eu = ussr redux?

10
!"#$%&' )#"*+,- ./ 0 /!!) )#1234 INTRODUCTION 56 ,7%8 8"#$%&' +#"*+,9 :# &6&';<# ,7# $*''&"8# *= ,7# ! *>%#, /6%*69 &61 1%8$#+6 ,#6 $*+# $&28#8 *= ,7# $ +&87 *= ,7# /!!)? @# A&B# & !"#$% '( !"#$% )"*!+,#-"$ .#%/ 01,"!2 %"3+(9 &61 $*A# ,* ,7# $*6$'28%*6 ,7&, %,8 8 %,2&,%*6 1*#8 6*, 1%==#+ &'' ,7&, A2$7 :%,7 ,7&, *= ,7# %A"'*1%6C /!!)? D8 & A&,,#+ *= =&$,9 ,7#  "&+&''#''8 &+# *=,#6 8,&+,' %6C? E7#+# &+# "'#6,; *= 1%8F2%#,%6C #>*'2,%*68 C*%6C *6 %6 .2+*"# ,*1&;- ,7# +%*,8 %6 ,7# G55H! $*26,+%#89 ,7# &""#&+%6C';  "#+A&6#6, $+%8%8 %6 ,7# I&6B%6C :*+'19??? J&%6, &%6%6C ,7# 8,&,28 F2* %8 6* '*6C#+ "*88%I'#9 ,7&, A2$7 %8 $'#&+? K2, :7&, :%'' ,7# $7&6C# '**B '%B#4 @%'' %, I# & 8 ,#&1; +#=*+A9 *+ *6 ,7# $*6,+&+; & 8211#6 $+&87 *= ,7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*6 & 61 ,7# #2+*4 !*A#*6# :7* %8 $*6>%6$#1 ,7# '&,,#+ :%'' 7&""#69 %8 ,7# =&A*28 )288%&6 1%88%1#6,  L'&1%A%+ K2B*:8B;? 56 & MNNO 8"##$7 P*6# ;#&+ I#=*+# ,7# =%6&6$%&' $+%8%8 7%,Q9 K2B*:8B; A&1# ,7# =*''*:%6C $*AA#6,- R  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 ,+#618 $&6 I# 1%8$#+6#1 %6 .2+*"#? D=,#+ +#&1%6C ,7%8 $*A"&+%8*69 ,7# +#&1#+ :%'' I# &I'# ,* 1+&: 7%8 *:6 $*6$'28%*68 &8 ,* 7*: 8%A%'&+ ,7# ./ ,*1&; +#&''; %8 ,* ,7# =&%'%6C /!!)? T#+# %8 & 82AA&+; *= :7&, =*''*:8- 1.  @7; 1%1 ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6 $*''&"8#4  @ ',#28 "=2,=#2. "8 %/2 5+-% (2+,- "8 % /2 >??A 2.  E7# G&,,#+6 *= & U*''&"8#  B"#$% '( !"#$% )"*!+,#-"$ .#%/ %/2 0> %"3+( 3.  U*6$'28%*6 CD )"$%,#'1%#$7 8+)%",- )"*!+,23 E  7"53"$"*#):'2 C

Upload: dtuur

Post on 01-Mar-2018

246 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: EU = USSR Redux?

7/25/2019 EU = USSR Redux?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-ussr-redux 1/10

!"#$%&' )#"*+,- ./ 0 /!!) )#1234

INTRODUCTION

56 ,7%8 8"#$%&' +#"*+,9 :# &6&';<# ,7# $*''&"8# *= ,7# !*>%#,

/6%*69 &61 1%8$#+6 ,#6 $*+# $&28#8 *= ,7# $+&87 *= ,7# /!!)?

@# A&B# & !"#$% '( !"#$% )"*!+,#-"$ .#%/ 01,"!2 %"3+(9 &61

$*A# ,* ,7# $*6$'28%*6 ,7&, %,8 8%,2&,%*6 1*#8 6*, 1%==#+ &'' ,7&,

A2$7 :%,7 ,7&, *= ,7# %A"'*1%6C /!!)? D8 & A&,,#+ *= =&$,9 ,7#

 "&+&''#''8 &+# *=,#6 8,&+,'%6C?

E7#+# &+# "'#6,; *= 1%8F2%#,%6C #>*'2,%*68 C*%6C *6 %6 .2+*"#

,*1&;- ,7# +%*,8 %6 ,7# G55H! $*26,+%#89 ,7# &""#&+%6C';

 "#+A&6#6, $+%8%8 %6 ,7# I&6B%6C :*+'19??? J&%6,&%6%6C ,7# 8,&,28

F2* %8 6* '*6C#+ "*88%I'#9 ,7&, A2$7 %8 $'#&+?

K2, :7&, :%'' ,7# $7&6C# '**B '%B#4 @%'' %, I# & 8,#&1; +#=*+A9

*+ *6 ,7# $*6,+&+; & 8211#6 $+&87 *= ,7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*6 &61

,7# #2+*4

!*A#*6# :7* %8 $*6>%6$#1 ,7# '&,,#+ :%'' 7&""#69 %8 ,7# =&A*28 )288%&6 1%88%1#6,  L'&1%A%+ K2B*:8B;? 56 &

MNNO 8"##$7 P*6# ;#&+ I#=*+# ,7# =%6&6$%&' $+%8%8 7%,Q9 K2B*:8B; A&1# ,7# =*''*:%6C $*AA#6,-

R 4% 5""6- 5#62 .2 +,2 /2+3#$7 %".+,3- -"*2 6#$3 "8 )"55+!-29 -"*2 6#$3 "8 ),#-#-: ;/2 *"-% 5#625( "1%)"*2 #-

%/+% %/2,2 .#55 '2 +$ 2)"$"*#) )"55+!-2 #$ 01,"!29 ./#)/ #$ 312 %#*2 #- '"1$3 %" /+!!2$ .#%/ %/#- 7,".%/ "8

2<!2$-2- +$3 %+<2-: ;/2 #$+'#5#%( %" ),2+%2 + )"*!2%#%#=2 2$=#,"$*2$%9 %/2 "=2,,2715+%#"$ "8 %/2 2)"$"*(9 %/2

'1,2+1),+%#-+%#"$9 #% #- 7"#$7 %" 52+3 %" 2)"$"*#) )"55+!-2: ::: ;/2,2 .#55 '2 + )"55+!-2 "8 %/2 01,"!2+$

>$#"$ !,2%%( *1)/ 5#62 %/2 ?"=#2% >$#"$ )"55+!-23:R

J&+B E:&%6 +#"*+,#1'; 8&%1 ,7&, 7%8,*+; 1*#86S, +#"#&, %,8#'=9 I2, %, 1*#8 +7;A#? 56 ,7%8 8"#$%&' +#"*+,9 :#

8#&+$7 =*+ ,7# =261&A#6,&' $&28#8 ,7&, '#1 ,* ,7# $*''&"8# *= ,7# !*>%#, /6%*69 &61 1#,#$, :7#,7#+ 8%A%'&+ 

,+#618 $&6 I# 1%8$#+6#1 %6 .2+*"#? D=,#+ +#&1%6C ,7%8 $*A"&+%8*69 ,7# +#&1#+ :%'' I# &I'# ,* 1+&: 7%8 *:6

$*6$'28%*68 &8 ,* 7*: 8%A%'&+ ,7# ./ ,*1&; +#&''; %8 ,* ,7# =&%'%6C /!!)?

