fatigue crashes_is new zealand doing enough to counter this issue
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
1/146
!
"#$%
$&'
() *'"+&& ",-.%
#&/&&&%0%"1&1
&%1*'
2
'3445
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
2/146
i
#'
!"
#
!$%&$%
$ %
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
3/146
ii
#6% ' '
( ) *(+ $%,- . /
01
, $% *2- / 0 3 /
( ( ( *4-
( 5 6!1,,!4
(5/
,..
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
4/146
iii
'! ............................................................................................................................................... i! ............................................................................................................................... ii,& .......................................................................................................................................v, .......................................................................................................................................vi7 ..................................................................................................................................18 )'......................................................................................................................29 , ..........................................................................................................................3
97 *##- .................................................................................................398 #&:..............................................................................................................499 3# ........................................................................................................................6
9; #& .....................................................................................................79< &, ..................................................................................................................89= # ......................................................................................................119> .3 .........................................................................129? 2#2.$% ........................................................................................139@ 2#2A ..........................................................................................2097B CD ................................................................................................................25977 #............................................................................................................................31
; )'7#: ................................................34;7 + .............................................................................................................................34;8 )'......................................................................................................34;9 3D ...................................................................................................................36
;; !E ................................................................................................................39;< !.................................................................................................................................40;= 3!2 ......................................................................................................41;> ..................................................................................................................................41;? +3(&2.....................................63;@ #A!#! ...............................................................64
2..............................................................................................................................112>7 )'7 ...........................................................................................................................112>8 )'8 ...........................................................................................................................113>9 )'9 ...........................................................................................................................114>; 23.............................................................................................................115
? .....................................................................................................................117?7 2D............................................................................................117?8 $ ......................................................................................................................119
@ & ......................................................................................................................120
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
5/146
iv
@7 2& ..............................................................................................................120@8 #2!...................................................................................................120@9 &33(.........................................................................................120@; 2.F! ................................................................................120
7B ...............................................................................................................................121!!.D& ........................................................................................................... I!E.32# ........................................................................................................II
!2.3(&2# ............................................................III!#.C2,03D .......................................................................................IV!.33G& ...............................................................................V!&.3)& .....................................................................................VI
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
6/146
v
.&7H&2#&........................................................................................................ 5&8H!.................................................................. 5&9H3 ...................................................................................................................... 11&;H$%(33, ........................................................................................ 35&H33D/........................................................................................................... 42&?H .................................................................. 43&@H$)'3...................................................................................................................... 44&7BH3)'3.................................................................................................................... 44&77H$2#C ......................................................................................................... 44&78H32#C......................................................................................................... 44&79H$.................................................................................................... 44&7;H3 ................................................................................................... 44&7H$
..................................................................................................... 46&7?H3.................................................................................................... 46&7@H3,, ......................................................................................... 48&8BH27*-..................................................................................... 49&87H29*-..................................................................................... 51&88H2
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
7/146
vi
.'&7H&2#&........................................................................................................ 5&8H!.................................................................. 5&9H3 ...................................................................................................................... 11&;H$%(33, ........................................................................................ 35&H33D/........................................................................................................... 42&?H .................................................................. 43&@H$)'3...................................................................................................................... 44&7BH3)'3.................................................................................................................... 44&77H$2#C ......................................................................................................... 44&78H32#C......................................................................................................... 44&79H$.................................................................................................... 44&7;H3 ................................................................................................... 44&7H$..................................................................................................... 46&7?H3.................................................................................................... 46
&7@H3,, ......................................................................................... 48&8BH27*-..................................................................................... 49&87H29*-..................................................................................... 51&88H2
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
8/146
vii
(
## $%!! (## ! # !22 $%0# !22 $%'D
#7+ !2D)*$-
#7+$ !2D)*3-
# !2 !##8 !2!
F3!2
#88! !E !
#$! !3E !3!!# E!2#.8#$ 2#
#81 2
#$ 2!3 2(
+ 2#+7$ 2)D3 $3!D# # F10#
.8 #,
09.# #6,! F10"$# &(23!(7 0D (# (7$ 0D3 3-9 +26-$"$ +3(
3$2F3!2#
. ,$%
.&
,$%*&,3!-
,$%2
"+ (#
" ( $%-$# $+3!
