emerita casilla nunez, a042 893 719 (bia nov. 20, 2013)

8/13/2019 Emerita Casilla Nunez, A042 893 719 (BIA Nov. 20, 2013)

1/14

Pritche, Arundel, Esq.Alaska Immigratio Justice Project431 West 7th Ave, Suite 208

Anchorage, AK 99501

Nme: CASILLA NUNEZ, EMRITA

US pmn of Jus

Executive Ofce r Immgaon Review

Board ofImmigraton AppealsOce of he Clerk

5107 leesbug Pke, Suite 2000Fs Cch Vrgina 2030

OHS/ICE ce of Chief Counse - ANC100SW 5th Aveue, Ste 505 Porta, R 97204

A 042893719

Date of this notce 11/20/2013

cosed s a copy of he Boad's ecsio ad oe i he bove-reeced case.

cosue

Mb:Cle, Patricia A.

Siceely,

D ctDo C

Chief ek

Lulseges Dcket

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished

Cite as: Emerita Casilla Nunez, A042 893 719 (BIA Nov. 20, 2013)


2/14

CASILLA NUNEZ EMERITAP. BX 141783

ANCHRAGE, AK 99514

Name: CASILLA NUNEZ, EMERIA

U.S p f J

Exeutve Ofe Immgato evew

Board of Immigation AppealsOce o he Clek

10 7 Leesburg Pke, Site 2000Falls Chrch Vrgna 20530

OS/ICE ce of Chef Counsel - ANC1001 SW 5th Aveue Ste 505Porland R 97204

A 042-89379

Date of ths notice: 11202013

Ecosed s a opy of the Boad's deisio i he aove-eeed ase. Ths opy s egpovded to you as a courtesy You attoey o epesetave has bee seved wth tisdeso pusuat to 8 CFR. 1292(a) f te attahed desio odes tat you eeoved o the Uted States o ams a mgaio Judge's deso odeig tha youe eoved, ay petton eview of e ataed deisio mus e ed wh ad ecevedy the appopate cout of appeals wi 30 days of he date of te deciso

Ecosue

Pn MbrC, ii A

Sely

D caDoa CaCef Cek

Lulsgsam: Docket



3/14

U.S. Departmen of JusticeExecutiv Oe r Imaon Revew

Deciso of e Bod of mmaon Appals

Falls Chc, Vrg

Fle A04 93 719Polnd OR

re: EMERITA CAIA Z

I REMOVAL PROCEEDG

PEAL

e:

ON BEHALF F REPNENT Ardel rche, Eue

ON BEHALF F DH:

CRGE:

Edwrd L lyDepy Ce Cnel

NV 2 0 Z\3

Nce Sec 1()()(A)()(I) I&N Ac UC 11()()(A)()(I)] Crme nlng mol de

ALICATION: Termnn

e eprmen of omel ecy (DH) ppe e c 15, 01, decn f heImmon Juge nng he eponden moon ermne rem prceedng eppel wll be dme

he reponden ne n czen e Dmncan Republc d lwl peenreen o he Uned e nce 1990 On Aug 0 00, e repnden pped rmn reng lw permen reden nd w cged rg en 1 bedn a 007 cncn ce Apper) A ue weer e eponden' 007 cncn

pu o ple o no cone, r lon o ALASK TATUTES OTTD (AA) l46140()() 2 he n e hd egree cne crime ilng ml ude(CIMT), hereby renderng he eponen remble nder ecn 1()()(A)()(I), of eImmgrn d Nonly Ac UC 11()()(A)()(, n en conced of CIMT We reew ndg of c r cler error, bu ueon f lw, dcren, and uden,n l oher ue n ppe, de no CFR 1003 (d)(3)(), () deermng

hehe he repnden' cncn w r CIMT we ppy he cegorc d modedcegrc pprche e in ayor v. United States, 495 S 575 (990)

On ppel, he DHS gue he mmn Juge eed n deenng ereponden' concn n cegrclly CT In he lee e HS gue h e

he eponen d n cllenge he D deermnon chge her ng len

he epnden a orgnlly chge w olng 146130()(), e n he ecndegree, nd 1116110()() o (B) legl ccounbly be on he conduc nher (eeDHS Apr 6 011 Secnd Spplemenl Eence Submon 3)



4/14

A042 893 719

Immigaion udge eed in not roceeding o e i pong" anaysis set r n Mer ofSv-Teno, 24 I&N Dec. 687 (A.G. 2008) regdg te consieration of evidence beyon erecord of convicton The DS's ateative argment i recse y Olv-Mo . Holde,76 F.3d 199 (9h Cir 2013) (rejectng e ird prong" aysis set r in Mter of Slvrevno, 24 I&N Dec 687 (A.G. 2008) regarding e consideraion of evience beyond he

record of coviction).

