erisa update

50
ERISA Update Roberta J. Ufford Groom Law Group April 18, 2011

Upload: zaza

Post on 13-Jan-2016

98 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

ERISA Update. Roberta J. Ufford Groom Law Group April 18, 2011. Pending Disclosure Regulation Investment Advice Other New Guidance DOL Enforcement Issues Litigation Update IRA Issues. Disclosure Regulation. Trends Highlighting Importance of Disclosure - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ERISA Update

ERISA Update

Roberta J. UffordGroom Law Group

April 18, 2011

Page 2: ERISA Update

2

Pending Disclosure Regulation Investment Advice Other New Guidance DOL Enforcement Issues Litigation Update IRA Issues

Page 3: ERISA Update

3

Disclosure RegulationTrends Highlighting Importance of Disclosure Retirement system shift to participant-directed

defined contribution plans. Development of fee structures relying on "indirect"

and "hidden" direct compensation (retirement and welfare plans).

Media attention/legislative pressure to improve disclosure.

Ongoing class action litigation against plan sponsors and plan service providers.

Page 4: ERISA Update

4

New Disclosure Regulation Service Provider Disclosure

Amendment of Form 5500 Schedule C 75 Fed. Reg. 64710 and 64731 (Nov. 16, 2007)

"Point of Sale" – Interim Final 408(b)(2) Regulation 75 Fed. Reg. 41600 (July 16, 2010)

Disclosure to Participants 75 Fed. Reg. 64910 (Oct 20, 2011) (final regulation) 75 Fed. Reg. 73987 (Nov 30, 2010) (target date

funds) (proposed) Regulatory Agenda – Pension Benefit Statements

SEC Proposed Rule 12b-2 75 Fed. Reg. 47064 (Aug 4, 2010)

Page 5: ERISA Update

5

Service Provider Disclosure Form 5500 – Schedule C

Administrator must report all service providers receiving $5000 or more direct and indirect compensation paid by the plan. Applies - if plan has more than 100 participants to welfare as well as pension plans to any person receiving compensation in

connection with plan services or a position with the plan

Administrators required to report to DOL providers who refuse to provide compensation information for 5500 reporting.

Page 6: ERISA Update

6

Service Provider Disclosure – Interim Final Regulation

ERISA prohibits a "party in interest" from providing plan services, unless statutory exemption under § 408(b)(2) applies. New regulation defines "reasonable arrangement"

Providers who do not comply may engage in a "prohibited transaction" under Code § 4975. Provider may be liable for excise taxes, possibly

required to return "excess compensation" to plan. Class exemption provides relief for plan fiduciary (not

provider). Requires fiduciary to report provider non-compliance to DOL.

Page 7: ERISA Update

7

Service Provider Disclosure – Interim Final Regulation

In general, covered service providers to covered plans must disclose direct and indirect compensation they expect to receive for providing services.

Covered Plans - ERISA-covered pension plans excludes IRAs, SEPs, SIMPLE accounts, "top-hat"

plans separate regulation pending for welfare plans

Covered Service Providers – a person who: (1) expects to receive more than $1000 in direct or

indirect compensation, and (2) provides certain fiduciary or non-fiduciary services

Form 5500 Schedule C uses similar definition of compensation; but covered plans and providers are not the same.

Page 8: ERISA Update

8

Service Provider Disclosure – Interim Final Regulation

Covered Service Providers – persons who provide: services as fiduciary or registered investment

adviser recordkeeping or brokerage services to defined

contribution plans (e.g., 401(k)) and provide "designated options"

accounting, auditing, actuarial, appraisal, banking, consulting, custodial, legal, recordkeeping, securities brokerage, insurance, valuation, but only if "indirect compensation" for the services

Excludes most providers to "investment funds." Service providers should consider risk of becoming

inadvertently covered.