T#+# %8 & 82AA&+; *= :7&, =*''*:8-

1.   @7; 1%1 ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6 $*''&"8#4

 @ ',#28 "=2,=#2. "8 %/2 5+-% (2+,- "8 %/2 >??A

2.   E7# G&,,#+6 *= & U*''&"8#

 B"#$% '( !"#$% )"*!+,#-"$ .#%/ %/2 0> %"3+(

3.   U*6$'28%*6

CD )"$%,#'1%#$7 8+)%",- )"*!+,23

E  7"53"$"*#):'2  C

Page 2: EU = USSR Redux?

7/25/2019 EU = USSR Redux?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-ussr-redux 2/10

 

V? @TW X5X ET. !YL5.E /Z5YZ UY[[DG!.4

D $#6,+&''; "'&66#1 #$*6*A;

\+*A %,8 I%+,7 %6 V]MM9 &61 '&,#+ #>#6 A*+#9 ,7# /!!) :&8 & $#6,+&''; "'&66#1 #$*6*A;^ ,7# '&+C# =%+A8 :#+#

7#'1 ,* "+*12$,%*6 F2*,&8 I; ,7# &2,7*+%,%#8 P,7# =&A*28 S=%># ;#&+ "'&68SQ? D 62AI#+ *= I&8%$ 8#+>%$#89 82$7

&8 #12$&,%*69 7#&',7 $&+#9 &61 ,7# ,+&68"*+,&,%*6 $*A"&6; D#+*='*,9 &'8* :#+# #6,%+#'; C*>#+6A#6, =261#1?

E7# $*68#F2#6$# *= ,7# &I8#6$# *= "+*=%,8 &61 ,7# $*A"'%$&,#19 *I#1%#6$#_1+%>#6 I2+#&2$+&,%$ 8;8,#A9

$&28#1 !*>%#, $%,%<#68 ,* =%61 ,7#A8#'>#8 %6 & "#+A&6#6, 8,&,# *= #$*6*A%$ $+%8%89 %6 & 8*$%#,; +%=# :%,7

87*+,&C#89 26#A"'*;A#6,9 "*>#+,; &61 =&A%6#? Z*6#,7#'#889 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, =26$,%*6#1 F2%,# :#''9 &8 %, :&8

=261#1 I; ,&3#8 &61 "+*=%,8 =+*A ,7# 8&'# *= 6&,2+&' +#8*2+$#8 82$7 &8 C*'1 &61 *%' ,* ,7# +#8, *= ,7# :*+'1?

J2$7 *= ,7# C+*:,7 *= ,7# !*>%#, #A"%+# :&8 &'8* =%6&6$#1 :%,7 $&87

&61 $+#1%, P+2I'#8Q I; ,7# H*8I&6B9 ,7# $#6,+&' I&6B *= ,7# /!!)9 :%,7

 I+&6$7#8 ,7&, 8,+#,$7#1 &'' *>#+ ,7# 26%*6? 5, :&8 :%,7 ,7# H*8I&6B ,7&,

 "2I'%$ $*A"&6%#89 $*''#$,%># =&+A89 &61 "+%>%'#C#1 %61%>%12&'8 $*2'1

&$F2%+# $+#1%, ,* &$7%#># ,7# "'&68 *= ,7# &2,7*+%,%#8? 5, :&8 &'8* ,7#

H*8I&6B ,7&, "+*>%1#1 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, :%,7 82==%$%#6, '%F2%1%,; ,* :&C#

& 1#$&1# '*6C :&+?

E7# !*>%#, /6%*6S8 )#8*2+$# @&+8

D8 ,7# $*AA26%8, 8;8,#A *= ,7# /!!) 1%1 6*, &''*: =*+ #$*6*A%$

#==%$%#6$; &61 & "+*12$,%># "*"2'&,%*69 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, +#'%#1 *6 ,7#

#3"*+, *= 6&,2+&' +#8*2+$#8 ,* =261 %,8#'=- *%'9 $*&'9 6&,2+&' C&89 8,##'9

C*'1 ? @7#6 ,7# "+*12$,%*6 *= ,7# 6&,%*68S "+%1#9 ,7# V` I%''%*6 I&++#'

)*A&87B%6* =%#'19 8,&+,#1 ,* :&6# %6 V]`O9 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, 8,&+,#1

'**B%6C %6,* 6#: 8*2+$#8 *= +#>#62#- #3"#68%># #3"'*+&,%*6 *= !%I#+%&9

&61 +#8*2+$# $*6=%8$&,%*6 I; A#&68 *= :&+=&+# &61 "*'%,%$&' $*6,+*'?

Y6 $7+%8,A&8 1&; *= V]`]9 ,7# /!!) %6>&1#1 D=C7&6%8,&69 & $*26,+; ,7&, "+*>%1#1 &I261&6, 6&,2+&'

+#8*2+$#89 &8 :#'' &8 &6 #3$#''#6, *"#+&,%6C I&8# :%,7%6 +#&$7 *= ,7# *%'_+%$7 D+&I "#6%682'&? \*+ ,7# 6#3,

6%6# ;#&+89 ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6 :*2'1 =%C7, & :&+ &C&%68, ,7# U5D 82""*+,#1 J2a&7#1##6 *= D=C7&6%8,&6? W#&+';

$*8,- M_b I%''%*6 1*''&+8?

E7# !*>%#, /6%*6 :&8 6*, *6'; #6,&6C'#1 %6 A%'%,&+; :&+=&+#9 I2, &'8* %6 #$*6*A%$ :&+=&+#? D8 c&A#8

 Z*+A&6 1*$2A#6,8 %6 7%8 I**B SE7# Y%' U&+1S9 ,7# 8,&CC#+%6C V]b I%''%*6 I&++#' a2A" %6 V]dd +#"*+,#1 YG.U

*%' +#8#+>#8 :&8 A*8, '%B#'; & =+&212'#6, #3$28# ,* +&A" 2" *%' "+*12$,%*6 &61 %6 ,7%8 :&; 8%C6%=%$&6,'; '*:#+

%,8 "+%$#9 ,728 I*;$*,,%6C ,7# /!!)? E7# +#82',%6C *%' C'2, %61##1 $&28#1 ,7# "+%$# *= $+21# *%' ,* 1+*"9 #>#6

 I; eNf9 :7%$7 :&8 & 1#>&8,&,%6C I'*: =*+ ,7# &'+#&1; :#&B#6#1 !*>%#, #$*6*A;?

D8 & $*68#F2#6$#9 1*''&+ "+*=%,8 *= !*>%#, *%' #3"*+,8 "'2AA#,#19 :7%$7 '#1 ,* & 1%8+2",%*6 *= ,7# =**1

%A"*+, $7&%6? E7# 72C# 1+*" %6 #&+6%6C89 ,7# =**1 87*+,&C#89 &61 ,7# #3"#68%># A#&82+#8 ,* "&,$7 2" ,7#

E  7"53"$"*#):'2  F

G"-'+$6H >??AI- )2$%,+5 '+$6 

Page 3: EU = USSR Redux?

7/25/2019 EU = USSR Redux?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-ussr-redux 3/10

$+%""'#1 #$*6*A; P:%,7 &8 & 8&1 $'%A&3 ,7# E8a#+6*I;' 1%8&8,#+9 $*8,%6C Vb I%''%*6 1*''&+8 &61 #A"'*;%6C

eNN?NNN :*+B#+8Q =%''#1 ,7# I2$B#, ,* ,7# I+%A- ,7# /!!) :&8 >%+,2&''; I&6B+2",?

