fbi report on cattle mutilations

Upload: andrew-whalen

Post on 03-Apr-2018

226 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    1/130

    5

    .r-~I W

    Q >L 3

    FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

    ENCLOSURE COVER SHEET

    V. ,4,,,,,,,,L/A

    SUBJECT Z477 ./..s=

    CROSS-REFERENCES

    51 PAGES REVIEWED FOR11115 RELEASE

    HQ53 SPAGHES AVAILABLEFOR RELEASE

    THIS IS ENCLOSURE OF ENCLOSURES

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    2/130

    =~'-11.1-

    eQ .e -

    3~; -'

    i.-

    Li

    8

    ' . -;--I _' I

    I -r ._ ..&. - -920 ''H._""""92 I

    I- '-'--', _92e

    ' .-"'92JJ - _ _ . -_

    " T .- '9

    . ..'._. . _....__-

    September101!?!

    5?-IQI_ I an-.4lQ'92". "~"

    M 15-5 - o">/>@92 L ".._ IQ-

    ..92"'.. ..' ,'. . : ,.

    - __I-

    Icncreble Ce:-lI'.curtie "7 '5 ,1United Stetee Senate ' -

    Ileehingtun, U. Ce @510

    I,,9;, 92._'hi'-. - _'F L.5;1!! s llli X11]! """ '_ "''."' "''-

    .> ..e- r --:a_r-= =-~~__;_ ,._-,_--,,--g..-~--_'~_

    thisie to eckncvledgereceiptof your1-=='. H*September lth, with enclosure, concerning thetecent Ielring end killing of cattlein eevezel Iebre e cctunitiee. -_ ,-1

    . = .-1.1;

    Onlcgaet23tdIene92Ieredycu:1ette1'eIIng'eet31lt;..L&indiceted I ne having e repreeentativecl en:mane _ ,__

    rice contact llr. Georgelitchcccl: of Stuart, Iebre egin -";&ternine ebetbe: the tecte ccnetitetee pceeible vio1eI:iQ"'lav virgin the investigative jeriedictice el the M _ _. ._

    J' '=*

    A -13:11 _ceticeIra ed 4

    ederel

    :O!!iee te el ietervieee

    lee-131-

    .cu V 1tEllieletter Biiii I

    I.nve1vel.""-_-'7

    ebtb . -.e.eed-~ -- r erQ._indivdutih, it

    '-" E.-=1-14;.ctice

    V gugcnereiQeine icu:k led enilele-c-e-a eiuli i i.|l 'i ii iiiendlawenlcecdeengefticeure _4_

    . _":.:_.__.,_3:;,3,"_ :": :>

    * _ Sincerely gee:-e -.-.;-. '-. :f-- U8I hi '- _,_f$-3-u4 -

    -/l.s-an-_.-A-.-.'-;;....--as-=.~| ""

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    3/130

    3.3:-

    _,o

    0

    i

    DL

    ._i .An|,,921cu|=gl'lS'. ',ccu;": nllnuuu' I """' A Iua.nlIunI'a|I.|nu

    ' _ . AlaIIuurtA|.uoIr-lsiiclac

    Qlcaaea-$lales,$e'na{c92 Assoc. DiDepDep.D.-

    Ant. Dir.Admin.

    p.W5- ,- Eh-eI:

    September4, 1974 _

    -1 / //

    _ C IQa0 I92

    ._- _ . Departmentof Justice/-92

    _,, WW Washington,D,C, L/G. d DearHr.Kelley:'

    92Iva

    -I-I

    a

    .-2

    D

    ~92

    ; ' s ti''. " lntell.

    I.nborulPlan. &I-Ir.ClarenceI-I.Kelley_ V 39""

    I

    Dvirewr D _ J;2Federal Bureauof Investigation . 1-1q,

    Di:-ecwrBI-

    Y Thiswillreferto mypreviousletterofAugust21toyouregardingtheseriesof incidentsstretchingfromOklahoma/to Nebraskain whichcattle havebeendismemberedin somekind [of strange witchcraftcult. _

    Enclosedisa newspaperarticle which appearedin the Hastings,Nebraska,DailyTribuneconcerningtheseweirdevents.*Articles similar to this one have appeared in manyof the Nebraskanewspapers. I thoughtyou would want to see this article in'order to substantiate the claims whichhave beenmade.0

    I amwonderingifyour goodoffices have instigated aninvestigation into this situation either in Nebraskaor any ofthe other states experiencingsimilar acts of mutilation to -|

    livestock.I willappreciatehearingfromyou. 6I |Thankingyou, I am

    ' cerelyyo_u_r_s__,__/-/. /I .

    twtd}cm. cunns,ussI5'D I "EH:3 ...0-.--3

    ~ Q Em, - Id -4".'92,-,~ .. r /

    Q,hta,. CORR3 3 :

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    4/130

    _ ___*_

    _I_ _U_h"__ %#__OWP_____ ___:%_H_L__9292O _#39;%

    :3___

    __.'_ 92__L;______t.____"_r,_h__

    .

    ;39;Mw_m$MmuM%m_1%_wHm_p__wWMmm___k__q_L____1____N___

    MAmM%mM_wmmwM__mm_mmm_mAm_m%_"?mmMm__|H__ _92_H_HH ____'__I_h _'hHwhF Ew

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    5/130

    ___ ,'__ ____WP&m _

    _ ___%&mF M_hu_m_

    m__JHq_nwhE_*rruN!_m__%M_ %__f'_%m__

    ___

    __92_wO_.__39;__

    J

    9;_h__'__h_~_M_

    _

    _&__._ __

    _.___,_

    _____9;

    h uh&m@MMmmH $%_w___Mu 'mun%%h@%mwhmmw_ mF_:hJ____m'w__&__WmW M__HWWWmmmummmmmmmumwwmwamdI M&m&hB

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    6/130

    iseu-I7 I

    ' 'FD ll Hos S II--I0

    . _

    92T3.

    I.-

    n

    :4 -'

    _

    '.92

    a

    "1

    L.

    -1-

    is-.I.

    E.5.._

    Date 75

    Transmit the following inTypeillpldulleslorioisli

    Vlo.iAIRIE1- _ _ __ __ __________ _Pnont

    DIRECTOR, FBI KITENTIONS

    mom s c, 1-mmmrous%! s--0-/W143summon ILATIONS or mnumssscum mxon ,......-.=-.._n1nmzso:rA._uonmg_%usmcu 2-unrrsn - _ -

    n lsrcllaneous}_ons92.I.lJ92Cl'l|/FortheinformationoftheBureau,animals,at

    mostllivestock,havebeenreportedasutilatedinthet reestate area of this division and parts of theirbodies missing The parts listed as missing have beenthe sexual organs, ears, li s and udders, and in some

    instances,the blood from e animals was consideredco letely drained." No evidence of value ever locatedat t e scene.

    State veterinarians, after examination oflntilated animal carcasses, contend dead animals wereeatenby other animals or varmits, believed tobe foxesduetotheirsharpsideteeth,whichweredescribedasshearing teeth l ke scissors.

    The Bureau is requested to furnish theMinneapolis Division with any supporting information tothe above ooments madeby stake veterinarians or,if

    already contacted by other aw enforcement agencies, theresultsoftheirinvestigatonsoryo92i:;dabo1-atoryresultsofevidencepreviouslysubmittedns arcaszs 5ea - '-

    Enclosed is a xeroxclipping o mnents maeby RICHARDHILDE NA!, Ch EAgent, North Dakota Crime

    Bureau,Bismarck. "vim -_.,______O

    r

    Q-an=m..

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    7/130

    -0

    R

    .92.

    ru1_|92

    eI

    92

    3

    n

    1'I

    i

    -.-IQ

    '-

    II

    I

    92

    ._

    1

    92-

    h:_ .

    K

    $-

    ,_.e5.I

    Q-.P

    s?

    J " J9292, J U

    e~ '0-

    6*/

    92-a-

    laea. lb. _en. an aaa._'00- llUh .-

    lee!--Ima

    GI- i--1ele1.lbe__Iii-lG1_.

    BI-be--._-,

    U . ' '..-i.lnea-I-lb__,_

    I S I

    .,-Jgl -Q go":

    _Y-_ -..,..._ __.._._......._,,.._-_._..._.,_.._..-

    < id >__" . '

    .- ' ._ 1-ofsm, 11::_- Airtel l-Hr.Clea-_I;_

    ."' 21'?" "i-.-v ' -

    ". 8 .I '0, .9.-__.. . - .15.:I: 'l .. ' .1., .'._.:j;_-1";=.-'_1'am, Hinneamliesz-o-1414:! _Iron: _Qirector, I322:Q3 -'0 "'-unxF1Xrm'1 17;o mums '-s r -

    ,.!P-M5014. H0313 a6-.aSOU'a1'Ha DAKOTA- - '-'7an . ...ansmncu mu-ran

    Reference Hinneapolia eirtel dated January 21, 1975

    - The circinatancee act forth in referenced airtelwere discussed with Dr. Don ilileon, Chief, liamalogy Section,

    ' II.8. Iish and IlildlifeService, Uaahington, D. C.

    Dr. Wilson aaid that the circunatancee aet forth in-referenced airtel are consiatent'11th natural-ghenonena.According to Dr. Wilson, vhen anallIammall such ea foxes and_9pposua feed on the carcaaoea of_largelnanmala such ancattle that have not decayed they first feed on aoft tiasueeauch ea the nose, lips, uddera and genital areaa. Be saidthat it haa been frequently observed that the genital area

    |ia eoat often the first aoft tiasue to be attacked.

    __'_ Dr. Vilsonhad info:-nation concerningthe ageappearance of tiaaue bitten by foxes.

    'ce;li 1/$1. l

    ' Q92' '2:h'5!W9

    oi .o!?.

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    8/130

    '92

    g -

    '3.1I.

    1

    I

    0

    S

    3 I.3

    _

    92

    I5

    :1:

    mt2,.

    v

    3.

    >-- _'__~ '=:} 1.! T';::e __A~ _, ,._Z----- - - Ix .~31'

    .'- nae-I

    . aD If .

    '0

    8Bt.t?.CIC. ND. MP! - Aneaptattation may have beenhead-fee a nah ol livestock ::i::tl-atit-asthathavepleaded$25 Le:-1:: andhavere-eentty

    * "" = #5 uizota.

    53':are :.t':t:'altn the Itoethhie-eta CrisieBureaua.

    Otis .- gent Richanl Hildanil ta oi ce Ind beengetfmgai::.t:e:edregora t'ece:tI_eattiaeatze- e ztutilatioze aeroaaElkrtl .1 -a. -'-::.:shirt: Iere sin- IIID a rat-it oi mutilation re-

    pam fromSouthDakotaearlierhie nmtil

    =51 wein C.-ifzakeen Se-at'. :eaztieteiadiedof

    u

    I --q-a

    t."ai'II:'ll'1I.eertqn-nqtan au-'yea he3-an-e.Hildeseal.The Q-.'.:e'at'==i=!-8lh *52%;: ;-.edt :etialdysentery.

    it-..::b:u=.u-tttbat foxes and

    am: sail ar.i:-.:Lemy have has reegoaihiefor themutila-nun.i i:i a1ii i'iedti-ei -

    ta-ab.I-Zeacted tat suchsmalla:-ale re:-e at able ta hi.-I

    inane : ta rite

    -7- *1

    I"-"-92IF:_Q92.Iti. --.3

    tnlural t-auaesandthat animatehave eatenthe part: at thelit-enactattertheyare dead,l-tilde said.

    we-a -t.ii.the"dread hii ri-eeivedrewtts at livutock mu-tilation inaeveral North Dakotacounties,heaid. Twocan anda bullwerereportedea killedinI-leltlenqCounty,tour cattlewerefounddeedwith pert: oftheirhodia missingin DickeyCountya.-ataewtraaIoundieasimilar condition in I- e ater

    County.he said. In addition,iii- iiiiii"Ell'Se"I-epurteu"**'iiailtou.'.:yin I-ZclatoahCouaty,

    -1.. 1--08"" ' - ".

    Y5

    =

    yss5*"UIhlth areaaltereporteelaabelt!mutilated.he added.-_"t'J__ehadheengetting teee

    reportsandtheyhadcalleditI|ttttilatiott,"hesaid."Furttcta

    0c

    '-

    thiapointtlntwe aothaveatnaniaeor cultan the twe

    ltildeaaid.illeaoledthatlei eialaintmthatateehadttee

    :1 tinevit'u-idrwt'*";nn *'*tisad' il'lfit :l&ii iitvasijiatheycouldnever nd at-hide

    tnclte."tmtszutwttt

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    9/130

    92': " eB e

    ._, -. _- ,'r- _' ._.----- - -- ,; 1! ? A.3:.- ' -'.. _,__. "__H'_.'.,_. '17 $TIGIllmll_ll'll|0|1O92'I'il'lqin . ______WW __ _

    {a,1,_-_ ''-T TypeInplaten-~m- -.'at . ... @-U go e92'Vic

    1

    e .

    F

    -II

    '..--

    -.54

    e0

    a-'-

    -nuI

    5 '.'I Dales:-I-'1'..'=- ,

    to

    Q _'-

    Q. "'' FBl -

    ilor ebdilr I I "WI . QD 01

    AIRTIIL " -'-. AIRHAIL

    /qr' Jill?!!:r|1|.:u|.:s- =92'on-?"Jul|'.'_5'$vBJB.T= -

    3 .."_ ; __-. I '9._' . __;__ -nQ_

    .g-;_-

    .

    I. .'"1J

    =: -. :;iiTt*I 71 11 11$1 &1 1 11$

    . -"':? -'1';-nxnncronFBI -

    'I-590"

    I-Ill. Dim'

    Mia In.

    Comp.SyIsl. Lllel

    muI.CGen. luvI "ell. ._.._

    in pes fn5--tiii.

    To."'-.'-9" ..~ ~'" "'3'-'*'I'. - : ' " 92 I'.i I J'-rnou;-7--;_'-_.'-'_AC,,DENVER,,I I,-.

