emanuel 2014 the first autograph of the tosafists from the european genizah
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
1/18
LEIDEN BOSTON
2014
Books within Books
New Discoveries in Old Book Bindings
Edited by
Andreas LehnardtJudith Olszowy-Schlanger
2014 Koninklijke Brill NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
2/18
CONTENTS
L Illura .......................................................................................... x
Crbur ..................................................................................................... xv
Edr Frwrd ............................................................................................ xx
Irdu: Bk wh kTh Sa Rarh
ad Nw Prpv ............................................................................... 1
Andreas Lehnardt and Judith Olszowy-Schlanger
PART I
HISTORY OF RESEARCH
Cara Puda Lr Hbra Srpa: Th Awar h
Bdg Hbrw Fragm Hry. A Ovrvw ad a
Pladyr ....................................................................................................... Saverio Campanini
PART II
STUDIES IN HEBREW FRAGMENTS
Th Fr Augraph h Tafi rm h Eurpa
Gzah ......................................................................................................... 3
Simcha Emanuel
Th Rru a Sefer Haftarotrm h Rh Vally:
Tward a Typlgy Ahkaz Pauh
Maurp ................................................................................................. 43
Judith Kogel
A Nwly Dvrd Fragm rm Midrash Tanhuma h
Cll Wr Eurpa Maurp h RuaSa Lbrary (Mw) ............................................................................ 69
Alina Lisitsina
201 Kkljk Brll NV ISBN 78-0-0-258-5
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
3/18
v contentscontents v
Jphu Tr PFragm Sefer Yosippon Gza
Grmaa ...................................................................................................... 3
Saskia Dnitz
Bdg Au: A Lgr a Jwh Paw Brkr rm
4h Cury Suhr Fra (MS Krakw, BJ Przyb/63/9) ... 9
Judith Olszowy-Schlanger
Hbrw Fragm a a Wdw Em Avy:
Hldg h Hral Arhv Gra
(Arxu Hr d Gra) ...................................................................... 49Esperana Valls i Pujol
PART III
REGIONAL PROJECTS
A Rgal Prpv Hbrw Fragm: Th Ca
Mrava .........................................................................................................
Tams Visi and Magdalna Jnokov
Bdg ad Cvr: Fragm Bk ad Nbk
rm h Agla Lbrary (Bbla Agla, Rm) ................ 3
Emma Abate
Mdval Hbrw Maurp Fragm Swzrlad:
Sm Hghlgh h Dvr .....................................................
Justine Isserles
Nwly Dvrd Hbrw Fragm h Sa Arhv
Ambrg (Bavara)Sm Sugg Thr Hral
Bakgrud ..................................................................................................
Andreas Lehnardt
Eurpa Fragm h Sp h Bk Cll a
Ym Cmmuy ..............................................................................
Michael Krupp
201 Kkljk Brll NV ISBN 78-0-0-258-5
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
4/18
contents x
Gza Yruhalaym: Th Naal Lbrary Iral
Jrualm ...................................................................................................... 99
Abraham David
Fragm a Obj: Mdval Aura Fragm h Jwh
Muum Va .................................................................................... 3
Martha Keil
Idx Pr .............................................................................................. 39
Idx Subj ............................................................................................. 336
201 Kkljk Brll NV ISBN 78-0-0-258-5
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
5/18
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
PART TWO
STUDIES IN HEBREW FRAGMENTS
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
6/18
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
7/18
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
THE FIRST AUTOGRAPH OF THE TOSAFISTSFROM THE EUROPEAN GENIZAH*
S E
Introducton
T x dd by dvy C Gz
wd . My dv x fid Jwd C Gz, w
dd wd y . O v x C Gz
dvy wd . Sv v b d C Gz, d y b
dvdd w . O , , v fi w by v dvd. S
w-kw d x y w by d. A dvd C Gz d x .
N , w , b fi d , w dw. T -
d b w w wkd: w y w fi, w y d, w y ddd
, d .T dvd C Gz
w db Md. S d Md w vd CGz. A y kw, Md vd F, w
* T w d by I S Fd. S, , w by R. Jd Hv H b
N. I wd M G d Ez F, w dd , wv w w by Jd Hv d
w . S M G d Ez F, Yehuda ha-Lev and Hs Crcle: 55Genza Documents (J: Wd U Jw SdT Rbb Dvd Md A R Fd, 2001), 21 ( Hbw).
S, ..: B Ow d Fd N, A Nwy Dvd A F- Md Gd Pxd C Gz. Journal o JewshStudes 57 (2006): 287297; w b, 287288.
