� fgh]h_\ihke_^kl\bb��B lh]^Z�lh`_�ijhbkoh^yl�b^_glbnbdZpbb�k wlbfb�[he__�iha^gbfb�jh^bl_eyfb�hgb�^Z`_�h[uqgh�kihkh[kl\mxl�nhjfbjh\Zgbx�oZjZdl_jZ��gh�wlh�dZkZ_lky�lhevdh�Y��gZ�K\_jo�Y��dhlhjh_�[ueh�knhjfbjh\Zgh�[he__�jZggbf�h[jZahf�jh^bl_e_c��hgb�m`_�g_�\ebyxl�GZ^_xkv�� m \Zk� m`_� keh`behkv� \i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� ihgylb_� K\_jo�Y hibku\Z_l^_ckl\bl_evgh�kljmdlmjgh_�khhlghr_gb_��Z g_�ijhklh�i_jkhgbnbpbjm_l�Z[kljZdpbx�gZih^h[b_kh\_klb��Fu�^he`gu�mihfygmlv�_s_�h^gm�\Z`gmx�nmgdpbx��dhlhjhc�fu�gZ^_ey_f�wlh�K\_jo�Y�Hgh� y\ey_lky� lZd`_� ghkbl_e_f� Y�b^_ZeZ�� k dhlhjuf� Y khbaf_jy_l� k_[y�� d dhlhjhfm� hghklj_fblky�� qv_� lj_[h\Zgb_� ihklhyggh]h� kh\_jr_gkl\h\Zgby� hgh� klZjZ_lky� \uihegblv�G_khfg_ggh�� wlhl� Y�b^_Ze� y\ey_lky� hljZ`_gb_f� klZjh]h� ij_^klZ\e_gby� h jh^bl_eyo�\ujZ`_gb_f�\hkobs_gby�bo�kh\_jr_gkl\hf��dhlhjh_�j_[_ghd�bf�lh]^Z�ijbibku\Ze�AgZx��qlh�\u�fgh]h�keurZeb�h qm\kl\_�g_iheghp_gghklb��dhlhjh_�oZjZdl_jbam_l�dZd�jZag_\jhlbdh\�� Hgh� ijhy\ey_lky�� \ qZklghklb�� \ lZd� gZau\Z_fhc� om^h`_kl\_gghc� ebl_jZlmj_�IbkZl_ev�� mihlj_[b\rbc� keh\hkhq_lZgb_� ©dhfie_dk�g_iheghp_gghklbª�� kqblZ_l�� qlh� wlbf� hgm^h\e_l\hjy_l�\k_f� lj_[h\Zgbyf�ikbohZgZebaZ�b ih^gbfZ_l� k\h_� l\hj_gb_�gZ�[he__� \ukhdbcikboheh]bq_kdbc� mjh\_gv�� < ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� bkdmkkl\_ggh_� keh\hkhq_lZgb_� ©dhfie_dkg_iheghp_gghklbª� \ ikbohZgZeba_� ihqlb� g_� mihlj_[ey_lky�� Hg� g_� y\ey_lky� ^ey� gZk� q_f�lhijhkluf��l_f�[he__�we_f_glZjguf��K\h^blv�_]h�d kZfh\hkijbylbx�\hafh`gh]h�g_^hjZa\blbyhj]Zgh\�� dZd� wlh� ex[yl� ^_eZlv� ij_^klZ\bl_eb� rdheu� lZd� gZau\Z_fhc� bg^b\b^mZevghcikboheh]bb�� dZ`_lky� gZf� g_^Zevgh\b^guf� aZ[em`^_gb_f�� Qm\kl\h� g_iheghp_gghklb� bf__l]em[hdh� wjhlbq_kdb_� dhjgb�� J_[_ghd� qm\kl\m_l� k_[y� g_iheghp_gguf�� _keb� aZf_qZ_l�� qlh� hgg_ex[bf��b lhqgh�lZd�`_�\ajhkeuc��?^bgkl\_gguc�hj]Zg��dhlhjuc�fh`_l�jZkkfZljb\Zlvky�dZdg_iheghp_gguc�� wlh� jm^bf_glZjguc� i_gbk�� deblhj� ^_\hqdb�� Gh� ih� [hevr_c� qZklb� qm\kl\hg_iheghp_gghklb�ijhbkoh^bl�ba�hlghr_gby�Y d�k\h_fm�K\_jo�Y��y\eyykv��lZd�`_�dZd�qm\kl\h\bgu��\ujZ`_gb_f�gZijy`_gby�f_`^m�gbfb��Qm\kl\h�g_iheghp_gghklb�b qm\kl\h�\bgu�\hh[s_ljm^gh�hl^_eblv�^jm]� hl�^jm]Z��<hafh`gh��[ueh�[u�ijZ\bevgh� \b^_lv� \ i_j\hf� wjhlbq_kdh_^hiheg_gb_�d qm\kl\m�fhjZevghc�g_iheghp_gghklb��Wlhfm�\hijhkm�jZa]jZgbq_gby�ihgylbc�fu\ ikbohZgZeba_�m^_eyeb�fZeh�\gbfZgby�

Page 293: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Bf_ggh� ihlhfm�� qlh� dhfie_dk� g_iheghp_gghklb� klZe� lZd� ihimeyj_g�� y iha\hex� k_[_k^_eZlv� a^_kv� g_[hevrh_� hlklmie_gb_�� M h^gh]h� bklhjbq_kdh]h� ^_yl_ey� gZr_]h� \j_f_gb�dhlhjuc� a^jZ\kl\m_l� b ihgug_�� gh� hlhr_e� hl� ^_e�� \ke_^kl\b_� jh^h\hc� ljZ\fu� bf_eh� f_klhg_dhlhjh_�g_^hjZa\blb_�h^gh]h�qe_gZ��Hq_gv�ba\_klguc�ibkZl_ev�gZrbo�^g_c��hohlg__�\k_]hibrmsbc�[bh]jZnbb�aZf_qZl_evguo�ex^_c��aZgyeky�`bagvx�wlh]h�mihfygmlh]h�fghc�q_eh\_dZ�Gh� \_^v� ljm^gh� ih^Z\blv� \ k_[_� ihlj_[ghklv� m]em[e_gby� \ ikboheh]bx�� dh]^Z� ibr_rv[bh]jZnbx��Ihwlhfm�gZr�Z\lhj�hl\Z`beky�gZ�ihiuldm�ihkljhblv�\k_�jZa\blb_�oZjZdl_jZ�k\h_]h]_jhy� gZ� qm\kl\_� g_iheghp_gghklb�� \ua\Zgghf� wlbf� nbabq_kdbf� ^_n_dlhf�� Gh� ijb� ihf� hgmimklbe� h^bg� fZe_gvdbc�� gh� g_fZeh\Z`guc� nZdl�� H[uqgh� fZl_jb�� dhlhjuf� km^v[Z� ^ZeZ[hevgh]h�beb�g_iheghp_ggh]h�j_[_gdZ��iulZxlky�\hkihegblv�wlm�g_kijZ\_^eb\hklv�qj_af_jghcex[h\vx��< gZr_f�kemqZ_�]hj^Zy�fZlv�ih\_eZ�k_[y�ih�^jm]hfm��hgZ�hldZaZeZ�j_[_gdm�\ ex[\bba�aZ�_]h�g_^hklZldZ��Dh]^Z�hg�klZe�fh]ms_kl\_gguf�q_eh\_dhf��lh�\k_fb�k\hbfb�^_ckl\byfb^hdZaZe�� qlh� lZd� gbdh]^Z� b g_� ijhklbe� k\hx� fZlv�� ?keb� \u� ij_^klZ\bl_� k_[_� agZq_gb_fZl_jbgkdhc�ex[\b�^ey�^_lkdhc�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��\u��\b^bfh��fuke_ggh�\g_k_l_�ihijZ\db�\l_hjbx�g_iheghp_gghklb�[bh]jZnZ�Gh�\_jg_fky�d K\_jo�Y��Fu�gZ^_ebeb�_]h�kZfhgZ[ex^_gb_f��kh\_klvx�b nmgdpb_c�b^_ZeZ�Ba� gZrbo� jZkkm`^_gbc� h _]h� \hagbdgh\_gbb� ihemqZ_lky�� qlh� hgh� h[mkeh\e_gh� qj_a\uqZcgh\Z`guf� [bheh]bq_kdbf�� Z lZd`_� hij_^_eyxsbf� km^v[m� ikboheh]bq_kdbf� nZdlhf�� Z bf_ggh^ebl_evghc� aZ\bkbfhklvx� j_[_gdZ� hl� k\hbo� jh^bl_e_c� b W^bih\uf� dhfie_dkhf�� dhlhju_hiylv�lZdb� \gmlj_gg_� k\yaZgu� f_`^m� kh[hc�� K\_jo�Y y\ey_lky� ^ey� gZk� ij_^klZ\bl_e_f� \k_ofhjZevguo�h]jZgbq_gbc��ih[hjgbdhf�klj_fe_gby�d kh\_jr_gkl\h\Zgbx��dhjhq_��l_f��qlh�gZfklZeh�ikboheh]bq_kdb�^hklmigh�ba�lZd�gZau\Z_fh]h�[he__�\ha\ur_ggh]h�\ q_eh\_q_kdhc�`bagb�Ihkdhevdm�hgh�kZfh�\hkoh^bl�d \ebygbx�jh^bl_e_c��\hkiblZl_e_c�b bf�ih^h[guo��fu�magZ_f_s_� [hevr_� h _]h� agZq_gbb�� _keb� h[jZlbfky� d wlbf� bklhqgbdZf�� DZd� ijZ\beh�� jh^bl_eb� bZgZeh]bqgu_�bf�Z\lhjbl_lu�\ \hkiblZgbb�j_[_gdZ�ke_^mxl�ij_^ibkZgbyf�kh[kl\_ggh]h�K\_jo�Y��DZd�[u�eb�jZkoh^behkv�bo�Y kh�K\_jo�Y��\ \hkiblZgbb�j_[_gdZ�hgb�kljh]b�b \aukdZl_evgu�Hgb�aZ[ueb�ljm^ghklb�k\h_]h�kh[kl\_ggh]h�^_lkl\Z��^h\hevgu��qlh�fh]ml�gZdhg_p�iheghklvxb^_glbnbpbjh\Zlv�k_[y�kh�k\hbfb�jh^bl_eyfb��dhlhju_�\ k\h_�\j_fy�gZeZ]Zeb�gZ�gbo�ly`_eu_h]jZgbq_gby��LZdbf�h[jZahf��K\_jo�Y j_[_gdZ�kljhblky�kh[kl\_ggh�g_�ih�ijbf_jm�jh^bl_e_c��Zih� jh^bl_evkdhfm� K\_jo�Y�� hgh� gZihegy_lky� l_f� `_� kh^_j`Zgb_f�� klZgh\blky� ghkbl_e_fljZ^bpbb��\k_o�l_o�khojZgb\rboky�\h�\j_f_gb�p_gghkl_c��dhlhju_�ijh^he`Zxl�kms_kl\h\ZlvgZ� wlhf� imlb� q_j_a� ihdhe_gby�� <u� e_]dh� m]Z^Z_l_�� dZdmx� \Z`gmx� ihfhsv� ^ey� ihgbfZgbykhpbZevgh]h� ih\_^_gby� q_eh\_dZ�� gZijbf_j�� ^ey� ihgbfZgby� [_kijbahjghklb�� beb� ^Z`_ijZdlbq_kdb_�kh\_lu�ih�\hkiblZgbx�fh`gh�ba\e_qv�ba�ij_^klZ\e_gby�h K\_jo�Y��<b^bfh��lZdgZau\Z_fu_� fZl_jbZebklbq_kdb_� \haaj_gby� gZ� bklhjbx� ]j_rZl� g_^hhp_gdhc� wlh]h� nZdlhjZ�Hgb�hl^_eu\Zxlky�hl�g_]h�aZf_qZgb_f��qlh�©b^_heh]bbª�ex^_c�kmlv�g_�qlh�bgh_��dZd�j_amevlZlb gZ^kljhcdZ�^_ckl\mxsbo�wdhghfbq_kdbo�hlghr_gbc��Wlh�ijZ\^Z��gh�hq_gv�\_jhylgh�²�g_�\kyijZ\^Z�� Q_eh\_q_kl\h� gbdh]^Z� g_� `b\_l� iheghklvx� \ gZklhys_f�� \ b^_heh]byo� K\_jo�Yijh^he`Z_l� `blv� ijhreh_�� ljZ^bpby� jZku� b gZjh^Z�� dhlhju_� ebrv� f_^e_ggh� ih^^Zxlky\ebygbyf�kh\j_f_gghklb��gh\uf�baf_g_gbyf��b��ihdZ�hgh�^_ckl\m_l�q_j_a�K\_jo�Y��hgh�b]jZ_lagZqbl_evgmx��g_aZ\bkbfmx�hl�wdhghfbq_kdbo�hlghr_gbc�jhev�\ q_eh\_q_kdhc�`bagb�< �����]��ijb�bamq_gbb�ikboheh]bb�fZkk�y ihiulZeky�bkihevah\Zlv�^bnn_j_gpbZpbx�Y b

Page 294: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

K\_jo�Y�� Y ijbr_e� d nhjfme_�� ©Ikboheh]bq_kdZy� fZkkZ� y\ey_lky� h[t_^bg_gb_f� hl^_evguoebqghkl_c�� dhlhju_� \\_eb� \ k\h_� K\_jo�Y h^gh� b lh� `_� ebph� b gZ� hkgh\_� wlhc� h[sghklbb^_glbnbpbjh\Zebkv�^jm]�k ^jm]hf�\ k\h_f�Yª��HgZ�hlghkblky��dhg_qgh��lhevdh�d l_f�fZkkZf�dhlhju_� bf_xl� h^gh]h� \h`^y� ��� ?keb� [u� m gZk� [ueh� [hevr_� ijbf_jh\� lZdh]h� jh^Z�� lhij_^iheh`_gb_� K\_jo�Y i_j_klZeh� [u� [ulv� kh\_jr_ggh� qm`^uf� ^ey� gZk� b fu� kh\k_fhk\h[h^bebkv� [u� hl� lhc� jh[hklb�� dhlhjZy� \k_� _s_� ho\Zlu\Z_l� gZk�� ijb\udrbo� d Zlfhkn_j_ij_bkih^g_c�� ijb� ijh^\b`_gbb� gZ� [he__� ih\_joghklgu_�� [he__� \ukhdb_� kehb� ikbobq_kdh]hZiiZjZlZ�� JZamf__lky�� fu� g_� ^mfZ_f�� qlh�� \u^_eyy� K\_jo�Y�� fu� ]h\hjbf� ihke_^g__� keh\h� \ikboheh]bb�Y��Wlh�kdhj__�gZqZeh��k lhc�ebrv�jZagbp_c��qlh�lml�g_�lhevdh�gZqZeh�ljm^gh�Gm� Z l_i_jv� gZk� `^_l� ^jm]Zy� aZ^ZqZ�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� k ^jm]hc� klhjhgu� Y�� HgZ� \hagbdeZ[eZ]h^Zjy�gZ[ex^_gbx�\h�\j_fy�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�jZ[hlu��gZ[ex^_gbx��kh[kl\_ggh�]h\hjy��hq_gvklZjhfm��DZd�m`_�g_�jZa�[u\Zeh��bf�^Z\gh�ihevah\Zebkv��ij_`^_�q_f�j_rbebkv�ijbagZlv��DZd\u�agZ_l_��\ky�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdZy�l_hjby��kh[kl\_ggh��ihkljh_gZ�gZ�ijbagZgbb�khijhlb\e_gby�dhlhjh_� hdZau\Z_l� gZf� iZpb_gl� ijb� ihiuld_� k^_eZlv� khagZl_evguf� _]h� [_kkhagZl_evgh_�H[t_dlb\guf�ijbagZdhf� khijhlb\e_gby�y\ey_lky� lh��qlh�_]h� ZkkhpbZlb\gu_�fukeb� hklZxlkyg_h[tykgbfufb� beZ� ^Ze_dh� mdehgyxlky� hl� h[km`^Z_fhc� l_fu�� Km[t_dlb\gh� hg� fh`_l� bijbagZ\Zlv�khijhlb\e_gb_��ihlhfm�qlh�bkiulu\Z_l�hsms_gb_�klu^Z��ijb[eb`Zykv�d l_f_��Ghwlhl� ihke_^gbc� ijbagZd� fh`_l� b hlkmlkl\h\Zlv�� Lh]^Z� fu� ]h\hjbf� iZpb_glm�� qlh� ba� _]hhlghr_gby�fu�aZdexqZ_f��qlh�hg�gZoh^blky�k_cqZk�\ khklhygbb�khijhlb\e_gby��Z hg�hl\_qZ_l�qlh� gbq_]h� h[� wlhf� g_� agZ_l� b aZf_qZ_l� lhevdh� aZljm^g_gby� >\ ihy\e_gbb@� ZkkhpbZlb\guofuke_c�� H[gZjm`b\Z_lky�� qlh� fu� [ueb� ijZ\u�� gh� lh]^Z� _]h� khijhlb\e_gb_� [ueh� lh`_[_kkhagZl_evguf��lZdbf�`_�[_kkhagZl_evguf��dZd�b \ul_kg_ggh_ �9HUGUDQJWH�� gZ^�mkljZg_gb_fdhlhjh]h�fu� jZ[hlZeb��Ke_^h\Zeh� [u� ^Z\gh� ihklZ\blv� \hijhk��ba� dZdhc� qZklb� _]h� ^mr_\ghc`bagb�bkoh^bl�lZdh_�[_kkhagZl_evgh_�khijhlb\e_gb_"�Gh\bqhd�\ ikbohZgZeba_�[ukljh�gZc^_lhl\_l��wlh�b _klv�khijhlb\e_gb_�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��>\mkfuke_gguc��g_ijb_fe_fuc�hl\_l��?kebih^�wlbf�ih^jZamf_\Z_lky��qlh�hg�bkoh^bl�ba�\ul_kg_ggh]h��lh�fu�^he`gu�kdZaZlv��wlh�g_�lZd�<ul_kg_gghfm� fu� kdhj__� ijbibr_f� kbevguc� bfimevk�� klj_fe_gb_� ijh[blvky� d khagZgbx�Khijhlb\e_gb_� fh`_l� [ulv� lhevdh� \ujZ`_gb_f� Y�� dhlhjh_� \ k\h_� \j_fy� hkms_kl\beh\ul_kg_gb_��Z l_i_jv�ohq_l�_]h�khojZgblv��LZd�fu�\k_]^Z�b ihgbfZeb�wlh�jZgvr_��K l_o�ihj�dZdfu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f�\ Y�hkh[mx�bgklZgpbx��ij_^klZ\eyxsmx�h]jZgbqb\Zxsb_�b hldehgyxsb_lj_[h\Zgby��K\_jo�Y��fu�fh`_f� kdZaZlv�� qlh� \ul_kg_gb_� y\ey_lky�^_ehf� wlh]h�K\_jo�Y�� hghijh\h^bl�\ul_kg_gb_�beb�kZfh��beb�ih�_]h�aZ^Zgbx�wlh�^_eZ_l�ihkemrgh_�_fm�Y��B \hl�_kebgZebph�kemqZc��dh]^Z�khijhlb\e_gb_�ijb�ZgZeba_�iZpb_glhf�g_�hkhagZ_lky��lh�wlh�agZqbl��qlheb[h�K\_jo�Y b�Y \�hq_gv�\Z`guo�kblmZpbyo�fh]ml�jZ[hlZlv�[_kkhagZl_evgh��eb[h��qlh�[ueh�[u_s_� agZqbl_evg__�� qlh� g_dhlhju_� qZklb� lh]h� b ^jm]h]h�� Y b� kZfh]h� K\_jo�Y�� y\eyxlky[_kkhagZl_evgufb��< h[hbo� kemqZyo�fu� \ugm`^_gu� ijbclb� d g_ml_rbl_evghfm� \u\h^m�� qlhK\_jo�Y b�khagZl_evgh_��k h^ghc�klhjhgu��b \ul_kg_ggh_�b [_kkhagZl_evgh_�²�k ^jm]hc��gb�\dh_f�kemqZ_�g_�kh\iZ^Zxl�M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��<b^bfh��gZ^h�k^_eZlv�i_j_^urdm��ijhlb\�q_]h�b \u�lh`_�g_[m^_l_� \hajZ`Zlv�� gh�� ij_`^_� q_f� y ijh^he`m�� \ukemrZcl_� fhb� ba\bg_gby�� Ohqm� k^_eZlv^hiheg_gby�d \\_^_gbx�\ ikbohZgZeba��dhlhjh_�y gZqZe�iylgZ^pZlv�e_l�lhfm�gZaZ^��b \ugm`^_g\_klb� k_[y� lZd�� [m^lh� b \u� \ wlhl� ijhf_`mlhd� \j_f_gb� g_� aZgbfZebkv� gbq_f� bguf�� djhf_

Page 295: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ikbohZgZebaZ�� Y agZx�� qlh� wlh� g_\_jhylgh_� ij_^iheh`_gb_�� gh� y [_kihfhs_g�� y g_� fh]mihklmiblv�bgZq_��B k\yaZgh�wlh�k l_f��qlh�\hh[s_�hq_gv�ljm^gh�ihagZdhfblv�k ikbohZgZebahflh]h��dlh�kZf�g_� y\ey_lky�ikbohZgZeblbdhf��Ih\_jvl_��fu�g_�ohlbf�ijhba\_klb�\i_qZle_gb_�[m^lh�fu�qe_gu�lZcgh]h�h[s_kl\Z�b aZgbfZ_fky�dZdhc�lh�lZcghc�gZmdhc��B \k_�`_�fu�^he`guijbagZlv�b h[ty\blv�k\hbf�m[_`^_gb_f��qlh�gbdlh�g_�bf__l�ijZ\Z�\f_rb\Zlvky�\ jZa]h\hj�hikbohZgZeba_��g_�h\eZ^_\�hij_^_e_gguf�hiulhf��dhlhjuc�fh`gh�ihemqblv�lhevdh�ijb�ZgZeba_k\h_c�kh[kl\_gghc�ebqghklb��Dh]^Z�y qblZe�\Zf�e_dpbb�iylgZ^pZlv�e_l�lhfm�gZaZ^��y iulZeky�g_h[j_f_gylv� \Zk� g_dhlhjufb� mfhajbl_evgufb� fhf_glZfb� gZr_c� l_hjbb�� gh� bf_ggh� k gbfbk\yaZgu�gh\u_�^Zggu_��h dhlhjuo�y ohqm�kdZaZlv�k_]h^gy�<ha\jZsZxkv� d l_f_�� K\h_� khfg_gb_�� fh]ml� eb� Y beb� ^Z`_� K\_jo�Y [ulv[_kkhagZl_evgufb� beb� hgb� lhevdh� kihkh[gu� hkms_kl\eylv� [_kkhagZl_evgu_� ^_ckl\by�� fu� kiheguf�hkgh\Zgb_f�j_rZ_f�\ ihevam�i_j\hc�\hafh`ghklb��>Z��agZqbl_evgu_�qZklb�Y b�K\_jo�Y fh]ml� hklZ\Zlvky� [_kkhagZl_evgufb�� h[uqgh� y\eyxlky� [_kkhagZl_evgufb��Wlh� agZqbl�� qlhebqghklv�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_l�h[�bo�kh^_j`Zgbb�b _c�lj_[m_lky�mkbeb_��qlh[u�k^_eZlv�bo�^ey�k_[ykhagZl_evgufb��;u\Z_l��qlh�Y b�khagZl_evgh_��\ul_kg_ggh_�b [_kkhagZl_evgh_�g_� kh\iZ^Zxl�Fu� bkiulu\Z_f� ihlj_[ghklv� hkgh\Zl_evgh� i_j_kfhlj_lv� k\hc� ih^oh^� d ijh[e_f_khagZl_evgh_�[_kkhagZl_evgh_�� KgZqZeZ� fu� [ueb� kdehggu� agZqbl_evgh� kgbablv� agZqbfhklvdjbl_jby� khagZl_evghklb�� ihkdhevdm� hg� hdZaZeky� klhev� g_gZ^_`guf�� Gh� fu� ihklmibeb� [ug_kijZ\_^eb\h��A^_kv�^_eh�h[klhbl�lZd�`_��dZd�k gZr_c�`bagvx��hgZ�g_�fgh]h]h�klhbl��gh�wlh\k_��qlh�m gZk�_klv��;_a�k\_lZ�wlh]h�dZq_kl\Z�khagZgby�fu�[u�aZl_jyebkv�\ ihl_fdZo�]em[bgghcikboheh]bb��gh�fu�bf__f�ijZ\h�ihiulZlvky�khjb_glbjh\Zlv�k_[y�ih�gh\hfm�Lh��qlh�^he`gh�gZau\Zlvky�khagZl_evguf��g_�gm`^Z_lky�\ h[km`^_gbb��a^_kv�g_l�gbdZdbokhfg_gbc��KZfh_�klZjh_�b kZfh_�emqr__�agZq_gb_�keh\Z� ©[_kkhagZl_evgucª�²�hibkZl_evgh_�[_kkhagZl_evguf� fu� gZau\Z_f� ikbobq_kdbc� ijhp_kk�� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� dhlhjh]h� fu� ^he`guij_^iheh`blv��ihkdhevdm�fu�\u\h^bf�_]h�ba�_]h�\ha^_ckl\bc��gbq_]h�g_�agZy�h g_f��>Ze__��fubf__f�d g_fm�lZdh_�`_�hlghr_gb_��dZd�b d�ikbobq_kdhfm�ijhp_kkm�^jm]h]h�q_eh\_dZ��lhevdh�hg�lh� y\ey_lky� gZrbf� kh[kl\_gguf�� ?keb� \ujZablvky� _s_� dhgdj_lg__�� lh� ke_^m_l� baf_gblvij_^eh`_gb_� ke_^mxsbf� h[jZahf�� fu� gZau\Z_f� ijhp_kk� [_kkhagZl_evguf�� dh]^Z� fuij_^iheZ]Z_f�� qlh� hg� Zdlb\babjh\Zeky� k_cqZk� ohly� k_cqZk fu� gbq_]h� h g_f� g_� agZ_f�� Wlhh]jZgbq_gb_� aZklZ\ey_l� aZ^mfZlvky� h lhf�� qlh� [hevrbgkl\h� khagZl_evguo� ijhp_kkh\khagZl_evgu�lhevdh�dhjhldh_�\j_fy��hq_gv�kdhjh�hgb�klZgh\ylky�eZl_glgufb� gh�e_]dh�fh]ml\gh\v�klZlv�khagZl_evgufb��Fu�fh]eb�[u�lZd`_�kdZaZlv��qlh�hgb�klZeb�[_kkhagZl_evgufb��_keb[u�\hh[s_�[ueb�m\_j_gu��qlh�\ khklhygbb�eZl_glghklb�hgb�y\eyxlky�_s_�q_f�lh�ikbobq_kdbf�LZdbf�h[jZahf�fu�g_�magZeb�[u�gbq_]h�gh\h]h�b ^Z`_�g_�ihemqbeb�[u�ijZ\Z�\\_klb�ihgylb_[_kkhagZl_evgh]h� \ ikboheh]bx�� Gh� \hl� ihy\ey_lky� gh\uc� hiul�� dhlhjuc� fu� m`_� fh`_fijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv�gZ� >ijbf_j_@� hrb[hqguo�^_ckl\bc��GZijbf_j�� ^ey� h[tykg_gby� dZdhc�lhh]h\hjdb� fu� \ugm`^_gu� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� m ^himklb\r_]h� __ h[jZah\Zehkv� hij_^_e_ggh_j_q_\h_� gZf_j_gb_�� Ih� ijhbkr_^r_c� hrb[d_� \ j_qb� fu� kh� \k_c� hij_^_e_gghklvx^h]Z^u\Z_fky�h g_f��gh�hgh�g_�hkms_kl\behkv�� l�� _��hgh�[ueh�[_kkhagZl_evguf��?keb�fu�ihijhr_kl\bb� dZdh]h�lh� \j_f_gb� ijb\h^bf� _]h� ]h\hjb\r_fm� b lhl� kfh`_l� ijbagZlv� _]hagZdhfuf�� lh�� agZqbl�� hgh� [ueh� [_kkhagZl_evguf� ebrv� dZdh_�lh� \j_fy�� _keb� `_� hg� [m^_lhljbpZlv� _]h� dZd� qm`^h_� _fm�� lh�� agZqbl�� hgh� ^ebl_evgh_� \j_fy� [ueh� [_kkhagZl_evguf�

Page 296: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

<ha\jZsZykv�d kdZaZgghfm��ba�wlh]h�hiulZ�fu�ihemqZ_f�ijZ\h�h[ty\blv�[_kkhagZl_evguf�b lh�qlh� gZau\Z_lky� eZl_glguf�� Mqblu\Zy� wlb� ^bgZfbq_kdb_� hlghr_gby�� fu� fh`_f� l_i_jv�\u^_eblv�^\Z�\b^Z�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��h^gh��dhlhjh_�ijb�qZklh�ih\lhjyxsboky�mkeh\byo�e_]dhij_\jZsZ_lky�\ khagZl_evgh_��b ^jm]h_��ijb�dhlhjhf�wlh�ij_\jZs_gb_�ijhbkoh^bl�k ljm^hf�bebrv� kh� agZqbl_evgufb� mkbebyfb�� Z fh`_l� b gbdh]^Z� g_� ijhbahclb�� Qlh[u� ba[_`Zlv^\mkfuke_gghklb��bf__f�eb�fu�\ \b^m�h^gh�beb�^jm]h_�[_kkhagZl_evgh_��mihlj_[ey_f�eb�keh\h\ hibkZl_evghf� beb� \ ^bgZfbq_kdhf� kfuke_�� ^h]h\hjbfky� ijbf_gylv� ^ha\he_gguc�� ijhklhciZeebZlb\�� Lh� [_kkhagZl_evgh_�� dhlhjh_� y\ey_lky� lhevdh� eZl_glguf� b e_]dh� klZgh\blkykhagZl_evguf�� fu� gZah\_f� ij_^khagZl_evguf�� ^jm]hfm� `_� hklZ\bf� gZa\Zgb_©[_kkhagZl_evgucª�� BlZd�� m gZk� ljb� l_jfbgZ�� khagZl_evguc�� ij_^khagZl_evgvr� b[_kkhagZl_evguc��dhlhjuo�^hklZlhqgh�^ey� hibkZgby�ikbobq_kdbo�n_ghf_gh\��?s_� jZa��qbklhhibkZl_evgh� b ij_^khagZl_evgh_� [_kkhagZl_evgh�� gh� fu� lZd� _]h� g_� gZau\Z_f�� jZa\_� qlh� \k\h[h^ghf�baeh`_gbb�� _keb� gZf�gm`gh� aZsblblv� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� [_kkhagZl_evguo� ijhp_kkh\\hh[s_�\ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb�GZ^_xkv�� \u� ijbagZ_l_�� qlh� wlh� ihdZ� g_� lZd� m`� keh`gh� b \iheg_� ijb]h^gh� ^eymihlj_[e_gby�� >Z�� gh�� d kh`Ze_gbx�� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdZy� jZ[hlZ� gZklhcqb\h� lj_[m_lmihlj_[e_gby� keh\Z� ©[_kkhagZl_evgucª� _s_�b \�^jm]hf�� lj_lv_f� kfuke_��b wlh�� \hafh`gh��b\ghkbl� imlZgbpm�� Ih^� gh\uf� b kbevguf� \ebygb_f� lh]h�� qlh� h[rbjgZy� b \Z`gZy� h[eZklv^mr_\ghc�`bagb� h[uqgh� kdjulZ� hl� agZgby�Y�� lZd� qlh�ijhl_dZxsb_� \ g_c� ijhp_kku� ke_^m_lijbagZlv� [_kkhagZl_evgufb� \ ijZ\bevghf� ^bgZfbq_kdhf� kfuke_�� fu� ihgbfZ_f� l_jfbg©[_kkhagZl_evgucª� lZd`_� b \� lhibq_kdhf� beb� kbkl_fZlbq_kdhf� kfuke_�� ]h\hjy� h kbkl_f_ij_^khagZl_evgh]h�b [_kkhagZl_evgh]h��h dhgnebdl_�Y k�kbkl_fhc�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h �QEZ�� \k_[hevr_�ijb^Z\Zy� keh\m� kdhj__� kfuke� h[eZklb� ^mrb�� q_f� dZq_kl\Z�ikbobdb��Y\gh� g_m^h[gh_hldjulb_�� kh]eZkgh� dhlhjhfm� ^Z`_� qZklb� Y b� K\_jo�Y \� ^bgZfbq_kdhf� hlghr_gbb[_kkhagZl_evgu�� fu� \hkijbgbfZ_f� a^_kv� dZd� h[e_]q_gb_�� b[h� hgh� iha\hey_l� gZf� mkljZgblvhkeh`g_gb_��Fu�\b^bf��qlh�g_�bf__f�ijZ\Z�gZau\Zlv�qm`^mx�Y h[eZklv�^mrb�kbkl_fhc XEZ�lZd� dZd� g_hkhagZgghklv� g_� y\ey_lky� bkdexqbl_evgh� __ oZjZdl_jbklbdhc�� Ohjhrh�� g_� [m^_f[hevr_� mihlj_[eylv� keh\h� ©[_kkhagZl_evgucª� \ kbkl_fZlbq_kdhf� kfuke_�� ^Z\� ij_`g_fmh[hagZq_gbx�emqr__��g_�^himkdZxs__�g_ijZ\bevgh]h�lhedh\Zgby�gZa\Zgb_��<ke_^�aZ�Gbpr_�bih�ijbf_jm�=��=jh^^_dZ��������fu�[m^_f�gZau\Zlv�_]h�\ ^Zevg_cr_f�Hgh �(V�� Wlh�[_aebqgh_f_klhbf_gb_�dZ`_lky�hkh[_ggh�ih^oh^ysbf�^ey�\ujZ`_gby�hkgh\gh]h�oZjZdl_jZ�wlhc�h[eZklb^mrb��__ qm`^hklb�Y��K\_jo�Y��Y \Hgh�²�\hl� ljb�pZjkl\Z��kn_ju��h[eZklb��gZ�dhlhju_�fu�jZaeh`bf�ikbdbq_kdbc� ZiiZjZlebqghklb��\aZbfh^_ckl\byfb�dhlhjuo�fu�aZcf_fky�\ ^Zevg_cr_f�Gh�ij_`^_�lhevdh�h^gZ�dhjhldZy�\klZ\dZ��>h]Z^u\Zxkv��qlh�\u�g_^h\hevgu�l_f��qlh�ljbdZq_kl\Z� khagZl_evgh]h� b ljb� kn_ju� ikbobq_kdh]h� ZiiZjZlZ� g_� khq_lZxlky� \ ljb� fbjghkh]eZkmxsb_ky� iZju�� \b^y� \ wlhf� g_qlh� hfjZqZxs__� gZrb� j_amevlZlu�� H^gZdh�� ih�fh_fm�kh`Ze_lv� h[� wlhf� g_� klhbl�� b fu� ^he`gu� kdZaZlv� k_[_�� qlh� g_� bf__f� ijZ\Z� h`b^Zlv� lZdh]hijb]eZ`_ggh]h�mihjy^hqb\Zgby��Iha\hevl_�ijb\_klb� kjZ\g_gb_��ijZ\^Z�� kjZ\g_gby�gbq_]h�g_j_rZxl��gh�hgb�fh]ml�kihkh[kl\h\Zlv�gZ]ey^ghklb��Ij_^klZ\vl_�k_[_�kljZgm�k jZaghh[jZagufj_ev_nhf�²� ohefZfb�� jZ\gbghc� b p_iyfb� ha_j�� kh� kf_rZgguf� gZk_e_gb_f�²� \ g_c�`b\ml

Page 297: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_fpu�� fZ^vyju� b keh\Zdb�� dhlhju_� aZgbfZxlky� jZaebqghc� ^_yl_evghklvx�� B \hljZkij_^_e_gb_�fh]eh�[u�[ulv�lZdbf��gZ�ohefZo�`b\ml�g_fpu��hgb�kdhlh\h^u��gZ�jZ\gbg_�²fZ^vyju��dhlhju_�\ujZsb\Zxl�oe_[�b \bgh]jZ^��gZ�ha_jZo�²�keh\Zdb��hgb�eh\yl�ju[m�b ie_lmlljhklgbd��?keb�[u�wlh�jZkij_^_e_gb_�[ueh�[_amdhjbag_gguf�b q_ldbf��lh�<bevkhg�fh]�[u�_fmihjZ^h\Zlvky��wlh�[ueh�[u�lZd`_�m^h[gh�^ey�khh[s_gby�gZ�mjhd_�]_h]jZnbb��H^gZdh�hq_\b^gh�qlh��iml_r_kl\my�ih�wlhc�kljZg_��\u�gZc^_l_�a^_kv�f_gvr_�ihjy^dZ�b [hevr_�i_kljhlu��G_fpu�fZ^vyju�b keh\Zdb�\kx^m�`b\ml� \i_j_f_rdm��gZ�ohefZo� lh`_�_klv�iZrgb��gZ�jZ\gbg_� lZd`_^_j`Zl�kdhl��Dh_�qlh��_kl_kl\_ggh��kh\iZ^_l�k \Zrbfb�h`b^Zgbyfb��l��_��\ ]hjZo�g_�aZgbfZxlkyju[heh\kl\hf��Z \bgh]jZ^�g_�jZkl_l�\ \h^_��>Z��dZjlbgZ�f_klghklb��dhlhjmx�\u�ij_^klZ\bebk_[_��\ h[s_f�b p_ehf�[m^_l�khhl\_lkl\h\Zlv�^_ckl\bl_evghklb��\ qZklghklyo�`_�\u�^himklbl_hldehg_gby�G_�`^bl_��qlh�h[�Hgh� djhf_�gh\h]h�gZa\Zgby�� y khh[sm�\Zf�fgh]h�gh\h]h��Wlh� l_fgZy�g_^hklmigZy�qZklv�gZr_c�ebqghklb�� lh�g_fgh]h_��qlh�\Zf�h g_c�ba\_klgh��fu� magZeb��bamqZyjZ[hlm� kgh\b^_gby� b h[jZah\Zgb_� �g_\jhlbq_kdbo� kbfilhfh\�� b [hevrbgkl\h� wlbo� k\_^_gbcghkyl�g_]Zlb\guc�oZjZdl_j��^himkdZy�hibkZgb_� lhevdh�\ dZq_kl\_�ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb�Y��Fuijb[eb`Z_fky� d >ihgbfZgbx@� Hgh� ijb� ihfhsb� kjZ\g_gby�� �gZau\Zy� _]h� oZhkhf�� dhlehf�iheguf� [mjeysbo� \ha[m`^_gbc��Fu� ij_^klZ\ey_f� k_[_�� qlh� m k\h_]h� ij_^_eZ� hgh� hldjulhkhfZlbq_kdhfm��\[bjZy�hllm^Z�\ k_[y�bgklbgdlb\gu_�ihlj_[ghklb��dhlhju_�gZoh^yl�\ g_f�k\h_ikbobq_kdh_�\ujZ`_gb_��gh�fu�g_�fh`_f�kdZaZlv��\ dZdhf�km[kljZl_��;eZ]h^Zjy�\e_q_gbyf�hghgZihegy_lky� wg_j]b_c�� gh� g_� bf__l� hj]ZgbaZpbb�� g_� h[gZjm`b\Z_l� h[s_c� \heb�� Z lhevdhklj_fe_gb_� m^h\e_l\hjblv� bgklbgdlb\gu_� ihlj_[ghklb� ijb� khojZg_gbb� ijbgpbiZm^h\hevkl\by��>ey�ijhp_kkh\�\ Hgh�g_�kms_kl\m_l�eh]bq_kdbo�aZdhgh\�fure_gby��ij_`^_�\k_]hl_abkZ�h ijhlb\hj_qbb��Ijhlb\hiheh`gu_�bfimevku�kms_kl\mxl�^jm]�ih^e_�^jm]Z��g_�hlf_gyy^jm]�^jm]Z�b g_�m^Zeyykv�^jm]�hl�^jm]Z��\ emqr_f�kemqZ_�^ey�jZajy^db�wg_j]bb�ih^�^Z\e_gb_fwdhghfbq_kdh]h�ijbgm`^_gby�h[t_^bgyykv�\ dhfijhfbkkgu_�h[jZah\Zgby��< Hgh�g_l�gbq_]h�qlh�fh`gh�[ueh�[u�hlh`^_kl\blv�k hljbpZgb_f��b fu�k m^b\e_gb_f�\b^bf�lZd`_�bkdexq_gb_ba� ba\_klgh]h�nbehkhnkdh]h� iheh`_gby�� qlh� ijhkljZgkl\h� b \j_fy� y\eyxlky� g_h[oh^bfufbnhjfZfb�gZrbo�ikbobq_kdbo�Zdlh\��< Hgh�g_l�gbq_]h��qlh�khhl\_lkl\h\Zeh�[u�ij_^klZ\e_gbxh \j_f_gb��gbdZdh]h�ijbagZgby�l_q_gby�\h�\j_f_gb�b��qlh�\ \ukr_c�kl_i_gb�kljZggh�b `^_lk\h_]h� h[tykg_gby�nbehkhnZfb�� g_l� gbdZdh]h� baf_g_gby� ikbobq_kdh]h� ijhp_kkZ� k l_q_gb_f\j_f_gb�� Bfimevkb\gu_� `_eZgby�� dhlhju_� gbdh]^Z� g_� i_j_klmiZxl� q_j_a� Hgh�� Z lZd`_\i_qZle_gby��dhlhju_�[eZ]h^Zjy�\ul_kg_gbx�himklbebkv�\ Hgh��\bjlmZevgh�[_kkf_jlgu��kimkly^_kylbe_lby� hgb� \_^ml� k_[y� lZd�� keh\gh� \hagbdeb� aZgh\h�� IjbagZlv� \ gbo� ijhreh_�� kmf_lvh[_kp_gblv�bo�b ebrblv�aZjy^Z�wg_j]bb�fh`gh�lhevdh�\ lhf�kemqZ_��_keb�iml_f�ZgZeblbq_kdhcjZ[hlu�hgb�klZgml�hkhagZggufb��b gZ�wlhf�\ g_fZehc�kl_i_gb�hkgh\u\Z_lky�l_jZi_\lbq_kdh_^_ckl\b_�ZgZeblbq_kdh]h�e_q_gby�M f_gy�\k_�\j_fy� kha^Z_lky�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�ba� wlh]h�g_�ih^e_`Zs_]h� khfg_gbx�nZdlZg_baf_gghklb� \ul_kg_ggh]h� \h� \j_f_gb�fu�fZeh� qlh� ^Zeb� ^ey� gZr_c� l_hjbb��: \_^v� a^_kv�dZ`_lky�� hldju\Z_lky� ih^oh^� d kZfhfm� ]em[hdhfm� ihgbfZgbx�� D kh`Ze_gbx�� b y� g_ijh^\bgmeky�a^_kv�^Zevr_�KZfh� kh[hc� jZamf__lky��Hgh�g_� agZdhfu� gbdZdb_� hp_gdb�� gbdZdh_�^h[jh� b aeh��gbdZdZy

Page 298: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fhjZev�� Wdhghfbq_kdbc� beb�� _keb� ohlbl_�� dhebq_kl\_gguc� fhf_gl�� l_kgh� k\yaZgguc� kijbgpbihf�m^h\hevkl\by��mijZ\ey_l�\k_fb�ijhp_kkZfb��<k_�wlb�bgklbgdlu��lj_[mxsb_�\uoh^Z�iheZ]Z_f� fu�� gZoh^ylky� \ Hgh�� DZ`_lky� ^Z`_�� qlh� wg_j]by� wlbo� bgklbgdlb\guo� bfimevkh\gZoh^blky�\ ^jm]hf�khklhygbb��q_f�\ bguo�^mr_\guo�h[eZklyo��hgZ�[he__�ih^\b`gZ�b kihkh[gZd jZajy^d_�� ihlhfm� qlh� bgZq_� g_� fh]eb� [u� ijhbkoh^blv� l_� kf_s_gby� b k]ms_gby�� dhlhju_oZjZdl_jgu�^ey�Hgh�b kh\_jr_ggh�g_� aZ\bkyl�hl�dZq_kl\Z� aZjy`_ggh]h �%HVHW]WH� ²�\ Y�fh]gZa\Zeb�[u� wlh�ij_^klZ\e_gb_f��Q_]h�[u�fu� lhevdh�gb�^Zeb��qlh[u�ih[hevr_� agZlv� h[� wlbo\_sZo��F_`^m�ijhqbf�� \u� \b^bl_�� qlh�fu� \ khklhygbb� gZa\Zlv� _s_�b ^jm]b_� k\hckl\Z�Hgh�djhf_�lh]h��qlh�hgh�[_kkhagZl_evgh��Z lZd`_�ijbagZ_l_�\hafh`ghklv�lh]h��qlh�qZklb�Y b�K\_jo�Y y\eyxlky� [_kkhagZl_evgufb�� g_� bf_y� lZdbo� `_� ijbfblb\guo� b bjjZpbhgZevguo� q_jl�� DoZjZdl_jbklbd_� kh[kl\_ggh�Y��gZkdhevdh� hgh� ^himkdZ_l� h[hkh[e_gb_� hl�Hgh�� b K\_jo�Y fu�kdhj__� \k_]h�� ijb[ebabfky�� _keb� ijbf_f� \h� \gbfZgb_� _]h� hlghr_gb_� d kZfhc� \g_rg_cih\_joghklghc�qZklb�ikbobq_kdh]h�ZiiZjZlZ��dhlhjmx�fu�h[hagZqbf�dZd�kbkl_fm :²%Z��WlZkbkl_fZ� h[jZs_gZ� d \g_rg_fm� fbjm�� hgZ� hihkj_^m_l� _]h� \hkijbylby�� \h� \j_fy� __nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby� \ g_c� \hagbdZ_l� n_ghf_g� khagZgby�� Wlh� hj]Zg� qm\kl\� \k_]h� ZiiZjZlZ�\hkijbbfqb\uc�� f_`^m� ijhqbf�� d \ha[m`^_gbyf�� b^msbf� g_� lhevdh� ba\g_�� gh� b ba� g_^j^mr_\ghc�`bagb��<jy^�eb�gm`^Z_lky�\ ihykg_gbb�lhqdZ�aj_gby��kh]eZkgh�dhlhjhc�Y y\ey_lkylhc� qZklvx�Hgh�� dhlhjZy�fh^bnbpbjh\ZeZkv� [eZ]h^Zjy� [ebahklb� b \ebygbx� \g_rg_]h�fbjZ�ijbkihkh[e_gZ�d \hkijbylbx�jZa^jZ`_gbb�b aZsbl_�hl�gbo��fh`_l�[ulv�kjZ\gbfZ�k dhjdh\ufkeh_f��dhlhjuf�hdjm`_g�dhfhq_d�`b\hc�km[klZgpbb��Hlghr_gb_�d \g_rg_fm�fbjm�^ey�Y klZehj_rZxsbf�� hgh� \ayeh� gZ� k_[y� aZ^Zqm� ij_^klZ\eylv� _]h� i_j_^�Hgh� ^ey� [eZ]Z�Hgh�� dhlhjh_� \ke_ihf� klj_fe_gbb� d m^h\e_l\hj_gbx� \e_q_gbc�� g_� kqblZykv� k wlhc� k\_jokbevghc� \g_rg_c\eZklvx��g_�kfh]eh�[u�ba[_`Zlv�mgbqlh`_gby��<uihegyy�wlm�nmgdpbx��Y ^he`gh�gZ[ex^Zlv�aZ\g_rgbf� fbjhf�� hldeZ^u\Zlv� \ ke_^Zo� k\hbo� \hkijbylbb� ijZ\bevguc� _]h� h[jZa�� iml_fijh\_jdb� j_Zevghklvx� m^Zeylv� ba� wlhc� dZjlbgu� \g_rg_]h� fbjZ� \k_� ^h[Z\e_gby�� b^msb_� hl\gmlj_ggbo�bklhqgbdh\�\ha[m`^_gby��Ih�ihjmq_gbx�Hgh�Y \eZ^__l�ih^oh^Zfb�d fhlhjbd_��ghf_`^m� ihlj_[ghklvx� b ^_ckl\b_f� hgh� ^_eZ_l� hlkjhqdm� ^ey� fukebl_evghc� jZ[hlu�� \h� \j_fydhlhjhc�bkihevam_l� hklZldb� \hkihfbgZgbc�ba� hiulZ��LZdbf� h[jZahf��ijbgpbi� m^h\hevkl\by�dhlhjuc�g_h]jZgbq_ggh�ijZ\bl�oh^hf�ijhp_kkh\�\ Hgh��hdZau\Z_lky�gba\_j]gmluf�k ljhgZ�baZf_gy_lky�ijbgpbihf�j_Zevghklb��dhlhjuc�h[_sZ_l�[hevr_�gZ^_`ghklb�b mki_oZ�Hq_gv� keh`gh_� ^ey� hibkZgby� hlghr_gb_� dh� \j_f_gb� lZd`_� khh[sZ_lky� Y kbkl_fhc\hkijbylby��_^\Z�eb�fh`gh� khfg_\Zlvky�\ lhf��qlh� kihkh[�jZ[hlu� wlhc� kbkl_fu�^Z_l�gZqZehij_^klZ\e_gbx�h \j_f_gb��Q_f�hkh[_ggh�hlebqZ_lky�Y hl�Hgh��lZd�wlh�klj_fe_gb_f�d kbgl_amk\hbo� kh^_j`Zgbc�� d h[h[s_gbx� b mgbnbdZpbb� k\hbo� ikbobq_kdbo� ijhp_kkh\�� dhlhjh_kh\_jr_ggh�hlkmlkl\m_l�m Hgh��Dh]^Z�fu�\ [m^ms_f�ih\_^_f�jZa]h\hj�h \e_q_gbyo�\ ^mr_\ghc`bagb��gZf��\_jhylgh��m^Zklky�gZclb�bklhqgbd� wlhc�kms_kl\_gghc�oZjZdl_jghc�q_jlu�Y��HgZ_^bgkl\_ggZy� ^Z_l� lm� \ukhdmx� kl_i_gv� hj]ZgbaZpbb�� dhlhjhc� Y h[yaZgh� emqrbfb� k\hbfb^hklb`_gbyfb�� JZa\blb_� b^_l� hl� \hkijbylby� \e_q_gbc� d h\eZ^_gbx� bfb�� gh� ihke_^g__^hklb]Z_lky� lhevdh� l_f�� qlh�ikbobq_kdh_� \ujZ`_gb_� \e_q_gbc� \dexqZ_lky� \ [he__�rbjhdmxkbkl_fm�� \oh^bl� \ dZdmx�lh� \aZbfhk\yav�� Ihevamykv� ihimeyjgufb� \ujZ`_gbyfb�� fh`ghkdZaZlv�� qlh� Y \� ^mr_\ghc� `bagb� ij_^klZ\ey_l� a^jZ\uc� kfuke� b [eZ]hjZamfb_�� Z Hgh� ²g_mdjhlbfu_�kljZklb�

Page 299: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

>h� kbo� ihj� gZf� bfihgbjh\Zeh� i_j_qbke_gb_� ij_bfms_kl\� b kihkh[ghkl_c� Y�� l_i_jvgZklZeh� \j_fy� \kihfgblv� b h[� h[hjhlghc� klhjhg_�� Y y\ey_lky� ebrv� qZklvx� Hgh�� qZklvx�p_e_khh[jZagh� baf_g_gghc� [ebahklvx� d ]jhays_fm� hiZkghklyfb� \g_rg_fm� fbjm�� <^bgZfbq_kdhf� hlghr_gbb� hgh� keZ[h�� k\hx� wg_j]bx� hgh� aZbfkl\h\Zeh� m Hgh�� b fu� bf__fg_dhlhjh_� ij_^klZ\e_gb_� hlghkbl_evgh� f_lh^h\�� fh`gh� ^Z`_� kdZaZlv�� eZa__d�� [eZ]h^Zjydhlhjuf� hgh� ijh^he`Z_l� hlgbfZlv� wg_j]bx� m Hgh��LZdbf� iml_f� hkms_kl\ey_lky�� gZijbf_j�lZd`_� b^_glbnbdZpby� k khojZgb\rbfbky� beb� hklZ\e_ggufb� h[t_dlZfb�� Ijb\yaZgghklv� dh[t_dlZf� bkoh^bl� ba� bgklbgdlb\guo� ijblyaZgbc� Hgh�� Y kgZqZeZ� bo� j_]bkljbjm_l�� Gh�b^_glbnbpbjmykv� k h[t_dlhf�� hgh� ij_^eZ]Z_l� k_[y� Hgh� \f_klh� h[t_dlZ�� `_eZy� gZijZ\blveb[b^h�Hgh�gZ�k_[y��Fu�m`_�agZ_f��qlh�\ ijhp_kk_�`bagb�Y ijbgbfZ_l�\ k_[y�[hevrh_�qbkehhklZldh\�[u\r_c�ijb\yaZgghklb�d h[t_dlZf��< h[s_f��Y ^he`gh�ijh\h^blv�\ `bagv�gZf_j_gbyHgh��hgh�\uihegy_l�k\hx�aZ^Zqm��baukdb\Zy�h[klhyl_evkl\Z��ijb�dhlhjuo�wlb�gZf_j_gby�fh]ml[ulv�hkms_kl\e_gu�gZbemqrbf�h[jZahf��Hlghr_gb_�Y d�Hgh�fh`gh�kjZ\gblv�k hlghr_gb_fgZ_a^gbdZ� d k\h_c� ehrZ^b�� EhrZ^v� ^Z_l� wg_j]bx� ^ey� ^\b`_gby�� gZ_a^gbd� h[eZ^Z_lij_bfms_kl\hf�hij_^_eylv�p_ev�b gZijZ\e_gb_�^\b`_gby�kbevgh]h�`b\hlgh]h��Gh�f_`^m�Y bHgh� kebrdhf� qZklh� bf__l� f_klh� ^Ze_dh� g_� b^_Zevgh_� \aZbfhhlghr_gb_�� dh]^Z� gZ_a^gbd\ugm`^_g�gZijZ\eylv�kdZdmgZ�lm^Z��dm^Z�lhfm�\a^mfZ_lky�Hl�h^ghc�qZklb Hgh�Y hl^_ebehkv�[eZ]h^Zjy�khijhlb\e_gbyf�\ul_kg_gby��Gh�\ul_kg_gb_g_�ijh^he`Z_lky�\ Hgh��<ul_kg_ggh_�keb\Z_lky�k��hklZevguf�Hgh�Ih]h\hjdZ� ij_^hkl_j_]Z_l� hl� kem`_gby� ^\mf� ]hkih^Zf�� ;_^ghfm� Y _s_� ly`_e__�� hghkem`bl�lj_f�kljh]bf�\eZkl_ebgZf��klZjZykv�ijb\_klb��bo�ijblyaZgby�b lj_[h\Zgby�\ kh]eZkb_f_`^m� kh[hc�� Wlb� ijblyaZgby� \k_� \j_fy� jZkoh^ylky�� qZklh� dZ`mlky� g_kh\f_klbfufb�g_m^b\bl_evgh�� qlh� Y qZklh� g_� kijZ\ey_lky� kh� k\h_c� aZ^Zq_c�� Lj_fy� lbjZgZfb� y\eyxlky�\g_rgbc�fbj��K\_jo�Y b�Hgh��?keb�ihgZ[ex^Zlv�aZ�mkbebyfb�Y��gZijZ\e_ggufb�gZ�lh��qlh[ukem`blv� bf� h^gh\j_f_ggh�� Z lhqg__�� ih^qbgylvky� bf� h^gh\j_f_ggh�� \jy^� eb� fu� klZg_fkh`Ze_lv�h lhf��qlh�ij_^klZ\beb�Zlh�Y \�i_jkhgbnbpbjh\Zgghf�\b^_�dZd�g_dh_�kms_kl\h��Hghqm\kl\m_]�k_[y�kl_kg_gguf�k lj_o�klhjhg��_fm�]jhayl�ljb�hiZkghklb��gZ�dhlhju_�hgh��[m^mqb�\kl_kg_gghf� iheh`_gbb�� j_Z]bjm_l� ihy\e_gb_f� kljZoZ�� ;eZ]h^Zjy� k\h_fm� ijhbkoh`^_gbx� bahiulZ� kbkl_fu� \hkijbylby�� hgh� ijba\Zgh� ij_^klZ\eylv� lj_[h\Zgby� \g_rg_]h� fbjZ�� gh� hghohq_l�[ulv�b \_jguf�kem]hc�Hgh��ij_[u\Zlv�k gbf�\ kh]eZkbb��ij_^eZ]Zy�_fm�k_[y�\ dZq_kl\_h[t_dlZ�� ijb\e_dZlv� _]h� eb[b^h� gZ� k_[y�� < k\h_f� klj_fe_gbb� ihkj_^gbqZlv� f_`^m� Hgh� bj_Zevghklvx� hgh� qZklh� \ugm`^_gh� h^_\Zlv� [_kkhagZl_evgu_ �XEZ� lj_[h\Zgby� Hgh� \ k\hbij_^khagZl_evgu_ �YEZ� jZpbhgZebaZpbb�� aZlmr_\u\Zlv� dhgnebdlu� Hgh� k j_Zevghklvx�� k^biehfZlbq_kdhc� g_bkdj_gghklvx� jZau]ju\Zlv� h]ey^dm� gZ� j_Zevghklv�� ^Z`_� _keb� Hghmihjkl\m_l�b g_�k^Z_lky��K ^jm]hc�klhjhgu��aZ�gbf�gZ�dZ`^hf�rZ]m�gZ[ex^Z_l�kljh]h_�K\_jo�Y�dhlhjh_�ij_^ibku\Z_l�_fm�hij_^_e_ggu_�ghjfu�ih\_^_gby��g_\abjZy�gZ�ljm^ghklb�kh�klhjhguHgh� b \g_rg_]h� fbjZ�� b gZdZau\Z_l� _]h� \ kemqZ_� g_ihkemrZgby� gZijy`_gguf� qm\kl\hfg_iheghp_gghklb�b khagZgby�\bgu��LZd�Y��^\b`bfh_�Hgh��kl_kg_ggh_�K\_jo�Y��hllZedb\Z_fh_j_Zevghklvx��ijbeZ]Z_l�\k_�mkbeby�^ey�\uiheg_gby�k\h_c�wdhghfbq_kdhc�aZ^Zqb�mklZgh\e_gby]Zjfhgbb�f_`^m� kbeZfb�b \ebygbyfb�� dhlhju_� ^_ckl\mxl� \ g_f�b gZ�g_]h��b fu�ihgbfZ_f�ihq_fm�lZd�qZklh�g_�fh`_f�ih^Z\blv�\hkdebpZgby��`bagv�g_�e_]dZ��?keb�Y \ugm`^_gh�ijbagZlvk\hx� keZ[hklv��\ g_f� \hagbdZ_l� kljZo�� j_Zevguc� kljZo�i_j_^� \g_rgbf�fbjhf�� kljZo� kh\_klb

Page 300: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

i_j_^�K\_jo�Y��g_\jhlbq_kdbc�kljZo�i_j_^�kbehc�kljZkl_c�\ Hgh�Kljmdlmjgu_� khhlghr_gby� ikbobq_kdhc� ebqghklb�� baeh`_ggu_� fghx�� y ohl_e� [uij_^klZ\blv�\ g_ijblyaZl_evghf�jbkmgd_��dhlhjuc�y a^_kv�ijbeZ]Zx�A^_kv�\u�\b^bl_��qlh�K\_jo�Y ih]jm`Z_lky�\ Hgh��dZd�gZke_^gbd�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ�hghbf__l� k gbf�bglbfgu_� k\yab�� hgh�^Zevr_� hl� kbkl_fu� \hkijbylby�� q_f�Y��Hgh� khh[sZ_lky� k\g_rgbf� fbjhf� lhevdh� q_j_a�Y�� ih� djZcg_c� f_j_� gZ� wlhc� ko_f_�� K_]h^gy�� dhg_qgh�� ljm^ghkdZaZlv��gZkdhevdh�jbkmghd�ijZ\be_g��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��\ h^ghf�hlghr_gbb�wlh�hij_^_e_ggh�g_lZd��IjhkljZgkl\h��dhlhjh_�aZgbfZ_l�[_kkhagZl_evgh_�Hgh��^he`gh�[ulv�g_kjZ\g_ggh�[hevr_�q_f�ijhkljZgkl\h�Y beb�ij_^�khagZl_evgh]h��Ijhrm�\Zk��k^_eZcl_�fuke_ggh�ihijZ\dm�: l_i_jv� \ aZdexq_gb_� wlbo� [_amkeh\gh� mlhfbl_evguo� b�� \hafh`gh�� g_� kh\k_f� ykguojZkkm`^_gbc� _s_� h^gh� ij_^hkl_j_`_gb_�� JZa^_eyy� ebqghklv� gZ� Y�� K\_jo�Y b� Hgh�� \u�jZamf__lky��g_�bf__l_�\ \b^m�kljh]b_

]jZgbpu� gZih^h[b_� l_o�� dhlhju_� bkdmkkl\_ggh� ijh\_^_gu� \ iheblbq_kdhc� ]_h]jZnbb�K\h_h[jZab_� ikbobq_kdh]h� fu� bah[jZabf� g_� ebg_cgufb� dhglmjZfb�� dZd� gZ� jbkmgd_� beb� \ijbfblb\ghc� `b\hibkb�� Z kdhj__� jZkieu\qZlufb� p\_lh\ufb� iylgZfb�� dZd� m kh\j_f_gguoom^h`gbdh\��Ihke_�lh]h�dZd�fu�ijhba\_eb�jZa]jZgbq_gb_��fu�^he`gu�\u^_e_ggh_�hiylv�keblv\f_kl_��G_�km^bl_�kebrdhf�kljh]h�h i_j\hc�ihiuld_�k^_eZlv�gZ]ey^guf�ikbobq_kdh_��k lZdbfljm^hf�ih^^Zxs__ky�ihgbfZgbx��<_kvfZ�\_jhylgh��qlh�h[jZah\Zgb_�wlbo�hl^_evguo�h[eZkl_c�mjZaebqguo� ebp� \_kvfZ� \ZjbZ[_evgh�� \hafh`gh�� qlh� ijb� nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgbb� hgb� kZfbbaf_gyxlky�b \j_f_ggh�j_]j_kkbjmxl��Wlh��\ qZklghklb��dZkZ_lky�nbeh]_g_lbq_kdb�ihke_^g_]hb kZfh]h� bglbfgh]h� ²� ^bnn_j_gpbZpbb� Y b� K\_jo�Y�� G_khfg_ggh�� qlh� g_qlh� ih^h[gh_\uau\Z_lky�ikbobq_kdbf�aZ[he_\Zgb_f��Fh`gh�ohjhrh�ij_^klZ\blv�k_[_�lZd`_��qlh�dZdbf�lhfbklbq_kdbf� ijZdlbdZf� bgh]^Z� m^Z_lky� hijhdbgmlv� ghjfZevgu_� hlghr_gby� f_`^m� wlbfbhl^_evgufb�h[eZklyfb��lZd�qlh��gZijbf_j��\hkijbylb_�fh`_l�meh\blv�khhlghr_gby�Y b�Hgh�dhlhju_�\ bguo�kemqZyo�[ueb�_fm�g_^hklmigu��Fh`gh�kihdhcgh�mkhfgblvky�\ lhf��qlh�gZ�wlhfimlb�fu�^hklb]g_f�ihke_^g_c�bklbgu��hl�dhlhjhc�`^ml�\k_h[s_]h�kiZk_gby��gh�fu�\k_�lZdbijbagZ_f�� qlh� l_jZi_\lbq_kdb_� mkbeby� ikbohZgZebaZ� ba[jZeb� k_[_� ZgZeh]bqgmx� lhqdmijbeh`_gby�� <_^v� bo� p_ev� ²� mdj_iblv� Y�� k^_eZlv� _]h� [he__� g_aZ\bkbfuf� hl� K\_jo�Y�jZkrbjblv� ihe_� \hkijbylby� b i_j_kljhblv� _]h� hj]ZgbaZpbx� lZd�� qlh[u� hgh� fh]eh� hk\hblvgh\u_� qZklb�Hgh�� LZf�� ]^_� [ueh�Hgh�� ^he`gh� klZlv� Y�� Wlh� ijbf_jgh� lZdZy� `_� dmevlmjgZyjZ[hlZ��dZd�hkmr_gb_�Azc^_j�A_�

Page 301: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

LJB>P:LV�<LHJ:Y�E?DPBYKljZo�b `bagv�\e_q_gbcM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��<u�g_�m^b\bl_kv��mkeurZ\��qlh�y gZf_j_g�khh[sblv�\Zf�h lhfgh\hf��qlh�ihy\behkv� \ gZr_f�ihgbfZgbb� kljZoZ�b hkgh\guo� \e_q_gbc�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��g_m^b\bl_kv�lZd`_�b lhfm��qlh�gbq_]h�ba�wlh]h�gh\h]h�g_�ij_l_g^m_l�gZ�hdhgqZl_evgh_�j_r_gb_klhysbo�i_j_^�gZfb�ijh[e_f��Y gZf_j_ggh�]h\hjx�a^_kv�h ihgbfZgbb��AZ^Zqb��k dhlhjufb�fuklhedgmebkv��qj_a\uqZcgh�ljm^gu��gh�ljm^ghklv�khklhbl�g_�\ g_^hklZld_�gZ[ex^_gbc��dZd�jZagZb[he__�qZklh�\klj_qZxsb_ky�b ohjhrh�agZdhfu_�n_ghf_gu�b aZ^Zxl�gZf�wlb�aZ]Z^db�^_eh� lZd`_�g_�\ mfhajbl_evguo�ihkljh_gbyo��d dhlhjuf�hgb�ih[m`^Zxl��mfhajbl_evgZyh[jZ[hldZ� \ wlhc� h[eZklb� fZeh� ijbgbfZ_lky� \h� \gbfZgb_�� J_qv� b^_l� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� hihgbfZgbb�� l�� _�� h lhf�� qlh[u� \\_klb� ijZ\bevgu_� Z[kljZdlgu_� ij_^klZ\e_gby�� ijbf_gb\dhlhju_�d kujhfm�fZl_jbZem�gZ[ex^_gbc��fh`gh�^h[blvky�ihjy^dZ�b ykghklb�KljZom y m`_�ihk\ylbe�h^gm�e_dpbx�ijhreh]h�pbdeZ��^\Z^pZlv�iylmx��Dhjhldh�ih\lhjx__ kh^_j`Zgb_�� Fu� ]h\hjbeb�� qlh� kljZo� ²� wlh� khklhygb_� Znn_dlZ�� l�� _�� h[t_^bg_gb_hij_^_e_gguo� hsms_gbc� jy^Z� m^h\hevkl\b_²g_m^h\hevkl\b_� k khhl\_lkl\mxsbfb� bfbgg_j\Zpbyfb� jZajy^db� >gZijy`_gby@� b bo� \hkijbylb_f�� Z lZd`_�� \_jhylgh�� b hljZ`_gb_hij_^_e_ggh]h� agZqbfh]h� kh[ulby�� aZi_qZle_\r_]hky� gZke_^kl\_ggh� b�� ke_^h\Zl_evgh�kjZ\gbfh]h� k bg^b\b^mZevgh� ijbh[j_l_gguf� bkl_jbq_kdbf� ijbiZ^dhf��< dZq_kl\_� kh[ulby�hklZ\b\r_]h�lZdhc�Znn_dlb\guc�ke_^��fu�\ayeb�ijhp_kk�jh`^_gby��ijb�dhlhjhf�k\hckl\_ggu_kljZom� \ha^_ckl\by� gZ� k_j^_qgmx� ^_yl_evghklv� b ^uoZgb_� [ueb� p_e_khh[jZagufb�� LZdbfh[jZahf�� kZfuc� i_j\uc� kljZo� [ue� lhdkbq_kdbf�� AZl_f� fu� bkoh^beb� ba� jZaebqby� f_`^mj_Zevguf� kljZohf� b g_\jhlbq_kdbf�� jZkkfZljb\Zy� i_j\uc� dZd� dZ`msmxky� gZf� ihgylghcj_Zdpbx�gZ�hiZkghklv��l��_��gZ�h`b^Z_fuc�ms_j[�ba\g_��\lhjhc�²�dZd�kh\_jr_ggh�[_kp_evgucb ihlhfm�aZ]Z^hqguc��Ijb�ZgZeba_�j_Zevgh]h�kljZoZ�fu�k\_eb�_]h�d khklhygbx�ih\ur_ggh]hk_gkhjgh]h�\gbfZgby�b fhlhjgh]h�gZijy`_gby��dhlhju_�fu�gZau\Z_f�]hlh\ghklvx�d kljZom�$QJVWEHUHLWVFKDIW�� Ba� g__� jZa\b\Z_lky� j_Zdpby� kljZoZ�� < g_c� \hafh`gu� ^\Z� bkoh^Z�� BebjZa\blb_�kljZoZ� ih\lhj_gb_�klZjh]h�ljZ\fZlbq_kdh]h�i_j_`b\Zgby�h]jZgbqb\Z_lky�kb]gZehf�lh]^Z� hklZevgZy� j_Zdpby� fh`_l� ijbkihkh[blvky� d gh\hc� hiZkghc� kblmZpbb�� \ujZablvky� \[_]kl\_�beb�aZsbl_��beb�`_�klZjh_�h^_j`bl�\_jo��\ky�j_Zdpby�bkq_jiZ_lky�jZa\blb_f�kljZoZ��blh]^Z�Znn_dlb\gh_�khklhygb_�iZjZebam_l�b klZg_l�^ey�gZklhys_]h�g_p_e_khh[jZaguf�AZl_f�fu� h[jZlbebkv� d g_\jhlbq_kdhfm� kljZom�b kdZaZeb��qlh�jZkkfZljb\Z_f� _]h� \ lj_ohlghr_gbyo�� <h�i_j\uo�� dZd� k\h[h^gmx �IUHL� IORWWLHUHQGH� g_hij_^_e_ggmx� [hyaeb\hklv�]hlh\mx� gZ� dZdh_�lh� \j_fy� ijb\yaZlvky� d ex[hc� ihy\b\r_cky� \hafh`ghklb�� dZd� lZdgZau\Z_fuc� kljZo�h`b^Zgby��gZijbf_j��ijb� lbibqghf�g_\jha_� kljZoZ��<h�\lhjuo�� dZd� kljZo�gZdj_idh�k\yaZgguc�k hij_^_e_ggufb�kh^_j`Zgbyfb�ij_^klZ\e_gbc�\ lZd�gZau\Z_fuo�nh[byo�\ dhlhjuo�fu��ijZ\^Z�� _s_�fh`_f�m\b^_lv� k\yav� k \g_rg_c�hiZkghklvx��gh� kljZo�i_j_^�g_c^he`gu�ijbagZlv�kbevgh�ij_m\_ebq_gguf��B gZdhg_p��\�lj_lvbo��kljZo�ijb�bkl_jbb�b ^jm]bonhjfZo� ly`_euo�g_\jhah\��dhlhjuc�beb� khijh\h`^Z_l�kbfilhfu��beb�gZklmiZ_l�g_aZ\bkbfh�dZd�ijbklmi�beb�[he__�^ebl_evgh_�khklhygb_��gh�\k_]^Z�[_a�\b^bfhc�h[mkeh\e_gghklb�\g_rg_chiZkghklvx�� AZl_f� fu� ihklZ\beb� i_j_^� kh[hc� ^\Z� \hijhkZ�� q_]h� [hylky� ijb� g_\jhlbq_kdhf

Page 302: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kljZo_"�B dZd�fh`gh�_]h�khhlg_klb�k j_Zevguf�kljZohf�i_j_^�\g_rgbfb�hiZkghklyfb"GZrb� bkke_^h\Zgby� hlgx^v� g_� hklZebkv� [_amki_rgufb��fu� k^_eZeb� g_dhlhju_� \Z`gu_hldjulby��< hlghr_gbb� h`b^Zgby� kljZoZ� debgbq_kdbc� hiul� gZmqbe� gZk� \b^_lv� ihklhyggmxk\yav� k [x^`_lhf� eb[b^h� \ k_dkmZevghc� `bagb�� KZfhc� h[uqghc� ijbqbghc� g_\jhaZ� kljZoZy\ey_lky� njmkljbjh\Zggh_� \ha[m`^_gb_�� Eb[b^hagh_� \ha[m`^_gb_� \uau\Z_lky�� gh� g_m^h\e_l\hjy_lky�� g_� bkihevam_lky�� \f_klh� wlh]h� g_� gZr_^r_]h� k_[_� ijbf_g_gby� eb[b^hihy\ey_lky� [hyaeb\hklv�� Y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� fh`gh� ^Z`_� kdZaZlv�� qlh� wlh� g_� m^h\e_l\hj_ggh_eb[b^h� ijyfh� ij_\jZsZ_lky� \ kljZo��Wlh�fg_gb_� gZreh� ih^l\_j`^_gb_� \ g_dhlhjuo� \_kvfZh[uqguo�nh[byo�fZe_gvdbo�^_l_c��Fgh]b_�ba�wlbo�nh[bc�^ey�gZk�\_kvfZ�aZ]Z^hqgu��^jm]b_�`_�dZd�� gZijbf_j�� kljZo� hklZlvky� h^ghfm� b kljZo� i_j_^� ^jm]bfb� ebpZfb�� \iheg_� h[tykgbfu�H^bghq_kl\h��Z lZd`_�qm`h_�ebph�ijh[m`^Zxl�lhkdm�ih�ohjhrh�agZdhfhc�fZl_jb��j_[_ghd�g_�\kbeZo�gb kh\eZ^Zlv�k wlbf�eb[b^haguf�\ha[m`^_gb_f��gb hklZ\blv�_]h�\ g_hij_^_e_g�ghklb��bhg�ij_\jZsZ_l�_]h�\ kljZo��LZdbf�h[jZahf��wlhl�^_lkdbc�kljZo�ke_^m_l�hlg_klb�g_�d j_ZevghfmkljZom��Z d�g_\jhlbq_kdhfm��>_lkdb_�nh[bb�b h`b^Zgb_�kljZoZ�ijb�g_\jha_�kljZoZ�^Zxl�gZf�^\Zijbf_jZ� h^gh]h� kihkh[Z� \hagbdgh\_gby� g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� kljZoZ� iml_f� ijyfh]h� ij_\jZs_gbyeb[b^h�� Kh� \lhjuf� f_oZgbafhf� fu� k_cqZk� ihagZdhfbfky�� hdZ`_lky�� qlh� hg� g_agZqbl_evghhlebqZ_lky�hl�i_j\h]h�Ijb�bkl_jbb�b ^jm]bo�g_\jhaZo�hl\_lkl\_gguf�aZ�kljZo�fu�kqblZ_f�ijhp_kk�\ul_kg_gby�Fu� iheZ]Z_f�� qlh� fh`gh� hibkZlv� _]h� [he__� ihegh�� q_f� ^h� kbo� ihj�� _keb� hl^_eblv� km^v[m\ul_kgy_fh]h�ij_^klZ\e_gby�hl� km^v[u� kh^_j`Zs_]hky� \ g_f� aZjy^Z� eb[b^h��Ij_^klZ\e_gb_�dhlhjh_�ih^\_j]Z_lky�\ul_kg_gbx��fh`_l�bkdZablvky�^h�g_magZ\Z_fhklb��gh�_]h�Znn_dlb\gucaZjy^�h[uqgh�ij_\jZsZ_lky�\ kljZo��ijbq_f�kh\_jr_ggh�[_ajZaebqgh��dZdh]h�lbiZ�wlhl�Znn_dl�Z]j_kkby�beb�ex[h\v��G_�bf__l�kms_kl\_ggh]h�jZaebqby�b lh��ih�dZdhc�ijbqbg_�aZjy^�eb[b^hhdZaZeky� g_bkihevah\Zgguf�� ba�aZ� bgnZglbevghc� keZ[hklb� Y�� dZd� ijb� ^_lkdb_� nh[byo�\ke_^kl\b_� khfZlbq_kdbo� ijhp_kkh\� \ k_dkmZevghc� `bagb�� dZd� ijb� g_\jha_� kljZoZ�� beb[eZ]h^Zjy�\ul_kg_gbx��dZd�ijb�bkl_jbb��BlZd��h[Z�f_oZgbafZ�\hagbdgh\_gby�g_\jhlbq_kdh]hkljZoZ��kh[kl\_ggh�]h\hjy��kh\iZ^Zxl�<h� \j_fy� wlbo�bkke_^h\Zgbc�fu� h[jZlbeb� \gbfZgb_�gZ� qj_a\uqZcgh� \Z`gh_� hlghr_gb_f_`^m�jZa\blb_f�kljZoZ�b h[jZah\Zgb_f�kbfilhfZ��Z bf_ggh�gZ�lh��qlh�h[Z�hgb�ij_^klZ\eyxl^jm]� ^jm]Z� b ijboh^yl� gZ� kf_gm� ^jm]� ^jm]m��M kljZ^Zxs_]h� Z]hjZnh[b_c�� gZijbf_j�� g_^m]gZqbgZ_lky� k ijbklmiZ� kljZoZ� gZ� mebp_�� B \hl� hg� kha^Z_l� kbfilhf� kljZoZ� i_j_^� mebp_c�dhlhjuc�fh`gh�gZa\Zlv�lZd`_�lhjfh`_gb_f��h]jZgbq_gb_f�nmgdpbb�Y��b ij_^mij_`^Z_l�l_fkZfuf� ijbklmi� kljZoZ�� H[jZlgh_� fh`gh� \b^_lv�� dh]^Z� ijhbkoh^bl� \f_rZl_evkl\h� \h[jZah\Zgb_� kbfilhfZ�� dZd�� gZijbf_j�� ijb� gZ\yaqb\uo� ^_ckl\byo�� ?keb� [hevghfm� ihf_rZlv\uihegblv� p_j_fhgbx� fulvy�� hg� \iZ^Z_l� \ ljm^gh� i_j_ghkbfh_� khklhygb_� kljZoZ�� ijhlb\dhlhjh]h�_]h��hq_\b^gh��aZsbsZe�_]h�kbfilhf��LZdbf�h[jZahf��ih�\b^bfhfm��jZa\blb_�kljZoZ²�[he__�jZgg__��Z h[jZah\Zgb_�kbfilhfZ�²�[he__�iha^g__��dZd�[m^lh� kbfilhfu�h[jZamxlky^ey� lh]h�� qlh[u� ba[_`Zlv� ihy\e_gby� khklhygby� kljZoZ�� B wlh� kh]eZkm_lky� lZd`_� k l_f�� qlhi_j\u_�g_\jhau�^_lkdh]h� \hajZklZ� y\eyxlky�nh[byfb�� khklhygbyfb��ih�dhlhjuf� ykgh� \b^gh�dZd� gZqZevgh_� jZa\blb_� kljZoZ� kf_gy_lky� [he__� iha^gbf� h[jZah\Zgb_f� kbfilhfZ�� kha^Z_lky\i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� wlb� hlghr_gby� hldju\Zxl� emqrbc� ^hklmi� d ihgbfZgbx� g_\jhlbq_kdh]h

