federal supereme court cassation decisions volume 15

527

Upload: leliem

Post on 01-Jan-2017

547 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • - 15

    2006 .

    www.chilot.me

  • /

    15 2005 2006 . 15 / www.fsc.gov. et

  • I

    2005 2006 .

    .

    //

    1.

    /

    /////.5

    80343

    ///

    06/2005 2

    www.chilot.me

  • II

    . 377/96 96(1)97 109 138(1)

    /////. 80(2)

    2.

    . 377/96 27(1)

    82091

    25/2005 9

    3.

    . 377/96

    ///.2574(2)

    .377/96 43(4) ()

    84661

    27/2005 12

    4.

    ()

    . 377/96 162(1-4)

    79476

    ( )

    12/2005 17

    5.

    . 377/96 2(3),4

    81814 /

    (12 )

    18/2005 24

    6.

    ()

    86284

    (.)

    13/2005 27

  • III

    . 377/96 27(1)(), 13(3)

    7.

    . 377/96 162

    ... 42(2)

    87338

    ..

    ( )

    21/2005 30

    8.

    377/96 85(4)

    87285 /

    23/2006 34

    9.

    . 377/96 27(1)(), 17(1)()(), 14(2)()

    90389

    18/2006 38

    10.

    -

    . 377/96 3(2)()

    . 494/98 2(1)()

    92466

    02/2006 41

    www.chilot.me

  • IV

    11. 3

    4/2004 6

    ///.1140, 1149

    82670 /

    09 /

    ( )

    09/2005 46

    12. /

    ///. 2011(1),2003 ,1730(1)

    84330

    /

    (

    )

    10/2005 50

    13.

    ///. 2950(1) (2), 1687

    81163

    11/2005 55

    14.

    79794

    22/2005 59

  • V

    ///. 1790, 1800, 2102(1)(2)

    ..

    15. ()

    ///. 1727, 1728(3), 2005

    83674 /

    19/2005 65

    16.

    /// 1818, 2162

    90862 /

    /

    14/2006 69

    17. 3

    ///. 2957(1)(2), 1731

    . 3/2004,

    4/2004

    86847

    ( )

    18/2006 73

    18.

    86813

    22/2006 77

    www.chilot.me

  • VI

    ///. 1827(1)

    ( )

    19.

    / //

    ///. 2008, 2007, 2001, 2005

    86187

    21/2005 80

    - 20. /

    /////.223234137(3)145256,136-138,246,248

    77983

    (

    )

    /

    24/2005 87

    21. / ()

    (

    )

    /////. 8(1),11,244, 245

    81275 /

    05/2005 92

    22. 83007 / 03/2005 98

  • VII

    /////. 5(1)

    .... 79(2)

    ( )

    23. /

    - -

    /

    /////. 30(1)324(1) (),215(2)17(3)

    83169

    //

    28/2005 103

    24. / /

    /////. 277

    ///. 3312 3324

    85873 /

    13/2005 108

    25. /

    86551 /

    /

    25/2005 112

    www.chilot.me

  • VIII

    /////. 182(1) ,92, 225, 226, 250,136

    26.

    /////. 358

    /////. 358

    79871 /

    ( )

    /

    ( )

    11/2005 116

    27.

    /

    ... 37(1), 79(1)

    /////. 4

    80202

    ( )

    12/20

    05

    120

    28. /

    ////. 33, 80, 222, 225, 226 231

    83915

    29/2005 123

    29.

    ///. 1195,1196

    /////. 6,358,378

    78(1), 79(1)(4) , 37

    42501

    (

    )

    28 /2005

    126

  • IX

    30. ()

    -

    /////. 231(1)(), 33(2-3), 222, 224

    82234

    /

    ( )

    26/2005 130

    31.

    /////. 136, 137, 272, 327(3), 345

    72980 /

    ( )

    06/2004 134

    32.

    / (Declaratory Judgment)

    /

    82679 /

    /

    27/2005 138

    33. /

    /

    /////. 358

    /

    /////. 358,360,277(1)(2)

    83582 /

    /

    ( )

    27/2005 144

    34. /////. 5

    /

    ()

    84446

    24/2005 149

    www.chilot.me

  • X

    /////. 5, 32

    35. /

    /////. 212

    85718

    03/2005 153

    36.

    ()

    /////. 234(1) ()(), 215(2), 235(2)

    86454 /

    ( )

    23/2005 156

    37.

    /////. 241

    /////. 246-248

    /////. 222, 234, 235, 236, 83, 224, 182, 241, 246-248, 251, 255

    86510

    ///

    /./

    18/2005 160

    38. / 60

    87190

    21/2006 164

  • XI

    39.

    /

    /

    /////. 5,212

    ///. 881

    85102

    21/2006 168

    40. /////. 418 -

    -

    /////. 418, 419, 421

    86133

    ( )

    /

    ( )

    20/2006 172

    41.

    89494

    19/2006 177

    www.chilot.me

  • XII

    /////. 145(1)(2),

    42.

    /////. 5(2)

    90543

    ( )

    /

    21/2006 183

    43. -

    -

    ///// 481

    449(1)()

    92459

    /

    19/2006 186

    44.

    /

    /////. 462-464

    91103

    ..

    /

    ( )

    16/2006 188

    45. /

    90452

    14/2006 191

  • XIII

    /////. 78(2), 70()

    /

    46. /

    /////. 6(1)

    /////. 6(1)

    403405

    91968

    /

    15/2006 194

    47.

    /

    /

    /////. 234(1)

    85468

    ..

    24/2006 197

    48.

    ()

    87834

    /

    /

    21/2006 204

    www.chilot.me

  • XIV

    3 3

    / ()

    3

    ///. 3311

    /////. 358

    (

    )

    49.

    (Interlocutory order)

    /////. 320(3)(4)

    89893

    ///

    24/2005 207

    50. (Review of Judgement)

    ()

    /

    /////. 6(1)()()

    . 25/88

    ... 80(3)()

    93137 /

    /

    11/2006 210

    51. /

    83771

    10/2005 214

  • XV

    /

    /////. 136

    /

    (

    )

    52.

    () ()

    90298

    /

    10/2006 217

    53.

    3

    . 127 (),145(),

    79561

    08

    /

    11/2005 221

    54.

    ()

    211, 517, 518, 532(1)

    82503 /

    (

    )

    //

    21/2005

    224

    55. ()

    85009

    ( )

    21/2006 229

    www.chilot.me

  • XVI

    . 147/91 21, 18, 32, 19

    106/96 20(2) 123

    56.

    657, 675

    83489

    19/2005 233

    57. (Collation)

    ///. 1065-1078

    80920 /

    25/2005 237

    58.

    ///. 973, 974

    82585 /

    (

    )

    ( )

    13/2005 240

    59.

    ///. 996(1), 998(1), 999

    89641 /

    ( )

    /

    (

    )

    21/2006 243

  • XVII

    /////. 91, 6

    60. /

    /

    /////. 5(1)(2), 244(2)(), 245(2)

    188/92 5(4), 6(2)

    ... 34(5)

    93779 /

    30/2005 247

    61.

    /////. 231 (1)()

    ///. 32(1) 36(1)

    95995 /

    -

    10/2006 251

    62. /

    ///. 42 , 33(1) , (2)

    87420 /

    24/2005 254

    // 63.

    ()

    286/94 37(7)

    79189

    /

    ..

    9/2005 258

    www.chilot.me

  • XVIII

    //

    64.

    /

    /

    . 285/94 49

    . 286/94 96, 162

    ... 13(2)

    78/94

    ICCPR- 11

    84623 .

    (

    )

    /

    04/2005 261

    65.

