familly settlement or partition does not amount to transfer air 1966 sc 323

12

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 12 PETITIONER: RAM CHARAN DAS Vs. RESPONDENT: GIRJANANDINI DEVI AND ORS. DATE OF JUDGMENT: 20/04/1965 BENCH: MUDHOLKAR, J.R. BENCH: MUDHOLKAR, J.R. SARKAR, A.K. BACHAWAT, R.S. CITATION: 1966 AIR 323 1965 SCR (3) 841 CITATOR INFO : F 1971 SC1041 (8) R 1972 SC1279 (10) F 1976 SC 807 (14,17,40) ACT: U.P. Court of Wards Act, 1912 (Act 4 of 1912), s. 37(a)--Family’ Settlement whether amounts to transfer or creation of interest in property within the meaning of section. Compromise in suit--Document recording compromise whether amounts to family settlement--Monies paid by one of the parties under the document-Other parties whether estopped from challenging its validity--Party receiving benefit under document--Whether can challenge its validity. HEADNOTE: C’s property passed under his Will, drawn in 1883, to K and M who were brothers. M died and K entered into possession of his share also. On K’s death in 1922 his mother entered into possession of the whole property. She gave over the management of the property to the Court of Wards under s. 10 of the U.P. Court of Wards Act, 1912. The daughter of M however with the consent of K’s mother got her father’s share released from the management of the Court of Wards in her favour. In 1932 G, sister’s son of K, filed a suit in which he challenged the release of M’s share in favour of his daughter. Two other suits were filed in respect of the property by descendants of C’s brother who as collaterals claimed to be next reversioners to the property. The plaintiff in one of these suits was the present appellant; in the other suit the plaintiff was his brother. In these suits a declaration was sought that G and M’s daughter had no rights in the properties in question. G, M’s daughter. K’s mother and the Court of Wards were made parties to these suits. Both these suits were cornpromised. The suit of the present appellant was compromised by ,a document Ex. Y-13, to which, among others, the appellant, G, and K s mother were parties. G had withdrawn his own suit shortly before. Acting on the document Ex. Y-13 G paid monies to the Court of Wards to clear his liabilities and get released from its management the properties in question.

Upload: sridhara-babu-n-

Post on 05-Apr-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents

0 download

Report

Download

Embed Size (px):

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 1/12

Page 2: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 2/12

Page 3: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 3/12

Page 4: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 4/12

Page 5: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 5/12

Page 6: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 6/12

Page 7: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 7/12

Page 8: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 8/12

Page 9: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 9/12

Page 10: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 10/12

Page 11: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 11/12

Page 12: Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

7/31/2019 Familly Settlement or Partition Does Not Amount to Transfer Air 1966 Sc 323

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/familly-settlement-or-partition-does-not-amount-to-transfer-air-1966-sc-323 12/12

OM, 323 C, 323 L, 323 LD, 323 CX, 325 LX, 325 LDX, 2005-01

louiscandell.com - Louis Candell...Bmm/.323" 338/.338" 3S,'.3S8" g.3mmL366" nosler Partition-HG Handgun Hunting Bullets noslerg Partition-HG"' designed to deliver a high degree of

· 322-89 322-90 323-1 323-2 323-3 323 4 323 —5 323- 6 323 323 -8 323- 9 323- 10 323- 11 323- 12 323- 13 323- 14 Survey locating plot of ground deeded to

Magazine Familly Torah N°11 - Spécial Hechvan

Familly Torah N°02 - Spécial Tou Bichvat

Magazine Familly Torah N°10 - Spécial Tichrei

Betriebssysteme, Rechnernetze und verteilte Systeme 1 ...€¦ · Partition 1 Betriebssystem Partition 2 Partition 3 Partition 4 . BSRvS1: 07 – Interprozesskommunikation 25 Adressbindung

Partition Managerâ„¢ 9 - PARAGON Software Group - partition

We're a happy familly #2 Chamonix

Magazine Familly Torah N°07 - Spécial Tamouz

GAMES FAMILLY 3000 in 1 - Chabanis Jeux …...GAMES FAMILLY 3000 in 1 52 After Burner II After Burner II Sega 1525 Mister Viking 53 Aggressors of Dark Kombat / Tsuukai GANGAN Koushinkyoku

Refinement of Some Partition Inequalities Partitions, The Partition Counting Function Restricted Partition Functions Ferrers Diagram, Durfee Square Partition Generating Functions Partition

MARRIAGE AND THE FAMILLY: Economic Issues and Application Chapter 4

MY FAMILLY PICS

UBICC Manuscript 323-2-323

Lesson 4 Familly

A COMPLETE PRODUCTS FAMILLY FOR THE BEST ANTI-CORROSION SOLUTION Stops time!

Partition function Applications of Partition function What

Hwai Ang Youth Fellowship Familly Letter

Familly Torah N°04 - Spécial Pessah

Download Active@ Partition Manager Help (PDF) - …pcdisk.com/download/partman_manual.pdf · | Partition Manager Overview | 4 Partition Manager Overview Partition Manager is advanced

Partition Assistant User Manual - Partition Manager … ® ®Partition Assistant 6.5 Welcome About AOMEI Partition Assistant AOMEI Partition Assistant is a highly-efficient, easy-to-use

IBM i Partition Mobiltypublic.dhe.ibm.com/.../14_IBMi_Partition_Mobility.pdf · –Active Partition Mobility: Active Partition Mobility is the actual movement of a running partition

Filegroup “Stage A” Filegroup “Stage A” Filegroup “A” Partition 1,2 Filegroup “B” Partition 3,4 Filegroup “C” Partition 5,6 Filegroup “D” Partition

Partition de l'étude de Chopin - Sheet MusicTitle Partition de l'étude de Chopin Author Partitions-piano.fr Subject Partition piano Keywords Partition, Piano, Partition piano, piano

Familly Torah N°03 - Spécial Pourim

TECHNOLOGY INTEGRATED INTO PARTITION · glazed partition, OMEGA - classic framed partition or RAVA® - the trendy, frameless partition with negative gap. Learn more about our partition

new familly dog

Familly Killer 4, reto fancine 2012

Descubre el folleto informativo de "Pinturas de la Rubell Familly Collection"

Magazine Familly Torah N°08 - Spécial Av

IPL, 323 C, 323 L, 323 LD, 323 R, 323 RJ, 325 Cx, 325 Lx

prélude en do majeur de bach : partition piano BWV …...Title prélude en do majeur de bach : partition piano BWV 846 Author Partition-piano.fr Subject Partition piano Keywords "Partition,

Lion-ours Familly 23hBD Rough

Familly Killer 3