Page 303: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kljZoZ��H^gh\j_f_ggh�gZf�m^Zehkv�lZd`_�hl\_lblv�gZ�\hijhk��q_]h�[hylky�ijb�g_\jhlbq_kdhfkljZo_��b lZdbf�h[jZahf�mklZgh\blv�k\yav�f_`^m�g_\jhlbq_kdbf�b j_Zevguf�kljZohf��Lh��q_]h[hylky�� y\ey_lky�� hq_\b^gh��� kh[kl\_gguf� eb[b^h�� Hlebqb_� hl� kblmZpbb� j_Zevgh]h� kljZoZaZdexqZ_lky�\ ^\mo�fhf_glZo��\ lhf��qlh�hiZkghklv�y\ey_lky�\gmlj_gg_c��Z g_�\g_rg_c��b \�lhf�qlh�hgZ�khagZl_evgh�g_�ijbagZ_lky�< nh[byo� fh`gh� hq_gv� ykgh� m\b^_lv�� dZd� wlZ� \gmlj_ggyy� hiZkghklv� i_j_\h^blky� \h\g_rgxx�� l�� _�� dZd� g_\jhlbq_kdbc� kljZo� ij_\jZsZ_lky� \ dZ`msbcky� j_Zevguc� kljZo��Qlh[umijhklblv�aZqZklmx�\_kvfZ�keh`gh_�iheh`_gb_�\_s_c��ij_^iheh`bf��qlh�Z]hjZnh[�ihklhygghkljZrblky� kh[eZagh\�� dhlhju_� ijh[m`^Zxlky� \ g_f� [eZ]h^Zjy� \klj_qZf� gZ� mebp_�� < k\h_cnh[bb�hg�ijhba\h^bl�kf_s_gb_�b gZqbgZ_l�[hylvky�\g_rg_c�kblmZpbb��?]h�\ub]jur�ijb�wlhfhq_\b^_g�� ihkdhevdm� hg� ^mfZ_l�� qlh� lZd� kfh`_l� emqr_� aZsblblvky�� Hl� \g_rg_c� hiZkghklbfh`gh�kiZklbkv�[_]kl\hf��ih�ev]ldZ�[_]kl\Z�hl�\gmlj_gg_c�hiZkghklb�²�^_eh�ljm^gh_�< aZdexq_gb_� d k\h_c� ijhrehc� e_dpbb� h kljZo_� y ^Z`_� \ukdZaZe� km`^_gb_�� qlh� wlbjZaebqgu_�j_amevlZlu�gZr_]h�bkke_^h\Zgby� \jh^_�[u�b g_�ijhlb\hj_qZl�^jm]�^jm]m��gh� \k_�lZdb� dZdbf�lh� h[jZahf� b g_� kh]eZkmxlky��KljZo�� [m^mqb� Znn_dlb\guf� khklhygb_f�� y\ey_lky\hkijhba\_^_gb_f� klZjh]h� ]jhays_]h� hiZkghklvx� kh[ulby�� kljZo� kem`bl� kZfhkhojZg_gbx� by\ey_lky� kb]gZehf�gh\hc� hiZkghklb�� hg� \hagbdZ_l� ba� eb[b^h�� dZdbf�lh� h[jZahf� hklZ\r_]hkyg_bkihevah\Zgguf�� b \� ijhp_kk_� \ul_kg_gby� kf_gy_lky� h[jZah\Zgb_f� kbfilhfZ�� keh\gh� hgk\yaZg� ikbobq_kdb�²� qm\kl\m_lky�� qlh� a^_kv� q_]h�lh� g_� o\ZlZ_l�� qlh� kh_^bgy_l�njZ]f_glu� \^_eh_�M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��Lh�jZa^_e_gb_�ikbobq_kdhc�ebqghklb�gZ�K\_jo�Y��Y b�Hgh��hdhlhjhf�y ]h\hjbe�\Zf�gZ�ij_^u^ms_c�e_dpbb��\ugm`^Z_l�gZk�ijbgylv�gh\mx�hjb_glZpbx�b \ijh[e_f_� kljZoZ��IheZ]Zy�� qlh� Y ²� _^bgkl\_ggh_� f_klh� >khkj_^hlhq_gby@� kljZoZ�� lhevdh� Yfh`_l� ijhba\h^blv� b qm\kl\h\Zlv� kljZo�� fu� aZgyeb� gh\mx� ijhqgmx� ihabpbx�� k dhlhjhcg_dhlhju_�hlghr_gby�ij_^klZxl�\ ^jm]hf�k\_l_��B ^_ckl\bl_evgh��fu�g_�agZ_f��dZdhc�kfuke[ueh� [u� ]h\hjblv� h ©kljZo_� Hghª� beb� ijbibku\Zlv� K\_jo�Y kihkh[ghklv� d [hyaeb\hklb�GZijhlb\��fu�ijb\_lkl\h\Zeb�dZd�`_eZl_evgh_�lh�khhl\_lkl\b_��qlh�ljb�hkgh\guo�\b^Z�kljZoZ�j_Zevguc� kljZo�� g_\jhlbq_kdbc�b kljZo� kh\_klb�²� [_a� \kydhc�gZly`db� kh]eZkmxlky� k lj_fyaZ\bkbfhklyfb�Y²hl�\g_rg_]h�fbjZ��hl�Hgh�b hl�K\_jo�Y��;eZ]h^Zjy�wlhc�gh\hc�lhqd_�aj_gbygZ� i_j_^gbc� ieZg� \uklmibeZ� nmgdpby� kljZoZ� dZd� kb]gZeZ�� mdZau\Zxs_]h� gZ� kblmZpbxhiZkghklb��dhlhjZy�gZf�b jZgvr_�g_�[ueZ�qm`^Z��\hijhk�h lhf��ba�dZdh]h�fZl_jbZeZ�kha^Z_lkykljZo�� ihl_jye� ^ey� gZk� bgl_j_k�� Z hlghr_gby� f_`^m� j_Zevguf� b g_\jhlbq_kdbf� kljZohfg_h`b^Zgguf�h[jZahf�ijhykgbebkv�b mijhklbebkv��Klhbl�� \ijhq_f�� aZf_lblv��qlh� k_cqZk�fuemqr_� ihgbfZ_f� kemqZb� \hagbdgh\_gby� kljZoZ�� dZaZ\rb_ky� keh`gufb�� q_f� l_�� dhlhju_kqblZebkv�ijhklufb�G_^Z\gh� gZf� ^h\_ehkv� bkke_^h\Zlv�� dZd� \hagbdZ_l� kljZo� ijb� hij_^_e_gguo� nh[byo�dhlhju_� fu� ijbqbkey_f� d bkl_jbb� kljZoZ�� Fu� \u[jZeb� kemqZb�� \ dhlhjuo� j_qv� b^_l� hlbibqghf� \ul_kg_gbb� `_eZgbc� ba� W^bih\Z� dhfie_dkZ�� Fu� h`b^Zeb�� qlh� eb[b^hagZyijb\yaZgghklv� d fZl_jb� dZd� d h[t_dlm� \ke_^kl\b_� \ul_kg_gby� ij_\jZsZ_lky� \ kljZo� b\uklmiZ_l� hlgug_� \ kbfilhfZlbq_kdhf� \ujZ`_gbb� \ k\yab� k aZf_ghc� hlphf�� Y g_� fh]mjZkkdZaZlv� \Zf� h[� hl^_evguo� wlZiZo� lZdh]h� bkke_^h\Zgby�� ^hklZlhqgh� kdZaZlv�� qlh� bo

Page 304: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hr_ehfeyxsbc� j_amevlZl� hdZaZeky� iheghc� ijhlb\hiheh`ghklvx� gZrbf� h`b^Zgbyf�� G_\ul_kg_gb_�kha^Z_l�kljZo��Z kljZo�ihy\ey_lky�jZgvr_��kljZo�ijhba\h^bl�\ul_kg_gb_��Gh�qlh�wlhfh`_l� [ulv� aZ� kljZo"�Lhevdh� kljZo�i_j_^� m]jh`Zxs_c� \g_rg_c� hiZkghklvx�� l�� _�� j_ZevguckljZo�� <_jgh�� qlh� fZevqbd� bkiulu\Z_l� kljZo� i_j_^� dZdbf�lh� ijblyaZgb_f� k\h_]h� eb[b^h�� \^Zgghf� kemqZ_� i_j_^� ex[h\vx� d fZl_jb�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� wlh� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� kemqZcg_\jhlbq_kdh]h�kljZoZ��Gh�wlZ�\ex[e_gghklv�dZ`_lky�_fm�\gmlj_gg_c�hiZkghklvx��dhlhjhc�hg^he`_g�ba[_`Zlv�iml_f�hldZaZ�hl�wlh]h�h[t_dlZ�ihlhfm��qlh�hgZ�\uau\Z_l�kblmZpbx�\g_rg_chiZkghklb��B \h�\k_o�kemqZyo��bkke_^m_fuo�gZfb��fu�ihemqZ_f�lhl�`_�j_amevlZl��IjbagZ_fky`_��qlh�fu�g_�[ueb�]hlh\u�d lhfm��qlh�\gmlj_ggyy�hiZkghklv�\e_q_gby�hdZ`_lky�mkeh\b_f�bih^]hlh\dhc�\g_rg_c��j_Zevghc�kblmZpbb�hiZkghklb�Gh�fu�_s_�gbq_]h�g_�kdZaZeb�h lhf��qlh�lZdh_�j_ZevgZy�hiZkghklv��dhlhjhc�[hblky�j_[_ghd\ke_^kl\b_� \ex[e_gghklb� \ fZlv�� Wlh� gZdZaZgb_� dZkljZpb_c�� ihl_j_c� k\h_]h� qe_gZ�� <u�dhg_qgh�� aZf_lbl_�� qlh� wlh� g_� y\ey_lky� gbdZdhc� j_Zevghc� hiZkghklvx��GZrbo� fZevqbdh\� g_dZkljbjmxl�aZ�lh��qlh�hgb�\ i_jbh^�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ�\ex[eyxlky�\ fZlv��Gh�hl�wlh]h�g_�lZd�lh�ijhklh�hlfZogmlvky��Ij_`^_�\k_]h�^_eh�g_�\ lhf��^_ckl\bl_evgh�eb�ijhba\h^blky�dZkljZpby�j_rZxsbf�y\ey_lky�lh��qlh�hiZkghklv�m]jh`Z_l�ba\g_�b qlh�j_[_ghd�\ g__�\_jbl��B ih\h^�^eywlh]h� m g_]h� _klv�� ihkdhevdm� _fm� ^hklZlhqgh� qZklh� m]jh`Zxl� hlj_aZgb_f� qe_gZ� \ _]hnZeebq_kdbc� i_jbh^�� \h� \j_fy� _]h� jZgg_]h� hgZgbafZ�� b gZf_db� gZ� wlh� gZdZaZgb_� ihklhygghfh]eb� ihemqZlv� m g_]h� nbeh]_g_lbq_kdh_� mkbe_gb_�� Fu� ij_^iheZ]Z_f�� qlh� \ ^j_\ghklb� \q_eh\_q_kdhc� k_fv_� dZkljZpby� ih^jZklZxsbo� fZevqbdh\� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� hkms_kl\eyeZkvj_\gb\uf�b `_klhdbf�hlphf��b h[j_aZgb_��dhlhjh_�m ijbfblb\guo�gZjh^h\�lZd�qZklh�y\eyehkvkhklZ\ghc� qZklvx� jblmZeZ� \klmie_gby� \ iheh\mx� aj_ehklv�� fh`gh� kqblZlv� y\guf� __i_j_`bldhf��Fu�agZ_f��gZkdhevdh�^Ze_db�fu�k_cqZk�hl�h[s_ijbgylh]h�\a]ey^Z��gh�fu�^he`gul\_j^h� ijb^_j`b\Zlvky� lh]h�� qlh� kljZo� dZkljZpbb� y\ey_lky� h^gbf� ba� gZb[he__� qZklh\klj_qZxsboky� b gZb[he__� kbevguo� ^\b]Zl_e_c� \ul_kg_gby� b l_f� kZfuf� b h[jZah\Zgbyg_\jhah\��:gZebau� kemqZ_\�� dh]^Z� g_� dZkljZpby�� Z h[j_aZgb_� m fZevqbdh\� hkms_kl\eyehkv� \dZq_kl\_� l_jZibb� beb� gZdZaZgby� aZ� hgZgbaf�� qlh� g_� lZd� m`� j_^dh� ijhbkoh^beh� \ Zg]eh�Zf_jbdZgkdhf�h[s_kl\_��ijb^Z_l�gZr_fm� m[_`^_gbx�hdhgqZl_evgmx�m\_j_gghklv��<hagbdZ_lkbevguc�kh[eZag�ih^hclb�\ wlhf�f_kl_�[eb`_�d dhfie_dkm�dZkljZpbb��gh�fu�g_�ohlbf�moh^blvhl�gZr_c�l_fu��KljZo�dZkljZpbb��dhg_qgh��g_�_^bgkl\_gguc�fhlb\�\ul_kg_gby��\_^v�m `_gsbghg� m`_�g_�bf__l�f_klZ�� ohly� m gbo�fh`_l�[ulv� dhfie_dk� dZkljZpbb��gh�g_� kljZo� dZkljZpbb�<f_klh�g_]h�m ^jm]h]h�iheZ�ihy\ey_lky�kljZo�ihl_jylv�ex[h\v�²�\b^bfh_�ijh^he`_gb_�kljZoZ]jm^gh]h�feZ^_gpZ��_keb�hg�g_�gZoh^bl�fZlv��<u�ihgbfZ_l_��dZdZy�j_ZevgZy�kblmZpby�hiZkghklbh[gZjm`b\Z_lky� [eZ]h^Zjy� wlhfm� kljZom�� ?keb� fZlv� hlkmlkl\m_l� beb� ebrZ_l� j_[_gdZ� k\h_cex[\b�� hg� i_j_klZ_l� [ulv� m\_j_g� \ m^h\e_l\hj_gbb� k\hbo� ihlj_[ghkl_c� b�� \hafh`gh�bkiulu\Z_l� kZfu_� g_ijbylgu_� qm\kl\Z� gZijy`_gghklb�� G_� hldZau\Zcl_kv� hl� b^_b�� qlh� wlbmkeh\by�kljZoZ�ih�kmlb�ih\lhjyxl�kblmZpbx�i_j\hgZqZevgh]h�kljZoZ�jh`^_gby��dhlhjh_�\_^vlh`_�hagZqZ_l�hl^_e_gb_�hl�fZl_jb��<_^v�_keb�\u�ihke_^m_l_�aZ�oh^hf�fukeb�N_j_gpb��������\u�kfh`_l_�ijbqbkeblv�kljZo�dZkljZpbb�d wlhfm�jy^m��ihlhfm�qlh�mljZlZ�fm`kdh]h�qe_gZ�bf__lke_^kl\b_f�g_\hafh`ghklv�\hkkh_^bg_gby�\ iheh\hf�Zdl_�k fZl_jvx�beb�k __�aZf_ghc��AZf_qmihimlgh�� qlh� lZd� qZklh� \klj_qZxsZyky� nZglZaby� \ha\jZs_gby� \ fZl_jbgkdh_� ehgh� y\ey_lkyaZf_s_gb_f� wlh]h� `_eZgby� dhblmkZ�� Y fh]� [u� khh[sblv� _s_� fgh]h� bgl_j_kguo� \_s_c� b

Page 305: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

m^b\bl_evguo� k\ya_c�� gh� g_� fh]m� \uoh^blv� aZ� jZfdb� \\_^_gby� \ ikbohZgZeba�� ohqm� lhevdhh[jZlblv� \Zr_� \gbfZgb_� gZ� lh�� dZd� ikboheh]bq_kdb_� bkke_^h\Zgby� kfudZxlky� k[bheh]bq_kdbfb�nZdlZfb�AZkem]hc� Hllh� JZgdZ�� dhlhjhfm� ikbohZgZeba� h[yaZg� fgh]bfb� ij_djZkgufb� jZ[hlZfb�y\ey_lky�b lh��qlh�hg�gZklhcqb\h�ih^q_jdb\Ze�agZq_gb_�ZdlZ�jh`^_gby�b hl^_e_gby�hl�fZl_jb��������IjZ\^Z��fu�\k_�khqeb�g_\hafh`guf�ijbgylv�l_�djZcgb_�\u\h^u��dhlhju_�hg�k^_eZe�bawlh]h�^ey�l_hjbb�g_\jhah\�b ^Z`_�^ey�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�l_jZibb��H^gZdh�y^jh�_]h�l_hjbb�²�lh�qlh�i_j_`b\Zgb_�kljZoZ�jh`^_gby�y\ey_lky�ijhh[jZahf�\k_o�ihke_^mxsbo�kblmZpbc�hiZkghklb²� [ueh� hldjulh� _s_� ^h� g_]h��HklZgZ\eb\Zykv� gZ� gbo�� fu� fh`_f� kdZaZlv�� qlh�� kh[kl\_ggh�dZ`^uc� \hajZkl� h[eZ^Z_l� hij_^_e_gguf� mkeh\b_f� >\hagbdgh\_gby@� kljZoZ�� l�� _�� kblmZpb_chiZkghklb�� Z^_d\Zlghc� _fm�� HiZkghklv� ikbobq_kdhc� [_kihfhsghklb� khhl\_lkl\m_l� klZ^bbjZgg_c� g_aj_ehklb� Y�� hiZkghklv� ihl_jb� h[t_dlZ� �ex[\b�� ²� g_kZfhklhyl_evghklb� i_j\uo^_lkdbo�e_l��hiZkghklv�dZkljZpbb�²�nZeebq_kdhc�nZa_�b��gZdhg_p��aZgbfZxsbc�hkh[h_�f_klhkljZo� i_j_^� K\_jo�Y ²� eZl_glghfm� i_jbh^m�� < ijhp_kk_� jZa\blby� klZju_� mkeh\by� kljZoZ^he`gu�hliZ^Zlv��lZd�dZd�khhl\_lkl\mxsb_�bf�kblmZpbb�hiZkghklb�h[_kp_gb\Zxlky�[eZ]h^Zjymdj_ie_gbx� Y�� Gh� wlh� ijhbkoh^bl� hq_gv� g_kh\_jr_gguf� h[jZahf��Fgh]b_� ex^b� g_� fh]mlij_h^he_lv�kljZoZ�i_j_^�ihl_j_c�ex[\b��hgb�gbdh]^Z�g_�klZgh\ylky�g_aZ\bkbfufb�hl�ex[\b^jm]bo�� ijh^he`Zy� \ wlhf� hlghr_gbb� k\h_� bgnZglbevgh_� ih\_^_gb_�� KljZo� i_j_^� K\_jo�Yh[uqgh� g_� ^he`_g� bkq_aZlv�� lZd� dZd� hg� \ dZq_kl\_� kljZoZ� kh\_klb� g_h[oh^bf� \ khpbZevguohlghr_gbyo��b hl^_evguc�q_eh\_d�lhevdh�\ kZfuo�j_^dbo�kemqZyo�fh`_l�klZlv�g_aZ\bkbfuf�hlq_eh\_q_kdh]h�h[s_kl\Z��G_dhlhju_�klZju_�kblmZpbb�hiZkghklb�fh]ml�i_j_clb�b \�iha^g_crbci_jbh^�� fh^bnbpbjmy� \ khhl\_lkl\bb� kh� \j_f_g_f� k\hb� mkeh\by� kljZoZ�� LZd�� gZijbf_j�hiZkghklv�dZkljZpbb�khojZgy_lky�ih^�fZkdhc�kbnbehnh[bb��;m^mqb�\ajhkeuf��q_eh\_d� agZ_l�qlh� dZkljZpby� [hevr_� g_� ijbf_gy_lky� \ dZq_kl\_� gZdZaZgby� aZ� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� k_dkmZevguo\e_q_gbc��gh� aZlh� hg� magZe�� qlh� lZdZy� k_dkmZevgZy� k\h[h^Z� ]jhabl� ly`_eufb� aZ[he_\Zgbyfb�G_l�gbdZdh]h�khfg_gby�\ lhf��qlh�ebpZ��dhlhjuo�fu�gZau\Z_f�g_\jhlbdZfb��hklZxlky�\ k\h_fhlghr_gbb�d hiZkghklb�bgnZglbevgufb��g_�ij_h^he_\�klZju_�mkeh\by�kljZoZ��Ijbf_f�wlh�aZnZdl�^ey�oZjZdl_jbklbdb�g_\jhlbdh\��gh�ihq_fm�wlh�lZd��kjZam�hl\_lblv�g_\hafh`gh�GZ^_xkv�� qlh� \u� _s_� g_� ihl_jyeb� hjb_glZpbx� b ihfgbl_�� qlh� fu� hklZgh\bebkv� gZbkke_^h\Zgbb� hlghr_gbc� f_`^m� kljZohf� b \ul_kg_gb_f�� Ijb� wlhf� fu� magZeb� ^\_� gh\u_\_sb�²�\h�i_j\uo��qlh�kljZo�hkms_kl\ey_l�\ul_kg_gb_��Z g_�gZh[hjhl��dZd�fu�iheZ]Zeb��b��\h�\lhjuo�� qlh� kblmZpby� \e_q_gbc�� dhlhjZy� \uau\Z_l� kljZo�� \hkoh^bl� \ hkgh\ghf� d \g_rg_ckblmZpbb� hiZkghklb�� Ke_^mxsbc� \hijhk� lZdh\�� dZd� fu� ij_^klZ\ey_f� k_[_� l_i_jv� ijhp_kk\ul_kg_gby� ih^� \ebygb_f� kljZoZ"� Y ^mfZx� lZd�� Y aZf_qZ_l�� qlh� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_ihy\eyxs_]hky� lj_[h\Zgby� \e_q_gby� \uau\Z_l� h^gm� ba� ohjhrh� aZihfgb\rboky� kblmZpbchiZkghklb�� WlZ� aZo\Zq_gghklv� \e_q_gb_f� ^he`gZ� [ulv� dZdbf�lh� h[jZahf� ih^Z\e_gZ�ij_h^he_gZ��ebr_gZ�kbeu��Fu�agZ_f��qlh�wlZ�aZ^ZqZ�m^Z_lky�Y��_keb�hgh�kbevgh�b \dexqbeh�\k\hx� hj]ZgbaZpbx� khhl\_lkl\mxs__� \e_q_gb_�� : \ul_kg_gb_� gZklmiZ_l� \ lhf� kemqZ_�� _keb\e_q_gb_�_s_�hlghkblky�d Hgh�b Y�qm\kl\m_l�k_[y�keZ[uf��Lh]^Z�Y ihfh]Z_l�k_[_� l_ogbdhc�dhlhjZy�ih� kmlb�^_eZ�b^_glbqgZ� l_ogbd_�h[uqgh]h�fure_gby��Fure_gb_� y\ey_lky�ijh[guf^_ckl\b_f� k bkihevah\Zgb_f� fZeuo� dhebq_kl\� wg_j]bb�� ih^h[gh� i_j_^\b`_gbx� fZe_gvdbonb]mj�gZ�dZjl_��ij_`^_�q_f�ihedh\h^_p�ijb\_^_l�\ ^\b`_gb_�\hckdZ����Y ij_^\hkobsZ_l��lZdbf

Page 306: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

h[jZahf�� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� hiZkgh]h� \e_q_gby� b jZaj_rZ_l� _fm� \hkijhba\_klb� hsms_gbyg_m^h\hevkl\by� d gZqZem� \gmrZxs_c� kljZo� kblmZpbb� hiZkghklb�� L_f� kZfuf� \dexqZ_lkyZ\lhfZlbaf� ijbgpbiZ� m^h\hevkl\by²g_m^h\hevkl\by�� dhlhjuc� b ijhba\h^bl� \ul_kg_gb_hiZkgh]h�\e_q_gby�Klhi�� kdZ`_l_� \u� fg_�� lZd� ^_eh� g_� ihc^_l�� <u� ijZ\u�� y ^he`_g� _s_� dh_�qlh� k^_eZlv�ij_`^_�q_f�wlh�ihdZ`_lky�\Zf�ijb_fe_fuf��KgZqZeZ�ijbagZxkv�\Zf��qlh�y iulZeky�i_j_\_klbgZ� yaud� gZr_]h� h[uqgh]h� fure_gby� lh�� qlh� \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� g_� y\ey_lky�� [_amkeh\gh�khagZl_evguf� beb� ij_^khagZl_evguf� ijhp_kkhf� f_`^m� dhebq_kl\Zfb� wg_j]bb� \ km[kljZl_�dhlhjuc�g_evay�k_[_�ij_^klZ\blv��Gh�wlh�g_�hq_gv�kbevguc�Zj]mf_gl��Z \_^v�bgZq_�g_\hafh`ghihklmiblv��<Z`g__�lh��qlh�fu�ykgh�jZaebqZ_f��qlh�ijb�\ul_kg_gbb�ijhbkoh^bl�\ Y�b qlh�\ Hgh�Qlh� ^_eZ_l� Y�� fu� lhevdh� qlh� kdZaZeb�� hgh� bkihevam_l� ijh[gh_� aZiheg_gb_� >wg_j]b_c@� bijh[m`^Z_l� Z\lhfZlbaf� ^_ckl\by� ijbgpbiZ� m^h\hevkl\by²g_m^h\hevkl\by� kb]gZehf� kljZoZ�AZl_f�\hafh`gh�g_kdhevdh�beb�fgh`_kl\h�j_Zdpbc�k f_gyxsbfbky�dhebq_kl\Zfb�wg_j]bb��Bebiheghklvx� jZah\v_lky�ijbklmi� kljZoZ� b Y� kh\k_f� hlklmiblky� hl� g_ijbebqgh]h� \ha[m`^_gby�beb� \f_klh� ijh[gh]h� aZiheg_gby� hgh� ijhlb\hihklZ\bl� _fm� h[jZlguc� ihlhd� >wg_j]bb@�*HJHQEHVHW]XQJ�� dhlhjuc� kh_^bgblky� k wg_j]b_c� \ul_kg_ggh]h� ih[m`^_gby� \ h[jZah\ZgbbkbfilhfZ� beb� [m^_l� ijbgyl� \ Y� dZd� j_Zdlb\gh_� h[jZah\Zgb_�� dZd� mkbe_gb_� hij_^_e_gguoij_^jZkiheh`_gbc�� dZd� ihklhyggh_� baf_g_gb_�� Q_f� [hevr_� jZa\blb_� kljZoZ� fh`_lh]jZgbqblvky�lhevdh�kb]gZehf��l_f�[hevr_�Y bkihevam_l�aZsblgu_�j_Zdpbb��dhlhju_�koh^gu�kikbobq_kdbf�k\yau\Zgb_f�\ul_kg_ggh]h��l_f�[hevr_�wlhl�ijhp_kk�ijb[eb`Z_lky�d ghjfZevghci_j_jZ[hld_��_kl_kl\_ggh��g_�^hklb]Zy�__��F_`^m�ijhqbf��gZ�wlhf�klhbl�g_fgh]h�hklZgh\blvky�<u�� dhg_qgh�� kZfb� m`_� ij_^iheh`beb�� qlh� lh� ljm^gh� hij_^_ebfh_�� dhlhjh_� gZau\ZxloZjZdl_jhf� ke_^m_l�hlg_klb�d Y��Fu�m`_�meh\beb�dh_�qlh�ba�lh]h��qlh�kha^Z_l�wlhl�oZjZdl_j�Wlh� ij_`^_� \k_]h� \dexq_gb_� \ k_[y� \ jZgg_f� \hajZkl_� jh^bl_evkdhc� bgklZgpbb� \ dZq_kl\_K\_jo�Y�²� ih`Zemc�� kZfuc� \Z`guc�� j_rZxsbc� fhf_gl�� aZl_f� b^_glbnbdZpbb� k h[hbfbjh^bl_eyfb� b ^jm]bfb� \ebyl_evgufb� ebpZfb� \ [he_x� iha^g__� \j_fy� b lZdb_� `_b^_glbnbdZpbb� dZd� hljZ`_gb_� hlghr_gbc� d hklZ\e_gguf� h[t_dlZf�� L_i_jv� ijb[Z\bf� dnhjfbjh\Zgbx� oZjZdl_jZ� \ dZq_kl\_� \k_]^Z� bf_xsboky� ^h[Z\hd� j_Zdlb\gu_� h[jZah\Zgby�dhlhju_�Y ihemqZ_l�kgZqZeZ�\ k\hbo�\ul_kg_gbyo��iha^g__�`_��ijb�hldehg_gbb�g_`_eZl_evguoih[m`^_gbc��ijb�ihfhsb�[he__�ghjfZevguo�kj_^kl\�: l_i_jv� \_jg_fky� gZaZ^� b h[jZlbfky� d Hgh�� Qlh� ijhbkoh^bl� ijb� \ul_kg_gbb� kih[_`^_gguf� \e_q_gb_f��^h]Z^Zlvky�g_� lZd�lh� e_]dh��<_^v�gZk�bgl_j_km_l� ]eZ\guf� h[jZahf�qlh�ijhbkoh^bl�k wg_j]b_c��k eb[b^haguf�aZjy^hf�wlh]h�\ha[m`^_gby��dZd�hg�bkihevam_lky��<uihfgbl_�� jZgvr_� fu� ij_^iheZ]Zeb�� qlh� bf_ggh� hg� ij_\jZsZ_lky� [eZ]h^Zjy� \ul_kg_gbx� \kljZo�� L_i_jv� fu� lZd� ml\_j`^Zlv� g_� fh`_f�� gZr� kdjhfguc� hl\_l� [m^_l� kdhj__� lZdbf�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� _]h� km^v[Z�g_�\k_]^Z�h^bgZdh\Z��<_jhylgh��bf__lky�bglbfgh_� khhl\_lkl\b_�f_`^mijhp_kkhf��ijhbkoh^b\rbf�\ Y�b \�Hgh�ijb�\ul_kg_gbb�\e_q_gby��dhlhjh_�klZeh�gZf�ba\_klgh�K l_o� ihj� dZd� fu� iha\hebeb� k_[_� \dexqblv� \ \ul_kg_gb_� bf_ggh� ijbgpbi� m^h\hevkl\by²g_m^h\hevkl\by��dhlhjuc�ijh[m`^Z_lky�kb]gZehf�kljZoZ��m gZk�ihy\bebkv�hkgh\Zgby�baf_gblvgZrb�ij_^iheh`_gby��Wlhl�ijbgpbi�mijZ\ey_l�ijhp_kkZfb�\ Hgh�kh\_jr_ggh�g_h]jZgbq_ggh�Fu� kqblZ_f� _]h� kihkh[guf� ijhba\h^blv� \_kvfZ� ]em[hdb_� baf_g_gby� \ khhl\_lkl\mxs_f\e_q_gbb��Fu�ih^]hlh\e_gu� lZd`_� d lhfm��qlh� mki_ob� \ul_kg_gby�[m^ml� hq_gv� jZaebqgufb�

Page 307: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[he__� beb� f_g__� ^Ze_dh� b^msbfb�� < g_dhlhjuo� kemqZyo� \ul_kg_ggh_� \e_q_gb_� fh`_lkhojZgblv�k\hb�eb[b^haguc�aZjy^��ijh^he`Zlv�kms_kl\h\Zlv�[_a�baf_g_gby�\ Hgh��ohly�b ih^ihklhygguf�^Z\e_gb_f�Y��< ^jm]bo� kemqZyo� \_jhylgh��ijhbkoh^bl� _]h�ihegh_�jZajmr_gb_�� Z_]h�eb[b^h�hdhgqZl_evgh�gZijZ\ey_lky�ih�^jm]bf�dZgZeZf��Y iheZ]Ze��qlh�lZd�ijhbkoh^bl�ijbghjfZevghf� jZaj_r_gbb� W^bih\Z� dhfie_dkZ�� dhlhjuc�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� �\ wlhf�`_eZl_evghfkemqZ_ g_ ijhklh�\ul_kgy_lky��Z jZajmrZ_lky�\ Hgh��>Ze__�debgbq_kdbc�hiul�ihdZaZe�gZf��qlh\h�fgh]bo�kemqZyo�\f_klh�ijb\uqgh]h�mki_rgh]h�\ul_kg_gby�ijhbkoh^bl�ihgb`_gb_�eb[b^h�_]h� j_]j_kkby� gZ� [he__� jZggxx� klmi_gv� hj]ZgbaZpbb�� Wlh� fh`_l� ijhbkoh^blv�� _kl_kl\_ggh�lhevdh�\ Hgh��b _keb�wlh�ijhbkoh^bl��lh�ih^�\ebygb_f�lh]h�`_�dhgnebdlZ��dhlhjuc�gZqbgZ_lky[eZ]h^Zjy� kb]gZem� kljZoZ�� KZfuc� yjdbc� ijbf_j� lZdh]h� jh^Z� ij_^klZ\ey_l� kh[hc� g_\jhagZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc��ijb�dhlhjhf�j_]j_kkby�eb[b^h�b \ul_kg_gb_�\aZbfh^_ckl\mxl�M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��Y [hxkv��qlh�wlb�jZkkm`^_gby�dZ`mlky�\Zf�fZehihgylgufb��b\u�^h]Z^u\Z_l_kv��qlh�baeh`_gu�hgb�g_�bkq_jiu\Zxsbf�h[jZahf��Kh`Ze_x��qlh�\ua\Ze�\Zr_g_^h\hevkl\h��Gh�y g_�fh]m�ihklZ\blv�i_j_^�kh[hc�bghc�p_eb��djhf_�lhc��qlh[u�\u�ihemqbebij_^klZ\e_gb_�h[�hkh[_gghklyo�gZrbo�j_amevlZlh\�b ljm^ghklyo�bo�ihemq_gby��Q_f�]em[`_�fuijhgbdg_f� \ bamq_gb_� ikbobq_kdbo� ijhp_kkh\�� l_f� [hevr_� fu� magZ_f� h [h]Zlkl\_� bokh^_j`Zgby� b h[� bo� aZimlZgghklb�� G_dhlhju_� ijhklu_� nhjfmeu�� dZaZ\rb_ky� gZf� ihgZqZemijb_fe_fufb��iha^g__�hdZaZebkv�g_^hklZlhqgufb��Fu�g_�mklZg_f�f_gylv�b bkijZ\eylv�bo��<e_dpbb�h l_hjbb�kgh\b^_gbc�y \\_e�\Zk�\ h[eZklv��]^_�\ l_q_gb_�iylgZ^pZlb�e_l�g_�ijhbahrehihqlb�gbq_]h�gh\h]h�� a^_kv�`_�� dh]^Z�fu� ]h\hjbf� h kljZo_�� \u� \b^bl_�� qlh� \k_� gZoh^blky� \^\b`_gbb�b baf_g_gbb��Wlb�gh\u_�^Zggu_�_s_�g_^hklZlhqgh�hkgh\Zl_evgh�ijhjZ[hlZgu��fh`_l[ulv��ihwlhfm�bo�baeh`_gb_� \uau\Z_l� aZljm^g_gby��Ihl_jibl_��fu� kdhjh� hklZ\bf� ijh[e_fmkljZoZ��y g_�ml\_j`^Zx��ijZ\^Z��qlh�lh]^Z�__ j_r_gb_�gZk�m^h\e_l\hjbl��GZ^_xkv��qlh�ohly�[ug_fgh]h�fu�\k_�`_�ijh^\bgmebkv�\i_j_^��: ih�oh^m�^_eZ�fu�jZah[jZeb�\k_�\hafh`gu_�gh\u_\a]ey^u��LZd��ih^�\ebygb_f�bamq_gby�kljZoZ�fu�fh`_f�l_i_jv�d gZr_fm�hibkZgbx�Y ^h[Z\blvgh\mx� q_jlm��Fu� ]h\hjbeb�� qlh�Y keZ[h� ih� kjZ\g_gbx� k Hgh�� y\ey_lky� _]h� \_jguf� kem]hc�klZjZ_lky� ijh\_klb� \ `bagv� _]h� ijbdZaZgby�� \uihegblv� _]h� lj_[h\Zgby��Fu� g_� kh[bjZ_fky[jZlv�wlh�ml\_j`^_gb_�gZaZ^��Gh��k ^jm]hc�klhjhgu��wlh�Y ²�\k_�lZdb�emqr_�hj]Zgbah\ZggZy�hjb_glbjh\ZggZy� gZ� j_Zevghklv� qZklv� Hgh�� Fu� g_� ^he`gu� q_j_kqmj� ij_m\_ebqb\Zlvh[hkh[e_gghklv�h[hbo��Z lZd`_�m^b\eylvky��_keb�Y��kh�k\h_c�klhjhgu��m^Z_lky�hdZaZlv�\ebygb_gZ� ijhp_kku� \ Hgh�� Y iheZ]Zx�� qlh� Y hkms_kl\ey_l� wlh� \ebygb_�� aZklZ\eyy� ^_ckl\h\Zlvihkj_^kl\hf� kb]gZeZ� kljZoZ� ihqlb� \k_fh]msbc� ijbgpbi� m^h\hevkl\by�g_m^h\hevkl\by�<ijhq_f��g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�ihke_�wlh]h�hgh�hiylv�h[gZjm`b\Z_l�k\hx�keZ[hklv��hldZau\Zykv�ba�aZ� ZdlZ� \ul_kg_gby� hl� qZklb� k\h_c� hj]ZgbaZpbb� b ^himkdZy�� qlh[u� \ul_kg_ggh_� \e_q_gb_^ebl_evgh_�\j_fy�hklZ\Zehkv�[_a�_]h�\ebygby�: l_i_jv�_s_�lhevdh�h^gh�aZf_qZgb_�ih�ijh[e_f_�kljZoZ��< gZrbo�jmdZo�g_\jhlbq_kdbckljZo� ij_\jZlbeky� \ j_Zevguc� kljZo�� \ kljZo� i_j_^� hij_^_e_ggufb� \g_rgbfb� kblmZpbyfbhiZkghklb��Gh�gZ�wlhf�g_evay�hklZgZ\eb\Zlvky��fu�^he`gu�k^_eZlv�ke_^mxsbc�rZ]��h^gZdh�wlh[m^_l�rZ]�gZaZ^��Kijhkbf�k_[y��qlh��kh[kl\_ggh�]h\hjy��y\ey_lky�hiZkguf��q_]h�[hblky�q_eh\_d\ lZdbo� kblmZpbyo� hiZkghklb"�Hq_\b^gh�� g_� ms_j[Z�� h dhlhjhf�fh`gh� km^blv� h[t_dlb\gh� bdhlhjuc�ikboheh]bq_kdb�fh]�[u�kh\_jr_ggh�gbq_]h�g_�agZqblv��Z lh]h��qlh�ijbqbgy_lky�bf�\^mr_\ghc�`bagb��Jh`^_gb_��gZijbf_j��ijhh[jZa�gZr_]h�khklhygby�kljZoZ��kZfh�ih�k_[_�\jy^�eb

Page 308: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fh`_l�jZkkfZljb\Zlvky�dZd�ms_j[��ohly�hiZkghklv�ih\j_`^_gbc�ijb�wlhf�_klv��Kms_kl\_gguf\ jh`^_gbb��dZd�b \�ex[hc�kblmZpbb�hiZkghklb��y\ey_lky�lh��qlh�\ ^mr_\ghf�i_j_`b\Zgbb�hgh\uau\Z_l� khklhygb_� \ukhdhgZijy`_ggh]h� \ha[m`^_gby�� dhlhjh_� \hkijbgbfZ_lky� dZdg_m^h\hevkl\b_�b k�dhlhjuf�q_eh\_d�g_�fh`_l�kijZ\blvky�iml_f�jZajy^db��GZa\Z\�khklhygb_�ijb�dhlhjhf�mkbeby�ijbgpbiZ�m^h\hevkl\by� l_jiyl�g_m^Zqm��ljZ\fZlbq_kdbf nZdlhjhf��fuijboh^bf�q_j_a�jy^�g_\jhlbq_kdbc�kljZo�²�j_Zevguc�kljZo�²�hiZkgZy�kblmZpby�d ijhklhfmiheh`_gbx�� lh�� qlh� \uau\Z_l� [hyagv�� ij_^f_l� kljZoZ�²� wlh� dZ`^uc� jZa� ihy\e_gb_ljZ\fZlbq_kdh]h�nZdlhjZ��dhlhjuc�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�mkljZg_g�^_ckl\b_f�ijbgpbiZ�m^h\hevkl\by�Fu�kjZam�`_�ihgbfZ_f��qlh�[eZ]h^Zjy�gZebqbx�ijbgpbiZ�m^h\hevkl\by�fu�aZkljZoh\Zgu�g_�hlh[t_dlb\gh]h� ms_j[Z�� Z lhevdh� hl� hij_^_e_ggh]h� ms_j[Z� gZr_c� ikbobq_kdhc� wdhghfbb��HlijbgpbiZ� m^h\hevkl\by� ^h� bgklbgdlZ� kZfhkhojZg_gby� ^he]bc� imlv�� fgh]h]h� g_� o\ZlZ_l� ^eylh]h��qlh[u�bo�p_eb�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ�kh\iZ^Zeb��Gh�fu�\b^bf�lZd`_�dh_�qlh�^jm]h_��\hafh`gh�wlh� lh� j_r_gb_�� dhlhjh_� fu� bs_f�� : bf_ggh�� a^_kv� \_a^_� j_qv� b^_l� h[� hlghkbl_evguodhebq_kl\Zo�Lhevdh� \_ebqbgZ� kmffu� \ha[m`^_gby� ijb\h^bl� d ljZ\fZlbq_kdhfm�nZdlhjm�� iZjZebam_ljZ[hlm�ijbgpbiZ�m^h\hevkl\by��ijb^Z_l�kblmZpbb�hiZkghklb�__ agZq_gb_��: _keb�wlh�lZd��_kebwlZ� aZ]Z^dZ� mkljZgy_lky� lZdbf�ijhaZbq_kdbf� h[jZahf�� lh�ihq_fm� g_�fh`_l� [ulv� lh]h�� qlh[uih^h[gu_�ljZ\fZlbq_kdb_�nZdlhju�\hagbdeb�\ ^mr_\ghc�`bagb�g_aZ\bkbfh�hl�ij_^iheZ]Z_fuohiZkguo�kblmZpbc��ijb�dhlhjuo�kljZo�ijh[m`^Z_lky�g_�dZd�kb]gZe��Z \hagbdZ_l�aZgh\h�gZ�bghfhkgh\Zgbb"�Debgbq_kdbc� hiul� k hij_^_e_gghklvx�ih^l\_j`^Z_l�� qlh� wlh� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� lZd�Lhevdh�[he__�iha^gb_�\ul_kg_gby�hldju\Zxl�hibkZgguc�gZfb�f_oZgbaf��ijb� dhlhjhf� kljZoijh[m`^Z_lky�dZd�kb]gZe�dZdhc�lh�[he__�jZgg_c�kblmZpbb�hiZkghklb��i_j\u_�b i_j\hgZqZevgu_ba� gbo� \hagbdZxl� ijyfh� ijb� \klj_q_� Y kh� k\_jokbevguf� ijblyaZgb_f� eb[b^h� baljZ\fZlbq_kdbo�nZdlhjh\��hgb�aZgh\h�h[jZamxl�k\hc�kljZo��ohly�b ih�ijhh[jZam�jh`^_gby��Lh`_� kZfh_� fh`gh� hlg_klb� b d� jZa\blbx� kljZoZ� ijb� g_\jha_� kljZoZ� ba�aZ� khfZlbq_kdh]hgZjmr_gby�k_dkmZevghc�nmgdpbb��Lh��qlh�wlh�kZfh�eb[b^h��ij_\jZs_ggh_�ijb�wlhf�\ kljZo��fug_�[m^_f�[hevr_�ml\_j`^Zlv��Gh�y g_�\b`m�gbdZdbo�\hajZ`_gbc�ijhlb\�ijbagZgby�^\hydh]hijhbkoh`^_gby� kljZoZ�� lh�dZd�ijyfh]h� ke_^kl\by� ljZ\fZlbq_kdh]h�nZdlhjZ�� lh� dZd� kb]gZeZ�hlhf��qlh�\hagbdZ_l�m]jhaZ�ih\lhj_gby�wlh]h�nZdlhjZ�M\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��<u��dhg_qgh��jZ^u�lhfm��qlh�\Zf�g_�ijb^_lky�[he__�gbq_]h\ukemrb\Zlv� h kljZo_�� Gh� wlh� ^_eZ� g_� f_gy_l�� b[h� ^Zevg_cr__� g_� emqr_� lh]h�� Y gZf_j_gk_]h^gy� `_� \\_klb� \Zk� \ h[eZklv� l_hjbb� eb[b^h� beb� l_hjbb� \e_q_gbc�� ]^_� lh`_�� dZ`_lky�ihy\behkv�dh_�qlh�gh\h_��G_�ohqm�kdZaZlv��qlh�fu�^hklb]eb�a^_kv�gZklhevdh�[hevrbo�mki_oh\�qlh[u� klhbeh� ijbeZ]Zlv� mkbeby� ^ey� mk\h_gby� \k_]h� wlh]h��G_l�� wlh� lZdZy� h[eZklv�� ]^_� fu� kljm^hf�hjb_glbjm_fky�b ^hklb]Z_f�ihgbfZgby��\u�[m^_l_�ebrv�k\b^_l_eyfb�gZrbo�mkbebc�ba^_kv�fg_�lh`_�ijb^_lky�\_jgmlvky��dklZlb��d lhfm��h q_f�y ]h\hjbe�jZgvr_�L_hjby�\e_q_gbc�²�wlh��lZd�kdZaZlv��gZrZ�fbnheh]by��<e_q_gby�²�fbnbq_kdb_�kms_kl\Z�]jZg^bhagu_�\ k\h_c�g_hij_^_e_gghklb��Fu�\ gZr_c�jZ[hl_�gb�gZ�fbgmlm�g_�fh`_f�mimkdZlvbo� ba� \b^m� b ijb� wlhf� gbdh]^Z� g_� m\_j_gu�� qlh� \b^bf� bo� ykgh�� <u� agZ_l_�� dZd� h[u^_ggh_fure_gb_� h[tykgy_l� \e_q_gb_�� Ij_^iheZ]Z_lky� ]hjZa^h� [hevr__� dhebq_kl\h� jZaghh[jZaguo\e_q_gbc��q_f�wlh�gm`gh��\e_q_gb_�d kZfhml\_j`^_gbx��ih^jZ`Zgbx��b]j_��h[s_gbx�b fgh]b_

Page 309: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

bf� ih^h[gu_�� Bo� dZd� [u� ijbgbfZxl� d k\_^_gbx�� ^Zxl� dZ`^hfm� ba� gbo� \uihegylv� k\hxnmgdpbx�b aZl_f�hiylv�bo�hlkljZgyxl��GZf�\k_]^Z�dZaZehkv��qlh� aZ� wlbfb�fgh]hqbke_ggufbf_edbfb�aZbfkl\h\Zggufb�\e_q_gbyfb�kdju\Z_lky�g_qlh�k_jv_agh_�b fh]ms_kl\_ggh_��d q_fmfu�`_eZeb�[u�hklhjh`gh�ijb[ebablvky��GZr�i_j\uc�rZ]�[ue�\_kvfZ�kdjhfguf��Fu�kdZaZebk_[_�� qlh�� \_jhylgh�� g_� aZimlZ_fky�� _keb� ^ey� gZqZeZ� \u^_ebf� ^\Z� hkgh\guo� \e_q_gby�� \b^Z\e_q_gbc� beb� ]jmiiu� \e_q_gbc� ih� ^\mf� [hevrbf� ihlj_[ghklyf�� ]heh^� b ex[h\v�� DZd� [uj_\ghklgh�fu�gb�aZsbsZeb�\ bguo�kemqZyo�g_aZ\bkbfhklv�ikboheh]bb�hl�ex[hc�^jm]hc�gZmdb�a^_kv�fu�\k_�lZdb�gZoh^bfky�\ ie_gm�g_au[e_fh]h�[bheh]bq_kdh]h�nZdlZ��kh]eZkgh�dhlhjhfmhl^_evgh_� `b\h_� kms_kl\h� kem`bl� ^\mf� gZf_j_gbyf�� kZfhkhojZg_gbx� b khojZg_gbx� \b^Z�dZ`msbfky� g_aZ\bkbfufb� ^jm]� hl� ^jm]Z�� dhlhju_�� gZkdhevdh� gZf� ba\_klgh�� ihdZ� _s_� g_k\_^_gu�d _^bghfm�bklhqgbdm�b bgl_j_ku�dhlhjuo�\ `b\hlghc�`bagb�qZklh�ijhlb\hj_qZl�^jm]^jm]m�� Fu� dZd� [u� aZgbfZ_fky� a^_kv� kh[kl\_ggh� [bheh]bq_kdhc� ikboheh]b_c�� bamqZ_fikbobq_kdb_� y\e_gby�� khijh\h`^Zxsb_� [bheh]bq_kdb_� ijhp_kku�< dZq_kl\_� ijbf_jh\� wlh]hjh^Z� \ ikbohZgZeba_� ij_^klZ\e_gu� ©\e_q_gby� Yª� b ©k_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gbyª�� D i_j\uf� fuijbqbkey_f� \k_�� qlh� hlghkblky� d khojZg_gbx�� ml\_j`^_gbx�� \ha\ur_gbx� ebqghklb�� <ihke_^gb_� fu� \deZ^u\Zeb� lh� [h]Zlkl\h� kh^_j`Zgby�� dhlhjh]h� lj_[m_l� ^_lkdZy� ba\jZs_ggZyk_dkmZevgZy� `bagv�� IhagZdhfb\rbkv� ijb� bamq_gbb� g_\jhah\� k Y� dZd� k h]jZgbqb\Zxs_c�\ul_kgyxs_c�kbehc��Z k�k_dkmZevgufb�klj_fe_gbyfb�dZd�k ih^\_j]Zxsbfbky�h]jZgbq_gbx�b\ul_kg_gbx��fu�iheZ]Zeb�� qlh� gZsmiZeb� g_� lhevdh� jZaebqb_�� gh� b dhgnebdl�f_`^m� h[_bfb]jmiiZfb�\e_q_gbc��Ij_^f_lhf�gZr_]h�bamq_gby�kgZqZeZ�[ueb�lhevdh�k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby�wg_j]bx� dhlhjuo� fu� gZa\Zeb� ©eb[b^hª�� GZ� bo� ijbf_j_� fu� ih� iulZebkv� ijhykgblv� gZrbij_^klZ\e_gby�h lhf��qlh�lZdh_�\e_q_gb_�b qlh�_fm�fh`gh�ijbibkZlv��LZdh\h�agZq_gb_�l_hjbbeb[b^h�BlZd�� \e_q_gb_� hlebqZ_lky� hl� jZa^jZ`_gby� l_f�� qlh� hgh� ijhbkoh^bl� ba� bklhqgbdh\jZa^jZ`_gby�\gmljb�l_eZ��^_ckl\m_l�dZd�ihklhyggZy�kbeZ�b qlh�q_eh\_d�g_�fh`_l�kiZklbkv�hlg_]h� [_]kl\hf�� dZd� wlh� fh`gh� k^_eZlv� ijb� \g_rg_f� jZa^jZ`_gbb�� <h� \e_q_gbb� fh`ghjZaebqblv�bklhqgbd��h[t_dl�b p_ev�Bklhqgbdhf�y\ey_lky�khklhygb_�\ha[m`^_gby�\ l_e_��p_evx²�mkljZg_gb_�wlh]h�\ha[m`^_gby��gZ�imlb�hl�bklhqgbdZ�d p_eb�\e_q_gb_�klZgh\blky�ikbobq_kdb^_ckl\_gguf�� Fu� ij_^klZ\ey_f� k_[_� _]h� dZd� hij_^_e_ggh_� dhebq_kl\h� wg_j]bb�� dhlhjh_^_ckl\m_l� \ hij_^_e_gghf� gZijZ\e_gbb�� Wlhfm� ^_ckl\bx� ^Zgh� gZa\Zgb_� ©\e_q_gb_ª �7ULHE��<e_q_gby� [u\Zxl� Zdlb\gufb� b iZkkb\gufb�� lhqg__� [ueh� [u� kdZaZlv�� _klv� Zdlb\gu_� biZkkb\gu_� p_eb� \e_q_gby�� ^ey� ^hklb`_gby� iZkkb\ghc� p_eb� lh`_� gm`gZ� aZljZlZ� Zdlb\ghklb�>hklb]Z_fZy� p_ev� fh`_l� [ulv� \ kh[kl\_gghf� l_e_�� gh�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� \dexqZ_lky� \g_rgbch[t_dl��[eZ]h^Zjy�dhlhjhfm�\e_q_gb_�^hklb]Z_l�\g_rg_c�p_eb��_]h�\gmlj_gg_c�p_evx�hklZ_lky\kydbc� jZa� baf_g_gb_� l_eZ�� \hkijbgbfZ_fh_� dZd� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�� Ijb^Z_l� eb� hlghr_gb_� dkhfZlbq_kdhfm�bklhqgbdm�dZdmx�eb[h�ki_pbnbdm�\e_q_gbx�b dZdmx��hklZ_lky�^ey�gZk�g_ykguf�Lh��qlh�\e_q_gby�ba�h^gh]h�bklhqgbdZ�ijbfudZxl�d lZdh\uf�ba�^jm]bo�bklhqgbdh\�b jZa^_eyxlbo�^Zevg_crmx� km^v[m�b qlh�\hh[s_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�h^gh]h� \e_q_gby�fh`_l�[ulv� aZf_g_gh^jm]bf�� wlh�²� ih� k\b^_l_evkl\m� ZgZeblbq_kdh]h� hiulZ�²� g_khfg_ggu_�nZdlu��IjbagZ_fkylhevdh��qlh�fu�g_�hkh[_ggh�ohjhrh�ihgbfZ_f�bo��Hlghr_gb_�\e_q_gby�d p_eb�b h[t_dlm�lh`_^himkdZ_l� baf_g_gby�� h[Z� fh]ml� [ulv� aZf_g_gu� ^jm]bfb�� gh� \k_�lZdb� hlghr_gb_� d h[t_dlme_]q_� hkeZ[blv�� Hij_^_e_gguc� oZjZdl_j� fh^bnbdZpbb� p_eb� b kf_gu� h[t_dlZ�� ijb� dhlhjhc

Page 310: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

mqblu\Z_lky�gZrZ� khpbZevgZy� hp_gdZ��fu� \u^_ey_f� dZd� km[ebfZpbx� Djhf_� lh]h��fu� bf__fhkgh\Zgb_�jZaebqZlv�_s_�\e_q_gby��aZ^_j`Zggu_�gZ�imlb�d p_eb �]LHOJHKHPPWH���\e_q_gby�baohjhrh�ba\_klguo�bklhqgbdh\� k g_^\mkfuke_gghc�p_evx�� aZ^_j`Z\rb_ky�� h^gZdh��gZ�imlb� dm^h\e_l\hj_gbx��\ j_amevlZl_�q_]h�gZklmiZ_l�^ebl_evgZy�ijb\yaZgghklv�d h[t_dlm�b mklhcqb\h_klj_fe_gb_��LZdh]h�jh^Z��gZijbf_j��hlghr_gb_�g_`ghklb��dhlhjh_�g_khfg_ggh�ijhbkoh^bl�bak_dkmZevghc� ihlj_[ghklb� b h[uqgh� hldZau\Z_lky� hl� k\h_]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby�� Fh`_l_� k_[_ij_^klZ\blv��kdhevdh�_s_�k\hckl\�b km^_[�\e_q_gbc�hklZ_lky�aZ�ij_^_eZfb�gZr_]h�ihgbfZgby�a^_kv� g_h[oh^bfh� lZd`_� gZihfgblv� h jZaebqbb� f_`^m� k_dkmZevgufb� \e_q_gbyfb� bbgklbgdlZfb� kZfhkhojZg_gby�� dhlhjh_�bf_eh� [u� qj_a\uqZcgh_� l_hj_lbq_kdh_� agZq_gb_�� _keb[u� hlghkbehkv� dh� \k_c� ]jmii_�� K_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gby� ihjZ`Zxl� gZk� k\h_c� ieZklbqghklvx�kihkh[ghklvx� f_gylv� k\hb� p_eb�� k\h_c� aZf_sZ_fhklvx�� l_f�� qlh� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� h^gh]h\e_q_gby� iha\hey_l� aZf_s_gb_� ^jm]bf�� Z lZd`_� k\h_c� hlkjhq_gghklvx�� ohjhrbf� ijbf_jhfdhlhjhc�y\eyxlky�bf_ggh�aZ^_j`Zggu_�gZ�imlb�d p_eb�\e_q_gby��< wlbo�dZq_kl\Zo�fu�ohl_eb[u�hldZaZlv�bgklbgdlZf�kZfhkhojZg_gby��kdZaZ\�h gbo��qlh�hgb�g_ij_dehggu��[_ahleZ]Zl_evgu�bfi_jZlb\gu�kh\k_f�^jm]bf�h[jZahf�b bf_xl�kh\k_f�^jm]h_�hlghr_gb_�dZd�d \ul_kg_gbx��lZdb d�kljZom��H^gZdh�ke_^mxs__�jZafure_gb_�]h\hjbl�gZf��qlh�wlh�bkdexqbl_evgh_�iheh`_gb_aZgbfZxl� g_� \k_� \e_q_gby� Y�� Z lhevdh� ]heh^� b `Z`^Z� b qlh�� hq_\b^gh�� hgh� h[hkgh\Zghhkh[_gghklvx�bklhqgbdh\�\e_q_gbc��<i_qZle_gb_� aZimlZgghklb� \hagbdZ_l� _s_�b ihlhfm��qlhfu� g_� jZkkfhlj_eb� hl^_evgh�� dZdb_� baf_g_gby� ij_l_ji_\Zxl� \e_q_gby�� i_j\hgZqZevghijbgZ^e_`Z\rb_�Hgh��ih^�\ebygb_f�hj]Zgbah\Zggh]h�Y�Fu�gZoh^bfky�gZ�[he__�l\_j^hc�ihq\_��dh]^Z�bkke_^m_f��dZdbf�h[jZahf�\e_q_gby�kem`Zlk_dkmZevghc�nmgdpbb��A^_kv�fu�ihemqbeb�j_rZxsb_�^Zggu_��dhlhju_�b ^ey�\Zk�g_�gh\u��<_^vk_dkmZevgh_� \e_q_gb_� magZ_lky� g_� ih� lhfm�� qlh� _fm� k kZfh]h� gZqZeZ� k\hckl\_ggZmklj_fe_gghklv� d p_eb� k_dkmZevghc� nmgdpbb� ²� kh_^bg_gbx� ^\mo� iheh\uo� de_lhd�� gh� fu\b^bf� [hevrh_� dhebq_kl\h� qZklguo� \e_q_gbc�� dhlhju_� ^h\hevgh� g_aZ\bkbfh� ^jm]� hl� ^jm]Zklj_fylky� d m^h\e_l\hj_gbx�b gZoh^yl� wlh� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� \ q_f�lh��qlh�fu�fh`_f�gZa\Zlvm^h\hevkl\b_f� hl� nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby� hj]Zgh\ �2UJDQOXVW�� =_gblZebb� y\eyxlky� kj_^b� wlbowjh]_gguo� ahg kZfufb� iha^gbfb�� m^h\hevkl\bx� hl� nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby� wlbo� hj]Zgh\� g_evay[he__� hldZau\Zlv� \ gZa\Zgbb� k_dkmZevgh_� gZkeZ`^_gb_� G_� \k_� ba� wlbo� klj_fysboky� dgZkeZ`^_gbx�ih[m`^_gbc� \dexqZxlky� \ hdhgqZl_evgmx� hj]ZgbaZpbx� k_dkmZevghc�nmgdpbb�G_dhlhju_� ba� gbo� mkljZgyxlky� dZd� g_ijb]h^gu_� \ul_kg_gb_f� beb� dZdbf�eb[h� ^jm]bfkihkh[hf��g_dhlhju_�m\h^ylky�hl�k\h_c�p_eb�m`_�mihfygmluf�hkh[uf�h[jZahf�b bkihevamxlky^ey� mkbe_gby� bguo� ih[m`^_gbc�� ^jm]b_� hklZxlky� gZ� \lhjhkl_i_gguo� jheyo�� kem`Zhkms_kl\e_gbx�\\h^guo�Zdlh\��\uau\Zy�ij_^\Zjbl_evgh_�m^h\hevkl\b_��<u�magZeb��qlh�\ wlhf^ebl_evghf�jZa\blbb�fh`gh�mkfhlj_lv�g_kdhevdh�nZa�ij_^r_kl\mxs_c�hj]ZgbaZpbb��Z lZd`_lh��dZdbf�h[jZahf�ba�jZa\blby�k_dkmZevghc�nmgdpbb�h[tykgyxlky�__ hldehg_gby�b aZ^_j`db�I_j\mx� ba� wlbo� ij_]_gblZetguo� nZa fu� gZau\Z_f� hjZevghc� ihlhfm� qlh� \ khhl\_lkl\bb� kiblZgb_f�]jm^gh]h�feZ^_gpZ�wjh]_ggZy�ahgZ�jlZ�^hfbgbjm_l�lZd`_�b \�lhf��qlh�fh`gh�gZa\Zlvk_dkmZevghc� ^_yl_evghklvx� wlh]h� i_jbh^Z� `bagb�� GZ� \lhjhc� klmi_gb� gZ� i_j\uc� ieZg\u^\b]Zxlky� kZ^bklkdb_ b ZgZevgu_ bfimevku�� dhg_qgh� `_�� \ k\yab� k ihy\e_gb_f� am[h\�mkbe_gb_f�fmkdmeZlmju�b h\eZ^_gb_f�nmgdpbyfb�knbgdl_jZ��DZd�jZa�h[�wlhc�ijbf_qZl_evghcklmi_gb�jZa\blby�fu�magZeb�fgh]h�bgl_j_kguo�ih^jh[ghkl_c��Lj_lvy�nZaZ�²�nZeebq_kdZy� \

Page 311: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dhlhjhc� m h[hbo� iheh\� fm`kdhc� qe_g� b lh�� qlh� _fm� khhl\_lkl\m_l� m ^_\hq_d�� ijbh[j_lZ_lagZq_gb_�� dhlhjh_� g_evay� g_� aZf_lblv�� GZa\Zgb_� ]_gblZevgZy� nZaZ� fu� hklZ\beb� ^eyhdhgqZl_evghc� k_dkmZevghc� hj]ZgbaZpbb�� dhlhjZy� mklZgZ\eb\Z_lky� ihke_� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb�dh]^Z� `_gkdb_� iheh\u_� hj]Zgu� gZoh^yl� lZdh_� `_� ijbagZgb_�� dZdh_� fm`kdb_� ihemqbeb� m`_^Z\gh�<k_�wlh�ih\lhj_gb_�^Z\gh�ba\_klgh]h��G_�^mfZcl_�lhevdh��qlh�\k_�lh��h q_f�y gZ�wlhl�jZa�g_kdZaZe�� mljZlbeh� k\h_� agZq_gb_�� Wlh� ih\lhj_gb_� [ueh� gm`gh� ^ey� lh]h�� qlh[u� i_j_clb� dkhh[s_gbyf�h[�baf_g_gbyo�\ gZrbo�\a]ey^Zo��Fu�fh`_f�iho\Zeblvky��qlh�dZd�jZa�h jZggbohj]ZgbaZpbyo�eb[b^h�fu�magZeb�fgh]h�gh\h]h��Z agZq_gb_�ij_`g_]h�ihgyeb�ykg__��qlh�y b�ohqmijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv�\Zf��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��gZ�hl^_evguo�ijbf_jZo��< �����]��:[jZoZf�ihdZaZe�qlh� \ kZ^bklkdh�ZgZevghc� nZa_� fh`gh� jZaebqblv� ^\_� klmi_gb�� GZ� [he__� jZgg_c� ba� gbo]hkih^kl\mxl� ^_kljmdlb\gu_� l_g^_gpbb� mgbqlh`_gby� b mljZlu�� gZ� [he__� iha^g_c� ²^jm`_kl\_ggu_� h[t_dlm� l_g^_gpbb� m^_j`Zgby� b h[eZ^Zgby��LZdbf� h[jZahf�� \ k_j_^bg_� wlhcnZau� \i_j\u_� ihy\ey_lky� \gbfZgb_� d h[t_dlm� dZd� ij_^\_klgbd� [he__� iha^g_c� ex[h\ghcijb\yaZgghklb �/LHEHVEHVHW]XQJ���Fu�\ijZ\_�lZd`_�ij_^iheh`blv�lZdh_�jZa^_e_gb_�b gZ�i_j\hchjZevghc� nZa_�� GZ� i_j\hc� klmi_gb� j_qv� b^_l� h[� hjZevghf� ih]ehs_gbb�� gbdZdhcZf[b\Ze_glghklb� ih� hlghr_gbx� d h[t_dlm� fZl_jbgkdhc� ]jm^b� g_l�� <lhjmx� klmi_gv�hlf_q_ggmx� ihy\e_gb_f� dmkZl_evghc� ^_yl_evghklb�� fh`gh� gZa\Zlv� hjZevgh�kZ^bklkdhc� hgZ\i_j\u_� h[gZjm`b\Z_l� ijhy\e_gby� Zf[b\Ze_glghklb�� dhlhju_� gZ� ke_^mxs_c�� kZ^bklkdh�ZgZevghc� nZa_� klZgh\ylky� gZfgh]h� hlq_leb\_c�� P_gghklv� wlhc� gh\hc� deZkkbnbdZpbbh[gZjm`b\Z_lky� hkh[_ggh� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� ijb� hij_^_e_gguo� g_\jhaZo� ²� g_\jha_� gZ\yaqb\uokhklhygbc��f_eZgohebb�²�bsml�agZq_gb_�ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklb�\ jZa\blbb�eb[b^h��<_jgbl_kva^_kv�� fuke_ggh� d lhfm�� qlh� fu� magZeb� h k\yab� nbdkZpbb� eb[b^h�� ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklb� bj_]j_kkbb�GZr_�hlghr_gb_�d nZaZf�hj]ZgbaZpbb�eb[b^h�\hh[s_�g_fgh]h�baf_gbehkv��?keb�jZgvr_fu� ij_`^_� \k_]h� ih^q_jdb\Zeb�� dZd� h^gZ� ba� gbo� bkq_aZ_l� ijb� gZklmie_gbb� ke_^mxs_c�� lhl_i_jv� gZr_� \gbfZgb_� ijb\e_dZxl� nZdlu�� ihdZau\Zxsb_�� kdhevdh� hl� dZ`^hc� [he__� jZgg_cnZau� khojZgbehkv� gZjy^m� k [he__� iha^gbfb� h[jZah\Zgbyfb�� kdjulh� aZ� gbfb� b gZkdhevdh^ebl_evgh_�ij_^klZ\bl_evkl\h� ihemqZxl� hgb� \ [x^`_l_� eb[b^h�b \� oZjZdl_j_�bg^b\b^mmfZ�?s_�[he__�agZqbl_evgufb�klZeb�^Zggu_��ihdZaZ\rb_�gZf��dZd�qZklh�\ iZlheh]bq_kdbo�mkeh\byoijhbkoh^yl� j_]j_kkbb� d [he__� jZggbf�nZaZf� b qlh� hij_^_e_ggu_� j_]j_kkbb� oZjZdl_jgu� ^eyhij_^_e_gguo�nhjf�[he_agb��Gh�y g_�fh]m�a^_kv�wlh�h[km`^Zlv��wlh�hlghkblky�d ki_pbZevghcikboheh]bb�g_\jhah\�F_lZfhjnhau�\e_q_gbc�b koh^gu_�ijhp_kku�fu�kfh]eb�bamqblv��\ qZklghklb��gZ�ZgZevghcwjhlbd_��gZ�\ha[m`^_gbyo�ba�bklhqgbdh\�wjh]_gghc�ZgZevghc�ahgu�b [ueb�ihjZ`_gu�l_f��dZdh_jZaghh[jZagh_� bkihevah\Zgb_� gZoh^yl� wlb� \e_q_gby�� <hafh`gh�� g_e_]dh� hk\h[h^blvky� hlg_^hhp_gdb� bf_ggh� wlhc� ahgu� \ ijhp_kk_� jZa\blby�� Ihwlhfm� iha\hebf� :[jZoZfm� ������gZihfgblv� gZf�� qlh� Zgmk� wf[jbheh]bq_kdb� khhl\_lkl\m_l� i_j\hgZqZevghfm� jlm�� dhlhjuckf_klbeky�gZ�dhg_p�ijyfhc�dbrdb��>Ze__�fu�magZ_f��qlh�k h[_kp_gb\Zgb_f�kh[kl\_ggh]h�dZeZ�wdkdj_f_glh\�� wlhl� bgklbgdlb\guc� bgl_j_k� i_j_oh^bl� hl� ZgZevgh]h� bklhqgbdZ +,� h[t_dlu�dhlhju_�fh]ml�^Z\Zlvky�\ dZq_kl\_�ih^ZjdZ� B wlh� kijZ\_^eb\h��ihlhfm�qlh�dZe�[ue�i_j\uf

Page 312: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ih^Zjdhf�� dhlhjuc� fh]� k^_eZlv� ]jm^ghc� feZ^_g_p�� hlju\Zy� _]h� hl� k_[y� ba� ex[\b� dmoZ`b\Zxs_c�aZ�gbf�`_gsbg_��< ^Zevg_cr_f��kh\_jr_ggh�ZgZeh]bqgh�baf_g_gbx�agZq_gbc�\jZa\blbb� yaudZ�� wlhl� ij_`gbc� bgl_j_k� d dZem� ij_\jZsZ_lky� \ ijb\e_dZl_evghklv� ahehlZ b^_g_]� Z lZd`_� kihkh[kl\m_l� Znn_dlb\ghfm� gZiheg_gbx� ihgylbc� j_[_ghd b i_gbk� Ihm[_`^_gbx�\k_o�^_l_c��dhlhju_�^he]h�ijb^_j`b\Zxlky�l_hjbb�dehZdb��j_[_ghd�jh`^Z_lky�dZddmkhd�dZeZ�ba�ijyfhc�dbrdb��^_n_dZpby�y\ey_lky�ijhh[jZahf�ZdlZ�jh`^_gby��Gh�b i_gbk�lh`_bf__l� k\h_]h� ij_^r_kl\_ggbdZ� \ klhe[_� dZeZ�� dhlhjuc� aZihegy_l� b jZa^jZ`Z_l� kebabklmxh[hehqdm� \gmlj_gg_c� klhjhgu� ijyfhc� dbrdb�� ?keb� j_[_ghd�� ohly� b g_hohlgh�� gh� \k_�lZdbijbagZe��qlh�_klv�q_eh\_q_kdb_�kms_kl\Z��dhlhju_�wlbf�qe_ghf�g_�h[eZ^Zxl��lh�i_gbk�dZ`_lky_fm� q_f�lh� hl^_ey_fuf� hl� l_eZ� b ijbh[j_lZ_l� g_khfg_ggmx� ZgZeh]bx� k wdkdj_f_g�lhf�dhlhjuc� [ue� i_j\hc� l_e_kghc� qZklvx�� hl� dhlhjhc� gZ^h� [ueh� hldZaZlvky�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�[hevrZy�qZklv� ZgZevghc� wjhlbdb�i_j_ghkblky�gZ�i_gbk��gh�bgl_j_k�d wlhc�qZklb� l_eZ�� djhf_ZgZevgh�wjhlbq_kdh]h�� bf__l�� \b^bfh�� _s_� [he__� fhsguc� hjZevguc� dhj_gv�� lZd� dZd� ihke_ij_djZs_gby�dhjfe_gby�i_gbk�gZke_^m_l�lZd`_�dh_�qlh�hl�khkdZ�]jm^b�fZl_jbgkdh]h�hj]ZgZ�G_\hafh`gh� hjb_glbjh\Zlvky� \ nZglZabyo�� ijbqm^Zo�� \hagbdZxsbo� ih^� \ebygb_f[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��b \�yaud_�kbfilhfh\�q_eh\_dZ��_keb�g_�agZlv�wlbo�]em[hdh�e_`Zsbo�k\ya_c�DZe� ²� ahehlh� ²� ih^Zjhd� ²� j_[_ghd� ²� i_gbk� \uklmiZxl� a^_kv� dZd� jZ\ghagZqgu_� bij_^klZ\eyxlky�h[sbfb�kbf\heZfb��G_�aZ[u\Zcl_�lZd`_��qlh�y fh]m�k^_eZlv�\Zf�ebrv�^Ze_dhg_�ihegu_�khh[s_gby��Fh]m�ijb[Z\blv�ebrv�\kdhevav��qlh�ihy\eyxsbcky�iha^g__�bgl_j_k�d\eZ]Zebsm�bf__l�\ hkgh\ghf�ZgZevgh�wjhlbq_kdh_�ijhbkoh`^_gb_��Wlh�g_m^b\bl_evgh��lZd�dZd\eZ]Zebs_�� ih� m^Zqghfm� \ujZ`_gbx� Em� :g^j_Z�KZehf_� �������� ©\aylh� gZijhdZlª� m ijyfhcdbrdb�� \ `bagb� ]hfhk_dkmZebklh\�� dhlhju_� g_� ijhreb� hij_^_e_gghc� qZklb� k_dkmZevgh]hjZa\blby�� hgh� b ij_^klZ\e_gh� ijyfhc� dbrdhc�� < kgh\b^_gbyo� qZklh� \hagbdZ_l� ihf_s_gb_�dhlhjh_� jZgvr_� [ueh� _^bguf�� Z l_i_jv� jZa^_e_gh� kl_ghc� beb� gZh[hjhl�� Ijb� wlhf� \k_]^Zbf__lky� \ \b^m� hlghr_gb_� \eZ]ZebsZ� d ijyfhc� dbrd_�� Fu� fh`_f� lZd`_� hq_gv� ohjhrhijhke_^blv�� dZd� m ^_\mrdb� kh\_jr_ggh� g_� `_gkl\_ggh_� `_eZgb_� h[eZ^Zlv� i_gbkhf� h[uqghij_\jZsZ_lky� \ `_eZgb_�bf_lv� j_[_gdZ�� Z aZl_f�b fm`qbgm� dZd� ghkbl_ey� i_gbkZ� b ^Zxs_]hj_[_gdZ�� lZd� qlh� b a^_kv� \b^gh�� dZd� qZklv� i_j\hgZqZevgh� ZgZevgh�wjhlbq_kdh]h� bgl_j_kZmqZkl\m_l�\ [he__�iha^g_c�]_gblZevghc�hj]ZgbaZpbb�<h�\j_fy�bamq_gby�ij_]_gblZevguo�nZa�eb[b^h�fu�ijbh[j_eb�g_kdhevdh�gh\uc�\a]ey^�gZnhjfbjh\Zgb_�oZjZdl_jZ��Fu�h[jZlbeb�\gbfZgb_�gZ�ljbZ^m�k\hckl\��dhlhju_�^h\hevgh�qZklhijhy\eyxlky�\f_kl_�ZddmjZlghklv��[_j_`eb\hklv�b mijyfkl\h�²�b ba�ZgZebaZ�lZdbo�ex^_c�aZdexqbeb��qlh�wlbk\hckl\Z� h[mkeh\e_gu� bklhs_gb_f� b bguf� bkihevah\Zgb_f� bo� ZgZevghc� wjhlbdb�� LZdbfh[jZahf�� dh]^Z� fu� \b^bf� lZdh_� ijbf_qZl_evgh_� kh_^bg_gb_�� fu� ]h\hjbf� h[� ZgZevghfoZjZdl_j_� b hij_^_e_gguf� h[jZahf� ijhlb\hihklZ\ey_f� ZgZevguc� oZjZdl_j� g_jZa\blhcZgZevghc�wjhlbd_��Ih^h[gh_��Z fh`_l�[ulv��b _s_�[he__�l_kgh_�hlghr_gb_�gZoh^bf�fu�f_`^mq_klhex[b_f� b mj_ljZevghc� wjhlbdhc�� Ijbf_qZl_evguc� gZf_d� gZ� wlm� k\yav� fu� [_j_f� bae_]_g^u�� kh]eZkgh� dhlhjhc� :e_dkZg^j� FZd_^hgkdbc� jh^beky� \ lm� `_� ghqv�� dh]^Z� g_dbc=_jhkljZl ba� `Z`^u� keZ\u� ih^`_]� bamfbl_evguc� ojZf� :jl_fb^u� Wn_kkdhc� Fh`_lihdZaZlvky�� qlh� ^j_\gbf� wlZ� k\yav� [ueZ� g_[_aua\_klgZ�� <_^v� \u� agZ_l_�� gZkdhevdh

Page 313: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fhq_bkimkdZgb_�k\yaZgh�k h]g_f�b lmr_gb_f�h]gy��Fu��dhg_qgh��ij_^iheZ]Z_f��qlh�b ^jm]b_k\hckl\Z�oZjZdl_jZ�ih^h[guf�`_�h[jZahf�h[gZjm`Zlky�\ hkZ^dZo �1LHGHUVFKODJH���j_Zdlb\guoh[jZah\Zgbyo� hij_^_e_gguo� ij_]_gblZevguo� nhjfZpbc� eb[b^h�� gh� g_� fh`_f� wlh]h� ihdZihdZaZlv�L_i_jv�`_�kZfh_�\j_fy�\_jgmlvky�d bklhjbb��Z lZd`_�d l_f_�b kgh\Z�\aylvky�aZ�kZfu_�h[sb_ijh[e_fu�`bagb�\e_q_gbc��< hkgh\_�gZr_c�l_hjbb�eb[b^h�kgZqZeZ�e_`Zeh�ijhlb\hihklZ\e_gb_\e_q_gbc� Y b� k_dkmZevguo� \e_q_gbc�� Dh]^Z� iha^g__� fu� gZqZeb� bamqZlv� kZfh� Y b� ihgyebhkgh\ghc� ijbgpbi� gZjpbkkbafZ�� kZfh� wlh� jZaebqb_� ihl_jyeh� k\hx� ihq\m��< j_^dbo� kemqZyofh`gh� ijbagZlv�� qlh� Y [_j_l� kZfh� k_[y� \ dZq_kl\_� h[t_dlZ�� \_^_l� k_[y� lZd�� dZd� [m^lh� hgh\ex[e_gh� \ kZfh_� k_[y�� Hlkx^Z� b aZbfkl\h\Zggh_� ba� ]j_q_kdhc� e_]_g^u� gZa\Zgb_� ²gZjpbkkbaf� Gh� wlh�ebrv�djZcg__�ij_m\_ebq_gb_�ghjfZevgh]h�iheh`_gby�\_s_c��GZqbgZ_rvihgbfZlv�� qlh� Y y\ey_lky� \k_]^Z� hkgh\guf� j_a_j\mZjhf� eb[b^h�� ba� dhlhjh]h� h[t_dluaZihegyxlky�eb[b^h�b dm^Z�wlh�eb[b^h�kgh\Z�\ha\jZsZ_lky��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�[hevrZy�_]h�qZklvihklhyggh�ij_[u\Z_l�\ Y��BlZd��b^_l�[_kij_klZggh_�ij_\jZs_gb_�Y�eb[b^h�\ h[t_dl�eb[b^h�bh[t_dl�eb[b^h�\ Y�eb[b^h��Gh�h[Z�hgb�fh]ml�b g_�jZaebqZlvky�ih�k\h_c�ijbjh^_��lh]^Z�g_�bf__lkfukeZ� hl^_eylv� wg_j]bx� h^gh]h� hl� wg_j]bb� ^jm]h]h��fh`gh� himklblv� gZa\Zgb_� eb[b^h� beb\hh[s_�mihlj_[eylv�_]h�dZd�jZ\ghagZqgh_�ikbobq_kdhc�wg_j]bb�Fu� g_^he]h� hklZ\Zebkv� gZ� wlhc� lhqd_� aj_gby�� Ij_^qm\kl\b_� dZdh]h�lh� ZglZ]hgbafZ� \jZfdZo� bgklbgdlb\ghc� `bagb� kdhjh� gZreh� ^jm]h_�� _s_� [he__� j_adh_� \ujZ`_gb_�� Fg_� g_ohl_ehkv�[u�baeZ]Zlv�\Zf��dZd�fu�ihkl_i_ggh�ih^oh^beb�d wlhfm�gh\hfm�iheh`_gbx�\ l_hjbb\e_q_gbc��hgh�lh`_�hkgh\u\Z_lky�]eZ\guf�h[jZahf�gZ�[bheh]bq_kdbo�^Zgguo��y jZkkdZ`m�\Zf�hg_f�dZd�h ]hlh\hf�j_amevlZl_��Ij_^iheh`bf��qlh�_klv�^\Z�jZaebqguo�ih�kmlb�\b^Z�\e_q_gbc�k_dkmZevgu_� \e_q_gby�� ihgbfZ_fu_ )� rbjhdhf� kfuke_�� Wjhk� _keb� \u� ij_^ihqblZ_l_� wlhgZa\Zgb_�� b Z]j_kkb\gu_� \e_q_gby� p_ev� dhlhjuo� ²� jZajmr_gb_�� < lZdhf� \b^_� \u� \jy^� ebkhql_l_� wlh� aZ� gh\hklv�� wlh� ihdZ`_lky� \Zf� ihiuldhc� l_hj_lbq_kdb� h[eZ]hjh^blv� [ZgZevgmxijhlb\hiheh`ghklv� ex[\b� b g_gZ\bklb�� dhlhjZy�� \hafh`gh�� kh\iZ^Z_l� k ZgZeh]bqghciheyjghklvx� ijbly`_gby²hllZedb\Zgby�� dhlhjmx� nbabdb� ij_^iheZ]Zxl� kms_kl\mxs_c� \g_hj]Zgbq_kdhf�fbj_���Gh�ijbf_qZl_evgh��qlh�gZr_�iheh`_gb_�fgh]bfb�\hkijbgbfZ_lky�dZdgh\hklv��ijbq_f�hq_gv�g_`_eZl_evgZy�gh\hklv��dhlhjmx�dZd�fh`gh�kdhj__�ke_^m_l�mkljZgblv��YiheZ]Zx�� qlh� \ wlhf� g_ijbylbb� ijhy\ey_lky� kbevguc� Znn_dlb\guc� nZdlhj�� Ihq_fm� gZfihgZ^h[behkv� lZd� fgh]h� \j_f_gb�� qlh[u� j_rblvky� ijbagZlv� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� klj_fe_gby� dZ]j_kkbb�� ihq_fm� hq_\b^gu_� b h[s_ba\_klgu_� nZdlu� g_� bkihevah\Zlv� [_a� ijhf_^e_gby� ^eyl_hjbb"�?keb�ijbibkZlv�lZdhc�bgklbgdl�`b\hlguf��lh�\jy^�eb�wlh�\klj_lbl�khijhlb\e_gb_��Gh\dexqblv� _]h� \ q_eh\_q_kdmx� dhgklblmpbx� dZ`_lky� njb\hevguf�� kebrdhf� fgh]bfj_eb]bhaguf�ij_^ihkuedZf�b khpbZevguf�mkeh\ghklyf�wlh�ijhlb\hj_qbl��G_l��q_eh\_d�^he`_g[ulv� ih� k\h_c� ijbjh^_� ^h[juf� beb�� ih� djZcg_c� f_j_�� ^h[jh^mrguf�� ?keb�`_� hg� bgh]^Z� bijhy\ey_l� k_[y� ]jm[uf�� `_klhdbf� gZkbevgbdhf�� lh� wlh� \j_f_ggu_� aZl_fg_gby� \ _]hwfhpbhgZevghc�`bagb��qZklh�kijh\hpbjh\Zggu_��\hafh`gh��ebrv�ke_^kl\b_�g_p_e_khh[jZagh]hh[s_kl\_ggh]h�mkljhckl\Z��\ dhlhjhf�hg�^h�kbo�ihj�gZoh^beky�Lh��h q_f�ih\_kl\m_l�gZf�bklhjby�b qlh�gZf�kZfbf�^h\_ehkv�i_j_`blv��d kh`Ze_gbx��g_ih^l\_j`^Z_l� kdZaZggh_�� Z kdhj__� ih^dj_iey_l� km`^_gb_� h lhf�� qlh� \_jZ� \ ©^h[jhlmª

