Download - CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHI · 135ay CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHI MINUTES OF 35th Meeting of Ayurved Committee held on 24th February, 2006 at New

135ay

CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINENEW DELHI

MINUTES OF 35th Meeting of Ayurved Committeeheld on 24th February, 2006 at New Delhi

PRESENT

1. Vaidya Devendra Kumar Triguna Chairman2. Vaidya Shriram Sharma Ex-officio Member3. Vaidya SK Mishra Member4. Vaidya SK Sharma Member5. Vaidya GL Chanana Member6. Dr. Jaya Prakash Narayan Member7. Vaidya Ved Prakash Tyagi Member8. Dr. Marri Vaman Reddy Member9. Dr. Sivanandam Member10. Dr. Gajendra Bharali Member11. Dr. Deovrat Narayan Singh Member12. Dr. Indra Mohan Jha Member13. Dr. Om Prakash Vashisth Member14. Dr. KC Sharma Member15. Dr. Bimla Chaudhary Member16. Dr. Ashok Kumar Sharma Member17. Dr. K Chandershekara Ballal Member18. Dr. Ramanathan Devraj Iyer Member19. Dr. Ranvir Singh Parihar Member20. Dr. Pramod Kumar Jain Member21. Dr. Rajesh Shukla Member22. Dr. Satish Dutt Garg Member23. Dr. Gyan Kumar Ahuja Member24. Vaidya Shah Kisan Vithaldas Member25. Vaidya Ramesh Krishan Yadav Member26. Dr. NV Salgarkar Member27. Dr. BK Jaya Singh Member28. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma Member29. Dr. Suresh Chander Gupta Member30. Dr. Jagjeet Singh Member31. Dr. Mukesh Walia Member32. Vaidya SN Parchure Member33. Dr. T Girish Krishnan Member34. Vaidya SP Bhattacharya Member35. Prof. Kulwant Singh Member

235ay

36. Vaidya Sanjay Janardan Tilak Member37. Prof. Ved Vrat Sharma Member38. Vaidya Hari Narayan Swami Member39. Dr. RK Chhabra Member40. Dr. Kamlesh Verma Member41. Dr. Niranjan Singh Tyagi Member42. Dr. Roop Lal Sharma Member43. Dr. P Lakshmaiah Member44. Dr. K Sankaran Member45. Vaidya V.R. Pathrabe Member46. Vaidya Hari Ram Member47. Dr. Anand Vardhan Dwivedi Member48. Dr. SK Bannigol Member

following could not attend the meeting:-

1. Dr. Alakh Narayan Singh Member2. Dr. P Narayanan Member3. Dr. Swapan Kumar Bhunia Member4. Dr. CHS Shastry Member5. Dr. Arvind Keshavlal Patel Member6. Dr. Sukhdevsinh Vansia Member7. Dr. K . Anilkumar Member8. Vaidya Mahendra Kumar Sharma Member9. Dr. AG Lakhabhai Member10. Dr. VV Chhikara Member11. Dr. DP Aggarwal Member12. Vaidya Abdul Wahid Member13. Vaidya Balendu Prakash Member

Special Agenda Item No.1 Condolence Resolution on the sad demiseof Prof. Jyotir Mitra, Dr. R Bharathrajan,Member, CCIM and Dr. Kishore Mohan, Ex-Member, CCIM

It was noted that Prof. Jyotir Mitra, Dr. R Bharathrajan, Member, CCIM and Dr. Kishore Mohan,Ex-Member, CCIM have passed away on 17.1.2006, 8.2.2006 and 29.3.2005 respectively.Central Council of Indian Medicine was observed two minutes silence for the peace of departedsouls and passed the following resolution to be forwarded to the bereaved families:-.

“ The members of CCIM are shocked to know the sad and untimely demise of Prof. Jyotir Mitra,Member, CCIM and Dr. Kishore Mohan, Ex-Member, CCIM. They devoted their life to the

335ay

cause of development of Indian Systems of Medicine in general and Ayurveda in particular.Members of the CCIM offer their condolence and sympathy to the members of the bereavedfamilies and pray to God that departed souls may rest in eternal peace.”

Agenda Item No.1 Confirmation of the minutes of 34th meeting ofAyurved Committee held on 20th March, 2005 at NewDelhi.

It was noted that minutes of 34th meeting of Ayurved Committee held on 20.3.2005 were placedbefore the Central Council in its meeting held on 21.3.2005 for consideration and ratification.The same were ratified by the Central Council.

Ayurved Committee confirmed the same.

Agenda Item No.2 Ratification of the minutes of 54th meeting ofEducation Committee (Ayurved) held on 27th & 28th

June, 2005 at New Delhi.

It was noted that 54th meeting of Education Committee (Ayurved) was held on 27th & 28th June2004 at New Delhi and the minutes of the same were circulated to all the members of EducationCommittee (Ayurved) vide this office letter No.3-2/2005-54th Edu. Com (Ay.) dated 15.7.2005.It was requested that addition/deletion, if any may kindly be suggested within 21 days from thedate of issue of the same. In response to the same, no comments of any member were received.

The Ayurved Committee considered and ratified the minutes of EducationCommittee as under:-

i) Consideration of visitation reports of Ayurved Colleges

It was noted that 94 Ayurvedic colleges were visited to assess the available facilities of teachingand practical training for conducting Ayurvedacharya/Ayurved Vachaspati Course and to verifythe compliance before granting permission for the session 2005-06.

The visitation reports were considered by the Committee and decision of the Committee are asunder:-

435ay

________________________________________________________________Name of the College Recommendations

1. ALN Rao Memorial Ayurvedic Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Koppa and practical training in the Institution,

Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 60 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and for PG Course as underfor the year 2005-2006.

Dravyaguna 06Bhaishajya Kalpana 05Kayachikitsa 05The shortcomings be informed to the collegeseparately for fulfillment and submission ofthe compliance report by 30th November,2005.

2. KVG Ayurvedic Medical College Considering available facilities of teaching& Hospital, Sulliya and practical training in the Institution,

Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 60 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.

The shortcomings be informed to the collegeseparately for fulfillment and submission ofthe compliance report by 30th November,2005.

3. Karnataka Ayurvedic Medical Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Mangalore and practical training in the Institution,



4. Babe ke Ayurvedic Medical Considering available facilities of teachingCollege & Hospital, Moga and practical training in the Institution,


535ay


5. Shri Laxmi Narayan Ayurvedic Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Amritsar and practical training in the Institution,


Committee also decided that strong andstrict warning for construction ofbuilding and removal of othershortcomings be issued.

6. Om Ayurved Medical College, Betul Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 40 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.


7. Rani Dullaya Ayurved College & Considering available facilities of teachingHospital, Bhopal and practical training in the Institution,


The shortcomings alongwith the instructionto improve the hospital condition beinformed to the college for fulfillment andsubmission of the compliance report by 30th

November, 2005.

8. Rajeev Lochan Ayurved Mahavidyalaya Considering available facilities of teachingDurg and practical training in the Institution,


635ay

Committee also decided that cadavers bemade available to the students forteaching and practical trainingwithin two months under intimationto CCIM.

Other shortcomings be informed to thecollege separately for fulfillment andsubmission of the compliance report by 30th

November, 2005.

9. Government Ayurved College, Jabalpur Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 40 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.

The Committee noted that teaching staffis very less. Bed strength has not beenincreased upto 100, therefore, college beasked to increase the bed strength upto100 immediately.

The other shortcomings be informed to thecollege separately for fulfillment andsubmission of the compliance report by 30th

November, 2005.

10. Bapuji Ayurvedic Medical College Considering available facilities of teaching& Hospital, Challakere and practical training in the Institution,



11. Amrutha Ayurved College, Amrutha It was noted that 20 UG teachers areChittradurga working in the college in spite of repeated

instructions of Central Council. Committeedecided first college be asked to replacegraduate teachers with qualified teachers.

735ay

Then only admission to 40 students bepermitted.

12. Chattarpati Sahu Maharaj Shikshan Considering available facilities of teachingAyurved Mahavidyalaya, Aurangabad and practical training in the Institution,

Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 100 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and PG in following subjectsfor the year 2005-2006.

Sharir Rachna 04Kayachikitsa 04


13. Rama Rao Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Considering available facilities of teachingParbhani and practical training in the Institution,

Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 40 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006 subject tofulfillment of shortcomings and submit thecompliance report by 30th November, 2005.

The Committee noted that Conditionof hospital needs immediateimprovement and college be askedfor the purpose.


November, 2005.

14. Manjara Ayurved College & Hospital, Considering available facilities of teachingGandhinagar, Latur and practical training in the Institution,


The shortcomings be informed to the collegeseparately for fulfillment and submission of

835ay

the compliance report by 30th November,2005.

15. Dhanwantri Ayurved College & Considering available facilities of teachingHospital, Udgir and practical training in the Institution,


Committee also decided that pay scale ofteachers be increased and teachers ofabove 65 years be replaced.


November, 2005.

16. Vaidya Yagyadutt Sharma Ayurved Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Khurja and practical training in the Institution,


Committee observed that names of some ofteachers practicing in Delhi are included inthe list of teachers. The matter be pointedout to the college authorities and asked toappoint only full time teachers by thecollege as per CCIM norms.


November, 2005.

17. Swami Kalyan Dev Government Considering available facilities of teachingAyurved College, Rampur,Muzaffarnagar and practical training in the Institution,


Committee also decided to instruct thecollege that Demonstrator be convered

935ay

into Lecturer and letter should bewritten to UP Government also.


November, 2005.

18. Uttaranchal Ayurved College, Dehradoon Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 50 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.

Committee also decided that teachers whoare above 65 be replaced immediatelyby qualified teachers.


November, 2005.

19. Jupitar Ayurved College, Nagpur Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 40 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.


20. Sunil Ram Singh Chunawale Ayurved Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Chikhli and practical training in the Institution,



1035ay

21. Murarilal Rasiwasia Ayurved College Considering available facilities of teachingCharkhi Dadri and practical training in the Institution,

Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 30 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006 subject tofulfillment of shortcomings and submit thecompliance report by 30th November, 2005.


22. Gaur Brahmin Ayurved College Considering available facilities of teaching& Hospital, Rohtak and practical training in the Institution,



23. Bharatiya Sanskriti Darshan Trust Considering available facilities of teachingAyurved Vidya Dham, Wagholi and practical training in the Institution,



24. Gangadhar Shastri Gune Ayurved Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Ahmednagar and practical training in the Institution,

Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 50 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse only and PG is not permittedfor the year 2005-2006.


1135ay

25. Government Ayurved College, Patna Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 40 students in Ayurvedacharyaand PG in following subjects Coursefor the year 2005-2006.

Rasa Shastra 04Dravyaguna 04 students

The committee also decided tha thePresident, CCIM alongwith adelegation may meet the Hon’bleGovernor of Bihar and othersconcerned for improvements in theState colleges of Bihar.


26. Nitishwar Ayurvedic Medical College Committee noted that a complaint by the& Hospital, Muzzafarpur college is received by the President and

decided that after scruitiny of the matter thePresident is authorized to decide foradmission in the college for the year 2005-2006.

27. Gopabandhu Ay. Mahavidyalaya, Puri Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 40 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and PG in following subjectsfor the year 2005-2006.

Kayachikitsa 07Shalya 03Prasuti & Striroga 01Kaumarbhrittya 02Rasashastra 02

1235ay

Committee also decided that upper agebar for UG & PG teachers be 65years. Demonstrators be convertedinto Lecturers. Letter be written toState Government.


November, 2005.

28. Rajiv Gandhi Education Society It was noted that many UG teachers areAyurvedic College, Ron working in the college in spite of repeated

instructions of Central Council. Committeedecided that first college be asked to replacegraduate teachers with qualified teachers.Then only admission of 40 students bepermitted.

29. Taluka Shikshana Prasaraka Sahakara It was noted that many UG teachers areMandal Ayurvedic College, Sindhagi working in the college in spite of repeated

instructions of Central Council. Committeedecided that first college be asked to replacegraduate teachers with qualified teachers.Then only admission to 40 students bepermitted.

30. Govt. Dhanwantri Ayurved College Considering available facilities of teachingUjjain and practical training in the Institution,


Kayachikitsa 03Sharir Rachana 02Dravyaguna 04


31. Subh Deep Ayurved College, Indore Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,

1335ay


Committee also decided that bed strength beincreases upto 100 immediately.


November, 2005.

32. Veenavadini Ayurved College Considering available facilities of teaching& Hospital, Bhopal and practical training in the Institution,


Committee also decided to ask the collegethat teachers above 65 years age bereplaced immediately.


November, 2005.

33. Rajiv Gandhi Ay. Maha., Bhopal Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 50 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.


34. Indira Gandhi Memorial Ayurved Committee decided that as this college isCollege & Hospital, Bhubneshwar visited only as per directions of Government

of India and recommendations of the visitorsbe rejected and report be forwarded to theGovernment of India as desired byGovernment of India.

1435ay

House is of the opinion that Central Councildid not accept the admission made byCollege. Admission made by the college areirregular.

35. State Ayurved College, Lucknow Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 50 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and PG in following subjectsfor the year 2005-2006.

Kayachikitsa 06Sharir Kriya 04Dravyaguna 04

Committee also decided that strongwarning be issued that bedoccupancy should be improved upto60% and than only permission fornext year will be considered.


November, 2005.

36. JB Roy State Ayurved College & Considering available facilities of teachingHospital, Kolkatta and practical training in the Institution,


Committee also decided that strictwarning for conversion ofDemonstrators into Lecturers beappointed, teachers appointed oncontractual basis be removed andmore Professors and Readers beappointed as per CCIM norms.

Other shortcomings be informed to thecollege separately for fulfillment and

1535ay

submission of the compliance report by 30th

November, 2005.

37. Belley Sankerpur Rajiv Gandhi Considering available facilities of teachingMemorial Ayurved College & Hospital and practical training in the Institution,Distt. 24 Pargna (N) Committee decided to grant permission to

admit 50 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.


38. Vasant Dada Patil Ayurved College Considering available facilities of teachingSangali and practical training in the Institution,


Committee also decided that Permissionbe granted with strict warning that asinstitution has made not muchimprovement. If improvement arenot made within stipulated periodfurther permission shall not begranted.


November, 2005.

39. Loknete Rajarambapu Patil Ayurved Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Islampur, Sangli and practical training in the Institution,



1635ay

40. Guru Nanak Ayurved College & Considering available facilities of teachingResearch Institute, Ludhiana and practical training in the Institution,


Committee also decided that enquiry bemade about Dr. RK Pundir’s namein the teachers’s list. More Readersand Professors be appointed. Indooroccupancy should be improved.


November, 2005.

41. Shri Bhartesh Vidya Mandal Considering available facilities of teachingGramin Ayurved College, Terdal and practical training in the Institution,



42. Shri Shivayogeshwar Rural Ay.Medical Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Inchal and practical training in the Institution,



43. Chaudhary Devilal College of Considering available facilities of teachingAyurveda, Jagadhary and practical training in the Institution,


1735ay


44. Swami Raghwendracharya Tridandi Considering available facilities of teachingAyurved mahavidyalya, Gaya and practical training in the Institution,



45. Surya Mukhi Dinesh Ayurved College Considering available facilities of teaching& Hospital, Ranchi and practical training in the Institution,



46. Institute of Post-graduate Ayurved Considering available facilities of teachingEducation & Research at Shyamadas and practical training in the Institution,

Vidya Shastrapeeth, Kolkatta Committee decided to grant permission toadmit students Ayurvedacharya Course andPG in following subjects for the year 2005-2006 as per teachers ratio.

Kayachikitsa 04Ayurved Siddhant 02


47. Shree Narayan Institute of Ayurvedic Visitation report alongwith shortcomings beStudies & Research, Puthur, Kollam forwarded to Government of India.

1835ay

48. Amrita Ayurveda Medical College Visitation report alongwith shortcomings beKollam forwarded to Government of India.

49. Muniyal Institute of Ayurved, Manipal Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 40 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.


50. Shri DM College of Ayurved, Udupi Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 75 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and PG in following subjectsfor the year 2005-2006.

Shalaya 06Kayachikitsa 06Dravyaguna 05Bhaishajayakalpana 02Prasuti & Strirog 06Rasashastra 03Rognidan 03Panchkarma 05Rachna Sharir 06


51. Smt. Urmiladevi Ayurvedic Medical Considering available facilities of teachingSciences, Hoshiarpur and practical training in the Institution,



1935ay


52. Nangelil Ayurved Medical College, Considering available facilities of teachingNangelil and practical training in the Institution,



53. Govt. Ayurved College, Tripunithura Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 30 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.


54. Pankaj Kasthure Ayurved College, Considering available facilities of teachingKallode, Kattakada and practical training in the Institution,



55. Govt. Ayurved College, Trivandrum Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 70 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and PG in following subjectsfor the year 2005-2006.

Swasthvritta 06Maulik Siddhant Avm

2035ay

Ayurved Samhita 06Prasuti & Stri roga 06Panch Karma 05Shalakya 03Shalya 03Agad tantra 05Kaumar bhritta 05Ras shastra 06Dravyaguna 06Bhaishajya Kalpana 06Kayachikitsa 06


56. Shri CB Guttal Ayurvedic Medical Visitation report alongwith shortcomingsCollege, Dharwad forwarded to Government of India.

57. Shri Krishna Govt. Ayurved College, Considering available facilities of teachingKurukshetra and practical training in the Institution,


A strong letter be written toGovernment of Haryana toredesignate the Demonstrator asLecturer.


58. Sangam Sevabhavi Trust Ayurvedic Considering available facilities of teachingMahavidyalaya, Sangamner and practical training in the Institution,


2135ay


59. YMT Ayurvedic College, Mumbai The Committee noted that followinganomalies have been observed:-

1. Hospital is not working properly.

2. Some portion of building ofHospital is transferred toHomoeopathy college.

3. Payscale of teachers is not as perUGC norms.

4. Building and space is not at parwith CCIM norms.

5. Even Board of Name of theCollege at the gate or building isnot given.

The Committee authorized thePresdient to enquire on above issuesproperly and then only decision foradmission be taken by him.

The college be informed not toadmit any student prior to writtenpermission of the Council.

60. Dr. DY Patil Ayurved College, Narul The visitation report alongwith shortcomingNavi Mumbai be sent to Government of India as per rule.

61. JD Ayurved College & Hospital, Aligarh Visitation report alongwith shortcomings beforwarded to Government of India.

62. Sri Sai Ayurved College & Hospital, Considering available facilities of teachingAligarh and practical training in the Institution,

2235ay



63. Bharati Vidyapeeth College of Ayurveda, Considering available facilities of teachingKatraj, Dhankanwadi, Pune and practical training in the Institution,


Ayurved Siddhant & 04DarshanaRachana Sharir 04Dravyaguna 04Rog Nidan 03Prasuti & Striroga 04Shalakya 04Panchkarma 03Bhaishjya Kalpana 04Swasthyavritta 05Kriya Sharir 04Kayachikitsa 05


64. Maharashtra Arogya Mandal Sumati Considering available facilities of teachingBhai Saheb Ayurved Mahavidyalaya and practical training in the Institution,

Hadapsar Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 60 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and PG in following subjectsfor the year 2005-2006.

Kriyasharir 03 students

2335ay


65. SSN Ayurved College & Research Considering available facilities of teachingInstitute, Paikmal and practical training in the Institution,


The shortcomings be informed to the collegeseparately for fulfillment and submission ofthe compliance report by 30th November,2005. The college should be intimatedspecifically for improvement in the hospitalfunctioning.

66. Govt. Ayurved College, Bolangir Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 30 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.


November, 2005.

67. Veer Pulekeshi Vidyavardhak Ayurved Considering available facilities of teachingCollege & Research, Badami and practical training in the Institution,


Committee also decided that authoritiesbe informed to implement properscale to teachers and intimate toCCIM.


November, 2005.

2435ay

68. Shri Kalidas Ayurvedic Medical Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Badami and practical training in the Institution,


Committee also decided that authoritiesbe informed to implement properscale to teachers and intimate toCCIM.


69. Sushrutha Ayurvedic Medical College Considering available facilities of teaching& Hospital, Bangalore and practical training in the Institution,



70. Sri Sri College of Ayurvedic Sciences The visitation report alongwith shortcoming& Research Kankanpur, Bangalore be forwarded to Government of India.

71. Kvj. AT Ayureved College, Ankushpur Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 30 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.


72. Ashvin Rural Ayurvedic College, Considering available facilities of teachingManchi Hill, Ahmednagar and practical training in the Institution,


2535ay


73. Dada Saheb Surup Singh Naik Ayurved Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Dhule and practical training in the Institution,


Committee also decided that consideringimprovement in various sections ofthe college, the admission strengthbe restored to 60 which was reducedpreviously 40 by the Council andGovt. of India be requested forapproval for the purpose.


November, 2005.

74. Lt. Dr. Pt. Shiv Shaktilal Sharma Considering available facilities of teachingAyurved College, Ratlam and practical training in the Institution,



75. Santhigiri Ayurved Medical College, Considering available facilities of teachingPalghat, Olassery and practical training in the Institution,



2635ay


76. Parrasianikkadavu Ayurved Medical Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Kannur and practical training in the Institution,



77. Vishnu Ayurved Medical College, Considering available facilities of teachingPalakkad and practical training in the Institution,



78. Shri Lal Bahadur Shastri Rajkiya Considering visitation report by one memberAyurved Mahavidyalaya, Handia no decision was taken. However, the

Committee also decided not to grantpermission to admit students inAyurvedacharya Course for the year 2005-2006 as no compliance is received from theinstitution.

79. Sri Sairam Ayurved College & Research Considering available facilities of teachingCentre, Kancheepuram and practical training in the Institution,



2735ay

80. Dharma Ayurved College & Hospital, Considering available facilities of teachingKancheepuram and practical training in the Institution,



81. AV Samiti’s Ayurved Mahavidyalya Considering available facilities of teachingBijapur and practical training in the Institution,


Rasashastra 05 students


82. Ayurved Medical College, Hubli Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 50 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and PG in following subjectsfor the year 2005-2006.

Kayachikitsa 05Shalya 02


83. SG Minority Ayurved College, Gazipur Considering lack of facilities of teaching andPractical training in the institute, EducationCommittee did not agree to grant

2835ay

permission for taking admission for thesession 2005-06

84. Mahaganpati Ayurved College, Dharwad Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 60 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.


85. Shri Sankara Ayurved College, Considering available facilities of teachingTrichurapali and practical training in the Institution,



86. Shri Gurudev Ayurved Mah.,Mozari Considering available facilities of teachingAmrawati and practical training in the Institution,

Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 50 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006 with strictwarning.


87. DMM Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Yeotmal Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 50 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and PG in following subjectsfor the year 2005-2006.

Kayachikitsa 03 students

2935ay

Committee also decided that warning forimprovement be made in thisinstitution as well as other grant-in-aid colleges in Maharashtra Stateand the President, CCIM with adelegation may meet to ChiefMinister, Health Minister and otherconcerned persons in MaharashtraState for discussing the problems ofGrant-in-aid colleges and remedialmeasures for these.


November, 2005.

88. SC Mutha Aryangal Ayurved Maha. Considering available facilities of teachingSatara and practical training in the Institution,

Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 50 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and 03 PG in Kayachikitsasubject for the year 2005-2006.


89. Rural Institute of Ay. Research Hospital, The visitation report alongwith shortcomingMyani be forwarded to Government of India.

90. Shri Venkatarmana Ayurved College, Considering lack of available facilities ofChennai teaching and practical training in the

Institution, Committee decided not togrant permission to admit students inAyurvedacharya Course for the year 2005-2006.


3035ay


91. Ashwini Ayurved College, Tumkur Committee decided that indicating theshortcomings report be sent Government ofIndia as per rule.

92. SDM Ayurved College, Hassan Considering available facilities of teachingand practical training in the Institution,Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 75 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse for the year 2005-2006.

Shalya 05Kaumar Bhritta 05Swasthavritta 04Manas Rog 02Panch Karma 04Shalakya 04


93. Government Akhandanand Ayurved Considering available facilities of teachingCollege, Ahmedabad and practical training in the Institution,

Committee decided to grant permission toadmit 75 students in AyurvedacharyaCourse and in PG in followingsubjects for the year 2005-2006.

Kayachikitsa 06Panchkarma 05


94. Shri Balahanuman Ayurved Mahavidalaya Considering available facilities of teachingLodra, Gujarat and practical training in the Institution,

3135ay


Committee also decided that Letter beforwarded to college and StateGovernment about the redesignationof Demonstrators as Lecturer andBuilding should be renovated.


November, 2005.

ii) Recommendations of Workshop to finalise the Minimum list of Essential equipments/instruments/machineries/charts/models etc. for the department of Sanskrit, Samhita &Siddhant, Rachna Sharir, Kriya Sharir and Swastha Vritta organised on 14th & 15th

March, 2005 at Ayurvedic College, Coimbatore

It was noted that a Workshop to finalise the Minimum list of Essentialequipments/instruments/machineries/charts/models etc. for the department of Sanskrit, Samhita& Siddhant, Rachna Sharir, Kriya Sharir and Swastha Vritta was organized on 14th & 15th

March, 2005 at Ayurvedic College, Coimbatore.

The Committee discussed the recommendations and following decision weretaken:-

Computerised dissection facilities should be made available.

Deep freezer also included in the list of equipments.

List of equipments mentioned in the Department of Basic Principle shouldbe deleted and added in the Department of Rasashastra and Dravyaguna

Recommendations made for list of space, equipments, books, models,charts machinery etc. should be taken as reference.

In Charak Samhita “Sharir Sthan” be also included

3235ay

The Committee further decided that members are requested to send theirsuggestions within 15 days.

iii) Recommendations of Workshop to finalise the Minimum list of Essentialequipments/ instruments/machineries/charts/models etc. for the department ofRasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana, Dravyaguna, Agad Tantra andVyavharayurveda on 28th & 29th March, 2005 at Government Ayurved College,Bangalore.

It was noted that a Workshop to finalise the Minimum list of Essentialequipments/instruments/machineries/charts/models etc. for the Department of Rasashastra &Bhaishajya Kalpana, Dravyaguna, Agad Tantra and Vyavharayurveda was organized on 28th &29th March, 2005 at Government Ayurved College, Bangalore.

The Committee decided that members are requested to send their suggestionswithin 15 days.

iv) Certificate Courses on Applications of Analytical Techniques in Ayurveda at elementaryand advanced level – regarding.

It was noted that Department of AYUSH, New Delhi has forwarded the proposal to startcertificate courses on applications of Analytical Techniques in Ayurveda at elementary andadvance level. The sailent points of proposal are as under:-

1. Syllabus may be seen at Annexure .

2. Certificate/diploma courses in application of Analytical Techniques in Ayurved.

3. Course at Elementary level deals with the analysis of raw materials as per pharmacopealmethods like titrementry P.H metry.

4. Through correspondance

5. Duration – 03 months + 10-15 days of Laboratory work.

6. Examination should be conducted by University of Pune and CCRAS/AYUSH.

The Education Committee decided that relevant portion of the syllabus be included in thesyllabus of Rasashastra, Bhaishajya Kalpana and Dravyaguna in UG & PG Course.

Ayurved Committee decided that Committee should be constitutedearly and decision be taken within six months.

3335ay

v) Inclusion of subjects of modern medicine in syllabus ofAyurved (BAMS) as per resolution of the Council.

It was noted that Central Council in its meeting held on 21.3.2005 while considering the minutesof Ayurved Committee for ratification, ratified the following resolution of Dr. Suhar Purchure &others with some modifications and decided that matter be referred to respective EducationCommittees to workout details of syllabus, curriculum and other relevant matters.:-

“Resolution of Dr. VP Tyagi seconded by Dr. SN Purchure and Dr. Shah Kishan Vitthaldas

It was resolved that in the syllabus of Ayurvedacharya (BAMS), Kamil-e-Tib-o-Jarahat (BUMS),Siddha Maruthuva Arignar BSMS one question paper of

1. Anatomy 75%2. Bio Chemistry 25%3. Physiology 25%4. Pathology 50%5. Drug Standardization & quality control 25%6. Radio diagnosis 25 marks7. Anesthesia 25 marks

Ayurved 50Rachna Sharir

Anatomy 150

Ayurved 100Kriya Sharir

75Physiology 25

Ayurved 100Swasth Vritta

PSM 100

Ayurved 150Dravyaguna

Pharmacology 50

Ayurved (Rasa Shastra+Bhaishajya Kalpana) 150Rasshastra

3435ay

Pharmacy 50Quality control and Drug standardization

Ayurved 100AgadtantraVyavhar Ayurved Forensic Medicine 100

Nidan 100Nidan

Pathologyincluding 75Biochemistry

Microbiology 25

100Panchkarma

100

Kayachikitsa 100Kayachikitsa

Medicine 100

Ayurved 100Shalakya

Surgery 100(Anasthesia+Radiology)

Ayurved 100Shalya

Surgery 100

Ayurved 100Shalakya

Eye, ENT & Dental 100

Ayurved 100Gynecology

3535ay

Gynecology 100

Ayurved 50Balrog

Pediatrics 50

The Education Committee considered the issue and decided to constitute a SubCommittee to consider the matter further. The President, CCIM was authorizdto constitute a sub-committee.

Ayurved Committee noted the present action.

vi) Amendment in staffing pattern prescribed by CCIM.

It was noted that Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik vide their letterNo.MUHS/E-3/503/753 dated 7.5.2005 has asked for amendment in the staffing patternprescribed by Central Council of Indian Medicine.

Content of the letter are as under:-

“In the meeting of Board of studies and faculty of Ayurveda & Unani of this University, therequirement of teachers in the Department of Sanskrit, Samhita and Siddhant was discussed atlengths and it was brought out that one lecturer prescribed by Central Council of IndianMedicine for the subject Samhita Siddhant in the college having 50 intake capacity is notsufficient for teaching present syllabus. Therefore, there should be provision of at least twolecturers for this subject. Accordingly, it was resolved that the Central Council of IndianMedicine may be requested to prescribe at least one more Lecturer for Samhita Siddhant subject.

In view of this, you are requested to consider the suggestion for providing two lecturers in thestaffing pattern for the subject Samhita Siddhant.”

Total number of lectures under Regulations are as under:-

Auyrved ka Itihas 60Padarth Vigyan 150

___210

Ap per norms of the Central Council following teachers are required for Under-graduateCourse:-

Professor 01 Reader 01 Lecturer 02(1 for Sanskrit)

3635ay

Education Committee considered the matter and agreed to it.

vii) iapdeZ dk fo"k; ikB~;dze fu/kkZfjr djus o dk;fpfdRlk dkikB~;dze la’kksf/kr djus o Hkkjrh; fpfdRlk (f’k{kk dsU;wure ekud (la’kksf/kr) fofu;e) 1989 esa iapdeZ fo"k;ds vad o O;k[;ku vkfn fu/kkZfjr djus ds laca/k esa A

lwpukFkZ izLrqr gS fd vk;qosZn lfefr }kjk Mk- lqgkl ijpqjs ovU; lnL;ksa ds fuEu izLrko ij fopkj dj fu.kZ; fy;k x;k Fkk fddk; fpfdRlk dk ikB~;fooj.k rhu eghus ds vUnj rS;kj fd;k tk,A

“ifj"kn~ }kjk Lukrd Lrj ij Lora= iapdeZ foHkkx fodflr djus dsfu.kkZ;kraxZr dk;kfpfdRlk ds prqFkZ isij ds ctk; iapdeZ dsnks isij dh ijh{kk dk ekU;rk iznku dh tk; A

ik'oZHkwfe vk;qosZn ’kkL= esa iapdeZ dk egRo loZfofnrgS A gekjs LukrdLrj ds vH;kldze esa iapdeZ Lora= fo"k; ugksrs gq, Hkh dk;fpfdRLkk ds varxZr prqFkZ isij ds :i esalekos’k gS ijarq dqN le; igys bl fn’kk esa ifj"kn~ }kjk fy;k x;kfu.kZ; Lokxr ;ksX; ,oa vfHkuanuh; gS ijarq LukrdLrj ijiapdeZ fo"k; dh ijh{kk ,oa v?;kiu fdl rjg gks bldk Li"VfunsZ’k u gksus ls mijkDr izLrko }kjk fu.kZ; fy;k tk; fddk;kfpfdRlk dh ijh{kk 3 isij ds :i esa gks rFkk prqFkZ isij dhctk; ifj"kn~ }kjk fu/kkZfjr iapdeZ vH;kl dze ds vk/kkj ij 2 isij,oa izkR;kf{kd ijh{kk Lora= fo"k; ds :i esa fy;k tk, rFkk blgsrq izR;sd isij esa 100 vad ,oa izR;kf{kd ijh{kk gsrq 100vad j[kk tk, A rFkk lHkh fo’ofo|ky; dks mudh vad lwph esabl izLrko ds vuq:i dk;Zokgh djus gsrq lwfpr fd;k tk, A ;gfu.kZ; ebZ 2006 ls gksus okyh ijh{kk ls dk;kZfUor fd;k tk, A“

3735ay

It was also submitted that Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik vide their letterNo.MUHS/E-3153/1027 dated 11.3.2005 has asked to revise the syllabus of Kayachikitsaalongwith marks allocation etc. in view of the bifurcation of syllabus of Kayachikitsa andPanchakarma as well as make the provision of lecturer, papers and maximum marks and passingmarks under concern Regulations.

“that University is intending to implement Panchkarma as a new subject from III BAMS firstterm) of October 2004 batch. As the policy of the University is required to be amendedaccordingly the syllabus cannot be implemented retrospectively, the matter was placed beforethe Board of Studies and Faculty of the University for their consideration. These authoritiessuggested following addition and deletion for implementation of the said syllabus.

You sanction for the consequent changes is required.

For third BAMS Course, there will be total 07 subjects instead of 06 subjects and 13papers instead of 12 papers.

The portion related with Panchkarma should be deleted from Kayachikitsa to avoid therepetition of the syllabus. Accordingly, there will be three papers for Kayachikitsainstead of four papers. Therefore, the remaining part of syllabus mentioned in fourthpaper of Kayachikitsa should be included in the third paper of Kayachikitsa.

There will be 300 marks for theory examination in (i) Kayachikitsa instead of 400.

There will be 150 marks for practical examination (ii) Kayachikitsa instead of 200.

As per your suggestion the new subject namely Panchkarma will be of 200 marks (twopapers each of 100 marks) for Theory paper and 100 marks for Practical and oral.

The above amendments will cause the change in total aggregate marks for third BAMSCourse i.e.1300 instead of 1200 for theory examination and 700 instead of 650 forpractical examination. Thus the aggregate marks will be 2000 instead of 1850.

Presently, total period allotted for clinical training to the department of Kayachikitsa(indoor & outdoor), in the hospital attached with the college, is 12 months. Now it shallbe 10 months for the department of Kayachikitsa and 2 months for department ofPanchakarma.

The teachers who are eligible for the post of Professor, Reader, Lecturer in Kayachikitsasubject shall be eligible as a Professor, Reader, Lecturer for Panchakarma subjectalongwith the teacher who is Post-graduate in Panchakarma subject.

Approval to the teachers of Panchakarma cannot be granted without your permission toimplement the syllabus of Panchakarma. The syllabus will be implemented and approval will be

3835ay

given to the appointed teachers, soon after receiving your permission regarding the above saidpoints.”

In this regard, it is submitted that Syllabus of Panchkarma has been prepared in the workshoporganized at RT Ayurved College, Akola. (under refer annexure IV). The syllabus ofKayachikitsa after deleting the syllabus of Panchkarma has been prepared in the Workshop atGovernment Ayurved College, Lucknow. (See at annexure V).

If agreed to the Panchkarma subject may be added in the Regulations namely “Indian MedicineCentral Council (Minimum Standards of Education in Indian Medicine) (Amendment)Regulations, 1989”

8.3 THIRD PROFESSIONAL EXAMINATION (To be held at the end of4-1/2 /5 years)

7. Panchkarma

12. NUMBER OF PAPERS AND MARKS FOR THEORY/PRACTICAL:

Subject No.of Papers Total Marks in theory Total Marks in practical/oral.

1 2 3 4

15. Kayachikitsa Four 400 200

19. Panchkarma Two 200 100

13.1 NUMBER OF LECTURES PRACTICALS AND DEMONSTRATIONSFOR VARIOUS SUBJECTS.

________________________________________________________________________SUBJECT Lectures Practicals & Demonstration

SUBJECTS OF THIRD PROFESSIONAL

15. Kaya Chikitsa 400 12 months

19. Panchkarma ? ?

Total marks of Kayachikitsa may also be reduced.

3935ay

The Education Committee decided that above points be considered thoroughly and draftamendment be prepared for consideration in the next meeting.

Ayurved Committee noted the present action.

viii) Resolution of Dr. CHS Shastry and Dr.Vijay Pathrabe, Member, CCIM.

It was noted that following resolution was submitted by Dr. CHS Shastry & Dr. Vijay Pathrabe,Member, CCIM:-

“While all universities has been allowing Professors and other teachers till the age of 65 years toteach and guide PG students, the Maharashtra Government does not allow such teachers to guidePG students after the age of 60 years.

This is objectionable to CCIM. The Council should direct the Government of Maharashtra toallow teachers till the age of 65 years. This is further requested in view of shortage of teachers inAyurveda.

Education Committee agreed to it and decided that 65 years should be age limitfor teaching and all relevant pruposes.

ix) Decision in respect of consideration of representations and permission for admission etc.

The Committee decided that a Sub Committee consisting of President, CCIM,Vice-President (Ayurved) and Chairman, Education Committee (Ayurved) isauthorized to take decision in respect of decision relating to EducationalInstituti8ons of Ayurved regarding visitation and decision in respect ofpermitting admission etc. after the meeting and prior to convening the nextmeeting of Education Committee (Ayurved).

Agenda Item No.3 Ratification of the minutes of 55th meeting ofEducation Committee (Ayurved) held on 22nd

August, 2005 at New Delhi.

It was noted that 55th meeting of Education Committee (Ayurved) was held on 22nd August, 2006at New Delhi and the minutes of the same were circulated to all the members of EducationCommittee (Ayurved) vide this office letter No.3-2/2005-55th Edu. Com(Ay.) dated 21.8.2005.It was requested that addition/deletion, if any may kindly be suggested within 21 days from thedate of issue of the same. In response to the same, no comments of any member were received.

The Ayurved Committee considered and ratified the minutes of EducationCommittee as under:-

4035ay

i) Consideration of visitation reports of Ayurved Colleges.

The Committee was informed that 41 proposals have been received from Government of Indiafor establishment of new Ayurved colleges, 19 for starting Post-graduate course, 18 to increaseintake capacity of Under-graduate course and one to increase intake capacity of Post-graduatecourse with the request to send the recommendations to Government of India as required underSection 13 A of IMCC (Amendment) Act, 2003 strictly in accordance with the notifiedRegulations in this regard.

The proposal were examined by the office and further by President, Vice-President (Ayurved)and Chairman, Education Committee (Ayurved). It was decided that those new proposalsfulfilling the NOC of State Government, affiliation of University concerned, sent application feeand possesses land requirement fully or partially be visited for assessment of scheme beforemaking the recommendation for issuing/not issuing letter of intent by Government of India tothe concerned Institution.

It was also noted that remaining proposals which were not fulfilling above said criteria have notbeen proposed for visitation.

The Visitation reports were considered by the Education Committee (Ayurved) andrecommended as under:-

At the outset of the meeting, the Education Committee (Ayurved) went through eligibilitycriteria prescribed under concerned Regulations. It was decided that following points should beensured while recommending for permission to new Ayurved Colleges:-

(i) Proof for 10/15 acres of a single plot of land possessed by the management.

(ii) Existence of 100 beded own running Ayurvedic hospital.

(iii) Is in a position to construct college & hospital building on that own plot beforecommencement of Academic year and progress of work be ensured by 30th November2005.

(iv) has obtained permission of State Government for the purpose and assured affiliationof concerned University.

Name of the College Recommendations1 2

1. Rajeev Ayurved College, Hassan The Education Committee after consideringthe Scheme decided to approve the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of Intent.

i) Building of Hospital and college should

4135ay

be constructed at its own specific land asrequired before starting First ProfessionalCourse.

2. Gautham Ayurved Medical College, The Education Committee after consideringBangalore the Scheme decided to approve the


i) Building of Hospital and college shouldbe constructed at its own land and

accommodation required for FirstProfessional Course made available.

3. Hillside Ayurved Medical College, The Education Committee after consideringKanakpura Road, Bangalore the Scheme decided to approve the



accommodation required for FirstProfessional Course.

4.Yadeyuru Ayurved Medical College, The Education Committee after consideringBallary the Scheme decided to approve the




5.Sant Vinoba Bhave Ayurved Medical The Education Committee after consideringCollege, Chatra the Scheme decided to approve the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of Intent

:i) Building of Hospital and college should

be constructed at its own land andaccommodation required for FirstProfessional Course.

6.Chhatisgarh Ayurved Medical College, The Education Committee after considering

4235ay

Rajnandgaon the Scheme decided to approve theScheme and agreed to recommend to

Government of India to issue letter of Intentfor 75 students.



7. Sanjivani Ayurved Medical College, The Education Committee after consideringKhanna the Scheme decided to disapprove the

Scheme as:

i) NOC of the State Government is not asper proforma.

ii) There is no running Ayurved hospital.

iii) College has no required infrastructure.

8.KMCT Ayurved Medical College, The Education Committee after consideringKozikode the Scheme decided to approve the




9. Srinivas Ayurved Medical College The Education Committee after consideringMangalore the Scheme decided to approve the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of Intentfor 50 seats.



ii) Clarification of Indenture of sale of non-agriculture immovable properties heldwrag right for 6.00 lakh

4335ay

iii) Deed of sale of full right or rightrealization of annual report for the 50,000.

10. Shree Devi Ayurved Medical College The Education Committee after consideringMangalore the Scheme decided to approve the


i) Building of Hospital and college shouldbe constructed at its own land as perrequirement

11. Parul Institute of Ayurved, Limbda The Education Committee after consideringthe Scheme decided to approved theScheme and agreed to recommend to

Government of India to issue letter of Intentfor 75 admission.



12. Siddhivinayaka Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringRaibagh the Scheme decided to approved the




13. SDMT Trust Ayurved College, Terdal The Education Committee after consideringthe Scheme decided to approve the




4435ay

14. Sonia Ayurved Medical College, The Education Committee after consideringDharwad the Scheme decided to approved the




15. Ayurved Medical College, Kalyan The Education Committee after consideringMantap, Bidar the Scheme decided to approved the




16. KLE Society’s Ayurved College The Education Committee after consideringAyurved College, Athani the Scheme decided to approve the




17. Gomantesh Ayurved Medical College As college has already admitted 43Hindwadi, Belgaum students which is a violation of Regulations

prescribed by CCIM, therefore, Committeedid not approve the Scheme and decided torecommend to Government of India for notissuing letter of Intent.

18. Govindbhai Ayurved Medical College The Education Committee after consideringVallabh, Vidyanagar the Scheme decided to approve the



4535ay


19. Major SD Singh Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringFatehgarh the Scheme decided to approve the


.i) Building of Hospital and college should

be constructed at its own land andaccommodation required for FirstProfessional Course.

20. Himalayi Ayurved College, Dehradun The Education Committee after consideringthe Scheme decided to approve theScheme and agreed to recommend to

Government of India to issue letter of Intent.



21. RKDF Institute of Medical Sciences The Education Committee after consideringBhopal the Scheme decided to approve the


The Education Committee noted thatState Government has issued the NOCfor establishment of Ayurved College atMandideep which falls under the Distt.ofRaisingh.

The college is being established atHoshangabad Road, Bhopal. The approvalof State Government be obtained for thepurpose.

University has issued the Consent foraffiliation on three different dates and notas per proforma. A fresh letters fromUniversity be obtained.

Building of Hospital and college should beconstructed at its own land and

4635ay


22. Bhopal Ayurved College, Bhopal The Education Committee after consideringthe Scheme decided to recommend to

Government of India for not issuing letterof Intent due to non-existance of requiredfacilities and infrastructure.

23. Hare Krishna Ayurvedic Mahavidyalaya The Education Committee after consideringBhopal the Scheme decided to approve the




24. Punjab Ayurved medical College & The Education Committee after consideringHospital, Sriganganagar the Scheme decided to approve the




25. Saint Sahara Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringBhatinda the Scheme decided to approve the




26. Muniyal Institute of Ayurvedic The Education Committee after consideringSciences, Manipal the Scheme decided to approve the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of IntentFor increasing intake capacity from 40-60.

4735ay

27. Shri Vijay Mahantesh Ayurvedic The Education Committee after consideringMedical College, Ilkal the Scheme decided to approve the Scheme

and agreed to recommend to Government ofIndia to issue letter of Intent for increasingintake capacity from 40-50.

28. Bhagwan Mahaveer Jain Ayurvedic The Education Committee after consideringMedical College, Gajendergarh the Scheme decided to approve the Scheme

and agreed to recommend to Government ofIndia to issue letter of Intent for increasingintake capacity from 40-60.

29. BSPS Gomantak Ayurvedic College, The Education Committee after consideringShiroda Goa the Scheme decided to approve the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of Intentfor increasing intake capacity from 40-50.

30. Shri Gulab Kunverba Ayurved The Education Committee after consideringMahavidyalaya, Gujarat the Scheme decided to approve the

admission strength from 40 to 50.

However, the Committee noted that collegehas asked Enhancement of seats for foreigncandidates for permission as under:-

1999-2000 042000-2001 072001-2002 132002-2003 132003-2004 042004-2005 05

The Education Committee decided thatenhancement of seats shall be specificallynot for foreign students and can not be withprevious effect.

31. BSDTS Ayurved College, Wagholi, The Education Committee after consideringPune the Scheme decided to approve the Scheme

and agreed to recommend to Government ofIndia to issue letter of intent for starting PG

in

4835ay

i) Samhita 04ii) Rachna Sharir 04

iii) Rog Vigyan 04

32. Maharashtra Arogya Mandal The Education Committee after consideringSumati Bhaishah Ayurved Medical the Scheme decided to approve the SchemeCollege, Hadapsar and agreed to issue the letter of intent for

starting PG in

Kayachikitsa 04Prasuti Evam Striroga 04Shalya 04Rachna Sharir 04Rasashastra 04

33. Shri JG Cooperative Hospital Society’s The Education Committee after consideringShankar Ayurved Medical College the Scheme decided to approve the SchemeGhatprabha and agreed to recommend to Government of

India for starting PG Course to issue letter ofintent for

Shalya 05Dravyaguna 05

34. Alva’s Ayurved Medical College, The Education Committee after consideringMoodbidri the Scheme decided to approve the Scheme

to recommend to Government of India toissue letter of Intent for increasing intakecapacity from 70 to 100 and for starting PGin

Rachna Sharir 05Dravyaguna 05Panchkarma 05Ayurved Siddhant 05Shalya 05

35. Government Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringTripunithura the Scheme decided to approve the

scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of Intentto start PG in Shalya with intake capacity of05 students.

4935ay

36. Government Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringRaipur the Scheme decided to approve the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of Intentfor starting PG with 05 seats in eachsubject:

Ayurved Siddhant 05Rachna Sharir 05Rasashastra 05Shalya 05

37. Atrey Ayurved Medical College, The Education Committee after consideringBangalore the Scheme decided to approve the



accommodation required for FirstProfessional Course made available.

38. Lathe Education Society’s Acharya The Education Committee noted that collegeDesh Bhushan Ayurved College is admitting students from last 2-3 yearsBedkihal, Belgaum without the permission of the CCIM which

is a violation of concerned Regulations.College has asked the permission underSection 13 C of IMCC act, 1970. In thisregard no regulation has been prescribedby CCIM so far.

The Committee did not agree to recommendto Government of India to issue the letter ofintent.

39. Vagdevi Ayurved College, Warangal The Education Committee after consideringthe Scheme decided to approve the



accommodation required for First

5035ay

Professional Course.

40. Shankar Dayal Sharma Ayurved The Education Committee after consideringMedical College, Bhopal the Scheme decided to approve the




41. Manam Ayurved College, Kerala The Education Committee after consideringthe Scheme decided to approve the




42. Yashwant Ayurved College, Kodoli The Education Committee after consideringthe Scheme decided to approve the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of Intentfor starting PG in

(i) Shalakya 04(ii) Roganidan 04(iii) Agadtantra 04

43. Kedari Redekar Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringKolhapur the Scheme decided to approve the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of Intentto increase seats from 40 to 50 seats .

44. Ganga Education Society’s Ayurved The Education Committee after consideringAyurved Medical College, Kolhapur the Scheme decided to disapprove the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India for not issuing letterof Intent.

5135ay

45. Shri Kalabhairaveshwara Swami The Education Committee after consideringAyurved College, Bangalore the Scheme decided to approve the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India for issuing letter ofIntent for increasing seats from 50 to 80 .

46. Ayurved College, Imphal Manipur As there is no college in North-EasternState, the Education Committee afterconsidering the Scheme decided to approvethe Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of Intentsubject to fulfillment of eligibility criteria

and other certain norms laid down by CentralCouncil by the applicant organization.

47a & b) AV Samiti’s Ayurved Maha., The Education Committee after consideringBijapur the Scheme decided to approve the


to increase intake capacity from 60-75 and tostart PG course in

i) Ayurved Siddhant 05

ii) Kayachikitsa 05

iii) Shalya 03

48. TMAE Ayurved Mahavidyalaya The Education Committee after consideringNidge, Bhadrawati the Scheme decided to approve the

Scheme and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India to issue letter of Intentto increase intake capacity from 40 to 50.

49. Raghvendracharya Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringChitradurga the Scheme decided to approve the




50. Acharya Gyan Ayurvedic College, The Education Committee after consideringIndore the visitation report decided to grant

5235ay

permission with intake capacity of 50students

i) It was also decided that the Status ofexamination etc. of student admitted lastyear be obtained.

51. Nitishwar Ayurved Medical College, The Education Committee noted that as& Hospital, Bihar per instructions of the President, CCIM,

the college was visited again.

After considering the visitation report,Committee decided to grant permission forthe session 2005-06 with intake capacity of50 students.

52. SG Minority Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringGazipur the visitation report decided to permit the

college for taking admission for session2005-06 with intake capacity of 40 students.

53. Kalmathada Pujaya Virupksha Ayurved The Education Committee after consideringCollege, Manvi visitation report decided to grant

permission for taking admission for theSession 2005-06 with intake capacity of

40 students.

ii) Indian Medicine Central Council (Post-graduate Ayurveda) Education) Regulations,2005 – implementation for the MD/MS (Ayr.) admission 2005-06 as per new CCIM rules.

It was noted that Government of India letter No.R.13014/7/2005-NI dated 13.6.2005 hasforwarded the letter of Dr. SV Savarikar, Vice-Chancellor, Gujarat Ayurved University,Jamnagar regarding notified Regulations of PG Course.

Education Committee did not endorsed the content of the letter of Dr. SVSavarikar, Vice-Chancellor, Gujarat Ayurved University, Jamnagar and was ofthe opinion that as CCIM is expert body to prescribe the Standards of Education,therefore, Post-graduate Regulations prescribed by the CCIM are true in thespirit of present need and development of Ayurveda.

5335ay

iii) Inclusion of Ayurvedacharya (Bachelor of Ayurvedic Medicine & Surgery) degreeawarded by Vinoba Bhave Vishwavidyalaya, Ranchi (Jharkhand) in the Second Scheduleto IMCC Act, 1970.

It was noted that Government of India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, department ofAYUSH vide their letter No.R.12013/3/2005-Ay.Desk dated 2.2.2005 forwarded a copy of letterNo.Estt./R0/52/05 dated 13.1.2005 of Vinoba Bhave University, Hazaribag as required underSection 14(2) of the IMCC Act, 1970 for inclusion of Ayurvedacharya (Bachelor of AyurvedicMedicine & Surgery (BAMS) degree of Vinoba Bhave University, Jharkhand. It has beenrequested to send comments/recommendations of Central Council in accordance with theprovision of Section 14(2) of IMCC Act, 1970.

In this connection, it was further noted that Registrar, Vinoba Bhave University vide this officeletter No.27-18/2004-Uni. Dated 11.2.2005 and 29.3.2005 was requested to send the requiredinformation voluntary to Ayurvedacharya (Bachelor of Ayurvedic Medicine and Surgery)qualification in the prescribed proforma alongwith a cancelled copy of original degree.

The Vinoba Bhave University vide their letter No. VBU/Ex 484/05 dated 12.7.2005 forwardedthe same.

The following facts were noted by the Committee:-

Before bifurcation of Bihar State Surya Mukhi Dinesh Ayurved Medical College, Booty Ranchiwas earlier affiliated to Kameshwar Singh Darbhanga Sanskrit University, Darbhanga. Now thiscollege is affiliated to Vinoba Bhave University, Jharkhand and is imparting AyurvedacharyaCourse.

It was noted that Surya Mukh Dinesh Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Ranchi is affiliation to thisUniversity is being permitted by CCIM for conducting Ayurvedacharya Course after assessingthe available facilities for teaching and practical training permission being granted to the college.

i) university is following the Curriculum & Syllabus etc. as prescribed by CCIM.

ii) University is following the nomenclature as prescribed by CCIM

Education Committee considered the matter and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India for inclusion of the Ayurvedacharya (BAMS) degreeawarded by Sant Vinoba Bhave University, Hazaribagh Jharkhand in SecondSchedule to IMCC Act, 1970.

iv) Resolution of Dr. Vijay Pathrabe.

It was noted that following resolution has been received from Dr. Vijay pathrabe, Member,CCIM seconded by Dr. KV Shah

5435ay

“CCIM is the Apex Governing Body of teaching, training and Research in Ayurveda in India.It’s acts and resolutions are binding and are expected to be uniformly executed..

For Under-graduate level, the efforts of CCIM are widely acclaimed and appreciated. However,regarding Post-graduate training, teaching and research, it is unfortunate and said to know thatthere is neither uniformily nor equal standards.

It is pertinent to note that Universities under whose aegis PG programmes and examinations areconducted act as per their own whims and standards, which in turn undermines and diminishesthe authority of the Apex body. The most damaging aspect is the standard of Post-graduatetraining which suffers to no end.

The pattern of teaching, training and examination of PG Study varies and there is no uniformitywhat so ever.

To elucidate pre MD exam, Maharashtra has 1+4 papers in Pune University, Pre MD papers areof 1+1 pattern in Nagpur University. Some examples can be cited by quoting RGUHS,Rajasthan University, BHU. Therefore, to maintain and confirm equal standard of Post-graduatetraining, teaching and examination in a time bound manner, a schedule of programme must befinalized which can be mediated and managed through a Post-graduate board of CCIM whichwill not only bring uniformity but also enhance the standard of Post-graduate teaching, trainingand research in Ayurveda.

It will also address the concerns regarding high standard of research in Ayurveda. Therefore, itis absolutely essential to constitute a Post-graduate board in CCIM.

Therefore, all Hon. Members are requested to give consent for formation of INDEPENDENTPSOT GRADUATE BOARD OF CCIM.

Education Committee considered the matter and agreed to constitute a Post-graduate Committee of the CCIM to regulate the Post-graduate educationspecifically.

v) Consideration of recognition/inclusion of Ayurvedacharya (BAMS) qualification ofBaraktullah University, Bhopal in Second Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970.

It was noted that Government of India vide their letter No.R.12013/12/2004-Ay.Desk dated 16th

June 2004 has forwarded the request of Barkatullah University, Bhopal for inclusion/recognitionfor Ayurvedacharya (BAMS) degree as required under Section 14(2) of IMCC Act, 1970 forcomments.

In this regard following facts are placed below:-

1. Desired information was asked. University has forwarded the curriculum and syllabusbeing followed by the University for conducting Ayurvedacharya Course.

5535ay

2. Following colleges are affiliated to the Unviersity:-

i) Pt. Khushilal Sharma Ayurved Mahavidyalaya Sansthan, Bhopal

ii) Rajiv Gandhi Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Shahpur, Bhopal

iii) Rani Dhullaiya Ayurved College & Hospital, Bhopal

iv) Veenavadini Ayurved College & Hospital, Bhopal

v) Om Ayurved College, Betul

These colleges are being visited by the CCIM time to time and after assessing the availablefacilities for teaching and practical training permission being granted to these colleges.

3. University is following the nomenclature as prescribed by CCIM under concernedRegulations.

Education Committee considered the matter and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India for inclusion of Ayurvedacharya (BAMS) Degree awardedby Barkatullah University, Bhopal in Second Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970.

vi) Rights and privileges of ISM graduates – regarding.

It was noted that a Contempt Application No.174762 of 2004 has been filed by Shri Om PrakashMal. In contempt pettion No.820/2002. In this regard following facts are placed below:-

Petitioner is an Ayurved graduate.

He is running a Pathology Lab and Radio Diagnostic Centre.

Chief Medical Officer of district has directed to ban these two centers.

To revoke the order of CMO, Writ Petition have been filled by the Petitioner.

It is learnt that a Writ Petition No.820 of 2002 has also been filed by hoders of MD(Ayurved) in Rog Vigyana & Vikriti Vigyan of Banaras Hindu University asking to therights and privileges to running the Pathology Lab.

Education Committee was considered to elucidate rights and privileges of the practitioners ofGraduate and Post-graduates of ISM. In this regard, it was also noted that the Central Councilhas pass a resolution.

In this regard, it was noted that Mr. Prabhakar Awasthi, Advocate, High Court was contacted tooffer the opinion in this regard. Opinion of the Advocate, Mr Prabhakar Awasthi is as under:-

5635ay

“Necessary concomitant of the order dated 19.4.2005 which has been reproduced above is to theeffect that in every given circumstances Council has to clarify its stand and thus shouldessentially file its reply.

This contempt petition is a high profile case wherein High Court has shown its concern regardingquack doctors who are practicing in State of UP without any check and thus is monitoring thepreventive measure which is sought to be taken by various agencies like yours.

It was, therefore, opined that Council should clarify its stand and thus should file its reply beforenext date of listing i.e.24.8.2005.

Education Committee considered the matter and decided that Graduate andPost-graduate of ISM are entitled to run their diagnostic lab etc.

Agenda Item No.4 Ratification of the minutes of 56th meeting of EducationCommittee (Ayurved) to be held on 23rd February,2006 at New Delhi.

The Ayurveda Committee ratified as under:-

i) Recognition of the Post-graduate degree awarded by Amrawati University, Amrawati.

It was noted that Post-graduate qualification awarded by Amrawati University, Amrawati is notincluded in the Second Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970. Government of India vide their letterNo.R.12013/3/2005-Ay.Desk dated 2.2.2005 has asked the comments of CCIM for its inclusionin Second Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970 as required under Section 14 (2) of IMCC Act, 1970.

The Committee noted the following facts:-

1. Required information was asked from the University time to time.

2. Following colleges are affiliated to this University. Details are as under:-

1. Shri Radha Krishna Toshniwal 50 PermittedAyurved Mahavidyalaya 02 PG in SamhitaStation Road 02 Rachana SharirAKOLA 444001 03 Shalaya

03 Kayachikitsa

2. Vidarbha Ayurved Mahavidyalaya 50 PermittedHanuman Vyayam Nagar 03 PG in ShalyaAMRAWATI 444605 01 Shalakya

5735ay

02 Swastha Vritta02 Kayachikitsa

3. Shri Gurudev Ayurved Mahavidyalaya 50 PermittedGurukunj Ashram (Mozari) 444601AMRAWATI

4. DMM Ayurved Mahavidyalaya 50 PermittedAarni Road, Shivaji Nagar 03 PG in KayachikitsaYEOTMAL 445601

These colleges have been visited by CCIM and have been permitted time to time to conductUnder-graduate and Post-graduate courses as mentioned against them.

3. Cancelled copy of certificate is also enclosed which is as per nomenclature prescribed byCCIM.

4. Copy of syllabus and ordinance for conducting PG has also been forwarded by Universityand it has been observed that University is not following the Syllabus and Curriculum asprescribed by CCIM.

The comparative statement of available facilities of teaching and practical training was alsoconsidered by the Education Committee.

It was also noted that Hon’ble High Court in which CCIM was also a party has directed tocomplete all the formalities within six months.

The Education Committee decided to recommend to Government of India for its inclusion inthe Second Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970. The Committee considering the shortcomings ofinfrastructure in affiliated colleges also decided that a letter be written to the colleges,University and Government also to fulfill the shortcomings about bed occupancy, Pharmacy,Dissection hall, Library etc. within six months.

ii) Examination of Second Professional

It was noted that following provisions (reads as under) has been made under concern Regulationregarding examination of third profession. It has been observed that this provision is not in truespirit of examination.

(i) “The first professional period shall start from 1st day of July and end on 31st December nextyear. The examination shall ordinarily be completed by the end of December. TheSupplementary examination of first professional shall be held within two months of declaration

5835ay

of result. The subsequent first professional examination will be held every six months and failedcandidates shall ordinarily be allowed 3 (three) chances for passing First Professional.

However, a student failed in one or more subjects of First Professional examination may beallowed to keep term in Second Professional Course. Only those students who passed in allsubjects, shall be allowed to take the Third Professional examination.”

In this regard it was also noted that if any candidate pass the First Professional but does not passthe Second Professional examination may be allowed to appear in the examination of ThirdProfessional. If candidate passed in Third Professional and does not pass the SecondProfessional can not be declared as pass. After passing the student he/she will be entitle to dothe Internship. Therefore, it is not feasible.

The Committee decided as under:-

A student failed in one or two subjects in First Professional examination may beallowed to keep term in Second Professional Course. However, he/she shouldclear remaining subjects of First Professional Course before appearing inSecond Professional examination.

Likewise, students after passing all subjects of Second Professional Courseshould be allowed to appear in Third Professional examination.

iii) y?kq fl)kar dkSeqnh ds LFkku ij ije y?kq fl)kardkSeqnh dks ekU; djus ds lEcU/k esa izLrko

vafdr fd;k x;k fd iz/kkukpk;Z Lo’kklh; vk;qosZn egkfo|ky; Xokfy;j}kjk vuqjks/k fd;k x;k gS fd orZeku esa izFke O;kolkf;d ds laLd`rfo"k; esa Hkkjrh; fpfdRlk dsUnzh; ifj"kn~ fu/kkZfjr ikB~;dze esay?kq fl)kar dkSeqnh dh vfuok;Zrk gS A blds LFkku ij ikB~;dze esalaf/k lekl rFkk dkjd vkfn dk ek= Hkkx lekos’k gh vkt ds le;kuqlkjO;kogkfjd gksxk] bl gsrq ije y?kq fl)kUr dkSeqnh dks fu/kkZfjriqLrd ds :i esa ekU; fd;k tkuk mfpr gksxk A

Education Committee considered the matter and did not agreed to it.

iv) Detailed guidelines for Internship – regarding.

5935ay

It was noted that Education Committee (Ayurved) in its meeting held on 21.3.2004 felt thatprovision made under concern Regulations regarding internship are not sufficient, therefore,Committee, decided to prepare the further details in the matter. The decision of the EducationCommittee was ratified by Subsequent Ayurved Committee and Central Council. The SubCommittee of following members was constituted by President, CCIM:-

1. Vaidya SK Mishra, Chairman, Education Committee (Ayurved)

2. Dr. Madan Sarup Gupta, Education Committee (Unani)

3. Vaidya GL Chanana, Chairman, Finance Committee.

It was also noted that the meeting of Sub Committee was convened on 5.7.2005 and 6.7.2005and 6.10.2005. All the members attended the meeting.

The Ayurved Committee after going through the recommendations amended theprogramme and time distribution as under:-

1. Nine months training should be in the approved hospital in the followingsubjects:-

i) Kayachikitsa 02 monthsii) Panchkarma 01 monthsiii) Shalya 02 monthiv) Shalakya 01 monthv) Prasuti & Striroga 02 monthvi) Kaumarbhritya 01 month.

2. Three months training should be mainly in respect of National HealthProgrammes in one or more following institutions:-

a. Primary Health Centreb. Community Health Centre/District Hospitalc. Any recognized hospital of modern medicine by Director of Health

Services/University concernedd. Any recognized Ayurvedic hospital or Dispensary by Director of

Ayurved/University concerned.

6035ay

v) Clarifications regarding new regulations of PG Education ofAyurveda gazetted on 3.2.2005.

It was noted that Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences, Bangalore was asked theclarification regarding clause 11 (b) which states fundamental of non-clinical subjects/clinicalsubjects of Ayurved with an emphasis of applied aspects alongwith with reference studies ofBasic Sciences of Modern Medicine.

1. To provide course contents and scheme of examination for the newly introduced subjectsand the subjects that are split to form new subjects.

2. Clarification of the terminologies ‘Subject’, ‘Specialty’ and ‘Super Specialty’.

3. Academic qualification and experience for eligibility to become teachers, guides andexaminer for the newly introduced subjects like Chaya Avam Vikiran Vigyan and newlyformed subjects like Shalakya Tantra – Danta avam Mukha Roga.

4. Whether a teacher with Academic qualification in Kayachikitsa can become Teacher/Guide/Examiner in Panchakarma etc.,

5. Clause 11-b states “fundamentals of non-clinical Subjects/Clinical subjects of Ayurvedawith an emphasis on applied aspects alongwith reference studies of basic sciences ofmodern medicine”. Please clarify and specify what basic sciences of modern medicineare to be studied.

Education Committee deferred the matter for next meeting.

vi) Addition of Panchkarma subject in the Regulations of IMCC (Minimum Standards ofEducation in Indian Medicine)(Amendment), Regulations 1989.

It was noted that the 54th meeting of Education Committee (Ayurved) held on 27-28th June 2005while passing following resolution and facts decided that following points be consideredthoroughly and draft amendment be prepared for consideration in the next meeting.

vafdr fd;k x;k fd vk;qosZn lfefr }kjk Mk- lqgkl ijpqjs o vU;lnL;ksa ds fuEu izLrko ij fopkj dj fu.kZ; fy;k x;k Fkk fd dk;fpfdRlk dk ikB~;fooj.k rhu eghus ds vUnj rS;kj fd;k tk,A

6135ay

“ifj"kn~ }kjk Lukrd Lrj ij Lora= iapdeZ foHkkx fodflr djus dsfu.kkZ;kraxZr dk;kfpfdRlk ds prqFkZ isij ds ctk; iapdeZ dsnks isij dh ijh{kk dk ekU;rk iznku dh tk; A

ik'oZHkwfe vk;qosZn ’kkL= esa iapdeZ dk egRo loZfofnrgS A gekjs LukrdLrj ds vH;kldze esa iapdeZ Lora= fo"k; ugksrs gq, Hkh dk;fpfdRLkk ds varxZr prqFkZ isij ds :i esalekos’k gS ijarq dqN le; igys bl fn’kk esa ifj"kn~ }kjk fy;k x;kfu.kZ; Lokxr ;ksX; ,oa vfHkuanuh; gS ijarq LukrdLrj ijiapdeZ fo"k; dh ijh{kk ,oa v?;kiu fdl rjg gks bldk Li"VfunsZ’k u gksus ls mijksDr izLrko }kjk fu.kZ; fy;k tk; fddk;kfpfdRlk dh ijh{kk 3 isij ds :i esa gks rFkk prqFkZ isij dhctk; ifj"kn~ }kjk fu/kkZfjr iapdeZ vH;kl dze ds vk/kkj ij 2 isij,oa izkR;kf{kd ijh{kk Lora= fo"k; ds :i esa fy;k tk, rFkk blgsrq izR;sd isij esa 100 vad ,oa izR;kf{kd ijh{kk gsrq 100vad j[kk tk, A rFkk lHkh fo’ofo|ky; dks mudh vad lwph esabl izLrko ds vuq:i dk;Zokgh djus gsrq lwfpr fd;k tk, A ;gfu.kZ; ebZ 2006 ls gksus okyh ijh{kk ls dk;kZfUor fd;k tk, A“

It was also noted that Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik vide their letterNo.MUHS/E-3153/1027 dated 11.3.2005 has asked to revise the syllabus of Kayachikitsaalongwith marks allocation etc. in view of the bifurcation of syllabus of Kayachikitsa andPanchakarma as well as make the provision of lecturer, papers and maximum marks and passingmarks under concern Regulations.

“that University is intending to implement Panchkarma as a new subject from III BAMS firstterm) of October 2004 batch. As the policy of the University is required to be amendedaccordingly the syllabus cannot be implemented retrospectively, the matter was placed before theBoard of Studies and Faculty of the University for their consideration. These authoritiessuggested following addition and deletion for implementation of the said syllabus.

You sanction for the consequent changes is required.

6235ay

For third BAMS Course, there will be total 07 subjects instead of 06 subjects and 13papers instead of 12 papers.

The portion related with Panchkarma should be deleted from Kayachikitsa to avoid therepetition of the syllabus. Accordingly, there will be three papers for Kayachikitsainstead of four papers. Therefore, the remaining part of syllabus mentioned in fourthpaper of Kayachikitsa should be included in the third paper of Kayachikitsa.

There will be 300 marks for theory examination in (i) Kayachikitsa instead of 400.

There will be 150 marks for practical examination (ii) Kayachikitsa instead of 200.

As per your suggestion the new subject namely Panchkarma will be of 200 marks (twopapers each of 100 marks) for Theory paper and 100 marks for Practical and oral.

The above amendments will cause the change in total aggregate marks for third BAMSCourse i.e.1300 instead of 1200 for theory examination and 700 instead of 650 forpractical examination. Thus the aggregate marks will be 2000 instead of 1850.

Presently, total period allotted for clinical training to the department of Kayachikitsa(indoor & outdoor), in the hospital attached with the college, is 12 months. Now it shallbe 10 months for the department of Kayachikitsa and 2 months for department ofPanchakarma.

The teachers who are eligible for the post of Professor, Reader, Lecturer in Kayachikitsasubject shall be eligible as a Professor, Reader, Lecturer for Panchakarma subjectalongwith the teacher who is Post-graduate in Panchakarma subject.

Approval to the teachers of Panchakarma cannot be granted without your permission toimplement the syllabus of Panchakarma. The syllabus will be implemented and approval will begiven to the appointed teachers, soon after receiving your permission regarding the above saidpoints.”

In this regard, it was noted that Syllabus of Panchkarma has been prepared in the workshoporganized at RT Ayurved College, Akola. The syllabus of Kayachikitsa after deleting thesyllabus of Panchkarma has been prepared in the Workshop at Government Ayurved College,Lucknow.

If agreed to the Panchkarma subject may be added in the Regulations namely “Indian MedicineCentral Council (Minimum Standards of Education in Indian Medicine) (Amendment)Regulations, 1989”

8.3 THIRD PROFESSIONAL EXAMINATION (To be held at the end of4-1/2 /5 years)

1. Panchkarma

6335ay

NUMBER OF PAPERS AND MARKS FOR THEORY/PRACTICAL:_________________________________________________________________Subject No.of Papers Total Marks in theory Total Marks in practical/

oral.1 2 3 4

15. Kayachikitsa Four 400 200

19. Panchkarma Two 200 100

13.1 NUMBER OF LECTURES PRACTICALS AND DEMONSTRATIONSFOR VARIOUS SUBJECTS.

SUBJECT Lectures Practicals & Demonstration

SUBJECTS OF THIRD PROFESSIONAL

15. Kaya Chikitsa 400 12 months

19. Panchkarma ? ?

Total marks of Kayachikitsa may also be reduced.

Revised Syllabus of Panchkarma and Kayachikitsa is also enclosed herewith for ready reference.

It was further noted that Central Council in the reviewed Syllabus which is not implemented sofar has made the provision of three papers of Kayachikitsa and one paper of Panchkarma.

Ayurveda Committee considered the matter and decided that:

There should be three papers of Kayachikitsa and one papers ofPanchkarma

Theory practical

Kayachikitsa 300 150

Panchakarma 100 50

Total numbers of Lecturer etc. for regulation be adjusted accordingly.

6435ay

vii) Recommendations of Workshop to finalise the Minimum list of Essentialequipments/ instruments/machineries/charts/ models etc. for the Department of

Kayachikitsa, Shalya, Shalakya & Kaumarbhritya organized on 19-20th December, 2005at New Delhi.

It was noted that Workshop to finalise the Minimum list of Essential equipments/instruments/machineries/charts/ models etc. for the Department of Kayachikitsa, Shalya,Shalakya & Kaumarbhritya organized on 19-20th December, 2005 at New Delhi

The recommendations of the same was considered by the Education Committeeand approved. All departmental requirements should be divided later on in twogroups i.e. essential and desirable.

viii) Recognition/inclusion of Ayurvedacharya & Ayurved Vachaspatiqualifications awarded by Hemwati Nandan Bahuguna Garwal University,

Srinagar (Uttaranchal)

It was noted that degree awarded by Hemwati Nandan Bahuguna Garwal University, Srinagar(Uttaranchal) is not included in the Second Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970 so far. In this regardfollowing facts are placed:-

1. Government of India forwarded the request of the University for the same vide their letterNo.R.12013/14/2004-Ay.Desk dated 14th July 2004 and comments of the Central Councilhave been asked.

2. Following colleges are affiliated to this University. Details are as under:-

i. Govt. Gurukul Ayurved College 50 PermittedGurukul KangariHARIDWAR 249404

ii. Govt. Rishikul Ayurved College 60 PermittedHARIDWAR 249401 07 PG in Rasashastra

07 Bhaishjyakalpna

iii. Uttaranchal Ayurved College 50 PermittedAyurved Estate

17, Old Mussorie Road, RajpurDEHRADUN - 248009

Before the constitution of the Uttaranchal State these colleges were affiliated to the KanpurUniversity, Kanpur.

6535ay

3. University has followed the Nomenclature of the degree as prescribed by CentralCouncil.

The Committee considered the comparative statement of available facilities of teaching andpractical training of these institutions.

Education Committee decided to recommend to Government of India for itsinclusion in Second Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970

ix) Relaxation for Post-graduate qualification for the teaching staff appointed prior to1.7.89.

It was noted that Joint Secretary (Ayush) called a meeting with the President, CCIM regardingenforcement of essentiality of Post-graduate qualification for the appointment of teaching staffappointed before 1.7.89. However, the meeting was attended by the Secretary, CCIM.

Further, it was noted that on the demand of President, CCIM, the second meeting was called byJoint Secretary (Ayush) in his Chamber on 19.11.2005. Content of the minutes are as under:-

Raising the issue of non-implementation of essentiality of PG qualification of appointment andpromotion of Ayurveda teachers, the Regulations, 1989 was referred to by the Advisor(Ayurveda). The Chairman, Education Committee, CCIM read out the relevant portion of theRegulations, 1989 and stated that the essentiality of PG degree is applicable only for newappointments and for obtaining promotions only experience has been indicated as essential. TheAdvisor (Ayurveda) corrected him by stating that the spirit of the Regulations, 1989 was toenforce essentiality of PG qualification for all teaching posts from the level of the Lecturer toProfessor. Experience could not replace essentiality of PG qualification for grant of promotion.

It was brought to the notice of the CCIM officials that their stand that the Regulations, 1989 hasnot made PG qualification essential for grant of promotions was not approved by theGovernment and the Government, vide its letters dated 23.12.1996 and 28.4.1997, has made itclear that such an exemption is against the spirit of the Regulation, 1989. On humanitariangrounds, a relaxation can be made to the extent as not to treat the existing, as on 1.7.89, non PGteachers as ineligible for teaching posts but, for gaining promotions they will have to acquire aPG qualification.

Advisor (Ayurveda) insisted that we are dealing with teaching of medical science, whichinvolves question of human lives. When the UGC has made an M.Phil/Ph.D essential forteaching posts even in Arts Colleges, not implementing essentiality of post-graduate qualificationfor teachers of medical sciences is a retrograde step. It is now more than 15 years and the CCIM

6635ay

has not implemented essentiality of PG qualification, and has allowed non-PG teachers to getpromotions even to the level of Principals of post-graduate colleges. The Joint Secretary(AYUSH) suggested that, atleast w.e.f. 1.1.2006, the Council should not allow further promotionto any non-post-graduate teacher. No appointment to other colleges in the name of transfer ofteachers would be permitted. The President, CCIM assured that this issue will be discussed inthe next meeting of CCIM.

The attention of CCIM office bearers was drawn to the stand taken by CCIM in Writ Petition atJabalpur Bench of High Court wherein the CCIM has made a statement that “PG qualification inthe concerned subject has been made compulsory for new recruitment of teachers made after1.7.89, but for teachers appointed before 1.7.89 but promoted/nominated after 1.7.89, PGqualification shall not be compulsory.” The Council has issued similar clarification to all StateGovernment vide letter dated 29.3.1996. In this context, attention of the CCIM officials wasinvited to the provisions of Section 36(1) of the IMCC Act, 1970. The Section 36(1) of the Actstipulates that all the Regulations, which include Regulations and amendment/addendum orclarification to the Regulations, to be issued by the CCIM; (i) should have prior approval of theGovernment and (ii) should be notified in the Official Gazette. The Government of India hasnot approved the proposal dated.11.12.91 of the Council as such their clarification, sent to theState Governments vide letter dated 29.3.96, and the statements made in the said Writ Petitionare legally void for not complying with the provisions of the IMCC Act, 1970.

The Joint Secretary (AYUSH) requested the President, CCIM that in the interest of maintainingquality and credibility of the Ayurveda/Unani education essentiality of PG qualification for allappointments and promotions of teachers should be implemented, immediately. Atleast fromnow on teachers not having post-graduation degree should not be made Professors and Principalsof Ayurveda/Unani colleges. The President, CCIM informed that he will take this matter in thenext meeting of the Council, which is due in March, 2006.

Education Committee referred the matter to the Central Council.

x) Consideration of visitation/verification report of compliance etc. of the college(proposals) received through Government of India for forwarding

recommendations/comments of Central Council to the Government of India.

It was noted that Government of India has forwarded the compliance report of following collegesfor forwarding the recommendations/comments of the CCIM.

In view of the above, the colleges were proposed for visitation. The Education Committeedecided as under:-

______________________________________________________________________________Name of Institution Recommendations

6735ay

1. SD Major Singh Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringFarukhabad the visitation/compliance report and all

relevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for issuing letter ofpermission.

2. Parul Ayurved College, Limbda The Education Committee after consideringthe visitation/compliance report and allrelevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for issuing letter ofpermission.

3. Vidya Mandal Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringVidyanagar the visitation/compliance report and all

relevant papers decided not to recommendto Government of India for issuing letter ofpermission.

4. TMAE Ayurved College, Nidge The Education Committee after consideringBhadrawati the visitation/compliance report and all

relevant papers decided not to recommendto Government of India for increasing intakecapacity.

5. KMCT Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringKozikode the visitation/compliance report and all


6. Atrey Ayurved College, Bangalore The Education Committee after consideringthe visitation/compliance report and allrelevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for issuing letter ofpermission.

7. Sri Siddhi Vinayak Ayurved College, The Education Committee after consideringHarigare Belgaum the visitation/compliance report and all


8. Shri Raghvendracharya Ayurved The Education Committee after considering

6835ay

College, Malladehalli, Chitradurga the visitation/compliance report and allrelevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for issuing letter ofpermission..

9. Harekrishna Ay.Medical College, The Education Committee after consideringBhopal the visitation/compliance report and all


10. Sonia Ayurved College, Dharwad The Education Committee after consideringthe visitation/compliance report and allrelevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for issuing letter ofpermission. subject to verification ofavailability of 10 acre land for Ayurvediccollege purpose only

11. KMS Ayurved College, Bellary The Education Committee after consideringKanmadu the visitation/compliance report and all


12. JGCH Ayurved College, Ghatprabha The Education Committee after consideringthe visitation/compliance report and allrelevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for issuing letter ofpermission .for starting PG Course in Shalyaand Dravyaguna with intake capacity of five(05) seats in each subject.

13. Muniyal Ayurved College, Manipal The Education Committee after consideringthe visitation/compliance report and allrelevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for increasingadmission strength from 40 to 50.

14. Alvas Ayurved College, Moodbidri The Education Committee after consideringthe visitation/compliance report and allrelevant papers decided to recommended toGovernment of India for issuing letter ofpermission in Shalya and Dravyaguna withintake capacity of five (05) seats for eachsubject.

6935ay

15.Bharteeya Sanskri Darshan Ayurved The Education Committee after consideringCollege, Wagholi the visitation/compliance report and all

relevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for starting Post-graduate Course in Samhita, Rachna Sharirand Kaya Chikitsa with intake capacity offive (05) seats in each speciality.

16. Yashwant Ayurved College, Kodoli The Education Committee after consideringthe visitation/compliance report and allrelevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for PG in Shalakya andRoganidana with five seats in each specialityto availability of recognized PG teachers byUniversity.

17.Government Ayurved College The Education Committee after consideringRajanandgaon the visitation/compliance report and all

relevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for issuing letter ofpermission for 75 seats.

18. Govt. Ayurved College, Raipur The Education Committee after consideringthe visitation/compliance report and allrelevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for PG Course insubjects of Ayurved Siddhanta, RachanaSharir, Rasashastra, Shalya with five seats ineach subject.

19. RKDF Ayurved College, Bhopal The Education Committee after consideringthe visitation/compliance report and allrelevant papers decided to recommend toGovernment of India for issuing letter ofpermission for admission of 100 students.

xi) Recognition/inclusion of Ayurvedacharyadegree awarded by BanarasHindu University, Varanasi.

It was noted that Government of India vide their letter No.V.27016/1/2006-Ay.Desk dated1.2.2006 has forwarded the request of the Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi to the CCIM to

7035ay

recognise/ inclusion of Ayurvedacharya degree awarded by Banaras Hindu University, Varanasiin the Second Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970. In this regard following facts are placed below:-

Banaras Hindu University has been permitted by the Central Council for conductingAyurvedacharya Course with intake capacity of 50 students since 2000-2001.

University has forwarded the cancelled copy of the degree which seems to be as perprescribed nomenclature of CCIM.

University has forwarded a copy of curriculum and syllabus of Ayurvedacharya course

Education Committee considered the matter and agreed to recommend toGovernment of India for its inclusion in Second Schedule.

xii) Finalization of Minimum Standard & Requirement forAyurved/UnaniSiddha colleges and Hospital .

It was noted that Govt. of India vide letter No. R.11011/6/2005-EP dated 12th January, 2006 hasconstituted a sub committee of following members is for following purposes.

1. to look into Course Curriculum of BAMS, BUMS and BSMS and in view of that fixminimum standard for ASU Colleges .

2. To examine the draft regulation of minimum standard for establishment of new colleges inAyurved/ Siddha/ Unani

3. To formulate minimum standard format/check list for verification for infrastructure of theapplicant as per minimum standard of ASU education regulation for use of inspection team.

1. Prof. R.H. Singh, Vice Chanclellor, ChairmanRajasthan Ayurved University, Jodhpur

2. Dr. S.S. Savrikar, Vice Chancellor, MemberGujarat Aired University, Jamnagar

3. Dr. S.K. Sharma, Advisor Ayurved Member

4. Dr. Anis A.Ansari, Advisor (Unani) Member

5. Dr. G. Veluchamy, Director MemberN. I. S, Chennai

6. Dr. B.L. Gaur, Director Member

7135ay

N.I.A. Jaipur

7. Dr. Abdul Wahid, Dean MemberFaculty of Ayurved RA Poddar College, Mumbai

8. Vaidya Devendra Triguna, MemberVice-President (Ayurveda)

9. Dr. V.V. Prasad, Director MemberRAV, New Delhi

10.Dr. Adarsh Kumar, Research Officer (Ayurved) Member

11.Dr. D.C.Katoch, Deputy Advisor (Ayurved) Convener

As per instruction of the President, CCIM matter was placed before the Committee.

Education Committee decided that this matter pertains to CCIM so only CCIMshould finally decide.

xiii) Minutes of Sub Committee constituted by Education Committee (Ayurved)

It was noted that a resolution regarding inclusion of Modern subjects in the syllabus of Under-graduate Course in all the systems of Medicine was moved by Dr. VP Tyagi and seconded by Dr.Suhas Purchure and other in the meeting of Ayurved Committee held on 18.3.2005. CentralCouncil while considering the resolution referred to respective Education Committees.Education Committee (Ayurved) in its meeting held on 27-28th June 2005 authorized thePresident, CCIM to constitute a Sub-Committee for consideration of the matter. President,CCIM constitute a sub-committee consisting of the following:-

1. Vaidya Shriram Sharam, President, CCIM2. Vaidya Devendra Triguna, Vice-President (Ayurved)3. Vaidya SK Mishra, Chairman, Education Committee (Ayurved)4. Prof. Kulwant Singh5. Dr. P Lakshmaiah6. Dr. VV Chhikara7. Dr. SN Purchure8. Vaidya HN Swamy9. Vaidya GL Chanana10. Dr. KV Shah11. Dr. SK Sharma

7235ay

Education Committee noted the same.

Visitation report of Om Ayurved College, Betul

It was noted that a complaint regarding infrastructure, teaching staff etc. of Om AyurvedCollege, Betul was received in the office. As per instructions of the President, CCIM the collegewas visited by Dr. BK Jaisingh, Member CCIM and Dr. PR Sharma, Secretary CCIM.

Education Committee considered the matter and decided that decision on thisvisitation report will be taken with the next visitation report.

Addl. Agenda Item No.1 Regarding Karnataka State Private AyurvedicMedical College & Hospital Association’sFederation, Gajendragad.

It was noted that a letter dated 172.2006 was received from Karnataka State Private AyurvedicMedical College & Hospitals Association’s Federation, Gajendragad requested to consider thefollowing:-

1. Provision of Ayurvedacharya (BAMS) Graduates as teacher in Ay. colleges is permittedonly upto June 1989. As there is a shortage of PG in the country, we request you toextend graduates as Lecturers by utilizing their services for para medical andclinicalpracticals which gives life to more than 700 families of Ayurveda teachers whoare working as a teaching staff with many years of service. So once again it is ourrequest let them serve as lecturer only if they want promotion PG qualification be madecompulsory.

2. Bed Ratio instead of 1:3 it should be 1:1.

In Ayurveda major treatment is Panchkarma and Ksharakarma. As most of the patients receivedPanchkarma treatment they are not taking the admission in the hospital. They are trated as outpatients. In the course of treatment they admit only one or two days and about Ksharakarma alsousually cannot admit they take only out patient treatment, though there is a patients flow i.e. onlyfor OPD and OPD based treatment but not IPD. Only few patients get admit for the treatment soit is our requested to reconsider bed ratio to 1:1.

3. Reconsideration of Staff Pattern:

7335ay

The work load of teaching staff be considered on par with UGC norms. The PG staff be allowedto teach allied subjects keeping the old seven department pattern, BAMS graduates be allowed asLecturer for para medical and clinicals and practicals. BAMS graduates can be promoted if theypass PG. In order to strengthen Prasootitantra and Shalya department, MBBS, MD Gynocologyand MBBS MS be permitted teach BAMS students and consider their teaching as part of workload.

4. To encourage PG Course needs some relaxations as stop gaparrangements for a period of 5 years

a) As qualified PG teachers are very less in number or some time even not availableso relax the age limit 65 to 70.

b) Allowed to guide lecturer, Assistant Professor and Professor at the ratio of 2,3 and5.

c) New PG course should be introduced and permitted to the guide and deal withallied subjects in the same college or neighboring college.

Ayurveda Committee did not agree to the above.

Addl. Agenda Item No.2 Resolution of Dr. SP Bhattachrya,Member,CCIM

That following resolution is to be incorporated in the Ayurved Committee and Central Councilmeeting. This become necessary as because ISM doctors have to work under Allopathicadministration in most of the States.

RESOLUTION: AYUSH (Ayurved/Unani/Siddha) doctors are competent to handle medicolegal cases as they are being taught in their syllabus. The information are to be passed to allChief Secretaries and Health Secretary of the States.”

Ayurveda Committee agreed to the above.

Addl. Agenda Item No.3 Resolution moved by Dr. HarinarayanSwamy and seconded by Dr. VP Tyagi, Dr.OP Vashishth, Dr. Jagjeet Singh, Dr. PLakshmaiah, Dr. IM Jha Members,CCIM

A resolution moved by Dr. Hari Narayan Swamy and seconded by Dr. VP Tyagi, Dr. OPVashishth, Dr. Jagjeet Singh, Dr. P Lakshmaiah, Dr. IM Jha Members, CCIM stated that

7435ay

ifj"kn~ ds ikB~dze esa fo"k;ksa ds fo"k; esa iqufuZ?kkj.kfd;k tkuk pkfg, A bl fo"k; ij lkef;d ifjflFkfr ds vuqlkj fopkj fd;ktkuk vko’;d gS] d`i;k fopkj ds fy, izlRko Lohdkj dj f’k{kk lfefresa fopkjkFkZ Lohd`fr iznku djsa A

Ayurveda Committee referred the matter to the next meeting of EducationCommittee (Ayurved)

Addl. Agenda Item No.4 Resolution moved by Dr. Ved PrakashTyagi seconded by Dr. Jagjeet Singh,Member, CCIM.

fuosnu gS fd jk"Vz~h; vk;qosZn laLFkku] t;iqj esLukrdksRrj ikB~;dze esa izos’k gsrq 20% vad ojh;rk dsvk/kkj ij fn, tkrs gS A bl lanHkZ esa esjk fuosnu gS fd 20%

lekIr dj vU; fo’ofo|ky; dh rjg fyf[kr ijh{kk ds vk/kkj ij gh izos’kfn, tkrs gS A

Ayurveda Committee decided that this institution should also follow the rulesas other Universities followed in this regard.

Addl. Agenda Item No.5 Resolution of Dr. Sivanandam & Others

It was noted that following resolution was moved by Vaidya Sivanandam & other 17 membersstated that the following matter which is very important norm to include in the morms ofAyurveda by establishing Goshala with minimum cows in the institution (to start or run thecollege & hospital).

It is well known fact that cow milk is used to prepare number of important formulations likeKounchapakam, Ksheerabale Tailam, Ganadhaka Shudhi etc.

Cow mutram is used in number of formulation like Punarnavamanduram for shudhi, Vishamusi,Vatsanabhi etc.

7535ay

Butter milk for shodhanam and used to cure various diseases and shodhanam for number of rawdrugs.

Curd is used to prepare a number of medicines and in various formulations.

Cow dung is used to purify number of raw drags like Bhaliataka etc. and to prepare the Bhasmasand being used in putas.

Cow dung also useful as fertilizer to cultivate the medicinal plants and herbs.

Cow grutham used in number of grutham formulations and in Shudhi of many raw drugs and inthe treatment of various diseases Goshala is very very imports as Herbarium and Pharmacyprovision.

We have mentioned only few examples there are thousands of benefits for Ayurvedic system andto the students of Ayurvedic and its patrons.

We reques you Sir, kindly include the Goshala with minimum cows in the norms of Ayurveda tostart or to run the college and hospitals.

Ayurveda Committee decided that provision of Gaushala may be keptattached to Rasayanasala to the possible extent.

Meeting concluded with the vote of thanks to the Chair.

********

********

Download - CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHI · 135ay CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHI MINUTES OF 35th Meeting of Ayurved Committee held on 24th February, 2006 at New

Top Related