dynamics of land use change the case of commonwealth avenue road widening

Upload: cynthiafeliciano

Post on 02-Jun-2018

226 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/10/2019 DYNAMICS of LAND USE CHANGE the Case of Commonwealth Avenue Road Widening

    1/9

    DYNAMICS OF LAND USE CHANGE:

    THE CASE OF COMMONWEALTH AVENUE ROAD WIDENING

    (Section of Katipunan to Litex Roads)

    Commonwealth Avenue was part of the grand plan of President Manuel Quezon to transfer the

    seat of government to a new city, the present day Quezon City. He had envisioned a city with all the

    major government institutions in one location, after he was advised that Manila was not an ideal

    location for the seat of government. Manila was then under the constant threat of attacks from the

    Manila Bay. He then commissioned American architects William Parsons and his assistant Harry Frost to

    draft the plan for his ideal city.

    Commonwealth Avenue, played a vital role in linking the Government Center (the present day

    Elliptical Circle) to the proposed Legislative Building, where The Congress compound now sits. Originally

    intended to be an avenue flanked with the embassies of countries with whom we maintain diplomatic

    relations, present day Commonwealth Avenue was among those project plans that never materialized,

    as it was intended. Nevertheless, it evolved into a business hub that Quezon City can be proud of.

    Build in the late 1960s, Commonwealth Avenue, formerly known as Don Mariano MarcosAvenue, has undergone a number of road widening programs that transformed a four- lane highway to

    the eighteen- lane highway it is today. It proposed to link the Quezon Memorial Circle northwards to

    Quirino Highway, as part of the radial road 7 plan (R7). In the following decades, Quezon City

    population increased exponentially, as developers, representing the formal economy, began to market

    Quezon City as an ideal place to take up residence, offering very affordable home lots to low and middle

    income families.

    Farm lands of the Zuzuarreguis (covering parts of D2, QC) were transformed into residential

    subdivisions, easily distinguishable by the subdivision names bearing the prefix Don and Dona.

    Other developers followed suit. Thus, subdivision developments in the area mushroomed left and right

    of the highway, while multiple road right of way allowed access to interior subdivision developments,

    expanding both eastward, towards San Mateo and Marikina and westward, towards Caloocan.

    The stretch of Commonwealth Avenue from Katipunan to Litex and its neighboring communities

    cover most of District 2 Quezon City. It includes the barangays of Matandang Balara, Batasan Hills

    (largest urban poor community in the country), Bagong Silang Commonwealth, Payatas and Holy Spirit.

    Based on the local government data, the population of these barangays is estimated to have grown to

    1,785,242 with an annual growth rate of 4.12% and a population density of 18,545.

    Urban Development

    Commonwealth Avenue provided access to a number of government buildings namely the

    Commission on Audit, the Department of Social Welfare and Development, the Electoral Tribunal and

    the House of Representatives. This government initiated investment translated to the development of

    the area surrounding the IBP Complex, particularly the IBP-San Mateo Road, which is an alternate route

    to Marikina and San Mateo, and a number of residential subdivisions (Filinvest) which provided housing

    for government employees, members of congress and their legislative staff.

    Sometime in the 1980s, the road was widened to a 12-lane highway, to keep up with the urban

    sprawl and worsening traffic congestion experienced in Quezon City.

  • 8/10/2019 DYNAMICS of LAND USE CHANGE the Case of Commonwealth Avenue Road Widening

    2/9

    Urban development though the influx of population best characterizes development along

    Commonwealth Avenue. The surge of human settlements resulted in a free-for-all urban

    development, where formal housing developments were punctuated by shanty towns. Subdivision walls

    delineate economic boundaries of residential developments.

    The moneyed communities, in their interest to protect themselves from criminality, build gates

    that regulate the flow of people into the subdivisions. Under PD 1216- Sec2, it has becomemandatory for subdivision owners/developers to donate roads to the local government upon the

    completion of the project, as certified by the Authority. The rule only makes the exception for parks

    and playgrounds as open space which could be donated to the homeowners association, upon the

    consent given by the local government. As such, no homeowners association should refuse entry to

    roads donated to the local government, which in effect became public property upon its donation, and

    thus should be accessible to all.

    In reality, homeownersassociations remain in control of securing subdivision roads , thereby

    rendering the local government toothless in enforcing its jurisdiction over previously turned over roads,

    and the use of the same in gaining access to a network of roads which could ease the traffic congestion

    in some areas during rush hours.

    According to the Local Governments Subdivision Administration Unit, homeowners association

    cannot refuse entry to these roads, precisely because these roads are for public use, to be enjoyed not

    only by residents of the subdivisions, but also by the general public.

    In my opinion, the local governments inability to provide security to these community at a level

    they require, makes them cede authority over such matters, to the detriment of the general public, who

    have every right to use these roads, specially as alternate routes to avoid traffic congestion.