We have ong e a in order r a taking o e a e oense t invoves moaude a peanent kng mut be intended. See eg Me of Grl 14 I&N Dec 330333 (BIA 1973). ASA 1 .46.140(a)() rovides in perien p ha a erson commits ecrie f e in te rd eee if te pen cmmit e as ene in ASA 1.46.00. InASA 1.46.10 e" require an inent to deprive oer of proper or to aproriateproper o anoher." Deprve" and appriate" are dened n ASA 11.46.990(8) nSA 1.46.990(2) esecvey. ASA 11.46.990(8) an ASA 11.46.990(2) eac conainoy one sbsecion t eqires nent o permeny epve." e aee wi eImmigraion dge t e in viation of 1.46.140(a)() is no caegoricay a IT

becase o every subsection of e divsibe satte require iten o peanenty derive eowne of the propery (lJ. a 45). See Chmpon v Se, 908 .2d 454 464 (Aaska t. Ap.199) (rejecting the contention a a tes reqire he intent to emnenty derve in ASA l .46.990(8)(A) an oding at the can e remised pof of any of e cuae menastate ie i e ve subsecions f ASA 1.46.990(8)).

ing to e moed caegorica appoac we aee wi e Immiaon dge t erecor of conviction does no estabish hat e reponents conviction was r a CI SeeDecm v Unted Se 133 S. Ct. 2276 2281 (2013) (oing t actin of eode ctegorca aproac s aproate when e atte of conviction sets out one or moreof te eemens in te aeatve"); Seprd v Uned Stes, 44 .S. 13 (2005). e moded

categoica aproac erits e ajudicator o const a imite cass of ocument (i.e.judcay ecgnizbe") to deterine which ateaive eemen rmed e asis of ededans ror convicton. Id A the Imigration Judge ere e tatue n oun isted in the ination e not the same as e statue nder wic e resonen wascvicted (I.. a 5; ee DHS Ari 26 201 Second Sppemen vience Sbmison at22-23). Furher e noed hat ere s o ea coqy or tatement in sor of e pea dat e coece amended inrmain does not provide scien deai to concue at eresponden was convicted nder a ssecio of e saue hat reqires n inent o eentydeive .J. a 6-8; ee DS Ar 26 201 Second Suppemena vience Submission at6-7). We agee. Terere at is e end of te inquiy. See Olo olde uprTh e concde tat e DHS ha o e its burden of demonrating t e resondent is

removabe as chaged r havng commited a IT. No oer cges e pendng aganst erespondent. Accoringy e owig order wi e eneed

R The DHS appea i diie an proceeng are tenate.



5/14

UNIE SAES EPAMEN OF USICEEXECIVE OICE OR IMMIGRAION REVIEW

NIE SAES IMMIRAION COURPORLA ORON

File: A487 Marc 5

In the Mater of

ARUNDL CASILLA NUNE IN REMOVAL PROCEINGS

RESPONDEN

CARGES: Secio () () () (i I to wi - iamssbleat e time of reques for reery for avig

been conced of a crie invovig moraurpiude (applcai fr readmissio byrerg awf perane residence) . -

APPLICAIONS:

ON EALF O RESPONEN: ARUNDEL RICE

) -

,

ON BAL OF HS: EDAR UNLAY " ;

ORA DISION O E IMMIGRAION GE

Ti a deciso o a mtio o erminae e care s

nt constittin a crime involvng oral turpide made by e

reodent Te brief ackoud f is mater s a e

repondent ha aited a e s not a citize or aiona of

i_ j

1


6/14

te Uite States as ae is a atie a ctize of te

omiia epui as cae. Se as amitte tat se as

aoe afu pemaet esiet status o Auust 9

Se as amitte tat se as cicte i Aoae Aasa o

Jaua , 27 of te offese of teft i te ti eee i

ioatio of Aaska Statute . 4. 4(a ) a se as aitte

tat se as setene to a te of impioet of 6 as

it as suspee tee eas poato. Se as aso

atte tat o Auus 2 2 se a aie at iami

Iteatioa Aipot a appie fo amisio as a etui

af pemaet esiet.