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
8/18
smcha emanuel
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
C Gz w d, d dvy v
Gz . T C Gz, wv,
d w dd C. F x: dw R. H G, w vd Bdd; dw R. S b A, Bdd; d v by Pv y Mshneh Torah
d by R. M.3 Obvy, y x d b ddd .
N kw b vd E Gz, d C E.
T Gz w d ( d b)w w d; b b y kwd, x composton d E
Gz . I I w fi dvy x: y Td, dw-
, b d Gy y y. T dvy d dfi -
dv y w , dfi x E Gz.
The Leaves n Melk and Graz
A w y T Bk Bby Td vd by y Mk,A (Mk, Bdk, F. XI). T d b d
bd bk, d by d . A , wv, w dd bd-
, d qy b d b. Uy, y by d
bk d b dd .T w , b y d v v
; y d b y xd d
3 Md A. Fd, R H GNw F Gz.
Teuda (198): 7175 ( Hbw); M G, In the Kngdom o Ishmael (T Avv: TAvv Uvy, 1997), v. 2: Texts rom the Caro Genza, 204212, . 7582 ( Hbw);Ez Hvz, Cy Hlchoth Tefilln Md by Rbb M Nb. Hadorom 40 (1974): 57122 ( Hbw); P R, Later ProvenalSagesRabbnc Creatvty n the South o France n the 13th Century, PD. D,T Hbw Uvy J, 2012, 110111 ( Hbw).
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
9/18
the rst autograph o the tosasts
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
by b, w d b d dy d -
k. Hwv, y dd
w d, d w ( fi. .1). T d x b ky d d y, b dd dd ( bw). Cqy, d .
Add v y y TBk d by vy Gz.
I vd by Jy 2010, d d L w bd d v Hbw (Gz, Uv-
bbk, Cd. 1206). O d bk, bkbd d db , , w v, Hbw . T dd by bd d b d, w
d , v y w wd .
O d bk, bd d dd w v Hbw . T bd w d y
Hbw , w d wd d dw. M fi b, b d
d. Oy w wd b d ,d y bk d dw ( fi. .2).
D y v Gz by d wd, by
b v v,M. Md My, w xy , d dy y q.
My fi q w d Hbw v d bd L, b d d b d. A y wk
I vd M. My d . A
d b vd bd, w zd w -y d v. T bd d k v Hbw, d d d w w bd L . T v d
dd . T bd w, v y wd w, d , wd, . H d ,
dd , w d . T wd d d, wd v vy . T
bd y dd y d w d d dw: w b vd w w d x ( fi. .).
T w w v v , w v bd y. My d q M. My w
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
10/18
smcha emanuel
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
w v, y d v . M. My
dd d w . W w -
w , d dd db , w v w, d . O db w dd w d , d x ( fi. .4).
My d d q M. My w v . Idd, w d ,
d b vb , b d y, d, w d bk bd, bd, d
dfi d. T v bd d y.T y w v T-
Bk (. 6264). A d , y dv , I d w d wd: I
w y b R. Jd: d y Ld b Obd-d [. . .]. T d vb q-
Yhuse Tannam ve-Amoram d by R. Jd b Ky- b M Sy. Nw w dd
y T Bk vd bkbd Mk d Gz w b R. Jd b Ky.
The Nature o the Commentary
T, w w v y
by y Mk, d w v by vy Gzd w , Gz. T
v v. O ( Mk) -y T Bk, . 27b28b;
w y , .29b0 ( d) d x , . 5 (
' ] ' [ " []' . ', ] [ " ' [] [']
[]. Erkhe Tannam ve-Amoram, d. M Yd B, (Nw Yk: M Yd B,
1994), 8485 ( Hbw).
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
11/18
the rst autograph o the tosasts
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
d); d ( Gz) y
x , . 4042; d d ( Gz) -
y d , . 6264. Id b d , y, y .
T v y. A db
ddd fid Rbb dv dd T Bk. T
x vb w w d v. H M, T, Bby
d P Td, Mdrashe HalakhahSra d Sre; d Mdrashe AggadahGeness Rabbah,Avot de-Rabb Nathan, d Prke
de-Rabb Elezer.
A , wd . Fx, y dv (BT Bk 28):
R. J d: w y Mnhah, dwd y Mussa, xy
T Zv: T b TZv, Wv [. 10]. I y
, wv, , -d . T, x, w dv d w b d v d bd (BT Bk 40b),
d d Toseta d Bby T-d d d d. O dd
d kw halakhah Toseta, T T, d w terumah (v-) b d,
k T Sv, d v-y d
b d, d dd dv , v bw dv .
