8/9/2019 Due Process American Tobacco vs Director of Patents

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/due-process-american-tobacco-vs-director-of-patents 1/2

 Title : AMERICAN TOBACCO COMPANY vs THE DIRECTOR OF PATENTSCitation : G.R. No. L-!"#$

O%to&e' ()* (+,Ponente : ANTONIO* .:

Fa%ts :

ATC et al /le0 &e1o'e t2e P2ili33ine Patent O4%e %on%e'nin5 t2e 6se o1 t'a0e7a'8 an0 t'a0e na7e. ATC et al %2allen5e0 t2e vali0it9 o1 R6le (!" o1 t2e Revise0R6les o1 P'a%ti%e &e1o'e t2e P2ili33ine Patent O4%e in T'a0e7a'8 Cases; asa7en0e0* a6t2o'i<in5 t2e Di'e%to' o1 Patents to 0esi5nate an9 'an8in5 o4%ial o1 sai0 o4%e to 2ea' inte' 3a'tes; 3'o%ee0in5s. Sai0 R6le li8e=ise 3'ovi0es t2at all

 >6057ents 0ete'7inin5 t2e 7e'its o1 t2e %ase s2all &e 3e'sonall9 an0 0i'e%tl93'e3a'e0 &9 t2e Di'e%to' an0 si5ne0 &9 2i7.; T2ese 3'o%ee0in5s 'e1e' to t2e2ea'in5 o1 o33osition to t2e 'e5ist'ation o1 a 7a'8 o' t'a0e na7e* inte'1e'en%e3'o%ee0in5 instit6te0 1o' t2e 36'3ose o1 0ete'7inin5 t2e ?6estion o1 3'io'it9 o1 a0o3tion an0 6se o1 a t'a0e-7a'8* t'a0e na7e o' se'vi%e-7a'8* an0 %an%ellation o1 'e5ist'ation o1 a t'a0e-7a'8 o' t'a0e na7e 3en0in5 at t2e Patent O4%e. Petitione's

/le0 t2ei' o&>e%tions to t2e a6t2o'it9 o1 t2e 2ea'in5 o4%e's to 2ea' t2ei' %ases*alle5in5 t2at t2e a7en07ent o1 t2e R6le is ille5al an0 voi0 &e%a6se 6n0e' t2e la=t2e Di'e%to' 76st 3e'sonall9 2ea' an0 0e%i0e inte' 3a'tes %ase. Sai0 o&>e%tions =e'eove''6le0 &9 t2e Di'e%to' o1 Patents* 2en%e* t2e 3'esent 3etition 1o' 7an0a76s* to%o73el t2e Di'e%to' o1 Patents to 3e'sonall9 2ea' t2e %ases o1 3etitione's* in lie6 o1 t2e 2ea'in5 o4%e's.

Iss6e :

@2et2e' o' not t2e 2ea'in5 0one &9 2ea'in5 o4%e's a'e =it2in 06e 3'o%ess.

Hel0 :

 T2e SC '6le0 t2at t2e 3o=e' to 0e%i0e 'esi0es solel9 in t2e a07inist'ativea5en%9 veste0 &9 la=* t2is 0oes not 3'e%l60e a 0ele5ation o1 t2e 3o=e' to 2ol0 a2ea'in5 on t2e &asis o1 =2i%2 t2e 0e%ision o1 t2e a07inist'ative a5en%9 =ill &e7a0e. T2e '6le t2at 'e?6i'es an a07inist'ative o4%e' to ee'%ise 2is o=n >6057entan0 0is%'etion 0oes not 3'e%l60e 2i7 1'o7 6tili<in5* as a 7atte' o1 3'a%ti%ala07inist'ative 3'o%e06'e* t2e ai0 o1 s6&o'0inates to investi5ate an0 'e3o't to 2i7t2e 1a%ts* on t2e &asis o1 =2i%2 t2e o4%e' 7a8es 2is 0e%isions. It is s64%ient t2att2e >6057ent an0 0is%'etion /nall9 ee'%ise0 a'e t2ose o1 t2e o4%e' a6t2o'i<e0 &9

la=. Neit2e' 0oes 06e 3'o%ess o1 la= no' t2e 'e?6i'e7ents o1 1ai' 2ea'in5 'e?6i'et2at t2e a%t6al ta8in5 o1 testi7on9 &e &e1o'e t2e sa7e o4%e' =2o =ill 7a8e t2e0e%ision in t2e %ase. As lon5 as a 3a't9 is not 0e3'ive0 o1 2is 'i52t to 3'esent 2iso=n %ase an0 s6&7it evi0en%e in s633o't t2e'eo1* an0 t2e 0e%ision is s633o'te0 &9t2e evi0en%e in t2e 'e%o'0* t2e'e is no ?6estion t2at t2e 'e?6i'e7ents o1 06e3'o%ess an0 1ai' t'ial a'e 16ll9 7et. In s2o't* t2e'e is no a&ne5ation o1 'es3onsi&ilit9on t2e 3a't o1 t2e o4%e' %on%e'ne0 as t2e a%t6al 0e%ision 'e7ains =it2 an0 is 7a0e&9 sai0 o4%e'. It is* 2o=eve'* 'e?6i'e0 t2at to 5ive t2e s6&stan%e o1 a 2ea'in5*=2i%2 is 1o' t2e 36'3ose o1 7a8in5 0ete'7inations 63on evi0en%e t2e o4%e' =2o

8/9/2019 Due Process American Tobacco vs Director of Patents

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/due-process-american-tobacco-vs-director-of-patents 2/2

7a8es t2e 0ete'7inations 76st %onsi0e' an0 a33'aise t2e evi0en%e =2i%2 >6sti/est2e7.;