drafting dispute resolution clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
www.adr.org
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses
A p r A c t i c A l G u i d e
Amended and effective September 1, 2007
![Page 2: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
This booklet is intended to assist parties in drafting alternative dispute resolution (ADR) clauses. With that in mind, and in addition to the suggested clauses, the committee compiled a checklist of considerations for the drafter, as well as examples of supplemental language which go beyond the basic clauses. Users will benefit from the commentary throughout the text which helps to identify points of interest. Parties with questions regarding drafting an AAA clause should contact their local AAA office. Offices are listed on the AAA’s website, www.adr.org.
![Page 3: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Table of Contents
Introduction 3
I. AChecklistfortheDrafter 4
II. MajorFeaturesofArbitration 5
AWrittenAgreementtoResolveDisputes bytheUseofImpartialArbitration 5
InformalProcedures 6
ImpartialandKnowledgeableNeutrals toServeasArbitrators 6
FinalandBindingAwards thatareEnforceableinaCourt 6
III. ClausesApprovedbytheAAA forGeneralCommercialUse 7
Arbitration 7
Negotiation 10
Mediation 11
Large,ComplexCases 11
IV. ClausesforUseinSpecificContexts 13
A. ClausesforUseinInternationalDisputes 13
B. ClausesforUseinConstructionDisputes 16
C. ClausesforUseinEmploymentDisputes 18
D. ClausesforUseinPatentDisputes 20
V. OtherProvisionsThatMightBeConsidered 22
![Page 4: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
A. SpecifyingaMethodofSelection andtheNumberofArbitrators 23
B. ArbitratorQualifications 25
C. LocaleProvisions 26
D. Language 26
E. GoverningLaw 27
F. ConditionsPrecedenttoArbitration 27
G. PreliminaryRelief 28
H.Consolidation 29
I. DocumentDiscovery 30
J. Depositions 31
K. DurationofArbitrationProceeding 32
L. Remedies 32
M.“Baseball”Arbitration 33
N. ArbitrationWithinMonetaryLimits 34
O. AssessmentofAttorneys’Fees 35
P. ReasonedOpinion AccompanyingtheAward 36
Q. Confidentiality 36
R. Appeal 37
S. Mediation-Arbitration 38
T. StatuteofLimitations 38
U. DisputeResolutionBoards 39
V. MassTorts 39
Conclusion 40
![Page 5: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Introduction
Everyyear,millionsofbusinesscontractsprovideformediationandarbitrationaswaysofresolvingdisputes.AlargenumberofthesecontractsprovideforadministrationbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociation(AAA),apublic-service,not-for-profitorganizationofferingabroadrangeofconflictmanagementprocedures.AAAservicesareavailablethroughofficeslocatedinmajorcitiesthroughouttheUnitedStatesandDublin,Ireland,aswellasthrougharrangementswithotherinstitutionsworldwide.Hearingsmaybeheldatlocationsconvenientfortheparties.Inaddition,theAAAprovideseducationandtraining,producesspecializedpublicationsandconductsresearchonout-of-courtdisputesettlement.
Typically,theparties’agreementtomediateorarbitrateiscontainedinafuture-disputesclauseintheircontract;theclausemayprovidethatanydisagreementwillberesolvedunderthemediationorarbitra-tionrulesoftheAmericanArbitrationAssociation.
TheAmericanArbitrationAssociationisknownforthehighqualityofitspanelsofmediatorsandarbitrators,includingaLarge,ComplexCasePanel.AspecialAAAinternationalcenter,theInternationalCentreforDisputeResolutionSM,administerscasesaroundtheglobeandanywhereintheU.S.
Thefirstsectionofthisbookletcontainsabriefchecklistofsomeofthemoreimportantelementsapractitionershouldkeepinmindwhendraftingoradoptinganydisputeresolutionclause,nomatterhowbasic.Thesecondsectiondescribesthemajorfeaturesofarbitration,andthethirdsectionprovidesaseriesofclausesthattheAAAfeelsareappropriateforuseinageneralcommercialsettingandwhichmeetdifferentneedsandconcernsinsuchacontext.ThefourthsectioncontainsaseriesofclausesthattheAAAdeemsappropriateforuseintheparticularcontextsofinternationaldisputes,constructiondisputes,employmentdisputes,andpatentdisputes.ThefinalsectionconsistsofexamplesofsupplementallanguagewhichgobeyondthebasicdisputeresolutionclausesinSectionsIIIandIV.WhiletheAAA
3
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
![Page 6: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
doesnotnecessarilyrecommendsuchexpandedprovisions,itrecog-nizesthatsuchadditionsareusedfromtimetotimetomeetspecificwishesorneedsoftheparties.Explanatorytextsetsforthfactorsonemighttakeintoaccountwhenconsideringwhethertoincludesuchsupplementallanguage.
I. A Checklist for the Drafter
Itisnotenoughtostatethat“disputesarisingundertheagreementshallbesettledbyarbitration.”Whilethatlanguageindicatestheparties’intentiontoarbitrateandmayauthorizeacourttoenforcetheclause,itleavesmanyissuesunresolved.Issuessuchaswhen,where,howandbeforewhomadisputewillbearbitratedaresubjecttodisagreementonceacontroversyhasarisen,withnowaytoresolvethemexcepttogotocourt.
Someofthemoreimportantelementsapractitionershouldkeepinmindwhendrafting,adoptingorrecommendingadisputeresolutionclausefollow.
> Theclausemightcoveralldisputesthatmayarise,oronlycertaintypes.
> Itcouldspecifyonlyarbitration–whichyieldsabindingdecision–oralsoprovideanopportunityfornon-bindingnegotiationormediation.
> Thearbitrationclauseshouldbesignedbyasmanypotentialpartiestoafuturedisputeaspossible.
> Tobefullyeffective,“entryofjudgment”languageindomesticcasesisimportant.
> Itisnormallyagoodideatostatewhetherapanelofoneorthreearbitrator(s)istobeselected,andtoincludetheplacewherethearbitrationwilloccur.
> Ifthecontractincludesageneralchoiceoflawclause,itmaygovernthearbitrationproceeding.Theconsequencesshouldbeconsidered.
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
4
![Page 7: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
> ConsiderationshouldbegiventoincorporatingtheAAA’sProceduresforLarge,ComplexCommercialDisputesforpotentiallysubstantialorcomplicatedcases.
> ThedraftershouldkeepinmindthattheAAAhasspecializedrulesforarbitrationintheconstruction,patent,securitiesandcertainotherfields.Ifanticipateddisputesfallintoanyoftheseareas,thespecializedrulesshouldbeconsideredforincorporationinthearbitrationclause.AnexperiencedAAAadministrativestaffmanagestheprocessingofcasesunderAAArules.
> Thepartiesarefreetocustomizeandrefinethebasicarbitrationprocedurestomeettheirparticularneeds.IfthepartiesagreeonaprocedurethatconflictswithotherwiseapplicableAAArules,theAAAwillalmostalwaysrespectthewishesoftheparties.
II. Major Features of Arbitration
Arbitrationisaprivate,informalprocessbywhichallpartiesagree,inwriting,tosubmittheirdisputestooneormoreimpartialpersonsauthorizedtoresolvethecontroversybyrenderingafinalandbindingaward.Itisusedforawidevarietyofdisputes–fromcommercialdisagreementsinvolvingconstruction,securitiestransactions,computersorrealestate(tonamejustafew),toinsuranceclaimsandlabor-uniongrievances.Whenanagreementtoarbitrateisincludedinacontract,itmightexpeditepeacefulsettlementwithoutthenecessityofgoingtoarbitrationatall.Thus,anarbitrationclauseisaformofinsuranceagainstlossofgoodwill.
Themajorfeaturesofarbitrationare:
1. AWrittenAgreementtoResolveDisputesbytheUseofImpartialArbitration.Suchaprovisionmaybeinsertedinacontractforresolutionoffuturedisputesormaybeanagreementtosubmittoarbitrationanexistingdispute.
5
![Page 8: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
2. InformalProcedures.UndertheAAArules,theprocedureisrelativelysimple:courtroomrulesofevidencearenotstrictlyapplicable;thereusuallyisnomotionpracticeorformaldiscovery;andthereisnorequirementfortranscriptsoftheproceedingsorforwrittenopinionsofthearbitrators.Thoughtheremaybenoformaldiscovery,theAAA’svariouscommercialrulesallowthearbitratortorequireproductionofrelevantinformationanddocuments.TheAAA’srulesareflexibleandmaybevariedbymutualagreementoftheparties.
3. ImpartialandKnowledgeableNeutralstoServeasArbitrators.Arbitratorsareselectedforspecificcasesbecauseoftheirknowledgeofthesubjectmatter.Basedonthatexperience,arbitratorscanrenderanawardgroundedonthoughtfulandinformedanalysis.
4. FinalandBindingAwardsthatareEnforceableinaCourt.Courtinterventionandreviewislimitedbyapplicablestateorfederalarbitrationlawsandawardenforcementisfacilitatedbythosesamelaws.