    686/2002 2(10), 36, 60(1)

    86388

    ///

    /

    17/2005 268

    66. /

    (VAT )

    ( )

    86597

    ..

    21/2006 271

  • XIX

    285/94 56(3),(), 3(1)(), 2(11), 3(1)()

    609/2001 2, 19(50) ()

    67. ()

    .285/94 3(1)(3), 16(1)()

    82061

    /

    20/2006 274

    68. ()

    285/94 11(1)(2) 22(1)(3)

    609/2001 11(1)

    23(2) 58(3)

    139/1999

    86672

    /

    ( )

    22/2006 277

    69.

    ()

    89640

    23/2006 281

    www.chilot.me

  • XX

    ///. 2010, 2011, 2090, 2091, 2141, 2152, 2153

    /////. 136, 138, 180 (1)

    70.

    ///. 1179

    ///.1179

    .... 11,27 (1-3)

    UDHR-Art. 18

    ICCPR.Art. 18(1)

    85979 (/)

    /

    13/2005 286

    71. 3

    88798

    /

    08 /

    ( )

    18/2005 291

    72.

    80241

    ..

    ( )

    12/2005 295

  • XXI

    ()

    73.

    ()

    334/1995 2(1), 4(1), 5(1)()

    83060 / /

    /

    21/2005 300

    74.

    ... - 40(1), 37

    /////. 1206

    83665 /

    /

    ( )

    22/2005 305

    75.

    88084 /

    /

    ( )

    19/2006 309

    www.chilot.me

  • XXII

    ///. 1195, 1196, 2884, 2882-2884

    ... 40(1)(2)

    76.

    47/67

    ///. 2257

    86049

    /

    ( )

    20/2006 313

    77.

    ///. 1677, 1896, 2081, 18, 2156

    /////. 36(2)

    89504

    ( )

    22/2006 317

    78.

    91710

    16/2006 319

  • XXIII

    ()

    /// 28 29(2), 2142

    .

    79. ( )

    ()

    ... 36(2), 15, 25

    3, 6(1)

    4(1), 5(1)

    ///. 2126(2), 2127, 2130 2131, 2089(2), 2081(1)

    92020 ...

    ( )

    15/2005 323

    80.

    3

    /

    ///. 2069

    88432

    22/2006 327

    81. /

    82154

    24/2005

    330

    www.chilot.me

  • XXIV

    ///. 2126, 2127 (1)(2)(3)

    82. /

    . 686/2002 61

    81934

    / 5

    /

    50

    28/2005

    336

    83.

    /

    . 622/2001 87(1), (5), (9), (10),

    146/2000

    86817

    ..

    22/2006 338

    84.

    /

    .377/96 138, 142

    /////. 9(1), 231(1)(),

    . 416/96 41(1),

    89530

    21/2006 341

  • XXV

    85.

    / /

    147/91 49(1-4), 47(1), 26(2), 39(1)()(), 152

    402/96 46

    106/96 14()()()

    90737

    /

    (

    )

    16/2006 344

    86. /

    ()

    /

    . 25/88 5(6),14

    ... 80(4)

    64(4)

    /////. 9, 231(1)()

    90920

    .

    06/2006 347

    87. /

    ( )

    ///. 2149

    /////. 141

    78470

    07/2005 351

    88. 85237 / 27/2005 355

    www.chilot.me

  • XXVI

    ( )

    2(5), 678, 696() 378

    23

    89.

    194(1) (2)190192

    85596

    25/2005 359

    90. (Legitimate self-defense)

    ()

    78 ,79

    86570

    07/2005 363

    91.

    10%

    667(1)

    80119

    11/2005 367

    92.

    32/1//702/3/219/2/

    79389 /

    ( )

    /

    12/2005 371

  • XXVII

    93.

    411

    411(), 407

    86845 -

    -

    /

    22/2006 374

    94.

    2, 23(2), 3, 61

    ////. 112

    83/86 59(1), (), 2(),

    81178

    /

    ( )

    21/2006 380

    95. ()

    27(1), 581(), 540

    90089

    ////

    20/2006 384

    96.

    93741

    14/2005 387

    www.chilot.me

  • XXVIII

    59(1), 543(2), 57

    97.

    481(1)()

    809()

    481(1)(), 809()

    93173

    (

    )

    /

    17/2006 391

    98.

    675

    89276

    23/2006 395

    99.

    223(1) 32(1)

    91535

    // /

    12/2006 400

  • XXIX

    /////. 111112141142

    100.

    657

    78180

    /

    09/2005 405

    101.

    ///. 1678()

    90793

    ( )

    04/2006 410

    102. /

    /

    /

    /////. 458-460

    78206 /

    (

    )

    20/2005 415

    103.

    /////. 403

    /

    88867

    28/2006 423

    www.chilot.me

  • XXX

    /

    /////. 403

    /////. 403, 378

    104.

    ///// 428(1)

    89088

    17/2006 426

    105.

    ()

    /////. 378

    85764 /

    ( )

    21/2006 429

    106. /

    3

    81023

    5/2005 433

  • XXXI

    ///. 1197(2)

    ( )

    107. / 3

    /////. 351(2)(), 317, 318()

    399

    . . 6/2000 31

    80301

    24/2005 440

    108.

    208/92 56

    88060

    /

    23/2006 444

    109.

    ()

    88959

    6

    /

    17/2006 447

    www.chilot.me

  • XXXII

    361/95 11(2)()(), 38

    110.

    . 44/1991 78, 79, 82(1)(2), 83(1)(3),

    84(), 85, 86()

    ... 25, 37

    92546

    ...

    /

    18/2006 450

    111.

    -

    . 621/2001 2/2/3/4/14/5/14/2/690111/2/112108110

    168/2002 18/3/10/2/36

    75877

    23/2005 454

  • 1

    www.chilot.me

  • 2

    //. 80343

    6 2005 ..

    - /

    - /// -

    - -

    . 377/96

    96(1)

    /

    ///

    335,680

    . 377/96 96(1) 97 109

    24,000

    -

    /

    -

  • 3

    139,219.9

    /

    / ///// 348(1)

    .377/96

    96(3) /

    96 3

    109

    /

    /

    . 377/96 96(1)

    109

    138(1)()

    96(3)

    www.chilot.me

  • 4

    3

    96(1) 96(3)

    -

    ///// 80(2)

    -

    ///// 92

    ////

    -

    -

    24,000

    ///// 5

    ///// 5(2) /

    139,219.9

    /// /

    -

  • 5

    1. /// // 23356 20 2004 /

    // / 117346 18 2004 / ///// 348(1)

    2.

    . 377/96 96(1)

    3. 96(1)

    4.

    1.

    377/96 96(1)

    24,900 ( )

    377/96 96

    3

    www.chilot.me

  • 6

    139,219.90 ( )

    2.

    96(1)

    377/96 96(3)

    377/96 1

    3

    377/96 96

    3. 377/96 95

    102

    96 99

    101 102 95

    4. 96

    1

    96 2

    93 3

    377/96

    96 3

    1

    96 3 The

    provision of sub Art 1 of this article shall not affecte the right of the workers to claim

    damage in accordance with the relevant law where an ocupational injury is a resulet of

  • 7

    fault on the part of the employer 96 3

    95 102

    5. 377/96 96 3

    96 1 101 102

    96

    3

    377/96 12 4

    377/96 96 3

    12(4)

    96 3

    () (civil sanction) 96

    1

    96 3

    1

    6. 96 3

    95 102

    96 3

    7.

