faraday’s law applied to cleaning _ products finishing

17
2 Faraday’s Law Applied to Cleaning Article: External From: Products Finishing Posted on: 3/18/2015 This paper is a re-publication of the the 2nd William Blum Lecture, presented at the 47th AES Annual Convention in Los Angeles by Dr. A. Kenneth Graham, 1959 AES Scientific Achievement Award recipient. While Faraday's Law had long been applied to electrodeposition processes, Dr. Graham took it a step further, considering its usage in the electrocleaning of various metal substrates in terms of electrical charge passed during the cleaning operation.  by  Dr. A. Kenneth Graham Recipient of the 1959 AES Scientific Achievement Award  Editor’s Note: Originally published as A.K. Graham,  Annual Technical Proceedings of the American Electroplater’s Society , 47, 41-44 (1960), this article is a re-publication of N ewsle tt er S u bs cr ibe A dver ti se C on ta ct U s  ARTICLES SUPPLIERS PRODUCTS EXPERTS CALEND AR P ROCES S ZO NES RESOURCES

Upload: jmpcalcao

Post on 04-Nov-2015

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

plating

TRANSCRIPT

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 1/17

    2

    FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaningArticle:ExternalFrom:ProductsFinishingPostedon:3/18/2015

    Thispaperisarepublicationofthethe2ndWilliamBlumLecture,presentedatthe47thAESAnnualConventioninLosAngelesbyDr.A.KennethGraham,1959AESScientificAchievementAwardrecipient.WhileFaraday'sLawhadlongbeenappliedtoelectrodepositionprocesses,Dr.Grahamtookitastepfurther,consideringitsusageintheelectrocleaningofvariousmetalsubstratesintermsofelectricalchargepassedduringthecleaningoperation.

    by

    Dr.A.KennethGraham

    Recipientofthe1959AESScientificAchievementAward

    EditorsNote:OriginallypublishedasA.K.Graham,AnnualTechnicalProceedingsoftheAmericanElectroplatersSociety,47,4144(1960),thisarticleisarepublicationof

    Newsletter Subscribe Advertise ContactUsARTICLES SUPPLIERS PRODUCTS

    EXPERTS CALENDAR PROCESSZONES RESOURCES

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 2/17

    the2ndWilliamBlumLecture,presentedatthe47thAESAnnualConventioninLosAngeles,California,onJuly25,1960.AprintablePDFversionisavailablebyclickingHERE.

    Introductionandbackground

    WhatisFaraday'sLaw?"ThatwastheonlyquestionaskedmebytheplatingforemanoftheWelsbachCompanyin1921whenthesuperintendentintroducedmeandinquirediftheremightbeajobavailableforme.Atthetime,IhadmyBSdegreeinchemicalengineeringandtwoyearsexperienceinindustry,butrecognizedthepracticalvalueofworkingoverthetanksunderanexperiencedplater.Thesuperintendentagreedtogivemetheopportunitytoapplyforsuchajobwithoutdisclosingmybackground.Igotthejobbyansweringthequestion"WhatisFaraday'sLaw?"

    AllofyouappreciatethatFaraday'stwoLawsarethebasisofallplatingand,infact,oftheentireElectrochemicalIndustry.Intheyearssincethelastwar,wehavelearnedthattheycanbeappliedwithgreatadvantagetocleaningaswellasplating.ItisabouttheirapplicationtocleaningthatIwishtospeaktoday.

    Cleaningofthecommonbasismetalsforpresentdaydecorativeandprotectiveplatingapplicationshasbeendevelopedtothepointwheretheconscientiousplatercanapplytheavailableinformationanddoanacceptablejob.However,thepresentdayplatingapplicationsinotherareas,thesocalledengineeringapplications,arepresentinganeverincreasingarrayofcleaningandplatingproblems.Oneindustryrequireselectrodepositedgold,silveroralloycoatingonberylliumcopper,bronzeorbrasstapeorwire.Coatingsofbuffednickeloverbuffednickelwithorwithoutafinalchromiumcoatinghavebeenusedtoovercomecavitationfailureofdieselcylinderlinersandtoobtainimprovedcorrosionresistanceinvariousapplications.Manyvarietiesofstainlesssteelalloysmustbeadherentlyplatedwithvariousmetalstomeetspecialservicerequirements.Theextremelypassivematerials,suchasStellite,Inconel,Hastalloy,andCarballoysometimesrequireadherentplatedcoatingsforsomeapplications.Sometimesthemoreexoticmetals,suchasniobium,titanium,zirconium,uranium,berylliumandmolybdenum,requireadherentplatedcoatingsforvariousreasons.Itisreasonabletoassumethatsuchproblemswillincreaseinthefuture.