    '" Esmuus ,

    . '.'~34!: ~

    r ..-. s/ReDen_verairtelB/_29/75. .A -.,e1'='=-_ . ' '. __6"E[' _-A

    ' 'Enclosed herewith isa copy of an editorialap aring

    DirectorSQ

    .q-

    - requestthat theFBIentercaptionedinvetigztion... _ -'. . ___ /:,_,@j/as_ .L'" Onthe morningof 9/14/75SADJNALDJ. SEBESTA,lied/ia

    'inthe DenverPost"9/3/75relatingto$_enatorFLLOIDK%iAS

    Relations Representative, and I visitedwith the editorial staffof the "Denver Post" concerning the article. Wemet with'Cl

    5 iR. BUXTON,Executive Vice President, Editor and Publisher,-- _ROBERTFATTRIDGE,Editor of the Editorial Page, and LEEOLSO!-I,

    Editorial Page writer and writer ofenclosed article, and explain'ed to them the manner in which thisBureau enters investigations,'_" stressingthepoint that unlessthe FBI hasinvestigative juris-._.'diction_under Federalstatute,"we cannotenteranyinvestigatio_'._It was_'p,gintedout to these individuals that if the FBI wereto

    'enter an investigation merely becausesomeone felt we.should,wewould soon be categorized asa national police force. 'I helimi-

    - -tations placedon theBureau by Congressand-the Departmentofqlustieeere well defined and it was pointed out that the FBI -' "alwa s o erate within thesco e of its investi ative urisdiction

    Lebolaiory'|e|92I lv

    Spec.In.

    -" _ ATTENTION nxrnmmn armns _ Y--I--._

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    10/130

    1.Q

    F92:-

    1?.-!

    *.

    _1

    Q

    4

    1.

    u

    1-

    5.

    ...I:

    3

    tF

    Ji.

    -.Q,.4"r..'-

    v

    G

    st - '-" .9 - a '' " . } .0 ,1 .I --of _ - _. ". 0.1 -.- - --_' . . ..- -I-_ B-.: , . '- .5 ._$'l__._Q'92QI .._._ .ix -":"' I_ V_ I -.-on-

    Is

    Q 'U

    Q

    __ .92_ev: _ ' I '

    5" -'2;extended_to theseindividuals to visit t ne__D_en'v'_e[BI pffieePf. -iw

    -_'--l'.'-

    - 92._: I

    W-~Y=-.-n _--- Q.- uQ. ,

    .=_ .E_-.f-.*.'.'=~- .

    19;? -.

    1-

    1.92..,

    an .'|Q

    s _ --'.-$1. .-, -.:._".._,_ :5?~. _Q:1 '--.9.at. , P - .v10 KP 9* . -11-pp-5*-... "'.* :-. -. - -.- '- . -

    -..

    "-.-".r..-I.-- ,--.- - "- ' -:a_ . .-_: . ,. . 1,

    Isf - '.." " ' - ,. .r-- :--.- 1'-P -*~ 1. --:-=1 '---. Q

    Q. .. 0112-; . . 'L'i-ls? '9"

    ".Q 0 92,

    _.-g. 3,,"_n-I -I'n" -. ..

    a 6. :1- -0!} - I_:..-in -, , _ , Q_;- :..,"- ,- ..-; r I '-.--1 - I_ 'I >

    .jurisdiction~;asAresult o_ thismeeting -and"-'expreappr-eciat_ion'.for'the visitfrom-this office. It.is believed

    __i:t_hat -thiskgpeetingwas extremely -beneficial,__bcthto the repre-sentatives of the "Denver Post and to this office since it gave :-; me agood reason' notonlyto meet_them personally but.to discussmatters of mutualinterest. ~. . '

    At the conclusion of this meeting aninvitation was

    at_a_ny_-time" -jrhich they readily acce ted .' '

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    11/130

    4-

    i.

    1.

    11

    '-I.-

    '2'9

    '___

    a1

    eI

    a

    3

    l .-7,.ar5

    I

    -T=2

    |

    2

    e

    |92

    J-

    e

    1r

    Er

    !

    Z'1

    r

    .f

    -*=92.2e.

    _, .

    .~-*-

    Moon! Cll ping In SpaceBelow!

    - 1

    W,-_ ;;i, e .__._.._ -' -__ _

    all the FBI wlll not enterhe investigation Ifyslerlous Ilvestodrdeaths In Coloradoadmeadjacent atalea thanSen. FloydI-task .ahould take the nutter to Oongreaa rSolution. .. -

    'The lnoldenls areloo widespread and poten-

    tially too dangerous topublic order-lo Ignore.Narrow Interpretationsor whatthe FBl aroleBvls-a-vla stateauthority arenot adequatebIreneed. '

    ' Therels alreadylederal involvement.Oomlderink: Bo-citricof the gon=h:pp-; tram:ct

    developing Ineastern Coloradowhere moatofgthe Incidentshave been oocurrlng!. theU.S.:8urear.r ofLand ManagementBLM!has had b_- elahelicopterinventory olItslandsit-unlies. BLM otlicielsare almplyatrald '

    r-' '"'1'-.~ --~- _

    4-.t '_C~a_tt|e__|Jeathsialdlhe F5_i_

    _ :-_','ef ! . 1," .'-73" F

    *7 T . __

    " newspaper, any

    92-aim92

    [Indicate peqe,nene ofInd lilll-I

    Iicoplora mightbe mtdownbynreiia d-_g The Denver plhera lrightenedbyoatlle deaths.It that Ian ! a reason tor lederal involvement. we

    don1knowwhatls.Argdthequaalionolerhlcl1tederal agency Investigate: tan !asimportant eaE-.er92.eedwMr~.g etoc-.'sonM!rr..i-'..'enl.s!.h.a.t!broader than the lurladictlon ol one etate.' Kllingsand mutilation: of livestodr have bee

    occurring I1 Wyoming. Nebraska. Kanaaeelsewhere-not lust I1Cobrapattern lo the Incident: Ibroadest possibleatudy ofthembhdlcated.

    lranycaamsenator aalrellahouldlreeplreassure onthe FBI. It has manpowerandaor

    ange oflnvealigatory tools.AndIthe FBI ree suooeaaluly. thesenator ehouldgo I: Oonore

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    12/130

    5_:.

    5;4,3

    PI-

    ._-QTI92S

    r. i_

    - .

    .s, __F_0.,.

    5'"

    Ya

    J

    i

    '7;..-

    Q

    Q

    r".

    .A ,.

    I-_-.

    '. '57//7

    - 9 '__':::tit. as -*3"

    UNl'l_ l-ll!s'| .92'|'i-i-LRNMI-2N1'' iiMemorandum '

    ' ' 1

    lv-lro Auam "A'I'I'.fCp[e[I]D

    . _ . IJMLR.J.o llgnlr - 1- M1"-

    Al '92.I .. 1 '-MI ., " "s!.':"-_="=.'#"::.I.&:-an--.=1-iv... 1 - Mr-

    /1'=1=orfS4UTILAT10Normvssrocx. 1-Mr.SheerSTATE01-"cononnno 1- Mr.BowerIN,FORMATl0l~{concsnnmo _, | ;,r5. t

    e |~w#'z1

    In.fllnI

    GeIa-mllopL-loI45j

    er is,

    AdamsGallaghe

    O'CoCooke

    I'll :

    1 1FIOK1 2

    pt

    I 11:1responsetoa telephonecallfromHonorable_FloydK. I"/_ askel1,UnitedStatesSenatorfromColorado,totheQirector9/11/&Ttontacted Senatorllaskell telephonicallytoday, Q/12/75.

    Senator Haskell indicated his concern for asituation occurringin the western states where cattle have been discovered mutilated. Thebizarre mutilattons involve loss of left ear, left eye, sex organ, andtheblood drained from the carcass withno traces ofblood left on tie groundandnofootprints.

    Senatorllaskell repeated his request that the Flil enter theinvestigation. Theprovisionsof theInterstateTransportationof StolenCattleStatute,Title 18, U.S. Code,Section2311,wereexplainedto him. It waspointedoutthattheremustbeaninterstatetransportation.

    Senator Haskell said that he had no iniorniation that an interstate transpo -tion hadoccurredin anyof thesecases. lie saidhefelt thiswastoobigfor the local authorities, andthe FBI with its resources couldcometo asolution.He saidtheranchersare gettingconsiderablyworriedoutthereandhefelt ii theFBI wouldjustentertheinvestigationit wouldhaveadeterrenteffect. Our jurisdictionwasexplainedto SenatorHaskellandhe said that he imderstoodour statutory limitations andinquired asto

    whetheraresolutionwouldgiveustheneces_safyt}nv:es_tl.g. . i .-1 aI- __

    SenatorHaskellwaggdv edtha%%"robablywouldtakealaw&whereuponheaskedif therewereanyonethathecoulddiscussthismatte

    with. He wasreferred to the CriminalDivisionof the Departmentof' g -"- InnI-.-nu :-_

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    13/130

    E]-

    *...

    5

    i.

    -.-".

    F-4-

    . ,.-;

    L

    0'.

    AI_-.-.4-

    .__.

    ,r,

    I

    2J.

    eaI

    |

    i5.

    ' ,l

    1;.

    -1 ~t - 1'51; . oi

    Memorandum to Mr. Adams -

    RE: MUTILATION OF LIVESTOCK

    STATE OF CODORADO

    Senator Haskell rccont ct'edme thisafternoon and said that .

    he hadreceivedacallfrom Dans i-Idwards,editor ofthepaperinBrush, Colorado, who furnished information that U. S.Army helicoptershad beenseenin thevicinity of where some of thecattle were mutilatedand that he, Edwards, had been threatened but Senator Haskell did notknow whatsort oi threats Edwards had received or bywhom.

    .' Hewas advised that this irnformationnwould be furnished toour Denver Office and that Denver would closely follow the situation.Senator Haskell expressed his appreciation;

    C CC itInasmuch as Senator Haskell stated he might call the CriminalDivision of the Department of Justice, John Keeney, Deputy AssistartAttorney General, Criminal Division, was teiephonicaiiy adfised oi mycontact with Senator Haskell and he was furnished background informationconcerning this situation. ' '

    The above information was also furnished to SA Jim Bristol,

    ppppW _,,_,WDenver Office. Bristol was instructed to have Mr. Hdwardsggcontactedconcerning the alleged threats thathe hasreceived. ' ' '

    ACTION:

    For information.

    I /

    9/Pw _/FPO

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    14/130

    .-

    -

    .3

    .n

    I--1

    a

    E

    -

    A.

    __;_:___,..,___.,__._ :,,?__.__ ._;_,_ ___...;._.j= _.-.':. la_-.. 3..I -....-_'.-..r_":Q;1;-'::f;;:J-i; -u s o e su ' - I '.'-'9: Q... :'-.. . . ..._

    Q

    '-.~:=*- -.'- --:i--

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    15/130

    ' Haul.

    .1-'1 .

    I-.II92 L;-In |...4-us ...-u./I.-.----p-- -.. --__- ii !_1' Q.L .=->- ,u/L- q1'~__ .M. ._ A--'--.- - : ..; .-.-_.L''-:14"T_____.__.__-'9,t F's2,4 , 92Q. ' 0i Slit. 0|?--.-.- J3! 0 . au__ , -'' S t,o.,.As* .----f - mA;s

    Qilill. i.-- -.--

    e - .. --Date: s/29175-' ' Files I to *5 'Truman! thelollowlnq In__ _ __a _1, _ 1 W W _ _

    ' {Type 2eiee-1:2 ev ede! Gen. lav

    _"I vAIRTEL anuum. ._IO _, s,_ _, ee, :1 aax _We , W ,,_ '_ _hgpsclloll rag! bu"

    & $QQQ-hchar-1-1:;xenon:-11-0-$ ra -In-In--Dc-c-culquillilidhcQ92Q.II.

    i'.. J- 1 $$$ -- _

    ? T0 = n1cron; rs: I' M ' " ' Sa iiscellancbus-Non-SubvenlrqiSpec. luv- Ac .77'7V:; 77VJ77:7 M1|-Qlglng

    in _I e ------- _I/ I n 1 _h_i92ll92III9VESTDCK I 9:.SUBJECT. nu'rI1_a1r_;Qu__qr_L1;__ ,- -.I-;=_..is'r.'r1:or co_1_.o1uu>o_ __

    mronmrrou concnnnms ' __

    -0". -- -

    E Enclosed herewith isthe originalof'a letterfrom,U. S. Senator FLOYD K. HASKELL which was personally handed to

    i' th's daterelating to incidents involvingmutilationofme 1cattle and other livestock in Colorado.

    1_ Senator HASKELL indicatesthat 130suchcaseshavej, beenreported to localofficials. He makesreference to the" fact that such mutilation has occurred during the past two _r ' IIiYears in nine states

    iIn hiscommunication Senator HASKELLrequests thatS ' t the investigations being conducted inorder to__;- the FBI en er' provide unified irection to the overall matter of such __k

    d

    hutilations.

    1' - Iindi ted to Senator HASKELLthat his request would_ _ be furnishedto gs}Headquarters, WashingtonD.C-, andthat h

    rly pertaining te his reeeest= Ialso pointed_I ente

    Q? wouldreceive a -'- out to the Sena or that as he well knew,before the PB can>-= any case, wemus '

    I pointed out that inthis instance I was -

    927a

    ii!Qve investigative jurisdictionprovided prmarily by statut

    it_ -Est awareofany ute whichwouldprovide or_jur1sdic.g this matter. 45; , ;__ 67____*~*1~i j>- Bu Enc. 1!RHurea1 SEP"E - Benver.{l =S2=9}@, - so-new!

    2'.l PR:jb _ .H" p'L /a./75"H! 1; __P-9'92 M~drfv" I'g-p !|'/vre-. .

    -- FB:zu *' o " _- J . __. _ V ~_- - .-. -- -;- ... -__,.- .-_

    ..' I- 92 ..o_ _.' ._I _ 3.._.-... _. -.___ .