    2094

    95 102

    www.chilot.me

  • 8

    12 4

    96 3

    2094

    95 102

    95 102

    () 96 2

    12 4 2035

    2094

    /

  • 9

    //. 82091

    25 25 ..

    - /

    -

    - -

    ? /

    2 26 24 .

    377/96 27/1//

    //

    13 24 .

    www.chilot.me

  • 10

    ()

    /

    2

    26

    377/96 27(1)()

    /

    - -

  • 11

    1. / // 125715 18/11/24

    .

    2.

    3. -

    -

    2,125. / / 9. / /

    15. / / 4. /

    /

    4.

    .

    www.chilot.me

  • 12

    //. 84661

    27 2005 ..

    - /

    - -

    - - /

    ///

    -

    11

    2003 /

    -

    /

    -

  • 13

    -

    ///2577(2)

    // //

    //// 337

    -

    377/1996

    -

    192/2003

    -

    ? ?

    192/2003

    192/2003 19 2003 /

    12 27 2004 /

    www.chilot.me

  • 14

    122/1998

    //

    -

    ///2573

    6 377/1996

    //. 2574 (2)

    2002 / -

    51(1)

    //

    377/1996 43(4)()

  • 15

    //. 2577(2) (1)

    //.2577(2)

    -

    www.chilot.me

  • 16

    1. /// //03537 15/10/2004 /

    // //126268 17/12/2004/

    /////348(1)

    2.

    377/1996

    43(4)() 180

    3.

    /////348(1)

    4.

    5.

    /

  • 17

    //. 79476

    12 25 ..

    - /

    - VC

    -

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    9.

    10.

    11.

    12.

    13.

    14.

    15.

    16.

    17.

    18.

    19.

    20.

    21.

    22.

    23.

    24.

    25.

    26.

    27.

    28.

    29.

    30.

    31.

    32.

    33.

    34.

    35.

    36.

    37.

    38.

    39.

    40.

    41.

    www.chilot.me

  • 18

    42.

    43.

    44.

    45.

    46.

    47.

    48.

    49.

    50.

    51.

    52.

    53. /

    54.

    55.

    56.

    57.

    58.

    59.

    60.

    61.

    62.

    63.

    64.

    65.

    66.

    67.

    68.

    69.

    70.

    71.

    72.

    73.

    74.

    75.

    76.

    77.

    78.

    79.

    80.

    81.

    82.

    83.

    84.

    85.

    86.

    87.

    88.

    89.

    90.

    91. /

    92. /

    93.

    94.

    95.

    96.

  • 19

    377/96

    22 2003 .

    1999 / 01 2001 / 30 2002

    . 01 2002 / 2002 /

    01

    2002 / 18

    www.chilot.me

  • 20

    1284 86 93 67 827 53.5561 6974 81 85 94

    5 9 1929 31 3846

    48 53 56 69 73 7479 81 82 848 5

    377/96 162/1/

    ? ?

    1999

    / 2001 / 01 2002 /

    2002 /

    30 2001 /

    02

    2001

    377/1996 162/3/

    162/1/

    22 2003 /

    2001 /

  • 21

    377/96 .377/96 162-

    166 .377/96

    162 /1/

    . 377/96 162 /2/ /3/ /4/

    162

    162/2/

    162/4/

    .377/96 162

    /3/

    .

    www.chilot.me

  • 22

    //

    162/3/

    /2/ /4/

    ... .. .. 0thher payments ~

    ?

    . 377/96 162

    /2/ /4/

    /1/

    . 377/96 162

    377/96 162/3/

    162/1/

  • 23

    30 2002 . 22 2003 .

    1. 07 2004 .

    / 07453 04 2004 .

    ///// 348 (1)

    2.

    377/1996 162 (3)

    3.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 24

    //. 81814

    18 2005 ..

    -

    - / (12 )

    -

    //// /

    377/96

    ///

    07/11/2003 .. ..

    "" ""

    1,242

    23/04/2002 ..

  • 25

    35 81011 12

    124 9

    28/11/2003 ..

    1,242

    /

    377/96 4

    8 9

    3 4

    ///

    /

    /

    /

    ?

    www.chilot.me

  • 26

    /

    377/96

    4

    377/96 2(3)

    4(1)

    ... 1711

    ...1731(1)

    /

    1. //// .. 73969 02/08/2004 .. /// ..

    119009 24/09/2004 .. ..... 348(1)

    2.

    3.

    /

  • 27

    // 86284

    13 2005 /

    - /

    - (.)

    -

    377/96

    //

    390 /

    / 580 / /

    190 / /

    190

    //

    190

    www.chilot.me

  • 28

    377/96 43 3

    390 / /

    580 / /

    377/96 27/1/

    9 2005 .

    6 2005 .

    ?

    390 / /

    390

    580 190 /

    / 190

    390

    377/96 /1/ /

  • 29

    // 377/96

    13/3/

    27/1/

    1.

    2. 377/96 27/1/

    3.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 30

    //. 87338

    21 2005 ..

    -

    - .. - /

    - 1/

    2/

    3/

    4/

    5/ /

    377/1996

    -

  • 31

    ...

    377/1996

    -

    www.chilot.me

  • 32

    377/1996

    ... 42(2)

    162

    377/1996 77(5)

  • 33

    12(1()) 12(2) 53 54

    377/1996

    1. / 24912 06

    2005 / ///// 348(1)

    2.

    3.

    26 2005 ..

    www.chilot.me

  • 34

    //. 87285

    23 2006 ..

    -

    /

    - /

    - /

    377/1996

    1975 / 21 2004 /

    21 2004 / 30

    2004 /

    -

    21 2004 /

    /

    21 2004 /

    377/1996 27(1())

  • 35

    21 2004 / 30 2004 /

    377/1996 85(4)

    www.chilot.me

  • 36

    377/1996 85

    377/1996 39

    1

    377/1996 43(3)

    43(3)

  • 37

    1. / 04639 22 2004 /

    / 12679 28 2005 /

    ///// 348(1)

    2.

    3. 377/1996 39

    42/4/ 35/1//

    2004 / 21

    21 2004 / 43

    4.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 38

    //. 90389

    18 2006 ..

    -

    - /

    -

    1. // 23-10-2002 .

    // 27-04-2004 . 30-05-

    2004 .

    // 10-02-

    2004

    27-03-2004 .

    2.

  • 39

    3. 22-09-2005 .

    3-11-2005 .

    11-11-2005 .

    4.

    ?

    5. 10 2004 .

    16-02-2004 .

    6. 10-2-2002 . 27 2004 .

    27/03/2004

    ..

    30 2004 .

    23 2004 .

    7.

    www.chilot.me

  • 40

    377/96 27 1//

    //

    377/96 17/1/ // 14/2//

    8.

    1.

    2.

    3.

    /

  • 41

    //. 92466

    2 2006 ..

    -

    -

    /

    -

    /

    22/06/02 .

    -

    /

    /

    .

    377/96 3 .494/98 2//

    www.chilot.me

  • 42

    / ..42901

    /////. 244/2/ //

    /

    . 494/98 2//

    /

    .. 42901

    / /////. 341

    /

    / /

    ?

    ?

    -

    . 377/96 3/2/ //

    494/98 2(1) ()

    ? ?

  • 43

    /

    / /

    /

    /

    . 377/96 3/2// .494/98 2/1//

    www.chilot.me

  • 44

    1. / //. 135628 2/11/2005 .

    /////. 348/1/

    2. / //. 81696 15/8/2005 .

    /////. 348/1/

    3.

    4.

    5.

    /

  • 45

    www.chilot.me

  • 46

    //. 82670

    09 2005 ..