    Suchengineeringplatingapplicationswillonlybesuccessfulifoneisabletodevelop

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 3/17

    cleaningcyclesthatwillpermitonetodepositadherentmetalcoatings.Toaccomplishthisonemustremoveoxideorothersurfacefilmsandthenkeepthebasismetalsurfaceactivateduntiltheplatedcoatingcanbeapplied.Thechemistryofsomeofthebasismetalsinvolvedrenderthisextremelydifficult.Thereismuchyettobelearnedaboutthesematters.

    Theconventionalapproachtosolvingsuchaproblemistofirstremoveorganicsoilsbysuitabledegreasingmeans,includinganelectrocleaningtreatment.Whetherthelattershouldbeanodicorcathodicisnotalwaysclear.Inanyevent,thecommonlyrecommendedconditionsforaproprietarycleanersuchasconcentration,temperature,currentdensityandtime,areusuallyemployed.Someacidtreatmentwithorwithouttheuseofcurrentisthenchosentoetchandactivatethesurfaceandthecommonlyrecommendedconditionsofbathcomposition,concentration,temperature,timeandcurrent,ifany,arepreciselyfollowed.Insomecases,ifallowable,theWood'stypeofnickelchloridestrikeisfinallyusedundertheconditionsrecommended.Iftheseproceduresthendonotgivethedesiredresults,wereallydohaveaproblem.

    Undersuchcircumstances,IhavefounditmosthelpfultosimplyapplyFaraday'sLawstotheelectrolytictreatments.IthereforetrustyouwillbearwithmeifIbrieflydiscusstheseLawsinanelementaryfashionasappliedtocleaning.

    AccordingtoFaraday'sfirstLaw,theamountofchemicalchangeproducedbyanelectriccurrentflowingthroughanelectrolyteisproportionaltothequantityofelectricity.Thequantityofelectricityistheproductofthecurrentflowingtimesthetime.Theunitofquantity,acoulomb,isoneampereflowingforonesecond.Tenamperesflowingforsixsecondswillcausethesamechemicalchangeasoneampereforsixtyseconds,bothbeingthesamequantityofelectricity,60coulombsoroneampereminute.Ineithercase,thesameamountofhydrogenwillbeliberatedatametalsurfaceincathodiccleaning.Ifonedoublesthequantityofelectricity,theamountofhydrogenliberatedalsowillbedoubled.Whateverbenefitmaybederivedfromtheliberationofhydrogenincathodiccleaningmaythereforebevariedbyapplyingthisconcept.

    AccordingtoFaraday'ssecondLaw,theamountsofdifferentsubstancesliberatedbyagivenquantityofelectricityareproportionaltotheirchemicalequivalentweights.Statedanotherway,96,500coulombsoroneFaradayofelectricitywillliberateoneequivalentweightoronegramofhydrogenatthecathodeandoneequivalentweightoreightgramsofoxygenattheanodeinalkalineelectrocleaning.Therefore,theeffectoftheoxygenliberatedinanodiccleaning,whetherbeneficialorotherwise,canalsobevaried

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 4/17

    quantitativelybyapplyingthisLaw.

    AccordingtoAvogadro,agrammolecularweightofanygasoccupiesthesamevolumeatthesametemperatureandpressure.Sincetheequivalentorcombiningweightofhydrogenisonehalfitsmolecularweight,butthatofoxygenisonlyonefourthitsmolecularweight,thenthevolumeofhydrogenliberatedatthecathodeinalkalineelectrocleaningistwicethevolumeofoxygenliberatedattheanode.ThusthiswellknownvolumerelationshipfollowsdirectlyfromFaraday'sLaws.Also,thegreatervolumeofhydrogenliberatedatthecathodeledtothepreferreduseofcathodicelectrocleaningintheearlydays.

    Inmanycasesthescrubbingactionofthevolumeofgasliberatedatthesurfaceofthemetalinalkalineelectrocleaningisofsecondaryimportancetothenatureofrelatedchemicalreactionsandthisdependsuponthereactionsofhydrogenandoxygenattheelectrodesurfaces.Inouropinion,theresultingadhesionoftheelectrodepositedmetalcoatingisthemostimportantfactor,bothasanindicationofaproperlycleanedsurfaceandasameansofinsuringqualityoftheplatedcoating.Experiencehasshownthatgoodadhesionisfavoredbyanodiccleaningofthecommonferrousmetals.Cathodiccleaningisusuallypreferredfornickel.Copperorzinccanbecleanedeitherwayforgoodadhesion,butanodiccleaningismostcommonlyusedtoavoiddepositionoffilms.Leadiscathodicallycleanedtoavoidetchingandstaining.