    ._ ltpprove-d: ~ -.i_ so Sen!l _ll Per.spxld A9. chug. .e|.awI'$:l' 1llII'IIeIIII=h

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    16/130

    Ki

    -

    _l'

    -

    _92--

    .ataE2_92

    Zn

    -

    .-

    5

    '-

    u

    5

    rTr4

    r.

    ,4-r.92-

    1In

    4.I

    I

    iI

    |t

    .

    1' J

    -v-

    I rf1! . - ,

    L I' -

    .-m 92.

    .-

    1n:_ u .lb - _,.._*' u__'-u--92.--.. . Iik-I .'n...'0- . .I .|r' " Q-..-. _'_ __ . '.',-- --. 'I .,-~~ so ' a .

    . ._ .._ Ar _ __ H92 . --u .'- _.-. -.'

    _. _.. .;..., H . n .-'- . '. ". a .

    -- v

    - -'- . - --_ -.-- -- .-_ _. . -._--, __l

    . 0- '-v 0 II 'I . 0

    - 0 - .- _,1, __.'..',:~.nn s2-0 s- -- ,. _*._ ,'..=~w-n- *..'f' 0' '.- ' ';_-92 92__ . '-

    _.D --C

    092_

    - - 'I _. . -92-_-I I _ I Q.'. .'' -;-Q . ,- -

    contacted UnitedStates;- ,.'.1- _ _ . '

    L- ' On this date I personally _ _Attorney JAMES L.TREECB, District of Colorado, discussed _P;.

    . 5enator's HASKELL'sletterwith him, and he concurred with+fh;my comments to Senator HASKELL.._--.'_f*";;::'@ ;%> ?. U

    i-- 1 o ..U.'In connection with furnishing me this letter}*** "L

    Senator HASKELL, in advance, had released astatement to the;'press indicating that he was asking the FBI to enter the =, .

    investigation. Several inquirieshave been received and I haveindicated to the news media that the Senator : letter wasbeing referred to FBI Headquarters in Washington and thathisrequest would be resolved. Upon being pressed I indicated thatI, personally, knew of no legislation specifically covering themutilation of livestock which would enable the FBI to enter.such an investigation. ' _- - _ evi ~

    " The above is being furnished to the Bureau for '3 -information and for an official reply to Senator HASKELL's"-request. Senator HASKELL indicated that he is returning to _Washington, D.C.in connection with the reconvening of the 'Senate session. '

    _92. . .'B

    :-

    I

    - _.

    u . ,'-', ' - u-- .. .

    ----- -s--.---- -- .- 0 ....-..- ,,_.' 1."--,.,._:._.- _.-._ ..'$

    ,--,u- Q '.~ "_'- 1;:'_"~.

    ' - -

    - _ =- ..~ 92- 0

    --Q .1

    Q. -- _ . ._ -

    '~a '-

    .='2';T*f. ' .g - ."5-nu -

    .. _. -. . - 0a . .'_ 92

    :5II';:--,'6.

    . - - 4' ._I.-' ,_|

    n' I.>1 --'I__""r'-. ,

    . .--u __-uf-' ...-

    1. -- 07': 'I.. .I

    -'- 'Pf,-1' 92'."-I 92

    ' __ .- '_ - I. . _V0 -_ v

    _.- 92 K .' __' - .. .. -; -

    .*_ ,-T 3 3--.__--I-.:'_ .-- ___ _____

    u-?: --l'ac-_; .'-__.... . . - . ,_|-_- - 9-I ~.- ~'-"-at-~'

    " - -:. _ .21 '-u

    , 1__ 4

    _ =,._ - ..I 92 I, 'd -- S90 ' -r I 'In - 1 qI '92

    ' "-"-'$'-&

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    17/130

    ,.

    _-'-

    w

    '-

    "2-a

    nI

    -2--_

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    18/130

    :.

    '_II

    '1J I

    :r '-

    !."-

    I-E

    ._.

    -.

    4

    '92.

    5-":

    ,, .-92

    -4

    Q

    _-.

    I

    5_ 1 ,

    I.

    I Vi. . _

    ._ ':.. _ .. 1 !_' w,U0 __ 'trio

    Page 2 -

    The fact thatallegations have beenmade of the loss of livestockin Zl states under similar circumstances strongly suggests the very _real possibility that the crossing of state lines is involved and, thisalone, I feel, should justify the participation of the FBI in this case.

    Iurge you to begin your investigation as soon as possible, and tocontact my office to discuss in more detail the incidents Ihave describeHe stand ready to give you all possible assistance.

    a *aa""'7i Since:-ly,

    United Sttes SeIn ----"i"

    -vFKI-lzenu H/_,. -

    -..---- 'i"&

    ' .r

    -___nu."

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    19/130

    '-:.'1

    _.92

    .2;

    e

    -.3

    L-S.2

    :_* __8Ul_]B

    1Q?-'1'-.4..

    2_p

    1

    1

    - I

    F

    InI-

    ,.,.

    , . , . -

    NW, _ _ _.

    e 92 aw

    ~_ 1125059-0

    A 92S>*929t _2-S - __'[email protected] Incl1! .. so S g

    ?S a S-. spr'nir1h-1:1"ss* so I SS4 doorsoms' am/ clI /"J J are

    S .. "to -_=-11:

    -,.,_p

    _

    . .'92_5 .. >

    . k . _._ I !_ nu'_,-,._q_,,,5,1- 1, . , ._ .. . ~~'s _ r = 1---.1: l---. #1 '_.

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    20/130

    .5'1

    * .

    0;

    .

    'oA

    I3-.1.

    ,-

    0

    VI

    u

    .92

    o

    0

    .- -an

    ?

    ., w-a-.

    ItQ

    1:.eir:

    . ."

    '0-I

    o-4

    ~'.Ia-_--. a a_

    at-_

    .

    . __

    ".1!

    ' .- ..-----.._6_~.._i._,..___>-s-o 92_.- _ _.

    ' .- ... _,

    '0.

    .

    .0-s

    a -a.

    I

    .'-1'

    u

    w

    '2

    Ed-.*rsttoftsts,tr1re1-meaboutF40 frighteningcattlernutilationsin

    dot tiesin north-centralM hitof outrageinlawentororrnentcircles1

    .- e. _...-.s..-=1.... - . - ~~~:7-. _.

    An.

    .~o_- . j J_ __.'""',. . I;_.._f'.. 'W[115.* _ ._ _.. Q 9 t

    E- __ .'.DUFilNGTHEPASTTHREEYEARS."--NOR: THAN1500 CATTLEt~ 22 states HAVE

    KILLEDANDMUTILATEDIHEIFIatoooDRAI _.~_ANDSELECTEDoncaausREMOVED_ _- .. 8!!i-isuR%|cA|_Pt=:Ec|s|o~.r RAN mom SATANICcutrtsts. - ~ 'SUSPE SG

    TOGOVERNMENTRESEARCHERS.

    o

    2 a II" *1. '_*1. .. i W _ __-_ _ 441-

    AN EXCLUSIVEREPORT BYEDSANDERS_7 V if 7 j j77* becrtzmtltilatedhadbeencausedh;natti-

    ral tactors.Such statementstriggered a

    a en counKansas.roostof themoccurringinthel2 Kansascountiesa ectod,with

    rig U.S. ll. whichrunsttorth manyotlicialsmaintainingtheirbeliefthroughKansasintoNebraska.Nebraslta,thathumanswereinvolved. _ialsohadsomemutilated rnooa.. _g Therewereseveralbitsofevidence

    Kant- tssltcridepartments.thehigh-*thatpointedawayfrompredators.Thereway patrolandthestatebureauoiin- wastheabsenceoibloodandfootprints.4-

    -victirniacdcattle ranchers.Therancherslalargernudhole.butstilltherewerenotracks.Then, therewasapeculiarab-senceof danglingguts and scatteredhunksof esh predatorsdo not readEmilyPost!.Also.thoughmanyanimalsweretoundit secludedareas.otherswere

    vestigstiooseemedbattled.asdidtheltoresarnple.OnecowwssevenfoundittllJ

    as-ereusedtothenocturnaldepredationsof predators.buttheyhadneverseenanythinglikethesurgicalprecisionand5

    theseanimalshad beenchoppedup:

    _ .A- - L _7_,Vif pr

    ballbutalsotheeyelid,rnemtaall,1'_hcrewaslopemore.Muchs'-'-- "*5-'-'-. "'1&."-7 ._" rm: reaaorsna,mnea

    in April I914, thetsttttilatoit againlo Ncbraslta,altlt thfamiliar anoduroprraadi: Blodrainedlo someinstances;therefootprints:andvariousorganswsnovod.QlllilreotlyattrgirallI-eialsagainleanedtowardthepeoyotelcrowlracooo-witory. Ilsetoll 0! Ittatel,as anhullsbeganreferringtotheacta.sthroughoutthesteamer.andbylvemomeSdeaseshadheeathe ornhuslrcrState._ -

    As in Kansas. e rtastorthatlilatiottawere tlta lets OI heoquippeddevil worshipers.or *ritttali$la."beganto spreadangoodlarmersoi Febtaska.S

    sotingvigilaotestooktoridingtroads from dawn to dusk. Raoroetitnesstoppedout-cl -stafor acow-bloodcheck.Sensesonlo a pickupapparentlytriedan aircraftthat waschecking&linenear_GrattdIsland,l92result.the stateNational Guarditschopperstoy atasrtieitnufeet ratherthanat thenarrnallosfeet. Sheri! Herb ThompsonoiKnoxCountyreportedthat.on

    'hel' tserasectsooocaatorls. lcopters_ _when_'snutil.:tionoecurn=dalsocoptetsspottedit-st._.s92thlo labia;thereondutylids, a

    Crick taroier wasshot-ctlrotttthatis-arenoideoti ctttiortnumbIn the hllo|~l9 l4. as-th

    taperedoli it NCbl'Hthetnttl.ilationshowworkeditswa

    '$outhDakotaandotterintoldAgain.copiersandborutggorrnuetfia evidence_andthe asnetlsoriicaidiscriminationwithwhich

    some with their ears"and tongue and.say.-aneyeremoved;otherswithaswishoi tail.theirstddersandapatch otneckfleshcutcleanlyaway:aodnearlyall at therowith the anusand genitalsoeatlyeacised-- -_ -'--'

    11'teremovalof cowtrttlrasandbulldonpscausedspeculationthatweirdoswereinvolved.Suspicionlellupononeor snoreot thefollowing: I! sheirre-

    sleepingfarmersta-indows closertoelv-iliaationthanpredatorsusuallyroam. _r And thentherewerethe helicopters.Helicopterswithotnled ightplsns_weregsightedquiteoftenin thealllietedcoun-ties, aotnetirneshoveringabovecattlepens.Butauthoritieswereootableto

    catchthechoppersor to locatetheirlandingandrefuelingareas.Oneoi the

    foundnearlsarnsorafewtactironschose

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    21/130

    -

    _ ta.1

    1'.

    af-

    a

    F-I

    92._

    ,0

    -3s

    n

    Ia

    I

    ,-

    -'0

    sa

    '5

    _

    0

    i .

    . I

    -"3'5-F

    a _

    2", .92..,_w. -.

    L-btrtaprerrerottrarttf mrere ca

    _-__-~. . -

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    22/130

    . ,-

    -o

    '

    Itaaui .a-a9.,.

    -0

    1 s -. >__

    -a- I

    E .'.

    -00'

    .

    31;-'-

    I P '-

    a

    Eag -a.1

    .

    '_ O--.3 _B -i:

    0a-

    -a

    1.-_.n

    Iv!

    0Q

    ea0

    -

    .u

    Jar

    oi

    .._ ,. ~'_l[_B.. -thattiieniuatationr natal:-appear_-tobe.

    F- -_- '1. F:'7'i r .. .- .92__/1

    a' _all - ' "'.v- 0 _. __ Ila;-go _a . . . a- 0e.- -'., ,_._92b;___' ~a_= _:

    !

    - mt: tturrtartoztm's JtttfHeraid that theeat: member:It yertedubqur humpvii.-.. .

    neat rtep.but hehm! though!they were[rm engrrgrrrgin Sdldnftjive-and hyperbole.g.I_I:~F >~* -_--lg-3-It|I|III|IIIIII I l I txt14_ I_ {Continued Jrorngage $2! was takenlrorn Marion to the Dakota Countyhit.in"I-lastieit. Minnesota,byU. S. Mar-ahah.OnFebruary ldth. agentFiieltingerconducted hitrst irtterr_ogation;tnithhim,as observers,viere lerorne Clark and aformer Army yaratroop =eommaadonamed BradAyers, actitewith theCenterluUFOSttrdica.- -- '

    -9292'hile_elaimingnot to havebeenamember elthe rrtutilationmob hirntelt.iinitsfoa iiieied during the iatea-ie--' _dtat behad beenincorrespondence withgertg naernbeqqtthe mob_ll ottrttl the__

    dhntry.'1'Icaaitlitliit he 556-o llg?ttaIIya_-Iteard aboutthe group{tern otherinmatesQhad retarded his conversations in anotebook crarrtrnedwith prison-cell goa-uip. He then outlinedaaeertario thatahed lightonm_arty puzzling aapectaolthe tnutilatiortt. -.