F3!&
8 $2 $2!
$, $3 !$! $3E F3!3+1 )2A
#+$# )3! 3# 71" D'( D'7+.:5: &2 $%D
8# 2! !
8+$7# 3D! F1
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
9/146
viii
8# ! !$330
8$ 23 G!2#$#$;< F12## !2 3.6!
$%8. ,98 260
!660
98 62 2D
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
10/146
1
; A
* - ! 2 )*-2D2
&3+
)*-
$%D2!*2!K-
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
11/146
2
3 8+'/&'&$%
H 2 & &
+
'+'H 23*$%- 2CD
,
'''H #" #" .
' '
$ 2
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
12/146
3
= .8
=;
*- * - *- I J .!L3
!++
& +
! (*7@?
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
13/146
4
N
=3 ,
3& *!8BB7- AK
' & *E8BB
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
14/146
5
(*- D
&7*!&08BB7-
;'
3*8BB;-&8
3#&%&2&&%
&+
3
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
15/146
6
!IJ
3*- + *7@@@-
== $&
*-
EK
==; $&
3!H)
*)3!-
)C *-
3!K)
==3 &
$OA!
$$#3*$+8BB
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
16/146
7
$)
$!F1*$8BB
+
#($%DD)
F D
D+'
A+'#
D
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
17/146
8
I J I J 39@;
! A 39?=
=: .
&!2*-
! 8BBB * " 8BBB- & 0 !7>7@*E!2-BB
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
18/146
9
=:3 *$#
?.I(K,J A+@=?I (K,H$##!8BB9J
(K,##+F3!)8BB8&8BB9
I(K,J H
I 7 7'#8
E3 K
98:#22;)& *
=:= #
9,K8
&2)D3*2)D3-
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
32/146
23
2$3
$I2)D3A
3!
!A! # *8BB9- 3 A
I!$37@@>J*!7@@@-)H
2(
- "
F#2H,N*-23GD# E!
GD#+)D
223*23-)I 2J
# !3GDIJ39@;
9#2H3D36D#(!
6D#+)D
!26
%=#% 01
2H#2D'F1
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
33/146
24
HCCC
!F3!F1 ' $2 3#*#-
#,0*#,-
+ 3!37@
I 8BB8 G ! ' 3J *#, 8BB8-
HI! / 9!/!9:= 9'J
!2D'
=
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
34/146
25
= $"
' *2$58BB7-
#
+*7@@
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
35/146
26
!
) $
)
! 0 3TH
& #
!
!A 3=3= $%
=;4; 7%%D#
!! 6 $ 3 G # 6 ! ( G !
!
#A
A !3
A
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
36/146
27
!=
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
37/146
28
$ + 7%%630 #D"&3"
6 &3&!6
!2 ((27@@7*6L-"E$330 &3$3
! 332"&"#
3!G30 #3"&3G
(GCG
0G!"&3&!"#D
'517%%A#
=;43 7%%D*$#
!F3!#F3!2)*(#)2#) 2!,!$3-
F3!
! ! F3! !A!
!! !
A
)%B>9002!&
F3!>
$ + 7%% !,, E0
*D)-#D+3
D*3$D-
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
38/146
29
$ + 7%%$3& &"
!!!&3 !1FD42$+3
!*$+3!-#2.##
#&(23
!*&(23!-2#2.##"
3)*-
$3E*$3E- 33
2 2#) &"PE0DQ2 2#)P2Q 3!31 1#) &3"#3( (#) &"$ #) &"$3!F F#) &"
'@17%%A*$#
=;4= 7%%D*)
)F1+$1432F1#&
+$14*+$148BB 7%%D
!$%
0!32A0#
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
39/146
30
$ % 2 ) *, $% $ % !22 (-
! ! F3! $ % #
!!22,$%
F!!
3 2A 0
'23D
30
3
&!22$%' 8BB
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
40/146
31
!! #,0 &!& "*-
'
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
41/146
32
$%! =M
+
8BM9BM !
$%
$%
=;;= 78&
!$%
!
2F3! +
$%
=;;> #
!
+#+$14&
H
" &" " $%" $%
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
42/146
33
=;;: A$
39?88 7=>> 77;; @
3
7BB 7@@?