Page 314: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

q_eh\_q_kdhc�gZlmju�y\ey_lky�h^ghc�ba�kZfuo�om^rbo�beexabc��hl�dhlhjuo�q_eh\_d�h`b^Z_lmemqr_gby�b h[e_]q_gby�k\h_c�`bagb��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�hgb�gZghkyl�lhevdh\j_^��G_l�gm`^u�ijh^he`Zlv�wlm�ihe_fbdm��b[h�g_�lhevdh�mjhdb�bklhjbb�b `bag_gguc�hiul]h\hjyl�\ ihevam�gZr_]h�ij_^iheh`_gby��qlh�\ q_eh\_d_�lZblky�hkh[uc�bgklbgdl�²�Z]j_kkbb�bjZajmr_gby�� wlh� ih^l\_j`^Zxl� b h[sb_� jZkkm`^_gby�� d dhlhjuf� gZk� ijb\_eh� ijbagZgb_n_ghf_gh\� kZ^bafZ b fZahobafZ� <u� agZ_l_�� qlh� fu� gZau\Z_f� k_dkmZevgh_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_kZ^bafhf��_keb�hgh�k\yaZgh�k mkeh\b_f��qlh�k_dkmZevguc�h[t_dl�bkiulu\Z_l�[hev��bklyaZgby�bmgb`_gby�� b fZahobafhf�� dh]^Z� bf__lky� ihlj_[ghklv� kZfhfm� [ulv� h[t_dlhf� bklyaZgby�� <uagZ_l_� lZd`_��qlh�hij_^_e_ggZy�ijbf_kv� wlbo�h[hbo� klj_fe_gbc� \dexqZ_lky�b \�ghjfZevgu_k_dkmZevgu_�hlghr_gby�b qlh�fu�gZau\Z_f�bo�ba\jZs_gbyfb��_keb�hgb�hll_kgyxl�\k_�ijhqb_k_dkmZevgu_� p_eb�� klZ\y� gZ� bo�f_klh� k\hb� kh[kl\_ggu_��?^\Z� eb� hl� \Zk� mkdhevagmeh� lh�� qlhkZ^baf�bf__l�[he__�bglbfgh_�hlghr_gb_�d fm`_kl\_gghklb��Z fZahobaf�d `_gkl\_gghklb��dZd[m^lh�a^_kv�bf__lky�dZdh_�lh�lZcgh_�jh^kl\h��ohly�y kjZam�`_�^he`_g�\Zf�kdZaZlv��qlh�^Zevr_�\wlhf� \hijhk_�fu� g_� ijh^\bgmebkv��H[Z� hgb�²� kZ^baf� b fZahobaf� ²� y\eyxlky� ^ey� l_hjbbeb[b^h�\_kvfZ�aZ]Z^hqgufb�n_ghf_gZfb��hkh[_ggh�fZahobaf��b \iheg_�\ ihjy^d_�\_s_c��dh]^Zlh��qlh�^ey�h^ghc�l_hjbb�[ueh�dZfg_f�ij_ldgh\_gby��^he`gh�klZlv�^ey�^jm]hc��__ aZf_gyxs_c�djZ_m]hevguf�dZfg_f�BlZd�� fu� kqblZ_f�� qlh� \ kZ^baf_� b fZahobaf_� fu� bf__f� ^\Z� aZf_qZl_evguo� ijbf_jZkebygby�h[hbo�\b^h\�\e_q_gbc��WjhkZ�b Z]j_kkbb��ij_^iheh`bf�`_�l_i_jv��qlh�wlh�hlghr_gb_y\ey_lky� ijbf_jhf� lh]h�� qlh� \k_� bgklbgdlb\gu_� ih[m`^_gby�� dhlhju_� fu� fh`_f� bamqblv�khklhyl�ba�lZdbo�kf_k_c�beb�kieZ\h\�h[hbo�\b^h\�\e_q_gbc��Dhg_qgh��\ kZfuo�jZaghh[jZaguokhhlghr_gbyo�� Ijb� wlhf� wjhlbq_kdb_� \e_q_gby� dZd� [u� \\h^yl� \ kf_kv� fgh]hh[jZab_� k\hbok_dkmZevguo�p_e_c��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�^jm]b_�^himkdZxl�kfy]q_gby�b ]jZ^Zpbb�k\h_c�h^ghh[jZaghcl_g^_gpbb�� Wlbf� ij_^iheh`_gb_f� fu� hldju\Z_f� i_jki_dlb\m� ^ey� bkke_^h\Zgbc�� dhlhju_dh]^Z�gb[m^v� ijbh[j_lml� [hevrh_� agZq_gb_� ^ey� ihgbfZgby� iZlheh]bq_kdbo� ijhp_kkh\��<_^vkf_kb�fh]ml� lh`_�jZkiZ^Zlvky��b lZdhc� jZkiZ^�fh`_l�bf_lv� kZfu_� ly`_eu_�ihke_^kl\by�^eynmgdpbb��Gh�wlb�\a]ey^u�_s_�kebrdhf�gh\u��gbdlh�^h�kbo�ihj�g_�iulZeky�bkihevah\Zlv�bo�\jZ[hl_�<_jg_fky� d hkh[hc� ijh[e_f_�� dhlhjmx� hldju\Z_l� gZf� fZahobaf�� ?keb� fu� gZ� \j_fy� g_[m^_f�ijbgbfZlv�\h�\gbfZgb_�_]h�wjhlbq_kdbc�dhfihg_gl��lh�hg�[m^_l�^ey�gZk�jmqZl_evkl\hfkms_kl\h\Zgby� klj_fe_gby�� bf_xs_]h� p_evx� kZfhjZajmr_gb_�� ?keb� b ^ey� \e_q_gby� djZajmr_gbx� \_jgh� lh�� qlh� Y ²� a^_kv� fu� [hevr_� bf__f� \ \b^m� Hgh�� \kx� ebqghklv� ²i_j\hgZqZevgh�\dexqZ_l�\ k_[y�\k_�bgklbgdlb\gu_�ih[m`^_gby��lh�ihemqZ_lky��qlh�fZahobafklZjr_�kZ^bafZ��kZ^baf�`_� y\ey_lky�gZijZ\e_gguf�\h\g_�\e_q_gb_f�d jZajmr_gbx��dhlhjh_�lZdbf�h[jZahf��ijbh[j_lZ_l�Z]j_kkb\guc�oZjZdl_j��Kdhevdh�lh�hl�i_j\hgZqZevgh]h�\e_q_gby�djZajmr_gbx�hklZ_lky�_s_�\gmljb��dZ`_lky��qlh�fu�fh`_f�_]h�\hkijbgylv�ebrv�ijb�wlbo�^\momkeh\byo�²�_keb�hgh�kh_^bgy_lky�k wjhlbq_kdbfb�\e_q_gbyfb�\ fZahobaf_�beb�_keb�hgh�dZdZ]j_kkby� gZijZ\e_gh� ijhlb\� \g_rg_]h� fbjZ� ²� k [hevrbf� beb� f_gvrbf� wjhlbq_kdbf^h[Z\e_gb_f�� GZijZrb\Z_lky� fukev� h agZqbfhklb� g_\hafh`ghklb� gZclb� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_Z]j_kkbb� \h� \g_rg_f� fbj_�� lZd� dZd� hgZ� gZlZedb\Z_lky� gZ� j_Zevgu_� ij_iylkl\by�� Lh]^Z� hgZ�\hafh`gh��hlklmibl�gZaZ^��m\_ebqb\�kbem�]hkih^kl\mxs_]h�\gmljb�kZfhjZajmr_gby��Fu�_s_m\b^bf��qlh�wlh�ijhbkoh^bl�^_ckl\bl_evgh�lZd�b gZkdhevdh�\Z`_g�wlhl�\hijhk��G_�gZr_^rZy

Page 315: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\uoh^Z� Z]j_kkby� fh`_l� hagZqZlv� ly`_eh_� ih\j_`^_gb_�� \k_� \u]ey^bl� lZd�� dZd� [m^lh� gm`ghjZajmrblv� ^jm]h_� b ^jm]bo�� qlh[u� g_� jZajmrblv� kZfh]h� k_[y�� qlh[u� h]jZ^blv� k_[y� hlklj_fe_gby�d kZfhjZajmr_gbx��Ihbklbg_�i_qZevgh_�hldjulb_�^ey�fhjZebklZ�Gh�fhjZebkl�_s_�^he]h�[m^_l�ml_rZlvky�g_\_jhylghklvx�gZrbo�mfhaZdexq_gbc��KljZggh_klj_fe_gb_� aZgbfZlvky�jZajmr_gb_f� k\h_]h� kh[kl\_ggh]h�hj]Zgbq_kdh]h�h[blZebsZ��IjZ\^Z�ihwlu� ]h\hjyl� h lZdbo� \_sZo�� gh� ihwlu� gZjh^� [_ahl\_lkl\_gguc�� ihevamxsbcky� k\hbfbijb\be_]byfb��Kh[kl\_ggh�]h\hjy��ih^h[gu_�ij_^klZ\e_gby�g_�qm`^u�b nbabheh]bb��gZijbf_j�kebabklZy�h[hehqdZ�`_em^dZ��dhlhjZy�kZfZ�k_[y�i_j_\Zjb\Z_l��Gh�ke_^m_l�ijbagZlv��qlh�gZr_\e_q_gb_�d kZfhjZajmr_gbx�gm`^Z_lky�\ [he__�rbjhdhc�ih^^_j`d_��<_^v�g_evay�`_�j_rblvkygZ� lZdh_� ^Ze_dh� b^ms__� ij_^iheh`_gb_� lhevdh� ihlhfm�� qlh� g_kdhevdh� [_^guo� ]emiph\k\yau\Zxl� k\h_� k_dkmZevgh_� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_� k g_h[uqguf� mkeh\b_f�� Y iheZ]Zx�� qlhm]em[e_ggh_� bamq_gb_� \e_q_gbc� ^Zkl� gZf� lh�� qlh� gm`gh�� <e_q_gby� mijZ\eyxl� g_� lhevdhikbobq_kdhc�� gh� b \_]_lZlb\ghc� `bagvx�� b wlb� hj]Zgbq_kdb_� \e_q_gby� h[gZjm`b\ZxloZjZdl_jgmx� q_jlm�� dhlhjZy� aZkem`b\Z_l� gZr_]h� kZfh]h� ijbklZevgh]h� \gbfZgby�� H lhf�y\ey_lky�eb�wlh�h[sbf�oZjZdl_jhf�\e_q_gbc��fu�kfh`_f�km^blv�ebrv�iha`_��Hgb�\uklmiZxlbf_ggh�dZd�klj_fe_gb_�\hkklZgh\blv�[he__�jZgg__�khklhygb_��Fu�fh`_f�ij_^iheh`blv��qlh�kfhf_glZ��dh]^Z�^hklb]gmlh_�h^gZ`^u�khklhygb_�gZjmrZ_lky��\hagbdZ_l�klj_fe_gb_�kha^Zlv�_]hkgh\Z�� jh`^Zy� n_ghf_gu�� dhlhju_� fu� fh`_f� gZa\Zlv� ©gZ\yaqb\uf� ih\lhj_gb_fª� LZd�h[jZah\Zgb_� b jZa\blb_� wf[jbhgh\� y\ey_lky� kiehrguf� gZ\yaqb\uf� ih\lhj_gb_f�� m jy^Z`b\hlguo� rbjhdh� jZkijhkljZg_gZ� kihkh[ghklv� \hkklZgZ\eb\Zlv� mljZq_ggu_� hj]Zgu�� bbgklbgdl� kZfhe_q_gby�� dhlhjhfm� fu� \kydbc� jZa� h[yaZgu� gZrbf� \ua^hjh\e_gb_f� gZjy^m� kl_jZi_\lbq_kdhc� ihfhsvx�²� wlh�� ^he`gh� [ulv�� hklZlhd� wlhc� lZd� \_ebdhe_igh� jZa\blhckihkh[ghklb� m gbarbo�`b\hlguo��G_j_klh\Zy� fb]jZpby� ju[�� \hafh`gh�� b i_j_e_lu� ilbp�� Zfh`_l� [ulv�� b \k_�� qlh� m `b\hlguo� fu� gZau\Z_f� ijhy\e_gb_f� bgklbgdlZ�� ijhbkoh^bl� ih^^_ckl\b_f� gZ\yaqb\h]h� ih\lhj_gby�� \ dhlhjhf� \ujZ`Z_lky� dhgk_j\Zlb\gZy� ijbjh^Zbgklbgdlh\�� B \� ikbobd_� gZf� g_� ijb^_lky� ^he]h� bkdZlv� ijhy\e_gbc� lh]h� `_� kZfh]h�� Fuh[jZsZeb�\gbfZgb_�gZ�lh��qlh�aZ[ulu_�b \ul_kg_ggu_�i_j_`b\Zgby�jZgg_]h�^_lkl\Z�\h�\j_fyZgZeblbq_kdhc� jZ[hlu� \hkijhba\h^ylky� \ kgh\b^_gbyo� b j_Zdpbyo�� \ qZklghklb� \ j_Zdpbyoi_j_g_k_gby�� ohly� bo� \hajh`^_gb_� b ijhlb\hj_qbl� ijbgpbim� m^h\hevkl\by�� b fu� ^Zebh[tykg_gb_�� qlh� \ wlbo� kemqZyo� gZ\yaqb\h_� ih\lhj_gb_� ij_h[eZ^Z_l� ^Z`_� gZ^� ijbgpbihfm^h\hevkl\by��Ih^h[gh_�fh`gh�gZ[ex^Zlv�b \g_�ZgZebaZ��?klv�ex^b��dhlhju_�\ k\h_c�`bagb[_a�ihijZ\hd�ih\lhjyxl�\k_]^Z�bf_ggh�l_�j_Zdpbb��dhlhju_�bf�\h�\j_^��beb�dhlhjuo��dZ`_lky�ij_ke_^m_l�g_mfhebfZy�km^v[Z��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�[he__�lhqgh_�bkke_^h\Zgb_�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�hgb�kZfb�lh]h�g_� agZy�� ]hlh\yl�k_[_�wlm�km^v[m��Lh]^Z�fu�ijbibku\Z_f�gZ\yaqb\hfm�ih\lhj_gbx^_fhgbq_kdbc oZjZdl_j�Gh� qlh� `_� fh`_l� ^Zlv� wlZ� dhgk_j\Zlb\gZy� q_jlZ� bgklbgdlh\� ^ey� ihgbfZgby� gZr_]hkZfhjZajmr_gby"�DZdh_�[he__�jZgg__� khklhygb_� ohl_e�[u� \hkklZgh\blv� lZdhc�bgklbgdl"�LZd\hl�� hl\_l� [ebahd�� hg� hldju\Z_l�rbjhdb_� i_jki_dlb\u��?keb� ijZ\^Z� lh�� qlh� \ g_aZiZfylgu_\j_f_gZ�b g_ihklb`bfuf�h[jZahf�h^gZ`^u�ba�g_`b\hc�fZl_jbb�jh^beZkv�`bagv��lh�kh]eZkghgZr_fm�ij_^iheh`_gbx�lh]^Z�\hagbdeh�\e_q_gb_��dhlhjh_�klj_fblky�\gh\v�mgbqlh`blv�`bagvb \hkklZgh\blv�g_hj]Zgbq_kdh_�khklhygb_��?keb�fu�\ wlhf�\e_q_gbb�d kZfhjZajmr_gbx�m\b^bfih^l\_j`^_gb_� gZr_c� ]bihl_au�� lh� fu� fh`_f� kqblZlv� _]h� \ujZ`_gb_f� \e_q_gby� d kf_jlb�

Page 316: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

�7RGHVWULHE��� dhlhjh_� g_� fh`_l� g_� hdZau\Zlv� k\h_]h� \ebygby� \ ijhp_kk_� `bagb�� : l_i_jvjZa^_ebf� \e_q_gby�� h dhlhjuo�fu� ]h\hjbf�� gZ� ^\_� ]jmiiu�� wjhlbq_kdbo�� dhlhju_� klj_fylkyijb\_klb� \k_� _s_� `b\mx� km[klZgpbx� \ [hevr__� _^bgkl\h�� b \e_q_gbc� d kf_jlb�� dhlhju_ijhlb\hklhyl� wlhfm� klj_fe_gbx� b ijb\h^yl� `b\h_� d g_hj]Zgbq_kdhfm� khklhygbx�� Ba\aZbfh^_ckl\by�b [hjv[u�h[hbo�b \hagbdZxl�y\e_gby�`bagb��dhlhjuf�kf_jlv�deZ^_l�dhg_p�<hafh`gh�� \u� kdZ`_l_�� ih`bfZy� ie_qZfb�� wlh� g_� _kl_kl\_ggZy� gZmdZ�� wlh� nbehkhnbyRhi_g]ZmwjZ��Gh�ihq_fm��m\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��kf_euc�mf�g_�fh]�m]Z^Zlv�lh��qlh�aZl_fih^l\_j^beh�lj_a\h_�b gm^gh_�^_lZevgh_�bkke_^h\Zgb_"�< lZdhf�kemqZ_�\k_�m`_�dh]^Z�lh�[uehh^gZ`^u�kdZaZgh��b ^h�Rhi_g]ZmwjZ�]h\hjbeb�fgh]h�ihoh`_]h��B aZl_f��lh��qlh�fu�]h\hjbf��g_kh\k_f�Rhi_g]Zmwj��Fu� g_� ml\_j`^Z_f�� qlh� kf_jlv� _klv� _^bgkl\_ggZy� p_ev� `bagb�� fu� g_b]ghjbjm_f�i_j_^�ebphf�kf_jlb�`bagv��Fu�ijbagZ_f�^\Z�hkgh\guo�\e_q_gby�b ijbibku\Z_fdZ`^hfm�_]h�kh[kl\_ggmx�p_ev��DZd�i_j_ie_lZxlky�h[Z�\ `bag_gghf�ijhp_kk_��dZd�\e_q_gb_�dkf_jlb�bkihevam_lky�^ey�p_e_c�WjhkZ��hkh[_ggh�\ _]h�gZijZ\e_gghklb�\h�\g_rgbc�fbj�\ nhjf_Z]j_kkbb�²�\k_�wlh�aZ^Zqb�[m^msbo�bkke_^h\Zgbc��Fu�g_�ihc^_f�^Zevr_�lhc�h[eZklb��]^_�gZfhldjueZkv� wlZ� lhqdZ� aj_gby��LZd`_�b \hijhk��g_� \k_f� eb� [_a�bkdexq_gby� \e_q_gbyf�ijbkmsdhgk_j\Zlb\guc� oZjZdl_j�� g_� klj_fylky� eb� b wjhlbq_kdb_� \e_q_gby� \hkklZgh\blv� ij_`g__khklhygb_�� dh]^Z� hgb� kbgl_abjmxl�`b\h_� ^ey� ^hklb`_gby� khklhygby� [hevr_]h� _^bgkl\Z��fuhklZ\bf�[_a�hl\_lZ�Fu� g_fgh]h� hl^Zebebkv� hl� gZr_c� hkgh\ghc� l_fu��Ohqm� \Zf� ^hihegbl_evgh� khh[sblv�dZdh\� [ue� bkoh^guc� imgdl� wlbo� jZafure_gbc� h l_hjbb� \e_q_gbc�� Lhl� `_� kZfuc�� dhlhjucijb\_e�gZk�d i_j_kfhljm�hlghr_gby�f_`^m�Y b�[_kkhagZl_evguf��Z bf_ggh�\hagbdZ\r__�ijbZgZeblbq_kdhc� jZ[hl_� \i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� iZpb_gl�� hdZau\Zxsbc� khijhlb\e_gb_�� aZqZklmxgbq_]h�g_�agZ_l�h[�wlhf�khijhlb\e_gbb��Gh�[_kkhagZl_evguf�^ey�g_]h�y\ey_lky�g_�lhevdh�nZdlkhijhlb\e_gby��gh�b _]h�fhlb\u��Fu�^he`gu�[ueb�bkke_^h\Zlv�wlb�fhlb\u�beb�wlhl�fhlb\�bgZreb� _]h�� d gZr_fm� m^b\e_gbx�� \ kbevghc� ihlj_[ghklb� \ gZdZaZgbb�� dhlhjmx� fu� fh]ebhlg_klb�lhevdh�d fZahobklkdbf�`_eZgbyf��IjZdlbq_kdh_�agZq_gb_�wlh]h�hldjulby�g_�mklmiZ_ll_hj_lbq_kdhfm�� ihlhfm� qlh� wlZ� ihlj_[ghklv� \ gZdZaZgbb� y\ey_lky� ae_crbf� \jZ]hf� gZrbol_jZi_\lbq_kdbo� mkbebc��HgZ� m^h\e_l\hjy_lky� kljZ^Zgb_f�� k\yaZgguf� k g_\jhahf� b ihwlhfmp_iey_lky�aZ�[he_ag_ggh_�khklhygb_��DZ`_lky��qlh�wlhl�nZdlhj��[_kkhagZl_evgZy�ihlj_[ghklv�\gZdZaZgbb�� mqZkl\m_l� \ dZ`^hf� g_\jhlbq_kdhf� aZ[he_\Zgbb�� Hkh[_ggh� m[_^bl_evgu� \ wlhfhlghr_gbb� kemqZb�� \ dhlhjuo� g_\jhlbq_kdh_� kljZ^Zgb_� fh`_l� [ulv� aZf_g_gh� ^jm]bf��Ohqmijb\_klb�\Zf�h^bg�lZdhc�ijbf_j��H^gZ`^u�fg_�m^Zehkv�hk\h[h^blv�h^gm�g_fheh^mx�^_\m�hldhfie_dkZ�kbfilhfh\��dhlhjuc�\ l_q_gb_�ijbf_jgh�iylgZ^pZlb�e_l�h[j_dZe�__ gZ�fmqbl_evgh_kms_kl\h\Zgb_� b bkdexqZe� ba� mqZklby� \ `bagb��Ihqm\kl\h\Z\� k_[y� a^hjh\hc�� hgZ� k ]heh\hcmreZ� \ [mjgmx� ^_yl_evghklv�� ^Z\Zy� \hex� k\hbf� g_fZeuf� lZeZglZf� b `_eZy� ^h[blvky� ohlvg_[hevrh]h�ijbagZgby��m^h\hevkl\by�b mki_oZ��Gh�dZ`^Zy�ba�__ ihiulhd�dhgqZeZkv�l_f��qlh�_c^Z\Zeb�ihgylv�beb�hgZ�kZfZ�ihgbfZeZ��qlh�kebrdhf�klZjZ�^ey� lh]h��qlh[u�q_]h�lh�^hklbqv�\wlhc�h[eZklb��Ihke_�dZ`^hc�lZdhc�g_m^Zqb�ke_^h\Zeh�[u�h`b^Zlv�j_pb^b\Z�[he_agb��gh�b gZ�wlhhgZ� m`_� [ueZ�g_� kihkh[gZ�� \f_klh� wlh]h� k g_c� dZ`^uc� jZa�ijhbkoh^beb� g_kqZklgu_� kemqZb�dhlhju_� gZ� dZdh_�lh� \j_fy� \u\h^beb� __ ba� kljhy� b aZklZ\eyeb� kljZ^Zlv�� HgZ� iZ^ZeZ� bih^\hjZqb\ZeZ� gh]m� beb� ih\j_`^ZeZ� dhe_gh�� Z _keb� ^_eZeZ� dZdmx�gb[m^v� jZ[hlm�� lh� qlh�lhkemqZehkv� k jmdhc�� dh]^Z� __ \gbfZgb_� [ueh� h[jZs_gh� gZ� __� kh[kl\_ggh_� mqZklb_� \ wlbo

Page 317: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dZ`msboky� kemqZcghklyo�� hgZ� baf_gbeZ�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� k\hx� l_ogbdm�� Ih� lZdbf� `_� ih\h^Zf\f_klh� g_kqZklguo� kemqZ_\� \hagbdZeb� e_]db_� aZ[he_\Zgby�� dZlZju�� Zg]bgu�� ]jbiihagu_khklhygby��j_\fZlbq_kdb_�ijbimoZgby��ihdZ�gZdhg_p�hldZa�hl�^Zevg_crbo�ihiheagh\_gbc��gZdhlhjuc�hgZ�j_rbeZkv��g_�ihdhgqbe�kh�\k_f�wlbf�gZ\Z`^_gb_f�Hlghkbl_evgh�ijhbkoh`^_gby�wlhc�[_kkhagZl_evghc�ihlj_[ghklb�gZdZaZgby��fu�iheZ]Z_f�g_l�gbdZdbo� khfg_gbc��HgZ� \_^_l� k_[y� dZd�qZklv� kh\_klb�� dZd�ijh^he`_gb_�gZr_c� kh\_klb� \[_kkhagZl_evghf�� hgZ� bf__l� lh� `_� ijhbkoh`^_gb_�� qlh� b kh\_klv�� l�� _�� khhl\_lkl\m_l� qZklbZ]j_kkbb��dhlhjZy�mreZ�\h\gmljv�b ijbgylZ�K\_jo�Y��?keb�[u�lhevdh�keh\Z�emqr_�ih^oh^beb^jm]� d ^jm]m�� lh� ^ey� ijZdlbq_kdh]h� mihlj_[e_gby� [ueh� [u� hijZ\^Zggh� gZa\Zlv� __©[_kkhagZl_evguf� qm\kl\hf� \bguª�� H^gZdh� k l_hj_lbq_kdhc� lhqdb� aj_gby� fu� khfg_\Z_fky�ke_^m_l�eb�ij_^iheZ]Zlv��qlh�\ky�\ha\jZs_ggZy�ba�\g_rg_]h�fbjZ�Z]j_kkby�k\yaZgZ�K\_jo�Y bh[jZs_gZ� l_f� kZfuf� ijhlb\� Y beb� qlh� qZklv� __ hkms_kl\ey_l� k\hx� lZcgmx� aeh\_smx^_yl_evghklv�\ Y�b Hgh�dZd�k\h[h^gh_�\e_q_gb_�d jZajmr_gbx�LZdh_� jZa^_e_gb_� [he__� \_jhylgh�� gh� [hevr_�fu� gbq_]h� h[� wlhf� g_� agZ_f��Ijb� i_j\hf\dexq_gbb� K\_jo�Y ^ey� hnhjfe_gby� wlhc� bgklZgpbb�� [_amkeh\gh�� bkihevam_lky� lZ� qZklvZ]j_kkbb� ijhlb\� jh^bl_e_c�� dhlhjhc� j_[_ghd� \ke_^kl\b_�nbdkZpbb� ex[\b�� Z lZd`_� \g_rgboljm^ghkl_c� g_� kfh]� ^Zlv� \uoh^Z� gZjm`m�� b ihwlhfm� kljh]hklv� K\_jo�Y g_� ^he`gZ� ijyfhkhhl\_lkl\h\Zlv� kljh]hklb� \hkiblZgby�� <iheg_� \hafh`gh�� qlh� ^Zevg_crb_� ih\h^u� dih^Z\e_gbx�Z]j_kkbb�ih\_^ml�\e_q_gb_�l_f�`_�iml_f��dhlhjuc�hldjueky�_fm�\ lhl�j_rZxsbcfhf_gl�EbpZ�� m dhlhjuo� wlh� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� qm\kl\h� \bgu� qj_af_jgh�� \u^Zxl� k_[y� ijbZgZeblbq_kdhf� e_q_gbb� klhev� g_ijbylghc� k ijh]ghklbq_kdhc� lhqdb� aj_gby� hljbpZl_evghcj_Zdpb_c�gZ�l_jZibx��?keb�bf�khh[sbeb�h[�hkeZ[e_gbb�kbfilhfZ��aZ�dhlhjuf�h[uqgh�^he`ghihke_^h\Zlv�� ih� djZcg_c� f_j_�� _]h� \j_f_ggh_� bkq_agh\_gb_�� lh� m gbo�� gZijhlb\�� gZklmiZ_lg_f_^e_ggh_�mkbe_gb_�kbfilhfZ�b kljZ^Zgby��QZklh�[u\Z_l�^hklZlhqgh�iho\Zeblv�bo�ih\_^_gb_ijb�e_q_gbb��kdZaZlv�g_kdhevdh�h[gZ^_`b\Zxsbo�keh\�h[�mki_rghklb�ZgZebaZ��qlh[u�\ua\Zlvy\gh_� mom^r_gb_� bo� khklhygby�� G_ZgZeblbd� kdZaZe� [u�� qlh� a^_kv� g_^hklZ_l� ©\heb� d\ua^hjh\e_gbxª�� ijb^_j`b\Zykv� ZgZeblbq_kdh]h� h[jZaZ� fure_gby�� \u� m\b^bl_� \ wlhfijhy\e_gb_� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� qm\kl\Z� \bgu�� dhlhjh_� dZd� jZa� b mkljZb\Z_l� [he_agv� k __kljZ^Zgbyfb� b kju\Zfb��Ijh[e_fu�� dhlhju_� \u^\bgmeh� [_kkhagZl_evgh_� qm\kl\h� \bgu�� _]hhlghr_gby�d fhjZeb��i_^Z]h]bd_��ij_klmighklb�b [_kijbahjghklb�y\eyxlky�\ gZklhys__�\j_fyij_^ihqlbl_evghc�h[eZklvx�^ey�jZ[hlu�ikbohZgZeblbdh\�A^_kv� fu� g_h`b^Zggh� \u[bjZ_fky� ba� ij_bkih^g_c� ikbobdb� \ rbjhdh� hldjuluc� fbj�>Zevr_�\_klb�\Zk�y g_�fh]m��gh�gZ�h^ghc�fukeb�\k_�`_� aZ^_j`mkv��ij_`^_�q_f�ijhklblvky�k\Zfb� gZ� wlhl� jZa��M gZk� \hreh� \ ijb\uqdm� ]h\hjblv�� qlh� gZrZ� dmevlmjZ� ihkljh_gZ� aZ� kq_lk_dkmZevguo�\e_q_gbc��dhlhju_�k^_j`b\Zxlky�h[s_kl\hf��qZklbqgh�\ul_kgyxlky��Z qZklbqghbkihevamxlky�^ey�gh\uo�p_e_c��>Z`_�ijb�\k_c�]hj^hklb�aZ�gZrb�dmevlmjgu_�^hklb`_gby�fuijbagZ_f��qlh�gZf�g_e_]dh�\uihegylv� lj_[h\Zgby� wlhc�dmevlmju��ohjhrh�qm\kl\h\Zlv� k_[y�\g_c�� ihlhfm� qlh� gZeh`_ggu_� gZ� gZrb� \e_q_gby� h]jZgbq_gby� ly`dbf� [j_f_g_f� eh`Zlky� gZikbobdm��B \hl�lh��qlh�fu�magZeb�hlghkbl_evgh�k_dkmZevguo�\e_q_gbc��\ jZ\ghc�f_j_��Z fh`_l[ulv�� ^Z`_� b \� [hevr_c� kl_i_gb� �hdZau\Z_lky� ^_ckl\bl_evguf� ^ey� ^jm]bo�� Z]j_kkb\guo

Page 318: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

klj_fe_gbc�� Hgb� \uklmiZxl� ij_`^_� \k_]h� l_f�� qlh� hkeh`gy_l� kh\f_klgmx� `bagv� ex^_c� bm]jh`Z_l� __ ijh^he`_gbx�� h]jZgbq_gb_� k\h_c� Z]j_kkbb� y\ey_lky� i_j\hc�� \hafh`gh�� kZfhck_jv_aghc� `_jl\hc�� dhlhjmx� h[s_kl\h� lj_[m_l� hl� bg^b\b^mmfZ�� Fu� magZeb�� dZdbfbah[j_lZl_evguf� kihkh[hf� hkms_kl\ey_lky� wlh� mdjhs_gb_� kljhilb\h]h��< ^_ckl\b_� \klmiZ_lK\_jo�Y�� dhlhjh_� h\eZ^_\Z_l� Z]j_kkb\gufb� ih[m`^_gbyfb�� dZd� [u� \\h^y� hddmiZpbhggu_\hckdZ� \ ]hjh^�� ]hlh\uc� d fyl_`m�� Gh�� k ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� jZkkfZljb\Zy� \hijhk� qbklhikboheh]bq_kdb��ke_^m_l�ijbagZlv��qlh�Y qm\kl\m_l�k_[y�g_�hq_gv�lh�ohjhrh��dh]^Z�_]h�lZdbfh[jZahf� ijbghkyl� \ `_jl\m� ihlj_[ghklyf� h[s_kl\Z� b hgh� \ugm`^_gh� ih^qbgylvkyjZajmrbl_evguf�gZf_j_gbyf�Z]j_kkbb��dhlhjmx�kZfh�hohlgh�imklbeh�[u�\ oh^�ijhlb\�^jm]bo�Wlh�dZd�[u�jZkijhkljZg_gb_�gZ�h[eZklv�ikbobq_kdh]h�lhc�^be_ffu�²�eb[h�kt_rv�kZf��eb[hkt_^yl� l_[y�²�dhlhjZy�pZjbl�\ hj]Zgbq_kdhf�`b\hf�fbj_��D kqZklvx�� Z]j_kkb\gu_� \e_q_gbygbdh]^Z�g_�kms_kl\mxl�kZfb�ih�k_[_��gh�\k_]^Z�khijy`_gu�k wjhlbq_kdbfb��Wlb�ihke_^gb_�\mkeh\byo�kha^Zgghc�q_eh\_dhf�dmevlmju�fh]ml�fgh]h_�kfy]qblv�b ij_^hl\jZlblv�LJB>P:LV�LJ?LVY�E?DPBY@_gkl\_gghklvM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��<k_�wlh�\j_fy��ihdZ�y ]hlh\beky�d [_k_^Zf�k \Zfb��y [hjheky�k\gmlj_ggbf� aZljm^g_gb_f�� Y qm\kl\h\Ze� k_[y� \ g_dhlhjhc� kl_i_gb� g_m\_j_gguf� \ k\h_cijZ\hl_��>_ckl\bl_evgh�� aZ�iylgZ^pZlv� e_l�ikbohZgZeba�baf_gbeky�b h[h]Zlbeky��gh� \k_�lZdb\\_^_gb_� \ ikbohZgZeba� fh]eh� [u� hklZlvky� [_a� baf_g_gbc� b ^hiheg_gbc�� Fg_� \k_� \j_fydZ`_lky��qlh�^Zggu_�e_dpbb�g_�bf_xl�ijZ\Z�gZ�kms_kl\h\Zgb_��:gZeblbdZf�y ]h\hjx�kebrdhffZeh�b \�h[s_f�gbq_]h�gh\h]h��\Zf�`_�kebrdhf�fgh]h�b h�lZdbo�\_sZo��d ihgbfZgbx�dhlhjuo\u�g_�ih^]hlh\e_gu�b dhlhju_�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�d \Zf�g_�hlghkylky��Y bkdZe�hijZ\^Zgbc�b ^eydZ`^hc�hl^_evghc�e_dpbb�ohl_e�gZclb�k\h_�h[hkgh\Zgb_��I_j\Zy��h l_hjbb�kgh\b^_gbc��^he`gZ[ueZ� kjZam� ih]jmablv� \Zk� \ kZfmx� ]msm� ZgZeblbq_kdhc� Zlfhkn_ju� b ihdZaZlv�� dZdbfbmklhcqb\ufb�hdZaZebkv�gZrb�\haaj_gby��<h�\lhjhc��dhlhjZy�ijhke_`b\Z_l�imlb�hl�kgh\b^_gbyd lZd� gZau\Z_fhfm� hddmevlbafm�� f_gy� ijb\e_dZeZ� \hafh`ghklv� k\h[h^gh� \ukdZaZlvky� \ lhch[eZklb�� ]^_� m[_`^_gby�� ihegu_� ij_^jZkkm^dh\�� gZlZedb\Zxlky� k_]h^gy� gZ� kljZklgh_khijhlb\e_gb_�� b y� kf_e� gZ^_ylvky�� qlh� \u�� \hkiblZggu_� gZ� ijbf_j_� ikbohZgZebaZ� \ ^mo_l_jibfhklb�� g_� hldZ`_l_kv� khijh\h`^Zlv� f_gy� \ wlhf� wdkdmjk_�� < lj_lv_c� e_dpbb���� hjZa^_e_gbb� ebqghklb�� [ueb� \u^\bgmlu�� [_amkeh\gh�� kZfu_� j_adb_� ^ey� \Zk� �gZklhevdhk\h_h[jZagh�bo�kh^_j`Zgb_��ij_^iheh`_gby��gh�y kq_e�g_\hafh`guf�kdjulv�hl�\Zk�wlhl�i_j\ucih^oh^�d ikboheh]bb�Y��b _keb�[u�fu�bf_eb�_]h�iylgZ^pZlv�e_l�gZaZ^��y ^he`_g�[ue�[u�m`_lh]^Z�mihfygmlv�h g_f��B gZdhg_p��\ ihke_^g_c�e_dpbb��gZ�dhlhjhc�\u��\_jhylgh��ke_^beb� aZfghc�k [hevrbf�ljm^hf��[ueb�\g_k_gu�g_h[oh^bfu_�ihijZ\db��k^_eZgZ�ihiuldZ�^Zlv�gh\u_j_r_gby�kZfuo�\Z`guo�aZ]Z^hd��b fh_�\\_^_gb_�[ueh�[u�\\_^_gb_f�\ aZ[em`^_gby��_keb�[u�ymfheqZe� h[� wlhf�� DZd� \b^bl_�� _keb� ij_^ijbgbfZ_rv� ihiuldm� ba\bgblvky� aZ� qlh�lh�� wlhk\h^blky�\ dhgp_�dhgph\�d ijbagZgbx�lh]h��qlh�\k_�[ueh�g_ba[_`gh��\k_�ij_^hij_^_e_gh�Y ihdhjyxkv��ijhrm�b \Zk�k^_eZlv�lh�`_�kZfh_�

Page 319: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

K_]h^gyrgyy� e_dpby� lh`_� fh]eZ� [u� g_� \hclb� \h� \\_^_gb_�� gh� hgZ� ^Zkl� \Zf� ijbf_jih^jh[ghc� ZgZeblbq_kdhc�jZ[hlu��b y�j_dhf_g^mx� __ \�^\mo�hlghr_gbyo��< g_c�g_l�gbq_]h�djhf_�gZ[ex^_gbc�nZdlh\�ihqlb�[_a�\kydbo�mfhaZdexq_gbc��gh�__ l_fZ�fh`_l�aZbgl_j_kh\Zlv\Zk��dZd�gbdZdZy�^jm]Zy��GZ^ aZ]Z^dhc�`_gkl\_gghklb�fgh]h�fm^jbeh�]heh\ \k_o�\j_f_g�=heh\�\ dheiZdZo�k b_jh]ebnZfb��=heh\�\ qZefZo�b q_jguo��k i_jvyfb��rZidZo��=heh\�\ iZjbdZo�b lukyqb�lukyq�^jm]bo�=heh\�q_eh\_q_kdbo��`Zedbo��[_kkbevguo����= =_cg_��K_\_jgh_�fhj_� I_j_\h^�FFboZceh\Z�<Zf� lh`_� g_� qm`^u� wlb� jZafure_gby�� ihkdhevdm� fu� fm`qbgu�� hl� `_gsbg� `_�ijbkmlkl\mxsbo� kj_^b� \Zk�� wlh]h� `^Zlv� g_� ijboh^blky�� hgb� kZfb� y\eyxlky� wlhc� aZ]Z^dhc�Fm`qbgZ�beb�`_gsbgZ�²�\hl�i_j\h_��qlh�\u�jZaebqZ_l_��\klj_qZykv�k ^jm]bf�q_eh\_q_kdbfkms_kl\hf�� b ijb\uqgh� ^_eZ_l_� wlh� k m\_j_gghklvx� b [_a� jZa^mfbc�� :gZlhfbq_kdZy� gZmdZjZa^_ey_l�\Zrm�m\_j_gghklv�ebrv�\ h^ghf�imgdl_��Fm`kdh_�²�wlh�fm`kdhc�iheh\hc�ijh^mdl�ki_jfZlhahb^�b _]h�ghkbl_ev��`_gkdh_�²�ycph�b hj]Zgbaf��dhlhjuc� aZdexqZ_l� _]h�\ k_[_��Mh[hbo�iheh\�h[jZah\Zebkv�hj]Zgu��kem`Zsb_�bkdexqbl_evgh�iheh\uf�nmgdpbyf��jZa\b\rb_ky�\_jhylgh��ba�h^gh]h�b lh]h�`_�ij_^jZkiheh`_gby�\ ^\_�jZaebqgu_�nhjfu��Djhf_�lh]h��m l_o�b^jm]bo�ijhqb_�hj]Zgu��nhjfZ�l_eZ�b ldZg_c�h[gZjm`b\Zxl�\ebygb_�iheZ��gh�hgh�g_ihklhyggh��b_]h� fZkrlZ[� baf_gqb\�� wlh� lZd� gZau\Z_fu_� \lhjbqgu_� iheh\u_� ijbagZdb�� : ^Ze__� gZmdZ]h\hjbl� \Zf� g_qlh�� qlh� ijhlb\hj_qbl� \Zrbf� h`b^Zgbyf� b qlh�� \_jhylgh�� kihkh[gh� kfmlblv\Zrb�qm\kl\Z��HgZ�h[jZsZ_l�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�lh��qlh�b \�l_e_�`_gsbgu�ijbkmlkl\mxl�qZklbfm`kdh]h�iheh\h]h�ZiiZjZlZ��ohly�b \�jm^bf_glZjghf�khklhygbb��b lh�`_�kZfh_�bf__l�f_klh�\h[jZlghf�kemqZ_��HgZ�\b^bl�\ wlhf�y\e_gbb�ijbagZd�^\mihehklb��[bk_dkmZevghklb�dZd�[m^lhbg^b\b^mmf�y\ey_lky�g_�fm`qbghc�beb�`_gsbghc��Z \kydbc�jZa�b l_f�b ^jm]bf��lhevdh�h^gbf�\[hevr_c�kl_i_gb��Z ^jm]bf�\ f_gvr_c�AZl_f� \Zf� ijb^_lky� hk\hblvky� k fukevx�� qlh� khhlghr_gb_� fm`kdh]h� b `_gkdh]h�khq_lZxs_]hky�\ hl^_evghf�bg^b\b^mmf_��ih^\_j`_gh� \_kvfZ� agZqbl_evguf� dhe_[Zgbyf��Ghihkdhevdm��g_kfhljy�gZ�\_kvfZ�j_^db_�kemqZb��m dZ`^h]h�bg^b\b^mmfZ�gZebq_kl\mxl�eb[h�l_�eb[h� ^jm]b_� iheh\u_� ijh^mdlu� ²� ycp_de_ldb� beb� ki_jfZlhahb^u�²� \u�� ^he`gh� [ulv�mkhfgbl_kv� \ j_rZxs_f� agZq_gbb� wlbo� we_f_glh\� b k^_eZ_l_� \u\h^�� qlh� lh�� ba� q_]hkhklZ\ey_lky�fm`_kl\_gghklv�beb�`_gkl\_gghklv�� g_ba\_klgh]h� oZjZdl_jZ�� dhlhjuc� ZgZlhfbyg_�fh`_l�jZkihagZlv�Fh`_l� [ulv�� wlh� kmf__l� k^_eZlv� ikboheh]by"�Fu� ijb\udeb� jZkkfZljb\Zlv� fm`kdh_� b`_gkdh_�b dZd�ikbobq_kdb_�dZq_kl\Z��i_j_ghky�ihgylb_�[bk_dkmZevghklb�lZd`_�b \�^mr_\gmx`bagv��LZdbf�h[jZahf��fu�]h\hjbf��qlh�q_eh\_d��[m^mqb�kZfphf�beb�kZfdhc��\ h^ghf�kemqZ_\_^_l�k_[y�ih�fm`kdb��Z \�^jm]hf�²�ih�`_gkdb��Gh�\u�kdhjh�ihcf_l_��qlh�wlh�ebrv�mklmidZZgZlhfbb� b mkeh\ghklyf�� <u� g_� kfh`_l_� ^Zlv� ihgylbyf� ©fm`kdh_ª� b ©`_gkdh_ª� gbdZdh]hgh\h]h� kh^_j`Zgby��Wlh� g_� ikboheh]bq_kdh_� jZaebqb_�� dh]^Z� \u� ]h\hjbl_�� qlh�fm`kdh_�� dZdijZ\beh�� ij_^iheZ]Z_l� ©Zdlb\gh_ª�� Z `_gkdh_� ²� ©iZkkb\gh_ª�� IjZ\bevgh�� lZdZy� k\yav^_ckl\bl_evgh�kms_kl\m_l��Fm`kdZy�iheh\Zy�de_ldZ�Zdlb\gh�^\b`_lky��hlukdb\Z_l�`_gkdmx��Z

Page 320: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ihke_^gyy�� ycph�� g_ih^\b`gh�� iZkkb\gh� `^_l�� Wlh� ih\_^_gb_� we_f_glZjguo� iheh\uohj]Zgbafh\� ²� h[jZa_p� ih\_^_gby� iheh\uo� iZjlg_jh\� ijb� iheh\uo� kghr_gbyo�� KZf_pij_ke_^m_l� kZfdm� k p_evx� kh\hdmie_gby�� gZiZ^Z_l� gZ� g__�� ijhgbdZ_l� \ g__�� Gh� bf_gghikboheh]bq_kdb� \u�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� k\_eb� hkh[_gghklb� fm`kdh]h� d nZdlhjm� Z]j_kkbb�� <u[m^_l_�khfg_\Zlvky��m^Zehkv�eb�\Zf�l_f�kZfuf�meh\blv�qlh�lh�kms_kl\_ggh_��_keb�ijbf_l_�\h\gbfZgb_� lh�� qlh� \ g_dhlhjuo� deZkkZ� `b\hlguo� kZfdb� y\eyxlky� [he__� kbevgufb� bZ]j_kkb\gufb��kZfpu�`_�Zdlb\gu�lhevdh�ijb�Zdl_�kh\hdmie_gby��LZd�ijhbkoh^bl��gZijbf_j��miZmdh\�� b nmgdpbb� \ukb`b\Zgby� b \ujZsb\Zgby� ihlhfkl\Z�� dZ`msb_ky� gZf� lZdbfbbkdexqbl_evgh� `_gkdbfb�� m `b\hlguo� g_� \k_]^Z� k\yaZgu� k `_gkdbf� ihehf�� M \_kvfZ\ukhdhjZa\bluo�\b^h\�fu�gZ[ex^Z_f�mqZklb_�h[hbo�iheh\�\ moh^_�aZ�ihlhfkl\hf�beb�^Z`_�lh�qlh� kZf_p� h^bg� ihk\ysZ_l� k_[y� wlhc� aZ^Zq_�� ^Z� b \� h[eZklb� k_dkmZevghc� `bagb� q_eh\_dZg_ljm^gh�aZf_lblv��gZkdhevdh�g_^hklZlhqgh�oZjZdl_jbah\Zlv�fm`kdh_�ih\_^_gb_�Zdlb\ghklvx�Z `_gkdh_�iZkkb\ghklvx��FZlv�\ ex[hf�kfuke_�Zdlb\gZ�ih�hlghr_gbx�d j_[_gdm��^Z`_�h[�Zdl_khkZgby�\u�fh`_l_�k h^bgZdh\uf�mki_ohf�kdZaZlv��hgZ�dhjfbl�j_[_gdZ� ]jm^vx�beb�hgZ�^Z_lj_[_gdm� khkZlv� k\hx� ]jm^v�� Q_f� ^Ze__� aZl_f� \u� \uc^_l_� aZ� ]jZgbpu� madhc� h[eZklbk_dkmZevgh]h�� l_f� ykg__� ijhy\blky� ©hrb[dZ� gZeh`_gbyª��@_gsbgu� \ khklhygbb� jZa\b\Zlv[hevrmx� Zdlb\ghklv� \ jZaguo� gZijZ\e_gbyo�� fm`qbgu� g_� fh]ml� `blv� \f_kl_� k k_[_ih^h[gufb��_keb�m gbo�g_�jZa\blZ�\ \ukhdhc�kl_i_gb�iZkkb\gZy�mklmiqb\hklv��?keb�\u�l_i_jvkdZ`_l_��qlh�wlb�nZdlu�dZd�jZa�^hdZau\Zxl��qlh�fm`qbgu��dZd�b `_gsbgu��\ ikboheh]bq_kdhfkfuke_� [bk_dkmZevgu�� lh� hlkx^Z� y k^_eZx� \u\h^�� qlh� ijh� k_[y� \u� j_rbeb� ijbagZlvkhhl\_lkl\b_�©Zdlb\gh]hª�©fm`kdhfmª��Z ©iZkkb\gh]hª�©`_gkdhfmª��Gh�^_eZlv�wlh]h�y \Zf�g_kh\_lmx��Fg_� dZ`_lky� wlh�g_p_e_khh[jZaguf�b g_� ^Zxsbf�gbq_]h�gh\h]h� \ ihagZ\Zl_evghfhlghr_gbb�Fh`gh� [ueh� [u� ihiulZlvky� hoZjZdl_jbah\Zlv� `_gkl\_gghklv� ikboheh]bq_kdb� dZdij_^ihql_gb_�iZkkb\guo�p_e_c��Wlh��dhg_qgh��g_�lh�`_�kZfh_��qlh�iZkkb\ghklv��^ey�lh]h�qlh[uhkms_kl\blv� iZkkb\gmx� p_ev�� fh`_l� ihgZ^h[blvky� [hevrZy� aZljZlZ� Zdlb\ghklb�� <hafh`gh�^_eh� h[klhbl� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� qlh� m `_gsbgu� ijb� \uiheg_gbb� __ k_dkmZevghc� nmgdpbbij_h[eZ^Zgb_�iZkkb\gh]h�ih\_^_gby�b iZkkb\guo�p_e_mklj_fe_gbc�qZklbqgh�jZkijhkljZgy_lkyg_kdhevdh�^Zevr_�\ `bagv��[he__�beb�f_g__�^Ze_dh��\ aZ\bkbfhklb�hl�lh]h��gZkdhevdh�]jZgbpuk_dkmZevghc�`bagb� km`_gu�beb� jZkrbj_gu��Gh�ijb� wlhf�fu� ^he`gu� h[jZlblv� \gbfZgb_�gZg_^himklbfhklv�g_^hhp_gdb�\ebygby�khpbZevguo�mklh_\��dhlhju_�dZd�[u�aZ]hgyxl�`_gsbgm�\kblmZpbb�iZkkb\ghklb��<k_� wlh� _s_� g_� kh\k_f� ykgh��H^gZdh�g_� [m^_f� aZ[u\Zlv� h[� hkh[_gghijhqghc� k\yab� f_`^m� `_gkl\_gghklvx� b iheh\hc� `bagvx�� Ij_^ibkZggh_� `_gsbg_dhgklblmpbhgZevgh� b gZeZ]Z_fh_� gZ� g__� khpbZevgh� ih^Z\e_gb_� k\h_c� Z]j_kkbb� kihkh[kl\m_lh[jZah\Zgbx� kbevguo� fZahobklkdbo� ih[m`^_gbc�� dhlhjuf� \k_�lZdb� m^Z_lky� wjhlbq_kdbih^Z\blv� gZijZ\e_ggu_� \gmljv� jZajmrbl_evgu_� l_g^_gpbb��BlZd��fZahobaf�� qlh� gZau\Z_lky�ihbklbg_�`_gkdh_�ba\jZs_gb_��Gh�_keb�\u�\klj_lbl_�fZahobaf�m fm`qbg��qlh�[u\Z_l�^h\hevghqZklh�� lh� qlh� `_� hklZ_lky� kdZaZlv�� djhf_� lh]h�� qlh� wlbf� fm`qbgZf� k\hckl\_ggu� \_kvfZhlq_leb\u_�`_gkdb_�q_jlu"<hl� \u� m`_� b ih^]hlh\e_gu� d lhfm�� qlh� b ikboheh]by� g_� j_rbl� lZcgu�`_gkl\_gghklb�JZatykg_gb_�wlh]h�\hijhkZ�^he`gh�ijbclb��\b^bfh��ba�dZdh]h�lh�^jm]h]h�bklhqgbdZ��b hgh�g_ijb^_l�^h� l_o�ihj��ihdZ�fu�g_�magZ_f��dZd�\hh[s_� \hagbdeh�^_e_gb_�`b\uo� kms_kl\�gZ�^\Z

Page 321: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

iheZ��Fu�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_f�h[�wlhf��Z \_^v�^\mihehklv�y\ey_lky�lZdbf�hlq_leb\uf�ijbagZdhfhj]Zgbq_kdhc�`bagb��dhlhjuf�hgZ�klhev�j_adh�hlebqZ_lky�hl�g_`b\hc�ijbjh^u��: f_`^m�l_fq_eh\_q_kdb_� bg^b\b^mmfu�� dhlhju_� [eZ]h^Zjy� gZebqbx� `_gkdbo� iheh\uo� hj]Zgh\oZjZdl_jbamxlky� dZd� y\gh� beb� ij_bfms_kl\_ggh� `_gkdb_�� ^Zxl� g_fZeh� fZl_jbZeZ� ^eybkke_^h\Zgby��< khhl\_lkl\bb� kh� k\h_c� ki_pbnbdhc� ikbohZgZeba� g_� gZf_j_g� hibku\Zlv�� qlhlZdh_�`_gsbgZ�²�wlh�[ueh�[u�^ey�g_]h�_^\Z�eb�jZaj_rbfhc�aZ^Zq_c�²�Z hg�bkke_^m_l��dZd�hgZ_x�klZgh\blky��dZd�jZa\b\Z_lky�`_gsbgZ�ba�ij_^jZkiheh`_ggh]h�d [bk_dkmZevghklb�j_[_gdZ��AZihke_^g__� \j_fy� fu� dh_�qlh� magZeb� h[� wlhf� [eZ]h^Zjy� lhfm� h[klhyl_evkl\m�� qlh� g_kdhevdhaZf_qZl_evguo� `_gsbg� ²� gZrbo� dhee_]� ih� ikbohZgZebam� ²� gZqZeb� jZajZ[Zlu\Zlv� wlmijh[e_fm�� >bkdmkkby� h[� wlhf� ijbh[j_eZ� hkh[mx� ijb\e_dZl_evghklv� ba�aZ� jZaebqby� iheh\�ihlhfm�qlh�dZ`^uc�jZa��dh]^Z�kjZ\g_gb_�hdZau\Zehkv�dZd�[m^lh�[u�g_�\ ihevam�bo�iheZ��gZrb^Zfu� ih^haj_\Zeb� gZk�� ZgZeblbdh\�fm`qbg�� \ lhf�� qlh� fu�� g_� ij_h^he_\� hij_^_e_gguo�]em[hdh� mdhj_gb\rboky� ij_^m[_`^_gbc� ijhlb\� `_gkl\_gghklb�� [ueb� ijbkljZklgu� \ k\hbobkke_^h\Zgbyo�� GZ� ihq\_� [bk_dkmZevghklb� gZf�� gZijhlb\�� [ueh� e_]dh� ba[_`Zlv� ex[hcg_\_`eb\hklb��Gm`gh�[ueh�lhevdh�kdZaZlv��wlh�d \Zf�g_�hlghkblky��<u�²�bkdexq_gb_��gZ�wlhljZa�\ \Zk�[hevr_�fm`kdh]h��q_f�`_gkdh]h�< k\hbo� bkke_^h\Zgbyo� jZa\blby� `_gkdhc� k_dkmZevghklb� fu� lh`_� hibjZ_fky� gZ� ^\Zij_^iheh`_gby�� i_j\h_� aZdexqZ_lky� \ lhf�� qlh� b a^_kv� dhgklblmpby� g_� [_a� khijhlb\e_gbyih^qbgy_lky� nmgdpbb�� <lhjh_� ]eZkbl�� qlh� j_rZxsb_� i_j_f_gu� ih^]hlZ\eb\Zxlky� bebkh\_jrZxlky� m`_� ^h� gZklmie_gby� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb�� H[Z� ij_^iheh`_gby� g_ljm^ghih^l\_j^blv��AZl_f�kjZ\g_gb_�k jZa\blb_f�fZevqbdZ�]h\hjbl�gZf��qlh�ij_\jZs_gb_�fZe_gvdhc^_\hqdb�\ ghjfZevgmx�`_gsbgm�ijhbkoh^bl�ljm^g__�b keh`g__��ihkdhevdm�hgh�\dexqZ_l�\ k_[ygZ�^\_� aZ^Zqb�[hevr_��b wlbf� aZ^ZqZf�g_l�khhl\_lkl\by�\ jZa\blbb�fm`qbgu��Ijhke_^bf�wlmiZjZee_ev�k kZfh]h�gZqZeZ��Dhg_qgh��kZfZ�fZl_jbZevgZy�[ZaZ�m fZevqbdZ�b m�^_\hqdb�jZaebqgZ�qlh[u� wlh� mklZgh\blv�� g_� gm`gh�gbdZdh]h�ikbohZgZebaZ�� JZaebqb_� \ nhjfbjh\Zgbb� iheh\uohj]Zgh\�khijh\h`^Z_lky�^jm]bfb�nbabq_kdbfb�hlebqbyfb��dhlhju_�kebrdhf�ohjhrh�ba\_klgu�qlh[u�h gbo�]h\hjblv��< kljmdlmj_�kdehgghkl_c�lh`_�ijhy\eyxlky�^bnn_j_gpbZpbb��dhlhju_iha\heyxl� ihqm\kl\h\Zlv� [m^msmx� kmsghklv� `_gsbgu�� FZe_gvdZy� ^_\hqdZ�� dZd� ijZ\beh�f_g__� Z]j_kkb\gZ�� mijyfZ� b w]hp_gljbqgZ�� < g_c�� ih�\b^bfhfm�� [hevr_� ihlj_[ghklb� \g_`ghklb��ihwlhfm�hgZ�[he__�aZ\bkbfZ�b ihkemrgZ��Lh��qlh�__ e_]q_�b [uklj__�fh`gh�gZmqblvmijZ\eylv� k\hbfb� wdkdj_lhjgufb� nmgdpbyfb�� \_jhylgh�� _klv� ebrv� ke_^kl\b_� wlhcihkemrghklb�� fhqZ� b klme� y\eyxlky� i_j\ufb� ih^ZjdZfb�� dhlhju_� j_[_ghd� ^_eZ_lmoZ`b\Zxsbf�aZ�gbf�ebpZf��Z mijZ\e_gb_�bfb�²�i_j\hc�mklmidhc��gZ�dhlhjmx�\ugm`^_gghb^_l� bgklbgdlb\gZy� `bagv� j_[_gdZ�� Kha^Z_lky� \i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� fZe_gvdZy� ^_\hqdZbgl_eeb]_glg__��`b\__�fZevqbdZ�l_o�`_�e_l��hgZ�[hevr_�b^_l�gZ\klj_qm�\g_rg_fm�fbjm��\ lh`_� \j_fy� m g__� [he__� kbevgZy� ijb\yaZgghklv� d h[t_dlZf�� G_� agZx�� ih^l\_j`^Z_lky� eb� wlhhi_j_`_gb_� jZa\blby� lhqgufb� ^Zggufb�� \h� \kydhf� kemqZ_� mklZgh\e_gh�� qlh� ^_\hqdm� g_evaygZa\Zlv�bgl_ee_dlmZevgh�hlklZehc��Gh�wlb�iheh\u_�jZaebqby�fh`gh�g_�ijbgbfZlv�\h�\gbfZgb_�hgb� fh]ml� [ulv� mjZ\gh\_r_gu� bg^b\b^mZevgufb� \ZjbZpbyfb�� >ey� p_e_c�� dhlhju_� fu� \gZklhysbc�fhf_gl�ij_ke_^m_f��bfb�fh`gh�ij_g_[j_qv�JZggb_�nZau�jZa\blby�eb[b^h�h[Z�iheZ�ijhoh^yl��ih�\b^bfhfm��h^bgZdh\h��Fh`gh�[ueh[u�h`b^Zlv��qlh�m ^_\hq_d�m`_�\ kZ^bklkdh�ZgZevghc�nZa_�ijhy\ey_lky�hlklZ\Zgb_�\ Z]j_kkbb�

Page 322: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gh� wlh�g_� lZd��:gZeba�^_lkdhc�b]ju�ihdZaZe�gZrbf�`_gsbgZf�ZgZeblbdZf�� qlh� Z]j_kkb\gu_bfimevku�m fZe_gvdbo�^_\hq_d�ih�jZaghh[jZabx�b bgl_gkb\ghklb�jZa\blu�dZd�g_evay�emqr_�Kh�\klmie_gb_f�\ nZeebq_kdmx�nZam�jZaebqby�iheh\�iheghklvx�hlklmiZxl�gZ�aZ^gbc�ieZg��bfu�^he`gu�ijbagZlv��qlh�fZe_gvdZy�^_\hqdZ�²�wlh�dZd�[u�fZe_gvdbc�fm`qbgZ��M fZevqbdh\wlZ� nZaZ�� dZd� ba\_klgh�� oZjZdl_jbam_lky� l_f�� qlh� hg� mf__l� ^hklZ\eylv� k_[_� gZkeZ`^_gb_� kihfhsvx� k\h_]h� fZe_gvdh]h� i_gbkZ�� k\yau\Zy� _]h� \ha[m`^_ggh_� khklhygb_� kh� k\hbfbij_^klZ\e_gbyfb� h iheh\uo� kghr_gbyo�� Lh� `_� kZfh_� ^_eZ_l� ^_\hqdZ� kh� k\hbf� _s_� [he__fZe_gvdbf� deblhjhf�� DZ`_lky�� qlh� \k_� hgZgbklbq_kdb_� Zdlu� ijhbkoh^yl� m g__� k wlbfwd\b\Ze_glhf� i_gbkZ�� Z kh[kl\_ggh�`_gkdh_� \eZ]Zebs_� hklZ_lky� _s_� g_hldjuluf� ^ey� h[hboiheh\��IjZ\^Z��_klv�hl^_evgu_�k\b^_l_evkl\Z�h jZggbo�\Z]bgZevguo�hsms_gbyo��gh�bo�ljm^ghhlebqblv�hl�ZgZevguo�beb�hl�hsms_gbc�ij_^^\_jby�\eZ]ZebsZ��hgb�gb \�dZdhf�hlghr_gbb�g_fh]ml� b]jZlv� [hevrhc� jheb��Fu� kf__f� gZklZb\Zlv� gZ� lhf�� qlh� \ nZeebq_kdhc�nZa_� ^_\hqdb\_^ms_c�wjh]_gghc�ahghc�y\ey_lky�deblhj��Gh�\_^v�lZd�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�\k_]^Z��k i_j_oh^hf�d`_gkl\_gghklb� deblhj� kh\k_f� beb� qZklbqgh� mklmiZ_l� \eZ]Zebsm� k\hx� qm\kl\bl_evghklv�� Zke_^h\Zl_evgh��b agZq_gb_��B wlh�h^gZ�ba�^\mo�ijh[e_f��dhlhju_�ij_^klhbl�j_rZlv�`_gkdhfmjZa\blbx�� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd� [he__� kqZkleb\uc� fm`qbgZ� dh� \j_f_gb� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb� ^he`_glhevdh� ijh^he`Zlv� lh�� q_fm� hg� ij_^\Zjbl_evgh� gZmqbeky� \ i_jbh^� jZgg_]h� k_dkmZevgh]hkhaj_\Zgby�Fu� _s_�\_jg_fky�d jheb�deblhjZ��h[jZlbfky� l_i_jv�dh�\lhjhc�ijh[e_f_��dhlhjZy� klhbli_j_^�jZa\blb_f�^_\hqdb��I_j\uf�h[t_dlhf�ex[\b�fZevqbdZ� y\ey_lky�fZlv�� hgZ� hklZ_lky�bflZd`_� b ijb�nhjfbjh\Zgbb�W^bih\Z� dhfie_dkZ�� ih� kmlb�� gZ� ijhly`_gbb� \k_c�`bagb��B ^ey^_\hqdb�fZlv��Z \f_kl_�k g_c�b h[jZau�dhjfbebpu��gygb�lh`_�y\eyxlky�i_j\uf�h[t_dlhf��\_^vi_j\u_�ijb\yaZgghklb�d h[t_dlZf�k\yaZgu�k m^h\e_l\hj_gb_f�\Z`guo�b ijhkluo�`bag_gguoihlj_[ghkl_c��Z mkeh\by�moh^Z�aZ�j_[_gdhf�^ey�h[hbo�iheh\�h^bgZdh\u��Gh�\ kblmZpbb�W^bih\Zdhfie_dkZ� h[t_dlhf� ex[\b� ^ey� ^_\hqdb� klZgh\blky� hl_p�� b fu� \ijZ\_� h`b^Zlv�� qlh� ijbghjfZevghf�oh^_�jZa\blby�hgZ�gZc^_l�imlv�hl�h[t_dlZ�hlpZ�d hdhgqZl_evghfm�\u[hjm�h[t_dlZ�BlZd��^_\hqdZ�k l_q_gb_f�\j_f_gb�^he`gZ�ihf_gylv�wjh]_ggmx�ahgm�b h[t_dl��m fZevqbdZ�lh�b^jm]h_�khojZgy_lky��<hagbdZ_l�\hijhk��dZd�wlh�ijhbkoh^bl��\ qZklghklb��dZd�^_\hqdZ�i_j_oh^blhl�fZl_jb�d ijb\yaZgghklb�d hlpm��beb��^jm]bfb� keh\Zfb��ba� k\h_c�fm`kdhc�\ [bheh]bq_kdbhij_^_e_ggmx�_c�`_gkdmx�nZam"J_r_gb_� [ueh� [u� b^_Zevgh� ijhkluf�� _keb� [u� fu� fh]eb� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� khij_^_e_ggh]h� \hajZklZ� \klmiZ_l� \ kbem� we_f_glZjgh_� \ebygb_� ijbly`_gby� ^jm]� d ^jm]mijhlb\hiheh`guo�iheh\��dhlhjh_�b \e_q_l�fZe_gvdmx�`_gsbgm�d fm`qbg_��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�lhl`_� aZdhg�iha\hey_l�fZevqbdm�mihjgh�^_j`Zlvky�fZl_jb��Fh`gh�[ueh�[u�_s_�ijb[Z\blv��qlhijb�wlhf�^_lb�ke_^mxl�gZf_dZf��dhlhju_�ih^Zxl�bf�jh^bl_eb��ij_^ihqblZy�b \�aZ\bkbfhklb�hliheZ��Gh�^_eh�^Ze_dh�g_� lZd�ijhklh�� \_^v�fu� _^\Z� agZ_f��fh`_f� eb�fu� \k_jv_a� \_jblv� \ lmlZbgkl\_ggmx��ZgZeblbq_kdb�^Ze__�g_�jZaeh`bfmx�kbem��h dhlhjhc�lZd�qZklh�]j_ayl�ihwlu��Baljm^h_fdbo�bkke_^h\Zgbc��^ey�dhlhjuo��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��e_]dh�[ueh�ihemqblv�fZl_jbZe��fuihq_jigmeb� k\_^_gby� kh\k_f� bgh]h� jh^Z�� : bf_ggh�� \u� ^he`gu� agZlv�� qlh� qbkeh� `_gsbg�dhlhju_�^he]h�hklZxlky�\ g_`ghc�aZ\bkbfhklb�hl�h[t_dlZ�hlpZ��d lhfm�`_�hl�j_Zevgh]h�hlpZ�hq_gv� \_ebdh�� LZdb_� `_gsbgu� k bgl_gkb\ghc� b aZlygm\r_cky� ijb\yaZgghklvx� d hlpmij_^hklZ\beb�gZf�\hafh`ghklv�k^_eZlv�ihjZabl_evgu_�hldjulby��Fu��dhg_qgh��agZeb��qlh�[ueZ

Page 323: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ij_^\Zjbl_evgZy� klZ^by� ijb\yaZgghklb� d fZl_jb�� gh� fu� g_� agZeb�� qlh� hgZ� fh]eZ� [ulv� lZdkh^_j`Zl_evgZ�� lZd� ^ebl_evgZ� b fh]eZ� ^Zlv� lZd� fgh]h� ih\h^h\� ^ey� nbdkZpbc� bij_^jZkiheh`_gbc�� < wlh� \j_fy� hl_p� ²� lhevdh� h[j_f_gbl_evguc� khi_jgbd�� \ g_dhlhjuokemqZyo�ijb\yaZgghklv�d fZl_jb�aZly]b\Z_lky�^h�q_l\_jlh]h�]h^Z��<k_��qlh�fu�iha^g__�gZoh^bf\ hlghr_gbb� d hlpm�� m`_� [ueh� \ g_c� b ihke_� lh]h� [ueh� i_j_g_k_gh� gZ� hlpZ�� Dhjhq_�� fum[_`^Z_fky�� qlh� g_evay� ihgylv� `_gsbgm�� g_� hl^Z\� ^he`gh_� wlhc� nZa_� ^hw^bih\hcijb\yaZgghklb�d fZl_jb�: l_i_jv� aZ^Z^bfky� \hijhkhf�� dZdh\u� eb[b^hagu_� hlghr_gby� ^_\hqdb� d fZl_jb��Hl\_l]eZkbl�� hgb� hq_gv� jZaghh[jZagu�� Ijhoh^y� q_j_a� \k_� ljb� nZau� ^_lkdhc� k_dkmZevghklb�� hgbijbgbfZxl�ijb�wlhf�ijbagZdb�hl^_evguo�nZa��\ujZ`Zxlky�hjZevgufb��kZ^bklkdh�ZgZevgufb�bnZeebq_kdbfb� `_eZgbyfb�� Wlb� `_eZgby� ij_^klZ\eyxl� dZd� Zdlb\gu_�� lZd� b iZkkb\gu_ih[m`^_gby�� _keb� bo� hlg_klb� d ijhy\eyxs_cky� iha^g__� ^bnn_j_gpbZpbb� iheh\�� q_]h� ih\hafh`ghklb�ke_^m_l�ba[_]Zlv��lh�bo�fh`gh�gZa\Zlv�fm`kdbfb�b `_gkdbfb��Hgb��djhf_�lh]h�iheghklvx� Zf[b\Ze_glgu�� klhev� `_� g_`ghc�� kdhevdh� b \jZ`^_[gh�Z]j_kkb\ghc� ijbjh^u�Ihke_^gb_�qZklh�ijhy\eyxlky��ebrv�ij_\jZlb\rbkv�\ kljZob��G_�\k_]^Z�e_]dh�knhjfmebjh\Zlvwlb� jZggb_� k_dkmZevgu_� `_eZgby�� hlq_leb\__� \k_]h� \ujZ`Z_lky� `_eZgb_� k^_eZlv� fZl_jbj_[_gdZ� b khhl\_lkl\mxs__� _fm�`_eZgb_� jh^blv� _c� j_[_gdZ�� h[Z� hlghkylky� d nZeebq_kdhfmi_jbh^m��hgb�^hklZlhqgh� kljZggu��gh�g_khfg_ggh�mklZgh\e_gu� ZgZeblbq_kdbf�gZ[ex^_gb_f�Ijb\e_dZl_evghklv�wlbo�bkke_^h\Zgbc�²�\ hr_ehfeyxsbo�hl^_evguo�gZoh^dZo��dhlhju_�hgbgZf� ^Zxl�� LZd�� gZijbf_j�� m`_� \ wlhl� ^hw^bih\� i_jbh^� fh`gh� h[gZjm`blv� hlghkysbcky� dfZl_jb� kljZo� [ulv� m[blhc� beb� hljZ\e_gghc�� dhlhjuc� \ihke_^kl\bb� fh`_l� h[jZah\Zlv� y^jhaZ[he_\Zgby� iZjZghc_c�� Beb� ^jm]hc� kemqZc�� \u� ihfgbl_� bgl_j_kguc� wibah^� ba� bklhjbbZgZeblbq_kdbo�bkke_^h\Zgbc��dhlhjuc�^hklZ\be�fgh]h�g_ijbylguo�fbgml��< lh� \j_fy�� dh]^Zhkgh\ghc� bgl_j_k� [ue� gZijZ\e_g� gZ� jZkdjulb_� ^_lkdbo� k_dkmZevguo� ljZ\f�� ihqlb� \k_� fhbiZpb_gldb�jZkkdZau\Zeb�fg_��qlh�hgb�[ueb�kh\jZs_gu�hlphf��< dhgp_�dhgph\�y ^he`_g�[ueijbclb�d \u\h^m��qlh�wlb�ijbagZgby�g_�khhl\_lkl\mxl�^_ckl\bl_evghklb��b gZqZe�ihgbfZlv��qlhbkl_jbq_kdb_� kbfilhfu� _klv�ieh^�nZglZabc�� Z g_�j_Zevguo� kh[ulbc��Lhevdh�iha^g__� y kfh]jZkihagZlv�\ wlhc�nZglZabb�h kh\jZs_gbb�hlphf�\ujZ`_gb_�lbibqgh]h�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ�m`_gsbgu�� : l_i_jv� fu� kgh\Z� gZoh^bf� \ ^hw^bih\hc� ij_^uklhjbb� ^_\hq_d� nZglZabxkh\jZs_gby�� h^gZdh� kh\jZlbl_evgbp_c�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� [u\Z_l� fZlv�� Gh� a^_kv� nZglZaby� m`_kimkdZ_lky�gZ�j_Zevgmx�ihq\m��ihlhfm�qlh��^_ckl\bl_evgh��fZlv��moZ`b\Zy�aZ�l_ehf�j_[_gdZ��\uau\Z_l�m g_]h�\ ]_gblZebyo�hsms_gby�m^h\hevkl\by��\hafh`gh��^Z`_�\i_j\u_�bo�ijh[m`^Zy�Y ij_^iheZ]Zx�� qlh� \u� ]hlh\u� ih^haj_\Zlv�� [m^lh� wlh� hibkZgb_� iheghlu� b kbeuk_dkmZevguo� hlghr_gbc�fZe_gvdhc� ^_\hqdb� d k\h_c�fZl_jb� hq_gv�ij_m\_ebq_gh��<_^v� dh]^ZgZ[ex^Z_rv�aZ�fZe_gvdbfb�^_\hqdZfb��gbq_]h�ih^h[gh]h�aZ�gbfb�g_�aZf_qZ_rv��Gh�wlhl�^h\h^g_�]h^blky�fh`gh� ^hklZlhqgh� fgh]h_� m\b^_lv� \ ^_lyo�� _keb� mf_lv� gZ[ex^Zlv�� Z djhf_� lh]h�� g_aZ[u\Zcl_��dZd�fZeh�ba�k\hbo�k_dkmZevguo�`_eZgbc�j_[_ghd�fh`_l�ij_^khagZl_evgh�\ujZablvbeb�l_f�[he__�khh[sblv��Dh]^Z�fu�ihevam_fky�gZrbf�ijZ\hf�bamq_gby�hklZldh\�b ihke_^kl\bcwlh]h�fbjZ�qm\kl\�m ebp��m dhlhjuo�^Zggu_�ijhp_kku�jZa\blby� klZeb�hkh[_ggh�hlq_leb\ufbbeb�^Z`_�qj_af_jgufb��<_^v�iZlheh]by�[eZ]h^Zjy�baheypbb�b ij_m\_ebq_gbx�\k_]^Z�hdZau\ZeZ

Page 324: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gZf� mkem]m� \ ihagZgbb� hlghr_gbc�� dhlhju_� \ ghjf_� hklZxlky� kdjulufb�� : lZd� dZd� gZrbbkke_^h\Zgby�gbdh]^Z�g_�ijh\h^bebkv�gZ� ex^yo�� kljZ^Zxsbo� ly`_eufb� hldehg_gbyfb�� lh� yiheZ]Zx��qlh�fu�fh`_f�kqblZlv�ihemq_ggu_�j_amevlZlu�^hklh\_jgufb�: l_i_jv�khkj_^hlhqbf�k\h_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�ke_^mxs_f�\hijhk_��hlq_]h�mfbjZ_l�wlZ�kbevgZyijb\yaZgghklv�^_\hqdb�d fZl_jb"�Fu�agZ_f��qlh�wlh�__ h[uqgZy�km^v[Z��hgZ�ij_^gZagZq_gZ�^eylh]h��qlh[u�mklmiblv�f_klh�ijb\yaZgghklb�d hlpm��B \hl�fu�klZedb\Z_fky�k nZdlhf��dhlhjucmdZau\Z_l� gZf� ^Zevg_crbc� imlv�� Wlhl�rZ]� \ jZa\blbb� k\b^_l_evkl\m_l� g_� h ijhklhc� kf_g_h[t_dlZ��Hloh^�hl�fZl_jb�ijhbkoh^bl�ih^�agZdhf�\jZ`^_[ghklb��k\yav�k fZl_jvx�\ueb\Z_lky�\g_gZ\bklv��LZdZy�g_gZ\bklv�fh`_l�klZlv�hq_gv�yjdh�\ujZ`_gghc�b khojZgblvky�gZ�\kx�`bagv�iha^g__� hgZ� fh`_l� ih^\_j]gmlvky� lsZl_evghc� k\_jodhfi_gkZpbb�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� dZdZy�lh� __qZklv�ij_h^he_\Z_lky��^jm]Zy� hklZ_lky��Dhg_qgh�� kbevgh_� \ebygb_� hdZau\Zxl�gZ�g__� kh[ulbyihke_^mxsbo�e_l��Gh�fu�h]jZgbqbfky�bamq_gb_f�__ \h�\j_fy�i_j_oh^Z�d hlpm�b \uykg_gb_f�__fhlb\h\��Fu� mkeurbf�^ebgguc�i_j_q_gv� \_kvfZ�jZaebqgh]h� k\hckl\Z� h[\bg_gbc�b `Zeh[� \Z^j_k�fZl_jb�� ijba\Zgguo� hijZ\^Zlv� \jZ`^_[gu_� qm\kl\Z� j_[_gdZ�� agZq_gb_� dhlhjuo� g_evayg_^hhp_gb\Zlv�� G_dhlhju_� ba� gbo� ²� y\gu_� jZpbhgZebaZpbb�� ^_ckl\bl_evgu_� bklhqgbdb\jZ`^_[ghklb�ij_^klhbl�_s_�hlukdZlv��GZ^_xkv��\u�ihke_^m_l_� aZ�fghc��dh]^Z�gZ� wlhl�jZa�yijh\_^m�\Zk�q_j_a�\k_�^_lZeb�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�bkke_^h\Zgby�Mij_d�\ Z^j_k�fZl_jb�� d dhlhjhfm�[hevr_� \k_]h�ijb[_]Zxl�� aZdexqZ_lky� \ lhf��qlh� hgZkebrdhf�fZeh�hl^Z\ZeZ� j_[_gdm�fhehdZ�� qlh�^he`gh� k\b^_l_evkl\h\Zlv� h g_^hklZld_� ex[\b�Wlhl� mij_d� bf__l� \ gZrbo� k_fvyo� hij_^_e_ggh_� hijZ\^Zgb_�� M fZl_j_c� qZklh� g_� [u\Z_l^hklZlhqgh�iblZgby�^ey�j_[_gdZ��b hgb�h]jZgbqb\Zxlky�l_f��qlh�dhjfyl�_]h�]jm^vx�g_kdhevdhf_kyp_\��ihe]h^Z�beb� ljb�q_l\_jlb� ]h^Z��M ijbfblb\guo�gZjh^h\�^_l_c�dhjfyl�fZl_jbgkdhc]jm^vx�^h�^\mo�b lj_o�e_l��H[jZa�dhjfbebpu��dZd�ijZ\beh��keb\Z_lky�k fZl_jvx��lZf��]^_�wlh]hg_� ijhbkoh^bl�� mij_d� ij_\jZsZ_lky� \ ^jm]hc�� Z bf_ggh� qlh� hgZ� kebrdhf� jZgh� hlhkeZeZdhjfbebpm��dhlhjZy�lZd�hohlgh�dhjfbeZ�j_[_gdZ��Gh�dZd�[u�lZf�gb�[ueh��g_�fh`_l�[ulv��qlh[udZ`^uc� jZa� mij_d� j_[_gdZ� bf_e� ih^� kh[hc� ihq\m�� Kdhj__� dZ`_lky�� qlh�`Z^ghklv� j_[_gdZ� dk\h_fm�i_j\hfm�iblZgbx� \hh[s_�g_mlhebfZ��qlh�hg�gbdh]^Z� lZd�b g_�ijbfbjblky� k mljZlhcfZl_jbgkdhc� ]jm^b��Y [u� gbkdhevdh� g_� m^b\beky�� _keb� [u� ZgZeba� j_[_gdZ�� ijbgZ^e_`Zs_]hijbfblb\ghfm�gZjh^m��dhlhjuc�khk_l�fZl_jbgkdmx�]jm^v��^Z`_�gZmqb\rbkv�[_]Zlv�b ]h\hjblv�\ujZabe�[u�lhl�`_�mij_d��K hlgylb_f�hl�]jm^b�k\yaZg��\_jhylgh��b kljZo�i_j_^�hljZ\e_gb_f��Y^²� wlh� ibsZ�� dhlhjZy� ^_eZ_l� dh]h�lh� [hevguf��Fh`_l� [ulv�� qlh� b k\hb� jZggb_� aZ[he_\Zgbyj_[_ghd� k\h^bl� d wlhfm� hldZam�� Qlh[u� ih\_jblv� \ kemqZc�� gZ^h� bf_lv� hij_^_e_ggh_bgl_ee_dlmZevgh_�\hkiblZgb_��ijbfblb\gu_��g_h[jZah\Zggu_�ex^b�b��dhg_qgh��j_[_ghd�mf_xl\k_fm�� qlh�ijhbkoh^bl��gZclb�ijbqbgm��<hafh`gh�� qlh�i_j\hgZqZevgh� wlh� [ue�fhlb\� \ ^mo_ZgbfbafZ��< g_dhlhjuo�kehyo�gZr_]h�gZk_e_gby�_s_�k_]h^gy�g_evay�mf_j_lv�[_a�lh]h��qlh[u�g_kdZaZeb�� qlh� mf_jr_]h� dlh�lh� ih]m[be�� kdhj__� \k_]h�� ^hdlhj�� : h[uqghc� g_\jhlbq_kdhcj_Zdpb_c�gZ�kf_jlv�[ebadh]h�y\ey_lky�kZfhh[\bg_gb_�\ lhf��qlh�lu�kZf�y\ey_rvky�ijbqbghc_]h�kf_jlb�Ke_^mxs__� h[\bg_gb_� \ Z^j_k�fZl_jb� \hagbdZ_l�� dh]^Z� \ ^_lkdhc� ihy\ey_lky� _s_� h^bgj_[_ghd��<hafh`gh��hgh�nbdkbjm_l�k\yav�k \ugm`^_gguf�hjZevguf�hldZahf �RUDOH�9HUVDJXQJ��FZlv�g_�fh]eZ�beb�g_�ohl_eZ�^Z\Zlv�j_[_gdm�[hevr_�fhehdZ��ihlhfm�qlh�hgh�gm`gh�^ey�\gh\v