Duringitsmanyyearsofexistence,theAAAhasrefineditsstandardarbitrationclause.Thatclause,whenlinkedtoAAAcasemanagement,offersthepartiesasimple,time-testedmeansofresolvingdisputes.Occasionally,partiesortheircounseldesireadditionalprovisions.Thisbooklethasbeenpreparedasageneralguidefordraftingdisputeresolutionclauses.ItcontainsexamplesofclausesandportionsofclausesthathavebeenusedbypartiesincasesfiledwiththeAAA.ReadersshouldfeelfreetocontacttheirlocalAAAofficeforfurtherinformation.
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
6
![Page 9: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
III. Clauses Approved By the AAA for General Commercial Use
ThestandardarbitrationclausesuggestedbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationaddressesmanybasicdraftingquestionsbyincorporatingAAArules.Thissimpleapproachhasprovenhighlyeffectiveinhundredsofthousandsofdisputes.Additionallanguage,whichpartiesmaywishtoaddinspecificcontexts,isdiscussedinSectionIVofthisbooklet.
ThestandardarbitrationclausealsomayincludereferencetotheAAA’sOptionalRulesforEmergencyMeasuresofProtection(beforeanarbitratorisselected)andforexpeditedarbitration.
Ifthepartieswish,standardclausesalsomaybeusedfornegotiationandmediation.Therearealsostandardclausesforuseinlarge,complexcases.
Arbitration
Thepartiescanprovideforarbitrationoffuturedisputesbyinsertingthefollowingclauseintotheircontracts(thelanguageinthebracketssuggestspossiblealternativesoradditions).
STD1 Anycontroversyorclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothiscontract,orthebreachthereof,shallbesettledbyarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationinaccordancewithitsCommercial[orother]ArbitrationRules[includingtheOptionalRulesforEmergencyMeasuresofProtection],andjudgmentontheawardrenderedbythearbitrator(s)maybeenteredinanycourthavingjurisdictionthereof.
Arbitrationofexistingdisputesmaybeaccomplishedbyuseofthefollowing.
STD2 We,theundersignedparties,herebyagreetosubmittoarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsCommercial[orother]ArbitrationRulesthefollowingcontroversy:[describebriefly].Wefurtheragreethatajudgmentofanycourthavingjurisdictionmaybeenteredupontheaward.
7
![Page 10: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Theprecedingclauses,whichrefertothetime-testedrulesoftheAAA,haveconsistentlyreceivedjudicialsupport.Thestandardclauseisoftenthebesttoincludeinacontract.ByinvokingtheAAA’srules,suchaclausemeetsthefollowingrequirementsofaneffectivearbitrationclause:
> Itmakesclearthatalldisputesarearbitrable.Thus,itminimizesdilatorycourtactionstoavoidthearbitrationprocess.
> Itisself-enforcing.Arbitrationcancontinuedespiteanobjectionfromaparty,unlesstheproceedingsarestayedbycourtorderorbyagreementoftheparties.
> Itprovidesacompletesetofrulesandprocedures.Thiseliminatestheneedtospelloutdozensofproceduralmattersintheparties’agreement.
> Itprovidesfortheselectionofaspecialized,impartialpanel.Arbitratorsareselectedbythepartiesfromascreenedandtrainedpoolofavailableexperts.UndertheAAArules,aprocedureisavailabletodisqualifyanarbitratorforbias.
> Itsettlesdisputesoverthelocaleofproceedings.Whenthepar-tiesdisagree,localedeterminationsaremadebytheAAAastheadministrator,precludingtheneedforinterventionbyacourt.
> Itmakespossibleadministrativeconferences.IftheclauseincorporatestheAAAcommercial,constructionindustryorrelat-edarbitrationrules,anadministrativeconferencewiththeparties’representativesandAAAcasemanagementtoexpeditethearbitrationproceedingsisavailablewhenappropriate.
> Itmakesavailablepreliminaryhearings.IftheclauseprovidesforAAArules,apreliminaryhearingcanbearrangedincommercialcasesofanysizetospecifytheissuestoberesolved,clarifyclaimsandcounterclaims,provideforapre-hearingexchangeofinformation,andconsiderothermattersthatwillexpeditethearbitrationproceedings.
8
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
![Page 11: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
> Italsomakesmediationavailable.IftheclauseprovidesforanyoftheAAA’svariouscommercialarbitrationrules,mediationconferencescanbearrangedtofacilitateavoluntarysettlement,withoutadditionaladministrativecosttotheparties.
> Itestablishestimelimitstoensurepromptresolutionforalldis-putes.AnadditionalfeatureofthevariousAAArulesisaspecialexpeditedprocedure,whichmaybeusedtoresolvesmallerclaimsandotherdisputesthatneedmorespeedyresolutions.
> ItprovidesforAAAadministrativeassistancetothearbitratorandtheparties.Toprotectneutralityandavoidunilateralcon-tact,mostrulesprovidefortheAAAtochannelcommunicationsbetweenthepartiesandthearbitrator.AnAAAcasemanagermayalsoprovideguidancetohelpensurepromptconclusionofapro-ceeding.
> Itestablishesaprocedureforservingnotices.Dependingontherulesusedandthetypeofthecase,noticesmaybeservedbyregularmail,addressedtothepartyoritsrepresentativeatthelastknownaddress.Undertherules,theAAAandthepartiesmayusefacsimiletransmissionorotherwrittenformsofelectroniccommunicationtogivethenoticesrequiredbytherules.
> Unlessotherwiseprovided,itgivesthearbitratorthepowertodecidemattersequitablyandtofashionappropriaterelief.TheAAAcommercialrulesallowthearbitratortograntanyremedyorreliefthatthearbitratordeemsjustandequitableandwithinthescopeoftheagreementoftheparties,includingspecificperformance.
> Itallowsexpartehearings.Ahearingmaybeheldintheabsenceofapartywhohasbeengivenduenotice.Thus,apartycannotavoidanawardbyrefusingtoappear.
9
![Page 12: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
> Itprovidesforenforcementoftheaward.Theawardcanbeenforcedinanycourthavingjurisdiction,withonlylimitedstatu-torygroundsforresistingtheaward.If,inadomestictransaction,asdistinguishedfromaninternationalone,thepartiesdesirethatthearbitrationclausebefinal,bindingandenforceable,itisessentialthattheclausecontainan“entryofjudgment”provisionsuchasthatfoundinthestandardarbitrationclause(“andjudgmentontheawardrenderedbythearbitratormaybeenteredinanycourthavingjurisdictionthereof”).
Negotiation
Thepartiesmaywishtoattempttoresolvetheirdisputesthroughnegotiationpriortoarbitration.Asampleofaclausewhichprovidesfornegotiationfollows.
NEG1 Intheeventofanydispute,claim,question,ordisagreementarisingfromorrelatingtothisagreementorthebreachthereof,thepartiesheretoshallusetheirbesteffortstosettlethedispute,claim,question,ordisagreement.Tothiseffect,theyshallconsultandnegotiatewitheachotheringoodfaithand,recognizingtheirmutualinterests,attempttoreachajustandequitablesolutionsatisfactorytobothparties.Iftheydonotreachsuchsolutionwithinaperiodof60days,then,uponnoticebyeitherpartytotheother,alldisputes,claims,questions,ordifferencesshallbefinallysettledbyarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationinaccordancewiththeprovisionsofitsCommercialArbitrationRules.
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
10
![Page 13: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Mediation
Thepartiesmaywishtoattemptmediationbeforesubmittingtheirdisputetoarbitration.Thiscanbeaccomplishedbymakingreferencetomediation(whichmaybeterminatedatanytimebyeitherparty)inthearbitrationclause.
MED1 Ifadisputearisesoutoforrelatestothiscontract,orthebreachthereof,andifthedisputecannotbesettledthroughnegotiation,thepartiesagreefirsttotryingoodfaithtosettlethedisputebymediationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsCommercialMediationProceduresbeforeresortingtoarbitration,litigation,orsomeotherdisputeresolutionprocedure.
MED2 Thepartiesherebysubmitthefollowingdisputetomedia-tionadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsCommercialMediationProcedures[theclausemayalsoprovideforthequalificationsofthemediator(s),themethodforallocatingfeesandexpenses,thelocaleofmeetings,timelimits,oranyotheritemofconcerntotheparties].
AnAAAadministratorcanassistthepartiesregardingselectionofthemediator,scheduling,pre-mediationinformationexchangeandattendanceofappropriatepartiesatthemediationconference.
Itisprudenttoincludetimelimitsonstepspriortoarbitration.Underabroadarbitrationclause,thequestionofwhetheraclaimhasbeenassertedwithinanapplicabletimelimitisgenerallyregardedasanarbitrableissue,suitableforresolutionbythearbitrator.