E7# ,#A"*+&+; 8*'2,%*6 ,7&, :&8 ,7*2C7, *2, ,* "*8,"*6# ,7# "+*I'#A89 :*2'1 '#&1 ,* ,7# 2',%A&,# $*''&"8#?

56='&,%*6 &61 )#>*'2,%*6

X2+%6C ,7# '&,# V]dN89 J*8$*: =%''#1 ,7# 7*'#8 %6 ,7# I21C#, :%,7 +2I'#8 "+%6,#1 *2, *= ,7%6 &%+? D61 A&6;

+2I#'8 :#+# "+%6,#1 %6 ,7*8# 1&;8- %6 V]dN )288%&6 I&6B8 7#'1 VeO I%''%*6 +2I'#8 %6 1#"*8%,^ I; V]d`9 ,7&,

&A*26, 7&1 +%8#6 26,%' MM` I%''%*6? D61 %6 ,7&, ;#&+9 ,7# '%I#+&'%<&,%*6 *= ,7# =%6&6$%&' 8#$,*+ 7&1 *6'; I#C26?

@7#+#&8 I#=*+#9 ,7#+# :&8 *6'; *6# I&6B %6 ,7# /!!) PH*8I&6BQ9 ,7# =%6&6$%&' "#+#8,+*%B& I#F2#&,7#1 VbON

 "+%>&,# I&6B8 I; V]]M?

D, =%+8,9 "+%$# %6='&,%*6 8##A#1 $*6,&%6&I'#9 &8 %, +*8# =+*A

e9`f %6 V]dV ,* VNf %6 V]]N? W#, ,7# $*8,8 *= '%>%6C 1%1 +%8#

=&8,#+ ,7&6 ,7# :&C#89 &61 $%,%<#68 :#+# =&$#1 :%,7 87*+,&C#8

*= A&6; B%618? E7%8 &6C#+#1 ,7# "*"2'&,%*6? E7%8 G%<<& T2,

$*AA#+$%&'  =+*A V]dO %''28,+&,#8 7*: )288%&68 ,7*2C7,

&I*2, ,7#%+ $*26,+;? !,%''9 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, ='&,'; 1#6%#1 ,7#+#

:&8 & =261&A#6,&' "+*I'#A :%,7 %6='&,%*6?

56 &6 &,,#A", ,* B##" ,7# I&6B2", 8;8,#A &='*&,9 ,7# !*>%#,

/6%*6 8*'1 7261+#18 *= ,*68 *= C*'1 &=,#+ V]d]9 %6 #3$7&6C#

=*+ =**1 &61 *,7#+ =&>*+8 *= =*+#%C6 6&,%*68?

J#&6:7%'# ,7# C+2AI'%6C "#+8%8,#19 &61 A*+# &61 A*+# )288%&6 $%>%'%&68 1#A&61#1 %61#"#61#6$# =+*A =&+&:&; J*8$*:? H*+I&$7#>8 SC'&86*8,S P,+&68"&+#6$;9 '#88 $#68*+87%"Q :&8 & =%+8, &,,#A", ,* 87*: $**"#+&,%*6

:%,7*2, C%>%6C 2" ,7# %1#&' *= ,7# !*>%#, .A"%+#? T*:#>#+ ,7%8 :&8 ,* 6* &>&%'9 &61 8**6 ,7# =%+8, 8#$#88%*68

:#+# & =&$,9 &8 8#>#+&' +#"2I'%$8 1#$'&+#1 %61#"#61#6$#?

56 ,7# #619 &'' +#=*+A&,%*6 &,,#A",8 =&%'#1- ,7# /!!) 1#8$#61#1 %6,* $7&*89 &61 %6 Z*>#AI#+ V]]V ,7#

L6#87#B*6*AI&6B %6=*+A#1 ,7# !*>%#, '#&1#+8 ,7&, &'' &>&%'&I'# =2618 7&1 I##6 1#"'#,#1? E7&, :&8 ,7# #61

*= &6 #A"%+# ,7&, 7&1 1#=%6#1 ,7# C'*I&' "*:#+ #F2%'%I+%2A =*+ ,7+## $*68#F2#6, C#6#+&,%*68?

D=,#+ ,7# X%88*'2,%*6- T;"#+%6='&,%*6 %6 .&8,#+6 .2+*"#

E7# 82$$#88*+ *= ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6 :&8 & 8,&,# ,7&, $'&%A#1 a2+%81%$,%*6 *>#+ & 8A&''#+ C#*C+&"7%$&' &+#&-

)288%&? E7%8 6#: "*'%,%$&' #6,%,; ,**B *6 &'' =*+#%C6 1#I,89 &61 '&%1 $'&%A ,* ,7# *>#+8#&8 !*>%#, "+*"#+,%#8?

E7# H*8I&6B :&8 ,+&68=*+A#1 %6 ,7# K&6B *= )288%&9 &61 $#6,+&' I&6B#+ L%B,*+ H#+&8$7#6B* '#=, ,7#

H*8I&6B ,* ,&B# $*AA&61 &8 $7&%+A&6 %6 ,7# 6#: %68,%,2,%*6?

X#8"%,# ,7#%+ 6#:=*261 "*'%,%$&' %61#"#61#6$#9 Ve 6#: "*8,_!*>%#, 8,&,#8 $*6,%62#1 ,* +#'; *6 ,7# A*6#,&+;

26%*6 *= ,7# +2I'# g H*8I&6B? .&$7 *= ,7#A ,7#8# 8,&,#8 =&$#1 ,*2C7 #$*6*A%$ ,%A#89 8%6$# 261#+ ,7# 6#:

 "*'%,%$&' $*68,#''&,%*6 ,7# =*+A#+ !*>%#, $*+"*+&,%*68 82==#+#1 72C# '*88#8? 56 *+1#+ ,* &>*%1 I&6B+2",$%#89

'*$&' C*>#+6A#6,8 %882#1 I*618 ,* '*&6 +2I'#8 =+*A ,7# )288%&6 U#6,+&' K&6B? E7%8 "+*$#88 *= =+##_+%1%6C

'#&1 ,* &6 #6*+A*28 %6$+#&8# %6 ,7# A*6#; 82""';9 &61 & '%B#:%8# #6*+A*28 $*''&"8# *= ,7# >&'2# *= ,7#

E  7"53"$"*#):'2  J

K#6%", G2,+-/)/2$6" +$3 K5+3#*#, B1%#$

Page 4: EU = USSR Redux?

7/25/2019 EU = USSR Redux?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-ussr-redux 4/10

+2I'#?

E7# $*68#F2#6$#8 =*+ ,7# )288%&6 "*"2'&,%*6 :#+# 1%8&8,+*28- ,7# "+%$#8 *= &'' C**18 8*&+#1? D8 ,7# "+%$#

'#>#' +*8#9 ,7# =*+A#+ 8*>%#, 8,&,#8 &8B#1 =*+ #>#+ '&+C#+ '*&68 :%,7 ,7# $#6,+&' I&6B? E7%8 8#'= +#%6=*+$%6C

8"%+&' '#1 ,* &6 %6='&,%*6 *= 2" ,* eNNNf "#+ ;#&+ %6 ,7# "#+%*1 V]]M_V]]h?