23+
;= 78< 89= 879 @ 7BB 97 +'/;%&
!$%H
1" #1*#+" 1+81"1" 1(118(
3 +
>; -&+
>3 &+'/
(+$%$23+$7@@=7@@@
$ ( 23&
7@@@(+
2 3D23!1!&;
# $ 3 ( ( ) $%$%'*)8BB9- . N 6
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
44/146
35
&
3F
>"&$$.
3+D23 2 A 3 $%
>3; -8'
! 7@@= 7@@@
!39?
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
45/146
36
>= $7%
!
2 0 2
H +N
6 6
!39?=;
8%:: !
!D7@@@A'D7@@@
&
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
46/146
37
(//2!:E$$& :$ E E
$%3+7
7A@@8-
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
47/146
38
3+
! ?BC
8%:E!692
$ %K3+3 * -
$% 3 + &
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
48/146
39
(
! E+26
77 7=A@@8= )> (& &
';;$
$ * ' C N- 2!3 .$
8%:G !4/
!
2!3#!8(T
F 3 > #!
C
2 3D23!121D18
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
49/146
40
% 6%2*$- D B B 2
9B S ;B =B 7 ?B@B 7S 78B78B 8 7=B7B ;S 9=B D
D*3- 2 B B D9B S ;B=B 7 ?B@B 7S 78B78B 8 7=B 17B ;S 9=B 2
';3%
1 1 ' *#-
#2!3 ! !
!62K
!2!3 279: #
2!3
H 2 )' #C D( D#
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
50/146
41
D
&=&7?3;>
!03(+$%,79
$ $ $%( ,$%
3+! $%230D3D
';=($$
2!303&*$-$
>5 $
!03AN C
!79@ 8!' 3+2!3$%
&=&7?
!&N!E.32#
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
51/146
42
>@; +
8G:: "9H
! )A'*&=L&>-+, $%7@@@
+
)A'8BBB!,$%7@@@&8BBBA'D8BBBA'
SH1 RS90 to RS317 - North / Ea st bound Fatigue Crashes
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
NumberofCrashes
Non Injury Minor injury Serious Injury FatalCrashes
SH1 RS90 to RS 317 - South / West bound Fatigue Crashes
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
NumberofCrashes
Non Injury Minorinjury Serious Injury FatalCrashes
5'$7'C @$'$7'C
@M79MM3+$%
! &?
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
52/146
43
B8
7@@?8BB7=BM88BB8+8BB88BB;8BM9BMA'
*X7=B-*X@9@-!78
8G:# .9
!'
'''''
'&C,2CE#)!&@&7B&C,2
SH1 RS90 to RS317 - North / East bound Fatigue Crashes
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 910
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Driven oracco mpanied animals
Bridge/tunnel abutment, approach or handrail
Cliff,bank or retainingwall(upright)
Debris, boulder, orobject droppedfrom vehicle
Overedge of bank
Fence, letterbox, hoarding ,etc
Guardorguiderail
Houseorbuilding
Traffic island ormedian
Public furniture(ph boxes, bus shelters, signalcontrollers, etc)
Kerb (directly contributing to crash)
Landslide, washout or floodwater
Parked motor vehicle
Train
(N/A)
Utility pole
Broken down vehicle,work man's vehicle, taxis picking up,etc
Roadworks signs or barriers
Traffic signals or signalbollards
Trees
(N/A)
Ditch
Wild animal, stray, or outof control
Other
Objects thrown at ordropped onto vehicles
Intowater,river orsea
Objects struck (mayhave >1 per crash)
Non Injury
Minorinjury
Serious Injury
FatalCrashes
SH1 RS90 to RS 317 - South / West bound Fatigue Crashes
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 910
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
Driven oracco mpanied animals
Bridge/tunnelabutment, approachor handrail
Cliff,bank or retainingwall(upright)
Debris, boulder, or object droppedfromvehicle
Overedge of bank
Fence, letterbox, hoarding ,etc
Guardorguiderail
Houseorbuilding
Traffic island ormedian
Public furniture(ph boxes, bus shelters, signalcontrollers, etc)
Kerb (directly contributing to crash)
Landslide, washout or floodwater
Parked motorve hicle
Train
(N/A)
Utility pole
Broken down vehicle,workman's vehicle, taxis picking up,etc
Roadworks signs or barriers
Traffic signals or signalbollards
Trees
(N/A)
Ditch
Wild animal, stray, or outof control
Other
Objects thrown at ordropped onto vehicles
Intowater,river orsea
Objects struck (mayhave >1 per crash)
Non Injury
Minor injury
SeriousInjury
Fatal Crashes
Fatigue Ratio of all Crashes
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
Year
Percentageofallcrashes
Ratio (F) Ratio (S) Ratio (M) Ratio (NI)
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
53/146
44
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
54/146
45
2!3*X9?;>-$
!&N*X>BX@B-
)&&8
A
8G:8 ",!#5 $ % 2 C $ / *&7- $
SH1 North / East bound Fatigue Crashesn = 70
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
Month
%ageofallcrashes
Crashes by Month - StudySite Crashes byMonth- All SH
SH1 South/West Crashes by Monthn= 90
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
Month
%ageofallcrashes
Crashes by Month- Study Site Month - All SH
;:'&'% ;5$'&'%
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
55/146
46
8G:E "2
2 &7>&7?)33
!