Large,ComplexCases
Thelarge,complexcaseframeworkofferedbytheAAAisdesignedprimarilyforbusinessdisputesinvolvingclaimsofatleast$500,000,althoughpartiesarefreetoprovideforuseoftheLCCRulesinotherdisputes.Thekeyelementsoftheprogramare(1)selectionofarbitratorswhosatisfyrigorouscriteriatoinsurethatthepanelisanextremelyselectone;(2)training,orientation,andcoordination
11
![Page 14: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
ofthosearbitratorsinamannerdesignedtofacilitatetheprogram;(3)establishmentofproceduresforadministrationofthosecasesthatelecttobeincludedintheprogram;(4)flexibilityofthoseproceduressothatpartiescanmorespeedilyandefficientlyresolvetheirdisputes;and(5)administrationoflarge,complexcasesbyspeciallytrained,experiencedAAAstaff.
TheproceduresprovideforanearlyadministrativeconferencewiththeAAA,andapreliminaryhearingwiththearbitrators.Documentaryexchangesandotheressentialexchangesofinformationarefacilitated.Theproceduresalsoprovidethatastatementofreasonsmayaccom-panytheaward,ifrequestedbytheparties.Theproceduresaremeanttosupplementtheapplicablerulesthatthepartieshaveagreedtouse.Theyincludethepossibilityoftheuseofmediationtoresolvesomeorallissuesatanearlystage.
Thepartiescanprovideforfutureapplicationoftheproceduresbyincludingthefollowingarbitrationclauseintheircontract.
LCCP1 AnycontroversyorclaimarisingfromorrelatingtothiscontractorthebreachthereofshallbesettledbyarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderits[applicable]ProceduresforLarge,ComplexCommercialDisputes,andjudgmentontheawardrenderedbythearbitrator(s)maybeenteredinanycourthavingjurisdictionthereof.
ApendingdisputecanbereferredtotheprogrambythecompletionofaSubmissiontoDisputeResolutionformiftheunderlyingcontractdocumentsdonotprovideforAAAadministration.
LCCP2 We,theundersignedparties,herebyagreetosubmittoarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderits[applicable]ProceduresforLarge,ComplexCommercialDisputesthefollowingcontroversy[describebriefly].Judgmentofanycourthavingjurisdictionmaybeenteredontheaward.
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
12
![Page 15: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
IV. Clauses for Use in Specific Contexts
Thefollowingclauses,whichalsocanprovideforperiodsofnegotia-tionand/ormediationpriortoarbitration,maybeconsideredforuseinspecificcontexts.ThechecklistofconsiderationsinSectionIabovealsoshouldbeconsulted.
A.ClausesforUseinInternationalDisputes
TheInternationalCentreforDisputeResolution(ICDR),theinternationaldivisionoftheAmericanArbitrationAssociation,administersinternationalcommercialcasesundervariousarbitra-tionrulesworldwide.TheICDRadministerscasesunderitsownInternationalDisputeResolutionProcedures,variousAAArules,theCommercialArbitrationandMediationCenterfortheAmericas(CAMCA)Rules,theRulesoftheInter-AmericanCommercialArbitrationCommission(IACAC)andtheUNCITRALArbitrationRules.UnderArticle1oftheInternationalArbitrationRules,partiesmaydesignateeithertheICDRortheAAAinthearbitrationclauseforthepurposesofnaminganadministrativeagencyandconferringproperjurisdictiontotheICDRortheAAA.Followingaresamplesofarbitrationclausespertinenttointernationaldisputes.
INTL1 Anycontroversyorclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothiscontractshallbedeterminedbyarbitrationinaccor-dancewiththeInternationalArbitrationRulesoftheInternationalCentreforDisputeResolution.
INTL2 Anydispute,controversy,orclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothiscontract,orthebreachthereof,shallbefinallysettledbyarbitrationadministeredbytheCommercialArbitrationandMediationCenterfortheAmericasinaccordancewithitsrules,andjudgmentontheawardrenderedbythearbitrator(s)maybeenteredinanycourthavingjurisdictionthereof.
13
![Page 16: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
INTL3 Anydispute,controversy,orclaimarisingfromorrelatingtothiscontract,orthebreach,termination,orinvaliditythereof,shallbesettledbyarbitrationinaccordancewiththeRulesofProcedureoftheInter-AmericanCommercialArbitrationCommissionineffectonthedateofthisagreement.
INTL4 Anydispute,controversy,orclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothiscontract,orthebreach,termination,orinvaliditythereof,shallbesettledbyarbitrationundertheUNCITRALArbitrationRulesineffectonthedateofthiscontract.TheappointingauthorityshallbetheInternationalCentreforDisputeResolution.ThecaseshallbeadministeredbytheInternationalCentreforDisputeResolutionunderitsProceduresforCasesundertheUNCITRALArbitrationRules.
Thepartiesshouldconsideraddingarequirementregardingthenumberofarbitratorsappointedtothedisputeanddesignatingtheplaceandlanguageofthearbitration.ThepartiesmayalsosubmitaninternationaldisputeundertheAAA’scommercialandotherspecializedarbitrationrules.Thoseproceduresdonotsupersedeanyprovisionoftheapplicablerulesbutmerelycodifyvariousprocedurescustomarilyusedininternationalarbitration.Includedamongthemareprovisionsspecifyingtheneutralityofarbitrators,consecutivehearingdays,thelanguageofhearings,andopinions.Thethrustoftheproceduresistoexpediteinternationalproceedingsandkeepthemaseconomicalaspossible.
Forstrategicorlongtermcommercialcontracts,thepartiesmaywishtoprovidea“step”disputeresolutionprocessencouragingnegotiatedsolutions,ormediationinadvanceofarbitrationorlitigation.Amodelstepclauseandmediationclausefollow.
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
14
![Page 17: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
INTL5 Intheeventofanycontroversyorclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothiscontract,thepartiesheretoshallconsultandnegotiatewitheachotherand,recognizingtheirmutualinterests,attempttoreachasolutionsatisfactorytobothparties.Iftheydonotreachsettlementwithinaperiodof60days,theneitherpartymay,bynoticetotheotherpartyandtheInternationalCentreforDisputeResolution,demandmediationundertheInternationalMediationProceduresoftheInternationalCentreforDisputeResolution.Ifsettlementisnotreachedwithin60daysafterserviceofawrittendemandformediation,anyunresolvedcontroversyorclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothiscon-tractshallbesettledbyarbitrationinaccordancewiththeInternationalArbitrationRulesoftheInternationalCentreforDisputeResolution.
INTL6 Intheeventofanycontroversyorclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothiscontract,thepartiesheretoagreefirsttotryandsettlethedisputebymediationadministeredbytheInternationalCentreforDisputeResolutionunderitsrulesbeforeresortingtoarbitration,litigation,orsomeotherdisputeresolutiontechnique.
Usually,theeffectivemanagementoftimeandexpenseinarbitrationisbestleftinthehandsofexperiencedcasemanagersandarbitrators.Occasionally,however,partieswishtoensurethatmattersareresolvedinaminimumoftimeandwithoutrecoursetotheexpenseandtimenecessitatedbycommonlawmethodsofpre-hearinginformationexchange.Theclausesthatfollowlimitthetimeframeofarbitration(clausespresentedinthealternative)andtheamountofpre-hearinginformationexchangeavailabletotheparties.Onewordofcaution:onceenteredinto,theseclauseswilllimitthearbitrator’sauthoritytomoldtheprocesstothespecificdictatesofthecase.
15
![Page 18: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
INTL7 Theawardshallberenderedwithinninemonthsofthecommencementofthearbitration,unlesssuchtimelimitisextendedbythearbitrator.
Alternative
ItistheintentofthePartiesthat,barringextraordinarycircumstances,arbitrationproceedingswillbeconcludedwithin60daysfromthedatethearbitrator(s)areappointed.Thearbitraltribunalmayextendthistimelimitintheinterestsofjustice.Failuretoadheretothistimelimitshallnotconstituteabasisforchallengingtheaward.
INTL8 Consistentwiththeexpeditednatureofarbitration,pre-hearinginformationexchangeshallbelimitedtothereasonableproductionofrelevant,non-privilegeddocuments,carriedoutexpeditiously.
Enforcementofinternationalawardsisfacilitatedbythe1958UNConventionontheRecognitionandEnforcementofForeignArbitralAwards(the“NewYorkConvention”),whichhasbeenratifiedbymorethan110nations,andfacilitatedinthishemispherebytheInter-AmericanConventiononInternationalCommercialArbitration(the“PanamaConvention”).
B.ClausesforUseinConstructionDisputes
TheAAAConstructionIndustryArbitrationRulesandMediationProceduresaredesignedtoexpeditethedisputeresolutionprocessandhelptheAAAbemoreresponsivetotheneedsoftheconstructionindustry.Therulescontaina“fasttrack”arbitrationsystemforcasesinvolvingclaimsoflessthan$75,000;enhancementstothe“regulartrack”rules;andaLarge,ComplexConstructioncasetrackforuseincasesinvolvingclaimsofatleast$500,000.
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
16
![Page 19: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Thepartiescanprovideforarbitrationoffuturedisputesbyinsertingthefollowingclauseintotheircontracts.