ose ae te fie aeatios in te otie to ppea

Se as oee oteste tat tis is a ime ioi oa

tuptue. eefoe se caims tat se is amissie o ot

iaissie as ae a e oiai it is te appiat

fo amissos ue to so tat e o se i ot

iamissie i etui afu pemaet esiets te

e is o te oemet to so cea coici

equoca eiece tat e peso is iaissie as cae

ts pata case te ssue te comes o to a

etemiatio ue aska a ete o ot e cim ioes

categoica a ie ioi moa tuptue a i

ete o ot e te moifie ateoa appoac te cime

A2-7 2 a 22


7/14

,

ca till be determied to have volved, egay as charged ad

determied, a crime ivolvig moral urptde

The Cort is o goig to do etesve ctatio i thi

matter i that he parties have doe so ad the Cour doe ot

fid the eed to do that Thi is ot about whch law o apy

t abo the facts ad circustace of this case

The first sue s that the epartmet of omelad ecurty

ha aged that the Aaka deftio of theft does coste

the crime ivolvig oral turpiude he citatio is

bref, he Chief Couse ccraey cies the las seco

whch is 116140(a) (1, which s a perso cots the crime of

theft the thrd degree f he pero coit theft as defied

Aaska tatte 11610 ad he value of property of

ervce is $5 or ore bu ess ha 5

The defitio of theft s fod at that ectio o 10

where t ays theft wth et to depive aother of propery

or to approprate roperty of aother o oe self or a third

perso, the perso obais he property of aother The other

Sectos 2 through 6 are o pplcale here ad they were ot

the ecto covered

The overmet arges tha the itet to deprive aother of

property is the geeric defitio of theft The Court aes

tha o mea the coo lw defito of larcey, which has te

042-893-19 3 March 15, 212


8/14

eno o permanenly deprve and coe a crme

vovg mora rpde

However he Cor covced a a orogh revew of

e aka aw of hef ad he cao ade by repode of

Champon v ae ced a 908 P 2d 454 199 The Cor

revewed he deco dcae ha here omehg or

of he necey of he en o permaeny deprve o

coe hef ogh ere mc he decon where

e negave mpcaon of wha he la Cor of Appeal

ad ha dcae ch he Cor afed ha when he

Cor of ppea held Mr Chapo covcon par of wch

coed he hef and he hef ad o be an elemen of

crme of brgary a fr he argme wa over he are

of he permae deprvao e Cor fond ad ha Sae

Cor n Alaka fond ha here a eogh deprvaon o

coe he crme of Mr Chapon ad wa he fond fac

a nended o ake propery of an acanance and pawn o

oban moey for drg ad acoho b ha he dd no have he

e o permaenly deprve hey fond a a baal

deprvao of he rg of owerhp an red agan hm

H econd grond wa ha e ae ra jdge aca

adved he ry a he ae had o prove he ne o

permaneny derve e ower of he propery fer er lg

02-893-19 Marc 15 2012


9/14

evalatio of th prmannt intent to deprve, th cort id,

well, h fal on that cu even f thi wa an error, i wa

an error h fvor. Hovr the Court doe not fid y

eqivocaton in their dcision that it did not hav to hve that

prmnt deprivtion.