! 1 (3
!!7=B!
$%
2!3*X9?;>-$
SH1 North / East bound Fatigue Crashes by Dayn = 70
0
5
10
15
20
25
MON TUE WED THU FRI SAT SUN
Day
Percentageofallcrashes
Crashes by Day - StudyLength Crashes by Day - All SH
SH1 South/West Crash by Dayn = 90
0
5
10
15
20
25
MON TUE WED THU FRI SAT SUN
Day
Percentageofallcrashes
Crashes by Day - StudyLength Crashes by Day - All SH
;@'&' ;B$'&'
8G:F 6
!
H 3 ( 3
! 7;
8(% ' $'$ ;BM ;BM1 9@M 9BM
" 7=M 89M$ =M >M
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
56/146
47
';>8'8(%A$-;
?BME
>@3 *!3;97@= #$'
! 3;97 !@B
79
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
57/146
48
&N!#.C2,03D
3;>97 ;>99 ! 3>7
&7@
3F
;
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
58/146
49
8G%: 9:6
34;6%&'
;9&8B
!
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
59/146
50
!3;>8F*7=-
%' 7I>=
# 9< ?7M(# ? 7@M
+# B BM 8@ =>M
';5$';6%8
?BM$
&>BM *-*-
7 +N;9
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
60/146
51
8G%# 9%6
3;=6%&'
9@&87
!
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
61/146
52
!3;>8F*7>-
%' 7I3=
# 7> >;M(# = 8=M+# B BM 7; =7M
';@$'=6%8
>
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
62/146
53
8G%% 9E6
33:6%&'
7>&88
!
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
63/146
54
!3;>8F*7?-
%' 7I;@
# 79 >=M(# ; 8;M
+# B BM > ;7M
';B$':6%8
>
8G%8 99
*7@-
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
64/146
55
$';6%I>=
$'=6%I3=
$';6%I;@
#$'
# ?7M >;M >=M >>M(# 7@M 8=M 8;M 89M+# BM BM BM BM
=>M =7M ;7M
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
65/146
56
>@> #'
! 3;97 !@B
7997 ;>99 ! 3>7
&8;
3F
3=$..
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
66/146
57
8G8: :6
3>;6%&'
9@&8;
!
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
67/146
58
!3;>8F*8B-
%' 7I=@M(# ? 87M
+# B BM 7@ ;@M
'34';6%8
?BM$
&
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
68/146
59
8G8# %6
3:=6%&'
88&8
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
69/146
60
!3;>8F*8;-
%' 7I33
# 7? ?8M(# ; 7?M
+# B BM 77
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
70/146
61
8G8% E6
35:6%&'
7
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
71/146
62
!3;>8F*8
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
72/146
63
';6%I=
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
73/146
64
! !#.C2,03D
>
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
74/146
65
>
!2!3 )!
2!3
!! &8>
8B7
7B8B>79 '
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
75/146
66
3@1%&$$
>
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
76/146
67
: +'/3*&&
!
38!
$
%
:; $&$
+2!
! $%+
)(*3-8@ !8BB
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
77/146
68
! +&
!6D
!
A
!AD;
)8B(*B;"9
!
