federal burea ou f investigationsep 09, 2010  · current fisa target s under indictment to reques...

111
(Rev. 01-31-2003) DATE: 05-29-2009 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC REASON: 1.4 (c) DECLASSIFY OH": 05-29-2034 ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT WHERE SHOW OTHERWISE SÎfÇRET FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION Precedence: DEADLINE 7/14/2006 06/28/2006 Date : To: Counterterrorism General Counsel Attn: Attn : Attn: Attn: Attn: Attn: SAC ASACTT CDÇL SA SA A/SAC A/CDC SA SA ASAC CDÇj £ SA SA SAC CDC_ SA!" A/AÔE yç I From: Operational Technology DES/Data Intercept Technology Unit Contact: SSAl Approved By: Drafted By: Case ID #: glm b2 b6 ' hlC b7E J STLU :b6 b7C (U) (U) (U) (U) (U) 1 t" 1 ni rr T 1 ~~~ n (Pending) (Pending) (Pending) (Pending) (Pending) hi A SEGBET !

Upload: others

Post on 22-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

(Rev. 01-31-2003)

DATE: 05-29-2009 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC REASON: 1.4 (c) DECLASSIFY OH": 05-29-2034

ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT WHERE S H O W OTHERWISE

SÎfÇRET

FEDERAL B U R E A U O F INVESTIGATION

Precedence: DEADLINE 7/14/2006 06/28/2006

Date :

To:

Counterterrorism General Counsel

Attn:

Attn :

Attn:

Attn:

Attn: Attn:

SAC ASACTT CDÇL SA SA A/SAC A/CDC SA SA ASAC CDÇj £

SA SA SAC CDC_ SA!" A/AÔE yç I

From: Operational Technology DES/Data Intercept Technology Unit Contact: SSAl

Approved By:

Drafted By: Case ID #:

glm

b2 b6 ' hlC b7E

J STLU

:b6 b7C

( U )

( U ) (U) (U) ( U )

1 t" 1 ni rr T 1 ~~~ n • (Pending) (Pending) (Pending)

(Pending) (Pending)

hi A

SEGBET !

Page 2: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SEZxET

~1 From: ^Operational Technology il^HQ-Al48W99-OTD, "06/2^/2006

b2 b7E hi A

(U) (Pending) PROCEDURAL & OPERATIONAL ISSUANCES CURRENT FISA TARGETS UNDER INDICTMENT

To request an audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regarding below listed FISA

targets, (U! M Details:

I 3 ë r i v e d - ^ r a m j _ — S — 3 —~ D e s l a & s i ^ —

1 the Department of Justice (DOJ) , Office of Intelligence P o l i c y a n d R e v i e w ( O T P R ) obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of the

W o l f , 1 databases to confirm: Red

b2 b7E

h 2 b7E b5

W h i l e - v Ê h e - c o i r p l e t e p a r a m e t e r s o f t r i e > a u d i t a r e b e i n g à e l p l l ò p e d b y j a i o i n t DOJ/OGC c o m m i t t e e , OGC nas a d v - r s e & OTD t o b.égfri i t h l s r a u d i t - n o w - w i t h

^ A c c o x d i - n q W ^ - O G C h a s r e q u e s t e d , , t h a t ' OT-Q_ f a c i l i t a t e a s e a r c h , as d e s c r i b e d h e r e i n , ( w i t h t n e a s s i s t a n c e ' bS the .'respective caseX€acreht • if necessary)-t f r f c o ^ d f i M t l ä m n q t o f

b b b

Page 3: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

From: Operational ® 7 A 1 4 8 7 6 9 9 - O T D ,

Technology b2 b7E

_tttni»si r e a u e s i f e d ^ e s c n b e d B e ^ f f r o m Tya. jfe

fiteci7 rto a search for records __ [ and^RedhWolf databases.

Afjfected flelfcT ojgfiees^mav receive "additU'cr.al j g l i x d a n c e / x e e i u e a L g x e q a f ^ l x m a

_For pufposes-of- .this request. ..for, egpond separately ""to the ¿following

.ea e'hydat abase:,

b2 "b7E b5

5 i l i r e ' ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ M

|h£BlTowilg^.l ¥h&l

(S)

bl

Page 4: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

sè^RET

(S)

bl

SEjkagi

4

Page 5: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SÇ&ÇET To: Re:

From: Operational ^ilPIBÉi 9 9-OT D,

Technoloqy 0 6 / « «

h 2 hi E

LEAD(s): Set Lead 1: (Action)

ALL RECEIVING OFFICES

iT-Ti Conduct requested search of and provide information as requested. [ Q u e s t i o n . S h o u l d t h i s b e FO o r *nust~ r e c i p i e f i " r e c i p i e n t s t h e n we a r e t a s k i n g CTD. . ]

database b2 b7E

S^CSgT 5

Page 6: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SEÖRET

O G C ) ( F B I )

DATE: 05-29-2009 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC REASON: 1.4 ¡c) DECLASSIFY OU: 05-29-2034

ALL INFÜRHATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT WHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE

From: Sent: To: Subject:

(OTD) (FBI) ThnrcHaw hma9Q 2006 3:55 PM

be b7C

OGC) (FBI) RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

bbNSniUfc BUT UNCLASStHEB-NON-RECORD

Can I have a copy of the EC to review? Thanks for helping

Assistant Section Chief Electronic Surveillance Technology Section Diwatinnal Taphnnlnnv Division

b6 b7C b7E

—Original Message— From: | ~jOGQ (FBI) Sent: Thursday, liine 29. ?nnfi 3:54 PM To: I If OTD) (FBI) Cc: I KOGO (FBI) Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

For your information. b2

I've incorporated the| land Red Wolf databases into the EC and have sent it to DITU for review and, if no b6 problems arise, for UC/DITU s initials. It will go tc| |ancj ~|tomorrow morning and then on tob7c you or| tyour call).

There are some admin issues unresolved abouf I think the body of the EC is in good shape, incorporated in the EC.

b7E

ithat needs to be resolved but Jias made changes to her guidance re"this first effort which I have

c

Assistant General Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel Federal Bureau of Investigation Ph -I I Ph (Secure) J I Fax-I I

b5

b2 b6 b7C

—Original Message— From: I l(OTD) (FBI) , , Sent: mursriflv. limp. 29, 2006 2:05 PM To: (OGC) (FBI) D , L

S E ^ E T

Page 7: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

PRET

Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

¿ b N S I I I V b U U I UNCLASSH=H=P— NON-RECORD

Let us include the other OTD Collection systems, which include Red Wolf , b2 b7E

Electronic Surveillance Technology Section Operational Techno oav Division

b2 bo b7C b7E

—Original Message— F r o m : I l(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Ttiursday, June 22. 2006 2:45 PM

rOTDI (FBI)| ~ IOGC) (FBUt

To: Cc: Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

-SCH3IT1VC BUI UNlLAbblHbU' NON-RECORD

lOTDI (FBI) JOGC) (FBI)

piPR obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of thi _ "hatabases to confirm:

be b7C

b2 b7E b5

Red

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIFR no later than September 15, 2006, which

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep vou updated), but we would liketo conduct a nrpliminarv coarrh nf niir Hgtahacpg-

i ODtain tne ronowing information

h 2 b7E

SE^tej

Page 8: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SECRET

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Engineering Research Facility

Fa: pagei

b2 b6 b7C b7E

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

-—Original Message-From: | Sent: To: E

[OGC) (FBI) e 21. m 10:19 AM JOGC) (FBI)j_

Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSiriED NON-RECORD

](OGC) (FBI)£ 1(OGC) (FBI) b-7C

See below.

b2 b6 b7C

Original Message-v. X lOGC) (FBI) From:

Sent: Thursday, June 08, 2006 1:28 PM To: I (OGC) (FBI) Cc: |(OGC) (FBI) Subject: Current FISA largets under Indictment

SbNblllVb BUI UNCLA89fHEB NON-RECORD

(OGC) (FBI) be b7C

So here's what we have.

bl

Page 9: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SEJ^ET

<S>

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIRÉD

SENSITIVE BUT UNC :IED

SENSITIVE BUT/UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUTvUNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED 7s —

Page 10: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SEÇftÇT

(OGC) (FBI) b6 -b7C

To: Subject:

Follow Up Flag: Due By: Flag Status:

l o T D ) (FBI) oe t-W: Current MSA Targets under Indictment

Follow up Thursday, June 22, 2006 1:30 PM Flagged

Assistant General Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel Federal Bureau of Investigation Ph £ Ph (Regimi Fax-

h2 h 6 blC

—Original Message— From: I tOTDI (FBI) Sent: Thursday. June 29. 2006 2:05 PM To: | [(OGC) (FBI) Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUI UNlLASSIHfcU NON-RECORD

Let us include the other OTD Collection systems, which include Red Wolf, h 6 b7C

Ü Z 3

] Assistant Section Chief Electronic Surveillance Technology Section Operational Technology Division

h 2 b6 b7C b7E

—Original Message From: | Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

J (OGC) (FBI) Thnrerlav lime 73. 700fi 2:45 PM

(OTP) (FBI )£_T (FBÎ)L JOGC) (

IOTP) (FBI) be b7C

(OGC) (FBI) FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUI UNCLASSIFIED" NON-RECORD

OIPR obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of t h e databases to confirm:

Red Wolf, h 2 b7E b5

1 SEFWET

Page 11: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15, 2006, which information

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep vou updated), but we would like to conduct a preliminary sfiarrh nf nur riatahasfts- _

to obtain the following information:

h 2 hi E b5

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

As to local systems—it's mv understanding that the specific cases listed below hail from the'following offices^

b2 b7E b5

Accordingly, please reach out to these offices to have a search done for the targeted case data, if these offices want tol

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Assistant general Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Engineering Research Facility

Tëiï Fax page]

h 2 ho hi C b7E

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY.LAW UNIT OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

—Original Message— From: I IfOGCHFBn Sent: Wednesday. June 21. 2006 10:19 AM TO: I "TOGO (FBI)J toGC) (FBI)| Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

2

S E j ^ T

be hie

](0GC) (FBI)

Page 12: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S p ^ R E T

bbNbl I IVb BUT UUCLAOSfHEB-NON-RECORD

See below.

Original Message— From: | Sent: Thursday. JuneW To: Cc: Subject:

I S OGC) (FBI) ÉL28PM

(OGC) (FBI)t [OGC) (FBI)

Current FISA Targets under Indictment

QCNOITIVC PUT UNCLA33IFIED NON-RECORD

b2 be b7C

][OGC) (FBI) be b7C

So here's what we have.

(S)

b l

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLAOStBE&

3

s e C K E T

Page 13: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E ^ E T

¿SITIVE BUT UNCl^ASSIFIËB^

SENSITIVE BÜ>äNCLASSIFlED

dSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIE

SEÖRET 4

Page 14: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E ^ E T

(QGC> <FB|) From: Sent: To: Subject:

Follow Up Flag: Due By: Flag Status:

E i l l l^ .k lWITÎ 3 (OTD) (FBI)

29, 2006 2:05 PM (OGC) (FBI)

FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

Follow up Thursday, June 22, 2006 1:30 PM Flagged

b6 b7C

SbNSI I l\/t: BU I U N C L A b f i i n r n NON-RECORD

Let us include the other OTD Collection systems, which include Red Wolf,

Assistant section Chief Electronic Surveillance Technology Section Operational Technology Division

h 2 b7E

h 2 b6 b7C b7E

-Original Message-From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

3(OGC) (FBI) Thursday. June 22, 2006 2:45 PM

I (OTP) (FBI) ](OGC) (FBIJ|

JÇOTD) (FBI)

b6 b7C

FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment J OGC) (FBI)

SENSITIVE PUT UHCLAOSH=ti=B-NON-RECORD

OIPR obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of t h e databases to confirm:

b2 b7E

Red Wolf, bs

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15, 2006, which information

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep you updated), but we would like to conduct a preliminary search of our databases]"

[• to obi Dtain the following information:

SECRET

Page 15: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E ^ T

1 1 I RedWolf

b b 2 7

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

As to local systems-it's my understanding that the specific cases listed below hail from the following offices: Accordingly, please reach out to these offices to have a

search done for the targeted case data. If these offices want tc|

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

[ 1 Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Engineering Research Facility

Tel: Fa>J pagerT

b2 b6 b7C b7E

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

—Original Message-From: Sent: Wednesday. June 21. 2006 10:19 AM To: I lOGC) (FBI)E Subject:

~|(OGC) (FBI) né:

FW: Current FISA Targets under indictment ](OGC) (FBI)£ lOGC) (FBI)

b6 b7C

SENSI IIVE BUT UNCLAGStf4EB-NON-RECORD

See below. b2 b6 b7C

—Original Message-From: [_"" Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

](OGC) (FBI) Thursday. June 08, 2006 1:28 PM

|(OGC) (FBI)f ;OGC) (FBI)

Current F1SA Targets under Indictment

TDGC) (FBI) h 6 blC

2

S E C R E T

Page 16: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SECRET SENSITIVE BUT UNCL/(SSIFIEP NON-RECORD

So here's what we have.