Page 9: ERISA Update

9

Service Provider Disclosure – Interim Final Regulation

Required Disclosures description of services provided to plan statement of fiduciary status, if applicable "direct" compensation

excludes payments by plan sponsor or employer "indirect" compensation

including a description of services provided for indirect compensation and payer identity

includes "non-monetary" compensation manner of receipt of compensation

Page 10: ERISA Update

10

Service Provider Disclosure – Interim Final Regulation

Required Disclosures (con’t) compensation among "related parties"

(subcontractors and affiliates), ONLY if (1) set on a transaction basis (2) charged against investment and reflected in investment value or (3) commissions or other "transaction-based" compensation.

termination compensation – compensation provider expects to receive if arrangement terminates

recordkeeper/broker disclosure (next slide) On request, within 30 days, information requested

by plan administrator for "Title I" purposes (e.g., Form 5500, participant disclosure)

Page 11: ERISA Update

11

Service Provider Disclosure – Interim Final Regulation

Additional Recordkeeper/Broker Disclosure Investment fees – recordkeepers, brokers and

investment fiduciaries of "designated investment alternatives" must disclose investment fund fees

Recordkeepers, brokers must disclose if they make the investment available on their platform.

Recordkeeping fee- a "good-faith estimate" of plan cost for recordkeeping, if recordkeeping fee is not separately stated or is reduced by indirect compensation.

Page 12: ERISA Update

12

Service Provider Disclosure – Interim Final Regulation

Timing Requirements Existing service arrangements

before January 1, 2012 effective date All arrangements

"reasonably in advance" of entering into service arrangement

within 60 days of service provider knowledge of change

within 30 days to correct an error

Page 13: ERISA Update

13

Plan Expenses –Service Provider Disclosure

Service Provider Planning Inventory services and compensation

Direct/indirect Meals, entertainment and gifts

Existing clients – comply by 1/1/2012 Ongoing Procedures

Delivery in advance of entering/renewal of contracts or arrangements

Timely notice of changes/corrections Timely reply to requests for information

Page 14: ERISA Update

14

Participant Disclosure –Background

DOL interprets ERISA fiduciary rules to require plan fiduciaries to ensure that participants and beneficiaries responsible for investing their account within the plan are provided with "sufficient information" to make informed investment decisions.

Plan "administrator" is required to provide disclosure, but providers can expect to support disclosure requirements.

Disclosures required by 404(c) have been "optional"– new requirements are mandatory.

Page 15: ERISA Update

15

Participant Disclosure – New Rules

In October 2010, DOL issued final rules under ERISA section 404(a) requiring disclosure of information to participants in directed individual account plans.

75 FR 64910 (October 20, 2010)

Effective Date – Dec. 20, 2010

Applicability Date – Plan years beginning on or after Nov. 1, 2011.

Page 16: ERISA Update

16

Participant Disclosure – New Rules

Overview of Required Disclosures Automatic disclosures – provided on or before the

date participant may give investment instructions, and annually General Investment Information Administrative Expense Information Individual Expense Information Information For Each Designated Alternative

Includes investment performance and fee information in a comparative format

Web site disclosures On request disclosures

Page 17: ERISA Update

17

General Investment Information Explanation of circumstances under which

participants/beneficiaries may give investment instructions, and any limits on instructions

Plan investment alternatives Investment managers Description of any brokerage windows, self-directed

brokerage accounts, or similar plan arrangements Description/reference to plan provisions relating to

the exercise of voting, tender and similar rights and restrictions on such rights.

Participant Disclosure – New Rules

Page 18: ERISA Update

18

Plan-Level Expenses –Annual DisclosuresAdministrative Expenses Explanation of fees and expenses for general plan

administrative services charged against participants’ individual accounts.

The basis on which such charges will be allocated to, or affect the balance of, each individual’s account.

Individual Expenses Explanation of fees and expenses charged against

participant accounts, on an individual, rather than a plan-wide basis, and which are not reflected in the total annual operating expenses of any investment alternative.