    Thecleaningofmanymetalspriortoplatingaspracticedtodayfrequentlyinvolvesvariouspretreatmentsincombinationwithbothelectrolytealkalineandacidsteps.Theseelectrolytictreatmentsareusuallylimitedtonotovertwominutesandoftentooneminuteorless.Thetanksizesandconveyorchainspeedfrequentlydeterminesthis.Also,thecurrentdensityiseitherlimitedtothatobtainableatthevoltageofthecurrentsourceavailableorispurposelyrestrictedbecauseofthesensitivityofaparticularmetalsurfacewithrespecttoetchingorstaining.Thisisespeciallytruefordecorativebrightplatedfinishes.Thusthequantityofelectricity,theproductofthetimemultipliedbytheamperesflowing,istherebylimitedandtheapplicationofFaraday'sLaws,inanyrealsense,hasbeendisregardedasfarascleaningisconcerned.

    Ofcoursethisisnotsowithplating.OneFaradayor96,500coulombsofelectricitywilldepositonechemicalequivalentorcombiningweightofanymetalat100percentcathodeefficiency.WeroutinelyrefertotheTableofElectrochemicalEquivalentsandRelatedDatatofindtheampereminutesrequiredtodepositanymetaltoacoatingthicknessofonemilpersquarefoot.Fromthiswedeterminetheplatingtimerequired

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 5/17

    atagivencurrentdensitytodepositanythicknessofmetalorviceversa.Westilldesignandcontrolourplatingoperationstoobtainagivenplatingtimeatacontrolledaveragecurrentdensitytoobtainacontrolledaverageweightofmetalcoating.Wealsomakeallowancefortheefficiencyoftheplatingprocessandforvariationsincurrentandmetaldistributionwiththedesignofthepartbeingplated.AllthisisstrictlyinaccordancewithFaraday'sLaws.

    WealsoknowthatFaraday'sLawsapplytotheperformanceofsolubleanodesinplatingandthatthemetalplatedoutatthecathodeissubstantiallyallsuppliedbymetaldissolvingattheanodeinproperlycontrolledprocesses.

    ToapplyFaraday'sLawstocleaningismuchmoredifficultandonemightask,"Whybother?"Itismoredifficultbecauseweareobligedtoremovesomanydifferenttypesofsoil,andthetermsoilisusedhereinthebroadestsense.Thesurfacechemistryofthebasismetalitselfcannotbedefined.Asmanyofyouwellknowwhochromiumplatenickel,thesurfacechemistryofanickelcoatingimmediatelyafterplatingisdifferentthanonethathasjustbeenbuffedandbothwillbedifferentafterexposuretoairfor24hours.Thesurfacechemistryalsovarieswitheachmetalanditsmetallurgicalhistory.Onethereforecannotdeterminethechemicalequivalentweightofthecombinationofsoils,oxidesandmetalsurfacefilmsandrelateittoagivenquantityofelectricityincleaning.OuronlyrecourseistoapplythequantitativeconceptsofFaradayblindly.Increasingthecurrentdensityand/orthetimewillquantitativelyincreasethehydrogenandoxygenliberatedandthechemicalreactionsresultingatbothanodeandcathodeinelectrocleaningtreatments,eventhoughthereactionsareundefined.Bysodoingwecanaccomplishresultsincleaningandplatingthatcanbeguaranteedandnotlefttochance.Thisisespeciallytruewithrespecttothesocalledengineeringapplications,manyofwhichrequireplatinguponthemoredifficultorunusualbasismetals.

    Mr.F.W.Stockton,formerlyoftheStandardSteelSpringCo.,wasthefirst,toourknowledge,toemphasizetheimportanceofFaraday'sLawsinelectrocleaning.Heobservedthatcathodiccleaningofsteelpriortonickelplatinggaveverypooradhesion,comparedtoanodiccleaning.Hethenshowed,ifcathodiccleaningwasfirstused,theadverseeffectofthistreatmentonadhesioncouldbeovercomebyfollowingwithanodiccleaning,usingatleastthesamequantityofampereminutespersquarefootandpreferablymore.