H & #
E
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
78/146
69
:= $F
:=; $;A%$$
H 3+=C3+=
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
79/146
70
2 ;B + 3 3+>,D.3!$2
!0'!22!0$%
E%#: 9,
!, &2
7 !;BB
)EB2;" )FB;"94
!EEG!C
!!0
3
#H D D $ #
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
80/146
71
2
! .33G&
E%##
! >8 @ 8;M
3B91%&
) 7BB M
!'2
:== $=A7$$
H 3+7C37@
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
81/146
72
D 3 + 7 788 D
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
82/146
73
2
! .33G&
E%%#
!?;8H;
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
83/146
74
& 3*2D-
:>; "
E8:: !4
&,$%*,$%-D#A$IAAAJ
'
K/!45942&L/!45942&L/!45942&&'
HK
K1!
/!4K&
942K*&
'K
1H
$7 17 $. 8 2 2 7B@= 7
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
84/146
75
AA
E8:#!2
!
!
!CC" &" "
E8:% 0
&>7 &8 #9 &
; 3C!
)&23
"! $%C)E
2 3 & D0 )
$ 7 8 9 ; < = >2 0 E 2 #C&
'35*8A%1%&
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
85/146
76
&
$
E8:89)
!,
32D!
IJ?8;)3D!*8BB7->@
:>3 $;A%$$
&3 ! 898
!
E8#: !2
!
) 898 >
8>
, &333 23
&.; &.3#&. 7=; ?;"&. 7
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
86/146
77
'3@%$&$A&.$%%
7=B0'?BC7= $3A1%&$$2&3!>8
Total Trip Length (Tasman Survey)
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Trip Length (km)
CumulativePercentage
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
87/146
78
#
E8%: !2
! 2
2
8@#39;
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
88/146
79
. 2&33$& 63
&.; &.3#&. 7B 88?
"%%&. = 7B$%&$J >8 9>&.#&. 879"&. 87="%%&. ;BB"%%&. =9$%&$J >8
'3
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
89/146
80
1' ,'#&. 79; 77@"&. 78? 77@"%%&. 8?> 8>;"%%&. 8@ 7=$%&$J 9@ 7?
'=41%&$&$A&.$%%
79;77@
0 ' ?B C 79B7;B
8
!@BM9BB&97
=;1%&$&$A0&
! 2 3 33!2$
N*X88
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
90/146
81
$ I J
!
E8%% 9)
!
, 2&333 63
$$& >=
"$& ?"%%$& 78"%%$& B$%&$J >8
'=31%&$&$A$&$%%
!>
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
91/146
82
:>> $=A7$$
D&3 !=#&. 779 ?@ ?= ;8B 8>7 777"%%&. 88 78 78 78$%&$J ?; 7$&$A&.$%%
D 2
!@BM
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
92/146
83
==7$&$A0&
77970'?BC78;
!3$%&$J 7B
Total Trip Length (Parnassus)
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%70%
80%
90%
100%
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Trip Length (km)
CumulativePercenta
ge
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
93/146
84
'=57$&$A
0 ' ?B C 7;
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
94/146
85
Sleep Profile by Day
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
50%
11
hrs
Hours sleep
Percentageo
fdrivers
SaturdaySunday
Monday
=>$&7'7
E?98;!9?BM*9?-
. D&33$& 236
$$& >9"$& ?
"%%$& 78"%%$& B$%&$J ?;
'=B7$&$A$&$%%
:: $&
::; 7'#$&%&
!
! 2 2
DD
E79M 2
Marginal to Very Poor Good or Better
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
95/146
86
D(D!*-
!!22
EE:: 9""
& 3 2 2D
!!*AC-
)A
$2
::3 %&
&3D
EE#: I99
$%
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
96/146
87
!"#
C
"
'
E*(- E*-
(% H $ ,!(
E
'=
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
97/146
88
&9>
=@$*)K-)LM%& =B 7& 8 " $$
EE#E )99
!&9
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
98/146
89
&.'" &*-
D !
EE%# )9
D&A'
H .2'" &&.EEG" "
) !22 2 !0
EE%% 9
3$%C
Y
Y*-
+
3&
::> %%!
2!0'!22
! *-
E
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
99/146
90
!2
!
::: .