Participant Disclosure – New Rules

Page 19: ERISA Update

19

Plan-Level Expenses – Quarterly DisclosuresAdministrative Expenses The dollar amount of general plan administrative fees

and expenses actually charged during the preceding quarter to a participant’s account

Explanation (if applicable) that some of the plan’s administrative expenses for the preceding quarter were paid from operating expenses of one or more of the plan’s investment alternatives

Individual Expenses The dollar amount of fees and expenses charged on

an individual basis during the preceding quarter to the participant’s account and a description of the services to which the charges relate

Participant Disclosure – New Rules

Page 20: ERISA Update

20

Designated Investments – Automatic Disclosures Name and category of investment (e.g., money

market, balanced, stocks, bonds, employer stock) Internet Web site for more information Performance (1, 5 and 10 years) and comparable

information for a broad-based index Fees – total operating expenses and "shareholder"

type fees Special rules for investments with fixed or stated

rates of return and annuities Glossary (automatic or on a Web site)

*Prospectus delivery no longer automatically required.

Participant Disclosure – New Rules

Page 21: ERISA Update

21

Table 1—Variable Return Investments

Name/ Type of Option

Average Annual Total Return

as of 12/31/XX 1yr. 5yr. 10yr. Since

Inception

Benchmark

1yr. 5yr. 10yr. Since

Inception

Equity Funds A Index Fund/ S&P 500 www. website address

26.5% .34% -1.03% 9.25% 26.46% .42% -.95% 9.30% S&P 500

B Fund/ Large Cap www. website address

27.6% .99% N/A 2.26% 27.80% 1.02% N/A 2.77% US Prime Market 750 Index

C Fund/ Int’l Stock www. website address

36.73% 5.26% 2.29% 9.37% 40.40% 5.40% 2.40% 12.09% MSCI EAFE

D Fund/ Mid Cap www. website address

40.22% 2.28% 6.13% 3.29% 46.29% 2.40% -.52% 4.16% Russell Midcap

Bond Funds E Fund/ Bond Index

www. website address 6.45% 4.43% 6.08% 7.08% 5.93% 4.97% 6.33% 7.01%

Barclays Cap. Aggr. Bd. Other

F Fund/ GICs www. website address

.72% 3.36% 3.11% 5.56% 1.8% 3.1% 3.3% 5.75% 3-month US T-Bill Index

G Fund/ Stable Value www. website address

4.36% 4.64% 5.07% 3.75% 1.8% 3.1% 3.3% 4.99% 3-month US T-Bill Index

Generations 2020/ Lifecycle Fund

www. website address

27.94% N/A N/A 2.45% 26.46% N/A N/A 3.09% S&P 500

23.95% N/A N/A 3.74%

Generations 2020 Composite Index*

Participant Disclosure Example – Variable Return Investments

Page 22: ERISA Update

22

Table 3—Fees and Expenses

Name / Type of Option

Total Annual

Operating Expenses

As a % Per $1000

Shareholder-Type Fees

Equity Funds A Index Fund/

S&P 500 0.18% $1.80

$20 annual service charge subtracted from investments held in this option if valued at less than $10,000.

B Fund/ Large Cap

2.45% $24.50 2.25% deferred sales charge subtracted from amounts withdrawn within 12 months of purchase.

C Fund/ International Stock 0.79% $7.90 5.75% sales charge subtracted from amounts invested. D Fund/

Mid Cap ETF 0.20% $2.00

4.25% sales charge subtracted from amounts withdrawn.

Bond Funds E Fund/

Bond Index 0.50% $5.00

N/A

Other F Fund/

GICs 0.46% $4.60

10% charge subtracted from amounts withdrawn within 18 months of initial investment.

G Fund/ Stable Value

0.65% $6.50 Amounts withdrawn may not be transferred to a competing option for 90 days after withdrawal.

Generations 2020/ Lifecycle Fund

1.50% $15.00 Excessive trading restricts additional purchases (other than contributions and loan repayments) for 85 days.

Fixed Return Investments

H 200X / GIC N/A 12% charge subtracted from amounts withdrawn before maturity. I LIBOR Plus/ Fixed-Type

Invest Account N/A 5% contingent deferred sales charge subtracted from amounts withdrawn; charge reduced by 1% on 12-month anniversary of each investment.