Page 17: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S É Ì ^ E T

~ 1 ° G C > < F B I >

DATE: 05-29-2009 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC REASON: 1.4 (c) DECLASSIFY ON: 05-29-2034

ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT M E R E SHOOT OTHERWISE

From: Sent: To:

Cc: Subject:

JOGC) (FBI) Thursday. June 29, 2006 1:59 RM.

I ~l(OGC) (FBI) j_ (OTP) (FBI) ,

OTD) (FBI)

b6 b7C

J(OGC) (FBI)L RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment-Systems AUDIT

J(OGC) (FBI)

OCNOITIVC BUT UNGLASSlHfiP. NON-RECORD

This sounds good, does not require a change to the ec, so let's bring it up monday

Unit Chief National Security Law Policy and Training Unit FBI HQ Room 7975 STUIIIJ _ I Unclassified Fax Secure Fax

—Original Message— From: | |(OGC) (FBI) Sent: TTiursdav. June 29.2006 1:31 PM bo T o : I |(OGC) (FBI)j l(OTD) (FBI):| IfOTD) (FBI) b7C Cc: I lOGCHFBni fOGCI (FBD:I kOGCHFBI) Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment-Systems AUDIT

bfcNbl I IV/fc BUI UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

b2 b7E b5

Upon further consideration: T

bo b7C

—Original Message-From: | |(OGC) (FBI) Sent: 1 hursday, June 22, 2006 2:45 PM To: I rn-rn) (FBI)l |OTD) (FBI) b 6 Cc: | tOGC) (FBI);| |[OGC) (FBI) b7C Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVb BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

1

S E p f ^ E T

Page 18: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SEÖRET b2 b7E b5

Wolf, jOIPR obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of the _

Triafabasea to confirm:

Red

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15, 2006, which

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep vou updated), but we would like to conduct a preliminary search of our databases]

Jo obtain the following information:

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

As to local systems—it's mv understanding that the specific cases listed below hail from the following offices:

offices to have a search done for the targeted case data. If these offices want tof Accordingly, please reach out to these

h 2 b7E b5

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Engineering Research Facility

b2 bo b7C b7E

Tel: Faxl pageiL

2

Page 19: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S È ^ E T

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

Original Message--Ongi l(OGC) (FBI) From:

Sent: Wednesday. June 21, 2006 m-io am To: I l(QGC) (FBI);| Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

JOGC) (FBlf (OGC) (FBI)

be b7C

iabNSI I IVb Ü U I UNCLAQSH=tES-NON-RECORD

See below.

h 2 b6 b7C

—Original Message--From: I U(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Thursday. June 08. 2006 1:28 PM To: (OGC) (FBI) Cc: |(OGC) (FBI) Subject: Current hibA I argets under Indictment

[OGC) (FBI) b6 b7C

ÎS)

SENSI I IVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

So here's what we have.

b l

3

S Ë ^ E T

Page 20: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E M E T

b l

S E Í ^ E T 4

Page 21: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S Ê B R E T ^

~ l O G C ) ( F B I ) ,b6 a b7C

From: Sent: To: Cc:

Subject:

(OGC) (FBI) ThnrsHav .Inn»90 i m p 1:51 PM

JQIQl (FBI ) lOTD) (FBI);

(OGC) (FBI) FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment-Systems AUDIT

JoGC) (FBI);

— 5 C N S I T I V C PUT l i n n fl^'pipp NON-RECORD

I understand from your voicemail that you will OTD EC to the field. I've coordinated this with

ding me text to "fold" into the DES EC re this subject to create an nd stand ready to revise the DES EC. Please send your provisions.

b2 bo b7C

Assistant General Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel Federal Bureau of Investigaten p h r _ _ z _ i Ph (Secure)! Fax -I

-Original Message--From: | feGC) (FBI) Sent: I hursday, June"Z$,20061:31 PM b6 To: Cc: Subject:

VOGCHFBnr "I (OTP) (FBIVJ tOTD) (FBI) b 7 C frOGC) (FBI)J 1(060 (FBI)| |0GC) (FBI)

RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment-Systems AUDIT

OCNOITIVC PUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD b2

b7E b5

Upon further consideration:

be b7C

—Original Message-From: Sent: To:

lOGC) (FBI) Thursday. June 22. 2006 2:45 PM

(OTD) (FBI)[ ](OTD) (FBI) be b7C

S ^ E T

Page 22: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Cc: I KOGCHFBDI I r a n cran b 7 c Subject: FW: Current HSA Targets under Indictment

OCHOITIVC PUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

OIPR obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of the Red Wolf,

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15,2006, which

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep you updated), but we would like to conduct a preliminary search of our databases]

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

As to local systems-it's my understanding that the specific cases listed below hail from the following offices: Accordingly, please reach out to these offices to have a

search done for the targeted case data. It these offices want to

b2 b7E b5

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Fnninsfirinn Research Farilitv

2 S É ^ T

Page 23: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E I L E T

E Tell Fa pagei

b2 b6 b7C b7E

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

Original Message— From: | J (OGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday, June 21,2006 io-iq AM To: I lOGC) (FBI);| Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

](OGC) (FBI);[ (OGC) (FBI)

b e b7C

See below. h 2 b 6 b7C

(SJ

From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

Original Message-](OGC) (FBI)

Thiireriav lunp (IR. 7f)06 1 78 PM (OGC) (FBI [OGC) (FBI'

Current FISA Targets under Indictment

OCNOITIVC P U T UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

So here's what we have.

DGC) (FBI)

be b7C

b l

3

S Ê J ^ E T

Page 24: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E d f c r

i s) •bl

^SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASS1BIÉD

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUTUNCLASSIFIEP

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIF

S E t ^ T 4

Page 25: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

From: Sent: To: Subject:

S E ^ E T

|(OGC) (FBI)

L ](OGC) (FBI) Thursday. June 29. 2006 1:50 PM

(OGC) (FBI)

b6 b7C

RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Nope-thanks for helping out

—Original Message— ](OGC) (FBI) From:

Sent: To: Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

Thursdav.June 29. 2006 1:49 PM 3 (OGC) (FBI)

bo b7C

3CN0ITIVC BUT UMCLASSIE1EÛ. NON-RECORD

I can make this change.

Also, I received a voicemail frorrC tasking me to fold into the DES EC provisions that cover his interests. I understood that he would be sending me text to work with. Are you working with him on this?

[ ] Assistant General Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel Federal Bureau of Investigation p M , I Ph (Sflrnrp) i Fax h

b2 b6 b7C b7E

—Original Message-From: L lOGC) (FBI) b6

b7C l(OGC) (FBI) To: |

Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment Importance: High

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Upon further consideration: I would recommend,

—Original M From: Sent:

less^ inp— ÏOGC) (FBI)

Thursday, June 29, 2006 10:31 AM

SEJ^ET

Page 26: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

ÏÈ^E ET

To=r Subject:

~~|(OGC) (FBI) "RE: Current RSA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT 1 INruvSSIFIFD NON-RECORD

be b7C

Thanks again.

Assistant bSneral Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel Federal Bureau of Investigation P H I — L Ph (Secure) I Fax •

b2 bo b7C

-Original Message-From: Sent: To: Subject:

JOGC) (FBI) Thursday. June 29. 2006 10:28 AM

JOGC) (FBI) FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Jiere's the email that I sent with audit parameter guidance

ss<jg —Original Me; From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

agg 3(OGC) (FBI)

Thursday. June 22, 2006 2:45 PM KOTD) (FBI);| £ JOGC) (F§C

FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

iQID) (FBI) _ ] ( O G C ) (FBI)

SENSI 11 VE BUT UHCLAESIFIEn NON-RECORD

be b7C

b6 b7C

be b7C

Red Wol£,[ ]0 IPR obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of t h e _

databases to confirm:

b2 b7E b5

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15, 2006, which

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep you updated), but we would like to 2

Page 27: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E ^ T conduct a preliminary search of our databases-f

J- to obtain the following information: b2 b7E b5 J

RedWolf,

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit

Tel: Fax pager[

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT

b2 bo b7c b7E

OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

—Original Message From: I Sent: To: Subject:

](OGC) (FBI) Wprlnpsrtw liinq 21,2006 io- ,mM

(OGC) (FBI);! FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

loGC) (FBI);[

b e b7C

](OGC) (FBI)

See below.

—Original Messaqe-From: ](OGC) (FBI)

b2 b6 b7C

T

Page 28: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SEILET Sent: To: Ce: Subject:

Thiiraiav lnnp flR 7nnfi1-7R PM (OGC) (FBI) (OGC) (FBI)

Current RSA Targets under Indictment

OCHaiTIVC BUT UHCLAGSTPIEP-NON-RECORD

So here's what we have.

(OGC) (FBI) be b7C

(Sii

b l

\SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNOUVSSIFIED

\ 7 SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITÌ^EBUTÌ)NCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLL )

4

S f ^ E T

Page 29: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

From: Sent: To:

Cc:

Subject:

S E ^ E T

|(OGC) (FBI)

VOGC) (FBI) Thursday. June 29' 2006 1:31 PM

OGC) (FBI) ; r (OTP) (FBI)

lOGC) (FBI)C

](OTD) (FBI)C

(OGC) (FBI) RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment-Systems AUDIT

J(OGC) (FBI);

bo b7C

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Upon further consideration: In those few casesf

b2 b7E b5

—Original Messaae From: | Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

(OGC) (FBI) TTllirStiflY. June2L2Q06 2:45 PM

liQID) (FBI); | I __|(OGC) (fflJiL

FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

be • b7C

3 a m ) (FBI) OGC) (FBI)

b6 hlC

b2 b7E b5

£ SECRET

Page 30: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SEFTFTET The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep vou updated), but we would like to conduct a

h 2 b7E b5

preliminary search of our databases-I- to optàih m tôllôwirtg IfitòrrtlàtiòiV

jRedWolfl b2 b7E b5

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Engineering Research Facility

Tel: Fa> page

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT - OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

h 2 be b7C

L —Original Message-

From: Sent: To: Subject:

~VOGC) (FBI) 1,21, 20Ù6 10:19 AM JOGC) (FBI]

FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment > G C ) (FBI); (OGC) (FBI)

be b7C

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

See below.

b2 be b7C

—Original Message— From: | (OGC) (FBI)

SEpf^ET

Page 31: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E C R E T

Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

Thursday. Inns OB. 7006 1:28 PM :OGC) (FBI) OGC) (FBI) Indictment Current FISA Targets under

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

So here's what we have.

(OGC) (FBI) b 6 b7c

(S)

b l

Page 32: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

From: Sent: To:

Subject:

Importance:

SEÈ&ET

IfOGC) (FBI)

|{OGC) (FBI) Ihnrsrlav .liinpyg' 2006 1:21 PM

:b6 b7C

OGC) (FBI) RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

High

SENSITIVE BUT UMCLASSIFIFn NON-RECORD

b2 b6 b7C b7E b5

Upon further consideration: I would recommend, in those few cases!