    - /

    - 1/ / 09 / -

    2/ -

    - - -

    // 83247

    /

    / 09 528//

    1

    2

    22 2004 /

    2

    2

    01 2000 /

    2006 /

    1 2

    2

    2 1

    2

    3000.00

  • 47

    1 2

    2

    /

    2

    2

    / 2

    2

    06

    1996 /

    6 1997 /

    2

    1997 / 2004 /

    2

    1

    1

    /

    4/2004

    www.chilot.me

  • 48

    /

    1996 / 2

    06 1997 /

    /

    /

    / 2

    /////

    92 528/

    2

    1

    2

    2

    /

    1

    2

  • 49

    /

    1

    4/2004 6 /// 1140 1149

    1. / / 04938 24 2004 /

    / / 17796 17 2004 / 17696

    15 2004 / 18358 4

    2004 / / 18247 19 2004 /

    ///// 348(1)

    2.

    1

    3.

    / 83247

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 50

    //. 84330

    10 2005 ..

    -

    - //

    -1. /

    2. /

    3.

    4.

    5. /

    - 22/10/2002

    /

    30,000

    9,000 20,000

    6,000

    -

    22/10/2002 /

  • 51

    4,000

    22/10/2002 /

    30,000 /

    1

    2

    30,000

    20,000

    ///1890(2)

    /////337

    -

    ()

    ///17191726 1727 200120032005 2012

    ( )

    -

    www.chilot.me

  • 52

    022956 01/10/2002 /

    6

    -

    -

    -

    ?

    ?

    30,000

    4,000

    ///2011(1)

    ///2003

    ///1730(1)

  • 53

    30000

    // 2635

    ///1730(1)

    www.chilot.me

  • 54

    1. // //147419 05/02/2005 /

    ////348(1)

    2.

    3.

    /

  • 55

    //. 81163

    11 2005 ..

    - /

    -

    - /

    /// //

    1

    1 1997. 3 21.

    519.45 1 21 .

    13,800

    1/7/21. 3 22 . 18

    13,800 156,429

    1 23 . 13,800

    13,800

    /

    1 21 .

    13,800

    www.chilot.me

  • 56

    1 21 . 15 24 .

    13,800 387,990.45

    // / /////

    337

    25 24.

    13,800

    ///

    1684

    /// 295

    /

    /

    ///. 1684

    ? ?

    /

    ///. 1684 (2)

  • 57

    ///. 2950(1)

    5,109.45

    13,800

    ///. 2950(2)

    // 1 2001 .

    13,800

    //

    www.chilot.me

  • 58

    1. // //

    13,800 1 2001 .

    387,990.45

    ///// 348(1)

    2. // / 05667 1

    2001 /

    /// / 343(1)

    3.

    4. 24 2005 .

    /

  • 59

    //. 79794

    22 2005 ..

    - /

    - ..

    - /

    - 01 1990 /

    10/11/12 672

    16 2001 /

    151,725.25

    150,848.00

    20,000.00 4000.00

    01

    2001 / 30 2002 / 528,000.00

    302,573.25

    6(12) 30,000.00 860,573.25

    www.chilot.me

  • 60

    01 2001 /

    16 2001 /

    528,000.00

    50,000.00

    30,000.00

    302,573.25

    488,000.00 29 2002 /

    2000.00( )

    488,000.00 244,000.00(

    )

    302,573.25

  • 61

    16 2001 /

    151,725.25

    150,848.00

    20,000.00 4000.00

    01 2001 / 30 2002 /

    528,000.00

    302,573.25

    ? ?

    ? ?

    ... 80(3()) 25/1988 10

    www.chilot.me

  • 62

    ///

    1678()17311790 1757

    /// 1678()17181771(1)1790

    // 1790(1)

    ? ?

    // 1790

    /// 1800

    /// 1790(2)

    //

    2102(1)

    ///

    2102(2)

    20,000.00 4000.00

    528,000.00

  • 63

    4000.00

    40,000.00 528,000.00

    488,000.00

    60,000.00

    24,000.00

    /// 1799(1) /// 1800

    ///

    1790(2)179918001802 2102

    www.chilot.me

  • 64

    1. / 97396 30 2003 /

    / 65129 27 2004 /

    ///// 348(1)

    2. 302,573.25(

    ) 244,000.00(

    ) 2000.00( )

    3.

    /

  • 65

    //. 83674

    19 2005 ..

    -

    - / - -

    - - -

    - 30 2000 /

    10 3798 200,000.00( )

    55,000.00

    145,000.00 ( )

    30,000.00( )

    5000.00 ( ) 55,000.00 ( )

    5000.00

    ...

    40(3)

    /// 2005

    www.chilot.me

  • 66

    3798

    647 .

    30 2000 /

    ? ?

    30 2000 /

    200 .

    3798

    200 . 647 /

  • 67

    30 2000 / "

    "

    10 3798 200 / /10/02/93-

    4208/22572/01

    200,000.00 ( ) 55,000.00

    145,000.00(

    )

    //.1728/3/

    /// 1728(3)

    //. 1727 1728/3/

    3

    30/05/2000 /

    /// 2005 1723 1728(3)

    www.chilot.me

  • 68

    1. / 103872 30 2003 /

    / 71988 30 2004 /

    ///// 348(1)

    2. // / / 166591 20 2003 .

    30 2000 /

    ///// 342 348(1)

    3. 30 2000 . /// 1728(3)

    5000.00( )

    30 2000 / (9%)

    4.

    /

  • 69

    //. 90862

    14 2006.

    -

    - /

    - /

    //

    20 2002 .

    10 1992 / 30 1992

    / 10,000.00 ( )

    01 147 /

    //

    / 07334

    /

    20,800.00( )

    // 88,330.00( )

    109,130.00( )

    www.chilot.me

  • 70

    20,800.00

    41,507.87( )

    62,307.87( )

    41,507.87( )

    600.00 3,487.95

    103,815.75( )

    -

    / 07334

  • 71

    /

    83,015.75 /

    /

    // 1818

    /

    /// 1818

    www.chilot.me

  • 72

    /// 1818 ///

    2162

    // 18182162

    1. / 113645 06 2004 /

    / 147924 09 2005 /

    ///// 348/1/

    2. / 01302 22 2003 /

    ///// 348(1)

    3. 41,507.87 (

    )

    4.

    /

  • 73

    //. 86847

    18 2006 .

    -

    -

    -1.

    2. /

    3. 8 /

    /

    / 8

    4-078/879/

    1 2 05 2003 /

    25 2004 /

    15,000.00

    3 1 2

    3/2004 4/2004

    www.chilot.me

  • 74

    1 2 18,000.00

    3

    1 2

    /

    /

    3/2004 4/2004

    3 1 2

    1 2

    /

    1 2

    /

    /

    1 2 3

    1 2

  • 75

    ? ?

    /

    / 18210 18209

    03 2004 /

    / 04905 7/10/2004 /

    / 18210 / 04905 07 2004

    30 2005 /

    1 2

    3 1 2

    1 2

    ...

    80(3() 25/1988 10

    ///2957(1) 3

    3 3 /// 2957

    2

    3 3

    // 1731(1)2957(2)

    www.chilot.me

  • 76

    3/2004 4/2004 1 2

    3

    1. // 04905 07/10/2004 /

    //18210 30/02/2005 /

    // 19016 12/04/2005 /

    /////348(1)

    2.

    3.

    /

  • 77

    //. 86813

    22 2006 .

    - /

    - /

    1.

    2.

