enc’s for complex - ienc kennisportaal · rijkswaterstaat 9 rws bedrijfsinformatie starting point...

19
Rijkswaterstaat 1 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE Lessons learned after an accident on the Maas. René Visser Encoding Inland ENC’s for complex situations Rijkswaterstaat EEG MAY 18 Question here: to what extent the IENC should be equipped to provide the user with information, so that the user will NOT take an undesirable course when passing a complex infrastructure situation (“lock , barrage and bridge”)

Upload: others

Post on 07-Oct-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

1 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Lessons learned after an accident on the Maas.

René Visser

Encoding Inland ENC’s for complex situations

Rijkswaterstaat

EEG MAY 18

Question here: to what extent the IENC should be equipped to provide the user with information, so that the user will NOT take an undesirable course when passing a complex infrastructure situation (“lock , barrage and bridge”)

Page 2: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

2 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Page 3: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

3 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Schaal 1 7500

Possible IECDIS view at that moment downstream approach to the complex Grave

After research it is known that the use of Inland Ecdis was not related with the accident !

Page 4: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

4 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Verantwoordelijkheid schipper

• As an authority , RWS has an influence on the information that the skipper can have before and during the voyage. This is in addition to the voyage preparation

another location Radar image is not always that clear

Page 5: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

5 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

RWS Research on several complex situations Situation & ATON’s in the real world

General

It is not always that clear what the desired sailing route is

• Difference in use of signs

• Some place there is the sign ‘Weir’ ; at other spots not

• Three different ways of closing the weir channel with ATON’s

Page 6: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

6 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

RWS Research on several complex situations Inland ENC

General

ECDIS users (information mode) can choose the method of symbolization themselves!! So it is not certain that coded information will be shown in the IECDIS

Results

• Important signs for deciding the recommended route are not clearly visible

• Deviations from the actual situation outside

• Conflicting information by encoding both routes (Lock channel & Weir channel)

Page 7: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

7 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Showing detailed information of Notice marks what is the desired sailing route ?

Less Clear

Clear

Page 8: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

8 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Wrong symbolization priority

Page 9: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

starting point IENC’s

• We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes.

• The IENC will not follow this dynamic situation in real time.

• The IENC ‘ll be statically coded, with a recommended route. This is the route through the lock. If the weir is open for navigation, it will not be displayed in the IENC.

Page 10: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

10 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

1. Match ATON’s with ATON’s outside

2. Improve A1-signs with the right oriënt

3. towards the lock

4. towards the lock

5. Remove yellow light or sign from the bridge

6. Remove E1-sign

7. Encode fenceline with

8. Remove fairway from the weir channel

9. Add restricted area’s

10. Add recommended track towards the lock

complex Belfeld

Oude borden

Page 11: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

11 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

OLD..

NEW

Page 12: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

12 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Not recommended adjustments in the IENC!

Apply virtual marking.

One said : Could lead to confusion!

Future?!

Page 13: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

13 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Display ALL Display Basis

Use of TWRTPT ??

The arrow is not recommended for now. But….

Page 14: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

14 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Issues – Solutions?

• Make these notice marks always visable, like the A1 sign

Page 15: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

15 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

How to reduce clutter Is B5 needed in the IENC?

Page 16: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

16 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Better visible symbolization for weirs

Page 17: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

17 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Another S52 symbolisation of weir (gatcon ; catgat = 2) would be welcome) ( colour or a more bold line symbol??)

Page 18: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

18 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

Questions • is inclusion possible for a separate encoding instruction of "complex

waterway infrastructure" in the IEHG IENC Encoding Guide?

• Is there a solution for not showing signs that are related to the opposite sailing direction, because sometimes these are confusing in the Inland ECDIS

Page 19: ENC’s for complex - IENC Kennisportaal · Rijkswaterstaat 9 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE starting point IENC’s • We have to deal with dynamic situations in barrage and lock complexes

Rijkswaterstaat

19 RWS BEDRIJFSINFORMATIE

• Thank you!

• Ideas , remarks are welcome

[email protected]