Therefore, the Cort find tht th Alka ttte, as

pretly contitted, dos not categorcally costitute a crime

nvolving mora trptd and therefore, the Cort mt loo to

he record tlf in ordr to determ whether or not the

covicton for wich the respondnt ffered, i indd a crime

nvolving moral trpitde as the Govrnment allg

o, threfore, ndr te modified ctegorical pproac, it

hen ecoms important to evalate what fact or crcmtnc

of record the Court my ook t. t ca, the convicti

rcord hows tat there w an informato tht originaly

chargd th respondet with a crim of theft in th cod

degree, which involved th os of the value of proprty or

rvc of $00 or more, is th dfitio ndr lka lw of

theft in th econd degre. that nformatio, which i a one

cot informtion, hre is sworn sttemnt attached whch

give th ody of fact of a firly lrge mont of retail tft,

what ppars to the C. Pnney store n Anchorge, Alas,

from un 3 of 2006. And t is charged a a cla C felo d

02-83-19 March 1, 202


10/14

'I

te cagng ocuent s ate, aaenty, tey ut te yea on

te sta as te inte ate is ugust 28 of 2006

Te Cout net fins esponents convcton eco

consttutes wat is labele as an aene infoaton ate

Januay of 200, sa fe in oen cout n in tat

aene infoation, wie stating te sae ate, an te ente

cage s as follows, te boy of facts ae a one sentence

aaga An tey ae as follows, tat on o about June 3,

2006 at o nea ncoage in te 3 uicia Dstct, te

State of lasa, Eeita Casilla coitte te cie of teft

an te value of popety o sevices was $50 o oe t s

une aene infoation an te tee is, folowng tat, te

sae boy of facts fle egt ays late calle coectng

aene infoation, coecting T, te Cout's not falia

wit tat, but te boy of facts int cange

Wat s note to te Cout is tat tee s no language n

tis aene infoaton, ete te coect o te ognal

aene infoation, wc outlines tat ts cage was a

lesse inclue of te oigina nfoaton n ave not

been give any infomation tat, as a atte of law, tat tis

s te case. Tee s no ea collouy o stateent n suot

of te lea, it is a "ule 1 plea" an so tee is o fcs n

te infoatio tat, at least, as been ove to t Cout

02-89319 6 Ma 5, 2012


11/14

aot the ea hich old icorrate the dy o ac i the

or declarato t te orgal ioratio.

A he Court ha aid i the record o roceedg i

there ere ay i o icororati or tateet hich did

icororate thoe act thi Cor o eqivocaly id

hat he ie o thet i th cae a or a large ao o

retail thet ad er a oiie categorica aroac hi

rie did coiue a crie ivlvig ora tritue.

There i a retttio juget to . C. Pey i the a

o $ i hich the ree ith t other ero

jily ad everely liable here i laer a atiacio

hi jge The Cour i hat tha i o cie

ice a crimial covictio ca alo rel i civi liabiity.

he Cort oe o tae tha that iicao aoe he doe

icororae by re erece hoe other a. he Cort doe

that it i ot aroriae o lo a the orga iorai

becae the Crt doe ot o that it tra the ame crie

The Cort i o ave. t beieve that it i iey b a a

matter o roo he Cort aot that.

hereore e Cor al i that thi i ot a mater

o hether Matter o ilvaTrevo 24 I&N Dec. 8 A. G 28

oght to be aied he reao or tht i tha he he

orgia iorao idicate a hi a a large aot

A42-893-9 March 15 212


12/14

eai hef fo J Penney in nchoage laska and he

amended nforaio was sien s o ha dd no ncopoae

by efeence nd hee s no saee in he pea ha ooing

a a poce epo which was abou ha Penney hef woud

be a \/t: infoaio did no folow forwad o hecharge had a lle bi of ifomaon abou a hef a J

Penney's hen ybe a Sla-Teino woud pode he answe

one has o have a eason o evew haeoude1 in heecods heseles

heefore he ou fnds ha wih he eidence

presened and he ou will noe hee s no anscp of any

plea cooquyo any spuaed facs ha wee agreed upon ha

he plea of guy is ased on he oigna infoaion e

ceea e ceea f here wee such facs as he ou has

sad i woud find he odifed cegoica approach ha he

cme dd cosue a cime noving oal upiude

ih he ecod pesened he ou wi indcae ha h

only pause have is ha he resiuion udgmen s fo $6,000

fo J Penney f ha is enough o gge he es of he

nforao hen hs uling s in eo f i is no f

is no o be consideed hen as he ou eees ha

one is o enough ha heefoe he our fnds ha as

aed the ovenen has faied o ee is bde of oo o

A42-89371 8March


13/14

.

showig ha his is a crime ivovig ora urpde I

reea, he Cour ids he asa aue as charged i his

case does o cosie caegorca a cme vog mora

upude

he covicio as uimaey charged ad pead o he Cour

ids he Cour cao deermie mora urpiude om hose

recods

OD

Thereore, hese poceedigs ae ermiaed

'

igraio dge

A4-893-7 9 Mah 15, 202


14/14

I

CIFIAT AG

I ee cetfy at e atached poceedig efoe D

MICHA H B te matter o

AUD ASIA UZ

A042-37

PTAD G

a accae veat tacip of te ecodg a povided

y e xecive ffice fo iatio evie ad ta th

te oigi acpt teeof o te fie of te xecve

ffice fo Iigaio evie.

F A OI Ic

AP 2 2012

oo Dae

emerita casilla nunez, a042 893 719 (bia nov. 20, 2013)

Documents