So it seems to make sense to ensure tnat is seing done or nas been done, sooner rather than later-we'll be asked to do it eventually.

loGC) (FBI) —Original Message—

From: I Sent: ThnrcH:.» 1.inp7q 2006 10:31 AM To: L _ |(OGC) (FBI) Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

be b7C

bbNSI IIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Thanks again.

Assistant General Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel Farterai Bureau of Investigation

b2 b6 b7C

Ï Ph Ph (Secure) -I Fax £

Original Message From: |(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Ihursdav. June A . 2006 10:28 AM To: | lOGC) (FBI) Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

jhere's the email that I sent with audit parameter guidance

-Original Message— (OGC) (FBI)

Thursday. June~ft. 2006 2:45 PM From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictmenf

06 IOTP) (FBI)j

JOGC) £BÌ5£ "k0TD) (FBI)

tOGC) (FBI)

SE0RET

Page 33: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E ^ E T

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

b2 b7E b5

sbligated the FBI to conduct an audit of the

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15, 2006, which

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keen vou undatedV but we would like to conduct a preliminary search of our databases-

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology b2 for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time. b7E

b5

Y o u r assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT • OGC APPROVAL

NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR

Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Engineering Research Facility

b2 b6 b7C b7E

2

S E ^ T

Page 34: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

(S)

l ë l ï T Faxj pagei

S É Y É E T

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT

—Original Message From: I TOGQ (FBI) Sent: Wednesday, June 21. 2006 10:19 AM To: I "TOGO (FBIIJ Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

See below.

Original Mpssanp—-- ( From: L |(OGC) (FBI) Sent: , Thurgfav. lune na. 7006 1:28 PM To: Cc: Subject: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

(OGC) (FBI), (OGC) (FBI)

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLAOSIHEB-NON-RECORD

So here's what we have.

OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

b2 b6 b7C b7E

JOGC) (FBI){_ ]JOGC) (FBI) b7C

b2 b6 b7C

(OGC) (FBI) be b7C

bl

3

SEÎTËET

Page 35: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

sBÓkj ( S )

F ^ l SEOßET

Page 36: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SEJ^ET

IjQGC) (FBI)

From: Sent: To: Subject:

Follow Up Flag: Due By: Flag Status:

OGC) (FBI) lEEsHiZ^ I InESC 2006 10:28 AM

OGC) (FBI) FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

Follow up Thursday, June 22, 2006 1:30 PM Flagged

b6 b7C

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLA33H=tEB-NON-RECORD

here's the email that I sent with audit parameter guidance

—Original Message— From: | Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

JOGC) (FBI) Thi ircrtav Inno T) JClOR 2:45 PM

lam) (FBI)L OGC) (FBI); I

FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

l i i l P ) (FBI) |(OGC) (FBI)

•b6 b7C

b6 b7C

•SENO ITI VC DUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

b2 b7E b5

OIPR obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of th£ Red Wolf, databases to confirm:

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15, 2006, which information

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep vou updated), but we would like to conduct a preliminary search of our databases]

X

S E ^ E T

Page 37: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E È É E I

b2 b7E

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the b5 record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Engineering Research Facility

Tel: Fax pageij_

h 2 b6 b7C

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

—Original Message— From: | ]OGC) (FBI) Sent: ' WpHnpeHav W ^ WWIWIQAM To: I I (OGC) (FBI)| Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UHCLA09fftEP NON-RECORD

be ](OGC) (FBPJ I (OGC) (FBI) b 7

See below. b2 b6 b7C

—Original Message— From: | |[OGC) (FBI) Sent: Thnrcrlav lnnpiw 7nfe 1 PM To: Cc: Subject:

(OGC) (FBI); [OGC) (FBI)

Current FISA Targets under Indictment

OCNQITIVC DUT UNCLASSIEI6D-NON-RECORD

So here's what we have.

(S)

OGC) (FBI) be b7C.

bl

Page 38: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSm^RBUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BtiT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

S E J ^ T

Page 39: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E ^ T

lOGC) (FBI)

From: I l(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Mferinasriav .limp 28, 2006 3:55 PM To: I l O G C ) (FBI) Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Thanks-glad they worked it out and thanks for keeping me out of the mix.

—Original Message— From: | l(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday, June 28, 2006 3:14 PM To: I l(OGC) (FBI) Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLAOSfftiEB NON-RECORD

I understand that He put the draft t u on|

]telktc It appears to me that ASC| I s backing away from his objections. jesk with his comments. I'll send my comments to| |as well

Assistant üeneral Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel Federal Bureau of Investigation Ph< " I . Ph (Secure) -I I Fax ~

b2 b6 b7C

—Original Message— From: I ~kOGC) (FBI) Sent: Friday, June 23, 2006 9:36 AM To: I rOGC) (FBI) Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

be b7C

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

FYI-I believel through me

]has asked that DITU coordinate final submissions re[

b2 be b7C b7E

audits with you before sending

—Original Message— From: I l(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Thinly iunp?7 ?npfi 2:45 PM To: J [QTC Cc: Subject:

CUD) ( F B I ) ; [ _ I (OGC) (FBI)|_

t-W: Current l-ibA largets under Indictment

iQTD.) (FBI) |OGC) (FBI)

be b7C

SENSITIVE PUT UNCLAOGiriCD NON-RECORD

S È ^ Ç T

Page 40: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S ^ R E T b2 b7E b5

DI PR obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of thej_ Red Wolf,

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15, 2006, which

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep you updated), but we would like to conduct a preliminary search of our databases-]

I I- to obtain the following information: b2 b7E b5 RedWolf,

b2 b7E -b5

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Assistant general Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Engineering Research Facility

TiT Fa>

b2 be b7C b7E

pager£ S ^ R E T

Page 41: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S Ç & Ï E T

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

, Wednesday, limi JOGC) (FBI)

—Original Message-From: | Sent: To: L • • -Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

5 21, 2006 10:19 AM (OGC) (FBI)r

ide SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

JOGC) (FBI)[ ](OGC) (FBI)

to 6 to7C

See below.

b2 h 6 b7C

Original Message— From: I I (OGC) (FBI) Sent: Thiircriav. limp ns. 7006 1:7« PM To: (OGC) (FBI) Cc: (OGC) (FBI) Subject: UllTent HbA 15^515 unggr Indictment

DGC) (FBI) b6 b7C

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

So here's what we have.

(S)

bl

3

SEÇRET

Page 42: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S F f e é F T

(S) b l

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVDBUT .SSIFIED

SENSITIV&BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UN IFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

4 /

Page 43: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E C R E T

[OGC) (FBI)

To: i IrtYmWFRIV l(ITD) (FBli f (FBI)i (OTP) (FBI)

1. At page 2. paragraph fa). draft EC (attached) - PES and DITU have no official knowledge o f

b6 IOTDIb7c

Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets.under Indictment

•b2 Review of the draft EC raises the following concerns: b 7 E

Accordingly, all names of such individuals must necessarily be provided to DES. The list contained in the draft EC was, I am told, provided by OGC. The EC should attribute this list to OGC and it should state that DES is dependent upon OGC for the accuracy and completeness of this list. See yellow highlights in attachment.

2. At page 2, paragraph (b), draft EC - PES and DITU have no official knowledge ol I ' 11 agree that if DES and DITU are to respond to this query, it must obtain information from the responsible field offices.

I I • Assistant General Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel b 2 Federal Bureau of Investigation b 6 Ph -I I b 7 c Ph (Secure) -I I Fax -I I

—Original Message— From: I I (OTP) (FBI) b6 Sent: Tuesday. June 27,200610:06 AM b 7 c To: | ~lfOGC) (FBI) Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIE1EP NON-RECORD

« File:| Search.wpd » I '

Here is the EC I wrote. I already sent it to) | Probably should have had you look at it first, but was under a time crunch. " ~

• SSA I Hata Intorrent Tprhnnlngy Unit

b2 b6 b7C b7E

—Original Message--— From: I ~1 (OGC) (FBI) Sent: Friday, June 23, 2006 9:41 AM To: I KOTD) (FBI) Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

l

SEQL$ET

Page 44: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SECRET

I think you are working on this. We briefly discussed this but we, at some point, need to talk and figure out how to respond. When is a good time for you?

Assistant ueneral Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel Federal Bureau of Investigation Ph-T 7 _ J Ph ffirjirR) L Fax •

b2 b 6 b7C

Original Message— From: | "~l(OGQ (FBI) Sent: Friday. June 23, 2006 9:36 AM T o : I ~l(OGC) (FBI) Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

"SfcrtmilVbBUl UNILAS31WEB NON-RECORD

be b7C

FYI-I believd" has asked that DITU coordinate final submissions re sending through me...

audits with you before

b2 b6 b7C b7E

—Original Message— From: I |(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Thursday, June 22, 2006 2:45 PM To: tOTD) (FBI)£—I Cc: |(OGQ(Finr

lOT?) (FBI) b6 b7C

Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

-QCNOITIVC PUT UMCLASSIEIED

JOGC) (FBI)

NON-RECORD

Wolf, "]OIPR obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of the

^databases to confirm

Red b2 b7E b5

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15, 2006, which

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep you updated), but.we would like to conduct

S^ÇRET

Page 45: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E ^ E T

h 2 b7E b5

a preliminary search of our databases-! I ¡to obtain the following information:

edWolf,

|b2 b7E b5

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

b2 b7E

Your assistance is appreciated! b 5

PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Fnoineerina Research Facility

Tel: Fax I Pagerl I

SCIENCES TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT - OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

b2 b6 b7C b7E

—Original Message— From: | |(OGQ (FBI) Sent: Wednesday, June 21.2006 10; 19 AM b 6 To: I 1 (OGC) (FBI)] tOGC) (FBI);! KOGC) (FBI) b 7 , Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

OCNOITIVC PUT UHGLAGSiriED NON-RECORD

See below.

—Original Mpsvinp-From: (OGC) (FBI)

b2 b6 b7C

SEQFEET

Page 46: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S g & R E T

Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

Thursday InnP OR. 7006 1 78 PM (OGC) (FBI); OGC) (FBI)

-OCNOITIVC PUT UMGLACGTWEO-NON-RECORD

;OGC) (FBI) b 6 b7C

So here's what we have.

(S)

b l

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED/

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT&NCLASSIFIED

A SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED\ SEPRET

Page 47: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SEJ^ET

(OGC) (FBI)

From: I l(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday. June 28, 2006 11:25 AM To: I H (OGC) (FBI) Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

QCHOITIVC PUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

be blC

I don't know & haven't seen the EC you mention-can you forward it

—Original Message— From: | ~|(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday. June 28, 2006 11:20 AM To: | ~ | (OGC) (FBI) Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

bfcNSI I IVb BUI UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORP

bo • Z I : b 7 c

This is the subject of the conversation that we need to have this morning. Assistant Section Chiej Idoes not want to be responsible for providing this information. The reason for this position is that while DITU develops and maintains the software, sets up the collection for field offices, it does not have access to the actual data. So, this means that the only way DITU can answer the questions is to ask CTD, or OGC, or the various field offices. DES does not want to be responsible for the responses provided by other divisions. In other words, DES does not want to be the middleman in an action going to the FISC.

Right now I have on my desk a copy of a draft EC to the Field asking for responses to the questions posed by the FISC. brought it to me saying that this is not the way to handle this matter.

I don't know how flexible you can be on this, but I'm getting considerable push-back. Basically, DES is going to have to be told to do this and then expect that the response will have caveats from DES clarifying that their response is based solely upon information provided by , etc.

CTD may be the better choice to turn to for this information. They have a continuing working relationship with the field offices.

Let's talk.

Assistant General Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel Federal Bureau of Investigation Phi Ph (Secure) Fax -|

1 b2 bo b7C

—Original Message— From: I "lOGO (FBI) Sent: Friday. June 23. 2006 9:36 AM b ' To: I ~lfOGQ (FBI) Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

QCNOITIVC PUT UNCLA33IFICP S E C Ç ^ T

Page 48: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SEQRET NON-RECORD

FYI--I believq[ ]has asked that DITU coordinate final submissions re sending through me...