    WehaveextendedthisapplicationofFaraday'sLawsbyincreasingtimeand/orcurrentdensityofboththeelectrolyticalkalineandacidtreatmentsindevelopingcleaning

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 6/17

    cyclesforspecificplatingapplications.Eachcyclesodevelopedmustbeshownbytesttomeettherequiredspecifications,especiallytheadhesion,beforebeingusedinproduction.Thenbycontrollingtheproductioncyclesteps,asestablishedbythisprocedure,thequalityoftheplatedproductcanbeassured.Afewillustrationsofhowthishasbeenappliedmaybeofinterest.

    Platingchemicalequipment

    ThelateCarlHeussnerused18cleaningstepsincludingrinsesforthefirstatomicenergyprogram(theManhattanProject)inthepreparationofsteelequipmentfornickelplating.Henaturallyincludedeveryfavorabletreatmentstepthathadbeenrecommendedintheliteratureinordernotonlytomeetthecorrosionandadhesionteststhatwerespecified,butinthehopethatthequalityofnickelplatingsoproducedwouldprovesatisfactoryfortheintendedservice.Fortunatelytheplatednickelcoatingsperformedsuccessfully.OtherwisesolidwroughtnickelwouldhavebeenrequiredandthisprogramalonewouldhaveconsumedtheavailableoutputofnickelinAmericafortwoyears.1Ofcourse,nosuchquantitywasavailable,soifplatinghadfailed,wemightnothavehadtheatombomb.

    Theequipmentprogramsthatfollowedthewarwerenolongeronacrashbasisandmoneywasnolongerbeingspentonanemergencybasis.Itwasimportantthereforetolimitthenumberofpreplatingstepstoaminimuminordertoreduceplantinvestments.Fortunatelywehadthetimetoinvestigatethis.ByapplyingthequantitativeconceptofFaradayindevelopingthecleaningcyclewewereabletomeetthenickelplatingspecificationforboththeadhesionandhotwaterporosityratingwithacycleofonlyfoursteps,twoofwhichwererinses.2(SeeTable1.)

    Weknewthatanodicalkalineandanodicsulfuricacidtreatmentsfavoredtheadhesionofnickeltomildsteel.Wedidnotknowwhatquantityofelectricityinthesetreatmentswasrequiredtomeetthespecificationsor,infact,whethersomefurthercyclevariationswouldberequired.Weincreasedthequantityofcurrentstepwiseinboththeanodicalkalineandacidtreatmentsandultimatelyfoundthatwithaminimumof300Amin/ft2inbothtreatmentswegotperfectadhesion.Thenonsilicatedproprietarycleanerthathadoriginallybeenspecifiedwasoperatedataconcentrationof1012oz/galandatemperatureof190200F.Theanodicacid50percentbyvolumesulfuricacidwasoperatedatatemperaturenotinexcessof85F.Aminimumcurrentdensityof50Amin/ft2andsixminutestreatmenttimewasusedinbothtreatments.

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 7/17

    Table1Cleaningcyclesfornickelplating.*

    Itisconservativelyestimatedthatoverthreemillionsquarefeetofsurfacewereplatedtoanaverageof57milofnickelwithoutasinglefailureduetoadhesion.Whenapieceofsome700squarefeetofsurfacefailedtopassthehotwaterporositytestoccasionally,thedefectiveareaswerewirebrushed.Thepiecewasthengiventhesamecleaningtreatmentswithminormodificationpriortoplatingadditionalnickelovertheinitialcoating.Noadhesionfailurebetweenthetwonickelcoatingswaseverexperienced.

    Inpractice,theanodicalkalineelectrolytictreatmentwassometimesincreasedtoasmuchas500Amin/ft2.Theanodicacidtreatmentwassometimesincreasedto1000Amin/ft2.Thiswasdonetocompensateforaparticularlybadlotofsteelorasafurtherfactorofsafety,especiallywhenplatingnickelovernickel.Inthelattercasewewerealwayscarefultousemoreampereminutespersquarefootintheacidtreatmentthanintheanodicalkalinetreatment,sincethelatteraloneadverselyaffectstheadhesionofnickelovernickel.

    Onemustrealizethatthisapplicationofplatingwasforcorrosionresistanceinachemicalenvironmentandinvolvedtheuseofheavynickelcoatings.Abrightappearancewasofnoimportance.Thereforeetchingresultingfromthelonganodicacidtreatmentcouldbeusedtoadvantage.Theproblemisquitedifferentwhenplatingnickelovernickelforadecorativeapplication,asdiscussedinthenextexample,wherethecoatingsarethinnerandlusterissoimportant.