@7%'# ,7# +2I'# 7;"#+%6='&,%*6 '&8,#19 *6# 8,&,# &=,#+ ,7# *,7#+ '#=, ,7# A*6#,&+; 26%*6 &61 %68,#&1 %68,&''#1

%,8 *:6 A*6#,&+; 8;8,#A? .>#6,2&'';9 %6 V]]h9 L%B,*+ H#+&87$7#6B* :&8 =%+#1 &8 $7&%+A&6 *= ,7# )288%&6

$#6,+&' I&6B? T%8 +#"'&$#A#6, A&6&C#1 ,* +#%C6 %6 %6='&,%*6 ,* &I*2, VNf "#+ A*6,7?

ET. GDEE.)Z Y\ D UY[[DG!.

E7# F2#8,%*6 :# &+# ,+;%6C ,* &68:#+ 7#+# %8 :7#,7#+ ,7# 8%,2&,%*6 %6 ,7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*6 ,*1&; %8 8%A%'&+ ,*

,7&, *= ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6 %6 ,7# "#+%*1 +%C7, I#=*+# 7#+ 1*:6=&'' &61 ,7# 7;"#+%6='&,%*6? E7%8 %8 &6 %A"*+,&6,

F2#8,%*69 #>#6 ,7*2C7 ,7# ./ A&; 8##A & C%>#6 ,*1&;9 &6 %68,%,2,%*6 ,7&, %8 ,7#+# ,* 8,&;? G*:#+=2' 6&,%*68&61 '&+C# "*'%,%$&' #6,%,%#8 *=,#6 $*A# ,* &6 #61 $*A"'#,#'; 26#3",#$,#1';9 &8 :&8 ,7# $&8# :%,7 ,7# /!!)-

&'A*8, 6* *6# "+#1%$,#1 %,8 $*''&"8#?

@# 7#+# 82A 2" ,7# A*8, %A"*+,&6, =&$,*+8 ,7&, 7&># '#1 ,* ,7# $*''&"8# *= ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6? @# %1#6,%=%#1

,#6 82$7 =&$,*+8-

V? U#6,+&'%8#1 J*6#,&+; !;8,#A

Y6# *= ,7# 8,%"2'&,%*68 =+*A ,7# $*AA26%8, A&6%=#8,* *= J&+3 &61 .6C#'8 :&8 R%/2 )2$%,+5#-+%#"$ "8 *"$2(

+$3 ),23#% #$ %/2 /+$3- "8 %/2 -%+%2R? E7%8 1#A&61 :&8 I+*2C7, %6,* "+&$,%$# I; ,7# /!!)? \+*A V]MV

*6:&+189 ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6S8 8,&,# I&6B9 ,7# H*8I&6B9 ,**B $7&+C# *>#+ ,7# A*6#; 82""';9 &61 +#C2'&,#1 ,7#

=26$,%*6%6C *= ,7# *,7#+ I&6B8 %6 ,7# $*26,+;? /61#+ ,7# !*>%#, /6%*69 ,7# >&'2# *= ,7# +2I'# :&8 $*2"'#1 ,*

,7# >&'2# *= ,7# 1*''&+9 :7%$7 %6 ,2+6 :&8 '**8#'; I&8#1 *6 ,7# >&'2# *= C*'1? D=,#+ V]`V9 ,7# /!!) '%6B#1 ,7#

+2I'# :%,7 & I&8B#1 *= '&+C# @#8,#+6 $2++#6$%#8? 56 *,7#+ :*+189 ,7# +2I'# :&8 =%&, A*6#;9 A*6#; $*>#+#1 I;

6*,7%6C &61 7&>%6C *6'; >&'2# I#$&28# ,7# &2,7*+%,%#8 1#$'&+#1 %, 8*? E7# H*8I&6B *"#+&,#1 :%,7 =+&$,%*6&'

+#8#+>#8- ,7# $+#1%,8 %, #3,#61#1 1%1 6*, $*A# =+*A +#&' #3%8,%6C +#8#+>#89 I2, :#+# A&62=&$,2+#1 *2, *= ,7%6

&%+?

D8 ,&2C7, I; @#%A&+ H#+A&6;9 ,7# A*6*"*'; *6 ,7# $+#&,%*6 *= A*6#; I; *6# 8%6C'# %68,%,2,%*6 A&B#8 %,,#A",%6C =*+ ,7# "*'%,%$&' &61 =%6&6$%&' &2,7*+%,%#8 ,* 8,&+, "+%6,%6C A*6#; +3 5#'#%1*? E7# $+#&,%*6 *= $+#1%,

PA*6#;Q I; ,7# !*>%#, 8,&,# I&6B9 #+*1#1 ,7# +2I'# &61 #>#6,2&''; $&28#1 %, ,* $*''&"8#? E7%8 "+*$#88 *=

%6='&,%*6 #A"*>#+%87#1 &61 &6C#+#1 ,7# "#*"'#9 A&B%6C %, & $+2$%&' $*6,+%I2,%6C =&$,*+ ,* ,7# $*''&"8# *= ,7#

/!!)?

56 .2+*"#9 ,7# A*6#,&+; 8;8,#A %8 &'8* $#6,+&'%<#1? !%6$# V]]d9 ,7#+# %8 ,7# .2+*"#&6 U#6,+&' K&6B9 :%,7

 "*:#+8 8%A%'&+ ,* ,7*8# *= ,7# H*8I&6B9 82$7 &8 +#C2'&,%6C ,7# A*6#; 82""'; &61 $*6,+*''%6C ,7# %6,#+#8,

+&,#8?

56 &11%,%*69 =+*A %,8 %6$#",%*6 ,7# #2+* 7&8 I##6 ,7# 2',%A&,# =%&, $2++#6$;- $*>#+#1 I; 6*,7%6C9 6*, '%6B#1 ,*

E  7"53"$"*#):'2  L

Page 5: EU = USSR Redux?

7/25/2019 EU = USSR Redux?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-ussr-redux 5/10

&6; 6&,%*6 8,&,#9 &61 & >&'2# 8*'#'; I&8#1 *6 S,+28,S P!## [&A=&'288;  V]O]9 G&1%*_!$7%*""&  V]]]9 &61

X2%8#6I#+C  MNNMQ? J*+#*>#+9 ,7# "+&$,%$# *= =+&$,%*6&' +#8#+># I&6B%6C 7&8 I##6 1*A%6&6, %6 @#8,#+6

.2+*"# #>#+ 8%6$# ,7# 1*:6=&'' *= ,7# I&6B *= DA8,#+1&A %6 V`dN? E7%8 %8 :7; .2+*"#&6 I&6B8 &+# 8*

>2'6#+&I'# ,* & 8211#6 $*''&"8#?

M? G'&66#1 .$*6*A;

E7# /!!) #$*6*A; :&8 '&+C#'; S"'&66#1S I; #$*6*A%$ "'&66%6C &C#6$%#8? E7#8# &C#6$%#8 7&61#1 *2,

82I8%1%#8 ,* $*+"*+&,%*68 &61 +#C2'&,#1 ,7#A ,7+*2C7 F2*,&8 &61 *,7#+ A#&68?

E7#8# $*6,%62*28 %6,#+>#6,%*68 $&28#1 ,7# #$*6*A; ,* I#$*A# >#+; +%C%1 &61 I2+#&2$+&,%$- ,7# A&+B#,8 :#+#

A#, :%,7 1&%'; "+*I'#A8 *= *>#+_ &61 261#+"+*12$,%*6 PA%8&''*$&,%*6 *= C**18Q9 &61 ,7# C#6#+&' F2&'%,; *=

,7# C**18 :&8 '*:? K#$&28# *= ,7%89 ,7# )288%&6 "*"2'&,%*6 :&8 "**+ &61 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, :&8 1#"#61#6, *6

%A"*+, *= :#8,#+6 :7#&, &61 A&$7%6#+;?

