dry cask storage of nuclear spent fuel · susquehanna dry cask storage susquehanna uses a...

32
Earl Easton Division of Spent Fuel Storage and Transportation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel

Upload: others

Post on 25-Apr-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Earl Easton

Division of Spent Fuel Storage and Transportation

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Dry Cask Storage

of Nuclear Spent Fuel

Page 2: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

2

U.S. Commercial Nuclear

Power Plants

Page 3: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

3

Commercial Nuclear Power

Generation

Page 4: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

4

Current Expiration Dates for

existing Reactor Licenses

Page 5: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

5

Proposed New Nuclear Power Plants

Page 6: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

6

Existing Commercial Spent Fuel

Storage Facilities

Page 7: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

7

Spent Fuel Storage by State

Page 8: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Spent Fuel Storage by State

Page 9: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Impacts Associated with Transfer of Spent Nuclear Fuel from Spent Fuel Storage

Pools to Dry Storage After Five Years of Cooling, EPRI 11/10

SOURCE:

Spent Fuel Storage over Time

Page 10: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Spent Fuel Management

Current practice is to move

fuel to dry storage when

reactor storage pools become

filled.

Page 11: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Spent Fuel Storage Casks

Page 12: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

12

Preparation of Empty

Canister

Page 13: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

13

Fuel Loading in Transfer Cask

Page 14: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Welding of Canister Lid

Page 15: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

15

Transfer of Canister

into Overpack

Page 16: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

16

Transfer of Overpack to

ISFSI Pad

Page 17: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Storage Cask Array on

ISFSI Pad

Page 18: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

NAC MPC Dual-Purpose Canister System

Connecticut Yankee ISFSI

Page 19: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Susquehanna Dry Cask

Storage

Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model

NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment of the transport cask so

that the canister containing the spent nuclear fuel can be pushed into the

storage module by a hydraulic ram.

Page 20: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Impacts Associated with Transfer of Spent Nuclear Fuel from Spent Fuel Storage Pools

to Dry Storage After Five Years of Cooling, EPRI 11/10

SOURCE:

Page 21: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Evolving Spent Fuel

Management Program

• Blue Ribbon Commission on America’s

Nuclear Future

• Revising the Paradigm on Spent Fuel

storage

• Waste Confidence Decision

Page 22: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

BRC Recommendations

• DOE or FEDCORP may submit an

application for a dry cask storage facility

to NRC - focused on orphan sites?

• Proceeding could be similar to Private

Fuel Storage Application

22

Page 23: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Revising the Paradigm Program goals

• Technical basis and regulating long-term storage (100+ years)

• Transition to risk-informed and performance-based regulation

• Evaluate spent fuel storage and transport regulations

• Address issues with transporting very old fuel

• Cradle to grave view including stakeholder input

Page 24: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

• Near-Term

– Evaluate key aging issues important for eventual transportation

– Identify issues requiring further research (e.g. high burnup fuel)

• Long-term

– Demonstration program

– Known condition of spent fuel consistent with transportation requirements

Revising the Paradigm Propose evaluations

Page 25: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Example: Cladding Integrity

• Safety Functions

– Primary fission product barrier

– Geometry control

– Defense in Depth

• Technical Challenges

– Higher burnup levels

– Temperature effects

– New cladding types

– In-situ monitoring in sealed

canisters 25

Page 26: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Example: Canister Integrity

• Safety Functions

– Confinement

– Inert environment

– Criticality control

• Technical Challenges

– Long-term corrosion

– Basket properties

– Absorber efficiency

– Monitoring sealed internals

26

Page 27: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Example: Overpack

Performance

• Safety Functions

– Shielding

– Heat transfer

– Robustness against severe

events

• Technical Challenges

– Long-term degradation

– Response to external natural

events and external disruption

27

Page 28: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Waste Confidence Rule

28

Page 29: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

29

Waste Confidence Rule

Page 30: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Waste Confidence Rule

Page 31: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

31

Waste Confidence Rule

- Schedule

Page 32: Dry Cask Storage of Nuclear Spent Fuel · Susquehanna Dry Cask Storage Susquehanna uses a horizontal storage module, a Transnuclear model NUHOMS 52-B. Note the transporter and alignment

Questions ?

32