    Human Settlements

    Human settlement, prior to the road expansion can be characterized as mostly, single family

    dwellings of modest to average size. Today, formal housing types vary from single family dwellings, totown houses/duplex, low rise condos and high rise condominium. This translates to increased

    population densities, a larger demand for utilities and services, a greater demand for education and

    employment, more economic activity, more revenues for the government in terms of real property tax

    and other taxes, an increase in road use and pollution, and an increase in solid waste production.

    The market for high end residential living became an off-shoot of the road expansion. As the

    city transitions into an urbanized area, it becomes more attractive to the high end market. Apart from

    high density condos, high end residential developments have likewise become major players in the citys

    economy, bringing in more revenues, with minimal demand for consumption spending on the part of

    the government. (Tivoli Royale, Vista Real Estates, Ayala Heights)

    Traffic

    The road expansion of Commonwealth Avenue can be viewed as a two-edged sword, as far as

    traffic is concerned. Though Commonwealth Avenue is notoriously dubbed the Killer Highwayto this

    day, it has brought about benefits beyond the expectations of those who regularly use the road.

    It has greatly eased traffic congestion specially during rush hours, with the exception of the

    bottleneck caused by the narrow Tandand Sora flyover. The wider avenue likewise allowed more buses

  • 8/10/2019 DYNAMICS of LAND USE CHANGE the Case of Commonwealth Avenue Road Widening

    3/9

    and jeepneys to ply more routes and in greater number, making the suburban city more accessible and

    investor-friendly.

    The DPWHs response to the death of Lourdes Simbulan led to the road assessment of

    Commonwealth Avenue by a third party group of consultants in 2011. It proved vital in minimizing the

    occurrence of accident by implementing the recommendations given in the study. Some of these

    measures included the stricter implementation of the speed limit, the bus-PUJ and motorcycle

    segregation by means of designating lanes, the MMDAs re-study of U-turn slot locations , increasing the

    weaving distance, the provision of road warning signs and fences to discourage jaywalking, and the

    reconfiguration of pedestrian overpass.

    The significant drop in the occurrence of accidents prompted the MMDA in 2013 to implement

    the same speed limit for stretch from Batasan to Dona Carmen.

    Mixed reactions came from different segments of society. Civil society groups proposed that

    government should regulate the issuance of LTFRB bus franchises, while Partyt list member 1UTAK

    aired concern with regard to the practice of making bus drivers work 10-16 hours on the average to

    meet the daily boundaries set by bus companies. Rep. Teddie Casino reacted by drafted a bill for PU busdrivers to receive fixed salaries, and do away with the boundary system.

    DSWD Inefficiency

    It is noteworthy that urban poor children as young as 3 years old can be seen begging on the

    highway and getting on and off public utility vehicles to beg from commuters, while their mothers chit-

    chat with friends from a distance. This practice exposes these children to unnecessary risks, condones

    child labor and abuse, and irresponsible parenthood.

    There are likewise solvent-sniffing children who are often seen loitering near the pedestrian

    overpass, either begging or engaging in petty crimes.

    The DSWD, which holds office just a few kilometers away allows these things to occur right

    under their noses, in spite of repeated reports made by the citizenry.

    The Formal Economy

    From small, single story leasable space to multi-story office buildings, full- fledged companies

    and major banking institutions-this is perhaps the biggest contribution of the road widening program to

    the urbanization and shift in land use patterns for the area in study.

    The wide avenue opened the doors to investments from BPO companies which in turn

    generated employment for the young urban population. With a high purchasing power, theseemployees gave rise to businesses such as malls, coffee shops, restaurants, bars and 24-hour

    establishments that cater to their needs. Condominiums and townhouses became in fashion as housing

    units for urban professionals.

    Car dealerships became an indicator of progress as a growing population acquired more money

    that enabled them to spend for these luxuries. Major commercial banks supplied the option for

    housing, car and business loans that continued to propel the economy.

  • 8/10/2019 DYNAMICS of LAND USE CHANGE the Case of Commonwealth Avenue Road Widening

    4/9

    Home depots are slowly replacing small hardware companies, sash companies and furniture

    shops in the area, which is actually indicative of an economic gentrification. So have established dub

    shops substituted small-scale vulcanizing, machine and car maintenance shops. It is unclear if these

    enterprises developed on their own or, if these small scale businesses are being eased out by business

    owners who have the capital, who in turn just hire the manpower to provide the service. It probably

    requires a more in depth study to know the implications of such a shift.

    Supermarkets thrive side by side with the public markets and talipapa since these cater to

    people from different economic backgrounds. Malls with different clientele likewise sprout like

    mushrooms, seemingly oblivious to the possible traffic they will create once operational.

    In my opinion, the proposed construction of an SM mall along Amsterdam Road, next to the

    Residences at Commonwealth development is expected to create a traffic bottle neck for residents

    from Vista Real, Tivoli Royale, Capitol Park Homes among other neighboring villages, due to a very

    narrow street servicing the area.

    More private schools are founded to meet the growing number of students requiring theirservices, as affordable fast food restaurants near schools provide them budget-friendly meals.