56 .2+*"# ,*1&;9 ,7# #$*6*A; %8 &'8* +#C2'&,#1 *6 ,7# 6&,%*6&' &61 82"+&6&,%*6&' '#>#' P,7# =&+A 82I8%1%#8 &+# I2, *6# #3&A"'#Q? T*:#>#+9 8* =&+ ,7#+# 7&># I##6 6* C#6#+&'%<#1 "+*12$,%*6 F2*,&9 &61 +#'&,%>#'; =#:

8#$,*+8 &+# $*6=+*6,#1 :%,7 "+%$# $*6,+*'8? \*+ ,7%8 +#&8*6 :# 7*'1 ,7&, ,7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*6 1*#8 6*, =2'';

F2&'%=; =*+ ,7# '&I#' S"'&66#1 #$*6*A;S?

b? U#6,+&'%8#1 K&8%$ !#+>%$#8

56 ,7# /!!)9 &'' $%,%<#68 7&1 & +%C7, ,* :*+B9 '#%82+#9 %6$*A# 8#$2+%,;9 &61 ,* =+## #12$&,%*6 &61 A#1%$&'

,+#&,A#6,? \2'=%''%6C &, ,7#8# &AI%,%*28 "+*A%8#8 :#+# '&+C# %68,%,2,%*68 ,7&, $*8,#1 72C# &A*26,8 *= A*6#;

,* ,7# 8,&,#? @%,7 &6 &C#%6C "*"2'&,%*69 ,7# $*8,8 *= ,7%8 >&8, 8;8,#A =2+,7#+ %6$+#&8#1 &8 ,7# #%C7,%#8

 "+*C+#88#1?

.>#6,2&'';9 :7#6 %, I#$&A# $'#&+ ,7&, ,7# C*>#+6A#6, :&8 I&6B+2",9 &'' "+*C+&A8 :#+# 8,*""#1 *+ 1+&8,%$&'';

$2,i,* ,7# 7*++*+ *= ,7# !*>%#, $%,%<#68?

56 ,7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*6 ,*1&;9 ,7# 8&A# 8#+>%$#8 &+# &'8* "+*>%1#1 *+

C2&+&6,##1 I; ,7# C*>#+6A#6,- #12$,%*6 %8 >%+,2&''; #6,%+#'; & "2I'%$

&==&%+9 A#1%$&' $&+# %8 &'A*8, $*A"'#,#'; =%6&6$#1 I; ,7# C*>#+6A#6,9

&61 ,7# "#68%*6 =2618 &+# '&+C#'; $*>#+#1 I; C*>#+6A#6, I*618 *+

1%+#$,'; =%6&6$#1 =+*A ,&3 %6$*A#? K#$&28# *= ,7# &C#%6C I&I;I**A#+C#6#+&,%*69 &6 #>#+ 8A&''#+ :*+B%6C "*"2'&,%*6 %8 "+*>%1%6C ,7# A*6#;

=*+ &6 #>#+ C+*:%6C C+*2" *= "#68%*6#+8?

E7# 8%A%'&+%,%#8 I#,:##6 ,7# *+C&6%8&,%*6 *= I&8%$ 8#+>%$#8 I#,:##6 ,7#

/!!) &61 ,7# ./ &+# 8,+%B%6C %6 A*+# ,7&6 *6# +#C&+1? \*+ #3&A"'#9 %6

& V]]b 8,21; =+*A ,7# c*%6, .$*6*A%$ U*AA%,,## *= ,7# /! U*6C+#889

:# +#&1-

M;/2 !,2NG",'+)/2= O-")#+5 -2)1,#%(P -(-%2* -/+,23 *+$( "8 %/2

 82+%1,2- %/+% )/+,+)%2,#Q2 -")#+5 -2)1,#%( -(-%2*- #$ R2-%2,$ *+,62%N

E  7"53"$"*#):'2  S

Page 6: EU = USSR Redux?

7/25/2019 EU = USSR Redux?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-ussr-redux 6/10

'+-23 2)"$"*#2-: ;/2 ?"=#2% !2$-#"$ '2$28#%- .2,2 .+72 ,25+%239 T1-% +- %/"-2 #$ R2-%2,$ 2)"$"*#2-: :::

 B2$-#"$ !,"7,+* 8#$+$)#$7 .+- '+-23 "$ %/2 -"N)+5523 U!+(N+-N("1N7"U *2%/"39 ./2,2'( )1,,2$%

"'5#7+%#"$- %" '2$28#)#+,#2- .2,2 81$323 2$%#,25( '( %/2 )1,,2$% 72$2,+%#"$ "8 .",62,-: ?1)/ !,"7,+*- *+(

'2 81$323 '( 2*!5"(2, +$3V", 2*!5"(22 )"$%,#'1%#"$- W+- #$ X,+$)2 +$3 %/2 >:?:Y9 7"=2,$*2$% '1372%

+55")+%#"$- W+- #$ @1-%,+5#+ +$3 Z2. [2+5+$3Y9 ", + )"*'#$+%#"$ %/2,2"8 W+- #$ G2,*+$(9 Z2%/2,5+$3-9

?.232$9 +$3 %/2 ?"=#2% >$#"$ 4%-258Y:\

h? T%C7 &61 )%8%6C H*>#+6A#6, X#I,

\+*A V]de ,* V]d]9 !*>%#, I21C#, 1#=%$%,8 +*8# =+*A V9df ,* ]9ef *= HXG? D'' B%618 *= &28,#+%,; A#&82+#8

&61 I&%'*2,8 P12A"%6C *= C*'19 %882%6C C*>#+6A#6, I*618 ,7+*2C7 ,7# 5J\9 #,$?Q $&28#1 ,7%8 62AI#+ ,* 1+*"

,* d9ef %6 V]]N P8*2+$#- V9 MQ? T*:#>#+9 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, #3"#68#8 +*8# &C&%6 I#$&28# *= ,7# #3"#68%># =**1

 "+*C+&AA#89 &61 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, %6$*A# 1+*""#1 I#$&28# *= ,7# +%8%6C 26#A"'*;A#6,? T#6$#9 %6 V]]V ,7#

 I21C#, 1#=%$%, #3"'*1#1 ,* V]9ef *= HXG? 56 ,7# #619 ,7# 1#I,8 :#+# ,** '&+C# ,* "&; :%,7 ,7# #>#+

1#"+#$%&,%6C +2I'#9 &61 ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6 $*''&"8#1?

E7# 1#I, "+*I'#A %6 .2+*"# %8 6*, A2$7 8A&''#+? 56 MNN`9 ,7# *==%$%&' 1#=%$%, *= ,7# ./ A#AI#+ 8,&,#8 :&8

N9df *= HXG? E7%8 +*8# ,* M9bf %6 MNNd &61 ,* O9df %6 MNN]? E7# G55H! $*26,+%#8 &+# :*+8, *==- %6 MNN]

G*+,2C&' =&$#1 & 1#=%$%, *= ]9bfgKKG9 !"&%6 *6# *= VV9VfgKKG9 5+#'&61 :%,7 Vh9hfgKKG9 &61 H+##$# :&8

'**B%6C &, & 1#=%$%, *= Ve9hfgKKG P8*2+$#- #2+*8,&,Q? \*+ MNVV9 ,7# .2+*"#&6 U*AA%88%*6 "+#1%$,8 & =2+,7#+

%6$+#&8# *= ,7# 1#I,8 %6 #>#+; ./ A#AI#+ 8,&,#?