    . Bankatonasserted thatthe groupusedapvierfui animaltranquilizer called?C ?-an calm the cattle. They next heidamyl nitrite to aft animal : noseto causell-l'heart-torapidIt'..tben withdrew_

    blood via a' |eveterinarian syringe.I92..- a.--n-ea '4aQl.0:nll L-'-tuneupIla; annaaIUGIG GIG III lvvafa anti aruuc wb can can-anwalkedonpieua of cardboard: inanew.they med biotnorehea to melt the tracks"

    around the artintatr. On:reason for eru-anlutma claimed, IIto

    drew-orlt of eatraterreetrra- lanluton stated that at _Le:tve_n92wurth--i

    fig it'-Pe rtitcttti:r{ aroundQ69. hehad r_riettheteartrrer_a=ehapte_rof a,l i. 92QBn_iotor-';'-q~cie- gangand that-this 'bike? 1aI]ted-- - --r'i--ttie tttiiatia-1:. % biker1.0 Q. W GI I ICi

    -''aha deaeribetfbia capcriettecainthe Air

    '

    Force , ta-herebebad driven i general' aroundto inspectvarious missileeiba. In-_

    iIlAl k I l IdB k

    aeribed tvaa a!t-Caucasian; Rwaa ca-tremely anti-blztltand anti-Mealean.ltaadherents, in lacl, could bctailed Salam-aeelta. Aral what was the name oi this

    organization? lrtbit letter!-and IIt-vaaeen someI5 oi them-Banbton refersto ther-turiiaiors aimpiyat re faeeuhi iiFliekinger, however.both lanltatnnandDugan aaltiedatell-known nationalorganization devotedId the Ironhip _ of Satan.. , -Leavenworth Penrteatiary ahw

    "92--~-- i - wheve beee ied l_heea9!law'vbomber.9292lo h.1'aaa92 around.fhia_'aame aaexpe

    todru;aattbe tirne,'be con rmed,_vaa latchedia

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    23/130

    -;'

    _Z

    3.

    a_.-_

    .0

    ._

    I .-

    $-

    Z

    'n

    0

    3

    0

    1

    tr

    I !

    - I.I

    wQ.

    -I

    "

    -"'- ...'-rm:--.;._ Q}- ". .'-_ Dr-_ .-_.-_.. -- -'- _._mt:ItUt1t.A t't0.92ltltY$ l't. .: ..'Te-.rn.rhaditsownprimemrarrlragipects:rtgrgrpcalledglrSSttlatt.InI974,oKilgoreCollegesmdcrtthadts-rittenthatthis3'-Ypperformeddoting.r_ltrr

    .tfoatittttnffromputt93! Investigationhunclear.I havereadonereport,pre-

    t paredbyFlickingeranddatedApril I0,tars,in whichmanyotherreportsantiint-estigstiornarementioned.Fora few

    monthsin 197$,theFederal iosernmentapparentlyilltjestigatetlsatanicorganiza-tionsandactivitiesalloverthecountry.

    The tnotives of the informants also

    rctnaiaa hit unclear.Bantston. for In-uante,appearsto havewantedto ntske

    ,I tlr-tlsothathe couldhetransferred-toa at-rteiail inhishomestateof Missis-tsptiahealsoscentsfront his Iettcrstoin-ewantetito matesomemoneyfronttheyttltltcationofhisstot;y.panDuran

    headol eattle Itt fact, thereare morecattlethan peoplein 'l esas antIit hobviousthata groupof tttonc}-rdmuti-iatorscouldchopawayprettymuchtothetuneol theirownlolly. More than,

    500.000cattlercportotllydieeachyearIn Texasfrom naturalcauses.soa fewhundredntoosttttttilaledbynightstealthwouldnotbesigni cant.

    The Tears rnutesreachedpuhlicot-tentionin NoscntbcrI914 andthenap-pearedto atop. More castesoccurred itearly I915, with parallelsto easesinotherslates.On JanuaryZltth. for ht-stanee,HopkinsCouittysheri PaulILIonesannouncedthat_ahlootl-slurping

    __tS=.ttte;_';iiue qs.tinfoitnant,transitsiii -.3groiiis'cstttr.;tttettoie-taisvtttDisciplesexchangehistestimonyfor a reductiohoIhiss.-ten-yearsentence. ..

    Forreasonsunknown,Federalol-kialsdecidedin the_latespringof I975mt topursuethe investigationfurther.Oneapparentproblemwith theinform-antfstutywastheirallegationsregardingthenationalleaderof thernutcmob.Ac-

    aeuttiingto ianitstonand ugan, this_ Itaa_hatIsen-eda sentenceIn Les92-en-

    'hathona, hank-robberyconviction,'.tIhicls _accurate!andhadrecently

    - atovolto Austin.'Teaasalso accurate!:hunter, uhen 1 _exasreporterJohnhlatcigobtainedthe allegedleader'slt-wl andjail history. it indicatedthat he

    'bl ltceninjailduringmostof thetime'" at the informant~l'eI.~IirhetIhewit roam-

    Egfromstatetostateperforminghema-

    --"-jc-us re-'uonia.._ . ,__ ._-.,:. ':U$arrte,autl1o:itieshclic92 c..llte_Hat92]tstOtt_-1 Iluganallairwas partofamasterescape

    pot predicatedon the assumptionthat_ asmallcountyjail_iseasierto eethan~'ai'tgFederalprison.On my '31.Bank-

    sbodid,in fact,escapefromthejail-inlusts, Minnesota to whichhehatlbeenntnydfront_I-lauingsh.alongwith an-ibr '|irisonerE'whenth'cF"slrctea'|'aiehndcdsishosts:later, Banltstoninsisted== k aha: prisoner.emurderer,Itata-d togo along with thecaper.D.-pa.meanuhile,hadlacenremanded

    - Ijesas.and hltetIartkttotfs

    ebtle,Duganescaped,too:hewascap-, ltd on June I901. duringI holdupIleloplin GlenwoodSprings.Colorado.lankttoalaterassertedthat Duganhadetcapdinfearfor hisIile. .. -

    Despitethedoubteastonthesatanic-iual tleury.theltutilatiortacontinues!toqrt:nt"'atstiiaaa:re=ne"itirequeney_inI915. IhcywereEspeciallycommonInI'eaas,whereIankstonwllohavchis

    fear- lledinningsaswell. - -o'-

    _ acute-nan ssuraa

    Onestaraatasnapoi Tens. withits254eountitacuotainingsomeI I,N0.000

    1hestjshtiuid_"_a'injIic_itittarnottnt'of.nico-

    washeliescdresponsiblefor the muses.In KaufmanCounty,eastof Dallas,mysterioushelicopterswerereportedand

    policeoflicersstarteddirectingthcir'sput-lightsintothenightsky.AndTess au-thoritiestendedto ascribethe mules tothose coyoteswith table rnanncraand

    stomachsbigenoughtoholdeightof rnooblood etrenthough,asin other_sts_t_a;_there.wereInstancesin I'esas_wherepredatorshaduncharacteristicallyts-oidcsl -cattle that had haen tnutilattnl.

    Usually, whenI cow lies dead forIIewdays.theripeningfumesspreadwide-r

    os * "*5. Q1

    l;- andpredatorsquicklyarriveby Iand,--air andburrowfor thefeast.!- --Also,-in JanuaryrthcFort Wurtlt Star's

    Telegrampaidfor tosionlogytcstsloo1'

    I-cite;fauna near drop-'n-a-.-scatandthc_

    tine -inthe.Iis'e|fand-t_hcblood;nicotine'1the trlaterialmostcommonlyusedin_tranquiliaerguns.In hlar;h,_acoypep_ehonorth of -B ns udderPM to' it Sprint:'hadbeenrernos-ed hutcarefully.sothatthe stomachlininghail not beenpunc-

    tures!- Ind_.it=loan-on!trot ttnortl:throughasrnallhplcinitscheat. - .

    There were UFO: repnnol also.InCochranCounty.followingnurnerotntly-htg-objectreportsin cattyhlarch.tworouteswereIoundjna.largcwhi.;stficltl.eachIyits'gina'citcIeottrot-neit.notiona-wheatatsout30 Iect in diameter.ShcritlC. G. Richardscheckedthe circlesandreported nding someradiation residue._ Iy late March I973. Teaasinvestiga-tors had gottenwont or due Federalitvettiptionof themuteItulrinMinne-sota.As scsertiof aaI|aectcu _" '%ltctnhers ineIudingthe _hader--weresupposedlyresidingin Tessa.thelatedeportrnontof ptl-lic safety.aswell aslocalpolio:departments.oonsluctolsur-veillanceopct'ali.atsaIn-Austin aotl.inHurst.Texas,near Fort Worth. '

    Texas,however.had its own prime

    satanicsuspectsInthetnutitatronegroupcalledtheSonsof Satan.Ina IiilgoreCollegeprudenthadwrpaperinwhich hesaidthatthisperformeddawn ritualsin tshich

    were chopped_up.The student&twasdcttroyedbyM9 or moreoteachers,who felt that the materiadisgusting.ourswordotthepaperreI .0. Tinsley.anemployeeof the

    and SouthwesternCattle Ilaiscta A

    alion,'whowasIttvestigatilatiuns;TinslcyIncatetlthestudeiii%icsiamuadTessa,taiizingwitoralofthestudent'ssources._ _?'.l_92'-gtc92smotorcyclegang infornia that also called itstrltthe So

    Satan:In I970, a packof itssnmurderedanOrangeCountytsom

    acoordingtoayoungmanwhohtmolested.dleretiherhart toSaplacingIt in thewoman'sstationIaandsettingthevehicleatire.Theleathe CaliforniaSonsof Satanclaimhelengtoa largersaianicorganthatregt.g1_a_rlysacri cedItturtanyit oercrhonicsItiNorthernandSoCalifornia. l_Z oloradoInvestiglievesthattheSonsofSarahareinvis thentutilationgandthag.tlseUte|rtuti_la'tionaIs'ciatldhsha!-war,fa'tuteseatdtrl Iottndtic inlion, however.ehat.t'IaeCaltfotniInd-ljeitasSonsptSatanacreconnec

    . BctugeenIanaty Q Qptetnlac!M'aIse_igo[.t.IteForr'llfonhIto!-zfele irnaqotca"ig_ries_ themutiIatior.'. Iarticlesei cattractedtheattci-|tion.otntate-t-IorniaotlanIteton,'wht_shegano-c

    _ Iuysterr:% at-at-.a-..-r-..-:."tI-atat-as

    apondenoewith hlaltcig.it whibIepoattal tttofltitoltlchnrpealntlaIsogttr_te_up_withautnt3-tr forrem.outr.s.rTthcterrorthatBatirotspriogand.

    Inasrnaltcirysosahotl-Iottsto

    esantple,feastsDcparuncntof P8aIeryagettt.sel.lIeltieI-ofpolicandannottnoeddtatthe

    plywaspingtoheso-rnriats.In May ower

    JratIr=lIotlltt="I="l=

    weregoing tohernutilatutl.tit:Itothplaceswastotalfear- re.

    hiearttshilc.learningthatthe.F

    InrcttigatiotshadhccncalledotI,_hheg.-anto treat lanisten with onetion WI:-tn Itutlttttttotntstrtanc

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    24/130

    .4

    II~

    -._924

    -p

    '..r.'.'='

    B

    5o-a._,P1

    i

    as92I

    .1 a0

    0

    .-.-_4 'qv9g..ti.in_t_..aurnson.lll'.rttt_tt|;_tttols_ lltIr:?92'.h7"-'tHllcd".'lrIsl:'eirottfoteinem-. n

    I 0

    I92n

    . no.0

    .1''.-.

    - I,-.i..l '5 s

    .-|0

    I I Q 'c

    -

    - Q92

    if-"'- :'I l_l_ii'hIUTll.A l'l0 _r't $'I'l.-Ill?InUtah,0-UnitedS!ahL_Jr'p_o!.dgrrrarrnouncedthatrmanimalhehadautopsiedhadbeenInjectedttitlt_hoelet&

    -- ;_-___r r renders-outin Augustat the llig BendNationalPark In southTeaas,Makeigegntnetedtheparksup-erint.-ndent.Ihowatch -|_.but no gatheringlook place.

    WhenllanltstonpromisedtodeliverI listot mute-mobnames,Maleig waitedpatiently{orseveralsseclt,butno listlrtived. '.' '- ". lankstontheneontpouniledhiscred-lriliry problemsby hintingthatI stock-brol~er Idaughterhehadalreadyngered

    .,_IsImemberol thernute-mobwasabout_ - I9"or!Jometbingpossiblybalefulto

    -_tvt.s=t;,trim; rooktheveiledthreat'icriouslyandgavetheFortWorthpolice

    a

    e=-. - I $< t>'her I975, I want the policeto haveplentyof leads. _"'- Ir '

    -__:_Aroundthistime.CIplainKeithWol-Jerton, I yery diligent investigatorfromth Clteasle County. Montana, sheriff :departrrsent.trlveledto MarionPeniten-tiIry to ve 'BanltstonI polygraph

    _-eurnination;BankstonIailedon impor-tant questions.Halzeigfollowedup bycallingIllcgedmembersoithemutilationItob' including"t heallegedleaderInd

    Irortsan--Ind Iostnd~no'ir92dicItionoi

    '.I

    3he-Wwa r vMid;in.I~1vnIrM_=~_I

    hrdw k t. -' ' .,'.-~In earlyOctobhms. st.s.t; mu.I Icathing Irtielc it tIte'8r:r-Telegram

    ._ , ,.I741 1 L , ,_r_ 7 at._-'y_.peopledist.-rungdeedeorresrerlorblo-Iogirolorexpr'r"i'rrtrrrtuIpurpose:[empha-sisaddedl. The reportalsostated: WeIre oltheopinionthattheItuntanIn-volsementin nmtilationsis I_lad gener-Ited bypublicityandisonlytemporary.A lad!Youknow:llula Hoops,phone-btioth|"J92 til92g,'thetwist,tioltagainsttheIvar. and nbwreeteetornyand teenagerswith tceret dried udder sacshidden intheirclosets.The report'sprophecydid.ln fact,cometrue;themutilarionsvirtu-allyceaseduntilthe[Ill of I975.I-henotutititions occurred it the northwestpartol thestate.. _' _I Therehadbeenrnutilationsonoppnlte

    _ hly'covrtonguehadit Sacramento,t_Ialil&had uIe_dChristmassrotted_a'n_gelonthem

    I clue!For werenotSInd herpol SandyGoodSacramentotightIt thatimminentgore-And weIttlrid in redrobes andIiad theysentthetongutioo I svarnever able to

    Icouldarrangeto rtasegirlslt'theyhadsbadlungedat Presidenandwasinha.. -'About I month Iher

    erft:..t.-.a.-tiiussmritwo1_4.;-'.no.,1...'n.sreadinthcs in otl91$ snit- ThryP_ I" t_ -

    by thetall.animalswerebeingcartedup

    Ill overthestate.ElbertCounty,in pat-Iieular.enperiencedI surnrnerInd tallofterror of the sort that talk-show comedi-

    InsIacribetotheItrectaolNe92vYorkCity.'I'eoplewereafraidtoventuretarabroad in country IvlscrrbelieopterahoveredIt nightand cattleLy "It_it'Iandmutilatedin_thcdatln. . ,',. Despitethe o_'rg'aniaede ortsoI latr-

    'crtIorcetitentotl tciIls_the tnsltilatiortl Qt -.I'rtu:

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    25/130

    =5.