CONST1 Anycontroversyorclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothiscontract,orthebreachthereof,shallbesettledbyarbitra-tionadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsConstructionIndustryArbitrationRules,andjudgmentontheawardrenderedbythearbitrator(s)maybeenteredinanycourthavingjurisdictionthereof.
CONST2 We,theundersignedparties,herebyagreetosubmittoarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsConstructionIndustryArbitrationRulesthefollowingcontroversy:(citebriefly).Wefurtheragreethatthecontroversybesubmittedto(one)(three)arbitrator(s).Wefurtheragreethatwewillfaithfullyobservethisagreementandtherules,andthatajudgmentofanycourthavingjurisdictionmaybeenteredontheaward.
Ifpartieswishtoadoptmediationaspartoftheircontractualdisputesettlementprocedure,theycaninsertthefollowingmediationclauseinconjunctionwithastandardarbitrationprovision,andmayalsoprovidethattherequirementoffilinganoticeofclaimwithrespecttothedisputesubmittedtomediationshallbesuspendeduntiltheconclusionofthemediationprocess.
CONST3 Ifadisputearisesoutoforrelatestothiscontract,orthebreachthereof,andifthedisputecannotbesettledthroughnegotiation,thepartiesagreefirsttotryingoodfaithtosettlethedisputebymediationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsConstructionIndustryMediationProceduresbeforeresortingtoarbitra-tion,litigation,orsomeotherdisputeresolutiontechnique.
Partiesalsohavetheoptionofinsertinga“step”mediation-arbitrationclauseintotheircontracts.Adisputeresolutionhybrid,theclauseprovidesfirstformediationandthen,ifthedisputeisnotresolvedwithinaspecifiedtimeframe,arbitration.
17
![Page 20: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
CONST4 Anycontroversyorclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothiscontractorbreachthereof,shallbesettledbymediationundertheConstructionIndustryMediationProceduresoftheAmericanArbitrationAssociation.Ifwithin30daysafterserviceofawrittendemandformediation,themediationdoesnotresultinsettlementofthedispute,thenanyunresolvedcontroversyorclaimarisingfromorrelatingtothiscontractorbreachthereofshallbesettledbyarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationinaccordancewithitsConstructionIndustryArbitrationRulesandjudgmentontheawardrenderedbythearbitrator(s)maybeenteredinanycourthavingjurisdictionthereof.
Ifthepartieswanttouseamediatortoresolveanexistingdispute,theycanenterintothefollowingsubmission.
CONST5 Thepartiesherebysubmitthefollowingdisputetomedia-tionadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsConstructionIndustryMediationProcedures(theclausemayalsoprovideforthequalificationsofthemediator(s),methodofpayment,localeofmeetings,thetollingofthestatuteoflimitations,pre-arbitrationstepclausewithtimeframesandanyotheritemofconcerntotheparties).
C.ClausesforUseinEmploymentDisputes
Conflictswhichariseduringthecourseofemployment,suchaswrong-fultermination,sexualharassmentanddiscriminationbasedonrace,color,religion,sex,nationalorigin,ageanddisability,haveredefinedresponsiblecorporatepracticeandemployeerelations.TheAAAthereforehasdevelopedspecialrulescalledtheNationalRulesfortheResolutionofEmploymentDisputes.TheAAA’spolicyonemploy-mentADRisguidedbythestateofexistinglaw,aswellasitsobligationtoactinanimpartialmanner.Infollowingthelaw,andintheinterestof
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
18
![Page 21: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
providinganappropriateforumfortheresolutionofemploymentdisputes,theAssociationadministersdisputeresolutionprogramswhichmeetthedueprocessstandardsasoutlinedinitsNationalRulesfortheResolutionofEmploymentDisputesandtheDueProcessProtocolforMediationandArbitrationofStatutoryDisputesArisingoutoftheEmploymentRelationship.IftheAssociationdeterminesthatadisputeresolutionprogramonitsfacesubstantiallyandmateriallydeviatesfromtheminimumdueprocessstandardsoftheNationalRulesfortheResolutionofEmploymentDisputesandtheprotocol,theAssociationwilldeclinetoadministercasesunderthatprogram.Otherissueswillbepresentedtothearbitratorfordetermination.
AnemployerintendingtoincorporatetheserulesortorefertothedisputeresolutionservicesoftheAAAinanemploymentADRplan,shall,atleast30dayspriortotheplannedeffectivedateoftheprogram,(1)notifyand(2)providetheAssociationwithacopyoftheemploymentdisputeresolutionplan.Ifanemployerdoesnotcomplywiththisrequirement,theAssociationreservestherighttodeclineitsadministrativeservices.
Partiescanprovideforarbitrationoffuturedisputesbyinsertingthefollowingclauseintotheiremploymentcontracts,personnelmanualsorpolicystatements,employmentapplications,orotheragreements.
EMPL1 Anycontroversyorclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothis[employmentapplication;employmentADRprogram;employmentcontract]shallbesettledbyarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsNationalRulesfortheResolutionofEmploymentDisputesandjudgmentupontheawardrenderedbythearbitrator(s)maybeenteredinanycourthavingjurisdictionthereof.
Arbitrationofexistingdisputescanbeaccomplishedbyuseofthefollowingclause.
EMPL2 We,theundersignedparties,herebyagreetosubmittoarbitration,administeredbytheAmericanArbitration
19
![Page 22: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
AssociationunderitsNationalRulesfortheResolutionofEmploymentDisputes,thefollowingcontroversy:(describebriefly).Wefurtheragreethattheabovecontroversybesubmittedto(one)(three)arbitrator(s)selectedfromtherosterofarbitratorsoftheAmericanArbitrationAssociation,andthatajudgmentofanycourthavingjurisdictionmaybeenteredontheaward.
Partiesmayagreetousemediationonaninformalbasisforselecteddisputes,ormediationmaybedesignatedinapersonnelmanualasasteppriortoarbitration,litigationorsomeotherdisputeresolutiontechnique.Ifthepartieswanttoadoptmediationasapartoftheircontractualdispute-settlementprocedure,theycanaddthefollowingmediationclausetotheircontract.
EMPL3 Ifadisputearisesoutoforrelatestothis[employmentapplication;employmentADRprogram;employmentcontract]orthebreachthereof,andifthedisputecannotbesettledthroughnegotiation,thepartiesagreefirsttotryingoodfaithtosettlethedisputebymediationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsNationalRulesfortheResolutionofEmploymentDisputes,beforeresortingtoarbitration,litigationorsomeotherdisputeresolutionprocedure.
Ifthepartieswanttouseamediatortoresolveanexistingdispute,theycanenterintothefollowingsubmission.
EMPL4 Thepartiesherebysubmitthefollowingdisputetomedia-tionadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsNationalRulesfortheResolutionofEmploymentDisputes(theclausemayalsoprovideforthequalificationsofthemediator(s),methodofpayment,localeofmeetings,andanyotheritemofconcerntotheparties).
D.ClausesforUseinPatentDisputes
Thesuitabilityofarbitrationasapromptandeffectivemeansofresolving
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
20
![Page 23: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
intellectualpropertydisputeshasbeenwellrecognizedinrecentyears.Thosewhouseandsupportarbitrationasawayofresolvingintellectualpropertyandlicensingdisputeshaveacknowledgedthefollowingadvantagesofarbitrationoverlitigationinthistechnicalfield:relativespeedandeconomy,privacy,convenience,informality,reducedlikelihoodofdamagetoongoingbusinessrelationships,greatersuitabilitytointernationalproblems,and,especiallyimportant,theabilityofthepartiestoselectarbitratorswhoareexpertsandfamiliarwiththesubjectmatterofthedispute.
Theawardisbindingonlyonthepartiestothearbitration,andthepartiesmayagreethattheawardwillbemodifiedifthepatentthatisthesubjectofthearbitrationissubsequentlydeterminedtobeinvalidorunenforceable.Ifpartiesforeseethepossibilityofneedingemergencyreliefakintoatemporaryrestrainingorder,theymightspecifyanarbitratorbynameforthatpurposeintheirarbitrationclauseorauthorizetheAAAtonameapreliminaryreliefarbitrator;forsampleclauses,consultSectionV,discussionofPreliminaryRelief.Partiescanprovideforarbitrationoffuturedisputesbyinsertingthefollowingclauseintotheircontracts.
PATENT1 Anycontroversyorclaimarisingoutoforrelatingtothiscontract,orthebreachthereof,shallbesettledbyarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsPatentArbitrationRules,andjudgmentontheawardrenderedbythearbitrator(s)maybeenteredbyanycourthavingjurisdictionthereof.
Arbitrationofexistingdisputesmaybeaccomplishedbyuseofthefollowingclause.
PATENT2 We,theundersignedparties,herebyagreetosubmittoarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsPatentArbitrationRulesthefollowingcontroversy:(describebriefly).Wefurtheragreethattheabovecontroversybesubmittedto(one)
21
![Page 24: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
(three)arbitrator(s),andthatajudgmentofanycourthavingjurisdictionmaybeenteredontheaward.
