enve 302 environmental engineering unit processesbilge.alpaslan/enve 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · aotr...

51
1 ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processes Assist. Prof. Bilge Alpaslan Kocamemi Marmara University Department of Environmental Engineering Istanbul, Turkey CHAPTER: 7 Aeration Systems Air Requirement Calculations

Upload: others

Post on 07-Jun-2021

13 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

1

ENVE 302

Environmental Engineering Unit Processes

Assist. Prof. Bilge Alpaslan Kocamemi

Marmara University

Department of Environmental Engineering

Istanbul, Turkey

CHAPTER: 7

Aeration Systems

Air Requirement Calculations

Page 2: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

AERATION SYSTEMS

Because of low solubility of oxygen , low rate of oxygen transfer;

sufficient oxygen to meet the requirement of aerobic waste

treatment does not enter water through normal air-water

interface.

To transfer the large quantites of oxygen ;

additional interfaces must be formed

air or oxygen can be introduced into liquid

the liquid in the form of droplets can be exposed to the atmosphere 1

Page 3: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Factors Affecting Oxygen Transfer

The rate of gas transfer is generally proportional to the difference

between the existing concentration and the equilibrium

concentration of the gas in solution

. ( )c g sdc A

r K C Cdt V

3

KLa

)tLaK(

0s

ts eCC

CC

Page 4: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

The overall mass transfer coefficient (KLa) is determined in test or

full-scale facilities.

If pilot-scale facilities are used → Scale up must be considered to

determine KLa

4

Page 5: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

5

Determination of KLa in clean water (ASCE, 1992)

Dissolved oxygen (DO) is removed from a known volume of water

by the addition of sodium sulfite

Then the water is reoxygenated to mean the saturation level. During

reoxygenation (reaeration) period, DO concentrations are measured

Time, min DO Concentration, mg/L

….. ….

….. …

Experimental Data:

Page 6: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Using experimental data, Cs-Ct versus t is plotted

Cs-Ct

time

Slope = KLa / 2.303 ═ KLa = (slope) (2.303)

Logarithmic

Scale 6

303.2

K)CClog()CClog(e

CC

CC La0sts

)tLaK(

0s

ts

Page 7: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Determination of KLa in wastewater

Uptake of oxygen by microorganisms must be considered.

Typically, oxygen is maintained at a level of 1 to 3 mg/L and the

microorganisms use the oxygen as rapidly as it is supplied.

Rate of oxygen used by microorgnisms

can be determined in lab by using respirometer

7

If the oxygen level is maintaned at a constant level, dc/dt = 0 and ;

msLa r)CC(Kdt

dc

)CC(

rK)CC(Kr

s

mLasLam

Page 8: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

8

The mass transfer coefficient KLu is a function of:

Temperature

Intensity of mixing (type of aeration device & geometry of mixing basin)

Constituents in water

Page 9: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Effect of Temperature on Oxygen Transfer

ϴ = 1.015 – 1.040

1.024 is a typical for both diffused and mechanical aeration devices.

9

)20T()C20(La)T(La KK

Page 10: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Effects of mixing intensity & tank geometry

α varies with;

Type of aeration device

The basin geometry

The degree of mixing

The ww characteristics

10

α = 0.3 – 1.2

For diffused aeration equip. = 0.4 – 0.8

For mechanical equipment = 0.6 – 1.2

Pöpel Equation

)watertap(K

)wastewater(K

La

La

3/2)1000

(16.01MLSS

Page 11: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Effects of wastewater characteristics

β → is used to correct the test system oxygen transfer rate for

differences in oxygen solubility due to constituents in the water

such as salts, particulates, and surface-active substances

β = 0.7 – 0.8

(0.95 is commonly used for ww)

11

)(

)(

watertapCs

wastewaterCs

Page 12: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

CALCULATION OF ACTUAL AMOUNT OF OXYGEN

REQUIRED UNDER FIELD CONDITIONS

AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O2 / hr

SOTR = standard oxygen transfer rate in tap water at 20 C, and zero dissolved oxygen, kg O2 / hr

β = salinity-surface tension correction factor = Cs (ww) /Cs(tapwater)

Cs,T,H = average dissolved oxygen saturation concentration in clean water in aeration tank at temperature T

and altitude H, mg/L

CL = operating oxygen concentration, mg/L

CS,20 = DO saturation concentration in clean water at 20 C and 1 atm, mg/L

T = operating temperature, C

α = oxygen transfer correction factor for waste

F = fouling factor (typically 0.65 – 0.9) is used to account for both internal & external fouling of air

diffusers.

