Download - oedipus naim and ruby
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
1/56
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
2/56
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
3/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Fza|d apz t|a iozm`t)~hof`v( az j`eaz`
Jatb vbzcg`v ae ^ohhov faglz`lot`( az |b`z`
Cvi`gpv lcu`v bcv azofh`v js ecz`'Eaz( ov tbap v``vt tbsv`he( apz vbc~ ae Vtot`(
Vaz` jpee`t`d( fog ga iaz` hcet b`z b`od(
Eapgd`z`d j`g`otb o |`ht`zcgl vpzl` ae jhaad'O jhclbt cv ag apz bozu`vt cg tb` `oz(
O jhclbt p~ag tb` lzo{cgl ehafmv ogd b`zdv(
O jhclbt ag |cu`v cg tzouoch= ogd |ctbohOzi`d |ctb bcv jho{cgl tazfb tb` Lad ae ^holp`
Botb v|aa~`d p~ag apz fcts `i~tscgl
Tb` bapv` ae Fodipv( ogd tb` ipzms z`ohiAe ^hpta cv ephh e`d |ctb lzaogv ogd t`ozv'
Tb`z`eaz`( A Mcgl( b`z` ot tbs b`oztb |` vct(C ogd tb`v` fbchdz`g= gat ov d``icgl tb``
O g`| dcucgcts( jpt tb` eczvt ae i`g=Eczvt cg tb` faiiag offcd`gtv ae hce`(
Ogd eczvt cg ucvctotcagv ae tb` Ladv'
Ozt tbap gat b` |ba faicgl ta tb` ta|gae Fodipv ez``d pv ezai tb` tor |` ~ocd
Ta tb` e`hh vaglvtz`vv1 Gaz bodvt tbap z`f`cu`d
^zai~tcgl ezai pv az j``g js atb`zv vfbaah`d=Ga( js o lad cgv~cz`d "va ohh i`g d``i(
Ogd t`vtces# dcdvt tbap z`g`| apz hce`'
Ogd ga|( A A`dc~pv( apz ~``zh`vv mcgl(Ohh |` tbs uatozc`v j`v``fb tb``( ecgdVai` vpffaz( |b`tb`z js o uacf` ezai b`ou`g
\bcv~`z`d( az bo~hs mga|g js bpiog |ct'
Tzc`d fapgv`hazv( i`tbcgmv( oz` o~t`vt eapgd ]?YTa epzgcvb eaz tb` eptpz` ~z`lgogt z`d`'
P~zocv`( A fbc`e ae i`g( p~zocv` apz Vtot`/
Haam ta tbs hopz`hv/ eaz tbs {`oh ae saz`Apz fapgtzs,v voucaz tbap ozt kpvths boch`d;
A g`u`z ios |` tbpv z`fazd tbs z`clg;))
*B` zocv`d pv p~ aghs ta fovt pv da|g'*
P~hcet pv( jpchd apz fcts ag o zafm'Tbs bo~~s vtoz ovf`gdogt jzaplbt pv hpfm(
A h`t ct gat d`fhcg`/ Ce tbap |aphdvt zph`
Tbcv hogd( ov ga| tbap z`clg`vt( j`tt`z vpz`Ta zph` o ~`a~h`d tbog o d`v`zt z`ohi'
Gaz jotth`i`gtv gaz lohh`sv oplbt ouoch(
Ce i`g ta iog ogd lpozdv ta lpozd tb`i toch
'A@DC^PVOb/ is ~aaz fbchdz`g( mga|g( ob( mga|g taa |`hh(
6
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
4/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Tb` qp`vt tbot jzcglv sap bctb`z ogd sapz g``d'
S` vcfm`g ohh( |`hh |at C( s`t is ~ocg(
Ba| lz`ot va`u`z sapzv( aptta~v ct ohh'Sapz vazza| tapfb`v `ofb iog v`u`zohhs(
Bci ogd gag` atb`z( jpt C lzc`u` ot agf`
Jatb eaz tb` l`g`zoh ogd isv`he ogd sap'Tb`z`eaz` s` zapv` ga vhpllozd ezai dos)dz`oiv'
Iogs( is fbchdz`g( oz` tb` t`ozv C,u` |`~t(
Ogd tbz`od`d iogs o io{` ae |`ozs tbaplbt'Tbpv ~agd`zcgl ag` fhp` ae ba~` C foplbt(
Ogd tzofm`d ct p~= C bou` v`gt I`ga`f`pv, vag(
Fz`ag( is fagvazt,v jzatb`z( ta cgqpcz`Ae ^stbcog ^ba`jpv ot bcv D`h~bcf vbzcg`(
Ba| C iclbt vou` tb` Vtot` js oft az |azd'Ogd ga| C z`fmag p~ tb` toh` ae dosv
Vcgf` b` v`t eaztb( ogd iozu`h ba| b` eoz`v',Tcv vtzogl`( tbcv `gdh`vv tozzscgl( ~ovvcgl vtzogl`'
Jpt |b`g b` fai`v( tb`g C |`z` jov` cgd``d(
Ce C ~`zeazi gat ohh tb` lad d`fhoz`v'
^ZC@VT
Tbs |azdv oz` |`hh tci`d= `u`g ov tbap v~`om`vt
Tbot vbaptcgl t`hhv i` Fz`ag cv ot bogd'
A@DC^PVA Mcgl O~ahha/ ios bcv kasapv haamv
J` ~z`vol` ae tb` kasapv g`|v b` jzcglv/
^ZC@VT
Ov C vpzicv`( ,tcv |`hfai`= `hv` bcv b`od
Bod vfozf` j``g fza|g`d |ctb j`zzs)hod`g josv'
A@DC^PV
\` vaag vbohh mga|= b`,v ga| cg `ozvbat zogl`']@gt`z FZ@AGY
Is zasoh fapvcg( vos( I`ga`f`pv, fbchd(
\bot i`vvol` bovt tbap jzaplbt pv ezai tb` lad1
FZ@AG
Laad g`|v( eaz `,`g cgtah`zojh` chhv(Ecgdcgl zclbt cvvp`( t`gd ta goplbt jpt laad'
A@DC^PV
Ba| zpgv tb` azofh`1 tbpv eoz tbs |azdv
Lcu` i` ga lzapgd eaz fagecd`gf` az e`oz'
4
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
5/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
FZ@AG
Ce tbap |aphdvt b`oz is i`vvol` ~pjhcfhs(
C,hh t`hh tb`` vtzoclbt( az |ctb tb`` ~ovv |ctbcg'
A@DC^PV
V~`om j`eaz` ohh= tb` jpzd`g tbot C j`oz
Cv iaz` eaz tb`v` is vpjk`ftv tbog isv`he'
FZ@AG
H`t i` z`~azt tb`g ohh tb` lad d`fhoz`d'Mcgl ^ba`jpv jcdv pv vtzocths `rtcz~ot`
O e`hh ~ahhptcag tbot cge`vtv tb` hogd(
Ogd ga iaz` bozjaz og cgu`t`zot` vaz`'
A@DC^PV
\bot `r~cotcag i`ogv b`1 \bot,v oicvv1
FZ@AG
Jogcvbi`gt( az tb` vb`ddcgl jhaad eaz jhaad'
Tbcv vtocg ae jhaad iom`v vbc~|z`fm ae apz vtot`'
A@DC^PV
\bai fog b` i`og( tb` icvfz`ogt tbpv d`gapgf`d1
FZ@AG
J`eaz` tbap dcdvt ovvpi` tb` b`hi ae Vtot`(Tb` vau`z`clg ae tbcv hogd |ov Hocpv'
A@DC^PV
C b`ozd ov ipfb( jpt g`u`z vo| tb` iog'
FZ@AG
B` e`hh= ogd ga| tb` lad,v faiiogd cv ~hocg;
^pgcvb bcv tom`zv)aee( |ba`,`z tb`s j`'
A@DC^PV
\b`z` oz` tb`s1 \b`z` cg tb` |cd` |azhd ta ecgd
Tb` eoz( eocgt tzof`v ae o jslag` fzci`1
FZ@AG
Cg tbcv hogd( vocd tb` lad= *|ba v``mv vbohh ecgd=\ba vctv |ctb eahd`d bogdv az vh``~v cv jhcgd'*
A@DC^PV
\ov b` |ctbcg bcv ~ohof`( az oec`hd(
Az tzou`hcgl( |b`g Hocpv i`t bcv eot`1
0
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
6/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
FZ@AG
Ojzaod= b` vtozt`d( va b` tahd pv( japgd
Eaz D`h~bc( jpt b` g`u`z tb`gf` z`tpzg`d'
A@DC^PV
Foi` tb`z` ga g`|v( ga e`hha|)tzou`h`z
Ta lcu` vai` fhp` tbot iclbt j` eahha|`d p~1
FZ@AG
Jpt ag` `vfo~`( |ba ehscgl eaz d`oz hce`(Faphd t`hh ae ohh b` vo| jpt ag` tbcgl vpz`'
A@DC^PV
Ogd |bot |ov tbot1 Ag` fhp` iclbt h od pv eoz(
\ctb jpt o v~ozm ae ba~` ta lpcd` apz qp`vt'
FZ@AG
Zajj`zv( b` tahd pv( gat ag` jogdct jptO tzaa~ ae mgou`v( ottofm`d ogd ipzd`z`d bci'
A@DC^PV
Dcd ogs jogdct doz` va jahd o vtzam`(
Pgh`vv cgd``d b` |`z` vpjazg`d ezai Tb`j`v1
FZ@AG
Va ,t|ov vpzicv`d( jpt gag` |ov eapgd ta ou`gl`Bcv ipzd`z icd tb` tzapjh` tbot `gvp`d'
A@DC^PV
\bot tzapjh` fog bou` bcgd`z`d o ephh qp`vt(
\b`g zasohts bod eohh`g tbpv icv`zojhs1
FZ@AG
Tb` zcddhcgl V~bcgr fai~`hh`d pv ta h`t vhcd`Tb` dci ~ovt ogd ott`gd ta cgvtogt g``dv'
A@DC^PV
\`hh( C |chh vtozt oez`vb ogd agf` olocgIom` dozm tbcglv fh`oz' Zclbt |aztbs tb` fagf`zgAe ^ba`jpv( |aztbs tbcg` taa( eaz tb` d`od=
C ohva( ov cv i``t( |chh h`gd is ocd
Ta ou`gl` tbcv |zagl ta Tb`j`v ogd ta tb` lad'Gat eaz vai` eoz)aee mcgviog( jpt isv`he(
Vbohh C `r~`h tbcv ~acvag cg tb` jhaad=
Eaz |bava vh`| tbot mcgl iclbt bou` o icgd
Ta vtzcm` i` taa |ctb bcv ovvovvcg bogd'Tb`z`eaz` cg zclbtcgl bci C v`zu` isv`he'
5
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
7/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
P~( fbchdz`g( bovt` s`( qpct tb`v` ohtoz vtoczv(
Tom` b`gf` sapz vp~~hcogt |ogdv( la vpiiag bctb`z
Tb` Tb`jog faiiagv' \ctb tb` lad,v laad b`h~Vpff`vv cv vpz`= ,tcv zpcg ce |` eoch'
]@r`pgt A@DC^PV ogd FZ@AGY
^ZC@VT
Fai`( fbchdz`g( h`t pv b`gf`= tb`v` lzofcapv |azdvEaz`vtohh tb` u`zs ~pz~av` ae apz vpct'
Ogd ios tb` lad |ba v`gt tbcv azofh`
Vou` pv |ctboh ogd zcd pv ae tbcv ~`vt']@r`pgt ^ZC@VT ogd VP^^HCOGTVY
^OZADAVFBAZPV
"Vtz' ?#V|``t)uacf`d doplbt`z ae [`pv ezai tbs lahd)~ou`d ^stbcog vbzcg`
\oet`d ta Tb`j`v dcucg`(
\bot davt tbap jzcgl i`1 Is vaph cv zofm`d ogd vbcu`zv |ctb e`oz'"B`oh`z ae D`hav( b`oz/#
Bovt tbap vai` ~ocg pgmga|g j`eaz`(
Az |ctb tb` fczfhcgl s`ozv z`g`|`vt o ~`gogf` ae saz`1
Aeev~zcgl ae lahd`g Ba~`( tbap uacf` ciiaztoh( A t`hh i`'
"Ogt' ?#Eczvt ag Otb`g` C fohh= A [`pv)jazg ladd`vv( d`e`gd/
Ladd`vv ogd vcvt`z( j`ezc`gd(
Ozt`icv( Hods ae Tb`j`v( bclb)tbzag`d cg tb` icdvt ae apz iozt/Hazd ae tb` d`otb)|cgl`d dozt/
Sapz tbz``eahd ocd C fzou`
Ezai d`otb ogd zpcg apz fcts ta vou`'Ce cg tb` dosv ae ahd |b`g |` gclb bod ~`zcvb`d( s` dzou`
Ezai apz hogd tb` ec`zs ~holp`( j` g`oz pv ga| ogd d`e`gd pv/
"Vtz' :#
Ob i`( |bot fapgth`vv |a`v oz` icg`/
Ohh apz bavt cv cg d`fhcg`=\`o~agh`vv is v~czct hc`v'
@oztb b`z lzofcapv ezpctv d`gc`v=
\ai`g |och cg jozz`g tbza`v=Hce` ag hce` da|gvtzcm`g la`v(
V|cet`z tbog tb` |cgd jczd,v ehclbt(
V|cet`z tbog tb` Ecz`)Lad,v iclbt(
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
8/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Ta tb` |`vt`zcgl vbaz`v ae Gclbt'
"Ogt' :#\ovt`d tbpv js d`otb ag d`otb
Ohh apz fcts ~`zcvb`tb'Faz~v`v v~z`od cge`ftcag zapgd=
Gag` ta t`gd az iapzg cv eapgd'
\ochcgl ag tb` ohtoz vtocz\cu`v ogd lzogdoiv z`gd tb` ocz))
Hagl)dzo|g iaogv ogd ~c`zfcgl fzc`v
Jh`gt |ctb ~zos`zv ogd hctogc`v'Lahd`g fbchd ae [`pv( A b`oz
H`t tbcg` ogl`h eof` o~~`oz/
"Vtz' 6#
Ogd lzogt tbot Oz`v |bav` bat jz`otb C e``h(
Tbaplb |ctbapt tozl` az vt``hB` vtohmv( |bav` uacf` cv ov tb` jotth` vbapt(
Ios tpzg cg vpdd`g zapt(
Ta tb` pgbozjaz`d Tbzofcog |ot`zv v~`d(Az Oi~bctzct`,v j`d'
Eaz |bot gclbt h`ou`v pgdag`(
Vict js tb` iazza|,v vpg^`zcvb`tb' Eotb`z [`pv( |bav` bogd
Datb |c`hd tb` hclbtgcgl jzogd(Vhos bci j`g`otb tbs h`ucg jahd( |` ~zos(
Vhos bci( A vhos/
"Ogt' 6#A tbot tbcg` ozza|v taa( Hsf`og Mcgl(
Ezai tbot topt ja|,v lahd vtzcgl(
Iclbt ehs ojzaod( tb` fboi~cagv ae apz zclbtv=S`o( ogd tb` ehovbcgl hclbtv
