fourstar v. amazon - complaint
DESCRIPTION
Fourstar v. Amazon - ComplaintTRANSCRIPT
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
TAMPA DIVISION FOURSTAR GROUP USA, INC. Plaintiff, v. Case No. DEAL GENIUS, INC., AMAZON.COM, INC., and BUY.COM, INC. d/b/a RAKUTEN.COM, Defendants. _______________________________________/
COMPLAINT AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (Injunctive Relief Sought)
Plaintiff, Fourstar Group USA, Inc. (“Fourstar”), sues Defendants, Deal Genius,
Inc. (“Deal Genius”), Amazon.Com, Inc. (“Amazon”), and Buy.Com, Inc. d/b/a
Rakuten.com (“Rakuten”), and alleges the following:
NATURE OF THE ACTION
1. This is an action for Defendants’ infringement of Fourstar’s federally-
registered copyright.
THE PARTIES
2. Plaintiff, Fourstar, is a Delaware corporation with a major office located in
Clearwater, Florida.
3. Defendant, Deal Genius, is an Illinois corporation with its principal place
of business in Chicago, Illinois. Deal Genius is an online retailer, and “flash deals site,”
that uses its interactive website, www.dealgenius.com, to advertise, market, offer for sale,
and sell goods, including the infringing goods at issue, online.
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 1 of 26 PageID 1
2
4. Defendant, Amazon, is a Delaware corporation with its principal place of
business in Seattle, Washington. Amazon is an online retailer that uses its interactive
website, www.amazon.com, to advertise, market, offer for sale, and sell goods, including
the infringing goods at issue, online. Amazon operates two large fulfillment centers
within this judicial district. One of Amazon’s large fulfillment centers is located in
Ruskin, Hillsborough County, and the other is in Lakeland, Polk County, Florida.
5. Defendant, Rakuten, is a Delaware corporation with its principal place of
business in Aliso Viejo, California. Rakuten is an online retailer that uses its interactive
website, www.rakuten.com, to advertise, market, offer for sale, and sell goods, including
the infringing goods at issue, online.
JURISDICTION AND VENUE
6. This is an action, pursuant to 17 U.S.C. §501 et seq., seeking preliminary
and permanent injunctive relief, other equitable relief, recovery of Fourstar’s actual
damages and an award of the profits realized by Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten or,
alternatively, statutory damages. Fourstar also seeks recovery of the costs, expert fees,
and attorneys’ fees it incurs as a result of Defendants’ infringement of Fourstar’s rights
granted under the Copyright Laws of the United States.
7. This Court possesses subject matter jurisdiction over this case under 28
U.S.C. §§1331 and 1338 because this is an action by Fourstar under the Copyright Laws
for Defendants’ infringement of Fourstar’s copyright.
8. This Court possesses personal jurisdiction over Defendants because they
are infringing Fourstar’s federally protected copyright rights within this judicial district,
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 2 of 26 PageID 2
3
have delivered the infringing goods at issue in this judicial district, and because they
maintain interactive websites through which users residing in Florida may their infringing
goods over the internet.
9. Venue properly lies in this judicial district under 28 U.S.C. §1391(b)(2)
because a substantial part of the events giving rise to the claims in this case occurred in
this judicial district, including, but not limited to, the advertising, marketing, and offering
for sale of the Defendants’ infringing goods via their websites in this judicial district and
the shipment of those infringing products to Clearwater, Florida.
10. All conditions precedent to the maintenance of this action have occurred,
been performed, or have been excused or waived.
COUNT I – FEDERAL COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT AGAINST DEAL GENIUS, AMAZON, AND RAKUTEN
11. Fourstar realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations in
paragraphs 1 through 10 above as if set forth fully herein.
12. Fourstar specializes in the creation, development, sourcing, and sale of
products, including decorations, food and candy, general merchandise, and household
goods, for sale to the public by retail mass merchandisers.
13. In connection with developing a new product line, Fourstar designed and
authored original, holiday-themed artwork and sculpture titled “Christmas Solar” which
artwork and sculpture was first published on March 25, 2011. Fourstar’s Christmas Solar
Artwork includes artwork and sculpture of a penguin (“Fourstar’s Penguin Artwork”) and
a snowman (“Fourstar’s Snowman Artwork”).
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 3 of 26 PageID 3
4
14. On December 6, 2011, Fourstar obtained a Federal copyright, registration
number VA 1-798-928, for Fourstar’s Penguin Artwork and Fourstar’s Snowman
Artwork (“Fourstar’s Christmas Copyright”). True and accurate copies of the Certificate
of Registration and the copyright deposit for Fourstar’s Christmas Copyright are attached
hereto as Composite Exhibit “A”.
15. Fourstar recently discovered that Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten were
and are selling to the public, through their interactive websites, products that infringe
Fourstar’s Christmas Copyright.
16. Deal Genius continues to advertise, market, and sell products called “Solar
Power Dancing Snowman & Penguin” (the “Infringing Christmas Products”), which
exactly copy Fourstar’s Penguin Artwork and Fourstar’s Snowman Artwork. A screen
shot of Deal Genius’ website showing the Infringing Christmas Products is attached as
Exhibit “B”.
17. Amazon continues to advertise, market, and sell the Infringing Christmas
Products, which were and are fulfilled by Deal Genius. A screen shot of Amazon’s
website showing the Infringing Christmas Products is attached as Exhibit “C”.
18. Rakuten continues to advertise, market, and sell the Infringing Christmas
Products, which were and are fulfilled by Deal Genius. A screen shot of Rakuten’s
website showing the Infringing Christmas Products is attached as Exhibit “D”.
19. Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten are each disseminating and selling the
Infringing Christmas Products without Fourstar’s permission or consent.
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 4 of 26 PageID 4
5
20. The actions of Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten regarding the
Infringing Christmas Products constitute infringement of Fourstar’s Christmas Copyright
in violation of 17 U.S.C. §501.
21. As a result of Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten infringing Fourstar’s
Christmas Copyright, Fourstar has suffered and continues to suffer damages, and is
entitled to all remedies provided by Chapter 5 of Title 17, United States Code.
22. Upon information and belief, the copyright infringement by Deal Genius,
Amazon, and Rakuten will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
23. Fourstar has suffered irreparable injury and has been damaged by the
infringing activities of Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten, and will continue to suffer
damages and irreparable injury unless such infringing actions are enjoined by this Court.
24. Fourstar has no adequate remedy at law to prevent the injuries caused by
the continuing infringement by Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten.
25. Given the clear infringement by Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten of
Fourstar’s copyright, Fourstar will likely prevail on the merits of this action.
26. The balance of the hardships and public interest require that Deal Genius,
Amazon, and Rakuten immediately and permanently cease its infringing activities.
27. Fourstar has retained the law firm of Fee & Jeffries, P.A. to vindicate its
rights against Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten and is obligated to pay reasonable
attorneys’ fees for its attorneys’ services.
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 5 of 26 PageID 5
6
WHEREFORE, Fourstar respectfully requests this Court to:
A. Enter judgment in Fourstar’s favor and against Deal Genius, Amazon, and
Rakuten;
B. Award to Fourstar and against Deal Genius, Amazon and Rakuten:
1) Fourstar’s actual damages;
2) Deal Genius’ profits from its sales of the Infringing Christmas
Products;
3) Amazon’s profits from its sales of the Infringing Christmas
Products;
4) Rakuten’s profits from its sales of the Infringing Christmas
Products;
5) statutory damages, as an alternative to Fourstar’s actual damages
and the profits of Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten; and
6) the attorneys’ fees, expert fees, and costs incurred by Fourstar as a
result of the infringement of Fourstar’s Christmas Copyright by
Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten.
C. Preliminarily and permanently enjoin Deal Genius, Amazon, and Rakuten
from further infringing, or in any way benefiting from their past infringement of,
Fourstar’s Christmas Copyright, specifically including, but not limited to, enjoining the
advertising, marketing, disseminating, selling, and offering for sale the Infringing
Christmas Products; and
D. Grant Fourstar all additional relief that this Court deems appropriate.
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 6 of 26 PageID 6
7
DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
Fourstar hereby demands a trial by jury on all issues so triable.
Dated: November 26, 2014 Respectfully submitted, /s/ Richard E. Fee Richard E. Fee
Florida Bar No. 813680 Jillian L. Feltham Florida Bar No. 58383 FEE & JEFFRIES, P.A. 1227 N. Franklin Street Tampa, Florida 33602 (813) 229-8008 (813) 229-0046 (Facsimile) [email protected] [email protected] Counsel for Plaintiff, Fourstar Group USA, Inc.
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 7 of 26 PageID 7
COMPOSITE EXHIBIT A
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 8 of 26 PageID 8
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 1
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 9 of 26 PageID 9
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 2
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 10 of 26 PageID 10
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 3
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 11 of 26 PageID 11
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 4
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 12 of 26 PageID 12
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 5
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 13 of 26 PageID 13
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 6
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 14 of 26 PageID 14
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 7
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 15 of 26 PageID 15
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 8
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 16 of 26 PageID 16
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 9
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 17 of 26 PageID 17
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 10
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 18 of 26 PageID 18
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 11
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 19 of 26 PageID 19
Complaint - Composite Ex. A - Page 12
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 20 of 26 PageID 20
EXHIBIT B
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 21 of 26 PageID 21
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 22 of 26 PageID 22
EXHIBIT C
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 23 of 26 PageID 23
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 24 of 26 PageID 24
EXHIBIT D
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 25 of 26 PageID 25
Get Rakuten Super Points™ | Login | Email Sign-Up | +Feedback | Sell | Help
1 Day left until our Black Friday Event
HOME & OUTDOOR FURNITURE, DÉCOR & STORAGE DÉCOR & ARTWORK HOLIDAY DÉCOR
Add to Wishlist Save for later
Ships from/sold by DealGenius
Seller Rating: Seller Return Policy
Sell Your Item
QUANTITY: 1
ADD TO CART9 Reviews / Write Review
LIST PRICE: $20.00 (Save 60%)
$7.99 + FREE SHIPPING
Share 0LikeLike 0
an $80 value†Up to 8,000 Rakuten Super Points™
Item Price:Savings:
Special Price:*Learn More >
$7.99-$80.00
$0.00
EARN 8 RAKUTEN SUPER POINTS™
CONDITION: Brand NewIN STOCK: Usually Ships in 1 to 2 business days
Solar Powered Dancing Snowman & Penguin Set Christmas Holiday Figure Decoration
Description Reviews Seller Information
Manufacturer: Made in China Mfg Part#: 30057 Sku: 257395110 UPC: 898806300574 UPC 14: 00898806300574
Package Weight: 0.33 lbs Sales Rank: 83458
See more in Holiday Décor
Learn more about Solar Powered Dancing Snowman & Penguin Set Christmas Holiday Figure Decoration:
FeaturesApproximately 4.25"(L) x 2.25"(D) x 3.5"(W)Solar Powered FigurinesThey Dance in the Light
I could watch these guys dance all day. Actually, I have one on my desk just bopping away right now. Solar Powered Mr. Penguin and Mr. Snowman are simply mesmerizing. They are adorable, festive, and (since they're solar powered) easy. No annoying plugs or batteries. They have adhesive on the bottom so you can peel and stick them to your car dashboard. Or, avoid the stick, and just stand them on the fireplace mantle, or anywhere else a fun decoration belongs. These are the perfect stocking stuffer. At this price you can afford to stuff a lot of stockings, so spread the joy.
60%OFF
Computers & Office
Electronics Fashion & Beauty Video Games Books, Movies, Music
Home & Household
Health & Fitness Toys & Baby Deals & More
All Categories Cart (0)Find it fast...
http://www.rakuten.com/prod/solar-powered-dancing-snowman-penguin-set-christmas-holiday-figure...
Page 1 of 411/26/2014
Case 8:14-cv-02971-CEH-TBM Document 1 Filed 11/26/14 Page 26 of 26 PageID 26