^audits with you before

b2 bo b7C b7E

—Original Message— From: I IfOGQ (FBI) Sent: Thursday. June 22. 2006 2:45 PM To: ' Cc:

iÛID) (FBI)J__~ J (OGC) (FBÌ)L

Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

OCNOITIVC PUT UNCLMSSIHliD NON-RECORD

IfQTP) (FBI) rOGC) (FBI)

b6 B7C

obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of t h e | _ databases to confirm:

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15, 2006, which

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep you updated), but we would like to conduct a preliminary search of our databases-f

to obtain the following information: b2 b7E

RedWolf,

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

b2 b7E b5

2

S j ^ E T

Page 49: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

b2 S ^ R E T

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Engineering Research Facility

T e l f " Fa>t_r pagel

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT - OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

b2 bo b7C

—Original Message— From: | |(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday, June 21. 2006 10:19 AM b6 To: | tOGCHFBI);^ H l ( O G C ) (FBI);| |[0GC) (FBI) b 7 c Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVb BUI UNCLASblhlfcU NON-RECORD

See below. b2 b6 b7C

—Original Message— From: I l(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Thursday. June 08, 2006 1:28 PM To: [OGC) (FBI) Cc: [OGC) (FBI) Subject: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

[OGC) (FBI) b6 b7C

SbNbl I IVfc BUT UNCLA5Sti=tiEe-NON-RECORD

So here's what we have.

b l

3

Page 50: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SFERET

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED j ^ S i

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SEC,

Page 51: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E I L E T

|(OGC) (FBI)

From: I IOTP) (FBI) Sent: TiipsHav .inne 77 ?onfi 10:06 AM To: (OGC) (FBI) Subject: RE: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE fctu I UNCLAbSIHbÜ NON-RECORD

Search.wpd (17 KB)

Here is the EC I wrote. I already sent it to| | Probably should have had you look at it first, but was under a time crunch.

S S A [

b2 b6 b7C b7E

Data Intercept Technology Unit

Original Message— From: I l(OGC) (FBI) ; b 6 Sent: Friday. June 23. 2(106 9:41 AM b 7 c To: I I (OTP) (FBI) Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

5EN3ITIVC PUT UHCLASSIEIEP-NON-RECORD

I think you are working on this. We briefly discussed this but we, at some point, need to talk and figure out how to respond. When is a good time for you?

b2

b7C Assistant General Counsel Science and Technology Law Unit Office of the General Counsel Federal Bureau of I nvestigation Ph -I I Ph (Secure)-I | F a x 1

Original Message— From: | ¡[OGC) (FBI) sent: Friday. June 23 2006 9:36 AM To: | [OGC) (FBI) D ' c

Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SFNSITIVF PUT UNOLAQQiriCD NON-RECORP

S É ^ E T

Page 52: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E Ì ^ E T

I

FYI--I believe through me...

Ihas asked that DITU coordinate final submissions re[ ^audits with you before sending

](OGC) (FBI) Thursday. June 22. 2006 2:45 PM

—Original Message— From: I Sent: To: Cc: Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

l£2ID) (FBI);[~ JOGC) (FBÎJL

b2 b6 b7C b7E

l o i P ) (FBI) I (OGC) (FBI)

b2 b7E b5

lOIPR obligated the FBI to conduct an audit of the|_ Red Wolf,

The status of the audit is to be reported to OIPR no later than September 15,2006, which

The specific parameters of the audit are still being developed (I'll keep you updated), but we would like to conduct a preliminary search of our databases-!

|- to obtain the following information:

1 RedWolf

Please provide results or status by July 5, 2006. Please also document your search methodology for the record, but you need not report the methodology at this time.

b2 b7E b5

2

S E I L E T

Page 53: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E I ^ É T

Your assistance is appreciated! PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT-APPROVAL

Assistant General Counsel Science & Technology Law Unit Fnaineerinn Ftesparrh Far.ility

Tel: Fax pager£

NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC

b2 b6 b7C

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY LAW UNIT OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

—Original Message--From: I Sent: To: Q Subject: FW: Current FISA Targets under Indictment

D(OGC) (FBI) WPrinP^av. limp 21, 2006 10:19 AM

(OGC) (FBI);[ ](OGC) (FBI); (OGC) (FBI) be b7C

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASairiCD NON-RECORD

See below.

-Original Message-From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

L J (OGC) (FBI) Thursday. Iiine OS. 7006 1:28 PM

(OGC) (FBI) KOGC) (FBI)

Current FISA Targets under Indictment

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

to 2 to6 to7C

OGC) (FBI)

toe to7C

So here's what we have.

(S)

toi

SECRET 3

Page 54: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E C R E T

< S h

b l

S ^ R E T

4

Page 55: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

](OGC) (FBI)

ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED DATE 06-03-2009 BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC

From: Sent: To: Subject:

I kOTD) (FBI) Wednesday, February 15, 2006 3:34 PM

b6 b7C

FW: Databases (OGC) (FBI)

UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

SSA I I Data Intercept Technology Unit

b2 bo b7C

—Original Message From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: RE: Databases

(ITD) (FBI) ary 15,2006 2:12 PM ûqQ (FBI)

(OTD) (FBI)

b6 b7C

UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

No...respectfully. There is no computer access RedWolf.

b2 b6 b7C b7E

venture to guess, the same is true of

—Original Message From: [ Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

](OGC) (FBI) Wednesday, February 15. 2006 1:06 PM

1 (OTD) (FBI)] KOTD) (FBI)

YW: Databases

](OTD) (FBDC ](ITD) (FBI)

b6 b7C

UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Is there computer access b £ responding is appreciated! thanks

fto RedWolf, Your assistance

—Original Message— From: I irOGQ (FBI) Sent: Wednesday. Febmarv 15, 2006 11:46 AM To: I If OGC) (FBI) Subject: Databases

UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

b2 bó b7C b7E

| | in our responses from| ~| they h a v e uniformly said that they don't maintain databases with FISA information. But they generally forgot to address the part about whether they have access to such databases, regardless of whether they maintain them.

Page 56: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

b2 b7E

Can you tell me if there Is any chance that there is computer access Please tell me no!

to RedWolf

• b 6 b7C

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED

2

Page 57: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

From: Sent: To: Cc:

( S ) Subject:

S ^ E T

l(OGC) (FBI)

DATE: 06-03-2009 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC REASON: 1.4 (c) DECLASSIFY OH: 06-03-2034

(OGC)(FBI) N.ftRrtav Ai mi ist 7Q 90f)fi Q-?1 AM

](OGC) (FBI)[

RE: Q n ZtZQGCUFBI)

SECHRET//NOFORN RECORD 315Ö"

ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED HERE in IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT WHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE

b6 *b7C

](OGC) (FBI)

bl

I do now; not sure if I was aware of this case already, as I've been focusing on the historical cases rather than present ones.

• —Original Message—

From: I Sent: To: Cc:

] (OGC) (FBI)

g J Subject: RE: Q

SÉ8ÛRET//NOFORN RECÖRD 3150"

Tuesday. August 29. 2006 8:23 AM lOSC) (FBI) _

IfOGCHFBDf

be b7C

JOGQ(FBI) bl

Thanksl lo you have this as part of your audit?

b2 b6 b7C

Assistant General Counsel Policy & Training Unit National Ronirity Law Branch

(SJ

—Original Message— From: | |OGC) (FBI) Sent: MnnHa» Ann.iri-7« m 2\ 14 PM To: Cc: Subject: RE: Q r

be b7C

(OGC) (FBI) J2SOIEBI)

bl SEQ&ET//NOFORN RECORD 31 So"

be b7C

It did go to court last week and was approved by the Judge without hearing. SSAl "land OIPR attornevF I Hare setting-up training with the personnel who will have access to the information. There was specific

language in the order indicated that access would be restricted.

SAC lis the field agent in charge of the investigation from[ l In order for the information to be b2 b6

restricted irj to a select few, the field agent was required to make the request and submit to the folks at b7c b7E

Please do not ¡¡esitate to call to let me know what other specifics I can assist with. S E C R E T

i

Page 58: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

V/r

S E ^ E T

Assistant General Counsel, National Security Law Branch Phone: Internai Pager:

b2 b6 b7C

J

(S)

From: Sent: To:r Cc:

-Original Message— ](OGC) (FBI)

Monday August 28, 2006 2:07 PM

Subject: RE: Qr

SE^RET/ZNOFORN RECORD 315o

_ J(OGC) (FBI) J ( Ö G Q i E B D _ _

bo b7C

bl

]was working on the redwolj blocking. I'm currently irl land I have not followed up with him in the last few days to find out what the status is. I'm cc:ing| Ihere so maybe he can fill you in as to the status.

b2 b6 b7C b7E

r i

(S)

—Original Message-— From: V Sent: To: F Cc: [ Subject: FW'Qri

loRCVFBnt

](OGC) (FBI) 6 10:03 AM

](Oqa (FBI)

bo b7C

SECftET/ZNOFORN RECORD 315Ö"

](OGC) (FBI)E lOGC) (FBI) bl

]what' s the status of this case? We are in the process of preparing an audit of indicted targets for OIPR, which Thanks.

is handling. b2 b6 b7C

Assistant üenerai Counsel Policy & Training Unit National Security Law Branch

(S)

—Original Message— From: | Sent: Friday. August 11. 201 To:

Ì;OGC) (FBI) &2:51 PM

Cc:

Subject; RE: <J re

SESBOETZ/NOFORN =COË RECORD 315o

(cmiiEBiiC tFBI)^

T n r i n fFRD

j k \ SECRET

FBI) FBI);[_ J(OGC) (FBI);

b2 b6 b7C b7E

bl

Page 59: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

X

( S )

All - this is a FISA which we're trying to initiate next week. Target is under sealed indictment.

provide training.

ivsvicw i_otjs anu| i Jj lease contact your CDC about the general training as this bC sent a lead to all CDCs lo

3tc to

persons witn access andf J can you

wn I'm going to askl U n penned the above EC, and

2SJ53} rouTthef^^^00"1^acc ;" r°Rfiriwnlf ^ ^ ^ /ou kindly initiate the process to do this? I hanks-I — ' —

bl b6 blC b2 b7E

As to the taint team issue once the target is indicted, NSLB should be closely coordinating with you on

As I am leaving town, I'm going to ask b6 b7C b5

(S)

-—Original Message— From: | Sent: To: Cc: Subject: RE: Q re

SEpftETZZNOFORN RECORD 315Ö"

m

JCTD) (FBI) Friday. Ann, ich 1 ^nc 1 o g ^

IfFED.:. JÎQSQ(FBI)

FBI) b l

b2 b6 b7C b7E

i n f o T m a t o i T b e i L ^ ^ Wh

e c a n b r i e f a i l t h e analysts with the access to the be m n L h l believe analysts a| ^Iso have access to the info, as well as CD analysts This b7c could be a large number of people, too large to be practical. What do we do here? Thanks biz

SSAl I

Secure| f

(S)

-Original Message-From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

E ](FBI) ,Friday. Anni m i ?npfì ì 2:23 PM

_I(CTD) (FBI):F

SEKRETZZNOFORN RCCÒRD 315Ö"

mni IRFBI) j(OGC) (FBI)

b2 be b7C b7E

b l

(S)

Ok—Here is a good one- b l

„ _ _ and since he is P, . t u . , . Jllfe d Idim Wulk^d l/lIS QUE --we think with During thi? another question/concern w^ThUnht to ^ t i n n l ™ ^ |

JOn thejjœjside of the house we have had issues wifh this

S ^ E T

b2 be b7C b7E

Page 60: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S E ^ T I suggest that some one for OCG brief who ever will have access to this FISA.