    92-92bl-o

    -_ ""

    ---

    Q

    0

    92-

    n_..

    av

    -, .

    . 92_-Q

    ,-

    -O

    in0 -

    .r4'.|.- '- I92

    '0--wt;-3" i. . ,-=-- -..-

    u$ $?%;'o.0oI:,r.'-IQ. ' _Springs. Naluially.I umaeannin-K mediet for- ying mmuequs n3uug:Ie;tly I

    - .wl

    in '.!-;- ass;an zsvunonoa noun mnm'4t:-tuaol. nu. I looked for an entranceuthe grazing range.envisioning ncross-lnontry elm: titer evilSatin ltknlittt. Iamped theear andzotout tolisten for

    vhirrint 0!.9P l'_P'!=liIlla11*- M ,di{:pfq3Id, om!there .9292'a

    an but tlrivc any-Fad.I Waslxlutt:OIdis-Ippointntentllttlmean, whopallywants loan unlit nieiaospq wrgicai1And the ugly Itel_dlinet:

    " Il NfS l'lOAT0l'n_mt.r.n 1'0Q000 _ "- 1:; .

    .-wewere

    ''__ ,9'lfny '92.!!.:'et:1.2!; @!!sis!!''la rge thirtywhite toiletbeen trawlingatBSmiles

    tocatch lip. hoping toliceme number, butThe trailer, I decided.ge enoughtocarry _n

    and I lad justsuggestedshes-i a -plliee thatwas min; trucksto

    _._QE 9?WIIX IIIP' ' 'V'hie: I Wu q-@115;with theiptor atthe diiniet attorney :'Tmlal. Colonic.

    the thooq thatthe mails-__ at I h:terioIo;ieaI-i_mr-"'|t6it-'1!"islet 'Oi:'utl6

    Ami. or ground-support

    lationinpoh 92n_rouldto'open_li_o;_u-ill:

    - -----v-v awn pyr-

    dau: are

    nil with

    o Ilnqhet -itKim,Ind also: atnod hit one.

    pullin; n-l|lle_lnilen'."'ab. - lfq-pplates:

    J '."'l..!;u1 l- _

    -.

    U

    ;I. .92. jg I-nuuui all

    .180you ln_voanything-

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    26/130

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    27/130

    I

    Q--

    -e

    1 V1

    _.. '-no

    -ur-

    tf;- 1

    i-.

    - :-.-n;m_=|;,-tinptu :-an-gm:

    IIoet,tlIrut:l|erl92ldlterhtt:i92edttpndreoJytolttttehe."=-_ -

    ctr-0e-e--Q.Q- POv-OI0--IownusI: "f92fThecomallttreattott ldti,

    o itiallyhoganit: investigationofotutilatiunsin the summerofIIlseurgingof GovernorRich:Lmm; however.its report--ts-hicltumreieated in Novetnber el92o92I-edthatsomeinvestigationhad beendone asearly6 :April 915.The $5 e- asNeedontome20_J_Incidentsofapparentntitihtion: the eonelttsioawas that 95peentol the mutilationhadbeenretfsedbypredators.._, ..

    Thisprompto_dotrot :-statechorusoimin"andieenRootlocalle92v

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    28/130

    xQQ

    in

    0I.

    >-

    .D

    dot_ . _ _ iV4i*Hi _ iii iii if i. , -'- I -. ',I.9if_. .'' ii" "ii j Wiiv ii"' T. _ T-WI' '

    southwesternhehrastlta.They lust at-, disappearedo theradar.". ''.. ."Did theyland?I aslted.

    ,_- 'Well, laeltsonreplied,"we had I'--_'planeIn theair thatwason thesiteand

    _saw.-thelightsbelow;it wasselearnight,andwhenthelightstalentout,eteryhody

    I- ea

    _ ''uteeante dttwrtto'_ltItltoI50feet,thepiloteouldntseeanything.' '

    - ..-. What wasthere? lasted.- '"'l'heonlythingthatwastherewasaI .'"missilesilo, Jaelisonsaid. --

    . ~. -_ Aha!I t_he~ught -Ilsettltitrsatecover!' UseI revampedmissilesiteasI landing-

    , __supplyz_oneforrnuteeopters!J herehad. _ '.._

    _ . PhoveredshoveI StrategicAirCommand

    _ snissilesitesouthofJlushnell,Nebraska,._ _ ithenhaddisappearedintoColorado.'1 Theonlyproblemtwithmissileinstalla-

    itionsas landingzonesis theirsize.Ae-= -

    . thr.92ttght_thatthey.'dhtltded.Il'ulwheitthe.

    _ +,Q

    af. .

    . .U . .

    .:nf"_U'I.Q~got-Q.

    : I9

    .23$

    0,..._ ..

    a ".1, I .0I ;

    t-''-0 I

    a.. ..I '

    .-0

    _ f . '0I

    O.-

    "'htChareunmanned--areeneiosedwith|hat'hed-ts-if:fenceant!Ire Ipprrtairrtately140'I 4-0 .There ls attttsailshackoneach

    triteandthen.there'a_.theaealed'.ntis92ile.isiloitself.a-liiehis aboutI2 teetin~diatn'e-terwith aboutI toutandI haltzahotsingahuvedieground._.ltwouldheii ieiilt tohidethreehelicoptersinsuettIIsmallspaee,unlesslIhete,tias_aarnesort

    .'~ot'eatttotI|l'l_a;edhunternearby.I wouldt s6'|'tie d'th:afth'e'elEe1I'6'nie'seamI11!iI airiyintensenearI nukesite.but-earl

    :-ll_h_e_,that __Unitt:dStatesnttclartr-__'.'-10*:tw rtit bit-1'kiI=stimean-1that-.gird-.-. "te=r.-1f'.-i=;r-as..'~==1-'- - e.ilatneheot nees atop our missile-silo

    ;_t~at._-linearJrquon.theaite3, Im_tt-et-

    SterlrngInaremoteareaealledhintneyCanyon.'lltere aalwulutelynothingupthere.The lltilttalswere ltttttilatedon Ibigranch.andjustoutof curiosity,theaherilitookI Geigercounteralongandgota readingonbothanimalsaroundthe

    "headandanus-butnoto_n_thetestoftheir.hu.lii.a._"_.Thetehavebeen repur-t_satradioactivityIt I site HWyomingalso. ".

    The thoughtthat radio-ttet-ive-rnutantbacteria,orperhaps;I haeteriaradioac-tive-rnaterialrniekey,arehe-in;slippedtolnirnalseattte_s-themindtogo ll-yi-;yi!

    ll -

    'P I0 - 1 s'-'92-5' I a . I I.0 -'01".'- - '-5'R_ll" $l -*."_"" .! ""_"-5?92'.21.'.-, G,~ .'Er1ahiII."ayri92'afe'.lnts-ttiyuoeii

    ' I973,when anttniderntihedhe-Tie terhad * -it ColoradoSpringswhobeganIncl-htgintothesnutilatiortsinItlayI915,takesthelaaeteriologgieal-researchtheoryveryseriotnty.For I numher"olyears,Briannewasanemployeeof oneat theclandestineinteIliger1|ee_services; was

    s0tion'e rlinEuropesisin a's|:ee_ial-'latin Russianallairss;later.In theearlySixties,he-was_hasedl[orI shorttitne.lnWashington. withtheo leeoiSicretiry-or Defense."Brianne-itsas-

    - curednse'thathehasnoettrrentebnnet:-tionwiththeAg.-ne;y_:in,Iaet.heseerns.D havekittedtheever-groisiomter.

    enemleadhitntosu1ipes_.-tthattherecentmutilation;arereallytheyork fttllte_ 5."_" m*_u""_.,"*ail

    .r_etear_e_t.e_n,.tnt.9t;ria.aiteelait t--in.. % =. F'.'."'bathedthatsecretlrt=teart:h'_'Flh. . _ _ . _

    .- _ .- -'Ot't:ltted'-theu.s. -'-.115'*==t>w-. I1i=

    -_._ltaretsesf _-;-3 J . _haeteriarsa!'s:_"'.|'.:!I'bI=lt'"|".I.

    lstinnaeonslstaolselentistredlit l970_whentheNiac

    haeterinlpgieal-warfareresearcw|l'9=li.l trhW.thestoryapostlesof lerntjivesuhsetainedclandestineundin;Ironern_mettt.:I he|ehasalsoheattpthatI privateeolpt-ratittw

    Iutttltheresearch,perhapslnanof thedaywhenIlheGO92&wotddl:ed_ropped.__,1 =

    Oneot the rim pon ail s.wl_tilsoneesugpnteqtlytargeOn'ent_al_s'. researchany Illlted_i.di=Ile:ent lsur

    _ Qw Q_ -ait 'v ,II : an;'3",.- 0 ''.".:t*,'':".92_.:.'d],_ _.92'.__'_1118'l92lU l1LATliDNhtY..?=IRYCrmitbeIlia;theUnit?!S!at$.Tin.rtelgrrleb;-'_v_i'randthatt;|-eirdotnrefreeJoperformdrorilii-rgrinreneojute-e.i'our_ml:.t&li

    _euqnqq-i~r_sr_tangle;lIl ti|llit.-gatorathatth'e'snecow'seyeposstnsptogtertiessimIueousmembranes0!I particandthattheeow,therefore.lsIsubjeetortwhiehuisertth

    Jtaeteriologiealagent. _ ..ltalt_uItt;dedtb'Ipaddedwal_ofR905" Iill .I~lendr'i:of RTVX

    _I.ll1;s_se'ctry._I tim'dttsirt'|'lSixties,lllltelIIrytUri-.~_unddidportonanantgentsor toxin:the allttllhadheen

    ;;D_ugaay |'|rt:surna&fruitsFortofpatriotic-hut-critiettllortoerern uyaea.ofOotemmentinielilipetteeagencies.af ,

    ---SotneofElhnhe-'I'Go92Of llfl ..rhsit.Io=e!_92t----M

    _ot'thedgeirood._A_tgs-ttheLheaterofsuchreteanem-ashs

    An olhetalIt bugy-"ayhad

    E:tst"h.adbeenIl lhgttlgrs.tits

    P -a 2"-1''"".- - " --IsfhtellethesdaNaval!rt:-spamattest;=i=tlII=?==w~-tti

    ,-~ltttIeent|oont.lts.there'hasheettI,sai_n9rtttediaI,-pp_o92ve_r_allegedSovietti-'iolaliot-taol theUnitedNationsgerm-srarfare hart. lack Andersonwrote Ietslurnnin whichhetieeusedthe Sovietser! etttttinuinfgem warfareresearch

    DefenseRobert] hllehlatnara.At the

    , tirne.I_.taorkedforin-=_sqe;.-.;;-jse'trie_e,-_-_'_:soit's|:retty_a'elt_attl:|stInriatedthat they'

    didh i i f

    pitytn1ee'ted_ran,.Watthelttti-Qriciptttlgermor

    1'.s q . g . I_ Ia I. -.. a I Ia-- -.-_ -.-3;-_'aaatoai-rrvrrrtu-ra'e_tasta- -;-Oiseotthepeopletherettaslseet-etary'et.P"i'l[-_l""92 *=-"&

    92

    '-. --...- .-.-.Clattl ia?Verypeissrbly.Wl tridiaBvereonurstani I|

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    29/130

    5

    Ir1

    F

    .-

    i

    'u

    Q

    J1

    i

    .-1.-'-_-.

    Qa

    i

    O

    -4

    4

    c.

    '2

    __uyinglotiekitolllheirownhcksma'ge:itmnb|h:I.ofll92eoecul|.".. _

    AnotherqniestionB:SinceWar-._ rancher;areamongthemostpalrialii:of_-Americans,whynotusIland them

    .1'cheeksandall them u: uh:CIA mmI eoupieoi ii-.-iicutie-aaaiaa

    city,youknow--andtopleaseleavethe=- gmunlockedandtokeepquietaboutll?;. DowninNan Vim. NewMexico,In:

    _31-mung,Kitty Canunactoperates0'land: ulrh her hmbandin In ire: that

    - Im beenhard-hi:sin: mum andcopier:-.. u92devcaUFOa.Mn.Cemme:kIus

    -.lnveuigaaeithemulesleel localneu-per.In Opil_0fthewelrdgeaandIII -

    ___ dueIlrQIe. -'l!__thia_is_Gjmrnnnentll inimepeopie

    informed.To anythatthereareezper

    _='1|1sif92ed'u-6:116aefminyIl!li

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    30/130

    4-

    92

    u_-"-

    -

    *.~.

    e

    _|la

    .- .. O

    ..U.%-'-I.

    0'.

    ._- -i

    -t'..- iInI _

    - .-'0" '.:'ee'.." .. '4.. "aI .." '- . - L, !'- -1-1-5, ....._I-g 3 , - . . --ye o . . . -, _ ._ -; -92--. _-,,-- J-.v,-{ . 0 -t. '_'92_.- D -.v_,-;QI"{:.'mt=:'Mt.'Ttut't't0NMY t_-tttYInIdaho}o manti-ordrlulnghisjeepatabout$30tuttihe

    1'It! It tr Jtried to ito his cor"claims,15tttttsl'ed_Pt.'01f_rstoodacrossthehiglm-o!wtoce rt;on_ _ _p.pFmere[cw footprietu.Noonema taught.