Page 325: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ihy\b\r_]hky�� < kemqZ_�� dh]^Z� ^_lb� jh`^Zxlky� ke_^hf� ^jm]� aZ� ^jm]hf�� lZd� qlh� dhjfe_gb_]jm^vx� gZjmrZ_lky� \lhjhc� [_j_f_gghklvx�� wlhl� mij_d� ihemqZ_l� j_Zevgh_� h[hkgh\Zgb_�� bijbf_qZl_evgh��qlh�j_[_ghd�^Z`_�k jZagbp_c�\ \hajZkl_�\k_]h�ebrv�\ ���f_kyp_\�g_�kebrdhffZe��qlh[u�g_�ihgylv�iheh`_gb_�\_s_c��Gh�j_[_ghd�qm\kl\m_l�k_[y�ms_fe_gguf�i_j_^�ebphfg_`_eZl_evgh]h�ijbr_evpZ�b khi_jgbdZ�g_�lhevdh�\ dhjfe_gbb�fhehdhf��gh�lZd`_�b \h�\k_o^jm]bo� k\b^_l_evkl\Zo� fZl_jbgkdhc� aZ[hleb\hklb�� Hg� qm\kl\m_l� k_[y� gba\_j]gmluf�h]jZ[e_gguf��h[^_e_gguf�\ k\hbo�ijZ\Zo��gZ�ihq\_�j_\ghklb�g_gZ\b^bl�fZe_gvdh]h�[jZlZ�bebk_kljm� b gZijZ\ey_l� gZ� g_\_jgmx� fZlv� k\hx� aeh[m�� dhlhjZy� hq_gv� qZklh� \ujZ`Z_lky� \g_ijbylghf� baf_g_gbb� _]h� ih\_^_gby�� Hg� klZgh\blky� ©iehobfª�� jZa^jZ`bl_evguf�g_ihkemrguf�� hldZau\Zykv� hl� ijbh[j_l_gguo� gZ\udh\� \ mf_gbb� mijZ\eylv� k\hbfbwdkdj_lhjgufb� nmgdpbyfb�� Wlh� \k_� ^Z\gh� ba\_klgh� b ijbgbfZ_lky� dZd� kZfh� kh[hcjZamf_xs__ky��gh�fu�j_^dh�bf__f�ijZ\bevgh_�ij_^klZ\e_gb_�h kbe_�wlbo�j_\gb\uo�qm\kl\��h[mklhcqb\hklb�� k dhlhjhc� hgb� ijh^he`Zxl� khojZgylvky�� Z lZd`_� h \_ebqbg_� bo� \ebygby� gZihke_^mxs__� jZa\blb_�� L_f� [he__� qlh� wlZ� j_\ghklv� \ ihke_^mxsb_� ^_lkdb_� ]h^u� iblZ_lkygh\ufb�bklhqgbdZfb��b \k_�wlh�ihljyk_gb_�ih\lhjy_lky�k jh`^_gb_f�dZ`^h]h�gh\h]h�[jZlZ�bebk_klju��G_fgh]h_�f_gy_lky�hl�lh]h��qlh�j_[_ghd�hklZ_lky�ex[bfp_f�fZl_jb��ijblyaZgby�ex[\bj_[_gdZ�[_af_jgu��hgb�lj_[mxl�bkdexqbl_evghklb�b g_�^himkdZxl�gbdZdh]h�jZa^_e_gby�H agZqbl_evghf� bklhqgbd_� \jZ`^_[ghklb� j_[_gdZ� d fZl_jb� k\b^_l_evkl\mxl� _]hfgh]hh[jZagu_�f_gyxsb_ky�\ aZ\bkbfhklb�hl�nZau�eb[b^h� k_dkmZevgu_�`_eZgby�� dhlhju_� \[hevrbgkl\_�k\h_f�g_�fh]ml�[ulv�m^h\e_l\hj_gu��KZfuc�kms_kl\_gguc�\ugm`^_gguc�hldZabf__l�f_klh�\ nZeebq_kdhc�nZa_��dh]^Z�fZlv�aZij_sZ_l�²�g_j_^dh�khijh\h`^Zy�wlh�kmjh\ufbm]jhaZfb� b \k_fb� agZdZfb� g_m^h\hevkl\by� ²� \uau\Zxsb_� gZkeZ`^_gb_� fZgbimeypbb� k]_gblZebyfb�� d dhlhjuf� hgZ�� ijZ\^Z�� kZfZ� _]h� ih^\_eZ�� Ke_^h\Zeh� [u� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlhfhlb\hf�^ey�h[hkgh\Zgby�hloh^Z�^_\hqdb�hl�fZl_jb�^hklZlhqgh��Lh]^Z�ijbrehkv�[u�\ukdZaZlvkm`^_gb_�� qlh� wlZ� ^\hckl\_gghklv� g_ba[_`gh� ke_^m_l� ba� ijbjh^u� ^_lkdhc� k_dkmZevghklb�� baqj_af_jghklb�ijblyaZgbc�ex[\b�b g_\uihegbfhklb�k_dkmZevguo�`_eZgbc��Dlh�gb[m^v��fh`_l[ulv��^Z`_�ih^mfZ_l��qlh�wlh�i_j\h_�ex[h\gh_�hlghr_gb_�j_[_gdZ�h[j_q_gh�gZ�g_m^Zqm�bf_gghihlhfm�� qlh� hgh� i_j\h_�� ihlhfm� qlh� wlZ� jZggyy� ijb\yaZgghklv� d h[t_dlm�� dZd� ijZ\beh�� \\ukhdhc�kl_i_gb�Zf[b\Ze_glgZ��gZjy^m�k kbevghc�ex[h\vx�\k_]^Z�bf__lky�kbevgZy�kdehgghklvd Z]j_kkbb�� b q_f� [he__� kljZklgh� j_[_ghd� ex[bl� h[t_dl�� l_f� \hkijbbfqb\__� hg� djZahqZjh\Zgbyf� b hldZaZf� kh� klhjhgu� h[t_dlZ�� < dhgp_� dhgph\� ex[h\v� g_� \ khklhygbbijhlb\hklhylv�gZdhib\r_cky�\jZ`^_[ghklb��Beb�`_� lZdmx�i_j\hgZqZevgmx�Zf[b\Ze_glghklvqm\kl\_gguo�ijb\yaZgghkl_c�fh`gh�hldehgblv�b mdZaZlv�gZ�lh��qlh�hlghr_gb_�fZlv²j_[_ghdbf__l�hkh[mx�ijbjh^m��dhlhjZy�k lZdhc�`_�g_ba[_`ghklvx�\_^_l�d jZajmr_gbx�^_lkdhc�ex[\b�ihlhfm� qlh� ^Z`_� kZfh_� fy]dh_� \hkiblZgb_� g_� fh`_l� h[hclbkv� [_a� ijbgm`^_gby� dh]jZgbq_gbyf��Z dZ`^h_�lZdh_�\f_rZl_evkl\h�\ _]h�k\h[h^m�\uau\Z_l�m j_[_gdZ�dZd�j_Zdpbxkdehgghklv�d khijhlb\e_gbx�b Z]j_kkbb�Y ^mfZx��qlh�^bkdmkkby�h[�wlbo�\hafh`ghklyo�fh]eZ�[u�klZlv�hq_gv�bgl_j_kghc��gh�\hlg_h`b^Zggh� \hagbdZ_l� \hajZ`_gb_�� dhlhjh_�^Z_l�gZr_fm�bgl_j_km� ^jm]h_�gZijZ\e_gb_��<_^v\k_�wlb�nZdlhju��h[b^u��jZahqZjh\Zgby�\ ex[\b��j_\ghklv��kh[eZag�k ihke_^mxsbf�aZij_lhf�²^_ckl\bl_evgu�lZd`_�^ey�hlghr_gby�fZevqbdZ�d fZl_jb��h^gZdh�hgb�g_�\ khklhygbb�\ua\Zlv�mg_]h�hlqm`^_gby�d h[t_dlm²fZl_jb��?keb�fu�g_�gZc^_f�q_]h�lh��qlh�y\ey_lky�ki_pbnbqguf

Page 326: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

^ey�^_\hqdb��hlkmlkl\m_l�m fZevqbdZ�beb�ijhbkoh^bl�m g_]h�bgZq_��lh�fu�g_�kfh`_f�h[tykgblvkm^v[u�k\yab�k fZl_jvx�m ^_\hqdb�Y ^mfZx��qlh�fu�gZreb� wlhl�ki_pbnbq_kdbc�nZdlhj�b bf_ggh�\ ij_^iheZ]Z_fhf�f_kl_�ohly�b \�g_h`b^Zgghc�nhjf_��Y ]h\hjx��\ ij_^iheZ]Z_fhf�f_kl_��ihlhfm�qlh�hg�gZoh^blky�\dhfie_dk_� dZkljZpbb�� :gZlhfbq_kdh_� �iheh\h_�� jZaebqb_� ^he`gh� \_^v� kdZau\Zlvky� b gZikbobq_kdbo� ihke_^kl\byo��Gh� \_kvfZ� g_h`b^Zggh� [ueh� magZlv� ba� ZgZebah\� lh� qlh� ^_\hqdZkqblZ_l� fZlv� hl\_lkl\_gghc� aZ� hlkmlkl\b_� i_gbkZ� b g_� fh`_l� ijhklblv� _c� wlhc� k\h_ch[^_e_gghklb�>Z�^Z��fu�b `_gsbg_�ijbibku\Z_f�dhfie_dk�dZkljZpbb�b k�iheguf�hkgh\Zgb_f��ohly�hgg_�fh`_l�bf_lv� lh�`_� kh^_j`Zgb_�� qlh�b m�fZevqbdZ��M g_]h� dhfie_dk� dZkljZpbb� \hagbdZ_lihke_� lh]h��dZd��m\b^_\�`_gkdb_� ]_gblZebb��hg�magZe��qlh�klhev�\ukhdh�p_gbfuc�bf�qe_g�g_h[yaZl_evgh� ^he`_g� [ulv� \f_kl_� k l_ehf�� AZl_f� hg� \kihfbgZ_l� m]jhau�� dhlhjuf� hgih^\_j]Zeky��aZgbfZykv�k\hbf�qe_ghf��gZqbgZ_f�bf�\_jblv�b ihiZ^Z_l�k wlbo�ihj�ih^�\ebygb_kljZoZ� dZkljZpbb� dhlhjuc� klZgh\blky� kZfhc� fhsghc� ^\b`ms_c� kbehc� _]h� ^Zevg_cr_]hjZa\blby�� Dhfie_dk� dZkljZpbb� m ^_\hqdb� lh`_� \hagbdZ_l� [eZ]h^Zjy� lhfm�� qlh� hgZ� \b^bl]_gblZebb� ^jm]h]h�� HgZ� kjZam� `_� aZf_qZ_l� jZaebqb_� b�� gZ^h� ijbagZlvky�� _]h� agZq_gb_�� HgZqm\kl\m_l�k_[y�]em[hdh�h[^_e_gghc��qZklh�^Z_l�ihgylv��qlh�_c�lh`_�ohl_ehkv�[u�©bf_lv�lZdh_`_ª��\ g_c�ihy\ey_lky�aZ\bklv�d i_gbkm� dhlhjZy�hklZ\ey_l�g_ba]eZ^bfu_�ke_^u�\ __�jZa\blbb�bnhjfbjh\Zgbb� oZjZdl_jZ�� ij_h^he_\Z_fu_� ^Z`_� \ kZfhf� [eZ]hijbylghf� kemqZ_� g_� [_ak_jv_aghc�aZljZlu�ikbobq_kdbo�kbe��Lh��qlh�^_\hqdZ�ijbagZ_l�nZdl�hlkmlkl\by�i_gbkZ��hlgx^vg_�]h\hjbl�h lhf��qlh�hgZ�k wlbf�kfbjy_lky��GZijhlb\��hgZ�_s_�^he]h�^_j`blky�aZ�`_eZgb_�lh`_ihemqblv� ©wlhª�� \_jbl� \ wlm� \hafh`ghklv� g_\_jhylgh� ^he]h�� b ^Z`_� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� agZgb_j_Zevghklb� ^Z\gh� hl[jhkbeh� wlh� `_eZgb_� dZd� g_\uihegbfh_�� ZgZeba� fh`_l� ihdZaZlv�� qlh� \[_kkhagZl_evghf� hgh� hklZehkv� b khojZgbeh� agZqbl_evguc� aZiZk� wg_j]bb��@_eZgb_� \k_�lZdbihemqblv�\ dhgp_�dhgph\�^he]h`^Zgguc�i_gbk�fh`_l�kihkh[kl\h\Zlv�\hagbdgh\_gbx�fhlb\h\�dhlhju_�ijb\_^ml�aj_emx�`_gsbgm�d ikbohZgZebam�b lh��q_]h�hgZ��ihgylgh��fh`_l�h`b^Zlv�hlZgZebaZ�� Z bf_ggh� \hafh`ghklb� aZgbfZlvky� bgl_ee_dlmZevghc� ^_yl_evghklvx�� fh`_l� [ulvqZklh�bklhedh\Zgh�dZd�km[ebfbjh\ZggZy�\ZjbZpby�wlh]h�\ul_kg_ggh]h�`_eZgby�< agZq_gbb�aZ\bklb�d i_gbkm�\iheg_�fh`gh�g_�khfg_\Zlvky��Ijb\_^m�\ dZq_kl\_�ijbf_jZfm`kdhc�g_kijZ\_^eb\hklb�ml\_j`^_gb_��qlh�aZ\bklv�b j_\ghklv�b]jZxl�_s_�[hevrmx�jhev�\^mr_\ghc�`bagb�`_gsbgu��q_f�fm`qbgu��G_�lh�qlh�[u�wlb�dZq_kl\Z�hlkmlkl\h\Zeb�m fm`qbg�beb� hgb�g_�bf_eb�[u� m `_gsbgu�gbdZdh]h� ^jm]h]h� dhjgy�� djhf_� aZ\bklb� d i_gbkm�� gh� wlhcihke_^g_c� fu� kdehggu� ijbibku\Zlv� [hevr__� agZq_gb_� ^ey� `_gsbg�� H^gZdh� m g_dhlhjuoZgZeblbdh\� _klv� kdehgghklv� ijbgb`Zlv� agZq_gb_� lh]h� i_j\h]h� ijbklmiZ� aZ\bklb� d i_gbkm�dhlhjuc�\hagbdZ_l�\ nZeebq_kdhc�nZa_��Hgb�iheZ]Zxl��qlh�dh]^Z�m `_gsbgu�h[gZjm`b\Z_lkyih^h[gZy� mklZgh\dZ�� lh� j_qv� b^_l�� ]eZ\guf� h[jZahf�� h \lhjbqghf� h[jZah\Zgbb�� dhlhjh_� \kemqZ_� ihke_^mxsbo� dhgnebdlh\� hkms_kl\ey_lky� [eZ]h^Zjy� j_]j_kkbb� gZ� lh� jZgg__bgnZglbevgh_�ih[m`^_gb_��Gm��Z wlh�²�h[sZy�ijh[e_fZ�]em[bgghc�ikboheh]bb��Ijb�fgh]boiZlheh]bq_kdbo� beb� \k_]h� ebrv� g_h[uqguo� mklZgh\dZo� \e_q_gbc�� gZijbf_j�� ijb� \k_ok_dkmZevguo� ba\jZs_gbyo� \hagbdZ_l� \hijhk�� dZdmx� ^hex� bo� kbeu� gm`gh� hlg_klb� gZ� kq_ljZggbo� bgnZglbevguo� nbdkZpbc� b dZdmx� ²� gZ� kq_l� \ebygby� ihke_^mxsbo� i_j_`b\Zgbc� b

Page 327: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

jZa\blbb��Ijb�wlhf�ihqlb�\k_]^Z�j_qv�b^_l�h ^hihegbl_evguo�jy^Zo��dZd�fu�wlh�ij_^iheh`bebijb� h[km`^_gbb� wlbheh]bb� g_\jhah\�� H[Z� nZdlhjZ� \ jZaebqghf� khhlghr_gbb� y\eyxlkyijbqbghc��f_gvrZy�^hey�mqZklby�h^gh]h�nZdlhjZ�\haf_sZ_lky�[hevr_c�^jm]h]h��BgnZglbevgh_\h�\k_o� kemqZyo�y\ey_lky�gZijZ\eyxsbf��g_�\k_]^Z��gh� \k_�lZdb�qZklh�j_rZxsbf��DZd�jZa� \kemqZ_� aZ\bklb� d i_gbkm� y ohl_e� [u� j_rbl_evgh� \uklmiblv� aZ� ij_h[eZ^Zgb_� bgnZglbevgh]hnZdlhjZ�Hldjulb_� k\h_c� dZkljZpbb� y\ey_lky� ih\hjhlguf� imgdlhf� \ jZa\blbb� ^_\hqdb�� Hghhldju\Z_l�ljb�gZijZ\e_gby�jZa\blby��h^gh�\_^_l�d ih^Z\e_gbx�k_dkmZevghklb�beb�d g_\jham�^jm]h_�d baf_g_gbx�oZjZdl_jZ�\ kfuke_�dhfie_dkZ�fm`_kl\_gghklb��gZdhg_p��ihke_^g__�²�dghjfZevghc�`_gkl\_gghklb��H[h�\k_o�lj_o�gZijZ\e_gbyo�fu�magZeb�^h\hevgh�fgh]h_��ohly�b g_\k_��Hkgh\gh_�kh^_j`Zgb_�i_j\h]h�gZijZ\e_gby�khklhbl�\ lhf��qlh�fZe_gvdZy�^_\hqdZ��dhlhjZy^h� kbo� ihj� `beZ� ih�fm`kdb�� mf_eZ� ^hklZ\eylv� k_[_� gZkeZ`^_gb_� \ha[m`^_gb_f� deblhjZ�khhlghkbeZ�wlh�aZgylb_�kh�k\hbfb�qZklh�Zdlb\gufb�k_dkmZevgufb�`_eZgbyfb��hlghkysbfbky�dfZl_jb�� ih^� \ebygb_f� aZ\bklb� d i_gbkm� ebrZ_lky� m^h\hevkl\by� hl� k\h_c� nZeebq_kdhck_dkmZevghklb��Mya\e_ggZy�\ k\h_f�kZfhex[bb�kjZ\g_gb_f�k fZevqbdhf��gZ^_e_gguf�i_gbkhf�hgZ� hldZau\Z_lky� hl� fZklmj[Zpbhggh]h� m^h\e_l\hj_gby� deblhjhf�� hl\_j]Z_l� k\hx� ex[h\v� dfZl_jb��g_j_^dh�\ul_kgyy�ijb�wlhf�agZqbl_evgmx�qZklv�k\hbo�k_dkmZevguo�klj_fe_gbc�\hh[s_�Hloh^� hl� fZl_jb� ijhbkoh^bl�� ijZ\^Z�� g_� kjZam�� lZd� dZd� ^_\hqdZ� kqblZ_l� dZkljZpbx� kgZqZeZk\hbf�bg^b\b^mZevguf�g_kqZklv_f��hgZ�ebrv�ihkl_i_ggh�jZkijhkljZgy_l�__ gZ�^jm]b_�`_gkdb_kms_kl\Z�b��gZdhg_p��lZd`_�gZ�fZlv��?_�ex[h\v�hlghkbeZkv�d nZeebq_kdhc fZl_jb��k hldjulb_flh]h��qlh�fZlv�dZkljbjh\ZgZ��\hafh`gh��hgZ�hldZau\Z_lky�hl�g__�dZd�hl�h[t_dlZ�ex[\b��lZd�qlh^Z\gh� gZdhie_ggu_� fhlb\u� \jZ`^_[ghklb� [_jml� \_jo�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� wlh� hagZqZ_l�� qlhhldjulb_� hlkmlkl\by� i_gbkZ� h[_kp_gb\Z_l� `_gsbgm� \ ]eZaZo� ^_\hqdb�� dZd� b fZevqbdZ�� Ziha^g__��\hafh`gh�b fm`qbgu�<k_� \u� agZ_l_�� dZdh_� qj_a\uqZcgh_� wlbheh]bq_kdh_� agZq_gb_� gZrb� g_\jhlbdb� ijb^Zxlk\h_fm�hgZgbafm��Hgb� kqblZxl� _]h�\bgh\gbdhf�\k_o� k\hbo�g_^m]h\��b gZf� lj_[m_lky�g_fZehmkbebc��qlh[u�hgb�ih\_jbeb��qlh�aZ[em`^Zxlky��Gh��kh[kl\_ggh��fu�^he`gu�[ueb�[u�ijbagZlv�qlh�hgb�ijZ\u��lZd�dZd�hgZgbaf�y\ey_lky�\ujZ`_gb_f�^_lkdhc�k_dkmZevghklb��hl�g_ijZ\bevgh]hjZa\blby�dhlhjhc�hgb�b kljZ^Zxl��IjZ\^Z��g_\jhlbdb�\ hkgh\ghf�h[\bgyxl�hgZgbaf�i_jbh^Ziheh\hc�aj_ehklb��h jZgg_f�^_lkdhf�hgZgbaf_��hl�dhlhjh]h�\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�\k_�aZ\bkbl��hgbh[uqgh� aZ[u\Zxl�� Y ohl_e� [u� bf_lv� dh]^Z�gb[m^v� \hafh`ghklv� ih^jh[gh� baeh`blv� \Zf�gZkdhevdh�\Z`gu�\k_�nZdlbq_kdb_�qZklgu_�hkh[_gghklb�jZgg_]h�hgZgbafZ�^ey�ihke_^mxs_]hg_\jhaZ� beb� oZjZdl_jZ� bg^b\b^mmfZ�� [ue� eb� hg� h[gZjm`_g� beb� g_l�� dZd� jh^bl_eb� k gbf[hjhebkv� beb� ^himkdZeb� _]h�� m^Zehkv� eb� _fm� kZfhfm� _]h� ih^Z\blv�� <k_� wlh� hklZ\behg_ba]eZ^bfu_�ke_^u�\ _]h�jZa\blbb��Gh�y ^Z`_�jZ^��qlh�fg_�g_�gm`gh�wlh]h�^_eZlv��wlh�[ueZ�[uljm^gZy� aZ^ZqZ�� dhlhjZy� aZgyeZ� [u�fgh]h� \j_f_gb�� b \� dhgp_� \u� kfmlbeb� [u�f_gy� l_f�� qlhihlj_[h\Zeb�[u�hl�f_gy�kh\_jr_ggh�hij_^_e_gguo�ijZdlbq_kdbo�kh\_lh\��dZd�jh^bl_eyf�beb\hkiblZl_eyf�ke_^m_l�hlghkblvky�d hgZgbafm�fZe_gvdbo�^_l_c��< jZa\blbb�^_\hqdb��h dhlhjhfy ]h\hjx��\b^_g�ijbf_j�lh]h��qlh�j_[_ghd�kZf�klZjZ_lky�hk\h[h^blvky�hl�hgZgbafZ��Gh�wlh�g_\k_]^Z�_fm�m^Z_lky��LZf��]^_�aZ\bklv�d i_gbkm�ijh[m^beZ�kbevgh_�ijhlb\h^_ckl\b_�deblhjghfmhgZgbafm��Z hg�\k_�lZdb�g_�ohq_l�mklmiZlv��gZqbgZ_lky�wg_j]bqgZy�hk\h[h^bl_evgZy�[hjv[Z��\dhlhjhc� ^_\hqdZ� dZd� [u� [_j_l� gZ� k_[y� jhev� hlklZ\e_gghc� fZl_jb� b \ujZ`Z_l� \k_� k\h_

Page 328: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

g_^h\hevkl\h�g_iheghp_gguf�deblhjhf��khijhlb\eyykv�m^h\e_l\hj_gbx�k _]h�ihfhsvx��M`_fgh]h� e_l� kimkly�� dh]^Z� hgZgbklbq_kdb_� ^_ckl\by� ^Z\gh� ih^Z\e_gu�� bgl_j_k� ijh^he`Z_lkhojZgylvky�� b _]h� fu� ^he`gu� lhedh\Zlv� dZd� aZsblm� hl� \k_� _s_� kms_kl\mxs_c� [hyagbbkdmr_gby��Wlh� \ujZ`Z_lky� \ \hagbdgh\_gbb� kbfiZlbb� d ebpZf�� m dhlhjuo� ij_^iheZ]Zxlkykoh`b_�ljm^ghklb��wlh�klZgh\blky�fhlb\hf�^ey�aZdexq_gby�[jZdZ��wlh�fh`_l�^Z`_�hij_^_eylv\u[hj� iZjlg_jZ� ih� [jZdm� beb� ex[\b�� Hk\h[h`^_gb_� hl� jZgg_c� ^_lkdhc� fZklmj[Zpbb^_ckl\bl_evgh�y\ey_lky�^_ehf�hlgx^v�g_�e_]dbf�beb�[_ajZaebqguf�Ij_djZs_gb_� deblhjghc� fZklmj[Zpbb� hagZqZ_l� hldZa� hl� qZklb� Zdlb\ghklb�� L_i_jviZkkb\ghklv�[_j_l�\_jo��h[jZs_gb_�d hlpm�ijhbkoh^bl�ij_bfms_kl\_ggh�k ihfhsvx�iZkkb\guoih[m`^_gbc��<u�\b^bl_��qlh�lZdhc�k^\b]�\ jZa\blbb��mkljZgyxsbc�nZeebq_kdmx�Zdlb\ghklv�ih^]hlZ\eb\Z_l�ihq\m� ^ey�`_gkl\_gghklb��?keb� ijb� wlhf� g_� kebrdhf�fgh]h_� l_jy_lky� ba�aZ\ul_kg_gby��wlZ�`_gkl\_gghklv�fh`_l�hkms_kl\eylvky�ghjfZevgh��@_eZgb_��k dhlhjuf�^_\hqdZh[jZsZ_lky�d hlpm��wlh�\_^v�i_j\hgZqZevgh�`_eZgb_�bf_lv�i_gbk��\ dhlhjhf�_c�hldZaZeZ�fZlv�bdhlhjh]h� hgZ� `^_l� hl� hlpZ�� Gh� `_gkdZy� kblmZpby� \hkklZgZ\eb\Z_lky� lhevdh� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z`_eZgb_�bf_lv�i_gbk�aZf_sZ_lky�`_eZgb_f�bf_lv�j_[_gdZ��j_[_ghd��lZdbf�h[jZahf��kh]eZkghwd\b\Ze_glZf�^j_\g_c�kbf\hebdb��aZgbfZ_l�f_klh�i_gbkZ��Hl�gZk�g_�mkdhevaZ_l�lh��qlh�^_\hqdZ_s_�jZgvr_��\ g_gZjmr_gghc�nZeebq_kdhc�nZa_��ohl_eZ�j_[_gdZ��\_^v�lZdh\�[ue�kfuke�__ b]juk dmdeZfb�� Gh� wlZ� b]jZ� g_� [ueZ�� kh[kl\_ggh�� \ujZ`_gb_f� __ `_gkl\_gghklb�� hgZ� kem`beZb^_glbnbdZpbb�k fZl_jvx�k gZf_j_gb_f�aZf_gblv�iZkkb\ghklv�Zdlb\ghklvx��HgZ�b]jZeZ�jhevfZl_jb��Z dmdehc�[ueZ�hgZ�kZfZ��l_i_jv�hgZ�fh]eZ�^_eZlv�k j_[_gdhf�\k_�lh��qlh�fZlv�h[uqgh^_eZeZ�k g_c��Lhevdh�k ihy\e_gb_f�`_eZgby�bf_lv�i_gbk�dmdeZ�j_[_ghd�klZgh\blky�j_[_gdhf�hlhlpZ� b hlgug_� kZfhc� `_eZgghc� `_gkdhc� p_evx�� <_ebdh� kqZklv_�� _keb� dh]^Z�gb[m^v\ihke_^kl\bb�wlh�^_lkdh_�`_eZgb_�gZc^_l�k\h_�j_Zevgh_�\hiehs_gb_�b hkh[_ggh�_keb�j_[_ghd[m^_l�fZevqbdhf��dhlhjuc�ijbg_k_l�k kh[hc�^he]h`^Zgguc�i_gbk��< k\yab�©j_[_ghd�hl�hlpZªZdp_gl� ^hklZlhqgh� qZklh� kf_s_g� gZ� j_[_gdZ�� Z g_� gZ� hlpZ�� LZd� klZjh_� fm`kdh_� `_eZgb_h[eZ^Zlv�i_gbkhf�_s_�ijhk\_qb\Z_l�kd\hav�keh`b\rmxky�`_gkl\_gghklv��Gh��fh`_l�[ulv��wlh`_eZgb_�bf_lv�i_gbk�fu�^he`gu��kdhj__��ijbagZlv�bkdexqbl_evgh�`_gkdbf�K i_j_ghkhf� `_eZgby� j_[_gdZ�i_gbkZ� gZ� hlpZ� ^_\hqdZ� \klmiZ_l� \ kblmZpbx� W^bih\Zdhfie_dkZ�� <jZ`^_[ghklv� d fZl_jb�� dhlhjhc� g_� gm`gh� kha^Z\Zlvky� aZgh\h�� ihemqZ_l� l_i_jvkbevgh_�ih^dj_ie_gb_��ihlhfm�qlh� lZ�klZgh\blky�khi_jgbp_c��dhlhjhc�^hklZ_lky�hl�hlpZ�\k_�q_]h�`_eZ_l�hl�g_]h�^_\hqdZ��W^bih\�dhfie_dk�^_\hqdb�^he]h_�\j_fy�kdju\Ze�hl�gZk�^hw^bih\mk\yav� k fZl_jvx�� dhlhjZy� klhev� \Z`gZ� b hklZ\ey_l� lZdb_� klhcdb_� nbdkZpbb�� >ey� ^_\hqdbw^bih\Z� kblmZpby� y\ey_lky� bkoh^hf� ^he]h]h� b ljm^gh]h� jZa\blby�� q_f�lh� \jh^_ij_^\Zjbl_evgh]h�hk\h[h`^_gby��g_dhc�lhqdhc�ihdhy��dhlhjmx�hgZ�g_�lZd�lh�kdhjh�hklZ\bl��l_f[he__�qlh� l_i_jv�g_^Ze_dh�b gZqZeh�eZl_glgh]h�i_jbh^Z��< hlghr_gbb�W^bih\Z� dhfie_dkZ� ddhfie_dkm�dZkljZpbb�h[jZsZ_l�gZ�k_[y�\gbfZgb_�jZaebqb_�iheh\��dhlhjh_��\_jhylgh��qj_\Zlhihke_^kl\byfb�� W^bih\� dhfie_dk� fZevqbdZ�� dh]^Z� hg� `_eZ_l� k\hx� fZlv�� Z hlpZ� ohl_e� [umkljZgblv� dZd� khi_jgbdZ�� jZa\b\Z_lky�� dhg_qgh�� ba�nZau� _]h�nZeebq_kdhc� k_dkmZevghklb��Ghm]jhaZ� dZkljZpbb� ijbgm`^Z_l� _]h� hldZaZlvky� hl� wlhc� mklZgh\db�� Ih^� \ebygb_f� hiZkghklbihl_jylv�i_gbk�W^bih\� dhfie_dk� hklZ\ey_lky�� \ul_kgy_lky� b \� gZb[he__� ghjfZevghf� kemqZ_jZajmrZ_lky� ^h� hkgh\Zgby�� Z \� dZq_kl\_� _]h� gZke_^gbdZ� \klmiZ_l� \ kbem� kljh]h_�K\_jo�Y��M^_\hqdb� ijhbkoh^bl� ihqlb� ijhlb\hiheh`gh_�� Dhfie_dk� dZkljZpbb� ih^]hlZ\eb\Z_l� W^bih\

Page 329: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dhfie_dk��\f_klh�lh]h�qlh[u�_]h�jZajmrZlv��ih^�\ebygb_f�aZ\bklb�d i_gbkm�gZjmrZ_lky�k\yav�kfZl_jvx��b ^_\hqdZ�ihiZ^Z_l�\ w^bih\m�kblmZpbx�dZd�\ dZdmx�lh�]Z\Zgv��K mkljZg_gb_f�kljZoZdZkljZpbb�hliZ^Z_l�]eZ\guc�fhlb\��dhlhjuc�aZklZ\ey_l�fZevqbdZ�ij_h^he_lv�W^bih\�dhfie_dk�>_\hqdZ� hklZ_lky� \ g_f� g_hij_^_e_ggh� ^he]h� b ebrv� iha^gh�� ^Z� b lh� g_� iheghklvxhk\h[h`^Z_lky� hl� g_]h�� < wlbo� mkeh\byo� ^he`gh� ihkljZ^Zlv� h[jZah\Zgb_� K\_jo�Y�� hgh� g_kfh`_l� ^hklbqv� lhc� kbeu� b g_aZ\bkbfhklb�� dhlhju_� b ijb^Zxl� _fm� dmevlmjgh_� agZq_gb_�� bn_fbgbklu� g_� ex[yl�� dh]^Z� bf� mdZau\Zxl� gZ� ihke_^kl\by� wlh]h� fhf_glZ� ^ey� h[uqgh]h`_gkdh]h�oZjZdl_jZ�: l_i_jv�\_jg_fky�gZaZ^��dZd�\lhjmx�\hafh`gmx�j_Zdpbx�gZ�hldjulb_�`_gkdhc�dZkljZpbbfu� \u^_ebeb� jZa\blb_� kbevgh]h� dhfie_dkZ�fm`_kl\_gghklb��Ih^� wlbf�ih^jZamf_\Zehkv�� qlh^_\hqdZ�dZd�[u�hldZau\Z_lky�ijbagZlv�wlhl�g_ijbylguc�nZdl��mijyfuf�ijhl_klhf�_s_�[hevr_ij_m\_ebqb\Z_l� k\hx�ij_`gxx�fm`_kl\_gghklv��g_� ohq_l� hldZau\Zlvky� hl� k\hbo� deblhjguo^_ckl\bc�b gZoh^bl�k_[_�ijb[_`bs_�\ b^_glbnbdZpbb�k nZeebq_kdhc�fZl_jvx�beb�hlphf��Qlhfh`_l�[ulv�j_rZxsbf�^ey�lZdh]h�bkoh^Z"�Fu�g_�fh`_f�ij_^klZ\blv�k_[_�gbq_]h�bgh]h��djhf_dhgklblmpbhgZevgh]h�nZdlhjZ��[hevr_c�f_ju� Zdlb\ghklb��qlh�h[uqgh�oZjZdl_jgh�^ey� kZfpZ�Kmsghklvx� ijhp_kkZ� y\ey_lky� lh�� qlh� \ wlhf� f_kl_� jZa\blby� g_� ijhbkoh^bl� k^\b]Z� diZkkb\ghklb�� dhlhjuc� hldju\Z_l� ih\hjhl� d `_gkl\_gghklb�� DjZcgbf� ijhy\e_gb_f� wlh]hdhfie_dkZ� fm`_kl\_gghklb� dZ`_lky� gZf� \ebygb_� gZ� \u[hj� h[t_dlZ� \ kfuke_� hldjulh]h]hfhk_dkmZebafZ�� Ohly� ZgZeblbq_kdbc� hiul� ihdZau\Z_l� gZf�� qlh� `_gkdbc� ]hfhk_dkmZebafj_^dh� beb� gbdh]^Z� g_� ijh^he`Z_l� ijyfh� bgnZglbevgmx� fm`_kl\_gghklv�� Kx^Z� `_�� ih�\b^bfhfm��hlghkblky�b lh��qlh�b lZdb_�^_\mrdb�gZ�g_dhlhjh_�\j_fy�ijbgbfZxl�hlpZ�\ dZq_kl\_h[t_dlZ�b ihiZ^Zxl� \ w^bih\m� kblmZpbx��Gh� aZl_f� \ke_^kl\b_�g_ba[_`guo� jZahqZjh\Zgbc� \hlp_�hgb�\ugm`^_gu�j_]j_kkbjh\Zlv�d k\h_fm�jZgg_fm�dhfie_dkm�fm`_kl\_gghklb��G_�ke_^m_li_j_hp_gb\Zlv� agZq_gb_� wlbo� jZahqZjh\Zgbc�� bo� g_� fbgm_l� b ^_\mrdZ�� kdehggZy� d`_gkl\_gghklb��gh�[_a�lh]h�`_�j_amevlZlZ��Ij_\hkoh^ysZy�kbeZ�dhgklblmpbhgZevgh]h�nZdlhjZdZ`_lky� g_hkihjbfhc�� gh� ^\_� nZau� \ jZa\blbb� `_gkdh]h� ]hfhk_dkmZebafZ� hq_gv� ohjhrhhljZ`Zxlky�\ ijZdlbd_�]hfhk_dkmZebklh\��dhlhju_�lZd�`_�qZklh�b lZd�`_�y\gh�b]jZxl�^jm]�k^jm]hf�\ fZlv�b j_[_gdZ��dZd�b \�fm`qbgm�b `_gsbgm�Lh��qlh�y \Zf�lml�jZkkdZaZe��wlh��lZd�kdZaZlv��ij_^uklhjby�`_gsbgu��Wlh�j_amevlZlu�kZfuoihke_^gbo� e_l�� \hafh`gh�� hgb� aZbgl_j_kmxl� \Zk� dZd� ihiuldZ� djhihleb\hc� ZgZeblbq_kdhcjZ[hlu��LZd�dZd�l_fhc�y\ey_lky�kZfZ�`_gsbgZ��y iha\hex�k_[_�gZ�wlhl�jZa�mihfygmlv�ihbf_gghg_dhlhjuo� `_gsbg�� dhlhjuf� wlh� bkke_^h\Zgb_� h[yaZgh� \Z`gufb� jZ[hlZfb�� >�j Jml� FZd�;jmgk\bd�i_j\hc��������hibkZeZ�kemqZc�g_\jhaZ��bklhdb�dhlhjh]h�ijhke_`b\Zxlky�\ nbdkZpbbgZ�^hw^bih\hc�klZ^bb�b dh]^Z�w^bih\Z�kblmZpby�\hh[s_�g_�[ueZ�^hklb]gmlZ��Hg�bf_e�nhjfmiZjZghcb�j_\ghklb�b hdZaZeky�ih^^Zxsbfky�l_jZibb��>�j @ZggZ�EZfiev�^_�=jm�^hklh\_jgufbgZ[ex^_gbyfb� mklZgh\beZ� ������� klhev�fZeh\_jhylgmx�nZeebq_kdmx� Zdlb\ghklv� ^_\hqdb� ihhlghr_gbx� d fZl_jb�� ^�j ?e_gZ�>_cq�ihdZaZeZ� �������� qlh� ex[h\gu_� Zdlu� ]hfhk_dkmZevguo`_gsbg�\hkijhba\h^yl�hlghr_gby�fZl_jb�b j_[_gdZ�Ijhke_^blv� ^Zevg_cr__� jZa\blb_� `_gkl\_gghklb� q_j_a� iheh\h_� khaj_\Zgb_� \iehlv� ^hi_jbh^Z� aj_ehklb� g_� \oh^bl� \ fhb� gZf_j_gby�� >Z� b gZrb� agZgby� g_^hklZlhqgu� ^ey� wlh]h�G_dhlhju_�q_jlu�y kmffbjmx�gb`_��KkueZykv�gZ�ij_^uklhjbx��y lhevdh�ohqm�ih^q_jdgmlv��qlh

Page 330: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

jZa\blb_� `_gkl\_gghklb� ih�ij_`g_fm� ih^\_j]Z_lky� gZjmr_gbyf� kh� klhjhgu� hklZlhqguoy\e_gbc�ij_^\Zjbl_evgh]h�i_jbh^Z�fm`_kl\_gghklb��J_]j_kkbb� d nbdkZpbyf� l_o� ^hw^bih\uonZa�bf_xl�f_klh�hq_gv�qZklh��\ g_dhlhjuo�bklhjbyo�`bagb�^_eh�^hoh^bl�^h�g_h^ghdjZlgh]hih\lhj_gby�i_jbh^h\��\ dhlhjuo�ij_h[eZ^Z_l�lh�fm`_kl\_gghklv��lh�`_gkl\_gghklv��QZklbqghlh�� qlh� fu�� fm`qbgu�� gZau\Z_f� ©aZ]Z^dhc� `_gsbguª�� \hafh`gh�� \_^_l� gZqZeh� hl� wlh]hijhy\e_gby�[bk_dkmZevghklb�\ `bagb�`_gsbgu��Gh�\h�\j_fy�wlbo�bkke_^h\Zgbc��ih�\b^bfhfm�gZaj_e�^jm]hc�\hijhk��>\b`ms_c�kbehc�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb�fu�gZau\Z_f�eb[b^h��K_dkmZevgZy`bagv� ih^qbg_gZ� iheyjghklb� fm`kdh]h²`_gkdh]h�� lZdbf� h[jZahf�� dZ`_lky� g_h[oh^bfuf\gbfZl_evgh�jZkkfhlj_lv�hlghr_gb_�eb[b^h�d wlhc�iheyjghklb��G_�[ueh�[u�g_h`b^Zgghklvx�_keb�[u�hdZaZehkv��qlh�dZ`^hc�k_dkmZevghklb�ih^qbgy_lky�k\h_�hkh[h_�eb[b^h�� lZd�qlh�h^bg\b^�eb[b^h�ij_ke_^m_l�p_eb�fm`kdhc��Z ^jm]hc�²�p_eb�`_gkdhc�k_dkmZevghc�`bagb��Gh�gbq_]hih^h[gh]h� g_� kms_kl\m_l�� ?klv� lhevdh� h^gh� eb[b^h�� dhlhjh_� kem`bl� dZd� fm`kdhc�� lZd� b`_gkdhc�k_dkmZevghc�nmgdpbb��Fu�g_�fh`_f�kZfb�ijbibkZlv�_fm�ihe��_keb�fu��kh]eZkb\rbkvgZ� hlh`^_kl\e_gb_� Zdlb\ghklb� b fm`_kl\_gghklb�� ih`_eZ_f� gZa\Zlv� _]h� fm`kdbf�� gZf� g_ke_^m_l� aZ[u\Zlv�� qlh� hgh� >eb[b^h@� ij_^klZ\ey_l� lZd`_� klj_fe_gby� d iZkkb\guf� p_eyf�Keh\hkhq_lZgb_� ©`_gkdh_� eb[b^hª� \k_�`_� ebr_gh� \kydh]h� hijZ\^Zgby��Hgh� \uau\Z_l� m gZk\i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� eb[b^h� kl_kgyxl�� dh]^Z� ijbgm`^Zxl� d kem`_gbx�`_gkdhc�nmgdpbb�� b qlhijbjh^Z�� _keb� ]h\hjblv� l_e_heh]bq_kdb��f_g__� k_jv_agh� kqblZ_lky� k __� ijblyaZgbyfb�� q_f� \kemqZ_� fm`_kl\_gghklb�� : wlh�� fukebfh_� hiylv�lZdb� l_e_heh]bq_kdb�� fh`_l� bf_lv� k\h_hkgh\Zgb_�\ lhf��qlh�ijh\_^_gb_�\ `bagv�[bheh]bq_kdhc�p_eb�\\_jy_lky�Z]j_kkbb�fm`qbgu�bg_dhlhjuf�h[jZahf�g_aZ\bkbfh�hl�kh]eZkby�`_gsbgu�K_dkmZevgZy� njb]b^ghklv� `_gsbgu�� qZklhlZ� dhlhjhc�� dZ`_lky�� ih^l\_j`^Z_l� wlhij_g_[j_`_gb_�� y\ey_lky� \k_]h� ebrv� g_^hklZlhqgh� ihgyluf� n_ghf_ghf�� Bgh]^Z� hgZ� ghkblikboh]_gguc� oZjZdl_j� b lh]^Z� ih^\eZklgZ� \ha^_ckl\bx�� \ ^jm]bo� kemqZyo� hgZ� iha\hey_lij_^iheZ]Zlv�dhgklblmpbhgZevgmx�h[mkeh\e_gghklv�b ^Z`_�\deZ^�ZgZlhfbq_kdh]h�nZdlhjZ�Y h[_sZe� jZkkdZaZlv� \Zf� _s_� h g_dhlhjuo� ikbobq_kdbo� hkh[_gghklyo� aj_ehc`_gkl\_gghklb�� dZd� hgb� ijhy\eyxlky� ijb� ZgZeblbq_kdhf� gZ[ex^_gbb�� Fu� g_� ij_l_g^m_fwlbfb�ml\_j`^_gbyfb�gZ�hdhgqZl_evgmx�bklbgm��djhf_�lh]h��g_�\k_]^Z�e_]dh�hl^_eblv�lh��qlhfh`gh�ijbibkZlv�\ebygbx�k_dkmZevghc�nmgdpbb��Z qlh�²�khpbZevghfm�\hkiblZgbx��BlZd��fuijbibku\Z_f� `_gkl\_gghklb� [he__� \ukhdmx� kl_i_gv� gZjpbkkbafZ�� dhlhjZy� b \eby_l� gZ� __\u[hj�h[t_dlZ��lZd�qlh�[ulv�ex[bfhc�^ey�`_gsbgu�²�[he__�kbevgZy�ihlj_[ghklv��q_f�ex[blv�< nbabq_kdhf�ls_keZ\bb�`_gsbgu�\k_�_s_�kdZau\Z_lky�^_ckl\b_�aZ\bklb�d i_gbkm��ihkdhevdmk\hb� ij_e_klb� hgZ� l_f� [he__� \ukhdh� p_gbl�� qlh� hgb� ij_^klZ\eyxlky� _c� dhfi_gkZpb_c� aZi_j\hgZqZevgmx� k_dkmZevgmx� g_iheghp_gghklv�� Klu^eb\hklb�� dhlhjZy� kqblZ_lkyhlebqbl_evguf�`_gkdbf�dZq_kl\hf��gh�y\ey_lky�]hjZa^h�[he__�h[mkeh\e_gghc�ljZ^bpbyfb��q_fke_^h\Zeh�[u�^mfZlv��fu�ijbibku\Z_f�i_j\hgZqZevgh_�gZf_j_gb_� kdjulv�^_n_dl� ]_gblZebc�Fu�g_�aZ[u\Z_f��qlh�iha^g__�hgZ�ijbgyeZ�gZ�k_[y�^jm]b_�nmgdpbb��IheZ]Zxl��qlh�`_gsbgu\g_keb�f_gvrbc�\deZ^�\ hldjulby�b bah[j_l_gby�bklhjbb�dmevlmju��gh��fh`_l�[ulv��bf_gghhgb�hldjueb�h^bg�\b^�l_ogbdb�²�l_ogbdm�ie_l_gby�b ldZq_kl\Z��?keb�wlh�lZd��lh�ihiulZ_fkyhl]Z^Zlv� [_kkhagZl_evguc� fhlb\� wlh]h� ^hklb`_gby�� KZfZ� ijbjh^Z� dZd� [m^lh� ih^Z_l� ijbf_jlZdhfm� ih^jZ`Zgbx�� aZklZ\eyy� ]_gblZebb� k gZklmie_gb_f� iheh\hc� aj_ehklb� h[jZklZlv\hehkZfb�� kdju\Zxsbfb� bo��RZ]�� dhlhjuc� gZ^h� [ueh� k^_eZlv� ^Ze__�� khklhye� \ lhf�� qlh[u

Page 331: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

kdj_iblv�\hehdgZ�^jm]�k ^jm]hf��dhlhju_�gZ� l_e_�\uklmiZeb�ba�dh`b�b [ueb�ebrv� kimlZgu�?keb� wlZ� g_h`b^ZggZy� fukev� dZ`_lky� \Zf� nZglZklbqghc� b \u� kqblZ_l_� \ebygb_� hlkmlkl\byi_gbkZ�gZ�nhjfbjh\Zgb_�`_gkl\_gghklb�fh_c�b^__c IL[� lh�y��_kl_kl\_ggh��h[_ahjm`_g���Mkeh\by� \u[hjZ� h[t_dlZ� `_gsbghc� ^hklZlhqgh� qZklh� ^h� g_magZ\Z_fhklb� baf_gyxlkykhpbZevgufb�hlghr_gbyfb��LZf��]^_�hg�fh`_l�ijhy\blvky�k\h[h^gh��hg�qZklh�ijhbkoh^bl�ihgZjpbkklbq_kdhfm� b^_Zem� fm`qbgu�� dhlhjuf� ^_\mrdZ� ohl_eZ� klZlv�� ?keb� ^_\mrdZhklZgh\beZkv�gZ�ijb\yaZgghklb�d hlpm��l��_��gZ�W^bih\hf�dhfie_dk_��lh�hgZ�\u[_j_l�_]h�ih�lbimhlpZ��Ihkdhevdm�ijb�i_j_oh^_�hl�fZl_jb�d hlpm�\jZ`^_[ghklv�Zf[b\Ze_glgh]h�wfhpbhgZevgh]hhlghr_gby�hklZeZkv�gZijZ\e_gghc�gZ�fZlv��lZdhc�\u[hj�^he`_g�h[_ki_qblv�kqZkleb\uc�[jZd�Gh� hq_gv� qZklh� kemqZ_lky� lh�� qlh� \hh[s_� klZ\bl� ih^� m]jham� ih^h[gh_� jZaj_r_gb_Zf[b\Ze_glgh]h� dhgnebdlZ�� KhojZgb\rZyky� \jZ`^_[ghklv� ke_^m_l� aZ� iheh`bl_evghcijb\yaZgghklvx�b i_j_oh^bl�gZ�gh\uc�h[t_dl��Kmijm]��dhlhjuc�kgZqZeZ�ihemqZ_l�\ gZke_^kl\hqm\kl\Z� d hlpm�� kh� \j_f_g_f� gZke_^m_l� b qm\kl\Z� d fZl_jb�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� e_]dh� fh`_lijhbahclb�lh��qlh�\lhjmx�iheh\bgm�`bagb�`_gsbgu�aZihegy_l�[hjv[Z�ijhlb\�k\h_]h�fm`Z��dZdi_j\mx�� [he__� dhjhldmx�²� khijhlb\e_gb_� ih� hlghr_gbx� d k\h_c� fZl_jb�� Ihke_� lh]h� dZdj_Zdpby�ba`blZ��\lhjhc�[jZd�fh`_l�e_]dh�keh`blvky�]hjZa^h�[he__�m^h\e_l\hjbl_evgh��>jm]hcih\hjhl�\ kmsghklb�`_gsbgu��d dhlhjhfm�g_�ih^]hlh\e_gu�ex[ysb_��fh`_l�ijhbahclb�ihke_jh`^_gby�\ [jZd_�i_j\h]h�j_[_gdZ��Ih^�\i_qZle_gb_f�kh[kl\_ggh]h�fZl_jbgkl\Z�fh`_l�kgh\Zh`blv� b^_glbnbdZpby� k kh[kl\_gghc�fZl_jvx�� dhlhjhc�`_gsbgZ� \iehlv� ^h� [jZdZ� hdZau\ZeZkhijhlb\e_gb_��b ijb\e_qv�d k_[_�\k_�bf_xs__ky�eb[b^h��lZd�qlh�k gZ\yaqb\uf�ih\lhj_gb_fj_ijh^mpbjm_lky�g_kqZklguc�[jZd�jh^bl_e_c��Lh��qlh�ij_`gbc�nZdlhj�hlkmlkl\by�i_gbkZ�\k__s_�g_�mljZlbe�k\h_c�kbeu��h[gZjm`b\Z_lky�\ g_h^bgZdh\hc�j_Zdpbb�fZl_jb�gZ�jh`^_gb_�kugZbeb�^hq_jb��Lhevdh�hlghr_gb_�d kugm�ijbghkbl�fZl_jb�g_h]jZgbq_ggh_�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_��hgh\hh[s_�y\ey_lky�ba�\k_o�q_eh\_q_kdbo�hlghr_gbc�kZfuf�kh\_jr_gguf�b gZb[he__�k\h[h^gufhl�Zf[b\Ze_glghklb��GZ�kugZ�fZlv�fh`_l�i_j_g_klb�k\h_�q_klhex[b_��dhlhjh_�hgZ�^he`gZ�[ueZih^Z\blv�\ k_[_��hl�g_]h�hgZ�`^_l�m^h\e_l\hj_gby�\k_]h�lh]h��qlh�hklZehkv�m g__�hl�dhfie_dkZfm`_kl\_gghklb��>Z`_�[jZd�g_evay� kqblZlv�mklhcqb\uf��ihdZ�`_gsbg_�g_�m^Zklky� k^_eZlv�bfm`Z�k\hbf�j_[_gdhf�b jZau]ju\Zlv�i_j_^�gbf�fZlv�B^_glbnbdZpby�`_gsbgu�k fZl_jvx�iha\hey_l�jZaebqblv�^\Z�kehy�²�^hw^bih\��dhlhjuchkgh\Zg� gZ� g_`ghc� ijb\yaZgghklb� d fZl_jb�� kqblZxsbcky� h[jZaphf�� b [he__� iha^gbc� baW^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ��dh]^Z�fZlv�mkljZgy_lky�b aZf_gy_lky�hlphf��Fgh]h_�hl�h[hbo�hklZ_lky�^ey[m^ms_]h�� b fh`gh� ih�ijZ\m� kdZaZlv�� qlh� gb h^bg� g_�ij_h^he_\Z_lky� \ ijhp_kk_� jZa\blby� \^hklZlhqghc� f_j_�� Gh� nZaZ� g_`ghc� ^hw^bih\hc� ijb\yaZgghklb� y\ey_lky� ^ey� [m^ms_]h`_gsbgu� j_rZxs_c�� \ g_c� ih^]hlZ\eb\Z_lky� ijbh[j_l_gb_� l_o� dZq_kl\�� [eZ]h^Zjy� dhlhjufhgZ� iha^g__� [m^_l� khhl\_lkl\h\Zlv� k\h_c� jheb� \ k_dkmZevghc� nmgdpbb� b ^hklb]ZlvihjZabl_evguo� khpbZevguo� mki_oh\�� < wlhc� b^_glbnbdZpbb� hgZ� ijbh[j_lZ_l� lZd`_ijb\e_dZl_evghklv�^ey�fm`qbgu��dhlhjZy�ij_\jZsZ_l�_]h�w^bih\m�ijb\yaZgghklv�d fZl_jb�\h\ex[e_gghklv��Ebrv�lh]^Z�kug�aZqZklmx�ihemqZ_l�lh��q_]h�hg�^h[b\Zeky�^ey�k_[y��Kha^Z_lky\i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� ex[h\v� fm`qbgu� b ex[h\v� `_gsbgu� jZa^_eyxlky� ikboheh]bq_kdbfjZaebqb_f�nZa�Lh�� qlh� `_gsbg_� fZeh� k\hckl\_ggh� qm\kl\h� kijZ\_^eb\hklb�� k\yaZgh� k ij_h[eZ^Zgb_f

Page 332: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

aZ\bklb�\ __�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��ihlhfm�qlh�lj_[h\Zgb_�kijZ\_^eb\hklb�i_j_jZ[Zlu\Z_l�aZ\bklv�kha^Z\Zy�mkeh\b_��ijb�dhlhjhf�hl�g__�fh`gh�hldZaZlvky��Fu�]h\hjbf�h `_gsbgZo�lZd`_��qlh�bokhpbZevgu_�bgl_j_ku� keZ[__�� Z kihkh[ghklv� d km[ebfZpbb� \e_q_gbc�f_gvr_�� q_f� m fm`qbg�I_j\h_�� ijZ\^Z�� ijhbkl_dZ_l� ba� ZkhpbZevgh]h� oZjZdl_jZ�� dhlhjuc�� g_khfg_ggh�� ijbkms� \k_fk_dkmZevguf�hlghr_gbyf��Ex[ysb_�gZoh^yl�m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�^jm]�\ ^jm]_��b ^Z`_�k_fvy�_s_ijhlb\blky� ijbgylbx� \ [he__�rbjhdb_� khh[s_kl\Z��Kihkh[ghklv� d km[ebfZpbb� ih^\_j`_gZkZfuf� agZqbl_evguf� bg^b\b^mZevguf� dhe_[Zgbyf�� Y g_� fh]m� g_� mihfygmlv� \i_qZle_gby�dhlhjh_�\k_�\j_fy�ihemqZ_rv�ijb�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�^_yl_evghklb��Fm`qbgZ�hdheh�ljb^pZlb�e_lij_^klZ\ey_lky� fheh^uf�� kdhj__� g_aj_euf� bg^b\b^mmfhf�� hl� dhlhjh]h� fu� `^_f�� qlh� hg� \iheghc�f_j_�bkihevam_l�\hafh`ghklb�jZa\blby��dhlhju_� _fm�hldju\Z_l� ZgZeba��Gh�`_gsbgZlh]h�`_�\hajZklZ�qZklh�im]Z_l�gZk�k\h_c�ikbobq_kdhc�aZdhkl_g_ehklvx�b g_baf_gy_fhklvx��?_eb[b^h�aZgyeh�hdhgqZl_evgu_�ihabpbb�b dZ`_lky�g_�kihkh[guf�hklZ\blv�bo�jZ^b�^jm]bo��Iml_c^ey� ^Zevg_cr_]h� jZa\blby� g_l�� ^_eh� h[klhbl� lZd�� dZd� [m^lh� \_kv� ijhp_kk� m`_� aZdhgq_g�� g_fh`_l�ih^\_j]gmlvky�hlgug_�gbdZdhfm�\ha^_ckl\bx�b ^Z`_�dZd�[m^lh�ljm^gh_�jZa\blb_�gZ�imlbd `_gkl\_gghklb� bkq_jiZeh� \hafh`ghklb� ebqghklb�� Fu� dZd� l_jZi_\lu� `Zem_fky� gZ� wlhiheh`_gb_�\_s_c��^Z`_�_keb�gZf�m^Z_lky�mkljZgblv�g_^m]�iml_f�jZaj_r_gby�g_\jhlbq_kdh]hdhgnebdlZ�Wlh� \k_�� qlh� y ohl_e� \Zf� kdZaZlv� h `_gkl\_gghklb�� JZamf__lky�� \k_� wlh� g_ihegh� bnjZ]f_glZjgh��^Z�b g_�\k_]^Z�ijbylgh�a\mqbl��G_�aZ[u\Zcl_��qlh�fu�hibkZeb�`_gsbgm�ebrv�\lhc�f_j_��\ dZdhc�__ kmsghklv�hij_^_ey_lky�__ k_dkmZevghc�nmgdpb_c��Wlh�\ebygb_� aZoh^bl�ijZ\^Z�� hq_gv� ^Ze_dh�� gh� fu� bf__f� \ \b^m�� qlh� hl^_evgZy� `_gsbgZ� \k_� jZ\gh� fh`_l� [ulvq_eh\_q_kdbf�kms_kl\hf��?keb�\u�ohlbl_�agZlv�h `_gkl\_gghklb�[hevr_��lh�kijhkbl_�h[�wlhfkh[kl\_gguc�`bag_gguc�hiul��beb�h[jZlbl_kv�d ihwlZf��beb�ih^h`^bl_��ihdZ�gZmdZ�g_�^Zkl�\Zf[he__�]em[hdb_�b emqr_�kh]eZkmxsb_ky�^jm]�k ^jm]hf�k\_^_gby�LJB>P:LV�Q?L<?JL:Y�E?DPBYH[tykg_gby��ijbeh`_gby��hjb_glZpbbM\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Iha\hevl_� fg_� \f_klh�� lZd� kdZaZlv�� kmoh]h� baeh`_gbyfZl_jbZeZ�ih[_k_^h\Zlv�k \Zfb�h \_sZo��bf_xsbo�hq_gv�fZeh�l_hj_lbq_kdh]h�agZq_gby��gh�\k_�lZdb� [ebadh� dZkZxsboky� \Zk�� ihkdhevdm� \u� \_^v� ^jm`_kdb� gZkljh_gu� ih� hlghr_gbx� dikbohZgZebam"� Ij_^klZ\bf� k_[_�� gZijbf_j�� kemqZc�� dh]^Z� \u� \ qZku� ^hkm]Z� [_j_l_� \ jmdbg_f_pdbc��Zg]ebckdbc�beb�Zf_jbdZgkdbc�jhfZg��h`b^Zy�gZclb�\ g_f�hibkZgb_�ex^_c�b \_s_cgZ� k_]h^gyrgbc� ^_gv�� Q_j_a� g_kdhevdh� kljZgbp� \u� gZlZedb\Z_l_kv� gZ� i_j\h_� km`^_gb_� hikbohZgZeba_��Z aZl_f�b gZ�^jm]b_��^Z`_�_keb�ba�dhgl_dklZ�wlh��ih�\b^bfhfm��g_�\ul_dZ_l��G_^mfZcl_�� qlh� j_qv� b^_l� h[� bkihevah\Zgbb� ]em[bgghc� ikboheh]bb� ^ey� emqr_]h� ihgbfZgby^_ckl\mxsbo�ebp�beb�bo�ihklmidh\��ohly�kms_kl\mxl�b [he__�k_jv_agu_�khqbg_gby��\ dhlhjuowlb�ihiuldb�^_ckl\bl_evgh�bf_xlky��G_l��ih�[hevr_c�qZklb�wlh�ebrv�bjhgbq_kdb_�aZf_qZgby�dhlhjufb� Z\lhj� jhfZgZ� ohq_l� ihdZaZlv� k\hx� gZqblZgghklv� beb� bgl_ee_dlmZevgh_ij_\hkoh^kl\h��B ^Ze_dh�g_�\k_]^Z�m \Zk�\hagbdZ_l�\i_qZle_gb_��qlh�hg�^_ckl\bl_evgh�agZ_l�lh�h q_f�\ukdZau\Z_lky��Beb�\u�b^_l_�\ ^jm`_kdmx�dhfiZgbx�hl^hogmlv��wlh�fh`_l�[ulv�b g_�\

Page 333: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

<_g_��Q_j_a� g_dhlhjh_� \j_fy� jZa]h\hj� i_j_oh^bl� gZ� ikbohZgZeba�� b \u� keurbl_�� dZd� kZfu_jZaebqgu_� ex^b� \ukdZau\Zxl� k\h_� km`^_gb_� ih� [hevr_c� qZklb� \ lhg_� g_khfg_gghcm\_j_gghklb��Km`^_gb_�wlh�h[uqgh�ij_g_[j_`bl_evgh_��qZklh�[jZgv��ih�f_gvr_c�f_j_��\gh\vgZkf_rdZ��?keb�\u�[m^_l_�lZd�g_hklhjh`gu�b \u^Z^bl_��qlh�dh_�qlh�ihgbfZ_l_�\ ij_^f_l_��gZ\Zk�\k_�gZdbgmlky��lj_[my�k\_^_gbc�b h[tykg_gbc��b q_j_a�g_dhlhjh_�\j_fy�\u�m[_^bl_kv��qlh\k_�wlb�kljh]b_�ijb]h\hju�hlklmiZxl�i_j_^�ex[hc�bgnhjfZpb_c��qlh�_^\Z�eb�ohlv�h^bg�ba�wlboijhlb\gbdh\� [jZe� \ jmdb� ohly� [u� h^gm� ZgZeblbq_kdmx� dgb]m�� Z _keb� \k_�lZdb� [jZe�� lh� g_ij_h^he_e�i_j\h]h�`_�khijhlb\e_gby�ijb�agZdhfkl\_�k gh\uf�fZl_jbZehf�Hl� \\_^_gby� \ ikbohZgZeba� \u�� fh`_l� [ulv�� b `^_l_� mdZaZgby�� dZdb_� Zj]mf_glubkihevah\Zlv�^ey�bkijZ\e_gby�y\gh�hrb[hqguo�fg_gbc�h[�ZgZeba_��dZdb_�dgb]b�j_dhf_g^h\Zlv^ey� emqr_]h� hagZdhfe_gby� k gbf� beb� `_� dZdb_� ijbf_ju� ba� ebl_jZlmju� beb� \Zr_]h� hiulZke_^m_l� ijb\h^blv� \ ^bkdmkkbb�� qlh[u� baf_gblv� mklZgh\dm� h[s_kl\Z�� Gh� y ijhrm� \Zk�� g_^_eZcl_� gbq_]h� wlh]h�� Wlh� [ueh� [u� [_kihe_agh�� emqr_� \k_]h� \Zf� \hh[s_� kdjulv� k\hxhk\_^hfe_gghklv��?keb�`_�wlh�m`_�g_\hafh`gh��lh�h]jZgbqvl_kv�l_f��qlh�kdZ`bl_��gZkdhevdh\Zf� ba\_klgh�� ikbohZgZeba� ²� hkh[Zy� hljZkev� agZgby�� hq_gv� ljm^gZy� ^ey� ihgbfZgby� bh[km`^_gby��b aZgbfZ_lky� hg� hq_gv� k_jv_agufb� \_sZfb�� lZd� qlh�rmlblv� a^_kv�g_q_]h�� Z ^eyim[ebqguo� jZa\e_q_gbc� emqr_� ihbkdZlv� ^jm]mx� b]jmrdm��B dhg_qgh� `_� g_� mqZ\kl\mckl_� \ihiuldZo�lhedh\Zgbc��_keb�g_hklhjh`gu_�ex^b�jZkkdZ`ml�k\hb�kgh\b^_gby��b g_�ih^^Z\Zcl_kvbkdmr_gbx�\_j[h\Zlv�klhjhggbdh\�ZgZebaZ�khh[s_gbyfb�h kemqZyo�\ua^hjh\e_gby�Gh�\u�fh`_l_�kijhkblv��ihq_fm�wlb�ex^b��dZd�ibrmsb_�dgb]b��lZd�b \_^msb_�jZa]h\hju�\_^ml�k_[y�lZd�g_dhjj_dlgh��b kdehgbl_kv�d ij_^iheh`_gbx��qlh�^_eh�g_�lhevdh�\ ex^yo��gh�b \ikbohZgZeba_�lh`_��Y ^mfZx�h[�wlhf�lhqgh�lZd�`_��lh��qlh�\ ebl_jZlmj_�b h[s_kl\_�\uklmiZ_l^ey�\Zk�dZd�ij_^jZkkm^hd�²�wlh�ihke_^kl\by�ij_^r_kl\mxs_]h�km`^_gby��Z bf_ggh�km`^_gby�dhlhjh_� iha\heyeb� k_[_� ij_^klZ\bl_eb� hnbpbZevghc� gZmdb� h fheh^hf� ikbohZgZeba_�� Y m`_h^gZ`^u�`Zeh\Zeky�gZ�wlh�\ h^ghc�bklhjbq_kdhc�jZ[hl_�b g_�[m^m�^_eZlv�wlh]h�\gh\v�²�[ulvfh`_l��b wlh]h�h^gh]h�lh�jZaZ�kebrdhf�fgh]h�²�gh�ihbklbg_�g_�[ueh�gb�h^gh]h�gZjmr_gbyaZdhgh\� eh]bdb�� jZ\gh� dZd� b gb� h^gh]h� gZjmr_gby� ijZ\be� ijbebqby� b ohjhr_]h� lhgZ�� ddhlhjhfm�g_�ijb[_]Zeb�lh]^Z�gZmqgu_�ijhlb\gbdb�ikbohZgZebaZ��KblmZpby�[ueZ�dZd�\ kj_^gb_\_dZ�� dh]^Z� ij_klmigbdZ� beb� ^Z`_� \k_]h� ebrv� iheblbq_kdh]h� ijhlb\gbdZ� ijb]\h`^Zeb� dihahjghfm� klhe[m�b hl^Z\Zeb�gZ�ihjm]Zgb_�q_jgb��B \u��fh`_l�[ulv��g_�ij_^klZ\ey_l_� k_[_hlq_leb\h�� gZkdhevdh� \ gZr_f� h[s_kl\_� jZkijhkljZgy_lky� ^mjghc� lhg� b dZdb_� [_ah[jZabyiha\heyxl� k_[_� ex^b�� _keb� hgb� dZd� qZklv� h[s_c�fZkku� qm\kl\mxl� k_[y� hk\h[h`^_ggufb� hlebqghc� hl\_lkl\_gghklb�� D gZqZem� l_o� \j_f_g� y [ue� ^h\hevgh� h^bghd�� \kdhj_� m\b^_e�� qlhihe_fbdZ�g_�bf__l�gbdZdbo�i_jki_dlb\��b qlh�^Z`_�kZfhh[\bg_gb_�b Zi_eebjh\Zgb_�d emqrbfmfZf�[_kihe_agh��lZd�dZd�ijhklh�g_�kms_kl\m_l�gbdZdbo�bgklZgpbc��dhlhju_�^he`gu�[ueb�[ujZkkfZljb\Zlv� `Zeh[m�� Lh]^Z� y ihr_e� ^jm]bf� iml_f�� y \i_j\u_� ijbf_gbe� ikbohZgZeba�h[tykgb\� k_[_� ih\_^_gb_� fZkku� n_ghf_ghf� lh]h� `_� kZfh]h� khijhlb\e_gby�� k dhlhjuf� y[hjheky�m hl^_evguo�iZpb_glh\��kZf�\ha^_j`b\Zeky�hl�ihe_fbdb�b hdZau\Ze�\ebygb_�\ lhf�`_gZijZ\e_gbb�gZ�k\hbo�klhjhggbdh\��dhlhju_�ihkl_i_ggh�ihy\eyebkv��F_lh^�[ue�ohjhr��hiZeZ�\ dhlhjmx�ihiZe�lh]^Z�ZgZeba��k l_o�ihj�[ueZ�kgylZ��gh�dZd�hklZ\e_ggZy�\_jZ�ijh^he`Z_l�`blv�\km_\_jbb�� Z hl\_j]gmlZy� gZmdhc� l_hjby� khojZgy_lky� \ gZjh^ghf� fg_gbb�� lZd� b lhli_j\hgZqZevguc�[hcdhl�ikbohZgZebaZ�gZmqgufb�djm]Zfb�ijh^he`Z_lky�k_]h^gy�\ bjhgbq_kdhf

Page 334: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ij_g_[j_`_gbb�ibrmsbo�dgb]b�b \_^msbo�[_k_^u�ex[bl_e_c��LZd�qlh�g_�m^b\eycl_kv�wlhfm�Gh�b g_�gZ^_cl_kv�mkeurZlv�jZ^hklgh_�ba\_klb_��qlh�[hjv[Z�aZ�ZgZeba�aZdhgq_gZ�b ijb\_eZ\f_kl_�k ijbagZgb_f�_]h�dZd�gZmdb�d ij_ih^Z\Zgbx�_]h�dZd�mq_[gh]h�fZl_jbZeZ�\ mgb\_jkbl_l_�H[�wlhf�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�b j_qb��hgZ�ijh^he`Z_lky��lhevdh�\ [he__�\_`eb\uo�nhjfZo��Gh\ufy\ey_lky� lZd`_� lh��qlh�\ gZmqghf�h[s_kl\_�h[jZah\Zeky�g_dbc� Zfhjlbabjmxsbc� kehc�f_`^mZgZebahf�b _]h�ijhlb\gbdZfb��ex^b��dhlhju_�^himkdZxl�gZebqb_�q_]h�lh�p_ggh]h�\ ZgZeba_�ijbagZxl� wlh� ijb� [eZ]hijbylguo� mkeh\byo�� aZlh� g_� ijb_fexl� ^jm]h_�� h q_f� hgb� g_� fh]mlaZy\blv� \h� \k_mkeurZgb_��Qlh� hij_^_ey_l�bo� \u[hj�� g_e_]dh� jZa]Z^Zlv��<b^bfh�� wlh� ebqgu_kbfiZlbb��H^gh]h�jZa^jZ`Z_l� k_dkmZevghklv��^jm]h]h�²�[_kkhagZl_evgh_��hkh[_ggh��dZ`_lky�g_\aex[beb� nZdl� kbf\hebdb�� Lh�� qlh� a^Zgb_� ikbohZgZebaZ�� ohly� _s_� g_� aZ\_jr_ggh_�� m`_k_]h^gy�ij_^klZ\ey_l�kh[hc�_^bgkl\h��ba�dhlhjh]h�g_evay�ijhba\hevgh�\u[jZku\Zlv�hl^_evgu_we_f_glu��wlbfb�wde_dlbdZfb��dZ`_lky��g_�mqblu\Z_lky��Gb�hl�h^gh]h�ba�wlbo�ihem��b q_l\_jlvijb\_j`_gp_\�y g_�ihemqbe�\i_qZle_gby��qlh�bo�hldZa�hkgh\Zg�gZ�ijh\_jd_��>Z`_�g_dhlhju_\u^Zxsb_ky�fm`b�hlghkylky�d wlhc�dZl_]hjbb��IjZ\^Z��bo�ba\bgy_l�lhl�nZdl��qlh�bo�\j_fy��dZdb bo�bgl_j_k��ihk\ys_gu�^jm]bf�\_sZf��Z bf_ggh�l_f��\ j_r_gbb�dhlhjuo�hgb�^hklb]eb�klhevagZqbl_evguo�mki_oh\��Gh�g_�emqr_�lh]^Z�[ueh�[u�bf�\ha^_j`Zlvky�hl�km`^_gby��\f_klh�lh]hqlh[u� \uklmiZlv� klhev� j_rbl_evgh�� H^gh]h� ba� wlbo� \_ebdbo� ex^_c� fg_� m^Zehkv� h^gZ`^u[ukljh�h[jZlblv�\ k\hx�\_jm��Wlh�[ue�\k_fbjgh�ba\_klguc�djblbd��dhlhjuc�k [eZ]hkdehgguf�\gbfZgb_f� b ijhjhq_kdb� hkljuf� \a]ey^hf� ke_^be� aZ� ^moh\gufb� l_q_gbyfb� \j_f_gb�� YihagZdhfbeky� k gbf� lhevdh� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� _fm� [ueh� aZ� \hk_fv^_kyl�� gh� hg� [ue� \k_� _s_hqZjh\Zl_evguf�kh[_k_^gbdhf��<u�e_]dh�^h]Z^Z_l_kv��dh]h�y bf_x�\ \b^m��G_�y i_j\uc�aZ\_ejZa]h\hj�h ikbohZgZeba_��wlh�k^_eZe�hg��h[jZsZykv�dh�fg_�kZfuf�kdjhfguf�h[jZahf��©Y lhevdhebl_jZlhj�²� kdZaZe� hg�²� Z <u� ²� _kl_kl\hbkiulZl_ev� b i_j\hhldju\Zl_ev��Gh� y ohqm� <ZfkdZaZlv�h^gh��y gbdh]^Z�g_�bf_e�k_dkmZevguo�qm\kl\�d k\h_c�fZl_jbª��©Gh�<u�kh\_jr_ggh�b g_h[yaZgu�h gbo�agZlv�²�\hajZabe�y�²�\_^v�^ey�\ajhkeuo�wlh�[_kkhagZl_evgu_�ijhp_kkuª��©:o�<u� lZd� wlh� ihgbfZ_lky�kdZaZe� hg� h[e_]q_ggh� b ih`Ze� fhx� jmdm��Fu� [_k_^h\Zeb� \ ^h[jhfkh]eZkbb�_s_�g_kdhevdh�qZkh\��Iha^g__�y keurZe��qlh�aZ�lhl�dhjhldbc�hklZlhd�`bagb��dhlhjuc_fm� km`^_gh� [ueh� _s_� ijh`blv�� hg� g_h^ghdjZlgh� ^jm`_kdb� hlau\Zeky� h[� ZgZeba_� b hohlghmihlj_[eye�gh\h_�^ey�g_]h�keh\h�©\ul_kg_gb_ª�Ba\_klgh_�baj_q_gb_�gZihfbgZ_l��qlh�gZ^h�bamqZlv�k\hbo�\jZ]h\��IjbagZxkv��fg_�gbdh]^Zwlh�g_�m^Z\Zehkv��gh�y \k_�`_�^mfZe��qlh�^ey�\Zk�[ueh�[u�ihmqbl_evguf��_keb�[u�y ij_^ijbgyek \Zfb� ijh\_jdm� \k_o� mij_dh\� b \hajZ`_gbc�� dhlhju_� ijhlb\gbdb� ikbohZgZebaZ� \u^\b]Zebijhlb\�g_]h��b mdZaZe� [u�gZ� >bo@� lZd� e_]dh� h[gZjm`b\Z_fmx�g_kijZ\_^eb\hklv�b gZjmr_gbyeh]bdb��Gh RQ�VHFRQG�WKRXJKWV y kdZaZe�k_[_��wlh�[ueh�[u�kh\k_f�g_�bgl_j_kgh��Z mlhfbl_evghb g_ijbylgh��b bf_ggh�ihwlhfm�\k_�wlb�]h^u�y lsZl_evgh�ba[_]Ze�wlh]h��BlZd��ba\bgbl_�f_gy �Ih�aj_ehf�jZafure_gbb��Zg]e���²Ijbf_q��i_j�aZ� lh�� qlh� y g_� ke_^mx� ^Ze__� wlbf� iml_f� b ba[Z\eyx� \Zk� hl� km`^_gbc� gZrbo� lZdgZau\Z_fuo�ijhlb\gbdh\��<_^v�j_qv�ihqlb�\k_]^Z�b^_l�h ebpZo��_^bgkl\_gguf�ih^l\_j`^_gb_fd\ZebnbdZpbb� dhlhjuo� y\ey_lky� [_kijbkljZklghklv�� dhlhjmx� hgb� khojZgbeb� [eZ]h^ZjyhlkljZg_gbx�hl�hiulZ�ikbohZgZebaZ��Gh�y agZx��qlh�fg_�g_�lZd�e_]dh�[m^_l�hl^_eZlvky�\ ^jm]bokemqZyo�� <u� ihklZ\bl_� fg_� \ mij_d�� \_^v� _klv� lZd� fgh]h� ebp�� d dhlhjuf� \Zr_� ihke_^g__