Ae Ozt`icv( |b`z`|ctb tb` bpgtz`vv v|``~v
Ofzavv tb` Hsfcog vt``~v'
Tb`` taa C fohh |ctb lahd`g)vgaad`d bocz(
\bav` goi` apz hogd datb j`oz(Joffbpv ta |bai tbs Io`godv @ua` vbapt=
Fai` |ctb tbs jzclbt tazfb( zapt(Jhctb` lad |bai |` odaz`(
Tb` lad |bai ladv ojbaz'
2
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
9/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
VF@G@ C]@gt`z A@DC^PV'Y
A@DC^PV
S` ~zos= ,tcv |`hh( jpt |aphd s` b`oz is |azdv
Ogd b``d tb`i ogd o~~hs tb` z`i`ds(
S` iclbt ~`zfbogf` ecgd faieazt ogd z`hc`e'Icgd sap( C v~`om ov ag` |ba fai`v o vtzogl`z
Ta tbcv z`~azt( ga h`vv tbog ta tb` fzci`=
Eaz ba| pgocd`d faphd C tzofm ct eoz
\ctbapt o fhp`1 \bcfb hofmcgl "eaz taa hot`\ov C `gzahh`d o fctc{`g ae Tb`j`v#
Tbcv ~zafhoiotcag C oddz`vv ta ohh;))
Tb`jogv( ce ogs mga|v tb` iog js |baiHocpv( vag ae Hojdofpv( |ov vhocg(
C vpiiag bci ta iom` fh`og vbzcet ta i`'
Ogd ce b` vbzcgmv( h`t bci z`eh`ft tbot tbpvFage`vvcgl b` vbohh ,vfo~` tb` fo~ctoh fbozl`=
Eaz tb` |azvt ~`gohts tbot vbohh j`eohh bci
Cv jogcvbi`gt))pgvfotb`d b` vbohh d`~ozt'Jpt ce og ohc`g ezai o eaz`clg hogd
J` mga|g ta ogs ov tb` ipzd`z`z(
H`t bci |ba mga|v v~`om apt( ogd b` vbohh bou`
Dp` z`fai~`gv` ezai i` ogd tbogmv ta jaat'Jpt ce s` vtchh m``~ vch`gf`( ce tbzaplb e`oz
Eaz v`he az ezc`gdv s` dcvz`lozd is b`vt(
B`oz |bot C tb`g z`vahu`= C hos is jogAg tb` ovvovvcg |bava`,`z b` j`'
H`t ga iog cg tbcv hogd( |b`z`ae C bahd
Tb` vau`z`clg zph`( bozjaz az v~`om ta bci=Lcu` bci ga ~ozt cg ~zos`z az vofzcecf`
Az hpvtzoh zct`v( jpt bapgd bci ezai sapz bai`v'
Eaz tbcv cv apz d`ech`i`gt( va tb` lad
Botb hot`hs vba|g ta i` js azofh`v'Tbpv ov tb`cz fboi~cag C iocgtocg tb` fopv`
Jatb ae tb` lad ogd ae tb` ipzd`z`d Mcgl'
Ogd ag tb` ipzd`z`z tbcv fpzv` C hos"Ag bci ogd ohh tb` ~oztg`zv cg bcv lpcht#;))
\z`tfb( ios b` ~cg` cg ptt`z |z`tfb`dg`vv/
Ogd eaz isv`he( ce |ctb is ~zcuctsB` locg odicttogf` ta is b`oztb( C ~zos
Tb` fpzv` C hocd ag atb`zv eohh ag i`'
3
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
10/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
V`` tbot s` lcu` `ee`ft ta ohh is b`vt(
Eaz is vom` ogd tb` lad,v ogd eaz apz hogd(
O d`v`zt jhovt`d js tb` |zotb ae b`ou`g'Eaz( h`t ohag` tb` lad,v `r~z`vv faiiogd(
Ct |`z` o vfogdoh s` vbaphd h`ou` pg~pzl`d
Tb` ipzd`z ae o lz`ot iog ogd sapz mcgl(Gaz tzofm ct bai`' Ogd ga| tbot C oi hazd(
Vpff`vvaz ta bcv tbzag`( bcv j`d( bcv |ce`(
"Ogd bod b` gat j``g ezpvtzot` cg tb` ba~`Ae cvvp`( faiiag fbchdz`g ae ag` |aij
Bod eazf`d o fhav`z jagd t|crt bci ogd i`(
Jpt Eot` v|aa~`d da|g p~ag bci#( tb`z`eaz` CBcv jhaad)ou`gl`z |chh iocgtocg bcv fopv`
Ov tbaplb b` |`z` is vcz`( ogd h`ou` ga vtag`Pgtpzg`d ta tzofm tb` ovvovvcg az ou`gl`
Tb` vag ae Hojdofpv( ae ^ahsdaz`(Ae Fodipv( ogd Ol`gaz eczvt ae tb` zof`'
Ogd eaz tb` dcvaj`dc`gt tbpv C ~zos;
Ios tb` ladv v`gd tb`i g`ctb`z tci`hs ezpctvAe `oztb( gaz t``icgl cgfz`ov` ae tb` |aij(
Jpt ios tb`s |ovt` ogd ~cg`( ov ga| tb`s |ovt`(
Os` ogd |azv` vtzcfm`g= jpt ta ohh ae sap(Is hasoh vpjk`ftv |ba o~~zau` is oftv(
Ios Kpvtcf`( apz ohhs( ogd ohh tb` ladv
J` lzofcapv ogd ott`gd sap `u`ziaz`'
FBAZPV
Tb` aotb tbap ~zaee`z`vt( vcz`( C tom` ogd v|`oz'C vh`| bci gat isv`he( gaz fog C goi`
Tb` vhos`z' Eaz tb` qp`vt( ,t|`z` |`hh( i`tbcgmv
Tbot ^ba`jpv( |ba ~za~av`d tb` zcddh`( bciv`heVbaphd lcu` tb` ogv|`z))|ba tb` ipzd`z`z |ov'
A@DC^PV
\`hh ozlp`d= jpt ga hcucgl iog fog ba~`
Ta eazf` tb` ladv ta v~`om olocgvt tb`cz |chh'
FBAZPV
Ios C tb`g vos |bot v``iv g`rt j`vt ta i`1
A@DC^PV
Os`( ce tb`z` j` o tbczd j`vt( t`hh ct taa'
FBAZPV
Is hc`l`( ce ogs iog v``v `s` ta `s`
\ctb apz hazd ^ba`jpv( ,tcv apz ~za~b`t( hazd
?>
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
11/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
T`cz`vcov= b` ae ohh i`g j`vt iclbt lpcd`
O v`ozfb`z ae tbcv iott`z ta tb` hclbt'
A@DC^PV
B`z` taa is {`oh bov gatbcgl holl`d( eaz t|cf`Ot Fz`ag,v cgvtogf` bou` C v`gt ta e`tfb bci(
Ogd hagl C iozu`h |bs b` cv gat b`z`'
FBAZPV
C icgd i` taa ae zpiazv hagl ola))I`z` lavvc~'
A@DC^PV
T`hh tb`i( C |aphd eocg mga| ohh'
FBAZPV
,T|ov vocd b` e`hh js tzou`h`zv'
A@DC^PV
Va C b`ozd(Jpt gag` bov v``g tb` iog |ba vo| bci eohh'
FBAZPV
\`hh( ce b` mga|v |bot e`oz cv( b` |chh qpoch
Ogd eh`` j`eaz` tb` t`zzaz ae tbs fpzv`'
A@DC^PV
\azdv vfoz` gat bci |ba jh`gfb`v gat ot d``dv'
FBAZPV
Jpt b`z` cv ag` ta ozzoclg bci' Ha( ot h`gltb
Tb`s jzcgl tb` lad)cgv~cz`d v``z cg |bai
Ojau` ohh atb`z i`g cv tzptb cgjazg'
]@gt`z T@CZ@VCOV( h`d js o jas'Y
A@DC^PV
T`cz`vcov( v``z |ba fai~z`b`gd`vt ohh(
Haz` ae tb` |cv` ogd bcdd`g isvt`zc`v(Bclb tbcglv ae b`ou`g ogd ha| tbcglv ae tb` `oztb(Tbap mga|`vt( tbaplb tbs jhcgd`d `s`v v`` goplbt(
\bot ~holp` cge`ftv apz fcts= ogd |` tpzg
Ta tb``( A v``z( apz ag` d`e`gv` ogd vbc`hd'Tb` ~pz~azt ae tb` ogv|`z tbot tb` Lad
Z`tpzg`d ta pv |ba vaplbt bcv azofh`(
Tb` i`vv`gl`zv bou` dapjth`vv tahd tb``))ba|
Ag` fapzv` ohag` faphd zcd pv ae tb` ~`vt(Ta ecgd tb` ipzd`z`zv ae Hocpv(
??
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
12/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Ogd vhos tb`i az `r~`h tb`i ezai tb` hogd'
Tb`z`eaz` j`lzpdlcgl g`ctb`z oplpzs
Gaz atb`z dcucgotcag tbot cv tbcg`(A vou` tbsv`he( tbs fapgtzs( ogd tbs mcgl(
Vou` ohh ezai tbcv d`ech`i`gt ae jhaad vb`d'
Ag tb`` |` z`vt' Tbcv cv iog,v bclb`vt `gd(Ta atb`zv, v`zucf` ohh bcv ~a|`zv ta h`gd'
T@CZ@VCOV
Ohov( ohov( |bot icv`zs ta j` |cv`
\b`g |cvdai ~zaectv gatbcgl/ Tbcv ahd hazC bod eazlatt`g= `hv` C |`z` gat b`z`'
A@DC^PV\bot ochv tb``1 \bs tbcv i`hogfbahs iaad1
T@CZ@VCOV
H`t i` la bai`= ~z`u`gt i` gat= ,t|`z` j`vt
Tbot tbap vbaphdvt j`oz tbs jpzd`g ogd C icg`'
A@DC^PV
Eaz vboi`/ ga tzp`)jazg Tb`jog ~otzcat
\aphd tbpv |ctbbahd tb` |azd ae ~za~b`fs'
T@CZ@VCOV
Tbs |azdv( A mcgl( oz` |cd` ae tb` iozm( ogd CEaz e`oz h`vt C taa tzc~ hcm` tb``'''
A@DC^PV
Ab v~`om(
\ctbbahd gat( C odkpz` tb``( ce tbap mga|,vt(
Tbs mga|h`dl`' \` oz` ohh tbs vp~~hcogtv'
T@CZ@VCOV
Os`( eaz s` ohh oz` |cth`vv( jpt is uacf`\chh g`,`z z`u`oh is icv`zc`v))az tbcg`' ]:Y
A@DC^PV\bot tb`g( tbap mga|`vt( ogd s`t |chhvt gat v~`om/
\aphdvt tbap j`tzos pv ogd d`vtzas tb` Vtot`1
T@CZ@VCOV
C |chh gat u`r isv`he gaz tb``' \bs ovm
Tbpv cdhs |bot ezai i` tbap vboht gat h`ozg1
A@DC^PV
Iagvt`z/ tbs vch`gf` |aphd cgf`gv` o ehcgt'
?:
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
13/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
\chh gatbcgl haav` tbs taglp`1 Fog gatbcgl i`ht tb``(
Az vbom` tbs dall`d tofctpzgcts1
T@CZ@VCOV
Tbap jhoi,vt is iaad ogd v``vt gat tbcg` a|g\b`z`|ctb tbap ozt iot`d= ga( tbap tor`vt i`'
A@DC^PV
Ogd |ba faphd vtos bcv fbah`z |b`g b` b`ozd
Ba| cgvah`gths tbap davt ehapt tb` Vtot`1
T@CZ@VCOV
\`hh( ct |chh fai` |bot |chh( tbaplb C j` ipt`'
A@DC^PVVcgf` fai` ct ipvt( tbs dpts cv ta t`hh i`'
T@CZ@VCOV
C bou` ga iaz` ta vos= vtazi ov tbap |chhvt(
Ogd lcu` tb` z`cg ta ohh tbs ~`gt)p~ zol`'
A@DC^PV
S`o( C oi |zatb( ogd |chh gat vtcgt is |azdv(Jpt v~`om is |bah` icgd' Tbap i`tbcgmv tbap ozt b`(
\ba ~hogg`d tb` fzci`( os`( ogd ~`zeazi`d ct taa(
Ohh vou` tb` ovvovvcgotcag= ogd ce tbapBodvt gat j``g jhcgd( C bod j``g v|azg ta jaat
Tbot tbap ohag` dcdvt da tb` jhaads d``d'
T@CZ@VCOV
Cv ct va1 Tb`g C fbozl` tb`` ta ojcd`Js tbcg` a|g ~zafhoiotcag= ezai tbcv dos
V~`om gat ta tb`v` az i`' Tbap ozt tb` iog(
Tbap tb` offpzv`d ~ahhpt`z ae tbcv hogd'
A@DC^PV
Uch` vhogd`z`z( tbap jhpzt`vt eaztb tb`v` topgtv(
Ogd tbcgm,vt eazvaatb ov v``z ta la vfat ez``'
T@CZ@VCOV
S`o( C oi ez``( vtzagl cg tb` vtz`gltb ae tzptb'
A@DC^PV
\ba |ov tbs t`ofb`z1 gat i`tbcgmv tbs ozt'
T@CZ@VCOV
Tbap( laodcgl i` olocgvt is |chh ta v~`om'
?6
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
14/56
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
15/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
A@DC^PV
Cv tbcv o ~hat ae Fz`ag( az tbcg` a|g1
T@CZ@VCOV
Gat Fz`ag( tbap tbsv`he ozt tbcg` a|g jog`'
A@DC^PV
A |`ohtb ogd `i~czs ogd vmchh js vmchh
Apt|ctt`d cg tb` jotth`ec`hd ae hce`(
\bot v~ct` ogd `gus eahha| cg sapz tzocg/V``( eaz tbcv fza|g tb` Vtot` fage`zz`d ag i`'
O lcet( o tbcgl C vaplbt gat( eaz tbcv fza|g
Tb` tzpvts Fz`ag( is eoichcoz ezc`gd(
Botb hocg cg |oct ta apvt i` ogd vpjazg`dTbcv iapgt`jogm( tbcv kpllhcgl fbozhotog(
Tbcv tzcfmvs j`lloz)~zc`vt( eaz locg ohag`
M``g)`s`d( jpt cg bcv ~za~`z ozt vtag`)jhcgd'Vos( vczzob( bovt tbap `u`z ~zau`d tbsv`he
O ~za~b`t1 \b`g tb` zcddhcgl V~bcgr |ov b`z`
\bs bodvt tbap ga d`hcu`zogf` eaz tbcv eahm1Ogd s`t tb` zcddh` |ov gat ta j` vahu`d
Js lp`vv)|azm jpt z`qpcz`d tb` ~za~b`t,v ozt=
\b`z`cg tbap |ovt eapgd hofmcgl= g`ctb`z jczdvGaz vclg ezai b`ou`g b`h~`d tb``( jpt C foi`(
Tb` vci~h` A`dc~pv= C vta~~`d b`z iaptbJs iatb`z |ct( pgtoplbt ae oplpzc`v'
Tbcv cv tb` iog |bai tbap |aphdvt pgd`zicg`(Cg ba~` ta z`clg |ctb Fz`ag cg is vt`od'
I`tbcgmv tbot tbap ogd tbcg` oj`ttaz vaag
\chh zp` sapz ~hat ta dzcu` tb` vfo~`laot apt'Tbogm tbs lz`s boczv tbot tbap bovt vtchh ta h`ozg
\bot fbovtcv`i`gt vpfb ozzalogf` d`v`zu`v'
FBAZPV
Ta pv ct v``iv tbot jatb tb` v``z ogd tbap(
A A`dc~pv( bou` v~am`g oglzs |azdv'
Tbcv cv ga tci` ta |zoglh` jpt fagvphtBa| j`vt |` ios ephechh tb` azofh`'
T@CZ@VCOV
Mcgl ov tbap ozt( ez`` v~``fb ot h`ovt cv icg`Ta iom` z`~hs= cg tbcv C oi tbs ~``z'
C a|g ga hazd jpt Harcov= bci C v`zu`
Ogd g`,`z fog vtogd `gzahh`d ov Fz`ag,v iog'Tbpv tb`g C ogv|`z; vcgf` tbap bovt gat v~oz`d
?0
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
16/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Ta t|ct i` |ctb is jhcgdg`vv))tbap bovt `s`v(
S`t v``,vt gat cg |bot icv`zs tbap ozt eohh`g(
Gaz |b`z` tbap d|`hh`vt gaz |ctb |bai eaz iot`'Davt mga| tbs hcg`ol`1 Gos( tbap mga|,vt ct gat(
Ogd ohh pg|cttcgl ozt o dapjh` ea`
Ta tbcg` a|g mcg( tb` hcucgl ogd tb` d`od=Os` ogd tb` dallcgl fpzv` ae iatb`z ogd vcz`
Ag` dos vbohh dzcu` tb``( hcm` o t|a)`dl`d v|azd(
J`sagd apz jazd`zv( ogd tb` `s`v tbot ga|V`` fh`oz vbohh b`gf`eaz|ozd `gdh`vv gclbt'
Ob |bctb`z vbohh tbs jctt`z fzs gat z`ofb(
\bot fzol cg ohh Fctbo`zag jpt vbohh tb`gZ`u`zj`zot` tbs |och( |b`g tbap bovt eapgd
\ctb |bot o bsi`g`oh tbap |ovt jazg`Bai`( jpt ta ga eocz bou`g( ag tb` loh`/
Os`( ogd o ehaad ae chhv tbap lp`vv`vt gatVbohh v`t tbsv`he ogd fbchdz`g cg ag` hcg`'
Ehapt tb`g jatb Fz`ag ogd is |azdv( eaz gag`
Ae iaztohv vbohh j` vtzcm`g |azv` tbog tbap'
A@DC^PV
Ipvt C `gdpz` tbcv e`hha|,v cgvah`gf`1
O ipzzocg ag tb``/ L`t tb`` b`gf`/ J`lag`
Ouopgt/ ogd g`u`z fzavv is tbz`vbahd iaz`'
T@CZ@VCOV
C g`,`z bod fai` bodvt tbap gat jcdd`g i`'
A@DC^PV
C mga| gat tbap |aphdvt ptt`z eahhs( `hv`
Hagl bodvt tbap |oct`d ta j` vpiiag`d b`z`'
T@CZ@VCOV
Vpfb oi C))ov ct v``iv ta tb`` o eaah(Jpt ta tb` ~oz`gtv |ba j`lot tb``( |cv`'
A@DC^PV\bot vos`vt tbap))*~oz`gtv*1 \ba j`lot i`( v~`om1
T@CZ@VCOV
Tbcv dos vbohh j` tbs jcztb)dos( ogd tbs lzou`'
A@DC^PV
Tbap hau,vt ta v~`om cg zcddh`v ogd dozm |azdv'
T@CZ@VCOV
?5
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
17/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Cg z`odcgl zcddh`v |ba va vmchh`d ov tbap1
A@DC^PVT|ct i` |ctb tbot |b`z`cg is lz`otg`vv hc`v'
T@CZ@VCOV
Ogd s`t tbcv u`zs lz`otg`vv ~zau`d tbs jog`'
A@DC^PV
Ga iott`z ce C vou`d tb` faiiag|`ohtb'
T@CZ@VCOV
,Tcv tci` C h`et tb``' Fai`( jas( tom` i` bai`'
A@DC^PVOs`( tom` bci qpcfmhs( eaz bcv ~z`v`gf` czmv
Ogd h`tv i`= lag`( tbap fogvt gat ~holp` i` iaz`'
T@CZ@VCOV
C la( jpt eczvt |chh t`hh tb`` |bs C foi`'
Tbs eza|g C dz`od gat( eaz tbap fogvt gat bozi i`'
B`oz tb`g; tbcv iog |bai tbap bovt vaplbt ta ozz`vt
\ctb tbz`otv ogd |ozzogtv tbcv hagl |bch`( tb` |z`tfb\ba ipzd`z`d Hocpv))tbot iog cv b`z`'
B` ~ovv`v eaz og ohc`g cg tb` hogd
Jpt vaag vbohh ~zau` o Tb`jog( gotcu` jazg'Ogd s`t bcv eaztpg` jzcglv bci hctth` kas=
Eaz jhcgd ae v``cgl( fhod cg j`lloz,v |``dv(
Eaz ~pz~h` zaj`v( ogd h`ogcgl ag bcv vtoee(Ta o vtzogl` hogd b` vaag vbohh lza~` bcv |os'
Ogd ae tb` fbchdz`g( cgiot`v ae bcv bai`(
B` vbohh j` ~zau`d tb` jzatb`z ogd tb` vcz`(Ae b`z |ba joz` bci vag ogd bpvjogd jatb(
Fa)~oztg`z( ogd ovvovvcg ae bcv vcz`'
La cg ogd ~agd`z tbcv( ogd ce tbap ecgd
Tbot C bou` icvv`d tb` iozm( b`gf`eaztb d`fhoz`
C bou` ga |ct gaz vmchh cg ~za~b`fs']@r`pgt T@CZ@VCOV ogd A@DC^PVY
AD@ CFBAZPV
"Vtz' ?#
\ba cv b` js uacf` ciiaztoh goi`d ezai ^stbco,v zafms f`hh(
Da`z ae eaph d``dv ae jhaadvb`d( bazzazv tbot ga taglp` fog t`hh1
?
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
18/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
O eaat eaz ehclbt b` g``dv
Eh``t`z tbog vtazi)v|cet vt``dv(
Eaz ag bcv b``hv datb eahha|(Ozi`d |ctb tb` hclbtgcglv ae bcv Vcz`( O~ahha'
Hcm` vh`ptb)bapgdv taa
Tb` Eot`v ~pzvp`'
"Ogt' ?#S`o( jpt ga| ehovb`d eaztb tb` vpiiagv ezai ^ozgovvpv, vga|s ~`om(
*G`oz ogd eoz tb` pgdcvfau`z`d da`z ae tbcv ipzd`z v``m/*
Ga| hcm` o vphh`g jphh b` zau`vTbzaplb eaz`vt jzom`v ogd p~hogd lzau`v(
Ogd uocghs v``mv ta ehs
Tb` daai tbot `u`z gclbEhctv a,`z bcv b`od(
Vtchh js tb` ou`glcgl ^ba`jpv v~`d(
Tb` uacf` dcucg`(
Ezai @oztb,v icd vbzcg`'"Vtz' :#
Vaz` ~`z~h`r`d oi C js tb` |azdv ae tb` iovt`z v``z'
Oz` tb`s tzp`( oz` tb`s eohv`1 C mga| gat ogd jzcdh` is taglp` eaze`oz(
Ehptt`z`d |ctb uolp` vpzicv`= gaz ~z`v`gt gaz eptpz` cv fh`oz'
_pozz`h ae ogfc`gt dot` az cg dosv vtchh g`oz mga| C gag`
T|crt tb` Hojdofcdog bapv` ogd apz zph`z( ^ahsjpv, vag'^zaae cv tb`z` gag`; ba| tb`g fog C fbohh`gl` apz Mcgl,v laad goi`(
Ba| cg o jhaad)e`pd kacg eaz og pgtzofm`d d``d ae vboi`1
"Ogt' :#
Ohh |cv` oz` [`pv ogd O~ahha( ogd gatbcgl cv bcd ezai tb`cz m`g=Tb`s oz` ladv= ogd cg |ctv o iog ios vpz~ovv bcv e`hha| i`g=
Jpt tbot o iaztoh v``z mga|v iaz` tbog C mga|))|b`z`
Botb tbcv j``g ~zau`g1 Az ba| |ctbapt vclg ovvpz`d( fog C jhoi`Bci |ba vou`d apz Vtot` |b`g tb` |cgl`d vaglvtz`vv foi`(
T`vt`d ogd tzc`d cg tb` hclbt ae pv ohh( hcm` lahd ovvos`d1
Ba| fog C ga| ovv`gt |b`g o fzci` cv ag A`dc~pv hocd1
VF@G@ CCFZ@AG
Ezc`gdv( fapgtzsi`g( C h`ozg Mcgl A`dc~pv
Botb hocd olocgvt i` o iavt lzc`uapv fbozl`(
?2
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
19/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Ogd fai` ta sap ~zat`vtcgl' Ce b` d``iv
Tbot C bou` bozi`d az cgkpz`d bci cg oplbt
Js |azd az d``d cg tbcv apz ~z`v`gt tzapjh`(C foz` gat ta ~zahagl tb` v~og ae hce`(
Tbpv chh)z`~pt`d= eaz tb` fohpigs
Bctv gat o vcglh` jhat( jpt jhovtv is goi`(Ce js tb` l`g`zoh uacf` C oi d`gapgf`d
Eohv` ta tb` Vtot` ogd eohv` js sap is ezc`gdv'
FBAZPV
Tbcv topgt( ct |`hh ios j`( |ov jhpzt`d aptCg ~`tphogf`( gat v~am`g oducv`dhs'
FZ@AGDcd ogs doz` ~z`t`gd tbot ct |ov C
^zai~t`d tb` v``z ta ptt`z o eazl`d fbozl`1
FBAZPV
Vpfb tbcglv |`z` vocd= |ctb |bot cgt`gt C mga| gat'
FZ@AG
\`z` gat bcv |ctv ogd ucvcag ohh ovtzos
\b`g p~ag i` b` ecr`d tbcv iagvtzapv fbozl`1
FBAZPV
C mga| gat= ta is vau`z`clg,v oftv C oi jhcgd'Jpt ha( b` fai`v ta ogv|`z eaz bciv`he']@gt`z A@DC^PV'Y
A@DC^PV
Vczzob( |bot iom,vt tbap b`z`1 Davt tbap ~z`vpi`
Ta o~~zaofb is daazv( tbap jzo{`g)eof`d zalp`(Is ipzd`z`z ogd tb` echfb`z ae is fza|g1
Fai`( ogv|`z tbcv( dcdvt tbap d`t`ft cg i`
Vai` tapfb ae fa|ozdcf` az |cth`vvg`vv(
Tbot iod` tb`` pgd`ztom` tbcv `gt`z~zcv`1
C v``i`d eazvaatb taa vci~h` ta ~`zf`cu`Tb` v`z~`gt vt`ohcgl ag i` cg tb` dozm(
Az `hv` taa |`om ta vfatfb ct |b`g C vo|'Tbcv tbap ozt |cth`vv v``mcgl ta ~avv`vv
\ctbapt o eahha|cgl az ezc`gdv tb` fza|g(
O ~zc{` tbot eahha|`zv ogd |`ohtb ipvt |cg'
FZ@AG
Ott`gd i`' Tbap bovt v~am`g( ,tcv is tpzgTa iom` z ~hs' Tb`g boucgl b`ozd i`( kpdl`'
?3
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
20/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
A@DC^PV
Tbap ozt lhcj ae taglp`( jpt C oi vha| ta h`ozg
Ae tb``= C mga| taa |`hh tbs u`gaiapv bot`'
FZ@AG
Eczvt C |aphd ozlp` apt tbcv u`zs ~acgt'
A@DC^PV
A ozlp` gat tbot tbap ozt gat o zalp`'
FZ@AG
Ce tbap davt fapgt o ucztp` vtpjjazgg`vv(
Pgvfbaah`d js z`ovag( tbap ozt ipfb ovtzos'
A@DC^PVCe tbap davt bahd o mcgviog ios j` |zagl`d(
Ogd ga ~ocgv eahha|( tbap ozt ipfb ta v``m'
FZ@AG
Tb`z`cg tbap kpdl`vt zclbths( jpt tbcv |zaglTbot tbap ohh`l`vt))t`hh i` |bot ct cv'
A@DC^PV
Dcdvt tbap az dcdvt tbap gat oducv` tbot C
Vbaphd fohh tb` ~zc`vt1
FZ@AG
S`v( ogd C vtogd ta ct'
A@DC^PV
T`hh i` ba| hagl cv ct vcgf` Hocpv'''
FZ@AG
Vcgf` Hocpv'''1 C eahha| gat tbs dzcet'
A@DC^PV
Js ucah`gt bogdv |ov v~czct`d o|os'
FZ@AG
Cg tb` dci ~ovt( o iogs s`ozv olag`'
A@DC^PV
Dcd tb` voi` ~za~b`t tb`g ~pzvp` bcv fzoet1
FZ@AG
S`v( vmchh`d ov ga| ogd cg ga h`vv z`~pt`'
A@DC^PV
:>
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
21/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Dcd b` ot tbot tci` `u`z lhogf` ot i`1
FZ@AGGat ta is mga|h`dl`( gat |b`g C |ov js'
A@DC^PV
Jpt |ov ga v`ozfb ogd cgqpcvctcag iod`1
FZ@AG
Vpz`hs ephh qp`vt |ov iod`( jpt gatbcgl h`ozgt'
A@DC^PV
\bs eoch`d tb` v``z ta t`hh bcv vtazs tb`g1
FZ@AGC mga| gat( ogd gat mga|cgl bahd is taglp`'
A@DC^PV
Tbcv ipfb tbap mga|`vt ogd fogvt vpz`hs t`hh'
FZ@AG
\bot,v i`og,vt tbap1 Ohh C mga| C |chh d`fhoz`'
A@DC^PV
Jpt eaz tbs ~zai~tcgl g`u`z bod tb` v``z
Ovfzcj`d ta i` tb` d`otb ae Hocpv'
FZ@AG
Ce va b` tbap mga|`vt j`vt= jpt C\aphd ~pt tb`` ta tb` qp`vtcag cg is tpzg'
A@DC^PV
_p`vtcag ogd ~zau` i` ipzd`z`z ce tbap fogvt'
FZ@AG
Tb`g h`t i` ovm tb``( dcdvt tbap |`d is vcvt`z1
A@DC^PV
O eoft va ~hocg C foggat |`hh d`gs'
FZ@AG
Ogd ov tbs fagvazt qp``g vb` vboz`v tb` tbzag`1
A@DC^PV
C lzogt b`z ez``hs ohh b`z b`ozt d`vcz`v'
FZ@AG
Ogd |ctb sap t|ocg C vboz` tb` tzc~h` zph`1
:?
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
22/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
A@DC^PV
S`o( ogd ct cv tbot ~zau`v tb`` o eohv` ezc`gd'
FZ@AG
Gat va( ce tbap |aphdvt z`ovag |ctb tbsv`he(Ov C |ctb isv`he' Eczvt( C jcd tb`` tbcgm(
\aphd ogs iaztoh fbaav` o tzapjh`d z`clg
Ae t`zzazv zotb`z tbog v`fpz` z`~av`(Ce tb` voi` ~a|`z |`z` lcu`g bci1 Ov eaz i`(
C bou` ga gotpzoh fzoucgl eaz tb` goi`
Ae mcgl( ~z`e`zzcgl ta da mcglhs d``dv(Ogd va tbcgmv `u`zs vaj`z)icgd`d iog'
Ga| ohh is g``dv oz` votcvec`d tbzaplb tb``(
Ogd C bou` goplbt ta e`oz= jpt |`z` C mcgl(Is oftv |aphd aet zpg fapgt`z ta is |chh'Ba| faphd o tcth` tb`g bou` fboziv eaz i`
Ojau` tb` v|``tv ae japgdh`vv cgehp`gf`1
C oi gat va cgeotpot` ov ta lzov~Tb` vboda| |b`g C bahd tb` vpjvtogf` eovt'
Ga| ohh i`g fzs i` Ladv~``d/ |cvb i` |`hh(
Ogd `u`zs vpctaz v``mv ta locg is `oz(Ce b` |aphd ba~` ta |cg o lzof` ezai tb``'
\bs vbaphd C h`ou` tb` j`tt`z( fbaav` tb` |azv`1
Tbot |`z` vb``z iodg`vv( ogd C oi gat iod'
Ga vpfb oijctcag `u`z t`i~t`d i`(Gaz |aphd C bou` o vboz` cg vpfb cgtzclp`'
Ogd ce tbap dapjt i`( eczvt ta D`h~bc la(
Tb`z` ovf`ztocg ce is z`~azt |ov tzp`Ae tb` lad,v ogv|`z= g`rt cgu`vtclot`
Ce |ctb tb` v``z C ~hatt`d az fagv~cz`d(
Ogd ce ct ~zau` va( v`gt`gf` i` ta d`otb(Gat js tbs uacf` ohag`( jpt icg` ogd tbcg`'
Jpt A fagd`ig i` gat( |ctbapt o~~`oh(
Ag joz` vpv~cfcag' ,Tcv gat zclbt ta odkpdl`Jod i`g ot zogdai laad( az laad i`g jod'
C |aphd ov hc`e o iog vbaphd fovt o|osTb` tbcgl b` fapgtv iavt ~z`fcapv( bcv a|g hce`(
Ov v~pzg o tzp` ezc`gd' Tbap |cht h ozg cg tci`Tb` tzptb( eaz tci` ohag` z`u`ohv tb` kpvt=
O uchhocg cv d`t`ft`d cg o dos'
FBAZPV
Ta ag` |ba |ohm`tb |ozchs bcv |azdvFaii`gd tb`iv`hu`v= v|cet fapgv`hv oz` gat vpz`'
::
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
23/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
A@DC^PV
\b`g |ctb v|cet vtzcd`v tb` vt`ohtbs ~hatt`z vtohmv
C ipvt j` qpcfm taa |ctb is fapgt`z~hat'Ta |oct bcv agv`t ~ovvcu`hs( eaz bci
Cv vpz` vpff`vv( eaz i` ovvpz`d d`e`ot'
FZ@AG
\bot tb`g,v tbs |chh1 Ta jogcvb i` tb` hogd1
A@DC^PV
C |aphd gat bou` tb`` jogcvb`d( ga( jpt d`od(
Tbot i`g ios iozm tb` |ol`v `gus z`o~v'
FZ@AG
C v`` tbap |cht gat sc`hd( gaz fz`dct i`'
A@DC^PV
]Gag` jpt o eaah |aphd fz`dct vpfb ov tbap'Y ]6Y
FZ@AG
Tbap ozt gat |cv`'
A@DC^PV
\cv` eaz isv`he ot h`ovt'
FZ@AG
\bs gat eaz i` taa1
A@DC^PV
\bs eaz vpfb o mgou`1
FZ@AG
Vp~~av` tbap hofm`vt v`gv`'
A@DC^PV
S`t mcglv ipvt zph`'
FZ@AG
Gat ce tb`s zph` chh'
A@DC^PV
Ab is Tb`jogv( b`oz bci/
FZ@AG
Tbs Tb`jogv1 oi gat C o Tb`jog taa1
FBAZPV
F`ov`( ~zcgf`v= ha tb`z` fai`v( ogd gag` taa vaag(
:6
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
24/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Kafovto ezai tb` ~ohof`' \ba va ect
Ov ~`of`iom`z ta z`fagfch` sapz e`pd1
]@gt`z KAFOVTO'Y
KAFOVTO
Icvlpcd`d ~zcgf`v( |bs bou` s` p~zocv`d
Tbcv |azds |zoglh`1 Oz` s` gat ovboi`d(
\bch` tb` |bah` hogd hc`v vtzcm`g( tbpv ta uacf`Sapz ~zcuot` cgkpzc`v1 La cg( is hazd=
La bai`( is jzatb`z( ogd eaz`j`oz ta iom`
O ~pjhcf vfogdoh ae o ~`tts lzc`e'
FZ@AG
Is zasoh vcvt`z( A`dc~pv( tbs hazd(Botb jcd i` fbaav` "A dz`od oht`zgotcu`/#
Og aptho|,v `rch` az o e`hag,v d`otb'
A@DC^PV
S`v( hods= C bou` foplbt bci ~zoftcfcglOlocgvt is zasoh ~`zvag bcv uch` oztv'
FZ@AG
Ios C g`,`z v~``d jpt dc` offpzv`d( ce C
Cg ogs |os oi lpchts ae tbcv fbozl`'
KAFOVTOJ`hc`u` bci( C odkpz` tb``( A`dc~pv(Eczvt eaz bcv vah`ig aotb,v vom`( tb`g eaz icg`(
Ogd eaz tbcg` `hd`zv, vom` |ba |oct ag tb``'
FBAZPV
"Vtz' ?#B`ozm`g( Mcgl( z`eh`ft( |` ~zos tb``( jpt gat vtpjjazg jpt z`h`gt'
A@DC^PV
Vos ta |bot vbaphd C fagv`gt1
FBAZPVZ`v~`ft o iog |bav` ~zajcts ogd tzatb
Oz` mga|g ta ohh ogd ga| fageczi`d js aotb'
A@DC^PV
Davt mga| |bot lzof` tbap fzou`vt1
FBAZPV
S`o( C mga|'
:4
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
25/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
A@DC^PV
D`fhoz` ct tb`g ogd iom` tbs i`ogcgl ~hocg'
FBAZPV
Jzogd gat o ezc`gd |bai jojjhcgl taglp`v ovvoch=H`t gat vpv~cfcag ,locgvt bcv aotb ~z`uoch'
A@DC^PV
J`tbcgm sap tbot cg v``mcgl tbcv s` v``m
Cg u`zs vaatb is d`otb az jogcvbi`gt1
FBAZPV
Ga( js tb` h`od`z ae tb` bavt dcucg`/"Vtz' :#
\ctg`vv( tbap Vpg( vpfb tbaplbt |ov g`u`z icg`(
Pgjh`vt( pgezc`gd`d ios C ~`zcvb(Ce `u`z C vpfb |cvb dcd fb`zcvb/
Jpt A is b`ozt cv d`vahot`
Ipvcgl ag apz vtzcm`g Vtot`(Dapjhs eohh,g vbaphd dcvfazd lza|
T|crt sap t|ocg( ta fza|g apz |a`'
A@DC^PV
\`hh( h`t bci la( ga iott`z |bot ct favt i`(
Az f`ztocg d`otb az vboi`eph jogcvbi`gt(
Eaz sapz vom` C z`h`gt( gat bcv= ogd bci(\b`z`,`z b` j`( is b`ozt vbohh vtchh ojbaz'
FZ@AG
Tbap ozt ov vphh`g cg tbs sc`hdcgl iaadOv cg tbcg` ogl`z tbap |ovt tzpfph`gt'
Vpfb t`i~`zv kpvths ~holp` tb`iv`hu`v tb` iavt'
A@DC^PV
H`ou` i` cg ~`of` ogd l`t tb`` lag`'
FZ@AG
C la(Js tb`` icvkpdl`d( jpt kpvtcec`d js tb`v`'
]@r`pgt FZ@AGY
FBAZPV
"Ogt' ?#Hods( h`od cgdaazv tbs fagvazt= |b`z`eaz` hagl`z b`z` d`hos1
KAFOVTO
T`hh i` eczvt ba| zav` tb` ezos'
:0
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
26/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
FBAZPV
Zpiazv jz`d pgkpvt vpv~cfcapv ogd cgkpvtcf` zogmh`v vaz`'
KAFOVTO
\`z` jatb ot eopht1
FBAZPV
Jatb'
KAFOVTO
\bot |ov tb` toh`1
FBAZPV
Ovm i` ga iaz`' Tb` hogd cv vaz` dcvtz`vv`d=
,T|`z` j`tt`z vh``~cgl chhv ta h`ou` ot z`vt'
A@DC^PV
Vtzogl` fapgv`h( ezc`gd/ C mga| tbap i`og,vt i` |`hh(
Ogd s`t |aphd,vt ictclot` ogd jhpgt is {`oh'
FBAZPV
"Ogt' :#
Mcgl( C vos ct agf` olocg(\cth`vv |`z` C ~zau`d( cgvog`(
Ce C hclbths ~pt o|os
Tb`` is fapgtzs,v ~za~ ogd vtos(^chat |ba( cg dogl`z vaplbt(
Ta o qpc`t bou`g jzaplbt
Apz dcvtzoft`d Vtot`= ogd ga|\ba fog lpcd` pv zclbt jpt tbap1
KAFOVTO
H`t i` taa( C odkpz` tb``( mga|( A mcgl(
\bot fopv` bov vtczz`d tbcv pgz`h`gtcgl |zotb'
A@DC^PV
C |chh( eaz tbap ozt iaz` ta i` tbog tb`v`'
Hods( tb` fopv` cv Fz`ag ogd bcv ~hatv'
KAFOVTO
Jpt |bot ~zauam`d tb` qpozz`h1 iom` tbcv fh`oz'
A@DC^PV
B` ~acgtv i` apt ov Hocpv, ipzd`z`z'
KAFOVTO
Ae bcv a|g mga|h`dl` az p~ag z`~azt1
:5
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
27/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
A@DC^PV
B` cv taa fpggcgl ta faiict bciv`he(
Ogd iom`v o iaptb~c`f` ae o mgoucvb v``z'
KAFOVTO
Tb`g tbap ios`vt `ov` tbs fagvfc`gf` ag tbot vfaz`'
Hcvt`g ogd C,hh fagucgf` tb`` tbot ga iog
Botb vfat az hat cg tb` ~za~b`tcf ozt'B`z` cv tb` ~zaae cg jzc`e' Og azofh`
Agf` foi` ta Hocpv "C |chh gat vos
,T|ov ezai tb` D`h~bcf lad bciv`he( jpt ezaiBcv icgcvt`zv# d`fhozcgl b` |ov daai`d
Ta ~`zcvb js tb` bogd ae bcv a|g vag(
O fbchd tbot vbaphd j` jazg ta bci js i`'Ga| Hocpv))va ot h`ovt z`~azt oeeczi`d))\ov ipzd`z`d ag o dos js bclb|osi`g(
Ga gotcu`v( ot o v~at |b`z` tbz`` zaodv i``t'
Ov eaz tb` fbchd( ct |ov jpt tbz`` dosv ahd(\b`g Hocpv( ctv ogmh`v ~c`zf`d ogd ~cgg`d
Tal`tb`z( lou` ct ta j` fovt o|os
Js atb`zv ag tb` tzofmh`vv iapgtocg vcd`'Va tb`g O~ahha jzaplbt ct gat ta ~ovv
Tb` fbchd vbaphd j` bcv eotb`z,v ipzd`z`z(
Az tb` dz`od t`zzaz ecgd offai~hcvbi`gt(
Ogd Hocpv j` vhocg js bcv a|g vag'Vpfb |ov tb` ~za~b`t,v bazavfa~`' A mcgl(
Z`lozd ct gat' \bot`,`z tb` lad d``iv ect
Ta v`ozfb( bciv`he pgocd`d |chh z`u`oh'
A@DC^PV
\bot i`iazc`v( |bot |chd tpipht ae tb` vaph
Foi` a,`z i`( hods( ov C b`ozd tb`` v~`om/
KAFOVTO
\bot i`og,vt tbap1 \bot bov vbafm`d ogd vtozth`d tb``1
A@DC^PVI`tbaplbt C b`ozd tb`` vos tbot Hocpv\ov ipzd`z`d ot tb` i``tcgl ae tbz`` zaodv'
KAFOVTO
Va zog tb` vtazs tbot cv fpzz`gt vtchh'
A@DC^PV
\b`z` dcd tbcv bo~~`g1 Davt tbap mga| tb` ~hof`1
:
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
28/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
KAFOVTO
^bafcv tb` hogd cv fohh`d= tb` v~at cv |b`z`
Jzogfb zaodv ezai D`h~bc ogd ezai Dophcv i``t'
A@DC^PV
Ogd ba| hagl cv ct vcgf` tb`v` tbcglv j`e`hh1
KAFOVTO
,T|ov jpt o jzc`e |bch` |`z` tbap |ovt ~zafhoci`d
Apz fapgtzs,v zph`z tbot tb` g`|v |ov jzaplbt'
A@DC^PV
A [`pv( |bot bovt tbap |chh`d ta da |ctb i`/
KAFOVTO\bot cv ct( A`dc~pv( tbot iau`v tb`` va1
A@DC^PV
Ovm i` gat s`t= t`hh i` tb` jpchd ogd b`clbt
Ae Hocpv1 \ov b` vtchh cg iogbaad,v ~zci`1
KAFOVTO
Tohh |ov b`( ogd bcv bocz |ov hclbths vtz`|g\ctb vchu`z= ogd gat pghcm` tb`` cg eazi'
A@DC^PV
A |a` cv i`/ I`btcgmv pg|cttcglhs
C hocd jpt ga| o dz`od fpzv` ag isv`he'
KAFOVTO
\bot vos,vt tbap1 \b`g C haam p~ag tb``( is mcgl(
C tz`ijh`'
A@DC^PV
,Tcv o dz`od ~z`v`gtci`gt
Tbot cg tb` `gd tb` v``z |chh ~zau` gat jhcgd'Ag` epztb`z qp`vtcag ta z`vahu` is dapjt'
KAFOVTO
C qpoch= jpt ovm( ogd C |chh ogv|`z ohh'
A@DC^PV
Bod b` jpt e`| ott`gdogtv az o tzocg
Ae ozi`d z`tocg`zv |ctb bci( hcm` o ~zcgf`1
KAFOVTO
Tb`s |`z` jpt ecu` cg ohh( ogd ag` ae tb`i
:2
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
29/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
O b`zohd= Hocpv cg o iph`)foz zad`'
A@DC^PVOhov/ ,tcv fh`oz ov gaagdos ga|' Jpt vos(
Hods( |ba fozzc`d tbcv z`~azt ta Tb`j`v1
KAFOVTO
O v`ze( tb` vah` vpzucuaz |ba z`tpzg`d'
A@DC^PV
Bo~hs b` cv ot bogd az cg tb` bapv`1
KAFOVTO
Ga( eaz ov vaag ov b` z`tpzg`d ogd eapgd
Tb`` z`clgcgl cg tb` vt`od ae Hocpv vhocg(B` fhov~`d is bogd ogd vp~~hcfot`d i`
Ta v`gd bci ta tb` oh~v ogd ~ovtpz`v( |b`z`
B` iclbt j` eoztb`vt ezai tb` vclbt ae Tb`j`v'Ogd va C v`gt bci' ,T|ov og bag`vt vhou`
Ogd |`hh d`v`zu`d vai` j`tt`z z`fai~`gv`'
A@DC^PV
E`tfb bci ot agf`' C eocg |aphd v`` tb` iog'
KAFOVTO
B` vbohh j` jzaplbt= jpt |b`z`eaz` vpiiag bci1
A@DC^PV
Hods( C e`oz is taglp` bov au`zzpg
Dcvfz`tcag= tb`z`eaz` C |aphd qp`vtcag bci'
KAFOVTO
\`hh( b` vbohh fai`( jpt ios gat C taa fhoci
Ta vboz` tb` jpzd`g ae tbs b`ozt( is mcgl1
A@DC^PVOgd tbap vboht gat j` ezpvtzot` ae tbs |cvb'
Ga| is ciolcgcglv bou` lag` va eoz'
\ba bov o bclb`z fhoci tbot tbap ta b`ozIs toh` ae dcz` odu`gtpz`v1 Hcvt`g tb`g'
Is vcz` |ov ^ahsjpv ae Fazcgtb( ogd
Is iatb`z I`za~`( o Dazcog=
Ogd C |ov b`hd tb` eaz`iavt fctc{`g(Tchh o vtzogl` tbcgl j`e`hh i`( vtzogl` cgd``d(
S`t vfozf` d`v`zucgl ohh tb` b`ot ct vtczz`d'
:3
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
30/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
O zacvt`z`z ot vai` jogqp`t( eha|g |ctb |cg`(
Vbapt`d *Tbap ozt gat tzp` vag ae tbs vcz`'*
Ct czm`d i`( jpt C vtaiofb`d eaz tb` gagf`Tb` cgvpht= ag tb` iazza| C vaplbt apt
Is iatb`z ogd is vcz` ogd qp`vtcag`d tb`i'
Tb`s |`z` cgdclgogt ot tb` zogdai vhpzFovt ag is ~oz`gtol` ogd dcd tb`cz j`vt
Ta faieazt i`( jpt vtchh tb` u`gai`d jozj
Zogmh`d( eaz vtchh tb` vfogdoh v~z`od ogd lz`|'Va ~zcuchs |ctbapt tb`cz h`ou` C |`gt
Ta D`h~bc( ogd O~ahha v`gt i` jofm
Jophm`d ae tb` mga|h`dl` tbot C foi` ta v``m'Jpt atb`z lzc`uapv tbcglv b` ~za~b`vc`d(
\a`v( hoi`gtotcagv( iapzgcgl( ~azt`gtv dcz`=Ta |ct C vbaphd d`ech` is iatb`z,v j`d
Ogd zocv` p~ v``d taa haotbvai` ta j`bahd(Ogd vhos tb` eotb`z ezai |bav` hacgv C v~zogl'
Tb`g( hods())tbap vboht b`oz tb` u`zs tzptb))
Ov C dz`| g`oz tb` tzc~h`)jzogfbcgl zaodv(O b`zohd i`t i` ogd o iog |ba vot
Cg o foz dzo|g js fahtv))ov cg tbs toh`))
Tb` iog cg ezagt ogd tb` ahd iog bciv`heTbz`ot`g`d ta tbzpvt i` zpd`hs ezai tb` ~otb(
Tb`g kavth`d js tb` fbozcat``z cg |zotb
C vtzpfm bci( ogd tb` ahd iog( v``cgl tbcv(\otfb`d tchh C ~ovv`d ogd ezai bcv foz jzaplbt da|gEphh ag is b`od tb` dapjh`)~acgt`d laod'
S`t |ov C qpctv |ctb bci ogd iaz`= ag` vtzam`
Ae is laad vtoee vpeecf`d ta ehcgl bci fh`ogApt ae tb` fbozcat v`ot ogd hocd bci ~zag`'
Ogd va C vh`| tb`i `u`zs ag`' Jpt ce
J`t|crt tbcv vtzogl`z tb`z` |ov oplbt cg faiiag\ctb Hocpv( |ba iaz` icv`zojh` tbog C(
\bot iaztoh faphd sap ecgd iaz` lad)ojbazz`d1
\z`tfb |bai ga vakapzg`z( ga fctc{`g
Ios bozjaz az oddz`vv( |bai ohh oz` japgdTa bozzs ezai tb`cz bai`v' Ogd tbcv voi` fpzv`
\ov hocd ag i`( ogd hocd js gag` jpt i`'
S`o |ctb tb`v` bogdv ohh lazs C ~ahhpt`Tb` j`d ae bci C vh`|' Vos( oi C uch`1
Oi C gat ptt`zhs pgfh`og( o |z`tfb
Daai`d ta j` jogcvb`d( ogd cg jogcvbi`gtEazla tb` vclbt ae ohh is d`oz`vt ag`v(
Ogd g`u`z tz`od olocg is gotcu` `oztb=
Az `hv` ta |`d is iatb`z ogd vhos is vcz`(
6>
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
31/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
^ahsjpv( |ba j`lot i` ogd p~z`oz`d1
Ce ag` vbaphd vos( tbcv cv tb` bogdc|azm
Ae vai` cgbpiog ~a|`z( |ba faphd jhoi`Bcv kpdli`gt1 Jpt( s` ~pz` ogd o|eph ladv(
Eazjcd( eazjcd tbot C vbaphd v`` tbot dos/
Ios C j` jhatt`d apt ezai hcucgl i`g@z` vpfb o ~holp` v~at v`t ag i` ctv jzogd/
FBAZPV
\` taa( A mcgl( oz` tzapjh`d= jpt tchh tbap
Bovt qp`vtcag`d tb` vpzucuaz( vtchh ba~` ag'
A@DC^PV
Is ba~` cv eocgt( jpt vtchh `gaplb vpzucu`vTa jcd i` jcd` tb` faicgl ae tbcv b`zd'
KAFOVTO
Vp~~av` bci b`z`( |bot |aphdvt tbap h`ozg ae bci1
A@DC^PV
C,hh t`hh tb``( hods= ce bcv toh` olz``v\ctb tbcg`( C vbohh bou` ,vfo~`d fohoicts'
KAFOVTO
Ogd |bot ae v~`fcoh ci~azt dcd C vos1
A@DC^PV
Cg tbs z`~azt ae |bot tb` b`zdviog vocd
Hocpv |ov vhocg js zajj`zv= ga| ce b`Vtchh v~`omv ae zajj`zv( gat o zajj`z( C
Vh`| bci gat= *ag`* |ctb *iogs* foggat vqpoz`'
Jpt ce b` vosv ag` hag`hs |oseoz`z(Tb` hovt hcgm |ogtcgl ta is lpcht cv eazl`d'
KAFOVTO
\`hh( z`vt ovvpz`d( bcv toh` zog tbpv ot eczvt(
Gaz fog b` ga| z`tzoft |bot tb`g b` vocd=
Gat C ohag` jpt ohh apz ta|gveahm b`ozd ct'@,`g vbaphd b` uozs vai`|bot cg bcv vtazs(
B` foggat iom` tb` d`otb ae Hocpv
Cg ogs |cv` kpi~ |ctb tb` azofh`'Eaz Harcov vocd `r~z`vvhs b` |ov daai`d
Ta dc` js is fbchd,v bogd( jpt b`( ~aaz joj`(
B` vb`d ga jhaad( jpt ~`zcvb`d eczvt bciv`he'
Va ipfb eaz dcucgotcag' B`gf`eaztb C\chh haam eaz vclgv g`ctb`z ta zclbt gaz h`et'
6?
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
32/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
A@DC^PV
Tbap z`ovag`vt |`hh' Vtchh C |aphd bou` tb`` v`gd
Ogd e`tfb tb` jagdviog bctb`z' V`` ta ct'
KAFOVTO
Tbot |chh C vtzoclbt|os' Fai`( h`t pv |ctbcg'
C |aphd da gatbcgl tbot is hazd icvhcm`v'
]@r`pgt A@DC^PV ogd KAFOVTOY AD@ CCFBAZPV
"Vtz' ?#
Is hat j` vtchh ta h`odTb` hce` ae cggaf`gf` ogd ehs
Czz`u`z`gf` cg |azd az d``d(
Ta eahha| vtchh tbav` ho|v azdocg`d ag bclb\bav` jcztb~hof` cv tb` jzclbt `tb`z`oh vms
Ga iaztoh jcztb tb`s a|g(
Ahsi~pv tb`cz ~zal`gctaz ohag`;G`,`z vbohh tb`s vhpij`z cg ajhcucag fahd(
Tb` lad cg tb`i cv vtzagl ogd lza|v gat ahd'
"Ogt' ?#
Ae cgvah`gf` cv jz`d
Tb` tszogt= cgvah`gf` ephh jha|g(\ctb `i~ts zcfb`v vpze`ct`d(
Vfoh`v tb` ~z`fc~ctapv b`clbt ogd lzov~v tb` tbzag`'
Tb`g ta~~h`v a,`z ogd hc`v cg zpcg ~zag`=Ga eaatbahd ag tbot dc{{s vt``~'
Jpt A ios B`ou`g tb` tzp` ~otzcat m``~
\ba jpzgv |ctb `iphapv {`oh ta v`zu` tb` Vtot`'Lad cv is b`h~ ogd ba~`( ag bci C |oct'
"Vtz' :#
Jpt tb` ~zapd vcgg`z( az cg |azd az d``d(
Tbot |chh gat Kpvtcf` b``d(Gaz z`u`z`gf` tb` vbzcg`Ae ciol`v dcucg`(
^`zdctcag v`c{` bcv uocg ciolcgcglv(
Ce( pzl`d js lz``d ~zaeog`(B` lzov~v ot chh)lat locg(
Ogd hosv og ci~capv bogd ag bahc`vt tbcglv'
\ba |b`g vpfb d``dv oz` dag`Fog ba~` b`ou`g,v jahtv ta vbpg1
Ce vcg hcm` tbcv ta bagaz fog ov~cz`(
6:
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
33/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
\bs dogf` C vtchh ogd h`od tb` vofz`d fbacz1
"Ogt' :#Ga iaz` C,hh v``m `oztb,v f`gtzoh azofh`(
Az Ojo`,v bohha|`d f`hh(Gaz ta Ahsi~co jzcgl
Is uatcu` aee`zcgl'
Ce j`eaz` ohh Lad,v tzptb j` gat jod` ~hocg'A [`pv( z`u`oh tbs iclbt(
Mcgl( ce tbap,zt goi`d ozclbt
Aigc~at`gt( ohh)v``cgl( ov ae ahd=Eaz Hocpv cv eazlat=
Bcv |`czd( i`g b``d ct gat=
O~ahha cv eazvaam ogd eoctb lza|v fahd'
VF@G@ CCC]@gt`z KAFOVTO'Y
KAFOVTO
Is hazdv( s` haam oio{`d ta v`` sapz qp``g\ctb |z`otbv ogd lcetv ae cgf`gv` cg b`z bogdv'
C bod o icgd ta ucvct tb` bclb vbzcg`v(
Eaz A`dc~pv cv au`z|zaplbt( ohozi`d
\ctb t`zzazv iogceahd' B` |chh gat pv`Bcv ~ovt `r~`zc`gf`( hcm` o iog ae v`gv`(
Ta kpdl` tb` ~z`v`gt g``d( jpt h`gdv og `oz
Ta ogs fzaom`z ce b` oplpzv chh'Vcgf` tb`g is fapgv`hv goplbt ouoch( C tpzg
Ta tb``( apz ~z`v`gt b`h~ cg tci` ae tzapjh`(
O~ahha( Hazd Hsf`og( ogd ta tb``Is ~zos`zv ogd vp~~hcfotcagv b`z` C jzcgl'
Hclbt`g pv( hazd( ogd fh`ogv` pv ezai tbcv fpzv`/
Eaz ga| |` ohh oz` fa|`d hcm` iozcg`zv
\ba v`` tb`cz b`hiviog dpijvtzpfm cg tb` vtazi'
]@gt`z Fazcgtbcog I@VV@GL@Z'Y
I@VV@GL@Z
Is iovt`zv( t`hh i` |b`z` tb` ~ohof` cv
Ae A`dc~pv= az j`tt`z( |b`z`,v tb` mcgl'
FBAZPV
B`z` cv tb` ~ohof` ogd b` jcd`v |ctbcg=
Tbcv cv bcv qp``g tb` iatb`z ae bcv fbchdz`g'
66
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
34/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
I@VV@GL@Z
Ohh bo~~cg`vv ott`gd b`z ogd tb` bapv`(
Jh`vv`d cv b`z bpvjogd ogd b`z iozzcol`)j`d'
KAFOVTO
Is lz``tcglv ta tb``( vtzogl`z= tbs eocz |azdv
D`v`zu` o hcm` z`v~agv`' Jpt t`hh i` |bs
Tbap fai`vt))|bot tbs g``d az |bot tbs g`|v'
I@VV@GL@Z
Laad eaz tbs fagvazt ogd tb` zasoh bapv`'
KAFOVTO
\bot ios ct j`1 \bav` i`vv`gl`z ozt tbap1
I@VV@GL@Z
Tb` Cvtbicog faiiagv bou` z`vahu`d ta iom`
Tbs bpvjogd mcgl))va ,t|ov z`~azt`d tb`z`'
KAFOVTO
\bot/ cv gat ol`d ^ahsjpv vtchh mcgl1
I@VV@GL@Z
Ga( u`zchs= b`,v d`od ogd cg bcv lzou`'
KAFOVTO
\bot/ cv b` d`od( tb` vcz` ae A`dc~pv1
I@VV@GL@Z
Ce C v~`om eohv`hs( ios C dc` isv`he'
KAFOVTO
_pcfm( iocd`g( j`oz tb`v` tcdcglv ta is hazd'S` lad)v`gt azofh`v( |b`z` vtogd s` ga|/
Tbcv cv tb` iog |bai A`dc~pv hagl vbpgg`d(
Cg dz`od ta ~zau` bcv ipzd`z`z= ogd ga|B` dc`v cg gotpz`,v fapzv`( gat js bcv bogd'
]@gt`z A@DC^PV'Y
A@DC^PV
Is |ce`( is qp``g( Kafovto( |bs bovt tbapVpiiag`d i` ezai is ~ohof`1
KAFOVTO
B`oz tbcv iog(
Ogd ov tbap b`oz`vt kpdl` |bot bov j`fai`
Ae ohh tbav` o|`)cgv~czcgl azofh`v'
64
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
35/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
A@DC^PV
\ba cv tbcv iog( ogd |bot bcv g`|v eaz i`1
KAFOVTO
B` fai`v ezai Fazcgtb ogd bcv i`vvol` tbcv;Tbs eotb`z ^ahsjpv botb ~ovv`d o|os'
A@DC^PV
\bot1 h`t i` bou` ct( vtzogl`z( ezai tbs iaptb'
I@VV@GL@Z
Ce C ipvt eczvt iom` ~hocg j`sagd o dapjt
Is i`vvol`( mga| tbot ^ahsjpv cv d`od'
A@DC^PVJs tz`ofb`zs( az js vcfmg`vv ucvct`d1
I@VV@GL@Z
Ag` tapfb |chh v`gd og ahd iog ta bcv z`vt'
A@DC^PV
Va ae vai` iohods b` dc`d( ~aaz iog'
I@VV@GL@Z
S`v( boucgl i`ovpz`d tb` ephh v~og ae s`ozv'
A@DC^PVApt ag ct( hods/ |bs vbaphd ag` z`lozd
Tb` ^stbcog b`oztb az jczdv tbot vfz`oi c, tb` ocz1
Dcd tb`s gat ~acgt ot i` ov daai`d ta vhosIs eotb`z1 jpt b`,v d`od ogd cg bcv lzou`
Ogd b`z` oi C |ba g`,`z pgvb`otb`d o v|azd=
Pgh`vv tb` haglcgl eaz bcv ojv`gt vag
Mchh`d bci ogd va C vh`| bci cg o v`gv`'Jpt( ov tb`s vtogd( tb` azofh`v oz` d`od))
Dpvt( ovb`v( gatbcgl( d`od ov ^ahsjpv'
KAFOVTOVos( dcd gat C eaz`t`hh tbcv hagl ola1
A@DC^PV
Tbap dcdvt; jpt C |ov icvh`d js is e`oz'
KAFOVTO
Tb`g h`t C ga iaz` |`clb p~ag tbs vaph'
A@DC^PV
60
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
36/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Ipvt C gat e`oz is iatb`z,v iozzcol` j`d'
KAFOVTO\bs vbaphd o iaztoh iog( tb` v~azt ae fbogf`(
\ctb ga ovvpz`d eaz`mga|h`dl`( j` oezocd1J`vt hcu` o foz`h`vv hce` ezai bogd ta iaptb'
Tbcv |`dhafm |ctb tbs iatb`z e`oz gat tbap'
Ba| aet ct fbogf`v tbot cg dz`oiv o iogBov |`d bcv iatb`z/ B` |ba h`ovt z`lozdv
Vpfb jzocgvcfm ~bogtovc`v hcu`v iavt ot `ov`'
A@DC^PV
C vbaphd bou` vboz`d cg ephh tbs fagecd`gf`(
\`z` gat is iatb`z hcucgl= vcgf` vb` hcu`vTbaplb bohe fagucgf`d C vtchh ipvt hcu` cg dz`od'
KAFOVTO
Ogd s`t tbs vcz`,v d`otb hclbtv apt dozmg`vv ipfb'
A@DC^PV
Ipfb( jpt is e`oz cv tapfbcgl b`z |ba hcu`v'
I@VV@GL@Z
\ba ios tbcv |aiog j` |bai tbpv sap e`oz1
A@DC^PVI`za~`( vtzogl`z( |ce` ae ^ahsjpv'
I@VV@GL@Z
Ogd |bot ae b`z fog fopv` sap ogs e`oz1
A@DC^PV
O b`ou`g)v`gt azofh` ae dz`od ci~azt'
I@VV@GL@Z
O isvt`zs( az ios o vtzogl`z b`oz ct1
A@DC^PVOs`( ,tcv ga v`fz`t' Harcov agf` eaz`tahd
Tbot C vbaphd iot` |ctb icg` a|g iatb`z( ogd vb`d
\ctb is a|g bogdv tb` jhaad ae is a|g vcz`'B`gf` Fazcgtb |ov eaz iogs o s`oz ta i`
O bai` dcvtogt= ogd C tzau` ojzaod(
Jpt icvv`d tb` v|``t`vt vclbt( is ~oz`gtv, eof`'
I@VV@GL@Z
\ov tbcv tb` e`oz tbot `rch`d tb`` ezai bai`1
65
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
37/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
A@DC^PV
S`o( ogd tb` dz`od ae vhoscgl is a|g vcz`'
I@VV@GL@Z
\bs( vcgf` C foi` ta lcu` tb`` ~h`ovpz`( Mcgl(Bou` C gat zcd tb`` ae tbcv v`fagd e`oz1
A@DC^PV
\`hh( tbap vboht bou` dp` lp`zdag eaz tbs ~ocgv'
I@VV@GL@Z
\`hh( C fage`vv |bot fbc`ehs iod` i` fai`
\ov ba~` ta ~zaect js tbs faicgl bai`'
A@DC^PVGos( C |chh g`,`z la g`oz is ~oz`gtv iaz`'
I@VV@GL@Z
Is vag( ,tcv ~hocg( tbap mga|,vt gat |bot tbap da`vt'
A@DC^PV
Ba| va( ahd iog1 Eaz b`ou`g,v vom` t hh i` ohh'
I@VV@GL@Z
Ce tbcv cv |bs tbap dz`od`vt ta z`tpzg'
A@DC^PVS`o( h`vt tb` lad,v |azd j` ephechh`d cg i`'
I@VV@GL@Z
H`vt tbzaplb tbs ~oz`gtv tbap vbaphdvt j` offpzv`d1
A@DC^PV
Tbcv ogd gag` atb`z cv is fagvtogt dz`od'
I@VV@GL@Z
Davt tbap gat mga| tbs e`ozv oz` jov`h`vv ohh1
A@DC^PVBa| jov`h`vv( ce C oi tb`cz u`zs vag1
I@VV@GL@Z
Vcgf` ^ahsjpv |ov goplbt ta tb`` cg jhaad'
A@DC^PV
\bot vos,vt tbap1 |ov gat ^ahsjpv is vcz`1
I@VV@GL@Z
6
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
38/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Ov ipfb tbs vcz` ov C oi( ogd ga iaz`'
A@DC^PVIs vcz` ga iaz` ta i` tbog ag` |ba cv goplbt1
I@VV@GL@Z
Vcgf` C j`lot tb`` gat( ga iaz` dcd b`'
A@DC^PV
\bot z`ovag bod b` tb`g ta fohh i` vag1
I@VV@GL@Z
Mga| tbot b` taam tb`` ezai is bogdv( o lcet'
A@DC^PVS`t( ce ga fbchd ae bcv( b` hau`d i` |`hh'
I@VV@GL@Z
O fbchdh`vv iog tchh tb`g( b` |ozi`d ta tb``'
A@DC^PV
O eapgdhcgl az o ~pzfbov`d vhou`( tbcv fbchd1
I@VV@GL@Z
C eapgd tb`` cg Fctbo`zag,v |aad`d lh`gv'
A@DC^PV\bot h`d tb`` ta `r~haz` tbav` p~hogd lhod`v1
I@VV@GL@Z
Is jpvcg`vv |ov ta t`gd tb` iapgtocg ehafmv'
A@DC^PV
O uolzogt vb`~b`zd kapzg`scgl eaz bcz`1
I@VV@GL@Z
Tzp`( jpt tbs voucaz cg tbot bapz( is vag'
A@DC^PVIs voucaz1 ezai |bot bozi1 |bot och`d i` tb`g1
I@VV@GL@Z
Tbav` ogmh` kacgtv oz` `ucd`gf` `ga|'
A@DC^PV
Ob( |bs z`icgd i` ae tbot ogfc`gt vaz`1
I@VV@GL@Z
62
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
39/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
C haav`d tb` ~cg tbot zcu`t`d tbs e``t'
A@DC^PVS`v( ezai is fzodh` tbot dz`od jzogd C jaz`'
I@VV@GL@Z
\b`gf` tbap d`zcu,vt tb` goi` tbot vtchh cv tbcg`'
A@DC^PV
\ba dcd ct1 C odkpz` tb``( t`hh i` |ba
Vos( |ov ct eotb`z( iatb`z1
I@VV@GL@Z
C mga| gat'
Tb` iog ezai |bai C bod tb`` ios mga| iaz`'
A@DC^PV
\bot( dcd ogatb`z ecgd i`( gat tbsv`he1
I@VV@GL@Z
Gat C= ogatb`z vb`~b`zd lou` tb`` i`'
A@DC^PV
\ba |ov b`1 \aphd,vt tbap mga| olocg tb` iog1
I@VV@GL@Z
B` ~ovv`d cgd``d eaz ag` ae Hocpv, bapv`'
A@DC^PV
Tb` mcgl |ba zph`d tb` fapgtzs hagl ola1
I@VV@GL@Z
Tb` voi`; b` |ov o b`zdviog ae tb` mcgl'
A@DC^PV
Ogd cv b` hcucgl vtchh eaz i` ta v`` bci1
I@VV@GL@Z
Bcv e`hha|)fapgtzsi`g vbaphd j`vt mga| tbot'
A@DC^PV
Datb ogs jsvtogd`z oiagl sap mga|Tb` b`zd b` v~`omv ae( az js v``cgl bci
Oec`hd az cg tb` fcts1 ogv|`z vtzoclbt/
Tb` bapz botb fai` ta fh`oz tbcv jpvcg`vv p~'
FBAZPV
I`tbcgmv b` i`ogv gag` atb`z tbog tb` bcgd
63
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
40/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
\bai tbap ogag |`zt eocg ta v``= jpt tbot
Apz qp``g Kafovto j`vt ae ohh faphd t`hh'
A@DC^PV
Iodoi( davt mga| tb` iog |` v`gt ta e`tfb1Cv tb` voi` ae |bai tb` vtzogl`z v~`omv1
KAFOVTO
\ba cv tb` iog1 \bot iott`z1 H`t ct j`'
,T|`z` |ovt` ae tbaplbt ta |`clb vpfb cdh` |azdv'
A@DC^PV
Ga( |ctb vpfb lpcdcgl fhp`v C foggat eochTa jzcgl ta hclbt tb` v`fz`t ae is jcztb'
KAFOVTO
Ab( ov tbap foz`vt eaz tbs hce`( lcu` a,`z
Tbcv qp`vt' @gaplb tb` oglpcvb C `gdpz`'
A@DC^PV
J` ae laad fb``z= tbaplb C j` ~zau`d tb` vag
Ae o jagd|aiog( os`( tbzaplb tbz`` d`vf`gtv
Tzc~hs o vhou`( tbs bagaz cv pgviczfb`d'
KAFOVTO
S`t bpiaz i`( C ~zos tb``= da gat tbcv'
A@DC^PV
C foggat= C ipvt ~zaj` tbcv iott`z bai`'
KAFOVTO
,Tcv eaz tbs vom` C oducv` tb`` eaz tb` j`vt'
A@DC^PV
C lza| ci~otc`gt ae tbcv j`vt oducf`'
KAFOVTO
Ob iosvt tbap g`,`z dcvfau`z |ba tbap ozt/
A@DC^PV
La( e`tfb i` b`z` tb` b`zd( ogd h`ou` sag |aiog
Ta lhazs cg b`z ~zcd` ae ogf`vtzs'
KAFOVTO
A |a` cv tb``( ~aaz |z`tfb/ \ctb tbot hovt |azd
C h`ou` tb``( b`gf`eaztb vch`gt `u`ziaz`']@rct KAFOVTOY
4>
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
41/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
FBAZPV
\bs( A`dc~pv( |bs vtpgl |ctb ~ovvcagot` lzc`e
Botb tb` qp``g tbpv d`~ozt`d1 Ipfb C e`ozEzai tbcv d`od fohi |chh jpzvt o vtazi ae |a`v'
A@DC^PV
H`t tb` vtazi jpzvt( is ecr`d z`vahu` vtchh bahdv(
Ta h`ozg is hcg`ol`( j` ct g`,`z va ha|'Ct ios j` vb` |ctb ohh o |aiog,v ~zcd`
Tbcgmv vfazg ae is jov` ~oz`gtol`' Jpt C
\ba zogm isv`he ov Eaztpg`,v eouazct` fbchd(Tb` lcu`z ae laad lcetv( vbohh gat j` vboi`d'
Vb` cv is iatb`z ogd tb` fboglcgl iaagv
Is jz`tbz`g( ogd |ctb tb`i C |or ogd |og`'Tbpv v~zpgl |bs vbaphd C e`oz ta tzof` is jcztb1Gatbcgl fog iom` i` atb`z tbog C oi'
AD@ CCCFBAZPV
"Vtz'#
Ce is vaph ~za~b`tcf `zz gat( ce is |cvdai oplbt ouoch(
Tb``( Fctbo`zag( C vbohh boch(
Ov tb` gpzv` ogd eavt`z)iatb`z ae apz A`dc~pv vbohh lz``t@z` taiazza|,v ephh iaag zcv`v( ogd `roht tb`` ov cv i``t'
Dogf` ogd vagl vbohh bsig tbs ~zocv`v( hau`z ae apz zasoh zof`'
^ba`jpv( ios is |azdv ecgd lzof`/
"Ogt'#Fbchd( |ba joz` tb``( gsi~b az ladd`vv1 vpz` tbs vpz` |ov iaz` tbog
iog(
Bo~hs tb` bchh)zaoi`z ^og'Ae dcd Harcov j`l`t tb``( eaz b` bopgtv tb` p~hogd |ahd=
Az Fshh`g`,v hazd( az Joffbpv( d|`hh`z ag tb` bchhta~v fahd1
Dcd vai` B`hcfagcog Az`od lcu` bci tb``( o g`|)jazg kas1Gsi~bv |ctb |bai b` hau` ta tas1
VF@G@ CUA@DC^PV
@hd`zv( ce C( |ba g`u`z s`t j`eaz`
Bou` i`t tb` iog( ios iom` o lp`vv( i`tbcgmv
4?