P8*2+$#8- V9M9b)

E  7"53"$"*#):'2  ] 

Page 7: EU = USSR Redux?

7/25/2019 EU = USSR Redux?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-ussr-redux 7/10

e? @&+ 

E7# U5D #8,%A&,#8 ,7&, I#,:##6 V]dN &61 V]dO9 ,7# /!!) 8"#6, &I*2, Ve I%''%*6 +2I'# P,7#6 7&>%6C &""+*3?

,7# 8&A# >&'2# &8 ,7# 1*''&+Q ,* =%C7, ,7# :&+ %6 D=C7&6%8,&6? V A%''%*6 )288%&6 8*'1%#+8 :#+# %6>*'>#1 %6 ,7#

$*6='%$,? E7%8 :&+ 8%C6%=%$&6,'; $*6,+%I2,#1 ,* ,7# I21C#, 1#=%$%,8 *= ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6?

E7# .2+*"#&6 :&+ %6 D=C7&6%8,&6 7&8 A&%6'; I##6 & S8*=,S *6#? !%6$# MNNM9 ,7# ./ 7&8 "'#1C#1 *>#+ V9h

 I%''%*6 #2+* =*+ "+*a#$, D=C7&6%8,&6? \+*A V]]] 26,%' 6*:9 ,7# ./ 7&8 7&1 I#,:##6 ee?NNN &61 `]?NNN

8*'1%#+8 *6 & A%88%*6 &I+*&1?

@7%'# %, %8 $'#&+ ,7&, ,7# ./ %8 %6>*'>#1 %6 & A%'%,&+; $*6='%$,9 %,8 $*8, "&'#8 $*A"&+#1 ,* ,7# :&+ $*8,8 *= ,7#

/!!)? E7289 ,7# ,:* 26%*68 &+# 1%==#+#6, %6 ,7%8 +#8"#$,? PT*:#>#+9 %= *6# 87*2'1 $*68%1#+ ,7# /! &61 ,7#

./ &8 *6# =%6&6$%&' I'*$i&61 ,7#+# &+# &+C2A#6,8 %6 =&>*+ *= ,7%89 C%>#6 ,7# A2,2&' $*6,&C%*6 +%8B *= ,7#

 I&6B89 %, :&8 6* $*%6$%1#6$# ,7&, ,7# \.X &'8* I&%'#1 *2, .2+*"#&6 I&6B8 %6 MNN]i,7#6 ,7# :&+ $*8, *=

VVMN I%''%*6 1*''&+ *= ,7# 5+&F &61 D=C7&6%8,&6 %6>&8%*68 $&6 I# I+*2C7, %6,* &$$*26,?Q

O? .3,#+6&' !7*$B 

56 ,7# :&; & 1#&1 ,+## #>#6,2&''; =&''8 1*:6 I#$&28# *= & 8211#6 C28,9 & :#&B#6#1 &61 7*''*: #A"%+# *=,#6

=&''8 I#$&28# *= & 8211#6 #3,#+6&' 87*$B? D8 1#=#61#1 I; c&A#8 Z*+A&6 %6 7%8 I**B9 ,7# 1#$%8%># #$*6*A%$

2""#+$2, =*+ ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6 %8 '%B#'; ,* 7&># $*A# =+*A ,7# =&''%6C *%' "+%$#8 *= ,7# V]dN8? E7# S*%' C'2,S

$&28#1 & 8,+*6C =&'' %6 C*>#+6A#6, +#>#62#89 :7%$7 $&28#1 ,7# U*AA26%8, 26%*6 ,* C#, %6,* 1##" =%6&6$%&'

,+*2I'#? E7# *%' 87*$B :&8 ,7# #3,#+6&' 87*$B ,7&, '#1 ,* ,7# =&'' *= ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6?

E7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*6 ,*1&; =&$#8 8#>#+&' 87*$B8? \%+8, *= &'' & $+#1%, 87*$B- %6 MNNd %, I#$&A# $'#&+ ,7&, ,7#

.2+*"#&6 I&6B8 &+# 7%C7'; #3"*8#1 ,* +%8B; DA#+%$&6 =%6&6$%&' "+*12$,8? K#$&28# *= ,7%89 ,7# $+&87 %6 ,7# /!

A&+B#,8 &==#$,#1 ,7# .2+*"#&6 P=%6&6$%&'Q 8,*$B8 %6 & 8#>#+# :&;? E7%8 >2'6#+&I%'%,; "#+8%8,89 &61 %8 =2+,7#+

6*2+%87#1 I; ,7# C+#&, 1*''&+ +#8#+>#8 ,7# .2+*<*6# A#AI#+ 8,&,#8 7*'1 P+#"*+,#1'; *>#+ j`NN I%''%*6Qi&

$+&87 %6 ,7# 1*''&+ A&; &==#$, ,7# $+#1%I%'%,; *= ,7# #2+*?

56 &11%,%*69 &8 =&+ &8 6&,2+&' +#8*2+$#8 C*9 .2+*"#9 &8 +#8*2+$# $*682A#+9 %8 %6 ,7# *""*8%,# $&A" ,7# !*>%#,

/6%*6 :&8- +%8%6C $*AA*1%,; "+%$#8 %6 .2+*"# A&B# %, 7&+1#+ =*+ $*A"&6%#8 &61 C*>#+6A#6,8 ,* "&; ,7#%+

%A"*+, I%''8? D61 8* ,7%8 ,%A# &+*2619 %, %8 ,7# *%' "+*12$%6C $*26,+%#8 ,7&, S87*$BS ,7# *'1 @#8, :%,7 7%C7#+

$*AA*1%,; "+%$#8? E7# 26+#8, %6 Z*+,7#+6 D=+%$& P=*+ #3&A"'# D'C#+%&9 =+*A :7*A .2+*"# I2;8 MNf *= %,8

6&,2+&' C&8Q &61 ,7# J%11'# .&8, &118 =2+,7#+ =2#' ,* ,7%8 $*AA*1%,; =%+#?

`? E+&68"&+#6$; &61 )#=*+A

56 ,7# V]dN89 ,7# )288%&6 "*"2'&,%*6 C*, ,%+#1 *= ,7# 1#8%6=*+A&,%*6 $*A%6C =+*A ,7# C*>#+6A#6,?

 Z#:8"&"#+8 "2I'%87#1 $+%,%$&' $*'2A68 &I*2, *6C*%6C =+&21 &61 $*++2",%*6? D ,%""%6C "*%6, =*+ ,7%8 #>*'2,%*6

:&8 ,7# U7#+6*I;' #3"'*8%*69 & 1%8&8,#+ ,7# %A"&$, *= :7%$7 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, ,+%#1 ,* A%6%A%8#9 26,%' 6#:8

$&A# ,* )288%& ,7&, 8$%#6,%8,8 %6 !:#1#6 :#+# 1#,#$,%6C +&1%*_&$,%>%,;9 $*A%6C =+*A ,7# #&8,?

G*'%,%$%&68 :7* =&>*+#1 +#=*+A89 82$7 &8 J%$7&%' H*+I&$7#>9 82+=#1 *6 ,7# 6#: "*"2'&+ :&>#9 &61 "+#&$7#1

& "*'%$; *= 75+-$"-% 9 & :*+1 ,7&, P%6 $*6,+&8, ,* :7&, A&6; ,7%6B ,*1&;Q 1%1 6*, 8,&61 =*+ =+## 8"##$79 I2,

E  7"53"$"*#):'2  ^ 

Page 8: EU = USSR Redux?