12

)F)()(024.1)(C

CC(SOTRAOTR 20T

20,s

LH,T,S

Page 13: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

13

internal

caused by impurities in the compressed air

Diffuser Fouling

external

caused by the formation of biological slimes

and inorganic precipitants

Page 14: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

For surface aerators:

CS,T,H = CS,T,H

CS,T,H = oxygen saturation concentration in clean water at temperature T

and altitude H ), mg/L (see Metcalf & Eddy, 2004, Appendix D)

Pd = pressure at the depth of air release, kPa

(Patm,H + Pw,effective depth)

Patm,H = atmospheric pressure at altitude H, kPa (see Metcalf & Eddy, 2004, Appendix D)

OT = % oxygen leaving tank (usually 18 – 20 % )

14

)21

O

P

P(

2

1CC t

H,atm

dH,T,SH,T,S

Page 15: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

The term in the brackets when multiplied by one-half represents the

average pressure at mid depth and accounts for the loss of oxygen to

biological uptake.

If biological uptake is not considered,

Pw,mid depth = pressure at mid depth, above point or air release due to

water column. 15

)(,

,,

,,,,Hatm

depthmidwHatm

HTSHTS P

PPCC

)21

O

P

P(

2

1CC t

H,atm

dH,T,SH,T,S

Page 16: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Oxygen Transfer Efficiency (OTE) of Diffusers

16

Specific Oxygen Transfer Efficiency (SOTE) of Diffusers

(% OTE / m water depth )

284 MLSS10.56.2MLSS10.63.89)m/(%SpOTE

depthwatermxSpOTE(%)OTE

Page 17: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Typical clean water transfer efficiencies (SOTE) for various diffused air devices → M&E, 4th

Edition Table 5.27, pg. 437

17

Page 18: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Example: Calculate the required total blower capacity necessary to supply

oxygen requirement of 2892.7 kg/d for the plant having following characteristics.

18

Fine bubble aeration system

DO in aeration basin = 2 g/m3

Site elevation = 500 m (pressure 95.6 KLu))

α = 0.5, β = 0.95, F = 0.9

Liquid depth for aeration basin = 4.9 m

The point of air release for the aerobic diffuser is 0.5 m above the tank bottom

Page 19: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Solubility of Dissolved Oxygen in Water as a Function of Salinity and

Barometric Pressure Ref: Metcalf & Eddy

19

Page 20: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Ref: Metcalf & Eddy

20

Page 21: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Ref: Metcalf & Eddy

21

Page 22: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Table B-1

Molecular weight, specific weight, and density of gases found in

wastewater at standard conditions (0 C and 1 atm)

Ref: Metcalf & Eddy

22

Page 23: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Table B-2

Composition of dry air at 0o C and 1.0 atmosphere

Ref: Metcalf & Eddy

23

Page 24: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Ref: Metcalf & Eddy

24

Page 25: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Ref: Metcalf & Eddy

25

Page 26: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Aeration Systems Used for WW Treatment

Diffused Air Systems

Blower , air mains, header pipes through

which air passes

Diffusers that are submerged in ww

Mechanical Aeration Systems

Aerations w/ vertical axis

→surface aerator

→submerged aerator

Aeration w/ horizontal axis

→surface aerator

→submerged aerator

High Purity Oxygen Systems

Downflow bubble contactor

U tube contacter

26

•Porous diffusers

•Non-porous diffusers

•Other diffusion devices

Page 27: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Domestic disks membranes

Tubes

Plutes

Typical Porous Air Diffusers

27

Page 28: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Typical Porous Air Diffusers (continue)

28

Page 29: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Diffused – Air Aeration Systems

the size of bubbles varies from

coarse to fine

• fine-bubble diffusers

• coarse bubble diffusers

29

air is introduced into liquid being aerated in the form of bubbles which

typically rise through the liquid

common device for ;

transferring oxygen in aerobic biological treatment

systems stripping of volatile organics

COARSE BUBBLE

FINE BUBBLE

Ref: http://www.brightwaterfli.com/diffused_aeration_systems.htm

Ref:http://www.hellotrade.com/diffused-gas-technologies-incorporated/ss-series-plenum-coarse-bubble-diffusers.html

Page 30: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Diffused – Air Aeration Systems (continue)

Porous diffusers (e.g., plate, dome, disc, tubular diffusers)

Nonporous diffusers (e.g., fixed orifice, valved orifice)

Other diffusers (e.g., jet aeration)

30

gas transfer rate size of bubbles

→ smaller bubbles → greater A/ → more efficient than larger sized

bubbles for mass transfer

Page 31: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

31

Dome, disc diffusers are mounted on or screwed into air manifolds

Ref: Metcalf & Eddy, 1991, McGraw Hill

DOME DIFFUSER DOME DIFFUSER DISC DIFFUSER

Typical Porous Diffusers

Diffused – Air Aeration Systems (continue)

Page 32: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

32

Produce larger bubbles than

porous diffusers

Lower aeration efficiency

Lower cost, less maintanance

Typical Non Porous Diffusers

Ref: Metcalf & Eddy, 1991, McGraw Hill

Valved orifice diffuser

VALVED ORIFICE DIFFUSER

(non porpous diffuser)

Device that contains a check value to

prevent backflow when air is shut off.