Ifpartieswanttoadoptmediationasapartoftheircontractualdisputesettlementprocedure,theycaninsertthefollowingmediationclauseinconjunctionwithastandardarbitrationprovision.
PATENT3 Ifadisputearisesoutoforrelatestothiscontract,orthebreachthereof,andifthedisputecannotbesettledthroughnegotiation,thepartiesagreefirsttotryingoodfaithtosettlethedisputebymediationadminis-teredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsCommercialMediationProceduresbeforeresortingtoarbitration,litigation,orsomeotherdisputeresolutionprocedure.
Ifthepartieswanttouseamediatortoresolveanexistingdispute,theycanenterintothefollowingsubmission.
PATENT4 ThepartiesherebysubmitthefollowingdisputetomediationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsCommercialMediationProcedures(theclausemayalsoprovideforthequalificationsofthemediator(s),methodofpayment,localeofmeetings,andanyotheritemofconcerntotheparties).
V. Other Provisions That Might Be Considered
ThissectioncontainsvariousprovisionswhichexpanduponandaresupplementaltothebasicdisputeresolutionclausessetforthinSectionsIIIandIV.Thelistingofsuchprovisionsisnotintendedtobeall-inclusiveanddoesnotnecessarilyindicatethattheAAAendorsestheuseofsuchadditionallanguage.TheAAArecognizes,however,thatsomedrafterschoosetoexpandtheirdisputeresolutionclausestoreflectatleastsomeoftheseideas.Sinceitisimportantthatpractitionersbewellinformedwhenmakingchoicesindrafting,thesectionalsosetsforth,whereappropriate,certainoftheprosand
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
22
![Page 25: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
consofadoptingthevarioussupplementalprovisions.
A.SpecifyingaMethodofSelectionandtheNumberofArbitrators
UndertheAAA’sarbitrationrules,arbitratorsaregenerallyselectedusingalistingprocess.TheAAAcasemanagerprovideseachpartywithalistofproposedarbitratorswhoaregenerallyfamiliarwiththesubjectmatterinvolvedinthedispute.Eachsideisprovidedanum-berofdaystostrikeanyunacceptablenames,numbertheremainingnamesinorderofpreference,andreturnthelisttotheAAA.Thecasemanagertheninvitespersonstoservefromthenamesremainingonthelist,inthedesignatedorderofmutualpreference.Thepartiesmayagreetohaveonearbitratororthree(whichincreasesthecost).Ifpartiesdonotagreeonthenumberofarbitrator(s),itwillbelefttothediscretionofthecasemanager.
Thepartiesmayuseotherarbitratorappointmentsystems,suchastheparty-appointedmethodinwhicheachsidedesignatesonearbitratorandthetwothusselectedappointthechairofthepanel.
TheCommercialArbitrationRulesandtheConstructionIndustryArbitrationRulesprovidethatunlessthepartiesspecificallyagreeinwritingthattheparty-appointedarbitratorsaretobenon-neutral,arbitratorsappointedbythepartiesmustmeettheimpartialityandindependencestandardssetforthwithintherules.Ifpartiesintendthattheirpartyappointedarbitratorsserveinanon-neutralcapacity,thisshouldbeclearlystatedwithintheirclause.
Thearbitrationclausecanalsospecifybynametheindividualwhomthepartieswantastheirarbitrator.However,thepotentialunavailabilityofthenamedindividualinthefuturemayposearisk.
Alloftheseissuesandotherscanbedealtwithinthearbitrationclause.
23
![Page 26: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Someillustrativeprovisionsfollow.
ARBSEL1 Thearbitratorselectedbytheclaimantandthearbi-tratorselectedbyrespondentshall,withintendaysoftheirappointment,selectathirdneutralarbitrator.Intheeventthattheyareunabletodoso,thepartiesortheirattorneysmayrequesttheAmericanArbitrationAssociationtoappointthethirdneutralarbitrator.Priortothecommencementofhearings,eachofthearbitratorsappointedshallprovideanoathorundertakingofimpartiality.
ARBSEL2 Within15daysafterthecommencementofarbitration,eachpartyshallselectonepersontoactasarbitratorandthetwoselectedshallselectathirdarbitratorwithintendaysoftheirappointment.[Thepartyselectedarbitratorswillserveinanon-neutralcapacity.]Ifthearbitratorsselectedbythepartiesareunableorfailtoagreeuponthethirdarbitrator,thethirdarbitratorshallbeselectedbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociation.
ARBSEL3 Intheeventthatarbitrationisnecessary,[nameofspecificarbitrator]shallactasthearbitrator.
Whenprovidingfordirectappointmentofthearbitrator(s)bytheparties,itisbesttospecifyatimeframewithinwhichitmustbeaccomplished.Also,inmanyjurisdictions,thelawpermitsthecourttoappointarbitratorswhereprivately-agreedmeansfail.Sucharesultmaybetimeconsuming,costly,andunpredictable.Partieswhoseektoestablishanad-hocmethodofarbitratorappointmentmightbewelladvisedtoprovideafallback,suchas,shouldtheparticularprocedurefailforanyreason,“arbitratorsshallbeappointedasprovidedintheAAACommercialArbitrationRules.”
B.ArbitratorQualifications
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
24
![Page 27: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Thepartiesmaywishthatoneormoreofthearbitratorsbealawyeroranaccountantoranexpertincomputertechnology,etc.Insomeinstances,itmakesmoresensetospecifythatoneofthreearbitratorsbeanaccountant,forexample,thantoturntheentireproceedingovertothreeaccountants.Sampleclausesprovidingforspecificqualificationsofarbitratorsaresetforthbelow.
QUAL1 Thearbitratorshallbeacertifiedpublicaccountant.
QUAL2 Thearbitratorshallbeapracticingattorney[oraretiredjudge][ofthe[specify]Court].
QUAL3 Thearbitrationproceedingsshallbeconductedbeforeapanelofthreeneutralarbitrators,allofwhomshallbemembersofthebarofthestateof[specify],activelyengagedinthepracticeoflawforatleasttenyears.
QUAL4 Thepanelofthreearbitratorsshallconsistofonecontractor,onearchitect,andoneconstructionattorney.
QUAL5 Thearbitratorswillbeselectedfromapanelofpersonshavingexperiencewithandknowledgeofelectroniccomputersandthecomputerbusiness,andatleastoneofthearbitratorsselectedwillbeanattorney.
QUAL6 Intheeventthatanyparty’sclaimexceeds$1million,exclusiveofinterestandattorneys’fees,thedisputeshallbeheardanddeterminedbythreearbitrators.
Partiesmightwishtospecifythatthearbitratorshouldorshouldnotbeanationalorcitizenofaparticularcountry.Thefollowingexamplescanbeaddedtothearbitrationclausetodealwiththisconcern.
NATLY1 Thearbitratorshallbeanationalof[country].
NATLY2 Thearbitratorshallnotbeanationalofeither[countryA]or[countryB].
NATLY3 Thearbitratorshallnotbeofthenationalityofeitheroftheparties.
C.LocaleProvisions
25
![Page 28: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Partiesmightwanttoaddlanguagespecifyingtheplaceofthearbitration.Thechoiceoftheproperplacetoarbitrateismostimportantbecausetheplaceofarbitrationimpliesgenerallyachoiceoftheapplicableprocedurallaw,whichinturnaffectsquestionsofarbitrability,procedure,courtinterventionandenforcement.
Inspecifyingalocale,partiesshouldconsider(1)theconvenienceofthelocation(e.g.,availabilityofwitnesses,localcounsel,transportation,hotels,meetingfacilities,courtreporters,etc.);(2)theavailablepoolofqualifiedarbitratorswithinthegeographicalarea;and(3)theapplicableproceduralandsubstantivelaw.Ofparticularimportanceininternationalcasesistheapplicabilityofaconventionprovidingforrecognitionandenforcementofarbitralagreementsandawardsandthearbitrationregimeatthechosensite.
Anexampleoflocaleprovisionsthatmightappearinanarbitrationclausefollows.
LOC1 Theplaceofarbitrationshallbe[city],[state],or[country].
D.Language
Inmattersinvolvingmultilingualparties,thearbitrationagreementoftenspecifiesthelanguageinwhichthearbitrationwillbeconducted.Examplesofsuchlanguagefollow.
LANG1 Thelanguage(s)ofthearbitrationshallbe[specify].
LANG2 Thearbitrationshallbeconductedinthelanguageinwhichthecontractwaswritten.
Sucharbitrationclausescouldalsodealwithselectionandcostallocationofaninterpreter.
E.GoverningLaw
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
26
![Page 29: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Itiscommonforpartiestospecifythelawthatwillgovernthecontractand/orthearbitrationproceedings.Someexamplesfollow.