I kd fi d dd . S, x: [ "). ( ] -) , , (, ) (, ] [.
. ") ( ]' . [ ' ' . ' ' '
. ' ' . ', (158 ' , , ( '. [] ' ' . (190 ' -, (,
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
12/18
smcha emanuel
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
T dvd dd d d-
v (BT Bk 28), w A R.
J A v bk Z.T k dd dv Td w R. J d v A, dd dd fi B-
k. S w ddd x, b dw. O dv T P w
d , w dd w ddd d, w dv
:) [[' , (") [...] {} ]] [], [[") ") ( (' ")]] ( ' [...] [[' ") ( . ' ' (")]]. ' ' ")
T y d
, w dd dv , d w .
The Commentator
W, , w w, w w, d - b w b d bk R. Jd b Ky
b M?F, w d w w kw b R. Jd, b
. R. Jd b Ky vd Sy, Gy,d dd y w y. H K-y y, Gy
dy. H w d y d w b k y x. H
' ' {} ' ' ") ( .. '
S E E Ub, The Tosaphsts: Ther Hstory, Wrtngs, and Methods(J: Bk I, 41980), 6178 ( Hbw).
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
13/18
the rst autograph o the tosasts
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
w S b. Ky -Hd, d R. Jd
-Hd w .
R. Jd kw y Yhuse Tannam ve-Amoram (Seder Tannam ve-Amoram, y bk), b w x . T wk xv d vb Td T d
A d . S d wk vb R. Jd d, x
d, d vdd w v d xv x-, x d k y Td .
R. Jd w wk x, d Seerha-Agron d tosaot b .B w w b, y T
Bk w Gz d Mk? W kw w b R. Jd b Ky. O R. M b Ky,3
w w d R. Jd, d w d b y b bk. I , w dd fid yw R. M
y b R. Jd. I ky R. M, d b, w y
T Bk.A b R. Jd w R. Dvd b Ky M-
zb. E E Ub q w R. Dvd w
R. Jd b , v w db. F, R. Jd b R. M v , b v R. Dvd.
Sd, R. Dvd dd dby y R. Jd: w by w -
w R. Jd. Hwv, Ub d db v -
y fi. R. Dvd w dd dby y R. Jd,d vd y y , w y wy R. Jd vd bk. R. Jd dd wd d wy, w R. Dvd w v 1220, w w y
T fi bk w bd by Jd Lb M (Seer Yhuse Tannamve-Amoram, J: Md Hv Kk, 196) d d w bd byB ( bv, . 5). R N N Rbbvz, w w fi b
bk, d Seer Yhuse Tannam ve-Amoram (Lyk: Mkz Nd, 1874), d d wk kw Seder Tannam ve-Amoram. S S E, Fragments o the Tablets: Lost Books o the Tosaphsts (J-
: M P, 2006), 0708 ( Hbw).3 S Ub, The Tosaphsts, 665. S Ub, The Tosaphsts, 6566.
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
14/18
smcha emanuel
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
takkanot() R . W vpyyutm ( y) w by R. Dvd, w
x : (Dvd b Rbb Ky b Rbb M. B d ,
Amen Selah). T, w y - bw R. Jd b Ky d R. Dvd b Ky.
W y by R. Dvd b Ky Mzb w y T Bk,
w x y by Mk d vy by Gz. T w y b
R. Jd w, d x d bk Yhuse Tannam ve-Amoram. Ady, E Gz vd -y wd E w w v fi q
y. T E Gz bby w R. Dvd w d, d y
fi kw wk by Tfi.
S L Fk, Jewsh Sel-Government n the Mddle Ages (Nw Yk: Jw
T Sy A, 1924), 218251. Leket Pyyute Selhot(Preces Poententales quae Selchoth vocantur a poets German-cs et Francogallcs conscrptae), d. D Gdd d Av Fk, (J-: Mkz Nd, 199), 169176 ( Hbw). T d bv pyyut w d d; d b d b d d M ( . 172).
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
15/18
the rst autograph o the tosasts
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
F. .1 Mk, Bdk F. XI ().
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
16/18
smcha emanuel
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
F. .2 Gz, Uvbbk, Cd. 1206 (b d).
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
17/18
the rst autograph o the tosasts
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
Fig.
3.3
Graz,
Universitatsbibliothek
1206(afterpartialdetaching).
-
8/22/2019 Emanuel 2014 the First Autograph of the Tosafists From the European Genizah
18/18
smcha emanuel
2014 Kkjk B NV ISBN 978-90-04-25849-5
F. .4 Gz, Uvbbk 1206 ( d).