    Platingnickelonbuffednickel

    In1947theInternationalNickelCo.wantedtohavesomesteelpanelsplatedwithdoublenickelcoatingstobeincludedintheoutdoorexposureprogramofCommitteeB

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 8/17

    8ofASTM,nowknownasProgramNo.1.ThelotofpanelsrequiringafirstcoatingofbuffedWattstypenickel,followedbyasecondcoatingofthesamenickel,presentedaproblem.Onehadtocleanandactivatethefirstbuffednickelsurfacesothatthebuffedsurfacewouldnotbedestroyed,butatthesametimewouldinsureadequateadhesionofthesecondnickelcoating.Weknewcathodicalkalicleaningandastronghydrochloricaciddipwouldfavoractivationofthebuffednickelsurfaceandadhesionofthesecondnickelcoating.Wedidnotknowthequantityofcurrentrequiredtoaccomplishthis.InourlaboratoryevaluationofthecyclewekeptincreasingtheampereminutesofcathodiccleaninguntilasshowninCycle1ofTable2withtwoseparatetreatmentsof75Amin/ft2each,followedbyathreeminutedipin50volumepercenthydrochloricacid,weobtainedgoodadhesionofnickelonthebuffednickelsurface.Theadhesiononthebackofthetestpanelwherethesteelhadonlybeenroughpolishedandthefirstnickelcoatwasunbuffedwasstillverypoor.Bytheninsertingbetweenthetwocathodiccleaningstepsa15Amin/ft2anodicetchin30percentbyweightsulfuricacidasshowninCycle2,weobtainedexcellentadhesionofthesecondnickelcoatingonboththefrontandbackofatestpanel.BythusapplyingthequantitativeconceptofFaraday'sLawstocleaning,wedevelopedasatisfactorycycleanditisnowamatterofrecordthatthepanelssopreparedperformedwellwhentestedoutdoors.

    Itisconservativelyestimatedthatoverthreemillionsquarefeetofsurfacewereplatedtoanaverageof57milofnickelwithoutasinglefailureduetoadhesion.Whenapieceofsome700squarefeetofsurfacefailedtopassthehotwaterporositytestoccasionally,thedefectiveareaswerewirebrushed.Thepiecewasthengiventhesamecleaningtreatmentswithminormodificationpriortoplatingadditionalnickelovertheinitialcoating.Noadhesionfailurebetweenthetwonickelcoatingswaseverexperienced.

    Inpractice,theanodicalkalineelectrolytictreatmentwassometimesincreasedtoasmuchas500Amin/ft2.Theanodicacidtreatmentwassometimesincreasedto1000Amin/ft2.Thiswasdonetocompensateforaparticularlybadlotofsteelorasafurtherfactorofsafety,especiallywhenplatingnickelovernickel.Inthelattercasewewerealwayscarefultousemoreampereminutespersquarefootintheacidtreatmentthanintheanodicalkalinetreatment,sincethelatteraloneadverselyaffectstheadhesionof

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 9/17

    nickelovernickel.

    Onemustrealizethatthisapplicationofplatingwasforcorrosionresistanceinachemicalenvironmentandinvolvedtheuseofheavynickelcoatings.Abrightappearancewasofnoimportance.Thereforeetchingresultingfromthelonganodicacidtreatmentcouldbeusedtoadvantage.Theproblemisquitedifferentwhenplatingnickelovernickelforadecorativeapplication,asdiscussedinthenextexample,wherethecoatingsarethinnerandlusterissoimportant.

    Platingnickelonbuffednickel

    In1947theInternationalNickelCo.wantedtohavesomesteelpanelsplatedwithdoublenickelcoatingstobeincludedintheoutdoorexposureprogramofCommitteeB8ofASTM,nowknownasProgramNo.1.ThelotofpanelsrequiringafirstcoatingofbuffedWattstypenickel,followedbyasecondcoatingofthesamenickel,presentedaproblem.Onehadtocleanandactivatethefirstbuffednickelsurfacesothatthebuffedsurfacewouldnotbedestroyed,butatthesametimewouldinsureadequateadhesionofthesecondnickelcoating.Weknewcathodicalkalicleaningandastronghydrochloricaciddipwouldfavoractivationofthebuffednickelsurfaceandadhesionofthesecondnickelcoating.Wedidnotknowthequantityofcurrentrequiredtoaccomplishthis.InourlaboratoryevaluationofthecyclewekeptincreasingtheampereminutesofcathodiccleaninguntilasshowninCycle1ofTable2withtwoseparatetreatmentsof75Amin/ft2each,followedbyathreeminutedipin50volumepercenthydrochloricacid,weobtainedgoodadhesionofnickelonthebuffednickelsurface.Theadhesiononthebackofthetestpanelwherethesteelhadonlybeenroughpolishedandthefirstnickelcoatwasunbuffedwasstillverypoor.Bytheninsertingbetweenthetwocathodiccleaningstepsa15Amin/ft2anodicetchin30percentbyweightsulfuricacidasshowninCycle2,weobtainedexcellentadhesionofthesecondnickelcoatingonboththefrontandbackofatestpanel.BythusapplyingthequantitativeconceptofFaraday'sLawstocleaning,wedevelopedasatisfactorycycleanditisnowamatterofrecordthatthepanelssopreparedperformedwellwhentestedoutdoors.