Page 335: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

aZf_qZgb_�g_�ih^oh^bl��Hgb�g_�hldZaZebkv�hl�ZgZeblbq_kdh]h�hiulZ���ZgZebabjh\Zeb�iZpb_glh\�fh`_l�[ulv��kZfb�ih^\_j]ebkv�ZgZebam��[ueb�dZdh_�lh�\j_fy�\Zrbfb�khljm^gbdZfb�b \k_�lZdbijbreb� d ^jm]bf� \haaj_gbyf� b l_hjbyf�� gZ� hkgh\Zgbb� dhlhjuo� hlhreb� hl� \Zk� b hkgh\ZebkZfhklhyl_evgu_�rdheu�ikbohZgZebaZ��H \hafh`ghklb�b agZq_gbb�wlbo�^\b`_gbc�hloh^Z��klhevqZkluo�\ oh^_�jZa\blby�ZgZebaZ��\u�^he`gu�[ueb�[u�^Zlv�gZf�h[tykg_gb_�>Z��y ihiulZxkv�wlh�k^_eZlv��ijZ\^Z��\djZlp_��ihlhfm�qlh�^ey�ihgbfZgby�ikbohZgZebaZ�wlh^Zkl�f_gvr_��q_f�\u�^mfZ_l_��Y agZx��qlh�\ i_j\mx�hq_j_^v�\u�bf__l_�\ \b^m�bg^b\b^mZevgmxikboheh]bx�:^e_jZ��dhlhjZy�\ :f_jbd_��gZijbf_j��jZkkfZljb\Z_lky�dZd�ijZ\hfhqgZy�ih[hqgZyebgby�gZr_]h�ikbohZgZebaZ�b h[uqgh�mihfbgZ_lky�\f_kl_�k gbf��< ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�hdZ�bf__lk gbf� hq_gv�fZeh� h[s_]h�� gh� \ke_^kl\b_� hij_^_e_gguo� bklhjbq_kdbo� h[klhyl_evkl\� \_^_l� \g_dhlhjhf�jh^_�iZjZablbq_kdh_�kms_kl\h\Zgb_�aZ�_]h�kq_l��D __�hkgh\Zl_ex�mkeh\by��dhlhju_fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f�^ey�ijhlb\gbdh\�^jm]hc�]jmiiu��ih^oh^yl�ebrv�\ g_agZqbl_evghc�f_j_��KZfhgZa\Zgb_�y\ey_lky�g_m^Zqguf��dZ`_lky�ke_^kl\b_f�aZljm^g_gby��fu�g_�fh`_f�k_[_�iha\heblvihf_rZlv�ihevah\Zlvky�bf�k iheguf�ijZ\hf�\ dZq_kl\_�ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb�ikboheh]bb�fZkk�lh�� q_f� aZgbfZ_fky� fu�� lh`_� y\ey_lky� ih� [hevr_c� qZklb� b ij_`^_� \k_]h� ikboheh]b_cq_eh\_q_kdh]h�bg^b\b^mmfZ��< h[t_dlb\gmx�djblbdm�bg^b\b^mZevghc�ikboheh]bb�:^e_jZ�y g_[m^m�k_]h^gy�\^Z\Zlvky��hgZ�g_�\oh^bl�\ ieZg�wlh]h�\\_^_gby��y lZd`_�iulZeky�m`_�h^gZ`^u�wlhk^_eZlv�b g_�\b`m�ijbqbg�qlh�eb[h�baf_gylv�\ g_c��: \i_qZle_gb_��dhlhjh_�hgZ�ijhba\h^bl��yemqr_�ihdZ`m�gZ�ijbf_j_�fZe_gvdh]h�ijhbkr_kl\by�\ ]h^u�^h�\hagbdgh\_gby�ZgZebaZ�<[ebab� fZe_gvdh]h� fhjZ\kdh]h� ]hjh^dZ�� \ dhlhjhf� y jh^beky� b dhlhjuc� ihdbgmelj_oe_lgbf� j_[_gdhf�� gZoh^blky� kdjhfguc� dmjhjl�� mlhiZxsbc� \ ij_djZkghc� a_e_gb�� <]bfgZabq_kdb_�]h^u�y g_kdhevdh�jZa�[u\Ze�lZf�gZ�dZgbdmeZo��Ijbf_jgh�^\Z�^_kylbe_lby�kimkly[he_agv�h^ghc�[ebadhc�jh^kl\_ggbpu�ihkem`beZ�ih\h^hf�kgh\Z�m\b^_lv�wlh�f_klh��< [_k_^_�kdmjhjlguf� \jZqhf�� dhlhjuc� hdZau\Ze� ihfhsv� fh_c� jh^kl\_ggbp_�� y hk\_^hfbeky� h _]hhlghr_gbyo� kh� keh\Zpdbfb� dj_klvygZfb�� dhlhju_� abfhc� khklZ\eyeb� _]h� _^bgkl\_ggmxdeb_glmjm�� Hg� jZkkdZaZe�� dZdbf� h[jZahf� hkms_kl\ey_lky� _]h� \jZq_[gZy� ^_yl_evghklv�� dh\j_f_gb�ijb_fguo�qZkh\�iZpb_glu�ijboh^yl�\ _]h�dZ[bg_l�b klZgh\ylky�\ jy^��AZl_f�h^bg�aZ^jm]bf�\uoh^yl�\i_j_^�b `Zemxlky�gZ�k\hb�g_^m]b��m g_]h�^_�[heb�\ dj_klph\hc�h[eZklb��bebkiZafu�`_em^dZ��beb�mklZehklv�\ gh]Zo�b l��^��AZl_f��\jZq�h[ke_^m_l�dZ`^h]h�b��\hc^y�\ dmjk^_eZ�� h[ty\ey_l� ^bZ]gha�� \ dZ`^hf� kemqZ_� h^bg� b lhl� `_�� Hg� i_j_\_e� fg_� wlh� keh\h�� hghhagZqZeh�lh�`_�kZfh_��qlh�©g_qbklucª��Y kijhkbe�m^b\e_ggh��g_�\hajZ`Zeb�eb�dj_klvyg_��qlh�hgm \k_o�gZoh^be�h^gm�b lm�`_�[he_agv��©H g_l�²�hl\_lbe�lhl�²�hgb�[ueb�hq_gv�^h\hevgu�l_f�qlh� wlh� [ueh� bf_ggh� lh�� q_]h� hgb� h`b^Zeb�� DZ`^uc�� \ha\jZsZykv� \ jy^�� ihykgye� ^jm]hfmfbfbdhc�b `_klZfb��^Z�� wlhl� agZ_l� k\h_� ^_ehª��Lh]^Z� y kfmlgh�ij_^klZ\eye� k_[_�� ijb� dZdboh[klhyl_evkl\Zo�kgh\Z�\klj_qmkv�k ZgZeh]bqghc�kblmZpb_c�;m^v� dlh�lh� ]hfhk_dkmZebklhf�beb�g_djhnbehf�� aZim]Zgguf� bkl_jbdhf�� bahebjh\Zggufg_\jhlbdhf� k gZ\yaqb\ufb� khklhygbyfb� beb� [mcgh� ihf_rZgguf�� \ dZ`^hf� kemqZ_ihke_^h\Zl_ev�bg^b\b^mZevghc�ikboheh]bb� Z^e_jh\kdh]h�gZijZ\e_gby�ij_^iheh`bl�\_^msbffhlb\hf�>^Zggh]h@�khklhygby�`_eZgb_�[hevgh]h�aZklZ\blv�kqblZlvky�k kh[hc��kdhfi_gkbjh\Zlvk\hx�g_iheghp_gghklv��hklZlvky�gZ�\ukhl_��i_j_clb�k `_gkdhc�ebgbb�ih\_^_gby�gZ�fm`kdmx�Qlh�lh� hq_gv� ihoh`__� fu� keurZeb� fheh^ufb� klm^_glZfb� \ debgbd_�� dh]^Z� h^gZ`^u

Page 336: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

^_fhgkljbjh\Zeky� kemqZc� bkl_jbb�� kljZ^Zxsb_� bkl_jb_c� ijhba\h^yl� k\hb� kbfilhfu�� qlh[uk^_eZlv� k_[y� bgl_j_kgufb�� ijb\e_qv� d k_[_� \gbfZgb_�� DZd� qZklh� \k_�lZdb� klZjZy� fm^jhklv\ha\jZsZ_lky��Gh�wlhl�dmkhq_d�ikboheh]bb�m`_�lh]^Z��dZd�gZf�dZaZehkv��g_�jZkdju\Ze�aZ]Z^dbbkl_jbb��HklZ\Zehkv��gZijbf_j��g_ykguf��ihq_fm�[hevghc�g_�\hkihevam_lky�^jm]bf�kj_^kl\hf^ey�^hklb`_gby�k\h_]h�gZf_j_gby��Dh_�qlh�\ wlhc�l_hjbb�bg^b\b^mZevghc�ikboheh]bb�^he`gh[ulv�� dhg_qgh�� ijZ\bevguf�� dZdZy�lh� qZklbqdZ� p_eh]h�� Bgklbgdl� kZfhkhojZg_gby� [m^_liulZlvky�bkihevah\Zlv�^ey�k_[y�ex[mx�kblmZpbx��Y lh`_�aZohq_l�\hkihevah\Zlvky�khklhygb_f[he_agb� ^ey� k\h_]h� ij_bfms_kl\Z�� < ikbohZgZeba_� wlh� gZau\Z_lky� ©\lhjbqghc� \u]h^hc� hl[he_agbª��IjZ\^Z��_keb�\kihfgblv�h nZdlZo�fZahobafZ��[_kkhagZl_evghc�ihlj_[ghklb�gZdZaZgbyy g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� kZfhih\j_`^_gby�� dhlhju_� aZklZ\eyxl� ij_^iheh`blv� \e_q_gby�ijhlb\hj_qZsb_� kZfhkhojZg_gbx�� lh� mkhfgbrvky� b \� h[s_c� agZqbfhklb� lhc� [ZgZevghcbklbgu�� gZ� dhlhjhc� ihkljh_gh� a^Zgb_� bg^b\b^mZevghc� ikboheh]bb�� Gh� [hevrbgkl\m� lZdZyl_hjby�\ \ukr_c�kl_i_gb�`_eZl_evgh��hgZ�g_�ijbagZ_l�gbdZdbo�hkeh`g_gbc��g_�\\h^bl�gh\uo�ljm^gh� ihklb]Z_fuo� ihgylbc�� gbq_]h� g_� agZ_l� h [_kkhagZl_evghf�� h^gbf� m^Zjhf� mkljZgy_ll_dmsmx� ^ey� \k_o� ijh[e_fm� k_dkmZevghklb�� h]jZgbqb\Z_lky� hldjulb_f� eZa__d�� k ihfhsvxdhlhjuo� dhq_l� k^_eZlv�`bagv� m^h[ghc��<_^v�fZkkZ� kZfZ� m^h[gZ�� g_� lj_[m_l� ^ey� h[tykg_gby[he__�h^ghc�ijbqbgu��[eZ]h^ZjgZ�gZmd_�g_�aZ�__ ih^jh[ghklb��ohq_l�bf_lv�ijhklu_�j_r_gby�bkqblZlv� ijh[e_fu� jZaj_r_ggufb�� ?keb� \a\_kblv�� gZkdhevdh� bg^b\b^mZevgZy� ikboheh]byhl\_qZ_l��wlbf�lj_[h\Zgbyf��lh�g_evay�g_�\kihfgblv�h^gh�\ukdZau\Zgb_�ba�<Zee_grl_cgZ�G_�[m^v�lZd�wlhl�aZfuk_e�dh\Zj_g��=emi_crbf�y gZa\Zlv�[u�fh]��_]h��I_j_\h^�Y��KeZ\ylbikdh]h��DjblbdZ�ki_pbZebklh\��klhev�g_mfhebfZy�\ hlghr_gbb�ikbohZgZebaZ��\ h[s_f�dhkgmeZkvbg^b\b^mZevghc� ikboheh]bb� aZfr_\ufb�i_jqZldZfb��IjZ\^Z�� \ :f_jbd_� [ue� kemqZc�� �dh]^Zh^bg�ba�\b^g_crbo�ikbobZljh\�him[ebdh\Ze�klZlvx�ijhlb\�:^e_jZ�ih^�gZa\Zgb_f (QRXJK� �]^_�hg�\u� �>h\hevgh���Zg]e�����Ijbf_q��i_j�jZabe� k\h_� hl\jZs_gb_� d ©gZ\yaqb\hfm� ih\lhj_gbxª�� ?keb� ^jm]b_� \_eb� k_[y� gZfgh]hex[_ag__��lh��\b^bfh��wlhfm�kihkh[kl\h\ZeZ�\jZ`^_[ghklv�d ZgZebam�H ^jm]bo�rdheZo�� dhlhju_� hl\_l\bebkv� hl� gZr_]h� ikbohZgZebaZ�� fg_� g_� gm`gh� fgh]h]h\hjblv�� Lh�� qlh� wlh� ijhbahreh�� g_� ]h\hjbl� gb� aZ�� gb� ijhlb\� ikbohZgZebaZ�� Ih^mfZcl_� hkbevguo�Znn_dlb\guo�nZdlhjZo��dhlhju_�fgh]bf�aZljm^gyxl�\hafh`ghklv�\dexqblvky�\h�qlh�lh� beb� ih^qbgblvky� q_fm�lh� b h� _s_� [hevrbo� ljm^ghklyo�� dhlhju_� ih� ijZ\m� ih^q_jdb\Z_l\ujZ`_gb_ TXRW� FDSLWD� WRW� VHQVDV � ?keb� jZaebqby� \h� fg_gbyo� i_j_rZ]gmeb� hij_^_e_ggmx]jZgbpm�� lh� kZfh_� p_e_khh[jZagh_� jZaf_`_\Zlvky� b k� wlbo� ihj� b^lb� jZaebqgufb� imlyfb�hkh[_ggh� dh]^Z� l_hj_lbq_kdh_� jZaebqb_� bf__l� k\hbf� ke_^kl\b_f� baf_g_gby� ijZdlbq_kdbo^_ckl\bc�� Ij_^iheh`bl_�� gZijbf_j�� qlh� dZdhc�lh� ZgZeblbd� g_^hhp_gb\Z_l� \ebygb_� ebqgh]hijhreh]h� b iulZ_lky� h[tykgblv� ijbqbgu� g_\jhah\� bkdexqbl_evgh� fhlb\Zfb� gZklhys_]h� bh`b^Zgbyfb�� gZijZ\e_ggufb� \ [m^ms__�� AZl_f� hg� [m^_l� ij_g_[j_]Zlv� ZgZebahf� ^_lkl\Z�\hh[s_� gZqg_l� ihevah\Zlvky� ^jm]hc� l_ogbdhc�� Z g_^hklZlhd� ^Zgguo� ZgZebaZ� ^_lkl\Z� ^he`_g[m^_l� \haf_klblv� mkbe_gb_f� k\h_]h� l_hj_lbq_kdh]h� \ebygby� b ijyfufb� mdZaZgbyfb� gZ

Page 337: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

`bag_ggu_�p_eb��Lh]^Z�fu��^jm]b_��kdZ`_f��wlh��fh`_l�[ulv��b rdheZ�fm^jhklb��gh�m`�gbdZd�g_ZgZeba�� Beb� ^jm]hc� fh`_l� ijbclb� d \u\h^m�� qlh� i_j_`b\Zgb_� kljZoZ� jh`^_gby� y\ey_lkyaZjh^ur_f� \k_o� ihke_^mxsbo� g_\jhlbq_kdbo� gZjmr_gbc�� lh]^Z� _fm� ihdZ`_lky� ijZ\bevgufh]jZgbqblvky�ZgZebahf�^_ckl\bc�wlh]h�h^gh]h�\i_qZle_gby�b h[_sZlv�l_jZi_\lbq_kdbc�mki_oq_j_a� ljb�q_luj_� f_kypZ� e_q_gby�� AZf_lvl_�� y \u[jZe� ^\Z� ijbf_jZ�� dhlhju_� bkoh^yl� ba^bZf_ljZevgh� ijhlb\hiheh`guo� ij_^ihkuehd�� LZdh\� ihqlb� \k_h[sbc� oZjZdl_j� ©^\b`_gbchloh^Zª�� dZ`^h_� ba� gbo� h\eZ^_\Z_l� dZdhc�lh� qZklvx� [h]Zlkl\Z� fhlb\h\� \ ikbohZgZeba_� bklZgh\blky� kZfhklhyl_evguf� gZ� hkgh\_� wlh]h� h\eZ^_gby�� [m^v� wlh� klj_fe_gb_� d \eZklb�wlbq_kdbc�dhgnebdl��fZlv��]_gblZevghklv�b l��^��?keb�\Zf�dZ`_lky��qlh�lZdb_�hloh^u�\ jZa\blbbikbohZgZebaZ�k_]h^gy�ijhbkoh^yl�qZs_��q_f�\ ^jm]bo�^moh\guo�^\b`_gbyo��lh�g_�agZx��^he`_geb�y kh]eZkblvky�k \Zfb��Dhev�kdhjh�wlh�lZd��lh�hl\_lkl\_ggufb�aZ�wlh�ke_^m_l�kqblZlv�l_kgu_k\yab�f_`^m�l_hj_lbq_kdbfb�\a]ey^Zfb�b l_jZi_\lbq_kdhc�ijZdlbdhc��dhlhju_�kms_kl\mxl�\ikbohZgZeba_�� JZaebqby� lhevdh� \h� fg_gbyo� fh`gh� [ueh� [u� \ughkblv� ^hevr_�� GZk�ikbohZgZeblbdh\�� ex[yl� h[\bgylv� \ g_l_jibfhklb�� ?^bgkl\_gguf� ijhy\e_gb_f� wlh]hhl\jZlbl_evgh]h�dZq_kl\Z�[ueh�jZaf_`_\Zgb_�bf_ggh�k bgZdhfukeysbfb��< hklZevghf�bo�gb�\q_f�g_�h[b^_eb��gZijhlb\��hgb�ihiZeb�\ [eZ]hijbylgh_�iheh`_gb_��k l_o�ihj�bf�klZeh�emqr_�q_f�jZgvr_�� lZd�dZd�ihke_�hloh^Z�hgb�hk\h[h^bebkv�hl�mij_dh\��hl�dhlhjuo�fu� aZ^uoZ_fky�gZijbf_j�� \ ihahjghklb� ^_lkdhc� k_dkmZevghklb� beb� kf_ohl\hjghklb� kbf\hebdb�� Z l_i_jv� bokqblZxl�\ fbj_�gZiheh\bgm�q_klgufb��q_f�fu��hklZ\rb_ky��g_�y\ey_fky��Hgb�kZfb�hlhreb�hlgZk�\iehlv�^h�h^gh]h�ijbf_qZl_evgh]h�bkdexq_gby�DZdb_�`_�_s_�ijblyaZgby�\u�h[hagZqbl_�gZa\Zgb_f�l_jibfhklv"�Lhl �Kdhevdh�]heh\�²�klhevdh�mfh\��eZl���²�Ijbf_q��i_j�kemqZc��dh]^Z�dlh�lh�\ujZabe�fg_gb_��dhlhjh_�\u�kqblZ_l_�Z[khexlgh�g_ijZ\bevguf��gh]h\hjbl_� _fm�� ©;hevrh_� kiZkb[h�� qlh� \u� \ujZabeb� wlh� ijhlb\hj_qb_�� <u� kiZkeb� gZk� hlhiZkghklb� kZfh^h\hevkl\Z� b ^Z_l_� gZf� \hafh`ghklv� ^hdZaZlv� Zf_jbdZgpZf�� qlh� fu^_ckl\bl_evgh�gZklhevdh�EURDG�PLQGHG � gZkdhevdh�hgb�\k_]^Z�wlh]h�`_eZeb��Fu�g_�\_jbf�gbh^ghfm�keh\m�ba�lh]h��qlh�\u�]h\hjbl_��gh�wlh�g_\Z`gh��<_jhylgh��\u�lZd�`_�ijZ\u��dZd�b fu�Dlh�\hh[s_�fh`_l�agZlv��dlh�ijZ\"�Iha\hevl_�gZfª�g_kfhljy�gZ�khi_jgbq_kl\h��\ujZablv�\Zrmlhqdm�aj_gby�\ ebl_jZlmj_��GZ^__fky��qlh�\u�[m^_l_�klhev�ex[_agu�b ihklZjZ_l_kv�\ukdZaZlvkyaZ�gZrm��dhlhjmx�\u�hl\_j]Z_l_ª��Wlh��hq_\b^gh��klZg_l�\ [m^ms_f�h[uqguf�\ gZmqghc�jZ[hl_�dh]^Z�hdhgqZl_evgh�ml\_j^blky�aehmihlj_[e_gb_�l_hjb_c�hlghkbl_evghklb�Wcgrl_cgZ��IjZ\^Z�ihdZ� fu� ^h� wlh]h� g_� ^hreb�� Fu� h]jZgbqb\Z_fky� klZjhc� fZg_jhc� ij_^klZ\eylv� k\hbkh[kl\_ggu_� m[_`^_gby�� ih^\_j]Zykv� hiZkghklb� hrb[blvky�� ihlhfm� qlh� ijhlb\� wlh]h� g_evayaZsblblvky��b hl\_j]Z_f� lh��qlh�gZf�ijhlb\hj_qbl��< ikbohZgZeba_�fu�\ ^hklZlhqgh�iheghcf_j_� ihevah\Zebkv� ijZ\hf� gZ� baf_g_gb_� k\h_]h� fg_gby�� _keb� iheZ]Zeb�� qlh� gZreb� qlh�lhemqr__�H^gbf� ba� i_j\uo� ijbeh`_gbc� ikbohZgZebaZ� [ueh� lh�� qlh� hg� gZmqbe� gZk� ihgbfZlvijhlb\gbdh\�� dhlhju_� ihy\bebkv� \ gZr_f� hdjm`_gbb� ba�aZ� lh]h�� qlh� fu� aZgbfZebkvikbohZgZebahf�� >jm]b_� ijbeh`_gby�� h[t_dlb\gh]h� oZjZdl_jZ�� fh]ml� \ua\Zlv� [he__� h[sbcbgl_j_k�� <_^v� gZrbf� i_j\uf� gZf_j_gb_f� [ueh� ihgylv� gZjmr_gby� q_eh\_q_kdhc� ^mr_\ghc`bagb��ihlhfm�qlh�h^bg�ihjZabl_evguc�ijbf_j�ihdZaZe��qlh�ihgbfZgb_�b \ua^hjh\e_gb_�a^_kv

Page 338: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ihqlb�kh\iZ^Zxl��qlh�imlv��ih�dhlhjhfm�fh`gh�b^lb��\_^_l�hl�h^gh]h�d ^jm]hfm��B wlh�^he]h_\j_fy�hklZ\Zehkv�gZrbf� _^bgkl\_gguf�gZf_j_gb_f��Gh� aZl_f�fu�h[gZjm`beb� l_kgmx� k\yav�^Z`_� \gmlj_ggxx� b^_glbqghklv� f_`^m� iZlheh]bq_kdbfb� b lZd� gZau\Z_fufb� ghjfZevgufbijhp_kkZfb��ikbohZgZeba�klZe�]em[bgghc�ikboheh]b_c��Z lZd dZd gbq_]h�ba�lh]h��qlh�q_eh\_dkha^Z_l�beb�q_f� aZgbfZ_lky��g_evay�ihgylv�[_a�ihfhsb�ikboheh]bb��ikbohZgZeba�gZr_e�k\h_ijbf_g_gb_� \ fgh]hqbke_gguo� h[eZklyo� gZmdb�� hkh[_ggh� ]mfZgblZjguo�� hgh� gZijZrb\ZehkvkZfh�kh[hc�b lj_[h\Zeh�jZajZ[hldb����D kh`Ze_gbx��wlb�aZ^Zqb�gZlhedgmebkv�gZ�ij_iylkl\by�ih� kmlb� ^_eZ� h[hkgh\Zggu_�� dhlhju_� g_� ij_h^he_gu� b ih� k_c� ^_gv�� LZdh_� ijbf_g_gb_ij_^iheZ]Z_l�ijhn_kkbhgZevgu_�agZgby��dhlhjuo�g_�bf_xl�ZgZeblbdb��\ lh�\j_fy�dZd�l_��dlhbfb�h[eZ^Z_l��gbq_]h�g_�agZxl�h[�ZgZeba_��Z fh`_l�[ulv��g_�ohlyl�gbq_]h�agZlv��LZdbf�h[jZahf�ihemqbehkv�� qlh� ZgZeblbdb�� dZd� ^be_lZglu� k [he__� beb� f_g__� ^hklZlhqguf� [Z]Z`hf�� qZklhkh[jZgguf�\ ki_rd_��ij_^ijbgbfZeb�wdkdmjku�\ lZdb_�h[eZklb�gZmd��dZd�fbnheh]by��bklhjbydmevlmju�� wlgheh]by�� j_eb]bh\_^_gb_� b l�� ^�� Ihklhyggh� aZgbfZxsb_ky� wlbfb� gZmdZfbbkke_^h\Zl_eb�h[oh^bebkv�k gbfb�\hh[s_�dZd�k g_a\Zgufb�]hklyfb��ihgZqZem�hldZau\Zy�bf�\agZdhfkl\_�dZd� kh� k\hbfb�f_lh^Zfb�� lZd�b k�j_amevlZlZfb�� _keb� l_� klhbeb�\gbfZgby��Gh� wlbhlghr_gby�ihklhyggh�memqrZxlky��\h�\k_o�h[eZklyo�jZkl_l�qbkeh�ebp��bamqZxsbo�ikbohZgZebak l_f��qlh[u�ijbf_gblv�_]h�\ k\h_c�ki_pbZevghc�h[eZklb� �L_jibfu ^Zg]e���²Ijbf_q��i_j�kf_gblv�ibhg_jh\�\ dZq_kl\_�dhehgbklh\��A^_kv�fu�fh`_f�gZ^_ylvky�gZ�[h]Zluc�mjh`Zcgh\uo�\a]ey^h\��Ijbf_g_gb_�ZgZebaZ�²�wlh�\k_]^Z�b _]h�ml\_j`^_gb_��LZf��]^_�gZmqgZy�jZ[hlZhlklhbl� hl� ijZdlbq_kdhc� ^_yl_evghklb� ^Ze_dh�� g_ba[_`gZy� [hjv[Z� fg_gbc�� ih`Zemc�� [m^_lf_g__�h`_klhq_gghc�Y hsmsZx� kbevguc� kh[eZag� ihdZaZlv� \Zf� \k_� \hafh`gu_� ijbeh`_gby� ikbohZgZebaZ� \]mfZgblZjguo� gZmdZo�� Wlb� \_sb�� ^hklhcgu_� \gbfZgby� dZ`^h]h� q_eh\_dZ� k ^moh\gufbbgl_j_kZfb��Z dZdh_�lh�\j_fy�gbq_]h�g_�keurZlv�h g_ghjfZevghklb�b [he_agb�[ueh�[u�^ey�\ZkaZkem`_gguf�hl^uohf��Gh�y \ugm`^_g�hldZaZlvky�hl�wlh]h��wlh�hiylv�m\_eh�[u�gZk� aZ�jZfdbgZrbo�[_k_^�� Z�� q_klgh� ]h\hjy�� y b�g_� kihkh[_g� \uihegblv� wlm� aZ^Zqm��< g_dhlhjuo� ba� wlboh[eZkl_c�y��ijZ\^Z��kZf�k^_eZe�i_j\uc�rZ]��gh�k_]h^gy�m`_�g_�fh]m�©o\Zlblv�fZl_jbZe�\h�\k_ciheghl_��b fg_�ijbrehkv�[u�bamqblv�fgh]h_�^ey� lh]h�� qlh[u� jZah[jZlvky� \ lhf�� qlh�gh\h]hihy\behkv�kh�\j_f_gb�fhbo�gZqbgZgbc��L_�ba�\Zk��dlh�jZahqZjh\Zg�fhbf�hldZahf��fh`_l�\iheg_m^h\e_l\hjblvky�gZrbf�`mjgZehf ,PDJR� ij_^gZagZq_gguf�g_�^ey�f_^bpbgkdh]h�ijbeh`_gbyZgZebaZ�Lhevdh�h^gm�l_fm�y g_�fh]m�lZd�ijhklh�h[hclb��g_�ihlhfm��qlh�fgh]h�ihgbfZx�beb�kZf�lZdfgh]h�k^_eZe�\ g_c��Kh\k_f�gZh[hjhl��y _x�ihqlb�gbdh]^Z�g_�aZgbfZeky��: f_`^m�l_f�wlh�lZdqj_a\uqZcgh�\Z`gh��lZd�fgh]h�h[_sZ_l�\ [m^ms_f�b��fh`_l�[ulv��y\ey_lky�kZfuf�\Z`guf�ba\k_]h�� q_f� aZgbfZ_lky� ZgZeba�� Y bf_x� \ \b^m� bkihevah\Zgby� ikbohZgZebaZ� \ i_^Z]h]bd_�� \\hkiblZgbb�[m^ms_]h�ihdhe_gby��JZ^��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��khh[sblv��qlh�fhy�^hqv��:ggZ�Nj_c^�\b^bl� \ wlhc� jZ[hl_� k\hx�`bag_ggmx� aZ^Zqm� b ebd\b^bjm_l�� lZdbf� h[jZahf��fh_� mims_gb_�Imlv�� dhlhjuc� \_^_l� d wlhfm� bkihevah\Zgbx�� e_]dh� ih^^Z_lky� h[haj_gbx�� Dh]^Z� fu� ijbe_q_gbb�\ajhkeh]h�g_\jhlbdZ�bkke_^h\Zeb�^_l_jfbgbjh\Zgghklv�_]h�kbfilhfh\��lh�ihklhyggh^hoh^beb�^h�_]h�jZgg_]h�^_lkl\Z��AgZgby�[he__�iha^g_c�wlbheh]bb�[ueh�g_^hklZlhqgh�gb ^ey

Page 339: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ihgbfZgby��gb�^ey� l_jZi_\lbq_kdh]h�\ha^_ckl\by��LZd�fu�[ueb�\ugm`^_gu�ihagZdhfblvky� kikbobq_kdbfb�hkh[_gghklyfb�^_lkdh]h�\hajZklZ�b magZeb�[hevrh_�dhebq_kl\h�\_s_c��dhlhju_fh`gh�[ueh�mklZgh\blv�ebrv�g_�bgZq_�dZd�[eZ]h^Zjy�ZgZebam��kfh]eb�\f_klb�lZd`_�ihijZ\db\h� fgh]b_� h[s_ijbagZggu_� fg_gby� h ^_lkl\_�� Fu� h[gZjm`beb�� qlh� i_j\u_� ^_lkdb_� ]h^u�ijbf_jgh�^h�iylb�e_l��bf_xl�hkh[h_�agZq_gb_�ih�g_kdhevdbf�ijbqbgZf��<h�i_j\uo��ihlhfmqlh�\ wlh�\j_fy�ijhbkoh^bl�jZggbc�jZkp\_l�k_dkmZevghklb��hklZ\eyy�ih_e��k_[y�j_rZxsb_�^eyk_dkmZevghc�`bagb� aj_eh]h� i_jbh^Z� ih[m`^_gby�� <h�i_j\uo�� ihlhfm� qlh� \i_qZle_gby� wlh]h\j_f_gb�iZ^Zxl�gZ�g_aZ\_jr_ggh_�b keZ[h_�Y��gZ�dhlhjh_�hgb�^_ckl\mxl�dZd�ljZ\fu��Y fh`_laZsblblvky�hl� Znn_dlb\guo�[mjv��dhlhju_�hgb�\uau\Zxl��g_�q_f�bguf��dZd�\ul_kg_gb_f��bihemqZ_l� lZdbf� kihkh[hf� \ ^_lkdhf� \hajZkl_� \k_� ij_^jZkiheh`_gby� d ihke_^mxsbfaZ[he_\Zgbyf�b nmgdpbhgZevguf�gZjmr_gbyf��Fu�ihgyeb�� qlh� ljm^ghklv� ^_lkl\Z� khklhbl� \lhf�� qlh� aZ� dhjhldbc� i_jbh^� \j_f_gb� j_[_ghd� ^he`_g� h\eZ^_lv� j_amevlZlZfb� dmevlmjgh]hjZa\blby��dhlhjh_�^ebehkv�lukyq_e_lby��h\eZ^_lv�\e_q_gbyfb�b khpbZevgh�ijbkihkh[blvky��ihdjZcg_c�f_j_��k^_eZlv�i_j\u_�rZ]b�\ h[hbo�gZijZ\e_gbyo��K\hbf�kh[kl\_gguf�jZa\blb_f�hgebrv� qZklbqgh� ^h[b\Z_lky� baf_g_gby� \ wlm� klhjhgm�� fgh]h_� ijboh^blky� gZ\yau\Zlv� _fm\hkiblZgb_f��GZk�g_�m^b\ey_l��_keb�j_[_ghd�qZklh�g_�\iheg_�kijZ\ey_lky�k wlhc�aZ^Zq_c��< wlhljZggbc� i_jbh^� fgh]b_� ^_lb� ²� b m`�� dhg_qgh�� \k_� l_�� dlh� iha^g__� hldjulh� aZ[he_\Z_l�²i_j_`b\Zxl�khklhygby��dhlhju_�fh`gh�ijbjZ\gylv�d g_\jhaZf��M g_dhlhjuo�^_l_c�[he_agv�g_^h`b^Z_lky� i_jbh^Z� aj_ehklb�� hgZ� gZqbgZ_lky� m`_� \ ^_lkl\_� b ^hklZ\ey_l� fgh]h� oehihljh^bl_eyf�b \jZqZf�Fu�gbkdhevdh�g_�hiZkZebkv�ijbf_gylv� ZgZeblbq_kdmx� l_jZibx�d lZdbf�^_lyf�� dhlhju_h[gZjm`b\Zeb� beb� g_^\mkfuke_ggu_� g_\jhlbq_kdb_� kbfilhfu� beb� `_� ij_^ihkuedb� ^eyg_[eZ]hijbylgh]h� jZa\blby� oZjZdl_jZ�� HiZk_gb_� ih\j_^blv� j_[_gdm� ZgZebahf�� dhlhjh_\ujZ`Zeb�ijhlb\gbdb�ZgZebaZ��hdZaZehkv�g_h[hkgh\Zgguf��Ij_^ijbgbfZy�wlh��fu�\ub]ju\Zeb\ lhf��qlh�fh]eb�ih^l\_j^blv�gZ�`b\hf�h[t_dl_�lh��qlh�m \ajhkeuo�hldju\Zeb��lZd�kdZaZlv��babklhjbq_kdbo� ^hdmf_glh\�� Gh� b ^ey� ^_l_c� wlh� [ueh� hq_gv� [eZ]hijbylgh�� HdZaZehkv�� qlhj_[_ghd�²�hq_gv�\u]h^guc�h[t_dl�^ey�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�l_jZibb��mki_ob�e_q_gby�hkgh\Zl_evgu�bijh^he`bl_evgu�� JZamf__lky�� l_ogbdZ�� jZajZ[hlZggZy� ^ey� e_q_gby� \ajhkeh]h�� ^ey� j_[_gdZ^he`gZ� [ulv� \h�fgh]hf� baf_g_gZ��Ikboheh]bq_kdb� j_[_ghd� ^jm]hc� h[t_dl�� q_f� \ajhkeuc�� mg_]h�_s_�g_l�K\_jo�Y��f_lh^�k\h[h^ghc�ZkkhpbZpbb�\_^_l�g_^Ze_dh��i_j_g_k_gb_�b]jZ_l�^jm]mxjhev��lZd�dZd�kms_kl\mxl�_s_�j_Zevgu_�jh^bl_eb��<gmlj_ggb_�khijhlb\e_gby��k dhlhjufb�fu[hj_fky� m \ajhkeh]h�� aZf_gyxlky� m j_[_gdZ� h[uqgh� \g_rgbfb� ljm^ghklyfb�� ?keb� jh^bl_ebklZgh\ylky� ghkbl_eyfb� khijhlb\e_gby�� lZd� qlh� p_ev� ZgZebaZ� beb� kZf� ijhp_kk� ih^\_j]ZxlkyhiZkghklb�� lh� qZklh� ijb� ZgZeba_� j_[_gdZ� g_h[oh^bfh� g_fgh]h� ih\ebylv� b gZ� jh^bl_e_c�� K^jm]hc�klhjhgu��g_ba[_`gu_�hldehg_gby�ZgZebaZ�j_[_gdZ�hl�ZgZebaZ�\ajhkeh]h�mf_gvrZxlky[eZ]h^Zjy� lhfm� h[klhyl_evkl\m�� qlh� g_dhlhju_� gZrb� iZpb_glu�� khojZgbeb� lZd� fgh]hbgnZglbevguo� q_jl� oZjZdl_jZ�� qlh� ZgZeblbdZf� hiylv�lZdb� ^ey� ijbkihkh[e_gby� d h[t_dlm� g_hklZ\Zehkv� gbq_]h� ^jm]h]h�� dZd� bkihevah\Zlv� \ bo� kemqZ_� hij_^_e_ggu_� ijb_fu� ^_lkdh]hZgZebaZ��KZfh�kh[hc�ihemqbehkv��qlh�^_lkdbc�ZgZeba�klZe�ij_h[eZ^Zlv�m `_gsbg�ZgZeblbdh\��blZd�wlh��\b^bfh��b hklZg_lky�Fg_gb_��qlh�[hevrbgkl\h�gZrbo�^_l_c�ijhoh^bl�\ k\h_f�jZa\blbb�g_\jhlbq_kdmx�nZam�g_k_l�\ k_[_�aZjh^ur�]b]b_gbq_kdh]h�lj_[h\Zgby��Fh`gh�ihklZ\blv�\hijhk��g_�p_e_khh[jZagh

Page 340: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

eb�ihfhqv�j_[_gdm�ZgZebahf��^Z`_�_keb�hg�g_�h[gZjm`b\Z_l�gbdZdbo�ijbagZdh\�gZjmr_gby��\dZq_kl\_� ijhnbeZdlbdb� _]h� a^hjh\vy� lZd�� dZd� k_]h^gy� ^_eZ_lky� ijb\b\dZ� ijhlb\� ^bnl_jbba^hjh\uf� ^_lyf�� g_� ^h`b^Zykv�� ihdZ� hgb� aZ[he_xl� _x�� >bkdmkkby� lh� wlhfm� \hijhkm� gZk_]h^gyrgbc�^_gv�bf__l�ebrv�ZdZ^_fbq_kdbc�bgl_j_k��y fh]m�k_[_�iha\heblv�h[km^blv�_]h�k\Zfb�� ^ey� [hevrh]h� qbkeZ� gZrbo� kh\j_f_ggbdh\� m`_� ijh_dl� ihdZaZeky� [u� m`Zkghcnjb\hevghklvx��Z ijb�kms_kl\mxs_f�\ gZklhys__�\j_fy�hlghr_gbb�[hevrbgkl\Z�jh^bl_e_c�dZgZebam�gm`gh�hldZaZlvky�hl�\kydhc�gZ^_`^u�gZ�_]h�ijh\_^_gb_�\ `bagv��LZdZy�ijhnbeZdlbdZg_j\haghklb�� dhlhjZy� [ueZ� [u� ^_ckl\_gghc�� ij_^iheZ]Z_l� kh\_jr_ggh� bgmx� mklZgh\dmh[s_kl\Z��=eZ\gh_�ihe_�^_yl_evghklb�^ey�bkihevah\Zgby�ikbohZgZebaZ�\ \hkiblZgbb�gZoh^blkyk_]h^gy� \ ^jm]hf� f_kl_�� Mykgbf� ^ey� k_[y�� qlh� y\ey_lky� [eb`Zcr_c� aZ^Zq_c� \hkiblZgby�J_[_ghd� ^he`_g� h\eZ^_lv� \e_q_gbyfb�� >Zlv� _fm� k\h[h^m� k l_f�� qlh[u� hg� g_h]jZgbq_gghke_^h\Ze� \k_f� k\hbf�bfimevkZf��g_\hafh`gh��Wlh�[ue�[u� hq_gv�ihmqbl_evguc� wdki_jbf_gl^ey�^_lkdbo�ikboheh]h\��gh�ijb� wlhf�g_�^he`gh�[ueh�[u�[ulv�\ `b\uo�jh^bl_e_c�� Z kZfbf^_lyf� gZg_k_g� [ue� [u� [hevrhc� \j_^�� dhlhjuc� kdZaZeky� [u� hlqZklb� kjZam�� hlqZklb� \ihke_^mxsb_�]h^u��BlZd��\hkiblZgb_�^he`gh�lhjfhablv��aZij_sZlv��ih^Z\eylv��qlh�hgh�\h�\k_\j_f_gZ� mki_rgh� b ^_eZeh��Gh� ba� ZgZebaZ�fu� magZ_f�� qlh� dZd� jZa� wlh� ih^Z\e_gb_� \e_q_gbcg_k_l� \ k_[_� hiZkghklv� g_\jhlbq_kdh]h� aZ[he_\Zgby�� Ihfgbl_�� fu� lsZl_evgh� bkke_^h\Zeb�dZdbfb�imlyfb� wlh�ijhbkoh^bl��LZdbf�h[jZahf�� \hkiblZgb_�^he`gh�bkdZlv� k\hc�imlv�f_`^mKpbeehc� ij_^hklZ\e_gby� iheghc� k\h[h^u� ^_ckl\bc� b OZjb[^hc� aZij_lZ�� Ohly� aZ^ZqZ� g_y\ey_lky� \hh[s_� g_jZaj_rbfhc�� gm`gh� gZclb� ^ey� \hkiblZgby� hilbfZevguc� \ZjbZgl�� l�� _�^hklbqv�dZd�fh`gh�[hevr_]h�b dZd�fh`gh�f_gvr_�ih\j_^blv��J_qv�b^_l�h lhf��qlh[u�j_rblv�kdhevdh�fh`gh�aZij_sZlv��\ dZdh_�\j_fy�b dZdbfb�kj_^kl\Zfb��: ^Ze__�g_h[oh^bfh�kqblZlvky�kl_f�� qlh� h[t_dlu� \hkiblZgby� g_kml� \ k_[_� kZfu_� jZaebqgu_� dhgklblmpbhgZevgu_ij_^jZkiheh`_gby��lZd�qlh�h^bg�b lhl�`_�f_lh^�\hkiblZl_evgh]h�\ha^_ckl\by�g_�fh`_l�[ulvh^bgZdh\h� ohjhr� ^ey� \k_o� ^_l_c�� Ke_^mxs__� khh[jZ`_gb_� k\b^_l_evkl\m_l� h lhf�� qlh\hkiblZgb_�^h�kbo�ihj�hq_gv�iehoh�\uihegyeh�k\hx� aZ^Zqm�b ijbqbgyeh�^_lyf�fgh]h�\j_^Z�?keb�hgh�gZc^_l�hilbfmf�b j_rbl�k\hx�aZ^Zqm�b^_Zevgh��lh�fh`gh�gZ^_ylvky�gZ�mkljZg_gb_h^gh]h�nZdlhjZ�\ wlbheh]bb�aZ[he_\Zgby�²�\ebygby�ih[hqguo�^_lkdbo�ljZ\f��>jm]hc�nZdlhj²� kbem� g_� ih^e_`Zs_c� aZij_lm� dhgklblmpbb� \e_q_gbc� ²� hgh� gbdhbf� h[jZahf� g_� kfh`_lmkljZgblv��?keb�ijh^mfZlv� l_i_jv�ihklZ\e_ggu_�i_j_^� \hkiblZl_e_f� ljm^gu_� aZ^Zqb�� magZlvdhgklblmpbhgZevgh_�k\h_h[jZab_�j_[_gdZ��ih�fZe_crbf�ijbagZdZf�jZkihagZlv��qlh�ijhbkoh^bl\ _]h�g_knhjfbjh\Z\r_cky�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��\ujZablv�_fm�\ gm`ghc�f_j_�ex[h\v�b \k_�lZdbkhojZgblv�^_ckl\_gghklv�Z\lhjbl_lZ��lh�kdZ`_rv�k_[_�_^bgkl\_gghc� p_e_khh[jZaghc� ih^]hlh\dhc� d ijhn_kkbb� \hkiblZl_ey� y\ey_lkyhkgh\Zl_evgh_�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh_�h[mq_gb_��Emqr_�\k_]h��_keb�hg�kZf�ih^\_j]g_lky�ZgZebam�ihlhfm� qlh� [_a� hiulZ� gZ� kh[kl\_gghc� ebqghklb� g_evay� \k_�lZdb� h\eZ^_lv� ZgZebahf��:gZebamqbl_e_c� b \hkiblZl_e_c� dZ`_lky� [he__� ^_ckl\_gghc� ijhnbeZdlbq_kdhc� f_jhc�� q_f� ZgZebakZfbo�^_l_c��^Z�b ijb�_]h�ijh\_^_gbb�\hagbdg_l�f_gvr_�ljm^ghkl_c�Gh��f_`^m�ijhqbf��ke_^h\Zeh�[u�ih^mfZlv�h dhk\_gghf�kh^_ckl\bb�\hkiblZgbx�^_l_c�ijbihfhsb� ZgZebaZ�� dhlhjuc� kh� \j_f_g_f�fh`_l� ijbh[j_klb� [hevr__� \ebygb_�� Jh^bl_eb�� kZfbmagZ\rb_�ZgZeba�b fgh]bf�_fm�h[yaZggu_��\ lhf�qbke_�b ihgbfZgb_f�hrb[hd�\ kh[kl\_gghf\hkiblZgbb��[m^ml�h[jZsZlvky�kh�k\hbfb�^_lvfb�[he__�khqm\kl\_ggh�b ba[Z\yl�bo�hl�fgh]h]h�

Page 341: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hl�q_]h�kZfb�g_�[ueb�ba[Z\e_gu��IZjZee_evgh�kh�klZjZgbyfb�ZgZeblbdh\�hdZaZlv�\ebygb_�gZ\hkiblZgb_� ijh\h^ylky� bkke_^h\Zgby� h \hagbdgh\_gbb� b ij_^mij_`^_gbb� [_kijbahjghklb� bij_klmighklb��A^_kv�y \Zf�lh`_�ebrv�ijbhldjhx�^\_jb�b ihdZ`m�ihdhb�aZ�gbfb��gh�g_�\\_^m\Zk�\h\gmljv��M\_j_g��qlh�_keb�\Zr�bgl_j_k�d ikbohZgZebam�khojZgblky��\u�kfh`_l_�magZlv�h[wlbo� \_sZo�fgh]h�gh\h]h� b p_ggh]h��Gh�fg_� g_� ohl_ehkv� [u� hklZ\eylv� l_fm� \hkiblZgby�� g_mihfygm\� h[� hij_^_e_gghc� lhqd_� aj_gby�� KdZaZgh� ²� b k� iheguf� ijZ\hf�²� qlh� ex[h_\hkiblZgb_� iZjlbcgh�� qlh� hgh� klj_fblky�� qlh[u� j_[_ghd� ijbkihkh[beky� d kms_kl\mxs_fmh[s_kl\_gghfm� kljhx�� g_� mqblu\Zy�� gZkdhevdh� hg� kZf� ih� k_[_� p_g_g� b gZkdhevdh� mklhcqb\�;m^mqb� m[_`^_gguf� \ g_^hklZldZo� gZrbo� kh\j_f_gguo� khpbZevguo� mqj_`^_gbc�� g_evayhijZ\^u\Zlv� lh]h�� qlh[u� bf� gZ� kem`[m� [ueh� ihklZ\e_gh� _s_� b ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbhjb_glbjh\Zggh_� \hkiblZgb_�� I_j_^� gbf� gm`gh� ihklZ\blv� ^jm]mx�� [he__� \ukhdmx� p_evhk\h[h`^_gby�hl� ]hkih^kl\mxsbo� khpbZevguo� lj_[h\Zgbc��Gh� y iheZ]Zx��qlh� wlhl� Zj]mf_gla^_kv�g_� mf_kl_g��Lj_[h\Zgb_� \uoh^bl� aZ� jZfdb�nmgdpbc� ZgZebaZ��<jZq�� ijba\Zgguc� e_qblvig_\fhgbx��lh`_�g_�^he`_g�aZ[hlblvky�h lhf��y\ey_lky�eb�aZ[he_\rbc�h[jZaph\uf�q_eh\_dhf�kZfhm[bcp_c�beb�ij_klmigbdhf��aZkem`be�eb�hg��qlh[u�hklZ\Zlvky�\ `b\uo��b gm`gh�eb�_fmwlh]h� `_eZlv�� WlZ� ^jm]Zy� p_ev�� dhlhjmx� ohlyl� ihklZ\blv� i_j_^� \hkiblZgb_f�� lh`_� [m^_liZjlbcghc��b g_� ^_eh� ZgZeblbdZ� \u[bjZlv�f_`^m� iZjlbyfb��F_gy� gbkdhevdh� g_� m^b\bl�� qlhikbohZgZebam� [m^_l� hldZaZgh� \ ex[hf� \ebygbb� gZ� \hkiblZgb_�� _keb� hg� aZy\bl� h k\h_cijbqZklghklb� d gZf_j_gbyf�� g_� kh]eZkmxsbfky� k kms_kl\mxsbf� h[s_kl\_gguf� kljh_f�IkbohZgZeblbq_kdh_� \hkiblZgb_� \havf_l� gZ� k_[y� g_gm`gmx� hl\_lkl\_gghklv�� _keb� ihklZ\blk_[_�p_evx�i_j_^_eu\Zlv�k\h_]h�\hkiblZggbdZ�\ fyl_`gbdZ��Hgh�k^_eZ_l�k\h_�^_eh��khojZgb\_]h� ih� \hafh`ghklb� a^hjh\uf� b jZ[hlhkihkh[guf�� < g_f� kZfhf� kh^_j`blky� ^hklZlhqghj_\hexpbhgguo�fhf_glh\��qlh[u�]ZjZglbjh\Zlv��qlh�_]h�\hkiblZggbd�\ ihke_^mxs_c�`bagb�g_\klZg_l�gZ�klhjhgm�j_]j_kkZ�b ih^Z\e_gby��e ^Z`_�iheZ]Zx��qlh�^_lb�j_\hexpbhg_ju�gb�\ dZdhfhlghr_gbb�g_�`_eZl_evgu�M\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Y ohqm� kdZaZlv� _s_� g_kdhevdh� keh\� h ikbohZgZeba_� dZd� hl_jZibb�� H l_hj_lbq_kdhf� __ hkgh\Zgbb� y ]h\hjbe� g_kdhevdh� e_l� lhfm� gZaZ^� b k_]h^gy� g_kqblZx� gm`guf� nhjfmebjh\Zlv� _]h� bgZq_�� l_i_jv� ^he`_g� kdZaZlv� k\h_� keh\h� hiul� wlboijhr_^rbo�e_l��<u�agZ_l_��qlh�ikbohZgZeba�\hagbd�dZd�l_jZiby��hg�^Ze_dh�\ur_e�aZ�__ jZfdb�gh�g_�hldZaZeky�hl�k\h_c�jh^ghc�ihq\u�b ^ey�k\h_]h�m]em[e_gby�b ^Zevg_cr_]h�jZa\blby�\k__s_� k\yaZg� k [hevgufb��Kh[jZggu_�^Zggu_��gZ�hkgh\Zgbb�dhlhjuo�fu� kljhbf�gZrb� l_hjbb�g_evay�[ueh�ihemqblv�^jm]bf� kihkh[hf��G_m^Zqb��dhlhju_�fu� l_jibf� dZd� l_jZi_\lu�� klZ\yli_j_^� gZfb� \k_� gh\u_� aZ^Zqb�� lj_[h\Zgby� j_Zevghc� `bagb� y\eyxlky� ^_ckl\_gghc� aZsblhcijhlb\�m\_ebq_gby�qbkeZ�mfhajbl_evguo�ihkljh_gbc��hl�dhlhjuo�fu�\ gZr_c�jZ[hl_�\k_�lZdblh`_� g_� fh`_f� hldZaZlvky�� DZdbfb� kj_^kl\Zfb� ikbohZgZeba� ihfh]Z_l� [hevguf�� _keb� hgihfh]Z_l��b dZdbfb�imlyfb��h[�wlhf�fu�m`_�]h\hjbeb�jZgvr_��k_]h^gy�fu�ohlbf�kijhkblv��q_]h`_�hg�^hklb]�<u��fh`_l�[ulv��agZ_l_��qlh�y gbdh]^Z�g_�[ue�wglmabZklhf�l_jZibb�lZd� qlh� g_q_]h� hiZkZlvky�� qlh� y aehmihlj_[ex� \ wlhc� [_k_^_� j_deZfhc�� Y emqr_� kdZ`mkebrdhf�fZeh��q_f�kebrdhf�fgh]h��< lh�\j_fy��dh]^Z�y [ue�_^bgkl\_gguf�ZgZeblbdhf��y qZklhkeurZe�hl�ebp��dhlhju_�hlghkbebkv�d fh_fm�^_em��ih�\b^bfhfm��^jm`_kdb��©<k_�wlh�ij_djZkgh

Page 342: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

b hkljhmfgh��gh�ihdZ`bl_�gZf�kemqZc��dhlhjuc�\u�\ue_qbeb�ijb�ihfhsb�ZgZebaZª��Wlh�[ueZh^gZ�ba�fgh]bo�nhjfmebjh\hd��dhlhju_�kh�\j_f_g_f�kf_gyeb�^jm]�^jm]Z�k p_evx�hlh^\bgmlv�\klhjhgm�g_m^h[gh_�gh\r_kl\h�Ijh^he`_gb_�e_dpbc�ih�\\_^_gbx�\ ikbohZgZebaK_]h^gy� hgZ� lh`_� mklZj_eZ�� dZd� fgh]b_� ^jm]b_�²� gZc^_lky� \ iZid_� ZgZeblbdZ� b iZqdZ[eZ]h^Zjkl\_gguo� ibk_f� \ue_q_gguo� iZpb_glh\�� GZ� wlhf� ZgZeh]by� g_� aZdZgqb\Z_lky�IkbohZgZeba�^_ckl\bl_evgh�l_jZiby��dZd�b \kydZy�^jm]Zy��M g__�_klv�k\hb�ljbmfnu�b iZ^_gby�k\hb�ljm^ghklb��h]jZgbq_gby��ihdZaZgby��< ba\_klgh_�\j_fy�ijhlb\�ZgZebaZ�ijha\mqZe�ijhl_kl�qlh� _]h� g_evay� ijbgbfZlv� \k_jv_a� aZ� l_jZibx�� ihlhfm� qlh� hg� g_� j_rZ_lky� hagZdhfblv� khklZlbklbdhc�k\hbo�mki_oh\��K l_o�ihj�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbc�bgklblml�\ ;_jebg_��hkgh\Zgguc�^�jhf� FZdkhf� Wclbg]hghf�� him[ebdh\Ze� k\hc� klZlbklbq_kdbc� hlq_l� aZ� ^_kylbe_lb_�� Mki_obe_q_gby�g_�^Zxl�hkgh\Zgbc�gb�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�bfb�o\Zeblvky��gb�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�bo�klu^blvky�Gh�lZdb_�klZlbklbdb�\hh[s_�g_�ihmqbl_evgu��h[jZ[hlZgguc�fZl_jbZe�gZklhevdh�]_l_jh]_g_g�qlh�lhevdh�hq_gv�[hevrb_�qbkeZ�fh]eb�[u�qlh�lh�ihdZaZlv��Emqr_�h[jZlblvky�d hl^_evguf�_]hkemqZyf�� A^_kv� y ohl_e� [u� kdZaZlv�� qlh� g_� ^mfZx�� qlh[u� gZrb� mki_ob� \ e_q_gbb� fh]ebkhi_jgbqZlv�k mki_oZfb�Emj^Z��GZkdhevdh�[hevr_�kms_kl\m_l�ex^_c��dhlhju_�\_jyl�\ qm^_kZk\ylhc� ^_\u�� q_f� l_o�� dlh� \_jbl� \ kms_kl\h\Zgb_� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� ?keb� fu� h[jZlbfky� da_fghc� dhgdmj_gpbb�� lh� ^he`gu� khihklZ\blv� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdmx� l_jZibx� k ^jm]bfbf_lh^Zfb�ikbohl_jZibb��Hj]Zgbq_kdb_�nbabq_kdb_�f_lh^u�e_q_gby�g_\jhlbq_kdbo�khklhygbck_]h^gy�\jy^�eb�gm`gh�mihfbgZlv��DZd�ikbohl_jZi_\lbq_kdbc�f_lh^��ZgZeba�g_�ijhlb\hj_qbl^jm]bf� f_lh^Zf� wlhc� ki_pbZevghc� h[eZklb� f_^bpbgu�� hg� g_� ebrZ_l� bo� agZqbfhklb�� g_bkdexqZ_l� bo�� < l_hjbb� \k_� dZd� [m^lh� ohjhrh� khq_lZ_lky�� \jZq�� dhlhjuc� ohq_l� kqblZlvkyikbohl_jZi_\lhf��bkihevam_l� ZgZeba�gZjy^m� k ^jm]bfb�f_lh^Zfb� e_q_gby� k\h_]h� [hevgh]h� \aZ\bkbfhklb� hl� ki_pbnbdb� kemqZy� b [eZ]hijbylghklb� beb� g_[eZ]hijbylghklb� \g_rgboh[klhyl_evkl\�� < ^_ckl\bl_evghklb� `_� wlh� l_ogbdZ�� lj_[mxsZy� ki_pbZebaZpbb� \jZq_[ghc^_yl_evghklb��LZdbf�`_�h[jZahf�^he`gu�[ueb�hl^_eblvky�^jm]�hl�^jm]Z�objmj]by�b hjlhi_^by�IkbohZgZeblbq_kdZy� ^_yl_evghklv� ljm^gZ� b lj_[h\Zl_evgZ�� k g_c� g_evay� h[jZsZlvky�� dZd� khqdZfb��dhlhju_�gZ^_\Zxl�ijb�ql_gbb�b kgbfZxl�ijb�ijh]med_��DZd�ijZ\beh��ikbohZgZeba�eb[haZo\Zlu\Z_l� \jZqZ� iheghklvx�� eb[h� kh\k_f� g_� aZo\Zlu\Z_l�� Ikbohl_jZi_\lu�� dhlhju_ihevamxlky� ZgZebahf� hl� kemqZy� d kemqZx�� klhyl�� ih�fh_fm�� g_� gZ� gZ^_`ghc� ZgZeblbq_kdhcihq\_��hgb�ijbgbfZxl�g_�\_kv�ZgZeba��Z \mev]Zjbabjmxl�_]h��ih`Zemc��^Z`_�©h[_a\j_`b\Zxlª�bo�g_evay�ijbqbkeblv�d ZgZeblbdZf��Y ^mfZx��qlh�wlh�^hklhcgh�kh`Ze_gby��gh�\aZbfh^_ckl\b_\h� \jZq_[ghc� ^_yl_evghklb� ZgZeblbdZ� b ikbohl_jZi_\lZ�� dhlhjuc� h]jZgbqb\Z_lky� ^jm]bfbf_lh^Zfb�f_^bpbgu��[ueh�[u�\ \ukr_c�kl_i_gb�p_e_khh[jZagh�Ih� kjZ\g_gbx� k ^jm]bfb� f_lh^Zfb� ikbohl_jZibb� ikbohZgZeba�� [_a� khfg_gby�� y\ey_lkykZfuf� kbevguf��Gh� kijZ\_^eb\h� b lh�� qlh� hg� lZd`_� kZfuc� ljm^h_fdbc� b hlgbfZ_l� [hevr_\k_]h� \j_f_gb�� _]h� g_� [m^_rv� ijbf_gylv� \ e_]dbo� kemqZyo�� k _]h� �ihfhsvx� \ ih^oh^ysbokemqZyo� fh`gh� mkljZgblv� gZjmr_gby�� \ua\Zlv� baf_g_gby�� gZ� dhlhju_� g_� kf_eb� gZ^_ylvky� \^hZgZeblbq_kdb_�\j_f_gZ��Gh�hg�bf__l�k\hb�\_kvfZ�hsmlbfu_�h]jZgbq_gby��G_dhlhjuf�fhbfklhjhggbdZf�k bo�l_jZi_\lbq_kdbf�q_klhex[b_f�klhbeh�hq_gv�fgh]bo�mkbebc�ij_h^he_lv�wlbij_iylkl\by�� lZd� qlh� \k_� g_\jhlbq_kdb_� gZjmr_gby� klZeb� dZd� [u� bae_qbfufb� ijb� ihfhsb

Page 343: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ikbohZgZebaZ��Hgb�iulZebkv�ijh\h^blv�ZgZeblbq_kdmx�jZ[hlu�\ khdjZs_gguc�kjhd��mkbeb\Zlvi_j_g_k_gb_� gZklhevdh�� qlh[u� hgh� i_j_kbeb\Zeh� \k_� khijhlb\e_gby�� khq_lZlv� k gbf� ^jm]b_kihkh[u�\ha^_ckl\by��qlh[u�\ugm^blv�\ua^hjh\e_gb_��Wlb�mkbeby��dhg_qgh��iho\Zevgu��gh�y^mfZx��qlh�hgb�gZijZkgu��Hgb�g_kml�\ k_[_�hiZkghklv�kZfhfm�\uclb�aZ�jZfdb�ZgZebaZ�b \iZklv\ [_kdhg_qgh_�wdki_jbf_glbjh\Zgb_��Ij_^iheh`_gb_��qlh�\k_�g_\jhlbq_kdh_�fh`gh�\ue_qblv�dZ`_lky�fg_�ih^hajbl_evguf�ba�aZ�\_ju�^be_lZglh\�\ lh��qlh�g_\jhau�[m^lh�[u�y\eyxlky�q_f�lh�kh\_jr_ggh�baebrgbf��qlh�\hh[s_�g_�bf__l�ijZ\Z�gZ�kms_kl\h\Zgb_��GZ� kZfhf�^_e_�hgby\eyxlky� ly`_eufb�� dhgklblmpbhgZevgh� aZnbdkbjh\Zggufb� ihjZ`_gbyfb�� dhlhju_� j_^dhh]jZgbqb\Zxlky� g_kdhevdbfb� \kiurdZfb�� ih� [hevr_c� `_� qZklb� khojZgyxlky� \ l_q_gb_^ebl_evguo�i_jbh^h\�`bagb�beb�\kx�`bagv��:gZeblbq_kdbc�hiul��ihdZau\Zxsbc��qlh�gZ�gbofh`gh�rbjhdh� \ha^_ckl\h\Zlv�� _keb�ba\_klgu� bklhjbq_kdb_� ih\h^u� [he_agb� b ijb\oh^ysb_fhf_glu��ih[m^be�gZk�ij_g_[j_qv�\ l_jZi_\lbq_kdhc�ijZdlbd_�dhgklblmpbhgZevguf�nZdlhjhf�\_^v�fu�g_�fh`_f�ba�g_]h�gbq_]h�ba\e_qv��\ l_hjbb�`_�fu�^he`gu�\k_�\j_fy�h g_f�ihfgblv�M`_� h[sZy� g_^hklmighklv� ^ey� ZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_jZibb� ikbohah\� ijb� bo� [ebadhf� jh^kl\_� kg_\jhaZfb� ^he`gZ� [ueZ� h]jZgbqblv� gZrb� ijblyaZgby� gZ� wlb� ihke_^gb_�� L_jZi_\lbq_kdZy^_ckl\_gghklv� ikbohZgZebaZ� hklZ_lky� h]jZgbq_gghc� \ke_^kl\b_� jy^Z� agZqbl_evguo� b _^\Zih^^Zxsboky� \ha^_ckl\bx� nZdlhjh\�� M j_[_gdZ�� ]^_� fh`gh� [ueh� [u� jZkkqblu\Zlv� gZgZb[hevrb_�mki_ob��wlbf�nZdlhjhf�y\eyxlky�\g_rgb_�ljm^ghklb�gZebqby�jh^bl_e_c��dhlhju_\k_�lZdb�bf_xl�hlghr_gb_�d [ulbx�j_[_gdZ��M \ajhkeuo�wlh�ij_`^_�\k_]h�^\Z�nZdlhjZ��kl_i_gvikbobq_kdhc� hdhkl_g_ehklb�b hij_^_e_ggZy�nhjfZ�[he_agb� kh� \k_f� l_f�� qlh�g_�^Z_l� _c� ^Zlv[he__�]em[hdh_�hij_^_e_gb_��I_j\uc�nZdlhj�qZklh�g_ijZ\hf_jgh�g_�aZf_qZxl��DZd�gb�\_ebdZieZklbqghklv�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��Z lZd`_�\hafh`ghklv�\hah[gh\e_gby�ij_`gbo�khklhygbc��g_evaykgh\Z� h`b\blv� \k_�� G_dhlhju_� baf_g_gby� hdhgqZl_evgu�� lbiZ� h[jZah\Zgby� rjZfh\� hlaZ\_jrb\rboky� ijhp_kkh\�� < ^jm]bo� kemqZyo� \hagbdZ_l� \i_qZle_gb_� h[s_c� aZdhkl_g_ehklb^mr_\ghc�`bagb��ikbobq_kdb_�ijhp_kku��dhlhju_��\_kvfZ�\_jhylgh��fh`gh�[ueh�[u�gZijZ\blvih�^jm]bf�imlyf��ih�\b^bfhfm��g_�kihkh[gu�hklZ\blv�ij_`gb_��Gh�\hafh`gh��wlh�lh�`_�kZfh_�qlh� [ueh� jZgvr_�� lhevdh� m\b^_ggh_�ih�^jm]hfm��Kebrdhf� qZklh� hsmsZ_rv�� qlh� l_jZibb�g_o\ZlZ_l� dZdhc�lh� g_h[oh^bfhc� ^\b`ms_c� kbeu�� qlh[u� ^h[blvky� baf_g_gby�� DZdZy�lhhij_^_e_ggZy� aZ\bkbfhklv�� dZdhc�lh� hij_^_e_gguc� dhfihg_gl� \e_q_gbc� y\ey_lky� kebrdhfkbevguf�ih�kjZ\g_gbx�k ijhlb\hiheh`gufb�kbeZfb��dhlhju_�fu�fh`_f�k^_eZlv�ih^\b`gufb�< kZfuo�h[sbo�q_jlZo�lZd�[u\Z_l�ijb�ikbohaZo��Fu�ihgbfZ_f�bo�gZklhevdh��qlh�dZd�[u�agZ_f�]^_� ijbf_gblv� juqZ]b�� gh� hgb� g_� fh]ml� k^\bgml�� ]jmaZ�� A^_kv� \hagbdZ_l� ^Z`_� gZ^_`^Z� gZ[m^ms__��qlh�ihgbfZgb_�^_ckl\bc� ]hjfhgh\�²�\u� agZ_l_��qlh� wlh� lZdh_�²�ij_^hklZ\bl�gZfkj_^kl\Z�^ey�mki_rghc�[hjv[u�k dhebq_kl\_ggufb�nZdlhjZfb�aZ[he_\Zgbc��gh�k_]h^gy�fu��_s_^Ze_db�hl�wlh]h��Y iheZ]Zx��qlh�g_m\_j_gghklv�\h�\k_o�wlbo�hlghr_gbyo�^Z_l�gZf�ihklhyggucklbfme�^ey�kh\_jr_gkl\h\Zgby�l_ogbdb�ZgZebaZ��b \�qZklghklb�i_j_g_k_gby��Gh\bqhd�\ ZgZeba_hkh[_ggh�[m^_l� khfg_\Zlvky�ijb�g_m^Zq_�� \bgblv� eb� _fm� \ g_c� k\h_h[jZab_� kemqZy� beb� k\h_g_eh\dh_�h[jZs_gb_�k l_jZi_\lbq_kdbf�f_lh^hf��Gh�y m`_�kdZaZe��y g_�^mfZx��qlh�[eZ]h^Zjymkbebyf�\ wlhf�gZijZ\e_gbb�fh`gh�^hklbqv�fgh]h]h�>jm]h_�h]jZgbq_gb_�ZgZeblbq_kdbo�mki_oh\�hij_^_ey_lky�nhjfhc�[he_agb��<u�m`_�agZ_l_�qlh� h[eZklvx� ijbeh`_gby� ZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_jZibb� y\eyxlky� g_\jhau� i_j_g_k_gby�� nh[bb�bkl_jbb��g_\jhau�gZ\yaqb\uo�khklhygbc��djhf_�lh]h��g_ghjfZevghklb�oZjZdl_jZ��jZa\b\rb_ky

Page 344: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\f_klh� wlbo� aZ[he_\Zgbc�� <k_�� qlh� y\ey_lky� bguf�²� gZjpbkklbq_kdb_�� ikbohlbq_kdb_khklhygby�²�g_�ih^oh^bl�\ [hevr_c�beb�f_gvr_c�kl_i_gb��Gh�\_^v�\iheg_�aZdhggh�[ueh�[uaZsblblvky� hl� g_m^Zq�� lsZl_evgh� bkdexqZy� lZdb_� kemqZb�� KlZlbklbdb� ZgZebaZ� ihemqbeb� [u[eZ]h^Zjy� wlhc� hklhjh`ghklb� [hevrh_� h[e_]q_gb_�� >Z�� gh� lml� _klv� h^gZ� aZ]\ha^dZ�� GZrb^bZ]ghau� hq_gv� qZklh� klZ\ylky� ebrv� kh� \j_f_g_f�� hgb� ih^h[gu� jZkihagZ\Zgbx� \_^vfrhleZg^kdbf�dhjhe_f��h dhlhjhf�y qblZe�m <bdlhjZ�=x]h��Wlhl�dhjhev�ml\_j`^Ze��qlh�h[eZ^Z_l[_ahrb[hqguf� f_lh^hf� hij_^_e_gby� \_^vf��Hg� aZklZ\eye� hriZjblv� __ dbiyldhf� \ dhle_�� ZaZl_f�ijh[h\Ze� kmi��Ihke_� wlh]h�hg�fh]� kdZaZlv�� ©Wlh�[ueZ� \_^vfZª�beb�� ©G_l�� wlh�[ueZ�g_\_^vfZª�� :gZeh]bqgh_� ijhbkoh^bl� m gZk�� k lhc� ebrv� jZagbp_c�� qlh� fu� bf__f� ^_eh� kgZjmr_gbyfb�� Fu� g_� fh`_f� km^blv� h iZpb_gl_�� dhlhjuc� ijbr_e� gZ� e_q_gb_�� beb� `_� hdZg^b^Zl_�^ey� h[mq_gby��ihdZ�g_� bamqbf� _]h� \ l_q_gb_�g_kdhevdbo�g_^_ev� beb�f_kyp_\��Fu^_ckl\bl_evgh�ihdmiZ_f�dhlZ�\ f_rd_��IZpb_gl�\ukdZau\Z_l�g_hij_^_e_ggu_�h[sb_�`Zeh[u�dhlhju_�g_�iha\heyxl�ihklZ\blv�\_jguc�^bZ]gha��Ih�bkl_q_gbb� wlh]h� djblbq_kdh]h� \j_f_gbfh`_l�h[gZjm`blvky��qlh�wlh�g_ih^oh^ysbc�kemqZc��DZg^b^ZlZ�fu�lh]^Z�hlkueZ_f��iZpb_glZ`_�hklZ\ey_f�gZ�g_dhlhjh_�\j_fy��iulZykv�m\b^_lv�_]h�\ [he__�\u]h^ghf�k\_l_��IZpb_gl�fklblgZf� l_f��qlh� m\_ebqb\Z_l� kibkhd�gZrbo�g_m^Zq�� hl\_j]gmluc� dZg^b^Zl�� _keb� hg�iZjZghbd�²ijbf_jgh� l_f�� qlh� kZf� gZqbgZ_l� ibkZlv� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdb_� dgb]b�� DZd� \b^bl_�� gZrZhklhjh`ghklv�gZf�g_�ihfh]eZ�;hxkv�� qlh� wlb� ^_lZevgu_� h[km`^_gby� m`_� g_� ij_^klZ\eyxl� ^ey� \Zk� bgl_j_kZ��Gh� y [ukh`Ze_e� _s_� [hevr_�� _keb� [u� \u� ih^mfZeb�� qlh� fhbf� gZf_j_gb_f� [ueh� ijbgbablv� \Zr_m\Z`_gb_�d ikbohZgZebam�dZd�l_jZibb��<hafh`gh��y ^_ckl\bl_evgh�g_m^Zqgh�gZqZe��gh�y ohl_edZd� jZa� ijhlb\hiheh`gh]h�� ba\bgblv� l_jZi_\lbq_kdb_� h]jZgbq_gby� ZgZebaZ�� mdZaZ\� gZ� bog_ba[_`ghklv�� K l_f� `_� gZf_j_gb_f� y h[jZsZxkv� d ^jm]hfm� fhf_glm�� d lhfm� mij_dm�� qlhZgZeblbq_kdh_� e_q_gb_� aZgbfZ_l� g_kjZ\gbfh� [hevr__� \j_fy�� GZ� wlh� ke_^m_l� kdZaZlv�� qlhikbobq_kdb_�baf_g_gby�ijhbkoh^yl�dZd�jZa�f_^e_ggh��_keb�hgb�gZklmiZxl�[ukljh��g_h`b^Zggh²� wlh� iehohc� ijbagZd��>_ckl\bl_evgh�� e_q_gb_� ly`_eh]h� g_\jhaZ� \iheg_�fh`_l� ijh^eblvkyg_kdhevdh�e_l��gh�\ kemqZ_�mki_oZ�aZ^Zcl_�k_[_�\hijhk��kdhevdh�[u�ijh^ebeky�g_^m]"�<_jhylgh�^_kylbe_lb_�aZ�dZ`^uc�]h^�e_q_gby��wlh�agZqbl��[he_agv�\hh[s_�gbdh]^Z�[u�g_�m]ZkeZ��dZd�fuqZklh�\b^bf�m [hevguo��dhlhju_�g_�e_qbebkv��< g_dhlhjuo�kemqZyo�fu�bf__f�hkgh\Zgb_�\gh\vgZqZlv�ZgZeba�q_j_a�g_kdhevdh�e_l��`bagv�^Z_l�gh\u_�ih\h^u�^ey�gh\uo�[he_ag_gguo�j_Zdpbc�\ ijhf_`mld_� `_� gZr� iZpb_gl� [ue� a^hjh\�� Ijhklh� i_j\uc� ZgZeba� h[gZjm`be� g_� \k_� _]hiZlheh]bq_kdb_�ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklb��b _kl_kl\_ggh�[ueh�ij_djZlblv�ZgZeba��ihke_�lh]h dZdmki_o� [ue�^hklb]gml��?klv� lZd`_� ex^b� k ly`_eufb�gZjmr_gbyfb�� dhlhju_� \kx� k\hx�`bagvgZoh^ylky�ih^�ZgZeblbq_kdbf�gZ[ex^_gb_f�b \j_fy�hl�\j_f_gb�kgh\Z�ih^\_j]Zxlky�ZgZebam�gh�bgZq_�wlb�ebpZ�\hh[s_�[ueb�[u�g_kihkh[gu�d kms_kl\h\Zgbx��b gm`gh�jZ^h\Zlvky��qlh�bofh`gh� ih^^_j`b\Zlv� lZdbf� qZklbqguf� b ih\lhjyxsbfky� e_q_gb_f�� :gZeba� gZjmr_gbcoZjZdl_jZ� lh`_�hlgbfZ_l�fgh]h�\j_f_gb��Z agZ_l_�eb�\u�dZdmx�gb[m^v�^jm]mx� l_jZibx��ijbihfhsb� dhlhjhc� fh`gh� [ueh� [u� \aylvky� aZ� wlm� aZ^Zqm"� L_jZi_\lbq_kdh_� ls_keZ\b_� fh`_lqm\kl\h\Zlv� k_[y� g_� m^h\e_l\hj_gguf� wlbfb� ^Zggufb�� gh� \_^v� gZ� ijbf_j_� lm[_jdme_aZ� b\heqZgdb� fu� gZmqbebkv� lhfm�� qlh� mki_oZ� fh`gh� ^hklbqv� ebrv� lh]^Z�� dh]^Z� l_jZibykhhl\_lkl\m_l�oZjZdl_jm�g_^m]Z�Y ]h\hjbe�\Zf��qlh�ikbohZgZeba�gZqZe�dZd�l_jZiby��gh�y ohl_e�[u�\Zf�_]h�j_dhf_g^h\Zlv�g_

Page 345: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\ dZq_kl\_�l_jZibb��Z ba�aZ�kh^_j`Zgby�\ g_f�bklbgu��ba�aZ�jZatykg_gbc��dhlhju_�hg�gZf�^Z_l��hlhf��qlh�dZkZ_lky�q_eh\_dZ�[eb`_�\k_]h��_]h�kh[kl\_gghc�kmsghklb��b ba�aZ�k\ya_c��dhlhju_�hg\kdju\Z_l� \ kZfuo� jZaebqguo� h[eZklyo� _]h� ^_yl_evghklb�� DZd� l_jZiby� hg� h^bg� ba� fgh]bo�fh`_l�[ulv� SULPD�LQWHU�SDUHV � ?keb�[u�hg�g_�bf_e�k\h_c�l_jZi_\lbq_kdhc�p_gghklb��hg�g_�[ue[u�hldjul�gZ�[hevguo�b g_�jZa\b\Zeky�[u�\ l_q_gb_�[he__�ljb^pZlb�e_l�LJB>P:LV�IYL:Y�E?DPBYH fbjh\haaj_gbbM\Z`Z_fu_�^Zfu�b ]hkih^Z��<h�\j_fy�gZr_c�ihke_^g_c�\klj_qb�fu�aZgbfZebkv�f_edbfbih\k_^g_\gufb� \hijhkZfb�� dZd� [u� ijb\h^y� \ ihjy^hd� \k_� gZr_� kdjhfgh_� ohayckl\h�Ij_^ijbf_f� `_� l_i_jv� hl\Z`gmx� ihiuldm� b jbkdg_f� hl\_lblv� gZ� \hijhk�� dhlhjucg_h^ghdjZlgh�klZ\beky�k ^jm]hc�klhjhgu�²�\_^_l�eb�ikbohZgZeba�d dZdhfm�lh�hij_^_e_gghfmfbjh\haaj_gbx�b _keb�\_^_l��lh�d dZdhfm�;hxkv��qlh�fbjh\haaj_gb_ �:HOWDQVFKDXXQJ��² ki_pbnbq_kdb�g_f_pdh_�ihgylb_��i_j_\h^dhlhjh]h� gZ� bghkljZggu_� yaudb� fh`_l� [ulv� aZljm^g_g�� ?keb� y b� ihiulZxkv� ^Zlv� _fmhij_^_e_gb_��hgh��\_jhylgh��ihdZ`_lky�\Zf�g_mdex`bf��BlZd��y iheZ]Zx��qlh�fbjh\haaj_gb_�²wlh�bgl_ee_dlmZevgZy�dhgkljmdpby��dhlhjZy�_^bghh[jZagh�j_rZ_l�\k_�ijh[e_fu�gZr_]h�[ulby�bkoh^y�ba�g_dh_]h�\ukr_]h�ij_^iheh`_gby��\ dhlhjhc�\ khhl\_lkl\bb�k wlbf�gb h^bg�\hijhk�g_hklZ_lky�hldjuluf��Z \k_��qlh�\uau\Z_l�gZr�bgl_j_k��aZgbfZ_l�k\h_�hij_^_e_ggh_�f_klh��E_]dhihgylv�� qlh� h[eZ^Zgb_� lZdbf� fbjh\haaj_gb_f� ijbgZ^e_`bl� d b^_Zevguf� `_eZgbyf� ex^_c�IheZ]Zykv�gZ�g_]h��fh`gh�gZ^_`gh�qm\kl\h\Zlv�k_[y�\ `bagb��agZlv��d q_fm�ke_^m_l�klj_fblvky�dZd�gZb[he__�p_e_khh[jZagh�jZkihjy^blvky�k\hbfb�Znn_dlZfb�b bgl_j_kZfb�

�I_j\uc�kj_^b�jZ\guo��eZl����Ijbf_q��i_j�?keb� wlh� y\ey_lky� kmlvx�fbjh\haaj_gby�� lh� hl\_l� \ hlghr_gbb� ikbohZgZebaZ� yk_g��DZdki_pbZevgZy� gZmdZ�� dZd� hljZkev� ikboheh]bb� ²� ]em[bgghc� ikboheh]bb�� beb� ikboheh]bb[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�²� hg� kh\_jr_ggh� g_� kihkh[_g� \ujZ[hlZlv� kh[kl\_ggh_�fbjh\haaj_gb_�� hg^he`_g� aZbfkl\h\Zlv� _]h� m gZmdb��Gh� gZmqgh_� fbjh\haaj_gb_� m`_� fZeh� ihiZ^Z_l� ih^� gZr_hij_^_e_gb_�� ?^bghh[jZab_ h[tykg_gby� fbjZ�� ijZ\^Z�� ij_^iheZ]Z_lky� b bf�� gh� lhevdh� dZdijh]jZffZ��\uiheg_gb_�dhlhjhc�hlh^\b]Z_lky�\ [m^ms__��< hklZevghf�`_�hgh�oZjZdl_jbam_lkyg_]Zlb\gufb� k\hckl\Zfb�� h]jZgbq_gghklvx� ihagZ\Z_fh]h� gZ� ^Zgguc� fhf_gl� b j_adbfg_ijbylb_f� hij_^_e_gguo��qm`^uo� _fm� we_f_glh\��Hgh� ml\_j`^Z_l��qlh�g_l�gbdZdbo� ^jm]bobklhqgbdh\� ihagZgby� fbjZ�� djhf_� bgl_ee_dlmZevghc� h[jZ[hldb� lsZl_evgh� ijh\_j_gguogZ[ex^_gbc�� l�� _�� lh]h�� qlh� gZau\Z_lky� bkke_^h\Zgb_f�� b g_� kms_kl\m_l� gbdZdbo� agZgbc�y\eyxsboky�j_amevlZlhf� hldjh\_gby��bglmbpbb�beb�ij_^\b^_gby��DZ`_lky�� wlZ� lhqdZ� aj_gby[ueZ�ihqlb� h[s_ijbagZgghc� \ ij_^u^msb_� klhe_lby�� AZ� gZrbf� klhe_lb_f� hklZ\Zehkv� ijZ\h\ukhdhf_jgh�\hajZablv��qlh�ih^h[gh_�fbjh\haaj_gb_�klhev�`_�[_^gh��kdhev�b g_ml_rbl_evgh�qlh�hgh�g_�mqblu\Z_l�ijblyaZgbc�q_eh\_q_kdh]h�^moZ�b ihlj_[ghkl_c�q_eh\_q_kdhc�^mrb�Wlh� \hajZ`_gb_�fh`gh� hijh\_j]gmlv� [_a� hkh[uo� mkbebc��Hgh� kh\_jr_ggh� [_kihq\_ggh�

Page 346: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ihkdhevdm� ^mo� b ^mrZ� kmlv� lZdb_� `_� h[t_dlu� gZmqgh]h� bkke_^h\Zgby�� dZd� b dZdb_�eb[h� g_ijbkmsb_� q_eh\_dm� \_sb�� IkbohZgZeba� bf__l� hkh[h_� ijZ\h� kdZaZlv� a^_kv� keh\h� \ aZsblmgZmqgh]h� fbjh\haaj_gby�� ihlhfm� qlh� _]h� g_evay� mij_dgmlv� \ lhf�� qlh� hg� ij_g_[j_]Z_l^mr_\guf� \ dZjlbg_� fbjZ�� ?]h� \deZ^� \ gZmdm� dZd� jZa� b khklhbl� \ jZkijhkljZg_gbbbkke_^h\Zgby�gZ�h[eZklv�^mrb��<h�\kydhf�kemqZ_�[_a�lZdhc�ikboheh]bb�gZmdZ�[ueZ�[u�\_kvfZ�b\_kvfZ�g_iheghc��Gh�_keb�\dexqblv�\ gZmdm�bamq_gb_�bgl_ee_dlmZevguo�nmgdpbc�q_eh\_dZ��b`b\hlguo��� lh� h[gZjm`blky�� qlh� h[sZy� mklZgh\dZ� gZmdb� hklZg_lky� ij_`g_c�� g_� ihy\blkygbdZdbo�gh\uo�bklhqgbdh\�agZgby�beb�f_lh^h\�bkke_^h\Zgby��LZdh\ufb�[ueb�[u�bglmbpby�bij_^\b^_gb_��_keb�[u�hgb�kms_kl\h\Zeb��gh�bo�fh`gh�ijhklh�kqblZlv�beexabyfb��bkiheg_gb_f`_eZgbc��E_]dh�aZf_lblv�lZd`_��qlh�\ur_mdZaZggu_�lj_[h\Zgby�d fbjh\haaj_gbx�h[hkgh\Zguebrv� Znn_dlb\gh�� GZmdZ�� ijbagZ\Zy�� qlh� ^mr_\gZy� `bagv� q_eh\_dZ� \u^\b]Z_l� lZdb_lj_[h\Zgby��]hlh\Z�ijh\_jylv�bo�bklhqgbdb��h^gZdh�m g__�g_l�gb�fZe_cr_]h�hkgh\Zgby�kqblZlvbo�hijZ\^Zggufb��GZijhlb\��hgZ��\b^bl�k_[y�ijba\Zgghc�lsZl_evgh�hl^_eylv�hl�agZgby�\k_��qlhy\ey_lky�beexab_c��j_amevlZlhf�lZdh]h�Znn_dlb\gh]h�lj_[h\Zgby�Wlh�gb�\ dh_f�kemqZ_�g_�hagZqZ_l��qlh� wlb�`_eZgby�ke_^m_l�k ij_aj_gb_f�hl[jZku\Zlv�\klhjhgm� beb� g_^hhp_gb\Zlv� bo� agZqbfhklv� ^ey� `bagb� q_eh\_dZ�� Ke_^m_l� ijhke_^blv�� dZd\hiehlbebkv�hgb�\ ijhba\_^_gbyo�bkdmkkl\Z��\ j_eb]bhaguo�b nbehkhnkdbo�kbkl_fZo��h^gZdhg_evay�g_�aZf_lblv��qlh�[ueh�[u�g_ijZ\hf_jgh�b \�\ukr_c�kl_i_gb�g_p_e_khh[jZagh�^himklblvi_j_ghk�wlbo�ijblyaZgbc�\ h[eZklv�ihagZgby��Ihlhfm�qlh�wlh�fh`_l�ijb\_klb�d ikbohaZf��[m^vlh� bg^b\b^mZevgu_� beb� fZkkh\u_� ikbohau�� ebrZy� p_gghc� wg_j]bb� l_� klj_fe_gby�� dhlhju_gZijZ\e_gu�d ^_ckl\bl_evghklb��qlh[u�m^h\e_l\hjblv�\ g_c��gZkdhevdh�wlh�\hafh`gh��`_eZgbyb ihlj_[ghklb�K lhqdb� aj_gby� gZmdb� a^_kv� g_h[oh^bfh� gZqZlv� djblbdm� b ijbklmiblv� d hlihjm�G_^himklbfh�]h\hjblv��qlh�gZmdZ�y\ey_lky�h^ghc�h[eZklvx�^_yl_evghklb�q_eh\_q_kdh]h�^moZ��Zj_eb]by�b nbehkhnby�²�^jm]bfb��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��jZ\ghp_ggufb�_c�h[eZklyfb��b qlh�gZmdZ�g_fh`_l� gbq_]h� kdZaZlv� \ wlbo� ^\mo� h[eZklyo� hl� k_[y�� hgb� \k_� bf_xl� jZ\gu_� ijblyaZgby� gZbklbgm�� b dZ`^uc� q_eh\_d� k\h[h^_g� \u[jZlv�� hldm^Z� _fm� q_jiZlv�� k\hb� m[_`^_gby� b \h� qlh\_jblv�� LZdh_� \haaj_gb_� kqblZ_lky� hkh[_ggh� [eZ]hjh^guf�� l_jibfuf�� \k_h[t_fexsbf� bk\h[h^guf�hl�f_ehqguo�ij_^jZkkm^dh\��D kh`Ze_gbx��hgh�g_mklhcqb\h��hgh�bf__l�qZklbqgh\k_� g_^hklZldb� Z[khexlgh� g_gZmqgh]h� fbjh\haaj_gby� b ijZdlbq_kdb� jZ\ghagZqgh� _fm�IhemqZ_lky�lZd��qlh�bklbgZ�g_�fh`_l�[ulv�l_jibfhc��hgZ�g_�^himkdZ_l�gbdZdbo�dhfijhfbkkh\b h]jZgbq_gbc�� qlh� bkke_^h\Zgb_� jZkkfZljb\Z_l� \k_� h[eZklb� q_eh\_q_kdhc� ^_yl_evghklb� dZdk\hx� \hlqbgm� b ^he`gh� [ulv� g_mfhebfh� djblbqguf�� _keb� ^jm]Zy� kbeZ� ohq_l� aZ\eZ^_lv� __qZklvx�^ey�k_[y�Ba� lj_o� kbe�� dhlhju_� fh]ml� ihkihjblv� k gZmdhc�� lhevdh� j_eb]by� y\ey_lky� k_jv_aguf\jZ]hf��Bkdmkkl\h�ihqlb�\k_]^Z�[_ah[b^gh�b [eZ]hl\hjgh��hgh�b g_�ohq_l�[ulv�gb�q_f�bguf�djhf_� beexabb�� ?keb� g_� kqblZlv� l_o� g_fgh]bo� ebp�� dhlhju_�� dZd� ]h\hjblky�� h^_j`bfubkdmkkl\hf�� hgh� g_� j_rZ_lky� gb� gZ� dZdb_� \lhj`_gby� \ h[eZklv� j_Zevgh]h�� Nbehkhnby� g_ijhlb\hiheh`gZ�gZmd_��hgZ�kZfZ�\h�fgh]hf�ZgZeh]bqgZ�gZmd_��jZ[hlZ_l�qZklbqgh�ijb�ihfhsbl_o� `_� f_lh^h\�� gh� hl^Zey_lky� hl� g__�� ijb^_j`b\Zykv� beexabb�� qlh� hgZ� fh`_l� ^Zlv[_amij_qgmx�b k\yagmx�dZjlbgm�fbjZ��dhlhjZy��h^gZdh��jZkiZ^Z_lky�k dZ`^uf�gh\uf�mki_ohf

Page 347: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

gZr_]h� agZgby�� F_lh^bq_kdb� hgZ� aZ[em`^Z_lky� \ lhf�� qlh� i_j_hp_gb\Z_l� ihagZ\Zl_evgh_agZq_gb_� gZrbo� eh]bq_kdbo� hi_jZpbc�� ijbagZ\Zy� b ^jm]b_� bklhqgbdb� agZgby�� lZdb_�� dZdbglmbpby��B ^hklZlhqgh� qZklh� kqblZxl�� qlh� gZkf_rdZ� ihwlZ� �=�� =_cg_��� dh]^Z� hg� ]h\hjbl� hnbehkhn_�Hg�klZjuf�reZnjhdhf�b ijhqbf�ljyiv_f�Ijhj_ob�aZrlhiZ_l�m fbjha^Zgvy�²�I_j_\h^ =��KbevfZg�g_� ebr_gZ� hkgh\Zgby��Gh�nbehkhnby� g_� bf__l� gbdZdh]h� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh]h� \ebygby� gZ[hevrb_�fZkku�ex^_c��hgZ�bgl_j_km_l�ebrv�kZfmx�g_[hevrmx�qZklv�kZfh]h�madh]h�\_jog_]hkehy�bgl_ee_dlmZeh\�� hklZ\Zykv�^ey� \k_o�ijhqbo�fZeh^hklmighc��GZijhlb\�� j_eb]by� y\ey_lkyg_\_jhylghc� kbehc�� dhlhjZy� \eZ^__l� kZfufb� kbevgufb� wfhpbyfb� q_eh\_dZ�� DZd� ba\_klgh�dh]^Z�lh�hgZ�ho\Zlu\ZeZ�\k_�^moh\gh_�\ q_eh\_q_kdhc�`bagb��hgZ�aZgbfZeZ�f_klh�gZmdb��dh]^ZgZmdZ� _^\Z� aZjh`^ZeZkv�� b kha^ZeZ� fbjh\haaj_gb_�� hlebqZ\r__ky� [_kijbf_jghcihke_^h\Zl_evghklvx� b aZdhgq_gghklvx�� dhlhjh_� _s_� k_]h^gy�� ohly� b ihrZlgm\r__ky�ijh^he`Z_l�kms_kl\h\Zlv�Hl^Z\Zy�^he`gh_�]jZg^bhaghklb�j_eb]bb��gm`gh�ihfgblv��qlh�hgZ�klj_fblky�^Zlv�ex^yf�HgZ� ^Z_l� bf� h[tykg_gb_� ijhbkoh`^_gby� b jZa\blby� fbjZ�� hgZ� h[_ki_qb\Z_l� bf� aZsblm� b \dhg_qghf� kq_l_� kqZklv_� kj_^b� \k_o� ij_\jZlghkl_c�`bagb�� b hgZ� gZijZ\ey_l� bo� m[_`^_gby� b^_ckl\by�ij_^ibkZgbyfb��dhlhju_�ij_^klZ\ey_l�\k_f�k\hbf�Z\lhjbl_lhf��LZdbf�h[jZahf��hgZ\uihegy_l� ljb� nmgdpbb�� <h�i_j\uo�� hgZ� m^h\e_l\hjy_l� q_eh\_q_kdmx� ex[hagZl_evghklv�^_eZ_l�lh�`_�kZfh_��qlh�iulZ_lky�^_eZlv�gZmdZ�k\hbfb�kj_^kl\Zfb��b khi_jgbqZ_l�a^_kv�k g_c�<lhjhc� k\h_c�nmgdpbb� hgZ�� ih`Zemc�� h[yaZgZ� [hevr_c� qZklvx� k\h_]h� \ebygby��HgZ� mfZey_lkljZo� ex^_c� i_j_^� hiZkghklyfb� b ij_\jZlghklyfb� `bagb�� \k_ey_l� m\_j_gghklv� \ ^h[jhfbkoh^_��ml_rZ_l�bo�\ g_kqZklv_��b lml�gZmdZ�g_�fh`_l�k g_c�khi_jgbqZlv��IjZ\^Z��gZmdZ�mqbl�dZd�fh`gh�ba[_`Zlv�hij_^_e_gguo�hiZkghkl_c��mki_rgh�ih[hjhlv�g_dhlhju_�kljZ^Zgby��[ueh[u�g_kijZ\_^eb\h�hkiZjb\Zlv��qlh�hgZ�kbevgZy�ihfhsgbpZ�ex^yf��gh�\h�fgh]bo�kemqZyo�hgZ\ugm`^_gZ�ij_^hklZ\eylv�q_eh\_dZ�_]h�kljZ^Zgbx�b fh`_l�ihkh\_lh\Zlv�_fm�ebrv�ihdhjghklv�< k\h_c� lj_lv_c� nmgdpbb�� ^Z\Zy� ij_^ibkZgby�� ijh\ha]eZrZy� aZij_lv�� b h]jZgbq_gby�� hgZ� \gZb[hevr_c�kl_i_gb�hl^Zey_lky�hl�gZmdb��ihkdhevdm�gZmdZ�^h\hevkl\m_lky�bkke_^h\Zgbyfb�bdhgklZlZpbyfb��IjZ\^Z��ba�__ ijbeh`_gbc�\u\h^ylky�ijZ\beZ�b kh\_lu�^ey�ih\_^_gby�\ `bagb�Bgh]^Z�hgb�l_�`_��qlh�ij_^eZ]Z_l�b j_eb]by��gh�lhevdh�k ^jm]bfb�h[hkgh\Zgbyfb�Kh_^bg_gb_� wlbo� lj_o� nmgdpbc� j_eb]bb� g_� \iheg_� hq_\b^gh�� Qlh� h[s_]h� f_`^mh[tykg_gb_f� \hagbdgh\_gby� fbjZ� b kljh]bf� \gmr_gb_f� hij_^_e_gguo� wlbq_kdboij_^ibkZgbc"�H[_sZgby� aZsblu�b kqZklvy�[he__� l_kgh� k\yaZgu� k wlbq_kdbfb� lj_[h\Zgbyfb�Hgb�y\eyxlky�ieZlhc� aZ�\uiheg_gb_� wlbo� aZih\_^_c�� lhevdh� lhl��dlh�bf�ih^qbgy_lky��fh`_ljZkkqblu\Zlv�gZ�wlb�[eZ]h^_ygby��g_ihkemrguo�`^ml�gZdZaZgby��<ijhq_f��b \�gZmd_�_klv�g_qlhihoh`__��Dlh�g_�h[jZsZ_l�\gbfZgby�gZ�__�ij_^ibkZgby��iheZ]Z_l�hgZ��lhl�\j_^bl�k_[_�KljZggh_�khq_lZgb_�ihmq_gby��ml_r_gby�b lj_[h\Zgby�\ j_eb]bb�fh`gh�ihgylv�lhevdh� �\lhf� kemqZ_�� _keb� ih^\_j]gmlv� __ ]_g_lbq_kdhfm� ZgZebam�� ?]h� fh`gh� aZqZlv� k kZfh]h� yjdh]hdhfihg_glZ� wlh]h� ZgkZf[ey� ²� k mq_gby� h \hagbdgh\_gbb� fbjZ�� b[h� ihq_fm� `_� bf_gghdhkfh]hgby�\k_]^Z�[ueZ�ihklhygghc�khklZ\ghc�qZklvx�j_eb]bhaghc�kbkl_fu"�Mq_gb_�lZdh\h��

Page 348: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

fbj�[ue�kha^Zg�kms_kl\hf��ih^h[guf�q_eh\_dm��gh�ij_\hkoh^ysbf�_]h�\h�\k_o�h kghr_gbyo�²\eZklb��fm^jhklb��kbeu�kljZkl_c��l��_��g_dbf�b^_Zebabjh\Zgguf�k\_joq_eh\_dhf��@b\hlgu_�dZdkha^Zl_eb� fbjZ� mdZau\Zxl� gZ� \ebygb_� lhl_fbafZ�� dhlhjh]h� fu� iha^g__� dhkg_fky� ohly� [uh^gbf�aZf_qZgb_f��Bgl_j_kgh��qlh�wlhl�kha^Zl_ev�fbjZ�\k_]^Z�lhevdh�h^bg��^Z`_�lZf��]^_�\_jyl\h�fgh]bo� [h]h\��Lhqgh� lZd�`_� h[uqgh� wlh�fm`qbgZ�� ohly� g_l� g_^hklZldZ� b \� mdZaZgbyo� gZ`_gkdb_�[h`_kl\Z��b \�g_dhlhjuo�fbnheh]byo�khl\hj_gb_�fbjZ�gZqbgZ_lky�dZd�jZa�k lh]h��qlh[h]�fm`qbgZ� mkljZgy_l� `_gkdh_� [h`_kl\h�� dhlhjh_� gba\h^blky� ^h� qm^h\bsZ�� A^_kv� g_fZehbgl_j_kg_crbo� qZklguo� ijh[e_f�� gh� fu� ^he`gu� ki_rblv�� >Zevg_crbc� imlv� e_]dhhij_^_ey_lky� l_f��qlh� wlhl�[h]�l\hj_p�ijyfh�gZau\Z_lky� hlphf��IkbohZgZeba� aZdexqZ_l�� qlhwlh�^_ckl\bl_evgh� hl_p�� lZdhc� ]jZg^bhaguc�� dZdbf� hg� dh]^Z�lh� dZaZeky�fZe_gvdhfm� j_[_gdm�J_eb]bhaguc� q_eh\_d� ij_^klZ\ey_l� k_[_� khl\hj_gb_� fbjZ� lZd� `_�� dZd� k\h_� kh[kl\_ggh_\hagbdgh\_gb_�>Ze__� e_]dh� ihgylv�� dZd� ml_rbl_evgu_� aZ\_j_gby� b kljh]b_� lj_[h\Zgby� khq_lZxlky� kdhkfh]hgb_c�� Ihlhfm� qlh� lh� `_� kZfh_� ebph�� dhlhjhfm� j_[_ghd� h[yaZg� k\hbfkms_kl\h\Zgb_f�²� hl_p� �ohly� ijZ\bevg__� ²� khklhysZy� ba� hlpZ� b fZl_jb� jh^bl_evkdZybgklZgpby�� h[_j_]Ze� b hojZgye� keZ[h]h�� [_kihfhsgh]h� j_[_gdZ�� ij_^hklZ\e_ggh]h� \k_fih^kl_j_]Z\rbf�_]h�hiZkghklyf�\g_rg_]h�fbjZ��ih^�_]h�aZsblhc�hg�qm\kl\h\Ze�k_[y�m\_j_ggh�B ohly�� klZ\� \ajhkeuf�� q_eh\_d� ihqm\kl\h\Ze� \ k_[_� ]hjZa^h� [hevr_� kbe�� _]h� hkhagZgb_hiZkghkl_c�`bagb�lh`_�\hajhkeh��b hg�ih�ijZ\m�aZdexqZ_l��qlh�\ hkgh\_�k\h_c�hklZeky�lZdbf�`_[_kihfhsguf�b [_aaZsblguf��dZd�\ ^_lkl\_��qlh�ih�hlghr_gbx�d fbjm�hg�\k_�_s_�j_[_ghd��LZdqlh�hg�b l_i_jv�g_�ohq_l�hldZau\Zlvky�hl�aZsblu��dhlhjhc�ihevah\Zeky�\ ^_lkl\_��Gh�hg�^Z\ghm`_�ihgye��qlh�\ k\h_c�\eZklb�_]h�hl_p�y\ey_lky�\_kvfZ�h]jZgbq_gguf�kms_kl\hf��h[eZ^Zxsbf^Ze_dh� g_� \k_fb� ij_bfms_kl\Zfb��Ihwlhfm� hg� h[jZsZ_lky� d h[jZam� \hkihfbgZgby� h[� hlp_�dhlhjh]h� lZd�i_j_hp_gb\Ze� \ ^_lkl\_�� \ha\urZy� _]h�^h�[h`_kl\Z�b \dexqZy� \ gZklhys__�b \j_Zevghklv��:nn_dlb\gZy�kbeZ�wlh]h�h[jZaZ�\hkihfbgZgby�b ^Zevg_crZy�ihlj_[ghklv�\ aZsbl_g_kml�\ k_[_�_]h�\_jm�\ [h]Z�B lj_lbc� hkgh\ghc� imgdl� j_eb]bhaghc� ijh]jZffu�� wlbq_kdh_� lj_[h\Zgb_�� [_a� ljm^Z\ibku\Z_lky� \ wlm� ^_lkdmx� kblmZpbx�� GZihfgx� \Zf� a^_kv� agZf_gblh_� baj_q_gb_� DZglZ�dhlhjuc� kh_^bgy_l� mkuiZggh_� a\_a^Zfb�g_[h�b gjZ\kl\_gguc� aZdhg� \ gZk��DZd� [u� qm`^h�gba\mqZeh� wlh� khihklZ\e_gb_�²� b[h� qlh� fh`_l� [ulv� h[s_]h� f_`^m� g_[_kgufb� l_eZfb� b\hijhkhf�� ex[bl� eb� h^gh� ^bly� q_eh\_q_kdh_� ^jm]h_� beb� m[b\Z_l"� ²� hg \k_�lZdb� hljZ`Z_l[hevrmx� ikboheh]bq_kdmx� bklbgm�� Lhl� `_� hl_p� �jh^bl_evkdZy� bgklZgpby��� dhlhjuc� ^Zej_[_gdm�`bagv�b h[_j_]Ze�_]h�hl�hiZkghkl_c��mqbe�_]h��qlh�fh`gh�^_eZlv��Z hl�q_]h�hg�^he`_ghldZau\Zlvky�� mdZau\Ze� _fm� gZ� g_h[oh^bfhklv� hij_^_e_gguo� h]jZgbq_gbc� k\hbo� \e_q_gbc�aZklZ\be�magZlv��dZdbo�hlghr_gbc�d jh^bl_eyf��d [jZlvyf�b k_kljZf�hl�g_]h�`^ml��_keb�hg�ohq_lklZlv�l_jibfuf�b `_eZgguf�qe_ghf�k_f_cgh]h�djm]Z�� Z iha^g__�b [he__�rbjhdbo�khxah\��Kihfhsvx� kbkl_fu� ihhsj_gbc� ex[h\vx� b gZdZaZgbc� m j_[_gdZ� \hkiblu\Z_lky� agZgb_� _]hkhpbZevguo� h[yaZgghkl_c�� _]h� mqZl� lhfm��qlh� _]h�[_ahiZkghklv� \ `bagb� aZ\bkbl� hl� lh]h�� qlhjh^bl_eb��Z aZl_f�b ^jm]b_�ex[yl�_]h�b fh]ml�\_jblv�\ _]h�ex[h\v�d gbf��<k_�wlb�hlghr_gbyq_eh\_d�i_j_ghkbl�g_baf_g_ggufb� \ j_eb]bx��AZij_lu�b lj_[h\Zgby�jh^bl_e_c�ijh^he`Zxl`blv� \ g_f� dZd�fhjZevgZy� kh\_klv�� k ihfhsvx� lhc�`_� kbkl_fu�ihhsj_gbc�b gZdZaZgbc�[h]mijZ\ey_l� q_eh\_q_kdbf�fbjhf�� hl� \uiheg_gby� wlbq_kdbo� lj_[h\Zgbc� aZ\bkbl�� \ dZdhc�f_j_

Page 349: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

aZsblZ�b kqZklv_�^hklZxlky�bg^b\b^mmfm�gZ� ex[\b� d [h]m� b gZ� khagZgbb� [ulv� ex[bfuf� ab`^_lky� m\_j_gghklv�� dhlhjZy� kem`blhjm`b_f�ijhlb\� hiZkghkl_c� dZd� \g_rg_]h�fbjZ�� lZd�b q_eh\_q_kdh]h� hdjm`_gby��GZdhg_p�� \fhebl\_�\_jmxsb_�hdZau\Zxl�ijyfh_�\ebygb_�gZ�[h`_kl\_ggmx�\hex��ijbh[sZykv�l_f�kZfufd [h`_kl\_gghfm�\k_fh]ms_kl\m�Y agZx��qlh��ihdZ�\u�f_gy�kemrZeb��m \Zk�\hagbdeb�fgh]hqbke_ggu_�\hijhku��gZ�dhlhju_\u�ohl_eb�[u�ihemqblv�hl\_l��A^_kv�b k_]h^gy�y g_�fh]m�wlh]h�k^_eZlv��gh�m\_j_g��qlh�gb�h^ghba�wlbo�^_lZevguo�bkke_^h\Zgbc�g_�ihdhe_[Zeh�[u�gZr_]h�iheh`_gby�h lhf��qlh�j_eb]bhagh_fbjh\haaj_gb_�^_l_jfbgbjh\Zgh�kblmZpb_c�gZr_]h�^_lkl\Z��L_f�[he__�ijbf_qZl_evgh�lh��qlh�g_kfhljy�gZ�k\hc�bgnZglbevguc�oZjZdl_j��hgh�\k_�lZdb�bf__l�ij_^r_kl\_ggbdZ��;_a�khfg_gby�[ueh� \j_fy� [_a� j_eb]bb�� [_a� [h]h\�� Hgh� gZau\Z_lky� Zgbfbafhf�� Fbj� b lh]^Z� [ue� ihehgq_eh\_dhih^h[gufb� ^moh\gufb� kms_kl\Zfb� �fu� gZau\Z_f� bo� ^_fhgZfb��� \k_� h[t_dlu\g_rg_]h�fbjZ� gZk_eyebkv� bfb� beb��fh`_l� [ulv�� [ueb� b^_glbqgu� bf�� gh� g_� [ueh� gbdZdhck\_jo\eZklb�� kha^Z\r_c� bo� \k_o� b ijh^he`Z\r_c� bfb� ijZ\blv�� d dhlhjhc� fh`gh� [ueh� [uh[jZlblvky� aZ� aZsblhc�b ihfhsvx��>_fhgu�ZgbfbafZ�[ueb�\ [hevrbgkl\_�k\h_f�\jZ`^_[ghgZkljh_gu�d q_eh\_dm��gh�dZ`_lky��qlh� lh]^Z�q_eh\_d�[hevr_�^h\_jye� k_[_��q_f�iha^g__��Hg�dhg_qgh�� ihklhyggh� kljZ^Ze� hl� kbevg_cr_]h� kljZoZ� i_j_^� wlbfb� aeufb� ^moZfb�� gh� hgaZsbsZeky�hl�gbo�hij_^_e_ggufb�^_ckl\byfb��dhlhjuf�ijbibku\Ze�kihkh[ghklv�ba]hgylv�bo�B \�^jm]bo�kemqZyo�hg�g_�[ue�[_kkbevguf��?keb�hg�ohl_e�^h`^y��lh�g_�fhebeky�[h]m�ih]h^u��Zijhba\h^be�fZ]bq_kdh_� ^_ckl\b_�� hl� dhlhjh]h� h`b^Ze� ijyfh]h� \ha^_ckl\by� gZ� ijbjh^m�� kZfkha^Z\Ze�qlh�lh�ihoh`__�gZ�^h`^v��< [hjv[_�k kbeZfb�hdjm`Zxs_]h�fbjZ�_]h�i_j\uf�hjm`b_f[ueZ�fZ]by� i_j\Zy�ij_^r_kl\_ggbpZ�gZr_c�gug_rg_c�l_ogbdb��Fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f��qlh�\_jZ�\fZ]bx� [_j_l� gZqZeh� \ i_j_hp_gd_� kh[kl\_gguo� bgl_ee_dlmZevguo� hi_jZpbc�� \ \_j_� \h©\k_fh]ms_kl\h� fukebª�� dhlhjh_� fu�� f_`^m� ijhqbf�� \gh\v� gZoh^bf� m gZrbo� g_\jhlbdh\�kljZ^Zxsbo�gZ\yaqb\ufb�khklhygbyfb��Fu�fh`_f�k_[_�ij_^klZ\blv��qlh�ex^b�lh]h�\j_f_gbhkh[_ggh� ]hj^bebkv� k\hbfb� yaudh\ufb� ^hklb`_gbyfb�� k dhlhjufb� ^he`gh� [ueh� [ulvkhijy`_gh�[hevrh_�h[e_]q_gb_�fure_gby��Hgb�gZ^_eyeb� keh\h�\her_[ghc�kbehc��WlZ�q_jlZ[ueZ�iha^g__�aZbfkl\h\ZgZ�j_eb]b_c��©B kdZaZe�;h]��^Z�[m^_l�k\_l��B klZe�k\_lª��<ijhq_f��nZdlfZ]bq_kdbo� ^_ckl\bc� ihdZau\Z_l�� qlh� Zgbfbklbq_kdbc� q_eh\_d� g_� ijhklh� iheZ]Zeky� gZ� kbemk\hbo� `_eZgbc�� Hg� h`b^Ze� mki_oZ� hl� \uiheg_gby� ZdlZ�� dhlhjhfm� ijbjh^Z� ^he`gZ� [ueZih^jZ`Zlv��?keb�hg�ohl_e�^h`^y��lh�kZf�ebe�\h^m��_keb�ohl_e�ih[m^blv�a_fex�d ieh^hjh^bx��lhij_^klZ\eye�gZ�ihe_�kp_gm�iheh\h]h�kghr_gby�<u� agZ_l_�� k dZdbf� ljm^hf� bkq_aZ_l� lh�� qlh� ihemqbeh� g_dh]^Z� ikbobq_kdh_� \ujZ`_gb_�Ihwlhfm� \u� g_� m^b\bl_kv�� mkeurZ\�� qlh� fgh]b_� ijhy\e_gby� ZgbfbafZ� khojZgbebkv� ^hk_]h^gyrg_]h�^gy�\ [hevrbgkl\_�k\h_f�dZd�lZd�gZau\Z_fu_�km_\_jby�gZjy^m�k j_eb]b_c�b aZg_c�� ;he__� lh]h�� \u� \jy^� eb� kfh`_l_� hldZaZlv� \ ijZ\hl_� km`^_gbx�� qlh� gZrZ� nbehkhnbykhojZgbeZ� kms_kl\_ggu_� q_jlu� Zgbfbklbq_kdh]h� h[jZaZ� fure_gby�� i_j_hp_gdm� \her_[ghckbeu�keh\Z��\_jm�\ lh��qlh�j_Zevgu_�ijhp_kku�\ fbj_�b^ml�imlyfb��dhlhju_�bf�ohq_l�mdZaZlvgZr_�fure_gb_��Wlh��ijZ\^Z��kdhj__�Zgbfbaf�[_a�fZ]bq_kdbo�^_ckl\bc��K ^jm]hc�klhjhgu��fufh`_f�h`b^Zlv��qlh�\ lm�wihom�kms_kl\h\ZeZ�m`_�dZdZy�lh�wlbdZ��ijZ\beZ�h[s_gby�ex^_c��ghgbqlh�g_�]h\hjbl�aZ�lh��qlh�hgb�[ueb�l_kg__�k\yaZgu�k Zgbfbklbq_kdhc�\_jhc��<_jhylgh��hgb

Page 350: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[ueb�g_ihkj_^kl\_gguf�\ujZ`_gb_f�khhlghr_gby�kbe�b ijZdlbq_kdbo�ihlj_[ghkl_c�;ueh�[u�\_kvfZ�bgl_j_kgh�magZlv��qlh�h[mkeh\beh�i_j_oh^�hl�ZgbfbafZ�d j_eb]bb��gh�\ufh`_l_� k_[_� ij_^klZ\blv�� dZdZy� lvfZ� b ihgug_� hdmlu\Z_l� wlb� ^j_\gb_� \j_f_gZ� \ bklhjbbjZa\blby� q_eh\_q_kdh]h� ^moZ�� Ih�\b^bfhfm�� y\ey_lky� nZdlhf� lh�� qlh� i_j\hc� nhjfhcijhy\e_gby� j_eb]bb� [ue� m^b\bl_evguc� lhl_fbaf�� ihdehg_gb_�`b\hlguf�� khijh\h`^Z\r__kyi_j\ufb� wlbq_kdbfb� aZih\_^yfb�� lZ[m��< k\h_� \j_fy� \ dgb]_� Lhl_f� b lZ[m �����²������ y\u^\bgme� ij_^iheh`_gb_�� qlh� wlh� baf_g_gb_� y\ey_lky� ke_^kl\b_f� i_j_\hjhlZ� \ hlghr_gbyoq_eh\_q_kdhc� k_fvb�� =eZ\gh_� ^hklb`_gb_� j_eb]bb� ih� kjZ\g_gbx� k Zgbfbafhf� khklhbl� \ikbobq_kdhf� ij_h^he_gbb� kljZoZ� i_j_^� ^_fhgZfb�� H^gZdh� \ dZq_kl\_� i_j_`bldZ^hbklhjbq_kdh]h�\j_f_gb�aehc�^mo�khojZgbe�k\h_�f_klh�b \�kbkl_f_�j_eb]bb���?keb�wlh�[ueh�ij_^uklhjb_c�j_eb]bhagh]h�fbjh\haaj_gby��lh�l_i_jv�^Z\Zcl_�h[jZlbfky�dlhfm�� qlh� ijhbahreh� k l_o� ihj� b ihgug_� ijhbkoh^bl� gZ� gZrbo� ]eZaZo�� GZmqguc� h[jZafure_gby��hdj_irbc� \ gZ[ex^_gbyo� aZ�ijbjh^gufb�ijhp_kkZfb��gZqZe� k l_q_gb_f� \j_f_gbjZkkfZljb\Zlv�j_eb]bx�dZd�^_eh�q_eh\_dZ��ih^\_j]Zy�__ djblbq_kdhc�ijh\_jd_��I_j_^�wlbf�hgZg_� fh]eZ� mklhylv�� KgZqZeZ� wlh� [ueb� khh[s_gby� h qm^_kZo�� dhlhju_� \uau\Zeb� m^b\e_gb_� bg_^h\_jb_�� ihkdhevdm� ijhlb\hj_qbeb� \k_fm�� q_fm� mqbeh� lj_a\h_� gZ[ex^_gb_�� kh\_jr_gghhq_\b^gh�g_ky�gZ�k_[_�\ebygb_�^_yl_evghklb�q_eh\_q_kdhc�nZglZabb��AZl_f�^he`gh�[ueh�[ulvhl\_j]gmlh�__ mq_gb_��h[tykgy\r__�kms_kl\mxsbc�fbj��ihlhfm�qlh�hgh� k\b^_l_evkl\h\Zeh�hg_agZgbb�� dhlhjh_� g_keh� gZ� k_[_� i_qZlv� ^j_\gbo� \j_f_g� b dhlhjh_� gZmqbebkv� ij_h^he_\Zlv[eZ]h^Zjy� \hajhkr_fm� ihklb`_gbx� aZdhgh\� ijbjh^u�� Lh�� qlh� fbj� \hagbd� [eZ]h^Zjy� ZdlZfaZqZlby� beb� khl\hj_gby�� ZgZeh]bqgh� \hagbdgh\_gbx� hl^_evgh]h� q_eh\_dZ�� g_� dZaZehkv� [he__kZfuf� [ebadbf� d bklbg_�� kZfh� kh[hc� jZamf_xsbfky� ij_^iheh`_gb_f�� k l_o� ihj� dZd� ^eyfure_gby�klZeh�hq_\b^guf�jZaebqb_�f_`^m�`b\ufb�h^mr_\e_ggufb�kms_kl\Zfb�b g_`b\hcijbjh^hc��ijb�dhlhjhf�klZeh�g_\hafh`gh�ijb^_j`b\Zlvky�i_j\hgZqZevgh]h�ZgbfbafZ��G_evayg_� aZf_lblv� lZd`_� \ebygby� kjZ\gbl_evgh]h� bamq_gby� jZaebqguo� j_eb]bhaguo� kbkl_f� b bo\aZbfgh]h�bkdexq_gby�b g_l_jibfhklb�^jm]�d ^jm]m�AZdZe_gguc�wlbfb�ij_^\Zjbl_evgufb�mijZ`g_gbyfb��gZmqguc�h[jZa�fure_gby�ijbh[j_egZdhg_p�fm`_kl\h�j_rblvky�gZ�ijh\_jdm�kZfuo�agZqbl_evguo�b Znn_dlb\gh�gZb[he__�p_gguoqZkl_c�j_eb]bhagh]h�fbjh\haaj_gby��<k_]^Z�[ueh�hq_\b^gh��gh�lhevdh�\ihke_^kl\bb�j_rbebkv\ukdZaZlv��qlh�b j_eb]bhagu_�ihklmeZlu��h[_sZxsb_�q_eh\_dm�aZsblm�b kqZklv_��_keb�lhevdhhg�\uihegy_l�hij_^_e_ggu_�wlbq_kdb_�lj_[h\Zgby��hdZau\Zxlky�gZ�ih\_jdm�g_khklhyl_evgufb�DZ`_lky�� qlh� gZ� kZfhf� ^_e_� g_l� \h� \k_e_gghc� kbeu�� dhlhjZy� h jh^bl_evkdhc� aZ[hleb\hklvxhojZgy_l�[eZ]hihemqb_�hl^_evgh]h�q_eh\_dZ��b \h�\k_f��qlh�bf__l�d g_fm�hlghr_gb_��\_^_l�dkqZkleb\hfm�dhgpm��Kdhj__�\k_]h��g_evay�h[tykgylv�km^v[u�ex^_c�ba�]bihl_au�pZjys_c�\ fbj_^h[jhlu� beb� fbjh\hc� kijZ\_^eb\hklb�� hlqZklb� ijhlb\hj_qZs_c� _c�� A_fe_ljyk_gby�� [mjb�ih`Zju�g_�^_eZxl�jZaebqby�f_`^m�^h[juf�b [eZ]hq_klb\uf��k h^ghc�klhjhgu��b aeh^__f�bebg_\_jmxsbf�²�k ^jm]hc��Djhf_�lh]h��lZf�� ]^_�g_�bf__lky�\ \b^m�g_`b\Zy�ijbjh^Z�b km^v[Zhl^_evgh]h� q_eh\_dZ� aZ\bkbl� hl� _]h� hlghr_gbc� k ^jm]bfb� ex^vfb�� g_� kms_kl\m_l� ijZ\beZ�kh]eZkgh� dhlhjhfm� ^h[jh^_l_ev� lhj`_kl\m_l�� Z ihjhd� gZdZau\Z_lky�� b kebrdhf� qZklhgZkbevgbd��oblj_p��g_�kqblZxsbcky�gb k�q_f�q_eh\_d�ijbk\Zb\Z_l�k_[_�aZ\b^gu_�[eZ]Z�fbjZ��Z[eZ]hq_klb\uc� hklZ_lky� gb k� q_f�� L_fgu_�� [_kqm\kl\_ggu_� b ebr_ggu_� ex[\b� kbeu

Page 351: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hij_^_eyxl� q_eh\_q_kdmx� km^v[m�� kbkl_fZ� gZ]jZ^� b gZdZaZgbc�� dhlhjZy�� kh]eZkgh� j_eb]bb�]hkih^kl\m_l�\ fbj_��dZd�[u�b g_�kms_kl\m_l��Wlh��\ k\hx�hq_j_^v��^Z_l�ih\h^�hldZaZlvky�hlqZklb�h^mr_\e_gghklb��dhlhjZy�i_j_reZ�\ j_eb]bx�ba�ZgbfbafZ�Ihke_^gbc� \deZ^� \ djblbdm� j_eb]bhagh]h� fbjh\haaj_gby� \g_k� ikbohZgZeba�� mdZaZ\� gZijhbkoh`^_gb_�j_eb]bb�ba�^_lkdhc�[_kihfhsghklb�b \u\h^y�__ kh^_j`Zgb_�ba�hklZ\rboky�\aj_ehc�`bagb�`_eZgbc�b ihlj_[ghkl_c�^_lkl\Z��Wlh�hlgx^v�g_�hagZqZeh�hijh\_j`_gby�j_eb]bb�Z [ueh� g_h[oh^bfuf� aZ\_jr_gb_f� __ ihagZgby� b�� ih� djZcg_c� f_j_�� \ h^ghf� imgdl_ijhlb\hj_qbeh� _c�� ihkdhevdm� hgZ� kZfZ� ijbibku\Z_l� k_[_� [h`_kl\_ggh_� ijhbkoh`^_gb_�IjZ\^Z��\ wlhf�hgZ�g_�lZd�m`�g_ijZ\Z��_keb�ijbgylv�gZr_�lhedh\Zgb_�[h]Z�H[h[sZxs__�km`^_gb_�gZmdb�h j_eb]bhaghf�fbjh\haaj_gbb��lZdbf�h[jZahf��]eZkbl��ihdZhl^_evgu_� j_eb]bb� kihjyl� ^jm]� k ^jm]hf�� dZdZy� ba� gbo� \eZ^__l� bklbghc�� fu� iheZ]Z_f�� qlhkh^_j`Zgb_f� bklbgu� j_eb]bb� fh`gh� \hh[s_� ij_g_[j_qv�� J_eb]by� y\ey_lky� ihiuldhcij_h^he_lv�qm\kl\_gguc�fbj��\ dhlhjuc�fu�ihklZ\e_gu��ihkj_^kl\hf�fbjZ�`_eZgbc��dhlhjucfu�ihkljhbeb�\ k_[_�\ke_^kl\b_�[bheh]bq_kdhc�b ikboheh]bq_kdhc�g_h[oh^bfhklb��Gh�hgZ�g_fh`_l�wlh]h�^hklbqv��?_�mq_gby�g_kml�gZ�k_[_�hli_qZlhd�l_o�\j_f_g��\ dhlhju_�hgb�\hagbdZeb�\j_f_g�^_lkdh]h�g_\_^_gby�q_eh\_q_kl\Z��?_�ml_r_gby�g_�aZkem`b\Zxl�^h\_jby��Hiul�mqbl�gZk�fbj�g_�^_lkdZy�dhfgZlZ��Wlbq_kdb_�lj_[h\Zgby��dhlhjuf�j_eb]by�ohq_l�ijb^Zlv�kbem��lj_[mxlkh\k_f�^jm]h]h�h[hkgh\Zgby��ihlhfm�qlh�hgb�g_hl^_ebfu�hl�q_eh\_q_kdh]h�h[s_kl\Z��b hiZkghk\yau\Zlv�ke_^h\Zgb_�bf�k j_eb]bhaghc�gZ[h`ghklvx��?keb�ihiulZlvky�\dexqblv�j_eb]bx�\ijhp_kk�jZa\blby�q_eh\_q_kl\Z��lh�hgZ�hdZ`_lky�g_�\_qguf�^hklhygb_f��Z ZgZeh]b_c�g_\jham�dhlhjuc� dZ`^uc� dmevlmjguc� q_eh\_d� ^he`_g� [ue� ij_h^he_lv� gZ� k\h_f� imlb� hl� ^_lkl\Z� daj_ehklb�<u��dhg_qgh��\hevgu�djblbdh\Zlv�wlh�fh_�baeh`_gb_��y ijb�wlhf�kZf�ihc^m�\Zf�gZ\klj_qm�Lh��qlh�y kdZaZe�h ihkl_i_gghf�jZkiZ^_�j_eb]bhagh]h�fbjh\haaj_gby��[ueh��jZamf__lky��ba�aZk\h_c� djZldhklb� g_ihegh�� ihke_^h\Zl_evghklv� hl^_evguo� ijhp_kkh\� [ueZ� ^ZgZ� g_� kh\k_fijZ\bevgh�� \aZbfh^_ckl\b_� hl^_evguo� kbe� ijb� ijh[m`^_gbb� gZmqgh]h� h[jZaZ� fure_gby� g_[ueh�ijhke_`_gh��Y lZd`_�hklZ\be�[_a�\gbfZgby� l_�baf_g_gby��dhlhju_�ijhbahreb�\ kZfhfj_eb]bhaghf� fbjh\haaj_gbb� aZ� \j_fy� _]h� g_hkihjbfh]h� ]hkih^kl\Z� b aZl_f� ih^� \ebygb_fijh[m`^Zxs_cky�djblbdb��GZdhg_p��kljh]h�]h\hjy��y h]jZgbqbe�k\h_�h[km`^_gb_�ebrv�h^ghcj_eb]b_c�� j_eb]b_c� aZiZ^guo� gZjh^h\��Y kha^Ze�� lZd� kdZaZlv��nZglhf� k p_evx� mkdhj_gghc� bgZb[he__�\i_qZleyxs_c�^_fhgkljZpbb��HklZ\bf�\ klhjhg_�\hijhk�h lhf��^hklZlhqgh�eb�\hh[s_[ueh�fhbo�agZgbc�^ey�lh]h��qlh[u�k^_eZlv�wlh�emqr_�b iheg__��Y agZx��\k_��qlh�y \Zf�kdZaZe��\ufh`_l_�gZclb�\ ^jm]bo�bklhqgbdZo�\ emqr_f�baeh`_gbb��b gbqlh�ba�wlh]h�g_�gh\h��Iha\hevl_`_�fg_�\ukdZaZlv�m[_`^_gb_��qlh�kZfZy�lsZl_evgZy�h[jZ[hldZ�fZl_jbZeZ�ih�ijh[e_fZf�j_eb]bbg_�ihdhe_[ZeZ�[u�gZr�j_amevlZl�<u�agZ_l_��qlh�[hjv[Z�gZmqgh]h�h[jZaZ�fure_gby�ijhlb\�j_eb]bhagh]h�fbjh\haaj_gby�g_aZdhgqbeZkv��hgZ�ijh^he`Z_lky�gZ�gZrbo�]eZaZo�b \�gZklhys__�\j_fy��DZd�[u�fZeh�ikbohZgZebagb ihevah\Zeky�ihe_fbq_kdbf�hjm`b_f�\ ^jm]bo�\hijhkZo��fu�g_�ohlbf�hldZau\Zlvky�aZgylv�\wlhf� kihj_� hij_^_e_ggmx� ihabpbx�� Ijb� wlhf�� [ulv� fh`_l�� fu� ^h[v_fky� ^Zevg_cr_]hjZatykg_gby�gZr_c�ihabpbb�ih�hlghr_gbx�d fbjh\haaj_gbyf��<u�m\b^bl_��dZd�e_]dh�fh`ghhijh\_j]gmlv�g_dhlhju_�ba�Zj]mf_glh\��ijb\h^bfuo�klhjhggbdZfb�j_eb]bb��^jm]b_�`_�fh]ml

Page 352: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hklZ\Zlvky�g_hijh\_j]gmlufb�I_j\h_� \hajZ`_gb_�� dhlhjh_� ^h\h^blky� keurZlv�� ]eZkbl�� kh� klhjhgu� gZmdb� ijhklhkZfhgZ^_yggh� ^_eZlv� j_eb]bx� ij_^f_lhf� k\h_]h� bamq_gby�� ihlhfm� qlh� hgZ� y\ey_lky� q_f�lhkm\_j_gguf�� e_`Zsbf� aZ� ij_^_eZfb� q_eh\_q_kdh]h� jZamfZ�� d q_fm� g_evay� ijb[eb`Zlvky� kmfgbqZxs_c�djblbdhc��>jm]bfb�keh\Zfb��gZmdZ�g_�dhfi_l_glgZ�km^blv�h j_eb]bb��H[uqgh�hgZijb_fe_fZ�b p_ggZ��dhev�kdhjh�h]jZgbqb\Z_lky�k\h_c�h[eZklvx��gh�j_eb]by�g_�__ h[eZklv��lZf_c�g_q_]h�bkdZlv��?keb�g_�hklZgh\blvky�i_j_^�wlbf�j_adbf�hlihjhf��Z kijhkblv�^Ze__��gZ�q_fhkgh\u\Z_lky�wlh�ijblyaZgb_�gZ�bkdexqbl_evgh_�iheh`_gb_�kj_^b�\k_o�^_e�q_eh\_q_kdbo�� lhihemqbrv� hl\_l�� _keb� \hh[s_� [m^_rv� m^hklh_g� hl\_lZ�� qlh� j_eb]bx� g_evay� f_jblvq_eh\_q_kdbfb� f_jdZfb�� ihlhfm� qlh� hgZ� [h`_kl\_ggh]h� ijhbkoh`^_gby�� ^Z_lky� gZf� q_j_ahldjh\_gb_�^moZ��dhlhjuc�q_eh\_q_kdbc�^mo�g_�\ kbeZo�ihgylv��DZ`_lky��g_l�gbq_]h�e_]q_��dZdhijh\_j]gmlv� wlhl� Zj]mf_gl�� wlh� \_^v� hq_\b^gh_ SHWLWLR� SULQFLSLL�� EHJJLQJ� WKH� TXHVWLRQ �� \g_f_pdhf� yaud_� y g_� agZx� gbdZdh]h� ih^oh^ys_]h� wlhfm� \ujZ`_gby�� <_^v� klZ\blky� ih^khfg_gb_�kms_kl\h\Zgb_�[h`_kl\_ggh]h�^moZ�b _]h�hldjh\_gby��b wlh��dhg_qgh��g_�hl\_l��dh]^Z]h\hjyl�� qlh� h[� wlhf� g_evay� kijZrb\Zlv�� ihkdhevdm� g_evay� klZ\blv� ih^� khfg_gb_� [h`_kl\h�A^_kv�lh�`_��qlh�ihjhc�ijhbkoh^bl�ijb�ZgZeblbq_kdhc�jZ[hl_��Dh]^Z�h[uqgh�jZamfguc�iZpb_glhlf_lZ_l� dZdh_�lh� ij_^iheh`_gb_� k hkh[_ggh� ]emiuf� h[tykg_gb_f�� wlZ� eh]bq_kdZy� keZ[hklvk\b^_l_evkl\m_l�h kms_kl\h\Zgbb�hkh[_ggh�kbevgh]h�fhlb\Z�^ey�ijhlb\hj_qby��dhlhjuc�fh`_l[ulv�lhevdh�Znn_dlb\gh]h�oZjZdl_jZ��k\yaZgghklvx�qm\kl\Zfb�Fh`gh�ihemqblv�b ^jm]hc�hl\_l��\ dhlhjhf�hldjulh�ijbagZ_lky�lZdhc�fhlb\��j_eb]bx�^_g_evay� ih^\_j]Zlv� djblbq_kdhc� ijh\_jd_�� ihlhfm� qlh� hgZ� _klv� kZfh_� agZqbl_evgh_�� kZfh_p_ggh_�b kZfh_�\ha\ur_ggh_��qlh�ijhba\_e�q_eh\_q_kdbc�^mo��ihlhfm�qlh�hgZ�^Z_l�\ujZ`_gb_kZfuf�]em[hdbf�qm\kl\Zf��ihlhfm�qlh�hgZ�^_eZ_l�fbj�kghkguf��Z `bagv�^hklhcghc�q_eh\_dZ�GZ� wlh� gZ^h� hl\_qZlv�� g_� hkiZjb\Zy� hp_gdm� j_eb]bb�� Z gZijZ\eyy� \gbfZgb_� gZ� ^jm]h_h[klhyl_evkl\h��Ih^q_jdb\Zxl�� qlh� j_qv� b^_l� g_� h \lhj`_gbb� gZmqgh]h� h[jZaZ�fure_gby� \h[eZklv�j_eb]bb��Z��gZh[hjhl��h \lhj`_gbb�j_eb]bb�\ kn_jm�gZmqgh]h�fure_gby��DZdh\u�[u�gb[ueb� p_gghklv� b agZq_gb_� j_eb]bb�� hgZ� g_� bf__l� ijZ\Z� dZdbf� [u� lh� gb [ueh� h[jZahfh]jZgbqb\Zlv�fure_gb_��Z lZd`_�ijZ\Z�bkdexqZlv�k_[y�ba�kn_ju�ijbeh`_gby�fure_gby�GZmqgh_�fure_gb_�\ k\h_c�kmsghklb�g_�hlebqZ_lky�hl�h[uqghc � Ij_^\hkobs_gb_� hkgh\Zgby�� eh]bq_kdZy� hrb[dZ� \ ^hdZaZl_evkl\_�� dh]^Z� \u\h^� ^_eZ_lky� ba� iheh`_gby�dhlhjh_�kZfh�_s_�^he`gh�[ulv�^hdZaZgh��eZl���Zg]e����Ijbf_q��i_j�fukebl_evghc� ^_yl_evghklb�� dhlhjhc� \k_�fu�� \_jmxsb_� b g_\_jmxsb_�� ihevam_fky� ^eyj_r_gby�gZrbo�`bag_gguo�\hijhkh\��Lhevdh�\ g_dhlhjuo�q_jlZo�hgh�hj]Zgbam_lky�hkh[h��hghbgl_j_km_lky� lZd`_� \_sZfb�� g_� bf_xsbfb� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh� hsmlbfhc� ihevau�� \kyq_kdbklZjZ_lky� hlkljZgblvky� hl� bg^b\b^mZevguo� nZdlhjh\� b Znn_dlb\guo� \ebygbc�� [he__� kljh]hijh\_jy_l�gZ^_`ghklv�qm\kl\_gguo�\hkijbylbb��hkgh\u\Zy�gZ�gbo�k\hb�\u\h^u��kha^Z_l�gh\u_\a]ey^u�� dhlhjuo� g_evay� ^hklbqv� h[u^_ggufb� kj_^kl\Zfb�� b \u^_ey_l� mkeh\by� wlbo� gh\uoagZgbc� \ gZf_j_ggh� \Zjvbjm_fuo� hiulZo�� ?]h� klj_fe_gb_� ²� ^hklbqv� kh]eZkh\Zgghklb� kj_Zevghklvx�� l�� _�� k l_f�� qlh� kms_kl\m_l� \g_� gZk�� g_aZ\bkbfh� hl� gZk� b�� dZd� gZk� mqbl� hiul�y\ey_lky�j_rZxsbf�^ey�bkiheg_gby�beb�g_bkiheg_gby�gZrbo�`_eZgbc��Wlm�kh]eZkh\Zgghklv�kj_Zevguf�\g_rgbf�fbjhf�fu�gZau\Z_f�bklbghc��HgZ�hklZ_lky�p_evx�gZmqghc�jZ[hlu��^Z`_

Page 353: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

_keb�fu�mimkdZ_f�__ ijZdlbq_kdmx�agZqbfhklv��BlZd��dh]^Z�j_eb]by�ml\_j`^Z_l��qlh�hgZ�fh`_laZf_gblv�gZmdm��qlh�hgZ�lh`_�bklbggZ��ihlhfm�qlh�^_ckl\m_l�[eZ]hl\hjgh�b \ha\urZxs_��lh�\^_ckl\bl_evghklb�wlh�\lhj`_gb_��dhlhjhfm�gZ^h�^Zlv�hlihj�ba�kZfuo�h[sbo�khh[jZ`_gbc��Wlhk_jv_agh_�b g_kijZ\_^eb\h_�lj_[h\Zgb_�d q_eh\_dm��gZmqb\r_fmky�\_klb�k\hb�h[uqgu_�^_eZ�ihijZ\beZf�hiulZ�b k�mq_lhf�j_Zevghklb��dhlhjh_�aZdexqZ_lky�\ lhf��qlh�aZ[hlm�bf_ggh�h kZfuobglbfguo� k\hbo� bgl_j_kZo� hg� ^he`_g� i_j_^Zlv� bgklZgpbb�� ihevamxs_cky� dZd� k\h_cijb\be_]b_c� hk\h[h`^_gb_f� hl� ij_^ibkZgbc� jZpbhgZevgh]h� fure_gby�� Qlh� `_� dZkZ_lkyaZsblu��dhlhjmx�j_eb]by�h[_sZ_l�k\hbf�\_jmxsbf��lh�y ^mfZx��qlh�gbdlh�ba�gZk�g_�ohl_e�[uk_klv�\ Z\lhfh[bev��\h^bl_ev�dhlhjh]h�aZy\ey_l��qlh�hg�m\_j_ggh�ih_^_l�ih�ijZ\beZf�mebqgh]h^\b`_gby��jmdh\h^kl\mykv�ebrv�ihe_lhf�k\h_c�nZglZabb�AZij_l� gZ� fure_gb_�� d dhlhjhfm� ijb[_]Z_l� j_eb]by� \ p_eyo� k\h_]h� kZfhkhojZg_gby�hlgx^v� g_� [_ahiZk_g� gb ^ey� hl^_evgh]h� q_eh\_dZ�� gb� ^ey� q_eh\_q_kdh]h� h[s_kl\Z�:gZeblbq_kdbc� hiul� gZmqbe� gZk�� qlh� lZdhc� aZij_l�� ^Z`_� _keb� hg� i_j\hgZqZevgh� bh]jZgbqb\Zeky� hij_^_e_gghc� h[eZklvx�� bf__l� kdehgghklv� jZkijhkljZgylvky�� klZgh\ykvijbqbghc� ly`_euo� aZ^_j`_d �+HQXQXQJHQ� \ ih\_^_gbb� ebqghklb�� Wlh� ^_ckl\b_� fh`ghgZ[ex^Zlv�b gZ�ijbf_j_�`_gsbg�dZd�ke_^kl\b_�aZij_lZ�aZgbfZlvky�ohly�[u�\ ihfukeZo�k\h_ck_dkmZevghklvx�� H \j_^_� j_eb]bhaguo� aZ^_j`_d� >jZa\blby@� fure_gby� k\b^_l_evkl\mxl`bag_hibkZgby�ihqlb�\k_o�\u^Zxsboky�ex^_c�ijhreuo�\j_f_g��K ^jm]hc�klhjhgu��bgl_ee_dl²�beb�gZah\_f�_]h�ijb\uqguf�gZf�bf_g_f��jZamf�²�hlghkblky�d kbeZf��hl�dhlhjuo� kdhj__\k_]h�fh`gh�h`b^Zlv�h[t_^bgyxs_]h�\ebygby�gZ�ex^_c��ex^_c��dhlhjuo�lZd�ljm^gh�kh_^bgblv\f_kl_� b dhlhjufb� ihwlhfm� ihqlb� g_\hafh`gh� mijZ\eylv�� Ij_^klZ\bf� k_[_�� gZkdhevdhg_\hafh`guf� [ueh� [u� q_eh\_q_kdh_� h[s_kl\h�� _keb� [u� dZ`^uc� bf_e� k\hx� kh[kl\_ggmxlZ[ebpm�mfgh`_gby�b k\hx�hkh[mx�kbkl_fm�f_j�b \_kh\��GZr_c�emqr_c�gZ^_`^hc�gZ�[m^ms__y\ey_lky� lh�� qlh� bgl_ee_dl� ²� gZmqguc� h[jZa� fure_gby�� jZamf� ²� kh� \j_f_g_f� aZ\hx_lg_h]jZgbq_ggmx�\eZklv�\ q_eh\_q_kdhc�^mr_\ghc�`bagb��Kmsghklv�jZamfZ�y\ey_lky�ihjmdhclhfm��qlh� lh]^Z�hg�h[yaZl_evgh�hl\_^_l�^hklhcgh_�f_klh�q_eh\_q_kdbf�qm\kl\Zf�b lhfm��qlhbfb hij_^_ey_lky��Gh�h[sZy�g_ij_eh`ghklv�wlh]h�]hkih^kl\Z�jZamfZ�hdZ`_lky�kZfhc�kbevghch[t_^bgyxs_c�k\yavx�f_`^m�ex^vfb�b ijheh`bl�imlv�d ^Zevg_crbf�h[t_^bg_gbyf��Lh��qlhijhlb\hj_qbl� lZdhfm� jZa\blbx�� ih^h[gh� aZij_lm� gZ� fure_gb_� kh� klhjhgu� j_eb]bb�ij_^klZ\ey_l�kh[hc�hiZkghklv�^ey�[m^ms_]h�q_eh\_q_kl\Z�L_i_jv� fh`gh� kijhkblv�� ihq_fm� j_eb]by� g_� ij_djZlbl� wlhl� [_ki_jki_dlb\guc� ^ey� g__kihj��ijyfh�aZy\b\��©>_ckl\bl_evgh��y g_�fh]m�^Zlv�\Zf�lh]h��qlh�h[uqgh�gZau\Z_lky�bklbghc�< wlhf�\u�^he`gu�ke_^h\Zlv�gZmd_��Gh�lh��qlh�^Zx�y��g_kjZ\g_ggh�ij_djZkg__��ml_rbl_evg__�b\ha\ur_gg__��q_f�\k_��qlh�\u�fh`_l_�ihemqblv�hl�gZmdb��B ihwlhfm�y ]h\hjx�\Zf��wlh�bklbggh\ ^jm]hf��[he__�\ukhdhf�kfuke_ª��Hl\_l�gZoh^blky�e_]dh�J_eb]by�g_�fh`_l�k^_eZlv�lZdh]h�ijbagZgby��ihlhfm�qlh�l_f�kZfuf�hgZ�mljZlbeZ�[u�\kydh_\ebygb_�gZ�lheim��Ijhklhc�q_eh\_d�agZ_l�lhevdh�h^gm�bklbgm��\ ijhkl_cr_f�kfuke_�keh\Z��QlhlZdh_�[he__�\ukhdZy�beb�\ukrZy�bklbgZ��hg�g_�fh`_l�k_[_�ij_^klZ\blv��BklbgZ�dZ`_lky�_fm�lZd`_�fZeh�kihkh[ghc�d ]jZ^Zpbb��dZd�b kf_jlv��b hg�g_�fh`_l�kh\_jrblv�kdZqhd�hl�ij_djZkgh]h�dbklbgghfm��<hafh`gh��lZd�`_�dZd�b y��\u�ih^mfZ_l_��qlh�\ wlhf�hg�ijZ\�BlZd��[hjv[Z�g_�hdhgq_gZ��Klhjhggbdb�j_eb]bhagh]h�fbjh\haaj_gby�^_ckl\mxl�ih�klZjhfm

Page 354: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijZ\bem�� emqrZy� aZsblZ²� gZiZ^_gb_�� Hgb� kijZrb\Zxl�� qlh� wlh� aZ� gZmdZ�� dhlhjZy� ^_jaZ_lh[_kp_gblv� gZrm� j_eb]bx�� ^Zjb\rmx� fbeebhgZf� ex^_c� bkp_e_gb_� b ml_r_gb_� \ l_q_gb_^he]bo�lukyq_e_lbc"�Q_]h�hgZ�kh�k\h_c�klhjhgu�m`_�^hklb]eZ"�Q_]h�fu�fh`_f�`^Zlv�hl�g__�\^Zevg_cr_f"� >Zlv� ml_r_gb_� b \ha\ur_ggu_� qm\kl\Z� ²� gZ� wlh� hgZ�� ih� kh[kl\_gghfmijbagZgbx��g_�kihkh[gZ��HldZ`_fky�hl�wlh]h��ohly�wlh�b g_�e_]dbc�hldZa��: dZd�h[klhbl�^_eh�k__ ^hdljbgZfb"�Fh`_l�eb�hgZ�gZf�kdZaZlv��dZd�ijhbahr_e�fbj�b dZdZy�km^v[Z�_fm�ij_^klhbl"Fh`_l� eb� hgZ� gZjbkh\Zlv� gZf� ohlv� dZdmx�lh� k\yagmx� dZjlbgm�fbjZ�� ihdZaZlv�� dm^Z� hlg_klbg_h[tykgbfu_� n_ghf_gu� `bagb�� dZd� fh]ml� ^moh\gu_� kbeu� \ha^_ckl\h\Zlv� gZ� bg_jlgmxfZl_jbx"�?keb�[u�hgZ�wlh�fh]eZ��fu�g_�fh]eb�[u�hldZaZlv�_c�\ gZr_f�m\Z`_gbb��Gh�gbq_]h�bawlh]h�� gb h^ghc� ih^h[ghc� ijh[e_fu� hgZ� _s_� g_� j_rbeZ�� HgZ� ij_^hklZ\ey_l� gZf� h[ju\dbij_^iheZ]Z_fuo�agZgbc��dhlhju_�g_�fh`_l�kh]eZkh\Zlv�^jm]�k ^jm]hf��kh[bjZ_l�gZ[ex^_gby�aZkh\iZ^_gbyfb� \ oh^_� kh[ulbc�� dhlhju_� h[hagZqZ_l� dZd� ©aZdhgª� b ih^\_j]Z_l� k\hbfjbkdh\Zgguf�lhedh\Zgbyf��: dZdmx�fZemx�kl_i_gv�^hklh\_jghklb�bf_xl�__�j_amevlZlu��<k_�q_fm�hgZ�mqbl��ij_oh^ys_��lh��qlh�k_]h^gy�kqblZ_lky�\ukr_c�fm^jhklvx��aZ\ljZ�hl[jZku\Z_lkyb ebrv� \ \b^_� ij_^iheh`_gby� aZf_gy_lky� q_f�lh� ^jm]bf�� Lh]^Z� ihke_^g__� aZ[em`^_gb_h[ty\ey_lky�bklbghc��B wlhc�lh�bklbg_�fu�^he`gu�ijbg_klb�\ `_jl\m�\ukr__�[eZ]h�M\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Y ^mfZx�� ihkdhevdm� \u� kZfb� ijb^_j`b\Z_l_kv� gZmqgh]hfbjh\haaj_gby�� gZ� dhlhjh_� gZiZ^Zxl�� lh� \u� g_� kebrdhf� ]em[hdh� [m^_l_� ihljyk_gu� wlhcdjblbdhc��< dZca_jh\kdhc�:\kljbb� [ueb� h^gZ`^u� kdZaZgu� keh\Z�� dhlhju_� y ohl_e� [u� a^_kvgZihfgblv��KlZjuc� ]hkih^bg�djbdgme�h^gZ`^u�^_e_]Zpbb�g_m]h^ghc�_fm�iZjlbb��wlh�m`_�g_h[uqgZy�hiihabpby��wlh�hiihabpby�[mglh\sbdh\��Lhqgh�lZd�`_�\u�ihcf_l_��qlh�mij_db�\ Z^j_kgZmdb�aZ�lh��qlh�hgZ�_s_�g_�j_rbeZ�fbjh\uo�aZ]Z^hd��g_kijZ\_^eb\h�b aeh[gh�jZa^mlu��^ey�wlbo\_ebdbo� ^hklb`_gbc� m g__� ^h� kbo� ihj� ^_ckl\bl_evgh� [ueh� fZeh� \j_f_gb�� GZmdZ� ²� hq_gvfheh^Zy�� iha^gh� jZa\b\rZyky� q_eh\_q_kdZy� ^_yl_evghklv�� >Z\Zcl_� aZ^_j`bfky� b \kihfgbfebrv�g_dhlhju_�^Zggu_��ijhreh�hdheh�����e_l�k l_o�ihj��dZd�D_ie_j�hldjue�aZdhgu�^\b`_gbyieZg_l��`bag_gguc�imlv�GvxlhgZ��dhlhjuc�jZaeh`be�k\_l�gZ�p\_lZ�b \u^\bgme�l_hjbx�kbeuijbly`_gby��aZ\_jrbeky�\ �����]���l��_��g_fgh]bf�[he__�^\mokhl�e_l�lhfm�gZaZ^��g_aZ^he]h�^hNjZgpmakdhc� j_\hexpbb� EZ\mZav_� h[gZjm`be� dbkehjh^��@bagv� q_eh\_dZ� hq_gv� dhjhldZ� ihkjZ\g_gbx� k ^ebl_evghklvx� jZa\blby�q_eh\_q_kl\Z�� y k_]h^gy� hq_gv� klZjuc� q_eh\_d��gh� \k_�lZdb�m`_�`be�gZ�k\_l_��dh]^Z�Q��>Zj\bg�ij_^eh`be�h[s_kl\_gghklb�k\hc�ljm^�h \hagbdgh\_gbb\b^h\��< wlhf�`_������]h^m�jh^beky�Iv_j�Dxjb��hldju\rbc�jZ^bc�: _keb�\u�ihc^_l_�_s_�^Zevr_�gZaZ^��d \hagbdgh\_gbx�lhqgh]h�_kl_kl\hagZgby�m ]j_dh\��d:jobf_^m��:jbklZjom�KZfhkkdhfm� �hdheh�����]��^h�g��w����ij_^r_kl\_ggbdm�Dhi_jgbdZ��beb�dkZfhfm� gZqZem� Zkljhghfbb� m \Z\behgyg�� lh� \u� ihdjh_l_� wlbf� ebrv� fZemx� ^hex� \j_f_gb�dhlhjh_�Zgljhiheh]by�hl\h^bl�^ey�jZa\blby�q_eh\_dZ�hl�_]h�h[_avyghih^h[ghc�i_j\hgZqZevghcnhjfu�b dhlhjh_��[_amkeh\gh��ho\Zlu\Z_l�[he__�q_f�h^gh�klhlukyq_e_lb_��G_�aZ[m^_f�lZd`_�qlh� ihke_^g__� klhe_lb_� ijbg_keh� k kh[hc� lZdh_� h[beb_� gh\uo� hldjulbc�� lZdh_� mkdhj_gb_gZmqgh]h�ijh]j_kkZ��qlh�fu�bf__f�\k_�hkgh\Zgby�k m\_j_gghklvx�kfhlj_lv�\ [m^ms__�gZmdb�>jm]bf�mij_dZf�fu�^he`gu�\ ba\_klghc�f_j_�hl^Zlv�kijZ\_^eb\hklv��Bf_ggh�lZdh\�imlvgZmdb�� f_^e_gguc�� gZsmiu\Zxsbc�� ljm^guc�� Wlh]h� g_evay� hljbpZlv� b baf_gblv�G_m^b\bl_evgh��qlh�]hkih^Z��ij_^klZ\eyxsb_�^jm]mx�klhjhgm��g_^h\hevgu��hgb�ba[Zeh\Zgu��k

Page 355: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hldjh\_gb_f�bf�[ueh�e_]q_��Ijh]j_kk�\ gZmqghc�jZ[hl_�^hklb]Z_lky�lZd�`_��dZd�b \�ZgZeba_��<jZ[hlm�ijb\ghkylky�g_dhlhju_�h`b^Zgby��gh�gZ^h�mf_lv�bo�hl[jhkblv��;eZ]h^Zjy�gZ[ex^_gbxlh� a^_kv�� lh� lZf� hldju\Z_lky� qlh�lh� gh\h_�� kgZqZeZ� qZklb� g_� ih^oh^yl� ^jm]� ^jm]m�<ukdZau\Zxlky� ij_^iheh`_gby�� kljhylky� \kihfh]Zl_evgu_� dhgkljmdpbb�� hl� dhlhjuoijboh^blky�hldZau\Zlvky��_keb�hgb�g_�ih^l\_j`^Zxlky��lj_[m_lky�fgh]h�l_ji_gby��]hlh\ghklv�dex[uf�\hafh`ghklyf��d hldZam�hl�ij_`gbo�m[_`^_gbc��qlh[u�ih^�bo�^Z\e_gb_f�g_�mimklblvgh\uo�� g_h`b^Zgguo� fhf_glh\�� b \� dhgp_� dhgph\� \k_� hdmiZ_lky�� jZajhag_ggu_� gZoh^dbkdeZ^u\Zxlky�\h_^bgh��hldju\Z_lky�dZjlbgZ�p_eh]h�wlZiZ�^mr_\gh]h�ijhp_kkZ��aZ^ZqZ�j_r_gZ�b qm\kl\m_rv�k_[y�]hlh\uf�j_rblv�ke_^mxsmx��Lhevdh�\ ZgZeba_�ijboh^blky�h[oh^blvky�[_aihfhsb��dhlhjmx�bkke_^h\Zgbx�hdZau\Z_l�wdki_jbf_gl�< mihfygmlhc� djblbd_� gZmdb� _klv� b ba\_klgZy� ^hey� ij_m\_ebq_gby�� G_ijZ\^Z�� qlh� hgZ[j_^_l� \ke_imx� hl� h^gh]h� wdki_jbf_glZ� d ^jm]hfm�� aZf_gyy� h^gh� aZ[em`^_gb_� ^jm]bf��DZdijZ\beh�� hgZ� jZ[hlZ_l� keh\gh� om^h`gbd� gZ^� fh^_evx� ba� ]ebgu�� g_mklZggh� qlh�lh� f_gyy�^h[Z\eyy� b m[bjZy� \ q_jgh\hf� \ZjbZgl_�� ihdZ� g_� ^hklb]g_l� m^h\e_l\hjyxs_c� _]h� kl_i_gbih^h[by�kh�ajbfuf�beb�\hh[jZ`Z_fuf�h[t_dlhf��K_]h^gy��ih�djZcg_c�f_j_��\ [he__�klZjuo�b[he__�aj_euo�gZmdZo�m`_�kms_kl\m_l�kheb^guc�nmg^Zf_gl��dhlhjuc�lhevdh�fh^bnbpbjm_lky�bjZkrbjy_lky��gh�g_�mijZa^gy_lky�< gZmd_� \k_� \u]ey^bl� g_� lZd� m`� iehoh��B gZdhg_p�� dZdmx� p_ev� klZ\yl� i_j_^� kh[hc� wlbkljZklgu_�ihghr_gby�\ Z^j_k�gZmdb"�G_kfhljy�gZ�__ gug_rg__�g_kh\_jr_gkl\h�b ijbkmsb_�_cljm^ghklb��hgZ�hklZ_lky�g_h[oh^bfhc�^ey�gZk�b __�g_evay�aZf_gblv�gbq_f�bguf��HgZ�kihkh[gZgZ�g_\b^Zggu_�kh\_jr_gkl\h\Zgby��gZ�qlh�j_eb]bhagh_�fbjh\haaj_gb_�g_�kihkh[gh��Ihke_^g__aZ\_jr_gh� \h� \k_o� k\hbo� hkgh\guo� qZklyo�� _keb� hgh� [ueh� aZ[em`^_gb_f�� hgh� hklZg_lky� bfgZ\k_]^Z��B gbdZdh_�mfZe_gb_� >jheb@�gZmdb�g_�fh`_l�ihdhe_[Zlv� lhl�nZdl��qlh�hgZ�iulZ_lky\ha^Zlv� ^he`gh_� gZr_c� aZ\bkbfhklb� hl� j_Zevgh]h� \g_rg_]h� fbjZ�� \ lh� \j_fy� dZd� j_eb]byy\ey_lky�beexab_c��b __� kbeZ� khklhbl� \ lhf�� qlh� hgZ� b^_l� gZ\klj_qm� gZrbf� bgklbgdlb\guf`_eZgbyf����Y h[yaZg�gZihfgblv�_s_�b h�^jm]bo�fbjh\haaj_gbyo��dhlhju_�ijhlb\hj_qZl�gZmqghfm��gh�y^_eZx�wlh�g_hohlgh��lZd�dZd�agZx��qlh�y g_�klhev�dhfi_l_gl_g��qlh[u�km^blv�h gbo��Ijbfbl_�`_\ k\_l_� wlh]h� ijbagZgby� ke_^mxsb_� aZf_qZgby�� b _keb� m \Zk� ijh[m^blky� bgl_j_k�� ihbsbl_emqr_]h�gZklZ\e_gby�m ^jm]hc�klhjhgu�< i_j\mx�hq_j_^v��ke_^h\Zeh�[u�gZa\Zlv�a^_kv�jZaebqgu_�nbehkhnkdb_�kbkl_fu��dhlhju_hl\Z`bebkv� gZjbkh\Zlv� dZjlbgm� fbjZ� \ lhf� \b^_�� dZd� hgZ� hljZ`ZeZkv� \ mf_� h[uqghhl\_jgm\r_]hky�hl�fbjZ�fukebl_ey��Gh�y m`_�iulZeky�^Zlv�h[smx�oZjZdl_jbklbdm�nbehkhnbbb __�f_lh^h\��km^blv�`_�h[�hl^_evguo�kbkl_fZo�y��ih`Zemc��]h`mkv�f_g__��q_f�dlh�eb[h�^jm]hc�LZd� qlh� h[jZlbl_kv� \f_kl_� kh�fghc� d ^\mf� ^jm]bf� y\e_gbyf��fbfh� dhlhjuo� dZd� jZa� \ gZr_\j_fy�gbdZd�g_evay�ijhclb�H^gh� ba� wlbo� fbjh\haaj_gbc� y\ey_lky� dZd� [u� ZgZeh]hf� iheblbq_kdh]h� ZgZjobafZ�\hafh`gh��_]h�wfZgZpb_c��LZdb_�bgl_ee_dlmZevgu_�gb]bebklu��dhg_qgh��[ueb�b jZgvr_��gh�\gZklhys__�\j_fy��dZ`_lky��l_hjby�hlghkbl_evghklb�kh\j_f_gghc�nbabdb�m^ZjbeZ�bf�\ ]heh\m�IjZ\^Z�� hgb� bkoh^yl� ba� gZmdb�� gh� klZjZxlky� ijb� wlhf� \ugm^blv� __ d� kZfhmgbqlh`_gbx�� dkZfhm[bckl\m�� ij_^ibku\Zxl� _c� aZ^Zqm� m[jZlv� k_[y� kZfh_� k ^hjh]b� iml_f� hijh\_j`_gby� __