I [--can you call me today re translators for this FISA. Tx

be b7C

>ERIVED FROM: G-3 FBI Classification Guide G-3. dated 1/97, Foreign Counterlntelligenc I investigations DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET/ZNOFORN

DERIVED FROWk. G-3 FBI Classification Guide G-3. dated 1/97. Foreign Counterintelligence Investigations DECLASSIFICATIOKvEXEMPTION 1 SECRET//NOFORN

DERIVED FROM: G-3 FBI Classification Guide G-3. dated 1/97. Fgj»6ign Counterintelligence Investigations DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION SECRET//NOFORN

DERIVED FROM: G-3 FBI Classification Guide G-3^aated 1/97. Foreign Counterintelligence Investigations DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET//NOFORN

DERIVED FROM: G-3 FBI Classification Guide G-3. dated 1/Sfr.Foreion Counterintelligence Investigations DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION^ SECRET//NOFORN

DERIVED FROM: G-3 FBI giassification Guide G-3. dated 1/97. Foreign Counterintelligence Investigations DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET//NOFORN

DERIVED FROMyG-3 FBI Classification Guide G-3. dated 1/97. Foreign Counterlntelligenc^4nvestigations DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET//N0FORN"

DERIVE0 FROM: G-3 FBI Classification Guide G-3. dated 1/97. Foreign Counterintelligence Investigation^ DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET//NOFORN"

4

Page 61: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

ET

tOGC) (FBI)

DATE: 06-03-2009 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC REASON: 1.4 (c) DECLASSIFY OH: 06-03-2034

ALL INFORHATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT WHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE

Tuesday. August 1 (OGC) (OGA)

:11JEM_ UOUSL29, 2006 12:11 l(OGC) (OGA)

I S m i Q G A X C Z — (OGC) (OGAf

TÖGCTWm (OGC) (FBI)J

l(OGC)TÜÜA) |(OGC) (FBl£

JOGCHFBi)

b2 b6 b7C b7E

X

(S) CZI b e b7C

jpiu ui u iu 11 mi i U l l U I U U L u u , i uui iu mum uiu pi " 3 " b l report any overhears of the defendant market people/Brady/Rule 16, the case agent ran a link analysis in Telephone Applications (TA) which indicated about 300 calls between the market and the travel agency - the case agent then had the disks of the unlogged calls pulled from archive and reinstalled Into Redwolf so that the monitor/language specialists could go back and write up those 300 calls - because Detroit had started in Oct 05 double tracking the monitors' write ups, all to/from info from these 300 calls was indexed into ERS/ELSUR and because all tech cut/summaries are pulled up every 8 hours from Redwolf into EDMS, all the summaries are also in EDMS, including the "calls not answered" summaries - this

• background relates to one set of problems re the Oct 05 policy but also the following which I believe changes our understanding of what our obligations are . . .

l

S E I ^ T

Page 62: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

(S)'

SÇ5ÇET

Talk to you at 3 PM today. Thanks b l be b7C

DERtVE&FROM: Multiple S o u r c e s - ^ DECLASSIFie?n3eN=EXËMPTION 1 SECRET

2

SÈB^ET

Page 63: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

DECLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC OH 06-03-2009

C

From: Sent: To:

Cc: Subject:

-SECRET RECORD 9999-777

][OGC) (FBI)

: ](OGC) (OGA)

be m "b7C

Thursday. August 31, 2006 10:53 AM IfOGCi (FBllf

( O G A i i l(OGC) (FBI):r

l iOGCi rOGAV ' (OGC) (FBI)C

~l?qGCHOGA>r TOGC) (OGA)J

]OGCi (FBi)f

ÌOGC) (OGA);[ |OGCi fFBh:

Ì S )

](OGC) (OGA) Topic for tomorrow's meeting re the SMP & databases

bZ be b7C b7E b5

with our regular issues. Thanks[ } lets talk about this tomorrow along

TJEWVSOLEROM: Multiple-sources DECLASSIFICABPW=EXEMPTI0N 1

-SEGRET"

1

Page 64: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Ì ^ R SECRET

KOGC) (FBI)

DATE: 06-03-2009 CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC REASOII: 1 . 4 (c) DECLASSIFY OH: 06-03-2034

ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT WHERE SHOWN OTHERWISE

h 2 "bo ' b7C b7E From:

Sent: To:

Cc:

( S ) Subject:

r 3 (OGC) (OGA) Thursday Annnst 31 700fi «:17 AM

i m

(FBI)[

(OGC) fOGAlE (OGC) CFBlf

][OGC) (OGA);

RE Tfiimmization - corrected list FÓGO) (OGA) lis

] (OGC) (FBI);

bl

SECRET RECORD

b7A b2 b6 b7C b7E b5

Also, there was one particular item which is even more of a problem -f

k

Obviously we need to work through all such details. Thanks [j

—Original Message— From: | ~|(FBI) Sent: Wednesday. August 30. 2fflKH2:27 PM To: Cc:

^ g j Subject: RE

SEtfeET

(OGA)

OGC) (OGA) (OGC) (FBI)

w'nimization - corrected list

RECORD[

~ l(FBI) lÖGCj(FBI) ]COQQ (OGA)£ ](OGC)

b7A

b2 b6 b7C b7E

bl • b2 b7E

We will begin immediately. Thank you,

55/41

-Office -Hall

« File:

From: | l(OGC) (OGA) Sent: Wednesday. August 30.2006 10-44 AM To:

306 1QJ (FBI);|_

(FBI).vcf »

Nl) l

S / ^ T

b2 be b7C b7E

Page 65: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SECÈ?6; (OGC) (FBI)L 3OGC) (FBl£

ET

minimization - corrected list

)R[

loGC) (OGA)

hi A

he (OGC);b7C

bl

e note additional 03 January cut below. Original Messape—

OGC) (OGA) From: Sen To: Cc:

Wprinpgriav. August Jl). 2006 10:09 AM

Subject: •IQGAL

August

3ÔGC)(fel

> io,:

ninimization

SEPTET RECORDl

](OGC) (OGA);[

b7A

"kOGC)

bl b2 b6 b7C b7E

As we discussed, pursuant to FBI's continuing obligation to minimize US person information,!

Thank you very much for all your assistance. Please do not hesitate to contacj [or me if you have any questions.

S E ( ^ T

Page 66: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

S ^ R E T TV b2

b6 b7C

DERIVED FROM: Single Souroé Document DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1

^SECRET

DERIVE1VFROM: Single Source Document DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET

DERIVED FROM: Sitrolte Source Document DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET

DERIVED FROM: Single Source Dochment DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET

SEGRET 3

Page 67: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

DECLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC OU 06-03-2009

OGC) (FBI)

From: Sent: To: Cc:

Subject:

(OTD) (FBI) Thursday Anni ist 10. 2006 7:40 A M I I (OGC) (FBI)

be b7C

^ l (OTD) (FBI):! Q c x s r W K O G C K F B » ; !

R t : Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

IfQGC) (FBI)I O G C ) (FBI)

-aeukfci— R E C O R D 99999-3333

Every Red Wolf II DCS 5000 does have a

b2 b7E

Hope this helps.

1 Supervisory Engineering Technician ELSUR Technology Management Unit (ETMU) Electronic Surveillance Technology Section (ESTS) Operational Technology Division (OTD) ERF

—Original Message— From: . | |(OGC) (FBI)

' Sent: U W W ^ , , TTTïïIct no 2006 5:30 PM To: J J (OTD) (FBI) Ce: I [OTD) (FBI) Subject: ' FW: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

C r r u u ^

b2 b6 b7C b7E

b6 b7C

1

Page 68: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

SECRET RECORD 99999-3333

b6 blC

Can you please provide answers to the below questions from| ~]and copy all those folks listed below in the response.

Based on an explanation of theÇ my understanding is that there is

b2 b6 b7C b7E

Thanks,! I

—Original Message-

d—seems like it could be done, but is it??

From: | |(OGC) (FBI) Sent: wpdnpgriav Anni^ng ?nnft 3:44 PM . . To: I IfOGC) (FBI); I KOGC) (FBI); | |(OGC)(FBI) Cc: | |(OGC) (FBI)J [OGQ (FBI) Subject: RE: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

OCCRCT RECORD 99999-3333

1 = 1 Does every Red Wolf system use the s access limited t<£

^ Hne^this relate to the other issue we were looking at, i.e., |

Assistant General Counsel Policy & Training Unit ^National Security Law Branch

h 6 hlC

h 2 be bic b7E

, 2006 6:40 PM

Oriojnal Message From: | fOGC) (FBI) Sent: , Tuesday, August 08, To: I -Subject: Kt: Minimization ana aai

o c T F T

which need attention ASAP lOGC) (FBI)£ l0GC)(FBI)

RECORD 99999-3333

b2 b6 b7C b7E b5

b6 b7C

|Here's what I learned:

2

Page 69: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

b2 :b7E

J)GC) (FBI) b6 ' b7C

(1) Froml "lema'1 below, are you familiar with what| |is describing in REDWOLF as a

h 2 b6

W e need to have this explained so we can decide what may have to be reported b7C to the Court ???

explained so we can decide what may have to be reported •b7E

Original Message-From: [ Sent; I « t Subject:

o c o n c T

Monday. Auoust 07. (OGC) (FBI)I

JOGC) (FBI)

FW: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP OGC)(FBI)j_

ittë

RECORD 99999-3333

Assistant General Counsel Policy & Training Unit National Sorurity Law Branch

—Original Messasi From: I Sent To:

H(OGC) (FBI) Mrvrv ay, August 07 ?0Qf> Ifi. r? AM ,

PGQ (OGA)| __ . . KOGC) (FBI);

Cc: ZÖGCj (FBI); THOMAS. JUUE F. (OGC) (FBI) HiOGO (OGA);| ~](OGC) (OGA);l

JOGC) (OGTCTTl Ü. lUbLl IÒGA)I £

Subject: Ï (OGC) (OGA) mm Ì

KoocHhrira |OGC)(FBÏr

J(OGC) (FBI)i

](OGC) (FBI);[

TOGC) (FBn fOGC) (FBlf

OGO fOGA):l JfOGC) (OGA); I

b2 b6 b7C

b2 bo b7C b7E

J (ÓÒC) (FBI) ] (OGC) (FBC

"ÌOGCi IOGA); IfOGC) (FBI);

Kb: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

RECORD 99999-3333

Page 70: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Z l »lease as!) [to raise these issues with| [during their next meeting. b2

k€ will askl labout some of your issues, but I do not see a need for another survey at this time. b7c

1 1 b7E Did you discuss these issues with the| "|CDC?

Unit Chief National Security Law Policy and Training Unit FBI HO Room 7975 STU III:| 1 Unclassified FaxJ Secure FajJj I

b2 b6 b7C b7E

—Original Message--From: I Sent: To:

J(OGC) (OGA)

Cc:

Subject:

be b7C

l(OGC) (FBD:I irOGC) (FBI) J l(OGC) (FBI); fOGC) (FBI) RV:N ÎDRAVI tOGC) (OGA) OGC)

(OGA) tOGC) (OGA (OGC) (OGA) |(OGC) (OGA)

. SECRET RECORD 99999-3333

] last weekT land I were out ir For the reviews (along with! [from OIPR) and several minimiztion issues were identified which we think need attention ASAP - in addition. I 1 also asked me to ask about

b2 b6 b7C b7E h 5

Thel Ifield office advised us that last year an inspection team of some sort had critiqued them for not

4

Page 71: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

h 2 ta 5 bo ta7C BVE

We need to nave thii to the Court???

explained so we can décidé what may hàVè \ù D5 fëporiëU

Please advise how we can handle these matters quickly. Thanks

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sourc 'CLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1

be hie

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sotirces DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET \ 7

DERIVED FFtoM: Multiple Sources DECLASSIFlÛATIOt/EXEMPTION 1 SECRET \ /

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET / \

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET / \

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sourcés DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTIONS S E C R E T \

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sources CLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION"^

ÉCRET

5

Page 72: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

DECLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC ON 06-03-2009

From: Sent: To:

Cc: Subject:

RECORD 99999-3333

l 2 = ç i m . (OGC) (FBI)

Werinesdav Anni ist 09, 2006 5:53 PM

b6 • hlC

fnfinvFBn

St 09, 20U6 b:b JOGC) (FBI)j_

]OGC) (FBlJ

](OGC)(FBI);[

]OGC) (FBI) RE: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

b2 be b7C b7E

Did you send me the description that OTD provided to you of the|_ you were getting this but I don't think I have it. Thanks.