GOV1 ThisagreementshallbegovernedbyandinterpretedinaccordancewiththelawsoftheStateof[specify].Thepartiesacknowledgethatthisagreementevidencesatransactioninvolvinginterstatecommerce.TheUnitedStatesArbitrationActshallgoverntheinterpretation,enforcement,andproceedingspursuanttothearbitrationclauseinthisagreement.
GOV2 DisputesunderthisclauseshallberesolvedbyarbitrationinaccordancewithTitle9oftheUSCode(UnitedStatesArbitrationAct)andtheCommercialArbitrationRulesoftheAmericanArbitrationAssociation.
GOV3 ThiscontractshallbegovernedbythelawsoftheStateof[specify].
Ininternationalcases,wherethepartieshavenotprovidedforthelawapplicabletothesubstanceofthedispute,theAAA’sInternationalArbitrationRulescontainspecificguidelinesforarbitratorsregardingapplicablelaw.SeethediscussionconcerningInternationalDisputes.
F.ConditionsPrecedenttoArbitration
Underanagreementoftheparties,satisfactionofspecifiedconditionsmayberequiredbeforeadisputeisreadyforarbitration.Examplesofsuchconditionsprecedentincludewrittennotificationofclaimswithinafixedperiodoftimeandexhaustionofothercontractuallyestablishedprocedures,suchassubmissionofclaimstoanarchitectorengineer.Thesekindsofprovisionsmay,however,beasourceofdelayandmayrequirelinkagewithastatuteoflimitationswaiver(seebelow).Anexampleofa“conditionprecedent”clausefollows.
CONPRE1 Ifadisputearisesfromorrelatestothiscontract,thepartiesagreethatuponrequestofeitherpartytheywillseektheadviceof[amutuallyselectedengineer]andtryingoodfaithtosettlethedisputewithin30daysofthatrequest,followingwhicheitherpartymaysubmitthemattertomediationundertheCommercialMediation
27
![Page 30: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
ProceduresoftheAmericanArbitrationAssociation.Ifthematterisnotresolvedwithin60daysafterinitiationofmediation,eitherpartymaydemandarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderits[applicable]rules.
G.PreliminaryRelief
WhilepreliminaryreliefispermittedundertheAAA’scommercialrules,itisappropriatetoprovidespecificallyforitifaneedforaninterimremedyisanticipated.OnewaytodosoistoincorporatetheOptionalRulesforEmergencyMeasuresofProtectionoftheAAACommercialArbitrationRulesandMediationProcedures,discussedabove.Alternatively,ifthepartiesforeseethepossibilityofneedingemergencyreliefakintoatemporaryrestrainingorder,theymightspecifyanarbitratorbynameforthatpurposeintheirarbitrationclauseorauthorizetheAAAtonameapreliminaryreliefarbitratortoensureanarbitratorisinplaceinsufficienttimetoaddressappropriateissues.
Specificclausesprovidingforpreliminaryreliefaresetforthbelow.
PRELIM1 Eitherpartymayapplytothearbitratorseekinginjunctivereliefuntilthearbitrationawardisrenderedorthecontroversyisotherwiseresolved.Eitherpartyalsomay,withoutwaivinganyremedyunderthisagreement,seekfromanycourthavingjurisdictionanyinterimorprovisionalreliefthatisnecessarytoprotecttherightsorpropertyofthatparty,pendingtheestablishmentofthearbitraltribunal(orpendingthearbitraltribunal’sdeterminationofthemeritsofthecontroversy).
NotethattheAAA’srulesprovideforinterimreliefbythearbitratoruponapplicationofaparty.
Pendingtheoutcomeofthearbitration,partiesmayagreetoholdinescrowmoney,aletterofcredit,goods,orthesubjectmatterofthearbitration.Asampleofaclauseprovidingforsuchescrowfollows.
ESCROW1 Pendingtheoutcomeofthearbitration[nameofparty]shallplaceinescrowwith[lawfirm,institution,orAAA]
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
28
![Page 31: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
astheescrowagent,[thesumof____________________,aletterofcredit,goods,orthesubjectmatterindispute].Theescrowagentshallbeentitledtoreleasethe[funds,letterofcredit,goods,orsubjectmatterindispute]asdirectedbythearbitrator(s)intheaward,unlessthepartiesagreeotherwiseinwriting.
H.Consolidation
Wheretherearemultiplepartieswithdisputesarisingfromthesametransaction,complicationscanoftenbereducedbytheconsolidationofalldisputes.Sincearbitrationisaprocessbasedonvoluntarycontractualparticipation,partiesmaynotberequiredtoarbitrateadisputewithouttheirconsent.However,partiescanprovidefortheconsolidationoftwoormoreseparatearbitrationsintoasingleproceedingorpermitthejoinderofathirdpartyintoanarbitration.Inaconstructiondispute,consolidatedproceedingsmayeliminatetheneedforduplicativepresentationsofclaimsandavoidthepossibilityofconflictingrulingsfromdifferentpanelsofarbitra-tors.However,consolidatingclaimsmightbeasourceofdelayandexpense.Anexampleoflanguagethatcanbeincludedinanarbitra-tionclausefollows.
CONSOL1 Theowner,thecontractor,andallsubcontractors,specialtycontractors,materialsuppliers,engineers,designers,architects,constructionlenders,bondingcompanies,andotherpartiesconcernedwiththeconstructionofthestructurearebound,eachtoeachother,bythisarbitrationclause,providedthattheyhavesignedthiscontractoracontractthatincorporatesthiscontractbyreferenceorsignedanyotheragreementtobeboundbythisarbitrationclause.Eachsuchpartyagreesthatitmaybejoinedasanadditionalpartytoanarbitrationinvolvingotherpartiesunderanysuchagreement.Ifmorethanonearbitrationisbegununderanysuchagreementandanypartycontendsthattwoor
29
![Page 32: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
morearbitrationsaresubstantiallyrelatedandthattheissuesshouldbeheardinoneproceeding,thearbitrator(s)selectedinthefirst-filedofsuchproceedingsshalldeterminewhether,intheinterestsofjusticeandefficiency,theproceedingsshouldbeconsolidatedbeforethat(those)arbitrator(s).
I.DocumentDiscovery
UndertheAAArules,arbitratorsareauthorizedtodirectaprehearingexchangeofdocuments.Thepartiestypicallydiscusssuchanexchangeandseektoagreeonitsscope.Inmost(butnotall)instances,arbitratorswillorderpromptproductionoflimitednumbersofdocumentswhicharedirectlyrelevanttotheissuesinvolved.Insomeinstances,partiesmightwanttoensurethatsuchproductionwillinfactoccurandthusprovideforitintheirarbitrationclause.Indoingso,however,theyshouldbemindfulofwhatscopeofdocumentproductiontheydesire.Thismaybedifficulttodecideattheoutset.Ifthepartiesaddressdiscoveryintheclause,theymightincludetimelimitationsastowhenalldiscoveryshouldbecompletedandmightspecifythatthearbitratorshallresolveoutstandingdiscoveryissues.Samplelanguageissetforthbelow.
DOC1 Consistentwiththeexpeditednatureofarbitration,eachpartywill,uponthewrittenrequestoftheotherparty,promptlyprovidetheotherwithcopiesofdocuments[relevanttotheissuesraisedbyanyclaimorcounterclaim][onwhichtheproducingpartymayrelyinsupportoforinoppositiontoanyclaimordefense].Anydisputeregard-ingdiscovery,ortherelevanceorscopethereof,shallbedeterminedbythe[arbitrator(s)][chairofthearbitrationpanel],whichdeterminationshallbeconclusive.Alldiscoveryshallbecompletedwithin[45][60]daysfollowingtheappointmentofthearbitrator(s).
TheAAA’svariouscommercialarbitrationrulesprovideanopportu-
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
30
![Page 33: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
nityforanadministrativeconferencewiththeAAAstaffand/orapre-liminaryhearingwiththearbitrator.Thepurposesofsuchmeetingsincludeestablishingtheextentofandascheduleforproductionofrelevantdocumentsandotherinformation.
J.Depositions
Generallyarbitratorsprefertohearandbeabletoquestionwitnessesatahearingratherthanrelyondepositiontestimony.However,par-tiesarefreetoprovideintheirarbitrationclauseforatailoreddiscov-eryprogram,preferablytobemanagedbythearbitrator.Thismightoccur,forexample,ifthepartiesanticipatetheneedfordistantwit-nesseswhowouldnotbeabletotestifyexceptthroughdepositionsor,inthealternative,bythearbitratorholdingahearingwherethewitnessislocatedandsubjecttosubpoena.Inmostcaseswherepartiesprovidefordepositions,theydosoinverylimitedfashion,i.e.,theymightspecifya30-daydepositionperiod,witheachsidepermittedthreedepositions,noneofwhichwouldlastmorethanthreehours.Allobjectionswouldbereservedforthearbitrationhearingandwouldnotevenbenotedatthedepositionexceptforobjectionsbasedonprivilegeorextremeconfidentiality.Samplelanguageprovidingforsuchdepositionsissetforthbelow.
