fidis - future of identity in the information society identity in the context of civil law -...
TRANSCRIPT
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
Identity in the Context of Identity in the Context of Civil Law - discussionCivil Law - discussion
FIDIS - WP 2Fontainebleau - 10th December 2004
Wim Schreurs (V.U.B.-L.S.T.S.)
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
OverviewOverview
Decisions in Civil Case law
E.U. Legislation on Data Retention
Relationship & discussion
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
Case law :Case law :
Indicator for future application of law
Not only look to data protection cases
Other concept of (approach to) data protection and privacy in civil cases than in criminal cases?
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
TestAchat/EMI – SONY et aliaTestAchat/EMI – SONY et alia
In the field of copyright
Facts : (anti-copying) technology infringing mandatory legislation
France Belgium : confusion
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
TestAchat/EMI – SONY et aliaTestAchat/EMI – SONY et alia
Inspiring to questions / remarks...
Analogy with Identity Management Systems
Can you prevent “illegal” technology?
Proportionality and consent principle.
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
R.I.A.A. Vs. Many OthersR.I.A.A. Vs. Many Others
Interesting link between data protection law and intellectual property law
They both deal with information
Use copyright mechanisms for data protection?
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
R.I.A.A. Vs. Many OthersR.I.A.A. Vs. Many Others
Facts : “ R.I.A.A. (a private organisat. representing music industry) searches for illegal content on PC’s, searches for the IPnumbers and forces ISP’s to give personal data (name & address)”
But : R.I.A.A. : Right to search my PC? Software : Right to provide my IP? ISP : Right to provide my identity?
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
Pessers vs. Lycos (Holland)Pessers vs. Lycos (Holland)
Facts : conditional anonimity ([email protected])
Legal Tools for organising de- anonymisation : 5- Steps Test California Bill
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
4 Steps test (case law)4 Steps test (case law)
Facts : conditional anonimity ([email protected])
Legal Tools for organising de- anonymisation : 5- Steps Test California Bill
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
California Draft LegislationCalifornia Draft Legislation Procedure for de-anonymising
1. plaintiff sends suit to de-anonymise to a SP
2. SP notifies the suit to the anonymus + copy
3. Anonymus has reasonable term to defend against this suit. and sends his defence to SP who sends it to judge
4. judge makes a judgement on defence.
5. if demander misuses this procedure, he should pay damages
Assembly Bill 1143. (info.sen.ca.gov).
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
Draft Framework Decision of the Council of the European Union dd. april 2004.
IN GENERAL tele-phony
sms, ems, mmms
Ipn°, sub-sets
www, url, http
Ftp, Ntp, voip vobb
Future comm. Technologies
traffic data xx xx xx xx xx xx
location data xx xx xx xx xx xx
user data xx xx xx xx xx xx
subscriber data xx xx xx xx xx xx
source of communication xx xx xx xx xx xx
routing of communication xx xx xx xx xx xx
destination of communication xx xx xx xx xx xx
time & date of communication xx xx xx xx xx xx
duration of communication xx xx xx xx xx xx
communication device xx xx xx xx xx xx
location start and throughout duration of the communication xx xx xx xx xx xx
FIDIS - Future of Identity in the Information Society
[© Anonequity.org]