    Table2Cleaningcyclesfornickelplatingoverbuffednickel.*

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 10/17

    Nickelplatingovernickelreruns

    Defectivenickelchromiumplatedsteelparts,suchasbumpers,arefrequentlysalvagedbyfirststrippingthechromium,thenpolishingoutthedefectsandrenickelplating.Variouscyclesareuseddependingtoalargedegreeuponthetreatmentsavailableinagivenplatinginstallation.ThefollowingillustrateshowFaraday'sLawswereappliedinonecaseforevaluatingacleaningcycleforthispurpose.

    Table3Cleaningcyclesfornickelplatingoverpolishednickel.*

    TwocleaningcyclesAandBinTable3werefirstevaluated.Omittinganyreferencetorinsinginbetweentreatments,bothcyclesincludedaoneminutealkalisoakand30A

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 11/17

    min/ft2ofcathodicelectrocleaningwitha15second2Nhydrochloricaciddippriortonickelplating.TheonlydifferencebetweenthetwocycleswasthatBhadinadditiona35Amin/ft2anodicelectrocleaningstepinsertedaheadoftheaciddip.CycleAthereforehadbut30Amin/ft2cathodiccleaningwhileCycleBhadatotalof65Amin/ft2ofelectrocleaning,thelast54percentofwhichwasanodic.InspiteofthisadditionalelectrocleaningadhesionbetweenthefirstandsecondnickelcoatingswhenusingCycleBwasratedpoorwhileAwasratedgood.

    AthirdCycleCwasthenevaluatedinwhichthefirsttwotreatmentstepswerecathodicelectrocleaningforacombinedtotalof70Amin/ft2.Thiswasfollowedbythesame15second2Nhydrochloricaciddippriortonickelplating.CycleCgaveexcellentadhesionbetweenthetwonickelcoatingscomparedtoCycleAwhichonlyratedgood.Thisdifferencewasobtainedbysubstitutingacathodicelectrocleanerforthealkalisoakinstep1ofCycleA,andtherebyincreasingthequantityofcathodiccleaningfrom30to70Amin/ft2.

    Platingbimetalsurfaces

    Whenplatingrerunsofnickelplatedsteelpartsacomplicationarisesif,inremovingthenickelcoatingdefectsbypolishing,steelareasareexposed,becauseoptimumadhesiononsteelisfavoredbyanodictreatmentswhilecathodictreatmentsarebestfornickel.Agoodcompromiseinvolvestheuseofananodicelectrocleaningtreatmentfollowedbyananodicacidtreatment,acathodicelectrocleaningtreatmentandahydrochloricaciddipasshowninColumn2ofTable4.Thelastthreetreatmentsallactivatethenickel,thusfavoringadhesionwhenplated.Thecathodicelectrocleaningwhichisunfavorabletosteelshouldpreferablybewithalessquantityofcurrentthantheanodicelectrocleaning.Theanodicacidtreatmentwhichisbeneficialtoadhesiononbothnickelandsteelshouldalwaysemployagreaterquantityofcurrent,thaneitherofthealkalineelectrocleaningtreatments.Therequiredampereminutespersquarefootforeachelectrolytictreatmentshouldbedeterminedbytesttoobtainoptimumadhesion.