Mounts on air distribution piping.

Perforated tube diffuser

Diffused – Air Aeration Systems (continue)

Ref: Metcalf & Eddy, 1991, McGraw Hill

Page 33: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

33

Jet aerator

discharges a mixture of pumped liquid and

compressed air through a nozzle.

Jet aerator Aspirating aerators

Typical Other Diffusion Devices

Diffused – Air Aeration Systems (continue)

Page 34: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

34

Page 35: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

35

Page 36: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

36

Page 37: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

37

Page 38: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

38

Page 39: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

DIFFUSER PERFORMANCE The efficiency of oxygen transfer depends on many factors;

Type, size, and shape of diffuser

The air flowrate

The depth of submersion

Tank geometry including the header and diffuser location

ww characteristics

Aeration devices → evaluated in clean water (SOTE, standard oxyen transfer

efficiency)

→ the results are adjusted to process operating conditions 39

Page 40: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Typical Nonporous Air Diffusers (continue)

Non-porous Diffusers; (produce more bubble than porous

diffusers)

• Orifice

• tube

40

Page 41: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Other Diffusion Devices Other Diffusion Devices

• Jet aerator

• Aspirating aerator

• U-tube

41

Page 42: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Other Diffusion Devices (continue)

42

Page 43: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Blowers;

3 types of blower are commonly used for aeration;

Centrifugal

Rotary lobe positive displacement

Inlet guide vane-variable diffuser

43

Page 44: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Centrifugal blowers (capacity > 425 m3/min

discharge pressure ranges 48-62 kN/m2

similar to low-specific-speed centrifugal pumps

the operating point is determined by the intersection of the

head-capacity curve and system curve

44

Page 45: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

Rotary lobe positive displacement (capacity < 425 m3/min)

for higher discharge pressure applications > 55 kN/m2

is a machine of constant capacity w/ variable pressure

the units can not be throttled but capacity control can be

obtained by the use of multiple units or a variable speed drive

45

Page 46: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

a relatively new blower design

a single stage centrifugal operation that

incorporates activaters to position the inlet

guide vane and variable diffuser to vary

blower flowrate.

well suited to applications with medium to

high fluctuations in inlet temperature,

discharge pressure and flowrate

46

Inlet guide vane-variable diffuser (capacity 85 – 1700 m3/min)

blower capacity 85 – 1700 m3/min at pressures up to 170 kN/m2

turndown rate (Qmin/Qmax) : 40% is possible w/o significant

reduction in operating efficiencies

high initial cost , sophisticated computer control system

Page 47: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

In WWTP, blowers must supply a wide range of airflows under varied

environmental conditions. Provisions have to be included in the

blower system design to regulate or turndown the blowers

47

Methods to achieve regulation or turndown;

Flow blow-off or by passing → effective method of controlling

surging of a centrifugal blower

Inlet throttling are applicable only to adjustable

discharge diffuser centrifugal blowers

variable speed driver → more commonly used on positive

displacement blowers

parallel operation or multiple units

Page 48: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

MECHANICAL AERATORS

By producing a large air-water interface the transfer of oxygen

from atmosphere is enhanced

Can be VERTICAL SHAFT or HORIZONTAL SHAFT

48Ref: http://www.waterandwastewater.com/www_services/newsletter/april_18_2011.htm Ref: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Surface_Aerator.jpg

Page 49: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

MECHANICAL AERATOR PERFORMANCE

are rated in terms of kg O2 / kw – hr at standard conditions, 20 C,

DO = 0, test liquid is tap water.

commercial size surface aerators range in efficiency from 1.2 – 2.4

kg O2 / kwhr

49

For design purposes, the standard performance data must be adjusted

to reflect field conditions by using the following equation;

20TLwalt0 024.1)

17.9

)CC(NN

Page 50: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

N = kg O2/ kw.hr transferred under field conditions

No = kg O2/kw.hr transferred in water at 20 C, and 0 DO.

β = salinity-surface tension correction factor (usually 1)

Cwalt= oxygen saturation concentration for tap water at given

temperature and altitude (Appendix D) (Figure 5.68)

CL = operating oxygen concentration, mg/L

T = temperature, C

α = oxygen transfer correction factor for waste (Table 5.32, pg.447)

Figure 5.68 (Metcalf & Eddy, 2004

Elevation, 103

Oxygen

Solubility

Correction

Factor (Fa)

50

xFa)levelseaat(Cs)alt(Cs

Page 51: ENVE 302 Environmental Engineering Unit Processesbilge.alpaslan/ENVE 302... · 2012. 6. 1. · AOTR = actual oxygen transfer rate under field conditions, kg O 2 / hr SOTR = standard

51

Oxygen transfer data for various types or mechanical aerators → Table 5.31,

pg. 446 (Metcalf & Eddy, 4th Edition)