7/25/2019 EU = USSR Redux?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-ussr-redux 8/10

+&,7#+ =*+ C+#&,#+ ,+&68"&+#6$; %6 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, %6 *+1#+ ,* A&B# %, A*+# #==%$%#6,? 56 ,7%8 :&;9 C'&86*8,

 I#$&A# & ,**' =*+ ,7#  !2,2-%,"#6+9 ,7# +#=*+A A*>#A#6, *= :7%$7 H*+I&$7#> &61 c#',8%6 :#+# ,7# =%C2+#

7#&18?

E7# "*'%$; *= 75+-$"-%  7&1 26#3"#$,#1 $*68#F2#6$#8 =*+ ,7# "*'%,%$%&68- %, &''*:#1 =*+ ,7# =+## $%+$2'&,%*6 *=

%6=*+A&,%*6 &I*2, $*++2",%*6 &61 &,+*$%,%#8 :%,7%6 ,7# C*>#+6A#6,? E7%8 I#$&A# & I+##1%6C C+*261 =*+ ,7#

%61#"#61#6$# 8,+2CC'# *= ,7# !*>%#, )#"2I'%$8? 56 ,7%8 :&;9 ,+&68"&+#6$; &61 +#=*+A&,%*6 :#+# $&28#8 *= ,7#

$*''&"8# *= ,7# /!!)?

E*1&;9 & 8%A%'&+ 1;6&A%$ $&6 I# 8##6 %6 .2+*"#? Y6# $*2'1 8&; ,7&, ,7# $+%8%8 *= MNNd :&8 ,7# .2+*"#&6

>#+8%*6 *= ,7# U7#+6*I;' 1%8&8,#+- %6 & =#: :##B8 ,%A#9 A%''%*68 *= "#*"'# :#+# $*6=+*6,#1 :%,7 ,7#

$*68#F2#6$#8 *= C+#&, &61 %68,%,2,%*6&'%8#1 $*++2",%*6 %6 8*$%#,;? E7# I&6B%6C 8$&61&'8 %6 5$#'&61 :#+#

 "&+&1%CA&,%$ =*+ ,7# ,+*2I'#8 %6 ,7# +#8, *= ,7# /6%*6? E7#+# :&8 &'8* ,7# $+%8%8 %6 H+##$#9 :7#+#I; ,7# =+&21

%6 ,7# C*>#+6A#6, I**B8 :&8 '&%1 I&+# PH+##$# '%#1 &I*2, %,8 1#=%$%,8 %6 *+1#+ ,* C#, "#+A%88%*6 ,* #6,#+ ,7#

./Q? E7# +#$#6,'; '#&B#1 :%B%'#&B8 $&I'#8 &+# '#&1%6C ,* & =2+,7#+ #+*8%*6 *= ,7# $*6=%1#6$# %6 ,7# :*+'1 *=

 "*'%,%$8 &61 =%6&6$#? 56 87*+,9 75+-$"-%  7&8 $*A# ,* #2+*"#?

!*A# 7&># &'+#&1; 1%8$*>#+#1 ,7&, #AI+&$%6C ,7# 6#: ,+#61 $&6 '#&1 ,* "*'%,%$&' >%$,*+%#89 82$7 &8 ,7#

 !#,+%!+,%#2%  %6 !:#1#69 *+ ,7# ,#& "&+,; A*>#A#6, %6 ,7# /?!?? !7&B#6 I; ,7# &6C#+ *= ,7# "*"2'&,%*69 A&6;

./ +#=*+A "+*C+&AA#8 7&># I##6 "2, %6,* "'&$#9 "+*C+&AA#8 ,7&, %6 ,2+6 :%'' '%B#'; 26>#%' A&6; '*6C B#",

8#$+#,8? D, ,7# 8&A# ,%A# :# :%,6#889 &8 %6 ,7# /!!) *= ,7# V]dN89 &,,#A",8 ,* $2+I =+## 8"##$7 %6 *+1#+ ,*

&>*%1 & 6#: 8;8,#A%$ $+%8%8? D 8,+%B%6C #3&A"'# %8 ,7# +#$#6, X2,$7 '&: "+*"*8&' ,* I&6 &'' $&''8 =*+ & I&6B

+26? @# $&6 $*6$'21# ,7&, ,+&68"&+#6$; &61 +#=*+A &+# ,:* .2+*"#&6 ,+#618 *= ,7# "&8, ;#&+8 &61 A*6,78?

d? 56,#+6&' G*'%,%$&' /6+#8,

56 ,7# /!!) #>#6 ,7# 8,+*6C#8, 8,&,#8 :#+# :#&B#6#19 &61 ;#, ,7#; 7&1 ,* 7#'" $&++; ,7# :#&B#8, *6#8?

K#$&28# *= ,7%89 ,7# $&''8 =*+ 8#$#88%*6 I#$&A# #>#+ '*21#+9 &61 =+*A V]dd *6:&+189 8#>#+&' +#"2I'%$8

1#$'&+#1 %61#"#61#6$#?

E7# ./ ,*1&; =&$#8 8%A%'&+ "+*I'#A8- ,7# '#88 :#&B 8,&,#8 82$7 &8 H#+A&6; &61 !:#1#6 &+# &6C+; I#$&28#

,7#; &+# =*+$#1 ,* "&; =*+ ,7# :#&B#8,9 82$7 &8 H+##$# &61 5+#'&61? 56 ,7# $*++%1*+8 *= ,7# .2+*"#&6

G&+'%&A#6, ,7#+# %8 ,&'B *= & S$*+#S 6*+,7#+6 #2+*<*6#? 56 $*26,+%#8 82$7 &8 H+##$#9 5,&';9 &61 5+#'&619 ,7#+# &+#

>%*'#6, "+*,#8,8 &C&%68, "+#8#6, &61 =2,2+# I&%'*2, &61 &28,#+%,; "'&68?

]? )%8%6C 56='&,%*6

D8 1#8$+%I#1 %6 "&+, V9 ,7# /!!) =&$#1 & "#+%*1 *= +%8%6C %6='&,%*6? .2+*"# =&$#8 8%A%'&+ "+*I'#A8?

Y==%$%&' %6='&,%*6 %6 ,7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*6 %8 '*:9 &+*261 ,7+## "#+$#6,? T*:#>#+9 %= :# '**B &, :7&, &

.2+*"#&6 $&6 I; =*+ 7%8 #2+*S8 *6 ,7# :*+'1 A&+B#, ,*1&;9 &8 $*A"&+#1 ,* I#=*+#9 %, I#$*A#8 $'#&+ ,7&, "+%$#

%6='&,%*6 %8 & =&$,? \*+ ,7# .2+*"#&69 %6 ,7# '&8, 8%3 A*6,78 *= MNVN9 ,7# $*""#+ "+%$# +*8# I; Vdf9 $*+6 I;

b`f9 &61 $*,,*6 I; Oef?

VN? K&%'*2,8 =+*A ,7# U#6,+&' K&6B 

E  7"53"$"*#):'2  _

Page 9: EU = USSR Redux?