You mentioned in your 7/27 email that

1 Assistant General Cou nsel Policy & Training Unit National Security Law Branch

h 2 be b7C

—Original From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

•tessaoe-IkoGC) (FBI)

Wednesday, August 09, 2006 5:40 PM |(OGC) (FBIÇ

>T , lOGC) (FBI): I If OGC) (FBI) pnd database issues which need attention ASAP

](OGC) (FBI)C 30GC)(FBI)

—SECRET— RECORD 99999-3333

be b7C

be b7C

b2 b7E

As to the last question: Based on an explanation of th J" between the!

1 there is no relationship

I've asked for confirmation, and that responses are sent to this distribution list.

—Original Message— From: | | (OGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday. August 09.2006 3:44 PM b e To: | |(OGC) (FBI);I lOGC) (FBI)I 1(0GC)(FBI) b 7 c

Page 73: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Ce: Subji

: C Z ibjeciTRET JOGC) (FBI){ ]OGQ(FBI)

b6 b7C

: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

— s e e R E T -RECORD 99999-3333

Does every Red Wolf system use tha

b2 bo b7C b7E

Assistant General Counsel Policy & Training Unit National Security Law Branch

h 2 b6 b7C

Original Message From: I IFOGC) (FBI) B 6

Sent Tuesday August 08. 2006 6:40 PM b7C Toi I (OGC) fFBI):l IfOGC) (FBI);| |(OGC)(FBI) Subject: RE: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASSP

SECRET RECORD 99999-3333 b6

b7C

Here's what I learned :

So for example, vou will havef

—Original Message— From: I I TOGO (FBI) Sent: Monday, August 07, 2006 1:37 PM . To: I I fOGC) (FBI)I KOGC)(FBI):| |[OGC) (FBI) Subject: FW: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

SEC.RET RECORD 99999-3333

b7C

2

Page 74: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

b2 b6 blC b7E b5

Do you have any other into on thisY

Assistant General Counsel Policy & Training Unit National Security Law Branch

b2 b6 b7C

—-Original Message-From: I Sent: To:

Cc:

Subject:

JOGC) (FBI) Mnnrlav tiinntffl7 2006 10:33

I UÛGC) (OGA), J(OGC) (FBI]

L(OGC) (OGA)F £ «A.

I T ] (OGC) (FBI)[ IfÖGC) (FBI)

VOGC) (OGA); JOGC) (QGA|

(OGC) (FBI)| (OGC) (FBI) RE: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

_JxBCft€rf~ RECORD 99999-3333

J (OGC) (FBI);

b2 b6 b7C b7E

OGC) I (OGC)

KOGO(FBI): 3ÚGQÍEBI); ai);

Please ask| [to raise these issues with] during their next meeting.

I will askl Tabout some of your issues, but I do not see a need for another survey at this time.

Did you discuss these issues with thej [CDC?

b2 b6 b7C b7E

[ Unit Chief National Security Law Policy and Training Unit FBI HO Room 7975 STUIII:! ' b2 bo b7C

Unclassified Fax: Secure Fax:

Page 75: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

—Original Message— From: Sent: To:

Cc:

Subject:

](OGC) (OGA) b6 b7C

Monday. August 07.2006 9:12 AM-

m

(OGA)r (OGA)L

OCCRCT RECORD 99999-3333

liOGC) (FBI);|_ IfOGC) (FBI)

JOGQ (FBI);[ JOGC)

J(OGC) (OGA)I ](OGC)(OGA)|_

ItfOGC) (OGA)

JfOGC) (OGA); J(OGC) (OGA

OGC) (OGC)

land database issues which need attention ASAP

last weeC Hand. WFirfì m iLirC reviews {along with. minimiztion issues were identified which we think need attention AS, asked me to ask about

fror thef Jfrom 01 PR) and several AP- in additionf Halso

b2 b5 b6 b7C b7E

we need to have this to the Court ???

4

jexplained so we can decide what may have to be reported

Page 76: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Please advise how we can handle these matters quickly. Thanks [

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sound , DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 \SECRET

DERyED FROM: Multiple Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET 7

DERIVED FROM: Mùltiple Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRETÒ 7

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET / \

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET*

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECfRET \

ÎIVED FROM: Multiple Source* ECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION '

SECRET

5

Page 77: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

From: Sent: To:

Cc: Subject:

I (OGC) (FBI)

koGC) (FBI) Wednesday. August 09. 2006 5:40 PM. J

PSCifFBI) (OGC) (FBl f

OGC) (FBl£

JOGC) (FBI)

](OGC) (FBI) RE: Minimization and dataoase issues which need attention ASAP

,b6 . hl C

SECRET • RECORD 99999-3333 b2

b6 b7C b7E b5

As tn thft last niipstinn- Raspri nn an Pvnlanatinn nf thri thd

"InrnviHPfl hv DTD thprp is nn rplatinnshin hptwppn

I've asked for confirmation, and that responses are sent to this distribution list.

—Original Message— From: Sent: To: Cc:

Subject:

SECRET

I (OGC) (FBI) Wednesday. August 09. 2006 3:44 PM

IOGC) (FBI): [ JOGC) (FBI)[

;OGC) (FBI)|_ (OGC) (FBI)

](OGC)(FBI)

Kt: Minimization and data base issues which need attention ASAP

RECORD 99999-3333

1 Dnps pyprv Rpri Wnlf system i ISP thJ"

h 6 hlC

b2 b6 b7C b7E b5

Assistant General Counsel Policy & Training Unit Motional Qori iritx/ I s»»/ Branch

Original Message— From: | fcOGC) (FBI) Sent: Tuesday, August 08, 2006 6:40 PM To: I KOGC) (FBI)L Subject: RE: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

RECORD 99999-3333

J(OGC) (FBI) [OGQ(FBI)

be b7C

Page 78: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

—Original Mi From Sen] nt_ : I

ess|ûfc

iMihfclW: To: Subject:

SECRET — RECORD 99999-3333

,ugust 07, lOGC) (FBI'

m JOGC) (FBI) * 1 V PM

|(OGC)(FBI); FW: Minimization anci database issues which need attention ASAK

(OGC) (FBI) b2 b5 b6 b7C b7E

]DO you have any other info on this?

Assistant General Counsel Policy & Training Unit National Security Law Branch

-Original Message-

Page 79: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

From: Sent: T o d Cc:

Subject:

~|0GC) (FBI) TT,, Monday, August U/. 2006 10:33 AM

kOGC) (OGA)i KOGC) (FBI)i JQGC) ^frt^I Irrvyi fPEn

I (OGC) (OGÄl I l(OGC) (C (OGC) (OGA) a (FBI)! KOCCWW

• M

JOGC) (FBI)J

m m ~

iOGC)7FBnC

mecHO&nf )GC) (OGA)f

. (OGC) (FBI) rOGC) (FBI):

JOGC) (FBI)

1(OGC) (OGA)f OCÌO rnfiA)»

RE: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

J(OGC7TFBI7j[ Jj(OGC) (FBI)

SECRET RECORD 99999-3333

(OGC) h 2 KOGC)'(OGA); b 6

]OGC) (FBI);b7c

b7E

L Please ask| |to raise these issues with) |during their next meeting.

I will asl4 "kbout some of your issues, but I do not see a need for another survey at this time.

Did you discuss these issues with the| |CDC?

b 2 b6 b7C b7E

Unit Chief National Security Law Policy and Training Unit FBI HQ Room 7975 STU III Unclassified Fax Secure Fax£

1

—Original Message From: L Sent: To: I

fiBliPJSHEIEBEliHKiBK JOGC) (OGA) 9:12 AM

¿OGC) (FBI);

Cc:

Subject:

RPrPFT

(OGAf (OGAÏÏ.

kOGC) (FBI) IfOGCHOGA)!

IfOGQ fOGAH J(OGC) (OGA)

JOGC) (FBl£

J(OGC) (OGA) •(OGC) (OGA

Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

RECORD 99999-3333

b2 b6 b7C

bo b7C

30GC) (FBI);

[OGC) (OGC)

last Wfifif "knd I were out irl |for th (along witH FFöm niEBland several minimiztion issues were ident tied which we think need attention ASAP - in a c t i o n . I lalso asked me to ask about

Reviews

Page 80: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

We need to have this to the Court ???

Explained so we can decide what may have to be reported

Please advise how we can handle these matters quickly. Thank

)ERIVED FROM: Multiple Source 'CLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1

SECRET

PERIVEDNFROM: Multiple Séurces DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET

DERIVED FROMyMultiple Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRE

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sourc DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION SECRET

4

Page 81: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

I (OGC) (FBI)

DECLASSIFIED BY 60322LP/plj ON 07-31-2009

From: Sent: To:

Cc: Subject:

(OGC) (FBI) WorlnocHav Anruf t "TnOfi 4:44 PM

;OGC) (FBI (UGÜWhBH

(OGC) (FBI);

] [ O G C ) (FBI); RE: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

(OGC) (FBI)

b6 b7C

• S E C R E T R E C O R D 99999-3333

" b o e s every Red Wolf system use the I

b2 I b 6

Assistant General Counsel b 7 c Policy & Training Unit b 7 E National Security Law Branch f

—Original Message— From: | j(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Tuesday, August 08, 2006 6:40 PM To: I ' ' l(OGC) (FBI);| |OGQ (FBI);| |OGC)(FBI) Subject: Rfc: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP Subject: Rfc: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASA

be S 6 G R E T ;b-7C

R E C O R D 99999-3333

learned: Here's what I b2

b5 b7E

So for example, vou will have

—Original Message— From: | |OGC) (FBI) Sent: Monday, August 07, 2006 1:37 PM To: I I (OGC) (FBI){_ l0GC)(FBI) ;OGC) (FBI)

b6 b7C

Page 82: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Subject: FW: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

«EGRET RECORD 99999-3333

We need to have this Court ???

sxplained so we can decide what may have to be reported to the

Assistant General Cou nsel Policy & Training Unit Matinnai gen irity Law Branch

h 2 be blC

—Original Message— From: | |(OGC) (FBI) Sent: Monday. August 07. 2006 10:33 AM_ To: I | (OGC) (OGA)l

' (OlSCi (Ffen: THOMAij Cc: | [(OGH (OGA);,

(OGC) (OGA)

b2 be blC b7E

L

M

HP e WVWRRIR (OGC) (FBI)|_ ~VoGC) (FBI)

X : croi iuüc)(mii£

T o m fFRTII

UFBÜTT l o G G (OGAìl

\(OGC) (OGA):f

idJGLHhsa: |(OGC) (OGAX

|(OGC) (OGA£

3(OGC) (FBI) ¿OGC) (FBI)] t l(OGC) (OGA

pGC) (FBI)[_ I

IOGC) (FBI)f IfOGCI

Subject: RE: Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

GCGRCT-RECORD 99999-3333

lOGC)

1 Please aslj [o raise these issues with iuring their next meeting.

I will ask | labout some of your issues, but I do not see a need for another survey at this time.

Did you discuss these issues with the| frDC?

b2 bo b7C b7E

Unit Chief National Security Law Policy and Training Unit

2

b6 b7C

Page 83: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

FBI H O Room 7975 STU III: Unclassified Fax Secure Faa|

—Original Message— From: I Sent Monday, August 07,2006 9:12 AM Toi KOGC) (FBI);,

](OGC) (OGA)

Cc: _iQGC) (FBI)

I (OGC) (OGA)i

3 (OGC) (FBI),

I I (OGC) (OGÄjl , KOGC J (OGC) (OGA]|_

jroGci roGAif

Subject: (OGC) (OGA) Minimization and database issues which need attention ASAP

b2 b6 b7C

b6 b7C

:OGC) (FBI)£

l(OGQ (QGA);| I (OGC) (OGA)j

RECORD 99999-3333

"I last weehT "1 and I were out ini ror the reviews (along witf rFrnm OIPR) and several minimiztion issues were identified which we think need attention ASAP - in additionl lalso asked me to ask about another

b2 h 6 hlC b7E b5

3'

We need to have this Court ???

explained so we can decide what may have to be reported to the

Page 84: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Please advise how we can handle these matters quickly. Thankq

)ERIVED FROM: Multiple Source 'CLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1

S&CRET

DERIVEEXFROM: Multiple Sfouroes DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET \ /

DERIVED FROwl/n/lultiple Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET / \

DERIVEDXROM: Multirite Sources DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION 1 SECRET \

DERIVED FROM: Multiple Sourcé ^CLASSIFICATION EXEMPTION

SECRET

4

Page 85: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

DECLASSIFIED BY UC6Q322LP/PLJ/CC OCT 06-03-2009

BENDER, JOSEPH E. JR (OGC) (FBI)

From: Sent: To:

Cc:

Subject:

(OGC) (FBI) luesday, July IB. ijUtHM1':54 AM

"VOGO (FBI): ,(FBI);L

(OGC) (QGAÌ (OGA);

/CPIV

All

l . iDQGMEBil ](OGC) (FBI);

(01) (FBI);)

Revised 8/1 Redwolf EC ] (OGC) (OGA)

(OGC) (OGA); löüUIIEEli

(CTD) (FBI): I

(OGC)

(OGC)

b6 hie

SECRET RECORD 319xx

All: Attached is the revised 8/1 Red Wolf EC, which incorporates OIPR's comments. I will provide this tcj |this afternoon w/o redlining so that she can review it and send it to Valerie Caproni. So, if you have any comments, please let me know by 2:00 pm today.