    Therearemanyothercasesofplatingovertwodifferentmetalsononeobjectinwhichdifficultyisexperienced.OnecasewhereFaraday'sLawswereappliedinvolvedtheplatingofbrasspartswithsolderedjoints.ThecleaningcyclethatprovedmostsuccessfulasshowninColumn3ofTable4consistedoffoursteps,namely,asoakcleaner,90Amin/ft2inacathodicelectrocleaner,195Amin/ft2ina20Bcathodic

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 12/17

    sulfuricacidtreatment,and120Amin/ft2inacopperstrike.Itisnecessarytousesufficientampereminutespersquarefootintheelectrolytictreatmentstoreducetheoxidesformedinsolderinginordertogetadherentplatedcoatings.Theappearanceofthesurfaceaftertheacidtreatmentmaybefarfrompleasing,butthisinnowayimpairstheappearanceorqualityofplatedcoatingswhichmaybeapplied.

    PlatingStelliteandHastalloyC

    InoneengineeringapplicationrequiringadherentnickelplatingonStellite,Faraday'sLawswereagainappliedtoadvantageinthedevelopmentofthepreparatorycleaningcycleasshowninColumn4ofTable4.Thedesiredresultswerefinallyobtainedwithacycleinvolvingtreatmentsof200Amin/ft2ofanodicelectrocleaning,50Amin/ft2ofanodic50volumepercentsulfuricacid,a5seconddipin10volumepercenthydrochloricacidandaWood'snickelchloridestrikeof300Amin/ft2priortoplating.

    ThissamecyclealsowasusedsuccessfullyforadherentlyplatingsomeHastalloyCandCarballoyparts.

    Table4Cleaningcyclesforplating

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 13/17

    Platingtheexoticmetals

    Aqualifyingwordisinorderwithrespecttocleaningtheexoticmetalspriortoplating.Theirchemistryissodifferentfromthemorecommonbasismetalsthatothertreatments,specificallyforagivenmetal,mayhavetobeadded.Thisistheareainwhichmuchremainstobelearned.However,totheextentthatelectrolytictreatmentsareinvolved,theapplicationofFaraday'sLawshasprovenfruitful.

    Inconclusion,maywesummarizeasfollows:

    Assumingtheremovalofthevaryingamountsofmanydifferentorganicsoilsinpreliminarycleaningsteps,thesubsequentelectrolyticcleaningandactivatingtreatmentsdetermineboththeadhesionandqualityoftheplatedcoating.

    Therearethreeelectrolytictreatments,buildingblockssotospeak,commonlyusedindevelopingasuccessfulcycle:

    1. Electrolyticalkalicleaning.2. Anacidtreatment,frequentlyelectrolytic.3. Astrike(usuallyWood'snickelchloridestrike),acathodictreatment,if

    allowableandnecessary.Wewoulddiscouragethepracticeofsimplycopyingspecifictreatmentsoracombinationofstepsasreportedintheliteraturewhensearchingforacycletoperformadifficultjobofcleaningbeforeplating.Oneverygoodreasonisthefactthatjustchangingaproprietarycleanermaychangetheresults.Butthen,therearemanyotherreasons.

    Onthebasisofoursuccess,werecommendinsteadtheapplicationofFaraday'sLawstoalltheelectrolytictreatmentstepsinthedevelopmentofanycycleandtothedegreenecessarytoattainthedesiredadhesionandquality.

    OnlytotheextenttowhichthisispracticedcanonelearntoappreciatethefullsignificanceofFaraday'sLawsasappliedtocleaningbeforeplating.

    References

    1.W.W.Stout,"Secret,"ChryslerCorporation,Detroit(1947).

    2.F.K.Savage,A.K.GrahamandE.P.Strothman,MaterialsandMethods,August1952.

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 14/17

    3.A.K.Graham,Trans.Inst.Met.Finishing,31,259266(1954).

    AboutDr.A.KennethGraham(fromthebiographyprintedin1959atthetimeofhisreceivingtheAESScientificAchievementAward)

    Dr.A.KennethGrahamwasborninPhiladelphia,December25,1896.Heattendedthepublicschools.UpongraduatingfromtheCentralHighSchoolin1915,hewasawardedaCityscholarshiptotheUniversityofPennsylvania.HegraduatedwithaB.S.degreeinChemicalEngineeringinJune1919,afterhavingservedtenmonthsin1918withtheU.S.MarinesinWorldWarI.

    HethenworkedintheresearchdepartmentoftheScovillMfg.Co.,Waterbury,Conn,fortwoyears.DuringthistimehemetandworkedwithGeorgeB.Hogaboom.Thiswasthebeginningofalifelongfriendship.ItwasthroughthisassociationthatDr.Grahambecameinterestedinelectroplatinganddecidedtospecializeinthisfield.