DEP1 Attherequestofaparty,thearbitrator(s)shallhavethediscretiontoorderexaminationbydepositionofwitnessestotheextentthearbitratordeemssuchadditionaldiscoveryrelevantandappropriate.Depositionsshallbelimitedtoamaximumof[three][insertnumber]perpartyandshallbeheldwithin30daysofthemakingofarequest.Additionaldepositionsmaybescheduledonlywiththepermissionofthe[arbitrator(s)][chairofthearbitrationpanel],andforgoodcauseshown.Eachdepositionshallbelimitedtoamaximumof[threehours][sixhours][oneday’s]dura-tion.Allobjectionsarereservedforthearbitrationhearingexceptforobjectionsbasedonprivilegeandproprietaryorconfidentialinformation.
31
![Page 34: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
K.DurationofArbitrationProceeding
WhileAAACommercialArbitrationRulesnormallyprovideforanawardwithin30daysoftheclosingofthehearing,partiessometimesunderscoretheirwishforanexpeditedresultbyprovidinginthearbitrationclause,forexample,thattherewillbeanawardwithinaspecifiednumberofmonthsofthenoticeofintentiontoarbitrateandthatthearbitrator(s)mustagreetothetimeconstraintsbeforeacceptingappointment.Beforeadoptingsuchlanguage,however,thepartiesshouldconsiderwhetherthedeadlineisrealisticandwhatwouldhappenifthedeadlinewerenotmetundercircumstanceswherethepartieshadnotmutuallyagreedtoextendit(e.g.,whethertheawardwouldbeenforceable).Itthusmaybehelpfultoallowthearbitratortoextendtimelimitsinappropriatecircumstances.Samplelanguageissetforthbelow.
TIME1 Theawardshallbemadewithinninemonthsofthefilingofthenoticeofintentiontoarbitrate(demand),andthearbitrator(s)shallagreetocomplywiththisschedulebeforeacceptingappointment.However,thistimelimitmaybeextendedbyagreementofthepartiesorbythearbitrator(s)ifnecessary.
L.Remedies
UnderabroadarbitrationclauseandmostAAArules,thearbitratormaygrant“anyremedyorreliefthatthearbitratordeemsjustandequitable”withinthescopeoftheparties’agreement.Sometimespartieswanttoincludeorexcludecertainspecificremedies.Examplesofclausesdealingwithremediesfollow.
REM1 Thearbitratorswillhavenoauthoritytoawardpunitiveorotherdamagesnotmeasuredbytheprevailingparty’sactualdamages,exceptasmayberequiredbystatute.
REM2 Innoeventshallanawardinanarbitrationinitiatedunderthisclauseexceed$________.
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
32
![Page 35: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
REM3 Innoeventshallanawardinanarbitrationinitiatedunderthisclauseexceed$________foranyclaimant.
REM4 Thearbitrator(s)shallnotawardconsequentialdamagesinanyarbitrationinitiatedunderthissection.
REM5 Anyawardinanarbitrationinitiatedunderthisclauseshallbelimitedtomonetarydamagesandshallincludenoinjunctionordirectiontoanypartyotherthanthedirectiontopayamonetaryamount.
REM6 Ifthearbitrator(s)findliabilityinanyarbitrationinitiatedunderthisclause,theyshallawardliquidateddamagesintheamountof$________.
REM7 Anymonetaryawardinanarbitrationinitiatedunderthisclauseshallincludepre-awardinterestattherateof____%fromthetimeoftheactoractsgivingrisetotheaward.
M.“Baseball”Arbitration
“Baseball”arbitrationisamethodologyusedinmanydifferentcontextsinadditiontobaseballplayers’salarydisputes,andisparticularlyeffectivewhenpartieshavealong-termrelationship.Theprocedureinvolveseachpartysubmittinganumbertothearbitrator(s)andservingthenumberonhisorheradversaryontheunderstandingthat,follow-ingahearing,thearbitrator(s)willpickoneofthesubmittednumbers,nothingelse.Akeyaspectofthisapproachisthatthereisincentiveforapartytosubmitahighlyreasonablenumber,sincethisincreasesthelikelihoodthatthearbitrator(s)willselectthatnumber.Insomeinstances,theprocessofsubmittingthenumbersmovesthepartiessoclosetogetherthatthedisputeissettledwithoutahearing.Samplelanguageprovidingfor“baseball”arbitrationissetforthbelow.
BASEBALL1 Eachpartyshallsubmittothearbitratorandexchangewitheachotherinadvanceofthehearingtheirlast,bestoffers.Thearbitratorshallbelimitedtoawardingonlyoneortheotherofthetwofiguressubmitted.
33
![Page 36: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
N.ArbitrationWithinMonetaryLimits
Partiesareoftenabletonegotiatetoapointbutarethenunabletoclosetheremaininggapbetweentheirrespectivepositions.Byset-tingupanarbitrationthatmustresultinanawardwithinthegapthatremainsbetweentheparties,thepartiesareabletoeliminateextremerisk,whilegainingthebenefitoftheextenttowhichtheirnegotiationsweresuccessful.
Therearetwocommonly-usedapproaches.Thefirstinvolvesinformingthearbitrator(s)thattheawardshouldbesomewherewithinaspeci-fiedmonetaryrange.Samplecontractlanguageprovidingforthismethodologyissetforthbelow.
LIMITS1 Anyawardofthearbitratorinfavorof[specifyparty]andagainst[specifyparty]shallbeatleast[specifyadollaramount]butshallnotexceed[specifyadollaramount].[Specifyaparty]expresslywaivesanyclaiminexcessof[specifyadollaramount]andagreesthatitsrecoveryshallnotexceedthatamount.Anysuchawardshallbeinsatisfactionofallclaimsby[specifyaparty]against[specifyaparty].
Asecondapproachisforthepartiestoagreebutnottellthearbitrator(s)thattheamountofrecoverywill,forexample,besomewherebetween$5and$10.Iftheawardislessthan$5,thenitisraisedto$5pursuanttotheagreement;iftheawardismorethan$10,thenitisloweredto$10pursuanttotheagreement;iftheawardiswithinthe$5-10range,thentheamountawardedbythearbitrator(s)isunchanged.Samplecontractlanguageprovidingforthismethodologyissetforthbelow.
LIMITS2 Intheeventthatthearbitratordeniestheclaimorawardsanamountlessthantheminimumamountof[specify],thenthisminimumamountshallbepaidtotheclaimant.Shouldthearbitrator’sawardexceedthemaximumamountof[specify],thenonlythismaximumamountshallbepaidtotheclaimant.Itisfurtherunderstoodbetweenthepartiesthat,ifthearbitratorawardsanamountbetweentheminimumandthemaximumstipulatedrange,thentheexactawarded
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
34
![Page 37: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
amountwillbepaidtotheclaimant.Thepartiesfurtheragreethatthisagreementisprivatebetweenthemandwillnotbedisclosedtothearbitrator.
O.AssessmentofAttorneys’Fees
TheAAArulesgenerallyprovidethattheadministrativefeesbeborneasincurredandthatthearbitrators’compensationbeallocatedequallybetweenthepartiesand,exceptforinternationalrules,aresilentconcerningattorneys’fees;butthiscanbemodifiedbyagreementoftheparties.Feesandexpensesofthearbitration,includingattorneys’fees,canbedealtwithinthearbitrationclause.Sometypicallanguagedealingwithfeesandexpensesfollow.
FEE1 Theprevailingpartyshallbeentitledtoanawardofreasonableattorneyfees.
FEE2 Thearbitratorsshallawardtotheprevailingparty,ifany,asdeterminedbythearbitrators,allofitscostsandfees.“Costsandfees”meanallreasonablepre-awardexpensesofthearbitration,includingthearbitrators’fees,administrativefees,travelexpenses,out-of-pocketexpensessuchascopyingandtelephone,courtcosts,witnessfees,andattorneys’fees.
FEE3 Eachpartyshallbearitsowncostsandexpensesandanequalshareofthearbitrators’andadministrativefeesofarbitration.
FEE4 Thearbitratorsmaydeterminehowthecostsandexpensesofthearbitrationshallbeallocatedbetweentheparties,buttheyshallnotawardattorneys’fees.
P.ReasonedOpinionAccompanyingtheAward
35
![Page 38: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Indomesticcommercialcases,arbitratorsusuallywillnotwriteareasonedopinionexplainingtheirawardunlesssuchanopinionisrequestedbyallparties.Whilesometakethepositionthatreasonedopinionsdetractfromfinalityiftheyfacilitatepost-arbitrationresorttothecourts,partiessometimesdesiresuchopinions,particularlyinlarge,complexcasesorasalreadyprovidedbymostapplicablerulesininternationaldisputes.Ifthepartieswantsuchanopinion,theycanincludelanguagesuchasthefollowingintheirarbitrationclause.
OPIN1 Theawardofthearbitratorsshallbeaccompaniedbyareasonedopinion.
OPIN2 Theawardshallbeinwriting,shallbesignedbyamajor-ityofthearbitrators,andshallincludeastatementsettingforththereasonsforthedispositionofanyclaim.
