external audit services - broward county, florida · external audit services may 30, 2017 ... 115...
TRANSCRIPT
Scoring Summary SheetCombination Initial and Final Evaluation Meeting
R2112554P2External Audit Services
May 30, 2017
Firm Name George Tablack Kathie-Ann Ulett Helena James-Rendleman Linda Levinson Michael Novar Total Ranking
BCA Watson Rice LLP 66.00 79.00 67.00 93.00 71.00 376.00 4
Cherry Bekaert LLP 94.50 82.50 81.50 91.50 87.50 437.50 2
RSM US LLP 96.97 95.97 89.97 96.97 96.97 476.85 1
S. Davis & Associates, P.A. 84.61 82.61 69.61 94.61 88.61 420.05 3
115 S. Andrews Avenue, Room GC430, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Scoring Sheet
Combination Initial and Final Evaluation Meeting
R2112554P2 External Audit Services
May 30, 2017
115 S. Andrews Avenue, Room GC430, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Evaluation Criteria - Project Specific Criteria Maximum BCA Watson Cherry Bekaert RSM US LLP
(Complete text of questions provided separately) Points Rice LLP LLP
I. ABILITY OF PROFESSIONAL PERSONNEL (Total Maximum 30 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 1 15 /() )Li !< See Evaluation Criteria - question 2 10 7 /() ID See Evaluation Criteria - question 3 5 _j-- .!:,..- s-
II. ABILITY to FURNISH the REQUIRED SERVICES/PROJECT APPROACH
(Total Maximum 30 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 4 10 -3 9 } /j
See Evaluation Criteria - question 5 5 .1 -_!::> -~
See Evaluation Criteria - question 6 5 3 ~ -..r See Evaluation Criteria - question 7 5 L/ s-- ~
I
See Evaluation Criteria - question 8 5 L/ s- ..5-I
Ill. EXPERIENCE/PAST PERFORMANCE - COMPANY PROFILE for PRIME and SUBCONTRACTORS
(Total Maximum 20 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 9 10 ,_.] 9 In '
See Evaluation Criteria - question 1 O 10 s /6 /0 POINTS POINTS POINTS
IV. PRICE ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING
See Evaluation Criteria - Pricing 20 ~o I 1. 50 /{p,q'f TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE
CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING
TOTAL SCORE WILL BE ENTERED BY PURCHASING Max 100 &; le qf,5 q~,q7 One Hundred
George Tablack
_/ ) ~ ,I A
Sign a~ / / /~ /~r ,,, L
v v
S. Davis & Associates, P.A.
JI ~
s--
~ . ~·
~ s-L/ '"1--~
7 7 POINTS
ENTERED BY PURCHASING
/q,/p/ TOTAL SCORE
CALCULATED BY PURCHASING
~~, w I
Scoring Sheet Combinat ion Initial and Final Evaluation Meeting
R2112554P2 External Audit Services
May 30, 201 7
115 S. A ndrews Avenue, Room GC430, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Evaluation C r iteria - Project Specific Criteria Max imum SCA Watson Cherry Bekaert RSM US LLP
(Complete text of questions provided separately) Points Rice LLP LLP
I. ABILITY OF PROFESSIONAL PERSONNEL (Total Maximum 30 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 1 15 I() )'2. is See Evaluation Criteria - question 2 10 g 8 )0
See Evaluation Criteria - question 3 5 W- 5 s-II. ABILITY to FURNISH the REQUIRED
SERVICES/PROJECT APPROACH (Total Maximum 30 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 4 10 (p / C{
See Evaluation Criteria - question 5 5 Ll 5 G See Evaluation Criteria - question 6 5 3 3 5 See Evaluation Criteria - question 7 5 5 ~ s See Evaluation Criteria - question 8 5 3 ~ 5
Ill. EXPERIENCE/PAST PERFORMANCE - COMPANY PROFILE for PRIME and SUBCONTRACTORS
(Total Maximum 20 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - quest ion 9 10 7 8 10 See Evaluation Criteria - question 10 10 q \6 t o
POINTS POINTS POINTS IV. PRICE ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY
PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING
See Evaluation Criteria - Pricing 20 ~o 17.50 /(.p,q1 TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE
CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING
Max 100 ib~ 'l)~ ,50 '-fb ,51 ~1
- - -TOTAL SCORE WILL BE ENTERED BY PURCHASING I I .... I . , If - - 1 One Hundred .. . ....... r~ I 'V ' I rth0
.,___
/\Kathie-Ann Ul_:tt I
"' r-.J I \ ' I ) ~ ' Sign~ ~ ~L [ I J
/ )
