from paddles to pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

66
Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? Iscontrollerdesignkilling creativityinvideogames? FromPaddles toPads: 1 [email protected]

Upload: infovore

Post on 12-Dec-2014

3.030 views

Category:

Technology


2 download

DESCRIPTION

A talk I delivered at the O'Reilly Emerging Technology Conference in 2006, on how the devices we play games with affects the games we can play (amongst other things).

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Iscontrollerdesignkillingcreativityinvideogames?

FromPaddlestoPads:

1

[email protected]

Page 2: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

TomArmitage,aged2.5

2

Page 3: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Iscontrollerdesignkillingcreativityinvideogames?

3

Page 4: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 4

Current-genjoypads

Page 5: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 5

Next-generationjoypad

Page 6: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 6

New-lookshoulderbuttons!

Page 7: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 7

RevolutionRemote

Page 8: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Thanksverymuch!

8

Page 9: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

9

Page 10: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Thegamesindustryisbig

‣Halo2:firstdayonsale:

2.38millioncopies

$125m

‣Spider-man:openingweekend:

$114m

10

Page 11: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 11

Thepowerofsequels

Page 12: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 12

Page 13: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 13

Thingswhicharethesame:

Page 14: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Itassumesyou’veusedajoypadbefore

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

What’swrongwiththis?

14

Page 15: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

NESpad

15

Page 16: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

SNESpad

16

Page 17: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Playstationpad

17

Page 18: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Playstation2pad

18

Page 19: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Modernhandhelds

19

Page 20: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Xboxpad

20

Page 21: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Xboxpadbeingheld

21

Page 22: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 22

“Complexitylostthecasualgamer...”

NolanBushnell

Page 23: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 23

“...Ifyoulookattoday’scontrollerwithtriangles,Xs,squaresandcircles,it’sscary.It’slikeakeyboard.Peopleareinterfacephobic.”

NolanBushnell

Page 24: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

“Peopleareinterfacephobic”

24

Page 25: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Snake-gamingonaphone

25

Page 26: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Bricks-gamingonaPDA

26

Page 27: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Solitaire-gamingonaniPod

27

Page 28: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 28

Current-genjoypads

Page 29: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Alex

29

(notehappy,smiling

demeanour,priorto

playingHalo)

Page 30: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

AlexplayingHalo

30

Page 31: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Isitthecontrollersthatarescaringpeopleoff?

31

Page 32: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Consoletake-upintheUS

32

0m

12m

24m

36m

48m

60m

8-bit 16-bit 32-bit now

52m48m

42m

31m

Consistently:about31-32%ofhouseholdshaveaconsole

Page 33: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Currentjoypadsareaestheticallyuninspiring

33

Page 34: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 34

Singstar

http://flickr.com/photos/paalb/80551306/

Page 35: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 35

Buzz

Page 36: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 36

DonkeyKonga

Page 37: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 37

GuitarHero

http://flickr.com/photos/mayoff/71389886/

Page 38: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 38

SteelBattalion

Page 39: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Halo

39

Page 40: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 40

MetroidPrime

Page 41: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 41

Killer7

Page 42: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 42

MicroMachines2

Page 43: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 43

MicroMachines2cart

Page 44: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 44

Page 45: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 45

Sameidiominnext-gen

Page 46: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Handedness

46

Page 47: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Asymmetricpads

47

Page 48: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

DonkeyKongcabinet

48

Page 49: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Eventhispadhasabias

49

Page 50: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 50

Entirelysymmetrical

Page 51: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 51

Revolution“nunchuck”

Page 52: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 52

Noincentivetousethesewell

Page 53: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Iscontrollerdesignkillingcreativityinvideogames?

53

Page 54: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

The“UncannyValley”

54

Page 55: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

PS3controller

55

Controllerspecificsare

“nothingweneedtobeconcernedaboutasdevelopers”

Page 56: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Isthisthebestwecando?

56

Page 57: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 57

“Ifwecannotexpandthemarket,allwecandoiswaitforthe

industrytoslowlydie”

SatoruIwata

Page 58: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 58

“Itisourresponsibilitytomakegamesforallskilllevels...includingpeoplewhoarenotplayinggamesnow”

SatoruIwata

Page 59: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 59

Revolution

Page 60: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Controllersincomicbooks

60

Page 61: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Controllersinfilms

61

Page 62: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 62

“Avideogameissomethingyouplaywithcontrols,usuallybutnotalwaysusingyour

thumbs.”

TomLangston

Page 63: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 63

Arethesecontrollerswhatwewanttorepresentvideogames?

Page 64: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 64

Gamesaremorethanthis

Page 65: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Thisisnottheendofevolution

65

Page 66: From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Thanksverymuch!

66

[email protected]