effects of skip row planting on cotton - khalilian
TRANSCRIPT
Effect of skip‐row planting on cotton yield, biomass and soil moisture in
South Carolina
J.O. Payero, A. Khalilian, R. Davis, M. Marshall, and A. Nafchi
NRCS‐CIG grant Drought Adaptation Options:
1. Conservation Tillage2. Cover Crop3. Deficit Irrigation4. Variable rate irrigation5. Sensor‐based irrigation6. Drought tolerant varieties7. Skip‐row planting
Objectives:
• Demonstrate skip‐row planting to farmers in SC
• Evaluate agronomic, economic and environmental benefits
2013 (Dryland)
• FARMER – (S, SS)• EREC – (S,SS, AS, DS)
Skip (Included)
Solid
Skip
Skip (Included)
Skip (Included)
Solid (Excluded)
Solid (Included)
Rep 1 Rep 1 Rep 1
Solid (Included)
Solid (Excluded)
Solid (Included)
Solid (Excluded)
2014 Planting Configurations:• S, SS, DS, AS
Water regimes:• Dryland• Deficit irrigation • Full irrigation
2015Solid
Alternate SkipSingle Skip
Water regimes:• Dryland• Deficit irrigation • Full irrigation
Planting:• S, SS, DS, AS
Measurements
• Soil moisture• Biomass• Yield• Economics
Decagon Watermark
Lint yield 2013
Biomass 2014Biomass (g m‐2)
Configuration Full Deficit Dryland Average ΔB (%)Solid (S) 1091 1072 856 1006 a 0%Single Skip (SS) 1020 945 933 966 ab ‐4%Double Skip (DS) 809 722 621 717 c ‐29%Alternate Skip (AS) 938 682 689 770 bc ‐23%
ANOVA (P>F):Planting configurationIrrigation
****
Biomass (g m‐1)Configuration Full Deficit Dryland Average ΔB (%)Solid (S) 1091 1072 856 1006 a 0%Single Skip (SS) 1359 1260 1244 1288 ab 28%Double Skip (DS) 1618 1444 1242 1435 a 43%Alternate Skip (AS) 1877 1363 1378 1540 a 53%
ANOVA (P>F):Planting configurationIrrigation
****
Dryland Biomass (g/m)
Dryland Biomass (g/m2)
2013 ‐Decagon
Cumulative soil water Gain & Use
2014 ‐Watermark ‐
Cumulative Stress
Economics at EREC 2013
Item Solid SingleSkip
AlternateSkip
DoubleSkip
Seed cost ($/ac) $84.00 $56.28 $42.00 $42.00Yield (lb/ac) 964 1129 765 8312013 cotton price ($/lb) $0.90 $0.90 $0.90 $0.90Gross Income ($/ac) $868 $1,016 $688 $748Income - seed cost ($/ac) $784 $960 $646 $706% income of Solid 100% 122% 83% 90%Income over Solid ($/ac) - $176 (-$137) (-$78)
Economics at FARMER 2013
Item Solid Single SkipSeed cost ($/ac) $84 $56.28Yield (lb/ac) 939 10882013 cotton price ($/lb) $0.90 $0.90Gross Income ($/ac) $845 $979Income - seed cost ($/ac) $761 $923% income of Solid 100% 121%Income over Solid ($/ac) - $162
$0
$200
$400
$600
$800
$1,000
$1,200
Solid Single Skip Alternate skip Double Skip
E5 field Bates field
+$176/acre
‐$137/acre‐$78/acre
Income ‐ Cost of seeds ($/acre)
Conclusions:
• The skip‐planting treatments tended to:– Conserve soil water– Produce bigger plants (higher biomass/m)– Reduce biomass per unit area (g/m2).
• Biomass (and yield) of SS were similar to S.• SS reduced seed cost and increased income, but DS, and AS reduced income.