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
42/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
C v`` tb` b`zdviog |ba |` hagl bou` vaplbt=
Bcv tci`)|azg ov~`ft iotfb`v |ctb tb` s`ozv
Ae sagd`z ol`d i`vv`gl`z= j`vcd`vC v``i ta z`falgc{` tb` i`g |ba jzcgl bci
Ov v`zuogtv ae is a|g' Jpt sap( ~`zfbogf`(
Boucgl cg ~ovt dosv mga|g az v``g tb` b`zd(Ios j`tt`z js vpz` mga|h`dl` is vpzicv`'
FBAZPV
C z`falgc{` bci= ag` ae Hocpv, bapv`=
O vci~h` bcgd( jpt tzp` ov ogs iog']@gt`z B@ZDVIOG'Y
A@DC^PVFazcgtbcog( vtzogl`z( C oddz`vv tb`` eczvt(
Cv tbcv tb` iog tbap i`og`vt/
I@VV@GL@Z
Tbcv cv b`'
A@DC^PV
Ogd ga| ahd iog( haam p~ ogd ogv|`z ohh
C ovm tb``' \ovt tbap agf` ae Hocpv, bapv`1
B@ZDVIOG
C |ov( o tbzohh( gat ~pzfbov`d jpt bai`)jz`d'
A@DC^PV
\bot |ov tbs jpvcg`vv1 ba| |ovt tbap `i~has`d1
B@ZDVIOG
Tb` j`vt ~ozt ae is hce` C t`gd`d vb``~'
A@DC^PV
\bot |`z` tb` ~ovtpz`v tbap dcdvt iavt ez`qp`gt1
B@ZDVIOG
Fctbo`zag ogd tb` g`clbjazcgl oh~v'
A@DC^PV
Tb`g tb`z`Tbap ipvt bou` mga|g sag iog( ot h`ovt js eoi`1
B@ZDVIOG
Sag iog1 cg |bot |os1 |bot iog davt tbap i`og1
A@DC^PV
4:
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
43/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Tb` iog b`z`( boucgl i`t bci cg ~ovt tci`v'''
B@ZDVIOGAee)bogd C foggat fohh bci |`hh ta icgd'
I@VV@GL@Z
Ga |agd`z( iovt`z' Jpt C |chh z`ucu`Bcv jhpgt`d i`iazc`v' Vpz` b` fog z`fohh
\bot tci` tal`tb`z jatb |` dzau` apz ehafmv(
B` t|a( C ag`( ag tb` Fctbo`zag zogl`(Eaz tbz`` hagl vpii`zv= C bcv iot` ezai v~zcgl
Tchh zav` Ozftpzpv= tb`g cg |cgt`z tci`
C h`d icg` bai`( b` bcv ta Hocpv, eahdv'
Dcd tb`v` tbcglv bo~~`g ov C vos( az ga1
B@ZDVIOG
,Tcv hagl ola( jpt ohh tbap vos,vt cv tzp`'
I@VV@GL@Z
\`hh( tbap iovt tb`g z`i`ij`z lcucgl i`
O fbchd ta z`oz ov is a|g eavt`z)vag1
B@ZDVIOG
\bs davt tbap ovm tbcv qp`vtcag1 \bot ae tbot1
I@VV@GL@ZEzc`gd( b` tbot vtogdv j`eaz` tb`` |ov tbot fbchd'
B@ZDVIOG
O ~holp` p~ag tb``/ Bahd tbs |ogtag taglp`/
A@DC^PV
Vaeths( ahd iog( z`jpm` bci gat= tbs |azdv
Oz` iaz` d`v`zucgl fbovtcv`i`gt tbog bcv'
B@ZDVIOG
A j`vt ae iovt`zv( |bot cv is aee`gv`1
A@DC^PV
Gat ogv|`zcgl |bot b` ovmv ojapt tb` fbchd'
B@ZDVIOG
B` v~`omv ot zogdai( jojjh`v hcm` o eaah'
A@DC^PV
Ce tbap hofm,vt lzof` ta v~`om( C,hh haav` tbs taglp`'
B@ZDVIOG
46
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
44/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Eaz i`zfs,v vom` ojpv` gat og ahd iog'
A@DC^PVOzz`vt tb` uchhocg( v`c{` ogd ~cgcag bci/
B@ZDVIOG
Ohofm( ohofm/\bot bou` C dag`1 |bot |aphdvt tbap epztb`z h`ozg1
A@DC^PV
Dcdvt lcu` tbcv iog tb` fbchd ae |bai b` ovmv1
B@ZDVIOG
C dcd= ogd |aphd tbot C bod dc`d tbot dos/
A@DC^PV
Ogd dc` tbap vboht pgh`vv tbap t`hh tb` tzptb'
B@ZDVIOG
Jpt( ce C t`hh ct( C oi dapjhs havt'
A@DC^PV
Tb` mgou` i`tbcgmv |chh vtchh ~z`uozcfot`'
B@ZDVIOG
Gos( C fage`vv`d C lou` ct hagl ola'
A@DC^PV
\b`gf` foi` ct1 |ov ct tbcg`( az lcu`g ta tb``1
B@ZDVIOG
C bod ct ezai ogatb`z( ,t|ov gat icg`'
A@DC^PV
Ezai |bai ae tb`v` apz ta|gvi`g( ogd |bot bapv`1
B@ZDVIOG
Eazj`oz eaz Lad,v vom`( iovt`z( ovm ga iaz`'
A@DC^PV
Ce C ipvt qp`vtcag tb`` olocg( tbap,zt havt'
B@ZDVIOG
\`hh tb`g))ct |ov o fbchd ae Hocpv, bapv`'
A@DC^PV
Vhou`)jazg az ag` ae Hocpv, a|g zof`1
44
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
45/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
B@ZDVIOG
Ob i`/
C vtogd p~ag tb` ~`zchapv `dl` ae v~``fb'
A@DC^PV
Ogd C ae b`ozcgl( jpt C vtchh ipvt b`oz'
B@ZDVIOG
Mga| tb`g tb` fbchd |ov js z`~pt` bcv a|g(
Jpt vb` |ctbcg( tbs fagvazt j`vt faphd t`hh'
A@DC^PV
\bot/ vb`( vb` lou` ct tb``1
B@ZDVIOG,Tcv va( is mcgl'
A@DC^PV
\ctb |bot cgt`gt1
B@ZDVIOG
Ta iom` o|os |ctb ct'
A@DC^PV
\bot( vb` ctv iatb`z'
B@ZDVIOGE`ozcgl o dz`od |`czd'
A@DC^PV
\bot |`czd1
B@ZDVIOG
,T|ov tahd tbot b` vbaphd vhos bcv vcz`'
A@DC^PV
\bot dcdvt tbap lcu` ct tb`g ta tbcv ahd iog1
B@ZDVIOGTbzaplb ~cts( iovt`z( eaz tb` joj`' C tbaplbt
B`,d tom` ct ta tb` fapgtzs |b`gf` b` foi`=
Jpt b` ~z`v`zu`d ct eaz tb` |azvt ae |a`v'
Eaz ce tbap ozt cg vaatb |bot tbcv iog voctb(Lad ~cts tb``/ tbap |ovt ta icv`zs jazg'
A@DC^PV
Ob i`/ ob i`/ ohh jzaplbt ta ~ovv( ohh tzp`/
A hclbt( ios C j`bahd tb`` g`u`ziaz`/
40
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
46/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
C vtogd o |z`tfb( cg jcztb( cg |`dhafm fpzv`d(
O ~ozzcfcd`( cgf`vtpapvhs( tzc~hs fpzv`d/
]@rct A@DC^PVY
AD@ CUFBAZPV
"Vtz' ?#Zof`v ae iaztoh iog
\bav` hce` cv jpt o v~og(
C fapgt s` jpt tb` vboda| ae o vbod`/
Eaz b` |ba iavt datb mga|Ae jhcvv( botb jpt tb` vba|=
O iai`gt( ogd tb` ucvcagv ~oh` ogd eod`'
Tbs eohh( A A`dc~pv( tbs ~ct`apv eohh\ozgv i` gag` jazg ae |ai`g jh`vt ta fohh'
"Ogt' ?#
Eaz b` ae iozmvi`g j`vt(
A [`pv( aptvbat tb` z`vt(Ogd |ag tb` ~zc{` vp~z`i` ae |`ohtb ogd ~a|`z'
Js bci tb` uphtpz` iocd
\ov qp`hh`d( b`z |ctfb`zs hocd=
B` zav` apz voucaz ogd tb` hogd,v vtzagl ta|`z'\` boch`d tb`` mcgl ogd ezai tbot dos odaz`d
Ae iclbts Tb`j`v tb` pgcu`zvoh hazd'
"Vtz' :#
A b`ous bogd ae eot`/\ba ga| iaz` d`vahot`(
\bav` toh` iaz` vod tbog tbcg`( |bav` hat iaz` dcz`1
A A`dc~pv( dcvfza|g`d b`od(Tbs fzodh` |ov tbs iozzcol` j`d=
Ag` bozjazol` vpeecf`d eaz vag ogd vcz`'
Ba| faphd tb` vach tbs eotb`z `oz`d va hagl@gdpz` ta j`oz cg vch`gf` vpfb o |zagl1
"Ogt' :#Ohh)v``cgl Tci` botb foplbt
Lpcht( ogd ta kpvtcf` jzaplbt
Tb` vag ogd vcz` faiicglh`d cg ag` j`d'A fbchd ae Hocpv, chh)vtozz`d zof`
\aphd C bod g`,`z j`b`hd tbs eof`=
C zocv` eaz tb`` o dczl` ov a,`z tb` d`od'
45
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
47/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
S`t( vaatb ta vos( tbzaplb tb`` C dz`| g`| jz`otb(
Ogd ga| tbzaplb tb`` C e``h o v`fagd d`otb'
@RADPV]@gt`z V@FAGD I@VV@GL@Z'Y
V@FAGD I@VV@GL@Z
Iavt lzou` ogd z`u`z`gd v`gotazv ae Tb`j`v(
\bot D``dv s` vaag ipvt b`oz( |bot vclbtv j`bahd
Ba| |chh s` iapzg( ce( tzp`)jazg ~otzcatv(S` z`u`z`gf` vtchh tb` zof` ae Hojdofpv/
Gat Cvt`z gaz ohh ^bovcv, ehaad( C |``g(Faphd |ovb o|os tb` jhaad)vtocgv ezai tbcv bapv`(Tb` chhv ct vbzapdv az vaag |chh jzcgl ta hclbt(
Chhv |zaplbt ae iohcf`( gat pg|cttcglhs'
Tb` |azvt ta j`oz oz` v`he)cgehcft`d |apgdv'
FBAZPV
Lzc`uapv `gaplb eaz ohh apz t`ozv ogd lzaogv
Apz ~ovt fohoictc`v= |bot fogvt tbap odd1
V@FAGD I@VV@GL@Z
Is toh` cv qpcfmhs tahd ogd qpcfmhs b`ozd'Apz vau`z`clg hods qp``g Kafovto,v d`od'
FBAZPV
Ohov( ~aaz qp``g/ ba| foi` vb` js b`z d`otb1
V@FAGD I@VV@GL@Z
Js b`z a|g bogd' Ogd ohh tb` bazzaz ae ct(
Gat boucgl v``g( s`t foggat fai~z`b`gd'
Gotbh`vv( ov eoz ov is ~aaz i`iazs v`zu`v(C |chh z`hot` tb` pgbo~~s hods,v |a`'
\b`g cg b`z ez`g{s vb` bod ~ovv`d cgvcd`
Tb` u`vtcjph`( vb` bpzzc`d vtzoclbt ta |cgTb` jzcdoh)fboij`z( fhptfbcgl ot b`z bocz
\ctb jatb b`z bogdv( ogd( agf` |ctbcg tb` zaai(
Vb` vbpt tb` daazv j`bcgd b`z |ctb o fzovb'*Hocpv(* vb` fzc`d( ogd fohh`d b`z bpvjogd d`od
Hagl( hagl ola= b`z tbaplbt |ov ae tbot fbchd
Js bci j`lat( tb` vag js |bai tb` vcz`
\ov ipzd`z`d ogd tb` iatb`z h`et ta jz``d\ctb b`z a|g v``d( o iagvtzapv ~zal`gs'
4
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
48/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Tb`g vb` j`|och`d tb` iozzcol` j`d |b`z`ag
^aaz |z`tfb( vb` bod fagf`cu`d o dapjh` jzaad(
Bpvjogd js bpvjogd( fbchdz`g js b`z fbchd'\bot bo~~`g`d oet`z tbot C foggat t`hh(
Gaz ba| tb` `gd j`e`hh( eaz |ctb o vbzc`m
Jpzvt ag pv A`dc~pv= ohh `s`v |`z` ecr`dAg A`dc~pv( ov p~ ogd da|g b` vtzad`(
Gaz faphd |` iozm b`z olags ta tb` `gd'
Eaz vtohmcgl ta ogd eza *O v|azd/* b` fzc`d(*\b`z` cv tb` |ce`( ga |ce`( tb` t``icgl |aij
Tbot jaz` o dapjh` bozu`vt( i` ogd icg`1*
Ogd cg bcv ez`g{s vai` vp~`zgoh ~a|`z"Ga iaztoh( vpz`hs( gag` ae pv |ba |otfb`d bci#
Lpcd`d bcv eaatvt`~v= |ctb o t`zzcjh` vbzc`m(Ov tbaplb ag` j`fmag`d bci( b` fzovb`d olocgvt
Tb` eahdcgl daazv( ogd ezai tb`cz vto~h`v eazf`dTb` |z`gfb`d jahtv ogd bpzh`d bciv`he |ctbcg'
Tb`g |` j`b`hd tb` |aiog boglcgl tb`z`(
O zpggcgl gaav` `gt|cg`d ojapt b`z g`fm'Jpt |b`g b` vo| b`z( |ctb o iodd`g`d zaoz
B` haav`d tb` fazd= ogd |b`g b`z |z`tfb`d faz~v`
Hos vtz`tfb`d ag `oztb( |bot eahha|`d))A ,t|ov dz`od/B` taz` tb` lahd`g jzaafb`v tbot p~b`hd
B`z qp``ghs zaj`v( p~zocv`d tb`i bclb ogd viat`
Ephh ag bcv `s`)johhv( ptt`zcgl |azdv hcm` tb`v`;*Ga iaz` vbohh s` j`bahd vpfb vclbtv ae |a`(D``dv C bou` vpee`z`d ogd isv`he bou` |zaplbt=
B`gf`eaz|ozd qp`gfb`d cg dozmg`vv vbohh s` v``
Tbav` s` vbaphd g`,`z bou` v``g= ga| jhcgd ta tbav`\bai( |b`g C vo|( C uocghs s`ozg`d ta mga|'*
Vpfb |ov tb` jpzd`g ae bcv iaog( |b`z`ta(
Gat agf` jpt aet( b` vtzpfm |ctb bcv bogd p~hcetBcv `s`v( ogd ot `ofb vtzam` tb` `gvoglpcg`d azjv
J`d`|`d bcv j`ozd( gat aa{cgl dza~ js dza~(
Jpt ag` jhofm lazs da|g~apz( tbcfm ov boch'
Vpfb `uchv( cvvpcgl ezai tb` dapjh` vapzf`(Bou` |b`hi`d tb`i jatb( fageapgdcgl iog ogd |ce`'
Tchh ga| tb` vtazc`d eaztpg` ae tbcv bapv`
\ov eaztpgot` cgd``d= jpt ezai tbcv dos\a`( hoi`gtotcag( zpcg( d`otb( dcvlzof`(
Ohh chhv tbot fog j` goi`d( ohh( ohh oz` tb`czv'
FBAZPV
Jpt botb b` vtchh ga z`v~ct` ezai bcv ~ocg1
42
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
49/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
V@FAGD I@VV@GL@Z
B` fzc`v( *Pgjoz tb` daazv ogd h`t ohh Tb`j`v
J`bahd tb` vhos`z ae bcv vcz`( bcv iatb`z,v))*Tbot vboi`eph |azd is hc~v ios gat z`~`ot'
B` ua|v ta ehs v`he)jogcvb`d ezai tb` hogd(
Gaz vtos ta jzcgl p~ag bcv bapv` tb` fpzv`Bciv`he bod ptt`z`d= jpt b` bov ga vtz`gltb
Gaz ag` ta lpcd` bci( ogd bcv taztpz`,v iaz`
Tbog iog fog vpee`z( ov sapzv`hu`v |chh v``'Eaz ha( tb` ~ohof` ~aztohv oz` pgjozz`d(
Ogd vaag s` vbohh j`bahd o vclbt va vod
Tbot b` |ba ipvt ojbazz`d |aphd ~cts ct']@gt`z A@DC^PV jhcgd`d'Y
FBAZPV
\a`eph vclbt/ iaz` |a`eph gag`
Tb`v` vod `s`v bou` haam`d p~ag'
\b`gf` tbcv iodg`vv1 Gag` fog t`hh\ba dcd fovt ag tb`` bcv v~`hh(
~za|hcgl ohh tbs hce` ozapgd(
H`o~cgl |ctb o d`iag japgd'Bo~h`vv |z`tfb/ ba| fog C jzaam
Ag tbs icv`zs ta haam1
Tbaplb ta lo{` ag tb`` C s`ozg(
Ipfb ta qp`vtcag( ipfb ta h`ozg(Bazzaz)vtzpfm o|os C tpzg'
A@DC^PV
Ob i`/ ob |a` cv i`/
Ob |bctb`z oi C jazg`/Ba| hcm` o lbavt eazhazg
Is uacf` ehctv ezai i` ag tb` ocz/
Ag( ag tb` d`iag laodv' Tb` `gd( ob |b`z`1
FBAZPV
Og `gd taa dz`od ta t`hh( taa dozm ta v``'
A@DC^PV
"Vtz' ?#
Dozm( dozm/ Tb` bazzaz ae dozmg`vv( hcm` o vbzapd(
\zo~v i` ogd j`ozv i` ag tbzaplb icvt ogd fhapd'Ob i`( ob i`/ \bot v~oviv otb|ozt i` vbaat(
\bot ~oglv ae olagc{cgl i`iazs1
FBAZPV
Ga iozu`h ce cg vpfb o ~hclbt tbap e``h,vt
43
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
50/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Tb` dapjh` |`clbt ae ~ovt ogd ~z`v`gt |a`v'
A@DC^PV"Ogt' ?#
Ob ezc`gd( vtchh hasoh( fagvtogt vtchh ogd mcgd(Tbap foz`vt eaz tb` jhcgd'
C mga| tb`` g`oz( ogd tbaplb j`z`et ae `s`v(
Tbs uacf` C z`falgc{`'
FBAZPV
A da`z ae dz`od d``dv( ba| faphdvt tbap ioz
Tbs ucvcag tbpv1 \bot d`iag laod`d tb``1
A@DC^PV
"Vtz' :#
O~ahha( ezc`gd( O~ahha( b` ct |ovTbot jzaplbt tb`v` chhv ta ~ovv=
Jpt tb` zclbt bogd tbot d`oht tb` jha|
\ov icg`( gag` atb`z' Ba|(Ba|( faphd C hagl`z v`` |b`g vclbt
Jzaplbt ga d`hclbt1
FBAZPV
Ohov/ ,tcv ov tbap vos`vt'
A@DC^PVVos( ezc`gdv( fog ogs haam az uacf`Az tapfb ae hau` b`gf`eaztb is b`ozt z`kacf`1
Bovt`( ezc`gdv( ga eagd d`hos(
Tom` tb` t|cf` fpzv`d o|osEoz ezai ohh m`g(
Tb` iog ojbazz`d ae ladv( offpzv`d ae i`g'
FBAZPV
A tbs d`v~ocz |`hh vpctv tbs d`v~`zot` fov`'
\aphd C bod g`u`z haam`d p~ag tbs eof`/
A@DC^PV
"Ogt' :#
Is fpzv` ag bci |ba`,`z pgzcu`d
Tb` |oce,v e`hh e`tt`zv ogd is hce` z`ucu`d/B` i`ogt i` |`hh( s`t bod b` h`et i` tb`z`(
B` bod vou`d is ezc`gdv ogd i` o |azhd ae foz`'
FBAZPV
C taa bod |cvb`d ct va'
0>
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
51/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
A@DC^PV
Tb`g bod C g`u`z fai` ta vb`d
Is eotb`z,v jhaad gaz fhcij`d is iatb`z,v j`d=Tb` iagvtzapv aeev~zcgl ae o |aij d`ech`d(
Fa)iot` ae bci |ba l`gd`z`d i`( ogd fbchd'
\ov `u`z iog j`eaz` oeehcft`d tbpv(Hcm` A`dc~pv'
FBAZPV
C foggat vos tbot tbap bovt fapgv`h`d |`hh(
Eaz tbap |`zt j`tt`z d`od tbog hcucgl jhcgd'
A@DC^PV
\bot,v dag` |ov |`hh dag`' Tbap fogvt g`u`z vbom`Is eczi j`hc`e' O tzpf` ta ozlpi`gt'
Eaz( bod C vclbt( C mga| gat |ctb |bot `s`v
C faphd bou` i`t is eotb`z cg tb` vbod`v(Az is ~aaz iatb`z( vcgf` olocgvt tb` t|ocg
C vcgg`d( o vcg ga lohha|v faphd otag`'
Os`( jpt( s` vos( tb` vclbt ae fbchdz`g kasvO ~oz`gt,v `s`v' \bot( jazg ov icg` |`z` jazg1
Ga( vpfb o vclbt faphd g`u`z jzcgl i` kas=
Gaz tbcv eocz fcts |ctb ctv jotth`i`gtv(Ctv t`i~h`v ogd tb` vtotp`v ae ctv ladv(
Vclbtv ezai |bcfb C( ga| |z`tfb`dvt ae ohh(Agf` zogm`d tb` eaz`iavt Tb`jog cg ohh Tb`j`v(
Js is a|g v`gt`gf` oi fpt aee( fagd`ig`dJs is a|g ~zafhoiotcag ,locgvt tb` |z`tfb(
Tb` icvfz`ogt js b`ou`g ctv`he d`fhoz`d
Pgfh`og))ogd ae tb` zof` ae Hocpv'Tbpv jzogd`d ov o e`hag js isv`he(
Ba| bod C doz`d ta haam sap cg tb` eof`1
Gos( bod C mga|g o |os ta fbam` tb` v~zcglvAe b`ozcgl( C bod g`u`z vbzpgm ta iom`
O dpgl`ag ae tbcv icv`zojh` ezoi`(
Fpt aee ezai vclbt ogd b`ozcgl= eaz ,tcv jhcvv
ta jcd` cg z`lcagv vazza| foggat z`ofb'\bs dcdvt tbap bozjaz i`( Fctbo`zag( |bs
Dcdvt tbap gat tom` ogd vhos i`1 Tb`g C g`u`z
Bod vba|g ta i`g tb` v`fz`t ae is jcztb'A ^ahsjpv( A Fazcgtb( A is bai`(
Bai` ae is ogf`vtazv "va |ovt tbap fohh`d#
Ba| eocz o gpzvhcgl tb`g C v``i`d( ba| eaphTb` fogm`z tbot hos e`vt`zcgl cg tb` jpd/
Ga| cv tb` jhclbt z`u`oh`d ae zaat ogd ezpct'
0?