    TheremaI particularlyInterestingcan to itpueiteGout-try,itrizona,92vitctelnutiteted eairnelt were found to have

    I.

    ..-4'

    0

    - ono_w

    '5

    IrvI

    ''Ia

    tttyatetiottaeoftball-tiredburtta.Iealletlahctil!Artlee andaskedhimaboutthisreport."'_I heretterethreeJ the.-.1thatitati the burn. on the insideoi therightltind_qu.ttter,abouthalfwayuptheham.he said.Tho livestockinvestigatorot-IofPhoenixwrotea_lettertothelocal newpaperhere.Leetqldloe. ant!raid th-Itne-se'i- eiii foI i{t_ii6i-t"i% iiii|'estee-ta.

    IattaoeredltimartdlvatatveryniccIUI-ltaiit.'52.......;aII.-'-::.:::,'?""!t":'orenotpredator-ravagedcarcasses.;-.lrt Montana.-the mutilation: beganer-ea-.dlow 3925.:::"-by "..!eee.-ttl.~er,

    number of eereataet found ureaelotethe

    ._to_IN. They werede nitelyburnatt- t!-r-92 l.-.a'eoqtit_in|to-CabtainW lge dnzof CascadeCounty.Wolverwtthasetud-

    _h_dthe trtutitatiour nationwide {ll

    ,'-_-'-tionedeirlicr,he vvetttto}-larionFederalYet-titent.i:i'yto givc'a- polygraph,ekant-'_ZI'ith~tbehappening; ownI118.itItatiort to A. KennethBpnltstott!,andhetoldrneeboutemutilotiort ease that

    _be|:'unod"I_eaily I975, in ohic-h the.'animal had beenmutilatedwith art in-

    Iftlaertt that eiutet a no-toothed out.

    ._-Jflerhatm r iypinkitteglgeap._92_jqlvet-togelaoludaeaeirtyolvinibtirnr."92VEbaveooetabreporttttarcameioooa

    we ::_.":r-:..':=12-..- ___i|ttt_92ve-get_t_he'ee:l3itis:baetend !!-----T.-'uu-M.-e~~==~=r.u=.1:~u-the_ - t. .---- ~.-.. .. . . .

    lefrtttetlartdbt|t'tted."' _ .'.'--2 eaeaaoae -',,92r'e_tottatIy,_" ~'--:-*t'92"11teEmabegao'-atNewlleeiegat~_-= = ;4tt.;=_-$2.14!e'str.gt! urtti!arot1,r_td'!'lt.-1.n.l:t_g tv-

    . 0n

    H3; the'darted upagainittglrly I976.In October end Novet-nber. there eere

    .= '5"etutilatiotiainttemtu.-u Ittiuouri.thetauhear! Oetoberandoon--_ tesbegart y

    'tittuediooeveraleotmtieaiotobeoernber

    -. 3

    cI

    00 o

    o':I0

    .1I

    I975.Therewereabourtettease;re-portedit_tHarocy'County.,Oregon,atthe

    ':'t" '-ertd-oI'_tti'euioutterh,-intl;e'regionthat-ltordertNevadaiothe toutttti-'ctl.ernpartol'thelate.There were I outttber oi

    ar:utetiaW'ueo|uioioOctobert91$.otteolwhich iavolvedanimatebelongingtoliebattl Ioottt. If Eettrnan. loomOlti-ttk|II|at teQttle...ItetekilIederit!92

    $aa|reoade._aepomdoqqctottert1tt_t.. _ 'ln92Vyotniog.begint-tinglo September.Iteteiraetttathdiotettieotbclieoptera,

    .'lJFOeandabtolroutilatal cattle;there incidentitwettort County-o_o__Oetoberith,erberenl$0-pttrtdllere~

    I92I. - .I' ..Q.l u '

    "loedoowereaearvedupartdetteteaitrtideitsHt-tearlanke rentleltavetl

    I

    I '" "9ThelliltvoukerIolrli:

    pmperUFO oppc:trar|ee,-there_er:aobunchot ':tnpt_et'iottl!ellovr__em-loreabout two tout all tttameter. mat were

    located Irortt ten to I00 yards Itottt lherttulelite._ '

    In Idaho that Se|itetttl>ct',a lorri-servicef"92 92!92!t92}'el't92otlt'.'t|acveralperantttin 5000:* '-dbiaeizratesv-eitiagdowno'- cCreekin BlaineCounty; the neatday,aeveraldead cattlewerefound,but thehoodedhiltcre detpite In Interttive,acarch--g-erenever{outu flea. inat-there :4-et-.=er. %'.-er9:!-.e etc:-.waadriving-hisjeepelortgU.S- 95 at_t-'~_-*'3_fOem.vvltem lte elailllt. 18trtetted peopleottltttlheroesthe ttt|,rt92-my

    urithjocledarmaandtriedtottopltiaeer;!!~emet!getetlrey.butliteegir!9!Iefrotdid ant. The Terort Voffey Netti.

    o!Brigg;Idaho.forto.whit "tit wmiet nt = mt3=-emhtt.|e=ct'eeeitre'jIoti'k'rtoyour childrenareet night ond_espwia_lly-Halloweennight. On Hullugleert-ttidtl.

    oistitdbeodviubleto It-"Nethe'yo't_toiei"-ehildrettbornebeforedarkandtheolder,ooeahomeimmediatelygfter_th:Iootbttll

    famescheduledorithatn'tg.ht."=.-'- Ida-ltou-altqrd-hit.'lh:tIltletiet'e

    Iralltedalonfa lcooefor lboutttile to the road.grllcreprertnnav-areiiclted iii. he? |-om .eaearcltedtheentirearea._buttol urthereluee- -= '"-?-

    Itvvatstrictlyby thatilhappenedto.bein thevietttitythel -- -l'l.an-anonFl l lnbamcll Qral. IIIUIIIIUIII II 1.0"--I

    drove by end aeoogniaed_nyl~Iedeliuetoldtt92e.I_-tevvewhere theheilerIey led perfoleld autopsy;he tlteoptepltttl ae! M. !._-dirt; Eeealteri ; ReadingtheHedeliuarepnd: thatthe uual thingsba

    -0-:00 :-1.:-I.

    Irererrtittirmtltettterutehttdbecn

    etrttartdeulyingontltegrounthethree-month-oldfetus.which hremoved;the tipof the heifc-t&elaoremoved.Iutt attaverageatti

    ---tt tut auuio-r'

    tbebacteriaIretemjoctedintothtJo oneofaeventotboeqttenteo

    utediealolftcerforu-e'u.s'.Degtattitnertt I-ledeliua.reuteaBi

    Iledeliu;ia-oneofa_:I'ottpol abouttsoht;-hit trained irttltvttlttolt who acneI

    o

    u

    leeoitteforeigt-ertirttaldiaeaaeaoutoi the

    Uttitod'States.I-ledeliu'mama ease hvolved I pregrtatttheiferthattrrat dia-ooteredittat bclore ember

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    31/130

    7e.

    1-

    -,.

    =

    ;.u--

    -_,..

    I.in:a-'0

    92

    - t

    ' 0Q

    ,, .

    0-

    0

    1|

    ct

    I -aee

    _.l.QQ-I

    ; Q-.... no8

    onoI '

    , ,._oI;,_-gs

    ,-- " "'92t.1 we

    ._o

    ..

    0'-. O10 .

    -In-.o in

    .1 Q . but_s;_ith_thiseni_nul.the rstthingthat

    ..It

    e

    .'0

    .-'amlilptorsmaylqvettterilieedtinntrttcnl" I '_"iJeEi:_l ;ii|nih'uniio'blc_talqtn='isw

    ea!-gesin-else-pact or rttotcgtthein-t

    . 92-.

    .1 .." .';'>c~i-It *2-l'~ ~':"W=.~&kindsol thingsthatlttani- tlerercarcltcrtmightt._-tke,inorderto thespreadoichcrnicolorbiologicalagents._- _

    stow to sates: tt-te case

    Whoeverbreaksthiscaseoouldeollet:

    moot QQQJQQI-"1Il t"t_lE ,tOI]|e~Q pi_'ogi.matetotalot rewardsnowbeingotlere-lby various,s_tote-cattleusociations,gov-,ernors.stettspapers.etc. P_n'92'atr.inveati-~-'gitor'Eriartneno-|pt'e-tenteda-tut

    tornelobeagnodapproaehtocraIsiscase.his-cJonlltislongettperiettceinIII intelligencehi-Id:Anal!: the nsuitivht't'attist.-L.-t'.'lcloetits-Gtetl..'l_ titers rtoIuat '92ertt.ttlett-ttt.aL92al'diethey y. _9 Jlntgr 7"?-

    ~v-lsy.~'-hetrtInqGl'crurute.thJwuk--tors _sy't-tentoI__Ilthlhld cover-uporal

    n u I U I

    .s=='rth-.3.thi= a_'= :tiioIi_5c'iay,theU-1over irghts,TM U-I. ightscouldhavebeenttncovered,'byittvtst_ipmg'hx I M." } mH. P Ihrwtrh. '_qr __dvilian-ba_sed;uppJ|y_-ont.l-lopsucalcons-

    _panies:etenrequisitionor ordertoms_lteldclogigto thr:natureolthecntebpriaeiigolt-ed.In thesttutilation58.ri:trutepottstsoot.orteeouldchecktteli-mgtteqltaeldeiivery'_ andrepairsorderedtor supplyvehic ; oneootlldlook[ortlttltattilsuns.pttrh.-upwithFed-~

    qal stairaliicsl.tt4tich,t'.ttay-appearto -ltavebrokendownbtytl92esideolthee6ad.''It turnsout thatthemy tltalIyine,

    aeniecstransporthelicopters--Ioroil--544 st-orb.lorcsantple istocarrythettt

    e Io

    witha slightbaciqgroundtnlawtttentor intelligencelsgoingttodolt.lIhedo>.reat:hag-IWI. thecttlprifeboctpgtrU becoveredIt let!aspossib

    sterile:-;e:n:*t;!PIil"taupe _t=.. qt meritittis'dt_"&lsttenrionedtoErianne.nIhod

    otherinst.-stigit_tors,,theobt-in'99 ?!F I5"!-i_lf*'ttrecfableacienttllcotaacur

    nut. they'reout;gtick;tit~lthe it! donto

    echelonofhL.

    :al'9e'Itcise tendsD

    you on tcl't|:l92tt_;o:st.l._ _ __- .-.Eri+="=;Pit92tt'ottt1*-=tit-smartQlftl92e"_T,"

    tendresiarchersIntheArtrt yt or1'rs"ate_Quotedit placintci;.ht.'||pthereh=tis_l.c.ap.9

    knows? thewhi

    Bnot the work totsloppyouiowcry bums.malt!ill l92patriotserasedtrtotttoverNi

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    32/130

    rnl |- 9--_ |_-___ _-s-_-_-9_ _ -1

    I ! 10 " lnwitlylltl ll--0!

    Illl r

    an

    : 'm l-N1 -P"_L.u_',r" Fr_..W nu.u-' m~.'am'nu.'mumlomu

    I./-Md

    '-:-=- -'=:=%a---'6_ lhulr an all I'llhip

    haul

    -.....--'~'--,,......:IceDmulmantnuI'llIce In Alba-92

    ' ma Involved Inbeen, .. lgallon ol thancnthubaail mauovqral

    ......"~ ~-iuucu 'wed

    MugsTcarilll

    marina; ya Int at hullsLahlrlarluwhlchhandlol -g

    ~4-

    sn "'. Ei &=r'Q-Q.~--.. -

    -, -1.92'92' -I .

    '-!~-'@='=;~':.~s~.-=~'~1 "*-'~'

    Iv.-""92'-1'05"";lnvolvdhl:

    pndllori

    will

    0 llnl

    ml:marIIII Ill the

    rodnlor can

    hill!

    -Dr. lhnr llonlollh. Ill |n|l= 92J w 1

    a no

    crullovcrnmcntprojonaa,ro-vou __lllgl Indian! an notor-rllllll by thi Inulllhllonu.theyburythocarculu lmundlllmly and an uluclant to dhcullwhat hlnptnnd. Evan lholrdlll

    llllllill

    -.__1:;__3____

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    33/130

    . landarea in lhqUultnd lama

    XIHII

    IF!

    &1I'anu.g,;uhnou|un,,*--unahlolonllwill'%%_."&". -5.'."". 5'1"

    "To lulu Ni

    13$-tlol

    P.'.'='annals vl-''-'6u'::.{|92ulrIt-h:ho_-" vnrvalhu

    '1'Any when we ?! had u.. mmluuon um have also had

    .,._---_ .,- - nu. -|92,|l|

    1,-u|.m_nm: nmllnunsquaremil: aw; aL:u!c!92_ing '! un:!v_u.ue1.9mutilation: begunaround I010.The LI

    '3

    v

    UHii|-III".

    """ -Wbltlli Illa!_ Ill cll lllll InunodhlI-

    uly and an nluount92odheu_

    m agma amxamsDr llonloltll. UM Ital been

    lnvallgallng the attach sincethe beilm llid lndlnnl haveml him ol actually eeing

    lplwllhllllHandandunlpadf. UFO sightings." manned Gabe,. ,.J || ||. anvuivrun N I.

    mm .

    ms-$1:

    I_'

    --O Al- I-nu-0.1'

    * -

    u92rl.rIll]nan lhnI79 II ?

    IIdonllurlwlllnl

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    34/130

    5, _11*?"

    -ii

    FEDERALBUREAUOF INVESTIGATION

    ENCLOSURE COVER SHEET

    #0//7744/susxncnjj647145War/~97-/0,0S_

    EILE: /foaf-//cc?

    SECTION,/ OF /

    THISSECTIONIS COMPRISEDOF PAGESWHICHWEREREVIEWED FOR THIS RELEASE.

    g PAGESAREAVAILABLEFROMTHISSECTIONFOR RELEASE .

    THIS IS ENCLOSURE OF ENCLOSURE S!