    3. 2

    ///

    /

    1

    54,150 6,338 61,088

    2 3 1

    30,000

    1

    2 3 1 6

    1

    / 1

    1500

    www.chilot.me

  • 78

    2 3 1

    1

    //

    ///// 337 /

    1

    2 3

    / 2 3

    2 3 /

    2

    2 3 1

    2 3 1

    /

    ///

    1827/1/

    2

    2 3

    /

  • 79

    1. / //// 348/1/

    2.

    3. /

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 80

    // 86187

    21 2005 ..

    - /

    :- -

    :- -

    /

    /

    1998 . 10

    1999 / 10 1999 /

    7,079,604.86 (

    ) 10 1999 /

    946,270.06 (

    )

    8,025,874.92 (

    92/100 ) 6

    6

    03 2001 /

  • 81

    10 1999 / 1999 /

    10 1999 /

    946,270.06

    500.00

    1 1999 .

    /

    1 1999 .

    /. 87441

    25 2004 . -

    1 1999 .

    7,079,604.86

    946,270.06

    500.00

    www.chilot.me

  • 82

    8,025,874.92 /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    ?

    /

    1 1999 .

    ///// 234/1//

    /

    /// 21 25 /

    1 1999 .

    /// 27

    ?

    / /// 28

    /

    /

  • 83

    /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    -

    ///// 207

    ? / -

    - 80(3)() 25/88 10 22

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 84

    /

    ?

    /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    10 1999 .

    7,079,604.86

  • 85

    /

    / /

    /

    1. / //// 78275 20 2005

    .

    2.

    3.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 86

    -

  • 87

    //. 77983

    24 25 ..

    - /

    - 1. -

    2. /

    3.

    4.

    5. /

    - /

    -

    // 19/2 816 1

    /

    1/2 KH-B2 B104

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 88

    2 GEB1 Co/04

    2-52682 /

    3-46778 /

    2-42462 .

    3-6469

    1

    594/13/2

    25 2 .

    2 3 5

    213/1992 68 69

    4

    // 2208 2209 2188

    1 4 //

    70423 5 // 70623 /

    /

    /

  • 89

    /

    25 2005 /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    / ...

    80(3()) 25/1988 10

    www.chilot.me

  • 90

    /

    ?

    ///// 136 137 138 246 247 248 256

    ///// 223 234 137(3) 145 256

    1 / 25 2003 /

    /

  • 91

    2208(1)

    2209 (1)

    2211(1)

    2187(1)

    2188(1)

    1. / 99766 01 2003 .

    / 7042370632 24 2004 .

    ///// 348(1)

    2.

    3.

    21 2004 .

    /

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 92

    //. 81275

    5 2005 ..

    - /

    :- / -

    :- -

    / /

    /

    400,000.00

    ( ) /

    / 37363 25/06/2003 /

    400,000.00 ( )

    21 1998 /

    30 2000 /

    // / 02 B6/14

    05 2001 /

    02 2002 /

    / / 45441

    06 2002 /

    / / 45441

  • 93

    12 1998 / 21 1998 /

    21 1998 / 21 1998 /

    400,000.00 ( )

    /

    / // 45441

    1 // / 37363

    / 45441 // 37363

    3 6

    /

    // 37363 25 2003 /

    21 1998 / 400,000.00 (

    ) // 45441

    21 1998 / 400,000.00 ( )

    10 2003 /

    // 45441

    6

    3

    08 2004 /

    // 37363

    / /

    / 119226 04/08/2004 / // 37363

    ///// 337

    www.chilot.me

  • 94

    /

    21 1998 /

    ?

    ///// 347(4) 182(3) 21 1998 /

    400,000.00 ( )

    / /

    ?

    /

    /

    /

    ////

    ///// 8(1)

    -

    / /

    / /

    /

    ///// 11

    244 245

    ////

  • 95

    / / -

    .

    ///// 8 11

    //// 11(1)

    /

    11(2)

    .

    ///// 8 11

    ///// 234

    ///// 244(3) 11(2)

    / /

    /

    8 11

    www.chilot.me

  • 96

    /

    /

    /

    ///// 208 08 2004

    / /

    6

    ///// 8 11

    ///// 345 32(2) 244(3)

    ///// 11(3)

    / 45441 /

    // 45441

    /

    -

    116629

    21 1998 /

    / 45441

    / 45441

    /

    / / 119226 /

    ///// 8 11 244(3) -

    / 45441

    /

    ///// 345 -

  • 97

    / 37363 04 2004 /

    / 37363 21 1998 /

    / 45441

    400,000.00

    ( )

    / 37363 25 2003 /

    400,000 ( )

    1. / / 119226 04 2004 /

    2. 400,000.00 ( )

    3. / / 116629

    4.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 98

    //. 83007

    3 2005 ..

    - /

    -1. /

    2.

    -

    147083 4 2004

    .

    1.

    / /

    / /

    1992

    1998 .

    2.

    //

  • 99

    3.

    99/90

    10 1992 .

    12882 //// 384

    / / //

    12882

    4 2003 .

    //

    12882 /// 323/2/

    14255

    11 2003 . 12882

    4. 2 2002 . 1951 .

    1060/1/ 12882

    1168

    43600 5 2002 .

    5. 21 2005 .

    12882

    www.chilot.me

  • 100

    9 2005 .

    6.

    7.

    8. //

    99/90 10 1992 .

    12882

    /// 384

    12882

    4 2003 .

    12882 4 2003 .

    9.

    12882 4 2003 .

    //// 320/1/ 324 327

    /

  • 101

    / //

    14255 11

    2003 .

    10. 12882

    4 2003 .

    07355 12882

    14255

    12882

    /// 5/1/

    79 2

    11. 14255

    320/1/ 324 327

    12882 07355

    1060

    1168

    /// 324

    12882 4 2003

    .

    12. 12882

    14255 11 2003 .

    12882

    ///

    5/1/

    www.chilot.me

  • 102

    1.

    2.

    /

  • 103

    //. 83169

    28 2005 .

    - /

    -

    - //

    1.

    140, 000,000/ /

    // 35,000,000 /

    / 094872

    //

    35,000,000 / /

    35,000,000 / / ?

    www.chilot.me

  • 104

    2.

    35,000,000

    78, 750,000 /

    40,000 1993-2000 .

    3,360,000

    5,000,000

    40,600

    1179

    3.

    // //

    35,000,000

    8,360,000 / /

    25/1988 14

    4.

    8,360,000

  • 105

    5. 7 2005 .

    35000000

    26 2005 .

    21

    2005 .

    6.

    8360000

    ?

    6.1.

    ///

    30/1/ 324/1/ 215/2/

    www.chilot.me

  • 106

    /// 17 3

    8360000

    //// 320 /3/

    //// 320 3

    35,000,000

    8,360,000 / /

    8,360,000

    //// 17 3

  • 107

    //// 17 3

    //// 17 3

    1. 11396 3 2004 .

    150799 14 2004

    .

    2.

    ////

    17/3/

    3.

    4.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 108

    ... 85873

    13 2005 .

    - /

    - /

    -

    01 2002 . ...

    /

    17 2003 .

    26 2004 .

    10,000.00 (

    )

    01 2002 .

  • 109

    01 2002 .

    ?

    ?

    / 01

    2002 .

    16 2003 .

    ... 34 (5)

    188/1992

    188/92 6 (1)

    188/1992 .

    6 ///// 9 231 (1())

    ... 80

    (3()) 188/1992 6

    www.chilot.me

  • 110

    ///// 277

    /// 3312 3324

    188/1992

    01 2002 .

    2

    (4)4 (5) 5 (1)

    188/92 5 (1) ()

    188/1992 6 (1) /////

    277

  • 111

    1. / 4595/04 17 2003 . 18

    2005 . / 007/05 22 2005

    . ///// 348 (1)

    2. 01 2002 .