Page 356: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijblyaZgbc�� QZklh� ijb� wlhf� \hagbdZ_l� \i_qZle_gb_�� qlh� wlhl� gb]bebaf� ebrv� \j_f_ggZymklZgh\dZ��gm`gZy�ebrv�ijb�j_r_gbb�wlhc� aZ^Zqb��MkljZg_gb_�gZmdb�hk\h[h`^Z_l�f_klh�^eyjZkijhkljZg_gby� dZdh]h�gb[m^v� fbklbpbafZ� beb� `_� \gh\v� ij_`g_]h� j_eb]bhagh]hfbjh\haaj_gby�� Kh]eZkgh� ZgZjobklkdhfm� mq_gbx�� \hh[s_� g_l� gbdZdhc� bklbgu�� gbdZdh]hgZ^_`gh]h� ihagZgby� \g_rg_]h�fbjZ�� Lh�� qlh�fu� \u^Z_f� aZ� gZmqgmx� bklbgm�� y\ey_lky� \k_]hebrv� ijh^mdlhf� gZrbo� kh[kl\_gguo� ihlj_[ghkl_c� \ lhc� nhjf_�� \ dZdhc� hgb� ^he`guijhy\eylvky�ijb�f_gyxsboky�\g_rgbo�mkeh\byo��l��_��hiylv�lZdb�beexab_c��< kmsghklb��fugZoh^bf�lhevdh�lh��qlh�gZf�gm`gh��\b^bf�lhevdh�lh��qlh�ohlbf�\b^_lv��Fu�g_�fh`_f�bgZq_�Ihkdhevdm� djbl_jbc� bklbgu�� kh]eZkh\Zgghklv� k \g_rgbf� fbjhf� hliZ^Z_l�� lh� kh\_jr_ggh[_ajZaebqgh��dZdbo�fg_gbc�fu�ijb^_j`b\Z_fky��<k_�h^bgZdh\h�bklbggh�b h^bgZdh\h�eh`gh��Bgbdlh�g_�bf__l�ijZ\Z�mebqZlv�^jm]h]h�\ aZ[em`^_gbb�>ey� mfZ� l_hj_lbdh�ihagZ\Zl_evgh]h� kdeZ^Z� [ueh� [u� aZfZgqb\h� ijhke_^blv�� dZdbfbimlyfb�� dZdbfb� khnbafZfb� ZgZjobklZf� m^Z_lky� ijbibkZlv� gZmd_� ih^h[gu_� dhg_qgu_j_amevlZlu��Wlh�gZlhedgmeh�[u�gZ�kblmZpbx��koh^gmx�k kblmZpb_c�ba�ba\_klgh]h�ijbf_jZ��h^bg`bl_ev�DjblZ�]h\hjbl��\k_�`bl_eb�DjblZ�²�e`_pu�b l��^��Gh�m f_gy�g_l�`_eZgby�b kihkh[ghklbimkdZlvky�\ [he__�]em[hdb_�jZkkm`^_gby��Fh]m�ebrv�kdZaZlv��ZgZjobq_kdh_�mq_gb_�a\mqbl�lZdg_hijh\_j`bfh�� ihdZ� ^_eh� dZkZ_lky� fg_gbc� h[� Z[kljZdlguo� \_sZo�� gh� hgh� hldZau\Z_l� ijbi_j\hf�`_�rZ]_�\ ijZdlbq_kdmx�`bagv��<_^v�^_ckl\byfb�ex^_c�jmdh\h^yl�bo�fg_gby��agZgby��b\k_� lhl� `_� gZmqguc� mf� jZafurey_l� h kljh_gbb� Zlhfh\� b h� ijhbkoh`^_gbb� q_eh\_dZ� bijh_dlbjm_l�dhgkljmdpbx�kihkh[gh]h�\u^_j`Zlv�gZ]jmadm�fhklZ��?keb�[u�[ueh�^_ckl\bl_evgh[_ajZaebqgh��qlh�bf_ggh�fu�^mfZ_f��g_�[ueh�[u�gbdZdbo�agZgbc��dhlhju_��ih�gZr_fm�fg_gbx�kh]eZkmxlky� k ^_ckl\bl_evghklvx�� b fu� fh]eb� [u�� k lZdbf� `_� mki_ohf� kljhblv� fhklu� badZjlhgZ��dZd�b ba�dZfgy��\\h^blv�[hevghfm�^_pb]jZff�fhjnbgZ�\f_klh�kZglb]jZffZ��ijbf_gylv^ey�gZjdhaZ�ke_ahlhqb\uc�]Za�\f_klh�wnbjZ��Gh�b bgl_ee_dlmZevgu_�ZgZjobklu�hldZaZebkv�[uhl�lZdh]h�ijZdlbq_kdh]h�ijbeh`_gby�k\h_]h�mq_gby�>jm]h]h�ijhlb\gbdZ� ke_^m_l� \hkijbgbfZlv� ]hjZa^h� [he__� k_jv_agh�� b y� b \� wlhf� kemqZ_`b\_crbf�h[jZahf� kh`Ze_x� h g_^hklZlhqghklb� k\h_c� hjb_glbjh\db��Y ij_^iheZ]Zx��qlh� \u[he__� f_gy� k\_^msb� \ wlhf� ^_e_� b ^Z\gh� \ujZ[hlZeb� hlghr_gb_� aZ� beb� ijhlb\� fZjdkbafZ�Bkke_^h\Zgby� D�� FZjdkZ� h[� wdhghfbq_kdhc� kljmdlmj_� h[s_kl\Z� b \ebygbb� jZaebqguowdhghfbq_kdbo�nhjf�gZ�\k_�h[eZklb�q_eh\_q_kdhc�`bagb�aZ\h_\Zeb�\ gZr_�\j_fy�g_hkihjbfucZ\lhjbl_l��GZkdhevdh�hgb�ijZ\bevgu�beb�hrb[hqgu�\ qZklghklyo��y��jZamf__lky��g_�fh]m�agZlv�<b^bfh�� b ^jm]bf�� emqr_� hk\_^hfe_gguf�� lh`_� g_� e_]q_�� < l_hjbb� FZjdkZ fg_ qm`^uiheh`_gby�� kh]eZkgh� dhlhjuf� jZa\blb_� h[s_kl\_gguo� nhjf� y\ey_lky_kl_kl\_gghbklhjbq_kdbf� ijhp_kkhf� beb� baf_g_gby� \ khpbZevguo� kehyo� ijhbkoh^yl� \j_amevlZl_� ^bZe_dlbq_kdh]h� ijhp_kkZ�� Y ^Ze_dh� g_� m[_`^_g�� qlh� ijZ\bevgh� ihgbfZx� wlbml\_j`^_gby�� hgb� b a\mqZl� g_� ©fZl_jbZebklbqghª�� Z�� kdhj__�� hl]hehkdhf� lhc� l_fghc]_]_e_\kdhc�nbehkhnbb��q_j_a�dhlhjmx�ijhr_e�b FZjdk��G_� agZx�� dZd�fg_� hk\h[h^blvky��hlk\h_]h� ^be_lZglkdh]h� fg_gby�� ijb\udr_]h� d lhfm�� qlh� h[jZah\Zgb_� deZkkh\� \ h[s_kl\_h[tykgy_lky�[hjv[hc��dhlhjZy�k gZqZeZ�bklhjbb�jZau]ju\Z_lky�f_`^m�hj^Zfb�ex^_c��\ q_f�lhhlebqZ\rboky� ^jm]� hl� ^jm]Z�� KhpbZevgu_� jZaebqby� [ueb�� dZd� y iheZ]Ze�� i_j\hgZqZevghie_f_ggufb� beb� jZkh\ufb� jZaebqbyfb�� Ikboheh]bq_kdb_� nZdlhju�� lZdb_�� dZd f_SDdhgklblmpbhgZevgh]h�klj_fe_gby�d Z]j_kkbb��Z lZd`_�mklhcqb\hklv�hj]ZgbaZpbb�\gmljb�hj^u��b

Page 357: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

nZdlhju� fZl_jbZevgu_�� dZd� h[eZ^Zgb_� emqrbf� hjm`b_f�� hij_^_eyeb� ih[_^m�� < kh\f_klghc`bagb�gZ�h[s_c�a_fe_�ih[_^bl_eb�klZgh\bebkv�]hkih^Zfb��ih[_`^_ggu_�²�jZ[Zfb��Ijb�wlhfg_� gm`gh� hldju\Zlv� gbdZdbo� aZdhgh\� ijbjh^u� beb� baf_g_gby� \ ihgylbyo�� gZijhlb\�g_hkihjbfh� \ebygb_�� dhlhjh_� ijh]j_kkbjmxs__� h\eZ^_gb_� kbeZfb� ijbjh^u� hdZau\Z_l� gZkhpbZevgu_�hlghr_gby�ex^_c��\k_]^Z�klZ\y�\gh\v�ijbh[j_l_ggu_�kj_^kl\Z�\eZklb�gZ� kem`[mZ]j_kkbb�b bkihevamy� bo� ^jm]� ijhlb\� ^jm]Z��Ijbf_g_gb_�f_lZeeZ�� [jhgau��`_e_aZ�iheh`behdhg_p�p_euf�dmevlmjguf�wihoZf�b bo�khpbZevguf�mqj_`^_gbyf��Y ^_ckl\bl_evgh�^mfZx��qlhihjho�� h]g_klj_evgh_� hjm`b_� mijZa^gbeb� jupZjkl\h� b ]hkih^kl\h� agZlb� b qlh� jmkkdbc^_kihlbaf� [ue� h[j_q_g� _s_� ^h� ijhb]jZgghc� \hcgu�� ihkdhevdm� gbdZdhc� bgpmol� \gmljb]hkih^kl\mxsbo� \ ?\jhi_� k_f_c� g_� fh]� ijhba\_klb� gZ� k\_l� jh^� pZj_c�� kihkh[gucijhlb\hklhylv�\aju\ghc�kbe_�^bgZfblZ�>Z�� \hafh`gh�� kh\j_f_gguc� wdhghfbq_kdbc� djbabk�� ihke_^h\Z\rbc� aZ�fbjh\hc� \hcghc�_klv�ebrv�ieZlZ�aZ�ihke_^gxx�]jZg^bhagmx�ih[_^m�gZ^�ijbjh^hc��aZ�aZ\h_\Zgb_�\ha^mrgh]hijhkljZgkl\Z�� Wlh� a\mqbl� g_� hq_gv� m[_^bl_evgh�� gh� \h� \kydhf� kemqZ_� i_j\u_� a\_gvy� k\yabfh`gh� ykgh� jZkihagZlv�� IheblbdZ� :g]ebb� hij_^_eyeZkv� [_ahiZkghklvx�� dhlhjmx]ZjZglbjh\Zeh�_c�hfu\Zxs__�__ [_j_]Z�fhj_��< lhl�fhf_gl��dh]^Z�;e_jvh�i_j_e_l_e�ijheb\�EZ�FZgr�gZ�ZwjhieZg_��wlZ�aZsblgZy�baheypby�[ueZ�gZjmr_gZ��Z \�lm�ghqv��dh]^Z�\ fbjgh_�\j_fy�kp_evx�lj_gbjh\db�]_jfZgkdbc�p_ii_ebg�djm`be�gZ^�Ehg^hghf��\hcgZ�ijhlb\�=_jfZgbb�[ueZ�ih�\b^bfhfm�� j_r_gguf� ^_ehf� �� Ijb� wlhf� g_� ke_^m_l� aZ[u\Zlv� b h[� m]jha_� kh� klhjhguih^\h^ghc�eh^db�Fg_� ihqlb� klu^gh� aZljZ]b\Zlv� \ [_k_^_� k \Zfb� klhev� \Z`gmx� b keh`gmx� l_fm� \ lZdboih\_joghklguo� aZf_qZgbyo�� khagZx� lZd`_�� qlh� g_� kdZaZe� \Zf� gbq_]h� gh\h]h�� Y ohqm� ebrvh[jZlblv�\Zr_�\gbfZgb_�gZ�lh��qlh�hlghr_gb_�q_eh\_dZ�d h\eZ^_gbx�ijbjh^hc��m dhlhjhc�hg[_j_l� hjm`b_� ijhlb\� k_[y� ih^h[guo�� g_ba[_`gh� ^he`gh� \ebylv� b gZ� _]h� wdhghfbq_kdb_mqj_`^_gby��Fu��dZ`_lky��^Ze_dh�hlhreb�hl�ijh[e_f�fbjh\haaj_gby��gh�fu�kdhjh�\_jg_fky�dgbf�� KbeZ� fZjdkbafZ� khklhbl�� \b^bfh�� g_� \ _]h� ihgbfZgbb� bklhjbb� b hkgh\Zgghf� gZ� g_fij_^kdZaZgbb� [m^ms_]h�� Z \� ijhgbpZl_evghf� ^hdZaZl_evkl\_� g_ba[_`gh]h� \ebygby�� dhlhjh_hdZau\Zxl�wdhghfbq_kdb_�hlghr_gby�ex^_c�gZ�bo�bgl_ee_dlmZevgu_��wlbq_kdb_�b wkl_lbq_kdb_mklZgh\db��Wlbf� \kdjul�p_euc� jy^� \aZbfhk\ya_c�b aZ\bkbfhkl_c�� dhlhju_�^h� kbo�ihj�ihqlbkh\_jr_ggh�g_�hkhagZ\Zebkv�Gh� \_^v� g_evay� ij_^iheh`blv�� qlh� wdhghfbq_kdb_� fhlb\u y\eyxlky� _^bgkl\_ggufb�hij_^_eyxsbfb�ih\_^_gb_�ex^_c�\ h[s_kl\_��M`_�lhl�g_khfg_gguc�nZdl��qlh�jZaebqgu_�ebpZ�jZku�� gZjh^u� \ h^bgZdh\uo� wdhghfbq_kdbo� mkeh\byo� \_^ml� k_[y� ih�jZaghfm�� bkdexqZ_l_^bgh\eZklb_�wdhghfbq_kdbo�fhlb\h\��<hh[s_�g_ihgylgh��dZd�fh`gh�h[hclb�ikboheh]bq_kdb_nZdlhju��dh]^Z�j_qv�b^_l�h j_Zdpbyo�`b\uo�q_eh\_q_kdbo�kms_kl\��\_^v�^_eh�g_�lhevdh�\ lhf�qlh�hgb�m`_�mqZkl\h\Zeb�\ mklZgh\e_gbb�wlbo�wdhghfbq_kdbo�hlghr_gbc��b ijb�bo�]hkih^kl\_ex^b� g_� fh]ml� g_� \\h^blv� \ b]jm� k\hb� i_j\hgZqZevgu_� \e_q_gby�� k\hc� bgklbgdlkZfhkhojZg_gby��k\h_�klj_fe_gb_�d Z]j_kkbb��k\hx�ihlj_[ghklv�ex[\b��k\h_�`_eZgb_�ihemqZlvm^h\hevkl\b_� b ba[_]Zlv� g_m^h\hevkl\by�� < [he__� jZgg_f� bkke_^h\Zgbb� fu� ijbagZeb^_ckl\bl_evguf� agZqbl_evgh_�ijblyaZgb_�K\_jo�Y��dhlhjh_�ij_^klZ\ey_l� ljZ^bpbb�b b^_Zeuijhreh]h�b dZdh_�lh�\j_fy�[m^_l�hdZau\Zlv�khijhlb\e_gb_�ih[m`^_gbyf��ijhbkoh�

Page 358: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

�LZd�fg_�khh[sbeb�h[�wlhf�\ i_j\uc�]h^�\hcgu�ba�^hklh\_jguo�bklhqgbdh\�^ysbf�ba�gh\hc� wdhghfbq_kdhc� kblmZpbb��GZdhg_p��^Z\Zcl_�g_�[m^_f� aZ[u\Zlv��qlh�b \q_eh\_q_kdhc� fZkk_�� dhlhjZy� ih^qbg_gZ� wdhghfbq_kdhc� g_h[oh^bfhklb�� lh`_� ijhbkoh^blijhp_kk� dmevlmjgh]h� jZa\blby� ²� pb\bebaZpbb�� dZd� ]h\hjyl� ^jm]b_�²� dhlhjuc�� [_amkeh\gh�ih^\_j`_g�\ebygbx�\k_o�^jm]bo�nZdlhjh\��gh�\ k\h_f�ijhbkoh`^_gbb��g_khfg_ggh��g_aZ\bkbfhl�gbo��kjZ\gbf�k hj]Zgbq_kdbf�ijhp_kkhf�b��hq_gv�fh`_l�[ulv��qlh�hg�\ khklhygbb��kh��k\h_cklhjhgu��\ha^_ckl\h\Zlv�gZ�^jm]b_�nZdlhju��Hg�kf_sZ_l�p_eb�\e_q_gbc�b ^_eZ_l�lZd��qlh�ex^b\hkklZxl� ijhlb\� lh]h�� qlh� [ueh� ^ey� gbo� ^h� kbo� ihj� kghkgh�� lZd`_�� ih�\b^bfhfm�ijh]j_kkbjmxs__�mdj_ie_gb_�gZmqgh]h�h[jZaZ�fure_gby�y\ey_lky�_]h�kms_kl\_gghc�qZklvx�?keb�[u�dlh�gb[m^v�[ue�\ khklhygbb�ihdZaZlv��\ qZklghklb��dZd�wlb�jZaebqgu_�fhf_glu�\k_h[sZy� q_eh\_q_kdZy� bgklbgdlb\gZy� ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklv�� __ jZkh\u_� jZaebqby� b bodmevlmjgu_�ij_h[jZah\Zgby�\_^ml�k_[y�\ mkeh\byo�khpbZevgh]h�ih^qbg_gby��ijhn_kkbhgZevghc^_yl_evghklb� b \hafh`ghkl_c� aZjZ[hldZ�� lhjfhayl� b klbfmebjmxl� ^jm]� ^jm]Z�� _keb� [u� dlh�gb[m^v� fh]� wlh� k^_eZlv�� lh� lh]^Z� hg� ^h\_e� [u� fZjdkbaf� ^h� ih^ebggh]h� h[s_kl\h\_^_gby�Ihlhfm�qlh�b khpbheh]by��aZgbfZxsZyky�ih\_^_gb_f�ex^_c�\ h[s_kl\_��g_�fh`_l�[ulv�gbq_fbguf�� dZd� ijbdeZ^ghc� ikboheh]b_c�� <_^v�� kljh]h� ]h\hjy�� kms_kl\mxl� lhevdh� ^\_� gZmdb�ikboheh]by��qbklZy�b ijbdeZ^gZy��b _kl_kl\hagZgb_�K \gh\v�ijbh[j_l_gguf�\a]ey^hf�gZ�^Ze_dh�b^ms__�agZq_gb_�wdhghfbq_kdbo�hlghr_gbcihy\behkv� bkdmr_gb_� ij_^hklZ\blv� bo� baf_g_gby� g_� bklhjbq_kdhfm� jZa\blbx�� Z ijh\_klb� \`bagv�iml_f�j_\hexpbhggh]h�\f_rZl_evkl\Z��< k\h_f�hkms_kl\e_gbb�\ jmkkdhf�[hevr_\baf_l_hj_lbq_kdbc�fZjdkbaf�gZr_e�wg_j]bx��aZdhgq_gghklv�b bkdexqbl_evghklv�fbjh\haaj_gby��ghh^gh\j_f_ggh�b aeh\_s__�ih^h[b_� lhfm��ijhlb\�q_]h�hg�[hj_lky��;m^mqb�i_j\hgZqZevgh� kZfqZklvx�gZmdb��hibjZykv�\ k\h_f�hkms_kl\e_gbb�gZ�gZmdm�b l_ogbdm��hg�kha^Ze��h^gZdh��aZij_lgZ� fure_gb_�� dhlhjuc� lZd� `_� g_mfhebf�� dZd� \ k\h_� \j_fy� \ j_eb]bb�� Djblbq_kdb_bkke_^h\Zgby�fZjdkbklkdhc�l_hjbb�aZij_s_gu��khfg_gby�\ __�ijZ\bevghklb�dZjZxlky�lZd�`_�dZd�dh]^Z�lh�_j_lbq_kl\h�dZjZehkv�dZlhebq_kdhc�p_jdh\vx��Ijhba\_^_gby�FZjdkZ�dZd�bklhqgbdhldjh\_gby� aZgyeb�f_klh� [b[ebb� b dhjZgZ�� ohly� hgb� g_�f_g__� k\h[h^gu� hl� ijhlb\hj_qbc� bl_fguo�f_kl��q_f�wlb�[he__�^j_\gb_�k\ys_ggu_�dgb]b�B ohly� ijZdlbq_kdbc� fZjdkbaf� [_a`Zehklgh� ihdhgqbe� kh� \k_fb� b^_Zebklbq_kdbfbkbkl_fZfb�b beexabyfb��hg�kZf�jZa\be�beexabb��dhlhju_�g_�f_g__�kihjgu�b [_a^hdZaZl_evgu�q_f� ij_`gb_�� Hg� gZ^__lky� \ l_q_gb_� `bagb� g_fgh]bo� ihdhe_gbc� baf_gblv� q_eh\_q_kdmxijbjh^m�lZd��qlh�ijb�gh\hf�h[s_kl\_gghf�kljh_�kh\f_klgZy�`bagv�ex^_c�ihqlb�g_�[m^_l�agZlvlj_gbc�b qlh�hgb�[_a�ijbgm`^_gby�ijbfml�^ey� k_[y� aZ^Zqb� ljm^Z��F_`^m� l_f�g_ba[_`gu_�\h[s_kl\_� h]jZgbq_gby� \e_q_gbc� hg� i_j_ghkbl� gZ� ^jm]b_� p_eb� b gZijZ\ey_l� Z]j_kkb\gu_gZdehgghklb�� m]jh`Zxsb_� ex[hfm� q_eh\_q_kdhfm� khh[s_kl\m�� \h\g_�� o\ZlZ_lky� aZ\jZ`^_[ghklv�[_^guo�ijhlb\�[h]Zluo��g_�bf_\rbo�^h�kbo�ihj�\eZklb�ijhlb\�[u\rbo�\eZklvbfmsbo�� Gh� lZdh_� baf_g_gb_� q_eh\_q_kdhc� ijbjh^u� kh\_jr_ggh� g_\_jhylgh�� WglmabZaf�� kdhlhjuf� lheiZ� ke_^m_l� \ gZklhys__� \j_fy� [hevr_\bklkdhfm� ijbau\m�� ihdZ� gh\uc� kljhc� g_ml\_j^beky�b _fm�]jhabl�hiZkghklv�ba\g_��g_�^Z_l�gbdZdhc�]ZjZglbb�gZ�[m^ms__��\ dhlhjhf�hgmdj_ibeky� [u� b klZe� g_mya\bfuf�� Kh\_jr_ggh� ih^h[gh� j_eb]bb� [hevr_\baf� ^he`_g\hagZ]jZ`^Zlv�k\hbo�\_jmxsbo�aZ�kljZ^Zgby�b ebr_gby�gZklhys_c�`bagb�h[_sZgb_f�emqr_]h

Page 359: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ihlmklhjhgg_]h� fbjZ�� \ dhlhjhf� g_� hklZg_lky� gb� h^ghc� g_m^h\e_l\hj_gghc� ihlj_[ghklb�IjZ\^Z�� wlhl� jZc� ^he`_g� [ulv� ih� _x� klhjhgm�� ^he`_g� [ulv� kha^Zg� gZ� a_fe_� b hldjul� \h[hajbfh_�\j_fy��Gh�\kihfgbf��qlh�b _\j_b��j_eb]by�dhlhjuo�gbq_]h�g_�agZ_l�h ihlmklhjhgg_c`bagb��h`b^Zeb�ijbr_kl\by�f_kkbb�gZ� a_fex�b qlh�ojbklbZgkdh_�kj_^g_\_dh\v_�\_jbeh��qlh[ebablky�pZjkl\h�[h`b_�G_l�khfg_gbc�\ lhf��dZdh\�[m^_l�hl\_l�[hevr_\bafZ�gZ�wlb�mij_db��Hg�kdZ`_l��ihdZ�ex^bih�k\h_c�ijbjh^_�_s_�g_�baf_gbebkv��g_h[oh^bfh�bkihevah\Zlv�kj_^kl\Z��dhlhju_�^_ckl\mxlgZ�gbo�k_]h^gy��G_evay�h[hclbkv�[_a�ijbgm`^_gby�\ bo�\hkiblZgbb��[_a�aZij_lZ�gZ�fure_gb_�[_a�ijbf_g_gby�gZkbeby�\iehlv�^h�djh\hijheblby��Z g_�ijh[m^b\�\ gbo� l_o�beexabc��g_evay[m^_l�ijb\_klb�bo�d lhfm��qlh[u�hgb�ih^qbgyebkv�wlhfm�ijbgm`^_gbx��B hg�fh]�[u�\_`eb\hihijhkblv�mdZaZlv�_fm�\k_�lZdb��dZd�fh`gh�k^_eZlv�wlh�bgZq_��Wlbf�fu�[ueb�[u�kjZ`_gu��Y g_fh]� [u� ^Zlv� gbdZdh]h� kh\_lZ��Y [u� ijbagZeky�� qlh� mkeh\by� wlh]h� wdki_jbf_glZ� m^_j`b\Zxlf_gy�b fg_�ih^h[guo�hl�_]h�ijh\_^_gby��gh�fu�g_�_^bgkl\_ggu_��d dhfm�wlh�hlghkblky��?klvlZd`_� ex^b� ^_eZ�� g_ihdhe_[bfu_� \ k\hbo� m[_`^_gbyo�� g_� agZxsb_� khfg_gbc�g_\hkijbbfqb\u_�d kljZ^Zgbyf�^jm]bo��_keb�l_�klhyl�gZ�imlb�\uiheg_gby�bo�gZf_j_gbc��LZdbfex^yf� fu� h[yaZgu� l_f�� qlh� ]jZg^bhaguc� wdki_jbf_gl� >ih� kha^Zgbx@� lZdh]h� gh\h]h� kljhyl_i_jv�^_ckl\bl_evgh�ijh\h^blky�\ Jhkkbx��< lh�\j_fy�dZd�\_ebdb_�gZpbb�aZy\eyxl��qlh�`^mlkiZk_gby�lhevdh�\ khojZg_gbb�ojbklbZgkdhc�j_eb]bhaghklb��i_j_\hjhl�\ Jhkkbb��g_kfhljy�gZ\k_�ijbkdhj[gu_�hl^_evgu_�q_jlu��\u]ey^bl�\k_�`_�ij_^\_klgbdhf�emqr_]h�[m^ms_]h�D kh`Ze_gbx��gb \�gZr_f�khfg_gbb��gb \�nZgZlbqghc�\_j_�^jm]bo�g_l�gZf_dZ�gZ�lh��dZdh\[m^_l�bkoh^� wdki_jbf_glZ��;ulv�fh`_l��[m^ms__�gZmqbl�� hgh�ihdZ`_l��qlh� wdki_jbf_gl�[ueij_`^_\j_f_gguf��qlh�dhj_ggh_�baf_g_gb_�khpbZevgh]h�kljhy�bf__l�fZeh�rZgkh\�gZ�mki_o�^hl_o�ihj��ihdZ�gh\u_�hldjulby�g_�m\_ebqZl�gZrm�\eZklv�gZ^�kbeZfb�ijbjh^u�b l_f�kZfuf�g_h[e_]qZl� m^h\e_l\hj_gb_�gZrbo�ihlj_[ghkl_c��Ebrv� lh]^Z� klZg_l� \hafh`guf� lh��qlh�gh\uch[s_kl\_gguc� kljhc� g_� lhevdh� ihdhgqbl� k fZl_jbZevghc� gm`^hc� fZkk�� gh� b mkeurbldmevlmjgu_� ijblyaZgby� hl^_evgh]h� q_eh\_dZ�� K ljm^ghklyfb�� dhlhju_� ^hklZ\ey_lg_h[ma^Zgghklv� q_eh\_q_kdhc� ijbjh^u� ex[hfm� \b^m� khpbZevgh]h� h[s_`blby��fu�� gZ\_jgh_�^he`gu�[m^_f�b lh]^Z�_s_�hq_gv�^he]h�[hjhlvky�M\Z`Z_fu_� ^Zfu� b ]hkih^Z�� Iha\hevl_� fg_� \ aZdexq_gb_� ih^ulh`blv� lh�� qlh� y kfh]kdZaZlv�h[�hlghr_gbb�ikbohZgZebaZ�d fbjh\haaj_gbx�Y ^mfZx�� qlh� ikbohZgZeba� g_� kihkh[_g� kha^Zlv� k\h_� hkh[h_� fbjh\haaj_gb_�� ?fm� b g_gm`gh�wlh��hg�y\ey_lky�qZklvx�gZmdb�b fh`_l�ijbfdgmlv�d gZmqghfm�fbjh\haaj_gbx��Gh�hgh_^\Z� eb� aZkem`b\Z_l� klhev� ]jhfdh]h� gZa\Zgby�� ihlhfm� qlh� g_� \k_� \b^bl�� kebrdhfg_kh\_jr_ggh��g_�ij_l_g^m_l�gZ�aZdhgq_gghklv�b kbkl_fZlbqghklv��GZmqgh_�fure_gb_�kj_^bex^_c� _s_� hq_gv� fheh^h�� kebrdhf� fgh]b_� ba� \_ebdbo� ijh[e_f� _s_� g_� fh`_l� j_rblv�Fbjh\haaj_gb_�� hkgh\Zggh_� gZ� gZmd_�� djhf_� ml\_j`^_gby� j_Zevgh]h� \g_rg_]h� fbjZ�� bf__lkms_kl\_ggu_�q_jlu�hljbpZgby��dZd�lh��h]jZgbq_gb_�bklbghc��hldZa�hl�beexabc��Dlh�ba�gZrbokh\j_f_ggbdh\� g_^h\he_g� wlbf� iheh`_gb_f� \_s_c�� dlh� lj_[m_l� ^ey� k\h_]h� mkihdh_gby� gZ^Zgguc� fhf_gl� [hevr_]h�� imklv� ijbh[j_lZ_l� _]h�� ]^_� gZc^_l��Fu� gZ� g_]h� g_� h[b^bfky�� g_kfh`_f�_fm�ihfhqv��gh�g_�klZg_f�ba�aZ�g_]h�f_gylv�k\hc�h[jZa�fuke_c�

Page 360: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Nj_c^�b ijh[e_fu�ikbobq_kdhc�j_]meypbb�ih\_^_gby�q_eh\_dZDhff_glZjbb�;b[ebh]jZnbyNJ?C>�B IJH;E?FU�IKBOBQ?KDHC�J?=MEYPBBIH<?>?GBY�Q?EH<?D:©E_dpbb� ih� \\_^_gbx� \ ikbohZgZebaª� ²� hkgh\gZy� jZ[hlZ� ��� Nj_c^Z�� \ dhlhjhckbkl_fZlbabjh\Zgb_� baeh`_gZ� _]h� dhgp_ipby�� I_j\Zy� b \lhjZy� qZklb� ©E_dpbcª� [uebih^]hlh\e_gu�Nj_c^hf�dZd�dmjk��aZqblZgguc�\jZqZf��Z lZd`_�g_ki_pbZebklZf�\ l_q_gb_�^\moabfgbo�k_f_kljh\���������b ��������]]��Lj_lvy�qZklv��©Ijh^he`_gb_�e_dpbc���ª��[ueZ�gZibkZgZ\ �����]��?keb�mq_klv��qlh�wlb����e_l�y\bebkv�i_jbh^hf�hkh[_ggh�bgl_gkb\ghc�jZ[hlu�Nj_c^ZgZ^�l_hjb_c�ikbohZgZebaZ��lh�e_]dh�ihgylv�agZq_gb_�wlhc�dgb]b�Kha^Zggh_�Nj_c^hf�\ [he__�iha^g_f�i_jbh^_�ghkbeh�hli_qZlhd�_]h�ijh]j_kkbjh\Z\r_]hmoh^Z�ba�h[eZklb�ikbohiZlheh]bb�\ h[eZklv�khpbheh]bb�b nbehkhnbb�b ij_^klZ\ey_l�f_gvrbcbgl_j_k����H L<HJQ?KL<?�AB=FMG>:�NJ?C>:Bklhjby�`bagb����Nj_c^Z�bf__l�^\Z�jZaguo�Zki_dlZ��H^bg�ba�gbo�²�wlh�hkgh\gu_�nZdlul\hjq_kdh]h�imlb�Nj_c^Z��Wlb�nZdlu�ohjhrh�bamq_gu�b fgh`_kl\h�jZa�hibku\Zebkv��>jm]hcZki_dl� ²� wlh� bgl_ee_dlmZevgZy� kj_^Z�� ^moh\gZy� Zlfhkn_jZ�� ih^� \ebygb_f� dhlhjhcnhjfbjh\Zebkv� b^_b� Nj_c^Z�� dhgp_ipbb�� hl� dhlhjuo� hg� hllZedb\Zeky� dZd� hl� bkoh^guo�� bljZ^bpbb��dhlhju_�\^hogh\eyeb�_]h�gZ�[he__�iha^gbo�wlZiZo�_]h�`bagb��A^_kv�fgh]h_�^h�kboihj�hklZ_lky�_s_�g_^hklZlhqgh�ykguf�b hk\_sZ_lky�\ ebl_jZlmj_�jZaghj_qb\h�Ab]fmg^�Nj_c^�jh^beky�\ ]��Nj_c[_j]_�\ :\kljh�<_g]jbb� �gug_�Ijrb[hj��QKKJ����fZy����� ]�� < ����� ]�� hg� ihklmibe� gZ� f_^bpbgkdbc� nZdmevl_l� <_gkdh]h� mgb\_jkbl_lZ�� BamqZyf_^bpbgm�� hg� \uihegbe� ih^� jmdh\h^kl\hf�W�� ;jxdd_� g_kdhevdh� bkke_^h\Zgbc�� hk\_sZ\rbo\hijhku� kjZ\gbl_evghc� ZgZlhfbb�� nbabheh]bb�� ]bklheh]bb�� Ihemqbe� mq_gmx� kl_i_gv� \mgb\_jkbl_l_� <_gu� �������� lZf� `_� jZ[hlZe� k ����� ]�� ijb\Zl�^hp_glhf�� Z aZl_f� �k ������ ²ijhn_kkhjhf�g_\jhiZlheh]bb��K ����� ]��klZe�jZ[hlZlv�\ dZq_kl\_�\jZqZ�� kgZqZeZ�\ hl^_e_gbb\gmlj_ggbo� [he_ag_c� <_gkdhc� h[s_c� debgbdb� ih^� jmdh\h^kl\hf� =��GhlgZ]_ey�� iha^g__²� \ikbobZljbq_kdhc�debgbd_�ih^�jmdh\h^kl\hf�L��F_cg_jlZ��AZl_f�hg�m_oZe�\ IZjb`�^ey�jZ[hluih^�jmdh\h^kl\hf�@��RZjdh�\ debgbd_�©KZevi_ljb_jª��< �����]��\_jgmeky�\ <_gm�;hevrbgkl\h� him[ebdh\Zgguo� bf� \ wlhl� i_jbh^� jZ[hl� hlghkylky� d l_hjbb� ZnZabc�\hijhkZf� ehdZebaZpbb�fha]h\uo�nmgdpbc�� mq_gbx� h ^_lkdhf� iZjZebq_�� gZjmr_gbyf� aj_gby�Wlb�bkke_^h\Zgby�hlebqZebkv��ih�hlau\Zf�\_^msbo�g_\jheh]h\�lh]h�\j_f_gb��hjb]bgZevghklvxaZfukeZ�b mdZau\Zeb�gZ�\ukhdmx�wjm^bjh\Zgghklv�b kljh]hklv�fukeb�bo�Z\lhjZ�GZqbgZy� k ����� ]�� Nj_c^� klZe� bgl_j_kh\Zlvky� \hafh`ghklvx� e_q_gby� bkl_jbq_kdbojZkkljhckl\� \gmr_gb_f�� aZbfkl\my� gZ� i_j\hf� wlZi_� hiul� njZgpmakdbo� g_\jheh]h\� B�;_jg]_cfZ� b D��Ev_[h��< ����²����� ]]�� hg� jZajZ[Zlu\Z_l� kh\f_klgh� k \jZqhf�B�� ;j_c_jhf

Page 361: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hkh[uc� f_lh^� ]bighl_jZibb� �lZd� gZau\Z_fuc� dZlZjkbk��� Wlh� bkke_^h\Zgb_� [ueh� aZl_fhljZ`_gh� bf� \ dgb]_� ©Hq_jdb� ih� bkl_jbbª�� KjZam� ihke_� him[ebdh\Zgby� wlhc� fhgh]jZnbbNj_c^hf� [ue� gZibkZg� ©Ijh_dlª� �ljm^�� him[ebdh\Zgguc� lhevdh� \ ����� ]��� m`_� ihke_� kf_jlbNj_c^Z���\ dhlhjhf�ij_^klZ\e_gZ�ihiuldZ�bklhedh\Zlv�aZdhghf_jghklb�jZ[hlu�fha]Z�k ihabpbcf_oZgbklbq_kdb�ljZdlm_fhc�nbabheh]bb�K ����� ]�� ]eZ\ghc� aZ^Zq_c� Nj_c^Z� klZgh\blky� kbkl_fZlbq_kdZy� jZajZ[hldZ� l_hjbbikbohZgZebaZ�� Bf� im[ebdm_lky� pbde� fhgh]jZnbc�� ©Lhedh\Zgb_� kgh\b^_gbcª� ������� �dgb]Z�dhlhjmx�Nj_c^� \ ^Zevg_cr_f� g_baf_ggh� kqblZe� k\h_c� ]eZ\ghc� jZ[hlhc��� ©IkbohiZlheh]byh[u^_gghc� `bagbª� �������� ©Hkljhmfb_� b _]h� hlghr_gb_� d [_kkhagZl_evghfmª� �������� ©Ljbhq_jdZ� ih� l_hjbb� k_dkmZevghklbª� ������� b g_dhlhju_� ^jm]b_�� < ]h^u�� ij_^r_kl\h\Z\rb_i_j\hc� fbjh\hc� \hcg_�� b hkh[_ggh� ihke_� \hcgu� Nj_c^� klZe� \k_� [he__� i_j_dexqZlvky� gZjZajZ[hldm�nbehkhnkdbo�b khpbheh]bq_kdbo�Zki_dlh\�kha^Zggh]h�bf�dhgp_ilmZevgh]h�ih^oh^Z�D wlhfm� \j_f_gb� hlghkblky� ihy\e_gb_� lZdbo� _]h� jZ[hl�� dZd� ©E_hgZj^h� ^Z� <bgqb�� wlx^� ihl_hjbb� ikbohk_dkmZevghklbª� �������� ©Lhl_f� b lZ[mª� �������� ©Ih� lm� klhjhgm� ijbgpbiZm^h\hevkl\byª�� ©Ikboheh]by� fZkk� b ZgZeba� q_eh\_q_kdh]h� ©Yªª� �������� ©Y b� Hghª� �������©Pb\bebaZpby�b g_^h\hevgu_�_xª��������b jy^�^jm]bo�bkke_^h\Zgbc��\ ihke_^g_f�ba�dhlhjuo²�©Fhbk_c�b _^bgh[h`b_ª� �������²�hg�ijh^he`be�jZa\blb_� k\hbo�dmevlmjgh�bklhjbq_kdbodhgp_ipbc�Ihke_� hddmiZpbb� :\kljbb� gZpbklZfb� Nj_c^� [ue� ih^\_j]gml� ij_ke_^h\Zgbyf�F_`^mgZjh^guc� Khxa� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbo� h[s_kl\� kfh]�� h^gZdh�� mieZlb\� nZrbklkdbf\eZklyf� \ \b^_� \udmiZ� agZqbl_evgmx� kmffm� ^_g_]�� ^h[blvky� \u^Zqb�Nj_c^m� jZaj_r_gby� gZ\u_a^�\ :g]ebx��<kdhj_�ihke_�i_j__a^Z�\ Ehg^hg�Nj_c^�\ \hajZkl_����e_l�mf_j�����k_gl������]��� LZdh\u�hkgh\gu_�nZdlu�ba�[bh]jZnbb� ���Nj_c^Z�²�q_eh\_dZ�� ljm^u� dhlhjh]h�hklZ\bebg_hkihjbfh�hq_gv�]em[hdbc�ke_^�\ bklhjbb�g_�lhevdh�ikboheh]bb��ikbobZljbb��g_\jheh]bb��ghb \k_c�dmevlmju�gZr_]h�\_dZ�Q_f� `_� hij_^_eyxlky� agZqbl_evghklv� b \ebygb_� \deZ^Z� Nj_c^Z"� Bf� [ueb� hldjuluijh[e_fu�� ikbobq_kdb_� f_oZgbafu�� n_ghf_gu�� nZdlu�� dZkZxsb_ky� lh]h� h[rbjgh]h� ieZklZj_]meypbb� q_eh\_q_kdh]h� ih\_^_gby�� \ dhlhjhf� ij_^klZ\e_gZ� keh`gZy� b aZ]Z^hqgZy� h[eZklv[_kkhagZl_evghc� ikbobdb��>h�Nj_c^Z� \ gZmqguo� bkke_^h\Zgbyo� ih\_^_gby� q_eh\_dZ� ]eZ\gh_\gbfZgb_� m^_eyehkv� eb[h� nbabheh]bq_kdbf� hkgh\Zf� b nZdlhjZf� wlh]h� ijhp_kkZ�� eb[h� _]haZ\bkbfhklb� hl� khagZgby�� KZfZ� ikboheh]by�� \hagbdrZy� \ dZq_kl\_� kZfhklhyl_evghc� h[eZklbagZgbc�� hlebqghc� hl� nbehkhnbb� b nbabheh]bb�� ihgbfZeZkv� dZd� gZmdZ� h khagZgbb�� h l_oy\e_gbyo� \gmlj_gg_]h� fbjZ�� dhlhju_� bg^b\b^mZevguc� km[t_dl� kihkh[_g� \hkijbgylv� ykgh� bhlq_leb\h� b ^Zlv� h gbo� kZfhhlq_l�� GZ� lZdbo� kZfhhlq_lZo� km[t_dlZ� [Zabjh\ZeZkvwdki_jbf_glZevgZy�ikboheh]by��Ij_^iheZ]Zehkv��qlh�gbdlh�g_�fh`_l�mklZgh\blv�ikbobq_kdbcnZdl� k lZdhc�^hklh\_jghklvx�� dZd� lhl�� dlh� _]h�g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh�bkiulu\Z_l�� dlh� khh[sZ_l� hg_f�� gZijZ\eyy� \gmlj_ggbc� Ä\ahj�� gZ� ijhbkoh^ys__� \ kh[kl\_gghf� khagZgbb�� Nj_c^�j_rbl_evgh�ij_h^he_\�lZdh_�ihgbfZgb_�ikbobdb��\u^\bgme�\ dZq_kl\_�p_gljZevgh]h�^ey�\k_o_]h� dhgp_ipbc� iheh`_gb_� h lhf�� qlh� gZjy^m� k khagZgb_f� bf__lky� ]em[bggZy� h[eZklvg_hkhagZ\Z_fhc� ikbobq_kdhc� Zdlb\ghklb�� g_� bamqb\� dhlhjmx� g_\hafh`gh� ihgylv� ijbjh^m

Page 362: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

q_eh\_dZ�� ?keb� ^h�Nj_c^Z� b \u^\b]Zebkv� jZaebqgu_� ij_^klZ\e_gby� h lhf�� qlh� ikbobdZ� g_wd\b\Ze_glgZ� khagZgbx�� lh� hgb� ghkbeb� mfhajbl_evguc� oZjZdl_j�� ^Ze_dbc� hl� j_Zevguoijhp_kkh\�ih\_^_gby�< l_o� kemqZyo�� dh]^Z� bkke_^h\Zl_eb�� bamqZy� wlb� ijhp_kku�� aZljZ]b\Zeb� gZjy^m� kkhagZl_evghc� ikbobdhc� g_hkhagZ\Z_fmx�� hgb� g_� \uy\eyeb� __ ki_pbnbdm�� G_hkhagZ\Z_fu_ij_^klZ\e_gby��gZijbf_j��fukebebkv�dZd�b^_glbqgu_�l_f��dhlhju_�\hagbdZxl�\ khagZgbb��ghhdZau\Zxlky� \ ^Zgguc� fhf_gl� aZ� _]h� ihjh]hf�� G_� bamqZebkv� keh`gu_�� ijhlb\hj_qb\u_hlghr_gby� f_`^m� jZaebqgufb� mjh\gyfb� hj]ZgbaZpbb� ikbobdb�� f_`^m� __ g_hkhagZ\Z_fufbijhy\e_gbyfb�b ^Zggufb�km[t_dlm�\ kZfhgZ[ex^_gbb�GZ�ijh[e_f_�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�\ _]h�khhlghr_gbb�k khagZgb_f�b khkj_^hlhqbeZkv�fukevNj_c^Z��< jZkdjulbb�b lsZl_evghf�bamq_gbb�jZaebqguo�Zki_dlh\�wlhc�ijh[e_fu��\h�\\_^_gbb\ gZmqguc� h[hjhl� jZaebqguo� ]bihl_a�� fh^_e_c� b ihgylbc�� ho\Zlu\Zxsbo� h]jhfgmxg_ba\_^Zggmx� h[eZklv� q_eh\_q_kdhc� `bagb�� b khklhbl� g_hkihjbfZy� bklhjbq_kdZy� aZkem]ZNj_c^Z�� < k\hbo� bkke_^h\Zgbyo� Nj_c^� jZajZ[hlZe� jy^� ihgylbc�� aZi_qZle_\rbo� j_Zevgh_k\h_h[jZab_�ikbobdb�b ihlhfm�ijhqgh�\hr_^rbo�\ Zjk_gZe� kh\j_f_ggh]h�gZmqgh]h� agZgby�hg_c�� D gbf� hlghkylky�� \ qZklghklb�� ihgylby� h aZsblguo� f_oZgbafZo�� njmkljZpbb�b^_glbnbdZpbb��\ul_kg_gbb��nbdkZpbb��j_]j_kkbb��k\h[h^guo�ZkkhpbZpbyo��jheb�Y b�^j�Hkh[h_� f_klh� aZgyeZ� \ _]h� bkke_^h\Zgbyo�� l_kgh� khijy`_gguo� k ikbohl_jZi_\lbq_kdhcijZdlbdhc�� dZl_]hjby� fhlb\Zpbb�� ^bgZfbdb� ih[m`^_gbc�� \gmlj_gg_]h� kljh_gby� ebqghklb�Ih]jm`_gguc� \ ih\k_^g_\guc� ZgZeba� ijbqbg� aZ[he_\Zgbc� k\hbo� iZpb_glh\�� kljZ^Z\rbo� hlg_\jhah\�� Nj_c^� bkdZe� imlb� bae_q_gby� \ \ha^_ckl\bb� g_� gZ� hj]Zgbaf� �ohly� ijb� g_\jhaZogZ[ex^Zxlky�hj]Zgbq_kdb_�kbfilhfu���Z gZ�ebqghklv�Ba� _]h� jZ[hl� ke_^h\Zeh�� qlh�� b]ghjbjmy� ebqghklgh_� gZqZeh� \ q_eh\_d_�� bf_xs__� k\hxbklhjbx� b fgh]hieZgh\uc� kljhc�� g_\hafh`gh� \uykgblv�� qlh� `_� gZjmr_gh� \ hj]ZgbaZpbbZghfZevgh]h�ih\_^_gby�� Z g_� agZy� wlh]h�� g_\hafh`gh� \ha\jZlblv� _]h� d ghjf_��Fgh]b_� l_fu�dhlhju_� ih^kdZaZeZ� debgbq_kdZy� ijZdlbdZ�²� jhev� k_dkmZevguo� i_j_`b\Zgbc� b ^_lkdboikbobq_kdbo� ljZ\f� \ nhjfbjh\Zgbb� oZjZdl_jZ�²� ^Zeb� lheqhd� jZa\blbx� gh\uo�gZijZ\e_gbcbkke_^h\Zgbc��\ qZklghklb�k_dkheh]bb�Nj_c^�\u^\bgme�gZ�i_j_^gbc�ieZg�`bag_ggu_�\hijhku��dhlhju_�gbdh]^Z�g_�i_j_klZ\Zeb\hegh\Zlv�ex^_c�²�h keh`ghklb�\gmlj_gg_]h�fbjZ�q_eh\_dZ��h[�bkiulu\Z_fuo�bf�^mr_\guodhgnebdlZo�� h ihke_^kl\byo� g_m^h\e_l\hj_gguo� \e_q_gbc�� h ijhlb\hj_qbyo� f_`^m©`_eZ_fufª� b ©^he`gufª��@bag_gghklv� b ijZdlbq_kdZy� \Z`ghklv� wlbo� \hijhkh\� \u]h^ghdhgljZklbjh\ZeZ�k Z[kljZdlghklvx�b kmohklvx�ZdZ^_fbq_kdhc��©mgb\_jkbl_lkdhcª�ikboheh]bb�Wlh�b h[mkeh\beh� lhl�[hevrhc�j_ahgZgk��dhlhjuc�ihemqbeh�mq_gb_�Nj_c^Z�dZd�\ kZfhcikboheh]bb�� lZd� b ^Ze_dh� aZ� _\ ij_^_eZfb��<f_kl_� k l_f� gZ� bgl_jij_lZpbx� \u^\bgmluo� bfijh[e_f�� fh^_e_c� b ihgylbc� g_ba]eZ^bfmx� i_qZlv� gZeh`beZ� khpbZevgh�b^_heh]bq_kdZyZlfhkn_jZ��\ dhlhjhc�hg�l\hjbe��GZklmiZeZ�wihoZ�bfi_jbZebafZ��j_adh�h[hkljb\rZy�deZkkh\u_ijhlb\hj_qby�� G_klZ[bevghklv� wdhghfbq_kdhc� b iheblbq_kdhc� `bagb� ihjh`^ZeZ� \f_edh[mj`mZaghc� kj_^_� qm\kl\Z� [_kihdhckl\Z�� ih^Z\e_gghklb�� g_m\_j_gghklb� \ [m^ms_f�Ihimeyjghklv� ijbh[j_lZeb� dhgp_ipbb�� ijhih\_^mxsb_� bjjZpbhgZebaf�� fbklbdm�� mq_gb_� h

Page 363: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

lhf��qlh�i_j_^� ]hehkhf�bgklbgdlh\�[_kkbe_g� keZ[uc� ]hehk� khagZgby��< bkdmkkl\_�ihy\bebkvjZaghh[jZagu_� \ZjbZpbb� gZ� l_fm� ©km^v[u� q_eh\_dZ� dZd� \ujZ`_gby� _]h� [_kkhagZl_evguo\e_q_gbcª��Kj_^b�\eZklbl_e_c�^mf�aZiZ^ghc�bgl_eeb]_gpbb�[hevrmx�ihimeyjghklv�ijbh[j_ebbjjZpbhgZebklu�Rhi_g]Zmwj�b Gbpr_��< wlbo� khpbZevgh�b^_heh]bq_kdbo� mkeh\byo� jZa\blb_b^_c�Nj_c^Z�ihreh�g_�klhevdh�ih�ebgbb�^Zevg_cr_]h�m]em[e_gby�debgbdh�ikboheh]bq_kdh]h�bl_f�[he__�debgbdh�nbabheh]bq_kdh]h�ZgZebaZ�l_o�\Z`guo�nZdlh\��dhlhju_�h[gZ`beZ�_]h�jZ[hlZ\ dZq_kl\_� \jZqZ�ikbohl_jZi_\lZ�� kdhevdh� \ gZijZ\e_gbb� ihkljh_gby� h[sbo� nbehkhnkdh�khpbheh]bq_kdbo� b dmevlmjheh]bq_kdbo� ko_f�� [Zabjh\Z\rboky� gZ� f_lh^heh]bb�� kha\mqghc]hkih^kl\h\Z\r_fm�gZ�AZiZ^_�fbjh\haaj_gbx�Dexq_\uf� ^ey�Nj_c^Z� klZgh\blky� ij_^klZ\e_gb_� h lhf�� qlh� ih\_^_gb_f� ex^_c� ijZ\ylbjjZpbhgZevgu_� ikbobq_kdb_� kbeu�� Z g_� aZdhgu� h[s_kl\_ggh]h� jZa\blby�� qlh� bgl_ee_dl� ²ZiiZjZl� fZkdbjh\db� wlbo� kbe�� Z g_� kj_^kl\h� Zdlb\gh]h� hljZ`_gby� j_Zevghklb�� \k_� [he__m]em[e_ggh]h�hkfuke_gby�__��qlh�bg^b\b^�b khpbZevgZy�kj_^Z�gZoh^ylky�\ khklhygbb�ba\_qghcb lZcghc� \hcgu��NbehkhnkdZy� ^hdljbgZ� ikbohZgZebaZ� l_f� kZfuf� j_adh� ^_nhjfbjh\ZeZ� _]hdhgdj_lgh�gZmqgu_�nZdlu��f_lh^u��ko_fu�hj]ZgbaZpbb�b j_]meypbb�ikbobq_kdhc�^_yl_evghklb�I_j\hgZqZevgh� ikbohZgZeba� h]jZgbqb\Zeky� bklhedh\Zgb_f� ijhbkoh`^_gby� b e_q_gbynmgdpbhgZevguo�aZ[he_\Zgbc��<hkijbgy\�\ xghklb�hl�k\hbo�mqbl_e_c��ij_^klZ\bl_e_c�nbabdh�obfbq_kdhc�rdheu�\ nbabheh]bb��_kl_kl\_gghgZmqguc�\a]ey^�gZ�hj]Zgbaf��Nj_c^�iheghklvxijbagZ\Ze�� qlh� ikbobq_kdZy� Zdlb\ghklv� ²� wlh� nmgdpby� fha]Z�� gh� gZ� hkgh\_� bkke_^h\ZgbynmgdpbhgZevguo� b hj]Zgbq_kdbo� debgbq_kdbo� jZkkljhckl\� hg� ijbr_e� d m[_`^_gbx�� qlhhihjguo�lhq_d�^ey�bo�ikboheh]bq_kdh]h�ZgZebaZ�kh\j_f_ggZy�_fm�nbabheh]by�^Zlv�g_�fh`_l�Hlkx^Z�ihke_^h\Ze�\u\h^��qlh�ikbohiZlheh]bb�gZ^e_`bl�bkoh^blv�lhevdh�ba�ikboheh]bq_kdbo]bihl_a�Khkj_^hlhqb\rbkv� gZ� ijh[e_f_� bkl_jbb�� Nj_c^� jZajZ[hlZe� f_lh^� e_q_gby� wlh]haZ[he_\Zgby�� hkgh\Zgguc� gZ� ]bihl_a_�� ih� dhlhjhc� bkl_jbq_kdbc� kbfilhf� \hagbdZ_l� dZdke_^kl\b_� ih^Z\e_gby� [hevguf� gZijy`_ggh]h� Znn_dlb\gh� hdjZr_ggh]h� \e_q_gby� bkbf\hebq_kdb� aZf_sZ_l� kh[hx�^_ckl\b_��g_� j_Zebah\Zggh_� \ke_^kl\b_�ih^Z\e_gby� Znn_dlZ� \ih\_^_gbb�� Bae_q_gb_� gZklmiZ_l�� _keb� \ mkeh\byo� ]bighlbq_kdh]h� kgZ� m^Z_lky� aZklZ\blv[hevgh]h�\kihfgblv�b \gh\v�i_j_`blv�ih^Z\e_ggh_�\e_q_gb_��WlZ�dhgp_ipby�lZd�gZau\Z_fh]h©dZlZjkbkZª�kh^_j`ZeZ�m`_�fgh]b_�ba�we_f_glh\��y\b\rboky�g_kdhevdh�iha^g__�nmg^Zf_glhfikbohZgZebaZ�Ij_^klZ\e_gby� h iZlh]_g_a_� bkl_jbq_kdbo� kbg^jhfh\�� k dhlhjuo� gZqZeZkv� jZajZ[hldZl_hjbb� ikbohZgZebaZ�� klZeb� \ ^Zevg_cr_f� ihkl_i_ggh� mkeh`gylvky�� :nn_dlb\gh_� \e_q_gb_klZeh� jZkkfZljb\Zlvky� dZd� ikboheh]bq_kdh_� khklhygb_�� bf_xs__� k\hc� ki_pbnbq_kdbc©wg_j]_lbq_kdbc� aZjy^ª� �©dZl_dkbkª��� ;m^mqb� ih^Z\e_gguf�� \e_q_gb_�� kh]eZkgh� l_hjbbikbohZgZebaZ�� g_� mgbqlh`Z_lky�� Z ebrv� i_j_oh^bl� \ hkh[mx� ikbobq_kdmx� kn_jm�©[_kkhagZl_evgh]hª��� ]^_� hgh� m^_j`b\Z_lky� ©ZglbdZl_dkbq_kdbfbª� kbeZfb�� <ul_kg_ggucZnn_dl� klj_fblky�� h^gZdh�� \gh\v� \_jgmlvky� \ khagZgb_�� b _keb� hg� g_� fh`_l� ij_h^he_lvkhijhlb\e_gb_� ©ZglbdZl_dkbkZª�� lh� hg� iulZ_lky� ^h[blvky� wlhc� p_eb� gZ� h[oh^guo� imlyo�bkihevamy� kgh\b^_gby�� h[fhe\db�� hibkdb� beb� ijh\hpbjmy� \hagbdgh\_gb_� kbf\hebq_kdb� _]haZf_sZxs_]h�debgbq_kdh]h�kbg^jhfZ��Qlh[u�mkljZgblv�jZkkljhckl\h��\ua\Zggh_�\ul_kg_gguf

Page 364: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Znn_dlhf�� gZ^h� aZklZ\blv� [hevgh]h� wlhl� Znn_dl� hkhagZlv��F_lh^Zfb� h[gZjm`_gby� lh]h�� qlh[ueh� \ul_kg_gh� �l�� _�� ikbohZgZebahf� \ madhf� kfuke_��� y\eyxlky� bkke_^h\Zgby� k\h[h^guoZkkhpbZpbc�� jZkdjulb_� kbf\hebq_kdb� \ujZ`_ggh]h� kdjulh]h� kfukeZ� kgh\b^_gbc� bjZkrbnjh\dZ�lZd�gZau\Z_fh]h�ljZgkn_jZ��i_j_g_k_gby��²�hkh[h]h��ihkl_i_ggh�kha^Zxs_]hky�\ijhp_kk_�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�e_q_gby�Znn_dlb\gh�hdjZr_ggh]h�hlghr_gby�[hevgh]h�d ebpm�ijh\h^ys_fm�ikbohZgZeba�=eZ\guf� \b^hf� \ul_kg_gguo� Znn_dlh\� Nj_c^� h[ty\be� \e_q_gby� wjhlbq_kdb_�ih^q_jdb\Zy�� qlh� ijhp_kk� \ul_kg_gby� gZ[ex^Z_lky� m`_� gZ� i_j\uo� wlZiZo� ^_lkl\Z�� dh]^Znhjfbjmxlky�gZqZevgu_�ij_^klZ\e_gby�h ©g_^ha\he_gghfª��JZa\blb_�wlhc�b^_b�ij_^klZ\e_gh�\jZ[hlZo� Nj_c^Z�� ihk\ys_gguo� ijh[e_fZf� bgnZglbevghc� ©ZgZevghc� wjhlbdbª�� ©W^bih\Zdhfie_dkZª� �\jZ`^_[gh]h� qm\kl\Z� kugZ� d hlpm� aZ� lh�� qlh� ihke_^gbc� f_rZ_l� [_ajZa^_evgh\eZ^_lv�fZl_jvx��b ^j��Wg_j]by��iblZxsZy�k_dkmZevghklv�j_[_gdZ�b \ajhkeh]h�²�wlh�©eb[b^hª�\Z`g_crbc��ih�Nj_c^m��^\b]Zl_ev�ikbobq_kdhc�`bagb��dhlhjuc�hij_^_ey_l��k h^ghc�klhjhgu�\k_�[h]Zlkl\h�i_j_`b\Zgbc�� Z k�^jm]hc�²�iulZ_lky�khj\Zlv� aZij_lu��gZeZ]Z_fu_� khpbZevghckj_^hc� b fhjZevgufb� mklZgh\dZfb�� \ kemqZ_�`_� g_\hafh`ghklb� ^h[blvky� lZdh]h� kju\Z� wlhlnZdlhj�\\_j]Z_l�km[t_dlZ�\ g_\jha�b bkl_jbx�< ^Zevg_cr_f� wlhc� ko_f_� [ue� ijb^Zg� _s_� [he__� keh`guc� oZjZdl_j�� IhfbfhkZfhml\_j`^Zxsboky�eb[b^haguo�\e_q_gbc�^ey�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�h[ty\ey_lky�oZjZdl_jghc�bijhlb\hiheh`gZy� jZajmrbl_evgZy�� Z]j_kkb\gZy� l_g^_gpby�� ©bgklbgdl� kf_jlbª�� <ky� ikbobdZij_\jZsZ_lky� \ k\h_h[jZagh_� khq_lZgb_� lj_o� bgklZgpbc�� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� �\f_klbebsZ\ul_kg_gguo� Znn_dlb\guo� \e_q_gbc��� ih^khagZl_evgh]h� �dhlhjh_� \uihegy_l� nmgdpbx©p_gamjuª��ba[bjZl_evgh�ijhimkdZxs_c�\ khagZgb_�lh��qlh�^ey�g_]h�[he__�ijb_fe_fh��b kZfh]hkhagZgby�Ke_^mxsbc� wlZi� \ jZa\blbb� ikbohZgZebaZ� k\yaZg� k _]h� ihkl_i_gguf� ij_\jZs_gb_f� bal_hjbb� ij_bfms_kl\_ggh� f_^bpbgkdhc� b ikboheh]bq_kdhc� \ dhgp_ipbx� nbehkhnkdmx�ij_l_g^mxsmx� gZ� \_^msmx� jhev� ijb� jZkkfhlj_gbb� h[sbo� \hijhkh\� khpbheh]bb�� bklhjbb�l_hjbb� bkdmkkl\Z�� ebl_jZlmjh\_^_gby� b p_eh]h� jy^Z� ^jm]bo� h[eZkl_c� l_hj_lbq_kdh]h� bijbdeZ^gh]h�agZgby�Ba�ij_^klZ\e_gbc�h ih^qbg_gghklb�ih\_^_gby�ijbfblb\guf�g_hkhagZ\Z_fuf�\e_q_gbyf�bh ijbkms_f� ydh[u� q_eh\_dm� ©bgklbgdl_� kf_jlbª� Nj_c^� ijbr_e� d aZdexq_gbx� hg_hl\jZlbfhklb� \hcg� b h[s_kl\_ggh]h� gZkbeby�� ba� lh]h�� qlh� \hkiblZgb_� ij_^iheZ]Z_llhjfh`_gb_�bgklbgdlb\guo�klj_fe_gbc� �ljZdlm_fh_�Nj_c^hf�dZd�iZlh]_ggh_� ©\ul_kg_gb_ª��[ue� k^_eZg� \u\h^� h jZajmrbl_evghf� \ebygbb�� hdZau\Z_fhf� gZ� ikbobq_kdh_� a^hjh\v_pb\bebaZpb_c��b [ueb�\ukdZaZgu�]em[hdh�i_kkbfbklbq_kdb_�fukeb�ih�ih\h^m�\hafh`ghkl_c�bp_gghklb� ^Zevg_cr_]h� h[s_kl\_ggh]h� ijh]j_kkZ�� kZfh_� \hagbdgh\_gb_� q_eh\_q_kdh]hh[s_kl\Z�� dmevlmju� b gjZ\kl\_gghklb� [ueh� h[tykg_gh� g_� ljm^h\hc� ^_yl_evghklvx�� g_hlghr_gbyfb��\ dhlhju_�ex^b�\klmiZxl�\ ijhp_kk_�h[s_kl\_ggh]h�ijhba\h^kl\Z��Z \k_�l_fb�`_wjhlbq_kdbfb� b Z]j_kkb\gufb�� \e_q_gbyfb�� dhlhju_� y\eyxlky�� ih� Nj_c^m�� \Z`gufb^\b]Zl_eyfb�^mr_\ghc�`bagb�b kh\j_f_gguo�pb\bebah\Zgguo�ex^_c�WlZ� h[sZy� l_g^_gpby� bgl_jij_lbjh\Zlv� kZfu_� jZaebqgu_� h[s_kl\_ggu_� n_ghf_gu^_ckl\b_f�©]em[bgguoª�ikboheh]bq_kdbo�nZdlhjh\�ijb\_eZ�Nj_c^Z�g_�lhevdh�d jZkkfhlj_gbx

Page 365: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

\k_c�^moh\ghc�`bagb�q_eh\_q_kl\Z� �bkdmkkl\Z��gZmdb��jZaebqguo�khpbZevguo�bgklblmlh\��dZd\ujZ`_gby�ij_h[jZah\Zgghc�wg_j]bb�eb[b^h��gh�b d�jy^m�gZklhevdh�k\h_h[jZaguo�ihkljh_gbc�qlh�^Z`_�m gZb[he__�hjlh^hdkZevguo�_]h�mq_gbdh\�wlb�ihkljh_gby�^Ze_dh�g_�\k_]^Z�gZoh^bebkhqm\kl\b_� �gZijbf_j�� d l_hjbb� \hagbdgh\_gby� j_eb]bb� ba� qm\kl\Z� \bgu� aZ� m[bckl\ZiZljbZjoh\�jh^Z��kh\_jr_ggu_�ydh[u�ih�k_dkmZevguf�fhlb\Zf�\ i_j\h[ulghf�h[s_kl\_�d l_hjbb�lZd�gZau\Z_fuo�mgZke_^h\Zgguo�jZkh\uo�\hkihfbgZgbc��d l_hjbb��h[tykgyxs_cij_h[eZ^Zxsmx�jhev�fm`qbgu�\ kh\j_f_gghf�h[s_kl\_�qm\kl\hf�g_iheghp_gghklb��dhlhjh_bkiulu\Zxl�fheh^u_�^_\mrdb�\ k\yab�k hlkmlkl\b_f�m gbo�fm`kdbo�iheh\uo�ijbagZdh\�b l�i����G_kfhljy�gZ� \kx� iZjZ^hdkZevghklv� wlh]h� khpbheh]bq_kdh]h� Zki_dlZ� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhcl_hjbb�b fgh`_kl\h�\hajZ`_gbc��dhlhju_�[ueb�\u^\bgmlu�ijhlb\�g_]h�\ ebl_jZlmj_��Nj_c^m^_eye�_fm�\iehlv�^h�ihke_^g_]h�wlZiZ�k\h_c�^_yl_evghklb�hq_gv�fgh]h�\gbfZgby����H DGB=? ���NJ?C>: ©E?DPBB�IH�<<?>?GBX�< IKBOH:G:EBAªDgb]Z����Nj_c^Z�©E_dpbb�ih�\\_^_gbx�\ ikbohZgZebaª�aZgbfZ_l�\ jy^m�_]h�ebl_jZlmjguojZ[hl� hkh[h_� f_klh�� Wlh� \ul_dZ_l� m`_� ba� \j_f_gb� gZibkZgby� wlh]h� ijhba\_^_gby��Fu� m`_mihfbgZeb�� qlh� i_j\u_� qZklb� ©E_dpbcª� [ueb� ih^]hlh\e_gu� \ ����²����� ]]��Ihy\e_gb_�`_©Ijh^he`_gby�e_dpbcª�hlghkblky�d ���f ]h^Zf��Ihwlhfm�i_j\Zy�qZklv�kh^_j`bl�lh��qlh�fh`ghjZkkfZljb\Zlv� dZd� y^jh�� dZd� hkgh\m� kha^Zgghc� Nj_c^hf� dhgp_ipbb�� dZd� hibkZgb_l_hj_lbq_kdbo� ijbgpbih\� b f_lh^h\� ikbohZgZebaZ�� Z lZd`_� kihkh[h\� bklhedh\Zgby� ^Zgguo�ihemqZ_fuo�\ j_amevlZl_�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�bkke_^h\Zgby��<lhjZy�qZklv�ihk\ys_gZ�h[sbfijbgpbiZf� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_hjbb� g_\jhah\�� Lj_lvy� `_� kh^_j`bl� lh�� qlh� fgh]bfb� bdjblbdZfb��b Z^_ilZfb�nj_c^bafZ�ljZdlm_lky�dZd�_]h�jZa\_jgmluc�hdhgqZl_evguc�\ZjbZgl��dZdk\h_]h� jh^Z� Jm[bdhg�� i_j_c^y� dhlhjuc� Nj_c^� ihkl_i_ggh� ij_\jZlbeky� ba� debgbpbklZ� \khpbheh]Z� b nbehkhnZ�� \ hkgh\Zl_ey� fbjh\haaj_gby�� ihemqb\r_]h� bkdexqbl_evgh� [hevrh_\ebygb_�gZ�AZiZ^_�H k\h_h[jZabb� kbkl_fu� \a]ey^h\� Nj_c^Z� ]h\hjbl� lh�� qlh� \ g_c� hdZaZebkvij_^klZ\e_ggufb��k h^ghc�klhjhgu��]em[hdh�gh\ZlhjkdZy�ikboheh]bq_kdZy�dhgp_ipby�²�l_hjbyg_hkhagZ\Z_fhc� ikbobq_kdhc� ^_yl_evghklb�� ml\_j`^ZxsZy�� qlh� \ hl\e_q_gbb� hl� nZdlhjZ[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�ihkljh_gb_�h[s_c�l_hjbb�khagZgby�q_eh\_dZ�ijbgpbibZevgh�g_\hafh`gh��Z k^jm]hc�²�lZdhc�jy^�hrb[hqguo�iheh`_gbc�b f_lh^heh]bq_kdb�g_Z^_d\Zlguo�lhedh\Zgbc��qlh\uy\e_gb_� gZmqgh� p_gguo� we_f_glh\�nj_c^bafZ� hdZaZehkv� \hafh`guf� lhevdh� ihke_� kihjh\�^eb\rboky�^_kylbe_lbyfb�DZdb_�`_�hkh[_gghklb�nj_c^bafZ�h[_ki_qbeb�_fm�lZdh_�[_kij_p_^_glgh_�jZkijhkljZg_gb_b \ebygb_��g_kfhljy�gZ�_]h�fgh]hqbke_ggu_�^_n_dlu"IjbklmiZy�d ql_gbx�©E_dpbcª��ke_^m_l�bf_lv�\ \b^m�^\Z�h[sbo�iheh`_gby��I_j\h_�ba�gboiha\hey_l� q_ldh� ijh\_klb� ]jZgbpm� f_`^m� l_f�� qlh� y\ey_lky� kbevghc� klhjhghc� nj_c^bafZ�h[mkeh\b\r_c�_]h�\ebygb_�gZ�kh\j_f_ggmx�ikboheh]bx��b l_f��qlh�gZeh`beh�gZ�dhgdj_lgu_ihkljh_gby� ikbohZgZebaZ� hli_qZlhd� h]jZgbq_gghklb�� k\h_h[jZagh]h� bklhjbq_kdh]h� b]_h]jZnbq_kdh]h�©ijh\bgpbZebafZª��h[_^gb\�h[s__�agZq_gb_�\k_]h�gZmqgh]h�gZke_^by�Nj_c^Z�

Page 366: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Dhgp_ipby��jZajZ[hlZggZy�Nj_c^hf��aZkem`b\Z_l�\gbfZgby�ij_`^_�\k_]h�ihlhfm��qlh�hgZihklmebjm_l� kms_kl\h\Zgb_� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� dZd� \ \ukr_c� kl_i_gb� \Z`gh]h� dhfihg_glZq_eh\_q_kdh]h�khagZgby��H^ghklhjhgghklv�`_�b ©ijh\bgpbZebafª�\ jZkdjulbb�ijbjh^u�wlh]hdhfihg_glZ�\uklmibeb�hq_gv�yjdh� �\ qZklghklb��bf_ggh�\ ©E_dpbyoª��dZd�k\_^_gb_�hkgh\ghcjZ[hlu� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� d ^bgZfbd_� i_j_`b\Zgbc�� k\yaZgguo� ij_bfms_kl\_ggh� k h[eZklvxk_dkZ�� k jZa\blb_f� b n_ghf_gheh]b_c� iheh\hc�`bagb� g_� lhevdh� \ajhkeuo�� gh� b ^_l_c�²� hlgZb[he__�jZggbo�nZa�bo�hglh]_g_lbq_kdh]h�jZa\blby��Lh��qlh�[ueh��ih�\b^bfhfm��oZjZdl_jgh^ey� gjZ\h\� lhevdh� hij_^_e_gguo� keh_\� �deZkkh\uo� ]jmii�� \_gkdh]h� h[s_kl\Z� gZqZeZ� \_dZ�ihemqbeh�m Nj_c^Z�agZq_gb_�mgb\_jkZevghc�khpbZevghc�oZjZdl_jbklbdb��Bf_ggh�wlh�fu�bf__f\ \b^m��]h\hjy�h ©ijh\bgpbZebaf_ª�bkoh^guo�ihkljh_gbc�Nj_c^Z�Hkgh\ghc� q_jlhc� ih^oh^Z� Nj_c^Z� d ZgZebam� debgbq_kdbo� ijhy\e_gbc�� kbfilhfh\� bkbg^jhfh\� [he_agb� y\behkv� jZkkfhlj_gb_� fgh]bo� ba� lZdbo� ijhy\e_gbc� dZd� bf_xsbohij_^_e_gguc� kdjuluc� kfuke� hij_^_e_ggh_� aZrbnjh\Zggh_� agZq_gb_� ^ey� km[t_dlZ� bmkljZgyxsbo�� dh]^Z� wlhl� kfuke� ^h\h^blky� \ j_amevlZl_� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbo� ijhp_^mj� bijb_fh\�^h�ykgh]h�khagZgby�[hevgh]h�H[jZlbfky� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh� d kh^_j`Zgbx� ©E_dpbcª�� I_j\Zy� e_dpby� ²� wlh� h[s__\\_^_gb_���²��e_dpbb�ihk\ys_gu�lZd�gZau\Z_fuf�hrb[hqguf�^_ckl\byf� �hibkdZf��hqbldZf�h]h\hjdZf��aZ[u\Zgbx�\_s_c��^Zl��Z^j_kh\�b l��i����\ �²���e_dpbyo�jZkkfZljb\Z_lky�ijh[e_fZkgh\b^_gbc�Hibku\Zy�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by��Nj_c^�gZ�fgh]hqbke_gguo�ijbf_jZo�ih^\h^bl�qblZl_ey�dij_^klZ\e_gbx� h lhf�� qlh� dZ`^h_� ba� lZdbo� ^_ckl\bc� bf__l� k\hc� kfuke�� k\h_� hij_^_e_ggh_agZq_gb_��b \u^Z_l�kms_kl\h\Zgb_�g_hkhagZ\Z_fhc��gh�\iheg_�j_Zevgh�bf_xs_cky�m km[t_dlZl_g^_gpbb��gZf_j_gby��`_eZgby��< g_dhlhjuo�kemqZyo�hrb[hqgu_�^_ckl\by��ghkysb_�oZjZdl_j©aZ[u\Zgbyª�� y\eyxlky� \ujZ`_gb_f� klj_fe_gby� khagZgby� ba[Z\blvky� hl� q_]h�lh� ^ey� g_]hg_ijbylgh]h��\ujZ`_gb_f�\ul_kg_gby�ly]hklgh]h�Znn_dlZ�\ h[eZklv�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�Ke_^m_l� hlf_lblv�� qlh� wlZ� qZklv� h[sbo� ij_^klZ\e_gbc� Nj_c^Z� baeh`_gZ� bf� \ nhjf_fgh]bo� b jZaghh[jZaguo� wibah^h\� b gbdh]^Z� g_� \uau\ZeZ�� ^Z`_� m m[_`^_gguo� djblbdh\ikbohZgZebaZ�� hkh[uo� \hajZ`_gbc��Ohly� gZmqgu_� ©^hdZaZl_evkl\Zª� �\ nhjfZevghf� agZq_gbbwlh]h� ihgylby�� Z^_d\Zlghklb� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_hjbb� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc� \ ©E_dpbyoªhlkmlkl\m_l�� hkiZjb\Zlv� wlb� ml\_j`^_gby� Nj_c^Z� hohlgbdh\�� dZd� ihdZaZeb� fgh]b_� ]h^u�bkl_drb_�kh�\j_f_gb�kha^Zgby�wlhc�l_hjbb��g_�gZrehkv�Hl� jZkkfhlj_gby� hrb[hqguo� ^_ckl\bc� Nj_c^� i_j_oh^bl� d ^_lZevghfm� ZgZebamkgh\b^_gbc�²� wlhc�� ih� _]h� kh[kl\_gghfm� \ujZ`_gbx�� ©pZjkl\_gghc� ^hjh]bª� \ h[eZklv[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� Hg� ijbeZ]Z_l� [hevrb_� mkbeby�� qlh[u� \hafh`gh� ^_lZevg__� hibkZlv� dZdkljmdlmjm�kgh\b^_gbc��lZd�b kdjulu_�aZdhghf_jghklb�bo�^bgZfbdb�Hg�ih^q_jdb\Z_l�hij_^_e_ggh_�koh^kl\h��kms_kl\mxs__�f_`^m�hrb[hqgufb�^_ckl\byfbb kgh\b^_gbyfb��ih^h[gh�lhfm�dZd�\ hrb[hqghf�^_ckl\bb�kms_kl\m_l�lZ�beb�^jm]Zy�nhjfZ�_]h\ujZ`_gby�\ ih\_^_gbb��lZd�\ kgh\b^_gbb�kms_kl\m_l�_]h� ©y\gZyª� �ij_^klZ\e_ggZy�khagZgbxkiys_]h��nhjfZ��b kdjulh_� �eZl_glgh_��kh^_j`Zgb_��dhlhjh_�hij_^_ey_lky�[_kkhagZl_evguf�bfh`_l� [ulv� jZkrbnjh\Zgh� lhevdh� ikbohZgZebahf�� Nj_c^� hibku\Z_l� jy^� f_oZgbafh\�

Page 367: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ij_h[jZamxsbo�� Z lhqg__�� fZkdbjmxsbo� kdjulh_� kh^_j`Zgb_� kgh\b^_gby�� k ij_\jZs_gb_fwlh]h�kdjulh]h�kh^_j`Zgby�\ kgh\b^_gb_�©y\gh_ª��H[sZy�nmgdpby�kgh\b^_gbc��ih�Nj_c^m�²wlh� mkljZg_gb_� jZa^jZ`_gbb�� f_rZxsbo� iheghp_gghfm� kgm�� iml_f� ]ZeexpbgZlhjgh]hm^h\e_l\hj_gby�ihlj_[ghkl_c��\hagbdZxsbo�m kiys_]h�Nj_c^� hibku\Z_l� jZaghh[jZagu_� f_oZgbafu�� f_rZxsb_� ihgylv� kdjulh_� kh^_j`Zgb_kgh\b^_gbc�� BkdZ`_gby� wlh]h� kdjulh]h� kh^_j`Zgby� \hagbdZxl� ij_`^_� \k_]h� [eZ]h^Zjy©p_gamj_ª�� ij_iylkl\mxs_c� ijhgbdgh\_gbx� \ khagZgb_� g_ijb_fe_fuo� ^ey� g_]h� we_f_glh\[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� H^gZdh� a^_kv� kdZau\Z_lky� b hkh[uc� ²� kbf\hebq_kdbc� ²� oZjZdl_jhlghr_gbc�� mklZgZ\eb\Zxsboky� \h� kg_� f_`^m� h[jZahf� y\gh]h� kgh\b^_gby� b _]h� kdjulufagZq_gb_f�� hkh[uc� oZjZdl_j� hlghr_gby� we_f_glh\� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� d kljmdlmj_� y\gh]hkgh\b^_gby� ²� ihy\e_gb_� \ y\ghf� kgh\b^_gbb� ©qZklb� \f_klh� p_eh]hª�� ©k]ms_gbyª� h[jZah\�©gZf_dh\ª��©hebp_l\hj_gbyª�b fgh`_kl\Z�^jm]bo�: ^Ze__�Nj_c^�kh\_jrZ_l��dZd�wlh�ihdZaZeb�^he]b_�]h^u��bkl_drb_�ihke_�\hagbdgh\_gbyikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_hjbb� kgh\b^_gbc�� h^gm� ba� ]eZ\guo� k\hbo� l_hj_lbq_kdbo� hrb[hd�ihklmebjmy� gZebqb_� ihklhygguo�� dhgklZglguo hlghr_gbc�� kms_kl\mxsbo� ydh[u� f_`^mwe_f_glhf�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby�b _]h�kdjuluf�agZq_gb_f��Hg�khklZ\ey_l�hkh[uc�©keh\Zjvª�^eyi_j_\h^h\�h[jZah\�y\gh]h�kgh\b^_gby�\ kdjulu_�aZ�wlbfb�h[jZaZfb�kfukeu��©^hf�k ]eZ^dbfbkl_gZfbª�²fm`qbgZ�� ©^hf� k \uklmiZfbª�²�`_gsbgZ�� dZdh_�lh� hlghr_gb_� d \h^_�²� jh^u�iZedb�� ahglbdb�� lhjqZsb_� \\_jo�� \ha^mrgu_� rZju� ²� wj_dpbhggu_� kgu�� rdZlmedZ� k^jZ]hp_gghklyfb�²�kbf\he�`_gkdbo� ]_gblZebc��\uiZ^_gb_� am[Z�²�dZkljZpby�\ gZdZaZgb_� aZhgZgbaf�b l��^����B h^gh\j_f_ggh�hg�kh\_jrZ_l�^jm]mx�hrb[dm��hl^Z\Zy�y\gh_�ij_^ihql_gb_ijb� khklZ\e_gbb� wlh]h� keh\Zjy� l_fZlbd_�� lZd� beb� bgZq_� k\yaZgghc� k k_dkmZevgufbi_j_`b\Zgbyfb�Q_f�h[tykgyxlky�wlb�g_�fh]msb_�g_�\ua\Zlv�m^b\e_gby�hrb[db�Nj_c^Z"Ij_`^_� \k_]h� _]h� hq_gv� k\h_h[jZaguf� \a]ey^hf� gZ� jZa\blb_� k_dkmZevghklb�� < hkgh\mij_^klZ\e_gbc� h jZa\blbb� k_dkmZevghc� nmgdpbb� bf� [ueh� iheh`_gh� jZa]jZgbq_gb_� f_`^mnmgdpbyfb� k_dkmZevghc� b ]_gblZevghc� �iheh\hc��� Ihke_^gxx� hg� k\yaZe� kh� kihkh[ghklvxijh^he`_gby�jh^Z��Z i_j\mx�²�kh�klj_fe_gb_f�d k\h_]h�jh^Z�©m^h\hevkl\byfª�Ih� kms_kl\m� Nj_c^� \ k\h_f� h[tykg_gbb� w\hexpbb� iheh\hc� nmgdpbb� \ha\jZlbeky� dij_^klZ\e_gbyf� ^j_\g_]h� ]_^hgbafZ�� \ qZklghklb� ^j_\g_]j_q_kdhc� dbj_gkdhc� rdheu�©dbj_gZbdh\ª��� h[ty\ey\r_c� klj_fe_gb_� d m^h\hevkl\bx� hkgh\guf� ih[m^bl_evguf^\b]Zl_e_f� `bagb�� <h� \e_q_gbb� j_[_gdZ� d m^h\hevkl\bx� Nj_c^� \uqe_gbe� jy^ihke_^h\Zl_evguo�klZ^bc��g_�bf_xsbo�hlghr_gby�d agZqbl_evgh�[he__�iha^gh�jZa\b\Zxs_ckyiheh\hc� nmgdpbb� �hjZevgmx� klZ^bx�� ijb� dhlhjhc� ©h[t_dlhf� ex[\bª� y\ey_lky� fZl_jbgkdZy]jm^v�� Z nhjfhc� ijhy\e_gby� ²� khkZgb_�� ZgZevgh�kZ^bklkdmx�� k\yaZggmx� k ijbylgufbhsms_gbyfb�� ihemqZ_fufb� j_[_gdhf� ijb� wdkdj_lhjghc� ^_yl_evghklb� lheklhc� dbrdb� bfhq_\h]h� imaujy� b ^j���� =_^hgbklbq_kdbc� we_f_gl�� ijbkmsbc� wlbf� ijhy\e_gbyf�� aZklZ\beNj_c^Z�jZkkfZljb\Zlv�bo�dZd�aZdhghf_jgu_�ij_^klZ^bb�\ khaj_\Zgbb�iheh\h]h�\e_q_gby��GZ^gbfb� hg� ml\_j^be� dZd� wfhpbhgZevgmx�nhjfm� jZgg_c� k_dkmZevghklb� lZd�gZau\Z_fuc�W^bih\dhfie_dk� �i_jbh^� h[hklj_gghc� ijb\yaZgghklb� kugZ� d fZl_jb�� khijh\h`^Z_fuc� qm\kl\hf\jZ`^_[ghklb�d hlpm���^hiheg_gguc�\ ^Zevg_cr_f� ©dhfie_dkhf�We_dljuª� �i_jbh^hf�hkh[hc