J Financial Serv Co. / Fixed Account Investment

N/A 90 days of interest subtracted from amounts withdrawn before maturity.

Participant Disclosure Example –Fee and Expense Information

Page 23: ERISA Update

23

Participant Disclosure – New Rules

Designated Investments – Web site Disclosures Name of investment issuer Objectives and goals* Principal strategies (including type of assets) and

principal risks* Portfolio turnover rate* Performance data (updated quarterly)* Fees and expenses*

*provided in a manner consistent with SEC Form N1-A

Page 24: ERISA Update

24

ERISA and Advisers Act employ different definitions of "advice." Advice requiring RIA registration may not result in

ERISA fiduciary status. Brokers exempt from RIA registration may still

provide fiduciary "advice" for ERISA purposes. Under current DOL regulations, "fiduciary" investment

advice requires (1) recommendations, (2) which are individualized, (3) provided on a regular basis, (4) with mutual understanding that advice will be a "primary basis" for decisions, and (5) for a fee. Sales presentations, fund menu offerings, and

participant education (IB 96-1) generally are not "fiduciary advice" under this definition.

Investment Advice – ERISA Definition

Page 25: ERISA Update

25

Investment Advice – ERISA Definition DOL has proposed amendments that would expand

definition of "fiduciary" advice. 75 FR 65263 (October 22, 2010). Hearings held March 1 and 2.

Under the proposed regulation, a person provides "fiduciary" advice if the person -- provides "advice" as defined, has one more defined relationships to the plan, and receives a fee.

Some limitations on scope are provided.

Page 26: ERISA Update

26

Investment Advice – ERISA Definition"Advice" under the proposed rule includes:

advice/appraisals concerning the value of securities or property,

recommendations as to advisability of investing in, purchasing, holding or selling securities or other property, and

recommendations as to "management" of securities or other property (includes proxy voting and manager recommendations).

DOL asked for comments on including advice relatingto "rollovers" in investment advice definition.

Page 27: ERISA Update

27

Investment Advice – ERISA Definition A person who provides "advice" will be a fiduciary if

the person is any of the following - any person who agrees to be, or is, a fiduciary (or

an affiliate of a fiduciary), any RIA, and a person providing advice if there is mutual

agreement that the advice will be considered, and will be individualized to the needs of the plan, or a participant or beneficiary.

New test eliminates "regular basis" and "primary basis" elements of current test.

Page 28: ERISA Update

28

Investment Advice – Definition Limitations – not fiduciary advice if:

Advice recipient knows (or reasonably should know) that the advice is provided by (or on behalf of) a seller or purchaser, and person making recommendations is not undertaking to provide impartial advice.

With respect to individual account plans, services are limited to investment education (IB 96-1), offering an investment menu, and general information about menu options, if there is written disclosure that there is no undertaking to provide impartial advice.

Only a general report or statement reflecting value of investments, unless no generally recognized market for assets involved and statement is used as a basis for plan to make distributions to participants.

Page 29: ERISA Update

29

Investment Advice – Issues Recordkeeper Considerations

Sample and customized fund menus Fund monitoring services

Rollover Advice Disclaimers Required by Sellers Exception Periodic Reporting by Trustees/Custodians Appraisers and Consultants

Page 30: ERISA Update

30

Participant Investment Advice ERISA § 408(b)(14) exempts (i) provision of advice to

participants of participant-directed plans by a “fiduciary adviser” and (ii) receipt of compensation by fiduciary adviser or an affiliate resulting from the advice, if conditions of ERISA Section 408(g) are met.

ERISA Section 408(g) describes two Eligible Arrangements:

Level-fees: Adviser’s fees do not vary based on advice.

Computer Model: Adviser provides advice using a computer model certified by an independent expert.