&3
23!;B'
)A
'''
#2
DD2' D 79 2 ! 2
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
100/146
91
5 +'/=17'A!7
3 ;
3
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
101/146
92
5= 7%%8
!*$%-
! $ %
G ;B $
+ 7 7' 8&CG
.6CG
$% ( $ $,$% / $!224 / $32A / $!1,,! / $
!F3 G#( / $!.$3 / $
F3! !!!& / $EL0 / $
F1 F1# / $
'>4+1%&
5=; 1$
!)
'
7*- :
D7
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
102/146
93
7=7 ?
5> 7%%8&
5>; "&
(%#A
$%O(*(-2O $%3#8BB8
! O ( O$%3*$%3-
F8:: )9
!0( + (
F8:# 1
!(( (
( ' ! $%!
;7
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
103/146
94
7%%%
8
.
7&
8
9
$
C"
C%
7
$,6
$
&
%
8%*
876
176
1
&3A =
2#D
>
'>;"D$%%6
F8:% 495.
(
2!3 (,$%!3$%
5>3 .&
(%#A
G , $% 2 7 #8BB;
,$%O'H 2
, $% $ % A
,$%*D(2!K0-!
! '
!
,$%
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
104/146
95
F8#: )9
&,$%&3&,$%,$%
F8## 1
&3,$%$%
3
;8
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
105/146
96
7%%%
8
.
7&
8
9
$
C"
C%
7
$,6
$
&
%
8%*
876
176
1
&3A =
'>3.&D$%%6
F8#% 4.95.
! , $% # , $%
5>= #A6L
(%#A
!22*!22-!22$%K'$%N$%'
!222H
' ' '
' '
8BB9 , 3 ! * , $%- ZKZK=M'!22*!22-W78
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
106/146
97
6A
!22$%!22
!22I0J 2"
I K K KJ
!22 ' $% $ % '3=#6D$%%6
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
107/146
98
F8%% 4.95.
$,+3
!22 !0 2&0E!22!0! , $% $%
5>> 8$D
(%#A
$%
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
108/146
99
*-*'-*&9@-
%%&% %+& +'/&%%
=>8$DD$%%6
2 A 2 3D*N-!
$ % $
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
109/146
100
F88% 4.95.
& 2 3 D 0,$%!22 3*2 - +
!A$%
5>: #)..#
78$1%&A
!V 3 3 2 $ %K A
$33&2*-
!V332((35'3379#8BB9
![332
NA(50
(5!1,,![
'!1,,![
F8E: )9
![3 3 2 $%!1,,![6'
A
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
110/146
101
A
F8E# 1
!1,,![$8BB:#)...#ND$%%6
F8E% 4.95.
!1,,![ $#2*8BB
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
111/146
102
5>5 F&%"8
(%8#D#
(GGK9;BBB A G
*-
G(G
& &;
DZKZKH # $ 7
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
112/146
103
78BB7 K7&2P8BB8Q887QOO
)7@@@1A19694!56C
+7%) 2A(K 9 GK*.2-#
8#F$&&%&37@@?!2GG
F8F# 1
;=
7%%%
8
.
7&
8
9
$
C"
C%
7
$,6
$&
%
8%*
876
176
1
##2
9
D2
;
!303,E
:
#3
;
'>5"8FD$%%6
G?=M
!RDR'*@>M-
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
113/146
104
F8F% 4.95.
G&3 G 0 G!!
G 2*3- ,3) 3+
D!2G(#T
5>@ 8#D$,
(%8#D#
!*!-$37>=89397B,
&'$3!B$38BB8)8BM!'8BB8
F8G:)9
!K A # 1 1N I $&8$M
"&%&K$&8$M(#8BB7
8%
2E7B=K 2 (!8BB9
'H + A
)Z#KZK$3
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
114/146
105
@B# $3 2 # 6 ! 3 3 ,2ET!
F8G# 1
!!$3
;>
7%%%
8
.
7&
8
9
,'7
$
C"
C%
7
$,6
$&
%
8%*
876
176
1
&3A =
3 32
>
# 3
>
'>@8#D$%%6
F8G% 4.95.
!&3!$3!!
!2*3-,3)3 +
5>B ###$
78$81#D*$#
!!!&3'37@;>&77B' '!!!&N
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
115/146
106
!!! &
F8J: )9
!!! &K
,6*&L
! !!! & C' NK K !