    SincetherewasnomoderntextonplatinguntilBlumandHogaboompublishedtheirbookin1923,Dr.Grahamdecidedthebestwaytolearnaboutplatingwastoworkatit.Thishedidasaplater'shelperfromOctober1920untilJuly1921firstattheHartfordSterlingCo.,Philadelphia,andthenattheWelsbachCo.,Gloucester,N.J.

    Thesummerof1921,Dr.GrahamstudiedmetallographyatColumbiaUniversity.ThiswasfollowedbyfiveyearsinthegraduateschooloftheUniversityofPennsylvania,duringwhichtimeheservedasInstructorinChemistryandcompletedworkleadingtoatechnicaldegreeofCh.E.andgraduatedegreesofM.S.andPh.D.

    Afterasixmonthboutwithanulcer,Dr.GrahamdeliveredhisfirstpaperbeforetheAESattheconventioninNewarkinJune1926,forwhichhelaterreceivedamedalaward.

    HethenjoinedtheHansonVanWinkleCompanyofNewark,N.J.andbecameassociatedwithGeorgeHogaboomforthesecondtime.HeinstalledalaboratoryatNewarkandlateratMatawan,N.J.,whentheHansonCompanyjoinedwithMunning.Duringthisperiodthesimplifiedmethodsofanalysisforplatingbathsweredeveloped,thecourseforplaterswasfirstoffered,thestandardsolutionsforanalysesweremadeavailableforplaters,andthezincaluminumanode,whichlaterbecamepatented,wasdeveloped.

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 15/17

    Startinginthefallof1928,Dr.Grahamheldthefollowingpositions:

    UniversityofPennsylvania,Philadelphia,Pa.,InstructorandAssistantProfessorinChemicalEngineering,September1928toFebruary1937.KennethGraham&Associates,Jenkintown,Pa.,ConsultingEngineer,July1936toJune1942.WarProductionBoard,Washington,D.C.,PlatingConsultantandDeputyChief,ProductsBranch,ConservationDivision,June1942toJune1943.HoudailleHersheyCorp.,Decatur,Ill.,DirectorofResearchandDevelopment,GarfieldDivision,June1943toAugust1944.Graham,Crowley&Associates,Inc.,(laterbecomingGraham,Savage&Associates,Inc.),Jenkintown,Pa.,President,September1944todate[asofthiswritinginJune1959Ed.].

    Dr.GrahamjoinedtheNewarkBranchoftheAESin1926.In1928,hetransferredtothePhiladelphiaBranch.HeorganizedandtaughtthefirstchemistryclassforthePhiladelphiaBranchoftheAES.HehaswonthreegoldmedalawardsforpapersfromtheAES.HeservedasExecutiveSecretaryoftheSocietyfrom1945to1951,duringwhichtimethemonthlypublicationwaschangedfromthesmallsizeMonthlyReviewtothepresentformatofPlating.HewaselectedanHonoraryMemberofthePhiladelphiaBranchin1957.

    HeisalsoamemberoftheInstituteofMetalFinishing,ASTM,ACS,AIChE,AssociationofConsultingChemistsandChemicalEngineers,Inc.,andTheElectrochemicalSociety.HehasbeenactiveoncommitteesofmostofthesesocietiesandservedasmanagerandvicepresidentofTheElectrochemicalSocietyforelevenyears.

    Hehaspublishedoverfortytechnicalpapers,obtainedseveralpatents,contributedchapterstoModernElectroplatingbyGray,theACSMonographonCopperbyButts,andtheElectroplatingEngineeringHandbook,forwhichhealsoservedasEditorinChief.

    CommentsarereviewedbymoderatorsbeforetheyappeartoensuretheymeetProductsFinishingssubmissionguidelines.

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 16/17

    0Comments ProductsFinishing Login1

    Share SortbyBest

    Startthediscussion

    Bethefirsttocomment.

    Subscribe AddDisqustoyoursited Privacy

    Recommend

    Youmightalsolike:

    OmegasonicsLaunchesRebrandedLogo,Website,Tagline

    AbsorbentSpongeMaterialsEaseSurfaceCoating,Cleaning,Dehydrating

    ManufacturingManagementSoftwareEasesDataCollectiononMultipleDevices

    HighvolumeMaterialHandlingSystemUsesLessSpacethanMonorailSystems

    2

    TheVoiceoftheFinishingIndustrySince1936CopyrightGardnerBusinessMedia,Inc.2015

  • 4/23/2015 FaradaysLawAppliedtoCleaning:ProductsFinishing

    http://www.pfonline.com/articles/faradayslawappliedtocleaning 17/17