Page 31: ERISA Update

31

Participant Investment Advice

Proposed Reg. § 2550.408g-1 generally tracks requirements under Section 408(g). Plan fiduciary must authorize arrangement for

plan. Advice is provided under an “eligible

arrangement.” Detailed participant disclosure, including all

program fees and the fiduciary adviser’s compensation arrangement. (proposed rule provides non-mandatory form).

Annual independent audit of services. 75 Fed. Reg. 9360 (March 2, 2010).

Page 32: ERISA Update

32

Participant Investment Advice Compared to 2009 rule (withdrawn), the new

proposed rule: Does not provide relief for “off-model advice” if a

computer model is used. For level fee arrangements, (i) requires that

entity’s fees are “level” - even if individual agent/representative’s fees do not change based on advice provided, and (ii) limits fees received by fiduciary advisers from affiliates.

Importantly, does not change EBSA’s other prior regulation, exemptions, interpretative or other guidance addressing participant advice programs.

E.g., dollar-for-dollar offset and ‘SunAmerica’ programs are preserved.

Page 33: ERISA Update

33

Other New Guidance – Target Date Funds

DOL/SEC guidelines for Target Date Funds advise fiduciaries/participants evaluating target date funds to consider: “Investment Style” - active or “hands-off” approach? Fund Prospectus – understand the strategy and risks of

fund, and underlying funds. How the Investment Will Change Over Time–

understand when the fund will reach its most conservative mix; whether at or after the target date; whether participant risk tolerance matches the fund.

When Will Participant Access the Fund – does the fund’s investment mix at target date fit with future plans?

Fees – understand costs of fund and underlying funds. http://www.dol.gov/ebsa/pdf/TDFInvestorBulletin.pdf

Page 34: ERISA Update

34

Other New Guidance – Target Date Disclosure

DOL regulations implementing relief for investments in qualified default investment options designate "target date" funds as a possible "QDIA". 72 FR 60452 (October 24, 2007); 73 FR 23349 (April 30, 2008).

Proposed amendment of QDIA regulation would – cross-reference participant disclosure regulation amend participant disclosure regulation and QDIA

regulation to include new disclosure requirements for target date funds.

75 FR 73987 (November 30, 2010).

Page 35: ERISA Update

35

Other New Guidance – Target Date Disclosure

Amendments would require disclosure to explain – how asset allocation may change over time and

when most conservative allocation will be achieved (chart or other graphical representation);

intended age group, relevance of any date in name, and assumptions about whether participants will withdraw or contribute after that date; and

participant may still lose money, even near retirement date.

Page 36: ERISA Update

36

Other New Guidance – Fiduciary Conflict Interpretation

DOL Advisory Opinion 2011-03A (Feb. 4, 2011) Applies fiduciary self-dealing prohibition (ERISA § 406(b))

to manager affiliate of global financial institution.

Mitsubishi Bank (“MB”)

Mitsubishi Group Broker – Dealers

(“MBDs”)

Aberdeen PLC

AAM (ERISA Manager)

(Up to 19.9%)(Up to 100%)

Page 37: ERISA Update

37

Other New Guidance – Fiduciary Conflict Interpretation

DOL Advisory Opinion 2011-06A Because MBDs are not parties in interest to AAM plan

clients based on common ownership through MB, AAM not per se prohibited from directing trades to MBDs.

BUT, must still examine facts/circumstances. Some key considerations: There may be a disqualifying affiliation (so that AAM

could not direct trades to MBDs) if substantial and close control of AAM by common parent.

If objective criteria/policies for selecting brokers limits AAM’s exercise of fiduciary judgment, AAM may not be prohibited from directing plan transactions to MBDs.

Under PTE 84-14 (QPAM Exemption) MBDs not “related” parties of AAM.

Page 38: ERISA Update

38

EBSA –National Enforcement Projects

Delinquent Contributions Contributory Plans Criminal Project (Final Participant Contribution Regulation 75 FR

2068 (Jan 14, 2010)) Plans in Bankruptcy/Abandoned Plans Employee Stock Ownership Plans Consultant/Adviser Project Participant and Beneficiary Complaints 5500 Desk Reviews/Non-Filer Enforcement Health Fraud/Multiple Welfare Arrangements

See www.dol.gov.ebsa/erisa_enforcement.html

Page 39: ERISA Update

39

Litigation – 401(k) Fee Lawsuits Claims by participants against plan sponsors allege:

Service arrangements with “unreasonable,” “hidden” and “excessive” fees are imprudent.