7/25/2019 EU = USSR Redux?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-ussr-redux 9/10

56 ,7# /!!) '&+C# $*A"&6%#8 :#+# I&%'#1 *2, P82I8%1%<#1Q *6 & "#+A&6#6, I&8%89 I; ,7# U#6,+&' K&6B? 58 ,7&,

&'8* ,7# $&8# %6 ,7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*64

W#8? 56 ,7# ./9 '&+C# 6&,%*6&' &61 *,7#+ =%+A8 &+# &'8* I&%'#1 *2, *+ B#", &='*&, I; &$,%*68 =+*A ,7# .2+*"#&6

U#6,+&' K&6B? J*8, I&%'*2,8 7&""#6 %61%+#$,';9 =*+ #3&A"'# I; &''*:%6C ,7# .UK ,* I2; ,+#&82+%#89 *+ I;

B##"%6C ,7# %6,#+#8, +&,# &, & 7%8,*+%$&''; '*: '#>#69 :7%$7 &''*:8 $*A"&6%#8 &61 C*>#+6A#6, &C#6$%#8 ,* C#,

$7#&" '*&68 =+*A ,7# "+%>&,# I&6B89 *+9 I; A#&68 *= *6# *= ,7# A&6; 82I8%1; "+*C+&AA#8 =*+ $*+"*+&,%*68?

UYZU[/!5YZ- VN UYZE)5K/E5ZH \DUEY)! UYJGD).X

T#+# :# 87*: ,7# =&$,*+8 &6&';8#1 &I*># %6 & 82AA&+; ,&I'#-

!"#$%&%"#' ')'&*+%, ,-.'/ 0112 30

U#6,+&'%<#1 A*6#,&+; 8;8,#A   ! !

G'&66#1 #$*6*A;   !

U#6,+&'%<#1 I&8%$ 8#+>%$#8   ! !

T%C7 &61 +%8%6C C*>#+6A#6, 1#I,   ! !

@&+    !

.3,#+6&' 87*$B ! !

E+&68"&+#6$; &61 +#=*+A   ! !

56,#+6&' "*'%,%$&' 26+#8,   ! !

)%8%6C %6='&,%*6   ! !

K&%'*2,8 =+*A ,7# $#6,+&' I&6B    ! !

!"#$%&%"#' +*&4 56756 68756

E7# ./ ,*1&; A##,8 #%C7, *2, *= ,7# ,#6 $+%,#+%& ,7&, 7&># "287#1 !*>%#, )288%& %6,* "*'%,%$&' 1#8%6,#C+&,%*6

&61 7;"#+%6='&,%*6? @%'' ,7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*6 =&$# ,7# 8&A# 1#8,%6; &8 ,7# K#&+ =+*A ,7# .&8,4

H*'1*6*A%$ %8 *= ,7# *"%6%*6 ,7&, &6 %6='&,%*6&+; 1#"+#88%*6 %8 %6#>%,&I'#9 &61 7%8,*+; ,#&$7#8 ,7&, 82$7 &

A*6#,&+; 8,*+A9 1#8,+*;%6C ,7# "2+$7&8%6C "*:#+ *= A%''%*68 *= "#*"'# %6 & +#'&,%>#'; 87*+, ,%A# 8"&69 &'8*

'#&18 ,* ,7# 1#8%6,#C+&,%*6 *= "*'%,%$&' 8,+2$,2+#8? !2$7 7&8 I##6 ,7# '#88*6 =+*A ,7# )*A&6 .A"%+#9 =+*A

+#>*'2,%*6&+; \+&6$#9 &61 =+*A ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6?

T*: #3&$,'; ,7# 1#8%6,#C+&,%*6 *= ,7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*6 :%'' 26=*'1 %8 & 8"#$2'&,%># F2#8,%*69 I2, ,7&, %, :%''

$*A# 8##A8 6*: %6#>%,&I'#? D'8* ,7# .2+* %8 %6 & 1##" $+%8%8? @7#,7#+ 7;"#+%6='&,%*6 $*A#8 =%+8,9 *+ :7#,7#+

,7# #2+* :%'' I# 8"'%, %6,* 1%==#+#6, 6#: 26%,8 *= "&;A#6,9 ,7# >&'# *= "&"#+ A*6#; %6 .2+*"# 7&6C8 I; &

,7+#&1? 56 ,7#8# 8,*+A; ,%A#89 & :%8# %6>#8,*+ :%'' 7&># ,* '**B *2, =*+ :&;8 *= A&%6,&%6%6C 7%8 "2+$7&8%6C

 "*:#+ I; *,7#+ A#&68 ,7&6 =%&, A*6#; &61g*+ C*>#+6A#6, I*618?

E  7"53"$"*#):'2  `

Page 10: EU = USSR Redux?

7/25/2019 EU = USSR Redux?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-ussr-redux 10/10

!Y/)U.!

D'I#+, c? !$7A%1,- kE7# 5A"&$, *= G#+#8,+*%B& *6 !*>%#, [&:l

H&+; YmU&''&C7&6- kE7# !,+2$,2+# &61 Y"#+&,%*6 *= ,7# @*+'1 H*'1 J&+B#,l

D+*6 n&,8#6#'%6I*%C#6- kE7# !*>%#, /6%*6- .A"%+#9 Z&,%*69 &61 !;8,#Al

[#*6 K*%A- k[#C&' U*6,+*'8 %6 ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6l

E7&;#+ @&,B%68- E7# T;"#+%6='&,%*6 %6 )288%& %6 ,7# V]]Nm8

:::?$I+?+2- E7# !,&,# K&6B *= ,7# /!!) 

L?D? D$7&+B&6- k!,&,# G#68%*68 %6 ,7# /!!)- \#&,2+#8 &61 E+#618l

 Z&,7&6 n? [#:%8- kH*'1- ,7# Y6$# &61 \2,2+# J*6#;l

 "I8?*+C- kU*AA&61%6C T#%C7,8l

c&A#8 )? Z*+A&6- kE7# Y%' U&+1l

D=C7&6%8,&6 *6'%6#- E7# )*'# *= D=C7&6%8,&6 %6 ,7# \&'' *= ,7# /!!) 

U5D P*==%$# *= 8*>%#, &6&';8%8Q- kE7# U*8,8 *= !*>%#, 56>*'>#A#6, %6 D=C7&6%8,&6l

)&=&#' )#2>#6;- kE7# D=7&6%8,&6 :&+ &61 ,7# I+#&B1*:6 *= ,7# !*>%#, /6%*6l

55!!- .2+*"#&6 J%'%,&+; U&"&I%'%,%#8

@%B%"#1%&- kV]`` !*>%#, U*68,%,2,%*6l

@%B%"#1%&- kG+#1%$,%*68 *= ,7# !*>%#, $*''&"8#l

n&+' J&+3- kJ&6%=#8,* *= ,7# U*AA26%8, G&+,;l

T*+&$# @7%,#- kJ*6#; &61 K&6B%6Cl

D6,7*6; c*6#8- kE7# H+#&, J&+B#, X#I&,# %6 !*>%#, D6,7*'*C;l

G&,+%$B c? U*6:&;- kU+%8%89 !,&I%'%<&,%*69 &61 H+*:,7- #$*6*A%$ &1a28,A#6, %6 ,+&68%,%*6 #$*6*A%#8l

c*8#"7 H%II8- H*+I&$7#>m8 C'&86*8,- ,7# !*>%#, A#1%& %6 ,7# =%+8, "7&8# *= "#+#8,+*%B&

!#+C#; L&88%6- E7# X#,#+A%6&6,8 &61 5A"'%$&,%*68 *= &6 DC%6C G*"2'&,%*6 56 )288%&

.2+*"#8# U*AA%88%#- )#C%8,+&,%*6 *= U+21# Y%' 5A"*+,8 &61 X#'%>#+%#8 %6 ,7# .2+*"#&6 /6%*6 

E  7 "53"$"*#):'2  CD