Page 368: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ijb\yaZgghklb�^hq_jb�d hlpm���b p_euc�jy^�^jm]bo�k\h_h[jZaguo�nhjf��q_j_a�dhlhju_��ih�_]hfg_gbx��ijhoh^bl�khaj_\Zgb_�bgnZglbevgh�k_dkmZevguo�wfhpbc�<k_� wlb� ihkljh_gby� gZeh`beb� ]em[hdbc� hli_qZlhd� gZ� Zgljhiheh]bq_kdb_� bkhpbheh]bq_kdb_�\haaj_gby�Nj_c^Z��ebrb\�bo�²�wlh�gZ^h�kdZaZlv�ykgh�²�gZmqghc�p_gghklb�Hgb�lZd`_�kdZaZebkv�hljbpZl_evgh�gZ�fgh]bo�_]h�debgbq_kdbo�ihkljh_gbyo�< \u\_^_gbb� keh`g_crbo� ijhp_kkh\� Zgljhih]_g_aZ� ba� hkh[_gghkl_c� [bheh]bq_kdh]hjZa\blby�q_eh\_dZ�yjdh�h[gZjm`beZkv�hkgh\gZy�q_jlZ�h[s_c�f_lh^heh]bb�Nj_c^Z��ihegh_��ihkms_kl\m��b]ghjbjh\Zgb_�khpbZevguo�fhf_glh\��hij_^_eyxsbo�w\hexpbx�dmevlmju�gZ�jZggboklZ^byo� __ jZa\blby�� G_m^b\bl_evgh� ihwlhfm�� qlh� dh]^Z� [ueb� ij_^ijbgylu� ihiuldbh[t_dlb\gh�ijh\_jblv�kms_kl\h\Zgb_�W^bih\Z�dhfie_dkZ��lZdb_�bkke_^h\Zgby�ijh\h^bebkv�gZ[hevrbo� klZlbklbq_kdbo� dhglbg]_glZo� _s_� \ ���o ]h^Zo�NZjj_ehf� � b ^j���� lh� bo� j_amevlZlhdZaZeky�iheghklvx�hl�)DUUHO <� 7KH�VWXG\�RI�SHUVRQDOLW\��1� <�� �����jbpZl_evguf�� AZ\bkbfhklv� wfhpbc� lbiZ�W^bih\Z� dhfie_dkZ� beb� dhfie_dkZ�We_dlju� hlk_f_cgh]h� ©debfZlZª�� hl� jZaghh[jZaguo� ikboheh]bq_kdbo� mklZgh\hd�� kdeZ^u\Zxsboky� \k_f_cguo� dhee_dlb\Zo�� hl� h[s_c� h[klZgh\db�� \ dhlhjhc� ijhbkoh^bl� \hkiblZgb_� j_[_gdZ�� hl_kl_kl\_ggh]h�ly]hl_gby�j_[_gdZ�d lhfm�ba�jh^bl_e_c��k dhlhjuf�m g_]h�mklZgZ\eb\Zxlky�[he__l_kgu_� ikboheh]bq_kdb_� dhglZdlu�� iheghklvx� i_j_dju\Z_l� \ebygb_� wlbo� dhfie_dkh\�� ^Z`__keb�^himkdZ_lky�]bihl_lbq_kdb�dZdh_�lh�bo�bkoh^gh_�kms_kl\h\Zgb_�?s_� [he__� ijhba\hevguf� y\behkv� ihklmebjh\Zggh_� Nj_c^hf� ij_^klZ\e_gb_� hkms_kl\h\Zgbb�dhgklZglguo�agZq_gbc��dhlhju_�bf_xl�y\eyxsb_ky�gZf�h[jZau�kgh\b^_gbc�Ebr_gZ� gZmqguo� hkgh\Zgbc� ihklmebjm_fZy� Nj_c^hf� kf_gZ� nZa� bgnZglbevghck_dkmZevghklb�� ?]h� Zglbbklhjbaf� \ ijbqm^eb\hc� nhjf_� ijhy\beky� \ ij_^klZ\e_gbb� h[hij_^_ey_fhklb� kh^_j`Zgbc� [_kkhagZl_evghx� ]bihl_lbq_kdbf� ©ijZyaudhfª�� h[sbf� \ k\hbohkgh\guo�we_f_glZo�jZaebqguf�gZjh^ghklyf��h^ghlbigh�ydh[u�\uklmiZxsbf�\ nhevdehj_�bfbnhl\hjq_kl\_�jZaebqguo�wlgbq_kdbo�]jmii�b hljZ`Zxsboky�\ [_kkhagZl_evghc�Zdlb\ghklbbg^b\b^h\��ijbgZ^e_`Zsbo�wlbf�]jmiiZf�AZ� ^he]b_� ]h^u�� ihke_^h\Z\rb_� ihke_� gZibkZgby� ©E_dpbcª�� gbdZdbo� nZdlh\�ih^l\_j`^Zxsbo� lZdmx� ljZdlh\dm�� h[gZjm`_gh� g_� [ueh��Fh`gh� m\_j_ggh� kdZaZlv�� qlh� _kebNj_c^� [ue� ljb`^u� ijZ\�� h[jZsZy� \gbfZgb_� gZ� kms_kl\mxsb_� \ ^mr_� q_eh\_dZg_hkhagZ\Z_fu_� \e_q_gby�� lh� _]h� ^hims_gb_� h [_kkhagZl_evghf� ©agZgbb� h[s_ijbgylh]hagZq_gby�kbf\heh\ª�hklZehkv�g_�[he__�q_f�nZglZab_c��g_�hdZaZ\r_c�\ ^Zevg_cr_f�\ebygby�gZgZmqgmx�fukev�^Z`_�kj_^b�l_o��dlh�jZa^_eye�b j_\ghklgh�ih^^_j`b\Ze�jZaghh[jZagu_�^jm]b_ihklmeZlu�ikbohZgZebaZ�< p_ehf�`_�deZkkbq_kdbc�ikbohZgZeba��dZd�hg�baeh`_g�\ ©E_dpbyoª��oZjZdl_jbam_lky�l_f�qlh� ]eZ\gh_� \gbfZgb_� ijb�g_f� h[jZsZ_lky�gZ� km[t_dlb\gh_� kh^_j`Zgb_� kbfilhfh\��DZ`^h_keh\h�[hevgh]h��dZ`^Zy�_]h�nZglZaby�b kgh\b^_gb_�ih^\_j]Zxlky�ZgZebam�k p_evx�jZkdjulby�bobagZqZevgh]h� kfukeZ��IZlh]_ggu_�\g_rgb_�ijbqbgu�ijb\h^yl� eb[h� d j_]j_kkm�� d [_]kl\m� hlj_Zevghc�`bagb� \ jZaghh[jZagu_�nZglZabb�� eb[h� d \u^\b`_gbx� gZ� Z\Zgkp_gm� \ul_kg_gguo

Page 369: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

i_j_`b\Zgbc�� bgnZglbevguo� l_g^_gpbc�� Bae_q_gb_� `_�� ih� ij_^klZ\e_gbyf� deZkkbq_kdh]hikbohZgZebaZ��gZklmiZ_l��dh]^Z�\ul_kg_ggu_�i_j_`b\Zgby�^h\h^ylky�^h�bo�ihegh]h�khagZgby�MkljZg_gb_�\ul_kg_gby�²�wlh��ih�Nj_c^m��]eZ\guc�rZ]�\ mkljZg_gbb�g_\jhaZ�D wlhfm� aZdexqbl_evghfm� ©Zddhj^mª� ikbohZgZebaZ� fu� _s_� \_jg_fky�� Im[ebdZpby©E_dpbc� ih� \\_^_gbx� \ ikbohZgZebaª� ijb\e_deZ� \ k\h_� \j_fy�rbjhdh_� \gbfZgb_� \ k\yab� kijh[e_fhc� \h_gguo� g_\jhah\�� < ����� ]�� \ ;moZj_kl_� kh[jZeky� ki_pbZevguc� dhg]j_kk�ihk\ys_gguc� wlhc� ijh[e_f_�� Ih^� \i_qZle_gb_f� kh[ulbc� i_j\hc� fbjh\hc� \hcgu�[_kkfuke_ggh� mg_kr_c� fbeebhgu� `bag_c�� Nj_c^�� ijbh[j_lrbc� d lhfm� \j_f_gb� fbjh\mxkeZ\m��im[ebdm_l�jZ[hlm�©Ih�lm�klhjhgm�ijbgpbiZ�m^h\hevkl\byª���������\ dhlhjhc�aZ\_jrZ_lbaeh`_gb_� b^_c� k\h_c� ©f_lZikboheh]bbª� ²� lZd� hg� gZa\Ze� kbkl_fm� hibkZgby� ikbobq_kdhc`bagb� k ^bgZfbq_kdhc� �k lhqdb� aj_gby� dhgnebdlh\� \e_q_gbc��� lhih]jZnbq_kdhc� �mjh\gb[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��ij_^khagZl_evgh]h�b khagZgby��b ©wdhghfbq_kdhcª� �ijbgpbi�m^h\hevkl\by�lhq_d�aj_gby�Baf_g_gby��\g_k_ggu_�Nj_c^hf�\ ij_`gbc�\ZjbZgl�ikbohZgZebaZ��aZdexqZebkv�\ lhf��qlhd ij_`g_fm�k\_^_gbx�\k_o�\e_q_gbc�d k_dkmZevghfm��eb[b^h��ijbkh_^bgyeky�hkh[uc�bgklbgdl�gZa\Zgguc�©bgklbgdlhf�kf_jlbª�²�LZgZlhkhf��Ih^�gbf�ihgbfZehkv�klj_fe_gb_�hj]ZgbafZ�dlhfm�� qlh[u� \ha\jZlblvky� \ [_a`bag_ggh_� khklhygb_�� klZlv� g_h^mr_\e_gghc� fZl_jb_c�Kms_kl\h\Zgb_�bg^b\b^Z�²�wlh�dhfijhfbkk�f_`^m�^\mfy�]eZ\gufb�bgklbgdlZfb�²�Wjhkhf�bLZgZlhkhf�� ijbq_f� ij_\Zebjm_l� \lhjhc�� ihemqZxsbc� \ujZ`_gb_� \ ZdlZo� Z]j_kkbb�� dhlhjZyfh`_l� [ulv� gZijZ\e_gZ� dZd� gZ� ^jm]bo�� lZd� b gZ� kZfh]h� km[t_dlZ�� Wlhl� \a]ey^�Nj_c^Z� [uebkihevah\Zg� klhjhggbdZfb� \_jkbb� h g_ba[_`ghklb� \hcg�� h lhf�� qlh� bo� ijbqbgu� djhxlky� \kZfhc�[bheh]bq_kdhc�ijbjh^_�q_eh\_dZ�>jm]hc�rZ]�Nj_c^Z� gZ� imlb� ij_h[jZah\Zgby� bkoh^ghc� ko_fu� ikbohZgZebaZ� aZi_qZle_eZgh\Zy� ljZdlh\dZ� kljmdlmju� q_eh\_q_kdhc� ebqghklb�� WlZ� gh\Zy� ljZdlh\dZ�� \i_j\u_ij_^klZ\e_ggZy� \ �dgb]_� ©Y b�Hghª� �������� baeh`_gZ� \ ���c e_dpbb�� ]^_� ^_lZebabjh\Zgu� bdhgdj_lbabjh\Zgu�hkgh\gu_�iheh`_gby�mdZaZgghc�dgb]b��?keb�ij_`^_�ikbohZgZeba�bkoh^be�balj_o� mjh\g_c� hj]ZgbaZpbb� ikbobq_kdhc� `bagb� ²� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� ij_^�khagZl_evgh]h� bkhagZl_evgh]h�²�lh�l_i_jv�wlZ�hj]ZgbaZpby�\uklmibeZ�\ \b^_�bghc�fh^_eb��bf_xs_c�k\hbfbdhfihg_glZfb�jZaebqgu_�ikbobq_kdb_�bgklZgpbb��h[hagZq_ggu_�l_jfbgZfb��B^��W]h�b Kmi_j�w]h�� Ih^� B^� �beb� Hgh�� ihgbfZeZkv� gZb[he__� ijbfblb\gZy� qZklv� q_eh\_q_kdhc� ebqghklb�dhlhjZy� ho\Zlu\Z_l� \k_� ijbjh`^_ggh_�� ]_g_lbq_kdb� i_j\bqgh_�� ih^qbg_ggh_� ijbgpbimm^h\hevkl\by�b gbq_]h�g_�agZxs__�gb h�j_Zevghklb��gb h[�h[s_kl\_��WlZ�bgklZgpby�g_�ijbagZ_lgbdZdbo� dhgnebdlh\� b ijhlb\hj_qbc�� HgZ� bagZqZevgh� bjjZpbhgZevgZ� b ZfhjZevgZ�� ?_lj_[h\Zgbyf�\ugm`^_gZ�kem`blv�^jm]Zy�bgklZgpby�²�Y �beb�W]h���<f_kl_�k l_f�W]h�ke_^m_lijbgpbim� j_Zevghklb� b \ujZ[Zlu\Z_l� jy^� f_oZgbafh\�� iha\heyxsbo� Z^Zilbjh\Zlvky� dlj_[h\Zgbyf�kj_^u��W]h�²�ihkj_^gbd�f_`^m�klbfmeZfb��b^msbfb�dZd�ba�wlhc�kj_^u��lZd�b ba]em[bg� hj]ZgbafZ�²� k h^ghc� klhjhgu�� hl\_lgufb� ^\b]Zl_evgufb� j_Zdpbyfb�²� k ^jm]hc��Dnmgdpbyf�W]h�hlghkblky�kZfhkhojZg_gb_�hj]ZgbafZ��aZi_qZle_gb_�hiulZ�\g_rgbo�\ha^_ckl\bc\ iZfylb�� ba[_]Zgb_� m]jh`Zxsbo� \ebygbc�� dhgljhev� gZ^� lj_[h\Zgbyfb� bgklbgdlh\�bkoh^ysbfb�hl�B^������������ �Hkh[h_� agZq_gb_� [ueh� ijb^Zgh� Kmi_j�w]h�� dhlhjh_� kem`bl� bklhqgbdhf� fhjZevguo� b

Page 370: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

j_eb]bhaguo� qm\kl\�� dhgljhebjmxsbf� b gZdZamxsbf� Z]_glhf�� ?keb� B^� \ujZklZ_l� bagZke_^kl\_ggh]h� hiulZ�� Z W]h� ²� bg^b\b^mZevgh]h�� lh� Kmi_j�w]h� ²� ijh^mdl� \ebygbc�bkoh^ysbo�hl�^jm]bo�ex^_c� �jh^bl_e_c�b hdjm`Zxs_c� khpbZevghc� kj_^u���Hgh� \hagbdZ_l� \jZgg_f�^_lkl\_� �k\yaZgh��kh]eZkgh�Nj_c^m�� k W^bih\uf�dhfie_dkhf��b hklZ_lky�ijZdlbq_kdbg_baf_gguf� \ ihke_^mxsb_� ]h^u�� Hgh� h[jZam_lky� [eZ]h^Zjy� f_oZgbafm� b^_glbnbdZpbb� khlphf�� dhlhjuc� kem`bl� fh^_evx� ^ey� j_[_gdZ�� ?keb� W]h� ijbf_l� j_r_gb_� beb� kh\_jrbl^_ckl\b_� \ m]h^m�B^�� gh� \ ijhlb\h\_k� Kmi_j�w]h�� hgh� bkiulu\Z_l� gZdZaZgb_� \ \b^_� mdhjh\kh\_klb�� qm\kl\Z� \bgu�� Ihkdhevdm� Kmi_j�w]h� q_jiZ_l� wg_j]bx� m B^�� hgh� qZklh� ^_ckl\m_l`_klhdh�GZ�wlhf�gh\hf�wlZi_�w\hexpbb�ikbohZgZebaZ�Nj_c^�h[tykgye�qm\kl\h�\bgm�m g_\jhlbdh\\ebygb_f�Kmi_j�w]h��LZdhc�ih^oh^�hij_^_ebe�[hevrh_�f_klh�\ ikbohZgZeba_��dhlhjh_�aZgyehh[tykg_gb_� n_ghf_gZ� lj_\h`ghklb�� DZd� \b^gh� ba� kh^_j`Zgby� ©Ijh^he`_gby� e_dpbcª�jZaebqZebkv� ljb� \b^Z� lj_\h`ghklb�� gZjy^m� k \ua\Zgghc� j_Zevghklvx� \u^_eyebkv� lj_\h]b�h[mkeh\e_ggu_� ^Z\e_gb_f� kh� klhjhgu� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� B^� b kh� klhjhgu� Kmi_j�w]h�Khhl\_lkl\_ggh�aZ^ZqZ�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc�ijhp_^mju�mkfZljb\ZeZkv�\ lhf��qlh[u�hk\h[h^blvW]h�hl�jZaebqguo�nhjf�^Z\e_gby�gZ�g_]h�b m\_ebqblv�_]h�kbem��Hl�gZijy`_gbc��bkiulu\Z_fuoW]h� ih^� ^Z\e_gb_f� jZaebqguo� kbe�� hgh� kiZkZ_lky� k ihfhsvx� ©aZsblguo� f_oZgbafh\ª� ²\ul_kg_gby��j_]j_kkbb��km[ebfZpbb��<ul_kg_gb_�hagZqZ_l�Zdlb\gh_��gh�g_�hkhagZ\Z_fh_�kZfbfbg^b\b^hf�mkljZg_gb_�ba�khagZgby�qm\kl\��fuke_c�b klj_fe_gbc�d ^_ckl\bx��I_j_f_sZykv�\h[eZklv� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� hgb� ijh^he`Zxl�fhlb\bjh\Zlv� ih\_^_gb_�� hdZau\Zxl� gZ� g_]h� ^Z\e_gb_�� i_j_`b\Zxlky� \ iZlheh]bq_kdbo� �g_\jhlbq_kdbo�� kbfilhfZo� b l�� ^�� J_]j_kkby� ²khkdZevau\Zgb_�gZ�[he__�ijbfblb\guc�mjh\_gv�ih\_^_gby�b fure_gby��Km[ebfZpby�²�h^bgba� f_oZgbafh\�� ihkj_^kl\hf� dhlhjuo� aZij_lgZy� k_dkmZevgZy� wg_j]by� jZajy`Z_lky� \ nhjf_^_yl_evghklb�� ijb_fe_fhc� ^ey� bg^b\b^Z� b h[s_kl\Z�� JZagh\b^ghklvx� km[ebfZpbb� y\ey_lkyl\hjq_kl\h�WlZ� fh^_ev� ebqghklb� ij_^iheZ]ZeZ� fgh]hieZgh\hklv� fhlb\Zpbhgguo� kljmdlmjq_eh\_q_kdh]h� ih\_^_gby�� ij_^klZ\e_gghklv� \ wlbo� kljmdlmjZo� [bheh]bq_kdh]h� �B^��bg^b\b^mZevgh�ebqghklgh]h��W]h��b khpbZevgh]h��Kmi_j�w]h��mjh\g_c�hj]ZgbaZpbb��H^gZdh�\k_mdZaZggu_�dhfihg_glu�\uklmiZeb�\ fbklbnbpbjh\Zgghc�nhjf_�²�[bheh]bq_kdh_�k\h^behkv�dwg_j]bb�eb[b^h��khpbZevgh_�²�d k_dkmZevghc�gZijZ\e_gghklb�j_[_gdZ��Z ©[_^ghfm�W]hª��dZdgZau\Ze� _]h� Nj_c^�� hklZ\Zehkv� ebrv� g_ij_ju\gh� kh]eZkh\u\Zlv� lj_[h\Zgby�� \eZklghij_^ty\ey_fu_�k lj_o�klhjhg��j_Zevghklvx��[_kkhagZl_evguf�b Kmi_j�w]h�<f_kl_� k l_f� ke_^m_l� h[jZlblv� \gbfZgb_� gZ� lh�� qlh� Nj_c^� \ ���o ]h^Zo� i_j_r_e� dljZdlh\d_� khagZgby� dZd� k\h_]h� jh^Z� kbkl_fu�� klj_fys_cky� d kZfhkhojZg_gbx��IkbohZgZebahl\_j]�g_�lhevdh�hlh`^_kl\e_gb_�ikbobdb�k khagZgb_f��gh�b _s_�g_�mljZlb\rbc�\ lhl�i_jbh^ihimeyjghklb� \a]ey^� gZ� khagZgb_� dZd� gZ� ihlhd� fuke_c� b i_j_`b\Zgbc�� KhagZgb_� `b\_l�[hj_lky��ijhlb\h^_ckl\m_l�g_kh\f_klbfuf�k ©\e_q_gbyfb�Yª�kbeZf��>hdZau\Zehkv��qlh�jZ[hlZkhagZgby� g_� k\h^blky� d \gmlj_gg_fm� \hkijbylbx� kh^_j`Zgbc�� qlh� hgZ�`bag_ggh� \Z`gZ� ^eykhojZg_gby� q_eh\_q_kdh]h� Y�� dhlhjh_� Nj_c^� \ hlebqb_� hl� k\hbo� ij_`gbo� \haaj_gbcij_^klZ\eye� l_i_jv� \ dZq_kl\_� hkh[hc� bgklZgpbb� �ih^kbkl_fu� ebqghklb��� j_rZxs_ckh[kl\_ggu_�aZ^Zqb�

Page 371: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

H^gZdh� wg_j]_lbq_kdbc� Zki_dl� ikbobq_kdhc� ^_yl_evghklb� ihemqbe� m g_]h� g_Z^_d\Zlgmxbgl_jij_lZpbx�� ihkdhevdm� ]eZ\ghc� fhlb\Zpbhgghc� kbehc� ijbagZ\ZeZkv� kn_jZ[_kkhagZl_evgh]h� �bgklbgdlh\��B^���Ghkbl_ev� agZgby� h \g_rg_c� kj_^_�²� khagZgb_�� kh]eZkghNj_c^m�� kZfh� ih� k_[_� [_kkbevgh�� <ky� _]h� wg_j]by� q_jiZ_lky� \ dhg_qghf� kq_l_� ba� ]em[bg[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� J_Zevgu_� hkh[_gghklb� fhlb\Zpbb� kms_kl\mxl� g_aZ\bkbfh� hl� lh]h�� dZdh_hlh[jZ`_gb_�\ khagZgbb�hgb�ihemqZxl��=em[hdhc�hrb[dhcNj_c^Z� y\eyehkv� m[_`^_gb_�� [m^lh� ijh_dpby� \ khagZgbb� fhlb\Zpbhgguo� klj_fe_gbcebqghklb�ghkbl�beexahjguc�oZjZdl_j��Gh�jZpbhgZevguc�fhf_gl�kh^_j`ZeZ�b^_y�h lhf��qlh�^eygZmqgh]h� h[tykg_gby� ^bgZfbdb� fhlb\h\� g_^hklZlhqgh� k\b^_l_evkl\� kZfhgZ[ex^_gby�� Bog_^hklZlhqgh�g_�lhevdh�^ey�jZkdjulby�ijbjh^u�fhlb\h\��g_�aZljZ]b\Zxsbo�y^jh�ebqghklb��__Y�� gh� b ^ey� ihgbfZgby� wlh]h� Y dZd� hkh[hc� kbkl_fu�� ^ey� dhlhjhc� h^gb� fhlb\u� y\eyxlkyp_gljZevgufb��^jm]b_�²�i_jbn_jbcgufb�Iheh`_gb_�h g_b^_glbqghklb�khagZgby�b Y��keh`b\r__ky�m Nj_c^Z�\ ���o ]h^Zo��ihemqbehjZa\blb_� \ ©Ijh^he`_gbb� e_dpbcª�� ]^_� baeh`_g� gh\uc� ih^oh^� d ijh[e_f_� kljh_gbyq_eh\_q_kdhc� ebqghklb�� mjh\gyf� __ hj]ZgbaZpbb� b oZjZdl_jm� hlghr_gbc� f_`^m� wlbfbmjh\gyfb��G_\jha� jZkkfZljb\Z_lky� dZd� j_amevlZl� hkeZ[e_gby� kbeu� W]h� ba�aZ� bgl_gkb\ghklb^Z\e_gby� gZ� g_]h� kh� klhjhgu�B^�� jZkk_b\Zgb_� wg_j]bb� gZ� ijhlb\h^_ckl\b_� wlhfm� ^Z\e_gbx�©ZglbdZl_dkbkª���>jm]hc� bklhqgbd� g_\jhaZ²dhgnebdl�f_`^m�W]h� b Kmi_j�w]h� �\ kblmZpbb�dh]^Z�Y khijhlb\ey_lky�fhjZevguf�aZij_lZf�b lj_[h\Zgbyf�����H;�HP?GD?�B>?C�NJ?C>:�G:�A:I:>?�I:J:>HDK�DHGLJ:KLH<DZdh_� hlghr_gb_� \ua\Zeb� d k_[_� b^_b� ��� Nj_c^Z"� Dh]^Z� [m^msbc� bklhjbd� dmevlmjuaZ^mfZ_lky�gZ^�mfkl\_gghc�`bagvx�gZr_]h�[mjgh]h�\_dZ��hg��[_amkeh\gh��\u^_ebl�dhgp_ipbxikbohZgZebaZ� dZd� y\e_gb_� hkh[h]h� ihjy^dZ�� ihgylv� kms_kl\h� b km^v[m� dhlhjh]h� g_e_]dh�Hkgh\Zgb_f� ^ey� lZdhc� hp_gdb� y\blky� ^ey� g_]h� ij_`^_� \k_]h� [_kij_p_^_glgh_� jZkoh`^_gb_fg_gbc�ih�\hijhkm�h[�hlghr_gbyo�d ikbohZgZebam��ijhy\b\r__ky�ih�jZaguf�ih\h^Zf�\ jZaguokljZgZo��Fh`gh� m\_j_ggh� kdZaZlv�� qlh� gb h^gh� ba� [hevrbo� mfkl\_gguo� l_q_gbc� \ h[eZklbh[s_c� b debgbq_kdhc� ikboheh]bb�� ikbohl_jZibb�� ikbobZljbb� g_� \uau\Zeh� klhev� jZaguo�\aZbfhbkdexqZxsbo� km`^_gbc�� g_� kha^Z\Zeh� lZdhc� jZagh]hehkbpu� \ hp_gdZo�� lZdhch`_klhq_gghklb�\ kihjZo��dZd�b^_b��ijh\ha]eZr_ggu_�gZ�aZj_�gZr_]h�\_dZ_�Nj_c^hf�K h^ghc� klhjhgu�� kms_kl\mxl� \ aZiZ^gh_\jhi_ckdhc� b Zf_jbdZgkdh_� i_qZlbfgh]hqbke_ggu_� mdZaZgby� gZ� lh�� qlh� b^_b�Nj_c^Z� ih� ]em[bg_� \ebygby�� hdZaZggh]h� bfb� gZikboheh]bx� aZiZ^gh]h� q_eh\_dZ�� fh]ml� [ulv� ijbjZ\g_gu� d b^_yf� Dhi_jgbdZ�� >Zj\bgZ�Wcgrl_cgZ��qlh�[hevrZy�qZklv�kha^Z\Z_fuo�\ gZrb�^gb�gZ�AZiZ^_�ijhba\_^_gbc�ikboheh]bb�nbehkhnbb� b bkdmkkl\Z� g_k_l� gZ� k_[_� \ lhc� beb� bghc� kl_i_gb� hli_qZlhd� nj_c^bafZ� �>�He^jb^`��� qlh� ljZ^bpbhggu_� ko_fu� ikbohZgZebaZ� gZklhevdh� ijhgbdeb� \ ©djh\vª� aZiZ^ghcdmevlmju�� qlh� __ ij_^klZ\bl_eyf� agZqbl_evgh� e_]q_� fukeblv� bfb�� q_f� b]ghjbjh\Zlv� bo� �K�P\_c]��b l��^�

Page 372: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

K ^jm]hc�`_�klhjhgu��hklZ_lky�nZdlhf��qlh�\ kZfuo�jZaguo�kljZgZo�mq_gu_�i_j\h]h�jZg]Zj_adh�ihjbpZeb�b ihjbpZxl�nj_c^baf��ih^\_j]Zy�djblbd_��Z bgh]^Z�b iheghklvx�hl\_j]Zy�_]hkhpbheh]bq_kdb_�b f_^bpbgkdb_�hkgh\u�DZd� `_� fh`gh� h[tykgblv� lZdh_� jZaebqb_� ih^oh^h\�� khijh\h`^Z_fh_� d lhfm� `_g_h[udgh\_gghc�kljZklghklvx�\uau\Z_fuo�bf�kihjh\"<ur_� m`_� [ueh� mdZaZgh� gZ� g_dhlhju_� ba� h[klhyl_evkl\�� kihkh[kl\h\Z\rbo� rbjhdhfmiheh`bl_evghfm� hldebdm� gZ� b^_b� Nj_c^Z�� H^gbf� ba� gbo� y\beky�� g_khfg_ggh�� hq_gvk\h_h[jZaguc� oZjZdl_j� \hijhkh\�� ih^gyluo�Nj_c^hf��`bag_gghklv� b ijZdlbq_kdZy� \Z`ghklvdhlhjuo� \u]h^gh� dhgljZklbjh\Zeb� kh�fgh]bfb� gZijZ\e_gbyfb� \ bkke_^h\Zgbyo� ih\_^_gby�bkhagZgby�G_hkihjbfh��qlh�nj_c^baf�y\beky�h^ghc�ba�i_j\uo�dhgp_ipbc��gZklhcqb\h�iulZ\rbokyjZah[jZlvky� \ ijh[e_f_� kdjuluo� fhlb\h\� ih\_^_gby� q_eh\_dZ� b \� jheb� wlh]h� nZdlhjZ� \debgbd_�� Bf� [ueh� ijb\e_q_gh� \gbfZgb_� d keh`ghklb� \gmlj_gg_]h� fbjZ� q_eh\_dZ�� dihke_^kl\byf�g_m^h\e_l\hj_gguo�\e_q_gbc��d ijhlb\hj_qbyf�f_`^m�`_eZ_fuf�b ^he`guf��Hgh[jZlbeky�\ wlhc� k\yab�d `bagb�\h�\k_c� __ j_Zevghklb��d __�jZ^hklyf�b i_qZeyf�� lj_\h]Zf�bklj_fe_gbyf��h[_sZy�ihfhsv�\ mkeh\byo�^mr_\gh]h�gZ^ehfZ�b lj_[my�^ey� wlh]h�\k_]h�ebrvgZ\_^_gby�hij_^_e_ggh]h�©ihjy^dZª�\ ^mr_��B ^he]h_�\j_fy�_]h�b^_b�\hkijbgbfZebkv�fgh]bfbdZd� _^bgkl\_ggh� kihkh[gu_� hk\_lblv� \k_� wlb� `bag_ggu_� \hijhku�� dhlhju_� gbdh]^Z� g_i_j_klZ\Zeb� \hegh\Zlv� ex^_c�� Nj_c^baf� r_e� l_f� kZfuf�� ih� djZcg_c� f_j_� ih� \b^bfhklb�gZ\klj_qm�]em[hdbf�^mr_\guf�aZijhkZf�fgh]bo��Ke_^m_l�eb�m^b\eylvky��qlh�iheh`bl_evgucj_ahgZgk�� dhlhjuc� ihemqbeb� \ hij_^_e_gguo� khpbZevguo� djm]Zo� _]h� b^_b�� hdZaZeky� lZdbfrbjhdbf"�B \� lh�`_� \j_fy� \ b^_yo�Nj_c^Z� kh^_j`Zebkv� \gmlj_ggb_�ijhlb\hj_qby�� dhlhju_hq_gv� hkeh`gbeb� hlghr_gb_� d l_hjbb� ikbohZgZebaZ� ^Z`_� kh� klhjhgu� l_o�� dlh� \uklmiZe� gZjZggbo�wlZiZo�nhjfbjh\Zgby�wlhc�l_hjbb�\ dZq_kl\_�__�kljZklguo�Z^_ilh\�Ihke_� \lhjhc� fbjh\hc� \hcgu� ikbohZgZeba� \ _]h� gh\_crbo� \ZjbZpbyo� ijh^he`Z_lhklZ\Zlvky� \ aZiZ^guo� kljZgZo� h^gbf� ba� gZb[he__� jZkijhkljZg_gguo� l_q_gbc� \ ikboheh]bb�ikbohl_jZibb�b nbehkhnbb��Hg�]em[hdh�ijhgbdZ_l�\ om^h`_kl\_ggmx�ebl_jZlmjm��\ bkdmkkl\h�\ dbgh�� _]h� \ebygb_� kh� \k_� [hevr_c� hlq_leb\hklvx� ijhy\ey_lky� \ lZd� gZau\Z_fhcikbohkhfZlbq_kdhc� f_^bpbg_�� Nj_c^baf� ihkl_i_ggh� ^h[b\Z_lky� ijbagZgby� ^Z`_� \dZlhebq_kdbo�j_eb]bhaguo�djm]Zo��wlh�hkh[_ggh�yjdh�ijhy\behkv�gZ�kh\_sZgbb�dZlhebq_kdbo^_yl_e_c�\ukr_]h�jZg]Z��ijhbkoh^b\r_f�\ �����]��\ <ZlbdZg_��\ k\yab�k ihiuldhc�_ibkdhiZ�J�I��=j_]mZjZ�e_]Zebah\Zlv�bkihevah\Zgb_�ikbohZgZebaZ�\ fhgZklujyo�B \�lh�`_�\j_fy�g_mdehggh�gZjZklZ_l�\hegZ�djblbq_kdh]h�hlghr_gby�d ikbohZgZebam��WlZdjblbdZ�\uklmiZ_l�\ jZaguo�nhjfZo��Bgh]^Z�hgZ�ghkbl�h]jZgbq_gguc�oZjZdl_j��ijbau\Zy�g_klhevdh�d iheghfm� hldehg_gbx�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�gZijZ\e_gby�� kdhevdh� d dhfijhfbkkm� kgbf�� d ijbgylbx� hl^_evguo� _]h� iheh`_gbc� �ij_`^_� \k_]h� _]h� l_hjbb� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h��Bgh]^Z� `_� __� ijh\h^yl� j_rbl_evgh� b g_ijbfbjbfh�� klZ\y� Zdp_glu� gZ� gZmqghcg_khklhyl_evghklb�ikbohZgZebaZ�b gZ�_]h�l_jZi_\lbq_kdhc�g_wnn_dlb\ghklb�Hkh[uc�bgl_j_k�ij_^klZ\eyxl�jZ[hlu��\ dhlhjuo�h[km`^_gb_�\hijhkZ�h l_jZi_\lbq_kdhcp_gghklb�ikbohZgZebaZ�ijhba\h^blky�gZ�hkgh\_�bamq_gby�hlghkbl_evgh�djmiguo�debgbq_kdbo

Page 373: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

dhglbg]_glh\�� Ba� wlbo� jZ[hl� \ul_dZ_l�� qlh� [eZ]hijbylgu_� bkoh^u�� gZ[ex^Z_fu_� ijbikbohZgZeblbq_kdhf� e_q_gbb�� k\yaZgu� [hevr_c� qZklvx� kh� kihglZgguf� \ua^hjh\e_gb_f�� kihke_^kl\byfb� baf_g_gby� khpbZevguo� mkeh\bc�� k g_aZf_lgh� \djZ^u\Zxsbfbky� \ikbohZgZeblbq_kdmx� ijhp_^mjm� we_f_glZfb� km]]_klbb� b k� jZaghh[jZagufb� ^jm]bfbnZdlhjZfb��qm`^ufb�ih�k\h_c�ijbjh^_�wlhc�ijhp_^mj_��K\yav�`_�\ua^hjh\e_gby�k kms_kl\hfikbohZgZeblbq_kdh]h�e_q_gby�hklZ_lky�\h�fgh]bo�kemqZyo�g_^hklZlhqgh�ykghc�Ijh\_jdZ� ihdZaZeZ�� qlh� h[t_dlb\guo� ijbagZdh\� kms_kl\h\Zgby� W^bih\Z� dhfie_dkZ�b]jZxs_]h�klhev�[hevrmx�jhev�\ kbkl_f_�\haaj_gbc�Nj_c^Z��Z lZd`_�^jm]bo�ihklmebjm_fuonj_c^bafhf� hkh[_gghkl_c� bgnZglbevghc� k_dkmZevghklb� g_� m^Z_lky� h[gZjm`b\Zlv� magZqbl_evgh]h�dhebq_kl\Z�^_l_c�^Z`_�ijb�kZfhf�lsZl_evghf�ikboheh]bq_kdhf�bkke_^h\Zgbb�?klv�ihwlhfm�hkgh\Zgby�iheZ]Zlv��qlh�\ hkgh\m�ij_^klZ\e_gby�h[�W^bih\hf�dhfie_dk_�dZd�h[h[yaZl_evghf�dhfihg_gl_�bgnZglbevghc�ikbobdb�gZ�hij_^_e_gghf�wlZi_�hglh]_g_aZ�Nj_c^hf[ueb� iheh`_gu� hkh[_gghklb� ^_lkdhc� k_dkmZevghklb�� kdhj__� oZjZdl_jgu_� ^ey� dZdbo�lhhl^_evguo�� k\h_h[jZaguo� debgbq_kdbo� kemqZ_\� beb�� \hafh`gh�� ^ey� gjZ\h\� hij_^_e_gghckhpbZevghc� kj_^u�� : _keb� wlh� lZd�� lh� g_\hevgh� \hagbdZ_l� fukev�� dZd� e_]dh� ^_eZe� Nj_c^rbjhdb_�\u\h^u�ba�wdkd\bablguo�debgbq_kdbo�nZdlh\�b gZkdhevdh�i_j_hp_gb\Zehkv�bkoh^gufikbohZgZeblbq_kdbf� gZijZ\e_gb_f� agZq_gb_� Zijbhjgh� ihklmebjh\Zgguo� [bheh]bq_kdbonZdlhjh\� \ ms_j[� \ebygbyf�� dhlhju_� fh]ml� hdZau\Zlv� gZ� k_dkmZevgh_� jZa\blb_� j_[_gdZkemqZcgu_�hkh[_gghklb�hdjm`Zxs_c�h[klZgh\db�b \hkiblZgby�B \f_kl_�k l_f�gZb[he__�lbibqghc�^ey�aZiZ^guo�bkke_^h\Zl_e_c�Z ihke_\h_gguc�i_jbh^y\ey_lky� ihabpby� g_� h]mevgh]h� hldehg_gby� ij_^klZ\e_gbc� ikbohZgZebaZ�� Z kdhj__� boqZklbqgh]h�ijbgylby��ihabpby�ihbkdZ�jZaebqguo�nhjf�dhfijhfbkkZ�k gbfb��LZdh_�hlghr_gb_[ueh� oZjZdl_jgh� ^ey� bkke_^h\Zl_e_c�� dhlhju_�� g_� ijb_fey� nj_c^baf� dZd� aZdhgq_ggmxnbehkhnkdh�ikboheh]bq_kdmx�kbkl_fm��iheZ]Zeb�\f_kl_�k l_f��qlh�\ g_f�kdjulh�jZpbhgZevgh_y^jh� b qlh� _]h� iheh`bl_evgu_� we_f_glu� fh]ml� [ulv� [_a� ijhlb\hj_qbc� k\yaZgu� k ^jm]bfbl_hjbyfb�� hk\_sZxsbfb� jZ[hlm� fha]Z� b khagZgby�� P_gljZevguf� Zj]mf_glhf�� dhlhjuc\u^\b]Zeky�\ ihevam�lZdh]h�ihgbfZgby��y\eyehkv�h[uqgh�lh��qlh�f_lh^�Nj_c^Z�²�wlh�\Z`gucimlv� d jZkdjulbx� ijbjh^u� kdjuluo� ^mr_\guo� ^\b`_gbc�� ijbjh^u� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� b qlhihwlhfm�� dZdbfb�[u�g_^hklZldZfb� hg�gb h[eZ^Ze�� d dZdbf� [u� l_hj_lbq_kdbf� ljm^ghklyf� gbijb\h^be��_]h�hl\_j]Zlv�g_evay�LZdh\h� fg_gb_� G�� <bg_jZ�� \u^Zxs_]hky� dZgZ^kdh]h� g_cjhobjmj]Z� <�� I_gnbe^Z� b ^j�GZjy^m� k fgh]hqbke_ggufb� jZ[hlZfb� ikboheh]bq_kdh]h�� debgbq_kdh]h� b db[_jg_lbq_kdh]hieZgZ�� ]^_� \ukdZau\Zxlky� khh[jZ`_gby� h `_eZl_evghklb� dhfijhfbkkZ�f_`^m�nj_c^bafhf� b^jm]bfb� gZijZ\e_gbyfb�� gZ� AZiZ^_� a\mqZl� hkljhdjblbq_kdb_� ]hehkZ�� Ih� fg_gbx� \_kvfZZ\lhjbl_lgh]h� njZgpmakdh]h� ikbobZljZ� :�� ;ZjxdZ�� ©k f_^bpbgkdhc� lhqdb� aj_gby^h]fZlbq_kdb_� mklZgh\db� g_dhlhjuo� ikbohZgZeblbdh\� b ikbohkhfZlbdh\�fh]ml� ij_^klZ\eylvbgh]^Z� ih^ebggmx� hiZkghklvª� �� ;Zjxd� ijbagZ_l�� qlh� b^_b� Nj_c^Z� gZeh`beb� ]em[hdbchli_qZlhd�gZ�ikb� �%DUDN G� (QWUHWLRQ�GH�%LFKDW��3�������� J� ��obZljbx��f_^bpbgm��nbehkhnbx�b \kx�bgl_ee_dlmZevgmx�`bagv�kh\j_f_ggh]h�h[s_kl\Z�

Page 374: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

Gh�\ q_f�wlh�\ebygb_�ij_`^_�\k_]h�kdZaZehkv"�JZkijhkljZg_gb_�b^_c�Nj_c^Z�bf_eh��ih�fg_gbx;ZjxdZ��ebrv�hljbpZl_evgu_�khpbZevgu_�ihke_^kl\by���;Zjxd� hklZgZ\eb\Z_lky� ^Ze__� b gZ� ikboheh]bq_kdhf� ZgZeba_� kZfhc� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhcijhp_^mju�� ;hevghc� qm\kl\m_l� k_[y� \ mkeh\byo� wlhc� ijhp_^mju� iZkkb\guf�� jZkkeZ[e_gguf�gZoh^ysbfky�\h�\eZklb�qm`hc�\heb��gZkbevkl\_ggh�ijhgbdZxs_c�\ ]em[bgu�_]h�ikbobdb��: \j_amevlZl_� ijh^he`bl_evgh]h� ijbf_g_gby� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdbo� ijb_fh\� e_q_gby� �^eysbokybgh]^Z� fgh]b_� f_kypu�� _keb� g_� ]h^u�� \hagbdZ_l� jbkd� ihkl_i_ggh]h� ihgb`_gbyikboheh]bq_kdhc� khijhlb\ey_fhklb� [hevgh]h�� _]h� nbdkbjh\Zgghklb� gZ� bglbfguoi_j_`b\Zgbyo� b _]h� ij_\jZs_gby� \ ebqghklv�� fZehkihkh[gmx� d Zdlb\ghfm� ij_h^he_gbxljm^ghkl_c� `bagb�� l_jiysmx� nbZkdh� ijb� i_j\hf� `_� khijbdhkgh\_gbb� kh� kdhevdh�gb[m^v]jm[hc� ^_ckl\bl_evghklvx�� Kebrdhf� \ukhdh_� Znn_dlb\gh_� gZijy`_gb_�� aZf_qZ_l� ;Zjxd�[_kkihjgh� fh`_l� ijb\_klb� d g_\jham�� gh� g_� f_gvrb_� hiZkghklb� lZbl� \ k_[_� b qj_af_jgh_Znn_dlb\gh_�jZkkeZ[e_gb_��b g_ba\_klgh��dZdmx�ba�wlbo�djZcghkl_c�\u]h^gh�ij_^ihq_klv�;Zjxd�\b^bl�hljbpZl_evgu_�q_jlu�ikbohZgZebaZ�b \�lhf��qlh�ihke_^gbc�qZklh�k\yau\Z_l]_g_a� g_\jhaZ� k hkh[_gghklyfb� k_f_cghc�`bagb� [hevgh]h� b ihwlhfm� g_j_^dh� gZ� wlhc�`bagbhljbpZl_evgh� kdZau\Z_lky�� < p_ehf� `_� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdZy� dhgp_ipby� ²� wlh�� ih� ;Zjxdm�©kdhj__� j_eb]by�� q_f� gZmdZª�� j_eb]by�� bf_xsZy� k\hb� ^h]fu�� k\hb� jblmZeu� b k\hxhjb]bgZevgmx�kbkl_fm�g_dhgljhebjm_fuo�bklhedh\Zgbc�G_[_augl_j_kgh�� qlh� ^Z`_� ba� mkl� lhc�� dhlhjZy� gZ� ijhly`_gbb� ^_kylbe_lbc� [ueZkljh`Zcr_c� [exklbl_evgbp_c� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� hjlh^hdkbb�²� ^hq_jb� ��� Nj_c^Z�� :gguNj_c^�²� \uj\Zehkv� oZjZdl_jgh_� ijbagZgb_�� ih^q_jdb\Zxs__� ljm^ghklb�� k dhlhjufbklZedb\Z_lky� \ kh\j_f_gguo� mkeh\byo� jZkijhkljZg_gb_� b^_c� ikbohZgZebaZ�� kh\j_f_ggZyfheh^_`v��]h\hjbeZ�:ggZ�Nj_c^��©bgl_j_km_lky�[hjv[hc�q_eh\_dZ�g_�k kZfbf�kh[hc��b [hjv[hcq_eh\_dZ�ijhlb\�h[s_kl\Zª�H khfg_gbyo� kZfbo� ijb\_j`_gp_\� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� l_jZibb� \ __� wnn_dlb\ghklb]h\hjbl�\ukdZau\Zgb_�h^gh]h�ba�Z\lhjbl_lguo�kh\j_f_gguo�njZgpmakdbo�ikbohZgZeblbdh\�K�<b^_jfZgZ�� ©Kj_^b� kZfbo� ikbohZgZeblbdh\� \k_� [hevr_� ijhy\eyxlky� ijbagZdb� jZaeZ^Z� ²h]h\hjdb��hkiZjb\Z_fu_�iheh`_gby��Z \�ihke_^g__�^_kylbe_lb_�\k_�[he__�\gylgh�a\mqZl�]hehkZ�mdZau\Zxsb_�gZ�ijh]j_kkbjmxsmx�jZkl_jygghklv����Gh�\ dhgp_�dhgph\�gZ�nmg^Zf_glZevguc\hijhk� gm`gh� [m^_l� hl\_qZlv� [_a� m\_jlhd�� Y\eyxlky� eb� debgbq_kdb_� kbfilhfu� wnn_dlhf\ul_kg_gby"� <iheg_� \_jhylgh�� KlZgh\blky� eb� mkljZg_gb_� \ul_kg_gby� g_\hafh`guf� bebaZljm^g_gguf� \ke_^kl\b_� dhgljkbeu�� gZau\Z_fhc� khijhlb\e_gb_f"� M\_j_gguc� hl\_l� a^_kvg_\hafh`_g�� Y\eyxlky� eb� mkljZg_gb_� \ul_kg_gby� iml_f� bgl_jij_lZpbb� �kbfilhfh\�� bebd\b^Zpby� �gZ� wlhc�hkgh\_��debgbq_kdbo�gZjmr_gbc� l\_j^h� mklZgh\e_ggufb�^hklb`_gbyfbikbohZgZebaZ"�Kljh]h�]h\hjy��hl\_l�^he`_g�[ulv�hljbpZl_evgufª� � �9LHGHUPDQ�6� &RQIURQWDWLRQ����$PHU��-��RI�3V\FKRO�����������3��������>ey�l_o��dlh�agZdhf�k ij_^klZ\e_gbyfb�h ijbjh^_�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��h jheb�\ul_kg_gby��hl_jZibb��hkgh\Zgghc�gZ�_]h�hkhagZgbb��b l��i���a\mqZ\rbfb�\ aZiZ^ghc�ebl_jZlmj_�ihke_^g_]h^_kylbe_lby�� ^he`gh� [ulv� hq_\b^gh� ba� ijb\_^_ggh]h� hlju\dZ�� dZdhc� ]em[hdbc� djbabki_j_`b\Z_l� kh\j_f_ggZy� aZiZ^gZy� debgbq_kdZy� ikboheh]by�� aZljZ]b\Zy� ijh[e_fm

Page 375: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��b dZdhc� ljm^guc�ijhp_kk�i_j_hp_gdb� ljZ^bpbhgguo�^ey�g__� lhedh\Zgbc� \g_c� ijhbkoh^bl��Wlh�� dhg_qgh�� g_�fh`_l� g_� mdj_ieylv� m\_j_gghklv� \ lhf�� qlh� i_j_^� kh\k_fbguf� ih^oh^hf� d ijh[e_f_� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� oZjZdl_jguf� ^ey� kh\_lkdhc� ikboheh]bb�� Zij_`^_� \k_]h� i_j_^� ih^oh^hf�� jZajZ[Zlu\Z_fuf� gZ� ijhly`_gbb� ^_kylbe_lbc� \ rdhe_�>��G�MagZ^a_��hldjulu�rbjhdb_�b [eZ]hijbylgu_�i_jki_dlb\u�^Zevg_cr_]h�jZa\blby����H EBQGHKLB�NJ?C>:�B H�LJ:=?>BB�NJ?C>BAF:< aZiZ^ghc�ebl_jZlmj_�fh`gh�g_j_^dh�\klj_lblv�\ukdZau\Zgby��ih�dhlhjuf� hldehg_gb_kh\_lkdbfb�bkke_^h\Zl_eyfb�h[s_c�ihabpbb��ij_^klZ\e_gbc�b mklZgh\hd�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhcrdheu� h[tykgy_lky� jZaebqgh]h� jh^Z� ih\_joghklgufb�� kblmZpbhggufb� fhf_glZfb� beb� ^Z`_dZdbf�lh� ij_^\ayluf� hlghr_gb_f� d __� hkgh\Zl_ex�� Ljm^gh� ij_^klZ\blv� k_[_� [he__g_ijZ\bevgmx�hp_gdm�<jy^� eb�fh`_l� dlh�eb[h� khfg_\Zlvky� \ lhf�� qlh�Nj_c^� [ue� \u^Zxsbfky�fukebl_e_f�h^gbf� ba� djmig_crbo� mq_guo� k\h_]h� \j_f_gb�� hlebqZ\rbfky� j_^dhc� gZ[ex^Zl_evghklvx� b[e_klys_c� debgbq_kdhc� bglmbpb_c�� Hg� [ue� lZd`_� q_eh\_dhf� ijbgpbibZevguf� b ]em[hdhij_^Zgguf� gZmd_��H[� wlhf� ]h\hjbl� \ky� bklhjby� _]h�`bagb� b ij_`^_� \k_]h� lZ� g_ij_dehggZyj_rbfhklv��k dhlhjhc�hg�hldZaZeky�hl�m`_� aZ\h_\Zgghc�bf�d ���f lh?�^Zf�;,;�\��j_imlZpbb_\jhi_ckdb� ba\_klgh]h� g_\jhiZlheh]Z� ^ey 72)2/� qlh[u� ihk\ylblv� k_[y� dZdbf�lh� kljZgguf�gbdhfm�gZ�i_j\uo�ihjZo�g_�ihgylguf�baukdZgbyf��jZ[hlZf��ih^gbfZ\rbf�klhev�g_h[uqgu_�klhev�rhdbjmxsb_�\hijhku��qlh�^Z`_�_]h�[ebadb_�^jmavy�^he]b_�]h^u�g_�j_rZebkv�ke_^h\ZlvaZ�gbf�\ wlm�gh\mx�h[eZklv�B h^gZdh��wlZ�ijb\e_dZl_evghklv�ebqghklb��^moh\gh]h�h[ebdZ�Nj_c^Z�hlgx^v�g_�hagZqZ_l�qlh� \ lZdhc�`_� kl_i_gb� ^he`gZ� bfihgbjh\Zlv� kha^ZggZy�bf� ihke_�fgh]bo� e_l� gZklhcqb\h]hljm^Z�ikboheh]bq_kdZy�dhgp_ipby��Ohjhrh�ba\_klgh��qlh� jZkoh`^_gby�� hq_gv�ih^qZk� j_adb_�f_`^m� ebqghklvx� kha^Zl_ey� b oZjZdl_jhf� kha^Zggh]h� gZ[ex^Zebkv� \ gZmd_� b Aebl_jZlmj_g_h^ghdjZlgh�� ;bh]jZnby� b l\hjq_kl\h�N�� Gbpr_�� wlh]h� ²� \ ]h^u� ^mr_\gh]h� a^hjh\vy� ²fy]dh]h� \ ebqghc� `bagb�� aZkl_gqb\h]h� q_eh\_dZ�� kha^Z\r_]h� l_f� g_� f_g__� kbkl_fmij_^klZ\e_gbc��dhlhjZy�kimkly�^_kylbe_lby�[ueZ�ij_\jZs_gZ�\ hkgh\m�\Zj\Zjkdh]h�gZpbklkdh]hfbjh\haaj_gby�²�yjdbc�lhfm�ijbf_j�LjZ]_^by�Nj_c^Z� dZd�fukebl_ey� aZdexqZeZkv� \ lhf�� qlh� hg� agZqbl_evgh� hi_j_^be� k\hxwihom�� h[jZlb\� \gbfZgb_� gZ� debgbq_kdb_� ijhy\e_gby�� ^ey� jZkdjulby� ijbjh^u� dhlhjuoikboheh]by��g_cjhnbabheh]by��ikbohl_jZiby�_]h�\j_f_gb�[ueb�kh\_jr_ggh�g_�ih^]hlh\e_gu�Ihke_�`_� lh]h�� dZd� wlb� ijhy\e_gby�²� Zdlb\ghklv� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h�²� [ueb� bf� ih^f_q_gu�i_j_^ gbf \hagbdeZ�g_e_]dZy�Zevl_jgZlb\Z��eb[h�iulZlvky�h[tykgylv�\uy\e_ggu_�bf�n_ghf_gugZ� hkgh\_� h[s_c� l_hjbb�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�� dhlhjmx� ke_^h\Zeh�� h^gZdh�� _s_� lhevdh�gZqbgZlvkha^Z\Zlv��eb[h�h[tykgylv�bo�gZ�hkgh\_�ij_^iheh`_gbc��kha^Z\Z_fuo DG�KRF� l��_��g_aZ\bkbfh�hl[he__�h[s_]h�dhgp_ilmZevgh]h�ih^oh^Z��kihkh[gh]h�hk\_lblv��ihfbfh�l_o�qZklguo�ijhy\e_gbc[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��dhlhju_� _^bgkl\_ggh�ijbdh\u\Zeb� \gbfZgb_�Nj_c^Z�� lZd`_� ]hjZa^h�[he__rbjhdmx�jhev�wlh]h�nZdlhjZ�\ kbkl_f_�khagZgby�q_eh\_dZ�\ p_ehf�Nj_c^� g_� fh]� ihclb� ih� i_j\hfm� imlb� ohly� [u� ihlhfm�� qlh� kha^Zgb_� h[s_c� l_hjbb

Page 376: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�g_fukebfh�[_a�hihju�gZ�wdki_jbf_glZevguc�f_lh^�\ rbjhdhf�ihgbfZgbb�\k_]^Z�hklZ\Z\rbcky�^ey�g_]h�qm`^uf��[_a�hihju�gZ�l_hj_lbq_kdb_�ij_^klZ\e_gby��\hr_^rb_�\ikboheh]bx�ebrv�^_kylbe_lby�kimkly��fu�bf__f�\ \b^m��\ qZklghklb��ihgylb_�lZd�gZau\Z_fhcikboheh]bq_kdhc� mklZgh\db�� \\_^_ggh_� \ ikboheh]bx�>��G��MagZ^a_� b _]h�rdhehc���B^y�`_\lhjuf� iml_f�� Nj_c^� g_� fh]� g_� ijb^Zlv� \ \ukr_c� kl_i_gb� keh`guf� ijhp_kkZf� mqZklby[_kkhagZl_evgh]h�dZd�\ mkeh\byo�ghjfZevghc�ikbobdb�� lZd�b \�nhjfbjh\Zgbb�g_\jhlbq_kdbojZkkljhckl\�bklhedh\Zgb_�mijhs_ggh_��k[b\Zxs__ky�gZ�k\h_h[jZaguc�Zgljhihfhjnbaf�Fh`gh�� dhg_qgh�� kdZaZlv�� qlh� \ky� wlZ� ZgljhihfhjnbaZpby� [_kkhagZl_evgh]h� [ueZ� ^eyNj_c^Z� lhevdh� k\h_]h� jh^Z� bah[jZabl_evguf� ijb_fhf��Gh� [_^Z� aZdexqZeZkv� \ lhf�� qlh� hgZbf_eZ� k\hx�eh]bdm�jZa\blby��ie_ggbdhf�dhlhjhc�Nj_c^�ihkl_i_ggh� klZe��<k_�[he__�b [he__mkeh`gyykv��\k_�[he__�hibjZykv�gZ�f_lZnhju��d dhlhjuf�Nj_c^��dZd�ba\_klgh��hq_gv�rbjhdhijb[_]Ze�� aZf_sZy� bfb� hlkmlkl\mxsb_� m g_]h� kljh]b_� ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z�� wlbZgljhihfhjnbabjmxsb_�dhgkljmdpbb�ijb\_eb�bo�Z\lhjZ�d kha^Zgbx�fgh`_kl\Z�ijbqm^eb\uo�bh^gh\j_f_ggh� gZb\guo� fbnh\� \ jZ[hl_� fha]Z�� d ij_^klZ\e_gbx� h nZlZevghc� ]_]_fhgbb[_kkhagZl_evgh]h� gZ^� khagZgb_f�� d b^__� lhevdh ZglZ]hgbklbq_kdbo� hlghr_gbc� f_`^m[_kkhagZl_evguf� b khagZgb_f�� d mq_gbx� h \ul_kg_gbb�� g_� khijh\h`^Zxs_fmky�� h^gZdh�jZatykg_gb_f�� \h� qlh� `_� ij_h[jZam_lky� dZd� ikboheh]bq_kdbc� n_ghf_g� Znn_dlb\gh_i_j_`b\Zgb_� ihke_� lh]h�� dZd� hgh� ih^\_j]Zehkv� \ul_kg_gbx�� : lhl�� dlh� \_jm� \ wlb� fbnujZa^_eye�� ij_\jZsZeky� ²� bgh]^Z� ^Z`_� [_a� ykgh]h� khagZgby� wlh]h� ²� \ ihke_^h\Zl_eyfbklbnbpbjh\Zgghc� kbkl_fu� khpbZevghc� ikboheh]bb�� g_� hklZ\eyxs_c� gbdZdhc� gZ^_`^uq_eh\_dm� gZ� _]h� dhg_qgh_� hk\h[h`^_gb_� hl� \eZklb� ]hkih^kl\mxsbo� ydh[u� gZ^� gbf[bheh]bq_kdb�ijbfblb\guo��bjjZpbhgZevguo�kbe�LZdbf� jbkm_lky� k\h_h[jZaguc� imlv� Nj_c^Z� \ gZmd_�� Hg� [ue� ljZ]bqguf� b ijblhf� \^\hcghf�kfuke_��LjZ]_^by�Nj_c^Z�aZdexqZeZkv�g_�lhevdh�\ lhf��qlh�ih^f_q_ggu_�bf�nZdlu�²nZdlu�� ijbhldju\Z\rb_� aZ\_km� gZ^� _s_� hq_gv� fZeh� ba\_klghc� b hq_gv� \Z`ghc klhjhghcikbobdb� q_eh\_dZ�²� [ueb� hklZ\e_gu� bf� [_a� ^he`gh]h� hkfuke_gby�� ?keb� [u� ^_ehbkq_jiu\Zehkv� lhevdh� wlbf�� gZ^e_`Zeh� [u� ]h\hjblv� ebrv� h ebqghc� ljZ]_^bb� Nj_c^Z� dZdbkke_^h\Zl_ey��< ^_ckl\bl_evghklb�`_�ljZ]bq_kdh_�bf_eh�a^_kv�bghc�oZjZdl_j�b bghc�fZkrlZ[�Fh`gh� g_� \h� \k_f� kh]eZrZlvky� k djblbdhc� b^_c�Nj_c^Z�� a\mqZs_c� k_]h^gy� \ aZiZ^ghcebl_jZlmj_�²�__ ijbf_ju�fu�ijb\h^beb�\ur_�²�gh�^h\hevgh�ljm^gh�hl\_j]gmlv�mdZaZgb_�gZZnn_dl��\uau\Z_fuc�ijbagZgb_f�ijbfblb\guo�[bheh]bq_kdbo�\e_q_gbc�]eZ\guf�\ dhg_qghfkq_l_�nZdlhjhf�� dhlhjuc�gZijZ\ey_l�b hij_^_ey_l�ih\_^_gb_�q_eh\_dZ�²� \ lh� \j_fy�� dZd�gZ^hex� khagZgby� hl\h^blky� ebrv� beexaby mijZ\e_gby� ^_yl_evghklvx�� : \_^v� bf_ggh� lZd� �\ihevam� wlh]h�fh`_l� [ulv� ijb\_^_gh� agZqbl_evgh_� dhebq_kl\h� ^hdZaZl_evkl\�� ijha\mqZeZ� ^eyhq_gv�b hq_gv�fgh]bo�hkgh\gZy�b^_y�ikbohZgZebaZ��B wlh�]em[hdh�i_kkbfbklbq_kdh_�ihgbfZgb_rbjhdh� ml\_j^behkv� g_aZ\bkbfh� hl� lh]h�� qlh�� \hafh`gh�� ohl_e�� gh� g_� kmf_e� ^hklZlhqghhlq_leb\h�kdZaZlv�Nj_c^�<k_�wlh�\ p_ehf��hlkmlkl\b_�m l_hjbb�ikbohZgZebaZ�kljh]h�jZajZ[hlZgghc�gZmqghc�hkgh\ub ki_pbnbq_kdbc� dhehjbl�� dhlhjuc� ijb^Z_lky� ikbohZgZebahf� ij_^klZ\e_gbyf� h ^moh\ghc`bagb�q_eh\_dZ��h lhf��qlh� wlm�`bagv�gZijZ\ey_l�b ^\b`_l�²�gZihegy_l� ]em[hdbf� kfukehfkeh\Z� h^gh]h� ba� djmig_crbo� ikboheh]h\� kh\j_f_gghc� NjZgpbb� I�� Nj_kkZ�� j_rbl_evgh

Page 377: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

hldZaZ\r_]h�nj_c^bafm� \ ijZ\_�gZ� klZlmk�gZmdb�� ©IkbohZgZeba�²� wlh� \_jZ�� Z qlh[u� \_jblv�gZ^h�kgZqZeZ�Ä\klZlv�gZ�dhe_gb�ª��K oZjZdl_jguf�]Zeevkdbf�eZdhgbafhf�a^_kv�dhjhldh�kdZaZghfgh]h_�>mfZ_lky�� qlh� \ k\_l_� lZdh]h� h[s_]h� ihgbfZgby� ^_n_dlh\� gZmqgh]h h[hkgh\Zgbynj_c^bafZ� b k\h_h[jZaby� khpbZevghc� jheb� b^_c� ikbohZgZebaZ�� hljbpZl_evgh_� hlghr_gb_� dwlhfm�gZijZ\e_gbx��a\mqZs__�\ kh\_lkdhc�ebl_jZlmj_�gZ�ijhly`_gbb�m`_�fgh]bo�^_kylbe_lbc�klZgh\blky�[he__�ihgylguf���������������� � ����H IJBQBG:O�I:J:>HDK:EVGHC�©@BAG?KIHKH;GHKLBªIKBOH:G:EBA:B gZdhg_p��\hijhk��dhlhjuf�fu�ohl_eb�[u�aZ\_jrblv�gZklhysbc�hq_jd�DZdb_� h[klhyl_evkl\Z� ijb^Zeb� ikbohZgZebam� g_hkihjbfmx� khijhlb\ey_fhklv�� ohly� gbh^gh��ih`Zemc��gZijZ\e_gb_�ikboheh]bq_kdhc�fukeb�g_�ih^\_j]Zehkv�lZdhc�j_adhc�b gbdh]^Zg_�ij_djZsZ\r_cky�djblbd_��dZd�kh�klhjhgu�l_o��dlh�b^_b�wlh]h�gZijZ\e_gby�\ lhc�beb�bghckl_i_gb�ijbagZ\Ze��lZd�b l_f�[he__�kh�klhjhgu�l_o��dlh�wlb�b^_b�hl\_j]Ze��I_kljhlZ�fg_gbc�dhlhjZy�ihgug_�gZ[ex^Z_lky�\ _]h�jZfdZo��^_eZ_l�g_e_]dbf�hl\_l�^Z`_�gZ�lZdhc��dZaZehkv�[u�ijhklhc�\hijhk��y\ey_lky�eb�ikbohZgZeba��g_kfhljy�gZ�\k_�i_jbi_lbb�b iZjZ^hdku�_]h�bklhjbb�[he__� beb�f_g__� _^bghc� l_hj_lbq_kdhc� dhgkljmdpb_c� beb�`_�� jZkkfZljb\Zy� _]h� k_]h^gy��fuhdZau\Z_fky� kdhj__� ebrv� i_j_^� ih\_joghklgh� h[t_^bg_gguf� dhg]ehf_jZlhf� l_q_gbc�ebr_gguf�ki_pbnbq_kdh]h�^ey�g_]h�dhgp_ilmZevgh]h�y^jZ"Hl\_l� gZ� wlhl� \hijhk� l_f� [he__� aZljm^gbl_e_g�� qlh�� k h^ghc� klhjhgu�� l_hj_lbq_kdb_ihabpbb��dhlhju_�oZjZdl_jbamxl�jZaebqgu_�gZijZ\e_gby�kh\j_f_ggh]h�ikbohZgZebaZ��gbdh]^Zg_� [ueb� jZg__� lZd� ljm^gh� kh\f_klbfufb�� Z k� ^jm]hc� ²� lh�� qlh�� g_kfhljy� gZ� wlm� k\hx\gmlj_ggxx� jZaghjh^ghklv� b ^Z`_� jZks_ie_gghklv�� ikbohZgZeba� ijh^he`Z_l� hklZ\Zlvky� \jZfdZo� aZiZ^ghc� dmevlmju� l_q_gb_f� dZq_kl\_ggh� hkh[uf�� ijhlb\hklhysbf� [hevrbgkl\m^jm]bo� gZijZ\e_gbc�� dhlhju_� \ lhc� beb� bghc� kl_i_gb� kbf\hebabjmxl� beb� \ujZ`Zxl� wlmdmevlmjm�K_]h^gy�fh`gh� m\_j_ggh� kdZaZlv��qlh�� aZ\h_\Z\� k [hyfb�hij_^_e_ggh_�f_klh� \ aZiZ^ghcdmevlmj_�dZd�l_q_gb_��bf_\r__�\gZqZe_�ikbohl_jZi_\lbq_kdmx��Z aZl_f�lZd`_�nbehkhnkdmx�bkhpbheh]bq_kdmx� hjb_glZpbx�� ikbohZgZeba� klZe� ihkl_i_ggh� gZlZedb\Zlvky� \ \hajZklZxsbofZkrlZ[Zo�gZ�^h\hevgh�j_adh_�khijhlb\e_gb_�_]h�^Zevg_cr_c�wdkiZgkbb��Ijb�\k_c�©fh^ghklbªg_dhlhjuo�_]h�ihgylbc�b ijbau\h\��bo�ihimeyjghklb�gZ�kljZgbpZo�g_\aukdZl_evghc�fZkkh\hci_qZlb�� hg� hklZ_lky� l_f� g_� f_g__� \ mkeh\byo� kh\j_f_gghc� dmevlmju� AZiZ^Z� kdhj__bahebjh\Zgghc� kn_jhc� fukeb�� Ih^ebggh]h� hieh^hl\hj_gby� b^_yfb� ikbohZgZebaZ� ^jm]bodhgp_ilmZevguo� gZijZ\e_gbc�� ijhgbdgh\_gby� wlbo� b^_c� \ bgu_� nbehkhnkdb_� bebikboheh]bq_kdb_� l_q_gby� �_keb� g_� kqblZlv� ba\_klgh]h� \ebygby� gZ� kZjljh\kdbcwdabkl_gpbZebaf��i_jkhgZebaf�W��Fmgv_�b e_\bkljhkkh\kdmx�Zgljhiheh]bx��g_�ijhbahreh��Bl_f�[he__��dhg_qgh��g_�ijboh^blky�]h\hjblv�h dZdhf�[u�lh�gb [ueh�\ebygbb�b^_c�ikbohZgZebaZ�_keb�hl\e_qvky�hl�m`_�ihemaZ[ulhc�kblmZpbb����o ]h^h\��gZ�jZ[hlu�kh\_lkdbo�bkke_^h\Zl_e_c�LZdh_�iheh`_gb_�\_s_c�g_�fh`_l�g_�aZhkljblv�_kl_kl\_ggh�\hagbdZxsbc�\hijhk��q_f�`_

Page 378: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

h[mkeh\eb\Z_lky�wlZ�iZjZ^hdkZevgZy�`bag_kihkh[ghklv�kbkl_fu��dhlhjZy�kZfZ�ih�k_[_��l��_��ijbj_ljhki_dlb\ghf� \a]ey^_� gZ� __ kh[kl\_ggu_� \gmlj_ggb_� ijhlb\hj_qby�� h[jbkh\u\Z_lky� dZddjZcg_� g_mklhcqb\Zy"� Qlh� iha\hey_l� wlhc� kbkl_f_� khojZgylv� hij_^_e_ggmx� kl_i_gvbklhjbq_kdb� \ujZ`_gghc� klZ[bevghklb� ijb� hlgx^v� g_� khqm\kl\_gghf� ijbgylbb� __ fbjhf^jm]bo� b^_c�� ijb� y\ghf� gZebqbb� \ g_c� kbevguo� djblbq_kdbo� l_g^_gpbc�� gZijZ\e_gguo� gZi_j_hkfuke_gb_�__ hkgh\guo�bkoh^guo�iheh`_gbc"Hl\_qZy�� ke_^m_l� ij_`^_� \k_]h� ih^q_jdgmlv�� qlh� k\h_h[jZab_� km^v[u� ikbohZgZebaZh[tykgy_lky� k\h_h[jZab_f� ki_dljZ� b^_c� dhlhju_� hg� iulZ_lky� ml\_j^blv�� kms_kl\h\Zgb_f� \wlhf�ki_dlj_�dZd�\Z`guo�b^_c��bf_xsbo�k_jv_agh_�agZq_gb_�^ey�^Zevg_cr_]h�jZa\blby�gZrboagZgbc�� lZd� b b^_c� fZehc� b ^Z`_� g_]Zlb\ghc� gZmqghc� p_gghklb�� b^_c�wn_f_jh\�� h dhlhjuoi_j_klZxl�]h\hjblv�b ^mfZlv�hq_gv�kdhjh�ihke_�lh]h��dZd�hgb�knhjfmebjh\Zgu��?keb�ihke_^gb_ijb^Zxl� bklhjbb� ikbohZgZebaZ� h[ebd� ^bgZfbqghc� fhaZbdb�� g_mklZgghc� kf_gu� ijh]jZff� b^_dhjZpbc�� lh� i_j\u_� \uklmiZxl� dZd� hkgh\Z� g_hkihjbfhc� khijhlb\ey_fhklb� dhlhjmx� wlhl_q_gb_�hdZau\Zeh�gZ�ijhly`_gbb�^_kylbe_lbc�kZfuf�jZaghh[jZaguf�ihiuldZf�_]h�djblbdb�DZdh\u�`_�wlb�©klZ[bebabjmxsb_ª�ikbohZgZeba�b^_b"�Hl\_l�lj_[m_l�]em[hdh]h�ZgZebaZ�ihlhfm� qlh� hgb� g_e_]dh� \hkijbgbfZ_fu�� kh]eZkb_� k gbfb� \hafh`gh� ebrv� ijb� hldZa_� hlljZdlh\hd��m`_�^Z\gh�klZ\rbo�ljZ^bpbhggufb��l��_��ijb�mkeh\bb�gh\h]h�\a]ey^Z�gZ�p_euc�jy^ikboheh]bq_kdbo�b debgbq_kdbo�ijh[e_f�Ihqlb�m`_�\_dh\Zy�bklhjby�ikbohZgZebaZ�m[_^bl_evgh�]h\hjbl�\ ihevam�lh]h��qlh��kdhev�[uyjdh� gb� ijhy\eyeZkv� baf_gqb\hklv� gZijZ\e_gbc� ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc� fukeb�� \k_� wlbgZijZ\e_gby��gZqbgZy�hl�kha^Zgguo�i_j\ufb�©hlklmigbdZfbª�:��:^e_jhf�b D��Xg]hf�b dhgqZygZb[he__�ba\_klgufb� kh\j_f_ggufb� l_hj_lbdZfb�ikbohZgZebaZ�>`��DeZcghf�b @��EZdZghf�hkgh\u\Zxlky� lZd� beb� bgZq_� gZ� h^ghc� b lhc� `_� h[s_c� ^ey� gbo� b^__ kms_kl\h\Zgby[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��ihgbfZ_fh]h�dZd�dZl_]hjby�ijbgpbibZevgh�ikboheh]bq_kdZy�?keb�ml\_j`^Z_lky��qlh�g_hkhagZ\Z_fZy�ikbobq_kdZy�^_yl_evghklv�h[gZjm`b\Z_lky�\ lhfbeb� bghf� \b^_� \ kljmdlmj_� ex[hc�nhjfu� q_eh\_q_kdh]h� j_Z]bjh\Zgby�� \ kljmdlmj_� ex[h]hih\_^_gq_kdh]h�n_ghf_gZ� lh� klZgh\blky� hq_\b^ghc� g_\hafh`ghklv� ihgylv� \ hl\e_q_gbb� hl�wlhc�b^_b�gb�h^gh��ih�kms_kl\m��ba�ijhy\e_gbc�p_e_gZijZ\e_gghc�Zdlb\ghklb�q_eh\_dZ�Bf_ggh� wlZ�hihjZ�gZ�dZl_]hjbx�[_kkhagZl_evgh]h��dhlhjZy�h[t_^bgy_l� kZfu_�jZaebqgu_gZijZ\e_gby�ikbohZgZeblbq_kdhc�fukeb��iha\hebeZ�ikbohZgZebam�mp_e_lv�dZd�ki_pbnbq_kdhfmdhgp_ilmZevghfm�l_q_gbx�gZ�ijhly`_gbb�ihqlb�m`_�p_eh]h�\_dZ�Kd_ilbq_kdh_� hlghr_gb_� Nj_c^Z� d wdki_jbf_glZevghc� ikboheh]bb� fh]eh� [ulvh[mkeh\e_gh� l_f�� qlh� p_gljZevgZy� ^ey� g_]h� ijh[e_fZ� fhlb\Zpbb� i_j\hgZqZevgh� g_ih^\_j]ZeZkv� k_jv_aghfm� wdki_jbf_glZevghfm� bamq_gbx�� Ebrv� \ihke_^kl\bb� \ jy^_bkke_^h\Zgbc� �\ qZklghklb�� m D�� E_\bgZ� b _]h� rdheu�� wlZ� ijh[e_fZ� klZgh\blky� h[eZklvxijbf_g_gby�wdki_jbf_glZevguo�f_lh^h\�Nj_c^� ihklhyggh� ih^q_jdb\Ze�� qlh� ikbohZgZeba� hldjue� h[eZklv� [_kkhagZl_evguo^mr_\guo�ijhp_kkh\��lh]^Z�dZd�\k_�hklZevgu_�dhgp_ipbb�b^_glbnbpbjmxl�ikbobdm�b khagZgb_�JZkkfZljb\Zy� wlm� ihabpbx� \ bklhjbq_kdhc� i_jki_dlb\_�� ke_^m_l� ih^q_jdgmlv�� qlh� Nj_c^g_Z^_d\Zlgh� hp_gb\Ze� h[smx� kblmZpbx� \ ikboheh]bq_kdhc� gZmd_��Ihgylb_� [_kkhagZl_evghc

Page 379: GB? < IKBOH:G:EBA - Главнаяosp.kgsu.ru/library/PDF/315.pdf · ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h _]h ihgyleb\hklb k]h\hjqb\hklb b\u^_j‘db ?kl_kl\_ggh mgZk _klv \_kdb_ hkgh\Zgby ^ey lZdh]h

ikbobdb�[ueb�\\_^_gh�E_c[gbp_f��nbehkhnkdmx�dhgp_ipbx�dhlhjh]h�=_j[Zjl�i_j_\_e�gZ�yaud^hklmighc� wfibjbq_kdhfm� ZgZebam� ©klZlbdb� b ^bgZfbdb� ij_^klZ\e_gbcª�� I_j_oh^� hlmfhajbl_evguo� dhgkljmdpbc�� \dexqZ\rbo� ihgylb_� h [_kkhagZl_evghc� ikbobd_� �\ qZklghklb�nbehkhnbb�Rhi_g]ZmwjZ���d bkihevah\Zgbx�\ wdki_jbf_glZevghc�gZmd_�gZf_lbeky�\ k_j_^bg_;,;� \��� dh]^Z� bamq_gb_� nmgdpbc� hj]Zgh\� qm\kl\� b \ukrbo� g_j\guo� p_gljh\� ih[m^beh_kl_kl\hbkiulZl_e_c� h[jZlblvky� d mdZaZgghfm� ihgylbx� k p_evx� h[tykg_gby� nZdlh\�g_kh\f_klbfuo�kh�\a]ey^hf�gZ�ikbobdm�dZd�h[eZklv�y\e_gbc�khagZgby��=_evf]hevp�\u^\b]Z_lihgylb_�h ©[_kkhagZl_evguo�mfhaZdexq_gbyoª�dZd�f_oZgbaf_�ihkljh_gby� k_gkhjgh]h� h[jZaZ�Ij_^iheh`_gb_�h [_kkhagZl_evghc�ikbobd_�e_`Zeh�\ hkgh\_�ikbohnbabdb�N_og_jZ��Kh]eZkghK_q_gh\m��©[_kkhagZl_evgu_�hsms_gbyª�beb�qm\kl\h\Zgby�kem`Zl�j_]meylhjZfb�^\b]Zl_evghcZdlb\ghklb��Hlh`^_kl\e_gb_� ikbobdb� b khagZgby� hl\_j]Zeb� b fgh]b_� ^jm]b_� bkke_^h\Zl_eb�>_ckl\bl_evgZy� gh\bagZ� dhgp_ipbb�Nj_c^Z� k\yaZgZ� k jZajZ[hldhc� ijh[e_f� g_hkhagZ\Z_fhcfhlb\Zpbb�� bamq_gb_f� g_hkhagZ\Z_fuo� dhfihg_glh\� \ kljmdlmj_� ebqghklb� b ^bgZfbq_kdbohlghr_gbc�f_`^m�gbfb�IkbohZgZeba�� dZd� y\kl\m_l� ba� wlbo� iheh`_gbc�� g_� h]jZgbqb\Zeky� ijblyaZgb_f� gZihkljh_gb_� gh\hc� ikboheh]bb� b gh\h]h� mq_gby� h[� wlbheh]bb� g_j\guo� b ikbobq_kdboaZ[he_\Zgbc�� <uc^y� aZ� ]jZgbpu� wlbo� gZijZ\e_gbc�� hg� klZe� ij_l_g^h\Zlv� gZ� h[tykg_gb_^\b`msbo�kbe�jZa\blby�q_eh\_q_kdh]h�h[s_kl\Z�b hlghr_gbc�f_`^m�ebqghklvx�b dmevlmjhc�LZdh_� hlghr_gb_� ljZdlh\Zehkv� dZd� bagZqZevgh� ZglZ]hgbklbq_kdh_�� Wlh� ke_^h\Zeh� m`_� babkoh^guo�ihabpbc�Nj_c^Z��kh]eZkgh�dhlhjuf�k_dkmZevgu_�\e_q_gby�b Z]j_kkb\gu_�bgklbgdlu�h[jZamy�]em[bggu_��[bheh]bq_kdb_�ih�k\h_c�kmsghklb�hkgh\u�ebqghklb��g_kh\f_klbfu�k l_fblj_[h\Zgbyfb��dhlhju_�gZ\yau\Zxl�_c�khpbZevgZy�kj_^Z�k __�gjZ\kl\_ggufb�ghjfZfb