Jo 6 b7C

Thanks.

REDWOLF2EC.wpd (25 KB)

DERIVEDTROWn^r^^Bt-etasstfkationjGuide G-3. dated 1/97. Forqjfln '"-I in^rintetttqencelnvisnqaUor^ DECLASSIFICATION EXEMPTIQMJ SECRET " —

l

Page 86: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

DECLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PL.J/CC ON 06-03-2009

(OGC) (FBI)

From: Sent: To: Subject:

I KOGC) (FBI) Wednesday, November 29, 2006 1:09 PM

|(CTD) (FBI);| FW: Further USA Minimization Guidance

4CTD) (FBI)

be hie

SECRET-RECORD FISAxxx

Just a note to let you know that I wanted to make sur^ [was up on all the latest guidance on minimization. I talked with her today about it, ensured that the case agent would check in with her to oversee the work as it goes along, and have asked the Associate Division Counself" |to assist as necessary. I also senj |the guidance below.

See you tomorrow.

tzzi • —Original Message— , 2

From: | KOGC) (FBI) b 6

b7C Sent: " Wednesday. November 29. 2006 12:05 PM To: J I T-TTO (FBJ1 Cc: . . __ Subject: Further FISA Minimization Guidance

3FCIJLT RECORD FISA xxx

P ) (FBI) ] (FBI);| |(FBI)

b2 b6 b7C b5

I believe you are using RedWolf]^ [s bringing you a recent EC for RedWolf users that contains guidance sent out by NSLB on July 31, 2006. It pertains to how you log and summarize, so please take a look at it and follow its advice. If you have any questions, don't hesitate to asl| |or me.

You are probably working alongsidq If you are, they also are a good resource to tap if vou have questions; sometimes they know more about what to do than the agents. Nevertheless, coordinate with ")as

•necessary.

' • Be aware of the following rules:

Again, feel free to call me at any time with questions.

bo b7C

Page 87: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Assistant General Counsel Counterterrorism Law Unit II National Security Law Branch I V I Siiitg 3R-11»

DgRWaaJEBOM: G-3 FBI Classification Guide G-3. dated 1/97. Foreign Counterintelligence Investigatiooe-DECLASSIFICATIDW-etSMETION 1 SECRET

DERIVED FROM: G-3 Fm ClasstfteaflSnGuide G-3. dated 1/97. Foreign Counterlntelfiggf DECLASSIFICAH0W-EXEMPTION 1

aations

2

Page 88: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

From: Sent: To: Subject:

RECORD FISA xxx

1CTD)(FBI) WoHnocHow MnuomherTQ "Wlfi 1 ;07 PM OGC) (FBI)

RE: Further F ISA Minimization Guidance b2 • b6 b7C

Thanks for the help, will keep all this in mind.

rrn/rrns n/am i

IM —-Original l essaoe-From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

JrOGC) (FBI) Wednesday. IMnvpmhe^2972006 12:05 PM O D ) (FBI]_ J (FBI);

Further FISA Minimization Guidance ](FBI)

—SECRET RECORD FISA xxx

b2 b6 b7C

b2 b6 b7C b5 IZZ1

I believe you are using Red Wolf . r lis bringing you a recent EC for RedWolf users that contains guidance sent out by NSLB on July 31, 2006. It pertains to how you log and summarize, so please take a look at it and follow its advice. If you have any questions, don't hesitate to askl lor me.

You are probably working alongside If you are, they also are a good resource to tap if vou have questions; sometimes they know more about what to do than the agents. Nevertheless, coordinate witl necessary.

> Be aware of the following rules:

Again, feel free to call me at any time with questions.

be b7C

Assistant General Counsel DECLASSIFIED BY 60322LP/plj OH 07-31-2009

Page 89: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Counterterrorism Law Unit II National Security Law Branch I V I C . .ITQ SQ--11 ft

b2 be bic

DER1VEO-EROM: G-3 FBI Classification Guide G-3. dated 1/97. Foreign CounterlntelligenceJnvesttaations DECLASSlFICATTONHiXEMPTlON 1 SECRET

DERIVED FROM: G-3 £Bj-€taSsification Guide G-3. dated 1/97. Foreign Couniertrrteiliqence Investigations DECLASS<Fie/rn5N EXEMPTION 1 SECRET

89

Page 90: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION FOIPA

DELETED PAGE INFORMATION SHEET

Serial Description ~ COVER SHEET

Total Deleted Page(s) - 1 3 Page 339 ~ Duplicate Page 340 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 341 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 342 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 343 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 344 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 345 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 346 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 347 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 348 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 349 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 350 ~ b2, b4, b7E Page 351 ~ b2, b4, b7E

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx X Deleted Page(s) X X No Duplication Fee X No Duplication Fee X X for this Page X XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Page 91: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION FOIPA

DELETED PAGE INFORMATION SHEET

Serial Description ~ COVER SHEET

Total Deleted Page(s) - 7 Page 94 ~ Duplicate Page 9 5 - b4 Page 96 ~ b4 Page 97 ~ b4 Page 9 8 - b4 Page 9 9 - b4 Page 100 - b4

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx X Deleted Pagete) X X No Duplication Fee X )boa>axxxxSxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Page 92: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION FOIPA

DELETED PAGE INFORMATION SHEET

Serial Description ~ COVER SHEET

Total Deleted Page(s) ~ 11 Page 74 ~ b2, b5, b6, b7C, b7E Page 75 ~ b2, b5, b6, b7C, b7E Page 76 ~ b2, b5, b6, b7C, b7E Page 77 ~ b2, b5, b6, b7C, b7E Page 78 ~ b2, b5, b6, b7C, b7E Page 79 ~ b2, b5, b6, b7C, b7E Page 82 ~ b2, b6, b7C, b7E Page 83 ~ b2, b5, b6, b7C, b7E Page 84 ~ b2, b6, b7C, b7E Page 85 ~ b2, b6, b7C, b7E Page 86 ~ b2, b6, b7C, b7E

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX X Deleted Page(s) X

Page 93: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Message Page 1 of 8

(RMD) (FBI) DECLASSIFIED BY 60322 UC/LP/STP/JCF OH 03-30-2009 •

From: Sent: To:

Subject: RE: DATABASES

-SECRET^ RECORD 315xxxxxx

OGC) (FBI) Wednesday, December 07, 2005 10:23 AM

|(OTD) (FBI)

b2 h 6 b7C b7E

thanks, pik

Original Messaqe-From: ]OTD) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday, December 07, 2005 10:14 AM T o f Sufc Subject: RE: DAIABAStS

RECORD 315xxxxxx

(OGC) (FBI)

That is/was or

ar someone from his staff would best answer your questions-

-Original Messaoe-From{_ (OGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday, December 07, 2005 10:06 AM To:I I (OTD) (FBI) Subject: RE: DATABASES

QEXRET RECORD 315xxxxxx

thank you.

Do you also operate thej | database, and if not, do you know who does? Thanks.

pik

—Original Messaqe-From:[_ (OTD) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday, December 07, 2005 10:01 AM To{ Cc

1 (OGC) (FBI)

J(OTD) (FBI) 1(OTP) (FBI) J

(FBI)

Subject: RE: DATABASES

-SECRET—

J (OTD) (FBI) it OTP) (FBI); (ITD)

RECORD 315xxxxxx

Here, is the responses as they relate to

9/11/2007

Page 94: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

M e s s a g e Page 1 of 9

J(OGC) (FBI)

JCyD)(FBI); J O G C ) (FBI)i KOTD) (FBI),

h 6 b7C

Subject: DATABASES

SECRET ' RECORD 315xxxxxx

Attached is a memo responding to Judge Kotelly's questions. Again I apologize for this coming late in the day. Putting all this into words that everyone was comfortable with took longer than anyone anticipated.

Ç VED FROM: MuJiipfé'ëources C _ASSlFY~QMr?0151112

HVED FROM: Multiple S c r e e s DE(?fc>ASSIFY ON: 2015VM2 SECRFI

DERIVED FROM: Mult i le Sources DECLASSIFY ON: 201511'

fCRET

9/11/2007

Page 95: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Message Page 1 of 95

ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED _ • HEREIN 15 UNCLASSIFIED

( R M D ) ( F B I ) DATE 03-30-2009 BY 60322 UC/LP/STP/JCF.

From: (OGC) (FBI)

Monday, October 17, 2005 2:11 PM (OGC) (FBI); _ ~~|(OGC) (FBI)

Sent: To: Cc: Subject: FW: Heads up for Tech Cuts effort

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

fyi.

(OGC) (FBI)

b2 b 6 b7C b7E

Assistant General Counsel Policy & Training Unit National Security Law,Branch.

Original Messaqe-From:| ~ JOGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday, October 12, 2005 9:09 AM To:J J (OGC) (FBI) C d rOGC) (FBI) Subject: RE: Heads up for Tech Cuts effort

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

We received the attached preliminary draft frorrj I but have not had an opportunity to review it. We are going to determine whether PIAs are required for related systems at the meeting.

Assistant General Counsel Administrative Law Unit, Room 7338

THIS IS A PRIVILEGED COMMUNICATION AND IS NOT TO BE DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

Original Message From J I (OGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday. October 12, 2005 8:50 AM ; To:l l(OGC) (FBI);| I (OGC) (FBI) Ccj KOGC) (FBDI KOGCTTFBI) Subject: RE: Heads up for Tech Cuts effort

9/11/2007

Page 96: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Page 2 of5

ENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED DN-RECORD

i, we'll be there. Have you decided whether to do a PIA? If so, is there a draft or will there be one before je mtg? Oram I delusional....

Assistant General Counsel Policy & Training Unit National Security Law Branch

b2 ;b5 be b7C

—-Original Messaae-From: (OGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday. October 12. 2005 8:43 AM Toi Ce:

_ l (OGC)(FBnf JOGC) (FBI)j_

Subject: RE: Heads up for Tech Cuts effort ](OGC) (FBI)

] (OGC) (FBI)

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

We just set up a meeting with is here in ALU. .

related folks on the 20th at 11:00. I think the meeting

-—Original Message From:! ] (OGC) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday. October 12, 2005 8:22 AM

J ( O G C ) (FB11:1 ](OGC) (FBI);[

To CcJ Subject: RE: Heads up for Tech Cuts effort

l(OGC) (FBI) J (OGC) (FBI)

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Wemet with the| Tfolks yesterday and I had some questions for you. We are working on revising the standard minimization procedures for FISA and one of the issues isl

Lèt rVié krY>w it liâvè lYiêl àiïèàdy or will be rtiëetihg. vpc

Assistant General Counsel Policy & Training Unit National Security Law Branch

Oqninal Mpçsanp-From: (OGC) (FBI)

9/11/2007

Page 97: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Message Page 1 of 97

Sent: Friday, September 09. 2005 9:23 AM T<H I (OGC) ( F B D C Cc:l I (OGC) (FBI) Subject: FW: Heads up for Tech Cuts effort

(OGC) (FBI) b2 b6 b7C b7E

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Have you all heard anything more on this?! |and I are looking at PIA isstfes associated with| |Red Wolf/CITAI I If we set up a meeting to discuss these systems with the system owners are you interested in attending?

did your ec on the tech cut database ever get signed out? If so, could you email me a copy?