Plan sponsor fiduciaries did not understand/recognize revenue sharing arrangements.

Fiduciaries did not disclose to participants in “proper detail and clarity” fees and expenses, including “revenue-sharing.”

Claims against financial institutions and other service providers (by participants and/or plan sponsors) allege: Service provider is a fiduciary based on selection of

plan options and/or failure to disclose fees, and Breached fiduciary duties by failing to disclose and

engaging in prohibited transactions, e.g.,“using” plan assets, self-dealing, receiving kickbacks.

Page 40: ERISA Update

40

Litigation – 401(k) Fee Lawsuits Hecker v. Deere & Co., 496 F. Supp. 967 (W.D. Wisc.

2007), aff’d 556 F.3d 575 (7th Cir. 2009). Court dismissed participant claims against plan

committee and Fidelity. Fidelity not a fiduciary because plan sponsor

selected plan investment options. Revenue-sharing not material and need not be

disclosed to participants. Because plan offered a broad selection of funds,

offering allegedly expensive fund options not a fiduciary breach.

ERISA section 404(c) defense also precluded liability for fund selection.

Page 41: ERISA Update

41

Litigation – 401(k) Fee Lawsuits Court dismissed claims alleging CitiStreet was a

"functional" fiduciary by virtue of offering an investment menu. F.W. Webb Co. v. State Street Bank and Trust Co.,

No. 09 Civ.1241 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 21, 2010). Recordkeeper not a fiduciary merely because it offered

a limited fund menu and could modify the menu with notice. Court noted that recordkeeper creates its menu before the existence of any contractual relationship with a plan and is free to design investment menus for prospective clients. Zang v. Paychex, Inc., No. 08-CV-6046L

(W.D.N.Y. Aug. 2, 2010).

Page 42: ERISA Update

42

Litigation – 401(k) Fee Lawsuits In suits by plan sponsors against insurers offering group

annuity contracts to 401(k) plans (insurers receive fees from mutual funds offered through these contracts), courts have held that insurers may be, or are fiduciaries. Charters v. John Hancock Life Ins. Co., 583 F. Supp. 2d

189 (D. Conn. 2007); Phones Plus, Inc. v. The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc., 2007 WL 3124733 (D. Conn 2007); Haddock v. Nationwide Fin. Services, Inc., 419 F.Supp. 2d 156 (D. Conn. 2006).

Court granted motion for class certification in Haddock, concluding that plan by plan decision on Nationwide’s fiduciary status is not required. 262 F.R.D. 97 (D. Conn. 2009); compare Ruppert v.

Principal Life Ins. Co., 2007 WL 2025233 (S.D. Iowa 2007) (denying motion for class certification).

Page 43: ERISA Update

43

Litigation – 401(k) Fee Lawsuits Court granted Fidelity motion to dismiss because plaintiff

did not allege Fidelity was a fiduciary in setting its compensation or selecting plan investment options. Columbia Air Services, Inc. v. Fidelity Management Trust

Co., 2008 WL 4457861 (D. Mass. 2008). Court dismissed claims in plan sponsor suit against

Principal. For purpose of its motion, Principal did not disclaim fiduciary status. Court (i) followed Deere, holding that revenue sharing need not be disclosed, and (ii) held that Principal’s fees were not unreasonable, because factored into fees charged to the plan. A motion for reconsideration by 8th Circuit has been filed. Ruppert v. Principal Life Ins. Co., 4:07-CV-00344 (S.D.

Iowa Nov. 5, 2009).

Page 44: ERISA Update

44

Litigation – 401(k) Fee Lawsuits Braden v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 590 F.Supp. 2d 1159 (W.D. Mo.