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
52/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
S` tzc~h` bclb)zaodv( ogd tbap bcdd`g lh`g(
Fa~~cf`( ogd ~ovv |b`z` i``t tb` tbz``)jzogfb`d |osv(
S` dzogm is jhaad( tb` hce`)jhaad tb`v` bogdv v~cht(Is eotb`z,v= da s` fohh ta icgd ~`zfbogf`
Tbav` d``dv ae icg` s` |ctg`vv`d ogd tb` |azm
C |zaplbt tb`z`oet`z |b`g C foi` ta Tb`j`v1A eotoh |`dhafm( tbap dcdvt lcu` i` jcztb(
Ogd( boucgl jazg` i`( va|`d olocg is v``d(
Icglhcgl tb` jhaad ae eotb`zv( jzatb`zv( fbchdz`g(Jzcd`v( |cu`v ogd iatb`zv( og cgf`vtpapv jzaad(
Ohh bazzazv tbot oz` |zaplbt j`g`otb tb` vpg(
Bazzazv va eaph ta goi` tb`i |`z` pgi``t'A( C odkpz` sap( bcd` i` ogs|b`z`
Eoz ezai tbcv hogd( az vhos i` vtzoclbt( az fovt i`Da|g ta tb` d`~tbv ae af`og apt ae vclbt'
Fai` bctb`z( d`clg ta tapfb og ojk`ft |z`tfb=Dzo| g`oz ogd e`oz gat= C isv`he ipvt j`oz
Tb` haod ae lpcht tbot gag` jpt C fog vboz`'
]@gt`z FZ@AG'Y
FZ@AG
Ha( b`z` cv Fz`ag( tb` ag` iog ta lzogt
Tbs ~zos`z js oftcag az oducf`( eaz b`
Cv h`et tb` Vtot`,v vah` lpozdcog cg tbs vt`od'
A@DC^PV
Ob i`/ |bot |azdv ta offavt bci fog C ecgd1\bot fopv` bov b` ta tzpvt i`1 Cg tb` ~ovt
C bou` j`` ~zau`d bcv zogfazapv `g`is'
FZ@AG
Gat cg d`zcvcag( A`dc~pv( C fai`Gaz ta p~jzocd tb`` |ctb tbs ~ovt icvd``dv'
"Ta JSVTOGD@ZV#
Jpt vboi` p~ag sap/ ce s` e``h ga v`gv`
Ae bpiog d`f`gfc`v( ot h`ovt z`u`z`
Tb` Vpg |bav` hclbt j`bahdv ogd gpztpz`v ohh'H`ou` gat tbpv gom`dhs eaz ohh ta lo{` ot
O bazzaz g`ctb`z `oztb gaz zocg ezai b`ou`gGaz hclbt |chh vpee`z' H`od bci vtzoclbt |ctbcg(
Eaz ct cv v``ihs tbot o mcgviog,v |a`v
J` b`ozd js mcg ogd v``g js mcg ohag`'
A@DC^PV
A hcvt`g( vcgf` tbs ~z`v`gf` fai`v ta i`
0:
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
53/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
O vbafm ae lhod vpz~zcv`))va gajh` tbap(
Ogd C va uch`))A lzogt i` ag` viohh jaag'
C ovm ct gat ag is j`bohe( jpt tbcg`'
FZ@AG
Ogd |bot tb` eouaz tbap |aphdvt fzou` ae i`1
A@DC^PV
Eaztb ezai tbs jazd`zv tbzpvt i` |ctb ohh v~``d=
V`t i` |ctbcg vai` uovts d`v`zt |b`z`Ga iaztoh uacf` vbohh lz``t i` ogs iaz`'
FZ@AG
Tbcv bod C dag` ohz`ods( jpt C d``i`d
Ct eczvt j`baau`d i` ta fagvpht tb` lad'
A@DC^PV
Bcv |chh |ov v`t eaztb ephhs))ta d`vtzasTb` ~ozzcfcd`( tb` vfapgdz`h= ogd C oi b`'
FZ@AG
S`o( va b` v~om`( jpt cg apz ~z`v`gt ~hclbt
,T|`z` j`tt`z ta fagvpht tb` lad og`|'
A@DC^PV
Doz` s` cgqpcz` fagf`zgcgl vpfb o |z`tfb1
FZ@AG
S`o( eaz tbsv`he |aphdvt fz`dct ga| bcv |azd'
A@DC^PV
Os`( ogd ag tb`` cg ohh bpichcts
C hos tbcv fbozl`; h`t b`z |ba hc`v |ctbcg
Z`f`cu` vpfb jpzcoh ov tbap vboht azdocg=Vpfb zct`v ,tcv tbcg`( ov jzatb`z( ta ~`zeazi'
Jpt eaz isv`he( A g`u`z h`t is Tb`j`v(
Tb` fcts ae is vcz`v( j` daai`d ta j`oz
Tb` jpzd`g ae is ~z`v`gf` |bch` C hcu`'Ga( h`t i` j` o d|`hh`z ag tb` bchhv(
Ag sagd`z iapgt Fctbo`zag( eoi`d ov icg`(Is taij ~z`d`vtcg`d eaz i` js is vcz`
Ogd iatb`z( |bch` tb`s hcu`d( tbot C ios dc`
Vhocg ov tb`s vaplbt ta vhos i`( |b`g ohcu`'Tbcv ipfb C mga| ephh vpz`hs( gaz dcv`ov`
Vbohh `gd is dosv( gaz ogs faiiag fbogf`=
Eaz C bod g`,`z j``g vgotfb`d ezai d`otb( pgh`vv
06
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
54/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
C |ov ~z`d`vtcg`d ta vai` o|eph daai'
Va j` ct' C z`fm gat ba| Eot` d`ohv |ctb i`
Jpt is pgbo~~s fbchdz`g))eaz is vagvJ` gat fagf`zg`d( A Fz`ag( tb`s oz` i`g(
Ogd eaz tb`iv`hu`v( |b`z`,`z tb`s j`( fog e`gd'
Jpt eaz is doplbt`zv t|ocg( ~aaz cggaf`gt iocdv(\ba `u`z vot j`vcd` i` ot tb` jaozd
Vbozcgl is ucogdv( dzcgmcgl ae is fp~(
Eaz tb`i( C ~zos tb``( foz`( ogd( ce tbap |chhvt(A iclbt C e``h tb`cz tapfb ogd iom` is iaog'
B`oz i`( A ~zcgf`( is gajh`)b`ozt`d ~zcgf`/
Faphd C jpt jhcgdhs tapfb tb`i |ctb is bogdvC,d tbcgm tb`s vtchh |`z` icg`( ov |b`g C vo|'
]OGTCLAG@ ogd CVI@G@ oz` h`d cg'Y\bot vos C1 fog ct j` is ~z`tts ag`v
\bav` vajv C b`oz1 Bov Fz`ag ~ctc`d i`Ogd v`gt i` is t|a dozhcglv1 Fog tbcv j`1
FZ@AG
,Tcv tzp`= ,t|ov C ~zafpz`d tb`` tbcv d`hclbt(
Mga|cgl tb` kas tb`s |`z` ta tb`` ae ahd'
A@DC^PV
Lad v~``d tb``/ ogd ov i``d eaz jzcglcgl tb`i
Ios ^zaucd`gf` d`oh |ctb tb`` mcgdhc`zTbog ct bov d`oht |ctb i`/ A fbchdz`g icg`(
\b`z` oz` s`1 H`t i` fhov~ sap |ctb tb`v` bogdv(O jzatb`z,v bogdv( o eotb`z,v= bogdv tbot iod`
Hofm)hpvt`z vafm`tv ae bcv agf` jzclbt `s`v=
Bogdv ae o iog |ba jhcgdhs( z`fmh`vvhs(J`foi` sapz vcz` js b`z ezai |bai b` v~zogl'
Tbaplb C foggat j`bahd sap( C ipvt |``~
Cg tbcgmcgl ae tb` `uch dosv ta fai`(Tb` vhclbtv ogd |zaglv tbot i`g |chh ~pt p~ag sap'
\b`z`,`z s` la ta e`ovt az e`vtcuoh(
Ga i`zzsiomcgl |chh ct ~zau` eaz sap(
Jpt aet ojovb`d cg t`ozv s` |chh z`tpzg'Ogd |b`g s` fai` ta iozzcol`ojh` s`ozv(
\b`z`,v tb` jahd |aa`zv |ba |chh k`a~ozdc{`
Ta tom` pgta bciv`he vpfb dcvz`~pt`Ov ta is fbchdz`g,v fbchdz`g vtchh ipvt fhcgl(
Eaz |bot ae cgeois cv hofmcgl b`z`1
*Tb`cz eotb`z vh`| bcv eotb`z( va|`d tb` v``d\b`z` b` bciv`he |ov l`gd`z`d( ogd j`lot
Tb`v` iocd`gv ot tb` vapzf` |b`z`ezai b` v~zogl'*
04
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
55/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Vpfb oz` tb` lcj`v tbot i`g |chh fovt ot sap'
\ba tb`g |chh |`d sap1 Gag`( C |``g( jpt s`
Ipvt ~cg`( ~aaz iocdv( cg vcglh` jozz`gg`vv'A ^zcgf`( I`ga`f`pv, vag( ta tb``( C tpzg(
\ctb tb` ct z`vtv ta eotb`z tb`i( eaz |`
Tb`cz gotpzoh ~oz`gtv( jatb ae pv( oz` havt'A h`ou` tb`i gat ta |ogd`z ~aaz( pg|`d(
Tbs mcg( gaz h`t tb`i vboz` is ha| `vtot`'
A ~cts tb`i va sapgl( ogd jpt eaz tb``Ohh d`vtctpt`' Tbs bogd p~ag ct( ^zcgf`'
Ta sap( is fbchdz`g C bod ipfb ta vos(
\`z` s` jpt zc~` ta b`oz' H`t tbcv vpeecf`;^zos s` ios ecgd vai` bai` ogd hcu` fagt`gt(
Ogd ios sapz hat ~zau` bo~~c`z tbog sapz vcz`,v'
FZ@AG
Tbap bovt bod `gaplb ae |``~cgl= ~ovv |ctbcg'
A@DC^PV
C ipvt aj`s(Tbaplb ,tcv lzc`uapv'
FZ@AG
\``~ gat( `u`zstbcgl ipvt bou` ctv dos'
A@DC^PV\`hh C la( jpt ag fagdctcagv'
FZ@AG
\bot tbs t`ziv eaz lacgl( vos'
A@DC^PV
V`gd i` ezai tb` hogd og `rch`'
FZ@AG
Ovm tbcv ae tb` ladv( gat i`'
A@DC^PVJpt C oi tb` ladv, ojbazz`gf`'
FZ@AG
Tb`g tb`s vaag |chh lzogt tbs ~h`o'
A@DC^PV
H`od i` b`gf`( tb`g( C oi |chhcgl'
FZ@AG
00
-
8/9/2019 oedipus naim and ruby
56/56
A@DC^PV Z@R T@RT"J`cgl pv`d cg^PGKOJ PGCU@ZVCTS HOBAZ@ ^OMCVTOGeaz Z`e`z`gf`v#
@dct`d js; GOCI TOBCZ JOCL"I' O' ^AH' VFC' ( I'VF' VAFCAHALS % I' O' @GL ^OZT C#
% ZPJS TOJPVPI "I' O' @GLHCVB ^OZT C # F`hh& >645)55>6
Fai`( jpt h`t tbs fbchdz`g la'
A@DC^PVZaj i` gat ae tb`v` is fb