    Different religions fight over followers, as both major and minor groups establish their places of

    worship in an attempt to gain a steadier foothold. As a result, more often than not, the informal

    economy takes advantage of the heavy foot traffic by setting up businesses ranging from selling street

    food, fruits and vegetables, religious articles, DVDs and the like right outside the compounds of these

    churches. As a result, crowd control and petty crime soon become the problem of the government.

    The construction of mortuaries and columbaries proved significant, as 24-hour establishments

    and flower shops flourish to meet the demands of a steady clientele.

    Informal Settlements and Informal Economies

    As I had observed informal settlements began to proliferate along the highway, particularly near

    Luzon Avenue and the creek near BF Homes Quezon City. Before we knew it, areas without known

    structures became magnets for informal settlers. With the designation of Payatas as a garbage

    dumpsite in the 1990s, the informal settlement population ballooned. The ravine which was deemed

    unfit for habitation, turned into a squatter colony overnight, as scavengers flocked to the dumpsite to

    earn their living.

    It also gave rise to informal businesses along the Manggahan Road and Litex Roads

    intersections, as street hawkers turned the highway into a big market place, causing horrendous traffic

    in the area. There were numerous attempts by local government to clear the highway of vendors. But,time and again, whoever is assigned to head the clearing operation, turned up dead.

    Of the 6 lanes of the highway, only one or two lanes became passable. Then Mayor Sonny

    Belmonte conducted an public dialogue which included the barangay, market and hawker officials and

    the police and law enforcement, in order to reach an agreement with regard to the problem. It was

    settled that plant boxes will be situated along the highway to prevent vendors from encroaching on

    streets.

  • 8/10/2019 DYNAMICS of LAND USE CHANGE the Case of Commonwealth Avenue Road Widening

    5/9

    Late last year, a QCPD officer assigned to Task Force Commonwealth, in charge of operations

    against illegal vendors was ambushed. A few days later, 20 illegal vendors on the Litex pedestrian

    overpass were charged for selling their wares on non-designated areas. To date, the flower boxes have

    been replaced by steel fence, but vendors continually sell their wares right where they can be seen by

    law enforcers.

    In the case of informal settlement and informal economies, obviously the local government is atthe losing end in such a scenario. Apart from being unable to extract real property tax, they are likewise

    not receiving proceeds from the conduct of business from these informal businesses. Furthermore,

    these communities pose as a liability since a great number of them are dependent on social services

    provided by the government.

    Solid Waste Management

    Disposal of garbage account for a large portion of local government expenditures. As such, the

    council passed ordinance SP2235, Series of 2013 requiring all households in Quezon City to share in the

    burden of solid waste disposal by charging a garbage fee, based on the area of their real property. Of

    course, this will be a subject of debate since garbage collection used to be a service provided for by the

    local government, at no added cost to its citizenry.

    The Local Government and the MMDA

    It is perhaps the local government and the MMDA that are equally at fault for its failure to

    enforce laws pertaining to illegal parking, jaywalking, vendor control, littering and the like. The unclear

    delineation of responsibility between the two bodies is probably the issue we must look into, as far as

    legal mandate is concerned. The overlapping of responsibility leaves the citizenry with the burden of

    having to deal with minor issues which in turn create bigger problems for the society.

    Site of Demonstrations:

    There must have been a reason why President Manuel Quezon wanted embassies to line the

    avenue towards Congress. It was probably his brand of leadership, to highlight the growing pains

    plaguing our nation today. After all, it was he who said that he preferred a government run like hell by

    Filipinos to a government run like heaven by Americansbecause, however bad a Filipino government

    might be, we can always change it.

    Commonwealth Avenue lives up to its name, whenever people rally for the common good at

    every State of the Nation Address delivered in Congress.

    The issues with regard to poverty, unemployment, lack of access and inadequacy of basic social

    services, social justice, peace and order, and the environmental degradation will remain with us for now.

    It will take time before we achieve the equilibrium we dream of realizing, where the general welfare isguaranteed and where the economic gap between the rich and the poor is almost nil.

    But, it is only by being true to ourselves, and through our own admission of our shortcomings

    that we can correct our mistakes and move forward. It is not in fabricating statistics that support our

    claim for development, so as to satisfy our egos and receive standing ovations from the members of

    Congress.

  • 8/10/2019 DYNAMICS of LAND USE CHANGE the Case of Commonwealth Avenue Road Widening

    6/9

    . For now, we validate the conflict theory, as we undergo the never ending series of actions and

    reaction, until such time all parties to the exercise are satisfied and an equilibrium is achieve, if there is

    such a thing.

    *******

  • 8/10/2019 DYNAMICS of LAND USE CHANGE the Case of Commonwealth Avenue Road Widening

    7/9

  • 8/10/2019 DYNAMICS of LAND USE CHANGE the Case of Commonwealth Avenue Road Widening

    8/9

  • 8/10/2019 DYNAMICS of LAND USE CHANGE the Case of Commonwealth Avenue Road Widening

    9/9