2008), decision vacated 588 F.3d. 585 (8th Cir. Nov. 25, 2009). District court dismissed, but 8th Circuit remanded, holding

that fiduciaries must disclose “material” information to participants, including fund expense and revenue sharing information.

Tussey v. ABB Inc., 2008 WL 379666 (W.D. Mo. 2008). In case similar to Deere, court denied motions to dismiss by

ABB and Fidelity; trial held January 2010. Martin v. Caterpillar, Inc., Civil Action No. 1:07-CV-01009 (C.D.

Ill. November 5, 2009) Settled for $16.5 million ($5.8 million in attorneys fees) plus

Caterpillar agreement to certain restrictions on plan operations.

Tibble v. Edison Int’l, 2010 WL 2757153 (C.D. Cal. July 8, 2010) After bench trial, court held that using retail class shares

instead of institutional class shares was a fiduciary breach.

Page 45: ERISA Update

45

Litigation – Directed Trustee Issues

On appeal, DOL amicus brief argues directed trustee of 404(c) plan had duties in connection with manager hired by participant and accurate valuation of assets. Tullis v. UMB Bank, N.A., 640 F.Supp. 2d 974, (N.D.

Oh. 2009) Investment manager could be liable for "black-out"

penalty. Roholt Vision Institute, Inc., 401(K) Profit Sharing

Plan, et al. v. Principal Life Insurance Company, et al., No. 5:09-CV-02431, 2010 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 71070 (N.D. Oh. July 15, 2010)

Court allows participant claim that plan fiduciaries and directed trustee breached fiduciary duties by transferring funds to QDIA. Falcone v. DLA Piper US LLP Profit Sharing Plan, No.

09-5555 (N.D. Cal 2010)

Page 46: ERISA Update

46

IRAs – Background Most IRAs not subject to ERISA

IB 99-1 establishes conditions for payroll-deduction IRAs, not subject to ERISA.

Prohibited transaction excise tax provisions under Code § 4975 apply to IRAs A “disqualified person” (including service

providers and fiduciaries) who engages in a prohibited transaction is liable for excise taxes.

Disqualification is penalty if IRA owner engages in a prohibited transaction.

Page 47: ERISA Update

47

IRAs – Background Automatic IRA Act of 2010 (S. 3760/H.R. 3760)

Employers who do not offer a tax-qualified retirement plan would be required to offer an auto-IRA, or pay $100 per employee per year.

Requirement would “phase in,” beginning with firms with 100 or more employees.

Employees participate if age 18, with 3 months employment, must affirmatively opt-out.

Default would be 3% employee contribution; no employer contribution; standardized investments.

Senate program would include approved federally approved providers list.

Page 48: ERISA Update

48

IRAs – Litigation Disqualification affects bankruptcy exemption

In re: Willis, 2009 WL 2424548 (Bankr. D. Fla. Aug. 6, 2009)

IRA Rollover Desk Issue Young v. Principal Financial Group, 547 F.Supp. 2d

965 (S.D. Iowa 2008) Valuation Responsibilities

Cohen v. First Trust Corp. Retirement Accounts, Inc., et. al. No. 09-cv-01356 (D. Colo. June 10, 2009)

Page 49: ERISA Update

49

IRA Issues – Problem Transactions “Co-investments” of Personal and IRA Funds

BUT see DOL AO 2000-10A (July 27, 2000) Transactions with family members, real estate that

the IRA owner may occupy, or other IRA owner business interests See DOL AO 2011-04A (Feb. 3, 2011) and AO

2006-09A (Dec. 19, 2006) IRA owner may not grant security interest in non-

IRA assets to cover potential IRA indebtedness. DOL AO 2009-03A (Oct. 27, 2009)

Decision to take a distribution not “fiduciary” act. DOL AO 2009-02A (Sept. 28, 2009)

Page 50: ERISA Update

50

Questions?Roberta J. Ufford, Esq. - (202) 861-6643

Groom Law Group, Chartered1701 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Suite 1200Washington, DC 20006

[email protected]