    3.

    01 2002

    .

    4.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 112

    //. 86551

    25 2005 ..

    - /

    - / / -

    - -

    /

    25,000.00

    ( )

    50,000.00 /

    / /

    / /

    /

    93,750.00 ( ) 64/353/2005 30/01/2005

    / /

    /

  • 113

    50,000.00

    /

    /

    /

    /

    50,000.00 25,000.00

    /

    50,000.00 /

    /

    ///// 250 136

    ///// 182(1)

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 114

    ///// 92182(1) ///// 225 226

    50,000.00 ( )

    25,000.00

    /

    ///// 182(1)

    /

    /

    ///// 182(1) 250

    /

  • 115

    1. / / 02775 22 2005 /

    / / 35974 27 2005 / /

    / 157217 17 2005 /

    ///// 348(1)

    2. 50,000.00 ( )

    3. 50,000.00 ( ) 25,000.00 (

    )

    /

    4. 93,750.00 ( )

    /

    5.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 116

    //. 79871

    11 2005 ..

    -

    - 1. / -

    2. / -

    - 1. /

    2. /

    3. /

    4. /

    5.

    - 04/05/1994 /

    / / / 24/07/1994 /

    -

    / /

  • 117

    -

    / /

    1990 /

    ( ) 26/09/2002 /

    1976 / 1990 /

    //38843 28/05/2002 10

    // 1845 10

    /

    5 ( )

    5

    10

    /

    /

    - ///// 358

    ( )

    ///1185

    /////358

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 118

    -

    26 12

    ///1000(1) 1845

    5

    / /

    /

    -

    - /////358

    ? ?

    /////358

  • 119

    //38843 28/05/2002 / /

    ///// 358 /

    /////358

    /

    1. / //131390 06/09/2004 /

    /////348(1)

    2.

    /////358

    3.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 120

    //. 80202

    12 2005 .

    - /

    - 1.

    2.

    -

    3250 . 1 2

    18/05/01

    /

    1994

    1999 .

    1999

  • 121

    /

    618,815.93

    //

    /

    19/1995 13/2/

    /

    // /

    12/11/04

    /

    /

    19/1995 13/2/

    /

    // /

    //

    // /

    /

    19/1995

    13/2/

    13

    www.chilot.me

  • 122

    13 13/2/

    /

    13 16

    10 11

    /

    ... 37/1/ 79/1/ //// 4

    / /

    1. /// / / / 47481 04/04/04 / 47436

    04/04/04 / / 49966 03/08/04

    //// 348/1/

    2. / /

    //// 341/1/ / /

    3.

    4.

    /

  • 123

    //. 83915

    29 2005 ..

    - /

    -

    - 1. /

    2. / /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    ///// 337

    www.chilot.me

  • 124

    ///// 3380222225226 231

    223234241

    /

    /

    //// 225

    ///// 33/2/222225226 231/1///

  • 125

    1.

    / 50332 19 2004

    / ///// 348/1/

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 126

    //. 42501

    28 2005 .

    - /

    :- /

    - ( ) - -

    08 305

    /////. 280

  • 127

    /

    ////

    378

    ////

    //// 6 358

    ...

    78/1/ 79/1/ /4/

    www.chilot.me

  • 128

    37

    ...

    25 13/1/

    / /

    ... 40/12/

    /// 1195 1196

    //

    1198

    ...

    3778 79

  • 129

    1. / 64032 25 2001 .

    / 75215 24 2001 /

    ///// 348/1/

    2.

    3.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 130

    //. 82234

    26 2005 .

    - /

    - /

    - 1 /

    2 / 5

    3

    4 /

    5 /

    6 /

    ///// 231/1//

    /

    / 03 696

    2 6 1

    27 1990 .

    /// 2879

    /

  • 131

    /

    ? // 37513 25/7/2004

    . /

    /

    /

    /

    /// 1679

    /

    /

    //// 33/2/ 33/3/

    ///// 33/2/ 33/3/

    ////

    www.chilot.me

  • 132

    ///// 33/2/ 33/3/

    ///// 231/1//

    /

    ////// 222 224

    ?

    //// 33/2/ 33/3/

    /////

    231/1//

    / /////

    33/2/33/3/ 231/1//

  • 133

    1. / // 37513 25/7/2004 .

    / // 118522 06 2004 .

    2.

    ///// 341 /

    3.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 134

    //. 72980

    06 2004 ..

    - /

    - / -

    - 1. - /

    2. /

    3. /

    1996

    /

    ///// 358

    // 20036

    16 1998 / 454/1997

  • 135

    1996 / 11 /

    /

    // 20036

    // 20036

    1996 / /

    1996 / /

    www.chilot.me

  • 136

    ?

    ?

    (

    /

    / )

    ///// 136137

    272 327(3) 345

    213/1992 94

    / 20036

    1996 /

    /

    1. / 1879/02 08 2003 /

    / 16359 01

    2003 / ///// 348(1)

    2. / 15639 17 2003 /

  • 137

    3. / 1879/02

    ///// 343(2)

    4.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 138

    //. 82679

    27 2005 ..

    - /

    - / /

    - / -

    / /

    / / /

    1960 .

    / 09/15

    487

    / 09/15 457

    / 08/15

    487 /

    /

    /

    / ()

    / /

    / () /

  • 139

    /

    ( ) ( )

    /

    ()

    /

    25/1988 9

    ()

    () /

    ()

    ( ) /

    /

    /

    07 2004 .

    /

    / /

    /

    / /

    1954

    1954

    5 2005 .

    /

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 140

    17 2005 .

    / /

    1. /

    1960 .

    / /

    1950 .

    /

    /

    /

    / 22

    2001 . /

    7 2004 .

    1950 .

    /// 234(1)

    4 2005 /

    /// 235(2)

    1960 .

    /

  • 141

    2.

    1960 .

    213/1992

    62(1)

    /

    213/92 62(1)

    /// 1195 1

    213/92 62(1)

    /// 1195(1)

    1954 .

    /// 1196

    62 /// 1195(1)

    /

    3. /

    / ()

    /

    //// 360(2)

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 142

    /

    (Declaratory

    Judgment)

    /

    14290 .. 17058

    4. /

    25/1988 9

    / 25/1988

    / /

    /

    9 1 2

    /

    /

    /

    25/1988 9(2)

    / /

    / / /

    25/1988

    9 2

    /

    /

    25/1988 9(2)

    /

    9 2

    /

  • 143

    /

    /

    1. / /

    2. /

    3. / 09/15 487

    4. /

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 144

    //. 83582

    27 2005 ..

    - /

    - /

    - 1. /

    2.

    3.

    /

    7

    /

    06-04-2002 .

    //// 418

  • 145

    3 1996 .

    /// 182

    /// 358

    30 2004 .

    18281 3 2002 .

    23 2002 .

    06-

    04-2002 . /// 377

    www.chilot.me

  • 146

    /

    18281 6 2002 .

    ////

    418

    1 2005 .

    24007

    22 2005 .

    ?

    1. 18281

    6 2003 .

    18281 3 2003 .

    6 2003 .

  • 147

    t

    3 2003 .

    6 2003

    . 3 2003 .

    184598

    2. 6 2003 .

    3 2003 .

    3 2003 .

    / 06 2003 . 3 2003 .

    277 1

    3 2003 .

    377 1 6 2003

    . 3 2003 .

    3 2003 .

    277 2

    6 2003 .

    3 2003 .

    www.chilot.me

  • 148

    277 1

    ////. 227 2

    //// 358

    6 2003 .

    3 2003 .

    //// 360 2 //// 418

    ////. 358

    1. 18281 26 2004 .