,6*&L%& *-
N
'H +
8
!!!&)I#D+##2:A#5#J *37@@@-
A2 $ 2 I J I J H*7- $ 2
*8- $2
!F32D)DO##E*!!!&3"8BB;-*$"7@@?-
F8J# 1
NK H D" F42" !IJ
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
116/146
107
;?
7%%%
8
.
7&
8
9
8
$
C"
C%
7
$,6
$&
%
8%*
876
176
1
IF4J2
>
D
D3!
:
'>B###D$%%6
F8J% 4.95.
! !!! & ) !!! & *-
( !!! &
5>
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
117/146
108
F8=# 1
3
2 C
7%%%
8
.
7&
8
9
$
$
C"
C%
7
$,6
$&
%
8%*
876
176
1
#DD
>
'>;4 *)&%&
(%8#D*)
#*#-' #
F10'';B*
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
118/146
109
F8:$: )9
# A 6 A!
#&,&,
0 * - 0O
!(;
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
119/146
110
F8:$# 1
+$142
7%%%
8
.
7&
8
9
$
C"
C%
7
$,6
$&
%
8%*
876
17
6
1
+$142
>
&3 >
DD
>
':4*)&%&D$%%6
F8:$% 4.95.
+$142#
5:
!'$%)
+ % %& &%%
(
!
!
(
!+
E 0 !1,,! !!! & ''K( *-
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
120/146
111
(!F3!
'
$% 23D
D
)
*# " 8BB;- C
* - *-
0#Y ( (
) ! +
'
!3
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
121/146
112
@ '''H7 #"
8 #"9 .
''
'.
@; +'/;
@;; .
! ?BM $
&;
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
122/146
113
N
2!3
2!3
@3 +'/3
)'8'
&3*#-3
* 3- *2D3-
#
)
C*-
'8!8$%2
A+
) D 3+7D2 . 3 $% 2 3 $
A2+
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
123/146
114
2D2DDA
!2;MD77M
0
2*-H
$" '
" F" 3" 3"
@3; &%
!
H # # # . C
#
#
@= +'/=
3= $C
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
124/146
115
+
'
F1#F1F1#
#
)3D!
$% $ % E
)$%
F1#-)L2
$%'&$%0
0A.'
.$%1!E'
@> $%%
'H #"
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
125/146
116
#" .
3+ 7 3 C
+
$%
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
126/146
117
B 8%% $ %
9BM$%
& $ % $%
B; %&%7
B;;
! 3 9? 9@
$% !+$%F3!
J::: ("
!
J::# ("2/
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
127/146
118
B;3 $&$
& 33
!
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
128/146
119
B3
B3; 6
!!397E $%
'H #'" #"
H #A"
" " ! *
4-
B33 17%%
) A $ %
C !#4 *-
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
129/146
120
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
130/146
121
;4 8!3E*8BB8-I"+///$!3E!3H)893E$7A?>>B>7AB
E!23!&E7@@?
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
131/146
122
+3*8BB7- !*$8BB7
+'!30*8BB9- /,/,&22!23D28BB9!*!-99>.;8*8-3$3!
+N(*8BB;&>B6/B/(GD!!!8BB;
+5!,!*7@@
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
132/146
123
!*8BB7-2+)2"9!38BB7
)3D!*8BB7-2/+/4))O&8BB7
!*7@@@-!/9>:==G+99 !3!33$B7
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
133/146
I
#&A78&%
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
134/146
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
135/146
II
#&&!A$%%&
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
136/146
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
137/146
III
#&& A $ " %
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
138/146
#$GD$8$88&+83=2#$!2#
$3AH K"C
AA*"A
GAH !7BBCN*8.;
7B.=-"
!AH D" !A
"
*A-
6A
3!$!2
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
139/146
IV
#&&AG.($7
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
140/146
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
141/146
V
#&&1A$&$F%&
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
142/146
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
143/146
VI
#&&A$%&+8%
&
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
144/146
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
145/146
P)$Q+
.
P,Q
8
!6
,'
-
8/2/2019 Fatigue Crashes_Is New Zealand Doing Enough to Counter This Issue
146/146
7%%$#
7%% 8 . 7& 8 9 7%%&
PQ
$
1 # 1 -1PQ 3 ; 3 = > :
# #
)&%%
: :
%%7%%