    .,.

    NO DUPLICATIONFOR THIS PAG

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    35/130

    . i,, -

    1 I_'_

    i.

    ..-

    _rI92'-v- :1"'1"!

    ._-we-.-4,--..=':~ i

    _'>_ I

    5-23;-_..._ ;

    :r--fa -_1-|-,--,

    51$-II-"'=*-"-.-12%g3%=

    ---9-_--'; .-4.5":7. II :4=. -..__.|

    .-5'1 ?

    !-

    Z:'- 92-,'

    n - Pi '-.i- ;.

    ~"-e;--;'1_ '_ 11I

    - . - i!~-= -,". __._b :9 -_JY'; __

    J

    Airtel

    -

    n

    3/12/7 9

    -To: 3 - Albuquerque_E? 3 D 1 - J. E. Sm

    From: Drector, FBIii!??? ?v;L ,w.1 ex? ' 'CL Iggy orU,-._.-... .-_-"I7

    it 92~OO:; Albuquerque? H ' M" ' '

    A/LRe Bureau eirtel to Albuquerque, 3/6/79.

    .Enclosed for the Albuquerque Division is a'paccontaining numerous documents from the Department of Justiceconcerning captioned matter. It isforwarded for theinformation of the Albuquerque Division. '

    Enclosure -

    s,~.,4a

    _= ="_._._=,|3.if?

    5 - EC-5.9..

    '5 / n I15-ll //?zgun-

    Anoc.Dir._.__i .:r,_.__., _-_. . -D'8-';'i2;t'"11.5 '

    ' me, B mo F.- o mm 1:; 1919I

    C111. hr.i.._ n inn!!! KGHm. i___ O '-' llhll.i.._

    Lebellhq i,._ vjLegal Con._......._ ~Flu.I lnsp. ...__Ru. Hglli...i ,. 'Tool. Sana....i

    .T;'."1I|.T|t '= F 1R"1979

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    36/130

    I

    ii

    I

    0I

    -.#39;-5. u,

    OFFICEOF

    Tn: A1"rc:=.ss1G: e;=u._

    _ ._ . ,_._....__-._.wL~-,_,.._._;... . .. ...._

    _.---....1'.:-. . ._._. I- .'--.1'.'-!-"-' =";_--_-._-'''..:.-.. ----,_.. .. _ - V -.. _ ,-"-,"92-Q1".-.-. __..-'.-__~.--._- _-'7 .1"'9.- - I92_.-Em-__,;'i.".==

    _ .__,__,_.____._."JR"f~t.';,:_-92r_:-sf>T. V&,1 Q

    Y

    L52.I I

    I~ i%.+w/==w

    %

    " 5%2; . I 7- _ @.:i*%.::/2

    .1

    E

    I!

    Q

    .31

    L

    , A

    J Llitgj} ii! /..0

    J!-.353-";&.-in ' -a3""- -n. 3/'3/ I3'-fa -f

    1'

    Jif 92 H

    iw.&4

    _

    _. _..-2~

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    37/130

    -I I

    3

    - S9!-

    .; ...- -5%

    ii - -:5

    '1.-"_,_- -91;

    Q12?-L; '

    *2"?t _1'? -1'ten !!!

    I-Z7--'.--,

    .J_-_.1~

    -:_.

    -;;_-. .-J

    .;-,- .11Q'_.';'l

    '-'; -;'- :1-3-'*-_-'.'-T51--J-._-.

    '-5 -_"_r.:"'i

    1'-.'J,'.

    s

    -A

    .P

    . .1 _L!

    January 10, 1979

    Honorable Harrison E6 sohmitt

    United S tates Senate

    1251 DSOB J M WI H.-HM".l ;

    Washington, D.C. 2q0lO ''92

    Dear Senator Schmitt:

    As I told you over the telephone yesterday, Ihave asked Philip Heymann, head ofto look into our jurisdiction over

    the Criminal Division,the cattle mutilation

    problem with which you are concerned. We will be intouch with you at an early date.

    Twnglnh I111!I'!-| 'Q-J. ;_ Q= 5- 3;;-I 92_5; ,;92,, ,,.92"J.-92-92 92-92.-5J-we-go

    existence of one of the strangest phenomenon: _

    warn regards.

    c::n1+- 1::-92 ."1 "l ','.92....92........-...-.-_.-...... _.._...

    Sincerely,

    Griffin B. Bell

    :63 -'#-" '

    bcc: w/materials to Terry Adamson_A/ ay Calamaro

    Phil Hevmenn Please have someone look int

    YSen,M$ch@itt is our freind

    I

    this matter at an early da

    there have.been about 60

    mutilations in New Mexico_____._L .._.l__L1__ Pkc-Innrecent montns. g_a g$?un

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    38/130

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    39/130

    10

    i

    11.

    :____._.,.

    -e

    -,_-;._.,1-IQ1-...-.92r

    _.,-

    ',1..._,;--'

    __-

    .%%.

    NEW'.uEx|cosrncrsPOLICEDEPARTHEHTmi-- --ii-_

    INTER-DEPARTMENTALCORRESPONDENCE

    I.

    SUBJECT

    FRDM

    TD_ 1 -

    J-

    I

    I

    -

    :' 1: +_ " r ~ 7 r~ r o .__ . _ _-- I

    'CORRE'SPONDENCE- SJ;-INATORSCHMITT_.- . viwJ'LIVESTOCK I-1U'1 ILATIONS! 'D

    MARTIN E.VIGIL, DIRECTOR'

    CAPTAIN _CHARL_I'f .P. ANAYA. *T"5"T " orNewMexico State Police .MAJOR M. S: cunvetEspanola,NewMexico-P _ 00.Dear Captain: '' i?

    of correspondencefromthe HonorablState Senator, and Mr. Manuel S. Gomregarding livestock mutilations in-for the past two years.

    we are in receiptHarrison Schmitt,Dulce, New Mexico

    Rio Arriba County

    Kindlyinstruct Officer GabeValdezto submitcopies ofall his reports concerningthis mattertothis office;in order that wemay'forwardthemto SenatorSchmittoffice. '

    Very truly yours,_

    MARTINE. VIGIL, DIRECTOR

    W. J.. LI.-OCK,CHIEF "Unifo ed Bureau

    State Police Division .CriminalJustice Department ,

    = File]. __ ',' _The Honorable Harrison Schmitt, State Senator

    MEV/WJB/cl -' '

    ATTACHMENTS:

    I ., .'.

    ,0 I --

    mcrosumaronLETTERDAT!-_DAususrIa,".1976,ToI- IR.wmusr.-s'.lcowgz

    -ri

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    40/130

    1r_,f:i'-'.:~ ._1' ,~ .- _ "-_ _--l.--4.-1 '= -.1 _-'.- '__- _-< - 1-. w -,_,__-- .-

    J55

    ,ix

    *1

    ?i>92

    L

    I

    vJ

    192

    ,:..4-!

    4

    J.

    -i_|>

    i1_|

    1r

    Elnitsb SwansI rpartmrut of f ustice92'lPjASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL

    9 i.zc:s:.:cnv: AFFAERS

    ' January 3, 1978 -

    TO: Criminal Division

    On December 29, 1978, John Ryan,Schmitt s administrative assistant,oa11n OLA racar inc +hp q+a+ns 0F_ - .-_ -_----._-as----_--3 ---- _-----_ -_

    this matter. OLA only received this

    correspondence yesterday but we havelearned that the Senator has personallydiscussed this matter with the AttorneyGeneral. The AG agreed to have someonein the Criminal Division look into this

    matter to determine whether or not '

    there isany statutory basisforfederal intervention.

    I

    V .r" ' 7* I '

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    41/130

    __ ____ _ 1u.-;-:- -. -

    "'-?.- = '-" """''-1.us.n - .- . |-r -tr.-1 -5_. . . F-_ nl-oer. .

    ; is -r-"" _...- _ l-0-0"-.-

    go

    _H _- 7 -~:'

    .: ._entlm rr ; i- ~ _ :_ 1- e eegs -.-1'-.-,.4

    _g 'I ._Q I I 2-'-veg"_ 'fa_

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    42/130

    0

    l

    and with the tip of its nose, itstongue. left ear, udder and vagina allremoved with a knife. And on andon, from Texas to Colorado to Mon-tana. Behind them the mutilators al-a-ays leavecounty sheriffs and.!!et-erinarians saying they have neverseen anything like it before, and localauthorities on black ritual discours-

    ing on the importance of alwaysusing fresh warm blood, if drinkingthe stuff is called for.

    A survey of newsclips and otherliterature on cattle mutilation seems

    to indicate that the whole business

    started with the mysterious death ofSnippy. Snippy wm shorse whosemutilated body was found on aranchnear --Alamosa, Colorado, eight yearsago. Snippy s throat had been cut andesh from the head and neck re-

    moved. Also removed were Snippy sbrain and stomach. Snippy s ownerwas convinced that his horse had

    been "zapped by a flying saucer."Snippy s bones may still be viewed inthe museum at Adams State College

    in Alamusa.

    U.F.0.'s arestill being blamed forthe cattle mutilations. Some students

    of the craze simply see no otherex-

    planation. Carl Whiteside, of theColorado Bureau of Investigation,evidently felt itnecessary to contestthis hypothesis, since he told me seri-ously, We do not feel these peoplehave any magical quality that putsthem in the realm of the supernaturalor some alien planet civilization.

    The occupants of U.F.O.'shave not

    so far appeared to refute slanderousallegations abouttheir attitudetoward terrestrial livestock. Peopleassociated with occult groups, on theother hand, have been vehementlytrying to distance themselves fromthe unknown slicers. Backat the

    start of the year, after twenty-threemutilations in Texas, aself-professedwitch in Dallas told a localreportershe thought they were the work ofa satanist group from Fort Worth."

    These Texas cattle had been drained

    of their blood, which the witchthought was consonant with satanic

    addiction to blood. They give.witch-craft abad name, she added.

    A writer in Gnostico. was even

    more alarmed. "Despite the obviousiiloglcality of it, said Isaac Bone-wits, aformer member of the Church

    of Satan, "the favorite theory right,now among state and federal investi-gators is that occultists of some sortare involved. This of course is sheer

    scapegoating, since only arank ama-teur would believe it possible to getusable psychic energy out ofsuchmutilations, and arank amateurwould not be able to a! levitate so"

    -I"R linen ha'n.Jon-inf; np ,1;- Hy

    JII .

    .. . - pML ! ' __

    without leaving evidence of apump-ing machine, c! make the neat sur-gical incisions that were used to re-move organs and extremities, or d!teleport so as to be able to performtwo such operations on the samenight, hundreds of miles apart."

    It wouldbe interesting to knowwhat Bonewits would consider the

    talents of aprofessional; but he wasright in thinking thatat one pointfederal and state investigators didthink that occultists were involved.

    For a time.indeed, they thought asolution to the great mutilation wavewas at hand.

    Early in 1'.!'i4,estudent at KilgoreJunior College in Texas wrote apaper on 'fTheSonsof Satan," whichcontained detailed descriptions ofhow this group would mutilate cattlebetween midnight and sunrise. Theritual would be completed just assunlight started to lter down on theanimal through the branches of atree. In the absence of trees, theadept: would hold abranch over thebeast and proceed as usual with thissubstitute.! '

    The teacherat KilgoreJunior Col- -legewas sufliciently revolted by thetheme's detailstodestroy it forth-with. The student said he had heardthe story from afriend familiar with

    the satanlsts. An English professorfrom Pennsylvania told John lllalzeigof the Fort Wort].-. Star-Telegram

    that he was familiar with the Sons

    of Satan group. had some of its morn-bers in his class, and had seen somegirls who'dcut o 'their ngers andpieces of their ears and things likethat." Their primary thrill, headded, was to eat their own flesh.

    All this information was passed onto Don Flickinger, an Alcohol, To-bacco and Firearms agent in Minne-apolis. Early this year Flickinger be-came the main federal investigatorof the mutilation phenomenon, forsomewhat bizarre reasons. Cattle

    . _

    mutilation is not, as aspokesmthe Justice Department stifflyformed me. afederal offense. inger became involved because

    prisoners infederal institutions sdenly wrote to various authoannouncing that not only didknow the satanic cult practicinmutilations, but that this same

    had compiled a"death list" of tended assassination victims. Amthe alleged targets were Senatobert Humphrey and a federal jip Minneapolis. '~_.

    The U.S. attorney in MinneaRobert Renner, put A.T.F. s inger on the case because, ashit to me, "We thought it was the

    agency freewheeling enough reado something." The informants tinned to pour out their storiessmall city near the Gulf Coast w

    haveits water deliberately poistwo people in another Texas twould suffer dismemberrnent in

    near future.Just enoughof thformants' storieschecked out to

    Elickinger and investigators in eral states to continue the hunt

    the allegedly .four-hundred-stroband of rich cattle-mutilating sists. Reputed leaders of the grouTegcas were polygraphed. All sursuch examinations. One of the cl

    was that the group was escalfrom animal to human mutilat

    and police earnestly scanned allof ritualistic murders that occu

    Fliclcinger himself was threateand his door claubed with blood.

    Sometime in the summer of

    year the federal investigation to an abrupt end. All that apeinthe Justice Department assowith the case would tell mewas,

    were looking into alleged threaelected ofticials from the same

    of people involved in cattle mutions and we were unable to cowith anything atall. This wasparticularly illuminating, but

    _moor PRICE

    Oscar Pricedied withohunk of steakin his rhroot,dining among friends at Top of 21,orestaurant '-,for people on top of it off. His friend: thought '

    him Ialighing,then mildlymi ed, red-faced -or his wife, whosoiled herpotato andmissed hisgoing.

    I.0

    Where shelives new on top of ohill!,she wondersabout choking.This ison dayswhen rocksshift placeand daisiesare spinelesswith west wind or their bucks. She watchesbirds,

    how ycarcherstake loadand orelgone.-It is frightening: all this shifting andbending

    and ying. The thing obou: choking, too.

    She mirsrs Oscar, she Mys.