    118786 24 2004 .

    2. 3 2003 .

    6 2003 .

    ////. 360

    //// 341/1/

    3.

    4.

    /

  • 149

    //. 84446

    24 2005 .

    - /

    -

    199/92 24/3 /

    / /

    /

    ///// 5

    199/92 24/3/

    5,000.00 / /

    /

    ::

    / 05802 09/10/2002

    .

    www.chilot.me

  • 150

    173354

    /

    / / ///// 337

    /

    1

    /

    /

    /

    1

    /

    ///// 5

    ///// 5 /

  • 151

    ///// 32

    5

    /

    1

    /

    /

    /

    1

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 152

    1. /

    / / 125177 01 2004 .

    2.

    3.

    /

  • 153

    //. 85718

    03 2005 ..

    - /

    -

    -

    / 02693 19

    25. /

    /

    1. / 1

    1993.

    / / /

    / / 0793 02-

    06-1993. /

    28 21.

    /

    469 16 21. /

    1

    2. /

    / 2 24.

    2 2004 .

    www.chilot.me

  • 154

    //

    //

    25/1985 5/2/

    /// 5/1/

    3. 19 2004 . 2

    2004 . /////. 5/1/

    27 2005 .

    5 2004 .

    25 2005 .

    4.

    2

    2004 .

    /// 5/1/

    5.

    // // 10 2004 .

    2 .

    79 1

    2 2004 . /// 320/1/ ///

    314 /// 327

  • 155

    25/1988 5/2/

    80 4

    2 2004 .

    6. 2 2004 .

    /// 212

    2 2004 .

    02693 /// 5/1/

    /// 5/1/

    2 2004 .

    8 2005 .

    1. 02693

    26210

    56287

    2. 2 2004 .

    //// 511

    3.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 156

    //. 86454

    23 2005 .

    - /

    - 1. / VC

    2. /

    3.

    -

    // / /

    /

    80,000 4

    / / 80,000 200,000

    18 -

  • 157

    / 5

    /

    160,482.765 /

    //

    160,482.765 / -

    / / /

    //

    //

    /// 171/1/

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 158

    ? ?

    /

    ///// 234/1/ // //// 215/2/

    //

    /

    ///// 234/1/ // 235 /2/

    //

    160,482.765

  • 159

    1. // / 54034 26 2005

    / 55375 17 2005 .

    //// 348/1/

    2.

    3.

    4.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 160

    // 86510

    18 2005 ..

    - /

    - ///

    - /./ /

    ECLO car diagram ultra sound GE modele

    VIVID of system

    30% 702,000.00 / /

    1,404,000.00

    12 2002 /

    12 2002 / 437

    0.1% 2,340,000 .00 999, 180. 00 /

    /

    702,000.00 /

  • 161

    /

    999,180.00

    ? ?

    1,404,000.00 / /

    02 2004 .

    /// 1792

    www.chilot.me

  • 162

    12 2002 / 427

    2, 340,000. 00 0.1% 10%

    2.3// /// 1731

    ///// 222234235236 83

    ///// 224 182

    ///// 224

    ///// 241 /

    ///// 246-248

    ///// 255 251

    /// 1883

    ///// 224

  • 163

    999, 180.00

    702,000.00 / /

    999,180. 00

    1, 404,000.00 /

    / 297,180. 00 / /

    ///// 182/2/

    1. / 111482 20 2004 /

    / 78582 19 2005 /

    2.

    702,000.00 / /

    3. 702,000. 00 / /

    9%

    4.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 164

    //. 87190

    19 2005 ..

    - /

    -

    - -

    ?

    / 16273

    21 2004 . ///// 208

    22 2004

    13 2004 .

    9

  • 165

    //// 60

    60

    22 2004 .

    ?

    60 51

    60

    ?

    www.chilot.me

  • 166

    1. // 126464

    7/5/2005 .

    2.

    13 2004 .

    3.

    /

  • 167

    //. 85102

    21 2006 ..

    - /

    - -

    - -

    21 2002

    /

    /

    06

    1989 /

    139,900.00 23,316.20

    www.chilot.me

  • 168

    139,900.00(

    ) 23,316.60

    1989 / 1998 /

    1996 /

    /// 915(1)

    /

    /

    ///// 337

    / 03 1988 /

    / 99/89

    / 19749

  • 169

    /

    / 99/89

    15 1994 /

    / 16107

    03 2001 /

    / 33024 21

    2002 /

    / 05200 27 2002 /

    21 2002 /

    / 99/89

    14 1994 /

    //.881 1

    / 42623

    //. 881

    www.chilot.me

  • 170

    / 99/89

    / 99/89

    // 17058

    ? ? // 17058

    ///// 5

    ///// 212

    / 99/89

    / 05200 27 2002 /

    ///// 5

    / 99/89

    ///// 5

  • 171

    1. / 42623 24 2003 /

    / 01-32078 29 2003

    / 18331 22 2004 / /////

    348(1)

    2. /

    ///// 5

    3. / 19749 24 2003 /

    ///// 348(1) / 03 1988

    / / 99/89

    4.

    5.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 172

    // 86133

    20 2006 .

    -

    -

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    7.

    8.

    9.

    10.

    11. /

    1. / -

    2. / - -

  • 173

    ///// 418

    1 2

    1 2

    3 32

    803 805 5 06

    936 953

    5 06 936 953

    22 1999 /

    /

    ( ) 2 08 1999 /

    1 3

    32 803 805

    2

    2 5

    06 936/2/947 952953/2/ 954 954/2/

    803 936/3/938/1/946 947/2/

    937/1/938940941943944945

    ///

    1723(1) 127 /// 1432(1)

    ///// 418

    ///// 421

    www.chilot.me

  • 174

    // 37214

    ///// 418 421

    ///// 418

    ///// 421

    ? ?

    5 06

    936 953

    22 1999 /

    / ( ) 2

    08 1999 / 1 2

    ///// 418 419

    /

  • 175

    ///// 419 /

    ///// 419

    // 87833

    454/1997 2(1)

    // 37214

    ///// 421

    // 87833

    ///// 418

    ///// 418

    ///// 421

    www.chilot.me

  • 176

    /////

    418419 421

    // 87833

    1. / 81670 23

    2005 / ///// 348/1/

    2. / 81670

    ///// 341

    3.

    /

  • 177

    //. 89494

    19 2006 .

    -

    - /

    - / / -

    - 3-52129

    3-00947

    23/11/2003 /

    287,003.40 (

    ) 100,000.00

    ( ) 187,003.40

    www.chilot.me

  • 178

    ///

    2084(3)

    245,588.25 ( )

    100,000.00( )

    145,588.25 72,794.12. (

    )

    ///// 145

    23 2003 /

    187,003.40

  • 179

    23 2003 /

    ///// 145

    ///// 145

    ///// 145

    ///// 145(1) (2)

    ///// 145

    ///// 235 83

    www.chilot.me

  • 180

    // 1498143453

    454/1997 2(1)

    80(3()) 25/88 10

    /// 2084(1) (2)

    ///// 145

  • 181

    1. / 940/03 02 2004 /

    / 185/2004 08 2005 /

    ///// 348(1)

    2.

    3. /

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 182

    //. 90543

    21 2006 ..

    -

    -1.

    2.

    3.