( (/ ., \ v v I .v / ~ \J
S. Davis & Associates, P.A.
11
8' s-
7 s -::s w 3
7 10
POINTS ENTERED BY PURCHASING
,q,{p/ TOTAL SCORE
CALCULATED BY PURCHASING
,~' ~,, I - 1 r lk' )G;.;
'---
Scoring Sheet Combination Initial and Final Evaluation Meeting
R2112554P2 External Audit Services
May 30, 2017
115 S. Andrews Avenue, Room GC430, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Evaluation Criteria - Project Specific Criteria Maximum SCA Watson Cherry Bekaert RSM US LLP
(Complete text of questions provided separately) Points Rice LLP LLP
I. ABILITY OF PROFESSIONAL PERSONNEL (Total Maximum 30 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 1 15 g /( 13
See Evaluation Criteria - question 2 10 =t- g q See Evaluation Criteria - question 3 5 3 tr- s-
II. ABILITY to FURNISH the REQUIRED SERVICES/PROJECT APPROACH
(Total Maximum 30 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 4 10 s- ~ 9 See Evaluation Criteria - question 5 5 3 - Lr <.S
See Evaluation Criteria - question 6 5 3 3 Lt-See Evaluation Criteria - question 7 5 3 ~
,,...,
~
5 3 {" -See Evaluation Criteria - question 8 ~ Ill. EXPERIENCE/PAST PERFORMANCE - COMPANY
PROFILE for PRIME and SUBCONTRACTORS (Total Maximum 20 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 9 10 -~ ~ 10 See Evaluation Criteria - question 10 10 ';}· ~ q
POINTS POINTS POINTS IV. PRICE ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY
PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING
See Evaluation Criteria - Pricing 20 ~ o I '1 .5 0 llt, . q1 TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE
CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING
TOTAL SCORE WILL BE ENTERED BY PURCHASING Max 100 0 '7 <g /, 50 <tq,q '7 One Hundred
Helena James-Rendleman
Signature ~~AA J_ v l'V
v
S. Davis & Associates, P.A.
~
":t-3
~ 4-J 4-3
s-:r
POINTS ENTERED BY PURCHASING
/q,tp ) TOTAL SCORE
CALCULATED BY PURCHASING
(oq, w I
Scoring Shee t
Combination Initial and Final Evaluation M e eting
R21 12554 P 2
E x ternal Aud it S e rv ices May 30, 2017
11 5 S. Andrews Avenue, Room GC430, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Evaluation Criteria - Project Specific Criteria M a x imum BCA Watson Cherry Bekaert RS M US LLP
(Complete text of questions provided separately) Points Rice LLP LLP
I. ABILITY OF PROFESSIONAL PERSONNEL (Total Maximum 30 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 1 15 IS- /:) 1~-
See Evaluation Criteria - question 2 10 /() /;) /)
J J -See Evaluation Criteria - question 3 5 ~
II. ABILITY to FURNISH the REQUIRED SERVICES/PROJECT APPROACH
(Total Maximum 30 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 4 10 /~ lo /0 See Evaluation Criteria - quest ion 5 5 ~ ~ s--See Evaluation Criteria - question 6 5 ~ L/ ~tn See Evaluation Criteria - question 7 5 !/ f/" --_j
See Evaluation Criteria - question 8 5 5 s :5 Ill. EXPERIENCE/PAST PERFORMANCE - COMPANY
PROFILE for PRIME and SUBCONTRACTORS (Total Maximum 20 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - quest ion 9 10 1 x /(} See Evaluation Criteria - question 1 O 10 /} /tl ~
POINTS POINTS POINTS IV. PRICE ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY
PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING
See Evaluation Criteria - Pricing 20 8,o 11.5D /{p,q'1 TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE
CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING
TOTAL SCORE WILL BE ENTERED BY PURCHASING Max 100 q3 9!1 50 Cff.o,q•7 One Hundred
Linda Levinson
A ' /
l/h/lf (._ {ff Signature
/ ' / / f ; -
S. Davis & Assoc iates, P.A.
1< /.I
---~
/?! ,.--
s
c/ ~ s
7 ~
POINTS ENTERED BY PURCHASING
/q,{p) TOTAL SCORE
CALCULATED BY PURCHASING
q+,0 I
Scoring Sheet Combination Initial and Final Evaluation Meeting
R2112554P2 External Audit Services
May 30, 2017
115 S. Andrews Avenue, Room GC430, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Evaluation Criteria - Proje ct Specific Criteria Maximum BCA Watson Cherry B ekaert RSM US LLP
(Complete text of questions provided separately) Points Rice LLP LLP
I. ABILITY OF PROFESSIONAL PERSONNEL (Total Maximum 30 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 1 15 IV ,~ 15 See Evaluation Criteria - question 2 10 1- 8 1 b See Evaluation Criteria - question 3 5 2- L/ 5
II. ABILITY to FURNISH the REQUIRED SERVICES/PROJECT APPROACH
(Total Maximum 30 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 4 10 s q I{)
See Eva luation Criteria - question 5 5 3 Lf 5 See Evaluation Criteria - question 6 5 ~ L/ s See Evaluation Criteria - question 7 5 3 y 5 See Evaluation Criteria - question 8 5 3 z.J s
Ill. EXPERIENCE/PAST PERFORMANCE - COMPANY PROFILE for PRIME and SUBCONTRACTORS
(Total Maximum 20 Points)
See Evaluation Criteria - question 9 10 5 °! l () See Evaluation Criteria - question 10 10 ID ) c l 0
POINTS POINTS POINTS IV. PRICE ENTERED BY ENTERED BY ENTERED BY
PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING
See Evaluation Criteria - Pricing 20 ao /'71 50 /lo ,q{ TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE TOTAL SCORE
CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY CALCULATED BY PURCHASING PURCHASING PURCHASING
TOTAL SCORE WILL BE ENTERED BY PURCHASING Max 100 7/ <t 7, 50 q{o,q'f One Hundred
Michael Novar
Signature ~H /;w~-~
S. Dav is & Associates, P.A.
I t..f
~-a fJ L(
g'
Lf
'-{ y
'-t
~ /0
POINTS ENTERED BY PURCHASING
,q,t_p/ TOTAL SCORE
CALCULATED BY PURCHASING
~g , 0 I