Thanks!

-Original

Message-From:L I F B I ) Sent: Thursday. April 28. 2005 11:25 AM Toj l (OGC) (FBI); Subject: FW: Heads up for Tech Cuts effort

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Re my earlier e-mail - here is the ITD e-mail to the field.

" • ( F B I )

(OGC) (FBI)

Original Message From: Sent: Thursday. April 28. 2005 11:23 AM To: I If FBI"): I CcL

](FBI) (FBI)

Subject: FW: Heads up for Tech Cuts effort

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Guys, Here is the email I was talking about

heading up this project. is an engineer a a who is

-Original Messaqe-From:| l ( I T D ) (FBI) Sent: Wednesday. April 20. 2005 7:54 AM

l(FBI)i (FBI)i KFBIii (FBI)I _J(FBI)j_ IfFBI):

l(FBI);l l(FBI)i 1 1 KFBIii (FBI)l If FBI):

l(FBI)i l(FBI);| 1 (FBlU ÌFBDi l(FBI);l 1

](FBÏ) (FBljf

9/11/2007

Page 98: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Message Page 4 of 5

(FBIVl liFBIi: fFBIV.I 1 lfFBD:l (FBI):!

|(FBI):I lfFBI):l l(FBT); ÏFBIÎÎ (FBI);

VFKW.i rFBOrl |(FBI); jiFBI rFBD:l 1

KFBDi KFBI);I l(FBI);

b2 b6 b7C b7E

CFBIi:l KFBIU (FBI);| l(FBI); imi);

IfFBIi:! iTFRTVl 1 IfFHM |(FBI);

IfFBTil m)i [FBI); l(FBI);| kFBl);| 1

l(FBI);| l(FBI);| FBI); l(FBI);l l(FBI);| 1

liFBIli TFBIU ÍÍFBIÍÍ 1 mm l(FBI):l l(ITD)

E Ü 3 (FBI); ,1 írFBI):! I m i

H l(FBI)f "|(FBI);f

IFBÏF " M F

Cc:l 2 E M

j F B f j i t KFBIK

TTFBÏH

JlTD) (FBI) IrrD) (FBI); ](rTD) (FBI);

Subject: Heads up for Tech Cuts effort

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

This is an informal "heads up" from the ELSUR Technology Management Unit (ETMU). An EC will follow.

The Counterintelligence and Counterterrorism Divisions have requested the ETMU's support in providing functionality for indexing and searching DCS-5000 generated Tech Cuts within the ELSUFj | The ETMU is coordinating with the Telecommunications Intercept and Collection Technology Unit

Please forward questions/concerns tc

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

Page 99: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION FOIPA

DELETED PAGE INFORMATION SHEET

Serial Description ~ COVER SHEET

Total Deleted Page(s) ~ 20 Page 29 ~ b2, b6, b7C, b7E Page 30 ~ b5 Page 31 ~ b5 Page 3 2 - b5 Page 33 ~ b5 Page 3 4 - b5 Page 3 5 - b5 Page 3 6 - b5 Page 37 - b5 Page 3 8 - b5 Page 3 9 - b5 Page 4 0 - b5 Page 41 - b5 Page 4 2 - b5 Page 4 3 - b5 Page 4 4 - b5 Page 4 5 - b5 Page 46 - b5 Page 47 - b5 Page 4 8 - b5

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX X Deleted Page(s) X X No Duplication X No Duplication F e e X

)bocxjocxxxx^xxxxxxxxxxxx

Page 100: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION FOIPA

DELETED PAGE INFORMATION SHEET

Serial Description ~ COVER SHEET

Total Deleted Page(s) - 1 1 7 Page 2 - Duplicate pg. 255 OTD/SPTU docs DR6

Duplicate Duplicate Duplicate Duplicate

Page 3 -Page 4 -Page 5 -Page 9 -Page 10 -Page 1 1 -Page 13 -Page 14 -Page 15 -Page 16 -Page 17 -Page 18 -Page 19 -Page 20 ~ Page 21 -Page 24 -Page 25 -Page 26 -Page 92 -Page 93 -Page 94 -Page 95 -Page 96 -Page 97 -Page 98 -Page 99 -Page 100 -Page 101 -Page 102 -Page 105 -Page 106 -Page 107 -Page 108 -Page 109 -Page 110 -Page 111-Page 112 -Page 113 -Page 114 -Page 115 -Page 116 -Page 117 -Page 118 -

Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl

Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl Dupl

cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate ícate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate cate

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX X Deleted Page(s) Xw X No Duplication Fee X X No Duplication Fee X )booiocxxxx£xxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Page 101: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Page 119 ~ Duplicate Page 120 ~ Duplicate Page 121 ~ Duplicate Page 122- Duplicate Page 123 - Duplicate Page 124 - Duplicate Page 125 - Duplicate Page 126 - Duplicate Page 127- Duplicate Page 128 - Duplicate Page 129 - Duplicate Page 130 - Duplicate Page 131 - Duplicate Page 132- Duplicate Page 147 - Duplicate Page 148 - Duplicate Page 149 - Duplicate Page 150 - Duplicate Page 151 ~ Duplicate Page 152- Duplicate Page 153 - Duplicate Page 173 - Duplicate Page 174 - Duplicate Page 175 - Duplicate Page 176 - Duplicate Page 177 - Duplicate Page 178 - Duplicate Page 193 - Duplicate Page 2 1 2 - Duplicate Page 2 1 3 - Duplicate Page 2 1 4 - Duplicate p. 408 Page 2 1 5 - Duplicate Page 2 1 6 - Duplicate Page 2 1 7 - Duplicate Page 2 1 8 - Duplicate Page 2 1 9 - Duplicate Page 2 2 0 - Duplicate Page 221 ~ Duplicate Page 222 - Duplicate Page 223 - Duplicate Page 224 - Duplicate Page 2 2 5 - Duplicate Page 2 2 6 - Duplicate Page 227 - Duplicate

docs DR6 (1083022)

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx X Deleted Page(s) X.

Page 102: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Page 228 ~ Duplicate Page 2 2 9 - Duplicate Page 2 4 9 - b4 Page 2 5 0 - b4 Page 251 - b4 Page 2 5 2 - b4 Page 2 5 3 - b4 Page 2 5 4 - b4 Page 2 5 5 - b4 Page 2 5 6 - b4 Page 2 5 7 - b4 Page 297 - Duplicate Page 298 - Duplicate Page 352 - Duplicate Page 353 - Duplicate Page 3 5 4 - Duplicate Page 355 - b2, b7E Page 356 - b2, b7E Page 357 - Duplicate Page 358 - Duplicate Page 359 - Duplicate Page 360 - Duplicate Page 361 - Duplicate Page 362 - Duplicate Page 363 - Duplicate Page 364 - Duplicate Page 3 6 5 - Duplicate Page 366 - Duplicate Page 371 - Duplicate

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx X Deleted Page(sl X X No Duplication X No Duplication F e e x

SooajoDoxxSxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Page 103: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

jAgenda for Monday 10/31/05 at 2:30 pm - Room 1342

This agenda Includes some CRs that are part of the backlog we are trying to eliminate. If you received this e-message, it is because your name appears on the CR as the requester or the originator. Any information you can provide on your CR will be appreciated. Thank you.

CR# 226122-

CR# 236973 -

CR# 235736 -

CR# 235763 -

CR# 235895 -

CR# 236325 -

CR# 236440 -

2571

Page 104: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

CR# 236458 -

CR# 236602 -

CR# 236608 -

CR Backlog begins here: b2 b7E

CR# 120447-

CR# 120279-SITE

CR# 120911-

CR# 126284-

CR# 126288-

CR# 126312-

CR# 126878-

CR# 132553-

CR# 146359 -

CR# 163761 -

CR# 207016-SERVER

The teleconference phone number is

-b6 CM/PPMU b7.

2572

Page 105: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

UNCLASSIFIED

2573

Page 106: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

s J f c l ^ T

(OTP) (FBI)

From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

L (OTD) (CON) Friday. October 28. 2005 3:07 PM

NON-RECORD

b2 b6 b7C b7E

DATE: 04-03-2009 CLASSIFIED BY 60322/UCyLRP/PLJ/sdb REASON: 1.4 (c) DECLASSIFY ON::04-03-2034

I |- Based on our discussion this morning regarding!. to take with regards to| Imessaae below?| expecting a response from someone iH I

From:f Original Message-

](OTD)(CON) Sent: Friday, October 28, 2005 8:15 AM To: I "l(OTDHCON) Cc:|

]what action would you want me ]vas included in the distribution, so he will be

b6 b7C

Subject: RE i I

"ÑON-RECORD IED ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED

HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT M E R E SHOOT OTHERWISE

b2 b6 b7C b7E

received a copy of the email informing us that thel —~~ I I also received an email fromL

J Please contact He also indicated they needf

[]had reversed their position and would not bej ~ | clarifying that the space relocation in their office would

directly to see what can be worked out.

Thanks,

Original Message-From: (_ J(OTD)(CON) Sent: Wednesday, October 26, 2005 10:14 AM To:l ~1 (OTm fCONI Cc:

b2 b6 b7C b7E

Subject: RE£

2566

Page 107: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Message Page 1 of2 AIL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN 15 UNCLASSIFIED DATE 04-03-2009 BY 60322/UC/LRP/PLJ/sdi)

From: Sent: Friday, November 04, 2005 3:39 PM To: Subject: RE: Red Wolf materials

b2 b6 b7C bl E

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

We can make this happen.

AT

Original Messaqe-Fromj] Sent: Friday, November 04, 2005 11:57 AM To: I Cc:

Subject: FW: Red Wolf materials

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

I need us to set up a training group onC for the next few weeks.

"1- if vou could start the process and coordinate with) j-e the

pould you please[

Thanx

Original Message-Fromj Sent: Friday, November 04, 2005 10:49 AM To: 1 Cc:

1 2 / 1 1 / 2 0 0 6

Page 108: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

Message Page 1 of2

Subject; Red Wolf materials

UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

I Iwlytt wm ild it take to get some materials for the training we are doing Nov. 30th on RW here atj |

We need:

1.

b2 h 6 b7C

brwarded here before the date.

2. Manuals for RW, if we can get some fronr

Thanks!

Technology Planning and Operations Support Unit Intelligence Program Management Section The Directorate of Intelligence

(new number)

UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

1 2 / 1 1 / 2 0 0 6

Page 109: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

Monday. November 07. 2005 12:53 PM b2 b6 hlC b7E

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

A question came up as to whether we are still using Apparently there was an issue identified a while ago which indicated thatT

vith the Red Wolf -Z I

\ If so how many ?????

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

ALL INFORMATIOH CONTAINED HEREIN 15 UNCLASSIFIED DATE 04-03-2009 BY 60322/UC/LRP/PLJ/sdb

2515

Page 110: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

From: Sent: To: Subject:

UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Tuesday, November 08. 2005 3:35 PM

FW: Rewolf Data ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED DATE 04-03-2009 BY 60322/UC/LRP/PLJ/sdb

b2 b6 b7C b7E

Is this related to the stuff recently tasked wJ

-cee Original Message--—

From: | Sent: Tuesday, November 08, 2005 2:03 PM To: I Cc:| Subject: RE: Rewolf Data

UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

Do you know the specific problem the users are having? We may need to involve the folks from| |and certainly the Red Wolf Team | "let, al.).

• Original Message

• From J ~1 Sent: Tuesday, November 08, 2005 12:05 PM To: I I Subject: Rewolf Data

UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD

I have several users that are having a problem with record to see what you think?

Ire-wolf data. Could you take a look at the following

658

Page 111: FEDERAL BUREA OU F INVESTIGATIONSep 09, 2010  · CURRENT FISA TARGET S UNDER INDICTMENT To reques at n audit of ARB ^^ilfe-ses be performed regardin belog w liste FISd A targets,

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED