forum materials
TRANSCRIPT
1
*15-16 2009 ., , (,2)*
.
, , . 8:00-9:00 . . : , Fuel Alternative 9:00 ( , Fuel Alternative). 9:05 : ( ()). 9:20 ( , . ) 9:30 ( . ., ). 9:40 : ? ( , ) 10:00 ( , ). 10:10 ( , . ). 10:25 (Cliff Aron, GreenMax Capital Advisors). 10:40 . (Alejandro Nieto, ) 10:55 - 11:10 - 11:00-11:30 - : : , , , , . . . : , : 11:30 : ? ( , , ). 11:45 ( , ). 12:15 ( , . . ., - , ) 12:30 - ( , ).
2
12:45 ( . ., . ., . . . ). 13:00 - ( , ). 13:15 ( , UNISOLAR). 13:30 : (- , , ). 14:00 Abeinsa (Mr. Jos Javier Gonzlez Solano, Abeinsa). 14:30-15:00 . . : , : 15:00 : ? ( , ). 15:20 ( , , ). 15:35 : ? ( , , ). 15:50 ( .., .., . . . ). 16:05 : (CMS Cameron McKenna LLC) 16:20 (Winder) 16:30 ( , -) 16:45 - 17:00-17:15 - . . , 17:15 : ( , -1). 17:35 . ( , , ). 17:55 : ( , ). 18:20 ( , , ). 18:40 - 19-00
.
. 9:00 . . , 9:00 . 9:10 : ( , ). 9:30 ? ( , ) 9:45 - , ( , ). 10:00 ( , ). 10:25 : , , ( , (). 10:40 ( , ) 11:00 - 11:10-11:30 - . . 11:30 ( , ). 11:45 : ? ( , ). 12:00 ( , ). 12:15 : ( , . ). 12:30 - 12:45-13:30 . . : , Greencubator 13:30 : ( , ) 13:45 , ? ( ). 14:00 . Nordic Environment Finance Corporation ( , NEFCO). 14:20
14:30 14:50 15:05 15:20 15:35
3
15:45
( , ). ? ( , ). : ( , ) ( , Camco International) : (MGM International). IT - ( -, energy.ua) -.
16:00-17:00 17:00-18:00 : ?
, , Fuel Alternative , , , 2006 . : , , . - , , . , , , . , , , , , . , . , . . , , , . , , . ,
4
FuelAlternative, . - . 20012005 . , 2006 2007 . , 20072008 . (), 2009 . .
. . -. 90- . 1991 . , 1992 . , , 1995 . , - , 1997 . -`- , 1999 . . 2006 . . , - , , .
5
- (), . . . , . . . 500 , 10 190 . . . . . . . International Journal of Heat and Masstransfer, , Drying Technology Journal, , - , . . . , (1984, 1997, 2004), . . . (1985), . . . (1998), , (2001), . . (2005). . . (1991), (2007), - (2007). , , - , , . - 2001 . , , - . . : (1986), III (2002).
6
. . . . 21 1931 . . 1949 . - . , 1954 . 1954 1956 - . , . 1957 . . : , , , , . 1982 . , 2002 . , . . . . . 1962 . , 1972 . . - 1978 ., 1988 . 1985 . 2004 . . . - - .
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
08.12.1953 . , . 1980 . . . , , -. - . 09.1993-08.1994 . , . 4 04.2002., N 117 ( ). 12 - 41,38 %. : - , , . 05.2002 , 06.2002 - -
. 03.1998 . , N 189 . : , (. ). 04.1990-08.1993 . . , . 09.1993-08.1994 . , . 08.1994-03.1996 . 1- , . 05.1996-03.2000 . . 03.2000-05.2001 . - . 09.2005-08.2006 . - , - . I- , III . , .
19
20
21
22
23
26 1984 . 2001 135. , 2007 . 2006 , . 2008 . 2007 . , .
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
30 1969 . . 1992 - , -; 1997 , ; 2007 , . 1986 . , : 1992 1993 ; 1993 1998 - ; 1998 1999 - . 1999 2008 . 7 2008 ( 05.05.08 138-).
32
, ! , , . , -, , , , , , . 30 . , - , . , . , - , , , , . . , , , . 2007-2010 , 22.06.07 338. , , , , . 147 . . ( 2006 ). , , : , , , . 90 . , 5 . . , , , . : , , . , , , . . , , . , , . , . , 60 %, , . 40-45 % , , . 1,5 . 3 , 400 . 3 . 5 . 3 . (, , ), (, , , ). (), . , 0,5-0,65 . , . . 14-15 . , . (60 ), (200 ). .
33
, . - 12 . . , , - . (, , , , , , . .). , , . 2007 . 25,4 . . ( 2006 ). , 2008 / 2009 , . , 27.03.09 743 , 2009 / 2010 38 . 78 . . , . , , , , , . , . 14 , , . , - , . , 4-5 . . 50-60 . . 5 , 1,1 , 4,5 . / . . 1 000 . , 3-30 3 / , 150 . / , 5 . , , , , , , , , . 20 , . . , , 11 , , -, , -. , , , , , . . . , 120 . . , , . , . . , , , . : 7 % 10-12 3-5 . , , - . 22.12.06 1774 2010 . 2006-2010 , 35 . . , -
34
. , , . - . 5 . 6 2,6 / . 0,8 . , . - 2009-2010 150 . 3 .. 2,3 . ., 6 . . , . . . . . . . . ., - - - , , . - , . -53 . , . , . 6 . 18 . ., - , . . , 350 . . , - . , , . , , , , , , - . .
35
banks. He has assisted in closing transactions for the financing of end use energy efficiency projects, ESCOs, wind farms, biomass and solar projects in more than 30 countries of the Americas, Europe and Africa. Recently Cliff has served as financial advisor on renewable energy transactions in Poland, Romania, Bulgaria, Ukraine, Turkey and Italy for financial and strategic investors including Electricite de Portugal, Mid Europa Partners, RP Global, Ellakos, Fersa Renovables and Bilgin Elektrik. Cliff has also led the development of products throughout the CEE region for the financing of energy efficiency in residential blockhouses that have resulted in more than Euro 400 million in housing renovation investments. Prior to his involvement in international energy projects, Cliff was a leader in restructuring of the power sector in New York. Earlier, he spent thirteen years leading BEI Energy Corp., a successful New York-based ESCo he founded in 1982. As one of the pioneers of the US energy services industry and the founding President of the New York Energy Efficiency Council, Cliff helped develop the statutory framework authorizing implementation of performance contracts by public facilities in New York State. Cliff also was actively involved in gaining regulatory approval for the implementation of Demand Side Management programs and the competitive acquisition of DSM Resources by electric and gas utilities in New York State. In 1989, his firm delivered 3.5MW of reduced power consumption or negawatts to Con Edison. Cliff s company also operated a variety of DSM programs for area utilities and government agencies on a contract basis and installed, financed and operated 22 small gas-fired co-generation units.
36
Clifford J Aron, Principal, GreenMax Capital Advisors Cliff, one of the founders of GreenMax, is an energy finance expert who has had a diverse career as a business entrepreneur and energy and environmental sector specialist encompassing all aspects of management, marketing, project finance, policy and regulatory affairs. Cliff is an advisor to international financial institutions in the design, establishment and operation of energy sector finance and technical assistance programs and serves as advisor to commercial banks and investment funds on energy efficiency and renewable energy transactions. He has developed innovative sustainable energy related financial products for international financial institutions including IFC, the World Bank, EIB, KfW and the Dutch International Guarantees on Housing and for commercial lenders including Raifeissen, Dexia, Erste, OTP, SEB and Hansa
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
Alejandro Nieto
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
. : 24 1968 . . 1993 -. 2002 . . 1993 . 1993 . 1994 . 1996 . 1998 . 2005 . 2007 .
62
14-16 2009 . , : . 1) . 2) ? 3) ? 4) . 5) ! 6) . 7) .
1 1956. . . 1978. (). 1982. , 1985. . 1984. , 1990. (, ), , , , , . 1995. . . 2001. . , , 2002. . . 2005 . . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . , - . . . , , . - : , -
63
, , , , . - , . . .
- , , . 70- - . , , , . , , , . . , , . , , . (Hubbert, 1982) . 2010-2025 , . , -
. , , . , , , , . ? . , , . . 1. , , , - , , , , , , . , 2010-2030 , . . , , , . , , , , . , 50 2004 . 2030 60 ! , , , , . , , , . , , , , . 2010 6 % 63. . , . 2. - , , 2030 2006 . , . , . , , . , , . , - - 2010 , ( 3458-IV 22 2006 ) , . , . 2008 - - 2009-2012 , c ( 1317 8 2008 .), . , , , , . - -
64
- - . , , , . ? , . 3. . , 15$ / 5000 / ( ., 2006). , , , : 1) ; 2) ( ), . . (Al, Fe, Ti, V, P, B) 10-5-10-3 . % ( 0,1-10 ppm). , . : ) ; 2) ; 3) -; 4) . , . , . , , (Masahiko Bessho et al., 2009), . , . , ( 50 300 ppm) ( 99, Al2O3 < 0.10-0.25-0.50, CaO < 0.10. 1.65-3.0 %, SiO2 96.5-98.0 %. . SiO2 96.0 %. - . . 4 (, , ) ( ). ( ., 2006) 174057. ++1 7294 . 2. ++1 9579. , 2-299. (( ., 2006). 2505 . , - ( . .), - ( ), ( . .). , . , , ( , 2006), : 1) ( ); 2) ; 3) . 1936 . , 2-3. , . SiO2 96.0-98.7 %.
66
900, 38-110, 70. , , . . ( 50-55), 2 . 100, 3-10. - , , . SiO2 96.0-96.5 %, FeO 2.0 %. , . 50-60, 24-68, 40. 70 100 . . - 1958 20-30 . 1980-1984 , . . - . - 2, . (1-3), 0.3 18.8. SiO2 98.4-99.8 %. 13. , . -, , . , , . - . . . ( , 2001). , , . . , , , , - , . . , , - , . , ( , 2001; , 2003). , , -, - . , , . 0.1 0.5. - , . , . : , , , -, , (- ), (- ) ( ), ( , 2001; , 2003). , , . 9050 , . , , . . 585 . , , . 502020. 312 . , , .
67
- . 700, 50. -, , 1.5. , , , , , , , , . . 2100 . , 500 , 50. , , . . . , , , . . 5. . - - . , . , . , , , , . . 1. . ., . ., . . . . . II. . -. - , 2006. 552. 2. . ., . ., . . . : / / , 2001. 23., 1. . 11-22 3. . ., . ., . . XXI / / , 2006, 12. . 13-16 4. . . . . . . , , 2003. 5. Flem, B., Larsen R. B., Grimstvedt, A., Mansfeld, J In situ analysis of trace elements in quartz by using laser ablation inductively coupled mass spectrometry / / Chemical Geology, 2002, 182: . 237-247 6. Hubbert M. K. Oil and gas supply modeling: NBS special publication 631, U. S. Department of Commerce / / National Bureau of Standards (now the National Institute of Standards and Technology, NIST) May 1982. p. 90 7. Masahiko Bessho, Yasuhiro Fukunaka, Hiromu Kusuda et al. High-Grade Silica Refined from Diatomaceous Earth for Solar-Grade Silicon Production / / Energy Fuels, 2009, 23 (8). P. 4160-4165 8. Mller A., Kronz A., Breiter K Trace elements and growth patterns in quartz: a fingerprint of the evolution of the subvolcanic Podles Granite System (Krune Hory, Czech Republic). Bulletin of the Czech Geological Survey, 2002, 77 / 2: . 135145
68
, . 1998 . , . 2002 2003 ( ). . . . . .
69
1991 - - . 1991 . . . . 1998 . . . . 1991 2009 , , , . . . , , , . - . 2009 - . . . . 70 , , .
70
20 1955 . , 1978 , , . 1978 . . . , , . 1979 . . . .
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
. 1975. . 1992-1997- - . . 2006 . MBA 2007 - 1995: - ROTOS ( ), 2004: ( ), - . 2007: ( Fronius International GmbX), - . 2009: UNISOLAR, .
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
5 1959 . (-), 1962 , , . , . . 1991 -, , . 1996-98 . 1998 2004 . , , , . 2003 2006. - , . 2001 2008 , . 2003 - ( ). 2003 WWEA. 2005 INFORSE. 2007 . 2008 . 200 , , , , DIERET.
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93 03 1959. -. . . . 27 . : , , , . 8 5. 2007 - . . , 1995-2007 - , ; 1982-1995 - -, . . , 1976-1982 - . : . . , . , 1, , , 49047. / : +38 (056) 375-15-40 : 8 067 91 51 469 : [email protected] 23 1931. . . . . 54 . : , , . 4 , 36 , 8 - .. 57, 2.. . 2006 - , - ; 1993-2006 - , ; 1988 - ; 1968-1988 - ; 1955-1993 - , , , ; 1949-1955 - . : . . , . , 1, , , 49047. / : +38 (056) 375-15-40 : [email protected]
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
s ; s ; s , ; s ; s , , 100 . ; s ; s ; s , ; s ; s ; s , ; s ; s , ; s - .
102
, , . , , , . CMS Cameron McKenna Gide Loyrette Nouel, Baker & McKenzie. : s , , ; s , , / ; s ;
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
300 . -300 : . . . (), ELTEL (), . , , . . , : , ; ( , ) . - ; ; ; , , ; ; , ; , ; 600 ; .
112
, - 12.11.1979 . i ii 2002 . ( - ) (( - ). 2000 . 2002 2005 . 2005 2007 . - . 2007 -. .
-300 . . , , . , , , . , 8 % . , - 2005
. 100 , 300 . , , , , . . , , , , . . - 10 , - , , . , . , . , . , , . . , , , , , , . .. , . - VI , 25-27 2008, . 2009 ., 2010 . - , . - . .
3 : - (), . : ; 113 ; - , . , . , , - , , . . . : : ; ; . - . , 2.1 . , Vestas Nordex. 151 101 50 . , , 10 % 80 %. 900 . / , 16 % ( 2007 ). 300 . . . .
21.11.1951 . . 1974 . , . . , . . 1990 . -1. : , .
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
. 27.01.1949. . ( ., ). (1972), - - (1983). . . . (1983). (1995). , IHA (1996). , (1973-1979). (1979-1989). , - - (1989-1990). ( 1990). , . , , 15 . (1987), (2003). 300- - (2004). (1974) (1978) , (2001). 40 20 . , .
125
. : 2922 , , 600 800 . 15-20 200 . 1960- 1000 . , 2600 1261 . , . 90 800 , , 5-10 4 . . , . , . . , : () - , ; , . , , 0.95 10 . ., 0,9 - 20 . ., ; , , . .; 2-3 %, , 15 %; , ; , .
, . 126 , . 63 . 135,8 . , 60 . (95 %) ( 10 ). 10 20,1 500 . . , . 12,5 . ., 28 % . , . - 8,3 . . 81 () 320-420 . . , 5 % - . , , : ; ; , ; , ; ; , , . , , , . . 50-60- , . 1948 3337
(). 2. , . , . 3. 10 . 4. , 2002 . . . ,
: , , ; . -, , . 127 , , , : 1,4 5000 / ; 1,4 3 , , ; 3 . 15 25 , , , . 49 , 61 % , 14 % . , , , , 5,03 . * , 61 % , 5 150 . *. , 3 %. , 2000 . : -, , 2030., 2005. -, , , () , 2007. . , , : 1.
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
. 1979-1981 . . , , . 1993 : , , . , , - () - . , , - , , -. : , , , . , , , (1986.), , .
140
1949 . , . - , 1972 . (). : , , , 26- -
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
- ( , ; Richard Ivey School of Business, Canada). . 1994-1998 . . 1997 ( ). - , . 1998 - . , . - . 1998 . 2002 . 209- . . , - . 01.01.2002 - . 2002 . . . . 8 . : , , , , , .
154
, 1972 . . . , , (. ), , .
, . . : , ; ; ; ; ; ; ; , ; . , , , . : - , , . 30 % , ( , - . .) 40 %. . , -
, , . - , 155 . , , , . . , . ( ) , , . , -, , , -, . . , , . , . . , , , - , , , . , , . -
, . () - . , , (, ), , (, , , ). , , , : ; , , ; , , . , , , , , , . , , , - . , , , .
, , , , , , 10-14 %. , , 156 , 50 % , 5 %. , ( ) 8 %. - : ; 5-30 , , : , , ( , ), , ; , ; ( - , , , , . .); ; ( ); . - , . -
, 2005 . 2009 . , 2009 . , , , . : - , , -1430 , , - , 5 , - 1, . , . . , , , . , , . , , . . . , . .
157
1981 . 1982 . 1999 . - . , , , , ; , , , , 2- . - , (), (), (). 1999 . 2005 .
158
159
160
1971-1993 . - ( , , ). 1994 . . , . 2003 . . , -, 200 ( ). 2006 . . . . ( , ), - . (), 2006 . , . , : ; ; ; ; ; ; , , , .
161
, , , , 1997. - - : 12.01.1947 . : 1971 . , : - . 1994 . Duke University Fuqua School of Business Executive Education . : 1962 . c.
Yuriy Favorskyy WORK EXPERIENCE (briefly) Mar. 2005 - Now, Associate Professor National University `Kyiv Polytechnic Institute` (Ukraine) Nov.2004 - Now Deputy Director INSTITUTE OF RENEWABLE ENERGY` (Ukraine) Mar. 2004 - Nov.2004 Chief Engineer Institute of Renewable Energy, National Academy of Science (Kyiv, Ukraine) Dec. 2000 - Now (part-time job) Marketing Director `Svit Vitru`, Private Company (Kharkiv, Ukraine) Dec. 1999 - Now Technical Director AVANTE, private company (Kyiv, Ukraine) 1991-1999 Manager position in private companies (ZhytomirKyiv) 1988-1989 Engineer Zhytomir Research Institute of Complex Automatics EDUCATION (briefly) 2004 Certificate in Renewable Energy Technology (INFORSE) 1989-1991 MBA, Moscow Business School, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 1978-1984 Specialist degree in Electromechanic engineering, Kharkiv Aviation Institute
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
, . . ., ; - . 15 (, , , , .).
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
. : 1994 . 1995 . : 1999 1999 . . (). 2004 (, ). 2006 . 2007 . . . ( ). . . . . 2007 70 ( 8 100 ).
181
. 2004 . , : 1999-2004 - 1994-1999 - , - . 20 10 . 09.04.1955 . . 182 : , - (1974) . . . (), (1980) (1989).
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
: , , Tacis Managers Training Programme of the European Union. . ( ). . , , : 1998-2002 , , . 10 - , . 2002-2004 , . . 2004- . .
199
200
201
202
203
204
30 1980 . . . 1998 . . . : ( ) ( . . ). 2004 . . , . 2005 . . . . : , , , , . , , , .
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
. : 2006 - - (), 2008 - - (), : 06.2009 - , Camco International Ltd., http: / / www.camcoglobal.com 04.2008-05.2009, , http: / / ji. com. ua : 12.2006-03.2008, , http://ukrshpon.com.ua
213
214
215
216
217
218
. . . -, . IT 5 . 2008 Energy. ua
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232