    - / /

    /

    15

    1994 /

    ///// 5

    / 01110

    20,000.00 10,000.00 1

    7/7/2004 /

  • 183

    / 08 2004 /

    16 1994 / 10,000.00

    10,000.00

    10,000.00

    / 28

    2004 /

    /Res judicata/

    ////// 5

    /

    ///// 5

    www.chilot.me

  • 184

    ///// 5(1) (2)

    ///// 244(2()) 245(2)

    //// 5/2/

    ///// 216

    ///// 5(3) ///// 5

    1

    16 1994 /

    1

    1

    (2 3 )

    /// 944

  • 185

    ///// 5(2)

    ///// 5(2)

    ///// 5244(2()) 245(2)

    1. //// / 57725

    28 2005 / ///// 348(1)

    2. / 01280 20 2004 /

    12576 16 2004 / /////

    348(1)

    3.

    ///// 5

    4.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 186

    //. 92459

    19 2006 ..

    -

    - /

    -

    ///// 481

    26 2005 /

    ?

    ?

    72908

  • 187

    .... 80(3() 25/1988 10

    449(1())

    " "

    ///// 481 449(1())

    1.

    2.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 188

    //. 91103

    16 2006 ..

    -

    - .. -

    - 1. / -

    2. (5 )

    1

    26 1991 / 350,000.00( )

    30 2003 /

    30 2001 / 2,000,000.00( ) 2

    ///// 358

    2

  • 189

    2

    ? ?

    //////. 183

    /////. 462-464 /////. 462

    /

    -

    ///// 463 / ?

    2

    /////. 463 464

    2

    /////. 462

    /

    2

    www.chilot.me

  • 190

    1. / 81591 14 2005 /

    / 89064 29 2005 /

    ///// 348(1)

    2.

    3.

    /

  • 191

    //. 90452

    14 2006 ..

    -

    - - /

    - / -

    ////

    300,109.15 29/05/2000 ..

    26/02/2001 .. 19/11/2002 ..

    6,294.30

    /

    /

    ... 2024(1)

    /// .. 29181 20/04/2002 ..

    ... 2473(2)

    41,391.50

    19,586.87

    22/02/2004 ..

    ///

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 192

    ///

    //// //

    ..... 343(1) //

    /// /

    300,109.15

    /

    ... 2024(1)

    ..... 78(2)

    ///

    /// /// /

    ?

    /

    ..... 78

    ////

    /

  • 193

    /

    ..... 70()

    ..... 78(2)

    ///

    /// /// /

    1.

    //// .114956

    22/02/2004 ..

    /// ..118042 08/12/2004 ..

    ///

    ..... 343(1) /// /// /

    .. 82803 21/06/2005 .. ..... 348(1)

    2. /

    3.

    4.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 194

    //. 91968

    15 200..

    -

    - /

    37983 15

    2005 / //// 6

    1. //

    15 2005 /

    2. 09

    417 /

    418

    //// 6 09

  • 195

    / 7///0 /363/105 23 2005 /

    18 2005 /

    3. 12 2005 /

    //// 6

    13 2005 /

    4 2006 /

    4.

    9 //// 6/1/

    ?

    5. 15 2005 .

    9

    GIS 9997

    / /

    8 11 417

    418 20/11/26812/00

    09

    6.

    //

    //// 6/1/

    //// 6/1/

    www.chilot.me

  • 196

    403 405 //// 6/1/

    7. 15 2005 /

    09 //// 6/1

    1. 37483 15 2005 /

    2. //// 6

    //// 343/1/

    3.

    4.

  • 197

    //. 85468

    24 2006 .

    -

    - ..

    - /

    /

    /

    /

    /

    08 1999 / 17,020,570.00

    4(2) 12 2002 /

    35% 5,957,060.00 65%

    08 2004

    17 2003 / 30

    2003 / 5,129,494.00

    735,637.00 5,865,131.00 6(2)

    1 1998 /

    2,821,490.00

    www.chilot.me

  • 198

    8,686,621.00 (

    ) (7.5%)

    35%

    65% 08 2004 /

    150 200,000.00

    5,957,060.00

    3,732,622.00 9,689,682.00

    30 2003 /

    03 26 2003

    12 /

    //

  • 199

    30 2003 /

    5,129,494.00

    8(3) 735,637.00 6(2) 1 1998

    / 2,821,490.00

    4(4) 7.5%

    ///// 337

    ? ?

    //// 145 /

    ///// 234(1)

    www.chilot.me

  • 200

    12 2002 /

    /// 1722(1)

    /// 1731(1)174017561846

    08 2004 /

    08 2004 /

    17 2003 /

    13

    2004 /

  • 201

    ///// 280

    /

    03 16 2003 /

    ?

    ?

    ///.1792

    2

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 202

    03

    16 2003 /

    ///// 235 83

    16 2003 /

    /// 1791,1792 1793 () ()

    ///// 39 40

  • 203

    1. // .. 108074 13 2004 . /// ..

    82501 17/03/2005 .

    /////. 348/1/

    2.

    25 2005 /

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 204

    //. 87834

    21 2006 ..

    -

    /

    - / / - /

    - 1

    2/

    3/ -

    ///// 358

    /

    /

    / 29 1993 / / 27/93

    // 178781

    /

    / / 27/93

  • 205

    /// 3311

    /

    /// 3311

    /// 3311

    3

    /

    /

    ///// 358

    ///// 358

    // 3311 /

    www.chilot.me

  • 206

    1. / / /

    27/93 29 2004 / // 127958 02 2005 /

    2. / / 27/93 29 2003 /

    ///// 358

    /

    ///// 341

    /

    3.

    /

  • 207

    //. 89893

    24 2005 ..

    -

    /

    - /// -

    - - /

    - /

    2

    24 2005 /

    /

    3,641,052.04

    516,744.56 4,442,616.36

    / 8 2003 /

    /

    21 2003 .

    /

    2,438,255.44

    5,488,693.84

    www.chilot.me

  • 208

    /

    / 15/8/2004 /

    / 8/10/2003 / /

    / 8/10/2003 .

    15/8/2004 / ///// 320(2)

    21 2003 /

    /

    ? ?

    /

    / 15 2004 / ///// 320(2)

    / 17352

    21

    2003 /

    //

    /

    15/8/2004 / ///// 320(2)

    15 2004 /

    ///// 341 /

    /

    / 6

    2004 / 15 2004 /

    ? ?

    6 2004 / /

    ? ?

  • 209

    ///// 320(4)

    / -

    ///// 320(3) /

    6 2004 /

    ///// 320(4)

    / 6 2004 /

    ( ) 21 2003 /

    - -

    (interlocutory order)

    -

    ///// 320(3)

    //

    -

    1. // / 81511 21/8/2005 /

    ///// 348(1)

    2. // // 99819 6 2004 /

    (interlocutory order)

    3. /

    4.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 210

    //. 93137

    11 2006 ..

    -

    - / -

    - / -

    /////

    /

    /

    / /

    / / 15/09/1995 ..

    / 19/08/2002 ..

    / / / 26/08/2002 ..

    / //

    / / 15/09/1995 ..

    /

    / /

  • 211

    15/02/2004 ..

    /// ..75679 27/04/2004 ..

    15/02/2004 .. ..... 6

    /

    15/09/1995 .. /

    17/11/2005 ..

    1995 ..

    /

    ..... 6

    /

    /

    / 15/09/1995 ..

    /

    ..... 6(1)() ()

    / ..... 6(1)

    /

    /

    ....

    80(3)() ()//

    www.chilot.me

  • 212

    / /

    ..... 6

    ..... 6

    /

    / /

    /

    /

    1. // // .. 09404 17/11/2005 ..

    ..... 348(1)

    2. ..1

    ..... 348(1)

    3. ..1

    ..... 348(1)

  • 213

    4. ..... 6

    ..... 341(1) /

    5. /

    6.

    7.

    8.

    /

    www.chilot.me

  • 214