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    43/130

    ll

    J

    i

    -924-s

    I .

    -s

    ;

    l

    l

    l

    "92

    liialceig at the Fort Worth Stor-ToIe-gro-in hadalso beenreceiving lettersfrom two of the informants--comvicted armed robbers in the Marionfederal prison and was able to con-cludethat the -federal investigatorshad. become convinced that the in-formants wereputting out alot ofbogus information in an attempt to

    get moved to prisons from which itwould beeasier for them to escape.This view was strengthened by thefact that all three informants had in-

    deed made escape attempts.Thus ended federal involvement in

    the investigation of cattle mutila-tions and thus also ended the last

    convincing series oileads anyone hasyet come up with. ', _What are weleft with?-In thehun- -dreds of cases ofcattle mutilations,no one has ever been seen at or nearthe scene of thecrime. Notrace of

    the perpetrators -footprints, car

    tracks or even evidence of the use ofhelicopters -has ever been detected.Manyranchers believe that heli-copters have been used, partly be-cause alarge number or sightings oi"unidenti ed helicopters have been re-ported, partly because it seemsthisis the only form of transport allow-ing easy access to remote rangeland.Some investigators believe that suchfurtive use of helicopters would ex-

    ;-3 : ..p-----.-_-_.- -..-- ... ----....*__ * %

    "The Sporlables are seven brand-new black and while television sels lromRCA-featuring twomodels withbattery packsbuill righl into lheirbases. Pullthe

    _olug oneilher ACIDCmodel and you'llslill gel up to four hour'sof grealviewing. _7

    An advancedVHF tunerhelps keepthe pictureclear almostevery-.-.-here itgoes."3 _See theentire HCAline. includingthe smart.new. indoor"Sponables" AConly! Sghd St3te']'

    plain the large number of U.F.0.sightings in the affected states. .-

    Cynics say that small predatorsare responsible for many of the al-leged mutilations. This may some-times be the case, but Carl White-sirle, the Colorado Bureau of Investi-gation ollicer, told me that out of allthe dead animals sent to the veteri-

    nary school at Colorado State Uni-versity six werefresh enough to beamenable to autopsy. One had beenthe victim of apredator, ve hadde nitely beenmutilated by humans.In all cases, he added, the animalshad died ofnatural causes and the

    mutilations had occurred post-mor- whicnhe said produced curiousquestions: Are the cattle beingkilledand mutilated bythe same peo-ple, or do the mutilators oome uponthem and do the cutting?"

    Out of all the investigations onlyone clue has emerged. In the late

    summer aColorado rancher found ablueplastic valise on his land.In itwere a cow'stongue, an ear and nscalpel.

    The day I spoke wiih. Whiteside hehad just returned from ameeting ofthreehundred ranchers in Kiowa,Elbert County. Elbert County suf-fered sixty-three cases ofmutilationover the summer. Whitesirle said the

    ranchers were literally up in

    with thesame greatpicture andsound. Nowshowing atyour RCADealer. _

    '" Gate-IO""*,;vnr -as .-" " ,.

    /' R.-- '2 -'.g _ -'_ __ '.__-y- e 1 = ''i . 'I Y'"-- - -- :2'. 'bu ~"

    ...___,._____ '.,_. ____._____ hIIIl !Vp|||92o||.. -_ . i-.I.l,- , --.. . ~."_-. --i--_;_ -.,_.vn- _ 92.-; 5 __

    *-1-

    -_ H' "."1- -'-.

    1 _

    -_ L.

    .55. -

    0-,

    ... 92-

    srms.... The thinand frightening to body can get onto actually cut up an notrace. What we&afra

    weare going to h01-Ir hands. Aperson wanders onto aranc

    thing you knowthese

    spooked become inder."

    So be careful about

    time youdrive arostates. Ed Sanders,an, told me that ondriving around mwas seeing trucks trto orthodox slaugsteak for alifetime

    titted over the fate

    Whose organs haveunknown cow moleironic tension betwtistics versus humd

    roads. As I said aquestion of viewpowhatyou care to s- And how to so

    51.-nwnavnw MI

    _. _ . .-Y J _.; -- . I.*;-.. L - ,.;.- -__-__,__ __~: _. -7:; v 4;__. -i-_--. _,_;; _'_.L -... ._- terry?!. 1*.-.15-"-=.-

    .-if ' -= ---r--T-1.45 ---t. -' .~; "' - -.. -' ""~=_" -- -47 It ., -1._ll in: 3'if - _- -{Ii/ii:. ..

    -=-*;~ .~~~- .-r- -' '"='T;;5- "1.-__ _ _?.._._.:~ _-_.J-__92_V: .:-I-,I ..,_.,: _:r- - -_- ,-;_.I_"- I-_ _._ V_ . _ i '

    ""' ";.-. -92.."I' -_- -, ''-Q . ~ _ .,1. -' -' -_.-, _- ;:.I'_. . _: '-.- ___- . -; -_e- . - . ._ _| . _ -- ':-._l,- H: .I n_-3. _925} .r~ . "92 |-. 1 i--- "-- - . *~ -O - ___._ . _gas , . _- -- '- _V, .-- .. - -Ix. _.-

    - =. 1 IQ, saints ; -*7 -.=E'--~ i--'0-1 -'751= l.:..f_'{-." -"'3' ':-- ~. -".- - r.1; ~_, _ ,_ . .-.. . -1 . .- -_.': 1;; _._ 92_/-a- v. .J '43.3-1;, s._kl- OJ -. ,- 'F0,3-__.. " a$L- 3':' Ir ~45 : 1- r H ; 1,. ~-L' - It I _v . , _ . ,.,, 4 __ _ a__ -T :5 - air. U .;-g H ~--' -,..au

    jolly All .-F. of eiasweris to get twas abull with speciastandthem onthe It could work, I susee that the. investideeper t -iiit B

    .-__ I................ ..&

    :31-.

    L

    _~%

    . 5I -'

    I5

    ~. '1'

    - _.._ 1' Qt-

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    44/130

    rm-'r.n'm.:.;'n'-;P.i. :.~s."-* .___'

    roost.4themadoptedaw:titL.-.1 -see;;|;i||,,t.-_And sortieof the Statesidefugi-tive; l|;ttl |grmvndo92vnri|thtparanoidni-ter yearson the lam."l low doI knowtheywon'tlockmeupandputmebackin theArmy?"askedadieharddcserterin New York.Wlren the Clemency Board-lteadcd

    hy an outspokencriticof the war, iot-rnrr New York Sen. Charles Coodell lu-ttinsits worlr, someoi the resistorsfears may be eased. Coodcll'sdovish92-icwswillbe holstercdby thoseof otherhoardmembers,including National Ur-ban League director Vernon E. Iordanandthe ltev.Theodorellesburglt, res-identofNotreDameanda formerlieadoi the U.S. Civil lli 'hts Commission.

    Incpanelistsclirarlyhavesome very diilicult problems __-aln:.1d weigl1ing,for example, _timeservedin iailagainsttimeowd lor alternate service, orhattle honorsagainsttime spent

    P.i lSTEl'tlES: .

    TheMidnigittMarauderEach clay, just hr-loredusk. ranchers

    and iarmllandspile into pickup tmeksand fan out acrossthe rolling prairie oinortlteasternNebraska.They parkmostlyon ridgesor hilltops. where they canscanthe pasturesand the narrowroadsthat windthroughthem.With riliesand

    shotgunsleaningagainsttheirtrucks,themenwatch nervously.smokingcigarettesand talking with eachother overa net-tvorlr of citizen's-bandradios. Some of

    themenwill standguardall night,yetnoneof themreallyknowswhat he islookingfur. "I'veneverseenanything

    _. . .-.- --A_.5 .-. .1.-_ - -, .. - -.~_.-.

    .. --1'._,'._ T7.r - "".l:Tl.l

    AWOL. And the board con- -. --'- '1'-tainedsomehawltishtnemhers. _''"ii '. -'who might opposeleniency,in-'cltrdirn:retired Marine Corps.Gen. Lewis Walt and james Ma!-e, executive director ofParalyzedVeteransof America.Stiil, the Ford plan had the vir-tue oi all compromises.Saidlh-slmrglr: "As long as Nixonwas in, theseguyscould rot asiar as he was concerned. It's the tlitierence between tm chance and some chance.

    it-EDIANS:BlazingSaddles

    lt didn'tlook like tnut-l'of ahnrrh-rcrossing.The signby theside of the road merely dc- |n:nnlerl:110-centtoll frompars- -

    ? _"I'92' '1

    "I i.r='-"1-1-1- "'.b-F

    W

    ing motorists, most oi whom . _sli-_!n'teven stop. But the rnili-taut Knntenai Indians manningthe roadsidepicket linesoutsideIlonncrs Ferry, Idaho, weren'tkidding. After years oi fnistra-tinntryingtodealwith fashington,the6? mernhersoi the Kootcnaitribe linallylostpatiencelastweekand declaredwaron the United Statcs by registeredmail.Their challenge_wasdeliveredin o

    letter to PresidentFord demandinga

    128.000-acrereservation,plus as mnch.... Q10 ...:tl:.... I... r- I-.-.tI-....I|'l._ mum.-=IQvlinqIIIQIIIUII I92JIlllllall lBII92.lIIIY b92lI'BIIIrnenthadpaidfor in 1962at therateoi36 centsan acre. To hack it up, they threatened to lax white homeowners and businessessquattingon theirancienttribal lands. Idaho'sGov. Cecil Andrussentin GDlawmentokeep the highwaysclear, hut tensionssooneased.The Bu-re.nt of Indian Mlairs invited tribal lead-r.-rsto lveginnegotiations,and theciti-7.1-nsof Banners Ferry relaxed. TheIndianshavetold usthat theydon'twantawar,"saidonesyrnpatlrctichmal.Theyknowit'ston|:lIforti?peopletogeto re-actionfrom92 i'ashin;:tnn,D.C."o32 - A

    TEL?Kn

    miarpotlf:Tribearnonsolicitingtollsu

    like this," says State. Sen. Inles Bor-bach,who hasrepresentedKnoxCountyfor eighteen years.""Folks are almosthysterical.

    Sincelast May, more than 100 cattlehave been found dead and grucsomely

    mutilatedin Nebraska,Kansasand Iowa.fl It-slrn gnnrinu-rr|:92n'efnrrn nI '1"._.n ..................- . .... .. ..n.s:...a Madison,Neh.,a cow waskilledwithnlrlnnt instnnnentlastInnc andher udderand sexualorganswere cnt o|'l'.Wlrenaveterinarianexaminedthe corpse,hefound that all of the animal'sblood hadheen drained. On the nearhy ranch of92'emStringliehl, a month-old hull callwas clubbed to death. Its blood was drained oil , too. and someone cut ahole in the calls side, removingtheintestinesrindcoilingthemneatlynest

    Rumor and anxietyhave prodnecdahostof unpmvcdthr-_oriesto explainthe

    J.rizarreevents.hlanypr-rs]-It-_|m|;,,""Sl tll"oi the92 ir.'liInswerehint-t;__92.that r.lr-voter'soi witt-hcraltrnoylt;donethefouldeeds.It ;-mitt}I . ,,,mone setting upa fertility cult oi _9kind, saysllichardThill, a Genitstudies professorat the l.lniver_92l92't lJl al

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    45/130

    __ ________mw_____ymi __'__%_g______&39;__1_J___:T___W____;,__3

    H___m_$%%%mw_H%%___?A_&__u__i_x___ m_g_m_HA%W__%9;w_ W_

    W_%____m&__ __M_H_%__gin?%_W_""_J_m_ rq___,___W%mm:_ _%%%

    g wmhwiw w39;__'_H ____J__,w__r__MH_ 1______r_______ _I _____ _"_M_____i ___"_____ _________mm_""_'_m_J%"___'________/_/_uh_______H _______'__L__m____"_______h"______ ___f5 g_ _%_____H_______ "*______"__h___D__~_h_________ ____@_@ _m___

    mm"%$_____

    :__m______"_ _m L_ q%_%u_n"__._.__~________w___q_NM__i_n_y_____h__m"_r _qH__m'_m_%m_%_____'_ ____5_ _____m W_r_::a;_k 5?_d_H5_ __H_9;____uv _"$ ___?_r___E_ ___F_m__m__*______n_3__J_&______i_"__"__H_ _w_ i2____ mM_"?__i ___?_h__ ___m__ _ __H____LEFw&~Lh!#{_39;5Hwm M%%wm % Q% mD_0__"__f____ __ r___d__~____MWVw_m__m _m_ _*w_92_H w 92___ g n

    __A_____ ~_____H_w__hc__}___'__#39;____H__h_

    MMMN: _ __m__M_.g _%_%%w_$___w__h % Hm"__hmL_ 9h"_%$_u_ ______________r_ __"__ _"__hm_M_%__%__,___.____92_ ____________m__m__f_A_n%_W____@_W_AUm_m_ p __i_r_P_!H"_f _*MhH$m__?_1__9;u ____ __ ____4__J_u___w__*___"_"P___1_LH___vi_39;_:____l v__PH__,___hm%_~_wm__%qWM_m_ H%VV_$__mmm?____N__n__________h__~_L__ _ __U__ __ _*__P_%J?________H_m_

    _"__________m_%___A__Eh______W_'_E________&_h_g? hM h&p_&urM_ H_ _y9;__=__ _t______39;______v_______H:__m_______~____r___u_____H_________:_ ___rMWgM_H

    92__

    9;_

    #39;l_

    w

    __

    H

  • 7/28/2019 FBI Report on Cattle Mutilations

    46/130

    nu'.;"'_l_',T'92; { __j_- - - _.f-.'_'- 4-:._ -- -:"'.'-"Inq 'Z

    '. '-a_..'-u__.

    '.J- _

    ..".g --5-, . .. - -. '

    :_n92 -__.-.

    I-

    ..".1. .

    ___

    .

    .- ii H

    - f. 1*;

    .5

    Y7-3?1: .-".:_"Q'A'|

    . :;- 1;_=.