OPIN3 Theawardshallincludefindingsoffact[andconclusionsoflaw].
OPIN4 Theawardshallincludeabreakdownastospecificclaims.
Q.Confidentiality
WhiletheAAAandarbitratorsadheretocertainstandardsconcerningtheprivacyorconfidentialityofthehearings(seetheAAA-ABACodeofEthicsforArbitratorsinCommercialDisputes,CanonVI),partiesmightalsowishtoimposelimitsonthemselvesastohowmuchinformationregardingthedisputemaybedisclosedoutsidethehearing.Thefollowinglanguagemighthelpservethispurpose.
CONF1 Exceptasmayberequiredbylaw,neitherapartynoranarbitratormaydisclosetheexistence,content,orresultsofanyarbitrationhereunderwithoutthepriorwrittenconsentofbothparties.
Theprecedinglanguagecouldalsobemodifiedtorestrictonlydisclosureofcertaininformation(e.g.,tradesecrets).
R.Appeal
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
36
![Page 39: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Thebasicobjectiveofarbitrationisafair,fastandexpertresult,achievedeconomically.Consistentwiththisgoal,anarbitrationawardtraditionallywillbesetasideonlyinegregiouscircumstancessuchasdemonstrablebiasofanarbitrator.Sometimes,however,thepartiesdesireamorecomprehensiveappeal,mostofteninthesettingoflegallycomplexcases.Providingamechanismforsuchanappealassuresthatthelosingpartywilluseit.Whilepartiescanattempttoprovideforanappealinthecourtsystempursuanttotraditionalstandardsofcourtreview,theauthorityismixedastowhethercourtswillacceptappealsfromarbitrationonsuchabasis.Anotherapproachistoprovideforanappealtoanotherpanelofarbitratorswhowouldapplywhateverstandardofreviewthepartiesmightspecify.Setforthbelowisanexampleofarbitrationclauselanguageprovidingforthislattertypeofappeal.
APP1 Within30daysofreceiptofanyaward(whichshallnotbebindingifanappealistaken),anypartymaynotifytheAAAofanintentiontoappealtoasecondarbitraltribunal,constitutedinthesamemannerastheinitialtribunal.Theappealtribunalshallbeentitledtoadopttheinitialawardasitsown,modifytheinitialawardorsubstituteitsownawardfortheinitialaward.Theappealtribunalshallnotmodifyorreplacetheinitialawardexcept[formanifestdisregardoflaworfacts][forclearerrorsoflaworbecauseofclearandconvincingfactualerrors].Theawardoftheappealtribunalshallbefinalandbinding,andjudgmentmaybeenteredbyacourthavingjurisdictionthereof.
S.Mediation-Arbitration
37
![Page 40: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
AclausemayprovidefirstformediationundertheAAA’smediationprocedures.Ifthemediationisunsuccessful,themediatorcouldbeauthorizedtoresolvethedisputeundertheAAA’sarbitrationrules.Thisprocess,issometimesreferredtoas“Med-Arb.”Exceptinunusualcircumstances,aprocedurewherebythesameindividualwhohasbeenservingasamediatorbecomesanarbitratorwhenthemediationfailsisnotrecommended,becauseitcouldinhibitthecandorwhichshouldcharacterizethemediationprocessand/oritcouldconveyevidence,legalpointsorsettlementpositionsexparte,improperlyinfluencingthearbitrator.Asampleofamed-arbclausefollows.
MEDARB1 Ifadisputearisesfromorrelatestothiscontractorthebreachthereof,andifthedisputecannotbesettledthroughdirectdiscussions,thepartiesagreetoendeavorfirsttosettlethedisputebymediationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationunderitsCommercialMediationProceduresbeforeresortingtoarbitration.Anyunresolvedcontroversyorclaimaris-ingfromorrelatingtothiscontractorbreachthereofshallbesettledbyarbitrationadministeredbytheAmericanArbitrationAssociationinaccordancewithitsCommercialArbitrationRules,andjudgmentontheawardrenderedbythearbitratormaybeenteredinanycourthavingjurisdictionthereof.Ifallpartiestothedisputeagree,amediatorinvolvedintheparties’mediationmaybeaskedtoserveasthearbitrator.
T.StatuteofLimitations
Partiesmaywishtoconsiderwhethertheapplicablestatuteoflimitationswillbetolledforthedurationofmediationproceedings,andcanrefertothefollowinglanguage.
STATLIM1 Therequirementsoffilinganoticeofclaimwithrespecttothedisputesubmittedtomediationshallbesuspendeduntiltheconclusionofthemediationprocess.
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
38
![Page 41: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
U.DisputeResolutionBoards
ADisputeResolutionBoard(DRB)providesaprompt,rational,impartialreviewofdisputesbymutuallyacceptedexperts,whichfrequentlyresultsinsubstantialcostsavingsandcaneliminateyearsofwastedtimeandenergyinlitigation.DRBproceduresmaybemadeapartofconstructioncontractdocuments.
ThecontractshouldcontainaparagraphreflectingtheagreementtoestablishtheDRB.Thetextoftheactualproceduresalsoshouldbephysicallyincorporatedintothegeneralconditionsorsupplementaryconditionsofthecontractforconstructionwhereverpossibleandpractical,andsuchdocumentsastheinvitationtobiddersortherequestforproposalsshouldmentionthattheformationofaDRBiscontemplated.TheDRBproceduresshouldbecoordinatedwiththeotherdisputeresolutionproceduresrequiredbythecontractdocuments.
Suggestedlanguageforincorporationinthecontractfollows.
DRB1 ThepartiesshallimpanelaDisputeResolutionBoardofoneorthreemembersinaccordancewiththeDisputeResolutionBoardGuideSpecificationsoftheAmericanArbitrationAssociation.TheDRB,incloseconsultationwithallinterestedparties,willassistandrecommendtheresolutionofanydisputes,claims,andothercontroversiesthatmightariseamongtheparties.
V.MassTorts
ADRtechniquescanbeemployedprivatelybypartiesfacingthepros-pectofmasstortlitigationtoexploreinanonbindingfashiontheoptionsformanagement,evaluation,and/orresolutionofthedispute.Awiderangeofbindingandnonbindingtechniques,includingneu-tralevaluation,mediation,andarbitrationcanbeusedtoexplorethepotentialforresolutionofadisputeand/ortodevelopabasicframeworkfordiscussions.Althoughtheseoptionshavelimitationsandmaynotbeasubstituteforlitigationwithpossiblefullevidentiarytrials,theycanprovideausefulframeworkforearlydiscussionoftheissues.Thepartiesshouldbeabletoformulateprocedurestoassureconfidentialityandtoprotectagainsttheinappropriateuseofinformation.
39
![Page 42: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Conclusion
Adisputeresolutionclauseshouldaddressthespecialneedsofthepartiesinvolved.AninadequateADRclausecanproduceasmuchdelay,expense,andinconvenienceasatraditionallawsuit.Whenwritingadisputeresolutionclause,keepinmindthatitspurposeistoresolvedisputes,notcreatethem.Ifdisagreementsariseoverthemeaningoftheclause,itisoftenbecauseitfailedtoaddresstheparticularneedsoftheparties.Useofstandard,simpleAAAlanguagemayavoiddifficulties.DraftinganeffectiveADRagreementisthefirststepontheroadtosuccessfuldisputeresolution.
Afteradisputearises,partiescanrequestanadministrativeconferencewithaAAAcasemanagertoassisttheminestablishingappropriateproceduresnecessaryfortheiruniquecase.Thiscanbedonebeforeoraftermediatororarbitratorselection.Suchconferencescanexpeditetheproceedingsinmanycases.
ThisbrochuredescribeswaysinwhichsomepartieshavemodifiedtheAAA’stime-testedstandardclausetodealwithspecificconcerns.Giventhatcommercialtransactionsvarygreatly,itspurposeisnottourgeuseoftheprovisionscited,butrathertosuggesttherangeofpossibleoptions.ToarriveatthemostsuitableandeffectiveADRclause,partiesshouldconsultlegalcounselforguidanceandadvice.
Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses – A Practical Guide
40
![Page 43: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Rules, forms, procedures and guides, as well as information about applying for a fee reduction or deferral, are subject to periodic change and updating. To ensure that you have the most current information, see our website at www.adr.org.
©2004, all rights are reserved by the American Arbitration Association.
© 2007 American Arbitration Association, Inc. All rights reserved. These Rules are the copyrighted property of the American Arbitration Association (AAA) and are intended to be used in conjunction with the AAA’s administrative services. Any unauthorized use or modification of these Rules may violate copyright laws and other applicable laws. Please contact 800.778.7879 or [email protected] for additional information.
![Page 44: Drafting Dispute Resolution Clauses€¦ · drafting or adopting any dispute resolution clause, no matter how basic. The second section describes the major features of arbitration,](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022081613/5f8a492031c57f773e2b6657/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
AAA197-2.5M-7/07